| [ |
| { |
| "entry_id": "A_001", |
| "sample_id": "224", |
| "dimension": "A", |
| "dimension_name": "Overlap", |
| "question": "Has the rearrangement of elements on this slide introduced any new overlaps between objects?", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "label": true, |
| "objects_involved": [ |
| 132, |
| 133, |
| 135, |
| 136, |
| 139, |
| 140, |
| 142, |
| 143, |
| 145, |
| 146, |
| 148, |
| 149, |
| 151, |
| 152 |
| ], |
| "evidence": { |
| "new_overlap_pairs": [ |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 132, |
| "shape_a_type": "TextBox", |
| "shape_b_id": 133, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 0.2028 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 135, |
| "shape_a_type": "TextBox", |
| "shape_b_id": 139, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 1.0 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 135, |
| "shape_a_type": "TextBox", |
| "shape_b_id": 142, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 1.0 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 136, |
| "shape_a_type": "TextBox", |
| "shape_b_id": 140, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 0.7837 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 136, |
| "shape_a_type": "TextBox", |
| "shape_b_id": 143, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 0.7837 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "difficulty": "Easy", |
| "difficulty_rationale": "High IoU of 1.00 — overlap is visually obvious", |
| "source_files": { |
| "original_json": "json/original_224.json", |
| "perturbed_json": "json/perturbed_224.json", |
| "updates_json": "json/llm_schema/updates_224.json", |
| "original_png": "png/original_224_1.png", |
| "perturbed_png": "png/perturbed_224_1.png" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "entry_id": "A_002", |
| "sample_id": "58", |
| "dimension": "A", |
| "dimension_name": "Overlap", |
| "question": "Do any elements on this slide overlap with each other in a way that was not present in the original design?", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "label": true, |
| "objects_involved": [ |
| 2, |
| 6, |
| 7 |
| ], |
| "evidence": { |
| "new_overlap_pairs": [ |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 2, |
| "shape_a_type": "Group", |
| "shape_b_id": 6, |
| "shape_b_type": "Rectangle", |
| "iou": 0.0227 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 2, |
| "shape_a_type": "Group", |
| "shape_b_id": 7, |
| "shape_b_type": "Chart", |
| "iou": 0.9187 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "difficulty": "Easy", |
| "difficulty_rationale": "High IoU of 0.92 — overlap is visually obvious", |
| "source_files": { |
| "original_json": "json/original_58.json", |
| "perturbed_json": "json/perturbed_58.json", |
| "updates_json": "json/llm_schema/updates_58.json", |
| "original_png": "png/original_58_1.png", |
| "perturbed_png": "png/perturbed_58_1.png" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "entry_id": "A_003", |
| "sample_id": "444", |
| "dimension": "A", |
| "dimension_name": "Overlap", |
| "question": "Are there shapes on this slide that now cover or occlude other shapes compared to the original layout?", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "label": true, |
| "objects_involved": [ |
| 448, |
| 449, |
| 434, |
| 435, |
| 436, |
| 444, |
| 445, |
| 446, |
| 447 |
| ], |
| "evidence": { |
| "new_overlap_pairs": [ |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 434, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 435, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.2655 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 434, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 447, |
| "shape_b_type": "Group", |
| "iou": 0.2946 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 434, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 448, |
| "shape_b_type": "Freeform", |
| "iou": 0.2822 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 434, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 449, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 0.2946 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 435, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 444, |
| "shape_b_type": "Group", |
| "iou": 0.0672 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "difficulty": "Medium", |
| "difficulty_rationale": "Moderate IoU of 0.29 — overlap visible but not dramatic", |
| "source_files": { |
| "original_json": "json/original_444.json", |
| "perturbed_json": "json/perturbed_444.json", |
| "updates_json": "json/llm_schema/updates_444.json", |
| "original_png": "png/original_444.png", |
| "perturbed_png": "png/perturbed_444.png" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "entry_id": "A_004", |
| "sample_id": "144", |
| "dimension": "A", |
| "dimension_name": "Overlap", |
| "question": "Are there shapes on this slide that now cover or occlude other shapes compared to the original layout?", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "label": true, |
| "objects_involved": [ |
| 25, |
| 18, |
| 2 |
| ], |
| "evidence": { |
| "new_overlap_pairs": [ |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 18, |
| "shape_a_type": "Rectangle", |
| "shape_b_id": 25, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.2691 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 2, |
| "shape_a_type": "", |
| "shape_b_id": 25, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.1415 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "difficulty": "Medium", |
| "difficulty_rationale": "Moderate IoU of 0.27 — overlap visible but not dramatic", |
| "source_files": { |
| "original_json": "json/original_144.json", |
| "perturbed_json": "json/perturbed_144.json", |
| "updates_json": "json/llm_schema/updates_144.json", |
| "original_png": "png/original_144_1.png", |
| "perturbed_png": "png/perturbed_144_1.png" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "entry_id": "A_005", |
| "sample_id": "213", |
| "dimension": "A", |
| "dimension_name": "Overlap", |
| "question": "Do any elements on this slide overlap with each other in a way that was not present in the original design?", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "label": true, |
| "objects_involved": [ |
| 16, |
| 2, |
| 3, |
| 4 |
| ], |
| "evidence": { |
| "new_overlap_pairs": [ |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 16, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 2, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.1438 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 2, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 3, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.0568 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 2, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 4, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.2581 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "difficulty": "Medium", |
| "difficulty_rationale": "Moderate IoU of 0.26 — overlap visible but not dramatic", |
| "source_files": { |
| "original_json": "json/original_213.json", |
| "perturbed_json": "json/perturbed_213.json", |
| "updates_json": "json/llm_schema/updates_213.json", |
| "original_png": "png/original_213.png", |
| "perturbed_png": "png/perturbed_213.png" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "entry_id": "A_006", |
| "sample_id": "410", |
| "dimension": "A", |
| "dimension_name": "Overlap", |
| "question": "Are there shapes on this slide that now cover or occlude other shapes compared to the original layout?", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "label": true, |
| "objects_involved": [ |
| 1026, |
| 3, |
| 1030, |
| 7, |
| 1032, |
| 1034 |
| ], |
| "evidence": { |
| "new_overlap_pairs": [ |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 3, |
| "shape_a_type": "", |
| "shape_b_id": 7, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.0624 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 3, |
| "shape_a_type": "", |
| "shape_b_id": 1030, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.0496 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 3, |
| "shape_a_type": "", |
| "shape_b_id": 1032, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.062 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 3, |
| "shape_a_type": "", |
| "shape_b_id": 1034, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.049 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 3, |
| "shape_a_type": "", |
| "shape_b_id": 1026, |
| "shape_b_type": "Picture", |
| "iou": 0.049 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "difficulty": "Hard", |
| "difficulty_rationale": "Low IoU of 0.06 — subtle edge overlap", |
| "source_files": { |
| "original_json": "json/original_410.json", |
| "perturbed_json": "json/perturbed_410.json", |
| "updates_json": "json/llm_schema/updates_410.json", |
| "original_png": "png/original_410.png", |
| "perturbed_png": "png/perturbed_410.png" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "entry_id": "A_007", |
| "sample_id": "112", |
| "dimension": "A", |
| "dimension_name": "Overlap", |
| "question": "Has the rearrangement of elements on this slide introduced any new overlaps between objects?", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "label": true, |
| "objects_involved": [ |
| 147, |
| 148, |
| 149, |
| 150, |
| 151, |
| 152, |
| 153, |
| 154, |
| 155, |
| 156, |
| 93, |
| 94, |
| 95, |
| 160, |
| 157, |
| 162, |
| 158 |
| ], |
| "evidence": { |
| "new_overlap_pairs": [ |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 93, |
| "shape_a_type": "Group", |
| "shape_b_id": 147, |
| "shape_b_type": "Group", |
| "iou": 0.049 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 93, |
| "shape_a_type": "Group", |
| "shape_b_id": 148, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 0.0166 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 93, |
| "shape_a_type": "Group", |
| "shape_b_id": 150, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 0.0144 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 93, |
| "shape_a_type": "Group", |
| "shape_b_id": 151, |
| "shape_b_type": "Group", |
| "iou": 0.049 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 93, |
| "shape_a_type": "Group", |
| "shape_b_id": 152, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 0.0166 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "difficulty": "Hard", |
| "difficulty_rationale": "Low IoU of 0.05 — subtle edge overlap", |
| "source_files": { |
| "original_json": "json/original_112.json", |
| "perturbed_json": "json/perturbed_112.json", |
| "updates_json": "json/llm_schema/updates_112.json", |
| "original_png": "png/original_112.png", |
| "perturbed_png": "png/perturbed_112.png" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "entry_id": "A_008", |
| "sample_id": "30", |
| "dimension": "A", |
| "dimension_name": "Overlap", |
| "question": "Do any elements on this slide overlap with each other in a way that was not present in the original design?", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "label": true, |
| "objects_involved": [ |
| 3, |
| 6, |
| 7, |
| 8, |
| 9, |
| 10, |
| 12, |
| 13, |
| 14, |
| 15, |
| 16 |
| ], |
| "evidence": { |
| "new_overlap_pairs": [ |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 6, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 8, |
| "shape_b_type": "", |
| "iou": 0.0935 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 9, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 8, |
| "shape_b_type": "", |
| "iou": 0.0379 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 10, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 8, |
| "shape_b_type": "", |
| "iou": 0.0513 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 12, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 8, |
| "shape_b_type": "", |
| "iou": 0.097 |
| }, |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 13, |
| "shape_a_type": "Picture", |
| "shape_b_id": 8, |
| "shape_b_type": "", |
| "iou": 0.0955 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "difficulty": "Hard", |
| "difficulty_rationale": "Low IoU of 0.10 — subtle edge overlap", |
| "source_files": { |
| "original_json": "json/original_30.json", |
| "perturbed_json": "json/perturbed_30.json", |
| "updates_json": "json/llm_schema/updates_30.json", |
| "original_png": "png/original_30_1.png", |
| "perturbed_png": "png/perturbed_30_1.png" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "entry_id": "A_009", |
| "sample_id": "7", |
| "dimension": "A", |
| "dimension_name": "Overlap", |
| "question": "Are there shapes on this slide that now cover or occlude other shapes compared to the original layout?", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "label": true, |
| "objects_involved": [ |
| 17, |
| 51 |
| ], |
| "evidence": { |
| "new_overlap_pairs": [ |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 17, |
| "shape_a_type": "Rounded Rectangle", |
| "shape_b_id": 51, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 0.0285 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "difficulty": "Ambiguous", |
| "difficulty_rationale": "Minimal IoU of 0.03 — may be decorative contact", |
| "source_files": { |
| "original_json": "json/original_7.json", |
| "perturbed_json": "json/perturbed_7.json", |
| "updates_json": "json/llm_schema/updates_7.json", |
| "original_png": "png/original_7_1.png", |
| "perturbed_png": "png/perturbed_7_1.png" |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "entry_id": "A_010", |
| "sample_id": "51", |
| "dimension": "A", |
| "dimension_name": "Overlap", |
| "question": "Do any elements on this slide overlap with each other in a way that was not present in the original design?", |
| "ground_truth": { |
| "label": true, |
| "objects_involved": [ |
| 17, |
| 51 |
| ], |
| "evidence": { |
| "new_overlap_pairs": [ |
| { |
| "shape_a_id": 17, |
| "shape_a_type": "Rounded Rectangle", |
| "shape_b_id": 51, |
| "shape_b_type": "TextBox", |
| "iou": 0.0285 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "difficulty": "Ambiguous", |
| "difficulty_rationale": "Minimal IoU of 0.03 — may be decorative contact", |
| "source_files": { |
| "original_json": "json/original_51.json", |
| "perturbed_json": "json/perturbed_51.json", |
| "updates_json": "json/llm_schema/updates_51.json", |
| "original_png": "png/original_51_1.png", |
| "perturbed_png": "png/perturbed_51_1.png" |
| } |
| } |
| ] |
