| | Name Animal Type Introduced Reintroduced Retired Beanie Baby Resembled |
| | Antlers Moose 1999 (neon) 1999 Chocolate |
| | Baba Lamb 1999 (neon) 1999 Fleece |
| | Bruiser Bulldog 1997 Wrinkles |
| | Carrots Bunny 1999 (neon) 1999 Ears, but pink instead of brown |
| | Chewy 1999 (neon) 1999 |
| | Clover Bunny 1998 Ears, but white instead of brown |
| | Foxy Fox Sly |
| | Glide Porpoise Echo the Dolphin |
| | Huggy Bear 1995 1999 (neon) 1999 Cubbie, but yellow instead of brown |
| | Meow Cat 1997 1999 (neon) 1999 Snip |
| | Moo Cow 1995 Daisy, but with white body instead of black |
| | Oink Pig 1995 Squealer |
| | Paddles Platypus 1999 (neon) 1999 Patti |
| | Purr Tiger Stripes, but yellow-orange instead of orange-black |
| | Red Bull Snort |
| | Ribbit (All-Green) Frog 1995 1999 (neon) 1999 Legs |
| | Ribbit (Green-Yellow) Frog Smoochy |
| | Sherbert Tie-Dye Bear 1998 1999 (neon) 1999 Sammy |
| | Snap (All-Yellow) Turtle 1995 Speedy, but yellow instead of green |
| | Snap (Yellow-Green) Turtle 1999 (neon) Peekaboo |
| | Snuggy Bear 1995 Cubbie, but pink instead of brown |
| | Sparkler Bear 1999 Spangle |
| | Speckles Leopard Freckles |
| | Spotty Dalmatian Dotty |
| | Squirt Elephant 1999 (neon) 1999 Peanut |
| | Swinger Monkey 1999 (neon) 1999 Bongo |
| | Tide Whale Splash |
| | Tubby Hippopotamus Happy |
| | Woof Dog 1995 1999 (neon) 1999 Bones |
| | Zulu Zebra Ziggy, but pink-green instead of black-white |
| | |
