| Year Title Role Notes | |
| 1997 Hercules Young Hercules (singing voice) - | |
| 1999 The Insider Seelbach Hotel Manager - | |
| 2001 Lady and the Tramp II: Scamp's Adventure Scamp (singing voice) Direct-to-Video | |
| 2004 The Stepford Wives Roger Bannister remake of the 1975 film | |
| 2005 The Producers Carmen Ghia based on the 1968 musical | |
| 2006 I Want Someone to Eat Cheese With Burl Cannalo - | |
| 2007 Hostel: Part II Stuart - | |
| 2007 American Gangster U.S. Attorney - | |
| 2008 Spy School Principal Hampton - | |
| 2008 Harold & Kumar Escape from Guantanamo Bay Dr. Beecher - | |
| 2008 The Midnight Meat Train Jurgis - | |
| 2009 Law Abiding Citizen Brian Bringham - | |
| 2011 One Night Stand Himself - | |
| 2012 Excision Bob - | |
| 2012 Freaky Deaky Jerry Baker - | |
| 2012 A Green Story Johnson - | |
| 2012 The Producers Carmen Ghia Direct-to-Video | |
| 2012 Smiley Professor Clayton - | |
| 2012 The Last Man Will Short film | |
| 2013 April Apocalypse Jack - | |
| 2013 Last Vegas Maurice Tischler - | |
| 2015 Molly Brad Short film | |
| 2015 Trumbo Buddy Ross - | |
| 2016 Internet Famous Chris! - | |
| 2017 Speech & Date Principal Bellingham - | |
| 2018 Ghost Light Henry Asquith - | |
| 2019 Bayou Tales Adam filming | |
| TBA Butterfly in the Typewriter Les Phillabaum pre-production | |
| TBA Broadway: The Next Generation Himself Documentary filming | |