| Name,Year,Weight Class,Place,NCAA Location,High School | |
| Ray Vohden,1952,177,4th,University of Iowa,"Springfield Regional, New Jersey" | |
| Emil Perona,1952,157,4th,University of Iowa,"Newton, New Jersey" | |
| George Mulligan,1955,147,4th,Cornell University,"Bound Brook, New Jersey" | |
| Mike Leta,1960,137,3rd,University of Maryland,"Plainfield, New Jersey" | |
| Ed Scharer,1964,UNL,6th,Cornell University,"Dover, New Jersey" | |
| Tony Surage,1980,150,7th,Oregon State University,"Passaic Valley, New Jersey" | |
| Tony Surage,1983,142,7th,"Oklahoma City, OK","Passaic Valley, New Jersey" | |
| Tom Tanis,2002,184,4th,"Albany, NY","Jefferson, New Jersey" | |
| Anthony Perrotti,2014,157,8th,"Oklahoma City, OK","West Essex, New Jersey" | |
| Anthony Ashnault,2015,141,8th,"St. Louis, MO","South Plainfield, New Jersey" | |
| Anthony Ashnault,2016,141,4th,"New York City, NY","South Plainfield, New Jersey" | |
| Anthony Perrotti,2016,165,8th,"New York City, NY","West Essex, New Jersey" | |
| Anthony Ashnault,2017,141,6th,"St. Louis, MO","South Plainfield, New Jersey" | |
| Kenny Theobold,2017,149,7th,"St. Louis, MO","Toms River South, New Jersey" | |
| Nick Suriano,2018,125,2nd,"Cleveland, OH","Bergen Catholic, New Jersey" | |
| Scott DelVecchio,2018,133,6th,"Cleveland, OH","South Plainfield, New Jersey" | |
| Nick Suriano,2019,133,1st,"Pittsburgh, PA","Bergen Catholic, New Jersey" | |
| Anthony Ashnault,2019,149,1st,"Pittsburgh, PA","South Plainfield, New Jersey" | |