| -,Game,Season,Career | |
| Points,"45 John Conforti vs Wagner (January 10, 1970)",680 Ray Minlend (1998–99),"1,720 Jalen Cannon (2011–15)" | |
| Points Per Game,-,24.3 Ray Minlend (1998–99) 24.3 John Conforti (1968–69),21.3 Dennis McDermott | |
| Rebounds,"37 Al Inniss vs Lafayette (March 17, 1956)",367 Jalen Cannon (2011–15),"1,159 Jalen Cannon (2011–15)" | |
| Assists,"16 Jim Paguaga vs York College (February 7, 1986)",233 Jim Paguaga (1985–86),616 Brent Jones (2011–15) | |
| Steals,"11 Ron Arnold vs Mount St. Mary's (February 4, 1993)",120 Jim Paguaga (1985–86),202 Greg Nunn (1997–01) | |
| Blocked Shots,"11 Richard Lugo vs Rider (February 12, 1997)",125 Richard Lugo (1996–97),244 Julian McKelly (1981–86) | |