| | | Name | Animal Type | Introduced | Reintroduced | Retired | Beanie Baby Resembled | |
| | | Antlers | Moose | | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Chocolate | |
| | | Baba | Lamb | | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Fleece | |
| | | Bruiser | Bulldog | 1997 | | | Wrinkles | |
| | | Carrots | Bunny | | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Ears, but pink instead of brown | |
| | | Chewy | | | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | | |
| | | Clover | Bunny | 1998 | | | Ears, but white instead of brown | |
| | | Foxy | Fox | | | | Sly | |
| | | Glide | Porpoise | | | | Echo the Dolphin | |
| | | Huggy | Bear | 1995 | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Cubbie, but yellow instead of brown | |
| | | Meow | Cat | 1997 | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Snip | |
| | | Moo | Cow | 1995 | | | Daisy, but with white body instead of black | |
| | | Oink | Pig | 1995 | | | Squealer | |
| | | Paddles | Platypus | | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Patti | |
| | | Purr | Tiger | | | | Stripes, but yellow-orange instead of orange-black | |
| | | Red | Bull | | | | Snort | |
| | | Ribbit (All-Green) | Frog | 1995 | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Legs | |
| | | Ribbit (Green-Yellow) | Frog | | | | Smoochy | |
| | | Sherbert | Tie-Dye Bear | 1998 | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Sammy | |
| | | Snap (All-Yellow) | Turtle | 1995 | | | Speedy, but yellow instead of green | |
| | | Snap (Yellow-Green) | Turtle | | 1999 (neon) | | Peekaboo | |
| | | Snuggy | Bear | 1995 | | | Cubbie, but pink instead of brown | |
| | | Sparkler | Bear | | | 1999 | Spangle | |
| | | Speckles | Leopard | | | | Freckles | |
| | | Spotty | Dalmatian | | | | Dotty | |
| | | Squirt | Elephant | | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Peanut | |
| | | Swinger | Monkey | | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Bongo | |
| | | Tide | Whale | | | | Splash | |
| | | Tubby | Hippopotamus | | | | Happy | |
| | | Woof | Dog | 1995 | 1999 (neon) | 1999 | Bones | |
| | | Zulu | Zebra | | | | Ziggy, but pink-green instead of black-white | |
| |
|
