{ "phase": "Cross-Source Agreement Study", "timestamp": "2026-07-21 21:08:07", "total_entries": 266732, "total_formulas": 148141, "multi_source_formulas": 11915, "pair_reports": { "mp_oqmd": { "source_a": "mp", "source_b": "oqmd", "n_overlapping_formulas": 225, "n_entries_a": 450, "n_entries_b": 2, "property_agreement": { "formation_energy_per_atom": { "n": 225, "mae": 0.2138, "rmse": 0.3046, "max": 1.1547, "p95": 0.7096, "median": 0.1401, "bias_mean": 0.2138 }, "energy_above_hull": { "n": 225, "mae": 0.2072, "rmse": 0.2996, "max": 1.0614, "p95": 0.7343, "median": 0.16, "bias_mean": 0.2072 }, "band_gap": { "n": 225, "mae": 0.1525, "rmse": 0.3912, "max": 2.0309, "p95": 0.8965, "median": 0.0, "bias_mean": 0.1525 }, "volume": { "n": 90, "mae": 49.8792, "rmse": 56.0977, "max": 90.7166, "p95": 79.2355, "median": 59.776 }, "density": { "n": 90, "mae": 9.354, "rmse": 10.5563, "max": 19.4356, "p95": 17.1369, "median": 10.6448 }, "nsites": { "n": 225, "mae": 38.4111, "rmse": 52.5045, "max": 95.8333, "p95": 89.5, "median": 50.0 } }, "space_group_agreement": { "agree": 0, "disagree": 0, "missing_a": 0, "missing_b": 225 }, "sg_agreement_pct": 0.0, "detailed_samples": [ { "formula": "Zn", "n_a": 8, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0052, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0243, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0191, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0052, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0243, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0191, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 1, "nsites_b": 1, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MnZn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.11, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0663, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0437, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1882, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0823, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1058, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "TiZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1929, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0771, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1159, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1385, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1385, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "ScZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3816, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3793, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0023, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgNiSb", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 4, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4605, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4237, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0368, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgTaZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.6688, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 1.146, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4772, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.7396, "energy_above_hull_b": 1.2204, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.4808, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 58.22, "volume_b": 59.36, "volume_diff_pct": 1.92, "density_a": 7.72, "density_b": 7.57, "density_diff_pct": 1.92, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgScTl", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.2551, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.2443, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0107, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.3828, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.4588, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.076, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 82.67, "volume_b": 79.97, "volume_diff_pct": 3.26, "density_a": 5.5, "density_b": 5.68, "density_diff_pct": 3.26, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgO", "n_a": 22, "n_b": 4, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.9062, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.9459, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0397, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1321, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0003, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1317, "band_gap_a": 3.4114, "band_gap_b": 4.975, "band_gap_diff": 1.5636, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 83.33 }, { "formula": "MgS", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.637, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.5796, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0574, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.025, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0001, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0249, "band_gap_a": 4.1133, "band_gap_b": 2.95, "band_gap_diff": 1.1633, "nsites_a": 4, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgSe", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 4, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.4743, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.014, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4603, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2538, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2538, "band_gap_a": 2.5791, "band_gap_b": 0.55, "band_gap_diff": 2.0291, "nsites_a": 4, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgPb", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0027, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0129, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0102, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0246, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0383, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0138, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 4, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgRh", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4498, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.476, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0263, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0004, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0004, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgPt", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6965, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5937, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1028, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2856, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2856, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "MgPd", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.7268, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7445, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0177, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0021, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0021, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgOs", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.1751, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.2645, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0894, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2792, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2645, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0146, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 4, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgP", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 4, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3858, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4705, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0847, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1745, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.24, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0655, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "MgTe", "n_a": 4, "n_b": 4, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.003, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.8796, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1234, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0686, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.001, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0676, "band_gap_a": 0.4271, "band_gap_b": 2.458, "band_gap_diff": 2.0309, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgSb", "n_a": 13, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2153, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0811, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1342, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1415, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2344, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0929, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgSn", "n_a": 15, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0561, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.111, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0549, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0692, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0664, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0029, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "MgNi", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1235, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0255, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1489, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0583, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2366, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1783, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "MgSi", "n_a": 47, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0943, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.1285, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0342, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1758, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2498, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.074, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 24, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 91.67 }, { "formula": "MgZn", "n_a": 17, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0392, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0082, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.031, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.067, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1035, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0365, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "MgTl", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.017, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0342, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0172, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.003, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.003, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgMn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.3224, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.3574, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.035, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.3224, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.3574, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.035, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 4, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgTi", "n_a": 26, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.2451, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.178, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0671, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2451, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1798, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0653, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "MgTa", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.3488, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.3372, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0117, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.3488, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.3372, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0117, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 4, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgSc", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0264, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0425, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0161, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0007, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0007, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 4, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgZr", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0717, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0556, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0161, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0717, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0853, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0136, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "Mg", "n_a": 8, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.1656, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0288, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1368, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1656, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0288, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1368, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 10, "nsites_b": 1, "nsites_diff_pct": 90.0 }, { "formula": "HfZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2322, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1968, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0354, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0082, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0082, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "HfMg", "n_a": 8, "n_b": 4, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.1467, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.1289, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0177, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1467, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1289, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0177, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "LuMgTl", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2442, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1183, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1259, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.144, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.144, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.387, "band_gap_diff": 0.387, "volume_a": 216.16, "volume_b": 83.06, "volume_diff_pct": 61.57, "density_a": 9.3, "density_b": 8.07, "density_diff_pct": 13.25, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "LuZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4084, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3552, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0532, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0005, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0005, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "LuMg", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0306, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0441, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0136, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "TmZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4047, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2763, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1284, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0769, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0769, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "ErTlZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2793, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0873, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.192, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0302, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2285, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1983, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.387, "band_gap_diff": 0.387, "volume_a": 137.49, "volume_b": 77.56, "volume_diff_pct": 43.59, "density_a": 10.56, "density_b": 9.36, "density_diff_pct": 11.36, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "ErMgPd", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6883, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.082, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.7703, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.7836, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.7836, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 189.19, "volume_b": 76.04, "volume_diff_pct": 59.81, "density_a": 7.85, "density_b": 6.51, "density_diff_pct": 17.07, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "ErMgSn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5315, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1253, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4062, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.4541, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.4541, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 149.34, "volume_b": 80.21, "volume_diff_pct": 46.29, "density_a": 6.9, "density_b": 6.42, "density_diff_pct": 6.91, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "ErMgTl", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2831, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1562, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1269, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.15, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.15, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.383, "band_gap_diff": 0.383, "volume_a": 221.32, "volume_b": 84.53, "volume_diff_pct": 61.81, "density_a": 8.91, "density_b": 7.78, "density_diff_pct": 12.72, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "ErZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3934, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3517, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0416, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0001, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0001, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "ErMg", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0519, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0666, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0147, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "HoMgPd", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6805, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.087, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.7676, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.787, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.787, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 191.29, "volume_b": 76.76, "volume_diff_pct": 59.87, "density_a": 7.7, "density_b": 6.4, "density_diff_pct": 16.93, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "HoMgSn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5402, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1456, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3946, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.4473, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.4473, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 150.6, "volume_b": 81.05, "volume_diff_pct": 46.18, "density_a": 6.79, "density_b": 6.31, "density_diff_pct": 7.1, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "HoMgTl", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2938, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1669, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1268, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1512, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1512, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.5, "band_gap_diff": 0.5, "volume_a": 223.56, "volume_b": 85.21, "volume_diff_pct": 61.89, "density_a": 8.77, "density_b": 7.67, "density_diff_pct": 12.54, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "HoZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3429, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3479, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.005, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0001, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0001, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "HoMg", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0509, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0731, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0222, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0001, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0001, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "YZn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1085, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2903, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1817, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2786, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0731, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2056, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "DyTlZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3733, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1083, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.265, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0235, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2236, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2001, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.372, "band_gap_diff": 0.372, "volume_a": 140.17, "volume_b": 78.83, "volume_diff_pct": 43.77, "density_a": 10.24, "density_b": 9.11, "density_diff_pct": 11.09, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "DyMgPd", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6794, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0923, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.7717, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.7887, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.7887, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 192.86, "volume_b": 77.64, "volume_diff_pct": 59.74, "density_a": 7.57, "density_b": 6.27, "density_diff_pct": 17.2, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "DyMgSn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5543, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1661, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3883, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.4394, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.4394, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 152.05, "volume_b": 80.57, "volume_diff_pct": 47.01, "density_a": 6.67, "density_b": 6.3, "density_diff_pct": 5.64, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "DyMgTl", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3057, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1767, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1291, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1519, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1519, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.367, "band_gap_diff": 0.367, "volume_a": 225.52, "volume_b": 85.66, "volume_diff_pct": 62.02, "density_a": 8.64, "density_b": 7.58, "density_diff_pct": 12.24, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "DyZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3895, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1206, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.269, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2236, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2236, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "DyMg", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0589, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0794, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0205, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "GdTlZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3835, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1254, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2581, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2124, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2124, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.428, "band_gap_diff": 0.428, "volume_a": 139.45, "volume_b": 80.4, "volume_diff_pct": 42.35, "density_a": 10.17, "density_b": 8.82, "density_diff_pct": 13.28, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "GdMgPt", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.9315, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.819, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1125, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1339, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1339, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 193.82, "volume_b": 73.24, "volume_diff_pct": 62.21, "density_a": 9.68, "density_b": 8.54, "density_diff_pct": 11.79, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "GdMgPd", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6739, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0028, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.6712, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.6858, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.6858, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 197.99, "volume_b": 72.39, "volume_diff_pct": 63.44, "density_a": 7.25, "density_b": 6.61, "density_diff_pct": 8.83, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "GdMgTl", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.328, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1946, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1335, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1513, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1513, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.215, "band_gap_diff": 0.215, "volume_a": 231.95, "volume_b": 87.2, "volume_diff_pct": 62.4, "density_a": 8.29, "density_b": 7.35, "density_diff_pct": 11.34, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "GdZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.345, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3374, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0075, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.001, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.001, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "GdMg", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0788, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0927, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0139, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "EuMgPb", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4338, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2937, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1401, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.24, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.24, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 362.22, "volume_b": 92.61, "volume_diff_pct": 74.43, "density_a": 7.03, "density_b": 6.88, "density_diff_pct": 2.22, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "EuMgPd", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5998, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1302, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4696, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.5627, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.5627, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 281.9, "volume_b": 78.66, "volume_diff_pct": 72.1, "density_a": 6.66, "density_b": 5.97, "density_diff_pct": 10.4, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "EuMgSn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.561, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4215, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1395, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2552, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2552, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 338.12, "volume_b": 88.67, "volume_diff_pct": 73.78, "density_a": 5.79, "density_b": 5.52, "density_diff_pct": 4.67, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "EuMgNi", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0186, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.3816, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4002, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1082, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.6343, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.5262, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 314.92, "volume_b": 75.85, "volume_diff_pct": 75.92, "density_a": 4.96, "density_b": 5.14, "density_diff_pct": 3.66, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "EuMgSi", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4148, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3718, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.043, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1164, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1164, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.902, "band_gap_diff": 0.902, "volume_a": 286.45, "volume_b": 80.96, "volume_diff_pct": 71.74, "density_a": 4.74, "density_b": 4.19, "density_diff_pct": 11.54, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "EuMgTl", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2825, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1867, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0958, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1881, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1881, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 344.0, "volume_b": 97.93, "volume_diff_pct": 71.53, "density_a": 7.35, "density_b": 6.45, "density_diff_pct": 12.18, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "EuZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2577, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3764, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1187, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0018, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0018, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "EuMg", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0483, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0991, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0508, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0161, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0002, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0159, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "SmTlZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3332, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1342, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.199, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0202, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2115, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1913, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.37, "band_gap_diff": 0.37, "volume_a": 143.52, "volume_b": 82.52, "volume_diff_pct": 42.5, "density_a": 9.72, "density_b": 8.45, "density_diff_pct": 13.04, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "SmZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3297, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0867, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.243, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2408, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2408, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "NdTlZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3371, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1398, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1972, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0238, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2114, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1876, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.345, "band_gap_diff": 0.345, "volume_a": 148.13, "volume_b": 84.86, "volume_diff_pct": 42.72, "density_a": 9.28, "density_b": 8.1, "density_diff_pct": 12.71, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "NdZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3147, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3182, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0035, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0002, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0002, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "PrZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.299, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3111, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0121, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CeTlZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2323, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1376, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0947, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.034, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.213, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.179, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.308, "band_gap_diff": 0.308, "volume_a": 150.8, "volume_b": 88.63, "volume_diff_pct": 41.22, "density_a": 9.03, "density_b": 7.68, "density_diff_pct": 14.93, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "CeMgRh", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5421, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3791, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.163, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1187, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1187, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 195.58, "volume_b": 77.1, "volume_diff_pct": 60.58, "density_a": 6.81, "density_b": 5.76, "density_diff_pct": 15.44, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CeMgPt", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.8297, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7096, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1201, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1605, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1605, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 204.2, "volume_b": 80.44, "volume_diff_pct": 60.61, "density_a": 8.77, "density_b": 7.42, "density_diff_pct": 15.38, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CeMgPd", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5532, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4641, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.089, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1728, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1728, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 209.18, "volume_b": 81.29, "volume_diff_pct": 61.14, "density_a": 6.45, "density_b": 5.53, "density_diff_pct": 14.22, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CeMgSn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.451, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3019, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1491, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.3217, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.3217, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 331.06, "volume_b": 87.43, "volume_diff_pct": 73.59, "density_a": 5.68, "density_b": 5.38, "density_diff_pct": 5.34, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CeMgTl", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1982, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2208, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0225, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1418, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1418, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 250.29, "volume_b": 94.54, "volume_diff_pct": 62.23, "density_a": 7.34, "density_b": 6.48, "density_diff_pct": 11.75, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CeZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1916, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0749, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1167, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0293, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2237, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1943, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CeMg", "n_a": 15, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0125, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1228, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1353, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0489, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0001, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0488, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "YbZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0692, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3375, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2684, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2669, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0007, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2662, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "TbZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3852, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0967, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4819, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2273, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2273, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "LaTlZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.36, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1733, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1868, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0282, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1996, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1714, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 159.89, "volume_b": 89.63, "volume_diff_pct": 43.94, "density_a": 8.49, "density_b": 7.57, "density_diff_pct": 10.81, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "LaMgRh", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6119, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.3055, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.9174, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.9317, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.9317, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 540.15, "volume_b": 82.1, "volume_diff_pct": 84.8, "density_a": 6.54, "density_b": 5.38, "density_diff_pct": 17.76, "nsites_a": 24, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 87.5 }, { "formula": "LaMgPd", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6557, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.1353, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.791, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.8058, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.8058, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 216.09, "volume_b": 88.02, "volume_diff_pct": 59.27, "density_a": 6.22, "density_b": 5.09, "density_diff_pct": 18.17, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "LaMgTl", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0873, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2447, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1575, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2745, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1347, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1398, "band_gap_a": 0.053, "band_gap_b": 0.258, "band_gap_diff": 0.205, "volume_a": 92.35, "volume_b": 95.31, "volume_diff_pct": 3.11, "density_a": 6.61, "density_b": 6.4, "density_diff_pct": 3.11, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "LaZn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3253, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0714, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2539, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2445, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2445, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "LaMg", "n_a": 7, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0683, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1153, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.047, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0325, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0001, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0324, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CaGaGeH", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4696, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4354, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0342, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0, "band_gap_a": 0.4903, "band_gap_b": 0.652, "band_gap_diff": 0.1617, "nsites_a": 4, "nsites_b": 4, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaGePt", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.9069, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.6005, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3064, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.3223, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.3223, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 235.61, "volume_b": 67.95, "volume_diff_pct": 71.16, "density_a": 8.68, "density_b": 7.52, "density_diff_pct": 13.31, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaHgPb", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3502, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0847, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2655, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0763, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.3404, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2641, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 173.74, "volume_b": 96.71, "volume_diff_pct": 44.34, "density_a": 8.56, "density_b": 7.69, "density_diff_pct": 10.18, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "CaNiTe", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5062, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7618, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2556, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.7333, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.3453, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.3881, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.442, "band_gap_diff": 0.442, "volume_a": 74.91, "volume_b": 65.51, "volume_diff_pct": 12.55, "density_a": 5.02, "density_b": 5.74, "density_diff_pct": 12.55, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaCuSb", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.7318, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.6292, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1026, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.0595, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.0595, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 140.3, "volume_b": 69.69, "volume_diff_pct": 50.33, "density_a": 5.34, "density_b": 5.37, "density_diff_pct": 0.66, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "CaCuGe", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5105, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.238, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2725, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2452, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2452, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 684.76, "volume_b": 63.57, "volume_diff_pct": 90.72, "density_a": 5.13, "density_b": 4.6, "density_diff_pct": 10.23, "nsites_a": 36, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 91.67 }, { "formula": "CaCuSn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4436, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3771, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0665, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.1201, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.1201, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 399.08, "volume_b": 72.03, "volume_diff_pct": 81.95, "density_a": 5.55, "density_b": 5.13, "density_diff_pct": 7.65, "nsites_a": 18, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 83.33 }, { "formula": "CaCuSi", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4158, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0426, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4584, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0072, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.4435, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.4363, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 60.04, "volume_b": 64.53, "volume_diff_pct": 6.95, "density_a": 3.64, "density_b": 3.39, "density_diff_pct": 6.95, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaCoSi", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4758, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.2295, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.7054, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.009, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.7578, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.7489, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 114.1, "volume_b": 60.41, "volume_diff_pct": 47.06, "density_a": 3.7, "density_b": 3.49, "density_diff_pct": 5.55, "nsites_a": 6, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "CaGaPt", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.9194, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.6711, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2483, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2571, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2571, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 238.47, "volume_b": 68.92, "volume_diff_pct": 71.1, "density_a": 8.49, "density_b": 7.35, "density_diff_pct": 13.49, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaGaGe", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6136, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2824, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3311, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.2528, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.2528, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 266.24, "volume_b": 74.73, "volume_diff_pct": 71.93, "density_a": 4.55, "density_b": 4.05, "density_diff_pct": 10.93, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaGaSn", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4998, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0664, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4333, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0034, "energy_above_hull_b": 0.4801, "energy_above_hull_diff": 0.4767, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "volume_a": 308.29, "volume_b": 88.99, "volume_diff_pct": 71.13, "density_a": 4.92, "density_b": 4.26, "density_diff_pct": 13.39, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 } ] }, "mp_jarvis": { "source_a": "mp", "source_b": "jarvis", "n_overlapping_formulas": 11741, "n_entries_a": 23482, "n_entries_b": 2, "property_agreement": { "formation_energy_per_atom": { "n": 11741, "mae": 0.2038, "rmse": 0.4508, "max": 6.8935, "p95": 0.6357, "median": 0.1021, "bias_mean": 0.2038 }, "energy_above_hull": { "n": 0 }, "band_gap": { "n": 11741, "mae": 0.2895, "rmse": 0.6929, "max": 7.4418, "p95": 1.6334, "median": 0.0235, "bias_mean": 0.2895 }, "volume": { "n": 0 }, "density": { "n": 11741, "mae": 7.4704, "rmse": 20.1105, "max": 98.2533, "p95": 27.7117, "median": 2.3959 }, "nsites": { "n": 11741, "mae": 7.9968, "rmse": 21.6155, "max": 95.8333, "p95": 50.0, "median": 0.0 } }, "space_group_agreement": { "agree": 9226, "disagree": 2515, "missing_a": 0, "missing_b": 0 }, "sg_agreement_pct": 78.6, "detailed_samples": [ { "formula": "ZnFe8Co3O16", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.6146, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.2938, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3209, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.008657977946420203, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.5578, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 1.5578, "density_a": 5.02, "density_b": 5.91, "density_diff_pct": 15.01, "nsites_a": 28, "nsites_b": 28, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnTe6O13", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.5146, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.17, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3446, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.01754400474999951, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.9724, "band_gap_b": 3.104, "band_gap_diff": 0.1316, "density_a": 6.07, "density_b": 6.0, "density_diff_pct": 1.03, "nsites_a": 40, "nsites_b": 40, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnNi9O10", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.2281, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7697, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4584, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.04725472625000027, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.0625, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 2.0625, "density_a": 6.56, "density_b": 6.82, "density_diff_pct": 3.77, "nsites_a": 20, "nsites_b": 20, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCu4Sn2HgS8", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.616, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4086, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2074, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.007031118125000013, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0128, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0128, "density_a": 4.96, "density_b": 4.99, "density_diff_pct": 0.51, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCr2F12", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.368, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.3272, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0408, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.004550119999999325, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.486, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.486, "density_a": 3.61, "density_b": 3.59, "density_diff_pct": 0.73, "nsites_a": 15, "nsites_b": 15, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "Zn2Cu10Sb4S13", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4834, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3249, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1585, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.04191724137930919, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.5191, "band_gap_b": 0.466, "band_gap_diff": 0.0531, "density_a": 4.88, "density_b": 4.87, "density_diff_pct": 0.14, "nsites_a": 29, "nsites_b": 29, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnAs2Pb2O9", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.563, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.2305, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3324, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.08946258351190384, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.39, "density_b": 6.66, "density_diff_pct": 3.99, "nsites_a": 28, "nsites_b": 28, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnBP2PbO9", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.3402, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.0095, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3307, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.08119351089923565, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.3284, "band_gap_b": 0.217, "band_gap_diff": 0.1114, "density_a": 4.67, "density_b": 4.76, "density_diff_pct": 1.79, "nsites_a": 28, "nsites_b": 28, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnFe4CoO8", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.6569, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.3407, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3162, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0069900433928644645, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.5246, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 1.5246, "density_a": 5.07, "density_b": 5.91, "density_diff_pct": 14.2, "nsites_a": 14, "nsites_b": 14, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCr4NiO8", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.0677, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.8973, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1703, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.09234079107141646, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.04, "density_b": 5.26, "density_diff_pct": 4.17, "nsites_a": 14, "nsites_b": 14, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCr4CuSe8", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.804, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5246, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2795, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.00486016249999377, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.54, "density_b": 5.6, "density_diff_pct": 1.0, "nsites_a": 14, "nsites_b": 14, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCr4CoO8", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.2022, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.9259, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2763, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0026488753571349832, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.7997, "band_gap_b": 0.443, "band_gap_diff": 2.3567, "density_a": 5.01, "density_b": 5.25, "density_diff_pct": 4.51, "nsites_a": 28, "nsites_b": 28, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCr4CdSe8", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.8403, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5535, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2867, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.005945833214269669, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.5298, "band_gap_b": 0.247, "band_gap_diff": 0.2828, "density_a": 5.43, "density_b": 5.52, "density_diff_pct": 1.6, "nsites_a": 14, "nsites_b": 14, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnNiTe3O8", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.5296, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.1385, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3911, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.64, "band_gap_b": 0.949, "band_gap_diff": 1.691, "density_a": 5.68, "density_b": 5.63, "density_diff_pct": 0.92, "nsites_a": 26, "nsites_b": 26, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCoTe3O8", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.5437, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.1535, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3902, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.932, "band_gap_b": 0.177, "band_gap_diff": 2.755, "density_a": 5.28, "density_b": 5.56, "density_diff_pct": 5.14, "nsites_a": 52, "nsites_b": 26, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "Zn2Si3Pb4SO15", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.3207, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.0205, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3002, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 3.4961, "band_gap_b": 3.626, "band_gap_diff": 0.1299, "density_a": 5.85, "density_b": 6.05, "density_diff_pct": 3.23, "nsites_a": 50, "nsites_b": 50, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnB4O7", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.6875, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.3981, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2895, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 4.6601, "band_gap_b": 5.719, "band_gap_diff": 1.0589, "density_a": 3.03, "density_b": 3.97, "density_diff_pct": 23.58, "nsites_a": 96, "nsites_b": 24, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnBi2B2O7", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.2079, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.9549, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.253, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.5198, "band_gap_b": 2.689, "band_gap_diff": 0.1692, "density_a": 7.04, "density_b": 6.92, "density_diff_pct": 1.8, "nsites_a": 48, "nsites_b": 48, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnNi9Ge2", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2013, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1893, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0119, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.03458910250000091, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 9.02, "density_b": 8.97, "density_diff_pct": 0.52, "nsites_a": 12, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnP2PbO7", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.435, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.0921, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3429, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 4.2572, "band_gap_b": 4.511, "band_gap_diff": 0.2538, "density_a": 4.98, "density_b": 5.15, "density_diff_pct": 3.26, "nsites_a": 44, "nsites_b": 44, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnSnP2O7", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.3444, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.0265, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3179, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.05655544732955953, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.8288, "band_gap_b": 3.442, "band_gap_diff": 0.6132, "density_a": 4.07, "density_b": 4.0, "density_diff_pct": 1.77, "nsites_a": 22, "nsites_b": 22, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnSn3O7", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.812, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.5063, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3057, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.23791990500000004, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.5793, "band_gap_b": 0.657, "band_gap_diff": 0.0777, "density_a": 6.27, "density_b": 6.42, "density_diff_pct": 2.34, "nsites_a": 44, "nsites_b": 44, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnNiP2O7", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.31, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.9018, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4083, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.020653729715918168, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 3.5472, "band_gap_b": 1.16, "band_gap_diff": 2.3872, "density_a": 3.97, "density_b": 4.1, "density_diff_pct": 3.25, "nsites_a": 44, "nsites_b": 44, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnCuP2O7", "n_a": 4, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.2062, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.8732, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.333, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.024548005511364934, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.1967, "band_gap_b": 0.296, "band_gap_diff": 0.0993, "density_a": 4.03, "density_b": 4.14, "density_diff_pct": 2.72, "nsites_a": 22, "nsites_b": 11, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnCoP2O7", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.3153, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.8995, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4158, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.027404846704557784, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.4361, "band_gap_b": 0.014, "band_gap_diff": 2.4221, "density_a": 3.79, "density_b": 4.16, "density_diff_pct": 8.91, "nsites_a": 44, "nsites_b": 22, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCd3GeS6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.806, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.6073, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1987, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.04000838948863539, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.8416, "band_gap_b": 1.222, "band_gap_diff": 0.6196, "density_a": 4.29, "density_b": 4.38, "density_diff_pct": 2.12, "nsites_a": 22, "nsites_b": 22, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCr4O6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.9425, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.6703, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2722, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.22375034151515294, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.26, "density_b": 5.57, "density_diff_pct": 5.57, "nsites_a": 22, "nsites_b": 22, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnGe2WO6", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.8328, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.7422, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0906, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1324304190000003, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.8992, "band_gap_b": 1.942, "band_gap_diff": 0.0428, "density_a": 5.47, "density_b": 5.7, "density_diff_pct": 4.08, "nsites_a": 40, "nsites_b": 20, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnHg4Te5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4043, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0466, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3577, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.033688240000000924, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 7.01, "density_b": 7.13, "density_diff_pct": 1.7, "nsites_a": 10, "nsites_b": 10, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnNi4O5", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.2751, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7969, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4782, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.057576226999998426, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.6, "density_b": 6.81, "density_diff_pct": 3.08, "nsites_a": 10, "nsites_b": 10, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnSi2SnO6", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.5535, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.2844, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2691, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.10168652162499647, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 3.0589, "band_gap_b": 3.553, "band_gap_diff": 0.4941, "density_a": 4.5, "density_b": 4.11, "density_diff_pct": 8.83, "nsites_a": 80, "nsites_b": 20, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnSi2NiO6", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.5219, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.1873, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3345, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.056423484541669566, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 3.4739, "band_gap_b": 1.25, "band_gap_diff": 2.2239, "density_a": 4.12, "density_b": 4.18, "density_diff_pct": 1.38, "nsites_a": 80, "nsites_b": 20, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnIn2Cu2S5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.768, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.6083, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1597, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0268942550000002, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.1348, "band_gap_b": 0.033, "band_gap_diff": 0.1018, "density_a": 4.5, "density_b": 4.52, "density_diff_pct": 0.5, "nsites_a": 10, "nsites_b": 10, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "Zn3Fe8CoO16", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.6993, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.42, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2794, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.005111975267857005, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.6058, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 1.6058, "density_a": 5.08, "density_b": 5.87, "density_diff_pct": 13.42, "nsites_a": 28, "nsites_b": 28, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "Zn3Cr8FeS16", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.9956, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7583, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2373, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.02160183285714634, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 3.9, "density_b": 4.0, "density_diff_pct": 2.47, "nsites_a": 28, "nsites_b": 28, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnPb2F6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.6339, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.4878, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1461, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.01995090472222305, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 3.9228, "band_gap_b": 4.042, "band_gap_diff": 0.1192, "density_a": 7.78, "density_b": 7.55, "density_diff_pct": 2.84, "nsites_a": 36, "nsites_b": 36, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnH2SO5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.6927, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.3502, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3425, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 4.2716, "band_gap_b": 4.731, "band_gap_diff": 0.4594, "density_a": 3.22, "density_b": 3.34, "density_diff_pct": 3.45, "nsites_a": 18, "nsites_b": 18, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnH2SeO5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.3503, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.9944, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3559, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.7214, "band_gap_b": 2.922, "band_gap_diff": 0.2006, "density_a": 3.7, "density_b": 3.85, "density_diff_pct": 3.85, "nsites_a": 18, "nsites_b": 18, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnTeMoO6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.7652, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.6925, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0727, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.013359836111116685, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 3.0952, "band_gap_b": 2.985, "band_gap_diff": 0.1102, "density_a": 5.09, "density_b": 5.33, "density_diff_pct": 4.49, "nsites_a": 18, "nsites_b": 18, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnHg3Se3Br2", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3941, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2238, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1703, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.32186314145833084, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.7927, "band_gap_b": 0.779, "band_gap_diff": 0.0137, "density_a": 5.63, "density_b": 6.4, "density_diff_pct": 11.94, "nsites_a": 18, "nsites_b": 18, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCoPHO5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.0428, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.6257, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4172, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.8374, "band_gap_b": 0.023, "band_gap_diff": 2.8144, "density_a": 3.74, "density_b": 3.72, "density_diff_pct": 0.46, "nsites_a": 36, "nsites_b": 18, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnGaCu3Se4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4129, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.208, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2049, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2052911236111119, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.57, "density_b": 5.58, "density_diff_pct": 0.2, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnIn3AsSe4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.7151, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5147, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2004, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.003493708888888225, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.8268, "band_gap_b": 0.619, "band_gap_diff": 0.2078, "density_a": 5.01, "density_b": 5.23, "density_diff_pct": 4.2, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCrCu3Se4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4491, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2389, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2102, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1445146427777777, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.57, "density_b": 5.62, "density_diff_pct": 0.85, "nsites_a": 9, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnWF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.7216, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.4841, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2376, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.69, "density_b": 5.73, "density_diff_pct": 0.69, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnPbF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.3957, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.1465, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2493, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.9566, "band_gap_b": 1.894, "band_gap_diff": 0.0626, "density_a": 5.86, "density_b": 5.79, "density_diff_pct": 1.12, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnRhF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.1054, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.9102, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1952, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 4.79, "density_b": 4.77, "density_diff_pct": 0.35, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnPtF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.0325, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.8135, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.219, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.0919, "band_gap_b": 2.182, "band_gap_diff": 0.0901, "density_a": 6.37, "density_b": 6.25, "density_diff_pct": 1.92, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnPt3O4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.7652, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5851, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1801, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.24389578825000413, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 12.11, "density_b": 12.16, "density_diff_pct": 0.42, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnPdF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.9797, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.77, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2097, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.5286, "band_gap_b": 1.709, "band_gap_diff": 0.1804, "density_a": 4.94, "density_b": 4.86, "density_diff_pct": 1.63, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnH2SeO4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.3985, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.0948, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3037, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.020488866406251915, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 4.3087, "band_gap_b": 4.244, "band_gap_diff": 0.0647, "density_a": 3.61, "density_b": 3.95, "density_diff_pct": 8.51, "nsites_a": 32, "nsites_b": 32, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnMoF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.6983, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.484, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2144, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 4.4, "density_b": 4.36, "density_diff_pct": 0.88, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnMo2O5", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.5907, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.5958, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0051, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.3731788468749997, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 4.61, "density_b": 4.97, "density_diff_pct": 7.34, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnSbF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.5729, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.3168, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2561, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.06363814453125016, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 3.96, "density_b": 4.47, "density_diff_pct": 11.41, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnSbAsO5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.6682, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.3349, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3333, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.13502672718749764, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.4172, "band_gap_b": 3.005, "band_gap_diff": 0.5878, "density_a": 4.41, "density_b": 4.49, "density_diff_pct": 1.71, "nsites_a": 32, "nsites_b": 32, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "Zn3B7ClO13", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.5398, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.3217, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2181, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.026515364036452382, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 4.4852, "band_gap_b": 4.631, "band_gap_diff": 0.1458, "density_a": 3.74, "density_b": 3.81, "density_diff_pct": 1.71, "nsites_a": 48, "nsites_b": 48, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnB3Ir4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2964, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.229, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0673, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 15.56, "density_b": 15.21, "density_diff_pct": 2.25, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnBiF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.4784, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.2266, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2519, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.08, "density_b": 5.51, "density_diff_pct": 7.76, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnBiAsO5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.6684, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.3917, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2767, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1077291246874994, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.9212, "band_gap_b": 2.918, "band_gap_diff": 0.9968, "density_a": 5.37, "density_b": 6.25, "density_diff_pct": 14.08, "nsites_a": 32, "nsites_b": 32, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnBi2O5", "n_a": 4, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.5132, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.0637, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4495, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.029389191562499306, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.2345, "band_gap_b": 0.289, "band_gap_diff": 0.0545, "density_a": 7.91, "density_b": 7.91, "density_diff_pct": 0.02, "nsites_a": 64, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnSnF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.7481, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.5136, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2346, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 3.7163, "band_gap_b": 3.775, "band_gap_diff": 0.0587, "density_a": 4.7, "density_b": 4.67, "density_diff_pct": 0.52, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnSn2O5", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.9649, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.6478, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3171, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.06346278312499987, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.8464, "band_gap_b": 1.003, "band_gap_diff": 0.1566, "density_a": 5.81, "density_b": 5.87, "density_diff_pct": 1.08, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnAg2GeO4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.3534, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.107, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2463, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.030939900000000797, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.2668, "band_gap_b": 0.308, "band_gap_diff": 0.0412, "density_a": 6.01, "density_b": 6.16, "density_diff_pct": 2.39, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnAg2SnS4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.621, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.411, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.21, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.2182, "band_gap_b": 0.155, "band_gap_diff": 0.0632, "density_a": 4.63, "density_b": 4.71, "density_diff_pct": 1.62, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnAg2SnSe4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5823, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3297, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2526, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.010297994687499479, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.42, "density_b": 5.5, "density_diff_pct": 1.6, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnNiF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.9358, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.8662, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0696, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.6071, "band_gap_b": 1.146, "band_gap_diff": 0.4611, "density_a": 4.45, "density_b": 4.41, "density_diff_pct": 0.88, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnSiNiO5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.7785, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.6905, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.088, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.21699824343750151, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.3017, "band_gap_b": 0.205, "band_gap_diff": 0.0967, "density_a": 4.53, "density_b": 4.82, "density_diff_pct": 6.0, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnCu2GeS4", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6957, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5119, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1839, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.002865244375000131, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.5078, "band_gap_b": 0.325, "band_gap_diff": 0.1828, "density_a": 4.43, "density_b": 4.27, "density_diff_pct": 3.61, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnCu2GeSe4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5948, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3555, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2393, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.003936023749999684, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.35, "density_b": 5.35, "density_diff_pct": 0.08, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCu2GeTe4", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3995, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1703, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2293, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0027299249999992448, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.64, "density_b": 5.75, "density_diff_pct": 1.92, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCu2SnS4", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.7045, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5224, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1822, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0027631224999993265, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.115, "band_gap_diff": 0.115, "density_a": 4.64, "density_b": 4.49, "density_diff_pct": 3.33, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnCu2SnSeS3", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6236, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4963, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1273, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.06861707056249955, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0269, "band_gap_b": 0.031, "band_gap_diff": 0.0041, "density_a": 4.78, "density_b": 4.78, "density_diff_pct": 0.03, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCu2SnSe3S", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4637, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4337, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.03, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.19843970918749898, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0059, "band_gap_b": 0.016, "band_gap_diff": 0.0101, "density_a": 5.26, "density_b": 5.26, "density_diff_pct": 0.07, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnCu2SnSe4", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6288, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3911, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2376, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.005351925437500071, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.028, "band_gap_diff": 0.028, "density_a": 5.45, "density_b": 5.48, "density_diff_pct": 0.65, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCu2SnTe4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4347, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2037, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.231, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.009806888500000444, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.8, "density_b": 5.79, "density_diff_pct": 0.07, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCu2SiS4", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.8002, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.6148, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1853, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.001620530624999894, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.2823, "band_gap_b": 1.272, "band_gap_diff": 0.0103, "density_a": 4.08, "density_b": 3.96, "density_diff_pct": 2.94, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCu2SiSe4", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6328, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3981, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2347, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.004776664375000017, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.4002, "band_gap_b": 0.663, "band_gap_diff": 0.2628, "density_a": 5.1, "density_b": 5.12, "density_diff_pct": 0.37, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnCu2SiTe4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.389, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1567, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2323, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.159, "band_gap_b": 0.166, "band_gap_diff": 0.007, "density_a": 5.71, "density_b": 5.54, "density_diff_pct": 2.95, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCoF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.1017, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.9714, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1302, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.6668, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.6668, "density_a": 4.44, "density_b": 4.42, "density_diff_pct": 0.51, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCoPO5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.9984, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.7112, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2872, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.08650874921641538, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.1137, "band_gap_b": 0.381, "band_gap_diff": 0.2673, "density_a": 4.28, "density_b": 4.57, "density_diff_pct": 6.35, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnFeF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.3263, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.1528, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1735, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.845, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.845, "density_a": 3.81, "density_b": 4.04, "density_diff_pct": 5.57, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnFePO5", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.1724, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.8236, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3488, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.05660539156250355, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.8076, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 1.8076, "density_a": 4.02, "density_b": 4.38, "density_diff_pct": 8.05, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnGa3N3O", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.7349, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.8014, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0665, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.20479769468749964, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 1.329, "band_gap_diff": 1.329, "density_a": 5.74, "density_b": 5.82, "density_diff_pct": 1.37, "nsites_a": 32, "nsites_b": 32, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnIn2GeAs4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0809, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0581, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0228, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2704437856249995, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.37, "density_b": 6.33, "density_diff_pct": 0.69, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnIn2SnAs4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1995, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1983, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0013, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.003531986250000063, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.29, "density_b": 5.32, "density_diff_pct": 0.43, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCd3S4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.8096, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7064, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1032, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.013561217053570829, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.2164, "band_gap_b": 1.191, "band_gap_diff": 0.0254, "density_a": 4.61, "density_b": 4.55, "density_diff_pct": 1.33, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCd3Se4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.8577, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.6266, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2311, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.008423413125000945, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.6264, "band_gap_b": 0.487, "band_gap_diff": 0.1394, "density_a": 5.46, "density_b": 5.34, "density_diff_pct": 2.24, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCrF6", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.6433, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.5094, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1339, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.6673, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 1.6673, "density_a": 4.1, "density_b": 4.04, "density_diff_pct": 1.47, "nsites_a": 8, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCrSF5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.2966, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.1292, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1674, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.19852602468749758, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.2167, "band_gap_b": 0.401, "band_gap_diff": 0.8157, "density_a": 3.26, "density_b": 3.19, "density_diff_pct": 1.96, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCrPO5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.3802, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.0488, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3314, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.05560111546875035, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 1.5748, "band_gap_b": 0.134, "band_gap_diff": 1.4408, "density_a": 4.02, "density_b": 4.17, "density_diff_pct": 3.67, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": false }, { "formula": "ZnCrSiO5", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.3784, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.2018, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1766, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.08849631725694795, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.5386, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.5386, "density_a": 4.16, "density_b": 4.38, "density_diff_pct": 5.18, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnCr2O5", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.7864, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.7686, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0179, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.22917513427083058, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 3.92, "density_b": 4.08, "density_diff_pct": 3.94, "nsites_a": 16, "nsites_b": 16, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "Zn3TeP2Pb3O14", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.0876, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.7834, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3042, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.00011102079710045842, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 3.2694, "band_gap_b": 3.398, "band_gap_diff": 0.1286, "density_a": 6.48, "density_b": 6.33, "density_diff_pct": 2.28, "nsites_a": 23, "nsites_b": 23, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "Zn3TeAs2Pb3O14", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.7547, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.4297, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.325, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.9591, "band_gap_b": 3.075, "band_gap_diff": 0.1159, "density_a": 6.58, "density_b": 6.45, "density_diff_pct": 2.03, "nsites_a": 23, "nsites_b": 23, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "Zn3SbAs2Pb3O14", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.732, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.428, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.304, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.023122098442024175, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.22, "density_b": 6.51, "density_diff_pct": 4.45, "nsites_a": 23, "nsites_b": 23, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "Zn3GaB6PO12", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.4009, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.181, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2199, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 4.0713, "band_gap_b": 4.166, "band_gap_diff": 0.0947, "density_a": 4.02, "density_b": 4.06, "density_diff_pct": 0.88, "nsites_a": 23, "nsites_b": 23, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "Zn3P6N12Cl", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4371, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.458, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0209, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.15758528630681923, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 3.41, "density_b": 3.45, "density_diff_pct": 1.1, "nsites_a": 22, "nsites_b": 22, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnPd5Se", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3932, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2924, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1008, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 10.23, "density_b": 9.98, "density_diff_pct": 2.46, "nsites_a": 7, "nsites_b": 7, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnHIO4", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.1693, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.8352, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3341, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.04111135053571324, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 3.7566, "band_gap_b": 3.319, "band_gap_diff": 0.4376, "density_a": 4.14, "density_b": 4.27, "density_diff_pct": 3.0, "nsites_a": 14, "nsites_b": 14, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true }, { "formula": "ZnH6", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0289, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.1238, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0949, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.028948922857142456, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 4.617, "band_gap_b": 4.4, "band_gap_diff": 0.217, "density_a": 0.85, "density_b": 1.49, "density_diff_pct": 42.88, "nsites_a": 28, "nsites_b": 28, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0, "sg_match": true } ] }, "oqmd_jarvis": { "source_a": "oqmd", "source_b": "jarvis", "n_overlapping_formulas": 339, "n_entries_a": 678, "n_entries_b": 2, "property_agreement": { "formation_energy_per_atom": { "n": 339, "mae": 0.2302, "rmse": 0.3381, "max": 2.3838, "p95": 0.758, "median": 0.1695, "bias_mean": 0.2302 }, "energy_above_hull": { "n": 0 }, "band_gap": { "n": 339, "mae": 0.1008, "rmse": 0.3393, "max": 2.696, "p95": 0.7024, "median": 0.0, "bias_mean": 0.1008 }, "volume": { "n": 0 }, "density": { "n": 141, "mae": 8.8103, "rmse": 10.4477, "max": 20.3748, "p95": 18.5769, "median": 8.7298 }, "nsites": { "n": 339, "mae": 23.0252, "rmse": 39.8518, "max": 91.6667, "p95": 75.8333, "median": 0.0 } }, "space_group_agreement": { "agree": 0, "disagree": 0, "missing_a": 339, "missing_b": 0 }, "sg_agreement_pct": 0.0, "detailed_samples": [ { "formula": "Zn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0243, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0243, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.02426913, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 1, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MnZn", "n_a": 6, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0663, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.1309, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0646, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.08233642381565072, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "TiZn", "n_a": 6, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0771, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1946, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1176, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.13853815000000058, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "ScZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3793, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4119, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0326, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgNiSb", "n_a": 4, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4237, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4296, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0059, "energy_above_hull_a": 2.7266666667025152e-05, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgTaZn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 1.146, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.6033, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.5427, "energy_above_hull_a": 1.22035990564027, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 7.57, "density_b": 7.79, "density_diff_pct": 2.87, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgScTl", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.2443, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.2033, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.041, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.458796073333334, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.68, "density_b": 5.63, "density_diff_pct": 0.99, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgO", "n_a": 4, "n_b": 11, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -2.9459, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -2.8907, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0552, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0003461549999999036, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 4.975, "band_gap_b": 3.857, "band_gap_diff": 1.118, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "MgS", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.5796, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.6234, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0438, "energy_above_hull_a": 5.281500000009487e-05, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.95, "band_gap_b": 2.945, "band_gap_diff": 0.005, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgSe", "n_a": 4, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -1.014, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.3488, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3348, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.25380669000001, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.55, "band_gap_b": 2.117, "band_gap_diff": 1.567, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgPb", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0129, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0697, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0568, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0383461700000001, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 4, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgRh", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.476, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5044, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0284, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.00041471500000100914, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgPt", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.5937, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7844, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1908, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.28563997499999993, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "MgPd", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.7445, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7618, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0173, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0020555050000000685, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgOs", "n_a": 6, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.2645, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.1864, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0781, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.264546605416665, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 4, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgP", "n_a": 4, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4705, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4983, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0278, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.24004310587499972, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "MgTe", "n_a": 4, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.8796, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.9509, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0713, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0009973300000000185, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 2.458, "band_gap_b": 2.53, "band_gap_diff": 0.072, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 4, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgSb", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0811, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1977, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1166, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2343668047797193, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "MgSn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 6, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.111, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0366, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1476, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0663560621875, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "MgNi", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 4, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0255, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2098, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2352, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.23657597652777812, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgSi", "n_a": 6, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.1285, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.1138, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0148, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.24983512624999998, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 4, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 8, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0082, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0841, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0759, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.10352850737818275, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "MgTl", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0342, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.04, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0058, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0029861399999999982, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgTi", "n_a": 6, "n_b": 9, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.178, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.2602, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0822, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.17984044833333246, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "MgTa", "n_a": 6, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.3372, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.3043, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0329, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.337193420416664, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 4, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "MgSc", "n_a": 6, "n_b": 4, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0425, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0316, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0109, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0006542200000003995, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "MgZr", "n_a": 6, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0556, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0619, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0063, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0853171475000005, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "Mg", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 5, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0288, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0037, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0251, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0288302008333299, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 1, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 88.89 }, { "formula": "HfZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1968, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2009, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0041, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "HfMg", "n_a": 4, "n_b": 9, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.1289, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.9555, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.8265, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.128945717916665, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "LuMgTl", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1183, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2878, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1695, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.143983912222222, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.387, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.387, "density_a": 8.07, "density_b": 9.24, "density_diff_pct": 12.65, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "LuZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3552, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3859, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0307, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.00051768499999999, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "LuMg", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0441, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0275, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0166, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "TmZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2763, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3848, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1085, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.07686569499999996, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "ErTlZn", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0873, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2822, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.195, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.22852181416666667, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.387, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.387, "density_a": 9.36, "density_b": 10.75, "density_diff_pct": 12.95, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "ErMgPd", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.082, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7384, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.8204, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.783603363333333, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.51, "density_b": 7.86, "density_diff_pct": 17.18, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "ErMgSn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1253, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.566, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4407, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.454073446666667, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.42, "density_b": 6.91, "density_diff_pct": 7.0, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "ErMgTl", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1562, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3307, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1745, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.14996022, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.383, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.383, "density_a": 7.78, "density_b": 8.87, "density_diff_pct": 12.33, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "ErZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3517, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3859, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0341, "energy_above_hull_a": 5.7254999999978295e-05, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "ErMg", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0666, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0538, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0128, "energy_above_hull_a": 6.875000000003406e-06, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "HoMgSn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1456, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5785, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4329, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.447283146666667, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.31, "density_b": 6.8, "density_diff_pct": 7.19, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "HoMgTl", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1669, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3279, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.161, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.151180177777777, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.5, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.5, "density_a": 7.67, "density_b": 8.74, "density_diff_pct": 12.25, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "HoZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3479, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3832, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0352, "energy_above_hull_a": 6.602500000002509e-05, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "HoMg", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0731, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0591, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.014, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.00011308000000020968, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "YZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2903, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4117, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1215, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.07306486000000001, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "DyTlZn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1083, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3089, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2006, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.22363714, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.372, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.372, "density_a": 9.11, "density_b": 10.44, "density_diff_pct": 12.76, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "DyMgPd", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0923, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7208, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.8131, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.788703156666667, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.27, "density_b": 7.58, "density_diff_pct": 17.23, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "DyMgSn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1661, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.6055, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4394, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.439410143333333, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.3, "density_b": 6.7, "density_diff_pct": 6.01, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "DyZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1206, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3808, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2603, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.223642495, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "DyMg", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0794, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.0665, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0128, "energy_above_hull_a": 1.730999999999261e-05, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "SmTlZn", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1342, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3442, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.21, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.211512180153521, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.37, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.37, "density_a": 8.45, "density_b": 9.67, "density_diff_pct": 12.58, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "SmZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0867, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3675, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2808, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2407572599999998, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "NdTlZn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1398, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3554, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2156, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.21139441982104698, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.345, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.345, "density_a": 8.1, "density_b": 9.21, "density_diff_pct": 12.01, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "NdZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3182, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.359, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0408, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.00016701000000002297, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "PrZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3111, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3531, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.042, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CeTlZn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1376, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2244, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0868, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2130399261905404, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.308, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.308, "density_a": 7.68, "density_b": 9.46, "density_diff_pct": 18.82, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "CeMgRh", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3791, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5843, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2053, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.118666671109114, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.76, "density_b": 6.97, "density_diff_pct": 17.43, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CeMgPt", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.7096, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.8872, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1776, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.1605360333333331, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 7.42, "density_b": 9.02, "density_diff_pct": 17.74, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CeMgPd", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4641, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.579, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1149, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.172827685555555, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.53, "density_b": 6.67, "density_diff_pct": 17.11, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CeMgSn", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3019, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4824, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1806, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.321665714166667, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.38, "density_b": 5.87, "density_diff_pct": 8.31, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CeMgTl", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2208, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.197, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0238, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.14184179, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.48, "density_b": 7.64, "density_diff_pct": 15.25, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CeZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0749, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2066, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1317, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2236558949999998, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CeMg", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 11, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1228, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.0175, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1402, "energy_above_hull_a": 5.007499999999665e-05, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 8, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "YbZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3375, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4276, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0901, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0006964549999999847, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "TbZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0967, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3787, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4753, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.22732444743114694, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "LaTlZn", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1733, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.387, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2137, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.19961965700981432, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 7.57, "density_b": 8.61, "density_diff_pct": 12.04, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "LaMgRh", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.3055, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7069, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 1.0125, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.931656438333333, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.38, "density_b": 6.54, "density_diff_pct": 17.73, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 24, "nsites_diff_pct": 87.5 }, { "formula": "LaMgPd", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.1353, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7376, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.873, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.805767211111111, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.09, "density_b": 6.25, "density_diff_pct": 18.58, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "LaMgTl", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2447, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.119, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1257, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.134718201111111, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.258, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.258, "density_a": 6.4, "density_b": 6.76, "density_diff_pct": 5.3, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "LaZn", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0714, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3695, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2981, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.24453281, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "LaMg", "n_a": 5, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1153, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1135, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0017, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.00010739499999999624, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 2, "nsites_b": 2, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaGaGeH", "n_a": 1, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4354, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4882, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0528, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.0, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.652, "band_gap_b": 0.568, "band_gap_diff": 0.084, "nsites_a": 4, "nsites_b": 4, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaGePt", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6005, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.9898, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3893, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.322282601666667, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 7.52, "density_b": 8.54, "density_diff_pct": 11.95, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaHgPb", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0847, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2961, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2114, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.3404151278321341, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 7.69, "density_b": 8.89, "density_diff_pct": 13.5, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "CaNiTe", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.7618, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4376, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3242, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.3452574788688517, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.442, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.442, "density_a": 5.74, "density_b": 5.15, "density_diff_pct": 10.2, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaCuSb", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6292, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.732, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1028, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.05948582500000055, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.37, "density_b": 5.32, "density_diff_pct": 0.97, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "CaCuSn", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3771, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5373, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1603, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.120134508333334, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.13, "density_b": 5.55, "density_diff_pct": 7.64, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 18, "nsites_diff_pct": 83.33 }, { "formula": "CaCuSi", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0426, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.1835, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.226, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.443472274301045, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 3.39, "density_b": 3.61, "density_diff_pct": 6.03, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaCoSi", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.2295, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5548, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.7844, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.7578432262200872, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 3.49, "density_b": 3.88, "density_diff_pct": 9.83, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "CaGaPt", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6711, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -1.0061, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.335, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.25706130000000094, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 7.35, "density_b": 8.4, "density_diff_pct": 12.54, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaGaGe", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2824, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.597, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3145, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2527610225, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 4.05, "density_b": 4.51, "density_diff_pct": 10.21, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaGaSn", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0664, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5763, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.5099, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.4801080100000005, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 4.26, "density_b": 4.92, "density_diff_pct": 13.39, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaGaSi", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 2, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1403, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4802, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.3399, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.31773210583333344, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 3.24, "density_b": 3.55, "density_diff_pct": 8.76, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaInRh", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4017, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.6146, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2129, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.159902310833334, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.91, "density_b": 6.5, "density_diff_pct": 9.03, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaInPt", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.7097, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.9168, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2071, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.13978208583333396, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 7.67, "density_b": 8.55, "density_diff_pct": 10.35, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaInPd", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.571, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.754, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1831, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.15074238583333277, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.68, "density_b": 6.34, "density_diff_pct": 10.43, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaCdPb", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0144, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.4436, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4293, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.3939750750000002, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 6.15, "density_b": 7.11, "density_diff_pct": 13.51, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CaCdPt", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.6282, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.827, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1987, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.11016373749999997, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 7.63, "density_b": 8.6, "density_diff_pct": 11.26, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaCdPd", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.2479, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.6833, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4354, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.3753212575, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 5.63, "density_b": 6.37, "density_diff_pct": 11.71, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaCdGe", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4645, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5594, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.0949, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.043496782222222696, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.347, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.347, "density_a": 4.83, "density_b": 5.36, "density_diff_pct": 10.01, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CaCdSn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4667, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5751, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1084, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.08985684999999999, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.699, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.699, "density_a": 5.04, "density_b": 5.63, "density_diff_pct": 10.45, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 9, "nsites_diff_pct": 66.67 }, { "formula": "CaCdSi", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3261, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.194, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1322, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.06159748472442356, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.7, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.7, "density_a": 4.03, "density_b": 4.06, "density_diff_pct": 0.59, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaMnSn", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.0076, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.2398, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2322, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.4611405594125811, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 4.16, "density_b": 4.83, "density_diff_pct": 13.76, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "CaMnSi", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.0771, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3544, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.4315, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.5034388762922657, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 2.93, "density_b": 3.51, "density_diff_pct": 16.51, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 6, "nsites_diff_pct": 50.0 }, { "formula": "CaTaTc", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 2.0901, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": 0.9233, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 1.1669, "energy_above_hull_a": 2.424186805003555, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 8.18, "density_b": 8.14, "density_diff_pct": 0.49, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaMgPb", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.209, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5077, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.2987, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.2392620875, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 4.99, "density_b": 5.44, "density_diff_pct": 8.21, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaMgPd", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.1184, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.7074, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.589, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.512283969166666, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "density_a": 3.81, "density_b": 4.27, "density_diff_pct": 10.78, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaMgSn", "n_a": 2, "n_b": 3, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.4959, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.3773, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1186, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.10371748000000036, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.797, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.797, "density_a": 3.33, "density_b": 3.59, "density_diff_pct": 7.45, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 3, "nsites_diff_pct": 0.0 }, { "formula": "CaMgSi", "n_a": 3, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": -0.3586, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.5121, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.1535, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.09111308666666601, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.799, "band_gap_b": 0.022, "band_gap_diff": 0.777, "density_a": 2.0, "density_b": 2.25, "density_diff_pct": 10.74, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 }, { "formula": "CaMgZn", "n_a": 6, "n_b": 1, "formation_energy_per_atom_a": 0.6159, "formation_energy_per_atom_b": -0.249, "formation_energy_per_atom_diff": 0.8649, "energy_above_hull_a": 0.8331132875, "energy_above_hull_b": null, "energy_above_hull_diff": null, "band_gap_a": 0.0, "band_gap_b": 0.0, "band_gap_diff": 0.0, "nsites_a": 3, "nsites_b": 12, "nsites_diff_pct": 75.0 } ] } }, "total_cross_source_overlaps": 12305, "elapsed_seconds": 0.5 }