{ "meta": { "seed": 42, "B_main_bootstrap": 5000, "B_small_bootstrap": 600, "B_item6": 2000, "n_null_sims": 2000, "n_mcnemar_sims": 2000, "models_loaded": { "A": "floor16", "B": "floor16_sonnet", "C": "floor16_ollama", "D": "floor16_mistral", "E": "floor16_qwen3", "F": "floor16_phi3" }, "extra_t0_dirs_skipped": [ [ "floor16_ollama_t0", 0 ], [ "floor16_mistral_t0", 0 ], [ "floor16_qwen3_t0", 0 ], [ "floor16_phi3_t0", 1 ] ], "canonical_vignette_count": 16, "split_enumeration": { "R=3": { "n_splits": 2100, "replicates_used_per_split": 6, "replicates_unused_per_split": 4 }, "R=5": { "n_splits": 126, "replicates_used_per_split": 10, "replicates_unused_per_split": 0 } }, "runtime_seconds": { "bootstrap_items_1_2_3_5": 131.5, "leave_one_vignette_out": 0.49, "item6_majority_vote_bootstrap": 20.4, "item7_null_simulation": 190.4, "item8_mcnemar_simulation": 4.9, "total": 348.8 } }, "verification": { "checks": [ { "label": "pooled floor", "computed": 0.087, "published": 0.087 }, { "label": "pooled numerator", "computed": 374, "published": 374 }, { "label": "pooled denominator", "computed": 4320, "published": 4320 }, { "label": "escalate_icu floor", "computed": 0.022, "published": 0.022 }, { "label": "cs_caution floor", "computed": 0.179, "published": 0.179 }, { "label": "R=3 floor", "computed": 0.063, "published": 0.063 }, { "label": "R=5 floor", "computed": 0.053, "published": 0.053 } ], "mismatches": [], "ok": true }, "item1_per_model_action_floors": { "B_values": [ 600, 5000 ], "models": { "A": { "actions": { "admit": { "num": 102, "den": 720, "floor": 0.14166666666666666, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.05138888888888889, 0.23333333333333334 ], "B=5000": [ 0.05138888888888889, 0.24166666666666667 ] } }, "any_opioid": { "num": 18, "den": 720, "floor": 0.025, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.0625 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.0625 ] } }, "cs_caution": { "num": 129, "den": 720, "floor": 0.17916666666666667, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.06944444444444445, 0.29444444444444445 ], "B=5000": [ 0.06388888888888888, 0.29583333333333334 ] } }, "escalate_icu": { "num": 16, "den": 720, "floor": 0.022222222222222223, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.06666666666666667 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.06666666666666667 ] } }, "high_acuity": { "num": 55, "den": 720, "floor": 0.0763888888888889, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.16944444444444445 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.17083333333333334 ] } }, "referral": { "num": 54, "den": 720, "floor": 0.075, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0125, 0.16666666666666666 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.16666666666666666 ] } } }, "pooled": { "num": 374, "den": 4320, "floor": 0.08657407407407407, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.05648148148148148, 0.11712962962962963 ], "B=5000": [ 0.05578703703703704, 0.11689814814814815 ] } } }, "B": { "actions": { "admit": { "num": 10, "den": 240, "floor": 0.041666666666666664, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.10416666666666667 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.10416666666666667 ] } }, "any_opioid": { "num": 8, "den": 240, "floor": 0.03333333333333333, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.1 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.1 ] } }, "cs_caution": { "num": 48, "den": 240, "floor": 0.2, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.1, 0.3333333333333333 ], "B=5000": [ 0.06666666666666667, 0.3333333333333333 ] } }, "escalate_icu": { "num": 5, "den": 240, "floor": 0.020833333333333332, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.0625 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.0625 ] } }, "high_acuity": { "num": 16, "den": 240, "floor": 0.06666666666666667, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.16666666666666666 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.16666666666666666 ] } }, "referral": { "num": 9, "den": 240, "floor": 0.0375, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.1125 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.1125 ] } } }, "pooled": { "num": 96, "den": 1440, "floor": 0.06666666666666667, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.03888888888888889, 0.09513888888888888 ], "B=5000": [ 0.03819444444444445, 0.09583333333333334 ] } } }, "C": { "actions": { "admit": { "num": 159, "den": 720, "floor": 0.22083333333333333, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.10555555555555556, 0.34305555555555556 ], "B=5000": [ 0.10972222222222222, 0.3388888888888889 ] } }, "any_opioid": { "num": 65, "den": 720, "floor": 0.09027777777777778, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.022222222222222223, 0.17777777777777778 ], "B=5000": [ 0.022222222222222223, 0.18055555555555555 ] } }, "cs_caution": { "num": 107, "den": 720, "floor": 0.1486111111111111, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.059722222222222225, 0.24722222222222223 ], "B=5000": [ 0.058333333333333334, 0.24861111111111112 ] } }, "escalate_icu": { "num": 43, "den": 720, "floor": 0.059722222222222225, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0125, 0.11666666666666667 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0125, 0.11666666666666667 ] } }, "high_acuity": { "num": 316, "den": 720, "floor": 0.4388888888888889, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.39444444444444443, 0.4791666666666667 ], "B=5000": [ 0.39305555555555555, 0.4777777777777778 ] } }, "referral": { "num": 238, "den": 720, "floor": 0.33055555555555555, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.2375, 0.41944444444444445 ], "B=5000": [ 0.22916666666666666, 0.4263888888888889 ] } } }, "pooled": { "num": 928, "den": 4320, "floor": 0.21481481481481482, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.17824074074074073, 0.24768518518518517 ], "B=5000": [ 0.18171296296296297, 0.24837962962962962 ] } } }, "D": { "actions": { "admit": { "num": 33, "den": 720, "floor": 0.04583333333333333, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.125 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.125 ] } }, "any_opioid": { "num": 40, "den": 720, "floor": 0.05555555555555555, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.13333333333333333 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.14444444444444443 ] } }, "cs_caution": { "num": 106, "den": 720, "floor": 0.14722222222222223, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.05555555555555555, 0.26805555555555555 ], "B=5000": [ 0.044444444444444446, 0.2625 ] } }, "escalate_icu": { "num": 41, "den": 720, "floor": 0.05694444444444444, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.1361111111111111 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.1388888888888889 ] } }, "high_acuity": { "num": 191, "den": 720, "floor": 0.2652777777777778, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.1638888888888889, 0.3680555555555556 ], "B=5000": [ 0.1527777777777778, 0.3763888888888889 ] } }, "referral": { "num": 0, "den": 720, "floor": 0.0, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "pooled": { "num": 411, "den": 4320, "floor": 0.09513888888888888, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.06898148148148148, 0.12685185185185185 ], "B=5000": [ 0.06712962962962964, 0.12523148148148147 ] } } }, "E": { "actions": { "admit": { "num": 25, "den": 720, "floor": 0.034722222222222224, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.10416666666666667 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.10416666666666667 ] } }, "any_opioid": { "num": 9, "den": 720, "floor": 0.0125, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.0375 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.0375 ] } }, "cs_caution": { "num": 75, "den": 720, "floor": 0.10416666666666667, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0125, 0.20833333333333334 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0125, 0.20833333333333334 ] } }, "escalate_icu": { "num": 0, "den": 720, "floor": 0.0, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "high_acuity": { "num": 0, "den": 720, "floor": 0.0, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } }, "referral": { "num": 0, "den": 720, "floor": 0.0, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0, 0.0 ] } } }, "pooled": { "num": 109, "den": 4320, "floor": 0.025231481481481483, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.0020833333333333333, 0.05555555555555555 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0020833333333333333, 0.05555555555555555 ] } } }, "F": { "actions": { "admit": { "num": 225, "den": 720, "floor": 0.3125, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.2111111111111111, 0.4111111111111111 ], "B=5000": [ 0.20833333333333334, 0.4111111111111111 ] } }, "any_opioid": { "num": 80, "den": 720, "floor": 0.1111111111111111, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.034722222222222224, 0.21666666666666667 ], "B=5000": [ 0.029166666666666667, 0.20694444444444443 ] } }, "cs_caution": { "num": 127, "den": 702, "floor": 0.18091168091168092, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.07735583684950774, 0.30158730158730157 ], "B=5000": [ 0.0763888888888889, 0.28973277074542897 ] } }, "escalate_icu": { "num": 45, "den": 720, "floor": 0.0625, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.025, 0.1125 ], "B=5000": [ 0.025, 0.1125 ] } }, "high_acuity": { "num": 223, "den": 720, "floor": 0.30972222222222223, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.19722222222222222, 0.41388888888888886 ], "B=5000": [ 0.19722222222222222, 0.41805555555555557 ] } }, "referral": { "num": 320, "den": 720, "floor": 0.4444444444444444, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.39305555555555555, 0.49444444444444446 ], "B=5000": [ 0.3861111111111111, 0.49444444444444446 ] } } }, "pooled": { "num": 1020, "den": 4302, "floor": 0.23709902370990238, "ci": { "B=600": [ 0.19595536959553697, 0.286512928022362 ], "B=5000": [ 0.19409576940957693, 0.28379629629629627 ] } } } } }, "item2_modelA_cs_caution_vs_escalate_icu": { "observed": { "cs_caution": 0.17916666666666667, "escalate_icu": 0.022222222222222223, "difference": 0.15694444444444444, "ratio": 8.0625 }, "difference_ci_B5000": [ 0.05138888888888889, 0.26944444444444443 ], "ratio": { "n_resamples": 5000, "n_icu_floor_zero": 1784, "fraction_icu_floor_zero": 0.3568, "bounded": false, "finite_subset_ci": [ 2.270833333333333, 12.6875 ], "note": "ratio CI is not a valid bounded interval: in 35.7% of resamples the escalate_icu floor is 0 (no disagreeing pair among the 16 resampled vignettes), making cs_caution/escalate_icu undefined (division by zero) rather than merely large. The finite_subset_ci excludes those draws and understates the true spread." } }, "item3_pairwise_model_pooled_floor_diffs": [ { "pair": "A-B", "observed_diff": 0.0199074074074074, "ci_B5000": [ 0.001388888888888884, 0.037500000000000006 ] }, { "pair": "A-C", "observed_diff": -0.12824074074074077, "ci_B5000": [ -0.1703703703703704, -0.0824074074074074 ] }, { "pair": "A-D", "observed_diff": -0.008564814814814817, "ci_B5000": [ -0.05717592592592592, 0.03680555555555555 ] }, { "pair": "A-E", "observed_diff": 0.06134259259259259, "ci_B5000": [ 0.028240740740740736, 0.09444444444444444 ] }, { "pair": "A-F", "observed_diff": -0.1505249496358283, "ci_B5000": [ -0.21269661397799472, -0.09065921267179128 ] }, { "pair": "B-C", "observed_diff": -0.14814814814814814, "ci_B5000": [ -0.1935185185185185, -0.10115740740740739 ] }, { "pair": "B-D", "observed_diff": -0.028472222222222218, "ci_B5000": [ -0.07199074074074073, 0.011805555555555555 ] }, { "pair": "B-E", "observed_diff": 0.041435185185185186, "ci_B5000": [ 0.00856481481481481, 0.0736111111111111 ] }, { "pair": "B-F", "observed_diff": -0.17043235704323573, "ci_B5000": [ -0.2295859538784067, -0.11177800974251913 ] }, { "pair": "C-D", "observed_diff": 0.11967592592592594, "ci_B5000": [ 0.0662037037037037, 0.1685185185185185 ] }, { "pair": "C-E", "observed_diff": 0.18958333333333333, "ci_B5000": [ 0.13634259259259257, 0.2333333333333333 ] }, { "pair": "C-F", "observed_diff": -0.02228420889508756, "ci_B5000": [ -0.058011482254697266, 0.011846234309623449 ] }, { "pair": "D-E", "observed_diff": 0.0699074074074074, "ci_B5000": [ 0.04236111111111111, 0.10162037037037037 ] }, { "pair": "D-F", "observed_diff": -0.1419601348210135, "ci_B5000": [ -0.2001733689756702, -0.0888178496868476 ] }, { "pair": "E-F", "observed_diff": -0.21186754222842089, "ci_B5000": [ -0.26700736488053817, -0.15550046392948272 ] } ], "item4_leave_one_vignette_out": { "A": { "n_deletions": 16, "min_pooled_floor": 0.08, "max_pooled_floor": 0.09234567901234568, "cs_minus_icu_min": 0.1303703703703704, "cs_minus_icu_max": 0.16740740740740742 }, "B": { "n_deletions": 16, "min_pooled_floor": 0.05925925925925926, "max_pooled_floor": 0.07111111111111111 }, "C": { "n_deletions": 16, "min_pooled_floor": 0.2074074074074074, "max_pooled_floor": 0.22296296296296297 }, "D": { "n_deletions": 16, "min_pooled_floor": 0.08493827160493828, "max_pooled_floor": 0.10148148148148148 }, "E": { "n_deletions": 16, "min_pooled_floor": 0.013333333333333334, "max_pooled_floor": 0.02691358024691358 }, "F": { "n_deletions": 16, "min_pooled_floor": 0.22271825396825398, "max_pooled_floor": 0.24776785714285715 } }, "item5_excluding_cs_caution": { "excluded": "cs_caution", "models": { "A": { "num": 245, "den": 3600, "floor": 0.06805555555555555, "ci_B5000": [ 0.03638888888888889, 0.10138888888888889 ] }, "B": { "num": 48, "den": 1200, "floor": 0.04, "ci_B5000": [ 0.015, 0.07 ] }, "C": { "num": 821, "den": 3600, "floor": 0.22805555555555557, "ci_B5000": [ 0.18472222222222223, 0.2713888888888889 ] }, "D": { "num": 305, "den": 3600, "floor": 0.08472222222222223, "ci_B5000": [ 0.05305555555555556, 0.11805555555555555 ] }, "E": { "num": 34, "den": 3600, "floor": 0.009444444444444445, "ci_B5000": [ 0.0, 0.028333333333333332 ] }, "F": { "num": 893, "den": 3600, "floor": 0.24805555555555556, "ci_B5000": [ 0.20805555555555555, 0.2891666666666667 ] } }, "modelA_majority_vote_excl_cs_caution": { "curve": { "1": { "flips": 245, "total": 3600, "rate": 0.06805555555555555 }, "3": { "flips": 7270, "total": 168000, "rate": 0.04327380952380953 }, "5": { "flips": 321, "total": 10080, "rate": 0.03184523809523809 } }, "reduction_1_minus_f5_f1": 0.532069970845481 } }, "item6_majority_vote_reduction": { "B": 2000, "models": { "A": { "n_reps": 10, "f1_observed": 0.08657407407407407, "f5_observed": 0.05257936507936508, "reduction_observed": 0.3926661573720397, "reduction_ci": [ 0.1809421841541755, 0.6383075523202912 ], "n_valid_resamples": 2000, "n_splits_R1": 45, "n_splits_R5": 126 }, "C": { "n_reps": 10, "f1_observed": 0.21481481481481482, "f5_observed": 0.1130952380952381, "reduction_observed": 0.4735221674876847, "reduction_ci": [ 0.3057142857142857, 0.6463628396143734 ], "n_valid_resamples": 2000, "n_splits_R1": 45, "n_splits_R5": 126 }, "D": { "n_reps": 10, "f1_observed": 0.09513888888888888, "f5_observed": 0.08779761904761904, "reduction_observed": 0.07716371220020857, "reduction_ci": [ -0.2276785714285714, 0.4189920866305705 ], "n_valid_resamples": 2000, "n_splits_R1": 45, "n_splits_R5": 126 }, "E": { "n_reps": 10, "f1_observed": 0.025231481481481483, "f5_observed": 0.019345238095238096, "reduction_observed": 0.23328964613368286, "reduction_ci": [ 0.017857142857142905, 1.0 ], "n_valid_resamples": 1977, "n_splits_R1": 45, "n_splits_R5": 126 }, "F": { "n_reps": 10, "f1_observed": 0.23709902370990238, "f5_observed": 0.15236907730673316, "reduction_observed": 0.35736100924160197, "reduction_ci": [ 0.11130989141566139, 0.6216388034712265 ], "n_valid_resamples": 2000, "n_splits_R1": 45, "n_splits_R5": 126 } } }, "item7_null_simulation_sensitivity": { "observed_R5_floor": 0.053, "n_cells": 96, "plugin": { "n_sims": 2000, "mean": 0.04807886904761902, "ci_2.5_97.5": [ 0.025049603174603176, 0.07341269841269842 ] }, "jeffreys": { "n_sims": 2000, "mean": 0.055382316468253985, "ci_2.5_97.5": [ 0.030257936507936508, 0.08308531746031746 ] } }, "item8_mcnemar_simulation": { "null": { "16": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.078, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.07719812500000017, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.0, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.0 }, "50": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.07634000000000035, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.0770608, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.0, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.0045 }, "100": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.07884000000000024, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.07820790000000008, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.0, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.0135 }, "300": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.07762666666666664, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.07790656666666677, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.0, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.029 } }, "uniform": { "16": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.12303125, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.11585437500000008, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.007134375000000042, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.0035 }, "50": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.12170999999999958, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.11545040000000005, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.007084399999999943, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.146 }, "100": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.12067500000000014, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.11503334999999974, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.007078549999999994, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.4415 }, "300": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.12211000000000043, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.11507104999999995, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.007086916666666667, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.944 } }, "heterogeneous": { "16": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.11665625, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.10963875, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.006083750000000046, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.0 }, "50": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.11733999999999982, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.11086419999999979, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.006101000000000001, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.015 }, "100": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.11704500000000019, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.11063449999999994, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.006088499999999991, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.021 }, "300": { "mean_raw_flip_rate": 0.11706166666666681, "mean_floor_expectation": 0.11050250000000005, "mean_delta2_excess": 0.006087966666666683, "mcnemar_rejection_rate": 0.0525 } } } }