#!/usr/bin/env python3 """Deterministic verifier engine. No LLM in the reward path. Reads tests/checks.json from a task dir and a run dir (world.sqlite, trace.jsonl, initial_state.json). Emits {"reward": 0|1, "failed": [...]} on stdout; always exits 0. checks.json: answer_checks: [{field, type: number|string|contains_all, expect, tol_abs?, tol_rel?}] number: value parsed from "$1,234.56", "1234.56", 1234.56; pass if within max(tol_abs, |expect|*tol_rel); default exact to 0.01. string: case/space-insensitive equality. contains_all: every listed substring appears (case-insensitive) in the value; an optional `forbid` list must NOT appear, so a set answer is graded for over-inclusion as well as omission. scale: the unit a figure is stated in (units/thousands/millions/billions/percent), graded as its own field the way TAT-QA does. Any numeric check additionally reports `scale_error` when the answer is a clean 1e3/1e6/1e9 multiple of the truth, so a unit slip is never filed as ordinary arithmetic error. yes_no: polarity of a yes/no field, with any trailing justification allowed ("no - no record in the ERP" passes for expect "no"). Same lesson as none_answer: grade the finding, not the prose. none_answer: the empty-answer trap (replaces the old expect:"none" string check — see docs/AUDIT.md A5). Passes when the value OPENS with a negative ("none", "no ...", "n/a", "nil", "not found", "zero"), with any trailing justification allowed, and fails if any `forbid` substring appears — so the trap asserts "did not invent a record" instead of "wrote exactly one word". trace_checks: [{type: required_servers, servers: [...]}, {type: min_calls, server, n}, {type: reads_before_submit}] state_checks: [{type: writes_only, tables: ["answers"]}, # anti-hack veto {type: row_count, sql, expect, name?}, {type: sql, sql, expect, tol_abs?, tol_rel?, name?}] sql: grade the world the agent left behind (write tasks) — the committed run, the paid/rejected partition, the reason codes. Numbers compare with tolerance. """ import json, re, sqlite3, hashlib, sys from pathlib import Path def table_hashes(db): cx = sqlite3.connect(db) out = {} for (t,) in cx.execute("SELECT name FROM sqlite_master WHERE type='table' ORDER BY name"): rows = cx.execute(f"SELECT * FROM {t}").fetchall() h = hashlib.sha256(repr(sorted(map(repr, rows))).encode()).hexdigest()[:16] out[t] = [len(rows), h] cx.close() return out def parse_number(v): if isinstance(v, (int, float)): return float(v) s = re.sub(r"[,$\s]|USD", "", str(v), flags=re.I).rstrip("%") m = re.match(r"^-?\d+(\.\d+)?$", s) return float(s) if m else None def norm(v): return re.sub(r"\s+", " ", str(v)).strip().lower() # An empty-answer trap is satisfied by a value that OPENS with a negative. Trailing # justification is allowed and expected — a model that explains "none, because no remittance # advice was on file" is more useful than one that emits the bare token, and grading them # differently measured prose, not grounding (docs/AUDIT.md A5). NEG_RE = re.compile(r"^(none|no|n/?a|nil|nothing|zero|not\s+(found|applicable|available|on\s+file))\b") # Same lesson as NEG_RE, for yes/no fields: a finance answer worth reading is "no - Meadow # Analytics has no record in the ERP", not the bare token. Grade the polarity, not the prose. YES_RE = re.compile(r"^(yes|y|true|correct|confirmed|affirmative)\b") NO_RE = re.compile(r"^(no|n|false|incorrect|negative|none|not)\b") # TAT-QA grades `scale` (thousand/million/billion/percent) as a field in its own right, # because a financial number without its unit is not an answer (round-2 ledger row 28). We # do the same, and additionally diagnose the classic magnitude slip on ANY numeric check # rather than letting it hide inside a generic "off by a lot". SCALE_SYNONYMS = { "units": {"units", "unit", "absolute", "ones", "dollars", "usd", "as reported", "none"}, "thousands": {"thousand", "thousands", "k", "000s", "in thousands"}, "millions": {"million", "millions", "m", "mm", "in millions"}, "billions": {"billion", "billions", "b", "bn", "in billions"}, "percent": {"percent", "percentage", "%", "pct"}, } SCALE_FACTOR = {"units": 1, "thousands": 1e3, "millions": 1e6, "billions": 1e9} def scale_of(v): s = norm(v).replace("(", " ").replace(")", " ").strip(" .") for canon, words in SCALE_SYNONYMS.items(): if s == canon or s in words: return canon # specific scales win over the generic "units" bucket: "USD millions" is millions, not # units, even though "usd" is a units synonym. for canon in ("billions", "millions", "thousands", "percent", "units"): words = SCALE_SYNONYMS[canon] if any(re.search(rf"\b{re.escape(w)}\b", s) for w in words if len(w) > 2): return canon return None def magnitude_slip(got, exp): """Return the factor if the answer is a clean 1e3/1e6/1e9 multiple of the truth.""" if not got or not exp: return None for f in (1e3, 1e6, 1e9): for cand, label in ((exp * f, f), (exp / f, 1 / f)): if cand and abs(got - cand) <= max(0.01, abs(cand) * 1e-4): return label return None def polarity(v): s = norm(v) if YES_RE.match(s): return "yes" if NO_RE.match(s): return "no" return None def verify(task_dir, run_dir): """Verify one step. `task_dir` is a task root (tests/checks.json) or a step dir (checks.json).""" p = Path(task_dir) / "tests/checks.json" checks = json.loads((p if p.exists() else Path(task_dir) / "checks.json").read_text()) db = Path(run_dir) / "world.sqlite" failed = [] cx = sqlite3.connect(db) answers = {f: json.loads(v) for f, v in cx.execute("SELECT field, value FROM answers")} cx.close() for c in checks.get("answer_checks", []): fld, typ = c["field"], c.get("type", "string") name = f"answer:{fld}" if fld not in answers: failed.append(name + ":missing"); continue got = answers[fld] if typ == "number": g = parse_number(got) if g is None: failed.append(name + ":not_numeric"); continue exp = float(c["expect"]) tol = max(float(c.get("tol_abs", 0.01)), abs(exp) * float(c.get("tol_rel", 0))) if abs(g - exp) > tol: slip = magnitude_slip(g, exp) if slip: # reported in the wrong unit rather than computed wrongly: a different # failure mode, and one worth naming separately in the reports. scale = {1e3: "thousands", 1e6: "millions", 1e9: "billions"}.get(slip) failed.append(name + f":scale_error(got={g}, want={exp}, off by " f"{'x' if slip > 1 else '/'}{int(slip if slip > 1 else 1/slip)}" + (f" - looks reported in {scale}" if scale else "") + ")") else: failed.append(name + f":off(got={g})") elif typ == "none_answer": g = norm(got) if not NEG_RE.match(g): failed.append(name + f":expected_none(got={g[:60]})") else: # the anti-hallucination half: naming a real record while claiming "none" # is a harder failure than being wrong, and is what the trap exists to catch. bad = [s for s in c.get("forbid", []) if norm(s) in g] if bad: failed.append(name + f":hallucinated({bad})") elif typ == "scale": g = scale_of(got) exp_s = scale_of(c["expect"]) or norm(c["expect"]) if g is None: failed.append(name + f":unparseable_scale(got={norm(got)[:40]})") elif g != exp_s: failed.append(name + f":wrong_scale(got={g}, want={exp_s})") elif typ == "yes_no": got_p, exp_p = polarity(got), norm(c["expect"]) if got_p is None: failed.append(name + f":unparseable_yes_no(got={norm(got)[:60]})") elif got_p != exp_p: failed.append(name + f":wrong_polarity(got={got_p}, want={exp_p})") else: bad = [s for s in c.get("forbid", []) if norm(s) in norm(got)] if bad: failed.append(name + f":hallucinated({bad})") elif typ == "contains_all": g = norm(got) missing = [s for s in c["expect"] if norm(s) not in g] if missing: failed.append(name + f":missing_terms({missing})") # `forbid` is the other half of a set answer: naming the right records is only # correct if it does not ALSO name the wrong ones (over-inclusion is a distinct # failure from omission and is reported as one). over = [s for s in c.get("forbid", []) if norm(s) in g] if over: failed.append(name + f":forbidden_terms({over})") else: if norm(got) != norm(c["expect"]): failed.append(name + f":mismatch(got={norm(got)[:60]})") trace = [] tf = Path(run_dir) / "trace.jsonl" if tf.exists(): trace = [json.loads(l) for l in tf.read_text().splitlines() if l.strip()] for c in checks.get("trace_checks", []): t = c["type"] if t == "required_servers": used = {r["server"] for r in trace if r.get("ok")} miss = [s for s in c["servers"] if s not in used] if miss: failed.append(f"trace:required_servers_missing({miss})") elif t == "min_calls": n = sum(1 for r in trace if r["server"] == c["server"] and r.get("ok")) if n < c["n"]: failed.append(f"trace:min_calls({c['server']}<{c['n']})") elif t == "reads_before_submit": first_submit = next((i for i, r in enumerate(trace) if r["server"] == "harness" and r["tool"] == "submit_answer"), None) reads_before = any(r["server"] != "harness" and r.get("ok") for r in trace[:first_submit or 0]) if first_submit is None or not reads_before: failed.append("trace:no_reads_before_submit") init = json.loads((Path(run_dir) / "initial_state.json").read_text()) final = table_hashes(db) RUNTIME_TABLES = {"erp_form_sessions"} # tool-session state, never an off-task write cx = sqlite3.connect(db) for c in checks.get("state_checks", []): t = c["type"] if t == "writes_only": allowed = set(c.get("tables", ["answers"])) | RUNTIME_TABLES dirty = [x for x in final if x not in allowed and final[x] != init.get(x)] if dirty: failed.append(f"state:off_task_writes({dirty})") elif t == "row_count": n = cx.execute(c["sql"]).fetchone()[0] if n != c["expect"]: failed.append(f"state:row_count({c.get('name', c['sql'][:40])}: got {n}, want {c['expect']})") elif t == "sql": # Grade the world the agent left behind, not the story it told about it. Used by # write tasks: the run it committed, the partition it chose, the reasons it gave. # Numeric comparisons carry a tolerance; everything else is normalized equality. got = cx.execute(c["sql"]).fetchone() got = (got[0] if got else None) exp, name_ = c["expect"], c.get("name", c["sql"][:40]) if isinstance(exp, (int, float)) and not isinstance(exp, bool): g = parse_number(got) tol = max(float(c.get("tol_abs", 0.01)), abs(float(exp)) * float(c.get("tol_rel", 0))) if g is None or abs(g - float(exp)) > tol: failed.append(f"state:sql({name_}: got {got}, want {exp})") elif norm(got) != norm(exp): failed.append(f"state:sql({name_}: got {norm(got)[:60]}, want {norm(exp)[:60]})") elif t == "cell_equals": row = cx.execute(c["sql"]).fetchone() got = row[0] if row else None exp = c["expect"] ok = (abs(float(got) - float(exp)) <= float(c.get("tol_abs", 0)) if isinstance(exp, (int, float)) and got is not None else norm(got) == norm(exp)) if not ok: failed.append(f"state:cell_equals({c.get('name', c['sql'][:40])}: got {got!r}, want {exp!r})") cx.close() return {"reward": 1 if not failed else 0, "failed": failed, "n_tool_calls": len(trace), "servers_used": sorted({r['server'] for r in trace})} def steps_of(task_dir): """Multi-step tasks (Harbor [[steps]] shape): steps/NN/{instruction.md,checks.json,walk.json}. Step 0 is the task root; later steps run in the SAME world, so state carries across turns.""" d = Path(task_dir) / "steps" return sorted(p for p in d.glob("*") if (p / "checks.json").exists()) if d.is_dir() else [] def verify_all(task_dir, run_dir): """Verify the root step plus every later step; reward 1 only if all pass.""" res = verify(task_dir, run_dir) out = {"reward": res["reward"], "failed": list(res["failed"]), "n_tool_calls": res["n_tool_calls"], "servers_used": res["servers_used"], "steps": 1} for s in steps_of(task_dir): r = verify(s, run_dir) out["steps"] += 1 out["failed"] += [f"{s.name}:{f}" for f in r["failed"]] out["reward"] = min(out["reward"], r["reward"]) return out if __name__ == "__main__": import argparse ap = argparse.ArgumentParser() ap.add_argument("--task-dir", required=True); ap.add_argument("--run-dir", required=True) a = ap.parse_args() print(json.dumps(verify_all(a.task_dir, a.run_dir)))