| Year Production Role Notes Ref. | |
| 2003 Top Girls Marlene Guthrie Theater, Minneapolis, MN - | |
| 2003 Pride and Prejudice Elizabeth Bennet Guthrie Theater, Minneapolis, MN - | |
| 2004 Pygmalion Eliza Doolittle Guthrie Theater, Minneapolis, MN - | |
| 2004 Mr. Fox: A Rumination Columbine/Mattie/Young Woman/Maffitt Signature Theatre Company (Peter Norton Space, Off-Broadway) - | |
| 2005 As You Like It Rosalind Guthrie Theater, Minneapolis, MN - | |
| 2006 The Importance of Being Earnest Gwendolen Fairfax Brooklyn Academy of Music (BAM Harvey Theater, Brooklyn, NY) - | |
| 2006–07 The Coast of Utopia (Part 1: Voyage) Miss Chamberlain Vivian Beaumont Theater (Broadway) - | |
| 2006–07 The Coast of Utopia (Part 2: Shipwreck) Emma Herwegh Vivian Beaumont Theater (Broadway) - | |
| 2007 The Coast of Utopia (Part 3: Salvage) Joanna Kinkel Vivian Beaumont Theater (Broadway) - | |
| 2007 Trumpery Emma Atlantic Theater Company (Linda Gross Theater, Off-Broadway) - | |
| 2010 A Midsummer Night's Dream Titania/Hippolyta Pittsburgh Public Theater (O'Reilly Theater, Pittsburgh, PA) - | |
| 2010 The Taming of the Shrew Katharina Chicago Shakespeare Theater (Courtyard Theater, Chicago, IL) - | |
| 2012 The Broken Heart Calantha Theatre for a New Audience (The Duke on 42nd Street, Off-Broadway) - | |
| 2012 Private Lives Amanda Huntington Theatre Company (Boston, MA); Elliot Norton Award; IRNE Award nomination - | |
| 2013 Neva Olga Knipper Joseph Papp Public Theater (Anspacher Theater, Off-Broadway) - | |
| 2013–14 Macbeth Lady Macduff Vivian Beaumont Theater (Broadway) - | |
| 2014 King Lear Regan Theatre for a New Audience (Polonsky Shakespeare Center, Brooklyn, NY) - | |
| 2014 Private Lives Amanda Shakespeare Theatre Company (Lansburgh Theatre, Washington, D. C.); Emery Battis Award - | |
| 2014 Shakespeare at Fenway Beatrice/Much Ado About Nothing Commonwealth Shakespeare Company (Fenway Park, Boston, MA) - | |
| 2016 Stupid Fucking Bird Emma Arkadina (The Seagull) Pearl Theatre, Manhattan - | |