| Year,Film,Role,Director,Notes | |
| 2001,Okénka,-,Joseph Cahill,Short film | |
| 2005,North Country,Ricky Sennett,Niki Caro,- | |
| 2006,Lucky Number Slevin,Saul,Paul McGuigan,- | |
| 2007,The Number 23,Sgt. Burns,Joel Schumacher,- | |
| 2009,Brief Interviews with Hideous Men,Subject #51,John Krasinski,- | |
| 2009,Push,Agent Mack,Paul McGuigan,- | |
| 2010,Helena from the Wedding,Steven,Joseph Infantolino,- | |
| 2010,Salt,Schnaider,Phillip Noyce,- | |
| 2011,Midnight in Paris,Ernest Hemingway,Woody Allen,Nominated—Independent Spirit Award for Best Supporting Male | |
| 2012,The Bourne Legacy,Zev Vendel,Tony Gilroy,- | |
| 2012,The Time Being,Eric,Nenad Cicin-Sain,- | |
| 2012,Victoriana,Bill,Jadrien Steele,- | |
| 2013,C.O.G.,Curly,Kyle Patrick Alvarez,- | |
| 2013,Decoding Annie Parker,Sean,Steven Bernstein,- | |
| 2014,Non-Stop,Austin Reilly,Jaume Collet-Serra,- | |
| 2014,Glass Chin,Bud Gordon,Noah Buschel,- | |
| 2014,This Is Where I Leave You,Paul Altman,Shawn Levy,- | |
| 2014,The Good Lie,Jack,Philippe Falardeau,- | |
| 2015,Dark Places,Ben Day,Gilles Paquet-Brenner,- | |
| 2015,Anesthesia,Sam,Tim Blake Nelson,- | |
| 2015,Ant-Man,Darren Cross / Yellowjacket,Peyton Reed,- | |
| 2015,Black Mass,Fred Wyshak,Scott Cooper,- | |
| 2016,Café Society,Ben,Woody Allen,- | |
| 2016,Gold,Brian Wolff,Stephen Gaghan,- | |
| 2018,The Seagull,Boris Trigorin,Michael Mayer,- | |
| 2018,First Man,Buzz Aldrin,Damien Chazelle,- | |
| 2018,Driven,Benedict Tisa,Nick Hamm,- | |
| 2019,The Report,Cyrus Clifford,Scott Z. Burns,- | |
| 2020,The Many Saints of Newark,-,Alan Taylor,Filming | |