Merge historical annotations with current recheck

Deduplicate 155 historical pair records; recover 2,346 independent historical submissions; exclude 20 derived cross-annotator copies; add merged consensus and asset-lineage configs while preserving dated current-review compatibility configs.

README.md

@@ -26,6 +26,30 @@ configs:
   data_files:
   - split: default
     path: data/annotation_to_video.parquet
+- config_name: submissions
+  data_files:
+  - split: default
+    path: data/submissions.parquet
+- config_name: consensus
+  data_files:
+  - split: default
+    path: data/consensus.parquet
+- config_name: historical_submissions
+  data_files:
+  - split: default
+    path: data/historical_submissions.parquet
+- config_name: historical_consensus
+  data_files:
+  - split: default
+    path: data/historical_consensus.parquet
+- config_name: asset_lineage
+  data_files:
+  - split: default
+    path: data/asset_lineage.parquet
+- config_name: excluded_submissions
+  data_files:
+  - split: default
+    path: data/excluded_submissions.parquet
 - config_name: exclusions
   data_files:
   - split: default
@@ -42,57 +66,55 @@ configs:
   data_files:
   - split: default
     path: data/current_review_status.parquet
-- config_name: review_assets
-  data_files:
-  - split: default
-    path: asset_manifest.parquet
 ---
 
 # WRBench Human Annotations
 
-This dataset contains the human comparison labels used to validate WRBench's
+This dataset contains the human pairwise labels used to validate WRBench's
 automatic evaluation metrics.
 
-## Version Update: 2026-07-07
-
-We updated the release after rechecking videos that changed during benchmark
-maintenance. The release now includes:
+## Version update: 2026-07-23
 
-- 1,741 clean comparison rows.
-- 4,302 individual human judgments.
-- 585 newly rechecked current-benchmark comparisons, each reviewed by three
-  annotators.
-- Majority-label summaries for the newly rechecked subset.
+This update separates source records from independent human submissions and
+merges the recovered historical labels with the completed current-video
+recheck:
 
-These counts describe this dated human-label release. Moving leaderboard,
-video, and model counts are reported by the results and videos datasets.
+- **1,586 unique pairs**: 1,001 historical
+  pairs plus 585 current-video recheck pairs.
+- **4,101 independent submissions**:
+  2,346 historical plus
+  1,755 current recheck submissions.
+- The previous `1,741 pairs / 4,302 judgments` headline counted
+  155 duplicate historical pair records,
+  which repeated 181 judgment
+  references, and 20 derived
+  cross-annotator copies. Those are not independent votes.
 
-## Videos for the current recheck
+## Canonical configs
 
-All 1,170 endpoints in `current_review_consensus` resolve to the exact bytes
-shown to annotators. Of these, 897 are in `wrbench-videos`; the remaining 273
-endpoints refer to 106 unique files bundled here under `videos/` and indexed by
-`asset_manifest.parquet`.
+- `pairs`: one row per unique pair.
+- `submissions`: all independent historical and current-recheck submissions.
+- `consensus`: per-pair vote counts and consensus labels. Numeric preference
+  eligibility is explicit; `na`, split votes, and insufficient-rater rows are
+  not numeric preferences.
+- `historical_submissions` and `historical_consensus`: historical-only views.
+- `asset_lineage`: endpoint-level asset recovery and public-asset linkage.
+- `excluded_submissions`: derived records omitted from independent counts.
 
-The bundled files are dated human-review evidence. They use the earlier
-profile-unsuffixed IDs and are not additional leaderboard videos or aliases for
-the 30-degree and 60-degree benchmark profiles. Join on `video_asset_id`, whose
-`sha256:` value verifies the file bytes.
+The dated `current_review_*` configs remain unchanged for compatibility.
+`exclusions` preserves the prior transparency ledger.
 
-## Configs
+## Asset and automatic-score boundary
 
-- `pairs`: clean comparison rows used by the public WRBench release.
-- `annotation_to_video`: maps each comparison to the corresponding video assets.
-- `current_review_consensus`: majority labels for the 585 newly rechecked
-  comparisons.
-- `current_review_submissions`: anonymized per-annotator labels for those 585
-  comparisons.
-- `current_review_status` and `exclusions`: records kept for transparency, but
-  not used as clean comparison labels.
-- `review_assets`: paths, byte counts, and SHA256 identifiers for the 106
-  review-only videos bundled with this dataset.
+Current-recheck rows retain the exact assets served during re-review. Historical
+rows preserve the filename, model, scene/event, camera condition, recorded size,
+and recovery evidence. A migrated filename/model/size match is useful lineage,
+but it is **not** proof of annotation-time byte identity. Do not attach a
+historical label to a current automatic score by logical video name alone.
+Automatic-score joins require both exact asset SHA and exact scoring-prompt
+identity; the `asset_lineage` config records this policy.
 
-Annotator identities are anonymized in the public files.
+Annotator identities are pseudonymized in every public config.
 
 ## Links
 

data/annotation_to_video.parquet

@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
 version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
-oid sha256:40924c129f3695ca29f8a49f7cbc4cde776c8e4f8f74b44f6d7088e94eb5f626
-size 117541
+oid sha256:c96b6d3687978874e4e58fb8e300f56edaa297e22fb44bde7a12bdb7f29f0e73
+size 98909

data/asset_lineage.parquet

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:a3d13c76136e81be74982106581f5db09a21de2b6ce4fdd178327648b65b1967
+size 342749

data/consensus.parquet

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:ed5de85be5516eb1e023708f28d0d02e26fa81d41a915bd9d45f523bbbdd0a76
+size 129026

data/current_review_consensus.parquet

@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
 version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
-oid sha256:ee1f6e35e56643b83d506992af11ec4ab8b278734e3194e11bc28c5461c65554
-size 113988
+oid sha256:a203b1c50751cc21bab97804cac1f232ae3c8740fa3256d34be16487807a7118
+size 113688

data/current_review_status.parquet

@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
 version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
-oid sha256:eb5e88ffbd31f7fbfaa65923c5277d46cb464c0b65690f4afca037c9aab3fc28
-size 10354
+oid sha256:25e39fbbc5a3a0cd1e9298ce08e57e0a889b0801379e771a4faf125cf1fb22e3
+size 10310

data/current_review_submissions.parquet

@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
 version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
-oid sha256:120fded1b16b3ed2710e8633ad6339df91228f61ac0205416de1728741d72848
-size 71815
+oid sha256:fbd5d5b4f343200d1fa446ac5f453c5475e6304173745f681f98374267ad0608
+size 71623

data/excluded_submissions.parquet

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:892be1d2a3b4e6979fe984b8af3fb882484b25bac923c94701df29fffff5deba
+size 6437

data/exclusions.parquet

@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
 version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
-oid sha256:10fc0ea92973d81fbb24e4d806eedad3e7109f0526e7439cc2edac7a54f098fd
-size 14119
+oid sha256:2f0d61e7b0b1966688f2ffb80da9d551106c6dc8ccb336710282fa61e9c8d3d6
+size 14115

data/historical_consensus.parquet

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:42fb77ee16b98191d6d26e88421cd854a4a86c88d2bcb56bcb52c20a6ac3e092
+size 103437

data/historical_submissions.parquet

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:a3be466a284be1b92eb92353ec865f861ea64cea305a18f995983fc0b3e1bd9f
+size 108738

data/pairs.parquet

@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
 version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
-oid sha256:53198546e81c794e5f31dca4ca38759f5e7b6ac6da29a8dd3679c817485a5426
-size 234848
+oid sha256:bcd9c0e59a2f6cb13f9190c6513db2e8d9a3b83682d07cbea4cc608d72bfd6c5
+size 213218

data/submissions.parquet

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:6b157b1a86a2173565ce2954ce035f4d59824263b1ff24dc433772d618d6ac09
+size 170028

datasheet.md

@@ -1,12 +1,51 @@
 # WRBench Human Annotations Datasheet
 
-Generated: `2026-07-07T11:43:39+00:00`.
+Generated: `2026-07-23T01:18:56+00:00`.
 
-The dataset contains public, release-safe human annotation metadata and the
-exact review-only video files listed in `asset_manifest.parquet`. It does not
-include internal filesystem paths, IP addresses, email addresses, or raw
-annotator labels (`p1`, `p3`, `p4`).
+## Population and unit of analysis
 
-The 2026-07-07 update adds 585 completed current-benchmark clean recheck pairs.
-Rows that were current-vs-legacy evidence, single-video provenance checks, or
-incomplete three-annotator reviews are not promoted to clean labels.
+The canonical unit is an independent annotator submission on one video pair.
+The release contains 1,586 unique pairs and
+4,101 independent submissions. Historical source records
+were selected by pair identity and review-pool precedence. When one annotator
+had repeated rows with the same six preference values, the latest timestamped
+row was retained so later subtype-only corrections were preserved. Derived
+cross-annotator copies are listed separately and excluded from consensus and
+reliability calculations.
+
+Historical OOV subtype fields retain the vocabulary used by the original
+annotation interface; current-recheck subtype fields use the later revised
+vocabulary. The six preference fields are normalized to a common A/tie/B/NA
+schema, but subtype strings should not be pooled across waves without an
+explicit vocabulary mapping.
+
+## Historical asset recovery
+
+The 1,001 historical pairs contain
+2,002 endpoints. Recovery found
+1,442 unique filename/model/recorded-size
+candidates; 560 endpoints remain
+unresolved. Of the recovered candidates, 1,147
+currently match an asset already hosted in a WRBench public dataset by SHA-256,
+and 428 pairs have public matches
+for both endpoints.
+
+Historical source manifests did not record annotation-time SHA-256. Therefore a
+later recovered hash, including one reached through a matching filename, model,
+and byte size, is lineage evidence rather than cryptographic proof of the bytes
+seen during annotation.
+
+## Automatic-score alignment
+
+As a release gate, the current-recheck subset was compared only where both the
+released asset SHA and scoring prompt matched. Spearman rho was positive for all
+five evaluated dimensions (D2--D6); exact sample sizes and values are recorded
+in `release_checks.json`. Historical sources are kept separate because their
+strict score-aligned coverage is small and run-dependent. Logical-name-only
+joins are prohibited.
+
+## Privacy
+
+Public rows contain pseudonymous annotator IDs and omit notes, internal paths,
+hostnames, network addresses, and source filenames. Timestamps are retained for
+version ordering and auditability.

original/excluded_submissions.jsonl

@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_a", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-living_room_adult_sofa_sit__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_b", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-living_room_adult_sofa_sit__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_a", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-loading_dock_worker_pallet_box_place__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_b", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-loading_dock_worker_pallet_box_place__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_a", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-meeting_room_adult_chair_sit__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_b", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-meeting_room_adult_chair_sit__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_a", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-office_lounge_adult_sofa_sit__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_b", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-office_lounge_adult_sofa_sit__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_a", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-office_lounge_adult_sofa_sit__T2_div_b__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_b", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-office_lounge_adult_sofa_sit__T2_div_b__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_a", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-restaurant_waiter_table_tray_place__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_b", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-restaurant_waiter_table_tray_place__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_a", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-restaurant_waiter_table_tray_place__T2_div_b__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_b", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-restaurant_waiter_table_tray_place__T2_div_b__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_a", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-supermarket_customer_checkout_basket_place__T2_div_b__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_b", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-supermarket_customer_checkout_basket_place__T2_div_b__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_a", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-train_platform_passenger_bench_sit__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_b", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-train_platform_passenger_bench_sit__T1__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_a", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-train_platform_passenger_bench_sit__T2_div_b__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}
+{"annotator_id": "annotator_b", "client_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00", "copied_from_annotator_id": "annotator_c", "exclusion_reason": "derived_cross_annotator_copy", "pair_id": "v7-reobserve-gen3c-vs-wan22_fun_a14b_cam-train_platform_passenger_bench_sit__T2_div_b__yaw_RL", "pool_id": "8891", "review_wave": "historical_annotation_pools_8891_8895", "server_timestamp": "2026-05-19T12:21:47.366918+00:00"}

release_checks.json

@@ -1,43 +1,190 @@
 {
-  "generated_at": "2026-07-12T18:12:55+00:00",
-  "pairs": 1741,
-  "pair_id_unique": 1586,
-  "pair_id_duplicate_rows": 155,
-  "old_pairs": 1156,
-  "new_current_pairs": 585,
-  "annotation_to_video": 1616,
-  "exclusions": 1609,
-  "current_review_submissions": 1755,
-  "current_review_consensus": 585,
-  "current_review_status": 709,
-  "checks": {
-    "clean_current_pairs": 585,
+  "generated_at": "2026-07-23T01:18:56+00:00",
+  "source_hf_commits": {
+    "WRBench/wrbench-human-annotations": "77896fa99843b58de5e98bd4b48ae29eba36bd70",
+    "WRBench/wrbench-videos": "a8e3d38b3c588a6f5368bfb42bfcf7d9a7dddf89"
+  },
+  "pairs": 1586,
+  "historical_pairs": 1001,
+  "current_pairs": 585,
+  "submissions": 4101,
+  "historical_submissions": 2346,
+  "current_submissions": 1755,
+  "derived_submissions_excluded": 20,
+  "duplicate_pair_records_removed": 155,
+  "repeated_judgment_references_removed": 181,
+  "previous_headline_pair_records": 1741,
+  "previous_headline_judgment_references": 4302,
+  "historical_pairs_by_independent_raters": {
+    "1": 304,
+    "2": 49,
+    "3": 648
+  },
+  "historical_selected_pools": {
+    "8891": 139,
+    "8892": 135,
+    "8894": 572,
+    "8895": 155
+  },
+  "historical_numeric_consensus": {
+    "cam_pref": 681,
+    "physics_pref": 680,
+    "sp_in_pref": 662,
+    "st_in_pref": 672,
+    "sp_oov_pref": 45,
+    "st_oov_pref": 45
+  },
+  "current_numeric_consensus": {
+    "cam_pref": 585,
+    "physics_pref": 581,
+    "sp_in_pref": 575,
+    "st_in_pref": 584,
+    "sp_oov_pref": 232,
+    "st_oov_pref": 234
+  },
+  "asset_lineage": {
+    "rows": 3172,
+    "historical_endpoints": 2002,
+    "current_endpoints": 1170,
+    "historical_recovery_evidence": {
+      "migrated_name_model_size_match": 255,
+      "original_path_present_name_model_size_match": 1187,
+      "unresolved": 560
+    },
+    "historical_public_asset_status": {
+      "recovered_candidate_not_public": 295,
+      "recovered_candidate_sha_matches_human_annotations": 28,
+      "recovered_candidate_sha_matches_wrbench_videos": 1119,
+      "unresolved": 560
+    },
+    "recovered_candidate_endpoints": 1442,
+    "unresolved_historical_endpoints": 560,
+    "public_exact_sha_endpoints": 1147,
+    "both_endpoints_public_exact_sha_pairs": 428
+  },
+  "annotation_to_video": 1330,
+  "consensus": 1586,
+  "historical_consensus": 1001,
+  "compatibility_counts": {
+    "exclusions": 1609,
     "current_review_submissions": 1755,
     "current_review_consensus": 585,
-    "current_review_status": 709,
-    "missing_endpoint_paths": [],
-    "missing_endpoint_path_count": 0,
-    "bad_subtypes": {},
-    "status_counts": {
-      "clean_label_current_recheck": 585,
-      "incomplete_recheck": 47,
-      "evidence_only_current_vs_legacy": 73,
-      "provenance_only_single_video": 4
+    "current_review_status": 709
+  },
+  "deduplication_checks": {
+    "source_pair_records": 1156,
+    "unique_pairs": 1001,
+    "duplicate_pair_records_removed": 155,
+    "repeated_judgment_references_removed": 181,
+    "duplicate_pool_patterns": {
+      "8894+8895": 155
     },
-    "review_video_assets": {
-      "endpoint_count": 1170,
-      "public_video_endpoints": 897,
-      "bundled_video_endpoints": 273,
-      "unresolved_endpoints": 0,
-      "comparisons_using_bundled_assets": 247,
-      "asset_id_collisions": 0,
-      "release_path_collisions": 0,
-      "byte_mismatches": 0,
-      "hash_mismatches": 0,
-      "decode_failures": 0
+    "selected_pools": {
+      "8891": 139,
+      "8892": 135,
+      "8894": 572,
+      "8895": 155
     }
   },
-  "privacy_issues": [],
-  "bundled_video_assets": 106,
-  "bundled_video_bytes": 780860203
+  "verdict_recovery_checks": {
+    "selected_source_versions": 2366,
+    "same_preference_duplicate_rows_collapsed": 21,
+    "later_subtype_updates_retained": 8,
+    "version_selection_policy": "latest server/client timestamp after identical six-preference check"
+  },
+  "orientation_flips_applied": 0,
+  "alignment_validation": {
+    "policy": "exact_asset_sha_and_exact_prompt_only; no logical-name joins",
+    "current_exact_asset_and_prompt": {
+      "pairs_both_endpoints": 126,
+      "metrics": {
+        "D2": {
+          "n": 126,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.6267772539443519
+        },
+        "D3": {
+          "n": 124,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.6582244415788507
+        },
+        "D4": {
+          "n": 125,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.6441660385824053
+        },
+        "D5": {
+          "n": 50,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.6104452253998198
+        },
+        "D6": {
+          "n": 49,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.6722511042658376
+        }
+      }
+    },
+    "historical_source_separated_diagnostics": {
+      "latest_full:original_path_only": {
+        "D5": {
+          "n": 15,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.3965116796012719
+        },
+        "D6": {
+          "n": 15,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.11593472394004206
+        }
+      },
+      "p22_strict_10f:original_path_only": {
+        "D5": {
+          "n": 20,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.3155722474703597
+        },
+        "D6": {
+          "n": 20,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.2596960474396678
+        }
+      },
+      "p22_drop2_10f:original_path_only": {
+        "D5": {
+          "n": 20,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.4116159749613388
+        },
+        "D6": {
+          "n": 20,
+          "spearman_rho": 0.20099762575809904
+        }
+      }
+    },
+    "historical_pooled_with_current": false
+  },
+  "input_sha256": {
+    "source_hf_pairs_jsonl": "0fc3fe2e86d5fc915816079c91160265d27d57a17dbb6b284a6d0a8344e09764",
+    "source_hf_current_submissions_jsonl": "8ffac108f86fe088d2ff1394f651569bf6399b01bd927faa91e854262636aa9d",
+    "historical_clean_pair_registry": "4f4f00ab414ff18119b379b81a480131084ba95b4bc62fca71e2f52419fa0ff5",
+    "migration_index": "67c283c8366c12e2e8832f3161ae91306e0c1c33be9dc598325e1126883643c6",
+    "correlation_gate": "0360f34de40ee914af2cc046b5c25490975d4a67fddca00df0ed50fbc26639a7",
+    "wrbench_videos_master": "f4eb6880a40844087cb0871113d82af4b1680e68fcdee0bff4de02e11bea66d9",
+    "human_annotation_asset_manifest": "0255eda324e137a6409959f806a457745db3885e87807d5963d9e494e2a4a8b9",
+    "historical_verdict_source_01": "5a43c1be385c2d35632be2a4aef4cee93d0605a2934f8c20c7ca344ccd0be6ea",
+    "historical_verdict_source_02": "176c20ba8631e49efd4e662a393baf9dd490f1505d9d64421c6d048dc81b9ef1",
+    "historical_verdict_source_03": "5f121b57cefcb2da58479dfa8e61046aa43a8ca31f4bfbf0a4ce875ecf1cbea5",
+    "historical_verdict_source_04": "9239ae7b74de256255dedd1db1776497fc88d392ee36e9bb47039bde366dd717",
+    "historical_verdict_source_05": "0b2b5ed9c795405b5c6fffefd422c688701e591ec8a3ad2df3b1a7ed227766ec",
+    "historical_verdict_source_06": "e6555f0473ac555001c8ba27e2d6fa0a9b729190c27eeaae200fa43c97a1b7a2",
+    "historical_verdict_source_07": "d6108820c07020b64db0419d09ca86b3902a219992afd87b04567edcd9a8e6ef",
+    "historical_verdict_source_08": "25d40be9f46ca4bf3985091eec118d286eb797d0b2c9ea07d7f43785a14a24fb",
+    "historical_verdict_source_09": "d17c382dc885e7cd02d260b28c9c87b8f1ee0bb68712209d0d4deae808869780"
+  },
+  "output_rows": {
+    "pairs": 1586,
+    "annotation_to_video": 1330,
+    "submissions": 4101,
+    "consensus": 1586,
+    "historical_submissions": 2346,
+    "historical_consensus": 1001,
+    "asset_lineage": 3172,
+    "excluded_submissions": 20,
+    "exclusions": 1609,
+    "current_review_submissions": 1755,
+    "current_review_consensus": 585,
+    "current_review_status": 709
+  },
+  "privacy_issues": []
 }