Datasets:
| Year Champion Score Runner-up Coach | |
| 1954 Boston College 4–1 Harvard John "Snooks" Kelley | |
| 1956 Boston College 4–2 Harvard John "Snooks" Kelley | |
| 1957 Boston College 5–4 (OT) Boston University John "Snooks" Kelley | |
| 1959 Boston College 7–4 Boston University John "Snooks" Kelley | |
| 1961 Boston College 4–2 Harvard John "Snooks" Kelley | |
| 1963 Boston College 3–1 Harvard John "Snooks" Kelley | |
| 1964 Boston College 6–5 Boston University John "Snooks" Kelley | |
| 1965 Boston College 5–4 Boston University John "Snooks" Kelley | |
| 1976 Boston College 6–3 Boston University Len Ceglarski | |
| 1983 Boston College 8–2 Northeastern Len Ceglarski | |
| 1994 Boston College 2–1 (OT) Harvard Steve Cedorchuck | |
| 2001 Boston College 5–3 Boston University Jerry York | |
| 2004 Boston College 2–1 (OT) Boston University Jerry York | |
| 2008 Boston College 6–5 (OT) Harvard Jerry York | |
| 2010 Boston College 4–3 Boston University Jerry York | |
| 2011 Boston College 7–6 (OT) Northeastern Jerry York | |
| 2012 Boston College 3–2 (OT) Boston University Jerry York | |
| 2013 Boston College 6–3 Northeastern Jerry York | |
| 2014 Boston College 4–1 Northeastern Jerry York | |