| Year Goalkeeper Defenders Forwards | |
| 1970 Bill Nuttall (Davis & Elkins) Buzz Demling (Michigan State) Alan Harte (Quincy University) Nick Iwanik (UIC) Gerardo Pagnani (Eastern Illinois) Aladin Rodrigues (San Jose State) Al Henderson (Howard) Richard Parkinson (Akron) Randy Smith (Buffalo State) Stan Startzell (Penn) Al Trost (Saint Louis) | |
| 1971 Cal Kern (Buffalo State) Alan Harte* (Quincy University) Gerardo Pagnani* (Eastern Illinois) John Schneider (Quincy University) Andy Smiles (Ohio) William Smyth (Davis & Elkins) Keith Aqui (Howard) Al Henderson* (Howard) Richard Parkinson* (Akron) Mike Seerey (Saint Louis) John Moore (Brockport) | |
| 1972 Bob Rigby (East Stroudsburg) Chris Bahr (Penn State) Gordon Cholmondeley (Philadelphia) Alan Harte* (Quincy University) Gerardo Pagnani* (Eastern Illinois) Hans Wango (Davis & Elkins) Ian Bain (Howard) Eugene Durham (Philadelphia Textile) Tom Kazembe (Wooster) Chris Papagianis (Harvard) Andy Rymarczuk (Penn State) | |
| 1973 Frank Tusinski (UMSL) David D'Errico (Hartwick) Kip Jordan (Cornell) Kevin Missey (UMSL) Farrukh Quraishi (Oneonta State) Ferdinand Treusacher (Brown) Henry Abadi (Clemson) Chris Bahr* (Penn State) Steve Baumann (Penn) Dale Russell (Philadelphia Textile) Tom Kazembe* (Wooster) | |
| 1974 Peter Mannos (NIU) Jesse Cox (Loyola) Bruce Hudson (Saint Louis) John Nusum (Philadelphia Textile) Farrukh Quraishi* (Oneonta State) Mickey Rooney (Keene State) Chris Bahr* (Penn State) Frantz Innocent (UConn) Tom Kazembe* (Wooster) Dale Russell* (Philadelphia Textile) Fred Pereira (Brown) | |
| 1975 Peter Mannos* (NIU) Sam Bick (Quincy University) Nimrod Dreyfus (Adelphi) Greg Makowski (SIUE) John Nusum* (Philadelphia Textile) Dale Rothe (Baltimore) Carlos Merchan (Fairleigh Dickinson) George Nanchoff (Akron) Steve Ralbovsky (Brown) Dale Russell* (Philadelphia Textile) Elson Seale (Philadelphia Textile) | |
| 1976 Dragan Radovich (St. Francis) Carl Christensen (Vermont) George Gorleku (Eastern Illinois) Paul Hunter (UConn) Greg Makowski* (SIUE) Glenn Myernick (Hartwick) Andy Atuegbu (San Francisco) Ty Keough (Saint Louis) George Nanchoff* (Akron) Louis Nanchoff (Akron) Fred Perira* (Brown) | |
| 1977 Dragan Radovich* (St. Francis) Greg Makowski* (SIUE) John Nusum* (Philadelphia Textile) Adrian Brooks (Philadelphia Textile) Herve Guilliod (Fredonia) Billy Gazonas (Hartwick) Angelo DiBernardo (Indiana) Emilio John (Quincy University) Paul Milone (Princeton) John Maciel (Western Illinois) Rich Reice (Penn State) | |
| 1978 Dragan Radovich* (St. Francis) George Gorleku* (Eastern Illinois) Adrian Brooks* (Philadelphia Textile) Greg Ryan (SMU) Ty Keough* (Saint Louis) Barry Nix (Columbia) Raymond Ford (UM-Baltimore) George Lesyw (Temple) Peter Notaro (Loyola) Jim Stamatis (Penn State) Ole Mikkelsen (UCLA) | |
| 1979 Randy Phillips (SMU) Saeid Baghvardani (SMU) Mike Freitag (Indiana) Barry Nix* (Columbia) Gerry Reardon (Adelphi) John Young (Hartwick) Armando Betancourt (Indiana) Steve Charles (Columbia) Clyde O'Garro (St. Francis) Ray Taylor (Western Illinois) | |
| 1980 Randy Phillips* (SMU) Saeid Baghvardani* (SMU) Tim Gagan (Lock Haven) Erhardt Kapp (UConn) Joe Morrone (Jr.) (UConn) Kevin Murphy (Rhode Island) Trevor Adair (Lock Haven) Chico Borja (NJIT) Damien Kelly (Eastern Illinois) Kemal Khilian (SMU) Robert Meschbach (Indiana) | |
| 1981 Skip Gilbert (Vermont) Dan Canter (Penn State) Richard Chinapoo (LIU Brooklyn) Tom Groark (SIUE) Tom McDonald (Philadelphia Textile) Barry Nix* (Columbia) Armando Betancourt* (Indiana) Pedro DeBrito (UConn) John Hayes (Saint Louis) Damien Kelly* (Eastern Illinois) Agyeman Prempeh (Eastern Illinois) | |
| 1982 Skip Gilbert* (Vermont) Lou Karbiener (Penn State) Erik Nelson (San Francisco) Adubarie Otorubio* (Clemson) Joe Ulrich (Duke) Matthew English (Akron) Tom Killeen (Philadelphia Textile) Kevin Maher (Yale) Steve McLean (Philadelphia Textile) Neil Ridgway (Bowling Green) Roy Wegerle (South Florida) | |