YearAwardCategoryWorkResult
1970Tony AwardBest Performance by a Featured Actor in a MusicalCocoNominated
1974Drama Desk AwardOutstanding PerformanceMy Fat FriendWon
1974Outer Critics Circle AwardOutstanding Actor in a MusicalMy Fat FriendWon
1975Tony AwardBest Performance by a Featured Actor in a PlayMy Fat FriendNominated
1976Tony AwardBest Performance by a Leading Actor in a MusicalMy Fair LadyWon
1976Drama Desk AwardOutstanding Featured Actor in a MusicalMy Fair LadyWon
1977Drama Desk AwardOutstanding Featured Actor in a MusicalShe Loves MeNominated
1979Drama Desk AwardOutstanding Featured Actor in a PlayThe KingfisherWon
1981Tony AwardBest Performance by a Leading Actor in a MusicalThe Pirates of PenzanceNominated
1981Drama Desk AwardOutstanding Actor in a MusicalThe Pirates of PenzanceNominated
1986Tony AwardBest Performance by a Leading Actor in a MusicalDroodWon
1986Drama Desk AwardOutstanding Actor in a MusicalDroodWon