depth-probe artifacts: probe-dependent layer ranking, scaling curves, SugarCrepe fitted re-test, banked null
9497609 verified | { | |
| "question": "does the L20 advantage over L47 survive more training data", | |
| "holdout": 1000, | |
| "seeds_per_point": 5, | |
| "results": { | |
| "L20": { | |
| "250": { | |
| "mean_r@1": 0.06620000451803207, | |
| "std": 0.009495263234598202, | |
| "seeds": [ | |
| 0.07300000637769699, | |
| 0.0690000057220459, | |
| 0.049000002443790436, | |
| 0.06400000303983688, | |
| 0.07600000500679016 | |
| ] | |
| }, | |
| "500": { | |
| "mean_r@1": 0.10200000554323196, | |
| "std": 0.009055386540152885, | |
| "seeds": [ | |
| 0.0860000029206276, | |
| 0.11000000685453415, | |
| 0.09800000488758087, | |
| 0.10900000482797623, | |
| 0.10700000822544098 | |
| ] | |
| }, | |
| "1000": { | |
| "mean_r@1": 0.1674000084400177, | |
| "std": 0.0061514241166914455, | |
| "seeds": [ | |
| 0.16600000858306885, | |
| 0.15700000524520874, | |
| 0.17500001192092896, | |
| 0.16700001060962677, | |
| 0.1720000058412552 | |
| ] | |
| }, | |
| "2000": { | |
| "mean_r@1": 0.2190000146627426, | |
| "std": 0.011644741355641638, | |
| "seeds": [ | |
| 0.22200001776218414, | |
| 0.1990000158548355, | |
| 0.23500001430511475, | |
| 0.22200001776218414, | |
| 0.21700000762939453 | |
| ] | |
| }, | |
| "4000": { | |
| "mean_r@1": 0.28880001306533815, | |
| "std": 0.007934730169064928, | |
| "seeds": [ | |
| 0.30000001192092896, | |
| 0.28600001335144043, | |
| 0.29600000381469727, | |
| 0.27900001406669617, | |
| 0.28300002217292786 | |
| ] | |
| } | |
| }, | |
| "L47": { | |
| "250": { | |
| "mean_r@1": 0.056800002604722975, | |
| "std": 0.0059799675602018616, | |
| "seeds": [ | |
| 0.06200000271201134, | |
| 0.049000002443790436, | |
| 0.0560000017285347, | |
| 0.0650000050663948, | |
| 0.052000001072883606 | |
| ] | |
| }, | |
| "500": { | |
| "mean_r@1": 0.08860000371932983, | |
| "std": 0.006216108670602526, | |
| "seeds": [ | |
| 0.09400000423192978, | |
| 0.08300000429153442, | |
| 0.09800000488758087, | |
| 0.08300000429153442, | |
| 0.08500000089406967 | |
| ] | |
| }, | |
| "1000": { | |
| "mean_r@1": 0.13700000643730165, | |
| "std": 0.004049695137703997, | |
| "seeds": [ | |
| 0.13900001347064972, | |
| 0.1380000114440918, | |
| 0.14300000667572021, | |
| 0.13300000131130219, | |
| 0.13199999928474426 | |
| ] | |
| }, | |
| "2000": { | |
| "mean_r@1": 0.1868000090122223, | |
| "std": 0.0053065998604589475, | |
| "seeds": [ | |
| 0.18000000715255737, | |
| 0.18400001525878906, | |
| 0.19600000977516174, | |
| 0.1860000044107437, | |
| 0.18800000846385956 | |
| ] | |
| }, | |
| "4000": { | |
| "mean_r@1": 0.2282000094652176, | |
| "std": 0.00331058983915294, | |
| "seeds": [ | |
| 0.22300000488758087, | |
| 0.22800001502037048, | |
| 0.23000000417232513, | |
| 0.2330000102519989, | |
| 0.22700001299381256 | |
| ] | |
| } | |
| } | |
| }, | |
| "gap_L20_minus_L47": { | |
| "250": 0.0094, | |
| "500": 0.0134, | |
| "1000": 0.0304, | |
| "2000": 0.0322, | |
| "4000": 0.0606 | |
| }, | |
| "gap_note": "mean r@1 at L20 minus mean r@1 at L47 at each training size, 5 seeds, same 1000 held out. Direction replicates on train2017 (tap_layer_scaling_30k.json) but magnitude does not." | |
| } |