| Year,Award,Category,Title,Result | |
| 2010,Vision Fest,Best Acting – Female Lead,Consent,Won | |
| 2010,Philadelphia First Glance Film Festival,Best Actress,Consent,Won | |
| 2011,Young Hollywood Awards,"Cast to Watch (shared with Ashley Benson, Lucy Hale and Shay Mitchell)",Pretty Little Liars,Won | |
| 2011,Teen Choice Awards,Choice Summer TV Star: Female,Pretty Little Liars,Nominated | |
| 2012,Teen Choice Awards,Choice Summer TV Star: Female,Pretty Little Liars,Won | |
| 2013,New York Festivals,Best Performance by an Actress,Lauren,Won | |
| 2013,Streamy Award,Best Female Performance – Drama,Lauren,Nominated | |
| 2013,Teen Choice Awards,Choice TV Actress: Drama,Pretty Little Liars,Won | |
| 2014,IAWTV Award,Best Female Performance – Drama,Lauren,Nominated | |