{ "question": "does the object/arrangement spectrum shift with depth", "arm": "head-free, pool-mean centred cosine on raw states", "control": "L47 must reproduce sugarcrepe_diagnostic_20260806.json sep: swap_obj 0.396, replace_obj 0.582, swap_att 0.498, replace_rel 0.485", "sep_note": "sep = mean cos(positive, negative caption), lower is better separated", "backbone": "google/gemma-4-31B-it", "layers": [ 4, 12, 20, 28, 36, 44, 47, 54, 60 ], "results": { "L4": { "add_att": { "acc": 0.5679, "sep": 0.5654, "n": 692 }, "add_obj": { "acc": 0.5436, "sep": 0.3819, "n": 2062 }, "replace_att": { "acc": 0.5457, "sep": 0.5877, "n": 788 }, "replace_obj": { "acc": 0.5139, "sep": 0.4983, "n": 1652 }, "replace_rel": { "acc": 0.522, "sep": 0.5185, "n": 1406 }, "swap_att": { "acc": 0.488, "sep": 0.5789, "n": 666 }, "swap_obj": { "acc": 0.4531, "sep": 0.5517, "n": 245 }, "macro_acc": 0.5192 }, "L12": { "add_att": { "acc": 0.5332, "sep": 0.649, "n": 692 }, "add_obj": { "acc": 0.5466, "sep": 0.5035, "n": 2062 }, "replace_att": { "acc": 0.5508, "sep": 0.6551, "n": 788 }, "replace_obj": { "acc": 0.5285, "sep": 0.6039, "n": 1652 }, "replace_rel": { "acc": 0.4957, "sep": 0.5967, "n": 1406 }, "swap_att": { "acc": 0.4775, "sep": 0.6318, "n": 666 }, "swap_obj": { "acc": 0.4449, "sep": 0.6076, "n": 245 }, "macro_acc": 0.511 }, "L20": { "add_att": { "acc": 0.5289, "sep": 0.7108, "n": 692 }, "add_obj": { "acc": 0.5752, "sep": 0.5293, "n": 2062 }, "replace_att": { "acc": 0.5533, "sep": 0.7096, "n": 788 }, "replace_obj": { "acc": 0.5708, "sep": 0.6664, "n": 1652 }, "replace_rel": { "acc": 0.6017, "sep": 0.5633, "n": 1406 }, "swap_att": { "acc": 0.5135, "sep": 0.6603, "n": 666 }, "swap_obj": { "acc": 0.4776, "sep": 0.6152, "n": 245 }, "macro_acc": 0.5459 }, "L28": { "add_att": { "acc": 0.4855, "sep": 0.6382, "n": 692 }, "add_obj": { "acc": 0.5407, "sep": 0.4193, "n": 2062 }, "replace_att": { "acc": 0.5368, "sep": 0.6512, "n": 788 }, "replace_obj": { "acc": 0.5333, "sep": 0.6085, "n": 1652 }, "replace_rel": { "acc": 0.5455, "sep": 0.4954, "n": 1406 }, "swap_att": { "acc": 0.5225, "sep": 0.5494, "n": 666 }, "swap_obj": { "acc": 0.5429, "sep": 0.4414, "n": 245 }, "macro_acc": 0.5296 }, "L36": { "add_att": { "acc": 0.5029, "sep": 0.6385, "n": 692 }, "add_obj": { "acc": 0.5917, "sep": 0.4463, "n": 2062 }, "replace_att": { "acc": 0.5381, "sep": 0.6378, "n": 788 }, "replace_obj": { "acc": 0.5611, "sep": 0.6106, "n": 1652 }, "replace_rel": { "acc": 0.6017, "sep": 0.4958, "n": 1406 }, "swap_att": { "acc": 0.47, "sep": 0.5449, "n": 666 }, "swap_obj": { "acc": 0.5673, "sep": 0.4561, "n": 245 }, "macro_acc": 0.5475 }, "L44": { "add_att": { "acc": 0.4957, "sep": 0.6146, "n": 692 }, "add_obj": { "acc": 0.5689, "sep": 0.4452, "n": 2062 }, "replace_att": { "acc": 0.5343, "sep": 0.6336, "n": 788 }, "replace_obj": { "acc": 0.6168, "sep": 0.5973, "n": 1652 }, "replace_rel": { "acc": 0.6024, "sep": 0.5022, "n": 1406 }, "swap_att": { "acc": 0.536, "sep": 0.513, "n": 666 }, "swap_obj": { "acc": 0.5143, "sep": 0.4154, "n": 245 }, "macro_acc": 0.5526 }, "L47": { "add_att": { "acc": 0.5058, "sep": 0.5973, "n": 692 }, "add_obj": { "acc": 0.5684, "sep": 0.4326, "n": 2062 }, "replace_att": { "acc": 0.5381, "sep": 0.616, "n": 788 }, "replace_obj": { "acc": 0.6138, "sep": 0.5826, "n": 1652 }, "replace_rel": { "acc": 0.5996, "sep": 0.4854, "n": 1406 }, "swap_att": { "acc": 0.5465, "sep": 0.4975, "n": 666 }, "swap_obj": { "acc": 0.4939, "sep": 0.3949, "n": 245 }, "macro_acc": 0.5523 }, "L54": { "add_att": { "acc": 0.5694, "sep": 0.5229, "n": 692 }, "add_obj": { "acc": 0.5664, "sep": 0.3895, "n": 2062 }, "replace_att": { "acc": 0.5939, "sep": 0.5514, "n": 788 }, "replace_obj": { "acc": 0.6659, "sep": 0.518, "n": 1652 }, "replace_rel": { "acc": 0.6095, "sep": 0.4494, "n": 1406 }, "swap_att": { "acc": 0.527, "sep": 0.4402, "n": 666 }, "swap_obj": { "acc": 0.4531, "sep": 0.3432, "n": 245 }, "macro_acc": 0.5693 }, "L60": { "add_att": { "acc": 0.5202, "sep": 0.4547, "n": 692 }, "add_obj": { "acc": 0.4777, "sep": 0.3392, "n": 2062 }, "replace_att": { "acc": 0.5431, "sep": 0.4894, "n": 788 }, "replace_obj": { "acc": 0.5406, "sep": 0.4587, "n": 1652 }, "replace_rel": { "acc": 0.5128, "sep": 0.4254, "n": 1406 }, "swap_att": { "acc": 0.5435, "sep": 0.3654, "n": 666 }, "swap_obj": { "acc": 0.5184, "sep": 0.2617, "n": 245 }, "macro_acc": 0.5223 } }, "n_images": 1560, "n_captions": 11844, "n_pairs": 7511 }