"Rank","Name","Caps","Goals","Years"
"1","Bedford Jezzard","3","6","1954–1955"
"2","Tommy Taylor","2","4","1956"
"=","Gordon Hill","6","4","1978"
"=","Alan Smith","4","4","1990–1992"
"5","Jack Rowley","1","3","1949"
"=","Brian Talbot","6","3","1978–1980"
"=","Paul Merson","4","3","1991–1998"
"=","Matthew le Tissier","6","3","1990–1998"