| Year,Nominated work,Category,Result | |
| 1973,The Sting,Best Actor,Nominated | |
| 1980,Ordinary People,Best Director,Won | |
| 1994,Quiz Show,Best Picture,Nominated | |
| 1994,Quiz Show,Best Director,Nominated | |
| 2001,N/A,Lifetime Achievement Award,Won | |
| Year,Nominated work,Category,Result | |
| 1973,The Sting,Best Actor,Nominated | |
| 1980,Ordinary People,Best Director,Won | |
| 1994,Quiz Show,Best Picture,Nominated | |
| 1994,Quiz Show,Best Director,Nominated | |
| 2001,N/A,Lifetime Achievement Award,Won | |