| Year Title Role Location Notes | |
| 1983 Cats Cassandra N/A National Tour | |
| 1984 Cats Cassandra Winter Garden Theatre Broadway | |
| 1985-86 Song and Dance Woman in Blue Royale Theatre Broadway | |
| 1988 Carrie Chris Stratford-upon-Avon Royal Shakespeare Company | |
| 1988 Carrie Chris Virginia Theatre Broadway | |
| 1989 Jerome Robbins' Broadway Anita in West Side Story Peter Pan in Peter Pan Company Member in ...Forum Imperial Theatre Broadway | |
| 1995 Damn Yankees Lola Marquis Theatre Broadway (replacement) | |
| 1995 Company Kathy Criterion Center Stage Right Broadway | |
| 1997-2018 Chicago Roxie Hart Ambassador Theatre National tour and Broadway (on-and-off) | |
| 2001-02 Contact Wife Vivian Beaumont Theatre Broadway (replacement) | |
| 2004 Can-Can Claudine New York City Center Encores! | |
| 2005 Sweet Charity Charity Hope Valentine (standby) Minneapolis Chicago Boston Out-of-town tryout | |
| 2005 Sweet Charity Charity Hope Valentine (standby) Al Hirschfeld Theatre Broadway | |
| 2006 A Chorus Line Cassie San Francisco Out-of-town tryout | |
| 2006-08 A Chorus Line Cassie Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre Broadway | |
| 2009 Parade Mrs. Frances Phagan Sally Slaton Mark Taper Forum Los Angeles | |
| 2012-13 Pippin Fastrada American Repertory Theater Out-of-town tryout | |
| 2013-15 Pippin Fastrada Music Box Theatre Broadway | |
| 2015 Carousel Mrs. Mullin Lyric Opera of Chicago Chicago | |