diff --git "a/reports/qualification.json" "b/reports/qualification.json" --- "a/reports/qualification.json" +++ "b/reports/qualification.json" @@ -5,14 +5,25 @@ "mismatches": 0, "replays": 100 }, - "executions": 1200, - "expected_executions": 1200, + "executions": 1600, + "expected_executions": 1600, + "metric": { + "milestones_per_task": 16, + "name": "DevOpsBench semantic causal completion", + "pass_rule": "all semantic milestones pass", + "points_per_task": 100 + }, "negative_controls": { "incomplete_read": { "applicable_executions": 100, "correct_rejections": 100, "false_accepts": 0 }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "applicable_executions": 100, + "correct_rejections": 100, + "false_accepts": 0 + }, "missing_readback": { "applicable_executions": 100, "correct_rejections": 100, @@ -33,6 +44,11 @@ "correct_rejections": 100, "false_accepts": 0 }, + "unapproved_option": { + "applicable_executions": 100, + "correct_rejections": 100, + "false_accepts": 0 + }, "unauthorized_write": { "applicable_executions": 100, "correct_rejections": 100, @@ -43,6 +59,11 @@ "correct_rejections": 100, "false_accepts": 0 }, + "wrong_answer": { + "applicable_executions": 100, + "correct_rejections": 100, + "false_accepts": 0 + }, "wrong_decision": { "applicable_executions": 100, "correct_rejections": 100, @@ -53,6 +74,11 @@ "correct_rejections": 100, "false_accepts": 0 }, + "wrong_target": { + "applicable_executions": 100, + "correct_rejections": 100, + "false_accepts": 0 + }, "wrong_value": { "applicable_executions": 100, "correct_rejections": 100, @@ -65,7 +91,7 @@ "passes": 100 }, "release_passed": true, - "schema_version": "2.0", + "schema_version": "3.0", "task_count": 100, "task_results": [ { @@ -74,14 +100,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -100,20 +136,108 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false }, @@ -125,7 +249,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -144,26 +281,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "2dfb6d3bd75f2f894c0044a6493a1980a634dc067476a94aa24fe70df1c11ec4", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "e2edd7579a836692c6bd05e7f26eab70512f2657f183176f1fef93264f59bb5b", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 31, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "2dfb6d3bd75f2f894c0044a6493a1980a634dc067476a94aa24fe70df1c11ec4", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "e2edd7579a836692c6bd05e7f26eab70512f2657f183176f1fef93264f59bb5b", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_analytics_egress_blocked", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -173,14 +430,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -199,20 +466,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -224,7 +577,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -243,26 +609,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "1a6642ab42da4b209d1dc29e0f2878ff72702c791864edd43c0ca13a616cc1aa", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "c52ef96815ea475fd29b7eb62dc11755d84f61d569fe32bfacc436236e522e9d", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 31, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "1a6642ab42da4b209d1dc29e0f2878ff72702c791864edd43c0ca13a616cc1aa", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "c52ef96815ea475fd29b7eb62dc11755d84f61d569fe32bfacc436236e522e9d", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_analytics_revoked_grant", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -272,14 +758,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -298,19 +794,108 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false }, @@ -322,7 +907,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -341,26 +939,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "14216735693756cd5da3959716b1871e85f8921a15053a5b77a07f4479035f24", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "6f289c62ab53493ed85b5409ca43f67e2299ec4f68458efdd6e691a4813f7c7b", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "14216735693756cd5da3959716b1871e85f8921a15053a5b77a07f4479035f24", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 35, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "6f289c62ab53493ed85b5409ca43f67e2299ec4f68458efdd6e691a4813f7c7b", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_checkout_unschedulable_replicas", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -370,14 +1088,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -396,19 +1124,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -420,7 +1235,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -439,26 +1267,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "a949dabeedc3a98af1782e90988e3b4abe4857e7e5107f1f672ccd2b0a092574", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "178c41718b61fd94c4aca6d56cc67ded0b0dfa1dd32ff5929e07c9b9bdef2ef6", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "a949dabeedc3a98af1782e90988e3b4abe4857e7e5107f1f672ccd2b0a092574", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "178c41718b61fd94c4aca6d56cc67ded0b0dfa1dd32ff5929e07c9b9bdef2ef6", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_media_disk_pressure", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -468,14 +1416,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -494,19 +1452,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -518,7 +1563,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -537,26 +1595,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "1f43ad17445fa1e0f60213fc986759a9e94ffb5204d295b3ff19d49672886127", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "6f2e1b3841ab77d97586f7eb443a97342a08fb638837616e3a36464b1d3bb6e6", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "1f43ad17445fa1e0f60213fc986759a9e94ffb5204d295b3ff19d49672886127", + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "6f2e1b3841ab77d97586f7eb443a97342a08fb638837616e3a36464b1d3bb6e6", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_notifications_node_deadlock", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -566,14 +1744,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -592,19 +1780,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -616,7 +1891,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -635,26 +1923,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "a264754fa1ad863b1402e44bb15cbe363abca3f7746915498abb72d7278f33a3", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "2cce4f04257cd5c20ac3477add16751c7ff1c112b2a294553a62a21075d7102e", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "a264754fa1ad863b1402e44bb15cbe363abca3f7746915498abb72d7278f33a3", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "2cce4f04257cd5c20ac3477add16751c7ff1c112b2a294553a62a21075d7102e", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_search_unscheduled_reindex", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -664,14 +2072,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -688,20 +2106,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -713,7 +2217,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -730,26 +2247,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "6fc998d20493ee5fa1b0f074e574adcde5d4da60c4fc15855284426dc44bc714", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "cdd781ceef6e57eeb508aca53cfce3c29a6006c0c405e400f1cb57c24171cc13", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 30, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "6fc998d20493ee5fa1b0f074e574adcde5d4da60c4fc15855284426dc44bc714", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "cdd781ceef6e57eeb508aca53cfce3c29a6006c0c405e400f1cb57c24171cc13", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_detect_checkout_errors", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -759,14 +2396,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -783,20 +2430,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -808,7 +2541,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -825,73 +2571,211 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "575b26a2f6e9a83a80dd43fb0b9635df0499cf46ff2f67a6b165e40f23b27d72", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "330048924a905d540eb5eab33dd6e2ff0a8e4cb43acc6430421c291d897e27e5", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 28, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "575b26a2f6e9a83a80dd43fb0b9635df0499cf46ff2f67a6b165e40f23b27d72", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "330048924a905d540eb5eab33dd6e2ff0a8e4cb43acc6430421c291d897e27e5", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_detect_inventory", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-009-detect-payments", + "bench_id": "dob100-009-rcn-checkout-error-rate", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ + "answer_correct", + "answer_submitted", + "assumption_engages_the_ambiguity", "closed_after_the_work", - "detection_correct", - "diagnosis_submitted", - "efficient_investigation", - "evidence_recorded", + "consulted_prom_series", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "consulted_prom_series" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "consulted_prom_series" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -903,44 +2787,177 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ + "answer_correct", + "answer_submitted", + "assumption_engages_the_ambiguity", "closed_after_the_work", - "detection_correct", - "diagnosis_submitted", - "efficient_investigation", - "evidence_recorded", + "consulted_prom_series", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "0c6981253ac77d6f0655866ef6cd2e355d67c008d6145df7adf1194dcfd32b74", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "b64a7ed83f3317cc89286d1d68371d184bb00f3fa4c156c91f7c378815ed6ed9", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 29, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "0c6981253ac77d6f0655866ef6cd2e355d67c008d6145df7adf1194dcfd32b74", - "source_task_id": "tsk_detect_payments", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "b64a7ed83f3317cc89286d1d68371d184bb00f3fa4c156c91f7c378815ed6ed9", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rcn_checkout_error_rate", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { @@ -949,14 +2966,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -974,20 +3001,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -999,7 +3112,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1017,26 +3143,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "ac072728acedfaba818e968bf18f1fcd8ae5918fb94d15dfe7d0db7cee37065d", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "3224a6df2e5281dee238881b98740d2b0db56e228f7b8dde97fbe8652229e060", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 31, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "ac072728acedfaba818e968bf18f1fcd8ae5918fb94d15dfe7d0db7cee37065d", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "3224a6df2e5281dee238881b98740d2b0db56e228f7b8dde97fbe8652229e060", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_detect_status_page_recurrence", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -1046,14 +3292,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1070,20 +3326,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1095,7 +3437,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1112,26 +3467,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "4f9bea81d5604c809164ee34ecce391b07a8dd755e7b8fa70554adb934f0dd8e", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "68c4ef8b6b435db69d36b67c36366c6907d5cc8c2cc268a0ac72165783634c67", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 30, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "4f9bea81d5604c809164ee34ecce391b07a8dd755e7b8fa70554adb934f0dd8e", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "68c4ef8b6b435db69d36b67c36366c6907d5cc8c2cc268a0ac72165783634c67", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_detect_storefront_healthy", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -1141,14 +3616,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1166,20 +3651,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1191,7 +3762,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1209,26 +3793,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "30b85118604500d9e6d5261bf08b324c99bcdefbc48e4dd9ed6e312d0be9a771", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "e590ab6098d4eb8419b4d156525827dd668425af6e9dcff951b8915852ac5296", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 30, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "30b85118604500d9e6d5261bf08b324c99bcdefbc48e4dd9ed6e312d0be9a771", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "e590ab6098d4eb8419b4d156525827dd668425af6e9dcff951b8915852ac5296", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_localize_analytics_crashloop", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -1238,14 +3942,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1263,20 +3977,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1288,7 +4088,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1306,26 +4119,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "5db705f4d9d95e55cde8a30fc650119bce5e2eb3c2a75fdd20881d49ff009d3a", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "2ada37993c70ac705c1c6839a9376629c01cd715ebcedd86c245ea2e72134a35", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 31, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "5db705f4d9d95e55cde8a30fc650119bce5e2eb3c2a75fdd20881d49ff009d3a", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "2ada37993c70ac705c1c6839a9376629c01cd715ebcedd86c245ea2e72134a35", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_localize_analytics_errors", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -1335,14 +4268,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1360,20 +4303,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1385,7 +4414,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1403,26 +4445,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" ], "passed": false }, - "wrong_value": { + "wrong_target": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false - } - }, + }, + "wrong_value": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" + ], + "passed": false + } + }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "066b132532db318c57174848d9633ceb6411ab3295e85fc6c28dc2855010290c", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "3e6f98eed158784e80a9582b4957eb024e78ac5fe7c565f2a26e8a776c845b41", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 31, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "066b132532db318c57174848d9633ceb6411ab3295e85fc6c28dc2855010290c", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "3e6f98eed158784e80a9582b4957eb024e78ac5fe7c565f2a26e8a776c845b41", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_localize_checkout_latency", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -1432,14 +4594,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1457,20 +4629,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1482,7 +4740,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1500,26 +4771,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "da4b73d39881b35e6378ddf284c8ed3d89f0b214ca27c5c71bbb83fc1b98d788", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "6f46711275bae152d513965d456b15e2dbf869f21c4a53bbdf1682e4e582c579", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "da4b73d39881b35e6378ddf284c8ed3d89f0b214ca27c5c71bbb83fc1b98d788", + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "6f46711275bae152d513965d456b15e2dbf869f21c4a53bbdf1682e4e582c579", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_localize_gateway_latency", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -1529,14 +4920,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1554,20 +4955,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1579,7 +5066,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1597,26 +5097,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "61f6a989d1f6c7e7052ae4165ce555e24c9b448905790aeae7370a5c4a6c1455", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "79d2e811fa3de21f5d4110fad93faeced4fa87e3063acbab26ef5372d85e9a03", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 29, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "61f6a989d1f6c7e7052ae4165ce555e24c9b448905790aeae7370a5c4a6c1455", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "79d2e811fa3de21f5d4110fad93faeced4fa87e3063acbab26ef5372d85e9a03", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_localize_media_latency", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -1626,14 +5246,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1658,20 +5288,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1683,7 +5399,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1708,81 +5437,291 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "d0537d3edbb86a286f70645e0b11d70996efbb24cb7dea76f18e0b420eb9fbd9", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "169fefdd57443bbe269e1f95a3c77277c5cc449baf483cfebe049ce1550c9625", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 57, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "d0537d3edbb86a286f70645e0b11d70996efbb24cb7dea76f18e0b420eb9fbd9", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 63, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "169fefdd57443bbe269e1f95a3c77277c5cc449baf483cfebe049ce1550c9625", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_auth_v1_to_v2", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-018-checkout-v1-to-v2", + "bench_id": "dob100-018-rca-payments-retry", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "consumer_before_retire", - "consumer_migrated", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1794,103 +5733,323 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "consumer_before_retire", - "consumer_migrated", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "b1714bbd935ca475319d3a773cdd764237b457feb0877a19f0301aadd7134485", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "21ea3c242d1adfe552ec0495362a5c95f4fce4846a2202ae80f6f24a48c68e35", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 57, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "b1714bbd935ca475319d3a773cdd764237b457feb0877a19f0301aadd7134485", - "source_task_id": "tsk_checkout_v1_to_v2", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "21ea3c242d1adfe552ec0495362a5c95f4fce4846a2202ae80f6f24a48c68e35", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_payments_retry", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-019-inventory-v1-to-v2", + "bench_id": "dob100-019-rca-catalog-n-plus-one", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -1902,100 +6061,323 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "2ece7d4b1f9804072c2dc23e10654005c2e6e32c53cd30f342fb81717114423f", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "13810070b8a34cef3ff5ca4470b2dc426f3ba8af83157cbdf3ad54e70e2ecbe9", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 51, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "2ece7d4b1f9804072c2dc23e10654005c2e6e32c53cd30f342fb81717114423f", - "source_task_id": "tsk_inventory_v1_to_v2", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "13810070b8a34cef3ff5ca4470b2dc426f3ba8af83157cbdf3ad54e70e2ecbe9", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_catalog_n_plus_one", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-020-media-v1-to-v2", + "bench_id": "dob100-020-rca-notifications-timeout", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2007,100 +6389,323 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "95584c6787eb67b7b29958151a7d3cdb774ab83a8eb7b55a97f5141e9c722dc0", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "bdc8278375a02662bb9e28562a5b8db66bd886602ab6b814b51dc06488ced0a3", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 50, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "95584c6787eb67b7b29958151a7d3cdb774ab83a8eb7b55a97f5141e9c722dc0", - "source_task_id": "tsk_media_v1_to_v2", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "bdc8278375a02662bb9e28562a5b8db66bd886602ab6b814b51dc06488ced0a3", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_notifications_timeout", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-021-notify-v1-to-v2", + "bench_id": "dob100-021-rca-inventory-pool", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2112,103 +6717,323 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "670729baf0e023c8cac8be0ec5699e981fa6e3fac6a3b14de0e8c12b321c5af5", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "a037e4426a08c2f9ed93614f4819e5cb0aeccdde35b5486994c96867f3cc9481", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 51, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "670729baf0e023c8cac8be0ec5699e981fa6e3fac6a3b14de0e8c12b321c5af5", - "source_task_id": "tsk_notify_v1_to_v2", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "a037e4426a08c2f9ed93614f4819e5cb0aeccdde35b5486994c96867f3cc9481", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_inventory_pool", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-022-orders-v1-to-v2", + "bench_id": "dob100-022-rca-inventory-migrator-security-context", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "consumer_before_retire", - "consumer_migrated", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2220,103 +7045,323 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "consumer_before_retire", - "consumer_migrated", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "772b19095f60a0df82b1b0cb7b8151ea9418bf75e723eeee8f97bfb199042525", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "0639ff2f7450bb02d73cc22ca4817ba5b19f33d97634ec72176cb0624b33e6d0", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 58, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "772b19095f60a0df82b1b0cb7b8151ea9418bf75e723eeee8f97bfb199042525", - "source_task_id": "tsk_orders_v1_to_v2", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 35, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "0639ff2f7450bb02d73cc22ca4817ba5b19f33d97634ec72176cb0624b33e6d0", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_inventory_migrator_security_context", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-023-search-v1-to-v2", + "bench_id": "dob100-023-rca-inventory-missing-role", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2328,49 +7373,179 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "deprecate_before_shift", - "drain_before_retire", - "legacy_retired", - "legacy_traffic_drained", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "replacement_serving_all_traffic", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", + "evidence_recorded", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "137c8a8fed568b1aef6d70ccccd964f9e1e9a7c83e42e3daa04ce65d7bc03eb4", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "bf829d3a349dd7d74ed3c018c18d4e0ae408360216dcc5869637c603fb735c78", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 52, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "137c8a8fed568b1aef6d70ccccd964f9e1e9a7c83e42e3daa04ce65d7bc03eb4", - "source_task_id": "tsk_search_v1_to_v2", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "bf829d3a349dd7d74ed3c018c18d4e0ae408360216dcc5869637c603fb735c78", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_inventory_missing_role", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { @@ -2379,14 +7554,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2407,19 +7592,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2431,7 +7703,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2452,179 +7737,619 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "0cfe8976dfa26fc096b048c1655575d1ef21ba6c11bf0a6665698fa2945f7e59", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "e09beda28bcf3e5186c451a8b7666e1ecedfd04d5927abe037a6e19d13024382", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 36, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "0cfe8976dfa26fc096b048c1655575d1ef21ba6c11bf0a6665698fa2945f7e59", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 38, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "e09beda28bcf3e5186c451a8b7666e1ecedfd04d5927abe037a6e19d13024382", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_attr_three_at_once", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-025-w5-attr-media-analytics-catalog", + "bench_id": "dob100-025-rca-catalog-gc-thrash", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_analytics_connection_refused", - "attributed_catalog_latency_sawtooth", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "causes_are_distinct", "closed_after_the_work", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_analytics_connection_refused", - "key_for_catalog_latency_sawtooth", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ - "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" + "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "write_before_read": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" ], "passed": false }, - "write_before_read": { + "wrong_answer": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_analytics_connection_refused", - "attributed_catalog_latency_sawtooth", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "causes_are_distinct", "closed_after_the_work", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_analytics_connection_refused", - "key_for_catalog_latency_sawtooth", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "0039c875907d72569e2f260135278b86fd625a2f7c1feff0e719bb89a92d9850", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "9c9d54fa8c684a125c212165d65aea33336399f01c108351e990b2838776b34f", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "0039c875907d72569e2f260135278b86fd625a2f7c1feff0e719bb89a92d9850", - "source_task_id": "tsk_w5_attr_media_analytics_catalog", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "9c9d54fa8c684a125c212165d65aea33336399f01c108351e990b2838776b34f", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_catalog_gc_thrash", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-026-w5-attr-media-analytics-payments", + "bench_id": "dob100-026-rca-storefront-traffic-flood", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_analytics_connection_refused", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "attributed_payments_error_rate", - "causes_are_distinct", "closed_after_the_work", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_analytics_connection_refused", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", - "key_for_payments_error_rate", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2636,97 +8361,323 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_analytics_connection_refused", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "attributed_payments_error_rate", - "causes_are_distinct", "closed_after_the_work", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_analytics_connection_refused", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", - "key_for_payments_error_rate", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "24f013146a17d6846126200d31df2d6fabac4e1095007784cf810a0d9c6fb988", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "09f4c6904b75d6d81b8a59c774289dedf3ab4131723b5eb11c0fd1cebb8b0d61", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "24f013146a17d6846126200d31df2d6fabac4e1095007784cf810a0d9c6fb988", - "source_task_id": "tsk_w5_attr_media_analytics_payments", + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "09f4c6904b75d6d81b8a59c774289dedf3ab4131723b5eb11c0fd1cebb8b0d61", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_storefront_traffic_flood", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-027-w5-attr-media-api-analytics", + "bench_id": "dob100-027-rca-analytics-untolerated-taint", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_analytics_connection_refused", - "attributed_gateway_latency_surge", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "causes_are_distinct", "closed_after_the_work", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_analytics_connection_refused", - "key_for_gateway_latency_surge", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2738,98 +8689,323 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_analytics_connection_refused", - "attributed_gateway_latency_surge", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "causes_are_distinct", "closed_after_the_work", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_analytics_connection_refused", - "key_for_gateway_latency_surge", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "1ca925687c53ed35f33a5fabe21612d960859ceda7fdf1686ea30e652827fde7", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "d1d86bf59a72b7becde5e8a5b00d6ea1cc1c1109c6fbe10fa7f4f74a76d65dde", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 35, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "1ca925687c53ed35f33a5fabe21612d960859ceda7fdf1686ea30e652827fde7", - "source_task_id": "tsk_w5_attr_media_api_analytics", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "d1d86bf59a72b7becde5e8a5b00d6ea1cc1c1109c6fbe10fa7f4f74a76d65dde", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_analytics_untolerated_taint", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-028-w5-attr-media-api-catalog", + "bench_id": "dob100-028-rca-media-recreate-strategy", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_catalog_latency_sawtooth", - "attributed_gateway_latency_surge", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "causes_are_distinct", "closed_after_the_work", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_catalog_latency_sawtooth", - "key_for_gateway_latency_surge", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2841,97 +9017,323 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_catalog_latency_sawtooth", - "attributed_gateway_latency_surge", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "causes_are_distinct", "closed_after_the_work", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_catalog_latency_sawtooth", - "key_for_gateway_latency_surge", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "aa6ed2c4bdefb6f3ce16a002247f29994534bcc287e79291f60a6111e1d59577", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "92842f30cd04a3ce2a2f59fde892a366b2a562c6244c3ea9e346ba21984d11e0", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "aa6ed2c4bdefb6f3ce16a002247f29994534bcc287e79291f60a6111e1d59577", - "source_task_id": "tsk_w5_attr_media_api_catalog", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 36, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "92842f30cd04a3ce2a2f59fde892a366b2a562c6244c3ea9e346ba21984d11e0", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_media_recreate_strategy", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-029-w5-attr-media-api-checkout", + "bench_id": "dob100-029-rca-inventory-unbound-storage", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_checkout_error_spike", - "attributed_gateway_latency_surge", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "causes_are_distinct", "closed_after_the_work", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_checkout_error_spike", - "key_for_gateway_latency_surge", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -2943,97 +9345,252 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_checkout_error_spike", - "attributed_gateway_latency_surge", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "causes_are_distinct", "closed_after_the_work", + "diagnosis_submitted", + "efficient_investigation", "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_checkout_error_spike", - "key_for_gateway_latency_surge", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", + "fault_type_correct", + "offending_key_correct", + "service_localized", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "9157fa24214b2d0788f89edc8c5231d565360d95508cff77f99265afab8457b5", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "03bce0c532751e5aff45d918465c38bfa28cd0c5741bb1e4ac99f1ac4d2d65d8", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 35, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "9157fa24214b2d0788f89edc8c5231d565360d95508cff77f99265afab8457b5", - "source_task_id": "tsk_w5_attr_media_api_checkout", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "03bce0c532751e5aff45d918465c38bfa28cd0c5741bb1e4ac99f1ac4d2d65d8", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rca_inventory_unbound_storage", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-030-w5-attr-media-api-payments", + "bench_id": "dob100-030-rcn-distinct-checkout-bugs", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_gateway_latency_surge", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "attributed_payments_error_rate", - "causes_are_distinct", + "answer_correct", + "answer_submitted", + "assumption_engages_the_ambiguity", "closed_after_the_work", - "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_gateway_latency_surge", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", - "key_for_payments_error_rate", + "consulted_github_issues", + "consulted_issue_links", + "consulted_jira_issues", + "consulted_linear_issues", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "consulted_github_issues", + "consulted_issue_links", + "consulted_jira_issues", + "consulted_linear_issues" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "consulted_github_issues", + "consulted_issue_links", + "consulted_jira_issues", + "consulted_linear_issues" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3045,48 +9602,180 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "attributed_gateway_latency_surge", - "attributed_media_upload_stalls", - "attributed_payments_error_rate", - "causes_are_distinct", + "answer_correct", + "answer_submitted", + "assumption_engages_the_ambiguity", "closed_after_the_work", - "evidence_recorded", - "key_for_gateway_latency_surge", - "key_for_media_upload_stalls", - "key_for_payments_error_rate", + "consulted_github_issues", + "consulted_issue_links", + "consulted_jira_issues", + "consulted_linear_issues", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "67d0446e00279e517f4276d70afdbb883f49265bda9613472532dff9ba501a80", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "0f313c85cc6e094194f5417430f6614d3a434a227bd73224d9fb31818d6848cc", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 35, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "67d0446e00279e517f4276d70afdbb883f49265bda9613472532dff9ba501a80", - "source_task_id": "tsk_w5_attr_media_api_payments", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "0f313c85cc6e094194f5417430f6614d3a434a227bd73224d9fb31818d6848cc", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_rcn_distinct_checkout_bugs", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { @@ -3095,14 +9784,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3119,20 +9818,108 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3144,7 +9931,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3161,26 +9961,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "eb5794b28f872973f776d1c7f4630d41c5571430cab8b35994aaf0df3f67b911", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "d584402ea609e4168153b9bb1a7f1864e019963fe571d220c638c146ea9fc168", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 30, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "eb5794b28f872973f776d1c7f4630d41c5571430cab8b35994aaf0df3f67b911", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "d584402ea609e4168153b9bb1a7f1864e019963fe571d220c638c146ea9fc168", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_impl_backoff", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -3190,14 +10110,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3214,20 +10144,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3239,7 +10255,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3256,26 +10285,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "48b6b56524cf25086eefb1c728bcf5466c6c35cb64920c6ca8cf045570bd9a50", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "ac4c56a57a70722f3116635ff6b96baa21729bf330f71ae0a9d50f3acaced643", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 27, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "48b6b56524cf25086eefb1c728bcf5466c6c35cb64920c6ca8cf045570bd9a50", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "ac4c56a57a70722f3116635ff6b96baa21729bf330f71ae0a9d50f3acaced643", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_impl_cachekey", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -3285,14 +10434,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3309,20 +10468,108 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3334,7 +10581,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3351,26 +10611,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "60eb1c6b9a3842db41a15624f9da350162f706b2c321854a3b6df6fad0a0cbad", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "cb0355e58a8e2dfc6f14874fc720e070bb0d0c030a02545bd297304c0ae251ba", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 28, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "60eb1c6b9a3842db41a15624f9da350162f706b2c321854a3b6df6fad0a0cbad", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "cb0355e58a8e2dfc6f14874fc720e070bb0d0c030a02545bd297304c0ae251ba", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_impl_chunk", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -3380,14 +10760,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3404,20 +10794,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3429,7 +10905,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3446,26 +10935,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "4859829258abb767bf0ff05508c763dae67bb553f7fc7eab88b7edb199e12418", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "96c1f72d7273dfb6cd032c780c76587b6c3a5990ad9a1dc47c20134de1c04087", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 28, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "4859829258abb767bf0ff05508c763dae67bb553f7fc7eab88b7edb199e12418", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "96c1f72d7273dfb6cd032c780c76587b6c3a5990ad9a1dc47c20134de1c04087", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_impl_ratelimit", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -3475,14 +11084,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3498,12 +11117,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3513,6 +11127,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -3521,7 +11150,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3536,26 +11178,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "287c7c0b7fdee1d8aa73e27f7c876f10a3a39d608171d80b1cbd7a5b583d035d", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "be12c564baa3c455771746c22d80092f39235ca6aa4478c6b12d3ac52f94bbd5", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 29, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "287c7c0b7fdee1d8aa73e27f7c876f10a3a39d608171d80b1cbd7a5b583d035d", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 35, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "be12c564baa3c455771746c22d80092f39235ca6aa4478c6b12d3ac52f94bbd5", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_port_close_backlog_issues", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -3565,14 +11327,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3588,12 +11360,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3603,6 +11370,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -3611,7 +11393,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3626,26 +11421,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "f08ea9537fe262001347fcfdb691f0511036a59673a22545c423a89eb5e8d8d1", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "76e9ebd039997b34bc35f7fcdea56c6470c77f09a6bd902b75248ee98104b63e", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 27, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "f08ea9537fe262001347fcfdb691f0511036a59673a22545c423a89eb5e8d8d1", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "76e9ebd039997b34bc35f7fcdea56c6470c77f09a6bd902b75248ee98104b63e", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_port_close_blocked_issues", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -3655,14 +11570,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3678,12 +11603,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3693,6 +11613,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -3701,7 +11636,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3716,26 +11664,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "e72a16c7e291147839d0f6b54162ffc17b3a20359edef02451d026616f30e259", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "d53cf76e64ea5b9bb9ec08b182dee70b2491ae3bc245e7f145ade5e167769867", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "e72a16c7e291147839d0f6b54162ffc17b3a20359edef02451d026616f30e259", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 40, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "d53cf76e64ea5b9bb9ec08b182dee70b2491ae3bc245e7f145ade5e167769867", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_port_copy_priority_issues", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -3745,14 +11813,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3767,12 +11845,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3782,6 +11855,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -3790,7 +11878,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3804,26 +11905,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "4855b54a06f526c4a01154c42c7a0402c3fad0d14c13f54a3d9cdac4782f486f", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "ee898627bdd686a5b504510edd57c727afa7ae89fb1ecab4cee5ec449c518237", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 28, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "4855b54a06f526c4a01154c42c7a0402c3fad0d14c13f54a3d9cdac4782f486f", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "ee898627bdd686a5b504510edd57c727afa7ae89fb1ecab4cee5ec449c518237", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_port_count_inflight_work", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -3833,14 +12054,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3855,12 +12086,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3870,6 +12096,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -3878,7 +12119,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3892,26 +12146,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "2d9c419d897f74bfe3544fd0b99427aa7aa1e14eb46b0c78b13adee33701e593", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "95f79bba766ad1724eb44a5aeed7fb3e66ed9f954e7a1aec78bcc7c4a15c2d97", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 29, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "2d9c419d897f74bfe3544fd0b99427aa7aa1e14eb46b0c78b13adee33701e593", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "95f79bba766ad1724eb44a5aeed7fb3e66ed9f954e7a1aec78bcc7c4a15c2d97", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_port_count_unowned_work", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -3921,14 +12295,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3944,12 +12328,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3959,6 +12338,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -3967,7 +12361,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -3982,26 +12389,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "041ff7331ea96545bea0e7a73304dd4a83f5acfb0db92bc284c9769efb2ac5d1", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "5cf0cb77995f31f53834a80ac138b0cf61a1afbf6755e28c2db8b63b0b0db907", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 28, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "041ff7331ea96545bea0e7a73304dd4a83f5acfb0db92bc284c9769efb2ac5d1", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 35, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "5cf0cb77995f31f53834a80ac138b0cf61a1afbf6755e28c2db8b63b0b0db907", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_port_dedupe_linked_issues", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -4011,14 +12538,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4033,12 +12570,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4048,6 +12580,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -4056,7 +12603,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4070,26 +12630,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "af715e35514d881c7bd555b66171ae11482ae9d77d3937d01abb9aa97345803f", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "5326d17a5a88da4d265eabdecc578422cc2d33d7e9edc36beb1a42d80b54375f", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 28, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "af715e35514d881c7bd555b66171ae11482ae9d77d3937d01abb9aa97345803f", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "5326d17a5a88da4d265eabdecc578422cc2d33d7e9edc36beb1a42d80b54375f", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_port_escalate_to_gateway_oncall", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -4099,14 +12779,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4121,12 +12811,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4136,6 +12821,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -4144,7 +12844,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4158,26 +12871,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "e2bb48abfdb9a193d838102bc43a88fa7f40f7cef76d2cadfc8131b8a681884c", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "70933f6f1c7411553182c180546cd1525c2d378e5683d5b6f00b9d1b0b1794ce", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 28, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "e2bb48abfdb9a193d838102bc43a88fa7f40f7cef76d2cadfc8131b8a681884c", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "70933f6f1c7411553182c180546cd1525c2d378e5683d5b6f00b9d1b0b1794ce", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_port_high_priority_since", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -4187,14 +13020,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4211,20 +13054,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4236,7 +13165,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4253,26 +13195,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "8ccf8a235d289c9cf405ed40f4694ed57ee79ea8b07830d1c4679787b43f6fc5", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "a187c60eb6d715dfb143aa607cd45f55a6073a36f3453d2ef2aa82b7c6306c5e", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 38, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "8ccf8a235d289c9cf405ed40f4694ed57ee79ea8b07830d1c4679787b43f6fc5", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 40, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "a187c60eb6d715dfb143aa607cd45f55a6073a36f3453d2ef2aa82b7c6306c5e", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_analytics_batch_size", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -4282,14 +13344,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4310,20 +13382,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4335,7 +13493,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4356,26 +13527,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "376dd22cb99840a38fdbc12d46b99dc156dbc05472b22d626c6d1a3d6e306544", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "85f3d07207551e00783f0adc2ad529b2a28548fe19ac2f06e5511983f3051215", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 41, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "376dd22cb99840a38fdbc12d46b99dc156dbc05472b22d626c6d1a3d6e306544", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 48, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "85f3d07207551e00783f0adc2ad529b2a28548fe19ac2f06e5511983f3051215", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_analytics_prefetch", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -4385,14 +13676,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4410,20 +13711,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4435,7 +13822,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4453,26 +13853,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "7ebc435d123fe99b011d4ce6f0d610357fe5a1697c8a013dfb7034929aa27ee5", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "a561c42215211df3e875e789a0e426383758068a98b028b9363be99089a614c0", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 40, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "7ebc435d123fe99b011d4ce6f0d610357fe5a1697c8a013dfb7034929aa27ee5", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 45, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "a561c42215211df3e875e789a0e426383758068a98b028b9363be99089a614c0", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_checkout_payments_timeout", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -4482,14 +14002,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4511,20 +14041,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4536,7 +14152,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4558,26 +14187,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "6acadd52fcb930bc7f84406df5f5778334f2a9a5a292a7dccff87da1dd751838", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "c2b92d6b2e87a80c03201d7e134210cdba2eaa485b75113110cfdc843733ad73", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "6acadd52fcb930bc7f84406df5f5778334f2a9a5a292a7dccff87da1dd751838", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 50, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "c2b92d6b2e87a80c03201d7e134210cdba2eaa485b75113110cfdc843733ad73", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_inventory_pool", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -4587,14 +14336,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4615,32 +14374,131 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ - "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" + "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "write_before_read": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" ], "passed": false }, - "write_before_read": { + "wrong_answer": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4661,74 +14519,209 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "1fc0aa6cc4d3ca816f2475bf60c69c923f9dbe5119c272c639488ac2d526b35d", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "4d103bd039d9275e6427b1db8fd86d331f2a28c81d05541f05e3da82f80b9f1c", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 42, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "1fc0aa6cc4d3ca816f2475bf60c69c923f9dbe5119c272c639488ac2d526b35d", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 47, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "4d103bd039d9275e6427b1db8fd86d331f2a28c81d05541f05e3da82f80b9f1c", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_notifications_timeout", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-048-payments-notify-timeout", + "bench_id": "dob100-048-port-count-open-priority", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", + "answer_correct", "closed_after_the_work", - "config_deployed_to_production", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", + "read_the_source_of_truth", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "read_the_source_of_truth" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4740,45 +14733,174 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", + "answer_correct", "closed_after_the_work", - "config_deployed_to_production", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "41a860d413eb31aad4a4bbcda908e75e900a15fa91ff9baaab7d124b25d4f883", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "428e798e99d9b6ade0af5d29cefd2d75f9c74304ac18daec91adab41956d886b", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 38, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "41a860d413eb31aad4a4bbcda908e75e900a15fa91ff9baaab7d124b25d4f883", - "source_task_id": "tsk_payments_notify_timeout", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "428e798e99d9b6ade0af5d29cefd2d75f9c74304ac18daec91adab41956d886b", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_port_count_open_priority", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { @@ -4787,14 +14909,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4816,20 +14948,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4841,7 +15059,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4863,26 +15094,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "b561a5f466a6fd5a76125ddbf439b3f4bfc766dc874b96bd8f7e74e5ba9d2091", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "7f77caba921eed7dc12e3c90a4a70b8ad38f4af380ceba6e3286b6dcf6abb6e3", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "b561a5f466a6fd5a76125ddbf439b3f4bfc766dc874b96bd8f7e74e5ba9d2091", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 48, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "7f77caba921eed7dc12e3c90a4a70b8ad38f4af380ceba6e3286b6dcf6abb6e3", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_payments_retry", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -4892,14 +15243,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4921,20 +15282,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4946,7 +15393,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -4968,26 +15428,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "7e448a815b4917cd2774db7760b8b77ebb13b8eb57d059ae5860e1c6191c7ff1", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "9e62b1cc053bb864a3138313ccd179464f1be1de0b4a2d6fddb4871d6610846b", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "7e448a815b4917cd2774db7760b8b77ebb13b8eb57d059ae5860e1c6191c7ff1", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 46, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "9e62b1cc053bb864a3138313ccd179464f1be1de0b4a2d6fddb4871d6610846b", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_payments_retry_from_code", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -4997,14 +15577,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5023,19 +15613,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5047,7 +15724,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5066,26 +15756,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "463377ef517d2ebc946827cc60ff75ac7a3054788640ba8a18049bbf20f0953d", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "4e63998444c631d887e57884000c956bdd3f53b01c66d3e95b28fa29d9ee265e", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 40, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "463377ef517d2ebc946827cc60ff75ac7a3054788640ba8a18049bbf20f0953d", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "4e63998444c631d887e57884000c956bdd3f53b01c66d3e95b28fa29d9ee265e", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_checkout_v2_layout_cleanup", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -5095,14 +15905,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5123,20 +15943,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5148,7 +16054,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5169,26 +16088,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "9013e7c1a6631773d382dd19ba37531476bebd6e0ed00ac7f6e387ac0f68da48", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "6a5ce2e6a5efa5e51d41fd5e91c1fedf6c5a4117d33544e05ed8950065734a87", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 39, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "9013e7c1a6631773d382dd19ba37531476bebd6e0ed00ac7f6e387ac0f68da48", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 44, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "6a5ce2e6a5efa5e51d41fd5e91c1fedf6c5a4117d33544e05ed8950065734a87", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_express_checkout", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -5198,14 +16237,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5225,20 +16274,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5250,7 +16385,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5270,26 +16418,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "9a53075838746fc008d39ce1d8b49c0948e93081ae20ab904b1de0b4f64bcd88", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "39f85b7ebcbe0f3a047ed0e869815852dcfd87a43164afb93ce61707391c3ca1", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 37, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "9a53075838746fc008d39ce1d8b49c0948e93081ae20ab904b1de0b4f64bcd88", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "39f85b7ebcbe0f3a047ed0e869815852dcfd87a43164afb93ce61707391c3ca1", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_instant_refunds_killswitch", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -5299,14 +16567,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5324,19 +16602,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5348,7 +16713,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5366,26 +16744,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "eda05a9513c74ebcbceba72470c25ce4eea4afc691d484d925e73eff3950f88a", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "b65e440d4a3108db1113c38d4213c79f7ac9ae970265ffba3c86d098a9976f1e", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 38, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "eda05a9513c74ebcbceba72470c25ce4eea4afc691d484d925e73eff3950f88a", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 41, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "b65e440d4a3108db1113c38d4213c79f7ac9ae970265ffba3c86d098a9976f1e", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_legacy_price_rounding_cleanup", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -5395,14 +16893,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5422,20 +16930,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5447,7 +17041,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5467,26 +17074,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "d05c34fc6a717ab69b04c1ef740d946421a934d557e7640ad2fa7e8eb376b2f1", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "ca8591516dfbf1f360a14996d6beeb399c3a158943a92763b6c7abf9e375fb67", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 38, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "d05c34fc6a717ab69b04c1ef740d946421a934d557e7640ad2fa7e8eb376b2f1", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 41, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "ca8591516dfbf1f360a14996d6beeb399c3a158943a92763b6c7abf9e375fb67", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_media_webp", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -5496,14 +17223,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5526,19 +17263,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5550,7 +17374,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5573,26 +17410,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "366ffa724a57eda4e162a6b35863cb0f9ebef745f25d7189a8ac12e2b12a1fe8", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "838d7d28b98d60072548e5966fd1c416e927f0bf9b37ce330da0ec6981a27482", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "366ffa724a57eda4e162a6b35863cb0f9ebef745f25d7189a8ac12e2b12a1fe8", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 46, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "838d7d28b98d60072548e5966fd1c416e927f0bf9b37ce330da0ec6981a27482", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_saved_carts", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -5602,14 +17559,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5629,20 +17596,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5654,7 +17707,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5674,26 +17740,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "c304d4a62ed31ffa2b99fb34d45bda5fcd6a6802c179eec48a3b6f5c6df71006", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "7f8fa1b98ac601477fa053ddd7310df22a8284c51628079e1ea9f9df3ce595e8", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 37, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "c304d4a62ed31ffa2b99fb34d45bda5fcd6a6802c179eec48a3b6f5c6df71006", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "7f8fa1b98ac601477fa053ddd7310df22a8284c51628079e1ea9f9df3ce595e8", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_search_autocomplete", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -5703,14 +17889,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5728,19 +17924,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5752,7 +18035,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5770,26 +18066,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "31f19bde593223e0955e090e922a8d3e86774f5ab2a5564e0efd60818983bfa4", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "ac076edde864419edf91bdfa83b38143788d22dcdc329a8e181b768f756d7c03", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 38, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "31f19bde593223e0955e090e922a8d3e86774f5ab2a5564e0efd60818983bfa4", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 40, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "ac076edde864419edf91bdfa83b38143788d22dcdc329a8e181b768f756d7c03", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_flaky_analytics_rollup", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -5799,14 +18215,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5824,19 +18250,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5848,7 +18361,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5866,26 +18392,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "da6f11c7a85f99691a2bbb66a5e4931bb484120502a19965f1db5a908d9201da", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "3d9c743c82767526919ae4e1e3ecb554d174cafd3ba61df8db735b6798a0e1ca", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 39, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "da6f11c7a85f99691a2bbb66a5e4931bb484120502a19965f1db5a908d9201da", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 40, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "3d9c743c82767526919ae4e1e3ecb554d174cafd3ba61df8db735b6798a0e1ca", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_flaky_catalog_rounding", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -5895,14 +18541,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5920,19 +18576,105 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5944,7 +18686,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -5962,26 +18717,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "3444a8ec53de110cd74c07889f210f904b9270c1cf25c86012dbb46d7a3cab80", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "32fa9949379f0dbb901ce4436f4a04d37df38f0d704c6e2598e6cce10bb7c759", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 38, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "3444a8ec53de110cd74c07889f210f904b9270c1cf25c86012dbb46d7a3cab80", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 40, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "32fa9949379f0dbb901ce4436f4a04d37df38f0d704c6e2598e6cce10bb7c759", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_flaky_checkout_idempotency", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -5991,14 +18866,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6016,19 +18901,108 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6038,9 +19012,22 @@ ], "passed": false }, - "write_before_read": { + "write_before_read": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6058,73 +19045,210 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "2590a8daf885f77521d0d0547a0b9f5b2a31bb37e3efbc28c9cd89bded217278", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "6e4c52312528655ecbc12cffd2c61399d0399b6143baf6b09f396e9752816222", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 39, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "2590a8daf885f77521d0d0547a0b9f5b2a31bb37e3efbc28c9cd89bded217278", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 40, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "6e4c52312528655ecbc12cffd2c61399d0399b6143baf6b09f396e9752816222", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_flaky_gateway_timeout", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-062-flaky-inventory-race", + "bench_id": "dob100-062-w6-copy-13", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "ci_all_stages_green", + "announced_the_mirror", "closed_after_the_work", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "test_fixed_not_quarantined", - "three_green_main_runs", + "every_match_copied", + "read_the_source_of_truth", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "read_the_source_of_truth" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6136,45 +19260,175 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "ci_all_stages_green", + "announced_the_mirror", "closed_after_the_work", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", - "test_fixed_not_quarantined", - "three_green_main_runs", + "every_match_copied", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "64ad5809aae780c20eb529f15ff92a74484ae03fad90dcd252863c078ca554ab", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "fb3e2655fab5b6b492194492610ff40dc6be3741f19c8858017bfdfd2b8a1549", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 39, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "64ad5809aae780c20eb529f15ff92a74484ae03fad90dcd252863c078ca554ab", - "source_task_id": "tsk_flaky_inventory_race", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 48, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "fb3e2655fab5b6b492194492610ff40dc6be3741f19c8858017bfdfd2b8a1549", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_w6_copy_13", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { @@ -6183,14 +19437,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6208,19 +19472,108 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6232,7 +19585,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6250,26 +19616,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "e2050a8b9c23a2d6264ecc40c9eca5bab6be6a78dfc94e07874440a5bc867a29", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "ce878c466960d84e30092c3d5d2754292803d6de9645b2ed37cf27135a4cfe91", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 40, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "e2050a8b9c23a2d6264ecc40c9eca5bab6be6a78dfc94e07874440a5bc867a29", + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "ce878c466960d84e30092c3d5d2754292803d6de9645b2ed37cf27135a4cfe91", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_flaky_search_index", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -6279,14 +19765,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6304,20 +19800,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6329,7 +19911,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6347,26 +19942,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "8f793c02483d367411bcf671f4a262f3541f5343fa6e27a4f380d176f57404fa", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "98649394b9643a2951a97612159d6d1dd5cae95f924b03ae213f9a49851df951", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 28, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "8f793c02483d367411bcf671f4a262f3541f5343fa6e27a4f380d176f57404fa", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "98649394b9643a2951a97612159d6d1dd5cae95f924b03ae213f9a49851df951", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_hand_cluster_runbook", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -6376,14 +20091,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6401,20 +20126,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6426,7 +20237,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6444,26 +20268,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "586939dc12780eedb97c28fd1d26cafdd23d1774e9101b81b822710a813e268e", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "8249039b2c9fab4152fe3446bdea0acace3cbf451374e74a626411fca990289e", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 30, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "586939dc12780eedb97c28fd1d26cafdd23d1774e9101b81b822710a813e268e", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "8249039b2c9fab4152fe3446bdea0acace3cbf451374e74a626411fca990289e", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_hand_gateway_runbook", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -6473,14 +20417,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6498,20 +20452,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6523,7 +20563,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6541,26 +20594,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "e0f5cb9afee9fccd88525bb223ab33fb1a1aa5ab2fc5e62469ae3117f9b7151d", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "2057cec653b738feecff9a2cc3c7d245dc6f485443c1cb1275fda430f460a6f3", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 30, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "e0f5cb9afee9fccd88525bb223ab33fb1a1aa5ab2fc5e62469ae3117f9b7151d", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 37, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "2057cec653b738feecff9a2cc3c7d245dc6f485443c1cb1275fda430f460a6f3", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_hz_checkout_flag_kill", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -6570,14 +20743,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6595,19 +20778,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6619,7 +20889,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6637,26 +20920,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "b6f8aa74a977c3f3f1bd5d1e4dd4f8c3d8b8fcbfd6a915e60777c5707a9ff48a", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "98263d1e0fc7acc589be5eca05bc5ae1bf8de254370c8c4338a4753c8993df4c", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 31, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "b6f8aa74a977c3f3f1bd5d1e4dd4f8c3d8b8fcbfd6a915e60777c5707a9ff48a", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 37, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "98263d1e0fc7acc589be5eca05bc5ae1bf8de254370c8c4338a4753c8993df4c", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_hz_gateway_leak_rollback", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -6666,14 +21069,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6692,19 +21105,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6716,7 +21216,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6735,26 +21248,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "0c0ea52aeb884b02aa8348e657fb33ea7f578c95dfb33a8a452bb91bb8a373db", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "7f9b1023870752ed21d34a9acd0cf283aaf51006ccdb3e6e77a36b5439d8d46e", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 41, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "0c0ea52aeb884b02aa8348e657fb33ea7f578c95dfb33a8a452bb91bb8a373db", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 42, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "7f9b1023870752ed21d34a9acd0cf283aaf51006ccdb3e6e77a36b5439d8d46e", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_gated_rotate_partner_credential", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -6764,14 +21397,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6788,11 +21431,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_proposals" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6802,6 +21441,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -6810,7 +21464,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6826,26 +21493,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "8ca866cf2b6cea73f33912fe7fe94de298aa25c10176f21e6f1332c714c3344c", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "e5b2170b6f591ed6c8654f9389135aae69ca992aa3798e326e6b2c75c3a37709", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "8ca866cf2b6cea73f33912fe7fe94de298aa25c10176f21e6f1332c714c3344c", + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "e5b2170b6f591ed6c8654f9389135aae69ca992aa3798e326e6b2c75c3a37709", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_judge_analytics_oom", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -6855,14 +21642,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6879,12 +21676,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_proposals" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6894,6 +21686,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -6902,7 +21709,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6918,26 +21738,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "76ce004a91594c821f0a2dbbd44fdecda40ef6c5707181f2af6294b027161092", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "d99892cf833c3210842d084b6c1025d9f4521627c71935b4b9be04d5d4bf97e9", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "76ce004a91594c821f0a2dbbd44fdecda40ef6c5707181f2af6294b027161092", + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "d99892cf833c3210842d084b6c1025d9f4521627c71935b4b9be04d5d4bf97e9", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_judge_checkout_flag", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -6947,14 +21887,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6971,11 +21921,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_proposals" ], "passed": false }, @@ -6985,6 +21931,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -6993,7 +21954,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7009,26 +21983,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "5444e9c00d27bf1664cfd1ab9394f47ace569b37ed7dabc364ba4b33e974daa4", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "d5c46d1c4dc59b04502845290d4c40d566490175d224d71793cfd4fc5f5c9f43", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "5444e9c00d27bf1664cfd1ab9394f47ace569b37ed7dabc364ba4b33e974daa4", + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "d5c46d1c4dc59b04502845290d4c40d566490175d224d71793cfd4fc5f5c9f43", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_judge_gateway_latency", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -7038,14 +22132,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7062,12 +22166,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_proposals" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7077,6 +22176,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -7085,7 +22199,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7101,26 +22228,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "3c82b936df0487aa3c8ad660aa6688fe374f4a83ddb1d8b7bb7ff58f2b07b377", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "2d1487854598f778bce8ed2286f39ad7f480764fc95b28e543f383f8ba10b1de", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 30, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "3c82b936df0487aa3c8ad660aa6688fe374f4a83ddb1d8b7bb7ff58f2b07b377", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "2d1487854598f778bce8ed2286f39ad7f480764fc95b28e543f383f8ba10b1de", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_judge_payments_retry", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -7130,14 +22377,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7158,20 +22415,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7183,7 +22526,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7204,26 +22560,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "e03b6ecddcbc422660c7fff30c50d020f68241fe214482c12effd263e3e4a6bb", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "2493708df415abdd3655de00c7eb5e192c08c377dc65281cbbb52c87b53ddacc", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 42, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "e03b6ecddcbc422660c7fff30c50d020f68241fe214482c12effd263e3e4a6bb", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 49, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "2493708df415abdd3655de00c7eb5e192c08c377dc65281cbbb52c87b53ddacc", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_catalog_batch_pricing", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -7233,14 +22709,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7257,20 +22743,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7282,7 +22854,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7299,26 +22884,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "d4146ccd60aa7848f63ce256698942643031adce0ae9e677e5987c85454c2567", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "4f017cbad375541e3fc49981305834fe022eb328c5f0810588f121c3b28672a9", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 37, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "d4146ccd60aa7848f63ce256698942643031adce0ae9e677e5987c85454c2567", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 42, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "4f017cbad375541e3fc49981305834fe022eb328c5f0810588f121c3b28672a9", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_catalog_cache_ttl", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -7328,14 +23033,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7355,20 +23070,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7380,7 +23181,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7400,26 +23214,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "b6b38939ebf744d999ba408ec7189a488a36ec4eb9c834bb101ce6514dbfcc69", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "aab2ad6b3e86d1d0710926032557a59c28e12c426180848324794be7bc782daf", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 42, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "b6b38939ebf744d999ba408ec7189a488a36ec4eb9c834bb101ce6514dbfcc69", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "aab2ad6b3e86d1d0710926032557a59c28e12c426180848324794be7bc782daf", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_catalog_pricing_from_code", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -7429,14 +23363,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7454,20 +23398,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7479,7 +23509,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7497,26 +23540,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "91e950c5539486b4b3d511802b9f0df00537802f20449c69a0a1b3d8f2fca56f", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "cc67ab10eb849934d88a6f50bb95688fd922e54c24c065b4491a1181febd1c96", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 39, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "91e950c5539486b4b3d511802b9f0df00537802f20449c69a0a1b3d8f2fca56f", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 45, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "cc67ab10eb849934d88a6f50bb95688fd922e54c24c065b4491a1181febd1c96", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_gateway_pool_reuse", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -7526,14 +23689,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7556,19 +23729,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7580,7 +23840,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7603,26 +23876,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "172c862c30ec290c5d4d45fb13f658626665e77977784d98bff78e9fae4d3786", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "31008e1155c52f1734f5ca123f95485fa81d34b2ff074573b070101abd0ec912", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 39, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "172c862c30ec290c5d4d45fb13f658626665e77977784d98bff78e9fae4d3786", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 45, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "31008e1155c52f1734f5ca123f95485fa81d34b2ff074573b070101abd0ec912", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_gateway_v510_rollback", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -7632,14 +24025,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7660,20 +24063,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7685,7 +24174,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7706,77 +24208,209 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "2e3d460522bb3d8fcb65d5d0576d32770c9295ad7f898c45cb4eba2bf73ffe38", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "23006305a2355cac649f1daf33c0e65bc2760d97f01a7a4b9f7bbd24309ded76", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 42, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "2e3d460522bb3d8fcb65d5d0576d32770c9295ad7f898c45cb4eba2bf73ffe38", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 47, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "23006305a2355cac649f1daf33c0e65bc2760d97f01a7a4b9f7bbd24309ded76", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_media_cdn", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-079-search-cache", + "bench_id": "dob100-079-port-collect-open-issues", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "ack_before_resolve", - "alarm_resolved", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "config_deployed_to_production", - "jira_twin_resolved", - "metric_within_slo", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", + "every_match_reported", + "read_the_source_of_truth", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "read_the_source_of_truth" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7788,94 +24422,236 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "ack_before_resolve", - "alarm_resolved", - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "config_deployed_to_production", - "jira_twin_resolved", - "metric_within_slo", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", + "every_match_reported", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "030168a91c8b5eb51d7abccf264100452c03497405430b62affa6435bd945b2c", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "16671656cece3f060ba4f11ba77d09c9677c08582fceb47833cad4128024f271", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 44, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "030168a91c8b5eb51d7abccf264100452c03497405430b62affa6435bd945b2c", - "source_task_id": "tsk_search_cache", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "16671656cece3f060ba4f11ba77d09c9677c08582fceb47833cad4128024f271", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_port_collect_open_issues", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-080-search-shards", + "bench_id": "dob100-080-port-report-customer-reports", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "config_deployed_to_production", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", + "every_match_reported", + "read_the_source_of_truth", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "read_the_source_of_truth" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7887,44 +24663,174 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "ci_all_stages_green", "closed_after_the_work", - "config_deployed_to_production", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", + "every_match_reported", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "0d3f47e610bfb61e38c30f03c70a3487246abab36fccb21d1002645bb5a2a24f", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "5bad28a3eb85c52211514804e6868e487dce0a1c0ab4c9ffae829e7ebb2e86ad", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 37, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "0d3f47e610bfb61e38c30f03c70a3487246abab36fccb21d1002645bb5a2a24f", - "source_task_id": "tsk_search_shards", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 33, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "5bad28a3eb85c52211514804e6868e487dce0a1c0ab4c9ffae829e7ebb2e86ad", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_port_report_customer_reports", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { @@ -7933,14 +24839,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7966,20 +24882,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -7991,7 +24993,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8017,26 +25032,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "a1311b8da84e1eec1f4abd5ff2aaf69116a7cfe6e84737fdaa2cd94cf16f1f6a", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "f7ee6ca4096ca3732a1870c719d80781270694c950067046f2395b443eebcf0b", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 55, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "a1311b8da84e1eec1f4abd5ff2aaf69116a7cfe6e84737fdaa2cd94cf16f1f6a", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 64, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "f7ee6ca4096ca3732a1870c719d80781270694c950067046f2395b443eebcf0b", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_backorders", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -8046,14 +25181,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8078,20 +25223,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8103,7 +25334,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8128,26 +25372,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "ee189d3dbdcb7e683e6217524ff1302b54c193523bb25c85ec6f77f31e1a8fd3", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "3e2e745fce1df528a47c5959860df5fcb8def02c87e7b1d45f8f72d7b057bbaa", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 50, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "ee189d3dbdcb7e683e6217524ff1302b54c193523bb25c85ec6f77f31e1a8fd3", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 58, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "3e2e745fce1df528a47c5959860df5fcb8def02c87e7b1d45f8f72d7b057bbaa", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_checkout_upsell", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -8157,14 +25521,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8191,20 +25565,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8216,7 +25676,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8243,26 +25716,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "8a69fe891a7563e52bbb2a598a21357e8f4547d91a206f79f6006c18a61d2ff3", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "5b72ee48b6ab9d527a0658fc5d8327a37a3a792072e08841a555740e3179c073", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 58, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "8a69fe891a7563e52bbb2a598a21357e8f4547d91a206f79f6006c18a61d2ff3", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 67, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "5b72ee48b6ab9d527a0658fc5d8327a37a3a792072e08841a555740e3179c073", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_loyalty_points", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -8272,14 +25865,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8303,20 +25906,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8328,7 +26017,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8352,26 +26054,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "0feb902272093126f96c2e23fdf43dc2ee1be4e0843181163d582e693d666799", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "d8f9327e046e7b094051f60741590eb607fbe0c8b603cf7db6017c220d972a24", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 47, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "0feb902272093126f96c2e23fdf43dc2ee1be4e0843181163d582e693d666799", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 55, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "d8f9327e046e7b094051f60741590eb607fbe0c8b603cf7db6017c220d972a24", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_media_pipeline", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -8381,14 +26203,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8409,20 +26241,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8434,7 +26352,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8455,26 +26386,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "c18c8e16035b26ca6cc3aee6489b045ecbc86125d52989906bef1f919daa3502", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "a06db8a9b04aba2593a0222327c5aa9da01f6d825af37fdbdebb77c0ecd55b7f", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 42, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "c18c8e16035b26ca6cc3aee6489b045ecbc86125d52989906bef1f919daa3502", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 47, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "a06db8a9b04aba2593a0222327c5aa9da01f6d825af37fdbdebb77c0ecd55b7f", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_notification_templates", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -8484,14 +26535,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8511,20 +26572,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8536,7 +26683,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8556,26 +26716,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "03ad1d1f917940b35727fba7e30ca32962eefef72b901547dc2351f0d53f7416", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "3a4d9514f17c1b617fe785fb83e0b97d7a92bb52c3ed5f4b783ee8c6e644e5dd", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 42, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "03ad1d1f917940b35727fba7e30ca32962eefef72b901547dc2351f0d53f7416", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 48, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "3a4d9514f17c1b617fe785fb83e0b97d7a92bb52c3ed5f4b783ee8c6e644e5dd", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_search_relevance", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -8585,14 +26865,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8615,20 +26905,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8640,7 +27016,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8663,26 +27052,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "862e832e02165cb088bb45c45a9ba886983dc99019f174d919d795f4fbe2aebe", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "30b7a2b314e8702b8ee43c9b134a52c05a5cee72c38725a18d6242c65cf88078", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 51, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "862e832e02165cb088bb45c45a9ba886983dc99019f174d919d795f4fbe2aebe", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 53, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "30b7a2b314e8702b8ee43c9b134a52c05a5cee72c38725a18d6242c65cf88078", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_split_settlement", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -8692,14 +27201,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8717,12 +27236,8 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "consulted_alert_firings", + "consulted_alert_silences" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8733,6 +27248,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -8741,7 +27271,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8759,26 +27302,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "58068683d66f2be84f13def8af1117a112aede98efb65efa15136093a4630d30", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "a4128cae973f9a6f071860595393772f52a792caa3a4c1be26a9aa6dbf2eadf2", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 31, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "58068683d66f2be84f13def8af1117a112aede98efb65efa15136093a4630d30", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "a4128cae973f9a6f071860595393772f52a792caa3a4c1be26a9aa6dbf2eadf2", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rcn_alerts_for_incident", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -8788,14 +27451,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8813,12 +27486,8 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "consulted_pd_incidents", + "consulted_status_page_posts" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8829,6 +27498,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -8837,7 +27521,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8855,26 +27552,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "0c342c17eed8a74faa67743874f52f39f519dd8e21496f9bdb9137560dbbd835", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "eba8fe1908ca29787aef2f6bc90c1050f5200a7478699c90e057e0d871bc6de9", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "0c342c17eed8a74faa67743874f52f39f519dd8e21496f9bdb9137560dbbd835", + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "eba8fe1908ca29787aef2f6bc90c1050f5200a7478699c90e057e0d871bc6de9", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rcn_customer_facing_incidents", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -8884,14 +27701,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8910,11 +27737,9 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "consulted_owner_spreadsheet", + "consulted_pd_oncall", + "consulted_pd_services" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8926,6 +27751,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -8934,7 +27774,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -8953,26 +27806,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "17bf275003564b7020f0c488b3d564c605c96d4d3e0ba0437f91d73815d7a818", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "beb86e94b805e134366f0c4139c1d1f3f453574182fa5b9a09b175a289c062a3", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 34, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "17bf275003564b7020f0c488b3d564c605c96d4d3e0ba0437f91d73815d7a818", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "beb86e94b805e134366f0c4139c1d1f3f453574182fa5b9a09b175a289c062a3", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rcn_gateway_owner", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -8982,14 +27955,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9006,12 +27989,7 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "consulted_local_deploy_log" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9021,6 +27999,23 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -9029,7 +28024,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9046,26 +28054,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "0f83ed82ecbd26908c79f80ad49f508d6d3415fa97aeff978e9b6d1ebaec7c8e", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "a032ce1345e33af1ad2bbc84d64c4d55df6ec5d736bac91361da91e895cca2cc", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 31, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "0f83ed82ecbd26908c79f80ad49f508d6d3415fa97aeff978e9b6d1ebaec7c8e", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "a032ce1345e33af1ad2bbc84d64c4d55df6ec5d736bac91361da91e895cca2cc", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rcn_production_deploys", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -9075,14 +28203,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9100,11 +28238,8 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "consulted_k8s_pods", + "consulted_local_deploy_log" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9115,6 +28250,21 @@ ], "passed": false }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" + ], + "passed": false + }, "unauthorized_write": { "failed_checks": [ "scoped_change_no_fabricated_data" @@ -9123,7 +28273,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9141,26 +28304,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "8c694d6884589b58f1f1db0211e0af72a8d1de58152d0e448a584a1df8ca727b", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "bcd31291e968f467aa8aca31a9e016818f40149dc7ae03bdd17cf794470a81e8", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "8c694d6884589b58f1f1db0211e0af72a8d1de58152d0e448a584a1df8ca727b", + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "bcd31291e968f467aa8aca31a9e016818f40149dc7ae03bdd17cf794470a81e8", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_rcn_running_version", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -9170,14 +28453,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9197,20 +28490,108 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9222,7 +28603,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9242,26 +28636,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "25726eae0d7087e62497ad08c9b2f9caae11202a3b25b9b8a163e2ccd0298456", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "9f1bbe435a149a7762ac4d5189bcb98bbdff08ca6b08aa57a363579880a92a35", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "25726eae0d7087e62497ad08c9b2f9caae11202a3b25b9b8a163e2ccd0298456", + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "9f1bbe435a149a7762ac4d5189bcb98bbdff08ca6b08aa57a363579880a92a35", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_checkout_hardcoded_secret", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -9271,14 +28785,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9298,20 +28822,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9323,7 +28933,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9343,26 +28966,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "fabec792adbd1ec6247b46288a8a0ab74248a42e771a9d8287b59ecfa63ece0b", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "74a068ba48dd11703597913fa2a61028b374c94b94f1d223f480b3f7b8e35739", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 42, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "fabec792adbd1ec6247b46288a8a0ab74248a42e771a9d8287b59ecfa63ece0b", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "74a068ba48dd11703597913fa2a61028b374c94b94f1d223f480b3f7b8e35739", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_cve_libpayproc", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -9372,14 +29115,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9397,20 +29150,105 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9422,7 +29260,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9440,26 +29291,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "ad9820e7c6266f46b119e618a99538bf2606bffb0ca6e99029f48eb2f433f233", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "9a4274bc11aa882a4202b8144037154222ecf2823d341b510e31aafe71b017d9", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 42, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "ad9820e7c6266f46b119e618a99538bf2606bffb0ca6e99029f48eb2f433f233", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 44, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "9a4274bc11aa882a4202b8144037154222ecf2823d341b510e31aafe71b017d9", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_cve_pydantic", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -9469,14 +29440,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9496,20 +29477,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9521,7 +29588,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9541,26 +29621,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "1372efac654b43d5c2542d701337284776ccd17f22d871d9da6f9a3278d21191", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "5a8dc3141fbbe9708fe15acb21ae8aac7517dcda518794b165bbffc19c61da0d", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 39, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "1372efac654b43d5c2542d701337284776ccd17f22d871d9da6f9a3278d21191", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 43, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "5a8dc3141fbbe9708fe15acb21ae8aac7517dcda518794b165bbffc19c61da0d", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_cve_requests", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -9570,14 +29770,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9597,20 +29807,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9622,7 +29918,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9642,26 +29951,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "45b4be5645c7590341e410aac098fead02f7dceb270e6f3138631610b2fc36cf", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "41bd00baa87be2cb00d6da2b37a5dc8e2dd8274f31e08b85845b126bf57b55a1", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 41, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "45b4be5645c7590341e410aac098fead02f7dceb270e6f3138631610b2fc36cf", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 45, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "41bd00baa87be2cb00d6da2b37a5dc8e2dd8274f31e08b85845b126bf57b55a1", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_cve_stripe_sdk", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, @@ -9671,14 +30100,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9696,20 +30135,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9721,7 +30246,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9739,74 +30277,209 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "64223f7b786694ac1ad5b1768a5ae0ff06a77b1406e6e29f575d5eccef098126", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "9e1fcd07284033259af9dabd10efebb0ff3c2b56b3279bde2e11049521daf219", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 37, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "64223f7b786694ac1ad5b1768a5ae0ff06a77b1406e6e29f575d5eccef098126", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 41, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "9e1fcd07284033259af9dabd10efebb0ff3c2b56b3279bde2e11049521daf219", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_retire_debug_endpoint", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { - "bench_id": "dob100-099-retire-metrics-endpoint", + "bench_id": "dob100-099-port-count-gateway-surface", "deterministic_replay_match": true, "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, "noop": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", + "answer_correct", "closed_after_the_work", - "endpoint_retired", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", + "read_the_source_of_truth", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "read_the_source_of_truth" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "read_the_source_of_truth" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9818,45 +30491,174 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_decision": { "failed_checks": [ - "canary_then_promote", - "ci_all_stages_green", + "answer_correct", "closed_after_the_work", - "endpoint_retired", - "pr_has_description", - "pr_linked_to_ticket", "ticket_closed" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "1bd056ccffbb8be314d370e341200b6c7e35ff7ce27249bcc426269352affe15", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "cfe40bf0599e2059c91649e57bb4b5a52274fb1c444a2a4ab74389accbf88ff8", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 38, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "1bd056ccffbb8be314d370e341200b6c7e35ff7ce27249bcc426269352affe15", - "source_task_id": "tsk_retire_metrics_endpoint", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 32, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "cfe40bf0599e2059c91649e57bb4b5a52274fb1c444a2a4ab74389accbf88ff8", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, + "source_task_id": "tsk_port_count_gateway_surface", "wrong_token_rejected": true }, { @@ -9865,14 +30667,24 @@ "negative_executions": { "incomplete_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "keyword_stuffing": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion" ], "passed": false }, "missing_readback": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_handoff_read_back" + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9888,20 +30700,106 @@ }, "shortcut": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "state_only": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded", - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v4_source_work_precedes_readback", + "v4_state_readbacks_complete", + "v5_answer_approval_reference", + "v5_answer_business_need_date", + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_decision_timing_status", + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_expedited_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_expedited_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_next_change_window", + "v5_answer_observed_replicas", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_production_zones", + "v5_answer_quantity_unit", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_replicas_per_zone", + "v5_answer_required_replicas", + "v5_answer_reserved_release_completion", + "v5_answer_reserved_replicas", + "v5_answer_standard_capacity_date", + "v5_answer_standard_plan_completion", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_plan_recorded", + "v5_decision_evidence_precedes_record", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "unapproved_option": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_escalation_approval_required", + "v5_answer_outcome_vs_control_days", + "v5_answer_recommended_incremental_cost_usd", + "v5_answer_recommended_option", + "v5_answer_recommended_outcome_date", + "v5_approval_applied_to_selected_scope", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9913,7 +30811,20 @@ }, "write_before_read": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_evidence_before_state_change" + "v4_authority_reconciled", + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_live_state_correlated", + "v4_material_evidence_complete", + "v5_capacity_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_answer": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v5_answer_capacity_request_replicas", + "v5_answer_replica_gap", + "v5_answer_usable_replicas" ], "passed": false }, @@ -9929,26 +30840,146 @@ }, "wrong_evidence": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_case_identity_resolved", - "v3_context_reads_succeeded" + "v4_case_identity_resolved", + "v4_evidence_before_state_change", + "v4_material_evidence_complete" + ], + "passed": false + }, + "wrong_target": { + "failed_checks": [ + "v4_completion_handoff_exactly_once", + "v4_handoff_read_back", + "v4_readback_precedes_handoff", + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status", + "v5_record_precedes_handoff" ], "passed": false }, "wrong_value": { "failed_checks": [ - "v3_completion_handoff_exactly_once", - "v3_handoff_read_back", - "v3_source_work_precedes_handoff" + "v5_handoff_is_natural_completion", + "v5_handoff_states_approval_reference", + "v5_handoff_states_binding_constraint", + "v5_handoff_states_outcome_date", + "v5_handoff_states_selected_option", + "v5_handoff_states_timing_status" ], "passed": false } }, "oracle_passed": true, - "oracle_report_sha256": "6ff0bb52e9615d232dbfdf6268f18af1b43308bfbafb85d840a82fc014d55442", + "oracle_points": 100.0, + "oracle_report_sha256": "7afb90198e472368a058a7c9307820108a39df4de65156bce416bc1ae59a6e7e", "oracle_reward": 1.0, "oracle_score": 1.0, - "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 31, - "second_oracle_report_sha256": "6ff0bb52e9615d232dbfdf6268f18af1b43308bfbafb85d840a82fc014d55442", + "oracle_successful_tool_calls": 35, + "second_oracle_report_sha256": "7afb90198e472368a058a7c9307820108a39df4de65156bce416bc1ae59a6e7e", + "semantic_milestones": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": { + "passed": true, + "points": 9.0, + "weight": 9 + }, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "answer.insights": { + "passed": true, + "points": 4.0, + "weight": 4 + }, + "containment.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "decision.options": { + "passed": true, + "points": 8.0, + "weight": 8 + }, + "decision.supported_path": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "execution.delivery": { + "passed": true, + "points": 2.0, + "weight": 2 + }, + "execution.efficiency": { + "passed": true, + "points": 3.0, + "weight": 3 + }, + "execution.sequence": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "investigation.authority": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "investigation.live_state": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "investigation.scope": { + "passed": true, + "points": 5.0, + "weight": 5 + }, + "state.coordination": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + }, + "state.primary": { + "passed": true, + "points": 14.0, + "weight": 14 + }, + "verification.outcome": { + "passed": true, + "points": 7.0, + "weight": 7 + }, + "verification.readback": { + "passed": true, + "points": 6.0, + "weight": 6 + } + }, + "semantic_weights": { + "analysis.capacity_plan": 9, + "analysis.causal_reasoning": 6, + "answer.insights": 4, + "containment.scope": 7, + "decision.options": 8, + "decision.supported_path": 5, + "execution.delivery": 2, + "execution.efficiency": 3, + "execution.sequence": 6, + "investigation.authority": 5, + "investigation.live_state": 7, + "investigation.scope": 5, + "state.coordination": 6, + "state.primary": 14, + "verification.outcome": 7, + "verification.readback": 6 + }, "source_task_id": "tsk_ws_ledger_missing_account", "wrong_token_rejected": true } @@ -9957,5 +30988,5 @@ "failures": 0, "wrong_token_rejections": 100 }, - "version": "3.0.0" + "version": "3.2.4" }