TabQueryBench commited on
Commit
78ad33c
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): e6c15ac

Upload subgroup support3-vs-profile analysis

Browse files
evaluation/query_family/subgroup/support3_vs_profile_analysis/README.md ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ # Support3 vs. Profile Analysis
2
+
3
+ This folder builds a support-oriented version of the original
4
+ `support_vs_profile_query_density.png` figure.
5
+
6
+ Instead of the canonical subgroup `query_score`, the x-axis uses:
7
+
8
+ - `support3_score = mean(key_set_score, row_count_score, column_score)`
9
+
10
+ This makes the figure align more directly with the paper story that current
11
+ generators are better at preserving the subgroup scaffold/support than the
12
+ within-group analytical profile.
13
+
14
+ Files:
15
+
16
+ - `build_support3_vs_profile_analysis.py`
17
+ - `support3_vs_profile_query_density.png`
18
+ - `support3_vs_profile_query_density.tex`
19
+ - `support3_density_curves.csv`
20
+ - `summary_metrics.json`
evaluation/query_family/subgroup/support3_vs_profile_analysis/build_support3_vs_profile_analysis.py ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,292 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ from __future__ import annotations
2
+
3
+ import json
4
+ from pathlib import Path
5
+
6
+ import matplotlib.pyplot as plt
7
+ import numpy as np
8
+ import pandas as pd
9
+
10
+ try:
11
+ from scipy.stats import gaussian_kde
12
+ except Exception: # pragma: no cover
13
+ gaussian_kde = None
14
+
15
+
16
+ INTERNAL_COLOR = "#AA3377"
17
+ SIZE_COLOR = "#009988"
18
+ RUN_TAG = "v2_keyset_cts_48_20260504_2350"
19
+
20
+
21
+ def _density_curve(values: np.ndarray, grid: np.ndarray) -> np.ndarray:
22
+ values = np.asarray(values, dtype=float)
23
+ values = values[np.isfinite(values)]
24
+ if values.size == 0:
25
+ return np.zeros_like(grid)
26
+
27
+ if gaussian_kde is not None and values.size >= 3 and np.std(values) > 0:
28
+ curve = gaussian_kde(values)(grid)
29
+ else:
30
+ bins = np.linspace(0.0, 1.0, 26)
31
+ density, edges = np.histogram(values, bins=bins, density=True)
32
+ centers = 0.5 * (edges[:-1] + edges[1:])
33
+ curve = np.interp(grid, centers, density, left=density[0], right=density[-1])
34
+
35
+ curve = np.clip(curve, 0.0, None)
36
+ area = np.trapz(curve, grid)
37
+ if area > 0:
38
+ curve = curve / area
39
+ return curve
40
+
41
+
42
+ def _branch_summary(series: pd.Series) -> dict[str, float]:
43
+ return {
44
+ "count": int(series.size),
45
+ "mean": float(series.mean()),
46
+ "median": float(series.median()),
47
+ "p25": float(series.quantile(0.25)),
48
+ "p75": float(series.quantile(0.75)),
49
+ "share_le_0_4": float((series <= 0.4).mean()),
50
+ "share_ge_0_8": float((series >= 0.8).mean()),
51
+ }
52
+
53
+
54
+ def load_query_rows(data_dir: Path) -> pd.DataFrame:
55
+ df = pd.read_csv(data_dir / "subgroup_query_rows.csv")
56
+ df = df[df["model_id"] != "real"].copy()
57
+ df["query_score"] = pd.to_numeric(df["query_score"], errors="coerce")
58
+ return df
59
+
60
+
61
+ def load_query_details(run_dir: Path, sub_df: pd.DataFrame) -> pd.DataFrame:
62
+ needed = set(zip(sub_df["dataset_id"], sub_df["model_id"], sub_df["asset_key"], sub_df["query_id"]))
63
+ rows: list[dict[str, object]] = []
64
+
65
+ for dataset_id in sorted(sub_df["dataset_id"].dropna().unique()):
66
+ path = run_dir / "datasets" / str(dataset_id) / f"analysis_query_scores__{dataset_id}.jsonl"
67
+ with path.open("r", encoding="utf-8") as handle:
68
+ for line in handle:
69
+ obj = json.loads(line)
70
+ key = (obj["dataset_id"], obj["model_id"], obj["asset_key"], obj["query_id"])
71
+ if key not in needed:
72
+ continue
73
+ details = obj.get("details") or {}
74
+ rows.append(
75
+ {
76
+ "dataset_id": obj["dataset_id"],
77
+ "model_id": obj["model_id"],
78
+ "asset_key": obj["asset_key"],
79
+ "query_id": obj["query_id"],
80
+ "strict_set_score": details.get("strict_set_score", details.get("set_score")),
81
+ "key_set_score": details.get("key_set_score"),
82
+ "profile_score": details.get("profile_score"),
83
+ "row_count_score": details.get("row_count_score"),
84
+ "column_score": details.get("column_score"),
85
+ }
86
+ )
87
+
88
+ return pd.DataFrame(rows)
89
+
90
+
91
+ def add_support_scores(df: pd.DataFrame) -> pd.DataFrame:
92
+ out = df.copy()
93
+ for col in [
94
+ "strict_set_score",
95
+ "key_set_score",
96
+ "profile_score",
97
+ "row_count_score",
98
+ "column_score",
99
+ ]:
100
+ out[col] = pd.to_numeric(out[col], errors="coerce")
101
+ out["support3_score"] = out[["key_set_score", "row_count_score", "column_score"]].mean(axis=1)
102
+ return out
103
+
104
+
105
+ def build_plot(curves: pd.DataFrame, stats: dict[str, dict[str, float]], out_dir: Path) -> None:
106
+ plt.style.use("seaborn-v0_8-whitegrid")
107
+ fig, ax = plt.subplots(figsize=(8.8, 5.4))
108
+
109
+ ax.fill_between(
110
+ curves["score"],
111
+ curves["internal_support3_density"],
112
+ color=INTERNAL_COLOR,
113
+ alpha=0.14,
114
+ )
115
+ ax.plot(
116
+ curves["score"],
117
+ curves["internal_support3_density"],
118
+ color=INTERNAL_COLOR,
119
+ linewidth=2.5,
120
+ label="Internal profile stability",
121
+ )
122
+ ax.fill_between(
123
+ curves["score"],
124
+ curves["size_support3_density"],
125
+ color=SIZE_COLOR,
126
+ alpha=0.14,
127
+ )
128
+ ax.plot(
129
+ curves["score"],
130
+ curves["size_support3_density"],
131
+ color=SIZE_COLOR,
132
+ linewidth=2.5,
133
+ label="Subgroup size stability",
134
+ )
135
+
136
+ mean_internal = stats["internal_profile"]["mean"]
137
+ mean_size = stats["subgroup_size"]["mean"]
138
+ ax.axvline(mean_internal, color=INTERNAL_COLOR, linestyle="--", linewidth=1.2, alpha=0.85)
139
+ ax.axvline(mean_size, color=SIZE_COLOR, linestyle="--", linewidth=1.2, alpha=0.85)
140
+
141
+ ax.set_xlim(0.0, 1.0)
142
+ ax.set_xlabel("Query-level support3 score")
143
+ ax.set_ylabel("Relative density (area = 1)")
144
+ ax.set_title("Support-oriented subgroup preservation at the query level")
145
+ ax.text(
146
+ 0.015,
147
+ 0.97,
148
+ (
149
+ f"Queries: internal = {stats['internal_profile']['count']}, size = {stats['subgroup_size']['count']}\n"
150
+ f"Means: internal = {mean_internal:.3f}, size = {mean_size:.3f}\n"
151
+ f"Medians: internal = {stats['internal_profile']['median']:.3f}, "
152
+ f"size = {stats['subgroup_size']['median']:.3f}"
153
+ ),
154
+ transform=ax.transAxes,
155
+ va="top",
156
+ ha="left",
157
+ fontsize=9.0,
158
+ bbox={"boxstyle": "round,pad=0.25", "facecolor": "white", "edgecolor": "#CCCCCC", "alpha": 0.96},
159
+ )
160
+ ax.legend(frameon=False, loc="upper right")
161
+ ax.grid(True, color="#D8DDE3", linewidth=0.8, alpha=0.8)
162
+ ax.spines["top"].set_visible(False)
163
+ ax.spines["right"].set_visible(False)
164
+ fig.tight_layout()
165
+
166
+ fig.savefig(out_dir / "support3_vs_profile_query_density.png", dpi=240)
167
+ plt.close(fig)
168
+
169
+
170
+ def write_tex(curves: pd.DataFrame, stats: dict[str, dict[str, float]], out_dir: Path) -> None:
171
+ ymax = max(curves["internal_support3_density"].max(), curves["size_support3_density"].max()) * 1.05
172
+ mean_internal = stats["internal_profile"]["mean"]
173
+ mean_size = stats["subgroup_size"]["mean"]
174
+ internal_count = stats["internal_profile"]["count"]
175
+ size_count = stats["subgroup_size"]["count"]
176
+ internal_median = stats["internal_profile"]["median"]
177
+ size_median = stats["subgroup_size"]["median"]
178
+
179
+ tex = rf"""\documentclass[tikz,border=4pt]{{standalone}}
180
+ \usepackage{{pgfplots}}
181
+ \usepackage{{pgfplotstable}}
182
+ \pgfplotsset{{compat=1.18}}
183
+ \definecolor{{internalcolor}}{{HTML}}{{AA3377}}
184
+ \definecolor{{sizecolor}}{{HTML}}{{009988}}
185
+ \begin{{document}}
186
+ \begin{{tikzpicture}}
187
+ \begin{{axis}}[
188
+ width=14.8cm,
189
+ height=8.7cm,
190
+ xmin=0.0, xmax=1.0,
191
+ ymin=0.0, ymax={ymax:.4f},
192
+ xlabel={{Query-level support3 score}},
193
+ ylabel={{Relative density (area = 1)}},
194
+ title={{Support-oriented subgroup preservation at the query level}},
195
+ ymajorgrids,
196
+ grid style={{draw=gray!20}},
197
+ major grid style={{draw=gray!30}},
198
+ axis line style={{draw=black!70}},
199
+ tick style={{draw=black!70}},
200
+ legend style={{draw=none, fill=none, font=\small, at={{(0.98,0.98)}}, anchor=north east}},
201
+ ]
202
+ \addplot[draw=none, fill=internalcolor, fill opacity=0.14]
203
+ table[x=score, y=internal_support3_density, col sep=comma]{{support3_density_curves.csv}} \closedcycle;
204
+ \addplot[line width=1.9pt, color=internalcolor]
205
+ table[x=score, y=internal_support3_density, col sep=comma]{{support3_density_curves.csv}};
206
+ \addlegendentry{{Internal profile stability}}
207
+ \addplot[draw=none, fill=sizecolor, fill opacity=0.14]
208
+ table[x=score, y=size_support3_density, col sep=comma]{{support3_density_curves.csv}} \closedcycle;
209
+ \addplot[line width=1.9pt, color=sizecolor]
210
+ table[x=score, y=size_support3_density, col sep=comma]{{support3_density_curves.csv}};
211
+ \addlegendentry{{Subgroup size stability}}
212
+ \addplot[dashed, line width=1.0pt, color=internalcolor, opacity=0.85]
213
+ coordinates {{({mean_internal:.6f},0) ({mean_internal:.6f},{ymax:.4f})}};
214
+ \addplot[dashed, line width=1.0pt, color=sizecolor, opacity=0.85]
215
+ coordinates {{({mean_size:.6f},0) ({mean_size:.6f},{ymax:.4f})}};
216
+ \node[
217
+ anchor=north west,
218
+ draw=gray!55,
219
+ fill=white,
220
+ rounded corners=2pt,
221
+ fill opacity=0.96,
222
+ text opacity=1,
223
+ align=left,
224
+ font=\small
225
+ ] at (axis description cs:0.015,0.97) {{
226
+ Queries: internal = {internal_count}, size = {size_count}\\
227
+ Means: internal = {mean_internal:.3f}, size = {mean_size:.3f}\\
228
+ Medians: internal = {internal_median:.3f}, size = {size_median:.3f}
229
+ }};
230
+ \end{{axis}}
231
+ \end{{tikzpicture}}
232
+ \end{{document}}
233
+ """
234
+ (out_dir / "support3_vs_profile_query_density.tex").write_text(tex, encoding="utf-8")
235
+
236
+
237
+ def main() -> None:
238
+ out_dir = Path(__file__).resolve().parent
239
+ project_root = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[4]
240
+ subgroup_root = project_root / "Evaluation" / "query_fivepart_breakdown" / "subgroup_breakdown"
241
+ run_dir = project_root / "Evaluation" / "analysis" / "runs" / RUN_TAG
242
+
243
+ query_rows = load_query_rows(subgroup_root / "data")
244
+ detail_rows = load_query_details(run_dir, query_rows)
245
+ merged = query_rows.merge(
246
+ detail_rows,
247
+ on=["dataset_id", "model_id", "asset_key", "query_id"],
248
+ how="left",
249
+ )
250
+ merged = add_support_scores(merged)
251
+
252
+ internal = merged.loc[
253
+ merged["subitem_id"] == "internal_profile_stability", "support3_score"
254
+ ].astype(float)
255
+ size = merged.loc[
256
+ merged["subitem_id"] == "subgroup_size_stability", "support3_score"
257
+ ].astype(float)
258
+
259
+ stats = {
260
+ "internal_profile": _branch_summary(internal),
261
+ "subgroup_size": _branch_summary(size),
262
+ }
263
+
264
+ grid = np.linspace(0.0, 1.0, 500)
265
+ curves = pd.DataFrame(
266
+ {
267
+ "score": grid,
268
+ "internal_support3_density": _density_curve(internal.to_numpy(), grid),
269
+ "size_support3_density": _density_curve(size.to_numpy(), grid),
270
+ }
271
+ )
272
+ curves.to_csv(out_dir / "support3_density_curves.csv", index=False)
273
+ (out_dir / "summary_metrics.json").write_text(
274
+ json.dumps(
275
+ {
276
+ "run_tag": RUN_TAG,
277
+ "metric": "support3_score",
278
+ "definition": "mean(key_set_score, row_count_score, column_score)",
279
+ "row_level": stats,
280
+ },
281
+ indent=2,
282
+ ensure_ascii=False,
283
+ ),
284
+ encoding="utf-8",
285
+ )
286
+
287
+ build_plot(curves, stats, out_dir)
288
+ write_tex(curves, stats, out_dir)
289
+
290
+
291
+ if __name__ == "__main__":
292
+ main()
evaluation/query_family/subgroup/support3_vs_profile_analysis/summary_metrics.json ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ {
2
+ "run_tag": "v2_keyset_cts_48_20260504_2350",
3
+ "metric": "support3_score",
4
+ "definition": "mean(key_set_score, row_count_score, column_score)",
5
+ "row_level": {
6
+ "internal_profile": {
7
+ "count": 13332,
8
+ "mean": 0.7770301021787321,
9
+ "median": 0.8888888888888888,
10
+ "p25": 0.625,
11
+ "p75": 1.0,
12
+ "share_le_0_4": 0.14303930393039305,
13
+ "share_ge_0_8": 0.5377287728772877
14
+ },
15
+ "subgroup_size": {
16
+ "count": 9352,
17
+ "mean": 0.8184448182874395,
18
+ "median": 1.0,
19
+ "p25": 0.6666666666666666,
20
+ "p75": 1.0,
21
+ "share_le_0_4": 0.1292771599657827,
22
+ "share_ge_0_8": 0.6319503849443969
23
+ }
24
+ }
25
+ }
evaluation/query_family/subgroup/support3_vs_profile_analysis/support3_density_curves.csv ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,501 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ score,internal_support3_density,size_support3_density
2
+ 0.0,4.794020674788969e-18,6.138277725121947e-17
3
+ 0.002004008016032064,7.757917567468234e-18,9.627555879740568e-17
4
+ 0.004008016032064128,1.2517943837651227e-17,1.505948775400093e-16
5
+ 0.0060120240480961915,2.014018433095973e-17,2.349248772252812e-16
6
+ 0.008016032064128256,3.2309966836290023e-17,3.6548747162491064e-16
7
+ 0.01002004008016032,5.168353819855434e-17,5.670752304218308e-16
8
+ 0.012024048096192383,8.243481010662615e-17,8.774726306554723e-16
9
+ 0.014028056112224447,1.3110273500381227e-16,1.3541015008948037e-15
10
+ 0.01603206412825651,2.0790052870981566e-16,2.083980351858444e-15
11
+ 0.018036072144288574,3.2873216103097994e-16,3.1986064064307314e-15
12
+ 0.02004008016032064,5.182885114180194e-16,4.89612830124172e-15
13
+ 0.022044088176352703,8.1478642427946325e-16,7.474284140953361e-15
14
+ 0.024048096192384766,1.2771997641050566e-15,1.1379187880077904e-14
15
+ 0.026052104208416832,1.99625835788281e-15,1.7277376841826095e-14
16
+ 0.028056112224448895,3.1111257645990544e-15,2.6161897594295657e-14
17
+ 0.03006012024048096,4.834608597562792e-15,3.9508050391673035e-14
18
+ 0.03206412825651302,7.491142114954904e-15,5.950136157787152e-14
19
+ 0.03406813627254509,1.1573847281509267e-14,8.937029291807466e-14
20
+ 0.03607214428857715,1.7829964817544725e-14,1.33870368108358e-13
21
+ 0.038076152304609215,2.7388376242354276e-14,1.9998653650785995e-13
22
+ 0.04008016032064128,4.1949344432646244e-14,2.9794912405560724e-13
23
+ 0.04208416833667334,6.406593952078748e-14,4.4269900612560994e-13
24
+ 0.044088176352705406,9.75601330240403e-14,6.55994335645499e-13
25
+ 0.04609218436873747,1.481360523910537e-13,9.694307003599098e-13
26
+ 0.04809619238476953,2.2428094947249727e-13,1.4287578038084664e-12
27
+ 0.0501002004008016,3.385846596731867e-13,2.1000307738858858e-12
28
+ 0.052104208416833664,5.09665785645359e-13,3.0783495304509314e-12
29
+ 0.05410821643286573,7.649746298242836e-13,4.500237773534355e-12
30
+ 0.05611222444889779,1.1448589242250425e-12,6.56112455930711e-12
31
+ 0.058116232464929855,1.7084424177859985e-12,9.539957262137189e-12
32
+ 0.06012024048096192,2.54209741652829e-12,1.3833750341882588e-11
33
+ 0.06212424849699398,3.771616673836012e-12,2.0005933958714972e-11
34
+ 0.06412825651302605,5.5796436404292355e-12,2.8853809210865894e-11
35
+ 0.06613226452905811,8.230552315780116e-12,4.150237447013056e-11
36
+ 0.06813627254509018,1.2105845990891095e-11,5.953443471783954e-11
37
+ 0.07014028056112225,1.775435924701916e-11,8.517047368356941e-11
38
+ 0.0721442885771543,2.596322299296026e-11,1.215165604414695e-10
39
+ 0.07414829659318636,3.785785414330162e-11,1.729049755173219e-10
40
+ 0.07615230460921843,5.504238247521232e-11,2.453607953405688e-10
41
+ 0.0781563126252505,7.979622473481005e-11,3.47239042398167e-10
42
+ 0.08016032064128256,1.153483559196181e-10,4.900920646792902e-10
43
+ 0.08216432865731463,1.6625873406486697e-10,6.898466774045084e-10
44
+ 0.08416833667334668,2.3894699935108406e-10,9.683967276098387e-10
45
+ 0.08617234468937875,3.424228993275068e-10,1.3557509753984456e-09
46
+ 0.08817635270541081,4.892920776580383e-10,1.892920876651829e-09
47
+ 0.09018036072144288,6.971364513449973e-10,2.635790982270093e-09
48
+ 0.09218436873747494,9.904023970406194e-10,3.6602900015506183e-09
49
+ 0.09418837675350701,1.4029749603481129e-09,5.069277840148117e-09
50
+ 0.09619238476953906,1.9816756203647065e-09,7.00168902983426e-09
51
+ 0.09819639278557113,2.7909990410751105e-09,9.644633280415434e-09
52
+ 0.1002004008016032,3.919506139775224e-09,1.3249358526547692e-08
53
+ 0.10220440881763526,5.488423565612522e-09,1.8152242063629754e-08
54
+ 0.10420841683366733,7.663171964981712e-09,2.4802304971606467e-08
55
+ 0.1062124248496994,1.0668768076183257e-08,3.3797160866164576e-08
56
+ 0.10821643286573146,1.4810332302602684e-08,4.59298325611938e-08
57
+ 0.11022044088176351,2.0500300801736518e-08,6.224952419952071e-08
58
+ 0.11222444889779558,2.82944101012061e-08,8.414025151372406e-08
59
+ 0.11422845691382764,3.893911837562124e-08,1.1342224459407503e-07
60
+ 0.11623246492985971,5.343388202533083e-08,1.5248228799319752e-07
61
+ 0.11823647294589178,7.311265703719015e-08,2.0444070189752082e-07
62
+ 0.12024048096192384,9.975018760690159e-08,2.7336455372629127e-07
63
+ 0.1222444889779559,1.357001346685242e-07,3.645389897460935e-07
64
+ 0.12424849699398796,1.8407394990843946e-07,4.848113695754207e-07
65
+ 0.12625250501002003,2.489716942512104e-07,6.430262628223698e-07
66
+ 0.1282565130260521,3.357788251089053e-07,8.505734289982332e-07
67
+ 0.13026052104208416,4.51546440631731e-07,1.1220757648491e-06
68
+ 0.13226452905811623,6.054766954625332e-07,1.4762499964792424e-06
69
+ 0.1342685370741483,8.095402331803819e-07,1.9369797598863816e-06
70
+ 0.13627254509018036,1.079258677531563e-06,2.534648808824281e-06
71
+ 0.13827655310621242,1.4346926701610636e-06,3.307791581550684e-06
72
+ 0.1402805611222445,1.9016848404743092e-06,4.305129426758945e-06
73
+ 0.14228456913827653,2.5134176679709837e-06,5.588073620348045e-06
74
+ 0.1442885771543086,3.312358693177542e-06,7.233791089023354e-06
75
+ 0.14629258517034066,4.352680211925797e-06,9.338945683108507e-06
76
+ 0.14829659318637273,5.703257724724869e-06,1.2024247090352226e-05
77
+ 0.1503006012024048,7.4513712921553805e-06,1.5439961219356835e-05
78
+ 0.15230460921843686,9.70725685311909e-06,1.9772560242969258e-05
79
+ 0.15430861723446893,1.2609680770604894e-05,2.5252717576508093e-05
80
+ 0.156312625250501,1.6332740632477374e-05,3.216488291679454e-05
81
+ 0.15831663326653306,2.1094128867746906e-05,4.0858705058154114e-05
82
+ 0.16032064128256512,2.7165133199554683e-05,5.176260541308027e-05
83
+ 0.1623246492985972,3.488268942222769e-05,6.539984276835437e-05
84
+ 0.16432865731462926,4.46638474317851e-05,8.240744943771683e-05
85
+ 0.16633266533066132,5.702306069058022e-05,0.00010355846010524495
86
+ 0.16833667334669336,7.259276202955816e-05,0.00012978789657995304
87
+ 0.17034068136272543,9.214774434008349e-05,0.00016222301348118142
88
+ 0.1723446893787575,0.00011663392248786796,0.00020221835038931182
89
+ 0.17434869739478956,0.00014720211161285904,0.00025139617381182765
90
+ 0.17635270541082163,0.0001852475154490919,0.0003116929257361226
91
+ 0.1783567134268537,0.0002324556746281789,0.00038541232258103227
92
+ 0.18036072144288576,0.0002908556769331799,0.0004752857667302997
93
+ 0.18236472945891782,0.00036288147652685667,0.0005845407399461146
94
+ 0.1843687374749499,0.00045144220421335795,0.0007169778409450638
95
+ 0.18637274549098196,0.0005600023722647842,0.0008770571051352291
96
+ 0.18837675350701402,0.0006926728812547926,0.001069994199606469
97
+ 0.1903807615230461,0.0008543137182593631,0.0013018670174151099
98
+ 0.19238476953907813,0.0010506491908946574,0.001579733098405167
99
+ 0.1943887775551102,0.0012883964648413614,0.001911758175670784
100
+ 0.19639278557114226,0.0015754080584277554,0.0023073559838277763
101
+ 0.19839679358717432,0.0019208287911178625,0.0027773392643433326
102
+ 0.2004008016032064,0.0023352674780954493,0.0033340816615201477
103
+ 0.20240480961923846,0.0028309834055797395,0.003991689918215962
104
+ 0.20440881763527052,0.0034220873066473393,0.004766185451682805
105
+ 0.2064128256513026,0.0041247561815975576,0.005675694016739803
106
+ 0.20841683366733466,0.004957460867845528,0.0067406417467994525
107
+ 0.21042084168336672,0.005941204761014531,0.007983955405462883
108
+ 0.2124248496993988,0.007099771522159161,0.00943126418654359
109
+ 0.21442885771543085,0.008459978978904487,0.011111099874427653
110
+ 0.21643286573146292,0.010051935746247456,0.013055091627542955
111
+ 0.21843687374749496,0.01190929636411171,0.01529815108552121
112
+ 0.22044088176352702,0.014069509984906322,0.017878642937637447
113
+ 0.2224448897795591,0.016574056859907017,0.020838535540856733
114
+ 0.22444889779559116,0.019468666086366618,0.024223525656895197
115
+ 0.22645290581162322,0.02280350730926043,0.028083130907804815
116
+ 0.2284569138276553,0.02663334834731371,0.032470743148968764
117
+ 0.23046092184368736,0.03101767006017107,0.03744363564886511
118
+ 0.23246492985971942,0.036020729222779865,0.043062916769054015
119
+ 0.2344689378757515,0.04171155975671698,0.049393422778526784
120
+ 0.23647294589178355,0.048163902420158354,0.05650354253646577
121
+ 0.23847695390781562,0.05545605301265185,0.06446496705801208
122
+ 0.24048096192384769,0.06367061934126443,0.07335235745841497
123
+ 0.24248496993987975,0.07289417765263125,0.08324292546860425
124
+ 0.2444889779559118,0.08321681998907443,0.09421592164253537
125
+ 0.24649298597194386,0.09473158499959693,0.10635202754196812
126
+ 0.24849699398797592,0.10753376614562135,0.11973264958975084
127
+ 0.250501002004008,0.12172009299568277,0.1344391139245762
128
+ 0.25250501002004005,0.13738778340355054,0.15055176345676066
129
+ 0.2545090180360721,0.15463346679947884,0.16814896039728347
130
+ 0.2565130260521042,0.17355198157339297,0.18730599978328283
131
+ 0.25851703406813625,0.19423505255624154,0.2080939419170143
132
+ 0.2605210420841683,0.21676985786568423,0.23057837412787127
133
+ 0.2625250501002004,0.24123749781365952,0.254818114806427
134
+ 0.26452905811623245,0.2677113821040115,0.28086387518659833
135
+ 0.2665330661322645,0.29625555509453905,0.3087568968018246
136
+ 0.2685370741482966,0.32692298236434614,0.33852758484334566
137
+ 0.27054108216432865,0.3597538251131443,0.3701941597304015
138
+ 0.2725450901803607,0.3947737319148945,0.40376135098894383
139
+ 0.2745490981963928,0.4319921799439741,0.439219158953922
140
+ 0.27655310621242485,0.4714008998775606,0.4765417107908142
141
+ 0.2785571142284569,0.5129724201472144,0.5156862378095153
142
+ 0.280561122244489,0.556658766968046,0.5565922009640925
143
+ 0.282565130260521,0.6023903565316393,0.5991805907476412
144
+ 0.28456913827655306,0.6500751148370004,0.643353426373147
145
+ 0.2865731462925851,0.6995978588057171,0.6889934771592876
146
+ 0.2885771543086172,0.7508199695561297,0.7359642264171949
147
+ 0.29058116232464926,0.8035793849952129,0.7841100948750628
148
+ 0.2925851703406813,0.8576909342545682,0.8332569368224597
149
+ 0.2945891783567134,0.9129470310065645,0.8832128177577913
150
+ 0.29659318637274545,0.9691187364297595,0.9337690774577049
151
+ 0.2985971943887775,1.025957195670104,0.9847016771467484
152
+ 0.3006012024048096,1.0831954442012728,1.035772823938131
153
+ 0.30260521042084165,1.1405505726959237,1.0867328600625303
154
+ 0.3046092184368737,1.1977262310562486,1.1373223987347334
155
+ 0.3066132264529058,1.2544154443296005,1.1872746829652807
156
+ 0.30861723446893785,1.3103037055498323,1.236318138349512
157
+ 0.3106212424849699,1.3650723033230885,1.2841790860006974
158
+ 0.312625250501002,1.4184018354200911,1.3305845774738592
159
+ 0.31462925851703405,1.4699758539479106,1.375265309878498
160
+ 0.3166332665330661,1.5194845830391543,1.4179585765167007
161
+ 0.3186372745490982,1.5666286465669512,1.4584112064016364
162
+ 0.32064128256513025,1.611122741307854,1.4963824449860395
163
+ 0.3226452905811623,1.6526991903226573,1.531646728412126
164
+ 0.3246492985971944,1.6911113121621815,1.5639963046067884
165
+ 0.32665330661322645,1.7261365438525893,1.5932436565874413
166
+ 0.3286573146292585,1.7575792594356885,1.6192236863830691
167
+ 0.3306613226452906,1.785273231072943,1.6417956219554208
168
+ 0.33266533066132264,1.8090836862446305,1.6608446143378603
169
+ 0.33466933867735466,1.828908922245337,1.6762829977938332
170
+ 0.3366733466933867,1.844681447803729,1.688051191992681
171
+ 0.3386773547094188,1.8563686310215244,1.696118231871827
172
+ 0.34068136272545085,1.863972842704208,1.7004819178314297
173
+ 0.3426853707414829,1.867531094283545,1.7011685860277417
174
+ 0.344689378757515,1.8671141796580009,1.69823250562009
175
+ 0.34669338677354705,1.8628253401373676,1.6917549167130672
176
+ 0.3486973947895791,1.8547984810263383,1.6818427292564833
177
+ 0.3507014028056112,1.8431959769865154,1.668626909169153
178
+ 0.35270541082164325,1.828206110964348,1.6522605833010546
179
+ 0.3547094188376753,1.8100401979880723,1.6329168994249197
180
+ 0.3567134268537074,1.7889294503730755,1.6107866811588543
181
+ 0.35871743486973945,1.7651216447296125,1.5860759204969326
182
+ 0.3607214428857715,1.7388776535685035,1.5590031524212675
183
+ 0.3627254509018036,1.7104679052316243,1.5297967568712507
184
+ 0.36472945891783565,1.6801688353532405,1.4986922331654766
185
+ 0.3667334669338677,1.6482593911373606,1.4659294908447196
186
+ 0.3687374749498998,1.6150176465185098,1.4317501988904668
187
+ 0.37074148296593185,1.5807175818781543,1.396395232457326
188
+ 0.3727454909819639,1.5456260765775014,1.3601022527328563
189
+ 0.374749498997996,1.5100001563073653,1.3231034514259519
190
+ 0.37675350701402804,1.474084530346467,1.28562348680385
191
+ 0.3787575150300601,1.4381094464550417,1.2478776332793544
192
+ 0.3807615230460922,1.4022888835127203,1.210070161430552
193
+ 0.38276553106212424,1.3668190943412397,1.172392960139806
194
+ 0.38476953907815625,1.3318775036182866,1.1350244074013756
195
+ 0.3867735470941883,1.2976219585605,1.0981284913737968
196
+ 0.3887775551102204,1.2641903232964329,1.0618541785629363
197
+ 0.39078156312625245,1.231700401684364,1.0263350216924791
198
+ 0.3927855711422845,1.2002501678758757,0.9916889959393747
199
+ 0.3947895791583166,1.1699182792594236,0.958018548832444
200
+ 0.39679358717434865,1.1407648425986037,0.9254108462818049
201
+ 0.3987975951903807,1.112832401238175,0.8939381949483017
202
+ 0.4008016032064128,1.0861471091920414,0.8636586194839041
203
+ 0.40280561122244485,1.0607200567359965,0.8346165720721804
204
+ 0.4048096192384769,1.0365487117629029,0.8068437511508948
205
+ 0.406813627254509,1.0136184415729177,0.7803600061733471
206
+ 0.40881763527054105,0.9919040808838283,0.7551743057203656
207
+ 0.4108216432865731,0.9713715135932848,0.7312857471580562
208
+ 0.4128256513026052,0.9519792380991747,0.7086845872922708
209
+ 0.41482965931863724,0.9336798887095376,0.687353275037602
210
+ 0.4168336673346693,0.916421688746433,0.6672674689324295
211
+ 0.4188376753507014,0.9001498142757581,0.6483970243334664
212
+ 0.42084168336673344,0.8848076508891223,0.6307069372463974
213
+ 0.4228456913827655,0.8703379295405492,0.6141582339415318
214
+ 0.4248496993987976,0.8566837310129416,0.5987087977054724
215
+ 0.42685370741482964,0.8437893520980982,0.5843141262473938
216
+ 0.4288577154308617,0.8316010299448056,0.5709280153657016
217
+ 0.4308617234468938,0.8200675242130196,0.5585031664511204
218
+ 0.43286573146292584,0.8091405596254514,0.5469917172274645
219
+ 0.4348697394789579,0.7987751341857312,0.5363456967832286
220
+ 0.4368737474949899,0.7889297007123078,0.5265174074109196
221
+ 0.438877755511022,0.7795662313931161,0.5174597370335539
222
+ 0.44088176352705405,0.7706501767884498,0.5091264070504751
223
+ 0.4428857715430861,0.7621503320802424,0.5014721612780602
224
+ 0.4448897795591182,0.7540386243936669,0.4944529022951423
225
+ 0.44689378757515025,0.7462898356973384,0.4880257819351105
226
+ 0.4488977955911823,0.7388812761295857,0.4821492529066176
227
+ 0.4509018036072144,0.7317924226134483,0.476783088583027
228
+ 0.45290581162324645,0.7250045373293238,0.47188837789382365
229
+ 0.4549098196392785,0.7185002800271241,0.46742750199277716
230
+ 0.4569138276553106,0.7122633273084348,0.46336409898926245
231
+ 0.45891783567134264,0.7062780109132772,0.45966302252356384
232
+ 0.4609218436873747,0.7005289857448328,0.45629029937173454
233
+ 0.4629258517034068,0.6950009368808721,0.45321309059141907
234
+ 0.46492985971943884,0.6896783331991142,0.45039965999535675
235
+ 0.4669338677354709,0.6845452335137351,0.4478193529783445
236
+ 0.468937875751503,0.6795851493298658,0.44544258794731034
237
+ 0.47094188376753504,0.6747809665049481,0.4432408618336446
238
+ 0.4729458917835671,0.6701149263081825,0.4411867704162047
239
+ 0.4749498997995992,0.6655686646307041,0.4392540434728365
240
+ 0.47695390781563124,0.6611233064568744,0.437417594120448
241
+ 0.4789579158316633,0.6567596112045505,0.4356535811143962
242
+ 0.48096192384769537,0.6524581632094107,0.43393948236654395
243
+ 0.48296593186372744,0.648199600498546,0.43225417752088685
244
+ 0.4849699398797595,0.6439648740966423,0.430578037098974
245
+ 0.48697394789579157,0.6397355294550762,0.4288930155050217
246
+ 0.4889779559118236,0.6354940012026951,0.42718274505846915
247
+ 0.49098196392785565,0.6312239122952903,0.4254326282066479
248
+ 0.4929859719438877,0.6269103687858854,0.4236299251531608
249
+ 0.4949899799599198,0.6225402418447766,0.42176383431784353
250
+ 0.49699398797595185,0.6181024293089108,0.41982556331182735
251
+ 0.4989979959919839,0.6135880899151077,0.4178083884572491
252
+ 0.501002004008016,0.6089908444380353,0.41570770129404605
253
+ 0.503006012024048,0.6043069391837624,0.4135210409820103
254
+ 0.5050100200400801,0.59953536863799,0.41124811201146644
255
+ 0.5070140280561122,0.5946779554973937,0.408890787163627
256
+ 0.5090180360721442,0.5897393877760683,0.40645309619677134
257
+ 0.5110220440881763,0.5847272141333031,0.4039412012607508
258
+ 0.5130260521042084,0.5796517999696208,0.4013633605425726
259
+ 0.5150300601202404,0.5745262481405373,0.39872988210724986
260
+ 0.5170340681362725,0.5693662893066337,0.3960530703026532
261
+ 0.5190380761523046,0.5641901479356646,0.39334716743539067
262
+ 0.5210420841683366,0.5590183907705127,0.39062829368246
263
+ 0.5230460921843687,0.5538737651501725,0.38791438837124737
264
+ 0.5250501002004008,0.548781034904795,0.3852251558320365
265
+ 0.5270541082164328,0.5437668216276222,0.38258201899331035
266
+ 0.5290581162324649,0.5388594589550023,0.38000808375101275
267
+ 0.531062124248497,0.5340888670618271,0.3775281168927788
268
+ 0.533066132264529,0.5294864539164046,0.3751685400010804
269
+ 0.5350701402805611,0.5250850489468122,0.37295744129498193
270
+ 0.5370741482965932,0.5209188736772806,0.3709246068055716
271
+ 0.5390781563126252,0.517023552617286,0.3691015716205807
272
+ 0.5410821643286573,0.5134361662586433,0.3675216911893689
273
+ 0.5430861723446894,0.5101953464923151,0.3662202318595356
274
+ 0.5450901803607214,0.5073414131230396,0.36523447893623934
275
+ 0.5470941883767535,0.5049165484776995,0.3646038596268647
276
+ 0.5490981963927856,0.5029650054056016,0.3643700772762992
277
+ 0.5511022044088176,0.5015333422911856,0.36457725232913485
278
+ 0.5531062124248497,0.5006706770778933,0.3652720644948644
279
+ 0.5551102204408818,0.5004289507722327,0.3665038896648002
280
+ 0.5571142284569138,0.5008631894921688,0.36832492425590535
281
+ 0.5591182364729459,0.5020317528802989,0.3707902888662375
282
+ 0.561122244488978,0.5039965556472258,0.3739581024422604
283
+ 0.56312625250501,0.5068232481848783,0.37788951761019524
284
+ 0.565130260521042,0.5105813416136844,0.3826487074378372
285
+ 0.567134268537074,0.5153442623390911,0.3883027936991198
286
+ 0.5691382765531061,0.5211893212160946,0.394921706736229
287
+ 0.5711422845691382,0.5281975827824346,0.4025779672799442
288
+ 0.5731462925851702,0.5364536207424838,0.41134638111986194
289
+ 0.5751503006012023,0.5460451469890959,0.4213036383306786
290
+ 0.5771543086172344,0.5570625029502762,0.4325278098738869
291
+ 0.5791583166332664,0.5695980039510505,0.4450977358142888
292
+ 0.5811623246492985,0.5837451295949232,0.45909230111775945
293
+ 0.5831663326653306,0.5995975558812123,0.4745895970273047
294
+ 0.5851703406813626,0.6172480278719167,0.49166596833050763
295
+ 0.5871743486973947,0.6367870751780841,0.5103949494101399
296
+ 0.5891783567134268,0.6583015763059914,0.5308460947760066
297
+ 0.5911823647294588,0.6818731819415849,0.5530837127641757
298
+ 0.5931863727454909,0.7075766114861076,0.5771655142064759
299
+ 0.595190380761523,0.7354778415067353,0.6031411910494613
300
+ 0.597194388777555,0.7656322091435217,0.6310509430696097
301
+ 0.5991983967935871,0.7980824578046933,0.6609239739026748
302
+ 0.6012024048096192,0.8328567565788658,0.6927769804961385
303
+ 0.6032064128256512,0.8699667285617008,0.7266126627116014
304
+ 0.6052104208416833,0.9094055266122217,0.7624182820530359
305
+ 0.6072144288577154,0.9511459977866357,0.8001643002900507
306
+ 0.6092184368737474,0.9951389797157613,0.8398031299868278
307
+ 0.6112224448897795,1.0413117733765176,0.8812680295644967
308
+ 0.6132264529058116,1.0895668369472948,0.9244721754406201
309
+ 0.6152304609218436,1.1397807446384352,0.9693079429493913
310
+ 0.6172344689378757,1.1918034524836107,1.0156464261113662
311
+ 0.6192384769539078,1.2454579100191507,1.0633372238675751
312
+ 0.6212424849699398,1.3005400525480681,1.1122085171218028
313
+ 0.6232464929859719,1.3568192033113726,1.162067456870044
314
+ 0.625250501002004,1.41403890841391,1.2127008788824982
315
+ 0.627254509018036,1.4719182198732579,1.2638763549150833
316
+ 0.6292585170340681,1.5301534338031102,1.31534358435667
317
+ 0.6312625250501002,1.5884202816663568,1.366836123685862
318
+ 0.6332665330661322,1.6463765629385736,1.4180734442482161
319
+ 0.6352705410821643,1.703665197624979,1.4687633018366753
320
+ 0.6372745490981964,1.759917667120946,1.518604394519497
321
+ 0.6392785571142284,1.8147578021626452,1.5672892782984345
322
+ 0.6412825651302605,1.867805867343381,1.6145075036709886
323
+ 0.6432865731462926,1.9186828831467195,1.6599489301951231
324
+ 0.6452905811623246,1.9670151189261404,1.7033071708818914
325
+ 0.6472945891783567,2.012438683996106,1.7442831138388029
326
+ 0.6492985971943888,2.054604139186858,1.782588465185164
327
+ 0.6513026052104208,2.0931810480665476,1.8179492549907614
328
+ 0.6533066132264529,2.1278623856638346,1.8501092469334648
329
+ 0.655310621242485,2.158368723037075,1.878833192597157
330
+ 0.657314629258517,2.1844521084782347,1.9039098728640091
331
+ 0.6593186372745491,2.2058995704813875,1.9251548716864766
332
+ 0.6613226452905812,2.2225361737966174,1.9424130316125487
333
+ 0.6633266533066132,2.234227567780435,1.955560545702207
334
+ 0.6653306613226453,2.2408819756940423,1.9645066468058892
335
+ 0.6673346693386772,2.242451584342926,1.969194862427897
336
+ 0.6693386773547093,2.2389333052379454,1.9696038114070469
337
+ 0.6713426853707414,2.2303688910008495,1.9657475272176301
338
+ 0.6733466933867734,2.2168444036871486,1.9576753016233712
339
+ 0.6753507014028055,2.1984890447622623,1.9454710514803915
340
+ 0.6773547094188376,2.175473369256488,1.9292522204773435
341
+ 0.6793587174348696,2.1480069188515314,1.9091682362808557
342
+ 0.6813627254509017,2.116335319985943,1.8853985517402039
343
+ 0.6833667334669338,2.0807369032194143,1.858150306283571
344
+ 0.6853707414829658,2.0415189088372108,1.8276556502465149
345
+ 0.6873747494989979,1.9990133507926406,1.7941687804693667
346
+ 0.68937875751503,1.9535726164251122,1.7579627399571292
347
+ 0.691382765531062,1.9055648828622689,1.7193260376428896
348
+ 0.6933867735470941,1.8553694325649066,1.678559146274308
349
+ 0.6953907815631262,1.8033719501268677,1.6359709371451479
350
+ 0.6973947895791582,1.7499598802553165,1.5918751098368535
351
+ 0.6993987975951903,1.6955179229529085,1.546586673374904
352
+ 0.7014028056112224,1.6404237364602805,1.5004185323206218
353
+ 0.7034068136272544,1.585043911696748,1.4536782274295794
354
+ 0.7054108216432865,1.5297302739899066,1.4066648757274716
355
+ 0.7074148296593186,1.474816559051453,1.3596663493604433
356
+ 0.7094188376753506,1.4206155007213292,1.3129567265039528
357
+ 0.7114228456913827,1.3674163582122723,1.2667940411481369
358
+ 0.7134268537074148,1.3154829007137612,1.2214183518856516
359
+ 0.7154308617234468,1.2650518575207053,1.177050143080667
360
+ 0.7174348697394789,1.2163318325407286,1.133889065143408
361
+ 0.719438877755511,1.1695026733430047,1.092113014239726
362
+ 0.721442885771543,1.1247152769878102,1.0518775457473224
363
+ 0.7234468937875751,1.0820918078808504,1.0133156102448784
364
+ 0.7254509018036072,1.041726296918476,0.9765375958937184
365
+ 0.7274549098196392,1.0036855863148866,0.9416316567897426
366
+ 0.7294589178356713,0.9680105807382097,0.9086643033055115
367
+ 0.7314629258517034,0.9347177627653267,0.8776812276123344
368
+ 0.7334669338677354,0.9038009291131673,0.848708335482896
369
+ 0.7354709418837675,0.8752331036100627,0.8217529541234527
370
+ 0.7374749498997996,0.8489685833065309,0.7968051851228609
371
+ 0.7394789579158316,0.8249450754228999,0.7738393716003682
372
+ 0.7414829659318637,0.8030858848585237,0.7528156492263003
373
+ 0.7434869739478958,0.7833021146265098,0.7336815519040486
374
+ 0.7454909819639278,0.7654948447102978,0.7163736444763223
375
+ 0.7474949899799599,0.7495572583275338,0.7008191567646264
376
+ 0.749498997995992,0.7353766883225188,0.6869375954974459
377
+ 0.751503006012024,0.7228365602745556,0.674642313146897
378
+ 0.7535070140280561,0.7118182128057333,0.6638420153053225
379
+ 0.7555110220440882,0.7022025794052763,0.6544421909170067
380
+ 0.7575150300601202,0.6938717197950712,0.6463464523819987
381
+ 0.7595190380761523,0.6867101923613037,0.6394577751990528
382
+ 0.7615230460921844,0.6806062624468893,0.6336796293814927
383
+ 0.7635270541082164,0.6754529442831044,0.6289169973069627
384
+ 0.7655310621242485,0.6711488770314553,0.6250772749283096
385
+ 0.7675350701402806,0.6675990377864991,0.6220710553532244
386
+ 0.7695390781563125,0.6647152964652465,0.6198127956671033
387
+ 0.7715430861723446,0.6624168192773342,0.6182213695367083
388
+ 0.7735470941883766,0.6606303289527298,0.6172205095626023
389
+ 0.7755511022044087,0.6592902311067399,0.6167391445716319
390
+ 0.7775551102204408,0.6583386170805254,0.6167116380405464
391
+ 0.7795591182364728,0.6577251543122363,0.6170779346428212
392
+ 0.7815631262525049,0.6574068758030361,0.6177836225121196
393
+ 0.783567134268537,0.6573478805603151,0.6187799192413522
394
+ 0.785571142284569,0.6575189570469041,0.6200235898903941
395
+ 0.7875751503006011,0.6578971416516028,0.6214768053811571
396
+ 0.7895791583166332,0.6584652240541727,0.6231069496284065
397
+ 0.7915831663326652,0.6592112110840763,0.624886383606185
398
+ 0.7935871743486973,0.6601277602887314,0.6267921742951714
399
+ 0.7955911823647294,0.6612115939489939,0.6288057961198898
400
+ 0.7975951903807614,0.6624629037085883,0.6309128120707755
401
+ 0.7995991983967935,0.6638847553355649,0.6331025412403045
402
+ 0.8016032064128256,0.6654825024252822,0.6353677189927586
403
+ 0.8036072144288576,0.6672632170828393,0.6377041554497294
404
+ 0.8056112224448897,0.669235144812048,0.6401103974241432
405
+ 0.8076152304609218,0.6714071899970202,0.6425873983834004
406
+ 0.8096192384769538,0.6737884374989367,0.6451382004815531
407
+ 0.8116232464929859,0.676387715031428,0.6477676321861426
408
+ 0.813627254509018,0.679213200120185,0.6504820245385811
409
+ 0.81563126252505,0.6822720746286068,0.6532889486501116
410
+ 0.8176352705410821,0.6855702290419339,0.6561969766436362
411
+ 0.8196392785571142,0.6891120179714016,0.6592154679210225
412
+ 0.8216432865731462,0.6929000676694157,0.662354382368093
413
+ 0.8236472945891783,0.6969351357681459,0.6656241219048089
414
+ 0.8256513026052104,0.7012160229445724,0.6690354016533454
415
+ 0.8276553106212424,0.7057395358222179,0.6725991519286783
416
+ 0.8296593186372745,0.7105005001111865,0.6763264522483436
417
+ 0.8316633266533066,0.7154918227921634,0.6802284986116485
418
+ 0.8336673346693386,0.7207046020506988,0.6843166054024172
419
+ 0.8356713426853707,0.726128283666247,0.6886022434121432
420
+ 0.8376753507014028,0.7317508626507082,0.6930971156564557
421
+ 0.8396793587174348,0.7375591290950874,0.6978132728485505
422
+ 0.8416833667334669,0.7435389574149373,0.7027632705851231
423
+ 0.843687374749499,0.7496756384657275,0.7079603704760712
424
+ 0.845691382765531,0.7559542543036417,0.7134187875957992
425
+ 0.8476953907815631,0.7623600956849726,0.719153986721184
426
+ 0.8496993987975952,0.7688791226969803,0.7251830298422215
427
+ 0.8517034068136272,0.775498469169948,0.7315249773553333
428
+ 0.8537074148296593,0.7822069917168534,0.7382013451645357
429
+ 0.8557114228456913,0.7889958643457078,0.745236619593992
430
+ 0.8577154308617234,0.795859219577727,0.7526588315435494
431
+ 0.8597194388777555,0.802794836842528,0.760500190676637
432
+ 0.8617234468937875,0.8098048785987929,0.7687977796010093
433
+ 0.8637274549098196,0.8168966741116016,0.7775943069710873
434
+ 0.8657314629258517,0.8240835500943248,0.7869389172014716
435
+ 0.8677354709418837,0.8313857064698656,0.7968880530158714
436
+ 0.8697394789579158,0.8388311343172881,0.8075063653768866
437
+ 0.8717434869739479,0.8464565716242526,0.8188676634340424
438
+ 0.8737474949899798,0.8543084907812456,0.8310558950142362
439
+ 0.8757515030060119,0.8624441098112167,0.8441661458681016
440
+ 0.877755511022044,0.8709324171531219,0.8583056433994395
441
+ 0.879759519038076,0.8798551974298757,0.8735947479823208
442
+ 0.8817635270541081,0.8893080430483103,0.890167912246936
443
+ 0.8837675350701402,0.8994013337585248,0.9081745859441236
444
+ 0.8857715430861722,0.9102611634751518,0.9277800412462788
445
+ 0.8877755511022043,0.9220301908037077,0.9491660906725363
446
+ 0.8897795591182364,0.9348683869066161,0.972531667336026
447
+ 0.8917835671342684,0.9489536516450743,0.998093234978337
448
+ 0.8937875751503005,0.9644822664728756,1.026084993392246
449
+ 0.8957915831663326,0.981669150423204,1.0567588434463406
450
+ 0.8977955911823646,1.0007478838383796,1.0903840751239902
451
+ 0.8997995991983967,1.0219704633837954,1.1272467418909444
452
+ 0.9018036072144288,1.0456067514687954,1.1676486854232473
453
+ 0.9038076152304608,1.071943583602439,1.2119061763786658
454
+ 0.9058116232464929,1.1012834985720847,1.2603481395619809
455
+ 0.907815631262525,1.1339430587526886,1.313313935619503
456
+ 0.909819639278557,1.1702507314304453,1.3711506763598258
457
+ 0.9118236472945891,1.2105443068596242,1.4342100569813359
458
+ 0.9138276553106212,1.2551678348880546,1.502844695900385
459
+ 0.9158316633266532,1.3044680694417923,1.5774039815025431
460
+ 0.9178356713426853,1.3587904189218305,1.658229434931622
461
+ 0.9198396793587174,1.4184744105811071,1.7456496088656968
462
+ 0.9218436873747494,1.4838486881394444,1.8399745539884929
463
+ 0.9238476953907815,1.5552255740757464,1.9414898973506898
464
+ 0.9258517034068136,1.6328952410506976,2.0504505897866503
465
+ 0.9278557114228456,1.7171195504742778,2.1670743927569647
466
+ 0.9298597194388777,1.8081256300694708,2.2915351880839667
467
+ 0.9318637274549098,1.906099276025142,2.4239562067134197
468
+ 0.9338677354709418,2.011178278644636,2.5644032844839906
469
+ 0.9358717434869739,2.1234457827793554,2.712878263514117
470
+ 0.937875751503006,2.2429238054675404,2.869312666850825
471
+ 0.939879759519038,2.3695670425240483,3.0335617810634092
472
+ 0.9418837675350701,2.503257102995256,3.2053992860803437
473
+ 0.9438877755511021,2.643797314921285,3.384512573526255
474
+ 0.9458917835671342,2.790908247400735,3.5704988936703486
475
+ 0.9478957915831663,2.944224092173787,3.762862466739181
476
+ 0.9498997995991983,3.103290042577511,3.9610126865165545
477
+ 0.9519038076152304,3.267560798604919,4.164263532794353
478
+ 0.9539078156312625,3.4364003138497576,4.371834294364906
479
+ 0.9559118236472945,3.6090828833321296,4.582851685926866
480
+ 0.9579158316633266,3.7847956507863967,4.796353420780448
481
+ 0.9599198396793587,3.9626425901707654,5.011293276747871
482
+ 0.9619238476953907,4.141649989294096,5.2265476658916175
483
+ 0.9639278557114228,4.320773434188221,5.44092368970504
484
+ 0.9659318637274549,4.498906261568964,5.65316863127562
485
+ 0.9679358717434869,4.674889414429088,5.861980804989522
486
+ 0.969939879759519,4.847522602981488,6.066021653553623
487
+ 0.9719438877755511,5.015576640967337,6.2639289520678085
488
+ 0.9739478957915831,5.177806796377369,6.45433095056089
489
+ 0.9759519038076151,5.332966967015229,6.635861260426339
490
+ 0.9779559118236472,5.479824465789392,6.8071742674696685
491
+ 0.9799599198396792,5.617175179056262,6.9669608353617365
492
+ 0.9819639278557113,5.743858844427994,7.113964048960249
493
+ 0.9839679358717434,5.85877418290306,7.246994737612729
494
+ 0.9859719438877754,5.960893614415701,7.364946514632118
495
+ 0.9879759519038075,6.049277286314507,7.466810070977611
496
+ 0.9899799599198396,6.123086151032605,7.551686468756712
497
+ 0.9919839679358716,6.181593842325915,7.618799193575292
498
+ 0.9939879759519037,6.224197118649019,7.667504743720348
499
+ 0.9959919839679358,6.250424667309324,7.697301558388254
500
+ 0.9979959919839678,6.259944093245704,7.707837116036596
501
+ 1.0,6.252566951038547,7.698913066948093
evaluation/query_family/subgroup/support3_vs_profile_analysis/support3_vs_profile_query_density.png ADDED

Git LFS Details

  • SHA256: b22b74806f87b2f229235aed559e005dad9abc1c08261623b754808a94bd8d98
  • Pointer size: 131 Bytes
  • Size of remote file: 164 kB
evaluation/query_family/subgroup/support3_vs_profile_analysis/support3_vs_profile_query_density.tex ADDED
@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
+ \documentclass[tikz,border=4pt]{standalone}
2
+ \usepackage{pgfplots}
3
+ \usepackage{pgfplotstable}
4
+ \pgfplotsset{compat=1.18}
5
+ \definecolor{internalcolor}{HTML}{AA3377}
6
+ \definecolor{sizecolor}{HTML}{009988}
7
+ \begin{document}
8
+ \begin{tikzpicture}
9
+ \begin{axis}[
10
+ width=14.8cm,
11
+ height=8.7cm,
12
+ xmin=0.0, xmax=1.0,
13
+ ymin=0.0, ymax=8.0932,
14
+ xlabel={Query-level support3 score},
15
+ ylabel={Relative density (area = 1)},
16
+ title={Support-oriented subgroup preservation at the query level},
17
+ ymajorgrids,
18
+ grid style={draw=gray!20},
19
+ major grid style={draw=gray!30},
20
+ axis line style={draw=black!70},
21
+ tick style={draw=black!70},
22
+ legend style={draw=none, fill=none, font=\small, at={(0.98,0.98)}, anchor=north east},
23
+ ]
24
+ \addplot[draw=none, fill=internalcolor, fill opacity=0.14]
25
+ table[x=score, y=internal_support3_density, col sep=comma]{support3_density_curves.csv} \closedcycle;
26
+ \addplot[line width=1.9pt, color=internalcolor]
27
+ table[x=score, y=internal_support3_density, col sep=comma]{support3_density_curves.csv};
28
+ \addlegendentry{Internal profile stability}
29
+ \addplot[draw=none, fill=sizecolor, fill opacity=0.14]
30
+ table[x=score, y=size_support3_density, col sep=comma]{support3_density_curves.csv} \closedcycle;
31
+ \addplot[line width=1.9pt, color=sizecolor]
32
+ table[x=score, y=size_support3_density, col sep=comma]{support3_density_curves.csv};
33
+ \addlegendentry{Subgroup size stability}
34
+ \addplot[dashed, line width=1.0pt, color=internalcolor, opacity=0.85]
35
+ coordinates {(0.777030,0) (0.777030,8.0932)};
36
+ \addplot[dashed, line width=1.0pt, color=sizecolor, opacity=0.85]
37
+ coordinates {(0.818445,0) (0.818445,8.0932)};
38
+ \node[
39
+ anchor=north west,
40
+ draw=gray!55,
41
+ fill=white,
42
+ rounded corners=2pt,
43
+ fill opacity=0.96,
44
+ text opacity=1,
45
+ align=left,
46
+ font=\small
47
+ ] at (axis description cs:0.015,0.97) {
48
+ Queries: internal = 13332, size = 9352\\
49
+ Means: internal = 0.777, size = 0.818\\
50
+ Medians: internal = 0.889, size = 1.000
51
+ };
52
+ \end{axis}
53
+ \end{tikzpicture}
54
+ \end{document}