| Year | Goalkeeper | Defenders | Forwards |
| 1970 | Bill Nuttall (Davis & Elkins) | Buzz Demling (Michigan State) Alan Harte (Quincy University) Nick Iwanik (UIC) Gerardo Pagnani (Eastern Illinois) Aladin Rodrigues (San Jose State) | Al Henderson (Howard) Richard Parkinson (Akron) Randy Smith (Buffalo State) Stan Startzell (Penn) Al Trost (Saint Louis) |
| 1971 | Cal Kern (Buffalo State) | Alan Harte* (Quincy University) Gerardo Pagnani* (Eastern Illinois) John Schneider (Quincy University) Andy Smiles (Ohio) William Smyth (Davis & Elkins) | Keith Aqui (Howard) Al Henderson* (Howard) Richard Parkinson* (Akron) Mike Seerey (Saint Louis) John Moore (Brockport) |
| 1972 | Bob Rigby (East Stroudsburg) | Chris Bahr (Penn State) Gordon Cholmondeley (Philadelphia) Alan Harte* (Quincy University) Gerardo Pagnani* (Eastern Illinois) Hans Wango (Davis & Elkins) | Ian Bain (Howard) Eugene Durham (Philadelphia Textile) Tom Kazembe (Wooster) Chris Papagianis (Harvard) Andy Rymarczuk (Penn State) |
| 1973 | Frank Tusinski (UMSL) | David D'Errico (Hartwick) Kip Jordan (Cornell) Kevin Missey (UMSL) Farrukh Quraishi (Oneonta State) Ferdinand Treusacher (Brown) | Henry Abadi (Clemson) Chris Bahr* (Penn State) Steve Baumann (Penn) Dale Russell (Philadelphia Textile) Tom Kazembe* (Wooster) |
| 1974 | Peter Mannos (NIU) | Jesse Cox (Loyola) Bruce Hudson (Saint Louis) John Nusum (Philadelphia Textile) Farrukh Quraishi* (Oneonta State) Mickey Rooney (Keene State) | Chris Bahr* (Penn State) Frantz Innocent (UConn) Tom Kazembe* (Wooster) Dale Russell* (Philadelphia Textile) Fred Pereira (Brown) |
| 1975 | Peter Mannos* (NIU) | Sam Bick (Quincy University) Nimrod Dreyfus (Adelphi) Greg Makowski (SIUE) John Nusum* (Philadelphia Textile) Dale Rothe (Baltimore) | Carlos Merchan (Fairleigh Dickinson) George Nanchoff (Akron) Steve Ralbovsky (Brown) Dale Russell* (Philadelphia Textile) Elson Seale (Philadelphia Textile) |
| 1976 | Dragan Radovich (St. Francis) | Carl Christensen (Vermont) George Gorleku (Eastern Illinois) Paul Hunter (UConn) Greg Makowski* (SIUE) Glenn Myernick (Hartwick) | Andy Atuegbu (San Francisco) Ty Keough (Saint Louis) George Nanchoff* (Akron) Louis Nanchoff (Akron) Fred Perira* (Brown) |
| 1977 | Dragan Radovich* (St. Francis) | Greg Makowski* (SIUE) John Nusum* (Philadelphia Textile) Adrian Brooks (Philadelphia Textile) Herve Guilliod (Fredonia) Billy Gazonas (Hartwick) | Angelo DiBernardo (Indiana) Emilio John (Quincy University) Paul Milone (Princeton) John Maciel (Western Illinois) Rich Reice (Penn State) |
| 1978 | Dragan Radovich* (St. Francis) | George Gorleku* (Eastern Illinois) Adrian Brooks* (Philadelphia Textile) Greg Ryan (SMU) Ty Keough* (Saint Louis) Barry Nix (Columbia) | Raymond Ford (UM-Baltimore) George Lesyw (Temple) Peter Notaro (Loyola) Jim Stamatis (Penn State) Ole Mikkelsen (UCLA) |
| 1979 | Randy Phillips (SMU) | Saeid Baghvardani (SMU) Mike Freitag (Indiana) Barry Nix* (Columbia) Gerry Reardon (Adelphi) John Young (Hartwick) | Armando Betancourt (Indiana) Steve Charles (Columbia) Clyde O'Garro (St. Francis) Ray Taylor (Western Illinois) |
| 1980 | Randy Phillips* (SMU) | Saeid Baghvardani* (SMU) Tim Gagan (Lock Haven) Erhardt Kapp (UConn) Joe Morrone (Jr.) (UConn) Kevin Murphy (Rhode Island) | Trevor Adair (Lock Haven) Chico Borja (NJIT) Damien Kelly (Eastern Illinois) Kemal Khilian (SMU) Robert Meschbach (Indiana) |
| 1981 | Skip Gilbert (Vermont) | Dan Canter (Penn State) Richard Chinapoo (LIU Brooklyn) Tom Groark (SIUE) Tom McDonald (Philadelphia Textile) Barry Nix* (Columbia) | Armando Betancourt* (Indiana) Pedro DeBrito (UConn) John Hayes (Saint Louis) Damien Kelly* (Eastern Illinois) Agyeman Prempeh (Eastern Illinois) |
| 1982 | Skip Gilbert* (Vermont) | Lou Karbiener (Penn State) Erik Nelson (San Francisco) Adubarie Otorubio* (Clemson) Joe Ulrich (Duke) | Matthew English (Akron) Tom Killeen (Philadelphia Textile) Kevin Maher (Yale) Steve McLean (Philadelphia Textile) Neil Ridgway (Bowling Green) Roy Wegerle (South Florida) |