| | Year Award Category Nominee Result Refs
|
| | 2014 Leo Awards Best Lead Performance by a Female in a Dramatic Series Emily Bett Rickards Nominated -
|
| | 2014 Teen Choice Awards Female Breakout Star Emily Bett Rickards Nominated -
|
| | 2015 Leo Awards Best Guest Performance by a Female in a Dramatic Series Emily Bett Rickards (The Flash) Nominated -
|
| | 2015 Leo Awards Best Lead Performance by a Female in a Dramatic Series Emily Bett Rickards Nominated -
|
| | 2015 MTV Fandom Awards Ship of the Year Emily Bett Rickards & Stephen Amell Won -
|
| | 2015 Teen Choice Awards Choice TV Actress - Fantasy/Sci-Fi Emily Bett Rickards Nominated -
|
| | 2015 Teen Choice Awards Choice TV Liplock Emily Bett Rickards & Stephen Amell Nominated -
|
| | 2016 Leo Awards Best Lead Performance by a Female in a Dramatic Series Emily Bett Rickards Nominated -
|
| | 2016 MTV Fandom Awards Ship of the Year Emily Bett Rickards & Stephen Amell Won -
|
| | 2016 Teen Choice Awards Choice TV Actress - Fantasy/Sci-Fi Emily Bett Rickards Nominated -
|
| | 2016 Teen Choice Awards Choice TV Liplock Emily Bett Rickards and Stephen Amell Nominated -
|
| | 2017 Leo Awards Best Lead Performance by a Female in a Dramatic Series Emily Bett Rickards Nominated -
|
| | 2017 Teen Choice Awards Choice TV Actress - Action Emily Bett Rickards Nominated -
|
| | 2018 Teen Choice Awards Choice TV Actress - Action Emily Bett Rickards Nominated -
|
| | 2018 Teen Choice Awards Choice TV Ship Emily Bett Rickards & Stephen Amell Nominated -
|
| |
|
