#!/usr/bin/env python3 """Show a few concrete papers — v15 actual n_pred, v16 actual n_pred, n_gt, and what each setting would charge. Stratified pick: small-GT, mid-GT, large-GT to show edge behavior. """ import json import re from pathlib import Path ROOT = Path("/gpfs/radev/scratch/cohan/yz979/xucai/Abforge_Training") _TARGET_BULLET_RE = re.compile( r'\n\s*[-*]\s*(?:\*\*)?Target Module(?:\*\*)?\s*:', re.IGNORECASE) _RQ_BULLET_RE = re.compile( r'\n\s*[-*]\s*(?:\*\*)?Research Question(?:\*\*)?\s*:', re.IGNORECASE) def extract_result(raw): m = re.search(r"(.*?)", raw, re.DOTALL | re.IGNORECASE) if m: return m.group(1) m2 = re.search(r"(.*)", raw, re.DOTALL | re.IGNORECASE) return m2.group(1) if m2 else raw def count_pairs(raw): t = "\n" + extract_result(raw or "") return min(len(_TARGET_BULLET_RE.findall(t)), len(_RQ_BULLET_RE.findall(t))) def cp_progressive(n, g, tol, base, step, cap=0.5): excess = max(0, n - g - tol) if excess <= 0: return 0.0 return min(cap, sum(base + step * (i - 1) for i in range(1, excess + 1))) def cp_fixed(n, g, tol, rate, cap=0.5): return min(cap, max(0, n - g - tol) * rate) SETTINGS = [ ("v16-now", lambda n, g: cp_progressive(n, g, 1, 0.05, 0.01)), ("E (rec)", lambda n, g: cp_progressive(n, g, 2, 0.01, 0.01)), ("A ", lambda n, g: cp_progressive(n, g, 1, 0.01, 0.01)), ("C fixed", lambda n, g: cp_fixed(n, g, 1, 0.02)), ] def title_key(r): return r.get("meta", {}).get("title", "") v15 = {title_key(json.loads(l)): json.loads(l) for l in open(ROOT / "infer/task1_v15_ckpt100_bench50_qwen3_infer_task1.jsonl")} v16 = {title_key(json.loads(l)): json.loads(l) for l in open(ROOT / "infer/task1_v16_ckpt50_bench50_qwen3_infer_task1.jsonl")} evals = [json.loads(l) for l in open(ROOT / "infer/task1_v15_ckpt100_eval_50.jsonl")] papers = [] for ev in evals: title = title_key(ev) if title not in v15 or title not in v16: continue n_gt = ev.get("n_gt", 0) n15 = count_pairs(v15[title].get("infer_task1_response", "")) n16 = count_pairs(v16[title].get("infer_task1_response", "")) mr = ev.get("match_rate", 0) papers.append((title, n_gt, n15, n16, mr)) # stratified pick: 2 small-GT, 2 mid-GT, 2 large-GT papers.sort(key=lambda x: x[1]) small = papers[:2] + papers[3:5] mid = [p for p in papers if 3 <= p[1] <= 4][:3] large = [p for p in papers if p[1] >= 6][:3] print("CASE-BY-CASE count_penalty under each setting") print("=" * 100) print(f"{'title':<55} {'n_gt':>4} {'n15':>4} {'n16':>4} " f"{'v16-now (v15→v16)':>22} {'E (v15→v16)':>16} {'A (v15→v16)':>16} {'C (v15→v16)':>16}") print("-" * 160) for label, group in [("SMALL n_gt", small), ("MID n_gt", mid), ("LARGE n_gt", large)]: print(f"\n--- {label} ---") for title, n_gt, n15, n16, mr in group: title_s = (title[:50] + "…") if len(title) > 50 else title row = f"{title_s:<55} {n_gt:>4} {n15:>4} {n16:>4} " for name, fn in SETTINGS: p15 = fn(n15, n_gt) p16 = fn(n16, n_gt) row += f" {p15:.3f}→{p16:.3f} " print(row) # also: average penalty if model "stabilizes at n=5" vs current v16 n=4 print("\n\n=== summary: avg penalty across all 49 papers if model writes constant N ===") print(f"{'setting':<10} {'n=4 (v16 cur)':>15} {'n=5':>10} {'n=6':>10} {'n=7':>10}") for name, fn in SETTINGS: row = f"{name:<10} " for N in [4, 5, 6, 7]: mean = sum(fn(N, p[1]) for p in papers) / len(papers) row += f" {mean:>10.4f} " print(row)