| Year,Title,Role,Notes | |
| 1997,Hercules,Young Hercules (singing voice),- | |
| 1999,The Insider,Seelbach Hotel Manager,- | |
| 2001,Lady and the Tramp II: Scamp's Adventure,Scamp (singing voice),Direct-to-Video | |
| 2004,The Stepford Wives,Roger Bannister,remake of the 1975 film | |
| 2005,The Producers,Carmen Ghia,based on the 1968 musical | |
| 2006,I Want Someone to Eat Cheese With,Burl Cannalo,- | |
| 2007,Hostel: Part II,Stuart,- | |
| 2007,American Gangster,U.S. Attorney,- | |
| 2008,Spy School,Principal Hampton,- | |
| 2008,Harold & Kumar Escape from Guantanamo Bay,Dr. Beecher,- | |
| 2008,The Midnight Meat Train,Jurgis,- | |
| 2009,Law Abiding Citizen,Brian Bringham,- | |
| 2011,One Night Stand,Himself,- | |
| 2012,Excision,Bob,- | |
| 2012,Freaky Deaky,Jerry Baker,- | |
| 2012,A Green Story,Johnson,- | |
| 2012,The Producers,Carmen Ghia,Direct-to-Video | |
| 2012,Smiley,Professor Clayton,- | |
| 2012,The Last Man,Will,Short film | |
| 2013,April Apocalypse,Jack,- | |
| 2013,Last Vegas,Maurice Tischler,- | |
| 2015,Molly,Brad,Short film | |
| 2015,Trumbo,Buddy Ross,- | |
| 2016,Internet Famous,Chris!,- | |
| 2017,Speech & Date,Principal Bellingham,- | |
| 2018,Ghost Light,Henry Asquith,- | |
| 2019,Bayou Tales,Adam,filming | |
| TBA,Butterfly in the Typewriter,Les Phillabaum,pre-production | |
| TBA,Broadway: The Next Generation,Himself,Documentary filming | |