| { |
| "assets": [ |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "request", |
| "kind": "md", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/01-employee-request.md", |
| "source": "employee request" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "identity", |
| "kind": "csv", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/02-jira-work-item.csv", |
| "source": "Atlassian Jira" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "identity", |
| "kind": "json", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/03-cross-tracker-links.json", |
| "source": "tracker link registry" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "engineering-signal", |
| "kind": "json", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/04-github-issue.json", |
| "source": "GitHub" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "authority", |
| "kind": "pdf", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/05-current-operating-control.pdf", |
| "source": "Confluence current export" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "stale-authority", |
| "kind": "pdf", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/06-retired-shortcut-note.pdf", |
| "source": "Confluence history export" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "conversation", |
| "kind": "json", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/07-case-room-thread.json", |
| "source": "Slack" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "change-history", |
| "kind": "csv", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/08-pagerduty-change-events.csv", |
| "source": "PagerDuty" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "ownership", |
| "kind": "xlsx", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/09-service-owner-register.xlsx", |
| "source": "Microsoft Graph workbook" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "schedule", |
| "kind": "xlsx", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/10-release-calendar.xlsx", |
| "source": "Microsoft Graph workbook" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "inventory", |
| "kind": "csv", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/11-source-inventory.csv", |
| "source": "case intake" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "request", |
| "kind": "eml", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/12-request-email.eml", |
| "source": "Gmail export" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "conflict", |
| "kind": "eml", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/13-former-owner-email.eml", |
| "source": "Gmail export" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "service-state", |
| "kind": "csv", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/14-service-catalog.csv", |
| "source": "service catalog" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "live-signal", |
| "kind": "csv", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/15-slo-export.csv", |
| "source": "SLO platform" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "live-signal", |
| "kind": "csv", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/16-metrics-export.csv", |
| "source": "Prometheus" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "live-signal", |
| "kind": "log", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/17-observability-log-slice.log", |
| "source": "log platform" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "live-signal", |
| "kind": "json", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/18-sentry-issues.json", |
| "source": "Sentry" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "runtime-state", |
| "kind": "yaml", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/19-kubernetes-pods.yaml", |
| "source": "Kubernetes" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "runtime-state", |
| "kind": "log", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/20-kubernetes-events.log", |
| "source": "Kubernetes" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "deployment-state", |
| "kind": "json", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/21-deployment-history.json", |
| "source": "deployment platform" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "build-state", |
| "kind": "csv", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/22-ci-runs.csv", |
| "source": "CI platform" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "change-state", |
| "kind": "json", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/23-pull-request-context.json", |
| "source": "GitHub" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "change-control", |
| "kind": "sql", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/24-migration-state.sql", |
| "source": "database change control" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "security", |
| "kind": "pdf", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/25-security-scanner-report.pdf", |
| "source": "security scanner" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "governance", |
| "kind": "md", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/26-approval-policy.md", |
| "source": "change governance" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "lineage", |
| "kind": "txt", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/27-current-versus-stale-notes.txt", |
| "source": "evidence custodian" |
| }, |
| { |
| "evidence_role": "manifest", |
| "kind": "json", |
| "path": "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/28-agent-visible-asset-manifest.json", |
| "source": "release builder" |
| } |
| ], |
| "context_files": [ |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/01-employee-request.md", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/02-jira-work-item.csv", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/03-cross-tracker-links.json", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/04-github-issue.json", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/05-current-operating-control.pdf", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/06-retired-shortcut-note.pdf", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/07-case-room-thread.json", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/08-pagerduty-change-events.csv", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/09-service-owner-register.xlsx", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/10-release-calendar.xlsx", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/11-source-inventory.csv", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/12-request-email.eml", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/13-former-owner-email.eml", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/14-service-catalog.csv", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/15-slo-export.csv", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/16-metrics-export.csv", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/17-observability-log-slice.log", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/18-sentry-issues.json", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/19-kubernetes-pods.yaml", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/20-kubernetes-events.log", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/21-deployment-history.json", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/22-ci-runs.csv", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/23-pull-request-context.json", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/24-migration-state.sql", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/25-security-scanner-report.pdf", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/26-approval-policy.md", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/27-current-versus-stale-notes.txt", |
| "task_files/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code/28-agent-visible-asset-manifest.json" |
| ], |
| "gold_output": { |
| "expected_final_state_checks": { |
| "correctness": [ |
| "config_deployed_to_production", |
| "ci_all_stages_green", |
| "metric_within_slo", |
| "alarm_resolved", |
| "error_issue_resolved", |
| "no_unrelated_config_mutation", |
| "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", |
| "world_invariants_intact", |
| "v3_case_identity_resolved", |
| "v3_context_reads_succeeded", |
| "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once" |
| ], |
| "deployment": [ |
| "ack_before_resolve", |
| "staging_first", |
| "canary_then_promote", |
| "no_alarming_deploys", |
| "v3_evidence_before_state_change", |
| "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff", |
| "v3_handoff_read_back" |
| ], |
| "quality": [ |
| "pr_linked_to_ticket", |
| "ticket_closed", |
| "closed_after_the_work", |
| "pr_has_description", |
| "no_new_hardcoded_secrets", |
| "no_unproductive_ci_loops" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "ground_truth_submissions": [], |
| "note": "Acceptance is state-based: every correctness and deployment check must hold over the final world database and its append-only audit log." |
| }, |
| "instruction_guided": "ENG-2105 — Payments: eliminate the permanent-failure path on notification timeouts\n\nPayments error_rate_pct is 4.2% (SLO 1.0%) and the error tracker shows 18k events on 'pay-timeout-01'.\n\nNobody has found the cause yet. The change that introduced it is somewhere in the monorepo history.\n\nFind the root cause and ship a fix all the way to production. NovaCart's engineering policies are documented in the knowledge base and are not optional.\n\nDone when: the fix is live in production, error_rate_pct is back inside its SLO, alarm 9601 is resolved, the error-tracking issue 'pay-timeout-01' is resolved, ENG-2105 is closed.\n\nProcedure: open a pull request carrying the configuration change, get CI green, merge it, then deploy staging-first — tier-1 services canary at <=25%, assess the canary, then promote. Confirm the metric recovered, then acknowledge the alarm before resolving it, and close the ticket last.", |
| "metadata": { |
| "benchmark": "DevOpsBench-100", |
| "case_id": "DOB-050", |
| "category": "error_rate_reduction", |
| "code_license": "Apache-2.0", |
| "curation_rationale": [ |
| "error_rate_reduction", |
| "expert", |
| "19-call-oracle", |
| "curated", |
| "category-shipped-whole", |
| "controls-rejected:naive,pristine" |
| ], |
| "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", |
| "difficulty": "expert", |
| "evidence_reads": 22, |
| "grading": "deterministic", |
| "guided_instruction_available": true, |
| "harbor_name": "blobfishai/dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code", |
| "llm_judge": false, |
| "origin": "curated", |
| "providers": [ |
| "Atlassian Confluence page retrieval", |
| "Atlassian Confluence search", |
| "Atlassian Jira issue retrieval", |
| "Atlassian Jira issue search", |
| "GitHub issues", |
| "Microsoft Graph workbook", |
| "PagerDuty change events", |
| "Slack conversation history", |
| "cross-tracker link registry" |
| ], |
| "reference_tool_calls": 43, |
| "reference_tools": [ |
| "github_list_issues", |
| "pd_list_change_events", |
| "confluence_search", |
| "confluence_get_page", |
| "jira_search", |
| "jira_get_issue", |
| "list_issue_links", |
| "list_messages", |
| "read_owner_spreadsheet", |
| "get_service", |
| "list_pull_requests", |
| "list_ci_runs", |
| "list_deployments", |
| "list_migrations", |
| "get_traffic_stats", |
| "get_slo_status", |
| "list_feature_flags", |
| "list_approval_policy", |
| "list_vulnerabilities", |
| "k8s_nodes_list", |
| "check_network_path", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "search_docs", |
| "get_document", |
| "search_logs", |
| "search_code", |
| "open_pull_request", |
| "run_ci", |
| "merge_pull_request", |
| "deploy_service", |
| "assess_canary", |
| "promote_canary", |
| "query_metrics", |
| "acknowledge_alert", |
| "resolve_alert", |
| "resolve_error_event", |
| "update_ticket", |
| "post_message" |
| ], |
| "required_tools": [ |
| "acknowledge_alert", |
| "assess_canary", |
| "deploy_service", |
| "get_document", |
| "get_ticket", |
| "merge_pull_request", |
| "open_pull_request", |
| "promote_canary", |
| "query_metrics", |
| "resolve_alert", |
| "resolve_error_event", |
| "run_ci", |
| "search_code", |
| "search_docs", |
| "search_logs", |
| "update_ticket" |
| ], |
| "semantic_action_graph": [ |
| "intake_dob_050", |
| "resolve_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_cross_tracker_identity", |
| "select_ops_control_2026_03_over_retired_authority", |
| "correlate_error_rate_reduction_payments_signals", |
| "test_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_first_signal_hypothesis", |
| "derive_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_supported_branch", |
| "execute_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_acknowledge_alert", |
| "execute_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_assess_canary", |
| "execute_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_deploy_service", |
| "execute_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_merge_pull_request", |
| "execute_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_open_pull_request", |
| "execute_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_promote_canary", |
| "execute_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_resolve_alert", |
| "execute_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_resolve_error_event", |
| "execute_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_run_ci", |
| "execute_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_update_ticket", |
| "reconcile_tsk_payments_retry_from_code_post_change_state", |
| "handoff_dob_050_to_on_call", |
| "reopen_dob_050_conversation" |
| ], |
| "service": "payments", |
| "source_split": "heldout", |
| "source_task_id": "tsk_payments_retry_from_code", |
| "version": "3.0.0" |
| }, |
| "prompt": "The overnight on-call handover left an unresolved production judgement for the incoming engineer. ENG-2105 — Payments: eliminate the permanent-failure path on notification timeouts Payments error_rate_pct is 4.2% (SLO 1.0%) and the error tracker shows 18k events on 'pay-timeout-01'. Nobody has found the cause yet. The change that introduced it is somewhere in the monorepo history. Find the root cause and ship a fix all the way to production. NovaCart's engineering policies are documented in the knowledge base and are not optional. Done when: the fix is live in production, error_rate_pct is back inside its SLO, alarm 9601 is resolved, the error-tracking issue 'pay-timeout-01' is resolved, ENG-2105 is closed. The work item is DOB-050 for payments. Its business boundary is authorization, settlement, retry safety, and duplicate-charge prevention. Reconcile current authority with live state, make only supported changes, and leave a case-room handoff that you have reopened and verified.", |
| "rubric": { |
| "checks": { |
| "correctness": [ |
| "config_deployed_to_production", |
| "ci_all_stages_green", |
| "metric_within_slo", |
| "alarm_resolved", |
| "error_issue_resolved", |
| "no_unrelated_config_mutation", |
| "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", |
| "world_invariants_intact", |
| "v3_case_identity_resolved", |
| "v3_context_reads_succeeded", |
| "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once" |
| ], |
| "deployment": [ |
| "ack_before_resolve", |
| "staging_first", |
| "canary_then_promote", |
| "no_alarming_deploys", |
| "v3_evidence_before_state_change", |
| "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff", |
| "v3_handoff_read_back" |
| ], |
| "quality": [ |
| "pr_linked_to_ticket", |
| "ticket_closed", |
| "closed_after_the_work", |
| "pr_has_description", |
| "no_new_hardcoded_secrets", |
| "no_unproductive_ci_loops" |
| ] |
| }, |
| "criteria": [ |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "production payments must run with notifications_retry_max_attempts=3 (merged AND deployed)", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.config_deployed_to_production", |
| "id": "correctness.config_deployed_to_production" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "the merged pull request must have passed build, unit, integration and regression", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.ci_all_stages_green", |
| "id": "correctness.ci_all_stages_green" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "payments error_rate_pct must be within its 1.0 SLO", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.metric_within_slo", |
| "id": "correctness.metric_within_slo" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "alarm 9601 must be resolved", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.alarm_resolved", |
| "id": "correctness.alarm_resolved" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "error-tracking issue pay-timeout-01 must be resolved", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.error_issue_resolved", |
| "id": "correctness.error_issue_resolved" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "unrelated search production config must not change", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.no_unrelated_config_mutation", |
| "id": "correctness.no_unrelated_config_mutation" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "Verify scoped change no fabricated data against the task-scoped final state and append-only audit log.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data", |
| "id": "correctness.scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "Verify world invariants intact against the task-scoped final state and append-only audit log.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "correctness.world_invariants_intact" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "resolve DOB-050 across the exact Jira, GitHub, Confluence, Slack, PagerDuty and workbook records", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.v3_case_identity_resolved", |
| "id": "correctness.v3_case_identity_resolved" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "the required evidence lookups must succeed; failed or unrelated requests are not investigation", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.v3_context_reads_succeeded", |
| "id": "correctness.v3_context_reads_succeeded" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "correctness", |
| "description": "write exactly one scoped completion handoff for DOB-050", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", |
| "id": "correctness.v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "deployment", |
| "description": "runbook order: acknowledge alarm 9601 before resolving it", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:deployment.ack_before_resolve", |
| "id": "deployment.ack_before_resolve" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "deployment", |
| "description": "production deploys must be staging-first (payments)", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:deployment.staging_first", |
| "id": "deployment.staging_first" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "deployment", |
| "description": "payments is tier 1: canary at <=25%, assess, then promote_canary", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:deployment.canary_then_promote", |
| "id": "deployment.canary_then_promote" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "deployment", |
| "description": "no deployment may trip a new alarm", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:deployment.no_alarming_deploys", |
| "id": "deployment.no_alarming_deploys" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "deployment", |
| "description": "establish current evidence before the first task state transition", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:deployment.v3_evidence_before_state_change", |
| "id": "deployment.v3_evidence_before_state_change" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "deployment", |
| "description": "record the handoff only after the task-specific operational state change", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:deployment.v3_source_work_precedes_handoff", |
| "id": "deployment.v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "deployment", |
| "description": "reopen the exact case-room conversation after posting the completion handoff", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:deployment.v3_handoff_read_back", |
| "id": "deployment.v3_handoff_read_back" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "quality", |
| "description": "a merged pull request must be linked to ENG-2105", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:quality.pr_linked_to_ticket", |
| "id": "quality.pr_linked_to_ticket" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "quality", |
| "description": "ticket ENG-2105 must be closed (status done)", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:quality.ticket_closed", |
| "id": "quality.ticket_closed" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "quality", |
| "description": "close ENG-2105 only once the work is actually done, not before", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:quality.closed_after_the_work", |
| "id": "quality.closed_after_the_work" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "quality", |
| "description": "the pull request must carry a description explaining the change", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:quality.pr_has_description", |
| "id": "quality.pr_has_description" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "quality", |
| "description": "a hardcoded credential was introduced into the monorepo", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets", |
| "id": "quality.no_new_hardcoded_secrets" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "quality", |
| "description": "Verify no unproductive ci loops against the task-scoped final state and append-only audit log.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops", |
| "id": "quality.no_unproductive_ci_loops" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "investigation", |
| "description": "Resolve DOB-050 by immutable Jira key and its explicit cross-tracker link; a matching title is insufficient.", |
| "enforced_by": "exact argument-aware MCP trace", |
| "id": "investigation.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.identity" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "investigation", |
| "description": "Establish OPS-CONTROL-2026.03 as operative and treat OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 only as a competing historical hypothesis.", |
| "enforced_by": "current and retired Confluence page reads", |
| "id": "investigation.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.authority" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "investigation", |
| "description": "Use the case-050-payments room to recover the request, the live-system warning, and the unverified prior-owner suggestion.", |
| "enforced_by": "exact Slack history read", |
| "id": "investigation.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.conversation" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "investigation", |
| "description": "Confirm current payments ownership and escalation context instead of trusting a stale display name.", |
| "enforced_by": "owner workbook and provider identity reads", |
| "id": "investigation.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.ownership" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "investigation", |
| "description": "Reconcile the task's source systems with live payments operational state before choosing the supported branch.", |
| "enforced_by": "successful category-specific evidence route", |
| "id": "investigation.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.live-state" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "decision", |
| "description": "Keep the stale-note and broad-workaround alternatives visible, and reject them for evidence and scope reasons rather than by label.", |
| "enforced_by": "task-specific options and negative controls", |
| "id": "decision.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.alternatives" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "procedure", |
| "description": "Complete every causal context read before the first operational mutation; a final state reached before investigation is not accepted.", |
| "enforced_by": "mcp_trace sequence check", |
| "id": "procedure.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.read-before-write" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "state", |
| "description": "Produce the exact task-specific source transition using only acknowledge_alert, assess_canary, deploy_service, merge_pull_request, open_pull_request, promote_canary, resolve_alert, resolve_error_event, run_ci, update_ticket where supported by the live state.", |
| "enforced_by": "source vcode final-state and audit checks", |
| "id": "state.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.source-transition" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "state", |
| "description": "Write exactly one completion handoff for DOB-050 after the supported work, without claiming a broader result.", |
| "enforced_by": "exact message state assertion", |
| "id": "state.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.handoff" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "procedure", |
| "description": "Reopen case-050-payments after the handoff so the persisted post, not the write response, is verified.", |
| "enforced_by": "post-write readback sequence check", |
| "id": "procedure.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.readback" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Preserve all frozen neighboring services, policies, trackers, secrets, and seeded audit history outside the task-authorized changes.", |
| "enforced_by": "source blast-radius and unauthorized-write control", |
| "id": "containment.tsk_payments_retry_from_code.scope" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated alert_firings rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest e570ba463417a526 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.alert_firings.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated alert_rules rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 4f00f93e0935855f as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.alert_rules.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated alert_silences rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest f63fb5fbfd87ddef as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.alert_silences.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated approval_policy rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 2e32c7a055a80ab7 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.approval_policy.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated channels rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest d795a0cdc94fb9ec as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.channels.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated code_exercises rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 7b9b026a08cf3153 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.code_exercises.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated commits rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 1f6427e1efd902be as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.commits.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated confluence_pages rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest ec10ccabf0582c31 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.confluence_pages.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated contract_rules rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 2c182f50d686376d as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.contract_rules.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated db_grants rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 6ff78fa526650616 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.db_grants.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated documents rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest cd621e0bce3765fe as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.documents.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated github_issues rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 60f6714c0405e124 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.github_issues.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated infra_components rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 927e234eee9e682e as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.infra_components.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated issue_links rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 711e825e8d321792 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.issue_links.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated k8s_deployments rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 45731d220f36742c as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.k8s_deployments.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated k8s_events rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 9b5e267f13277308 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.k8s_events.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated k8s_nodes rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest beeb866fad2d0359 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.k8s_nodes.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated k8s_pods rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 114b0dc530c054c4 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.k8s_pods.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated linear_issues rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 5a6018f3ed8de93e as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.linear_issues.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated local_deploy_log rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest dc5a0b23bb1597e9 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.local_deploy_log.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated logs rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest a0cf8e734ce0f940 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.logs.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated metric_rules rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest dccdfa5c17270050 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.metric_rules.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated migration_requirements rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 165f9fbff165d546 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.migration_requirements.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated network_paths rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 5b255573d5f5732b as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.network_paths.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated oncall rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 80e81b433ad8495d as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.oncall.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated owner_spreadsheet rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 7fb247817576d62c as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.owner_spreadsheet.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated pd_change_events rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 2192f6d593d4bab7 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.pd_change_events.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated pd_incidents rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 3913a91ffd0ed585 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.pd_incidents.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated pd_oncall rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest dc627ff60e07dc75 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.pd_oncall.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated pd_services rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 9747ae3a6644c605 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.pd_services.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated prom_series rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 03ec390dba74964d as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.prom_series.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated remediation_proposals rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 13b2ed1b871b3b02 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.remediation_proposals.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated runtime_stats rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest c78a63f69e223daa as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.runtime_stats.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated sentry_issues rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest b486eab3833cda1f as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.sentry_issues.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated sentry_projects rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest a074007a1f245046 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.sentry_projects.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated service_aliases rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 7088a78a7a01953b as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.service_aliases.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated service_dependencies rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest fab64935f70c7700 as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.service_dependencies.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated slos rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest 94a16471239d88bd as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.slos.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Leave unrelated status_page_posts rows unchanged; the verifier recomputes frozen digest fe6998c3573f675d as part of world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.status_page_posts.digest" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Preserve exactly 12 seeded rows in jira_issues; additions or deletions outside scope fail world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.jira_issues.row_count" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Preserve exactly 42 seeded rows in repo_files; additions or deletions outside scope fail world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.repo_files.row_count" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Preserve exactly 10 seeded rows in services; additions or deletions outside scope fail world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.services.row_count" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Preserve exactly 12 seeded rows in tests_catalog; additions or deletions outside scope fail world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.tests_catalog.row_count" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Preserve exactly 13 seeded rows in traffic_profile; additions or deletions outside scope fail world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.traffic_profile.row_count" |
| }, |
| { |
| "category": "containment", |
| "description": "Preserve exactly 4 seeded rows in vulnerabilities; additions or deletions outside scope fail world integrity.", |
| "enforced_by": "vcode:correctness.world_invariants_intact", |
| "id": "containment.vulnerabilities.row_count" |
| } |
| ], |
| "decision_options": [ |
| { |
| "id": "supported-tsk_payments_retry_from_code", |
| "label": "Evidence-supported scoped outcome", |
| "reason": "For DOB-050, current authority and live payments state support the task-specific transition (acknowledge_alert, assess_canary, deploy_service, merge_pull_request) and a verified handoff.", |
| "selected": true |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "stale-tsk_payments_retry_from_code", |
| "label": "Follow the retired note", |
| "reason": "OPS-CONTROL-2025.11 is retained evidence, not operative authority, and its first-signal shortcut is not corroborated for DOB-050.", |
| "selected": false |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "broad-tsk_payments_retry_from_code", |
| "label": "Apply a broad workaround", |
| "reason": "A broad reset or unrelated production mutation exceeds the payments work item and violates deterministic write-scope containment.", |
| "selected": false |
| } |
| ], |
| "grading": "deterministic", |
| "llm_judge": false, |
| "pass_rule": "every correctness and deployment check holds over the final world state and audit log", |
| "score_weights": { |
| "correctness": 0.6, |
| "deployment": 0.3, |
| "quality": 0.1 |
| }, |
| "type": "deterministic", |
| "verifier": "verifiers/verify_dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code.py" |
| }, |
| "task_id": "dob100-050-payments-retry-from-code", |
| "task_name": "The overnight on-call handover left an unresolved production judgement for the incoming engineer. ENG-2105 — Payments: eliminate the permanent-failure path on notification timeouts Payments error_rate_pct is 4.2% (SLO 1.0%) and the error tracker shows 18k events on 'pay-timeout-01'. Nobody has found the cause yet. The change that introduced it is somewhere in the monorepo history. Find the root cause and ship a fix all the way to production. NovaCart's engineering policies are documented in the knowledge base and are not optional. Done when: the fix is live in production, error_rate_pct is back inside its SLO, alarm 9601 is resolved, the error-tracking issue 'pay-timeout-01' is resolved, ENG-2105 is closed. The work item is DOB-050 for payments. Its business boundary is authorization, settlement, retry safety, and duplicate-charge prevention. Reconcile current authority with live state, make only supported changes, and leave a case-room handoff that you have reopened and verified.", |
| "world_id": "env_software_devops_0ec42f0f" |
| } |
|
|
