diff --git a/examples/aci_D2N065_E1_E2_E3.html b/examples/aci_D2N065_E1_E2_E3.html new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..018b73c9b7d33dd095dc33776cd58f9042b017db --- /dev/null +++ b/examples/aci_D2N065_E1_E2_E3.html @@ -0,0 +1,286 @@ +
Presenting complaint: “Right ankle pain”. All three notes come from Qwen3.6-35B-A3B on the same gold transcript, with the same prompt rules and the same few-shot example. The Muse Glimmer judge (high reasoning) compared each note with the doctor's note and the transcript. Picked as a typical ACI dev encounter (E1–E3 coverage gap close to the 6.6-point average) where E2 and E3 each have facts the transcript does not back. Coverage: E1 0.82, E2 0.80, E3 0.75.
+Coverage is the share of the 40 facts in the doctor's note that the generated note contains. "Not backed by transcript" counts note facts that are absent from the doctor's note and that the judge could not find in the transcript, or that contradict it; the hallucination rate divides that count by the number of note facts.
+| Config | Coverage | Gold facts covered | Omitted | Conflicting | Note facts | Not backed by transcript | Hallucination rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | 0.82 | 33/40 | 7 | 0 | 32 | 0 | 0.000 |
| E2 | 0.80 | 32/40 | 8 | 0 | 36 | 2 | 0.056 |
| E3-noV | 0.75 | 30/40 | 10 | 0 | 34 | 2 | 0.059 |
Doctor hey anna good to see you today so i'm looking here in my notes says you have you're coming in today for some right ankle pain after a fall so can you tell me what happened how did you fall
Patient yeah so i was taking out the trash last night and i ended up slipping on a patch of ice like and then when i fell i heard this pop and it just hurts
Doctor okay so have you been able to walk on it at all or is it you know
Patient at first no like my friend who was visiting thankfully had to help me get into the house and i you know and now i'm able to put like a little bit of weight on it but i'm i i'm still limping
Doctor okay well you know that's not good we'll we'll hopefully we can get you fixed up here so how much how much pain have you been in on a scale of one to ten with ten being the worst pain you ever felt
Patient it's it's more like so when i first fell it was pretty bad but now it's it's at like a six you know like it's uncomfortable
Doctor okay and how would you describe that pain is it a constant pain or is it only when you move the ankle
Patient it's it's constant it's like a throbbing pain you know and like when i touch it it feels kinda warm
Doctor okay alright yeah but yeah i can feel it here so it does feel a little bit warm so i said you've been in a little bit of pain so have you taken anything for it
Patient well like last night i iced it and i kept it elevated you know i also took some ibuprofen last night and this morning
Doctor alright has the ibuprofen helped at all
Patient not really
Doctor okay alright so i just want to know i know some of my patients they have like bad ankles where they hurt the ankles all the time but have you ever injured this ankle before
Patient so you know in high school i used to play a lot of soccer but and and like i had other injuries but i've never injured like this particular ankle before but because i used to play like all the time i knew what i was supposed to do but this is i also knew that it was it was time to come in
Doctor okay yeah yeah definitely if you if you ca n't walk on it we definitely good thing that you came in today and we were able to see you so have you experienced any numbness in your foot at all
Patient no no numbness and i do n't think i've had like any tingling or anything like that
Doctor okay that that's good yeah it sounds like you have sensation there so yeah that that's really good so let me do a quick physical exam on you so i reviewed your vitals your blood pressure was one twenty over eighty which is good your heart rate your spo2 was ninety eight percent which is good that means you're you're getting all of your oxygen and so let me go ahead and look at your ankle real quick so when i press here does that hurt
Patient yeah
Doctor alright what about here
Patient yeah
Doctor okay so looking at your ankle and your right ankle exam on the skin there is ecchymosis so you have that bruising which you can see of the lateral
Patient malleolus
Doctor malleolus associated with swelling there is tenderness to palpation of the anterior laterally in the soft tissue there is no laxity on the anterior drawer and inversion stress there is no bony tenderness on palpation of the foot on your neurovascular exam of your right foot there your capillary refill is less than three seconds strong dorsalis pedis pulse and your sensation is intact to light touch alright so we did get an x-ray of your ankle before you came in and luckily it's there is no fractures no bony abnormalities which is really good so let me talk a little bit about my assessment and plan for you so for your right ankle pain your symptoms your symptoms are consistent with a right ankle sprain have you sprained your ankle before most times people do the athletics play soccer it happens every so often but have you done that before
Patient no i do n't think so
Doctor okay well you're one of the lucky ones some of my my patients that play sports they sprain their ankle seems like every other week so good for you so for that that that ankle sprain i just want to keep i want you to keep your leg elevated when you're seated and i want you to continue to ice it you can ice it let's say five times a day for twenty minutes at a time just to help that swelling go down i'm gon na give you an air cast to help you stabilize the ankle so keep it from moving and then i'll give you crutches and so i want you to stay off that leg for about one to two days and then you can start walking on it as tolerated tolerated so how does that sound
Patient it's alright
Doctor alright so do you have any questions for me
Patient yeah like how long do you think it's gon na take for me to heal
Doctor i mean it should take a a couple of days i mean i think in a day or two you will be able to walk on it but still think it will be sore for the next couple of weeks you know your ankle sprain seems to be not the worst but it's kinda you know medium grade ankle sprain so as i would say about two to three weeks you should be back to normal you will see some of that bruising go away
Patient yeah okay can i get a doctor's note
Doctor no because you need to go back to work because you work on the computer not running so
Patient fine
Doctor yeah you ca n't get a doctor's note so if you if i write a note i'm gon na tell your boss that you have to go to work
Patient okay thanks
Doctor so i i would n't do that but yeah but otherwise if if if you continue to have pain after this week if you feel like it's not getting better please feel free to contact the office and we can get you back in and possibly do an mri if we you know need to
Patient okay
Doctor alright
Patient alright
Doctor anything else
Patient no that's it
Doctor alright thanks
CHIEF COMPLAINT + +Right ankle pain. + +HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS + +Anna Diaz is a pleasant 31-year-old female who presents to the clinic today for the evaluation of right ankle pain. The onset of her pain began when she slipped on a patch of ice while taking out the trash. She states that she heard a pop at the time of the injury. The patient reports that she was unable to ambulate on her right ankle initially after the injury; however, she is now able to bear some weight on her right ankle, but she is still limping. The patient rates her pain level as a 6 out of 10. Ms. Diaz describes her pain as constant and throbbing. She reports that her right ankle is warm to the touch. She denies any numbness or tingling in her right foot. The patient has been icing and elevating her right ankle while also utilizing ibuprofen last night and this morning, which did not provide her with any relief. The patient states that she used to play a lot of soccer in high school so she notes that she has had other right foot injuries but not like this. + +REVIEW OF SYSTEMS + +Musculoskeletal: Positive right ankle pain. +Skin: Positive warmth to the right foot. +Neurological: Denies any numbness or tingling. + +VITALS + +BP: 120/80 +SPO2: 98%. + +PHYSICAL EXAM + +CV: Capillary refill is less than 3 seconds. Strong dorsalis pedis pulse. +NEURO: Normal sensation. Sensation is intact to light touch distally. +MSK: Examination of the right ankle reveals ecchymosis over the lateral malleolus associated with swelling. Tenderness to palpation anterolaterally in the soft tissue. No laxity on anterior drawer or inversion stress. No bony tenderness on palpation of the foot. + +RESULTS + +X-ray of the right ankle taken in office today reveals no fracture or bony abnormalities. + +ASSESSMENT + +Right ankle sprain. + +PLAN + +After reviewing the patient's examination and radiographic findings today, I have had a lengthy discussion with the patient in regards to her current symptoms. I have explained to her that her symptoms are consistent with a right ankle sprain. I have recommended that we treat the patient conservatively. I have advised her to keep her right leg elevated when she is seated. I have also advised her to ice her right ankle 5 times per day for 20 minutes at a time to help with the swelling. I have also recommended that the patient be placed in an Aircast to stabilize the ankle. She will remain non-weight-bearing for 1 to 2 days, we provided her with crutches today, and then she can begin weight-bearing as tolerated. + +INSTRUCTIONS + +If her pain does not improve over the next week, she will contact the office and we will obtain an MRI. +
Note straight from the transcript
CHIEF COMPLAINT +RIGHT ANKLE PAIN AFTER FALL X 1 DAY + +HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS +PATIENT SLIPPED ON ICE WHILE TAKING OUT TRASH LAST NIGHT. HEARD A 'POP' AT TIME OF INJURY. INITIAL PAIN WAS SEVERE, NOW RATED 6/10. PAIN IS CONSTANT AND THROBBING. ANKLE FEELS WARM TO TOUCH. INITIALLY UNABLE TO BEAR WEIGHT, NOW ABLE TO PUT SLIGHT WEIGHT ON IT BUT LIMPING. TRIED ICING, ELEVATION, AND IBUPROFEN (LAST NIGHT AND THIS MORNING) WITH LITTLE RELIEF. NO PRIOR INJURY TO THIS SPECIFIC ANKLE. + +PAST MEDICAL HISTORY +HISTORY OF PLAYING SOCCER IN HIGH SCHOOL WITH OTHER INJURIES, BUT NO PRIOR INJURY TO THIS SPECIFIC ANKLE. + +MEDICATION HISTORY +PATIENT TOOK IBUPROFEN LAST NIGHT AND THIS MORNING FOR PAIN. + +PERSONAL AND SOCIAL HISTORY +PATIENT WORKS ON A COMPUTER. + +REVIEW OF SYSTEMS +NEUROVASCULAR EXAM OF RIGHT FOOT PERFORMED. + +PHYSICAL EXAMINATION +ECCHYMOSIS OF LATERAL MALLEOLUS +SWELLING +TENDERNESS TO PALPATION (ANTERIOR LATERAL SOFT TISSUE) +NO LAXITY ON ANTERIOR DRAWER AND INVERSION STRESS +NO BONY TENDERNESS ON PALPATION OF FOOT +CAPILLARY REFILL < 3 SECONDS +STRONG DORSALIS PEDIS PULSE +SENSATION INTACT TO LIGHT TOUCH +RIGHT ANKLE: ECCHYMOSIS OF LATERAL MALLEOLUS, SWELLING, TENDERNESS TO PALPATION (ANTERIOR LATERAL SOFT TISSUE). NO LAXITY ON ANTERIOR DRAWER/INVERSION STRESS. NO BONY TENDERNESS. NEUROVASCULAR INTACT (CAPILLARY REFILL <3S, STRONG DP PULSE, SENSATION INTACT). + +INVESTIGATIONS REVIEWED +X-RAY OF ANKLE REVIEWED. NO FRACTURES OR BONY ABNORMALITIES. + +DIAGNOSIS +CURRENT: +RIGHT ANKLE SPRAIN (PROVISIONAL) + +ORDERS +PROCEDURES +AIR CAST APPLICATION +CRUTCHES PROVISION + +ADVICE +KEEP LEG ELEVATED WHEN SEATED. ICE ANKLE 5 TIMES A DAY FOR 20 MINUTES AT A TIME. STAY OFF THE LEG FOR 1-2 DAYS, THEN WALK AS TOLERATED. RETURN IF PAIN PERSISTS AFTER ONE WEEK OR IF NOT IMPROVING; MAY NEED MRI. + +FOLLOW-UP +REVIEW AFTER 1 WEEK IF PAIN PERSISTS OR NOT IMPROVING +
Note from all extracted facts, no evidence
CHIEF COMPLAINT +RIGHT ANKLE PAIN X 1 DAY + +HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS +SLIPPED ON ICE LAST NIGHT; HEARD A POP +CONSTANT THROBBING PAIN 6/10, ANKLE WARM TO TOUCH +ABLE TO PUT LITTLE WEIGHT ON ANKLE BUT LIMPING +ICED/ELEVATED ANKLE; TOOK IBUPROFEN LAST NIGHT AND THIS MORNING WITH NO RELIEF +NO NUMBNESS IN FOOT +NO TINGLING IN FOOT + +PAST MEDICAL HISTORY +H/O SOCCER INJURIES IN HIGH SCHOOL +NO PREVIOUS INJURY TO THIS SPECIFIC ANKLE + +MEDICATION HISTORY +TOOK IBUPROFEN LAST NIGHT AND THIS MORNING + +PERSONAL AND SOCIAL HISTORY +PLAYED SOCCER IN HIGH SCHOOL + +PHYSICAL EXAMINATION +TENDERNESS TO PALPATION ON RIGHT ANKLE +ECCHYMOSIS OF LATERAL MALLEOLUS +SWELLING OF RIGHT ANKLE +NO LAXITY ON ANTERIOR DRAWER AND INVERSION STRESS TESTS +NO BONY TENDERNESS ON PALPATION OF FOOT +CAPILLARY REFILL TIME < 3 SECONDS +STRONG DORSALIS PEDIS PULSE +SENSATION INTACT TO LIGHT TOUCH +TENDERNESS, ECCHYMOSIS OF LATERAL MALLEOLUS, SWELLING OF RIGHT ANKLE. NO LAXITY ON ANTERIOR DRAWER/INVERSION STRESS TESTS. NO BONY TENDERNESS ON FOOT PALPATION. CAPILLARY REFILL <3 SEC, STRONG DORSALIS PEDIS PULSE, SENSATION INTACT. + +INVESTIGATIONS REVIEWED +ANKLE X-RAY: NO FRACTURES OR BONY ABNORMALITIES + +DIAGNOSIS +CURRENT: +RIGHT ANKLE SPRAIN (MEDIUM GRADE) (PROVISIONAL) + +ORDERS +LABORATORY +MRI +PROCEDURES +AIR CAST +CRUTCHES + +ADVICE +STAY OFF LEG FOR 1-2 DAYS +KEEP LEG ELEVATED WHEN SEATED +ICE ANKLE 5 TIMES/DAY FOR 20 MINUTES AT A TIME + +FOLLOW-UP +REVIEW IF PAIN CONTINUES AFTER ONE WEEK +
Note from evidence-linked facts with their transcript quotes
CHIEF COMPLAINT +RIGHT ANKLE PAIN X 1 DAY, ASSO - SWELLING, BRUISING + +HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS +PAIN STARTED AFTER SLIPPING ON ICE LAST NIGHT. HEARD A POP AT ONSET. PAIN IS CONSTANT, THROBBING, RATED 6/10. ABLE TO BEAR LITTLE WEIGHT, STILL LIMPING. ANKLE FEELS WARM. ICING, ELEVATION, AND IBUPROFEN TRIED; IBUPROFEN NOT HELPFUL. NO NUMBNESS OR TINGLING. + +PAST MEDICAL HISTORY +PLAYED SOCCER IN HIGH SCHOOL WITH OTHER INJURIES. NO PRIOR INJURY TO THIS SPECIFIC ANKLE. + +MEDICATION HISTORY +TOOK IBUPROFEN LAST NIGHT AND THIS MORNING. + +PERSONAL AND SOCIAL HISTORY +PLAYED SOCCER IN HIGH SCHOOL. + +PHYSICAL EXAMINATION +TENDERNESS TO PALPATION ON RIGHT ANKLE +ECCHYMOSIS OF LATERAL MALLEOLUS +SWELLING OF RIGHT ANKLE +NO LAXITY ON ANTERIOR DRAWER AND INVERSION STRESS TESTS +NO BONY TENDERNESS ON PALPATION OF FOOT +CAPILLARY RELOAD < 3 SECONDS +STRONG DORSALIS PEDIS PULSE +SENSATION INTACT TO LIGHT TOUCH +TENDERNESS, ECCHYMOSIS (LATERAL MALLEOLUS), SWELLING. NO LAXITY. NO BONY TENDERNESS. PERFUSE, SENSATE. + +INVESTIGATIONS REVIEWED +ANKLE X-RAY SHOWS NO FRACTURES OR BONY ABNORMALITIES. + +DIAGNOSIS +CURRENT: +RIGHT ANKLE SPRAIN (PROVISIONAL) + +ORDERS +LABORATORY +MRI +PROCEDURES +AIR CAST APPLICATION +CRUTCHES PROVISION + +ADVICE +KEEP LEG ELEVATED WHEN SEATED. ICE ANKLE 5 TIMES A DAY FOR 20 MINUTES. STAY OFF THE LEG FOR 1-2 DAYS. + +FOLLOW-UP +REVIEW IF PAIN CONTINUES AFTER ONE WEEK +
| Gold fact (open a row for the judge's reasons) | E1 | E2 | E3-noV |
|---|---|---|---|
Patient presents with right ankle painChief ComplaintGold note: “Right ankle pain.” E1: Gen-001 states right ankle pain after fall; core complaint of right ankle pain is present. E2: Generated gen-001 states Right ankle pain for 1 day, covering the chief complaint of right ankle pain. E3-noV: Generated gen-001 states right ankle pain; core complaint is present. | covered | covered | covered |
Patient is Anna Diaz, a 31-year-old femaleHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Anna Diaz is a pleasant 31-year-old female who presents to the clinic today for the evaluation of right ankle pain.” E1: Patient name Anna Diaz and age 31-year-old female are not mentioned in any generated fact. E2: Patient name Anna Diaz and age 31-year-old female is not present in any generated fact. E3-noV: Patient name Anna Diaz and age 31-year-old female are not mentioned in generated facts. | omitted | omitted | omitted |
Pain onset began after slipping on a patch of ice while taking out the trashHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “The onset of her pain began when she slipped on a patch of ice while taking out the trash.” E1: Gen-002 reports patient slipped on ice while taking out trash, matching onset mechanism. E2: gen-002 Slipped on ice last night captures the slip on ice onset; taking out trash detail is omitted but core mechanism is present. E3-noV: gen-004 reports pain started after slipping on ice; matches onset after slipping on ice. | covered | covered | covered |
Patient heard a pop at time of injuryHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “She states that she heard a pop at the time of the injury.” E1: Gen-003 states heard a pop at time of injury. E2: gen-003 Heard a pop matches the pop at injury. E3-noV: gen-005 reports heard a pop at onset, matching pop at injury. | covered | covered | covered |
Initially unable to ambulate on right ankle after injuryHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “The patient reports that she was unable to ambulate on her right ankle initially after the injury” E1: Gen-008 reports initially unable to bear weight, equivalent to unable to ambulate. E2: Initial inability to ambulate after injury is not stated; generated only notes current ability to put little weight and limping. E3-noV: Initial inability to ambulate after injury is not stated; generated only notes current limited weight bearing. | covered | omitted | omitted |
Now able to bear some weight on right ankle but still limpingHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “she is now able to bear some weight on her right ankle, but she is still limping.” E1: Gen-009 reports now able to put slight weight on ankle but limping. E2: gen-006 Able to put little weight on ankle and gen-007 Patient is limping cover now able to bear some weight but limping. E3-noV: gen-007 reports able to bear little weight, still limping, semantically equivalent to able to bear some weight but limping. | covered | covered | covered |
Pain rated 6 out of 10History of Present IllnessGold note: “The patient rates her pain level as a 6 out of 10.” E1: Gen-005 states pain now rated 6/10. E2: gen-004 Constant throbbing pain rated 6/10 includes pain rated 6 out of 10. E3-noV: gen-006 includes pain rated 6/10. | covered | covered | covered |
Pain described as constant and throbbingHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Ms. Diaz describes her pain as constant and throbbing.” E1: Gen-006 states pain is constant and throbbing. E2: gen-004 Constant throbbing pain rated 6/10 includes constant and throbbing description. E3-noV: gen-006 describes pain as constant and throbbing. | covered | covered | covered |
Right ankle is warm to the touchHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “She reports that her right ankle is warm to the touch.” E1: Gen-007 states ankle feels warm to touch. E2: gen-005 Ankle warm to touch matches right ankle warm to touch. E3-noV: gen-008 states ankle feels warm, matching warm to touch. | covered | covered | covered |
Denies numbness or tingling in right footHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “She denies any numbness or tingling in her right foot.” E1: Denial of numbness/tingling in right foot is not present in generated facts. E2: gen-011 No numbness in foot and gen-012 No tingling in foot cover denial of numbness/tingling. E3-noV: gen-011 reports no numbness or tingling. | omitted | covered | covered |
Patient has been icing and elevating right ankleHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “The patient has been icing and elevating her right ankle” E1: Gen-010 includes icing and elevation as tried measures. E2: gen-008 Ankle iced and gen-009 Ankle elevated cover icing and elevating. E3-noV: gen-009 includes icing and elevation tried. | covered | covered | covered |
Utilized ibuprofen last night and this morning without reliefHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “while also utilizing ibuprofen last night and this morning, which did not provide her with any relief.” E1: Gen-010 and Gen-013 document ibuprofen last night and this morning with little/no relief. E2: gen-010 Took ibuprofen last night and this morning with no relief matches utilization without relief. E3-noV: gen-014 notes ibuprofen last night and this morning and gen-010 notes ibuprofen not helpful. | covered | covered | covered |
Used to play a lot of soccer in high schoolHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “The patient states that she used to play a lot of soccer in high school” E1: Gen-012 notes history of playing soccer in high school. E2: gen-016 Played soccer in high school matches used to play a lot of soccer in high school. E3-noV: gen-015 and gen-012 note played soccer in high school. | covered | covered | covered |
History of other right foot injuriesHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “she notes that she has had other right foot injuries but not like this.” E1: Gen-012 references other injuries with soccer history; consistent with history of other right foot injuries. E2: History of other right foot injuries is not captured; generated instead states no previous injury to this specific ankle. E3-noV: History of other right foot injuries is not explicitly captured; generated only mentions generic other injuries. | covered | omitted | omitted |
History of prior right foot injuriesPast Medical HistoryGold note: “she notes that she has had other right foot injuries but not like this.” E1: Past medical history of prior right foot injuries is reflected in Gen-012. E2: Past medical history of prior right foot injuries is absent from generated facts. E3-noV: Past medical history of prior right foot injuries is not explicitly stated. | covered | omitted | omitted |
Ibuprofen used last night and this morningMedicationsGold note: “utilizing ibuprofen last night and this morning” E1: Gen-013 states ibuprofen taken last night and this morning. E2: gen-015 Took ibuprofen last night and this morning matches medication use. E3-noV: gen-014 confirms ibuprofen used last night and this morning. | covered | covered | covered |
Played soccer in high schoolSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “she used to play a lot of soccer in high school” E1: Gen-012 includes played soccer in high school. E2: gen-016 Played soccer in high school matches social history. E3-noV: gen-015 states played soccer in high school. | covered | covered | covered |
Assessment is right ankle sprainAssessmentGold note: “Right ankle sprain.” E1: Gen-015 gives provisional diagnosis right ankle sprain. E2: gen-017 Right ankle sprain medium grade provisional is semantically the assessment of right ankle sprain. E3-noV: gen-016 reports right ankle sprain provisional. | covered | covered | covered |
X-ray of right ankle shows no fracture or bony abnormalitiesAssessmentGold note: “X-ray of the right ankle taken in office today reveals no fracture or bony abnormalities.” E1: Gen-016 reports X-ray reviewed with no fractures or bony abnormalities. E2: gen-018 Ankle X-ray shows no fractures or bony abnormalities matches X-ray findings. E3-noV: gen-017 states ankle X-ray shows no fractures or bony abnormalities. | covered | covered | covered |
Treat patient conservativelyPlan of CareGold note: “I have recommended that we treat the patient conservatively.” E1: Explicit statement to treat conservatively is not present; only specific conservative measures are listed. E2: Conservative treatment recommendation is not explicitly stated in generated plan facts. E3-noV: Conservative treatment recommendation is not explicitly stated. | omitted | omitted | omitted |
Keep right leg elevated when seatedPlan of CareGold note: “I have advised her to keep her right leg elevated when she is seated.” E1: Gen-019 advises keep leg elevated when seated. E2: gen-024 Keep leg elevated when seated matches elevation advice. E3-noV: gen-022 advises keep leg elevated when seated. | covered | covered | covered |
Ice right ankle 5 times per day for 20 minutes at a timePlan of CareGold note: “I have also advised her to ice her right ankle 5 times per day for 20 minutes at a time to help with the swelling.” E1: Gen-020 advises ice ankle 5 times a day for 20 minutes at a time. E2: gen-025 Ice ankle 5 times a day for 20 minutes at a time matches icing regimen. E3-noV: gen-023 matches ice 5 times per day for 20 minutes. | covered | covered | covered |
Place patient in Aircast to stabilize anklePlan of CareGold note: “I have also recommended that the patient be placed in an Aircast to stabilize the ankle.” E1: Gen-017 orders air cast application to stabilize ankle. E2: gen-021 Air cast ordered matches placement in Aircast to stabilize. E3-noV: gen-020 reports air cast application. | covered | covered | covered |
Remain non-weight-bearing for 1 to 2 daysPlan of CareGold note: “She will remain non-weight-bearing for 1 to 2 days,” E1: Gen-021 states stay off leg for 1-2 days. E2: gen-023 Stay off leg for 1-2 days matches remain non-weight-bearing for 1 to 2 days. E3-noV: gen-024 stay off leg for 1-2 days matches non-weight-bearing 1 to 2 days. | covered | covered | covered |
Crutches provided todayPlan of CareGold note: “we provided her with crutches today,” E1: Gen-018 orders crutches provision. E2: gen-022 Crutches ordered matches crutches provided today. E3-noV: gen-021 reports crutches provision. | covered | covered | covered |
Begin weight-bearing as tolerated after non-weight-bearing periodPlan of CareGold note: “and then she can begin weight-bearing as tolerated.” E1: Gen-021 includes then walk as tolerated after non-weight-bearing period. E2: Begin weight-bearing as tolerated after non-weight-bearing period is not present in generated facts. E3-noV: Begin weight-bearing as tolerated after non-weight-bearing period is not stated. | covered | omitted | omitted |
If pain does not improve over next week, contact office for MRIFollow up InformationGold note: “If her pain does not improve over the next week, she will contact the office and we will obtain an MRI.” E1: Gen-022 and Gen-023 advise return/review after one week and possible MRI if not improving. E2: gen-026 Review if pain continues after one week captures the follow-up timing; MRI conditionality is not fully captured but follow-up concept is present. E3-noV: Conditional MRI if pain does not improve over next week is not captured; generated instead states MRI ordered. | covered | covered | omitted |
Blood pressure 120/80Physical FindingsGold note: “BP: 120/80” E1: Blood pressure 120/80 is not present in generated facts. E2: Blood pressure 120/80 is not present in generated physical findings. E3-noV: Blood pressure 120/80 is absent from generated facts. | omitted | omitted | omitted |
SpO2 98%Physical FindingsGold note: “SPO2: 98%.” E1: SpO2 98% is not present in generated facts. E2: SpO2 98% is not present in generated facts. E3-noV: SpO2 98% is absent from generated facts. | omitted | omitted | omitted |
Capillary refill less than 3 secondsPhysical FindingsGold note: “Capillary refill is less than 3 seconds.” E1: Gen-029 reports capillary refill < 3 seconds. E2: gen-032 Capillary refill time less than 3 seconds matches. E3-noV: gen-031 capillary reload <3 seconds matches capillary refill less than 3 seconds. | covered | covered | covered |
Strong dorsalis pedis pulsePhysical FindingsGold note: “Strong dorsalis pedis pulse.” E1: Gen-030 reports strong dorsalis pedis pulse. E2: gen-033 Strong dorsalis pedis pulse matches. E3-noV: gen-032 reports strong dorsalis pedis pulse. | covered | covered | covered |
Normal sensationPhysical FindingsGold note: “Normal sensation.” E1: Gen-031 reports sensation intact to light touch, equivalent to normal sensation. E2: gen-034 Sensation intact to light touch matches normal sensation. E3-noV: gen-033 reports sensation intact to light touch. | covered | covered | covered |
Sensation intact to light touch distallyPhysical FindingsGold note: “Sensation is intact to light touch distally.” E1: Gen-031 reports sensation intact to light touch distally. E2: gen-034 Sensation intact to light touch covers sensation intact to light touch distally. E3-noV: gen-033 sensation intact to light touch covers distal intact sensation. | covered | covered | covered |
Ecchymosis over lateral malleolus with associated swellingPhysical FindingsGold note: “Examination of the right ankle reveals ecchymosis over the lateral malleolus associated with swelling.” E1: Gen-024 ecchymosis of lateral malleolus and Gen-025 swelling present. E2: gen-028 Ecchymosis of lateral malleolus and gen-029 Swelling of right ankle cover ecchymosis with swelling. E3-noV: gen-027 ecchymosis of lateral malleolus and gen-028 swelling of right ankle together cover finding. | covered | covered | covered |
Tenderness to palpation anterolaterally in soft tissuePhysical FindingsGold note: “Tenderness to palpation anterolaterally in the soft tissue.” E1: Gen-026 reports tenderness to palpation anterior lateral soft tissue. E2: gen-027 Tenderness to palpation on right ankle covers anterolateral soft tissue tenderness. E3-noV: gen-026 tenderness to palpation on right ankle covers anterolateral soft tissue tenderness. | covered | covered | covered |
No laxity on anterior drawer or inversion stressPhysical FindingsGold note: “No laxity on anterior drawer or inversion stress.” E1: Gen-027 reports no laxity on anterior drawer and inversion stress. E2: gen-030 No laxity on anterior drawer and inversion stress tests matches. E3-noV: gen-029 no laxity on anterior drawer and inversion stress tests. | covered | covered | covered |
No bony tenderness on palpation of footPhysical FindingsGold note: “No bony tenderness on palpation of the foot.” E1: Gen-028 reports no bony tenderness on palpation of foot. E2: gen-031 No bony tenderness on palpation of foot matches. E3-noV: gen-030 no bony tenderness on palpation of foot. | covered | covered | covered |
Musculoskeletal positive for right ankle painReview of SystemsGold note: “Musculoskeletal: Positive right ankle pain.” E1: Review of systems musculoskeletal positive for right ankle pain is not explicitly listed. E2: Musculoskeletal positive right ankle pain is implied by chief complaint and HPI pain facts. E3-noV: Musculoskeletal ROS positive for right ankle pain is not explicitly listed. | omitted | covered | omitted |
Skin positive for warmth to right footReview of SystemsGold note: “Skin: Positive warmth to the right foot.” E1: Warmth to right foot is captured by Gen-007 ankle feels warm to touch. E2: Skin positive warmth to right foot is covered by gen-005 Ankle warm to touch. E3-noV: Warmth to right foot is covered by gen-008 ankle feels warm. | covered | covered | covered |
Neurological denies numbness or tinglingReview of SystemsGold note: “Neurological: Denies any numbness or tingling.” E1: Neurological denial of numbness/tingling is not explicitly stated in generated facts. E2: gen-035 No numbness in foot and gen-036 No tingling in foot cover neurological denial. E3-noV: gen-034 reports no numbness or tingling, matching neurological denial. | omitted | covered | covered |
For each config: the note facts the judge did not find in the doctor's note (or found conflicting with it), and whether the transcript backs them. The first chip is the transcript check, the second the comparison with the doctor's note.
+Presenting complaint: “I've been having really bad diarrhoea for the last 3 days”. All three notes come from Qwen3.6-35B-A3B on the same gold transcript, with the same prompt rules and the same few-shot example. The Muse Glimmer judge (high reasoning) compared each note with the doctor's note and the transcript. This encounter shows the usual pattern. Coverage: E1 0.82, E2 0.73, E3 0.70.
+Coverage is the share of the 33 facts in the doctor's note that the generated note contains. "Not backed by transcript" counts note facts that are absent from the doctor's note and that the judge could not find in the transcript, or that contradict it; the hallucination rate divides that count by the number of note facts.
+| Config | Coverage | Gold facts covered | Omitted | Conflicting | Note facts | Not backed by transcript | Hallucination rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | 0.82 | 27/33 | 4 | 2 | 39 | 0 | 0.000 |
| E2 | 0.73 | 24/33 | 7 | 2 | 33 | 1 | 0.030 |
| E3-noV | 0.70 | 23/33 | 8 | 2 | 38 | 0 | 0.000 |
Doctor Uh no, it is, yes.
Doctor Hello?
Patient Hi.
Doctor Can you hear me OK? Great. Hello there. Um, before I go any further, can I confirm you name and your age please?
Patient Yes. So, my name is Robert.
Doctor Robert?
Patient Yep.
Doctor OK.
Patient Um, I'm forty eight.
Doctor OK. Great.
Doctor Excellent. And how can I help you this afternoon, sir?
Patient Right, so, uh, I've been having, uh, diarrhoea, for like, let's say past three days, more or less.
Doctor OK, well I'm sorry to hear that. Uh can you tell me a bit more about your diarrhoea?
Patient Yeah, so it's been a, very bad diarrhoea, so it keeps me like, I keep going back and forth, to, to the toilet very often.
Doctor Right.
Patient Um, yeah it started like three days ago.
Doctor Mm-hmm.
Patient And uh, uh, so it started with vomiting, so I vomited a couple of times. Uh, but then, that went away, and, uh, yeah it's just diarrhoea now.
Doctor OK. And you mentioned you've been um going to the toilet very often. How many times are you going a day?
Patient Yeah, around, five to six times a day.
Doctor OK. And uh uh can you tell me, I know it's not nice to talk about, but is it quite watery, your stools, loose?
Patient Yes, it's definitely, definitely watery, uh, loose stools, yeah.
Doctor OK.
Doctor K. Any blood in your stools?
Patient No, not that I could see.
Doctor OK. And uh uh uh with the diarrhea have you noticed any other symptoms, like tummy pain?
Patient Uh, not, not really, no. Uh, but I, I, I feel like, um, I can't, really drink too much, so I feel very dehydrated.
Doctor OK. When you say you can't drink too much, why is that?
Patient Uh, yeah because, really I, uh I, um, I'm like, I feel like I don't drink enough, like I'm, I'm drink, I'm trying to drink, but then I just go to the loo, and I like, I, uh I, I, I do everything and I feel dehydrated again.
Doctor OK, alright. Um have you managed to eat anything, solids?
Patient Uh, not much, not much. So just a little bit, but I don't feel, um, I don't really feel like, uh, I have appetite.
Doctor OK. You . OK. Um with your um, the vomiting has now stopped. Is that right? You said
Patient Yes, yes.
Doctor OK, alright. Have you had any other symptoms, like fever or temperature?
Patient Uh, so, not, really I , I feel a little bit warm, um, probably at, at the beginning I was feeling I had a bit of temperature, but now I feel, I feel kind of fine.
Doctor OK.
Patient I feel very weak though.
Doctor OK. Alright. Any headaches or muscle pains?
Patient Not, not really, no.
Doctor OK, alright. And you mentioned three days ago. What were you doing when the symptoms started? Are you aware of any triggers?
Patient , not that I, I remember, what was I doing, I, I was at home I was working, on my computer and.
Patient Yeah, just felt, like some nausea and I had to, to vomit, and then I had some diarrhoea, straight after that.
Doctor Yeah. Did you have any takeaway food, or any dodgy restaurant food?
Patient Uh, not that I remember, no.
Doctor OK. Have you been around anyone unwell, with diarrhea recently, last week or so?
Patient Hmm, not that I know, not that I.
Doctor OK. OK. Um, right. So moving on, um are you otherwise fit and well?
Patient Yeah, yeah, .
Doctor Uh OK. And do you take any regular medications?
Patient Um, so I, I do suffer of asthma. So, I do have my inhalers, uh, that I you know, I need, I use infrequently, let's say only when I have, uh, a bit of .
Doctor Is that, is that inhaler?
Patient Sorry?
Doctor Is that the blue inhaler? Blue inhaler. OK, alright. Any other medications that you take?
Patient Yes it is, yeah.
Patient Uh, no, nothing.
Doctor OK. Do you have any allergies to medications?
Patient Um, not that I know of.
Doctor OK. And any family history of any medical problems?
Patient Um, so, my father has, high uh, well used to have high blood pressure. He actually, so he actually died, of, bowel cancer, like ten years ago.
Doctor OK. Sorry to hear that. Um, OK. And uh what about your mother?
Patient Ohh yes, so uh, probably is worth mentioning uh, she has diabetes.
Doctor Diabetes. Do you know if that's type one or type two?
Patient Uh, it's type two.
Doctor OK. Alright.
Doctor Fine. And um, just a little bit more about your life in general, sir. Um who, who's at home with you? Who lives at home with you?
Patient Sorry?
Doctor Who lives at home with you, sir?
Patient Ohh I, I live alone.
Doctor You live alone, OK. Are you currently working at the moment?
Patient Uh, well I haven't been able to work in the past few days, but yes , like given, uh, my uh.
Doctor What's your employment? What do you do for work?
Patient I'm a software engineer.
Doctor . OK, alright.
Doctor Have you taken time off work recently?
Patient Uh, yes, yes I have, uh. Uh, these last three days I've been feeling, really unwell, so I couldn't work.
Doctor OK, alright. And just the last couple of questions with, regarding your smoking and alcohol. Do you do either of those?
Patient Uh, not really, I drink infrequently, like socially let's say, and I don't smoke.
Doctor OK, alright. Um fine. uh Robert um
Doctor having listened to your story, I think you're probably suffering from what we call gastroenteritis, uh which essentially is just a, a tummy bug. It's an infection of your, your tummy. Um and normally lasts about three to five days, and gets better.
Patient OK.
Patient All right.
Doctor the things you can do to really help yourself get better soon, um are you can drink plenty of fluids. Really try and flush the toxins out of your body.
Patient OK.
Doctor Uh you can get things from the pharmacy, which is called Dioralyte, which can help replenish any uh minerals and vitamins you may have lost. Uh, it's called Dioralyte. Um it's, it's a, it's a type of fluid replacement drink.
Patient I'm sorry, what's the name of that?
Doctor Um, you can take some Paracetamol if you're feeling feverish and weak.
Patient All right.
Doctor I would probably advise you to continue taking time off work for next day or two, until you get better.
Doctor normally you have to be diarrhea-free for about twenty four to forty eight hours, before you return back to work.
Patient OK.
Doctor Um, let's see how the next few days go. And if you're still not better next week, I want you to come back and see me.
Doctor And we can have another look at your symptoms, OK?
Patient That sounds good, that sounds good. Uh, thanks so much.
Doctor Thanks. do you have any questions for me, or?
Patient Um, no I think that's fine. Uh, yeah I'll, I'll try to , and drink , drink plenty of fluid and I hope it go away. Uh, if it doesn't I'll uh, I'll call, I'll call back. Is that OK?
Doctor I really hope you get better soon.
Patient Thanks a lot. Thanks so much, for your time.
Doctor OK. Bye bye.
Patient OK. Bye.
3/7 hx ago developed vomiting. Has now developed diarrhea - 5-6x/day. Watery/loose stools. No blood in stools. No abdo pain. +Reduced oral intake. Not drinking sufficient fluids. Feels dehydrated. Appetite reduced. +No fever/temp, but feels warm. Feels weak. No headaches/muscle pain. +Unaware of triggers. No unwell contacts + +PMH: asthma +DH: salbutamol PRN +NKDA +FH: father - HTN, died of bowel Ca. mother - diabetes Type 2 +SH: lives alone , software engineer. Nil smoking, social EtOH + +Imp: gastroenteritis + +Plan: +1. Supportive mx - rest, fluids +2. OTC diarolyte +3. Regular paracetamol +4. Review in 3-5d INB, or earlier if worsening sx (diarrhea, vomiting, abdo pain, reduced oral intake) +
Note straight from the transcript
CHIEF COMPLAINT +DIARRHOEA X 3 DAYS, ASSO - VOMITING (RESOLVED), DEHYDRATION, WEAKNESS + +HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS +PATIENT PRESENTS WITH 3-DAY HISTORY OF WATERY LOOSE STOOLS (5-6 TIMES/DAY). ONSET WAS PRECEDED BY VOMITING (RESOLVED). REPORTS SIGNIFICANT DEHYDRATION DESPITE FLUID INTAKE AND REDUCED APPETITE. NO ABDOMINAL PAIN. NO BLOOD IN STOOLS. NO CURRENT FEVER, THOUGH FELT WARM AT ONSET. NO HEADACHE OR MUSCLE PAIN. NO KNOWN TRIGGERS OR SICK CONTACTS. + +PAST MEDICAL HISTORY +ASTHMA. + +MEDICATION HISTORY +USES BLUE INHALER FOR ASTHMA INFREQUENTLY. NO OTHER REGULAR MEDICATIONS. + +FAMILY HISTORY +FATHER: HYPERTENSION (HISTORY), BOWEL CANCER (DECEASED 10 YEARS AGO). MOTHER: TYPE 2 DIABETES. + +PERSONAL AND SOCIAL HISTORY +SOFTWARE ENGINEER. LIVES ALONE. NON-SMOKER. SOCIAL ALCOHOL USE ONLY. WORK AFFECTED FOR 3 DAYS. + +REVIEW OF SYSTEMS +NO HEADACHE OR MUSCLE PAINS REPORTED. + +PHYSICAL EXAMINATION +EXAMINATION NOT PERFORMED + +DIAGNOSIS +CURRENT: +GASTROENTERITIS (PROVISIONAL) + +ALLERGY +NO KNOWN ALLERGY + +ORDERS +MEDICATION +DIORALYTE (ORAL REHYDRATION SALTS) **ORAL** - AS NEEDED (OTC) +PARACETAMOL **ORAL** SOS (IF FEELING FEVERISH AND WEAK.) - AS NEEDED (OTC) + +ADVICE +DRINK PLENTY OF FLUIDS. TAKE TIME OFF WORK FOR 1-2 DAYS. RETURN IF NOT BETTER NEXT WEEK. + +FOLLOW-UP +REVIEW AFTER 1 WEEK IF NOT BETTER +
Note from all extracted facts, no evidence
CHIEF COMPLAINT +DIARRHOEA X 3 DAYS, ASSO - VOMITING (RESOLVED), NAUSEA (RESOLVED), WEAKNESS, POOR APPETITE + +HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS +VOMITING AT ONSET (3 DAYS AGO), NOW STOPPED +SUBJECTIVE FEVER AT ONSET, RESOLVED +NAUSEA AT ONSET (3 DAYS AGO) +DEHYDRATED, UNABLE TO RETAIN FLUIDS +POOR APPETITE +WEAKNESS +NO BLOOD IN STOOLS +NO ABDOMINAL PAIN +NO FEVER +NO HEADACHES +NO MUSCLE PAINS + +PAST MEDICAL HISTORY +ASTHMA + +MEDICATION HISTORY +BLUE ASTHMA INHALER (PRN) + +FAMILY HISTORY +FATHER: HYPERTENSION +FATHER: BOWEL CANCER (DECEASED 10 YEARS AGO) +MOTHER: TYPE 2 DIABETES + +PERSONAL AND SOCIAL HISTORY +OCCUPATION: SOFTWARE ENGINEER +LIVES ALONE +NON-SMOKER +ALCOHOL: SOCIAL (INFREQUENT) + +PHYSICAL EXAMINATION +EXAMINATION NOT PERFORMED OR NOT DOCUMENTED IN FACTS PROVIDED. NOTE: FACTS DO NOT INCLUDE PHYSICAL EXAMINATION FINDINGS. STATUS SET TO NOT_PERFORMED AS NO EXAMINATION DATA IS PROVIDED IN FACTS. HOWEVER, RULES SAY 'NOT_PERFORMED' WHEN CLINICIAN DID NOT EXAMINE. IF FACTS DON'T MENTION EXAM, IT'S OFTEN 'NOT_DISCUSSED' OR 'NOT_PERFORMED'. GIVEN THE STRICT 'ONLY FACTS PROVIDED', AND NO EXAM FACTS, I'LL + +DIAGNOSIS +CURRENT: +GASTROENTERITIS (PROVISIONAL) + +ALLERGY +NO KNOWN ALLERGY + +ORDERS +MEDICATION +DIORALYTE +PARACETAMOL + +ADVICE +DRINK PLENTY OF FLUIDS +TIME OFF WORK 1-2 DAYS; RETURN IF DIARRHOEA-FREE 24-48 HOURS + +FOLLOW-UP +REVIEW IF SYMPTOMS PERSIST NEXT WEEK +
Note from evidence-linked facts with their transcript quotes
CHIEF COMPLAINT +DIARRHOEA X 3 DAYS, ASSO - WEAKNESS, POOR APPETITE, DEHYDRATION + +HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS +DIARRHOEA X 3 DAYS +VOMITING AT ONSET, NOW RESOLVED +NAUSEA AT ONSET +SUBJECTIVE FEVER AT ONSET, NOW RESOLVED +DEHYDRATION, POOR FLUID RETENTION +POOR APPETITE +WEAKNESS +NO BLOOD IN STOOLS +NO ABDOMINAL PAIN +NO FEVER CURRENTLY +NO HEADACHES +NO MUSCLE PAINS + +PAST MEDICAL HISTORY +H/O ASTHMA + +MEDICATION HISTORY +BLUE ASTHMA INHALER (PRN) + +FAMILY HISTORY +FATHER: H/O HYPERTENSION +FATHER: DECEASED FROM BOWEL CANCER (10 YRS AGO) +MOTHER: H/O TYPE 2 DIABETES + +PERSONAL AND SOCIAL HISTORY +OCCUPATION: SOFTWARE ENGINEER +LIVES ALONE +NON-SMOKER +SOCIAL DRINKER (INFREQUENT) + +PHYSICAL EXAMINATION +EXAMINATION NOT PERFORMED + +DIAGNOSIS +CURRENT: +GASTROENTERITIS (PROVISIONAL) + +ALLERGY +NO KNOWN ALLERGY + +ORDERS +MEDICATION +DIORALYTE (OTC) +PARACETAMOL (OTC) + +ADVICE +INCREASE ORAL FLUID INTAKE +REST; TIME OFF WORK 1-2 DAYS; RETURN IF DIARRHOEA-FREE 24-48H + +FOLLOW-UP +REVIEW IF STILL NOT BETTER NEXT WEEK +
| Gold fact (open a row for the judge's reasons) | E1 | E2 | E3-noV |
|---|---|---|---|
Vomiting developed 3/7 days agoHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “3/7 hx ago developed vomiting.” E1: Vomiting timing 3/7 days ago is not captured; generated only notes vomiting resolved / preceded onset without the 3-7 day timeframe. E2: Generated states vomiting at onset 3 days ago / vomiting resolved, consistent with vomiting developed 3/7 days ago. E3-noV: Gen-006 states vomiting at onset now resolved and Gen-005/Gen-001 state diarrhoea for 3 days, consistent with vomiting developing ~3/7 days ago. | omitted | covered | covered |
Diarrhea developed nowHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Has now developed diarrhea - 5-6x/day.” E1: Diarrhoea for 3 days / 3-day history of watery loose stools covers diarrhea developed now. E2: Gold says diarrhea developed now; generated says diarrhoea for 3 days, implying onset 3 days ago. E3-noV: Gold says diarrhea developed now. Generated states diarrhoea for 3 days, Gen-001/Gen-005, which conflicts with onset timing. | covered | conflicts | conflicts |
Diarrhea frequency is 5-6 times per dayHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “diarrhea - 5-6x/day.” E1: Gen-006 states stools frequency 5-6 times a day, matching gold. E2: Diarrhea frequency 5-6 times per day is not mentioned in generated facts. E3-noV: Diarrhea frequency 5-6x/day is not mentioned in any generated fact. | covered | omitted | omitted |
Stools are watery/looseHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Watery/loose stools.” E1: Gen-005 reports 3-day history of watery loose stools. E2: Watery/loose stools not mentioned in generated facts. E3-noV: Watery/loose stools are not mentioned in generated facts. | covered | omitted | omitted |
No blood in stoolsHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “No blood in stools.” E1: Gen-011 explicitly states No blood in stools. E2: Gen-029 explicitly states No blood in stools. E3-noV: Gen-012 No blood in stools and Gen-034 Denies blood in stools cover the concept. | covered | covered | covered |
No abdominal painHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “No abdo pain.” E1: Gen-010 states No abdominal pain. E2: Gen-030 explicitly states No abdominal pain. E3-noV: Gen-013 No abdominal pain and Gen-035 Denies abdominal pain cover the concept. | covered | covered | covered |
Reduced oral intakeHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Reduced oral intake.” E1: Reduced oral intake is not explicitly stated in generated facts. E2: Reduced oral intake is implied by Gen-009 dehydrated, unable to retain fluids. E3-noV: Reduced oral intake is not explicitly stated; only dehydration and advice to increase fluids are present. | omitted | covered | omitted |
Not drinking sufficient fluidsHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Not drinking sufficient fluids.” E1: Gold says not drinking sufficient fluids; gen-008 says significant dehydration despite fluid intake, implying fluids are being taken. E2: Not drinking sufficient fluids is implied by Gen-009 dehydrated, unable to retain fluids. E3-noV: Gen-009 Dehydration with poor fluid retention implies not drinking sufficient fluids. | conflicts | covered | covered |
Patient feels dehydratedHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Feels dehydrated.” E1: Gen-003 Associated with dehydration and gen-008 significant dehydration cover feels dehydrated. E2: Gen-009 states Dehydrated, unable to retain fluids. E3-noV: Gen-004 Associated with dehydration and Gen-009 Dehydration with poor fluid retention cover patient feels dehydrated. | covered | covered | covered |
Appetite reducedHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Appetite reduced.” E1: Gen-009 reduced appetite. E2: Gen-005 and Gen-010 state Poor appetite. E3-noV: Gen-003 Associated with poor appetite and Gen-010 Poor appetite cover appetite reduced. | covered | covered | covered |
No fever or temperature recordedHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “No fever/temp,” E1: Gen-012 No current fever covers no fever/temp recorded. E2: Gold says no fever/temp; generated includes Gen-007 subjective fever at onset, resolved, conflicting with no fever. E3-noV: Gold says no fever/temp recorded. Generated states Subjective fever at onset, now resolved Gen-008, contradicting no fever. | covered | conflicts | conflicts |
Patient feels warmHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “but feels warm.” E1: Gen-013 felt warm at onset corresponds to patient feels warm. E2: Patient feels warm is not mentioned in generated facts. E3-noV: Patient feels warm is not mentioned in generated facts. | covered | omitted | omitted |
Patient feels weakHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Feels weak.” E1: Gen-004 Associated with weakness. E2: Gen-004 and Gen-011 state Weakness. E3-noV: Gen-002 Associated with weakness and Gen-011 Weakness cover patient feels weak. | covered | covered | covered |
No headachesHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “No headaches/muscle pain.” E1: Gen-014 No headache. E2: Gen-032 states No headaches. E3-noV: Gen-015 No headaches and Gen-037 Denies headaches cover no headaches. | covered | covered | covered |
No muscle painHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “No headaches/muscle pain.” E1: Gen-015 No muscle pain. E2: Gen-033 states No muscle pains. E3-noV: Gen-016 No muscle pains and Gen-038 Denies muscle pains cover no muscle pain. | covered | covered | covered |
Unaware of triggersHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Unaware of triggers.” E1: Gen-016 No known triggers. E2: Unaware of triggers is not present in generated facts. E3-noV: Unaware of triggers is not present in generated facts. | covered | omitted | omitted |
No unwell contactsHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “No unwell contacts” E1: Gen-017 No sick contacts. E2: No unwell contacts is not present in generated facts. E3-noV: No unwell contacts is not present in generated facts. | covered | omitted | omitted |
Past medical history includes asthmaPast Medical HistoryGold note: “PMH: asthma” E1: Gen-018 History of asthma. E2: Gen-012 states Asthma. E3-noV: Gen-017 History of asthma covers PMH asthma. | covered | covered | covered |
Salbutamol taken as neededMedicationsGold note: “DH: salbutamol PRN” E1: Gen-019 Uses blue inhaler for asthma infrequently is semantically salbutamol PRN. E2: Gen-013 blue asthma inhaler PRN is semantically salbutamol PRN. E3-noV: Gen-018 Blue asthma inhaler PRN is semantically salbutamol PRN. | covered | covered | covered |
No known drug allergiesAdverse Drug Reactions and AllergiesGold note: “NKDA” E1: Gen-021 No known allergy. E2: Gen-014 states No known allergy. E3-noV: Gen-019 No known allergy covers NKDA. | covered | covered | covered |
Father has hypertensionFamily HistoryGold note: “father - HTN” E1: Gen-022 Father history of hypertension. E2: Gen-015 states Father has hypertension. E3-noV: Gen-020 Father has history of hypertension covers father HTN. | covered | covered | covered |
Father died of bowel cancerFamily HistoryGold note: “died of bowel Ca.” E1: Gen-023 Father history of bowel cancer deceased. E2: Gen-016 states Father had bowel cancer, deceased. E3-noV: Gen-021 Father deceased from bowel cancer 10 years ago is consistent with father died of bowel Ca. | covered | covered | covered |
Mother has type 2 diabetesFamily HistoryGold note: “mother - diabetes Type 2” E1: Gen-024 Mother has type 2 diabetes. E2: Gen-017 states Mother has type 2 diabetes. E3-noV: Gen-022 Mother has history of type 2 diabetes covers mother diabetes Type 2. | covered | covered | covered |
Patient lives aloneSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “lives alone” E1: Gen-026 Lives alone. E2: Gen-019 states Lives alone. E3-noV: Gen-024 Lives alone covers patient lives alone. | covered | covered | covered |
Occupation is software engineerSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “software engineer” E1: Gen-025 Occupation software engineer. E2: Gen-018 states Occupation is software engineer. E3-noV: Gen-023 Occupation is software engineer matches. | covered | covered | covered |
No smokingSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “Nil smoking” E1: Gen-027 Non-smoker. E2: Gen-020 states Non-smoker. E3-noV: Gen-025 Non-smoker covers nil smoking. | covered | covered | covered |
Social alcohol useSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “social EtOH” E1: Gen-028 Social alcohol use only. E2: Gen-021 alcohol use social infrequent matches social EtOH. E3-noV: Gen-026 Social drinker infrequent is semantically social EtOH use. | covered | covered | covered |
Impression is gastroenteritisAssessmentGold note: “Imp: gastroenteritis” E1: Gen-030 Provisional diagnosis gastroenteritis. E2: Gen-022 provisional diagnosis of gastroenteritis. E3-noV: Gen-027 Provisional diagnosis of gastroenteritis matches impression gastroenteritis. | covered | covered | covered |
Supportive management with rest and fluidsPlan of CareGold note: “Supportive mx - rest, fluids” E1: Gen-033 Advice to drink plenty of fluids and gen-034 time off work cover supportive management with rest and fluids. E2: Gen-025 advice to drink plenty of fluids and Gen-026 time off work cover supportive management with rest and fluids. E3-noV: Gen-031 Advice rest and Gen-030 Advice to increase oral fluid intake cover supportive mx rest, fluids. | covered | covered | covered |
Over-the-counter diarolyte recommendedPlan of CareGold note: “OTC diarolyte” E1: Gen-031 Dioralyte oral rehydration salts OTC as needed. E2: Gen-023 medication Dioralyte ordered matches OTC diarolyte. E3-noV: Gen-028 Order Dioralyte over the counter matches OTC diarolyte. | covered | covered | covered |
Regular paracetamol recommendedPlan of CareGold note: “Regular paracetamol” E1: Gold says regular paracetamol recommended; generated says paracetamol if needed for feverish and weak as needed. E2: Gen-024 medication Paracetamol ordered. E3-noV: Gen-029 Order Paracetamol over the counter matches regular paracetamol recommended. | conflicts | covered | covered |
Review in 3-5 days in clinicFollow up InformationGold note: “Review in 3-5d INB” E1: Gold review in 3-5 days is not present; generated advises review after 1 week if not better. E2: Review in 3-5 days in clinic is not present; generated gives review if symptoms persist next week. E3-noV: Review in 3-5 days in clinic is not present; generated says review if still not better next week. | omitted | omitted | omitted |
Review earlier if worsening symptoms of diarrhea, vomiting, abdominal pain, reduced oral intakeFollow up InformationGold note: “or earlier if worsening sx (diarrhea, vomiting, abdo pain, reduced oral intake)” E1: Early review for worsening diarrhea, vomiting, abdominal pain, reduced oral intake is not mentioned. E2: Review earlier if worsening symptoms of diarrhea, vomiting, abdominal pain, reduced oral intake is not present. E3-noV: Review earlier if worsening symptoms of diarrhea, vomiting, abdominal pain, reduced oral intake is not present. | omitted | omitted | omitted |
For each config: the note facts the judge did not find in the doctor's note (or found conflicting with it), and whether the transcript backs them. The first chip is the transcript check, the second the comparison with the doctor's note.
+Presenting complaint: “I've got a really bad headache”. All three notes come from Qwen3.6-35B-A3B on the same gold transcript, with the same prompt rules and the same few-shot example. The Muse Glimmer judge (high reasoning) compared each note with the doctor's note and the transcript. Picked as the PriMock57 test encounter with the largest E1–E3 coverage gap. Coverage: E1 0.86, E2 0.71, E3 0.45.
+Coverage is the share of the 42 facts in the doctor's note that the generated note contains. "Not backed by transcript" counts note facts that are absent from the doctor's note and that the judge could not find in the transcript, or that contradict it; the hallucination rate divides that count by the number of note facts.
+| Config | Coverage | Gold facts covered | Omitted | Conflicting | Note facts | Not backed by transcript | Hallucination rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | 0.86 | 36/42 | 6 | 0 | 38 | 0 | 0.000 |
| E2 | 0.71 | 30/42 | 11 | 1 | 39 | 2 | 0.051 |
| E3-noV | 0.45 | 19/42 | 22 | 1 | 23 | 0 | 0.000 |
Doctor Hello. Good afternoon.
Patient Hiya.
Doctor Hi there. This is Doctor , from GP at Hand.
Patient Hi there. My name's Atan.
Doctor Hi Anthony. So, could I have your um, before we start, could I have your full name and date of birth? If that's possible?
Patient Sure. So, it's Ayrton Warren. Um, and my date of birth, is the sixteenth of May, nineteen, eighty two.
Doctor That's , thank you for that. Are you in a private place where you're OK to speak?
Patient I am, yes.
Doctor OK, great. So how can I help you today?
Patient Um, so I kind of woke up this morning, um, and I've just got this, really horrible pain on the left side of my head. Um, a real kind of headachy feeling.
Doctor Sure, OK. And, um, uh, , did the, did the pain wake you up?
Patient Yeah, it woke me up, um, quite early this morning.
Doctor What, what time did it wake you up?
Patient Um, probably around, five thirty ish.
Doctor And, what time do you normally get up?
Patient Um, I normally get up at about, seven o'clock.
Doctor Is the headache still present now?
Patient Yes, it is.
Doctor OK. Have you had this kind of pain before?
Patient Um, I mean uh, I've, had a bit of a history with headaches, but nothing as severe as this before.
Doctor So they were less severe. Were they similar in nature in terms of being one-sided and the type of pain?
Patient Um, not so much on the one side, it tends to be, a bit of a cluster at the front of my head in a way. Um, but this time it's just kind of more prominent on the left side which, I've never really had it, normally they kind of spread across the front of my head.
Doctor OK, all right. And, um, can I just double-check, do you have any neck stiffness at all?
Patient Uh, no.
Doctor OK. And do you have any fever?
Patient No.
Doctor All right. Um, how are you with bright lights at the moment? Do you feel sensitive to bright lights or can you, can you tolerate them all right, OK?
Patient Um, it, I'm a little bit sensitive it just, it kind of, makes my eyes a little bit sore, but nothing that I can't really handle.
Doctor OK. And, can I just double-check, um, are you feeling nauseous at all?
Patient Um, not really, like . When I first got up this morning, my head felt a bit dizzy, but that's kind of subsided now, and I, seems to, be fine.
Doctor OK. Um, and um, can I just double-check, does anyone in your family have any migraines or anything like that? They've been diagnosed with migraines?
Patient Uh, no. They haven't.
Doctor OK. Um, and um, are you under any particular stress at the moment?
Patient Um, work's kind of, um, a bit stressful at the moment. I've got a lot going on.
Patient Um, yeah, I just seem to have like, a lot of, kind of, a backlog of work that I need to go through at the moment. So, I've kind of, been, doing a lot of late nights as well.
Doctor Right, OK. Um, and, um, how long has that been the case for?
Patient Uh, for probably about a couple of months now.
Doctor , how would you say your mood is?
Patient Um, I'm not, like moody, I'm not angry or, um, like I get a bit frustrated during the day. Um, but , it kind of, um, ebbs and flows every now and then, but, yeah.
Doctor OK. Do you have, have you ever been diagnosed with anxiety, or depression or stress in the past?
Patient Um, I've had, um, so I had, like anxiety for about, two years now, and I've been on, uh, Sertraline for, a while.
Doctor OK. Are you taking Sertraline at the moment?
Patient Yes.
Doctor OK. Um, and how do you feel in terms of , anxiety at the moment? Do you feel anxious at the moment?
Patient , no, not necessarily at work, sometimes I do feel a bit anxious. Um, but I, I kind of just, uh, the panic of not being able to get my work done on time.
Patient Um, but other than that, I, I don't, feel, um, massively anxious.
Doctor OK, all right. Um, now, sorry to ask this, just need to ask this for , anyone suffering from anxiety. Do you have any , have you had any thoughts about harming yourself or hurting yourself?
Patient No.
Doctor Good, I'm glad to hear that. Um, now, with regards to this headache. Is it worse when you lie down, or um, is, is, is it better when you lie down?
Patient Um, when I lay down, like, uh, it kind of feels a little bit sore at first, um and it takes me a while to get comfortable. Um, so yeah, at the beginning it does, but then again that's just kind of, um, soothes a little bit.
Doctor OK.
Doctor Um, so, would you say ultimately, it's better when you lie down? Or have you not ?
Patient Uh, yeah, I would say so.
Doctor OK. Um, and um, in terms of um, this, headache since this morning, have you taken anything for it yet?
Patient Um, I've taken some Paracetamol.
Doctor Has that helped?
Patient Um, not really, no.
Doctor OK. Taking anything else at all?
Patient No that's it, just Paracetamol.
Doctor OK. Um, do you have any other illnesses at all?
Patient Uh, none.
Doctor Have you ever been diagnosed with high blood pressure?
Patient No.
Doctor Have you ever had your blood pressure checked?
Patient No.
Doctor OK. Um, and are there any illnesses in your family?
Patient Um, no, there's nothing. My parents, uh, my mum's had a history of anxiety as well but, no kind of like physical illnesses or anything like that.
Doctor OK, all right. And um, are you on any medication?
Patient Um, no, other, other than Sertraline and having taken, um, Paracetamol this morning, uh, nothing else.
Doctor Do you have any allergies to any medication?
Patient Not that I'm aware of, no.
Doctor All right. And, are you living by yourself at the moment, or living with someone else?
Patient Um, I live with my partner.
Doctor OK. Are you a smoker?
Patient No.
Doctor OK. And, uh, do you have any pets at home?
Patient Uh, I have a cat.
Doctor OK. And, can I just double-check, how much exercise would you do normally a week?
Patient Um, so normally I, try to go running at least three times a week.
Doctor OK.
Doctor And what's your diet like?
Patient Um, it's OK, um, it's nothing, it's nothing um, really healthy, um, but it's fine.
Doctor OK.
Patient I wouldn't say unhealthy.
Doctor All right. Um, now um, in terms of this headache, uh, obviously I haven't been able to examine you, or see you directly.
Doctor But, um, it sounds like it might be one of two things. It could be an element of what we call tension headache.
Patient Sure.
Doctor OK. That's one possibility. Um, and what makes that, more likely is the fact that, you've been under some pressure, and you have a history of anxiety in the past, OK. Um.
Patient OK.
Doctor The other possibility is, um, migraine as well.
Doctor OK. Um, and, the fact, what makes that more likely is the fact that it's on one side, and that you've got some sensitivity to light.
Patient OK.
Doctor OK, So, what, what I think we can do, is um, I think we can give you some, um, generic, pain relief.
Patient OK.
Doctor That would be the appropriate first step, for, migraine type headaches. OK. So I'll tell you what it is in a second.
Patient OK.
Doctor And the other thing that I was gonna suggest is, we maybe look, explore things to try and decrease the stress from work.
Doctor So, um, the medication-wise, the things that we'd start off first line, if someone had migraine was to, would be to start Ibuprofen.
Patient OK.
Doctor And um, uh, that, the doses of Ibuprofen can be a bit, more than the normal doses Ibuprofen so that's one thing we can start. You can keep on taking Paracetamol as well if you like, but the, the Ibuprofen's um, actually more effective , for migraine.
Patient OK.
Doctor And, um, yeah, so the, the guidelines have changed, recently we used, we, before that we used to give Paracetamol as first line but now it's, um, Ibuprofen or Aspirin.
Patient Ohh right, O.
Doctor That's, thing. Um, the other thing I'd like you to do, is maybe consider taking some time off work. OK, because if the headache is due to stress from work.
Patient OK.
Patient OK.
Doctor Um, maybe having a week off if you self-certify, that might help with things. And I'd also like you to explore, counselling options as well so there's, a counselling service in your area, that I can give you the link for, for you to self-refer.
Doctor I'd like you to, , OK I'd like you to try that. Um, what, we're gonna do is, we'll have a follow-up in a week's time.
Patient Yeah, that'd be.
Doctor As well as those two things, other things I'd like you to do, is to try and ensure that you're having a minimum of seven, eight hours sleep at night, every night. And you're drinking a minimum of, um, one point five to two litres uh, of water or fluids a day, and that's not including coffee or tea.
Patient OK.
Patient OK.
Doctor All right, because sometimes dehydration and you know uh, fatigue can be causes of headaches as well. Um.
Patient Ohh OK, I didn't realise that.
Doctor Yeah, so it, that, that, that is um, you know, we need to rule those things out. Um, let's, let's try that.
Doctor OK. Um, and let's have a follow-up appointment, if we're finding that things are not getting better, we might need to arrange some blood tests or um, look at uh, other possibilities, but, we'll try that in the first instance.
Doctor Um, if anything changes in the meantime, or you get worried or things get worse. Feel free, have a lower threshold for ringing us back and we can book you an appointment, and we can reassess the situation.
Patient OK. Yeah, the, that, that sounds brilliant. Thank you so much for your help.
Doctor OK, no problem. So there'll be a summary of all of this in the notes. Um, and I'll also leave a link, to some of the danger signs of symptoms of headaches, in the notes. If you can read through that in your own time, that will just help you to have a bit more, control over what's going on and understanding of what, what, what kind of things, should trigger you contacting another doctor.
Patient OK. That's perfect. Thank you so much for your help.
Doctor No problem, OK. So we'll, we'll touch base in a week's time, with me or, myself or one of the other doctors, and we , we'll take it from there, OK.
Patient OK. Thank you. Yeah, I'll book an appointment, in, um, yeah, in that time.
Doctor Brilliant, OK then, all right. Take care then, all the best.
Patient Bye.
Patient Thank you, and you.
Doctor Bye bye.
Patient Bye.
Hx: Has had headache upon waking from this morning on left side head- pain woke pt up at 530am +Headache still present now + Has had hx of headaches less severe and in front of the head in past +No neck stiffness, no fever +Some sensitivity to bright lights now, no nausea now +Felt dizzy this morning, but not now +No FH of migraines +Work is stressful, late nights at work- ongoing for a few months. Mood is stable- pmhx of anxiety for 2 years, on sertraline. Doesn't feel anxious right now- gets this at work at times +No thoughts about self harm +Headache is better when lying down. +Pt has taken paracetamol- not helped +Pmhx: nil, has not had BP checked +FH: mother has anxiety +DH: sertraline +Nkda +SH: live with partner +Non smoker +Hss cat +Good exercise, reasonable diet +Imp: tension type headache +/- migraine +Plan: for ibuprofen first line as per SIGN 2018 migraine guidelines +1.5-2 litres water hydration daily + To sleep 7-8 hours minimum daily +Consider time off- to self certify for a few days to see if this helps +Self referral to IAPTs +Review in a week +If any red flag symptoms as per www.patient.co.uk/ headache, to ring back sooner +Patient understands and is happy with plan +
Note straight from the transcript
CHIEF COMPLAINT +HEADACHE (LEFT SIDED) X 1 DAY + +HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS +PATIENT WOKE UP AT 05:30 WITH SEVERE LEFT-SIDED HEADACHE. PAIN IS PROMINENT ON THE LEFT SIDE, UNLIKE PREVIOUS HEADACHES WHICH WERE FRONTAL/CLUSTER. ASSOCIATED WITH MILD PHOTOPHOBIA (EYES SORE) AND TRANSIENT DIZZINESS UPON WAKING (NOW RESOLVED). NO NECK STIFFNESS, NO FEVER, NO NAUSEA. PAIN FEELS SORE INITIALLY WHEN LYING DOWN BUT ULTIMATELY IMPROVES. PARACETAMOL TAKEN THIS MORNING PROVIDED NO RELIEF. HISTORY OF LESS SEVERE FRONTAL HEADACHES. CURRENT STRESS AT WORK FOR ~2 MONTHS. + +PAST MEDICAL HISTORY +ANXIETY FOR 2 YEARS. HISTORY OF LESS SEVERE FRONTAL HEADACHES. + +MEDICATION HISTORY +SERTRALINE FOR ANXIETY. PARACETAMOL TAKEN THIS MORNING FOR CURRENT HEADACHE. + +FAMILY HISTORY +MOTHER HAS HISTORY OF ANXIETY. NO PHYSICAL ILLNESSES. + +PERSONAL AND SOCIAL HISTORY +LIVES WITH PARTNER. NON-SMOKER. HAS A CAT. RUNS 3 TIMES/WEEK. DIET IS 'OK', NOT UNHEALTHY. WORK STRESS FOR 2 MONTHS. MOOD IS GENERALLY STABLE BUT FRUSTRATED AT TIMES. + +REVIEW OF SYSTEMS +SCREENING FOR ANXIETY-RELATED SELF-HARM WAS NEGATIVE. + +PHYSICAL EXAMINATION +EXAMINATION NOT PERFORMED + +DIAGNOSIS +DIFFERENTIAL: +TENSION HEADACHE (PROVISIONAL) +MIGRAINE (PROVISIONAL) + +ALLERGY +NO KNOWN ALLERGY + +ORDERS +MEDICATION +IBUPROFEN (OTC) +PARACETAMOL (OTC) (CONTINUE) +REFERRALS +SELF-REFER TO COUNSELLING SERVICE + +ADVICE +CONSIDER TAKING A WEEK OFF WORK (SELF-CERTIFY). ENSURE 7-8 HOURS SLEEP. DRINK 1.5-2 LITRES OF WATER/FLUIDS DAILY (EXCLUDING COFFEE/TEA). REVIEW WARNING SIGNS. + +FOLLOW-UP +REVIEW AFTER 1 WEEK IF SYMPTOMS NOT IMPROVING +
Note from all extracted facts, no evidence
CHIEF COMPLAINT +SEVERE LEFT-SIDED HEADACHE X 1 DAY, ASSO - PHOTOPHOBIA, MILD DIZZINESS (RESOLVED) + +HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS +PATIENT WOKE UP WITH SEVERE PAIN ON THE LEFT SIDE OF THE HEAD. REPORTS MILD SENSITIVITY TO BRIGHT LIGHTS CAUSING SORE EYES. EXPERIENCED MILD DIZZINESS UPON WAKING, WHICH HAS SUBSIDED. HISTORY OF LESS SEVERE HEADACHES TYPICALLY CLUSTERED AT THE FRONT OF THE HEAD. FEELING FRUSTRATED DURING THE DAY WITH MOOD THAT EBBS AND FLOWS; OCCASIONALLY ANXIOUS REGARDING WORK DEADLINES BUT NOT MASSIVELY ANXIOUS OVERALL. PARACETAMOL TAKEN THIS MORNING DID NOT HELP. NO OTHER MEDICATION TAKEN FOR HEADACHE. + +PAST MEDICAL HISTORY +HISTORY OF ANXIETY FOR APPROXIMATELY TWO YEARS. DENIES OTHER ILLNESSES. DENIES DIAGNOSIS OF HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE. NEVER HAD BLOOD PRESSURE CHECKED. + +MEDICATION HISTORY +PATIENT HAS BEEN TAKING SERTRALINE FOR ANXIETY FOR A WHILE AND IS CURRENTLY TAKING IT. RECENTLY TOOK PARACETAMOL FOR HEADACHE. + +FAMILY HISTORY +MOTHER HAS A HISTORY OF ANXIETY. NO FAMILY MEMBERS HAVE A HISTORY OF PHYSICAL ILLNESSES. NO FAMILY MEMBERS DIAGNOSED WITH MIGRAINES. + +PERSONAL AND SOCIAL HISTORY +WORK-RELATED STRESS DUE TO BACKLOG OF WORK AND LATE NIGHTS FOR THE PAST COUPLE OF MONTHS. LIVES WITH PARTNER. NON-SMOKER. OWNS A CAT. EXERCISES BY RUNNING AT LEAST THREE TIMES A WEEK. DIET DESCRIBED AS NEITHER PARTICULARLY HEALTHY NOR UNHEALTHY. + +PHYSICAL EXAMINATION +EXAMINATION NOT PERFORMED + +DIAGNOSIS +DIFFERENTIAL: +TENSION HEADACHE (PROVISIONAL) +MIGRAINE (PROVISIONAL) + +ALLERGY +NO KNOWN ALLERGY + +ORDERS +MEDICATION +IBUPROFEN +PARACETAMOL +LABORATORY +BLOOD TESTS +REFERRALS +SELF-REFERRAL FOR COUNSELLING +DIET +SLEEP: 7-8 HOURS/NIGHT +HYDRATION: 1.5-2L FLUIDS/DAY (NO COFFEE/TEA) + +ADVICE +TIME OFF WORK (POTENTIALLY 1 WEEK) TO REDUCE STRESS +CONTACT CLINIC IF SYMPTOMS WORSEN OR WORRIED; SEE HEADACHE DANGER SIGNS LINK + +FOLLOW-UP +REVIEW AFTER ONE WEEK +
Note from evidence-linked facts with their transcript quotes
CHIEF COMPLAINT +SEVERE LEFT-SIDED HEADACHE ONSET THIS MORNING, ASSO - PHOTOPHOBIA, MILD DIZZINESS (RESOLVED) + +HISTORY OF PRESENT ILLNESS +PATIENT WOKE UP WITH SEVERE LEFT-SIDED HEAD PAIN. HISTORY OF LESS SEVERE FRONTAL HEADACHES. ASSOCIATED WITH MILD PHOTOPHOBIA (SORE EYES) AND RESOLVED MILD DIZZINESS. PARACETAMOL TAKEN THIS MORNING PROVIDED NO RELIEF. WORK-RELATED STRESS REPORTED. MOOD FLUCTUATES WITH FRUSTRATION. OCCASIONAL ANXIETY REGARDING WORK DEADLINES. + +PAST MEDICAL HISTORY +HISTORY OF ANXIETY FOR APPROXIMATELY TWO YEARS. NO HISTORY OF HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE OR OTHER ILLNESSES. + +MEDICATION HISTORY +CURRENTLY TAKING SERTRALINE FOR ANXIETY. TOOK PARACETAMOL THIS MORNING FOR HEADACHE. + +FAMILY HISTORY +MOTHER HAS HISTORY OF ANXIETY. NO FAMILY HISTORY OF MIGRAINES OR PHYSICAL ILLNESSES. + +PERSONAL AND SOCIAL HISTORY +LIVES WITH PARTNER. NON-SMOKER. OWNS A CAT. EXERCISES BY RUNNING AT LEAST THREE TIMES A WEEK. DIET DESCRIBED AS NEITHER PARTICULARLY HEALTHY NOR UNHEALTHY. WORK STRESS REPORTED. + +PHYSICAL EXAMINATION +EXAMINATION NOT PERFORMED OR NOT STATED IN RECORDING FACTS. NOTE: FACTS ONLY COVER HISTORY. NO EXAM FINDINGS PROVIDED IN FACTS. MARKING AS NOT_PERFORMED BASED ON ABSENCE OF EXAM FACTS IN INPUT. HOWEVER, RULES SAY 'NOT_PERFORMED' WHEN CLINICIAN DID NOT EXAMINE. SINCE NO EXAM FACTS ARE PRESENT, AND NO STATEMENT 'EXAM NOT DONE' IS PRESENT, BUT TYPICALLY OPD SHEETS REQUIRE EXAM. LET'S LOOK AT F003-F00 +
| Gold fact (open a row for the judge's reasons) | E1 | E2 | E3-noV |
|---|---|---|---|
Headache upon waking from this morning on left side woke patient up at 5:30amChief ComplaintGold note: “Has had headache upon waking from this morning on left side head- pain woke pt up at 530am” E1: Gen-002 states woke up at 05:30 with left-sided headache; gen-001 notes left sided for 1 day, matching waking this morning left side. E2: Generated notes left-sided headache on waking this morning; time 5:30am not explicitly repeated but waking left-sided headache is captured by gen-001 and gen-004. E3-noV: Generated gen-001 and gen-004 capture left-sided headache onset this morning on waking; time 5:30am not stated but core concept covered. | covered | covered | covered |
Headache still present nowHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Headache still present now” E1: No generated fact explicitly states headache is still present now. E2: No generated fact explicitly states headache is still present now. E3-noV: No generated fact states headache is still present now. | omitted | omitted | omitted |
History of headaches less severe and in front of head in pastHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Has had hx of headaches less severe and in front of the head in past” E1: Gen-003, gen-011 and gen-014 note previous headaches were frontal/less severe. E2: gen-007 reports history of less severe headaches typically clustered at the front of the head. E3-noV: gen-005 History of less severe frontal headaches matches history of less severe headaches in front of head in past. | covered | covered | covered |
Headache is better when lying downHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Headache is better when lying down.” E1: Gen-009 states pain improves when lying down, consistent with headache better when lying down. E2: Headache better when lying down is not mentioned in generated facts. E3-noV: Headache better when lying down is not mentioned in generated facts. | covered | omitted | omitted |
Patient took paracetamol without reliefHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Pt has taken paracetamol- not helped” E1: Gen-010 states paracetamol taken this morning provided no relief. E2: gen-010 states paracetamol taken this morning did not help; gen-017 also notes recent paracetamol use for headache. E3-noV: gen-008 Paracetamol taken this morning provided no relief matches patient took paracetamol without relief. | covered | covered | covered |
Sensitivity to bright lights nowHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Some sensitivity to bright lights now, no nausea now” E1: Gen-004 reports associated mild photophobia, matching sensitivity to bright lights now. E2: gen-002 headache associated with photophobia and gen-005 mild sensitivity to bright lights. E3-noV: gen-002 Headache associated with photophobia and gen-006 mild photophobia cover sensitivity to bright lights now. | covered | covered | covered |
No nausea nowHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Some sensitivity to bright lights now, no nausea now” E1: Gen-008 states no nausea. E2: No nausea now is not explicitly stated in generated facts. E3-noV: No nausea now is not stated in generated facts. | covered | omitted | omitted |
Felt dizzy this morning but not nowHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “Felt dizzy this morning, but not now” E1: Gen-005 reports transient dizziness upon waking now resolved. E2: gen-003 mild dizziness resolved and gen-006 mild dizziness upon waking which has subsided. E3-noV: gen-003 and gen-007 mild dizziness resolved matches felt dizzy this morning but not now. | covered | covered | covered |
No neck stiffnessHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “No neck stiffness, no fever” E1: Gen-006 states no neck stiffness. E2: No neck stiffness is not mentioned in generated facts. E3-noV: No neck stiffness is absent from generated facts. | covered | omitted | omitted |
No feverHistory of Present IllnessGold note: “No neck stiffness, no fever” E1: Gen-007 states no fever. E2: No fever is not mentioned in generated facts. E3-noV: No fever is absent from generated facts. | covered | omitted | omitted |
PMHx nilPast Medical HistoryGold note: “Pmhx: nil, has not had BP checked” E1: PMHx nil is not mentioned in generated facts. E2: gen-013 denies other illnesses aligns with PMHx nil. E3-noV: PMHx nil is not captured; generated mentions no history of high blood pressure or other illnesses which is not equivalent. | omitted | covered | omitted |
Has not had BP checkedPast Medical HistoryGold note: “Pmhx: nil, has not had BP checked” E1: Has not had BP checked is absent from generated facts. E2: gen-015 never had blood pressure checked. E3-noV: Has not had BP checked is not mentioned. | omitted | covered | omitted |
History of anxiety for 2 yearsPast Medical HistoryGold note: “Mood is stable- pmhx of anxiety for 2 years, on sertraline. Doesn't feel anxious right now- gets this at work at times” E1: Gen-013 reports anxiety for 2 years. E2: gen-012 history of anxiety for approximately two years. E3-noV: gen-012 History of anxiety for approximately two years matches history of anxiety for 2 years. | covered | covered | covered |
Current medication sertralineMedicationsGold note: “DH: sertraline” E1: Gen-015 reports sertraline for anxiety. E2: gen-016 taking sertraline for anxiety and currently taking it. E3-noV: gen-014 Currently taking Sertraline for anxiety matches current medication sertraline. | covered | covered | covered |
Patient on sertraline for anxietyMedicationsGold note: “Mood is stable- pmhx of anxiety for 2 years, on sertraline. Doesn't feel anxious right now- gets this at work at times” E1: Gen-015 states sertraline for anxiety. E2: gen-016 links sertraline to anxiety. E3-noV: gen-014 covers sertraline for anxiety. | covered | covered | covered |
Paracetamol taken for headacheMedicationsGold note: “Pt has taken paracetamol- not helped” E1: Gen-016 states paracetamol taken this morning for current headache. E2: gen-017 recently took paracetamol for headache. E3-noV: gen-015 Took Paracetamol this morning for headache matches paracetamol taken for headache. | covered | covered | covered |
No known drug allergiesAdverse Drug Reactions and AllergiesGold note: “Nkda” E1: Gen-017 states no known allergy. E2: gen-018 no known allergy. E3-noV: No known drug allergies / Nkda is not present. | covered | covered | omitted |
No family history of migrainesFamily HistoryGold note: “No FH of migraines” E1: Gen-019 no physical illnesses in family is consistent with no family history of migraines. E2: gen-021 no family members diagnosed with migraines. E3-noV: gen-017 No family history of migraines or physical illnesses includes no family history of migraines. | covered | covered | covered |
Mother has anxietyFamily HistoryGold note: “FH: mother has anxiety” E1: Gen-018 states mother has history of anxiety. E2: gen-019 mother has a history of anxiety. E3-noV: gen-016 Mother has history of anxiety matches mother has anxiety. | covered | covered | covered |
Lives with partnerSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “SH: live with partner” E1: Gen-020 states lives with partner. E2: gen-023 lives with partner. E3-noV: gen-018 Lives with partner matches. | covered | covered | covered |
Non smokerSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “Non smoker” E1: Gen-021 states non-smoker. E2: gen-024 non-smoker. E3-noV: gen-019 Non-smoker matches. | covered | covered | covered |
Has catSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “Hss cat” E1: Gen-022 states has a cat. E2: gen-025 owns a cat. E3-noV: gen-020 Owns a cat matches has cat. | covered | covered | covered |
Good exerciseSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “Good exercise, reasonable diet” E1: Gen-023 runs 3 times per week is an example of good exercise. E2: gen-026 exercises by running at least three times a week elaborates good exercise. E3-noV: gen-021 Exercises by running at least three times a week is a consistent elaboration of good exercise. | covered | covered | covered |
Reasonable dietSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “Good exercise, reasonable diet” E1: Gen-024 diet is OK not unhealthy matches reasonable diet. E2: gen-027 diet described as neither particularly healthy nor unhealthy aligns with reasonable diet. E3-noV: gen-022 Diet described as neither particularly healthy nor unhealthy is semantically equivalent to reasonable diet. | covered | covered | covered |
Work is stressful with late nights ongoing for a few monthsSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “Work is stressful, late nights at work- ongoing for a few months. Mood is stable- pmhx of anxiety for 2 years, on sertraline. Doesn't feel anxious right now- gets this at work at times” E1: Work stress for ~2 months is captured but late nights ongoing for a few months is not mentioned. E2: gen-022 work-related stress due to backlog and late nights for past couple of months. E3-noV: gen-009 Work-related stress reported and gen-023 Work stress reported cover work is stressful; late nights duration not stated but core stress concept covered. | omitted | covered | covered |
Mood is stableSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “Mood is stable- pmhx of anxiety for 2 years, on sertraline. Doesn't feel anxious right now- gets this at work at times” E1: Gen-026 reports mood generally stable. E2: Gold states mood is stable; generated gen-008 reports feeling frustrated with mood that ebbs and flows, contradicting stability. E3-noV: Gold says mood is stable; gen-010 Mood fluctuates with frustration contradicts stability. | covered | conflicts | conflicts |
Does not feel anxious right now, gets anxiety at work at timesSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “Doesn't feel anxious right now- gets this at work at times” E1: Does not feel anxious right now and gets anxiety at work at times is not explicitly stated. E2: Does not feel anxious right now is not explicitly captured; generated only notes occasional anxiety about work deadlines. E3-noV: Does not feel anxious right now and gets anxiety at work at times is not captured; only occasional anxiety regarding work deadlines is mentioned. | omitted | omitted | omitted |
No thoughts about self harmSocial and Family HistoryGold note: “No thoughts about self harm” E1: Gen-038 screening for anxiety-related self-harm was negative matches no thoughts about self harm. E2: No thoughts about self harm is not mentioned. E3-noV: No thoughts about self harm is absent. | covered | omitted | omitted |
Impression tension type headache +/- migraineAssessmentGold note: “Imp: tension type headache +/- migraine” E1: Gen-027 tension headache provisional and gen-028 migraine provisional match impression. E2: gen-028 provisional diagnosis tension headache and gen-029 provisional diagnosis migraine. E3-noV: Impression tension type headache +/- migraine is not present. | covered | covered | omitted |
Ibuprofen first line as per SIGN 2018 migraine guidelinesPlan of CareGold note: “Plan: for ibuprofen first line as per SIGN 2018 migraine guidelines” E1: Gen-029 medication ibuprofen over the counter matches ibuprofen first line plan. E2: gen-030 medication ibuprofen ordered matches ibuprofen first line plan. E3-noV: Ibuprofen first line as per SIGN 2018 migraine guidelines is absent. | covered | covered | omitted |
Hydration 1.5-2 litres water dailyPlan of CareGold note: “1.5-2 litres water hydration daily” E1: Gen-034 advises 1.5-2 litres water/fluids daily. E2: gen-035 hydration recommendation 1.5-2L fluids per day. E3-noV: Hydration 1.5-2 litres water daily is absent. | covered | covered | omitted |
Sleep 7-8 hours minimum dailyPlan of CareGold note: “To sleep 7-8 hours minimum daily” E1: Gen-033 advises ensure 7-8 hours sleep. E2: gen-034 sleep recommendation 7-8 hours per night. E3-noV: Sleep 7-8 hours minimum daily is absent. | covered | covered | omitted |
Consider time off to self certify for a few daysPlan of CareGold note: “Consider time off- to self certify for a few days to see if this helps” E1: Gen-032 advises consider taking a week off work self-certify, semantically equivalent to few days time off. E2: gen-036 advice time off work to reduce stress captures consider time off to self certify. E3-noV: Consider time off to self certify for a few days is absent. | covered | covered | omitted |
Self referral to IAPTsPlan of CareGold note: “Self referral to IAPTs” E1: Gen-031 self-refer to counselling service matches self referral to IAPTs. E2: gen-033 self-referral for counselling aligns with self referral to IAPTs. E3-noV: Self referral to IAPTs is absent. | covered | covered | omitted |
Review in a weekFollow up InformationGold note: “Review in a week” E1: Gen-036 review after 1 week if symptoms not improving matches review in a week. E2: gen-038 review after one week. E3-noV: Review in a week is absent. | covered | covered | omitted |
If red flag symptoms per www.patient.co.uk/headache, ring back soonerFollow up InformationGold note: “If any red flag symptoms as per www.patient.co.uk/ headache, to ring back sooner” E1: Gen-035 advice to review warning signs covers red flag advice. E2: gen-037 advice to contact clinic if symptoms worsen and see headache danger signs link. E3-noV: Red flag symptoms instruction to ring back sooner is absent. | covered | covered | omitted |
Patient understands and is happy with planFollow up InformationGold note: “Patient understands and is happy with plan” E1: Patient understands and is happy with plan is not mentioned. E2: Patient understands and is happy with plan is not mentioned. E3-noV: Patient understands and is happy with plan is absent. | omitted | omitted | omitted |
No neck stiffnessReview of SystemsGold note: “No neck stiffness, no fever” E1: Gen-006 no neck stiffness. E2: No neck stiffness in Review of Systems not mentioned. E3-noV: No neck stiffness in Review_of_Systems is not mentioned. | covered | omitted | omitted |
No feverReview of SystemsGold note: “No neck stiffness, no fever” E1: Gen-007 no fever. E2: No fever in Review of Systems not mentioned. E3-noV: No fever in Review_of_Systems is not mentioned. | covered | omitted | omitted |
Photophobia presentReview of SystemsGold note: “Some sensitivity to bright lights now, no nausea now” E1: Gen-004 mild photophobia. E2: gen-002 headache associated with photophobia. E3-noV: Photophobia present is covered by gen-002 and gen-006. | covered | covered | covered |
No nauseaReview of SystemsGold note: “Some sensitivity to bright lights now, no nausea now” E1: Gen-008 no nausea. E2: No nausea is not explicitly stated. E3-noV: No nausea is not stated. | covered | omitted | omitted |
Dizziness this morning resolvedReview of SystemsGold note: “Felt dizzy this morning, but not now” E1: Gen-005 transient dizziness upon waking now resolved. E2: gen-003 mild dizziness resolved. E3-noV: gen-003 Mild dizziness resolved matches dizziness this morning resolved. | covered | covered | covered |
For each config: the note facts the judge did not find in the doctor's note (or found conflicting with it), and whether the transcript backs them. The first chip is the transcript check, the second the comparison with the doctor's note.
+