{"id": "article_1_en", "title": "Article 1. Concept of Development: The Foundational Principle", "author": "Vladlen V.K.", "book": "Concept of Development: A Non-Trivial Outlook on Evolution", "book_ru": "Концепция развития. Нетривиальный взгляд на эволюцию", "year": 2021, "publisher": "Prometej Publishers (Moscow)", "isbn": "978-5-00172-246-5", "license": "CC BY 4.0", "language": "en", "text": "ARTICLE 1\nConcept of Development: The Foundational Principle\nAbstract\nThis article is devoted to the exposition of a worldview concept based on the\nawareness of the significance and role of the relations of the widely known\nfoundational aspects of reality: content and form.\nContent and form are two inalienable constituent sides of any element of\nreality, be it an object, a process, or a phenomenon. By virtue of the\nomnipresence of content and form, the relations of these components —\nthese two principles of reality — prove to be the most important and\nessential.\nIn the course of analyzing the aforementioned relations, the internal source\nof evolutionary movement and the \"mechanism\" of its functioning are\nrevealed, on the basis of which the directionality of evolutionary processes is\ndefined and formulated for the first time (i.e., an idea of the vector of\nchange, movement, and development of the surrounding world and its\nelements is given).\n\n\fThe content-form transformations of unitary directionality described in the\narticle, which underlie all real processes, not only explain the spiral-cyclical\nnature of the world but also make it possible to forecast the prospect of its\ndevelopment. It is precisely this mode of interaction of the fundamental\naspects (principles) of reality that ensures the irreversibility of the evolution\nof forms, as well as the novelty, uniqueness, and inexhaustible diversity of\nthe latter.\nThe approach under consideration fundamentally levels any \"centrism\"\n(\"absolutism\") of whatever form, pointing both to the limited applicability of\nthe currently dominant anthropocentric (as well as bio-, theo-, and\nsociocentric) model of the world, and to the necessity of transition to\nanother, more integral and adequate model of it.\nThis concept may be recommended to the attention of researchers primarily\nin view of its integrity (in contrast to the fragmentary pictures of the world\nand theories of the past and present), as well as by virtue of the following\nconsiderations: whoever possesses the most adequate worldview — the\nfuture belongs to them.\nIntroduction\nA reader inclined toward the philosophical comprehension of natural-scientific\nand humanitarian knowledge has surely had occasion to reflect on the fact\nthat at the basis of real processes lie, and govern the surrounding world,\ndeep-lying regularities different from those that are discovered on the\nsurface and perceived as self-evident. We are speaking of objective\nfundamental relations that condition, among other things, the functioning\nand structure of the economy, politics, science, culture, and other aspects of\nthe life of human communities.\nOn the basis of many years of tracking discoveries and achievements in\nvarious fields of the natural and humanitarian sciences, I will venture to state\nthat to this day what takes place everywhere is chiefly the mere\naccumulation and mechanical \"warehousing\" of factual material, and there is\nas yet not a single contentful unifying idea that would allow us finally to\nrealize what the observed and \"warehoused\" phenomena actually represent.\nIn other words, the need for an integral and adequate model of everything\nthat exists, develops, and evolves is felt ever more acutely.\nI believe hardly anyone would object to the proposition that knowledge and\nunderstanding of the aforementioned regularities would contribute to raising\nthe accuracy of analysis and forecasting (based on this analysis) of the\ncourse of real events.\nThe article presents a non-standard view of the principles of organization of\nliving and non-living nature, of the origins and directionality of evolution;\nafter acquainting himself with it, a reader interested in such questions may\n\n\fdevelop a motivation for a critical rethinking of established worldview\nattitudes and a revision of the methods of analyzing the factual material and\ninformation obtained, which will ultimately be expressed in an increase in the\neffectiveness of the cognitive process.\nThis is, perhaps, the most integral and adequate concept available today,\nencompassing the spheres of interest of numerous scientific collectives and\nmaking it possible to comprehend the principles of correct forecasting of the\ndevelopment of reality.\nBelow it will be shown WHAT in fact lies at the basis of the development of\nreality, which is accomplished in many respects through inversion (i.e., the\n\"turning over\" of roles, methods, and notions, in Marx's figurative\nexpressions, or \"return into the foundation,\" in Hegel's terminology [12, p.\n102]).\nThus, the reader's attention is offered a \"thesis\" version of the concept [1;\n20], which examines the system of natural-scientific views and\nrepresentations concerning the evolutionary movement and development of\nreality from the standpoint of implicit but objective deep-lying regularities\nthat underlie these views and representations.\nThe essence of the proposed concept of development and its\nfoundational principle\nTraditionally, one speaks of the movement and development of anything,\nfirst of all, as of change: nothing remains for any length of time equal and\nidentical to itself. At the same time, it is impossible to speak of changes\napart from connection with what already exists. Stars, planets, oceans, and\nmountains change; plants, animals, people, and the products of human\nactivity change even faster and more strikingly. In other words, changes are\nnever isolated and abstract, but are always attached to what exists — to\nobjects, processes, phenomena, i.e., to some already existing basis. At that,\nit is not possible to separate the changing from the existing, i.e., change\nfrom basis, which compels us to speak of the movement and development of\nany object, process, or phenomenon as of a derivative of a certain symbiosis\n— of basis and change.\nIn general form, it is convenient to speak of such a symbiosis in terms of the\nbilateral, two-component relation {content/form}, i.e., in the notions of\nthe categorical apparatus developed sufficiently deeply before us by our\noutstanding predecessors-dialecticians. Of the movement and development\nof any object, process, or phenomenon one can speak as of a contentful\nchange of its form. The contentful changes that take place in reality manifest\nthemselves through changing forms. Indeed, if one scrupulously analyzes the\nchanges and transformations occurring in our surroundings (equally as in\nourselves), one can see that behind all changes and transformations there is\nimplicitly discovered a single-in-essence process of the movement of a\n\n\fcertain contentful activity through a series, a chain, a sequence of changing\nforms.\nIn order to avoid misunderstanding and divergent readings, let us cite the\ntextbook interpretation of the notions \"content\" and \"form\" [13, pp. 621,\n622]. Content is the determining side of the whole, the aggregate and unity\nof all its constituent parts, properties, internal processes, contradictions, and\ntendencies; form is the mode of existence and expression of content. In the\ninterrelation of content and form, content represents the dynamic side of the\nwhole, while form encompasses the system of its stable connections.\nThe relation of content and form is characterized by a unity reaching the\npoint of their transition into each other; however, this unity is relative.\nContent is not the substrate by itself, but its internal state, the aggregate of\nprocesses, and in this sense content itself acts as a process. The\nunderstanding of form, in turn, presupposes the consideration of it as a\ndeveloping and becoming structure.\nContent, being the active side, represents the mobile (as a rule, internal)\nconstituent of the relation {content/form} and symbolizes change (at times\nquite hidden, veiled). Form, at that, as the passive external constituent-side\nof the same relation, follows the active internal content.\nAs the active constituent side of the relation, content is internally inherent in\na certain impulse, stimulus, urge, motivation toward change, movement,\ndevelopment. This is, first of all, what distinguishes the active contentful side\nfrom the formal passive one. Then change, movement, and development\nthemselves do not arise suddenly and do not appear as some separate,\nisolated, and independent element, but prove to be a derivative or\nconsequence of the interaction of unequal, dissimilar constituent sides in\ntheir relation and striving to equalize, to identify with, and to become each\nother.\nMeanwhile, at every attempt to single out either of these two constituent\nsides in \"pure\" form, without the \"admixture\" of its other, we get into a fix —\nboth sides, upon closer examination, sink their roots one into the other, bear\nsimultaneously the features of their other, which testifies, apparently, to\ntheir deep syncretism.\nExtremely important in this connection is Hegel's point of view on the\ninterrelation of content and form, who believed that \"content is not formless,\nwhile form is at one and the same time both contained in content itself and\nrepresents something external to it,\" which reduces to the absolute relation\n\"between form and content, namely — their transition into each other, so\nthat content is nothing other than the transition of form into content, and\nform — the transition of content into form\" [2, p. 298].\nIn this way the constituents in the relation {content/form} interact with each\nother, or more precisely, as it were, \"live\" by the striving to become each\n\n\fother and to absorb each other completely and without residue, by the\nstriving to turn into identity with each other, by the striving toward mutual\ntransition, mutual interpenetration, mutual transformation, mutual\nexpression...\nSince it is simply impossible either to single out or to separate content from\nform (with respect to concrete objects, processes, phenomena), the most\nproductive, rational, and correct way is to speak only of the relation of\nthese two mutually interpenetrating constituents-components-sides of\nconcrete objects, processes, and phenomena.\nIn this light, every concrete object, process, or phenomenon is the relation of\nits sides or constituents {content/form}, and, in the final analysis, what\nmatters here is not each constituent side by itself, but precisely their\nrelation; the development of any object, process, or phenomenon, in turn,\nis the expression or representation of changing content by means of\nchanging forms and, ultimately, it is the process of becoming and\nmanifestation of each such concrete form in the form of a definite\ncorrelation (relative balance) of the aforementioned constituent sides\n(with the possibility of expressing and representing the said correlation,\nincluding in mathematical or digital form).\nAgainst the background and in the terms of these representations, the\nfollowing simple idea acquires a more or less coherent shape: everything that\nwe see, hear, and feel, everything with which and about which we think, i.e.,\neverything that surrounds us, including ourselves, — these are various\nformations or forms of different levels (different degrees) of contentfulness,\ninto which a certain contentful activity is clothed in its movement from\nlevel to level.\nSuch formations-forms represent dipoles (spirals) of two poles (two\nbranches), one of which is the contentful active constituent side of the dipole\n(spiral), the second — its (its) passive formal constituent side; in the\nphilosophical aspect, the aforementioned dipole (spiral) is similar to the\nrelation of two abstract notions {content/form}. An approximate visual\nmodel of such a dipole-spiral is given in Fig. 1.\n\n\f[Fig. 1 — schematic representation of a dipole-spiral: the contentful side\n(movement of content) and the formal side (movement of form) as two\nbranches of one spiral]\nContinuing to proceed from real relations and basing ourselves on them, we\nfollow further in our reasoning. Interacting with each other, dipole-forms of\ndifferent levels generate dipole-forms of new levels. The contentful\nconstituent, being the active side, strives to escape the control of any and\nevery form that encompasses and contains it; however, not having the\npossibility to realize itself otherwise than again through some form, it is\nforced each time to clothe itself in the next, unrelentingly following changing\nform. In prospect and in the ultimate expression, this process takes the form\nof an endless \"chase\" of the contentful constituent (content) after the very\nsame contentful constituent moving and developing in such an uncomplicated\nmanner. [One can arrive at such a conclusion by using, for example, the\ndevice of the limiting transition, which mathematicians apply when finding\nthe limits of functions.]\nModifying and adapting the initial model (Fig. 1) in line with what has just\nbeen said, we arrive at the following conceptual form of it, which brings us\nclose to understanding the directionality of the course and development of\nall real processes, i.e., the vector of development of anything whatsoever.\nIn a more or less laconic form, the formulation of the directionality of the\ndevelopment of reality looks as follows: the development of content is\naccomplished in the direction of the exhaustive expression\n(encompassment, absorption, assimilation, appropriation, comprehension...)\nby the developing content of the very content developing in such a\nway.\nLet us denote the formulation by the symbol @ for the convenience of further\nhandling of it.\nWith respect to the surrounding world, this formulation means approximately\nthe following: everything that exists and develops has as the direction of its\ndevelopment and existence the expression (encompassment, absorption,\nassimilation, appropriation, comprehension...) by itself, the existing and\ndeveloping, of itself, the existing and developing.\nTaking into account the previously noted inseparability of the components of\ncontent and form in their actual relation {content/form}, it becomes obvious\nthat the external manifestation of the above-described process of contentful\naccumulation @ proves to be the renewal of the form of expression of the\naccumulating content by raising the \"storey-ness\" or level of this very form\nof its (of the accumulated content) representation. As indeed happens in\nreality, the movement of content determined by formulation @ cannot be\nrealized otherwise than through forms of different levels of representation of\nthis content that do not repeat in details.\n\n\fThus, we are speaking of the description of an infinite, unceasing process of\ncontentful movement, realized by means of successive approximations to the\nexhaustive expression of the very contentful movement; in this way, in\nconceptual-abstract language, a multilevel formation (form) is described,\nwhose constituent parts (branches), like the formation as a whole, are similar\nto \"self-winding\" spirals.\nWithin the conceptual (notional) formulation @, which models the\ndevelopment of multilevel reality, in a \"sublated\" (as philosophers say) form\nare \"packed\" both the activity (movement-development), and the\ndirectionality of this activity (movement-development), and the contradiction\n(as the source of all movement-development), and the laws of dialectics,\netc., etc.\nIn essence, a general, single, universal internal principle of selfdevelopment (self-organization) of reality has been formulated, an implicit\nor explicit hint (and in other cases — a firm conviction) of the existence of\nwhich is present in the representations and statements of a huge number of\nscientists, researchers, and philosophers of the past and present who have\ndevoted themselves to the study and interpretation of the surrounding world\nand its evolutionary movement [3-7; 9-11; 14; 16; 17].\nThat is why all real processes have a spiral-cyclical character !!!\nIn other words, by virtue of relations of this kind, our world and all its\nelements are spiral-shaped: man is a spiral, a dog is a spiral, an ant is a\nspiral, a living cell is a spiral, a molecule is a spiral, an atom is a spiral, an\nelectron is a spiral, a photon is a spiral, a galaxy is a spiral, the Universe is a\nspiral; anyone who wishes may exercise in continuing this list as far as they\nlike. The brain of two hemispheres, the heart, the lungs, and other internal\norgans and systems of man (as, incidentally, of other individuals of the\nanimal world) likewise represent bipolar spiral structures (see Fig. 1).\nOn the other hand, it is precisely this mode of interaction of the foundational\ncomponents of the said relation {content/form} that ensures the novelty,\nuniqueness, and irreversibility of the development and evolution of forms, as\nwell as the inexhaustible diversity of the latter.\nAs already noted above, in this way the components-constituents in the\nrelation {content/form} interact with each other, submitting to the \"dictate\"\nof the objective tendency with directionality toward becoming each other and\nabsorbing each other completely and without residue.\nHowever, if one gives preference only to this point of view on development\nas the movement of the foundational principles-components of reality only in\nthe direction of convergence and reunification (i.e., thereby dooming\neverything visibly existing to a supposedly obvious end and degeneration into\nidentity), — then how can one explain the presence and the tireless,\nunceasing replenishment and renewal of opposites (\"dissimilarities\") and\n\n\ftheir inexhaustible interaction and opposition in the surrounding world? In\nwhat way does the inexhaustible difference then arise and manifest itself\nunder the conditions of the total striving of everything toward unification and\ncoincidence proclaimed here?\nHowever paradoxical this may seem, it is precisely by virtue of such a\nnaturally conditioned character of movement (striving) that renewed\nextremes, opposites, and their opposition can only arise and manifest\nthemselves. The interaction of two initial extremes, of two non-coinciding\nprinciples, of two \"sworn\" competitors, of two unequal and non-equivalent\nforms generates something third, a certain new form, which, along with the\ncontent and attributes \"absorbed\" into itself of the interacting initial forms,\nsimultaneously bears in itself also the difference from each of them. [For this\nreason, in particular, the \"holistic\" assertion that the whole is always greater\nthan the sum of its parts is not without foundation.]\nIt is precisely the striving of two unequal, non-identical competing\nconstituents of one relation to become each other in the course of their\ninteraction (see Fig. 1) that leads to the emergence of something third,\ncoinciding neither with the first nor with the second. In other words, the\nmovement of content through the encompassment and absorption into itself\nof the content of previous forms constantly generates dissimilarity to\neverything preceding, i.e., novelty and uniqueness. But this very\ndifference arising \"in continuation,\" simultaneously or \"in parallel,\" acquires,\nin essence, also the form of a new, next opposite, which immediately begins\nto oppose everything existing (and preceding) and, again, to enter into\ninteraction with it.\nThus, under the declared striving toward unity and coincidence, difference\nand dissimilarity (novelty) arise each time as if automatically and derivatively\nwith respect to the more primordial, more initial, more fundamental and\npriority movement toward identity. On the other hand, this derivatively\nobtained non-coincidence, in turn, proves to be the cause and ground for the\nexcitation of the next \"act\" of movement (striving) in the same direction\ntoward unification, which again, in its turn, generates a new portion of\ndifference and novelty, serving as the condition for the continuation of the\n\"conflict,\" competition, interaction, etc., etc. — to infinity in its process of\nquantitative and qualitative renewal. The very divergence into extremes and\nopposites is a consequence of the preceding and simultaneously a cause and\ncondition for initiating the subsequent movement in the same initially\ndetermined direction — toward the mutual transition and coincidence of\nextremes, toward their \"drawing together into a point.\" [Let us note that the\nlatter is not asserted (and not imposed) as a final result and achieved goal,\nbut is considered only as an understood and comprehended objective\ntendency that subordinates to itself the course of all processes without\nexception — as an asymptotic relative movement toward a certain absolute,\nbut never attained limit.]\n\n\fIt is superfluous to mention that representations of spiral development are\nas old as the world and there is no novelty in these representations. What\nis new and curious — is in the description of the \"mechanism\" that produces\nspiral-cyclical movement, i.e., in the description of the functioning of the\ninternal source of such movement.\nHeraclitus's saying is widely known that everything flows, everything\nchanges. But WHERE all this flows and changes — until now there have been\nno clear representations. Only today does the possibility open up to answer\nthis question more or less intelligibly. Today we can meaningfully determine\nourselves with respect to the vector of this universal movement: everywhere\nand always there takes place a total multilevel movement in the direction of\nachieving the highest level of contentfulness (see formulation @).\nEverything without exception is permeated by the striving and embraced by\nthe movement in the direction of possessing the highest contentfulness. By\nthis vector of universal movement are determined the causality, meanings,\nand goals: of life, development, evolution, history, etc. — i.e., of the being\nand existence of anything whatsoever, in whatever forms.\nThe formulation of the principle of self-development @ gives an idea of the\n\"unidirectionality\" and \"multilevelness\" of development, i.e., firstly, of the\nuniqueness of each of the arising and developing forms-levels (which\nfundamentally levels the centrism of any form whatsoever, including\nbiocentrism, anthropocentrism, theocentrism, sociocentrism, etc.), and,\nsecondly, of the universality of the mechanism of movement-development of\nall forms at their levels (which, at last, throws the long-awaited bridge\nbetween the levels of the non-living, the living, and thinking, extremely in\ndemand and necessary for the formation of integral and adequate\nrepresentations of the world).\nBy virtue of the inexhaustibility of the interconnection of the contentful and\nformal constituent sides in the relation {content/form} noted above,\nwhatever relative independence the contentful constituent may possess,\nnevertheless it too cannot manifest (and keep manifesting) itself otherwise\nthan through form. Therefore, despite the leadership and seeming autonomy\nof the active contentful side at all levels of development, as the contentful\nconstituent at any of the levels can act, again, only forms (such is the\nessence of the \"eternal curse\" imposed on content — to be burdened with\nform, if one paraphrases Marx's well-known expression about the relation of\nspirit and matter [8, p. 29]). Thus, in both cases (both in the case of the\nactive \"contentful\" constituent and in the case of the passive \"formal\" side) in\nreality one has to deal with changing and developing forms, by which one\nshould understand all sorts of structures and formations of different\n(objective and subjective) levels of reality of varying degrees of\ncontentfulness (both in macro- and microscopic executions).\nRealizing the total unitary directionality of all real processes, exhibited by\nformulation @, it is nevertheless necessary to take into account that at each\n\n\fof its levels of movement the dominant active contentful constituent\n(contentfulness) has its own special (specific) forms of representation.\nA). At the level of non-living nature — this is, as a rule, the energy of the\nSun and of space (light, heat, radiation, gravitation, high-energy particles),\nelectrical energy, the chemical energy of oxidation-reduction reactions, etc.\nB). At the level of living inanimate nature, in addition to what is named\nabove in point A — these are nutrients (from the composition of soil, water,\nair, combustion products), food (plant and animal), the flow of blood (in\nliving organisms), the genetic program, reflex-psychic activity, instincts, etc.\nC). At the level of human and social nature, in addition to what is named\nabove at the two previous levels A and B — these are mineral resources, fuel\n(coal, oil, gas and their industrial derivatives), the human resource (muscular\nforce, spiritual and moral forces, creative and intellectual potential), products\nof human activity and thinking (image, idea, notions, tool, money, capital,\nfinancial and information flows), etc. In other words, at the level of man and\nsociety the same active contentful constituent circulates in the form of the\nforms enumerated in the two previous points A and B, with the addition of\nhuman-mediated forms (including the forms of all sorts of products of human\nactivity and thinking — technologies and ideologies).\n[Additional commentary to the three last paragraphs above. From the\nstandpoint of this concept we proceed from the fact that various kinds of\nenergy, food (nutrients), money (financial flows), information (the\ninformation field), etc. — these are merely various forms of movement of\nthe active contentful constituent of the relation {content/form} at\ndifferent levels of reality. Thus, at the level of non-living nature the active\ncontentful constituent circulates in the form (in the forms) of, chiefly, solar\nand cosmic energy. A derivative and variety of such circulation flows is\nelectrical and chemical (of oxidation-reduction reactions, etc.) energy. At the\nlevel of living inanimate nature, to the above-enumerated circulation flows\n(continuing their natural transformations also at this level) is added the\ncirculation of the following basic contentful forms: nutrients from the\ncomposition of soil, water, air, and combustion products; nutrients from the\ncomposition of the soil, plant and animal food; the flow of blood of animals;\nthe genetic matrix, instinctive and reflex activity of the living, etc. And,\nfinally, at the level of man, human thinking, and society — this is, in addition\nto the above-enumerated flows at the two preceding levels, the circulation of\nthe contentful component in such forms as human-mediated energy of\nmineral resources and their industrial derivatives (metals, minerals, fuel,\netc.), the human resource (in the form of muscular energy, spiritual and\nmoral forces, intellectual potential), products of human activity and thinking\n(tool, money, capital, financial and information flows, ideas, notions,\ntheories, teachings, i.e., in the most general form — technologies and\nideologies), etc. Here it is necessary to note that everything enumerated\nabove from the most widespread forms of movement and circulation of the\n\n\factive contentful constituent at the aforementioned levels — these are only\n\"reference points\" in the general aggregate of such forms; guided by this\napproach, every inquisitive mind will be able to discover also many other\nactive forms of different levels of contentfulness, also submitting in their\nmovement to the single principle @.]\nAs can be seen on the basis of the analysis of the formulation of the principle\nof self-development @, the question of the essence of development is not\nexhausted by the understanding of development as the complication of\nforms, or as the action of the great biological law of complication, or as the\ncausal continuous complication of matter, etc. [4; 9; 11] (these explanations\nand definitions of the essence of development dominating in the scholarly\nmilieu are capable today of satisfying at most a housewife); the essence of\nany development consists in the achievement by forms of different levels of\ndevelopment of the highest contentfulness for each level, which is\nexpressed (and ensured) by the movement of forms in the direction of\npossessing the maximally possible contentfulness at their levels.\nThe formulated principle of self-development @ is universal; all processes\nwithout exception at all levels of reality known to us are subordinated to it\nand governed by it: at the level of non-living nature, at the level of living\ninanimate nature, and, finally, at the level of man, human thinking, and\nsociety, which can be confirmed and interpreted by diverse factual material,\nincluding simple examples from everyday life [1; 20].\nBelow, on numerous examples, we will show — how this internal principle of\nself-development \"works\" in different areas and at different levels of the\nacquisition of changing reality.\nWhy, then, are the concepts of such an obvious spiral movementdevelopment-evolution of forms considered obsolete today, are examined\nand discussed reluctantly, and are sometimes subjected to harsh criticism on\nthe part of the official scholarly community? Specialists on questions of\nevolution substantiate their disagreement with concepts of this kind by the\nfact that in none of the developing forms (objects, processes, phenomena)\ndoes the course of their development resemble (and reduce to) in pure form\nan ascending classical spiral, and in the majority of analyzed cases this spiral\nis distorted and interrupted by segments of some straight lines unlike spiral\nones (indicating the movement-development of forms by a certain \"inertia\"),\nhorizontal plateaus (symbolizing the stagnation of forms) and, finally,\ndescending segments (meaning regression, depression, decline, etc.).\nIndeed, in the study of the evolution of real forms, obvious deviations from\nthe spiral character of their development are observed and recorded at every\nturn, and therefore, probably, the collective spiral as an indicative external\nform of expression of any development recedes into the background.\n\n\fAt that, however, the scholarly community loses sight of the following\ncircumstance. As already noted above, the spiral contentful movement has as\nits reverse visible side the formation of new and the filling with content of\nrenewing forms. In other words, the reverse side of the implicit, hidden\nmovement of content in the direction @ proves to be the inevitable\nemergence and manifestation of modified and new forms of different levels\nfilled with content, visible and registered by human consciousness, which, as\nthey arise and are modified, enter into interaction with each other,\ncontinuing their movement-development in accordance with formulation @.\nAnd this objectively conditioned movement toward the increment of\ncontentfulness of any and every interacting form, which, as already noted\nabove, is characteristic of all levels-forms without exception, is accompanied\nby the total competition of forms (as if we were speaking of participants\nin a race to a single finish).\nNot having other sources for replenishing and building up their content\nexcept other similar forms, all forms, in the name of ensuring their own\nmovement and development under the \"dictate\" of principle @, are forced to\nenter into a harsh competitive struggle \"for survival\" with the forms\nsurrounding them, the outcome of which proves to be either continuing\ndevelopment, or the perishing and \"tearing apart\" into parts (absorption and\nassimilation by competitors) of this or that form. Regression, by and large\nand on a universal scale, does not happen!\nBy virtue of the mutual total, universal, and wholesale competition of forms\nstriving toward one \"goal,\" which is determined again by the principle of selfdevelopment @, forms \"withdraw\" from each other and \"appropriate\" for\nthemselves everything that lends itself to withdrawal and appropriation. The\n\"uncontrolled\" taking away and annexation of portions of content takes place\nat different levels and in different chains of development. At that, the objects\nof multilevel taking-away-appropriation prove to be quanta of energy,\nelectrons, ions, genes, chromosomes, cells, portions of substance, objects,\nideas, bits of information, name, glory, reputation, ideologies, technologies,\nand entire fortunes (everything, as in real life!). As the experience of\nnumerous and many-year observations shows, when one form \"weakens\"\nand \"dies\" — somewhere nearby (inside or outside) another begins to \"assert\nitself\" and \"flourish.\" Stagnation or regression of any form means an\nincrement of content in some of its neighbors (and perhaps not exactly\nneighbors). As soon as at any form at any of its sublevels the initiative is\nsubstantially \"intercepted,\" the \"tearing apart\" of the content of this form at\nall its other sublevels and sub-sublevels immediately begins — up to the\ncomplete liquidation of this form and the assimilation of its content by other\nforms. That is why one level-form can quite unexpectedly fade or disappear,\nand another begin to develop and modify spontaneously.\nThus, universal and wholesale stagnation or regression does not happen, but\nalways and everywhere there take place only content-form transformations\n(or, speaking in the habitual \"school\" language, — the transition of the\ncontentful constituent from one form into another, i.e., from level to level),\n\n\fduring which the decline or loss of content by one form are signs of the\ninterception of this content and its annexation to itself by another form.\nWhich of the forms, of what level, at what segment or stage of its\ndevelopment will hold out in the unceasing competitive struggle and continue\n(possibly even more intensively, with a \"leap\") its further development, and\nwhich will disappear forever — it is extremely difficult to predict; for, by\nvirtue of universal competition and total rivalry, the process of the\nevolution of forms does not have the appearance of a straight high road and\ndoes not fall under the definition of a strictly \"tree-like\" process (as is noted\nby modern leading evolutionists [18]), but is realized by the method of\n\"punctuated gradualism\" with the recreation and reproduction of a \"mosaic\"\npicture of development. That is why (namely — owing to such \"pressure\nacross the whole field\") any and every of the existing and developing forms\n(including humanity when colliding with the so-called challenges and threats\nfrom the side of both other forms of the surrounding world and man himself)\nhas to prove every moment its competitiveness, viability, and right to further\nexistence and development.\nIn the end, against the background of the general single regularity that lies\nat the basis of the change-movement-development-evolution of all forms\nwithout exception and is called the principle of self-development @, the\ninterference and mutual intervention of forms (in line with the same regular\nstriving of theirs toward the appropriation and annexation to themselves of\nportions of content by taking these portions away from other forms) lead to\nthe chaoticness and spontaneity of the movement of individual forms, which\nleads to the visible distortion of the general picture of development by\ninclusions of deviations from the general regularities. The implicitly\nexpressed cause of the departure from the regularities of development\n(determined by principle @), which (cause) is the interference-intervention of\nforms in each other's spiral development, has received (both in science and\nin everyday usage) the name of the all-reconciling, all-explaining, and allforgiving chance.\nMay the reader forgive some figurative expressions and free analogies used\nin the article to simplify the real picture with the aim of facilitating the\nexamination of the essence of the relations under consideration, — the\nFrench, for example, when encountering deviations of this kind in the\nbehavior of men, habitually say: \"Cherchez la femme\" (\"Look for the\nwoman\"). With respect to this context, i.e., in a broader sense, this means:\nlook for the form (or forms) from the near and far surroundings that draws\nonto itself, \"snatches away,\" and annexes to itself portions of \"alien\" content,\nthereby distorting the universally spiral configuration (with respect to\nindividual fragments of the general picture) of regular development. It is\nprecisely the total competition of forms unitarily oriented in their movement\nthat violates the decorous regularity and predictability of the trajectory of\ntheir development. Not seeing all this background, human consciousness in\nthe person of the scholarly community for that very reason does not wish to\n\n\frecognize the spiral character of development as the only essential and really\nrealized mode of evolutionary movement.\nWe will not fail to add that the above-stated fully applies also to man as a\nmultilevel natural formation, as an aggregate of a huge number of concrete\nrelations (of different levels and different contentful filling) of the same\nomnipresent abstract components {content/form}. The failures, illnesses,\nmiscalculations, and errors accompanying man throughout life are the result\nof the taking-away-appropriation of portions of his own multilevel content\n(from the category of energy resources of flesh and spirit, food, blood,\nmoney, capitals, ideas, knowledge, technologies, information, etc.), carried\nout (we are speaking of the taking-away-appropriation) by multilevel forms\n(both \"internal\" and \"external\") from among the forms of his near and far\nsurroundings. The complexity of the analysis of the development of such\nsystems is conditioned by the unimaginable interweaving of the\nsimultaneously interacting aforementioned levels-relations, as well as by the\ninseparability of the components of these relations; the said elements are so\ninterwoven with each other and coiled into such an \"ugly\" tangle that for the\ncorrect untangling of the tangle universal patience and exemplary accuracy\nare required.\n[The mentioned complexity is a consequence, firstly, of the natural, objective\nblurriness and fuzziness of the boundary between the constituentscomponents examined by us in their concrete relations and the most general\nrelation {content/form} and, secondly, a consequence of the infinity of the\nrepresentation of any and every form, including the \"numerators\" and\n\"denominators\" of the relations under consideration, the same thing in the\nform of similar relations, and, correspondingly, of the unthinkable\ninterweaving of all these relations and their components with each other. The\nlevels of development are often inseparable, not detachable from each other\nbecause the contentful constituent, say, of one level can at one and the same\ntime (in interconnection) prove to be the formal constituent for another level,\nand vice versa. And also because the contentful constituent of one level\nnecessarily represents a new relation {content/form} for another level. The\nsame should be said about any formal constituent. But the main obstacle on\nthe path of clear understanding of the course of the process of development\nand of its precise formulations consists in the fact that the natural boundary\nbetween the components-constituents \"content\" and \"form\" in their relation\nis difficult to distinguish, and sometimes simply not perceivable (for the time\nbeing). Thus, the ingrowing of levels-forms into each other and their growing\nout of one another is precisely the cause of the impossibility of singling out\nany of them in \"pure\" form].\nAnalogous reasoning, but with the opposite sign, can be adduced with\nrespect to the ascending segments of intensive development of any form (as\nof any organism, including man) — at such stages of its life path any form,\nbeing an active contentful link and on the rise, itself successfully performs\n\n\fthe taking-away and appropriation of contentful portions\ncomposition of the forms of its near and far surroundings.\n\nfrom\n\nthe\n\nIt should be especially noted that the principle of self-development is\nunconditional and non-relative, and this circumstance is emphasized by the\ncontent of its formulation @. The \"activity\" described by the presented\nformulation is inherent in all levels of reality without exception and can be\ncharacterized as \"blind,\" since in its initial foundational form it contains\nneither explicit features nor explicit shades of goal-setting. Shades of goalsetting and expediency of attitudes clearly manifest themselves only at quite\ndefinite levels of quite concrete forms of realization of this principle,\nbeginning with the forms of higher animals, where the intensity of\ncontent-form transformations is substantially higher than the intensity of\nsimilar transformations at the preceding levels.\nIn other words, by virtue of the noted heightened intensity of content-form\ntransformations at the levels of animal forms and man in comparison with\nthe speed of similar transformations at other levels-forms, the omnipresence\nof the said principle is guessed and fixed by human consciousness from a\ncertain time ever more and more definitely, which testifies to its (of the\nprinciple) unconditionality and non-relativity contrary to the erroneous\nopinion about the endowment with the capacity for goal-setting of only some\n\"higher\" levels. This, so-called, goal-setting (return to oneself at a new level,\nfeedback, reflection) is simply still very weakly manifested at the \"lower\"\nlevels of the development of reality owing to the small intensity of contentform transformations at these levels (i.e., by virtue of the small curvature of\nthe spiral coils of development of these levels). In actual fact, this internal\nprinciple is immanent to all levels of the development of reality\nwithout exception.\nIndependently of us and our preferences, the source of the development of\nconcrete forms-relations at all levels of the organization of reality known to\nus (quantum [15], atomic, molecular, cellular, tissue, organ, organismic,\nsocial) is served by the same principle @, which remains \"through-going\" for\nall levels of contentful movement; only the forms of realization of this\nprinciple at different levels change, owing to the growth of the intensity of\ncontent-form transitions from level to level.\nThus, the Universe (as an aggregate of non-living and living formsformations, including thinking) from the standpoint and in the light of this\nconcept — is a gigantic, majestic, multilevel content-form transition\nstretched over billions of years (more precisely, a chain or sequence of\ntransitional forms of different levels) in the already known direction @ (i.e.,\nin the ultimate expression the world, the Universe — this is precisely the\n\"self-winding\" content of \"all-embracing\" scale, see the simplified visual\nthree-dimensional model of the unfolding process in Fig. 1, approximately\nreproducing the picture of real \"universal\" relations). The starry sky — this is\nan instantaneous \"slice\" of the forms-traces of the parallel-sequential\n\n\fmovement of \"content,\" grasped and fixed by human consciousness at one\nmoment. The host of worlds hanging above us — these are intermediate\nlayers-stages-levels-forms of the passage of contentful activity, but not in\nthe form corresponding to the initial moment of its sequential movementpassage through the mentioned stages-forms, but in the form of something\nalready \"become\" and developed by virtue of the unceasing parallelcontinued and continuing since that moment contentful \"winding\" of these\nforms. At that, the conditionally-final link of the development of contentful\nactivity in the person of us (humanity) — is also merely an intermediate form\nof expression or representation of this activity, which, after the passed\nstages-levels of \"non-living\" forms, passed also through the stages of more\nmobile forms — \"living-biological,\" and further — \"living-thinking-animated.\"\nToday's we (humanity) have reached in our mental development such a level\nwhen we can quite well imagine ourselves in the role of a sort of \"contentful\nmollusk\" located \"in the shell\" of an all-round \"expanding form\" (the\nUniverse) and attempting, as the most contentful link (of those reliably\nknown to us at the current moment), to comprehend, to cognize (i.e., to fill\nwith content and true meaning) that chain of forms which we have \"passed\"\nbefore this since the time of the Big Bang. In turn, that \"expanding form\"\nonce passed by us strives after us (and, in essence, toward us) for\nreunification with us and the possession of our contentful principle. In actual\nfact, we, as the next form of the contentful principle, attempting to close this\ncoil, unwind it again, but already at a qualitatively different (new) level. At\nthat, we equally have no grounds to assert both that the sequential\ncontentful movement ends with us (humanity) and that we (humanity) are\nthe crown of all development, and that an analogous kind of movement of\ncontentful activity did not take place before the moment of the so-called Big\nBang and does not take place after the appearance of us (humanity).\nThe awareness of this circumstance, as it were, formally closes the next\n\"circle\" of cognition and opens a new stage-coil of qualitatively different\ninvestigations of the Universe and the evolutionary movement.\nContentful stratifications contribute to the change of the intensity of the\nstriving of content \"to itself at a new level\" or, in other words, to the change\nof the curvature of the coil of the spiral of development, — and it is chiefly by\nthe values of these characteristics that one level of development differs from\nanother. Whether we understand this or not as people, whether the dog and\nthe ant \"want\" this or not as an animal and an insect, whether the river, the\nocean, the mountain, the planet Earth, the Milky Way, or the Universe visible\nand thinkable by us \"know\" about this or not — independently of this,\neverything enumerated is in the movement described by formulation @.\nBy the way, when attempting to depict or reproduce in the minutest details\nthe most intimate moment of the mutual transition of content into form and\nvice versa with the help of, for example, pencil and paper, — your hand will\nunfailingly draw something resembling an apple, a pear, a leaf of a plant, a\n\n\fheart, or anything else in a similar vein (for schematic clarity one can\nrecommend for viewing the video clip [19]). This circumstance allows one to\ndiscern in the actions of nature a process analogous in directionality, namely\n— with stubborn periodic constancy, mother living nature herself, year after\nyear over hundreds of millions of years, solves the same task that you have\nintended to solve as well.\nApples, pears, acorns, grains, seeds, leaves, grass, flowers, bushes, trees,\nanimals with their mirror symmetry-asymmetry of forms-bodies (see Fig. 1),\nas well as the naturally conditioned relation {man/woman} continuing this\nsame list, etc., etc. — all these \"living\" attributes by their obvious external\nappearance and internal structure point to the uniform unitary directionality\nof natural processes, which have as their background the interaction of two\nconstituent sides-components of a single whole — the relation\n{content/form}. And just as you, she (nature) in no way succeeds in\nmastering the moment of the content-form mutual transition finally and\nirrevocably, since the very unattainability and unrealizability of the moment\nof the exhaustive expression of content by form, the very indeterminacy of\nthis moment (in view of the presence of the so-called step or gap in the place\nof the supposed closure of the \"circle,\" but of the actual transformation of the\n\"circle into a spiral,\" see Fig. 1) is precisely the main condition, the moving\nforce, the motive, the stimulus, the cause of the non-stopness,\ninexhaustibility, and unfathomability of the movement and development of\neverything existing. The moment of indeterminacy is also an objective and\ninalienable element of any development!\nIn an analogous manner proceed the processes (movement, flowing-over,\nand mutual transition of notions and images) also at the level of thinking. At\nthe seemingly attained moment of \"victory\" it is suddenly discovered that\nyou have expressed and comprehended by your thinking not quite what you\nwere exerting yourself to do a moment earlier, but stand at the source of\nsomething else, which is no longer the crown of the preceding, but is the\nbeginning of a new something; i.e., you and your thinking are simply thrown\nout onto a new coil, onto a new level, toward a new understanding, toward\nrefined-renewed notions and representations, and you are forced to continue\nthe begun movement in the direction of comprehending and shaping the\ncontinually slipping-away content (in the guise of a promising thought or a\ncoveted-sought meaning), but already on a new coil and at a new level...\nAnd there is no \"return\" road, since along the road \"there\" in the direct\ndirection you and your thinking have managed to change, to grow over, to\naccrete, to enrich yourselves with new contentful details, to \"shake off\" which\nand return to the former state there is no possibility whatsoever.\nProcesses similar in character proceed also in the milieu at the level of\nsociety; moreover, on the example of the development of social relations this\nshows through especially prominently. The confrontation (competition,\nrivalry) of, say, ideological schemes (ideologies) or the geopolitical opposition\nof states and peoples, the movement from a unipolar to a multipolar world\nand vice versa, the emergence and resolution of revolutionary situations —\n\n\fall this also belongs to the external manifestations of the development of the\nrelations of the aforementioned contentful and formal constituent sides (see\nFig. 1), but already at other levels and, correspondingly, in other specific\nforms.\nThe confrontation of ideas and ideologies — this is the highest (from the\npoint of view of human consciousness) level-form of contentful movement of\nthe levels-forms known to us today. The difference in ideologies, i.e., the\nvisible distinction of competing and opposing forms in their relations at this\nor that level, is conditioned by the internal functional distinctions of the\nactive (often aggressive) and passive (conservative) components of these\nrelations. And for a whole series of individuals (and their communities),\nparticipation in confrontation at such a \"high\" level will be more attractive\nthan interest in the results and consequences of movement and\ntransformations at other, more \"primitive\" (say, physiological, including the\nstriving toward satiety, physiological pleasures, bodily comfort) levels. And\ntherefore the human striving toward ideological victory, intellectual or moral\nsuperiority, spiritual greatness in many cases takes the upper hand and\nproves to be more priority than the striving toward physical well-being.\nEverywhere and always, at all levels without exception, there takes place\nthe wholesale, total competition (from soft \"sporting\" contest and rivalry to\nmerciless struggle) of forms for the possession of the highest level of\ncontentfulness; from the standpoint of human thinking, the level of the\nhighest rank and fullness of embodiment of accumulated contentfulness\ntoday is precisely the ideological level.\nProceeding from these representations and the understanding of the essence\nof the problem, it proves simpler to build an adequate model of the\nopposition and interaction of geopolitical antipodes (two branches of the coil\nof the spiral of development, see Fig. 1) in their relation of confrontation\n(conflicts, wars) and simultaneous closest interconnection with each other;\non this same basis it is easier to forecast and direct the efforts of competing\nhuman communities toward the achievement of a balance of interests, social\njustice, and harmony.\nAll nature, the whole world throughout its existence solves in fact all the\nsame, one and the same task — of the exhaustive expression of developing\ncontent by a moving form, spirally ascending by means of some of its\nelements (shoots, offshoots, curls), and the final solution of this task has not\nexisted, nor does it exist. To see this all-absorbing movement, one needs\nonly to look more intently at the world surrounding us, equally as at\nourselves. All the more so since thinking is already \"pregnant\" with this\nconcept; sooner or later this approach will be laid at the basis of a new\nworld-understanding. Humanity will be forced to pass over to the practical\napplication of the new model in the name of ensuring its own survival (as a\nseparate definite level-form) in the competitive struggle and interaction with\nall the other forms-levels surrounding it. Year after year this is demonstrated\never more prominently by the rapidly growing ecological dependence and\n\n\fvulnerability of man; for the following of the imperative of maintaining\necological equilibrium in the system {man/nature} is nothing other than the\npainful search by human thinking of the optimal (i.e., the most contentful\nfor every concrete level-stage of development) dialectically verified\ncorrelation (relative balance) between the contentful and formal\ncomponents in this system.\nThe new approach simultaneously testifies both to the limited applicability of\nthe currently dominant anthropocentric (including sociocentric, and\ntheocentric, if you will) model of the world, and to the necessity of transition\nto another, more integral and adequate model of it. Moreover, outside this\napproach humanity will not be able even correctly to untie the knot of the\naggravating internal contradictions between the components in the relation\n{West/East}, let alone effectively compete with the forms-levels of its\nexternal surroundings (from the composition of the planetary natural\nenvironment, and then of near and far space). And, finally, this concept\nknocks the ground out from under the feet of any and every fanaticism and\nterrorism: there are no objective grounds for any exclusivity and \"Godchosenness.\" Nazism, religious fundamentalism, \"American exceptionalism,\"\nor \"Banderism\" (implying the illusory racial, religious, intellectual, or any\nother superiority of one nation or confession over another) are based on the\nexcessive absolutization and unjustified centrism of their forms. No\nexclusivity whatsoever is realizable in principle by reason of the limitedness\nand transient character of any and every form; this conclusion must be\nbrought demonstratively to the consciousness of people in order thereby to\nliquidate worldview illiteracy.\nThe algorithm of development is common and universal for all levels-forms,\nfrom the photon to the most intricate notional schemes and constructions in\nthe heads of individual individuals: new content will always strive to acquire\na new form, and forms — to be filled, to be enriched with new content.\nHence — the vortex movement of everything and all. The concept\nmerely notes the typical, standard character of the course of things at all\nlevels: the universal, generalized relation {content/form} is clothed at each\nconcrete level in its own concrete form and \"marches\" in a through-going\nmanner across the levels in the direction of the replacement of forms by ever\nmore and more contentful ones.\nBehind each concrete relation-form from the series of such, for example,\nconcrete\nrelations\nas:\n{movement/rest},\n{time/space},\n{acceleration/gravitation},\n{energy/mass},\n{field/substance},\n{continuity/discreteness}, {wave/corpuscle}, {negative charge/positive\ncharge}, {seed/fruit}, {male/female}, {masculine principle/feminine\nprinciple},\n{spirit/flesh},\n{personality/society},\n{politics/economics},\n{liberalism/conservatism},\n{enterprise/inertness},\n{intuition/logic},\n{subjective/objective},\n{abstract/concrete},\n{function/structure},\n{process/result},\n{quality/quantity},\n{change/basis},\n{active\nprinciple/passive principle}, etc., etc., — hides the most abstract relation of\n\n\fthe components {content/form}. And now the investigation of the prospects\nof change, movement, development of the endless number of diverse\nconcrete relations conditioning the existence of various areas of\nmultilevel reality can be conducted already with the understanding of the\nessence of this movement-development, i.e., more effectively.\nWith respect to all concrete forms-relations (including the above-enumerated\nset), the noted movement @ in the direction of achieving the highest\ncontentfulness means that in the course of the development and evolution of\nconcrete forms-relations there is observed a shift toward the increase of the\n\"specific weight,\" role, and significance of the contentful component (i.e., the\n\"numerator\" of the relation) in the composition of concrete forms-relations.\nAt that, the previously formed correlation or established balance of the\nconstituents (components) in their concrete relations is little by little violated,\nwhich periodically requires the search and establishment of a new\ncorrelation, a new position of the boundary of division between the\ncomponents in the concrete relations-forms changing in this way.\nIn the course of studying the regularities of the development of relations of\nthis kind, the role and purpose of dialectics itself becomes clearer — as the\nart of seeking out and establishing the correct correlation (or balanced\nposition of the boundary of division) between the constituent sides in their\nconcrete relations, conditioned (we are speaking of the correct correlation)\neach time by a definite stage of the development of each concrete relation\n(i.e., by its definite location in the chain of development). Until now and to\nthis day the said task (of determining the correct correlation between the\ncomponents in concrete relations) has been solved and is being solved\nexclusively intuitively, by touch, empirically... The concept, however, allows\nand proposes to do this more consciously, with the attraction of the\nenormous potential of human thinking, thereby ensuring the competitiveness\nof humanity in the confrontation with other forms-levels rivaling it.\nThus, everything particular and concrete — these are separate forms into\nwhich the generalized abstract form of the relation {content/form} examined\nby us \"dresses itself\" in the process of its evolutionary movement @ through\nthe levels.\nAcquaintance with the concept, which discovers the omnipresent presence of\ncontent-form transformations of known directionality, allows one to look with\ndifferent eyes both at the Chizhevsky cycles, and at the Kondratiev cycles,\nand at Mendeleev's periodic law, and at the true roots of holism and\nBogdanov's tectology, and at the phenomena of similarity, fractality, the\nanthropic principle, and at the meaning of the golden section, and at the\nessence of world constants, and at the numerous physical laws of\nconservation (of substance, energy, momentum, charge, parity,\nstrangeness), and at the gender relations {men/women} [1, p. 55], and at\nthe symmetry-asymmetry of the world (including the mirror and \"chiral\"\nsymmetry of the forms of the animal world, of man, of his brain, internal\norgans and systems [1, pp. 13, 14, 25]), etc., etc.\n\n\fLet us show in the most general terms (without detailing) the \"work\" of the\nmodel {content/form} and of the principle of self-development on the\nexample of tracking the modifications of the forms of the animal world\n(including man).\nMollusks with their spiral-shaped shells — perhaps the most visual ancient\nspecimens of content-form transformations in the course of the movement\nand development of the contentful constituent of reality at the level of the\n\"living.\"\nThe mirror symmetry of living beings (the non-identity of the left and right\nhalves of the body) likewise personifies nothing other than the content-form\ninteraction of two sides, of two opposing components of one whole\n(organism) in the course of the entire life cycle of the individual (we are\nspeaking of insects, reptiles, fish, birds, mammals, etc.). The mirror-reflected\nparts (branches of the coil of the spiral, see Fig. 1) of living organisms\nalternately, in the process of the life of the individual, perform functions of\neither a \"purely formal\" or a \"more contentful\" character.\nThe interaction of the mirror halves of a living individual accompanies the\ngrowth (accumulation) of the volume and the maturation of the deep content\nup to the moment of the transfer of this accumulated contentful volume in a\n\"coiled,\" compressed, concentrated form to its offspring. Further, contentform transformations accompany the process of the mating of individuals,\nthe fertilization of the egg (ovum), the origination of a new phase of the\ncontentful principle and the continuation of its further movement in the same\ndirection, but at a new stage (coil) of its development. Most prominently this\nprocess is represented by the widely known examples of the metamorphosis\nof insects (butterfly — egg — caterpillar — chrysalis — new butterfly).\nAn ant, a dog, a man — these are \"shortened\" spiral coils of the forms of\nreality, manifested correspondingly to different stages-levels of its\ndevelopment. If for the non-living (and even for some early, simplest forms\nof the living) one still has to contrive to discern this spiral coil (by virtue of its\nsmall curvature-intensity of development), then for developed living forms it\nis manifested in the most visual way and is too obvious.\nThe opposition of the left and right halves of living beings (which is most\nexpressed in animals) unmasks the interaction of the contentful and formal\nhalves of the coil in the process of the existence and development of the\norganism (see Fig. 1) and makes this interaction, like the coil itself,\nmaximally visual and obvious. At that, the symmetry and equilibrium of the\nleft and right halves of the organism — are only seeming; in actual fact this\nis the asymmetry of two competing, non-identical, non-equivalent\nconstituents-sides of one whole (Fig. 1), ensuring the movementdevelopment of the organism as a whole.\n\n\fFor the entire animal world (including man) one can reveal, trace, and\ndescribe the content-form transformations in the most generalized form: the\nmovement of content against the background of the content-form interaction\nof visually symmetric parts of the organism; further, the interaction of the\ncomponents of \"content\" and \"form\" at the level of the relation\n{male/female}: mating, fertilization of the ovum, and the birth of a new\ncontentful link in the form of offspring; and as a continuation — the\nreproduction of the next similar coil of content-form relations at a new level.\nMoreover, the absorption of one form by another form (the eating of living\nforms) in the process of the life cycle of the individual and the enrichment\n(feeding, nourishment) thereby of the developing content — also constitute\nthe essence of content-form transformations at the level of the living.\nThe veil of mystery over the relations between man and woman (as two\n\"halves\" of the single whole of the relation {man/woman} — see Fig. 1), the\nsacraments of love and the continuation of the human race (including the\nacts of conception, the development of the embryo in the maternal womb,\nthe birth of a child — see Fig. 1), as, incidentally, the riddles of gender\nrelations as a whole, — becomes more transparent in the light of the\nrepresentations of the content-form movement determined by model @.\nAt that, the development of each smaller fragment (constituent part) of this\nprocess, in turn, can be examined (and requires examination) from the\nstandpoints of relations of similar sides (an example of this is, say, the\ncontent-form interaction of the branches of the spiral of the DNA molecule\nthroughout its life cycle, the replication of molecules, the division of cells,\netc.); processes of the same directionality proceed at the cellular, tissue,\norgan levels of living organisms, as well as at the atomic and molecular\nlevels of organic and inorganic nature.\nThe incomprehensible until now natural symmetry of the \"left\" and \"right\"\n(characterized\nby\nthe\nnon-coincidence,\nopposition,\nand\nmutual\ncomplementation of the symmetric parts of the whole, and not only in the\ncase of mirror, \"chiral,\" or circular symmetry, but also in the case of other\ntypes of symmetry, including the specific symmetries of the physics of\nelementary particles and quantum mechanics), the interaction of electric\ncharges and the phenomena of electromagnetic nature, the formulations of\nvarious laws of conservation and the conditions of the achievement of\nequilibrium or balance of the quantities (components-constituents-sides) of\nthe relations under consideration in different areas of reality, the phenomena\nof all sorts of \"periodic laws\" and \"similarity\" (including the so-called\n\"fractality\" and \"anthropic principle\") also conceal in their depth the presence\nand development of spiral-cyclical content-form transformations of known\ndirectionality. [At that, owing to the \"liveliness\" and inexhaustibility of the\nmentioned relations-transitions, symmetry inevitably transforms into\nasymmetry, and the laws of conservation are violated at every turn, i.e., are\nfulfilled only in some approximation with the indispensable reservationsassumptions-limitations].\n\n\fWithin the limits of the plant world, one can judge the analogous character of\ntransformations by the spiral-cyclical movement in the chain \"plant — fruit —\nseed — new plant,\" by the external appearance and internal structure of\ntrees, bushes, leaves, grass, flowers, fruits...\nThis same principle of self-development allows one to grasp the essence of\nthe directionality of the modifications of forms also in non-living nature, to\nwhich, say, for over a century and a half the Periodic system of elements of\nD.I. Mendeleev (the periodic law of the variability of the chemical and\nphysical properties of elements depending on their atomic mass) points us in\nits main features.\nTo see such development and manifestation of the essence of content-form\nrelations in the non-living objective world is much more difficult than in the\nliving, since the intensity of the development or transformations of the\ncomponents-constituents of the relation {content/form} here is extremely\nlow, and therefore the periods of such transformations (coils) stretch out\nsometimes not simply for centuries, but for millions and billions of years.\nLet us examine, for example, how and what content-form relations determine\nthe variability of natural landscapes.\nIt is known that the non-uniformity of the heating of various segments of the\nearth's surface by the sun causes the movement of air masses (winds,\nhurricanes, tornadoes, etc.). Even if one does not take into account other\nsources of changes (precipitation, earthquakes, thunderstorm phenomena,\ncosmic influences, etc.), the movement of air masses one way or another still\nchanges the relief of the locality (the form of the surface of segments of the\nEarth). This tells on the change of the conditions of the heating of the\nsurface, which, in turn, influence the intensity of the heating of the air and\nintroduce their changes into the character of the movement of the masses of\nthis air. The latter again is reflected in the relief of the locality and leads to\nthe change of the picture of the heating of the surface. In this way, by means\nof the accumulation of definite local changes (even excluding the actions of\ntectonic and volcanic nature), different platforms with different climatic zones\ncan be created on the earth's surface. The changed \"form\" of the surface (the\nrelief of the locality) immediately begins to absorb the sun's rays in a new\nway and to assimilate their energy-\"content\" in a new way. This is expressed\nin the change of heat emission, and, consequently, in the change of the\ndegree and intensity of the heating of the air above the surface. The latter\ncircumstance, in turn, leads to the change (with respect to the preceding) of\nthe character of the movement of the masses of air above the same surface\nand, correspondingly, to new changes of the relief (form) of the locality.\nThus, the new \"form\" of the surface, as it were, follows the changing heatenergy-\"content\" of the surrounding air medium.\nRepeatedly recurring changes of this kind over a long time lead, in the final\nanalysis, to radical qualitative transformations — to the avalanche-like\n\n\ffollowing of the form after the contentful (in everyday usage — thermal,\nenergy) changes, which means, in the end, a qualitative leap and the\ntransition to a new cardinally changed form with a new volume of\naccumulated content. The result can be the complete destruction of the\nformer form (landscape) and its replacement by a new one, or such its\nmodification which promotes the even more intensive further following of the\n\"form\" after the heat-energy-\"contentful\" changes (in everyday usage — the\nestablishment of an ever more flexible and close feedback).\nLet us complicate the task. The interaction with heated air and solar radiation\nof the surfaces of different water bodies (rivers, lakes, seas, oceans, etc.)\nleads to the evaporation of the surface layers of the water mirror, which,\nrising above the earth, are cooled by the atmosphere and form clouds of\nwater vapor. The formation of cloudiness in itself is a factor of substantial\ninfluence on the intensity of the heating of the locality by the sun's rays,\nwhich, in turn, tells on the character of the movement of air masses above\nthe earth's surface. But this is not all. In the course of rising and cooling, the\nwater vapors condense and the formed moisture, in the end, returns to the\nearth in the form of precipitation (rains, downpours, hail, snow). This\ncircumstance causes the change of the outlines of shores, of the areas of\nwater surfaces, of the depth of water bodies, of the speed and volumes of\nthe transfer of soil by water, the appearance of new water bodies, and,\nconsequently, the change of the conditions, character, intensity of the\nsubsequent stage of the evaporation of water. The alternate alternation (or,\nmore precisely, the \"parallel-sequential\" action) of the regimes of the\nevaporation of water and the falling of precipitation leads at times to\nsubstantial changes of the relief (form) of segments of the earth's surface\nand to the change of climatic zones. Thus, the \"form\" constantly, as it were,\npulls itself up to the \"content\" of the changes taking place. Even without\ntaking into account the influence of tectonic and volcanic activity, as well as\nof other cosmic influences, except the action of the sun's rays, one can see\nhow the content-form interaction described above is expressed in substantial\nmodifications of the \"forms\" (the change of segments of the locality, the\ndisplacement of climatic zones), following the heat-energy-\"contentful\"\nstratifications. From the standpoint of the described approach, by the way,\nthe essence of such a well-known phenomenon as the water cycle in nature,\nstudied in the junior grades of elementary school, is also understood more\neasily.\nNow let us add one more factor accompanying the process under\nconsideration. It is known that the formation of clouds is sometimes\naccompanied by their polarization (i.e., the accumulation in the cloud of\nelectric charges of one sign). Upon the approach and collision (contact) of\npolar-charged clouds with each other or with the earth, powerful electric\ndischarges (lightning) arise, which cause at times colossal changes in the\nsurrounding environment and lead to the appearance of new forms. Such can\nhappen again by reason of the change of the relief of localities because of\nfires, or owing to the formation of qualitatively new chemical compounds of\n\n\felements (from the composition of the earth's crust, water, air, etc.) under\nthe influence of the high temperature at the place of the electric discharge.\nThe arisen compounds of elements, having absorbed new contentful changes,\nthemselves contribute to the accumulations of further content in qualitatively\nnew forms. It is quite possible that it is precisely such electric discharges that\nled, in the opinion of scientists, to the creation of the conditions for the\nemergence of the prototypes of more mobile, more flexible forms adapted to\nthe absorption and accumulation of subsequent changes, i.e., of \"protoliving\" forms and subsequently — of protoplasm. The form here unswervingly\nfollows the contentful changes of the surrounding space, contributing, in\nturn, its own share to the volume of the contentful accumulations caused by\nthis movement. In the final analysis, this can lead to radical changes of a\ncontentful character in the form of cataclysms and the leap-like emergence of\ncardinally new forms. At that, not only the outlines (relief) of the former\nforms of the locality and the climatic conditions can change, but also\ncompounds of elements with changed and previously unseen chemical\ncompositions can appear, which, in turn, can become the cause of the\nemergence of new more flexible and mobile contentful structures and forms.\n[Let us note that the examples adduced here are examined by us under the\nassumption of the absence of any elements whatsoever of living nature. The\npresence of living forms would undoubtedly accelerate the content-form\ntransitions examined, which is what takes place in reality at the present\nstage of development.\nBesides, the analysis adduced here is based on the examination of only\nfactors belonging to the category of atmospheric phenomena. An analogous\nanalysis can be conducted also with the examination of the consequences of\nthe influence of other cyclical factors (such as, say, earthquakes with\nvolcanic eruptions and tsunami waves, as the rotation of the Earth around its\naxis and its movement along the solar orbit, as the leaps of solar activity, as\nthe collisions of the Earth with celestial bodies, etc.)].\nAll natural cyclical phenomena (for example, the change of seasons: spring\n— summer — autumn — winter) — this is nothing other than the spiral-like\nascent of the content of reality by its renewed forms, i.e., the manifestation\nof the same veiled content-form movement in the direction of the\nabsorption of the \"developing content\" by the \"developing content\" itself.\nIf one speaks of the regularities, say, in the sphere of economics and social\ndevelopment, then Marx's teaching on the change of socio-economic\nformations owing to the development of the productive forces and the\ninevitable entry of these forces into confrontation (contradiction) with the\nproduction relations (i.e., owing to the contentful outgrowing by the\nproductive forces of the forms or frames of the production relations) — is\nnothing other than the description of the manifestation of the action in a\nconcrete kind (form) and in a concrete area of reality of the same general\ntendency or generalized abstract model @.\n\n\fAgain, the productive and any other activity of man is directed at the\ncreation of new forms of different levels in the expectation of the all-round\nand exhaustive coverage by them and the realization (in accordance with\nformulation @) of the \"carrying-away\" content in the image of the needs,\ndesires, intentions, interests, will, aspirations, goals, schemes, ideas,\ntheories arising in the consciousness (and subconsciousness) of man...\nBillions of people daily, \"every moment\" consciously and unconsciously are\ninvolved in the same single universal process of content-form\ntransformations and participate in the chase by their \"forms\" after their\nown \"content\" fleeing from them, in the hope and striving to clothe this\n\"content\" in the proper and befitting the current (or prospective) moment\nnew or renewed (perfect) \"form.\" And let these people move (both\nmechanically, and physically, and \"psychophysiologically\") in different\ndirections, commit different deeds, perform various actions (lying, sitting,\nstanding, on the run, moving in an automobile or airplane, etc.), the essence\nof their striving, movement, existence is one and the same — the taming of\ntheir restless, fidgety contentful \"I\" by clothing it in a correspondingly new\nand more suitable for this new content form (both in the form of speculative\nschemes and plans, and in the form of productive activity and its products,\nas well as in the form of all sorts of external mechanical movements,\nincluding the purposeful movements of various parts and organs of the\nhuman body).\nThus, the productive (practical-theoretical) activity of modern man in\naggregate with the products of this activity (in the form of all sorts of\ntechnologies and ideologies) represents nothing other than the perfected,\ndeveloped, complex forms of manifestation of the same single changing\nreality, abiding at the levels of heightened contentfulness and having come\nto replace and as a continuation of the forms of the original (simple) labor\nand cognitive activity of early man in combination with its primitive primary\nresults.\nThe formulated principle of self-development is internally naturally and\norganically inherent both in us (man) and in all our surroundings. The\ncontent-form transformations of unitary directionality lying at the basis of all\nreal processes, described here, not only explain the spiral-cyclical character\nof these processes, but also allow one to forecast their development.\nOne can additionally adduce a great multitude of examples interpreting the\naction of the universal principle of self-development @ at different levels of\nthe content-form movement of reality: this internal principle ignites and\nextinguishes stars, rotates the Earth, moves across the surface of the planet\nthe masses of soil, water, and air; it also \"hides\" behind the external\nappearance of vortex atmospheric and oceanic currents and formations (well\ndistinguishable on weather images from near space), of processes of volcanic\nnature, of the processes of the formation and shaping of planets, stars,\ngalaxies, nebulae (on photographs of far space in the overwhelming majority\n\n\fof cases the patterns of spiral-like branches of the so-called interstellar and\nintergalactic substance catch the eye); this same principle stands behind the\ntransformations of chemical elements and compounds upon the change or\nloss of orbits by valence electrons at the atomic and molecular levels; it also\ndrives \"in a circle\" the herds of wild animals and flocks of migratory birds;\nthanks to the realization of this principle people are born, live, communicate\nwith each other, embody in life their intentions and plans. Everywhere\nvisually and speculatively the spiral-cyclical character of really proceeding\nprocesses is noted, behind the facade of which are hidden the content-form\ntransitions of known directionality.\nWe (humanity), equally as all our surroundings, are embraced and\nsimultaneously permeated by this principle, constitute its essence and\nrepresent it in phenomena, are in its power, are subordinated to it, and it is\nwe who permanently renew and reproduce it. And no external act of\ncreation and control on the part of some \"creator\" or \"maker\" is required for\nthe realization of this internal principle. The world is relatively simple and\nuniform in essence (by the principle of organization, the mechanism or\nalgorithm of the movement and development of content), but infinitely\ncomplex and diverse in its manifestations by form — owing to the natural,\nunimaginable in details mutual interlocking, interweaving, and ingrowing of\nforms-levels into each other in their interaction.\nMoreover, in the light of the concept expounded here, the universal and allembracing Absolute in the form of an eternal, unchanging, finished, and\nperfect abstraction is unrealizable in principle, since everything existing,\nin the final analysis, is a process to a much greater degree than some result\nfixed once and for all, than some finished formation, than some perfect\n\"construction,\" than some \"boundless-limitless essence,\" etc., etc. The\nUniverse, equally as all its separate elements, is made, recreated,\nreproduced, and renewed every moment, in real-time mode, being modified,\nexisting, and coexisting in the form of changing forms.\nWith an eye to what has been said, it becomes obvious in what manner one\nshould relate also to the question of the cognizability of the world. Since the\nworld, the Universe is incessantly and non-stop \"made,\" \"recreated by\nwinding,\" and does not represent a sort of suitcase with books, the cognition\nof the making, every-moment-reproducing world — this is all the more an\ninfinite and infinitely fascinating contentful process. How can one speak of\nsome all-round, full, and final cognition of the world, if the world incessantly\n\"unfolds\" in ever new and new contentful forms? In such a cross-section it is\nmore reasonable to speak of the cognizability and cognition of the world as of\nthe perfection of the possibilities for the anticipation of such an \"unfolding\" of\nforms, of the possibilities for the foretelling of the emergence of new and the\ntendency of the change of existing forms, i.e., of the forecasting of coming\nevents and their consequences, speaking in the habitual everyday language.\nThe effective forecasting of the development of the forms of reality — this is\nthe prospect of the contentful development of humanity.\n\n\fThe representations of development expounded above are directly connected\nalso with the question of the elaboration of the methodology of the\ninvestigation and cognition of the surrounding world. We are speaking of the\ncreation of a more or less universal form-algorithm of the investigation of the\ndevelopment of any objects, processes, and phenomena in different areas of\nreality [1, p. 66; 20, p. 36]. The revealed general objective regularities of\ndevelopment serve simultaneously as the single unifying foundation for all\nthe sciences and areas of knowledge existing at the present time.\nThe principle of self-development (self-organization), which is the central\ncore of the proposed concept of development, easily lends itself to\nmathematical formalization (by way of reduction to recurrent dependences\nand the organization of iterative-cyclical computations by the method of\nsuccessive approximations), which allows one to hope for the construction of\nmore perfect and effective (than those existing at present) prognostic models\nof the development of reality (or, in the habitual terminology, models of the\nsurrounding world). One can suppose that the most complex and interesting\nmoment in the course of the creation of the corresponding mathematical\nmodels of the investigation of the spiral-cyclical development of this or that\nform of reality will prove, in all probability, to be the solution of the question\nof the all-round account of the consequences of the interference\n(superposition, intervention, and influence) of the multitude of similar spiral\nprocesses of the development of all sorts of neighboring and accompanying\ncompeting forms.\nThe identification of the process of cognition with the process of the\ncontentful multilevel movement-development of reality by way of the change\nof its forms-levels in the direction @ allows one to speak confidently of the\nachievement of a certain meaningfulness in the realization of the process of\nthe cognition of reality itself.\nAs one can notice, there are described here mainly the general principles of\nthe organization and development of reality (including the process of its\ncognition). It goes without saying that it is impossible without the\nparticipation of professionals to correctly adapt the general propositions to\nthe numerous specifically-oriented areas of knowledge. This part of the work\nis within the power only of \"narrow\" specialists. At the same time,\nacquaintance with the general principles will considerably facilitate for any\nspecialist the sorting-out in the existing interweaving of specific formsrelations of different levels forming the sphere of his professional interests.\nAfterword\nIn our days, in scientific circles there is widespread a rather biased and\narrogant attitude toward the subjective and the ideal. And meanwhile, by\nwhat other path, if not as a result of the \"construction\" by individual\nindividuals of subjectively-abstract ideal forms, is the universally significant\n\n\fand universally accepted built up in the course of successive approximations\nto the reproduction of the most objective of all (i.e., the objective content of\nreality)?\nOne should not think that everything expounded above belongs only to the\ncategory of exercises in the construction of empty ideal abstract\nconstructions. Most concentratedly today the essence of even the most\npragmatic concept (theory, teaching, etc.) can be expressed only by means\nof conceptual (notional) formulations, i.e., by means of abstract\nsubjectively-ideal forms.\nThe region, the medium, and, finally, the level of the ideal — this is that\n\"space\" into which modern man lays out everything most significant, most\ncontentful, that he alone can dispose of today. And goals, and methods, and\nschemes, and decisions, and conclusions, and models, and images, and\npictures, and plans, and programs, and ideas, and theories, and teachings,\netc., etc. — all this is from the region of the ideal (which is likewise merely a\nform of the next approximation to the most complete expression of the\nobjective content of developing reality).\nOne more argument in favor of the significance of the ideal for man consists\nin the fact that without an idea and, in a broader sense, outside ideology,\nman simply \"becomes brutish,\" reducing his life to the stuffing of the belly\nand the performance of natural needs, i.e., to a \"looped\" existence at\n\"earthbound\" levels.\nIt is precisely with reliance on the contentful ideal constructions being built\nthat the speech here is about nothing other than the prospect of the\ndevelopment of humanity. In times when, behind the infinitely-routine\neveryday cyclicality, man sees no meaning in life and in his existence, there\nopens up the possibility of looking at all this with completely different eyes.\nEvery man is not simply capable, but obliged to become a researcher. In\neach of us slumbers the subconscious striving to \"contrive to peek around\nthe corner\" (satisfying his innate curiosity), to foretell the onset of events, to\nforecast and anticipate the appearance and development of new forms. One\nneeds only to activate this slumbering natural striving and impart to it a new\nimpulse, i.e., consciously bring it out to a new level.\nThe approach described here is called upon to aim man not simply at the\ncognition of a certain world existing from time immemorial, but predisposes\nto the meaningful investigation of everything that \"is being made,\" that \"is\nbeing reproduced\" and \"recreated\" directly here and now — in real-time\nmode both in our near and far surroundings.\nTo date there exist a million concepts of the world-order. Everyone builds his\nown model (picture) of the world in his own way, proceeding from the\nknowledge and experience both of his own and of preceding generations.\nHence grow the most diverse variants of world-understanding, a series of\n\n\fwhich proves to be among the dominant models of the world-order accepted\nby social consciousness. Being in actual fact different approximations to one\nand the same, many of them at first, and sometimes for quite a long time,\nseem equivalent — go figure which variant correlates more precisely with\ndeveloping reality... But only until the time when obvious failures and\nirreparable losses begin in the making of decisions and the realization of the\ncorresponding actions in the channel of following this or that universally\nsignificant model. And only then, when the problem of the survival of\nhumanity (or at least of its part) is pushed to the foreground, does the\nquestion of the assessment of the adequacy of the existing worldunderstanding rise to its full height, i.e., the assessment of the sufficiency\nof the level (fullness) of the objective contentfulness (objective\ncontent) of the ideal model \"chosen\" previously as the guiding star.\nInadequate (low-contentful) thinking (with all its low-contentful non-true\nabstract subjectively-ideal forms-models of reality), having as its foundation\nincluding false premises and sincere delusions, sooner or later risks being\npunished by the premature termination of existence and the disappearance\nof the very form of humanity owing to the \"dragging-apart\" into parts, the\nabsorption and assimilation of this form by more contentful competitors.\nTaking into account the circumstance that there are no two or more equally\ncontentful and equivalent \"truths\" or points of view regarding one and the\nsame subject of judgment or investigation (i.e., there do not exist in principle\nidentical and equal-sized approximations to the absolute truth), one must\nclearly realize that the acuteness of the question of the assessment and\nchoice by man of the most contentful (true) and most adequate variant of\ndecision from among two or more such variants will never be blunted or lost.\nMeanwhile, the inadequacy of the perception of the world leads man to\ncatastrophe — one wants to think that someday this thought will take\npossession of the developing human consciousness and become its topical\nand habitual content. In such a connection it is difficult to overestimate the\nsignificance of the decisions made by man (as well as the measure of his\nresponsibility) in the choice of this or that ideal model of the development of\nreality. Such is the far from harmless role of every, it would seem,\ninsignificant subjective ideal.\nMuch of what has been expounded above, as has already been noted, is\npresented in various sources of scientific and philosophical literature in parts.\nHowever, such a concentrated exposition of separate views and\nrepresentations in the form of an integral single concept is reproduced for the\nfirst time — everyone who is accustomed to systematically tracking scientific\nand philosophical publications of the indicated directionality can verify this.\nThe ever-growing number of examples of the interpretation and confirmation\nby factual material of the conceptual propositions formulated above gives\ngrounds to consider that the worldview concept presented here proves to be\ntoday the most contentful and adequate.\nReferences\n\n\f1. Vladlen V.K. To Recognize the Obvious. A Non-trivial Look at Evolution\n[Text]. — St. Petersburg: Super Publishing House, 2016. — 68 p.\n2. Hegel G.W.F. Encyclopedia of the Philosophical Sciences [Text]. — Vol. 1.\nScience of Logic. Moscow: Mysl, 1975. — 452 p.\n3. Gukhman A.A. Introduction to the Theory of Similarity [Text]. — Moscow:\nVyssh. shk., 1973. — 296 p.\n4. Darwin Ch. The Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection [Text]. —\nLeningrad: Nauka, 1991. — 539 p.\n5. Kaznacheev V.P. The Phenomenon of Man: Cosmic and Earthly Origins\n[Text]. — Novosibirsk: Novosibirsk Book Publishing House, 1991. — 126 p.\n6. Kedrov B.M. On Recurrence in the Process of Development [Text]. —\nMoscow: KomKniga, 2006. — 152 p.\n7. Krasilov V.A. Unsolved Problems of the Theory of Evolution [Text]. —\nVladivostok: DVNTs AN SSSR, 1986. — 91 p.\n8. Marx K., Engels F. The German Ideology [Text] / Collected Works. — 2nd\ned. — Vol. 3. — Moscow: Publishing House of Political Literature, 1955.\n9. Oparin A.I. Life, Its Nature, Origin and Development [Text]. — Moscow:\nNauka, 1968. — 173 p.\n10. Ponnamperuma S. The Origin of Life [Text]. — Moscow: Mir, 1977. —\n175 p.\n11. Chardin P.T. The Phenomenon of Man [Text]. — Moscow: Nauka, 1987.\n— 240 p.\n12. Philosophy of Science. — Issue 9: The Evolution of Creative Thinking\n[Text]. — Moscow: IF RAN, 2003. — 309 p.\nPhilosophical Encyclopedic Dictionary [Text] / Chief eds.: L.F. Ilyichev, P.N.\n13. Fedoseev, S.M. Kovalev, V.G. Panov. — Moscow: Sov. Encyclopedia,\n1983. — 840 p.\n14. Fox S. Molecular Evolution and the Origin of Life [Text] / S. Fox, K. Dose.\n— Moscow: Mir, 1975. — 374 p.\n15. Frenkel Ya.I. At the Dawn of the New Physics [Text]. Collection of\nselected popular-science works. — Leningrad: Nauka, 1970. — 384 p.\n16. Ebeling W. Physics of the Processes of Evolution [Text] / W. Ebeling, A.\nEngel, R. Feistel. — Moscow: Editorial URSS, 2001. — 328 p.\n17. Einstein A. Collected Scientific Works: articles, reviews, letters, the\nevolution of physics [Text]. — Vol. IV — Moscow: Nauka, 1967. — 599 p.\n18. Koonin E.V. (2012). The Logic of Chance: The Nature and Origin of\nBiological Evolution. — Upper Saddle River, N.J: Pearson Education, Inc.;\nKoonin E.V. The Logic of Chance. On the Nature and Origin of Biological\nEvolution. — Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf Publishing House, 2014.\n19.\nVideo\ntrailer\n[Electronic\nresource]\n//\nURL:\nhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V06B1mDMngI\n20. Vladlen V.K. To Cognize the Obviousness. Non-trivial Outlook on\nEvolution. — Houston, TX 77065: Strategic Book Publishing and Rights Co.,\n2013. — 46 p."} {"id": "article_2_en", "title": "Article 2. The Nature and Meaning of Fundamental Constants", "author": "Vladlen V.K.", "book": "Concept of Development: A Non-Trivial Outlook on Evolution", "book_ru": "Концепция развития. Нетривиальный взгляд на эволюцию", "year": 2021, "publisher": "Prometej Publishers (Moscow)", "isbn": "978-5-00172-246-5", "license": "CC BY 4.0", "language": "en", "text": "ARTICLE 2\nThe Nature and Meaning of Fundamental Constants\nAbstract\nThe description of the most general and many specific regularities of the\ndevelopment of the surrounding world is seldom managed without the\npresence of the so-called world constants — universal values entering into\nthe composition of the form-building means of such a description\n(mathematical\nformulas,\nmathematical\ndependences,\nmathematical\nexpressions).\nA great multitude of printed works is devoted to these values, and, despite\nthe abundance of investigations of their remarkable properties and\ncharacteristics, the circumstance is universally recognized that until now the\ntrue nature and the actual meaning of the fundamental world constants are\nunknown to anyone.\nThe present work removes the veil of mystery from the very popular and\nextraordinary numbers π, e, and φ, to the solving of the secret of which\nnumerous publications in various information sources are devoted.\nOn the example of these three most ancient and omnipresent numbers, the\narticle shows in what manner one should approach the establishment of the\nnature and the revelation of the meaning of constants of this kind.\nThe work can be recommended to the attention of researchers as initial\nmaterial for the study of the background and the elucidation of the meaning\nof the entire spectrum of existing fundamental constants, as well as as a\nsource of alternative views on the nature and essence of the surrounding\nworld.\nIntroduction\nMany versions are known regarding the origin, purpose, and role of the\nfundamental world constants. We are speaking, first of all, of the most\nancient constant \"π\" [2, 10, 11, 13, 17, 20, 22, 28, 34, 51, 52] — the\ndesignation and numerical value of the ratio of the length of the\ncircumference to its diameter, as well as of the no less fundamental and\npopular (although not so ancient as the first) constant \"e\" [2, 8, 10, 11, 17,\n20, 26, 29, 31, 43, 51, 53] — the designation and numerical value of the\nbase of natural logarithms. In this same connection we shall not fail to recall\nyet one more outstanding constant \"φ\" [1, 2, 3, 7, 14, 19, 23, 25, 35, 39,\n40, 47, 50, 51] — the designation and numerical value of the so-called\ngolden ratio, or golden section, or golden proportion.\n\n\fTo the extraordinary and mysterious (not to say — mystical) numbers π (pi),\ne, and φ (phi) a great multitude of printed works is devoted. Special\nattention is traditionally paid to the enumeration of the astonishing\nproperties of these dimensionless constants. And at the same time, despite\nthe abundance of investigations and descriptions of the remarkable\ncharacteristics of the indicated numbers, the circumstance is universally\nrecognized that until now the nature and the actual meaning of these values\nare unknown to anyone.\nIn contrast to the mission of replenishing the list of enthusiastic descriptions\nof the wonderful properties of the above-enumerated world constants, the\nmodest task of the present article consists in showing the source of their\nextraordinary properties, in uncovering and laying bare the true nature and\nessence of these values.\nWe shall solve the set task, relying on the concept of development described\nin the previous article of this same collection, as well as in the works [5, 21,\n54].\nIn investigating the essence of the mentioned constants, we proceed from\nthe fact that reality (the world surrounding us, nature) is always at least twosided (dual). Any object, process, phenomenon in the most general abstract\nform represents a relation of two sides-constituents-components:\n{content/form}. Then any concrete form (implying under itself the same\nobject, process, phenomenon) is determined by the correlation of the\nindicated sides-constituents in each of their concrete relations. The\ndevelopment of the forms themselves represents the change of the\ncorrelations of the noted constituents within the framework of their relations.\nIn such a connection it becomes obvious that the forms determined by the\nabove-mentioned correlations can be both more and less contentful (by\nvirtue of the presence of different shares of the contentful and formal\ncomponents in their relations). The general tendency of the development and\nchange of forms (as the experience of human observations throughout\nhuman history shows) is such that in the course of their (the forms')\ndevelopment there takes place a shift of the correlation of the components\n(in their relations) toward the \"numerator,\" i.e., toward the contentful\ncomponent (what is meant is the principled orientation toward the general\nmovement-development of forms in the direction of the acquisition of the\nhighest contentfulness) [5, 21]. Such an installation-orientation is called the\nprinciple of self-development, with the formulation of which the reader can\nacquaint himself there — in the previous article of the present collection and\nin the works [5, 21, 54]. This formulation means approximately the\nfollowing: everything that exists and develops has as the direction of its\ndevelopment and existence the expression (coverage, absorption,\nassimilation, comprehension...) by itself, existing and developing, of itself,\n\n\fexisting and developing. And such directionality or orientation of movementdevelopment is inherent in all developing forms without exception.\nIn the text of the article the reader will not encounter a single formulaic\nexpression for the determination (calculation) of the values investigated by\nus, just as he will not see \"juggling\" with their numerical values, which at\npresent have the possibility of being reproduced with any preassigned\naccuracy. The demonstration of such effects does not add, unfortunately,\nclarity in the intention to find out the true nature and meaning of the\nconstants under consideration: for no matter how many times one says the\nword \"halva,\" it will not become sweeter in the mouth. For us in this case the\nmost important thing is to uncover and manifest the deep philosophy of\nthese phenomena, i.e., to reveal the essence, meaning, background, nature,\nand the urgent necessity of the use by man of these parameters (values) in\nhis activity. The possibility of the solution of this task is determined by no\nmeans by the skills of mastery of the craft, but by the level of mastery of the\nart of \"aerobatics,\" i.e., dialectics.\nWithout being distracted by the description of the astonishing properties and\ncharacteristics of the dimensionless constants under consideration (these\nproperties are enumerated and described in abundance in the literary sources\nby the references mentioned at the very beginning and in many, many\nothers), let us stop on the main, in our opinion, question: in what, strictly\nspeaking, consisted and consists for man the urgent need or necessity of the\nintroduction of these numbers into everyday use, into practice, into\ncirculation? In other words, we shall answer predominantly such a question:\nwhat main problem for himself did man attempt to resolve (let it be\nunconsciously, unthinkingly, intuitively) by way of the introduction of these\nnumbers into practical circulation? At that, let us note that, answering these\nsimple questions, we shall inevitably have to answer also the more general\nquestion: what fundamental regularity of development leads to the necessity\nof the seeking-out and use of such constants?\nIn two words and still very simplistically, the answer to these questions will\nlook approximately as follows.\nWhen man does not know something, does not understand or underunderstands it (i.e., encounters something unexplored, both in the small and\nin the large), he strives with all his might to express this unknown through\nthe known and cognized, — let it be not so smoothly and thoroughly, not\ncompletely, but with some \"appendage\" of the not quite ordinary (say,\nthrough some atypical or unknown — until the time — combinations of\nknown forms), but still mainly through the habitual and already familiar. And\nthis means that in such cases man is moved by the striving — to clothe the\nnew developing content (new knowledge) in a more or less known form, to\nimpart to this new content (new knowledge) a more or less already\nmeaningful and habitual appearance. Therefore, however strange this may\nlook, not only at the first steps, but always in such cases human thinking\n\n\fsolves the main philosophical problem for itself of the seeking-out and\nclothing of the renewing and accumulating content of developing reality in a\nform more or less (and in the limiting expression — in the most and\nmaximally) answering to this content and simultaneously \"digestible\" for\ncomprehension. In the same cross-section, the initial internal contentful\nhuman activity or aspiration seeks embodiment or expression through the\nexternal formal pragmatic execution; at that, the contentful side in this\ntandem (relation of the contentful and formal components) always proves to\nbe the leading and moving side. Probably, for the majority of us this\nassertion abides in a still insufficiently manifested and not fully realized form,\nbut the matter stands precisely so!\nNow let us pass over to the detailed examination of what has just been said\nwith respect to the numerical constants of interest to us.\n§ 1. Let us begin with the number \"π\" (pi)\nAs is known still from the school bench, the number \"π\" represents the ratio\nof the length of the circumference to its diameter. This is the most distinctly\nmanifested relation of two sides-constituents of reality, for which are\ncharacteristic in this case such basic relations of its properties as\n{curvature/rectilinearity},\n{continuity/discreteness},\n{boundlessness/limitedness}, etc. In each of the noted relations there are\npresent and mutually linked two sides-constituents of reality. However,\nnotwithstanding the closest interconnection, neither the one nor the other\nside is identical to the other and represents components not replaceable by\neach other; at that, to such a degree not replaceable that between these\nsides-components there always lies a naturally conditioned boundary of\ndivision. Human thinking comparatively easily copes with the realization of\nthe formal side of such relations, i.e., of the \"denominator,\" and matters\nstand much worse with the perception of the contentful side — the\n\"numerator.\"\nProceeding from this, from the most ancient times everything still not\nunderstood and incomprehensible man trivially strives to express through the\nalready understood and comprehensible. The relations adduced above in this\nsense are no exception. In his attempts to express, to comprehend the\nincomprehensible continuity and boundlessness of the curvature of the\ncircumference through the comprehensible limitedness and discreteness of its\nrectilinear diameter, man inevitably comes to the sought relation, expressed\nand designated by a certain from time to time approximately repeating\nnumerical value (subsequently named the constant \"π\"): in a rather obvious\nand unpretentious way he manages to express the incomprehensible\nirrational through the well-known and sufficiently studied rational.\nThereby, in the image of the number \"π\" we find the first productive attempt\nof man to cope with quite serious difficulties, which are conditioned by the\nobjective presence of two objectively opposing and non-interchangeable\n\n\fsides of reality [5, p. 55]. This is an undoubted achievement and victory of\nman, but not without subsequent disappointments.\nPerhaps the simplest algorithm (way) of finding (computing) the constant \"π\"\nreduces to the seeking of the limit of the ratio of the perimeters of the\nregular polygons inscribed in the circumference and circumscribed (around it)\n(with the unlimited increase of the number of sides of these polygons) to the\ndiameter of this circumference. In this way is realized the striving toward the\nexpression of the most contentful correlation between the contentful and\nformal components in their relation {length of circumference/diameter\nof circumference}, indirectly determining, in essence, also the correlation\nbetween\nsuch\nfundamental\nsides-components\nof\nreality\nas\n{curvature/rectilinearity},\n{continuity/discreteness},\n{boundlessness/limitedness}, etc.\nThe straight line and the circumference — these are the two most popular\nlines on the plane of the times of the absolute leadership of geometry among\nall the sciences then being born. Between the two remarkable lines — the\ncircumference and its diameter — is enclosed a whole family of broken lines\n(polygons) inscribed in the circumference (and circumscribed around it) with\nperimeters easily computable and arbitrarily closely approaching the length\nof the circumference. An excursion into history shows in what unpretentious,\nbut quite laborious way rational man approached the comprehension of the\nirrational: Archimedes, as is known, in his computations went as far as the\ncalculation of the perimeters of the 96-gons inscribed in the circumference\nand circumscribed around it [42, p. 43; 52]. And, despite such laborious and\npainstaking work, to express the length of the circumference wholly and\nwithout remainder through its diameter still did not succeed [18, p. 291; 24,\np. 131; 51, pp. 33–34]. All subsequent attempts of new times only confirmed\nthe unsolvability of this task in an exhaustively exact expression. Today the\nconstant of interest to us has already been computed with an accuracy of up\nto billions of significant digits after the decimal point [20], but in the final\nform the task has still not been solved. What does this speak of? Only of the\nfact that in the course of investigations of this kind man has come up closely\nagainst the inexpressibility of the real (really existing) irrationality by a\nsimple rational way, even in the case of a deliberately limited, so-called flat\ngeometric space.\nAlongside the testimony of the achieved victory, corresponding to some\nsmallish possibility of representing one through the other, the number \"π\" —\nthis is at the same time also an indicator of the futility of the attempts to\nachieve the final and complete expressedness of the objective\nboundlessness, continuity, curvature through the no less objective\nlimitedness, discreteness, rectilinearity.\nThe inexhaustibility and progressive productiveness of such attempts, but at\nthe same time also the principled unattainability of the expression of the\nentire fullness of content in a final kind and form are interpreted and\nsubstantiated by the above-mentioned formulation of the principle of self-\n\n\fdevelopment, which proves to be the background of that very (sought)\nregularity of development leading to the necessity of the seeking-out and use\nof this constant.\nIn the indicated connection, the meaning of the constant \"π\" is seen in the\nfact that it fixes a certain transitional (\"borderline\") numerical correlation\nbetween the contentful and formal constituents in the relation {\"curvilinear\"\ncircumference/\"rectilinear\" diameter}. In this case human thinking contrived\nto express in a quite definite manner — by a more or less concrete number\n— the correlation between curvature, boundlessness, and continuity (the\npersonification of which is the curved line of the circumference), on the one\nhand, and rectilinearity, limitedness, and discreteness (personified by the\nrectilinear diameter of the circumference), on the other hand. And in this\nsame case we state by no means a final and exhaustive, but still a productive\nattempt of thinking to throw a bridge from the rational reality (from the\nstandpoint of traditional human thinking) to a reality to some extent\nirrational (the term \"irrational\" is used here in the meaning of something\nnot fully cognized, insufficiently investigated, and comparatively more\ncontentful, not yielding to realization in full measure, and not in the sense of\nsomething mystical and otherworldly). In the striving to express the\nirrational through the rational (i.e., to throw a \"little bridge\" from one to the\nother) and appear the remarkable relations, similar to the number \"π\". By\nreason of the objective unattainability of the full and exhaustive expression\nof the irrational through the rational (the infinite through the finite, the\ncontinuous through the discrete, the indefinite through the definite, the\nabstract through the concrete, etc.), such relations are expressed and\ndisplayed by irrational numbers (i.e., infinite non-periodic fractions). The\nvery irrationality of such numbers-relations (inherent in the dimensionless\nworld constants under consideration) always presupposes, as it were, a long\n(infinite) \"run-up\" before the \"jump\" from the formal side-constituent of the\nrelation to its more contentful side-constituent (for example, from the\nstraight line or plane to the circumference or sphere in the case of the\ndetermination of the number \"π\").\nJust as any natural formation, man and his thinking are at least two-sided\n(dual), and therefore contradictory. By virtue of the indicated peculiarities,\neven such a powerful instrument as abstract human thinking with its\ncharacteristic enormous intensity of the realization of content-form\ntransformations proves unable to solve such tasks, moving exclusively in\nmeasured-gradual steps; only by a leap in thinking (i.e., at the level of the\nforms-concepts and representations mediated by human thinking about the\ncontradictory components of reality in their actual relations of\ninterconnection and mutual transitions) is the barrier or boundary of division\nbetween the opposing sides-components of reality overcome.\nWhether we want it or not, dialectics is present here and further, as\nthey say, at full height.\n\n\fFrom the set of information about all sorts of investigations of the number\n\"π\" it is known that there exists a multitude of curves of different orders,\nsomehow correlating with the segments of straight lines connecting the ends\nof these curves on the plane, but only the ratio of the length of the\ncircumference to its diameter is the most large-scale and \"full-blooded\" in\nmagnitude (i.e., the most contentful) of all such relations. The highest\ncontentfulness of the relation-form expressed and designated by the number\n\"π\" (as the ratio of the length of the circumference to the length of its\ndiameter) is conditioned, first of all, by the remarkable property of the\n\"numerator\" of the relation, i.e., of the circumference; as mathematics\nasserts, of all closed curves of given length on the plane the circumference\nbounds the region of maximal area [2]. From the outstanding contentful\nfullness of the circumference and proceeds the intuitively-practical interest of\nman in the calculation of the length of the circumference by means of its\ndiameter — in the striving and hope of the finding of a simple device for the\nexhaustive expression of the irrational curvature through the rational\nrectilinearity. Let us keep in memory this remark about the highest\ncontentfulness of this wonderful correlation of the two components under\nconsideration in their relation.\nThus, of all the correlations between the components of reality in the general\nrelation-form {curvature/rectilinearity}, the number \"π\" represents such a\nspecial correlation of the components in their particular (and most kindred to\nthe\ngeneral)\nrelation-form\n{length\nof\ncircumference/diameter\nof\ncircumference} which answers to the maximally possible contentful filling (or\nthe highest contentfulness) of this form-relation.\nAt that, the irrationality of the number \"π\" testifies to the principled\nimpossibility of the establishment in exhaustive form of the final numerical\ncorrelation between the components of the relation-form {length of\ncircumference/diameter of circumference}, corresponding to its maximally\ncontentful filling, and thereby to the impossibility of the acquisition of the\nhighest contentfulness by this form-relation.\nThe impossibility of the exhaustive expression of the highest contentfulness\nby the indicated form-relation is ascertained in the course of the modeling of\nthe process of the acquisition (achievement) of this highest contentfulness by\nthe procedure of the computation of the correlations between the perimeters\nof the polygons inscribed in the circumference (or circumscribed around it)\nand the diameter of this circumference with the unlimited growth of the\nquantity of the sides of the polygons.\nThe productively realized attempt to link two independent and noninterchangeable sides of reality proves subsequently to be in demand in the\nplan of the use of the found compromise number \"π\" in all other cases which\none way or another require the replication of similar \"borderline\" values for\nthe adequate description of more complex real situations. Thereby the\nnumber \"π\" belongs to the series of remarkable and extraordinary numerical\n\n\fcorrelations thanks also to the need for it for the subsequent application in\nthe composition of formal (formulaic) expressions and dependences\ndescribing the development of diverse (including compromise) real complex\nforms and processes. The presence of the constant \"π\" in such descriptions\nindicates the belonging of the forms and processes described with its help to\nthe number of optimal (i.e., endowed with heightened contentfulness).\nExamples of diverse tasks in the solution of which the number \"π\"\nparticipates as a constant for the description of various kinds of optimal\nforms and processes can be found, say, in such printed works [6, 10, 11, 16,\n24, 27, 30, 32, 33, 38, 46, 48, 49].\n§ 2. Let us pass over now to the investigation of the constant \"φ\"\n(phi), responsible for the so-called golden ratio, or golden section, or\ngolden proportion\nThe main peculiarity and rule of the construction of the golden proportion are\nmore or less precisely, in our opinion, conveyed by the words of I. Kepler,\nwho called this proportion itself continuing itself: \"It is arranged so that the\ntwo junior members of this endless proportion in sum give the third member,\nand any two last members, if one adds them, give the following member,\nwith the same proportion being preserved to infinity\" [15]. This quotation\ndescribes a special algorithm of the composition of the whole from the\naggregate of parts.\nContinuing to answer the question posed at the beginning of the article —\nwhat fundamental regularity of development leads to the necessity of the\nseeking-out and use of such a constant and of the golden ratio displayed by\nit, — we state that this regularity too is conditioned by the above-mentioned\nprinciple of self-development.\nIn the course of the realization of this principle, the universal internal\nmechanism (algorithm) creates ever more \"living\" (i.e., ever more\ncontentful) unique natural forms-formations. Submitting to the single\nprinciple of the exhaustive expression of the whole integrity of the developing\ncontent, nature by successive approximations solves the task of the\ncoverage, representation, and comprehension of this contentful integrity by a\ntotality of ever newer and newer forms. In this concrete case investigated by\nus, the role of the contentful and formal constituent sides in the generalized\nabstract relation {content/form} is played by the components\n{whole/part}.\nNature, as a definite-level external formalization of the developing reality,\nconstantly gropes for the most optimal way of solving the indicated task. By\nthe empirical path (by way of the realization of numerous approximations)\nthere are produced forms which most correspond to the requirements of the\nexhaustive in the final analysis solution of the mentioned task, i.e., the most\ncontentful forms. Forms-relations reproduced on the basis of the golden\ncorrelation between the components of these relations stand in the row of\n\n\fsuch most contentful forms for their levels. The developing reality is capable,\nthrough human thinking as yet another link-form in the chain of forms of\nits contentful development, of fixing and evaluating the degree of\ncontentfulness of its own (both already existing and newly arising) linksforms in the striving of the latter toward the possession of the highest\ncontentfulness on their levels.\nWhat is characteristic of the heightened (and in the limiting case — the\nhighest) contentfulness, and in what does it express itself with respect to the\nforms-relations endowed with it? At the level of human consciousness the\nmentioned contentfulness of the correlation displayed by the number \"φ\" and\nthe effectiveness of the chosen path are evaluated and confirmed by the\nmaximal density of the \"mastering\" (i.e., the \"best mastering\") of free space\nby separate forms [2, 15], as well as, by virtue of this circumstance, by the\nestablishment of the presence of the indicated correlation in a whole series of\nnatural formations-forms-relations [1, 3, 14, 19, 23, 25, 40, 50, 51].\nAs in the case with the remark (see earlier) kept in memory about the\nhighest contentfulness of the correlation designated by the number \"π\", with\nrespect to the number \"φ\" the speech likewise goes about forms with\ncorrelations (between the components {whole/part} in their relation)\nanswering to the expression of heightened contentfulness. The golden\nrelation-form differs from other relations-forms by such a correlation of the\ncontentful and formal components which ensures the maximal filling with\ncontent of this form-relation at the given (this or that) stage-level of its\ndevelopment.\nA similar remarkable correlation is fixed by a certain number \"φ\" in the row\nof all other numerical values corresponding to all other correlations within the\nframework of the relation under consideration. And the matter, perhaps, is\nnot even in some concrete numerical value of this correlation, but in the fact\nthat such a remarkable correlation exists in principle among the multitude of\ncorrelations and of the numerical values corresponding to them.\nThe special correlation of the contentful and formal components, ensuring the\nmaximal contentfulness of the golden forms-relations, endows these forms\nwith heightened stability and viability. For the expression of the remaining\nadvantages of such outstanding forms-relations, and in fact for the\nevaluation of the degree or measure of their internal contentfulness, man has\ninvented and uses in everyday life a great multitude of all sorts of epithets\nand definitions (directly linked, among other things, with the aesthetic\nprinciple manifesting itself at the level of external human emotions), such as,\nfor example: divine beauty, perfection of form, ideality, exceptionality,\nuniqueness, harmony, optimality, special property, high quality, \"pleases the\neye,\" and many, many others. The heightened (maximally attainable or\nhighest for its level and stage of development) internal contentfulness of\nsuch forms-relations, expressing itself in a set of their remarkable external\ncharacteristics and properties, is connected with the presence, as already\nnoted, of the above-mentioned concrete numerical correlation in a whole\nseries of nonliving and living forms known to man. Confirmation of this can\n\n\fbe found in numerous literary sources (see the references above and below)\ndevoting excessive attention to the description of the wonderful properties of\nthe golden section. Coming to such a kind of optimal correlations in a series\nof certain forms, nature from year to year continues by spiral-cyclical\nmovements to \"polish\" its creations, achieving results still more astonishing\nand still more approximated to the expression of the highest contentfulness.\nIn such a way the developing reality itself, through the host of its changing\nand newly arising forms in the channel of the algorithm (formulation) of the\nprinciple of self-development, by periodic reciprocating movements\n\"refines\" the value of this correlation in the relation {whole/part}.\nMeanwhile, human admiration, deification, and exaltation of the known\nproperties represent a reaction of man only to the external signs of the\nmanifestation of the internal contentful fullness of such special forms and\nleave without due attention this very internal contentfulness. Not being\nsophisticated in such questions, man is inclined to absolutize and mystify\neverything that is above his understanding, taking the superficial\nphenomenon for the innermost essence. And the golden section as an\nexternal manifestation of the heightened internal contentfulness of definite\nforms is not an exception in this case.\nSo, in what, in fact, does the divinity of the forms-relations reproduced by\nthe algorithm of the golden proportion consist? Only in the fact that precisely\nsuch a correlation, such a proportion of the part and the whole ensures the\nmaximally possible contentful filling of this or that form at a definite stage of\nits development, i.e., at this definite segment of its path the given form is\nmost contentful (stands out from the other forms by its heightened\ncontentfulness). The loss or forfeiture by a form of a part of its heightened\ninternal contentfulness at another segment (stage) of its path inevitably\nleads also to the change (or disappearance) of the corresponding external\nsigns of this form.\nAs in the case with the number \"π\", the establishment of yet another\nremarkable correlation \"φ\" between the contentful and formal components in\ntheir relation is, undoubtedly, yet another victory of rational man. About the\nspecial relations of the whole and the part man has reflected from time\nimmemorial. The ancient Greek philosophers (beginning with Plato) supposed\nthat the whole does not reduce to the simple sum of its parts. But all the\nmost important suppositions and conjectures in this connection to this very\nday abide in the category of the theoretical (not to say scholastic) and have\nneither the status of recognized knowledge nor practical application. The\nofficial encyclopedic editions likewise limit themselves to very meager and\nvague utterances on this score [45, p. 768; 37, p. 1500].\nThe whole — this is not a simple sum (or totality) of its parts, but plus yet\nsomething else, obtained as a result of the interaction of the parts among\nthemselves and of the parts with the whole. When the whole grows by\nparts in such a correlation with the whole as is prescribed by the\n\n\falgorithm of the golden division, then the forming whole (under which\nare implied both the newly arising and the changing forms-relations)\nacquires the maximal contentful filling. Thus, the number \"φ\" is a\nquite concrete quantitative correlation between the whole and the\npart in certain relations-forms, answering to the maximally possible\ncontentful filling of these forms-relations in the course of their\ngrowth by parts in the mentioned quantitative correlations with the\nwhole at certain definite stages-levels of the development of these\nforms-relations. Precisely this correlation (this proportion) of the whole and\nthe part answers to the highest contentfulness of the whole growing by a\npart in the indicated correlation.\nThe regularity of the construction of the golden proportion described by\nKepler in an astonishing way resembles the sequence of Fibonacci numbers.\nAstonishing, however, only at first glance. The abstract and, it would seem,\nunconnected with practical application numerical sequence of Fibonacci is\nnothing other than a model of the optimal, most contentful growth of the\nwhole by parts, i.e., a model of the modification of existing and the formation\nof new forms of heightened (in the striving toward the highest)\ncontentfulness.\n[A passing remark. Mathematics is excessively full of surprises, sometimes\nconsidered products of the fruitless play of a brilliant mind, but having,\nhowever, a direct relation to the objective reality, although not always an\nobvious one. The whole matter is in the excess, speaking simplistically, of the\nintensity of the content-form transformations at the level of human thinking\nover the analogous intensity at the level of the subject-practical activity of\nman, in consequence of which many contentful developments of the \"pure\"\nreason gather dust on the shelves, humbly awaiting their \"binding\" and\ndemand at the level of formal practical embodiment.]\nIt should be especially noted that under the term \"golden section\" and its\nnumerical value there hides a boundary correlation between the components\nof the whole and the part with its (the correlation's) limit, guessed in the\nperspective of the infinite growth of the totality of the constituent parts in the\nwhole, modeled (the speech is about the growth) by the ascending sequence\nof Fibonacci numbers.\nThe analysis of the tendency of the change of the values of the relations of\nthe neighboring members of the Fibonacci sequence, lying in the basis of the\nsearch for the most contentful correlation between the whole and the totality\nof its constituent parts in concrete forms-relations built after the type of the\ngolden section, testifies to the fact that the increase of the number of parts\nincluded in the whole leads to the refinement of such a correlation and to its\never greater optimization, but the obtaining of an exhaustively exact\nnumerical value answering to the most optimal correlation, even with an\narbitrarily great (unlimited) growth of the quantity of parts in the\ncomposition of the whole (as also with the proportional increase of the\n\n\fgeometric dimensions of the whole and the parts), is impossible neither\npractically nor theoretically. In other words, the contentfully fulfilled whole is\nuncountable (does not yield to counting) and inexpressible wholly and\nwithout remainder by any number of limited parts and their totality; with the\nunbounded increase of the number of parts entering into the whole, modeled\nby the ascending Fibonacci sequence, the relation of the neighboring\nmembers of the sequence arbitrarily closely approaches a certain limit, but\nnever attains it. Only in such an unfinished way and in an approximate\nmanner is expressed (and can be expressed) the contentful fullness of the\nuncountable whole through the infinite succession of countable totalities of its\nparts.\nThereby the analysis in the indicated connection of the unending sequence of\nFibonacci numbers allows coming to an important conclusion about the\nprincipled unattainability of the exhaustive expression of the content of the\nwhole by any formal totality of its parts, even with the unlimited increase of\nthe quantity of parts in the totality.\nContinuing the investigation of this model (i.e., analyzing the variability of\nthe values of the relations of the neighboring numbers of the Fibonacci\nsequence), one can discern also the presence here of a certain likeness of\nforms developing at different levels with different volumes of contentfulness\n(with the variation of the number of parts or of their sizes in the composition\nof these different-level forms), but the repetition (i.e., the equality or\nidentity) of forms belonging to different levels with different volumes of\ncontentfulness is unrealizable and impossible in principle! About this again\ntestifies the infinite incompleteness and unattainability (in computation) of\nthe exhaustively exact correlation designated by the irrational number \"φ\",\nobserved (the speech is about the incompleteness and unattainability) in the\ninvestigation of the character of the change of the values of the relations of\nthe neighboring members of the increasing Fibonacci sequence.\nThe golden proportion, or the special correlation of the whole and the part\ndesignated by the number \"φ\", is an indicator of the heightened\ncontentfulness of forms-relations of a definite type, manifesting itself through\nthe optimality of properties-characteristics and through the aesthetic\nperfection of these forms. The irrationality of this number testifies both to the\nunattainability of the exhaustive expression of the highest contentfulness by\nthe forms of such proportions, and to the possibility of the unlimited\napproximation to its exhaustive expression. The coming of the event of the\nexhaustive expressedness of the highest contentfulness by the form of the\ngolden relation would mean that, beginning with some step of the realization\nof the algorithm of the computation of the constant \"φ\", the correlation of\nthe whole and the part (of the golden proportion) would remain unchanged,\ni.e., limited by some quantity of signs (by any their quantity, but necessarily\nlimited), and therefore unchanged. However, the infinity and non-periodicity\nof the fractional part (i.e., the irrationality) of the number displaying this\ncorrelation (as in the case with the number \"π\") speaks of the opposite.\n\n\fAs in the case with the number \"π\", the infinity and non-periodicity of the\nfractional part (the irrationality) of the number \"φ\" means that very barrier\nwhich separates two sides-constituents of one and the same relation\n{content/form} that are incompatible in exactness and non-interchangeable.\nAs in the case with the same \"π\", again we note the infinite \"run-up\" or the\nunending transition from one component of reality to the other (from one\nregion of reality — into the other) in their relation. If the case with the\nnumber \"π\" speaks of the impossibility of the whole expression of the\nboundless continuity and curvature by the limited discreteness and\nrectilinearity, then the case with the number \"φ\" testifies to the principled\ninexpressibility in an exhaustive manner of the contentful whole (again\nuncountable and continuous) by means of the totality of formally limited\nparts (i.e., by means of the countable and discrete). Despite the\ninseparability and interconnectedness of the contentful and formal sidesconstituents in the known relations \"π\" and \"φ\", the barrier between the\ncontentful and formal components (in both relations) is essential to such a\ndegree that it cannot be overcome by any successive or gradually-measured\nsteps-approximations, however long these steps-approximations might be\ncarried out. Even human thinking with its enormous potential is not capable\nof overcoming this barrier by measured gradualness; it is overcome\nexclusively by a leap. However, the latter always conceals in itself something\nnot fully understood and not fully said. Partly for this very reason the nature\nand meaning of the fundamental world constants up to now nobody can\nproperly explain.\nThus, the number \"φ\" is such a special quantitative correlation between the\ncomponents in the relation-form {whole/part} which answers to the\nmaximally possible contentful filling (or the highest contentfulness) of this\nform-relation.\nAt that, the irrationality of the number \"φ\" testifies to the principled\nimpossibility of the establishment in exhaustive form of the final numerical\ncorrelation between the components of the relation-form {whole/part},\ncorresponding to its maximally contentful filling, and thereby to the\nimpossibility of the acquisition of the highest contentfulness by this formrelation.\nThe impossibility of the exhaustive expression of the highest contentfulness\nby the indicated form-relation is ascertained in the course of the modeling of\nthe process of the acquisition (achievement) of this highest contentfulness by\nthe procedure of the computation of the correlations of the neighboring\nmembers of the infinitely-increasing Fibonacci sequence.\nUndoubtedly, the number \"φ\", fixing a definite correlation of the components\n(sides-constituents) in certain concrete forms-relations, is connected with a\ncertain optimality of these concrete forms-relations, conditioned by such a\nremarkable-kind correlation of components realized in them. At that, one\n\n\fcannot but see that the internal contentful fullness of these forms is primary,\nwhile the optimality and the remaining external qualities-characteristics of\nsuch forms are derivative and secondary; in practice, however, everything is\njust the opposite — the formal side is taken for the initial one, and only then\nthrough it do they attempt to express the rationality and irrationality of all\ninternal connections and relations.\nThe heightened internal contentfulness of forms-relations, marked by the\ngolden correlation of their components, sets the most optimal intensity of the\ndevelopment of such forms, ensuring their prolonged and productive\ncontentful existence at certain stages. However, a similar scenario can be\ntrue and realizable only at definite segments of the development of these or\nthose forms; with the change of conditions and circumstances (i.e., in the\ncourse of the inevitable further universal development) these or those\nbearers of golden proportions may lose their miraculous potential. For this\nreason it is very imprudent to be carried away by the excessive\nabsolutization of the special correlations of components and of the formsrelations corresponding to them, predicting for such forms the main roles for\nall times. Real forms are different and all sorts, and therefore the entire\nspectrum of developing forms-relations is by no means exhausted by one\n(this or that) concrete correlation of their components. At the given stage of\ndevelopment precisely such a correlation of the constituent sides within\ncertain forms-relations is and looks most optimal, stable, and expedient; at\nanother stage under other conditions and circumstances this correlation may\nbe forcedly transformed (just as over the centuries change the sympathies\ntoward the proportions and beauty, say, of the female figure). Therefore to\nattempt to reduce all forms-relations to the golden relation, i.e., to\nabsolutize, fetishize, mystify this relation and to spread the known myth\n(about the through presence of this correlation) wholesale over the entire\nhost of unique developing forms — is absurd. Moreover, in the indicated\nconnection the main task of man and of his thinking is to learn to foresee and\nanticipate the appearance of new correlations (including optimal ones, i.e.,\ndistinguished by heightened contentfulness) of the contentful and formal\nsides-constituents in their relations-forms at new stages of development,\nwhich, in fact, will determine the further progress of mankind.\nIn general, all manner of assertions about the \"final\" discovery of the most\nfinal and perfect of forms (be it the golden section, or some \"universal\"\nmathematical formula, or some \"super\" technologies) contradict the very\nspirit of development, which, despite any \"absolutes,\" breaks open and\novercomes by its contentful side any form attempting once and for all to fix\nin itself and by itself any contentful movement-development; from\ndefiniteness => through indefiniteness => to new definiteness, — such is the\nmost general form of the chain of the accomplished development. At that,\nthe elements of indefiniteness and unpredictability of the course of\ndevelopment were, are, and will always be — in accordance with the\nformulation of the principle of self-development (the return to oneself, but\nevery time to oneself changed, enriched, and developed). This context\n\n\fpresupposes as natural the representation of the fact that the moment of\nindefiniteness is also an objective and inalienable element of every\ndevelopment.\nExamples of the description of the optimal kind of all sorts of forms and\nprocesses, the construction, formation, or development of which submits to\nthe regularities of the golden proportion, can be found in such printed works:\n[2, 14, 15, 19, 25, 40, 50].\n§ 3. With the examination of the essence of the number \"e\" the\nmatter stands still more complicated\nIn the scientific and educational literature the constant e is identified as the\nbase of natural logarithms, which by no means introduces any additional\nclarity in our case. The constant e is not connected in an obvious way with\nsimple geometric relations like the constants π (pi) and φ (phi) examined\nabove. If the number π serves for the most part for the description of quite\nstatic forms-relations, the number φ — for the description of transitional\nforms ready for dynamic development, then the number e is present in the\ndescription of the most dynamic, in the fullest sense of the word, developing\nforms-relations-processes-systems, the components of which prove to be,\nfirst of all, such sides-constituents of reality as: {motion/rest},\n{time/space},\n{energy/mass},\n{kinetic\nenergy/potential\nenergy},\n{temperature/pressure}, etc.\nAs the authors of modern publications consider: \"If π is responsible for\nspace, then e — for time and likewise manifests itself almost everywhere\"\n[20]. In other words, e is responsible not for statics, but for dynamics, for\nthe process, for changing and progressing forms (and not for forms for the\nmost part object-like and static).\nProceeding from this, one should expect that the interconnection and\ncorrelation of the components in their relation, designated by the number e,\nare more complicated and more contentful than in the relations of π and φ,\nsince with respect to the constant e the speech goes about components of\nanother \"floor\" of reality, of another level of contentfulness, than those levels\nwhich are occupied by the components of the relations of π and φ.\nCorrespondingly to this, the numerical value of e fixes another, than π and\nφ, \"boundary\" and transitional correlation between the mentioned\ncomponents in their relations.\nBesides, from the position of our representations about the development of\nreality (i.e., from the position of the concept of development) the aboveenumerated set of relations ({motion/rest}, {time/space}, {energy/mass},\n{kinetic energy/potential energy}) enters into the \"clip\" or \"sphere of\ninfluence\" of such a generalized relation as {change/basis}. On this\nfoundation, further investigations of the essence of the constant e we shall\n\n\fconduct in the context of precisely this, most informative for us, initial\nrelation.\nThe relation {change/basis} — this is a completely different \"class,\" a\ndifferent level of forms-relations, than the relations {curvature/rectilinearity}\nand {whole/part} examined by us earlier (in the consideration of the\nconstants π and φ). The form-relation {change/basis} differs from the two\nlatter forms-relations by a more expressed dynamism, mobility, liveliness,\nchangeability.\nBut all this, as before, clarifies little; for a magic carpet by description may\nbe both square and Persian, and take part in air parades, but the main thing\n(in the channel of our mood for the revelation of the inconspicuous essence)\nwould still be the elucidation of that — what makes it a carpet-plane.\nTherefore, again, as in the cases with the numbers π and φ, let us turn to\nthe most capacious definitions and interpretations of the constant e, as well\nas to the history of its appearance and origin.\nThe initial and most effective, in our opinion, push or key to the\ncomprehension of the sense of the number e is provided by its classical\ndefinition [8, p. 231; 26, p. 354]. Scrupulously examining this definition of\nthe number e from the position of the concept of development mentioned\nalready more than once, one can discover that under the very definition of\nthe given number there hides a peculiar algorithm of the realization of the\nmost effective way of the accumulation and assimilation of the accreting\ncontent by some form developing in the direction of the acquisition of the\nhighest (maximally attainable) contentfulness! And again the speech goes\nabout a certain contentfulness, which likewise served for us as a key moment\nin the course of the revelation of the essence of the constants π and φ. The\nform realizing itself by such an algorithm represents an optimal formation\nthanks to the way, following from the given definition, of the appropriation of\nthe maximally possible volume of content accreting on the basis of a very\nlimited initial contentful volume of the form itself and over a quite definite\nfinite interval of time.\nOn what is this assertion based? On the comparison of the textbook definition\nof the constant e with the way of the calculation of the compound bank\ninterest accrued on a certain sum of the initial money deposit in the course of\na definite time interval [31]. Strictly speaking, the history of the origin of the\nnumber e, as is noted in many literary sources, is connected precisely with\nthe seeking-out of the maximal limit of the growth of the money deposit\naccreting with respect to its initial sum under the conditions of infinitely\nshortening intervals of time between the moments of the accrual of interest\non the successively accreting at those same moments sum of this deposit.\nOnly, in contrast to the history with the origin of the number e, in the case of\nthe investigation of the definition of this number from the position of the\nmentioned concept of development under the sum of the deposit and the\n\n\fbank interest there are implied a certain form of the initial content (basis)\nand a certain abstract content \"winding\" onto the basis (change), accreting\nto the basis by the algorithm corresponding to the above-mentioned way of\nthe accrual of the bank interest.\nAccording to the algorithm used for the calculation of e, providing for ever\nmore frequent (accelerating) interest accruals on the correspondingly\naccreting sum of the deposit, with such an increasing frequency accretes also\nthe very sum of the deposit; a similar algorithm is realized, as we have\nalready established, also in the computation of the ever more exact value of\nthe constant φ by means of the infinite sequence of Fibonacci numbers. Only\nin contrast to the forms, the static proportions of which are determined by\nthe measures of the number φ, the forms formed after the patterns of the\nnumber e are built by the dynamic path, with the participation of the stepby-step changing component of time, by virtue of which also in this latter\ncase the accumulating content does not succeed in being expressed by a\nform wholly, — the state of contentful \"saturation\" is not attained (does not\nset in) in principle, since there is always, there is always present a \"beyondform\" leakage of content, despite the process of the successive growth,\nperfection, and raising of the degree of the \"all-embracingness\" of the form\nof the representation of this content. Hence, even in the regime of the\nrapidly developing dynamic layering of content (change), predetermined (the\nspeech is about the regime) by the indicated algorithm of the computation of\nthe number e, and even with the limited content of the isolated initial form\n(basis), it is impossible in the limit (fully and without remainder) to cover,\nabsorb, and appropriate exhaustively all the accreting content by any final\nform whatsoever! Here we again (as in the case with the number φ)\nencounter the principally unattainable limit of the accumulation and\nexpression by any perfect form whatsoever of exhaustively all the\nunswervingly accreting (in the course of the development of this form)\ncontent.\nIt must be said that mathematicians, describing e as a remarkable limit of a\ncertain functional relation, do not connect the algorithm or procedure of the\ncomputation of the value of this relation with any of the physical processes\n[2]; in other words, for the mathematical cast of mind the examination and\nsolution of the task in the most general abstract formulation is a natural and\nhabitual matter.\nIn the case examined by us of the use of the algorithm of the computation of\nthe number e for the calculation of contentful accumulations (changes)\nproceeding from the initial limited contentful volume (basis), the\n\"denominator\" (i.e., the basis) of the relation {change/basis} adduced\nearlier, like the \"numerator\" (change), directly participates in the contentful\naccretions and accumulations: changes do not occur on an empty place, but\nalways \"cling\" to the basis (to the initial deposit, to some starting capital or\ncontribution), and this concerns not only the development of specific forms-\n\n\frelations in the domain of economics and finance, but also the development\nof any forms whatsoever and in any spheres whatsoever.\nA similar point of view on the correlation (interconnection) of the indicated\ncomponents in the mentioned relation is considered self-evident (can one\nreally separate the change itself in its \"pure\" form from that which\nchanges?), — see, for example, about the connection of change and the\nstability of the properties, structure, and laws of the existence of bodies [44,\np. 161]. Since the numerator of the relation (\"change\") is not essential by\nitself (outside the \"basis\"), then under the \"change\" of the numerator one\nshould understand the \"contentfully changing basis\" (or the \"basis accreting\nwith content\"). Under the \"basis\" of the denominator there is understood the\n\"basis of the initial content.\" So, the analysis of the given algorithm shows\nthat the maximal sum of the increment of the content of the changing basis,\ni.e., of the \"numerator\" of the relation, in comparison with the content of the\ninitial basis, i.e., with the \"denominator\" of the relation, under the conditions\nof the realization of such a special algorithm (specific way of the increment of\ncontent) cannot go out beyond the limits of the excess of the contentful\nprimary basis in e (as a certain definite number) times.\nLet us now examine, in what the specific algorithm of the calculation of the\ncompound bank interest (i.e., of contentful accretions and accumulations in\nthe context of our concept of development), coinciding in form with the\nalgorithm of the computation of the constant e, differs from the other\nalgorithms of bank accruals.\nAccording to the mechanism of the realization of the given algorithm, the\nmaximal increment by content of a certain form of limited initial\ncontentful volume in the course of a finite interval of time is attained\nunder the condition that every infinitely small part of the contentful\nvolume of the given form ensures an increment, externally accreting\nto this part of the contentful volume, proportional to the sum of the\ninitial contentful volume of this part and of the contentful volume\naccreting to it in the course of periodically repeated contentful\nadditions throughout the mentioned interval of time. By this somewhat\nornate phrase here there is merely verbally transmitted the essence of the\nwell-known mathematical expression for the computation of the constant e\n[8, p. 231; 26, p. 354], — and nothing more! In other words, thanks to such\na way of accumulation (contentful enrichment), every particle, every smallest\n(infinitely small) element (at first of the initial, and then of the \"layer-bylayer\" accreting form) participates in full measure in the general single\nprocess of the accumulation and assimilation (assimilation) of the externally\narriving content. And even under such a condition, the total volume of the\ncontent of the initial form (i.e., of the basis) and of the content externally\narriving or accreting to the content of the initial form (i.e., of the change) is\nnot capable of exceeding the contentful volume of the initial form (basis)\nmore than in e times.\n\n\fThus, the number e is located on the boundary of the demarcation of the two\ncomponents in the relation {change/basis} and binds them together by a\ndefinite dependence, conditioning the change (accumulation) of the content\naccreting to the basis (i.e., \"sticking\" or \"winding\" onto the initial,\ndeliberately limited volume of the basis) in the total calculation, not\nexceeding the volume of the primary basis more than in e times.\nAs it can now be seen, the algorithm of the calculation of e resembles the\nformulation of the principle of self-development. And in the one, and in the\nother cases there is present the dynamics of the development of the form in\ntime and space. The difference consists only in the fact that the first variant\ndescribes the particular case of the development of a form of initially limited\ncontentful volume (initial capital, a definite sum of a money deposit in a\nbank, some process in an isolated spatial volume, etc.) throughout a\nconcrete finite time interval; the second, generalized variant is applicable to\nthe description of the development of any forms (including open developing\nsystems, as well as the totalities of systems as a whole) without any spacetime limitations.\nThe conditions of the realization of such a special algorithm (answering to the\nabove-noted particular case) presuppose the presence of explicit limitations\nboth of the contentful and of the formal plan; there is evident the limitedness\nboth in time of the accrual of the interest, and in the volume of the initial\ndeposit (i.e., limitations of the space-time character). But along with this, all\nthe advantages of such an isolated process are likewise demonstrated in full\nforce.\nBeing a particular case of the general principle of self-development, the\nalgorithm of the calculation of the number e (similar in form to the process of\nthe \"winding\" of content described by the formulation of the principle of selfdevelopment) allows separate forms under the specific conditions of the\nactivity of their limited contentful primary basis in the course of finite time to\naccumulate the maximally possible content by virtue of the circumstance that\nevery small particle, every smallest element of these separate forms\nparticipates in a direct and full-valued way in the process of\ncontentful accumulation.\nThus, the number e, or more precisely the algorithm of its obtaining\n(computation, calculation), represents a description of the most optimal way\n(procedure) of the assimilation and accumulation by some concrete separate\n(isolated) form of the maximal volume of the content arriving from outside.\nIf in the cross-section of what has been said one imagines that the\ndeveloping reality (i.e., the entire world surrounding us) as the universal\nform of a single complex process (not having limitations neither of the\nformal, nor of the contentful character, i.e., not limited neither in space, nor\nin time) were composed (\"woven\") of such maximally effective (optimal)\nsmall \"e-forms,\" then this single universal big complex form would be\n\n\fcharacterized by the highest contentfulness. However, the \"harsh\" reality\nintroduces its corrections in the form of the interference and interpenetration\nof forms into the \"fates\" of one another. The \"atypicalness\" of such \"e-forms\"\nis conditioned by the circumstance that the given form is built on the basis of\nan initial form, contentfully limited and quite isolated from the interaction\nwith other forms; a similar algorithm of development is not viable in\napplication to the incomparably more widespread open forms-processes,\nwhich, by virtue of the forced interaction with other forms, develop by more\ngeneral and less optimal patterns. Meanwhile, the \"e-form\" — this is a vivid\nexample of the most optimal and effective development of a form within the\nframework of content-form limitations (i.e., limitations, in this case, of the\nspace-time character).\nBecause of the described limitations, a similar specific algorithm (after the\ntype of the calculation of the number e) is not realizable in full measure with\nrespect to the open forms-systems, having universal distribution and\ndeveloping by the general patterns of the generalized formulation of the\nuniversal principle of self-development. The capitalization of a limited bank\ndeposit or starting capital — this is almost the only specimens of really\nexisting more or less closed isolated systems, to the description of the\ndevelopment of which the algorithm of the computation of the number e is\nideally applicable: probably, for this very reason all literary sources, as if on\ncommand, refer exclusively to the example of the calculation (sanctified by\nthe name of Bernoulli) of the compound usurious interest, — as to the\nexample of a really functioning isolated system, guaranteeing the maximally\nattainable contentful accumulations under the conditions of known\nlimitations.\nHowever, this by no means signifies that the advantages of such special\nforms are in any noticeable degree not realized in practice; the fact that the\nspecific \"e-forms\" by urgent necessity are widely used by man in the form of\ndimensionless values in the description of a huge number of all sorts of real\nprocesses signifies that the real forms are oriented toward development after\nthe image and likeness of the most contentful \"e-forms,\" but by virtue of the\nmerciless external influence, interference, and interpenetration on the part of\nthe same forms the trajectory of their development can be substantially\ndistorted and significantly differ from the most optimal one. In other words,\nthe designation of the number e (preserving in the \"folded\" form the\nalgorithm of the obtaining of this number), being present in various\ncombinations with other parameters, variables, and arguments in formulaic\nexpressions describing all sorts of real processes, indicates thereby although\nfar from the highest, but still some optimality (heightened contentfulness) of\nthe forms of such processes. Besides, the need for \"e-forms\" in the\ndescription of complex forms-processes is conditioned also by the\ncircumstance that by these small forms there are \"patched\" the ruptures or\nsteps on the boundaries of the division between the sides-constituents of\nreality, objectively taking place under the conditions of the development of\nbig forms and processes; compromise small forms in similar cases are simply\n\n\fnecessary for the adequate and correct description of such really developing\nbig processes and forms.\nEvery form-relation-process has as the direction of its development the\noptimization of itself (which, strictly speaking, constitutes also the essence of\nthe formulation of the principle of self-development). By this same\ncircumstance there is conditioned also the presence-presence of optimizing\nvalues (\"e-forms\") in the formulaic expressions-descriptions of diverse real\ncomplex forms-relations-processes. As it follows from our investigation, the\nmost effectively the task of the above-mentioned optimization is solved\nnevertheless by the \"e-form,\" which, not having by virtue of the limitations\naccompanying it any noticeable distribution in the \"pure\" form, enters,\nhowever, as a component part and is extremely in demand in the description\nof optimally developing real general forms and processes.\nAlong with this, the limitedness by the number-limit e — not the only\nremarkable feature of the scenario of the development of forms in the\nchannel of the algorithm investigated by us. The second remarkable\npeculiarity of the given scenario — the principled unattainability of the limit\nof the highest (maximal) contentfulness and the inexpressibility of this limit\nin an exhaustively exact digital form. The process proceeding by such an\nalgorithm has neither a platform, nor a point of \"saturation.\" And again we\nencounter the relation of two components, whose transition from one to the\nother within the framework of the relation is impossible by a smooth\nmeasured course. In the role of the interacting and opposing components, as\nhas already been noted, in this case there act the sides-constituents\n\"change\" and \"basis.\" The relation composed of these components of reality\n(analogously to other, more concrete relations of the given type:\n{motion/rest}, {time/space}, {energy/mass}, {temperature/pressure},\netc.) is doomed to the presence (between the sides-components of this\nrelation) of a barrier in the image of an irrational number, answering to a\ncertain objective, although not expressible exhaustively, limit correlation of\nthese components. And, finally, the third remarkable feature of the same\nscenario consists in the possibility of its infinite development and\napproximation to the expression of the highest contentfulness of the\nmentioned relation arbitrarily closely.\nNeither practically, nor theoretically is it possible to establish exhaustively\nexactly the correlation, and consequently, also the boundary of the division\nbetween the accreting contentful volume (\"change\") and the initial contentful\nvolume (\"basis\"); in an analogous way it is impossible to determine also the\nexact boundary of the division between the components in the \"kindred\"\nrelations\nfrom\nthe\nsame\n\"clip\":\n{motion/rest},\n{time/space},\n{energy/mass}... With whatever frequency and however long one may\nattempt to realize similar steps of approximations in the course of the\nrealization of the algorithm analyzed by us, there will always remain some\ncontentful part, not expressed, not calculated, and not subject to calculation\nby any rational form. And this barrier between the expressed content and the\n\n\fcontent incapable of being expressed in all its fullness by any form\nwhatsoever — is insurmountable in principle!\nIn this very thing consists the sense of the irrational number e. The infinite\nnon-periodic fraction of this number personifies that same infinite \"run-up\"\nbefore the \"jump\" from one domain of reality (from the rational reality of the\nform) — into its other domain (to the irrational reality of the content), i.e.,\nfrom one (rational) component of the relation — to the other (irrational)\ncomponent of this same relation.\nThus, the number e is such a special quantitative correlation between the\ncomponents in the relation-form {change/basis}, which answers to the limitpossible contentful filling (or the highest contentfulness) of this form-relation.\nAt that, the irrationality of the number e testifies to the principled\nimpossibility of the establishment in an exhaustive form of the final\nnumerical correlation between the components of the relation-form\n{change/basis}, corresponding to its maximally contentful filling, and\nthereby to the impossibility of the acquisition of the highest contentfulness\nby this form-relation.\nThe impossibility of the exhaustive expression of the highest contentfulness\nby the indicated form-relation is ascertained in the course of the modeling of\nthe process of the acquisition (attainment) of this highest contentfulness by\nthe specific procedure of the accrual of the compound bank interest with the\nunlimited shortening of the intervals of time between the moments of its\naccrual.\nAs the experience of observations shows, in the descriptions of optimally\nproceeding real complex processes (with the maximal for definite conditions\ncontentful increment) there are always present \"e-forms,\" indicating thereby\nthe belonging of the forms of these general complex processes to the number\nof optimal forms. On this score in the scientific literature there are presented\nnumerous examples of the descriptions of the forms of the most contentful\ndevelopment of all sorts of processes in the most diverse domains of reality\n[9, 10, 11, 12, 17, 20, 29, 30, 31, 33, 36, 38, 41, 43, 46, 49, 55].\n§ 4. Having determined ourselves with the nature, meaning, and\nnecessity of the introduction by man of the world constants into\npractical circulation, let us make yet several more clarifications and\nexplanations\nAs it has been possible to establish in the course of the investigation, all\nthree constants examined by us — π, φ, and e — are limits, toward which\nfunctions-relations of a certain kind strive with the unlimited increase of their\narguments. The historical excursus allows revealing the circle of particular\npractical tasks, in the course of the solution of which the first mentions of the\nabove-named values appeared. The solutions of the indicated tasks are\n\n\f\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\n\nconnected with the finding of the algorithms of the computation of the\nfollowing limits:\nin the case of the constant π — of the limit of the relation of the\nincreasing perimeters of the polygons inscribed in the circumference (or\ncircumscribed around it) to the diameter of this circumference [42, p. 43];\nin the case of the constant φ — of the limit of the relation of the\nincreasing total whole to its parts on the basis of the modeling of the\ncomputational procedure by means of the ascending sequence of Fibonacci\nnumbers [39];\nin the case of the constant e — of the limit of the relation of the content\naccreting in a definite way (up to \"saturation\") onto the content of the initial\nform (i.e., of the \"numerator\") to the content of the initial form (i.e., to the\n\"denominator\") on the basis of the modeling of the procedure of the\ncomputation of the compound bank (or usurious) interest [31].\nThe further analysis gives the possibility to discern the relations of the\ngeneral sides-components of reality hiding behind the relations of the\nparticular sides of the practical tasks:\nin the case of the constant π such sides of reality are the components of\nthe relation {curvature/rectilinearity}, as well as the components of a\nseries\nof\nother\n\"kindred\"\nrelations:\n{continuity/discreteness},\n{boundlessness/limitedness}, etc.;\nin the case of the constant φ — the components of the relation\n{whole/part}, as well as the components of a series of other similar\nrelations: {general/singular}, {function/structure}, and the like;\nin the case of the constant e — the components of the relation\n{change/basis}, as well as the components of a series of other similar\nrelations: {motion/rest}, {energy/mass}, {time/space}, etc.\nA scrupulous study helps to understand that behind the above-indicated\nconstants there hide ways or devices of the expression and representation of\nthe objective, but not quite comprehensible for man (irrational) sides of\nreality through the no less objective and considerably more comprehensible\nfor man (rational) sides of it. In this sense the constants examined by us\nprove to be for human consciousness peculiar \"transitions\" or \"bridges\" from\nthe domains of the rational — into the domains of the irrational:\nin the case of the constant π — this is the transition from \"rectilinearity\"\nto \"curvature\";\nin the case of the constant φ — this is the transition from the \"part\" to\nthe \"whole\";\nin the case of the constant e — this is the transition from the \"basis\" to\nthe \"change.\"\nThe above-mentioned limits are precisely the personification of the barriers,\nwhich must be overcome in order to \"get over\" from one domain of the\nrelation into its other domain, from one component of reality to its other\ncomponent. The infinite non-periodic string of digits of the fractional parts of\nthe irrational numbers π, e, φ (and they are known today already with\n\n\fbillions of significant digits after the decimal point [2]) looks like an unending\n\"run-up\" before the \"jump\" from one domain of reality into another and\nsimultaneously indicates the impossibility and unrealizability of the smooth\novercoming of this barrier — the latter is overcome only by a leap in\nthinking, i.e., at the level of the notions and representations about the\ninteracting contradictory sides-components of reality in their relations.\nBeing expressed by irrational numbers, the given constants symbolize not\nsimply transitions from one component of reality to another in their actual\nrelations, but transitions infinite, uncompleted, unfinished, unclosed...\nPrecisely this circumstance allows making one of the most important\nconclusions: if π, φ, e and can be called numbers in reliance on the\nestablished terminology with respect to the definition of an irrational number,\nthen \"constants\" one cannot call them in any way!\nThe symbols π, φ, e designate \"living,\" uncompleted transitional processes,\nby which, strictly speaking, is caused the use in formulaic expressions and\ndescriptions of any and all real forms and processes precisely of symbols,\nand not of concrete numbers.\nThese are special forms of the expression of specific transitional contentful\nprocesses, which it would be proper to name precisely so: \"π-transition,\" \"φtransition,\" \"e-transition\" or \"π-form,\" \"φ-form,\" \"e-form,\" — proceeding\nfrom the corresponding understanding and handling of them as of the\ndesignations of actual transitional forms and processes.\nThe mathematical form of the expression of such limit transitions is the\nfunction. In the great multitude of descriptions of other all-possible formsprocesses (i.e., in the diverse formulaic expressions) these functions are\npresent not as constants, but as forms of processes, in principle not having\nthe possibility of being expressed by constant finite values; in the final\nanalysis π, φ, and e — these are infinite and unrealizable to the end\ntransitions from the rational to the irrational, clothed in mathematical form.\nAs soon as and when these transitions are reduced to numbers with a limited\nquantity of significant digits after the decimal point, only then do they cease\nto be both processes, and transitions, and functions inside the descriptions of\nmore complex and composite processes; only then do these forms turn into\nconstants, the presence of which instead of the corresponding symbols limits\nthe contentful potential (fullness and depth) of the mentioned descriptions.\nThus, under the designations π, φ, and e there are implied \"folded\"\nalgorithms (modeling the actual transitional processes) of the computation of\nthe limit numerical values of the correlations of the components in the\nrelations\n{curvature/rectilinearity},\n{whole/part},\n{change/basis}\nrespectively.\nBesides, in the course of the examination it was ascertained that all the\nirrational numbers π, φ, e examined above designate limits or limit\ncorrelations of the components in their relations, answering to the highest\ncontentfulness of the relations of these components. If one imagines that the\n\n\fmentioned relations {curvature/rectilinearity}, {whole/part}, {change/basis}\ncan be characterized by all-possible values of the correlations of their\ncomponents in the ranges (determining the measure of the contentfulness of\nthese correlations) from the conditional \"zero\" (i.e., of small contentfulness)\nup to some highest contentfulness, then the limit numerical values of the\n\"round π,\" the \"golden φ,\" the \"saturated e\" will correspond precisely to the\nmaximal contentfulness of the above-enumerated relations (which, as has\nbeen noted more than once, in itself is likewise in principle unattainable and\nrepresentable only in the form of an unattainable limit).\nObservations and practical experience show that by no means all formsrelations (objects, processes, phenomena) belong to the number of the\n\"round,\" \"golden,\" or \"saturated.\" The overwhelming majority of the real\n\"ordinary\" forms-processes-relations occupies the most diverse steps of\ncontentfulness within the limits of the ranges indicated above; true, all these\n\"ordinary\" forms-relations-processes likewise have as the directionality of\ntheir development the attainment of all the same heightened (and in the limit\nexpression — the highest) contentfulness. But the main thing in this\nconnection is nevertheless that among the boundless diversity of formsrelations man has managed to single out such which are characterized by\nheightened contentfulness, which is precisely what distinguishes these formsrelations from all the rest; at that, to the singled-out forms-relations it has\nbeen possible to put into correspondence the limit correlations of the\ncomponents of these relations established by man in the form of more or less\nconcrete numbers, which subsequently became the indicators of the\nheightened contentfulness of the given forms-relations. The singling-out and\nadvancement of such forms from all the rest was and is accompanied by a\nburst of human emotions (admiration, tenderness, and delight), which in\nreality prove to be a reaction by no means to the internal heightened\ncontentfulness of these forms in comparison with others, but to their external\nsigns, characteristics, and properties. And the matter here, perhaps, is not\neven in the values and magnitudes of the numbers π, φ, and e themselves,\nbut in the fact that such special numbers exist and they correspond to special\n(standing out from the rest) relations-forms of the development of reality.\nAs has already been noted, the symbols π, φ, e designate the \"boundary\"\ncorrelations of the components in the most contentful specific formsrelations-processes. But these are a kind of particular cases among the\nmultitude of other more general forms, the development of which is\ndescribed by the generalized algorithm (formulation) of the principle of selfdevelopment. Therefore the presence of the symbols π, φ, e in the\ndescription of other more general complex processes and forms indicates the\noptimality and heightened effectiveness of these other complex forms and\nprocesses in comparison with the configurations of all the other real\nprocesses and forms. Besides, in the presence of objectively taking place\nruptures or steps between the sides of reality at the boundaries of their\ndivision, in a series of cases the adequate description of really developing\n\n\fforms and processes without the attraction of the \"π-,\" \"φ-,\" and \"e-forms\"\nis simply impossible.\nThe following assertion will be the answer to the question posed at the\nbeginning of the article: all three algorithms for the calculation of the limit\ncorrelations of π, φ, e — these are particular cases of the generalized\nalgorithm (formulation) of the principle of self-development, which lies\nprecisely in the basis of the fundamental regularity of development,\nconditioning the necessity of the seeking-out and practical application of such\n\"constants.\" In all three cases the speech goes about conditionally \"ideal,\"\nconditionally \"exceptional,\" limit-contentful forms-relations, in some way\nisolated (especially in the case of the \"e-form\") from the interaction with all\nthe other real forms. In the \"harsh\" reality of such exceptional (ideal) forms\nthere are very few, they are — special; the forms of the open real world,\nhowever, are the product and consequence of the confrontation and\ninteraction of the whole host of the forms of the open world. And with\nrespect to such a kind of open real forms and processes the speech is\nconducted already not about their absolute perfection, exceptionality, and\nideality (as in the case of the particular specific forms-relations), but about\ntheir movement-development in the direction of a certain optimality (i.e.,\nof the maximally attainable contentfulness), but under the conditions of the\nreal interference and intervention of other forms. And in the same way the\nsign of the orientation toward optimality and the highest contentfulness, but\nalready in the case of the real complex open processes-forms, is the\npresence of the small \"π-,\" \"φ-,\" and \"e-forms\" in the descriptions of these\nbig real open processes-forms.\nThus, π, φ, and e — these are the algorithms of the particular specific formsrelations, characterized by the expressed directionality toward the attainment\nof the absolute perfection and exceptionality of their special forms, whereas\nthe algorithm (formulation) of the principle of self-development determines\nthe universal directionality of the movement-development of any all-possible\nforms-relations of reality, including also the specific particular forms\ninvestigated by us.\nAny and every SOMETHING is a relation, accessible to expression with\nrespect to everything else and in mathematical or digital form. The number\nin the given case acts as the measure of any and every relation; the number\nis the quantitative characteristic of the relation, indicating the correlation of\nthe components in their integral relation, the degree of the participation of\nthe sides-components of the relation in one another, the degree of the\nexpressiveness of one constituent by means of its other, the position of the\nboundary of division between the sides-components in their relation. The\nknown examples of the found remarkable limits of π, φ, and e speak of the\nreal and quite realizable possibility of the numerical expression (cognition) of\none through the other: of the whole through the part (or through the totality\nof parts), of the boundless continuity through the limited discreteness, of the\ndeveloping content (change) through the existing form (basis), of the\n\n\funcertainty through the certainty, of the unknown through the known (but\nevery time with some differences from the already known), etc., etc.\nPrecisely in such a way (by way of the expression of the unknown or of the\ncontentful not \"graspable\" by consciousness in full measure through the\nknown or cognized form-like) is realized the process of cognition (as,\nincidentally, also development itself), and another way and other path simply\ndoes not exist. The numbers π, φ, and e — these are examples of the\nresultative attempts of man to express one (insufficiently cognized) through\nthe other (sufficiently comprehended).\nHowever, besides the load — to be \"bridges\" between the sides-components\nof reality — the so-called \"constants\" examined by us fulfill yet one more\nimportant function: all three \"constants\" — these are boundary pillars\n(milestones), standing on different frontiers and outlining the boundaries of\nthe objective physical level of reality; the first two (π and φ) are located on\nthe boundaries of the division of the domains connected with the external,\nfor the most part static geometric (spatial) forms, the last one (e) — on the\nboundary of the division of the components of the more abstract, more deeplying and dynamic (temporal) forms-relations.\nFurther, taking into account that π, φ, and e are located on the boundaries\nof the components of completely differently planned and differently leveled\n(in any case, obviously not intersecting) forms-relations, which are the\nrelations-forms\n{curvature/rectilinearity},\n{whole/part},\nand\n{change/basis}, one must seek the quantitative connection between these\nforms-relations (and, correspondingly, between the numbers answering to\nthem) with the account of this differently-leveledness, i.e., more\nmeaningfully. It is not excluded that with time such an internal connection\nwill be established or there will be discovered a system of numeration (and\nmaybe, also a system of reference), in which the world \"constants,\" like the\nchemical elements of the Mendeleev table, will in an ordered way occupy\ndefinite little cells of the table, thanks to which it will prove possible to\nforecast the appearance and introduction (dictated by practical necessity)\ninto circulation of new world \"constants.\"\nAs for the other world \"constants,\" and in particular the so-called physical\n\"constants,\" then, probably, in a similar way one can investigate and\nestablish the genuine essence both of the speed of light [4, pp. 98–107; 5, p.\n37], and of the gravitational constant, and of the Planck constant, etc. At\nthat, it is necessary to remember that every world \"constant,\" still\ninsufficiently comprehended and for the time being passing for an\ninexplicable and unsolved number, — this is always a barrier or at least a\n\"boundary pillar\" on the frontier between the incompatible and differing from\none another components-constituents of a certain relation, i.e., between the\nobjective sides of reality. Moreover, it is no less important also to understand\nthat the mentioned relations of the noncoinciding and opposing sides\nof reality are not located somewhere there, in the \"far distance\" from\none another, and are not separated between themselves by some\n\n\f\"spaces\" and \"times,\" but are interwoven into one another and are\nfound in a single bundle in every smallest element of reality,\noccupying its different levels-floors.\nThe \"constants\" have an important significance, since they stand on the\nfrontiers between the thoroughly cognized and the insufficiently studied or\nnot yielding to understanding also as easily and freely as the already\ncognized; precisely the world \"constants\" outline the boundaries of the\nrational (from the position of the stereotyped human thinking) world, i.e., of\nthe habitual and very \"definiteness-like\" objective (geometrically-physical)\nlevel of reality. If π is located on the boundary of the transition from the\nlinear (flat) world to the spherical (filled with curvature), then the number e\nand a whole series of other world \"constants\" stands on the threshold of the\ntransformation of again the habitual for us three-dimensional world\n(absolutizing its static spatial-form side-constituent) into the dynamically\nchanging, so-called space-time continuum. In view of the importance of the\nrelations fixed by the designations of the world \"constants,\" with each of\nthese relations and the correlation of their components one must deal\nunhurriedly and carefully; offhand such questions cannot be correctly\nresolved. In any case one must begin with the study of the history of the\norigin of this or that problem form-relation — here at once there may be\ndiscovered the main hint for the disclosure of the secret of its special\nproperties and, correspondingly, popularity. The following of the principle of\nthe observance of the unity of the historical and the logical in the conduct of\nsuch examinations — is especially topical.\nThe understanding of the essence of the world \"constants\" pushes apart the\nhorizons of our representations about the developing reality, since the\n\"constants\" are the indispensable participants of the correct modeling of the\nbehavior of the most multi-leveled reality, being found in the composition of\nthe mathematical (formulaic) expressions describing this behavior. In this\nconnection it is most expedient, in our opinion, to adhere to that position\nthat with respect to each concrete case the best solution, interpretation, and\nexplanation will be found by the \"narrow\" professional, who has mastered the\nconcept of development presented here and mentioned yet again more than\nonce. Say, the specialist in the domain of the history of the formation of\ngeometry (with the knowledge both of mathematics and of its history, well\nacquainted moreover with the indicated concept of development) will find it\neasier than anyone else to come out onto the initial conditions and\ncircumstances which led to the empirical or intuitive discovery of the\nremarkable correlation of π; or the physicist (well acquainted with the\nhistorical background and again with the given concept) will find it simpler to\ndeal with the number e; and the biologist (zoologist, botanist), who has\nmastered the concept of development, — with the regularities of the golden\nrelation in living forms, etc., etc. The world \"constants\" are waiting for their\nresearchers.\n\n\fIn conclusion let us note that the present article serves as an example of the\npractical application of the concept of development as an instrument for the\ninvestigation of the surrounding world.\nConclusion\nLet us sum up what has been set forth.\n1. The world \"constants\" — these are the external forms of the manifestation\nof the internal connections and relations of the sides-components of reality;\nthese are peculiar \"bridges\" between the mentioned sides-components in\ntheir real relations; these are the limit correlations of the definite sidesconstituents of reality, expressed by numerical values.\n2. The concrete examples of the remarkable limits of π, φ, e testify to the\nprincipled realizability and resultatively realized by man aspirations and\nattempts of the quantitative expression (let it be even approximate) of the\ninsufficiently cognized (irrational) sides-constituents of reality through the\ncomprehensible and habitual (rational) sides-constituents of it.\n3. The irrationality (i.e., the infinity and non-periodicity of the fractional\nparts) of the numbers corresponding to the mentioned limits of the relations\nof π, φ, and e indicates, in the first place, the principled unattainability of\nthe expression in an exhaustive form of the irrational side-constituent of\nreality through the rational side-constituent of it and, in the second place,\nthe possibility of an arbitrarily close approximation to such an exhaustive\nexpression.\n4. The same irrationality of the numbers π, φ, and e indicates also the fact\nthat these numbers — by no means \"constants,\" as is customary to consider,\nbut certain forms of infinite processes of the transition from one sidecomponent of reality to its other side-component. Perceiving this at the level\nof intuition, man for that very reason includes them in the formulaic\nexpressions and descriptions of real forms and processes not in the form of\nconcrete numerical values, but in the form of symbols.\n5. The world \"constants\" — these are a kind of \"boundary markers\" along the\nperimeter of the boundary of the most studied by man, comprehensible for\nhim and habitual objective (physical) level of reality, i.e., precisely the world\n\"constants\" outline the boundaries of the so-called rational (from the position\nof the everyday human consciousness) world.\n6. The limits of the relations of π, φ, and e — these are also \"milestones\" on\nthe boundaries of the division between the components of quite differently\nleveled relations, such as: {curvature/rectilinearity}, {whole/part},\n{change/basis}; for that very reason to seek the quantitative correlations\nbetween their numerical values without the meaningful penetration into\nthese relations and their components preceding the given search, in our\n\n\fopinion, is little effective. It is quite admissible that between the aboveenumerated forms-relations there exists a deep-lying contentful (nonformal)\nconnection, which may be discovered with time; but in order to speak about\nthis concretely, further in-depth investigations of these very relations and\ntheir components are needed.\n7. The numerical values of π, φ, and e designate the correlations of the\ncomponents in the above-enumerated forms-relations, answering to the\nheightened (and in the limit — the highest) contentfulness of these formsrelations on their levels, which makes these forms-relations the \"happy\"\npossessors of their remarkable properties and characteristics, fixed by the\nhuman consciousness as something special and exceptional.\n8. Since, without resorting to the help of the \"constants\" investigated by us,\nmany real processes it is simply impossible to describe correctly and\nadequately, man attracts these specific forms-relations (π, φ, and e) for\nparticipation in the descriptions of many other real complex forms and\nprocesses. Being present as the designations of the processes of transition in\nthe formulaic expressions and descriptions of other, more complex forms and\nprocesses, these specific forms-relations of heightened contentfulness\nindicate thereby the optimality of those other forms and processes in\ncomparison with the multitude of other \"ordinary\" forms and processes, not\ndistinguished by a similar optimality. Besides, under the designations of the\n\"constants\" in such descriptions there hide compromise connections\n(bridges), \"smoothing\" the objectively existing ruptures or steps between the\ncomponents of reality.\nReferences\n1. Butusov K.P. The Golden Section in the Solar System [Text] // Problems of\nthe Investigation of the Universe. — Issue 7. — M.-L.: VAGO, 1978. — 475 p.\n2. Vasilenko S.L. Basic Correlations between the Fundamental Constants\n[Electronic\nresource]\n//\nURL:\nhttp://www.trinitas.ru/rus/doc/0016/001c/1934-vs.pdf\n3. Vasyutinsky N.A. The Golden Proportion [Text]. — M.: Molodaya Gvardiya,\n1990. — 238 p.\n4. Vladlen V.K. Development. A New Experience of Natural Philosophy. Essay\n[Text]. — Kiev: Logos, 2005. — 204 p.\n5. Vladlen V.K. To Cognize the Obviousness. A Non-trivial Outlook on\nEvolution [Text]. — SPb.: Super Publishing House, 2016. — 68 p.\n6. Volynsky M.S. The Extraordinary Life of an Ordinary Drop [Text]. — M.:\nZnanie, 1986. — 144 p.\n7. Vorobyov N.N. Fibonacci Numbers [Text] / 4th ed., suppl. — M.: Nauka,\n1978. — 144 p.\n8. Vygodsky M.Ya. Handbook of Elementary Mathematics [Text]. — M.:\nNauka, 1968. — 416 p.\n9. Gilderman Yu.I. Armed with the Integral... [Text]. — Novosibirsk: Nauka,\n1980. — 192 p.\n\n\f10. Gorobets B. The World Constants π and e in Nature [Electronic resource]\n// URL: http://7iskusstv.com/2009/Nomer1/Gorobec1.php\n11. Gorobets B. The World Constants \"pi\" and \"e\" in the Basic Laws of\nPhysics and Physiology [Text] // Nauka i Zhizn. — 2004. — No. 2.\n12. Dobrolyubov A.I. Running Deformation Waves [Text]. — Mn.: Nauka i\nTekhnika, 1987. — 144 p.\n13. Zhukov A.V. The Omnipresent Number π [Text]. — M.: Editorial URSS,\n2004. — 216 p.\n14. Siegel F.Yu. Astronomical Mosaic [Text]. — M.: Nauka; Chief ed. of\nphys.-math. lit., 1987. — 176 p.\n15. Kepler J. On the Six-Cornered Snowflake [Text] / Transl. from Latin by\nYu.A. Danilov. — M.: Nauka, 1982. — 194 p.\n16. Kikoin I.K. Stories about Physics and Physicists [Text]. — M.: Nauka;\nChief ed. of phys.-math. lit., 1986. — 160 p.\n17. Klein F. Elementary Mathematics from an Advanced Standpoint [Text]. In\n2 vols. — Vol. 1. Arithmetic. Algebra. Analysis / Transl. from German; ed. by\nV.G. Boltyansky. — 4th ed. — M.: Nauka; Chief ed. of phys.-math. lit., 1987.\n— 432 p.\n18. Klein F. Elementary Mathematics from an Advanced Standpoint [Text]. In\n2 vols. — Vol. 2. Geometry / Transl. from German; ed. by V.G. Boltyansky.\n— 2nd ed. — M.: Nauka; Chief ed. of phys.-math. lit., 1987. — 416 p.\n19. Kovalev F.V. The Golden Section in Painting [Text]. — K.: Vishcha\nShkola, 1989. — 143 p.\n20. Kozlovsky B. The 10 Numbers on Which the World Holds [Electronic\nresource] // URL: expert.ru/russian_reporter/2008/9/cisla/\n21. Kravchenko V.V. The Concept of Development: A View from Within [Text]\n// Journal of Philosophical Research. — 2018. — Vol. 4, No. 2. — Pp. 47–73.\n22. Kympan F. The History of the Number π [Text]. — M.: Nauka; Chief ed.\nof phys.-math. lit., 1971. — 216 p.\n23. Lavrus V.S. The Golden Section [Electronic resource] // URL: http://nt.ru/tp/iz/zs.htm\n24. Landau L.D., Kitaigorodsky A.I. Physics for Everyone: Physical Bodies\n[Text] — 6th ed. — M.: Nauka; Chief ed. of phys.-math. lit., 1984. — 208 p.\n25. Lipov A.N. The Golden Section as the Basic Morphological Law [Text] //\nPhilosophy and Culture. — 2010. — No. 9. — Pp. 96–108.\n26. Lopatnikov L.I. Concise Economic-Mathematical Dictionary [Text]. — M.:\n1979, Nauka. — 358 p.\n27. Nambu Y. Quarks [Text] / Transl. from Japanese. — M.: Mir, 1984. —\n225 p.\n28. Nikiforovsky V.A. The Path to the Integral [Text]. — M.: Nauka, 1985. —\n192 p.\n29. Nikolsky S.M. Elements of Mathematical Analysis [Text]. — M.: Nauka;\nChief ed. of phys.-math. lit., 1981. — 160 p.\n30. Osipov K.A. New Ideas and Facts in Metal Science [Text]. — M.: Nauka,\n1986. — 72 p.\n31. Perelman Ya.I. Entertaining Algebra [Text]. — M.: Nauka, 1967. — 200\np.\n\n\f32. Perelman Ya.I. Entertaining Physics [Text]. In 2 books. — Book 2. — 21st\ned., corr. and suppl. — M.: Nauka; Chief ed. of phys.-math. lit., 1983. — 272\np.\n33. Rabotnov Yu.N. Introduction to the Mechanics of Fracture [Text]. — M.:\nNauka; Chief ed. of phys.-math. lit., 1987. — 80 p.\n34. Savin A. The Number π [Text] // Kaleidoscope \"Kvant\". — 1996. — No. 6.\n35. Savin A. The Number of Phidias — the Golden Section [Text] //\nKaleidoscope \"Kvant\". — 1997. — No. 6.\n36. Samsonov V.A. Essays on Mechanics. Some Problems, Phenomena, and\nParadoxes [Text] — M.: Nauka; Chief ed. of phys.-math. lit., 1980. — 64 p.\n37. Soviet Encyclopedic Dictionary [Text] / Chief ed.: A.M. Prokhorov. — 4th\ned. — M.: Sov. Encyclopedia, 1989. — 1632 p.\n38. Spiridonov O.P. Universal Physical Constants [Text]. — M.:\nProsveshchenie, 1984. — 160 p.\n39. Stakhov A.P. The Harmony of the Universe and the Golden Section: The\nMost Ancient Scientific Paradigm and Its Role in Modern Science,\nMathematics,\nand\nEducation\n[Electronic\nresource]\n//\nURL:\nhttp://www.obretenie.info/txt/stahov/harmoni1.htm\n40. Stakhov A.P. Codes of the Golden Proportion [Text]. — M.: Radio i Svyaz,\n1984. — 152 p.\n41. Tarasov L.V., Tarasova A.N. Conversations about the Refraction of Light\n[Text] / Ed. by V.A. Fabrikant. — M.: Nauka; Chief ed. of phys.-math. lit.,\n1982. — 176 p.\n42. Tikhonov A.N., Kostomarov D.P. Stories about Applied Mathematics\n[Text]. — M.: Nauka; Chief ed. of phys.-math. lit., 1979. — 208 p.\n43. Feldblyum B. On the Most Important Thing in Mathematics [Text]. — L.:\nDetlit, 1969. — 126 p.\n44. Philosophical Dictionary [Text] / Ed. by M.M. Rosenthal and P.F. Yudin. —\nM.: Politizdat, 1963. — 544 p.\n45. Philosophical Encyclopedic Dictionary [Text] / Chief eds.: L.F. Ilyichev,\nP.N. Fedoseev, S.M. Kovalev, V.G. Panov. — M.: Sov. Encyclopedia, 1983. —\n840 p.\n46. Khurgin Ya.I. Yes, No, or Maybe... [Text]. — 2nd ed. — M.: Nauka; Chief\ned. of phys.-math. lit., 1983. — 208 p.\n47. Shevelev I.Sh. et al. The Golden Section: Three Views on the Nature of\nHarmony [Text]. — M.: Stroiizdat, 1990. — 343 p.\n48. Shilov G.E. The Simple Scale. The Structure of the Musical Scale [Text].\n— 2nd ed. — M.: Nauka, 1980. — 24 p.\n49. Schrödinger E. The Space-Time Structure of the Universe [Text] / Transl.\nfrom English; ed. by R.A. Asanov. — M.: Nauka; Chief ed. of phys.-math. lit.,\n1986. — 224 p.\n50. Steinhaus H. Mathematical Kaleidoscope [Text] / Transl. from Polish. —\nM.: Nauka; Chief ed. of phys.-math. lit., 1981. — 160 p.\n51. Shumikhin S. The Number Pi. A History 4000 Years Long [Text] / S.\nShumikhin, A. Shumikhina. — M.: Eksmo, 2011. — 192 p.\n52. O'Connor J.J., Robertson E.F. A History of Pi [Electronic resource] // URL:\nhttp://www.history.mcs.standrews.ac.uk/HistTopics/Pi_through_the_ages.html\n\n\f53. O'Connor J.J., Robertson E.F. History Topic: The Number e [Electronic\nresource] // URL: http://www.history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/PrintHT/e.html\n54. Vladlen V.K. To Cognize the Obviousness. Non-trivial Outlook on\nEvolution. — Houston, TX 77065: Strategic Book Publishing and Rights Co.,\n2013. — 46 p."} {"id": "article_3_en", "title": "Article 3. The Universal Criterion of Truth", "author": "Vladlen V.K.", "book": "Concept of Development: A Non-Trivial Outlook on Evolution", "book_ru": "Концепция развития. Нетривиальный взгляд на эволюцию", "year": 2021, "publisher": "Prometej Publishers (Moscow)", "isbn": "978-5-00172-246-5", "license": "CC BY 4.0", "language": "en", "text": "ARTICLE 3\nThe Universal Criterion of Truth\nAbstract\nThe cornerstone of the epistemology of any philosophical system or doctrine\nis the question of truth.\nBased on the analysis of the work of Vladimir I. Lenin \"Materialism and\nEmpiriocriticism\", it is shown that the criterion of truth or of the truthfulness\nof the forms of developing reality is not practice, erroneously considered as\nsuch to this day, but the contentfulness (substantive richness, pithiness) of\nthese forms; practice, in its turn, is a method or procedure of evaluating the\nfullness or the \"quantity\" of the contentfulness of the forms of reality.\nMoreover, practice represents only a particular case of a more developed\ntechnology of establishing the truth — interpretation.\nThe criterion of truth put forward in the present article makes it possible to\nevaluate quantitatively the significance of the forms of reality, which, in its\nturn, gives the possibility to rank the forms and, on this basis, to outline\nmore meaningfully the directions of promising investigations.\nIn the same connection it is noted that there do not exist two or more\nequally contentful truths (ideas, representations, statements, theories,\nconcepts, models, opinions, points of view, etc.) with respect to one and the\nsame investigated question or subject of judgment, just as there cannot in\nprinciple exist two or more equivalent approximations to objective truth\n(absolute truth). At every given moment of development, the truth in the\nindicated sense is always one.\nIn addition, it is shown that the concept of \"reflection\" (\"copy\", \"mapping\") of\nreality, used by dialectical materialism and other philosophical doctrines for\nthe description of the principle of the functioning of human thinking or\nconsciousness, serves as a limitation or barrier on the path of understanding\nthe essence of the processes of development and cognition of reality;\nobjective reality represents the movement and change of forms in the\n\n\fdirection of the possession of the highest contentfulness (i.e., of the\nmaximally achievable content), and all processes of development and\ncognition of reality are to be studied and considered through the prism of\ncontent-form\ntransitions,\nconversions,\ntransformations\nof\nunitary\ndirectionality.\n§ 1. Questions of the theory of cognition\nIn October 1908, Vladimir Ilyich Lenin finished, on the whole, the work on\nthe book \"Materialism and Empiriocriticism\". A good half of this work is\ndevoted to the critical analysis of the theory of cognition of empiriocriticism\n(a subjectively idealistic trend in philosophy, fashionable at the beginning of\nthe XX century) and to the exposition of views on the same questions of the\ntheory of cognition from the position of dialectical materialism (for brevity:\ndiamat) [11].\nBeginning with antiquity and up to the present time, the \"central category\" of\nthe theory of cognition and the \"most important, irreplaceable concept of\nscience\" is considered to be the category of truth [4, p. 6].\nThe ancient dispute of philosophers concerning the cognizability of the world\nand the truthfulness of the knowledge obtained, extracted, acquired, it would\nseem, was resolved there, in this Lenin's work, in general outline in favor of\nthe point of view of the Marxists, to whose number the author himself\nbelonged [19, p. 352—353]. And nevertheless, again and again generations\nof investigators of the surrounding world come, who do not tire of \"stepping\non the same rake\" and continue to fill their own bumps at the price of their\nown delusions.\nThus, the long-standing philosophical dispute does not subside to this day,\nand, in all probability, a more complete solution of the same problem, as\nalways, is impossible outside a fresh look at the established state of affairs\nand without reliance on a worldview requiring periodic refinement.\nWith regard to the indicated considerations, the present work (article) is\ncalled upon:\na) to show that the representations of diamat about truth in the main are\nnevertheless more correct and stand closer to the truth than the\nrepresentations of other philosophical systems and doctrines;\nb) and then, already on this basis, to develop and supplement somewhat the\nrepresentations of diamat.\nThe first question, actual at all times, considered by V.I. Lenin in his book on\nbehalf of dialectical materialism and in connection with the mentioned\nanalysis of the theory of cognition, is the question of the principled\ncognizability of the surrounding world in the course of the acquisition of\nknowledge about it.\n\n\fThe second question, following from the first, is the question of the criteria of\ntruthfulness, reliability, authenticity of the forms of the acquired knowledge.\nThe first question is resolved in the work of V.I. Lenin positively by the\nrecognition as real of a series (chain) of objective \"contents\" or the so-called\nrelative truths, represented by different cognitive forms, as well as by the\nindication of the movement and change of these forms or relative truths in\nthe course of cognition in the direction of the achievement of absolute truth.\nThe positive solution of the second question is connected with the reasonable\n(rational) sufficiency of the criterion of practice (as the criterion of truth),\nwhich is \"so 'indefinite' as not to allow man's knowledge to turn into an\n'absolute', and at the same time so definite as to wage a merciless struggle\nagainst all varieties of idealism and agnosticism\" [11, p. 138].\n§ 2. How diamat answers the questions of the theory of cognition\nLet us dwell in more detail on how dialectical materialism answers the\nquestions about the possibility of cognition (i.e., of the cognizability) of the\nsurrounding world and about the evaluation of the truthfulness of the\nacquired knowledge.\nFrom the position of diamat there exists an external world or object,\ncontaining in itself some objective content, on the one hand, and a subject\ncognizing (sensing and realizing) this world, on the other hand. The fact that\nthe diverse forms of the surrounding world (objects, bodies, things,\nprocesses, phenomena, etc.) are bearers of a certain objective content,\nindependent of the cognizing subject, raises no doubt from the point of view\nof diamat, since the results of the millennial practical activity of man testify\nto this. The question remains — how correctly the representations of the\ncognizing subject about these forms of the surrounding world correspond to\nthe content of these forms independent of the subject. In the words of V.I.\nLenin: \"The objects of our representations differ from our representations,\nthe thing in itself differs from the thing for us, for the latter is only a part or\none side of the former, just as man himself is only a small particle of the\nnature reflected in his representations.\" But if for Kant the \"thing in itself\" is\nan \"abstraction without reality\", then for Feuerbach the \"thing in itself\" is an\n\"abstraction with reality\", i.e., the world existing outside us is quite\ncognizable and in nothing principally different from the \"phenomenon\" [11, p.\n115].\nFurther, the presence of objective content in the feelings, sensations, and\nperceptions (i.e., in the \"experience\" — according to the terminology\nwidespread at that time [11, p. 123, 327]) of the cognizing subject is sought\nout and confirmed.\nAnd, finally, the \"objective content... of concepts, ideas, judgments, theories,\ndoctrines, and of the integral picture of the world in the dialectics of its\ndevelopment\" [19, p. 226] is established, i.e., the presence of objective\n\n\fcontent in the abstract forms (products) of human thinking is proved. The\nfact that objective content must be present and is present in the abstract\nforms and products of thinking of the cognizing subject is, from the position\nof diamat, again beyond doubt. The question reduces only to the manner in\nwhich this can be confirmed. In other words, in order to establish the\ntruthfulness of the obtained or acquired knowledge (judgments, statements,\ntheories, concepts, formulations of laws and regularities, doctrines,\nparadigms, models, etc.), it is necessary again to understand — whether the\ngiven knowledge (more precisely, its subjectively ideal forms) is likewise a\nbearer of objective content.\n§ 3. A review of the existing criteria of the truthfulness of knowledge\nThe ruler of today's representations about the criteria of the evaluation of the\nauthenticity or reliability of knowledge occupies the range from vulgarobjective objectivism to extremely idealistic subjectivism. Let us enumerate\nbriefly the most known and vivid of these representations [7].\nObjectivism considers the phenomena of reality as historically necessary\nirrespective of the subject of activity and cognition, and therefore truth here\nis almost identified with objectivity [13, p. 418]. In other words, the speech\nhere goes, as it were, not even about knowledge (a theoretical-abstract\nform), the truthfulness or reliability of which is necessary to establish, but\nabout representations identical with or \"coinciding\" with the object itself.\nThe founders of the already mentioned empirio-criticism considered that the\ncorrectness or truthfulness of thinking is conditioned by the principles of the\n\"economy of thinking\" (according to E. Mach) and of the \"least expenditure of\nforces\" (according to R. Avenarius) [11, p. 165-167]; these same principles\nthey laid also into the foundation of their theory of cognition.\nR. Descartes assumed clarity and obviousness as the criterion of truth: if\nsomething is understood clearly and obviously, then it is true.\nBy different thinkers there were proposed as criteria of truth, for example,\nthe internal consistency of thoughts, their value, etc.\nPragmatism puts forward the following criterion: true is that which is useful\nor advantageous to people.\nBy the flows of information of modern mass media there is unprecedentedly\nagitated and imposed on man the justice of the following point of view with\nrespect to the evaluation or choice of the criterion of truth: whoever is\nstronger (whoever wins) — that one is right. In other words, if one succeeds\nby force, by pressure, by \"impudence\", by unexampled insolence, cunning,\nand rigging to push through and implant into the consciousness of some\nmultitude of people (laymen) any doubtful judgment, statement, conclusions,\nor inference (and in the limiting case — even a whole system of world-\n\n\funderstanding), then the result of such an action is identified with truth or\nverity; in many cases it is precisely such a path that is chosen today by\ndifferent subjects for the assertion of the rightness of their position or point\nof view.\nA number of known philosophers see the criterion of truth in \"universal\nsignificance\". From the point of view of this criterion, truth is that which is\n\"universally significant\", i.e., that with which all people agree, or the\noverwhelming majority of them, or simply the majority.\nA variety of this point of view is yet another one, which was adhered to by\nthe French mathematician A. Poincaré. According to the concept put forward\nby him (this is the so-called conventionalism), scientific concepts and\ntheories do not reflect objective reality, but are the result of an agreement of\nscientists or arbitrarily established rules. The quintessence of his views is\nexpressed by the following phrase: \"The only true objective reality is the\ninternal harmony of the world\" [11, p. 161].\nKindred to the views of A. Poincaré there exists also such a point of view: the\ncriterion of truth is beauty (as a manifestation of the internal and external\nharmony of the world).\nIt must be said that the variant of appointing as the criterion of truth the\n\"universally significant\" (generally accepted, generally obligatory, etc.) is\nanalyzed in detail by V.I. Lenin in this same book of his, where it is shown\nthat in many cases the \"universally significant\" is a synonym or equivalent of\ncollective human delusions, if this \"universally significant\" is deprived of\nobjective content, given to man in experience, i.e., acquired or established\nby the empirical path in the course of the cognition of the surrounding world\n(or, what is the same, in the course of the object-practical activity of man).\n§ 4. The subjectivism of the majority of the criteria of truth\nIt is not difficult to see that the majority of the above-enumerated criteria is,\nto one degree or another, imbued with the spirit of subjectivism. With all the\nimportance of the signs or indicators of the truthfulness of knowledge\ncontained in them, there is absent the main one, which would emphasize or\npoint to the objectivity of knowledge, i.e., would tie it to the objectivity of the\ncontent of the forms of the external world. Certainly, no more or less integral\nor balanced philosophical system (doctrine) will consider the truthfulness of\nknowledge outside the connection with objective reality, and in the first place\n— with that objective world in which such a system abides (whether it\n\"wants\" it or not).\nHence grows the need for a complex criterion which would establish and take\ninto account the presence of that very objective content in all abstract and\nsubjective forms of knowledge. To this day, such a more or less balanced\nsystem of views is recognized to be the dialectical-materialistic philosophy,\n\n\fwhich does not deny the significance of the clarity of thoughts, their\nconsistency, their universal significance, their rationality, economy,\nobviousness, usefulness, pragmaticality, harmony, etc., etc., but at the same\ntime is fully aware of the fact that the above-enumerated indicators (signs),\nbecause of the absence of a sufficiently solid and stable natural connection of\ntheirs with the external world, cannot be recognized as fundamental criteria\nof truth. Proceeding from such an understanding, dialectical materialism sees\nas the most suitable sought-for criterion of truth practice or the objectpractical activity of man as a subject of cognition.\nThus, under the vaults of the soundly built edifice of dialectical-materialistic\nphilosophy, as its core there is discovered a seemingly quite harmonious\nsystem of views on the fundamental questions of the theory of cognition.\n§ 5. Peculiarities of the interpretation by diamat of the nature of the\nsubjectively ideal forms of cognition (forms of the representation of\nknowledge)\nAnd here I would like to draw attention to one peculiarity of the just\nmentioned system of views. If the subjectively idealistic philosophy turns the\nsensations of the subject cognizing the external world into a certain\n\"partition, wall separating consciousness from the external world\", then\ncontrary to these representations diamat considers that \"sensation is indeed\nthe direct connection of consciousness with the external world, is the\ntransformation of the energy of external irritation into a fact of\nconsciousness\" [11, p. 49].\nAs we see, according to the views of diamat, in defiance of the views\ncriticized by it of the idealistic (it should be said, both subjectively and\nobjectively idealistic) doctrines, no barrier separating the objective (including\nthe three-dimensional world of objects habitual for us) world, firstly, from the\nsensual world (sensations, experience) and, secondly, from the ideal world of\nthe cognizing subject, seemingly does not exist. We look further: \"These\nfacts of consciousness are not merely some conventional signs, symbols,\nhieroglyphs, but represent copies, images of real things and processes\ntaking place in nature, and cognition itself is a dialectical process of the\nreflection by consciousness of the objective world\" [19, p. 352]. In other\nwords, we see that the level of sensations here is still recognized as the\n\"direct connection of consciousness with the external world\". But what about\nconsciousness itself? — and here it is, it has turned into a \"fact\", and the\nfacts of consciousness represent already certain \"copies\", \"images\",\n\"reflections\" of real things and natural processes.\nAccording to these representations, the objective content of thinking exists in\nreality only in the form of a copy, in the form of some reflection of reality. At\nfirst, it would seem, one got rid of one \"partition\" between the forms of\nobjectivity and the forms of thinking, but exactly to the extent of then\ncoming to another \"partition\" — cognition turns into a dialectical process of\n\n\fthe reflection by consciousness of the objective world. Thereby an\ninvoluntary start is given to the process of the \"multiplication of entities\",\nwith which even a thoroughly religious consciousness cannot agree: willynilly there comes to mind the saying of the English monk known under the\nname of \"Occam's razor\": \"Entities should not be multiplied without\nnecessity.\" Denying in words the idealistic doctrines with their religious core,\nin fact we go into religion, for every religion is precisely the earthly\nembodiment (reflection, copying \"in image and likeness\") of some unearthly\nentity.\nMarxism, diamat, and indeed any materialism of any worth stand on the\npositions of the rigid opposition and separation by a \"partition\" or \"wall\" of\neverything objective and empirical (material) from everything ideal, which\nrepresents a certain ephemeral \"copy\" or \"reflection\" of everything material\n(read: real). At that, into what category this very \"reflection\" should be\nassigned, nobody still knows properly: on \"this side\" it does not take root in\nany way (for it is not material), whereas \"otherworldliness\" is ridiculed and\nrejected by the materialistic doctrines in the most resolute and merciless\nmanner.\nThe presence of such an inconsistency (according to the terminology given\nabove — a \"partition\" or \"wall\") violates, in our opinion, the harmonious\nsystem of representations about the transformation or transfer of objective\ncontent from form to form in the process of cognition and leaves no chances\nfor the correct interpretation and correct forecasting of the direction of\nfurther transformations of the forms of cognition.\nMeanwhile, in the course of the accumulation of knowledge and the\nimprovement of representations about the world surrounding us, the\ncircumstance is realized ever more distinctly and clearly that our\nenvironment, just as we ourselves, is a changing, moving, developing\nmultilevel reality, \"being made\" and \"reproducing itself\" in the real-time\nmode and manifesting itself at every moment in a single, unrepeatable,\nunique copy. In such an aspect, the well-known to us sayings about a certain\n\"copying\", \"photographing\", \"mapping\" and in the general case — \"reflection\"\nof objectively existing reality [11, p. 125] — somehow no longer \"get along\"\nvery well with the actual state of affairs.\n§ 6. Description of the process of the \"ascent\" of contentfulness by\nsuccessive forms\nBut, perhaps, one should not approach the interpretation of the process of\ncognition, as well as the perception and interpretation of the motion,\ndevelopment, evolution of nature, man, and society, so straightforwardly and\n\"head-on\", so mechanistically and trivially?\nWhy not consider this same process from a somewhat different position or in\na somewhat different light, namely: some deep essence or objective content\n\n\fof the developing reality \"ascends\" and manifests itself in separate\nsuccessive and mutually conjugated concrete forms — by the conventionallyinitial form of thingness (the world of things), further by the form of\nsensations (the vegetable and animal world, including man) and, finally, by\nthe form of thinking (subjective abstract human thinking).\nBeing objective content, initially represented by the thing form (about any\ninitiality of representation one can speak here very conditionally, since\nabout the forms preceding the thing ones, including various physical fields,\nwe cannot yet say anything definite here at all), the mentioned\ncontentfulness in the process of its motion-development changes the form for\na more flexible and capacious one, which turns out to be, from the point of\nview of human consciousness, the form of sensations, which then, in its turn,\nis replaced by a form still more capacious and embracing, and therefore more\nabstracted, called by us the form of thinking.\nFor this reason, each of the indicated forms, as merely different shells of the\nsame single, but transforming at the transition from level to level, objective\ncontent, must easily conjugate with the forms preceding and following it,\nwhich would testify to the succession (and, in the final analysis, to the\ntruthfulness) of all these forms.\nThe objective content independent of the subject (by analogy with the\nabove-mentioned \"thing in itself\"), present in any and every object of the\nsurrounding world, \"ascends\" (like the \"ascent\" of some deep essence of the\nsurrounding world) first into the subjective and abstract contentful forms of\nthe vegetable and animal world (including the form of human experience, to\nwhich the sensuous, or sensations, belongs) and then — into the ever more\nabstract forms of human thinking. In other words, the process \"begins\" to\ndevelop from the moment of the conditional start of the most \"coarse\",\nmechanistic-materialistic thing forms, further continues with the forms\nendowed with sensuousness (to which belong the sensations and reactions of\nthe living — the vegetable and animal world), then is \"taken over\" by the\nforms-carriers of the images of consciousness and representations already in\ncombination with the forms-carriers of sensations and the forms-carriers of\nthingness (higher animals and \"early\" man) and further continues with the\nforms-carriers of ever more abstract intellectual-spiritual contentfulness\n(which are \"late\", i.e., modern man and society) again in combination with all\nthe preceding forms.\nThanks to the ability to conjugate the separate forms of the single\n\"ascending\" objective content, following one after another as continuations of\nthe preceding forms, there arises a generalized (aggregate) multilevel form\n(of man with his thinking), consisting, like a pyramid, of interconnected and\nunimaginably interwoven layers-levels-forms, the summit part of which (of\nthe pyramid) is crowned by the form-carrier of an extremely abstract (the\nmost abstracted of those reliably known to us) content (theoretical\nknowledge).\n\n\fHaving before our eyes the just drawn image of the pyramid, it remains only\nto make sure that the contents of the mutually linked layers-forms-levels of\nthis pyramid are indeed successive, and, consequently, objective, i.e.,\nrepresent separate links of the single objective content of reality developing\nin a through manner (by means of the above-indicated forms). The latter, in\nits turn, is proved with the help of a very well-known procedure, from time\nimmemorial called practice (about which we will speak much and in detail\nbelow).\nThus, the \"hidden essence\" of reality being revealed, or its objective content,\n\"marches\" in a through manner in the process of its ascent-development by\nmeans of different, growing one out of another and therefore mutually linked\nforms.\nThe distinct visibility and confident ascertainment of this circumstance is\nhindered by the closest interweaving of the forms of the motion of objective\ncontent passing one into another. At the same time, one can notice that,\nbeing represented by different forms, the fragments of this general objective\ncontent differ from one another by some of their peculiarities, which are\nintroduced into them in the course of their development from the initial\nobjective, but still to some extent, uncertainty.\nSo, in accordance with our representations, separate objects (bodies, things,\nobjects) are the forms of existence and \"acquiring\" of the objective content\nof reality at the level of the inanimate, manifested by means of the formslevels of the living, i.e., of \"sensations\" and \"thinking\".\nFurther, plants and animals are the forms of the motion of that same\nobjective content at the level and through the levels of the living inanimate,\ngrowing out of the forms (and being the continuation of the forms) of the\ninanimate and, like the preceding thing forms, expressed and manifested by\nmeans of the forms-levels of \"sensations\" and \"thinking\".\nFinally, man with his thinking (mankind and society) is an even more specific\nform of the motion of again that same objective content at the level and\nthrough the levels of subjective thinking (consciousness), connected even\nmore closely by direct and feedback connection with the forms of the living\nand the inanimate and being the immediate continuation of the latter. This\nform is also expressed and manifested by means of the forms-levels of\n\"sensations\" and \"thinking\".\nAnd since the whole just enumerated set of forms is the continuation of the\nthing form, there is no need at that to introduce some intermediate gaskets\nin the form of the notions and terms \"reflection\" or \"copy\" only in order to\nemphasize once again the peculiar character of such forms. In other words,\nthe chain of the above-enumerated forms is the same expression,\nmanifestation, motion, \"march\", development of the objective content, only\n\n\fin the most specific, called subjective, forms, which are the continuations\nof the preceding thing forms. The root of the erroneousness of the\nrepresentations about such, in particular, a form as the form of thinking (as\nabout some ephemeral formation — the \"ideal reflection\" of reality), and the\nproblem of the interpretation of such a form lie in the artificial separation of\nthe highest (\"thinking\") layer from the general single bundle or aggregate of\nall the levels-forms available in the \"human\" structure and the subsequent\nabsolutization and opposition of it (of this most specific form) to all the\npreceding forms.\nOf course, it is undoubted that the objective contentfulness, which manifests\nitself and can manifest itself only through subjective forms, will never get rid\nof the shade of some subjectivity, but at the same time it remains objective\nby its nature, by its origin, by its roots, which lie in the foundation of the\nwhole chain of forms ensuring the transformation of this objectivity into\nsome specific subjectivity in the course of the motion-development of reality.\nThe objective content simultaneously ascends through the subject, and\nmoves in this form of its in the direction of the achievement of its \"final\"\nexpression in this same or another more perfect form, as the most perfect of\nall the forms. The difference of the forms of the representation of the\nobjective contentfulness in the course of its motion-development is\nconditioned and characterized by different values or magnitudes of the\nintensity of the contentful-formal transformations at different levels of the\nrepresentation and acquiring of these forms. The change of the intensity of\nthe contentful-formal transformations at the transition from level to level in\nthe final analysis turns out to be the main factor determining the\ndevelopment of the forms of reality. [In this work this aspect is practically\nnot considered and not disclosed.]\nBy every fragment, episode, act of its existence objects (if the speech goes\nabout the inanimate), by every breath and step an animal, by every deed or\nphrase man extract the hidden essence of their nature from inside outward\nand make it a phenomenon (make it visible), which (the phenomenon) in\nfact turns out every time to be only some next approximation to the full and\nall-round expression of this very essence.\nThe subject with his consciousness does not \"reflect\" reality, i.e., does not\nduplicate and does not multiply entities, but continues by himself the\nsearch for a more contentful form (correcting and supplementing the\ncontentfulnesses of the preceding forms-levels in their aggregate) of the\nreality developing in such a way. And this new sought-for refined form is\nrealized as a superstructure over the preceding aggregate of forms,\nabsorbing, including into itself in the main features, in a concentrated\n(\"sublated\") form the contents of the preceding forms.\nFrom the thing forms — to the subjectively ideal forms (which are\nsimultaneously the constituent parts of the general aggregate of forms,\n\n\fentering into \"engagement\" or conjugating with those same thing forms), —\nthis is, in accordance with our representations, the direction of the\ndevelopment of reality at the present stage in the cluster of the forms known\nto us.\nLet us show and analyze the process of the \"ascent\" and transformation of\nthe objective content by the example of a concrete object — a certain\nspherical boulder-stone, the definiteness of the form, dimensions, and\ninternal structure of which forces one to \"reckon\" with these peculiarities of\nits:\n— firstly, the inanimate objects surrounding it, running into it under the\ninfluence of diverse external forces as into an objectively present obstacle\nand interacting with it as with an obstacle;\n— secondly, the moving living bodies, interacting with it and \"taking into\naccount\" it already not only as an obstacle, but reproducing or generating in\nthis connection some simplest abstract images of it;\n— thirdly, the living animate organisms, which along with the results of the\nthing interactions with it and the sensuous representations about it, manifest\nits essence also in the form of developed abstract images and\nrepresentations, extending from the abstract formula description of its\nspherical surface to the descriptions of the physical, chemical, and quantummechanical properties of its material in the guise of even more abstracted\nsymbolic-formula expressions, mathematical equations, and theoretical\ncomputations.\nBy the example of a spherical boulder (such specimens are also encountered\nin nature), rounded from all sides by a glacier and subjected to the long-term\ninfluence of squall winds, stormy waters, raging fires, as well as of similar\nstone blocks (by virtue of collisions with the latter), one can trace the\n\"ascent\" of the contentful essence of a separate object by means of the\nforms changing in the course of such an \"ascent\".\nAn object of finite, limited dimensions, fixed and imprinted (\"perceived\") by\nthe neighboring objects as an obstacle, passes with time into the stage of the\nsensuous perception and the simplest figurative description of it by living\norganisms as streamlined, hard, solid, massive... and further passes to the\nstage of the perception of it by human thinking and the description by\nabstract means in the form of complicated images, symbols, and formulas:\nas a spherical object of radius R with the surface approximately calculated by\nthe formula 4πR²; as an object with the volume approximately calculated by\nthe formula (4/3)πR³; as an object with the ultimate strength of the material\nfor rupture (or compression), calculated as the ratio of the ultimate\nadmissible load on the object to the area of its cross-section; as an object\nwith hardness determined in conventional units, say, by Brinell; as an object\nwith wear resistance and other properties and characteristics determined by\nformulas and mathematical dependences known from the courses of\nmathematics, physics, chemistry, strength of materials... quantum\nmechanics, etc., etc. And all this complex description can be qualified as the\n\n\fmanifested contentful essence of one and the same something, represented\nby the forms of different degrees of abstractness and subjectivity, — in the\ncourse of the ascent of this essence successively through the forms-carriers\nof thingness, the forms-carriers of sensations and, finally, through the formscarriers of thinking.\nTo express the strength and hardness of the material of the boulder through\nthe forms of standards found by the empirical path and established at that,\nsuch as the limits of the strength of its material (say, for rupture and shear),\nand through the empirically established conventional units of hardness (say,\nby Rockwell, Brinell, or Vickers), — this means to find the expression of new\nabstract knowledge about the stone (i.e., to find the expression of its\nobjective content, developing by new and ever more abstract forms) through\nthe contents of the concrete thing and sensuous forms-standards formed or\nshaped \"in experience\". The same concerns the knowledge about the other\nproperties of the stone, such, say, as wear resistance, density, thermal\nconductivity, electrical conductivity, etc., etc.\nLet us now return to the above-cited words of V.I. Lenin regarding the cognition\nof the world as a process of the sequential transformation of the \"thing-in-itself\"\ninto the \"thing-for-us\", and see what emerges if we reinterpret Lenin's words in\nlight of the concept of the \"ascent\" of the objective content of reality (its deep\nessence) through forms transforming from objective substantial to subjective\nabstract ones, which has just been expounded. Then, the initial Lenin quote with\nour addition will read approximately as follows: \"The objects of our\nrepresentations differ from our representations, the thing-in-itself differs from\nthe thing-for-us, for the latter is only a part or one side of the former, just as\nman himself...\" — is merely a continuation of the content-based development of\nthe \"thing-in-itself\" into the \"thing-for-us\" through the aggregate of specific\nforms manifested by it, which grow sequentially one out of another, such as the\nform of sensations and the form of thought, which have transformed in the\ncourse of the aforementioned content-based development from the form of\nsubstantiality.\nIn the course of the described \"ascent\" of the content-based component of\ndeveloping reality — initially through non-living substantial forms, then through\nliving forms of sensations, and further through the intellectual and spiritual forms\nof human thought — all the aforementioned forms emerge as products of the\n\"demonstration\" of the accumulating contentfulness, which products then\nmanifest themselves in the form of successive technologies and ideologies.\nReality, as can be seen from our examples, remains the same general,\ncontinuous, unified changing substance, but it manifests itself differently at\ndifferent stages of its movement-development, that is, in different forms: from\nforms that are concrete and objective (independent of our consciousness,\naccording to the assessment of our own consciousness) — to forms that are\nincreasingly abstract and subjective...\n\n\fHere it is very important to understand that there is no ready (once and for\nall) essence of the world, which somewhere \"hides\" from man and which man\nhas only to cognize in small portions and steps, just as there is no ready\n(completely exhausting itself and existing independently of anything)\nobjective world: the essence of the world \"ascends\" by contentful forms\nsprouting one out of another, thanks to which the objective world is \"made\"\nevery moment, is recreated and reproduced from itself by the build-up of\nlayer-by-layer changes on the available and simultaneously changing in such\na way basis.\nThe neighboring external object is not simply \"reflected\" in me (in my\nconsciousness), but exists through me by its content, which changes\ntogether with me and my consciousness (as the continuation of the relation\nof the components {I/object} or of the more capacious relation\n{subject/object}) in the course of the deepening of the knowledge about this\nobject.\nThe essence of the changes taking place or occurring in the objective world\n\"ascends\" through me and by means of me, in direct connection or in relation\nwith me (as well as in relation with another individual, and in relation with an\nanimal, and in relation with an inanimate object). Without me this will be\nalready a somewhat different form of the manifestation of the essence, and\nwith another \"I\" — this will be a third form of the manifestation of the\nessence, etc. And only the generalized form as the aggregate of the aboveenumerated forms exposes, reproduces some generalized collective\ncontentfulness, which only can be called the objective content. In other\nwords, about a separate and independent of anyone or anything absolute\nessence there is nothing to speak here at all — such does not exist in nature.\nThe essence is \"extracted outward\", i.e., manifests itself only in the process\nof the interaction of something one with something other.\nIn accordance with such representations about development, the\nchangeability of the forms (from the concrete forms of thingness to the\nabstract forms of thinking) corresponds to the habitual natural (from the\nposition of human consciousness) course of events. Now, in the light of and\non the basis of these representations, one can come to a more exact\nunderstanding and conclusion about the actual relation of the components of\nthe subjective and the objective in the process of the described motion of the\nforms (from the thing ones — to thinking).\nMan is a multilevel formation, consisting of a hierarchical sequence\n(transformed with time into an inseparable aggregate) of conjugating formslevels characterized by their succession (it is precisely this that, first of all,\nshould catch the eye, but is taken into account by few). The aggregate or\nbundle of levels, beginning from the atomic and molecular (forming the thing\nlevel), further — to the cellular, organ-tissue, and organismic (forming the\nanimal level or the level of the \"living inanimate\") and further — to the\nbiospheric, subjective, and social (forming the level of the \"living animate\n\n\fand socially organized\"), — represents a specimen of the \"cohesive\"\norganization of the forms-levels transforming one into another and therefore\ncontentfully successive (including in themselves also even more numerous\nsubforms-sublevels).\nOn the basis of the adduced reasonings one can come to the following, not\nunimportant, in our opinion, conclusion: the consciousness of man is not\nsome passive \"reflection\" of reality, but it is reality itself, the reality itself or,\nmore exactly, the next form of the manifestation of the latter at the next\nstage of its (of the reality) \"ascent\", development. At this stage of its motiondevelopment the reality appears before us, as well as before itself, in the\nspecific form of man and his thinking. In this case, consciousness should be\naccepted not as a dead passive reflection or copy of everything preceding\nand existing inanimate and living, but as the next form of the manifestation\nof the contentfulness of the ascending, developing reality, continuing and\nuniting by itself the whole row of the preceding forms of this same reality.\nWith such an approach, the living chain of development (and its logic) is not\ninterrupted, growing by ever more capacious, contentful and therefore ever\nmore abstracted links-forms. Such a research approach gets rid of the\nartificial restriction from above on any development and, in particular,\nliquidates the known barrier erected by diamat. The succession of the\nchanging forms of reality is not blocked and does not end with the form of\nman and his thinking, but goes ever more in depth, into an ever more\nabstracting reality... Thereby the process of cognition is also not restricted to\nthe comprehension of the form of thinking as the most \"summit\" form of the\nforms of reality reliably known to us so far, but presupposes the presence\nand appearance of even more developed forms of it with a greater intensity\nof the contentful-formal transformations (transformations). But, what is more\nessential, such an approach makes it possible to forecast the further course\nof development (and, correspondingly, of cognition) and to anticipate with an\nincreasing degree of accuracy the appearance of new forms of the changing\nreality.\n§ 7. A model of reality from the position of our representations. The\nprinciple of self-development\nBut what, at least in the first and the roughest approximation, is this\ndeveloping reality that serves as the subject of our discussion? Let us try to\ndetermine a more or less integral model of it, answering to our views.\nLet us imagine some \"traveling\" two-component, but single integral\nformation or construction of the kind {content/form} — a very abstract\none (in its most general configuration), but in the course of its \"travel\"\nalways appearing in a concrete form, changing in the direction or towards the\nside of an ever greater and greater predominance in the composition of this\nconstruction of the component \"content\" and the acquisition thereby by the\n\n\f\"numerator\" of this relation of an ever greater specific weight within the\nscales of the integral relation [2, 8, 23].\nThe changeability of this abstract relation {content/form}, directed in a\ndefinite way, is conditioned by the simultaneous unity and non-identity\n(dissimilarity) of its components, by virtue of which both components are in a\nstate of interaction and inexhaustible motion towards rapprochement with\neach other and the acquisition of equilibrium (balance) or mutual\nexpressiveness by each other (which means: to become maximally contentful\n— for the form, and to determine itself with its perfect form — for the\ncontent). The presence in one integral relation of two components with\ndifferent types of activity gives rise to a vortex, a whirlwind, a circulation, a\n\"self-winding\" spiral, i.e., a change (motion, development) of a specific\ncharacter both of both constituents of this relation and of the relation itself as\na whole.\n\"Empirical experience\" and abstract thinking make it possible to reveal the\ndeep essence of this motion, clothing it in the formulation of a certain\nuniversal principle of self-development [2, p. 10; 8, p. 53-54; 23, p. 4]:\nthe development of content is carried out in the direction of the\nexhaustive expression by the developing content of the very same\ndeveloping content. Applied to the surrounding world, this means\napproximately the following: everything that exists and develops has as the\ndirection of its development and existence the expression by itself of the\nexisting and developing itself existing and developing.\nThe abstract relation {content/form} with a quite unambiguous directedness\nof the change-motion-development of the components or constituents of this\nrelation, as well as of the whole relation as a whole, — this is what exists\ninitially, everywhere, objectively and independently of any concreteness\nwhatsoever; this is what, by virtue of its omnipresence, permeates through\nitself all the available and arising concrete forms-levels-relations. It is\nprecisely the contentful-formal transformations of the above-described\ndirectedness (i.e., the changes of the components of the relation in a strictly\ndefinite side, in a strictly definite direction) that lie in the foundation of the\ndevelopment of the forms of reality, which are, in their turn, merely the\nconcrete attire and embodiment of the abstract model presented above. And\nit is precisely this initial model that, by virtue of its solidity, is, in our opinion,\nthe most acceptable and effective for the in-depth study, research, and\npenetration into the essence of the surrounding world (the changing reality)\nat the present stage of its development.\nThe noted dual-unity with a very strict and definite directedness of the\ncontentful-formal transformations (transformations) explains the everymoment uniqueness of the world being acquired (the Universe, nature, life,\netc.), as well as the uniqueness and diversity of the existing and nascent\nforms as separate elements of this world.\n\n\fBeing a strictly abstract formation, the indicated relation {content/form} is in\nprinciple not manifestable in its most general kind or image, but at the same\ntime constitutes the core or the very essence of any and every real concrete\nform.\nThe historical path of the abstract construction {content/form}, likened to\nthe \"travel\" of it in concrete images, runs through a great multitude of all\nsorts of concrete forms (including also such kindred to it, but still more\nconcrete forms-relations as {subject/object}, {subjective/objective},\n{abstract/concrete}, etc.). It is not the task of the present article to trace\nthe contentful-formal transformations of this relation in the course of its\nhistorical motion-development, — and therefore we shall note only that the\ninitial, as, probably, and the final points of its \"travel\" are lost in the hazy\nmists of the past and the future, in parallel coexisting in a single bundle or\naggregate of concrete forms growing one out of another and transforming in\nthe course of the \"travel\" under consideration.\nUnder the \"control\" of the mentioned principle of self-development, internally\ninherent in all formations-forms and conditioning the existence (on its basis)\nof all forms without exception, from the form of thingness, accepted by us as\nthe conditional beginning of the development of all the other forms of the\nsurrounding world, there developed the next new form of sensations, united\nwith the first form into one whole. This second form differs from the first by a\ngreater intensity of content-form transformations, that is, it ensures feedback, or\nreturn to itself, and the \"cognition\" (reproduction, self-organization) of itself with\na greater \"velocity\" than the substantial form. Under the pressure and control of\nthe same principle, the second form has developed over time into an even more\ncapacious and, accordingly, more abstract form of thought, uniting within itself,\nas it were, three interrelated forms — the substantial, the sensory, and the\ncognitive; and this third form is characterized by an even greater intensity of\ncontent-form transformations in comparison with the two preceding forms. Thus,\nall three indicated forms \"operate\" as if in a single bundle, in a unified aggregate,\nensuring an ever more intensive \"unwinding\" of the processes of development\nand cognition of the surrounding world under the \"control\" of the universal\nprinciple of self-development common to all forms.\nMan, who appears primarily as the \"carrier\" of the form of thought, in fact\nrepresents a tight knot of all three forms, characterized by the harmonious unity\nof these individual forms within their formed aggregate, crowned by the most\nabstracted, powerful, and capacious form of thought. Man is a \"pyramid\" of the\nabove-listed interlinked forms of developing reality in the thus \"equipped\" next\n\"advanced\" form of the same developing reality.\nUnder the \"diktat\" of the principle of self-development, the content of any form\nmoves beyond its own form in the direction of possessing a form of even greater\ncontentfulness, that is, a form of greater capacity and receptacle for the\n\"accommodation\" of this self-developing, \"self-making\" content. Thus, the\nprocess of the content \"coiling\" onto itself while existing — with the formation of\n\n\fa hierarchical chain of forms that are ever more content-capacious and,\ntherefore, ever more abstracted — is incessantly carried out.\nThe very formulation of the principle of self-development indicates that the\nprocess of cognition is carried out by the expression or replacement of the\nincomprehensible by the comprehended, of the unknown by the known and\nwell-familiar, i.e., by the circles of self-expression; and such a way of motion\n(cognition) most exactly fits the interpretation of the term \"interpreting\"\n(about which we will speak below). All the constructions of new forms,\nincluding the formation of the cognitive forms, go by the expression of the\nforms through themselves. In essence, the process of cognition, being at first\na separate twig standing out on the general trunk of development, closes up\nin the further course with the latter, turning out to be simply its continuation\nidentical to it.\nSince in nature there is no other building material than nature itself or the\nsurrounding world, everything is built and superstructed from itself, by \"selfmaking\", — everything \"dances from the stove\", from the basis, by means of\nthe unceasing self-expression, i.e., the expression of the changing through\nthe existing and the available.\nEverywhere, universally, and every moment there functions and is realized\nthe single principle of self-development, which conditions the motion of all\nthe forms. The impelling causes, \"mechanisms\", forces, and motives of any\nchange, motion, development should be considered as manifestations of\ndifferent intensity of the contentful-formal transformations of the\ncomponents in the relation {content/form} under the control of the universal\nprinciple of self-development. In the opinion of F. Engels, \"in any field of\nnatural science, even in mechanics, one makes a step forward every time\nwhen somewhere one gets rid of the word force\" [20, p. 130].\nEvery change-motion-development is explained by the presence of two\nunequal, non-identical principles in their single naturally-conditioned\nrelation, endowed, on the one hand, with an inexhaustible natural striving\nfor unification and mutual expressiveness and, on the other hand, with no\nless natural incompatibility and opposition. As has already been noted earlier,\nit is precisely such a dual-unity and confrontation of the two principles in\ntheir natural striving for identity, which they never attain, that determines\nthe diversity and uniqueness of the forms of the surrounding world.\nThe relation {content/form} in combination with the formulation of the\nprinciple of self-development gives a sufficiently exhaustive representation\nabout the directedness of all the processes, both on the gnoseological and on\nthe ontological levels of reality, and therefore can serve as a naturallyobjective foundation for the unification of the sciences that have taken shape\nover the period of the gnoseological activity of human thinking.\n\n\fOne can speak about some connection between the components in the\nrelations,\nsuch,\nsay,\nas\n{content/form},\n{subjective/objective},\n{abstract/concrete}, {man/nature}, etc., only when the presence of one\ncomponent in the other is established, when these components are mutually\npenetrated and expressed through each other, when some correlation is\nestablished between them. The formulation of the principle of selfdevelopment in the most compact form simply \"manifests\" and \"fixes\" such a\nrepresentation about the dynamic interconnection of the componentsconstituents of reality: the development of anything whatsoever is directed\nat the absorption, assimilation, and reproduction of itself developing in such\na way, as well as at the establishment every time of a new correlation\nbetween the investigated components \"content\" and \"form\" in their\ninvestigated relation {content/form}. As a particular case of development, as\nits separate branch, human cognition is also oriented at the comprehension\nof itself cognizing and thus developing.\nThe objective process of the increase of the contentfulness of the forms on\nthe gnoseological level (as a result of the active \"work\" of the principle of\nself-development on the level of thinking) is perceived and evaluated by\nthinking itself as the increase of the degree of its (of thinking) adequacy,\nwhich is equivalent to the perfection of the forms and ways of its\nrepresentation and existence on this level (in the form) of notions,\ncategories, theories, speculative models, etc.\nOn the other levels the results of the \"work\" of the same principle are,\ncorrespondingly, different. So, say, on the level of the living inanimate (the\nvegetable and animal world, including man as an animal) the process of the\naccumulation of contentfulness is clothed in the following forms: the\nextraction of nutritive substances from the soil and the surrounding\nenvironment (in plants); gathering, search, hunting, and the eating of prey\n(in animals); the taking of food (in man). The motion and enrichment of the\ncontentfulness by means of the reproduced and changing hereditary\n(inherited) forms, i.e., by means of the reproduction of offspring, — is also in\nthe row of the contentful development on the vegetable and animal levels. In\nother words, at the more primitive (from the standpoint of human\nconsciousness) animal and vegetative levels, content-based accumulations are\nrealized, respectively, in more primitive forms — less encompassing and less\ncontentful than at the level of thought. An indicator for assessing the results of\nthe \"work\" of the same principle at these levels, similar to the indicator of\nadequacy for the level of thought, is the effectiveness with which an animal or a\nplant solves the tasks of survival and ensuring its own stable development.\nIt follows from what has been said in the two preceding paragraphs that there is\nno insurmountable chasm between the content-based movement at the level of\nthe \"living inanimate\" and at the level of \"thought.\" This chasm is easily\novercome if we regard thought with its forms and modes of existence (in the\nform of concepts, categories, speculative models, theories, doctrines, teachings,\netc.) not as a kind of \"ideal reflection\" of something material in the human brain,\n\n\fbut as a continuation of the realization of the same mechanism, the same\nalgorithm of content-based movement, but in other (specific) forms and at\nanother level — with a bias, a shift towards ever more encompassing, ever more\ncontentful forms of developing reality, which the aforementioned conceptual\nforms are. Thus, the key moment in the awareness of the essence of the\ntransition of the contentful motion from level to level is the understanding or\nrepresentation about the change of the forms of the contentful motion\n(towards the increase of the degree of the abstraction of the forms), but\nwithout the change of the principle (mechanism or algorithm) of this\nmotion.\nNeither nature nor matter is endowed with the \"universal property of\nreflecting\", but act only as the forms of the manifestation of the action of the\nsingle universal dynamic principle of self-development, conditioning the\n\"self-winding\" or spiral-cyclic motion of everything existing, which in statics\nis perceived by human thinking as the reflection of itself in itself or as selfreflection.\nIt should be noted that the forecast about the emergence and appearance of\neven more abstracted forms, following the form of thinking, is made here\nalready not on an empty place, but on the basis of and with the account of\nthe principle of self-development, conditioning the spiral-cyclic contentfulformal transformations with a bias towards the increment of the\ncontentfulness of the next new forms. It would be the \"height of\nsuperficiality\" not to see that by the form of man and his thinking the\ncontentful motion (or the motion of the contentful constituent of reality) does\nnot end and is not exhausted. How, in what new abstracted forms this\nmotion continues after the contentful-formal \"transition\" or \"leap\" from the\nform of man with his consciousness — is still to be investigated and\nascertained. However, with all definiteness one can say that these next\nprospective forms have no bearing on any eternal paradise or hell under the\npatronage of a \"supreme deity\". The Absolute is impossible, is\nunrealizable in principle! Every subsequent form partly contains in a\nconcentrated (\"sublated\") form (and to some extent even \"surpasses\" by\nitself) the content of the preceding form, but is by no means final and allembracing. The contentful motion is inexhaustible and at its next stages\nappears by means of ever new and ever more contentful (and precisely\ntherefore ever more abstracting) forms.\nIn this connection let us allow ourselves to adduce a small exampleillustration to what has been said. On a clear sunny morning you \"walk\" your\ndog on a forest edge. The curious animal will not fail, perhaps, to thrust its\npaw or nose into a forest anthill, should such turn out to be nearby. As a true\nlover and guardian of wild nature, or perhaps for some other considerations,\nyou will hasten to drag the dog away from the anthill by the leash. Now put\nyourself in the place of the ant and imagine that anxiety and horror which\ntake possession of you every time when an incomprehensible something, by\n\n\fyour standards omnipotent, but alien to all your ant essence, suddenly\ncollapses from somewhere \"above\" onto your measured ant life.\nAnd then one fine day the veil falls from your eyes and it is discovered that\nthis very most horrifying and omnipotent something sits on a short leash at\nanother \"deity\" — an even more \"supreme\" and even more \"commander-inchief\", which does not let the first \"all-holder\" and arbiter of ant destinies run\nwild. For every \"master\" of the first level there is found its own \"master\" of\nthe second level, for the chain of the forms of the contentful motion is\ninfinite. It is not excluded that the \"master\" of the first level in some way\n\"interferes\" in your ant life, but it is true, however, also that he is dependent\nnot only on the \"masters\" of other \"supreme\" or more summit levels of\ndevelopment, but also on your ant level. And the name of this whole\nstructure of nested (more exactly, conjugated successive) forms and of the\nprocess generating it — is the spiral-like \"self-winding\" content-formal\ninfinity.\nLet us hope that this extremely simplified example will at least somehow help\nto understand the essence of the content-formal motion. If, however, even\nafter such an illustration you do not cease to consider that the omnipotent\n\"deity on a leash\" remains for you the most \"supreme commander-in-chief\",\nto whom, as before, one must bow in the hope of his patronage and\nprotection, then nothing will be able to prevent you from continuing to abide\nin peace in the captivity of your sweet dreams and delusions.\n[By the way, to seek the traces of the presence of a more highly organized\n(i.e., gone ahead in its development) level-form, proceeding from the\nprimitive representations about the extraterrestrial \"mind\" and other forms of\n\"life\", is absurd and fruitless. So far, with confidence one can assert only that\nthis next level of the development of reality differs from the forms-levels of\nour cluster of reality by a substantial leap in the intensity of the contentformal transformations. To say something definite about the forms in which\nreality is acquired at that next level of its existence is still extremely\nproblematic.]\n§ 8. The problem of the objectivity and independence of the object\nfrom the subject from the position of our representations\nThe problem of the independence-dependence of the object from the subject\nin the course of the establishment of the objectivity of the contentfulness in\nthe developing forms of reality was tried to be solved and is being solved by\nmany researchers. Here the following variant of its solution is proposed, or,\nmore exactly, merely the next approximation to its \"exhaustive\" (i.e., \"full\nand final\") solution.\nThe acute moment with which all philosophical currents in one way or\nanother collide is the necessity of the acceptance of one or the other side in\nthe reasonings about the independence or, on the contrary, the\n\n\finterdependence of the object and the subject. Diamat, as is known, solves\nthis task in favor of the visible and thinkable independence of the object from\nthe subject. From our position, the question about the independence of the\nobject from the subject or of the objective from the subjective in their\ncorresponding relations {subject/object} and {subjective/objective} is akin\nto the question about the attempt of the separation and isolation of the\ncontentful and formal components in the initial, most general (abstract)\nrelation {contentfulness/form}. Applied to this relation, the sources of the\ndistinction of the indicated components go back into the latent (hidden)\nsyncretic unity. The justice of such an assessment and such a conclusion is\nconfirmed by the point of view of G.W.F. Hegel: \"In the consideration of the\nopposition between form and content it is essentially important not to lose\nsight of the fact that the content is not formless, the form at one and the\nsame time is both contained in the content itself and represents something\nexternal to it\"; and even more definitely: \"The form is the content\" [3, p.\n298].\nSupposing that the relations {subject/object} and {subjective/objective} are\nmerely more concrete manifestations of the abstract relation {content/form},\nthat high rank of subjectivity [5] with which the \"numerators\" of the first two\nabove-indicated relations are endowed, in our opinion, in no way excludes\nthe deep inseparability and dependence of them on the corresponding\n\"denominators\", — except that the noted inseparability and dependence\nbecome even more latent and implicit when compared with the\nunambiguously manifesting interdependence of the components in the\nrelation {content/form}. The latter circumstance (the increasing hiddenness)\nand serves as the source of the assertions about the independence of the\ncomponents of the objective and the subjective (of the object and the\nsubject) from each other, categorically and endlessly reproduced (the speech\ngoes about the assertions) by the adherents of this opinion.\nProceeding from our position, it is necessary to state that, exactly the\nopposite, the visible isolation, autonomy, self-sufficiency, and independence\nof the components of the objective and the subjective from each other are\nonly relative, since subjectivity (as an active acting principle, as selfsufficiency, as selfhood, as individuality, as competence [15]) is\ncharacteristic of the contentful components (i.e., of the \"numerators\") of all\nthe concrete relations of this type, and this subjectivity or greater activity of\none component with respect to the other by no means abolishes their\ninterdependence and deep inseparability, and, consequently, the feedback\nconnection or the influence on each other.\nA known example of the demonstration of the presence of that same hidden\nsyncretic inseparability of the components in the relations of this type serves\nalso the ancient paradox concerning the establishment of the primacy of the\nhen or the egg.\n\n\fBy the way, the activity and the leading principle of the component of\ncontent in comparison with the passivity and conservatism of the component\nof form in the very relation {content/form}, as the forerunner of the clearly\nmanifesting subjectivity of the \"numerators\" of the derivative relations\n{subject/object} and {subjective/objective}, likewise is not an obstacle for\nthe deep syncretism of the components-constituents of this abstract relation.\nSumming up what has been said, let us muster the courage to declare that,\napplied to all the above-considered relations, such a question about the\nestablishment of the primacy and the assertion of the complete\nindependence of the components of these relations from each other is not\nsolvable and is meaningless in principle, since in the very content or\ncontentful component of the initial (for all the concrete relations) relation\n{content/form} there is already initially present the subjectivity of the\ncontent with respect to the form, as in the component with a clearly\nexpressed sign of the active leading principle in comparison with the more\npassive conservative component of the form, and nevertheless the sources of\nthe qualitative difference of one component of this relation from the other\n(the sources of the distinction of the components of this relation) go back\ninto the inseparable syncretic unity.\nIn the inanimate (thing) nature this, so to say, \"subjectivity of the thing\"\nmanifests itself episodically and therefore in an explicit way is expressed\nrather weakly, indistinctly, veiledly, but meanwhile even there already serves\nas the underlay of all sorts of interactions, manifesting themselves in the\nform of collisions, impacts, destructions, explosions and, in the general case,\nof all sorts of changes (winds, hurricanes, fires, downpours, floods,\nearthquakes...).\nAs the intensity of content-form transitions intensifies within a series and\nthrough a series of highly specific relations, the indicated subjectness of the\ncontent-based component \"fortifies\" and increasingly confidently and distinctly\n\"steps\" outward, thereby revealing the obvious confrontation and antagonism of\nthe two constituents, the two components of a certain unified relation, until,\nfinally, it takes shape as an allegedly separate, autonomous, and content-based\nsubject (man or, in some cases, a higher animal) existing independently of the\nform (i.e., the object, nature), which has in fact lost only the clearly (visually)\nexpressed connection with the object (nature).\nThe notorious active principle, latently present in any element of reality\n(manifesting itself, for example, through the movement of electrons in atoms\nand molecules, or in the form of the so-called forces of gravity between celestial\nobjects, or through streams of solar (cosmic) rays and the influence of\nelectromagnetic fields, or in the form of earthly tornadoes, cyclones, volcanoes,\netc.) — is the primordial prototype of that active content-based (subject)\ncomponent of all inanimate and living matter, which subsequently, after passing\nthrough numerous intermediate forms, transforming and modifying beyond\nrecognition, finally appears before us in the image or guise of the human\n\n\fpersonality as a creator, a maker, a subject, while, however, being at the same\ntime latently bound to the form-based passive (object) component in a single\nand integral {subject/object} relation. Thus, the mutual independence of form\nand content, as well as of object and subject in the cases examined, is highly\nrelative — greater in some aspects, lesser in others; however, in any case, the\nreverse side of this apparent independence is their hidden, deep, essential unity\nand interdependence.\nThe subjective has grown out of the so-called objective, is its continuation,\nbut only by other forms, and already for this very reason alone they (the\nobjective and the subjective) cannot be considered completely independent\nfrom each other. The subjective includes in itself the developed content of\nthe objective, — in some sense the initial (source) content of the object\n\"refracted\" by the subject. The subject — this is precisely the new form of\nthe \"ascending\" essence of the object. But if the subjective contains in itself\nthe sources and the developed part of the objective, does this not mean that\nsame latent unity with the objective after the manner of the syncretism of\nthe constituents in the relation {content/form}? And the fact that in the\nguise of the feedback connection the subject is capable of exerting an\ninfluence on the object also proves their single nature and basis. Thereby the\nindependence of the object from the subject can be recognized as purely\nnominal, relative, and by no means absolute.\nThe historically accomplished and visually ascertainable separation or\nisolation of the subject from the object testifies only to the fact that by some\npart of itself the object is still contained and present in the subject and,\nconsequently, represents also a part of their common system and therefore\nis dependent on it, — which, in essence, is confirmed by the possibility of the\nreverse influence on the object from the side of the subject.\nUnder the objective content of reality in its ultimate expression (like the\nnotion of the absolute truth as the motion from the relative truth in the\ndirection of the achievement of the absolute truth) is understood the\nmotion-development of its (of reality) contentfulness by means of the\nforms of different levels in the direction of the acquisition of a single\ngeneralized form of the highest (maximally possible) contentfulness. In the\ncourse of such a motion-development, registered and fixed by the human\norgans of sense and thinking, there takes place the change of the forms of\nthe representation and acquisition of the content on different levels: from the\ninanimate, further to the living-inanimate and, then, to the living-thinkinganimate, differing by different correlations of the components of\n{subjective/objective} in their multilevel relations-forms. At that, each of the\nforms successively grows out of the preceding one, being, as it were, its\ncontinuation and remaining in the bundle (with the indispensable presence\nof the direct and feedback connection) with all the preceding forms-levels\ninvolved in the general spiral-cyclic content-formal motion.\n\n\fBeing most closely interwoven in one bundle, these forms of the motiondevelopment of the objective content nevertheless (and precisely by virtue of\nthe mutual connectedness) are permeated and mediated by the subjective\nform of the conditionally finite and highest (of those reliably revealed at\nthe given moment) level, which is the form of human thinking\n(consciousness). This kind of mediation cannot but tell on the assessment of\nthe objectivity itself (of the objective content) through the prism of\nsubjectivity, i.e., conditions the impossibility of the separation and isolation\nof the properly objective content from the \"admixture\" of the subjective\ncontent, from the presence of the component of the subjective and the\nimpossibility of the conduct of the assessment of the objectivity outside the\npresence of the constituent of subjectivity.\nBy virtue of the inevitability of the conduct of the assessment of the\nobjectivity through the prism of subjectivity, the objective itself is penetrated\nby the subjective and is clothed in the form of the generally accepted and\nuniversally significant, which, however, does not prevent this form from\nbeing the continuation of the objective and at the same time being this\nsame objective. The separate subjects or individuals are precisely for that\nreason similar to each other, for that very reason are like each other (both\nexternally and internally), that in fact they represent the generalized\n(aggregate) form of the acquisition of the single objective content of\nreality, represented by uniform fragments at a quite definite level of its (of\nreality) motion-development.\nHowever, the set of subjective contents realized through the aggregate or\nrow of similar to each other subjects (individuals) acquires the status of the\nobjective content not at once and not always. The subjective contents,\nrepresented by the abstract subjectively ideal forms, can be considered\nobjective only then, when their objectivity is verified and confirmed by the\nsuccession of the contents of all the layers-forms of the generalized pyramid\n(see § 6-7) and, in the first place, by the possibility and admissibility of the\nexpression (\"substitution\") of the superstructural contents of the summit\nforms of the pyramid by the contents of the primary material-thing forms\nlying in the foundation of that same pyramid. Outside such a verification, the\ncontentfulness of the previously accepted universally significant (with a\n\"touch\" of the subjective) may turn out to be an ordinary lie, approved and\naffirmed by the collective majority in the expectation of its momentary gains\nand preferences. About the ways and methods of the establishment of the\nobjectivity of the content of the subjective forms we will speak below.\nThus, the objective content — this is also, by and large, always only a\nrelation of the type {subjective/objective}; in a pure form there is neither\nthe one nor the other. About what form of the object can one speak outside\nits mediation by the subject? Outside the relations with the subject — this is\nmerely an indeterminacy. The replenishing aggregate of the separate\nsubjective perceptions of one and the same something and demonstrates by\nitself the approximation to the ever more complete expression of the\n\n\fobjective content of this something. The criterion of the completeness of the\nexpression or comprehension of the objective in such a case can be only the\nvolume (or the \"quantity\") of the objective contentfulness, which gives the\n\"go-ahead\" for the becoming and the success of the existence of this or that\nform.\nLet us emphasize here once again that the subjective image of the object is\nnot the reflection of the object, but the continuation in a specific form of its\n(of the object) developing content (like the continuing \"ascent\" of the\nessence of the object in other, different from the thing, forms).\nSo that complete independence of the object from the subject, as well as of\nthe subject from the object, does not happen, — precisely by virtue of the\nsyncretism of the connection of the contentful and formal components in the\nrelations {subject/object}, {subjective/objective}.\nThe simplest and most illustrative example from everyday life in confirmation\nof what has been said — is the relation {child/mother}.\nThe \"numerator\" and \"denominator\" of the indicated relation correlate with\neach other as the components subject-object, change-basis, content-form in\nthe\ncorresponding\nrelations\n{subject/object},\n{change/basis},\n{content/form}. With respect to its child, the mother, undoubtedly, acts in\nthis case both as the basis, and as the form, and as the object — whoever,\nwhatever might say on this account. However far from each other in space\nand in time the mother and her child might be, the mutual connection and\ninterdependence are preserved forever — in the genes, in the tissues, in the\nthoughts, habits, behavior, way of life, preferences, etc., etc. Even by the\nmodern, not so perfect, means of objective control to establish this kinship\n(or the existence of the common ineradicable objective unifying basis)\npresents no difficulties whatsoever.\n§ 9. The point of view of diamat on the role of abstractions and\nsubjectively abstract forms in the course of cognition. The\ninterpretation of the term \"interpretation\"\nIn order to advance further in the exposition of our views and approach, one\nwill have to stop for a while on the representations of dialectical materialism\nabout the role of abstractions and the necessity of the recourse in the course\nof cognition to subjectively abstract forms.\nThe method of abstractions (or of abstracting) by the definition of the\n\"Philosophical Encyclopedic Dictionary\" [19, p. 7] — is a universal method of\ncognition, the logical foundation of the understanding of nature and social\nlife, — both in the subjective sense, since by means of abstraction \"we turn\nevery thing into a logical category\" [14, p. 131], and in the objective sense,\nsince abstractions (categories of thinking) are the \"expression of the\nregularity both of nature and of man\" [12, p. 83].\n\n\fThe significance and depth of the elaboration of this method is testified by\nthe following its characteristic: \"Abstractions applied to the immediate sense\ndata are called abstractions of the first order; the abstraction from the\nabstraction of the first order gives the abstraction of the second order, etc.\nCognitive significance can be possessed by abstractions of any order, but\nspecial trust is deserved by abstractions whose results can be comprehended\non material models. Such abstractions are called real, the rest — ideal\n(idealizations). The most important task of scientific methodology is the\ncomprehension of the abstractions of a high order through the abstractions of\na lower order or the replacement of the ideal abstractions by real ones.\n...The most developed system of abstractions is possessed by mathematics,\nwhich itself in essence is the science about abstractions: they constitute its\npremise, method, and subject\" [19, p. 7]. Here is also adduced one more\nextremely important, in our opinion, judgment concerning the fact that the\nordinary comprehension, say, of abstract theories goes, as a rule, by way of\ninterpretation.\nThe need for the analysis and systematization of the abstract constructions\nelaborated by thinking, as well as the above-listed diversity and hierarchy of\nthe latter, show how important it is for man (the cognizing subject, the\nresearcher) to be able to correctly assess the truthfulness of these\nconstructions and to have at his disposal reliable criteria and ways of such\nan assessment.\nAs we see, diamat approaches the analysis of the purpose and role of\nabstractions quite seriously. What main thought is traced in the description of\nthe method of abstractions? That one, that the understanding and\ninterpretation of abstractions requires the expression of them through each\nother (the higher through the lower, and further both of those through the\nmost thing-like and concrete — material ones). And the second important\ncircumstance, noted here as well, points to the fact that the comprehension\nof abstractions goes, as a rule, by way of interpretation.\nIn the indicated connection it is necessary also, in passing, to ascertain what\ncontentfulness diamat puts into the notion of interpretation. In the broad\nsense interpretation means \"explication, explanation, translation into a more\ncomprehensible language\" [17, p. 502]. In science and logic this notion is\ntreated as \"the aggregate of the values (meanings) attached in some way\nto the elements of a certain theory (to expressions, formulas, and separate\nsymbols)\". And further: \"The interpretation of the theoretical constructions of\nthe developed fields of scientific knowledge bears, as a rule, a mediated\ncharacter and includes in itself multistage [compare: multilevel, — Author's\nnote] hierarchical systems of intermediate interpretations. The connection\nof the initial and final links of such hierarchies is ensured by the fact that the\ninterpretation of the interpretations of a certain theory gives its\nimmediate interpretation. Thus, interpretation is an instrument of scientific\nmodeling. ...In the contentful natural-scientific and mathematical theories\nthere is always implied a certain interpretation: such theories use only the\n\n\fmeaningful expressions, i.e., the meaning of each expression is presupposed\nfrom the very beginning to be known\" [19, p. 215].\nIn continuation of the list of the adduced quotations one cannot but agree\nalso with the following interpretation: \"Contentful knowledge — this is such\nknowledge whose terms and statements have some value and meaning, i.e.,\na definite interpretation. To be contentful and means nothing other than\nto have an interpretation\" [10].\nAnd, finally, completing the quotation of the treatments of the term\n\"interpretation\", let us adduce one more judgment, according to which the\ninterpreting of notions means nothing other than the revelation in them of\nthe presence of objective content [7].\n§ 10. The role of abstractions and subjectively abstract forms from\nthe position of our representations\nIn view of the importance of the above-indicated questions let us speak\nthoroughly about what the subjective abstract forms represent, what is their\nrole and what are, in the end, the criteria of the truthfulness of these forms\n— now already from the position of our representations.\nAs the row of the above-adduced (see § 9) interpretations and definitions\nshows, the process of cognition is not reduced to the necessity of the\nexpression of the abstract forms exclusively or only through the thing forms,\nbut solves the task of the successive revelation and confirmation of the\nobjectivity of the contentfulnesses of all the forms present in the cognitive\nchain (from the thing forms, through the forms of sensations to the forms of\nthinking and within the framework of these latter — of the whole ramified\nhierarchy of abstract constructions and structures) by way of the expression\nof them through each other. In the final result this device or way of the\nmutual expression of the forms through each other and should lead to the\nestablishment of the truthfulness or falsity of the \"summit\" subjective\nabstract forms.\nSuch a device or way in its broadest sense is called interpreting. In the\nmost general case the main proof of the truthfulness of the hierarchical chain\nof the abstract forms turns out to be their interpretability (i.e., the possibility\nand admissibility of the interpreting of the abstract forms by more concrete\nforms). As one can already guess, the particular case of the technology of\ninterpreting, known and applied since time immemorial, is the procedure of\npractice, reducing to the interpreting of the abstract forms by the forms in\nthe overwhelming majority thing-like, mediated by the forms of sensations\n(or by the so-called empirical experience).\nWhat, in the end, is the speech about here? In essence, about the intentions\nto have a substantiated possibility to express one through the other: the\nincomprehensible through the comprehended, the particular through the\n\n\fgeneral, the abstract through the concrete — and then this concrete, in its\nturn already, to replace by the successive contentful abstract, in order to\noperate in the further investigations precisely with the verified\nabstract as with the next, more productive and effective means of\ncognition.\nIn distinction from the contentfulness of the form-level of the sensual (the\nsubjects of which can serve man and the animal) the content of the formlevel of the ideal (the subject of which serves man with his thinking) within\nthe framework, say, of the process of cognition of the above-mentioned\nobject (the stone-boulder, see § 6) constitute the following abstractions (in\nthe order of the increase of the degree of abstracting): the dimensions of the\nobject (length, width, height); the form of the object (cylinder, cube, sphere,\netc.); the weight (mass) of the object; the color of the object (the\nwavelength of the reflected light and its intensity); the hardness of the\nmaterial of the object (by Rockwell, Brinell, Vickers); the strength of the\nobject (for rupture, shear, bending, impact, etc.); the radioactivity of the\nmaterial, etc., etc. All this by the animals (from the ant to the dog and\nfurther — up to the anthropoid) is simply not assessed; the knowledge of the\nabove-listed properties of the object — this is from the field of the contentful\nideal, having significance only for man as an \"advanced\" subject of cognition.\nIn the establishment of the truthfulness of the abstract forms (i.e., of the\npresence in them of objective contentfulness) it is necessary in fact to\nanswer the question: does the found abstract construction or structure (as\nthe product of the form of thinking) admit the replacement or expression by\nmeans of the concrete form of thingness and/or by means of the less\nconcrete (than the thing) form of sensations, and to what degree is such a\nreplacement possible and admissible? For example, in order to ascertain in\nthe simplest way the truthfulness or justice of the abstract formula describing\nthe notorious law of Boyle-Mariotte (PV = const: the volume V of gases is\ninversely proportional to the pressure P [11, p. 131]), it is necessary\nempirically or mentally to \"replace\" (\"substitute\" or \"fill\") this abstraction\nwith concrete sensations; i.e., in the change of the position of the piston in\nthe cylinder, for instance, by pressing on the piston rod by hand, to put in\ncorrespondence to every its position (which is registered in a visual way as\nvisual sensations) the magnitude of the response force or of the back\npressure of the piston on the hand (which again is registered by the organs\nof touch as tactile and muscular-motor sensations). If under a certain\nstandard set of initial conditions (constant temperature and invariable mass\nof the gas in the cylinder), limiting the field of applicability or justice of this\nlaw, such a replacement is possible and admissible repeatedly, then this\nabstract product of the form of thinking can be considered true. And in this\nsame case, as is seen, the practical actions and their results serve as the\nmeasure or way certifying the possibility of the replacement (of one or\nanother degree of completeness) of the found abstract form (formula) by the\nconcrete form of another, more \"down-to-earth\", more \"low\" level (i.e., by\nthe measurement of the displacements of the piston and of the efforts\n\n\fcorresponding to them). Moreover, for the increase of the mentioned degree\nof the completeness of the replacement (for the purpose of the expansion of\nthe boundaries of the applicability of the abstract form) the description of the\nabstract form (in this case of the formula) requires, as is customary,\nrefinement and improvement, as a result of which the initial simple abstract\nform (the formula description of the law of Boyle-Mariotte) under other sets\nof the fixed initial conditions and parameters of the surrounding environment\ncan take the form of the laws of Gay-Lussac, Charles, Avogadro and, in the\nend, under the corresponding set of initial conditions can be replaced by the\nuniversal abstract form with maximally expanded boundaries of its\napplication. As a consequence of the produced refinements and the\nrefinement of the initial form of the law, there appears the equation of\nMendeleev — Clapeyron [22].\nIn other words, the essence of the practical actions or the verification by\npractice reduces to the establishment of the possibility and admissibility of\nthe replacement or substitution of the content of a certain abstract form (in\nthis case of the formula description of the law of Boyle-Mariotte) by the\ncontent of the form again more concrete (in this case by the content of the\nform of sensations). If the possibility of such a replacement is ensured and\nconfirmed, then there is confirmed or certified thereby also the truthfulness\nof the abstract form. In the final result (let us note once again) the\nverification by practice in fact turns out to be the particular case or variety of\nthe broader, generalized procedure of the establishment of the truthfulness\nof knowledge, which is the assessment of the possibility or admissibility of\nthe interpreting of the contents of the abstract forms by the contents of the\nmore concrete forms, i.e., by similar kindred practical examples and by the\nfactual material being obtained (obtained). If the abstract form admits\ninterpreting (i.e., the filling with concrete thing content, the conjugation and\nsuccession of the contents of the compared forms with the transition of them\ninto each other), then such an abstract form can be qualified as contentful\nand true.\nThe establishment of truth includes the coordination of the contentfulnesses\nof the forms (the sensual and the ideal), the finding of the correspondence of\nthe contents of the same forms and, as a perspective, the determination of\nthe quantitative correlations between the volumes of the conjugated\ncontents...\nThe question of the establishment and assessment of the truthfulness of\nknowledge and of the presence of objective content in the abstract forms by\nwhich this knowledge is represented — is always extremely actual, and not\nonly for the scientific and highly intellectual spheres of human activity, but\nalso for everyday life.\nIn the final result the most important in the process of cognition turns out to\nbe the contentful linkage of the abstract forms with the concrete ones,\nadmitting the interpreting or the expression of these abstract forms through\n\n\fthe preceding more concrete (including also the thing) forms-levels with the\naim, in the future, to operate with this abstract, as with a more\npowerful instrument of cognition in place of the concrete forms used\nwith the same purpose.\n§ 11. Development as the trajectory of transformations in the course\nof contentful movement. The ways of the establishment of the\npresence and completeness of objective content\nThus, the trajectory of the contentful-formal transformations in the course of\nthe \"through\" contentful movement looks as follows.\nTaking for the conditional beginning of the contentful movement (and of the\ntransformations of the forms) the form of thingness, we note the first\ntransition of the content of this form (by virtue of the inevitability of the\ncontentful-formal transformations, conditioned by the principle of selfdevelopment) into the content of the form of sensations; further we observe\nthe transition of the content of the form of sensations (by way of the\ncontentful-formal transformations, conditioned by the same principle of selfdevelopment) into the content of the form of thinking. Herewith the\nobjectivity of the contents of the forms of the presented chain is assessed\nonly in a mediated way — with the indispensable participation of the form of\nsensations and the form of thinking.\nFor the establishment of the presence of objective content in the thing forms\nof the surrounding world serve, in the end, not only the forms of sensations\n(the sense organs) of man, but also the sense organs of other\nrepresentatives of the animal world. Therefore not only the thing-practical\nactivity of man or practice turns out to be the way of the assessment of the\ncontentfulness of the thing forms; in the case of the expression of the\ncontent of the indicated thing forms by means of the content of the forms of\nsensations of the animal world the similar means is the behavioral reaction of\nthe animals.\nThe presence of objective content in the thing forms in the most simple cases\nis more impartially and reliably proved precisely by the comparison of the\nbehavioral reactions (habits, grimaces, emotions, sets of sounds, etc.) of the\nother, besides man, representatives of the animal world. If people can agree\namong themselves as to the coordination of the reactions to one and the\nsame object (which would mean the \"dragging through\" as objectivity of\nthe notorious general validity of the opinions about the object as the result\nof a certain agreement between people), then to imagine a similar\nagreement between the animals in relation to the similar reactions to the\ninvestigated object is simply impossible.\nOn the stage of the transformation of the objective content of the thing\nforms into the content of the forms of sensations of the representatives of\nthe animal world, including man, there occurs the filling and saturation of the\n\n\fforms of sensations with the content (contents) of the thing forms. This is\nthe stage of the accumulation by the forms of sensations of the so-called\nempirical experience. The establishment of the presence of objective content\nin the forms of sensations and the verification (assessment) of the content of\nthe forms of sensations for the objectivity of this content is carried out by the\nprocedure of practice.\nThe establishment of the objectivity of the content of the thing forms is\nperformed by the comparison of the contents of as large as possible a\nnumber of the forms of sensations. In the coincidence or sameness of the\ncontents of a row or a multitude of the forms of sensations there is made the\nconclusion about the objectivity of the content of the thing forms. If the\nconsequences and results of the interactions of the forms of sensations with\nthe thing forms (and of the thing forms among themselves) turn out to be\napproximately the same, then by such a coincidence of the contentfulnesses\nof the multitude of the forms of sensations of the representatives of the\nanimal world, including man, there is proved the relatively independent of\nthe separate forms of sensations uniformity of the content of the thing world,\ni.e., the objectivity of this content.\nBesides, by the coincidence or identity of the contents of the forms of\nsensations (for a row or a multitude of the representatives of the animal\nworld, including man) there is proved not only the presence of the common\nobjective content in the thing forms, but also the objectivity of the contents\nin the compared forms of sensations.\nThus, at a certain stage of the movement-development of reality the content\nof its thing forms is transformed into the content of the more mobile and\n\"advanced\" forms, which become the forms of sensations of the\nrepresentatives of the animal world, including man; in other words, the\nmentioned content of the thing forms \"ascends\", so to say, to a new level of\nits representation by the forms of sensations. The objectivity of the content\nof the thing forms, as well as of the contents of the forms of sensations, is\nestablished in a practical way (by the procedure of practice) — by the\nassessment of the possibility and admissibility of the replacement of the\ncontents of some forms of sensations by the contents of other forms of\nsensations (i.e., by the carrying out of the indicated assessment as if\n\"horizontally\"), about which and should testify the sameness (coincidence) of\nthe contents of these forms in their comparison. Even the very presence of\nthe similar to each other or identical forms-carriers of sensations in the plural\n(for example, of human individuals) proves the succession of the contents of\nthe form of sensations and the form of thingness and, in the final result, the\nobjectivity of the contents of these forms.\nThis is that which concerns the linkage of the forms of thingness and\nsensations. Now — about the linkage of the forms of thingness, sensations,\nand thinking.\n\n\fThe objectivity of the contents of the abstract forms of thinking is verified\nand confirmed by way of the comparison and the establishment of the\npresence in these abstract forms of the concrete content, one and common\nto a certain degree for the whole linkage of the forms of thingness,\nsensations, and thinking.\nThe objectivity of the content of the more abstracted (in relation to the forms\nof thingness and sensations) forms of thinking is proved by the possibility\nand admissibility of the approximate expression or replacement of the\ncontent of the abstract forms by the contents of the more concrete thing\nforms, mediated by the forms of sensations. Besides, at the level of thinking\nitself, for the confirmation of the truthfulness of the purely (highly) abstract\nforms-products of thinking there can be attracted the less abstract formsproducts of the same thinking, already having or having received the status\nof genuine knowledge (the carriers of objective content) at the preceding\nstages of human activity. In this case the speech is about the carrying out of\nthe assessment of the contentfulness of the forms as if \"vertically\".\nFurther, to reveal the objective contentfulness of a certain abstract formproduct of thinking — this means to establish (by way of comparison) the\npresence in this form of the content common with the contentfulnesses of the\nmore concrete conjugated forms, and on this basis to make the conclusion\nabout whether the content of the abstract form \"fits\" into the chain of the\ncontents of the preceding concrete forms and whether it continues by itself\nthis chain; the positive answer to these questions means the positive answer\nalso to the question of whether the content of the investigated abstract form\ncan in such a way lay claim to objectivity.\nScience is considered a skeptical method of cognition, asserting itself over\nthe course of 400 years in the conditions of the most severe competition of\nthe views on this or that phenomenon (in the sense of the explanation of its\nfoundations and the forecasting of its consequences). What, in such a case,\nensured the prerogative of the scientific approach and the superiority of the\nway of scientific thinking (and of the obtaining of knowledge) in relation to\nthe other methods? The installation and aim exclusively at the objectivity of\nthe contents of the obtained knowledge, certified by the succession of the\nconjugated and passing into each other objective contents of the forms\ninterpreting this knowledge.\nThe procedure of the establishment of the presence and volume (\"quantity\")\nof objective content in this or that aggregate form, which is, say, the\nmultilevel form of man himself, requires the assessment of the presence of\nthe obligatory direct and reverse connection between the levels in their\naggregate (aggregate form). Practice or the thing-practical activity of man\nprecisely and acts in the role of the way or device confirming or certifying the\npresence of such a connection. The presence of the immediate connection\nbetween the levels testifies to their succession.\n\n\fOne way or another the process or procedure of the establishment of truth or\nof the truthfulness of the subjectively abstract forms is always carried out in\na spiral-cyclic way of the return to the sources (to the foundation — to the\nthing forms and the forms of sensations) and thereby of the return \"to\noneself at a new level\" (in which, in fact, is seen the essence both of the\nreverse connection, and of the contentful enrichment, and of the changemovement-development in the direction of the acquisition of the highest\ncontentfulness — i.e., of objective content — by the whole aggregate of the\nforms).\nIf in the course of the carrying out of such a procedure there is observed the\nabsence or instability of the direct and reverse connections between the\nsubjective and objective levels (the components in the relation\n{subject/object}), then precisely on this basis and should follow the\nunambiguous\nconclusion\nabout\nthe\nuntruthfulness,\nincorrectness,\nincorrectness, inaccuracy of the verified subjective form — the product of\nthinking (knowledge, judgment, assertion, definition, notion, formula, theory,\nconception, teaching, model, etc.).\nIn this connection it would be appropriate to add also that by virtue of the\npeculiarities of such a reciprocating movement (in which on any section of\nthe path the very course or the natural spiral-like character of the\ndevelopment of reality presupposes the return to the foot-foundation of the\npyramid, the \"feeding\" or enrichment of the acquired content by the\nprimordial life-giving sources, as well as its \"reverse\" movement to the reforming summit, to the re-forming contentful abstractions), not only\nevolution, but also revolutions, and crises, and conflicts, and other upheavals\nare not excluded, not finished, and not completed (as this might be desired\nby the uninitiated and uninformed man as to the \"mechanism\" of the\nrealization of the dialectical movement).\n§ 12. The criterion of truth — contentfulness. Development as the\nmovement of the forms of reality in the direction of the possession of\nthe highest contentfulness\nAs it was already possible to notice, the central notion on the basis of which\nour narration is built up and which will be even more persistently woven into\nthe canvas of the further reasonings is the notion \"content\" and its derivative\n— \"contentfulness\" [soderzhatel'nost'].\nIn accordance with the point of view reproduced above, development\nrepresents the \"ascent\" of objective content by the multilevel, but conjugated\none with another successive forms, which in the measure of the mentioned\nascent become ever more abstract and capacious, shifting or displacing into\nthe field of the ever more contentful subject forms, i.e., in the direction of\nthe \"numerators\" of the known relations {contentfulness/form},\n{subject/object},\n{subjective/objective},\n{abstract/concrete},\n{change/foundation}, etc.\n\n\fCorrespondingly to our approach the development of reality is carried out in\nthe direction of the increase of the contentfulness of its forms, which,\noccupying new informative levels, become also ever more abstract.\nLet us now set ourselves the following question, actual for us: in what\nrelation with the contentfulness of the forms is their truthfulness?\nAccording to diamat, truth — this is the objective content of the sensual,\nempirical experience, notions, ideas, judgments, theories, teachings, and of\nthe integral picture of the world in the dialectics of its development [19, p.\n226]. Since content is not formless, and form is not contentless (see § 8),\nevery content, including also that answering to truth, appears in reality or is\nrealized only through form and not otherwise, — to which, in fact, and is\npointed in the very definition of truth. In other words, truth does not\nmanifest itself in reality otherwise than through the forms (including also\nthe forms enumerated in the definition, such as: notions, judgments, ideas,\ntheories, teachings, empirical experience, etc.), and in the indicated aspect\nthe question of whether truth is the form of the manifestation of objective\ncontent is a rhetorical question.\nBy what sign (indicator, quality, property, component, constituent, etc.),\nproceeding from the adduced definition, should one assess the truthfulness\nof the forms, and including also the abstract forms of knowledge (notions,\nideas, judgments, theories, teachings, etc.)? Obviously, by the presence in\nthese forms of objective content. In other words, the contentfulness of the\nforms is subject to assessment, and, it seems, precisely this indicator (sign,\nquality, property, component, constituent, etc.) and will serve as the\ncriterion of the assessment of the truthfulness of this or that form.\nTaking into account the syncretic inseparability of content and form, about\nwhich was said above, every form \"from birth\" is endowed with a certain\ncontentfulness, but for human thinking the orientation serves and arouses\ninterest, as a rule, the maximal contentfulness and, correspondingly, the\nform of the expression of the highest contentfulness. Therefore it is most\nlogical to suppose that the most contentful form (i.e., the form maximally\n\"filled\" with objective content or the form possessing the highest\ncontentfulness) and will be the true form. Thus, truth, from the position of\nour representations, — this is the form of the expression of objective\ncontent (i.e., the form of the expression of the highest, maximally\nachievable contentfulness) of reality or of its separate element at every\ndefinite stage of its (of reality) development.\nHow, by what path, way, by what means, procedures, technologies can one\nassess the volume or \"quantity\" of the contentfulness of this or that\ninvestigated abstract form? By way of the expression or \"substitution\" (at\nleast mental) of the content of the investigated abstract form by the already\nassessed, verified, approved, and affirmed by man (i.e., endowed with the\n\n\fstatus of true) contents of the more concrete forms. Such a procedure is\nnamed practice, and within the framework of the broader application of such\na procedure or technology — interpreting. In both cases the mentioned\nprocedures reduce to the assessment of the possibility and admissibility of\nthe expression or substitution of the content of the investigated abstract\nforms by the contents of the more concrete and already verified forms (after\nthe manner of the above-described in § 10 way or procedure of the\nassessment of the truthfulness of the abstract form-formula of the law of\nBoyle-Mariotte).\nHere is one more example of the assessment of the contentfulness and\ntruthfulness of the forms. Simply speaking, if the volume of a spherical\nvessel of radius R is expressed, according to the \"machinations\" of abstract\nthinking, by the formula (4/3)πR³, then it does not constitute any difficulties\nto verify or assess the volume calculated in such a way, pouring into the\nvessel water or pouring river sand. By the assessment of the contentfulness\nof the form of thinking (i.e., of the above-indicated formula), carried out in\nthis case by the way or procedure of the substitution of the content of the\nabstract form of thinking by the content of the concrete form of sensations\n(filling the vessel with the then measured quantity of water or sand), one can\nascertain the truthfulness of the formula, i.e., the truthfulness of the formproduct of abstract thinking. And further, this abstract form (the formula for\nthe computation of the volume of the sphere), verified a million times for the\ncorrespondence or \"coincidence\" of its content with the content of the form of\nsensations, can, in its turn, be used for the verification and assessment of\nthe contentfulness of the other forms, to refer to it and to use it in the\nfurther investigations as the foundation with the confirmed and certified\ntruthfulness.\nThus, that criterion (sign, indicator, quality, property, component, etc.) by\nwhich one should assess truth or in the general case the truthfulness of\nthe arising, existing, and disappearing forms — this is by no means practice,\nbut the contentfulness of the forms. Practice, however, — this is merely\nthe procedure (process) of the carrying out of such an assessment, and\nmoreover limited mainly by the thing field of the activity of man. In relation\nto the broader field of application, including the assessment of the\ntruthfulness of the abstract constructions, structures, and edifices of various\nhierarchy and nesting, such a procedure is named interpretation (see § 9)\nor interpreting. In this connection practice turns out to be merely the\nparticular case, the narrow layer of the more extensive procedure or\ntechnology of the establishment of the truthfulness of the forms —\ninterpreting. Thereby practice — this is also interpreting, i.e., the\nreplacement (often mental) of some forms, as a rule more abstract, by the\nmore concrete and verified forms (in this same row is found also the process\nof modeling).\n[Practice — this is, above all, a process, and therefore in a certain sense an\nindeterminacy, which in itself is not very suitable for the definition of a\n\n\fcriterion. From the position of our reasonings the criterion of truth is not\npractice itself or the thing-practical activity of the subject with its results, but\nthe presence and volume or \"quantity\" of objective content in the\ninvestigated abstract forms, which and is established with the help of the\nprocedure of practice or in the general case of the technology of\ninterpreting.]\nThe genuine criterion of the assessment of the truthfulness of the abstract\nforms-products of thinking is the contentfulness of these forms. Practice,\nhowever, or interpreting — this is the technology (procedure, way, process,\nmeans, etc.) of the establishment of the presence and \"quantity\" of\ncontentfulness (i.e., of the presence and \"quantity\" of objective content) in\nthe investigated forms, and hence, in the final result, also of truth or of the\ntruthfulness of the investigated forms.\nOn the first stage of the realization of the mentioned technology there is\nestablished the presence of objective content (contentfulness) in the\ninvestigated forms by way of the assessment or verification of the possibility\nand admissibility of the as complete as possible substitution (expression,\nreplacement) of the contents of the investigated forms by the contents of the\nmore concrete forms (already verified and with the confirmed truthfulness),\ni.e., there is established the admissibility of the replacement of one by the\nother (the unknown by the known, the incomprehensible by the\ncomprehended, the irrational by the rational, etc.). By the results of such a\nverification there is made the conclusion about the interpretability of the\ninvestigated forms, i.e., about the succession of the substituting and\nsubstituted contents. The interpretability of the investigated forms in such a\ncase means the confirmation of the presence of a certain \"quantity\" of\nobjective content (contentfulness) in the investigated forms.\nOn the second stage there is assessed the completeness of such a\nsubstitution (i.e., there is determined the \"quantity\" of the contentfulness of\nthe investigated forms) by way of the finding or establishment of the as large\nas possible number of the concrete forms (already verified and with the\nconfirmed truthfulness) suitable for the carrying out of the above-indicated\nreplacement. By the results of the performed assessment there is made the\nconclusion about the completeness of the contentfulness, and then also\nabout the truthfulness of the investigated forms.\nBoth stages can be united into one and realized simultaneously. Thus, the\ninterpretability of the investigated forms and the number of interpretations\ngive a more or less complete representation about the status (truthfulness or\nuntruthfulness) of the investigated forms.\nOn the basis of the above-adduced reasonings one can come to that\nconclusion that the genuine criterion of the truthfulness of the forms\nserves their contentfulness, and the status of the true form or of truth\n\n\fanswers to the form with the maximally achievable (at this or that stage of\nthe development of reality) contentfulness.\nWhat, then, is the contentfulness of this or that form? One should suppose\nthat in application to the concrete objects and other material elements of\nreality the contentfulness (as the predominantly internal hidden component\nor constituent) of the concrete forms must nevertheless be represented from\noutside by means of some concrete external attributes of these objects or\nelements. Can the manifestation of contentfulness be, for instance, the\nbeauty of the form? Probably, it can. Beauty may well turn out to be one of\nthe attributes suitable for the assessment of contentfulness, and\nconsequently, also for the assessment of the truthfulness of a certain\nconcrete form. The same thing, obviously, can be said also about such\nmanifestations of the contentfulness of the concrete forms as simplicity (or,\non the contrary, complexity), economy (economicalness), usefulness,\npragmaticalness, rationality, systemicity, integrity, originality, etc.\nNow as to the contentfulness of the abstract forms: theories, conceptions,\nparadigms, plans, schemes, formulas, projects, diagrams, models, teachings,\netc. Beauty (for instance, mathematical beauty and the elegance of the\nformula) also can turn out to be the external manifestation suitable for the\nassessment of the contentfulness of this or that abstract form. The external\nembodiment of the contentfulness of the abstract forms may well be also the\nclarity of the judgment, and the harmony of the exposition, and the\ndemonstrativeness of the assertion, and the laconism of the thought (idea),\nand the logicality of the conclusions, and the non-contradictoriness of the\ntheory, and the general validity of the results, and the informativeness of the\ndiagram, and the simplicity of the scheme, and the compactness of the\nplanning, etc., etc.\nHowever, in whatever clothes the contentfulness of the concrete and abstract\nforms may dress itself, in both cases the contentfulness in the person of its\nabove-indicated manifestations must be confirmed by the interpreting of the\nassessed forms either by the results of the thing-practical activity (practice),\nor by the repeatedly verified and approved results (products) of the\ntheoretical (mental, subjectively ideal) activity of man. The procedure of\ninterpreting, however, presupposes under itself the as complete as possible\nexpression, replacement, or substitution (at least mental) of the content of\nthe investigated (verified) abstract form by the contents of the more\nconcrete forms. Then by the interpretability of the forms (i.e., by the\npossibility and admissibility of the contents of the investigated forms to be\nexpressed or substituted by the contents of the more concrete and verified\nforms) there is proved the presence of objective content in the investigated\nabstract forms.\nThe maximal or highest contentfulness, and hence also the truthfulness of\nthe investigated forms, in its turn, is proved by the possibility and\nadmissibility of the expression or substitution of the content of the abstract\n\n\fform by the concrete contents of the maximally possible number of the\nconcrete forms of different levels of concreteness (by the practical examples,\nthe factual material, the results of the numerous experiments, the repeatedly\nverified and affirmed by the scientific community results of the theoretical\ninvestigations, etc.). Only then the form with the contentfulness assessed in\nsuch a way can lay claim to a place in the list of the maximally contentful\nabstract forms, and, consequently, also of the true forms. In other words,\nthe truthfulness, i.e., the maximal or in the extreme case the sufficient\ncontentfulness of the abstract form, must be certified and confirmed by its\ninterpretability (the possibility and admissibility of being expressed) by the\ncontents of the other forms:\n— the more concrete, i.e., of the more \"low\" (by hierarchy) level of the\nforms;\n— of the abstract forms whose truthfulness is confirmed earlier and does not\narouse doubts,\nwhich and would testify to the succession of the contents of all these forms of\ndifferent levels, and, consequently, also to their objectivity.\nHere it is appropriate to return to the criterion of truthfulness proposed by A.\nPoincaré (see § 3). Analyzing in detail the statement of the French scientist,\none can see that from his point of view the \"internal harmony of the world\"\nand is the objective contentfulness conditioning the truthfulness of this (real)\nworld.\nCan the harmony of the world be the manifestation of its contentfulness?\nObviously, it can, as also beauty. The matter remains only for the small — to\ndecide how to assess this contentfulness (i.e., the internal harmony of the\nworld or of reality), in what conventional units or standards one should\nexpress it, in order to reveal the highest degree (level) of this contentfulness,\nwhich and will answer to the true form of reality.\nAnd with all this the assessment of the contentfulness of the investigated\nform (the internal harmony of the world by A. Poincaré) must be conducted,\nas was noted above, in full correspondence with the technology of\ninterpreting (i.e., with the establishment of the admissibility and\ncompleteness of the substitution of the content of the investigated form by\nthe contents of the possibly larger number of the concrete forms, as well as\nof the abstract forms whose truthfulness is confirmed earlier and does not\narouse doubts).\nIn view of the special importance of the considered question let us\nreproduce once again the substantiation of the above-advanced\ncriterion of truth (of the truthfulness of the forms of reality).\nSince the multitude of the dictionaries, including also the philosophical ones,\ninterpret the criterion as the sign on the basis of which there is produced the\nassessment of something [16, p. 130; 17, p. 664] and by which one can\ndetermine the truthfulness or falsity of the judgment [21], as well as as the\n\n\f\"distinctive mark by means of which we can recognize it (truth)\" [6], then\nwith all confidence one can say that such a sign or indicator in the case of the\nassessment of the truthfulness of the forms (i.e., in the process of the search\nand establishment of truth) is by no means practice.\nHere, for example, is what is reported in the \"Encyclopedic Dictionary\" of F.\nA. Brockhaus and I. A. Efron [21]: \"The formal criterion of truth serve the\nlogical laws: everything that does not contain in itself an internal\ncontradiction is logically possible, but in order to be true, it must correspond\nalso to the material criterion, i.e., to the factual content of the thought.\"\nAs we see, in the final account and here as the criterion of the truthfulness of\nthe forms there is advanced their factual (objective) contentfulness, which\nby no means diverges from our representations and our position. After all, to\nthe most correct and appropriate in this connection question — by what\nuniform sign or indicator one should assess the truthfulness of the abstract\nforms, what quality or property of the abstract form is subject to assessment\nfor the revelation and certification of its truthfulness — the answer suggests\nitself the following: the different forms can be correctly compared,\njuxtaposed, assessed only by the sign inherent to any and every form and\nnamed contentfulness (i.e., by the completeness or filledness of the form\nwith content). The most true, genuine, and actual is the form possessing the\nhighest contentfulness at the given moment of its (of the form)\ndevelopment; the less contentful form is both less true, and less reliable, and\nless effective, and less actual.\nThe filledness of the abstract form with internal content is assessed,\nestablished, verified by the external manifestations of the form, such, say, as\nbeauty, rationality, simplicity, obviousness, laconism, etc. But how, in what\nmanner, by what path, way, with the help of what procedure is such an\nassessment performed — this is already a question of technology. By practice\nis meant the procedure of the assessment of the truthfulness of the abstract\nforms, connected with the determination of the possibility and admissibility of\nthe substitution of the content of the abstract form by the contents of the\nconcrete forms, namely — by the contents of the thing forms, mediated by\nthe forms of sensations. From the heights of the present day this procedure\nis somewhat \"narrow\" in order to embrace by itself the whole broadest\nspectrum of the fields of the activity of the modern researchers. Therefore for\nthe assessment of the truthfulness of the forms in all the fields of the activity\nof modern man there is applied the procedure named interpreting.\nThe technology of interpreting is connected with the determination of the\npossibility and admissibility of the as complete as possible substitution of the\ncontent of the abstract form not only by the contents of the forms of\nsensations and of the thing forms, mediated by the human sensations (as in\nthe case of the procedure of practice), but also by the contents of such\nabstract forms-products of thinking whose truthfulness is preliminarily\nverified and repeatedly confirmed in the course of the preceding activity of\nman (the speech is about the practical examples, the empirical data, the\n\n\ffactual material, the formula expressions and computations, the schemes,\nthe models, the theories, the teachings, the axioms, the postulates, etc.,\netc., whose truthfulness and actuality does not arouse doubt, above all, in\nthe scientific circles or in the milieu of the learned public). In such a\nconnection the procedure of practice turns out to be the particular case of the\ntechnology of interpreting; i.e., practice also belongs to the technology of\ninterpreting, but with that only difference that here the procedure of the\nassessment of the truthfulness of the forms is carried out by the substitution\n(possibly mental) of the contents of the abstract forms by the contents\nmainly of such concrete forms as the forms of thingness, mediated by the\nforms of sensations.\nLet us emphasize, thus, once again, that not practice or in the general case\nthe technology of interpreting serve as the criteria of the truthfulness of the\nabstract forms, but such an omnipresent component or constituent of all the\nforms as their internal contentfulness (filledness or the degree of the\nfilledness with content). The procedure of practice or the technology of\ninterpreting allow only to assess the presence and completeness (i.e., the\n\"quantity\") of the contentfulness (and hence, also the degree or level of the\ntruthfulness) of the investigated forms. And now on the basis of the\nunderstanding of the essence of the criterion of the truthfulness of the\nforms there appears the possibility to meaningfully develop its (of the\ncriterion) numerical standards — to build, say, scales, diagrams, nomograms,\nrating systems, etc. for the numerical (quantitative) assessment, firstly,\nof the contentfulness and, secondly, of the truthfulness of the all possible\nforms.\nThe criterion of the assessment of the truthfulness of the form — this is its\ncontentfulness, and the level of the truthfulness or genuineness of the form\nis determined by the completeness of the content or by the \"quantity\" of this\nvery contentfulness. Hence truth — this is the form of the highest\ncontentfulness or of the maximally achievable completeness of the content at\nevery definite moment of the development of this form. Any form of the\nhighest contentfulness (i.e., the form maximally filled with content) at every\ngiven moment of its (of the form) development and is the true form. In such\na context it is easily understood that in its essence absolute truth — this is\nan iterative process of the infinite approximations to the exhaustive (final\nand complete) expression of the objective content of the developing reality\nby the diverse its (of reality) forms of the highest contentfulness.\nIf practice (as a procedure, as a technology, as a way, as a process, etc.),\nerroneously acting until now in the role of the criterion of truth, does not\nyield to the quantitative assessment and therefore cannot serve as the\ninformative criterion in the establishment of the truthfulness of the forms,\nthen the contentfulness of the forms — this is such a sign or indicator which\norganically, in a natural way is suitable and adapted for such an assessment.\n\n\fSomeone, surely, will say what nonsense is being carried on here — how can\none measure the contentfulness and the more so the truthfulness of\nsomething? The answer is simple: man from time immemorial is engaged\nonly in that he assesses and measures the contentfulness of the all possible\nforms of reality. From now on he will do this more meaningfully.\nIn every sphere of human activity there exist their own rating systems,\nscales, graphs, tables, diagrams, nomograms, etc. for the assessment of the\ncontentfulness of the diverse forms. The metric system of measures, the\nsystems SI, CGS, etc. with their conventional units and standards (kilograms,\nmeters, seconds, etc.), the monetary system, the virtual system Bitcoin (or\nsomething similar crypto-currency, coming to replace and as the continuation\nof money), the indices IQ, Hirsch, RSCI, etc. (as the attempts of the\nexpression in conventional units of the level of the intellect of man), the\nhumanistic systems of the assessment of spirituality (as the attempts of the\nassessment in conventional units of the spiritual potential of man) — all this\nis the examples of the rating systems allowing to assess the contentfulness\nof the all possible forms of reality, abiding at its different levels and in\ndifferent fields. The \"quantity\" of the measured contentfulness of the forms\nand answers to the different approximations of these forms to the absolute\ntruth or to the form of the \"exhaustive\" expression of the objective content of\nreality (in this or that its field).\nMan as one of the multitude of the forms of the multilevel reality, in his turn,\nrepresents a multilevel formation. But from the ancient times and until now\nthe contentfulness of man is determined mainly by the level of the material\naccumulations, present and, unfortunately, dominating (for now) among the\nother levels in their hierarchical aggregate. Money, herewith, and is the\nquantitative measure of the contentfulness of this dominant (i.e., of the\ndominating level in the composition of the aggregate of all the other levels of\nman), why they and occupy a special place and are the most widespread\nrating system among the other systems and scales of the quantitative\nassessment of the contentfulness of the forms. Being, however, the measure\nof the contentfulness mainly of the \"down-to-earth\" material levels and\nsublevels in the composition of the multilevel form of man, the rating\nmonetary system by virtue of the indicated circumstance is not so universal\nas it seems, and is \"powerless\" in relation to the assessment, say, of the\nspiritual and other summit spheres and levels of the \"abiding\" of the true\ncontentfulness of the human \"I\". Spirituality or morality, being the aggregate\nof the deep human feelings, mediated by the human thinking\n(consciousness), in general poorly yields to the quantitative assessment with\nthe use of the existing \"down-to-earth\" standards. For the assessment of the\nspiritual potential of man there is required a special filigree-refined scale.\nMoney — this is a primitive \"measurer\" of the volumes of the content or\npotential of the forms mainly of the material-thing level (and not a certain\n\"universal equivalent\"; the incorrect or outdated basic representations\nsometimes seriously hinder the understanding of the essence of the\n\n\fproblem), behind the \"monumental\" facade of which is hidden the\nunpretentious essence of this \"gasket\" as one more superfluous intermediate\nelement (similar to the notions \"reflection\" or \"copy\" in the known\nepistemological theories), the need for which will fall away in the measure of\nthe perfection of the organization of the social structure.\nIn the same way as the scales, the clocks, the various kinds of counters\n(electric, gas, water) and other counting devices serve as the simple\nmeasurers of the volumes of the content or of the contentful resource of\nthese or those forms of different levels (of electric energy, heat, water, gas,\noil, air, time, etc.), money — this is also a \"mechanical\" measurer of the\ncontentful potential of the all possible forms-levels, assessed again by the\nsubstitution of the contents both of the concrete and of the abstract forms by\nthe content of the very concrete material form. In other words, money — this\nis also a trivial (with the claim to universality) rating system for the\nmeasurement of the \"quantity\" of the contentfulness of the forms.\nAs is known, every movement forward consists in that a step is made from\nthe achieved, and all the perspective forms (such, say, as the plans, the\nprojects, the programs, etc.), before receiving the approval for their\nembodiment and application, are verified by way of the replacement (at least\nmental) by the existing (achieved) and already applied by man forms. If the\ncontents of the investigated (verified) forms can be substituted (as\ncompletely as possible) by the contents of the already used forms (i.e., of\nthe forms endowed with objective contents — of the true forms), then there\nis made the conclusion both about the sufficient contentfulness of the\ninvestigated forms, and about their suitability for the further application.\n\"The success of human practice\", consider the Marxists, proves the\ncorrespondence of the representations of man \"to the objective nature of\nthings\" which he perceives [11, pp. 134-135]. The speech here is about the\ncorrespondence of the content of the products of human thinking (of these or\nthose abstract subjectively ideal constructions and edifices) to the content of\nthe thing world, i.e., about the truthfulness of the abstract forms produced\nby human thinking, which for man as the subject of cognition is the most\ninteresting, valuable, and important in the first place. The condition of the\n\"success\" of the application, and hence, also the sign (criterion) of the\ntruthfulness of the abstract form-product of thinking will be the\ncorrespondence of its content to the content of the form of thingness, or, in\nother words, the possibility and admissibility of the as complete as possible\nsubstitution of the content of the abstract form of thinking by the content of\nthe thing forms, mediated by the forms of sensations. In the final result the\npresence of objective content in the investigated abstract form — here is the\ncriterion of the truthfulness of this form, and hence, also of the \"success\" of\nits application in practice. As we see, neither \"human practice\" nor \"success\"\nare the key words in the above-adduced assertion; the determining factor of\nthe success of the practical application or of the truthfulness of this or that\nabstract form turns out to be its objective contentfulness.\n\n\fThus, as to the recognition of the special role and significance of practice in\nthe assessment process of the establishment of truth there are no objections\nwith that only difference, however, that practice in this case is not the\ncriterion of the truthfulness or of the success of the application of the\ninvestigated abstract constructions, but serves only as the device or way of\nsuch an assessment. The genuine criterion of truth or of the success of the\napplication of the abstract forms turns out to be the contentfulness of the\nverified forms, and more precisely — the \"quantity\" of this contentfulness, on\nthe basis of which it becomes possible, finally, to consciously assess the\ntruthfulness of the investigated forms quantitatively, i.e., by number or by\n\"digit\".\nIf the sense of practice reduces to the assessment of the possibility and\nadmissibility of the substitution of the content of the abstract forms by the\ncontents of the forms mainly thing (and more precisely, by the contents of\nthe forms of sensations), then the technology of interpreting is represented\nby a more expanded set of the means and devices of the establishment and\nverification of the truthfulness of the abstract forms: and by the forms of\nsensations, and by the already verified, approved, and recognized (affirmed)\nin their truthfulness abstract forms of different levels and constructions. The\nmultilevel abstractions with the established and confirmed truthfulness — this\nis also the steps of the \"ascent\" of the essence or of the objective content of\nreality.\nIn the former times the appeal to the procedure of practice was sufficient;\ntoday this procedure must be expanded by way of the conscious inclusion in\nits assessment arsenal of the set of the modern and more effective means —\notherwise man, relying on the false or unskillfully and erroneously chosen\norientations (\"untrue\" truths), risks losing the adequacy of the perception of\nthe world and disappearing as a species or a certain form-level of reality.\nThe well-known expression (the prototypes of which with great probability\nare found in the works of G. W. F. Hegel): \"Truth is always concrete\", — is\ncompletely correct from that point of view that truth at every given moment\n— this is merely the concrete limited form of the next approximation to the\nall-embracing expression of the moving, developing content (as the\nequivalent of the \"extracted\" from the depth of the abstract essence) of\nreality. Besides, the truthfulness of the contents (i.e., the completeness or\nthe \"quantity\" of the contentfulness) of the investigated abstract formsproducts of thinking (notions, judgments, projects, theories, conceptions,\nphilosophical systems, teachings, etc.) is established by the admissibility of\nthe interpreting and by the number of the interpretations of these\ninvestigated forms by the known point finite examples: by the factual\nmaterial, by the results of the thing-practical and theoretical activity, as well\nas by the already verified and confirmed abstract forms. In such a section it\nis easily understood that all the perspective forms laying claim to the\n\n\facquisition of the status of the true forms also subsequently will turn out to\nbe the concrete relative truths by virtue of the interpreting of them by the\nconcrete finite examples-results of the preceding practical and theoretical\nactivity in the process of the establishment of their truthfulness.\nThe \"success\" of the existence (i.e., the truthfulness, actuality,\nviability) of any real form is determined by its contentful resource or\nagain by the \"quantity\" of its contentfulness. The contentful resource, in\nits turn, is made up of the multitude of the constituents; for such a form as,\nfor example, the state — this is by no means only the developed economy,\nbut also the intellectual-spiritual potential of the population, the reserves of\nthe natural resources and the defense potential, the self-sufficiency, the high\nadaptability of the population to the changing conditions with the\npreservation of the adequacy of thinking, etc. In application, say, to the\nliving forms — this is and the endurance of the organism, and its\nsurvivability, and its energy-arming or energy potential, and the duration of\nlife (without the loss of quality), and the adequate reaction to the influences\nand the ability to adapt to the changing conditions of the external\nenvironment, and again the self-sufficiency, etc.\nGood-bad, better-worse, higher-lower, wide-narrow, much-little, more-less,\ndeep-shallow, useful-harmful — the origin and the wide use of these and of\nthe multitude of the similar pairs of comparisons is also conditioned by the\nneed in the assessment of the completeness of the contentfulness or of the\ncontentful resource of the all possible forms of reality mainly at the everyday\nlevel.\nAnalogously the success of the actions or the successfulness of the activity of\nman is determined by the contentful resource of the form of man (in the\ngeneral case — of mankind) and of his thinking.\nAny form-level lives or exists, enriching itself in a natural way, until such\ntime as any of the subforms-sublevels entering into the composition of the\nwhole aggregate of the subforms-sublevels of the form does not express by\nitself the maximally achievable for this subform-sublevel contentfulness. With\nthe onset of the moment of the expressedness of the maximal contentfulness\nby some subform-sublevel in the composition of the existing form (which\nanswers to the achievement of the peak of the activity of the whole form)\nthere begins to prevail the progressive taking away of its contentfulness by\nthe neighboring forms-levels. For this reason the form stagnates and\nregresses, being \"dragged apart\" into parts and assimilated by the other\nmore active forms-levels by virtue of the most severe competition between\nthem and of the inexhaustible \"demand\" for contentfulness. Every \"gaping\"\nform, having stopped in the increase of its content (contentful potential) and\nhaving slowed down the development, the competitors immediately drag\napart into the constituents, replenishing thereby the reserves of their\ncontentfulness correspondingly to the omnipresent principle of self-\n\n\fdevelopment. The boundaries, the resource, the quality of every form are\nconditioned by the volume of the contentfulness accumulated in it.\nAll the forms-levels have to prove their viability (i.e., the ability to increase\nand multiply their potential-contentfulness) in the hard competitive struggle.\nMan — is not an exception, but a specimen of the typical form submitting to\nthe action of the universal \"mechanism\" of the development of reality — the\nprinciple of self-development.\nThe very existence of any form takes place only thanks to the increase and\npreservation of the rates of the growth of its contentfulness, and the very\nfact of its existence testifies to the presence in it of the sufficient volume of\ncontentfulness. On the other hand, the highest contentfulness of this or that\nlevel is demonstrated, confirmed, and certified by the stability of its form.\nThus, the \"success\" or the duration of the stable existence of the form is the\nconsequence and the indicator of the presence in this form of the sufficient\nvolume of contentfulness, and this subject-to-assessment contentfulness (of\nthe ever-increasing degree of abstractness) of the forms must be tied up\nwith the concreteness of the preceding forms, i.e., admit the interpreting by\nthe preceding more concrete forms-levels.\nWhat advantages promises such, it would seem, insignificant refinement\nconcerning the advancement and substantiation of the correct and genuine\ncriterion of truth?\nIn the \"guise\" of the newly advanced criterion the researcher receives at his\ndisposal an effective instrument for the carrying out of the conscious\ncomparative quantitative assessment of the contentfulness (and hence, also\nof the truthfulness) of the diverse forms and, correspondingly, of the building\nof them by rank. And already on this basis there opens the possibility to take\nthe more competent and weighed decisions concerning the determination of\nthe direction of the further investigations of reality with the reliance on the\nmeaningfully selected true its forms.\n§ 13. The technology of interpretation as a universal way of the\nassessment of the contentfulness of forms\nLet us examine in greater detail the technology of interpretation applied in\nthe assessment and establishment of the contentfulness and truthfulness of\nthe investigated forms.\nAs it has already been clarified above (see § 9), \"to interpret\" — means to\nexpress something abstract and insufficiently definite through the thorough,\ndefinite, and concrete; to translate the incomprehensible into the language of\nthe comprehensible; to present the new and unusual by means of the known\nand habitual. In an analogous way to interpret a notion or to give a definition\n— this means to express the particular through the more general, or, in the\n\n\fwords of V. I. Lenin, \"this means, first of all, to bring the given notion under\nanother, broader one\" [11, p. 142]. In the indicated cases one thing is\nexpressed through another: something that is only just taking shape, unclear\nand vague — through the established and definite preceding one. In this\nsense the technology of interpretation fits into the channel of the principle of\nself-development (and submits to this principle), which determines and\nprescribes the unitary directionality of development to all real processes.\nIn other words, interpretation — this is both the elucidation (explication) of\nabstract constructions by way of the recourse to the content of concrete\nforms; and the expression of the irrational through the rational; and the\nassignment of concrete sense-values to abstract elements: images, notions,\njudgments, expressions, computations, schemes, formulas, symbols, etc.\nAll the scientific devices of the establishment of truth, including the\nexplanation and forecasting of the results of investigations (among which\nthere turn out to be: the modeling of processes, the reproduction of real\nsituations, the simulation of behavior, the anticipation of consequences,\netc.), relate one way or another to the technology (method, way, procedure)\nof interpretation.\nThe most marketable and widespread way of the confirmation of the\ncontentfulness of abstract forms — this is the interpretation of these forms\nby the habitual and accepted (accepted by reason, by the everyday\nconsciousness, or by the so-called common sense) particularities and\nconcretions.\nThe recourse to facts (examples, empirical data, approved results of\ntheoretical activity) with the aim of the expression of the contents of the\ninvestigated abstract forms by the contents of more concrete forms — there\nis the interpretation of the abstract by the concrete (such a practice is\napplied in relation to all subjectively ideal forms from different spheres of\nhuman activity, and not only to the products and results of theoretical\ninvestigations).\nThe ability or suitability of an abstract form to interpretation by other, more\nconcrete forms (i.e., the interpretability of the abstract form) by no means\nyet speaks of and does not testify to the sufficient contentfulness of this\nform, but nevertheless — this is the first obligatory condition on the path of\nthe certification of the truthfulness of this or that form. The second obligatory\ncondition in the establishment of the truthfulness of a form — the\ndetermination of the completeness of its contentfulness and, consequently, of\nthe level of its truthfulness depending on the \"quantity\" of this\ncontentfulness, conditioned by the number (and as large as possible) of the\ninterpretations of the content of the investigated form by the contents of\nmore concrete forms.\n\n\fBy the admission and conclusion of the Marxists themselves, the criterion of\ntruth adopted by them in the theory of cognition, built on the basis of\npractice, is to a certain extent indefinite, i.e., is not exhaustive (necessary\nand sufficient). But the point here is by no means in the perfectionimperfection of the procedure (practice) as a criterion; the indefiniteness of\nany of the possible criteria of truth in any case is conditioned by the fact\nthat, firstly, none of the investigated (tested for truthfulness) real forms can\nbe contentfully exhaustive or absolutely contentful and, secondly, the highest\ncontentfulness of none of the forms can be confirmed by an infinite number\nof interpretations. Here the principle of reasonable sufficiency comes into\nforce, on which one should orient oneself in practice in the establishment of\ntruth with the use of the technology of interpretation.\nThe same thing relates to the process of cognition in the first place. In the\norder of the decrease of the degree of concreteness and the increase of the\nabstractness of forms the trust in the method of interpretation as a\nprocedure or technology of the assessment of the contentfulness of forms is\ndistributed in the following way: first the preference is given to the\nsubstituting forms of \"empirical experience\", then to the practical examples\nand factual material and further — to the already in advance verified,\naccepted, and approved in the quality of true abstract (theoretical)\nconstructions and structures.\nWhy does the factual, concrete material of the thing world (i.e., the form of\nthingness) dominate in relation to the superstructural, abstract subjectively\nideal forms? Firstly, this level of the development of forms is historically\nprimary; the thing forms and the forms of sensations belong to the sphere of\nthe so-called everyday \"empirical experience\" of man. After all, we walk and\nrun on the earth by no means only and not so much thanks to the mind or\nintellect, not owing to the presence of abstract thinking and its potential\nreadiness to the construction and comprehension of abstract schemes and\nmodels, but in the first place, by virtue of the presence in the general linkage\nor aggregate of the forms of the \"human\" nature of the earlier in time of\ntheir origin foundation-forming forms-levels — precisely of those forms which\nare defined as \"living\", but so far without the accompanying prefixes:\nthinking, animate, highly organized, intellectual, spiritual, etc. Secondly, in\nthe process of the cognitive activity of man everything unknown and\nunexplored is always expressed through the already known and\ncomprehended. And since the general process of development (as well as its\nspecific form of a quite definite level — cognition) represents the infinite\nmovement of the contentful constituent through the ever more and more\ncontentful forms-levels, characterized by their uniqueness, unrepeatability,\nand irreversibility, — it is easily realized that the only possible way\n(procedure, algorithm, or technology) of the realization of such a movementdevelopment, as well as of cognition, — this is \"the making of oneself\nfrom oneself while changing\" with the reliance on the achieved and with\nthe indispensable use of the contents of the forms of the preceding levels.\n\n\fHence, by virtue of the striving to the ever more contentfully capacious\nabstract forms there naturally takes shape also the hierarchy of the formslevels, manifesting itself through their branching aggregate (from the thing\nforms to the forms of thinking). And all this diversity is determined by the\nunidirectionality of the movement-development (see the formulation of the\nprinciple of self-development, § 7). In this and consists the sense of the\nmovement in the direction of the irreversible \"height\": the new content\ngrows out of the available, out of the accumulated, out of the already\nachieved by way of \"the making of oneself from oneself\" and simultaneously\nturns out to be different from itself. [Even a simple external comparison\nshows that the technology of interpretation as an unalterable element of the\ncognition of the changing reality turns out to be the embodiment of the same\nuniversal principle of self-development].\nAnd again let us turn to the verified system of views of dialectical\nmaterialism.\n\"The practical activity of man billions of times had to bring the consciousness\nof man to the repetition of different logical figures, so that these figures\ncould acquire the significance of axioms\" [12, p. 172], — these well-known\nwords of V. I. Lenin give an unambiguous representation of how long a path\n(in the course of everyday observations and routine actions, contributing to\nthe accumulation of \"empirical experience\") the true abstract logical\nconstructions, filled with concrete contentful sense (the speech is about the\ninitial forms of sensations and thinking), take shape. Becoming ever more\ncontentful, the mentioned logical figures with time themselves can serve as\nthe foundations or axiomatic basis, as well as the landmarks and indicators of\nthe directionality of the subsequent activity of man, both practical and\ntheoretical. In such an uncomplicated trivial way the multilevel reality is\nbuilt.\nHere I would like to note without fail that the moment of the latent contentful\nform-formation is disclosed by our greatest native dialectician V. I. Lenin so\nmasterfully and conveyed by such a filigree-precise formulation that nothing\ncan be taken away from it or added to it, however much one would like to.\nThus, the ever more abstracting itself in the course of the development of\nreality contentfulness of its forms indicates at the same time also the\nperspective direction of the variability of the forms of the representation of\nthis reality. The maximally achievable (highest) contentfulness — here is the\nguiding star for all the changing forms on all possible levels of development.\nThe different logical figures, about which V. I. Lenin speaks, are nothing else\nbut the labor skills, habits, customs, traditions, rites, principles, convictions,\nideals, preferences, cultural codes, values, rules, and laws of the behavior of\npeople, taking shape in different human communities over the course of\nmillennia. These are those abstract constructions and structures which, being\nfilled with contentful sense, lead through life from birth to death both the\nseparate individual and the numerous their groupings, not letting them stray\n\n\ffrom the path — from the road, in its essence, righteous and true, with the\ncourse on the acquisition of the highest contentfulness by the human forms\nfollowing this road.\nSince the sensuous in the multilevel human nature takes the upper hand\nover the \"supersensuous\" (mental), the level of thinking (consciousness)\ntries in a natural and most obvious, primitive way (for the most part, by the\n\"mechanical\" path) to rationalize everything contentful (especially of the\nabstract kind), i.e., to express it through quite concrete forms of sensations,\nwhich turn out to be for the human consciousness closer, \"dearer\", and more\ncomprehensible (more thorough) than all the other forms. The technology of\ninterpretation — this is the universal way of the assessment of the\ncontentfulness of all possible forms of reality, but since in our cluster of\nreality the first-born foundation-forming forms are the thing, material,\nsubstantial forms, then in the calculation, in the first place, are taken and the\nemphasis for the most part is placed on these fundamental \"down-to-earth\"\nlevels-forms.\nIn order to establish the truthfulness, reliability, authenticity, actuality of this\nor that abstract form, it is necessary to reveal and \"extract\" from the\ncompared abstract and concrete forms the common (\"as the one in the many\nor the likeness of the many\" [18, p. 351]) for them content.\nThe confirmation of the contentfulness of a theory, conception, or any other\nabstract form is ensured by the realization of the procedure of the\ncomparison of the contents of different concrete forms with the content of\nthe abstract form with the aim of the revelation of the common or coinciding\n\"shares\" of the contents of the compared forms and the establishment\nthereby of the possibility of the replacement (substitution) of the content of\nthe abstract form by the contents of the concrete forms.\nIn the quality of the common content of all the compared forms there may\nturn out to be some single universal principle, \"mechanism\", postulate, or\nalgorithm, common for all the forms engaged in the indicated procedure. In\nthe approximate coincidence of the contents of the forms of sensations and\nthe abstract forms of thinking there is made the conclusion about the\ncontentfulness precisely of the abstract form (since the most interesting for\nman is the moment of the as large as possible coincidability and succession\nof the contents of the abstract and thing-sensuous forms). In the opposite\ncase (without the carrying out of the verification of the possibility of the\nreplacement of the contents of the indicated forms), giving free rein to one's\nsubjective abstract fantasies, one can fantasize god knows what. Therefore\nfrom time immemorial man is engaged in the search of the criteria for the\ndetermination of the truthfulness, in the first place, of the subjective abstract\nconstructions and structures.\nThe inadequate perception of the world, conditioned by the abstract\ninventions, false premises, and conclusions, can bring and brings, in the final\n\n\fresult, harm to man and mankind. For this reason man must pay heightened\nattention to the assessment and verification for contentfulness and reliability\nof all without exception abstract forms produced in his head, of all human\nsuppositions, hypotheses, inventions, creative ideas, and fantasies (including\nand especially the publications in the mass media, see § 17). The inaccuracy\nand negligence in this respect, the excessive credulity to the unverified\nfabrications brings to man, as well as to the whole of mankind as a whole,\nimmeasurably more harm than the benefit from the momentary gain built on\nthe foundation of false representations and conclusions. The untruthfulness\nof the abstract forms of thinking means their low-contentfulness (i.e., the\ninsufficient filling of these forms with objective content), about which and\nshould testify the non-succession and non-conjugacy of them with the\npreceding concrete forms of sensations and thingness. Thus, the abstract\nforms as the products of human thinking — these are the special, specific\nforms of the representation, the same thing, of the objective content of\nreality at the next definite stage of the movement-development of this very\nreality.\nThe establishment of the true knowledge about the object is equivalent to\nthe procedure of the mental revelation and \"extraction\" of the objective\ncontent from the thing form and the correlation of it with the transformed\ncontents of the more abstracted forms of other levels, namely: the form of\nsensations and the form of thinking.\nIt goes without saying that after the transformation into other forms and\nrepresentations in other forms of other levels, this thing objective content\ndoes not remain identical to itself or equal to the content of the formscarriers of thingness, — otherwise it would not change its form. The changes\nof the contents accompanying such transformations of the mentioned chain\nof forms and represent by themselves the peculiarities or the \"highlights\" of\nthose forms into which the objective content is transformed in the measure\nof its movement-development or \"ascent\" from the thing forms. Every\nsubsequent form of the indicated chain includes in itself in the \"folded\",\ncompressed form the contents of the preceding forms and something else\nspecial, different from them — a certain \"weight\" of novelty and\nunrepeatability.\nThe thing form — this is the source and forerunner of the human sensations.\nHowever, to compare the content of this form with the content of the form of\nthinking does not present itself possible, since the content of the form of\nthingness is not manifestable outside the form of sensations. Consequently,\nto compare and contrast correctly there always remain only the contents of\nthe forms of thinking and the forms of sensations. The form of thinking must\nbe verified for the possibility and admissibility of the replacement\n(substitution) of its content by the verified objective content of the form of\nsensations. Then the form of thinking lays claim to the presence in it of the\nsame objective content. Practice, embracing all the diversity of the thing\nactivity of man, including the theoretical devices of the approbation of\n\n\fknowledge, is the procedure of the verification of the possibility of the\nreplacement (substitution) of the contents of the abstract forms by the\ncontents of the concrete forms of any worth, and in particular and first of all\nby the content of the form of sensations. However, practice does not\nembrace such kinds of the verification and establishment of the\ncontentfulness of the abstract forms as the substitution (replacement) of\nthem by the forms also abstract, but of other levels, or by other, already\nverified abstractions with the confirmed truthfulness. Such a task is solved by\nthe procedure of a more developed character, called interpretation. With the\naccount of this circumstance we have at our disposal the complete set of the\ninstruments or procedures of the establishment and verification of the\ncontentfulness of the abstract constructions and structures of different kinds\nand levels (storiedness).\nAs this becomes ever more evident, what is interesting is not the truthfulness\nof the abstract form in itself (which, it seems, is not the final aim of the\nhuman investigations and researches), but the ability of the content of this\nform to be expressed most completely by means of the contents of the more\nhabitual for man forms of thingness, mediated by the forms of sensations,\nand the suitability of this content for the further \"use\". If such is observed,\nthen the found abstract form, pushing apart for man the horizons of the\nperception and understanding of reality, is built into the general aggregate of\nthe forms, replenishing thereby the contentful accumulations of this\naggregate and contributing to the progressive cognition of reality, which\n\"gropes\" simultaneously by means of man and his thinking the most optimal\ncontentful path of its own further development.\nThe criterion of the truthfulness of the forms — their contentfulness. The\ntruthfulness of the forms is assessed by the presence and \"quantity\" of this\ncomponent. The status of the true acquires or obtains the form possessing\nthe highest contentfulness of the possible and achievable at this definite\nstage of the development of reality. The assessment of the completeness,\nvolume, or \"quantity\" of the contentfulness of this or that form is carried out\nby means of the procedure of interpretation (the expression or substitution,\nat times mental, of the content of the investigated form by the contents of\nthe more concrete forms). The volume, quantity, reliability of the factual\nmaterial, and indeed of the concrete forms in general, participating in the\nassessment procedure, and will determine in the final result the\ncompleteness of the contentfulness, and hence, also the truthfulness of the\ninvestigated form.\nOnly those newly forming forms \"are layered\" and \"are held\" on the summit\nof the pyramid of the forms of reality which carry in themselves the content\nconjugating with the objective contents of the forms (constituting the\nfoundation of the pyramid) and continuing by itself the chain of their\nobjective contents. The pyramid of reality acquires stability if it is\nsuperstructed by the forms \"stuffed\" with objective content.\n\n\fThe replacement of the abstract forms by the more concrete forms (and\nmore precisely, the replacement of the contents of the abstract forms by the\ncontents of the more concrete forms) answers to the procedure of the filling\nof the abstract forms with senses or the endowing of them with objective\ncontent.\nBy the return \"to oneself at a new level\" there is carried out the constant\nrefinement of the content of the ever more abstracting summit form of the\npyramid by way of the correlation of it with the objective content of the\nmultilevel foundation of this same pyramid.\nThe assessment of the contentfulness of the theoretical knowledge by\npractice is equivalent to the procedure of the representation of the content of\nthe abstract forms by the replacing contents of the concrete thing forms,\nmediated by the forms of sensuousness and sensations (i.e., by the forms of\nempirical experience).\nThe truthfulness or reliability of the abstract subjectively ideal forms (i.e., of\nknowledge: axioms, postulates, assertions, judgments, representations,\ntheories, conceptions, teachings, paradigms, etc.), laying claim to the status\nof the carriers of objective content, is proved not by practice, but by the\n\"quantity\" or volume of the contentfulness of these generalizing forms. By\nthe procedures of practice or interpretation there are established the\npresence and \"quantity\" of the contentfulness of the investigated forms. The\npresence of the contentfulness of the forms is determined by the possibility\nand admissibility of their interpretation by the factual material or concrete\nexamples, and the \"quantity\" of the contentfulness is assessed by the\nnumber of such interpretations. The greater the number of the known\nconcrete examples interpreting the investigated subjectively ideal abstract\nform, the with greater foundation this form can lay claim to the status of the\ncarrier of objective content.\nIn other words, the process of the search and establishment of truth is\nreduced to the procedure of the maximally complete expression of the\nuncognized irrational through the cognized rational (i.e., of the unknown\nthrough the known) and the return thereby to one's rational sources or\nfoundations, but already at a new level — with the admixture of something\nspecial, as the supplemented rational.\nThus, the criterion of truth is not practice in itself (the thing-practical and\ntheoretical activity of the subject with its results), but the presence and\ncompleteness of the objective content in the investigated forms, which is\nestablished with the help of the procedure of practice or the technology of\ninterpretation.\nCorrectly generated and reproduced by thinking abstract forms turn out to be\nmore contentful, since they include in themselves in the \"removed\" or\n\n\f\"folded\" (i.e., compact, concentrated) form the data or contentful volumes of\na whole multitude of concrete forms.\nThe presence of a certain common in the particularities and concretions must\nbe confirmed by the as large as possible number of such particularities and\nconcretions. If this condition is fulfilled, then the \"extracted\" common\nacquires the status of objective content.\nAfter all, what in reality represents by itself this or that theory or conception\nor some foundation-laying principle which requires either the confirmation\nand acceptance, or the refutation? This is something common (which\nsomeone managed to \"spy out\" or notice accidentally or deliberately),\ncorrectly \"extracted\" from a certain number of particularities and concretions\nand concentratedly presented in the form of a generalized abstract theory\n(conception, model) for the explanation and comprehension of the essence of\nan even greater number of particularities and concretions (both existing and\nsupposed to existence), as well as for the forecasting and anticipation of the\nemergence of the new forms of reality on the basis of the knowledge about\nthis concentrated common.\nThe truthfulness or reliability of this or that conception (theory, model) is\nproved by the presence in it of the objective content admitting the\ninterpretation (i.e., the substitution, at least mental) of its content by the\ncontents of the particular and concrete forms (examples, facts). If something\nabstractly common, constituting the essence of the conception (theory,\nmodel), is discovered in the particularities and concretions of the thing world\nand thereby admits the possibility of the interpretation of it by these\nparticular and concrete forms of the thing world, then this abstractly common\nis viable and endowed with objective content, i.e., is true and reliable.\nSuch a path of the establishment of truth fits into the single channel of the\ngeneral contentful movement (from the \"incomplete\" truth to the ever more\nembracing and contentful truth), determined by the formulation of the\nprinciple of self-development. Thus are carried out both the process of\ncognition, and the processes of the development of anything whatsoever;\nanother path simply does not exist!\nProceeding from the fact that every just, true theory (conception, model) is\ninterpreted or can be interpreted by the factual material, the admissibility\nand suitability of the newly advanced conception to the interpretation by the\nnumerous facts serves as the unalterable condition requiring the verification\nfor feasibility in the establishment of its reliability or truthfulness (or at least\nscientificity). In the channel of this approach this means that the possibility\nof the effective interpretation of any conception by an infinite number (or at\nleast by a multitude) of facts endows this conception with the status of\nreliability (truthfulness); in other words, the greater the number of the\ncorrectly interpreting this or that theory facts is established, the more\n\n\freliable (truer) is the \"invented\" or generated by thinking theory (conception,\nmodel).\nAs it has already been said earlier, every principle — this is something\ncommon, extracted from a whole row of particular separate examples and\nmanifestations. The successful reverse \"return\" of the common into every\nnew separate concrete particular (if such is possible, admissible, and\nachievable) and there is the way of the proof of the unity and commonness\nof the whole row of particularities and concretions, as well as the way of the\nproof of the presence of the objective content in all the investigated forms\n(i.e., in the compared particularities and concretions).\nThe general principle (conception, theory) collects and unites by itself the\nseparate particularities and concretions. By the gathering into one of the\nmany particularities is determined the essence of the way of interpretation. If\nthe interpretation (the gathering into one of the many particularities)\nsucceeds, then the found or extracted earlier general principle can be\nrecognized as objectively contentful and presented to the interpretation by\nan even greater number of particularities. The truthfulness of the principle is\nestablished if this principle is just and common in relation to some in advance\ngiven multitude of particularities and concretions. The greater the number of\nparticularities and concretions is united by the commonness of the principle,\nthe greater the foundation to consider it the truth (true).\nThe more completely and large-scale the abstract is expressed by means of\nthe concrete, the greater the number of concretions it embraces and unites\n— the more contentful it is, the more truly it is endowed with objective\ncontent.\nIf the form growing by the abstract content does not include in itself the\ncontents of the more concrete forms, is not expressed by them and by their\naggregate in the most complete volume, is not substituted (at least mentally)\nby them, then it is not endowed with objective content and, consequently, is\nnot true.\nThe purpose of the technology of interpretation, in essence, and consists in\nthe verification and proof of the presence of the objective content in all\npossible abstract forms.\n§ 14. The differentiation of the forms by the volume of\ncontentfulness. The volume of the contentfulness of a form as the\nindicator of the approximation to the expression of the objective\ncontent of reality\nIn connection with the fact that the criterion of truth advanced here (that is,\nthe contentfulness of the forms) turns out to be suitable for the quantitative\nassessment of the forms, it becomes possible to build the diverse forms by\nrank depending on the completeness or \"quantity\" of their contentfulness\n\n\f(truthfulness). Such an approach opposes the myth of the possible\nequivalence of the different abstract forms (theories, conceptions, models,\nteachings, plans, etc.), including the identical truthfulness of the different\npoints of view on one and the same question or subject of judgment. The\ntrue model, assessed as the most \"close approximation\" to the absolute truth\nat any given moment of development, — is always one; that is why it is\nimportant to be able to recognize such a model, in order to rely in one's\nfurther perspective movement-development precisely on it.\nAs in any set (in any aggregate) of the forms of any level, exactly the same\nway at the level of the subjectively ideal forms there are encountered, in our\nopinion, both the less contentful forms, and the more contentful forms (the\nmost \"suitable\" to the expression of the maximally achievable volume of\ncontent at the \"summit\" levels of the abstracted forms).\nProceeding from such representations, the answer to the question — whether\nall the abstract constructions and structures, all the judgments (points of\nview, opinions, positions, decisions, conclusions, inferences, etc. in relation\nto any subject of judgment) are equal-righted, equal-powered, equal-sized,\nequal-valued, equivalent, and, finally, adequate, — is expectedly predictable\nand unambiguous: there is not and cannot be in principle equally adequate\npoints of view on one and the same subject of judgment, since any and each\nof them represents by itself only the next approximation to the exhaustive\nexpression of the objective content of the subject of judgment (i.e., only the\napproximation to a certain absolute truth). From all the judgments in such a\ncase it is necessary, using for this the most complex criterion of the\nassessment of the truthfulness of the judgments, to choose the one whose\ncontentful filling is maximal and most close to the expression of the objective\ncontent of reality (of the objective truth). All the other judgments represent\nby themselves even more coarse and inexact approximations.\nThe task of the choice from two and more points of view of the most true or\ncorrect one at any moment of the choice will stand before man always, since\nthe freedom of choice, proceeding from the indefiniteness and ambiguity of\nthe course of events and the perspectives of development, with which the\nsubject of cognition encounters and will always encounter, — is objective and\nconditioned by the dialectical nature of the world (of the developing reality).\nThe choice from the row of the approximations of the most \"close\napproximation\" to the form of the highest contentfulness will always be the\nmost responsible and dramatic moment in the destinies of mankind and of\nthe separate individuals; and never will this decision be simple. One can only\nachieve the ever more meaningful striving to the increase of the\ncontentfulness of such a decision.\nBy virtue of the contentful-formal (dialectical) nature of the world and its\ndevelopment and of the resulting from here impossibility of the repetition or\nrepeated reproduction of anything whatsoever in details and the smallest\n\n\fparticulars, — there is not and cannot be even two (not to mention a\nmultitude) of equally true, identically equal-sized opinions, judgments, or\npoints of view on one and the same subject (question, problem). One of the\npoints of view (or judgments) will always be closer to the truth than the\nothers. Precisely from this one must proceed, precisely this moment one\nmust take into account in the determination of the truthfulness of this or that\nform and in the choice thereby of the landmark and foundation for the\nfurther investigations and development.\nWhen in application to this or that conception (theory) it is said wholesale\nthat this is only one of the numerous equal-valued points of view or opinions\nin relation to this or that subject of cognition, one must, firstly, be informed\nabout the principal unattainability of the equivalence or equal-valuedness of\nthe different points of view on the subject of investigation and, secondly,\nremember about the necessity of the following of the certain rules or devices\n(procedures, technology) of the establishment of the truthfulness of the\ntheoretical forms with the help of the complex criterion of their\ninterpretability (by the verification by the factual material, concrete\nexamples, reliable logical constructions and structures, etc.).\nNaturally, few people will believe only on the word in the fact that such-andsuch a conception is or can become an alternative knowledge in relation to\nthe existing theories. Only by the presentation of the sufficient volume of the\nconfirming factual material can one convince the interested public (or side) in\nthe fact that this or that approach is at present the most \"close\napproximation\" to the true one.\nProceeding from these considerations, one should expect that the special and\nheightened interest will always be presented by the assessment of the\n\"contentfulnesses\" of the above-mentioned forms by way of their comparison\nand, correspondingly, the determination of their priority by way of the\nranking. Since each of the compared and ranked forms is in essence the next\napproximation to the form of the highest contentfulness, about the identity\nor equivalence of the compared and ranked forms there can be no speech.\nAll the established, comprehended, and preparing to the comprehension\ntruths — only the next approximations to the exhaustive expression of the\ncontent by the most perfect form, the next approximations to the absolute\ntruth. But among these approximations there is always such which\nrepresents by itself the most close at any given moment to the \"aim\"\napproximation. Precisely it and must be able to find, precisely on it and must\none orient oneself in one's investigations and in the adoption of the\ndecisions. This is that present, that actual, that true which acquires the right\nto the long-term and stable existence, — on which and accentuates the\nattention G. W. F. Hegel, remarking: \"Usually we call truth the agreement of\nthe object with our representation... In the philosophical sense — on the\ncontrary, truth in its abstract expression generally means the agreement of a\ncertain content with itself... The untrue means... the bad, the non-\n\n\fcorresponding to itself... The examination of truth in the sense explained\nhere, in the sense of the agreement with itself, constitutes the genuine task\nof logic\" [3, p. 126—127].\nTo find such a form which would express the whole fullness of the content of\nreality at the given moment, i.e., to find the most contentful form, the form\nof the highest contentfulness, signifying by itself the identity of the\ncomponents of the relation {content/form}, and, correspondingly, the\ndegeneration of the latter into the indivisible wholeness — here is the\ngenuine sense (from the position of our representations), enclosed in the\ncited words of Hegel.\nTruth is always expressed by the form most contentful at any given moment\nin comparison with all the other competing and accompanying forms.\nSupposing that the exhaustive expression of the content by the form is\npossible, admissible, and achievable only in god and through god: \"Only God\nis the true correspondence of the notion and reality\" [3, p. 126], — Hegel\nintuitively clothes the contentful movement of reality and its contentfulformal transformations into the attire of the iteration process of the infinite\napproximations to the expression of this very \"truth in the last instance\"\n(more laconically than Hegel in the light of his representations about this,\nperhaps, and one cannot say).\nIn science (as, however, and in life) the objective (content) cannot be\nbypassed without consequences; in the quality of the \"given from the age\"\nthere is the common, the foundation, the reproducible basis, on which\nsomething from the changing and subjective is layered, until this something\nacquires the status of the supplemented and developed objective.\nThe particularities, peculiarities, and individualities all the same \"dance from\nthe stove\", push off from the common, on which with time and are layered.\nThe common and objective (content) takes place beyond any doubts, and all\nof us, willingly or unwillingly, strive to see and manifest to the world this\nobjective content by means of the different forms.\nEverything that is \"creative\" subjective — this is only the approximations of\ndifferent degrees (the multilevel models, fragments, or integral pictures),\nfixed in their striving to the \"complete and final\" expression and\ncomprehension of the infinite contentful movement, i.e., of the development\nof this very common, foundation, objective. In the context of the considered\nmaterial philosophy (as, however, and literature, and painting, and music,\netc.) — this is the art of the subjective to see (discover) and manifest the\nobjective (content). For the understandable reasons the successful one here\nturns out to be the one who manages to do this (such an approach easily and\nunerringly reveals the true subtext of the depth and greatness, say, of the\nRussian literature of the XIX century, etc.).\nThe present approach has as its aim also to give the representation of that\ncommon, unifying objective which so far is not \"grasped\" by the modern\n\n\fsciences (the latter, as in the parable with the elephant, each separately see\neither the legs, or the trunk, or the tail, not having the possibility to make up\nthe representation about the whole). Without the single common objective\nfoundation neither science, nor philosophy have the chances for the\nacceleration or the leap in their development.\n§ 15. The \"winding\" of content as the essence of the principle of selfdevelopment\nWhat has been set forth in the preceding paragraphs fits into the channel of\nthe concept of development, the main provisions of which and the description\nof the \"mechanism\" of the change-movement-development of reality are\ncontained in the works [2, 8, 23].\nAt any given and arbitrary moment the world is unique and unrepeatable\n(which has already been noted above). But the unrepeatability or uniqueness\nof the changing and newly forming forms of reality is possible and realizable\nonly thanks to the \"winding\", the \"making of oneself from oneself\", i.e., to\nthe special specific character or way of the movement-development of the\nforms. This specific peculiarity of the development of reality must never fall\nout of the field of vision of the analysts engaged in theoretical investigations\nand the modeling of the changeability of the surrounding world. Under the\n\"dictate\" of the algorithm of the principle of self-development the correlation\nof the components-constituents in the known relation {change/basis}\nconstantly changes, as a result of which at every moment there is realized\nthe \"changing basis\", reproducing itself thanks to ever new and new\ncontentful layers, — which is why it does not become exhausted, which is\nwhy the very development of reality does not cease.\nAt every moment the \"lived-through\" becomes the \"building material\" for the\n\"coming\" present, \"winding\" and layering onto the still more distant past (the\n\"lived-through\"). Only such a way of movement-development as \"the making\nof oneself from oneself\", such a course of events, similar to \"winding\",\ninsures and delivers the future from the detailed repetitions of the past. By\nthe simple \"copying\" or \"reflection\" no single process is realized in full\nmeasure; the contrary — is from the category of delusions and chimeras. In\nreality there takes place the permanent movement in the direction of novelty\nand unrepeatability on the basis of the uniqueness of everything\n\"accomplishing itself\". The very character, type, and way of the movementself-development excludes the repeatability and reversibility of the forms.\nThe appearance of new content in new forms cannot be explained in any way\nby the \"copying\" or \"reflection\" of the external world by the organs of sense\n(sensations) and by the thinking of the cognizing subject [11, p. 125, 151].\nThe new content arises and is realized in new forms because it \"winds\" one\nlayer onto another with the accompanying changes of all the layers (by virtue\nof the absorption by the layers of these changes) and, correspondingly, with\n\n\fthe differences of the content of the subsequent forms from the content of\nthe preceding ones.\nMan, animal, plant breathes, drinks, eats, interacts with the external world,\nand precisely in such a way — by the path of the layering of changes onto\nthe basis — there is carried out the feeding, replenishment, renewal of the\ndeveloping content of the living forms (including the subjectively ideal forms\nof human thinking). On the simplest things, on the ordinary and everyday\nexamples one can be convinced of this again and again. In particular, the\norganism in the state of sleep is precisely that basis, that foundation onto\nwhich the changes and new volumes of content accumulated by the organism\nin the period of its activity are \"mounted\", into which they are built in. On the\nexample of sleep it is well noticeable that the layers are attached to the basis\nnot evenly and uninterruptedly, but by diverse portions, alternating with\npauses, rest, \"repose\", etc.\nIn what is seen the \"sense\" of the life or existence of the plant, animal, man?\nIn that, by the different levels of their multilevel formations, to assimilate,\nexpress, comprehend the contentful accumulations in the calculation (with\nanticipation) of the subsequent assimilation, expression, and comprehension\nof new, still greater volumes of diverse contentful accumulations.\nCopying and photographing does not give true representations of the current\nprocesses in the multilevel reality (including at the level of self-cognition). As\nreflection or copying this can be perceived and carried out only in immobility,\nin statics, in the form of a particular case of the universal movement; in\ndynamics, in development — this is always \"winding\", \"making from\noneself\"... The development-movement-change of actuality is the generation\nand embodiment of the objectively realizing principle of self-development\n(initially present in any \"something\", in any element of reality), which gives\nthe representation and testifies about the intensifying movement of the\ncontent (of reality) onto the coverage and comprehension of the very same\nmoving content in its ever more and more \"embryonic\" state. In the same\nway there is carried out also the process of cognition as the movement of the\nspecific (gnoseological) form of reality at the level and in the terms of human\nthinking.\nAs for the question of the cognizability of the surrounding world, then in the\nfinal account it will inevitably be necessary to come to the understanding of\nthe circumstance that the world — this is not a book and all the more not a\nrock or a boulder-stone in its immutability, but something unceasingly\n\"making itself\", reproducing itself, changing itself in the regime of real time;\nand a similar question in a correct formulation must be posed not in relation\nto the cognizability of something given and existing from the age in its\nconstancy, but in relation to the possibility of the foresight and anticipation of\nthe newly arising forms (including the consequences, results, events,\nconfigurations, situations) of the developing reality.\n\n\fThe levels of development are often inseparable, undetachable from each\nother for the reason that the contentful constituent, say, of one level can at\none and the same time (in interconnection) turn out to be the formal\nconstituent for another level and vice versa. And also for the reason that the\ncontentful constituent of one level necessarily represents a new relation\n{content/form} for another level. The same thing should be said also about\nany formal constituent. But the main obstacle on the path of the clear\nunderstanding of the course of the process of development and of its exact\nformulations consists in the fact that the natural boundary between the\ncomponents-constituents \"content\" and \"form\" in their relation is hardly\ndistinguishable, and at times simply not perceptible (for the time being).\nThus, the ingrowing of the levels-forms into each other and their growing out\nof one another is precisely the cause of the impossibility of their separation in\na \"pure\" form, as well as of the intricacy of the processes and of the difficulty\nof the expression (explanation) of the unexplored, and in some sense\nirrational, through the comprehended rational.\nIn such a connection one must always take into account the dual nature of\nthe world, and especially in the cases when the matter concerns the\nexamination and investigation of intricate (and precisely therefore complex)\nquestions. This thought is far from new, we simply often forget about it. And\nin order to come out onto the correct solution of the fundamental problems,\nwithout the dialectical approach it is already in no way possible to get by.\nThe striving to express the new abstract content through the preceding more\nconcrete forms by virtue of the effect of the winding of content, described\nand conditioned (the speech is about the effect of winding) by the\nformulation of the principle of self-development, leads to the search of a new\nform for the new content, which is the continuation of all the other contentful\nforms present in the linkage or in the aggregate. This form includes in itself\nin the \"sublated\", concentrated form the preceding manifestations of the\nessence of the object and simultaneously is their continuation, expansion,\nand superstructure with the \"inclusions\" of some peculiarities (differences)\nnot present until then in the preceding forms. Therefore the main thing that\none should catch in this process is not the \"reflection\" of one in the other\n(not the doubling or multiplication of essences), but the transformation, the\ntransformation of the available linkage of the preceding forms into a new\naggregate form, and moreover not equivalent to the simple sum of the\nforms, but qualitatively different from it.\nThe life and existence of man as the subject of cognition — this is the\nmovement of the contentful constituent through the forms-levels in the\ndirection of the acquisition of the most contentful form of such a movement,\nwhich is precisely what is affirmed by the formulation of the principle of selfdevelopment. In words we, as the embodiment of the predominantly\nconservative component-constituent of the relation {change/basis}, i.e., of\nthe \"basis\", of course, can deny that at every moment by each our action, by\neach breath in and out, by each word and deed (being simultaneously the\n\n\fpersonification also of the second component-constituent of the relation, i.e.,\nof the \"change\") we participate in the search and creation of the most\ncontentful forms of our existence and development; however, in fact\neverything indicates that there is no alternative to this process.\n§ 16. The systematization and refinement of some notions and\ndefinitions in the light of our representations about the development\nand cognition of reality\nLet us attempt to systematize what has been set forth above, breaking\nthrough, as before, through the veil of delusions and confusion in the notions\nand representations about the subject of our conversation.\nThe truthfulness of a form is determined by its contentfulness; hence the\ncriterion of truth or of the truthfulness of the forms is served by their\ncontentfulness. The more contentful the form, the more truthful it is. The\ninternal contentfulness of a form reveals itself by diverse external\nmanifestations, executions, embodiments.\nFrom time immemorial man observes and fixes the multitude of\nmanifestations of the internal contentfulness of the forms, such as: beauty\nand elegance, simplicity, harmony, laconism, systemicity, economy, noncontradictoriness, self-sufficiency, etc. For the establishment and\nconfirmation of the truthfulness of any form all these manifestationsexecutions of its contentfulness must pass one and the same procedure of\nassessment — interpretation, — consisting in the determination of the\npossibility and admissibility of the substitution of the contents of the\ninvestigated forms by the contents of as large as possible a number of\nconcrete and abstract forms, the truthfulness of which has already been\nconfirmed and does not raise doubts.\nThe matter remains only for the fact that with respect to each concrete\nmanifestation or execution of contentfulness one should find (reveal, select)\nits own specific standards for the correct determination of the \"quantity\" of\nthis contentfulness and the expression of it in conventional units. The more\nsuch manifestations falling into the field of vision of the human\nconsciousness, the more complex, all-embracing, and informative the\ncriterion of the assessment of the truthfulness of the forms turns out to be;\nin other words, if all the manifestations of contentfulness are gathered\ntogether, then there will be obtained the combined criterion of the all-round\nassessment of the truthfulness of any form, — by the aggregate of the\nmanifestations of the contentfulness of this form.\nHence, apparently, proceeds also the intuitive striving of a number of\nresearchers to introduce a certain complex criterion of the assessment of\ntruth; the striving itself is quite natural and justified, all the more so that in\nmany fields of human activity, conditioned and generated by the different\nmanifestations of the contentfulness of all possible forms, the criteria of the\n\n\fassessment of the truthfulness of the forms have already been worked out\nand exist, in others — they are still to be worked out. But with all the\nperspectiveness of the indicated idea one should nevertheless stop on the\npeculiarities of its interpretation and embodiment.\n\"We suppose, — write the authors, — that the synthesis of the existing\nconceptions of truth is possible. The core of the general theory of truth can\nbecome the conception of correspondence, in connection with the fact that\nonly it discloses the essence of true knowledge. According to the words of\nDescartes, who clearly and most briefly formulated the main idea of the\ntheory of correspondence, \"truth... means the correspondence of the thought\nto the object\". ... Without the correlation with the object the notion of truth\nhas no sense, there is no objectless truth, no truth about nothing\" [4, p. 6—\n7].\nOn the example of the cited quotation let us examine the confusion in the\nrepresentations, about which we have declared above. The matter is that in\nthis fragment of the article (as also in the multitude of publications on this\ntheme) there is compared the not quite comparable, similar, say, to the\nattempt of the establishment of the correspondence between meters and\nseconds. Despite the fact that both the one and the other \"grow\" from one\nroot as the components-constituents of the integral relation {time/space},\nnevertheless they are not equivalent and not identical to each other, just as\nthe components of the primordial relation {content/form} are not identical\nand not interchangeable. Here there is evident the attempt to correlate and\nidentify the \"formal\" and \"contentful\" beginnings of reality, which by and\nlarge is incorrect by virtue of their natural incompatibility.\nThe truthfulness of knowledge is determined by its contentfulness. The fuller,\nthe higher the contentfulness of knowledge, the more truthful, more reliable\nit is. As we see, the objectness here is generally beside the point.\nThe necessity of the \"correlation with the object\" appears not in connection\nwith the assessment of the truthfulness of knowledge, but in connection with\nthe assessment of the fullness or the \"quantity\" of its contentfulness, which\n(the assessment) is carried out, as has been said above, by means of the\nprocedure of practice or the technology of interpretation, i.e., by the\ncomparison and substitution (as complete as possible) of the content of the\nabstract form of knowledge by the contents of the more concrete forms of\nsensations and/or by the contents of the abstract forms of thinking, the\ntruthfulness of which has already been confirmed and does not raise doubts.\nAnd only on the basis of the established contentfulness of knowledge can\none speak about its truthfulness. The truthfulness of this or that form, thus,\nhas no direct relation to objectness (if only for the reason that the\nconfirmations of truthfulness are equally required by both the abstract and\nthe empirical forms or the forms of sensations, closely connected with the\nthing forms). The truthfulness of the abstract forms is correlated with\nobjectness only indirectly — through the procedure of the assessment and\nestablishment of the fullness of the contentfulness of the abstract forms.\n\n\fFor this same reason the verbal turns of speech of the type \"the\ncorrespondence of the thought to the object\" (in the formulation of\nDescartes) or \"the correlation of the notion with the object\" (in the modern\nformulation) from ancient times and up to this day are used incorrectly with\nrespect to the procedure of the search of truth or the establishment of the\ntruthfulness of knowledge. One should not forget that the subjective human\nknowledge about a real object serves as the expression of the objective\ncontent of the form of the object, already mediated by the form of human\nsensations and by the form of human thinking. Therefore only the contents of\nthe form of sensations and of the form of thinking can be compared,\ncorrelated, tested for correspondence. And only on the basis of the revealed\n(in the process of comparison and correlation) to some extent conjugacy,\ncorrespondence, equivalence, or \"coincidence\" of these contents, only then\ncan one make the conclusion about some commonality and continuity of their\nforms, and, consequently, about the objectivity of the contents of the forms\nof sensations and thinking, supplementing, deepening, and developing the\nobjective content of the form of the object itself. By virtue of the\nindicated circumstance the objective content of the form of the object\nappears already in the quality of the objective content of the generalized\nmultilevel aggregate (symbiosis) of all the three conjugated successive\nforms of the different levels (the form of thingness, the form of sensations,\nand the form of thinking). Finally, the content of the above-mentioned\naggregate of forms, manifested by means of the form of thinking, with the\nobjectivity certified (with the help of the procedure of practice or the\ntechnology of interpretation) (i.e., with the highest contentfulness) can lay\nclaim to the status of true knowledge about the object.\nThus, the content of the abstract form (of knowledge, thought, etc.) requires\nthe \"correlation\" or \"correspondence\" not with the object (objectness, being,\netc.), but with the content of the thing form, and moreover mediated by the\nform of sensations. And already on the basis of the mentioned correlation\nand the discovered correspondence (correspondence) or continuity of the\ncompared contents the conclusion is made about the presence in the\nabstract form of objective content, and, consequently, about the truthfulness\nof the abstract form.\nIn connection with the remarks expressed here in the address of the\nfragment of the article [4] I would like nevertheless to note that the article,\nin our opinion, is still topical, but there are some typical inaccuracies which\ncannot but be paid attention to in the context of the questions under\nconsideration. Continuing to think straightforwardly and ignoring without\nexaggeration the leading role and significance of the content-form relations\nin the development (and cognition) of reality, we shall never separate the\nwheat from the chaff and shall be marking time still unforgivably long. In\norder to truly penetrate into the essence of any question and to make it out\nthoroughly, one must consider this question necessarily through the prism of\nthe content-form transformations (unfortunately, this appeal so far is a voice\n\n\fcrying in the wilderness). This is all the more necessary for the reason that\nwe live in conditions when the time for the anticipation of the development of\nevents and the correct response reaction to the so-called challenges is\ncatastrophically shrinking. Equally there is no doubt in the fact that the\nprepared and uncompromising reader will discover in the text of the present\narticle also the inevitable flaws, which would be very good and absolutely\nnormal, for only by the path of the successive approximations can one\napproach the ever more exact and \"exhaustive\" expression of the objective\n(true) content of the developing reality.\nFurther one should necessarily once again emphasize that, despite the\ndifference of the external manifestations of the contentfulness of the forms,\nthe technology (or procedure, or way) of the assessment of the truthfulness\nof any forms remains universal and standard — this is interpretation, the\nparticular case of which is practice. This technology consists in the revelation\nof the possibility and admissibility of the substitution of the contents of the\ninvestigated forms by the contents of as large as possible a number of\nconcrete and abstract forms (with the already established and confirmed\ntruthfulness); i.e., the technology of interpretation is reduced in the final\naccount to the search or working out of the so-called standards or\nconventional units, by means of which one can express or present the\n\"quantity\" or the fullness of the assessed contentfulness of the investigated\nforms.\nThe essence of this technology is always one — the expression of the\nunknown through the known, of the unusual through the habitual, of\nthe uncognized through the cognized, of the incomprehensible\nthrough the comprehended, of the irrational through the rational, of\nthe indefinite through the definite, of the more abstract and less\nconcrete through the less abstract and more concrete, etc., etc.\nEverything uncognized and unexplored is assessed, tested, and expressed\nthrough the already available and existing, the truthfulness of which is\nestablished and tested by time. Nothing new here neither man nor nature will\nbe able to \"invent\" any more, since both the process of development (of\nanything whatsoever) and the process of cognition (of anything whatsoever)\nhave always submitted, submit, and will submit to the universal principle of\nself-development. Herewith it has no essential significance whether the\nparticular is expressed through the general or vice versa, — the main thing is\nthat as the result of the described procedure everything until then\nunexplored and indefinite acquires a more or less finished (balanced for the\ntime being) form of something tested, proved, achieved, and comprehended.\nHowever, there are also other points of view [9].\nThe impossibility to wholly or all-embracingly and exhaustively cover the\n\"making and developing\" by the existing and achieved both conditions and\ngenerates the approximateness, inexactness or, so to say, the \"chronic\"\nunfinishedness of the expression or coverage of the content by the form in\nthe course of the interaction of these two constituents. There necessarily\n\n\fremains something contentful (or some its share), uncovered and not\nyielding to the coverage by any form, with whatever \"zeal\" the latter would\nlay claim to the very perfection. The spiral, as also the comma — this is a\ncircle \"with development\" or a point \"with a tail\", foretelling always a new\nturn of events and a step into the insufficiently definite and not fully\nexplored.\nIt is also necessary to note that with the described approach to the\nassessment and establishment of truth or the truthfulness of the different\nforms of knowledge it has no significance whatsoever — whether this is\nhumanitarian knowledge (from the field of literature, journalism, politics, art,\netc.) or natural-scientific (technical, physical, mathematical, etc.), since\nfalsehood and falsity are objective categories, the essence of which consists\nin the low contentfulness (and, consequently, in the untruthfulness) of the\ncontents of their forms, which one way or another, sooner or later will be\nrefuted and rejected by the principle of self-development, indicating the\nobjective movement-striving to the highest contentfulness (and hence, also\nto the truthfulness) of all without exception the developing forms. The sooner\nman realizes this, the farther from the edge of the abyss (i.e., from the\nthreat of the disappearance of humanity as a definite level-form of reality) he\nwill (re)move.\nThus, the truthfulness of any form is determined by its contentfulness; the\nmost truthful are the forms possessing the highest contentfulness.\nProceeding from this, the criterion of the truthfulness of the forms is served\nby their contentfulness, whereas practice or in the broader sense\ninterpretation — this is only the universal technology, procedure, or way of\nthe assessment of the fullness or the \"quantity\" of the contentfulness of the\ninvestigated forms.\nIf one unites just what has been said into one phrase, then there will be\nobtained such a more or less compact expression: the criterion of truth or of\nthe truthfulness of the investigated forms — this is the contentfulness of\nthese forms, the fullness or the \"quantity\" of which is established by the\npossibility and admissibility of the substitution (at least mental) of the\ncontents of the investigated forms by the contents of as large as possible (in\nthe limit — infinite) a number of concrete and abstract forms with the\nalready established and confirmed truthfulness.\nWith respect to the determination of the criterion of the scientificity of\nknowledge (i.e., of the objectivity of the content of the abstract forms of\nknowledge) one can say the following.\nThe criterion of the scientificity of knowledge (or the criterion of the\nobjectivity of the content of the abstract forms of knowledge) — this is again\nthe contentfulness of these forms, the fullness or the \"quantity\" of which is\nestablished by the possibility and admissibility of the substitution (at least\n\n\fmental) of the contents of the abstract forms by the contents of a certain\nconditionally-limited number of concrete and abstract forms with the already\nestablished and confirmed truthfulness.\nFrom the position of our approach the main functions of science — the\nexplanatory and the prognostic — can be approximately determined and\ncharacterized in the following way.\nExplanation — this is the interpretation (expression, substitution,\nreplacement) of the contents of the unknown, incomprehensible, unusual,\nnon-standard abstract forms (judgments, constructions, structures, theories,\nconceptions, formulas, etc.) by the contents of the known concrete,\ncomprehensible, habitual, standard forms.\nForecasting — this is the anticipation of the formation, appearance, or\ndiscovery of the new forms of reality (as well as the foretelling of the\ndirection of the changes of the existing its forms) with the help of and on the\nbasis of the \"invented\", generated, created, formulated generalized abstract\nforms (judgments, theories, conceptions, hypotheses, constructions,\nstructures, formulas, etc.), the objectivity of the contents (i.e., the\ncontentfulness) of which either has already been established and confirmed,\nor is in the stage of the assessment and confirmation by the technology of\ninterpretation.\nThe very important criteria of the scientificity of knowledge — the\nreproducibility and repeatability of the results of the empirical investigations\n— in the terms of our approach mean the admissibility of the multiple\ninterpretation (expression, substitution, replacement) with the identical result\nof the contents of the investigated empirical forms by the contents of the\nsimilar empirical forms, the truthfulness of which has already been\nestablished and does not raise doubts.\nThe logic of the exposition of the research approach expounded here requires\nalso the corresponding interpretation and refinement of the term \"adequacy\"\nfrom the position of our representations about the development and\ncognition.\nAnd again we \"dance from the stove\". The philosophical dictionaries\ndetermine adequacy in the following way: \"In the theory of cognition the\nterm 'adequate' serves for the designation of the correct reproduction in the\nrepresentations, notions, and judgments of the objective connections and\nrelations of actuality. In this sense truth is determined as the adequacy of\nthinking to being\" [19, p. 13].\nBy this definition we are again attempted to be convinced of the correctness\nof the comparison of the incomparable and the comparison of the\nincomparable. Contrary to the cited definition, adequacy has no direct\nrelation to being, just as truth has no direct relation to objectness (as has\n\n\fbeen indicated above). The adequacy of thinking in the given case means the\nhigh contentfulness of the forms-products of this very thinking, which has\nalready passed the assessment or test by interpretation, as a result of which\nthe mentioned forms-products are recognized as true.\nThereby the term adequate designates and characterizes the content of the\ntrue form of thinking, maximally corresponding (i.e., successive and\ncontinuing by itself) to the objective content of the form of thingness (or\nto the objective content of being), mediated by the form of sensations.\nAnd truth, as has been determined earlier, — this is the form (but the form\nas the aggregate of the forms of thingness, sensations, and thinking),\nfulfilled with the highest (objective) contentfulness.\nAnd the one and the other — deeply interconnected notions. The inadequate\nthinking, operating with the content of the untrue forms, is punished by\n\"non-being\" ahead of time and prematurely.\nThe adequate notion, the adequate image, the adequate representation, the\nadequate theory, the adequate doctrine, etc. — this is all about the objective\ncontent of the diverse true abstract forms-products of thinking.\nAs we see, the term \"adequate\" is applicable only for the assessment,\ndesignation, and statement of the fullness of the contentfulness of the\nuppermost layer or the summit of the pyramid (i.e., of the human\nconsciousness), in the foundation of which lie the more primitive materialthing and plant-animal levels; at the same time, one should clearly realize\nthat without the linkage and interengagement with these more \"down-toearth\" fundamental levels that \"summit\" level of the human consciousness\nsimply does not exist.\nThe adequate thinking — this is the thinking operating with the content of\nthe true forms (the most contentful abstract constructions and structures),\ntested for the fullness of contentfulness by the procedure (technology) of\ninterpretation. The latter means that the highest contentfulness (and hence,\nalso the truthfulness) of such forms has already been confirmed and certified\nby the numerous concrete examples and factual material (including the\nabstract forms tested and approved for the use).\nThe inadequacy of thinking is punished by the premature (early) termination\nof the development of the form of man and humanity (by the retardation of\ndevelopment, the \"tearing apart\" of the form into parts, the absorption and\nassimilation by the competitors). One of the signs of the inadequacy of the\nthinking of the modern man is the neglect of dialectics.\nThe regress of a form — this is already the indicator that it is \"torn apart\",\nboth from within and from without, into parts by the other, more active\n\n\flevels. The form that has stopped in its development is \"picked up\" by the\nneighboring levels, assimilated (wholly or in parts) and acquires thereby a\nnew impulse for its own further development.\nIntegrally, harmoniously, capably, effectively, actually, and truly is that\nwhich is filled with objective content, which is the most contentful at the\ngiven moment and under the given circumstances.\nThe continuity of the forms presupposes the smooth docking, the smooth\ningrowing, the smooth transition from the contents of the forms of the thingpractical level to the contents of the forms-products of the level of thinking\n(which are the abstract representations and images).\nHowever, the determining here all the same, in the final account, turns out to\nbe the objective content of the thing-practical activity, i.e., the contents of\nthe forms of the thing level (mediated by the forms of sensations), since they\nare more fundamental in the multilevel structures of the forms of man and\nhumanity.\nThe abstract forms-products of the subjective thinking (i.e., knowledge in the\nform of representations, images, notions, theories, doctrines, etc.) and the\nmore concrete forms preceding them are capable of being built and are built\ninto the non-contradictory-successive sequence or chain of forms only then,\nwhen they are endowed with objective content, when they are united by the\ncommon component, which is the objective content of the developing reality.\nIn the indicated sense the objective content of the developing reality — this\nis the identity to the infinite movement to the exhaustive expression of the\ncontent of reality by the developing forms of this very same reality.\nIn its turn, the highest contentfulness of knowledge and of its forms (i.e., the\nfilledness of the abstract forms with objective content) and, correspondingly,\nthe adequacy of the perception of reality (the approximate, but as complete\nas possible coincidence or correspondence of the contents of the abstract\nforms of thinking and of the forms of sensations) ensure the success of the\nhuman activity and serve as the condition of the survival and stable\ndevelopment of humanity.\nIn the modern literature (and all the more in the publications of the past) the\nnotion of adequacy is very weakly, or more precisely, practically in no way\ntied up with the contentfulness of the forms. Meanwhile the solution of the\ntask of the establishment and detailing of such a connection will inevitably\nlead to the numerous discoveries in the field of medicine, biology,\ncybernetics, and other spheres of the scientific activity. With respect to man\nthe contentfulness in the face of such manifestations of the organism as\nhealth, longevity, adaptation abilities and possibilities, resource, intellect,\netc., must be investigated in the closest interconnection with the adequacy of\nthe thinking, perception, behavior of man (and of the other higher\nrepresentatives of the animal world), if the researcher is set on the obtaining\nof the original (breakthrough) results in the course of his investigations.\n\n\f§ 17. The truth about lies\nThe present section is devoted to the illustration of the material set forth\nabove by some concrete examples and considerations.\nAs has already been noted in § 3, the modern mass media, controlled by the\ncollective West, are devoid of doubts as to the \"exceptional\" justice of their\nendless attempts to attain unseemly goals by deliberate injections of false\ninformation, by force pressure, and by the manipulation of the consciousness\nof the man in the street, and by all possible means to push through the\nsuperiority of their own contentfulness, i.e., of their own \"unsurpassed\"\nunderstanding of truth or verity, mixed with false premises and foundations.\nIn confirmation of what has been said let us cite the frankly cynical opinion\non this score (in an article with the derisive title \"The Rabies of Russia\") of\none of the modern propagandists of such opinions, who has \"settled\" on the\nscreens of Russian TV:\n\"... Recently we saw the manifestation of the American 'right of the strong' in\nall its glory — the murder of the Iranian general Qasem Soleimani.\n... Yes, such an application of the 'right of the strong' is outrageous,\ndishonest, and often unlawful. ... But the fact remains a fact: the 'right of the\nstrong' is an inevitable, even natural, I would say, part of world politics.\nWhether anyone likes it or not, one must accept such a phenomenon as a\ngiven. Similar to the Darwinian natural selection, the 'international order' has\nexisted from time immemorial, and so it will always be to one degree or\nanother. The right of the strong — this is one of the most vivid and harsh\nmanifestations of 'realpolitik'\" [1].\nFrom time immemorial the Anglo-Saxon world has been consistent in its\nmain goals — to impose its own scenario of the development of events\ncontrary to their objective course and adequate perception. The AngloSaxons are obsessed with the belief that by a simple \"wishing\", by pressing,\nby the inculcation of a certain oversimplification (i.e., by the refusal to take\ninto account the multitude of interacting factors) one can artificially break the\nnaturally developing contentful process. By their standards, the thing-objectmaterial in its monetary expression will always prevail and overcome\neverything else.\nFor the assessment of the weight and authority of the position occupied in\nthe cited article one must answer a simple question: is the contentfulness of\nthe theory of \"social Darwinism\" high at the present stage of development?\nUndoubtedly, something \"long-playing\" remains from this theory to this very\nday (man, for example, will never fully free himself from the animal principle\npresent in him, if only because he has \"come out\" of this principle). At the\nsame time, any schoolboy today knows that \"wild\" nature is represented by\n\n\fonly a narrow stratum, an intermediate level in the universal human nature,\nalongside a whole series of newly superstructured levels, based on the taking\ninto account of such qualities of the developed man as his dignity, readiness\nfor cooperation and mutual aid, humanism, etc. Undoubtedly, the level of\n\"wildness\" is also represented in the linkage of all the other levels of the\nmultilevel structure of man and at times tramples under itself the less\naggressive by their nature \"intellectual\" (\"herbivorous\") levels, but it is also\nbeyond doubt that its specific weight in the general aggregate of levels at the\npresent stage of development is considerably smaller than in the epoch of\nCh. Darwin. And to reduce the whole objective contentfulness of the existing\nlinkage-aggregate of levels in the general structure of the modern man and\nhis thinking to this separate, very \"down-to-earth\" (\"carnivorous\") level —\nthis is a simple-minded delusion or a deliberate lie.\nThe justice of this point of view is confirmed by the centuries-old wisdom of\nour people (or by the somewhat paraphrased saying of Alexander Nevsky):\nnot in force is god (victory, success, perspective, goal, etc.), but in truth, in\nverity ...\nBut to the above-named cohort of people with colonial thinking this cannot\nbe explained. The speech is about people not simply of another discourse and\nnot even of another civilizational order, but about \"offspring\" and exponents\nof another (opposite) principle of reality, with whom to speak about the\npriority of harmony or of the objectively existing tendency to the\nachievement of a certain balance of the constituents-levels in the multilevel\nhuman nature is so far meaningless. They are convinced that the\nhypertrophied technological constituent in their state structure guarantees\nthem complete success and victory over the whole world. What nonsense! On\nthis soil they absolutize their significance and greatness; in reality, however,\nthey are sick with their imaginary exclusivity and see nothing further than\ntheir own nose. All the more problematic for themselves. The low-contentful\n(primitive) consciousness has a chance never to reach the critically necessary\nlevel and to turn out to be a dead-end branch of the development of\nhumanity: gentlemen Neanderthals, where are you? Hello!\nFortunately or unfortunately, but the objective truth exists; at any given\nmoment it is one (out of the multitude of similar approximations to the\nabsolute truth), and ever more insistently the requirement to determine\noneself with this question \"in an adult way\" shows through. The neglect of\nthe objective truth is fraught with the loss of humanity as a species or as one\nof the levels of reality; at stake is the fate of humanity, no more and no less.\nThe main stake of today's \"masters of life\" and of the mass media subject to\nthem — on the low \"down-to-earth\" instincts of man, i.e., on his\n\"dehumanization\": the accent is made on the stimulation and increase of the\ncontentfulness of only the most primitive forms-levels (in the composition of\nthe whole aggregate of the levels-constituents of the modern man), and, in\nparticular, of the simplest forms of sensations and behavioral reactions of the\n\n\fanimal level. The artless content of the indicated forms is \"sewn\" into the\nbrain of man by repeated hammering as axioms (the so-called unproved\ntruths). The main mass of undemanding philistine minds, by virtue of their\nignorance, \"falls for\" the cheap installation and propaganda of following the\nimposed way and mode of life. The capitalist world, saturated through and\nthrough with lies, hypocrisy, double standards, simply does not know how to\nlive otherwise (i.e., without taking \"cream\" under cover). And as for the\nmass media, they always take the position of the one from whose hands they\nare fed, which by no means testifies in favor of their independence; the mass\nmedia are still \"party\", as they were a hundred and two hundred years ago.\nThe question of the purification of today's mass media from the filth of lies\nand half-truths is not solvable, apparently, outside the clarification of the\npersonal positions of the representatives of these mass media. This question\nmust be posed approximately in this way: will you be able, are you\nvouchsafed personally, as a subject form (as a journalist, correspondent,\ncommentator, political scientist, etc.), to be a form-carrier and continuer of\nthe developing objective content in opposition to the \"fake\", lying, venal\nsubject forms that are present and rooted here today? Of course, this\nquestion makes sense only in conjunction with the solution of the problem of\nthe proper upbringing of young cadres. Journalistic cadres, like medical ones,\nmust be brought to an oath or a certain vow, proceeding from the\nunderstanding — of how serious a weapon against humanity the\npropagandized lies and inadequacy of thinking can be.\nThe collective West, in the person of the overseas \"hegemon\" and its\nhenchmen, has in fact already \"played out\" to the conviction that no\nobjective content, no truth or verity exists in principle; everything is\nexhausted by general validity and by what can be imposed on the\nundemanding majority by the manipulation of human consciousness and by\nfrankly force pressure. The manipulation of the consciousness of man — this\nis a crime against the person and against humanity. And the deliberate lie,\nand the sincere delusion, and all the more the manipulation of consciousness\n— are equally ruinous for the fates of humanity.\nThe Western mass media seriously discuss the question of the onset of the\nepoch of the so-called \"post-truth\". The \"post-truth\" of an infinite number of\nsubjective opinions and utterances (fictions, hardly distinguishable from\ntruth; unfounded assertions, \"appointed\" to be truth; retold rumors and idle\nconjectures) must be urgently refuted by the proof of the absence of a stable\ndirect and reverse connection, of succession and conjugacy of the contents of\nthe injected subjective abstract forms with the objective content of the thing\nreality, of concrete facts, of reliably verified abstract logical forms with\nconfirmed truthfulness.\nOne cannot arbitrarily and unceremoniously deal with truth (with verity), and\nnot because it is punishable by a certain \"supreme deity\" or \"providence\",\nbut because the world is arranged dialectically. The return to the initially\nrejected forms of greater contentfulness will take place sooner or later, and\n\n\fall the false, momentarily advantageous orientations together with their\npropagandists and customers will be rejected and overthrown. Such is the\ndialectical nature of the world, implying the inevitable return to itself, but\nevery time at a more and more contentful (genuine, true, actual) level. The\nuniversal principle of self-development \"governs\" everything and everyone,\nmanages all processes without exception, and so simply, on any crooked\ngoat, it can no longer be bypassed. Everyone is free to choose himself — to\naccept this principle and follow it in life, or to deny and ignore it with the\ninevitable consequences for himself.\nThe real state of affairs is such that, by virtue of this very dialectical nature\nof the surrounding world, everything sooner or later has the habit of\nreturning \"to the starting point\", but not in its former form, but in other,\nmore weighty and more contentful forms. In case of non-understanding or\nignoring of such a layout, or in case of unskillful and imprudent dealing with\nthe mentioned renewed forms — the impacts, and even the blows of these\n\"weighted\" returning forms may fall not where it is below the belt, but where\nit is above the neck.\nThe growing contentlessness of the collective West will ruin it. And this will\nhappen not by reason of God's punishment, God's providence, or the\nexecution of a certain \"law of karma\", but because the exhausting\ncontentfulness of their main everyday forms (of the way of life), based on\nhuman vices, provokes the absorption of these forms by considerably more\ncontentful stable forms. Too many empty (low-contentful) form-formations at\nall levels have been generated by their mercantile aim and rampant\nindividualism (sham post-industrial \"economies\"; the unsecuredness of the\nFed currency; lying mass media; fruitless same-sex marriages; pretentious\nidle celebrations; the perverted \"post-truth\" \"appointed as truth\";\nostentatious values;\npharisaical juvenile\njustice;\nthe hypocritical\nmulticulturalism, tolerance, political correctness that appeared out of\nnowhere, etc.). When a society (or a state) pursues low-contentful goals,\nthen it is absorbed by more contentful and balanced social arrangements.\nThe form-formations enumerated above (in parentheses) belong to abstract\nconstructions and structures, invented by an extremely subjectivized\nconsciousness and erected on shaky (false) unnatural foundations. These\nconstructions and structures, generated by the subjective imagination in the\nminds of a few individuals, do not belong to the number of those tested by\ntime and confirmed by customs and traditions, but have in their arsenal only\na limited number of more or less successfully realized examples. Here we\ndirectly encounter the manifestation of voluntarism, with the arbitrary\nabsolutization of the subjective component in the known systemic relation\n{subjective/objective}, which is fraught with the violation of the balance or\nequilibrium of the whole relation as a whole. Too small a volume of factual\nmaterial is at the disposal of man to verify and confirm the truthfulness of\nthe abstract constructions of the indicated type and to admit them then as\n\n\fnew foundations for mass application by humanity. Without a thorough\nassessment of the contentfulness of the fruits of the inflamed brain and\nunbridled fantasies by the procedures of practice and interpretation, the\ntruthfulness of these forms, to put it mildly, raises doubts, and the stubborn\nuniversal inculcation — is certainly dangerous.\nIn every relation similar to the relation {change/basis}, a typical\nrepresentative of which is also the relation {subjective/objective} examined\nby us, there is present a definite correlation of the components \"change\" and\n\"basis\" in their relation, guaranteeing the stability and steady development of\nthe relation itself as a whole at one or another stage of the development of\nreality. The finding of such a correlation of the components-constituents in\nthe indicated relations, corresponding to a certain averaged balanced value,\ndetermined and conditioned by every given stage of the development of\nreality, always has been and will be the most important priority task standing\nboth before individual subjects and before their communities.\nAs soon as the immature subjective thinking begins to ignore its connection\nwith the \"down-to-earth\" levels of the basis, so it goes into an extreme, into\na one-sidedness, into the absolutization of this one-sidedness. Thinking\nspeculatively and practically boundlessly can manipulate everything\nwhatsoever, which it does, and obtains any \"results\", and achieves\n\"outstanding\" successes. But much of these \"achievements\" is acquired at\nthe price of the loss of the adequacy of the representations about reality. And\nin this case the individual or community, recklessly and \"crazy-headedly\"\nusing the huge potential of thinking (characterized by the high intensity of\ncontent-form transformations), fall into a trap.\nQuite in the spirit of the Anglo-Saxon subjectivized tradition — by force to\ndrive into \"paradise\" and to \"cultivate\" (civilize, democratize, etc.) all the\ndisagreeing and resisting. Such, from time to time repeated, neglect of the\nobjectively taking-shape situation will inevitably return to the Anglo-Saxons\nas a boomerang of punishments for their new generations, which will have to\n\"reverse gear\", paying for the inadequacy and low-contentfulness of their\nancestors. Unfortunately, the majority (and, first of all, the youth) does not\nsee this yet, naively believing that the technocratic policy and technological\n\"advancement\" will automatically ensure primacy and advantage in all\nspheres of human activity. In reality, however, the ugly one-sidedness or\nimbalance in the development of different sides-constituents of individual\ncivilizations leads the latter to degeneration into their opposite and to\ninevitable collapse. [As a result of the excessive rocking or loss of\nequilibrium, the \"ship of civilization\", speaking figuratively, capsizes upside\ndown, i.e., the situation turns into its opposite: in the place where man was\n(the so-called crown of nature, according to the very widespread opinion\nnowadays), there turns out to be a bottom soaked with tar, and the crown of\nnature is swallowed by the abyss, i.e., returns into the wild (thing) nature\nand is assimilated by it.]\n\n\fAfter all, what mainly distinguishes the modern Western ideology from the\nEastern one (in particular, within the framework of the antagonism USA vs\nRussia)? These are different representations about the necessary and\nsufficient correlation of the components in the relation {change/basis} (or in\nthe most general relation {content/form}). The Western world makes the\naccent on the prevalence of the constituent of change (transcendent\nenterprise, infinite freedom, unlimited individualism and egoism, etc.),\nwhereas the East gives preference to the component of the basis — stability,\nexperience, common sense, justified conservatism, collectivism. And already\nfrom here, on the part of the West, follows the neglect of morality, ethics,\nhumanism. Here two different approaches meet and compete, relying on\ndifferent specific weights (including in digital expression) of the abovementioned components-constituents in their inseparable integrity. For the\nfinding of the balance or the golden mean between the indicated\ncomponents, of course, both a reserve of patience and an ever more\nmeaningful loyalty of the West and the East with respect to each other are\nneeded. However, no less significant is also the understanding that at times\nit is simply necessary to actively counteract aggression (both in the air, and\nat sea, and on land, and, especially, in space). In the trenches, alternately\nturning the cheeks for blows, one cannot sit out. One should more boldly and\nenergetically bloc with like-minded people and by collective efforts control\nthe balance of the system {West/East}. In particular, all the \"iron\" of opaque\nand doubtful purpose, launched into space by the \"hegemon\", must find its\nrest at the bottom of the world ocean.\nThere must be no illusions; one cannot fail to see that in this case the West\nrepresents not so much an active as an aggressive component of the relation\n{change/basis}, opposing the moderately-active component of the East. The\nWest is \"commanded\" by a quite different principle of reality than the East,\nand the full compatibility or coincidence of both principles is not achievable in\nprinciple. That is why the unsafe algorithms \"swarming\" in the heads of the\ncollective West must be neutralized at the earliest stages. The known\ninadequacy of a monkey with a grenade can lead to the collapse of the whole\nsystem {West/East} and to the departure \"into non-being\" of such a formlevel of reality as humanity. It goes without saying that the development of\nreality and the natural universal course of events under the \"control\" of the\nprinciple of self-development cannot be stopped by this single act — simply a\nseparate link in the general chain of development will be transformed into a\nnew form, which will continue its contentful movement at a new level, but\nalready without man. However, to man himself his fate, perhaps, is not so\nindifferent.\nThe procedure of finding the balance of the above-mentioned componentsconstituents is complicated also by the fact that the components are subject\nto the permanent influence of numerous external and internal factors (i.e., of\nthe same components of other relations), which makes them very mobile\nwithin the framework of a single relation and, in its turn, leads to the\nsporadic variability of the relation itself as a whole.\n\n\fChanges without a basis (i.e., the denial and reduction to a minimum of the\nsignificance and role of the basis) in the known relation {change/basis} —\nthis is absurd. The basis directs the changes, preserves them in the form of\nlayers and thereby sets the vector of the subsequent changes (i.e., of\ndevelopment). The changes that become isolated and \"tear away\" from the\nbasis liquidate the relation as a whole as such, since something, being\ndeprived of the basis and \"not remembering kinship\", is transformed into its\nopposite. The vector of development is to a considerable degree determined\nby the basis, i.e., by the past, by the \"lived-through\", by the preceding\naccumulations.\nThe role of Russia as the main stabilizing component or counterbalance in the\nsystem {West/East}, threatening at times to go to pieces, — is indisputable.\nTrue, the most effectively this counterbalance will function only on the basis\nof the renewed social structure with the socialist order, which, undoubtedly,\nis our national priority and pride for centuries.\nThe absence (especially among politicians) of adherence to such, for\nexample, qualities of man and indicators of the developed harmonious\nsociety as honor, conscience, decency, morality, ethics, philanthropy, mutual\nrespect — is a direct path \"into non-being\" for those human communities\nwhich refuse such humanistic acquisitions, ideals, and convictions.\nThe inadequate behavior of the majority of individuals (of society), as a\nreaction to the movement into nowhere, \"sanctified\" by contentless goals, is\npunished by \"non-being\", i.e., by the absorption and assimilation of the lowcontentful forms by the healthy adequate forms. Russia, with its considerably\nmore adequate than that of the collective West representations about reality,\nhas every chance for leadership with a humanistic orientation, provided that\na way is found to transform the ugly and defective capitalist forms imposed\non it into other harmonious forms of development.\nAs time and the course of the developing events show, the subjective, it\nwould seem, question of the justice of the social structure [Roman law, for\nexample, refers the notion of justice to the subjective categories] turns out\nto be a question not at all subjective, but exclusively objective. Taking into\naccount the striving and craving for justice originally inherent in our people,\nthe following ideological scheme or chain of contentful transformations has\nquite matured for embodiment at a new level: truth (verity) => justice\n=>law =>equality => (social) equilibrium =>balance =>harmony ... Any\nhuman community or civilization in one way or another (explicitly and\nimplicitly) strives for the realization of such a chain, conditioned by the\ndialectical nature of the surrounding world. In reality — this is a\nquestion of life and death for all the human communities presently existing.\nIt is worth, perhaps, to dwell separately on the role and significance of\nmodern advertising.\n\n\fToday's aggressive advertising on TV — this is, as a rule, well-paid lie and\ndeliberately distorted representation of the true state of affairs. In the\nlanguage of advertising, from the tenderest nails, a signal is sent to man:\none can lie a lot and with impunity, from a high tribune and to a multi-million\naudience. Advertising almost always peremptorily hypertrophies the limited\npositive and advantage of the goods, services, and all sorts of \"brands\",\nhiding in the backyard their negative features and shortcomings. In this\nconsists its lie, by this it perniciously influences the unformed young minds.\nThe lying advertising from morning till evening teaches the youth also to\ntreat easily and undemandingly their own unfulfilled promises and empty\nassurances.\nAdvertising must be removed from TV unambiguously. The most \"creative\"\nliars cry out that without advertising there will be no TV. They lie,\nshamelessly lie, for the principles of the functioning of TV are deliberately\ndistorted and disfigured by the dealers from TV. Those lie who have a\nrelation to the huge money that revolves in this backstage and that can be\nuncontrollably stuffed into pockets. In the conditions of the social character\nof production and the private-capitalist mode of appropriation, the throwing\nof dust in the eyes of the respectable public — is an inalienable element of all\ntelevision shows and attractions. When the matter concerns the distribution\nand appropriation of the product worked out under capitalism, everyone\nmust immediately forget about the transparency of these procedures —\notherwise by no forces will it be possible to gather on relatively tiny patches\nthe transcendent number of crooks and other odious individuals.\nMeanwhile, the way around these \"naturally\" organized difficulties is quite\nwell-known and artless — to create an accumulation fund, public\nconsumption funds and to feed with them the vital and demanded directions,\nand not only on TV; this is, perhaps, so far the most effective and tested way\nof the development of human initiatives in the conditions of the coming\nsocialist order.\nLet us touch upon the background of the origin and rooting of false premises.\nA lie — this is also a certain contentful form, but with an extremely low\ndegree of objective contentfulness, i.e., a form of a very distant (rough)\napproximation to the expression of the objective content of reality (a lowcontentful, and therefore untruthful form).\nA shameless lie — this is a factual refusal of the moral-ethical norms and\ncategories in favor of a temporary, momentary, as a rule, material gain (with\nits single measure — the volume of the money supply). To such a choice is\nbrought by the cultivation of the vividly expressed individualism in opposition\nto collectivism and the priority of public interests.\nThe inability and unwillingness to distinguish the inessential or little-essential\nfrom the essential, firstly, and the arbitrary absolutization of this little-\n\n\fessential to the detriment of the essential, secondly, — is akin to an\nimpudent shameless lie. Using such a device one can for a long time\neffectively make mountains out of molehills, deliberately belittling the\ncontentfulness of the essential forms. The conscious belittling of the essential\nand the exaltation of the inessential is equivalent to the mixing of lie with\nhalf-truth, and therefore this is the most refined, vile, and disgusting variety\nof lie. However, sooner or later the natural installation on the growth of the\ncontentfulness of the forms will take its toll and will arrange the forms in\ntheir places according to the level of their contentfulness.\nEvery lie — this is a deliberate attempt to lead aside and to evade the\nadequate thinking.\nWhen we are tried to be convinced that black is white, referring to the\ntruthfulness of the generally valid (i.e., to the opinion of a certain \"little\ncollective\" that has gathered under its banners a limited number of\nindividuals), then these propagandists of the generally valid to the detriment\nof the objective must bear in mind that the answer for the imposition of a\nfailed opinion may, as it may turn out, have to be held not before the\nhoodwinked \"little collective\", but before the deceived humanity.\nVirtual reality — this is a lie based on the unsupported and unconfirmed by\nthe content of concrete forms admissibility of the prevalence of the\nsubjective constituent in the relation {subjective/objective} to the detriment\nof the objective constituent. The modern cinematography of the \"overseas\"\nHollywood type (which has splendidly mastered the \"Solzhenitsyn\" motives\nand devices of inflating the less essential to scales surpassing everything\nessential) is saturated with fictions, tricks, and special effects, hindering the\nadequate perception of reality. The indulgence of the \"overseas\" inadequacy\nagain is fraught with consequences for the whole world.\nIn the final account, this is the right of every individual to choose — in which\ndirection and to what extent one should shift the dividing line in the relation\n{subjective/objective}, but, fortunately, the criterion of the correctness and\nadmissibility of such \"shifts\" nevertheless exists; this is the adequacy of the\ncontent of thinking to the content of being. In the case of the absolutization\nof the component \"subjective\", the harmless, at first glance, inadequacy of\nthinking and of the formed representations about reality can lead to serious\nconsequences. The above-mentioned \"little collective\" or a certain limited\ncommunity and its collective consciousness is capable of existing in the\n\"fake\" regime of the inadequate perception of reality only for a very limited\ntime as well, but even in a short period it can create a global threat to the\nsurvival of humanity as a whole, and even destroy it ...\nLet us cite a somewhat hyperbolized and therefore quite obvious for\ncomprehension example. Suppose, from the apartment of the seventh floor\nthere are two exits outside: through the door and through the window.\nEveryone knows that one can go out both through the door and through the\n\n\fwindow, but the overwhelming majority habitually uses the door, since it\nknows that the exit through the window is fraught with grave consequences.\nAnd nevertheless there are separate individuals who, following obsessive\nideas, leave the apartment through the window, and for one reason or\nanother their number will never be reduced to zero. The realization of such\nan alternative possibility on the scale of the whole humanity would threaten\nthe disappearance of humanity as a species. The loss of the adequacy of the\nrepresentations about reality in this case could turn out to be critical and be\nexpressed in the loss of humanity as a definite level of reality. The speech\nhere is precisely about such a \"can\" which \"cannot\" from the point of view of\nthe adequately thinking man (and of humanity as a whole). [Deliberately\nexaggerated examples sometimes help to feel the real danger of flirting with\ninadequacy].\nAnother example. The Ptolemaic picture of the world proceeded from the\nprimacy of the geocentric representations. Was this inadequacy of\nrepresentations critical for those times? Probably, no. But with time, little by\nlittle, it became such. In any case, no accuracy of the calculation of the\ntrajectory of the flight of space vehicles on the basis of the Ptolemaic model\n(because of the transcendent cumbersomeness and error of the calculations)\ncould be out of the question today.\nThinking easily shifts the boundary in the relation {subjective/objective} in\nthe direction of the prevalence of the subjective (for itself, as for the most\nabstracted level of reality, this is not critical), but at the same time it can, to\nthe detriment of adequacy, provoke the \"exit\" of the values of the whole\nrelation beyond the limits of the range admissible by this definite stage of\ndevelopment. In other words, for \"proper\" thinking some inadequate\npreferences and unbridled internal activity (while they are localized in the\nhead, without exit outside) can remain and without consequences, but for\nthe whole linkage-aggregate of the levels of man (dwelling in the thing world\nand including in itself the form of thingness, the form of sensations, and the\nform of thinking) — the arbitrary choice of thinking with the subsequent exit\nof the inadequate reactions outside can turn out to be critical, which is shown\nby the examples cited above.\nA lie is often dictated by the striving to adapt to the external conditions and\ninfluences in the name of the survival and prosperity of some separate formlevel in isolation from the remaining levels of the general aggregate in the\ncomposition of the structure of man (say, the exaltation of the flesh and\nmaterial acquisitions to the detriment or bypass of morality and ethics). At\nthe same time, at the mental level there \"reigns\" a factual \"dual power\"\n(split): something more formal collides with something more contentful. As a\nresult, a conflict arises: the contentful constituent \"supervises\", as a rule,\ndirectly the straightforward, artless path of the achievement of the goal; the\nformal constituent, however, for the sake of the achievement of the goal, as\nit seems, by a more sure-fire path, is ready to go roundabout, i.e., to lie.\n\n\fTruth and lie — forms of deliberately different degrees of approximation to\nthe expression of the fullness of the moving (objective) content. By virtue of\nthe perniciousness of the influence of even the smallest public \"fakes\" and\nfictions on the minds and consciousness of people, one must fight against lie\nharshly, resolutely, and mercilessly — to suppress, not leaving without\nattention a single serious attempt of the rooting of falsity. When the question\narises about the survival of humanity or of its separate communities, the\norientation to the inadequate thinking, false premises, and \"values\" not\napproved by life is categorically inadmissible.\nIn order not to find oneself on the sidelines of development, the\ncontentfulness of all without exception forms (ideas, perspective plans,\nprojects, programs, directions, etc.) planned on the state scale for\ndevelopment and embodiment must be analyzed and ranked at the state and\npublic levels in a permanent and uninterrupted regime.\nHowever, not only mean, petty, or mercenary motives and goals are the\nbackground of the fake injections and the spread of lies. Their \"feasible\"\ncontribution of confusion to the public life is made by the humanitarians,\nwho, by virtue of their professional orientation to the world of people and the\nsphere of psychology, live in isolation from the physical world and are easily\nintoxicated by the ruling \"top\", poorly imagining how bread grows, steel is\nboiled, and energy is released at the fission of the uranium nucleus. The\nwidening illiteracy in the questions of natural science — also one of the\ncauses of the false representations about the world, of the spread and\ntenacity of myths.\nThe unprincipledness of the position and the absence of firm convictions\namong the statesmen and ordinary citizens in a similar way is akin to the\nrenunciation of truth and the patronage of lie.\nThe \"comprador guts\" of the powers that be and of the so-called business —\nagain from the same series.\nThe very widespread opinion on that score that the market allegedly will put\neverything in its places, both in the sphere of production and consumption,\n— also a lie or at least a dense delusion. If already by chance, unexpectedly\n(well, they overlooked, \"missed\", with whom it does not happen!) there\narose man with his thinking (and, correspondingly, everything connected\nwith him, the so-called \"artificial\"), then, most likely, he in one way or\nanother consciously and unconsciously will interfere and in the nature of all\nthings (or this is already generally beyond the limits of understanding?).\nGetting burned and making mistakes and learning on them, man will\nconstantly correct both his own life and the influence of the external\nenvironment — another path of development, except for the \"making of\noneself from oneself\", simply does not exist. For this reason both the state\nplanning, and the state support, and the state regulation in various fields of\nproduction and consumption are quite regular and will certainly be present as\n\n\fa consequence of the vision of the processes of development by the eyes of\nthe subject (the initiator of everything \"artificial\"). Another matter is that\nwith all this the question remains as before topical, which also no one is able\nto cancel and which the subjective consciousness will have to solve\npermanently in the name of the provision of the steady contentful\ndevelopment — the finding of the optimal correlation or balance of the\nmutually complementary components of the \"invisible hand of the market\"\nand the \"state regulation\" (i.e., the balance or optimal correlation of the\nartificial and the natural).\nAnd, finally, one cannot fail to see today how destructive a weapon (a\nweapon of mass destruction) the information pandemic can turn out to be\nand how important it is to be able to verify and establish the truthfulness of\nthe information injections. In such a connection, the significance and role of\nthe technology of interpretation (in solving the problem of the establishment\nof truth) as a means of counteracting the threat of the infliction on humanity\nof all kinds of damage of a global scale by means of cunningly planned\ninformation attacks increase immeasurably.\nUnfortunately, we do not have the possibility to develop this theme further\nhere.\nEverywhere, at all levels of the development of reality, between all its forms\nof all levels without exception there takes place a harsh competitive struggle\nfor the possession of the highest contentfulness or the struggle for the\ncontentful resource, which turns out to be a direct consequence of the\nuniversality of the principle of self-development. The striving to the\nexpression of truth and verity, determined by this same principle, is originally\ninherent, including, in the very \"mechanism\" of human thinking\n(consciousness). And if today a certain lie is considered an ordinary and\nhabitual matter and is accepted \"with a bang\" by undemanding collectives\nand communities, then tomorrow there will certainly be found a subject (or\nsubjects) who, obeying the immanent principle of self-development present\nin him, will \"dig up\" the truth about this falsity, and all the constructions\nerected on lying premises will collapse in an instant, and even with the\nattendant consequences for those who erected the lie on a pedestal.\nMoreover, such a scenario is realized by no means by reason of the\nintervention of \"higher forces\", but under the \"pressure\" of the objectively\neverywhere present universal, unconditional, blind, and relative principle of\nself-development with its \"installations\" on the possession of the maximally\nachievable contentfulness by all forms-levels of the changing reality.\nConclusions\nThe above set forth we consider a sufficient basis for the following\nconclusions.\n1. The objective reality represents the movement and change of its forms in\nthe direction of the possession by the mentioned forms of the highest\n\n\fcontentfulness. The cognitive process can be more effective if the\ndevelopment of reality is examined from the position of the content-form\ntransformations of unitary directionality.\n2. The human consciousness (thinking) — this is the most abstracted (of the\nreliably known today) form of the representation of the content of reality,\ncontinuing by itself the series of the preceding forms, such as the form of\nthingness and the form of sensations. Getting rid of the representations\nabout consciousness as an \"reflection\" or \"copy\" of reality, human thinking\nacquires the possibility to see the development of reality as a single\n(\"through\") movement of its content by means of ever more abstracting\ncontentful forms; thereby the artificial gnoseological barrier is eliminated,\nerected by the human consciousness itself on the path of the cognition of the\ncontentfully infinite (multilevel) movement of reality.\n3. The genuine criterion of truth or of the truthfulness of the forms of\nthe developing reality is established. The truthfulness of this or that\nform of reality is determined by the fullness or the \"quantity\" of its\ncontentfulness. Hence, the criterion of the truthfulness of the forms\nof reality is served by their contentfulness.\n4. The above-mentioned criterion makes it possible to quantitatively assess\nthe contentfulness of the forms of reality, which gives the possibility to\narrange them by rank and thereby more precisely and more meaningfully\ndetermine the direction of the perspective investigations.\n5. Practice is not the criterion of truth, but serves as a procedure\n(technology, way) of the assessment of the fullness or the \"quantity\" of the\ncontentfulness of all sorts of forms of reality. In the indicated sense practice\nrepresents a particular case of the more general technology, named\ninterpretation.\n6. The essence of the process of cognition is reduced to the fact that\neverything investigated and uncognized is assessed, verified, and expressed\nthrough the available and existing, the truthfulness of which has already\nbeen established and verified by time.\n7. There do not exist two or more equally contentful truths (ideas,\nrepresentations, assertions, theories, conceptions, models, opinions, points\nof view, etc.) with respect to one and the same investigated question or\nsubject of judgment, just as there cannot be in principle two or more\nequivalent approximations to the objective truth or to the absolute truth. At\nany given moment of development among the forms of different\napproximations there exists only one form, the most approximated to the\nform of the objective (absolute) contentfulness. This is precisely the form on\nwhich one should orient oneself as on the true one.\nReferences\n\n\f1. Bom M. The Rabies of Russia [Electronic resource] // URL:\nhttps://subscribe.ru/digest/economics/news/n272917707.html\n2. Vladlen V.K. To Recognize the Obvious. A Non-trivial Look at Evolution\n[Text]. — St. Petersburg: Super Publishing House, 2016. — 68 p.\n3. Hegel G.W.F. Encyclopedia of the Philosophical Sciences [Text]. — Vol. 1.\nScience of Logic. — Moscow: Mysl, 1975. — 452 p.\n4. Gubanov N.N., Gubanov N.I. Categories in the System of Scientific\nKnowledge // Humanitarian Bulletin. — 2016. — No. 2 [Electronic resource].\n— URL: http://hmbul.ru/articles/344/344.pdf\n5. Deryabo S. Personality: From Subjectivity to Subjectness [Text] //\nDevelopment of Personality: journal. — 2002. — No. 3. — Pp. 261–265.\n6. Julia D. Philosophical Dictionary [Text]. — Moscow: International\nRelations, 2000. — 544 p.\n7. Ilyin V., Mashentsev A. Philosophy in Schemes and Commentaries\n[Electronic resource] // URL: http://eurasialand.ru/txt/ilyin/38.htm\n8. Kravchenko V.V. The Concept of Development: A View from Within [Text]\n// Journal of Philosophical Research. — 2018. — Vol. 4, No. 2. — Pp. 47–73.\n9. Lebedev S.A. The Method of Paradigmatic Substantiation of Scientific\nTheories [Text] // Journal of Philosophical Research. — 2019. — Vol. 5, No.\n4. — Pp. 3–7.\n10. Lebedev S.A. The Method of Formalization of Scientific Theories and Its\nPossibilities [Text] // Journal of Natural Science Research. — 2017. — Vol. 2,\nNo. 4. — Pp. 13–29.\n11. Lenin V.I. Materialism and Empirio-Criticism [Text]. — Moscow:\nPolitizdat, 1979. — 384 p.\n12. Lenin V.I. Philosophical Notebooks [Text]. — Moscow: Politizdat, 1978. —\n752 p.\n13. Lenin V.I. The Economic Content of Narodism [Text]. — Complete\nCollected Works, 5th ed. — Vol. 1. — Moscow: Politizdat, 1967. — 662 p.\n14. Marx K., Marx K. and Engels F. The Poverty of Philosophy [Text] //\nCollected Works. — 2nd ed. — Vol. 4. — Moscow: Politizdat, 1955. — 615 p.\n15. Petrovsky V.A. Subjectness as Consistency [Electronic resource] // URL:\nhttps://psy-journal.hse.ru/2015-12-3/161488495.html\n16. Dictionary of the Russian Language [Text] / Ed. by A.P. Evgenyeva. —\n2nd ed. — Vol. 2. — Moscow: Russky Yazyk, 1982. — 736 p.\n17. Soviet Encyclopedic Dictionary [Text] / Chief ed.: A.M. Prokhorov. — 4th\ned. — Moscow: Sov. Encyclopedia, 1989. — 1632 p.\n18. Feuerbach L. The History of Philosophy [Text] // Collected Works in Three\nVolumes. — Vol. 2. — Moscow: Mysl, 1974. — 480 p.\n19. Philosophical Encyclopedic Dictionary [Text]. — Chief eds.: L.F. Ilyichev,\nP.N. Fedoseev, S.M. Kovalev, V.G. Panov. — Moscow: Sov. Encyclopedia,\n1983. — 840 p.\n20. Engels F. Dialectics of Nature [Text]. — Moscow: Politizdat, 1975. — 359\np.\n21. Encyclopedic Dictionary [Text] / Ed. by I.E. Andreevsky, K.K. Arsenyev,\nF.F. Petrushevsky. — St. Petersburg: F.A. Brockhaus, I.A. Efron Publishing\nHouse, 1890–1907.\n\n\f22. Encyclopedia of Physics and Technology [Electronic resource] // URL:\nhttp://femto.com.ua/articles/part_1/1635.html\n23. Vladlen V.K. To Cognize the Obviousness. Non-trivial Outlook on\nEvolution. — Houston, TX 77065: Strategic Book Publishing and Rights Co.,\n2013. — 46 p."} {"id": "article_4_en", "title": "Article 4. Unlearned Lessons of Dialectics: From Whom and How to Learn to Think", "author": "Vladlen V.K.", "book": "Concept of Development: A Non-Trivial Outlook on Evolution", "book_ru": "Концепция развития. Нетривиальный взгляд на эволюцию", "year": 2021, "publisher": "Prometej Publishers (Moscow)", "isbn": "978-5-00172-246-5", "license": "CC BY 4.0", "language": "en", "text": "ARTICLE 4\nUnlearned Lessons of Dialectics: From Whom and How to Learn to Think\nDialectically\nAbstract\nThis article is dedicated to the lessons of dialectics from Vladimir I. Lenin — an\noutstanding national thinker to whom the ability of clear dialectical thinking was\ngenerously gifted by nature. Any work that came from Lenin's pen is imbued\nwith the spirit of dialectics.\nAny Lenin's thought is a chain or series of conceptual forms maximally filled with\nobjective content. Any of his theoretical work is a model of masterfully balanced\nsliding of thought as if on the \"razor's edge\", the opposite sides-facets of which\nsymbolize the confrontation of two non-identical opposing sides-components of\nreality.\nThe aim of this article is to draw the attention primarily of the young reader\nprecisely to these qualities of Vladimir I. Lenin's theoretical works.\nIn the course of familiarizing oneself with Lenin's theoretical heritage, the\ncircumstance that the research approach he used remains unclaimed to this day,\nand Lenin's lessons of dialectics, accordingly, remain unlearned, catches the eye.\nSince at the foundation of any certain form of reality (object, process,\nphenomenon) lie two highly abstract and non-identical, yet at the same time\nobjective and interrelated constituent sides-components \"content\" and \"form\",\nthe content-form relations (conversions, transformations) come to the fore and\nbecome the subject of close attention of dialectics.\nConsidering Lenin's theoretical works through the prism of content-form relations\nand identifying on this basis the general regularities of the construction and\npresentation of material makes it possible to speak about the possibility of\ncreating a single universal methodology for conducting effective research at any\nlevel and in any field of reality.\nIntroduction\n\n\fAs an epigraph to this article, we would like to take words by Vladimir I. Lenin\nfrom his work \"On the Road\", written in 1909: \"...this stage must be outgrown;\nthe new circumstances of the moment require new forms of struggle...\" [8, p.\n540].\nThe cited quote, in our view, vividly expresses not only the character of a\nremarkable living and flexible personality but also the essence of the entire life\nand revolutionary activity of V.I. Lenin: keenly and relentlessly tracking the\nsituation, accurately grasping its changes, and being constantly ready to respond\nto these changes with the most adequate actions — new forms of struggle.\nIn this article, we will examine and analyze the greatness and scale of Lenin's\nfigure from the standpoint of his innate ability: to be a dialectician. Discarding\nall fictional, doubtful and secondary elements that were thrust into the\nforeground during the \"murky\" 1990s — years of merciless reprisals against\nSoviet power and the USSR — we will focus mainly on this aspect of Lenin's\nactivities and personality in our research.\nA dialectical mindset is that indispensable trait of Lenin's individuality which, in\nour opinion, has not yet received due coverage in fiction and journalism. All\nother attributes of genius are already derivatives of such outstanding features of\nhis nature: adherence to a scientific approach in studying any issues; striving for\nobjective and impartial presentation of conclusions and results obtained through\nobservations and studies, etc. It was precisely Lenin's natural \"immersion\" in the\nmysterious medium of dialectics that provoked fierce hostility and rejection\ntowards him from his enemies and opponents who, lacking this natural gift,\ncould boast of nothing more than inventing plots \"out of their heads\" and\npresenting scholastic twists, assumptions, fables and fairy tales.\nAnother reason for pathological hatred and animosity toward Lenin's personality\nlies in the inability of his opponents to achieve a penetrating, Lenin-like insight\ninto the essence and order of things; and this unattainable depth of\nunderstanding actual relations remains the main irritant for his opponents even\nnow.\nWhat is the strength of Lenin, if even his most die-hard detractors and\nadversaries nevertheless recognize his influence and authority on a global scale?\nFirst of all, in our view, it lies in his philosophical significance and specifically in\nmastery of dialectics: when foresight is the result of a talent of an individual to\nsee the development of reality through the prism of interaction between directly\nopposing sides of this (reality). He was what many ordinary and extraordinary\nphilosophizing individuals secretly desire and dream of becoming, realizing\nhowever that they fall short, do not measure up, and cannot become anyone\nsimilar — because some extremely important constituent elements are missing\nin the multi-layered structure of their own \"I\".\nIt is difficult to find a modern public leader who stands at least level with (on the\nsame step) Lenin — an encyclopedic scholar and philosopher of profound depth,\n\n\fa brilliant polemicist, consistent and fearless revolutionary, prominent politician\nand outstanding statesman.\nPossession of the invaluable gift of a born dialectician allowed Lenin to handle\nevents and circumstances with exquisite precision, balancing on the crest of the\nwave.\nThe accuracy and precision with which historical figures of a dialectical \"leaven\"\nwalk along the \"razor's edge\", balancing between Scylla and Charybdis in\ninterpreting the questions under study, evokes admiration and envy in the best\nsense of the word. Through them (and via them), dialectics charts its way most\neffectively and optimally. It is precisely through them and their voices that\ndialectically developing nature speaks to us.\nIt is regrettable, of course, that the beauty and perfection of thought, say, of\nMarx or Engels can be appreciated by most of us only thanks to the efforts of\ntranslators. Undoubtedly, those translators of the time were highly qualified\nspecialists and quite exceptional people, but as someone aptly noted, reading\nclassics in translation is like taking a shower while wearing a coat. And so much\nthe better that the beauty, clarity and precision of Lenin's thought can, thank\ngod, be known and evaluated without the interference of intermediary\ntranslators.\nAll people (especially outstanding ones) are to one degree or another\nspontaneous dialecticians. And it does not matter what craft (of mental or\nphysical labor) they possess. Dialectics, ingrained in the flesh and blood of every\nperson, occasionally orients him/her towards certain paradoxical (it seems, from\nthe point of view of common sense) solutions, thanks to which he/she achieves\nremarkable results and therefore becomes famous among the general public. We\nrefer here, for example, to memoirs and recollections of celebrated personalities:\nMarshal Zhukov, pilots Pokryshkin and Kozhedub, aircraft engine designer\nMikulin, director Eisenstein, cardiac surgeon Amosov, weightlifter Vlasov and\nmany others whose innate art of paradoxical dialectical thinking helped them\n\"squeeze through\" literally through the eye of a needle and win unpredictable\nvictories, make discoveries, achieve unexpected and unforeseen success in\nseemingly unfavorable situations according to everyday consciousness. But Lenin\nwas by no means a spontaneous latent dialectician, whom there are countless\nnumbers of on planet Earth; rather, like Hegel, Marx and Engels, he undoubtedly\nfelt and realized himself as a dialectician and acted accordingly to the dialectical\nnature of the world and the set of tools provided by this nature: not inventing\ntools out of one's head, but discovering them using one's head [16, p. 148].\nAccordingly, any conclusion drawn by Lenin is not arbitrariness or fabrication,\nbut a sober judgment based on careful study and meticulous analysis of the\nestablished situation with identification of all the \"actors and performers\".\nAs mentioned above, through thinkers such as Marx, Hegel, Engels, Lenin,\nnature itself (the surrounding world, developing reality) talks to us in the\nlanguage of pure dialectics. And our Vladimir Ilyich looks in this row of\n\n\fdialecticians even \"cooler\" than the aforementioned Germans, especially in\nmatters of practical implementation and embodiment of theoretical\ndevelopments.\nNot only \"Philosophical Notebooks\" (compiled from quotes and notes made in\nmargins of books read) or “Materialism and Empiriocriticism” serve as evidence\nof the author's deep understanding of the dialectical foundations of building and\nharmony of the surrounding world, but any of his other works regardless of\ncontent, and even solely on formal grounds, confirm his belonging to the ranks\nof true conductors and tribunes of dialectics.\nWhy does Lenin's figure attract such close and lasting attention? Because he is\none of the greatest dialecticians of all times and peoples — a direct successor\nand multiplier of the dialectical legacy of Hegel, Marx, Engels.\nLenin is so great and significant in terms of the practical application of the\nmastery of dialectical thinking that none of the scientists and philosophers of all\nstripes who lived after him and live today can currently be placed alongside him\nin this respect. Brilliants of such size and cut appear once in hundreds of years.\nCompletely distancing ourselves from the heap of lies and absurdities expressed\nabout this outstanding thinker during the so-called \"time of trouble\" at the end of\nthe last century (let this remain entirely on the conscience of talkative\nsimpletons), we will assess the scale of Lenin's personality from the perspective\nof the spirit and atmosphere of his theoretical works freely available: please, feel\nfree to read, verify, adopt or refute what we have presented — depending on\nyour comprehension and preparation.\nWith the expectation that this article may provide some support in mastering the\nart of dialectical thinking (which is especially important for students of both\nhumanities and technical universities), we will demonstrate and reveal, using\nLenin's works as examples, the beauty and harmony of the dialectical method in\nopposition to mechanistic, metaphysical, eclectic and scholastic ways of thinking.\nUltimately, what is important to know when studying various forms of reality:\nobject, process, phenomenon, etc.? It is essential to identify and track the logic,\nhistoricism, trend, patterns, direction (i.e., the contentful side) of the\ndevelopment of these forms of manifestation and existence of reality, for which it\nturns out to be absolutely necessary to observe how transformation\n(transmutation, conversion) of one form of reality into another takes place, and\nfurthermore, on this basis, try to forecast such transformations (transformations,\nconversions), anticipating not only the change of existing forms but also the\nemergence of new forms. This constitutes the subject matter of dialectics.\nUltimately, it comes down to studying the surrounding world (nature, man,\nsociety) from the position of content-form transformations, transmutations,\nconversions [2, 3, 7, 18].\n\n\fEvery serious researcher, embarking on research work, proceeds from the\npremise that reality (the surrounding world, nature) is always at least dual-sided\n(i.e., double-faceted). Any real specific object, process or phenomenon in its\nmost general abstract form represents a relation of two principles (sides,\nconstituents, components, \"opponents\" etc.): {content/form}. Consequently,\nany concrete form of reality (implying: object, process, phenomenon) is\ndetermined by the correlation of these noted sides-constituents-components\nwithin each of their specific relations. The development of forms of reality itself\nrepresents changes in the correlations of these constituent-components within\ntheir relations. In this connection it becomes obvious that forms of reality\ndefined by the aforementioned ratios can be either more or less Contentful (due\nto different shares of content and formal components in their relations). The\noverall trend of development and change of forms of reality — as human\nobservations throughout human history show — is such that during their (forms')\ndevelopment there occurs a shift in the ratio of components (in their relations)\ntowards the numerator of the relation (if we consider such a relation as a\nmathematical fraction), i.e., toward the Contentful component of the relation\n(meaning the fundamental orientation toward the general movementdevelopment of forms of reality in the direction of increasing\ntheir Contentfulness, and ultimately achieving ultimate highest Contentfulness)\n[5, 7]. This setting-orientation indicating the direction of variability of all forms is\ncalled the universal principle of self-development (self-organization) of reality,\nformulated as follows: the development of the content of forms of reality takes\nplace in the direction of exhaustive expression of developing content by the very\nsame developing content of these forms [3, 5, 7, 18].\nApplied to the surrounding world, this formulation means roughly the following:\neverything that exists and develops has the direction of its development and\nexistence expressed (i.e., encompassed, absorbed, assimilated, comprehended,\netc.) by itself existing and developing. As a visual example in this case, the\nimage of a \"self-winding\" three-dimensional spiral seems most appropriate [2,\n7]. And such an orientation or tendency of change-movement-development\nbelongs to all developing forms of reality without exception.\nFor greater illustrativeness of what was just said, note that with regard to such a\nlevel (area) of developing reality as, say, man and society, this universal\nprinciple drives forward not only positive (from the standpoint of human\nconsciousness) morally ethical and humanitarian aspirations of man but also\nnegative ones (again, in terms of human consciousness) — his thoughts,\nmotives, secret impulses and \"sinful\" inclinations — such as arrogance and\ncondescension, feelings of exclusivity and superiority over one's neighbour, envy\nand vanity, etc., etc., Everyone intends and strains to present himself and\nappear as the most significant, competent, respectable, successful, etc., in short\n— the most contentful, which is also determined and conditioned by the same\nuniversal objective striving of any forms for possession of the\nhighest contentfulness. After all, how sweet and tempting it is to participate in\nsome kind of political hangout and be considered in this world an influential\nperson — a disposer of human destinies!\n\n\fThus, in light of the dialectical concept of development presented here,\nobjective reality represents motion and succession of its forms in the direction\nof possessing the highest contentfulness (i.e., maximally achievable content),\nand all processes of development and cognition of reality should be studied and\nviewed through the prism of content-form transitions, transformations,\ntransmutations of unitary (i.e., strictly defined) directionality.\nA specifically directed variability of the abstract relation {content/form} is\nconditioned, on the one hand, by the unity and, on the other hand, non-identity\n(non-sameness) of its components, due to which both components are in a state\nof interaction and inexhaustible movement towards convergence with each other\nand acquisition of equilibrium (balance) or mutual expressibility by each other\n(which means: becoming maximally contentful for form and defining its perfect\nform for content). The presence in one integral relation of two components with\ndifferent types of activity generates a whirlwind, vortex, circulation, \"selfwinding\" spiral, i.e., a specific type of change (movement, development) of both\ncomponents of this relation and the relation as a whole.\nThe famous saying of Heraclitus about everything flowing and changing still left\nopen the question of where exactly everything flows and changes — clear ideas\nwere lacking until now. Only today does the opportunity arise to answer this\nquestion more or less sensibly; today we can meaningfully define the vector of\nthis universal movement: everywhere and always there is total multi-level\nmovement towards reaching the highest level of contentfulness; everything\nis pervaded by the striving and covered by movement towards possession of the\nhighest contentfulness. This universal movement vector determines causality,\nmeanings and goals: life, development, evolution, history, etc., i.e., the\nexistence of anything whatsoever, in whatever forms.\nThe algorithm of development — common and universal for all levels-forms of\nreality, from photon to the most elaborate conceptual schemes and constructions\nin individual minds: new content will always strive to acquire a new form, while\nforms seek to be filled, enriched with new content. Hence — a vortex-like motion\nof everything. By this conception, only the typical, standard character of the\ncourse and transformation of things at all levels is pointed out: the universal\ngeneralized relation {content/form} is embodied on each specific level in its own\nconcrete form and consistently \"proceeds\" through levels towards replacing\nrelations with increasingly more contentful ones.\nThe movement or striving to achieve the highest contentfulness (as a single\ngoal for all changing forms of reality) conditions the fiercest rivalry and\ncompetition between such moving and developing forms of reality. The inevitable\ncompetition and rivalry arising from this movement (movement toward a\ncommon finish line) manifests itself as confrontation, opposition and\ninteraction of real objects, processes and phenomena at different stages, in\ndifferent areas and at different levels of their existence-movement-development.\n\n\fIn geopolitics, this can be expressed by the confrontation and opposition of\ncomponents in such relations, say, as {West/East}, {metropolis/colony},\n{global/national};\nin\npolitics\nand\neconomics\n—\nin\nrelations\n{internationalism/nationalism}, {proletariat/bourgeoisie}, {wage labor/capital},\n{liberalism/conservatism}; at the biological object level — in relations\n{male/female}, {man/woman}, {masculine principle/feminine principle}, {right\nside of the body [of living organisms]/left side of the body [of living\norganisms]}; in physics — by relations {time/space}, {energy/mass},\n{wave/corpora},\n{negative\ncharge/positive\ncharge},\n{motion/rest},\n{acceleration/gravity}, etc., etc.\nBeing an entirely abstract construct, the relation {content/form} is\nfundamentally not manifestable in its most general form or image, but it\nnevertheless constitutes the core or very essence of any and every real concrete\nform (object, process, phenomenon, etc.).\nThe noted duality of constituents-components of real forms-relations with a very\nstrict and definite directionality of content-form transformations during the\ninteraction of these constituents-components explains the moment-to-moment\nuniqueness of the emerging world (Universe, nature, life, etc.) as a whole, as\nwell as the unique and unprecedented diversity of existing and nascent\nforms as individual elements of this world.\nThe abstract relation {content/form} with quite unequivocal directionality of\nchange-movement-development of its components or constituents, just like the\nentire relation as a whole, is something that exists originally, everywhere,\nobjectively and independently of any particular concreteness; it is what pervades\nall existing and emerging concrete forms-levels-relations of surrounding reality\ndue to its omnipresence. It is precisely the content-form transformations\ndescribed above (i.e., changes of components and their relations in a strictly\ndefined direction — towards achieving the highest contentfulness) that underlie\nthe development of forms of reality, which are themselves only a concrete\nembodiment and incarnation of the model presented above (i.e., the abstract\nrelation {content/form}). And it is exactly this initial model, owing to its\nfoundational and universality, that is most acceptable and effective for deep\nstudy, research and penetration into the essence of the surrounding world\n(developing reality) at the current stage of its development.\nThis investigative approach demonstrates its effectiveness through examples of\nsuccessful studies of issues that until recently were considered highly\nproblematic and \"tricky\" [5, 6].\nWhy do content-form relations suddenly come to the fore, become the core and\nsubject of examination and study of dialectics? Because the very fact and the\ncorresponding irrefutable assertion that there does not exist a single real object,\nprocess or phenomenon devoid of content and/or formal sides-constituents\ninevitably leads to the conclusion that content and form are those two\n\"principles\" (two main key components, constituents, \"opponents\", etc.) which,\n\n\finteracting (opposing and simultaneously complementing each other) within the\nunified integral relation {content/form}, create (\"generate\") and reproduce socalled objective reality, i.e., the entire surrounding world (including ourselves)\nwith all the diversity and uniqueness of its forms.\nAccording to the textbook definition, dialectics is \"the teaching about the most\ngeneral lawful connections and becoming, development of being and cognition,\nand the method of creatively cognizing thinking based on this teaching... The\nfundamental principles of dialectics, constituting its backbone, are universal\nconnection, becoming and development, which are conceptualized using the\nentire historically established system of categories and laws\" [15, p. 154].\nThe priority of the categories {content/form} over all others is obvious and\nconfirmed by the circumstance that in the foundation of all other categories and\nconcepts (just as of the actual objects, processes, phenomena of the physicalobjective level of reality denoted by these categories and concepts), one can\neasily discover ubiquitous content-form beginnings-constituents-components.\nIt goes without saying and is undeniable that no one will ever be able to\nencompass (i.e., comprehend) the entire volume of connections and the total\nsum of changes occurring in all elements of the surrounding world (starting from\nphotons, including the abyss of atoms, molecules, living cells, etc., and ending\nagain with bizarre ideas and fantasies in the heads of individual human\nindividuals), but grasping and covering the trend or patterns of such changes\nwith human thought (from the standpoint of human thought or consciousness\nitself) still turns out to be possible.\nHere is what Lenin writes on this matter in his book “Materialism and\nEmpiriocriticism”, referring to just a relatively small segment of reality — the\nglobal economy: \"Each separate producer in the world economy is aware that he\nintroduces a certain change in production technique, each owner is aware that\nhe exchanges some products for others, but these producers and owners do not\nrealize that they thereby alter social being. No 70 Marxs could have covered\nthe sum of all these changes in all their ramifications in capitalist world\neconomy. At best, the laws of these changes have been discovered, the main\nand basic objective logic of these changes and their historical development has\nbeen shown... From the fact that you live and manage your affairs, give birth to\nchildren and produce goods, exchange them, an objectively necessary chain of\nevents emerges, a chain of development independent of your public\nconsciousness, never fully comprehended by it. The highest task of\nhumanity is to grasp this objective logic of economic evolution\n(evolution of social being) in general and basic terms in order to adapt\none's public consciousness to it as clearly, distinctly and critically as\npossible...\" [11, pp. 317–318].\nThus, the \"objectively necessary chain of events\" (including an objectively\nnecessary change in forms of economic management) determines or sets the\ndirection of change-movement-development-improvement of forms of human\n\n\fpublic consciousness, generating a so-called algorithm for changing its\n(human consciousness) forms. The abstract forms of human consciousness\n(thought) arising or newly appearing in this connection grow out of more\nconcrete forms by transforming their content to a new level of reality while\npreserving continuity and compatibility of contents of both — i.e., abstract\nand\nconcrete\n—\nforms,\nwhich\nultimately\ntestifies\nto\nthe contentfulness (objective contentfulness or truthfulness) of the entire\nchain or set of interconnected forms (from concrete to abstract ones) [5].\nFrom the \"objective logic of evolution of social being\", there follow: both\n\"...the highest task of humanity — to grasp this objective logic of economic\nevolution (evolution of social being) in general and basic terms...\" (according\nto Lenin, see above); and, in a broader sense, the task to define and cognize\nthe direction of development of reality and, accordingly, the goals and\nmeanings of life and development of mankind as a contentful movement (and\nsuccession) of cognitive forms of reality towards possession of the\nhighest contentfulness. Solving this last problem implies providing human\nthought with increasingly exhaustive and all-embracing methods of\nprospective, predictive, prognostic, anticipatory cognition. Efforts should be\nconcentrated precisely in this direction — on cognition of patterns of change\nand emergence of forms of reality, on cognition of patterns of its (i.e.,\nreality's) content-form transformations. It is here that the ideological\njustification of the essence (and existence) of man lies; it is by this that the\nperspective of life and development of all mankind as a whole is determined.\nAnd who, if not us — direct heirs and successors of the legendary\nbearers of priority ideas of the Great October — should continue to\nembody this revolutionary ideology into practice, into life !!!\nWith the destruction and loss of the USSR, Russia lost the prospects of its\nfurther development previously outlined. Lenin and his comrades, being\ndeeply enlightened and educated people, clearly understood what the\nformulation of goals and perspectives of movement-development meant for\nan individual person and for a nation as a whole. Without formulating a goal\nand prospect of development perceived and approved by the people, no\ninitiatives, initiative, enthusiasm can exist on a \"mass scale\". To unite and\norganize the masses, public goals, directions and prospects of country\n(state, society) development must be formulated according to which a\nstrategy for achieving these goals and prospects is developed. Moreover,\ndefining a perspective should not boil down to an immediate reaction to\nexternal and internal so-called challenges and irritants but must be drawn up\ntaking into account long-term forecasts and strategic plans. Why did Lenin\nand his like-minded associates understand this? Because the quality of\nthose country's leaders was immeasurable compared to today's; they were\npeople of a high level of consciousness and, respectively, personalities of\nquite another scale.\nUnder the rule of today's voracious and insatiable \"locusts\", such \"trivialities\"\nare not mentioned. Furthermore, current \"rulers\", waving off public demands\nfor ideology, do not even understand what is expected from them. Thus,\n\n\fpatriotism has somehow migrated into the realm of ideology and is presented\nto citizens of the country as an ideological prospect, although any reasonably\neducated person should realize that patriotism is not an ideology but a\nfeeling instilled (or not instilled) in a person with mother's milk (and\npossibly already present in embryo at the genetic level), but requiring, as a\nrule, further cultivation and education. An idea, however, is something\ndifferent from a feeling; it is a product of a completely different level. An idea\nis, speaking figuratively, the light at the end of the tunnel for every\nenlightened mind. A developed person cannot imagine himself without an\nidea and ideology. Feelings, sensations, needs, interests, \"values\" (in the\nmeaning of this word used by the \"Western\" world) — these are all products\nof more \"down-to-earth\", though also more fundamental levels-components\nof the human \"I\", whereas an idea is a product of the highest of reliably\nknown today levels of the latter — the level of human consciousness\n(thinking).\nAn idea is based on feelings, continues them, but by no means reduces to\nthem or is exhausted by them. An idea ignites a person from within and\nguides him through life like a guiding star; but not everyone, only one\nprepared, ripened enough to perceive this idea. Hence: you may not be a\nbearer of an idea, but you must be a patriot! — without any ideology,\nsimply by right and by the feeling of one's belongingness and relatedness to\na great people.\nUndoubtedly, of course, once an idea arises, it begins to influence the feeling\nin turn, developing and enriching it, from which spirituality of the human\npersonality emerges, having the most direct connection with patriotism. But\nprimordially in this tandem is still the feeling.\nIf patriotism is mainly cultivated, then ideology, being a category of\nworldview, is formed on the basis of knowledge, i.e., through educational\nmeans. For example, the socialist idea, based on developed feelings of\njustice and patriotism, is already the beginning of a renewed ideology. Yesyes, renewed (emphasized specially for the current \"rulers\" and their ilk),\nbuilt with consideration of previous blunders and lack of information, natural\nfor the previous epoch. And there is no need to frighten the people or hope\nthat everything will end again in levelling and stagnation: a ship reaches its\ndestination not only and not so much because it was correctly oriented at the\nstart of the journey, but mainly because its course is periodically corrected,\nclarified, changed according to circumstances. Improvement of wage systems\nand procedures of accounting and control, as well as turnover and renewal of\npersonnel at all managerial levels from top to bottom — just as with the\nclassics, but clearer, meticulous, thorougher, more energetic than before —\nwill eventually produce the expected positive effect. Back then, there was no\ntime for details; all attention was focused on creating foundations. And now\nit's not easier, but with a solid foundation underfoot, it is still simpler to\ntimely determine the directions of relevant and vitally necessary changes.\n\n\fBesides, today's civil society is different — older, more responsible,\ndemanding, exacting...\nThe people are not against the socialist idea per se, but against its ossified forms\nand against party functionaries of the past and present (including those sitting in\nparliamentary factions and supposedly opposing power), who parasitize on this\nidea in its deadened, dogmatic form, who have not changed since the hour when\nthey betrayed this idea, burying Soviet power with its institutions (although the\norgans and structures of Soviet power needed to be improved and modified, as\nLenin himself always pointed out — in each of his articles one can see how\nflexible, optimistic and \"creative\" he was in his aspiration toward updating and\nperfecting the forms of the revolutionary movement).\nThe question or idea of building a renewed socialism meets the demand of\nsociety for a new ideology. At the same time, the course toward building a\nsocialist society and a socialist way of life is no longer an end in itself, but merely\none\nof\nthe\nmain\nconditions\nand\nmeans\nof\nensuring\nfurther contentful development of man and mankind as a whole.\nHowever, it would be more correct in this case to speak not about the\nenthronement of some kind of renewed socialism, but about the manifestation\nand formation of another stage of the socialist movement or about the\nembodiment of the developing socialist idea through yet another of its forms.\nThe absence of an ideological perspective \"vacuums\" human consciousness. At\nthe same time, reliance on the old tried-and-tested religious idea is fruitless,\nsince the latter slowly but surely fades away. Having played, without any\nexaggeration or doubt, a progressive role in its time, but unable to satisfactorily\nanswer the increasingly acute and problematic worldview questions of young\ninquisitive minds, archaic god-centered doctrine will lose its relevance and\nnaturally, without any violence over it, recede into the background, giving way to\nnew worldview concepts (similarly, say, as horse-drawn carriages are still\nencountered on our roads, but the bulk of transportation is carried out by\nmodern modes of transport). This trend is visible to the naked eye. Therefore,\ntoday's \"rulers\" should not beat around the bush. It's a pity for the youth: at the\nstate level, \"popovshchina\" is being pushed through instead of focusing on\nliteracy and education. With a balanced and effectively functioning system of\nupbringing and education, there will be no loss of spirituality accompanying\nthe alleged decline of religion. Where does this categorical nonsense come from\n— that morality, ethics, humanism are allegedly always conditioned by a\nreligious idea? The aforementioned categories and notions (from which the\nspiritual and moral bonds and guidelines of many human communities are\n\"woven\") arose and took root in human life as the transformation and\nimprovement of forms-levels of human consciousness proceeded during man's\ndevelopment; one might think that Prince Svyatoslav, being a pagan, followed\nthe moral instructions of god Yahweh (Jehovah, YHWH, etc., depending on\nreading) when he uttered his immortal: \"Idu na vy\" [\"I go upon you\"] or\n\"Mertvye sramu ne imut\" [\"The dead know no shame\"], — all this came from the\n\n\fdeep nature of man, from his contentful constituent, acquired through\nhistorically changing forms of human consciousness in the multi-layered, multilevel structure of man: both in the form of \"spirit\", and in the form of \"soul\", and\nin its later complex form — the human personality.\nTo obsequiously cross oneself, relying on the supreme deity, requires little\nintelligence. It is certainly easier than taking full responsibility for the destinies of\nthe country and mankind solely on the strength of one's own abilities and\npossibilities. For an individual preferring to dwell on platforms of religious\nconcepts, the issue of responsibility is predetermined: fate and prospect will\nultimately be decided for him by god with his prophets. There seems to be no\ndilemma worth a cracked egg: choose whomever you like — believe and rely on\nthe omnipresent \"uncle\" or don't believe and rely on yourself. Nevertheless,\nfinding oneself suddenly, even in shallow water, none of the believers stops\nstruggling and fighting the wave, although, following their own logic, they could\nfully depend on the almighty supreme saviour... Any \"ruler\" should first learn,\nbesides parish school, proper teaching of natural science (natural-scientific\ndisciplines) in a Soviet university and not skip classes. Such a proven profile of\nthe educational process undoubtedly contributed to acquiring a correct worldview\norientation adequate to the level of cognition of developing reality achieved by\nhuman civilization. It is sometimes awkward to observe and listen to grown-up\n\"underdevelopeds\" with several (by their own words) \"completed prestigious\nhigher educations\" discussing with a thoughtful air on some political-economic\nshow or forum about \"good and all good\" in the guise of Christ or universal \"evil\nand all bad\" in the image of the devil. The advice in this case can only be: study\nLenin's lessons of dialectics, miserable C students!\nHowever, for a more or less adequate understanding of the substance of multilevel reality, initially one should firmly grasp only one thing: EVERYTHING\nTHAT exerts any influence on our level of reality (i.e., the level of human\nconsciousness) and tries to correct (interfere with) our lives, claiming the status\nof Absolute, ITSELF occupies a subordinate position and is represented by\nequally imperfect and non-absolute form, likewise dependent on influences\n(impact) of forms of all other levels of reality. Absolute is impossible in\nprinciple! — and development of reality, never ceasing for a moment, continues\nas the movement of the contentful component beyond the limits of its forms\nceaselessly and infinitely. As Absolute, human consciousness takes simple\naggregate of forms of various kinds (including those accessible only to\nsubjective imagination) levels of reality.\nOrienting on a model of reality's development based on representations\nof content-form transformations proceeding in the known direction, one clearly\nand unequivocally understands that man with his consciousness is not exhausted\nby subject-sensory-thought formation (i.e., three-dimensional physical-material\nlevel-form of existence in time and space of his flesh), but \"extends\" beyond the\nobvious boundaries of his bodily confines. The very process of development, the\nvery developing multi-level reality (as motion and succession of forms of this\nreality) is even more inexhaustible and unlimited by the reached level-form of\n\n\fman\nand\nmankind.\nHowever,\nin\nwhat\ntransformed\nform\nthe\nsubsequent contentful movement continues with transition to the next (next\nafter man) level of reality remains to be researched and studied. Still, even\ntoday we can say quite definitely regarding this matter that the form of clothing\nof the contentful principle on that next level of reality's movement differs in\nincreased informative or energy (i.e., contentful) \"capacity\" and \"capability\"\ncompared with preceding forms-levels, and therefore it is even more abstract\nthan the preceding forms-levels.\n[When moving to the next level of contentfulness of forms (to the next level of\ndevelopment of reality), importance for any individual, as a certain correlation of\ncomponents in the relation {content/form}, will have only what — with what\nintellectual-spiritual\n(contentful)\ndevelopments\nthe\ntransformational contentful constituent (principle) of this individual transforms\nonto that level. Since that next level is \"abstracted\" (abstract, abstracted) to a\nsignificantly greater degree than the preceding ones, it goes without saying that\nneither yachts nor mansions with Mercedes cars can be dragged along there.\nWhat matters will be the accumulated during the \"earthly\" cycle spiritualintellectual potential and experience of dealing with abstraction, whereas yachts\nand Mercedes cars — as well as all other material tools — are merely auxiliary\nauxiliary means expanding the framework of formal framing of the\ndeveloping contentful constituent for further disclosure (development) and\nmultiplication of this very potential. Hence, it is important to properly dispose of\nthese means during the period of \"earthly\" life. This explanation is addressed\nprimarily to those who want to see further than the tip of their nose. Ultimately,\nthe ability to identify, generate and use ideally abstract forms of a new level,\nmaximally filled with objective content, i.e., true forms (see article \"Universal\nCriterion of Truth\" in this collection)].\nEgo-centric and poly-centric models (pictures) of the world (including: theo-,\nsocio-, anthropo-centric models) are receding into the past. They are being\nreplaced by a concept of a single universal internal principle of selfdevelopment: all forms-structures of reality change and develop under the\nmanagement (i.e., under the auspices) of a universal \"mechanism\", algorithm,\ninner principle immanent to all form-structures of reality regardless of their level,\nstage (place and time) of development. This is a model (concept) of contentform transformations in the direction of achieving the highest contentfulness by\nany and every developing form of reality. To understand and anticipate the\nchange and development of real forms, to look as far ahead as possible \"around\nthe corner\", \"beyond the horizon\" — this is the main task that will stand before\nman and which man will be forced to solve quite consciously (thoughtfully) both\nin the near and distant future for the sake of preserving himself as a species and\nsurviving in competitive struggle with other forms-levels of reality. Without\nawareness of this circumstance, man will not be able to fully confront so-called\nchallenges from nature (the surrounding world).\nHumanity is painfully parting with the aforementioned models, theories and\npictures of the past; hence there is a new energetic surge of religious, ethnic,\n\n\fnational, racial, civilizational and other similar conflicts and wars. A worldview\ncrisis of faiths, ideologies, all kinds of \"values\", priorities and exclusivities (the\nnotions of exclusivity and absolute form lose their former significance and\ninformational value, receding into the background and making room for concepts\nof equal uniqueness and irreplaceability of forms) gives way to another\nworldview model [2, 3, 5, 7, 18]. Previous orthodox preferences require\nclarification, supplementation and replacement by new more contentful models\nand forms.\nHowever, the task of finding balance and correct correlation between interacting\nconstituents in the relation {content/form} at present and identifying the trend\nof change of this balance — for the future — remains as relevant as ever. In\naccordance with the universal principle of self-development (see above), multilevel change, movement, development of forms takes place (in contrast to the\nprinciple and mechanism of \"functioning\" of various centeric models) by \"piling\nup\" (i.e., developing) their content, \"making from oneself\". With the emergence\nand establishment of a new concept of the development of the surrounding\nworld (replacing losing meaning and strength God-centered theories), inevitable\nearlier wars and rivalry of religious ideologies will recede into the past.\nWhat was the contentfulness of that supposedly over-ideologized Soviet era?\nWhat inspired, motivated the Soviet person to move forward?\nThe romance of everyday life was built on the dictate of the heart, energy of\nimpulse, fascination with breaking through to the new and unknown; proceeding\nfrom the need of the soul, man was ready to discover what had not been\ndiscovered, comprehend what had not been comprehended, conquer nature,\nspace, taiga, virgin lands, peaceful atom, etc., etc. It was about unleashing and\nliberating man's inner forces and creative energy in the process of constructive\nlabor for the sake of achieving common goals and ideals (including well-being,\nbut by no means in its hypertrophied phase clothed in the guise of the golden\ncalf with prosaic accumulations). By refusing the elevated approach to setting,\nformulating and achieving socially demanded ambitious goals, we \"throw out the\nbaby with the bathwater\".\nFrom the very first days of Bolshevik Soviet power, the issues of actualizing\n(awakening) the energy of impulse, enthusiasm and initiative of the masses\narose in full force. The solution of both highly complex and simple everyday\nproblems implied and required not only routine strain of physical effort but also\nactivation of cognitive aspirations of man, inciting him to satisfy his innate\nhuman curiosity. One should primarily learn contentful thinking from Lenin. Lenin\nfully realized that human efforts ultimately aim to forecast, anticipate, predict\nwith increasing accuracy the perspective of development of real events, build\nsound plans and correctly set priorities in their implementation, which meant —\nlearning to look further and more successfully \"beyond the corner\", \"beyond the\nhorizon\" (i.e., looking into the future).\n\n\fTwo paths are known and possible for increasing, accumulating and multiplying\nthe own contentfulness (volume or fullness of content of one's own form):\n1. Appropriation of someone else's content (\"foreign\" volumes, accumulations\nof content belonging to other forms); as a particular case of this variant —\nsimple destruction (destruction, liquidation, neutralization) of an \"adversarial\"\nform that impedes or hinders the movement-development and enrichment of\ncontent of one's own form.\n2. Cooperation (symbiosis) with other forms and joint accumulation, increase of\ncontent of each of the interacting and cooperating forms.\nNeedless to say, combinations of these two variants are significant.\nApplied to the development of human communities, the essence of one and the\nother path boils down to the following.\nThe first path is the path of war, violence, coercion, applied, for example (at the\nlevel of states and peoples), by metropolises toward their colonies (subjugation\nby metropolises of the will, appropriation of natural resources and fruits of labour\nof colonial peoples and nations). To date, humanity has mastered and refined\nprecisely this path.\nThe second path, the socialist path of development with indispensable attributes\nof cooperation among people and achievement of goals jointly, is still in\nembryonic state; it was exactly this method of socialist construction and creation\nof a new type of public order on a mass scale that V.I. Lenin advocated.\nIt is well-known (and confirmed beyond doubt by processes taking place during\nthe not-so-distant times of the breakup of the USSR) that initial capital\naccumulation proceeds, as a rule, by violent and fraudulent means — by\nappropriation and seizure.\nWe have all witnessed how the redistribution of public and state property,\ncapitals and assets took place in post-perestroika Russia and other republics of\nthe USSR that suddenly became \"independent\". This was a path of deceit,\nswindling, gangster feuds, mockery of privatization coupons and pledge auctions.\nThe methods of executing this grand-scale fraud were, without any\nexaggeration, predatory, and they relate entirely to the first path (variant) of\nincreasing contentfulness (i.e., enrichment) of the most active individual\nreformers (young and not so young).\nUndoubtedly, reverse expropriation of property and assets acquired in such a\nmanner also implies, to some extent, responsive violence at the initial stage of\nbuilding socialism. The retaliatory move is inevitably connected with\nredistribution of once criminally appropriated or wrongly amassed \"bourgeois\"\nproperty and financial assets, but this procedure is carried out in the interests of\nthe overwhelming majority of working population (citizens of the country) and\nfor the sake of restoring historical justice.\n\n\fAs regards the legality of expropriation of property and capitals during times of\nsocialist revolutions, the procedure is performed, as already mentioned, in the\ninterests of the vast majority and is single-time (within a limited-short\ntimeframe); and whoever thinks that such procedures can be dispensed with at\nperiodic revolutionary iterations is deeply mistaken or simply ill-informed\nregarding the inevitability of substantial transformation of current\nfoundations into the configuration of future public and governmental structure.\nThis stage is necessary, in particular, for redistributing initial capital in the\ninterests of the majority of the population in order to create normal starting\nconditions (positions) for ordinary workers and to restore a justified balance with\nthe positions of aggressively pushy and shameless (for the most part) minority\nthat once usurped assets not belonging to them.\nYes, development proceeds, and history is written \"by tacks\", zigzags — every\ntime returning to itself at a new level by segments of spiral turns that never fully\nline up and are never perfectly finished. Such is the external appearance and\ncharacter of the dialectical mode of development of anything whatsoever.\nSomewhere again forced measures of expropriation will be needed, because\notherwise it just won't work: nobody ever voluntarily surrenders what was\ngained in the sweat of others' brows and appropriated in the sweat of\none's own brow. One must be quite naive and unschooled in practical life not\nto understand this.\nIn contrast to the first path, implementing the second option for increasing\nthe contentfulness of real forms of public order means immersion into\nsocialism, toward which man is increasingly pushed by emerging\ncircumstances regardless of his consciousness; and we will have to revive\nand continue this path whether we like it or not because\nfurther contentful development of mankind outside of this path is\nunprofitable, suboptimal, inefficient, \"dead-end\" and therefore unlikely. And\ndeeper study of socialist theory will be required. And again, one will have to\nacknowledge the fairness and scientific nature of Marx's approach applied in\nworking out social and economic theories (otherwise, gentlemen courtiersapologists of today's socio-economic foundations, you will simply lose your\ntarget \"fan\" audiences and, as a consequence, your piece of bread; then\nthere will come time to laugh good-naturedly at those who arrogantly\nmocked the orthodoxy of Marxism and indulged in primitivism of scientific\ncommunism — well, sirs, he laughs best who laughs last).\nFollowing Lenin's methods and research tools, we can state today that thanks\nto applying the dialectical approach or method of cognition, much of what is\ncalled world order becomes clearer than before. At the same time, the stillrelevant task does not diminish but rather stands out even more clearly: to\nkeep learning how to see the future picture more accurately (i.e., learn to\nlook ahead \"around the corner\" with ever greater efficiency) so as to\nunderstand ourselves and surrounding reality better.\n\n\fSolving this problem is identical to solving the eternal issue of finding\nmeaning in life for every individual person, which (solution), in its first\napproximation, takes on the following form: everything existing moves in a\nsingle direction towards expressing objective truth in its most contentful,\nultimate\nform\n— i.e.,\na\nform\nendowed\nwith\nthe\nhighest\n(objective) contentfulness or the form of so-called \"absolute\" truth. This path\nundoubtedly belongs not only to any separate individual but also to whole\npeoples and states. Knowing this, we must and should lead this movement\n(process) since we are currently the best informed about it and understand it\nbest. Following the course towards achieving the highest contentfulness by\nforms of developing reality (including humanity) is also a movement towards\neffective resolution of the perennially troubling human question regarding the\npossibility of cognizing and cognition of objective truth.\nWhat is life, motion, development, progress, etc., in general terms is already\nunderstood: it is a process of contentful filling of forms while striving for\nthem (at all levels without exception) to possess the highest\n(objective) contentfulness. It is a process of \"unleashing\" the inner content of\nreality and presenting it outwardly in the most contentful form possible at\nany given moment, approaching each time the form of exhaustive expression\nof objective truth. With small acts of subjective human movements (whether\nachievements in painting, literature, music, sports, science, etc.) humankind\napproaches closer to the fullest expression of the objective content of\ndeveloping reality (expression of objective truth) with each such\nelementary act. Every sound, every note produced by a skilled musician or\ncomposer seeks to bring to light and reveal to the world objective truth —\ni.e., the most contentful form of representation of reality at that particular\nmoment (from the viewpoint of the maestro). The same applies to poetic\nword or brushstroke on an artist's canvas, let alone the contentful theories\nand concepts of a scientist. From the most contentful subjective\nopinions and views on the world, objective truth is formed [5].\nBut understanding and awareness of the general trend of real processes by\nno means exhausts the solution of all current issues: the crucial and essential\nquestion for man remains open forever — the question of anticipating,\nforeseeing, preempting, predicting with maximum accuracy and certainty\nchanges (variability) of existing forms of reality and emergence (appearance)\nof new ones, and taking into account this circumstance — the question of\nplanning subsequent human activity. Well, and since man by his very\nnature and place in the chain of development is a highly active linkcomponent (in other words — subject of activity), he inevitably interferes\nwith the development of reality and embodies thereby his own vision,\nunderstanding and \"plans\", impacting the surrounding world and changing it\nin the direction required by him (strictly in accordance with the\naforementioned universal principle of self-development).\nDespite our ability to define the meaning of life and existence both for man\nand his entire environment today (see above), the matter still lies in learning\n\n\fto anticipate the change of existing forms of reality and the appearance of\nnew ones, in order to predict events and developments as precisely as\npossible, to learn to peer deeper into the future — and not just to satisfy\nimmediate curiosity, but mainly to survey and outline distant prospects.\nDevelopment is the succession of forms of reality aimed at creating and\nestablishing forms filled with higher objective content. All ongoing processes\nin the surrounding world are \"targeted\" at enhancing the contentfulness of\nexisting forms representing changing reality. In this lies the essence of the\norientation of transformation of nature in the universal cosmic dimension.\nThe search for, acquisition, comprehension of truth, i.e., discovering the\nmost contentful forms of representation or acquiring developing objective\ncontent, permeates all of nature — from living thinking beings (with their\nspecific subforms in the guise of ideal abstract constructs of thought) to an\ninanimate stone-boulder, and any molecule, atom, electron, photon\n(quantum) within this stone or beyond it. And no empty speculations on this\nscore, embodying former \"highbrow\" (sophistical, demagogic, speculative,\nscholastic, etc.) philosophy, are probably needed anymore, since they turn\nout to be low-contentful and therefore fruitless. Philosophy gradually changes\nits status and role, turning from a habitual tool of passively descriptive and\nexplanatory type into an instrument of actively prognostic, predictive and\ntransformative character. Its speculative nature, conditioned by centuries-old\nintrigues or games of idle human mind, finally turns itself into an\nuninteresting useless \"thingie\", a whimsically intricate relic of the past.\nDialectics comes forward as the core and embodiment of a new, deeper\nphilosophy, as the art of generating and bringing to life correct forecasts and\nplanned transformations conceived by man. And here our updated philosophy\nmeets its inevitable merger and fusion with science, as was excessively\ndiscussed throughout the 20th century.\nSummarizing the above in two words, we have every reason to draw the\nfollowing conclusion: to learn to understand and know how to see the\nperspective of development of reality, i.e., the perspective\n(orientation) of change of its (reality's) existing forms and\nemergence (appearance) of new ones, and on this basis plan\nsubsequent human activity — this is the main task facing the man of the\nfuture, worthy of investing any resources for its gradual step-by-step\nresolution.\nThe socialist idea is closest, most responsive to the very spirit of the Russian\nperson, whose essence since time immemorial has been considered an\ninexhaustible craving (aspiration) for justice. Truly popular can only be the\npower that professes exactly this idea; when a working person can feel with\nevery cell of his that this is his native people's power — then he will defend it,\nand cherish it, and nurture it, and improve the institutions of power, and invest\nwith enthusiasm his strength and energy into \"arranging\" life. But if we have\ngiven the land, its subsoil, national wealth and means of production into the\n\n\fhands of \"scoundrels\", allowed them to fence themselves off from the people\nwith high fences and armed security regarding all this primordially people's\nproperty — then where can unity for the sake of a common goal come from —\nno matter how you \"blur\" the eyes of your fellow citizens with pharisaic slogans\nabout the supposedly \"national property\".\nThe craving for justice inherent in every Russian person and, as a derivative of\nthis property of the soul, the aspiration to save one's neighbor are conditioned\nby his natural inclination to search for and find balance (equilibrium) both inside\nand on the outer contour of society in opposition to encroachments (aggression)\non freedom and dignity both at the level of an individual person and at the level\nof human communities.\nThe social orientation of the state or public structure in this case should be\ndetermined by the officially proclaimed policy of the state, not by charity,\nassistance, petty handouts, voluntary donations or patronage timidly pushed\nthrough from time to time and on the sly. Of course, a state of this type must be\nbuilt on principles other than the existing ones.\nIt is necessary to return to the working person the feeling of involvement in a\ngreat cause, a great people, a great country with its innumerable natural\nresources and national wealth; return the feeling of involvement in a great\ncommon goal, most effectively approached by joint efforts using socialized\nmeans of production. When there is such a feeling, which in turn revives and\nnourishes feelings of human pride and dignity, — then a person is ready to give\nhimself entirely to the common cause, which inevitably becomes the personal\ncause of everyone. We must return to our people the lost sense of selfworth inherent in the Soviet man.\nDoes the first tentative approach to mastering the socialist idea mean the\ncomplete collapse of Marxism, Leninism, theories of socialism and scientific\ncommunism, etc., as primitive and short-sighted politicians, political scientists,\nphilosophers, economists believe? Of course not! Humanity will return to such\nfundamental currents and theories more than once, approaching them in a\nspiral-cyclical way (or by successive approximations) — in full accordance with\nthe nature and character of the content-form (dialectical) movementdevelopment of reality — to an increasingly exhaustive version of their\nimplementation. And something here suggests that the point of view of the wise\nclassics of Marxism is not devoid of grounds and will, in the end, prevail in the\nstructure of searching for the optimal path of mankind's development, since it\nmost fully corresponds to the inner content of man, his mood, oriented towards\npreserving human identity, culture, traditions, dignity (accordingly to genetic\npredisposition, genetic matrix, genetic code and the so-called call of ancestors\nand blood). According to the formulation of the principle of self-development,\neverything existing and developing periodically returns \"to its own circle\", but in\nother, more contentful and enriched forms.\n\n\fDialectics is the art of finding balance of interacting sides, which (art) Lenin\npossessed impeccably and perfectly. For Lenin — it is always a result-oriented\nsearch for the optimal correlation between the most essential sides-constituentscomponents of development (in their relation): in the range, for example, from\nde-kulakization and surplus-appropriation to the introduction of a food tax and\nNEP, or from asserting total collective ownership of the means of production to\nestablishing and recognizing as relevant a mode of production with elements of\nprivate property, etc. In this regard, first of all, his ability to find and highlight\nthe most essential sides-constituents of reality, being in direct interaction and\nrelation to each other (i.e., in live confrontation and opposition) precisely at this\nparticular segment of their development, and already on this basis — to\ndemonstrate the ability to forecast the trend of change in the correlation of\nidentified sides, and along with this — to anticipate the further course and\nperspective of development of the entire relation as a whole. And it looks\nabsolutely fantastic to be able to identify sources of renewal (inflow, increase,\nreceipt) of Contentful energy in pairs of interacting components and further — to\nanticipate and track the bias of content-form transformations (transmutations) of\nthese components and their relations as a whole.\nIt is on considering issues similar to those touched upon above that we will\nfocus, studying and analyzing the works of V.I. Lenin from the standpoint of their\nbeing imbued with the spirit of dialectics.\nAny article or work of Lenin is a dynamic creation, structured according to a\nuniversal scheme corresponding to the dialectical nature of the development of\nreality itself (i.e., according to the scheme of tracking the change-movement of\ninteracting forms towards achieving their highest contentfulness): the variability\nof the correlation of two interacting sides-components in their relation is\ninvestigated with subsequent forecasting of the development of the result of this\ninteraction towards (into the area) of predominant increase in\nthe contentfulness of the active component and the relation as a whole.\nCompositionally and structurally it looks something like this.\no\n\no\n\no\no\n\nDescription and analysis of the current situation, i.e., description of the\nset and alignment of interacting forces-factors-constituents-components\n(regardless of whether it concerns the reorganization of the Rabkrin, the\nsituation at the front, the organization of socialist competition, etc., etc.).\nIdentification of directly interacting forces-factors-constituentscomponents and their \"combination\" into the main relation (at this step, the\nseparation of the essential from the non-essential is actually performed).\nIdentification and highlighting of the active (leading) and passive\n(driven) components within the established relation.\nAssessment of the established correlation of the mentioned components\nin the relation composed of them and determination of the vector (orientation) of\nprobable change-movement-development of both individual components and the\nintegral relation.\n\n\fo\n\nForecasting of event development: on the basis of the assessment\nmade, the change of existing forms and the emergence (appearance) of new\nforms of reality is anticipated (predicted).\nThus, every time after analyzing the established state of affairs and alignment of\nforces, Lenin determines, firstly, with specific further steps towards achieving\nimmediate goals and, secondly, with an assessment of the strategic perspective\nof the development of the situation as a whole.\nThat is why each such article turns out to be not just a beautiful dialectical twist\n(decorative icon), but a guide to action; each of his articles contains a\ndescription of a way out of the current situation and a transition (possibly with a\nleap) to a new turn-level of development of interacting elements, and in each\narticle without exception the author offers his original and effective solution to\nthe problem under consideration.\nAll of Lenin's forecasts are made on the basis of correctly composed relations\nfrom interacting sides-components of reality and also based on anticipating the\ntrend or orientation of subsequent contentful filling of these relations. At the\nsame time, the more accurately the sides-components directly opposing,\nconfronting and interacting with each other are identified, the more correct and\nreliable the predictions of further development of events and situations turn out\nto be.\nOf course, conditions, circumstances and forms interacting in the present differ\nfrom those of the past, but the principle (algorithm, \"mechanism\") determining\nthe development of reality is invariant over time; that is why the proposed\nscheme or methodology of effective research into the surrounding world\nresembles the one presented above.\nBelow we will analyze all this using examples of well-known theoretical works by\nV.I. Lenin relating to three different periods of his life: pre-revolutionary,\nimmediate pre-revolutionary and post-revolutionary.\n[We should only additionally note that square brackets scattered throughout the\ntext contain references to literary sources (as is usually done), as well as notes,\nexplanations and comments (including comments on comments) by the author\nof this article].\n§ 1. Works of the pre-revolutionary period\nWe will examine the dialectical background of Lenin's works from the prerevolutionary period (which began a dozen and a half years before the Great\nOctober Socialist Revolution) using such Leninist works as “What Is to Be\nDone?”, “One Step Forward, Two Steps Back”, “The Beginning of the Revolution\nin Russia”, “Marxism and Revisionism” and “On the Road”, united by a single\ninternal logic and canvas of corresponding historical events.\n1. In his book “What Is to Be Done? Burning Questions of Our Movement” [8,\npp. 80–236], published in March 1902, Lenin presented an overview of the initial\nstage of the revolutionary movement in Russia. The book was written during the\n\n\facute struggle for the creation of a revolutionary Marxist party of the Russian\nworking class and played an outstanding role in the formation of the party.\nIn this work, Lenin identifies three stages and accordingly — three periods in the\ndevelopment of the revolutionary movement in Russia.\nHe describes the first stage of 1884–1894 as the embryonic development of\nsocial democracy carried out separately from the labor movement.\nRegarding the second stage of 1894–1898: \"social-democracy appears on earth\nas a public movement, as an upsurge of popular masses, as a political party\" [8,\np. 227]. Alongside and instead of \"going into the people\", there began a flow of\nintelligentsia toward workers (as the most active force-component of the future\nrevolutionary movement) and widespread fascination among workers with\nstrikes. However, this same strike struggle for the sake of increasing its own\nefficiency forced them to learn, read illegal literature, as well as diligently engage\nwith issues of legal populism without forgetting at the same time about Marxist\ntheory and the task of overthrowing autocracy. \"The establishment of the party\nin the spring of 1898 was the most vivid and at the same time last act of the\nSocial Democrats of this stripe\" [8, p. 228].\nThe third stage finally replaces the second one starting in 1898. It is a period of\nconfusion, vacillation, disintegration. The leaders of the movement were afraid to\nmove forward (to political struggle), yielding to the strength of the spontaneous\nupsurge of the popular masses. The slogan \"class struggle\" did not push towards\never broader, more energetic activity but served as a means of appeasement:\nafter all, everyone knows that \"economic struggle is inextricably linked with\npolitical\". The idea of the party did not serve as a call to create a combat\norganization of revolutionaries but justified some kind of \"revolutionary\nbureaucracy\", childish playing with \"democratic\" forms. And here, in this\nconnection, the author, like a true scholar drawing conclusions only based on\nfacts (without fabrications or fantasies), having difficulty saying when the third\nstage will end and the fourth begin, nevertheless expresses firm confidence that\nthe fourth stage will lead to strengthening militant Marxism; that the rear-guard\nof conciliators and deserters will be replaced by the actual vanguard of the most\nrevolutionary class (proletariat), which will manage to overcome uncertainty,\nhesitation and lack of confidence in their own forces. And then (in terms of\ncalling for such a change and summarizing what has been said), it becomes\npossible to give a concise and exhaustive answer to the question \"what is to be\ndone?\" — liquidate the third stage (period of confusion, vacillations, hesitations\nand lack of confidence in one's own forces) [8, p. 229].\n[Thus, Lenin outlined here the objectively occurring successive replacement of\nstages (forms) of substantive revolutionary movement expressed qualitatively\nand quantitatively through changes in the correlation between the contentful and\nformal components in the known relation {proletariat/bourgeoisie}. The\ncorrelation of components (within the specified relation) changes with the growth\nin share and importance of the active revolutionary component (proletariat) due\n\n\fto increased contentfulness conditioned by the influence of the following\naccompanying factors: emergence of social democracy => becoming established\nof social democracy => unification of social democratic formations on the basis\nof the idea of creating a Marxist proletarian party => establishment of the\nBolshevik Party of the Russian working class as its most revolutionary vanguard.\nThis entire chain of transforming factors directly affected the numerator of the\naforementioned relation (i.e., the \"proletariat\" component), raising\nits contentfulness within the whole relation.\nIn other words, Vladimir Ilyich, with impartiality of a scientist, stated that for the\nperiod from 1884 to 1898 and further (later) there took place and continues\nobjective\nmovement\n(transformation,\ntransmutation)\nof\nthe contentful component of the mentioned relation towards increasing\nits contentfulness while simultaneously upsetting equilibrium in the relation\n{proletariat/bourgeoisie} in favor of strengthening and predominance of\ninfluence of more contentful active proletarian forms of movement over more\nconservative bourgeois ones. An innate ability and predisposition for dialectical\nthinking allowed Vladimir Ilyich to break down step-by-step the phase-wise and\nperiodic nature of the revolutionary struggle, identify the active and passive\nforces-components of the revolutionary movement in Russia of that time, trace\ntheir genesis and determine measures to activate and strengthen\nthe contentful proletarian component (which meant overcoming uncertainty,\nhesitation and lack of confidence inherent in socialist-democratic circles and\norganizations \"nourishing\" the contentfulness of the \"proletariat\" component).\nThere is also a source of replenishment of the contentfulness of the \"proletariat\"\ncomponent, which at that time consisted of the educational standard of the\nbourgeois intelligentsia].\n2. The continuation of the struggle for cleansing the revolutionary movement\nand its vanguard (the Marxist party) from its wavering members (random\nelements) is described very vividly by Lenin in the book “One Step Forward,\nTwo Steps Back (Crisis in Our Party)” [8, pp. 237–421]. The book resulted\nfrom Lenin's thorough study and analysis of numerous protocols of meetings and\nresolutions of the II Congress of the RSDLP and was released in May 1904. In\nthis work, Vladimir Ilyich shows how something big, main and essential\neventually emerges and takes shape from small things (seemingly insignificant\nmatters, squabbles, disputes, discussions and quarrels serving as signs of fierce\nclash of opinions and different points of view). The art of a great dialectician\nmanifested itself in this case in recognizing this essential thing — the role and\nsignificance of organizational issues in the process of forming the core of the\nrevolutionary movement (i.e., the Bolshevik Party), as well as timely\ndemarcation from conciliators and wavering elements regarding principal\nquestions, attracting to one's side by polemic and persuasion the majority of\npotential sympathizers. As a result of this struggle, the idea emerged of\nestablishing and organizing a monolithic nucleus of the labor movement — the\nBolshevik Party — in opposition to amateurishness and circle-mindedness\ncharacteristic of the social-democratic movement. Without consolidation around\na single center, without subordination to decisions of this center (that is, without\n\n\firon discipline), the future conquests of the Great October would have simply\nbeen unthinkable and impossible. Precisely from the standpoint of the dialectical\napproach (from beginning to end), Lenin conducts his painstaking analysis of the\naccompanying events of this struggle. For the proletariat (and any public\nassociation alike) there is no other weapon in the struggle for power\nexcept organization (organized effort) — writes Lenin. The proletariat can\nbecome an invincible force only because the ideological unity of its theoretical\nprinciples (first of all, Marxist theory) is secured by material unity of organization\nuniting millions of workers into a single army (of the working class). Before this\narmy, the decrepit power of international capital will not stand. This army will\ndraw closer and tighter ranks despite any zigzags and steps backward [8, p.\n413].\nIn the course of detailed study of the background of this issue, Lenin draws\nattention to the fact that every development indeed proceeds along a dialectical\npath of resolving emerging contradictions: minority becomes majority, majority\nbecomes minority, each side moves from defense to attack and from attack to\ndefense; the original point of ideological struggle is \"negated\", but then begins\n\"negation of negation\" and the struggling sides return to the original point of\npurely ideological struggle, but now this \"thesis\" is enriched by all the results of\nthe \"antithesis\" and turns into a higher \"synthesis\"; when an isolated random\nerror has grown into a quasi-system of conciliatory views on the organizational\nissue, and the erroneousness of such an approach becomes increasingly\napparent. \"In short, not only oats grow according to Hegel, but Russian socialdemocrats fight among themselves too according to Hegel,\" concludes Vladimir\nIlyich [8, p. 410].\n[It is extremely important to note that the dialectical character of formulating\nvarious conclusions and findings through \"piling up\" and layering of minor\nquestions and discussion results upon each other or through \"returning to\noneself at a new level\" is recorded by the author as self-evident.\nOf course, for us living today, concepts and terms like \"proletariat\",\n\"bourgeoisie\", \"classes\", \"class struggle\", etc., seem antiquated and exotic. At\nthe same time, forgetting the terminology of the past does not mean liberation\nfrom the elements of developing reality denoted by it. After all, the class\nstructure of society still persists, whatever anyone says: on the one hand —\nhired labor, on the other — financial-industrial capital (generally speaking,\n\"oligarchy\"). And only the most shameless liar risks claiming that everything in\nsuch a public arrangement is \"even\". That is why the meaning of the phrase\n\"class struggle\" nowadays differs little from the content of this terminology in the\nexamined pre-revolutionary times, and the concept of \"class struggle\" is unlikely\nto disappear until the notion of \"classes\" fades away. Therefore, even today it\nremains important (and perhaps even more so) to be able to find interacting\ncomponents (competing, conflicting, confronting sides) and correctly compose\nrelevant content-form relations (of the type {content/form}) in order to properly\ndefine directions of variability both of the components themselves and of their\nrelations as a whole (i.e., of social systems and structures), distinguish and\n\n\fseparate the essential from the secondary (less significant) and thereby predict\nchanges in existing forms and the appearance of new ones. All this, undoubtedly,\nmay assist in devising the most effective forms of class struggle, etc. Applying to\ntoday's situation, the terms in the relation {proletariat/bourgeoisie} can be\nreplaced by terms: {hired labor/capital}, {class of non-propertied/class of\nowners of means of production}, etc., without loss of meaning. Our current\ncapitalists and bourgeois are \"blown-up\", random, staged characters whose state\nand public property on the means of production fell into their private hands as a\nresult of unprecedented manipulations and machinations, fraud and raiding\n(people's memories are still fresh enough about how the initial capital was\nacquired and accumulated during the uncontrolled descent of the collapsing\ncountry into the quagmire of wild capitalism) — and therefore they receive no\nrespect, reverence or trust from the people or representatives of hired labor.\nIt is enough to look more closely to see the same standard scheme serving\nas the framework for the overwhelming majority of public (socio-economic)\nformations: hired labor on one side and capital on the other. The \"court\"\nphilosophers, economists and political scientists (just like in Lenin's prerevolutionary times, servicing similar power structures and institutions,\nfeeding from their hands, and imposing an opinion about the accomplished\nreconciliation of possessing and non-possessing counterparts) invented (no\ndoubt, out of thin air) some kind of \"middle class\"; although any schoolchild\nknows that there existed before and still exist today two main classes\ndiffering by their relation to ownership of means of production, with a\nbourgeois stratum of small commodity producers cushioning this entire\n\"construction\" between them. The reader probably understands that at the\ncurrent stage of social development, the arsenal of tools for production and\nreproduction has significantly expanded and, besides traditional ones, now\nincludes land, dams, roads, overpasses, vehicles, communication facilities,\ncomputers, printing and information dissemination media, instruments for\nmanaging financial flows, various robotic complexes, systems with artificial\nintelligence, etc., etc. Apologists of homogeneity and uniformity of modern\nsocial arrangements could be advised to pay attention to how the current\ncoronacrisis instantly stripped off the lacquered drapery and glittering tinsel\nfrom the appearance of the vast majority of representatives of the so-called\n\"middle class\" (for example, in the USA), leaving behind only debt credit\nobligations and nothing resembling substantial property (in the form of\nmeans of production, capitals, financial assets, fixed and working capital,\netc.).\nIn any conflict, war or internal catastrophe manifested externally, its inner\ncore ultimately turns out to be a dispute and confrontation of Contentful and\nformal constituents. And what these constituents are clothed in (what forms\nthey take) — this becomes the subject of skillful analysis and recognition;\nhere one must be able to correctly formulate (compose) a relation from\ninteracting components: whether it is {hired labor/capital}, or {class of\ndispossessed/class\nof\nowners\nof\nmeans\nof\nproduction},\nor\n{liberals/conservatives}, or {productive forces/production relations}, or\n\n\f{public character of production/private-capitalist mode of appropriation}, or\n{transnational (global)/national economy} and so on.\nCarrying out further analysis of variability, say, of the last relation listed\nabove, one cannot fail to notice that at today's stage of development the\ncomponent \"national\" represents a fairly stable side of the relation\n{transnational/global/national}; hence the noticeable and strong resistance\n(opposition) of this component relative to its opposite — the component\n\"transnational\". However, subsequently the correlation of components in this\nrelation\nwill\ninevitably\nchange\ndue\nto\nincreased\nefficiency\n(i.e., contentfulness) of the numerator component, and trans-national will\nprevail over nationally-state just as the public (socialized) will find itself in a\nbetter position compared with private (privatized) in the relation\n{public/private}, which will correspond to the law-governed increase\nin contentfulness (efficiency) of these form-relations. Cost reduction, market\nexpansion and other optimization characteristic of transnational (and in\nperspective — socialized) economy to a greater extent than national-state\neconomy will lead to growth in contentfulness both of the numerator\ncomponent of the considered relation and of the whole relation. In such\nconnection, it is fascinatingly interesting to follow the intricate flow of Lenin's\nthought flowing from less contentful preceding conceptual construction into a\nmore contentful and capacious conceptual formation, and to see that the\nspirit and manner of thinking of the great dialectician is akin to the process\nof contentful layering, similar to rolling up a \"snowball\", and remains\nessentially unchanged from article to article. Compositionally, this looks\nexactly like this: description of the initial situation and existing state of\naffairs; statement of alignment of forces; identification of objective\nprerequisites and trend towards changing the correlation of forces and the\noverall situation; prognostic description of prospective or succeeding new\nform-relation (or system of forms) and ways of its emergence].\n3. The article \"The Beginning of the Revolution in Russia\" [8, pp. 422–\n424] was written by Lenin in January 1905 — almost immediately after the\nevents of Bloody Sunday in St. Petersburg. Judging by the fact that the\nspring was slowly compressing (\"the tsarist government deliberately gave\nrelatively unhindered development to strike movements and the beginnings\nof broad demonstrations\"), it was not difficult to assume that the\ngovernment acted with the intention of driving things toward the use of\nmilitary force [8, p. 422]. As a result: thousands killed and wounded. The\nRubicon has been crossed: the compressed-to-the-limit spring had to release\nits accumulated energy — the proletariat rose up and began to arm itself.\nAnd immediately the entire palette of revolutionary appeals, slogans and\nactions changes. The rebellious Petrograd workers put forward demands for\nimmediate convocation of a constituent assembly based on universal, direct,\nequal and secret suffrage, as well as for the immediate overthrow of the\ngovernment; at the same time, \"arming the people becomes one of the\nnearest tasks of the revolutionary moment.\" Events develop with astonishing\nspeed: \"the revolutionary education of the proletariat advanced in one day\n\n\fmore than it could have done in months and years of gray, humdrum,\ndowntrodden life\". Immediate arming of workers and all citizens generally (it\nwas recognized and pointed out that revolutionaries of bourgeois democracy\ncould be used for the overthrow of Tsarism), \"preparation and organization of\nrevolutionary forces for the destruction of governmental authorities and\ninstitutions — this is the practical basis upon which all and any\nrevolutionaries can and should combine for a common blow\" [8, p. 424].\n[It should be noted here that there are no Councils of Workers', Soldiers' or\nPeasants' Deputies yet on the forefront of the growing struggle. The situation\ndevelops exclusively within the framework of the relation composed\n(\"formed\") of directly interacting components {proletariat/autocracy}: on the\none side — the working class under the wing of the Social-Democratic Party;\non the other side — autocracy with its coercive institutions].\nAnd no matter how the present uprising ends in St. Petersburg itself, it will\ninevitably and necessarily become the first step toward a much broader,\nmore conscious, better-prepared uprising. The government may manage to\npostpone the hour of reckoning, but postponement will only make the next\nstep of the revolutionary onslaught even grander [8, p. 423].\n[This example clearly demonstrates how V.I. Lenin masterfully formulated\nand \"calibrated\" the previously reproduced dialectical scheme: precise\nidentification and definition of interacting constituents-components in their\nrelation {organizing proletariat/institutions of autocratic power}; identifying\nthe active component in this relation; determining the direction of variability\n(movement, development) of the active component and the whole relation;\nforecasting the emergence, accordingly, of new contentful forms as a result\nof this change-movement.\nHuman thought always tends towards representing (expressing) its most\nperfect form of maximum content volume. Structurally-compositionally, the\nsame scheme looks like this: description of the established situation in\nconditions of disequilibrium; identification of causes and backgrounds\ncontributing to disruption of situational equilibrium; description of the\nprocess of situation development while moving it towards a more\nequilibrated, more balanced state; description of the new state of affairs and\nnewly emerging situation replacing the existing one due to inevitable ongoing\nchanges].\n4. The article \"Marxism and Revisionism\" [8, pp. 36–43] was written in\nMarch-April 1908. Describing the initial starting position, Lenin draws attention to\nthe alignment of forces (i.e., lists interacting components) in the course of the\nstruggle unfolding in the theoretical sphere. In this sphere, newly emerged\nnatural-historical theories in the mid-19th century, touching old theological\nprejudices, caused and continue to cause the fiercest opposition and struggle [8,\np. 36]. Bourgeois scientific thought and philosophy do not want to hear anything\nabout Marxism, declaring it refuted and destroyed [how wonderfully \"fresh\" and\n\n\frecognizable is such an attitude toward Marxism even today!]. The increasing\nrole of Marxism and consolidation of its ideas among the working class inevitably\nprovokes sharpening bourgeois attacks against Marxism, which after each\n\"destruction\" by official science becomes stronger, tougher and livelier. Having\ndefeated and outplayed many hostile external currents over the past fifty years,\ntoday Marxism faces opposing currents requiring its correction within Marxism\nitself. Pre-Marxian socialism remains strong in Russia and sometimes revives.\nGenerally speaking, pre-Marxian socialism has been broken, but it continues\nfighting not on its own independent ground but on common Marxist ground — as\nrevisionism [trying to legalize and prove viability of a mixture of \"a bulldog with\na rhinoceros\"]. Essentially, however, all this petty-bourgeois revision of Marxism\n(revision of small shopkeepers) always boils down to negation or diminution of\nthe factor of class struggle and channeling class struggle into the stream of\n\"class cooperation\" [8, pp. 38–39].\nWhat accounts for the inevitability of periodic revival of revisionism and its roots\nunder capitalism? It lies in the fact that in any capitalist country there are always\nbroad layers of petty bourgeoisie, small proprietors alongside the proletariat.\nCapitalism was born and constantly reborn (regenerated) from small production\n[8, p. 42]! A whole series of \"middle strata\" [by analogy with some \"middle\nclass\", using modern language] is inevitably created again and again by\ncapitalism due to its inner necessity (services of individual craftsmen, homebased work, small workshops serving large industry, etc.). When they go\nbankrupt, these small producers are inevitably thrown back into the ranks of the\nproletariat, \"diluting\" their views and beliefs with petty-bourgeois worldview,\ntheir ideology (which, apparently, requires constant work on retraining and reeducation). This is completely natural and will be so for a long time while\nantagonistic classes exist. And ideological struggle of revolutionary Marxism with\nrevisionism is merely the prelude to great revolutionary battles of the proletariat\nuntil complete victory of its cause despite all vacillations and weaknesses of the\npetit bourgeoisie [8, p. 43].\nBypassing superficial phenomena (effects), Lenin constantly brings to light the\nmost essential, profound sides-components consisting in actual relations of\ninteraction and confrontation. Thus, contrary to the widespread opinion among\nrevisionists, he states that growing parliamentarism and education of the\nproletariat do not weaken crises and eliminate revolutions but, on the contrary,\ncontribute to intensifying civil war during these crises and revolutions [8, p. 41].\nThey (parliamentarism and education) help enlighten and organize ever larger\nmasses of population correspondingly to the increase (\"piling up\") of substantive\n(informational) accumulations. This constitutes the internal dialectics of\nparliamentarism and bourgeois democratism, subordinate following of which\nexpresses itself in even more acute than before resolution of disputes and\ncontradictions through mass violence.\n[Lenin is a master at identifying dialectically confronting components (i.e., the\nmost interconnected and substantially conflicting sides, speaking in everyday\nterms) in all episodes of development of reality that he analyzes. In this case,\n\n\faccording to the established circumstances, he identifies the main actively\ninteracting components of development (of the revolutionary movement):\nBolsheviks on one side, Mensheviks on the other. Ideological grounds or\nbackground guiding the interacting parties are: revolutionary Marxism on the\none hand, and revisionism on the other. Material carriers of these sides turn out\nto be the revolutionary proletariat on one side and wavering petty-bourgeois\nmiddling elements on the other. At later times, the latter would give way to\nbourgeois intelligentsia (unsteady, eternally vacillating and conciliatory). Then\nLenin identifies the active contentful component, anticipates the direction of its\nchange-movement, and further forecasts the orientation and priority of\nsubsequent movement-development of the entire system composed of the\nconsidered components together with other changing factors of political reality].\n5. The transient nature and finiteness of prosperity of any form (whether among\nforms of economic management or among forms of revolutionary movement) is\nevidenced by the periodic renewal of crises (industrial, economic, financial,\npolitical, social, etc.).\nThe reason for writing the January 1909 article \"On the Road\" [8, pp. 537–544]\nwas the organizational and ideo-political crisis in the Social-Democratic Party of\nRussia. The background of the crisis lay in the urgent need to cleanse the\n\"workers' party of wavering, intellectual and petty-bourgeois elements who had\njoined the labor movement mainly hoping for the imminent triumph of the\nbourgeois-democratic revolution and who could not hold out during the reaction\"\n[8, p. 538]. The instability of these \"elements\" affected both theory, tactics and\norganizational policy of the party. Conscious workers took charge of running\nparty organizations and leading them. The situation required convening the AllRussian Conference of the RSDLP, where answers were actually formulated\nregarding what path the working-class party should choose in the difficult\ncurrent period.\nThe content of this answer consisted of the following decisions and developments\nof the conference: \"Marxist analysis of the current relationship between classes\nand new policies of Tsarism\"; indication of the immediate goal of struggle set by\nthe Social-Democratic Party; \"assessment of lessons learned from the revolution\nconcerning the correctness of revolutionary-social democratic tactics; clarification\nof causes of the party's crisis and pointing to the role of the proletarian element\nof the party in combating it; resolving the issue of the ratio of illegal and legal\norganization\"; recognition of the need to use the Duma tribune and development\nof precise guiding instructions for the social-democratic faction in connection with\ndirect criticism of its errors [8, p. 538].\nAutocracy [instead of the term \"autocracy\", one can use today's equivalents\n(terms closest and similar in meaning are): authoritarianism, autocracy, tyranny,\ndespotism] still acts as the main enemy of the proletariat and all democracy, but\nit would be a mistake to think that it remains unchanged, does not change or\nmimic. Today \"autocracy attempts to take upon itself the solution of objectively\nnecessary tasks of the bourgeois revolution — creation of popular representation\n\n\ftruly governing affairs of bourgeois society, and cleaning up medieval, tangled\nand obsolete agrarian relations in the village; but precisely the practical result of\nthese new steps of autocracy turns out so far equal to zero, and this only makes\neven clearer the necessity of other forces and means for solving the historical\ntask\" [8, pp. 539–540].\nNew conditions of the moment require new forms of struggle: using the Duma\ntribune appears an unconditional necessity; long-term work on education and\norganization of masses of the proletariat is moved to the forefront; combining\nillegal and legal organization presents special challenges to the party;\npopularization and explanation of the experience of the revolution discredited by\nliberals and liquidator intellectuals are needed both theoretically and practically.\nBut the tactical line of the party, which must manage to account for new\nconditions in methods and tools of struggle, remains unchanged. The correctness\nof revolutionary-social democratic tactics has been confirmed by the experience\nof mass struggle of 1905–1907. The defeat of the revolution at the end of this\nfirst campaign revealed not incorrectness of goals, not utopian nature of\nobjectives, not erroneousness of means and approaches, but insufficient\npreparedness of forces, insufficient depth and breadth of the revolutionary crisis.\nLet liberals and bewildered intelligentsia fall into despair after the first massive\nbattle for freedom. Conscious proletariat will respond to them that great tasks of\nrevolutions were solved only when advanced classes repeated their onslaught\nmore than once and achieved victory, having been taught by the experience of\ndefeats. Defeated armies learn well. Revolutionary classes of Russia have been\ndefeated in the first campaign, but the revolutionary situation persists. [Lenin's\ninexhaustible optimism calling to learn also from defeats evokes nothing but\nadmiration!!!]. In new forms and another way, the revolutionary crisis looms\nagain, matures again [it is known that any crisis always precedes and ends with\nreplacement of forms representing developing contents of reality]. Long-term\npreparation of broad masses — preparation taking into account higher and more\nconcrete goals — should be carried out, and the more successfully it is done, the\nsurer the victory in the new struggle will be. And the same proletariat will now\nbe able to patiently and steadfastly carry out the work of educating and\npreparing new cadres of a mightier revolutionary force.\n[It concerns periodic evaluation of the correlation of interacting components in\ntheir relation and constant tracking of the trend of shifting this correlation\ntowards increasing and predominance of the more contentful component, for\nwhich the contentfulness of the active component (i.e., the revolutionary spirit of\nthe proletariat) must be \"replenished\" through popularization and elucidation of\nthe experience of mass struggle and revolution].\nSince the general link diluting and weakening Marxist ideology of the proletariat\ncontinues to be the small commodity producer (petty bourgeoisie), drifting\nbetween two clearly defined classes of capitalists and proletariat, then under\nsuch circumstances the task of the day is: \"Strengthening of the illegal party\norganization, creating party cells in all areas of activity, creating above all purely\nparty, albeit few-membered workers' committees in every industrial enterprise,\n\n\fconcentration of leading functions in the hands of leaders of the socialdemocratic movement from among the workers themselves\" [8, p. 543].\nEach cell and each party worker committee must become a support point for\nagitational, propaganda and practically organizational work among the\nmasses, i.e., necessarily go where the mass goes and try at every step to push\nits consciousness toward socialism, winning for itself leadership in all proletarian\nlegal organizations by virtue of its energy and ideological influence (rather than\ntitles and ranks).\n[According to the testimony of N.V. Volsky (a contemporary of Vladimir\nIlyich, with the real surname N.V. Valentinov), who never was, by his own\nadmission, either a Bolshevik or a pronounced Menshevik [1], Lenin was a\nsupporter of the agitational work with all strata of the population, but the\nemphasis proposed to be made nevertheless on the work with the proletariat\nof Russia.]\nIn any case legally or semi-legally, openly or covertly, the working class will find\npoints of consolidation everywhere — conscious party social democrats will\nalways move ahead and consolidate among themselves to impact the masses in\nthe party spirit.\nA party of the vanguard class (proletariat), which manages to organize its avantgarde and direct its forces so as to exert social-democratic influence on every\nmanifestation of life of the proletariat — this party will win no matter what [8, p.\n544].\n[By analogy with the previous article, V.I. Lenin bases his analysis of current\nevents again on the existence and interaction of two main classes: the ruling\nclass of owners of means of production and the subordinate class of nonpropertied, dependent hired laborers free from ownership of means of\nproduction. Between these two classes drifts a layer of declassified pettybourgeois elements, periodically replenishing either class (much more often —\nthe class of non-propertied hired laborers). The cause of the ideological-political\ncrisis in the Russian Social-Democratic Party was exactly the uncertainty of\nposition of representatives of this stratum within the social-democratic milieu. All\nother conclusions and fabrications stem from evil, belong to the realm of fictions\ngenerated by apologists serving the ruling class among university professors,\nprofessional philosophers, political scientists and propagandists of all stripes.\nNeither Marx nor Lenin were discoverers of classes or originators of ideas about\nclass struggle as the driving force of social development — bourgeois historians\nand economists had \"exploited\" these discoveries long before Marxism emerged.\nBut both used primarily these concepts and representations to analyze ongoing\nhistorical processes, their patterns and trends.\nThen came times when the aforementioned concepts (denoting the main\nsubjects of social activity and the process of its implementation) were buried\n\n\funder splinters and chips flying from the axe that carried out major public\ntransformations. Thus, the most important components of development and\ntheir sacramental relations were put away in a drawer for a long time and\nthoroughly forgotten.\nNowadays it is quite common to hold an opinion — usually expressed by the\nsame \"court\" politicians, economists and philosophers close to power\nstructures, as well as their media outlets justifying the fairness and eternity\nof existing foundations, i.e., apologists of current social arrangements — that\nclass theory has hopelessly become obsolete and that now property\nownership itself (especially on means of production) plays no role;\nsupposedly, what matters today are opportunities to control financial flows.\nNo, gentlemen, you are wrong. In order to manage financial flows, play\nmulti-step financial combinations, rule over the whole world, etc., you still\nhave to eat, drink, live somewhere, \"manage households, give birth to\nchildren, produce products, exchange them...\" (see the above-quoted Lenin\npassage from the book “Materialism and Empiriocriticism”), which does not\nallow ignoring property relations and everything connected with them. And if\nyou want to rise higher, soar above earthly life with its material physical side\n— this will not happen either. To realize such a \"wish\", one would have to\ncompletely detach oneself from the objectively-material level of one's bodilyintellectual organization, from the basis of your precious \"I\", which is\nabsolutely impossible without loss or deprivation of this unique \"I\". The level\nof ideal subjective forms enters only narrowly (although being the\nmost contentful of reliably known ones today) into the overall set of levels\nconstituting your \"I\", whereas the bulk of every human \"I\" consists of rather\n\"down-to-earth\" object-matter layers of reality. And you cannot get rid of the\nheavy shackles of these \"coarse\" layers while remaining among those living\non earth. This is precisely what Marx called, recalling his words, the curse on\nspirit — to be burdened by matter. And however much anyone might wish,\nhaving achieved desired material prosperity, to dissociate themselves from\nall coarse physicality and ascend to the realm of the ideal and unearthly —\nproperty relations and especially those regarding means of production will\ncontinue to remain key, whoever says otherwise and however they try to\ncamouflage this fact. Therefore, staying on real ground and being part of the\nobject-matter level of reality forming and filling you up, you will inevitably\nhave to keep fighting for your flesh and for your place under the sun. You will\nalso inevitably have to think about your offspring, and in connection with this\n— about inheritance for your descendants, i.e., about that very mundane\nproperty which, god forbid, may end up in alien hands. Your own flesh will\nnot let you soar above the struggle and beyond this entire world like an elf or\nangel; but once you shed it (if such should ever occur), you will\nsimultaneously lose yourself (your \"I\") together with all your \"fantasies\" and\n\"desires\" — well, then what will your desires concern?\nThe direct path for you, gentlemen, lies toward socialism — there alone will\nyou find deliverance from unbearable fetters of property and endless\n\n\fthoughts about accumulation and transfer of material inheritance into the\nright hands, and finally begin caring about intellectual and spiritual legacy;\nthere you will acquire more or less genuine freedom from dreary thoughts\nabout how to master financial assets, ride financial flows — and who knows\nwhat else you cling to with iron grip. Welcome to socialism, gentlemen!\nIt must be said that denial of classes and class struggle is an inexhaustible\nelement of idle reasoning exercises, periodically reviving and again taking\npossession of unsophisticated minds after each successive \"defeat\" and\npublic expulsion. It seems, however, that the hour has come when public\nattention is drawn again to relations of key constituents of developing reality,\nas well as to their role and significance during replacement of forms of social\nprogress. The mere absence at present of visible signs of class struggle\nspeaks only of disorganization or insufficient organization of representatives\nof hired labor and lack of outstanding and incorruptible leaders of\nrevolutionary movement at this stage of social development.]\nIn relation {proletariat/autocracy (tsarism)} a fairly noticeable shift occurred\ntowards predominance of the fastest-developing contentful component —\nproletariat with its Marxist party, becoming richer in content due to growth in\neducational standard of party and proletarian ranks, while the second\ncomponent — autocracy — mimics, tries to mask itself as bourgeoisie and\nmerge with it. It should be noted that in his analysis Lenin never considers\nthe main interacting components or figures separately, detached from each\nother — always only together, in interaction, in relation. Proletariat is\nnonessential without bourgeoisie or capitalists, just as the latter are\nnonessential without proletariat. Capital is nonessential without hired labor,\nand vice versa. Only the interaction of these two constituents of reality, their\ncollision, their conflict, internecine struggle contributes to emergence of new\ndevelopmental forms and movement toward a new socio-economic\nformation, i.e., to new forms of acquiring social orders.\n[Periodically arising public conflicts have as their foundation accumulating\nunsolvable-for-the-time-being content-form contradictions:\nbetween\noutdated management system, bureaucratized power, \"bourgeoisified\" ruling\nclass with its institutions and forms of governance on the one hand, and, on\nthe other hand, competence and preparedness of society with its substantive\npublic opinions and representations surpassing this \"ossifying\" system.\nEvidence of this includes numerous examples of modern states with their\ninternal conflicts: frames, forms, methods of primitive management do not\nmeet the needs, demands, requirements of a complexifying, perfecting,\ndeveloping and rapidly increasing-in-contentfulness socium.]\nA crisis in the revolutionary movement (according to Lenin) is a harbinger of\nanother stage of construction and formation of a new relation of directly\ninteracting constituents-components and at the same time a precursor of a\nnew search for a way \"on the road\" and purification from the old form (its\nattributes) restraining the movement of the contentful constituent; it is a\n\n\fsign of outgrowing the existing form by its developed content and an\nindicator of necessity to master a new promising form sufficiently developed\nalready in terms of content. At the same time, the correlation of\nconstituents-components in the newly emerging and changing relation is\nanalyzed, where the numerator is enriched by decisions and conclusions of\nconferences and congresses of the Bolshevik Party, while the denominator is\nfed by resolutions of the Constituent Assembly of the State Duma (i.e.,\ncirculars of the \"mimicking\" form of state government).\n[Production, management, economic, ideological-political, etc., crises are\nindicators of a disrupted balance or equilibrium between interacting components\nin their various form-relations. The leading contentful constituent moving\nforward (or preparing to move forward and lead) \"requires\" search for and\ndiscovery of its corresponding formal component that balances (for some period\nof time) the combined relation of these constituents. The stagnant phase in\nwhich this new disequilibrium relation finds itself (in our case: {educated\nproletariat/mimicking autocracy}) is overcome by searching for and finding a\nmore active form of movement of the contentful component, which, when\nanother way out \"on the road\" is found, is ensured through accelerated increase\nin contentfulness of the numerator of the mentioned new relation; i.e., through\n(in Lenin's words): indication of the immediate goal of struggle; assessment of\ncorrectness of social-democratic tactics; clarification of causes of the party crisis\nand pointing to the role of the proletarian element of the party in combating it;\nresolution of the issue regarding the ratio of illegal and legal organization;\nrecognition of the need to use the Duma tribune and development of precise\nguiding instructions for the social-democratic faction.]\nAnd, as Lenin summarizes, this stage must be outgrown and the crisis overcome\nby discovering and applying new forms of struggle [8, p. 540].\nIn other words, a new exit \"on the road\" is sought through increasing\nthe contentfulness of forms of the Social-Democratic movement.\n§ 2. Works of the immediate pre-revolutionary period\nThe second period, which we have named as immediate pre-revolutionary\n(on the eve of the revolution), is represented by a number of works by\nVladimir I. Lenin, dictated by rapidly changing events (especially on the eve\nof the October coup).\n1. In the book \"On the Right of Nations to Self-Determination\" [8, pp.\n569-621], written in May 1914, Lenin analyzes in detail the specifics of\napplying the Marxist position on the secession of nations depending on\ndifferent historically established conditions for the formation of one or\nanother nation.\nDue to its closest connection with the present, we will dwell on this work in\nmore detail.\n\n\fPreliminarily, it should be said that the \"right of nations to selfdetermination\", regarding the legitimacy and expediency of whose\nproclamation and protection heated debates do not cease even in our days, is\nnot a figment of V.I. Lenin's imagination or an invention of the Bolsheviks,\nbut the result of discussions and decisions of the International congresses,\nand in particular the \"London International Congress (of socialist workers'\nparties and trade unions) of 1896\". The defense of this right and its inclusion\nin the program of the Social-Democratic Party of Russia was justified by\nLenin by referring to the corresponding stage of the national liberation\nmovement experienced by Russia. By analogy with the support by Marxists\nunder similar historical conditions of the said right in Western Europe, Lenin,\nfocusing on similar liberation processes in Eastern Europe and Asia (including\nRussia), but occurring with some delay (at least by half a century), concludes\non the necessity of advancing the same demand at the stage of revolutionary\ntransformations in Russia as well.\nTo convey the logic of Lenin's thought, let us provide a chain of characteristic\nquotes from this work.\n\"An unconditional requirement of Marxist theory in the analysis of any social\nquestion whatsoever is to place it within definite historical limits, and then, if\nthe question concerns one country (for example, a national program for a\ngiven country), to take into account the concrete specifics distinguishing this\ncountry from others within the limits of one and the same historical epoch\"\n[8, p. 574].\n\"The comparison of the political and economic development of different\ncountries, as well as their Marxist programs, is of enormous significance from\nthe standpoint of Marxism, for both the general capitalist nature of modern\nstates and the general law of their development are indisputable. But such a\ncomparison must be made skillfully. The ABC condition here is to clarify\nthe question of whether the historical epochs of development of the\ncompared countries are comparable\" [8, p. 578].\n\"In Western, continental Europe, the era of bourgeois-democratic revolutions\ncovers a rather definite time span, approximately from 1789 to 1871. It was\nprecisely this era that was the era of national movements and the creation of\nnational states. Upon the completion of this era, Western Europe turned into\nan established system of bourgeois states, as a general rule, at the same\ntime nationally unified states. Therefore, to now seek the right to selfdetermination in the programs of West European socialists means not to\nunderstand the ABC of Marxism.\nIn Eastern Europe and Asia, the era of bourgeois-democratic revolutions only\nbegan in 1905. ...And in this chain of events only a blind man can fail to see\nthe awakening of a whole series of bourgeois-democratic national\nmovements, aspirations for the creation of nationally independent and\n\n\fnationally unified states. It is precisely because and only because\nRussia, together with neighboring countries, is experiencing this era\nthat we need a point on the right of nations to self-determination in\nour program\" [8, pp. 578-579].\n\"Thus, it is the historical concrete specifics of the national question in\nRussia that give us a special urgency to the recognition of the right\nof nations to self-determination in the epoch we are experiencing\" [8,\np. 581].\n\"The bourgeoisie, which naturally acts as the hegemon (leader) of any\nnational movement at its beginning, calls the support of all national\naspirations a practical matter. But the policy of the proletariat in the national\nquestion (as in other questions) only supports the bourgeoisie in a certain\ndirection, but never coincides with its policy. ...Every bourgeoisie wants in\nnational matters either privileges for its nation or exclusive benefits for it;\nthis is called 'practical'. The proletariat is against any privileges, against\nany exclusivity\" [8, p. 582].\n\"The bourgeoisie always places its national demands in the foreground. It\nputs them unconditionally. For the proletariat, they are subordinated to the\ninterests of the class struggle. Theoretically, one cannot guarantee in\nadvance whether the secession of a given nation or its equal status with\nanother nation will complete the bourgeois-democratic revolution; for the\nproletariat, it is important in both cases to ensure the development of its\nclass; for the bourgeoisie, it is important to hinder this development,\npostponing its tasks before the tasks of 'their' nation. Therefore, the\nproletariat limits itself to a negative, so to speak, demand for the recognition\nof the right to self-determination, guaranteeing nothing to any nation,\nundertaking to give nothing regarding another nation.\nLet this be not 'practical', but in fact this most reliably guarantees the most\ndemocratic of possible solutions; the proletariat needs only these guarantees,\nand the bourgeoisie of each nation needs guarantees of its benefits without\nrelation to the position (to possible minuses) of other nations.\nThe bourgeoisie is most interested in the 'feasibility' of a given demand —\nhence the eternal policy of deals with the bourgeoisie of other\nnations to the detriment of the proletariat.\nLet this be not 'practical' for opportunists, but this is the only guarantee in\nfact, a guarantee of maximum national equality and peace in spite of both\nthe feudal lords and the nationalist bourgeoisie.\nThe entire task of the proletarians in the national question is\n'impractical' from the standpoint of the nationalist bourgeoisie of\neach nation, for the proletarians demand abstract equality, the\nprincipled absence of the slightest privileges, being hostile to any\nnationalism.\n\n\f...The proletariat is against such practicality: recognizing equality and equal\nright to a national state, it values and places above all the union of\nproletarians of all nations, evaluating any national demand, any national\nsecession from the angle of the class struggle of workers. The slogan of\npracticality is in fact merely the slogan of uncritical adoption of bourgeois\naspirations.\nThey tell us: by supporting the right to secession, you support bourgeois\nnationalism of oppressed nations. ...We answer: no, it is precisely the\nbourgeoisie that is interested in a 'practical' solution here, while for the\nworkers it is important to fundamentally distinguish two tendencies. Since\nthe bourgeoisie of the oppressed nation is fighting the oppressing one, we\nare always and in any case and more resolutely than all, for we are the\nboldest and most consistent enemies of oppression. Since the bourgeoisie of\nthe oppressed nation stands for its bourgeois nationalism, we are against.\nThe struggle against the privileges and violence of the oppressing\nnation and no connivance at the striving for privileges on the part of\nthe oppressed nation.\nIf we do not advance and conduct in our agitation the slogan of the right to\nsecession, we will play into the hands not only of the bourgeoisie, but also of\nthe feudal lords and the absolutism of the oppressing nation. ...In every\nbourgeois nationalism of an oppressed nation there is a general-democratic\ncontent against oppression, and it is this content that we unconditionally\nsupport, strictly separating the striving for one's own national exclusiveness,\nfighting against the striving of the Polish bourgeois to oppress the Jew, etc.,\netc. [That is, here, undoubtedly, one must see the boundary markers beyond\nwhich the striving for national identity degenerates into inveterate\nnationalism and then into bestial Nazism, and suppress such a content-form\ntransformation].\nThis is \"impractical\" from the point of view of the bourgeois and the\nphilistine. This is the only practical and principled and truly helping\ndemocracy, freedom, and the proletarian union policy in the national\nquestion: recognition of the right of nations to secession for all; evaluation of\neach specific question of secession from the standpoint eliminating any\ninequality, any privileges, any exclusivity.\nLet us take the position of the oppressing nation. Can a people that\noppresses other peoples be free? No. The interests of freedom of the\nGreat Russian population require a struggle against such oppression.\nA long history, a centuries-old history of suppressing the movements\nof oppressed nations, systematic propaganda of such suppression by\nthe \"higher\" classes have created enormous obstacles to the cause of\nfreedom of the Great Russian people itself in its prejudices, etc.\n\n\f...The Great Russian proletariat cannot achieve its goals, cannot clear\nits path to freedom, without systematically fighting these prejudices.\n[And the matter here, perhaps, is not only in prejudices or the moralhumanistic side of the issue, but also in the trivial discomfort of the everyday\nlife of the oppressing nation, being in constant tension, suspicion,\napprehensions and expectation of blows in the back from the oppressed,\nsuppressed, humiliated nation.\nThe Great Russian, privileged in relation to a non-Russian, is just as unfree,\nuneasy, unbalanced, unself-sufficient as a non-Russian — due to the social\ntension created by the counter-resistance and opposition from the oppressed\nnation. This contentfulness ought to be known to today's \"resolvers\" of the\nnational question].\n...We, the proletarians, declare ourselves in advance to be opponents of\nGreat Russian privileges and in this direction conduct all our propaganda and\nagitation... against all state-national privileges... such a task is our main\n(current) task in the national question, for only in this way do we defend the\ninterests of democracy and the equal union of all proletarians of all nations.\nLet this propaganda be impractical from the point of view of the\nGreat Russian oppressors and from the point of view of the\nbourgeoisie of oppressed nations. ...In fact, it is this propaganda, and\nonly it, that ensures a truly democratic and truly socialist education\nof the masses. Only such propaganda guarantees both the greatest\nchances of national peace in Russia if it remains a motley national\nstate, and the most peaceful (and harmless for the proletarian class\nstruggle) division into different national states, if the question of\nsuch a division arises\" [8, pp. 582-586].\n\"To accuse the supporters of the freedom of self-determination, i.e. the\nfreedom of secession, of encouraging separatism is the same stupidity and\nthe same hypocrisy as to accuse the supporters of the freedom of divorce of\nencouraging the destruction of family ties. Just as in bourgeois society the\ndefenders of privileges and venality, on which the bourgeois marriage is\nbuilt, oppose the freedom of divorce, so in the capitalist state the denial of\nthe freedom of self-determination, i.e. the secession of nations, means only\nthe defense of the privileges of the dominant nation and police methods of\nadministration to the detriment of democratic ones\" [8, p. 593].\n\"The real class significance of the liberal hostility to the principle of political\nself-determination of nations is one and only one: national-liberalism, the\ndefense of state privileges of the Great Russian bourgeoisie. [It is not difficult\nto see that the position of some leaders of the \"liberal\" parties of modern\nRussia is an absolute carbon copy of these Lenin's words].\n\n\f...The interests of the working class and its struggle against capitalism\nrequire full solidarity and the closest unity of workers of all nations, require\nresistance to the nationalist policy of the bourgeoisie of whatever nationality.\nTherefore, a deviation from the tasks of proletarian policy and the\nsubordination of workers to bourgeois policy would be both if the SocialDemocrats were to deny the right to self-determination, i.e. the right to\nsecession of oppressed nations, and if the Social-Democrats were to support\nall national demands of the bourgeoisie of oppressed nations. To a hired\nworker it is all the same whether his predominant exploiter will be the Great\nRussian bourgeoisie preferably over a non-Russian one, or the Polish\npreferably over a Jewish one, etc. A hired worker who has realized the\ninterests of his class is indifferent both to the state privileges of the\nGreat Russian capitalists and to the promises of the Polish or\nUkrainian capitalists that paradise on earth will be established when\nthey possess state privileges.\n...In any case, the hired worker will remain an object of exploitation, and a\nsuccessful struggle against it requires the independence of the proletariat\nfrom nationalism, the complete, so to speak, neutrality of the proletarians in\nthe struggle of the bourgeoisie of different nations for supremacy. The\nslightest support by the proletariat of any nation for the privileges of \"its\"\nnational bourgeoisie will inevitably cause distrust of the proletariat of another\nnation, will weaken the international class solidarity of workers, will divide\nthem to the delight of the bourgeoisie. And the denial of the right to selfdetermination, or to secession, inevitably means in practice support for the\nprivileges of the dominant nation\" [8, pp. 594-595].\n\"In the question of the self-determination of nations, as in any other\nquestion, we are interested first of all in the self-determination of the\nproletariat within nations\" [8, p. 597].\n[Nowadays, such an approach remains topical, counting on the unification of\nall wage workers (regardless of nations and nationality) in the struggle and\nopposition to the associated oligarchy.\nIn the application to the present day, everywhere in the text of Lenin's work,\nby the proletariat one should understand the wage workers and\nrepresentatives of wage labor, and by the bourgeoisie of the oppressing and\noppressed nation — the foreign and local oligarchy. After making such a\nreplacement, everything falls into place; as can be seen, the relations of\nwage workers and the oligarchy, as well as the consequences of these\nrelations, are written by the author of the book with the utmost clarity long\nbefore the October Revolution. We are obviously being punished today\nfor Unlearned lessons of dialectics, as negligent students, although\nwe have already passed all this once.\nTo please their personal interests (i.e., in pursuit of profit), the bourgeoisie\n(oligarchy) of any nation easily steps over national and patriotic principles,\n\n\fwhich fully justifies the label \"comprador\" (venal) bourgeoisie hung on it.\nThis, first of all, must be known and kept in mind by every people trying to\nfind the roots of national troubles. Only a consciously organized opposition\nto the market (i.e., spontaneously) \"molded\" oligarchy can change the\nposition (and status) of the working people for the better. Today's\nbourgeoisie, like the bourgeoisie of the past, are also not interested in social\ndevelopment (i.e., in improving methods of management and planning,\neconomic and political reforms, raising the standard of living of the\npopulation), since all this contributes to the growth of consciousness,\neducation and, accordingly, organization of wage workers. Therefore, no\none is in a hurry, and will not be, to transfer or invest their foreign savings\nand capital (allegedly earned \"by their own sweat and blood\") into the\ncountry's economy, to abandon offshore assets.\nWhat allows us to confidently use in this connection the terms \"oligarchs\",\n\"oligarchy\"? It is enough to look more closely at the structure of property,\nincome and acquisitions of any major official or deputy (not losing sight of\nrelatives and trusted persons with assets rewritten to them) to see there\nboth the owners of the means of production, and shareholders of the most\nprofitable industrial enterprises and banks, and owners of large property,\nowners of bank accounts and financial assets, and, moreover, undoubtedly,\nthose residing in power. And then how do such managers differ from\noligarchs or, at worst, from \"near-oligarchs\"? By formal features and\ndefinition — not at all, and among themselves they differ only in the size of\nappropriations and the degree of influence on the political and economic\ndecisions made regarding the fate of the country or region; in the final\nanalysis, all the so-called oligarchs differ from each other only in the size of\nthe damage inflicted on the country. In general, all capitalist states are built\non an oligarchic type (scheme): first money is made (and capital is\naccumulated), then power is desired in the name of new opportunities and\nnew money, and the combination of both again multiplies power and money.\nFor a person with an unprepared, immature, undeveloped consciousness —\nthis is a dead end, a closed vicious circle, a trap. A corrupt capitalist country\nis always an oligarchic state. On the other hand, the management\nconfiguration that has developed in the country today is quite accurately\ndetermined by the term \"plutocracy\". On the third hand, this is, of course,\nalso an \"autocracy\", represented by the \"face\" of the current \"ruler\". Before\nus is such a volatile mixture of plutocratic, oligarchic and autocratic elements\nof statehood. In this infrastructure, where there is everything and a lot of it,\nthere is only one small link missing — the rule of the people; the working\npeople simply do not \"fit\" with the modern government and\ntherefore are not represented in the government].\nThere are assurances that \"the recognition of the right to secession increases the\ndanger of the state's disintegration. ... From the point of view of democracy in\ngeneral, it is quite the opposite: the recognition of the right to secession reduces\nthe danger of the \"disintegration of the state\"\" [8, p. 592].\n\n\fFurther, the question is examined using the example of the Ukrainian\nnationality: \"Is it not clear that the more freedom the Ukrainian nationality has in\none or another country, the stronger the connection of this nationality with the\ngiven country will be? It seems that one cannot argue against this ABC truth if\none does not decisively break with all the premises of democratism. And can\nthere be greater freedom of a nationality as such than the freedom of secession,\nthe freedom of forming an independent national state?\" [8, p. 592].\n[At first glance, it may seem incorrect that the dialectical position, according to\nwhich the recognition of the right of nations to self-determination does not\nincrease the danger of the state's disintegration, but on the contrary, cements\nthe country and strengthens the ties between nationalities — since in relation to,\nsay, the above-mentioned Ukrainian nationality, this dialectical position was not\nfulfilled and is not being fulfilled. However, in this particular case, the following\ncircumstances should be taken into account. Unlike the conditions and events\ncorresponding to the temporary stage analyzed in the book by Lenin we are\nconsidering, for some time now (already in our times), under the patronage of\nthe local \"comprador\" oligarchy, on the territory once called the Ukrainian SSR, a\nshoot of rabid nationalism and fierce hatred of everything Russian, cultivated in\nthe deep past and pulled out from the dilapidated sewer outlets, has bloomed in\nfull bloom. From this perspective, the revived phenomenon already falls under\nthe definition not of a traditional national liberation movement (acquiring\nfreedom and the right of a nation to self-determination), but of aggressive\nNazism based on blood feud and innate hatred (the roots of which must be\nsought in the origin of the once artificially bred and carefully selected \"marginal\"\nnationalism), the formation of which has little in common with a national\nliberation movement. Extremely interesting in this regard is the fact that from a\nwhole range of levels-forms within the composition of their multi-level totality\n(uniting in itself diverse methods of interethnic interaction), the lowest, most\nprimitive level receives an impetus for priority development (under the\n\"management\" of the same universal principle of Self-development) in the image\nof some fanged horned creature with a tail and fur that has not yet fallen off,\ncrawled out of a dark deep cave to teach the whole civilized world its\nunderstanding of life and interethnic communication. Like a weed stifling\ncultivated plants at the root, this primitive \"misunderstanding\" is capable for\nsome time of diverting to itself and \"grinding\" the contentful volumes worked out\nlater, but already tested, or, simply put, absorbing (destroying) the civilized\nforms of higher levels. Such are the curiosities and \"inscrutable\" paths of the\ndialectical development of diverse forms-levels of reality].\nAs for the attitude to the national question, for example, of Marx: \"Marx makes\nno absolute of national movements, knowing that the complete liberation of all\nnationalities can only be given by the victory of the working class. To take into\naccount in advance all possible correlations between the bourgeois liberation\nmovements of oppressed nations and the proletarian liberation movement\namong the oppressing nation (this is precisely the problem that makes the\nnational question so difficult in modern Russia) is an impossible thing\" [8, p.\n608].\n\n\f[In other words, one must support the oppressed nation in its struggle and direct\nthis struggle towards facilitating the proletarian movement, since the analysis of\nall variants of correlations (line-up of forces) between the forces of national\nliberation and proletarian movements (in their relation) is impossible even with\nthe involvement of the intellectual power of 70 Marxs (to use Lenin's words, who\nalways meant the constant presence of some objective uncertainty in the\ndevelopment of certain forms-relations and the impossibility of knowing or\nanticipating the development of these forms with one hundred percent\ncertainty). As we can see, the ability to think dialectically allowed the classics of\nMarxism, and in particular V.I. Lenin, to focus attention by no means on\nobtaining exhaustive knowledge about the outcome of the interaction of the\nstudied components, but only on understanding the tendency of variability of\ntheir relations, in order to already on this basis forecast the further development\nof their forms].\n\"The protocols of the congress of 1903 [II Congress of the RSDLP], which\nadopted the program [of the party] of Russian Marxists, have become the\ngreatest rarity, and the vast majority of modern figures of the workers'\nmovement are not familiar with the motives of individual points of the program.\n...Let us note first of all that, however scanty the Russian Social-Democratic\nliterature concerning the \"right of nations to self-determination\" may be, it is\nnevertheless absolutely clear from it that this right was always understood in the\nsense of the right to secession.\n...The reader sees that at the II Congress of the party, which adopted the\nprogram, there were not two opinions on the question that self-determination\nmeans \"only\" the right to secession\" [8, pp. 610-611, 613].\n\"...The right to secession presupposes the solution of the question\nprecisely not by the central parliament, but only by the parliament\n(sejm, referendum, etc.) of the seceding region\" [8, p. 617].\n\"Great Russian nationalism, like any nationalism, goes through various phases\n[i.e., this question, like any other, Lenin considers through the prism of historical\ndevelopment: from having a hard autocratic reactionary color to appearing in the\ncolor of bourgeois liberalism], depending on the predominance [i.e., on the bias\nand shift towards a more substantial, more contentful component in their\nrelation — in this case in the relation {bourgeois national-liberalism/autocratic\nmonarchic national-reactionism}] of one or another class in a bourgeois country.\nBefore 1905, we knew almost only national-reactionaries. After the revolution of\n1905, national-liberals were born among us. And further, the birth of Great\nRussian national-democrats is inevitable\" [8, p. 619].\n\"From the point of view of the theory of Marxism in general, the question of the\nright to self-determination presents no difficulties. There can seriously be no talk\n\n\feither of challenging the London decision of 1896, or of the fact that by selfdetermination is meant only the right to secession, or of the fact that the\nformation of independent national states is a tendency of all bourgeoisdemocratic upheavals.\nThe difficulty is created to a certain extent by the fact that in Russia the\nproletariat of oppressed nations and the proletariat of the oppressing nation are\nfighting and must fight side by side. To defend the unity of the class struggle of\nthe proletariat for socialism, to repel all bourgeois and Black-Hundred influences\nof nationalism — this is the task. Among the oppressed nations, the separation\nof the proletariat into an independent party sometimes leads to such a fierce\nstruggle with the nationalism of a given nation that the perspective is distorted\nand the nationalism of the oppressing nation is forgotten\" [8, pp. 617-618].\n\"The slower the democratic transformation of Russia goes, the more persistent,\nrough, and fierce will be the national persecution and squabbling of the\nbourgeoisie of different nations. ...Full equality of nations; the right of nations to\nself-determination; the merging of workers of all nations — this national\nprogram teaches workers Marxism, teaches the experience of the whole world\nand the experience of Russia\" [8, p. 620].\n[Analyzing the above, one can be convinced that the slogan in defense of the\nright of nations to self-determination is always relevant — since it is an indicator\nof the recognition of the equality of all small and large nations in a multinational\nstate (which, undoubtedly, should serve as the main condition for the cohesion\nof nations in union states); in case of legalizing this right, it is easier for the\noppressed classes to defeat any oppressor, uniting on the basis of equality of all\nnations.\nTrue equality of nations is conditioned and ensured only by the recognition of the\nright of nations to self-determination (political self-determination, i.e. possible\nand permissible secession). This principle of self-determination is relevant for\nRussia (as it was relevant for the USSR) also because its peoples, like the\npeoples of the USSR, united and entered unions, as a rule, with their territories\n— i.e., not being newcomers or immigrants, which cannot be said, for example,\nabout the USA and a number of other states.\nBut all this was accepted with delight and looked exactly like that until the right\nof nations to self-determination enshrined in the constitution suddenly served as\na reason for merciless accusations of destroying a great country. It goes without\nsaying that the main claims were made against the founder of the first socialist\nstate in the world, Vladimir Ilyich Lenin, who allegedly \"laid\" a delayed-action\n\"mine\" under the Soviet Union.\n\nAdvancing such accusations, no one even remotely thinks about the objective\npossibility of an unfavorable (from the point of view of human plans and\n\n\fhopes) course and outcome of content-form transformations, which always\ntake place in the process of reality development. No one thinks about the\ninevitability of content-form transformations, conversions, transfigurations to\nwhich any developing form is subjected in the process of \"making itself out of\nitself\". In this case, it was only required to be a very well-informed and\ncompetent leader to always remember the objectivity of the tendency of\nnatural transfiguration of forms into their opposite, i.e. about the immanent\ndialectical property (character) of developing reality, described by the\nformulation of the universal principle of self-development (see above).\nNevertheless, the real state of affairs is such that by virtue of this very\ndialectical nature of the surrounding world, everything (without exception)\nsooner or later has a habit of returning \"to its own circle\", but not in its\nformer form, but in other — \"modified\" — forms. In case of misunderstanding\nsuch a layout or in case of inept and imprudent handling of the mentioned\nmodified forms — the impacts, and even blows of these weighted returning\nforms may fall not where the lower back is (it would be fine if it were so,\nwhich is still tolerable), but where the neck is higher.\nHaving detected such a trend manifesting in connection with the\ndevelopment of one or another form of reality, one can and should learn (if\nnecessary) to influence this trend, preventing or anticipating the emergence\nof undesirable (from the point of view of human consciousness)\nconsequences, which, naturally, no one in those times fulfilled not only was\nnot, but was not even supposed to be fulfilled — after all, the last\noutstanding dialectician in the chain of responsible persons turned out to be\nLenin, and all his other followers and continuators, from the point of view of\ndialectical training, are neither here nor there (ne prishey kobyle khvost).\nHowever, to blame, in all troubles and failures, the one who understands\nsuch issues best — this is in our days (as, indeed, always) a downright sign\nof good manners. Having an idea of the inevitable transformation or\ntransfiguration of changing forms into their opposites (i.e., about returning\n\"to one's own circle\"), in order to keep these forms within the framework of\ntheir former status, it is necessary in various ways to increase\ntheir contentfulness (in this case — literacy, education, awareness, etc.).\nPerhaps, one cannot even think of a more vivid example in confirmation of\nthe urgent need to master the art of dialectical thinking, dialectical\nresearch approach and practical activity!\nIn the USSR, at the stage of swaying and the so-called \"perestroika\", the\nparty nomenclature (the forerunner of the emerging bourgeoisie) of precisely\n\"aliens\", i.e. national formations (republics), finally went out of the control of\nthe central authority, which determined the collapse of the great Union.\nStarting from the Khrushchev times, and especially during the Gorbachev\nperestroika time, obvious and covert decomposition, de-ideologization and\ntransfiguration of both central (union) and local (republican), in modern\nslang, \"elites\" (or rather, pseudo-elites — party nomenclature, top and\nmiddle managers, heads of large enterprises, etc.) was in full swing, which\n\n\fwere swiftly becoming \"philistinized\" and \"bourgeoisified\", turning into their\nown ideologically contentless (but filled with bourgeois-mercantilist content)\nopposite in full accordance with the dialectical character of reality\ndevelopment. As is proper in such \"non-transparent\" cases (i.e., in times of\nturmoil), the contentful cause of what is happening is pushed to the\nbackground and its place is \"draped\" with the Formal component of the real\nprocess. In the established relation {nomenclature power in the localities /\nformal arrangement of local power based on the right of nations to political\nsecession}, due to the sharp spontaneous-uncontrolled expansion of the\npowers and capabilities of the nomenclature local power (i.e., the \"swelling\"\nof the contentful component or the \"numerator\" of the above-mentioned\nrelation), the \"denominator\" of the relation also begins to change — towards\nisolation or separation from the center and the dominance of the\nnomenclature local pseudo-elite (power structures).\nThe correctness and validity of the idea of the right of nations to selfdetermination even at that moment is beyond any doubt provided that strict\ncontrol is ensured over other particulars and details. The motives and actions\nof the nomenclature of \"aliens\" (using the terminology of Lenin's articles),\nwhich, having found itself without \"supervision and care\", played its\nmercantilist card to the victorious end, which could have been decisively\nsuppressed on quite legal grounds, should have been put under control.\nIllegal actions of the decaying nomenclature at the level of republican\nauthorities should have been stopped, relying on the \"Constitution (Basic\nLaw) of the USSR\" and on the then still functional central and republican\nstructures of law enforcement agencies: KGB, MVD, MO (Chekists, police,\narmy), continuing to keep ideology and personnel policy under control. And,\nas we now know for sure, due to the lack of such control and\ncountermeasures, the internal decomposition of the pseudo-elite ends, in the\nend, with its transformation into an oligarchy of central and local significance\n(scale); and, of course, not without external foreign influence and complicity.\nUnprincipled and unscrupulous nouveau riche nomenclature figures in\nconjunction with inveterate bandits and criminals became the new masters of\nlife.\nYes, the decisions (and actions) of the local pseudo-elites formally fell under\nthe patronage of the constitutional right of nations to self-determination, but\nthese decisions were not legal from the point of view of confirmation by the\nofficially identified will of the majority of citizens of the national republics.\nThe legality of actions was replaced by \"under-the-table\" activity and the\npushiness of local nomenclature structures and individuals. Thus, not the\nnotorious right of nations to self-determination became the cause of the\ndestruction of the USSR, but the dominance that had developed by that time\nof the satiated, transfigured de-ideologized \"comprador\" (venal) top and the\nlack of control over its behavior.\n\n\fThus (it is emphasized specifically for the current \"rulers\" and their ilk), Ilyich\ndid not \"lay\" any \"mines\" in the arrangement of the multinational Soviet\nstate — all decisions of the Bolsheviks were conditioned by the specific\ncontext of the epoch experienced and there is nothing to blame him for the\nalleged lack of foresight; in our opinion, the current \"armchair\" opponents\nand experts should read his works more attentively and thoughtfully and not\nrush to proclaim their own mental superiority. The very raising of the\nquestion of the alleged \"laid mine\" testifies to an insufficiently high level of\nintelligence and education of the persons raising this issue, since the\nquestion regarding the \"exhaustion\" or discovered over time \"nonoperability\" of this decision should not be asked of Lenin, who, we repeat,\nknew how to skillfully draw conclusions and make decisions in accordance\nwith the circumstances of a certain time stage, but with those persons who,\ndue to the rigidity of their thinking, could not subsequently flexibly react to\nchanging conditions. The role and significance of the human factor (and\npersonnel policy), ladies and gentlemen, no one has yet canceled. Again,\nwithout possessing a dialectical mindset, it is oh so difficult to search for and\nfind correct solutions to the most complex questions — which pushes (forces)\nordinary incompetent persons (including superficial researchers) to\nshamelessly attribute all mistakes and miscalculations to extraordinary,\nbut, unfortunately, humble and silent predecessors.\nIt is quite probable that in our days a variant of establishing a union association\ncould be more productive, in which any national formation (republic, state,\nautonomy) would enter the composition of a new federal arrangement on the\nrights of a territorial district with the same \"right to self-determination\", but not\non a national, but on a territorial basis and with the obligation to establish a\nsingle citizenship for the entire population as an indicator of belonging to the\ncommon state structure (well, naturally, and with all other attributes of a single\nstate: a single currency, common goals, a single defense doctrine and law\nenforcement agencies, etc.). But this is still a question requiring the involvement\nof dialectical minds for its effective solution, who would be able to track the\nperipeteia of the changing situation and accordingly adjust the decisions made\nthroughout the entire period of the relevance of this issue. God forbid the current\n\"rulers\" should imagine themselves to be qualified \"resolvers\" of national\nproblems, and on this wave get involved in defusing the \"mines\" allegedly \"laid\"\nby Lenin. Without taking into account the numerous nuances of the national\nquestion, these \"resolvers\", not being skilled dialecticians for a single time, will\nmake a mess and out of ignorance or lack of foresight will finally bury a big\ncountry under this firewood.\nIn any case, a simple solution to the national question by means of the so-called\n\"melting pot\", from which serious racial problems, still not even close to being\nresolved, suddenly crawled out (as the American near-election crisis of 2020\nshows), is also impossible, which should be taken into account by all primitive\nfigures and flat \"resolvers\" when they assume to close the sore topic once and\nfor all in this way.\n\n\fMeanwhile, this issue remains extremely topical at least because the sovereignty\n(and, consequently, the identity) of a small nation (for example, the people of\nBelarus in modern conditions) can be ensured and preserved on the principles of\nthe right of a nation to self-determination only if it exists (functions) in symbiosis\nwith a large (predominant in population) nation (within or under the wing of a\nunited Russia or an updated, modernized USSR, for example), which guarantees\nthis sovereignty and undertakes to protect the small nation from attacks and\nclaims from aggressive capitalist neighbors; otherwise, as the practice of today\nshows, the aspiration (as a temptation) of a small (unself-sufficient) state to\npursue its own independent policy (adherence to the so-called political multivector approach) will sooner or later turn this state into an appendage of more\npowerful capitalist states with inevitable leveling (nullification) of its national\nidentity. In fact, the analysis of Lenin's vision of the development options of this\ntopic leads precisely to such a conclusion.]\n2. The manifesto \"War and Russian Social-Democracy\" [8, pp. 622-628],\npublished in November 1914, was the first official document of the RSDLP, which\noutlined the position of the Bolshevik party regarding the beginning of the world\nimperialist war.\n\"The European war, which for decades had been prepared by the governments\nand bourgeois parties of all countries, broke out. ... Seizure of lands and\nsubjugation of foreign nations, ruin of a competing nation, plunder of its wealth,\ndiversion of the attention of the working masses from the internal political crises\nof Russia, Germany, England and other countries, disunity and nationalist duping\nof workers and the extermination of their vanguard for the purpose of weakening\nthe revolutionary movement of the proletariat — such is the only real content,\nsignificance and meaning of the modern war\" [8, p. 622].\n[At the beginning of the article, Lenin analyzes the current situation and the\nalignment of forces, showing that at the head of one of the warring groups\nstands the German bourgeoisie, assuring the working class that it is waging a\nwar for the defense of the homeland, freedom and culture, for the liberation of\nthe peoples oppressed by tsarism and the destruction of reactionary tsarism, but\nin fact being a faithful ally of tsarism and the enemy of the revolutionary\nmovement of workers and peasants in Russia and supporting the tsarist\nmonarchy against the revolution in Russia. At the head of the other group of\nwarring nations stands the English and French bourgeoisie, duping the working\nclass and the working masses, claiming that it is waging a war for the homeland,\nfreedom and culture against militarism and despotism of Germany, but in fact\nstriving to seize German colonies and ruin a competing nation, distinguished by\nfaster economic development. Contentful enrichment (accumulation of the\ncontent of one's own form) at the expense of others, at the expense of\ncompetitors — this is the meaning of this war (division, redistribution and seizure\nof markets, destruction of competitors). In other words, the attitudes of lower\n(i.e., more primitive) levels-forms towards multiplying their contentfulness by\ntaking away and consuming \"alien\" content overcome or take precedence over\nthe socialist attitudes or goals of more developed levels, professing the\naccumulation and increase of their contentfulness through joint creative labor,\n\n\fconducting research of developing reality by common forces, cognition and\nforecasting by joint efforts of the emergence of new forms of reality at all levels,\nas well as directions of prospective human activity].\n\"Both groups of belligerent countries do not yield to each other in robberies,\natrocities and endless cruelties of war, but in order to dupe the proletariat and\ndivert its attention from the only truly liberating war, namely the civil war\nagainst the bourgeoisie of both \"their\" country and \"foreign\" countries, for this\nhigh purpose the bourgeoisie of each country with false phrases about patriotism\ntries to exalt the significance of \"its\" national war and assure that it seeks to\ndefeat the enemy not for robbery and land seizure, but for the \"liberation\" of all\nother peoples, except its own.\n...But the more diligently the governments and the bourgeoisie of all countries\ntry to disunite the workers and set them against each other... — the more\nurgent is the duty of the conscious proletariat to defend its class cohesion, its\ninternationalism, its socialist convictions against the rampage of chauvinism of\nthe \"patriotic\" bourgeois clique of all countries. To refuse this task would mean\non the part of the conscious workers to refuse all their liberating and democratic,\nnot to mention socialist, aspirations.\nWith the deepest bitterness, it has to be stated that the socialist parties of the\nmain European countries did not fulfill this task of theirs, and the behavior of the\nleaders of these parties — especially the German one — borders on direct\nbetrayal of the cause of socialism. At the moment of the greatest world-historical\nimportance, the majority of the leaders of the current, second (1889–1914)\nSocialist International are trying to replace socialism with nationalism. Due to\ntheir behavior, the workers' parties of these countries did not oppose themselves\nto the criminal behavior of the governments, but called the working class to\nmerge their position with the position of the imperialist governments. The\nleaders of the International committed treason in relation to socialism, voting for\nwar credits, repeating the chauvinistic (\"patriotic\") slogans of the bourgeoisie of\n\"their\" countries, justifying and defending the war, entering the bourgeois\nministries of the warring countries, etc., etc. The most influential socialist leaders\nand the most influential organs of the socialist press of modern Europe stand on\na chauvinistic-bourgeois and liberal [by the way, nothing has fundamentally\nchanged since then], by no means on a socialist point of view. The responsibility\nfor this disgrace of socialism falls primarily on the German Social-Democrats,\nwho were the strongest and most influential party of the Second International\"\n[8, pp. 623-624].\n\"The collapse of the Second International is the collapse of opportunism\n[apostasy and conciliation], which was cultivated on the soil of the features of\nthe past (the so-called \"peaceful\") historical epoch and gained actual domination\nin the International in recent years. The opportunists had long been preparing\nthis collapse, denying the socialist revolution and replacing it with bourgeois\nreformism; denying the class struggle with its necessary transformation at\ncertain moments into a civil war and preaching class cooperation...\n\n\f...It is impossible to fulfill the tasks of socialism at the present time, it is\nimpossible to realize the real international cohesion of workers without a decisive\nbreak with opportunism and explaining to the masses the inevitability of its\nfiasco.\n[In other words, the war and the inability of the European social-democrats to\nresist the bourgeoisie, their conciliation with the slogans of the bourgeoisie\ntestify to the collapse of the Second International, which Lenin proposes not to\nhush up, but on the contrary, to recognize and emphasize. Without demarcation\nfrom such a position of the bourgeoisie, it is impossible to fulfill the tasks of\nsocialism — it is absolutely impossible to realize the international cohesion of\nworkers without a break with the apostates and conciliators].\nThe task of the social-democrats of each country must be in the first place the\nstruggle against the chauvinism of the given country.\n...In the current position, it is impossible to determine, from the point of view of\nthe international proletariat, the defeat of which of the two groups of belligerent\nnations would be the least evil for socialism. But for us, Russian socialdemocrats, there can be no doubt that from the point of view of the working\nclass and the working masses of all the peoples of Russia, the least evil would be\nthe defeat of the tsarist monarchy, the most reactionary and barbaric\ngovernment, oppressing the greatest number of nations and the greatest mass\nof the population of Europe and Asia.\nThe immediate political slogan of the social-democrats of Europe should be the\nformation of a republican United States of Europe, and in contrast to the\nbourgeoisie... the social-democrats will explain all the falsity and senselessness\nof this slogan without the revolutionary overthrow of the German, Austrian and\nRussian monarchies.\nIn Russia, the tasks of the social-democrats, due to the greatest backwardness\nof this country, which has not yet completed its bourgeois revolution, should still\nbe the three main conditions of a consistent democratic transformation: a\ndemocratic republic (with full equality and self-determination of all nations),\nconfiscation of landlords' lands and an 8-hour working day. But in all advanced\ncountries, the war puts the slogan of socialist revolution on the agenda. ...The\nuse by the bourgeoisie of the laws of wartime for completely silencing the\nproletariat sets before it the unconditional task of creating illegal forms of\nagitation and organization. ...The Proletarian International has not perished and\nwill not perish. The working masses will create a new International through all\nobstacles. The current triumph of opportunism is not long-lasting. The more\nvictims of the war there are, the clearer it will be for the working masses of the\nbetrayal of the workers' cause by the opportunists and the necessity to turn\nweapons against the governments and the bourgeoisie of each country\" [8, pp.\n626-627].\n\n\fSumming up all the \"pros\" and \"cons\" in the current international situation,\ni.e., analyzing the probable direction of change in the ratio of the active\n(contentful) and passive (formal) components in the relation composed of\nthem, and in this regard basing on the necessity of replacing the relation\n{people (instigated by the bourgeoisie) of one country / people (instigated by\nthe bourgeoisie) of another country} with a more contentful and therefore\nmore correct relation {proletariat of the belligerent countries / bourgeoisie of\nthe belligerent countries}, composed of objectively internally conflicting\ncomponents, Lenin comes to the conclusion that: \"The transformation of the\nmodern imperialist war into a civil war is the only correct proletarian slogan,\nindicated by the experience of the Commune... and following from all the\nconditions of the imperialist war between highly developed bourgeois\ncountries. However great the difficulties of such a transformation may seem\nat one or another moment, socialists will never abandon systematic,\npersistent, steady preparatory work in this direction, once the war has\nbecome a fact. Only on this path will the proletariat be able to break out of\nits dependence on the chauvinist bourgeoisie and in one form or another\nmore or less quickly take decisive steps along the path to the real freedom of\npeoples and along the path to socialism\" [8, p. 628].\n3. The small article \"On the National Pride of the Great Russians\" [8, pp.\n629-632] with a serious subtext of ambiguous views was written in\nDecember 1914.\nFrom the content of the article, first of all, it must be understood that the\nconscious unification of small peoples and nationalities is possible only on the\nbasis of the legalized right of nations to self-determination or a guaranteed\nopportunity for their free secession. And this content echoes the\nideological content of the work \"On the Right of Nations to SelfDetermination\".\nLenin begins his analysis by describing the state of affairs that had developed\nat that moment, when many correct words \"are said, interpreted, shouted...\nabout nationality, about the fatherland... the greatness of the principle of\nnational independence\". Meanwhile, he continues, \"... before us is a very\nwide and very deep ideological current, the roots of which are very firmly\nconnected with the interests of the ruling landlords and capitalists of the\ngreat-power nations. Tens and hundreds of millions are spent annually\non the propaganda of ideas beneficial to these classes...\" [8, p. 629].\nAnd it would be improper for us, Lenin writes, as representatives of a greatpower nation, to forget about the enormous significance of the national\nquestion, especially at a moment when the tsarist monarchy has put millions\nof Great Russians and non-Russians under arms to \"solve\" a whole range of\nnational questions exclusively in accordance with its own interests (the\ninterests of the united nobility, serf-landlords, capitalists), while the same\ntsarist executioners (noblemen and capitalists) subject our beautiful\nhomeland to oppression, violence, and mockery. Today, in Lenin's words, we\nare full of a sense of national pride, for the Great Russian nation, overcoming\n\n\fits slave past, has also created a revolutionary class, has also proven that it\nis capable of giving humanity great examples of the struggle for freedom and\nfor socialism, and not only great pogroms, rows of gallows, dungeons and\ngreat servility before priests, tsars, landlords and capitalists. And we are\nproud because after 1905 the Great Russian muzhik began to become a\ndemocrat and began to overthrow the priest and the landlord. It is precisely\nbecause we want a free and independent, sovereign, democratic, republican,\nproud Great Russia at all costs, building its relations with neighbors on the\nhuman principle of equality, and not on the humiliating great nation feudal\nprinciple of privileges, that we say: one cannot defend the fatherland\notherwise than by fighting with all revolutionary means against the\nmonarchy, landlords and capitalists of one's fatherland, i.e. the worst\nenemies of our homeland; Great Russians cannot defend the fatherland\notherwise than by wishing defeat in any war to tsarism (as the least evil for\nthe overwhelming majority of the population of Great Russia), for tsarism not\nonly oppresses this majority of the population economically and politically,\nbut also demoralizes, humiliates, devalues, prostitutes it, accustoming it to\noppressing foreign peoples, accustoming it to cover up its shame with\nhypocritical, allegedly patriotic phrases. In this connection, from the point\nof view of the interests of precisely the Great Russian proletariat, it is\nnecessary to conduct a long-term education of the population in the sense of\nthe most resolute, consistent, bold, revolutionary defense of full equality and\nthe right to self-determination of all nations oppressed by the Great\nRussians. \"The interest (not understood in a slavish way) of the national\npride of the Great Russians coincides with the socialist interest of the Great\nRussian (and all other) proletarians\" [8, p. 632].\n[As already noted earlier, instead of the terms \"tsarism\", \"bourgeoisie\",\n\"capitalists\", etc., one can safely use terms close in their current meaning:\n\"autocracy\", \"oligarchy\", \"plutocracy\", \"ruling pseudo-elite\", \"comprador\nliberal top\", etc.\nThis article by V.I. Lenin is such a dynamic creation as all the others: from\nthe initial, less contentful, through change — to a prospective,\nmore contentful result and product. Like any other work by Lenin, this article\ncan be structurally and compositionally laid out in the following template.\nInitial point (thesis): the position or view of the ruling class (autocracy,\ntsarism, the emerging and strengthening Great Russian capitalism) on the\nessence of Russian patriotism; i.e., by stating the skin-deep interests of this\nclass, supported by the propaganda of hypocritical kvass patriotism, one\ncomponent of the relation is established. Next point in development\n(antithesis): the essence and definition of Russian patriotism from the point\nof view of the revolutionary proletariat and its interests. In this way, the\nother component of the relation is determined. Then, from the found\ncomponents, a more contentful component is identified (by detecting and\nverifying the falsity, insincerity and untruth of one component, and vice\nversa — the authenticity, truthfulness and greater objectivity of the other)\nand on this basis the correct relation of the found components (synthesis) is\n\n\fbuilt, possessing the property and ability of self-development, — with\nsimultaneous forecasting of the development prospect of the whole relation\nas a whole. As a result of comparing two opposite positions and views on\nRussian patriotism belonging to two different interacting components\n(classes) in the relation {proletariat/tsarism (autocracy)}, the Bolsheviks\ngive preference to the position of the proletariat and, developing, increasing\nthe contentfulness of this position (by explanations, agitation and\npropaganda), achieve its predominance in the integral unified relation, which,\nin the end, in the future and leads to the curtailment of hostilities and the\nend of the bloody imperialist war.\nKnowing in advance that in any conflict, in any interaction there are always\nat\nleast\ntwo\nsides,\ntwo\ncomponents\n(namely:\nthe contentful and Formal components of development) of one relation, by\nthe nature and intensity of whose interaction the rate and completeness of\nthe increase in the contentfulness of the entire relation are determined, — it\nis very important to correctly identify and determine these interacting sidescomponents in order to compose a relation from them; a correctly composed\nrelation of two directly interacting sides (two most essential components)\ngives\nthe\nmost\nenergetic,\neffective\nand\noptimal\nincrease\nin contentfulness and development of both the components separately and\nthe relation as a whole.\nLet us give more examples of correctly composed relations. In the relation\n{wage labor/capital}, the components are inseparable, insignificant without\neach other, and therefore this relation is not contrived, not sucked out of the\nfinger, but natural and natural. The same applies to such (derivative of this\nrelation\nand\naccompanying\nthis\nrelation)\nrelations\nas\n{proletariat/bourgeoisie}, {Soviets/Provisional Bourgeois Government}, etc.\nCorrectly composed relations are easily amenable to research and analysis\n(for example, for the purpose of forecasting the prospects of their change\nand development)].\n[However, the pre-war situation developing in our time seems somewhat\ndifferent than on the eve of the First World War: it is beneficial for both\ninternational and national (to preserve their status quo) capital that Russia\nshould give up its positions, while today's have-nots (wage workers) are\ninherent in patriotism — as something that is present in them from birth, and\nnot bought or appropriated. Therefore, the slogan or call \"for the\nMotherland!\" is sincere and modern as never before precisely for the\ncommon people (in the hope of the coming socialist social transformations).\nThe \"comprador\" top thinks quite differently, there is no trace of patriotism\nthere — on the contrary, the latter is oppressed and despised by all forces\nand means.\nThe litmus test of Russian patriotism today is the attitude towards Crimea\nand Donbass. The entire \"patriotism\" of oligarchs and plutocrats consists in\njustifying the circumstance that financial-industrial (oligarchic and state-\n\n\fmonopolistic) structures do not \"bring\" either business or banks to Donbass\nand partially to Crimea (ignoring the problems of people living in the\nspecified territories) allegedly so as not to harm the whole country. In fact,\nhere one can see simple fears for their personal \"hides\", which may be\nspoiled by the notorious Western sanctions. Furthermore, the supply of all\ntypes of fuel (and other energy resources), spare parts and components to\nthe armed forces of a hostile state killing people on the territory of Donbass\n— is also evidence of the same \"patriotism\" of the same structures. If one\ndigs deep enough, one can find a lot of amazing, shameful and criminal\nthings in the actions and behavior of today's \"domestic\" bourgeoisie.\nThe problem of Novorossiya can be resolved in the shortest possible time\nprovided that the issue of neutralizing the ruling \"comprador\" top of the\nRussian plutocratic state is resolved. Even the \"Washington regional\ncommittee\" does not play such a significant role here. In fact, everything\nboils down to eradicating sabotage and overcoming resistance within the\ncountry (treason — that is what it was called in hoary antiquity).]\n[The policy of the current \"ruler\" towards Donbass is an ostrich head in the\nsand, a policy of betrayal and apostasy towards the Russian people living\nthere. Only a cowardly, well-fed, ruling, venal bourgeois top can endure and\nbear the dictate and mockery of the overseas \"hegemon\" (unremittingly\nsupervising all decisions on Donbass). A timid \"governor\" who lacks the will\nand ability to cope with his \"comprador\" entourage — this is the reason for\nthe lack of positive effect and the required outcome in solving the problem of\nDonbass (and Novorossiya as a whole). The key to solving this problem is in\nMoscow. But an indecisive and venal \"ruler\" is unlikely to cope with this task;\na leader with stronger convictions and righteousness is needed. How many\nbloody conflicts could have been \"nipped in the bud\" if one did not follow the\nwake of the requests and goals of the financial-industrial oligarchate, to\nwhom their own business projects and profits are much closer and more\nimportant than the interests of an entire country with its people.\nPeople whom he reassured expect protection and help from the current\n\"ruler\", and he time and again cowardly tucks his tail in fear of losing his\nwell-being and the favor (support) of his companions — god forbid the\nWestern masters \"cut off the oxygen\" for him and his entourage as well. Feel\nthe difference: an incorruptible, resolute and fearless revolutionary Lenin on\nthe one hand, and venal, dependent in everything on the overseas\n\"hegemon\" (and therefore — timid and indecisive) current \"rulers\" on the\nother. On the eve of a quite probable \"hot\" war, Russia can only be saved by\na \"purge\" of the ranks (according to Lenin) and the neutralization of the \"fifth\ncolumn\" (according to Stalin). Unity, firmness and support of the people in\nthis matter are unshakable.\nThe perfect weapon created thanks to the contentful resource of the people\n— this should be the main argument of the modern \"governor\" in response to\nthe unprecedented onslaught and pressure from the \"hegemon\". Instead of\n\n\forganizing a well-thought-out series of \"jabs\" (inflicting damage on the\noverseas \"hegemon\" in a volume sufficient to demoralize the public\nconsciousness of the \"democratizers\") and thus showing who is the master in\nthe house by demonstrating the advantages of their latest military equipment\nand military skill, our \"rulers\" are incessantly bowing and scraping and\nbowing. One wonders, who and why then need expensive military \"toys\", if\nthere is no skill and understanding of how to use them for the benefit of the\npeople? They are needed, first of all, to stop the dictatorship of the aggressor\nfor years to come by inflicting on him a sufficiently disorganizing property\nand moral damage.\nThey are playing a dishonest game (a game without any rules) against us,\nand the \"rulers\", instead of worthily responding with the excellent means at\ntheir disposal, shamefully justify themselves and wipe themselves off every\ntime after mocking spits from the completely impudent \"hegemon\".\nThe people have vested the current \"ruler\" with power and high powers so\nthat he, on behalf of the people, would not allow the honor and dignity of the\npeople to be trampled. If there is no strength to parry the attacks of the\ncollective West — one should step aside and not cling to power, as Lenin did\nnot cling to it, although he had much more reasons to be vested with this\npower. Moreover, one should step aside and take with him his diplomatic\nteam of chronic whiners and moaners who do not know how to confront the\ninsolent riff-raff and therefore constantly justify their worthlessness and\ninefficiency.\nWhat the hell is all this military might needed for in the full disposal of the\ncurrent \"governor\" (even if it is situationally transferred, for now), if he does\nnot have the will to implement his own policy, does not know how to use this\ntrump card for the benefit of the country and the people, if he stumbles and\ncowardly retreats at the first shout and askance look from the Western\n\"master\"? The timid and indecisive bungler should give way to a stronger,\nmore resourceful, more purposeful, more courageous leader...\nThe understanding and justification of the admissibility and necessity of a\nRussian force response in this particular case is facilitated by referring to the\nwell-known views of Clausewitz regarding the means of conducting state\npolicy. It is enough to keep in mind that politics (as an instrument of\npressure and imposition by various methods of worldview, position, point of\nview, way of life, etc., etc. of one group of people on another group of\npeople) implies a very extensive set of means and techniques of influencing\na partner, competitor, adversary or enemy, among which there may be\nmethods of an encouraging, stimulating, preventive, economic, intimidating,\nforceful and any other nature. Every political player is free to choose at his\ndiscretion the most suitable means of influence from the entire arsenal of\navailable means contrary to the detrimental opinion on the matter that one\ncan and should play only by the rules established by individual players (or a\nplayer) claiming exclusivity and absolute dominance. In the times of\n\n\funprecedented trampling of all international rights and rules that have come,\nit is worth, perhaps, finally starting to play by one's own rules (?) or to\nreconcile and finally allow oneself to be buried alive? Moreover, any\nexclusivity is alien (foreign) to our international education in the spirit of\n\"man is a friend, comrade and brother to man\", and therefore claims to\nexclusivity and absolutism in this context should be curbed immediately.\nContrary to and in opposition to the hypocritical foreign policy of not simple\ncontainment and economic pressure, but real strangulation and\ndestruction of Russia — it has long been time for Russia to move on to\nretaliatory sobering \"jabs\" (i.e., to counteract by those means that it has in\nits arsenal and that are most appropriate and effective in the given\ncircumstances).\n\"Well, what else should we expect? We keep begging. We get it on one\ncheek, and immediately offer the other. And so on to infinity. This will not\nend with anything good. In the end, if we survive, it is by accident. at the\nlast moment and at a very high cost. As, indeed, we always do... \" [14].\nEnough to express toothless and spineless diplomatic concern about the\ninsolent antics of the Anglo-Saxon conglomerate and its minions. It is\nnecessary to wean them from arbitrarily hindering the development of\nanyone by methods of economic, political and any other blockade (i.e.,\nthrough the so-called sanctions). We are talking about the sacred right of\nevery people, every nation to free economic and political development\n(in this regard, it is appropriate to recall the classical Marxist position, known\nfor its dialectics and indisputable justice, according to which only the free\ndevelopment of each is the condition for the free development of all). Not\neveryone understands today, unfortunately, that this right still has to be\nfought for, fought — and fought with all available means. And the fulfillment\nof this noble mission on an international scale can quite well be taken upon\nby Russia (possibly with its allies). Our people will understand the necessity\nand expediency of such preemptive steps and will support them most\nresolutely. If you do not want to walk as an \"outcast\" and eventually end up\nin some kind of \"reservation\" — you will have to destroy the established\n\"sanction\" system once and for all, using the force you have or at least\ncreating a threat of inevitable use of force. And to restore the lost status quo,\none must be ready to forcibly bring the \"democratizer\" out of the state of\nmaterial and moral comfort that seems to him eternal and cloudless. This\nmust be taken seriously. No one else will do this hard work for us. But. it\nseems that the current fattening government is quite satisfied with the\nestablished order of things.\nAnd again we ask ourselves the same rhetorical question: what are all these\nexpensive military means needed for, if not for ensuring the political and\neconomic freedom, independence and sovereignty of the people, who created\nthese security means for exactly this same purpose?\nAfter proclaiming such a doctrine and simultaneously carrying out several\nseries of demonstrative preventive \"jabs\", for many years these genderless\n\n\fstate\nformations\n(resembling\ntoday\nthe\nfancied-up\nstrutting\n\"misunderstandings\") will not dare to look askance at Russia or raise their\nvoice; at least until they come to their senses and in an urgent reverse order\n\"re-shoe\" themselves into the traditional, due to dialectical nature, two-sex\n(bipolar) execution. And that rooster cry with which they will be hoarse at the\nmoment of receiving a deserved thrashing will once again demonstrate to\nother peoples the fallacy and inconsistency of all these \"democratic mentors\",\nas well as the sham character of any rashly proclaimed hegemony and\nexclusivity.\nParadoxical as it may sound, this is precisely the most effective way\nto prevent a global war today.]\n4. The article \"On the Slogan of the United States of Europe\" [8, pp.\n633-636] was written in August 1915. It deals with the incorrectness\n(untimeliness) of this slogan in the economic aspect. If in the political aspect\nthis slogan, put in connection with the revolutionary overthrow of the three\nmost reactionary monarchies of Europe (German, Austrian and Russian), is\ncompletely invulnerable, there remains the most important question about\nthe economic content and significance of this slogan. \"From the point of view\nof the economic conditions of imperialism, i.e. the export of capital and the\ndivision of the world by \"advanced\" and \"civilized\" colonial powers, the United\nStates of Europe under capitalism is either impossible or reactionary\", since\n\"it amounts to an agreement on the division of colonies\" [8, pp. 634635].\nCapital has become international and monopolistic; the world is divided\namong a handful of \"great powers\" succeeding in great robbery and\noppression of nations. In the era of the highest development of capitalism, a\nhandful of great powers have organized the robbery of about a billion of the\nEarth's population. [Isn't this relevant today, and even to a greater extent?\nYou read Lenin's article more than a century old, and it seems as if it is\nwritten about our time!]. A different organization (i.e. voluntary renunciation\nof colonies, spheres of influence, export of capital) is impossible under\ncapitalism, as are a different basis and a different principle of division, except\nfor force. Capitalism is private ownership of the means of production and the\nanarchy of production. To preach a \"fair\" division of income on such a basis is\nthe dull-wittedness of a philistine. A billionaire cannot share income with\nanyone else otherwise than in proportion \"according to capital\". Hence — it\ncannot be divided otherwise than \"by force\" [i.e. by force methods]. And\nforce changes with the course of economic development, and to check the\nactual force of a developing capitalist state, there is and can be no other\nmeans except war. Under capitalism [due to the anarchy and spontaneity of\nmarket production], uniform growth of economic development of individual\nfarms and individual states is impossible, and therefore under capitalism\nthere are no other means of restoring from time to time the disturbed\nequilibrium and eliminating disproportions than crises in industry and\nwars in politics. War is not in contradiction with the foundations of private\nproperty, but is a consequence of the direct and inevitable development of\n\n\fthese foundations (i.e. the need for periodic revision and redistribution of the\naccumulations of private property).\nThus, based on what has been said on the modern economic basis, i.e. under\ncapitalism, the United States of Europe would mean the organization of\nreaction to delay the faster development of America. The times when the\ncause of democracy and the cause of socialism were connected only with\nEurope have passed irrevocably. Under such conditions, the slogan \"United\nStates of the World\" would be more correct and relevant, however, it could\ngive rise to an incorrect interpretation of the question in the impossibility of\nthe victory of socialism in one country [8, p. 636].\nThe unevenness of economic and political development is an absolute law of\ncapitalism. It follows from this that the victory of socialism is possible initially\nin a few or even in one single capitalist country. The political form of society\nin which the proletariat wins, overthrowing the bourgeoisie, will be a\ndemocratic republic, increasingly centralizing the forces of the proletariat of a\ngiven nation or given nations in the struggle against states that have not yet\ntransitioned to socialism. On the basis of the foregoing, Lenin comes to the\nconclusion (makes a diagnosis) about the impossibility of destroying\nclasses without the dictatorship of the oppressed class and the\nimpossibility of the free unification of nations in socialism without a more or\nless long, persistent struggle of socialist republics with backward states. By\nvirtue of these considerations, a conclusion is made about the incorrectness\nof the slogan of the United States of Europe at this particular historical\nmoment [8, p. 636], since it will be expressed in the postponement of the\nbeginning of the socialist revolution.\n[Contentful essence of the socialist revolution, as noted in the article, is\nrealized and presented not in the form of a one-time act, but in a whole\nseries (epoch) of forms of political revolutions and counter-revolutions,\nviolent political and economic upheavals, aggravated class struggle, civil\nwars, etc.\nWith regard to social transformations in Russia, the ultimately accomplished\nsocialist revolution with an aim at building a classless society is just an initial\nstage or the first stage of the implementation of the socialist movement,\nwhich in the future will only expand, deepen and accelerate. At the same\ntime, intermittency, stops, sharp turns, jerks, declines, rises (i.e. sections of\nvisible regression and backward movement: crises, wars, coups, revolutions,\ncounter-revolutions, etc.) are quite natural for this kind of movement and\nonly confirm the spiral-cyclical nature of social development (as well as\nuniversal development as a whole).\nIt is the striving to achieve the highest contentfulness by the forms-carriers\nof social progress that will serve as the main factor causing periodic\nreference to the theoretical and practical developments generalizing the\n\n\fresults and experience of all previous stages of the mentioned revolutionary\nmovement.\nHere Lenin informs the reader that Switzerland, for example (and some\nsimilar \"successful\" and \"prosperous\" dwarf state formations), is the result of\nan agreement of international capital on the arrangement of completely\nneutral quiet \"coves\" and \"harbors\" for the reliable storage of funds,\norganization of recreation and tourism of the fat cats. It was also conceived\nby the mighty of this world as a place where the owners of large capital could\ncatch their breath and rest from \"righteous\" labors next to their savings and\naccumulations. Thus, the defiantly colorful and openly transparent seemingly\nshell of some state structure turns out to be just a screen, shielding from the\neyes of outsiders the inconspicuous true essence and purpose of such a\nstructure, once erected by the efforts of a small handful of interested\npersons. Class solidarity, guarding the interests of the masters of life, will\nnever allow the transition to transparency of relations of production,\naccumulation and consumption under capitalism. However, everything\nrelated to the contentful resource of one or another form and the sources of\nits accumulations will always be under lock and key and seals].\n5. The article \"The Military Program of the Proletarian Revolution\" [8,\npp. 751-761] was written in German in September 1916, and was printed\nonly a year later. Then it was intended for Swiss, Swedish and Norwegian left\nSocial-Democrats. The publication was preceded by the following foreword:\n\"Nowadays, when Lenin is one of those figures of the Russian revolution who\nare most often spoken about, the following article of this old iron\nrevolutionary, outlining a significant part of his political program, is of\nparticular interest\" [8, p. 834]. In the Russian language in Russia, this work\nwas first published only in 1929.\nStructurally and compositionally, the article is built according to the same very\ntypical stencil: analysis of the current situation (state of affairs); identification of\nthe interacting sides in their relation, both old and new (transformed and\ndeveloped); determination of the active, leading, leading component in these\nrelations, especially in the new one; forecasting the direction of variability of\nboth the components-constituents themselves in this new relation and the\nrelation as a whole.\nThe appearance of this article was caused by the circumstance that along with\nthe justified and fair opposition to the false slogan of the social-chauvinists about\nthe \"defense of the fatherland\" in the ongoing imperialist war, voices began to be\nheard in favor of replacing the old point of the Social-Democratic program\n\"arming of the people\" (formation of a \"militia\") with the new point\n\"disarmament\".\n\"The main argument is that the demand for disarmament is the most consistent\nexpression of the struggle against all militarism and against any war.\" But in this\nargument lies the main fallacy of the supporters of disarmament: socialists,\n\n\fwithout ceasing to be socialists, cannot be against any war, and in particular a\nrevolutionary war, a national liberation war, a civil war (as well as the so-called\n\"defensive\" wars of the victorious proletariat against the bourgeoisie of other\ncountries) [8, pp. 751-752]. And from a scientific point of view, it would be\ncompletely incorrect and unrevolutionary to bypass or obscure the most\nimportant and most difficult thing: the necessity of suppressing the resistance of\nthe bourgeoisie during the transition to socialism. And in wars of this kind, to\nrecognize \"defense of the fatherland\" means to consider these wars \"just\" and\ncorresponding to the interests of the proletariat, since a reverse invasion of the\nbourgeoisie cannot be excluded in any war and, accordingly, resistance to such\nan invasion must be organized.\n[Establishing a new relation with new components in this new relation in place of\nthe relation {Entente (Great Britain, France, Russia) / Triple Alliance (Germany,\nAustria-Hungary, Italy)} (since new forces that entered into a new confrontation\nand war were awakened: {proletarian plus national revolution / bourgeois plus\nnational-chauvinistic war}) requires finding a new correlation of these new\ncomponents in the indicated relation, i.e. finding a new balance of the new forces\nthat have entered the arena.\nThus, analyzing the predatory conflict through the prism of the previously\nincorrectly composed relation {people (instigated by the bourgeoisie) of one\ncountry / people (instigated by the bourgeoisie) of another country} and\nshowing the hypocrisy and duplicity of the slogans of such falsely understood\npatriotism, Lenin moves on to a more correctly composed and substantiated\nrelation from such components {proletariat of the conflicting countries /\nbourgeoisie of the conflicting countries} and already, proceeding from this new\nrelation, one has to look for the correlation of its components, the direction of\nvariability of this correlation and the direction of change (new forms) of the\nrelation itself].\nTheoretically, Lenin says, it would be completely erroneous to forget that any\nwar is only a continuation of politics by other means: the current imperialist war\nis a continuation of the imperialist policy of two groups of great powers, and this\npolicy is generated and fed by the totality of relations of the imperialist epoch.\nBut the same epoch must necessarily generate and feed the policy of struggle\nagainst national oppression, and the struggle of the proletariat against the\nbourgeoisie, and therefore — the possibility and inevitability of revolutionary\nnational uprisings and wars, on the one hand, and wars and uprisings of the\nproletariat against the bourgeoisie, on the other hand, as well as the unification\nof both types of revolutionary wars [8, p. 754]\nTo this, Lenin adds the following consideration: one cannot forget that we\nlive in a class society and there is and can be no other way out of it than\nthrough the class struggle. In any class society (based on slavery, serfdom,\nwage labor), the oppressing class is armed (the military and the militia are taken\ninto account — otherwise, in the absence of means of suppression, social\ninequality or imbalance could not be maintained for an indefinitely long\n\n\ftime). The arming of the bourgeoisie against the proletariat is one of the most\nbasic facts of capitalist society. And to proclaim the slogan of disarmament for\nthe proletariat against this background is tantamount to abandoning the point of\nview of the class struggle. On the contrary, the arming of the proletariat is the\nonly possible tactic of the revolutionary class, a tactic dictated by the entire\nobjective development of capitalist militarism, prescribed by this development.\nAnd therefore our slogan should be the arming of the proletariat [i.e. increasing\nthe contentfulness of the form (the proletarian class) at a certain — force — sublevel of this form] in order to defeat and disarm the bourgeoisie. Saying that\n\"capitalist society was and always is horror without end\", Lenin masterfully notes\nthe trend of piling up contentful accumulations conditioned by military actions,\nleading to \"an end with horror\" (a terrible end). And at the same time, contrary\nto established beliefs, behind this \"terrible end\" he sees the emergence and\nemergence of a new form and, accordingly, a new perspective, consisting in the\nfact that \"before everyone's eyes, by the forces of the bourgeoisie itself, the only\nlegitimate and revolutionary war is being prepared, namely: civil war against the\nimperialist bourgeoisie\" [8, p. 755] with a new contentful turn in the course of\nthe upcoming contentful transformations and transformations.\n\"Now militarization penetrates all public life\" [8, p. 756]: today the imperialist\nbourgeoisie militarizes the entire male population, including youth, and in the\nplans for tomorrow — the militarization of women as well. Regarding this, one\ncan say: so much the better, the sooner and closer to the armed uprising against\ncapitalism. Mastering military science is necessary for the proletariat not in order\nto shoot at their brothers, workers of other countries, as is done in the current\nwar, but in order to fight against the bourgeoisie of their own country, to put an\nend to exploitation, poverty and wars not by kind wishes and hopes, by\nstatements of condemnation and concern, but by victory over the bourgeoisie\nand disarming it, which is achieved only by waging war against war, i.e. by civil\nconfrontation and civil war.\nThe main disadvantage of the demand for disarmament lies precisely in the fact\nthat all concrete questions of the revolution are left unattended (ignored). The\n\"disarmament\" of the proletariat (people), Lenin insists, professed by conciliators\nwith the bourgeoisie of all stripes (opportunists, following Lenin's terminology), is\nprecisely an escape from the vile reality, and not a struggle against it [the\nfundamental transformation of the established reality is possible only by decisive\nactions with weapons in hand]. The struggle against imperialism, not connected\nwith the struggle against opportunism, is an empty phrase and a deception. The\nmain danger emanating from all varieties of opportunism [i.e. conciliation and\napostasy] is that they hush up (or talk out) the question of the connection of the\nongoing war with the revolution and thus come out with a new absurd slogan:\nrevolution without weapons [8, pp. 757-758].\nFurthermore, the bourgeoisie of all great imperialist powers has become so\nreactionary [i.e. striving to avoid crisis and restore the lost balance in affairs]\nand so imbued with the striving for world domination [i.e. to achieve\ntheir contentful superiority] that any war on the part of the bourgeoisie of these\n\n\fcountries can only be reactionary. The proletariat should be not only against any\nsuch war, but should wish for the defeat of \"its\" government in such wars and\nuse it for a revolutionary armed uprising, if an uprising with the aim of\npreventing the war fails [8, pp. 758-759].\nWith the conciliators (fighters for the disarmament of the people) one cannot\nfight by means of programs alone, but only by means of relentless observation\nto ensure that they are actually implemented. The largest fatal mistake of the\nbankrupt Second International was that the word did not correspond to the\ndeed, that a habit of hypocrisy and shameless revolutionary phrase was\ncultivated. Disarmament as a social idea is generated, obviously, by the special\n\"peaceful\" living conditions of individual small states, which have stood aside\nfrom the bloody world road of wars for quite a long time and hope to remain so.\nThe petty-bourgeois desire to stay away from the great battles of world history,\nto use their relatively monopolistic position for passivity — this is the objective\nsocial environment that can provide the idea of disarmament with a certain\nsuccess and a certain spread in some small states. Of course, this aspiration is\nreactionary and rests on illusions, for imperialism one way or another drags\nsmall states into the whirlpool of the world economy and world politics. [This\n\"wonderful\" side or feature of the arrangement of \"well-fed\" lazy, arrogantly\nhaughty communities and societies must always be taken into account: their\nimpudently-pushy essence can be overcome by active persistent impact on them\nuntil the moment of their scattering to their shelters; brave and \"pushy\" at first,\nthey are not able to withstand a long siege and continuous onslaught, leading to\ntheir physiological discomfort or threatening complete physical destruction].\nSwitzerland, for example, its imperialist situation prescribes two lines of the\nworkers' movement: 1) the opportunists in alliance with the bourgeoisie strive to\nturn Switzerland into a republican-democratic monopolistic union to profit from\nthe tourists of the imperialist bourgeoisie and so that this \"peaceful\" monopolistic\nposition (a quiet \"harbor\") is as profitable as possible [here lie the roots of the\nsuccess, prosperity and well-being of neutral dwarf states like Switzerland and\nthe like. The quiet \"backwaters\" of Switzerland and similar small lands, where\none can sit out and hide one's savings in days of great crises and upheavals,\nwere prepared by the rich for themselves in advance — that is why these \"areas\"\nreceived such a lush bloom in inviolability]; 2) the real Social-Democrats of\nSwitzerland seek to use the relative freedom and \"international\" position of\nSwitzerland to help the close alliance of revolutionary elements of the workers'\nparties of Europe to win.\n[Both lines are conditioned by the special position and the historically established\nstatus quo of a small country].\nProceeding from these two pronounced tendencies, it becomes clear, Lenin sums\nup, that objectively \"disarmament\" is a specifically national program of small\nstates, and by no means an international program of revolutionary international\nSocial-Democracy [8, pp. 759-761].\n\n\fAnd then the hottest pre-revolutionary times came. One would think that the\nrhetoric and style of Lenin's articles should have become chaotic and less\nordered; however, no — all the same sustained and balanced tone, the same\nunhurried, patient deep analysis, the unhurried course of the presentation of\nthought, which lead to the most correct remarkable conclusions, based by no\nmeans on unfounded calls and slogans, but on the ability to see the general\nobjective behind individual specific facts, i.e. to guess and expose the regular\nin the process of building a dialectically verified scheme of analysis.\n6. Small in volume, but extremely rich in Content and permeated through and\nthrough with the spirit of dialectics, the article \"On Dual Power\" [9, pp. 16-18]\nwas written in April 1917. The fundamental question of any revolution, Lenin\nwrites at the beginning of the article, is the question of power in the state. But\nthe remarkable peculiarity of the current revolution is that it has created dual\npower, which no one thought of or could think of before. Therefore, the old\n\"formulas\" of Bolshevism must be supplemented and corrected. Dual power\nconsists in the fact that next to the Provisional Government of the bourgeoisie,\nanother government has emerged: the Soviets of Workers' and Soldiers'\nDeputies. Thus, there is a relation composed or formed of two sidescomponents: {\"growing\" government of the people in the face of the Soviets of\nWorkers' and Soldiers' (i.e. peasants dressed in soldiers' uniforms) Deputies /\ngovernment of the bourgeoisie}. The peculiarity of the people's power consists in\nthe fact that it: firstly, represents a revolutionary dictatorship, since its source is\nnot the law, but the direct initiative of the masses from below, i.e.\nrevolutionary\n\"seizure\"\n[the\nsource\nof\npower\nis\nsome\ninternal contentful (energetic) constituent of reality, determining the deep\nstriving of the people (or a group of people); power itself is the external form of\nacquiring this contentful constituent]; secondly, it carries out the replacement of\nthe police and the army by the armed people; thirdly, it places officials and the\nbureaucracy under the control of the armed people with the possibility of\nreplacing personnel at the first demand of the people and paying labor no higher\nthan the usual wage of a good worker [this extremely important and remarkable\nmove (technique) of the nascent power was invented by no means by Lenin and\nthe Bolsheviks, but was only successfully and justifiably implemented by the\nBolshevik government after the victory of the Great October Socialist Revolution.\nThis was an act approved by the people, in confirmation of the establishment of\na more just distribution of the worked-out product. By the way, both the\n\"Soviets\" and our proud word \"comrade\" and many other similar fashionable\nterms and concepts of that time are also not inventions of Lenin and company,\nbut verbal constructions corresponding to the achievements of the advanced\nenlightened thought of that time, skillfully used by the Bolsheviks in organizing\nthe public arrangement of a new type]. Thus, a state is formed according to the\ntype of the Paris Commune of 1871.\nAt the same time, this is only an embryonic power, for it still yields positions to\nthe bourgeoisie. The reason is the insufficient consciousness and organization of\nthe proletarians and peasants. The uncertainty of the new power is revealed by\nthe simple question it poses: should the Provisional Government be overthrown\n\n\fimmediately? Lenin answers this question as follows: 1) the government must\nbe overthrown — for it is oligarchic, bourgeois, and not nationwide, it can give\nneither peace, nor bread, nor freedom; 2) however, it cannot be overthrown\nnow, for it is held together by a formal and actual agreement with the Soviets of\nWorkers' Deputies; 3) it cannot be overthrown in the usual way at all, for it relies\non the support of the bourgeoisie by the Council of Workers' Deputies, which is\nthe only possible revolutionary government, directly expressing the\nconsciousness and will of the majority of workers and peasants (and above,\nbetter than this type of government, as the Soviets of workers, farm laborers,\npeasant, soldier deputies, humanity has not developed and we still do not know).\nHence, \"to become power, conscious workers must win the majority over to their\nside: as long as there is no violence against the masses, there is no\nother way to power\" [9, p. 18].\nThe bourgeoisie is for the sole power of the bourgeoisie, while the conscious\nworkers are for the sole power of the Soviets of workers, farm laborers, peasant\nand soldier deputies, for sole power prepared by the clarification of proletarian\nconsciousness and its liberation from the influence of the bourgeoisie, and not by\nadventures [i.e. the current relation from the indicated components (see above)\nmust now be enriched with content, saturated with contentfulness by feeding its\nupper component, the \"numerator\", with Content, in order to strengthen it as\nthe leading component by clarifying and enriching the proletarian\nconsciousness].\nThus, as we see, again guided by the dialectical method, Lenin precisely and\nunambiguously determines both the relation of the main componentsconstituents of development at this particular stage of the revolutionary\nmovement, and the actual class correlation of forces-components within the\nrelation composed by him, which determines (we are talking about the\ncorrelation) the tasks for the near-term development of the revolutionary\nsituation and the direction of the subsequent movement or change of this\nrelation as a whole.\n[This article is a classic example of skillful, filigree mastery of dialectics and its\neffective application].\n7. In the article \"Three Crises\" [9, pp. 124-127], written by Lenin in July 1917,\nvarious forms of the course of the revolution are considered (primarily from class\npositions). Three objective political crises that determined the nature of the\ncourse of the revolutionary process of that period served as the basis for lies and\nslander [i.e. numerous \"fakes\", as they would say in our time] about the artificial\norganization of these crises by the hands of the Bolsheviks. Objectively common\nto all three crises is the \"overflowing\" discontent of the people with the\nbourgeoisie and its government, which allows us to see behind all this the\nincessant class struggle. Individually in these crises — these are different forms\nof conducting (manifestation) of the mentioned class struggle. In all three cases\n— this is a demonstration, but: in the first case — stormy-spontaneous,\nunorganized, leading to shooting at the demonstrators by the Black Hundreds; in\n\n\fthe second case — appointed by the Bolsheviks, canceled and postponed to a\nnew date, a general more powerful demonstration with the predominance of\nBolshevik slogans; in the third case — a spontaneous rise of counter-revolution\ncontrary to the efforts of the Bolsheviks.\nAn instructive conclusion from the events under consideration, as Lenin notes, is\n\"that all three crises show us a certain. new in the history of our revolution, form\nof a demonstration of a more complex type, with a wave-like movement [from\nextreme to extreme], a rapid rise and a steep fall, with an aggravation of the\nrevolution and counter-revolution, with the \"washing out\", for a more or less\nlong time, of the middle elements\" [9, pp. 125-126].\nLenin masterfully notes that in such periods of acute political crises, the\ncontradictions between the main \"players\" of the revolutionary action are\naggravated [in this case between the components of the very main relation\n{proletariat/bourgeoisie}], while some intermediate \"middle elements\"\naccompanying every turmoil are pushed aside: \"But the point is that this is not\nan ordinary demonstration, it is much more than a demonstration and less than\na revolution. This is an explosion of revolution and counter-revolution together,\nthis is a sharp, sometimes almost sudden \"washing out\" of the middle elements\nin connection with the stormy manifestation of proletarian and bourgeois\n[elements]\" [9, p. 126].\nThe objective clash of two opposing sides, two classes — the proletariat and the\nbourgeoisie — corresponds to the political struggle of their parties — the\nBolsheviks and the Cadets. At the same time, the \"middle elements\" accuse the\nCadets that they facilitate the work of the Bolsheviks, and the Bolsheviks that\nthey facilitate the work of the Cadets. Now, Lenin says, if instead of political\nnames we substitute class ones, then we get the dreams of the petty bourgeoisie\nabout the \"disappearance\" of the class struggle between the proletariat and the\nbourgeoisie. And then follows an objective and dialectically verified conclusion\nthat no Bolsheviks in the world could have \"caused\" not only three, but even one\n\"popular movement\", if the deepest economic and political reasons did not\nset the proletariat in motion, that no Cadets and monarchists together can\ncause any movement \"from the right\", if equally deep reasons did not create\nthe counter-revolutionary nature of the bourgeoisie as a class [9, pp.\n126-127].\nThis is an indicator of the petty bourgeoisie's misunderstanding of the\nmechanism or essence of the class struggle of the proletariat against the\nbourgeoisie. Since the vast majority of the country's population is pettybourgeois in their life situation and even more so in their ideas, and in the\nconfrontation with large capital (in the face of banks and syndicates in the first\nplace) the urban proletariat is not yet capable of immediately winning over the\nmajority of the semi-proletarians and other strata of the population, such an\nobjectively formed situation [corresponding to the objectively formed at the\ncurrent moment correlation of force-components in the main class relation\n\n\f{proletariat/bourgeoisie}] will be expressed in the inevitability of crises similar to\nthe three crises under consideration in their three forms.\n[Economic and political crises (the confrontation of two deeply non-equilibrium\ncomponents of the known relation {proletariat/bourgeoisie}) set in motion both\nthe revolutionary proletariat (with its form of government or power — the\nSoviets of workers', soldiers' and peasants' deputies) on the one hand, and the\ncounter-revolutionary bourgeoisie (with its form of government — the Provisional\nGovernment) on the other. At the same time, the \"middle elements\" (petty\nbourgeoisie) with their parties (the Socialist-Revolutionaries and the Mensheviks)\nlash both of them for \"rocking\" the common boat. Behind the forms of the\nerupting crises, Lenin clearly sees their essence — the interaction, struggle,\nconflict of two components of development, two main sides of the relation\n{proletariat/bourgeoisie}. The middle elements or petty bourgeoisie (including\nthe intelligentsia) are always an oscillating stratum, which, depending on the\ncircumstances, can play the role of both a revolutionary-active and a counterrevolutionary element. And such oscillations from one pole to the other are\ninevitable, which leads to both a change in the established correlation between\nthe sides and a change in the relation itself as a whole.\nThat is why, in the final analysis, for the implementation of a full-fledged\nuprising, the proletariat today lacks a \"critical mass\" and therefore the topical\n(for now) task is to win over the oscillating semi-proletarian mass to its\nproletarian side, including the poorest peasantry and the petty-bourgeois\nstratum of the country's population. In this case, we are talking about the need\nto increase the contentfulness of the \"upper\" component (the \"numerator\" of the\ngiven relation, i.e. the consciousness and organization of the proletariat) in the\nactually formed relation of components {proletariat/bourgeoisie} by all possible\nmeans, including explanatory work, agitation, and propaganda.]\n8. Lenin's attitude to his probable arrest in the hot July days of 1917 will be\nshown by the example of the publications of two of his small articles \"Where is\nthe Power and Where is the Counter-Revolution\" [9, pp. 119-123] and \"On\nthe Question of the Appearance in Court of the Bolshevik Leaders\" [9,\npp. 128-129].\nIn the first article, the false statement of a certain former member of the State\nDuma about the readiness of Lenin and the Bolshevik party to conclude a\nseparate peace with Germany is analyzed, despite the fact that Lenin, on the\ncontrary, has always and unconditionally rejected a separate peace with\nGermany in the most resolute and irrevocable manner [9, p. 121]. This same\nsource reported that the Bolshevik leaders received money from German agents.\nAt the same time, everyone perfectly understood that if this information were\ntrue, the General Staff would by no means allow its premature leakage to the\nyellow press and would not hesitate for a minute to arrest the Bolshevik top.\nIn fact, as it turned out later, taking advantage of dual power (or rather, the\npowerlessness of that period), this information for the purpose of discrediting the\n\n\fBolsheviks was spread by the so-called behind-the-scenes counter-revolution —\nthe Cadets, well-known circles of the General Staff and the Black Hundred press.\n\"The counter-revolution takes advantage of the powerlessness, uniting the\nCadets with the well-known commanding tops of the army and with the Black\nHundred press\" [9, p. 123].\nThe second article on the question of the appearance of the Bolshevik leaders in\ncourt brings on this account, as one would expect, two opinions: to appear and\nnot to appear. At first, Lenin very seriously considered the possibility of his\npresence in court, since such a step would allow using the court as a tribune to\nclarify the essence of the Bolsheviks' position and additional agitation, to which\nIlyich always approached very scrupulously. Moreover, Lenin was by no means a\nman of a timid disposition to be frightened by threats from the Provisional\nGovernment. However, after a comprehensive collective discussion of this\noption, the VI Congress of the RSDLP(b) unanimously adopted a resolution in\nwhich it spoke out against the appearance of Lenin and a number of other\ncomrades in court, foreseeing a possible massacre of the Bolshevik leadership\n[or, as they would say today, the neutralization of the entire party asset].\n\"If we assume that in Russia there is and a correct government is possible, a\ncorrect court, the convening of the Constituent Assembly is probable, then one\ncan come to a conclusion in favor of appearance\" [9, p. 128]. However, due to\nthe absence of power [the established dual power as an equivalent to\npowerlessness], there was neither a correct court, nor a correct government, nor\na Constituent Assembly in Russia at that time. The court is supposedly fair, the\ncourt will figure it out, the court will be public, the people will understand — \"a\nreasoning naive to childishness\". It is not a court, but a persecution of\ninternationalists, that is what Kerensky and Co. needed. Therefore, \"let the\ninternationalists work illegally as much as they can, but let them not make the\nstupidity of voluntary appearance!\" [9, p. 129].\n[How honestly, responsibly and devotedly Lenin treated his cause, involving the\nimplementation of the socialist idea in life, how convinced he was of the\nrightness of this idea, can be judged by the memoirs of his contemporaries, even\nfrom among those who were not Bolsheviks and never shared their views. The\nMenshevik F. Dan, for example, once remarked with irritation: \"...There is no\nlonger such a person who would be busy with the revolution 24 hours a day,\nwho would have no other thoughts except the thought of the revolution, and\nwho even sees only the revolution in his dreams. Just try to cope with such a\none\" [13, p. 6].\nCan Lenin's devotion to the common cause, his lack of greed and purposefulness\nbe compared with the qualities of today's \"rulers\" or the so-called Duma\ncommunists and all other \"zealots for the people\" — with their camouflaged\nfinancial assets, unaffordable real estate and \"treacherously\" tinted bank\naccounts (including foreign ones). It's laughable, really. Can the current \"rulers\"\nand their ilk compare with Lenin's pleiad of state leaders, who descended into\n\n\fthe grave in the same frock coats in which they came into the revolutionary\npolitical movement, and then into power?\nEvery \"ruler\" has, by and large, only two options for \"exit\" from power structures\nwhen the earth is shaking underfoot and power is slipping from his hands. The\nfirst option: to inconspicuously \"merge\", saving one's \"hide\" (in modern\nlanguage), changing into a woman's dress or (which is tantamount to the same\nthing) timely pulling a retirement pajamas on oneself; the second option: again,\nsaving one's precious hide, to apply force against the rebels.\nBecause his own \"priceless\" life and excessive ambitions are at stake, the\nmodern \"ruler\" readily and without hesitation is ready to deploy against his own\npeople artillery, tanks, MLRS and aircraft, perfectly realizing that all this is a\nweapon of group destruction. And how should one treat such a nonentity after\nthat?\nAnd against such a background, someone has the tongue to make claims to\nLenin, who was not smeared and not noticed in anything similar (i.e., never\nclung to power and did not allow anything of the kind and close, which cannot be\nsaid about many other characters — once former and now residing in power). In\nthis regard, Lenin was always guided by the principle formulated in one of his\nreports: \"A revolution is worth something only if it knows how to defend itself...\".\nIt was about defense and the struggle against counter-revolution, which in every\nway and by all methods, including terror, sought to prevent the formation of a\nnew social order (new socio-economic formation) and the creative\ntransformation of the country: \"The revolution was an awakening to a new life of\nmillions. In February and March, these millions did not know what they were\ngoing to continue the slaughter into which they were driven by the tsars and\nKerenskys and the purpose of which was exposed only in December by the\nBolshevik government. This turning point has come; it changes the strength of\nthe revolution. If these masses have now created a new discipline in the Red\nArmy, not the discipline of the stick and the landlord's, but the discipline of the\nSoviets of workers' and peasants' deputies; if they are now going to the greatest\nself-sacrifice; if among them a new cohesion has developed, it is because for the\nfirst time in the consciousness and experience of tens of millions a new, socialist\ndiscipline is being born and has been born, the Red Army has been born. It was\nborn only when these tens of millions of people saw from their own experience\nthat they themselves had overthrown the landlords and capitalists, that a new\nlife was being built, that they themselves had begun to build it and that they\nwould build this life if a foreign invasion did not interfere\" [12, pp. 122-123].\nFor the current \"rulers\", for example, special cycles of television programs are\norganized so that they explain their most \"humane\" and \"sweet-tempered\"\nimpulses, talk about their grandiose plans, diligently winding flour products of\nwell-known names onto the ear shells of undiscriminating or confused listeners.\nAnd as a result or in the dry residue, there will still be the same two options for\n\"exit\" from \"power\": either quietly \"merge\" in women's underwear or retirement\npajamas, so that no one can \"catch\" the poor fellow for the miscalculations made\n\n\fin foreign and domestic policy, or drown everything in human blood for the sake\nof one's own salvation. And there should be no illusions about this. Wretches of\nall stripes who have got into power use all possible means to stay afloat or get\nout dry.\nMeanwhile, every such \"ruler\" should see at the end of his term of office not a\ncomfortable armchair with a woolen blanket, but a block with an axe; only then\ncan one hope that he will check every step he takes and make every decision in\nthe name of and for the benefit of the people, who have temporarily delegated\ntheir power powers to him].\nTo our great regret, many modern \"rulers\" (including Russian ones) still, as\nin the past, build up for themselves, cherish and nurture oligarchicplutocratic states: a) according to their perverted ideas of the ideal (in the\nsense of perfect) world order; b) as a natural product and indicator of their\nlack of education and bad taste. Moreover, to develop or \"further educate\"\nsuch a dwarf ruler due to his clinical limitations, as a rule, is not possible. All,\noutwardly looking like good intentions of such a worthless ruler, turn out, in\nthe final analysis, to be just a cover for the manifestation of private property\ninstincts, petty deeds and self-serving interests of the oligarchic-plutocratic\nenvironment, which serves for the caricature ruler as a kind of \"airbag\".\nIt is amusing to watch how an ordinary figure, after the insignificant\nsycophantic entourage \"blows\" into his ears about his non-ordinariness and\nexclusiveness, suddenly begins to claim the role of a large-scale theorist and\nteacher of the nation, practically not understanding the \"sublime matters\",\nlooking down with disdain and hostility at the past of the country, leveling\nand calling into question what was created by truly great predecessors\n(during the years of Soviet power and under the leadership of the Bolsheviks\nhated by him). It is surprising how a \"ruler\" with an inadequate assessment\nof the phenomenal past of his people can throw dust in the eyes of his fellow\ncitizens for so long.\nIn contrast to today's \"leaders\" and \"rulers\", the Bolsheviks (Lenin's closest\ncomrades) evoke sympathy not only due to their education, erudition, lively\nmind, sober views of the world, but also thanks to iron will (\"one could make\nnails from these people — there would be no stronger nails in the world\"),\nromanticism (albeit naive to some extent), unwavering faith in the future, in\nman, in his creative potential.\nThe Bolsheviks from the pleiad of Lenin's closest comrades selflessly, at the\ncost of their freedom, health, and in many cases their lives, — managed to\nbreak through a gap in such a thickness of millennial human ignorance,\ndeception and violence against ordinary people that it is simply impossible to\nreassess their contribution to the formation of a new worldview (world\noutlook and world order) and, therefore, one can admire them endlessly.\n\n\fAs for Lenin (as a politician and statesman), the decisions made by him and\nthe actions performed by him must always and first of all be considered in\nthe context of those tasks and problems that in those times, without\nexaggeration, simply \"took by the throat\". To understand the logic of\ndecisions and behavior of great politicians, one must consider this behavior\nand decisions in accordance with the events and circumstances, conditions\nand realities that, like a certain spatial environment or atmosphere, fill those\nor other times.\nBy the way, modern political wretches, as already noted above (\"true\ndemocrats\" — by their own standards), for the sake of preserving their\npower or at the slightest threat to this power of theirs (as a rule, even in\ninsignificant in historicism circumstances) easily use the power appropriated\nby them for the isolation or elimination of dissenters and freethinkers.\nOne must possess the true \"greatness\" and \"enormity\" of Lenin's nature to\nleave after himself such scanty autobiographical information from personal\nlife, preferences, hobbies, etc. — unlike our current \"rulers\" striving to\nimmortalize (with the help of court \"chroniclers\") and capture on film or \"in\ndigits\" (in the form of a cinematic epic of insignificant episodes) every step of\ntheir feigned path under the pharisaic slogan \"all life is service to the\npeople\"].\n9. \"Undoubtedly, the most important question of any revolution,\" V.I. Lenin\nbegins his article \"One of the Fundamental Questions of the Revolution\"\n[9, pp. 208-214], dated September 1917. — is the question of state power;\neverything is determined by the class in whose hands the power is: one\ncannot bypass or postpone the question of power, for this is the fundamental\nquestion determining everything in the development of the revolution, in its\nforeign and internal policy. However, the revolution has lost half a year due\nto the hesitation of the parties of the Socialist-Revolutionaries and the\nMensheviks, who are the avant-garde of the petty bourgeoisie with its\neconomic instability in the struggle between labor and capital. If in these\ngreat half-years the petty-bourgeois democracy has learned anything, then it\nis necessary to immediately create a stable unhesitating power; if not, then\nthe revolution has perished, and only the victorious uprising of the proletariat\ncan save it\" [9, p. 208].\nOnly the power of the Soviets can be stable, deliberately relying on the\nmajority of the people, no matter how the lackeys of the bourgeoisie lie. Only\nSoviet power could be stable and could ensure the broad development of the\nrevolution and the peaceful struggle of parties within the Soviets. Until such\npower is created, indecision, hesitation, endless \"crises of power\", a comedy\nof ministerial reshuffles are inevitable. But the slogan \"All Power to the\nSoviets\" is often understood completely incorrectly in the sense of \"a ministry\nfrom the parties of the Soviet majority\". In the indicated sense — this is just\na change in the composition of ministers while preserving the entire old\napparatus of government power, incapable of carrying out serious reforms.\n\n\fIn fact, \"All Power to the Soviets\" means a radical reworking of the entire old\nstate bureaucratic apparatus that hinders everything democratic, the\nelimination of this apparatus and its replacement by a new, people's\napparatus of the Soviets, i.e. the organized and armed majority of the\npeople, workers, soldiers, peasants, providing the initiative and\nindependence to the majority of the people not only in the election of\ndeputies, but also in governing the state, in carrying out reforms and\ntransformations [9, pp. 209-210].\nThe entire history of bourgeois-parliamentary and bourgeois-constitutional\ncountries, Lenin reminds, shows that a change of ministers means very little,\nfor the real work of management is in the hands of a gigantic army of\nofficials, which is thoroughly imbued with an anti-democratic spirit, is\nconnected by millions of threads with the bourgeoisie and is dependent on it.\nThis army is connected by relations of rank worship, known privileges of\n\"state\" service, and the upper ranks of this army through the mediation of\nshares and banks are completely enslaved by financial capital, representing\nits agents, conductors of its interests and influence. [Isn't it somehow\n\"peculiarly fresh\" sounding today!]. To carry out reforms to limit the right of\ncapital and the right of \"sacred private property\", such a state apparatus is\nabsolutely incapable [9, p. 210]. It was so and it will be so as long as the\nbourgeois system holds and the old, bourgeois, bureaucratic, state apparatus\nremains inviolable. The Soviets of workers', soldiers', peasants' deputies are\nvaluable precisely in that they represent a new, immeasurably higher,\nincomparably more democratic type of state apparatus [9, p. 211]. Here\nLenin calls for not being afraid of the initiative and independence of the\nmasses, who are capable of revolutionary transformations and replacing the\nold state apparatus.\nExperience has shown that there is no middle ground: either all power to the\nSoviets both in the center and on the local level, or the landlords and\ncapitalists hinder everything and restore their power. The situation in Russia\nis such that the unprecedented hardships and misfortunes of war, the\nformidable danger of collapse and hunger themselves suggested a way out\nand put forward as urgent reforms and transformations: the bread monopoly,\ncontrol over production and distribution, limiting the issue of paper money,\nthe correct exchange of bread for goods, etc. The only class that can show\nthe courage and decisiveness that is lacking today is the proletariat; at the\nsame time, the establishment of a firm course for reforms is impossible\nwithout the establishment of the dictatorship of the proletariat.\nAnd, finally, the brilliant Lenin's conclusion: \"Only the dictatorship of the\nproletarians and the poorest peasants is able to break the resistance of the\ncapitalists, show truly majestic courage and decisiveness of power, ensure\nfor itself enthusiastic, selfless, truly heroic support of the masses both in the\narmy and in the peasantry\" [9, p. 214]. The only thing that could make\nfurther development gradual, peaceful and calm is the transfer of power to\nthe Soviets, which would mean the transfer of management of the country\n\n\fand the economy to the workers and peasants, whom no one would dare to\nresist and who would quickly learn from experience to correctly distribute\nland, products, bread.\n[So, again we return to the initial, revealed in the course of Lenin's analysis\nof the situation relation of component-classes {proletariat/bourgeoisie}, by\nthe interaction of components in which some of their correlation is realized,\ndemonstrating the supremacy, priority or prevalence of one component in\nrelation to another (which determines the power of one class over another).\nThe relation {proletariat/bourgeoisie}, filled with new content, in the form of\nthe transformed, transformed relation {Councils of workers', peasants' and\nsoldiers' deputies / bourgeois Provisional Government} shows the ability of\ndevelopment (displacement) of this relation towards the \"upper\" component\n(the \"numerator\"), which corresponds to the strengthening of its activity,\ninitiative and readiness for revolutionary transformations, to the perception\nand mastery of new forms of management, productive forces, social\nproduction, etc., etc., and which, in turn, determines the acceleration of\nthe contentful development of the entire relation as a whole. The emergence\nof a new correlation of class forces to a new level of contentfulness (in the\nform of a new relation) — this is what the Socialist-Revolutionary and\nMenshevik leaders are afraid of. Again, the disruption of reforms by the\nbourgeoisie is the result of inactivity or lack of sufficient control over the\nsituation on the part of the revolutionary component. The full development of\nthe indicated relation as a whole is predicted by the transfer of power to the\nSoviets due to the readiness of the revolutionary popular masses for this.\nIn the same way, in modern conditions, without tough measures and a\nrevolutionary approach to solving the most urgent state tasks, one cannot do\nwithout, no matter how hard one tries and no matter how one \"blurs\" the\neyes of one's fellow citizens. If the current \"ruler\" hopes that everything will\nresolve itself, he is deeply mistaken in this regard — women have not yet\nlearned to give birth to such oligarchs, magnates, majors and other\n\"appropriators\" who would voluntarily renounce what was earned in the\nsweat of someone else's face and in favor of their own face appropriated. It\nis a pity, nevertheless, that the current \"governor\" is not a resolute\nrevolutionary.\nThe reverse side of any revolution, and then counter-revolution, is (along\nwith class wars and squabbles) the settlement of personal, family, shop,\ncorporate and other scores; at the same time, the following semantic chain is\napproximately realized: revenge => retribution => compensation =>\nrestoration of equilibrium (balance), i.e. justice... (the very etymology of\nwords builds them into a similar semantic chain, corresponding to the\ndirection of the course of processes of dialectical development). This is the\nexternal manifestation of the dialectical nature of developing reality in the\nfield of human relations. At the \"higher\" levels — this is a contest of\ncompeting concepts and ideologies; at more \"down-to-earth\" levels — this is\n\n\fa physical (force) struggle, conditioned by the desire (thirst) for the\nrestoration of trampled justice, violated property (household) equilibrium.\nThe mentioned chain can be clothed in a more attractive form, i.e. somehow\nennoble, put on the clothes of legal laws, but it will never be possible to\neradicate or abolish this chain, since in its depth, in essence — this is the\nsame engine of contentful renewal, progress, development.]\n10. The letter \"The Bolsheviks Must Take Power\" [9, pp. 325-327],\naddressed to the Central, Petrograd and Moscow Committees of the\nRSDLP(b), was written in September 1917. Here Lenin emphasizes that,\nhaving received a majority in both metropolitan Soviets of Workers' and\nSoldiers' Deputies, the Bolsheviks can and must take state power into their\nown hands. Having an active majority of the people (sufficient to break the\nenemy's resistance), proposing a democratic peace, giving the land to the\npeasants immediately, restoring the democratic freedoms trampled by the\nKerensky government, the Bolsheviks will form such a government that no\none will overthrow. One must not be deceived by the figures of elections to\ncity dumas: only elections to the Soviets show the true, truthful correlation\nof forces (i.e. of components in the established relation-form {Soviets of\nWorkers' and Soldiers' Deputies / bourgeois Provisional Government}) at the\npresent moment. The people are tired of the hesitation of the Mensheviks\nand Socialist-Revolutionaries, and only the victory of the Bolsheviks in both\ncapitals will draw the peasants after the Bolsheviks. Thus, the agenda should\ninclude questions about the armed uprising in Petrograd and Moscow, the\nconquest of power and the overthrow of the Provisional Government. In this\nregard, Lenin very aptly quotes Engels' words about the uprising:\n\"Insurrection is an art\" [17, p. 100].\n\"Having taken power at once in Moscow and Petrograd... we will win\nunconditionally and undoubtedly,\" Lenin concludes [9, p. 327].\n[The establishment and \"fixity\" of a new correlation between the components\nin the notorious relation-form {Soviets / Provisional Government} (i.e. the\nstatement of the fact of the majority of the people on the side of the Soviets)\ngives grounds for the conclusion about the relevance and legitimacy of a\nnon-violent transition and transfer of all state power into the hands of the\nSoviets. A correctly performed assessment of the achieved correlation\nbetween the mentioned components in their established relation allows one\nto confidently forecast the course of the uprising and count on its most\npeaceful and bloodless outcome].\n11. Another letter of Lenin to the Central Committee of the RSDLP(b) (known\nas an article under the title \"Marxism and Insurrection\" [9, pp. 328-332]\nand written approximately on the same days as the previous letter) was a\nreaction to the accusations of the Bolsheviks' adherence to the ideas of\n\"Blanquism\". These accusations arose on the basis of the Bolsheviks' attitude\nto the uprising as to an art (absolutizing allegedly the role of the subjective\n\n\fbeginning, which is characteristic of Blanquism, based, as is known, on the\ntheory of conspiracies and terror).\nMeanwhile, it was Marxism, according to Lenin, that called the uprising an\nart, explaining that the uprising must be treated as an art: to win the first\nsuccess and from success to go to success, without ceasing the offensive\nagainst the enemy, taking advantage of his confusion and indecision, etc.\nFighting the accusations of Blanquism, Lenin determines the three main\nsigns-conditions of success [i.e. of achieving the highest contentfulness by\nthe forms-relations participating in the revolutionary process] of the uprising:\nfirstly, reliance on the advanced class; secondly, reliance on the\nrevolutionary upsurge of the people; thirdly, reliance on such a turning point\nin the history of the growing revolution when the greatest activity of the\npeople is accompanied by the strongest fluctuations in the ranks of the\nenemies and indecisive \"friends\" of the revolution. \"It is by these three\nconditions of posing the question of the uprising that Marxism differs from\nBlanquism,\" Lenin concludes [9, p. 328].\nTo prove the urgent necessity of the uprising from the point of view of the\nobjective agenda, and not subjective conjectures, Vladimir Ilyich traces the\nchange of objective conditions, the situation in the period of time from July\nto September of the same 1917, trying to identify the trend or direction of\nsuch changes. In July, in his firm conviction, the above-mentioned\nindispensable conditions for the success of the uprising were not yet\nobserved, while by September the general picture had changed radically and\nnow \"all objective prerequisites for a successful uprising are evident\" [9, p.\n330]. Victory in the uprising, in Lenin's opinion, will disrupt Kerensky's game\nwith the surrender of Petrograd and the conclusion of a separate peace with\nGermany against the revolution and will ensure the conclusion of a more\ncomplete, open, fair peace in favor of the revolution. Only the Bolshevik\nparty, having won in the uprising, can save Petrograd from surrender to the\nGermans and save the whole of Russia from the separate division by the\nimperialists of both warring coalitions. The Bolsheviks must draw up a short\ndeclaration, insisting on the necessity of immediate actions for the sake of\nsaving the revolution, the necessity of a complete break with the bourgeoisie,\nthe complete removal of the current government, the complete break with\nthe Anglo-French imperialists preparing a separate division of Russia, the\nnecessity of an immediate transfer of all power into the hands of the\nrevolutionary democracy led by the revolutionary proletariat. The short and\nsharp declaration must contain two most important points: 1) the people are\ntired of the hesitation and indecision of the Socialist-Revolutionaries and\nMensheviks and therefore breaks with these parties finally, for they have\nbetrayed the revolution; 2) a break with the allied imperialists and a proposal\nfor peace without annexations lead either to an immediate truce or to the\ntransition of the revolutionary proletariat to defense and waging a truly fair\nrevolutionary war under its leadership. Having published the declaration, the\nBolsheviks must put their entire faction forward to the factories and barracks\n\n\f— that is its place, there is the nerve of life, there is the source of salvation\nof the revolution. Posing the question in this way, the Bolsheviks will be able\nto correctly appoint the moment of the beginning of the uprising, having\npreviously organized the headquarters of the rebel detachments, mobilized\nthe armed workers for a desperate last decisive battle, occupied the\ntelegraph, telephone and connected all factories, all regiments, all points of\narmed struggle with the headquarters, etc. [9, pp. 331-332].\n[Thus, the transfer of accents and the shift of the correlation of components\nin the known relations towards more contentful, active and active\ncomponents and thereby bringing these relations to the form {Soviets (under\nthe aegis of the Bolsheviks) / Provisional Government (in alliance with the\nbourgeoisie and foreign financial capital)} changes the entire tactics of the\nBolsheviks in the conditions of the growing revolutionary movement. In other\nwords, speaking in everyday language, the first revolution of the proletariat,\nthe peasantry and the bourgeoisie in alliance with the Anglo-French financial\ncapital against tsarism before our eyes is growing into a revolution of the\nproletariat and the poorest peasantry against the bourgeoisie with its ally the\nAnglo-French financial capital and the Kerensky government].\nAs has already been shown earlier, a similar schematically-described above\nplot construction can be seen in almost all of Lenin's theoretical works. Thus,\nwe have some grounds for building and formulating a methodology (or even\na whole methodology) for researching the perspective of the movementdevelopment-change of the forms-relations of interacting components in\ndifferent areas and at different levels of reality.\n12. The article \"On Compromises\" [9, pp. 158-163] was printed on\nSeptember 19, 1917 in connection with the opened opportunity for the\nBolsheviks to conclude a voluntary compromise with a number of other\nparties.\n\"A compromise,\" Lenin writes, \"is called in politics the concession of some\ndemands, the renunciation of part of one's demands by virtue of an\nagreement with another party\" [9, p. 158]. The usual idea of the Bolsheviks\nwas that the Bolsheviks do not agree with anyone and never on any\ncompromises. Such an idea is flattering, for even enemies are forced to\nrecognize the party of the revolutionary proletariat's fidelity to the principles\nof socialism and revolution. However, to tell the truth, such an idea does not\ncorrespond to the truth. The task of a truly revolutionary party consists not\nin not succumbing to compromises, but in being able, through all\ncompromises, to maintain fidelity to its principles, fidelity to its class, its\ncause of preparing the revolution and the corresponding education of the\nmasses.\nThe Bolshevik party, like any other, strives for political domination for itself\nin the name of achieving its goal; the immediate goal for the Bolsheviks is\nthe establishment of the dictatorship of the revolutionary proletariat. And\n\n\fyet, in the current conditions of the original turn of the Russian revolution,\nthe Bolsheviks (as a party) can offer a voluntary compromise, however, not\nto the bourgeoisie (i.e. the main class enemy), but to the SocialistRevolutionaries and Mensheviks (the dominant petty-bourgeois democratic\nparties). Now within a very short period of time it is possible to return to the\nslogan \"All Power to the Soviets\"; at the same time, the government\nresponsible to the Soviets will consist of the Socialist-Revolutionaries and\nMensheviks. Such a combined variant could ensure with a gigantic probability\nthe peaceful movement forward of the entire Russian revolution and\nextremely high chances of the worldwide movement towards peace and the\nvictory of socialism. \"Only in the name of this peaceful development of\nthe revolution — an opportunity, extremely rare in history and extremely\nvaluable, an opportunity, exceptionally rare, only in its name the Bolsheviks,\nsupporters of the world revolution, supporters of revolutionary methods, can\nand must, in my opinion, go for such a compromise\" [9, p. 159].\n[And again Lenin, as a true dialectician, discovers a certain new (capable of\nfunctioning effectively) relation of components {Soviets / government of\nSocialist-Revolutionaries and Mensheviks}, the correlation of which at that\ngiven particular moment would contribute to giving an additional impetus to\nthe prospective revolutionary movement].\nBut such an outcome was possible at the moment Lenin was preparing this\narticle. However, literally a couple of days later, the situation began to\nchange rapidly and the events that occurred showed that the proposal for a\ncompromise was already late; the few days during which peaceful\ndevelopment would still have been possible had passed. It became obvious\nthat due to the inaction of the Socialist-Revolutionaries, the favorable \"days\nwhen the road of peaceful development became possible by chance, have\nalready passed\" [9, p. 163].\n13. The article \"An Outsider's Tips\" [9, pp. 391-393] was written on the\neve of the Great October Socialist Revolution. The current situation makes it\nclear that in the conditions of the greatest sympathy and support for the\nrevolutionary-proletarian (Bolshevik) power on the part of all workers and\nexploited people in the world in general, and in the warring countries in\nparticular, and among the Russian peasantry in particular — all Bolsheviks\nshould be quite clear: the transfer of power to the Soviets now means in\npractice an armed uprising. To renounce the armed uprising is tantamount to\nrenouncing the main slogan of Bolshevism — \"All Power to the Soviets\". And\nhere Vladimir Ilyich again insists on the well-known Marxist thesis: \"Armed\nuprising, like war, is an art\" [9, p. 391]. Marxism formulates the following\nmain rules of this art: 1) having started the uprising, one must firmly go to\nthe end; 2) in the decisive place and at the decisive moment, it is necessary\nto gather a large superiority of forces; 3) defense is the death of an armed\nuprising — one must necessarily go over to the offensive; 4) one must try to\ntake the enemy by surprise; 5) to achieve small successes daily and move\nfrom success to success, maintaining at all costs the \"moral superiority\".\n\n\fIn the adaptation of these general rules to the specific situation, Lenin\nhighlights the following points: 1) the organization of a sudden and rapid\noffensive on Petrograd both from within and from outside with the aim of\ncreating a gigantic superiority of forces, paralyzing the response actions of\nthe Junkers, and thereby achieving the bloodlessness (\"low-bloodedness\") of\nthe uprising; 2) by the three main revolutionary forces (the fleet, workers\nand military units) the main objects must be taken under control and held at\nany cost: telephone, telegraph, bridges, railway stations; 3) the formation of\nsmall detachments from the most resolute and steadfast comrades, ready to\nprovide operational support in the most important directions.\n[Here we see that without any reservations or delays, Lenin finally bets on\nthe new correlation of components and the superiority of the \"Soviets\"\ncomponent (i.e. the predominance of the \"numerator\" over the\n\"denominator\") that had developed by that time in the relation {Soviets /\nProvisional Government} and on this basis plans the success and the\nacquisition of a new quality by the indicated relation in its transformation into\na more contentful and prospective form.]\nAccording to the circumstances that had developed then, Lenin believed that\n\"the success of the Russian and world revolution depends on two or three\ndays of struggle\" [9, p. 393].\n§ 3. Works of the post-revolutionary period\nThe Great October Socialist Revolution has been accomplished. The\nBolsheviks took power, but it did not become calmer or simpler. The agenda\nincludes new topical questions: how to hold power, how to suppress the\nresistance of the counter-revolution, how to move on to building a peaceful\nlife, how to awaken the creative initiative of the masses, etc.\n1. In the article \"Speech on the Nationalization of Banks at the Meeting\nof the All-Russian Central Executive Committee on December 27,\n1917. Protocol Record\" [9, pp. 462-464], published on December 29,\n1917, it is about the opposition of the new power of the Soviets by the old\nbourgeois bureaucratic apparatus. The old apparatus with all its might tries\nto present the banking issue as extremely fragile, complex and confusing, in\norder to maximally slow down the process of transferring affairs into the\nhands of representatives of the new power and to hinder all socialist\nundertakings. Regarding all decisions of the Council, they [\"apparatchiks\"]\ndeclare that they agree, but only in principle. The entire system of bourgeois\nintelligentsia, in Lenin's opinion, is distinguished by \"its constant agreement\nin principle and disagreement in practice\", which ruins the whole cause [9,\np. 462].\nFrom the very first days, the new power faces opposition, when its decisive\nsteps are approved in theory and nothing but sabotage is met in practice. No\none (except utopian socialists) had previously claimed that it is possible to\n\n\fwin without resistance and without establishing the dictatorship of the\nproletariat; and this fundamental point was not disputed by anyone. But\nwhen the word \"dictatorship\" is translated into Russian and its equivalent\n\"iron hand\" is reached, then all the former zeal disappears somewhere and\nlamentations begin about the fragility and confusion of the issue [all the\npressure is suddenly leveled and nullified by referring to the complexity and\nconfusion of issues]. However, here one must see that this iron hand,\ndestroying, also creates.\nAfter all, at first there was talk of an agreement with the banks (\"who wants\nto work — you are welcome\"), they were issued loans for financing\nenterprises, but they started sabotage of an unprecedented size, and practice\nled the Bolsheviks to exercise control by other measures. Now the words\n\"dictatorship of the proletariat\" are spoken by the Bolsheviks very seriously,\nand this dictatorship will be implemented.\n2. And then, on the hot heels, “A draft decree [\"road map\", as they would\nsay today] on the implementation of the nationalization of banks and\nthe necessary measures in connection with this” was created and\nsubmitted by Lenin for discussion by the bureau of the Supreme Council of\nthe National Economy [9, pp. 465-467], which determined the direction of\nmovement and transformations of the banking sector for the near future and\nmany years to come. Delay with the approval of the decree was already\ntantamount to the disruption of the entire economy due to the powerful\nopposition and sabotage on the part of the banks.\nIn the preamble to the mentioned Draft Decree [9, p. 465], it is said about\nthe critical food situation and the threat of famine generated by the\nspeculation and sabotage of capitalists and officials, which leads to the need\nto take extraordinary revolutionary measures to combat this evil. So that all\ncitizens of the state and, first of all, the working classes under the leadership\nof their Soviets of workers', soldiers' and peasants' deputies could\nimmediately, \"stopping at nothing and acting in the most revolutionary way,\ntake up such a struggle and the establishment of the correct economic life of\nthe country, the following rules are established\", which are further set out in\nthe body of the Draft Decree [below are the rules that, in our opinion, are of\nthe greatest interest to us today from the point of view of their continued\neffectiveness to this day.]\no\no\n\no\n\nAll joint-stock enterprises are declared the property of the state.\nAll shareholders \"belonging to the rich classes\" are obliged to continue\nmanaging the affairs of enterprises, providing weekly reports on their activities\nto the local Soviets.\nGovernment loans (external and internal) are annulled, but the interests\nof small owners of bonds (as well as shares) belonging to the working classes of\nthe population are fully secured.\n\n\fo\n\no\n\no\n\no\n\no\n\no\n\no\n\nUniversal labor conscription is introduced, when all citizens of both\nsexes, from 16 to 55 years old, are obliged to perform work assigned by the\nlocal Soviets.\nFor correct accounting and distribution of food and other essential\nproducts, all citizens of the state are obliged to join some consumer society and\nperform the work that will be imposed on them by the Soviets.\nUnions of railway workers and employees are obliged to urgently\ndevelop and immediately begin to implement emergency measures to provide\ntransport, especially for the delivery of food, fuel and other essential items. The\nduty of waging a merciless struggle against speculators is also imposed on them.\n\"Persons of the rich classes\" are obliged to keep all their money sums in\nthe State Bank, its branches and savings banks, receiving for consumer needs\nthe sums established by the local Soviets; sums for production and trade needs\ncan be obtained only with written certificates from worker control institutions;\n\"those guilty of deceiving the state and the people will be subject to confiscation\nof all property\".\n\"The same punishment, as well as imprisonment or sending to the front\nand to forced labor, is subject to all disobedient to this law, saboteurs and\nstriking officials, as well as speculators. The local Soviets... are obliged to\nurgently develop the most revolutionary measures of struggle against these real\nenemies of the people.\"\nTrade unions and other organizations of workers in conjunction with the\nlocal Soviets organize flying groups of controllers from the most reliable and\nrecommended by party organizations persons to monitor the implementation of\nthis law, to check the quantity and quality of work and to bring to revolutionary\ncourts those guilty of violating or circumventing the law.\n\"Workers and employees of nationalized enterprises are obliged to strain\nall forces and take emergency measures to improve the organization of work,\nstrengthen discipline, increase labor productivity. The bodies of worker control\nmust provide weekly reports on what has been achieved in this regard. For\nshortcomings and omissions, the guilty are answerable before the revolutionary\ncourt\" [9, p. 467].\n[And again the contradictory question requires a solution — finding the correct\ncorrelation of components-constituents in the relation {dictatorship of the\nproletariat / soft government apparatus of indecisive bourgeois intelligentsia}.\nThe \"iron hand\" or the dictatorship of the proletariat is precisely that rigorous\naccounting and control over production and distribution, which must be strictly\nexercised not only in wartime conditions, but throughout the entire period of\nsocialist construction, until the principles of morality, ethics, honest attitude to\nwork enter the blood and flesh of every person — both at the level of conscious\nperception and at the level of the subconscious. The tricks of bourgeois games\ndescribed in the article were revealed by the Bolsheviks in the first months of the\nfunctioning of Soviet power, which is why decisions were made to act in\nresponse quite harshly and immediately, so that the previous sacrifices and\nefforts would not be in vain.]\n\n\f3. In the article \"How to Organize Competition?\" [9, pp. 468-476], written in\nJanuary 1918, the conditions for awakening genuine competition to life, as well\nas the initiative of the masses, are considered.\nAlready at the dawn of the emergence of capitalist relations, the competition of\nsmall commodity producers could on a somewhat wide scale educate enterprise,\nenergy, the boldness of initiative; in fact, today capitalism has replaced small\nindependent production with the largest factory production, joint-stock\nenterprises, syndicates and other monopolies. Competition in this layout means,\non the contrary, the suppression of the enterprise of the mass of the population,\nthe replacement of competition with financial fraud and servility to the \"tops\" of\nthe social ladder [9, p. 468]. [How amazingly accurately and fairly this \"sounds\"\nin relation to the rampage of the wildest capitalism in modern Russia and in the\npost-Soviet space!].\nTo develop abilities, to reveal human talents (which the people have in\nabundance) on a mass scale is possible only with a properly organized socialist\nmethod of production. The most urgent task today, when the socialist\ngovernment is in power, is to organize competition.\n[It is striking how from the very first days of Soviet power, in the conditions of\nan economic chaos, collapse, and famine that have not yet been overcome,\nLenin thinks in categories of the most peaceful and calm time, in categories of\neducation and formation of new production relations between workers,\nawakening the initiative of people on a \"mass scale\"!].\n\"A broad, truly mass creation of the opportunity to show enterprise, competition,\na bold initiative is only now. ...For the first time after centuries of work for\nothers, forced work for exploiters, the opportunity to work for oneself arises, and\nmoreover work based on all the achievements of the latest technology and\nculture\" [9, p. 469].\nIt is quite clear that the greatest change in history of mankind from forced labor\nto labor for oneself cannot occur without conflicts, without overcoming the\nresistance of exploiters, without displacing the capitalists, which will take time.\nIn addition to the \"military\" measures of suppressing the resistance of the \"rich\nclasses\", the proletariat and the poorest peasantry will also need huge\norganizational efforts. Thus, the organizational task is intertwined with the task\nof ruthless military suppression of yesterday's slave owners (capitalists and their\nlackeys — the gentlemen of the bourgeois intelligentsia).\nNaturally, none of the past \"masters of life\" wants to voluntarily part with their\nformer command and \"bread\" privileged posts, considering themselves \"Godchosen\" patrons and managers over the people. \"But the matter of the exploiters\nand their intellectual lackeys is a hopeless matter.\" Their resistance, workers and\npeasants will eventually break decisively and ruthlessly.\n\n\fIntellectuals accustomed to serving capitalists and the capitalist state believe\nthat they cannot be done without. \"Their impudent calculation will not be\njustified: educated people are already standing out, going over to the side of the\npeople, to the side of the workers, helping to break the resistance of the\nservants of capital. And there are many organizational talents in the peasantry\nand the working class, and these talents are just beginning to realize\nthemselves, to wake up, to reach for living, creative, great work, to take up the\nconstruction of a socialist society independently\" [9, p. 470].\nPerhaps the most important task today, Lenin says, is to develop as widely as\npossible the independent initiative of workers in the matter of creative\norganizational work. It is necessary to break the vile and absurd prejudice that\nonly the so-called \"higher classes\" and only the rich can manage the\norganizational construction of society. Organizational work is \"within the power\nof an ordinary worker and peasant who has literacy, knowledge of people,\npractical experience. ...There is still an inexhaustible spring and a richest spring\nof such talents in the working class and in the peasantry.\" Workers and peasants\nare still timid, they have not yet got used to the fact that they are now the ruling\nclass. But the strength and vitality of the October Revolution of 1917 lies in the\nfact that it leads the working people to the path of independent creation of a new\nlife.\n[For the note of the current \"rulers\" and their ilk: Lenin in a matter of years\nfound ways from scratch to motivate the illiterate, bast-shod population of the\nbloodless country, and the current \"ruler\" with his \"valiant\" arrogant entourage\nhas been struggling for several terms (both in a row and intermittently) to solve\nthe same task, but in vain.\nThe conservative \"comprador\" entourage of the current \"ruler\" will not allow him\n(the ruler) to make a single decision encroaching on the self-serving interest of\nthis entourage. So all this pompous camarilla will sit and wait for mythical\nWestern investments like manna from heaven, shifting the blame for their failure\non the notorious Western sanctions. Fortunately, their own fortunes are reliably\nplaced in foreign lands with the hope that such ugliness will continue forever.\nFor the information of today's \"rulers\": Lenin, in the five or six years granted\nto him after the revolution, managed (in the conditions of discord and\ndevastation, having tried many options) to find ways to awaken both\nenthusiasm and the initiative of millions, and to attract foreign specialists,\nand to train and prepare his own... Human potential (physical strength,\nintellectual and spiritual energy of the people) — this is the source of all\ninvestments, technologies and innovations, and therefore the main\ncomponent of the country's economic success; however, the inept\n\"comprador\" entourage of the supreme \"ruler\" will skillfully, on the verge of\nsabotage, extinguish this potential and write off all failures to the lack of\noverseas investments and the omnipotence of overseas sanctions.\nBy the way, has the main \"ruler\" tried to pull \"overseas investments\" out of\nthe purse of his entourage?\n\n\fRegarding the liberal-minded (in relation to the aggressive collective West)\ncircles in Russia, it is somehow already old-fashioned, unpleasant, and not\ndesirable to speak. Since the words of F.M. Dostoevsky, it has been known\nthat \"our Russian liberal is first and foremost a lackey and only looks for how\nto clean someone's boots\" [4, p. 133]. Meanwhile, eternal kneeling before\nthe West is conditioned by the universality and generality of the very\nprinciple of self-development.\nThe aspiration of all forms to the highest contentfulness has an unsightly\nreverse side in the imposition (as a sample or standard) of its allegedly\nmost perfect and exclusive form — its understanding of the world, its\nideology (with the accompanying \"uprooting\" of dissent and everything\n\"wrong\"), its worldview, world outlook, world perception, its way of life —\nand all this is presented as an indisputable absolute truth. The Anglo-Saxon\nworld has since time immemorial professed an aggressive way of interacting\nwith other peoples or representatives (carriers) of a different principle, as,\nfor example, the peace-loving and more balanced Eastern Slavic peoples,\nwho always act as a pacifying counterweight to restrain and neutralize such\nexcessive activity (aggressiveness) of the Anglo-Saxons and their ilk.\nAnglo-Saxon communities and their accomplices (in aggregate — the\ncollective West) feel themselves at the same time champions and bearers of\ngood, enlightenment, civilization, morality, ethics, etc.; they are always\ncharged with the ideology of the expansion of everything, in their\nassessment, \"good\" against everything \"bad\" or \"good\" (according to their\nunderstanding) against \"evil\". Our liberals are led by this bait or false bait;\npersons with liberal views are very one-sided and superficial in their\nperceptions and beliefs, since they take the brilliant external packaging for\nthe most part as the deep hidden essence of things.\nIn addition, the aggression inherent in the Anglo-Saxon \"mentors\" and Co. is\nfurther enhanced due to a number of \"misses\" pursuing them, i.e. due to\nreceiving periodic spankings and thrashings from the Eastern Slavs in\nresponse to their excessive zeal in carrying out incessant attempts at forcible\n\"enlightenment\" and \"ennoblement\" of the latter; therefore, they always\nhave an unquenchable vulnerability due to their unchanged status of the\n\"eternally beaten\" in open clashes. It must be said straight out that these\n\"highly civilized\" peoples have never been able to correctly assess\ntheir contentful resource, i.e. to measure their capabilities against the\npotential of the Eastern Slavs, which is why they suffered defeats from them\ntime and again.\nThe collective West led by the US bets (unconsciously, of course) on the\nperfection of the form (i.e. mainly on the formal principle), while ignoring the\ndevelopment of the contentful side-constituent. This is the secret of their\ncertain technological advantage (quality of household items, equipment,\nservices, etc.), achieved by focusing on the Form (sometimes more or\n\n\fless contentful only\nfrom\nthe\nperspective\nof\nshort-term\nsuccess\nand contentless from the point of view of strategy and deep, long-term\nperspective of the development of mankind). It is still necessary to\nthoroughly \"dissect\" the dry calculating intellect of the Anglo-Saxon world —\nthis formal constituent, this formal principle of the universal human world —\nin order to understand the danger of such a one-sided approach on the scale\nof the development of all mankind. In their prevailing mechanicity and\ntechnological inclinations (i.e. a bias towards the technological side, often\ndevoid of moral underpinnings and moral attitudes) lie all the explanations of\ntheir modern actions and behavior. None other than they have become today\nthe first managers and manipulators of public consciousness on an\nunprecedentedly massive, global scale, through the Internet, and in\nparticular through social networks and platforms. In all their policy (foreign,\ninternal, technical, technological, social, etc. — especially against the\nbackground of the not so long ago once again proclaimed by Obama their\nimaginary and illusory exclusivity) there is something school-boyishly wellcalculated rational and at the same time humanly extremely primitive and\nlimited (the analogy with cold-blooded \"reptiloids\" trying to impose their way\nof life and behavior on warm-blooded earthlings suggests itself).\nHere it is also appropriate, in our opinion, to touch upon the question of the\nimposition on the whole world by the collective West of its allegedly most\nprogressive and most democratic \"values\" and preferences. First of all, it is\nnecessary in this regard to point out the entrenched confusion in the\ninterpretations of the terms \"values\" and \"interests\". This confusion is due to\nthe incompetence of the \"interpreters\" in terms of the correct correlation of\nthese concepts with two different, non-identical spheres of acquiring reality\n(in the composition of the multi-level form of man): the sphere (level) of the\n\"sensual\" and the sphere (level) of the \"ideal\". It must be said that such\nissues have long and deeply been analyzed by famous philosophers of the\npast, but the solutions to these issues have been quite successfully and\nthoroughly forgotten by our contemporaries. If we talk about \"values\" in the\nmeaning and sense invested in this concept by the Western world, then we\nare talking mainly about primitive interests limited to the sensual sphere of\nman. In this section, all the efforts and aspirations of the Western philistine\nare aimed mainly at the implementation of quite \"down-to-earth\" and simple\nhuman needs (in food, housing, source of income, in procreation, rest, as\nwell as in the satisfaction of various physiological desires, pleasures,\nfantasies, requests for boundless rights and freedoms, etc.). The concept of\n\"values\" from the point of view, for example, of a Russian person is by no\nmeans limited to the sensual sphere, but goes (\"protrudes\") beyond its limits\ninto the realm of the ideal; and in this sense it is already identified with\nspiritual categories (which for their more accurate identification and binding\nrequire different, more Contentful terminology): with principles, with\nconvictions, with ideals, with worldview, etc., etc., — i.e. with formsattributes of a higher level of acquiring reality, called human consciousness.\nIn this sense and in this hypostasis — this is no longer an orientation towards\nlow-level \"values\" of the Western world, but a conscious adherence to\n\n\fmore Contentful views: principles of human morality, ethics, spirituality,\nhumanism, etc. In the main and the big, the modern West (unlike, say,\nEurope of the Enlightenment) is devoid of aspiration to proclaim and follow\n(including in everyday life) high spiritual principles and convictions — it\nsimply got stuck on \"down-to-earth\" needs and low-grade interests,\nrefusing further movement towards ideals developing a person. It is\nprecisely for this reason that all the teachings and instructions of the Western\nworld regarding the unquestioning acceptance and \"implementation in life\"\nby other peoples of the line of Western, so to speak, \"values\" look at least\nridiculous and laughable.]\nAt the same time, implementing socialist undertakings, the Soviets of\nworkers', soldiers' and peasants' deputies, consumer societies, supply\nunions, factory committees and worker control bodies must understand that\nthe main economic task at this stage is accounting and control. The old\nhabit of a forced person is still strong — as if to \"grab\" at least a piece from\nthe bourgeoisie, without burdening oneself with extra work and obligations.\nSuch an approach of \"newcomers\" to the factory environment: \"Grab a\nbigger piece and run away\", — is transferred to the factory that has passed\ninto the ownership of the people. The advanced conscious workers have\nalready started fighting against such personnel, who will undoubtedly be\nsupported by honest, thinking peasants. Universal, universal, universal\naccounting and control over the distribution of products and the amount of\nlabor — this is the essence of the socialist transformation; the accounting\nand control necessary for the transition to socialism can only be mass.\nProceeding from this, Lenin turns to the new working owners of land, banks,\nfactories and plants: \"Take up the accounting and control of production and\ndistribution yourselves, — this is the only way to the victory of socialism, the\npledge of its victory, the pledge of victory over all exploitation, over all need\nand poverty\". In Russia, Lenin says, there is enough bread, iron, forest,\nwool, cotton and flax for everyone, if a nationwide businesslike, practical\ncontrol over distribution is established, if the enemies of the people (the rich\nand their \"hangers-on\" — bourgeois intellectuals) are defeated not only in\npolitics, but also in the everyday economic life of a society in which \"a\nhandful robbed the people and mocked the people\" [9, p. 472]. [An\nextremely topical appeal also applicable to the current situation in Russia!].\n\"The rich and crooks, these are two sides of the same coin, these are the two\nmain categories of parasites fostered by capitalism, these are the main\nenemies of socialism, these enemies must be placed under the special\nsupervision of the entire population, they must be dealt with, at the slightest\nviolation by them of the rules and laws of socialist society, mercilessly. Any\nweakness, any hesitation, any sentimentality in this regard would be the\ngreatest crime against socialism\" [9, p. 473].\n[If only Lenin with his dialectical mind were here, even for an hour !!!\n\n\fOur great Motherland has again been turned into a country of lackeys and\nmasters, where a handful of plutocrats does at an unconscious level\neverything that comes to mind, satisfying primarily their primitive\nmomentary whims and fancies, dictated only by the desire to increase their\nown savings, thereby determining and setting in advance, for years, the\nconfiguration of our (or rather, their) future and without our participation in\nthis. Before, such a thing could not even be dreamed of or seen in a\nnightmare. Lenin's lessons of dialectics have turned out to be, at\nbest, Unlearned lessons of dialectics.]\nThe way to neutralize these parasites is a nationwide, organized by millions\nof workers and peasants, voluntary and energetic accounting and control\nover the amount of labor, production and distribution of products. And in\norder to organize this accounting and control, which is quite accessible and\nfeasible for every honest, sensible and efficient worker and peasant, it is\nnecessary to call their own organizational talents to life, it is necessary to\nestablish on an all-state scale a competition in terms of organizational\nsuccesses, it is necessary that workers and peasants clearly understand the\ndifference between the necessary advice of an educated person and the\nnecessary control of a simple worker and peasant over the sloppiness, so\ncommon among educated people.\nSloppiness, carelessness, untidiness, \"the tendency to take on everything in\nthe world and bring nothing to an end is one of the properties of \"educated\npeople\", stemming not at all from their bad nature, much less from malice,\nbut from all the habits of life, from the setting of their work, from overwork\",\nfrom the abnormal correlation of the mental and physical components of\nlabor in the cycles of their activity, etc., etc.\n[And here we see a surprisingly insightful and precise statement of the\nconnection between the actual mistakes, shortcomings and misses made\nduring the revolution and those \"sad, but inevitable\" at that moment abovementioned \"properties of intellectuals\", as well as the lack of sufficient\ncontrol from the workers over the organizational work of intellectuals. Most\nof all, hesitation and indecision, which are so characteristic of the\nintelligentsia and which the intelligentsia is guilty of, are unacceptable to\nLenin.\nAny hesitation after the adoption of a collective decision was tantamount to\nbetrayal and defeat for Lenin. Ilyich is always tuned and charged for victory.\nThe same applies to compromises (namely in relation to his ideological\nopponents), to which the bourgeois intelligentsia is most inclined, being weak\nin spirit (i.e. not having fundamental ideological convictions). Lenin also\nincludes here the desire to sit on two chairs; nowadays — this is the\nnotorious political \"multi-vector\". Indecision and hesitation, in the end, often\nturn into extra unnecessary victims; these are those absurd mistakes that\ncould have been avoided by adhering to a firm position. The enemy is like an\nuncomfortable hard, but \"firm ground\", and the wavering and indecisive\n\n\f\"fellow traveler\" is akin to a swamp: try to know when it will \"absorb\" and\n\"digest\" you, i.e. simply betray.\nIn modern Russia, the role of the petty-bourgeois wavering conciliators with\nthose in power is played by \"pocket\" parties and groups like modern\ncentrists, communists, liberals of all names, etc., with a vague position —\ndeclassed elements, dangling somewhere \"between here and between\nthere\"; the place of the actual spokesman for the opinions of the working\nclass of wage workers remains vacant as before. In general, regarding the\nbetrayal and apostasy of the intelligentsia, when the cause of a whole life is\nthreatened, anyone would speak even more harshly and emotionally than\nVladimir Ilyich does.\nAs in the times of V.I. Lenin, modern political and economic literature is full\nof all kinds of absurdities: and some \"middle class\" was invented, and\nownership of the means of production no longer has any significance, and a\ntwo-party system is strictly obligatory for progress, etc. If you come to think\nof it, any person always has an internal content-form (i.e. at least twocomponent, two-sided, dual) contradiction, which serves as the engine of all\nprogress and development even more fiercely than the contest, competition\nor conflict of two or several parties; in one person, opposing components can\nbe observed and coexist, giving such an impulse of activity that no parties\nare needed at all.\nAs they say in Russia: \"In Russia there is still one party — it is just called\ndifferently.\" However, something similar is observed in other countries. For\nexample, in the USA, liberals and conservatives (Democrats and Republicans)\nhave long been fighting for power only for the sake of protecting and\nincreasing the property and income of the propertied class. In addition, one\nmust always be prepared for the fact that over time the \"bourgeoisification\"\nof the most advanced and progressive parties at first occurs due to the\ndegeneration of the top and part of the members of these parties into their\nopposites — such is the dialectical nature of reality: one just needs to recall\nthis more often and shake up (clean out, as Lenin said) the party ranks.\nAs in the times of Lenin's pre-revolutionary political activity, today, to curb\nthe threat of stratification and radicalization of society, the bourgeoisie\nsometimes try to integrate the topmost layers of the left and anarchists into\ntheir system, recruit them into their ranks (having bought them off with an\ninsignificant increase in the wealth tax or small concessions and benefits in\nthe social sphere, etc.).\nWhat kind of opposition is it in parliament if it consists of the power-fed\nrepresentatives of the same \"bourgeoisified\" class as the official propertied\nruling class? Where does the dividing line pass between the official power\nand the systemic alleged opposition, among the leading members of which\nthe owners and co-owners (shareholders) of \"factories, newspapers,\nsteamships\" with assets placed outside the borders of our Motherland\nsuddenly find themselves by chance?]\n\n\f\"Intellectuals give the most excellent advice and guiding instructions all the\ntime, but they turn out to be ridiculously, absurdly, disgracefully \"armless\",\nunable to put these advice and instructions into practice, to exercise practical\ncontrol over the fact that the word turns into action. This is where it is\nimpossible to do without the help and without the guiding role of practical\norganizers from the \"people\", from the workers and working peasants\" [9, p.\n474]. In this regard, competitions of practical organizers from workers and\npeasants with each other should be organized, to fight against any\n\"stamping\" and attempts to establish uniformity from above, to which\nintellectuals are so prone.\nAnd then follows an \"absolutely dialectically\" built semantic, in some ways\nfinal construction on the topic of the detailed conversation conducted in the\narticle, giving an idea of the presence of an objective natural direct\nconnection\nbetween\nthe contentful and formal components\nof\nthis\nconstruction, which serves as the brightest confirmation of its dialectics, and,\nconsequently, its truthfulness: \"With democratic and socialist\ncentralism, stamping or establishing uniformity from above has\nnothing in common. Unity in the main, in the root, in the essential is\nnot violated, but is ensured by diversity in details, in local features,\nin approaches to the matter, in ways of exercising control, in ways of\ndestroying and neutralizing parasites (the rich and crooks, slops and\nhysterics from the intelligentsia, etc., etc.)\".\n[Ah, if Ilyich were with us throughout the entire period of socialist\nconstruction, what unforgivably gross mistakes we could have avoided in\norder not to betray the most fruitful idea and not to deviate from this path!\nDialectics is the skill or art of balancing on the razor's edge, to walk on the\nsharpest blade without cutting and without falling to either side. At the same\ntime, this is not eclecticism and by no means the ability to sit on two chairs\nat once (not adherence to the so-called multi-vector).]\nThe Soviets of working people's deputies must follow the path of combining,\non the one hand, the initiative, independence, freedom of movement, energy\nfrom below and, on the other hand, voluntary, alien to templates, centralism.\nIt is necessary that any and every commune (factory, village, consumer\nsociety, supply committee) should come out, competing with another\ncommune, as a practical organizer of accounting and control over labor and\ndistribution of products. The communes themselves must develop and test in\npractice thousands of forms and methods of practical accounting and control\nover the rich and crooks. \"Diversity here is a guarantee of vitality, a\nguarantee of success in achieving a common single goal. ... The more\ndiverse, the better, the richer the general experience will be, the more\nreliable and faster, the easier the practice will develop — for only practice\ncan develop — the best methods and means of struggle\" [9, p. 475]. The\ncompetition of communes, communities, consumer-production societies and\npartnerships, Soviets of workers', peasants' and soldiers' deputies should\n\n\fdevelop on the issues of eliminating hunger, unemployment, eradicating the\nrich idlers, scoundrels from the lackeys of the bourgeoisie, saboteurs (calling\nthemselves intellectuals), on the issues of increasing labor productivity,\nbuilding new good houses for the poor, housing the poor in the houses of the\nrich, supplying a bottle of milk to every child from poor families. It is in the\ncourse of this work that organizational talents, which are abundant in the\npeople, should be practically singled out and promoted to the top, to the\nbodies of all-state administration. \"They need to be helped to unfold. They\nand they alone, with the support of the masses, will be able to save Russia\nand save the cause of socialism\" [9, p. 476].\n[And again, new optimal (best) relations with new components are being\nsought and found: {emancipated creative labor / socialized socialist\nenterprise}, {organizational talent of the working people / accounting and\ncontrol over production and distribution}, {knowledge and experience of an\neducated employee (intelligentsia) / control and efforts of a simple worker\nregarding the eradication of sloppiness and irresponsibility of an educated\nemployee (intelligentsia)}, {initiative and initiative of workers on the ground\n/ voluntary democratic socialist centralism}, — the correlations of which at\nthis particular moment (in contrast to the previously established relations\nwith known components {wage labor / capital}, {proletariat/bourgeoisie},\n{competing diversity/monopoly}, {enterprise / established bureaucratic\norder}) can give an additional impetus to the further revolutionary\nmovement. Thus, the task of reaching new correlations of components in\nsuch more general relations as {theory/practice}, {mental labor / physical\nlabor}, etc. is implicitly solved.]\n4. The article \"The Main Task of Our Days\" [9, pp. 569-573] was printed in\nMarch 1918. As an epigraph, the article was preceded by words from N.A.\nNekrasov's poem \"Who Lives Well in Russia\": \"You are both poor, you are\nboth abundant, you are both mighty, you are both powerless — Mother\nRussia!\". The article is written at the moment of the great turn from war to\npeace; from the war between predators, sending millions of exploited\nworkers to the slaughter in order to establish a new order of dividing the\nlooted booty, — to the war of the oppressed against the oppressors, for\nliberation from the yoke of capital and for a future society of sufficiency and\ndurable peace.\nRussia had to experience especially acutely the sharpest turns of history,\nturning from imperialism to the communist revolution. In a few days, one of\nthe oldest, most powerful, barbaric and brutal monarchies was destroyed; in\na few months, a number of stages of conciliation with the bourgeoisie, of\noutliving petty-bourgeois illusions were passed, for which other countries\nspent decades; in a few weeks the bourgeoisie was overthrown and its open\nresistance in the civil conflict was overcome. Bolshevism made a triumphant\nprocession from end to end of the vast country, and the lowest of the layers\nof the working masses oppressed by tsarism and the bourgeoisie were\nraised, introduced to independent life and endowed with freedom. The Soviet\n\n\frepublic was established — a new type of state, immeasurably higher and\nmore democratic than the best of the bourgeois-parliamentary republics. The\ndictatorship of the proletariat, supported by the poorest peasantry, was\nestablished, and the implementation of the conceived system of socialist\ntransformations began. Faith in one's own strength was awakened and the\nfire of enthusiasm was lit in millions and millions of workers of all countries\n[pride for everything done shines through in every Lenin's word.]\n\"And in a few days the imperialist predator who attacked the unarmed ...\nthrew us to the ground. The predator presses and chokes and tears Russia to\npieces with the greater frenzy, the more menacingly the specter of the\nworkers' revolution rises in his own country [we are talking about Germany].\nWe were forced to sign the \"Tilsit\" peace\" [9, p. 570].\nBut one must have the courage to look straight into the face of the bitter\ntruth and \"measure entirely, to the bottom, the whole abyss of defeat,\ndismemberment, enslavement and humiliation into which we have now been\npushed. The clearer we understand this, the more solid, tempered, steel our\nwill to liberation will become... our unbending determination to achieve at all\ncosts that Russia ceases to be poor and powerless, so that it becomes in the\nfull sense of the word mighty and abundant.\" And this will certainly happen,\nfor there is still enough space and natural wealth, \"there is material both in\nnatural wealth, and in the reserve of human strength, and in the excellent\nscope that the great revolution gave to folk creativity, — to create a truly\nmighty and abundant Russia.\"\nAnd Russia will become so if it throws away all despondency and all\nphraseology and, gritting its teeth, gathers all its strength. All that is needed\nnow is to move forward along the path of the socialist revolution, not losing\nheart from defeats, to work on strengthening self-discipline, organization and\norder, on improving the system of universal accounting and control over\nproduction and distribution of products: \"this is the path to creating military\npower and socialist power\" [9, p. 571].\nIn the event of a heavy defeat (the consequence of which was the signing of\nthe Treaty of Tilsit), Lenin says, it is unworthy either to swagger or to fall\ninto despair, as well as to agree with accusations of betraying one's ideals\nand one's friends. The commander who leads the remnants of the defeated\narmy into the depths of the country does not commit treason in relation to\nthose units which he is unable to help, but fulfills his duty, saving what can\nstill be saved, \"ceding space to gain time\", using any respite to gather\nstrength. The war shook Russia, and it, undoubtedly, is moving \"from the\nTreaty of Tilsit to a national upsurge, to a great patriotic war... to an\ninternational socialist revolution\", and not to a bourgeois state. \"We have\nbeen defenders since October 25, 1917. We are for the \"defense of the\nfatherland\", but that patriotic war to which we are going is a war for the\nsocialist fatherland, for socialism as a fatherland, for the Soviet Republic...\"\n\n\fInstead of the slogan, Lenin continues, of bourgeois patriotism \"Hatred for\nthe German, beat the German\", the Bolsheviks will say: \"Learn from the\nGerman! Remain faithful to the fraternal union with the German workers...\nHistory moves in zigzags and roundabout ways. It turned out so that\nit is the German who now embodies, along with bestial imperialism,\nthe beginning of discipline, organization, harmonious cooperation on\nthe basis of machine industry, the strictest accounting and control.\nAnd this is exactly what we lack. This is exactly what we need to\nlearn. This is exactly what our great revolution lacks in order to come\nfrom a victorious beginning... to a victorious end. This is exactly what\nis required of the Russian Soviet Socialist Republic in order to cease\nto be poor and powerless, in order to irrevocably become mighty and\nabundant\" [9, pp. 572-573].\n[The very unexpected turn \"about the German\", very consonant with some\nprogressive opinions in our days too! Taking this circumstance into account,\na new relation of components with a perspective of increasing\nthe contentful component (due to the growth of the economy) and an\nincrease in contentfulness of the entire relation as a whole is emerging on\nthe horizon].\n\no\n\no\n\no\n\no\n\n5. \"Theses of the Central Committee of the RCP(b) in connection with\nthe situation on the Eastern Front\" [10, pp. 145-147] of April 11, 1919\nplayed a huge role in the mobilization of the proletarian masses in the\nstruggle against Kolchak.\nKolchak's victories on the Eastern Front force both party organizations and\ntrade unions to implement the following measures in the shortest possible\ntime to involve broader layers of the working class in the active participation\nin the defense of the country.\nComprehensive support for the announced mobilization. The\nmobilized must see the active participation of trade unions and feel the\nsupport of their working class. From each party and trade union organization,\nthe Central Committee demands a weekly, albeit the shortest, report on what\nhas been done to help the mobilization and the mobilized.\nIn the frontline areas, it is necessary to carry out the universal\narming of all members of trade unions. \"Trade unions must everywhere with\ntheir own forces and means carry out a verification registration of their\nmembers for sending all those not absolutely necessary at home, to fight for\nthe Volga and the Urals\" [10, p. 146].\nThe most serious attention should be paid to strengthening agitation\namong the mobilized, mobilized and Red Army men: not to limit oneself to\nlectures and rallies, but to ensure that every member of the trade union\npersonally participates in agitation events and in personal conversations.\n\"Replace all male employees with women. Conduct a new reregistration for this, both party and trade union. Introduce special cards for\nall members of trade unions and all employees with a note on personal\nparticipation in the matter of helping the Red Army\" [10, p. 146].\n\n\fo\n\no\no\n\nImmediately establish assistance bureaus or support committees\nwith published addresses and notification of them to the population in the\nwidest possible way. Every mobilized person must know that in such a\nbureau or committee he will find help, advice, support to facilitate\ncommunication with military institutions, etc. A special task of such bureaus\nwill be to assist in the matter of supplying the Red Army with weapons,\nclothing, factory stocks of various property. \"For this task, one must take it\nwith all one's might\", immediate assistance must be provided to military\ninstitutions by the population itself [10, p. 147].\nThrough trade unions, the wide involvement of peasant youth from\nnon-agricultural provinces in the ranks of the Red Army should be organized.\n\"In relation to the Mensheviks and Socialist-Revolutionaries, the\nparty line in the current situation is as follows: to prison those who help\nKolchak consciously or unconsciously. We will not tolerate in our republic\nworking people who do not help us in deed in the struggle against Kolchak\"\n[10, p. 147].\nIn conclusion, Lenin calls to take up this work in a revolutionary, nontemplate way. Kolchak can be defeated quickly and finally, for the victories of\nthe Bolsheviks in the south and the improving international situation\ncontribute to this. \"It is necessary to strain all forces, to unfold revolutionary\nenergy, and Kolchak will be quickly defeated. The Volga, the Urals, Siberia\ncan and must be defended and won back\" [10, p. 147].\n[And again, we see how, on the basis of an accurate analysis of the alignment of\nforces and the situation that has arisen (without any panic and cries like\n\"everything is lost\" and \"every man for himself\"), clear instructions are born and\na complex of the most urgent measures is formed, aimed at correcting the\nsituation for the better. We see from the Content of the given points how\nseriously Lenin assesses this threat, how he seeks ways and approaches to\nactivating the creative energy of people capable of eliminating the threat. We\nalso see how much weight the trade union movement had at that time: the\ntrade union acts on an equal footing with party and management organizations.]\n6. The article \"An Example of the Petrograd Workers\" [10, pp. 213-215]\nappeared in October 1919 in parallel with the resolution of the plenum of the\nCentral Committee of the RCP(b) to carry out the mobilization of communists\nand send the best representatives of the party and the working class to the\nSouthern Front in connection with the difficult situation that had developed\nthere.\nThe workers of Petrograd, at the call of the party, began an intensified\nmobilization and sending of the best workers to fight against Denikin, who was\nactively helped with money and weapons by French and English capital. At the\nsame time, foreign propaganda was working to intimidate the population and the\npersonnel of the revolutionary troops.\n\n\fNever before has the enemy been so close to Moscow, Lenin writes. \"But to repel\nthis danger, in addition to the former forces of the troops, we are moving new\ndetachments of advanced workers capable of creating a turning point in the\nmood in the retreating units\" [10, p. 214].\nThe disorganization of the army ranks was largely caused by a large number of\ndeserters. In this regard, the support of the army by a new influx of proletarian\nforces is of paramount importance. \"Unstable elements will be strengthened, the\nmood will be raised, a turning point will be achieved. The proletariat, as has\nconstantly happened in our revolution, will support and direct the wavering\nstrata of the working population\" [10, p. 214].\nFor a long time, the Petrograd proletariat has borne more burdens than the\nworkers of other industrial centers; on its shoulders are the struggle against\nhunger, and against military danger, and the pulling out of the best workers to\nSoviet positions throughout Russia. But there is not the slightest despondency or\ndecline of strength among the Petrograd workers — they perfectly fulfill the task\nof the vanguard detachment, sending help and support where it is most needed.\n\"When such fresh forces go to strengthen the faltering parts of our army, then\nthe working masses, soldiers from the peasants, receive new leaders from\namong their own people, from among the more developed, more conscious,\nmore spiritually firm workers\" [10, p. 214]. This is the source of the superiority\nof the peasant army over the enemy, which replenishes and supports its ranks\nonly with \"landlords' sons\". It is known that such \"support\" ruined Kolchak, it will\nruin Denikin too. Lenin calls on other workers, following the example of the\nPetrograd workers, to intensify their activities in the troops, to show more\ninitiative and boldness in the desire not to yield to the Petrogradites — and then\nvictory will be for the workers, the bourgeois counter-revolution will be finished\noff. After Petrograd, Moscow has already started moving, after Moscow the rest\nmust start moving.\n[From the content of the article it is clearly visible how important the moral state\n(state of spirit) of the fighting soldiers of the Red Army is for Lenin. It is visible\nhow truly significant the high consciousness of the advanced workers and\nmembers of the Bolshevik party was in those days! Again, it is visible how strong\nand unshakable Lenin's faith in victory and a favorable outcome of the armed\nstruggle is, — his inexhaustible optimism in the most difficult moments of a\nmortal struggle causes deep respect.]\n7. The article \"From the Destruction of the Centuries-old Order to the\nCreation of a New One\" [10, pp. 282-284], written in April 1920, is devoted to\nthe issues set out in the one-day newspaper \"Communist Subbotnik\" of April 11,\n1920. The main topic of the newspaper is the question of communist labor. This\nmost important issue of the construction of socialism could be raised only after\nthe proletariat had conquered political power, only after the expropriation of\nlandlords and capitalists, only after the decisive victories of the proletariat that\nhad conquered state power over the exploiters who had organized desperate\nresistance, counter-revolutionary uprisings and civil war. It seemed that such a\n\n\ftime had already come in early 1918, but a new, stronger wave of counterrevolutionary uprisings broke out so quickly that the Soviet power then had no\nopportunity to deal with the issues of peaceful construction. Now, after\novercoming incredible difficulties and \"unheard-of victories of the Red Army over\nthe hordes of international capitalist reaction\" there are chances that peace will\nbe more lasting and stable.\nSome experience in the construction of socialism already exists, therefore the\nquestion of communist labor can and must be raised point-blank. However, it\nwould be more correct to say: not about communist, but about socialist labor,\nfor we are talking not about the highest, but about the lowest stage of the\ndevelopment of the new social order growing out of capitalism. Communist labor\nis unpaid, voluntary labor, outside the norm, out of the habit of working for the\ncommon good and out of a conscious (turned into a habit) attitude to the\nnecessity of labor as a need of a healthy organism. However, \"it is clear to\neveryone that it is still very, very far to the wide, truly mass application of such\nlabor for us, i.e. for our society, our social order\" [10, p. 283].\nBut the fact that this question has already been raised by the advanced\nproletariat and the state power is a step forward. To come to the big, one must\nstart with the small. \"Subbotniks, labor armies, labor conscription — this is the\npractical implementation in various forms of socialist and communist labor\" [10,\np. 283].\nMistakes and errors in such a difficult matter are inevitable. \"To build a new labor\ndiscipline, to build new forms of social connection between people, to build new\nforms and techniques of attracting people to labor, this is the work of many\nyears and decades. This is the most grateful and noble work\" [10, p. 283].\nNow, after the overthrow of the bourgeoisie and the suppression of its\nresistance, there is already soil on which such work has become possible; the\nproletariat will take up this work with all its energy and will fulfill it.\n[Again, the inexhaustible optimism of V.I. Lenin is admirable. The thesis about\nlabor out of habit as a need of a healthy organism is closely connected with the\nthesis about the contentful filling of the forms of the labor process to the level of\nthe identification of these forms in the final analysis with the very process of\ncognition itself and with the striving through such forms of the cognitive\nprocess to look around the corner, beyond the horizon, into the future as\neffectively and productively as possible.]\nConclusion\nIt should be said that the above-mentioned articles of Lenin were not selected\nspecially or with any particular bias — any of his works of the indicated periods is\nbuilt according to the stencil we have disassembled, according to the type of\nthinking that was formed in V.I. Ulyanov from a young age.\nAs can be seen, every article or work of Lenin, regardless of the range of issues\nconsidered in it, is a model of the effective application of the dialectical approach,\n\n\fextremely in demand and necessary when conducting research of objects,\nprocesses, phenomena in any area of reality, in all spheres of human activity in\norder to obtain the most correct and contentful results of such research.\nIn each work, the scheme of productive (\"triadic\" or three-stage) development of\nthe idea (thesis — antithesis — synthesis) is easily guessed, as well as\nadherence (in the analysis) to the well-known cliché of observing the unity of the\nhistorical and the logical.\nWhat first of all attracts attention in the course of getting acquainted with\nthe content of the theoretical works of V.I. Lenin? The same or similar algorithm\nfor presenting material concerning the issues under study, which is due to the\nvery universal nature of development or the very dialectical nature of any object,\nprocess, phenomenon under study. And Lenin inexorably follows this algorithm,\nrevealing the dialectical essence of the problems under study (\"piling up\" events,\nemerging situations, achieved results, etc.).\nLet us reproduce this algorithm once again.\n1. Composing correct relations of directly interacting side-components in the\nforms (objects, processes, phenomena) under study.\nAt this initial stage of research, one must be able to identify and show the\ndirectly interacting (i.e. the most essential at the moment) opposing, competing,\nopposing sides-components in the forms-relations under study.\n2. Determination and prioritization in the found relations, i.e. identification of the\nactive and passive sides-components in the composed relations.\nAt this stage of research among the directly interacting components in their\nrelations (as a rule, in pairs of such components) one must again be able to\nidentify, guess, understand and highlight, on the one hand, the\nmost contentful (active, leading) and, on the other hand, more formal (passive,\nconservative) components. Thus, such relations are brought to the generalized\nuniversal form {content/form}.\n3. Determination of the probable direction of change (transformation),\nmovement, development of the constituent sides-components (i.e. probable\nchange in the correlation or balance of components) within and inside the\nrelations formed from them, and consequently, the direction of variability of the\nrelations themselves as a whole (taking into account the influences and impact\nof surrounding forms on these relations).\nA correctly composed relation of two correctly identified directly interacting\ncomponents allows to determine and designate the bias or direction of their\nsubsequent change, movement, development of their relation; this bias or\ndirection of movement-development of the relation is conditioned by the\ncorrelation (approximate) of components within the relation, i.e. the degree of\npredominance of one (contentful) component over the other (formal)\ncomponent.\n\n\f4. Forecasting (anticipation) of the development of the relations under study, i.e.\ndetermination of the prospects for the modification of the forms under study\n(objects, processes, phenomena), as well as the prospects for the emergence of\nnew forms.\nAt this stage, both operational and strategic forecasts of the development of the\nforms-relations under study are made, which corresponds to forecasting the\nvariability of existing forms and anticipating the emergence of new forms of\nreality.\nWhen moving to the next stage of research or the next form of reality under\nstudy, paragraphs 1-4 are repeated in the same volume.\nAs can be seen from the presented scheme (algorithm) of conducting research,\nthe identification of two (or more) directly interacting, opposing components in\ntheir relation turns out to be an extremely important point, since it is\nthis Content-form structure (system) that will indicate the direction of its change\nand obtaining in the future an even more contentful structure or a new relation\n(system) composed of even more contentful components. It is important that\nthese are not \"pulled by the ears\" components, not mechanically (or eclectically)\ncombined opposites, but naturally growing one from the other opposing\nconstituent sides, interconnected so much that one can firmly talk about their\ninsignificance without each other.\nA correctly composed relation of two directly interacting components is\nsomething (a system) resembling the behavior of a liquid (or other similar\ncontinuous medium) in communicating vessels. Here, for example, are such\nrelations\n(or\nsystems)\nas:\n{time/space},\n{motion/rest},\n{active\nprinciple/passive principle}, {energy/mass}, {field/matter}, {north pole of a\nmagnet/south pole of a magnet}, {subjective /objective}, etc., etc., — they are\nexamples of correctly composed relations of directly interacting sidescomponents of reality.\nThe correct choice of a pair of interacting components and the formation of a\ncorrect relation from them is tantamount to an artfully formulated question; then\nthe very correct formulation of the question contains at least half of the answer\nto this question, which is a prerequisite for the successful solution of the task at\nhand.\nWell, and examples of incorrectly composed relations can be given much more —\nall unfairly conducted research and obtained false results sufficiently testify to\nthe initially incorrect relations identified [inappropriately chosen and designated\nso-called false grounds lead any research to a dead end]. Therefore, it is\nextremely important to identify the most essential sides of the problems under\nstudy, which are in direct interaction and direct relation to each other.\nAt each stage of the development of reality, at each specific spatio-temporal\nsegment of it, one must be able to correctly identify and identify (i.e. recognize)\nthe directly interacting components that are in contradiction or conflict with each\n\n\fother, conditioned (we are talking about contradiction or conflict) by the search\nfor a new form for the developing contentful component.\nFrom the listed steps of the above scheme (algorithm), a methodology (and\neven more — a whole methodology) for the effective research of any issue, any\nproblem, both in everyday life and in the field of science (so to speak, a\nuniversal research template) is formed.\nOf course, in that former form Lenin's works (and they were written on topical\nissues in connection with some specific events and circumstances) today to some\nextent lose their formal significance, but \"pushing\" the author into the\nbackground for this reason is as reckless and foolish as, for example, giggling at\nthe fact that Alexander the Great fought all his life on horseback, and not in a\ntank or an airplane. After all, in terms of contentful filling and presentation of\nviews, his works are, without any exaggeration, masterpieces (for those\nobsessed with the idea of knowing the essence of dialectics). One just needs to\nlook more pedantically into the composition of any of his articles to see the\nbeauty of the logical-dialectical schemes, constructions and forms. The future\nrequires a person to be more and more versed in the issues of dialectics.\nAs can be seen, in our research and conclusions we do not particularly touch\nupon the temporal context, focusing mainly on Lenin's logic — all the pearls of\nthe research approach shine without a deep attachment to the nuances of that\ngreat historical era. The historical background in each particular case gives the\ndevelopment process only peculiar shades and features, leaving its core (i.e.\ntendencies and patterns) typical and universal. In this perspective, any article by\nLenin, any of his works is a reader on dialectics, a manual on mastering the art\nof dialectical thinking (to some extent invariant with respect to specific historical\nframeworks), i.e. on mastering what belongs to the future. No one has been able\nto understand and feel the \"soul\" of dialectics so deeply for a long time, to the\ngreatest regret.\nAnd how much optimism and faith (namely due to the dialectical nature of the\ncharacter) in a favorable, positive outcome of the matter is laid in each of his\narticles! After all, at times the entire revolutionary movement hung on such a\nthin hair that it was time to fall into despair and run anywhere, fearing the\nreaction. He did not flinch once, and there are no traces of retreat or repentance\nfound to this day by either \"impartial\" historians or rabid enemies. Only forward\n— to the victorious heights of scientific thinking.\nIt would seem that Russia has a full set of conditions and resources (both human\nand natural) to be the most self-sufficient and harmoniously developing state on\nthe planet. And the understanding of the direction, trend, perspective of the\nmovement-development of the people and the country (where and why are we\ngoing?) has been lost since the times of the last most integral dialectician, which\nwas V.I. Lenin. The idea (in the most general form — ideology, and not just\nideology, but the most advanced ideology, which Lenin was guided by) as the\nmost perfect derivative of human consciousness and is the guiding star, which is\n\n\fthe most content-capacious of all reliably known to us forms of our (human)\nlevel of development of reality, — why the most contentful flows of the level of\nhuman consciousness strive to possess this form (to clothe themselves in this\nform). So what, it would seem, is simpler — take and learn dialectics from Lenin\n(master, so to speak, the dialectical style of thinking and advanced ideas, which\nare an inevitable product of this kind of thinking) instead of subjecting him to\nostracism. But no: to grow up to the perception of his ideas, it turns out, is much\nmore difficult than to revile, showing off one's not so perfect brains and very\nlimited abilities.\nMarxism is supposedly too orthodox, and Lenin's ideas have led to a dead\nend and have lost all relevance — these are the arguments of today's\nacademic community (primarily among economists, politicians, historians,\npolitical scientists, etc.). Enlightened people, however, say that one should\nlearn to follow not the letter of Marxism, not the letter of Lenin's\nmanuscripts, but their spirit. The spirit (contentful principle) of dialectics is\neternal: it only passes from form to form, i.e. it simply changes the form of\nits acquiring. And to learn to grasp, to perceive this spirit — this is the\npurpose and main goal of the life and activity of every educated person.\nThe approach described here is intended to direct a person not just to the\nknowledge of some world that has existed since time immemorial, but\npredisposes to a meaningful study of everything that \"is being done\", that \"is\nbeing reproduced\" and \"is being recreated\" right here and now — in real-time\nmode both in our near and far environment.\nAnother appeal to Lenin's words that even 70 Marxs will not be able to cover\nthe \"sum of all these changes in all their branches\" and cope with solving\nsuch a task, contributes to the realization of the circumstance that any, albeit\nthe most adequate at the moment, solution models the behavior of a very\nlimited, \"trimmed\", \"frozen\" system, while reality is constantly changing and\nslips out from under any rigid and comprehensive control. That is why one\nmust learn to perceive and grasp not the volumes of all kinds of changes of\nreal forms, but the trend of these changes, which is ultimately the key and\ncondition for the successful cognition of developing reality and the\ncomprehension of objective truth.\nWith an eye to what has been said, it becomes obvious how one should\nrelate to the question of the cognizability of the world. Since the world, the\nUniverse are incessantly and unceasingly \"being made\", \"being recreated by\npiling up\" (according to the formulation of the principle of self-development),\nand do not represent a kind of suitcase with books, then the cognition of the\nbeing made, every moment reproduced world — this is all the more an\ninfinite and infinitely fascinating contentful process. How can one talk about\nsome kind of comprehensive, complete and final knowledge of the world if\nthe world is incessantly \"unfolding\" with more and more contentful forms? In\nthis section, it is more reasonable to talk about the cognizability and\ncognition of the world as about the improvement of capabilities for\n\n\fanticipating such an \"unfolding\" of forms, capabilities for guessing the\nemergence of new ones and the trend of changing existing forms, i.e. for\nforecasting future events and their consequences, speaking in the usual\neveryday language. Effective forecasting of the development of the forms of\nreality — this is the perspective of the contentful development of mankind. In\ntimes when, due to the infinitely routine everyday cyclicity, a person sees no\nmeaning in life and in his existence, an opportunity opens up to look at all\nthis with completely different eyes. Every person is not just capable, but is\nobliged to become a researcher. In each of us, a subconscious striving is\ndormant to manage to look around the corner, beyond the horizon (satisfying\none's innate curiosity), to anticipate the onset of events, to forecast and\nanticipate the emergence and development of new forms. It is only\nnecessary to activate this dormant natural striving and give it a new impulse,\ni.e. consciously bring it to a new level.\nThere is not a single argument refuting or at least questioning the validity\n(universality and generality) of the dialectical concept of the development of\nreality — undoubtedly, it must be mastered and learn to correctly and\neffectively apply it.\nIn conclusion, I would like to appeal to the youth again: read Lenin, guys,\nenjoy the beauty of thought, clarity and consistency of the presentation of\nthe material, as well as the magnificent Russian language. This is our largest\nnational thinker, a born dialectician, who will give odds to any modern\nphilosophizing professional. His works contain developments that will be of\ninterest to society and the state for decades to come. This is not the priests'\nscholastic tricks, sucked out of the finger and postulating the\nAbsolute Form —\nwith\nwhatever\nspirituality,\n\"spirituality\",\nperfect\norganization and Absolute Content (in words) this Form is identified with.\nThrough the mouth of Vladimir Ilyich, life itself speaks to us. In his\nreflections you will find answers for yourself or at least prerequisites for\nfinding answers to the main worldview questions, you will feel out the right\npath to understanding the patterns of the development of reality (both of\nnature and of human communities).\nOne should not think that everything has already been passed, laid out and\nsummed up. Everything is just beginning — with each new turn of the\ndevelopment of reality, the struggle for the highest contentfulness acquires\nnew and more diverse forms: \"And again the battle continues, and the heart\nis anxious in the chest, and Lenin is so young, and a NEW October is\nahead...\".\n\nReferences\n1. Valentinov N.V. Vstrechi s Leninym [Elektronnyi resurs] // URL: https://www .\nyoubooks . com/book/N-Valentinov/Vstrechi-S-Leninym\n2.\nVideo\ntrailer\n[Elektronnyi\nresurs]\n//\nURL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V06B1mDMngI\n\n\f3. Vladlen V.K. Raspoznat' ochevidnoe. Netrivial'nyi vzglyad na evolyutsiyu\n[Tekst]. — SPb.: Super Izdatel'stvo, 2016. — 68 s.\n4. Dostoevskii F.M. Besy [Tekst] // Sobr. soch. V 15 t. — T. 7. — L.: Nauka,\n1990. — 673 s.\n5. Kravchenko V.V. Eshe raz o kriteriyakh istiny [Elektronnyi resurs] // Zhurnal\nfilosofskikh issledovaniy. — 2020. — T. 6, № 2. — S. 26–91. —\nURL: https://naukaru.ru/ru/nauka/article/37631/view\n6. Kravchenko V.V. K voprosu o prirode, smysle i roli mirovikh konstant\n[Elektronnyi resurs] // Zhurnal filosofskikh issledovaniy. — 2018. — T. 4, № 3.\n— S. 7–14. — URL: https://naukaru.ru/ru/nauka/article/22361/view\n7. Kravchenko V.V. Kontseptsiya razvitiya: vzglyad iznutri [Elektronnyi resurs] //\nZhurnal filosofskikh issledovaniy. — 2018. — T. 4, № 2. — S. 47–73. —\nURL: https://naukaru.ru/ru/nauka/article/20489/view\n8. Lenin V.I. Izbrannye proizvedeniya [Tekst]. V 3 t. — T. 1. — M.: Politizdat,\n1978. — 843 s.\n9. Lenin V.I. Izbrannye proizvedeniya [Tekst]. V 3 t. — T. 2. — M.: Politizdat,\n1978. — 826 s.\n10. Lenin V.I. Izbrannye proizvedeniya [Tekst]. V 3 t. — T. 3. — M.: Politizdat,\n1978. — 856 s.\n11. Lenin V.I. Materializm i empirikrititsizm [Tekst]. — M.: Politizdat, 1979. —\n384 s.\n12. Lenin V.I. Ob\"edinennoe zasedanie VTIK, Moskovskogo Soveta, fabrichnozavodskikh komitetov i professional'nykh soyzov 22 oktyabrya 1918 g. Doklad\n[Tekst] // Poli. sobr. soch. — 5 izd. — T. 37. — M: Politizdat, 1969. — 748 s.\n13. Loginov V.T Neizvestnyi Lenin [Tekst]. — M: Izd. Eksmo, Algoritm, 2010. —\n576 s.\n14. Satanovskii E.Ya. Budet nam i belka, budet i svistok... [Elektronnyi resurs] //\nURL: https://inforuss.info/satanovskij-budet-nam-i-belka-budet-i-svistok\n15. Filosofskiy entsiklopedicheskiy slovar' [Tekst] / Gl. red.: L.F. Il'ichev, P.N.\nFedoseev, SM. Kovalev, V.G. Panov. — M: Sov. entsiklopediya, 1983. — 840 s.\n16. Engels F. Razvitie sotsializma ot utopii k nauke [Tekst] / Marks K. i Engels F.\nIzbrannye proizvedeniya. V 3 t. — T. 3. — M: Politizdat, 1979. — 643 s.\n17. Engels F. Revolutsiya i kontrevolyutsiya v Germanii [Tekst] // Marks K.,\nEngels F. Soch. — 2 izd. — T. 8. — M.: Politizdat, 1957. — 701 s.\n18. Vladlen V.K. To Cognize the Obviousness. Nontrivial Outlook on Evolution. —\nHouston, TX 77065: Strategic Book Publishing and Rights Co., 2013.— 46 p.\n\nTranslation in English: Advanced AI models have translated the book from\nRussian into English. However, final copy-editing of the English text by a native\nspeaker is still advisable and welcome."}