| Year | Title | Label | Comments |
| 1967 | West Side Soul | Delmark | Recorded Chicago, 1967 |
| 1968 | Black Magic | Delmark | Recorded Chicago, 1968 |
| 1969 | Raw Blues Live 1969 | Rock Beat Records | Recorded in Berkeley, Calif., 1969 |
| 1980 | The Late Great Magic Sam | L+R | Recorded 1963–64, 1969 |
| 1981 | Magic Sam Live | Delmark | Recorded live in Chicago, 1963–64, and Ann Arbor, 1969 |
| 1981 | Magic Touch | Black Magic | Recorded live in Chicago, 1966 |
| 1989 | The Magic Sam Legacy | Delmark | Outtakes and alternate takes recorded in Chicago, 1966–68 |
| 1991 | Give Me Time | Delmark | Solo demo and rehearsal home recordings, 1968 |
| 2001 | With a Feeling – The Complete Cobra, Chief & Crash Recordings 1957–1966 | Westside | Most pre-Delmark recordings; also available as Out of Luck, P-Vine, 2003 |
| 2002 | Rockin' Wild in Chicago | Delmark | Recorded live in Chicago, 1963, 1964, 1966, 1968 |
| 2008 | Genius: The Final Sessions | Intermedia | Previously unreleased |
| 2013 | Live at the Avant Garde June 22, 1968 | Delmark | Recorded live at the Avant Garde coffeehouse, Milwaukee, June 22, 1968 |