| Year Film Role Awards | |
| 1952 Viva Zapata! Eufemio Zapata Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor | |
| 1956 Lust for Life Paul Gauguin Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor Nominated—Golden Globe Award for Best Supporting Actor – Motion Picture | |
| 1957 Wild Is the Wind Gino Nominated—Academy Award for Best Actor | |
| 1962 Lawrence of Arabia Auda abu Tayi Nominated—Golden Globe Award for Best Actor - Motion Picture Drama | |
| 1964 Zorba the Greek Alexis Zorba National Board of Review Award for Best Actor Nominated—Academy Award for Best Actor Nominated—BAFTA Award for Best Foreign Actor Nominated—Golden Globe Award for Best Actor – Motion Picture Drama | |
| 1969 The Secret of Santa Vittoria Italio Bombolini Nominated—Golden Globe Award for Best Actor - Motion Picture Musical or Comedy | |
| 1987 - - Golden Globe Cecil B. DeMille Award | |
| 1992 Mobsters Joe Masseria Nominated—Golden Raspberry Award for Worst Supporting Actor | |
| 1996 Gotti Aniello Dellacroce Nominated—Golden Globe Award for Best Supporting Actor - Series, Miniseries or Television Film Nominated—Satellite Award for Best Supporting Actor - Series, Miniseries or Television Film | |