--- pretty_name: JMID language: ja license: cc-by-4.0 task_categories: - text-classification - text-generation size_categories: - 1K 医療事故の内容から、背景・要因を生成させた時のBERTScoreの平均値 (Average BERTScore when generating background and contributing factors from the description of medical incidents)
モデル Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o0.6200.6980.6560.5770.6890.6280.7070.7170.7110.6950.7170.705
Mistral0.6000.6910.6420.5660.6840.6190.6220.6610.6400.6560.6990.676
Llama3.30.6120.6980.6510.5910.6970.6390.6860.7120.6980.6710.7050.687
MedSwallow0.6780.6360.6550.6660.6260.6440.7150.6890.7000.6730.6480.659
JMedLoRA0.6790.6570.6670.6800.7200.6980.7120.6860.6980.7140.6830.697
医療事故の内容から、改善策を生成させた時のBERTScoreの平均値 (Average BERTScore when generating proposed improvements from the description of medical incidents)
モデル Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6090.6980.650 0.5930.6960.640 0.6920.7300.710 0.6790.7270.702
Mistral 0.6010.6940.644 0.6500.6840.666 0.6560.6810.668 0.6490.7190.682
Llama3.3 0.6150.7000.654 0.5920.6960.640 0.6910.7310.710 0.6880.7240.705
MedSwallow 0.0270.0250.026 0.6670.6160.639 0.6470.6170.631 0.6850.6510.667
JMedLoRA 0.5390.5190.528 0.4680.4500.459 0.7030.6880.695 0.7230.7050.713
#### 具体情報を用いた際の、医療事故内容別の結果は以下である。 The following shows the results for each type of medical incident when utilizing the specific information. ## 背景・要因(background and contributing factors)
調剤(71件)
調剤 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6300.6900.658 0.6770.6770.697 0.7110.6930.702 0.6930.6920.692
Mistral 0.6140.6830.646 0.6810.6810.629 0.6490.6610.655 0.5530.5650.558
Llama3.3 0.6240.6880.654 0.6850.6850.639 0.6970.6900.693 0.6750.6880.681
MedSwallow 0.6810.6250.651 0.5660.5660.594 0.7140.6740.693 0.6490.6100.628
JMedLoRA 0.6890.6420.664 0.7090.7090.699 0.7090.6580.682 0.7200.6600.688
薬剤(438件)
薬剤 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6240.6990.659 0.6920.6920.699 0.7130.7150.713 0.6970.7120.704
Mistral 0.6080.6920.646 0.6890.6890.627 0.6240.6530.638 0.5710.5970.583
Llama3.3 0.6170.6960.654 0.6960.6960.642 0.6890.7050.696 0.6730.6990.685
MedSwallow 0.6730.6290.650 0.6120.6120.633 0.7150.6840.698 0.6760.6490.661
JMedLoRA 0.6620.6320.646 0.7220.7220.698 0.7100.6790.693 0.7100.6690.688
人工呼吸器(182件)
人工呼吸器(182件) Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6010.690.641 0.6870.6870.69 0.6980.7180.707 0.680.7120.695
Mistral 0.5830.6840.629 0.6750.6750.607 0.6110.6640.636 0.5280.5660.546
Llama3.3 0.6010.6950.644 0.6930.6930.632 0.6750.7120.692 0.660.7020.679
MedSwallow 0.680.6360.656 0.6640.6640.681 0.7190.6930.704 0.6940.6690.68
JMedLoRA 0.6830.6720.676 0.7200.7200.697 0.7080.690.698 0.7120.6860.698
輸液ポンプ(114件)
輸液ポンプ(114件) Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6290.7030.663 0.6950.6950.707 0.7210.7180.719 0.7030.7150.708
Mistral 0.6110.6920.648 0.6920.6920.632 0.6040.6390.620 0.6170.6410.628
Llama3.3 0.6210.7000.657 0.6960.6960.643 0.6980.7160.706 0.6810.7040.691
MedSwallow 0.6860.6420.663 0.6640.6640.691 0.7100.6750.691 0.6750.6460.659
JMedLoRA 0.6710.6380.653 0.7190.7190.700 0.7200.6800.699 0.7160.6740.693
持参薬(136件)
持参薬
(136件)
Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6460.7130.678 0.7090.7090.716 0.7250.7210.723 0.720.7260.722
Mistral 0.6310.7090.667 0.7030.7030.645 0.6560.680.667 0.6380.6650.651
Llama3.3 0.6350.710.67 0.7070.7070.656 0.7070.7180.712 0.6950.7140.704
MedSwallow 0.680.6410.659 0.610.610.632 0.7250.6930.708 0.6690.6380.652
JMedLoRA 0.6990.6660.681 0.730.730.711 0.7210.6840.702 0.7230.6830.702
ドレーンの挿入・管理(134件)
ドレーンの挿入・管理 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6260.6990.66 0.6930.6930.704 0.7130.7170.714 0.7040.7190.711
Mistral 0.6050.6910.645 0.6810.6810.619 0.6170.6530.634 0.5670.5920.579
Llama3.3 0.6160.7010.656 0.7020.7020.643 0.6930.7140.703 0.6710.7030.686
MedSwallow 0.6870.6430.664 0.6090.6090.633 0.7310.6860.707 0.7050.6620.682
JMedLoRA 0.6850.6610.672 0.7210.7210.703 0.7190.6840.7 0.7140.6770.694
(臨床)検査(84件)
(臨床)検査 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.590.6770.63 0.6790.6790.678 0.7030.7250.713 0.6850.720.701
Mistral 0.570.6680.615 0.6540.6540.587 0.6350.6870.659 0.5320.5660.548
Llama3.3 0.6010.6980.645 0.6970.6970.63 0.6810.7160.697 0.6650.7080.685
MedSwallow 0.6740.6370.654 0.6030.6030.614 0.710.690.698 0.6770.6520.663
JMedLoRA 0.6820.6650.672 0.7220.7220.696 0.7150.690.701 0.7120.6860.698
小児患者の療養(133件)
小児患者の療養 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6170.70.656 0.690.690.694 0.7140.7350.723 0.7010.7310.715
Mistral 0.5950.6940.641 0.6860.6860.614 0.6330.6840.657 0.6110.6560.632
Llama3.3 0.6110.7050.654 0.7040.7040.639 0.6840.7220.702 0.6740.7160.694
MedSwallow 0.6780.6370.656 0.6460.6460.664 0.7260.7030.714 0.6820.6630.671
JMedLoRA 0.7020.6860.693 0.7260.7260.704 0.7220.6980.709 0.7240.6980.71
リハビリテーション(131件)
リハビリテーション Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6360.7120.671 0.7040.7040.71 0.7180.7330.724 0.7080.7330.72
Mistral 0.6110.7070.655 0.7030.7030.634 0.6320.6770.653 0.6470.690.667
Llama3.3 0.6190.7090.66 0.7070.7070.645 0.6920.7270.709 0.680.7220.7
MedSwallow 0.6640.6230.642 0.6560.6560.674 0.7150.6950.704 0.6810.6580.668
JMedLoRA 0.6850.6680.675 0.7170.7170.696 0.7110.6930.701 0.7030.6870.694
輸血療法(121件)
輸血療法 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6280.7080.665 0.6940.6940.695 0.7120.7240.717 0.7010.7220.711
Mistral 0.6050.6970.647 0.6950.6950.628 0.6340.6710.652 0.5960.6350.614
Llama3.3 0.6080.6910.646 0.7010.7010.642 0.6910.7180.704 0.6750.7110.692
MedSwallow 0.6940.6570.674 0.6340.6340.648 0.7070.6880.697 0.6480.6350.64
JMedLoRA 0.6920.6730.681 0.7250.7250.705 0.7170.6950.705 0.720.6890.703
禁忌薬(83件)
禁忌薬 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6330.7120.67 0.7050.7050.711 0.7180.7280.722 0.7040.730.716
Mistral 0.6150.7070.658 0.7010.7010.634 0.620.6590.638 0.6110.6510.63
Llama3.3 0.6230.7090.662 0.7050.7050.64 0.6880.7170.701 0.6780.7150.695
MedSwallow 0.6640.6210.641 0.6210.6210.64 0.720.6970.707 0.6580.6310.643
JMedLoRA 0.6670.6440.655 0.7210.7210.699 0.7130.6930.702 0.7090.6760.691
放射線検査(71件)
放射線検査 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.5940.6970.64 0.70.70.688 0.6750.7130.692 0.6630.7160.687
Mistral 0.5760.6930.628 0.6790.6790.599 0.590.6520.618 0.5270.5810.552
Llama3.3 0.5720.6810.621 0.6830.6830.613 0.6540.7050.678 0.640.70.668
MedSwallow 0.6650.6330.647 0.6310.6310.635 0.6880.6960.69 0.6580.6630.659
JMedLoRA 0.6650.6690.666 0.710.710.672 0.6850.6910.687 0.6760.6720.672
左右(部位)間違い(73件)
左右(部位)間違い Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.5840.6740.625 0.6720.6720.671 0.6810.7080.693 0.6640.7030.682
Mistral 0.5610.6650.607 0.6560.6560.584 0.60.650.623 0.5360.5850.558
Llama3.3 0.5810.6770.624 0.6710.6710.606 0.650.6950.67 0.6390.690.662
MedSwallow 0.6620.6460.653 0.6410.6410.647 0.6870.6790.681 0.6170.6150.614
JMedLoRA 0.6810.670.674 0.710.710.687 0.6950.6830.687 0.6910.6820.685
異物残存(23件)
異物残存 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6310.7030.664 0.6940.6940.705 0.7160.7210.718 0.6910.7090.7
Mistral 0.6180.7010.656 0.6620.6620.605 0.6090.6420.625 0.5320.560.545
Llama3.3 0.6210.6980.657 0.70.70.657 0.6850.7070.695 0.680.710.694
MedSwallow 0.7010.6660.683 0.6390.6390.656 0.7070.6760.691 0.5730.5630.567
JMedLoRA 0.6790.6580.667 0.7180.7180.699 0.710.6810.695 0.7060.6820.694
ベッドなど病室の設備(71件)
ベッドなど病室の設備 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6260.7070.663 0.680.680.682 0.7050.7270.715 0.6910.7260.707
Mistral 0.5970.6990.643 0.690.690.617 0.6330.6830.656 0.6510.7010.674
Llama3.3 0.5990.6960.643 0.6930.6930.632 0.6750.7150.694 0.6690.7130.69
MedSwallow 0.6850.6390.661 0.6190.6190.637 0.7240.6990.71 0.6810.6480.663
JMedLoRA 0.6810.6770.678 0.7110.7110.693 0.710.6920.7 0.7080.6910.699
化学療法(60件)
化学療法 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6250.6960.658 0.6960.6960.703 0.7080.7140.711 0.6930.7090.7
Mistral 0.6060.690.645 0.6870.6870.625 0.6320.6680.649 0.5180.5460.531
Llama3.3 0.6160.6940.652 0.6910.6910.638 0.6850.7050.695 0.6750.7040.688
MedSwallow 0.6680.6210.643 0.5710.5710.593 0.7070.6760.69 0.6780.6530.665
JMedLoRA 0.6670.6370.651 0.7140.7140.691 0.710.6760.692 0.7130.6730.692
電気メス等(39件)
電気メス等 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.5630.6450.6 0.6710.6710.681 0.6880.7120.698 0.6720.7050.698
Mistral 0.5250.6190.567 0.5670.5670.508 0.6030.6540.627 0.5710.6130.591
Llama3.3 0.6070.70.649 0.6950.6950.64 0.6630.7110.685 0.6510.7030.675
MedSwallow 0.6780.6350.654 0.6060.6060.623 0.7120.6910.7 0.6320.6160.623
JMedLoRA 0.6710.6570.663 0.7130.7130.695 0.7050.690.696 0.7110.6880.698
患者取り違え(53件)
患者取り違え Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6290.7040.664 0.6980.6980.704 0.710.7150.712 0.6960.7180.706
Mistral 0.6020.6940.644 0.6920.6920.626 0.610.6460.627 0.5210.5490.534
Llama3.3 0.6050.6970.647 0.6930.6930.632 0.6930.7130.702 0.6740.7060.689
MedSwallow 0.6980.6720.684 0.6310.6310.643 0.7140.6920.702 0.7060.6850.695
JMedLoRA 0.6920.670.68 0.7240.7240.703 0.7140.6890.701 0.7170.6840.699
## 改善策(proposed improvements)
調剤(71件)
調剤 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6260.6990.660 0.7130.7130.699 0.7050.7240.714 0.6890.7210.704
Mistral 0.6190.6930.654 0.6810.6810.669 0.6750.6890.681 0.3250.3410.333
Llama3.3 0.6310.7000.664 0.6920.6920.645 0.7070.7220.714 0.7030.7180.710
MedSwallow 0.0200.0190.019 0.5640.5640.596 0.6750.6340.653 0.7190.6660.691
JMedLoRA 0.5530.5210.536 0.4480.4480.464 0.6810.6460.662 0.7360.6950.714
薬剤(438件)
薬剤 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6180.7020.657 0.7170.7170.697 0.7010.7310.715 0.6850.7260.705
Mistral 0.6120.6970.652 0.6870.6870.667 0.6590.6750.666 0.5130.5570.534
Llama3.3 0.6230.6990.659 0.6950.6950.643 0.70.7280.713 0.6940.720.706
MedSwallow 0.0220.0190.02 0.60.60.628 0.6430.6060.623 0.7240.6810.701
JMedLoRA 0.5040.4780.49 0.4060.4060.416 0.7030.6790.69 0.7230.6930.707
人工呼吸器(182件)
人工呼吸器(182件) Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6030.6920.644 0.7060.7060.681 0.6880.7290.707 0.6770.7230.698
Mistral 0.5980.6920.641 0.6820.6820.669 0.6550.6820.667 0.4940.5450.517
Llama3.3 0.6130.6980.652 0.6950.6950.639 0.6860.7280.706 0.6790.7150.696
MedSwallow 0.0420.0400.041 0.6440.6440.670 0.6590.6300.643 0.7270.6920.708
JMedLoRA 0.5370.5210.528 0.3990.3990.407 0.7110.6950.702 0.7130.6920.701
輸液ポンプ(114件)
輸液ポンプ(114件) Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6170.7060.659 0.7230.7230.700 0.6970.7330.714 0.6830.7310.706
Mistral 0.6090.7030.652 0.6950.6950.674 0.6250.6530.638 0.3910.4220.405
Llama3.3 0.6200.7070.660 0.7000.7000.644 0.6940.7340.713 0.6940.7280.710
MedSwallow 0.0320.0290.031 0.6630.6630.689 0.5850.5540.568 0.7200.6860.702
JMedLoRA 0.5010.4800.490 0.4170.4170.428 0.7090.6870.697 0.7210.7010.710
持参薬(136件)
持参薬
(136件)
Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6180.7110.661 0.7290.7290.702 0.7010.7430.721 0.6860.7370.710
Mistral 0.6120.7060.656 0.6960.6960.675 0.6690.6980.683 0.4370.4710.453
Llama3.3 0.6210.7070.661 0.7030.7030.647 0.7030.7440.722 0.7040.7400.721
MedSwallow 0.0440.0400.042 0.6150.6150.635 0.6790.6480.662 0.7280.6970.712
JMedLoRA 0.5270.5070.517 0.5120.5120.520 0.7070.6910.698 0.7390.7210.729
ドレーンの挿入・管理(134件)
ドレーンの挿入・管理 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6120.6970.651 0.7140.7140.690 0.6940.7300.711 0.6820.7270.704
Mistral 0.6020.6940.644 0.6840.6840.668 0.6490.6740.660 0.4140.4440.428
Llama3.3 0.6160.7010.655 0.6990.6990.643 0.6920.7320.711 0.6840.7170.700
MedSwallow 0.0490.0460.047 0.5980.5980.623 0.6770.6430.659 0.7260.6860.705
JMedLoRA 0.5620.5440.553 0.4330.4330.441 0.7190.7010.709 0.7120.7270.701
(臨床)検査(84件)
(臨床)検査 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.5820.6740.624 0.6990.6990.670 0.6870.7350.709 0.6700.7250.696
Mistral 0.5780.6760.622 0.6700.6700.651 0.6730.7070.689 0.3750.4050.389
Llama3.3 0.6090.7070.654 0.6980.6980.637 0.6860.7340.709 0.6830.7230.702
MedSwallow 0.0090.0090.009 0.6020.6020.621 0.6710.6410.654 0.7290.6930.710
JMedLoRA 0.5890.5680.577 0.5430.5430.549 0.7130.7040.708 0.7200.7110.715
小児患者の療養(133件)
小児患者の療養 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6040.6930.645 0.7000.7000.673 0.6880.7300.708 0.6740.7260.699
Mistral 0.5920.6890.636 0.6700.6700.656 0.6740.6960.684 0.5110.5550.532
Llama3.3 0.6140.7020.654 0.6950.6950.636 0.6880.7320.708 0.6870.7240.704
MedSwallow 0.0260.0240.025 0.6240.6240.647 0.6590.6240.640 0.7270.6970.711
JMedLoRA 0.5850.5640.574 0.5000.5000.508 0.6950.6900.692 0.7050.6960.700
リハビリテーション(131件)
リハビリテーション Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6230.7130.664 0.7210.7210.694 0.6960.7390.717 0.6840.7360.709
Mistral 0.6080.7070.654 0.6900.6900.673 0.6610.6860.673 0.6040.6660.633
Llama3.3 0.6210.7110.663 0.7060.7060.645 0.6860.7390.711 0.6890.7320.709
MedSwallow 0.0360.0350.035 0.6420.6420.664 0.6250.6010.612 0.7310.6990.714
JMedLoRA 0.5460.5290.537 0.4380.4380.444 0.6870.6850.685 0.7070.7020.704
輸血療法(121件)
輸血療法 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6110.7060.654 0.7040.7040.678 0.6920.7380.713 0.6780.7310.703
Mistral 0.6010.6970.645 0.6910.6910.673 0.6600.6850.671 0.5720.6400.603
Llama3.3 0.6010.6890.641 0.6970.6970.637 0.6910.7370.713 0.6880.7330.709
MedSwallow 0.0220.0220.022 0.6110.6110.631 0.6130.5920.602 0.7210.6870.702
JMedLoRA 0.5740.5520.562 0.4970.4970.505 0.6950.6820.688 0.7310.7150.722
禁忌薬(83件)
禁忌薬 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6130.7000.653 0.7180.7180.692 0.6910.7290.709 0.6780.7270.701
Mistral 0.6060.6950.647 0.6910.6910.673 0.6580.6810.669 0.5500.6120.579
Llama3.3 0.6190.7010.657 0.6960.6960.640 0.6890.7280.707 0.6830.7190.700
MedSwallow 0.0280.0240.026 0.6020.6020.622 0.6650.6350.649 0.7140.6820.696
JMedLoRA 0.4870.4730.479 0.4640.4640.475 0.6960.6800.687 0.7140.6940.703
放射線検査(71件)
放射線検査 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.5900.6880.635 0.7110.7110.677 0.6700.7250.696 0.6550.7160.683
Mistral 0.5810.6870.629 0.6920.6920.664 0.6370.6760.655 0.6260.7110.665
Llama3.3 0.5800.6770.623 0.6860.6860.623 0.6630.7220.690 0.6610.7110.684
MedSwallow 0.0320.0300.031 0.6220.6220.638 0.5990.5810.589 0.7060.6930.698
JMedLoRA 0.5570.5430.549 0.5280.5280.533 0.7080.7070.706 0.6940.6960.694
左右(部位)間違い(73件)
左右(部位)間違い Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.5790.6850.627 0.7030.7030.672 0.6810.7350.706 0.6650.7250.693
Mistral 0.5740.6810.622 0.6750.6750.657 0.6500.6900.669 0.6300.7180.670
Llama3.3 0.5920.6940.639 0.6870.6870.623 0.6690.7340.699 0.6740.7270.699
MedSwallow 0.0100.0090.009 0.6410.6410.658 0.6000.5860.592 0.7230.7040.713
JMedLoRA 0.5280.5160.521 0.4520.4520.455 0.6830.6820.681 0.7240.7170.719
異物残存(23件)
異物残存 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6180.7030.657 0.7190.7190.695 0.7000.7270.713 0.6810.7210.700
Mistral 0.6150.7060.657 0.6670.6670.652 0.6530.6750.663 0.6530.7180.683
Llama3.3 0.6180.6970.655 0.7020.7020.647 0.6910.7300.709 0.6920.7260.708
MedSwallow 000 0.6310.6310.659 0.6730.6260.648 0.7070.6910.698
JMedLoRA 0.5530.5280.540 0.3540.3540.359 0.6920.6670.679 0.7310.7010.715
ベッドなど病室の設備(71件)
ベッドなど病室の設備 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6080.6990.650 0.6890.6890.658 0.6810.7320.705 0.6680.7270.696
Mistral 0.5910.6930.637 0.6880.6880.674 0.6720.7030.686 0.6420.7170.676
Llama3.3 0.6070.6960.647 0.6940.6940.632 0.6760.7270.700 0.6810.7240.701
MedSwallow 0.0080.0080.008 0.6200.6200.641 0.6950.6750.683 0.7400.7010.719
JMedLoRA 0.5790.5690.573 0.5060.5060.512 0.7050.7080.705 0.7110.7100.710
化学療法(60件)
化学療法 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6130.7010.654 0.7210.7210.695 0.6900.7270.708 0.6760.7210.698
Mistral 0.6060.6950.647 0.6830.6830.662 0.6580.6820.669 0.6410.7130.675
Llama3.3 0.6160.6970.654 0.6940.6940.639 0.6910.7330.711 0.6890.7210.704
MedSwallow 0.0140.0110.012 0.5680.5680.592 0.6650.6320.648 0.7050.6780.690
JMedLoRA 0.4870.4690.477 0.3960.3960.405 0.7030.6870.694 0.7270.6990.712
電気メス等(39件)
電気メス等 Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.5520.6350.590 0.6870.6870.664 0.6700.7110.689 0.6590.7080.682
Mistral 0.5280.6130.567 0.5580.5580.551 0.6540.6770.665 0.6270.7050.663
Llama3.3 0.6030.6890.643 0.6860.6860.628 0.6640.7160.688 0.6680.7140.689
MedSwallow 0.0340.0320.033 0.6020.6020.625 0.7020.6680.684 0.7090.6960.701
JMedLoRA 0.5580.5400.549 0.4100.4100.416 0.7010.6860.692 0.7090.6920.699
患者取り違え(53件)
患者取り違え Zero-shot
(All Prediction)
Zero-shot
(Each Prediction)
Few-shot
(All Prediction)
Few-shot
(Each Prediction)
PRF1 PRF1 PRF1 PRF1
GPT-4o 0.6190.7210.666 0.7410.7410.712 0.7030.7510.725 0.6920.7470.718
Mistral 0.6050.7110.653 0.7150.7150.693 0.6460.6760.660 0.6660.7380.700
Llama3.3 0.6110.7100.656 0.7050.7050.642 0.7050.7490.726 0.7020.7430.722
MedSwallow 0.0140.0130.014 0.6440.6440.663 0.6790.6460.661 0.7570.7110.732
JMedLoRA 0.6320.6170.624 0.5420.5420.550 0.7430.7250.733 0.7390.7260.732