Update study dataset (4 files)

Exported by scripts/figures.mjs on the dashboard's default task selection.

README.md

@@ -0,0 +1,43 @@
+---
+license: cc-by-4.0
+tags: [human-study, web-agents, grounding, hci]
+---
+
+# PageGuide user study — results
+
+One row per answered task from the PageGuide web study, on the task selection the analysis
+dashboard uses by default. `rows.csv` is the row-level data; the two `behavior_*.csv` files are
+the aggregates plotted in the figures (mean, sd, se and n per cell).
+
+Exported 2026-08-13T21:34:43.581Z · 199 rows · 38 participants.
+
+## Conditions
+
+Every participant sees both arms, interleaved task by task:
+
+- `nongrounding` — the agent reports an answer with no evidence attached.
+- `grounding` — the same claims, with citations into the page and saved image crops.
+
+## Task selection
+
+Some tasks are excluded from their card by default. The figures and these files use the same
+selection, so they agree with the dashboard:
+
+| Facet | Left out | Why |
+|---|---|---|
+| Find × Text | MARS-v1, MUFC-V1-TEXT | a disputed answer key, and the page already read in Find × Visual |
+| Guide × Text | gv2-ed05a7b6-kk24zp, gv2-ms9iw0pq-5kj5zr, gv2-msf02a2n-88li4p, gv2-msf5mo9m-qm5brt | three duplicate re-recordings, plus both recordings of the New York goal |
+| Guide × Visual | gv2-msf1pyqv-omt0hz | a run whose ground truth blames one step under two error types, so no participant can score it in full |
+
+## What is not here
+
+Participants' free-text notes are omitted, and session ids are replaced with a per-export
+`participant` integer. Both are deliberate: the notes are the only column that can carry
+something about a person rather than about a task.
+
+## Scoring
+
+Localization quality is F1. For Find it is over the passages picked; for Guide it is the mean of
+an F1 over the error types named and an F1 over the steps blamed, with a correct "no error"
+scoring in full on a run that contains none. A null precision means the participant predicted
+nothing, which is zero true positives, so its F1 is 0 rather than missing.

behavior_by_facet.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,49 @@
+facet,metric,condition,n,mean,sd,se
+Find × Text,Scroll count,Non-grounded,22,8.0909,7.9875,1.7030
+Find × Text,Scroll count,Grounded,20,10.3500,6.7922,1.5188
+Find × Visual,Scroll count,Non-grounded,32,17.5000,15.0354,2.6579
+Find × Visual,Scroll count,Grounded,33,23.6061,23.2311,4.0440
+Guide × Text,Scroll count,Non-grounded,16,10.2500,7.2618,1.8154
+Guide × Text,Scroll count,Grounded,25,12.8000,8.4261,1.6852
+Guide × Visual,Scroll count,Non-grounded,24,9.4583,7.6214,1.5557
+Guide × Visual,Scroll count,Grounded,27,11.9259,8.3938,1.6154
+Find × Text,Ctrl+F,Non-grounded,22,1.1364,1.1668,0.2488
+Find × Text,Ctrl+F,Grounded,20,1.4000,1.3139,0.2938
+Find × Visual,Ctrl+F,Non-grounded,32,0.5313,0.7177,0.1269
+Find × Visual,Ctrl+F,Grounded,33,0.2424,0.5019,0.0874
+Guide × Text,Ctrl+F,Non-grounded,16,0.0000,0.0000,0.0000
+Guide × Text,Ctrl+F,Grounded,25,0.0400,0.2000,0.0400
+Guide × Visual,Ctrl+F,Non-grounded,24,0.0000,0.0000,0.0000
+Guide × Visual,Ctrl+F,Grounded,27,0.0000,0.0000,0.0000
+Find × Text,Text selections,Non-grounded,22,1.8636,2.5690,0.5477
+Find × Text,Text selections,Grounded,20,1.2000,1.3992,0.3129
+Find × Visual,Text selections,Non-grounded,32,1.8125,3.2072,0.5670
+Find × Visual,Text selections,Grounded,33,0.5455,1.5226,0.2650
+Guide × Text,Text selections,Non-grounded,16,2.6250,6.9366,1.7342
+Guide × Text,Text selections,Grounded,25,1.0800,1.8690,0.3738
+Guide × Visual,Text selections,Non-grounded,24,1.1250,2.4373,0.4975
+Guide × Visual,Text selections,Grounded,27,0.9259,1.8796,0.3617
+Find × Text,Mouse clicks,Non-grounded,22,16.0909,9.6900,2.0659
+Find × Text,Mouse clicks,Grounded,20,13.2000,4.3722,0.9776
+Find × Visual,Mouse clicks,Non-grounded,32,15.5000,8.3008,1.4674
+Find × Visual,Mouse clicks,Grounded,33,14.1212,7.4948,1.3047
+Guide × Text,Mouse clicks,Non-grounded,16,26.5625,15.3448,3.8362
+Guide × Text,Mouse clicks,Grounded,25,23.5200,14.9753,2.9951
+Guide × Visual,Mouse clicks,Non-grounded,24,23.0833,13.8906,2.8354
+Guide × Visual,Mouse clicks,Grounded,27,25.7778,15.0085,2.8884
+Find × Text,Mouse distance (px),Non-grounded,22,29983.4091,26879.6781,5730.7666
+Find × Text,Mouse distance (px),Grounded,20,21654.5000,16369.2342,3660.2721
+Find × Visual,Mouse distance (px),Non-grounded,32,20699.0938,15477.0318,2735.9785
+Find × Visual,Mouse distance (px),Grounded,33,20240.4545,19759.6468,3439.7130
+Guide × Text,Mouse distance (px),Non-grounded,16,13302.3125,10304.7959,2576.1990
+Guide × Text,Mouse distance (px),Grounded,25,24099.5600,17858.7613,3571.7523
+Guide × Visual,Mouse distance (px),Non-grounded,24,11814.7083,8422.6436,1719.2649
+Guide × Visual,Mouse distance (px),Grounded,27,18896.8889,12938.5811,2490.0311
+Find × Text,Page clicks,Non-grounded,22,5.7273,4.9587,1.0572
+Find × Text,Page clicks,Grounded,20,5.0500,3.5165,0.7863
+Find × Visual,Page clicks,Non-grounded,32,6.1875,7.6514,1.3526
+Find × Visual,Page clicks,Grounded,33,4.7273,6.3653,1.1081
+Guide × Text,Page clicks,Non-grounded,16,10.0000,16.4560,4.1140
+Guide × Text,Page clicks,Grounded,25,9.2000,12.8679,2.5736
+Guide × Visual,Page clicks,Non-grounded,24,6.0417,8.0351,1.6402
+Guide × Visual,Page clicks,Grounded,27,6.9259,9.7268,1.8719

behavior_pooled.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,13 @@
+facet,metric,condition,n,mean,sd,se
+All tasks,Scroll count,Non-grounded,94,12.0106,11.3512,1.1708
+All tasks,Scroll count,Grounded,105,15.5048,15.4759,1.5103
+All tasks,Ctrl+F,Non-grounded,94,0.4468,0.8246,0.0850
+All tasks,Ctrl+F,Grounded,105,0.3524,0.8202,0.0800
+All tasks,Text selections,Non-grounded,94,1.7872,3.7927,0.3912
+All tasks,Text selections,Grounded,105,0.8952,1.6809,0.1640
+All tasks,Mouse clicks,Non-grounded,94,19.4574,12.2480,1.2633
+All tasks,Mouse clicks,Grounded,105,19.1810,12.6360,1.2331
+All tasks,Mouse distance (px),Non-grounded,94,19344.6383,18055.0887,1862.2402
+All tasks,Mouse distance (px),Grounded,105,21083.1429,16978.1514,1656.8979
+All tasks,Page clicks,Non-grounded,94,6.6915,9.3280,0.9621
+All tasks,Page clicks,Grounded,105,6.4190,8.9322,0.8717

rows.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,200 @@
+participant,task_id,task_type,task_style,facet,condition,question_index,time_ms,answer_multiple_choice_ms,find_supporting_answer_ms,score_answer_correct,score_verdict_correct,score_evidence_precision,score_evidence_recall,score_type_precision,score_type_recall,score_step_precision,score_step_recall,score_no_error_agreement,confidence,helpfulness,scroll_count,ctrl_f_count,text_select_count,click_count,mouse_move_px,website_click_count,panel_click_count
+1,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,2,213251,188387,24864,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,10,1,0,9,14816,3,6
+2,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,240039,175784,64255,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,0,0,1,8,1209,2,6
+3,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,2,461598,418961,42637,true,,0,0,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,6,3,2,13,45996,5,8
+4,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,144769,89674,55095,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,notmuch,19,4,1,15,9207,5,10
+5,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,2,133843,7005,126838,true,,0,0,,,,,,notsure,notatall,0,0,0,19,2092,2,17
+6,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,337923,199204,138719,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,18,2,5,16,50783,7,9
+7,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,26281,2182,24099,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,4,1,0,11,12270,5,6
+8,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,332215,270564,61651,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,somewhat,12,2,1,18,46858,7,11
+9,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,2,224268,204720,19548,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,7,1,1,12,53399,6,6
+10,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,423193,316906,106287,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,7,5,1,20,61247,11,9
+11,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,73688,53308,20380,true,,0,0,,,,,,guessed,notatall,7,0,0,9,12864,3,6
+12,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,196854,114454,82400,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,14,3,3,10,26715,2,8
+10,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,2,483097,432110,50987,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,0,2,7,26,57665,3,23
+13,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,2,195970,100960,95010,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,9,1,4,31,61971,12,19
+11,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,187250,166097,21153,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,6,0,0,12,12512,3,9
+14,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,190428,172511,17917,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,very,6,0,0,8,12497,2,6
+15,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,0,636180,601762,34418,true,,1,1,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,19,1,4,27,30945,14,13
+16,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,0,74845,3529,71316,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,somewhat,3,1,0,10,10327,2,8
+17,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,213199,186070,27129,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,notmuch,4,1,0,13,36325,3,10
+18,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,208488,178135,30353,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,11,1,1,9,35706,3,6
+19,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,0,384077,278301,105776,true,,1,1,,,,,,notsure,notmuch,19,1,0,10,52835,3,7
+20,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,0,213290,183249,30041,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,6,3,2,14,42113,8,6
+21,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,1,168064,132847,35217,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,3,1,0,8,11281,3,5
+22,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,308894,17039,291855,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,somewhat,0,0,0,19,3302,8,11
+23,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,164968,110284,54684,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,7,2,7,15,16922,3,12
+24,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,204073,136176,67897,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,somewhat,16,1,2,15,20788,6,9
+25,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,35959,8577,27382,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,5,2,0,11,9103,2,9
+26,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,92622,50013,42609,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,very,12,0,1,12,14066,3,9
+26,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,133472,99355,34117,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,somewhat,7,4,3,20,32802,9,11
+27,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,1187031,373232,813799,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,notatall,35,0,8,48,114202,22,26
+28,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,38927,15445,23482,true,,1,1,,,,,,notsure,very,9,1,0,10,9338,2,8
+29,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,266744,236673,30071,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,3,0,1,12,12863,6,6
+30,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,194256,157962,36294,true,,1,1,,,,,,somewhat,very,27,1,2,17,18978,7,10
+31,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,1,91118,23512,67606,true,,1,1,,,,,,somewhat,very,17,1,1,9,8749,2,7
+32,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,291300,247518,43782,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,notatall,0,0,0,8,981,2,6
+33,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,70695,28328,42367,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,13,0,0,12,17580,3,9
+34,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,0,31627,8486,23141,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,somewhat,3,1,0,9,7710,3,6
+34,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,350308,312963,37345,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,somewhat,11,2,1,11,19663,5,6
+35,HARRY-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,1,215270,185878,29392,true,,1,1,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,6,1,4,20,36176,14,6
+36,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,1,24534,6925,17609,true,,0,0,,,,,,guessed,notmuch,7,0,0,7,7965,2,5
+37,EDU-v1,find,find_text,Find × Text,nongrounding,0,135273,102992,32281,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,12,2,1,13,17090,3,10
+37,NVIDA-V1,find,find_text,Find × Text,grounding,1,99861,76671,23190,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,5,1,1,22,22814,11,11
+3,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,1,106754,87272,19482,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,4,0,0,10,21046,3,7
+9,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,1,208126,181360,26766,true,,1,1,,,,,,somewhat,very,34,2,3,17,43238,11,6
+5,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,1,106369,41893,64476,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,somewhat,0,0,0,14,4667,3,11
+3,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,867454,346441,521013,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,notsure,notmuch,6,1,1,16,52413,3,13
+2,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,1,37916,21392,16524,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,very,3,0,0,8,813,2,6
+1,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,154004,131879,22125,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,very,26,0,0,9,7216,2,7
+5,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,135916,23688,112228,false,,0,0,,,,,,notsure,notmuch,0,0,0,17,2475,5,12
+10,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,150905,79137,71768,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,very,3,1,5,18,26743,5,13
+4,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,43648,37147,6501,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,notmuch,8,1,0,8,7961,2,6
+7,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,1,158768,121595,37173,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,very,49,0,0,15,39990,5,10
+4,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,1,86530,44180,42350,true,,0,0,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,29,1,0,12,13606,3,9
+8,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,1,217700,194124,23576,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,very,35,0,0,9,23965,2,7
+9,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,146329,46066,100263,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,very,41,1,8,25,35124,19,6
+10,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,1,73527,40064,33463,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,very,2,0,2,10,14258,2,8
+1,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,1,336175,177313,158862,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,59,0,0,13,13334,2,11
+7,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,105353,93611,11742,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,5,0,0,13,30607,6,7
+13,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,1,157093,126814,30279,false,,0,0,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,22,0,0,21,27593,6,15
+8,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,178078,155498,22580,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,6,0,0,8,22993,2,6
+13,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,129760,105540,24220,false,,0,0,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,19,0,0,10,25570,2,8
+11,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,23682,10798,12884,false,,0,0,,,,,,guessed,notatall,9,0,0,10,4978,3,7
+11,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,22494,8193,14301,false,,0,0,,,,,,guessed,notatall,9,0,0,9,4163,3,6
+14,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,110171,79171,30999,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,21,0,0,9,11514,2,7
+14,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,99853,65303,34550,true,,0,0,,,,,,somewhat,very,11,0,0,10,8250,2,8
+38,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,148452,115598,32854,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,very,27,0,8,46,18707,37,9
+38,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,79589,65063,14526,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,5,1,15,51,13351,43,8
+15,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,2,365352,337169,28183,true,,1,1,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,18,1,1,21,20712,8,13
+15,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,3,132306,111540,20766,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,somewhat,8,1,0,12,10156,4,8
+16,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,2,193460,126103,67357,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,34,0,0,10,18838,4,6
+16,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,3,405479,375616,29863,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,22,0,0,9,22154,3,6
+17,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,4033290,1647999,2385291,true,,1,1,,,,,,somewhat,very,125,0,1,25,112922,5,20
+17,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,1249660,997991,251669,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,notmuch,49,1,6,22,56732,3,19
+18,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,192282,107543,84739,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,33,1,1,9,27376,3,6
+18,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,155417,108249,47168,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,5,1,2,20,30835,10,10
+19,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,2,129946,100721,29225,true,,1,1,,,,,,somewhat,notmuch,6,0,0,8,20320,2,6
+19,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,3,35240,21648,13592,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,9,0,0,11,12931,2,9
+20,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,2,120329,83096,37233,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,very,25,0,0,10,28567,3,7
+20,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,3,134927,104566,30361,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,26,0,0,12,19842,3,9
+21,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,2,189829,158294,31535,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,4,0,0,9,12727,3,6
+21,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,3,106501,94035,12466,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,10,0,0,9,9359,2,7
+22,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,1484499,25227,1459272,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,notsure,notmuch,0,0,0,21,4588,7,14
+22,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,411086,42545,368541,false,,0,0,,,,,,guessed,notatall,0,0,0,17,2495,3,14
+23,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,149654,126627,23027,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,15,0,0,17,20906,2,15
+23,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,197265,53815,143450,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,very,17,1,2,14,15014,5,9
+24,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,113706,82659,31047,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,somewhat,27,0,0,9,11991,2,7
+24,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,64852,52786,12066,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,very,6,0,0,10,9852,4,6
+25,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,139268,118619,20649,false,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,notsure,somewhat,10,1,1,24,14912,13,11
+25,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,236519,208253,28266,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,64,2,0,17,20570,11,6
+26,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,115308,83908,31400,true,,0,0,,,,,,somewhat,notatall,21,0,2,19,19212,4,15
+26,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,60785,44130,16655,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,notmuch,11,0,1,15,8031,3,12
+27,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,242419,178207,64212,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,very,very,20,0,0,17,38042,7,10
+27,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,1018990,461883,557107,false,,1,1,,,,,,somewhat,very,23,1,4,22,63288,11,11
+30,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,30913,6501,24412,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,notsure,very,6,0,0,8,5767,2,6
+30,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,137291,122049,15242,true,,1,1,,,,,,somewhat,very,30,1,2,15,12691,3,12
+31,MUFC-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,2,66631,35259,31372,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,very,7,0,0,10,14138,3,7
+31,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,3,110553,22666,87887,true,,0,0,,,,,,somewhat,somewhat,44,0,0,9,15050,2,7
+33,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,73690,32022,41668,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,very,21,0,0,12,10098,2,10
+32,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,313602,257816,55786,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,27,0,0,19,2077,6,13
+32,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,268049,217634,50415,true,,0,0,,,,,,very,notmuch,27,0,0,13,1343,6,7
+33,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,89451,70531,18920,false,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,notsure,somewhat,24,0,1,11,10703,5,6
+35,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,2,172430,145873,26557,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,32,3,5,23,34743,9,14
+35,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,3,112928,95773,17155,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,7,1,0,8,33889,2,6
+36,PEDANT-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,2,342547,24817,317730,true,,1,1,,,,,,very,very,19,0,0,10,22041,2,8
+36,SVSF-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,3,114854,78733,36121,true,,0,0,,,,,,somewhat,very,19,0,1,12,14156,5,7
+37,TESLA-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,nongrounding,2,169812,118805,51007,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,very,20,1,4,23,29750,3,20
+37,TREE-V1,find,find_visual,Find × Visual,grounding,3,112473,63737,48736,true,,0.5,0.5,,,,,,somewhat,very,35,1,0,12,16913,2,10
+17,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,68579,39981,28598,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,9,0,0,16,17968,2,14
+18,gv2-ed05972e-i5fi3b,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,260416,209438,50978,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,12,0,1,16,42707,4,12
+26,gv2-ed05972e-i5fi3b,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,54293,49427,4866,,true,,,,0,,0,false,notsure,notatall,11,0,0,29,11322,18,11
+33,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,59753,26789,32964,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,13,0,0,19,5004,0,19
+20,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,1,61625,58189,3436,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,somewhat,8,0,0,13,23632,2,11
+25,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,98237,93403,4834,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,somewhat,20,0,1,29,11900,16,13
+32,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,173844,155502,18342,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,0,0,0,19,4259,8,11
+35,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,0,69184,65724,3460,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,7,0,6,40,20779,28,12
+9,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,185068,150334,34734,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,12,0,2,55,60229,43,12
+11,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,16928,5819,11109,,false,,,0,0,,0,true,somewhat,somewhat,10,0,2,23,6344,0,23
+13,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,591881,577656,14225,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,2,0,0,15,21831,4,11
+7,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,154044,145663,8381,,false,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,19,0,1,31,57601,18,13
+10,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,2,67880,43329,24551,,false,,,0,0,,0,true,very,very,0,0,1,19,14703,4,15
+8,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,147323,140906,6417,,false,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,somewhat,9,0,0,14,16551,2,12
+4,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,111503,36818,74685,,false,,,1,1,1,1,true,notsure,somewhat,23,1,1,18,13707,4,14
+1,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,122474,117135,5339,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,13,0,0,14,12771,3,11
+14,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,195291,184775,10516,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,10,0,5,30,30188,8,22
+38,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,212976,80800,132176,,true,,,0,0,,0,true,notsure,somewhat,14,0,5,63,40487,42,21
+16,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,1,51236,48274,2962,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,2,0,1,15,13178,2,13
+17,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,253504,87974,165530,,true,,,0,0,,0,true,very,notmuch,18,0,1,40,41277,6,34
+23,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,24581,8834,15747,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,2,0,0,11,3747,0,11
+19,gv2-ed35d549-ct71ub,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,0,123837,119175,4662,,false,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,notmuch,17,0,1,16,9542,4,12
+20,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,0,95801,90304,5497,,false,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,9,0,0,20,24572,6,14
+21,gv2-ed05972e-i5fi3b,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,1,309337,211554,97783,,true,,,1,1,1,0.666667,true,very,very,11,0,0,36,27032,16,20
+22,gv2-ed35d549-ct71ub,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,23746,21150,2596,,false,,,,0,,0,false,notsure,somewhat,0,0,0,15,1671,0,15
+23,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,8505,3856,4649,,false,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,2,0,0,13,4234,0,13
+24,gv2-ed05972e-i5fi3b,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,129891,95500,34391,,true,,,1,0.5,1,0.333333,true,somewhat,somewhat,24,0,0,14,22368,2,12
+25,gv2-ed35d549-ct71ub,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,386336,383022,3314,,false,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,somewhat,33,0,0,57,66805,36,21
+26,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,146370,103790,42580,,false,,,0,0,,0,true,notsure,notatall,13,0,1,18,21164,3,15
+27,gv2-ed35d549-ct71ub,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,30556,22490,8066,,true,,,,0,,0,false,guessed,very,9,0,0,20,10665,1,19
+36,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,205224,119537,85687,,false,,,,0,,0,false,notsure,somewhat,23,0,2,35,39854,17,18
+29,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,111469,83920,27549,,true,,,1,1,1,0.2,true,somewhat,very,6,0,0,13,7256,0,13
+30,gv2-ed35d549-ct71ub,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,153466,96347,57119,,false,,,,0,,0,false,guessed,somewhat,29,0,0,12,15140,1,11
+30,gv2-ms9hwloh-15fuvy,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,98571,81203,17368,,false,,,0,0,,0,true,very,very,23,0,2,29,22205,9,20
+37,gv2-ed05972e-i5fi3b,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,0,100514,69399,31115,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,somewhat,15,0,28,75,19245,64,11
+31,gv2-ed05972e-i5fi3b,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,1,36539,28868,7671,,true,,,1,0.5,0,0,true,somewhat,very,9,0,0,12,6175,0,12
+32,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,203252,160012,43240,,true,,,1,1,1,1,true,somewhat,notmuch,0,0,0,24,4151,4,20
+33,gv2-ed35d549-ct71ub,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,0,37122,28891,8231,,false,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,10,0,1,16,4187,0,16
+35,gv2-ed35d549-ct71ub,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,1,59702,57887,1815,,false,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,11,0,0,20,20808,9,11
+36,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,nongrounding,1,20421,7103,13318,,true,,,0,0,,0,true,notsure,notmuch,10,0,0,14,5223,0,14
+37,gv2-ms9j3200-u0i9nm,guide,guide_text,Guide × Text,grounding,1,64429,56615,7814,,false,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,16,0,7,25,12844,4,21
+23,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,9606,7565,2041,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,1,0,1,12,4089,1,11
+3,gv2-msf28nd3-gig8aj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,36685,15355,21330,,true,,,1,1,0,0,true,very,very,7,0,0,17,8066,1,16
+12,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,95559,84208,11351,,true,,,0,0,,0,true,very,very,15,0,0,16,15991,3,13
+2,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,1,18582,14931,3651,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,0,0,0,13,2098,0,13
+9,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,1,236685,145586,91099,,true,,,1,1,0.642857,1,true,somewhat,somewhat,20,0,2,73,38537,33,40
+1,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,135091,116356,18735,,true,,,1,0.5,0,0,true,very,somewhat,16,0,0,20,17591,7,13
+13,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,1,897410,894570,2840,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,1,0,0,12,6442,0,12
+5,gv2-msf28nd3-gig8aj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,54588,26947,27641,,true,,,1,1,1,0.2,true,very,very,0,0,0,14,3082,2,12
+7,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,1,175494,45779,129715,,true,,,1,1,1,1,true,somewhat,somewhat,26,0,0,36,32505,0,36
+10,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,72822,52168,20654,,true,,,1,1,1,0.428571,true,very,very,0,0,2,20,13638,0,20
+8,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,1,429595,356189,73406,,true,,,1,1,1,0.428571,true,somewhat,somewhat,13,0,0,19,21104,3,16
+13,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,11636,9229,2407,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,somewhat,3,0,0,11,11375,0,11
+9,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,145797,111999,33798,,false,,,1,0.5,1,0.5,true,notsure,notmuch,18,0,2,34,36002,5,29
+10,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,1,263173,75288,187885,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,0,0,1,20,43489,4,16
+4,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,1,34181,23514,10667,,true,,,0,0,,0,true,somewhat,somewhat,12,0,0,23,7126,0,23
+1,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,1,222225,174329,47896,,true,,,1,1,0.666667,0.222222,true,somewhat,very,20,0,0,27,28565,14,13
+11,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,6582,2960,3622,,true,,,1,0.5,0,0,true,notsure,somewhat,4,0,0,14,3977,0,14
+11,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,6471,2966,3505,,false,,,0,0,,0,true,somewhat,somewhat,4,0,0,18,3354,0,18
+14,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,112060,70091,41969,,true,,,1,1,0.666667,0.666667,true,somewhat,somewhat,10,0,0,27,15692,3,24
+14,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,36076,20791,15285,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,somewhat,6,0,0,15,7267,1,14
+17,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,116966,110854,6112,,true,,,,0,,0,false,notsure,somewhat,10,0,1,20,19975,8,12
+38,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,153912,135813,18099,,true,,,1,1,1,0.428571,true,very,very,13,0,5,53,24705,37,16
+16,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,3,128347,70574,57773,,true,,,1,1,0.7,0.777778,true,somewhat,somewhat,10,0,0,22,30899,0,22
+15,gv2-msf28nd3-gig8aj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,2,503563,400233,103330,,true,,,0.5,1,0.571429,0.8,true,somewhat,somewhat,29,0,5,69,27997,17,52
+16,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,2,69915,66371,3544,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,notmuch,6,0,0,17,10622,4,13
+17,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,41429,39433,1996,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,7,0,0,19,15004,6,13
+18,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,301134,264112,37022,,true,,,1,1,1,0.571429,true,somewhat,notmuch,19,0,1,31,30659,5,26
+19,gv2-msf28nd3-gig8aj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,2,79949,72206,7743,,true,,,1,1,0,0,true,somewhat,notmuch,21,0,1,17,8177,0,17
+20,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,2,79912,75697,4215,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,somewhat,9,0,0,13,13303,2,11
+20,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,3,74879,72760,2119,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,somewhat,9,0,0,13,17053,2,11
+21,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,3,298628,239728,58900,,true,,,1,1,1,0.857143,true,somewhat,very,11,0,0,32,27864,11,21
+22,gv2-msf28nd3-gig8aj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,35638,19129,16509,,true,,,0,0,,0,true,somewhat,notmuch,0,0,0,17,1857,1,16
+23,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,11098,8471,2627,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,2,0,1,13,5175,0,13
+24,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,132874,105498,27376,,true,,,1,1,0,0,true,somewhat,somewhat,23,0,0,23,23246,7,16
+25,gv2-msf28nd3-gig8aj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,89472,84721,4751,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,17,0,1,24,11730,6,18
+25,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,27210,25059,2151,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,9,0,1,17,6003,3,14
+26,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,47653,44110,3543,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,notmuch,4,0,0,16,8288,3,13
+26,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,39772,36355,3417,,true,,,,0,,0,false,notsure,notmuch,13,0,0,34,13136,20,14
+30,gv2-msf28nd3-gig8aj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,135993,116181,19812,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,25,0,8,56,23796,11,45
+30,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,65848,58122,7726,,true,,,,0,,0,false,notsure,notatall,15,0,3,38,14490,18,20
+31,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,3,44830,27649,17181,,false,,,0,0,,0,true,very,very,10,0,0,13,6538,0,13
+32,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,279423,226628,52795,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,very,0,0,0,26,6324,6,20
+32,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,400962,346257,54705,,false,,,1,0.5,0,0,true,somewhat,somewhat,0,0,0,30,6024,12,18
+33,gv2-msf28nd3-gig8aj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,66833,43407,23426,,true,,,1,1,1,0.2,true,somewhat,somewhat,14,0,0,14,3640,0,14
+33,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,42504,26267,16237,,false,,,1,1,0.666667,0.222222,true,somewhat,very,13,0,0,18,4580,0,18
+35,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,2,59535,56097,3438,,true,,,,0,,0,false,very,very,9,0,0,24,21931,11,13
+35,gv2-msf28nd3-gig8aj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,3,171696,159200,12496,,true,,,1,1,0,0,true,somewhat,somewhat,29,0,3,39,46696,22,17
+36,gv2-msf0i7ll-hffde9,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,2,52288,48075,4213,,true,,,,0,,0,false,notsure,notmuch,12,0,0,11,8633,1,10
+36,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,3,5384,2564,2820,,true,,,,0,,0,false,guessed,notatall,4,0,0,10,2317,0,10
+37,gv2-msf1kfhv-o9o8n8,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,nongrounding,2,65203,43514,21689,,true,,,1,1,1,0.428571,true,somewhat,very,18,0,11,52,11600,30,22
+37,gv2-msf0vpxs-qucehj,guide,guide_visual,Guide × Visual,grounding,3,187237,183813,3424,,true,,,,0,,0,false,somewhat,somewhat,12,0,3,28,21517,12,16