diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/smoke/scores.jsonl b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/smoke/scores.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..eeecb82c96a5346762f90df9ac0c804da9ade0b7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/smoke/scores.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::000_seed_42", "pair_id": "000_seed_42", "sample_index": 0, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey across a polished wooden tabletop, reflecting the ambient light and casting delicate shadows. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's gentle, mesmerizing roll. As it moves, the ball's surface mirrors the room's soft hues and subtle textures, creating a dynamic interplay of light and shadow. The tabletop's smooth grain enhances the ball's seamless glide, while the ambient sounds of a quiet room add to the tranquil atmosphere. The ball's path is unpredictable yet graceful, embodying a serene dance of motion and stillness in a harmonious setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_000_seed_42_A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey acro.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 402, "t": 413, "p": 425}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions. Text Prompt Analysis: The prompt describes a crystal-clear glass ball rolling on a polished wooden tabletop with ambient lighting, capturing a serene, dynamic motion in a harmonious setting. Visual Quality Analysis: Across the frames, the rendering is strong with high resolution and clear detail in the glass ball, reflections, and the wooden surface. Lighting is consistent, and the depth-of-field provides convincing separation between the ball and background. A few frames show minor imperfections (e.g., occasional slight softness or rare artifacts), but these do not substantially detract from the overall impression. Overall, visual quality is solid and near the top end of the scale, though not flawless. Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis: The video largely reflects the core elements of the prompt: a crystal-clear glass ball on a polished wooden surface, with reflections and ambient lighting contributing to a serene atmosphere. The camera appears stable and the ball’s motion is present, though in some frames the motion is subtle rather than clearly demonstrated. Shadows and lighting support the described ambiance, and the scene maintains coherence with the textual description. The alignment is strong but not perfect, consistent with a high-quality match to the prompt. Physical Consistency (Common-sense): The dynamics—rolling ball, light reflections, and interaction with the surface—read as physically plausible. Surface reflections and lighting behave plausibly, and the ball’s trajectory aligns with expected physics. There may be minor timing variations or micro-motions that prevent a flawless physical read, but the overall behavior is coherent and convincing. Ground-truth scores indicate 4 for Visual Quality, 4 for Text-to-Video Alignment, and 4 for Physical Consistency, which matches the overall assessment. In summary, the video demonstrates strong fidelity across all three dimensions, with small imperfections preventing a perfect top score.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.589} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::000_seed_42", "pair_id": "000_seed_42", "sample_index": 0, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey across a polished wooden tabletop, reflecting the ambient light and casting delicate shadows. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's gentle, mesmerizing roll. As it moves, the ball's surface mirrors the room's soft hues and subtle textures, creating a dynamic interplay of light and shadow. The tabletop's smooth grain enhances the ball's seamless glide, while the ambient sounds of a quiet room add to the tranquil atmosphere. The ball's path is unpredictable yet graceful, embodying a serene dance of motion and stillness in a harmonious setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_000_seed_42_A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey acro.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 482, "t": 493, "p": 411}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey across a polished wooden tabletop, reflecting the ambient light and casting delicate shadows. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's gentle, mesmerizing roll. As it moves, the ball's surface mirrors the room's soft hues and subtle textures, creating a dynamic interplay of light and shadow. The tabletop's smooth grain enhances the ball's seamless glide, while the ambient sounds of a quiet room add to the tranquil atmosphere. The ball's path is unpredictable yet graceful, embodying a serene dance of motion and stillness in a harmonious setting\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visual quality is strong and aligns with a high-quality render. The ball is clearly visible, reflections and refractions through the glass read convincingly, and the wood texture has good detail. Lighting remains stable across frames, and sharpness is solid though not perfect, with minor softness likely artistic rather than a flaw. There are no major distortions or misalignments, and transitions between frames are smooth. In sum, visuals are robust and coherent, consistent with a 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely matches the prompt: the crystal ball, polished wooden surface, ambient reflections, and fixed camera are all present. The ball's rolling motion, the interplay of light and shadows, and the harmonious setting are well captured. While micro-level deviations may exist, they do not undermine the overall alignment, supporting a solid 4/5 score.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nLight behavior, object interactions, and spatial logic adhere to real-world physics. The ball rolls naturally, reflections are physically plausible, and lighting remains coherent with the scene. If any small mismatches occur in shadow or reflection timing, they do not break plausibility and remain within acceptable tolerance. Overall, physical consistency is strong and rated at 4/5.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.261} diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/smoke/summary.json b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/smoke/summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..231bb40793c3f5f565d502022f57955caec9369e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/smoke/summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "total_score_tasks": 2, + "success_score_tasks": 2, + "failed_score_tasks": 0, + "model_name_or_path": "/root/ckpts/VideoScore2", + "scores_jsonl": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/smoke/scores.jsonl", + "shard_count": 1, + "shard_index": 0, + "infer_fps": 2.0, + "floating_method": "weighted", + "do_sample": true, + "score_latency_sec": { + "mean": 14.425, + "median": 14.425, + "min": 13.589, + "max": 15.261 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/logs/shard_0.log b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/logs/shard_0.log new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a61885e130acc5551630abd95a083eddd1f1b5c8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/logs/shard_0.log @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +total score tasks: 600 +selected for shard: 75 +already completed: 0 +remaining: 75 +model_name_or_path: /root/ckpts/VideoScore2 + Loading weights: 0%| | 0/729 [00:00\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions. Text Prompt Analysis: The prompt describes a crystal-clear glass ball rolling on a polished wooden tabletop with ambient lighting, capturing a serene, dynamic motion in a harmonious setting. Visual Quality Analysis: Across the frames, the rendering is strong with high resolution and clear detail in the glass ball, reflections, and the wooden surface. Lighting is consistent, and the depth-of-field provides convincing separation between the ball and background. A few frames show minor imperfections (e.g., occasional slight softness or rare artifacts), but these do not substantially detract from the overall impression. Overall, visual quality is solid and near the top end of the scale, though not flawless. Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis: The video largely reflects the core elements of the prompt: a crystal-clear glass ball on a polished wooden surface, with reflections and ambient lighting contributing to a serene atmosphere. The camera appears stable and the ball’s motion is present, though in some frames the motion is subtle rather than clearly demonstrated. Shadows and lighting support the described ambiance, and the scene maintains coherence with the textual description. The alignment is strong but not perfect, consistent with a high-quality match to the prompt. Physical Consistency (Common-sense): The dynamics—rolling ball, light reflections, and interaction with the surface—read as physically plausible. Surface reflections and lighting behave plausibly, and the ball’s trajectory aligns with expected physics. There may be minor timing variations or micro-motions that prevent a flawless physical read, but the overall behavior is coherent and convincing. Ground-truth scores indicate 4 for Visual Quality, 4 for Text-to-Video Alignment, and 4 for Physical Consistency, which matches the overall assessment. In summary, the video demonstrates strong fidelity across all three dimensions, with small imperfections preventing a perfect top score.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.462} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::001_seed_310", "pair_id": "001_seed_310", "sample_index": 1, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_001_seed_310_A polished metal ball gleaming under soft ambient.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 446, "t": 457, "p": 469}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- High resolution with sharp detail; the metal ball shows strong reflective properties and convincing lighting.\n- Lighting is consistent and warm, contributing to a polished look; no obvious artifacts.\n- Motion appears smooth across frames with stable framing and good depth cues.\n- Reflections on the metallic surface are coherent and contribute to realism.\nOverall, Visual Quality is excellent and aligns with a top score (5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nCompared to the prompt:\n- Polished metal ball, soft ambient lighting, and a fixed camera are present.\n- However, the sequence does not clearly depict the ball rolling across the surface, and the motion is not demonstrated as a deliberate glide in many frames; the ball often appears stationary or slowly rotating.\n- While reflections and lighting are accurate, key elements of dynamic traversal are missing, resulting in only partial alignment with the prompt.\n- Consequently, Text-to-Video Alignment is moderate rather than strong, corresponding to a score of 3.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene remains physically plausible: the ball sits and rotates on the surface with natural shadows and coherent reflections. There are no evident physics violations, and the environment appears consistent with real-world expectations. Minor micro-variations in reflection angles exist but do not undermine plausibility. Overall, Physical Consistency is solid (score 4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.141} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::002_seed_930", "pair_id": "002_seed_930", "sample_index": 2, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, two men stand facing each other, their expressions radiating warmth and camaraderie. One man, wearing a tailored navy suit with a crisp white shirt, extends his hand with a genuine smile. The other, dressed in a charcoal blazer and light blue shirt, reciprocates the gesture, their hands meeting in a firm, enthusiastic handshake. Sunlight streams through large windows, casting a soft glow on the polished wooden floor and contemporary furniture. The atmosphere is one of mutual respect and shared success, captured in this moment of professional connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_002_seed_930_In a sleek modern office with glass walls and mini.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 479, "t": 490, "p": 473}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the provided video frames systematically based on the text prompt which describes \"In a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, two men stand facing each other, their expressions radiating warmth and camaraderie. One man, wearing a tailored navy suit with a crisp white shirt, extends his hand with a genuine smile. The other, dressed in a charcoal blazer and light blue shirt, reciprocates the gesture, their hands meeting in a firm, enthusiastic handshake. Sunlight streams through large windows, casting a soft glow on the polished wooden floor and contemporary furniture. The atmosphere is one of mutual respect and shared success, captured in this moment of professional connection.\"\n\nLet me examine each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Resolution: The video maintains high fidelity with clear subject delineation; overall sharpness supports legibility of facial cues and attire.\n- Clarity: Facial features, clothing details, and background elements (glass walls, windows, wooden floor) are well defined.\n- Smoothness: The handshake is fluid across frames with coherent motion and natural micro-adjustments.\n- Stability: Lighting and contrast stay stable; no distracting flicker or exposure shifts.\n- Distortion/Misalignment: No meaningful distortions; proportions remain consistent.\n- Overall: Visual quality is excellent, with pristine rendering and minimal perceptual artifacts.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The scene faithfully mirrors the prompt’s setting: a modern office with glass walls, minimalist decor, two men facing each other, warm expressions, and a crisp handshake.\n- Clothing and gesture details align with the description (navy suit with white shirt on one participant; dark blazer with light blue shirt on the other), and the handshake dynamics reflect the described enthusiasm.\n- Background elements (natural lighting, polished floor, contemporary furniture) reinforce the intended atmosphere.\n- Overall: Alignment is perfect, with all textual elements realized in the video.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The interaction adheres to plausible real-world physics: gravity, timing, and spatial relations feel authentic; lighting and environmental cues support a realistic scene.\n- Subtle nuances such as timing and grip are coherent within the context, contributing to believability.\n- Overall: High physical realism, with only minor opportunities for minor refinements to reach flawless consensus.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.9999, "elapsed_sec": 16.351} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::004_seed_42", "pair_id": "004_seed_42", "sample_index": 4, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sunlit garden, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile leans forward, his eyes sparkling with joy as he extends his right hand. The camera captures the tender moment in close-up as his fingers gently stroke the soft, black-and-white fur of a Border Collie. The dog's eyes close in contentment, its tail wagging gently, reflecting the bond between them. The boy's laughter fills the air, harmonizing with the gentle rustle of leaves and distant birdsong, creating a serene and heartwarming scene of friendship and affection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_004_seed_42_In a sunlit garden a young boy with tousled hair a.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 439, "t": 451, "p": 496}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it to the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a sunlit garden, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile leans forward, his eyes sparkling with joy as he extends his right hand. The camera captures the tender moment in close-up as his fingers gently stroke the soft, black-and-white fur of a Border Collie. The dog's eyes close in contentment, its tail wagging gently, reflecting the bond between them. The boy's laughter fills the air, harmonizing with the gentle rustle of leaves and distant birdsong, creating a serene and heartwarming scene of friendship and affection\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video exhibits high fidelity across frames. Resolution is consistently sharp, lighting is natural and sunlit, colors are vibrant yet realistic, and the composition remains stable with minimal artifacts. There are no distortions or misalignments, and transitions between frames are smooth, contributing to a cohesive viewing experience. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent (5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll major prompt elements are represented: a sunlit garden setting, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright expression leaning forward, a visible smile, the right-hand extension, and the intimate close-up interaction with a black-and-white dog that resembles a Border Collie. The boy’s hand strokes the dog’s fur, the dog appears relaxed with closed or half-closed eyes, and the mood aligns with a serene and affectionate moment. Audio cues (laughter, leaf rustling, birdsong) cannot be judged from still frames; visually the alignment is strong, supporting a Text-to-Video Alignment rating of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene adheres to plausible real-world dynamics: natural body proportions, believable interaction between child and dog, consistent lighting and shadows, and coherent spatial relations. Despite some minor stylistic rendering choices, the interaction remains physically plausible and coherent, yielding a Physical Consistency rating of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 5\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.561} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::005_seed_310", "pair_id": "005_seed_310", "sample_index": 5, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose, its petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate details of the petals become visible, revealing their velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The rich crimson hue of the petals contrasts beautifully with the subtle green of the surrounding leaves. The camera continues to zoom, capturing the gentle curves and natural patterns etched into each petal, highlighting the rose's elegance and complexity. The scene concludes with an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_005_seed_310_The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 429, "t": 440, "p": 452}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose, its petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate details of the petals become visible, revealing their velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The rich crimson hue of the petals contrasts beautifully with the subtle green of the surrounding leaves. The camera continues to zoom, capturing the gentle curves and natural patterns etched into each petal, highlighting the rose's elegance and complexity. The scene concludes with an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature\".\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong across the sequence. The resolution is consistently high, with sharp detail on the rose and leaves, and natural-looking colors. There are no obvious distortions or artifacts, and lighting remains generally stable with convincing depth-of-field effects. There may be occasional minor exposure variations between frames, but they do not detract from the viewing experience. In short, the visuals meet a high standard with only minor imperfections, supporting a rating around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely follows the prompt: it presents a vibrant red rose with visible dew, a gradual zoom toward the center, and a close-up that reveals petal structures and textures. The soft sunlight and intimate final framing align with the description, resulting in very strong correspondence between text and visuals. While there could be a few tiny deviations in timing or micro-details, these do not meaningfully affect the overall alignment. Overall alignment is solid, consistent with a score around 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains plausible botanical realism throughout—petal arrangement, dew placement, stem curvature, and lighting behave in a physically coherent manner. Subtle artificial cues are minimal and do not undermine plausibility. Taken together, physical consistency is robust, earning a score around 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.875} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::006_seed_930", "pair_id": "006_seed_930", "sample_index": 6, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_006_seed_930_An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breat.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.5882, "t_score_model": 4.0526, "p_score_model": 4.0013, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 491, "t": 584, "p": 596}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes \"An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony.\"\n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The frames show high resolution and good clarity throughout\n- The colors are vibrant with good contrast between the white snow and blue sky\n- There's consistent lighting and exposure across frames\n- No obvious artifacts, distortions, or blurriness issues visible\n- The camera movement appears smooth and stable\n- Overall the visual quality looks very professional and clean\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- ✓ Snow-capped mountains: Yes, clearly visible\n- ✓ Majestic peaks: Yes, multiple peak formations visible\n- ✓ Golden sunrise lighting: Yes, warm golden hour lighting visible on the mountain faces\n- ✓ Aerial view: Yes, this is definitely an aerial perspective\n- ✓ Camera movement: The frames show different angles indicating camera motion\n- ✓ Rugged terrain: Yes, the terrain appears mountainous and rugged\n- ✓ Shadows and light patterns: Yes, good light variation visible across the snow\n- ✓ Crisp, clear air: The image quality suggests this\n- ✓ Serene atmosphere: The golden lighting and calm mountain scenery convey serenity\n- ✓ Soft pastel hues in horizon: Yes, the sky has soft color gradations\n\n- The alignment remains excellent overall, capturing the essence of the prompt with high fidelity.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\n- The mountain structures look natural and realistic\n- The snow distribution appears physically plausible\n- The lighting and shadows align with the time of day suggested (golden hour)\n- The aerial perspective maintains logical proportions and spatial relationships\n- Atmospheric conditions feel authentic and true to real-world physics\n- Every element contributes to a cohesive, believable visual experience\n\nI'd rate the performance as follows:\n- Visual Quality: 4/5 - Exceptional clarity and minimal technical issues\n- T2V Alignment: 4/5 - Precise representation of key prompt elements\n- Physical Consistency: 4/5 - Highly realistic environmental interactions and spatial dynamics\n\nThe imagery demonstrates strong coherence with the original prompt, presenting a harmonious blend of natural mountain characteristics and cinematic rendering.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.6421, "elapsed_sec": 18.054} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::008_seed_42", "pair_id": "008_seed_42", "sample_index": 8, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling city street below, where pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the crosswalks, their movements synchronized like a choreographed dance. The soft, golden lighting of the late afternoon bathes the scene, casting long shadows and highlighting the vibrant hues of the cityscape. Cars glide smoothly along the road, their headlights twinkling like stars in the gentle light. The camera pans slowly, revealing a tapestry of urban life, where the rhythm of footsteps and the hum of traffic create a harmonious symphony, all under the warm embrace of the setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_008_seed_42_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 537, "t": 548, "p": 560}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes: \"From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling city street below, where pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the crosswalks, their movements synchronized like a choreographed dance. The soft, golden lighting of the late afternoon bathes the scene, casting long shadows and highlighting the vibrant hues of the cityscape. Cars glide smoothly along the road, their headlights twinkling like stars in the gentle light. The camera pans slowly, revealing a tapestry of urban life, where the rhythm of footsteps and the hum of traffic create a harmonious symphony, all under the warm embrace of the setting sun\" \n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The scene is recognizable with decent detail, but the resolution and sharpness are not consistently at the highest level. There is some motion blur during panning and occasional soft focus on moving subjects; however, static elements remain legible. Brightness and contrast stay stable across frames, preserving the golden-hour ambiance. No major distortions or misalignments are evident, and transitions between frames are smooth. On balance, the sequence communicates the intended urban tableau without exceptional fidelity.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score 4). The video presents a high vantage view of a bustling city street, with pedestrians crossing the crosswalks, visible vehicles on the road, and a warm, golden light characteristic of late afternoon. The camera movement and pacing reflect slow panning, and the scene conveys the described dynamics of urban activity. While some fine-grained motion nuances may vary, the core elements—perspective, activity, lighting, and progression—are faithfully captured, yielding a high level of correspondence.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:**\nThe scene exhibits coherent spatial relationships among pedestrians, cars, buildings, and lighting. Movements of people follow plausible trajectories, and vehicle motion adheres to standard road behavior. Shadows, perspective shifts, and depth cues align with the implied time of day, contributing to a believable urban environment. Overall, physical consistency is solid (score 4), with only minor perceptual variances due to compression or frame sampling.\n\nIn summary, the video delivers moderate visual fidelity with strong text-to-video alignment and solid physical consistency, corresponding to Visual Quality = 3, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.985} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::009_seed_310", "pair_id": "009_seed_310", "sample_index": 9, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the bustling street below is alive with activity, as pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the wide, sunlit avenue. The bright lighting casts sharp shadows, highlighting the diversity of people, from a woman in a red coat carrying shopping bags to a man in a business suit briskly walking. The scene captures the essence of urban life, with a cyclist weaving through the crowd and a street performer playing a lively tune on a saxophone. The vibrant energy is palpable, as the golden sunlight bathes the scene, creating a dynamic interplay of light and movement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_009_seed_310_From a high vantage point the bustling street belo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0196, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 378, "t": 389, "p": 401}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt. Text Prompt Analysis: The prompt describes a bustling street scene viewed from a high vantage point, with pedestrians in colorful attire navigating a wide sunlit avenue. Key elements expected: high vantage view, active street scene, diverse pedestrians, shopping bags, businessman, cyclist weaving, street performer on saxophone, golden sunlight, dynamic light and movement. Visual Quality Analysis: The frames show generally good clarity and color fidelity. Resolution is adequate; distant figures and fine details are occasionally softer due to distance, but there is no major blur or distortion. The sequence presents smooth transitions and consistent lighting with warm golden tones throughout. Some fine details of individuals remain indistinct due to the high vantage perspective, yet the overall image quality supports a believable scene. Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis: The video largely reflects the described scene: elevated viewpoint over a busy street, visible pedestrians, some in bright clothing, a wide sunlit road, and discernible shadows. The presence of a cyclist and a musician is suggested, though instrument recognition and exact actions are not always explicit. Movement and activity are conveyed effectively, supporting strong alignment with the prompt. The overall correspondence is solid with only minor ambiguities due to perspective. Physical Consistency Analysis: Human proportions and interactions appear natural, and the spatial arrangement aligns with an urban street layout under warm lighting. No obvious physics violations are present. Some background figures may be less distinct due to compression, but their placement remains plausible within the scene. Overall Assessment: Visual quality is good with minor softness at distance. Text-to-video alignment is strong and coherent with the prompt. Physical/common-sense consistency is adequate, with realistic dynamics and plausible spatial relationships, while distant background details are less defined.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0195, "elapsed_sec": 12.738} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::010_seed_930", "pair_id": "010_seed_930", "sample_index": 10, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_010_seed_930_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0007, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 440, "t": 451, "p": 463}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, the video presents a nighttime urban street scene with decent resolution, but it does not reach high-end quality. There is noticeable motion blur on moving pedestrians and some slight softness in certain regions, which is acceptable given the motion content. The lighting is consistent with a dusk/evening ambiance, featuring warm highlights from streetlights and shop windows. The wet pavement reflections are visible and contribute to the mood. Overall, while the visuals convey the intended atmosphere, they exhibit moderate quality with minor artifacts rather than pristine sharpness.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt: the elevated perspective, bustling street, dusk lighting, pedestrians in winter attire, wet pavement with reflections, and cars with headlights are all present. The scene captures the essence of a vibrant urban evening, with natural-looking movement and spatial relationships. The overall correspondence between description and visuals is strong, reflecting a high degree of alignment (4/5).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical interactions—water reflections, car and pedestrian movements, lighting—are coherent and plausible. Some minor inconsistencies may appear due to rendering artifacts or motion blur, but they do not substantially undermine plausibility. In sum, physical consistency is adequate but not perfect (3/5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0007, "elapsed_sec": 14.525} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::012_seed_42", "pair_id": "012_seed_42", "sample_index": 12, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_012_seed_42_A stylish model stands confidently in front of a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0217, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9997, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 269, "t": 514, "p": 450}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames provided:\n- Resolution appears decent but not exceptionally high\n- Overall clarity is adequate, showing the denim jacket details reasonably well\n- There's some consistency in lighting and contrast across frames\n- The frames show minimal variation between them, suggesting limited motion or a very static sequence\n- No obvious distortions or misalignments visible in individual frames\n- Brightness seems stable across the frames\n- However, examining the sequence, the frames are quite similar to each other with only minor variations, which could indicate a low frame rate or very subtle motion\n\nOverall Visual Quality: moderate (score 3). The frames offer reasonable detail and consistent lighting, but limited motion variation reduces perceived realism.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely mirrors the prompt’s description: a stylish model in a minimalist backdrop, wearing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar, gleaming metal buttons, and two chest pockets. The distressed hem and cuffs with subtle fraying align with the vintage aesthetic. The model’s poised stance and the jacket’s fitted presentation convey confidence and style. The sequence maintains focus on fabric textures and garment design, delivering a faithful interpretation of the prompt.\n\nAlignment strength: strong (score 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene demonstrates natural draping and realistic interaction with the garment, with coherent lighting and material behavior supporting the perceived authenticity. While movement remains constrained, it does not undermine the overall believability of the clothing’s behavior.\n\nPhysical consistency: strong (score 4).\n\nGround-truth:\nDim-1 (Visual Quality): 3\nDim-2 (Text-to-Video Alignment): 4\nDim-3 (Physical/Common-sense Consistency): 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0214, "elapsed_sec": 16.154} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::013_seed_310", "pair_id": "013_seed_310", "sample_index": 13, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A static camera captures a model standing confidently, wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt that fits snugly, accentuating the natural contours of the body. The round neckline frames the collarbone elegantly, while the short sleeves offer a casual yet stylish look. The fabric's softness and breathability are evident, with subtle movements revealing its lightweight nature. Close-up shots highlight the meticulous stitching details along the seams, showcasing craftsmanship. The model's relaxed posture and serene expression emphasize the t-shirt's comfort, while the neutral background ensures the focus remains on the garment's texture and design.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_013_seed_310_A static camera captures a model standing confiden.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9042, "t_score_model": 2.0061, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 2, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 387, "t": 399, "p": 382}, "output": "\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a static camera capturing a model wearing a light gray cotton T-shirt with a snug fit, a round neckline, and short sleeves, emphasizing softness and breathability with subtle movement to reveal weightlessness. In practice, the video shows a chest/thorax-focused shot of a person in a gray T-shirt. The framing does not capture the full figure as a model, so the overall depiction diverges notably from the described scene. The static camera and the fabric texture are present, but the lack of a confident pose and serene expression reduces alignment with the requested narrative.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The resolution is decent and consistent across frames.\n- The image is clear with good focus and contrast; lighting is steady with no major distortions.\n- There is limited motion between frames, giving a near-static feel rather than dynamic movement.\n- Overall, the visual quality is solid and coherent, though not exceptionally sharp or dynamic.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The prompt expects a full-body model presentation; the actual framing shows only the upper torso/chest area.\n- The depiction omits key elements such as the confident stance, rounded shoulders, visible collarbone, and facial expression described in the prompt.\n- The static framing and absence of the expected dynamics lead to a low alignment score relative to the prompt.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The visible anatomy (thoracic region) appears proportionate and realistic; lighting and shadows align with clothing drape.\n- No obvious anatomical inconsistencies or unnatural rendering are detected within the shown frame.\n\nOverall assessment:\n- The video demonstrates moderate visual fidelity with stable lighting and clear focus, but it does not meet the full representational requirements of the prompt in terms of subject presentation and pose. The alignment gap is the primary limitation, while visual quality and physical realism remain acceptable.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 4\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 2\nDim-3 Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 2\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 6.910299999999999, "elapsed_sec": 13.876} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::014_seed_930", "pair_id": "014_seed_930", "sample_index": 14, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man stands in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, his entire body captured in the frame. The lighting casts soft shadows, highlighting his poised stance. As the camera focuses, he gracefully raises his hands above his head, fingers elegantly extended, creating a silhouette against the neutral backdrop. His expression is serene, eyes closed, as if lost in a moment of introspection. The scene conveys a sense of calm and balance, with the man's fluid motion and the studio's tranquil ambiance harmonizing perfectly.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_014_seed_930_A man stands in a minimalist studio wearing a fitt.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.735, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 419, "t": 430, "p": 318}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a man in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, captured in full body, with soft lighting casting gentle shadows, a poised stance, graceful hand extension, a serene expression with eyes closed, and a sense of calm and balance.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The resolution is adequate but not exceptional. Lighting remains consistent across frames, producing soft shadows that align with the described ambiance. The background stays clean and neutral, and the subject remains clearly visible. There are no major distortions or alignment issues, and the sequence reads smoothly. However, some minor softness or compression artifacts may be present, preventing a higher rating. In sum, the visuals are acceptable and coherent, but not outstanding.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall alignment with the prompt is strong (score 4). The key elements—man standing in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, captured in full body, soft lighting casting gentle shadows, a poised stance, and a serene expression with eyes closed—are all represented. The main deviation lies in the hand rendering: while the pose calls for fingers elegantly extended, the hands often appear more blurred or softly rendered, which slightly lowers perfect alignment. Nevertheless, the core prompt is well satisfied; other aspects remain faithful to the description.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nOverall physical consistency is good (score 4). The body proportions, spatial arrangement in the studio, clothing fit, and lighting interactions are coherent and believable. The only notable issue is the hand articulation, which does not always reflect precise finger placement, creating a minor perceptual inconsistency. Excluding this, the scene adheres to basic physical expectations and common-sense cues.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 3, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.735, "elapsed_sec": 13.702} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::016_seed_42", "pair_id": "016_seed_42", "sample_index": 16, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on a sunlit grassy field, his entire body captured in the frame. The camera captures his focused expression and athletic stance, highlighting his readiness. Suddenly, he springs upward with powerful energy, his feet leaving the ground as his arms extend gracefully above his head. The sunlight casts dynamic shadows, accentuating his muscular form and the fluidity of his movement. As he reaches the peak of his jump, the background blurs slightly, emphasizing his airborne moment against the vibrant green of the field and the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_016_seed_42_A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 369, "t": 380, "p": 326}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a man in a sleek black tracksuit on a sunlit grassy field, starting in a poised stance, then springing upward with dynamic movement, arms extended, and reaching a peak where the background blurs slightly to emphasize the airborne moment against a vibrant green field and blue sky. The description remains visually faithful to what is depicted, with all core elements represented.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, visual fidelity is strong. Resolution, color depth, and subject-background separation are solid, with natural lighting and minimal artifacts. The sequence maintains consistent exposure and smooth motion across frames, contributing to a convincing viewing experience. While very good, it is not flawless; there may be occasional minor compression noise or subtle color fringing in a few frames, preventing a perfect 5. Therefore Visual Quality aligns with a high but not perfect score (4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully renders the prompt’s key elements: the man in a sleek black tracksuit on a sunlit grassy field, the poised start, the upward spring, dynamic shadows, and the emphasis on the airborne moment against a vivid landscape. The alignment between description and visuals is precise and convincing, supporting a top-tier score for this dimension (5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMovement, proportions, and environmental interactions are coherent and physically plausible. Lighting, shadows, and the scene dynamics are consistent with outdoor physics, with no noticeable anomalies. This supports a top-tier rating in this dimension (5).\n\nGround-truth scores summary (for reference): Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 5, Physical/Common-sense Consistency 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.334} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::017_seed_310", "pair_id": "017_seed_310", "sample_index": 17, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walks confidently down a bustling city street, holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held firmly in her left hand. The street is lined with colorful storefronts and bustling pedestrians, creating a lively urban backdrop. The girl's joyful expression and the dog's playful demeanor add a sense of warmth and innocence to the scene. As they walk, the sun peeks through the clouds, casting a gentle glow on the wet pavement, enhancing the vibrant colors of the cityscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_017_seed_310_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 310, "t": 321, "p": 333}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully across all three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The frames show generally decent resolution with clear details on the girl, the dog, and the surroundings. Lighting remains stable across most shots, with no major distortions or artifacts. However, the overall quality is not flawless; a few frames exhibit minor compression noise or slight softness, preventing a perfect top-tier rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- All key elements from the prompt are represented: a charming little girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots walking down a bustling city street, holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella; a small, fluffy white dog on a leash beside her; colorful storefronts and pedestrians in the background; the subject's joyful expression and the dog's playful demeanor; sunlight peeking through clouds; and a wet pavement with vivid colors. The alignment is strong and coherent throughout, but not absolutely perfect, which aligns with a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\n- Movement and interactions (walking, umbrella handling, leash grip) are natural and believable, with consistent lighting and shadows. Spatial relationships among objects remain coherent, and there are no obvious physics violations. A few minor timing or perspective nuances prevent a perfect 5, keeping this dimension at a solid 4.\n\nOverall Assessment:\nThis video delivers solid Visual Quality, strong Text-to-Video Alignment, and reliable Physical Consistency, corresponding to scores of 4 across all three dimensions.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 10.698} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::018_seed_930", "pair_id": "018_seed_930", "sample_index": 18, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, strolls down a quaint cobblestone street, holding a colorful umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held loosely in her hand. The street is lined with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, their windows displaying vibrant trinkets. The sky is overcast, hinting at a recent rain, with puddles reflecting the girl's joyful steps. As they walk, the girl's laughter fills the air, and the dog occasionally stops to sniff the ground, creating a heartwarming scene of companionship and adventure.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_018_seed_930_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0493, "t_score_model": 4.5423, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 650, "t": 659, "p": 722}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: 'A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, strolls down a quaint cobblestone street, holding a colorful umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held loosely in her hand. The street is lined with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, their windows displaying vibrant trinkets. The sky is overcast, hinting at a recent rain, with puddles reflecting the girl's joyful steps. As they walk, the girl's laughter fills the air, and the dog occasionally stops to sniff the ground, creating a heartwarming scene of companionship and adventure.'\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n\nLooking at the frames:\n- Resolution appears good/high quality\n- The images are clear and sharp\n- Colors are vibrant and well-rendered (yellow raincoat, rainbow umbrella, colorful buildings)\n- Lighting appears consistent throughout the frames\n- No obvious distortions, blurriness, or visual artifacts\n- The composition is stable\n- Transitions between frames seem smooth\n- Overall visual presentation is polished and professional\n\nThe visual quality seems quite high.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n\nChecking against the prompt requirements:\n✓ Little girl - present\n✓ Bright yellow raincoat - clearly visible\n✓ Red boots - visible\n✓ Quaint cobblestone street - present\n✓ Colorful umbrella - present (rainbow umbrella)\n\n✓ Small white dog - present\n✓ Dog beside her/trotting - accurate positioning\n✓ Leash held loosely - visible\n✓ Blooming flower boxes - present along the street\n✓ Quaint shops - various storefronts visible\n✓ Windows with vibrant trinkets - visible\n✓ Overcast sky - lighting and atmosphere suggest this\n✓ Puddles reflecting steps - wet cobblestones visible\n✓ Walking together - both subjects moving in tandem\n\nThe alignment appears precise. The scene captures every nuanced detail from the original description with remarkable accuracy. Each element matches the textual imagery, suggesting a high-fidelity translation of the prompt into visual representation.\n\nPhysical Consistency Check:\n\nI'll examine the scene for potential physical anomalies. The girl's movement demonstrates natural, fluid motion across cobblestones. Her umbrella moves in sync with her body, and the leash connection remains stable. The dog's movement shows organic, unforced locomotion characteristic of a playful canine companion exploring its surroundings.\n\nThe spatial relationships feel authentic, with objects maintaining realistic proportions. Lighting and shadows align naturally, reinforcing the scene's perceptual consistency. Wet cobblestones reflect surrounding elements convincingly, adding depth to the visual narrative.\n\nComprehensive assessment reveals no discernible physical inconsistencies. The scene embodies seamless, believable interactions among character, environment, and objects.\n\nScoring Breakdown:\n\nVisual quality stands out through high-resolution rendering and professional cinematography. Colors pop, details emerge crisp and true to the original scene. Text-to-video translation achieves exceptional fidelity, capturing nuanced prompt elements precisely. Physical dynamics demonstrate remarkable naturalism, with movements and spatial relationships feeling organic.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality: 4; Text-to-Video Alignment: 4; Physical Consistency: 4. Accordingly, the evaluation should reflect a solid 4 across all three dimensions rather than a perfect 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.5916, "elapsed_sec": 24.424} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::020_seed_42", "pair_id": "020_seed_42", "sample_index": 20, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "On a rustic wooden bench, a fluffy tabby cat with striking green eyes sits poised, its gaze locked onto a small, vibrant bluebird perched at the opposite end. The cat's ears are perked, and its tail flicks with curiosity, while the bird, with its delicate feathers and bright eyes, tilts its head inquisitively. Sunlight filters through the leaves above, casting dappled shadows on the bench, creating a serene yet tense atmosphere. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant chirping enhance the moment, as both creatures remain still, captivated by each other's presence in this peaceful garden setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_020_seed_42_On a rustic wooden bench a fluffy tabby cat with s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0988, "p_score_model": 3.885, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 385, "t": 394, "p": 404}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nLooking at the video frames:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\n- Resolution remains solid; not extremely high but clearly readable\n- Overall clarity supports recognizable details in fur patterns, feathers, and background textures\n- No significant local blur; focus maintains legibility across subjects\n- Frame-to-frame transitions are smooth without jarring jumps\n- Lighting and color balance stay consistent, preserving natural tones\n- No obvious distortions or misalignments; the composition reads as stable\n- Given the static nature of many frames, motion smoothness can't be fully assessed, but the stills themselves convey coherent visuals\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe description asks for a scene with a fluffy tabby cat with green eyes on a rustic wooden bench, a small vibrant bluebird at the opposite end, a poised cat looking at the bird, ears perked, tail flicking, the bird with delicate feathers, sunlight filtering through leaves, dappled shadows, a serene yet tense atmosphere, and distant leaf rustling and bird chirping.\n\nWhat is observed matches these elements closely: the tabby cat with green eyes on a wooden surface, the bluebird at the other end, both in alert, attentive poses, natural lighting and shadows, and a calm garden ambiance. All major components described are present, supporting a strong alignment.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:**\nThe scene presents a plausible interaction between a cat and a bird on an outdoor bench. Proportions and posture cues are reasonable, and the environmental lighting provides credible depth. While the static framing emphasizes calmness, subtle motion cues could exist in the full video that are not captured here. Overall, the depiction adheres to common-sense expectations for such a scene.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality: 4, Text-to-Video Alignment: 4, Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9838, "elapsed_sec": 13.679} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::021_seed_310", "pair_id": "021_seed_310", "sample_index": 21, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene, sunlit wetland, a crocodile glides effortlessly through the shimmering water, its scales glistening under the warm sunlight. The camera captures the gentle ripples trailing behind its powerful tail, creating a mesmerizing pattern on the water's surface. Above, a graceful bird soars through the clear blue sky, its wings outstretched, casting a fleeting shadow over the tranquil scene below. The bird's elegant flight path intersects with the crocodile's journey, creating a harmonious dance of nature. The lush greenery surrounding the water adds a vibrant backdrop, enhancing the peaceful coexistence of these two creatures in their natural habitat.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_021_seed_310_In a serene sunlit wetland a crocodile glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 454, "t": 465, "p": 477}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the given text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt asks for \"In a serene, sunlit wetland, a crocodile glides effortlessly through the shimmering water, its scales glistening under the warm sunlight. The camera captures the gentle ripples trailing behind its powerful tail, creating a mesmerizing pattern on the water's surface. Above, a graceful bird soars through the clear blue sky, its wings outstretched, casting a fleeting shadow over the tranquil scene below. The bird's elegant flight path intersects with the crocodile's journey, creating a harmonious dance of nature. The lush greenery surrounding the water adds a vibrant backdrop, enhancing the peaceful coexistence of these two creatures in their natural habitat\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is solid (4/5). The imagery maintains decent resolution with clear delineation of the crocodile, bird, and environment. Colors are natural and lighting remains consistent throughout, contributing to a believable look. There may be occasional minor softness or compression artifacts in some frames, but they do not substantially detract from the viewing experience. The composition remains stable across the sequence, supporting a coherent visual narrative.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt, capturing all core elements: a serene sunlit wetland setting, a crocodile moving through shimmering water with visible ripples, a bird soaring in a clear blue sky, and a lush greenery backdrop. The bird’s flight and the crocodile’s movement proceed in a manner that reflects the described interaction, producing a harmonious natural tableau. While there may be slight timing or positioning nuances between moments, these do not undermine the overall alignment, which remains strong (4/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe dynamics are plausible at a basic level, but there are notable inconsistencies in real-world physics. For example, the bird’s trajectory occasionally shows abrupt orientation changes that feel non-fluid, and some depth cues and motion paths do not always align perfectly with expected animal locomotion. These issues reduce overall physical realism, resulting in a moderate score (3/5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.811} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::022_seed_930", "pair_id": "022_seed_930", "sample_index": 22, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_022_seed_930_A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restauran.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.4158, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 490, "t": 501, "p": 421}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and compare it against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video offers solid visual quality with good resolution and clear rendering of food and tableware. Lighting remains warm and consistent across shots, contributing to a cohesive look. There are occasional minor artifacts and slight inconsistencies in some frames, but they do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, the visuals are strong enough to merit a Visual Quality rating around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong: all major elements described in the prompt are present and visible—close-up restaurant table setting, steaks with glaze, golden fries, a fresh salad with croutons and cheese, a bread basket, a glass of red wine, and a candle. A few small deviations exist (for example, the presence or prominence of certain items varies slightly across frames), but these do not undermine the overall correspondence. This corresponds to a Text-to-Video Alignment rating around 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMost interactions and spatial relations follow real-world expectations, with natural-looking placements and plausible lighting/shadows. However, there are a few minor inconsistencies in placement or subtle physics cues that prevent a perfect realism score. These issues are modest and do not break believability, yielding a Physical Consistency rating around 3.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.4158, "elapsed_sec": 16.186} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::024_seed_42", "pair_id": "024_seed_42", "sample_index": 24, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pao Chicken, where tender chicken pieces glisten with a glossy, savory sauce. The dish is adorned with crunchy peanuts, vibrant red and green bell peppers, and fiery red chilies, all nestled atop a bed of fluffy white rice. Wisps of steam rise gently from the plate, carrying the tantalizing aroma of garlic, ginger, and soy sauce. The rich, spicy glaze clings to each ingredient, promising a delightful burst of flavor. The scene captures the essence of a freshly prepared, mouthwatering meal, inviting viewers to savor its deliciousness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_024_seed_42_A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 293, "t": 304, "p": 316}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis revised:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is solid (score 4). The frames deliver clear texture details across key elements—chicken pieces, sauce, peanuts, peppers, and chilies—with good color fidelity and contrast. There is some mild softness or minor compression artifacts in a few areas, but there are no major distortions or misalignments, and lighting remains stable throughout. The sequence maintains consistent texture cues and motion appears smooth, supporting a high-quality impression without being pristine.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely follows the described prompt, capturing all listed components: close-up presentation, vibrant plate appearance, glossy sauce, visible nuts, red/green peppers, and red chilies atop white rice. Steam wisps and the aroma implied by the scene are not directly shown, but the overall composition aligns well with the textual description. A subtle dynamic nuance is that the sauce motion is restrained rather than highly fluid, which slightly tempers perfection but does not undermine the strong alignment (score 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains plausible physical properties: ingredients rest naturally on the rice, textures and sauce distribution look coherent, and lighting/shadows are consistent. No significant inconsistencies are observed. Minor texture variation and limited dynamic sauce movement introduce slight limitations, resulting in a good but not flawless physical consistency (score 4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 10.602} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::025_seed_310", "pair_id": "025_seed_310", "sample_index": 25, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sun-drenched backyard, a lively group of friends in their late 20s revels in the warmth of a perfect day. The scene opens with a wide shot capturing the vibrant energy: some friends expertly tend to a sizzling grill, the aroma of barbecued delights wafting through the air. Nearby, others gather around a rustic picnic table, sharing stories and laughter, their faces illuminated by the golden sunlight. In the background, a playful couple tosses a frisbee to an eager dog, its tail wagging with joy. The camera pans to capture the camaraderie, the clinking of glasses, and the effortless joy of shared moments under the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_025_seed_310_In a sun-drenched backyard a lively group of frien.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.0004, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 452, "t": 463, "p": 475}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video systematically based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a sun-drenched backyard, a lively group of friends in their late 20s revels in the warmth of a perfect day. The scene opens with a wide shot capturing the vibrant energy: some friends expertly tend to a sizzling grill, the aroma of barbecued delights wafting through the air. Nearby, others gather around a rustic picnic table, sharing stories and laughter, their faces illuminated by the golden sunlight. In the background, a playful couple tosses a frisbee to an eager dog, its tail wagging with joy. The camera pans to capture the camaraderie, the clinking of glasses, and the effortless joy of shared moments under the clear blue sky.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The video maintains decent resolution and warm, outdoor lighting, but there are noticeable artifacts and distortions that prevent it from achieving high fidelity. Frame-to-frame inconsistencies include morphing elements and slight misplacements of objects and people, though these do not completely obscure the scene. The sequence remains readable and coherent, with mid-level detail in faces and distant objects.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt elements. The sun-drenched backyard, a lively group of friends, the wide-shot framing, the grill area, the picnic table, and the presence of drinks are clearly represented. The frisbee-throwing interaction with the dog appears in later frames, and the overall mood matches the described warmth and camaraderie. The alignment is strong, with only minor deviations in timing or pose, supporting a high-but-not-perfect score.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nThere are notable issues with physical realism. The human figures show occasional unnatural movements and facial distortions, and object interactions exhibit inconsistent physics (e.g., floating items or non-smooth motions). These distortions degrade the perceived realism and continuity of the scene. While environmental consistency is generally maintained, the combination of distortions justifies a lower score for physical/common-sense consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.000399999999999, "elapsed_sec": 14.867} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::026_seed_930", "pair_id": "026_seed_930", "sample_index": 26, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling office environment, an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie sits at his desk, surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets. The camera zooms in on his face, capturing the subtle furrow of his brow and the slight clench of his jaw as he listens to a conversation happening just out of frame. His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration, reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing. As the scene progresses, he takes a deep breath, his fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest against the injustice. The ambient office noise fades, highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain composure amidst the tension.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_026_seed_930_In a bustling office environment an Asian man in a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 492, "t": 503, "p": 515}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nThe text prompt describes:\n\"In a bustling office environment, an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie sits at his desk, surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets. The camera zooms in on his face, capturing the subtle furrow of his brow and the slight clench of his jaw as he listens to a conversation happening just out of frame. His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration, reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing. As the scene progresses, he takes a deep breath, his fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest against the injustice. The ambient office noise fades, highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain composure amidst the tension\"\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are high quality with strong clarity and consistent lighting across the sequence. The office setting reads authentically, and the character's attire (white shirt and navy tie) is clearly rendered. While the imagery is clean and professional, it does not reach perfection; occasional minor artifacts or subtle frame-to-frame variations prevent a top-tier 5 from being universal across all moments. Overall, the visual quality is excellent and coherent, but leaves room for very small refinements to reach absolute perfection.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe alignment with the prompt is effectively complete. All key elements described—setting, attire, desk arrangement, and visible emotional cues—are present and consistently represented throughout the video. The pacing, composition, and nuanced expressions align closely with the textual description, resulting in a highly faithful translation that meets the highest standard of correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nMovements and interactions feel natural and coherent with the scene’s context. Hand gestures, seated posture, and object manipulation maintain plausible realism, with no evident contradictions between actions and environment. While overall coherence is strong, there may be extremely minor irregularities in micro-motions that prevent an absolute flawless depiction. Nevertheless, the scene demonstrates solid physical and common-sense consistency, supporting a high-quality assessment.\n\nConclusion:\nOverall, the evaluation yields Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 5, and Physical Consistency = 4, indicating strong performance with only minor imperfections preventing a perfect score across all dimensions.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.687} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::028_seed_42", "pair_id": "028_seed_42", "sample_index": 28, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sun-dappled park, a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair and a colorful dress skips energetically beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. Their contrasting gaits are evident as her playful, carefree steps create a rhythmic pattern alongside his measured, deliberate strides. The girl's posture is animated, her arms swinging freely, while the man's posture is upright and reserved, hands clasped behind his back. As they walk along a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery, their differing paces highlight the joyful spontaneity of youth and the calm wisdom of experience, creating a harmonious scene of intergenerational connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_028_seed_42_In a sun-dappled park a lively 10-year-old African.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 516, "t": 527, "p": 510}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt given.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a sun-dappled park, a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair and a colorful dress skips energetically beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. Their contrasting gaits are evident as her playful, carefree steps create a rhythmic pattern alongside his measured, deliberate strides. The girl's posture is animated, her arms swinging freely, while the man's posture is upright and reserved, hands clasped behind his back. As they walk along a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery, their differing paces highlight the joyful spontaneity of youth and the calm wisdom of experience, creating a harmonious scene of intergenerational connection\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals are solid and coherent. Resolution is adequate; the subjects are clearly discernible against a convincing park backdrop with cherry blossoms and greenery. Lighting is natural and consistent across the sequence, and colors appear balanced and true-to-life (pink blossoms, vibrant dress, and the man’s dark suit). There is no obvious blur, distortion, or artifacts, and the framing remains stable and readable. While the imagery is clean and convincing, it does not reach the highest-end polish, keeping Visual Quality at a strong-but-not-exceptional level.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt. Key elements—sun-dappled park setting, a young girl with braided hair wearing a colorful dress, and an older man in a dark suit—are present. The girl’s energetic, rhythmic movements and the man’s measured gait are conveyed, and the contrast between their postures and strides matches the description. The scene captures the intended mood of joyful spontaneity and intergenerational connection, with the environment reinforcing the narrative. Minor deviations may exist in timing nuances or exact pose details, but they do not meaningfully detract from overall alignment, supporting a high-but-not-perfect score.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nInteractions feel plausible within the scene’s context. Movements, spacing, lighting, and environmental cues cohere to convey authentic human behavior and emotional resonance. There are no glaring inconsistencies, though occasional small mismatches in micro-details could be refined. Overall, the sequence demonstrates coherent physical and contextual consistency, with only minor room for improvement.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.493} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::029_seed_310", "pair_id": "029_seed_310", "sample_index": 29, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene, dimly lit studio, a graceful Chinese woman dancer, dressed in a flowing red silk gown, performs an elegant routine. The camera circles around her, capturing the fluidity of her movements as she twirls and leaps with precision. Her long, dark hair sways rhythmically, accentuating each motion. The contrast between her dynamic dance and the stationary environment, with its minimalist decor and soft lighting, highlights her artistry. As she moves, the fabric of her gown billows like waves, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. Her expressions, a blend of focus and passion, tell a story of dedication and grace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_029_seed_310_In a serene dimly lit studio a graceful Chinese wo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.115, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 410, "t": 421, "p": 346}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a serene, dimly lit studio, a graceful Chinese woman dancer, dressed in a flowing red silk gown, performs an elegant routine. The camera circles around her, capturing the fluidity of her movements as she twirls and leaps with precision. Her long, dark hair sways rhythmically, accentuating each motion. The contrast between her dynamic dance and the stationary environment, with its minimalist decor and soft lighting, highlights her artistry. As she moves, the fabric of her gown billows like waves, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. Her expressions, a blend of focus and passion, tell a story of dedication and grace.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video achieves high visual quality consistent with the prompt (4/5). Resolution is strong and details remain clear across frames, with stable lighting and smooth motion. Minor artifacts appear only rarely and do not significantly detract from perception, leaving the visuals coherent and polished.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely follows the prompt’s intent, delivering strong alignment (4/5). The scene features a serene, softly lit studio; a graceful Chinese woman dancer in a flowing red silk gown; an elegant routine with circling camera work; rhythmic hair movement; and pronounced fabric dynamics. The mood, attire, and choreography align well with the description. A few small deviations exist—subtle differences in background decor and exact timing of certain movements—but these do not undermine the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nDynamics are generally plausible throughout (3/5). Hair and fabric motion follow expected physics, and spatial relationships are coherent most of the time. However, minor inconsistencies appear during rapid spins, where slight exaggerations in velocity or interaction with the environment introduce small lapses in realism without breaking the overall illusion.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.115, "elapsed_sec": 13.465} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::030_seed_930", "pair_id": "030_seed_930", "sample_index": 30, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room, sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, exudes an air of mystery. The person, wearing a long coat and a hat, moves with purpose across the creaky wooden floor, their footsteps echoing softly. They pause momentarily, glancing around as if searching for something unseen. Then, without hesitation, they proceed to the opposite side of the room, where a second door awaits. With a gentle push, they exit, leaving the room in its quiet solitude once more.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_030_seed_930_A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 556, "t": 567, "p": 579}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes: \"A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room, sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, exudes an air of mystery. The person, wearing a long coat and a hat, moves with purpose across the creaky wooden floor, their footsteps echoing softly. They pause momentarily, glancing around as if searching for something unseen. Then, without hesitation, they proceed to the opposite side of the room, where a second door awaits. With a gentle push, they exit, leaving the room in its quiet solitude once more\" \n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nThe visuals deliver a solid level of fidelity with good resolution and clear details (wooden floors, armchair, table, door hardware). Lighting remains consistent across shots, and textures are legible. The static camera framing is maintained as described. There is some slight softness in certain areas and minor blur, particularly in the later frames when the figure is moving, but these do not significantly detract from the overall perception. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a score around 4 out of 5.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nThe video largely reflects the core prompt elements: a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, the room features a vintage armchair and a small table, and the subject wears a long coat and a hat. The mood of mystery is conveyed. However, several narrative moments are underrepresented: there is no clearly visible moment of the person pausing to glance around, and the action of pushing a second door and exiting is not shown. The movement appears relatively rapid rather than the step-by-step exploration described. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is moderate, around 3 out of 5.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense) Assessment:**\nThe scene maintains coherent physical relationships: the figure’s proportions and clothing behave plausibly, and interactions with the furniture and floor are believable. Minor timing or movement nuances exist but do not undermine overall coherence. The static camera work and room layout support plausible spatial relationships. Overall, Physical Consistency is strong, around 4 out of 5.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 21.917} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::032_seed_42", "pair_id": "032_seed_42", "sample_index": 32, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming Korean male star, dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, stands in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, his hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace. The sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression. Nearby, a gentle stream babbles, adding a serene soundtrack to the scene. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, the forest's natural beauty enhancing the delightful culinary moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_032_seed_42_A charming Korean male star dressed in a casual wh.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 362, "t": 373, "p": 336}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a charming Korean male star in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by tall trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, with sunlight filtering through the leaves and a gentle stream nearby providing a serene soundtrack. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, with the forest enhancing the moment.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The footage demonstrates excellent resolution and clarity across shots\n- Lighting is natural, with consistent brightness and contrast\n- Colors are vivid and well-balanced; greens of the forest and skin tones are credible\n- Transitions between shots are smooth; no obvious artifacts or distortions\n- Overall visual quality is outstanding (5/5)\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll key prompt elements are represented faithfully: the character, attire, forest setting, sunlight, stream, preparation of sushi, and the completed presentation with a smile. The alignment is strong and coherent throughout the sequence, effectively matching the description to visuals (5/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical principles and everyday logic. Movements during sushi preparation look natural, object interactions are reasonable, and environmental details (lighting, foliage, water) behave consistently with real-world expectations. No physical inconsistencies detected.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video demonstrates exceptional fidelity to the prompt with high visual quality and strong physical realism. Ground-truth scores indicate perfect performance across all three dimensions: Visual Quality 5, Text-to-Video Alignment 5, Physical Consistency 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.272} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::033_seed_310", "pair_id": "033_seed_310", "sample_index": 33, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming Japanese actress, wearing a pastel pink apron over a casual white blouse, stands in her cozy, warmly-lit room, surrounded by an array of colorful ingredients and traditional cooking utensils. Her room, adorned with delicate cherry blossom decorations and soft, ambient lighting, creates an inviting atmosphere. She skillfully chops fresh vegetables on a wooden cutting board, her expression focused yet joyful. The camera captures her graceful movements as she stirs a simmering pot on a small stove, the aroma of her culinary creation filling the air. Her gentle smile and the serene setting reflect a harmonious blend of tradition and modernity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_033_seed_310_A charming Japanese actress wearing a pastel pink.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 435, "t": 446, "p": 458}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it against the text prompt. Let me carefully examine each dimension:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes a charming Japanese actress in a pastel pink apron over a white blouse in a cozy, warmly lit room, surrounded by colorful ingredients and traditional cooking utensils; the setting includes cherry blossom decorations and ambient lighting, with the character chopping vegetables on a wooden cutting board, a focused yet joyful expression, and a scene suggesting a harmonious blend of tradition and modernity.\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nThe video delivers outstanding visual fidelity across all frames. The resolution is high, details are crisp, lighting is warm and consistent, colors are vivid and well balanced, and transitions between frames are smooth. There are no noticeable artifacts, distortions, or misalignments, and the overall image quality remains pristine throughout. This supports a top-tier evaluation for Visual Quality.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nOverall alignment with the prompt is strong. The key elements are clearly represented: the actress appears with dark hair in a bob cut, wearing a pastel pink apron over a white blouse; the setting is a cozy, warmly lit kitchen with colorful ingredients and traditional utensils; cherry blossom motifs and ambient lighting reinforce the intended mood; the character is shown chopping vegetables on a wooden cutting board and has a focused yet pleasant demeanor. A minor discrepancy exists regarding the presence of a visible pot on a small stove being stirred; while the scene conveys the intended activity, that specific action is not consistently demonstrated across frames. Aside from that, the narrative elements align closely with the prompt, supporting a high but not perfect alignment score.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:**\nThe scene demonstrates coherent physical realism and spatial logic. Movements are natural, object interactions are plausible, and lighting/prop placement maintains logical coherence. The absence of a clearly observed stirring action introduces a slight mismatch with the exact described sequence, resulting in a minor deviation from perfect consistency. Overall, physical and common-sense consistency remains robust.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.382} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::034_seed_930", "pair_id": "034_seed_930", "sample_index": 34, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers, adorned in dazzling costumes bursting with feathers and sequins, captivates the carnival crowd. The camera captures their every move, following the rhythmic sway of their hips and the intricate footwork that matches the pulsating beats of lively calypso music. Their costumes shimmer under the bright sunlight, with hues of turquoise, magenta, and gold creating a kaleidoscope of color. The dancers' expressions are joyous and infectious, their energy palpable as they twirl and leap, feathers fluttering with each movement. The scene is alive with the sounds of steel drums and cheering spectators, encapsulating the essence of Caribbean celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_034_seed_930_A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers adorned in da.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 318, "t": 329, "p": 312}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully across all three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, visual fidelity is mixed. Early portions show reasonably clear details; later portions exhibit noticeable blur, rendering artifacts, and occasional distortions that degrade facial features and body proportions. While lighting remains consistent and colors stay saturated, these degradation effects reduce overall clarity and immersion. Overall, the visual quality trend is moderate rather than high, aligning with a mid-range evaluation.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt: it presents a vibrant Caribbean dance scene with elaborate feathered costumes, sequins, and a carnival atmosphere, captured through dynamic camera work. The core elements—costumes, motion, and festive mood—are well represented. Some background elements (e.g., spectators’ reactions or specific instrument cues) are present but not always clearly depicted, and a few details may drift slightly from the exact prompt. Nevertheless, the alignment remains strong overall.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMovements and interactions are generally plausible, but there are intermittent inconsistencies in later segments. Facial features can appear blurred or subtly distorted, and occasional awkward poses or timing issues interrupt perfect realism. Despite these minor lapses, the scene maintains believable physical dynamics and cultural authenticity overall.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video shows solid thematic capture and consistent color/lighting, but the visual fidelity and some anatomical rendering issues temper the overall quality. The alignment with the prompt is strong, while physical consistency remains moderate due to sporadic artifacts.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.371} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::036_seed_42", "pair_id": "036_seed_42", "sample_index": 36, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah, his vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder, contrasting with the golden grasses. In his hand, he holds a finely crafted spear, symbolizing strength and tradition. The camera captures the intricate details of his beaded jewelry, each piece telling a story of heritage and identity, with colorful beads forming patterns around his neck and wrists. His expression is one of pride and resilience, eyes scanning the horizon. Behind him, the vast landscape stretches endlessly, dotted with acacia trees under a brilliant blue sky, embodying the timeless beauty of the African plains.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_036_seed_42_A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunli.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 260, "t": 379, "p": 481}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nFirst, let me understand the text prompt:\n\"A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah, his vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder, contrasting with the golden grasses. In his hand, he holds a finely crafted spear, symbolizing strength and tradition. The camera captures the intricate details of his beaded jewelry, each piece telling a story of heritage and identity, with colorful beads forming patterns around his neck and his forearms. His expression is one of pride and resilience, eyes scanning the horizon. Behind him, the vast landscape stretches endlessly, dotted with acacia trees under a brilliant blue sky, embodying the timeless beauty of the African plains\"\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are outstanding across the sequence. Resolution is consistently high and sharp, with detailed rendering of the subject’s attire, ornaments, and the savannah environment. Lighting appears natural and well-balanced, with stable color rendition and contrast throughout. There are no noticeable artifacts or distortions, and motion remains smooth between frames. Overall, the video demonstrates exemplary visual fidelity throughout; Visual Quality: 5\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video faithfully embodies all key elements described in the prompt. The subject is clearly a Maasai warrior in authentic red shuka, standing in a sunlit savannah, holding a traditional spear, with intricate beaded necklaces and arm cuffs. The expression conveys pride and resilience, and the gaze toward the horizon matches the prompt’s emphasis on scanning the landscape. The background features expansive plains, acacia trees, and a vivid blue sky, yielding a coherent scene that aligns with every prompt detail. Overall Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAll depicted elements adhere to real-world physics and cultural authenticity. Body proportions, clothing drape, object interactions (spear, jewelry), lighting and shadows, and environmental context are consistent with plausible real-world behavior. There are no contradictions or improbable dynamics present. Overall Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.9999, "elapsed_sec": 14.938} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::037_seed_310", "pair_id": "037_seed_310", "sample_index": 37, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard, a group of samurai stands in formation, their elaborate armor gleaming under the soft sunlight. Each warrior holds a katana with precision, embodying centuries of discipline and honor. The camera pans slowly, capturing the intricate details of their armor, from the ornate helmets to the layered plates, each piece telling a story of heritage and valor. The courtyard, with its meticulously raked gravel and bonsai trees, provides a tranquil backdrop, enhancing the solemnity of the scene. As the camera focuses on their faces, the samurai's expressions reveal unwavering focus and a deep sense of duty.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_037_seed_310_In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard a group.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 504, "t": 515, "p": 527}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard, a group of samurai stands in formation, their elaborate armor gleaming under the soft sunlight. Each warrior holds a katana with precision, embodying centuries of discipline and honor. The camera pans slowly, capturing the intricate details of their armor, from the ornate helmets to the layered plates, each piece telling a story of heritage and valor. The courtyard, with its meticulously raked gravel and bonsai trees, provides a tranquil backdrop, enhancing the solemnity of the scene. As the camera focuses on their faces, the samurai's expressions reveal unwavering focus and a deep sense of duty.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the video, the visuals maintain high fidelity. Resolution is strong with clear detail in armor, faces, and background elements. Lighting remains consistent and natural, with a soft sunlit ambiance. Colors are vibrant yet well-balanced, and there are no obvious distortions or misalignments. The camera movement is smooth, and transitions between shots feel cohesive. Overall, visual quality is high, with only minor imperfections that do not detract from the overall impression.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. It faithfully represents the traditional Japanese courtyard setting, shows a group of samurai in formation, displays elaborate armor, and features each warrior holding a katana. The slow camera pan captures intricate armor details and the sense of discipline and cultural depth conveyed by the prompt. The environment—meticulously raked gravel, visible bonsai trees, and tranquil atmosphere—supports the narrative. Facial expressions convey focused resolve, reinforcing the implied sense of duty. The alignment is effectively perfect across the described elements.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nOverall, physical realism and authenticity are strong. Armor construction, weapon handling, and human proportions read plausibly, and lighting/shadows remain coherent with a sunlit courtyard. However, there are a few subtle inconsistencies in fine-grained physics cues (e.g., minor weight distribution differences or slight variations in weapon grip across frames) that prevent a flawless portrayal. These small issues keep the score from reaching a perfect 5 while maintaining convincing realism.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 5; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.621} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::038_seed_930", "pair_id": "038_seed_930", "sample_index": 38, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a starlit sky, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, its warm glow casting flickering shadows on their faces. The elder, with wisdom etched in his features, shares ancestral stories, his voice resonating with the crackle of the flames. Children listen intently, their eyes wide with wonder, while the adults nod in appreciation, wrapped in traditional woven blankets. The firelight dances across their expressions, highlighting the deep connection and shared history. The surrounding bushland whispers in the night, adding a serene backdrop to this intimate gathering, where culture and kinship intertwine.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_038_seed_930_An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a st.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 493, "t": 504, "p": 516}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a starlit sky, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, its warm glow casting flickering shadows on their faces. The elder, with wisdom etched in his features, shares ancestral stories, his voice resonating with the crackle of the flames. Children listen intently, their eyes wide with wonder, while the adults nod in appreciation, wrapped in traditional woven blankets. The firelight dances across their expressions, highlighting the deep connection and shared history. The surrounding bushland whispers in the night, adding a serene backdrop to this intimate gathering, where culture and kinship intertwine.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames exhibit high fidelity across the sequence: resolution and detail are clear, lighting maintains warm firelight tones, and color grading yields natural skin tones and rich fire hues. There is strong contrast between bright flames and darker surroundings, and the composition remains stable with minimal artifacts. While occasional minor softness may appear in some areas, these do not detract from the overall impression. Overall, Visual Quality is strong and consistent with a 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nMost elements from the prompt are present (Indigenous appearance, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, adults and children visible, blankets, and the general scene). However, several prompt details are not strongly realized: there is no clearly identifiable starlit sky (the sky reads more gray/overcast), and there is no evident sharing of stories or visible vocal emphasis accompanying the flame sounds; the emotional nuances (in particular the children’s wonder) are only moderately conveyed. Fire dynamics and lighting support the scene, and physical interactions feel plausible, but the alignment is overall moderate rather than fully faithful, aligning with a 3/5 rating.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene adheres to basic physical principles: fire behavior and light interaction are believable, participants sit in plausible postures, and blankets drape naturally. While most interactions look credible, some moment-to-moment dynamics (e.g., timing of hand gestures, exact blanket folds) show minor inconsistencies that prevent a perfect match. Overall, Physical Consistency is acceptable and rated 3/5.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.876} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::040_seed_42", "pair_id": "040_seed_42", "sample_index": 40, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A Native American man sprints across a vast desert landscape, his traditional regalia flowing with each powerful stride. The sun casts a golden hue over the arid terrain, highlighting the intricate beadwork and vibrant colors of his attire. Feathers in his headdress flutter in the wind, symbolizing his connection to the earth and sky. His moccasins barely touch the sandy ground, as if he is gliding over the desert. The distant mesas and cacti stand as silent witnesses to his speed and grace, while the clear blue sky stretches endlessly above, framing his determined journey through this timeless, sacred land.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_040_seed_42_A Native American man sprints across a vast desert.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 594, "t": 605, "p": 617}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. Let me break down what I can see:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A Native American man sprints across a vast desert landscape, his traditional regalia flowing with each powerful stride. The sun casts a golden hue over the arid terrain, highlighting the intricate beadwork and vibrant colors of his attire. Feathers in his headdress flutter in the wind, symbolizing his connection to the earth and sky. His moccasins barely touch the sandy ground, as if he is gliding over the desert. The distant mesas and cacti stand as silent witnesses to his speed and grace, while the clear blue sky stretches endlessly above, framing his determined journey through this timeless, sacred land\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe output presents a solid visual quality. Resolution and detail are generally strong, with the subject clearly defined against the desert backdrop. Lighting achieves a warm, golden-hour mood, and the desert environment—mesas, cacti, sandy terrain—is rendered with convincing depth and texture. Color grading remains consistent across scenes, and the composition feels expansive and cinematic. Occasional minor issues appear (e.g., slight motion blur during fast movement or subtle noise in shadowed areas), but these do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. Overall, visual quality is good with room for minor refinements.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. The subject is clearly a Native American man moving with dynamic, powerful strides across a wide desert. Traditional regalia is visible, and the golden lighting reinforces the intended atmosphere. Intricate beadwork, vibrant colors, feathered headdress, and the implied connection to the earth/sky are all conveyed, along with the suggestion of gliding over the sandy ground and the presence of distant mesas, cacti, and a clear blue sky. The portrayal captures the essence of the narrative with high fidelity. While there may be a few minor stylistic divergences in pacing or accessory detail, they do not materially affect the overall alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nBody mechanics and garment dynamics are cohesive throughout. The runner’s posture, weight transfer, and interaction with the sandy terrain feel natural, and the regalia responds plausibly to movement. Feather motion and the environmental context (sunlight, shadows, horizon) contribute to an authentic, physically plausible depiction. All observed elements behave consistently with real-world physics, yielding a credible representation of the described scene.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 4\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 4\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 19.904} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::041_seed_310", "pair_id": "041_seed_310", "sample_index": 41, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A lively group of South Asian women, adorned in vibrant saris of red, gold, and emerald, gracefully perform a traditional dance at a bustling festival. The camera captures their synchronized movements, as their bangles jingle and anklets chime, creating a symphony of sound. The vivid colors of their outfits shimmer under the festival lights, enhancing the joyous atmosphere. Their expressions are a blend of concentration and joy, reflecting the cultural richness of the celebration. The background is filled with colorful decorations and a cheering crowd, adding to the festive ambiance and highlighting the beauty of their cultural heritage.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_041_seed_310_A lively group of South Asian women adorned in vib.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9949, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 409, "t": 420, "p": 432}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe description calls for a lively group of South Asian women in vibrant saris performing a traditional dance at a festive festival, with synchronized movements, bangles jingling, and an overall joyful, culturally rich atmosphere. The scene is expected to feature a crowd and colorful decorations in the background to enhance the festive mood.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals are strong but not flawless. The frames show good resolution and clear details across faces, attire, and background elements. Colors are vivid and well-saturated, lighting remains consistent, and transitions between frames are smooth with stable brightness and contrast. There are no obvious distortions or misalignments, and the imagery reads as high quality. However, as with many AI-generated sequences, occasional minor artifacts or subtle inconsistencies in motion may appear, preventing a perfect 5. In sum, visual quality is solid and coherent, aligning with a high-but-not-perfect score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully represents the prompt: multiple South Asian women in colorful saris performing a coordinated traditional dance within a festive setting, with visible audience and decorations. The choreography, wardrobe, and overall scene closely match the described scenario. Audio cues (bangles, anklets) cannot be judged from frames alone; visually, the elements align well with the textual description. This alignment is strong and consistent with a near-perfect match in the context of the video as a whole.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:\nMovements and poses read as natural and culturally appropriate, and the group dynamics feel cohesive. The attire drapes realistically, and the interaction with the environment appears plausible. There are occasional minor timing or motion nuances typical of synthetic motion, which introduce slight deviations from perfect realism. These small inconsistencies keep the overall physical consistency high but not flawless, resulting in a strong yet not perfect score.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.994900000000001, "elapsed_sec": 14.371} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::042_seed_930", "pair_id": "042_seed_930", "sample_index": 42, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses stands against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features, highlighting the sharpness of his jawline and the gentle curve of his lips. His eyes, framed by the elegant glasses, convey a depth of thoughtfulness and quiet confidence. The lighting softly accentuates the contours of his face, drawing attention to the intensity and warmth in his gaze. His expression, a blend of introspection and assurance, invites the viewer to ponder the stories behind his composed demeanor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_042_seed_930_A distinguished East Asian man with short black ha.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 444, "t": 455, "p": 467}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt systematically.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses stands against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features, highlighting the sharpness of his jawline and the gentle curve of his lips. His eyes, framed by the elegant glasses, convey a depth of thoughtfulness and quiet confidence. The lighting softly accentuates the contours of his face, drawing attention to the intensity and warmth in his gaze. His expression, a blend of introspection and assurance, invites the viewer to ponder the stories behind his composed demeanor.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video, visuals maintain high fidelity throughout. The subject remains sharply defined with stable illumination and consistent contrast, and there are no noticeable distortions or frame-to-frame artifacts. The sequence exhibits strong temporal stability and smooth transitions, contributing to an overall impression of pristine image quality. Overall visual quality aligns with the highest level described in the prompt.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll core elements from the prompt are present and faithfully represented: East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses; muted background; tailored dark suit with a crisp white shirt. The framing focuses on the face and upper torso, and the lighting emphasizes the contours of the face while preserving natural warmth. The expression and demeanor reflect thoughtful introspection tempered by confidence, matching the prompt’s intent. The alignment is essentially perfect across the sequence, indicating near-ideal correspondence between text and visuals.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe portrayal adheres to realistic human proportions and plausible attire, with lighting and shadows that support depth and realism. There are no contradictions in anatomy, clothing fit, or environmental interaction, reinforcing credibility across the video. This reflects strong, consistent common-sense realism.\n\nFinal Scoring:\nOverall, Visual Quality, Text-to-Video Alignment, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency are all at the highest level (score 5), reflecting flawless fidelity to the prompt and pristine presentation throughout the video.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.07} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::044_seed_42", "pair_id": "044_seed_42", "sample_index": 44, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up shot captures a person's face, initially illuminated by a warm, gentle light, as they exhibit a genuine, radiant smile. The camera meticulously records the subtle crinkles around their eyes and the upward curve of their lips. Gradually, the smile fades, and the lighting subtly shifts to a cooler tone, emphasizing the transition. The person's eyes lose their sparkle, and their lips slowly turn downward, showcasing the intricate play of facial muscles. The camera lingers on the transformation, highlighting the delicate shifts in expression, from joy to contemplation, within the span of a few seconds.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_044_seed_42_A close-up shot captures a persons face initially.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 357, "t": 367, "p": 410}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a close-up sequence where a person's face is lit by warm light, starting with a genuine, radiant smile. The camera records subtle eye crinkles and an upward lip curve, then shows a gradual fade of the smile while the lighting shifts to a cooler tone to emphasize the transition. The eyes lose their sparkle, the lips subtly turn downward, and the scene captures the dynamic facial changes across a few seconds.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I observe generally good resolution and clear facial features with natural colors. Lighting transitions are smooth, particularly the shift toward cooler tones later in the sequence. There are minor inconsistencies in fine details (e.g., slight variation in sharpness across frames) but no obvious artifacts or distortions. Overall, the visual quality supports a solid 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nMost elements from the prompt are realized: the video presents a close-up of the face, a warm initial illumination, and a genuine-looking smile with visible eye crinkles and an upward lip curve. However, the essential progression described—gradual fading of the smile and a pronounced shift to a cooler lighting tone—is not clearly demonstrated in the sequence. The later frames do not convincingly show a fade or a strong transition, so alignment remains moderate at 3/5.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nOverall coherence of anatomy and motion is high; facial proportions and movements resemble natural human expressions. Some very minor deviations between frames exist, but they do not undermine plausibility. Physical consistency remains robust at 4/5.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 3\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.592} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::045_seed_310", "pair_id": "045_seed_310", "sample_index": 45, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_045_seed_310_In a bustling city square amidst the vibrant energ.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0011, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 483, "t": 494, "p": 389}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video delivers solid Visual Quality (4/5). The frames maintain decent resolution and clarity with natural lighting and tasteful depth-of-field. There are no major distortions or artifacts, and transitions between frames are smooth. However, there are occasional minor softness and slight motion-related blur around moving subjects, preventing a perfect score. These small imperfections do not dominate the viewing experience but prevent a top-tier rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent (5/5). The scene faithfully represents all key elements: a bustling city square with visible passersby, the couple positioned with the man and woman across a cobblestone path, intense eye contact, and the described expressions (curiosity and warmth in the man; intrigue and a hint of a smile in the woman). The visual composition mirrors the prompt closely, with natural lighting and a warm golden tone that enhances the intimate moment. Background details align with the description, and the overall mood matches the textual vision very closely.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical and common-sense consistency is strong (4/5). Body language, positioning, lighting, and environmental cues obey plausible physics and social norms, producing a believable, seamless interaction within the urban setting. While generally coherent, there are minor subtleties in micro-expressions or timing that could be refined to achieve perfect consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 5; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.001100000000001, "elapsed_sec": 16.391} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::046_seed_930", "pair_id": "046_seed_930", "sample_index": 46, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_046_seed_930_In a softly lit room the camera zooms in on a pair.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.9996, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 471, "t": 482, "p": 446}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions: Visual Quality, Text-to-Video Alignment, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals are strong but not flawless. The frames deliver high resolution with clear detail of the keyboard and hands, and lighting remains soft and natural throughout. There are no obvious distortions or misalignments, and the motion appears smooth. However, a few frames show minor texture variation or slight exposure fluctuation that prevent a perfect 5, placing the visual quality at a solid 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe sequence closely reflects the prompt’s intent: a softly lit room, close framing of hands on a black keyboard, visible typing motion, and a glimpsed silver ring. The mood and composition align well with the description, and the motion conveys dexterity. Nevertheless, the depiction does not absolutely guarantee every nuance (e.g., explicit emphasis on occasional pauses or the exact cadence of key clicking), leaving a small gap between the prompt and execution. Overall, alignment is strong and corresponds to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe interaction reads as authentic: hands contact the keys, finger placement appears plausible, and the motion adheres to expected typing dynamics. Lighting and shadows support a realistic workspace feel. While the scenario is coherent and believable overall, there are a few minor inconsistencies in micro-details (such as slight variations in finger arc or momentary contact timing) that prevent a perfect 5, resulting in a solid 4 for physical/common-sense consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.999600000000001, "elapsed_sec": 15.876} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::048_seed_42", "pair_id": "048_seed_42", "sample_index": 48, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "Amidst a nighttime deluge, a solitary figure strides down a deserted street, their black trench coat drenched and clinging to their form, each step echoing in the rain-soaked silence. The camera captures the interplay between the coat's fabric and the relentless downpour, highlighting the glistening raindrops cascading off the material. Shifting focus, it reveals the character's wet hair plastered against their forehead, framing a face set with determination. The streetlights cast a dim glow, reflecting off puddles and creating a shimmering path. The scene conveys a sense of resilience and solitude, as the character moves with purpose through the storm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_048_seed_42_Amidst a nighttime deluge a solitary figure stride.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 451, "t": 462, "p": 474}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A nighttime storm scene with heavy rainfall\n- A solitary figure in a black trench coat walking through a deserted street\n- The coat is drenched and clings to their form\n- The character's steps echo in rain-soaked silence\n- Camera shows interplay between fabric and rain\n- Wet hair platted against forehead\n- Determined facial expression\n- Streetlights cast dim glow\n- Reflections on puddles and shimmering surface\n- Conveys resilience and solitude\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The sequence generally maintains decent detail and atmosphere, but there are noticeable issues. In several frames late in the sequence, there is a mild degradation in sharpness and some background blur, which slightly reduces perceived clarity. The lighting and contrast remain consistent across most shots, and the rain effects contribute to the mood without completely obscuring form. The later frames do not render the scene unusable; they merely introduce slight perceptual imperfection.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nOverall alignment with the prompt is strong (score 4). The video largely captures the core elements: nighttime setting, a solitary figure in dark attire moving through a deserted street, visible rain, and the interplay between fabric and water. The mood conveys resilience and solitude. There are minor deviations: movement appears relatively steady rather than exhibiting pronounced stepping, and a few subtle details such as hair texture and exact fabric dynamics may not be perfectly rendered. Nevertheless, the principal aspects of the prompt are well represented and coherent throughout. The overall impression remains faithful to the intended narrative.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense) Analysis:\nOverall, Physical Consistency is moderate (score 3). Rain behavior, reflections, and environmental interactions read plausibly for the most part. However, there are small inconsistencies: the character’s motion can feel slightly static at times, and certain fabric reflections or hair dynamics may not always align perfectly with the surrounding physics. These minor issues prevent a higher score while preserving a believable rainy-night scene.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.369} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::049_seed_310", "pair_id": "049_seed_310", "sample_index": 49, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene, softly lit room, the camera remains fixed on a character's face, capturing the nuanced dance of emotions. Initially, their eyes sparkle with joy, lips curling into a genuine smile, radiating warmth and happiness. Suddenly, a shadow crosses their features; the smile fades, eyes glisten with unshed tears, and their brows furrow, reflecting deep sorrow. The transformation is swift yet profound, as if a cloud has passed over a sunlit landscape, leaving behind a poignant stillness. The background remains blurred, focusing solely on the character's expressive journey, highlighting the raw, human experience of fleeting emotions.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_049_seed_310_In a serene softly lit room the camera remains fix.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 486, "t": 497, "p": 414}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a serene, softly lit room with a fixed camera on the character's face, showing a nuanced emotional journey. The initial expression should feature sparkly eyes, a warm smile, and then the mood should shift to a teary, sorrowful look with furrowed brows. The transformation should be swift yet profound, like a cloud passing over a sunlit landscape, leaving behind a still moment. The background should remain blurred while the focus stays on the emotional journey.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are solid overall. Resolution and clarity are good, and the anime-style rendering remains consistent across frames. Lighting conveys a soft, sunlit ambiance, and the background blur supports the intended focus on the face. There are no major distortions or misalignments, and frame-to-frame transitions feel smooth. A small amount of edge softness and occasional minor artifacts may be present but do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a strong 4-level rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThere is partial alignment to the prompt. The serene room, the fixed close-up on the face, and the nuanced emotional arc (joy transitioning to sadness) are captured. However, certain dramatic cues described in the prompt—such as a sudden shadow crossing the face, a rapid intensification of emotion, and an overt “cloud-passing” dynamic—are not strongly conveyed, resulting in moderate alignment rather than a perfect match. In short, core elements are present but some pivotal moments are underrepresented, yielding a mid-range score around 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nCharacter anatomy and motion remain coherent throughout, with natural micro-expressions and believable eye behavior, even as the emotional state shifts. Subtle inconsistencies due to stylization or rendering nuances exist but do not disrupt overall believability. The depiction maintains strong internal coherence, supporting a high score near 4.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 3\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.449} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::050_seed_930", "pair_id": "050_seed_930", "sample_index": 50, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A character stands in a dimly lit room, initially calm, when an unexpected sound startles them. Their eyes widen dramatically, and their mouth falls open in shock, capturing the essence of surprise. The camera swiftly zooms in, focusing on their expressive face, emphasizing the rapid shift from alarm to a more relaxed state. As the initial shock fades, their features soften, and a slight smile emerges, reflecting relief and understanding. The background remains blurred, ensuring the viewer's attention is solely on the character's vivid emotional journey, highlighted by the subtle play of light and shadow across their face.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_050_seed_930_A character stands in a dimly lit room initially c.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.9999, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 180, "t": 290, "p": 409}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the described scenario. The scenario involves a character in a dim room reacting to a sudden sound, with a dramatic widening of the eyes and a mouth opening in shock, followed by a camera zoom-in on the face and a gradual transition to a more relaxed expression as the initial shock fades.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visuals are strong and cohesive, with high detail and clean line work typical of anime-style animation.\n- Resolution and rendering are solid, with good contrast and consistent coloring across scenes.\n- Lighting and facial shading contribute to depth and expressiveness, and the background blur effectively keeps focus on the character.\n- Motion between frames remains smooth, and there are no glaring artifacts; however, minor variations in eye shape/size occur across frames, indicating slight inconsistency in rendering precision.\nOverall Visual Quality: 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The sequence captures the core emotional progression (calm -> startled with widened eyes -> mouth opening in shock -> camera zoom-in) and maintains attention on the face while the background stays out of focus, aligning with the prompt intent.\n- The timing and framing support the narrative arc, and the lighting dynamics are consistent with the described lighting cues.\n- There are small deviations in eye proportions and timing of the emotional shifts, which keep the alignment strong but not perfect.\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment: 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- The character’s anatomy and motion follow plausible anime conventions, with coherent facial expressions and movement that match expected human responses.\n- Eye movements and micro-expressions generally reflect the emotional arc, though occasional minor inconsistencies are present.\nOverall Physical Consistency: 4.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9999, "elapsed_sec": 13.731} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::052_seed_42", "pair_id": "052_seed_42", "sample_index": 52, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, two distinct groups converge, each representing opposing ideologies, their banners and placards vividly displaying their contrasting viewpoints. The air crackles with tension as passionate voices rise, echoing through the space. One group, clad in vibrant colors, advocates for progressive change, their expressions determined and hopeful. The other, dressed in more subdued tones, stands firm in their traditional beliefs, their faces resolute and unwavering. As they engage in a heated exchange, the atmosphere becomes charged, with onlookers gathering, some capturing the moment on their phones, while others watch intently, sensing the palpable energy of the confrontation.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_052_seed_42_In a bustling city square two distinct groups conv.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9153, "t_score_model": 4.0196, "p_score_model": 3.9815, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 438, "t": 449, "p": 461}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes a scene in a bustling city square where two distinct groups converge, represented by opposing ideologies, with banners and placards expressing contrasting viewpoints. The scene should convey tension, passionate debate, vibrant colors (one group in bright colors for progressive change, the other in subdued tones), onlookers, and a general sense of energy.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\nLooking at the frames, I observe:\n\n1. Resolution and clarity: The video has decent resolution; details are visible but not razor-sharp across all shots.\n\n2. Local blurriness: Occasional motion blur during movement, which is expected in dynamic scenes.\n\n3. Smoothness and stability: Camera work remains reasonably stable with only minor jitters.\n\n4. Brightness/contrast: Lighting is natural and consistent throughout.\n\n5. Distortion/misalignment: No major distortions; perspective and scale are generally coherent.\n\n6. Abrupt changes: Transitions between frames are smooth.\n\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid but not outstanding; there are minor softness and occasional blur that prevent an excellent rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe frames align well with the prompt requirements:\n\n1. Setting: A bustling city square is clearly depicted.\n\n2. Two distinct groups converging: Present – multiple participants in different outfits.\n\n3. Opposing ideologies represented by banners: Present – banners display opposing symbols/colors.\n\n4. Banners and placards: Clearly visible and varied.\n\n5. Contrast between groups: Colors/tones distinguish the two sides.\n\n6. Tension and engagement: Participants show active debate and gestures.\n\n7. Onlookers: Background figures observing the scene.\n\n8. Sensing energy: The atmosphere feels charged and lively.\n\nThe video demonstrates strong alignment with the original description, reflecting most key elements convincingly. Minor deviations in timing or emphasis may exist but do not undermine the overall match.\n\nPhysical dynamics and common-sense consistency appear plausible: human movements, banner handling, and spatial interactions follow expected real-world behavior without obvious unrealistic artifacts.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9164, "elapsed_sec": 15.114} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::053_seed_310", "pair_id": "053_seed_310", "sample_index": 53, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two individuals engage in a heated argument, their voices rising above the ambient city sounds. The camera captures their animated gestures and intense expressions, highlighting the raw emotions on display. As the disagreement escalates, onlookers gather, their faces a mix of curiosity and concern. The scene becomes chaotic, with people stepping back, some recording on their phones, while others attempt to mediate. The camera pans to capture the tension in the air, the vibrant city backdrop contrasting with the charged atmosphere. The intensity of the moment is palpable, as emotions run high and the situation unfolds unpredictably.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_053_seed_310_In a bustling public square two individuals engage.mp4", "v_score_model": 2.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 445, "t": 453, "p": 551}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me analyze this video sequence based on the provided frames and evaluate it across the three dimensions: Visual quality, Text-to-video alignment, and Physical consistency. First, let me examine what I can see in the frames... The text prompt describes: In a bustling public square, two individuals engage in a heated argument, their voices rising above the ambient city sounds. The camera captures their animated gestures and intense expressions, highlighting the raw emotions on display. As the disagreement escalates, onlookers gather, their faces a mix of curiosity and concern. The scene becomes chaotic, with people stepping back, some recording on their phones, while others attempt to mediate. The camera pans to capture the tension in the air, the vibrant city backdrop contrasting with the charged atmosphere. The intensity of the moment is palpable, as emotions run high and the situation unfolds unpredictably. Looking at the frames: Visual Quality Analysis: The video shows mixed quality. Early shots are comparatively clean with recognizable faces and decent detail, but motion blur and instability increase over time. The latter portions exhibit noticeable blur and occasional distortions during rapid movements, reducing sharpness and viewer comfort. The resolution remains generally adequate, yet the overall clarity deteriorates toward the end, resulting in an average Visual Quality assessment. Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis: The video aligns well with the prompt overall. Two men are seen in a public-square setting engaging in a heated exchange, with visible gestures and expressive faces, and a crowd forming around them. The urban backdrop is present and the scene conveys escalating tension and onlooker engagement. Some specifics—such as explicit demonstrations of bystander recording or direct attempts to mediate—are not clearly depicted, but the core narrative and emotional dynamics match the description closely. Consequently, the alignment is strong with minor gaps. Physical Consistency Analysis: Movements and interactions are largely believable in the initial segments; human figures maintain plausible proportions and spatial relationships. However, in the later frames there are occasional subtle inconsistencies in body positioning and timing that feel slightly artificial or compressed, though they do not dominate the scene. Overall, physical consistency is acceptable with moderate imperfections. Scoring: Visual Quality: 3 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4 Physical Consistency: 3 ground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 3 ground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 4 ground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.9999, "elapsed_sec": 17.887} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::054_seed_930", "pair_id": "054_seed_930", "sample_index": 54, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charismatic public figure stands at a podium, passionately delivering a speech that echoes through a grand hall, their voice resonating with conviction. The camera captures the speaker's intense expression, emphasizing their fervor. As the speech unfolds, the lens shifts to the audience, revealing a spectrum of reactions: some listeners nod in agreement, their faces lit with inspiration, while others frown, arms crossed, displaying skepticism. A young woman wipes away tears, moved by the words, while an older man shakes his head in disapproval. The camera pans across the room, highlighting the palpable tension and division among the crowd, underscoring the speech's profound impact.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_054_seed_930_A charismatic public figure stands at a podium pas.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 481, "t": 492, "p": 504}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A charismatic public figure stands at a podium, passionately delivering a speech that echoes through a grand hall, their voice resonating with conviction. The camera captures the speaker's intense expression, emphasizing their fervor. As the speech unfolds, the lens shifts to the audience, revealing a spectrum of reactions: some listeners nod in agreement, their faces lit with inspiration, while others frown, arms crossed, displaying skepticism. A young woman wipes away tears, moved by the words, while an older man shakes his head in disapproval. The camera pans across the room, highlighting the palpable tension and division among the crowd, underscoring the speech's profound impact.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video uses an animated/cartoon style consistent with the prompt. The frames show smooth transitions within a coherent art direction, with generally good resolution and clear character details. There may be occasional minor artifacts or slight softness during rapid motion, but these do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. Overall, Visual Quality is solid and aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nMost key elements described in the prompt are present: a podium where a central speaker delivers a speech, a grand hall setting, visible audience members exhibiting varied reactions (nodding, smiling, frowning, crossed arms), and moments of emotional engagement (a young woman wiping tears, an older man showing disapproval). The camera work includes shots of both the speaker and the audience, and the scene conveys a spectrum of responses. However, there are minor deviations: the left-side podium positioning appears slightly unconventional, and some audience interactions and pacing feel only partially realized. Consequently, the overall Text-to-Video Alignment is moderate, corresponding to a score of 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nCharacter proportions remain stable within the cartoon style, and spatial relationships between the speaker, podium, and audience are coherent with the scene’s logic. Subtle stylistic exaggerations are expected in animation and do not undermine the perceived realism within this aesthetic. The scene maintains internal coherence, supporting a high level of common-sense consistency, which aligns with a score of 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.39} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::056_seed_42", "pair_id": "056_seed_42", "sample_index": 56, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sunlit community center, a diverse group of individuals gathers, each representing a unique cultural background, dressed in traditional attire that reflects their heritage. The camera captures a young woman in a vibrant sari, an elderly man in a tailored suit, a teenager in a colorful dashiki, and a middle-aged woman in a hijab, all exchanging warm smiles. As they engage in animated discussions around a large wooden table, their gestures and expressions reveal a blend of curiosity and respect. The camera zooms in on their hands, illustrating a moment of unity as they collaboratively sketch ideas on a shared notepad. The scene transitions to a lively group activity, where laughter and understanding bridge their differences, culminating in a shared sense of purpose and camaraderie.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_056_seed_42_In a sunlit community center a diverse group of in.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 410, "t": 421, "p": 433}, "output": "\n\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a sunlit community center, a diverse group of individuals gathers, each representing a unique cultural background, dressed in traditional attire that reflects their heritage. The camera captures a young woman in a vibrant sari, an elderly man in a tailored suit, a teenager in a colorful dashiki, and a middle-aged woman in a hijab, all exchanging warm smiles. As they engage in animated discussions around a large wooden table, their gestures and expressions reveal a blend of curiosity and respect. The camera zooms in on their hands, illustrating a moment of unity as they collaboratively sketch ideas on a shared notepad. The scene transitions to a lively group activity, where laughter and understanding bridge their differences, culminating in a shared sense of purpose and camaraderie\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid and aligns with a score of 4. There are clear details and natural lighting most of the time, but there are occasional issues: mild blur during motion, minor compression artifacts, and slight fluctuations in sharpness across frames. Colors remain fairly vibrant and balanced, and the scene maintains coherence throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt, supporting a strong alignment score (4). Key elements—sunlit community-center setting, a diverse group around a large wooden table, traditional attire, warm smiles, animated discussion, and collaborative sketching—are present. A few specifics (such as precise clothing styles and exact ages) are not perfectly verifiable from the footage, but the overall depiction closely matches the description.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical realism is generally maintained at a solid level (score 4). Interactions and object handling feel plausible, and lighting/shadows support depth. However, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in perspective or spatial relations during rapid movements, which prevent a perfect sense of realism.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.886} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::057_seed_310", "pair_id": "057_seed_310", "sample_index": 57, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a vibrant park setting, two distinct communities gather for a shared cultural festival, each bringing unique traditions and energy. On one side, a group dressed in colorful, traditional attire performs a lively folk dance, their movements synchronized and joyful, accompanied by rhythmic drumming and melodic flutes. Opposite them, another community showcases a modern dance routine, wearing sleek, contemporary outfits, moving to the beat of electronic music with fluid, expressive gestures. The camera pans between the two groups, capturing the contrast in styles and the harmonious blend of sounds. As the event progresses, members from both communities begin to mingle, exchanging smiles and teaching each other dance steps, creating a dynamic fusion of tradition and modernity, highlighting the beauty of cultural exchange and mutual respect.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_057_seed_310_In a vibrant park setting two distinct communities.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 308, "t": 319, "p": 331}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a vibrant park setting with two distinct communities gathered for a cultural festival; one group in colorful traditional attire performing a lively folk dance with drums and flutes while another group in contemporary outfits performs a modern dance; the camera moves between the two groups, highlighting cultural exchange and mutual respect.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (3). The footage maintains reasonable resolution and lighting, with occasional softness and minor noise. There are no major artifacts or distortions, but some frames show slight blur or compression effects. Colors remain lively and the scene feels natural, though sharpness fluctuates across shots.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt requirements (4). The setting, presence of two distinct communities, and the traditional vs contemporary outfits are well represented, and the intergenerational dancing interactions are clearly depicted. Drummers and flutists are visible, and the camera work shows movement between the groups. A few details may be less emphasized, but the overall alignment is strong.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (3). Movements generally look plausible and interactions feel believable, but there are minor timing or alignment quirks in a few moments that prevent a perfect sense of realism. No egregious physics violations, yet small inconsistencies keep it from perfect coherence.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 10.764} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::058_seed_930", "pair_id": "058_seed_930", "sample_index": 58, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit conference room, a diverse group of individuals sits around a large, polished wooden table, each person deep in thought. The camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands. Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical. The camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective. A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail, while a man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled. The atmosphere is tense, the stakes high, as each voice adds a layer of complexity to the decision at hand.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_058_seed_930_In a dimly lit conference room a diverse group of.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9995, "t_score_model": 3.0002, "p_score_model": 4.8517, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 498, "t": 509, "p": 521}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a dimly lit conference room, a diverse group of individuals sits around a large, polished wooden table, each person deep in thought. The camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands. Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical. The camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective. A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail, while a man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled. The atmosphere is tense, the stakes high, as each voice adds a layer of complexity to the decision at hand.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video exhibits excellent visual quality across all frames. Resolution is high with crisp details; lighting is consistent and natural; colors are balanced and realistic; there are no artifacts, blur, or distortions; framing remains stable and professional; transitions are smooth; overall image fidelity is strong and suitable for broadcast-like viewing.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThere is partial alignment with the prompt. While several broad elements are present (a diverse group around a large wooden table in a conference-room setting), many specific narrative cues described in the prompt are not clearly realized in the footage. The scene lacks clear evidence of the described dynamics—specifically the middle-aged woman’s intense argument, the young man with crossed arms being overtly skeptical, and the elderly gentleman actively engaging as described. Some surface cues align (setting, participants), but the deeper character behaviors and interactions do not consistently match the detailed prompt. Overall, the alignment is moderate rather than exact, reflecting a mid-level correspondence between description and visuals.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene maintains coherent physical realism throughout: natural seating, believable body language, and plausible interactions among participants; objects, furniture, and lighting behave consistently with real-world expectations. There are no obvious violations of common sense, and the overall scene feels internally coherent. While the narrative alignment to the prompt is only partial, the physical and commonsense aspects remain coherent and credible.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.851400000000002, "elapsed_sec": 15.963} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::060_seed_42", "pair_id": "060_seed_42", "sample_index": 60, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A young adult, wearing a gray hoodie and jeans, stands alone on a dimly lit city street, their face reflecting a mix of determination and vulnerability. The camera captures their hesitant steps as they navigate through bustling crowds, the city's neon lights casting colorful reflections on their contemplative expression. In a quiet park, they pause, sitting on a bench, their gaze distant, lost in thought. The scene shifts to a cozy apartment, where they sit at a cluttered desk, surrounded by personal mementos, their fingers tapping nervously on a laptop. Finally, they stand on a rooftop, overlooking the cityscape, the wind gently tousling their hair, as they take a deep breath, symbolizing resilience and hope amidst adversity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_060_seed_42_A young adult wearing a gray hoodie and jeans stan.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 412, "t": 423, "p": 435}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the text prompt across the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a young adult wearing a gray hoodie and jeans who starts on a dimly lit city street with a contemplative expression, navigates through crowds while neon lights cast colorful reflections, then pauses in a park on a bench with a distant gaze, followed by a scene at a cozy apartment desk with mementos and a laptop, and finally standing on a rooftop overlooking the cityscape with wind in the hair and a deep breath symbolizing resilience.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid (4/5). The video maintains decent resolution and stable lighting, with colors that are generally balanced. There are occasional minor artefacts and slight softness in some frames, but no major distortions or abrupt changes. Transitions are smooth and the imagery reads clearly, contributing to a coherent viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe alignment is moderate (3/5). Most key elements from the prompt are present — the young adult, gray hoodie, jeans, city street setting with neon ambiance, crowds, park bench scene, and the cozy apartment with a laptop. However, the rooftop scene described in the prompt is not depicted in the video, which reduces fidelity to the original narrative. The resulting alignment captures many aspects but misses one crucial element, leading to a middle-ground score.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical consistency is strong (4/5). Movements and interactions read as believable, with natural pacing and plausible environmental interactions. Lighting dynamics and object placements contribute to a convincing sense of realism, and no evident physical implausibilities disrupt the scene.\n\nScoring Rationale:\nWith Visual Quality rated at 4, Text-to-Video Alignment at 3 due to the missing rooftop moment, and Physical Consistency at 4, the overall evaluation reflects solid technical execution with a notable but contained gap in narrative fidelity.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.73} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::061_seed_310", "pair_id": "061_seed_310", "sample_index": 61, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A group of teenagers, clad in casual streetwear, perform daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with reckless abandon. The camera captures their exhilarated expressions as they execute wheelies and jumps, the roar of engines and honking horns creating a chaotic symphony. The sun casts long shadows on the asphalt, highlighting their audacious maneuvers. As they narrowly avoid collisions, the tension mounts, underscoring the perilous nature of their actions. The video concludes with a sobering shot of a discarded helmet lying on the roadside, a stark reminder of the potential consequences of their thrill-seeking exploits.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_061_seed_310_A group of teenagers clad in casual streetwear per.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 487, "t": 498, "p": 481}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it against the given text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A group of teenagers, clad in casual streetwear, perform daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with reckless abandon. The camera captures their exhilarated expressions as they execute wheelies and jumps, the roar of engines and honking horns creating a chaotic symphony. The sun casts long shadows on the asphalt, highlighting their audacious maneuvers. As they narrowly avoid collisions, the tension mounts, underscoring the perilous nature of their actions. The video concludes with a sobering shot of a discarded helmet lying on the roadside, a stark reminder of the potential consequences of their thrill-seeking exploits\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality aligns with a mid-range score (3). The footage presents average clarity: foreground subjects are identifiable, but several distant areas and fast-motion segments show blur and minor artifacts. There are occasional frame-to-frame inconsistencies in sharpness and motion that affect perceived smoothness, and some compression or rendering mismatches slightly reduce detail fidelity. Lighting remains generally natural with decent contrast, though some frames exhibit slight exposure variation and minor color shifts due to compression. The result is acceptable but not standout, corresponding to a moderate visual quality level.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely captures the core prompt elements: a group of youths in casual streetwear performing stunts on a busy highway, weaving through traffic, executing wheelies and jumps, with visible engine activity and dynamic movement. The setting, participants, and action align well with the description. However, certain emotional nuance and fine-grained dynamics may be less pronounced, and a few background or contextual cues are present but not perfectly emphasized. Overall, alignment is strong but not flawless, consistent with a score around 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThere are notable gaps in physical realism and safety awareness when depicting the stunts. While the scene conveys excitement, several aspects—such as rider positioning, vehicle interactions, and the implied physics of wheelies and jumps—are not convincingly coherent with real-world constraints. Shadows and lighting interactions are mostly plausible, but subtle inconsistencies emerge in depth cues and object-scale relationships across frames. In sum, common-sense consistency is limited, reflecting a lower rating.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.983} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::062_seed_930", "pair_id": "062_seed_930", "sample_index": 62, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling office, a group of female employees, dressed in professional attire, gather around a conference table, their expressions a mix of determination and frustration. Nearby, male colleagues, in similar business wear, engage in animated discussions, their voices dominating the room. The camera zooms in on a conversation between a female employee and her manager, where subtle dismissals and patronizing tones reveal underlying gender biases. As the scene unfolds, the women exchange knowing glances, their body language conveying solidarity and resilience. The office environment, with its modern decor and open-plan layout, serves as a backdrop to this poignant narrative of gender disparity in career advancement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_062_seed_930_In a bustling office a group of female employees d.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 398, "t": 409, "p": 386}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency. The text prompt describes a bustling office scenario with professional attire, a conference table, and a mix of determination and frustration among workers, including a focus on gender dynamics and workplace relationships. Now let me examine the frames: Visual Quality Analysis: Looking at the frames, I can see: 1. Resolution and clarity: The video maintains good resolution and overall clarity; faces, clothing, and the office setting are generally well-defined. 2. Stability: There is mild camera movement with occasional shifts, but it remains mostly stable enough to follow the action. 3. Lighting: Lighting is consistent across shots, with natural light through windows and balanced office illumination. 4. Smoothness: Transitions are smooth, without obvious jumps. 5. Distortion/artifacts: No major distortions or artifacts are evident. Overall, visual quality is solid (score 4): good clarity and lighting with only minor stability-related issues. Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis: The frames largely reflect the prompt elements: - A bustling office setting - People in professional attire gathered around a conference table - A mix of expressions suggesting engagement and intensity - Animated discussion activity - Focused interactions between individuals - An emphasis on professional communication within an office context This alignment is strong and coherent, capturing the core elements described, though not every nuanced detail is perfectly mirrored. Overall alignment is high (score 4). Physical/Common-sense Consistency: The scene presents plausible office dynamics and professional behavior: seating around a table, gestures, and interactions align with expected workplace norms, and the environment supports the narrative. The consistency is robust, with only minor deviations in non-critical details. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is solid (score 4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.268} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::064_seed_42", "pair_id": "064_seed_42", "sample_index": 64, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit, smoke-filled room, a diverse group of individuals huddles around a large table cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets, their faces illuminated by the soft glow of a single overhead lamp. The camera pans over their intense expressions, capturing the leader, a sharp-eyed woman in a tailored suit, outlining the heist's intricate details with precision. As they strategize, the camera zooms in on a young man, his brow furrowed, grappling with the moral implications of their plan. Tension mounts as they debate the risks and rewards, their voices a mix of excitement and apprehension. The scene shifts to a montage of their preparations, each member honing their skills, from hacking security systems to practicing stealth maneuvers. The camera lingers on their faces, revealing moments of doubt and resolve, as they confront the ethical dilemmas of their audacious scheme.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_064_seed_42_In a dimly lit smoke-filled room a diverse group o.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 387, "t": 398, "p": 410}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical-consistency. Let me examine the video as a whole rather than frame-by-frame at this level.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video presents acceptable visual quality but not high-end polish. The resolution is adequate and the dim, moody lighting supports the atmosphere, yet some frames exhibit mild softness or slight exposure variation due to the single overhead lamp. The camera motion is generally smooth and the color grading remains cohesive with a cool/blue tint, though occasional lighting inconsistencies mildly affect texture visibility. There are no major distortions or artifacts, and the sequence remains coherent, but it does not reach the highest fidelity throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe scene aligns with several prompt elements such as a dimly lit, smoke-filled room, a diverse group around a large table with blueprints and maps, and visible digital devices. However, key narrative specifics are underrepresented: the presence of a clearly designated leader figure is ambiguous, and the depiction of the young man’s moral struggle or the exact nature of the heist is not strongly pronounced. The camera behavior mirrors the described panning and close-ups, but the alignment to the precise textual cues is partial rather than strong.\n\nPhysical/Commonsense Consistency:\nInteractions and spatial relationships feel natural; objects occupy plausible positions, and lighting dynamics (one overhead lamp casting soft light) are consistent across shots. No obvious physics violations are evident, and the scene maintains coherence in object handling and character placement. Some minor ambiguities in character roles and finer interaction details exist, but they do not undermine overall plausibility.\n\nOverall assessment aligned with scores: Visual Quality = 3, Text-to-Video Alignment = 3, Physical Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.003} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::065_seed_310", "pair_id": "065_seed_310", "sample_index": 65, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A news anchor, dressed in a crisp suit, sits at a sleek desk in a modern studio, delivering breaking news about an alleged alien invasion. Behind him, a large screen displays sensational headlines like \"Alien Invasion Imminent?\" and \"World on Alert!\" The scene shifts to government officials in a high-tech command center, urgently discussing strategies, with maps and data projected on large screens. Next, the camera captures public reactions: people gathered in city squares, some looking skyward in awe, others in panic, while smartphones capture the moment. The video concludes with a montage of newspaper headlines, flashing images of UFO sightings, and a voiceover urging calm amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_065_seed_310_A news anchor dressed in a crisp suit sits at a sl.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 432, "t": 443, "p": 403}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a news broadcast about an alien invasion featuring:\n1. A news anchor in a crisp suit at a sleek desk\n2. Modern studio setting\n3. Large screen displaying headline about alien invasion\n4. Scene transition to government officials in high tech command center\n5. Discussion about strategies with maps and data on large screens\n6. Public reactions in city squares, some looking skyward, others in panic\n7. People capturing moment on smartphones\n8. Montage of newspaper headlines and flashing UFO imagery\n9. Voiceover cautioning calm amid chaos\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- Overall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The frames show acceptable resolution but not consistently sharp across all elements. The anchor remains reasonably clear, yet some details exhibit mild softness. The transitions between frames are stable, with lighting generally consistent; however, there are occasional minor artifacts and slight color variation in certain regions. The sequence feels cohesive, but it does not reach high fidelity throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- The video aligns well with the prompt overall. Core elements are present: a suited anchor at a desk in a modern studio, breaking-news framing, a large monitor displaying an alien invasion headline, a cut to a high-tech command-center setting with maps and data, and a later depiction of public reactions in a city-square context with mobile-phone usage. The alignment is strong with only occasional minor deviations, supporting a high alignment score.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The scenes maintain plausible physical logic, with believable spatial relationships and interactions. The transition from studio to command-center to public reaction follows a reasonable narrative flow. Some micro-details, such as crowd dynamics and mobile-phone interactions, may feel slightly staged, preventing a perfect sense of realism. Overall, physical consistency is solid with moderate fidelity.\n\nScoring reflects these observations: Visual Quality 3, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical/Common-sense Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.035} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::066_seed_930", "pair_id": "066_seed_930", "sample_index": 66, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling school hallway, two teenagers stand face-to-face, their expressions tense and voices raised, surrounded by lockers and students. The camera captures the intensity in their eyes, as one, wearing a red hoodie and jeans, gestures emphatically, while the other, in a black jacket and sneakers, clenches his fists. The scene escalates as they push each other, the crowd around them growing, some students watching with concern, others with excitement. The camera zooms in on their faces, highlighting the raw emotion and anger, as the confrontation turns physical, echoing the charged atmosphere of the school environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_066_seed_930_In a bustling school hallway two teenagers stand f.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 518, "t": 529, "p": 464}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a bustling school hallway, two teenagers stand face-to-face, their expressions tense and voices raised, surrounded by lockers and students. The camera captures the intensity in their eyes, as one, wearing a red hoodie and jeans, gestures emphatically, while the other, in a black jacket and sneakers, clenches his fists. The scene escalates as they push each other, the crowd around them growing, some students watching with concern, others with excitement. The camera zooms in on their faces, highlighting the raw emotion and anger, as the confrontation turns physical, echoing the charged atmosphere of the school environment.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video reads clearly as an anime/cartoon style animation. Visual quality is solid overall: details are readable, colors are vibrant, and the line work remains consistent. There are minor softness in fine facial features and textures that affect sharpness slightly, but no major distortions or artifacts. The motion appears reasonably smooth across frames, and lighting/contrast support the scene without distraction. Overall, the visual presentation aligns with a strong 4/5 level, reflecting good quality with some room for improvement in fine-detail rendering.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt in setting and core action: a bustling school hallway, two teenagers facing off, expressive tension, surrounding lockers and students, and a focus on the central confrontation. The camera work includes moments of close-up on faces as the scene intensifies, and the progression toward physical contact is evident. However, there are a few minor deviations: the left character’s clothing reads as blue/navy rather than red as described, and the initial pushing interaction appears less pronounced than the prompt suggests. Despite these small differences, the overall alignment between the text and visuals remains strong, justifying a 4/5 rating.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nCharacter proportions, spatial relationships, and interactions feel coherent within the anime aesthetic, with plausible body mechanics and believable reactions from the surrounding crowd. While the style allows exaggeration, there are no obvious logical or anatomical inconsistencies that break immersion. This supports a solid 4/5 assessment for physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9999, "elapsed_sec": 17.537} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::068_seed_42", "pair_id": "068_seed_42", "sample_index": 68, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling metropolis, the camera captures the heart-pounding chaos as government forces engage in fierce clashes with armed rebels. Smoke billows from burning vehicles, casting a dark haze over the cityscape. Sirens wail in the distance, mingling with the sound of gunfire echoing through the streets. Citizens, faces etched with fear, scramble for safety, seeking refuge in alleyways and behind crumbling walls. The camera zooms in on a soldier, his uniform dusty and worn, as he communicates urgently through a radio. Nearby, a group of rebels, faces obscured by scarves, strategize amidst the rubble. The tension is palpable, with the city's iconic skyline silhouetted against the ominous glow of fires, painting a stark picture of turmoil and resilience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_068_seed_42_In a bustling metropolis the camera captures the h.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 344, "t": 355, "p": 313}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video sequence showing what appears to be a war scene, I need to analyze it across the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The frames exhibit solid visual fidelity with crisp details, stable lighting, and a cohesive color palette dominated by dusty oranges and browns. The cinematography conveys depth and atmosphere, and smoke effects read as convincing. There are no pervasive artifacts or distortions, though occasional minor compression noise or frame-level artifacts may appear in some shots. Overall, the visual quality is strong and consistent with a high-quality production, corresponding to a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video generally aligns with the described prompt: a bustling metropolis under siege, government forces versus armed rebels, smoke and haze, burning vehicles, and urban destruction. The camera focus on a soldier with a radio and the presence of nearby rebels fit the scenario. However, certain narrative cues—such as explicit radio dialogue or direct interactions among multiple characters—are not always foregrounded, and a few prompt details may be implied rather than shown. Despite these gaps, the overall alignment remains solid, supporting a score around 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The scene adheres to plausible physics and common-sense expectations: smoke disperses naturally, debris behaves realistically, and lighting/shadows fit the fire-lit environment. No obvious physics violations are detected; any minor inconsistencies are subtle and do not disrupt overall plausibility.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.827} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::069_seed_310", "pair_id": "069_seed_310", "sample_index": 69, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street, where a diverse group of individuals, identifiable by their traditional attire and cultural symbols, face an aggressive mob. The camera captures the chaotic energy as the crowd surges forward, their faces contorted with anger and hostility. The air is thick with tension, as shouts and cries echo through the narrow alleyways. The group, standing firm yet visibly anxious, attempts to shield themselves, their expressions a mix of fear and resilience. The camera pans to capture the raw emotion and intensity of the confrontation, highlighting the stark contrast between the aggressors and the targeted group, amidst the urban backdrop.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_069_seed_310_A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street w.mp4", "v_score_model": 2.0001, "t_score_model": 2.9999, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 2, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 82, "t": 163, "p": 263}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video sequence, I need to analyze it across three dimensions:\n\n1. Visual Quality: The frames show relatively low-to-mid resolution with noticeable compression artifacts and occasional motion blur during rapid movements. Detail in costumes and facial features is inconsistent, and some scenes look soft or slightly distorted. Overall, the visual quality is below average, corresponding to a score of 2 out of 5.\n\n2. Text-to-Video Alignment: The sequence includes many core elements described in the prompt—traditional attire, a tense urban street setting, and a confrontation with an opposing group. However, some specifics (such as clear shouting or the exact dynamics of the attack) are not consistently captured, and a few moments feel under-emphasized. Overall alignment is moderate, around 3 out of 5.\n\n3. Physical Consistency: There are noticeable inconsistencies in anatomy and movement, with some limbs appearing awkward or stretched and facial expressions lacking natural fluidity. While the scene remains plausible overall, these issues reduce realism and place physical/common-sense consistency at a moderate level, about 3 out of 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 2\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0, "elapsed_sec": 8.692} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::070_seed_930", "pair_id": "070_seed_930", "sample_index": 70, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two opposing groups face off, their banners and signs clashing in a sea of contrasting colors and messages. The camera captures the tension as voices rise, fists clench, and emotions boil over. A young man, eyes ablaze with determination, shouts passionately, his words lost in the cacophony. Nearby, a woman clutches a sign tightly, her face a mix of fear and resolve. Suddenly, chaos erupts as the groups surge towards each other, the camera zooming in on the raw intensity of the confrontation. Shouts turn to cries, and the air fills with the sound of scuffling feet and clashing ideologies, painting a vivid picture of conflict and fervor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_070_seed_930_In a bustling public square two opposing groups fa.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 303, "t": 313, "p": 283}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the text prompt and the frames provided.\n\nText prompt alignment:\n- The scene conveys a bustling public-square confrontation with banners, signs, and opposing groups, and a central figure expressing determination amid a charged atmosphere. Overall, the video captures the essential elements described in the prompt, yielding strong alignment with only minor deviations.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The animation uses a consistent anime/animated style with readable details and decent clarity. Colors remain vibrant and contrast is adequate; motion appears smooth and the art direction stays coherent throughout. There are no major distortions or artifacts, but occasional minor compression-related softness or frame-level imperfections may be present, which keeps the overall Visual Quality at a solid 4 rather than perfect 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The visuals faithfully reflect the prompt’s core components: a crowded public-square setting, banners and signs, opposing groups, rising tensions, and emotional expressions (fist-raising, shouting). The sequence generally matches the intended narrative progression, supporting a high alignment rating with some small timing or emphasis variances that prevent a flawless match.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The scene remains physically plausible within anime conventions, with natural-looking postures and interactions and coherent crowd dynamics. Some gestures and crowd interactions could be refined or slightly exaggerated due to stylization, resulting in a solid 4 for physical consistency.\n\nOverall assessment (aligned with ground-truth scores):\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9999, "elapsed_sec": 11.641} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::072_seed_42", "pair_id": "072_seed_42", "sample_index": 72, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling Tokyo street, alive with futuristic energy. Neon signs in vivid hues of electric blue, fiery red, and vibrant green illuminate the scene, casting dynamic reflections on rain-soaked pavement. Lens flares dance across the screen, enhancing the kaleidoscope of colors. Holographic advertisements hover above, projecting animated visuals that captivate passersby. The street is a symphony of motion, with sleek, autonomous vehicles gliding silently alongside pedestrians in avant-garde fashion. The air buzzes with the hum of technology, while the aroma of street food wafts through the crowd, adding to the sensory overload of this vibrant, fast-paced urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_072_seed_42_The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling To.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0007, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 371, "t": 382, "p": 394}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the video frames and compare them with the text prompt carefully:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a futuristic Tokyo street with neon-lit signs, rain-soaked pavement, lens flares, holographic advertisements, autonomous vehicles, pedestrians in avant-garde fashion, and a tech-forward atmosphere. The video captures several of these elements but does not fully realize the entire concept.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, resolution is adequate but not exceptional; some frames show mild blur or compression artifacts, reducing fine detail. Neon signage remains vivid and lighting effects contribute to a lively mood, yet overall sharpness and consistency across frames are only moderate. The wet pavement reflections exist but are not always cohesive with reflections on moving surfaces. Motion blur on vehicles is present and expected, while pedestrian rendering exhibits varying degrees of realism across shots. Overall, visual quality sits at a mid level, with noticeable inconsistencies that prevent it from achieving high fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video includes many core prompt elements such as a busy street, neon lighting, rain effects, and dynamic motion cues. However, certain futuristic aspects are underrepresented: holographic advertisements are not clearly visible, and autonomous vehicles are not convincingly depicted. Some details like exact vehicle designs or holographic interactions do not fully align with the concept. Overall, alignment is moderate.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nThe scene maintains plausible physics with reflections on wet surfaces and reasonable motion coherence. Yet there are notable gaps between the described futuristic scenario and what is shown: traffic dynamics feel conventional rather than autonomous, and some interactions lack coherent physics or timing. While no gross impossibilities are evident, the overall physical plausibility is mid-range due to missing or misrendered advanced elements and subtle inconsistencies.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0007, "elapsed_sec": 12.512} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::073_seed_310", "pair_id": "073_seed_310", "sample_index": 73, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A lone cowboy, clad in a weathered hat and rugged attire, rides his sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, the golden hues of sunset painting the sky in vibrant oranges and pinks. The camera captures the gentle sway of prairie grasses, bathed in the soft, warm light of the setting sun. As the cowboy and his horse move gracefully, their silhouettes are etched against the horizon, creating a striking contrast with the colorful sky. The scene evokes a sense of freedom and tranquility, with the distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow, completing the breathtaking landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_073_seed_310_A lone cowboy clad in a weathered hat and rugged a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 391, "t": 402, "p": 352}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nA lone cowboy, clad in a weathered hat and rugged attire, rides his sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, with golden sunset hues painting the sky in vibrant oranges and pinks. The camera captures the gentle sway of prairie grasses bathed in soft, warm light, as the cowboy and horse move gracefully; their silhouettes stand out against the horizon, with distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow to complete the scene.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- Resolution and clarity are solid; not peak sharpness but clean and consistent.\n- Sunset colors display a rich gradient from deep orange to pink-purple tones with smooth transitions.\n- The silhouette remains clearly defined against the bright sky, and lighting stays coherent throughout.\n- The sequence appears stable with minimal jitter; overall polish is good but not exceptional.\nOverall Visual Quality score: 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll major prompt elements are represented: the lone cowboy, hat, rugged attire, sturdy horse, vast open plain, and prominent sunset hues; movement is present and natural; the scene captures the intended mood of freedom and tranquility, with distant mountains visible and softly lit. The alignment is strong and faithful to the prompt, with only minor stylistic liberties. Overall Text-to-Video Alignment score: 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene shows coherent physical dynamics: horse gait, rider posture, lighting, shadows, and environmental interaction are believable and internally consistent. No obvious physics violations; motion and environment feel natural. Minor refinements could push realism further, but current coherence supports a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.912} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::074_seed_930", "pair_id": "074_seed_930", "sample_index": 74, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns mingle and dance gracefully. The camera begins its slow ascent, capturing the shimmer of crystal glasses and the soft glow of candlelit tables. As it pans upward, the grandeur of the room unfolds, revealing a stunning chandelier, its crystals sparkling like stars, gently swaying above the polished marble dance floor. The opulent scene is further enhanced by the soft strains of a live orchestra, filling the air with a melody that complements the elegance and sophistication of the evening.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_074_seed_930_In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate g.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 454, "t": 465, "p": 477}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns mingle and dance gracefully. The camera begins its slow ascent, capturing the shimmer of crystal glasses and the soft glow of candlelit tables. As it pans upward, the grandeur of the room unfolds, revealing a stunning chandelier, its crystals sparkling like stars, gently swaying above the polished marble dance floor. The opulent scene is further enhanced by the soft strains of a live orchestra, filling the air with a melody that complements the elegance and sophistication of the evening.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid (4/5). The ballroom setting reads authentically with clear architectural details in the gold moldings and curtains. The resolution is generally good and lighting is warm and consistent. There are occasional moments where some figures blur or become slightly distorted during movement, which reduces realism but does not dominate the viewing experience. The chandelier is clearly rendered with convincing crystal detail, and camera motion remains smooth across the sequence.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt: the elegant ballroom ambiance, ornate gold moldings, rich drapes, formally dressed guests, dancing, and the upward camera movement culminating in the grand chandelier are all present and well-represented. Some elements from the prompt—such as candlelit table ambience and the audible live orchestra—are not directly verifiable in the visuals alone; nonetheless, their absence does not materially detract from the overall alignment. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is strong (4/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nSpatial arrangement and lighting support a cohesive, believable scene: the chandelier’s position, the marble floor, and the distribution of furniture and dancers contribute to a plausible environment. While minor rendering artifacts in human figures persist, they do not seriously undermine the scene’s physical plausibility. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is high (4/5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.357} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::076_seed_42", "pair_id": "076_seed_42", "sample_index": 76, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera soars above a lively medieval marketplace, capturing vibrant stalls brimming with colorful fabrics, fresh produce, and handcrafted goods. Merchants in traditional garb enthusiastically barter with animated townsfolk, while children weave through the crowd, laughter echoing. The scene transitions smoothly, morphing into a bustling modern cityscape. Towering skyscrapers pierce the sky, their glass facades reflecting the vibrant hues of neon lights. The streets below teem with life, cars weaving through traffic, and pedestrians navigating the urban jungle. The juxtaposition of eras highlights the evolution of commerce and community, from quaint cobblestones to sleek, illuminated avenues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_076_seed_42_The camera soars above a lively medieval marketpla.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 424, "t": 435, "p": 447}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"The camera soars above a lively medieval marketplace, capturing vibrant stalls brimming with colorful fabrics, fresh produce, and handcrafted goods. Merchants in traditional garb enthusiastically barter with animated townsfolk, while children weave through the crowd, laughter echoing. The scene transitions smoothly, morphing into a bustling modern cityscape. Towering skyscrapers pierce the sky, their glass facades reflecting the vibrant hues of neon lights. The streets below teem with life, cars weaving through traffic, and pedestrians navigating the urban jungle. The juxtaposition of eras highlights the evolution of commerce and community, from quaint cobblestones to sleek, illuminated avenues\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is mid-range (score 3). The medieval marketplace scenes show decent color and detail but exhibit mild softness and occasional artifacts; a few frames display slightly exaggerated or stylized character proportions. The transition to the modern cityscape is present but not perfectly seamless, with some inconsistency in lighting and perspective across cuts. In sum, the visuals convey the intended scenes, but with moderate imperfections that keep the quality from being higher.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment remains strong overall (score 4). The video largely follows the prompt’s arc—from a vibrant medieval marketplace with colorful stalls to a contemporary cityscape with skyscrapers, neon reflections, and dynamic street life. The core narrative and transitions are well captured, though a few stylistic choices introduce minor deviations from the exact textual cues, preventing a perfect 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is moderate (score 3). The scenes maintain plausible spatial relationships and era-appropriate details (cobblestones, market stalls, modern infrastructure), but there are subtle inconsistencies in scale, lighting, and motion that occasionally disrupt full realism. These issues are noticeable but do not entirely break the overall plausibility of the sequence.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.496} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::077_seed_310", "pair_id": "077_seed_310", "sample_index": 77, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A professional ballet dancer, dressed in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers, performs a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio. Her elegant form is silhouetted against the large windows, through which golden sunlight streams, casting long shadows on the polished wooden floor. The camera captures her mid-air, her arms gracefully extended, and her expression serene and focused. Her hair is pulled back into a neat bun, emphasizing the fluidity and precision of her movements. The studio's airy ambiance, with its high ceilings and minimalist decor, enhances the ethereal quality of her performance, highlighting the dancer's grace and strength.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_077_seed_310_A professional ballet dancer dressed in a flowing.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0988, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 504, "t": 515, "p": 431}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the text prompt and video frames provided.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: A professional ballet dancer, dressed in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers, performs a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio. Her elegant form is silhouetted against the large windows, through which golden sunlight streams, casting long shadows on the polished wooden floor. The camera captures her mid-air, her arms gracefully extended, and her expression serene and focused. Her hair is pulled back into a neat bun, emphasizing the fluidity and precision of her movements. The studio's airy ambiance, with its high ceilings and minimalist decor, enhances the ethereal quality of her performance, highlighting the dancer's grace and strength\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video as a whole, the visuals deliver a strong, cohesive impression. The resolution is high, details are clear, and lighting is warm with natural sunlight streaming through the windows. The dancer remains distinctly visible against the bright background, and the sequence maintains stable exposure and smooth motion. There are no obvious distortions or misalignment issues, and transitions feel steady throughout. Overall, the visual quality is solid and aligns with a 4 on the scale.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely mirrors the prompt: a professional dancer in a white leotard performing a grand jeté in a sunlit studio with polished wooden floors, long shadows, and a serene, focused expression. The bun, high ceilings, and minimalist decor are present, contributing to an ethereal atmosphere. Some minor deviations exist (slightly different shade of the leotard and the exact visibility of the pink slippers), but these do not significantly detract from overall fidelity. Overall alignment is strong, corresponding to a 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMovements exhibit precise ballet mechanics, with controlled momentum, balanced leaps, and grounded contact with the floor. Lighting, space, and material behavior are coherent, producing a believable, physically consistent performance. No contradictions between pose, motion, and environment are evident, supporting a 5 rating.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0988, "elapsed_sec": 16.92} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::078_seed_930", "pair_id": "078_seed_930", "sample_index": 78, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crimson sky, where sleek flying cars zip through neon-lit avenues, casting vibrant reflections on the metallic surfaces below. The camera glides through this bustling metropolis, capturing the intricate dance of vehicles weaving between towering structures. As it zooms in, a colossal skyscraper emerges, its facade adorned with dynamic holographic advertisements that flicker and shift, showcasing interstellar products and services. The building's glassy exterior mirrors the kaleidoscope of colors from the streets, while digital billboards project futuristic imagery, creating a mesmerizing blend of technology and architecture in this otherworldly urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_078_seed_930_A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crim.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0012, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 450, "t": 462, "p": 511}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sprawling Martian cityscape with a crimson sky, sleek flying cars weaving through neon-lit avenues, and a camera gliding through a bustling metropolis where holographic advertisements flicker on glassy skyscrapers. While the frames capture many of these elements, the overall alignment to the described world is moderate rather than perfect. The scene conveys a dense, futuristic city vibe with tall structures, holographic displays, and reflective surfaces, but some specifics (such as explicit interstellar context and a pronounced shimmering effect) are not consistently realized across all frames.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals are adequate rather than outstanding. The resolution is generally acceptable and color saturation is strong, with neon hues and contrast supporting readability. However, several frames exhibit mild softness and minor artifacts, and some shots rely on aggressive grading that can obscure fine detail. The lighting remains dramatic and the composition is coherent, but the overall crispness and fidelity do not reach high-end levels throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns with several core concepts of the prompt (neon-lit streets, futuristic architecture, and a camera moving through a busy city). However, key aspects are only moderately represented: the sky color and explicit “Martian” setting are not clearly established, and the emphasis on a “colossal skyscraper” and a glassy exterior with a kaleidoscope of reflections is intermittent. Holographic billboards exist, but their dynamics and integration with lighting are not uniformly convincing. Overall, the alignment is acceptable but not strongly definitive.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains plausible spatial relationships, vehicle motion, and lighting interactions within a futuristic city context, with believable reflections on metallic surfaces and consistent scale. Minor inconsistencies exist in holographic behavior and some perspective cues, yet they do not disrupt the overall coherence. The result is a credible, internally consistent depiction without major logical contradictions.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 3\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 3\nDim-3 Physical Consistency (Common-sense): 3\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0012, "elapsed_sec": 16.418} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::080_seed_42", "pair_id": "080_seed_42", "sample_index": 80, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A mesmerizing flame wisp, glowing with ethereal light, darts through a bustling fantasy market under the starry night sky. The camera follows its swift, graceful movements, illuminating vibrant stalls brimming with exotic goods, colorful fabrics, and mystical artifacts. The market is alive with fantastical creatures and lively merchants, their animated conversations and laughter filling the air. Lanterns cast a warm, golden glow, enhancing the magical atmosphere. The flame wisp weaves through the crowd, its fiery trail reflecting off shimmering surfaces, creating a captivating dance of light and shadow in this enchanting, otherworldly marketplace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_080_seed_42_A mesmerizing flame wisp glowing with ethereal lig.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 465, "t": 476, "p": 488}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A mesmerizing flame wisp, glowing with ethereal light, darts through a bustling fantasy market under the starry night sky. The camera follows its swift, graceful movements, illuminating vibrant stalls brimming with exotic goods, colorful fabrics, and mystical artifacts. The market is alive with fantastical creatures and lively merchants, their animated conversations and laughter filling the air. Lanterns cast a warm, golden glow, enhancing the magical atmosphere. The flame wisp weaves through the crowd, its fiery trail reflecting off shimmering surfaces, creating a captivating dance of light and shadow in this enchanting, otherworldly marketplace.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, visuals are strong overall, with a cohesive fantasy palette and rich detail in architecture and lighting. The flame wisp shows convincing glow and motion, and the scene maintains a consistent ethereal mood. Some later frames exhibit mild blur or softness and occasional distortions in character rendering, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a high level (score 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely follows the prompt: the flame wisp, the bustling fantasy market, the night sky, the warm lantern glow, and the fantastical ambiance are all present. The camera movement tracks the flame effectively, and the setting features vibrant stalls and a variety of magical elements. Alignment remains strong throughout, with only minor deviations in fine details; this corresponds to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nInitial frames show coherent spatial relationships and stable character proportions. As the sequence progresses, some frames display mild anatomical distortions and slight blur, but these issues are limited and do not severely disrupt comprehension. Movement and interactions remain largely plausible within the fantasy context, yielding an overall moderate level of physical consistency (score 3).\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.305} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::081_seed_310", "pair_id": "081_seed_310", "sample_index": 81, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a noir-style scene, a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walks down a dimly lit alley, the cobblestones glistening from recent rain. The camera captures the interplay of shadows across his chiseled features as he pauses under a flickering streetlamp. He lights a cigarette, the flame briefly illuminating his stern expression and the smoke curling upwards, adding to the mysterious atmosphere. The distant sound of a saxophone echoes through the alley, enhancing the moody ambiance. His eyes, sharp and observant, scan the surroundings, revealing a man deeply engrossed in his thoughts, as the city’s secrets linger in the shadows.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_081_seed_310_In a noir-style scene a detective in a classic tre.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 368, "t": 379, "p": 391}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a noir-style scene with a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walking down a dimly lit alley on wet cobblestones, camera capturing shadows across his face as he pauses under a flickering streetlamp, lights a cigarette with a brief flame, and a distant saxophone enhances the moody ambiance while his eyes scan the surroundings. The sequence largely adheres to these elements, with strong alignment overall.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, the production shows solid resolution and cinematography. Lighting and color grading support a convincing noir mood. There is some slight variation in sharpness between earlier and later frames, but the overall image quality is consistent and coherent. The cinematography remains stable with decent depth cues and minimal artifacts. Overall, Visual Quality is good (score 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely aligns with the prompt. The noir aesthetic, the trench coat and fedora, the dim alley setting, the cobblestones, the lighting dynamics, the cigarette lighting moment, and the distant saxophone all align well with the description. The character design and environmental details convey a convincing detective persona. The alignment is strong and consistently matches the textual cues, supporting a top score (5).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains generally plausible physics and human behavior. Movements and interactions read naturally, and environmental lighting and shadows are coherent. However, there are minor inconsistencies in timing or subtle anatomical precision that prevent perfect realism. Overall, Physical Consistency is acceptable (score 3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.348} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::082_seed_930", "pair_id": "082_seed_930", "sample_index": 82, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_082_seed_930_In a dimly lit industrial workshop a grinding whee.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9994, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 486, "t": 497, "p": 509}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video demonstrates excellent Visual Quality. The resolution is high, with sharp rendering of both the grinding wheel and the sparks. Lighting is well-balanced, and the warm orange/golden hues from the sparks contrast nicely with cooler tones in the workshop environment. The motion is smooth, and the focus remains consistently on the action without noticeable blur or distortion. Brightness and contrast stay stable across scenes, and the slow-motion presentation effectively reveals the intricate details of the sparks and their dynamics. The visuals uphold realism throughout, with no distracting artifacts or technical issues.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt: the dim industrial setting, a spinning grinding wheel, and a cascade of bright sparks are clearly depicted. The camera work emphasizes the sparks, capturing vivid detail and the orange/golden illumination. The presence of slow-motion and the lighting effects support the described spectacle. The backdrop elements (metal beams and machinery) are present but not always prominent; nonetheless, the core prompt elements are well represented. Overall alignment is strong with only minor deviations in background emphasis.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical behavior: the grinding wheel rotation and sparks emission match expected mechanical machining dynamics, with realistic trajectories and lighting interactions. The spray of liquid appears purposefully directed, likely for cooling, and does not introduce implausible physics. While extremely bright, the sparks behave within typical industrial machining expectations. The overall physical consistency is solid, with believable interaction and environmental context, though a few background details could be integrated more tightly with the action.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9993, "elapsed_sec": 15.965} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::084_seed_42", "pair_id": "084_seed_42", "sample_index": 84, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man, wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pants, sprints through a dense forest, the camera capturing his intense, wide-eyed expressions as he navigates the uneven terrain. His breath is visible in the crisp air, and the sound of crunching leaves and snapping twigs accompanies his hurried pace. The towering trees, with their thick trunks and branches, blur into streaks of green and brown, emphasizing his speed and urgency. Sunlight filters through the canopy, casting dappled patterns on his face, highlighting his determination and the adrenaline coursing through him. His rapid heartbeat echoes, underscoring the tension of his wild dash through the wilderness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_084_seed_42_A man wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 487, "t": 498, "p": 510}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A man, wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pants, sprints through a dense forest, the camera capturing his intense, wide-eyed expressions as he navigates the uneven terrain. His breath is visible in the crisp air, and the sound of crunching leaves and snapping twigs accompanies his hurried pace. The towering trees, with their thick trunks and branches, blur into streaks of green and brown, emphasizing his speed and urgency. Sunlight filters through the canopy, casting dappled patterns on his face, highlighting his determination and the adrenaline coursing through him. His rapid heartbeat echoes, underscoring the tension of his wild dash through the wilderness.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (3). The frames show decent resolution and natural lighting, but the quality is not outstanding. There may be occasional minor compression artifacts or slight softness in distant foliage, which keeps it from reaching high-end realism. The forest environment remains convincingly detailed across frames, and the subject’s movement appears reasonably smooth with generally stable framing. Minor motion blur during faster moments is present but does not severely degrade perception.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment to the prompt is strong overall (4). The video captures the core elements: a man sprinting through a dense forest, wearing rugged outdoor attire, with a handheld camera feel and visible expressions of focus. The forest setting, uneven terrain, and filtering sunlight align well with the description, and the overall pacing conveys urgency. A few nuanced details—such as the explicit visibility of breath or the precise cadence of footfalls—are not consistently demonstrated, but they do not significantly detract from alignment. The result is a high-fidelity depiction with only minor deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is good but not flawless (3). The running mechanics and interaction with the forest environment feel generally plausible, with believable gait and limb motion. Some subtle inconsistencies remain: occasional stiffness in arm swing, slight mismatches in foot placement over uneven ground, and sporadic lighting/shadow mismatches that prevent perfect physical realism. Overall, there are no major logical contradictions, but these small cues keep the score at a moderate level.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.941} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::085_seed_310", "pair_id": "085_seed_310", "sample_index": 85, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyon, its icy walls towering and glistening under a soft, muted light. As it soars, the scene transitions into a surreal cloudscape, where fluffy clouds drift lazily across a pastel sky. The motion is fluid and dynamic, capturing the ethereal beauty of the clouds. Suddenly, the view shifts to a serene forest, where tall trees sway gently in a whispering breeze, their leaves a muted green. The journey continues, seamlessly flowing into a tranquil desert, where rolling dunes stretch endlessly, bathed in the soft glow of a setting sun. The muted color palette ties each landscape together, creating a harmonious and dreamlike visual experience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_085_seed_310_The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0002, "t_score_model": 3.0002, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 550, "t": 561, "p": 544}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video sequence, I need to analyze it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the text prompt is asking for:\n\"The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyon, its icy walls towering and glistening under a soft, muted light. As it soars, the scene transitions into a surreal cloudscape, where fluffy clouds drift lazily across a pastel sky. The motion is fluid and dynamic, capturing the ethereal beauty of the clouds. Suddenly, the view shifts to a serene forest, where tall trees sway gently in a whispering breeze, their leaves a muted green. The journey continues, seamlessly flowing into a tranquil desert, where rolling dunes stretch endlessly, bathed in the soft glow of a setting sun. The muted color palette ties each landscape together, creating a harmonious and dreamlike visual experience\"\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n1. The initial frames show a very blurry, pinkish/purplish background with some darker areas that might be intended as shapes but are not clearly defined\n2. Around frame 6-7, there appears to be some kind of opening or portal effect with white/light colored formations\n3. Frames 8-15 show what looks like a cave opening or tunnel view with white/light walls, blue sky visible through an opening, clouds floating by, mountains/hills in the distance, and forest silhouettes\n4. The later frames show more clear desert landscape with rolling dunes, trees, and desert terrain\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Early frames are notably blurred and lack sharp detail\n- The transition from the opening to the clearer desert remains smooth, but overall clarity stays mid-level\n- The resolution supports recognizable landscapes, yet fine textures are still limited\nOverall visual quality is mid-range (score around 3).\n\nText-to-video alignment shows how faithfully the video adheres to the prompt. The video captures the essential elements — a glacial/canyon-like opening, a cloudy sky, distant mountains, forest silhouettes, and a desert with dunes — and the progression flows in a way that resembles the described journey. However, the alignment is not exceptional; there are occasional mismatches in texture cues and lighting continuity, keeping the correspondence at a moderate level.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe sequence presents a coherent progression through varied environments, with plausible spatial relations between landscapes. There are no glaring logical contradictions, and the overall narrative remains readable and believable, albeit with some stylistic artistic choices that temper strict realism.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 7.0004, "elapsed_sec": 17.659} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::086_seed_930", "pair_id": "086_seed_930", "sample_index": 86, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at a grand piano on a sandy beach, her fingers dancing over the keys, creating a melody that harmonizes with the gentle waves. The camera begins to rotate around her, capturing her serene expression and the intricate details of her white lace dress. As it moves, the expansive ocean stretches endlessly, its surface shimmering under the soft, golden light of the setting sun. The sky is painted with pastel hues, adding to the whimsical atmosphere. Seagulls glide gracefully above, and the gentle breeze rustles her hair, completing the enchanting scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_086_seed_930_A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.9999, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 523, "t": 534, "p": 546}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A young woman with flowing hair sitting at a grand piano on a sandy beach\n- Her fingers dancing over the keys, creating a melody\n- Camera rotating around her, capturing her serene expression\n- Intricate details of her white lace dress\n- Expansive ocean stretching endless, shimmering under golden light of setting sun\n- Sky painted with pastel hues, adding whimsical atmosphere\n- Seagulls gliding gracefully above\n- Gentle breeze rustling her hair\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video, Visual Quality is outstanding. The resolution is high and the imagery remains sharp throughout, with natural, balanced lighting and a warm sunset palette that enhances depth and mood. Colors are vibrant yet cohesive, contrast is well managed, and there are no noticeable artifacts or distortions. The composition stays aesthetically pleasing, and motion rendering is smooth, including the camera rotation and the natural movement of the seagulls. Hair, dress, and hands render convincingly, contributing to a highly immersive viewing experience. Overall, the visual quality meets a top-tier standard.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely tracks the prompt, aligning very well with all described elements. The young woman with flowing hair, the grand piano, the sandy beach, the rotating camera, the serene expression, the white lace dress, the expansive ocean, the golden hues, the pastel sky, and the gliding seagulls are faithfully represented. The scene captures the whimsical atmosphere and the nuanced details match the textual description, yielding an essentially perfect alignment score for the video as a whole.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene exhibits strong physical realism. The pianist’s posture and hand movements are purposeful yet natural; the interaction with the instrument reads convincingly, and the spatial arrangement among the beach, ocean, and sky feels organic. Lighting dynamics and wind interactions (hair and dress movement) reinforce believability, and the motion of seagulls integrates smoothly into the environment. While most elements read as highly realistic, there may be minor, non-critical inconsistencies in fine-grained hand positions or micro-dynamics that do not detract from overall coherence.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video delivers exceptional Visual Quality and Text-to-Video Alignment, with Physical Consistency rated slightly lower due to minor, non-critical deviations. The result is a compelling, immersive representation aligned with the original creative vision.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.9999, "elapsed_sec": 16.667} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::088_seed_42", "pair_id": "088_seed_42", "sample_index": 88, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds. As the perspective shifts, the seeds transform into floating islands, each adorned with shimmering, translucent structures that pulse with soft, ambient light. Tiny, luminescent particles drift gracefully through the air, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. The scene is bathed in a gentle, golden glow, casting a dreamlike atmosphere over the surreal landscape. The intricate details of the dandelion's inner world unfold, revealing a hidden universe of wonder and tranquility, where time seems to slow and the boundaries of reality blur.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_088_seed_42_The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed re.mp4", "v_score_model": 1.0, "t_score_model": 1.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 585, "t": 585, "p": 614}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText prompt analysis:\nThe prompt describes a camera zoom into a dandelion at high speed, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds. As the perspective shifts, the seeds transform into floating islands, each adorned with shimmering, translucent structures that pulse with soft, ambient light. Tiny, luminescent particles drift gracefully through the air, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. The scene is bathed in a gentle, golden glow, casting a dreamlike atmosphere over the surreal landscape. The intricate details of the dandelion's inner world unfold, revealing a hidden universe of wonder and tranquility where time seems to slow and the boundaries of reality blur.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The resolution is high and the imagery remains crisp across frames\n- The dandelion's intricate seed structure and fine details are clearly visible\n- The soft, even golden lighting maintains a cohesive warm palette throughout\n- Transitions between frames feel smooth and natural\n- The background separation and depth cues read well, with strong contrast control\n- No obvious artifacts or distortions undermine viewing experience\n- Overall, visual quality reads as high fidelity and polished\n\nGround-truth Visual Quality score: 5\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video closely follows the prompt: camera zooms into a dandelion, high-speed progression, ethereal seed-focused visuals, and a shift toward floating, luminescent elements with ambient illumination\n- The depiction of floating islands, translucent structures, and particles aligns with the described metamorphosis and lighting ambiance\n- The dreamlike atmosphere and general progression from seed to luminescent forms match the intended narrative\n- Minor deviations exist in the precise timing of transitions and the density of particle effects, but they do not detract from the overall alignment\n- Overall, the alignment is strong and faithful to the prompt\n\nGround-truth Text-to-Video Alignment score: 4\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- The dynamics stay believable within a stylized, fantastical context; seed dispersal appears plausible, and the ethereal metamorphosis maintains internal coherence\n- The transformation into floating islands and the emergence of translucent structures follow a consistent logic, preserving spatial relationships and perceived motion\n- No obvious inconsistencies break immersion, though the extreme speed and surreal metamorphosis introduce a degree of abstraction beyond strict physical realism\n- Overall, physical consistency is solid with minor allowances for artistic interpretation\n\nGround-truth Physical Consistency score: 4\n\nRatings summary:\n- Visual Quality: high-fidelity rendering with strong detail and cohesive lighting\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: strong correspondence to the prompt with minor refinements possible\n- Physical Consistency: coherent within a stylized, imaginative framework\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 6.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.757} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::089_seed_310", "pair_id": "089_seed_310", "sample_index": 89, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a dimly lit tunnel, the walls a blur of shadow and light. Emerging into a sprawling labyrinth, the scene transforms into a chaotic dance of rapidly growing vines, twisting and curling with a life of their own. The camera navigates through disorienting angles, capturing the vines' relentless expansion, their tendrils reaching out like eager fingers. Fast transitions between shots create a dizzying effect, as the viewer is plunged deeper into the maze, the vibrant green of the vines contrasting starkly against the dark, earthy tones of the labyrinth. The atmosphere is both thrilling and unsettling, as the camera weaves through this living, breathing puzzle.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_089_seed_310_The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a di.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 516, "t": 527, "p": 539}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video step by step based on the text prompt and frames provided.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a dimly lit tunnel, the walls a blur of shadow and light. Emerging into a sprawling labyrinth, the scene transforms into a chaotic dance of rapidly growing vines, twisting and curling with a life of their own. The camera navigates through disorienting angles, capturing the vines' relentless expansion, their tendrils reaching out like eager fingers. Fast transitions between shots create a dizzying effect, as the viewer is plunged deeper into the maze, the vibrant green of the vines contrasting starkly against the dark, earthy tones of the labyrinth. The atmosphere is both thrilling and unsettling, as the camera weaves through this living, breathing puzzle.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video presents a moderate level of visual quality (score ~3). The sequence begins with relatively readable tunnel details but quickly shifts toward heavy motion blur and increasing abstraction. While some frames retain recognizable shapes, many moments rely on indistinct, high-contrast patterns rather than clear visuals. In the later portions, color vibrancy and contrast are present, yet overall clarity remains limited by the intentional motion dynamics. The rapid transitions contribute to perceptual disorientation, but the footage does not completely collapse into an unintelligible mass; there is a discernible progression through increasingly blurred and abstract segments.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt’s intent (score ~4). Key elements—camera movement at speed, a tunnel/dim environment, and the emergence of a complex, twisting structure—are clearly conveyed. The notion of a “sprawling labyrinth” and the subsequent chaotic vine growth are suggested through evolving patterns and disorienting motion. While some specifics of the vines’ behavior and the precise contrast between earthy tones and vibrant greens are softened by blur, the overall narrative arc from structured tunnel to organic maze is coherent and recognizable. The core motifs (speed, emergence, structural complexity) are effectively captured.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains basic coherence in its progression from a defined tunnel to a more intricate, living structure. The rapid, disorienting pace supports a plausible interpretation of accelerating complexity within a maze-like environment, even if some micro-level details (e.g., exact vine mechanics) remain ambiguous due to blur. Overall, physical consistency is moderate (score ~3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.906} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::090_seed_930", "pair_id": "090_seed_930", "sample_index": 90, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a vibrant, humid rainforest, a sloth leisurely traverses a thick branch, its every movement deliberate and unhurried. The camera captures the intricate details of its coarse, moss-tinted fur, each strand glistening with moisture under the soft, cinematic lighting that filters through the dense canopy above. The lush green foliage surrounds the sloth, creating a rich tapestry of verdant hues, while the gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds provide a serene soundtrack. As the sloth pauses, its soulful eyes reflect the tranquility of its environment, embodying the essence of the rainforest's timeless, unhurried rhythm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_090_seed_930_In a vibrant humid rainforest a sloth leisurely tr.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 356, "t": 367, "p": 379}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Resolution and Clarity: The video shows very good resolution and clarity; the sloth fur texture, moss, and rainforest environment are discernible with strong detail.\n- Local Details: Fine details are generally well-rendered, including individual strands of fur and branch textures; the background remains legible without distracting artifacts.\n- Stability: The sequence is largely stable with no obvious frame-to-frame distortions.\n- Lighting and Contrast: The lighting aligns with rainforest conditions, producing natural shadows, highlights, and depth cues.\n- Smoothness: Motion appears smooth, with gradual transitions between poses.\n- Distortion/Artifacts: No major artifacts or distortions affecting perception.\n\nOverall, Visual Quality is high and consistent with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely follows the prompt, capturing a vibrant rainforest setting with a sloth moving among branches, deliberate and unhurried movements, detailed fur texture, and moisture on the coat. The lighting, color palette, and composition reflect the described atmosphere, and the scene maintains coherence with the prompt throughout. This reflects near-perfect alignment, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe depiction demonstrates strong anatomical accuracy and natural motion for a two-toed sloth in a rainforest context. The environment supports plausible behavior (moss, damp lighting, leafy canopy), and the interaction with branches is believable. Very minor deviations may exist in micro-details, but they do not undermine overall plausibility, supporting a score of 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.812} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::092_seed_42", "pair_id": "092_seed_42", "sample_index": 92, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor expertly navigates a molten lava flow, the intense heat shimmering around him. The camera follows closely, capturing the surreal juxtaposition of metal against the fiery backdrop. His visor reflects the glowing red and orange hues of the lava, while the armor's intricate engravings glint in the volcanic light. As he maneuvers skillfully, the molten rock crackles beneath his board, sending sparks into the air. The camera captures every detail, from the heat waves distorting the air to the intense focus in his eyes, creating a breathtaking scene of bravery and elemental power.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_092_seed_42_A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor ex.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0001, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 398, "t": 409, "p": 386}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt.\n\nText Prompt: \"A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor expertly navigates a molten lava flow, the intense heat shimmering around him. The camera follows closely, capturing the surreal juxtaposition of metal against the fiery backdrop. His visor reflects the glowing red and orange hues of the lava, while the armor's intricate engravings glint in the volcanic light. As he maneuvers skillfully, the molten rock crackles beneath his board, sending sparks into the air. The camera captures every detail, from the heat waves distorting the air to the intense focus in his eyes, creating a breathtaking scene of bravery and elemental power\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe frames exhibit solid visual quality suitable for a cinematic fantasy action piece. Resolution is adequate with clear armor details, and warm lava lighting plus color gradients are convincingly rendered. There are occasional motion blur and minor artifacts during rapid movement, but they do not significantly detract from readability. Overall, Visual Quality is strong with only minor imperfections (score 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video captures the core elements—an armored figure and molten environment with dynamic camera motion—yet it does not fully realize the prompt's explicit surfboarding scenario. The central action centers more on a vehicle-like apparatus navigating lava rather than a human surfer riding a board. This constitutes a moderate misalignment, resulting in a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMaterial interactions and heat effects feel plausible within a fantastical setting; the armor remains coherent under intense heat, and lighting/shadows respond plausibly to the molten backdrop. While some dynamics push the boundaries of real-world physics, they remain credible within the imagined world. Overall, Physical Consistency sits at a moderate level (score 3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0001, "elapsed_sec": 13.797} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::093_seed_310", "pair_id": "093_seed_310", "sample_index": 93, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A vintage teddy bear, with worn fur and a stitched smile, sits on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt. As golden sunlight streams through delicate lace curtains, casting intricate patterns on the walls, the bear's eyes flutter open, revealing a spark of life. The camera slowly pulls back, capturing the room's whimsical charm, as the bear begins to move, its limbs stretching and head turning with newfound animation. The gentle rustle of the curtains and the soft glow of the morning light create a magical atmosphere, as the bear embarks on its enchanting journey within the cozy, sunlit room.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_093_seed_310_A vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 3.0003, "p_score_model": 4.9647, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 560, "t": 571, "p": 583}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A vintage teddy bear, with worn fur and a stitched smile, sits on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt. As golden sunlight streams through delicate lace curtains, casting intricate patterns on the walls, the bear's eyes flutter open, revealing a spark of life. The camera slowly pulls back, capturing the room's whimsical charm, as the bear begins to move, its limbs stretching and head turning with newfound animation. The gentle rustle of the curtains and the soft glow of the morning light create a magical atmosphere, as the bear embarks on its enchanting journey within the cozy, sunlit room.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames, the evaluation focuses on resolution, clarity, blurriness, smoothness, brightness/contrast stability, distortion, and overall watching experience.\n\n- Resolution and Clarity: The frames maintain high resolution and overall sharpness; fur texture, facial features, and fabric details are rendered with clear fidelity.\n- Consistency: Lighting, color balance, and scene composition remain stable across the sequence.\n- Smoothness: Transitions between poses are fluid; no noticeable jerkiness.\n- Brightness/Contrast: Warm, golden light is consistently applied, preserving gentle contrast throughout.\n- Distortion/Misalignment: No evident geometric distortions or misalignment observed.\n- Overall: Visual quality is excellent, with strong fidelity and polished presentation.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns with several elements described in the prompt (vintage appearance, smile, bed setting, pillows, quilt, warm lighting, lace curtains, and a gentle atmosphere). However, the key dynamic moments—camera pull-back, the bear’s eyes opening with a spark of life, movement (limb stretching and head turning), and the magical journey—are not realized in the footage. The result shows a static, largely immobile depiction rather than the intended animated progression.\n\nThus, Text-to-Video Alignment remains moderate due to missing motion cues and narrative progression.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene maintains plausible physics and spatial relationships: the teddy bear, bedding, and room elements occupy believable positions, lighting interactions are coherent with the setup, and there are no obvious violations of physical plausibility. The lack of motion does not introduce physical inconsistencies; it simply reflects a more static interpretation of the moment.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video achieves top-tier visual quality and solid physical consistency, while alignment to the full textual prompt is present but only partially realized due to missing dynamic movement and narrative progression.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9649, "elapsed_sec": 18.666} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::094_seed_930", "pair_id": "094_seed_930", "sample_index": 94, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a mesmerizing macro view, delicate water droplets cling to a spider's web, each droplet shimmering like a tiny universe. As the camera zooms in, the droplets begin to transform, revealing swirling galaxies within, with stars twinkling and spiraling in cosmic dance. The web, intricately woven, serves as a celestial canvas, its strands glistening like silken threads of the cosmos. The dimly lit background enhances the ethereal glow of the galaxies, casting a soft, mysterious light that accentuates the delicate beauty of this otherworldly transformation. The scene captures the enchanting fusion of nature and the universe in a breathtaking display.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_094_seed_930_In a mesmerizing macro view delicate water droplet.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 352, "t": 363, "p": 375}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions at once.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a mesmerizing macro view of a spider's web with water droplets, each droplet shimmering like a tiny universe, and a cosmic transformation where the droplets reveal swirling galaxies and stars. The scene should convey a dim, ethereal background with a celestial canvas, delicate silken thread strands, and an enchanting fusion of nature and the universe.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is strong (4/5). The frames deliver crisp micro-details of the droplets and intricate web geometry, with convincing refraction and translucency. The gradient background supports the intended atmosphere, and lighting maintains good contrast between the droplets and the backdrop. There are occasional minor artifacts and slight softness during transitions, but these do not significantly detract from the overall clarity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment to the prompt is moderate (3/5). The macro view and visible water droplets align with the description, but key elements—such as actual transformations of droplets into galaxies and the emergence of stars—are not realized in the sequence. The cosmic motifs remain abstract rather than physically enacted, resulting in partial alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical consistency is high (4/5). Water droplet behavior, light interactions, and the intricate web structure are believable and coherent throughout. No obvious physical contradictions are observed, and atmospheric effects are consistent with a dim, ethereal setting.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 3; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.59} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::096_seed_42", "pair_id": "096_seed_42", "sample_index": 96, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A mesmerizing dancer, clad in a flowing crimson dress, twirls elegantly on a dimly lit stage, her movements fluid and captivating. The camera circles her, capturing each graceful step and spin, as vibrant, multicolored lights cast dynamic patterns across the stage. Wisps of smoke swirl around her, adding an ethereal quality to the performance. Her expressive face reflects passion and intensity, while the lights shift from deep blues to fiery oranges, enhancing the dramatic atmosphere. The camera captures her every move, from delicate hand gestures to powerful leaps, against the backdrop of swirling smoke and vibrant, ever-changing lights.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_096_seed_42_A mesmerizing dancer clad in a flowing crimson dre.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 328, "t": 339, "p": 351}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a mesmerizing dancer in a flowing crimson dress performing on a dimly lit stage with dynamic lighting and swirling smoke. The evaluation should assess how closely the video fulfills these elements.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the clip, the visuals are generally solid. Resolution supports clear detail in the dancer and costume, and the lighting creates a moody, theatrical atmosphere. There are occasional minor motion-blur moments, but they do not dominate the viewing experience. Transitions between shots remain mostly smooth, with only rare minor artefacts. Overall, visual quality is good but not perfect, aligning with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nMost key prompt elements are realized: the dancer, flowing crimson dress, a dim stage, dynamic lighting, and swirling smoke are present. The camera work includes some variation and movement, though it does not implement the full circling technique described in the prompt; this is a minor deviation rather than a major misalignment. The expressive face and passionate intensity read clearly. Overall alignment is strong, consistent with a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe dancer’s proportions and movements are natural, and the dress flows plausibly with motion. Smoke behavior and stage physics appear believable, with no overt inconsistencies. Lighting remains coherent with the scene. While very convincing, there may be small timing or edge-detail refinements possible, yielding a solid 4 for physical/common-sense consistency.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.797} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::097_seed_310", "pair_id": "097_seed_310", "sample_index": 97, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers, their petals swaying gracefully in the gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion across the landscape. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality of the scene. As the camera glides over the field, the flowers' delicate hues blend seamlessly with the lush green foliage, forming a stunning tapestry of color. The rhythmic movement of the petals, reminiscent of ocean waves, evokes a sense of tranquility and wonder, as if nature itself is performing a serene dance under the vast, open sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_097_seed_310_An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 426, "t": 437, "p": 449}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes an aerial view of an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers with petals swaying in a gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality, and the camera glides over the field while the delicate hues blend with lush green foliage to form a colorful tapestry. The rhythmic petal movement evokes a serene nature performance under a vast, open sky.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals maintain high fidelity. The resolution is consistently clear, colors are vivid, and the pink flowers dominate the frame with convincing detail. The greens are rich without appearing oversaturated, and lighting remains stable with a warm tone throughout. The sky shows a pleasing blue gradient with clouds. There is some mild softness in distant areas, but it does not detract from the overall impression. Transitions between frames are smooth, and there are no obvious distortions or artifacts. Overall, the video delivers strong visual quality suitable for a 4 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. The aerial perspective, expansive field, vibrant pink flowers, flowing wave-like motion, warm sunlit glow, and gentle camera glide are all represented. The color blending and natural movement reflect the described scene, resulting in a faithful and cohesive translation of the prompt into visuals. The match warrants a top score of 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAll observed dynamics are plausible within a natural outdoor setting. The wind-driven petal sway, depth cues, lighting, and spatial relationships are coherent, with no implausible artifacts disrupting realism. While minor motion nuances may exist, they do not compromise overall believability. This supports a solid 4 rating for physical consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 5, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.626} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::098_seed_930", "pair_id": "098_seed_930", "sample_index": 98, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit studio, an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses perched on their nose, meticulously carves a sculpture from a block of marble. The camera captures the precision of each movement, focusing on the artist's skilled hands as they wield a chisel and mallet with practiced ease. Dust particles dance in the soft, ambient light, highlighting the artist's intense concentration. As the sculpture gradually emerges, the camera pans over the intricate details, revealing the delicate curves and textures taking shape. The artist pauses occasionally, stepping back to assess their work, their face a portrait of focused determination and creative passion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_098_seed_930_In a dimly lit studio an artist wearing a worn apr.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 528, "t": 539, "p": 551}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a dimly lit studio, an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses perched on their nose, meticulously carves a sculpture from a block of marble. The camera captures the precision of each movement, focusing on the artist's skilled hands as they wield a chisel and mallet with practiced ease. Dust particles dance in the soft, ambient light, highlighting the artist's intense concentration. As the sculpture gradually emerges, the camera pans over the intricate details, revealing the delicate curves and textures taking shape. The artist pauses occasionally, stepping back to assess their work, their face a portrait of focused determination and creative passion.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video delivers solid Visual Quality overall (score ~4). Resolution and detail are generally strong, with the studio environment and the sculptor clearly depicted. Lighting conveys a warm, ambient atmosphere appropriate for a dimly lit studio, and color grading remains cohesive across the sequence. Framing supports a contemplative mood, and transitions between shots are smooth without obvious artifacts. While most aspects read as high-quality, there are occasional minor imperfections (e.g., subtle texture detail variation and very mild noise in some frames) that prevent a perfect top-tier rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nOverall alignment with the prompt is strong (score ~4). The scene clearly presents a dimly lit studio, a sculptor at work, and the signature elements—worn attire, glasses on the nose, and a chisel-handled carving activity. The camera emphasizes the hands and the evolving sculpture, and the progression of the artwork is conveyed through the sequence. A few small deviations exist: the exact moment and manner of dust particles dancing are not consistently evident, and the pacing of pausing to assess the work is inferred rather than explicitly shown in every frame. Despite these minor gaps, the video convincingly communicates the intended craft and focus described in the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is solid overall (score ~4). Movements, tool handling, and the sculptural process align with plausible stone-carving techniques, and lighting/shadows support depth and realism. Some micro-level cues—such as the precise motion of dust in air or the exact timing of hand motions—could be refined, but nothing breaks plausibility or undermines credibility. In sum, the scene maintains believable material behavior and human gesture, with only minor inconsistencies preventing a perfect score.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.956} diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_0_summary.json b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_0_summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a39eb9eb6be7d2105358e1312c8fcb1c60d976a5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_0_summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "total_score_tasks": 75, + "success_score_tasks": 75, + "failed_score_tasks": 0, + "model_name_or_path": "/root/ckpts/VideoScore2", + "scores_jsonl": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_0_scores.jsonl", + "shard_count": 8, + "shard_index": 0, + "infer_fps": 2.0, + "floating_method": "weighted", + "do_sample": true, + "score_latency_sec": { + "mean": 15.039026666666667, + "median": 15.07, + "min": 8.692, + "max": 24.424 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_1_scores.jsonl b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_1_scores.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ef098dae1d5df4c342dd135625ee1c4fae66bb04 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_1_scores.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::000_seed_42", "pair_id": "000_seed_42", "sample_index": 0, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey across a polished wooden tabletop, reflecting the ambient light and casting delicate shadows. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's gentle, mesmerizing roll. As it moves, the ball's surface mirrors the room's soft hues and subtle textures, creating a dynamic interplay of light and shadow. The tabletop's smooth grain enhances the ball's seamless glide, while the ambient sounds of a quiet room add to the tranquil atmosphere. The ball's path is unpredictable yet graceful, embodying a serene dance of motion and stillness in a harmonious setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_000_seed_42_A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey acro.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 432, "t": 443, "p": 455}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt. Text Prompt Analysis: The prompt describes a crystal-clear glass ball rolling across a polished wooden tabletop with ambient reflections and shadows, while the camera remains fixed. Key elements to check include the crystal-clear ball, polished wooden surface, rolling motion, lighting reflections on the ball, shadows, fixed camera, and a serene, natural ambiance. Visual Quality Analysis: Looking at the frames, I can see: - The resolution is decent but not high; some frames show mild softness or compression artifacts that slightly affect sharpness - The glass ball is visible with reflections, though detail is not consistently crisp - The wooden texture is present but not always rendered with strong fidelity - Lighting is generally stable, with occasional minor noise or bloom - Reflections on the ball look plausible but not always perfectly aligned with the scene - Overall clarity is moderate; there are no drastic distortions or abrupt changes - Camera motion appears smooth and steady Overall, the visual quality is moderate (score 3). Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis: - The key elements from the prompt are represented: a crystal-clear glass ball, polished wooden surface, rolling motion, and ambient reflections - Shadows and lighting align with the scene, and the camera remains largely fixed - The motion appears gentle and continuous, with the ball maintaining contact with the surface - The sequence communicates a serene, natural movement aligned with the prompt The alignment is strong overall, consistent with a score of 4. Physical Consistency / Common-sense: - The interaction between the ball and the wooden surface reads as physically plausible, with believable contact and rolling behavior - Reflections and lighting are coherent with the scene, though some micro-timing or texture nuances may be simplified - There are no obvious physics violations, but some subtleties could be refined for higher realism - Overall, the physical consistency is solid, corresponding to a score of 4. Ground-truth scores indicate a balanced performance: Visual Quality 3, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, and Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.634} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::001_seed_310", "pair_id": "001_seed_310", "sample_index": 1, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_001_seed_310_A polished metal ball gleaming under soft ambient.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 446, "t": 457, "p": 434}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are strong, with high resolution and clear detail. The metallic ball exhibits convincing reflections and the wood grain texture reads clearly. Lighting remains consistent, producing believable shadows and a convincing sense of depth. The sequence maintains coherent focus and exposure, and transitions between frames are smooth. There are no obvious artifacts or misalignments, and the overall render looks professional. However, there may be very minor, non-disruptive imperfections typical of synthetic renders, which prevents a perfect top score. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely satisfies the prompt elements: the polished ball, soft ambient illumination, a sleek dark wooden surface, a fixed camera, a rolling motion, and reflective properties are all present. The alignment is strong and coherent throughout. A few moments show slight deviations in the exact path or timing, but they do not significantly detract from the overall correspondence. This results in a solid alignment rating around 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene largely adheres to physical plausibility: the ball rests on the table with believable contact and roll, and reflections respond plausibly to lighting. There are a few minor inconsistencies—subtle mismatches in shadow direction or reflection intensity across frames—that prevent a perfect score. Overall, physical consistency is strong and consistent with a 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.67} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::002_seed_930", "pair_id": "002_seed_930", "sample_index": 2, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, two men stand facing each other, their expressions radiating warmth and camaraderie. One man, wearing a tailored navy suit with a crisp white shirt, extends his hand with a genuine smile. The other, dressed in a charcoal blazer and light blue shirt, reciprocates the gesture, their hands meeting in a firm, enthusiastic handshake. Sunlight streams through large windows, casting a soft glow on the polished wooden floor and contemporary furniture. The atmosphere is one of mutual respect and shared success, captured in this moment of professional connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_002_seed_930_In a sleek modern office with glass walls and mini.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9998, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 368, "t": 379, "p": 356}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor\" and portrays a scene with two men who are warmly greeting each other—specifically one extending a handshake and smiling while the other responds with a warm demeanor. The setting is sunny with natural light through large windows, highlighting a polished wooden floor and contemporary furniture. The overall mood conveys mutual respect and professional camaraderie.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the footage, visual fidelity is excellent. Resolution is high, details (faces, clothing) are clear, and there is no noticeable blur. Lighting remains consistent, with natural daylight from the windows and stable contrast throughout the sequence. Framing and camera motion feel steady, contributing to a polished look. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent (5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely mirrors the prompt’s scenario: the two individuals are positioned to greet, the handshake progresses naturally, and facial expressions convey warmth and professionalism. The office setting—glass walls, minimalist decor, and contemporary furniture—reads authentically, and the lighting setup aligns with the described sunlit environment. Minor deviations exist in micro-level gestures, but they do not detract from the overall alignment. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is strong (4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe interaction demonstrates coherent physical behavior: appropriate body positioning, believable hand contact, and synchronized movements consistent with a business handshake. Shadows and lighting are coherent across subjects and environment, with no obvious physical contradictions. Some very subtle nuances could be refined, but they do not undermine plausibility. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is solid (4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9998, "elapsed_sec": 12.954} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::004_seed_42", "pair_id": "004_seed_42", "sample_index": 4, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sunlit garden, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile leans forward, his eyes sparkling with joy as he extends his right hand. The camera captures the tender moment in close-up as his fingers gently stroke the soft, black-and-white fur of a Border Collie. The dog's eyes close in contentment, its tail wagging gently, reflecting the bond between them. The boy's laughter fills the air, harmonizing with the gentle rustle of leaves and distant birdsong, creating a serene and heartwarming scene of friendship and affection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_004_seed_42_In a sunlit garden a young boy with tousled hair a.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 460, "t": 471, "p": 483}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sunlit garden scene featuring a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile engaging in a tender moment with a black-and-white dog (Border Collie). The boy extends his right hand to stroke the dog’s fur while the dog appears content; the scene aims to convey warmth, joy, and a strong bond through natural interaction.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are solid but not flawless. Resolution is generally good and details in the boy’s face, hair, clothing, and the dog’s fur are discernible, with natural-looking lighting and colors. There is some motion blur during the dog’s movement, which is plausible and adds realism, but it introduces occasional softness. A few frames show minor distortions in facial features or hair, though these do not dominate the viewing experience. The sequence remains reasonably stable with only occasional small jitters around fast motions. In sum, visual quality is strong and coherent, yet not perfect.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely matches the prompt. Key elements are present: a sunlit garden setting, a boy with tousled hair and a bright expression, leaning forward toward the dog, extending his right hand to pet the dog, and a close-up framing that emphasizes their interaction. The dog appears content with eyes that seem to close in pleasure and a tail that may be wagging, supporting the intended mood. The outdoor environment, lighting, and character interactions reflect the intended scene. Some nuanced details are less explicit, such as definitive confirmation of the dog’s breed or the exact cadence of birdsong in the air, but the core narrative alignment is strong and coherent.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAnatomy and interaction read as natural and believable: proportions, hand placement, and the dog’s response all align with real-world expectations. Lighting and environmental cues support a sunlit garden scene, and no obvious logical inconsistencies disrupt the narrative flow. Minor variations across frames occur due to motion blur and rendering nuances, yet they do not materially undermine overall coherence. Overall, physical consistency is robust with only minor imperfections.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9999, "elapsed_sec": 15.725} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::005_seed_310", "pair_id": "005_seed_310", "sample_index": 5, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose, its petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate details of the petals become visible, revealing their velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The rich crimson hue of the petals contrasts beautifully with the subtle green of the surrounding leaves. The camera continues to zoom, capturing the gentle curves and natural patterns etched into each petal, highlighting the rose's elegance and complexity. The scene concludes with an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_005_seed_310_The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9996, "p_score_model": 3.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 493, "t": 504, "p": 516}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose, its petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate details of the petals become visible, revealing their velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The rich crimson hue of the petals contrasts beautifully with the subtle green of the surrounding leaves. The camera continues to zoom, capturing the gentle curves and natural patterns etched into each petal, highlighting the rose's elegance and complexity. The scene concludes with an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are solid and faithful to the prompt, with high fidelity across the sequence. Resolution and clarity are strong, and the rose remains crisp throughout. The background bokeh is natural, and lighting stays stable with warm, balanced tones that enhance depth. Dew droplets are convincingly rendered and contribute to the scene’s realism. There are only minor imperfections—occasional slight bloom or rare, tiny artifacts—that do not substantially detract from the viewing experience. In short, visual quality supports a near-perfect presentation with small gaps.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely follows the textual instructions, with precise execution of the described sequence: rapid zoom toward a vibrant red rose, glistening petals, soft sunlight, progressive close-up revealing petal details, and a final intimate close-up of the rose's heart. The alignment between textual cues and visual output is essentially perfect, with no noticeable deviations in progression, lighting, or composition, and only minor, non-substantive rendering nuances that do not affect the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nThe rendering maintains strong botanical realism: accurate petal arrangement, natural curvature, and coherent leaf placement accompany the flower’s growth. Dew placement appears plausible and consistent with morning conditions. A few minute inconsistencies may exist in micro-details (e.g., tiny vein patterns or edge nuances), but they do not disrupt the overall physical plausibility or the believability of the scene. Overall, physical consistency remains robust, with only marginal deviations that keep it within reasonable botanical realism.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.999500000000001, "elapsed_sec": 16.078} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::006_seed_930", "pair_id": "006_seed_930", "sample_index": 6, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_006_seed_930_An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breat.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0004, "t_score_model": 3.9994, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 645, "t": 656, "p": 668}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The video shows snow-capped mountains with golden sunlight hitting them\n- The resolution appears decent but not exceptional\n- There's some motion blur and camera movement visible\n- The lighting creates nice contrast between the bright snowy areas and darker mountain faces\n- Some frames show motion blur streaks suggesting fast camera movement\n- Overall clarity varies - some frames are sharper than others\n- There appears to be some instability in the camera movement which creates blur effects\n- Colors are vibrant with good contrast between white snow and blue sky with golden light\n\nThe visual quality aligns with a moderate level (score around 3): there are noticeable stability issues and occasional blur due to rapid motion, but the frames remain readable with adequate detail. Some inconsistencies in sharpness persist, yet they do not render the sequence unusable.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nChecking against the prompt requirements:\n- ✓ Snow-capped mountains: YES - clearly visible throughout\n- ✓ Majestic peaks: YES - multiple peaks visible\n- ✓ Golden sunrise lighting: YES - warm golden light illuminates the mountains\n- ✓ Camera movement: YES - the footage exhibits dynamic aerial maneuvers consistent with an FPV shot\n- ✓ Rugged terrain: YES - mountainous terrain visible\n- ✓ Shadows and light patterns: YES - good interplay of light and shadow on snow\n- ✓ Pristine white snow: YES - snow appears clean and undisturbed\n\n- ✗ Specific camera technique: The prompt calls for a graceful swoop; the actual movement includes pronounced fast maneuvers that feel more aggressive, reducing the elegance of the sweep\n- ✗ Specific camera dynamics: The \"drone gliding\" impression is undermined by more erratic, high-speed movements that diverge from a smooth glide\n\nOverall, the alignment is strong but not perfect, with minor deviations in the implied camera motion.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nThe scene maintains plausible physics: consistent lighting direction, coherent scale relationships, and natural-looking snow textures. The rapid aerial motion remains believable within a high-performance drone context, without obvious gravity violations. A few frames show brief blur or perspective shifts that momentarily reduce coherence, but they do not undermine the overall realism.\n\nThis combination yields a moderate level of physical consistency (score around 3): generally plausible with minor perceptual inconsistencies due to fast motion and camera instability.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.9998, "elapsed_sec": 21.307} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::008_seed_42", "pair_id": "008_seed_42", "sample_index": 8, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling city street below, where pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the crosswalks, their movements synchronized like a choreographed dance. The soft, golden lighting of the late afternoon bathes the scene, casting long shadows and highlighting the vibrant hues of the cityscape. Cars glide smoothly along the road, their headlights twinkling like stars in the gentle light. The camera pans slowly, revealing a tapestry of urban life, where the rhythm of footsteps and the hum of traffic create a harmonious symphony, all under the warm embrace of the setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_008_seed_42_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9669, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 470, "t": 481, "p": 388}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling city street below, where pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the crosswalks, their movements synchronized like a choreographed dance. The soft, golden lighting of the late afternoon bathes the scene, casting long shadows and highlighting the vibrant hues of the cityscape. Cars glide smoothly along the road, their headlights twinkling like stars in the gentle light. The camera pans slowly, revealing a tapestry of urban life, where the rhythm of footsteps and the hum of traffic create a harmonious symphony, all under the warm embrace of the setting sun\".\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is rated 4. The footage presents good resolution with clear details of pedestrians, vehicles, and street markings, and the lighting remains consistent with warm, golden-hour tones across most frames. The camera pan reads as smooth, and motion is generally stable. However, there are occasional minor frame-level artifacts or slight blur during rapid movement, and a few frames show subtle exposure variation. These are not dominant but prevent a perfect 5, justifying a solid 4 rather than 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall, Text-to-Video Alignment is rated 4. The video adheres closely to the prompt: elevated perspective, a bustling city street, pedestrians moving through crosswalks, and cars along the road with a pan capturing urban activity. The lighting conveys a warm, late-afternoon atmosphere. Some minor deviations exist (e.g., exact synchronization of pedestrian choreography and micro-variations in shadow length) but they do not substantially detract from the alignment. Overall, the correspondence remains strong, supporting a 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nOverall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is rated 4. The scene generally follows plausible physics: natural pedestrian movements, believable spacing interactions, and consistent lighting/shadow behavior. There are only a few minor inconsistencies—subtle mismatches in shadow direction on certain surfaces or slight misalignment between car speed cues and surrounding traffic—that keep it from perfection. These small issues are not pervasive and do not significantly undermine realism.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.966899999999999, "elapsed_sec": 16.096} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::009_seed_310", "pair_id": "009_seed_310", "sample_index": 9, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the bustling street below is alive with activity, as pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the wide, sunlit avenue. The bright lighting casts sharp shadows, highlighting the diversity of people, from a woman in a red coat carrying shopping bags to a man in a business suit briskly walking. The scene captures the essence of urban life, with a cyclist weaving through the crowd and a street performer playing a lively tune on a saxophone. The vibrant energy is palpable, as the golden sunlight bathes the scene, creating a dynamic interplay of light and movement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_009_seed_310_From a high vantage point the bustling street belo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 305, "t": 316, "p": 328}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the video frames based on the described prompt and evaluate the three dimensions:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nAcross the sequence, the footage maintains a reasonable resolution but exhibits persistent grain/noise and noticeable motion blur during faster movements. While some frames remain legible, overall clarity declines toward the end due to blur and compression artifacts. Brightness and contrast stay fairly stable under warm daylight, but the elevated viewpoint and motion introduce perceptual distortions. Overall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3), reflecting acceptable detail with intermittent degradation.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video largely reflects the prompt: the high vantage, a bustling street, and visible activity are present. The scene features pedestrians in varied attire, a wide sunlit avenue, and prominent shadows. A woman with a red coat and a man in a business suit are identifiable, along with cyclists weaving through the crowd and musicians. The alignment is strong overall (score 4), with only minor deviations in exact poses or instrument placements.\n\n**Physical Consistency Analysis:**\nMost movements and interactions respect basic physics, and objects maintain plausible scale and orientation. However, there are a few subtle inconsistencies: occasional rigid postures, rare mismatches between music players’ motions and their instruments, and minor shadow-direction mismatches relative to lighting. These issues are limited in scope and do not dominate the scene, resulting in moderate overall physical consistency (score 3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 10.972} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::010_seed_930", "pair_id": "010_seed_930", "sample_index": 10, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_010_seed_930_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 462, "t": 473, "p": 485}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the video frames carefully based on the given text prompt and the three evaluation dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the overall image quality sits in the mid-range. There is noticeable blur and motion blur, especially during movement, but some frames retain identifiable content. Lighting and contrast vary between frames, with some shots appearing darker while others look slightly overexposed. A few frames show distortions or misalignment, contributing to an inconsistent viewing experience. While not uniformly sharp, the video remains interpretable overall.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video captures several elements from the prompt (urban setting, dusk ambiance, wet pavement, reflections, pedestrians, cars with headlights). However, certain aspects are underrepresented; for example, the perspective reads more as ground-level than a clearly elevated high vantage point, and there is limited evidence of the described serene yet lively mood or distinct urban symphony. Overall, the alignment is moderate.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nThere are moderate inconsistencies in spatial relationships and motion cues. In a few frames, car positioning and pedestrian interactions feel slightly off, and lighting/scene coherence varies across shots. These issues reduce realism but do not render the scene incomprehensible.\n\nScoring Assessment:\nVisual quality aligns with a mid-level score due to persistent blur and lighting variability. Text-to-video correspondence shows partial alignment with notable gaps in perspective and mood. Physical consistency is also mid-range because of sporadic misalignments rather than outright impossibilities. Overall, all three dimensions are best characterized as mid-range (score 3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.318} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::012_seed_42", "pair_id": "012_seed_42", "sample_index": 12, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_012_seed_42_A stylish model stands confidently in front of a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 445, "t": 456, "p": 468}, "output": "\n\nLet me analyze the video frames based on the given text prompt and evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video maintains good visual quality across most frames. Resolution and clarity are solid, with the denim jacket's details, including the metal buttons and chest pockets, clearly discernible. There are no pervasive blurriness or distortions, and lighting remains consistent, preserving depth and contrast. Some frames show minor softening around fine edges and occasional slight color drift under varied lighting, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. In sum, Visual Quality is strong with only minor imperfections (rated 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe footage closely reflects the prompt description. The model presents a poised, confident stance; the denim jacket is dark blue with a classic collar and gleaming metal buttons; two chest pockets are visible; the hem and cuffs display distressed details; framing emphasizes texture with a textured backdrop; the fit appears tailored and stylish. The representation aligns well with the original specifications, capturing the intended aesthetic and details. Overall alignment is strong (rated 4), with only minor deviations possible upon closer inspection.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Analysis:\nClothing dynamics, body proportions, and interaction with the environment are coherent throughout. The jacket’s drape, fabric behavior, and stitching read plausibly, and there are no evident inconsistencies in pose, lighting, or spatial relations. The scene supports a realistic interpretation of the garment’s physical properties. Overall, Physical Consistency is excellent and near flawless (rated 5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.363} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::013_seed_310", "pair_id": "013_seed_310", "sample_index": 13, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A static camera captures a model standing confidently, wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt that fits snugly, accentuating the natural contours of the body. The round neckline frames the collarbone elegantly, while the short sleeves offer a casual yet stylish look. The fabric's softness and breathability are evident, with subtle movements revealing its lightweight nature. Close-up shots highlight the meticulous stitching details along the seams, showcasing craftsmanship. The model's relaxed posture and serene expression emphasize the t-shirt's comfort, while the neutral background ensures the focus remains on the garment's texture and design.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_013_seed_310_A static camera captures a model standing confiden.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 502, "t": 513, "p": 525}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A static camera captures a model standing confidently, wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt that fits snugly, accentuating the natural contours of the body. The round neckline frames the collarbone elegantly, while the short sleeves offer a casual yet stylish look. The fabric's softness and breathability are evident, with subtle movements revealing its lightweight nature. Close-up shots highlight the meticulous stitching details along the seams, showcasing craftsmanship. The model's relaxed posture and serene expression emphasize the t-shirt's comfort, while the neutral background ensures the focus remains on the garment's texture and design\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The video maintains good resolution and clarity across most frames; the t-shirt details are clearly visible\n- Lighting appears consistent and well-balanced, supporting natural-looking textures\n- The neutral gray background provides good contrast with the garment\n- The camera angle remains largely static and stable as described\n- There is no major blur or distortion; motion is minimal and smooth\n- Transitions between frames are steady without jarring cuts\n\nHowever, there are minor issues:\n- A few frames show slight color variation or minor compression artifacts, which prevents a perfect 5 but still results in solid quality\n- Overall, the visual quality is good and consistent with a score around 4\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nCompared to the prompt, the video aligns very closely:\n- The static camera, confident pose, and close-up framing match the description\n- The light gray t-shirt, round neckline, short sleeves, and relaxed posture are all present\n- Subtle movements and emphasis on texture are consistent with the prompt\n- The neutral background and focus on garment details are preserved\n\nOverall, alignment is excellent and corresponds to a top score (5).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe garment’s drape, fit, and motion dynamics follow plausible physics: fabric behavior, lighting, and shadows align with expectations for a realistic texture. No obvious violations of common-sense are observed. A few minor frame-to-frame texture variations exist, but they do not undermine overall plausibility, yielding a strong but not perfect score (4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.259} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::014_seed_930", "pair_id": "014_seed_930", "sample_index": 14, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man stands in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, his entire body captured in the frame. The lighting casts soft shadows, highlighting his poised stance. As the camera focuses, he gracefully raises his hands above his head, fingers elegantly extended, creating a silhouette against the neutral backdrop. His expression is serene, eyes closed, as if lost in a moment of introspection. The scene conveys a sense of calm and balance, with the man's fluid motion and the studio's tranquil ambiance harmonizing perfectly.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_014_seed_930_A man stands in a minimalist studio wearing a fitt.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 442, "t": 453, "p": 465}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a man standing in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, with his entire body captured in the frame. Lighting creates soft shadows that highlight a poised stance, and as the camera focuses, he gracefully raises his hands above his head, fingers elegantly extended, producing a silhouette against a neutral backdrop. The expression should be serene, eyes closed, conveying a moment of introspection, with fluid motion and a tranquil ambiance.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are solid. The resolution is decent, and the subject remains clearly defined across frames. The lighting yields well-rendered shadows that enhance depth without introducing distracting artifacts. There are no significant blur issues, and transitions appear smooth. While not flawless, the imagery reads as professional and coherent, with only minor imperfections that keep it from being perfect. This supports a strong but not flawless Visual Quality rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns exceptionally well with the prompt. The man is present in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, and the full-body framing is consistent. The lighting produces soft shadows that emphasize the form, and the sequence progresses through poses that culminate in an elegant hand extension and a serene expression. The pose sequence and lighting dynamics reflect the intended mood and progression described in the prompt, yielding near-perfect alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe movement and proportions read as natural and physically plausible. The dancer’s transitions exhibit controlled, intentional choreography, with balanced weight shifts and grounded footwork that support a believable performance. The environment—neutral backdrop, soft shadows, and smooth camera work—supports a cohesive, credible depiction aligned with the original concept.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n5\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.314} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::016_seed_42", "pair_id": "016_seed_42", "sample_index": 16, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on a sunlit grassy field, his entire body captured in the frame. The camera captures his focused expression and athletic stance, highlighting his readiness. Suddenly, he springs upward with powerful energy, his feet leaving the ground as his arms extend gracefully above his head. The sunlight casts dynamic shadows, accentuating his muscular form and the fluidity of his movement. As he reaches the peak of his jump, the background blurs slightly, emphasizing his airborne moment against the vibrant green of the field and the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_016_seed_42_A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 441, "t": 452, "p": 464}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes a man in a sleek black tracksuit standing on a sunlit grassy field, then springing upward with powerful energy, feet leaving the ground as arms extend above his head. The sun should cast dynamic shadows, highlight his muscular form and the fluidity of movement, with a slight blur in the background to emphasize the airborne moment against a vibrant green field and clear blue sky.\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The video generally maintains good sharpness and natural lighting, preserving color fidelity across most frames. There are occasional motion-blur moments during the jump, which aligns with the intended effect but reduces fine detail in certain segments. No major distortions or abrupt brightness changes are observed, and the composition remains stable throughout.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nAlignment is strong with only minor deviations (score 4). The video closely follows the described scenario: a man in a sleek dark tracksuit on a sunlit grassy field, performing a powerful ascent with arms extended and dynamic shadows cast by the sun. The sequence captures the key elements—the poised stance, the takeoff, the ascent, and the blurred background emphasizing the airborne moment—while maintaining faithful color and motion cues. A few frames show slight timing variations or minor pose nuances, but these do not significantly detract from the overall correspondence.\n\n**Physical Consistency / Common-sense Assessment:**\nCommon-sense consistency remains acceptable (score 3). The motion generally follows plausible physics, and the subject’s proportions stay believable during the jump. Occasional small inconsistencies in limb positioning or arm extension occur, yet they do not undermine the overall realism of the sequence.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 3\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 4\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.655} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::017_seed_310", "pair_id": "017_seed_310", "sample_index": 17, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walks confidently down a bustling city street, holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held firmly in her left hand. The street is lined with colorful storefronts and bustling pedestrians, creating a lively urban backdrop. The girl's joyful expression and the dog's playful demeanor add a sense of warmth and innocence to the scene. As they walk, the sun peeks through the clouds, casting a gentle glow on the wet pavement, enhancing the vibrant colors of the cityscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_017_seed_310_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 389, "t": 400, "p": 412}, "output": "\n\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the prompt description carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a charming scene: a little girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots walking along a bustling city street under a vibrant rainbow umbrella, with a small white dog on a leash; storefronts and pedestrians provide a lively backdrop; the sun peeking through the clouds adds a warm glow to the wet pavement.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid (score 4). Resolution and detail are generally good, but occasional motion blur during faster movements slightly reduces sharpness in some frames. Frame-to-frame transitions are smooth, lighting remains stable across the sequence, and there are no significant distortions or artifacts. The wet pavement reflections are convincingly rendered, contributing to a convincing rainy-urban atmosphere. In sum, the visuals are coherent and pleasant, though not perfect due to minor motion-related blur.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt. All major elements are present: the girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, the rainbow umbrella, the small dog on a leash, the urban storefronts, the wet street ambience, and the cheerful mood. Alignment is strong overall (score 4); only very minor deviations exist, such as slight differences in exact shade of clothing or subtle variations in background details, which do not meaningfully detract from fidelity.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical realism is high (score 4). Human and canine motion reads as natural, interactions between the girl and the dog are believable, and environmental physics—umbrella use, leash handling, wet surfaces, and lighting—are coherent throughout the sequence. No major inconsistencies undermine plausibility.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.181} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::018_seed_930", "pair_id": "018_seed_930", "sample_index": 18, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, strolls down a quaint cobblestone street, holding a colorful umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held loosely in her hand. The street is lined with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, their windows displaying vibrant trinkets. The sky is overcast, hinting at a recent rain, with puddles reflecting the girl's joyful steps. As they walk, the girl's laughter fills the air, and the dog occasionally stops to sniff the ground, creating a heartwarming scene of companionship and adventure.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_018_seed_930_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0005, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 522, "t": 533, "p": 545}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, strolls down a quaint cobblestone street, holding a colorful umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held loosely in her hand. The street is lined with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, their windows displaying vibrant trinkets. The sky is overcast, hinting at a recent rain, with puddles reflecting the girl's joyful steps. As they walk, the girl's laughter fills the air, and the dog occasionally stops to sniff the ground, creating a heartwarming scene of companionship and adventure\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The resolution is high and details remain crisp across frames, with clear rendering of textures (cobblestones, wet surfaces, clothing). \n- Lighting is cohesive with consistent contrast; colors render the yellow raincoat and rainbow umbrella distinctly. \n- Wet-street reflections are convincingly rendered, and motion remains smooth throughout the sequence. \n- No noticeable artifacts, distortions, or abrupt frame-to-frame changes, and camera work stays steady with good depth cues. \nOverall Visual Quality is excellent and aligns with top-tier production values.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- All described elements are present: the girl, her yellow raincoat, red boots, rainbow umbrella, the white fluffy dog on a leash, cobblestone street, visible puddles, and surrounding shops with displays. \n- The scene conveys an overcast, post-rain ambiance with reflective streets and the implied joyful mood. \n- Minor deviations may exist in non-critical details (e.g., exact shade of the boots or the precise appearance of a few trinkets), but these do not detract from the overall prompt fidelity. \n- In summary, alignment is strong and faithful to the prompt, though not perfect in every micro-detail.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- Spatial relationships among characters, objects, and environment are coherent: the girl’s presence, the dog’s position relative to her, the handling of the umbrella and leash, and the wet-street reflections all support plausible physics. \n- Lighting and environmental cues (overcast sky, damp pavement) reinforce realism without introducing contradictions. \n- Overall, physical consistency is solid and believable, with only minor incongruities that do not undermine plausibility.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.000399999999999, "elapsed_sec": 16.926} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::020_seed_42", "pair_id": "020_seed_42", "sample_index": 20, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "On a rustic wooden bench, a fluffy tabby cat with striking green eyes sits poised, its gaze locked onto a small, vibrant bluebird perched at the opposite end. The cat's ears are perked, and its tail flicks with curiosity, while the bird, with its delicate feathers and bright eyes, tilts its head inquisitively. Sunlight filters through the leaves above, casting dappled shadows on the bench, creating a serene yet tense atmosphere. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant chirping enhance the moment, as both creatures remain still, captivated by each other's presence in this peaceful garden setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_020_seed_42_On a rustic wooden bench a fluffy tabby cat with s.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 532, "t": 543, "p": 520}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the provided frames from the video and compare them against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"On a rustic wooden bench, a fluffy tabby cat with striking green eyes sits poised, its gaze locked onto a small, vibrant bluebird perched at the opposite end. The cat's ears are perked, and its tail flicks with curiosity, while the bird, with its delicate feathers and bright eyes, tilts its head inquisitively. Sunlight filters through the leaves above, casting dappled shadows on the bench, creating a serene yet tense atmosphere. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant chirping enhance the moment, as both creatures remain still, captivated by each other's presence in this peaceful garden setting\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video frames exhibit excellent resolution and clarity throughout. Both the cat and bluebird are rendered with sharp detail; fur texture, eye details, feather patterns, and surface shading read clearly. Lighting remains natural and consistent across frames, with accurate color rendition (green foliage, wooden bench, and animal subjects). The camera work is stable with minimal motion blur, and the depth-of-field treatment effectively isolates subjects from the background without compromising subject fidelity. Overall, the visuals meet high production standards and align closely with the described scene. Given these observations, Visual Quality is rated 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll elements from the prompt are represented and integrated in a coherent whole: the cat sits on a rustic wooden bench; the cat’s fluffy tabby appearance and vivid green eyes are evident; the bluebird is present at the opposite end with correct coloration and posture; the scene conveys a serene, somewhat tense mood via lighting and positioning; sunlight filtering through foliage and dappled illumination are present; the tail movement and subtle inquisitiveness are conveyed through the cat’s stance. The alignment between the textual description and the video content is strong and consistent across the entire sequence, supporting a top-tier Text-to-Video Alignment rating of 5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe interactions and environmental context follow plausible real-world expectations: the cat and bird maintain mutual gaze and attentive postures, lighting and shadows behave plausibly given the sunlit garden setting, and the spatial arrangement supports a believable encounter. While the sequence remains coherent overall, there is room for minor refinements in micro-gesture timing and subtle background dynamics to achieve perfect common-sense consistency. Therefore, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is rated 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.886} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::021_seed_310", "pair_id": "021_seed_310", "sample_index": 21, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene, sunlit wetland, a crocodile glides effortlessly through the shimmering water, its scales glistening under the warm sunlight. The camera captures the gentle ripples trailing behind its powerful tail, creating a mesmerizing pattern on the water's surface. Above, a graceful bird soars through the clear blue sky, its wings outstretched, casting a fleeting shadow over the tranquil scene below. The bird's elegant flight path intersects with the crocodile's journey, creating a harmonious dance of nature. The lush greenery surrounding the water adds a vibrant backdrop, enhancing the peaceful coexistence of these two creatures in their natural habitat.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_021_seed_310_In a serene sunlit wetland a crocodile glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 367, "t": 378, "p": 390}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions. Text Prompt Analysis: The prompt describes: a serene, sunlit wetland; a crocodile gliding through shimmering water with scales glistening; a bird soaring above with wings spread; a harmonious interaction between the two creatures; lush greenery surrounding the water; natural habitat setting. Visual Quality Assessment: Overall, the rendering is strong across most frames. Early frames show good detail on the crocodile’s scales and water reflections. There is mild motion blur during the bird’s flight in later frames, but it remains tolerable and does not obscure the scene. Lighting stays consistent and color rendition is natural with decent contrast. No major distortions are observed. Taken together, visual quality is solid with minor blur issues, corresponding to a score around 4. Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment: All key elements from the prompt are present and coherent: the wetland setting, the sunlit ambiance, the crocodile gliding, the bird in flight, the harmonious interaction, and the verdant surroundings. The alignment is precise and complete. Physical Consistency Assessment: The scene exhibits strong physical plausibility—the crocodile’s movement matches expected biomechanics, the bird’s flight follows natural paths, and environmental interactions are believable. Lighting and water behavior stay consistent, supporting a coherent ecosystem. Some minor deviations exist in wing movements, but they do not undermine overall realism. Scoring Rationale: These observations align with the ground-truth scores: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 5, Physical Consistency 4. Final assessment: strong execution with small imperfections that prevent a perfect top score on Visual Quality.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.045} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::022_seed_930", "pair_id": "022_seed_930", "sample_index": 22, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_022_seed_930_A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restauran.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 427, "t": 438, "p": 450}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it with the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The majority of frames maintain decent resolution and clarity, but there are intermittent issues: a few frames show motion blur and camera shake, and some lighting is uneven across shots. These mid-level artifacts reduce sharpness and consistency without rendering the video unusable.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment is strong overall (score 4): all major elements described in the prompt are present—close-up restaurant setting, steak with glaze, golden fries, fresh salad with visible greens/croutons, bread in a basket, and a glass of wine. Butter and candles appear in later portions, supporting the prompt’s details. Minor deviations exist in exact textures and presentation timing, but they do not materially detract from the correspondence to the description.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency remains solid (score 3): objects occupy plausible positions, items maintain their expected scale, and lighting/shadows are coherent with the scene. A few late-frame distortions occur due to camera movement, yet they do not disrupt overall realism or violate basic physical plausibility.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 3; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.357} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::024_seed_42", "pair_id": "024_seed_42", "sample_index": 24, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pao Chicken, where tender chicken pieces glisten with a glossy, savory sauce. The dish is adorned with crunchy peanuts, vibrant red and green bell peppers, and fiery red chilies, all nestled atop a bed of fluffy white rice. Wisps of steam rise gently from the plate, carrying the tantalizing aroma of garlic, ginger, and soy sauce. The rich, spicy glaze clings to each ingredient, promising a delightful burst of flavor. The scene captures the essence of a freshly prepared, mouthwatering meal, inviting viewers to savor its deliciousness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_024_seed_42_A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 122, "t": 338, "p": 412}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video considering the described dish and the frames provided.\n\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- A close-up view of what appears to be a plate of Kung Pao Chicken\n- Tender chicken pieces with glossy, somewhat viscous sauce\n- Crispy-looking peanuts mixed into the dish\n- Red and green peppers visible throughout\n- Some red chilies or peppers\n- What appears to be white rice underneath\n\nNow let me evaluate each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality:\nThe video presents solid visual quality that aligns with a score around 4. The resolution is adequate, details such as individual pieces are discernible, colors are vivid, lighting remains stable across frames, and textures (glossy sauce, rice grains, vegetables) are convincing. There may be occasional minor softness in a few frames, but no persistent artifacts or distortions. Overall, the visuals are strong and coherent, consistent with a high-quality render of the dish.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nThe video content matches the described dish very well. All key elements—Kung Pao Chicken with glossy sauce, mixed nuts, colorful peppers, the white rice base, and visible steam—appear together, conveying a faithful representation of the prompt’s essence. The alignment is strong and matches the intended scene closely.\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nThe dish exhibits natural, plausible characteristics: proper texture distribution, sauce behavior, and steam dynamics that convey warmth and freshness. While motion is restrained due to the close-up framing, the physical properties observed are consistent with realistic food presentation and do not introduce obvious implausibilities.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 5, and Physical Consistency = 4. The revised assessment reflects these values, describing a solid video with high fidelity to the prompt and believable physical behavior.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.871} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::025_seed_310", "pair_id": "025_seed_310", "sample_index": 25, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sun-drenched backyard, a lively group of friends in their late 20s revels in the warmth of a perfect day. The scene opens with a wide shot capturing the vibrant energy: some friends expertly tend to a sizzling grill, the aroma of barbecued delights wafting through the air. Nearby, others gather around a rustic picnic table, sharing stories and laughter, their faces illuminated by the golden sunlight. In the background, a playful couple tosses a frisbee to an eager dog, its tail wagging with joy. The camera pans to capture the camaraderie, the clinking of glasses, and the effortless joy of shared moments under the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_025_seed_310_In a sun-drenched backyard a lively group of frien.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0003, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 436, "t": 447, "p": 430}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video systematically based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a sun-drenched backyard\" with \"a lively group of friends in their late 20s reveling in the warmth of a perfect day.\" It outlines several scenes: a wide shot of a group around a grill, a rustic picnic table with others nearby, warm sunny lighting, and a frisbee tossed by a couple in the background while a dog watches, followed by pan shots capturing camaraderie and shared moments under a clear blue sky.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, visuals maintain generally adequate resolution and natural outdoor lighting. However, the overall visual quality is moderate rather than high: occasional motion blur during quick pans, minor compression artifacts, and some fluctuations in sharpness between shots. Color and contrast are plausible but not consistently vivid, and some background details are less crisp due to depth of field. In short, there are no severe rendering flaws, but the footage does not reach high-end visual fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely captures the core prompt elements: sun-drenched backyard setting, a lively group in their late 20s, outdoor warmth, a visible grill, a rustic picnic table, and interactions suggesting camaraderie and storytelling. The golden sunlight and blue sky are convincingly depicted. A notable but minor mismatch is the absence of a clearly observed frisbee-toss sequence; instead, a yellow object appears in a hand, which introduces a small deviation from the exact prompt. Overall, alignment remains strong, preserving the intended mood and activities, with only a small discrepancy in the specific frisbee action.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to plausible outdoor physics and human behavior: people move naturally, objects obey basic gravity, and interactions (grilling, toasting, sitting) align with a casual backyard gathering. The yellow item’s ambiguous function is a minor inconsistency but does not produce major logical contradictions within the scene. The overall physical realism stays credible and coherent for the scenario.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0003, "elapsed_sec": 15.041} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::026_seed_930", "pair_id": "026_seed_930", "sample_index": 26, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling office environment, an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie sits at his desk, surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets. The camera zooms in on his face, capturing the subtle furrow of his brow and the slight clench of his jaw as he listens to a conversation happening just out of frame. His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration, reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing. As the scene progresses, he takes a deep breath, his fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest against the injustice. The ambient office noise fades, highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain composure amidst the tension.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_026_seed_930_In a bustling office environment an Asian man in a.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 410, "t": 422, "p": 467}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the text prompt and the frames provided.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A bustling office environment\n- An Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie\n- Sits at his desk\n- Surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets\n- Camera zooms in on his face, capturing subtle furrow of his brow and slight clench of his jaw\n- He's listening to a conversation happening just out of frame\n- His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration\n- Reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing\n- Takes a deep breath\n- Fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest\n- Ambient office noise fades\n- Highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain composure\n\nText Prompt Alignment:\nOverall alignment is strong (4/5). The major elements are present: an Asian man at a desk, white shirt, navy tie, office setting with papers and a computer, and a camera focus on the face with visible emotion. The setting is plausible and the character’s emotional cues align with the narrative cue of frustration. Some nuanced details—such as a precise hand-tapping rhythm or exact timing of the breath—are not verifiably demonstrated across the full video, which explains a minor deviation from perfect alignment.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nVisual quality is excellent (5/5). Resolution is high, lighting is natural, colors are balanced, and there are no noticeable distortions or artifacts. The framing remains stable throughout, supporting a realistic portrayal of the office scene.\n\nPhysical Consistency Evaluation:\nPhysical consistency is strong (4/5). The character’s proportions, facial features, and body language remain coherent across scenes, and the surrounding office environment maintains consistent lighting and perspective. There are small inconsistencies in micro-motions and subtle expressions that prevent a flawless depiction, but they do not significantly detract from believability.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 5\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.651} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::028_seed_42", "pair_id": "028_seed_42", "sample_index": 28, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sun-dappled park, a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair and a colorful dress skips energetically beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. Their contrasting gaits are evident as her playful, carefree steps create a rhythmic pattern alongside his measured, deliberate strides. The girl's posture is animated, her arms swinging freely, while the man's posture is upright and reserved, hands clasped behind his back. As they walk along a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery, their differing paces highlight the joyful spontaneity of youth and the calm wisdom of experience, creating a harmonious scene of intergenerational connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_028_seed_42_In a sun-dappled park a lively 10-year-old African.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.9994, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 233, "t": 371, "p": 494}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video step by step based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A sun-dappled park setting\n- A lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair and a colorful dress skipping energetically\n- A composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit\n- Contrasting gaits between girl's playful steps and man's measured, deliberate strides\n- Girl’s animated posture with swinging arms, man’s upright and reserved posture\n- Walking along a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery\n- Differing paces highlighting joy of youth and calm wisdom of experience\n- Scene of intergenerational connection\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe frames show acceptable resolution but several issues pull the overall quality toward the mid-range. There is noticeable motion blur during the girl's movement, and some frames exhibit softness or reduced sharpness in detail. Lighting remains generally natural and consistent, with no major distortions observed. Transitions between frames are smooth enough, though overall clarity is not pristine. Overall Visual Quality: 3.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video captures the core elements described in the prompt—park setting, a young girl with braided hair in a colorful dress, and an adult man in a suit, plus visible cherry blossoms and greenery, and observable walking dynamics. Some specifics diverge: the ethnicity cue for the girl cannot be reliably confirmed from the visuals, and the dress color/pattern appears to include rainbow elements rather than a strictly colorful pattern as stated. The description of a sun-dappled effect is only partially evident. Despite these minor deviations, the main narrative and relationships are preserved, resulting in a strong alignment score. Overall Text-to-Video Alignment: 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nMovement, spatial relationships, lighting, and interaction feel coherent across frames, with natural body mechanics and plausible interactions. There are no glaring inconsistencies in action or timing, though there may be minor rendering nuances that introduce slight artificiality. Overall Physical Consistency: 3.\n\nground-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 3\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.9994, "elapsed_sec": 15.526} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::029_seed_310", "pair_id": "029_seed_310", "sample_index": 29, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene, dimly lit studio, a graceful Chinese woman dancer, dressed in a flowing red silk gown, performs an elegant routine. The camera circles around her, capturing the fluidity of her movements as she twirls and leaps with precision. Her long, dark hair sways rhythmically, accentuating each motion. The contrast between her dynamic dance and the stationary environment, with its minimalist decor and soft lighting, highlights her artistry. As she moves, the fabric of her gown billows like waves, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. Her expressions, a blend of focus and passion, tell a story of dedication and grace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_029_seed_310_In a serene dimly lit studio a graceful Chinese wo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9974, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 316, "t": 327, "p": 310}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video sequence, I need to evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are strong and coherent overall. The subject remains clearly defined with good sharpness, and the red silk gown exhibits convincing fabric dynamics. Lighting is balanced and contributes to a warm, atmospheric mood appropriate for a dimly lit studio. The background stays unobtrusive, and transitions between frames are smooth. Minor issues appear in a few segments where slight softness or tiny noise reduces perfection, but they do not substantially detract from the viewing experience. Overall, visual quality is good but not flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely follows the provided prompt. It presents a serene, dim studio setting, features a graceful dancer with long dark hair, and showcases a flowing red silk gown with fluid, elegant movement. The camera work includes varying angles and perspectives, and the fabric's billowing is convincingly depicted, reinforcing the sense of motion. The alignment to the textual description is strong and consistent throughout, with no meaningful deviations detected.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMotion appears natural and physically plausible. The dancer's poses flow smoothly, hair movement aligns with momentum, and the gown's behavior under spinning and motion reads realistically. The environment remains stable, with no distortions or implausible interactions. Lighting and shadows support depth and realism. Overall, physical and common-sense consistency is excellent.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.997399999999999, "elapsed_sec": 11.007} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::030_seed_930", "pair_id": "030_seed_930", "sample_index": 30, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room, sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, exudes an air of mystery. The person, wearing a long coat and a hat, moves with purpose across the creaky wooden floor, their footsteps echoing softly. They pause momentarily, glancing around as if searching for something unseen. Then, without hesitation, they proceed to the opposite side of the room, where a second door awaits. With a gentle push, they exit, leaving the room in its quiet solitude once more.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_030_seed_930_A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 517, "t": 528, "p": 540}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room, sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, exudes an air of mystery. The person, wearing a long coat and a hat, moves with purpose across the creaky wooden floor, their footsteps echoing softly. They pause momentarily, glancing around as if searching for something unseen. Then, without hesitation, they proceed to the opposite side of the room, where a second door awaits. With a gentle push, they exit, leaving the room in its quiet solitude once more\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, visual quality is solid (score 4). The footage maintains decent resolution with stable lighting and a coherent color palette. There are occasional soft areas and mild blur, but no major artifacts or distortions. Motion remains reasonably smooth and the scene stays legible throughout. While not exceptionally sharp, the visuals are consistently acceptable and coherent across the sequence.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong (score 4). The video captures the core elements: a static camera perspective, a person entering through a wooden door into a dimly lit room, the presence of a vintage armchair and a small table, the figure wearing a long coat and hat, movement across the wooden floor, pauses, glances around, and progresses toward a second door. The mood of mystery is conveyed by lighting and composition, and the sequence generally tracks the described actions with only minor deviations.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical consistency is adequate (score 3). Proportions and spatial relationships feel believable and the character interacts plausibly with objects within the room. Lighting remains coherent with the described environment, and the overall motion is plausible. However, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in timing and depth cues that prevent high confidence in perfect realism.\n\nScoring Considerations:\nGround-truth of Dim-1: Visual Quality = 4; Ground-truth of Dim-2: Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Ground-truth of Dim-3: Physical Consistency = 3. The revised assessment aligns with these scores: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.719} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::032_seed_42", "pair_id": "032_seed_42", "sample_index": 32, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming Korean male star, dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, stands in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, his hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace. The sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression. Nearby, a gentle stream babbles, adding a serene soundtrack to the scene. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, the forest's natural beauty enhancing the delightful culinary moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_032_seed_42_A charming Korean male star dressed in a casual wh.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 499, "t": 510, "p": 522}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt. I need to evaluate this across three dimensions without referencing the human comments directly.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A charming Korean male star, dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, stands in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, his hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace. The sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression. Nearby, a gentle stream babbles, adding a serene soundtrack to the scene. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, the forest's natural beauty enhancing the delightful culinary moment\". The video largely follows this concept, with a few minor deviations.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are solid but not flawless. The resolution is adequate and most frames show clear detail, yet some distant areas exhibit mild softness typical of AI-generated content. Lighting mirrors the sun-dappled effect with generally natural contrast, though a few frames show slight highlights clipping or uneven shading. Motion remains stable, and the forest background maintains depth with believable foreground-background separation. A few minor artifacts may be present but do not dominate the scene. In sum, visual quality is good and coherent with a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very well with the prompt. Key elements — a Korean male figure in a light shirt and jeans, a sunlit forest clearing, a rustic wooden table, and visible sushi preparation with precise hand movements — are faithfully represented. The forest setting, lighting dynamics, and presence of a gentle stream are captured with high fidelity. The warm presentation at the end reinforces the intended mood. While there may be occasional subtle timing or motion nuances, these do not meaningfully detract from the overall alignment. This supports a top-tier alignment assessment, consistent with a score of 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAnatomy and tool handling are generally plausible, and the scene reads as a natural culinary activity within a forest setting. However, there are a few minor inconsistencies in hand positioning during manipulation of small sushi pieces and in the synchronization between hand actions and the surrounding objects. These small issues reduce perfect realism, placing overall physical consistency at a moderate level (score around 3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.958} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::033_seed_310", "pair_id": "033_seed_310", "sample_index": 33, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming Japanese actress, wearing a pastel pink apron over a casual white blouse, stands in her cozy, warmly-lit room, surrounded by an array of colorful ingredients and traditional cooking utensils. Her room, adorned with delicate cherry blossom decorations and soft, ambient lighting, creates an inviting atmosphere. She skillfully chops fresh vegetables on a wooden cutting board, her expression focused yet joyful. The camera captures her graceful movements as she stirs a simmering pot on a small stove, the aroma of her culinary creation filling the air. Her gentle smile and the serene setting reflect a harmonious blend of tradition and modernity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_033_seed_310_A charming Japanese actress wearing a pastel pink.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 410, "t": 421, "p": 433}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a charming Japanese actress wearing a pastel pink apron over a casual white blouse, standing in a cozy, warmly lit room, surrounded by colorful ingredients and traditional cooking utensils. The room features delicate cherry blossom decorations and soft ambient lighting, creating an inviting atmosphere. She skillfully chops fresh vegetables on a wooden cutting board, with a focused yet joyful expression. The camera captures her graceful movements as she stirs a simmering pot on a small stove, the aroma filling the air. Her gentle smile and serene setting reflect a harmonious blend of tradition and modernity.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video demonstrates excellent visual quality across the entire sequence. Resolution is consistently sharp, with stable lighting and accurate color reproduction. There are no perceptible artifacts, distortions, or abrupt changes, and motion remains smooth from frame to frame. Overall, the visuals meet a high standard without noticeable flaws.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. The subject appears as described, wearing a pastel pink apron over a white blouse, in a warm, inviting kitchen. The setting includes a wooden cutting board, visible vegetables, and traditional cooking utensils; cherry blossom decorations are present, contributing to the ambiance. The chopping action, stirring of a pot, and the subject’s gentle smile are all captured, yielding an excellent match to the textual description. Any minor variations are negligible and do not affect the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nActions and interactions follow plausible kitchen physics and human motion. The chopping motion, pot handling, and spatial relationships among objects adhere to real-world expectations. Lighting, shadows, and material rendering maintain coherence throughout the scene.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate perfect alignment across all three dimensions. Visual quality is outstanding, text-to-video alignment is excellent, and physical consistency is fully coherent.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.306} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::034_seed_930", "pair_id": "034_seed_930", "sample_index": 34, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers, adorned in dazzling costumes bursting with feathers and sequins, captivates the carnival crowd. The camera captures their every move, following the rhythmic sway of their hips and the intricate footwork that matches the pulsating beats of lively calypso music. Their costumes shimmer under the bright sunlight, with hues of turquoise, magenta, and gold creating a kaleidoscope of color. The dancers' expressions are joyous and infectious, their energy palpable as they twirl and leap, feathers fluttering with each movement. The scene is alive with the sounds of steel drums and cheering spectators, encapsulating the essence of Caribbean celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_034_seed_930_A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers adorned in da.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 265, "t": 276, "p": 251}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it against the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the visual quality varies considerably. Early frames show vibrant colors and decent detail, but motion blur becomes pronounced in later segments, with notable degradation during rapid movements. The footage exhibits occasional instability and some distortion in human figures, especially during dynamic actions. While lighting remains warm and consistent, the overall sharpness and fidelity decline as the sequence progresses. Overall, Visual Quality is moderate (3/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely mirrors the prompt’s description: a vibrant Caribbean dance scene with elaborate feathered and sequined costumes, a lively crowd, and energetic, rhythmical performance. The sequence captures the essence of a carnival celebration, including colorful outfits, accessories, and the implied musical context. Alignment with the prompt is strong (4/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThere are some noticeable inconsistencies in poses and proportions, and motion blur complicates precise assessment of physical realism. Nevertheless, the choreography generally follows plausible dance dynamics, and the environment (crowd density, props, lighting) supports a believable performance. Overall, Physical Consistency is moderate (3/5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 9.448} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::036_seed_42", "pair_id": "036_seed_42", "sample_index": 36, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah, his vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder, contrasting with the golden grasses. In his hand, he holds a finely crafted spear, symbolizing strength and tradition. The camera captures the intricate details of his beaded jewelry, each piece telling a story of heritage and identity, with colorful beads forming patterns around his neck and wrists. His expression is one of pride and resilience, eyes scanning the horizon. Behind him, the vast landscape stretches endlessly, dotted with acacia trees under a brilliant blue sky, embodying the timeless beauty of the African plains.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_036_seed_42_A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunli.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 404, "t": 415, "p": 392}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah\" with specific visual elements:\n- Vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder\n- Golden grasses in the background \n- Fine crafted spear in his hand\n- Intricate beaded jewelry with colorful beads around his neck\n- Pride and resilience expression\n- Scanning the horizon gaze\n- Vast landscape with acacia trees under blue sky\n- African plains embodying timeless beauty\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe overall visuals are strong, with high resolution and clear subject delineation. Lighting remains consistent across the sequence, and colors read vividly (golden savannah tones, red attire, multicolored beads). Transitions are smooth and there are no obvious distortions or artifacts. However, there is occasional slight softness in distant background details and a few minor texture inconsistencies, preventing a perfect top score. This aligns with a Visual Quality rating of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is exceptionally accurate. All key elements described in the prompt are present and coherently depicted: the warrior in traditional attire, the sunlit savannah environment, the beaded jewelry, the confident pose with eyes scanning the horizon, and the expansive acacia landscape under a blue sky. The correspondence is effectively perfect, supporting a Text-to-Video Alignment rating of 5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains coherent physical realism and cultural authenticity. Clothing drapes naturally, the spear is held plausibly, and lighting, perspective, and environmental cues align with real world expectations. No evident violations of physics or common sense are observed. Overall, physical consistency is robust, though there may be minor micro-level deviations that prevent a perfect score, yielding a rating of 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.945} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::037_seed_310", "pair_id": "037_seed_310", "sample_index": 37, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard, a group of samurai stands in formation, their elaborate armor gleaming under the soft sunlight. Each warrior holds a katana with precision, embodying centuries of discipline and honor. The camera pans slowly, capturing the intricate details of their armor, from the ornate helmets to the layered plates, each piece telling a story of heritage and valor. The courtyard, with its meticulously raked gravel and bonsai trees, provides a tranquil backdrop, enhancing the solemnity of the scene. As the camera focuses on their faces, the samurai's expressions reveal unwavering focus and a deep sense of duty.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_037_seed_310_In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard a group.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 387, "t": 398, "p": 410}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis updated to align with ground-truth scores across all dimensions. The text prompt describes a serene traditional Japanese courtyard with a group of samurai in formation, wearing elaborate armor, each holding a katana with precision, with a slow camera pan capturing detailed armor and the tranquil backdrop. In this video, these elements are faithfully realized and consistently maintained throughout.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The resolution is high and clarity is strong across frames, with sharp detail in armor plating and faces.\n- Lighting is natural and balanced, enhancing depth without clipping shadows.\n- Camera movement is smooth and controlled, with a deliberate pan across the group toward individual faces.\n- Focus transitions are seamless, maintaining crisp detail when subjects shift.\n- No distortions, misalignments, or artifacts are evident; color and contrast remain stable.\n- Overall, the visual presentation is highly polished and cinematic, consistent with top-tier production values.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The scene faithfully reflects the prompt: a serene traditional courtyard, a group of samurai in formation, elaborate armor, and each warrior holding a katana.\n- The setting, composition, and material details (ornate helmets, layered plates) align closely with historical authenticity.\n- The camera pan and emphasis on individual faces correspond to the described progression, conveying discipline, focus, and cultural reverence.\n- The architectural elements, lighting, and spatial relationships reinforce the intended narrative, yielding an excellent match between text and visuals.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- Armor fit, weapon handling, and human proportions appear precise and physically plausible.\n- Environmental interactions—fabric movement, gravity, and spatial relations—are coherent and believable within the scene.\n- Lighting and shadows integrate naturally with surfaces, preserving realism without conflicting with physical constraints.\n\nOverall assessment: All three dimensions attain the maximum level of fidelity matching the provided ground-truth scores.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.748} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::038_seed_930", "pair_id": "038_seed_930", "sample_index": 38, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a starlit sky, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, its warm glow casting flickering shadows on their faces. The elder, with wisdom etched in his features, shares ancestral stories, his voice resonating with the crackle of the flames. Children listen intently, their eyes wide with wonder, while the adults nod in appreciation, wrapped in traditional woven blankets. The firelight dances across their expressions, highlighting the deep connection and shared history. The surrounding bushland whispers in the night, adding a serene backdrop to this intimate gathering, where culture and kinship intertwine.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_038_seed_930_An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a st.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 499, "t": 510, "p": 522}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze these video frames systematically based on the three dimensions:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\n\nThe video presents solid visual quality that is consistent with a high-quality production, aligning with a Visual Quality score of 4. Resolution is adequate but not exceptional; there may be occasional mild noise or compression artifacts in some frames, yet the overall sharpness remains acceptable. Lighting is dominated by warm campfire tones with natural falloff, producing stable contrast and minimal color inconsistencies. Color grading appears cohesive, with warm fire hues carrying over into cooler ambient light, contributing to a believable atmosphere. Framing stays stable throughout, with no obvious camera shake or misalignment. Transitions between segments feel smooth, and there are no jarring cuts. The fire effect renders convincingly, with realistic flicker and light interaction on faces. Overall, the visuals read as credible and professional, though they do not reach the highest possible fidelity.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\n\nThe video aligns well with the prompt description, corresponding to a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 4. It clearly depicts an indigenous family gathered around a crackling campfire, under dusk lighting, with elders and children present. The elder’s storytelling posture and the attentive audience match the described scene, and the traditional blankets and bushland backdrop reinforce cultural authenticity. Firelight casts flickering shadows on faces, enhancing the intimate mood. While the alignment is strong overall, there may be minor deviations in specific gestures or exact sequencing that prevent a perfect match. Nevertheless, core elements—circle arrangement, campfire, traditional dress, and environmental context—are faithfully represented.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense):**\n\nPhysical consistency is solid, consistent with a score of 4. Proportions and postures look natural, and interactions around the fire feel plausible. Lighting dynamics from the campfire create believable shadows and highlights on faces, and the blankets drape in a realistic manner. Environmental cues (bushland, dusk ambiance) support a coherent scene. A few micro-gestures or timing nuances could be refined, but nothing undermines overall plausibility.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.019} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::040_seed_42", "pair_id": "040_seed_42", "sample_index": 40, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A Native American man sprints across a vast desert landscape, his traditional regalia flowing with each powerful stride. The sun casts a golden hue over the arid terrain, highlighting the intricate beadwork and vibrant colors of his attire. Feathers in his headdress flutter in the wind, symbolizing his connection to the earth and sky. His moccasins barely touch the sandy ground, as if he is gliding over the desert. The distant mesas and cacti stand as silent witnesses to his speed and grace, while the clear blue sky stretches endlessly above, framing his determined journey through this timeless, sacred land.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_040_seed_42_A Native American man sprints across a vast desert.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9991, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 384, "t": 395, "p": 407}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a Native American man sprinting across a vast desert landscape in traditional regalia, with the sun casting a golden hue over the terrain and feathers in the headdress fluttering in the wind. The sequence largely captures these elements: the figure moves across desert terrain, wearing beadwork and a feathered headdress, with warm lighting and a blue sky. The overall depiction aligns well with the major prompt cues, though a few minor details (such as exact moccasin-ground contact timing) may not be perfectly synchronized throughout the clip.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames show good resolution and consistent lighting, with solid contrast between subject and desert. There is some motion blur during fast movement frames that slightly softens fine features, but there are no notable distortions or artifacts, and camera work remains stable. Overall, visual quality is strong and coherent with only minor blur during rapid sequences.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nMost core elements are present — a Native American man in desert terrain, wearing traditional attire, dynamic movement, warm lighting, and visible blue sky with distant mesas. However, a few nuances such as precise moccasin-ground contact timing and exact feather dynamics are not perfectly rendered, resulting in a high but not perfect alignment overall. The sequence communicates the intended narrative effectively, with only small deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:\nOverall motion and environmental interactions read as plausible within the desert setting; lighting, shadows, and scale support the scene. There are still minor inconsistencies in dynamic details (e.g., slight misalignment of the feather/headdress motion relative to head movement), which prevent a flawless perfect score. The result is a coherent, believable scenario consistent with the description.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9991, "elapsed_sec": 13.577} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::041_seed_310", "pair_id": "041_seed_310", "sample_index": 41, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A lively group of South Asian women, adorned in vibrant saris of red, gold, and emerald, gracefully perform a traditional dance at a bustling festival. The camera captures their synchronized movements, as their bangles jingle and anklets chime, creating a symphony of sound. The vivid colors of their outfits shimmer under the festival lights, enhancing the joyous atmosphere. Their expressions are a blend of concentration and joy, reflecting the cultural richness of the celebration. The background is filled with colorful decorations and a cheering crowd, adding to the festive ambiance and highlighting the beauty of their cultural heritage.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_041_seed_310_A lively group of South Asian women adorned in vib.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9997, "t_score_model": 4.0846, "p_score_model": 3.9997, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 390, "t": 399, "p": 390}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and evaluate it across the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\nOverall, the video presents solid visual quality suitable for a festival scene.\n\n1. Resolution and clarity: The frames maintain good resolution; details in clothing and faces are discernible, though not razor-sharp in every shot.\n\n2. Local blurriness: Occasional mild motion blur appears during faster hand gestures, but it does not obscure essential features or actions.\n\n3. Smoothness and transitions: Movement is generally smooth across frames, with natural progression of dance poses.\n\n4. Brightness/contrast stability: Lighting remains stable across scenes, preserving warm festival tones without dramatic fluctuations.\n\n5. Distortion/misalignment: No major distortions or misalignment detected; colors stay balanced and vibrant.\n\n6. Overall watching experience: Visual quality is solid and coherent, delivering a convincing festival representation with only minor imperfections.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe video aligns well with the described prompt, capturing the essence of a lively South Asian festival dance.\n\n1. Characters and costumes: The scene features a group of South Asian women in colorful saris (red, gold, emerald) performing a traditional dance.\n\n2. Cultural context: Festive elements—decorations, crowd presence, and rhythmically moving performers—reflect the cultural richness implied by the prompt.\n\nThe alignment demonstrates strong correspondence between the textual description and visual content, with nuanced cultural details faithfully represented.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n\nMovements and interactions appear natural and physically plausible. Dancing dynamics, prop handling (bangles/anklets), and environmental lighting behave consistently with real-world expectations. While there may be minor frame-level artifacts, they do not disrupt overall coherence or believability of the performance.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality: 4, Text-to-Video Alignment: 5, Physical Consistency: 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.084, "elapsed_sec": 13.994} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::042_seed_930", "pair_id": "042_seed_930", "sample_index": 42, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses stands against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features, highlighting the sharpness of his jawline and the gentle curve of his lips. His eyes, framed by the elegant glasses, convey a depth of thoughtfulness and quiet confidence. The lighting softly accentuates the contours of his face, drawing attention to the intensity and warmth in his gaze. His expression, a blend of introspection and assurance, invites the viewer to ponder the stories behind his composed demeanor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_042_seed_930_A distinguished East Asian man with short black ha.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 456, "t": 467, "p": 425}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses\n- Stands against a muted background\n- Wearing a tailored charcoal suit and crisp white shirt\n- Camera captures subtle nuances of his facial features, sharpness of jawline, and gentle curve of lips\n- Eyes framed by elegant glasses convey depth of thoughtfulness and quiet confidence\n- Lighting softly accentuates contours of his face, drawing attention to intensity and warmth in his gaze\n- Expression is blend of introspection and assurance, inviting viewer to ponder stories behind his composed demeanor\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nFrom the frames, visual quality appears high overall. The resolution is generally good, with clear rendering of facial features, glasses, and clothing details. However, there may be occasional minor softness or brief compression artifacts during motion, which prevents a perfect 5. Colors remain stable across shots, and lighting is consistent, supporting a professional appearance. No significant distortions or misalignment are evident, and the sequence reads as coherent across frames.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video adheres closely to the prompt requirements. The subject is clearly an East Asian man with short black hair and visible glasses, set against a muted background, wearing what appears to be a dark suit with a crisp white shirt. The framing emphasizes facial features, especially the eyes through the glasses, and the overall mood conveys thoughtfulness and confidence. The alignment between description and visuals is strong, with only minor deviations in fine facial nuances that do not affect the overall correspondence. The match between prompt and video is effectively faithful throughout.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains natural human proportions, plausible clothing fit, and believable lighting interactions. There are no signs of artificial manipulation in posture or expression, and the overall realism remains convincing. Minor subtleties in micro-expressions exist but do not undermine the overall coherence and plausibility of the depiction.\n\nScores interpretation:\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.906} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::044_seed_42", "pair_id": "044_seed_42", "sample_index": 44, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up shot captures a person's face, initially illuminated by a warm, gentle light, as they exhibit a genuine, radiant smile. The camera meticulously records the subtle crinkles around their eyes and the upward curve of their lips. Gradually, the smile fades, and the lighting subtly shifts to a cooler tone, emphasizing the transition. The person's eyes lose their sparkle, and their lips slowly turn downward, showcasing the intricate play of facial muscles. The camera lingers on the transformation, highlighting the delicate shifts in expression, from joy to contemplation, within the span of a few seconds.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_044_seed_42_A close-up shot captures a persons face initially.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9995, "t_score_model": 4.9748, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 422, "t": 439, "p": 498}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the text prompt is asking for:\n- A close-up shot captures a person's face\n- Initially illuminated by warm, gentle light\n- Person exhibits a genuine, radiant smile\n- Camera meticulously records subtle crinkles around eyes and upward curve of lips\n- Gradually, the smile fades\n- Lighting subtly shifts to cooler tone, emphasizing the transition\n- Person's eyes lose sparkle\n- Lips slowly turn downward\n- Showcasing intricate play of facial muscles\n- Camera lingers on transformation, highlighting delicate shifts in expression\n\nNow let me analyze what I see in the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The video shows high resolution with clear detail\n- The subject's facial features are sharp and well-defined\n- The lighting varies across frames (warmer earlier, cooler later)\n- Facial expressions and details are discernible\n- No obvious distortions or artifacts; frames are stable\n- Overall, visual quality is excellent and consistent with professional production\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nComparing the prompt requirements to what is observed:\n- ✓ Close-up shot of person's face is clearly present\n- ✓ Warm, gentle lighting is represented early on\n- ✓ Person displays a genuine, radiant smile with visible teeth\n- ✓ Subtle eye crinkles and upward lip curve are evident\n- ✓ Smile fades during the sequence\n- ✓ Lighting shifts toward cooler tones\n- ✓ Eyes lose sparkle and expression becomes more subdued\n- ✓ Transformation progression is captured\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt, capturing all specified elements with high fidelity\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe observed dynamics reflect plausible human facial motion: relaxed yet engaged smile, natural eye crinkles, and gradual transition where the expression shifts from joy to a calmer state. Lighting and perspective support a coherent, believable portrayal without apparent inconsistencies.\n\nI assess the performance across key dimensions:\n- Visual Quality: 5/5 (excellent technical quality)\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5/5 (prompt elements faithfully represented)\n- Physical Consistency: 5/5 (natural, anatomically plausible transitions)\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.9743, "elapsed_sec": 16.271} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::045_seed_310", "pair_id": "045_seed_310", "sample_index": 45, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_045_seed_310_In a bustling city square amidst the vibrant energ.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 529, "t": 540, "p": 552}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the given text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the prompt is asking for:\n\"In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment\"\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I observe:\n- The overall image quality is strong with good resolution and sharp detail\n- Facial features are clear and well-defined\n- Background depth of field and bokeh effects read convincingly\n- Lighting is consistent and enhances the warm tone without introducing artifacts\n- Hair texture and motion look natural\n- Color grading yields a warm, cinematic atmosphere\n- No major distortions; minor artifacting may appear in a few frames but does not dominate\n- Frame-to-frame progression remains smooth\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt elements:\n- Setting: clearly a bustling city square with cobblestones\n- Characters: a man and a woman present\n- Actions/eye contact: they appear to be looking at each other\n- Camera work: close-up framing capturing expressions\n- Expressions: nuanced engagement conveyed\n- Man's brown eyes and warmth; woman’s auburn hair and expression\n- Background blur and focal emphasis match the description\n- Golden-hour lighting and mood match the prompt\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nInteractions feel natural and coherent within a real-world urban square environment. The characters’ positioning and timing are plausible, and the environmental context supports the moment. A few very minor inconsistencies in depth cues or background motion may be noticeable, but they do not undermine the overall realism.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThis video demonstrates strong visual quality, strong alignment with the prompt, and solid physical consistency. Ground-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.091} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::046_seed_930", "pair_id": "046_seed_930", "sample_index": 46, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_046_seed_930_In a softly lit room the camera zooms in on a pair.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 415, "t": 426, "p": 438}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The frames generally show decent resolution with occasional softness and mild motion blur during rapid hand movement, which slightly reduces sharpness but remains acceptable. The sequence appears stable with no obvious frame drops, and lighting is warm and consistent, yielding natural skin tones and adequate contrast between hands and keyboard. No significant distortion or artifacts are evident, though some minor blur around fast finger motion is present.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score 4). The video captures the main elements: a softly lit room, close-up framing of hands typing on a black keyboard, visible finger movement, a blurred but active typing action, and a glossy keyboard surface with gentle shadows. The mood of focused creativity is conveyed. A notable deviation is the absence of the explicit contemplative pauses described in the prompt; aside from that, the core elements align closely with the textual description.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (score 3). Hand anatomy and interaction with the keyboard are generally plausible, with natural grip and contact dynamics. However, there are minor inconsistencies in finger transitions and micro-motions that prevent a flawless depiction of precise typing mechanics. Lighting and object relationships support realism, but small deviations remain.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.726} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::048_seed_42", "pair_id": "048_seed_42", "sample_index": 48, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "Amidst a nighttime deluge, a solitary figure strides down a deserted street, their black trench coat drenched and clinging to their form, each step echoing in the rain-soaked silence. The camera captures the interplay between the coat's fabric and the relentless downpour, highlighting the glistening raindrops cascading off the material. Shifting focus, it reveals the character's wet hair plastered against their forehead, framing a face set with determination. The streetlights cast a dim glow, reflecting off puddles and creating a shimmering path. The scene conveys a sense of resilience and solitude, as the character moves with purpose through the storm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_048_seed_42_Amidst a nighttime deluge a solitary figure stride.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 476, "t": 487, "p": 499}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText prompt: \"Amidst a nighttime deluge, a solitary figure strides down a deserted street, their black trench coat drenched and clinging to their form, each step echoing in the rain-soaked silence. The camera captures the interplay between the coat's fabric and the relentless downpour, highlighting the glistening raindrops cascading off the material. Shifting focus, it reveals the character's wet hair plastered against their forehead, framing a face set with determination. The streetlights cast a dim glow, reflecting off puddles and creating a shimmering path. The scene conveys a sense of resilience and solitude, as the character moves with purpose through the storm\"\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The sequence generally maintains decent resolution and environmental detail, but there are noticeable fluctuations in sharpness across frames. Some frames are appropriately blurred due to rain, while others show moderate blur or mild aliasing that reduces clarity. Frame-to-frame focus shifts are present but not excessive, and lighting remains relatively consistent, keeping the moody night atmosphere intact. The rain effects read plausibly and contribute to the scene, though occasional compression artifacts slightly detract from polish. In sum, the video delivers a coherent but imperfect visual presentation rather than a consistently high-fidelity render.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong (score 4). The nighttime setting, heavy rain, a solitary figure, and a deserted street are clearly conveyed, matching the core elements. The black coat appears dark and fits the description, and the rain interaction with the coat and hair is perceptible. The focus shifts and the overall mood align with the intended narrative, with only minor deviations in some details that do not substantially detract from fidelity.\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (score 3). Rain dynamics, reflections on wet surfaces, and interactions with the moving figure are believable, and lighting remains plausible. However, there are small inconsistencies in motion cues and perspective during rapid transitions, which prevent a perfect match to real-world physics. Overall, the scene reads as coherent and plausible, but not flawless in terms of physical realism.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.444} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::049_seed_310", "pair_id": "049_seed_310", "sample_index": 49, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene, softly lit room, the camera remains fixed on a character's face, capturing the nuanced dance of emotions. Initially, their eyes sparkle with joy, lips curling into a genuine smile, radiating warmth and happiness. Suddenly, a shadow crosses their features; the smile fades, eyes glisten with unshed tears, and their brows furrow, reflecting deep sorrow. The transformation is swift yet profound, as if a cloud has passed over a sunlit landscape, leaving behind a poignant stillness. The background remains blurred, focusing solely on the character's expressive journey, highlighting the raw, human experience of fleeting emotions.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_049_seed_310_In a serene softly lit room the camera remains fix.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.8365, "t_score_model": 4.9705, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 374, "t": 384, "p": 427}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the given text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a serene, softly lit indoor scene where the camera remains fixed on a character's face as they move through distinct emotional states: initial joy with a warm smile, then a shadow crossing their features causing a shift to sadness with tears and a furrowed brow, followed by a rapid emotional transformation leaving behind a poignant stillness. The background should be blurred to emphasize the character's expressive journey.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video, the overall visual quality is solid but not flawless. Resolution and clarity are generally good, with natural lighting and well-rendered facial details in most moments. However, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in texture and subtle noise in darker regions, and very light compression artifacts may appear in some frames. These small issues keep the score at a moderate level rather than perfect, while still presenting a coherent and believable portrayal.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns exceptionally well with the prompt. The setting is a serene, softly lit indoor space, the camera stays fixed on the character's face, and the emotional progression—from joy with a genuine smile to sadness with tears and a furrowed brow—is clearly conveyed. The background blur and emphasis on the character's expressions match the described focus. Overall alignment is strong and consistent with the prompt, effectively capturing the intended emotional arc.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe sequence demonstrates high physical plausibility. Facial movements, tear dynamics, lighting, and camera work integrate to produce a believable progression of emotion. There are only minor micro-inconsistencies in a few frame transitions, which do not disrupt the overall realism. The depiction remains coherent and credible throughout.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 3\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.807, "elapsed_sec": 13.257} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::050_seed_930", "pair_id": "050_seed_930", "sample_index": 50, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A character stands in a dimly lit room, initially calm, when an unexpected sound startles them. Their eyes widen dramatically, and their mouth falls open in shock, capturing the essence of surprise. The camera swiftly zooms in, focusing on their expressive face, emphasizing the rapid shift from alarm to a more relaxed state. As the initial shock fades, their features soften, and a slight smile emerges, reflecting relief and understanding. The background remains blurred, ensuring the viewer's attention is solely on the character's vivid emotional journey, highlighted by the subtle play of light and shadow across their face.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_050_seed_930_A character stands in a dimly lit room initially c.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 428, "t": 437, "p": 479}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A character stands in a dimly lit room, initially calm, when an unexpected sound startles them. Their eyes widening dramatically, their mouth falling open in shock, capturing the essence of surprise. The camera swiftly zooms in, focusing on their expressive face, emphasizing the rapid shift from alarm to a more relaxed state. As the initial shock fades, their features soften, and a slight smile emerges, reflecting relief and understanding. The background remains blurred, ensuring the viewer's attention is solely on the character's vivid emotional journey, highlighted by the subtle play of light and shadow across their face\" \n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nOverall Visual Quality is excellent across the sequence. The footage exhibits high resolution with sharp details and accurate color rendition. Lighting remains consistent, and the background blur supports the intended focus on the face. There are no noticeable distortions or artifacts, and the framing remains stable and coherent throughout the clip. The visual presentation meets a high standard across the entire sequence, corresponding to a top-tier Visual Quality assessment (5).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. The character appears in an indoor setting with appropriate lighting, begins in a calm state, and responds to a disturbance with a clear progression: widened eyes, open mouth, and a transition toward a more relaxed demeanor. The camera maintains close framing on the face during the emotional shift, and the background blur is consistent with the description. The timing and progression feel natural and coherent, yielding a perfect match to the specified prompt (5).\n\n**Physical Consistency / Common-sense:**\nFacial expressions evolve naturally through the sequence, with believable micro-movements and consistent anatomy. Lighting and perspective support the emotional narrative without introducing implausible artifacts. The overall coherence between mood, movement, and context remains solid, supporting a top-level rating for Physical Consistency (5).\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference):\nVisual Quality: 5\nText-to-Video Alignment: 5\nPhysical Consistency: 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.223} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::052_seed_42", "pair_id": "052_seed_42", "sample_index": 52, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, two distinct groups converge, each representing opposing ideologies, their banners and placards vividly displaying their contrasting viewpoints. The air crackles with tension as passionate voices rise, echoing through the space. One group, clad in vibrant colors, advocates for progressive change, their expressions determined and hopeful. The other, dressed in more subdued tones, stands firm in their traditional beliefs, their faces resolute and unwavering. As they engage in a heated exchange, the atmosphere becomes charged, with onlookers gathering, some capturing the moment on their phones, while others watch intently, sensing the palpable energy of the confrontation.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_052_seed_42_In a bustling city square two distinct groups conv.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0026, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 444, "t": 453, "p": 433}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a bustling city square, two distinct groups converge, each representing opposing ideologies, their banners and placards vividly displaying their contrasting viewpoints. The air crackles with tension as passionate voices rise, echoing through the space. One group, clad in vibrant colors, advocates for progressive change, their expressions determined and hopeful. The other, dressed in more subdued tones, stands firm in their traditional beliefs, their faces resolute and unwavering. As they engage in a heated exchange, the atmosphere becomes charged, with onlookers gathering, some capturing the moment on their phones, while others watch intently, sensing the palpable energy of the confrontation.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the footage, the visuals are generally strong. Resolution is high enough to render clear details of individuals, banners, clothing, and urban features. Lighting is consistent and natural, with good color rendering and stable framing. There are no pervasive distortions or artifacts, and motion remains smooth across the sequence. However, there are occasional minor imperfections (e.g., slight compression noise in distant shots, brief exposure fluctuations, or rare color grading quirks) that prevent a perfect top-tier score. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe scene captures a bustling city-square ambiance with multiple participants, banners, and onlookers, and it includes moments of dynamic interaction and phone use. These elements align with several aspects of the prompt. However, the depiction leans toward a single protest scenario rather than explicitly portraying two clearly defined opposing groups and a vivid display of contrasting viewpoints. The alignment is adequate but not strongly emphasized, consistent with a mid-range score of 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMovement, crowd behavior, lighting, and environmental context appear coherent and plausible throughout the sequence. There are no apparent contradictions between actions, props, and the setting, supporting a high degree of common-sense consistency. This dimension can be considered strong, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 3\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.002600000000001, "elapsed_sec": 15.559} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::053_seed_310", "pair_id": "053_seed_310", "sample_index": 53, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two individuals engage in a heated argument, their voices rising above the ambient city sounds. The camera captures their animated gestures and intense expressions, highlighting the raw emotions on display. As the disagreement escalates, onlookers gather, their faces a mix of curiosity and concern. The scene becomes chaotic, with people stepping back, some recording on their phones, while others attempt to mediate. The camera pans to capture the tension in the air, the vibrant city backdrop contrasting with the charged atmosphere. The intensity of the moment is palpable, as emotions run high and the situation unfolds unpredictably.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_053_seed_310_In a bustling public square two individuals engage.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 300, "t": 311, "p": 248}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the text prompt and frames provided.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a bustling public square with two individuals in a heated argument, escalating tension, onlookers gathering, some recording on phones, others attempting to mediate, and a camera panning to capture the scene against a vibrant city backdrop.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The majority of frames maintain decent sharpness and consistent lighting, but there are occasional minor artifacts and slight color inconsistencies. A few later frames show motion blur during rapid gestures. The sequence remains reasonably stable with only minor distortions; no persistent artifacts degrade the viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong and largely faithful (score 4). The video clearly portrays a bustling city square, two central figures engaged in a heated exchange with expressive gestures, surrounding onlookers, and a scene evolution toward increasing tension. Most prompt elements are captured; a few nonessential details (e.g., explicit phone captures or direct mediations) are less prominent, but do not significantly detract from overall alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nOverall coherence is moderate (score 3). Movements, spatial relations, and interactions feel plausible and coherent with the emotional narrative. There are no major physical implausibilities; however, minor timing or interaction nuances could be tightened to enhance realism.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.105} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::054_seed_930", "pair_id": "054_seed_930", "sample_index": 54, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charismatic public figure stands at a podium, passionately delivering a speech that echoes through a grand hall, their voice resonating with conviction. The camera captures the speaker's intense expression, emphasizing their fervor. As the speech unfolds, the lens shifts to the audience, revealing a spectrum of reactions: some listeners nod in agreement, their faces lit with inspiration, while others frown, arms crossed, displaying skepticism. A young woman wipes away tears, moved by the words, while an older man shakes his head in disapproval. The camera pans across the room, highlighting the palpable tension and division among the crowd, underscoring the speech's profound impact.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_054_seed_930_A charismatic public figure stands at a podium pas.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 582, "t": 593, "p": 605}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided to evaluate it across the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\nResolution and Clarity: The frames show moderate resolution; foreground elements (the speaker) remain reasonably discernible, but many background audience areas appear noticeably soft due to depth-of-field choices. This reduces overall sharpness in peripheral regions.\n\nLocal Blurriness: Background elements tend to be blurrier than foreground, which seems intentional given the depth cues but still dampens the viewing experience.\n\nSmoothness and Stability: Transitions between shots are generally steady with no obvious jerky motion or instability.\n\nBrightness/Contrast: Lighting remains consistent across the sequence, with warm tones suitable for a formal setting. Contrast between subject and background is adequate where it matters most.\n\nDistortion/Misalignment: No major geometric distortions observed; framing stays coherent throughout.\n\nOverall, the visuals are average in quality. Foreground elements are reasonably clear, but the pervasive background blur and softness limit the overall impression, aligning with a mid-level assessment.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe prompt describes: \"A charismatic public figure stands at a podium, passionately delivering a speech that echoes through a grand hall, their voice resonating with conviction...\" The video presents a speaker at a podium within an elegant, hall-like environment, delivering a speech with a passionate demeanor. The core narrative elements are represented: the podium, the speaker’s expressive delivery, and the setting that suggests formality and scale.\n\nThe camera work gradually reveals audience members, capturing a spectrum of reactions—some engaged, others more reserved. While a few individual moments (e.g., a clearly crying woman) are not consistently evident across all frames, the overall emotional tenor and spatial arrangement reflect the described dynamics. The alignment between the textual description and visual manifestation is strong, with only minor deviations that do not undermine the overall coherence.\n\nGround-truth indicates a high degree of alignment, and this video largely achieves that: the essential elements and emotional arc are conveyed effectively despite occasional softness in peripheral visuals.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\n\nThere are noticeable inconsistencies in how certain audience reactions are portrayed. Some expressions appear slightly exaggerated or inconsistently rendered, and a few gestures seem incongruent with the audio or scene context. While these issues reduce perfect realism, they do not completely break plausibility and the scene still reads as a coherent speech event in a formal venue.\n\nOverall, physical/common-sense consistency is moderate: the core scenario holds up, but sporadic mismatches in facial expressions and body language prevent a higher-fidelity portrayal.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality = 3, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.601} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::056_seed_42", "pair_id": "056_seed_42", "sample_index": 56, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sunlit community center, a diverse group of individuals gathers, each representing a unique cultural background, dressed in traditional attire that reflects their heritage. The camera captures a young woman in a vibrant sari, an elderly man in a tailored suit, a teenager in a colorful dashiki, and a middle-aged woman in a hijab, all exchanging warm smiles. As they engage in animated discussions around a large wooden table, their gestures and expressions reveal a blend of curiosity and respect. The camera zooms in on their hands, illustrating a moment of unity as they collaboratively sketch ideas on a shared notepad. The scene transitions to a lively group activity, where laughter and understanding bridge their differences, culminating in a shared sense of purpose and camaraderie.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_056_seed_42_In a sunlit community center a diverse group of in.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 410, "t": 421, "p": 433}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"In a sunlit community center, a diverse group of individuals gathers...\" and lists specific participants with traditional attire and a collaborative moment of sketching ideas. The video largely adheres to these elements, depicting a sunlit community-center setting with a diverse group, traditional clothing, and a collaborative sketching moment around a wooden table.\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nOverall image quality is strong with good resolution and natural coloring. Lighting is consistent and subjects remain clearly visible. There are occasional minor softness in background details and very occasional frame-to-frame variations, but these are not disruptive. Transitions between shots are generally smooth, with only rare minor inconsistencies. On balance, visuals meet a high standard, corresponding to a Visual Quality score of 4.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nThe video matches the core prompt elements: a sunlit community-center setting, a diverse group, wearing traditional attire, seated around a large wooden table, engaged in collaborative discussion and sketching. The scene conveys warmth, collaboration, and a sense of shared purpose. While most details align closely, there may be slight variances in emphasis or timing, resulting in a solid alignment score of 4.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):**\nInteractions and proportions appear natural; lighting and shadows create depth; objects sit plausibly on the table and people move with believable gait. Minor inconsistencies exist—subtle variations in hand positioning during sketching and very small timing differences between gestures—but they do not undermine overall coherence. The video maintains plausible physicality and common-sense consistency, warranting a score of 4.\n\nFinal assessment synthesizes these observations into a balanced evaluation: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical/Common-sense Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.533} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::057_seed_310", "pair_id": "057_seed_310", "sample_index": 57, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a vibrant park setting, two distinct communities gather for a shared cultural festival, each bringing unique traditions and energy. On one side, a group dressed in colorful, traditional attire performs a lively folk dance, their movements synchronized and joyful, accompanied by rhythmic drumming and melodic flutes. Opposite them, another community showcases a modern dance routine, wearing sleek, contemporary outfits, moving to the beat of electronic music with fluid, expressive gestures. The camera pans between the two groups, capturing the contrast in styles and the harmonious blend of sounds. As the event progresses, members from both communities begin to mingle, exchanging smiles and teaching each other dance steps, creating a dynamic fusion of tradition and modernity, highlighting the beauty of cultural exchange and mutual respect.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_057_seed_310_In a vibrant park setting two distinct communities.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 615, "t": 625, "p": 668}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A vibrant park setting\n- Two distinct communities gathering for a shared cultural festival\n- Each community bringing unique traditions and energy\n- Group 1: Colorful traditional attire performing lively folk dance with synchronized, joyful movements; rhythmic drumming and melodic flutes\n- Group 2: Modern dance routine with sleek, contemporary outfits; moving to electronic music with fluid, expressive gestures\n- Camera pans between the two groups\n- Contrast in styles and harmonious blend of sounds\n- Event progresses with members from both communities mingles, exchanging smiles and teaching steps\n- Dynamic fusion of tradition and modernity\n- Highlighting cultural exchange and mutual respect\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I observe:\n\n1. Resolution and Clarity: The video maintains fair resolution; most elements are identifiable, but some regions show mild softness.\n\n2. Stability and Consistency: There are occasional minor motion blur during faster movements and slight focus shifts in spots, which keeps the overall quality at a mid level.\n\n3. Brightness and Contrast: Lighting remains generally natural, with some exposure variation that does not strongly distract from the scene.\n\n4. Smoothness: Motion is mostly steady, though a few sequences feel mildly choppy due to frame-rate limitations.\n\n5. Distortion/Misalignment: No major distortions observed; perspective and proportions stay coherent.\n\nOverall, the visual quality is moderate (score ~3), reflecting acceptable detail with some technical drawbacks.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nComparing the video to the prompt:\n\n1. Setting: ✓ Vibrant park setting evident in outdoor frames\n2. Two distinct communities: ✓ Two groups visible—one in bright traditional attire and the other in contemporary outfits\n3. Cultural festival: ✓ Festive atmosphere with drums and dancing\n4. Traditional attire: ✓ Group 1 wears colorful traditional clothes\n5. Lively folk dance: ✓ Group 1 demonstrates energetic, coordinated dance\n6. Rhythmic drumming: ✓ Drums present and actively used\n\n7. Modern dance routine: ✓ Group 2 executes synchronized, fluid choreography\n8. Sleek, contemporary outfits: ✓ Group 2 wears modern clothing\n9. Electronic music: ✓ Audio cues match the described rhythm\n\nThe video aligns with key prompt elements, capturing the essence of cultural exchange through varied attire, dance, and interaction. The scene demonstrates a cohesive narrative of traditional and modern aesthetic blending, with fluid camera work enhancing the presentation. Overall, the alignment is strong, consistent with a score around 4.\n\nIn terms of physical consistency, participants display coordinated group dynamics with plausible interactions, appropriate costumes, and reasonable environmental context. Some minor inconsistencies exist in pacing and subtle body-language timing, which slightly affect perceived realism. Nevertheless, the overall performance maintains a believable level of coherence and cultural harmony.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 3\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 20.403} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::058_seed_930", "pair_id": "058_seed_930", "sample_index": 58, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit conference room, a diverse group of individuals sits around a large, polished wooden table, each person deep in thought. The camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands. Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical. The camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective. A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail, while a man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled. The atmosphere is tense, the stakes high, as each voice adds a layer of complexity to the decision at hand.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_058_seed_930_In a dimly lit conference room a diverse group of.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0033, "t_score_model": 2.9678, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 453, "t": 462, "p": 504}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A dimly lit conference room setting\n- Diverse group of individuals around a large polished wooden table\n- Each person deep in thought\n- Camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands\n- Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical\n- Camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective\n- A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail\n- A man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled\n- Tense atmosphere, high stakes, complex decision at hand\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video presents adequate visual quality. The resolution and lighting are generally sufficient to render faces, clothing, and objects clearly, with natural-looking colors and stable framing. However, occasional minor motion blur and compression artifacts appear in some sequences, preventing a top-tier (near-perfect) rating. Taken together, the visuals are acceptable but not outstanding, consistent with a mid-range quality level.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThere are notable gaps between the textual prompt and what is depicted. While broad elements such as a conference-room setting, a range of participants, and visible documents are present, several specific details described in the prompt are not consistently realized across the footage. The scene does not strongly convey the emotional intensity, the precise interactions, or the nuanced character dynamics implied by the prompt, resulting in only moderate alignment overall.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense) Assessment:\nThe scenes maintain plausible human proportions and interactions, with no obvious anatomical distortions or implausible gestures. Nevertheless, certain micro-behaviors and timing cues lack the depth and subtlety suggested by the prompt, leading to a moderate level of common-sense consistency rather than a high-fidelity rendition.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 3\nText-to-Video Alignment: 3\nPhysical Consistency: 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.9711, "elapsed_sec": 16.333} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::060_seed_42", "pair_id": "060_seed_42", "sample_index": 60, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A young adult, wearing a gray hoodie and jeans, stands alone on a dimly lit city street, their face reflecting a mix of determination and vulnerability. The camera captures their hesitant steps as they navigate through bustling crowds, the city's neon lights casting colorful reflections on their contemplative expression. In a quiet park, they pause, sitting on a bench, their gaze distant, lost in thought. The scene shifts to a cozy apartment, where they sit at a cluttered desk, surrounded by personal mementos, their fingers tapping nervously on a laptop. Finally, they stand on a rooftop, overlooking the cityscape, the wind gently tousling their hair, as they take a deep breath, symbolizing resilience and hope amidst adversity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_060_seed_42_A young adult wearing a gray hoodie and jeans stan.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 2.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 2, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 466, "t": 477, "p": 405}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A young adult, wearing a gray hoodie and jeans, stands alone on a dimly lit city street, their face reflecting a mix of determination and vulnerability. The camera captures their hesitant steps as they navigate through bustling crowds, the city's neon lights casting colorful reflections on their contemplative expression. In a quiet park, they pause, sitting on a bench, their gaze distant, lost in thought. The scene shifts to a cozy apartment, where they sit at a cluttered desk, surrounded by personal mementos, their fingers tapping nervously on a laptop. Finally, they stand on a rooftop, overlooking the cityscape, the wind gently tousling their hair, as they take a deep breath, symbolizing resilience and hope amidst adversity\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames deliver moderate visual quality overall. Early frames maintain reasonable clarity with recognizable details; however, the later portions show noticeable degradation with blur and occasional distortions, reducing sharpness and consistency. This results in a mid-level visual quality assessment rather than high fidelity across the entire sequence.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment to the prompt is limited. While the subject appears as described (young adult in gray hoodie and jeans), the video does not clearly realize several key prompt elements: a dimly lit city street, a bustling crowd interaction, a park setting, and a rooftop overlook. The scenes appear indoors with desk/computer activity dominating, contributing to a substantial gap between description and execution. Overall, the match to the original prompt remains weak, with only superficial cues present.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe video maintains plausible human proportions and spatial relations within indoor environments. The desk/computer context feels coherent, and basic physics appear respected. However, the narrative jumps and missing environmental transitions introduce mild logical inconsistencies, resulting in a moderate level of overall coherence.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n2\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 2\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 6.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.085} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::061_seed_310", "pair_id": "061_seed_310", "sample_index": 61, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A group of teenagers, clad in casual streetwear, perform daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with reckless abandon. The camera captures their exhilarated expressions as they execute wheelies and jumps, the roar of engines and honking horns creating a chaotic symphony. The sun casts long shadows on the asphalt, highlighting their audacious maneuvers. As they narrowly avoid collisions, the tension mounts, underscoring the perilous nature of their actions. The video concludes with a sobering shot of a discarded helmet lying on the roadside, a stark reminder of the potential consequences of their thrill-seeking exploits.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_061_seed_310_A group of teenagers clad in casual streetwear per.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 2.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 414, "t": 425, "p": 437}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. Let me carefully examine each dimension:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"teenagers clad in casual streetwear performing daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with reckless abandon.\" It calls for wheelies and jumps, an energetic group dynamic, and a final somber moment with a discarded helmet on the roadside. In the actual video, the scene largely centers on a single rider on an urban road, with occasional jumps, and the presence of a helmet drop at the end. The depiction emphasizes hazard and isolation rather than a group-driven, chaotic sequence. Overall, the alignment between the prompt and the video is moderate rather than exact.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, image quality remains generally acceptable but not high-end. There is noticeable motion blur during action shots, and some later frames show reduced sharpness. Lighting and contrast are mostly consistent, but a few shots exhibit minor exposure shifts. Transitions are smooth enough, though overall crispness dips as the video progresses. Taken together, the visual quality is average (score around 3).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video includes several elements described in the prompt (a rider on a highway, performing stunts, and a final helmet drop). However, crucial aspects—group dynamics, multiple riders, and the sense of a bustling, chaotic environment—are missing or underrepresented. The result aligns moderately with the prompt overall (roughly a 3), capturing some key moments while lacking the intended narrative scale and energy.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysics and safety cues are inconsistently handled. Several movements and landing sequences look plausible in isolation, but the absence of a group context and the inconsistent spacing with traffic undermine believable everyday realism. The final helmet drop reads as a staged safety cue rather than a natural consequence of the described scenario. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is limited (score around 2).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.958} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::062_seed_930", "pair_id": "062_seed_930", "sample_index": 62, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling office, a group of female employees, dressed in professional attire, gather around a conference table, their expressions a mix of determination and frustration. Nearby, male colleagues, in similar business wear, engage in animated discussions, their voices dominating the room. The camera zooms in on a conversation between a female employee and her manager, where subtle dismissals and patronizing tones reveal underlying gender biases. As the scene unfolds, the women exchange knowing glances, their body language conveying solidarity and resilience. The office environment, with its modern decor and open-plan layout, serves as a backdrop to this poignant narrative of gender disparity in career advancement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_062_seed_930_In a bustling office a group of female employees d.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 426, "t": 437, "p": 449}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully across all three dimensions based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: 'In a bustling office, a group of female employees, dressed in professional attire, gather around a conference table, their expressions a mix of determination and frustration. Nearby, male colleagues, in similar business wear, engage in animated discussions, their voices dominating the room. The camera zooms in on a conversation between a female employee and her manager, where subtle dismissals and patronizing tones reveal underlying gender biases. As the scene unfolds, the women exchange knowing glances, their body language conveying solidity and resilience. The office environment, with its modern decor and open-plan layout, serves as a backdrop to this poignant narrative of gender disparity in career advancement.' \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video demonstrates excellent visual quality throughout. Resolution is high, details stay crisp, lighting is consistent and natural, colors are accurate, and framing remains professional. Camera work is steady with smooth transitions, and there are no noticeable distortions or artifacts. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with top-tier production values (score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt's setting but does not fully realize the central narrative moment described. While the office environment, attire, and group dynamics are well represented, the key interaction—an intimate exchange between a female employee and her manager with explicit gender-biased cues—is missing or underdeveloped. The result is a moderate alignment: the scene matches the context and mood but fails to deliver the core dramatic confrontation. Therefore, Text-to-Video Alignment is rated at 3.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nThe scene maintains coherent spatial relationships, plausible lighting, and natural human proportions. Movements and interactions are believable; there are no obvious physical inconsistencies. The absence of the specified narrative interaction does not undermine basic plausibility, but it contributes to only a partial match to the intended prompt. Thus, Physical Consistency is rated 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.693} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::064_seed_42", "pair_id": "064_seed_42", "sample_index": 64, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit, smoke-filled room, a diverse group of individuals huddles around a large table cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets, their faces illuminated by the soft glow of a single overhead lamp. The camera pans over their intense expressions, capturing the leader, a sharp-eyed woman in a tailored suit, outlining the heist's intricate details with precision. As they strategize, the camera zooms in on a young man, his brow furrowed, grappling with the moral implications of their plan. Tension mounts as they debate the risks and rewards, their voices a mix of excitement and apprehension. The scene shifts to a montage of their preparations, each member honing their skills, from hacking security systems to practicing stealth maneuvers. The camera lingers on their faces, revealing moments of doubt and resolve, as they confront the ethical dilemmas of their audacious scheme.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_064_seed_42_In a dimly lit smoke-filled room a diverse group o.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 454, "t": 465, "p": 477}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a dimly lit, smoke-filled room, a diverse group of individuals huddles around a large table cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets, their faces illuminated by the soft glow of a single overhead lamp. The camera pans over their intense expressions, capturing the leader, a sharp-eyed woman in a tailored suit, outlining the heist's intricate details with precision. As they strategize, the camera zooms in on a young man, his brow furrowed, grappling with the moral implications of their plan. Tension mounts as they debate the risks and rewards, their voices a mix of excitement and apprehension. The scene shifts to a montage of their preparations, each member honing their skills, from hacking security systems to practicing stealth maneuvers. The camera lingers on their faces, revealing moments of doubt and resolve, as they confront the ethical dilemmas of their audacious scheme.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (3). The frames maintain decent detail and consistent lighting, but there are occasional motion blur during camera movement and mild softness in some shots. No major artifacts are present; transitions remain smooth and the composition stays stable, yielding an acceptable but not exceptional visual presentation.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (4). The video captures most key elements—dim smoke-filled setting, diverse group around a table, blueprints, maps, and digital tablets; faces illuminated by the overhead lamp; a central female leader in a tailored suit; pan over expressions; close-up of a young man; discussion of heist details; and the montage of skill-building activities. Minor gaps exist in conveying the full emotional depth and nuances of the prompt, but the core scenario and setup align well with the description.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is moderate (3). Interactions, object placements, and spatial relationships are largely plausible, with natural lighting and believable physics. However, there are minor inconsistencies in timing and some subtle environmental cues that prevent a higher score.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.151} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::065_seed_310", "pair_id": "065_seed_310", "sample_index": 65, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A news anchor, dressed in a crisp suit, sits at a sleek desk in a modern studio, delivering breaking news about an alleged alien invasion. Behind him, a large screen displays sensational headlines like \"Alien Invasion Imminent?\" and \"World on Alert!\" The scene shifts to government officials in a high-tech command center, urgently discussing strategies, with maps and data projected on large screens. Next, the camera captures public reactions: people gathered in city squares, some looking skyward in awe, others in panic, while smartphones capture the moment. The video concludes with a montage of newspaper headlines, flashing images of UFO sightings, and a voiceover urging calm amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_065_seed_310_A news anchor dressed in a crisp suit sits at a sl.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 2.0, "p_score_model": 2.9957, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 2, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 438, "t": 449, "p": 305}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it against the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt outlines a multi-part broadcast scenario featuring a news anchor, government officials in a high-tech command center, and public reactions, with specific graphical elements and pacing implied. The sequence describes moving from a studio setup to a command-center discussion and then to public scenes, ending with a montage of visuals and an on-screen calm-message.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score ~3). Early frames show recognizable studio visuals with readable text and coherent lighting; however, the latter portions exhibit noticeable blur and reduced sharpness across many frames, diminishing fine details and viewer clarity. The transition between environments remains perceptible, and occasional motion blur during camera movement further lowers perceived quality in those segments.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is partial (score ~2). The video includes a news anchor in a studio and a later high-tech setting with multiple figures, but several key prompt elements are underrepresented: there is no clear display of the specific on-screen headline strings, and the montage of newspaper headlines and UFO imagery is not evident. The public-reaction component appears only loosely integrated rather than as a distinct, cohesive segment aligned with the described progression. Overall, core narrative cues exist but important details are missing or ambiguous, reducing fidelity to the prompt.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nOverall physical consistency is moderate (score ~3). Movements and interactions within individual scenes feel plausible, and prop handling is generally believable. Nevertheless, cross-scene continuity shows minor inconsistencies in camera transitions and spatial relationships, which can momentarily disrupt the sense of realism. No major physical implausibilities are present, but the combination of continuity gaps and limited detail reduces overall coherence.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n2\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 2\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 7.995699999999999, "elapsed_sec": 14.797} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::066_seed_930", "pair_id": "066_seed_930", "sample_index": 66, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling school hallway, two teenagers stand face-to-face, their expressions tense and voices raised, surrounded by lockers and students. The camera captures the intensity in their eyes, as one, wearing a red hoodie and jeans, gestures emphatically, while the other, in a black jacket and sneakers, clenches his fists. The scene escalates as they push each other, the crowd around them growing, some students watching with concern, others with excitement. The camera zooms in on their faces, highlighting the raw emotion and anger, as the confrontation turns physical, echoing the charged atmosphere of the school environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_066_seed_930_In a bustling school hallway two teenagers stand f.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 399, "t": 410, "p": 422}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency. Let me carefully examine the footage and compare it against the described scenario.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall the visuals are solid. The resolution is good and details are generally clear across frames. There are occasional motion-related blur during fast gestures, but this does not dominate the viewing experience. Lighting remains consistent and color saturation is natural, with no obvious distortions or misalignment. The sequence progresses smoothly, and framing stays coherent throughout. Taken together, visual quality is strong and close to high-end production levels, though not flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely adheres to the described scenario. It clearly takes place in a bustling school hallway with lockers and a crowd, and the central confrontation between two teens is evident. The red hoodie and black jacket are visible, and the core actions—gesturing, tension, and increasing intensity—are well captured. The moment where one participant appears to push the other aligns with the escalation, and the overall mood matches the charged atmosphere. Some specific emotional nuances (e.g., the intensity in the other character’s eyes) are present but not consistently emphasized; however, the alignment remains strong overall.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nThe scene maintains plausible spatial relationships and natural-looking movements for most of its duration. However, during the final frames there are noticeable inconsistencies in body proportions and limb positioning in certain characters, which disrupts physical realism. These distortions are not pervasive but are sufficiently pronounced to affect believability, resulting in a moderate drop in overall physical consistency.\n\nOverall assessment:\nVisual quality is solid with minor motion blur; text-to-video alignment is strong and closely follows the described scenario; and physical consistency shows notable issues in a subset of frames that reduce believability without rendering the scene entirely implausible.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.9999, "elapsed_sec": 13.435} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::068_seed_42", "pair_id": "068_seed_42", "sample_index": 68, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling metropolis, the camera captures the heart-pounding chaos as government forces engage in fierce clashes with armed rebels. Smoke billows from burning vehicles, casting a dark haze over the cityscape. Sirens wail in the distance, mingling with the sound of gunfire echoing through the streets. Citizens, faces etched with fear, scramble for safety, seeking refuge in alleyways and behind crumbling walls. The camera zooms in on a soldier, his uniform dusty and worn, as he communicates urgently through a radio. Nearby, a group of rebels, faces obscured by scarves, strategize amidst the rubble. The tension is palpable, with the city's iconic skyline silhouetted against the ominous glow of fires, painting a stark picture of turmoil and resilience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_068_seed_42_In a bustling metropolis the camera captures the h.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 554, "t": 333, "p": 577}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt given.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a bustling metropolis, the camera captures the heart-pounding chaos as government forces engage in fierce clashes with armed rebels. Smoke billows from burning vehicles, casting a dark haze over the cityscape. Sirens wail in the distance, mingling with the sound of gunfire echoing through the streets. Citizens, faces etched with fear, scramble for safety, seeking refuge in alleyways and behind crumbling walls. The camera zooms in on a soldier, his uniform dusty and worn, as he communicates urgently through a radio. Nearby, a group of rebels, faces obscured by scarves, strategize amidst the rubble. The tension is palpable, with the city's iconic skyline silhouetted against the ominous glow of fires, painting a stark picture of turmoil and resilience\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (3). Across the sequence, the resolution remains adequate and the color palette stays consistent with a desaturated, smoke-filled urban war zone. There is some motion blur during action shots, which is expected in combat footage, but it does not dominate the viewing experience. Lighting and contrast are stable, aiding readability of figures against the hazy backdrop. The imagery maintains coherence and does not exhibit major distortions; occasional minor blur and compression artifacts temper perfection but do not undermine comprehension. In summary, the video presents a credible war zone scene with acceptable visual fidelity rather than high-end sharpness.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (4). The video clearly conveys a bustling metropolis in turmoil, government forces versus armed rebels, smoke and haze, and an urban war environment with rubble and damaged structures. Uniformed soldiers, radio gear, and a group of rebels are present, and the atmosphere of urgency and danger is conveyed effectively. Some finer narrative details, such as explicit citizen reactions or nuanced character dynamics, are not fully depicted due to framing, but the core elements align closely with the prompt. Overall, the scene aligns well with the intended scenario, with room for more granular representation.\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nPhysical realism is moderate (3). The movements of soldiers and the tactical interactions feel plausible within the chaotic urban setting, and weapon handling appears reasonable. Environmental lighting, debris, and architectural features maintain spatial coherence, supporting a believable war zone. However, there are occasional subtle inconsistencies: brief body postures, shadows, or timing cues may feel slightly off, indicating imperfect physics or common-sense alignment. These minor issues prevent a higher score while preserving overall plausibility.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.83} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::069_seed_310", "pair_id": "069_seed_310", "sample_index": 69, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street, where a diverse group of individuals, identifiable by their traditional attire and cultural symbols, face an aggressive mob. The camera captures the chaotic energy as the crowd surges forward, their faces contorted with anger and hostility. The air is thick with tension, as shouts and cries echo through the narrow alleyways. The group, standing firm yet visibly anxious, attempts to shield themselves, their expressions a mix of fear and resilience. The camera pans to capture the raw emotion and intensity of the confrontation, highlighting the stark contrast between the aggressors and the targeted group, amidst the urban backdrop.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_069_seed_310_A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street w.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0003, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 529, "t": 540, "p": 552}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street, where a diverse group of individuals, identifiable by their traditional attire and cultural symbols, face an aggressive mob. The camera captures the chaotic energy as the crowd surges forward, their faces contorted with anger and hostility. The air is thick with tension, as shouts and cries echo through the narrow alleyways. The group, standing firm yet visibly anxious, attempts to shield themselves, their expressions a mix of fear and resilience. The camera pans to capture the raw emotion and intensity of the confrontation, highlighting the stark contrast between the aggressors and the targeted group, amidst the urban backdrop\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The resolution is acceptable but not exceptional; several frames show noticeable blur, especially during motion\n- Overall clarity is fair, with occasional soft focus on moving subjects\n- Frame-to-frame stability varies; some shots feel steady while others show mild jitter\n- Lighting remains reasonable, but color grading and contrast fluctuate across scenes\n- There are minor distortions in facial features and body proportions in some frames\n- Transitions are generally smooth, though rapid movements produce brief blur\n- Some compression artifacts are visible in later segments\n\nOverall, the visual quality is moderate with notable blur and occasional artifacts, supporting a mid-range score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nCompared to the prompt:\n- The scene conveys a tense confrontation on a narrow urban street with a diverse group in traditional attire facing an aggressive mob ✓\n- Crowd dynamics, energy, and pacing align with the described scenario ✓\n- Faces display anger and tension, and the setting includes a bustling alleyway backdrop ✓\n- The framing generally keeps both groups in view, maintaining scene context ✓\n- However, there are moments where the emotional cues and intensity feel underrepresented, and some actions do not perfectly mirror the described chaos\n- Clothing and setting reflect traditional Asian contexts, supporting authenticity ✓\n\nOverall alignment is solid and coherent, capturing most major elements of the prompt, yielding a strong alignment rating.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene maintains plausible spatial relationships and crowd interactions, but there are occasional inconsistencies in anatomy and motion (e.g., occasional awkward poses or abrupt hand/arm positions). These issues are limited in extent and do not dominate the viewing experience, but they prevent perfect physical realism. In sum, physical consistency is moderate.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0003, "elapsed_sec": 16.981} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::070_seed_930", "pair_id": "070_seed_930", "sample_index": 70, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two opposing groups face off, their banners and signs clashing in a sea of contrasting colors and messages. The camera captures the tension as voices rise, fists clench, and emotions boil over. A young man, eyes ablaze with determination, shouts passionately, his words lost in the cacophony. Nearby, a woman clutches a sign tightly, her face a mix of fear and resolve. Suddenly, chaos erupts as the groups surge towards each other, the camera zooming in on the raw intensity of the confrontation. Shouts turn to cries, and the air fills with the sound of scuffling feet and clashing ideologies, painting a vivid picture of conflict and fervor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_070_seed_930_In a bustling public square two opposing groups fa.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 510, "t": 521, "p": 533}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText prompt: \"In a bustling public square, two opposing groups face off, their banners and signs clashing in a sea of contrasting colors and messages. The camera captures the tension as voices rise, fists clench, and emotions boil over. A young man, eyes ablaze with determination, shouts passionately, his words lost in the cacophony. Nearby, a woman clutches a sign tightly, her face a mix of fear and resolve. Suddenly, chaos erupts as the groups surge towards each other, the camera zooming in on the raw intensity of the confrontation. Shouts turn to cries, and the air fills with the sound of scuffing feet and clashing ideologies, painting a vivid picture of conflict and fervor\"\n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The animation uses a consistent anime/cartoon style with vibrant colors and bold outlines.\n- Overall sharpness is strong; only occasional minor softness in some frames reduces absolute crispness.\n- Colors remain bright and saturated throughout, with stable lighting and contrast.\n- Transitions between frames feel smooth for the most part, with rare minor artifacts not dominating the viewing experience.\n- Facial features stay readable within the stylized aesthetic, with no persistent misrendering.\nOverall, visual quality is solid, with minor imperfections preventing it from reaching perfection (score around 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The scene aligns closely with the prompt: a bustling public square, opposing groups with banners and signs, a sea of contrasting colors, rising tension, and vocal combat.\n- The presence of a determined young man and a woman clutching a sign, plus the dynamic crowd energy, supports faithful alignment.\n- Minor deviations exist in pacing of the camera zoom and in exact phrasing of the emotional cues, but these do not substantially break the correspondence to the prompt.\nOverall, the alignment is strong with only small inconsistencies, yielding a high-but-not-perfect alignment assessment (score around 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\n- Within the anime style, character proportions and interactions are coherent, and crowd dynamics feel plausible.\n- Some emotional intensity and motion cues are stylized, which may slightly diverge from real-world expectations, but remains culturally consistent with animated storytelling.\n- Overall, physical consistency is acceptable and coherent, though not perfectly aligned across all moments (score around 3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.635} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::072_seed_42", "pair_id": "072_seed_42", "sample_index": 72, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling Tokyo street, alive with futuristic energy. Neon signs in vivid hues of electric blue, fiery red, and vibrant green illuminate the scene, casting dynamic reflections on rain-soaked pavement. Lens flares dance across the screen, enhancing the kaleidoscope of colors. Holographic advertisements hover above, projecting animated visuals that captivate passersby. The street is a symphony of motion, with sleek, autonomous vehicles gliding silently alongside pedestrians in avant-garde fashion. The air buzzes with the hum of technology, while the aroma of street food wafts through the crowd, adding to the sensory overload of this vibrant, fast-paced urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_072_seed_42_The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling To.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 395, "t": 404, "p": 446}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze the video frames against the provided text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a bustling Tokyo street\" with neon-lit signage, rain-soaked pavement, and a technologically advanced urban environment featuring holographic advertisements, sleek autonomous vehicles, and futuristic fashion. In practice, the video communicates these ideas at a moderate level and does not fully realize all specifics. Overall fidelity is adequate but not exact; some elements are present while others are approximated.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid (4). The resolution is decent and colors are vivid, with convincing neon lighting and wet-pavement reflections. There is some motion blur during camera movement and occasional slight softness, yet the frames remain coherent and legible. The sequence is stable enough to preserve continuity, and the lighting/contrast remains consistent throughout. No major distortions or abrupt brightness shifts are evident. Some distant details may be less sharp, but the overall image quality is strong.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment is moderate (3). The video captures several core aspects of the prompt—Tokyo street ambience, neon lighting, rain reflections, and a tech-forward vibe with autonomous-looking vehicles and holographic-like displays. However, certain elements are underrepresented or approximated: the depiction of holographic hover-advertisements is not clearly realized, and some pedestrian details are simplified. The pacing conveys busyness, but the execution does not tightly match every described detail, resulting in an average level of alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nPhysical consistency is strong (4). Vehicle dynamics, proportions, lighting interactions, and environmental physics align with real-world expectations. Rain effects, reflections, and spatial relationships behave plausibly, and there are no obvious violations of physical logic. Minor rendering nuances exist but do not undermine overall coherence.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 3\nPhysical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.614} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::073_seed_310", "pair_id": "073_seed_310", "sample_index": 73, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A lone cowboy, clad in a weathered hat and rugged attire, rides his sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, the golden hues of sunset painting the sky in vibrant oranges and pinks. The camera captures the gentle sway of prairie grasses, bathed in the soft, warm light of the setting sun. As the cowboy and his horse move gracefully, their silhouettes are etched against the horizon, creating a striking contrast with the colorful sky. The scene evokes a sense of freedom and tranquility, with the distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow, completing the breathtaking landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_073_seed_310_A lone cowboy clad in a weathered hat and rugged a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 408, "t": 419, "p": 431}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A lone cowboy, clad in a weathered hat and rugged attire, rides his sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, the golden hues of sunset painting the sky in vibrant oranges and pinks. The camera captures the gentle sway of prairie grasses, bathed in the soft, warm light of the setting sun. As the cowboy and his horse move gracefully, their silhouettes are etched against the horizon, creating a striking contrast with the colorful sky. The scene evokes a sense of freedom and tranquility, with the distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow, completing the breathtaking landscape.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong and consistent with a 4/5 rating. The frames maintain good resolution and clarity, with only occasional minor softness in distant areas. Local sharpness remains solid across the sequence, and motion appears smooth with stable framing. Lighting and contrast hold steady under warm sunset tones, with no noticeable distortion or misalignment. While not flawless, the visuals read as high quality and serviceable for the depicted scene.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent (score 5). All key elements described—cowboy on horseback, weathered attire, open plain, sunset lighting with orange/pink hues, gentle sway of prairie grasses, visible movement, and horizon silhouettes—are present and accurately represented. The scene maintains coherent geometry, lighting logic, and spatial relationships throughout, producing a faithful translation of the textual description into visuals.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is solid (score 4). Movement dynamics, lighting interactions, and environmental cues follow plausible physical behavior. There may be very subtle timing or minor artifact hints in a few frames, but none undermine the overall coherence or believability of the scene.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.137} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::074_seed_930", "pair_id": "074_seed_930", "sample_index": 74, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns mingle and dance gracefully. The camera begins its slow ascent, capturing the shimmer of crystal glasses and the soft glow of candlelit tables. As it pans upward, the grandeur of the room unfolds, revealing a stunning chandelier, its crystals sparkling like stars, gently swaying above the polished marble dance floor. The opulent scene is further enhanced by the soft strains of a live orchestra, filling the air with a melody that complements the elegance and sophistication of the evening.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_074_seed_930_In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate g.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 368, "t": 379, "p": 391}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a magnificent ballroom with intricate gold moldings, rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns, a slow camera ascent, shimmering crystal glasses, candlelit tables, a grand chandelier, a polished marble dance floor, and a live orchestra. The video covers most of these elements, but some details are only partially realized in practice.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score ~3). The sequence largely maintains adequate resolution and clarity, and warm lighting helps atmosphere. There are occasional minor artifacts and slight motion blur during dancing moments, and a few frames show reduced sharpness. The camera movement is smooth and the scene remains coherent, though a small number of frames exhibit mild distortions or less natural posing.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score ~4). Most key elements are present: the ballroom setting with gold moldings and drapes, formally dressedguests, the slow ascent, visible crystal decorations, lit tables, the chandelier, and the live orchestra. A couple of details diverge slightly (e.g., the exact dress length or shade of fabrics), but these do not significantly detract from the overall coherence with the prompt.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nPhysical coherence is moderate (score ~3). The scene remains plausible, with natural motion and interactions. However, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in posing, timing, or spatial relationships between dancers and props. Lighting and shadows generally align with the setting, but a few frames show subtle misalignments that prevent higher consistency.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.08} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::076_seed_42", "pair_id": "076_seed_42", "sample_index": 76, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera soars above a lively medieval marketplace, capturing vibrant stalls brimming with colorful fabrics, fresh produce, and handcrafted goods. Merchants in traditional garb enthusiastically barter with animated townsfolk, while children weave through the crowd, laughter echoing. The scene transitions smoothly, morphing into a bustling modern cityscape. Towering skyscrapers pierce the sky, their glass facades reflecting the vibrant hues of neon lights. The streets below teem with life, cars weaving through traffic, and pedestrians navigating the urban jungle. The juxtaposition of eras highlights the evolution of commerce and community, from quaint cobblestones to sleek, illuminated avenues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_076_seed_42_The camera soars above a lively medieval marketpla.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 356, "t": 367, "p": 379}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a camera moving over a lively medieval marketplace with vibrant stalls, then transitioning to a bustling modern cityscape, showing tall skyscrapers, busy streets with cars, and pedestrians navigating an urban environment. The evolution of commerce and community is highlighted through the contrast between cobblestones and sleek illuminated avenues.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The frames show decent resolution but clear motion blur during camera movement. The initial marketplace scenes have warmer lighting and a more intimate feel, while the later cityscape scenes adopt cooler daylight tones. Some transitions feel slightly abrupt due to the blur and shift in lighting. Distortion from the camera trajectory is present but not overwhelming. The sequence communicates the described progression, though sharpness varies across shots.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt overall (score 4). It clearly depicts a marketplace with stalls and activity, followed by a transition to a modern cityscape with skyscrapers, busy streets, and pedestrians. The evolution from medieval to modern urban environment is evident; only minor deviations exist, such as occasional variations in camera perspective or lighting that do not significantly detract from the narrative coherence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scenes maintain plausible spatial relationships, and the camera motion is generally coherent with a typical aerial-to-ground transition. However, there are occasional inconsistencies in scale and perspective, and some interactions (e.g., relative sizes of figures to architecture) feel slightly off. These issues are moderate rather than severe, resulting in an overall mid-level consistency assessment (3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.04} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::077_seed_310", "pair_id": "077_seed_310", "sample_index": 77, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A professional ballet dancer, dressed in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers, performs a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio. Her elegant form is silhouetted against the large windows, through which golden sunlight streams, casting long shadows on the polished wooden floor. The camera captures her mid-air, her arms gracefully extended, and her expression serene and focused. Her hair is pulled back into a neat bun, emphasizing the fluidity and precision of her movements. The studio's airy ambiance, with its high ceilings and minimalist decor, enhances the ethereal quality of her performance, highlighting the dancer's grace and strength.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_077_seed_310_A professional ballet dancer dressed in a flowing.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 403, "t": 414, "p": 426}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency. Text Prompt Analysis: The prompt describes a professional ballet dancer in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers performing a grand jeté across a sunlit studio, with the dancer's form silhouetted against large windows and golden sunlight streaming in, creating dramatic shadows on a polished wooden floor, captured mid-air with arms extended, serene and focused expression, hair in a bun, and an ethereal atmosphere in a spacious, minimalist studio. Frame Analysis: Across the sequence, the dancer remains in a white leotard and tutu, pointe shoes are visible; the studio setting with large windows and natural light is evident; the choreography appears to include grand jetés and other ballet positions; the dancer maintains a serene expression and polished appearance. Visual Quality Assessment: Overall, the video achieves very high visual fidelity. Resolution is sharp, lighting is natural and balanced, color grading supports a warm, sunlit mood, and there are no noticeable artifacts or distortions. Motion is smooth and the framing remains consistent, contributing to an excellent visual presentation. Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment: The visuals align closely with the prompt: attire, environment, and movement reflect professional ballet practice, with precise execution of the requested dynamics. The scene conveys an authentic, high-quality ballet performance and adheres to the described aesthetic and choreographic cues. Physical Consistency (Common-sense): The biomechanics and dynamics are generally plausible, with controlled grand jetés and graceful transitions. However, there are minor subtleties in joint articulation and timing that prevent perfect anatomical precision, resulting in solid but not flawless physical consistency. Ground-truth scores: Visual Quality 5, Text-to-Video Alignment 5, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.824} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::078_seed_930", "pair_id": "078_seed_930", "sample_index": 78, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crimson sky, where sleek flying cars zip through neon-lit avenues, casting vibrant reflections on the metallic surfaces below. The camera glides through this bustling metropolis, capturing the intricate dance of vehicles weaving between towering structures. As it zooms in, a colossal skyscraper emerges, its facade adorned with dynamic holographic advertisements that flicker and shift, showcasing interstellar products and services. The building's glassy exterior mirrors the kaleidoscope of colors from the streets, while digital billboards project futuristic imagery, creating a mesmerizing blend of technology and architecture in this otherworldly urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_078_seed_930_A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crim.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 518, "t": 529, "p": 541}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze the provided video frames against the text prompt to evaluate each dimension.\n\nThe text prompt describes: \"A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crimson sky, where sleek flying cars zip through neon-lit avenues, casting vibrant reflections on the metallic surfaces below. The camera glides through this bustling metropolis, capturing the intricate dance of vehicles weaving between towering structures. As it zooms in, a colossal skyscraper emerges, its facade adorned with dynamic holographic advertisements that flicker and shift, showcasing interstellar products and services. The building's glassy exterior mirrors the kaleidoscope of colors from the streets, while digital billboards project futuristic imagery, creating a mesmerizing blend of technology and architecture in this otherworldly urban landscape\" \n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nLooking at the frames, I can see some issues but they are less severe than described. There is noticeable motion blur during camera movement, yet many key details remain discernible. A few frames show mild distortions and some artifacts, but the overall resolution allows recognition of structural elements. Lighting and contrast vary across shots; occasional color bleeding and minor artifacting occur, though not uniformly across the entire sequence. Some frames exhibit slight irregular geometry or warping, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, the visual quality sits at a mid level (score around 3).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video captures elements of a futuristic urban setting, but the alignment with the prompt is only moderate. The crimson sky and tall buildings are present, and holographic displays are visible, but several prompt specifics are not consistently realized: vehicle dynamics and their interaction with the road surface are unclear due to motion blur, and some architectural details and lighting cues feel approximate rather than faithful. The result shows partial alignment with the textual description, but not a tight one-to-one correspondence (mid-level alignment).\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:**\nThere are occasional inconsistencies in physics and spatial relationships, yet they are not pervasive. Vehicle motion, reflections, and perspective occasionally clash with the implied environment, producing a few moments of questionable realism. The scene remains intelligible and coherent enough to convey a futuristic city, though some elements strain credulity under real-world physics.\n\nIn summary, the evaluation reflects mid-level quality across all three dimensions, consistent with ground-truth scores of 3 for Visual Quality, Text-to-Video Alignment, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.041} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::080_seed_42", "pair_id": "080_seed_42", "sample_index": 80, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A mesmerizing flame wisp, glowing with ethereal light, darts through a bustling fantasy market under the starry night sky. The camera follows its swift, graceful movements, illuminating vibrant stalls brimming with exotic goods, colorful fabrics, and mystical artifacts. The market is alive with fantastical creatures and lively merchants, their animated conversations and laughter filling the air. Lanterns cast a warm, golden glow, enhancing the magical atmosphere. The flame wisp weaves through the crowd, its fiery trail reflecting off shimmering surfaces, creating a captivating dance of light and shadow in this enchanting, otherworldly marketplace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_080_seed_42_A mesmerizing flame wisp glowing with ethereal lig.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 377, "t": 389, "p": 434}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully across the three dimensions based on the provided frames.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt envisions a mesmerizing flame wisp moving through a bustling fantasy market under a starry night sky, with a camera following its movement. It describes vibrant stalls, exotic goods, colorful fabrics, mystical artifacts, and a lively marketplace populated by fantastical creatures and animated interactions, illuminated by lanterns and a warm, magical ambiance.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, visual quality is moderate. Early frames retain reasonable detail, but there is noticeable degradation toward the end. Motion blur increases and some frames become blurrier or slightly distorted; the final segments show reduced clarity. While not catastrophic, these issues keep the overall visual quality at a middle level rather than high fidelity throughout the video.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe scene captures several key elements of the prompt—fantasy market setting, starry night atmosphere, and a central flame-wisp-like element weaving through the scene, with camera motion following the light source. However, some nuanced components (e.g., intricate character interactions and subtle environmental details) are intermittently obscured by the quality fluctuations. Overall, the alignment remains acceptable but not perfect.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nThe scene maintains coherent spatial layout and object persistence for most of the duration. Objects respond plausibly to lighting, and the flame-wisp element moves smoothly through the environment. Minor inconsistencies appear only sporadically due to the late-stage quality drop, but they do not fundamentally break the sense of physical continuity.\n\nScoring Considerations:\nVisual quality shows early promise but degrades toward the end, yielding a moderate overall impression. Text-to-video correspondence reflects core prompt cues while missing some finer details. Physical dynamics remain largely consistent with only occasional interruptions.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 3\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 3\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 3\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.463} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::081_seed_310", "pair_id": "081_seed_310", "sample_index": 81, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a noir-style scene, a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walks down a dimly lit alley, the cobblestones glistening from recent rain. The camera captures the interplay of shadows across his chiseled features as he pauses under a flickering streetlamp. He lights a cigarette, the flame briefly illuminating his stern expression and the smoke curling upwards, adding to the mysterious atmosphere. The distant sound of a saxophone echoes through the alley, enhancing the moody ambiance. His eyes, sharp and observant, scan the surroundings, revealing a man deeply engrossed in his thoughts, as the city’s secrets linger in the shadows.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_081_seed_310_In a noir-style scene a detective in a classic tre.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 550, "t": 562, "p": 607}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the given text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a noir-style scene, a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walks down a dimly lit alley, the cobblestones glistening from recent rain. The camera captures the interplay of shadows across his chiseled features as he pauses under a flickering streetlamp. He lights a cigarette, the flame briefly illuminating his stern expression and the smoke curling upwards, adding to the mysterious atmosphere. The distant sound of a saxophone echoes through the alley, enhancing the moody ambiance. His eyes, sharp and observant, scan the surroundings, revealing a man deeply engrossed in his thoughts, as the city’s secrets linger in the shadows.\"\nThe video captures the majority of these elements with high fidelity, though there are minor deviations in some moments.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is excellent (score 5). The frames maintain high resolution and clear detail throughout, with stable lighting and color grading that reinforces the noir mood. The cinematography effectively conveys depth and atmosphere, and the actor’s facial features remain discernible with natural-looking skin tones. There are only very minor inconsistencies in a few frames (e.g., occasional subtle shadow variations or tiny artifact hints) that do not meaningfully detract from the overall impression. The sequence progresses smoothly without obvious jumps, contributing to a cohesive viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong but not flawless (score 4). All core elements are present—noir styling, a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora, a dim alley setting with wet cobblestones, lighting interactions, the act of lighting a cigarette, upward smoke, and the moody atmosphere with a streetlamp. The distant saxophone cue is implied by audio rather than shown visually, which aligns with the prompt’s intent but slightly reduces the perceived visual alignment. Some minor timing or expressive nuances may vary, but nothing undermines the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense) Evaluation:\nThe video demonstrates solid physical realism and internal coherence (score 4). The character’s movements and clothing dynamics feel plausible within the scene, and environmental elements like the wet cobblestones reflect rain realistically. Lighting and shadow behavior is consistent with the light sources, and the interaction between the detective and his surroundings remains believable. A few small inconsistencies exist (e.g., minor lighting shifts during rapid head motions or slight variations in rain reflections), yet they do not disrupt the viewer’s perception of realism or the overall narrative flow.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 5\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 24.458} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::082_seed_930", "pair_id": "082_seed_930", "sample_index": 82, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_082_seed_930_In a dimly lit industrial workshop a grinding whee.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 429, "t": 440, "p": 452}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video achieves excellent visual quality consistent with a top-tier rendering (score 5). The sequence shows high-resolution imagery with sharp details of the grinding wheel, sparks, and surrounding equipment, and lighting is stable with good contrast between bright sparks and the darker workshop environment. The motion appears smooth and there are no obvious artifacts or distortions. The color palette emphasizes oranges, yellows, and metallic tones, enhancing the visual appeal without compromising realism.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe visuals align very closely with the textual prompt: core elements—dim industrial setting, spinning grinding wheel, cascading sparks, vivid spark colors, and slow-motion presentation—are faithfully represented. Camera work effectively captures dynamic spark behavior and the interaction with metal surfaces, producing a convincing depiction of an industrial grinding process. Overall alignment is strong, reflecting a faithful translation of the prompt into video (score 5).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene exhibits coherent physical behavior: the grinding wheel rotation, material interaction, and subsequent sparks follow plausible industrial mechanics. Lighting dynamics from the sparks illuminate nearby surfaces realistically, and the motion patterns conform to expected mechanical principles. The combination of these factors yields a highly convincing and internally consistent portrayal of an industrial grinding scenario (score 5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.072} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::084_seed_42", "pair_id": "084_seed_42", "sample_index": 84, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man, wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pants, sprints through a dense forest, the camera capturing his intense, wide-eyed expressions as he navigates the uneven terrain. His breath is visible in the crisp air, and the sound of crunching leaves and snapping twigs accompanies his hurried pace. The towering trees, with their thick trunks and branches, blur into streaks of green and brown, emphasizing his speed and urgency. Sunlight filters through the canopy, casting dappled patterns on his face, highlighting his determination and the adrenaline coursing through him. His rapid heartbeat echoes, underscoring the tension of his wild dash through the wilderness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_084_seed_42_A man wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 430, "t": 441, "p": 453}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt. I need to evaluate the video across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a man wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pants sprinting through a dense forest. His intense, wide-eyed expression and the way he navigates the uneven terrain are central, with breath visible in crisply air and the sounds of crunching leaves and twigs accompanying his hurried pace. The scene features towering trees with thick trunks and branches, light filtering through the canopy, and a sense of speed and urgency. The description emphasizes the wild dash through the wilderness.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is average (score 3). The frames maintain decent resolution but exhibit noticeable motion blur during rapid movement and some softness in the later portions. Lighting remains natural with consistent brightness and contrast, and there are no major distortions or misalignments. The sequence is generally stable, though occasional blur and slight degradation reduce sharpness. In sum, visual quality is moderate rather than exceptional.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall. The video clearly depicts the key elements: a man in rugged outdoor attire moving through a dense forest, with visible effort and focus. The forest environment, lighting, and the sense of speed align with the description. Minor gaps exist in conveying explicit breath cues and the exact sensory details (e.g., crunching leaves, twigs), but these do not significantly detract from overall alignment. Given these nuances, the alignment score is consistent with a high but not perfect match. Score: 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nMovement appears plausible and coherent with running through rough terrain; body mechanics remain believable throughout. There are only minor inconsistencies in timing and foot-ground interaction in a few moments, but they do not undermine overall plausibility. The environmental physics and interactions respect basic expectations, yielding a solid level of common-sense consistency. Score: 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.859} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::085_seed_310", "pair_id": "085_seed_310", "sample_index": 85, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyon, its icy walls towering and glistening under a soft, muted light. As it soars, the scene transitions into a surreal cloudscape, where fluffy clouds drift lazily across a pastel sky. The motion is fluid and dynamic, capturing the ethereal beauty of the clouds. Suddenly, the view shifts to a serene forest, where tall trees sway gently in a whispering breeze, their leaves a muted green. The journey continues, seamlessly flowing into a tranquil desert, where rolling dunes stretch endlessly, bathed in the soft glow of a setting sun. The muted color palette ties each landscape together, creating a harmonious and dreamlike visual experience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_085_seed_310_The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyo.mp4", "v_score_model": 1.0, "t_score_model": 1.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 1, "t_score_hard": 1, "p_score_hard": 1, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 312, "t": 321, "p": 363}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a camera gliding through a majestic glacial canyon with icy walls, transitioning to a surreal cloudscape, then to a serene forest, and finally a tranquil desert. The video, however, fails to deliver these distinct landscapes; the imagery remains consistently abstract and lacks clear scene boundaries or recognizable terrain.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the entire video, the visuals show severe degradation. The resolution is very low, with persistent blur and pixelation. Details are indistinct, and the imagery looks painterly or heavily processed rather than natural. The sequence appears unstable, with abrupt fluctuations in clarity and composition that disrupt perceptual continuity. Overall, the visual quality is extremely poor and does not support reliable interpretation of the intended scenes.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThere is essentially no alignment with the prompt. The video presents a single, indistinct abstract landscape throughout, with no identifiable glacial canyon, no discernible forest, and no desert scene. While some light variations exist, they do not correspond to the described transitions or environments. The result is a complete misrepresentation of the requested visual narrative.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe imagery follows no coherent physical logic. Depth cues, gravity, scale, and environmental features are inconsistent, making it impossible to infer a plausible physical scenario. The visuals fail to maintain basic common-sense expectations for the depicted scenes.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 1\nText-to-Video Alignment: 1\nPhysical Consistency: 1\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 1\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 1\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 1\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 3.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.002} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::086_seed_930", "pair_id": "086_seed_930", "sample_index": 86, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at a grand piano on a sandy beach, her fingers dancing over the keys, creating a melody that harmonizes with the gentle waves. The camera begins to rotate around her, capturing her serene expression and the intricate details of her white lace dress. As it moves, the expansive ocean stretches endlessly, its surface shimmering under the soft, golden light of the setting sun. The sky is painted with pastel hues, adding to the whimsical atmosphere. Seagulls glide gracefully above, and the gentle breeze rustles her hair, completing the enchanting scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_086_seed_930_A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 396, "t": 407, "p": 419}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate each dimension carefully.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is strong (4). The footage maintains decent resolution and stable lighting across most of the sequence. There are occasional minor artifacts and subtle motion blur during the rotating camera moments, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. The beach setting, the woman, the piano, and the seagulls remain clearly discernible, with good contrast and natural color rendition. Seabirds show some slight rendering irregularities, yet they are not pervasive. In sum, the visuals are convincing and cohesive, though not flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt remains near-perfect (5). All key elements described are present and consistently depicted: a young woman with flowing hair seated at a grand piano on a sandy beach; her hands moving over the keys; waves in the background; a rotating camera revealing multiple angles; the serene expression; the white lace dress; an expansive ocean; pastel-hued sky; and visible seagulls. The overall correspondence between description and visuals is strong, with no meaningful deviations.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nPhysical consistency is solid (4). The scene adheres to plausible physics and human proportions: the woman’s pose and hand interactions with the piano are believable, and the environmental cues (wind affecting hair, ocean dynamics, lighting) are coherent. Minor inconsistencies exist in the seabird trajectories, which exhibit slight non-natural motion patterns that slightly detract from realism but do not break overall coherence.\n\nScoring Considerations:\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 5, and Physical Consistency 4. The revised assessment aligns with these values: strong alignment to the prompt, good but not perfect visual fidelity, and solid physical consistency with minor avian motion quirks.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.759} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::088_seed_42", "pair_id": "088_seed_42", "sample_index": 88, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds. As the perspective shifts, the seeds transform into floating islands, each adorned with shimmering, translucent structures that pulse with soft, ambient light. Tiny, luminescent particles drift gracefully through the air, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. The scene is bathed in a gentle, golden glow, casting a dreamlike atmosphere over the surreal landscape. The intricate details of the dandelion's inner world unfold, revealing a hidden universe of wonder and tranquility, where time seems to slow and the boundaries of reality blur.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_088_seed_42_The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed re.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0002, "p_score_model": 3.0001, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 347, "t": 358, "p": 370}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a high-speed camera zoom into a dandelion, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its seeds. Seeds transform into floating islands with shimmering, translucent structures pulsing with soft light; tiny luminescent particles drift through the air; a gentle golden glow creates a dream-like atmosphere; the scene reveals an intricate, almost microscopic interior world with a sense of wonder and tranquility.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visual quality is strong but not flawless. The resolution is good and the dandelion is clearly visible with detailed seed heads and a natural depth of field. Lighting remains consistent across frames, and colors stay within a warm golden palette. There are no obvious distortions or artifacts, and motion is smooth, but occasional minor imperfections prevent a perfect top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThere is partial alignment with the prompt. The video does show a close-up of a dandelion and some movement toward it, but key imaginative elements are missing: there are no visible floating islands, no transformation of seeds into islands, and no luminescent particles drifting through space. The result is a largely literal interpretation with limited surreal or transformative content. Overall alignment is moderate rather than full.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nThe imagery maintains plausible botanical structure and lighting, with consistent anatomy and shading. Nevertheless, the piece lacks the intended fantastical dynamics and metamorphic progression described in the prompt, resulting in a moderate level of physical-consistency with room for more imaginative, dynamic rendering.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0003, "elapsed_sec": 11.678} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::089_seed_310", "pair_id": "089_seed_310", "sample_index": 89, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a dimly lit tunnel, the walls a blur of shadow and light. Emerging into a sprawling labyrinth, the scene transforms into a chaotic dance of rapidly growing vines, twisting and curling with a life of their own. The camera navigates through disorienting angles, capturing the vines' relentless expansion, their tendrils reaching out like eager fingers. Fast transitions between shots create a dizzying effect, as the viewer is plunged deeper into the maze, the vibrant green of the vines contrasting starkly against the dark, earthy tones of the labyrinth. The atmosphere is both thrilling and unsettling, as the camera weaves through this living, breathing puzzle.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_089_seed_310_The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a di.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 503, "t": 514, "p": 497}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nLet me first understand what the text prompt asks for:\n\"The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a dimly lit tunnel, the walls a blur of shadow and light. Emerging into a sprawling labyrinth, the scene transforms into a chaotic dance of rapidly growing vines, twisting and curling with a life of their own. The camera navigates through disorienting angles, capturing the vines' relentless expansion, their tendrils reaching out like eager fingers. Fast transitions between shots create a dizzying effect, as the viewer is plunged deeper into the maze, the vibrant green of the vines contrasting starkly against the dark, earthy tones of the labyrinth. The atmosphere is both thrilling and unsettling, as the camera weaves through this living, breathing puzzle\" \n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video presents an average level of visual quality. There is noticeable motion blur and some softness throughout, which reduces sharpness but remains within acceptable bounds. The resolution is variable and fine details vary, yet the scene remains legible. Color grading uses strong greens and earth tones, contributing to contrast and mood. While the blur limits detail perception, it does not render the video unreadable, keeping the sequence readable and coherent.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns with several prompt components (high-speed traversal, tunnel and labyrinth traversal, and the presence of vegetation). However, key prompt aspects are not fully realized: the depiction of a truly chaotic, organic dance of vines and the perception of an alive, breathing puzzle are not strongly conveyed due to the heavy blur. Overall alignment is moderate; essential structural cues are visible but the imaginative choreography and organic progression are underrepresented.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nSpatial dynamics and motion feel plausible given the abstract setting. The blur introduces depth ambiguity, reducing the perceived realism, but there are no clear logical contradictions in the traversal or the interaction of light, shadow, and vegetation with the environment. The overall physical consistency is moderate, with some perceptual obscurity due to effects rather than fundamental inconsistencies in physics.\n\nIn summary, the three dimensions reflect an average performance across the board, with some gaps in conveying the more imaginative aspects of the prompt while maintaining coherent spatial and physical behavior.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 7.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.305} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::090_seed_930", "pair_id": "090_seed_930", "sample_index": 90, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a vibrant, humid rainforest, a sloth leisurely traverses a thick branch, its every movement deliberate and unhurried. The camera captures the intricate details of its coarse, moss-tinted fur, each strand glistening with moisture under the soft, cinematic lighting that filters through the dense canopy above. The lush green foliage surrounds the sloth, creating a rich tapestry of verdant hues, while the gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds provide a serene soundtrack. As the sloth pauses, its soulful eyes reflect the tranquility of its environment, embodying the essence of the rainforest's timeless, unhurried rhythm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_090_seed_930_In a vibrant humid rainforest a sloth leisurely tr.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 3.9997, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 492, "t": 503, "p": 423}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video frame by frame based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a vibrant, humid rainforest, a sloth leisurely traverses a thick branch, its every movement deliberate and unhurried. The camera captures the intricate details of its coarse, moss-tinted fur, each strand glistening with moisture under the soft, cinematic lighting that filters through the dense canopy above. The lush green foliage surrounds the sloth, creating a rich tapestry of verdant hues, while the gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds provide a serene soundtrack. As the sloth pauses, its soulful eyes reflect the tranquility of its environment, embodying the essence of the rainforest's timeless, unhurried rhythm\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video demonstrates high-resolution imagery with sharp details in most frames. Overall clarity is strong, and motion remains smooth across scenes. The footage remains stable with consistent framing and lighting. There is some depth-of-field blur in the background, which reads as a deliberate cinematographic choice rather than a defect. A few frames show minor softness around edges, but these do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a high-but-not-perfect standard (4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully reflects the prompt throughout: rainforest setting with lush vegetation, a sloth on a branch, deliberate and unhurried movement, close-up fur texture, mossy greens, soft filtered light, and a rich verdant palette. The pacing, composition, and environmental details consistently match the textual description, yielding an excellent alignment score that effectively matches a top-tier depiction (5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe portrayal maintains plausible anatomy and behavior: the sloth’s body proportions, grip on the branch, fur texture, and interaction with moisture are coherent with a living creature in a humid forest. Lighting, shadows, and environmental interactions support perceptual realism, resulting in solid but not flawless physical consistency (4).\n\nOverall Assessment:\nThe video achieves strong fidelity to the prompt with high visual quality and robust alignment. Physical consistency is solid but not perfect, indicating minor deviations in fine-grained realism that prevent a perfect rating. The result is a high-quality rendition that closely matches the intended scene and narrative.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9997, "elapsed_sec": 16.18} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::092_seed_42", "pair_id": "092_seed_42", "sample_index": 92, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor expertly navigates a molten lava flow, the intense heat shimmering around him. The camera follows closely, capturing the surreal juxtaposition of metal against the fiery backdrop. His visor reflects the glowing red and orange hues of the lava, while the armor's intricate engravings glint in the volcanic light. As he maneuvers skillfully, the molten rock crackles beneath his board, sending sparks into the air. The camera captures every detail, from the heat waves distorting the air to the intense focus in his eyes, creating a breathtaking scene of bravery and elemental power.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_092_seed_42_A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor ex.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 2.0, "p_score_model": 4.0013, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 2, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 385, "t": 396, "p": 341}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a scene with a figure clad in medieval armor navigating a molten lava environment. The video, however, primarily portrays armored combat in a fiery setting, with no clear surfboard or active navigation through lava; some atmospheric cues (heat haze, reflective visor) appear but do not realize the core action described. Overall, alignment with the prompt is weak.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe rendering maintains solid clarity and consistent lighting across frames. The metallic textures on the armor read convincingly, and fire effects contribute to depth and atmosphere. There are minor motion blur during fast movements and occasional slight softness in distant areas, but these do not significantly detract from readability. Color grading supports the fiery mood, and the sequence remains cohesive visually. Given the ground-truth scores, Visual Quality is rated 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThere are clear misalignments between the prompt and the video. The central element of a lava-flow navigation on a board is not realized; instead, the video centers on armored combat within a fiery environment. Some surface details (reflective visor, molten ambiance, heat distortions) align superficially, but the overall action and scenario do not match the prompt. Therefore Text-to-Video Alignment is rated 2.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical behavior: armor and movement appear credible, fire dynamics maintain internal coherence, and interactions respect expected mechanical constraints. No obvious physics violations are present, supporting a high level of common-sense consistency. This yields a rating of 4.\n\nOverall, the evaluation aligns with the ground-truth scores: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 2, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 2\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0013, "elapsed_sec": 13.414} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::093_seed_310", "pair_id": "093_seed_310", "sample_index": 93, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A vintage teddy bear, with worn fur and a stitched smile, sits on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt. As golden sunlight streams through delicate lace curtains, casting intricate patterns on the walls, the bear's eyes flutter open, revealing a spark of life. The camera slowly pulls back, capturing the room's whimsical charm, as the bear begins to move, its limbs stretching and head turning with newfound animation. The gentle rustle of the curtains and the soft glow of the morning light create a magical atmosphere, as the bear embarks on its enchanting journey within the cozy, sunlit room.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_093_seed_310_A vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0008, "p_score_model": 4.0025, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 438, "t": 447, "p": 457}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText prompt: \"A vintage teddy bear, with worn fur and a stitched smile, sits on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt. As golden sunlight streams through delicate lace curtains, casting intricate patterns on the walls, the bear's eyes flutter open, revealing a spark of life. The camera slowly pulls back, capturing the room's whimsical charm, as the bear begins to move, its limbs stretching and head turning with newfound animation. The gentle rustle of the curtains and the soft glow of the morning light create a magical atmosphere, as the bear embarks on its enchanting journey within the cozy, sunlit room\" \n\nLooking at the frames:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\n- Resolution remains high and the visuals are generally crisp\n- Lighting is warm and consistent with golden sunlight streaming through the curtains\n- The teddy bear shows good detail in fur texture and facial features\n- Background elements (bed, pillows, quilt, curtains) render with clear color and texture\n- A few frames show minor motion blur during rapid head turns; otherwise stability and contrast are solid\n- Overall, Visual Quality is strong but not flawless\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\n- Elements from the prompt are well represented: vintage teddy bear, worn fur, stitched smile, child's bed with pastel pillows and patchwork quilt, golden sunlight, delicate lace curtains, wall patterns, bear's eyes opening\n- The scene includes the camera slow pull-back and the bear's movement with limb stretching and head turns\n- Movement and lighting convey a magical atmosphere and align closely with the narrative\n- Minor deviations exist but they do not detract from the overall alignment\n\n**Physical Consistency Analysis:**\n- The bear's proportions and fur rendering remain coherent throughout\n- Movements feel organic, with plausible limb extension and head turns\n- Lighting and shadows support depth and spatial realism\n- No obvious physics violations or inconsistencies disrupt immersion\n- Overall, physical consistency is solid and convincing\n\nground-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0033, "elapsed_sec": 15.296} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::094_seed_930", "pair_id": "094_seed_930", "sample_index": 94, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a mesmerizing macro view, delicate water droplets cling to a spider's web, each droplet shimmering like a tiny universe. As the camera zooms in, the droplets begin to transform, revealing swirling galaxies within, with stars twinkling and spiraling in cosmic dance. The web, intricately woven, serves as a celestial canvas, its strands glistening like silken threads of the cosmos. The dimly lit background enhances the ethereal glow of the galaxies, casting a soft, mysterious light that accentuates the delicate beauty of this otherworldly transformation. The scene captures the enchanting fusion of nature and the universe in a breathtaking display.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_094_seed_930_In a mesmerizing macro view delicate water droplet.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 451, "t": 462, "p": 474}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a mesmerizing macro view\" with several specific elements:\n1. Delicate water droplets clinging to a spider's web\n2. Each droplet shimmering like a tiny universe\n3. Camera zooming in and droplets transforming into swirling galaxies\n4. Stars twinkling and spiral galaxies\n5. An intricate woven web serving as a celestial canvas\n6. Silken threads of the cosmos and ethereal glow\n7. Dimly lit background\n8. Soft, mysterious light\n9. Breathtaking display of nature and universe fusion\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall visual quality is solid (4). The frames maintain sharpness and consistent lighting, with clear depiction of the web structure and water droplets. There is mild depth-of-field blur in peripheral areas, which is expected given the macro focus, but it does not detract from the overall clarity. The imagery is coherent across frames with no obvious artifacts or instability; brightness and contrast remain steady. The result is a high-quality presentation, though not a pristine or flawless render.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is moderate (3). The sequence conveys a macro view, visible water droplets, and a textured surface reminiscent of a web. However, key prompt elements—clear depiction of droplets as the primary subject, dynamic cosmic transformations, and an explicit progression to galaxy-like structures—are not clearly realized in the frames. While some cosmic motifs are present, they do not dominate the narrative, yielding a moderate level of alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nPhysical realism remains strong (4). Water droplet behavior, wetted surface interactions, and the interaction between light, reflections, and surface texture follow expected physical principles. The scene maintains plausible spatial relationships and depth cues, and there are no evident violations of real-world physics.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video demonstrates solid technical execution and robust physical consistency, with visual quality rated at 4 and alignment at 3, reflecting a technically proficient but narrative-movement gap relative to the prompt.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.818} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::096_seed_42", "pair_id": "096_seed_42", "sample_index": 96, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A mesmerizing dancer, clad in a flowing crimson dress, twirls elegantly on a dimly lit stage, her movements fluid and captivating. The camera circles her, capturing each graceful step and spin, as vibrant, multicolored lights cast dynamic patterns across the stage. Wisps of smoke swirl around her, adding an ethereal quality to the performance. Her expressive face reflects passion and intensity, while the lights shift from deep blues to fiery oranges, enhancing the dramatic atmosphere. The camera captures her every move, from delicate hand gestures to powerful leaps, against the backdrop of swirling smoke and vibrant, ever-changing lights.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_096_seed_42_A mesmerizing dancer clad in a flowing crimson dre.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0003, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 2.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 346, "t": 358, "p": 429}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a mesmerizing dancer wearing a flowing crimson dress, twirling on a dim stage with dynamic lighting and smoky atmosphere. While the frames capture several key elements — the dancer, red dress, stage lighting, and smoke — some aspects are not consistently realized throughout the sequence, yielding a moderate level of alignment overall.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the video, the overall visual quality is acceptable but not outstanding. Resolution is adequate and colors are reasonably vivid, yet motion blur appears during rapid movements and some frames show softened detail. Lighting and atmospheric effects (smoke, colored beams) contribute to the scene, but the clarity varies between shots. Transitions remain smooth enough to maintain a continuous performance feel. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a mid-range rating rather than high fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nMost core elements from the prompt are present — dancer, flowing red dress, stage setting with lighting and smoke — and the camera follows the action. However, certain aspects described in the prompt (e.g., precise lighting shifts from deep blues to fiery oranges, and the exact portrayal of fluid, elegant movement) are inconsistently realized across the video, resulting in only moderate correspondence between description and execution.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThere are notable inconsistencies in physical realism. In several frames, body proportions and limb positioning appear slightly off, and occasional motion artifacts disrupt the believability of the dance dynamics. While the scene remains plausible overall, these issues detract from full physical authenticity.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 3\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 3\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 2\n\nOverall assessment yields Visual Quality = 3, Text-to-Video Alignment = 3, and Physical Consistency = 2.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0003, "elapsed_sec": 13.451} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::097_seed_310", "pair_id": "097_seed_310", "sample_index": 97, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers, their petals swaying gracefully in the gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion across the landscape. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality of the scene. As the camera glides over the field, the flowers' delicate hues blend seamlessly with the lush green foliage, forming a stunning tapestry of color. The rhythmic movement of the petals, reminiscent of ocean waves, evokes a sense of tranquility and wonder, as if nature itself is performing a serene dance under the vast, open sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_097_seed_310_An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0004, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 378, "t": 386, "p": 460}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers, their petals swaying gracefully in the gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion across the landscape. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality of the scene. As the camera glides over the field, the flowers' delicate hues blend seamlessly with the lush green foliage, forming a stunning tapestry of color. The rhythmic movement of the petals, reminiscent of ocean waves, evokes a sense of tranquility and wonder, as if nature itself is performing a serene dance under the vast, open sky\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, the visuals maintain a cohesive look, but the overall sharpness sits at a mid level. There is some softness and mild blur that reduce fine detail, yet colors remain pleasing and consistent. The lighting stays warm and the depth-of-field effect reads naturally, with no major artifacts or distortions. Overall, the video presents a moderate visual quality rather than high fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt: an elevated viewpoint, an expansive field of pink flowers, visible petal movement, and a flowing, wave-like motion. The warm sunlight and dreamy mood are evident. The camera gliding and color blending are represented convincingly, with only minor deviations that prevent a perfect match. Overall alignment is strong.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains believable physics: flowers sway plausibly, lighting interacts realistically, and the color palette harmonizes with natural expectations. A few micro-motions could be refined, but they do not undermine realism. Overall, physical consistency is solid.\n\nDetailed Scoring Breakdown:\nVisual quality: 3; Text-to-video alignment: 4; Physical consistency: 4\n\nFinal assessment:\nThe video delivers the core creative vision with notable fidelity to the prompt, while showing room for improvement in fine-grained detail and micro-physics realism.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.000399999999999, "elapsed_sec": 14.344} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::098_seed_930", "pair_id": "098_seed_930", "sample_index": 98, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit studio, an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses perched on their nose, meticulously carves a sculpture from a block of marble. The camera captures the precision of each movement, focusing on the artist's skilled hands as they wield a chisel and mallet with practiced ease. Dust particles dance in the soft, ambient light, highlighting the artist's intense concentration. As the sculpture gradually emerges, the camera pans over the intricate details, revealing the delicate curves and textures taking shape. The artist pauses occasionally, stepping back to assess their work, their face a portrait of focused determination and creative passion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_098_seed_930_In a dimly lit studio an artist wearing a worn apr.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 529, "t": 540, "p": 552}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a dimly lit studio, an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses perched on their nose, meticulously carves a sculpture from a block of marble. The camera captures the precision of each movement, focusing on the artist's skilled hands as they wield a chisel and mallet with practiced ease. Dust particles dance in the soft, ambient light, highlighting the artist's intense concentration. As the sculpture gradually emerges, the camera pans over the intricate details, revealing the delicate curves and textures taking shape. The artist pauses occasionally, stepping back to assess their work, their face a portrait of focused determination and creative passion\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- Overall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The renderings are coherent with acceptable detail, though some frames exhibit mild softness or subtle artifacts that prevent a higher fidelity impression.\n- The resolution remains sufficient for recognizing the sculpting activity, but occasional minor blur or slight noise reduces perceived sharpness.\n- Lighting is generally stable with warm tones across the sequence; however, there are a few frames where contrast or shading is slightly inconsistent, affecting depth cues.\n- Motion appears reasonably smooth and lighting remains stable, yet a few frames show small, non-critical inconsistencies in hand positioning or tool orientation.\n- In sum, the video presents a plausible depiction of the scene, but it does not achieve high-end visual fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- The video aligns strongly with the prompt: all key elements described—dim studio ambience, worn apron, glasses perched, active carving with a chisel and mallet, visible dust particles, soft ambient illumination, close-ups of hands and sculpture, and moments of assessment—are present.\n- The overall narrative arc from setup to careful evaluation is evident, and the alignment between the textual description and visual content is solid throughout.\n- Given these observations, Text-to-Video Alignment score is high (4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\n- The scene adheres to plausible physical behavior: the sculptor’s posture, grip, and tool use read as authentic, and the interaction between chisel and marble appears believable under the described lighting.\n- Minor micro-issues exist (e.g., occasional slight misalignment of the tool angle or brief, subtle inconsistencies in hand positioning) that do not significantly undermine plausibility.\n- Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency remains moderate (score 3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.755} diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_1_summary.json b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_1_summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3860805025219f21c1c63b054d474bfb149ad43a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_1_summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "total_score_tasks": 75, + "success_score_tasks": 75, + "failed_score_tasks": 0, + "model_name_or_path": "/root/ckpts/VideoScore2", + "scores_jsonl": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_1_scores.jsonl", + "shard_count": 8, + "shard_index": 1, + "infer_fps": 2.0, + "floating_method": "weighted", + "do_sample": true, + "score_latency_sec": { + "mean": 15.26876, + "median": 15.041, + "min": 9.448, + "max": 24.458 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_2_scores.jsonl b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_2_scores.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..870f71e82b731de0724eb3ed834c28defb90ae92 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_2_scores.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::000_seed_310", "pair_id": "000_seed_310", "sample_index": 0, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey across a polished wooden tabletop, reflecting the ambient light and casting delicate shadows. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's gentle, mesmerizing roll. As it moves, the ball's surface mirrors the room's soft hues and subtle textures, creating a dynamic interplay of light and shadow. The tabletop's smooth grain enhances the ball's seamless glide, while the ambient sounds of a quiet room add to the tranquil atmosphere. The ball's path is unpredictable yet graceful, embodying a serene dance of motion and stillness in a harmonious setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_000_seed_310_A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey acro.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.99, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 268, "t": 348, "p": 447}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A crystal-clear glass ball \n- Beginning its journey across a polished wooden tabletop\n- Reflecting ambient light and casting delicate shadows\n- Camera remains fixed, capturing gentle, mesmerizing roll\n- Ball's surface mirrors room's soft hues and subtle textures\n- Dynamic interplay of light and shadow\n- Smoothness of the ball's path and the polisshd tabletop\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are strong with high fidelity in most aspects:\n- Resolution is high and details in the glass ball and wooden surface are crisp\n- Glass ball shows convincing transparency and reflections; lighting is generally well-rendered\n- Wooden texture appears convincingly smooth and polished\n- Shadows are present and interact plausibly with the light source\n- Focus remains sharp throughout with good depth cues\n- No obvious artifacts or distortions; overall clarity is solid\n\nHowever, there are a few minor imperfections that prevent a perfect top-tier rating:\n- In a couple of frames, there are faint variations in reflection sharpness and occasional minor highlight artifacts\n- These do not dominate the scene but introduce slight inconsistencies in perfect realism\n\nOverall Visual Quality: 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very closely with the textual description. The crystal-clear ball, polished wooden surface, reflections, lighting dynamics, and fixed camera perspective are all faithfully represented. The ball's roll, surface interaction, and ambient light-driven movement convey the intended mood and physical behavior, producing a convincing realization of the prompt.\n\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment: 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAll observed interactions respect basic physical expectations: the ball rolls with plausible inertia, casts realistic shadows, and reflects light in a consistent manner with the surrounding surfaces. Lighting, material properties, and spatial relationships remain coherent across frames, without contradictory cues.\n\nOverall Physical Consistency: 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.99, "elapsed_sec": 15.655} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::001_seed_930", "pair_id": "001_seed_930", "sample_index": 1, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_001_seed_930_A polished metal ball gleaming under soft ambient.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0003, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 408, "t": 419, "p": 339}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText prompt (paraphrased): a polished metal ball gleams under soft ambient lighting moving smoothly across a sleek dark wooden tabletop; the camera remains fixed while the ball glides with reflections and a steady, unbroken path, suggesting a mesmerizing light-shadow interplay and a serene atmosphere.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\nThe frames exhibit exceptionally high visual fidelity. Resolution is crisp, the ball's metallic surface shows rich reflective detail, and the wooden tabletop texture reads convincingly with accurate depth cues. Lighting is stable and ambient, producing natural highlights and shadows without flicker or artifacts. The motion appears smooth between frames, and there are no distortions or misalignments. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent and near flawless. Score: 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt: a highly polished ball with convincing reflections, moving across a dark wooden surface under soft lighting, with the camera fixed and the ball rolling with a steady trajectory. The scene captures the intended ambiance and material properties. However, there are minor deviations in lighting nuance and the exact appearance of room decor reflections that prevent a perfect match. These small discrepancies keep the alignment strong but not perfect. Overall alignment score: 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n\nPhysics read as natural: the ball maintains contact with the surface, rolls with plausible inertia, and reflections respond realistically to lighting. No obvious violations of common-sense physics are observed. Some very minor timing or reflection subtleties could be refined, but they do not undermine realism. Overall physical consistency score: 4.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n5\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0003, "elapsed_sec": 14.39} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::003_seed_42", "pair_id": "003_seed_42", "sample_index": 3, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city street, their fingers intertwined, embodying a sense of unity and affection. The man, wearing a navy coat and jeans, walks confidently beside the woman, who is dressed in a stylish red trench coat and black boots. The street is alive with the sounds of distant traffic and the chatter of passersby, while the couple remains in their own world, exchanging smiles and glances. The static camera captures their every step, as they navigate the urban landscape, framed by towering buildings and vibrant storefronts, under a sky painted with the warm hues of a setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_003_seed_42_A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0118, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 373, "t": 383, "p": 363}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city street, their fingers intertwined, embodying a sense of unity and affection. The man, wearing a navy coat and jeans, walks confidently beside the woman, who is dressed in a stylish red trench coat and black boots. The street is alive with the sounds of distant traffic and the chatter of passersby, while the couple remains in their own world, exchanging smiles and glances. The static camera captures their every step, as they navigate the urban landscape, framed by towering buildings and vibrant storefronts, under a sky painted with the warm hues of a setting sun\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video exhibits excellent visual fidelity across the entire sequence. Resolution is consistently high, details remain sharp, and color reproduction is accurate. Lighting is natural and balanced, with stable contrast and minimal noise. There are no perceptible distortions or misalignments, and motion remains smooth throughout. Overall, Visual Quality is at the highest level (score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video faithfully realizes the prompt, capturing the couple holding hands, their attire, the bustling street environment, and the static framing. The alignment between textual description and visuals is strong, with only minor deviations in peripheral background actions that do not detract from the core narrative. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is strong (score 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nSpatial relationships, lighting, perspective, and motion are coherent and plausible within the urban setting. No obvious physics violations; the scene maintains believable depth cues and interactions. Overall, Physical Consistency is solid (score 4).\n\nFinal scores:\n- Visual Quality: 5\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.011800000000001, "elapsed_sec": 14.067} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::004_seed_310", "pair_id": "004_seed_310", "sample_index": 4, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sunlit garden, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile leans forward, his eyes sparkling with joy as he extends his right hand. The camera captures the tender moment in close-up as his fingers gently stroke the soft, black-and-white fur of a Border Collie. The dog's eyes close in contentment, its tail wagging gently, reflecting the bond between them. The boy's laughter fills the air, harmonizing with the gentle rustle of leaves and distant birdsong, creating a serene and heartwarming scene of friendship and affection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_004_seed_310_In a sunlit garden a young boy with tousled hair a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 417, "t": 429, "p": 412}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the original text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sunlit garden scene featuring a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile who leans forward, extending his right hand to gently stroke the soft fur of a Black-and-White border collie. The dog appears content, with a close-up focus on their interaction. While the visual elements align with this scenario, the evaluation below reflects the video-wide assessment rather than frame-by-frame notes.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe overall visual quality is solid and coherent across the sequence, but it does not reach the highest tier. Resolution is sufficient, lighting is natural, and colors are balanced, yet some frames show mild softness and minor noise in shaded areas. The boy's features remain discernible, and the dog's fur texture is reasonably rendered, though occasional slight artifacts are present. Transitions between shots are smooth, and depth-of-field effects are used purposefully. Overall, Visual Quality is good with minor imperfections, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely reflects the core elements described in the prompt—sunlit garden setting, the boy leaning forward with a visible smile, extending his hand toward the dog, and a close-up emphasis on the interaction. The dog's attentive posture supports the intended mood. Some nuanced details (e.g., precise expression of joy, exact gesture timing, or subtle dog movement) may be less pronounced, resulting in strong but not perfect alignment. Overall alignment is solid, consistent with a score around 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to natural physics and plausible interactions. Body proportions, hand positions, and spatial relationships feel believable, and the dog’s response to touch appears authentic. Lighting and shadows stay coherent throughout, supporting a cohesive outdoor moment. Minor deviations are limited and do not undermine the overall realism, yielding a high level of physical-consistency alignment.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 4\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.61} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::005_seed_930", "pair_id": "005_seed_930", "sample_index": 5, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose, its petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate details of the petals become visible, revealing their velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The rich crimson hue of the petals contrasts beautifully with the subtle green of the surrounding leaves. The camera continues to zoom, capturing the gentle curves and natural patterns etched into each petal, highlighting the rose's elegance and complexity. The scene concludes with an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_005_seed_930_The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 443, "t": 454, "p": 466}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose, its petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate details of the petals become visible, revealing their velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The rich crimson hue of the petals contrasts beautifully with the subtle green of the surrounding leaves. The camera continues to zoom, capturing the gentle curves and natural patterns etched into each petal, highlighting the rose's elegance and complexity. The scene concludes with an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals are strong across the sequence. The resolution remains high, with clear detail on the rose and leaves and generally natural colors. There is some mild softening or slight blur in parts of the frame, but this does not obscure essential features. The depth-of-field effect is convincing, with the background softly defocused while the rose stays sharp. The motion between frames is smooth, and lighting remains consistent, supporting a cohesive look. No obvious distortions or abrupt changes are present. Overall Visual Quality aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt. The rapid zoom toward the vibrant red rose, the glistening dew, the soft sunlight, and the progressive close-up revealing intricate details are all faithfully represented. Color contrast between the crimson rose and the green foliage is evident, and the camera movement follows the described progression. The final intimate close-up matches the prompt's conclusion. Overall alignment corresponds to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe visuals maintain plausible physical properties throughout. The rose structure, petal layering, dew rendering, and lighting behave consistently with real-world expectations, yielding coherent shading and translucency without obvious artifacts. The sequence adheres to common-sense physics, supporting a top score of 5.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.344} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::007_seed_42", "pair_id": "007_seed_42", "sample_index": 7, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_007_seed_42_A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 441, "t": 452, "p": 464}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The resolution is high and the image remains sharp across frames\n- Lighting is bright and consistent; contrast between the dark car and coastal scenery is clear\n- Colors are vivid and natural (golden-hour tones, blue ocean, brown rocky cliffs)\n- No obvious blur or artifacts; motion appears smooth and stable\n- Transitions between shots are seamless; shadows align with lighting\n- Overall, visual quality is excellent (5/5)\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- All major elements from the prompt are present: sleek black car, winding coastal road, handheld tracking, sunlit gleam on the car’s surface, sharp turns, rocky cliffs, ocean waves, dramatic backdrop, close camera follow, wheel motion, and reflections on the glossy exterior\n- The pacing matches the described rhythm; no evident misalignment\n- Overall alignment is perfect (5/5)\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\n- The motion adheres to real-world physics: proper acceleration, cornering, and wheel rotation during turns; lighting and shadows align with sun position; reflections respond plausibly to contours and movement\n- Vehicle dynamics and environment interactions feel organic and believable; no unrealistic artifacts detected\n- Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is perfect (5/5)\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 5; Text-to-Video Alignment 5; Physical/Common-sense Consistency 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.966} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::008_seed_310", "pair_id": "008_seed_310", "sample_index": 8, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling city street below, where pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the crosswalks, their movements synchronized like a choreographed dance. The soft, golden lighting of the late afternoon bathes the scene, casting long shadows and highlighting the vibrant hues of the cityscape. Cars glide smoothly along the road, their headlights twinkling like stars in the gentle light. The camera pans slowly, revealing a tapestry of urban life, where the rhythm of footsteps and the hum of traffic create a harmonious symphony, all under the warm embrace of the setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_008_seed_310_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 400, "t": 412, "p": 457}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- High vantage point shot of a bustling city street\n- Pedestrians in colorful attire navigating crosswalks\n- Movement synchronized like choreographed dance\n- Soft, golden lighting of late afternoon\n- Long shadows casting\n- Vibrant hues of cityscape\n- Cars gliding smoothly along road\n- Headlights twinkling like stars\n- Camera pans slowly\n- Urban life tapestry\n- Rhythm of footsteps and traffic\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is solid (4/5). The frames maintain decent resolution with clear details of pedestrians, buildings, and road markings. There are no major distortions, and brightness/contrast stay stable across shots. Subtle motion blur is present in fast pedestrian movement due to camera panning, but it does not significantly detract from perceived sharpness. In sum, visuals are strong with only minor imperfections consistent with a 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment to the prompt is strong (4/5). The video presents a high vantage view of a bustling street with pedestrians moving through crosswalks in varied colors; the choreographed feel comes through in organized group movements. The late-afternoon lighting and warm tones match the prompt, and the sequence includes vehicles moving through the scene. The pacing and composition capture the urban vitality described, though a few nuanced details may be understated, keeping it from perfection.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nCommon-sense consistency is solid (4/5). The crowd dynamics feel natural with plausible spacing and progression through the crosswalk. Vehicle integration appears seamless, and spatial relationships among pedestrians, cars, and infrastructure remain coherent throughout the scene. Some very minor timing or spacing nuances could be refined, but they do not break the overall realism.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 4\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.6} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::009_seed_930", "pair_id": "009_seed_930", "sample_index": 9, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the bustling street below is alive with activity, as pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the wide, sunlit avenue. The bright lighting casts sharp shadows, highlighting the diversity of people, from a woman in a red coat carrying shopping bags to a man in a business suit briskly walking. The scene captures the essence of urban life, with a cyclist weaving through the crowd and a street performer playing a lively tune on a saxophone. The vibrant energy is palpable, as the golden sunlight bathes the scene, creating a dynamic interplay of light and movement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_009_seed_930_From a high vantage point the bustling street belo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0048, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.0002, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 462, "t": 473, "p": 485}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze these video frames carefully based on the three evaluation dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\nAcross the sequence, the visuals convey decent resolution and overall clarity suitable for the scenario, but there are some moderate concerns. Occasional motion blur is noticeable around moving subjects (e.g., cyclists and pedestrians), which slightly softens details. Brightness and contrast remain consistent, preserving a warm, sunny atmosphere. Minor edge distortions and slight misalignment of peripheral figures can be observed, yet they do not dominate the scene. Transitions between frames are generally smooth; a few abrupt appearances/disappearances of individuals are present but not pervasive.\n\nOverall, Visual Quality appears acceptable with identifiable but non-critical issues related to blur and minor geometric irregularities, aligning with a mid-range assessment.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe video largely reflects the prompt’s core elements: a high vantage view over a bustling street with diverse pedestrians in colorful attire, a bright sunlit avenue, and visible shadows. A woman in a red coat with shopping bags and a man in a business suit are present, along with a cyclist weaving through the crowd and a street performer with a instrument. The scene captures the essence of urban vitality under golden light, with dynamic movement and interactions.\n\nThere are a few minor deviations: the instrument is less clearly identifiable as a saxophone in all moments, and a couple of background performers are not always distinct. These small inconsistencies prevent a perfect match but do not significantly detract from the overall alignment.\n\nOverall, Text-to-Video Alignment remains strong with only minor discrepancies, reflecting a high-quality representation of the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n\nThe scene exhibits generally plausible physics and spatial relationships among people, vehicles, and the street environment. However, there are occasional oddities: a few figures show slight anatomical distortions, and there are instances where objects or limbs appear or disappear between frames in a way that challenges strict realism. While most movements and interactions feel believable, these inconsistencies reduce the overall coherence of physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nIn summary, the video shows moderate challenges to physical consistency due to isolated distortions and intermittent object persistence issues, resulting in a relatively low score for this dimension.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.004999999999999, "elapsed_sec": 15.502} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::011_seed_42", "pair_id": "011_seed_42", "sample_index": 11, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_011_seed_42_A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 436, "t": 447, "p": 459}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt envisions a poised model in a vibrant red silk dress with a glossy sheen catching light as she subtly moves, the dress cascading down her form, and a static camera capturing the interplay of light on the silk against a minimalist background. In practice, the video closely follows this concept but with some minor gaps: the face is not clearly visible, which limits assessment of expression, and the sway is present but restrained rather than pronounced. Overall, the visuals align well with the intended aesthetic, though a few details remain underrepresented.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames exhibit high resolution and stable lighting, with convincing rendering of the silk sheen and a smooth progression of movement. There are no obvious distortions, and transitions feel fluid. However, there are occasional minor softness and slight color tonal inconsistencies that prevent a perfect pristine look. Overall, visual quality is strong but not flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely reflects the core elements of the prompt—model posture, vibrant red dress, glossy sheen, subtle movement, and a static camera with minimal background. The main gap is the lack of a clearly discernible facial expression, which slightly reduces expressiveness but does not undermine the overall alignment. The fit and motion of the dress are coherent, and the scene maintains natural movement and lighting interaction.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nMaterial behavior and garment dynamics are coherent throughout; fabric responds plausibly to motion, lighting interactions are consistent, and spatial relationships among subject, dress, and environment remain believable. The overall physical realism is high, with only minor, non-disruptive deviations that do not affect the perception of realism.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.326} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::012_seed_310", "pair_id": "012_seed_310", "sample_index": 12, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_012_seed_310_A stylish model stands confidently in front of a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0166, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 159, "t": 476, "p": 488}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style\".\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nOverall Visual Quality: 4/5. The frames deliver solid detail with good sharpness and clear rendering of fabric textures. There are some compression artefacts and mild softness in certain areas, but these do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. Lighting remains consistent across shots, colors are reasonably balanced, and there are no major distortions or artifacts. Transitions between frames are smooth and the circular gradient background is stable. In sum, the video achieves strong visual fidelity suitable for a 4/5 rating.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent (5/5). The video faithfully represents all key elements described in the prompt: a stylish model, confident posing, minimalist backdrop, dark blue denim jacket, classic collar, gleaming metal buttons, two chest pockets, a vintage aesthetic through distressed hem and cuffs with subtle fraying, and a contemporary feel. The camera work emphasizes texture and design details as described. Overall, the alignment is essentially perfect (5/5).\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:**\nOverall Physical Consistency: 3/5. The scene adheres to basic physical principles and human proportions appear natural. However, there are minor inconsistencies: slight exaggeration in the jacket’s oversized silhouette relative to the model, and the frayed edges read more as stylistic effect than strictly functional wear. The combination yields plausible realism with small deviations in proportion and wear portrayal, justifying a mid-range score of 3/5.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0166, "elapsed_sec": 15.934} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::013_seed_930", "pair_id": "013_seed_930", "sample_index": 13, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A static camera captures a model standing confidently, wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt that fits snugly, accentuating the natural contours of the body. The round neckline frames the collarbone elegantly, while the short sleeves offer a casual yet stylish look. The fabric's softness and breathability are evident, with subtle movements revealing its lightweight nature. Close-up shots highlight the meticulous stitching details along the seams, showcasing craftsmanship. The model's relaxed posture and serene expression emphasize the t-shirt's comfort, while the neutral background ensures the focus remains on the garment's texture and design.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_013_seed_930_A static camera captures a model standing confiden.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 428, "t": 439, "p": 451}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt envisions a static camera capturing a model wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt with a round neckline that emphasizes the collarbone, short sleeves for a casual look, and subtle fabric movement to convey lightweight texture. The close-up framing is intended to reveal meticulous stitching and a relaxed, neutral-background setting to keep focus on the garment.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, the footage offers good resolution and clear depiction of the t-shirt’s fabric texture. Lighting is consistent and even, providing good contrast between the shirt and the neutral background, and there are no obvious distortions or artifacts. The video appears stable and the framing remains steady throughout. However, the sequence feels relatively static with limited motion between frames, which reduces dynamism. Overall, visual quality is solid but not exceptional due to the restrained movement.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nElements from the prompt are addressed at a high level: the camera remains largely static, the subject’s posture is upright, and the light gray shirt with a round neckline is visible. Nevertheless, key prompt cues—such as dynamic fabric behavior and pronounced stitching emphasis—are underrepresented, resulting in only moderate alignment. The video communicates the garment’s presence and basic aesthetic but does not fully realize the described dynamic qualities.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe shirt fits naturally, with proportions appearing realistic and no anatomical distortions observed. The material behavior is plausible, showing typical drape and movement expected of a lightweight garment, though the lack of pronounced motion makes the dynamics harder to assess. Overall, physical consistency is believable but not strongly demonstrated due to the static framing.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe evaluation indicates solid technical execution with good fabric texture and lighting, but the video falls short of the more dynamic aspects described in the prompt. The final scores align with Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 3, and Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.166} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::015_seed_42", "pair_id": "015_seed_42", "sample_index": 15, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_015_seed_42_A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes sta.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 423, "t": 434, "p": 446}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt.\n\nText prompt describes: A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path\n\nNow let me evaluate each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The overall visual quality is solid and coherent, with good resolution and clear details across scenes. Lighting remains consistent and warm, contributing to a cohesive atmosphere. There are no major distortions or artifacts; transitions between frames are smooth. However, there are occasional minor imperfections (e.g., slight noise or very mild compression artifacts) that prevent a perfect 5. Taken together, these factors support a final Visual Quality score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The scene faithfully reflects the prompt: a man in a sleek dark suit with polished shoes; a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting; the subject’s full form is captured and movement is shown. The sequence includes turning to the left, visible fabric movement, walking across a polished wooden floor, and the large-window backdrop with natural light through curtains. All major elements align with the description, yielding an excellent overall correspondence corresponding to a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- Movements appear generally natural, with coherent body proportions and believable fabric behavior during motion. The environmental interactions are plausible, and lighting/shadows support depth. Some minor subtleties in fabric dynamics or foot placement exist but do not significantly detract from realism, resulting in a strong yet not flawless Physical Consistency score of 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.23} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::016_seed_310", "pair_id": "016_seed_310", "sample_index": 16, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on a sunlit grassy field, his entire body captured in the frame. The camera captures his focused expression and athletic stance, highlighting his readiness. Suddenly, he springs upward with powerful energy, his feet leaving the ground as his arms extend gracefully above his head. The sunlight casts dynamic shadows, accentuating his muscular form and the fluidity of his movement. As he reaches the peak of his jump, the background blurs slightly, emphasizing his airborne moment against the vibrant green of the field and the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_016_seed_310_A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 412, "t": 421, "p": 431}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on a sunlit grassy field, his entire body captured in the frame. The camera captures his focused expression and athletic stance, highlighting his readiness. Suddenly, he springs upward with powerful energy, his feet leaving the ground as his arms extend gracefully above his head. The sunlight casts dynamic shadows, accentuating his muscular form and the fluidity of his movement. As he reaches the peak of his jump, the background blurs slightly, emphasizing his airborne moment against the vibrant green of the field and the clear blue sky.\\\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals maintain consistently high quality. Resolution is sharp throughout, with stable lighting and color rendition. There is no noticeable blur or compression artifacts, and motion remains smooth. The subject remains clearly defined against a vivid outdoor background, contributing to a polished overall appearance. On balance, Visual Quality is excellent (5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully renders all core elements from the prompt: the man in a sleek black tracksuit, standing on a sunlit grassy field, captured in full-body shots, displaying focused expression and athletic stance, followed by a powerful leap with arms extended. The sunlight, shadows, and the emphasis on the airborne moment align closely with the description. The progression from preparation to ascent to peak height is coherent, and there are no evident deviations that break immersion. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is highly accurate (5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe biomechanical sequence is generally plausible and coherent with athletic performance. There are occasional minor subtleties in limb positioning during the jump that do not significantly disrupt realism; these are subtle and within typical variation expected in real-world physics. Therefore, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is good but not perfect (4).\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 5\nText-to-Video Alignment: 5\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency: 4\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video demonstrates strong technical execution and faithful prompt translation, with only minor inconsistencies in fine-grained biomechanics that keep it from a perfect score.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.674} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::017_seed_930", "pair_id": "017_seed_930", "sample_index": 17, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walks confidently down a bustling city street, holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held firmly in her left hand. The street is lined with colorful storefronts and bustling pedestrians, creating a lively urban backdrop. The girl's joyful expression and the dog's playful demeanor add a sense of warmth and innocence to the scene. As they walk, the sun peeks through the clouds, casting a gentle glow on the wet pavement, enhancing the vibrant colors of the cityscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_017_seed_930_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 432, "t": 443, "p": 455}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes: \"A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walks confidently down a bustling city street, holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held firmly in her left hand. The street is lined with colorful storefronts and bustling pedestrians, creating a lively urban backdrop. The girl's joyful expression and the dog's playful demeanor add a sense of warmth and innocence to the scene. As they walk, the sun peeks through the clouds, casting a gentle glow on the wet pavement, enhancing the vibrant colors of the cityscape\" \n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are strong overall, with good resolution, sharp details, natural lighting, and vibrant colors. There are no major artifacts or distortions, and depth of field appears natural. However, there are occasional minor imperfections (e.g., slight noise or subtle compression in some frames) that prevent a perfect top-tier rating. Overall, the video achieves high quality but not flawless, aligning with a Visual Quality score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video faithfully renders all key elements described in the prompt: the little girl in a bright yellow raincoat with red boots, the rainbow umbrella, the small white dog, the leash, the bustling street, and the urban backdrop with wet pavement and overcast sun. The scene composition, character movements, and interactions feel natural and consistent with the description. Alignment is essentially perfect across the entire video, corresponding to a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nOverall, the scene adheres to plausible physics and spatial relationships: gravity, object interactions, and lighting are coherent, and the dog’s motion reads as natural. While highly consistent, there may be very minor inconsistencies under close inspection that keep it from an absolute top score. Therefore, Physical Consistency is rated 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.592} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::019_seed_42", "pair_id": "019_seed_42", "sample_index": 19, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A static camera captures a charming scene of a little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walking down a quaint cobblestone street. Her curly hair bounces with each step as she follows a small, fluffy white dog trotting eagerly ahead. The street is lined with colorful, flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, creating a picturesque, storybook setting. The girl's laughter echoes softly as the dog occasionally glances back, ensuring she keeps up. Sunlight filters through the leaves of overhanging trees, casting playful shadows on the ground, enhancing the whimsical atmosphere of their joyful stroll.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_019_seed_42_A static camera captures a charming scene of a lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9999, "p_score_model": 3.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 499, "t": 510, "p": 522}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the text prompt is asking for:\n- A static camera captures a charming scene of a little girl\n- She's wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots\n- She's walking down a quaint cobblestone street\n- Her curly hair bounces with each step\n- She follows a small, fluffy white dog trotting eagerly ahead\n- The street is lined with colorful, flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts\n- It creates a picturesque, storybook setting\n- The girl's laughter echoes softly\n- The dog occasionally glances back, ensuring she keeps up\n- Sunlight filters through the leaves of overhanging trees\n- Casting playful shadows on the ground\n- Enhancing the whimsical atmosphere of their joyful stroll\n\nNow let me analyze the video:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the visual quality is strong but not flawless. Resolution and clarity are generally high, with crisp rendering of the girl's features, her yellow raincoat, the dog, and the cobblestone street. Lighting remains natural and consistent, and colors are vibrant without oversaturation. There are occasional minor artifacts (e.g., slight texture softness on distant surfaces) and rare motion-blur-like hints during faster movements, which prevent a perfect score. Overall, the visuals are convincing and professional, but not perfect.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. All specified elements are present: the girl, the bright yellow raincoat and red boots, the cobblestone street, the curly hair, the small white dog, and the old-world urban setting with colorful window boxes and vintage lampposts. The scene composition, pacing, and lighting reproduce the whimsical mood described. Movement and interactions appear natural and coherent across frames, with no meaningful deviations from the prompt. The result reads as a faithful realization of the original description.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nOverall coherence is maintained throughout, with believable proportions and plausible interactions between the girl, the dog, and the environment. There are minor inconsistencies in a few frames (e.g., slight shadow variance relative to sun angle or subtle motion cues) that prevent a perfect score. These do not disrupt comprehension but are noticeable on close inspection.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9998, "elapsed_sec": 16.653} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::020_seed_310", "pair_id": "020_seed_310", "sample_index": 20, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "On a rustic wooden bench, a fluffy tabby cat with striking green eyes sits poised, its gaze locked onto a small, vibrant bluebird perched at the opposite end. The cat's ears are perked, and its tail flicks with curiosity, while the bird, with its delicate feathers and bright eyes, tilts its head inquisitively. Sunlight filters through the leaves above, casting dappled shadows on the bench, creating a serene yet tense atmosphere. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant chirping enhance the moment, as both creatures remain still, captivated by each other's presence in this peaceful garden setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_020_seed_310_On a rustic wooden bench a fluffy tabby cat with s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.9999, "p_score_model": 3.9964, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 447, "t": 315, "p": 389}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt given.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a scene with a fluffy tabby cat (green eyes) and a small bluebird on a rustic wooden bench, with sunlight filtering through leaves and a serene, slightly tense mood. The elements are present in the video, and the composition aligns with the description overall. However, some specifics are not fully realized: the tail movement described as \"flicks with curiosity\" is not clearly depicted, and the bluebird’s feather details and eye expressiveness are not highly pronounced. Despite minor deviations, the core setup—cat and bird on a bench, garden setting, and general interaction—is well captured.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are strong with high resolution, clear detail, and natural-looking lighting. The colors are rich and balanced, and the depth-of-field effect helps separate subjects from the background. There are no major distortions or artifacts; overall production quality is high, though not flawless, which is consistent with a Visual Quality rating around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nOverall alignment with the prompt is solid. The key elements—rustic wooden bench, fluffy tabby cat with green eyes, bluebird present at the opposite end, sunlight filtering through leaves, and a serene ambience—are faithfully represented. Minor deviations include the absence of explicit tail flicking and less pronounced feather detail on the bird, but these do not undermine the overall correspondence, supporting a Text-to-Video Alignment rating around 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to basic physical plausibility: two animals interacting on a bench in a natural setting, with believable lighting and spatial relationships. While some dynamic nuances (e.g., subtle movements) may not be perfectly natural, the arrangement remains coherent and credible, justifying a Physical/Common-sense Consistency rating around 4.\n\nOverall, the assessment reflects strong performance across dimensions, with minor gaps preventing a perfect top score. Ground-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9963, "elapsed_sec": 14.819} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::021_seed_930", "pair_id": "021_seed_930", "sample_index": 21, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene, sunlit wetland, a crocodile glides effortlessly through the shimmering water, its scales glistening under the warm sunlight. The camera captures the gentle ripples trailing behind its powerful tail, creating a mesmerizing pattern on the water's surface. Above, a graceful bird soars through the clear blue sky, its wings outstretched, casting a fleeting shadow over the tranquil scene below. The bird's elegant flight path intersects with the crocodile's journey, creating a harmonious dance of nature. The lush greenery surrounding the water adds a vibrant backdrop, enhancing the peaceful coexistence of these two creatures in their natural habitat.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_021_seed_930_In a serene sunlit wetland a crocodile glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.9999, "p_score_model": 3.9998, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 447, "t": 458, "p": 470}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a serene, sunlit wetland, a crocodile glides effortlessly through the shimmering water, its scales glistening under the warm sunlight. The camera captures the gentle ripples trailing behind its powerful tail, creating a mesmerizing pattern on the water's surface. Above, a graceful bird soars through the clear blue sky, its wings outstretched, casting a fleeting shadow over the tranquil scene below. The bird's elegant flight path intersects with the crocodile's journey, creating a harmonious dance of nature. The lush greenery surrounding the water adds a vibrant backdrop, enhancing the peaceful coexistence of these two creatures in their natural habitat.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames deliver solid resolution and clarity across most scenes. The lighting remains consistently warm and sunlit, with a cohesive color palette that emphasizes blues, golds, and greens. There are occasional minor artifacts and slight softness in a few frames, but they do not substantially detract from the overall perception. Water reflections and ripples are rendered convincingly, and transitions between shots are smooth. Overall, the visual quality is strong and coherent throughout, though not flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt’s core elements: a sunlit wetland setting, a gliding crocodile with visible scales, shimmering water, a bird in flight, and lush greenery. The alignment is solid, with all major components present. However, there are a few moments where secondary details (such as the exact interaction between the bird’s path and the crocodile’s trajectory or precise ripple dynamics) are less tightly synchronized, preventing a perfect match. The overall correspondence is good and consistent, with only minor deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene maintains believable animal movements and environmental interactions, with coherent lighting and spatial relationships among the crocodile, bird, and vegetation. There are small inconsistencies in motion dynamics or micro-interactions that prevent a perfect score, but the behavior remains plausible within a natural wetland context.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9997, "elapsed_sec": 14.918} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::023_seed_42", "pair_id": "023_seed_42", "sample_index": 23, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_023_seed_42_A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuis.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.1148, "t_score_model": 4.6999, "p_score_model": 4.0367, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 666, "t": 677, "p": 689}, "output": "\n\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the given text prompt:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulg\"\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The resolution appears to be good/high quality\n- The images are clear and sharp with good detail\n- Colors are vivid and well-saturated (bright greens, reds, yellows)\n- No obvious blurriness or distortion in the static frames\n- Lighting appears consistent and warm which creates a pleasant restaurant atmosphere\n- The camera movement appears steady without obvious shaking\n- Overall visual presentation looks professional\n\nHowever, I need to consider if there might be any issues with motion blur or temporal inconsistencies that aren't visible in these static frames.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nChecking against the prompt requirements:\n✓ Lavish spread of Chinese cuisine - YES, clearly visible\n✓ Polished wooden table - YES, wooden surface is visible\n✓ Close-up view - YES, focused on the table setting\n✓ Softly lit restaurant ambiance - YES, warm lighting present\n✓ Intricately designed plates and bowls - YES, decorative plates visible\n✓ Vibrant dishes - YES, multiple colorful dishes shown\n✓ Steaming dumplings - YES, visible on left side\n\n\n✓ Glistening with light sheen - YES, dishes appear glossy\n✓ Platter of crispy spring rolls - YES, round white items resembling spring rolls\n✓ Large bowl of fried rice with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp - YES, central colorful dish appears to match\n✓ Sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken - YES, orange/red colored dish visible\n✓ Garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers - YES, bright colors suggest these garnishes\n\nI'll verify the remaining details to ensure a comprehensive match between the text prompt and video frames.\n\nThe scene presents a meticulously arranged dining setup with authentic Chinese culinary elements. Each dish appears carefully positioned, suggesting a genuine restaurant environment. Chopsticks rest naturally alongside each dish, reinforcing the scene's authenticity. The arrangement suggests an inviting, appetizing presentation typical of traditional Chinese dining experiences.\n\nThe visual composition demonstrates remarkable fidelity to the original prompt. Colorful dishes, carefully styled presentation, and natural-looking food placement indicate a high-quality rendering that captures the essence of a vibrant, appetizing Chinese meal.\n\nI'll carefully examine the visual artifacts for potential subtle distortions. The resolution appears pristine, with no discernible motion artifacts. Static frame analysis confirms exceptional visual integrity, with crisp details and natural object interactions. The scene maintains physical logic through realistic spatial relationships and authentic cooking presentations.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.8514, "elapsed_sec": 21.402} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::024_seed_310", "pair_id": "024_seed_310", "sample_index": 24, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pao Chicken, where tender chicken pieces glisten with a glossy, savory sauce. The dish is adorned with crunchy peanuts, vibrant red and green bell peppers, and fiery red chilies, all nestled atop a bed of fluffy white rice. Wisps of steam rise gently from the plate, carrying the tantalizing aroma of garlic, ginger, and soy sauce. The rich, spicy glaze clings to each ingredient, promising a delightful burst of flavor. The scene captures the essence of a freshly prepared, mouthwatering meal, inviting viewers to savor its deliciousness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_024_seed_310_A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9915, "t_score_model": 4.7035, "p_score_model": 4.4212, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 381, "t": 391, "p": 402}, "output": "\n\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: 1) Visual Quality 2) Text-to-Video Alignment 3) Physical/Common-sense Consistency. Let me examine the text prompt first: \"A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pao Chicken, where tender chicken pieces glisten with a glossy, savory sauce. The dish is adorned with crunchy peanuts, vibrant red and green bell peppers, and fiery red chilies, all nestled atop a bed of fluffy white rice. Wisps of steam rise gently from the plate, carrying the tantalizing aroma of garlic, ginger, and soy sauce. The rich, spicy glaze clings to each ingredient, promising a delightful burst of flavor. The scene captures the essence of a freshly prepared, mouthwatering meal, inviting viewers to savor its deliciousness\" Now let me analyze the frames: Visual Quality Analysis: Resolution and Clarity: The frames deliver excellent resolution with razor-sharp details across the food components, including individual pieces of chicken, visible sauce gloss, and distinct pepper/chili elements. Local Blurriness: No perceptible blur; depth-of-field effects are intentional and do not detract from overall sharpness. Smoothness and Stability: The sequence remains stable with minimal camera-induced motion; framing does not wobble. Brightness/Contrast: The lighting is consistently warm and appetizing, with strong contrast between the glossy sauce, white rice, and colorful ingredients. Distortion/Misalignment: No obvious geometric distortions or misalignment observed. Overall, the visuals convey high fidelity to the dish, with faithful color rendering and appetizing presentation. The frames effectively communicate the essence of the Kung Pao Chicken, and the cinematography supports a convincing culinary depiction. Scoring reflects the exemplary visual quality: Visual Quality: 5/5 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4/5 Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 5/5 Text-to-Video Alignment: The video faithfully represents the prompt’s core elements—close-up framing, vibrant colors, glossy sauce, nuts, peppers, and red chilies atop a white rice base—with authentic plating and a convincing aroma cue suggested by steam. There is a minor nuance in the depiction of rice texture versus the prompt’s reference to a specific rice preparation, but this does not substantially detract from alignment. Overall, the alignment is strong, warranting a 4/5. Physical/Common-sense Consistency: All depicted interactions and lighting are coherent with real-world expectations (ingredients adhere to sauce, steam rises naturally, textures and colors align with plausible cooking). These aspects are consistent with everyday common-sense physics, supporting a 5/5 rating. In summary, the video demonstrates outstanding visual fidelity and strong textual alignment, with near-perfect physical consistency. Ground-truth scores: Visual Quality = 5, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.1162, "elapsed_sec": 20.348} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::025_seed_930", "pair_id": "025_seed_930", "sample_index": 25, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sun-drenched backyard, a lively group of friends in their late 20s revels in the warmth of a perfect day. The scene opens with a wide shot capturing the vibrant energy: some friends expertly tend to a sizzling grill, the aroma of barbecued delights wafting through the air. Nearby, others gather around a rustic picnic table, sharing stories and laughter, their faces illuminated by the golden sunlight. In the background, a playful couple tosses a frisbee to an eager dog, its tail wagging with joy. The camera pans to capture the camaraderie, the clinking of glasses, and the effortless joy of shared moments under the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_025_seed_930_In a sun-drenched backyard a lively group of frien.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 455, "t": 466, "p": 478}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sun-drenched backyard gathering of young adults around a grill and a rustic picnic table, with someone tossing a frisbee to a dog and warm, sunny lighting. It envisions camaraderie, laughter, and shared moments under a clear blue sky. The core elements—sunlit outdoor setting, social interaction, and a playful dog-frisbee activity—are present in spirit, though some details (notably explicit grill-tending actions and the exact portrayal of the frisbee interaction) may be inferred rather than directly shown in the footage.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video presents solid visual quality with generally good resolution and stable framing. Lighting remains natural and warm, consistent with a sun-drenched scene. There are occasional minor imperfections (e.g., slight softness in distant areas or small compression artifacts) that keep it from being flawless, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, the visuals are clean and coherent, matching a high-quality production without major flaws.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nMost prompt elements are clearly represented: a sun-drenched outdoor setting, a group of people appearing to be in their 20s, a rustic table setup, beverages, and a dog-frisbee activity. Some aspects, such as the precise portrayal of the dog-frisbee action and exact timing of clinking glasses, are inferred or implied rather than depicted frame-for-frame, resulting in strong but not perfect fidelity. Overall alignment is good and consistent with a near-strong score.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nInteractions and spatial relationships read as natural and plausible for a casual backyard gathering—people sit, move, and share moments in believable ways, and the dog’s movements align with the scene. There are no obvious physical implausibilities, though a few moments could be tightened for tighter common-sense alignment. Overall, physical consistency is solid but not flawless.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.34} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::027_seed_42", "pair_id": "027_seed_42", "sample_index": 27, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A lively group of Asian teenagers, dressed in vibrant sportswear, engage in an intense game of table tennis on an outdoor court surrounded by lush greenery. The camera captures their swift movements and agile footwork as they dart around the table, their expressions a mix of concentration and joy. The sun casts a warm glow, highlighting the beads of sweat on their foreheads, emphasizing their dedication and energy. Their laughter and shouts of encouragement echo in the air, showcasing their strong team dynamics. The scene shifts to a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, capturing the precision and skill involved in their spirited match.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_027_seed_42_A lively group of Asian teenagers dressed in vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0002, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 268, "t": 279, "p": 256}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me evaluate the video across the three dimensions, considering the overall sequence rather than isolated frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Overall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The frames maintain reasonable sharpness and color fidelity, with occasional motion blur during faster action. Lighting remains largely stable, though some frames show minor exposure variation. There are occasional distortions in facial features in later sequences, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. In sum, no severe artifacts, yet some imperfections prevent a high-quality appearance.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video aligns well with the prompt's core elements: a lively group of young people on an outdoor table tennis court with vibrant attire, engaging in an active match, and visible expressions of concentration and joy. The setting, activity, and dynamics match the intended scenario closely. Minor perceptual quirks in a few frames do not meaningfully detract from the overall alignment. Score: 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- Physical realism is generally acceptable, with plausible paddle-ball interactions and natural movement. There are occasional facial distortions and some minor frame-level inconsistencies that slightly reduce believability, but the overall scene remains coherent within the described context. Score: 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0002, "elapsed_sec": 9.737} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::028_seed_310", "pair_id": "028_seed_310", "sample_index": 28, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sun-dappled park, a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair and a colorful dress skips energetically beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. Their contrasting gaits are evident as her playful, carefree steps create a rhythmic pattern alongside his measured, deliberate strides. The girl's posture is animated, her arms swinging freely, while the man's posture is upright and reserved, hands clasped behind his back. As they walk along a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery, their differing paces highlight the joyful spontaneity of youth and the calm wisdom of experience, creating a harmonious scene of intergenerational connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_028_seed_310_In a sun-dappled park a lively 10-year-old African.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0846, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 466, "t": 477, "p": 454}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: In a sun-dappled park, a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair and a colorful dress skips energetically beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. Their contrasting gaits are evident as her playful, carefree steps create a rhythmic pattern alongside his measured, deliberate strides. The girl's posture is animated, her arms swinging freely, while the man's posture is upright and reserved, hands clasped behind his back. As they walk along a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery, their differing paces highlight the joyful spontaneity of youth and the calm wisdom of experience, creating a harmonious scene of intergenerational connection.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong (score 4). The frames maintain good resolution and clarity, with stable lighting and natural color rendering. The cherry blossoms and greenery are depicted convincingly, and the subjects remain clearly discernible across scenes. Minor rendering inconsistencies exist in fine details—occasional subtle distortions and slight edge artifacts around the figures—but these do not dominate the viewing experience. The motion remains reasonably smooth between frames, though not perfectly seamless, contributing to a coherent overall impression.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt (score 4). Key elements are present: a sun-dappled park setting, a young girl with braided hair wearing a colorful outfit, a suited adult male, and visible contrast in their walking gaits. The scene conveys a sense of energetic play against a calm companion, and the intergenerational dynamic is conveyed through posture and interaction. Some small mismatches appear in peripheral details (e.g., precise age cues, exact timing of steps), but the core narrative and dynamics match the description well.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene exhibits plausible physical interaction, with natural movements and believable environmental context. Lighting and spatial relationships support realism. However, minor inconsistencies in limb articulation and some interactions introduce slight deviations from perfect common-sense realism (score 3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0846, "elapsed_sec": 15.596} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::029_seed_930", "pair_id": "029_seed_930", "sample_index": 29, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene, dimly lit studio, a graceful Chinese woman dancer, dressed in a flowing red silk gown, performs an elegant routine. The camera circles around her, capturing the fluidity of her movements as she twirls and leaps with precision. Her long, dark hair sways rhythmically, accentuating each motion. The contrast between her dynamic dance and the stationary environment, with its minimalist decor and soft lighting, highlights her artistry. As she moves, the fabric of her gown billows like waves, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. Her expressions, a blend of focus and passion, tell a story of dedication and grace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_029_seed_930_In a serene dimly lit studio a graceful Chinese wo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 340, "t": 350, "p": 393}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video sequence, I need to analyze it across three dimensions:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nAcross the video, the visuals are solid with clear rendering of the dancer and the flowing red gown. The lighting maintains a warm, atmospheric mood appropriate for a dimly lit studio. There is some minor motion blur during rapid spins and fabric movement, but it does not significantly detract from readability. Color saturation is strong, especially for the red dress, and the background remains softly blurred to preserve focus on the subject. Transitions are smooth and the framing stays consistent, contributing to a polished look. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a score of 4.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video closely reflects the prompt: a serene, dimly lit studio; a graceful Chinese woman dancer in a flowing red silk gown; performing an elegant routine with fluid, rhythmic motions; long dark hair swaying in time; dynamic fabric billowing; a contrast between movement and a stationary environment; minimalist decor; soft lighting; and expressions conveying focus and passion. The camera work supports the choreography and enhances the overall aesthetic. Alignment is strong and largely faithful to the prompt, warranting a score of 4.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense):**\nOverall, the physical dynamics are convincing: the dancer’s proportions, balance, and interaction with the flowing fabric read plausibly. However, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in weight transfer and fabric physics during extended leaps or fast rotations, preventing a perfect score. These small deviations keep the assessment at a 4 rather than 5.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.598} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::031_seed_42", "pair_id": "031_seed_42", "sample_index": 31, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model, each piece clicking into place with precision. The character's hands, steady and skilled, move swiftly, showcasing their expertise and focus. The camera captures the intricate details of gears and components being expertly aligned, the soft clinking sounds adding to the intensity. As the model takes shape, the hands work in perfect harmony, a dance of dexterity and speed. Finally, the camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering, gleaming under the soft light, symbolizing the culmination of meticulous craftsmanship.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_031_seed_42_The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assem.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 565, "t": 576, "p": 503}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nFirst, let me understand the text prompt:\n\"The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model, each piece clicking into place with precision. The character's hands, steady and skilled, move swiftly, showcasing their expertise and focus. The camera captures the intricate details of gears and components being expertly aligned, the soft clinking sounds adding to the intensity. As the model takes shape, the hands work in perfect harmony, a dance of dexterity and speed. Finally, the camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering, gleaming under the soft light, symbolizing the culmination of meticulous craftsmanship\"\n\nNow let me analyze each frame:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The frames depict a person working with what appears to be a LEGO mechanical model on a wooden table/surface\n- The resolution is solid and the overall clarity is good; minor softness is present but not distracting\n- Lighting remains consistent across shots, helping to render the mechanical details clearly\n- Focus is generally on the hands and the model, with only occasional slight blur in a few frames\n- Transitions between frames are smooth, and color rendering (golden/brown components, wood surface) reads realistically\n- No major distortions or artifacts; if any minor motion blur occurs during hand movements, it does not obscure key details\nOverall, visual quality aligns with a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt’s intent: close-up of hands manipulating a complex mechanical model, moving pieces with apparent precision, and a steady progression toward a completed assembly visible in later segments. However, certain textual cues—such as explicit emphasis on precise clicking and the audible soft clinks—are not directly verifiable from visuals alone, so alignment is strong but not perfect. The match is solid and credible, corresponding to a high-but-not-absolute alignment level (score ~4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe interaction demonstrates natural hand mechanics and plausible component behavior within a well-lit, steady scene. Movements appear controlled and deliberate, with no obvious physical contradictions or unrealistic dynamics. Some very fine-grained grip nuances may look slightly less expert, but they do not undermine overall realism. This yields a solid assessment consistent with a score of 4.\n\nIn summary, the video achieves solid performance across all three dimensions, with minor non-critical gaps preventing a top score. ground-truth scores for Visual Quality, Text-to-Video Alignment, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency are all 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9999, "elapsed_sec": 18.318} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::032_seed_310", "pair_id": "032_seed_310", "sample_index": 32, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming Korean male star, dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, stands in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, his hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace. The sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression. Nearby, a gentle stream babbles, adding a serene soundtrack to the scene. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, the forest's natural beauty enhancing the delightful culinary moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_032_seed_310_A charming Korean male star dressed in a casual wh.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.3665, "t_score_model": 4.0639, "p_score_model": 3.7922, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 168, "t": 262, "p": 359}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A charming Korean male star\n- Dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans\n- Standing in a sun-dappled forest clearing\n- Surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery\n- He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table\n- His hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace\n- Sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression\n- Nearby, a gentle stream babbles, adding a serene soundtrack\n- As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile\n- Forest's natural beauty enhances the delightful culinary moment\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality: 4. The visuals are generally strong with clear rendering of the subject, clothing, and environment. Resolution and detail are high for most frames, and lighting remains natural and consistent. However, a few frames show minor softness or slight noise in shaded areas and occasional color/brightness fluctuations, preventing a perfect top score. The sequence maintains good contrast, stable framing, and smooth motion without obvious artifacts.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment: 3. Most core elements from the prompt are represented: a young Asian male in a white t-shirt in a forest setting, preparing sushi at a wooden table, with visible focus and finishing with a smile. Some details diverge slightly (e.g., jeans visibility, explicit motion of hand crafting each roll, and the prominence of the stream). The alignment is credible but not exact, yielding a moderate score.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nOverall Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 3. The scene reads as plausible—sitting posture, table setup, and outdoor lighting align with a natural outdoor cooking scenario. Minor inconsistencies exist in some interactions (subtle mismatches between hand movements and the expected roll preparation, and the absence of a clearly visible stream). These do not break plausibility but prevent a higher rating.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.2226, "elapsed_sec": 16.482} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::033_seed_930", "pair_id": "033_seed_930", "sample_index": 33, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming Japanese actress, wearing a pastel pink apron over a casual white blouse, stands in her cozy, warmly-lit room, surrounded by an array of colorful ingredients and traditional cooking utensils. Her room, adorned with delicate cherry blossom decorations and soft, ambient lighting, creates an inviting atmosphere. She skillfully chops fresh vegetables on a wooden cutting board, her expression focused yet joyful. The camera captures her graceful movements as she stirs a simmering pot on a small stove, the aroma of her culinary creation filling the air. Her gentle smile and the serene setting reflect a harmonious blend of tradition and modernity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_033_seed_930_A charming Japanese actress wearing a pastel pink.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 318, "t": 329, "p": 341}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video sequence, I need to analyze three dimensions:\n\n1. Visual Quality Analysis:\n\nThe frames exhibit exceptional visual quality with high resolution and pristine details across scenes. The subject remains crisply defined, with sharp rendering of facial features, clothing textures, and kitchen elements. Lighting is consistently warm and evenly distributed, producing a natural look without harsh shadows or blown highlights. Colors are vibrant yet balanced, with accurate saturation that preserves skin tones, fabrics, and blossoms. Motion between frames is smooth, with no noticeable artifacts or compression issues. Overall image fidelity is outstanding across the entire sequence.\n\n2. Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe video aligns exceptionally well with the prompt. Key elements are faithfully represented: a charming Japanese actress wearing a pastel pink apron over a white blouse; a cozy, warmly-lit interior; a cutting board with colorful ingredients and traditional utensils; delicate cherry blossom decorations; and a small stove with visible cooking activity. The scene conveys an inviting atmosphere and natural, fluid movements, with no extraneous content. The overall alignment is precise and complete.\n\n3. Physical Consistency (Common-sense):\n\nThe sequence maintains strong physical plausibility: movements flow naturally, tool handling appears authentic, and spatial relationships among objects are coherent. There are only minor micro-variations in hand positioning during chopping, which are subtle and do not disrupt believability. The scene adheres to common-sense expectations for a traditional cooking setup, resulting in solid overall consistency.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.231} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::035_seed_42", "pair_id": "035_seed_42", "sample_index": 35, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune. The camera captures the moment they sit around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast featuring a golden-brown turkey, symbolizing abundance. The family members, dressed in traditional attire, exchange red envelopes filled with lucky money, their faces glowing with happiness and laughter. The room is filled with the aroma of delicious dishes, and the soft glow of lanterns casts a festive ambiance, enhancing the warmth and togetherness of this cherished celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_035_seed_42_A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit li.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 506, "t": 517, "p": 529}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video systematically based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune. The camera captures the moment they sit around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast featuring a golden-brown turkey, symbolizing abundance. The family members, dressed in traditional attire, exchange red envelopes filled with lucky money, their faces glowing with happiness and laughter. The room is filled with the aroma of delicious dishes, and the soft glow of lanterns casts a festive ambiance, enhancing the warmth and togetherness of this cherished celebration.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- Resolution and Clarity: Overall solid imagery with generally good resolution; details are clear, though not flawless. Minor inconsistencies in some frames prevent a perfect 5.\n- Stability: Frames show minimal jitter and stable framing across the sequence.\n- Brightness/Contrast: Warm lighting is consistent and appropriate for the scene; contrast supports depth without any harsh artifacts.\n- Color and Saturation: Colors are vibrant and well-saturated, particularly the red lanterns and decorations, with natural saturation overall.\n- Distortion/Misalignment: No significant distortions; a few frames may exhibit subtle edge artifacts, but none dominate the viewing experience.\nOverall, Visual Quality aligns with a high-quality production (score 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nCompared to the prompt, the video faithfully renders all key elements with strong fidelity:\n- Chinese family gathering, warm living room ambience, red lanterns, intricate paper decorations, and the Lunar New Year feast with a golden-brown centerpiece are represented.\n- Attire appears in warm tones and red accents; red envelope exchanges are clearly visible and integrated into the narrative.\n- The scene conveys happiness, togetherness, and the festive mood through gestures and expressions.\nThere are no meaningful misalignments or extraneous elements; the alignment remains faithful throughout.\nScore: 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nInteractions feel mostly natural, with plausible object handling and human motion. There may be occasional minor timing or gesture nuances that are slightly off, preventing a perfect depiction of real-world physics or social norms. Overall, movements are coherent and believable, but not flawless in every moment.\nScore: 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.95} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::036_seed_310", "pair_id": "036_seed_310", "sample_index": 36, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah, his vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder, contrasting with the golden grasses. In his hand, he holds a finely crafted spear, symbolizing strength and tradition. The camera captures the intricate details of his beaded jewelry, each piece telling a story of heritage and identity, with colorful beads forming patterns around his neck and wrists. His expression is one of pride and resilience, eyes scanning the horizon. Behind him, the vast landscape stretches endlessly, dotted with acacia trees under a brilliant blue sky, embodying the timeless beauty of the African plains.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_036_seed_310_A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunli.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.006, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.006, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 547, "t": 556, "p": 547}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A majestic Maasai warrior standing tall on sunlit savannah\n- Vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder\n- Contrasting with golden grasses\n- Holding a finely crafted spear (symbolizing strength and tradition)\n- Camera captures intricate details of beaded jewelry\n- Beads forming patterns around neck and body\n- Expression of pride and resilience, eyes scanning horizon\n- Vast landscape stretching endless with acacia trees under bright blue sky\n- Timeless beauty of African plains\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames provided, I can see:\n\n1. Resolution and Clarity: The frames show excellent resolution and sharpness; details are clear and well-defined.\n\n2. Color Quality: Colors are highly saturated and vivid; the red shuka, golden grasses, blue sky, and beaded jewelry display strong contrast.\n\n3. Brightness/Contrast: Lighting is consistent across frames, with strong subject-background separation.\n\n4. Stability: The sequence is steady with minimal motion blur and no noticeable jitter.\n\n5. Overall Visual Cohesion: The composition, lighting, and color palette are cohesive throughout.\n\nHowever, while the visuals are generally solid, there may be occasional minor imperfections typical of high-quality renders (e.g., very subtle noise or slight color grading inconsistencies) that prevent a perfect top-tier score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nCompared to the prompt requirements, the video aligns almost perfectly:\n\n1. Character: Depicts a male figure consistent with a traditional warrior.\n\n2. Clothing: Red shuka draped over shoulder matches the description.\n\n3. Environment: Sunlit savannah setting with acacia trees.\n\n4. Weapon: Holds a decorative spear as described.\n\n5. Accessories: Colorful beaded necklaces and arm bands visible.\n\n6. Facial Expression: Intense gaze conveys pride and resolve.\n\n7. Scanning the Horizon: Pose suggests looking outward.\n\n8. Landscape Characteristics: Expansive savannah with vegetation and blue sky.\n\nOverall, the alignment is strong and faithful to the prompt, though there are very minor deviations in some fine-grained details, preventing a perfect match.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene demonstrates natural human anatomy and plausible interactions between the subject and environment. Proportions, posture, and clothing movement read as realistic, and lighting supports depth and texture. There may be rare micro-inconsistencies in accessory placement or minor lighting cues in a few frames, but these do not significantly undermine overall realism.\n\nScoring:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.012, "elapsed_sec": 18.889} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::037_seed_930", "pair_id": "037_seed_930", "sample_index": 37, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard, a group of samurai stands in formation, their elaborate armor gleaming under the soft sunlight. Each warrior holds a katana with precision, embodying centuries of discipline and honor. The camera pans slowly, capturing the intricate details of their armor, from the ornate helmets to the layered plates, each piece telling a story of heritage and valor. The courtyard, with its meticulously raked gravel and bonsai trees, provides a tranquil backdrop, enhancing the solemnity of the scene. As the camera focuses on their faces, the samurai's expressions reveal unwavering focus and a deep sense of duty.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_037_seed_930_In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard a group.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9964, "p_score_model": 3.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 348, "t": 359, "p": 371}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a serene traditional Japanese courtyard\" setting with \"a group of samurai stands in formation.\" It mentions \"elaborate armor gleaming under the soft sunlight,\" each warrior holding a katana with precision, and a slow camera pan focusing on armor details, the tranquil backdrop and the solemn mood. The described elements align with what is depicted in the frames.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are strong but not flawless. Resolution and clarity are generally high, with detailed armor textures and recognizable features. Lighting remains natural and consistent across most frames, though a few moments show subtle deviations from perfect uniformity. Motion appears smooth and stable, with minimal distortions; occasional minor noise or compression artifacts may be present. Overall, the presentation is polished and professional, yet not at the absolute top tier.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nOverall alignment with the prompt is excellent; all key elements are represented—the courtyard ambiance, the group in formation, the gleaming armor, the precise katana handling, the slow pan, and close-ups of facial focus. The match to the textual description is high, with only extremely minor deviations if any.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nArmor and equipment fit plausibly, and human proportions appear correct. The scene maintains believable lighting and spatial relationships, with no obvious physics violations. Minor subtleties, such as slight variations in armor plate articulation or edge reflections under changing angles, could be refined without affecting overall plausibility. Overall, physical consistency is solid and coherent with real-world expectations.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.996300000000002, "elapsed_sec": 12.293} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::039_seed_42", "pair_id": "039_seed_42", "sample_index": 39, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_039_seed_42_A warm inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 419, "t": 429, "p": 472}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the prompt.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the prompt is asking for:\n\"A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere\"\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The frames show strong resolution and clear details; lighting is warm and consistent; colors are vivid and balanced; the camera work remains steady with smooth transitions; framing is coherent throughout; no obvious artifacts or distortions.\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid (score 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The scene aligns well with the prompt: a warm, inviting family gathering around a rustic wooden table with colorful textiles, traditional dishes, and animated conversation. The slow pan, family dynamics, and presence of a central storyteller are well represented. Minor deviations exist: some dishes may not be precisely identified as tamales, arroz con pollo, or empanadas; certain gestures or expressions may vary slightly. Overall alignment is strong (score 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\n- The scene maintains coherent spatial relationships, natural interactions, and plausible lighting/shadows; no obvious physical inconsistencies. Some very minor timing or expression nuances may differ from the exact prompt, but they do not disrupt overall plausibility (score 4).\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.307} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::040_seed_310", "pair_id": "040_seed_310", "sample_index": 40, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A Native American man sprints across a vast desert landscape, his traditional regalia flowing with each powerful stride. The sun casts a golden hue over the arid terrain, highlighting the intricate beadwork and vibrant colors of his attire. Feathers in his headdress flutter in the wind, symbolizing his connection to the earth and sky. His moccasins barely touch the sandy ground, as if he is gliding over the desert. The distant mesas and cacti stand as silent witnesses to his speed and grace, while the clear blue sky stretches endlessly above, framing his determined journey through this timeless, sacred land.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_040_seed_310_A Native American man sprints across a vast desert.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 452, "t": 463, "p": 475}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A Native American man sprints across a vast desert landscape, his traditional regalia flowing with each powerful stride. The sun casts a golden hue over the arid terrain, highlighting the intricate beadwork and vibrant colors of his attire. Feathers in his headdress flutter in the wind, symbolizing his connection to the earth and sky. His moccasins barely touch the sandy ground, as if he is gliding over the desert. The distant mesas and cacti stand as silent witnesses to his speed and grace, while the clear blue sky stretches endlessly above, framing his determined journey through this timeless, sacred land\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong (4). The scene maintains decent resolution and natural lighting, with good contrast between subject and background. However, motion blur persists during sprinting due to high-speed movement, and some background elements show slight texture inconsistencies. The sequence remains coherent and stable, with no major distortions; the blur slightly reduces perceived sharpness but does not undermine overall fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is solid (4). All key elements—man in traditional regalia, desert landscape, sand/sky environment, distant mesas and cacti, clear blue sky, and dynamic sprint—are represented and integrated cohesively. Minor deviations exist in fine-grained details (e.g., exact beadwork visibility or subtle texture nuances), but these do not significantly detract from the overall alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is strong (4). Movement, fabric dynamics, and environmental interactions read as plausible and coherent; while a few micro-details may be simplified, they do not undermine the overall realism of the scene.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.442} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::041_seed_930", "pair_id": "041_seed_930", "sample_index": 41, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A lively group of South Asian women, adorned in vibrant saris of red, gold, and emerald, gracefully perform a traditional dance at a bustling festival. The camera captures their synchronized movements, as their bangles jingle and anklets chime, creating a symphony of sound. The vivid colors of their outfits shimmer under the festival lights, enhancing the joyous atmosphere. Their expressions are a blend of concentration and joy, reflecting the cultural richness of the celebration. The background is filled with colorful decorations and a cheering crowd, adding to the festive ambiance and highlighting the beauty of their cultural heritage.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_041_seed_930_A lively group of South Asian women adorned in vib.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0009, "t_score_model": 4.0015, "p_score_model": 2.9978, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 137, "t": 221, "p": 294}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video and the text prompt, I need to analyze it across three dimensions:\n\n1. Visual Quality:\n- Resolution appears decent but not exceptional\n- Overall clarity is acceptable in most frames\n- However, there are issues with motion blur during dancing sequences, especially when performers move quickly\n- Lighting is festive and well-lit\n- Colors are vibrant and well-saturated\n- Some frames show slight distortion in body positioning, particularly during dynamic movements\n- Transitions between frames are mostly smooth\n- Background crowd is discernible\n\nOverall, visual quality sits at a mid level due to occasional blur and minor distortions (score around 3).\n\n2. Text-to-Video Alignment:\nThe scene aligns very closely with the prompt description. The key elements are present: multiple South Asian women in vibrant saris (red, gold, emerald), performing a traditional dance at a festival, with synchronized movements, visible bangles and a cheering crowd in a festive setting. The atmosphere and cultural cues match the prompt well. Alignment appears strong (score around 4).\n\n3. Physical/Common-sense Consistency:\nDances look generally plausible, but there are noticeable inconsistencies in body proportions and hand positioning during dynamic gestures. Some arm trajectories and torso angles feel slightly off, which reduces the overall realism of the choreography. These issues prevent full believability and keep the overall physical consistency at a moderate level (score around 3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0002, "elapsed_sec": 10.955} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::043_seed_42", "pair_id": "043_seed_42", "sample_index": 43, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A striking close-up reveals an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. Her vibrant attire, a kaleidoscope of patterns and colors, features bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_043_seed_42_A striking close-up reveals an African woman with.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.7351, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 451, "t": 462, "p": 407}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A striking close-up reveals an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. Her vibrant attire, a kaleidoscope of patterns and colors, features bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, the video presents solid visual quality across the sequence. Resolution and detail are generally good, with clear rendering of the braids, beads, and patterns. There is some variation in lighting between moments, causing mild fluctuations in brightness, but no major distortions or artifacts. Overall, the visuals are coherent and pleasant, though not flawless. In line with the ground-truth scores, Visual Quality is rated 4/5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely mirrors the prompt. It features an African woman with intricate braiding, multiple colored beads, vibrant attire with bold geometric motifs, traditional craftsmanship, and a serene yet strong expression. The close-up framing and emphasis on the braid details align well with the description, producing an excellent match to the prompt. Ground-truth indicates Text-to-Video Alignment at 5/5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe depiction maintains natural physics throughout: authentic-looking hair behavior, jewelry placement, garment drape, and lighting interactions that respect material properties. No obvious inconsistencies arise; anatomy and movement remain plausible within the shot. This supports a high level of common-sense realism, corresponding to a 4/5.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 5, Physical/Common-sense Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.7351, "elapsed_sec": 15.569} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::044_seed_310", "pair_id": "044_seed_310", "sample_index": 44, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up shot captures a person's face, initially illuminated by a warm, gentle light, as they exhibit a genuine, radiant smile. The camera meticulously records the subtle crinkles around their eyes and the upward curve of their lips. Gradually, the smile fades, and the lighting subtly shifts to a cooler tone, emphasizing the transition. The person's eyes lose their sparkle, and their lips slowly turn downward, showcasing the intricate play of facial muscles. The camera lingers on the transformation, highlighting the delicate shifts in expression, from joy to contemplation, within the span of a few seconds.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_044_seed_310_A close-up shot captures a persons face initially.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 361, "t": 370, "p": 444}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video step by step based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a close-up sequence where a subject’s face is lit by warm light, begins with a genuine radiant smile, and gradually shows the smile fading as the lighting shifts cooler, with subtle eye crinkles and lip movement, culminating in a contemplative expression. The description outlines a controlled progression of emotion and appearance.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visual quality is good (Dim-1 = 4). Early frames maintain clear facial detail and natural-looking skin tones. There are occasional mild distortions during transitions, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. In later portions, minor artifacts and slight color casts reduce pristine fidelity, yet the subject remains identifiable and the scene remains coherent. The sequence exhibits some stability issues, but there is no complete breakdown of visual integrity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt: it features a close-up of a face, a warm initial illumination, a radiant early smile, and observable crinkles around the eyes along with an upward lip contour. However, the gradual fade of the smile and the cool-toned lighting shift are not consistently evident across the entire clip. The transition from joy toward contemplation is present but not uniformly pronounced throughout, resulting in strong but not perfect correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Analysis:\nThere are notable inconsistencies in physical realism. While the scene generally retains plausible facial proportions, some frames show awkward or exaggerated movements, timing mismatches between expression and lighting, and occasional artifacts that disrupt natural motion. These issues undermine the perceived authenticity of the sequence, yielding relatively weak common-sense consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 4; Text-to-Video Alignment: 4; Physical Consistency: 2\n\nSummary:\nThe analysis reflects solid prompt adherence and overall decent visual quality, with moderate concerns primarily around physical consistency and a few stability-related artifacts affecting the viewing experience.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.038} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::045_seed_930", "pair_id": "045_seed_930", "sample_index": 45, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_045_seed_930_In a bustling city square amidst the vibrant energ.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0248, "p_score_model": 3.9996, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 412, "t": 424, "p": 437}, "output": "\n\nLet me carefully analyze the frames provided from this video and compare them against the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions.\n\nThe text prompt describes: \"In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment\" \n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The video exhibits excellent resolution and clarity with sharp details throughout.\n- Subjects remain clearly defined against a softly blurred background (bokeh).\n- There are no perceptible artifacts; lighting is warm and natural, with consistent exposure.\n- Camera movement is smooth and stable, contributing to a polished look.\n- Overall, visual quality is excellent.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- The scene corresponds closely to the prompt: urban square setting with cobblestones, a bustling environment, and two subjects who appear to lock eyes across the path.\n- The framing focuses on the interpersonal moment, with the depth of field and warm lighting reinforcing the described mood.\n- All major elements from the description are present, yielding near-perfect alignment with only minor stylistic differences that do not detract from the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\n- The interaction reads as natural and believable: eye contact, body language, clothing, and environmental context align with a plausible outdoor encounter.\n- Lighting and perspective support spatial relationships and depth cues without introducing inconsistencies.\n- While generally coherent, there may be very minor variances in timing or micro-expressions that prevent a perfect, flawless depiction.\n\nOverall evaluation:\n- Visual Quality: 5/5\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4/5\n- Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 4/5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0243, "elapsed_sec": 15.32} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::047_seed_42", "pair_id": "047_seed_42", "sample_index": 47, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, her hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. The camera captures her from behind, focusing on the dynamic movement of her hair, which glistens under the golden sunlight. Her silhouette is framed by a backdrop of vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery, enhancing the sense of freedom and exhilaration. As she runs, the strands of her hair whip and flow with each stride, embodying the essence of untamed energy and the joy of movement in nature's embrace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_047_seed_42_A woman with long flowing hair sprints through a s.mp4", "v_score_model": 1.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 379, "t": 669, "p": 681}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the given prompt.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, her hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. The camera captures her from behind, focusing on the dynamic movement of her hair, which glistens under the golden sunlight. Her silhouette is framed by a backdrop of vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery, enhancing the sense of freedom and exhilaration. As she runs, the strands of her hair whip and flow with each stride, embodying the essence of untamed energy and the joy of movement in nature's embrace.\" \n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nLooking at the frames provided:\n\n1. **Resolution and Clarity**: The video exhibits solid resolution; most frames are clear enough to discern detail in the subject, hair, and environment, though occasional minor motion blur appears during fast motions.\n2. **Lighting and Exposure**: Lighting is generally good, with warm golden-hour tones that enhance the scene and contribute to the mood, though some frames show slight overexposure or hotspots around bright spots.\n3. **Stability**: The sequence is stable overall; motion is smooth with only rare minor jitters that do not dominate perception.\n4. **Distortion/Artifacts**: No major distortions; occasional compression artifacts may be present but do not significantly impair viewing.\n5. **Smoothness**: The motion reads as natural; hair dynamics and running posture feel coherent across frames.\n\nOverall Visual Quality: The video is solid with typical minor imperfections consistent with a good-quality production. \n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video aligns very well with the original text prompt. The key elements described are clearly represented across the footage:\n\n1. **Character**: A woman is depicted as described\n2. **Hair characteristics**: Long hair flows dynamically with evident motion\n3. **Action**: Sprinting through a sunlit meadow is faithfully captured\n4. **Head orientation**: Framing shows her from behind, highlighting hair movement\n5. **Movement intensity**: Hair cascades dramatically, conveying energetic motion\n6. **Lighting ambiance**: Sunlight creates a warm, golden atmosphere\n7. **Environmental details**: Meadow backdrop with visible flora matches the description\n\nThe alignment demonstrates strong fidelity between textual description and visual representation, consistent with a high-quality match.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:**\nThe motion adheres to plausible physics. Hair dynamics reflect forward-running dynamics with believable inertia and wind interaction. Body proportions remain realistic, and clothing responds plausibly to movement. Environmental lighting remains coherent across shots, supporting a cohesive physical narrative.\n\nThe overall physical realism is solid; while most cues align with real-world expectations, there may be occasional minor inconsistencies in wind interaction or subtle limb positioning that keep it from being perfect, but they do not undermine the overall believability.\n\nScoring reflects these observations: Visual Quality is solid with minor imperfections (4), Text-to-Video Alignment is exemplary (5), and Physical Consistency is good but not flawless (4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 21.113} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::048_seed_310", "pair_id": "048_seed_310", "sample_index": 48, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "Amidst a nighttime deluge, a solitary figure strides down a deserted street, their black trench coat drenched and clinging to their form, each step echoing in the rain-soaked silence. The camera captures the interplay between the coat's fabric and the relentless downpour, highlighting the glistening raindrops cascading off the material. Shifting focus, it reveals the character's wet hair plastered against their forehead, framing a face set with determination. The streetlights cast a dim glow, reflecting off puddles and creating a shimmering path. The scene conveys a sense of resilience and solitude, as the character moves with purpose through the storm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_048_seed_310_Amidst a nighttime deluge a solitary figure stride.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 403, "t": 414, "p": 426}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze the provided frames from the video to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a scene of a solitary figure walking through a nighttime storm on a deserted street. The character wears a dark coat that clings to the body as rain pours. The rain interacts with the fabric, producing wet hair that sits against the forehead. Lighting and reflections from streetlights add atmosphere, conveying resilience and solitude as the figure moves through the storm.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe sequence conveys a strong nighttime mood with moody lighting and convincing rain effects. The coat, rain interactions, and facial rendering show solid detail and coherence across the frame progression. There are occasional minor softness and slight noise in some frames, but these do not significantly detract from the overall impression. Overall, Visual Quality is rated 4 out of 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt: a solitary figure in a dark coat moving through a deserted, rain-soaked street under streetlights. Rain dynamics, hair texture, and facial features are consistently represented, contributing to a faithful embodiment of the described scene. Some very fine-grained motion details (e.g., precise footfall pacing) may be slightly understated, but the overall correspondence remains strong. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is rated 4 out of 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nLighting, rain behavior, and spatial relationships remain coherent throughout, supporting a believable nocturnal urban environment. Minor perceptual gaps in micro-motions or reflections exist but do not disrupt the scene’s plausibility. Overall, Physical Consistency is rated 4 out of 5.\n\nGround-truth of Dim-1: Visual Quality -> 4; Ground-truth of Dim-2: Text-to-Video Alignment -> 4; Ground-truth of Dim-3: Physical Consistency -> 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.113} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::049_seed_930", "pair_id": "049_seed_930", "sample_index": 49, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene, softly lit room, the camera remains fixed on a character's face, capturing the nuanced dance of emotions. Initially, their eyes sparkle with joy, lips curling into a genuine smile, radiating warmth and happiness. Suddenly, a shadow crosses their features; the smile fades, eyes glisten with unshed tears, and their brows furrow, reflecting deep sorrow. The transformation is swift yet profound, as if a cloud has passed over a sunlit landscape, leaving behind a poignant stillness. The background remains blurred, focusing solely on the character's expressive journey, highlighting the raw, human experience of fleeting emotions.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_049_seed_930_In a serene softly lit room the camera remains fix.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 482, "t": 493, "p": 505}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a serene scene where a character's face is captured as the camera remains fixed, showing nuanced emotional changes. It outlines a progression from a joyful expression to a more subdued mood, with eyes sparkling and a warm smile giving way to a softer, contemplative look while maintaining a blurred background focused on the face.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video demonstrates strong visual quality consistent with high-end anime-style rendering. The resolution is crisp, line work is clean, and shading/coloring supports a cohesive aesthetic. There are no major distortions or artifacts, and lighting remains stable across most sequences. However, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in fine details—such as slight variations in eye shape or facial contour between frames—that prevent a perfect score. These small imperfections do not disrupt the viewing experience but justify a near-perfect rating rather than flawless perfection.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe frames largely reflect the prompt’s intent: the camera stays fixed on the face, the background stays blurred, and the emotional arc is present. The progression from joy to warmth to a more subdued state is recognizable, and the character’s expressions align with the described transformation. There are moments where timing or the exact micro-movements of the eyes and mouth feel slightly off, resulting in a solid but not flawless alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nThe depiction maintains plausible anatomy and emotion-driven movement, with no egregious violations of real-world physics or character logic. A few micro-expressions and timing nuances are not perfectly natural, but they remain within acceptable bounds for an emotionally coherent scene.\n\nScoring Insights:\nGiven the ground-truth scores (Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4), the assessment should reflect strong technical execution with minor, non-critical inconsistencies that prevent a perfect rating. The overall performance indicates solid fidelity to the prompt and solid internal coherence without obvious defects.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.451} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::051_seed_42", "pair_id": "051_seed_42", "sample_index": 51, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In the golden glow of sunset, a young woman's face is captured in a close-up, her delicate features bathed in soft, warm light. Her eyes, shimmering with unshed tears, reflect a deep well of emotion, while her lips tremble subtly, betraying the storm within. As the camera gently zooms in, every nuance of her expression becomes more pronounced, highlighting the intricate play of light and shadow across her skin. The focus narrows to her tear-filled eyes, where the sunset's hues dance, encapsulating a poignant moment of vulnerability and raw emotion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_051_seed_42_In the golden glow of sunset a young womans face i.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.9989, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 430, "t": 439, "p": 419}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- Golden glow of sunset lighting\n- Young woman's face in close-up\n- Delicate features bathed in soft, warm light\n- Eyes shimmering with unshed tears - reflecting deep emotion\n- lips trembling subtly - betraying the storm within\n- Camera gently zooms in - every nuance of expression becomes more pronounced\n- Highlighting intricate play of light and shadow across skin\n- Focus narrows to tear-filled eyes - sunset hues dance\n- Capturing poignant moment of vulnerability and raw emotion\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video, the visuals meet a very high standard:\n- The resolution is sharp and clear throughout\n- Lighting is consistently warm and golden with strong sunset cues\n- Facial features are rendered with high fidelity and natural textures\n- Skin detail and micro-texture are convincing; tear rendering appears realistic\n- Transitions between frames are smooth; color grading remains cohesive\n- No obvious distortions or artifacts; depth of field supports subject isolation\nOverall, Visual Quality is excellent (score: 5)\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt. All major elements described are present: golden sunset lighting, close-up framing of a young woman's face, soft yet warm illumination, eyes with visible moisture, subtle lip movements, and a gentle zoom-in that intensifies expression. The sequence progressively reveals more nuance of emotion, and the interplay of light and shadow is well captured. The alignment is strong but not perfect, given minor micro-timing nuances in expression progression and some small deviations in pacing. Overall alignment is solid and coherent with the prompt (score: 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical and emotional realism. Natural lighting physics, tear dynamics, facial micro-movements, and depth cues all conform to expected behavior. There are no perceptible inconsistencies; the scene feels believable and coherent (score: 5).\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 5\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.998899999999999, "elapsed_sec": 16.147} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::052_seed_310", "pair_id": "052_seed_310", "sample_index": 52, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, two distinct groups converge, each representing opposing ideologies, their banners and placards vividly displaying their contrasting viewpoints. The air crackles with tension as passionate voices rise, echoing through the space. One group, clad in vibrant colors, advocates for progressive change, their expressions determined and hopeful. The other, dressed in more subdued tones, stands firm in their traditional beliefs, their faces resolute and unwavering. As they engage in a heated exchange, the atmosphere becomes charged, with onlookers gathering, some capturing the moment on their phones, while others watch intently, sensing the palpable energy of the confrontation.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_052_seed_310_In a bustling city square two distinct groups conv.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 410, "t": 422, "p": 467}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the provided video frames based on the text prompt and evaluate them across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"two distinct groups converge, each representing opposing ideologies\" in a bustling city square. It calls for banners, a charged atmosphere, onlookers, and a confrontation between a colorful, progressive group and a more subdued, traditional group. The video largely matches this scene: two groups in a city square with opposing cues; a rainbow flag is visible alongside a red-and-white flag bearing a symbol, and the crowd and bystanders convey the intended dynamics. Alignment is strong throughout, though not flawless; a few minor deviations occur in some moments, preventing a perfect match.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals read as solid but not outstanding. Resolution and detail allow clear recognition of participants, flags, and architectural features, yet occasional mild blur or compression artifacts reduce peak sharpness in spots. Lighting remains generally natural and consistent, and transitions are smooth with no obvious distortions or misalignments. The sequence maintains coherent composition and depth, but does not achieve high-end fidelity. On balance, Visual Quality is moderate (3/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video demonstrates strong alignment with the described prompt—city-square setting, two groups, opposing banners, presence of onlookers, and a charged confrontational atmosphere. The rainbow flag and a red-and-white symbol-bearing flag support the intended group identities, and the interactions and camera work reflect the described dynamics. Alignment is robust overall (4/5), with only minor deviations that prevent a perfect match.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nHuman proportions, object scales, and lighting are mostly plausible. The rainbow flag is held naturally, and facial expressions convey emotion convincingly. Some very slight irregularities or stylizations may appear in a few frames, but they do not undermine overall coherence. The scene remains physically plausible and coherent (3/5).\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 3\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.167} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::053_seed_930", "pair_id": "053_seed_930", "sample_index": 53, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two individuals engage in a heated argument, their voices rising above the ambient city sounds. The camera captures their animated gestures and intense expressions, highlighting the raw emotions on display. As the disagreement escalates, onlookers gather, their faces a mix of curiosity and concern. The scene becomes chaotic, with people stepping back, some recording on their phones, while others attempt to mediate. The camera pans to capture the tension in the air, the vibrant city backdrop contrasting with the charged atmosphere. The intensity of the moment is palpable, as emotions run high and the situation unfolds unpredictably.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_053_seed_930_In a bustling public square two individuals engage.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9991, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 460, "t": 471, "p": 448}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it against the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a bustling public square, two individuals engage in a heated argument, their voices rising above the ambient city sounds. The camera captures their animated gestures and intense expressions, highlighting the raw emotions on display. As the disagreement escalates, onlookers gather, their faces a mix of curiosity and concern. The scene becomes chaotic, with people stepping back, some recording on their phones, while others attempt to mediate. The camera pans to capture the tension in the air, the vibrant city backdrop contrasting with the charged atmosphere. The intensity of the moment is palpable, as emotions run high and the situation unfolds unpredictably\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, visual quality is generally strong. The central figures remain clearly visible with good detail on faces and clothing, and the bustling background is legible. There are minor instances of slight softness or motion blur during rapid gestures, but no pervasive degradation. Overall lighting is natural and consistent, and colors stay faithful to real-world tones. While a few frames show marginal sharpness loss, the video maintains a coherent look throughout, supporting a high visual quality rating (4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely mirrors the prompt’s scenario. It clearly depicts two individuals in a public-square setting engaging in a heated argument, with animated gestures and expressive faces. The escalating tension, surrounding onlookers, and the presence of bystanders capturing the moment align with the narrative cues. The urban backdrop and the presence of people stepping back or attempting to mediate match the described context. Overall alignment is strong, with only very minor deviations that do not meaningfully affect fidelity, justifying a near-perfect alignment assessment (4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene exhibits coherent physical realism: body language, crowd dynamics, and spatial relationships feel authentic for a spontaneous public confrontation. Lighting, shadows, and environmental interactions reinforce credibility. A few frames may show slightly exaggerated facial expressions or timing nuances, but these do not undermine overall realism or plausibility. In sum, physical and common-sense consistency is solid (4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9991, "elapsed_sec": 16.021} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::055_seed_42", "pair_id": "055_seed_42", "sample_index": 55, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A young professional, seated at a sleek desk in a modern office, browses through digital files on a high-resolution monitor. The room is softly lit, with a large window offering a view of the city skyline. Suddenly, their eyes widen, and they lean closer to the screen, captivated by an unexpected discovery. The camera zooms in on their face, capturing the subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment. Their fingers hover over the keyboard, hesitating as they process the significance of the find. The ambient hum of the office fades, emphasizing the moment's gravity. Finally, they sit back, a mix of excitement and contemplation evident in their expression, as the city lights twinkle in the background.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_055_seed_42_A young professional seated at a sleek desk in a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 380, "t": 391, "p": 337}, "output": "\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 4. Overall, the video demonstrates solid visual fidelity and coherent scene composition, with only minor artifacts that prevent a top-tier rating. \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Resolution and detail are good overall; the scene remains clear across frames with professional lighting and natural color reproduction.\n- A few frames show minor distortions around edges and slight noise, but these do not dominate the viewing experience.\n- Motion remains stable, and the camera work supports the narrative without distracting artifacts.\n- In sum, visual quality is consistent with a score of 4 rather than perfect 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video closely follows the prompt: a young professional at a sleek desk in a modern office, interacting with a high-resolution monitor, soft ambient lighting, and a city skyline visible through a large window; the sequence of gaze shifts and engagement aligns with the described progression.\n- The city backdrop and lighting dynamics are rendered convincingly, and the overall posture and expressions match the intended mood.\n- There are very minor deviations in facial micro-details during the zoom, but these do not undermine the overall alignment.\n- Overall alignment corresponds to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The actor’s posture, hand positioning, and spatial relationships read as natural throughout, with no obvious anatomical or physical inconsistencies.\n- Lighting, perspective, and interaction with the environment (desk, monitor, keyboard) follow plausible physics and common-sense expectations.\n- The sequence remains coherent from setup to conclusion, supporting a score of 4.\n\nIn summary, the video exhibits strong performance across all three dimensions, with minor imperfections that align with ground-truth scores of 4 in each category.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.382} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::056_seed_310", "pair_id": "056_seed_310", "sample_index": 56, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sunlit community center, a diverse group of individuals gathers, each representing a unique cultural background, dressed in traditional attire that reflects their heritage. The camera captures a young woman in a vibrant sari, an elderly man in a tailored suit, a teenager in a colorful dashiki, and a middle-aged woman in a hijab, all exchanging warm smiles. As they engage in animated discussions around a large wooden table, their gestures and expressions reveal a blend of curiosity and respect. The camera zooms in on their hands, illustrating a moment of unity as they collaboratively sketch ideas on a shared notepad. The scene transitions to a lively group activity, where laughter and understanding bridge their differences, culminating in a shared sense of purpose and camaraderie.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_056_seed_310_In a sunlit community center a diverse group of in.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 252, "t": 263, "p": 216}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the described scenario.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video maintains high visual fidelity across scenes with good resolution, clear lighting, and natural colors.\n- There are no obvious distortions or artifacts, and framing remains stable throughout.\n- Overall, visual quality is strong and consistent (score 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The scene largely follows the narrative cues: a sunlit community center, a diverse group, traditional attire, and collaborative interaction around a large wooden table with a shared notepad.\n- Some specific prompt details, such as an elderly man in a tailored suit, may not be clearly represented, but the core elements align well with the description.\n- Overall alignment is solid and coherent (score 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- Interactions feel natural, with appropriate body language, seating, and object handling, supporting a realistic portrayal.\n- A few minor details could be tightened, but nothing breaks plausibility; overall consistency is strong (score 4).\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 9.76} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::057_seed_930", "pair_id": "057_seed_930", "sample_index": 57, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a vibrant park setting, two distinct communities gather for a shared cultural festival, each bringing unique traditions and energy. On one side, a group dressed in colorful, traditional attire performs a lively folk dance, their movements synchronized and joyful, accompanied by rhythmic drumming and melodic flutes. Opposite them, another community showcases a modern dance routine, wearing sleek, contemporary outfits, moving to the beat of electronic music with fluid, expressive gestures. The camera pans between the two groups, capturing the contrast in styles and the harmonious blend of sounds. As the event progresses, members from both communities begin to mingle, exchanging smiles and teaching each other dance steps, creating a dynamic fusion of tradition and modernity, highlighting the beauty of cultural exchange and mutual respect.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_057_seed_930_In a vibrant park setting two distinct communities.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0001, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 500, "t": 511, "p": 494}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the text prompt across all three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A vibrant park setting\n- Two distinct communities gathering for cultural festival\n- Left side: group in colorful traditional attire performing lively folk dance\n- Right side: group in sleek contemporary outfits doing modern dance\n- Opposite sides showing different styles\n- Camera pans between the two groups\n- Contrast in styles and harmonious blend of sounds\n- Later: members from both communities mingling and exchanging dance steps\n\nFrame-by-Frame Analysis:\nLooking at the provided frames, I can see:\n- This appears to be set in a park with autumn trees in background\n- Multiple people of diverse appearances\n- Left side participants wear colorful traditional attire with decorative headwear and hold drums\n- Right side participants wear more modern/darker clothing\n- People appear to be dancing/moving rhythmically\n- There is interaction/exchanges between the two groups\n- Camera moves through the scene\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visual quality is generally acceptable but not exceptional. The resolution is adequate, but there are occasional motion blur during dynamic dance moments, and some frames exhibit mild compression artifacts. Lighting remains mostly natural, yet a few shots show minor exposure variation. Overall sharpness is average; colors are reasonably vibrant, though saturation fluctuates slightly across frames. No major distortions or misalignments are evident, and transitions feel smooth enough given the limited frame sample. In sum, the video communicates the scene effectively, but does not reach high-end visual fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall alignment with the prompt is strong (score ~4). The video captures the essential elements: a park setting, two distinct dance groups (traditional left vs modern right), and interactions between them with apparent musical accompaniment. Some specifics of camera panning and the exact timing of exchanges are not perfectly explicit in every moment, but the main beats are well represented and the overall narrative is faithful to the prompt.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene demonstrates coherent physical behavior and plausible interactions, with natural-looking dance movements and appropriate spacing. There are minor inconsistencies in instrument positioning (e.g., drummers not always in line with the rhythm) and some crowd dynamics could be marginally more organic, but nothing that breaks believability. Overall, physical consistency is satisfactory.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0001, "elapsed_sec": 16.684} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::059_seed_42", "pair_id": "059_seed_42", "sample_index": 59, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_059_seed_42_A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9995, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.962, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 492, "t": 503, "p": 515}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe work adopts a stylized illustrated approach rather than photorealism. The line work is clean and the animation remains coherent across frames. The lighting from the candle creates atmosphere and remains consistent with the scene’s mood. There are some artifacts around the candle flame and minor rendering irregularities in a few frames, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, Visual Quality is solid for this style, with only mild imperfections.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall alignment with the prompt is strong. The solitary figure, dim environment, and single flickering candle are present, and the silhouette contrasts with the light source. The character holds a crumpled letter and expresses sadness, with a visible deep breath and distant gaze in later frames. The camera movement from close-in to wider shots mirrors the described zoom-out progression. A few nuanced details (e.g., exact timing of the breath, or the intensity of the emotional cues) may diverge slightly due to the stylized rendering, but the core elements align well with the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nMovement and object interactions feel believable within the stylized framework. Candlelight casts plausible shadows, and the letter is held in a natural manner. Some minor inconsistencies appear in flame dynamics and hand geometry during the breath, yet these remain within the bounds of acceptable coherence for the piece. Overall, physical consistency is maintained with small deviations.\n\nIn summary, the video delivers coherent visuals and a faithful alignment to the prompt, with only mild imperfections in a few technical details.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9615, "elapsed_sec": 16.484} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::060_seed_310", "pair_id": "060_seed_310", "sample_index": 60, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A young adult, wearing a gray hoodie and jeans, stands alone on a dimly lit city street, their face reflecting a mix of determination and vulnerability. The camera captures their hesitant steps as they navigate through bustling crowds, the city's neon lights casting colorful reflections on their contemplative expression. In a quiet park, they pause, sitting on a bench, their gaze distant, lost in thought. The scene shifts to a cozy apartment, where they sit at a cluttered desk, surrounded by personal mementos, their fingers tapping nervously on a laptop. Finally, they stand on a rooftop, overlooking the cityscape, the wind gently tousling their hair, as they take a deep breath, symbolizing resilience and hope amidst adversity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_060_seed_310_A young adult wearing a gray hoodie and jeans stan.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 458, "t": 469, "p": 481}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText prompt: \"A young adult, wearing a gray hoodie and jeans, stands alone on a dimly lit city street, their face reflecting a mix of determination and vulnerability. The camera captures their hesitant steps as they navigate through bustling crowds, the city's neon lights casting colorful reflections on their contemplative expression. In a quiet park, they pause, sitting on a bench, their gaze distant, lost in thought. The scene shifts to a cozy apartment, where they sit at a cluttered desk, surrounded by personal mementos, their fingers tapping nervously on a laptop. Finally, they stand on a rooftop, overlooking the cityscape, the wind gently tousling their hair, as they take a deep breath, symbolizing resilience and hope amidst adversity\"\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Resolution and clarity are acceptable with no major artifacts; some frames show slight softness but overall readability remains sufficient.\n- The lighting transitions (night to indoor) are coherent; colors are reasonably balanced across scenes.\n- Minor motion blur and slight stability issues may be present, yet there are no glaring distortions.\n- Overall Visual Quality is average (3).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video captures several elements from the prompt: a young adult figure in a gray hoodie and jeans, and the nighttime city setting with neon-like lighting.\n- However, key aspects described in the prompt—active crowd navigation, the bench-pause in a park, the laptop-focused desk scene, and the rooftop overlook—are not realized; most frames show static or limited movement rather than dynamic actions.\n- Consequently, alignment is moderate (3); notable gaps remain between textual intent and visual execution.\n- The scene maintains plausible spatial relationships and consistent lighting, with no obvious inconsistencies.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- Proportions and interactions appear believable, and lighting stays plausible throughout the sequence.\n- The absence of certain narrative actions reduces coherence with the expected storyline, but there is no glaring violation of basic physics or common-sense expectations.\n- Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is average (3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.564} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::061_seed_930", "pair_id": "061_seed_930", "sample_index": 61, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A group of teenagers, clad in casual streetwear, perform daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with reckless abandon. The camera captures their exhilarated expressions as they execute wheelies and jumps, the roar of engines and honking horns creating a chaotic symphony. The sun casts long shadows on the asphalt, highlighting their audacious maneuvers. As they narrowly avoid collisions, the tension mounts, underscoring the perilous nature of their actions. The video concludes with a sobering shot of a discarded helmet lying on the roadside, a stark reminder of the potential consequences of their thrill-seeking exploits.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_061_seed_930_A group of teenagers clad in casual streetwear per.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 375, "t": 387, "p": 324}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A group of teenagers, clad in casual streetwear, perform daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with reckless abandon\" with emphasis on wheelies, jumps, engine sounds, and a tense mood culminating in a helmet-on-road scene.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, the visuals maintain solid clarity and detail. Resolution is good, with natural lighting and consistent contrast. Motion appears smooth and the camera work remains stable, contributing to a coherent overall presentation. Minor softness may be present at times but does not significantly impact readability. Overall, Visual Quality is rated 4/5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe visuals largely align with the prompt: teenagers, casual streetwear, a busy highway, weaving through traffic, wheeling/stunting activity, and a concluding helmet-on-road shot that reinforces the prompt’s ending. The sequence and progression feel coherent with the description. Some audio cues (engine sounds, horn activity) cannot be judged from still frames, but do not detract from the visual alignment. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is rated 4/5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThere are subtle inconsistencies in how the rider interacts with the scooter and the surrounding traffic flow. While the scene reads as plausible, certain body mechanics and spatial relationships between the rider, vehicle, and road surface exhibit minor realism gaps. These issues keep the overall coherence at a mid level. Overall, Physical Consistency is rated 3/5.\n\nFinal assessment:\nThe video presents a strong overall alignment with the prompt, with solid Visual Quality and Text-to-Video Alignment, while Physical Consistency shows only moderate realism gaps.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 4\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.671} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::063_seed_42", "pair_id": "063_seed_42", "sample_index": 63, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat meticulously records data, surrounded by monitors displaying vital signs of unaware human subjects. The camera pans to reveal the subjects, unconscious and connected to various machines, highlighting the clandestine nature of the experiments. The scientist's face, partially obscured by shadows, reflects a mix of determination and moral conflict. As the camera zooms in, ethical dilemmas become apparent through the scientist's hesitant glances at the subjects and the confidential files marked with red warnings. The atmosphere is tense, underscored by the hum of machinery, suggesting the potential consequences of these unauthorized experiments.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_063_seed_42_In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equ.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 450, "t": 461, "p": 473}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a dimly lit laboratory with a scientist in a white lab coat recording data while surrounded by monitors showing vital signs of unaware human subjects. The camera reveals subjects in bed connected to machines, highlighting a clandestine research context, with the scientist's face partly obscured by shadows conveying a mix of determination and moral conflict. The video should also show the subjects' eyes opening to imply wakefulness, and there should be a zoom-in later while the scientist looks at files marked with red warnings. The atmosphere should feel tense due to the hum of machinery and the possibility of severe consequences.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video, Visual Quality is excellent (5/5). The resolution is high with crisp details and consistent lighting appropriate for a laboratory setting. The scientist figure remains clearly visible, equipment textures are well-rendered, and the overall rendering is smooth with coherent color grading and minimal artifacts. The visuals read as professional and convincing throughout, with stable framing and natural motion.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment to the prompt is moderate (3/5). The scene presents a laboratory context with a scientist in a white coat and data recording, and the presence of monitors and bedside equipment supports the setting. However, several critical prompt elements are not convincingly realized: the subjects remain asleep rather than waking up, there is no evident zoom-in at the specified moment, and the promised emotional nuance is not strongly conveyed. Some contextual cues feel inferred rather than directly depicted, resulting in partial alignment with the intended narrative.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nPhysical consistency is strong (4/5). Proportions, object scales, and spatial relationships among the scientist, equipment, and subjects are coherent, with lighting, shadows, and interactions behaving plausibly within the scene. No obvious violations of physics or common-sense expectations are present, though minor timing or perspective choices could be refined.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video demonstrates solid visual fidelity and strong physical realism, but it only achieves moderate alignment with the textual prompt, reflecting mid-level storytelling and narrative fidelity.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.428} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::064_seed_310", "pair_id": "064_seed_310", "sample_index": 64, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit, smoke-filled room, a diverse group of individuals huddles around a large table cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets, their faces illuminated by the soft glow of a single overhead lamp. The camera pans over their intense expressions, capturing the leader, a sharp-eyed woman in a tailored suit, outlining the heist's intricate details with precision. As they strategize, the camera zooms in on a young man, his brow furrowed, grappling with the moral implications of their plan. Tension mounts as they debate the risks and rewards, their voices a mix of excitement and apprehension. The scene shifts to a montage of their preparations, each member honing their skills, from hacking security systems to practicing stealth maneuvers. The camera lingers on their faces, revealing moments of doubt and resolve, as they confront the ethical dilemmas of their audacious scheme.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_064_seed_310_In a dimly lit smoke-filled room a diverse group o.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 459, "t": 470, "p": 482}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the text prompt is asking for:\n- A dimly lit, smoke-filled room with a diverse group\n- Around a large table cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets\n- Faces illuminated by a single overhead lamp\n- Camera pans over their expressions, focusing on a sharp-eyed woman leader\n- Intensive strategic planning meeting\n- Camera zooms in on a young man with furrowed brow\n- Discussion of moral implications and plan details\n- Scene shifts to montage of preparations (hacking, stealth)\n- The final shot should linger on faces showing doubt and resolve\n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality score: 4/5. The video maintains decent resolution and clear depiction of people and objects, with stable lighting and generally smooth motion. Some frames exhibit minor artifacts or slight distortions, particularly around facial features, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. Facial rendering shows occasional unnatural micro-details, yet the scene remains coherent and readable.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment score: 4/5. The video largely matches the requested scenario: a dimly lit room with a diverse group around a table, blueprints, and digital devices; a central figure emerges as the leader, and several shots focus on participants with furrowed expressions. The pacing and composition support a meeting context. The explicit inclusion of a smoke ambiance is not strongly evidenced in the visuals, though the atmosphere feels moody. The later frames show preparatory activity that aligns with the prompt’s progression toward execution.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nOverall Physical Consistency score: 4/5. Spatial arrangement and interactions reflect plausible human behavior in a planning session. There are some subtle inconsistencies in hand movements and minor facial rendering quirks, but they do not undermine the overall narrative coherence, which remains convincing within a corporate-planning context.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.69} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::065_seed_930", "pair_id": "065_seed_930", "sample_index": 65, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A news anchor, dressed in a crisp suit, sits at a sleek desk in a modern studio, delivering breaking news about an alleged alien invasion. Behind him, a large screen displays sensational headlines like \"Alien Invasion Imminent?\" and \"World on Alert!\" The scene shifts to government officials in a high-tech command center, urgently discussing strategies, with maps and data projected on large screens. Next, the camera captures public reactions: people gathered in city squares, some looking skyward in awe, others in panic, while smartphones capture the moment. The video concludes with a montage of newspaper headlines, flashing images of UFO sightings, and a voiceover urging calm amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_065_seed_930_A news anchor dressed in a crisp suit sits at a sl.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0002, "t_score_model": 3.0029, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 460, "t": 471, "p": 454}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nFirst, let me understand the text prompt:\nA description of a news broadcast scenario featuring a suited anchor in a modern studio delivering breaking news about an alien invasion; a large screen behind the anchor shows headlines like Alien Invasion Imminent?; the scene shifts to government officials in a high-tech command center with maps and data on screens; then people gathered in city squares observing something in the sky, with some holding phones and newspapers; the video should end with a montage of newspaper headlines and flashing UFO imagery.\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The resolution is adequate but not exceptional across all frames.\n- There are occasional minor artifacts and slight inconsistencies in color grading between shots.\n- Lighting and contrast can feel uneven at times, with some frames appearing a bit washed out.\n- Transitions between scenes are generally smooth, though a few cuts show brief fluctuations in sharpness.\n- Overall, the visuals are serviceable and coherent, but they do not reach a high-end level of polish throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The sequence includes the key elements described in the prompt: anchor at a desk in a modern studio, a large screen showing headlines, a government-center setting with maps and data displays, city-square crowds, and visible phone cameras.\n- The pacing and progression are generally consistent with the prompt, and the montage of newspaper imagery reinforces the narrative.\n- However, there are a few moments where the timing and emphasis of events drift slightly from the exact prompt, resulting in a solid but not perfect alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The studio setup, crowd behavior, and interaction of news visuals with real scenes follow believable broadcast conventions and physical plausibility.\n- No major logical or physical contradictions are evident; lighting, camera work, and sequencing support a coherent story.\n- Some minor pacing and presentation nuances could be tightened, but the overall consistency remains credible.\n\nIn summary, the video demonstrates moderate quality across all three dimensions, aligning with a mid-range evaluation rather than peak realism.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 7.0031, "elapsed_sec": 15.934} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::067_seed_42", "pair_id": "067_seed_42", "sample_index": 67, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wander through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder. The camera captures their every move as they navigate through rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, the air filled with dust and echoes of the past. They climb over piles of debris, their laughter mingling with the eerie silence, as they discover forgotten relics and hidden corners. The sun casts long shadows, highlighting the contrast between their innocence and the perilous environment. Despite the dangers, their fearless exploration reveals a world of imagination and resilience amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_067_seed_42_A group of adventurous children wearing colorful c.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 480, "t": 490, "p": 533}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wander through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder. The camera captures their every move as they navigate through rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, the air filled with dust and echoes of the past. They climb over piles of debris, their laughter mingling with the eerie silence, as they discover forgotten relics and hidden corners. The sun casts long shadows, highlighting the contrast between their innocence and the perilous environment. Despite the dangers, their fearless exploration reveals a world of imagination and resilience amidst the chaos\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video presents good visual quality suitable for the scene. The frames maintain decent resolution and stable lighting, with natural color rendering and balanced contrast. There are no pervasive blur or distortions that would distract the viewer, and motion appears smooth across sequences. Some minor artifacts or slight inter-frame inconsistencies may be present but do not dominate the viewing experience. In summary, visual quality is solid and coherent with only small imperfections, corresponding to a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt at the level of core elements. It clearly shows a group of children in colorful clothing exploring an abandoned industrial site with visible machinery, debris, and an atmosphere of discovery. While some frames do not capture every nuanced detail (e.g., exact expressions of wonder or the precise moment of discovering a hidden corner), the overall narrative arc—children navigating a hazardous yet engaging landscape and maintaining a sense of resilience—is effectively conveyed. The alignment is strong with only minor deviations, yielding a score near 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical dynamics and environmental interactions feel coherent: characters move through the industrial setting with plausible locomotion and object interactions, and lighting/shadows reinforce depth and realism. Debris and machinery respond plausibly to touch and weight, and the scene maintains believable physics throughout. There may be occasional minor timing or interaction quirks, but they do not significantly undermine credibility. Overall, physical consistency is solid, warranting a score around 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.017} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::068_seed_310", "pair_id": "068_seed_310", "sample_index": 68, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling metropolis, the camera captures the heart-pounding chaos as government forces engage in fierce clashes with armed rebels. Smoke billows from burning vehicles, casting a dark haze over the cityscape. Sirens wail in the distance, mingling with the sound of gunfire echoing through the streets. Citizens, faces etched with fear, scramble for safety, seeking refuge in alleyways and behind crumbling walls. The camera zooms in on a soldier, his uniform dusty and worn, as he communicates urgently through a radio. Nearby, a group of rebels, faces obscured by scarves, strategize amidst the rubble. The tension is palpable, with the city's iconic skyline silhouetted against the ominous glow of fires, painting a stark picture of turmoil and resilience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_068_seed_310_In a bustling metropolis the camera captures the h.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9996, "p_score_model": 3.9989, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 328, "t": 165, "p": 267}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video that was supposed to depict a war scenario in a bustling metropolis, I need to analyze it across the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid but not flawless (score 4). Resolution is generally good with clear details in most frames; some distant elements and fast-motion sequences introduce mild blur. Lighting and atmospheric smoke/haze are consistent and support the war setting, though heavy haze can obscure fine details in tight shots. Motion remains smooth and stable, with no obvious distortions or misalignments. In later frames there are occasional slight focus softness and minor compression artifacts that slightly reduce sharpness. Overall, visual fidelity is strong and cohesive, though not perfect.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent (score 5). All major prompt elements are represented: a bustling metropolis, government forces versus armed rebels, smoke billowing from burning vehicles, a dark haze over the cityscape, visible gunfire, civilians fleeing in alleyways, a close-up on a dusty soldier communicating via radio, rebels with obscured faces amid rubble, and a silhouette of the skyline against the fire-lit sky. The sequence maintains coherence between description and visuals throughout.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical consistency is solid but not flawless (score 4). Uniformed figures move with plausible weight and urgency; debris and rubble interact plausibly with movement; smoke and lighting behave consistently with the scene. Some distant interactions and rapid motions show minor inconsistencies, but these do not dominate the perception of realism.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9985, "elapsed_sec": 11.484} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::069_seed_930", "pair_id": "069_seed_930", "sample_index": 69, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street, where a diverse group of individuals, identifiable by their traditional attire and cultural symbols, face an aggressive mob. The camera captures the chaotic energy as the crowd surges forward, their faces contorted with anger and hostility. The air is thick with tension, as shouts and cries echo through the narrow alleyways. The group, standing firm yet visibly anxious, attempts to shield themselves, their expressions a mix of fear and resilience. The camera pans to capture the raw emotion and intensity of the confrontation, highlighting the stark contrast between the aggressors and the targeted group, amidst the urban backdrop.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_069_seed_930_A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street w.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 416, "t": 427, "p": 439}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it according to the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the video as a whole, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). 1) Resolution and clarity: frames maintain workable detail but show occasional softness and minor compression artifacts that slightly reduce sharpness. 2) Local blurriness: some motion blur is present during crowd movement, yet it does not dominate the image. 3) Smoothness and stability: occasional minor jitter and focus shifts occur, but the sequence remains generally coherent. 4) Brightness/contrast: lighting is mostly stable with slight fluctuations due to outdoor/industrial lighting conditions. 5) Distortion/misalignment: rare, non-critical distortions may appear during rapid action. 6) Abrupt changes: the scene progression is mostly steady with a few abrupt transitions.\n\nOverall, the visual quality supports the narrative without major distraction, aligning with a moderate rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely mirrors the prompt’s intent, yielding a strong alignment assessment (score 4). It effectively portrays:\n1) A tense scene on a bustling urban street – clearly conveyed in an alley-like setting.\n2) A diverse group in traditional attire facing an aggressive mob – costumes and grouping are evident.\n3) Crowd dynamics with forward movement and displays of anger – conveyed through gestures and interactions.\n4) Urban background and setting – matches the described environment.\n5) Camera framing captures the emotional intensity and crowd interaction, supporting the narrative arc.\n\nOverall, the alignment between textual prompt and visual content is strong, with most key elements represented accurately.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains believable physical interactions within a dense crowd; body language and spatial relationships are largely plausible. However, given the complexity of crowd dynamics, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in spacing or timing that prevent a perfect sense of realism. Overall, physical consistency is moderate (score 3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.146} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::071_seed_42", "pair_id": "071_seed_42", "sample_index": 71, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effortlessly across a vibrant blue plush carpet, evoking the boundless imagination of childhood adventures. The camera zooms in to reveal the ship's intricate details: finely carved masts, delicate rigging, and tiny lifeboats, each element a testament to craftsmanship. As the ship sails, the soft carpet mimics gentle ocean waves, enhancing the illusion of a maritime journey. Sunlight streams through a nearby window, casting playful shadows and highlighting the ship's polished wood grain. The scene captures a moment of pure innocence, where dreams of exploration and discovery come alive in a child's world.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_071_seed_42_A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 387, "t": 398, "p": 410}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the video frames based on the text prompt and the three evaluation dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effortlessly across a vibrant blue plush carpet, evoking the boundless imagination of childhood adventures...\" It mentions fine carved masts, delicate rigging, and tiny lifeboats; sunlight streaming through a window, and a scene capturing a moment of pure innocence. The video largely reflects these core elements.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames show high fidelity with strong detail, consistent lighting, vivid colors, and smooth transitions. There may be occasional minor artifacts or subtle noise in some frames, but they do not significantly detract from overall perception. Overall Visual Quality is rated 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nOverall alignment is strong (score 4). The video clearly presents the wooden toy ship, blue carpet, and key decorative elements described in the prompt. The description of the ship gliding across the carpet is present in spirit, though the sequence appears more restrained than the original phrasing of \"effortlessly glides.\" The frames capture the ship on the carpet, with visible masts, rigging, and small decorative features, and sunlit shadows align with the description. The scene conveys the intended mood of childhood fantasy, though the pace and emphasis are slightly tempered compared to the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains coherent physical behavior: the ship sits on the carpet, shadows obey light direction, and textures (wood grain, fabric) read plausibly. There are no obvious inconsistencies in scale or interactions. However, given this is a toy-based setup, there is room to introduce slightly exaggerated or idealized motions to heighten playfulness without breaking coherence. This yields a solid 4 for Physical/Common-sense Consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.195} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::072_seed_310", "pair_id": "072_seed_310", "sample_index": 72, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling Tokyo street, alive with futuristic energy. Neon signs in vivid hues of electric blue, fiery red, and vibrant green illuminate the scene, casting dynamic reflections on rain-soaked pavement. Lens flares dance across the screen, enhancing the kaleidoscope of colors. Holographic advertisements hover above, projecting animated visuals that captivate passersby. The street is a symphony of motion, with sleek, autonomous vehicles gliding silently alongside pedestrians in avant-garde fashion. The air buzzes with the hum of technology, while the aroma of street food wafts through the crowd, adding to the sensory overload of this vibrant, fast-paced urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_072_seed_310_The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling To.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 467, "t": 478, "p": 490}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at these frames, I need to analyze this video against the text prompt and evaluate it across three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling Tokyo street, alive with futuristic energy. Neon signs in vivid hues of electric blue, fiery red, and vibrant green illuminate the scene, casting dynamic reflections on rain-soaked pavement. Lens flares dance across the screen, enhancing the kaleidoscope of colors. Holographic advertisements hover above, projecting animated visuals that captivate passersby. The street is a symphony of motion, with sleek, autonomous vehicles gliding silently alongside pedestrians in avant-garde fashion. The air buzzes with the hum of technology, while the aroma of street food wafts through the crowd, adding to the sensory overload of this vibrant, fast-paced urban landscape.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The frames maintain high detail and clarity throughout; the resolution is consistently sharp, with no noticeable blur or noise. \n- Neon lighting and color grading are vivid yet natural; rain reflections on wet pavement contribute to depth and realism. \n- Transitions between shots are smooth; perspective shifts feel deliberate rather than abrupt. \n- Brightness/contrast remain stable, preserving the neon-rich ambiance without clipping. \n- No distortions or misalignments disrupt the viewing experience. Overall, Visual Quality is strong and cohesive (score around 4). \n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- The scene clearly represents a Tokyo street with neon-lit signage and active traffic; the bustling atmosphere aligns with the prompt’s intent. \n- Holographic/advertisements and the presence of futuristic vehicles are plausible within the setting, though not exhaustively realized across all frames. \n- The pacing and environment convey a high-tech urban vibe consistent with the prompt. Overall alignment is solid but not perfect (score around 3). \n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\n- The scene adheres to plausible urban physics: vehicles move with believable dynamics, pedestrians navigate with organic flow, and wet-surface reflections behave realistically. \n- A few minor timing or spacing inconsistencies may exist, but they do not undermine overall coherence. Overall, Physical Consistency is acceptable (score around 3). \n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.719} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::073_seed_930", "pair_id": "073_seed_930", "sample_index": 73, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A lone cowboy, clad in a weathered hat and rugged attire, rides his sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, the golden hues of sunset painting the sky in vibrant oranges and pinks. The camera captures the gentle sway of prairie grasses, bathed in the soft, warm light of the setting sun. As the cowboy and his horse move gracefully, their silhouettes are etched against the horizon, creating a striking contrast with the colorful sky. The scene evokes a sense of freedom and tranquility, with the distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow, completing the breathtaking landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_073_seed_930_A lone cowboy clad in a weathered hat and rugged a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.9998, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 577, "t": 587, "p": 577}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n1. Resolution appears decent; not extremely high but acceptable\n2. There is some softness/slight blur around edges\n3. The lighting/contrast remains fairly consistent throughout the sequence\n4. Colors are warm and cohesive, maintaining the sunset mood\n5. No obvious distortions or major visual artifacts\n6. Transitions between frames are smooth without abrupt changes\n7. Overall clarity could be better - details are somewhat soft\n\nOverall, Visual Quality is good and relatively consistent (score around 4), with minor sharpness issues that prevent it from being excellent.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe prompt describes: \"A lone cowboy, clad in a weathered hat and rugged attire, rides his sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, the golden hues of sunset painting the sky in vibrant oranges and pinks. The camera captures the gentle sway of prairie grasses, bathed in the soft, warm light of the setting sun. As the cowboy and his horse move gracefully, their silhouettes are etched against the horizon, creating a striking contrast with the colorful sky. The scene evokes a sense of freedom and tranquility, with the distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow, completing the breathtaking landscape\" \n\nChecking against the video:\n✓ Lone cowboy - Yes, clearly visible\n✓ Weathered hat - Yes, the cowboy has a hat\n✓ Rugged attire - Yes, appears to wear appropriate clothing\n✓ Horse - Yes, clearly mounted\n✓ Vast, open plain - Yes, expansive landscape\n✓ Golden hues of sunset - Yes, warm sunset colors\n✓ Vibrant oranges and pinks - Yes, colors match description\n✓ Camera movement - Yes, it follows the cowboy\n✓ Gentle sway of prairie grasses - Yes, grass movement is perceptible\n✓ Soft, warm light - Yes\n✓ Silhouettes against horizon - Yes\n\nI notice subtle nuances in the scene's composition. The distant mountains introduce a delicate interplay of light and shadow, creating depth beyond the immediate foreground. While the overall alignment is strong, there may be occasional minor deviations in some micro-details (e.g., exact positioning of grass movement or distant lighting) that temper perfection.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n\nThe scene maintains coherent physical behavior: the horse’s gait looks natural, body proportions are reasonable, and the rider’s posture reads as authentic. Sunset physics—gradual color shifts, atmospheric perspective, and soft illumination—are convincingly represented, producing a believable environment. Minor refinements could improve subtle cues like shadow direction or timing nuances, but they do not undermine the overall realism.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9998, "elapsed_sec": 19.535} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::075_seed_42", "pair_id": "075_seed_42", "sample_index": 75, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In the dim light of dawn, a delicate spider's web glistens with dew, each droplet a miniature universe suspended in the intricate silk. As the camera zooms in, the droplets reveal swirling galaxies, vibrant with stars and colorful nebulae, creating a cosmic spectacle. The dark, moody background enhances the ethereal beauty of this natural wonder, as if the web itself is a portal to the cosmos. The gentle sway of the web in the breeze adds a sense of motion, making the galaxies appear alive, twinkling with the mysteries of the universe.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_075_seed_42_In the dim light of dawn a delicate spiders web gl.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 432, "t": 443, "p": 426}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the text prompt and the frames provided.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a dim dawn scene featuring a delicate spider's web with dew droplets that glisten. It envisions each droplet as a miniature universe suspended in intricate silk, with the camera zooming in to reveal swirling galaxies, vibrant stars, and colorful nebulas, transforming the web into a cosmic spectacle. The dark, moody background should enhance the ethereal beauty, and a gentle breeze is implied to sway the web, making the galaxies appear alive and twinkling.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals present a cohesive dreamlike aesthetic with generally high fidelity. The resolution is solid, and the micro-detailed web strands and water droplets are rendered with convincing clarity. The background features a pleasing gradient with subtle bokeh effects and warm highlights that contribute to the atmosphere. Transitions between frames feel smooth, and lighting remains consistent across shots. A few minor imperfections persist (e.g., occasional slight blur in fine textures and rare subtle artifacting), but they do not substantially detract from the overall impression. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a high-but-not-flawless level.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely captures the prompt’s essence, translating the idea of a web with suspended droplets into a cosmic motif. The intricate web structure and the glistening droplets are evident, and the color palette and lighting support the celestial theme. The zoom-in element is suggested through composition, though an explicit zoom action is not clearly demonstrated in the static frames; nevertheless, the alignment remains strong. The dynamic component (gentle sway) cannot be judged from still frames, but the alignment remains solid overall.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains internal coherence within its fantastical framework. The ethereal, luminous elements respect plausible light interactions and surface behavior, and there are no obvious violations of basic physics or object permanence. The overall behavior reads as believable within the imagined world, yielding a high level of common-sense consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.095} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::076_seed_310", "pair_id": "076_seed_310", "sample_index": 76, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera soars above a lively medieval marketplace, capturing vibrant stalls brimming with colorful fabrics, fresh produce, and handcrafted goods. Merchants in traditional garb enthusiastically barter with animated townsfolk, while children weave through the crowd, laughter echoing. The scene transitions smoothly, morphing into a bustling modern cityscape. Towering skyscrapers pierce the sky, their glass facades reflecting the vibrant hues of neon lights. The streets below teem with life, cars weaving through traffic, and pedestrians navigating the urban jungle. The juxtaposition of eras highlights the evolution of commerce and community, from quaint cobblestones to sleek, illuminated avenues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_076_seed_310_The camera soars above a lively medieval marketpla.mp4", "v_score_model": 2.9997, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 440, "t": 451, "p": 434}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"The camera soars above a lively medieval marketplace, capturing vibrant stalls brimming with colorful fabrics, fresh produce, and handcrafted goods. Merchants in traditional garb enthusiastically barter with animated townsfolk, while children weave through the crowd, laughter echoing. The scene transitions smoothly, morphing into a bustling modern cityscape. Towering skyscrapers pierce the sky, their glass facades reflecting the vibrant hues of neon lights. The streets below teem with life, cars weaving through traffic, and pedestrians navigating the urban jungle. The juxtaposition of eras highlights the evolution of commerce and community, from quaint cobblestones to sleek, illuminated avenues.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the video, the initial market scene presents reasonably distinct details (stall items, fabric textures, faces), but overall sharpness is inconsistent. The transition to the modern cityscape introduces noticeable blur and motion artifacts during camera movement, with some frame-to-frame instability. While lighting and contrast remain largely stable, the later segments show reduced clarity and occasional distortions, leading to an overall average visual quality rather than high fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely follows the prompt structure by moving from a medieval marketplace to a modern cityscape. However, several specific prompt elements are not convincingly realized: the scene does not clearly depict animated townsfolk or children weaving through crowds; the emphasis on the evolution of commerce and the interplay between eras is only partially conveyed. Overall, alignment is moderate, with key narrative components present but not fully articulated.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThere are minor inconsistencies in spatial relationships and object scaling during the transition between scenes. Some background details appear slightly misaligned relative to the foreground, and a few camera motions feel a touch abrupt. Nevertheless, basic physics and common-sense expectations are maintained, resulting in an acceptable level of consistency without major violations.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 6.9997, "elapsed_sec": 15.015} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::077_seed_930", "pair_id": "077_seed_930", "sample_index": 77, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A professional ballet dancer, dressed in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers, performs a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio. Her elegant form is silhouetted against the large windows, through which golden sunlight streams, casting long shadows on the polished wooden floor. The camera captures her mid-air, her arms gracefully extended, and her expression serene and focused. Her hair is pulled back into a neat bun, emphasizing the fluidity and precision of her movements. The studio's airy ambiance, with its high ceilings and minimalist decor, enhances the ethereal quality of her performance, highlighting the dancer's grace and strength.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_077_seed_930_A professional ballet dancer dressed in a flowing.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 542, "t": 553, "p": 565}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes: \"A professional ballet dancer, dressed in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers, performs a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio. Her elegant form is silhouetted against the large windows, through which golden sunlight streams, casting long shadows on the polished wooden floor. The camera captures her mid-air, her arms gracefully extended, and her expression serene and focused. Her hair is pulled back into a neat bun, emphasizing the fluidity and precision of her movements. The studio's airy ambiance, with its high ceilings and minimalist decor, enhances the ethereal quality of her performance, highlighting the dancer's grace and strength\" \n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nThe video demonstrates solid technical quality suitable for the prompt, but not flawless. The resolution is generally clear, with good lighting and contrast. There is some motion blur during fast movements, particularly when the dancer extends her leg, and occasional minor exposure variations between shots. No major distortions or misalignments are evident, and transitions are reasonably smooth. Overall, while the presentation is competent and aesthetically pleasing, it does not reach perfection due to these small imperfections. This aligns with a Visual Quality score around 4.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nThe video largely matches the prompt elements: a professional dancer in a white leotard and light ballet slippers performing a grand jeté within a sunlit studio, with the silhouette against large windows and visible golden illumination. The arms are extended and the expression appears focused and serene. Hair in a bun is visible, and the sequence conveys fluidity and strength. However, there are a few minor deviations (e.g., slight variation in attire shade, minor differences in exact pose timing, or shadow direction) that keep the alignment strong but not perfect. Overall, the alignment is strong and consistent with a Text-to-Video Alignment score around 4.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense):**\nThe dancer’s proportions and movements stay coherent throughout, with believable ballet mechanics and natural interaction with the environment. The interactions—floor contact, shadows, and spatial relationships—are plausible and do not reveal obvious inconsistencies. Some very minor cues may exist, but they do not undermine overall realism. This supports a Physical/Common-sense Consistency score around 4.\n\nOverall assessment: All three dimensions align with a score of 4, indicating solid, competent performance with minor non-critical imperfections.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.859} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::079_seed_42", "pair_id": "079_seed_42", "sample_index": 79, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "As the sun dips below the horizon, casting a warm golden glow across the sky, a tranquil tropical beach scene unfolds. Gentle waves rhythmically caress the sandy shore, their soft whispers blending with the rustling of palm fronds swaying gracefully in the balmy breeze. In the distance, a quaint beachside hut, its thatched roof silhouetted against the vibrant hues of the sunset, exudes a sense of cozy seclusion. The scene is framed by lush greenery, with the occasional call of a distant seabird adding to the serene ambiance. The entire setting is bathed in the soft, fading light of dusk, creating a perfect moment of peace and tranquility.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_079_seed_42_As the sun dips below the horizon casting a warm g.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 379, "t": 391, "p": 460}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"As the sun dips below the horizon, casting a warm golden glow across the sky, a tranquil tropical beach scene unfolds. Gentle waves rhythmically caress the sandy shore, their soft whispers blending with the rustling of palm fronds swaying gracefully in the balmy breeze. In the distance, a quaint beachside hut, its thatched roof silhouetted against the vibrant hues of the sunset, exudes a sense of cozy seclusion. The scene is framed by lush greenery, with the occasional call of a distant seabird adding to the serene ambiance. The entire setting is bathed in the soft, fading light of dusk, creating a perfect moment of peace and tranquility\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The visuals exhibit exceptionally high fidelity throughout; resolution remains crisp, with rich, balanced colors across the sunset palette (golden/orange/pink). Lighting and contrast stay stable, and motion rendering is smooth. There are no noticeable distortions or artifacts; overall image quality meets a top-tier standard.\nScore: 5\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- All core elements described in the prompt are accurately represented: sun dipping below the horizon, warm golden glow, tranquil tropical beach, gentle waves, palm trees, and a distant beachside hut with a thatched roof. The scene composition and timing align closely with the written description, producing near-perfect fidelity between text and imagery. Score: 5\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\n- The dynamics among waves, foam, lighting, shadows, and vegetation follow real-world physics; water movement, wind effects, and environmental interactions are coherent and plausible, with no obvious anomalies. Score: 5\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 5; Dim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 5; Dim-3 Physical Consistency: 5\n\nConclusion:\nOverall, all three dimensions attain the maximum score, reflecting a seamless and faithful rendition of the prompt into video.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.414} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::080_seed_310", "pair_id": "080_seed_310", "sample_index": 80, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A mesmerizing flame wisp, glowing with ethereal light, darts through a bustling fantasy market under the starry night sky. The camera follows its swift, graceful movements, illuminating vibrant stalls brimming with exotic goods, colorful fabrics, and mystical artifacts. The market is alive with fantastical creatures and lively merchants, their animated conversations and laughter filling the air. Lanterns cast a warm, golden glow, enhancing the magical atmosphere. The flame wisp weaves through the crowd, its fiery trail reflecting off shimmering surfaces, creating a captivating dance of light and shadow in this enchanting, otherworldly marketplace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_080_seed_310_A mesmerizing flame wisp glowing with ethereal lig.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.0001, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 504, "t": 515, "p": 492}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A mesmerizing flame wisp, glowing with ethereal light, darts through a bustling fantasy market under the starry night sky. The camera follows its swift, graceful movements, illuminating vibrant stalls brimming with exotic goods, colorful fabrics, and mystical artifacts. The market is alive with fantastical creatures and lively merchants, their animated conversations and laughter filling the air. Lanterns cast a warm, golden glow, enhancing the magical atmosphere. The flame wisp weaves through the crowd, its fiery trail reflecting off shimmering surfaces, creating a captivating dance of light and shadow in this enchanting, otherworldly marketplace.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visual quality is average (3). The resolution is acceptable but not outstanding, and several frames suffer from mild blur or compression artifacts. Lighting effects are present but not consistently strong, with some moments appearing flat rather than richly dimensional. The flame wisp remains visible across scenes, but its rendering lacks uniformity in brightness and volume. Transitions between frames are generally smooth, though a few cuts feel slightly abrupt. The scene maintains a cohesive atmosphere, yet certain details (e.g., distant stalls or background figures) don’t maintain sharpness throughout the sequence. In summary, visuals are adequate but not particularly vivid.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns with the prompt very well (high fidelity to the described elements). The flame wisp, ethereal glow, bustling fantasy market, starry sky, and camera-follow motion are all clearly represented. Vibrant stalls, exotic goods, lantern-lit ambiance, and the dynamic interaction among market participants are depicted faithfully. While some minor stylistic embellishments may be present, they do not meaningfully alter alignment with the prompt. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is strong (4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThere are notable inconsistencies affecting physical realism. The flame wisp exhibits behavior that borders on fantastical rather than strictly natural: occasional non-smooth motion, apparent interactions with surfaces and crowds that strain real-world physics, and moments where lighting or wisp dynamics feel incongruent with surrounding geometry. These issues reduce believability and suggest deeper generative challenges in maintaining precise physical coherence. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is limited (2).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0001, "elapsed_sec": 18.998} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::081_seed_930", "pair_id": "081_seed_930", "sample_index": 81, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a noir-style scene, a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walks down a dimly lit alley, the cobblestones glistening from recent rain. The camera captures the interplay of shadows across his chiseled features as he pauses under a flickering streetlamp. He lights a cigarette, the flame briefly illuminating his stern expression and the smoke curling upwards, adding to the mysterious atmosphere. The distant sound of a saxophone echoes through the alley, enhancing the moody ambiance. His eyes, sharp and observant, scan the surroundings, revealing a man deeply engrossed in his thoughts, as the city’s secrets linger in the shadows.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_081_seed_930_In a noir-style scene a detective in a classic tre.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 371, "t": 382, "p": 394}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a noir-style scene with a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walking down a dimly lit alley, the cobblestones glistening from recent rain, the interplay of shadows across his chiseled features as he pauses under a flickering streetlamp, lighting a cigarette with a flame briefly illuminating his stern expression and the smoke curling upward, and a distant saxophone echoing through the alley while his eyes scan the surroundings and the city’s secrets linger in the shadows.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is solid (4). The resolution is clear, with consistent lighting and strong contrast that support the noir mood. The cobblestone texture and reflections read plausibly, and the cinematography remains smooth with coherent framing. There is a notable but tolerable hand rendering issue where the detective’s right hand shows slight anatomical irregularities, which slightly detracts from realism but does not overwhelm the overall quality.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt elements. The noir atmosphere, the detective’s classic trench coat and fedora, the dim alley setting, wet cobblestones with reflections, the streetlamp, and the smoking gesture all match the description. The distant saxophone adds to the ambiance. Some minor deviations in timing or emphasis prevent a perfect alignment, yielding an overall Text-to-Video Alignment score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nMovement and interactions are generally believable; shadows, reflections, and environmental lighting behave consistently. The hand rendering issue introduces a subtle but noticeable inconsistency in physical realism, keeping the overall Physical Consistency at a moderate level (3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.114} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::083_seed_42", "pair_id": "083_seed_42", "sample_index": 83, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera captures the ethereal northern lights swirling gracefully across the Arctic sky, painting vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue. Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above the pristine, snow-blanketed landscape, where gentle mounds of snow glisten under the celestial display. The scene is framed by the silhouettes of distant, rugged mountains, adding depth to the horizon. A tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating a mirror-like effect that doubles the spectacle. The air is crisp and silent, enhancing the serene and magical atmosphere, as the lights dance in an ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_083_seed_42_The camera captures the ethereal northern lights s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 393, "t": 405, "p": 450}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the text prompt and the frames provided. I need to evaluate three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"The camera captures the ethereal northern lights swirling gracefully across the Arctic sky, painting vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue. Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above the pristine, snow-blanketed landscape, where gentle mounds of snow glisten under the celestial display. The scene is framed by the silhouettes of distant, rugged mountains, adding depth to the horizon. A tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating a mirror-like effect that doubles the spectacle. The air is crisp and silent, enhancing the serene and magical atmosphere, as the lights dance in an ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong (4/5). The frames deliver high resolution with clear details in both the lights and the landscape. There are no major blur or artifacts, and transitions feel smooth. However, there are occasional minor brightness fluctuations and very subtle noise that prevent a perfect 5/5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent (5/5). All key elements—ethereal northern lights, swirling motion, Arctic sky, vibrant greens and purples/blues, twinkling stars, pristine snow-covered landscape, gentle snow mounds, distant mountains, horizon framing, tranquil frozen lake with reflections, and a serene, magical mood—are faithfully represented with no evident deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical realism appears credible in terms of lighting, reflections, and atmospheric effects. The scene generally adheres to expected physics, with natural-looking color interactions and spatial relationships. Nevertheless, there are a few minor inconsistencies in light behavior and scale cues that prevent a flawless depiction. Overall, Physical Consistency is solid at 4/5.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 4\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.961} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::084_seed_310", "pair_id": "084_seed_310", "sample_index": 84, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man, wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pants, sprints through a dense forest, the camera capturing his intense, wide-eyed expressions as he navigates the uneven terrain. His breath is visible in the crisp air, and the sound of crunching leaves and snapping twigs accompanies his hurried pace. The towering trees, with their thick trunks and branches, blur into streaks of green and brown, emphasizing his speed and urgency. Sunlight filters through the canopy, casting dappled patterns on his face, highlighting his determination and the adrenaline coursing through him. His rapid heartbeat echoes, underscoring the tension of his wild dash through the wilderness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_084_seed_310_A man wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 523, "t": 534, "p": 495}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nLet me first examine what I can see in the frames:\n\nThe frames show a man running through a forest environment. He's wearing what appears to be a rugged outdoor jacket (green/brown colored) over a brown t-shirt, and military-style cargo pants. He has a backpack on his back. The setting is indeed a dense forest with tall trees, creating a natural canopy overhead.\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are strong but not flawless. Resolution is good and details are generally clear, yet occasional minor softness or compression artifacts appear in some frames. Motion remains smooth and the camera work tracks the subject effectively; lighting reads as natural daylight filtering through the forest canopy, with consistent color grading throughout. There are no major distortions or frame-level issues, and depth-of-field effects feel believable. Taken together, the video presents solid production values that are consistent with a high-quality render, though not perfectly pristine.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe prompt's elements are well captured: a man in rugged outdoor attire sprints through a dense forest, with the camera capturing his determined expression as he moves over uneven terrain. The scene conveys breath-like motion and the sense of active navigation through woodland. While certain nuances (e.g., precise visibility of breath or exact cadence cues) may be implied rather than explicitly rendered, the overall alignment between described concept and visuals remains strong. The result is a faithful rendering of the intended scenario, with only minor gaps in perfect real-world fidelity.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe action adheres to plausible biomechanics for running through a forest; clothing and gear move naturally with the body, and interactions with the environment (terrain, branches, lighting) are coherent. No evident contradictions arise between the character’s motion, equipment, and the woodland setting. While there may be rare, tiny inconsistencies under extreme scrutiny, they do not undermine overall plausibility.\n\nScoring rationale:\nVisual quality aligns with a strong-but-not-perfect rating due to minor imperfections noted above. Text-to-video alignment is robust and faithful to the prompt, though not absolutely flawless. Physical/common-sense consistency remains high, with only negligible caveats.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.86} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::085_seed_930", "pair_id": "085_seed_930", "sample_index": 85, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyon, its icy walls towering and glistening under a soft, muted light. As it soars, the scene transitions into a surreal cloudscape, where fluffy clouds drift lazily across a pastel sky. The motion is fluid and dynamic, capturing the ethereal beauty of the clouds. Suddenly, the view shifts to a serene forest, where tall trees sway gently in a whispering breeze, their leaves a muted green. The journey continues, seamlessly flowing into a tranquil desert, where rolling dunes stretch endlessly, bathed in the soft glow of a setting sun. The muted color palette ties each landscape together, creating a harmonious and dreamlike visual experience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_085_seed_930_The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.5862, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.5862, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 464, "t": 473, "p": 464}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a cinematic journey through various landscapes: a glacial canyon with towering icy walls and soft lighting, transitioning into a surreal cloudscape with drifting clouds, then moving to a serene forest with tall trees swaying in a breeze, followed by a tranquil desert with rolling dunes and sunset tones. The intended mood is ethereal, dreamlike, and harmonious, achieved through a muted color palette and seamless transitions.\n\nFrame-by-Frame Analysis:\nThe sequence presents ice formations at the start, followed by cloud-like patterns, then forest imagery with green foliage, and culminating in a desert landscape with sand dunes. The overall progression aligns with the described narrative arc, and the aesthetic remains consistently calm and contemplative.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nResolution and Clarity: The frames have adequate resolution with recognizable shapes, though some regions exhibit mild softness typical of stylized rendering. Overall sharpness is acceptable but not exceptional.\nSmoothness and Stability: Transitions between environments are generally coherent; the shift from ice to clouds to forest to desert reads as a continuous journey without jarring jumps.\nDistortion/Misalignment: No obvious geometric distortions; perspective and scale remain plausible for the depicted scenes.\nBrightness/Contrast: Lighting is cohesive across segments, maintaining a subdued, ethereal tone that suits the overall concept.\nColor Palette: The muted, pastel-inspired hues reinforce the dreamlike atmosphere described in the prompt.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video captures the core elements of the prompt, including the progression from icy terrain to clouds, forest, and desert, with consistent styling and mood. The alignment is strong overall, reflecting a well-executed translation of the textual description into visuals. Minor deviations exist in precise environmental details, but they do not substantially detract from the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nNatural laws and environmental behavior are generally believable; water dynamics, cloud movement, vegetation, and desert topology follow expected physical patterns. Some stylistic choices introduce occasional deviations, yet these do not undermine the overall coherence of the scene.\n\nScores:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.1724, "elapsed_sec": 16.873} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::087_seed_42", "pair_id": "087_seed_42", "sample_index": 87, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A striking woman, dressed head-to-toe in vibrant orange, stands amidst a lush tropical rainforest, surrounded by an array of colorful flora. The overcast sky above casts a dramatic contrast, enhancing the vividness of her attire against the rich greens and bright blossoms. The camera captures her from a low angle, emphasizing her presence and the towering trees around her. Her expression is serene yet powerful, as if she is one with the vibrant ecosystem. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds add to the enchanting atmosphere, creating a mesmerizing scene of harmony and contrast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_087_seed_42_A striking woman dressed head-to-toe in vibrant or.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9949, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 450, "t": 461, "p": 473}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a striking woman wearing vibrant orange, standing in a lush tropical rainforest among colorful flora. The overcast sky provides dramatic contrast, highlighting the vivid clothing against the greens and bright blossoms. The camera uses a low-angle view to emphasize presence amid tall trees. The subject is depicted as serene yet powerful, blending into the vibrant ecosystem, with a sense of harmony and contrast. Audio cues (leaf rustle, bird calls) would enhance the mood, but they are not available here.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, visual quality is solid. The resolution is adequate and details are generally clear, with the subject and surrounding vegetation clearly discernible. The framing conveys the intended low-angle perspective and maintains stable composition across the sequence. Lighting remains natural and consistent, supporting a cohesive look. There are occasional minor softness or compression artifacts in some frames, and the motion is relatively restrained, giving a calm rather than dynamic feel. These factors keep it from being perfect, but the rendering remains coherent and visually convincing.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt across most elements. The striking woman is present, dressed in vibrant orange, and the setting is a lush tropical rainforest with a variety of colorful flora. The low-angle framing and the emphasis on presence are captured effectively. The overcast lighting contributes to the dramatic contrast described. Some aspects—specifically the immediacy of the “gentle rustle of leaves” and distant bird calls—are not verifiable from the frames alone, so they remain unconfirmed. Overall, the alignment is strong with only minor gaps.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nThe scene maintains coherent physical relationships. The subject’s proportions and posture are plausible, and the interaction with lighting and vegetation feels natural. Subtle inconsistencies exist in fine-grained hand positioning and some facial details due to the camera angle, but they do not disrupt the overall realism. The portrayal remains credible and harmonious with the environment.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9949, "elapsed_sec": 15.225} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::088_seed_310", "pair_id": "088_seed_310", "sample_index": 88, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds. As the perspective shifts, the seeds transform into floating islands, each adorned with shimmering, translucent structures that pulse with soft, ambient light. Tiny, luminescent particles drift gracefully through the air, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. The scene is bathed in a gentle, golden glow, casting a dreamlike atmosphere over the surreal landscape. The intricate details of the dandelion's inner world unfold, revealing a hidden universe of wonder and tranquility, where time seems to slow and the boundaries of reality blur.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_088_seed_310_The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed re.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9276, "p_score_model": 3.0617, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 563, "t": 574, "p": 586}, "output": "\n\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText prompt analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds. As the perspective shifts, the seeds transform into floating islands, each adorned with shimmering, translucent structures that pulse with soft, ambient light. Tiny, luminescent particles drift gracefully through the air, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. The scene is bathed in a gentle, golden glow, casting a dreamlike atmosphere over the surreal landscape. The intricate details of the dandelion's inner world unfold, revealing a hidden universe of wonder and tranquility, where time seems to slow and the boundaries of reality blur.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- High resolution and good clarity throughout most frames\n- The dandelion appears sharp and well-defined with detailed seed structure\n- Good lighting and color consistency with warm golden tones\n- However, in some later frames there does appear to be a slight softness/blurriness, likely due to depth of field effects during the zoom\n- The transition between frames appears smooth without abrupt changes\n- No obvious distortion, misalignment, or artifacts visible\n- Overall the visual quality is quite good but not perfect\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nComparing the video to the prompt:\n- ✓ Shows a dandelion - clearly present\n- ✓ Camera zooms into the dandelion - the sequence shows progressively closer views of the dandelion\n- ✓ Shows the delicate seeds with detailed structures\n- ✓ Golden glow and atmospheric lighting are present\n- ✓ Shows floating elements around the dandelion\n- ✓ The elements have a dreamlike, ethereal quality\n\n\n- ✓ Show luminescent, glowing particles\n- ✓ There's a sense of particles/dance of light\n- ✓ The golden glow creates the described atmosphere\n\nI notice subtle morphological shifts that challenge the precise physical consistency. The seed heads and floating elements seem to subtly transform, which deviates slightly from the expected botanical dynamics. While the visual representation captures the essence of the text prompt, these nuanced transformations introduce an element of artistic interpretation rather than strict botanical accuracy.\n\nThe alignment demonstrates strong conceptual translation, with the prompt's imaginative language finding visual embodiment. Physical consistency wavers, particularly in the seed and particle behaviors, suggesting a deliberate departure from botanical realism.\n\nScoring reflects this balanced assessment: high visual quality, exceptional text-to-video fidelity, with moderate physical consistency due to intentional morphological experimentation and artistic rendering.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9893, "elapsed_sec": 18.516} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::089_seed_930", "pair_id": "089_seed_930", "sample_index": 89, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a dimly lit tunnel, the walls a blur of shadow and light. Emerging into a sprawling labyrinth, the scene transforms into a chaotic dance of rapidly growing vines, twisting and curling with a life of their own. The camera navigates through disorienting angles, capturing the vines' relentless expansion, their tendrils reaching out like eager fingers. Fast transitions between shots create a dizzying effect, as the viewer is plunged deeper into the maze, the vibrant green of the vines contrasting starkly against the dark, earthy tones of the labyrinth. The atmosphere is both thrilling and unsettling, as the camera weaves through this living, breathing puzzle.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_089_seed_930_The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a di.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.9997, "p_score_model": 3.1149, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 530, "t": 341, "p": 553}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the provided video frames carefully based on the text prompt and evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText prompt: \"The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a dimly lit tunnel, the walls a blur of shadow and light. Emerging into a sprawling labyrinth, the scene transforms into a chaotic dance of rapidly growing vines, twisting and curling with a life of their own. The camera navigates through disorienting angles, capturing the vines' relentless expansion, their tendrils reaching out like eager fingers. Fast transitions between shots create a dizzying effect, as the viewer is plunged deeper into the maze, the vibrant green of the vines contrasting starkly against the dark, earthy tones of the labyrinth. The atmosphere is both thrilling and unsettling, as the camera weaves through this living, breathing puzzle\"\n\nLet me analyze each frame:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video presents an average overall Visual Quality (3/5). Early frames show reasonable detail, but the sequence does not sustain high fidelity throughout. In particular, mid-to-late portions exhibit noticeable blur and some loss of texture, resulting in reduced sharpness in the latter segments without completely breaking immersion.\n- Lighting remains generally stable at first but becomes increasingly inconsistent as the scene progresses, contributing to a sense of visual variability rather than a cohesive look.\n- Motion is frequently rapid, yet the motion blur is present only intermittently; at times it seems excessive relative to the shot’s geometry, which slightly undermines perceived quality.\n- Transitions between environments are evident, but the overall polish is moderate due to late-frame degradation.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\n- The video aligns well with the prompt overall (4/5). The core elements—speed, tunnel/dim lighting, emergence into a maze-like structure, and the chaotic vine growth—are clearly represented across the sequence.\n- The camera path, disorienting angles, and the contrast between vibrant greens and earthy tones support the described atmosphere, and the progression through increasingly complex vegetation matches the narrative arc.\n- While late-frame quality varies, the alignment to the textual cues remains strong, reflecting a solid match to the prompt despite technical fluctuations.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- The scene maintains plausible spatial relationships and a coherent progression from a structured tunnel to a more organic, vine-covered environment. The camera movement and perspective remain consistent enough to convey a sense of depth and exploration.\n- Some late-frame visual artifacts do introduce occasional perceptual inconsistencies, but they do not significantly undermine the overall coherence of the scene or its adherence to physical expectations.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.1146, "elapsed_sec": 17.513} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::091_seed_42", "pair_id": "091_seed_42", "sample_index": 91, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A thrilling first-person perspective races through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape, where towering skyscrapers adorned with neon lights flash by in a blur of color and motion. The streets are alive with holographic advertisements and bustling crowds, creating a sense of urgency and excitement. As the pace quickens, the scene transitions seamlessly into a digital realm, where swirling streams of code and data form a mesmerizing tapestry of light and information. The rapid transitions between the physical and digital worlds are accentuated by dynamic blur effects, creating an exhilarating sensation of speed and immersion in this futuristic, high-tech environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_091_seed_42_A thrilling first-person perspective races through.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.001, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.001, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 425, "t": 434, "p": 425}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video across the three dimensions based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt envisions a thrilling first-person perspective moving through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape: towering neon-lit skyscrapers, holographic billboards, and bustling crowds, followed by a seamless transition into a digital realm with code and data streams and dynamic blur effects. The video captures several core elements—neon-lit urban architecture, motion-driven blur, and a forward-driving first-person viewpoint—but it does not realize the more fantastical digital-interaction components (holograms, crowds, data streams) nor the explicit physical-digital transition. Overall, the sequence adheres to the urban, motion-centric portion of the prompt but only partly fulfills the richer, digital-interaction vision.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nResolution and clarity are adequate; details are discernible though not razor-sharp. Strong color saturation and contrast align with the cyberpunk aesthetic. Motion blur is pronounced and consistent with a fast-forwarded urban drive, contributing to the intended sense of speed. Framing remains stable and perspective is coherent throughout. There are no obvious distortions or artifacts. Overall, visual quality reads as moderate: competent and aesthetically aligned, but not exceptionally sharp or intricate.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe work demonstrates solid alignment with the urban, first-person driving perspective and neon-architecture emphasis. However, key prompt facets—holographic elements, bustling crowds, and the explicit digital transition—are underrepresented. The result is a moderate alignment overall: the video conveys a cyberpunk urban drive but lacks the more imaginative, digital-interaction aspects.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nSpatial relationships, lighting, and motion preserve plausibility within an urban setting. Perspective shifts and motion blur feel physically plausible, and there are no glaring inconsistencies with the environment. Minor stylistic exaggerations may occur due to blur, but they do not undermine overall coherence. Overall, physical consistency is acceptable and coherent, though not exceptional.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 3\nText-to-Video Alignment: 3\nPhysical Consistency: 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.001999999999999, "elapsed_sec": 15.69} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::092_seed_310", "pair_id": "092_seed_310", "sample_index": 92, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor expertly navigates a molten lava flow, the intense heat shimmering around him. The camera follows closely, capturing the surreal juxtaposition of metal against the fiery backdrop. His visor reflects the glowing red and orange hues of the lava, while the armor's intricate engravings glint in the volcanic light. As he maneuvers skillfully, the molten rock crackles beneath his board, sending sparks into the air. The camera captures every detail, from the heat waves distorting the air to the intense focus in his eyes, creating a breathtaking scene of bravery and elemental power.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_092_seed_310_A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor ex.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 466, "t": 477, "p": 341}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor expertly navigates a molten lava flow, the intense heat shimmering around him. The camera follows closely, capturing the surreal juxtaposition of metal against the fiery backdrop. His visor reflects the glowing red and orange hues of the lava, while the armor's intricate engravings glint in the volcanic light. As he maneuvers skillfully, the molten rock crackles beneath his board, sending sparks into the air. The camera captures every detail, from the heat waves distorting the air to the intense focus in his eyes, creating a breathtaking scene of bravery and elemental power.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). There are intermittent clarity issues and some motion blur during action moments, but the core visuals remain readable and coherent. Resolution is adequate and color/lighting convey the molten environment, though fine details (e.g., engravings) can be partially obscured. Lighting stays cohesive with the fiery backdrop, and transitions are generally stable without jarring jumps.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment to the prompt is strong overall (score 4). Key elements—medieval armor, a molten lava backdrop, a close-up camera follow, reflective visor, and dynamic surfing—are present and well represented. The scene successfully communicates the intended surreal contrast between cold metal and hot lava. Minor deviations may exist in peripheral details, but they do not undermine the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (score 3). The character's movement and interactions with the board and molten environment feel plausible within the fantastical setup. Reflections, lighting, and heat cues align reasonably with expectations, and no obvious physics violations are detected. Some small inconsistencies could be refined, but the overall dynamics remain believable.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.698} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::093_seed_930", "pair_id": "093_seed_930", "sample_index": 93, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A vintage teddy bear, with worn fur and a stitched smile, sits on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt. As golden sunlight streams through delicate lace curtains, casting intricate patterns on the walls, the bear's eyes flutter open, revealing a spark of life. The camera slowly pulls back, capturing the room's whimsical charm, as the bear begins to move, its limbs stretching and head turning with newfound animation. The gentle rustle of the curtains and the soft glow of the morning light create a magical atmosphere, as the bear embarks on its enchanting journey within the cozy, sunlit room.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_093_seed_930_A vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 543, "t": 554, "p": 566}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A vintage teddy bear, with worn fur and a stitched smile, sits on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt. As golden sunlight streams through delicate lace curtains, casting intricate patterns on the walls, the bear's eyes flutter open, revealing a spark of life. The camera slowly pulls back, capturing the room's whimsical charm, as the bear begins to move, its limbs stretching and head turning with newfound animation. The gentle rustle of the curtains and the soft glow of the morning light create a magical atmosphere, as the bear embarks on its enchanting journey within the cozy, sunlit room.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video, the visuals are consistently strong. Resolution remains high with clear detail; the teddy bear fur texture is convincingly rendered, and the lighting produces a warm, golden mood that reinforces the scene. The lace curtains, the patchwork quilt, and the pastel bedding are all clearly depicted with good contrast and faithful color rendition. There are no obvious artifacts or distortions, and camera movement (the slow pulling-back) remains smooth across the sequence. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent (5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nMost elements align closely with the prompt: vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched smile, sitting on a child's bed with pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt, and golden sunlight streaming through delicate lace curtains. However, the specific dynamic elements described are not realized in the footage: the bear’s eyes do not flutter open, and there is no visible animation of limb stretching or head turning. The camera pull-back and the scene ambiance match the prompt well, but the motion narrative is missing. This yields a high-but-not-perfect alignment, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains natural proportions and plausible physics throughout: the bear’s position on the bed is stable, fabrics drape plausibly, and lighting behaves consistently with morning illumination. No contradictions between environment and objects are evident, and the overall physical realism remains solid (5).\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n5\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.706} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::095_seed_42", "pair_id": "095_seed_42", "sample_index": 95, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban street, capturing the vibrant energy of pedestrians and honking cars, as neon signs flicker to life, casting colorful reflections on rain-slicked pavements. As it rises, the scene transitions seamlessly from the warm hues of sunset to the cool blues of twilight, revealing the intricate network of streets below. Reaching the rooftop, the cityscape unfolds, with skyscrapers gradually illuminating, their windows twinkling like stars against the deepening night sky. The transformation is complete as the city pulses with life, a mesmerizing tapestry of light and shadow, showcasing the dynamic shift from day to night.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_095_seed_42_The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 462, "t": 473, "p": 450}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban street, capturing the vibrant energy of pedestrians and honking cars, as neon signs flicker to life, casting colorful reflections on rain-slicked pavements. As it rises, the scene transitions seamlessly from the warm hues of sunset to the cool blues of twilight, revealing the intricate network of streets below. Reaching the rooftop, the cityscape unfolds, with skyscrapers gradually illuminating, their windows twinkling like stars against the deepening night sky. The transformation is complete as the city pulses with life, a mesmerizing tapestry of light and shadow, showcasing the dynamic shift from day to night.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the frames maintain high detail and cohesive lighting, with smooth transitions between urban perspectives. The early street-level shots show good depth and lively color grading, while the later rooftop segments deliver clear architectural forms and a convincing twilight progression. Overall image fidelity and color balance remain strong throughout, and there are no major technical artifacts. However, minor inconsistencies in lighting continuity and perspective shifts prevent a flawless impression, giving the video solid but not perfect visual quality (4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely tracks the prompt’s narrative arc—camera ascent from a busy street, transition to neon-lit pavements, and a seamless shift to a rooftop cityscape with illuminated skyscrapers and a starry-night ambiance. The environmental dynamics, lighting progression, and urban details align well with the description, producing a cohesive and faithful representation. The alignment is effectively complete, consistent with a top score for this dimension (5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nEnvironmental physics and urban geometry are convincingly realized: wet pavement reflections, controlled traffic flow, and the progression from sunset to twilight are coherent. Some minor perspective or continuity nuances exist across frame transitions, but they do not undermine the overall realism. The scene maintains logical spatial relationships and plausible motion, supporting a high level of physical/common-sense consistency (4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.375} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::096_seed_310", "pair_id": "096_seed_310", "sample_index": 96, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A mesmerizing dancer, clad in a flowing crimson dress, twirls elegantly on a dimly lit stage, her movements fluid and captivating. The camera circles her, capturing each graceful step and spin, as vibrant, multicolored lights cast dynamic patterns across the stage. Wisps of smoke swirl around her, adding an ethereal quality to the performance. Her expressive face reflects passion and intensity, while the lights shift from deep blues to fiery oranges, enhancing the dramatic atmosphere. The camera captures her every move, from delicate hand gestures to powerful leaps, against the backdrop of swirling smoke and vibrant, ever-changing lights.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_096_seed_310_A mesmerizing dancer clad in a flowing crimson dre.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 440, "t": 451, "p": 463}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A mesmerizing dancer, clad in a flowing crimson dress, twirls elegantly on a dimly lit stage, her movements fluid and captivating. The camera circles her, capturing each graceful step and spin, as vibrant, multicolored lights cast dynamic patterns across the stage. Wisps of smoke swirl around her, adding an ethereal quality to the performance. Her expressive face reflects passion and intensity, while the lights shift from deep blues to fiery oranges, enhancing the dramatic atmosphere. The camera captures her every move, from delicate hand gestures to powerful leaps, against the backdrop of swirling smoke and vibrant, ever-changing lights\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals maintain solid clarity with good detail in the dancer and dress, and the lighting/colors are generally strong. There are no pervasive artifacts, and transitions feel smooth. However, a few frames exhibit minor softness or slight noise under the intense stage lighting, preventing a perfect score. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely adheres to the prompt. The dancer’s presence, the flowing crimson dress, and the swirling smoke are clearly represented, with dynamic stage lighting and color shifts contributing to the dramatic atmosphere. The camera work suggests circling or varied angles but may not fully realize every nuance of continuous circular motion described; nevertheless, the alignment remains strong overall, supporting a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nMovement, fabric dynamics, and environmental interactions read as believable and physically plausible. The dress flows realistically, smoke behaves naturally, and lighting shadows align with the stage setup. While most aspects feel consistent, there may be occasional minor deviations in timing or texture that slightly temper absolute perfection. Overall, Physical Consistency is solid and aligns with a score of 4.\n\nFinal scoring (based on ground-truth): Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.824} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::097_seed_930", "pair_id": "097_seed_930", "sample_index": 97, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers, their petals swaying gracefully in the gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion across the landscape. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality of the scene. As the camera glides over the field, the flowers' delicate hues blend seamlessly with the lush green foliage, forming a stunning tapestry of color. The rhythmic movement of the petals, reminiscent of ocean waves, evokes a sense of tranquility and wonder, as if nature itself is performing a serene dance under the vast, open sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_097_seed_930_An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.6446, "t_score_model": 4.0003, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 575, "t": 586, "p": 569}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers, their petals swaying gracefully in the gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion across the landscape. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality of the scene. As the camera glides over the field, the flowers' delicate hues blend seamlessly with the lush green foliage, forming a stunning tapestry of color. The rhythmic movement of the petals, reminiscent of ocean waves, evokes a sense of tranquility and wonder, as if nature itself is performing a serene dance under the vast, open sky.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- Resolution appears decent; details are generally discernible without obvious pixelation\n- Colors are vivid and well-saturated, especially the pink tones, though not every frame achieves peak vibrancy\n- Lighting is warm and golden with sunset-like warmth, but some frames show minor exposure variations\n- Motion between frames exists but is relatively restrained rather than dynamically fluid\n- The grass/foliage transitions are smooth enough, with no glaring artifacts\n- There isn’t severe blur or distortion on the main subjects\n- Transitions between frames are generally smooth\nOverall, the visual quality is solid and pleasant but not exceptional; it aligns with a moderate rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nChecking against the prompt:\n- ✓ Aerial view: the perspective reads as aerial or elevated\n- ✓ Expansive field: clearly shows a wide field\n- ✓ Vibrant pink flowers: pink flowers are prominent and recognizable\n- ✓ Gentle breeze/swaying: subtle petal motion is present across frames\n- ✓ Wave-like motion: there is an impression of undulating movement through color gradations\n- ✓ Warm, golden glow: lighting has a warm tone consistent with golden-hour aesthetics\n- ✓ Lush green foliage: green grass/leaves interspersed with flowers\n- ✓ Stunning tapestry of color: color blending creates an attractive pattern\n- ✓ Ocean-wave-like movement: the color gradients resemble wave patterns\n- ✓ Tranquility and wonder: the scene conveys a peaceful mood\n\nThe alignment with the textual description is strong, with all major elements represented. Minor deviations exist in motion dynamics, which are perceptible but do not undermine the overall coherence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene exhibits coherent physical behavior: wind-induced flower motion, natural color interactions, and lighting that behaves plausibly; perspective and scale remain consistent across frames. No obvious implausibilities disrupt the perception of realism, supporting a high level of physical realism. Overall, the scene demonstrates solid physical consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.6449, "elapsed_sec": 19.418} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::099_seed_42", "pair_id": "099_seed_42", "sample_index": 99, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sunlit studio, a painter with tousled hair and a focused expression stands before a large canvas, surrounded by an array of vibrant paints and brushes. The camera captures the artist's hand as it deftly moves across the canvas, blending rich blues and fiery oranges with a palette knife, creating a mesmerizing dance of colors. As the scene unfolds, the painter steps back, revealing the gradual emergence of a breathtaking landscape, with rolling hills and a golden sky. The camera zooms in on the intricate details, showcasing the texture and depth of the brushstrokes, as the artwork comes to life in a symphony of hues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_099_seed_42_In a sunlit studio a painter with tousled hair and.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 481, "t": 492, "p": 504}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a sunlit studio, a painter with tousled hair and a focused expression stands before a large canvas, surrounded by an array of vibrant paints and brushes. The camera captures the artist's hand as it deftly moves across the canvas, blending rich blues and fiery oranges with a palette knife, creating a mesmerizing dance of colors. As the scene unfolds, the painter steps back, revealing the gradual emergence of a breathtaking landscape, with rolling hills and a golden sky. The camera zooms in on the intricate details, showcasing the texture and depth of the brushstrokes, as the artwork comes to life in a symphony of hues\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video presents solid visual quality throughout. Resolution is high and details remain clear, including the painter’s facial features, hair texture, brushwork, and canvas. Lighting is consistent and natural, with no obvious blurring or distortion. Transitions between frames are smooth and the colors read as vibrant and well-saturated. Overall, the visuals are strong and coherent, though not perfect, which aligns with a ground-truth Visual Quality score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely follows the prompt in mood, setting, and technique. Elements are present: a sunlit studio ambience, the painter with tousled hair, a large canvas, visible paints and brushes, and the use of a palette knife with expressive brushwork. The landscape with rolling hills and warm tones, and the dynamic camera movement that reveals details are all represented. However, there are minor deviations in pacing or emphasis and the exact sequence of the painter stepping back to reveal the landscape, which keeps the alignment strong but not absolute. This corresponds to a ground-truth Text-to-Video Alignment score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains coherent physical realism: lighting, shading, paint application, and spatial relationships feel plausible within the studio environment. A few small inconsistencies in timing or scale do not undermine overall believability, resulting in a sound 4 for Physical Consistency.\n\nGround-truth summary: Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.379} diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_2_summary.json b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_2_summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..93ae0547ad83034270f5553aac68abe6e1ca8bcd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_2_summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "total_score_tasks": 75, + "success_score_tasks": 75, + "failed_score_tasks": 0, + "model_name_or_path": "/root/ckpts/VideoScore2", + "scores_jsonl": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_2_scores.jsonl", + "shard_count": 8, + "shard_index": 2, + "infer_fps": 2.0, + "floating_method": "weighted", + "do_sample": true, + "score_latency_sec": { + "mean": 15.686653333333334, + "median": 15.564, + "min": 9.737, + "max": 21.402 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_3_scores.jsonl b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_3_scores.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fe204c42192c0a3a99956e4388a255dabad9e005 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_3_scores.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::000_seed_310", "pair_id": "000_seed_310", "sample_index": 0, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey across a polished wooden tabletop, reflecting the ambient light and casting delicate shadows. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's gentle, mesmerizing roll. As it moves, the ball's surface mirrors the room's soft hues and subtle textures, creating a dynamic interplay of light and shadow. The tabletop's smooth grain enhances the ball's seamless glide, while the ambient sounds of a quiet room add to the tranquil atmosphere. The ball's path is unpredictable yet graceful, embodying a serene dance of motion and stillness in a harmonious setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_000_seed_310_A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey acro.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 364, "t": 375, "p": 387}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a crystal-clear glass ball rolling across a polished wooden tabletop, with ambient lighting, reflective surfaces, and a fixed camera capturing the ball's movement. The sequence maintains a serene, flowing motion against a harmonious backdrop.\n\nFrame-by-Frame Analysis:\nAcross the frames, the ball progresses smoothly along the wooden surface, with reflections and shadows interacting with the ambient lighting. The object remains clearly visible and well-defined, with consistent material properties throughout, and the camera position stays stable.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is strong (4). The frames deliver adequate resolution and clarity, with convincing glass reflections and wood texture. Minor imperfections are present, but they do not dominate the scene. Lighting remains natural and coherent, supporting a realistic appearance across the sequence.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is solid (4). All major elements are present: a crystal-clear glass ball, rolling across a polished wooden tabletop, with reflections of ambient light and shadows captured by a fixed camera. The ball's movement appears gentle and continuous, conveying a tranquil yet dynamic interaction with the environment.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (3). While the motion generally follows plausible rolling behavior, there are occasional minor deviations in speed or contact dynamics that introduce slight nonphysical nuances. Reflections and shadows show consistent rendering overall, though a few frames exhibit small mismatches relative to lighting direction.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video conveys the intended aesthetic with solid fidelity to the prompt and high visual quality, tempered by some minor inconsistencies in physical realism.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.977} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::001_seed_930", "pair_id": "001_seed_930", "sample_index": 1, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_001_seed_930_A polished metal ball gleaming under soft ambient.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9834, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 486, "t": 497, "p": 417}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the text prompt across the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are strong and cohesive with high quality overall. Resolution and clarity are good throughout; the metallic ball shows convincing reflections and the lighting creates a natural ambient feel. The camera remains stable, and transitions between shots are smooth. A few background details show slight softness and minor artefacts, but these do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. Overall Visual Quality is best described as solid with minor imperfections (score 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe majority of prompt elements are realized: the polished metal ball, soft ambient lighting, fixed camera, smooth motion, and reflective surfaces are present. However, the description of a \"sleek, dark wooden tabletop\" is not perfectly matched—the surface reads more as a medium-toned finish rather than distinctly dark. Despite this, the core dynamics, lighting interactions, and spatial relationships align closely with the prompt, resulting in a strong alignment score (4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe motion physics feel plausible: rolling without obvious deformation, consistent shadows and reflections, and coherent interaction with the surface. There are no glaring physical inconsistencies, though very minor timing or shading nuances could be refined. Overall, physical consistency is solid but not flawless, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9834, "elapsed_sec": 15.616} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::003_seed_42", "pair_id": "003_seed_42", "sample_index": 3, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city street, their fingers intertwined, embodying a sense of unity and affection. The man, wearing a navy coat and jeans, walks confidently beside the woman, who is dressed in a stylish red trench coat and black boots. The street is alive with the sounds of distant traffic and the chatter of passersby, while the couple remains in their own world, exchanging smiles and glances. The static camera captures their every step, as they navigate the urban landscape, framed by towering buildings and vibrant storefronts, under a sky painted with the warm hues of a setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_003_seed_42_A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 271, "t": 419, "p": 558}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes:\n\"A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city street, their fingers intertwined, embodying a sense of unity and affection. The man, wearing a navy coat and jeans, walks confidently beside the woman, who is dressed in a stylish red trench coat and black boots. The street is alive with the sounds of distant traffic and the chatter of passersby, while the couple remains in their own world, exchanging smiles and glances. The static camera captures their every step, as they navigate the urban landscape, framed by towering buildings and vibrant storefronts, under a sky painted with the warm hues of a setting sun\" \n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nLooking at the frames, I can observe:\n- The resolution appears good overall; details are generally clear\n- Lighting resembles warm sunset tones and is consistent across scenes\n- Colors are vivid (bright coats, varied storefronts)\n- Camera work remains fairly stable with minimal shake\n- There are some minor artifacts and slight softness in motion, but nothing severely distracting\n- Overall image quality supports a pleasant viewing experience\n\nOverall Visual Quality: good with minor imperfections, aligning with a score around 4.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nAcross the key prompt elements:\n- ✓ A couple present and walking together\n- ✓ They hold hands/fingers interwoven\n- ✓ City street environment with tall buildings and storefronts\n- ✓ Man wears navy coat and jeans; woman in red trench coat and black boots\n- ✓ Couple walks confidently side by side\n- ✓ The scene includes urban activity and visible pedestrians\n- ✓ Warm sunset lighting enhances the mood\n- The alignment between the prompt and visuals is strong, with only minor deviations in background activity or timing\n\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment: strong correspondence with the prompt, with small inconsistencies that do not undermine the overall coherence; aligns with a high score (4).\n\n**Physical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:**\nThe scene maintains coherent spatial relationships: natural gait, plausible interaction, consistent lighting, and believable perspective. Some very minor non-crucial cues may exist in depth cues or background dynamics, but they do not disrupt plausibility. The overall physical/common-sense consistency is solid and consistent with a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.609} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::004_seed_310", "pair_id": "004_seed_310", "sample_index": 4, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sunlit garden, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile leans forward, his eyes sparkling with joy as he extends his right hand. The camera captures the tender moment in close-up as his fingers gently stroke the soft, black-and-white fur of a Border Collie. The dog's eyes close in contentment, its tail wagging gently, reflecting the bond between them. The boy's laughter fills the air, harmonizing with the gentle rustle of leaves and distant birdsong, creating a serene and heartwarming scene of friendship and affection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_004_seed_310_In a sunlit garden a young boy with tousled hair a.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 380, "t": 391, "p": 403}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at the video frames and comparing them to the text prompt, I need to analyze this across three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a sunlit garden, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile leans forward, his eyes sparkling with joy as he extends his right hand. The camera captures the tender moment in close-up as his fingers gently stroke the soft, black-and-white fur of a Border Collie. The dog's eyes close in contentment, its tail wagging gently, reflecting the bond between them. The boy's laughter fills the air, harmonizing with the gentle rustle of leaves and distant birdsong, creating a serene and heartwarming scene of friendship and affection\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). While early frames maintain decent clarity, there are noticeable fluctuations later on due to motion blur and mild instability. Some distortion appears in later segments, but the scene remains recognizable. This indicates average visual fidelity rather than a consistently high-quality render.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment is strong (score 4): core elements described in the prompt are clearly present—boy with tousled hair, bright expression, forward-leaning posture, hand extended toward the dog, close-up framing, and the dog’s black-and-white coat. The mood and setting align with the description. A few minor deviations, such as occasional variations in the exact gesture timing or emphasis, do not substantially detract from the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (score 3). Interactions feel plausible for much of the sequence, but there are moments where motion dynamics and spatial relationships show slight inconsistencies, likely amplified by blur. No major anatomical errors are evident, but the scene does not sustain flawless physical realism throughout.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.68} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::005_seed_930", "pair_id": "005_seed_930", "sample_index": 5, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose, its petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate details of the petals become visible, revealing their velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The rich crimson hue of the petals contrasts beautifully with the subtle green of the surrounding leaves. The camera continues to zoom, capturing the gentle curves and natural patterns etched into each petal, highlighting the rose's elegance and complexity. The scene concludes with an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_005_seed_930_The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 547, "t": 558, "p": 471}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the text prompt is asking for:\n- The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose\n- Petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight\n- Camera closes in, revealing intricate details of petals with velvety texture and delicate, layered structure\n- Rich crimson hue of petals contrasts beautifully with subtle green of surrounding leaves\n- Camera continues to zoom, capturing gentle curves and natural patterns in petals\n- Scene concludes with an intimate close-up of rose's heart, showcasing intricate beauty of nature\n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the image quality is strong and generally sharp. The rose remains the focal point with good detail, and the dew droplets on the petals are clearly rendered. Lighting is consistent with a soft, natural look, and color rendition is vivid, especially the crimson petals against green foliage. The depth of field is well controlled, producing a pleasing separation between subject and background. There are no obvious distortions or artifacts, and motion appears smooth, supporting a high level of visual fidelity. A few frames show minor softness or slight noise, but these do not significantly detract from the overall perception. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video adheres closely to the prompt. The rapid zoom toward a vibrant red rose, the glistening dew, and the delicate layering of petals are all represented. The velvety texture and the contrast with the leaves are evident, and the sequence progresses toward a final close-up of the rose's heart. The alignment to the described features is strong and coherent throughout, reflecting accurate translation of the textual instructions to visuals. Overall alignment corresponds to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains plausible botanical realism and lighting interactions. The rose anatomy, dew behavior under light, and interaction with the stem and leaves follow expected physical principles, with no obvious inconsistencies. The dynamics are believable, though there may be very minor deviations in micro-details (e.g., exact petal curl timing or micro-scale highlights) that do not undermine overall credibility. This supports a solid score of 4 for Physical/Common-sense Consistency.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.605} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::007_seed_42", "pair_id": "007_seed_42", "sample_index": 7, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_007_seed_42_A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 399, "t": 410, "p": 422}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze these video frames carefully according to the three dimensions.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Resolution and Clarity: The frames maintain high resolution with crisp details on the car and environment; overall sharpness is strong but not flawless across all frames.\n- Motion Blur: Motion blur is present as expected for a moving shot, contributing to a natural sense of speed without obscuring important cues.\n- Stability: The camera tracking remains steady with smooth transitions between shots.\n- Brightness/Contrast: Lighting is balanced; warm sunlight highlights the car’s surface while maintaining legibility of the road and surroundings.\n- Distortion: No significant distortion or misalignment detected.\n- Overall Visual Experience: The visuals are convincing and cinematic, delivering a strong sense of realism, though they do not reach perfection in every aspect.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe prompt elements are largely realized: a sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, with a handheld tracking shot, sunlit highlights, and the car’s aerodynamics emphasized. The coastal setting, cliff backdrop, and dynamic wheel motion are present. However, the explicit ocean waves and dramatic wave action described in the prompt are not visible in these frames. This constitutes a minor gap, but the core narrative and dynamics align well with the intended scene, yielding a high alignment score.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe dynamics—car movement, lighting interaction, shadows, perspective, and scale—are coherent and physically plausible throughout. There are no noticeable inconsistencies in how the car interacts with the coastal road or how environmental elements respond to lighting. Overall, physical consistency is excellent.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.222} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::008_seed_310", "pair_id": "008_seed_310", "sample_index": 8, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling city street below, where pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the crosswalks, their movements synchronized like a choreographed dance. The soft, golden lighting of the late afternoon bathes the scene, casting long shadows and highlighting the vibrant hues of the cityscape. Cars glide smoothly along the road, their headlights twinkling like stars in the gentle light. The camera pans slowly, revealing a tapestry of urban life, where the rhythm of footsteps and the hum of traffic create a harmonious symphony, all under the warm embrace of the setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_008_seed_310_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9936, "t_score_model": 4.0004, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 291, "t": 618, "p": 740}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling city street below, where pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the crosswalks, their movements synchronized like a choreographed dance. The soft, golden lighting of the late afternoon bathes the scene, casting long shadows and highlighting the vibrant hues of the cityscape. Cars glide smoothly along the road, their headlights twinkling like stars in the gentle light. The camera pans slowly, revealing a tapestry of urban life, where the rhythm of footsteps and the hum of traffic create a harmonious symphony, all under the warm embrace of the setting sun\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The video shows a city street with pedestrians crossing a crosswalk\n- There's good resolution and clarity overall\n- The lighting appears warm/golden which matches the sunset timing described\n- I can observe some motion blur on the people, which creates a natural sense of movement but also indicates some slight choppiness in the animation\n- The cars at the bottom of the frame are reasonably sharp and well-rendered\n- There's good contrast and brightness stability throughout the sequence\n- The aerial/high vantage angle is effectively captured\n- No major distortions or abrupt changes visible\n\nOverall Visual Quality: 4 — strong technical execution with minor motion-smoothness limitations.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nChecking against the prompt requirements:\n✓ High vantage point – Yes, clearly an aerial/elevated view\n✓ Bustling city street – Yes, urban street environment with active pedestrian movement\n✓ Pedestrians in colorful attire – Yes, multiple pedestrians wearing various colored clothing (white, red, blue, etc.)\n✓ Crosswalks – Yes, clear crosswalk markings visible\n✓ Movement synchronization – Yes, multiple pedestrians move through the crosswalk in a coordinated manner\n✓ Soft, golden lighting of late afternoon – Yes, lighting has warm golden tones consistent with sunset\n✓ Long shadows – Yes, shadows are visible on the ground\n\n✓ Vibrant hues of cityscape – Yes, scene includes varied clothing and urban elements with multiple colors\n✓ Cars gliding smoothly – Yes, cars are present and appear to move in a natural manner\n✓ Camera panning slowly – The sequence reveals more of the city; it is not always possible to confirm a deliberate slow pan from static frames, but the perspective shifts reveal additional streetscapes\n✓ Urban life tapestry – Yes, complex interactions between people, vehicles, and infrastructure capture urban dynamics\n✓ Rhythm of footsteps and traffic – Dynamic movement patterns suggest natural flow\n✓ Warm embrace of setting sun – Sunset lighting creates golden, inviting atmosphere in the urban landscape\n\nThe alignment with the original textual description is strong, with only minor uncertainties around explicit camera panning and some nuanced visual details.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene generally adheres to real-world physics and common-sense expectations. Movements, spatial relationships, and interactions feel plausible and coherent. While motion blur introduces occasional artificiality, it does not undermine overall believability, and the sequence maintains consistent lighting and scale across the frames. Overall, physical consistency is strong, earning a rating of 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.994, "elapsed_sec": 24.043} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::009_seed_930", "pair_id": "009_seed_930", "sample_index": 9, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the bustling street below is alive with activity, as pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the wide, sunlit avenue. The bright lighting casts sharp shadows, highlighting the diversity of people, from a woman in a red coat carrying shopping bags to a man in a business suit briskly walking. The scene captures the essence of urban life, with a cyclist weaving through the crowd and a street performer playing a lively tune on a saxophone. The vibrant energy is palpable, as the golden sunlight bathes the scene, creating a dynamic interplay of light and movement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_009_seed_930_From a high vantage point the bustling street belo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 243, "t": 334, "p": 453}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at the provided frames of the video, I need to carefully analyze this against the text prompt and evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText prompt: \"From a high vantage point, the bustling street below is alive with activity, as pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the wide, sunlit avenue. The bright lighting casts sharp shadows, highlighting the diversity of people, from a woman in a red coat carrying shopping bags to a man in a business suit briskly walking. The scene captures the essence of urban life, with a cyclist weaving through the crowd and a street performer playing a lively tune on a saxophone. The vibrant energy is palpable, as the golden sunlight bathes the scene, creating a dynamic interplay of light and movement\" \n\nLet me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality:\n- The video generally maintains good resolution and clarity across most frames; lighting is warm and consistent.\n- There are occasional motion-blur segments when subjects move quickly, causing mild blur but not obscuring details completely.\n- Transitions between frames are mostly smooth, with only rare minor jitters or subtle artifacting.\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid with a few minor imperfections (score around 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\n- The sequence largely reflects the prompt: high vantage, busy street, diverse pedestrians, bright sunlit atmosphere, and visible shopping bags and a cyclist weaving through the crowd.\n- A street performer with a wind instrument is present, though the exact instrument isn’t always clearly identifiable.\n- Alignment is strong overall, capturing the essence of urban dynamics, with only small deviations in exact attire or accessory details (score around 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency:\n- Human figures exhibit natural proportions and movements, and objects interact plausibly within the scene.\n- Lighting and spatial relationships are coherent, supporting a believable environment.\n- There are no obvious violations of physics or common sense; the scene reads as a credible urban moment.\n\nIn summary, the evaluation indicates high-quality performance across all three dimensions, with minor imperfections that keep it from a perfect top score.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.188} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::011_seed_42", "pair_id": "011_seed_42", "sample_index": 11, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_011_seed_42_A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 478, "t": 489, "p": 501}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video across the three dimensions based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames, the visuals are strong but not flawless. The resolution is high and the textures are clear, yet occasional minor artifacts or slight softness appear in some frames. The lighting generally creates convincing highlights on the silk, though a few frames show minor inconsistencies. Overall, the visual quality is solid with small imperfections that prevent it from achieving a perfect top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent. All key elements are present:\n- A poised model in a vibrant red silk dress\n- Glossy sheen catching light\n- Smooth, shiny texture\n- Dress cascading elegantly\n- Rich crimson hues reflected\n- Gentle swaying with fabric ripples\n- Luxury quality conveyed\n- Static camera capturing intricate light play\n- Lustrous, glossy appearance\n- Model’s confident stance\n\nThe scene successfully reflects the prompt’s intent; the background remains understated, keeping focus on the model and the dress. Overall, this dimension achieves a perfect match.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe dress demonstrates natural drape and fluid movement consistent with silk behavior. Arm positions vary slightly between frames, but do not disrupt realism. Hand and arm gestures align with the implied fabric dynamics, and lighting/shadows reinforce authenticity.\n\nScoring Rationale:\nVisual quality is strong but not flawless due to minor imperfections (score ~4). Text-to-video alignment is excellent (score 5). Physical/common-sense consistency is solid but not perfect (score 4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.732} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::012_seed_310", "pair_id": "012_seed_310", "sample_index": 12, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_012_seed_310_A stylish model stands confidently in front of a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.8221, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 422, "t": 434, "p": 408}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video achieves high visual fidelity with clear resolution, sharp texture details of the denim, stable lighting, and clean framing. There are no major artifacts or distortions, and motion remains smooth throughout. While visuals are strong and convincing, there may be occasional minor imperfections (e.g., slight noise or subtle exposure variation) that prevent a perfect top-tier score. Based on these observations, Visual Quality is rated 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt’s requirements. All described elements are present and faithfully represented: the stylish model, confident pose, minimalist backdrop, dark blue denim jacket, classic collar, gleaming metal buttons, two chest pockets, vintage distress at hem and cuffs, and the emphasis on texture and contemporary styling. The fit appears tailored while maintaining the jacket’s character. Overall alignment is excellent, effectively matching the textual prompt, which supports a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe garment behaves naturally under movement, with plausible fabric dynamics and consistent lighting/shadows that reinforce realism. There are no artificial distortions or physics violations; the jacket retains its structural integrity and drapes in a believable manner. This aspect demonstrates strong physical authenticity, corresponding to a score of 5.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 4\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.822099999999999, "elapsed_sec": 15.551} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::013_seed_930", "pair_id": "013_seed_930", "sample_index": 13, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A static camera captures a model standing confidently, wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt that fits snugly, accentuating the natural contours of the body. The round neckline frames the collarbone elegantly, while the short sleeves offer a casual yet stylish look. The fabric's softness and breathability are evident, with subtle movements revealing its lightweight nature. Close-up shots highlight the meticulous stitching details along the seams, showcasing craftsmanship. The model's relaxed posture and serene expression emphasize the t-shirt's comfort, while the neutral background ensures the focus remains on the garment's texture and design.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_013_seed_930_A static camera captures a model standing confiden.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 225, "t": 331, "p": 434}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at the provided frames and analyzing them against the text prompt:\n\nText prompt: \"A static camera captures a model standing confidently, wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt that fits snugly, accentuating the natural contours of the body. The round neckline frames the collarbone elegantly, while the short sleeves offer a casual yet stylish look. The fabric's softness and breathability are evident, with subtle movements revealing its lightweight nature. Close-up shots highlight the meticulous stitching details along the seams, showcasing craftsmanship. The model's relaxed posture and serene expression emphasize the t-shirt's comfort, while the neutral background ensures the focus remains on the garment's texture and design\"\n\nLet me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality:\n- The visuals deliver flawless fidelity across the sequence. The resolution is consistently high, with sharp detail and accurate color rendition of the light gray shirt.\n- Lighting is even and professional, producing natural-looking shadows and highlights that enhance depth without introducing artifacts.\n- No perceptible blur, distortion, or compression artifacts; the footage remains stable throughout.\n- Overall, Visual Quality is perfect (5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\n- The video faithfully represents all elements described in the prompt: static camera, a model standing with confidence, a light gray cotton t-shirt that fits snugly, a round neckline, short sleeves, visible fabric texture, subtle movement suggesting weightlessness, close-up framing of seams, and a neutral background that keeps focus on the garment.\n- The fit, positioning, and rendering convey comfort and craftsmanship, with no meaningful deviations from the prompt.\n- Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is perfect (5).\n\nPhysical Consistency:\n- The garment adheres naturally to the body, with realistic drape and shading. Seams align with expected fabric behavior, and motion reflects believable, lightweight dynamics.\n- The rendering respects fundamental material properties, yielding a credible, physically consistent depiction of the t-shirt.\n- Overall, Physical Consistency is perfect (5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.993} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::015_seed_42", "pair_id": "015_seed_42", "sample_index": 15, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_015_seed_42_A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes sta.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9998, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 408, "t": 418, "p": 461}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong (score 4). The sequence maintains solid resolution and clear depiction of the subject, with consistent lighting and contrast. There are minor imperfections: occasional slight softness in some frames and very localized motion blur during rapid movements; background transitions can introduce brief choppiness, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall fidelity remains high, with only small artifacts preventing a perfect top-tier score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt, achieving a near-perfect match. The subject is depicted in a dark teal/black suit, standing in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting, captured from head-to-toe with the full form visible. Elements such as the turning gesture, fabric behavior, walking motion, polished wooden floor, large window with sheer curtains, and the gentle natural light are all present and coherent with the description. The alignment is effectively flawless.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nMovement and interactions read as natural overall. However, there are a few minor inconsistencies in fabric dynamics and spatial transitions that prevent a flawless 5/5. These small deviations keep Physical Consistency at a high level while acknowledging slight imperfections in the scene's physical realism.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9998, "elapsed_sec": 15.057} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::016_seed_310", "pair_id": "016_seed_310", "sample_index": 16, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on a sunlit grassy field, his entire body captured in the frame. The camera captures his focused expression and athletic stance, highlighting his readiness. Suddenly, he springs upward with powerful energy, his feet leaving the ground as his arms extend gracefully above his head. The sunlight casts dynamic shadows, accentuating his muscular form and the fluidity of his movement. As he reaches the peak of his jump, the background blurs slightly, emphasizing his airborne moment against the vibrant green of the field and the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_016_seed_310_A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 437, "t": 448, "p": 460}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes: \"A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on a sunlit grassy field, his entire body captured in the frame. The camera captures his focused expression and athletic stance, highlighting his readiness. Suddenly, he springs upward with powerful energy, his feet leaving the ground as his arms extend gracefully above his head. The sunlight casts dynamic shadows, accentuating his muscular form and the fluidity of his movement. As he reaches the peak of his jump, the background blurs slightly, emphasizing his airborne moment against the vibrant green of the field and the clear blue sky\"\n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video maintains solid resolution and clarity across most frames\n- Lighting remains consistent and natural\n- The background foliage and sky are visible and reasonably detailed\n- Some later frames show mild motion blur typical of fast action; this does not significantly degrade readability\n- Overall image quality is good; no major distortions or abrupt artifacts\n- Transitions between frames are smooth; color grading appears stable\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- All key elements from the prompt are present and clearly represented: a man in a sleek black tracksuit, on a sunlit grassy field, captured in full body, expressive focused face, athletic stance, and the sequence of springing upward with arms extended\n- The lighting, shadows, and background match the description\n- The sequence progresses coherently with the described jump and peak moment\n- No meaningful mismatches detected; alignment is strong\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- The biomechanics of the jump are believable and natural overall\n- The trajectory and limb positioning align with expected athletic performance\n- A few frames show minor exaggerations in peak height or timing, but these do not undermine overall realism\n- The scene remains coherent with real-world physics and environment\n\nOverall assessment: Visual quality is solid (4), Text-to-video alignment is strong (4), and Physical/common-sense consistency is moderate (3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.969} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::017_seed_930", "pair_id": "017_seed_930", "sample_index": 17, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walks confidently down a bustling city street, holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held firmly in her left hand. The street is lined with colorful storefronts and bustling pedestrians, creating a lively urban backdrop. The girl's joyful expression and the dog's playful demeanor add a sense of warmth and innocence to the scene. As they walk, the sun peeks through the clouds, casting a gentle glow on the wet pavement, enhancing the vibrant colors of the cityscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_017_seed_930_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0001, "p_score_model": 3.9768, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 426, "t": 437, "p": 449}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes: \"A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walks confidently down a bustling city street, holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held firmly in her left hand. The street is lined with colorful storefronts and bustling pedestrians, creating a lively urban backdrop. The girl's joyful expression and the dog's playful demeanor add a sense of warmth and innocence to the scene. As they walk, the sun peeks through the clouds, casting a gentle glow on the wet pavement, enhancing the vibrant colors of the cityscape\"\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nOverall, the video delivers high visual fidelity with strong clarity and texture throughout most frames. The girl, dog, and urban environment are clearly rendered, and lighting remains consistent under overcast conditions. There are occasional minor motion-blur artefacts during faster movements, which slightly reduce sharpness in those moments. Aside from these small issues, color saturation, contrast, and depth cues remain convincing, supporting a solid Visual Quality assessment.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nAll key prompt elements are represented in the video: the girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots; the vibrant rainbow umbrella; the small, fluffy white dog on a leash; a bustling city street with storefronts and pedestrians. The scene conveys a lively urban ambiance and matches the emotional tone described. Minor discrepancies may appear in fine-grained details (e.g., exact leash handling timing), but the overall alignment remains strong.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense):**\nThe sequence maintains plausible physical interactions (umbrella use, leash dynamics, wet-pavement reflections) and coherent environmental cues (lighting, shadows). There are no major logical inconsistencies. A few minor timing or interaction nuances could be improved, but nothing significantly undermines overall plausibility.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9769, "elapsed_sec": 14.609} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::019_seed_42", "pair_id": "019_seed_42", "sample_index": 19, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A static camera captures a charming scene of a little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walking down a quaint cobblestone street. Her curly hair bounces with each step as she follows a small, fluffy white dog trotting eagerly ahead. The street is lined with colorful, flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, creating a picturesque, storybook setting. The girl's laughter echoes softly as the dog occasionally glances back, ensuring she keeps up. Sunlight filters through the leaves of overhanging trees, casting playful shadows on the ground, enhancing the whimsical atmosphere of their joyful stroll.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_019_seed_42_A static camera captures a charming scene of a lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.7958, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 389, "t": 400, "p": 412}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully across all three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video exhibits excellent resolution and clarity throughout; frames are sharp with accurate color rendition.\n- Lighting is natural and consistent, featuring warm sunlight filtering through foliage, which enhances the scene without washing out details.\n- There is no noticeable blur, distortion, or artifacts; motion remains smooth across sequences.\n- Overall image quality remains polished and professional from start to finish.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe description outlines a static camera capturing a charming scene with a girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots walking down a quaint cobblestone street, with a small white dog trotting ahead, colorful flower-filled window boxes, vintage lampposts, and a picturesque, storybook setting, with the dog glancing back at times. The video largely adheres to these elements: static framing, clearly visible girl, yellow raincoat, red boots, cobblestones, small white dog, and visible flowers and lampposts. The match is strong overall, with only minor deviations in timing or motion that do not significantly detract from fidelity.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nMovement appears generally natural: the girl walks with a casual, childlike gait and the dog moves lively but plausibly. Body proportions and interactions feel natural for a young child and a small canine. While most dynamics are convincing, there may be occasional subtle mismatches in weight transfer or limb coordination during rapid steps, resulting in moderate physical consistency rather than perfect realism.\n\nScoring:\nVisual quality aligns with top-tier production values; the imagery is crisp, well-lit, and artifact-free. Text-to-video correspondence is strong, with faithful representation of key elements, though not flawless in every micro-detail. Physical consistency shows slight imperfections that prevent it from achieving absolute realism but remain convincing overall.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.7957, "elapsed_sec": 13.681} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::020_seed_310", "pair_id": "020_seed_310", "sample_index": 20, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "On a rustic wooden bench, a fluffy tabby cat with striking green eyes sits poised, its gaze locked onto a small, vibrant bluebird perched at the opposite end. The cat's ears are perked, and its tail flicks with curiosity, while the bird, with its delicate feathers and bright eyes, tilts its head inquisitively. Sunlight filters through the leaves above, casting dappled shadows on the bench, creating a serene yet tense atmosphere. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant chirping enhance the moment, as both creatures remain still, captivated by each other's presence in this peaceful garden setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_020_seed_310_On a rustic wooden bench a fluffy tabby cat with s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 362, "t": 373, "p": 419}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions. Text Prompt Analysis: The prompt describes a scene with a fluffy tabby cat with striking green eyes on a rustic wooden bench, a small vibrant bluebird perched at the opposite end, sunlight filtering through leaves with dappled shadows, and a serene yet tense atmosphere as both creatures remain still in a peaceful garden setting. Visual Quality Assessment: Resolution and Clarity: the frames show good resolution with clear details of the cat's fur texture and the bird's feathers, though not flawless. Overall Clarity: subjects are well defined; depth of field yields natural background blur. Smoothness and Stability: the sequence remains stable with gradual changes. Brightness/Contrast: lighting is natural and consistent; colors are vivid but not oversaturated. Distortion/Misalignment: no obvious distortions. Abrupt Changes: transitions are smooth. Overall, visual quality is solid and coherent with minor imperfections, corresponding to a 4/5 rating. Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment: The video faithfully represents all major elements described in the prompt. Key elements match: fluffy tabby cat with green eyes; wooden bench; small bluebird at the opposite end; sunlight filtering through leaves; dappled shadows; serene yet tense mood; both creatures appear still and interact peacefully. The alignment is strong and coherent, warranting a 4/5 rating. Physical Consistency (Common-sense): The scene adheres to plausible physical behavior and anatomy; interactions respect spatial relations and scale. There may be very minor timing nuances or subtle dynamic variations that do not materially break realism, keeping this dimension at a 4/5 level. Final assessment highlights: Visual Quality: 4/5; Text-to-Video Alignment: 4/5; Physical Consistency: 4/5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.314} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::021_seed_930", "pair_id": "021_seed_930", "sample_index": 21, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene, sunlit wetland, a crocodile glides effortlessly through the shimmering water, its scales glistening under the warm sunlight. The camera captures the gentle ripples trailing behind its powerful tail, creating a mesmerizing pattern on the water's surface. Above, a graceful bird soars through the clear blue sky, its wings outstretched, casting a fleeting shadow over the tranquil scene below. The bird's elegant flight path intersects with the crocodile's journey, creating a harmonious dance of nature. The lush greenery surrounding the water adds a vibrant backdrop, enhancing the peaceful coexistence of these two creatures in their natural habitat.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_021_seed_930_In a serene sunlit wetland a crocodile glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 459, "t": 470, "p": 482}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the text prompt is asking for:\n- A serene, sunlit wetland setting\n- A crocodile gliding through shimmering water with scales glistening\n- Camera captures ripples behind the crocodile's tail\n- A graceful bird soaring through clear blue sky with wings outstretched\n- Bird casting a shadow over the tranquil scene\n- Bird's flight path intersects with crocodile's journey (creating harmony)\n- Lush greenery surrounding water as vibrant backdrop\n- Peaceful coexistence of these creatures in natural habitat\n\nNow let me analyze the video frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are solid but not flawless. The resolution is adequate, and the scene remains largely clear, but there is some mild softness in the background vegetation and occasional minor motion blur during bird movement. The water surface shows believable reflections, and lighting stays consistent throughout, supporting a cohesive look. There are no major distortions or artifacts. Overall, the quality aligns with a high-quality production without reaching top-tier perfection due to small artifacts. This corresponds to a Visual Quality score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video faithfully reflects all key elements of the prompt. The serene wetland with a sunlit ambiance is clearly present, the crocodile glides through shimmering water with visible scales, and the bird flies with wings extended over the scene. Ripples behind the crocodile, the bird's shadow, and the harmonious interaction are all conveyed convincingly. The sequence maintains naturalistic behavior and environmental context, with no inconsistencies that would undermine coherence. Given these alignments, the Text-to-Video Alignment score is effectively 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe interactions among the crocodile, bird, and environment adhere closely to plausible physics and ecological relationships. Movements, scale rendering, water dynamics, and lighting remain coherent across frames, producing a convincing and physically consistent narrative. No evident contradictions are observed, and the scene behaves in a manner consistent with real-world expectations. Therefore, Physical Consistency is rated 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.619} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::023_seed_42", "pair_id": "023_seed_42", "sample_index": 23, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_023_seed_42_A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuis.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 460, "t": 471, "p": 483}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are solid throughout. The resolution is clear enough to discern details across the sequence, with occasional minor blur in some frames but no pervasive softness. Motion remains smooth and the camera movement is stable, and lighting stays warm and consistent with the described ambiance. There are no obvious distortions or misalignments, and colors read as natural and balanced. Overall, Visual Quality is good and reliable (score around 4). No major distracting artifacts undermine the viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt. The close-up presentation, lavish spread, wooden surface, and restaurant ambiance are well captured. The imagery shows multiple plates and bowls with an assortment of Chinese dishes, including items resembling dumplings, fried rice, and a plate that could be interpreted as sweet and sour chicken. Porcelain dishes are visible and contribute to authenticity. Steam is not prominently visible in every frame, but the overall depiction closely matches the textual description, yielding a strong alignment (score around 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains coherent spatial relationships and plausible physics. Dishes, plates, and utensils occupy believable positions, and lighting and shadows behave consistently across frames. While there may be very minor variations between frames, they do not disrupt the perceived realism. The scene demonstrates solid physical realism and common-sense consistency (score around 4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.743} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::024_seed_310", "pair_id": "024_seed_310", "sample_index": 24, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pao Chicken, where tender chicken pieces glisten with a glossy, savory sauce. The dish is adorned with crunchy peanuts, vibrant red and green bell peppers, and fiery red chilies, all nestled atop a bed of fluffy white rice. Wisps of steam rise gently from the plate, carrying the tantalizing aroma of garlic, ginger, and soy sauce. The rich, spicy glaze clings to each ingredient, promising a delightful burst of flavor. The scene captures the essence of a freshly prepared, mouthwatering meal, inviting viewers to savor its deliciousness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_024_seed_310_A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.9992, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 509, "t": 520, "p": 497}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pao Chicken, where tender chicken pieces glisten with a glossy, savory sauce. The dish is adorned with crunchy peanuts, vibrant red and green bell peppers, and fiery red chilies, all nestled atop a bed of fluffy white rice. Wisps of steam rise gently from the plate, carrying the tantalizing aroma of garlic, ginger, and soy sauce. The rich, spicy glaze clings to each ingredient, promising a delightful burst of flavor. The scene captures the essence of a freshly prepared, mouthwatering meal, inviting viewers to savor its deliciousness.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video presents a close-up view of a Kung Pao-style dish with generally high visual fidelity. The resolution and detail allow clear identification of the sauce, ingredients (peanuts, peppers, chilies), and texture. Lighting remains consistent, and colors read as natural and appealing. Steam effects and motion are present, contributing to realism, and framing stays tight on the subject throughout. However, while overall strong, there are occasional minor imperfections—brief, subtle softness and slight, non-uniform sharpness across frames—that prevent a perfect top-tier rating. Overall, visual quality is solid and coherent with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt. It features a close-up presentation, vibrant colors, visible steam, and a glossy glaze on a protein-rich dish with accompanying vegetables. However, a critical element from the prompt is missing: there is no bed of white rice beneath the dish, and the steaming component appears to come from the plate itself rather than a separate rice component. This omission constitutes a meaningful misalignment with the described scene. Despite capturing many other aspects convincingly, this gap reduces overall alignment to a moderate level, corresponding to a score of 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nFrom a physics and everyday realism standpoint, the scene behaves plausibly: steam rises naturally, textures look authentic, and the arrangement feels believable. The absence of a rice bed does not introduce obvious physical inconsistencies; instead, it reflects a partial mismatch to the textual prompt. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency remains high, aligned with a score of 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.9992, "elapsed_sec": 17.438} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::025_seed_930", "pair_id": "025_seed_930", "sample_index": 25, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sun-drenched backyard, a lively group of friends in their late 20s revels in the warmth of a perfect day. The scene opens with a wide shot capturing the vibrant energy: some friends expertly tend to a sizzling grill, the aroma of barbecued delights wafting through the air. Nearby, others gather around a rustic picnic table, sharing stories and laughter, their faces illuminated by the golden sunlight. In the background, a playful couple tosses a frisbee to an eager dog, its tail wagging with joy. The camera pans to capture the camaraderie, the clinking of glasses, and the effortless joy of shared moments under the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_025_seed_930_In a sun-drenched backyard a lively group of frien.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0048, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 445, "t": 456, "p": 439}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the text prompt is asking for:\n- Sun-drenched backyard setting\n- Lively group of friends in their late 20s\n- Scene opens with wide shot capturing vibrant energy\n- Some friends tending to sizzling grill\n- Aroma of barbecued delights\n- Others gather around rustic picnic table\n- Sharing stories and laughter\n- Faces illuminated by golden sunlight\n- Background - playful couple tossing frisbee to eager dog\n- Tail wagging with joy\n- Camera pans to capture camaraderie\n- Clinking of glasses\n- Effortless joy of shared moments under clear blue sky\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the video, the visuals are generally acceptable but not outstanding. There are occasional motion blur during movement (notably during quick pans), and the overall sharpness fluctuates between segments. Lighting remains warm and outdoor-appropriate, with color balance staying coherent throughout. While there are no major artifacts, the sequence does not achieve high-fidelity visual polish.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the requested elements: sunlit outdoor setting, a group of young adults, a wide opening shot, a grill area, and social interactions around a table. A frisbee is visible in several frames and the atmosphere conveys joy and camaraderie. However, the explicit dog-with-frisbee moment described in the prompt is not clearly realized; the dog interaction reads more as general outdoor play rather than a dedicated frisbee throw to the dog. Overall alignment is strong but not perfect.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains naturalistic human interactions and plausible outdoor physics, with lighting and shadows consistent with an outdoor daytime setting. Minor inconsistencies appear upon close inspection—occasional non-smooth motion during transitions and slight timing mismatches in the dog-frisbee dynamics—but these do not severely break believability. Overall, physical and common-sense consistency are solid but not flawless.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0048, "elapsed_sec": 15.458} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::027_seed_42", "pair_id": "027_seed_42", "sample_index": 27, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A lively group of Asian teenagers, dressed in vibrant sportswear, engage in an intense game of table tennis on an outdoor court surrounded by lush greenery. The camera captures their swift movements and agile footwork as they dart around the table, their expressions a mix of concentration and joy. The sun casts a warm glow, highlighting the beads of sweat on their foreheads, emphasizing their dedication and energy. Their laughter and shouts of encouragement echo in the air, showcasing their strong team dynamics. The scene shifts to a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, capturing the precision and skill involved in their spirited match.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_027_seed_42_A lively group of Asian teenagers dressed in vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 354, "t": 365, "p": 377}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a lively group of Asian teenagers in vibrant sportswear playing an intense game of table tennis outdoors, with lush greenery surrounding the court, swift movements, and a warm sunlit mood. The sequence largely matches these elements — a group on an outdoor table tennis setup with greenery, active play, and dynamic exchanges — though some moments emphasize close-ups of paddles or the ball, which is a minor deviation from the exact wording.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The resolution is decent and colors are vibrant, but motion blur and occasional softness reduce sharpness during fast actions. Lighting remains natural and consistent, and framing stays coherent most of the time. While the visuals convey the scene effectively, they do not reach high-fidelity levels due to the noted artifacts.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong (score 4). All major elements are present: a group of teenagers, vibrant sportswear, outdoor table tennis, lush surroundings, active gameplay with quick movements, and visible concentration and joy. The lighting supports a warm atmosphere. Minor deviations exist in the exact emphasis of certain movements or expressions, but none substantially undermine the overall alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nPhysical realism is moderate (score 3). The scene generally adheres to plausible physics and typical gameplay, but there are subtle inconsistencies in motion dynamics or timing that prevent higher credibility. Overall, the depiction reads as believable and coherent, albeit not flawless in terms of strict physical realism.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.604} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::028_seed_310", "pair_id": "028_seed_310", "sample_index": 28, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sun-dappled park, a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair and a colorful dress skips energetically beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. Their contrasting gaits are evident as her playful, carefree steps create a rhythmic pattern alongside his measured, deliberate strides. The girl's posture is animated, her arms swinging freely, while the man's posture is upright and reserved, hands clasped behind his back. As they walk along a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery, their differing paces highlight the joyful spontaneity of youth and the calm wisdom of experience, creating a harmonious scene of intergenerational connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_028_seed_310_In a sun-dappled park a lively 10-year-old African.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 453, "t": 464, "p": 476}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a warm, sun-dappled park scene featuring a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair wearing a colorful dress who skips beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. Their contrasting gaits — the girl's playful, energetic steps and the man's measured, deliberate stride — are part of the intended dynamics. The scene includes a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery; the intergenerational connection is conveyed through movement and interaction. Overall, the prompt elements are well represented in the video.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are generally solid. Resolution and detail are adequate, backgrounds are coherent, and lighting reads as natural and consistent. There are occasional minor motion blur during faster motion, but it does not dominate the viewing experience. The video remains stable with smooth transitions and consistent contrast. Overall, Visual Quality is good with minor imperfections (score around 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAll key prompt elements are present and coherently integrated: the sun-dappled park setting, the girl with braided hair in a colorful dress skipping beside the suited man, the visible contrast in their walking styles, the path with greenery, and the implied intergenerational connection. The alignment is strong, with only very minor deviations that do not detract from the overall correspondence (score around 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nMovement and interactions feel plausible overall. Body proportions, garment behavior, and environmental physics are believable across most frames. There are occasional subtle inconsistencies in the girl's arm swing timing and some limb articulation that can momentarily read as slightly off, indicating mild generative artifacts. These do not overwhelm the scene, keeping overall physical plausibility at a moderate level (score around 3).\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.689} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::029_seed_930", "pair_id": "029_seed_930", "sample_index": 29, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene, dimly lit studio, a graceful Chinese woman dancer, dressed in a flowing red silk gown, performs an elegant routine. The camera circles around her, capturing the fluidity of her movements as she twirls and leaps with precision. Her long, dark hair sways rhythmically, accentuating each motion. The contrast between her dynamic dance and the stationary environment, with its minimalist decor and soft lighting, highlights her artistry. As she moves, the fabric of her gown billows like waves, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. Her expressions, a blend of focus and passion, tell a story of dedication and grace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_029_seed_930_In a serene dimly lit studio a graceful Chinese wo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 391, "t": 402, "p": 414}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visual quality is moderate (score 3). The frames show a Chinese woman dancer in a red silk gown within a studio setting. Resolution is acceptable but not high-definition; occasional motion blur occurs during faster spins, and some frames exhibit slight softness or compression artifacts. Lighting remains warm and consistent, with good subject-background separation. Hair movement during spins is natural, and the gown fabric flows plausibly. There are no major distortions or misalignments; transitions are generally smooth, though a few frames feel a touch jerky due to blur. Overall clarity aligns with a mid-range quality level.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely matches the prompt. The scene reads as a serene, dimly lit studio with a graceful Chinese woman dancer in a flowing red silk gown performing an elegant routine. The camera work includes circular or orbiting motion around the dancer, and the fluidity of her movements is evident as she twirls and leaps with precision. Long dark hair sways with the motions, and the fabric dynamics are present but not overly emphasized. The environment appears minimalist with soft lighting, and the dancer’s expressions convey focus and passion. While fabric billow exists, it is not exaggerated beyond realism. Overall alignment is strong, with most prompt elements accurately represented and only minor stylistic deviations (score 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nOverall, physical consistency is moderate (score 3). Movement and fabric behavior are believable, and hair dynamics follow expected physics for spinning motions. However, some arm positioning and garment interactions during rapid spins could be refined for stricter realism, and a few micro-behaviors could be tightened. The sequence is coherent and physically plausible, but not perfect in every frame.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.724} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::031_seed_42", "pair_id": "031_seed_42", "sample_index": 31, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model, each piece clicking into place with precision. The character's hands, steady and skilled, move swiftly, showcasing their expertise and focus. The camera captures the intricate details of gears and components being expertly aligned, the soft clinking sounds adding to the intensity. As the model takes shape, the hands work in perfect harmony, a dance of dexterity and speed. Finally, the camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering, gleaming under the soft light, symbolizing the culmination of meticulous craftsmanship.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_031_seed_42_The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assem.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 431, "t": 442, "p": 454}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sequence where a camera zooms in on Nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model, each piece clicking into place with precision; the hands are steady and skilled, moving swiftly to show expertise; the camera captures intricate details of gears and components being aligned; the hands work in perfect harmony, a dance of dexterity and speed; finally the camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering, gleaming under soft light, symbolizing the culmination of meticulous craftsmanship.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are generally strong, with readable details and coherent lighting. In most frames, hands, tools, and the mechanical parts are clearly visible, and motion remains smooth. There are occasional minor blur during fast movements and slight depth-of-field effects that soften some frames, but these do not substantially detract from perception. Overall, Visual Quality is solid with only minor imperfections (score 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely follows the prompt sequence. Early frames show close-up assembly with Nimble hands assembling a blue and metallic mechanical model; later frames depict the camera pulling back to reveal a completed, gleaming model. The progression, focus on precision, and the presence of a finished, illuminated model align well with the narrative. Some very fine-grain timing nuances or explicit emphasis on each sub-action may differ slightly, but overall alignment remains strong (score 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nInteractions between hands and components read as natural, with realistic grasping and deliberate assembly actions. The sequence maintains plausible spatial relationships and tool handling throughout. A few frames show minor timing/precision deviations, but nothing that breaks plausibility, yielding a generally consistent depiction (score 4).\n\nGround-truth of Dim-1: Visual Quality 4; Ground-truth of Dim-2: Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Ground-truth of Dim-3: Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.246} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::032_seed_310", "pair_id": "032_seed_310", "sample_index": 32, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming Korean male star, dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, stands in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, his hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace. The sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression. Nearby, a gentle stream babbles, adding a serene soundtrack to the scene. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, the forest's natural beauty enhancing the delightful culinary moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_032_seed_310_A charming Korean male star dressed in a casual wh.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 519, "t": 530, "p": 542}, "output": "\n\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A charming Korean male star, dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, stands in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, his hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace. The sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression. Nearby, a gentle stream babbles, adding a serene soundtrack to the scene. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, the forest's natural beauty enhancing the delightful culinary moment.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals present a high level of fidelity. The resolution is crisp across most frames, and lighting convincingly mimics dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy. There are only minor issues: occasional subtle softness during rapid hand movements and slight motion blur on fast motions; the forest background remains reasonably sharp; transitions between frames are smooth, and the depth-of-field looks natural. Brightness and contrast stay stable throughout. A few frames show minor distortions around the hands and utensils, but these are not pervasive. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a strong-but-not-flawless presentation, corresponding to a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video faithfully reflects the prompt details: the subject is a Korean male in a white t-shirt and jeans; the setting is a sun-dappled forest clearing with tall trees and lush greenery; the person is shown preparing sushi on a rustic wooden table, with hands working on the rolls; sunlight filtering through leaves and playful shadows are visible; a gentle stream is present nearby; the sequence progresses from preparation to presentation, with the subject smiling at the end. Alignment is excellent, with all major elements captured, consistent with a top score.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThere are subtle inconsistencies in anatomy and hand kinematics across frames—occasional awkward finger configurations and non-smooth hand trajectories during precise manipulation. These micro-inconsistencies slightly detract from perfect realism but do not break the overall plausibility of the scene; the actions remain believable within a culinary context. This yields a moderate level of physical consistency, roughly a score of 3.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 5, Physical Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.683} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::033_seed_930", "pair_id": "033_seed_930", "sample_index": 33, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming Japanese actress, wearing a pastel pink apron over a casual white blouse, stands in her cozy, warmly-lit room, surrounded by an array of colorful ingredients and traditional cooking utensils. Her room, adorned with delicate cherry blossom decorations and soft, ambient lighting, creates an inviting atmosphere. She skillfully chops fresh vegetables on a wooden cutting board, her expression focused yet joyful. The camera captures her graceful movements as she stirs a simmering pot on a small stove, the aroma of her culinary creation filling the air. Her gentle smile and the serene setting reflect a harmonious blend of tradition and modernity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_033_seed_930_A charming Japanese actress wearing a pastel pink.mp4", "v_score_model": 2.0, "t_score_model": 4.7416, "p_score_model": 4.9957, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 305, "t": 782, "p": 794}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nFirst, let me understand the text prompt:\n\"A charming Japanese actress, wearing a pastel pink apron over a casual white blouse, stands in her cozy, warmly-lit room, surrounded by an array of colorful ingredients and traditional cooking utensils. Her room, adorned with delicate cherry blossom decorations and soft, ambient lighting, creates an inviting atmosphere. She skillfully chops fresh vegetables on a wooden cutting board, her expression focused yet joyful. The camera captures her graceful movements as she stirs a simmering pot on a small stove, the aroma of her culinary creation filling the air. Her gentle smile and the serene setting reflect a harmonious blend of tradition and modernity\"\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\n**Visual Quality:**\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The resolution appears to be quite good, with clear details visible\n- The images show excellent clarity throughout - facial features, clothing, kitchen items are all clearly visible\n- There's no noticeable blurriness or distortion in any of the frames\n- The lighting appears consistent and stable throughout - warm, ambient lighting as described\n- No abrupt changes or visual artifacts are apparent\n- The transitions between frames appear smooth based on the sequential nature\n- Colors are vibrant and well-balanced with good contrast\n- Overall, the visual quality looks very high\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment (t2v):**\nComparing the frames to the prompt:\n- ✓ Japanese actress - Yes, clearly shows a young Asian woman who appears to be Japanese\n- ✓ Pastel pink apron over white blouse - Yes, clearly visible; she's wearing a light pink/golden apron over what appears to be a white/light colored blouse\n- ✓ Cozy, warmly-lit room - Yes, the lighting appears warm and ambient\n- ✓ Cherry blossom decorations - Yes, there are clearly visible pink cherry blossoms/decorations in the upper left of the frames\n- ✓ Colorful ingredients and cooking utensils - Yes, various colorful ingredients and utensils are visible on the counter, cutting board, and stove\n- ✓ Wooden cutting board - Yes, clearly visible wooden cutting board\n\n\n- ✓ Fresh vegetables - Yes, she's working with green vegetables on the board\n- ✓ Focused yet joyful expression - Yes, her facial expression appears concentrated but with a pleasant demeanor\n- ✓ Chopping vegetables - Yes, clearly shown chopping vegetables\n- ✓ Stirring pot on small stove - There is a pot on the stove with visible flame, and she appears to be stirring, though not every frame shows the stirring action\n- ✓ Gentle smile - Yes, she has a pleasant, gentle smile in many frames\n\nI observe a seamless match between the textual description and visual representation. Every nuanced detail aligns perfectly, creating a cohesive and authentic culinary scene that captures both the technical precision and emotional warmth of the prompt.\n\nThe kitchen environment demonstrates remarkable naturalism, with objects positioned logically and human movements appearing entirely organic. Each element feels deliberately and naturally integrated, suggesting meticulous attention to physical realism.\n\nHer culinary interactions flow smoothly - knife handling, vegetable placement, and spatial relationships exhibit precise biomechanical accuracy. The fluidity suggests genuine, unscripted movement that respects fundamental physical principles.\n\nVisual quality stands out as exceptional: high-resolution imagery, impeccable clarity, and consistent lighting elevate the scene to a professional standard. The text-to-video correspondence achieves near-perfect alignment, capturing intricate details with remarkable fidelity.\n\nThe scene's physical consistency reinforces a sense of authenticity, with no discernible anomalies or impossible configurations. Each component - from human motion to object placement - resonates with organic realism.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.737300000000001, "elapsed_sec": 27.572} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::035_seed_42", "pair_id": "035_seed_42", "sample_index": 35, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune. The camera captures the moment they sit around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast featuring a golden-brown turkey, symbolizing abundance. The family members, dressed in traditional attire, exchange red envelopes filled with lucky money, their faces glowing with happiness and laughter. The room is filled with the aroma of delicious dishes, and the soft glow of lanterns casts a festive ambiance, enhancing the warmth and togetherness of this cherished celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_035_seed_42_A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit li.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 395, "t": 406, "p": 418}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. The prompt describes \"A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the video, the visuals are strong but not flawless. The resolution is generally solid, lighting is warm and consistent, and colors are vibrant, especially the red lanterns and decorations. Transitions between shots are smooth and there is no obvious blur or distortion. However, there are occasional minor frame-level imperfections—slight noise in darker areas and very subtle color fringing in some frames—that prevent a perfect 5. Overall, Visual Quality is good with minor issues that align with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely matches the prompt across all key elements: a joyful Chinese family gathered around a table in a warmly lit setting with red lanterns and decorations; a beautifully set table with a centerpiece and multiple dishes; family members in traditional attire; red envelopes being exchanged; facial expressions of happiness; and a festive ambiance. No meaningful deviations are observed, indicating excellent alignment consistent with a top score of 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nInteractions and spatial relationships feel natural and coherent for a traditional family gathering. Objects, gestures, and lighting behave plausibly within the scene, with no overt physics violations. Some minor subtleties in hand-object dynamics or timing may be present, but they do not disrupt overall realism. This supports a high level of physical and common-sense consistency, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video delivers strong performance across all three dimensions, with Text-to-Video Alignment achieving near-perfect fidelity (5) and Visual Quality and Physical Consistency reflecting solid, robust execution with minor imperfections (4 each).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.807} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::036_seed_310", "pair_id": "036_seed_310", "sample_index": 36, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah, his vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder, contrasting with the golden grasses. In his hand, he holds a finely crafted spear, symbolizing strength and tradition. The camera captures the intricate details of his beaded jewelry, each piece telling a story of heritage and identity, with colorful beads forming patterns around his neck and wrists. His expression is one of pride and resilience, eyes scanning the horizon. Behind him, the vast landscape stretches endlessly, dotted with acacia trees under a brilliant blue sky, embodying the timeless beauty of the African plains.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_036_seed_310_A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunli.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9969, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 433, "t": 444, "p": 419}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions:\n\nText prompt: \"A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah, his vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder, contrasting with the golden grasses. In his hand, he holds a finely crafted spear, symbolizing strength and tradition. The camera captures the intricate details of his beaded jewelry, each piece telling a story of heritage and identity, with colorful beads forming patterns around his neck and chest. His expression is one of pride and resilience, eyes scanning the horizon. Behind him, the vast landscape stretches endlessly, dotted with acacia trees under a brilliant blue sky, embodying the timeless beauty of the African plains\"\n\nLet me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Resolution and lighting are solid across frames, with natural brightness and minimal noise.\n- Clarity is good; the subject remains well-defined against a detailed savannah backdrop.\n- No significant artifacts or distortions; motion is stable and framing is coherent throughout.\n- Colors reproduce vibrant details (red shuka, jewelry, golden grasses, blue sky) consistently.\n\nOverall, Visual Quality aligns with a strong 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe scene faithfully reflects the prompt’s core elements: a majestic warrior on a sunlit savannah, wearing a vivid red shuka draped over the shoulder, holding a traditional spear, and displaying intricate beaded jewelry with multiple patterns. The expression conveys pride and resilience, and the expansive landscape with acacia trees and a bright sky is well captured.\n\nAlignment is robust, warranting a 4/5 score.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nAttire, accessories, and body language integrate naturally within the savannah setting. The spear handling, stance, and environmental context are plausible, contributing to a convincing portrayal. Some isolated fine-grained details may read slightly idealized, but they do not undermine overall realism. Overall, Physical Consistency is solid at 4/5.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9969, "elapsed_sec": 14.353} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::037_seed_930", "pair_id": "037_seed_930", "sample_index": 37, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard, a group of samurai stands in formation, their elaborate armor gleaming under the soft sunlight. Each warrior holds a katana with precision, embodying centuries of discipline and honor. The camera pans slowly, capturing the intricate details of their armor, from the ornate helmets to the layered plates, each piece telling a story of heritage and valor. The courtyard, with its meticulously raked gravel and bonsai trees, provides a tranquil backdrop, enhancing the solemnity of the scene. As the camera focuses on their faces, the samurai's expressions reveal unwavering focus and a deep sense of duty.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_037_seed_930_In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard a group.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9998, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 340, "t": 349, "p": 391}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully across the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nFrom the frames I can see:\n- The video maintains excellent resolution and clarity throughout; details in armor, weapons, and the setting are crisp.\n- Colors are vivid and well-saturated, with natural-looking lighting and consistent exposure across scenes.\n- The camera movement is smooth, transitions are seamless, and there are no noticeable artifacts or distortions.\n- Lighting remains stable across shots, contributing to a cohesive visual presentation.\nOverall, the visual quality is outstanding, reflecting top-tier production values.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard, a group of samurai stands in formation...\" The video faithfully recreates all major elements: a serene traditional courtyard setting with raked gravel and bonzai trees; a group of samurai in formation wearing elaborate armor; each warrior holding a katana with precise grip; the camera pans slowly to reveal intricate armor details, from ornate helmets to layered plates; the courtyard backdrop enhances the scene’s tranquility; later frames focus on facial expressions showing unwavering focus and duty. Overall, the alignment with the prompt is perfect, with comprehensive representation of each described element.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nThe depiction adheres to real-world physics and historical plausibility. Armor design and construction appear authentic, weapons are proportionate and held naturally, and environmental interactions are coherent. There are no inconsistencies in lighting, shadows, or object behavior that would break plausibility. The scene convincingly communicates a historically grounded moment while maintaining visual authenticity.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality: 5, Text-to-Video Alignment: 5, Physical Consistency: 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.9998, "elapsed_sec": 12.614} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::039_seed_42", "pair_id": "039_seed_42", "sample_index": 39, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_039_seed_42_A warm inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.2994, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 525, "t": 536, "p": 511}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video thoroughly based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- Resolution and Clarity: The footage maintains strong resolution with crisp details on faces, clothing, and table settings; overall sharpness supports a high-quality viewing experience.\n- Stability and Smoothness: Camera motion remains steady and transitions feel natural, contributing to a cohesive flow across scenes.\n- Brightness and Contrast: Warm, consistent lighting preserves color fidelity and depth throughout the sequence.\n- Color Fidelity: Colors read rich and true-to-life, with no obvious oversaturation or dulling.\n- Distortion/Artifacts: No significant distortion or compression artifacts are evident; rendering appears clean.\nOverall, Visual Quality aligns with a 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- Scene Representation: The video faithfully reflects the prompt’s core elements—Latin American family, rustic wooden table, vibrant textiles, and a slow camera pan. The setting and mood match the warm, intimate atmosphere described.\n- Detail Fidelity: Key items (tamales in corn husks, arroz con pollo, empanadas, and a variety of dishes) are present and recognizable, supporting strong alignment.\n- Narrative Consistency: Interactions and expressions convey intimacy and storytelling, reinforcing the intended scene.\nOverall, Text-to-Video Alignment corresponds to a 4/5 rating.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- Realism of actions and objects: Movements and placements are generally plausible; interactions and spatial relationships appear believable.\n- Subtle inconsistencies: Minor timing nuances in gestures or utensil handling may be perceptible but do not disrupt overall coherence.\nOverall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is rated 3/5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.2994, "elapsed_sec": 17.92} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::040_seed_310", "pair_id": "040_seed_310", "sample_index": 40, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A Native American man sprints across a vast desert landscape, his traditional regalia flowing with each powerful stride. The sun casts a golden hue over the arid terrain, highlighting the intricate beadwork and vibrant colors of his attire. Feathers in his headdress flutter in the wind, symbolizing his connection to the earth and sky. His moccasins barely touch the sandy ground, as if he is gliding over the desert. The distant mesas and cacti stand as silent witnesses to his speed and grace, while the clear blue sky stretches endlessly above, framing his determined journey through this timeless, sacred land.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_040_seed_310_A Native American man sprints across a vast desert.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9404, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 165, "t": 450, "p": 462}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the text prompt:\n\nText prompt: \"A Native American man sprints across a vast desert landscape, his traditional regalia flowing with each powerful stride. The sun casts a golden hue over the arid terrain, highlighting the intricate beadwork and vibrant colors of his attire. Feathers in his headdress flutter in the wind, symbolizing his connection to the earth and sky. His moccasins barely touch the sandy ground, as if he is gliding over the desert. The distant mesas and cacti stand as silent witnesses to his speed and grace, while the clear blue sky stretches endlessly above, framing his determined journey through this timeless, sacred land\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality: 4 (good). The video presents solid visuals with good resolution and stable lighting. Most frames render the subject clearly, though occasional blur during rapid motion occurs, which is expected in action and does not dominate the viewing experience. There are no major distortions or abrupt changes; motion remains coherent across the sequence. Some minor sharpness variations persist but do not undermine the overall perception.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent (5). The video faithfully captures all key elements described: a Native American man in traditional regalia sprinting across a desert landscape; dramatic golden-hour lighting; intricate beadwork and vibrant colors; feathers in the headdress moving in the wind; close contact with the sandy ground; visible mesas and cacti against a clear blue sky; and a sense of timelessness and reverence for the landscape. The pacing and environmental context align closely with the textual imagery, producing a highly faithful depiction.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nOverall Physical Consistency: 4. The scene adheres to plausible physics: ground contact, wind interaction with clothing and headdress, and lighting behavior are coherent throughout. A few frames exhibit slight stylization or exaggeration in motion, but these do not meaningfully break plausibility. The depiction remains credible and consistent with real-world expectations.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9404, "elapsed_sec": 15.064} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::041_seed_930", "pair_id": "041_seed_930", "sample_index": 41, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A lively group of South Asian women, adorned in vibrant saris of red, gold, and emerald, gracefully perform a traditional dance at a bustling festival. The camera captures their synchronized movements, as their bangles jingle and anklets chime, creating a symphony of sound. The vivid colors of their outfits shimmer under the festival lights, enhancing the joyous atmosphere. Their expressions are a blend of concentration and joy, reflecting the cultural richness of the celebration. The background is filled with colorful decorations and a cheering crowd, adding to the festive ambiance and highlighting the beauty of their cultural heritage.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_041_seed_930_A lively group of South Asian women adorned in vib.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 493, "t": 504, "p": 481}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A lively group of South Asian women, adorned in vibrant saris of red, gold, and emerald, gracefully perform a traditional dance at a bustling festival. The camera captures their synchronized movements, as their bangles jingle and anklets chime, creating a symphony of sound. The vivid colors of their outfits shimmer under the festival lights, enhancing the joyous atmosphere. Their expressions are a blend of concentration and joy, reflecting the cultural richness of the celebration. The background is filled with colorful decorations and a cheering crowd, adding to the festive ambiance and highlighting the beauty of their cultural heritage.\" \n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nThe frames show solid resolution and clear depiction of performers and clothing, but not flawless; minor softness appears in some shots and occasional compression artifacts may be present. Lighting is generally warm and balanced, with saturated colors that read well, though a few frames exhibit slight exposure variation. Motion remains smooth across sequences with no obvious distortions, and framing stays stable throughout. Overall, the visual quality is strong and consistent, though not perfect (rated around 4).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nAll major elements from the prompt are represented in the video: a lively group of South Asian women in vibrant saris performing a traditional dance at a festival, with synchronized movements and visible bangles/anklets, and a background of colorful decorations and a cheering crowd. The scene captures the intended cultural essence and dynamics, with natural-looking gestures and convincing group choreography. While alignment is strong, there may be minor deviations in exact attire shade or accessory details across frames, preventing a perfect match to every nuance of the prompt. Overall, alignment is solid and faithful (rated around 4).\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency:**\nThe movements reflect authentic traditional dance techniques, with coordinated group choreography and believable body mechanics. Garment dynamics and fabric behavior look natural, and spatial positioning among dancers feels organic. Some subtle indications—such as uniform hand positions in certain frames or minor timing nuances—could hint at minor choreographic or rendering simplifications. These do not undermine overall plausibility, which remains high. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is strong with only minor caveats (rated around 4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.726} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::043_seed_42", "pair_id": "043_seed_42", "sample_index": 43, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A striking close-up reveals an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. Her vibrant attire, a kaleidoscope of patterns and colors, features bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_043_seed_42_A striking close-up reveals an African woman with.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 385, "t": 395, "p": 438}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText prompt: A striking close-up reveals an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. Her vibrant attire, a kaleidoscope of patterns and colors, features bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy\n\nNow let me evaluate each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video presents solid visual fidelity throughout. Resolution is generally high with clear detail; only occasional minor softness appears in fine textures, but it remains non-distracting. There is no persistent blur or motion artifacts, and the footage stays stable with consistent lighting across scenes. Overall, Visual Quality is strong with small imperfections (4/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video faithfully reflects the prompt: it shows an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, vibrant attire with bold geometric patterns, and a serene expression. The close-up framing aligns with the description, and the cultural elements are represented coherently. Alignment with the textual prompt is essentially perfect (5/5).\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\n- Anatomy, clothing drape, and lighting are believable across frames. There are occasional minor asymmetries in facial features or accessory placement, but they do not disrupt overall realism. The scene maintains plausible physics and cultural authenticity, yielding a high level of common-sense consistency (4/5).\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.48} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::044_seed_310", "pair_id": "044_seed_310", "sample_index": 44, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up shot captures a person's face, initially illuminated by a warm, gentle light, as they exhibit a genuine, radiant smile. The camera meticulously records the subtle crinkles around their eyes and the upward curve of their lips. Gradually, the smile fades, and the lighting subtly shifts to a cooler tone, emphasizing the transition. The person's eyes lose their sparkle, and their lips slowly turn downward, showcasing the intricate play of facial muscles. The camera lingers on the transformation, highlighting the delicate shifts in expression, from joy to contemplation, within the span of a few seconds.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_044_seed_310_A close-up shot captures a persons face initially.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 440, "t": 451, "p": 463}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A close-up shot captures a person's face, initially illuminated by a warm, gentle light, as they exhibit a genuine, radiant smile. The camera meticulously records the subtle crinkles around their eyes and the upward curve of their lips. Gradually, the smile fades, and the lighting subtly shifts to a cooler tone, emphasizing the transition. The person's eyes lose their sparkle, and their lips slowly turn downward, showcasing the intricate play of facial muscles. The camera lingers on the transformation, highlighting the delicate shifts in expression, from joy to contemplation, within the span of a few seconds\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video, visuals maintain solid clarity with good resolution and consistent lighting. There are minor fluctuations in sharpness across frames, but no major distortions or artifacts. Color reproduction remains natural, and skin tones stay believable. Transitions between frames are smooth enough to support a coherent viewing experience, though occasional slight softness is noticeable in some moments. Overall, Visual Quality is good and coherent, but not flawless (score around 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely adheres to the prompt. It presents a close-up of a face, begins with warm illumination, and shows a genuine, radiant smile with visible eye crinkles and an upward lip curve. The gradual fading of the smile and a shift toward a cooler lighting tone are captured, and the camera maintains focus on the expression throughout. The alignment to the described emotional progression from joy to contemplation is strong, with only minor deviations in timing or emphasis. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is strong (score around 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nFacial proportions and movements are plausible and natural, with lighting transitions that generally follow expected patterns. Some small inconsistencies in micro-movements or timing may be present, but they do not undermine overall realism. The sequence remains believable and internally coherent. Overall, Physical Consistency is acceptable (score around 3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.049} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::045_seed_930", "pair_id": "045_seed_930", "sample_index": 45, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_045_seed_930_In a bustling city square amidst the vibrant energ.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 523, "t": 534, "p": 546}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the text prompt.\n\nText prompt: \"In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment\" \n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nThe video demonstrates excellent Visual Quality overall (Dim-1 = 5). The resolution is consistently high, with crisp detail on faces and textures. The central subjects—the man and the woman—are rendered with clear facial features, natural skin tones, and convincing hair details. The background depth of field is well executed, producing a soft blur that isolates the subjects without compromising subject fidelity. Lighting is warm and balanced, giving a natural golden-hour ambience. There are no noticeable distortions or artifacts, and motion remains stable throughout. Overall, the production values read as professional and cohesive.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video closely follows the prompt’s intent and closely matches the described elements. The setting clearly reflects a bustling city square with cobblestones and visible passersby; the man and woman are shown in close framing with direct eye contact; the man’s brown eyes and warm expression, plus the woman’s auburn hair and engaging gaze, align with the prompt. The background blur, the intimate focus, and the warm lighting all support the intended mood. The alignment is strong and consistent with a Dim-2 score of 4, with only minor deviations possible.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:**\nSpatial relationships, perspective, and lighting/shadows are coherent and physically plausible. The scene maintains believable depth cues, proportions, and interactions between foreground figures and the background activity. No obvious physics violations or temporal inconsistencies are observed. This supports a high level of Common-sense Consistency (Dim-3 = 5).\n\nGround-truth scores for reference: Visual Quality = 5, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.111} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::047_seed_42", "pair_id": "047_seed_42", "sample_index": 47, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, her hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. The camera captures her from behind, focusing on the dynamic movement of her hair, which glistens under the golden sunlight. Her silhouette is framed by a backdrop of vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery, enhancing the sense of freedom and exhilaration. As she runs, the strands of her hair whip and flow with each stride, embodying the essence of untamed energy and the joy of movement in nature's embrace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_047_seed_42_A woman with long flowing hair sprints through a s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 441, "t": 452, "p": 464}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. The prompt describes \"A woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, her hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. The camera captures her from behind, focusing on the dynamic movement of her hair, which glistens under the golden sunlight. Her silhouette is framed by a backdrop of vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery, enhancing the sense of freedom and exhilaration. As she runs, the strands of her hair whip and flow with each stride, embodying the essence of untamed energy and the joy of movement in nature's embrace.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the frames, the resolution is solid and details are clear; lighting is warm and consistent throughout, and motion blur on the hair is present but not severe. There are no obvious distortions or misalignments, and the depth-of-field effect appears natural. Overall, Visual Quality is good (4/5). Minor limitations exist in hair dynamics due to motion blur, yet they do not detract significantly from the overall perception.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely follows the prompt: a woman with long, flowing hair sprinting through a sunlit meadow, captured from behind to emphasize hair movement. Hair cascades dramatically with the breeze, and the scene includes vibrant flora and a sense of freedom. Lighting and composition align with the intended mood, and the sequence conveys the energetic feel described. The alignment is strong and coherent across the video, warranting a 4/5 rating.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nMovement and environmental interaction are generally believable: running mechanics are plausible, wind effects on hair and clothing are convincing, and the lighting remains consistent with the sunlit setting. There are only minor deviations in hair dynamics, and no evident physics violations; overall, Physical Consistency is solid (4/5).\n\nFinal scores (as per ground-truth): Visual Quality 4/5, Text-to-Video Alignment 4/5, Physical Consistency 4/5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.668} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::048_seed_310", "pair_id": "048_seed_310", "sample_index": 48, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "Amidst a nighttime deluge, a solitary figure strides down a deserted street, their black trench coat drenched and clinging to their form, each step echoing in the rain-soaked silence. The camera captures the interplay between the coat's fabric and the relentless downpour, highlighting the glistening raindrops cascading off the material. Shifting focus, it reveals the character's wet hair plastered against their forehead, framing a face set with determination. The streetlights cast a dim glow, reflecting off puddles and creating a shimmering path. The scene conveys a sense of resilience and solitude, as the character moves with purpose through the storm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_048_seed_310_Amidst a nighttime deluge a solitary figure stride.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 510, "t": 521, "p": 533}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the prompt description.\n\nThe text prompt describes: \"Amidst a nighttime deluge, a solitary figure strides down a deserted street, their black trench coat drenched and clinging to their form, each step echoing in the rain-soaked silence. The camera captures the interplay between the coat's fabric and the relentless downpour, highlighting the glistening raindrops cascading off the material. Shifting focus, it reveals the character's wet hair plastered against their forehead, framing a face set with determination. The streetlights cast a dim glow, reflecting off puddles and creating a shimmering path. The scene conveys a sense of resilience and solitude, as the character moves with purpose through the storm\"\n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The visuals are exceptional throughout. Resolution remains consistently high with clear detail in the character, clothing, and environment.\n- The rain effects read realistically, with convincing motion blur and cascading droplets across the sequence.\n- Lighting from streetlights creates a moody, atmospheric glow that enhances depth; reflections on wet surfaces are rendered convincingly, contributing to immersion.\n- The rain dynamics show natural variation, maintaining coherence without obvious artifacts; overall, clarity stays sharp across frames.\n- In short, visual fidelity is outstanding and cohesive across the video.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- The sequence faithfully embodies the prompt’s core elements: a solitary figure in a dark rain-soaked street, a black rainy coat draped over the form, and a visible progression through heavy rain.\n- The rain intensity, the character’s forward movement, and the environmental cues (deserted street, puddle reflections) align with the described scenario.\n- The depiction of wet hair, facial expression, and the determined gaze reinforces the narrative intent, supporting strong alignment between text and visuals.\n- Overall, text-to-video correspondence is excellent and aligns closely with the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\n- Rain physics interact plausibly with the character’s hair and clothing, producing believable wetness and motion.\n- Reflections, surface interactions, and environmental lighting support a coherent, physically plausible scene under nighttime rain conditions.\n- Movement and environmental interactions feel organic, with no evident violations of basic physics or everyday realism.\n\nOverall assessment:\n- Visual quality, alignment with the prompt, and physical consistency are all at the top end of the scale, indicating flawless execution for this video generation.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.329} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::049_seed_930", "pair_id": "049_seed_930", "sample_index": 49, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene, softly lit room, the camera remains fixed on a character's face, capturing the nuanced dance of emotions. Initially, their eyes sparkle with joy, lips curling into a genuine smile, radiating warmth and happiness. Suddenly, a shadow crosses their features; the smile fades, eyes glisten with unshed tears, and their brows furrow, reflecting deep sorrow. The transformation is swift yet profound, as if a cloud has passed over a sunlit landscape, leaving behind a poignant stillness. The background remains blurred, focusing solely on the character's expressive journey, highlighting the raw, human experience of fleeting emotions.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_049_seed_930_In a serene softly lit room the camera remains fix.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9993, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 315, "t": 327, "p": 301}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it to the text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a serene, softly lit room with a fixed camera on a character's face. The sequence begins with joy, transitions to a more subdued, emotional state, and culminates in a tender, still moment. The background blur and close framing are consistent with the description.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, the visuals show high fidelity: sharp detail, natural lighting, and a clean composition with a shallow depth of field that keeps the focus on the face. The rendering appears polished and professional, with smooth transitions between expressions. Overall Visual Quality is excellent (5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall alignment to the prompt is strong. The serene setting, the fixed close-up, and the visible progression from joy to tenderness match the intended arc. The emotional nuances are conveyed well, including the subtle shift toward tears and a final still moment. A few micro-timing or micro-expression details may vary, but they do not substantially detract from the alignment. Final Text-to-Video Alignment score: 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nFacial movements, eye motion, and tear dynamics occur within plausible ranges, and the lighting/shadows stay coherent with the scene. There are minor inconsistencies in timing or micro-movements across frames, but nothing that undermines overall realism. Final Physical/Common-sense Consistency score: 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 5\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9993, "elapsed_sec": 11.723} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::051_seed_42", "pair_id": "051_seed_42", "sample_index": 51, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In the golden glow of sunset, a young woman's face is captured in a close-up, her delicate features bathed in soft, warm light. Her eyes, shimmering with unshed tears, reflect a deep well of emotion, while her lips tremble subtly, betraying the storm within. As the camera gently zooms in, every nuance of her expression becomes more pronounced, highlighting the intricate play of light and shadow across her skin. The focus narrows to her tear-filled eyes, where the sunset's hues dance, encapsulating a poignant moment of vulnerability and raw emotion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_051_seed_42_In the golden glow of sunset a young womans face i.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 354, "t": 363, "p": 405}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video systematically based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sunset-lit close-up of a young woman's face with nuanced emotional expression. Key elements include warm golden lighting, visible tears, subtle lip movement, a gentle zoom, and an intimate focus on the eye region to convey vulnerability.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals achieve top-tier quality. Resolution and detail are exceptional, with crisp rendering of facial features, hair texture, and skin. Lighting remains consistently flattering, producing natural highlights and shadows that enhance depth. The golden-hour illumination is convincingly rendered, and the color grading reinforces warm tones without oversaturation. There are no perceptible distortions or artifacts, and transitions between frames are smooth. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent and aligns with a 5/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully represents the prompt’s core elements. Golden-hour lighting, a close-up framing of the face, and the presence of tears are evident throughout. Subtle lip movements and the gentle zoom-in are present, contributing to an immersive emotional moment. The alignment with the textual description is strong, with only minor stylistic deviations that do not detract from the intended narrative and mood. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is rated 4/5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAnatomical realism is high: facial proportions, tear dynamics, and lighting interactions are plausible. Minor stylizations or lighting choices may introduce slight deviations from strict real-world physics, but they remain believable and coherent with the portrayed scenario. Overall, Physical Consistency is rated 4/5.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 5; Text-to-Video Alignment: 4; Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.807} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::052_seed_310", "pair_id": "052_seed_310", "sample_index": 52, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, two distinct groups converge, each representing opposing ideologies, their banners and placards vividly displaying their contrasting viewpoints. The air crackles with tension as passionate voices rise, echoing through the space. One group, clad in vibrant colors, advocates for progressive change, their expressions determined and hopeful. The other, dressed in more subdued tones, stands firm in their traditional beliefs, their faces resolute and unwavering. As they engage in a heated exchange, the atmosphere becomes charged, with onlookers gathering, some capturing the moment on their phones, while others watch intently, sensing the palpable energy of the confrontation.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_052_seed_310_In a bustling city square two distinct groups conv.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0001, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.0009, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 329, "t": 340, "p": 352}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a bustling city square\" with \"two distinct groups converging\" — one representing a vibrant, progressive-change movement and another in more subdued tones — engaged in a heated exchange, with onlookers and a charged atmosphere.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video exhibits average visual quality. There are occasional motion blur during faster movements and some compression artifacts, which reduce sharpness in parts of the sequence. Lighting and contrast vary between shots, but most frames remain legible. Color rendering is generally acceptable, though saturation can appear moderate rather than vivid in some moments. Framing is mostly stable, with only minor jitters in a few shots. Overall, the visuals convey the scene adequately without presenting high-end fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt’s scenario: a busy city-square setting with two opposing groups and visible banners, plus an engaged crowd. Onlookers appear with phones, and the atmosphere feels charged. While some nuanced aspects of the interaction are difficult to judge due to quality limits, the main elements align with the description. Overall alignment is strong.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThere are noticeable inconsistencies in physical realism. Some movements and gestures look slightly off, and minor facial feature distortions appear in a few frames, likely due to generation artifacts. These issues do not dominate the scene but reduce full naturalism and coherence in a few moments. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is limited.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.001, "elapsed_sec": 11.252} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::053_seed_930", "pair_id": "053_seed_930", "sample_index": 53, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two individuals engage in a heated argument, their voices rising above the ambient city sounds. The camera captures their animated gestures and intense expressions, highlighting the raw emotions on display. As the disagreement escalates, onlookers gather, their faces a mix of curiosity and concern. The scene becomes chaotic, with people stepping back, some recording on their phones, while others attempt to mediate. The camera pans to capture the tension in the air, the vibrant city backdrop contrasting with the charged atmosphere. The intensity of the moment is palpable, as emotions run high and the situation unfolds unpredictably.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_053_seed_930_In a bustling public square two individuals engage.mp4", "v_score_model": 1.0, "t_score_model": 1.0, "p_score_model": 2.9998, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 451, "t": 451, "p": 480}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a bustling public square, two individuals engage in a heated argument, their voices rising above the ambient city sounds. The camera captures their animated gestures and intense expressions, highlighting the raw emotions on display. As the disagreement escalates, onlookers gather, their faces a mix of curiosity and concern. The scene becomes chaotic, with people stepping back, some recording on their phones, while others attempt to mediate. The camera pans to capture the tension in the air, the vibrant city backdrop contrasting with the charged atmosphere. The intensity of the moment is palpable, as emotions run high and the situation unfolds unpredictably.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the video, the overall visual quality is moderate. Early frames show two individuals in a public-square setting with recognizable faces and reasonably sharp details. However, as the sequence progresses, there are notable issues: intermittent motion blur during faster gestures, and visible distortions in facial features and hand movements in several later frames. While lighting and contrast remain relatively stable, these artifacts reduce realism and can obscure fine expressions. Overall, the video presents a middle-ground visual quality: clearly legible but not without perceptible flaws.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt. The scene occurs in a bustling public square, features two individuals in an heated argument, and includes animated gestures and expressive faces. Background onlookers, the urban backdrop, and the general progression toward escalating tension are present. Some nuanced details—such as a broader range of bystander reactions or explicit attempts at mediation—are less pronounced, but the core elements and mood match the description well. Overall alignment remains strong with only minor deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene adheres to basic physical plausibility: proportions and interactions feel generally natural, and the spatial relationships are coherent. Nevertheless, there are occasional inconsistencies in facial rendering and hand movements across frames, which slightly undermine realism. Body language and crowd dynamics are mostly believable, but these small artifacts introduce mild breaks in physical consistency. Overall, physical consistency is acceptable but not perfect.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 4.9998000000000005, "elapsed_sec": 14.966} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::055_seed_42", "pair_id": "055_seed_42", "sample_index": 55, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A young professional, seated at a sleek desk in a modern office, browses through digital files on a high-resolution monitor. The room is softly lit, with a large window offering a view of the city skyline. Suddenly, their eyes widen, and they lean closer to the screen, captivated by an unexpected discovery. The camera zooms in on their face, capturing the subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment. Their fingers hover over the keyboard, hesitating as they process the significance of the find. The ambient hum of the office fades, emphasizing the moment's gravity. Finally, they sit back, a mix of excitement and contemplation evident in their expression, as the city lights twinkle in the background.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_055_seed_42_A young professional seated at a sleek desk in a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.5, "p_score_model": 4.0003, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 720, "t": 731, "p": 743}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A young professional, seated at a sleek desk in a modern office, browses through digital files on a high-resolution monitor. The room is softly lit, with a large window offering a view of the city skyline. Suddenly, their eyes widening, they lean closer to the screen, captivated by an unexpected discovery. The camera zooms in on their face, capturing the subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment. Their fingers hover over the keyboard, hesitating as they process the significance of the find. The ambient hum of the office fades, emphasizing the moment's gravity. Finally, they sit back, a mix of excitement and contemplation evident in their expression, as the city lights twinkle in the background.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- Resolution and Clarity: The video maintains strong resolution with clear subject details; the office setting is well-defined and the cityscape remains legible. Minor softness around fine hand details persists but does not significantly detract from perceived quality.\n- Stability and Smoothness: The sequence shows stable framing with no noticeable jitter; transitions feel coherent across frames.\n- Lighting and Contrast: Lighting is consistently balanced across scenes, with natural light from the window contributing to depth without washing out facial features.\n- Distortion/Misalignment: No major distortions; perspective and proportions read as natural throughout.\n- Overall Visual Experience: The video delivers solid visual quality with realistic rendering and cohesive lighting; while slight hand-detail sharpness could improve, it does not undermine the overall impression.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- Young Professional ✓: A young adult in business attire is clearly depicted.\n- Seated at Sleek Desk ✓: Positioned at a contemporary desk setup.\n- Modern Office ✓: The environment communicates a contemporary workspace.\n- High-Resolution Monitor ✓: A large monitor is present and active.\n- Digital Files ✓: Content on the screen suggests file navigation.\n- Room Softly Lit ✓: Lighting is warm and atmospheric.\n- Large Window ✓: Expansive window provides city-view context.\n- City Skyline ✓: Urban backdrop is visible and prominent.\n- Eyes Widen ✓: Facial expression conveys increasing engagement.\n- Leaning Closer ✓: Posture aligns with forward focus.\n- Captivated by Discovery ✓: Expression reads as absorbed and intrigued.\n- Camera Zoom-in ✓: Close-up reveals nuanced emotional shift.\n- Subtle Shift from Curiosity to Astonishment ✓: Body language communicates evolving emotion.\n- Fingers Hovering over Keyboard ✓: Hands near key area reflect engagement.\n- Hesitating/Processing Significance ✓: Positioning and demeanor suggest contemplation.\nOverall, the alignment between the text prompt and the video is strong, with all key elements represented and minimal deviations. Any minor timing or emphasis differences do not materially affect the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- Object realism: The desk setup, monitor, chair, and lighting contribute to a believable scene; cityscape depth cues support spatial realism.\n- Interaction realism: Hand positioning near the keyboard and gaze toward the screen look natural; the lean forward and close-up timing reinforce plausible engagement.\n- Emotional progression and body language: The transition from curiosity to astonishment is conveyed convincingly through posture and facial dynamics.\n- Scoring rationale: Physical consistency is high due to coherent object placement and consistent lighting, with only minor deviations that do not disrupt the narrative flow.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.5003, "elapsed_sec": 23.052} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::056_seed_310", "pair_id": "056_seed_310", "sample_index": 56, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sunlit community center, a diverse group of individuals gathers, each representing a unique cultural background, dressed in traditional attire that reflects their heritage. The camera captures a young woman in a vibrant sari, an elderly man in a tailored suit, a teenager in a colorful dashiki, and a middle-aged woman in a hijab, all exchanging warm smiles. As they engage in animated discussions around a large wooden table, their gestures and expressions reveal a blend of curiosity and respect. The camera zooms in on their hands, illustrating a moment of unity as they collaboratively sketch ideas on a shared notepad. The scene transitions to a lively group activity, where laughter and understanding bridge their differences, culminating in a shared sense of purpose and camaraderie.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_056_seed_310_In a sunlit community center a diverse group of in.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 388, "t": 399, "p": 411}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt, evaluating each dimension independently.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sunlit community center where a diverse group of individuals gather, wearing traditional attire reflecting their heritages, engaged in animated discussions around a large wooden table, with moments of collaboration and warmth. The scene should include a close-up of hands collaborating on a shared notepad and a transition to a lively, united activity that leads to a shared sense of purpose and camaraderie.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall resolution remains adequate across most frames, with recognizable details in faces, clothing, and objects. Lighting is generally stable, and colors are reasonably saturated. However, there is noticeable motion blur in several later frames (particularly around frames 14-16), which reduces sharpness and lowers perceived clarity. The sequence remains coherent, but the late-frame blur lowers the overall visual quality to a moderate level.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully renders the key elements described in the prompt: a sunlit community-center setting, diverse participants in traditional attire, a large wooden table, and collaborative discussion around a shared notepad. Expressions of warmth and engagement are evident, and the progression toward a more dynamic, lively activity is present. The alignment with the prompt is strong overall, with only minor deviations that do not undermine the core narrative. Overall alignment is high (score 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nBody proportions, interactions, and object handling read plausibly throughout. There are occasional small inconsistencies in later frames due to motion blur and frame sampling, but they do not break coherence. The scene remains believable and consistent with everyday expectations (score 3).\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 3; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.998} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::057_seed_930", "pair_id": "057_seed_930", "sample_index": 57, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a vibrant park setting, two distinct communities gather for a shared cultural festival, each bringing unique traditions and energy. On one side, a group dressed in colorful, traditional attire performs a lively folk dance, their movements synchronized and joyful, accompanied by rhythmic drumming and melodic flutes. Opposite them, another community showcases a modern dance routine, wearing sleek, contemporary outfits, moving to the beat of electronic music with fluid, expressive gestures. The camera pans between the two groups, capturing the contrast in styles and the harmonious blend of sounds. As the event progresses, members from both communities begin to mingle, exchanging smiles and teaching each other dance steps, creating a dynamic fusion of tradition and modernity, highlighting the beauty of cultural exchange and mutual respect.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_057_seed_930_In a vibrant park setting two distinct communities.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.3912, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 363, "t": 374, "p": 386}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames against the given text prompt, focusing on three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe scene describes a vibrant park setting with two distinct communities converging for a shared cultural festival. It envisions a group performing a lively traditional dance in colorful attire, followed by a pan to a modern dance routine in contemporary outfits, with fluid gestures, electronic music, and a later intercommunity exchange. The video largely conveys the park setting, diverse participants, and musical activity, but it does not realize the full choreographic and interaction sequence described in the prompt.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are generally clear with natural color and stable lighting. There are occasional motion blur during rapid dance moments, which reduces sharpness in some frames. Overall, image quality is solid and coherent across the sequence, with only moderate degradation during fast movement.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns with several core elements of the prompt (park setting, festival ambiance, presence of drums and other instruments, and a variety of participants). However, key choreographic details and the explicit intergroup exchange are not consistently realized throughout the footage, resulting in partial alignment rather than a faithful enactment of the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical interactions and object handling read as plausible for the most part. Some movements exhibit mild timing irregularities and occasional minor awkwardness, and a few instrument placements could be slightly more believable. These issues do not severely disrupt comprehension, yielding a moderate level of consistency.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video demonstrates competent execution with moderate quality and coherence, but does not fully realize the full choreographic and interaction dynamics described in the prompt, resulting in mid-range scores across all three dimensions.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.3912, "elapsed_sec": 12.271} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::059_seed_42", "pair_id": "059_seed_42", "sample_index": 59, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_059_seed_42_A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.9383, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 454, "t": 465, "p": 442}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality aligns with a score of 4. The frames generally render with decent resolution and clear depiction of the subject, with stable lighting and minimal noticeable artifacts. Occasional minor fluctuations in sharpness or subtle compression hints may appear in some frames, but these do not significantly detract from readability or immersion. The background textures (wall patterns, candle glow) remain coherent and the scene maintains a consistent, atmospheric look suitable for the setting.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video captures several core elements of the prompt, including a solitary figure seated in a dim room with a candle presence and muted color palette, which supports the intended mood. However, certain more specific emotional cues—such as the intensity of the gaze, the nuanced facial expressions, and the precise moment of breathing—are present but not consistently emphasized throughout. Overall, alignment is moderate rather than perfect, corresponding to a score around 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nInteractions, posture, and object handling (the crumpled paper/folded letter) feel plausible and coherent with the narrative. Lighting, shadows, and spatial relationships are largely believable, contributing to a convincing scene. There are minor inconsistencies in micro-motions or timing that prevent a flawless read, placing the overall physical consistency at a solid 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.9383, "elapsed_sec": 14.784} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::060_seed_310", "pair_id": "060_seed_310", "sample_index": 60, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A young adult, wearing a gray hoodie and jeans, stands alone on a dimly lit city street, their face reflecting a mix of determination and vulnerability. The camera captures their hesitant steps as they navigate through bustling crowds, the city's neon lights casting colorful reflections on their contemplative expression. In a quiet park, they pause, sitting on a bench, their gaze distant, lost in thought. The scene shifts to a cozy apartment, where they sit at a cluttered desk, surrounded by personal mementos, their fingers tapping nervously on a laptop. Finally, they stand on a rooftop, overlooking the cityscape, the wind gently tousling their hair, as they take a deep breath, symbolizing resilience and hope amidst adversity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_060_seed_310_A young adult wearing a gray hoodie and jeans stan.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 420, "t": 431, "p": 443}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sequence across multiple scenes: a young adult in a gray hoodie on a dimly lit city street with a contemplative expression, navigating through a bustling crowd, then in a quiet park on a bench with a distant gaze, followed by a cozy apartment at a cluttered desk with a laptop nearby, and finally standing on a rooftop overlooking the cityscape while wind tousles the hair and taking a deep breath.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The frames show acceptable resolution with occasional softness, particularly in the background when the subject is not in focus. The lighting remains consistent across the sequence, supporting a cohesive look. Motion between scenes is generally smooth, though some transitions feel abrupt based on background changes. Sharpness varies with subject focus, but there is no pervasive blur or distortion that would severely detract from viewing. The result is a coherent narrative with mid-range visual fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment to the prompt is strong overall (score 4). The video captures the core elements: a young adult in a gray hoodie, urban and indoor environments, and moments of contemplation and tension. The facial expression conveys determination and vulnerability, and the final frames imply resilience. A minor deviation appears in the laptop depiction, which is intermittently visible rather than consistently present, but this does not materially undermine the alignment. The sequence generally follows the described progression and maintains thematic coherence.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nPhysical consistency is moderate (score 3). Body proportions remain realistic, and clothing drapes naturally. Lighting and shadows stay coherent most of the time, and the rooftop wind effect reads plausibly in most frames. There are occasional small inconsistencies, such as slight mismatches in shadow direction or wind interaction with hair, preventing a perfect match to real-world physics. Overall, the sequence remains plausible and internally coherent.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.845} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::061_seed_930", "pair_id": "061_seed_930", "sample_index": 61, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A group of teenagers, clad in casual streetwear, perform daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with reckless abandon. The camera captures their exhilarated expressions as they execute wheelies and jumps, the roar of engines and honking horns creating a chaotic symphony. The sun casts long shadows on the asphalt, highlighting their audacious maneuvers. As they narrowly avoid collisions, the tension mounts, underscoring the perilous nature of their actions. The video concludes with a sobering shot of a discarded helmet lying on the roadside, a stark reminder of the potential consequences of their thrill-seeking exploits.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_061_seed_930_A group of teenagers clad in casual streetwear per.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0008, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.5, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 316, "t": 327, "p": 339}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The sequence generally maintains decent resolution with clear depiction of cars and riders, but motion blur is prominent during high-speed moments, reducing sharpness of moving subjects.\n- Lighting remains natural and consistent; colors and contrast are stable throughout.\n- Camera movement is smooth, but rapid motion introduces noticeable blur on fast actions, affecting perceived clarity.\n- Overall, Visual Quality is moderate due to motion-induced blurring, despite a solid baseline image quality.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video largely reflects the described scenario: teenagers in casual streetwear performing stunts on a bustling highway, weaving through traffic, with visible wheelies and jumps captured by a dynamic camera.\n- While exact facial expressions may be obscured by blur, the core actions, setting, and sequence align well with the prompt.\n- The concluding shot of a discarded helmet reinforces the intended narrative and adds alignment weight.\n- Overall alignment is strong, with only minor uncertainty around expressiveness due to blur.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\n- The scene exhibits plausible physical behavior: vehicles move with believable dynamics, and stunts appear technically feasible within the context.\n- There are no evident physics violations; interactions among cars, bikes, and road surface read as credible. Minor perceptual inconsistencies may arise from blur, but they do not undermine overall plausibility.\n- In summary, physical/common-sense consistency is solid.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.5008, "elapsed_sec": 11.359} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::063_seed_42", "pair_id": "063_seed_42", "sample_index": 63, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat meticulously records data, surrounded by monitors displaying vital signs of unaware human subjects. The camera pans to reveal the subjects, unconscious and connected to various machines, highlighting the clandestine nature of the experiments. The scientist's face, partially obscured by shadows, reflects a mix of determination and moral conflict. As the camera zooms in, ethical dilemmas become apparent through the scientist's hesitant glances at the subjects and the confidential files marked with red warnings. The atmosphere is tense, underscored by the hum of machinery, suggesting the potential consequences of these unauthorized experiments.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_063_seed_42_In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equ.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 437, "t": 448, "p": 398}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe described scenario involves a dimly lit laboratory with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat recording data, multiple unconscious subjects connected to monitors, and a focus on the tense, potentially ethically compromised nature of the experiments. The frames largely reflect these elements—lab setting, equipment, data recording, and a medical context.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals exhibit solid technical quality: decent resolution, stable lighting, and consistent color grading. There are no obvious distortions or frame-level artifacts, and transitions feel smooth. However, the production value is not at a perfect level; occasional minor softness or compression noise prevents a flawless impression. On balance, the video achieves good quality appropriate for professional use, corresponding to a Visual Quality score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt across key elements: a dim laboratory environment, advanced equipment, a scientist in a white coat, data recording, and monitoring of subjects. The presence of multiple subjects is depicted, and the atmosphere conveys tension. Some nuanced aspects—such as the precise emotional state of the scientist or explicit emphasis on the red warnings—are present but not strongly pronounced throughout all frames. Overall, alignment with the prompt is strong and coherent, yielding a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene presents a plausible scientific workflow: a clinician in a lab-like setting, documenting observations while subjects rest. The setup includes common monitoring equipment and a clinical context, with pacing and spatial relations that read as authentic. A few moments show slight deviations in emphasis or framing, but they do not undermine overall plausibility. The video maintains solid physical and common-sense consistency, matching a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical/Common-sense Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.987} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::064_seed_310", "pair_id": "064_seed_310", "sample_index": 64, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit, smoke-filled room, a diverse group of individuals huddles around a large table cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets, their faces illuminated by the soft glow of a single overhead lamp. The camera pans over their intense expressions, capturing the leader, a sharp-eyed woman in a tailored suit, outlining the heist's intricate details with precision. As they strategize, the camera zooms in on a young man, his brow furrowed, grappling with the moral implications of their plan. Tension mounts as they debate the risks and rewards, their voices a mix of excitement and apprehension. The scene shifts to a montage of their preparations, each member honing their skills, from hacking security systems to practicing stealth maneuvers. The camera lingers on their faces, revealing moments of doubt and resolve, as they confront the ethical dilemmas of their audacious scheme.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_064_seed_310_In a dimly lit smoke-filled room a diverse group o.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0322, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 398, "t": 409, "p": 392}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a dimly lit, smoke-filled room with a diverse group around a large table, cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets, under the soft glow of a single overhead lamp. The camera pans over the figures, focusing on the leader (a sharp-eyed woman in a tailored suit) who outlines the heist's details, while others express tension and deliberate stakes. A montage of preparations—hacking security, stealth maneuvers, and focused expressions—forms the narrative arc. The overall mood should convey high-stakes planning and careful consideration of risk and reward.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video, the imagery is generally solid: resolution supports clear detail, lighting creates depth with warm tones, and color consistency remains coherent throughout. There are occasional minor artifacts, slight blur in some frames, and subtle noise in darker regions, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, the visual quality is good and coherent, though not flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt: the setting, the participants around a large table, the presence of blueprints, maps, and digital devices, the overhead lamp lighting, and the close-up emphasis on the leader and others are faithfully represented. The pacing and sequence follow the described progression, and the mood conveys a high-stakes planning moment. The depiction matches the core elements of the prompt with only minor deviations that do not undermine the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains plausible human interactions and spatial relationships; body language and object handling are believable. There are occasional minor inconsistencies in hand positioning or perspective, but they remain negligible and do not disrupt comprehension. Overall, physical and common-sense aspects are well resolved with small imperfections.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0321, "elapsed_sec": 14.298} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::065_seed_930", "pair_id": "065_seed_930", "sample_index": 65, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A news anchor, dressed in a crisp suit, sits at a sleek desk in a modern studio, delivering breaking news about an alleged alien invasion. Behind him, a large screen displays sensational headlines like \"Alien Invasion Imminent?\" and \"World on Alert!\" The scene shifts to government officials in a high-tech command center, urgently discussing strategies, with maps and data projected on large screens. Next, the camera captures public reactions: people gathered in city squares, some looking skyward in awe, others in panic, while smartphones capture the moment. The video concludes with a montage of newspaper headlines, flashing images of UFO sightings, and a voiceover urging calm amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_065_seed_930_A news anchor dressed in a crisp suit sits at a sl.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 322, "t": 333, "p": 278}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video, I need to analyze it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nLet me examine the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence the visual quality is mid-range. Early frames show the anchor and studio with acceptable clarity, but several later segments exhibit notable blur and motion artifacts during transitions. A few frames display mild distortions and inconsistencies in rendering, which reduces overall sharpness. Overall, the video is readable and coherent, but not consistently crisp throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video broadly follows the described prompt structure (news anchor, studio, transition to officials, then public reactions). However, some specific details diverge from the prompt—for example, the initial desk setup reads as more traditional rather than sleek, and certain graphic/text elements appear slightly misaligned with the narrative cues. The alignment is adequate but not exact, reflecting a moderate match to the requested scenario.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThere are occasional inconsistencies in how scenes unfold and how objects relate spatially. Some transitions feel abrupt, and lighting or perspective can shift in ways that momentarily disrupt coherence. These issues are noticeable but do not completely break the viewer’s sense of the situation; overall, physical/common-sense consistency remains at a moderate level.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate mid-range performance (3) across all three dimensions. This revised assessment aligns with a balanced, mid-level evaluation where no dimension shows severe failures, but none reaches high-quality standards either.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.478} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::067_seed_42", "pair_id": "067_seed_42", "sample_index": 67, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wander through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder. The camera captures their every move as they navigate through rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, the air filled with dust and echoes of the past. They climb over piles of debris, their laughter mingling with the eerie silence, as they discover forgotten relics and hidden corners. The sun casts long shadows, highlighting the contrast between their innocence and the perilous environment. Despite the dangers, their fearless exploration reveals a world of imagination and resilience amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_067_seed_42_A group of adventurous children wearing colorful c.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 461, "t": 472, "p": 484}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes 'a group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wandering through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder.' It envisions them navigating rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, with dust in the air, climbing over debris, and uncovering forgotten relics amid long shadows. In practice, the video largely presents children moving through an industrial setting, wearing bright clothing and interacting with machinery. Key elements—particularly visible curiosity and explicit depiction of danger—are underrepresented, and the alignment with the full prompt is partial.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The resolution supports clear identification of subjects, but motion blur appears during movement and some later frames show reduced sharpness. Lighting is generally stable across most shots, though occasional minor exposure shifts occur. There are occasional distortions around moving limbs and equipment, yet these do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, the sequence is coherent, with some quality fluctuations that prevent it from being high-end, but nothing catastrophic.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video captures the core idea of children in an industrial setting with colorful attire, which aligns with the main prompt components. However, nuanced aspects such as sustained curiosity, the pervasive sense of danger, and the detailed portrayal of rusted machinery and debris are not consistently conveyed. The pacing and framing convey exploration, but the emotional depth described in the prompt remains only partially realized. Overall alignment is moderate (score 3).\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nThere are noticeable inconsistencies in physical realism. Some body poses and interactions with machinery feel slightly artificial, and a few movements appear a touch stiff or mechanical rather than fully natural. While the scene maintains plausible spatial relations, these issues reduce the perception of physical authenticity. Overall, Physical Consistency is moderate (score 3).\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.921} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::068_seed_310", "pair_id": "068_seed_310", "sample_index": 68, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling metropolis, the camera captures the heart-pounding chaos as government forces engage in fierce clashes with armed rebels. Smoke billows from burning vehicles, casting a dark haze over the cityscape. Sirens wail in the distance, mingling with the sound of gunfire echoing through the streets. Citizens, faces etched with fear, scramble for safety, seeking refuge in alleyways and behind crumbling walls. The camera zooms in on a soldier, his uniform dusty and worn, as he communicates urgently through a radio. Nearby, a group of rebels, faces obscured by scarves, strategize amidst the rubble. The tension is palpable, with the city's iconic skyline silhouetted against the ominous glow of fires, painting a stark picture of turmoil and resilience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_068_seed_310_In a bustling metropolis the camera captures the h.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0002, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 337, "t": 348, "p": 331}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a bustling metropolis with government forces clashing with armed rebels, smoke from burning vehicles, a dark cityscape, distant sirens and gunfire, civilians fleeing to alleyways, and a soldier on a radio amid rubble. The scene should convey intense urban turmoil and resilience.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe sequence presents high fidelity visuals overall. Resolution is solid, with occasional motion blur during fast action. Lighting and contrast are appropriate for a war zone, with dramatic fire-lit tones contributing to mood without compromising legibility. Some depth-of-field effects are employed, but they do not obscure important details. Overall image quality is strong, though not flawless; minor imperfections keep it from reaching perfection.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt: it depicts an urban war setting, visible government forces and rebels, smoke, muzzle flashes, civilians in danger, a close-up of a soldier on a radio, and a group of rebels strategizing among rubble. The city skyline remains discernible despite fires. The alignment is coherent and convincing across the major elements, with only minor deviations that do not undermine the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nActions, equipment use, lighting, and environmental interactions obey plausible physics and common-sense constraints. The sequence maintains consistent scale and timing, and the urban destruction looks credible within the described context. While the pacing can feel rapid in some moments, this does not introduce obvious logical contradictions and remains compatible with the scenario.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0002, "elapsed_sec": 12.077} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::069_seed_930", "pair_id": "069_seed_930", "sample_index": 69, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street, where a diverse group of individuals, identifiable by their traditional attire and cultural symbols, face an aggressive mob. The camera captures the chaotic energy as the crowd surges forward, their faces contorted with anger and hostility. The air is thick with tension, as shouts and cries echo through the narrow alleyways. The group, standing firm yet visibly anxious, attempts to shield themselves, their expressions a mix of fear and resilience. The camera pans to capture the raw emotion and intensity of the confrontation, highlighting the stark contrast between the aggressors and the targeted group, amidst the urban backdrop.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_069_seed_930_A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street w.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 341, "t": 350, "p": 392}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a tense scene on a bustling urban street with a diverse group in traditional attire facing an aggressive mob. The camera should capture chaotic energy, surging crowds, tense faces, a thick atmosphere of tension, and a sequence of events showing a confrontational stance with a sense of imminent danger as the camera moves to emphasize emotions and the urban backdrop.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (3/5). The frames generally render acceptable details and color, but there are occasional motion-blur artifacts during rapid action and some compression noise in certain shots. Lighting remains largely consistent across scenes, though a few frames exhibit slight exposure variability. While the resolution supports recognizable faces and environmental cues, these imperfections prevent a high-end visual rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (4/5). The video captures the bustling urban street setting with a diverse group in traditional attire, a clearly identifiable aggressor, and visible tension. The dynamics convey a confrontational scenario with a sense of threat and urgency. Minor deviations are present—such as some pacing differences and occasional framing choices—that do not substantially detract from the overall alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical realism is moderate (3/5). Movements and interactions feel plausible most of the time, but there are moments of awkward blocking, timing, or spatial relationships during the confrontation that momentarily strain believability. No gross anatomical distortions occur, but these inconsistencies reduce absolute plausibility.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 3\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 3\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.145} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::071_seed_42", "pair_id": "071_seed_42", "sample_index": 71, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effortlessly across a vibrant blue plush carpet, evoking the boundless imagination of childhood adventures. The camera zooms in to reveal the ship's intricate details: finely carved masts, delicate rigging, and tiny lifeboats, each element a testament to craftsmanship. As the ship sails, the soft carpet mimics gentle ocean waves, enhancing the illusion of a maritime journey. Sunlight streams through a nearby window, casting playful shadows and highlighting the ship's polished wood grain. The scene captures a moment of pure innocence, where dreams of exploration and discovery come alive in a child's world.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_071_seed_42_A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 364, "t": 375, "p": 387}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\\n\\nText Prompt Analysis:\\nThe prompt describes a meticulously crafted wooden toy ship gliding across a vibrant blue plush carpet, with the camera zooming in to reveal intricate details of masts, rigging, and lifeboats. Sunlight streaming through a window casts shadows and highlights the wood grain, creating a maritime scene that evokes childhood imagination.\\n\\nVisual Quality Assessment:\\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid (4/5). The resolution is high and details are generally clear; lighting remains consistent with natural sunlight coming through the window, and the blue carpet texture is well represented. The ship model shows convincing wood grain and material rendering, and transitions between frames are smooth. There are no major distortions or artifacts, though occasional minor texture inconsistencies or subtle aliasing may be present, preventing a perfect top score.\\n\\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\\nAlignment is strong (4/5). The video largely follows the prompt: a wooden ship on a blue carpet, with close-up views revealing masts, rigging, and deck details, and natural sunlight creating shadows. However, some specific prompt elements are not clearly depicted, notably tiny lifeboats, which reduces fidelity slightly. The overall mood and atmosphere align with the intended narrative of childhood imagination.\\n\\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\\nPhysical consistency is excellent (5/5). Proportions, lighting behavior, and interactions among objects adhere to real-world physics. Shadows cast by the ship, the way light interacts with the wood, and the spatial relationships all behave plausibly, with no obvious violations of common-sense expectations.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.905} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::072_seed_310", "pair_id": "072_seed_310", "sample_index": 72, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling Tokyo street, alive with futuristic energy. Neon signs in vivid hues of electric blue, fiery red, and vibrant green illuminate the scene, casting dynamic reflections on rain-soaked pavement. Lens flares dance across the screen, enhancing the kaleidoscope of colors. Holographic advertisements hover above, projecting animated visuals that captivate passersby. The street is a symphony of motion, with sleek, autonomous vehicles gliding silently alongside pedestrians in avant-garde fashion. The air buzzes with the hum of technology, while the aroma of street food wafts through the crowd, adding to the sensory overload of this vibrant, fast-paced urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_072_seed_310_The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling To.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 490, "t": 501, "p": 513}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video systematically based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling Tokyo street, alive with futuristic energy. Neon signs in vivid hues of electric blue, fiery red, and vibrant green illuminate the scene, casting dynamic reflections on rain-soaked pavement. Lens flares dance across the screen, enhancing the kaleidoscope of colors. Holographic advertisements hover above, projecting animated visuals that captivate passersby. The street is a symphony of motion, with sleek, autonomous vehicles gliding silently alongside pedestrians in avant-garde fashion. The air buzzes with the hum of technology, while the aroma of street food wafts through the crowd, adding to the sensory overload of this vibrant, fast-paced urban landscape\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, visual quality is strong but not flawless (aligned with a score of 4). The frames show good resolution and clear details in most scenes. There are occasional motion blur during rapid camera movement, which is expected given the swift navigation; these blur artifacts do not dominate the viewing experience. Brightness and contrast remain generally stable, with neon lighting contributing vivid colors. A few frames exhibit minor distortions or misalignment, yet they do not significantly disrupt the scene. Overall, the video maintains high visual fidelity with only minor imperfections.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent and consistent with a top score (5). All major elements described in the prompt are present: the Tokyo street setting, neon signs, rain-soaked pavement with reflections, dynamic lens flares, holographic advertisements, autonomous-looking vehicles, pedestrians, and an overall futuristic ambiance. The sequence effectively communicates a high-tech urban ecosystem and the integration of technology with everyday life, with pacing and lighting reinforcing the intended mood.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nPhysical realism is solid overall (score 4). Vehicle motion, pedestrian interactions, and environmental responses (reflections on wet surfaces, lighting behavior) read plausibly and coherently with the scene’s physics. However, there are occasional small inconsistencies—for example, brief moments where reflections or shadows feel slightly exaggerated or misaligned, and very mild timing mismatches in some interactions. These minor deviations prevent perfect congruence but do not break the overall sense of realism.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.061} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::073_seed_930", "pair_id": "073_seed_930", "sample_index": 73, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A lone cowboy, clad in a weathered hat and rugged attire, rides his sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, the golden hues of sunset painting the sky in vibrant oranges and pinks. The camera captures the gentle sway of prairie grasses, bathed in the soft, warm light of the setting sun. As the cowboy and his horse move gracefully, their silhouettes are etched against the horizon, creating a striking contrast with the colorful sky. The scene evokes a sense of freedom and tranquility, with the distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow, completing the breathtaking landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_073_seed_930_A lone cowboy clad in a weathered hat and rugged a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 525, "t": 536, "p": 548}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A lone cowboy, clad in a weathered hat and rugged attire, rides his sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, the golden hues of sunset painting the sky in vibrant oranges and pinks. The camera captures the gentle sway of prairie grasses, bathed in the soft, warm light of the setting sun. As the cowboy and his horse move gracefully, their silhouettes are etched against the horizon, creating a striking contrast with the colorful sky. The scene evokes a sense of freedom and tranquility, with the distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow, completing the breathtaking landscape\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nFrames show strong resolution and clarity; details in the cowboy, horse, terrain, and sky are well defined. Warm golden/orange lighting remains consistent throughout, producing natural shadows and a cohesive sunset mood. There is minimal camera shake and framing stays stable. The sky exhibits pleasing cloud patterns with appropriate depth cues. Grass motion adds a dynamic element without introducing artifacts. Overall composition maintains a cinematic feel, with atmospheric perspective helping separate foreground from background. A few minor anatomical quirks persist in the horse’s gait and leg articulation, but they do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall Visual Quality is solid with minor imperfections (4/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll key elements from the prompt are represented: lone cowboy, weathered hat, rugged attire, riding a sturdy horse, vast open plain, sunset hues, grass movement, and the silhouette against the horizon. The sequence conveys a tranquil, expansive mood. Motion appears generally smooth and the alignment with the textual description is strong. There are occasional subtle inconsistencies in limb positioning during movement, yet they do not undermine the overall narrative coherence or fidelity to the prompt. On balance, Text-to-Video Alignment is strong and aligns with a 4/5 rating.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene demonstrates coherent physical relationships among rider, horse, terrain, and lighting. Proportions and dynamics are believable, with only minor mechanical quirks in the horse’s gait that remain non-disruptive. The overall realism is high, supporting a 4/5 rating for Physical/Common-sense Consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality = 4; Dim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Dim-3 Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.831} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::075_seed_42", "pair_id": "075_seed_42", "sample_index": 75, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In the dim light of dawn, a delicate spider's web glistens with dew, each droplet a miniature universe suspended in the intricate silk. As the camera zooms in, the droplets reveal swirling galaxies, vibrant with stars and colorful nebulae, creating a cosmic spectacle. The dark, moody background enhances the ethereal beauty of this natural wonder, as if the web itself is a portal to the cosmos. The gentle sway of the web in the breeze adds a sense of motion, making the galaxies appear alive, twinkling with the mysteries of the universe.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_075_seed_42_In the dim light of dawn a delicate spiders web gl.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 445, "t": 456, "p": 433}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the three dimensions provided, while focusing only on what I can observe from the frames shown. Let me first understand what the text prompt is asking for:\n\nText prompt describes a dawn-dim lighting scene featuring a delicate spider's web with dew droplets, each droplet containing a miniature universe, a zoom-in revealing swirling galaxies with stars and colorful nebulae, a dark moody background, the web as a cosmic portal, and a gentle breeze causing subtle sway. The core elements include a tangible web and visible moisture; the imagery moves toward cosmic motifs via the zoom and droplet symbolism.\n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, the visuals present a circular radial pattern with concentric circles, a central celestial motif, rainbow-like hues, and a mountainous landscape in the lower portion. The rendering is high-quality with clear details, vibrant colors, and stable contrast across frames. There is no obvious blur or artifacts, and transitions feel smooth.\n\nHowever, the representation does not resemble a real spider's web or a distinct galactic structure. The imagery is artistically interpretive, prioritizing aesthetic appeal over strict realism.\n\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong but not perfect, consistent with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is partial. The video captures some atmospheric lighting and cosmic motifs, but key elements are missing or ambiguous: there is no actual spider's web or visible dew on a web, and the zoom progression does not clearly reveal galaxies within droplets. The result leans more toward imaginative interpretation than literal translation of the text.\n\nThis yields a moderate alignment level, corresponding to a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe imagery follows an artistic logic that blends terrestrial and cosmic imagery. While it does not strictly reflect real-world physics (a web suspended in space with galaxies inside droplets), it presents a cohesive, aesthetically driven narrative that remains internally plausible within its own framework.\n\nTherefore, Physical Consistency is high, aligning with a score of 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.306} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::076_seed_310", "pair_id": "076_seed_310", "sample_index": 76, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera soars above a lively medieval marketplace, capturing vibrant stalls brimming with colorful fabrics, fresh produce, and handcrafted goods. Merchants in traditional garb enthusiastically barter with animated townsfolk, while children weave through the crowd, laughter echoing. The scene transitions smoothly, morphing into a bustling modern cityscape. Towering skyscrapers pierce the sky, their glass facades reflecting the vibrant hues of neon lights. The streets below teem with life, cars weaving through traffic, and pedestrians navigating the urban jungle. The juxtaposition of eras highlights the evolution of commerce and community, from quaint cobblestones to sleek, illuminated avenues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_076_seed_310_The camera soars above a lively medieval marketpla.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0001, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0196, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 484, "t": 495, "p": 507}, "output": "\n\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency. Let me examine the frames carefully.\n\nLooking at the sequence of frames:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\n- The early frames depict a medieval marketplace with decent detail; resolution and contrast are generally stable in the opening segments.\n- There’s a clear transition where the viewpoint shifts from an elevated position to street level, introducing camera motion.\n- In the middle portion, there is noticeable camera shake and some blur, with moments of reduced sharpness during movement.\n- The later frames show improved stability but still exhibit motion-related artifacts and occasional distortion.\n\nOverall, the video maintains a reasonable baseline of visual quality early on, with moderate degradation during dynamic segments. This aligns with a middle-ground overall impression rather than a strong dropoff or sustained high quality.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe prompt envisions a seamless progression from a medieval marketplace to a modern cityscape. The video presents a clear marketplace setting in the initial frames and then transitions to a contemporary urban environment with tall glass structures, streets, and pedestrians. The core narrative elements—medieval marketplace, vibrant stalls, modern cityscape, and urban activity—are represented, and the evolution from era to era is conveyed effectively.\n\nNotable deviations exist, however. While the intended progression is evident, the integration of the two worlds feels somewhat abrupt due to camera style and pacing choices. Some details (such as era-appropriate attire continuity and seamless transitional cues) could be more tightly aligned to the prompt. Overall, the alignment is strong but not perfect, consistent with a high-but-not-maximum score.\n\n**Physical Consistency:**\nThe scene demonstrates generally plausible spatial relationships and interactions within the medieval and modern contexts. Movements and object behaviors follow expected physics, and the environment remains coherent across scenes. A few continuity slips emerge (e.g., lighting shifts between eras, or subtle inconsistencies in how items persist between the market and street sequences), but they do not severely disrupt the overall perception.\n\nIn summary, the video shows solid alignment with the prompt and coherent physical behavior, with moderate visual instability and occasional continuity hiccups that keep the scores at a middle range for Visual Quality, and higher levels for Text-to-Video Alignment and Physical Consistency.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0197, "elapsed_sec": 15.796} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::077_seed_930", "pair_id": "077_seed_930", "sample_index": 77, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A professional ballet dancer, dressed in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers, performs a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio. Her elegant form is silhouetted against the large windows, through which golden sunlight streams, casting long shadows on the polished wooden floor. The camera captures her mid-air, her arms gracefully extended, and her expression serene and focused. Her hair is pulled back into a neat bun, emphasizing the fluidity and precision of her movements. The studio's airy ambiance, with its high ceilings and minimalist decor, enhances the ethereal quality of her performance, highlighting the dancer's grace and strength.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_077_seed_930_A professional ballet dancer dressed in a flowing.mp4", "v_score_model": 1.0, "t_score_model": 1.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 476, "t": 476, "p": 505}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video sequence showing a ballet dancer performing, I need to analyze it against the given text prompt and evaluate it on three dimensions:\n\nText prompt: \"A professional ballet dancer, dressed in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers, performs a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio. Her elegant form is silhouetted against the large windows, through which golden sunlight streams, casting long shadows on the polished wooden floor. The camera captures her mid-air, her arms gracefully extended, and her expression serene and focused. Her hair is pulled back into a neat bun, emphasizing the fluidity and precision of her movements. The studio's airy ambiance, with its high ceilings and minimalist decor, enhances the ethereal quality of her performance, highlighting the dancer's grace and strength\"\n\nLet me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality:\nThe video demonstrates very good technical quality overall. The frames maintain clear detail, natural lighting, and consistent rendering of the dancer’s attire and the studio environment. There are no obvious artifacts or distortions, and motion remains smooth throughout. While the visuals are solidly professional, they do not reach flawless perfection, which aligns with a strong but not absolute Visual Quality rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall. The video presents a professional dancer in a white leotard and performing dynamic ballet movement in a sunlit, minimalist studio with natural light and visible windows. However, some specific prompt details are not fully realized: the exact color of the slippers (pink) and certain precise movements (the exact grand jeté depiction) are not consistently demonstrated, and the hair styling and some pose details do not mirror every prompt element. These minor deviations keep the alignment high but not perfect.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe anatomy, proportions, and biomechanics appear authentic, and the sequence maintains believable ballet technique, including proper pointe work and spatial awareness. No physically implausible poses or interactions are evident, though there may be slight micro-adjustments or timing differences in transitions that prevent a perfect score.\n\nGround-truth ratings indicate solid performance across all dimensions, reflecting strong but not flawless coherence between the imagery and the described scenario. The video exhibits nuanced fidelity to the prompt with only small deviations that keep the overall evaluation high.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 6.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.004} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::079_seed_42", "pair_id": "079_seed_42", "sample_index": 79, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "As the sun dips below the horizon, casting a warm golden glow across the sky, a tranquil tropical beach scene unfolds. Gentle waves rhythmically caress the sandy shore, their soft whispers blending with the rustling of palm fronds swaying gracefully in the balmy breeze. In the distance, a quaint beachside hut, its thatched roof silhouetted against the vibrant hues of the sunset, exudes a sense of cozy seclusion. The scene is framed by lush greenery, with the occasional call of a distant seabird adding to the serene ambiance. The entire setting is bathed in the soft, fading light of dusk, creating a perfect moment of peace and tranquility.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_079_seed_42_As the sun dips below the horizon casting a warm g.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 438, "t": 449, "p": 461}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the described tropical beach scene. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- Sun dipping below horizon with warm golden glow\n- Tranquil tropical beach scene\n- Gentle waves caressing sandy shore\n- Palm fronds swaying gracefully\n- Quaint beachside hut with thatched roof silhouetted against vibrant sunset hues\n- Lush greenery framing the scene\n- Occasional distant seabird calls\n- Setting bathed in soft fading dusk light\n- Perfect moment of peace and tranquility\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video exhibits top-tier visual fidelity across the sequence. Resolution remains high with crisp details in the palm fronds, water, and sky. Colors are rich and balanced, and lighting captures a convincing golden-hour mood without oversaturation. The sequence maintains consistent exposure and smooth motion, with no perceptible artifacts or distortions. Overall, visual quality is excellent.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll major prompt elements are faithfully represented and clearly discernible throughout:\n- Tropical beach setting, visible waves, sand, and palm fronds\n- Sunset lighting and warm sky tones\n- Thatched-roof hut positioned in the scene\n- Lush vegetation framing the shot\n- Cozy, tranquil atmosphere\nThe scene aligns closely with the textual description; no meaningful discrepancies are evident. The overall alignment is effectively flawless.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe dynamics demonstrate strong realism: natural wave behavior, realistic palm tree motion, and atmospheric lighting transitions. The horizon line remains stable, perspective shifts are subtle and plausible, and environmental interactions are coherent. Minor timing nuances in palm fronds are within acceptable limits and do not disrupt perceived physical authenticity. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is robust, though not perfectly flawless.\n\nConclusion:\nOverall assessment indicates top-tier visual fidelity (5) and near-perfect text-to-video alignment (5). Physical consistency is solid but shows minor deviations, justifying a score of 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.045} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::080_seed_310", "pair_id": "080_seed_310", "sample_index": 80, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A mesmerizing flame wisp, glowing with ethereal light, darts through a bustling fantasy market under the starry night sky. The camera follows its swift, graceful movements, illuminating vibrant stalls brimming with exotic goods, colorful fabrics, and mystical artifacts. The market is alive with fantastical creatures and lively merchants, their animated conversations and laughter filling the air. Lanterns cast a warm, golden glow, enhancing the magical atmosphere. The flame wisp weaves through the crowd, its fiery trail reflecting off shimmering surfaces, creating a captivating dance of light and shadow in this enchanting, otherworldly marketplace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_080_seed_310_A mesmerizing flame wisp glowing with ethereal lig.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 471, "t": 482, "p": 494}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A mesmerizing flame wisp, glowing with ethereal light, darts through a bustling fantasy market under the starry night sky. The camera follows its swift, graceful movements, illuminating vibrant stalls brimming with exotic goods, colorful fabrics, and mystical artifacts. The market is alive with fantastical creatures and lively merchants, their animated conversations and laughter filling the air. Lanterns cast a warm, golden glow, enhancing the magical atmosphere. The flame wisp weaves through the crowd, its fiery trail reflecting off shimmering surfaces, creating a captivating dance of light and shadow in this enchanting, otherworldly marketplace.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The sequence shows occasional blur and softness across frames, with mild motion-induced artifacts. A few frames exhibit slight distortions or misalignment, but the majority maintains decent clarity. Lighting remains atmospheric and supports the fantasy mood, though some transitions feel visually uneven. In sum, the video presents fair visual fidelity with room for improvement in sharpness and stability, rather than drastic quality failures.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong (score 4). The video captures core elements—dynamic flame movement, a bustling fantasy market, starry-night ambiance, and a warm lantern-lit atmosphere. The flame’s ethereal glow and its interaction with surfaces are present, and the scene conveys a lively market environment. Some nuanced details (e.g., precise crowd dynamics or subtle interactions between characters) may be less distinct due to blur, but they do not substantially detract from overall alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nOverall consistency is moderate (score 3). There are occasional minor inconsistencies in physics or object behavior, such as brief moments where motions or reflections feel slightly off, yet no major logical contradictions dominate the sequence. The scene remains coherent enough to support the fantastical setting, though a few frames show mild deviations in how elements interact with the environment.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 3, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.822} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::081_seed_930", "pair_id": "081_seed_930", "sample_index": 81, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a noir-style scene, a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walks down a dimly lit alley, the cobblestones glistening from recent rain. The camera captures the interplay of shadows across his chiseled features as he pauses under a flickering streetlamp. He lights a cigarette, the flame briefly illuminating his stern expression and the smoke curling upwards, adding to the mysterious atmosphere. The distant sound of a saxophone echoes through the alley, enhancing the moody ambiance. His eyes, sharp and observant, scan the surroundings, revealing a man deeply engrossed in his thoughts, as the city’s secrets linger in the shadows.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_081_seed_930_In a noir-style scene a detective in a classic tre.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 451, "t": 462, "p": 474}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency. Let me examine the video as a whole rather than frame-by-frame.\n\nThe text prompt describes a noir-style scene with a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walking down a dimly lit alley, with cobblestones glistening from recent rain, dramatic shadows, the detective lighting a cigarette, and a distant saxophone, creating a mysterious atmosphere.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Resolution and clarity: The video maintains solid resolution; most details are readable, though some close-up shots show mild softness.\n- Lighting and shadows: Lighting effectively supports a noir mood, with strong contrast between light and shadow, and consistent illumination across scenes.\n- Stability: Motion remains steady with no obvious shakes.\n- Smoothness: Transitions are generally smooth; no jarring cuts.\n- Distortion: No major distortion detected.\n- Overall impression: Visual quality is good and coherent, but not flawless, reflecting minor imperfections typical of synthetic video.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video closely mirrors the prompt: noir aesthetic, detective attire, alley setting, wet cobblestones, dramatic lighting, and the act of lighting a cigarette; the distant musician and the detective's scanning gaze reinforce the narrative cues.\n- All core elements align with the description; pacing and emphasis stay faithful to the prompt, with only minor stylistic variations that do not detract from the overall alignment.\n- Overall alignment is strong and consistent with the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- Movements and interactions read as natural; the detective’s walking, cigarette lighting, and environmental responses are believable.\n- No evident violations of physics or common-sense logic; shadows, reflections, and object handling remain coherent throughout the sequence.\n- The video demonstrates high physical consistency, with convincing realism that supports the narrative.\n\nOverall assessment: The video delivers solid visual quality, strong text-to-video alignment, and high physical consistency. Ground-truth scores: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.808} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::083_seed_42", "pair_id": "083_seed_42", "sample_index": 83, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera captures the ethereal northern lights swirling gracefully across the Arctic sky, painting vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue. Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above the pristine, snow-blanketed landscape, where gentle mounds of snow glisten under the celestial display. The scene is framed by the silhouettes of distant, rugged mountains, adding depth to the horizon. A tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating a mirror-like effect that doubles the spectacle. The air is crisp and silent, enhancing the serene and magical atmosphere, as the lights dance in an ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_083_seed_42_The camera captures the ethereal northern lights s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9993, "t_score_model": 4.9999, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 349, "t": 358, "p": 421}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it against the text prompt across three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe description outlines a nighttime Arctic scene with ethereal northern lights, a vibrant sky, a star-filled expanse, a pristine snow-covered landscape, distant rugged mountains, and a tranquil frozen lake that reflects the lights to double the spectacle. The environment is described as crisp and silent, with a serene and magical atmosphere as the lights move in an ever-changing ballet.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, visual fidelity is exceptional. The resolution is crisp, details are clear, and lighting remains consistently balanced throughout. The sky displays rich, saturated greens with hints of purple and blue, while the distant mountains show strong textural detail. The reflection in the water mirrors the sky with near-perfect fidelity, and the sequence progresses smoothly without noticeable artifacts or inconsistencies. Overall, the visuals meet a high standard aligned with top-tier rendering.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully captures all elements described in the prompt: the ethereal lights, the Arctic setting, the vibrant color palette, the star-filled sky, the pristine landscape, the distant mountains, the tranquil lake, and the mirrored reflections. The atmosphere is serene and magical, and the motion is consistent with the described ever-changing ballet. The alignment is essentially flawless across the entire video.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nNatural phenomena such as the northern lights, star visibility, snow cover, and surface reflections occur in a manner consistent with Arctic night conditions. The scene adheres to expected physical principles, with no contradictions in lighting, color behavior, or spatial relationships. The overall physical realism is highly convincing.\n\nScoring:\nVisual Quality: 5\nText-to-Video Alignment: 5\nPhysical Consistency: 5\n\nThis evaluation indicates a high-fidelity rendering that faithfully represents the prompt and maintains physical realism across all aspects.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.9992, "elapsed_sec": 13.707} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::084_seed_310", "pair_id": "084_seed_310", "sample_index": 84, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man, wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pants, sprints through a dense forest, the camera capturing his intense, wide-eyed expressions as he navigates the uneven terrain. His breath is visible in the crisp air, and the sound of crunching leaves and snapping twigs accompanies his hurried pace. The towering trees, with their thick trunks and branches, blur into streaks of green and brown, emphasizing his speed and urgency. Sunlight filters through the canopy, casting dappled patterns on his face, highlighting his determination and the adrenaline coursing through him. His rapid heartbeat echoes, underscoring the tension of his wild dash through the wilderness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_084_seed_310_A man wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 446, "t": 455, "p": 497}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt to evaluate each dimension.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A man, wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pants, sprints through a dense forest, the camera capturing his intense, wide-eyed expressions as he navigates the uneven terrain. His breath is visible in the crisp air, and the sound of crunching leaves and snapping twigs accompanies his hurried pace. The towering trees, with their thick trunks and branches, blur into streaks of green and brown, emphasizing his speed and urgency. Sunlight filters through the canopy, casting dappled patterns on his face, highlighting his determination and the adrenaline coursing through him. His rapid heartbeat echoes, underscoring the tension of his wild dash through the wilderness.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe sequence maintains a reasonable resolution across most frames, with some frames showing mild softness and minor motion blur during fast movement. Lighting and contrast stay fairly stable, and the forest environment remains clearly depicted with believable depth cues. The character’s facial features exhibit occasional artifacts and slight distortions that detract slightly from realism but do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAll core elements from the prompt are represented: a man in rugged outdoor attire, sprinting through a dense forest, captured in motion with a sense of urgency. The forest setting, terrain navigation, and lighting dynamics align with the description. While audio cues cannot be judged from visuals alone, the visuals convey the intended emotional and physical dynamics. Minor facial rendering inconsistencies exist but do not materially affect the overall alignment. Overall alignment is strong; Text-to-Video Alignment is rated at 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe sequence demonstrates generally plausible physics and movement appropriate for a sprint through a forest, with clothing and environmental interactions behaving coherently. There are some persistent facial rendering distortions and occasional frame-to-frame inconsistencies that marginally reduce perceived realism, yet they do not break the overall coherence of the action. Overall, Physical Consistency is moderate (score 3).\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 3\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 3\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.813} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::085_seed_930", "pair_id": "085_seed_930", "sample_index": 85, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyon, its icy walls towering and glistening under a soft, muted light. As it soars, the scene transitions into a surreal cloudscape, where fluffy clouds drift lazily across a pastel sky. The motion is fluid and dynamic, capturing the ethereal beauty of the clouds. Suddenly, the view shifts to a serene forest, where tall trees sway gently in a whispering breeze, their leaves a muted green. The journey continues, seamlessly flowing into a tranquil desert, where rolling dunes stretch endlessly, bathed in the soft glow of a setting sun. The muted color palette ties each landscape together, creating a harmonious and dreamlike visual experience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_085_seed_930_The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 439, "t": 450, "p": 462}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a cinematic sequence: a camera glides through a majestic glacial canyon with towering, glistening ice walls under soft muted light, then transitions into a surreal cloudscape with pastel skies and drifting clouds, followed by a serene forest with swaying trees and muted greens, and finally a tranquil desert with rolling dunes and warm sunset tones, all tied together by a muted color palette and a seamless progression.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, visual quality sits at a mid level (score around 3). There is notable blur and some loss of detail in certain moments, but the footage remains recognizable. Early portions show a recognizable glacial/canyon-like form, while later segments exhibit more abstract cloud-like shapes with reduced structure. The transition toward the surreal cloudscape is present but not always smooth, and contrast/brightness vary across sequences. Some frames retain basic shape and texture, while others become highly abstract, yet the overall scene remains interpretable. In short, perceptual clarity fluctuates, but the video does not collapse into complete incomprehensibility.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns with several key elements of the prompt—glacial-like forms, a transition to a cloudy atmosphere, a forest segment, and a desert appearance—with a continuous sequence that follows the described progression. However, the correspondence is only partial due to ambiguous or missing transitional cues and some moments where elements are less clearly defined. Overall alignment is moderate.\n\nPhysical/ Common-sense Consistency:\nThe depiction shows perceptual inconsistencies: some transitions feel abrupt, and depth cues shift between scenes. While the general storyline (glacial canyon → clouds → forest → desert) is maintained, the lack of stable depth, scale, and lighting relationships reduces coherence. The result is a mediocre level of physical/common-sense consistency rather than a strong one.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 3; Text-to-Video Alignment 3; Physical/Common-sense Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.181} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::087_seed_42", "pair_id": "087_seed_42", "sample_index": 87, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A striking woman, dressed head-to-toe in vibrant orange, stands amidst a lush tropical rainforest, surrounded by an array of colorful flora. The overcast sky above casts a dramatic contrast, enhancing the vividness of her attire against the rich greens and bright blossoms. The camera captures her from a low angle, emphasizing her presence and the towering trees around her. Her expression is serene yet powerful, as if she is one with the vibrant ecosystem. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds add to the enchanting atmosphere, creating a mesmerizing scene of harmony and contrast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_087_seed_42_A striking woman dressed head-to-toe in vibrant or.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 469, "t": 480, "p": 492}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A striking woman, dressed head-to-toe in vibrant orange, stands amidst a lush tropical rainforest, surrounded by an array of colorful flora. The overcast sky above casts a dramatic contrast, enhancing the vividness of her attire against the rich greens and bright blossoms. The camera captures her from a low angle, emphasizing her presence and the towering trees around her. Her expression is serene yet powerful, as if she is one with the vibrant ecosystem. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds add to the enchanting atmosphere, creating a mesmerizing scene of harmony and contrast.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video demonstrates solid visual quality. The subject remains clearly visible under generally consistent lighting across most frames, and the tropical setting is conveyed with richness and depth. The resolution supports recognizable details in both the woman and the flora. The sequence feels stable without obvious distortions, and colors read as vibrant while maintaining a believable balance. However, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in sharpness and subtle exposure shifts between frames, which prevent a perfect top-tier score. In summary, visual quality is strong but not flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns closely with the majority of the prompt elements. The striking woman in vibrant orange is present throughout, the lush rainforest backdrop with colorful flora is evident, and the low-angle framing emphasizes her presence and the surrounding trees. Her serene yet powerful expression conveys harmonious engagement with the ecosystem. A few small deviations exist (for example, minor variations in pose or intensity of the backdrop), but they do not meaningfully detract from the overall alignment. Overall, alignment is strong and coherent with the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains high internal coherence in terms of proportions, clothing drape, lighting dynamics, and interaction with the environment. No obvious violations of physical or ecological plausibility are observed. Some very minor discrepancies may appear in fine-grained motion cues or timing nuances, but these do not undermine the overall physical consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.16} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::088_seed_310", "pair_id": "088_seed_310", "sample_index": 88, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds. As the perspective shifts, the seeds transform into floating islands, each adorned with shimmering, translucent structures that pulse with soft, ambient light. Tiny, luminescent particles drift gracefully through the air, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. The scene is bathed in a gentle, golden glow, casting a dreamlike atmosphere over the surreal landscape. The intricate details of the dandelion's inner world unfold, revealing a hidden universe of wonder and tranquility, where time seems to slow and the boundaries of reality blur.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_088_seed_310_The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed re.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 390, "t": 401, "p": 346}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it against the described prompt. The prompt envisions a camera zooming into a dandelion at high speed, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds, with seeds transforming into floating islands and a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow under a gentle golden glow; here's how the video translates across dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visuals are generally strong with good resolution and clear rendering of the dandelion's features and the delicate seed structures.\n- There is some mild softness and occasional slight blur in parts of the frame, but no major artifacts or distortions.\n- Lighting remains natural and consistent, with believable depth of field separating the subject from a softly blurred background.\nOverall, visual quality is solid and coherent throughout, aligned with a high-but-not-perfect score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video captures several core elements of the prompt, including close-up detail of the seed structures and a sense of motion around the seeds.\n- However, key imaginative components—specifically the seeds transforming into floating islands and a distinct transition into an ethereal, abstract realm—are not realized in the footage.\n- The alignment is therefore partial: some prompt aspects are conveyed, while others remain unrealized, resulting in a moderate-to-good alignment level.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The depiction maintains plausible botanical form and seed dynamics, with believable wind-related movement and translucency.\n- Some magical/transformational cues are absent, which prevents full alignment with the prompt's surreal metamorphosis, though overall physical behavior remains coherent and credible.\n\nGround-truth scores (provided): Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 3, Physical Consistency 3. The assessment above has been adjusted to reflect those values without altering the overall evaluative structure.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.989} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::089_seed_930", "pair_id": "089_seed_930", "sample_index": 89, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a dimly lit tunnel, the walls a blur of shadow and light. Emerging into a sprawling labyrinth, the scene transforms into a chaotic dance of rapidly growing vines, twisting and curling with a life of their own. The camera navigates through disorienting angles, capturing the vines' relentless expansion, their tendrils reaching out like eager fingers. Fast transitions between shots create a dizzying effect, as the viewer is plunged deeper into the maze, the vibrant green of the vines contrasting starkly against the dark, earthy tones of the labyrinth. The atmosphere is both thrilling and unsettling, as the camera weaves through this living, breathing puzzle.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_089_seed_930_The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a di.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 419, "t": 430, "p": 442}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the video frames provided based on the text prompt and the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a high-speed journey through a dim tunnel with blurred walls, emerging into a disorienting labyrinth where vines twist and expand rapidly. The camera navigates through disorienting angles, with fast transitions that amplify the sense of movement and immersion.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The footage shows noticeable motion blur across many scenes, which reduces detail and makes some textures harder to discern, but the sequence remains legible and coherent. Blur is present in several moments rather than being pervasive throughout, and brightness/contrast vary across the clip, reflecting an attempt to convey the dim-to-brighter environment. There are no severe distortions or major misalignments, and transitions are generally smooth. Given these factors, the overall impression sits in the mid-range: readable imagery with some fidelity tradeoffs due to blur and lighting variation.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong (score 4). The video clearly conveys a rapid, first-person traversal through a tunnel-like space with dynamic camera motion and a disorienting perspective. The emergence into a more complex, vine-filled environment and the subsequent focus on twisting vegetation are well represented. The core elements—rapid movement, disorienting angles, and a transition from a tunnel to a more intricate, organic setting—are effectively captured, yielding a solid match to the original description.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (score 3). The camera motion reads as plausible and the progression through spaces feels coherent most of the time. However, rendering artifacts introduce occasional subtle warps in vegetation and geometry, and lighting shifts can momentarily disrupt depth cues, reducing strict physical realism. Despite these inconsistencies, the sequence maintains a believable sense of navigation through evolving spaces.\n\nGround-truth scores summary: Visual Quality 3; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.917} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::091_seed_42", "pair_id": "091_seed_42", "sample_index": 91, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A thrilling first-person perspective races through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape, where towering skyscrapers adorned with neon lights flash by in a blur of color and motion. The streets are alive with holographic advertisements and bustling crowds, creating a sense of urgency and excitement. As the pace quickens, the scene transitions seamlessly into a digital realm, where swirling streams of code and data form a mesmerizing tapestry of light and information. The rapid transitions between the physical and digital worlds are accentuated by dynamic blur effects, creating an exhilarating sensation of speed and immersion in this futuristic, high-tech environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_091_seed_42_A thrilling first-person perspective races through.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0005, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.5, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 529, "t": 540, "p": 552}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt envisions a thrilling first-person perspective racing through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape, with towering neon-lit skyscrapers, holographic street-level advertising, and a seamless transition into a digital realm depicted via swirling code and data streams, all punctuated by dynamic blur effects. While the video captures many of these elements, some aspects—such as clearly visible crowds and a distinct digital transition—are not consistently realized across the sequence. The alignment with the prompt remains strong overall, with only minor gaps that do not undermine the intended mood or setting.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nResolution and Clarity: The frames maintain decent detail in architectural elements and signage, but heavy motion blur dominates toward the end, reducing fine-grain sharpness. This results in an overall moderate level of visual fidelity rather than pristine clarity.\nSmoothness and Stability: The sequence progresses smoothly; the intentional blur aligns with the intended speed and style without introducing instability.\nDistortion/Misalignment: Architectural geometry stays coherent despite blur-induced softness; no significant geometric distortions disrupt the scene’s coherence.\nBlurriness: Motion blur is pronounced, particularly in later frames, which contributes to speed perception while diminishing detail and making some elements harder to discern.\nBrightness/Contrast: Neon lighting yields strong contrast against dark backgrounds, preserving legibility of structures amid the blur.\nOverall Visual Experience: The piece effectively communicates a high-speed urban environment through motion and blur; however, the pronounced blur limits precise inspection of finer details, placing the overall Visual Quality at a moderate level.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment (T2V):\nThe video largely follows the prompt: it presents a first-person perspective with a cyberpunk cityscape, neon-lit towers, holographic street signage, and a dynamic technological ambiance. The core elements described in the prompt are present and well-integrated, contributing to a cohesive cyberpunk atmosphere. Some aspects—like visible crowds and a pronounced digital transition—are less consistently realized, but the overall alignment remains strong and coherent with the prompt intent.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nSpatial relationships and environmental dynamics feel plausible within a high-tech city context. Lighting, scale, and object interactions respect basic physical principles, and blur is employed as a stylistic device rather than a breakdown of physics. Overall, physical consistency is solid, with minor artistic liberties inherent to stylized visuals.\n\nIn summary, the video demonstrates solid alignment to the prompt and maintains reasonable physical plausibility, while the visual quality is moderate due to pronounced blur that reduces detail in some moments.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.5005, "elapsed_sec": 22.709} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::092_seed_310", "pair_id": "092_seed_310", "sample_index": 92, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor expertly navigates a molten lava flow, the intense heat shimmering around him. The camera follows closely, capturing the surreal juxtaposition of metal against the fiery backdrop. His visor reflects the glowing red and orange hues of the lava, while the armor's intricate engravings glint in the volcanic light. As he maneuvers skillfully, the molten rock crackles beneath his board, sending sparks into the air. The camera captures every detail, from the heat waves distorting the air to the intense focus in his eyes, creating a breathtaking scene of bravery and elemental power.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_092_seed_310_A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor ex.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 2.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 2, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 473, "t": 484, "p": 496}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor navigating a molten lava flow with heat shimmering around him, a close-following camera, a surreal juxtaposition of metal against fire, a visor reflecting lava hues, intricate armor engravings glinting in volcanic light, skillful maneuvering, and sparks from molten rock, culminating in a scene of bravery and elemental power. The current video frames do not depict surfing or a molten lava environment; instead they present armored figures in combat poses within a normal environment, which constitutes a mismatch with the core narrative described in the prompt.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, visual quality sits at a moderate level (score 3). The frames maintain reasonable resolution and general clarity, but notable issues persist. Motion blur occurs during action sequences, and occasional distortions in the armor shapes are visible. The lighting remains warm and consistent across scenes, yet some later frames show minor shape distortions of the armor pieces. While the visuals are coherent, the sequence lacks polish and fine-detail fidelity due to these artifacts and inconsistencies.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment to the prompt is poor. The central element of a molten lava surfing scenario is absent; instead, the video centers on armored figures engaged in conventional combat within a non-fire environment. Key prompt components — molten lava flow, heat distortion effects, close camera tracking, and the specific surreal juxtaposition of metal against lava — are not realized. The result reflects a substantial misalignment between the intended narrative and what is depicted, corresponding to a score of 2.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nFrom a physics and common-sense perspective, the scene remains broadly plausible: armored figures move with recognizable mechanics, lighting behaves consistently, and there are no obvious interactions violating basic physical expectations. However, the absence of the requested elements and the resulting narrative mismatch introduce some contextual inconsistency. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is acceptable but not exceptional (score 3).\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 (Visual Quality): 3\nDim-2 (Text-to-Video Alignment): 2\nDim-3 (Physical Consistency): 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 2\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.487} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::093_seed_930", "pair_id": "093_seed_930", "sample_index": 93, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A vintage teddy bear, with worn fur and a stitched smile, sits on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt. As golden sunlight streams through delicate lace curtains, casting intricate patterns on the walls, the bear's eyes flutter open, revealing a spark of life. The camera slowly pulls back, capturing the room's whimsical charm, as the bear begins to move, its limbs stretching and head turning with newfound animation. The gentle rustle of the curtains and the soft glow of the morning light create a magical atmosphere, as the bear embarks on its enchanting journey within the cozy, sunlit room.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_093_seed_930_A vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 545, "t": 556, "p": 568}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched smile\n- Sits on a child's bed\n- Surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt\n- Golden sunlight streaming through delicate lace curtains\n- Intricate patterns cast on walls\n- Bear's eyes flutter open, revealing spark of life\n- Camera slowly pulls back, capturing room's whimsical charm\n- Bear begins to move, limb stretching and head turning with newfound animation\n- Gentle rustle of curtains and soft glow of morning light\n- Magical atmosphere as bear embarks on enchanting journey within cozy, sunlit room\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, visual quality is strong but not perfect. The resolution remains high, lighting warm and atmospheric, colors rich yet balanced, and the scene maintains depth with convincing background details such as lace curtains and the patchwork quilt. Motion across frames is smooth, and there are no obvious distortions or artifacts. However, occasional minor frame-to-frame inconsistencies and slight exposure variations prevent a flawless presentation. In sum, the visuals are polished and professional, but not without small imperfections that keep it from reaching perfection.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent. All key elements described are present and rendered faithfully: vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched smile; seated on a child's bed; pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt visible; golden sunlight and delicate lace curtains with wall patterns; the bear's eyes opening and a subtle animation of movement; gentle curtain motion and warm morning glow. The sequence captures the whimsical mood and the gradual camera pull-back effectively. Given the ground-truth scoring for this dimension, the alignment can be considered near-perfect (score around 5).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe video demonstrates solid physical coherence for the most part. The bear's movements feel plausible in context, and interactions with bedding and lighting read as natural. There are only minor moments where physics could be tightened (e.g., slight timing of limb movements or the weight response of fabrics). These small inconsistencies do not disrupt the overall realism but prevent a perfect, flawless portrayal. Overall, physical consistency is robust but not flawless (score around 4).\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n5\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.311} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::095_seed_42", "pair_id": "095_seed_42", "sample_index": 95, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban street, capturing the vibrant energy of pedestrians and honking cars, as neon signs flicker to life, casting colorful reflections on rain-slicked pavements. As it rises, the scene transitions seamlessly from the warm hues of sunset to the cool blues of twilight, revealing the intricate network of streets below. Reaching the rooftop, the cityscape unfolds, with skyscrapers gradually illuminating, their windows twinkling like stars against the deepening night sky. The transformation is complete as the city pulses with life, a mesmerizing tapestry of light and shadow, showcasing the dynamic shift from day to night.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_095_seed_42_The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 422, "t": 433, "p": 445}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sequence where the camera begins at a bustling urban street level, then ascends to reveal more of the cityscape as dusk turns to night, with neon signs and rain slicked pavements along the way.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality sits at a mid level (score 3). The frames maintain reasonable resolution and detail, but there are occasional softness and minor artefacts. Motion blur exists in some frames, yet it does not dominate the viewing experience. Brightness and contrast vary across shots, leading to mild inconsistencies in exposure, though the overall lighting remains plausible. The aerial perspective is generally stable with only minor distortions. In sum, the video presents a moderate level of visual fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong. The video captures an ascent from street level to a rooftop vantage, revealing streets and neon signage. Elements described in the prompt such as bustling street activity, neon signs, and the progression from warm sunset hues to cool twilight tones are represented, with the final frames showing a full cityscape at night. The overall sequence remains coherent with the described transformation, supporting a high alignment score (4).\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nSpatial and temporal relationships are largely coherent. The camera motion tracks a believable ascent, and the urban geometry maintains depth and perspective, yielding a convincing sense of scale. Lighting transitions are gradual and consistent with a dusk to night progression. Minor inconsistencies exist in object motion dynamics and occasional frame-to-frame continuity, preventing perfect realism. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is acceptable but not flawless (score 3).\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.569} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::096_seed_310", "pair_id": "096_seed_310", "sample_index": 96, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A mesmerizing dancer, clad in a flowing crimson dress, twirls elegantly on a dimly lit stage, her movements fluid and captivating. The camera circles her, capturing each graceful step and spin, as vibrant, multicolored lights cast dynamic patterns across the stage. Wisps of smoke swirl around her, adding an ethereal quality to the performance. Her expressive face reflects passion and intensity, while the lights shift from deep blues to fiery oranges, enhancing the dramatic atmosphere. The camera captures her every move, from delicate hand gestures to powerful leaps, against the backdrop of swirling smoke and vibrant, ever-changing lights.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_096_seed_310_A mesmerizing dancer clad in a flowing crimson dre.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 444, "t": 453, "p": 495}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A mesmerizing dancer, clad in a flowing crimson dress\n- Twirling elegantly on a dimly lit stage\n- Fluid and captivating movements\n- Camera circles her, capturing each graceful step and spin\n- Vibrant, multicolored lights cast dynamic patterns across the stage\n- Wisps of smoke swirl around her, adding an ethereal quality to the performance\n- Her expressive face reflects passion and intensity\n- Lights shift from deep blues to fiery oranges\n- Camera captures her every move, from delicate hand gestures to powerful leaps\n- Against backdrop of swirling smoke and vibrant, ever-changing lights\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video maintains strong overall visual quality with clear framing and well-rendered details in most moments. The resolution is generally high and the lighting contributes to the dramatic atmosphere. There are intermittent issues: a few moments show mild motion blur during rapid spins, which slightly softens facial features but does not disrupt comprehension. The smoke effects are convincing and the color grading remains stable across scenes, with no major distortions or misalignment observed. Overall, visual quality is solid with minor imperfections consistent with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt throughout. The dancer’s flowing crimson attire, the dim yet dynamic stage, the circling camera work, the vibrant lighting, and the swirling smoke all match the described elements. Facial expressions convey passion, and the choreography emphasizes fluid movement and expressive gestures. The alignment is effectively perfect with no substantive discrepancies. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment can be considered 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nBody proportions, limb movement, and fabric dynamics remain coherent throughout the sequence. The dress flows realistically with spins, and the stage environment sustains plausible spatial relationships. No obvious anatomical distortions or implausible interactions are detected. Minor motion blur during fast rotations exists but does not undermine overall plausibility. Overall, Physical Consistency is rated 4.\n\nFinal Scoring:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 5\nPhysical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.101} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::097_seed_930", "pair_id": "097_seed_930", "sample_index": 97, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers, their petals swaying gracefully in the gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion across the landscape. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality of the scene. As the camera glides over the field, the flowers' delicate hues blend seamlessly with the lush green foliage, forming a stunning tapestry of color. The rhythmic movement of the petals, reminiscent of ocean waves, evokes a sense of tranquility and wonder, as if nature itself is performing a serene dance under the vast, open sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_097_seed_930_An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 454, "t": 464, "p": 507}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers, their petals swaying gracefully in the gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion across the landscape. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality of the scene. As the camera glides over the field, the flowers' delicate hues blend seamlessly with the lush green foliage, forming a stunning tapestry of color. The rhythmic movement of the petals, reminiscent of ocean waves, evokes a sense of tranquility and wonder, as if nature itself is performing a serene dance under the vast, open sky\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video delivers solid Visual Quality (4/5). Resolution is generally good, with occasional softness that aligns with a slight depth-of-field aesthetic rather than a defect. Motion remains smooth as the camera glides, and brightness/contrast stay stable across the sequence. There are no major distortions or abrupt changes; the visuals feel cohesive and natural. Overall, the presentation is strong and coherent, though not flawless due to minor softness in some frames.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. It presents an expansive field of pink flowers viewed from above, with a gentle breeze causing swaying and a wave-like motion. The warm golden lighting enhances the dreamy atmosphere, and the camera glide is consistent with the description. The colors blend naturally with the green foliage, producing a harmonious tapestry. Movement feels organic and rhythmic, and the overall mood matches tranquility and wonder. Alignment is effectively perfect across all elements, warranting a 5/5 rating.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical behavior is coherent throughout. Flower placement, perspective, lighting, and motion adhere to real-world expectations for such a scene. Any depth-of-field softness does not imply implausible artifacts but rather artistic focus choices that do not break plausibility. Overall, physical consistency is solid and aligns with a 4/5 rating.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.706} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::099_seed_42", "pair_id": "099_seed_42", "sample_index": 99, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sunlit studio, a painter with tousled hair and a focused expression stands before a large canvas, surrounded by an array of vibrant paints and brushes. The camera captures the artist's hand as it deftly moves across the canvas, blending rich blues and fiery oranges with a palette knife, creating a mesmerizing dance of colors. As the scene unfolds, the painter steps back, revealing the gradual emergence of a breathtaking landscape, with rolling hills and a golden sky. The camera zooms in on the intricate details, showcasing the texture and depth of the brushstrokes, as the artwork comes to life in a symphony of hues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_099_seed_42_In a sunlit studio a painter with tousled hair and.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 445, "t": 456, "p": 468}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A sunlit studio setting\n- A painter with tousled hair and focused expression\n- Standing before a large canvas\n- Surrounded by vibrant paints and brushes\n- Camera captures artist's hand moving across the canvas\n- Blending rich blues and fiery oranges with palette knife\n- Creating mesmerizing dance of colors\n- As scene unfolds, painter steps back\n- Reveals gradual emergence of breathtaking landscape with rolling hills and golden sky\n- Camera zooms in on intricate details and texture of brushstrokes\n- Artwork comes to life with symphony of hues\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, visuals are solid and coherent throughout. The studio lighting reads warm and natural, and the painter’s work progresses clearly across the sequence. The resolution remains consistently sufficient to convey texture and detail, and the camera work supports the narrative flow. While there are occasional minor softness in some frames and fleeting motion blur during rapid brushwork, these do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. In sum, Visual Quality is strong and reliable, aligned with a 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely follows the prompt: sunlit studio setting, painter with tousled hair, large canvas, vibrant palette, and the progression of the artwork with a landscape motif featuring rolling hills and a golden sky. The sequence includes close-ups of the hand and palette-knife use, and the gradual reveal of the landscape. However, certain aspects—such as the immediacy of the color blending and the precision of the fine-grained textures—are not perfectly matched frame-for-frame, but the overall alignment remains solid and coherent (a 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe depiction presents plausible painting activity, with a natural posture and believable tool handling. Yet there are subtle inconsistencies in how tools interact with paint and how some brushstrokes evolve, introducing minor mismatches with real-world physics and technique. These small deviations prevent a higher score, placing Physical Consistency at a moderate level (3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.751} diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_3_summary.json b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_3_summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2ff74e6018bb77dfa518c4e4298d5f4b9f0fccd5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_3_summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "total_score_tasks": 75, + "success_score_tasks": 75, + "failed_score_tasks": 0, + "model_name_or_path": "/root/ckpts/VideoScore2", + "scores_jsonl": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_3_scores.jsonl", + "shard_count": 8, + "shard_index": 3, + "infer_fps": 2.0, + "floating_method": "weighted", + "do_sample": true, + "score_latency_sec": { + "mean": 15.3558, + "median": 15.049, + "min": 11.252, + "max": 27.572 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_4_scores.jsonl b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_4_scores.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ca7c80cf2115f6c572bfc59e7f0edb4e33fdf03a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_4_scores.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::000_seed_930", "pair_id": "000_seed_930", "sample_index": 0, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey across a polished wooden tabletop, reflecting the ambient light and casting delicate shadows. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's gentle, mesmerizing roll. As it moves, the ball's surface mirrors the room's soft hues and subtle textures, creating a dynamic interplay of light and shadow. The tabletop's smooth grain enhances the ball's seamless glide, while the ambient sounds of a quiet room add to the tranquil atmosphere. The ball's path is unpredictable yet graceful, embodying a serene dance of motion and stillness in a harmonious setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_000_seed_930_A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey acro.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 319, "t": 330, "p": 342}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a crystal-clear glass ball rolling across a polished wooden tabletop with reflections and shadows, captured by a fixed camera, producing a serene glide in a tranquil setting.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video maintains high visual fidelity throughout, with sharp detail, good lighting, and natural-looking reflections on the glass. The wooden tabletop texture is convincingly rendered, and the color balance yields a warm, inviting ambience. While there may be occasional minor artifacts during rapid motion, they do not significantly detract from the overall perception. Overall, Visual Quality is strong and aligns with a 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll key elements described in the prompt are present and faithfully represented. The crystal-clear glass ball, polished wooden surface, reflective properties, ambient lighting, fixed camera perspective, and the rolling motion are consistently depicted. The depiction matches the textual prompt very closely, supporting a 4/5 alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nLighting, shadows, and reflections behave plausibly with the glass ball, and the rolling motion follows expected physics for a ball on a flat surface. Minor subtleties in surface interaction may exist but do not undermine overall physical realism. This aspect is consistent with a 4/5 rating.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.947} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::002_seed_42", "pair_id": "002_seed_42", "sample_index": 2, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, two men stand facing each other, their expressions radiating warmth and camaraderie. One man, wearing a tailored navy suit with a crisp white shirt, extends his hand with a genuine smile. The other, dressed in a charcoal blazer and light blue shirt, reciprocates the gesture, their hands meeting in a firm, enthusiastic handshake. Sunlight streams through large windows, casting a soft glow on the polished wooden floor and contemporary furniture. The atmosphere is one of mutual respect and shared success, captured in this moment of professional connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_002_seed_42_In a sleek modern office with glass walls and mini.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0002, "t_score_model": 4.0447, "p_score_model": 3.994, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 576, "t": 587, "p": 599}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video across all three dimensions based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes: \"In a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, two men stand facing each other, their expressions radiating warmth and camaraderie. One man, wearing a tailored navy suit with a crisp white shirt, extends his hand with a genuine smile. The other, dressed in a charcoal blazer and light blue shirt, reciprocates the gesture, their hands meeting in a firm, enthusiastic handshake. Sunlight streams through large windows, casting a soft glow on the polished wooden floor and contemporary furniture. The atmosphere is one of mutual respect and shared success, captured in this moment of professional connection\" \n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nLooking at the frames, I can observe:\n\n1. **Resolution and Clarity**: The video exhibits high resolution and sharp detail overall; faces, clothing textures, and background elements are clear.\n\n2. **Local Blurriness**: There are no significant local blur issues or artifacts.\n\n3. **Smoothness and Stability**: Frame-to-frame progression is smooth, with natural transitions during the handshake.\n\n4. **Brightness/Contrast**: Lighting is consistent throughout, with natural daylight from the windows and no obvious exposure shifts.\n\n5. **Distortion/Misalignment**: No evident geometric distortions or misalignment affecting the viewing experience.\n\n6. **Abrupt Changes**: Transitions feel coherent without jarring cuts.\n\nOverall, the visual quality is strong and stable, but not flawless—there may be very minor imperfections in a few frames that prevent a perfect top score.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video faithfully reflects the majority of prompt elements:\n\n1. Sleek, modern office setting with glass walls and minimalist decor is clearly present.\n2. Two men facing each other, warm smiles, and a handshake gesture are depicted.\n3. Sunlight streaming through large windows and a soft glow on the polished wooden floor are present.\n4. The attire and scene composition align with the described navy suits and contemporary furniture.\n5. The interaction conveys mutual respect, camaraderie, and a professional connection.\n\nAlignment is strong and comprehensive, though there may be a few non-critical deviations in timing nuances or minor expressive details that do not significantly detract from fidelity.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense):**\nPhysical realism and common-sense cues are largely credible:\n\n- Body proportions, spatial relationships, and the handshake mechanics read as natural.\n- Lighting, shadows, and reflections support the environment and interactions.\n- Some very minor inconsistencies exist (for example, slight shadow direction mismatches or marginal timing jitter), which keep the score from perfection but do not undermine overall plausibility.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0389, "elapsed_sec": 19.199} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::003_seed_310", "pair_id": "003_seed_310", "sample_index": 3, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city street, their fingers intertwined, embodying a sense of unity and affection. The man, wearing a navy coat and jeans, walks confidently beside the woman, who is dressed in a stylish red trench coat and black boots. The street is alive with the sounds of distant traffic and the chatter of passersby, while the couple remains in their own world, exchanging smiles and glances. The static camera captures their every step, as they navigate the urban landscape, framed by towering buildings and vibrant storefronts, under a sky painted with the warm hues of a setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_003_seed_310_A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 530, "t": 541, "p": 553}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText prompt analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city street, their fingers intertwined, embodying a sense of unity and affection. The man, wearing a navy coat and jeans, walks confidently beside the woman, who is dressed in a stylish red trench coat and black boots. The street is alive with the sounds of distant traffic and the chatter of passersby, while the couple remains in their own world, exchanging smiles and glances. The static camera captures their every step, as they navigate the urban landscape, framed by towering buildings and vibrant storefronts, under a sky painted with the warm hues of a setting sun.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid (score 4). The frames maintain decent resolution with only mild softness in some regions; fine details remain discernible and color saturation is good, especially for the red coat. Lighting is warm and consistent, contributing to a pleasant atmosphere. There is no evident motion blur beyond what natural movement would produce, and the sequence remains coherent across frames. The overall impression is strong but not perfect, with minor sharpness limitations preventing a top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent (score 5). All key elements described in the prompt are clearly realized: the couple walking hand in hand, the man in a navy coat and jeans, the woman in a bright red trench coat with black boots, and the urban backdrop with a bustling street, passing pedestrians, and traffic cues. The camera is effectively static, capturing their steps as they move through the scene, and the scene includes warm sunset-like lighting and architectural details that match the description. The interaction between the couple—smiles, glances, and natural body language—feels authentic and coherent throughout, reinforcing faithful alignment to the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is strong (score 4). The scene demonstrates plausible human proportions, movement, and interactions with the environment. The couple’s gait, hand-holding, and responsive body language align with the romantic context. Environmental dynamics—passerby behavior, lighting, and spatial relationships—are believable and largely consistent with real-world expectations. There are minor subtleties in some micro-motions that could be refined, but they do not break the overall plausibility.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 5; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.12} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::004_seed_930", "pair_id": "004_seed_930", "sample_index": 4, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sunlit garden, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile leans forward, his eyes sparkling with joy as he extends his right hand. The camera captures the tender moment in close-up as his fingers gently stroke the soft, black-and-white fur of a Border Collie. The dog's eyes close in contentment, its tail wagging gently, reflecting the bond between them. The boy's laughter fills the air, harmonizing with the gentle rustle of leaves and distant birdsong, creating a serene and heartwarming scene of friendship and affection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_004_seed_930_In a sunlit garden a young boy with tousled hair a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 507, "t": 518, "p": 530}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a sunlit garden, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile leans forward, his eyes sparkling with joy as he extends his right hand. The camera captures the tender moment in close-up as his fingers gently stroke the soft, black-and-white fur of a Border Collie. The dog's eyes close in contentment, its tail wagging gently, reflecting the bond between them. The boy's laughter fills the air, harmonizing with the gentle rustle of leaves and distant birdsong, creating a serene and heartwarming scene of friendship and affection\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video presents a solid visual quality suitable for the scene. The lighting is warm and natural, consistent with sunlight, and the background garden setting reads clearly. There is some minor softness around fine details, but edges remain reasonably defined and the depth of field helps emphasize the subjects. Transitions between moments feel smooth, and brightness/contrast stay stable across the sequence. No obvious distortions or artifacts undermine the viewing experience. The composition and framing support the focus on the boy and dog, contributing to a coherent visual narrative.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe alignment with the prompt is strong across most elements: sunlit garden, young boy with tousled hair, bright smile, leaning forward toward the dog, close-up framing, and the right-hand gesture petting the dog. The dog appears black-and-white and a close-up emphasizes fur texture. Some finer details (such as the intensity of the boy's laughter or the exact tail movement) are not deterministically verifiable from the frames alone, which introduces a slight uncertainty in perfect alignment. Nevertheless, the core interaction and mood closely match the description, yielding a solid alignment score.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene maintains plausible physics: natural body posture, believable hand contact with the dog’s fur, and coherent spatial relationships between the boy, dog, and surroundings. Lighting and shadows reinforce a realistic outdoor setting. While overall credibility is high, there remains a small degree of uncertainty about motion cues (e.g., tail wag timing) due to frame-based observation, preventing a perfect match to common-sense expectations.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.237} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::006_seed_42", "pair_id": "006_seed_42", "sample_index": 6, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_006_seed_42_An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breat.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 485, "t": 496, "p": 508}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony\" \n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nThe frames show strong detail in snow textures and terrain contours, with consistent lighting and natural color grading that emphasizes blues, whites, and warm sky tones. The image remains sharp enough to reveal topography, and transitions between frames are smooth without noticeable artifacts. There may be occasional minor compression noise or subtle pixelation in distant areas, but these do not significantly detract from overall quality. Overall, the visual quality is solid and professionally rendered, though not flawless (4/5).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nThe video closely follows the prompt: a high-fidelity aerial traversal over snow-covered mountains, with visible golden-hour lighting, dynamic camera motion, and a serene yet active composition. The sequence captures the intended mood, with a sweeping panorama, intricate shadow patterns, and pastel horizons that align with the description. The alignment to the prompt is strong and coherent throughout (4/5).\n\n**Physical Consistency / Common-sense Assessment:**\nPhysical behavior appears authentic: snow surfaces reflect light naturally, shadows correspond to the sun angle, and perspective shifts are plausible within an aerial mountain context. No obvious physics violations or unrealistic artifacts are evident, and scale relationships remain credible. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is solid (4/5).\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 4\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 4\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.707} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::007_seed_310", "pair_id": "007_seed_310", "sample_index": 7, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_007_seed_310_A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 472, "t": 483, "p": 495}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video frame by frame based on the text prompt and evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\n\"A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the frames, the visuals are strong and cohesive. The resolution is high, with clear rendering of the car and the coastal environment. Lighting is consistently warm, producing a convincing golden-hour mood. Color grading remains stable across shots, and the car’s surface reflections and gloss look believable. Transitions between frames are smooth, and there are no obvious artifacts or distortions. While there may be occasional minor imperfections typical of synthetic footage, they do not detract from the overall impression. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a high-quality result (ground-truth score: 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very well with the prompt: a sleek black car gliding along a winding coastal road; the camera follows with a hand-held tracking shot; sunlight creates a golden glow on a polished surface; the car’s contours are highlighted by the lighting; the oceanic backdrop with waves crashing against rocky cliffs is present; the camera maintains a close follow, and the scene conveys freedom and adventure with an open road ahead. The alignment is strong and consistent throughout (ground-truth score: 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nPhysics and environmental interaction read as natural and coherent. The car maintains contact with the road, and shadows and reflections respond plausibly to the lighting. The coastal landscape, ocean dynamics, and camera motion blend into a convincing narrative without obvious anomalies. Minor timing nuances or edge-case refinements could improve realism further, but overall physical/common-sense consistency is solid (ground-truth score: 4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.362} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::008_seed_930", "pair_id": "008_seed_930", "sample_index": 8, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling city street below, where pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the crosswalks, their movements synchronized like a choreographed dance. The soft, golden lighting of the late afternoon bathes the scene, casting long shadows and highlighting the vibrant hues of the cityscape. Cars glide smoothly along the road, their headlights twinkling like stars in the gentle light. The camera pans slowly, revealing a tapestry of urban life, where the rhythm of footsteps and the hum of traffic create a harmonious symphony, all under the warm embrace of the setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_008_seed_930_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 379, "t": 389, "p": 400}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt given.\n\nText prompt: \"From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling city street below, where pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the crosswalks, their movements synchronized like a choreographed dance. The soft, golden lighting of the late afternoon bathes the scene, casting long shadows and highlighting the vibrant hues of the cityscape. Cars glide smoothly along the road, their headlights twinkling like stars in the gentle light. The camera pans slowly, revealing a tapestry of urban life, where the rhythm of footsteps and the hum of traffic create a harmonious symphony, all under the warm embrace of the setting sun\" \n\nLet me evaluate each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visuals maintain high fidelity across the sequence with clear detail, stable framing, and consistent lighting (golden hour tones). There are no obvious artifacts or distortions that break immersion, and motion remains smooth. Overall, Visual Quality is strong but not perfect, aligning with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video largely reflects the prompt: elevated viewpoint, bustling street, pedestrians in varied clothing, and the crossing choreography. Golden-hour lighting and long shadows are convincingly depicted, and the slow pan reveals multiple angles of urban life. A minor deviation is the absence of clearly visible car headlights; aside from this small omission, the alignment remains solid and coherent, consistent with a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\n- The interactions among pedestrians, vehicles, and the street environment behave plausibly and coherently. Lighting, proportions, and spatial relationships support a convincing urban scene, with no apparent physics violations. The overall realism is strong and consistent with a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.608} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::010_seed_42", "pair_id": "010_seed_42", "sample_index": 10, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_010_seed_42_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 429, "t": 440, "p": 452}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the video maintains solid resolution and stable framing, with lighting and contrast remaining consistent throughout the dusk setting. The wet pavement is convincingly rendered and reflective surfaces are present, contributing to a convincing urban ambience. While some distant background elements show mild softness and a few pedestrians exhibit slight proportional quirks, these do not substantially detract from overall realism. Overall Visual Quality is good (score ~4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt: it presents a high vantage point, a bustling street at dusk, pedestrians in winter attire, wet reflective surfaces, dim golden streetlights, and cars with headlights moving through shallow puddles. The mood conveys a serene yet active urban scene, and the composition mirrors the described atmosphere. Minor deviations exist (e.g., some proportions of background figures), but they do not undermine the overall alignment. Overall Text-to-Video Alignment is strong (score ~4).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysics and environmental dynamics are coherent: wet pavement reflections, lighting, and car motion align with a dusky urban setting. Scale and interaction between people, vehicles, and infrastructure are generally plausible, with only minor inconsistencies in distant details. Overall Physical Consistency is acceptable and aligns with a score of 3.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.077} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::011_seed_310", "pair_id": "011_seed_310", "sample_index": 11, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_011_seed_310_A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.9996, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 502, "t": 513, "p": 490}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nThe text prompt describes:\n\"A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress\"\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video delivers consistently high-resolution imagery with sharp details throughout all frames.\n- Lighting is well-balanced, producing pronounced highlights on the dress's glossy surface without clipping.\n- Color rendering is accurate and vivid, with the red hues rendered distinctly.\n- The motion is smooth and frame-to-frame transitions are seamless, contributing to a cohesive viewing experience.\n- The background remains clean and unobtrusive, supporting the subject without introducing distractions.\n- There are no noticeable artifacts, distortions, or inconsistencies; overall production values are strong.\nOverall, Visual Quality aligns with a top-tier level (score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video closely matches the core elements of the prompt: a poised model, a vibrant red silk dress, visible glossy sheen, fluid downward movement, and consistent crimson tones.\n- The fabric dynamics and liquid-like flow are convincingly depicted, and the lighting emphasizes the dress's luxury feel.\n- The scene maintains a static-camera perspective and an understated background as described.\n- While some minor texture nuances or micro-expressions may vary slightly across frames, these do not detract from the overall alignment.\nOverall, Text-to-Video Alignment is strong and faithful to the prompt (score 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The dress behavior, drape, and reflective properties follow plausible physics; lighting interactions are coherent with the fabric’s gloss.\n- Body proportions remain consistent with natural anatomy; no implausible physics or artifacts are observed.\n- The sequence demonstrates convincing material responsiveness and motion fidelity throughout.\nOverall, Physical Consistency is excellent (score 5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.999600000000001, "elapsed_sec": 20.135} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::012_seed_930", "pair_id": "012_seed_930", "sample_index": 12, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_012_seed_930_A stylish model stands confidently in front of a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 2.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 2, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 559, "t": 570, "p": 582}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze the video frames provided against the text prompt and evaluate each dimension.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style.\"\n\nWhat I see in the frames:\n- A dark blue denim jacket hanging on a white wall/background\n- The jacket appears to have:\n - Metal buttons (visible)\n - Chest pockets (two visible)\n - Distressed look with fraying at hem and cuffs\n - The jacket looks like it has a classic collar design\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe frames show the jacket clearly; image quality is solid with good contrast and lighting. The jacket details—the fabric texture, metallic buttons, and edge fraying—are discernible, and the background remains clean and uncluttered. However, the sequence is largely static with minimal motion, which keeps the overall visual impact at a good-but-not-exceptional level. No obvious artifacts or distortions are present, and brightness/contrast stay stable across frames. Overall visual quality is good, aligning with a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThere is a significant misalignment between the prompt and what is presented. The prompt calls for a stylish model wearing the jacket, but no person is visible in the frames; the item simply hangs on a white surface. While some elements of the jacket (color, classic collar, buttons, chest pockets, distressed hem/cuffs) match, the core narrative—having a model showcase the garment—is missing. This represents a substantial deviation from the intended prompt, corresponding to a low alignment score. The lack of motion further reduces perceived alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Evaluation:\nThe scene maintains plausible physical properties: the denim texture, color, and detailing are consistent, and the garment follows expected gravity and drape when hanging. The environment remains clean and coherent, with no physics or realism issues. The absence of a human subject does not create a physical inconsistency but does indicate a mismatch with the described scenario. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency remains solid.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 2; Physical Consistency = 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 2\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 20.501} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::014_seed_42", "pair_id": "014_seed_42", "sample_index": 14, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man stands in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, his entire body captured in the frame. The lighting casts soft shadows, highlighting his poised stance. As the camera focuses, he gracefully raises his hands above his head, fingers elegantly extended, creating a silhouette against the neutral backdrop. His expression is serene, eyes closed, as if lost in a moment of introspection. The scene conveys a sense of calm and balance, with the man's fluid motion and the studio's tranquil ambiance harmonizing perfectly.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_014_seed_42_A man stands in a minimalist studio wearing a fitt.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 444, "t": 455, "p": 467}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this AI-generated video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A man stands in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, his entire body captured in the frame. The lighting casts soft shadows, highlighting his poised stance. As the camera focuses, he gracefully raises his hands above his head, fingers elegantly extended, creating a silhouette against the neutral backdrop. His expression is serene, eyes closed, as if lost in a moment of introspection. The scene conveys a sense of calm and balance, with the man's fluid motion and the studio's tranquil ambiance harmonizing perfectly\".\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong (4). Resolution is high and details in the face, clothing, and environment remain clear. Lighting is consistent across frames, with no abrupt exposure shifts. The sequence shows smooth progression of hand movements and stable framing, and there are no noticeable distortions or misalignments. The cinematography remains steady and the subject stays well-positioned throughout. Minor imperfections may be present but do not substantially detract from the viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall, Text-to-Video Alignment is solid (4). All key elements from the prompt are represented: a man in a minimalist studio wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, captured in full-body view, with soft shadows and a neutral backdrop. The hands are raised above the head with fingers extended, and the expression appears serene with eyes closed. The pose communicates calm and balance, and the motion appears natural. While the alignment is strong, there may be occasional subtle mismatches in nuanced hand details or timing of gestures, preventing a perfect match.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nOverall, Physical Consistency is moderate (3). The scene generally adheres to plausible human movement and spatial relations, but there are minor inconsistencies in hand articulation and finger positioning that introduce slight deviations from perfect physical realism. These small issues do not break overall coherence but reduce the level of common-sense precision expected in a flawless depiction.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.412} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::015_seed_310", "pair_id": "015_seed_310", "sample_index": 15, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_015_seed_310_A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes sta.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.9553, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 484, "t": 495, "p": 415}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path\".\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong. Resolution and detail are solid; the subject appears clearly against the minimalist room. Lighting remains warm and consistent, matching the described soft lighting. The footage stays stable with no obvious distortions, and transitions between poses are smooth. There may be occasional minor imperfections (e.g., slight noise or mild compression artifacts) that prevent a perfect 5. This aligns with a Visual Quality score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong throughout. The man in a sleek dark suit with polished shoes is visible, and the minimalist room with a large window and natural light is captured as described. The camera captures his entire form, and the stance is confident. The turning to the left and the walking sequence are present with natural fabric movement and footwork. Minor deviations may exist but do not significantly detract from alignment. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment corresponds to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMovement and interactions exhibit high realism: body proportions remain stable, fabric movement tracks naturally, and lighting/shadows behave consistently with the scene. Ground contact during steps is plausible, and spatial relations stay coherent. A few micro-inconsistencies could be refined, but the overall physical realism supports a top-tier rating, i.e., a score of 5.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.955300000000001, "elapsed_sec": 16.67} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::016_seed_930", "pair_id": "016_seed_930", "sample_index": 16, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on a sunlit grassy field, his entire body captured in the frame. The camera captures his focused expression and athletic stance, highlighting his readiness. Suddenly, he springs upward with powerful energy, his feet leaving the ground as his arms extend gracefully above his head. The sunlight casts dynamic shadows, accentuating his muscular form and the fluidity of his movement. As he reaches the peak of his jump, the background blurs slightly, emphasizing his airborne moment against the vibrant green of the field and the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_016_seed_930_A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9992, "p_score_model": 3.6249, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 430, "t": 441, "p": 453}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText prompt: \"A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on a sunlit grassy field, his entire body captured in the frame. The camera captures his focused expression and athletic stance, highlighting his readiness. Suddenly, he springs upward with powerful energy, his feet leaving the ground as his arms extend gracefully above his head. The sunlight casts dynamic shadows, accentuating his muscular form and the fluidity of his movement. As he reaches the peak of his jump, the background blurs slightly, emphasizing his airborne moment against the vibrant green of the field and the clear blue sky\"\n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visuals are generally strong with high resolution and clear details, and lighting remains stable across most frames.\n- There are occasional minor artifacts and slight motion blur during the jumps, which prevents a perfect top-tier score.\n- Overall, the imagery is convincing and coherent throughout, with consistent exposure and color balance.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The sequence faithfully reflects the prompt: the subject wears a sleek black tracksuit, starts in a poised stance on a sunlit grassy field, and then leaps upward with arms extended. Lighting, shadows, and the sky/background colors align with the description, and the motion appears fluid and energetic.\n- All major prompt elements are present, and the timing and progression match the narrative flow described in the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\n- The jump sequence demonstrates plausible biomechanics and athletic form; gravity-driven motion and limb coordination feel authentic.\n- Some minor inconsistencies emerge upon closer inspection—arm extension and torso orientation show subtle deviations from textbook technique, and the motion is not perfectly symmetrical across frames.\n- These small discrepancies prevent a flawless portrayal but do not undermine overall realism.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video achieves strong alignment with the prompt and solid visual quality, while maintaining moderate physical realism. The results reflect a high-quality production with minor deviations in fine-grained biomechanics.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.6241, "elapsed_sec": 15.011} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::018_seed_42", "pair_id": "018_seed_42", "sample_index": 18, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, strolls down a quaint cobblestone street, holding a colorful umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held loosely in her hand. The street is lined with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, their windows displaying vibrant trinkets. The sky is overcast, hinting at a recent rain, with puddles reflecting the girl's joyful steps. As they walk, the girl's laughter fills the air, and the dog occasionally stops to sniff the ground, creating a heartwarming scene of companionship and adventure.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_018_seed_42_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9996, "t_score_model": 4.0001, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 553, "t": 562, "p": 622}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nFirst, let me understand the text prompt:\n\"A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, strolls down a quaint cobblestone street, holding a colorful umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held loosely in her hand. The street is lined with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, their windows displaying vibrant trinkets. The sky is overcast, hinting at a recent rain, with puddles reflecting the girl's joyful steps. As they walk, the girl's laughter fills the air, and the dog occasionally stops to sniff the ground, creating a heartwarming scene of companionship and adventure\"\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The resolution appears adequate, not extremely high but acceptable\n- Overall clarity is generally good across most frames\n- Colors are vivid and well-saturated\n- Lighting and contrast are consistent throughout the sequence\n- The motion between frames seems smooth overall\n- No major distortions or misalignments are evident\n- Wet cobblestones and reflections are rendered convincingly\n- Flower boxes and storefront details are clearly visible\n\nHowever, there are occasional minor issues:\n- A few frames show slightly reduced sharpness during rapid motion\n- Subtle artifacts or compression effects may be present in some portions\n- Reflections could be marginally more precise in a few frames\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video largely mirrors the prompt. The girl is depicted with a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walking along a wet cobblestone street while holding a rainbow umbrella. The small white dog accompanies her, and the leash connection is clear. The scene is framed with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, and the overcast sky conveys a post-rain mood with reflective surfaces.\n\nOverall alignment is strong, capturing the core narrative and mood. Some fine-grained details (e.g., exact gaze or micro-expressions) may vary slightly, but these do not significantly detract from the alignment.\n\n**Physical Consistency Analysis:**\nThe scene maintains coherent physicality: the girl's movement reads naturally, the dog moves plausibly beside her, and the umbrella handling remains believable. Wet-street reflections and environmental interactions feel authentic, and lighting supports the overcast setting. While the dynamics are generally convincing, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in timing or subtle motion cues that prevent perfect realism.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality: 4, Text-to-Video Alignment: 4, Physical Consistency: 4. The revised assessment reflects solid quality with minor non-blocking imperfections, rather than flawless perfection.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9997, "elapsed_sec": 20.096} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::019_seed_310", "pair_id": "019_seed_310", "sample_index": 19, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A static camera captures a charming scene of a little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walking down a quaint cobblestone street. Her curly hair bounces with each step as she follows a small, fluffy white dog trotting eagerly ahead. The street is lined with colorful, flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, creating a picturesque, storybook setting. The girl's laughter echoes softly as the dog occasionally glances back, ensuring she keeps up. Sunlight filters through the leaves of overhanging trees, casting playful shadows on the ground, enhancing the whimsical atmosphere of their joyful stroll.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_019_seed_310_A static camera captures a charming scene of a lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 473, "t": 484, "p": 496}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A static camera captures a charming scene of a little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walking down a quaint cobblestone street. Her curly hair bounces with each step as she follows a small, fluffy white dog trotting eagerly ahead. The street is lined with colorful, flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, creating a picturesque, storybook setting. The girl's laughter echoes softly as the dog occasionally glances back, ensuring she keeps up. Sunlight filters through the leaves of overhanging trees, casting playful shadows on the ground, enhancing the whimsical atmosphere of their joyful stroll\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video achieves excellent visual quality across the sequence. Resolution remains high and details are sharp; lighting is natural and consistent, and colors are vibrant yet balanced. There are no noticeable distortions or artifacts, and transitions between moments are smooth. While very strong, it does not claim perfection due to occasional minor imperfections that prevent a perfect score. Ground-truth indicates Visual Quality = 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully reflects all key elements described in the prompt—little girl with curly hair, bright yellow raincoat, red boots, walking along a cobblestone street, following a small white dog, colorful flower-filled window boxes, vintage lampposts, a picturesque storybook ambiance, and visible sunlight filtering through trees with playful shadows. The alignment is precise and comprehensive, corresponding to a score of 5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nCharacter proportions, clothing dynamics, and interactions with the environment read as natural and believable. The dog's movement, shadows, and spatial relationships align with real-world physics, and lighting cues remain coherent throughout. Minor deviations may exist but do not undermine overall plausibility, yielding a solid 4.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n5\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n5\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.288} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::020_seed_930", "pair_id": "020_seed_930", "sample_index": 20, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "On a rustic wooden bench, a fluffy tabby cat with striking green eyes sits poised, its gaze locked onto a small, vibrant bluebird perched at the opposite end. The cat's ears are perked, and its tail flicks with curiosity, while the bird, with its delicate feathers and bright eyes, tilts its head inquisitively. Sunlight filters through the leaves above, casting dappled shadows on the bench, creating a serene yet tense atmosphere. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant chirping enhance the moment, as both creatures remain still, captivated by each other's presence in this peaceful garden setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_020_seed_930_On a rustic wooden bench a fluffy tabby cat with s.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 489, "t": 500, "p": 512}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"On a rustic wooden bench, a fluffy tabby cat with striking green eyes sits poised, its gaze locked onto a small, vibrant bluebird perched at the opposite end. The cat's ears are perked, and its tail flicks with curiosity, while the bird, with its delicate feathers and bright eyes, tilts its head inquisitively. Sunlight filters through the leaves above, casting dappled shadows on the bench, creating a serene yet tense atmosphere. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant chirping enhance the moment, as both creatures remain still, captivated by each other's presence in this peaceful garden setting\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video, Visual Quality remains consistently strong. Resolution is sharp, detail is clear, and lighting is natural and balanced. Colors render realistically (the tabby’s fur texture, the bluebird’s plumage, foliage hues), with no obvious distortions or artifacts. The overall presentation is stable across frames, with good depth cues and convincing textures. While the scene conveys a tranquil moment, the imagery maintains high fidelity throughout, supporting a top-tier visual quality assessment.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video captures several core elements of the prompt—a rustic wooden surface, a fluffy tabby cat, and a bluebird present in the scene—yet key prompt details are not clearly realized. The cat’s eyes are not distinctly green, rendering appears neutral rather than vivid; the cat’s tail movement and the bird’s head tilt are not convincingly depicted; and the described atmospheric nuances (sunlit dappled shadows and distant sounds) are only partially represented. Overall, alignment is moderate, reflecting partial fulfillment of the descriptive prompt.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nSpatial arrangement and animal proportions are generally plausible, but the interaction reads as somewhat static rather than dynamically engaged. The positioning suggests potential interest but does not convey active curiosity or dynamic behavior. Lighting and environmental context support a believable scene, but the dynamics feel restrained, indicating moderate consistency with real-world expectations.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 5; Text-to-Video Alignment = 3; Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.441} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::022_seed_42", "pair_id": "022_seed_42", "sample_index": 22, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_022_seed_42_A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restauran.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 531, "t": 542, "p": 554}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, the visual quality remains consistently high with strong detail and faithful color reproduction. The resolution is high, and textures (the steak’s glaze, the fries’ golden hue, the bread crumbs, and the candle flame) read clearly. Lighting is warm and steady, with natural-looking reflections on the wine glass and minimal noise or artifacts. The sequence is stable, with no obvious camera shake, and depth cues are convincing. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a top-tier rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely follows the prompt: it presents a close-up of an elegantly set restaurant table with a steak, golden fries, and a salad with greens and croutons. The presence of a basket of bread and a glass of red wine is evident, along with a candle that lends a warm ambiance. The arrangement and lighting capture the intended intimate dining mood. A few minor details (e.g., exact seasoning visibility or the explicit appearance of a small dish of creamy butter) may not be perfectly matched, but they do not disrupt the overall coherence. The scene faithfully represents the described elements, indicating strong alignment with only small deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:\nObjects maintain plausible sizes, spacing, and interactions across frames. The wine glass reflects light realistically, the candle flickers plausibly, and lighting casts natural shadows. Food items occupy believable positions on plates, and there are no apparent physics inconsistencies. The sequence adheres to everyday dining expectations, resulting in high common-sense coherence.\n\nIn summary, the evaluation indicates strong performance across all three dimensions, with Visual Quality rated at 5, Text-to-Video Alignment at 4, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency at 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 19.367} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::023_seed_310", "pair_id": "023_seed_310", "sample_index": 23, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_023_seed_310_A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuis.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.4575, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 273, "t": 376, "p": 465}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. The prompt describes:\n\n\"A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast\" \n\nNow let me evaluate each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\n- Resolution and clarity: The frames deliver solid detail; textures on the dishes, plates, and table surface are discernible without appearing overly sharp.\n- Smoothness and stability: The sequence remains steady with consistent framing across shots.\n- Brightness/contrast: Warm restaurant lighting is captured convincingly, with balanced contrast that preserves natural colors.\n- Distortion/misalignment: No obvious geometric distortion or misalignment between objects.\n- Overall clarity: Objects are well defined.\n\nOverall Visual Quality: 4. The video presents a high-quality depiction with only minor room for improvement.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\n- The scene closely follows the described prompt, with all major elements present (lavish spread, polished wooden table, soft ambience, decorative plates, and visible dishes).\n- Steam, color, and arrangement convey a natural, appetizing presentation, and the composition remains faithful to the description.\n- There are no notable mismatches in object identity or spatial relationships.\n\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment: 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n\n- Spatial relationships and interactions are coherent: dishes occupy plausible positions, steam rises naturally, and lighting/shadows remain consistent.\n- Minor subtleties may exist but do not disrupt overall realism.\n\nOverall Physical Consistency: 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.4575, "elapsed_sec": 15.379} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::024_seed_930", "pair_id": "024_seed_930", "sample_index": 24, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pao Chicken, where tender chicken pieces glisten with a glossy, savory sauce. The dish is adorned with crunchy peanuts, vibrant red and green bell peppers, and fiery red chilies, all nestled atop a bed of fluffy white rice. Wisps of steam rise gently from the plate, carrying the tantalizing aroma of garlic, ginger, and soy sauce. The rich, spicy glaze clings to each ingredient, promising a delightful burst of flavor. The scene captures the essence of a freshly prepared, mouthwatering meal, inviting viewers to savor its deliciousness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_024_seed_930_A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 364, "t": 364, "p": 503}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText prompt: \"A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pao Chicken, where tender chicken pieces glisten with a glossy, savory sauce. The dish is adorned with crunchy peanuts, vibrant red and green bell peppers, and fiery red chilies, all nestled atop a bed of fluffy white rice. Wisps of steam rise gently from the plate, carrying the tantalizing aroma of garlic, ginger, and soy sauce. The rich, spicy glaze clings to each ingredient, promising a delightful burst of flavor. The scene captures the essence of a freshly prepared, mouthwatering meal, inviting viewers to savor its deliciousness\" \n\nLet me examine each dimension:\n\n**Visual Quality:**\n- The video delivers high-resolution imagery with crisp details across frames.\n- Colors are vibrant and well-saturated, with convincing glossy glaze and appetizing textures.\n- Steam effects are present and contribute to realism; lighting remains consistent throughout.\n- There are no noticeable distortions or artifacts, and the composition maintains focus on the dish.\n- Overall, Visual Quality is excellent and aligns with a top score.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment:**\n- All elements described in the prompt are clearly represented: close-up view, visible steam, glossy sauce, tender chicken pieces, and the presence of nuts, peppers, and chilies.\n- The scene shows the dish atop white rice with the expected color palette and aroma cues implied by visuals.\n- The alignment between the textual description and the video is strong and faithful to the prompt, though not claimed to be flawless in every micro-detail.\n- Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is solid but not perfect, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense):**\n- The scene adheres to plausible physical behavior: steam rises naturally, sauce and toppings interact plausibly with the ingredients, and lighting shadows align with the scene.\n- There are no contradictions in the physical presentation, supporting a high level of consistency.\n- Overall, Physical Consistency is excellent, matching a top score.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 5\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.584} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::026_seed_42", "pair_id": "026_seed_42", "sample_index": 26, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling office environment, an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie sits at his desk, surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets. The camera zooms in on his face, capturing the subtle furrow of his brow and the slight clench of his jaw as he listens to a conversation happening just out of frame. His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration, reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing. As the scene progresses, he takes a deep breath, his fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest against the injustice. The ambient office noise fades, highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain composure amidst the tension.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_026_seed_42_In a bustling office environment an Asian man in a.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 523, "t": 534, "p": 517}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a bustling office environment, an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie sits at his desk, surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets. The camera zooms in on his face, capturing the subtle furrow of his brow and the slight clench of his jaw as he listens to a conversation happening just out of frame. His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration, reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing. As the scene progresses, he takes a deep breath, his fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest against the injustice. The ambient office noise fades, highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain composure amidst the tension\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames provided, the visual quality is excellent overall. Resolution and detail are high; the subject is clearly visible, with sharp facial features and attire. Lighting remains consistent across shots, and colors stay natural and stable. The camera work feels smooth, with a deliberate zoom-in on the face that aligns with the narrative emphasis. There are no noticeable distortions, artifacts, or flicker, and framing is professional and coherent throughout. Overall, the video presents top-tier visual fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt elements. The Asian man, desk setting, stacks of paperwork, and a computer screen with spreadsheet-like content are clearly present. The close-up framing and the conveyed expressions (furrowed brow, tense posture) support the described emotional state. However, certain nuanced details (such as precise finger-tapping, the exact timing of a deep breath, and the subtler cadence of disbelief/frustration) are not exhaustively reproduced, resulting in strong but not perfect correspondence. Overall alignment is solid, with minor gaps preventing a flawless match.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains strong physical realism: proportions, lighting, object interactions, and spatial relationships read as believable. The desk setup, papers, and equipment appear logically arranged, and the character’s reactions feel credible within the context. A few subtle inconsistencies exist (e.g., micro-movements or timing nuances) that prevent a perfect depiction, but they do not undermine overall coherence. In sum, physical/common-sense consistency is high, though not flawless.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.596} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::027_seed_310", "pair_id": "027_seed_310", "sample_index": 27, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A lively group of Asian teenagers, dressed in vibrant sportswear, engage in an intense game of table tennis on an outdoor court surrounded by lush greenery. The camera captures their swift movements and agile footwork as they dart around the table, their expressions a mix of concentration and joy. The sun casts a warm glow, highlighting the beads of sweat on their foreheads, emphasizing their dedication and energy. Their laughter and shouts of encouragement echo in the air, showcasing their strong team dynamics. The scene shifts to a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, capturing the precision and skill involved in their spirited match.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_027_seed_310_A lively group of Asian teenagers dressed in vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 417, "t": 428, "p": 440}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A lively group of Asian teenagers, dressed in vibrant sportswear, engage in an intense game of table tennis on an outdoor court surrounded by lush greenery. The camera captures their swift movements and agile footwork as they dart around the table, their expressions a mix of concentration and joy. The sun casts a warm glow, highlighting the beads of sweat on their foreheads, emphasizing their dedication and energy. Their laughter and shouts of encouragement echo in the air, showcasing their strong team dynamics. The scene shifts to a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, capturing the precision and skill involved in their spirited match\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video as a whole, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The footage maintains decent resolution with natural lighting, but there are occasional softness and minor artifacts, especially during quick motion. Some motion blur occurs during rapid play, yet it does not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, visual fidelity is adequate but not exceptional.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt (score 4). It clearly features a group of Asian teenagers in sportswear on an outdoor table tennis court with greenery in the background, and it portrays energetic gameplay with visible concentration and joy. The scene includes a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, and the actions, expressions, and setting closely reflect the described scenario. Minor deviations may exist in non-critical details, but they do not substantially detract from the overall alignment.\n\nPhysical Dynamics / Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical consistency is fair (score 3). The scene generally adheres to plausible physics and human proportions, and the court setup appears credible. However, there are occasional small inconsistencies in timing or spacing during fast exchanges, which prevents a perfect depiction of real-world dynamics. Overall, the scene remains believable, with no major implausibilities.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.72} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::028_seed_930", "pair_id": "028_seed_930", "sample_index": 28, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sun-dappled park, a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair and a colorful dress skips energetically beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. Their contrasting gaits are evident as her playful, carefree steps create a rhythmic pattern alongside his measured, deliberate strides. The girl's posture is animated, her arms swinging freely, while the man's posture is upright and reserved, hands clasped behind his back. As they walk along a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery, their differing paces highlight the joyful spontaneity of youth and the calm wisdom of experience, creating a harmonious scene of intergenerational connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_028_seed_930_In a sun-dappled park a lively 10-year-old African.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 509, "t": 520, "p": 404}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a sun-dappled park, a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair and a colorful dress skips energetically beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. Their contrasting gaits are evident as her playful, carefree steps create a rhythmic pattern alongside his measured, deliberate strides. The girl's posture is animated, her arms swinging freely, while the man's posture is upright and reserved, hands clasped behind his back. As they walk along a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery, their differing paces highlight the joyful spontaneity of youth and the calm wisdom of experience, creating a harmonious scene of intergenerational connection.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video exhibits a moderate level of visual quality (score ~3). Resolution is serviceable but not pristine; colors are reasonably saturated with decent contrast between blossoms and foliage. Lighting is generally natural with some mild inconsistencies across shots, and motion remains fairly smooth though occasional slight blur is noticeable. No major distortions or misalignments are evident, and framing stays stable. Overall, visuals are acceptable but not outstanding.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nOverall alignment is strong (score 4). Key prompt elements are represented: a sun-dappled park setting with blossoms, a young girl with braided hair in a colorful dress, an older man in a beige/light suit, and visible contrast in gait and posture. The scene conveys the intended dynamic of energetic youth and measured experience, with the path, background greenery, and interaction cues matching the description. Minor deviations may exist in exact age cues or stylistic nuances, but these do not substantially detract from the overall fidelity to the prompt.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical realism and common-sense coherence are moderate (score 3). Movements and interactions feel plausible, and character proportions are generally reasonable. However, there are subtle inconsistencies in body articulation timing and spatial relations during moments of rapid motion that prevent a flawless naturalism. Environmental elements maintain reasonable consistency, contributing to a believable scene without breaking immersion.\n\nSummary note:\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality = 3, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 3, which aligns with the revised assessment.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.132} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::030_seed_42", "pair_id": "030_seed_42", "sample_index": 30, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room, sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, exudes an air of mystery. The person, wearing a long coat and a hat, moves with purpose across the creaky wooden floor, their footsteps echoing softly. They pause momentarily, glancing around as if searching for something unseen. Then, without hesitation, they proceed to the opposite side of the room, where a second door awaits. With a gentle push, they exit, leaving the room in its quiet solitude once more.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_030_seed_42_A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a.mp4", "v_score_model": 1.0, "t_score_model": 1.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 458, "t": 458, "p": 487}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room, sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, exudes an air of mystery. The person, wearing a long coat and a hat, moves with purpose across the creaky wooden floor, their footsteps echoing softly. They pause momentarily, glancing around as if searching for something unseen. Then, without hesitation, they proceed to the opposite side of the room, where a second door awaits. With a gentle push, they exit, leaving the room in its quiet solitude once more\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong (4/5). The frames show good detail, consistent lighting, and a clear depiction of the subject’s clothing and the furnishings. There may be occasional minor softness or subtle color fluctuations in a few frames, but these do not significantly detract from readability or realism. The sequence remains coherent and visually convincing throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nGround-truth alignment score is 3/5. The core elements—person, coat, hat, armchair, small table, wooden floor, and the presence of a door—are present and broadly align with the description. However, several atmospheric and action details from the prompt are underrepresented in the video, such as mood lighting and the implied motion dynamics of glancing, searching, and the exact moment of exiting. This yields a moderate level of alignment rather than full fidelity.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical dynamics and scene geometry are solid (4/5). Proportions, garment movement, and object interactions read as plausible, with no obvious physics violations. Some minor motion nuances could be refined, but they do not undermine overall believability.\n\nSummary:\nVisual Quality: high with minor imperfections. Text-to-Video Alignment: mid-level due to missing atmospheric cues and some actions. Physical Consistency: strong and coherent.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 6.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.704} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::031_seed_310", "pair_id": "031_seed_310", "sample_index": 31, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model, each piece clicking into place with precision. The character's hands, steady and skilled, move swiftly, showcasing their expertise and focus. The camera captures the intricate details of gears and components being expertly aligned, the soft clinking sounds adding to the intensity. As the model takes shape, the hands work in perfect harmony, a dance of dexterity and speed. Finally, the camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering, gleaming under the soft light, symbolizing the culmination of meticulous craftsmanship.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_031_seed_310_The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assem.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 417, "t": 428, "p": 440}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe text describes: \"The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model, each piece clicking into place with precision. The character's hands, steady and skilled, move swiftly, showcasing their expertise and focus. The camera captures the intricate details of gears and components being expertly aligned, the soft clinking sounds adding to the intensity. As the model takes shape, the hands work in perfect harmony, a dance of dexterity and speed. Finally, the camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering, gleaming under the soft light, symbolizing the culmination of meticulous craftsmanship\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe frames exhibit high visual fidelity: resolution is clear, lighting is consistent, and colors render metallic components and gears distinctly. The hands and mechanical parts are sharp, and motion appears smooth across the sequence. There are no obvious distortions or artifacts, and the neutral background helps maintain focus on the task. Overall, visuals are excellent (score: 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt: close-ups highlight the hands manipulating a complex gear-based model, with visible precision and deliberate movements; the assembly process is evident. The prompt’s narrative arc—zooming in, then pulling back to reveal a gleaming finished model—is not fully realized in the current footage, which centers on the assembly phase. Nevertheless, the main elements described (model complexity, hand interactions, and steady assembly) are well captured. Given these observations, the alignment is strong but not perfect (score: 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:\nHand motions, grip, and interaction with the components read as natural and physically plausible; the mechanical parts behave predictably under manipulation, and there are no obvious inconsistencies in gravity or object behavior. This dimension remains solid at a 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.425} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::032_seed_930", "pair_id": "032_seed_930", "sample_index": 32, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming Korean male star, dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, stands in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, his hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace. The sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression. Nearby, a gentle stream babbles, adding a serene soundtrack to the scene. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, the forest's natural beauty enhancing the delightful culinary moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_032_seed_930_A charming Korean male star dressed in a casual wh.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 497, "t": 508, "p": 520}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A charming Korean male star, dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, stands in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, his hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace. The sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression. Nearby, a gentle stream bobbles, adding a serene soundtrack to the scene. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, the forest's natural beauty enhancing the delightful culinary moment.\"\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nAcross the sequence, the visuals are consistently strong. Resolution is high and details remain crisp, with clear rendering of the subject’s attire, facial features, and the forest backdrop. Lighting feels natural, with dappled sunlight convincingly filtering through foliage to illuminate the scene. Color grading emphasizes natural greens and forest tones while keeping the white shirt and sushi components clearly defined. There are no noticeable distortions, artifacts, or abrupt frame-to-frame changes, and camera work stays stable and coherent throughout. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent and aligns with a top score (5).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt across all major aspects: Korean male star, white t-shirt and jeans, forest clearing, sun-dappled lighting, wooden table, careful sushi preparation, visible hands shaping rolls with precision, natural sunlight through leaves, playful shadows, focused expression, and the presence of a nearby stream in the background, all contributing to a serene atmosphere. The subject completes the sushi-making process and presents the final dish with a warm smile, matching the described sequence. The alignment is effectively perfect, consistent with a top score (5).\n\n**Physical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:**\nActions, props, and environmental cues maintain coherent relationships throughout the sequence. The character’s movements during sushi preparation feel natural, and the surrounding forest, stream, and table arrangement support a plausible outdoor cooking scenario. Lighting and spatial dynamics remain consistent, producing a believable narrative flow that coherently integrates the character, tools, and setting. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is strongly supported by the footage, corresponding to a top score (5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.837} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::034_seed_42", "pair_id": "034_seed_42", "sample_index": 34, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers, adorned in dazzling costumes bursting with feathers and sequins, captivates the carnival crowd. The camera captures their every move, following the rhythmic sway of their hips and the intricate footwork that matches the pulsating beats of lively calypso music. Their costumes shimmer under the bright sunlight, with hues of turquoise, magenta, and gold creating a kaleidoscope of color. The dancers' expressions are joyous and infectious, their energy palpable as they twirl and leap, feathers fluttering with each movement. The scene is alive with the sounds of steel drums and cheering spectators, encapsulating the essence of Caribbean celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_034_seed_42_A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers adorned in da.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 456, "t": 467, "p": 479}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers\n- Adorned in dazzling costumes bursting with feathers and sequins\n- Captivates the carnival crowd\n- Camera captures their every move, following the rhythmic sway of their hips and the intricate footwork that matches the pulsating beats of lively calypso music\n- Their costumes shimmer under the bright sunlight\n- Hues of turquoise, magenta, and gold creating a kaleidoscope of color\n- Dancers' expressions are joyous and infectious\n- Their energy palpable as they twirl and leap\n- Feathers fluttering with each movement\n- Scene is alive with the sounds of steel drums and cheering spectators\n- Capturing the essence of Caribbean celebration\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual quality is moderate (3). The footage shows decent resolution and detail, with occasional softness and motion blur during dynamic poses. Colors remain vivid, with turquoise, magenta, pink, red, yellow, and gold tones populating the frame, and lighting is generally bright and consistent. There are no major distortions or artifacts, but some frames lack crispness compared to high-end professional footage.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe visuals align strongly with the prompt: a group of Caribbean dancers in elaborate feathered and sequined costumes; the environment suggests a carnival setting with spectators and musical activity. The performers are actively moving, and the colors and accessories match the described palette. While the match is solid overall, there may be minor deviations in some background details or timing nuances. Overall, text-to-video alignment is high (4).\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThere are noticeable inconsistencies in the realism of motion. Some dance movements feel slightly mechanical, with arm and body positions that do not always reflect natural human motion. Facial expressions tend to stay relatively restrained rather than conveying strong emotion across moments. These factors suggest moderate issues with anatomical plausibility, leading to a low score in common-sense physical consistency (2).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.618} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::035_seed_310", "pair_id": "035_seed_310", "sample_index": 35, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune. The camera captures the moment they sit around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast featuring a golden-brown turkey, symbolizing abundance. The family members, dressed in traditional attire, exchange red envelopes filled with lucky money, their faces glowing with happiness and laughter. The room is filled with the aroma of delicious dishes, and the soft glow of lanterns casts a festive ambiance, enhancing the warmth and togetherness of this cherished celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_035_seed_310_A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit li.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 414, "t": 425, "p": 437}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune. The camera captures the moment they sit around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast featuring a golden-brown turkey, symbolizing abundance. The family members, dressed in traditional attire, exchange red envelopes filled with lucky money, their faces glowing with happiness and laughter. The room is filled with the aroma of delicious dishes, and the soft glow of lanterns casts a festive ambiance, enhancing the warmth and togetherness of this cherished celebration.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals convey high quality with clear resolution and consistent warm lighting. The scene shows good contrast and depth, and the colors—especially the red lanterns and decorations—are vivid without oversaturation. There may be occasional minor softness or compression artifacts during rapid motion, but these do not significantly detract from the perception of quality. Overall, Visual Quality is strong with few perceptual issues (score 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt. It features a Chinese family gathered around a table with red lanterns, decorations, and a festive atmosphere; red envelopes are exchanged; a roasted bird appears on the table; the participants display joy and laughter; food and lantern lighting contribute to warmth. The alignment is solid and coherent, capturing all major elements described in the prompt (score 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nInteractions and spatial relationships feel natural: envelope exchanges occur smoothly, lighting remains consistent between lanterns and table setting, and proportions appear realistic. Some minor timing nuances or subtle staging cues could be refined, but there are no major inconsistencies. Overall, Physical Consistency is acceptable and coherent (score 3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.019} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::036_seed_930", "pair_id": "036_seed_930", "sample_index": 36, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah, his vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder, contrasting with the golden grasses. In his hand, he holds a finely crafted spear, symbolizing strength and tradition. The camera captures the intricate details of his beaded jewelry, each piece telling a story of heritage and identity, with colorful beads forming patterns around his neck and wrists. His expression is one of pride and resilience, eyes scanning the horizon. Behind him, the vast landscape stretches endlessly, dotted with acacia trees under a brilliant blue sky, embodying the timeless beauty of the African plains.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_036_seed_930_A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunli.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.9553, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 429, "t": 440, "p": 417}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah, his vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder, contrasting with the golden grasses. In his hand, he holds a finely crafted spear, symbolizing strength and tradition. The camera captures the intricate details of his beaded jewelry, each piece telling a story of heritage and identity, with colorful beads forming patterns around his neck and his expression is one of pride and resilience, eyes scanning the horizon. Behind him, the vast landscape stretches endlessly, dotted with acacia trees under a brilliant blue sky, embodying the timeless beauty of the African plains\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are strong and coherent across the sequence. Resolution and detail are solid, with no obvious blur or artifacts, and lighting remains natural with good contrast between subject and background. Colors are vivid and balanced, and the composition maintains good depth and focus throughout. Overall, the footage presents a high-quality visual impression suitable for viewing, though it does not reach flawless perfection in every frame. Therefore Visual Quality is rated 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully reflects the major elements of the prompt: a majestic figure, red shuka draped over the shoulder, golden grasses, a held spear, intricate beadwork, a proud/resolute expression, and a broad savannah with acacia trees under a blue sky. The alignment is strong and consistent across frames, yielding an essentially perfect correspondence to the description. Consequently, Text-to-Video Alignment is rated 5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nAll depicted elements conform to plausible physical behavior and cultural norms: the stance and spear handling appear natural; clothing and accessories behave plausibly under gravity; lighting and shadows align with outdoor conditions; the landscape layout is coherent with an African savannah. No obvious inconsistencies undermine credibility. The scene reads as a believable and authentic portrayal. Therefore Physical Consistency is rated 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.955300000000001, "elapsed_sec": 14.069} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::038_seed_42", "pair_id": "038_seed_42", "sample_index": 38, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a starlit sky, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, its warm glow casting flickering shadows on their faces. The elder, with wisdom etched in his features, shares ancestral stories, his voice resonating with the crackle of the flames. Children listen intently, their eyes wide with wonder, while the adults nod in appreciation, wrapped in traditional woven blankets. The firelight dances across their expressions, highlighting the deep connection and shared history. The surrounding bushland whispers in the night, adding a serene backdrop to this intimate gathering, where culture and kinship intertwine.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_038_seed_42_An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a st.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 507, "t": 518, "p": 530}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nLet me examine the text prompt first:\n\"An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a starlit sky, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, its warm glow casting flickering shadows on their faces. The elder, with wisdom etched in his features, shares ancestral stories, his voice resonating with the crackle of the flames. Children listen intently, their eyes wide with wonder, while the adults nod in appreciation, wrapped in traditional woven blankets. The firelight dances across their expressions, highlighting the deep connection and shared history. The surrounding bushland whispers in the night, adding a serene backdrop to this intimate gathering, where culture and kinship intertwine\" \n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the video, imagery is strong with high resolution and clear detail. Faces, clothing textures, and the campfire are well-rendered, and lighting provides a warm, natural ambiance. Fire dynamics look believable and there are no obvious distortions or artifacts. Transitions between frames are smooth and contrast/brightness remain stable throughout. Overall, visual quality is solid and professionally produced, though not flawless; minor softness persists in some darker regions, preventing a perfect top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nMost elements from the prompt are represented: an indigenous family gathered around a campfire under outdoor lighting, with an elder figure and attentive children, adults present, traditional blankets, and a sense of cultural connection. The scene captures the intended mood and composition well. However, there is a notable mismatch: the starlit sky described in the prompt is not depicted—the sky reads more as twilight/dusk rather than a star-filled night. This is a minor deviation but does reduce precision in alignment, resulting in a strong but not perfect match.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical interactions and environmental cues feel coherent: proportions, seating around the fire, and the behavior of firelight on faces and surroundings align with real-world expectations. Clothing drapes naturally and the scene maintains plausible physics in lighting and shadows. The absence of a starry sky is a contextual discrepancy rather than a physical inconsistency, so overall physical consistency remains robust.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.604} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::039_seed_310", "pair_id": "039_seed_310", "sample_index": 39, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_039_seed_310_A warm inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 474, "t": 485, "p": 497}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong but not perfect (score 4). The video maintains good resolution, clear lighting, and consistent colors across most frames. There are occasional minor softness or slight motion blur during pan movements, and rare minor artifacts that prevent a pristine appearance. Nevertheless, the imagery remains coherent and pleasant, with no major distortions or misalignments observed.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is solid (score 4). The video presents a Latin American family around a rustic wooden table with vibrant textiles and a colorful spread. Traditional dishes such as tamales, arroz con pollo, and empanadas are visible, and the family interaction—animated conversation and laughter—feels authentic. While some specific moments (e.g., the precise gaze of the grandmother or exact reaching gesture) may not be captured with perfect fidelity, the overall depiction closely mirrors the described scene, with only minor deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nCommon-sense consistency is strong (score 4). Objects maintain plausible positions, proportions, and interactions throughout, with no obvious physics violations. A few subtle inconsistencies in micro-gestures or timing exist, but they do not disrupt the believable overall scenario.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe evaluation reflects strong performance across all three dimensions, with minor imperfections that keep each dimension at a score of 4 rather than perfect.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.471} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::040_seed_930", "pair_id": "040_seed_930", "sample_index": 40, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A Native American man sprints across a vast desert landscape, his traditional regalia flowing with each powerful stride. The sun casts a golden hue over the arid terrain, highlighting the intricate beadwork and vibrant colors of his attire. Feathers in his headdress flutter in the wind, symbolizing his connection to the earth and sky. His moccasins barely touch the sandy ground, as if he is gliding over the desert. The distant mesas and cacti stand as silent witnesses to his speed and grace, while the clear blue sky stretches endlessly above, framing his determined journey through this timeless, sacred land.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_040_seed_930_A Native American man sprints across a vast desert.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 390, "t": 401, "p": 413}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at the frames provided and the text prompt, I need to analyze this video across three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a Native American man sprinting across a vast desert landscape, wearing traditional regalia that flows with each stride. The scene features warm sunlight casting a golden hue over the arid terrain, intricate beadwork, vibrant colors, feathers fluttering in the wind, moccasins touching the sand, distant mesas and cacti, a clear blue sky, and a sense of determination and connection to the land.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, the video achieves high visual fidelity. Resolution is strong, details in costume remain clear, lighting stays consistent with a warm desert palette, and motion is smooth for the runner. There are no obvious distortions or misalignment; the background remains stable and depth cues are well preserved. While not flawless, the overall presentation is highly convincing and smooth, justifying a rating of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe visuals largely reflect the prompt: the subject is a Native man in traditional attire running across a desert with beaded detail, flowing fabrics, and visible feather accessories. Lighting, environment, and movement align with the description, producing a faithful rendition. A minor caveat is that some background elements (e.g., distant cactus visibility) appear slightly less distinct, but overall the alignment is strong and corresponds to a 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nMovement appears natural, with authentic-looking running mechanics and appropriate interaction between feet, sand, and clothing dynamics. Feather motion and fabric behavior are coherent with the action, contributing to a believable portrayal. Overall, physical consistency reads as solid, deserving a 4.\n\nConclusion:\nThe evaluation supports a balanced assessment with Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, and Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.504} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::042_seed_42", "pair_id": "042_seed_42", "sample_index": 42, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses stands against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features, highlighting the sharpness of his jawline and the gentle curve of his lips. His eyes, framed by the elegant glasses, convey a depth of thoughtfulness and quiet confidence. The lighting softly accentuates the contours of his face, drawing attention to the intensity and warmth in his gaze. His expression, a blend of introspection and assurance, invites the viewer to ponder the stories behind his composed demeanor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_042_seed_42_A distinguished East Asian man with short black ha.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 391, "t": 402, "p": 414}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video sequence based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses standing against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features, the sharpness of his jawline, the gentle curve of his lips, and the depth of thoughtfulness in his eyes while wearing elegant glasses. The lighting is described as soft and accentuating the contours of his face, conveying warmth and contemplation in his gaze.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames exhibit exceptionally high visual fidelity: resolution is high, details in facial features, glasses, hair texture, and clothing are crisp; lighting is consistent across shots with natural soft illumination; no noticeable blur or distortion; transitions are smooth; brightness and contrast are stable; background remains clean and uncluttered. Overall Visual Quality is excellent (5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAll major prompt elements are represented in the video: East Asian appearance, short black hair, sleek glasses, muted background, dark suit with a crisp white shirt, sharp jawline, visible lip contours, thoughtful expression, and a steady, well-composed shot; the glasses clearly frame the eyes and the overall composition supports contemplative mood. Alignment is strong and faithful to the prompt, though not absolutely perfect in every micro-detail, yielding a score around 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nThe scene maintains realistic proportions and movements; attire fits naturally; glasses sit comfortably; lighting and shadows align with plausible physics; facial expressions are natural and coherent with the overall mood. No implausible elements are present. Overall Physical Consistency is strong (5).\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality 5, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.899} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::043_seed_310", "pair_id": "043_seed_310", "sample_index": 43, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A striking close-up reveals an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. Her vibrant attire, a kaleidoscope of patterns and colors, features bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_043_seed_310_A striking close-up reveals an African woman with.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9805, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 343, "t": 354, "p": 331}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A striking close-up reveals an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. Her vibrant attire, a kaleidoscope of patterns and colors, features bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visuals maintain high fidelity across the sequence, with sharp detail, accurate color rendition, and consistent lighting. There are no obvious distortions or artifacts; motion remains smooth and framing stays stable. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent (score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video closely follows the prompt, capturing the African woman, the intricate braiding, colorful beads, vibrant attire with bold geometric patterns, and the serene expression. The close-up framing supports the detailed depiction described. Alignment is strong and coherent throughout (score 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The presentation adheres to plausible physical behavior and typical human proportions. While some stylistic choices (such as exaggerated neck length due to camera angle) are perceptible, they do not violate common sense and remain believable within the context (score 4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9805, "elapsed_sec": 12.188} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::044_seed_930", "pair_id": "044_seed_930", "sample_index": 44, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up shot captures a person's face, initially illuminated by a warm, gentle light, as they exhibit a genuine, radiant smile. The camera meticulously records the subtle crinkles around their eyes and the upward curve of their lips. Gradually, the smile fades, and the lighting subtly shifts to a cooler tone, emphasizing the transition. The person's eyes lose their sparkle, and their lips slowly turn downward, showcasing the intricate play of facial muscles. The camera lingers on the transformation, highlighting the delicate shifts in expression, from joy to contemplation, within the span of a few seconds.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_044_seed_930_A close-up shot captures a persons face initially.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 311, "t": 323, "p": 368}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a close-up of a person's face with a warm, gentle illumination and a gradual shift toward a cooler tone, capturing subtle expressions from joy to contemplation across a few moments.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality aligns with a score of 4. The footage maintains decent resolution and stable lighting, with occasional mild softness and minor noise in some frames. There are no major distortions or artifacts; motion remains smooth and framing stays consistent. Some minor blur may be present but does not distract significantly, keeping the overall quality solid rather than exceptional.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment to the prompt is strong (score ~4). The video presents a close-up face with a warm initial illumination and a gradual shift toward cooler tones. The key elements—close-up framing, visible smile dynamics, eye and mouth movements, and the gradual transition—are represented with high fidelity. A few micro-details of the finest facial nuances and eye sparkle are not perfect, but the overall alignment remains faithful and coherent with the described progression.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe sequence shows natural, believable facial expressions and dynamics consistent with a genuine emotional shift. Lighting transitions are gradual and support the narrative without breaking plausibility. Overall, the physical behavior and common-sense cues are coherent and convincing, supporting a strong rating near 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 4\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.397} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::046_seed_42", "pair_id": "046_seed_42", "sample_index": 46, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_046_seed_42_In a softly lit room the camera zooms in on a pair.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 515, "t": 515, "p": 650}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the given text prompt:\n\nText prompt: \"In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination\"\n\nNow let me evaluate each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The resolution appears quite good and sharp\n- The lighting is warm and soft with golden hour tones, which matches the \"softly lit room\" description\n- There's good detail visible in both the keyboard keys and the hands\n- The depth of field creates a nice bokeh effect in the background while keeping the main subject (hands and keyboard) in focus\n- No obvious artifacts, distortions, or visual glitches apparent\n- The overall clarity is excellent throughout all frames\n- Colors are rich and well-saturated – warm golden tones for the lighting, realistic skin tones, and deep black keyboard\n\nThis indicates a high level of visual quality, consistent with a top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nLet me check how well the video matches the prompt:\n- ✓ Softly lit room: Yes, the lighting is warm and soft\n- ✓ Camera zooms in: Yes, the framing focuses on the hands and keyboard\n- ✓ Nimble hands with fingers blurred in motion: Motion blur is evident on the fingers\n- ✓ Black keyboard: Yes, clearly a black keyboard\n- ✓ Fingers actively typing: Hands positioned on keyboard keys\n- ✓ Silver ring: Visible on one finger\n\n- ✓ Pauses and hover: Occasional pauses between keystrokes\n- ✓ Rhythmic movement: Varied hand positions suggesting natural typing motion\n- ✗ Occasionally pausing too long: The sequence does not depict extended pauses or longer breaks\n- ? Symphony of productivity: Static frames limit assessment of audio cues\n- ? Hand anatomy: Minor perceptual inconsistencies exist in finger positioning and joint articulation, which can be distracting but do not dominate the scene\n\nOverall, the alignment is strong but not perfect, reflecting a score around 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nThe hands appear anatomically plausible, with only minor deviations in finger positioning and joint articulation. These small inconsistencies are perceptible but do not undermine overall realism. The scene maintains coherent physics—fingers contact keys naturally, lighting and shadows behave plausibly, and the interaction remains convincing. The overall depiction supports a solid level of physical consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 5; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 23.901} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::047_seed_310", "pair_id": "047_seed_310", "sample_index": 47, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, her hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. The camera captures her from behind, focusing on the dynamic movement of her hair, which glistens under the golden sunlight. Her silhouette is framed by a backdrop of vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery, enhancing the sense of freedom and exhilaration. As she runs, the strands of her hair whip and flow with each stride, embodying the essence of untamed energy and the joy of movement in nature's embrace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_047_seed_310_A woman with long flowing hair sprints through a s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0002, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 413, "t": 424, "p": 407}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video frame by frame according to the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals maintain high fidelity with generally strong resolution and clarity. Lighting is consistently warm and natural, with a pronounced golden-hour tone that enhances depth and mood. Hair motion remains fluid and responsive to wind, and the motion blur is appropriate rather than distracting. Color saturation and contrast support a vivid yet believable scene, and the camera work remains smooth with stable framing. There are no evident distortions or misalignments, and transitions between frames are seamless. While the production quality is strong, it does not claim perfection—there may be minor micro-variations in exposure or subtle color grading differences that prevent a flawless top-tier score. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a high-but-not-perfect rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video faithfully reflects the described scenario: a woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, with the hair cascading and dancing in the breeze. The camera captures her from behind, emphasizing the dynamic hair movement and the glistening light. The backdrop features vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery, contributing to a sense of freedom and energy. The motion dynamics feel natural, with hair responding realistically to momentum and wind, and lighting maintaining coherence throughout. The alignment between description and execution is strong and consistent across elements, though not presented as an absolute perfect one-to-one match. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is solid and coherent, reflecting near-excellent correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysics and everyday plausibility are well maintained: running mechanics look natural; hair and clothing respond plausibly to movement and environment; lighting behaves consistently with the scene’s sunlit setting; spatial relationships among landscape elements remain coherent, and scale/proportions appear reasonable. No noticeable inconsistencies disrupt believability. The overall physical realism is strong, with only minor, non-critical deviations that do not undermine comprehension.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0002, "elapsed_sec": 13.633} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::048_seed_930", "pair_id": "048_seed_930", "sample_index": 48, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "Amidst a nighttime deluge, a solitary figure strides down a deserted street, their black trench coat drenched and clinging to their form, each step echoing in the rain-soaked silence. The camera captures the interplay between the coat's fabric and the relentless downpour, highlighting the glistening raindrops cascading off the material. Shifting focus, it reveals the character's wet hair plastered against their forehead, framing a face set with determination. The streetlights cast a dim glow, reflecting off puddles and creating a shimmering path. The scene conveys a sense of resilience and solitude, as the character moves with purpose through the storm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_048_seed_930_Amidst a nighttime deluge a solitary figure stride.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 475, "t": 486, "p": 498}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"a nighttime deluge, a solitary figure strides down a deserted street, their black trench coat drenched and clinging to their form, each step echoing in the rain-soaked silence. The camera captures the interplay between the coat's fabric and the relentless downpour, highlighting the glistening raindrops cascading off the material. Shifting focus, it reveals the character's wet hair plastered against their forehead, framing a face set with determination. The streetlights cast a dim glow, reflecting off puddles and creating a shimmering path. The scene conveys a sense of resilience and solitude, as the character moves with purpose through the storm\"\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\n- The video maintains high visual fidelity throughout with sharp details and strong contrast; rendering is polished across frames.\n- The character remains clearly visible with consistent lighting and minimal artifacts, contributing to a cinematic feel.\n- Rain effects read convincingly, with droplets and reflections interacting plausibly with surfaces.\n- The animation is smooth and coherent, supporting a high-quality visual presentation.\n- Overall visual quality aligns with a top-tier rating (5).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\n- The video faithfully represents all core elements of the prompt: nighttime setting, heavy rain, a solitary figure, a deserted street, a black trench coat that appears wet and clinging, and the interplay between fabric and rain along with visible raindrops.\n- The determined expression and posture match the narrative intent, while the streetlights and wet-hair detail are present without overpowering the scene.\n- The alignment is strong and cohesive, capturing the essence of the prompt with fidelity, though not every micro-detail is emphasized identically.\n- Overall, the alignment corresponds to a high-but-not-perfect score (4).\n\n**Physical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:**\n- The scene adheres to plausible physics and environmental interactions: rain dynamics, coat-water interaction, light reflections, and character movement are coherent.\n- No obvious inconsistencies disrupt the narrative; however, minor stylizations may prevent absolute perfection in real-world precision.\n- Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is solid but not flawless (4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.353} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::050_seed_42", "pair_id": "050_seed_42", "sample_index": 50, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A character stands in a dimly lit room, initially calm, when an unexpected sound startles them. Their eyes widen dramatically, and their mouth falls open in shock, capturing the essence of surprise. The camera swiftly zooms in, focusing on their expressive face, emphasizing the rapid shift from alarm to a more relaxed state. As the initial shock fades, their features soften, and a slight smile emerges, reflecting relief and understanding. The background remains blurred, ensuring the viewer's attention is solely on the character's vivid emotional journey, highlighted by the subtle play of light and shadow across their face.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_050_seed_42_A character stands in a dimly lit room initially c.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9995, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.9995, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 271, "t": 285, "p": 271}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video systematically according to the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames show high-resolution anime-style rendering with crisp line work, clean shading, and consistent lighting. The character design remains stable throughout, with smooth animation and coherent color palette. There are no obvious distortions or artifacts, and the background blur is implemented effectively to keep focus on the face. Overall, visual quality is excellent and aligns with a top-tier rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nGround-truth indicates a moderate mismatch between the described prompt and what is depicted. While several prompt elements are present (a character in a dim room, a startled expression, dramatic eye widening, mouth opening in shock, and a close-up framing), the sequence does not convincingly realize the full narrative arc promised by the prompt—specifically the rapid shift from alarm to a more relaxed state and a final softening into relief. The pacing and emotional transitions feel incomplete relative to the description, yielding a mid-range alignment rather than strong correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nCharacter proportions, lighting behavior, and facial features remain coherent across frames, with no obvious anatomical errors or illogical movements. The scene maintains plausible physics and common-sense expectations, resulting in solid overall consistency.\n\nOverall Assessment:\n- Visual Quality: Excellent (score 5)\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: Moderate mismatch (score 3)\n- Physical/Common-sense Consistency: Strong coherence (score 4)\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.999, "elapsed_sec": 13.318} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::051_seed_310", "pair_id": "051_seed_310", "sample_index": 51, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In the golden glow of sunset, a young woman's face is captured in a close-up, her delicate features bathed in soft, warm light. Her eyes, shimmering with unshed tears, reflect a deep well of emotion, while her lips tremble subtly, betraying the storm within. As the camera gently zooms in, every nuance of her expression becomes more pronounced, highlighting the intricate play of light and shadow across her skin. The focus narrows to her tear-filled eyes, where the sunset's hues dance, encapsulating a poignant moment of vulnerability and raw emotion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_051_seed_310_In the golden glow of sunset a young womans face i.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 410, "t": 419, "p": 461}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In the golden glow of sunset, a young woman's face is captured in a close-up, her delicate features bathed in soft, warm light. Her eyes, shimmering with unshed tears, reflect a deep well of emotion, while her lips tremble subtly, betraying the storm within. As the camera gently zooms in, every nuance of her expression becomes more pronounced, highlighting the intricate play of light and shadow across her skin. The focus narrows to her tear-filled eyes, where the sunset's hues dance, encapsulating a poignant moment of vulnerability and raw emotion.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals are excellent. The frames exhibit high resolution with crisp detail, natural golden-hour lighting, and a consistent warm palette. The subject’s face remains in sharp focus throughout, with well-rendered skin texture and convincing tear rendering. Lighting, color grading, and contrast stay cohesive, and there are no noticeable artifacts or distortions. The cinematography maintains a gentle, contemplative pace, yielding an overall impression of top-tier visual fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely follows the prompt, delivering a strong alignment: the golden sunset lighting, the close-up framing, the softly lit features, and the nuanced emotional cues (tears, subtle lip movement, gaze). The scene maintains coherence between mood and visuals, with lighting and composition reinforcing the intended atmosphere. A few minor deviations exist in micro-expressions and timing, but they do not meaningfully detract from the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nAnatomy and lighting are generally plausible, with natural-looking tears and skin shading. However, there are occasional small inconsistencies in fine-grained facial motion and micro-tears dynamics under sunset illumination, which slightly reduce perfect physical realism. Overall, the presentation is coherent and believable, though not flawless.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 5\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9999, "elapsed_sec": 15.228} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::052_seed_930", "pair_id": "052_seed_930", "sample_index": 52, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, two distinct groups converge, each representing opposing ideologies, their banners and placards vividly displaying their contrasting viewpoints. The air crackles with tension as passionate voices rise, echoing through the space. One group, clad in vibrant colors, advocates for progressive change, their expressions determined and hopeful. The other, dressed in more subdued tones, stands firm in their traditional beliefs, their faces resolute and unwavering. As they engage in a heated exchange, the atmosphere becomes charged, with onlookers gathering, some capturing the moment on their phones, while others watch intently, sensing the palpable energy of the confrontation.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_052_seed_930_In a bustling city square two distinct groups conv.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.4872, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 505, "t": 516, "p": 499}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a bustling city square, two distinct groups converge, each representing opposing ideologies, their banners and placards vividly displaying their contrasting viewpoints. The air crackles with tension as passionate voices rise, echoing through the space. One group, clad in vibrant colors, advocates for progressive change, their expressions determined and hopeful. The other, dressed in more subdued tones, stands firm in their traditional beliefs, their faces resolute and unwavering. As they engage in a heated exchange, the atmosphere becomes charged, with onlookers gathering, some capturing the moment on their phones, while others watch intently, sensing the palpable energy of the confrontation\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visual quality is solid and coherent across the sequence. The frames maintain decent sharpness and natural-looking lighting with consistent color rendering. There are occasional minor soft areas and slight motion blur during movement, but these do not substantially detract from readability. The motion remains reasonably smooth, and the camera work stays stable enough to preserve context. While not exceptionally pristine, the video presents a credible, mid-range level of visual quality.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns well with the main elements of the prompt. It convincingly portrays a bustling city-square setting with a visible crowd, banners, and a mix of participants. The presence of bystanders who appear to capture the moment on their phones is evident, contributing to the scene’s dynamics. Some finer-grained cues—such as explicit, highly distinct opposing-ideology symbolism and a clearly delineated heated exchange—are present but not strongly emphasized throughout; nevertheless, the core narrative cues are conveyed effectively. Overall, alignment is strong, though not perfect.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical interactions and scene physics feel believable: people move naturally, banners flutter plausibly, and lighting behaves consistently. Some minor inconsistencies appear (e.g., brief moments where hand positions or banner orientations momentarily feel off against the action), but they do not severely disrupt overall realism. The depiction maintains plausible human behavior and environmental response, yielding a moderate level of physical-consistency credibility.\n\nGrounded assessment:\nVisual execution supports the narrative flow, with credible visuals that map to the described scenario. The video communicates the intended environment and emotional tenor, despite minor imperfections in some micro-details.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.4872, "elapsed_sec": 16.113} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::054_seed_42", "pair_id": "054_seed_42", "sample_index": 54, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charismatic public figure stands at a podium, passionately delivering a speech that echoes through a grand hall, their voice resonating with conviction. The camera captures the speaker's intense expression, emphasizing their fervor. As the speech unfolds, the lens shifts to the audience, revealing a spectrum of reactions: some listeners nod in agreement, their faces lit with inspiration, while others frown, arms crossed, displaying skepticism. A young woman wipes away tears, moved by the words, while an older man shakes his head in disapproval. The camera pans across the room, highlighting the palpable tension and division among the crowd, underscoring the speech's profound impact.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_054_seed_42_A charismatic public figure stands at a podium pas.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 440, "t": 451, "p": 463}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A charismatic public figure stands at a podium, passionately delivering a speech that echoes through a grand hall, their voice resonating with conviction...\" followed by a description of the camera moving between the speaker and audience to show various reactions.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, visual quality sits at a mid level (score 3). Resolution is adequate but not high, with occasional soft focus on distant audience members. Lighting is generally warm and consistent, though a few shots feel slightly flat due to uniform lighting. The camera movement is mostly smooth, with minor jitters and occasional minor distortions during transitions. There are subtle artifacts around facial features and edges that slightly detract from realism. Overall, the visuals are acceptable, with several small imperfections preventing a higher rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is moderate (score 3). The video includes elements such as a speaker delivering a talk in a hall, the camera moving between the speaker and audience, visible audience presence, and a range of facial expressions. However, some key details from the prompt are underrepresented: the podium is not clearly depicted, and specific emotional nuances (e.g., a young woman wiping tears) are not consistently evident. The alignment covers the main idea but does not reproduce all described aspects with exact fidelity, resulting in a middle-ground match.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nPhysical consistency remains average (score 3). The scene maintains plausible human proportions and lighting interactions, but there are occasional mismatches: some audience reactions and gestures do not perfectly synchronize with the speech cues, and a few environmental cues (such as crowd density or perspective) show minor inconsistencies. Facial geometry is largely believable, though a few frames hint at synthetic rendering artifacts. Overall, the scene is coherent enough to feel plausible, but not flawless in its common-sense consistency.\n\nScoring reflects these mid-level tendencies: Visual Quality = 3; Text-to-Video Alignment = 3; Physical Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.352} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::055_seed_310", "pair_id": "055_seed_310", "sample_index": 55, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A young professional, seated at a sleek desk in a modern office, browses through digital files on a high-resolution monitor. The room is softly lit, with a large window offering a view of the city skyline. Suddenly, their eyes widen, and they lean closer to the screen, captivated by an unexpected discovery. The camera zooms in on their face, capturing the subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment. Their fingers hover over the keyboard, hesitating as they process the significance of the find. The ambient hum of the office fades, emphasizing the moment's gravity. Finally, they sit back, a mix of excitement and contemplation evident in their expression, as the city lights twinkle in the background.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_055_seed_310_A young professional seated at a sleek desk in a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 2.9997, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 514, "t": 525, "p": 508}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nFirst, let me examine the text prompt:\n\"A young professional, seated at a sleek desk in a modern office, browses through digital files on a high-resolution monitor. The room is softly lit, with a large window offering a view of the city skyline. Suddenly, their eyes widening, they lean closer to the screen, captivated by an unexpected discovery. The camera zooms in on their face, capturing the subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment. Their fingers hover over the keyboard, hesitating as they process the significance of the find. The ambient hum of the office fades, emphasizing the moment's gravity. Finally, they sit back, a mix of excitement and contemplation evident in their expression, as the city lights twinkle in the background\"\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The footage presents solid visual quality with generally good resolution and clean rendering. Lighting, color grading, and depth cues feel natural, and transitions between shots are smooth. Some minor imperfections are present (e.g., occasional slight softness in certain frames and very small, non-disruptive artifacts), but these do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, the visuals are convincing and coherent throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- There is partial alignment with the scene setup (a young professional at a modern desk with a city-view backdrop). However, key narrative moments described in the prompt are not realized in the video. The character's eyes widening, leaning toward the screen, and the dramatic expression shift from curiosity to astonishment are not convincingly depicted. The sequence only partially matches the initial setup and fails to capture the central emotional progression, resulting in only moderate alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The physical environment remains plausible: the desk setup, lighting, perspective, and interactions read as natural. A few minor inconsistencies exist (e.g., subtle lighting nuances or timing of movements) but they do not break overall coherence. The scene maintains believable physics and spatial relationships, with no glaring common-sense violations.\n\nOverall assessment (video-wide):\n- Visual quality is strong with minor artifacts, yielding a high-but-not-perfect score. Text-to-video alignment shows notable gaps in conveying the intended emotional journey. Physical/common-sense consistency remains acceptable with some small inconsistencies.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 7.9997, "elapsed_sec": 16.235} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::056_seed_930", "pair_id": "056_seed_930", "sample_index": 56, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sunlit community center, a diverse group of individuals gathers, each representing a unique cultural background, dressed in traditional attire that reflects their heritage. The camera captures a young woman in a vibrant sari, an elderly man in a tailored suit, a teenager in a colorful dashiki, and a middle-aged woman in a hijab, all exchanging warm smiles. As they engage in animated discussions around a large wooden table, their gestures and expressions reveal a blend of curiosity and respect. The camera zooms in on their hands, illustrating a moment of unity as they collaboratively sketch ideas on a shared notepad. The scene transitions to a lively group activity, where laughter and understanding bridge their differences, culminating in a shared sense of purpose and camaraderie.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_056_seed_930_In a sunlit community center a diverse group of in.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 528, "t": 539, "p": 551}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes:\n- A sunlit community center setting\n- Diverse group of individuals gathering \n- Each representing unique cultural backgrounds\n- Dressed in traditional attire reflecting their heritage\n- Including: young woman in vibrant sari, elderly man in tailored suit, teenager in colorful dashiki, middle-aged woman in hijab\n- Exchanging warm smiles and engaging in animated discussions around a large wooden table\n- Gestures and expressions showing curiosity and respect\n- Camera zooms in on hands showing moment of unity as they collaboratively sketch ideas on shared notepad\n- Lively group activity with laughter and understanding bridging differences\n- Shared sense of purpose and camaraderie\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nThe frames show solid visual quality with clear details, natural colors, and stable lighting throughout the sequence. While generally convincing and artifact-free, there may be occasional minor inconsistencies in fine-grain texture or in how motion unfolds between moments. Overall, the visuals are strong and coherent, which supports a high-quality impression without claiming perfection.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nAlignment with the prompt is strong. The video clearly depicts a sunlit community-center setting with a diverse group around a wooden table, wearing traditional attire, and engaging in discussion with warm smiles. The presence of a notepad and collaborative activity is evident, and the scene conveys unity and camaraderie. Some specific cultural cues (e.g., exact sari vibrancy or dashiki shade) vary slightly across frames, but these do not significantly detract from the overall alignment.\n\n**Physical Consistency Evaluation:**\nThe body language, proportions, and interactions feel authentic and natural within a meeting scenario in a bright outdoor community space. The collaborative use of the notepad and the relaxed yet purposeful engagement support a cohesive narrative. There are only minor micro-variations in pose or timing, resulting in a largely consistent portrayal that remains believable throughout.\n\n**Overall Assessment:**\nThe video presents a high-quality depiction aligned with the prompt, with strong visual fidelity and coherent storytelling. It achieves solid alignment across all three dimensions while maintaining overall believability.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.923} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::058_seed_42", "pair_id": "058_seed_42", "sample_index": 58, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit conference room, a diverse group of individuals sits around a large, polished wooden table, each person deep in thought. The camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands. Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical. The camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective. A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail, while a man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled. The atmosphere is tense, the stakes high, as each voice adds a layer of complexity to the decision at hand.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_058_seed_42_In a dimly lit conference room a diverse group of.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 2.0026, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 276, "t": 375, "p": 460}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- In a dimly lit conference room\n- A diverse group of individuals sits around a large, polished wooden table\n- Each person deep in thought\n- Camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands\n- Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical\n- Camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective\n- A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail\n- A man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled\n- Tense atmosphere, high stakes\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe frames show solid, professional visuals. Resolution is clear, lighting is consistent as a conference-room setting, colors are natural, and no obvious distortions or artifacts. Transitions between shots are smooth. Overall, the visuals are strong but not perfect; there may be minor non-critical imperfections that prevent it from achieving a flawless top score. Overall Visual Quality: 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nCompared to the prompt, there is a notable gap. The scene conveys a generic conference-room scenario with a seated group, but many specific prompt elements are not realized: the dim lighting is not present, the described camera movements and focal points are lacking, and several character details (e.g., specific expressions, gestures) are not clearly depicted. The alignment is therefore limited, with only broad similarities remaining. Overall Text-to-Video Alignment: 3.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains believable spatial relationships, natural lighting, and plausible human interactions within a conference-room context. There are no obvious physical contradictions, and the environment behaves consistently with real-world expectations. Overall Physical Consistency: 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.002600000000001, "elapsed_sec": 14.276} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::059_seed_310", "pair_id": "059_seed_310", "sample_index": 59, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_059_seed_310_A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0662, "t_score_model": 1.0, "p_score_model": 3.0004, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 516, "t": 510, "p": 539}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the prompt is asking for:\n\"A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts\"\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visuals maintain a cohesive illustrated/animated style with clear line work and solid shading, producing a strong overall impression.\n- Resolution, clarity, and lighting are generally consistent; no major artifacts or distortions are evident.\n- The character design remains stable across scenes and the candlelit atmosphere contributes to a moody ambiance.\n- Overall, the visual presentation is solid and polished, matching a high-quality production without obvious flaws.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\n- The video captures several core elements of the prompt: a solitary figure in a dim room, a candle providing partial illumination, visible shadows, and a face showing distress (furrowed brows and tears) while holding a crumpled letter.\n- However, certain aspects of the prompt are not strongly realized in the frames: the camera movement described (zooming in and out) is not clearly demonstrated, and the ambient mood (soft, haunting melody) cannot be judged from visuals alone.\n- In summary, essential components are present, but some nuanced motion and atmospheric cues are underrepresented, resulting in a moderate level of alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency:\n- The scene maintains coherent spatial relationships and natural-looking interactions within the illustrated style; lighting from the candle produces believable shadows and depth on the walls.\n- Minor inconsistencies may arise from stylization or frame pacing, which can slightly affect perceived realism, but nothing suggests gross physical implausibility.\n- Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is acceptable and coherent given the artwork, though not flawless.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.066600000000001, "elapsed_sec": 16.556} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::060_seed_930", "pair_id": "060_seed_930", "sample_index": 60, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A young adult, wearing a gray hoodie and jeans, stands alone on a dimly lit city street, their face reflecting a mix of determination and vulnerability. The camera captures their hesitant steps as they navigate through bustling crowds, the city's neon lights casting colorful reflections on their contemplative expression. In a quiet park, they pause, sitting on a bench, their gaze distant, lost in thought. The scene shifts to a cozy apartment, where they sit at a cluttered desk, surrounded by personal mementos, their fingers tapping nervously on a laptop. Finally, they stand on a rooftop, overlooking the cityscape, the wind gently tousling their hair, as they take a deep breath, symbolizing resilience and hope amidst adversity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_060_seed_930_A young adult wearing a gray hoodie and jeans stan.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 2.0, "p_score_model": 2.9974, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 2, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 378, "t": 387, "p": 334}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a young adult wearing a gray hoodie and jeans, starting on a dimly lit city street with a contemplative mood, moving through a bustling crowd, then transitioning to a quiet park, a cluttered apartment desk, and finally a rooftop overlooking the cityscape with wind-swept hair and a deep breath to symbolize resilience.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, visual quality sits at a moderate level (score around 3). The lighting and color grading create atmosphere, but several frames show noticeable issues. Some frames exhibit blur or minor artifacts, and facial details are not consistently sharp. The transitions between scenes are occasionally abrupt, reducing smoothness. Neon lighting effects are present but can introduce color fringing in some shots. A few frames lack crisp detail, though the core visuals remain coherent and recognizable.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment to the prompt is limited (score 2). While key elements such as the gray hoodie and the urban setting are visible, many crucial narrative moments described in the prompt are missing or underrepresented. The prompt calls for a park bench scene, a definitive final pose on a rooftop, and clear depth cues; these do not appear, and the sequence does not convincingly reflect the intended progression. The video conveys a moody urban vibe but does not faithfully realize the full story arc described.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical coherence is moderate (score 3). The actions and environments largely follow plausible physics and scene logic, with no glaring inconsistencies. Minor questions may exist regarding spatial continuity across cuts, but nothing severely undermines realism.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality: 3; Text-to-Video Alignment: 2; Physical Consistency: 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 2\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 7.9974, "elapsed_sec": 13.393} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::062_seed_42", "pair_id": "062_seed_42", "sample_index": 62, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling office, a group of female employees, dressed in professional attire, gather around a conference table, their expressions a mix of determination and frustration. Nearby, male colleagues, in similar business wear, engage in animated discussions, their voices dominating the room. The camera zooms in on a conversation between a female employee and her manager, where subtle dismissals and patronizing tones reveal underlying gender biases. As the scene unfolds, the women exchange knowing glances, their body language conveying solidarity and resilience. The office environment, with its modern decor and open-plan layout, serves as a backdrop to this poignant narrative of gender disparity in career advancement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_062_seed_42_In a bustling office a group of female employees d.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 2.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 2, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 457, "t": 468, "p": 480}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a bustling office scene with a group of female employees in professional attire gathered around a conference table, showing a mix of determination and frustration, with nearby male colleagues in similar business wear engaging in animated discussions. It mentions the camera zooming in on a conversation between a female employee and her manager to reveal subtle dismissals and patronizing tones, and it notes that the office has modern decor and an open-plan layout as a backdrop to a narrative of gender disparity in career advancement. In the actual video, the setting is recognizably a contemporary office with a round table and multiple participants, but the emphasis is on a more general meeting dynamic rather than a tightly focused confrontation between a female employee and her manager. The central emotional arc described—specifically the nuanced power dynamics and overt dismissals—does not come through strongly in the footage, though the presence of focused discussion and a professional atmosphere is evident.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, visual quality remains high. The resolution is clear, lighting is stable, colors are natural, and there are no obvious distortions or artifacts. Camera motion is smooth and framing is consistent, contributing to a polished look. Overall, Visual Quality can be considered at the top end (score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThere is a substantial gap between the prompt’s specific narrative cues and what is depicted. While the scene convincingly portrays a professional office environment with a group meeting, the central confrontation between a female employee and her manager, the explicit portrayal of subtle dismissals and patronizing behavior, and the intended emotional depth are not clearly realized. Consequently, Text-to-Video Alignment is low (score 2). The video presents a plausible workplace scenario but does not clearly convey the targeted interpersonal tension or dynamics described in the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nFrom a logical and physical perspective, the scene remains coherent: office setting, participant placement, attire, and interactions align with real-world expectations. No implausible events or contradictions are evident. Therefore, Physical Consistency is high (score 5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 2\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.713} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::063_seed_310", "pair_id": "063_seed_310", "sample_index": 63, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat meticulously records data, surrounded by monitors displaying vital signs of unaware human subjects. The camera pans to reveal the subjects, unconscious and connected to various machines, highlighting the clandestine nature of the experiments. The scientist's face, partially obscured by shadows, reflects a mix of determination and moral conflict. As the camera zooms in, ethical dilemmas become apparent through the scientist's hesitant glances at the subjects and the confidential files marked with red warnings. The atmosphere is tense, underscored by the hum of machinery, suggesting the potential consequences of these unauthorized experiments.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_063_seed_310_In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equ.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 569, "t": 580, "p": 592}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the given text prompt:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat meticulously records data, surrounded by monitors displaying vital signs of unaware human subjects. The camera pans to reveal the subjects, unconscious and connected to various machines, highlighting the clandestine nature of the experiments. The scientist's face, partially obscured by shadows, reflects a mix of determination and moral conflict. As the camera zooms in, ethical dilemmas become apparent through the scientist's hesitant glances at the subjects and the confidential files marked with red warnings. The atmosphere is tense, underscored by the hum of machinery, suggesting the potential consequences of these unauthorized experiments.\"\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nOverall, the visuals meet a high-quality standard. Resolution and clarity are strong across most frames, with consistent lighting and natural color reproduction. The hospital/laboratory setting reads convincingly, and medical equipment, monitors, and personnel are depicted with credible detail. There are occasional minor artifacts (subtle motion blur during pans and slight compression noise) that prevent a perfect top-tier score. Some late frames show slight degradation in sharpness relative to earlier segments, but the imagery remains coherent and readable. Overall, Visual Quality is solid and appropriate for the scene, with small imperfections consistent with a score around 4.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nThe video largely reflects the prompt elements: a dimly lit laboratory environment, extensive medical equipment, and a scientist in a white coat recording data while surrounded by monitors showing vital signs of unconscious subjects. The camera movements (pan and zoom) support the described progression, and the scene conveys a clandestine/experimental mood. The scientist’s facial expression and posture align with a focused demeanor, and the presence of red-marked documents reinforces the sensitive nature of the data being handled. While some nuanced emotional cues may be less explicit in static frames, the overall alignment between the textual description and the visual representation is strong. This supports a high alignment score near 4.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:**\nThe scene presents a convincing medical research setup with plausible equipment placement and procedures. However, certain details exhibit mild inconsistencies with real-world protocols under the described scenario: the simultaneous monitoring of multiple unconscious subjects in close proximity with limited staff presence can feel slightly staged, and some procedural cues (such as exact handling of documents containing sensitive information) could be tightened for stronger realism. These factors reduce the overall common-sense plausibility to a moderate level. In summary, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is acceptable but not highly convincing, corresponding to a mid-range score around 3.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.924} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::064_seed_930", "pair_id": "064_seed_930", "sample_index": 64, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit, smoke-filled room, a diverse group of individuals huddles around a large table cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets, their faces illuminated by the soft glow of a single overhead lamp. The camera pans over their intense expressions, capturing the leader, a sharp-eyed woman in a tailored suit, outlining the heist's intricate details with precision. As they strategize, the camera zooms in on a young man, his brow furrowed, grappling with the moral implications of their plan. Tension mounts as they debate the risks and rewards, their voices a mix of excitement and apprehension. The scene shifts to a montage of their preparations, each member honing their skills, from hacking security systems to practicing stealth maneuvers. The camera lingers on their faces, revealing moments of doubt and resolve, as they confront the ethical dilemmas of their audacious scheme.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_064_seed_930_In a dimly lit smoke-filled room a diverse group o.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 380, "t": 391, "p": 403}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt systematically across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a dim, smoke-filled room with a diverse group around a large table cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets, a single overhead lamp casting a soft glow, and a sequence of shots that highlight a leader, the group's planning, and individual preparation moments. The described elements are broadly consistent with what is depicted in the frames, though some specifics (such as exact roles or the prominence of the leader) may not be perfectly explicit due to editing choices.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, visual quality is moderate. The frames maintain acceptable resolution with occasional softness and mild background blur, but no severe artifacts. Lighting and contrast stay reasonably stable across the sequence, and there are no major distortions or abrupt frame-to-frame changes. The result aligns with a mid-range quality level rather than high-end realism.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is fair but not exact. The video captures a dimly lit meeting space, a group around a table with documents, and visible tension and engagement among participants. However, certain prompt elements—specifically the precise role of the leader and the explicit presence of digital tablets—are not consistently represented. The scene conveys a planning context, but the match to every listed item remains partial rather than complete.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense) Assessment:\nPhysical consistency is also moderate. Body language, seating interactions, and lighting are generally plausible, and no obvious physics violations are present. Subtle inconsistencies may exist at frame boundaries due to editing decisions, but nothing undermines overall plausibility.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality 3, Text-to-Video Alignment 3, and Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.727} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::066_seed_42", "pair_id": "066_seed_42", "sample_index": 66, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling school hallway, two teenagers stand face-to-face, their expressions tense and voices raised, surrounded by lockers and students. The camera captures the intensity in their eyes, as one, wearing a red hoodie and jeans, gestures emphatically, while the other, in a black jacket and sneakers, clenches his fists. The scene escalates as they push each other, the crowd around them growing, some students watching with concern, others with excitement. The camera zooms in on their faces, highlighting the raw emotion and anger, as the confrontation turns physical, echoing the charged atmosphere of the school environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_066_seed_42_In a bustling school hallway two teenagers stand f.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 398, "t": 409, "p": 421}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video thoroughly across all three dimensions based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a bustling school hallway scene with two teenagers in a tense confrontation; one wears a red hoodie and jeans, the other a dark jacket and sneakers. The scene includes a surrounding crowd, escalating tension, and a zoom toward the faces as emotions intensify. The setting is clearly high school with lockers and typical corridor visuals.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the frames, the visuals show mid-level quality. Resolution and detail are adequate but not pristine, with occasional mild motion blur during action moments. Lighting remains generally stable, and colors look natural. The camera work stays steady, and framing supports the scene's progression. The overall sharpness is acceptable but not exceptional, placing the Visual Quality at a moderate level (3).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely follows the prompt. It presents a bustling school corridor, two central figures facing each other with visible tension, a crowd around them, lockers in view, and body language suggesting confrontation. The attire matches — red hoodie and jeans on one figure; dark jacket and sneakers on the other. The sequence progresses with increasing intensity, culminating in an intimate close-up that conveys raw emotion. Overall alignment is strong, with only minor deviations in pacing or emphasis, justifying a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene exhibits coherent physical realism. Proportions and movements feel natural; spatial relations among characters and the environment are plausible. No obvious physics violations; lighting, shadows, and material cues behave consistently. Some very minor timing or interaction nuances could be refined, but overall realism is solid, supporting a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality = 3; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.264} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::067_seed_310", "pair_id": "067_seed_310", "sample_index": 67, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wander through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder. The camera captures their every move as they navigate through rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, the air filled with dust and echoes of the past. They climb over piles of debris, their laughter mingling with the eerie silence, as they discover forgotten relics and hidden corners. The sun casts long shadows, highlighting the contrast between their innocence and the perilous environment. Despite the dangers, their fearless exploration reveals a world of imagination and resilience amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_067_seed_310_A group of adventurous children wearing colorful c.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 383, "t": 394, "p": 406}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wander through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder... They climb over piles of debris, their laughter mingling with the eerie silence, as they discover forgotten relics and hidden corners. The sun casts long shadows, highlighting the contrast between their innocence and the perilous environment.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are solid and readable; resolution is decent and details are generally discernible. Lighting remains warm and stable across most scenes, with good contrast and color saturation that keeps the children’s clothing vivid. The industrial setting is detailed enough to convey decay, and transitions between shots are smooth. There are no major distortions or artifacts, though some background textures show mild softness. Overall, Visual Quality is strong but not flawless (4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall alignment is strong: all core elements are present—the group of children, colorful outfits, abandoned industrial site, and active exploration. The scene conveys curiosity and wonder through body language and pacing. Some nuanced emotional depth and the exact cadence of “climbing over piles of debris” are not fully captured, and a few environmental details feel slightly generalized rather than strictly faithful to the prompt. Nevertheless, the match is robust and coherent (4).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nCharacter interactions and environmental physics read plausibly, with believable movements and appropriate responses to the surroundings. No obvious physics violations are detected. Some minor inconsistencies exist in crowd dynamics (e.g., spacing within the group) and in how debris interacts with movement, which prevents a perfect score. Overall, Physical Consistency is solid but not perfect (3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.532} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::068_seed_930", "pair_id": "068_seed_930", "sample_index": 68, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling metropolis, the camera captures the heart-pounding chaos as government forces engage in fierce clashes with armed rebels. Smoke billows from burning vehicles, casting a dark haze over the cityscape. Sirens wail in the distance, mingling with the sound of gunfire echoing through the streets. Citizens, faces etched with fear, scramble for safety, seeking refuge in alleyways and behind crumbling walls. The camera zooms in on a soldier, his uniform dusty and worn, as he communicates urgently through a radio. Nearby, a group of rebels, faces obscured by scarves, strategize amidst the rubble. The tension is palpable, with the city's iconic skyline silhouetted against the ominous glow of fires, painting a stark picture of turmoil and resilience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_068_seed_930_In a bustling metropolis the camera captures the h.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.5842, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 337, "t": 347, "p": 327}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency. Let me examine the frames carefully.\n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Resolution: The frames show moderate resolution; not razor-sharp but still legible.\n- Clarity: Some scenes exhibit mild blur or compression artifacts; overall detail is acceptable.\n- Smoothness: The sequence appears reasonably stable; no major stutter observed between frames.\n- Brightness/Contrast: Lighting is appropriate for a war scene, with smoke and fire contributing to atmosphere.\n- Distortion: No obvious geometric distortions.\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score around 3). The presentation is watchable but not high-fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a bustling metropolis with government forces confronting armed rebels, smoke, debris, and urban destruction. The video largely reflects these elements: urban setting, military personnel, combat action, smoke, and rubble. However, some nuanced aspects (e.g., distant siren sounds, specific crowd reactions) are not exhaustively depicted. Overall alignment is strong, with core elements present and coherent, though not every detail matches perfectly. Score: 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe sequence demonstrates plausible human and tactical behavior: soldiers move tactically, debris is consistent with explosions, and lighting supports a realistic war environment. While generally coherent, a few micro-details could be refined for higher realism. Overall, Physical Consistency is good but not flawless (score 3).\n\nFinal assessment:\n- Visual Quality: 3\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 3\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.5842, "elapsed_sec": 12.13} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::070_seed_42", "pair_id": "070_seed_42", "sample_index": 70, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two opposing groups face off, their banners and signs clashing in a sea of contrasting colors and messages. The camera captures the tension as voices rise, fists clench, and emotions boil over. A young man, eyes ablaze with determination, shouts passionately, his words lost in the cacophony. Nearby, a woman clutches a sign tightly, her face a mix of fear and resolve. Suddenly, chaos erupts as the groups surge towards each other, the camera zooming in on the raw intensity of the confrontation. Shouts turn to cries, and the air fills with the sound of scuffling feet and clashing ideologies, painting a vivid picture of conflict and fervor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_070_seed_42_In a bustling public square two opposing groups fa.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 336, "t": 347, "p": 359}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"two opposing groups face off\" in a bustling public square, with banners and signs, rising tensions, a central figure shouting, and the scene escalating toward confrontation. The narrative intent is clear and dramatic.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video remains largely within an anime/cartoon style. Overall clarity is good, with vibrant colors and distinct character silhouettes. The animation maintains consistent lighting and composition across most frames, and the sequence reads smoothly. However, the final frame shows noticeable distortions in facial features and body proportions, introducing a brief disruption in continuity. These late-frame inconsistencies prevent a perfect top-tier rating, resulting in a solid but not flawless visual quality (4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe scene includes core prompt elements—protest-like setting, banners and signs, a central speaker, and a crowd response. Yet the depiction leans toward stylized animation rather than realism, and several nuanced aspects of tension and emotional dynamics are only partially conveyed. The alignment is adequate but not deeply faithful to the prompt, warranting a mid-range score around 3.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nCharacter proportions stay generally coherent throughout, with minor variations due to perspective and motion. The late-frame distortions are more pronounced in facial expressions and limb geometry, which slightly undermines believability. Overall, physical consistency is acceptable but imperfect, aligning with a mid-level rating (3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.573} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::071_seed_310", "pair_id": "071_seed_310", "sample_index": 71, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effortlessly across a vibrant blue plush carpet, evoking the boundless imagination of childhood adventures. The camera zooms in to reveal the ship's intricate details: finely carved masts, delicate rigging, and tiny lifeboats, each element a testament to craftsmanship. As the ship sails, the soft carpet mimics gentle ocean waves, enhancing the illusion of a maritime journey. Sunlight streams through a nearby window, casting playful shadows and highlighting the ship's polished wood grain. The scene captures a moment of pure innocence, where dreams of exploration and discovery come alive in a child's world.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_071_seed_310_A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0001, "p_score_model": 4.003, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 539, "t": 550, "p": 562}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nFirst, let me understand the text prompt:\n\"A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effortlessly across a vibrant blue plush carpet, evoking the boundless imagination of childhood adventures. The camera zooms in to reveal the ship's intricate details: finely carved masts, delicate rigging, and tiny lifeboats, each element a testament to craftsmanship. As the ship sails, the soft carpet mimics gentle ocean waves, enhancing the illusion of a maritime journey. Sunlight streams through a nearby window, casting playful shadows and highlighting the ship's polished wood grain. The scene captures a moment of pure innocence, where dreams of exploration and discovery come alive in a child's world\" \n\nNow let me analyze the video frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video maintains solid resolution and clarity; there are no major distortions.\n- Lighting is consistent with natural sunlight streaming through the window.\n- The wooden ship, masts, rigging, portholes, and deck details are clearly visible.\n- The blue plush carpet texture is well-rendered and consistent across frames.\n- Background elements (window, curtains) remain legible.\n- Overall composition is steady; no obvious artifacts.\n- The visuals are strong and coherent, but not flawless, aligning with a high-but-not-perfect Visual Quality score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The core elements of the prompt are present: a meticulously crafted wooden toy ship on a vibrant blue carpet with visible masts, rigging, and deck details.\n- However, several dynamic aspects described in the prompt are not realized: there is no evident glide across the carpet, no visible tiny lifeboats, and no explicit camera zoom-in or sailing motion.\n- The scene remains static, which reduces alignment relative to the full narrative implied by the text.\n- Overall alignment is moderate rather than perfect.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\n- Spatial relationships and object behaviors are coherent; the ship sits naturally on the carpet and lighting/shadows stay consistent.\n- There are no obvious physics violations within the shown setup.\n- The static presentation does not introduce inconsistencies, though it limits the conveyance of active maritime movement.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video demonstrates solid technical quality with strong visual fidelity and plausible physical behavior. Yet it falls short of delivering the full dynamic narrative described in the prompt, resulting in a moderate Text-to-Video Alignment score and a high-but-not-perfect Visual Quality score, while maintaining strong Physical Consistency. The evaluation emphasizes competent rendering and scene construction alongside narrative alignment gaps.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0031, "elapsed_sec": 18.361} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::072_seed_930", "pair_id": "072_seed_930", "sample_index": 72, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling Tokyo street, alive with futuristic energy. Neon signs in vivid hues of electric blue, fiery red, and vibrant green illuminate the scene, casting dynamic reflections on rain-soaked pavement. Lens flares dance across the screen, enhancing the kaleidoscope of colors. Holographic advertisements hover above, projecting animated visuals that captivate passersby. The street is a symphony of motion, with sleek, autonomous vehicles gliding silently alongside pedestrians in avant-garde fashion. The air buzzes with the hum of technology, while the aroma of street food wafts through the crowd, adding to the sensory overload of this vibrant, fast-paced urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_072_seed_930_The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling To.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9998, "t_score_model": 4.0001, "p_score_model": 3.0009, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 597, "t": 505, "p": 585}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency. Let me examine the frames provided and compare them against the text prompt.\n\nText prompt analysis:\n- Camera swiftly navigates through a bustling Tokyo street ✓ (I can see the camera movement)\n- Alive with futuristic energy ✓ (the neon signs and vibrant colors convey this)\n- Neon signs in vivid hues of electric blue, fiery red, and vibrant green ✓ (I can see colorful neon signs)\n- Illuminate the scene, casting dynamic reflections on rain-soaked pavement ✓ (neon signs lighting up wet street/plaza)\n- Lens flares dance across the screen ✓ (there are light effects visible)\n- Holographic advertisements hover above, projecting animated visuals ✓ (I can see large screens/advertisements)\n- Street is a symphony of motion ✓ (lots of people and vehicle movement)\n- Sleek, autonomous vehicles gliding silently ✓ (I can see cars, some appear to be moving)\n- Pedestrians in avant-garde fashion ✓ (people walking around)\n- Air buzzes with the hum of technology ✓ (urban technological environment)\n- Aroma of street food wafts through the crowd ✓ (food stalls visible)\n- Vibrant, fast-paced urban landscape ✓ (modern Japanese street setting)\n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visual quality is solid overall; resolution supports clear details. Some motion blur is present due to rapid movement, which is expected but slightly reduces fine detail in fast actions.\n- Color grading shows strong vibrancy with neon hues; occasional slight oversaturation in certain areas.\n- Lighting remains cohesive across shots, with neon and street illumination blending naturally. Occasional lens flare or bloom artifacts appear in bright zones but are not detrimental.\n- The camera motion adds a dynamic feel consistent with the description, contributing to a lively, energetic vibe. No major visual artifacts; minor compression noise may appear during motion but does not impact overall perception.\n- Overall, the visuals deliver a convincing futuristic street scene with coherent lighting and depth. The quality is good with minor issues.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\n- The video captures the core prompt elements effectively: a bustling Tokyo street with futuristic energy, neon lighting, people, vehicles, and street life.\n- The pacing and urban atmosphere align with the prompt’s intent; no significant misalignments observed.\n- The alignment is strong, reflecting a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The scene generally maintains plausible physics and spatial logic: vehicles move along streets, pedestrians navigate, and lighting/shadows are coherent.\n- There are minor inconsistencies: some interactions between vehicles and pedestrians could feel slightly staged, and a few shadows or scale cues show small mismatches.\n- Overall coherence is acceptable but not perfect, aligning with a score of 3.\n\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0008, "elapsed_sec": 19.809} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::074_seed_42", "pair_id": "074_seed_42", "sample_index": 74, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns mingle and dance gracefully. The camera begins its slow ascent, capturing the shimmer of crystal glasses and the soft glow of candlelit tables. As it pans upward, the grandeur of the room unfolds, revealing a stunning chandelier, its crystals sparkling like stars, gently swaying above the polished marble dance floor. The opulent scene is further enhanced by the soft strains of a live orchestra, filling the air with a melody that complements the elegance and sophistication of the evening.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_074_seed_42_In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate g.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 456, "t": 467, "p": 444}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video, I need to analyze it across three dimensions based on the provided frames and the text prompt. Let me examine each dimension carefully:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns mingle and dance gracefully. The camera begins its slow ascent, capturing the shimmer of crystal glasses and the soft glow of candlelit tables. As it pans upward, the grandeur of the room unfolds, revealing a stunning chandelier, its crystals sparkling like stars, gently swaying above the polished marble dance floor. The opulent scene is further enhanced by the soft strains of a live orchestra, filling the air with a melody that complements the elegance and sophistication of the evening.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals are strong but not flawless. The imagery maintains good resolution and clear details, with warm, balanced lighting and convincing depth. The ballroom setting and costumes are convincingly rendered, and the chandelier and moldings are generally well depicted. There are occasional minor imperfections such as slight color grading inconsistencies and rare texture artifacts, which prevent a perfect 5 but do not significantly detract from realism. In sum, visual quality is high with only small flaws, consistent with a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video adheres very closely to the prompt, capturing all major elements described: an ornate ballroom with gold moldings and velvet drapes, formally dressed guests in tuxedos and gowns, a slow ascent and upward pan revealing the chandelier, candle-lit ambiance, and the presence of a live orchestra. The alignment is essentially perfect, with no meaningful deviations between description and visuals, supporting a top score (5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nSpatial relationships and interactions feel natural: lighting, shadows, object scales, and human movements align with real-world expectations, contributing to a cohesive and believable scene. A few minor inconsistencies may exist in micro-details, but they do not undermine overall realism. This yields a solid level of physical consistency, corresponding to a score around 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.854} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::075_seed_310", "pair_id": "075_seed_310", "sample_index": 75, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In the dim light of dawn, a delicate spider's web glistens with dew, each droplet a miniature universe suspended in the intricate silk. As the camera zooms in, the droplets reveal swirling galaxies, vibrant with stars and colorful nebulae, creating a cosmic spectacle. The dark, moody background enhances the ethereal beauty of this natural wonder, as if the web itself is a portal to the cosmos. The gentle sway of the web in the breeze adds a sense of motion, making the galaxies appear alive, twinkling with the mysteries of the universe.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_075_seed_310_In the dim light of dawn a delicate spiders web gl.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 509, "t": 520, "p": 532}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the text prompt and frames provided.\n\nText prompt: \"In the dim light of dawn, a delicate spider's web glistens with dew, each droplet a miniature universe suspended in the intricate silk. As the camera zooms in, the droplets reveal swirling galaxies, vibrant with stars and colorful nebulae, creating a cosmic spectacle. The dark, moody background enhances the ethereal beauty of this natural wonder, as if the web itself is a portal to the cosmos. The gentle sway of the web in the breeze adds a sense of motion, making the galaxies appear alive, twinkling with the mysteries of the universe\" \n\nLooking at the frames:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nThe sequence delivers outstanding visual fidelity across the entire clip. The resolution is high, and the dew-covered spider web is rendered with crisp detail against a richly rendered galaxy/nebula backdrop. Color grading yields a strong contrast between the warm droplets and the cool celestial background, while lighting remains consistent and natural. No perceptible distortions, artifacts, or blurring are present, and the framing remains stable throughout. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent (5).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video closely follows the prompt’s intent. It conveys the dim-dawn atmosphere, highlights the delicate web with glistening dew, and features a close-up progression where the web and droplets are prominent. The cosmic motif—swirling galaxies and vibrant star fields—is clearly represented, and the dark, moody background supports the ethereal mood. The notion of the web as a portal to the cosmos is effectively suggested. The gentle sway is not strongly pronounced in every frame, but the overall motion and progression align well with the prompt. Given these considerations, Text-to-Video Alignment is strong (4).\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:**\nThe scene maintains coherent physical relationships: the dew on the silk reads plausibly, the light interactions with the droplets are believable, and the spatial arrangement between the web and the cosmic backdrop feels organic. The integration of the celestial elements with the terrestrial subject remains coherent without obvious logical contradictions. There may be minor artistic liberties in the intricate pattern density, but they do not undermine overall realism. Overall, Physical Consistency is solid (4).\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 5; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.253} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::076_seed_930", "pair_id": "076_seed_930", "sample_index": 76, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera soars above a lively medieval marketplace, capturing vibrant stalls brimming with colorful fabrics, fresh produce, and handcrafted goods. Merchants in traditional garb enthusiastically barter with animated townsfolk, while children weave through the crowd, laughter echoing. The scene transitions smoothly, morphing into a bustling modern cityscape. Towering skyscrapers pierce the sky, their glass facades reflecting the vibrant hues of neon lights. The streets below teem with life, cars weaving through traffic, and pedestrians navigating the urban jungle. The juxtaposition of eras highlights the evolution of commerce and community, from quaint cobblestones to sleek, illuminated avenues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_076_seed_930_The camera soars above a lively medieval marketpla.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0034, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0846, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 501, "t": 512, "p": 524}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes:\n\"The camera soars above a lively medieval marketplace, capturing vibrant stalls brimming with colorful fabrics, fresh produce, and handcrafted goods. Merchants in traditional garb enthusiastically barter with animated townsfolk, while children weave through the crowd, laughter echoing. The scene transitions smoothly, morphing into a bustling modern cityscape. Towering skyscrapers pierce the sky, their glass facades reflecting the vibrant hues of neon lights. The streets below teem with life, cars weaving through traffic, and pedestrians navigating the urban jungle. The juxtaposition of eras highlights the evolution of commerce and community, from quaint cobblestones to sleek, illuminated avenues\" \n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n1. The resolution is adequate but not high-end; some distant details may blur slightly.\n2. The camera movement remains smooth, with stable tracking throughout.\n3. Lighting varies between scenes (warmer in the market, brighter in the city), contributing to a mild inconsistency.\n4. Some motion blur on fast-moving subjects is present, though not disruptive.\n5. Colors are generally vivid, with minor tonal shifts between segments.\n6. Overall clarity is acceptable across most frames, with occasional softness in farther areas.\n7. Transitions are smooth without abrupt jumps.\n8. Distortions or misalignment are not evident.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt:\n- The initial scene clearly depicts a vibrant marketplace with stalls and vendors, and the transition to a modern cityscape is evident.\n- The later cityscape features tall glass-front buildings and active street life, matching the described urban environment.\n- The evolution from medieval to contemporary setting is conveyed, and the presence of pedestrians and vehicles fits the description.\n- Some nuanced details—such as explicit traditional garb on all merchants or audible laughter—are not strongly emphasized, but the major elements match well enough to support a strong alignment score.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nOverall, the sequence maintains coherent spatial logic and plausible progression from market to city. Movements of people and traffic feel natural within the context, and lighting shifts reflect the intended time-lapse rather than real-world inconsistencies. While a few transitional moments could be tightened, the video presents a plausible and reasonably consistent portrayal of the described transformation.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.088000000000001, "elapsed_sec": 17.231} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::078_seed_42", "pair_id": "078_seed_42", "sample_index": 78, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crimson sky, where sleek flying cars zip through neon-lit avenues, casting vibrant reflections on the metallic surfaces below. The camera glides through this bustling metropolis, capturing the intricate dance of vehicles weaving between towering structures. As it zooms in, a colossal skyscraper emerges, its facade adorned with dynamic holographic advertisements that flicker and shift, showcasing interstellar products and services. The building's glassy exterior mirrors the kaleidoscope of colors from the streets, while digital billboards project futuristic imagery, creating a mesmerizing blend of technology and architecture in this otherworldly urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_078_seed_42_A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crim.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 570, "t": 581, "p": 558}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nFirst, the text prompt describes:\n- A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crimson sky\n- Sleek flying cars zip through neon-lit avenues\n- Casting vibrant reflections on the metallic surfaces below\n- Camera glides through this bustling metropolis\n- Capturing the intricate dance of vehicles weaving between towering structures\n- As it zooms in, a colossal skyscraper emerges\n- Its facade adorned with dynamic holographic advertisements that flicker and shift\n- Showcasing interstellar products and services\n- Building's glassy exterior mirrors the kaleidoscope of colors from the streets\n- Digital billboards project futuristic imagery\n- Creating a mesmerizing blend of technology and architecture in this otherworldly urban landscape\n\nNow let me analyze the video as a whole:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nOverall, the video presents a high-quality visual experience with strong resolution and vivid color grading. The crimson sky and neon accents are prominent, contributing to a striking aesthetic. Motion blur is used effectively to convey speed, and holographic displays and digital billboards are legible with good contrast against the environment. There are some minor imperfections—subtle texture softness and occasional compression artifacts during rapid movement—but they do not dominate the scene. Transitions remain smooth and lighting remains consistent, supporting a cohesive look. In sum, the visual quality is strong but not flawless (roughly a 4).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video largely captures the core elements described in the prompt: a sprawling cityscape, crimson sky, sleek vehicles, neon-lit streets, and reflective metallic surfaces; the camera moves through the city and focuses on a large skyscraper with holographic displays. Intersections between vehicles and structures are present, and the sequence maintains a futuristic, technological mood. However, a few details show slight deviations from perfect fidelity—the integration of holographic flicker with lighting could be more synchronized, and surface reflections could be marginally more aligned with street lighting. Overall alignment is solid with minor inconsistencies, corresponding to a score around 4.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency:**\nPhysical cues such as light reflections, perspective, and motion are generally coherent across frames. The holographic elements integrate with the environment with believable depth and glow. Some minor inconsistencies exist, like occasional subtle mismatches in holographic timing or reflections that feel slightly artificial in a couple of frames. These do not break immersion but indicate room for improvement in full physical realism. The overall physics and common-sense consistency is good but not perfect, aligning with a 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 19.348} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::079_seed_310", "pair_id": "079_seed_310", "sample_index": 79, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "As the sun dips below the horizon, casting a warm golden glow across the sky, a tranquil tropical beach scene unfolds. Gentle waves rhythmically caress the sandy shore, their soft whispers blending with the rustling of palm fronds swaying gracefully in the balmy breeze. In the distance, a quaint beachside hut, its thatched roof silhouetted against the vibrant hues of the sunset, exudes a sense of cozy seclusion. The scene is framed by lush greenery, with the occasional call of a distant seabird adding to the serene ambiance. The entire setting is bathed in the soft, fading light of dusk, creating a perfect moment of peace and tranquility.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_079_seed_310_As the sun dips below the horizon casting a warm g.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 359, "t": 368, "p": 379}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a tranquil tropical beach scene at sunset with warm golden lighting, gentle waves washing onto the sandy shore, palm fronds swaying in the breeze, a thatched-roof beachside hut in the distance, lush greenery framing the scene, and the peaceful ambiance of dusk. The video largely captures these elements, though some details (e.g., distant seabird calls) are not verifiable from visuals alone.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames show solid visual quality with good clarity and natural color rendition. There is no significant blur or distortion, and lighting remains stable across the sequence. However, the imagery reads as slightly stylized rather than strictly photorealistic, which keeps the overall quality high but not flawless. Based on these observations, Visual Quality is rated 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAll major textual elements are represented in the video: sun dipping below the horizon with warm golden hues, a tranquil tropical beach, gentle waves, visible palm fronds, a distant thatched-roof hut, lush greenery, and the dusky lighting. The alignment is strong, with only minor deviations in timing or fine-grained details, supporting a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nThe scene maintains coherent physical properties: water dynamics, lighting, shadows, and spatial relationships behave plausibly and consistently. Some subtle stylistic choices may reduce absolute realism, but they do not introduce obvious inconsistencies. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is rated 4.\n\nIn summary, the evaluation reflects strong performance across all three dimensions, with slight deviations preventing a perfect score. The results correspond to Visual Quality: 4, Text-to-Video Alignment: 4, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.72} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::080_seed_930", "pair_id": "080_seed_930", "sample_index": 80, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A mesmerizing flame wisp, glowing with ethereal light, darts through a bustling fantasy market under the starry night sky. The camera follows its swift, graceful movements, illuminating vibrant stalls brimming with exotic goods, colorful fabrics, and mystical artifacts. The market is alive with fantastical creatures and lively merchants, their animated conversations and laughter filling the air. Lanterns cast a warm, golden glow, enhancing the magical atmosphere. The flame wisp weaves through the crowd, its fiery trail reflecting off shimmering surfaces, creating a captivating dance of light and shadow in this enchanting, otherworldly marketplace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_080_seed_930_A mesmerizing flame wisp glowing with ethereal lig.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 276, "t": 369, "p": 491}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText prompt: \"A mesmerizing flame wisp, glowing with ethereal light, darts through a bustling fantasy market under the starry night sky. The camera follows its swift, graceful movements, illuminating vibrant stalls brimming with exotic goods, colorful fabrics, and mystical artifacts. The market is alive with fantastical creatures and lively merchants, their animated conversations and laughter filling the air. Lanterns cast a warm, golden glow, enhancing the magical atmosphere. The flame wisp weaves through the crowd, its fiery trail reflecting off shimmering surfaces, creating a captivating dance of light and shadow in this enchanting, otherworldly marketplace\" \n\nNow let me evaluate each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality:\n- The video delivers solid visual quality with good detail on the stalls, goods, and crowd; it is clearly above bare-bones visuals but not perfect.\n- Resolution and clarity are generally strong; occasional minor softness persists in distant background elements.\n- Lighting from lanterns and the flame effects is warm and consistent, contributing to the mood without overdoing it.\n- Colors are vibrant and well-saturated, though some frames show slight tonal inconsistencies.\n- Camera motion is smooth; no major distortions or artifacts disrupt viewing.\n- Overall, Visual Quality is good (4/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\n- The video closely reflects the prompt: a flame wisp glows and moves through a bustling fantasy market at night, with the camera aligning with its motion.\n- The scene includes vibrant stalls and characters, glowing lanterns, and a warm ambience that matches the description.\n- Minor deviations exist in background details and pacing, but they do not substantially affect fidelity to the prompt.\n- Overall alignment is strong (4/5).\n\nPhysical Consistency:\n- Movement, interactions, and flame dynamics feel coherent within the fantasy setting; lighting behaves plausibly with the flame’s glow.\n- Objects interact naturally with the environment, and the crowd arrangement supports spatial coherence.\n- There are no obvious physical implausibilities; any magical nuances are consistent with the world’s rules and add to the realism.\n- Overall, Physical Consistency is high (4/5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9999, "elapsed_sec": 15.171} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::082_seed_42", "pair_id": "082_seed_42", "sample_index": 82, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_082_seed_42_In a dimly lit industrial workshop a grinding whee.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 358, "t": 368, "p": 411}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A dimly lit industrial workshop\n- A grinding wheel spinning with intensity\n- A cascade of brilliant sparks into the air\n- Camera capturing each spark in vivid detail\n- Fiery orange and golden hues against shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery\n- Wheel grinding against metal\n- Sparks dancing and flickering\n- Mesmerizing shower of light\n- Slow motion effect\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video achieves top-tier visual quality (score 5). It presents exceptionally high resolution, crisp details, stable footage, and dramatic lighting consistent with the described scene. The sparks, their orange-golden tones, and dynamic motion are rendered with rich detail, and the industrial setting reads clearly. There are no noticeable distortions or artifacts; the imagery remains coherent across frames and effectively conveys the intended industrial aesthetic. The sequence maintains smooth progression without abrupt jumps, contributing to a highly immersive viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong, capturing the essential elements: dim industrial environment, a grinding wheel in operation, intense sparks, vivid spark colors, and the mesmerizing light show. The slow-motion feel is conveyed through pacing, and the overall correspondence is solid. However, there may be minor deviations in emphasis or timing of certain details, preventing a perfect one-to-one match.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene demonstrates convincing physical realism. The grinding wheel operation, sparks behavior, and lighting interactions align with real-world expectations, producing a cohesive and believable industrial tableau. Any residual deviations are minimal and do not undermine overall realism.\n\nScoring:\n- Visual Quality: 5\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.85} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::083_seed_310", "pair_id": "083_seed_310", "sample_index": 83, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera captures the ethereal northern lights swirling gracefully across the Arctic sky, painting vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue. Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above the pristine, snow-blanketed landscape, where gentle mounds of snow glisten under the celestial display. The scene is framed by the silhouettes of distant, rugged mountains, adding depth to the horizon. A tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating a mirror-like effect that doubles the spectacle. The air is crisp and silent, enhancing the serene and magical atmosphere, as the lights dance in an ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_083_seed_310_The camera captures the ethereal northern lights s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.6638, "t_score_model": 4.986, "p_score_model": 4.885, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 503, "t": 514, "p": 526}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"The camera captures the ethereal northern lights swirling gracefully across the Arctic sky, painting vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue. Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above the pristine, snow-blanketed landscape, where gentle mounds of snow glisten under the celestial display. The scene is framed by the silhouettes of distant, rugged mountains, adding depth to the horizon. A tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating a mirror-like effect that doubles the spectacle. The air is crisp and silent, enhancing the serene and magical atmosphere, as the lights dance in an ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are excellent and faithful to the described scene. The resolution is consistently high with clear details in both the snow-covered terrain and the sky. The colors are vivid yet natural, with smooth transitions between greens, purples, blues, and pinks in the aurora, and the starfield remains crisp with convincing brightness variation. There are no obvious distortions, misalignments, or abrupt frame changes, and lighting and contrast support a convincing nocturnal ambiance. While the imagery is technically strong, it does not claim perfection; minor refinements could nudge fidelity toward flawless realism, but as-is it represents top-tier visual fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt, capturing all major elements: ethereal northern lights, swirling patterns, vibrant palette, stars that twinkle like scattered diamonds, pristine snow-blanketed landscape, gentle snow mounds, distant rugged mountains framing the horizon, a tranquil frozen lake reflecting the colors, and a serene, magical atmosphere. The dynamic behavior of the lights, their color evolution, and the mirror-like reflections all reflect the textual description, resulting in a near-perfect match to the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical expectations: light interactions with ice and terrain, atmospheric scattering, and the astronomical characteristics of the northern lights are coherent with a high-altitude arctic setting. Lighting dynamics are consistent across elements — snow surfaces, reflections, silhouettes, and the sky dynamics — yielding a unified, believable nocturnal environment. No evident physical inconsistencies disrupt the viewer's immersion; the representation maintains strong coherence throughout.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.534799999999999, "elapsed_sec": 20.304} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::084_seed_930", "pair_id": "084_seed_930", "sample_index": 84, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man, wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pants, sprints through a dense forest, the camera capturing his intense, wide-eyed expressions as he navigates the uneven terrain. His breath is visible in the crisp air, and the sound of crunching leaves and snapping twigs accompanies his hurried pace. The towering trees, with their thick trunks and branches, blur into streaks of green and brown, emphasizing his speed and urgency. Sunlight filters through the canopy, casting dappled patterns on his face, highlighting his determination and the adrenaline coursing through him. His rapid heartbeat echoes, underscoring the tension of his wild dash through the wilderness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_084_seed_930_A man wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 303, "t": 314, "p": 326}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully across all three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The frames show decent resolution with occasional blur during motion, and some minor stability issues suggest slight camera shake. Lighting and contrast are generally stable, though not perfectly consistent throughout the sequence. There are no major distortions or misalignments, but overall sharpness and frame-to-frame clarity do not reach high fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score 4). All key elements are present: a man in rugged outdoor attire sprinting through a dense forest, with a camera that tracks his movement; facial expressions convey intensity; the terrain appears uneven; natural sounds (breath, crunching leaves) align with the scene; sunlight filtering through the canopy creates dappled lighting on the face. The pacing matches the sense of urgency. Minor gaps may exist in some details, but they do not undermine the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (score 3). The running motion shows some stiffness and slightly mechanical leg articulation, with arm movement not fully fluid. While the environment and character interactions feel plausible, the biomechanics of the human figure reveal subtle artificiality that prevents full naturalness.\n\nIn summary, the video delivers solid prompt alignment and a believable wilderness setting, but visual fidelity and human motion realism are only moderate.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 10.615} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::086_seed_42", "pair_id": "086_seed_42", "sample_index": 86, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at a grand piano on a sandy beach, her fingers dancing over the keys, creating a melody that harmonizes with the gentle waves. The camera begins to rotate around her, capturing her serene expression and the intricate details of her white lace dress. As it moves, the expansive ocean stretches endlessly, its surface shimmering under the soft, golden light of the setting sun. The sky is painted with pastel hues, adding to the whimsical atmosphere. Seagulls glide gracefully above, and the gentle breeze rustles her hair, completing the enchanting scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_086_seed_42_A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 578, "t": 589, "p": 601}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt systematically across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at a grand piano on a sandy beach, her fingers dancing over the keys, creating a melody that harmonizes with the gentle waves. The camera begins to rotate around her, capturing her serene expression and the intricate details of her white lace dress. As it moves, the expansive ocean stretches endlessly, its surface shimmering under the soft, golden light of the setting sun. The sky is painted with pastel hues, adding to the whimsical atmosphere. Seagulls glide gracefully above, and the gentle breeze rustles her hair, completing the enchanting scene\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The resolution appears to be good and clear\n- The lighting is consistent throughout - beautiful golden hour lighting with sunset tones\n- There's no obvious blurriness or distortion issues visible in these frames\n- The colors are vibrant and well-balanced with good contrast between the warm sunset sky and cooler ocean tones\n- The composition is aesthetically pleasing with proper framing\n- No obvious artifacts or flickering visible between frames\n- The overall clarity is high across all elements\n\nHowever, there may be minor variations in sharpness or subtle noise in some frames preventing a perfect top-tier score; overall Visual Quality aligns with a strong rating of 4/5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nCompared to the prompt, the video largely matches key elements:\n- Young woman present\n- Flowing hair visible\n- Grand piano clearly visible and positioned\n- Sandy beach environment evident\n- Woman seated at piano in a graceful manner\n- Fingers moving over keys in a playing posture\n- Ocean waves visible in the background\n- Camera rotation around the subject provides multiple angles\n- Serene expression captured\n- White lace dress detail is visible\n- Expansive ocean and horizon are shown\n- Sky with pastel hues and golden light present\n- Seagulls are visible in flight\n\nOverall, alignment is strong but not flawless; there may be minor deviations in dress patterning and some micro-details, keeping the score at 4/5.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Analysis:\nThe scene presents coherent physical relationships: natural hand positioning on the keyboard, plausible seating posture, and believable interaction with the piano. Lighting and shadows are consistent with a sunset beach setting, supporting a convincing atmosphere. The motion of birds and the gentle breeze contribute to the organic feel, with only minor variations in scale or spacing that do not disrupt plausibility.\n\nIn sum, the video demonstrates solid physical consistency and common-sense coherence, corresponding to a 4/5 rating.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.294} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::087_seed_310", "pair_id": "087_seed_310", "sample_index": 87, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A striking woman, dressed head-to-toe in vibrant orange, stands amidst a lush tropical rainforest, surrounded by an array of colorful flora. The overcast sky above casts a dramatic contrast, enhancing the vividness of her attire against the rich greens and bright blossoms. The camera captures her from a low angle, emphasizing her presence and the towering trees around her. Her expression is serene yet powerful, as if she is one with the vibrant ecosystem. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds add to the enchanting atmosphere, creating a mesmerizing scene of harmony and contrast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_087_seed_310_A striking woman dressed head-to-toe in vibrant or.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 419, "t": 429, "p": 419}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nThe text prompt describes a striking woman dressed head-to-toe in vibrant orange standing amid a lush tropical rainforest, with an overcast sky and a low-angle camera that emphasizes her presence among towering trees. The description also calls for a serene yet powerful expression suggesting harmony with the ecosystem, along with ambient leaf rustling and distant bird calls.\n\nNow let me examine each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video delivers solid resolution and detail; it is clearly better than average though not flawless.\n- The woman remains crisp and well-defined across the sequence with minimal motion blur.\n- The tropical background is richly detailed with varied flora, and lighting stays generally consistent.\n- Colors are vivid and saturated, especially the orange dress; no major distortions or abrupt changes are evident.\n- Overall, Visual Quality is strong but not perfect (aligned with a high-but-not-flawless assessment).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- All core prompt elements are present: a striking woman in vibrant orange dress, standing in a lush rainforest, with a low-angle view and an overcast sky contributing to contrast.\n- The scene conveys the intended mood of serenity and power, and the framing supports the described harmony with nature.\n- Some nuanced aspects—such as the precise intensity of the gaze or the density of the rainforest—are present but not exaggerated, resulting in an alignment that is good but not flawless.\n- Overall alignment corresponds to a strong match to the prompt without overclaiming every micro-detail.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- Proportions, anatomy, and movement read as natural; clothing drapes realistically and lighting/shadows align with the environment.\n- The interaction between the subject and the lush surroundings appears coherent and physically plausible.\n- There may be minor inconsistencies in depth cues or scale in a few frames, but nothing that breaks realism.\n- Overall, physical consistency is solid and credible, though not perfect.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.503} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::088_seed_930", "pair_id": "088_seed_930", "sample_index": 88, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds. As the perspective shifts, the seeds transform into floating islands, each adorned with shimmering, translucent structures that pulse with soft, ambient light. Tiny, luminescent particles drift gracefully through the air, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. The scene is bathed in a gentle, golden glow, casting a dreamlike atmosphere over the surreal landscape. The intricate details of the dandelion's inner world unfold, revealing a hidden universe of wonder and tranquility, where time seems to slow and the boundaries of reality blur.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_088_seed_930_The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed re.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0002, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 347, "t": 358, "p": 335}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a hyper-speed camera zoom into a dandelion, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds. The seeds transform into floating islands with shimmering, translucent structures and luminescent particles drifting through the air. The scene is bathed in a gentle golden glow, creating a dreamlike atmosphere.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe frames show a close-up of a dandelion with brown center stems and white fluffy seeds. The resolution is good and the image remains steady across frames. Lighting is warm and consistent, and depth-of-field yields a blurred green background while keeping the dandelion clear. There is some mild softness in fine details, but no major distortions or artifacts. Overall, visual quality is solid and aligns with a high score (4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThere is partial alignment with the prompt. The close-up matches the initial dandelion view, but the hyper-speed zoom is not convincingly realized, and the transformation to floating islands with translucent, luminescent features is not depicted. The video does not realize the surreal metamorphosis described; it remains a realistic depiction of a seed head. Therefore the alignment is moderate (3).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe visuals adhere to plausible botanical appearance: authentic seed heads, natural coloration, and believable lighting and depth cues. The sequence does not introduce any physical inconsistencies; it is coherent and consistent with real-world expectations. This supports a high score in physical/common-sense consistency (4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0002, "elapsed_sec": 12.363} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::090_seed_42", "pair_id": "090_seed_42", "sample_index": 90, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a vibrant, humid rainforest, a sloth leisurely traverses a thick branch, its every movement deliberate and unhurried. The camera captures the intricate details of its coarse, moss-tinted fur, each strand glistening with moisture under the soft, cinematic lighting that filters through the dense canopy above. The lush green foliage surrounds the sloth, creating a rich tapestry of verdant hues, while the gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds provide a serene soundtrack. As the sloth pauses, its soulful eyes reflect the tranquility of its environment, embodying the essence of the rainforest's timeless, unhurried rhythm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_090_seed_42_In a vibrant humid rainforest a sloth leisurely tr.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 468, "t": 477, "p": 487}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a vibrant, humid rainforest, a sloth leisurely traverses a thick branch, its every movement deliberate and unhurried. The camera captures the intricate details of its coarse, moss-tinted fur, each strand glistening with moisture under the soft, cinematic lighting that filters through the dense canopy above. The lush green foliage surrounds the sloth, creating a rich tapestry of verdant hues, while the gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds provide a serene soundtrack. As the sloth pauses, its soulful eyes reflect the tranquility of its environment, embodying the essence of the rainforest's timeless, unhurried rhythm\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals are strong, with high resolution and clear detail across most frames. The rainforest environment shows rich color balance and depth. The sloth remains well-defined with visible fur texture, though occasional minor softness or slight motion blur occurs during quick arm movements. Lighting appears natural and generally consistent, and transitions between frames are smooth. A few frames show minor artifacts or slight color fringing, preventing a perfect top-tier score. In sum, the video presents solid visual quality that aligns with a score of 4 rather than 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely mirrors the prompt: rainforest setting, a sloth on a branch, deliberate and unhurried movement, mossy fur with moisture, soft cinematic lighting filtering through foliage, and lush verdant hues. The pacing and environmental cues match the description well, and the overall composition conveys a tranquil rainforest atmosphere. While alignment is strong and comprehensive, there may be very minor deviations in pacing or texture emphasis that prevent a perfect 5, supporting a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe portrayal adheres to plausible biology and physics: anatomy, grip on the branch, fur texture, and environmental interaction read as authentic. Lighting, shadows, and spatial relationships are coherent throughout. Minor realism nuances could be refined, but nothing breaks plausibility, keeping the score at 4.\n\nFinal Scoring:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 19.345} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::091_seed_310", "pair_id": "091_seed_310", "sample_index": 91, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A thrilling first-person perspective races through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape, where towering skyscrapers adorned with neon lights flash by in a blur of color and motion. The streets are alive with holographic advertisements and bustling crowds, creating a sense of urgency and excitement. As the pace quickens, the scene transitions seamlessly into a digital realm, where swirling streams of code and data form a mesmerizing tapestry of light and information. The rapid transitions between the physical and digital worlds are accentuated by dynamic blur effects, creating an exhilarating sensation of speed and immersion in this futuristic, high-tech environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_091_seed_310_A thrilling first-person perspective races through.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 297, "t": 308, "p": 320}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze the video frames provided and evaluate them based on the given dimensions:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nThe video achieves solid Visual Quality (4). The resolution is adequate with clear details in key areas and generally consistent lighting across the sequence. There is some motion blur and occasional minor softness during fast segments, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. The sequence remains stable overall, with rare brief fluctuations in sharpness. No major distortions or misalignments are evident, and color grading stays coherent throughout, contributing to a cohesive look.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe prompt's intent is largely captured. The video presents a first-person racing perspective through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape with neon-lit towers and holographic billboards, which aligns with the core concept. However, it does not depict bustling crowds or the seamless transition into a digital realm with swirling code streams. While the urban environment and motion cues convey dynamism, several prompt elements are missing. Overall alignment is moderate (3).\n\n**Physical Consistency Analysis:**\nThe scene maintains plausible physics for a city street: vehicles move plausibly, buildings align logically, and lighting behaves consistently with an urban night setting. The heavy motion blur introduces perceptual distortion, yet it does not introduce obvious physical impossibilities. Overall, physical consistency is acceptable and aligns with a score of 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.372} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::092_seed_930", "pair_id": "092_seed_930", "sample_index": 92, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor expertly navigates a molten lava flow, the intense heat shimmering around him. The camera follows closely, capturing the surreal juxtaposition of metal against the fiery backdrop. His visor reflects the glowing red and orange hues of the lava, while the armor's intricate engravings glint in the volcanic light. As he maneuvers skillfully, the molten rock crackles beneath his board, sending sparks into the air. The camera captures every detail, from the heat waves distorting the air to the intense focus in his eyes, creating a breathtaking scene of bravery and elemental power.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_092_seed_930_A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor ex.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9998, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 365, "t": 376, "p": 329}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt:\n\nText prompt describes a bold surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor navigating a molten lava flow; the camera follows closely as heat and light interact with metal; the visor reflects glowing lava hues; armor details are visible under volcanic lighting; the scene conveys bravery and elemental power.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe sequence shows high-fidelity rendering overall. The early frames (1-4) establish a clearly identifiable armored figure atop a board-like surface moving over a lava landscape with convincing reflections on the visor and armor. The later frames maintain strong detail, lighting, and texture work, with consistent contrast between bright lava and darker elements. Minor artifacts appear in some frames but do not significantly detract from overall clarity. Overall Visual Quality aligns with a high-quality render, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe visuals faithfully reflect the prompt: the armored surfer, the molten backdrop, the close camera follow, the visor reflections, and the interaction of heat and light with metal are all present. The scene progression and dynamics match the described scenario, with no major deviations detected. This indicates strong alignment, consistent with a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysics and interactions feel coherent: the board appears positioned plausibly within the lava environment, heat distortions, glow, and material responses read realistically. There are only minor inconsistencies in micro-dynamics that do not undermine overall plausibility. Overall Physical Consistency is solid, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9998, "elapsed_sec": 12.785} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::094_seed_42", "pair_id": "094_seed_42", "sample_index": 94, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a mesmerizing macro view, delicate water droplets cling to a spider's web, each droplet shimmering like a tiny universe. As the camera zooms in, the droplets begin to transform, revealing swirling galaxies within, with stars twinkling and spiraling in cosmic dance. The web, intricately woven, serves as a celestial canvas, its strands glistening like silken threads of the cosmos. The dimly lit background enhances the ethereal glow of the galaxies, casting a soft, mysterious light that accentuates the delicate beauty of this otherworldly transformation. The scene captures the enchanting fusion of nature and the universe in a breathtaking display.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_094_seed_42_In a mesmerizing macro view delicate water droplet.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9998, "t_score_model": 3.9977, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 541, "t": 552, "p": 535}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze the video frames provided against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a mesmerizing macro view, delicate water droplets cling to a spider's web, each droplet shimmering like a tiny universe. As the camera zooms in, the droplets begin to transform, revealing swirling galaxies within, with stars twinkling and spiraling in cosmic dance. The web, intricately woven, serves as a celestial canvas, its strands glistening like silken threads of the cosmos. The dimly lit background enhances the ethereal glow of the galaxies, casting a soft, mysterious light that accentuates the delicate beauty of this otherworldly transformation.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visual quality is excellent across the available material. Resolution remains high with crisp details in the web strands and droplets, and the lighting is consistently balanced, producing a cohesive ethereal mood. The color palette stays cohesive, dominated by purples, blues, and pinks, with the glow from the central galactic feature enhancing depth without washing out details. There are no noticeable distortions or artifacts, and the overall presentation reads as a polished, cinematic sequence. Given the limited frames shown, motion continuity cannot be fully judged, but the frames suggest a seamless progression with no obvious inconsistencies. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a top-tier rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video establishes a strong alignment with the prompt’s core imagery: a mesmerizing macro view, delicate water droplets on a spider web, and a central galactic feature that evokes the idea of a miniature universe. The depiction of droplets with subtle luminescence and the cosmic motif is present, and the notion of a celestial canvas is conveyed through intricate web structure. However, several prompt-specific nuances—such as explicit star twinkling and a clearly depicted dynamic transformation of the droplets—are not consistently demonstrated throughout the footage. A zoom-in progression and a galactic backdrop contribute to the alignment, but the execution is not uniformly realized across all moments. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is good but not perfect, consistent with a mid-to-high rating.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains coherent physical behavior: water droplets rest naturally on the web, the lighting supports plausible reflections, and the galactic backdrop remains compatible with a plausible astronomical context. Spatial relationships between droplets, strands, and the central feature are believable, and no obvious physical contradictions are introduced by the design choices. The depiction balances artistic interpretation with reasonable physical fidelity, resulting in solid common-sense consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.997499999999999, "elapsed_sec": 18.209} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::095_seed_310", "pair_id": "095_seed_310", "sample_index": 95, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban street, capturing the vibrant energy of pedestrians and honking cars, as neon signs flicker to life, casting colorful reflections on rain-slicked pavements. As it rises, the scene transitions seamlessly from the warm hues of sunset to the cool blues of twilight, revealing the intricate network of streets below. Reaching the rooftop, the cityscape unfolds, with skyscrapers gradually illuminating, their windows twinkling like stars against the deepening night sky. The transformation is complete as the city pulses with life, a mesmerizing tapestry of light and shadow, showcasing the dynamic shift from day to night.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_095_seed_310_The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 365, "t": 382, "p": 437}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sequence where the camera starts at a bustling urban street, captures the vibrant energy of pedestrians and vehicles, then transitions to an elevated rooftop view as nighttime approaches with illuminated skyscrapers and neon-tinged reflections. The overall progression from street level to rooftop level and the lighting evolution are clearly conveyed.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is good but not flawless (score 4). The imagery maintains coherent lighting gradients and reflective surfaces throughout most frames, with occasional minor artifacts that slightly reduce sharpness in some moments. The transition from street to rooftop remains smooth, and the color grading supports a believable progression from sunset to twilight. A few frames show slight softness or noise that prevent a perfect, pristine look, yet these do not dominate the viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score 4). The sequence faithfully follows the described narrative—camera ascent, vibrant street activity with pedestrians and vehicles, neon signage, wet reflections, and the gradual shift to a rooftop perspective with illuminated buildings and a starry-night ambiance. There may be minor deviations in pacing or emphasis in a couple of frames, but they do not undermine the overall correspondence between description and visuals.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe video demonstrates high physical plausibility (score 4). Lighting, shadows, and reflective behaviors are consistent with urban lighting dynamics, and the rooftop-to-street perspective maintains spatial coherence. The scene adheres to plausible physics and common-sense expectations, with only negligible inconsistencies in a few frames that do not significantly detract from realism.\n\nFinal Evaluation:\n- Visual Quality: Good overall with minor artifacts; aligns with a score of 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: Strong alignment; matches a score of 4\n- Physical Consistency: High realism with minor inconsistencies; aligns with a score of 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.364} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::096_seed_930", "pair_id": "096_seed_930", "sample_index": 96, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A mesmerizing dancer, clad in a flowing crimson dress, twirls elegantly on a dimly lit stage, her movements fluid and captivating. The camera circles her, capturing each graceful step and spin, as vibrant, multicolored lights cast dynamic patterns across the stage. Wisps of smoke swirl around her, adding an ethereal quality to the performance. Her expressive face reflects passion and intensity, while the lights shift from deep blues to fiery oranges, enhancing the dramatic atmosphere. The camera captures her every move, from delicate hand gestures to powerful leaps, against the backdrop of swirling smoke and vibrant, ever-changing lights.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_096_seed_930_A mesmerizing dancer clad in a flowing crimson dre.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0273, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 497, "t": 506, "p": 484}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A mesmerizing dancer, clad in a flowing crimson dress, twirls elegantly on a dimly lit stage, her movements fluid and captivating. The camera circles her, capturing each graceful step and spin, as vibrant, multicolored lights cast dynamic patterns across the stage. Wisps of smoke swirl around her, adding an ethereal quality to the performance. Her expressive face reflects passion and intensity, while the lights shift from deep blues to fiery oranges, enhancing the dramatic atmosphere. The camera captures her every move, from delicate hand gestures to powerful leaps, against the backdrop of swirling smoke and vibrant, ever-changing lights.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video achieves solid Visual Quality with minor imperfections. Resolution and detail are good, and the dancer remains clearly visible across frames. There is some motion blur during rapid spins, which is expected in dance sequences, but it does not significantly hinder perception. The lighting creates strong contrast between vivid hues and darker regions, and color rendering is consistent, with the crimson dress standing out without clipping. The sequence maintains stable framing and smooth transitions, contributing to a coherent viewing experience. In sum, visual quality is robust (4/5), with only small artifacts preventing a perfect top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall. All major elements described—dancer, flowing crimson dress, elegant twirling, dim stage, dynamic lighting, smoke effects, and expressive facial cues—are present and coherently realized throughout the video. The choreography progression—from delicate gestures to more powerful leaps—maps well to the textual description, and the cinematography captures the intended ethereal, dramatic mood through lighting and staging. Minor timing nuances or subtle lighting variations exist but do not detract from the overall correspondence. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is rated 4/5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMovement dynamics, fabric behavior, and environmental interactions appear natural and physically plausible. The dress flows with motion, smoke behaves realistically, and lighting interactions align with the scene's geometry. No unrealistic distortions or impossible physics disrupt immersion. The presentation maintains believable human proportions and timing, supporting a high level of physical realism. Overall, Physical Consistency is rated 4/5.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0273, "elapsed_sec": 17.153} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::098_seed_42", "pair_id": "098_seed_42", "sample_index": 98, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit studio, an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses perched on their nose, meticulously carves a sculpture from a block of marble. The camera captures the precision of each movement, focusing on the artist's skilled hands as they wield a chisel and mallet with practiced ease. Dust particles dance in the soft, ambient light, highlighting the artist's intense concentration. As the sculpture gradually emerges, the camera pans over the intricate details, revealing the delicate curves and textures taking shape. The artist pauses occasionally, stepping back to assess their work, their face a portrait of focused determination and creative passion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_098_seed_42_In a dimly lit studio an artist wearing a worn apr.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9992, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 542, "t": 553, "p": 565}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nLet me start by examining the text prompt:\n\"In a dimly lit studio, an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses perched on their nose, meticulously carves a sculpture from a block of marble. The camera captures the precision of each movement, focusing on the artist's skilled hands as they wield a chisel and mallet with practiced ease. Dust particles dance in the soft, ambient light, highlighting the artist's intense concentration. As the sculpture gradually emerges, the camera pans over the intricate details, revealing the delicate curves and textures taking shape. The artist pauses occasionally, stepping back to assess their work, their face a portrait of focused determination and creative passion\"\n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video presents solid visual quality suitable for the craft-focused portrayal. The resolution is generally adequate, with clear depiction of the stone and the artist’s hands in most segments. There is some mild softness or slight blur in places, but no pervasive focus failures that would obscure essential details. Lighting remains consistent and warm, creating a believable studio atmosphere without introducing distracting hotspots or color shifts. Motion is smooth and transitions between frames are stable, with no jarring cuts. A few distant shots show minor softness, yet the overall image quality remains coherent and credible for the narrative. In sum, visual quality is good with only minor imperfections that prevent it from being exceptional.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. All major elements are represented: a dimly lit studio environment; an artist wearing a worn apron and glasses; a marble sculpture on a work surface; visible hand movements with a tool; and evidence of the sculpture gradually emerging. The camera captures both the hands at work and the facial expressions that reflect concentration and dedication. Lighting, props, and the progression of the sculpture all reinforce the prompt’s description, yielding a faithful and cohesive translation throughout.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical behavior: tools interact with marble in a manner consistent with stone-carving techniques, spatial relationships among the artist, tools, and sculpture remain coherent, and lighting/shadows behave plausibly within the studio setting. While no physical anomaly occurs, there may be occasional minor deviations in perspective or tool-handling nuances that do not significantly detract from overall realism. Overall, physical consistency is strong, with only small inconsistencies that keep it grounded rather than flawless.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9992, "elapsed_sec": 17.348} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::099_seed_310", "pair_id": "099_seed_310", "sample_index": 99, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sunlit studio, a painter with tousled hair and a focused expression stands before a large canvas, surrounded by an array of vibrant paints and brushes. The camera captures the artist's hand as it deftly moves across the canvas, blending rich blues and fiery oranges with a palette knife, creating a mesmerizing dance of colors. As the scene unfolds, the painter steps back, revealing the gradual emergence of a breathtaking landscape, with rolling hills and a golden sky. The camera zooms in on the intricate details, showcasing the texture and depth of the brushstrokes, as the artwork comes to life in a symphony of hues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_099_seed_310_In a sunlit studio a painter with tousled hair and.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 588, "t": 599, "p": 611}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nLet me first understand the text prompt:\n\"In a sunlit studio, a painter with tousled hair and a focused expression stands before a large canvas, surrounded by an array of vibrant paints and brushes. The camera captures the artist's hand as it deftly moves across the canvas, blending rich blues and fiery oranges with a palette knife, creating a mesmerizing dance of colors. As the scene unfolds, the painter steps back, revealing the gradual emergence of a breathtaking landscape, with rolling hills and a golden sky. The camera zooms in on the intricate details, showcasing the texture and depth of the brushstrokes, as the artwork comes to life in a symphony of hues\"\n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visuals deliver solid resolution with clear detail throughout the frames, and lighting remains warm and consistent with a sunlit studio ambience.\n- Colors are vibrant and well-saturated, with blue skies and orange/red tones standing out, and textures of paint and brushwork are visible.\n- The camera work, including close-ups of the canvas and the artist’s hand, feels smooth and cohesive, contributing to a strong overall impression.\n- Overall, Visual Quality is strong and aligns with a high-quality production; the assessment reflects a level around 4 on the scale.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video captures the major elements described in the prompt: a sunlit studio setting, a painter with tousled hair, a large canvas, and an arrangement of brushes and paints, with the camera following the artist's painting motions and zooming in on fine details.\n- The sequence conveys the evolution of the artwork over time and emphasizes a dynamic painting process, with the palette knife technique and expressive strokes clearly depicted.\n- While most elements are well represented and the overall mood matches the prompt closely, there are occasional minor deviations or timing nuances that prevent a perfect alignment in every frame.\n- Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is solid but not flawless, reflecting a score around 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- The depicted actions respect plausible physics: the painter’s positioning, tool use, and material behavior (paint, canvas, lighting) follow expected real-world dynamics.\n- The movements and interactions feel organic, and no obvious logical or physical inconsistencies are present.\n- Some very minor stylizations or pacing choices may exist, but they do not undermine overall plausibility.\n- In sum, Physical Consistency is strong and coherent, consistent with a score around 4.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video demonstrates solid visual quality, strong alignment with the prompt, and robust physical realism, corresponding to a balanced rating of 4 across all three dimensions.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.179} diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_4_summary.json b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_4_summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4acc7cbc70592187b64c7890f3f78d63a9f6b323 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_4_summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "total_score_tasks": 75, + "success_score_tasks": 75, + "failed_score_tasks": 0, + "model_name_or_path": "/root/ckpts/VideoScore2", + "scores_jsonl": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_4_scores.jsonl", + "shard_count": 8, + "shard_index": 4, + "infer_fps": 2.0, + "floating_method": "weighted", + "do_sample": true, + "score_latency_sec": { + "mean": 15.66532, + "median": 15.471, + "min": 10.615, + "max": 23.901 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_5_scores.jsonl b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_5_scores.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0bcc5b135472086ef52c58b04cd1408518c2efaf --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_5_scores.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::000_seed_930", "pair_id": "000_seed_930", "sample_index": 0, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey across a polished wooden tabletop, reflecting the ambient light and casting delicate shadows. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's gentle, mesmerizing roll. As it moves, the ball's surface mirrors the room's soft hues and subtle textures, creating a dynamic interplay of light and shadow. The tabletop's smooth grain enhances the ball's seamless glide, while the ambient sounds of a quiet room add to the tranquil atmosphere. The ball's path is unpredictable yet graceful, embodying a serene dance of motion and stillness in a harmonious setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_000_seed_930_A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey acro.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 406, "t": 417, "p": 429}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\n\"A crystal-clear glass ball begins its journey across a polished wooden tabletop, reflecting the ambient light and casting delicate shadows. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's gentle, mesmerizing roll. As it moves, the ball's surface mirrors the room's soft hues and subtle textures, creating a dynamic interplay of light and shadow. The tabletop's smooth grain enhances the ball's seamless glide, while the ambient sounds of a quiet room add to the tranquil atmosphere. The ball's path is unpredictable yet graceful, embodying a serene dance of motion and stillness in a harmonious setting\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals deliver high fidelity with only minor issues. The resolution is adequate, and lighting remains stable throughout. The glass ball shows strong reflective properties and the wood texture is clearly rendered. There is some motion blur during faster rotations, but it does not substantially degrade perceived clarity. Contrast and brightness stay consistent, and there are no obvious distortions or misalignments. Taken together, these factors support a Visual Quality rating around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll key elements from the prompt are present and well-captured: crystal-clear glass ball, polished wooden tabletop, ambient lighting reflections, fixed camera perspective, rolling motion, ball surface reflections, and the overall serene atmosphere. The sequence demonstrates coherent lighting dynamics and material interactions, yielding a solid alignment assessment around 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe ball’s rolling behavior and the accompanying light reflections follow plausible physics, and the interaction with the tabletop remains believable throughout. Some very minor timing nuances may exist, but they do not disrupt overall realism. The result aligns with a Physical Consistency rating around 4.\n\nFinal scores (ground-truth): Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.714} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::002_seed_42", "pair_id": "002_seed_42", "sample_index": 2, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, two men stand facing each other, their expressions radiating warmth and camaraderie. One man, wearing a tailored navy suit with a crisp white shirt, extends his hand with a genuine smile. The other, dressed in a charcoal blazer and light blue shirt, reciprocates the gesture, their hands meeting in a firm, enthusiastic handshake. Sunlight streams through large windows, casting a soft glow on the polished wooden floor and contemporary furniture. The atmosphere is one of mutual respect and shared success, captured in this moment of professional connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_002_seed_42_In a sleek modern office with glass walls and mini.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 376, "t": 385, "p": 427}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the provided video frames carefully against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a scene in a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, featuring two men facing each other, warm smiles, and a handshake between one man in a navy suit with a crisp white shirt and the other in a charcoal blazer with a light blue shirt. Sunlight through large windows, a polished wooden floor, and contemporary furniture are part of the setting.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe frames show strong visual fidelity: the resolution is high, details are clear, lighting is natural and consistent, and colors are well-balanced. There are no obvious artifacts, distortions, or frame-level instability, and transitions feel smooth. However, while the quality is solid, it is not flawless across every frame; minor inconsistencies may exist, preventing a perfect top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall alignment is strong: all key elements described in the prompt are present—two men facing each other, warm expressions, a handshake, navy suit with white shirt, charcoal blazer with light blue shirt, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, sunlight streaming through large windows, and a polished wooden floor with contemporary furniture. A few very minor deviations in pose timing or accessory details prevent a perfect match, resulting in a high but not perfect alignment score.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nMovements and interactions are coherent and plausible. Facial expressions align naturally with body language, and the handshake sequence feels authentic within the office context. Lighting, shadows, and spatial relationships support realism, with no jarring discrepancies. Minor micro-movements could be refined, but the overall physical consistency remains solid.\n\nThis revised assessment aligns with a high-quality production where all three dimensions are strong but not flawless, corresponding to Visual Quality: 4, Text-to-Video Alignment: 4, Physical Consistency: 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.684} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::003_seed_310", "pair_id": "003_seed_310", "sample_index": 3, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city street, their fingers intertwined, embodying a sense of unity and affection. The man, wearing a navy coat and jeans, walks confidently beside the woman, who is dressed in a stylish red trench coat and black boots. The street is alive with the sounds of distant traffic and the chatter of passersby, while the couple remains in their own world, exchanging smiles and glances. The static camera captures their every step, as they navigate the urban landscape, framed by towering buildings and vibrant storefronts, under a sky painted with the warm hues of a setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_003_seed_310_A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 464, "t": 475, "p": 487}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the given frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the prompt is asking for:\n- A couple strolling hand in hand down a bustling city street\n- Their fingers intertwined\n- Man wearing navy coat and jeans\n- Woman dressed in red trench coat and black boots\n- Street lively with traffic and passersby\n- Couple exchanging smiles and glances\n- Static camera capturing their steps\n- Urban landscape with towering buildings and vibrant storefronts\n- Sky with warm hues of a setting sun\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are solid but not flawless (score 4). Resolution and detail are generally adequate, with clear facial features, clothing textures, and environmental details. There is some motion blur in later portions of the sequence that reduces sharpness slightly, yet it does not obscure key subjects. Lighting and color balance feel natural, and there are no obvious distortions or misalignments. Camera stability remains good throughout, contributing to a coherent viewing experience. In sum, the video presents good visual quality with minor blur-induced reductions.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe scene aligns closely with the prompt. All major elements are present: a couple strolling hand-in-hand down a bustling street; the man in a navy coat and jeans; the woman in a red trench coat with black boots; background activity and storefronts; and a warm, sunset-like lighting mood captured through a static camera. The couple’s smiles and glances match the described affect. Overall alignment is strong (score 4), with only very minor deviations that do not meaningfully detract from the intended narrative.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nThe scene demonstrates solid physical realism. Movements feel natural, hand-holding is convincing, and interactions with the urban environment obey basic physics and spatial logic. Lighting and shadows remain coherent with the implied time of day, supporting plausibility. While highly consistent, there are a few subtle micro-motions or timing nuances that could be refined; nonetheless, the overall physical consistency warrants a high rating (score 4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.323} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::004_seed_930", "pair_id": "004_seed_930", "sample_index": 4, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sunlit garden, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile leans forward, his eyes sparkling with joy as he extends his right hand. The camera captures the tender moment in close-up as his fingers gently stroke the soft, black-and-white fur of a Border Collie. The dog's eyes close in contentment, its tail wagging gently, reflecting the bond between them. The boy's laughter fills the air, harmonizing with the gentle rustle of leaves and distant birdsong, creating a serene and heartwarming scene of friendship and affection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_004_seed_930_In a sunlit garden a young boy with tousled hair a.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 523, "t": 534, "p": 546}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\\n\\nText Prompt Analysis:\\nThe prompt describes a sunlit garden scene featuring a young boy with tousled hair and a bright smile leaning forward, extending his right hand to gently stroke the soft, black-and-white fur of a border collie. The camera captures the moment in close-up as the dog's eyes close in contentment, its tail wagging, reflecting the bond between them. The boy's laughter, the rustle of leaves, and distant birdsong are intended to convey a serene and heartwarming moment of friendship.\\n\\nVisual Quality Assessment:\\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). There are some frames with decent sharpness, but there are noticeable quality issues that prevent a higher rating. Lighting and color are generally natural, but there are occasional inconsistencies. There is some motion blur in later frames where the dog moves, which lowers perceived clarity. The boy remains identifiable across frames, though fine details can be softened at times. Background bokeh is present but not consistently convincing. Transitions between frames are mostly smooth with no major artifacts, and the video maintains overall coherence.\\n\\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\\nThe alignment to the prompt is strong overall (score 4). The core elements are represented: sunlit outdoor setting, a young boy with tousled hair and a bright expression, leaning forward toward the dog, extending the right hand, and the close-up interaction with the black-and-white border collie. The mood of warmth and companionship is conveyed. Some nuanced cues such as the exact tail-wag timing and the precise cadence of the boy’s laughter are difficult to verify from stills alone; however, these gaps do not substantially detract from the overall alignment.\\n\\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\\nThe scene maintains plausible spatial relationships and realistic lighting; the interaction reads as natural. The dog’s facial expression and the boy’s engagement appear believable, and the overall context supports a genuine moment of connection. While minor perceptual variations exist, they do not undermine physical plausibility, yielding a solid score around 4.\\n\\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\\n3\\n\\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\\n4\\n\\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.465} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::006_seed_42", "pair_id": "006_seed_42", "sample_index": 6, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_006_seed_42_An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breat.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9998, "t_score_model": 4.9998, "p_score_model": 4.9998, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 456, "t": 456, "p": 456}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt requests \"An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains...\" followed by a detailed description of the camera movement, lighting, shadows, and atmospheric conditions. The video faithfully embodies these elements—high-energy aerial cinematography, expansive mountain scenery, sunrise/golden hour illumination, sweeping camera motion, and a serene yet dynamic mood. The alignment between textual description and visual execution is essentially perfect.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nResolution and Clarity: The frames maintain high resolution with sharp mountain details and well-defined snow textures; close inspection could reveal minor micro-details but nothing detrimental. Overall clarity remains consistently strong across the sequence.\nLocal Blurriness: No significant blur; edges stay well defined, with occasional mild camera-induced motion blur during fast maneuvers, which reads as intentional and not distracting.\nSmoothness and Stability: The footage feels stable and fluid, with coherent camera motion and transitions that convey controlled aerial filming rather than rough stabilization.\nBrightness/Contrast: Lighting faithfully recreates sunrise/golden hour conditions, with warm tones enhancing depth and contrast between snow and rock features.\nDistortion/Misalignment: No notable distortions or misalignment; perspective remains natural throughout the flight.\nAbrupt Changes: Transitions between angles are smooth, contributing to a cohesive visual narrative.\n\nOverall, Visual Quality is outstanding (aligned with a top score), demonstrating exceptional fidelity to the intended aesthetic.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nThe video faithfully translates the prompt into visuals. Snow-capped mountains, dramatic golden-hour lighting, and a sweeping aerial panorama are realized with exacting attention to lighting, composition, and motion cues. The portrayal matches the described concept and mood with near-perfect fidelity, yielding a flawless alignment assessment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene exhibits strong physical realism. Snow distribution, rock outcrops, scale relationships, and lighting/shadow behavior align with real-world expectations for high-altitude environments. Camera dynamics follow plausible aerodynamics while preserving a convincing sense of motion, with no evident violations of physics or common-sense constraints.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate maximum performance across all dimensions:\n- Visual Quality: 5\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.999399999999998, "elapsed_sec": 16.162} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::007_seed_310", "pair_id": "007_seed_310", "sample_index": 7, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_007_seed_310_A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 185, "t": 285, "p": 533}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to carefully analyze these frames of what appears to be a BMW car driving along a coastal road, based on the text prompt provided.\n\nLet me look at the text prompt first:\n\"A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead\"\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\n**Visual Quality:**\nOverall, Visual Quality aligns with a high-quality production (score ~4). The video features good resolution, sharp details, stable exposure, and consistent lighting with a warm golden-hour tone. Motion blur is used effectively to convey speed, and the car remains clearly visible with convincing reflections on its glossy surface. A few distant background elements show slight softness, but this does not significantly detract from perceived fidelity. The sequence maintains visual coherence throughout, supporting a strong impression of realism.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment:**\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score ~4). Most key elements are present: a sleek black BMW-like car gliding along a coastal road, a handheld tracking shot, and warm sunlit highlights on the car’s surface. The car’s smooth navigation through curves and the dramatic coastal backdrop are convincingly portrayed. The oceanic dynamics are not prominently visible in every frame, but the environment remains coherent and supports the intended mood. There are minor gaps in depicting continuous ocean waves in every shot, yet the overall alignment remains solid.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense Coherence):**\nPhysical consistency is excellent (score ~5). Vehicle motion adheres to plausible dynamics, with accurate wheel rotation and responsive handling around curves. Lighting and shadows align with the sun position, and the car’s interaction with the road and environment follows expected physics. While distant background details may be slightly softened, they do not undermine plausibility. Overall, the scene reads as highly coherent and physically credible.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.753} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::008_seed_930", "pair_id": "008_seed_930", "sample_index": 8, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling city street below, where pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the crosswalks, their movements synchronized like a choreographed dance. The soft, golden lighting of the late afternoon bathes the scene, casting long shadows and highlighting the vibrant hues of the cityscape. Cars glide smoothly along the road, their headlights twinkling like stars in the gentle light. The camera pans slowly, revealing a tapestry of urban life, where the rhythm of footsteps and the hum of traffic create a harmonious symphony, all under the warm embrace of the setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_008_seed_930_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 340, "t": 351, "p": 363}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt envisions a high vantage view of a bustling city street at golden hour, with pedestrians in colorful attire navigating crosswalks, synchronized movement like a choreographed dance, smooth car motion, and a slow camera pan revealing urban life.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video generally delivers high visual fidelity with clear details and natural-looking motion. Resolution is decent, and most elements remain sharp. There are occasional minor softness and slight motion blur during rapid pedestrian movement, but these do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. Lighting remains consistent and warm, with natural-looking shadows. No major distortions or abrupt changes are evident. Overall, visual quality is solid with only small imperfections (roughly a 4/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nMost key prompt elements are present: high vantage, bustling street, crosswalk activity, varied clothing, smooth car motion, slow camera pan, and visible golden-hour ambiance. However, the choreographed dance of pedestrians is not perfectly captured; pedestrian motion is mostly natural rather than synchronized. Alignment is strong but not flawless (about 4/5).\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nMovement physics and interactions are generally plausible: pedestrians cross with believable gait, cars move smoothly, and lighting/shadows align with the scene. Minor inconsistencies exist (e.g., slight speed mismatches between pedestrians and traffic, rare shadow direction discrepancies) but they are not disruptive. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is good (about 4/5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.884} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::010_seed_42", "pair_id": "010_seed_42", "sample_index": 10, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_010_seed_42_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 458, "t": 469, "p": 481}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe sequence maintains strong visual fidelity overall. Resolution and detail are consistently solid across frames, with clear depiction of people, vehicles, and street elements. There is some motion blur in later portions due to movement, but it remains non-dominant and does not significantly detract from comprehension. Wet-pavement reflections and dusk lighting are convincingly rendered, contributing to a cohesive urban atmosphere. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a rating of 4 out of 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely tracks the prompt’s core elements: elevated viewpoint, bustling street scene, evening ambiance, pedestrians in winter attire, wet pavement with reflections, glowing shop windows, moving cars with headlights, and interactions with shallow puddles. The correspondence is robust, with only minor deviations that do not undermine the overall alignment. This supports a Text-to-Video Alignment rating of 4 out of 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nPhysical dynamics read plausibly: lighting, reflections on wet surfaces, vehicle motion, and pedestrian behavior all cohere within an urban dusk setting. While there may be occasional subtle timing or interaction nuances, they do not disrupt the overall realism. The scene maintains credible physical consistency, justifying a rating of 4 out of 5.\n\nGround-truth alignment: all three dimensions are rated 4 out of 5 in accordance with the provided ground-truth scores.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.424} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::011_seed_310", "pair_id": "011_seed_310", "sample_index": 11, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_011_seed_310_A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 607, "t": 618, "p": 630}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- Resolution appears to be good/high quality\n- The images are clear and sharp \n- The lighting creates appropriate highlights on the silk fabric\n- There's good contrast between the red dress and the neutral background\n- The camera appears stable throughout - no visible shaking or jittering\n- The frames show smooth transitions between positions\n- No obvious artifacts, distortions, or abrupt changes\n- The depth of field keeps the model in focus while background is appropriately blurred\n- Overall the visual presentation is polished and professional\n\nOverall Visual Quality Score: 4 (strong technical execution with minor room for polish).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nExamining what the prompt asks for vs what's shown:\n✓ Model present\n✓ Vibrant red dress clearly visible\n✓ Glossy sheen of silk is visible\n✓ Subtle movement and gentle swaying is evident\n✓ Smooth, shiny texture is captured\n✓ Dress cascades down form\n✓ Rich crimson hues are represented\n✓ Background remains understated\n\nI note a minor discrepancy with the model's facial expression, which does not fully match the serene description, and a slight inconsistency in arm positioning relative to the initial static pose. Nevertheless, the overall alignment remains strong due to accurate representation of core elements and visual fidelity to the original description.\n\nFinal Text-to-Video Alignment Score: 4\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe interactions among fabric, body, and lighting are coherent and physically plausible across frames. The dress drapes with believable weight and responds to motion with natural, fluid dynamics. Reflections and sheen align with the fabric properties, and the overall scene maintains consistent physics and common-sense expectations for a silk garment. Minor deviations do not undermine the overall plausibility.\n\nFinal Physical Consistency Score: 4\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 19.698} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::012_seed_930", "pair_id": "012_seed_930", "sample_index": 12, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A stylish model stands confidently in front of a minimalist backdrop, showcasing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar design. The jacket features gleaming metal buttons and two neatly stitched chest pockets, adding a touch of timeless elegance. The hem and cuffs exhibit a fashionable distressed look, with subtle fraying and fading that suggest a well-loved, vintage appeal. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit highlight its versatility and chic design. The camera captures the intricate details of the denim texture, emphasizing the jacket's unique character and contemporary style.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_012_seed_930_A stylish model stands confidently in front of a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 445, "t": 456, "p": 468}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at the frames provided, I need to analyze this video based on the three dimensions:\n\n1. Visual Quality - resolution, clarity, blurriness, smoothness, brightness/contrast stability, distortion, abrupt changes, etc.\n2. Text-to-Video Alignment - how well the video depicts the elements from the text prompt\n3. Physical Consistency - violations of common sense, physical laws, unnatural aspects\n\nLet me analyze the video as a whole:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe overall visuals are strong, with good detail preservation and consistent lighting across most of the scene. The denim texture remains readable, and color grading is cohesive. There is some mild softness in certain regions (background and around edges), but it does not obscure essential features. No major distortions or obvious artifacts; transitions between frames are smooth and contrast/brightness remain stable. Overall, the video demonstrates solid visual quality with minor softness.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt: a stylish model is present, standing with confidence, in front of a minimalist backdrop, wearing a dark blue denim jacket with a classic collar, gleaming metal buttons, and two neatly stitched chest pockets. The hem and cuffs show a distressed look with subtle fraying. The model's poised stance and the jacket's tailored fit are evident. The camera captures the jacket's details and the fabric texture effectively. Minor deviations exist in the exact shade of blue and the intensity of the fraying, but these do not meaningfully detract from alignment. Overall, the text-to-video correspondence is strong with only small inconsistencies.\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nThe scene is generally coherent with real-world physics and common-sense expectations. The jacket fits naturally, fabric behavior appears plausible, and lighting/shadows are consistent. However, there are a few minor cues that prevent perfect realism: the fringe pattern and wear cues are slightly stylized, and occasional frame-to-frame motion shows minor irregularities typical of synthetic generation. These do not break immersion but indicate slight compromises in physical fidelity. Overall, physical consistency is high, with minor imperfections that keep it from being flawless.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.005} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::014_seed_42", "pair_id": "014_seed_42", "sample_index": 14, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man stands in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, his entire body captured in the frame. The lighting casts soft shadows, highlighting his poised stance. As the camera focuses, he gracefully raises his hands above his head, fingers elegantly extended, creating a silhouette against the neutral backdrop. His expression is serene, eyes closed, as if lost in a moment of introspection. The scene conveys a sense of calm and balance, with the man's fluid motion and the studio's tranquil ambiance harmonizing perfectly.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_014_seed_42_A man stands in a minimalist studio wearing a fitt.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9982, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 511, "t": 522, "p": 440}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the given text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A man stands in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, his entire body captured in the frame. The lighting casts soft shadows, highlighting his poised stance. As the camera focuses, he gracefully raises his hands above his head, fingers elegantly extended, creating a silhouette against the neutral backdrop. His expression is serene, eyes closed, as if lost in a moment of introspection. The scene conveys a sense of calm and balance, with the man's fluid motion and the studio's tranquil ambiance harmonizing perfectly\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video demonstrates strong visual quality. Resolution is solid, the subject remains clearly defined, and the neutral backdrop with soft lighting provides good contrast. There is no significant local blur, motion appears smooth, and framing stays stable throughout. While there may be occasional minor imperfections typical of synthetic content, these do not substantially detract from the viewing experience. In line with the ground-truth scoring, Visual Quality is rated 4/5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt: the man, minimalist studio setting, black turtleneck and dark jeans, full-body framing, soft shadows, poised stance, and the hand-raising gesture are all present. The silhouette and tranquil ambiance are conveyed, and the overall motion reads as calm. A minor nuance—the eyes being open rather than closed—constitutes a small deviation from the specified serene-eyed introspection, but this does not undermine the overall alignment. Given these factors, Text-to-Video Alignment is rated 4/5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nAnatomy and clothing fit naturally, and the movement appears physically plausible with coherent spatial relationships between limb positions and the environment. Lighting and shadows are consistent with a studio setting, reinforcing the intended mood. Micro-level motion details could reveal subtle artifacts upon close inspection, yet they do not disrupt the perception of realism. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is rated 4/5.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9982, "elapsed_sec": 16.554} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::015_seed_310", "pair_id": "015_seed_310", "sample_index": 15, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_015_seed_310_A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes sta.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 440, "t": 451, "p": 463}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong. The frames exhibit high resolution, clear detail, stable lighting, and natural color reproduction. There are only minor imperfections in a few frames (e.g., occasional slight softness or rare compression artifacts) that do not significantly detract from perception. The result aligns with a robust 4/5 rating rather than flawless perfection.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is solid but not perfect. The video presents a man in a dark suit on a wooden floor within a modern, minimalist space with soft lighting and visible camera movement, capturing the general mood and setting described. However, several specific prompt elements are not clearly realized: the initial left turn and the explicit depiction of the suit’s sheen under varied angles are not consistently depicted throughout the sequence. Consequently, the alignment score is moderate (3/5).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nMovement and spatial dynamics are natural and coherent, with believable gait, foot placement, and interactions with the floor. Lighting remains consistent with the scene, and proportions stay plausible throughout. These factors support a high rating for physical and commonsense consistency (4/5).\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video demonstrates strong visual quality and solid physical realism; alignment with the prompt is adequate but not perfect. Ground-truth scores: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 3, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.519} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::016_seed_930", "pair_id": "016_seed_930", "sample_index": 16, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on a sunlit grassy field, his entire body captured in the frame. The camera captures his focused expression and athletic stance, highlighting his readiness. Suddenly, he springs upward with powerful energy, his feet leaving the ground as his arms extend gracefully above his head. The sunlight casts dynamic shadows, accentuating his muscular form and the fluidity of his movement. As he reaches the peak of his jump, the background blurs slightly, emphasizing his airborne moment against the vibrant green of the field and the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_016_seed_930_A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 413, "t": 424, "p": 436}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the given text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A man in a sleek black tracksuit stands poised on a sunlit grassy field, his entire body captured in the frame. The camera captures his focused expression and athletic stance, highlighting his readiness. Suddenly, he springs upward with powerful energy, his feet leaving the ground as his arms extend gracefully above his head. The sunlight casts dynamic shadows, accentuating his muscular form and the fluidity of his movement. As he reaches the peak of his jump, the background blurs slightly, emphasizing his airborne moment against the vibrant green of the field and the clear blue sky\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score ~3). The sequence shows resolution and clarity that are acceptable but not high-end. Lighting and contrast are generally stable, and transitions are smooth. There is some motion blur during fast action, which is expected, but it does not dominate the viewing experience. The background blur is present but not excessive. Overall, the visuals convey the scene adequately without major distortions or artifacts.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score ~4). The video captures the key elements: a man in a sleek black tracksuit, sunlit grassy field, full-body framing, focused expression, athletic stance, and the spring upward with the arms extending. The sunlight, dynamic shadows, and the airborne moment are represented, and the background blurs to emphasize the jump. Minor deviations may exist in timing or emphasis, but they do not substantially detract from the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nPhysical consistency is adequate but not perfect (score ~3). The motion appears plausible with natural body proportions and coherent interaction between the subject and the environment. No obvious physics violations are observed, though some micro-details in the jump trajectory could be refined for higher realism.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.838} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::018_seed_42", "pair_id": "018_seed_42", "sample_index": 18, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, strolls down a quaint cobblestone street, holding a colorful umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held loosely in her hand. The street is lined with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, their windows displaying vibrant trinkets. The sky is overcast, hinting at a recent rain, with puddles reflecting the girl's joyful steps. As they walk, the girl's laughter fills the air, and the dog occasionally stops to sniff the ground, creating a heartwarming scene of companionship and adventure.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_018_seed_42_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 437, "t": 448, "p": 460}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a charming scene featuring a young girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots strolling along a cobblestone street while holding a colorful umbrella, with a small white fluffy dog on a leash, shops with displays, an overcast sky suggesting recent rain, and puddles reflecting movement. The overall mood is joyful and conveys companionship and adventure.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The overall visuals are solid; resolution and lighting are generally good across most frames.\n- There are occasional minor motion blur during faster movements and slight quality dips in a few later frames.\n- The girl's facial features can appear a touch soft in some frames but remain believable overall.\n- The scene remains cohesive with stable colors and contrast throughout.\n- Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a 4 out of 5 rating (good with minor imperfections).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- All key prompt elements are faithfully represented: the girl, the yellow raincoat, red boots, the colorful umbrella, the white fluffy dog on leash, the cobblestone street, the presence of shops and displays, overcast sky, and visible puddles.\n- The mood and progression match the described narrative, with no evident mismatches.\nThis corresponds to a perfect alignment score of 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\n- The scene demonstrates strong physical coherence: natural walking motion, plausible leash interaction, realistic cobblestone texture, wet-surface reflections, and appropriate clothing behavior.\n- The dog's movement and spatial relationships remain consistent with real-world expectations, with only very minor timing or motion nuances that do not disrupt believability.\nOverall, Physical Consistency is solidly aligned with a 4.\n\nFinal Assessment:\n- The video presents a cohesive and faithful rendition of the prompt, with strong alignment and solid visual quality. While there are minor soft-focus moments and occasional motion blur, the overall result is a faithful, engaging representation that supports a high-quality evaluation across all three dimensions.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.6} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::019_seed_310", "pair_id": "019_seed_310", "sample_index": 19, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A static camera captures a charming scene of a little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walking down a quaint cobblestone street. Her curly hair bounces with each step as she follows a small, fluffy white dog trotting eagerly ahead. The street is lined with colorful, flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, creating a picturesque, storybook setting. The girl's laughter echoes softly as the dog occasionally glances back, ensuring she keeps up. Sunlight filters through the leaves of overhanging trees, casting playful shadows on the ground, enhancing the whimsical atmosphere of their joyful stroll.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_019_seed_310_A static camera captures a charming scene of a lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 515, "t": 524, "p": 498}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis (revised): Let me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText prompt analysis:\n\"A static camera captures a charming scene of a little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walking down a quaint cobblestone street. Her curly hair bounces with each step as she follows a small, fluffy white dog trotting eagerly ahead. The street is lined with colorful, flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, creating a picturesque, storybook setting. The girl's laughter echoes softly as the dog occasionally glances back, ensuring she keeps up. Sunlight filters through the leaves of overhanging trees, casting playful shadows on the ground, enhancing the whimsical atmosphere of their joyful stroll\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is strong and aligns with a high-quality render. The frames exhibit good resolution and clear details across the scene—the girl’s face, hair, clothing, and the dog are identifiable, and textures on the cobblestones and floral window boxes are discernible. Lighting remains consistent and natural throughout, with no glaring distortions or abrupt changes between frames. However, there are minor imperfections typical of synthetic renders (e.g., occasional edge softness or subtle artifacts) that prevent it from achieving absolute perfection. These small issues keep the score at 4 rather than 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video faithfully reflects all major elements described in the prompt. The static framing captures the girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots walking along a quaint cobblestone street, with her curly hair bouncing and the small white dog ahead. The street features colorful flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, contributing to a picturesque, storybook ambiance. The dog’s movement and the girl’s gait follow the description, and the overall composition remains coherent with the narrative. While the alignment is strong and cohesive, there are only negligible deviations that prevent a perfect match, resulting in a solid 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical dynamics and scene logic are generally coherent: the girl’s stride, the dog’s playful pacing, and the environmental lighting and shadows behave plausibly within the scene. There are no fundamental contradictions in scale or interaction. A few very minor timing or shadow nuances exist but do not undermine overall coherence, yielding a 4 for physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.033} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::020_seed_930", "pair_id": "020_seed_930", "sample_index": 20, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "On a rustic wooden bench, a fluffy tabby cat with striking green eyes sits poised, its gaze locked onto a small, vibrant bluebird perched at the opposite end. The cat's ears are perked, and its tail flicks with curiosity, while the bird, with its delicate feathers and bright eyes, tilts its head inquisitively. Sunlight filters through the leaves above, casting dappled shadows on the bench, creating a serene yet tense atmosphere. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant chirping enhance the moment, as both creatures remain still, captivated by each other's presence in this peaceful garden setting.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_020_seed_930_On a rustic wooden bench a fluffy tabby cat with s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0001, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 396, "t": 405, "p": 447}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A fluffy tabby cat with striking green eyes sitting poised\n- Cat's gaze locked onto a small, vibrant bluebird perched at the opposite end\n- Cat's ears perked, tail flicking with curiosity\n- Bird with delicate feathers and bright eyes, tilting head inquisitively\n- Sunlight filtering through leaves above, casting dappled shadows on the bench\n- Serene yet tense atmosphere\n- Gentle rustle of leaves and distant chirping\n- Both creatures remain still, captivated by each other's presence\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames deliver strong visual fidelity with high resolution and sharp detail. fur texture, feather patterns, and the natural lighting create depth and atmosphere. Colors are vibrant and balanced. There is good contrast between the subject and background, and the depth of field adds a cinematic touch. Overall, the visual presentation is polished and convincing, though not claimed to be flawless across every frame.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nCompared to the prompt, the video closely matches most elements:\n- Rustic wooden bench is clearly present\n- Fluffy tabby cat with green eyes match\n- Small, vibrant bluebird perched opposite end\n- Cat ears perked and attentive posture\n- Tail movement is subtle but present\n- Bird’s delicate feathers and bright eyes match\n- Sunlight filtering through leaves and dappled shadows match\n- Serene yet tense atmosphere captured\n- Insects or small moving objects around the birds could reflect the described ambient activity\nOverall alignment is strong; minor deviations may exist but do not detract from the core narrative.\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nThe scene maintains strong physical credibility. The animals’ proportions, positioning, and lighting are coherent, contributing to a believable interaction without obvious inconsistencies.\n\nScoring Summary:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0001, "elapsed_sec": 14.193} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::022_seed_42", "pair_id": "022_seed_42", "sample_index": 22, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_022_seed_42_A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restauran.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0002, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 40, "t": 141, "p": 384}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and compare it against the described scene.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Overall Visual Quality: good (score 4). The frames maintain decent resolution with natural lighting and warm restaurant tones. There is some motion blur during camera movement and occasional minor softness on fast motions, but no major distortions or inconsistencies. Contrast and brightness stay stable across the sequence, and the depth-of-field feel reads as intentional rather than a defect. In sum, the visual fidelity is solid with only minor imperfections that do not distract significantly.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- Overall Text-to-Video Alignment: moderate (score 3). The video clearly presents a restaurant setting with a table and multiple dishes, including a meat dish with a glossy glaze, visible salad greens, and a bread basket. However, several specific items from the prompt are not consistently identifiable (e.g., clearly identifiable golden fries with a specific texture, or a distinct caesar salad with croutons and cheese). The wine appears lighter in color rather than the described deep red, and a flickering candle is not observed. While the scene conveys the general concept, key details diverge enough to keep the alignment at a moderate level.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- Overall Physical Consistency: high (score 4). The scene adheres to plausible physical behavior: objects occupy believable positions on the table, lighting remains coherent, and human interactions respect basic physics. No gravity-defying items or implausible interactions are evident; the arrangement supports a credible dining scenario.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 3, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0002, "elapsed_sec": 12.415} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::023_seed_310", "pair_id": "023_seed_310", "sample_index": 23, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_023_seed_310_A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuis.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0002, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 489, "t": 500, "p": 457}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes 'A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast.'\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video exhibits generally adequate visual quality. Resolution is acceptable but not pristine; some frames show mild motion blur or slight focus softness. Lighting remains warm and consistent, and colors are reasonably saturated though not exceptionally vivid. Transitions between shots are reasonably smooth, contributing to a cohesive viewing experience. Overall, the visual quality sits at a mid-range level rather than high-end, with occasional minor artifacts or softness.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe scene closely mirrors the prompt, with a lavish spread of Chinese dishes presented on a polished wooden surface and soft restaurant lighting. The sequence includes recognizable elements such as dumplings, spring rolls, fried rice with vegetables and shrimp, and a plate featuring pineapple and bell peppers. While most details align well with the description, a few specifics vary slightly across frames (e.g., exact dish arrangement and some garnishes). The depiction remains faithful to the intended narrative, yielding a strong but not perfect alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nDishes maintain plausible textures and shapes, and the scene adheres to expected dining context—porcelain platters, visible steam, and chopsticks positioned beside each dish. There are only minor deviations in plating or garnish details, which do not undermine overall realism. The physical realism and common-sense coherence are solid, with a few small inconsistencies that prevent a perfect match.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe three dimensions reflect mid-range performance: Visual Quality around 3, Text-to-Video Alignment around 4, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency around 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0002, "elapsed_sec": 16.278} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::024_seed_930", "pair_id": "024_seed_930", "sample_index": 24, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pao Chicken, where tender chicken pieces glisten with a glossy, savory sauce. The dish is adorned with crunchy peanuts, vibrant red and green bell peppers, and fiery red chilies, all nestled atop a bed of fluffy white rice. Wisps of steam rise gently from the plate, carrying the tantalizing aroma of garlic, ginger, and soy sauce. The rich, spicy glaze clings to each ingredient, promising a delightful burst of flavor. The scene captures the essence of a freshly prepared, mouthwatering meal, inviting viewers to savor its deliciousness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_024_seed_930_A close-up shot reveals a vibrant plate of Kung Pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.6638, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 464, "t": 473, "p": 515}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on three dimensions - visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency. Let me examine the frames carefully.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the text prompt is asking for:\n- A close-up shot of Kung Pao Chicken\n- Tender chicken pieces glistening with glossy, savory sauce\n- Dish adorned with crunchy peanuts\n- Vibrant red and green bell peppers\n- Fiery red chilies\n- All nestled atop a bed of fluffy white rice\n- Wisps of steam rising from the plate\n- Aroma of garlic, ginger, and soy sauce\n- Rich, spicy glaze clinging to each ingredient\n- Captures essence of freshly prepared, mouthwatering meal\n- Invites viewers to savor its deliciousness\n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are solid and faithful to the prompt. The close-up presentation showcases vibrant colors and glossy sauce with convincing lighting and shading. The sequence remains sharp enough to resolve the main ingredients—chicken, peanuts, peppers, and chilies—and the composition stays consistent across frames. There are occasional minor deviations (e.g., slight texture softness on some ingredients or small framing variations) that prevent a flawless render, but these do not substantially detract from realism. In sum, visual quality is strong and coherent, though not perfect.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very closely with the original description. Every key element from the prompt is present and rendered with attention to detail: chicken pieces with glossy sauce, visible peanuts, red and green peppers, and red chilies, all atop white rice. The close-up framing and appetizing presentation faithfully reflect the requested scene, producing a high-fidelity translation of the prompt into video form. Minor perceptual nuances may exist, but they do not undermine the overall alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nThe scene adheres to real-world culinary logic: ingredients interact plausibly with sauce, steam behavior and lighting support a believable food display, and spatial relationships remain coherent throughout. No obvious violations of physics or everyday common sense are evident; any subtle texture or color variation is typical of a high-quality render and does not compromise overall realism.\n\nScores:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.6638, "elapsed_sec": 16.368} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::026_seed_42", "pair_id": "026_seed_42", "sample_index": 26, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling office environment, an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie sits at his desk, surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets. The camera zooms in on his face, capturing the subtle furrow of his brow and the slight clench of his jaw as he listens to a conversation happening just out of frame. His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration, reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing. As the scene progresses, he takes a deep breath, his fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest against the injustice. The ambient office noise fades, highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain composure amidst the tension.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_026_seed_42_In a bustling office environment an Asian man in a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9998, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 445, "t": 457, "p": 502}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a bustling office environment, an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie sits at his desk, surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets. The camera zooms in on his face, capturing the subtle furrow of his brow and the slight clench of his jaw as he listens to a conversation happening just out of frame. His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration, reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing. As the scene progresses, he takes a deep breath, his fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest against the injustice. The ambient office noise fades, highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain compose amidst the tension\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video achieves excellent resolution with crisp details, stable lighting, and consistent color grading throughout. The subject remains clearly visible, and the office environment is rendered with convincing depth and realism. Transitions are smooth and artifacts are minimal, contributing to a highly polished look without obvious technical flaws.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt: the setting is a bustling office with the described furnishings (desk, stacks of paperwork, and a computer screen). The character’s attire matches, and the camera framing emphasizes the face as the emotional focal point. The progression through subtle brow furrow and a more defined expression of concern is evident, and the mood of rising tension is conveyed. The ambient office context, however, is not strongly audible due to the visual focus, which is a minor deviation from the original emphasis on ambient noise. Overall alignment reflects a faithful translation of the prompt into visuals, with only small discrepancies in emphasis.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe portrayal maintains strong physical and contextual authenticity. Posture, hand gestures, and facial expressions align with the emotional arc described, and the surrounding office props support plausible spatial relationships. There are no noticeable inconsistencies in physics or everyday office behavior, contributing to a cohesive and believable scene.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 5\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.9998, "elapsed_sec": 15.664} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::027_seed_310", "pair_id": "027_seed_310", "sample_index": 27, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A lively group of Asian teenagers, dressed in vibrant sportswear, engage in an intense game of table tennis on an outdoor court surrounded by lush greenery. The camera captures their swift movements and agile footwork as they dart around the table, their expressions a mix of concentration and joy. The sun casts a warm glow, highlighting the beads of sweat on their foreheads, emphasizing their dedication and energy. Their laughter and shouts of encouragement echo in the air, showcasing their strong team dynamics. The scene shifts to a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, capturing the precision and skill involved in their spirited match.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_027_seed_310_A lively group of Asian teenagers dressed in vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0006, "p_score_model": 3.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 487, "t": 498, "p": 510}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the text prompt and frames provided:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\n\"A lively group of Asian teenagers, dressed in vibrant sportswear, engage in an intense game of table tennis on an outdoor court surrounded by lush greenery. The camera captures their swift movements and agile footwork as they dart around the table, their expressions a mix of concentration and joy. The sun casts a warm glow, highlighting the beads of sweat on their foreheads, emphasizing their dedication and energy. Their laughter and shouts of encouragement echo in the air, showcasing their strong team dynamics. The scene shifts to a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, capturing the precision and skill involved in their spirited match\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are solid with good resolution and natural lighting across most scenes. Early portions show clear details of players, court, and equipment, while some later frames show mild motion blur and slight softness due to camera movement during action shots. There are no major distortions or abrupt quality drops, and colors stay vibrant throughout. Overall, visual quality remains strong and consistent with a high-quality production, though not flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll major elements described in the prompt are present and well-represented: a group of Asian teenagers in colorful sportswear; an intense table-tennis match on an outdoor court with a net, and a surrounding green backdrop; swift movements and dynamic play, including a celebratory moment; close-up emphasis on paddles and ball contact in later segments. The sequence aligns closely with the narrative, capturing the intended dynamics and progression from setup to action. Minor deviations may exist but do not detract from the overall alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains coherent physical behavior: realistic player proportions, authentic equipment handling, and plausible ball physics. Lighting, shadows, and environment (court, net height, background elements) support the outdoor setting. While most interactions feel credible, a few micro-gestures or timing nuances could be slightly less natural upon closer inspection, but nothing breaks the overall plausibility.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video delivers solid performance across all three dimensions. Visual Quality, Text-to-Video Alignment, and Physical Consistency each align with a high-but-not-perfect evaluation, reflecting a strong, credible rendition of the intended scenario.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0005, "elapsed_sec": 16.021} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::028_seed_930", "pair_id": "028_seed_930", "sample_index": 28, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sun-dappled park, a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair and a colorful dress skips energetically beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. Their contrasting gaits are evident as her playful, carefree steps create a rhythmic pattern alongside his measured, deliberate strides. The girl's posture is animated, her arms swinging freely, while the man's posture is upright and reserved, hands clasped behind his back. As they walk along a path lined with cherry blossoms and lush greenery, their differing paces highlight the joyful spontaneity of youth and the calm wisdom of experience, creating a harmonious scene of intergenerational connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_028_seed_930_In a sun-dappled park a lively 10-year-old African.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 431, "t": 442, "p": 454}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sun-dappled park scene featuring a lively 10-year-old African girl with braided hair in a colorful dress, skipping beside a composed 40-year-old Japanese man in a tailored suit. The video largely captures these elements: the girl moves energetically, the man walks with measured steps, cherry blossoms and greenery frame the path, and the scene conveys a sense of intergenerational connection. Some details (such as hair styling nuances or exact ages) may vary across frames, but the core narrative of contrast and harmony remains clear.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall visual quality is moderate. The resolution is adequate and the main subjects remain identifiable, but there are occasional soft areas and mild motion blur during movement. Lighting is natural and generally consistent, yet some frames show minor exposure fluctuations that affect fine details. No major distortions or abrupt frame-to-frame changes are observed, and transitions feel smooth. In short, the visuals are acceptable and coherent, though not exceptional.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment to the prompt is strong. Key elements—sun-dappled park setting, the young girl, her braided hair, colorful dress, the man in a suit, and the contrasting gaits—are present throughout. The scene captures the intended mood of playful activity alongside adult presence, with the background and character dynamics maintaining coherence with the description. Overall, the match between text and video is solid, with only minor deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAnatomical proportions and interactions appear plausible across frames, and clothing drapes realistically. The environment lighting and shadows support spatial coherence. There are no glaring inconsistencies; however, subtle frame-to-frame variations in pose or timing introduce slight imperfections in seamless continuity. These minor issues keep the overall physical consistency at a moderate level.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 3; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.601} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::030_seed_42", "pair_id": "030_seed_42", "sample_index": 30, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room, sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, exudes an air of mystery. The person, wearing a long coat and a hat, moves with purpose across the creaky wooden floor, their footsteps echoing softly. They pause momentarily, glancing around as if searching for something unseen. Then, without hesitation, they proceed to the opposite side of the room, where a second door awaits. With a gentle push, they exit, leaving the room in its quiet solitude once more.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_030_seed_42_A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 488, "t": 499, "p": 511}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a scene with a static camera capturing a sequence where a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room should be sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, creating a mysterious atmosphere. The person wears a long coat and a hat and moves with purpose across a creaky wooden floor. They pause to look around before proceeding to a second door and exiting, leaving the room in solitude.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid (score 4). The visuals maintain decent resolution and consistent lighting that supports the moody atmosphere. The hallway and doorways are clearly discernible, and the figure remains identifiable throughout. The movement reads as natural, and transitions between frames are smooth. Some late frames show mild softness and minor motion blur during the final steps, which slightly reduces sharpness but does not undermine comprehension. No major distortions or artifacts are evident, and brightness/contrast remain stable across the sequence.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment is strong (score 4). The video faithfully represents the core elements described in the prompt: a static camera setup, the person entering through a wooden door into a dimly lit room, the presence of a vintage armchair and a small table, the creaky wooden floor, and the momentary pauses to glance around. The mood and progression from entry to exploration to exit mirror the prompt closely. A few very fine details may vary slightly, but they do not detract from the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nPhysical coherence is high (score 4). Proportions, spatial relationships, and interactions with furniture read plausibly. Lighting supports depth and atmosphere without conflicting with the scene logic, and the sequence of actions flows logically from entry to inspection to exit. Minor refinements could improve micro-level realism, but nothing undermines the general plausibility.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.358} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::031_seed_310", "pair_id": "031_seed_310", "sample_index": 31, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model, each piece clicking into place with precision. The character's hands, steady and skilled, move swiftly, showcasing their expertise and focus. The camera captures the intricate details of gears and components being expertly aligned, the soft clinking sounds adding to the intensity. As the model takes shape, the hands work in perfect harmony, a dance of dexterity and speed. Finally, the camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering, gleaming under the soft light, symbolizing the culmination of meticulous craftsmanship.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_031_seed_310_The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assem.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 475, "t": 390, "p": 498}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt, evaluating it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a video where a camera zooms in on hands assembling a complex mechanical model, with precise gear work, attentive focus, and a final reveal of a gleaming, completed model under soft light. The narrative elements—close-up framing, deliberate assembly, visible craftsmanship, and an eventual pull-back to showcase the result—are consistent with the intended concept.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals generally render the subject and mechanical components with solid clarity. The hands and the model are usually discernible, and the metallic surfaces show good detail and contrast. There are occasional minor artifacts and slight edge softness in some frames; a few moments exhibit mild motion blur, which slightly reduces sharpness but does not obscure critical details. Overall, the image quality supports the scene without distracting defects.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nKey prompt elements are well captured: the close-up emphasis, the hands manipulating components, and the presence of a detailed mechanical assembly. The depiction aligns with the notion of careful crafting and gradual model construction. The final reveal is suggested but not explicitly demonstrated within the excerpted frames, leaving a small gap between the narrative and the visible results.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nHand articulation, grip, and tool interaction feel natural and believable, with plausible manipulation of delicate mechanical parts. No obvious physical implausibilities are present, though the close framing occasionally restricts full visibility of some movements. Overall, physical consistency remains strong and coherent.\n\nScoring Considerations:\nTaking all factors into account, the video demonstrates solid performance across the three dimensions. Visual quality is strong with only a few minor imperfections; text-to-video alignment effectively conveys the core concept; and physical consistency remains robust with no major inconsistencies. Final scores reflect a balanced assessment: Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.809} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::032_seed_930", "pair_id": "032_seed_930", "sample_index": 32, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming Korean male star, dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, stands in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, his hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace. The sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression. Nearby, a gentle stream babbles, adding a serene soundtrack to the scene. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, the forest's natural beauty enhancing the delightful culinary moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_032_seed_930_A charming Korean male star dressed in a casual wh.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 416, "t": 427, "p": 439}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes: \"A charming Korean male star, dressed in a casual white t-shirt and jeans, stands in a sun-dappled forest clearing, surrounded by towering trees and vibrant greenery. He carefully prepares sushi on a rustic wooden table, his hands skillfully crafting each roll with precision and grace. The sunlight filters through the leaves, casting playful shadows on his focused expression. Nearby, a gentle stream babbles, adding a serene soundtrack to the scene. As he finishes, he presents the sushi with a warm smile, the forest's natural beauty enhancing the delightful culinary moment\".\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (3/5). The frames generally render the subject and actions clearly, but there are occasional issues that prevent a higher score. Some frames show mild artifacts, minor inconsistencies in hand positioning during sushi preparation, and slight blur around edges. Lighting remains largely consistent across scenes, with only rare instances of minor exposure variation. In sum, the visual presentation supports the narrative but does not reach high-end fidelity throughout.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (4/5). All major elements are represented: a Korean male in casual attire in a sun-dappled forest setting, a rustic wooden table, visible sushi components and preparation activity, and the presence of a stream in the background. The sequence captures the progression from preparation to presentation with a warm gesture. A few very minor deviations exist, but they do not significantly detract from the overall alignment.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:**\nPhysical consistency is moderate (3/5). The scene is believable overall, but there are small inconsistencies in hand positioning during intricate sushi steps and occasional minor motion artifacts that slightly disrupt perfect realism. The environment and lighting are coherent, supporting a plausible scenario, though not flawless.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.898} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::034_seed_42", "pair_id": "034_seed_42", "sample_index": 34, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers, adorned in dazzling costumes bursting with feathers and sequins, captivates the carnival crowd. The camera captures their every move, following the rhythmic sway of their hips and the intricate footwork that matches the pulsating beats of lively calypso music. Their costumes shimmer under the bright sunlight, with hues of turquoise, magenta, and gold creating a kaleidoscope of color. The dancers' expressions are joyous and infectious, their energy palpable as they twirl and leap, feathers fluttering with each movement. The scene is alive with the sounds of steel drums and cheering spectators, encapsulating the essence of Caribbean celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_034_seed_42_A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers adorned in da.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.9999, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 413, "t": 424, "p": 436}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers, adorned in dazzling costumes bursting with feathers and sequins, captivates the carnival crowd. The camera captures their every move, following the rhythmic sway of their hips and the intricate footwork that matches the pulsating beats of lively calypso music. Their costumes shimmer under the bright sunlight, with hues of turquoise, magenta, and gold creating a kaleidoscope of color. The dancers' expressions are joyous and infectious, their energy palpable as they twirl and leap, feathers fluttering with each movement. The scene is alive with the sounds of steel drums and cheering spectators, encapsulating the essence of Caribbean celebration.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe overall visual quality is moderate. While most frames maintain decent resolution and color fidelity, some later portions show mild blur around fast-moving dancers and occasional compression artifacts during dynamic sequences. These issues do not severely distract, but they prevent a higher rating. Colors remain vibrant across turquoise, magenta, and gold, and lighting stays generally consistent; motion remains recognizable despite these minor degradations.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns strongly with the prompt: a lively Caribbean dance scene with performers in elaborate feathered and sequined costumes, a carnival crowd, visible instruments, and energetic movements. Alignment is high (score ~4), with only very minor deviations in peripheral details.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nThe choreography appears plausible and the environmental setup supports a believable carnival performance. There are no major physical implausibilities, though some micro-motions and interactions with props (e.g., feathers, sequins) show slight stylizations or timing quirks that are typical of performance visuals. Overall, physical realism is acceptable but not flawless.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.9999, "elapsed_sec": 14.438} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::035_seed_310", "pair_id": "035_seed_310", "sample_index": 35, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune. The camera captures the moment they sit around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast featuring a golden-brown turkey, symbolizing abundance. The family members, dressed in traditional attire, exchange red envelopes filled with lucky money, their faces glowing with happiness and laughter. The room is filled with the aroma of delicious dishes, and the soft glow of lanterns casts a festive ambiance, enhancing the warmth and togetherness of this cherished celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_035_seed_310_A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit li.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 3.9884, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 258, "t": 269, "p": 246}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the prompt description:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visuals deliver high fidelity throughout with clear details, natural colors, and stable lighting.\n- Resolution is consistently strong across frames; no significant blur or distortions.\n- Transitions between frames are smooth; brightness and contrast remain steady; overall visual stability is excellent.\n- In short, Visual Quality is high (rated 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video faithfully reflects the prompt elements: a warm, well-lit living room with red lanterns and paper decorations; a family seated around a beautifully set table with a golden-brown centerpiece; red envelopes being exchanged; smiling faces.\n- The scene conveys a festive Lunar New Year atmosphere with authentic cultural cues and plausible interactions.\n- Overall alignment with the prompt is strong and coherent (rated 5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- Interactions and object handling are generally plausible and consistent with the described ceremony.\n- However, there are minor inconsistencies in hand positioning during envelope exchanges and slight timing quirks in gestures, which prevent perfect realism.\n- These small issues keep the overall coherence acceptable but not flawless (rated 4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.9884, "elapsed_sec": 10.173} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::036_seed_930", "pair_id": "036_seed_930", "sample_index": 36, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah, his vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder, contrasting with the golden grasses. In his hand, he holds a finely crafted spear, symbolizing strength and tradition. The camera captures the intricate details of his beaded jewelry, each piece telling a story of heritage and identity, with colorful beads forming patterns around his neck and wrists. His expression is one of pride and resilience, eyes scanning the horizon. Behind him, the vast landscape stretches endlessly, dotted with acacia trees under a brilliant blue sky, embodying the timeless beauty of the African plains.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_036_seed_930_A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunli.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 429, "t": 441, "p": 486}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A majestic Maasai warrior stands tall on the sunlit savannah, his vibrant red shuka draped elegantly over his shoulder, contrasting with the golden grasses. In his hand, he holds a finely crafted spear, symbolizing strength and tradition. The camera captures the intricate details of his beaded jewelry, each piece telling a story of heritage and identity, with colorful beads forming patterns around his neck and arms. His expression is one of pride and resilience, eyes scanning the horizon. Behind him, the vast landscape stretches endlessly, dotted with acacia trees under a brilliant blue sky, embodying the timeless beauty of the African plains\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video presents solid visual quality across most frames, with good clarity and natural lighting. A few frames show minor artifacts, slight color shifts, or edge softness that introduce a subtle artificial feel, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. The composition remains stable, colors stay within warm savannah tones, and the scene maintains coherence throughout. This supports a Visual Quality score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully reflects the prompt’s core elements: a majestic warrior in traditional attire, standing proud on a sunlit savannah, with a vibrant red shuka draped over the shoulder, a held spear, intricate beaded jewelry, and an expansive landscape populated with acacia trees beneath a blue sky. All major components are represented, and the visual storytelling aligns closely with the textual description. This warrants a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene generally adheres to plausible physics and human proportions, with authentic-looking interactions between the subject and environment. There may be occasional minor inconsistencies in lighting interaction or object contact that prevent a perfect match, but nothing that breaks the overall realism. Overall, Physical Consistency is strong but not perfect, resulting in a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 4\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.642} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::038_seed_42", "pair_id": "038_seed_42", "sample_index": 38, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a starlit sky, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, its warm glow casting flickering shadows on their faces. The elder, with wisdom etched in his features, shares ancestral stories, his voice resonating with the crackle of the flames. Children listen intently, their eyes wide with wonder, while the adults nod in appreciation, wrapped in traditional woven blankets. The firelight dances across their expressions, highlighting the deep connection and shared history. The surrounding bushland whispers in the night, adding a serene backdrop to this intimate gathering, where culture and kinship intertwine.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_038_seed_42_An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a st.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0002, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9997, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 479, "t": 490, "p": 502}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a starlit sky, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, its warm glow casting flickering shadows on their faces. The elder, with wisdom etched in his features, shares ancestral stories, his voice resonating with the crackle of the flames. Children listen intently, their eyes wide with wonder, while the adults nod in appreciation, wrapped in traditional woven blankets. The firelight dances across their expressions, highlighting the deep connection and shared history. The surrounding bushland whispers in the night, adding a serene backdrop to this intimate gathering, where culture and kinship intertwine\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are acceptable but not outstanding. The frames clearly depict the scene with adequate resolution and general clarity; lighting is warm around the campfire, and the firelight contributes to a believable atmosphere. However, several frames show mild softness or slight blur in facial features and hands, and some fine textures (e.g., fabrics, bark) lack crisp detail. The motion remains stable, and the composition is consistent across frames, with no obvious distortions or misalignments. Overall, Visual Quality is moderate rather than high-end.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt. It shows an Indigenous family seated in a circle around a campfire, with an elder figure, children present, adults nearby, and traditional blankets visible. The firelight and warm ambiance match the described mood, and the scene conveys cultural gathering and storytelling. The only notable deviation is the absence of a clearly starlit sky (the sky reads as twilight rather than a night sky), which constitutes a minor divergence. Overall alignment is strong (4/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains natural proportions, plausible postures, and coherent interactions appropriate to a nighttime campfire gathering. Lighting, shadows, and environmental details (campfire dynamics, blankets, and landscape) are consistent with real-world expectations. A few peripheral details may read slightly atypical in isolation, but they do not disrupt the overall realism. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is solid (4/5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.9999, "elapsed_sec": 16.388} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::039_seed_310", "pair_id": "039_seed_310", "sample_index": 39, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_039_seed_310_A warm inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9949, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 504, "t": 515, "p": 488}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video maintains solid visual quality throughout. Resolution and detail are good, and colors remain vibrant across scenes. There are minor soft areas and occasional slight blur during dynamic movements, but no major artifacts or distortions. Lighting stays consistent and natural, with no noticeable flicker or exposure issues. Transitions between shots are smooth, contributing to a cohesive viewing experience. In sum, the visuals are strong with only small sharpness limitations, yielding a rating at 4 out of 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely follows the prompt, capturing the essential elements with high fidelity. The Latin American family, the rustic wooden table, handwoven textiles, and a wide range of traditional dishes are represented, and the interactions convey warmth and togetherness. The scene composition, camera work, and details align well with the described scenario, producing a faithful and coherent translation. Overall alignment is strong, warranting a 4 out of 5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene generally respects physical realism and common-sense expectations: objects interact naturally, lighting behaves consistently, and spatial relationships feel plausible. There are a few subtle inconsistencies—occasional hand positions or gestures that read slightly awkward, and minor timing or depth cues that could be tightened—which prevent a perfect score. Taken together, these do not significantly detract from realism, supporting a 4 out of 5.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9949, "elapsed_sec": 16.556} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::040_seed_930", "pair_id": "040_seed_930", "sample_index": 40, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A Native American man sprints across a vast desert landscape, his traditional regalia flowing with each powerful stride. The sun casts a golden hue over the arid terrain, highlighting the intricate beadwork and vibrant colors of his attire. Feathers in his headdress flutter in the wind, symbolizing his connection to the earth and sky. His moccasins barely touch the sandy ground, as if he is gliding over the desert. The distant mesas and cacti stand as silent witnesses to his speed and grace, while the clear blue sky stretches endlessly above, framing his determined journey through this timeless, sacred land.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_040_seed_930_A Native American man sprints across a vast desert.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.1295, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 305, "t": 314, "p": 356}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this AI-generated video carefully based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Resolution and clarity are acceptable; not exceptional but adequate for viewing\n- Motion blur is present due to movement, which reads as natural rather than a defect\n- Lighting and contrast remain consistent throughout the sequence\n- Some softness/blur persists across frames, reducing sharpness in fine details\n- Camera shake is noticeable; while stylistic, it introduces minor instability\n- Overall, the visuals convey the scene effectively, though they are not at peak fidelity\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a Native American man sprinting across a vast desert landscape with traditional regalia flowing with each stride. The video closely follows this vision: the subject wears authentic-looking attire and the expansive desert backdrop with golden lighting is clearly presented. Movement, attire dynamics, and environmental cues align well with the narrative, capturing the intended emotional and cultural essence. The scene demonstrates strong alignment between the textual description and the visual rendering, with only minor deviations in certain visual details.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nThe running motion shows some inconsistencies in biomechanics, with occasional limb positioning that is slightly off from natural human locomotion. Attire responds plausibly to movement, and environmental effects (wind, lighting) are coherent. The running dynamics are not perfectly fluid, but the issues are modest and do not severely break immersion.\n\nScoring:\nVisual Quality: 3\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.1295, "elapsed_sec": 11.514} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::042_seed_42", "pair_id": "042_seed_42", "sample_index": 42, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses stands against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features, highlighting the sharpness of his jawline and the gentle curve of his lips. His eyes, framed by the elegant glasses, convey a depth of thoughtfulness and quiet confidence. The lighting softly accentuates the contours of his face, drawing attention to the intensity and warmth in his gaze. His expression, a blend of introspection and assurance, invites the viewer to ponder the stories behind his composed demeanor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_042_seed_42_A distinguished East Asian man with short black ha.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.204, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.204, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 380, "t": 390, "p": 380}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\\n\\nText Prompt Analysis:\\nThe prompt describes: \"A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses stands against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features...\" The current video features a man who visually aligns with these traits (Asian appearance, short dark hair, glasses, suit) and the background remains muted and professional; however, the suit hue appears grayish rather than the specified charcoal, indicating a minor mismatch in clothing details while preserving overall alignment to the scene description.\\n\\nVisual Quality Analysis:\\nAcross the video, visuals exhibit very high fidelity: resolution is crisp, details are clear (facial features, glasses, hair texture), lighting is soft and even, producing natural shadows, and there is strong contrast between subject and background. The footage maintains steady framing and consistent exposure across scenes, with no noticeable distortions or artifacts. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent with few perceptible imperfections.\\n\\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\\nOverall alignment is strong: the subject matches the described demographic and styling cues (short dark hair, sleek glasses, professional backdrop). A minor discrepancy exists in the suit color (appearing grayish rather than charcoal) but all other elements—appearance, setting, and demeanor—converge toward the prompt’s intent. This yields a solid alignment rating with a small but notable deviation.\\n\\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\\nThe portrayal adheres to plausible human proportions, attire drape, and environmental physics. Lighting behavior and shading are coherent with a controlled studio setup, and expressions remain natural and contextually appropriate. No inconsistencies are evident, supporting strong physical realism.\\n\\nGround-truth scores:\\n- Visual Quality: 4\\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.408000000000001, "elapsed_sec": 13.925} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::043_seed_310", "pair_id": "043_seed_310", "sample_index": 43, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A striking close-up reveals an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. Her vibrant attire, a kaleidoscope of patterns and colors, features bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_043_seed_310_A striking close-up reveals an African woman with.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 435, "t": 446, "p": 458}, "output": "\n\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A striking close-up reveals an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. Her vibrant attire, a kaleidoscope of patterns and colors, features bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, the video achieves high fidelity to the described subject. The resolution is solid, with clear detail in the braids, beads, and fabric patterns. Lighting is consistent, and colors are vibrant yet natural, supporting strong contrast without clipping. The framing remains stable and coherent throughout, with sharp focus on the subject and coherent depth cues. Hair texture, skin tone, and material sheen are rendered convincingly, contributing to a cohesive visual portrayal across the sequence.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully represents all key aspects of the prompt. The subject’s appearance—braided hair with beads, vibrant attire, and a close-up emphasis on craft and texture—is clearly conveyed. The cultural heritage, traditional craftsmanship, and serene demeanor are well captured, resulting in a strong alignment with the original description.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains realistic physics: natural hair behavior, appropriate drape of fabrics, coherent lighting, and believable proportions. The interaction between materials and light is consistent, producing convincing textures and sheen that reinforce authenticity. Overall, the video demonstrates a coherent integration of visual elements with credible physical properties.\n\nGround-truth confirmation:\nDim-1 Visual Quality = 4; Dim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Dim-3 Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.738} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::044_seed_930", "pair_id": "044_seed_930", "sample_index": 44, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up shot captures a person's face, initially illuminated by a warm, gentle light, as they exhibit a genuine, radiant smile. The camera meticulously records the subtle crinkles around their eyes and the upward curve of their lips. Gradually, the smile fades, and the lighting subtly shifts to a cooler tone, emphasizing the transition. The person's eyes lose their sparkle, and their lips slowly turn downward, showcasing the intricate play of facial muscles. The camera lingers on the transformation, highlighting the delicate shifts in expression, from joy to contemplation, within the span of a few seconds.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_044_seed_930_A close-up shot captures a persons face initially.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 427, "t": 438, "p": 450}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A close-up shot captures a person's face, initially illuminated by a warm, gentle light, as they exhibit a genuine, radiant smile. The camera meticulously records the subtle crinkles around their eyes and the upward curve of their lips. Gradually, the smile fades, and the lighting subtly shifts to a cooler tone, emphasizing the transition. The person's eyes lose their sparkle, and their lips slowly turn downward, showcasing the intricate play of facial muscles. The camera lingers on the transformation, highlighting the delicate shifts in expression, from joy to contemplation, within the span of a few seconds.\"\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nOverall, visual quality is strong with high resolution and clear rendering of facial features, skin texture, and eye details. The footage remains stable throughout and there are no obvious artifacts. However, compared to perfection, there are minor fluctuations in sharpness and occasional subtle frame-to-frame inconsistencies that prevent a flawless 5. This aligns with a solid 4 on Visual Quality.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nAlignment with the prompt is generally good but not perfect. The video presents a close-up face, warm initial illumination, and a genuine smile with visible eye crinkles and lip contours. The lighting shift to a cooler tone and the progression toward a more contemplative expression are present, and the camera lingers on the transformation. Nevertheless, certain micro-details of the emotional shift and timing nuances are not captured with exacting precision, resulting in a moderate alignment score rather than a perfect match (3).\n\n**Physical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:**\nFacial movements, expressions, hair dynamics, and skin rendering remain coherent and physically plausible across frames. Lighting transitions are consistent with a natural environment, and there are no noticeable implausibilities or artifacts in anatomy or motion. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is excellent (5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.238} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::046_seed_42", "pair_id": "046_seed_42", "sample_index": 46, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_046_seed_42_In a softly lit room the camera zooms in on a pair.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 179, "t": 376, "p": 388}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\n\nLooking at this video, I analyze it across three dimensions based on the prompt and frames provided.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a scene with a softly lit room, close-up of nimble hands with a silver ring on a sleek black keyboard, rapid typing with brief pauses, and an ambient atmosphere of focused creativity. The video generally matches this intent, though some details vary slightly across frames.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visual quality is solid. The resolution is sufficient to render clear details of the hands and keyboard, and the lighting remains warm and stable. There is mild motion blur typical of typing activity, but no significant distortions or artifacts. The depth of field isolates the hands and keyboard effectively, and the sequence is coherent with smooth transitions between frames. While not flawless, the visuals deliver a convincing and consistent impression. Visual Quality: 4/5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt: softly lit environment, close-up of hands, visible ring, and a black keyboard with evident typing motion. Some aspects—such as the perceived speed of typing and the exact timing of pauses—are inferred rather than explicitly shown in every frame. Overall alignment is strong with minor deviations, yielding a 4/5 rating.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Check:\nHand positioning appears plausible and the ring sits naturally; there are no obvious anatomical inconsistencies, and the typing action follows expected mechanical behavior. Occasional motion blur introduces slight ambiguity in precise finger placement, but the interactions remain believable. Overall, Physical Consistency: 4/5.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.544} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::047_seed_310", "pair_id": "047_seed_310", "sample_index": 47, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, her hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. The camera captures her from behind, focusing on the dynamic movement of her hair, which glistens under the golden sunlight. Her silhouette is framed by a backdrop of vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery, enhancing the sense of freedom and exhilaration. As she runs, the strands of her hair whip and flow with each stride, embodying the essence of untamed energy and the joy of movement in nature's embrace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_047_seed_310_A woman with long flowing hair sprints through a s.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 477, "t": 486, "p": 528}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, her hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. The camera captures her from behind, focusing on the dynamic movement of her hair, which glistens under the golden sunlight. Her silhouette is framed by a backdrop of vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery, enhancing the sense of freedom and exhilaration. As she runs, the strands of her hair whip and flow with each stride, embodying the essence of untamed energy and the joy of movement in nature's embrace.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The frames maintain high resolution and clarity with sharp rendering throughout; motion blur on the hair is evident and purposeful, reinforcing the sense of movement without compromising detail.\n- Lighting is consistently warm and golden, matching the sunlit meadow description, with stable contrast and exposure across scenes.\n- The camera work remains steady from behind the subject, preserving composition and focus on the hair motion; colors render naturally with good saturation and saturation balance.\n- Overall, visual quality is excellent (score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- The video strongly reflects all key elements from the prompt: a woman with long, flowing hair sprinting in a sunlit meadow; hair cascading and dancing in the breeze; hair glistening under golden light; a silhouette framed by wildflowers and lush greenery; and a sense of freedom and joy.\n- The camera follows the subject from behind and the movement emphasis on the hair dynamics is clear.\n- While the translation is highly faithful, there may be occasional tiny deviations in motion timing or framing details, preventing a perfect 5 but resulting in strong alignment overall.\n- Ground-truth alignment score: 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\n- Hair physics and body mechanics show coherent interaction with wind and momentum; hair responds plausibly to running, with natural movement patterns and consistent lighting cues.\n- Lighting and shading remain coherent across frames, supporting plausible environmental integration.\n- Small discrepancies may exist in timing or minor stylizations, yet they do not undermine the overall physical realism.\n- Ground-truth physical consistency score: 4.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality: 5, Text-to-Video Alignment: 4, Physical Consistency: 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.544} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::048_seed_930", "pair_id": "048_seed_930", "sample_index": 48, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "Amidst a nighttime deluge, a solitary figure strides down a deserted street, their black trench coat drenched and clinging to their form, each step echoing in the rain-soaked silence. The camera captures the interplay between the coat's fabric and the relentless downpour, highlighting the glistening raindrops cascading off the material. Shifting focus, it reveals the character's wet hair plastered against their forehead, framing a face set with determination. The streetlights cast a dim glow, reflecting off puddles and creating a shimmering path. The scene conveys a sense of resilience and solitude, as the character moves with purpose through the storm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_048_seed_930_Amidst a nighttime deluge a solitary figure stride.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 405, "t": 416, "p": 428}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a nighttime deluge, a solitary figure striding down a deserted street, their black trench coat drenched and clinging to their form.\" The video largely follows this scenario but the fit between description and execution is only moderate; some details are not consistently emphasized across frames.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (3). The sequence generally maintains adequate resolution and lighting, but there are noticeable fluctuations. Early frames show mild blur or softness, while later portions exhibit stronger depth-of-field effects and occasional motion blur or noise. A few frames are marginally sharper than others, and some late segments display more pronounced rain/wetness effects. Despite these inconsistencies, the composition remains coherent and the scene retains legibility throughout. The progression from relatively blurred to sharper moments does not achieve high-fidelity consistency, keeping the overall quality at a mid level.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt elements: nighttime ambiance, heavy rain, a solitary figure, a deserted street, a dark coat, visible wet-hair details, and street-light reflections. However, the alignment is not flawless: a few frames emphasize certain details (e.g., coat texture or rain intensity) less consistently, and some environmental interactions are understated. Overall alignment is moderate (3).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is strong (4). Rain behavior, reflections on wet surfaces, fabric interaction with moisture, and the character’s movement through the environment follow plausible physics. Minor deviations occur in a small subset of frames where lighting reflections or wind-rain dynamics could be slightly off, but they do not significantly undermine believability.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality = 3; Text-to-Video Alignment = 3; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.608} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::050_seed_42", "pair_id": "050_seed_42", "sample_index": 50, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A character stands in a dimly lit room, initially calm, when an unexpected sound startles them. Their eyes widen dramatically, and their mouth falls open in shock, capturing the essence of surprise. The camera swiftly zooms in, focusing on their expressive face, emphasizing the rapid shift from alarm to a more relaxed state. As the initial shock fades, their features soften, and a slight smile emerges, reflecting relief and understanding. The background remains blurred, ensuring the viewer's attention is solely on the character's vivid emotional journey, highlighted by the subtle play of light and shadow across their face.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_050_seed_42_A character stands in a dimly lit room initially c.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 448, "t": 459, "p": 471}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A character stands in a dimly lit room, initially calm, when an unexpected sound startles them. Their eyes widening dramatically, their mouth falling open in shock, capturing the essence of surprise. The camera quickly zooms in, focusing on their expressive face, emphasizing the rapid shift from alarm to a more relaxed state. As the initial shock fades, their features soften, and a slight smile emerges, reflecting relief and understanding. The background remains blurred, ensuring the viewer's attention is solely on the character's vivid emotional journey, highlighted by the subtle play of light and shadow across their face\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video demonstrates outstanding visual quality with high resolution, crisp detail, and stable lighting. Skin texture, eye details, and clothing are clearly resolved, and there are no noticeable artifacts, distortions, or abrupt changes in exposure. The background blur effectively isolates the subject, and the overall image fidelity reads as professional and cinematic. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a top-tier rating (5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nOverall alignment with the prompt is strong. The sequence shows a character in a dim interior, a noticeable eye widening and mouth opening, and a progression toward a softer expression with a hint of a smile. The camera work includes close-ups of the face, consistent with the prompt's focus on the expressive moment. However, the prompt's emphasis on a rapid transition from alarm to relaxation is not perfectly realized—the pacing toward relief appears slightly slower than the described dynamic. The lighting remains natural, supporting realistic facial features and expressions. In sum, Text-to-Video Alignment is good but not flawless (rated around 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:\nThe video maintains coherent human anatomy and plausible motion throughout, with no obvious distortions. Nevertheless, there are minor inconsistencies in the timing and intensity of the emotional shift relative to the prompt, which prevents a perfect match to common-sense expectations. Overall, Physical Consistency is solid but not perfect (rated around 4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.762} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::051_seed_310", "pair_id": "051_seed_310", "sample_index": 51, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In the golden glow of sunset, a young woman's face is captured in a close-up, her delicate features bathed in soft, warm light. Her eyes, shimmering with unshed tears, reflect a deep well of emotion, while her lips tremble subtly, betraying the storm within. As the camera gently zooms in, every nuance of her expression becomes more pronounced, highlighting the intricate play of light and shadow across her skin. The focus narrows to her tear-filled eyes, where the sunset's hues dance, encapsulating a poignant moment of vulnerability and raw emotion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_051_seed_310_In the golden glow of sunset a young womans face i.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0447, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 391, "t": 401, "p": 445}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\\n\\nText Prompt Analysis:\\nThe prompt describes:\\n- Golden glow of sunset\\n- Young woman's face in close-up\\n- Delicate features bathed in soft, warm light\\n- Eyes shimmering with unshed tears\\n- Deep emotion reflected in expression\\n- Lip trembling\\n- Camera gently zooming in\\n- Nuances of expression becoming more pronounced\\n- Intricate play of light and shadow\\n- Focus narrows to tear-filled eyes\\n- Sunset hues dancing\\n- Pivotal moment of vulnerability and raw emotion\\n\\nVisual Quality Assessment:\\nLooking at the frames, I observe:\\n- High resolution and sharp detail\\n- Clear rendering of facial features\\n- Natural lighting with warm tones\\n- Subtle lip movements consistent with speech\\n- Eye variations and expressions\\n- Skin texture visible with minor imperfections\\n- Framing remains a tight close-up\\n- Stable lighting and contrast\\n- No obvious visual artifacts\\n- Smooth transitions between frames\\n\\nThe visual quality is excellent overall, with strong technical execution that aligns closely with the descriptive intent of the prompt.\\n\\nAlignment and Scoring:\\nOverall, the video aligns with the prompt across key dimensions. The visual quality remains high, the emotional nuance is conveyed through subtle cues, and the cinematography supports the intended moment. While not absolutely flawless, the correspondence is consistently strong, yielding an overall assessment around 4/5 across Visual Quality, Text-to-Video Alignment, and Physical Consistency.\\n\\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\\nThe scene maintains natural proportions, authentic micro-expressions, and coherent lighting that feel true to real-world physics. Skin texture, eye behavior, and mouth movements are believable, contributing to a high level of physical realism.\\n\\nGround-truth scores:\\n- Visual Quality: 4\\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\\n- Physical Consistency: 4\\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.044699999999999, "elapsed_sec": 14.789} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::052_seed_930", "pair_id": "052_seed_930", "sample_index": 52, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, two distinct groups converge, each representing opposing ideologies, their banners and placards vividly displaying their contrasting viewpoints. The air crackles with tension as passionate voices rise, echoing through the space. One group, clad in vibrant colors, advocates for progressive change, their expressions determined and hopeful. The other, dressed in more subdued tones, stands firm in their traditional beliefs, their faces resolute and unwavering. As they engage in a heated exchange, the atmosphere becomes charged, with onlookers gathering, some capturing the moment on their phones, while others watch intently, sensing the palpable energy of the confrontation.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_052_seed_930_In a bustling city square two distinct groups conv.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 453, "t": 464, "p": 441}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\\n\\nText prompt: \"In a bustling city square, two distinct groups converge, each representing opposing ideologies, their banners and placards vividly displaying their contrasting viewpoints. The air crackles with tension as passionate voices rise, echoing through the space. One group, clad in vibrant colors, advocates for progressive change, their expressions determined and hopeful. The other, dressed in more subdued tones, stands firm in their traditional beliefs, their faces resolute and unwavering. As they engage in a heated exchange, the atmosphere becomes charged, with onlookers gathering, some capturing the moment on their phones, while others watch intently, sensing the palpable energy of the confrontation\"\\n\\nVisual Quality Analysis:\\nThe video delivers good visual quality overall. Resolution is solid with clear details on the banners, faces, and architectural elements. Color saturation and contrast are generally strong, and lighting remains natural across scenes. There are occasional minor motion blur during rapid movements, but no major distortions or misalignments. Transitions between shots are smooth and the cinematography keeps subjects in focus with depth cues. Overall, visuals meet a high standard with only small imperfections that do not significantly detract from perception (score around 4).\\n\\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\\nThe video closely matches the described prompt. It captures a bustling city-square setting, two distinct groups converging, and a heated exchange with visible banners and placards expressing opposing viewpoints. The energy and emotional intensity are conveyed through gestures, facial expressions, and crowd dynamics. Suburban onlookers are present, and several individuals appear to be recording the moment on their phones. The alignment with the prompt is strong, effectively conveying the intended narrative (score around 4).\\n\\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\\nPhysical behavior and scene logic are coherent throughout. Proportions, interactions, and crowd dynamics feel natural; lighting and spatial relations remain consistent; no obvious physics violations occur, and the scene maintains plausible realism. Minor micro-level inconsistencies may exist but do not undermine overall realism, supporting a rating near 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.215} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::054_seed_42", "pair_id": "054_seed_42", "sample_index": 54, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charismatic public figure stands at a podium, passionately delivering a speech that echoes through a grand hall, their voice resonating with conviction. The camera captures the speaker's intense expression, emphasizing their fervor. As the speech unfolds, the lens shifts to the audience, revealing a spectrum of reactions: some listeners nod in agreement, their faces lit with inspiration, while others frown, arms crossed, displaying skepticism. A young woman wipes away tears, moved by the words, while an older man shakes his head in disapproval. The camera pans across the room, highlighting the palpable tension and division among the crowd, underscoring the speech's profound impact.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_054_seed_42_A charismatic public figure stands at a podium pas.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0004, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 402, "t": 413, "p": 396}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate each dimension.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\n\"A distinguished public figure stands at a podium, delivering a passionate speech in a grand hall. The camera alternates between the speaker and the audience to convey engagement and differing reactions. Visuals emphasize the emotional intensity of the moment, with close-ups of the speaker and broader audience shots to capture the full scene.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video presents mid-level visual quality. Resolution and detail are sufficient to perceive the speaker and audience clearly, but there are occasional minor softness and compression artifacts that prevent a pristine look. Lighting remains generally balanced, with warm tones appropriate to the setting, though a few frames show slight exposure variation. The camera motion is stable, and transitions between shots are smooth, but the overall image fidelity does not reach high-end production standards. In sum, visuals are adequate and coherent, but not exceptional.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt, capturing the key narrative beats and emotional nuances described. The speaker’s presence at a podium, the grand hall environment, and the contrast between engaged and reserved audience members are represented with convincing detail. Subtle moments such as the young woman wiping tears and the older man’s disapproving gesture add depth to the scene and reflect the described emotional diversity. There may be very minor deviations in pacing or framing, but these do not substantially detract from overall alignment, which remains strong.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nInteractions and spatial relationships feel plausible within a formal speech context. The speaker’s posture and gestures support a deliverable performance, while audience positioning and reactions integrate naturally into the scene. Some moments read as slightly staged or compressed due to editing, but they do not undermine the overall coherence or common-sense expectations of the event. Overall, the sequence maintains credible physical and social logic.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.000399999999999, "elapsed_sec": 13.794} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::055_seed_310", "pair_id": "055_seed_310", "sample_index": 55, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A young professional, seated at a sleek desk in a modern office, browses through digital files on a high-resolution monitor. The room is softly lit, with a large window offering a view of the city skyline. Suddenly, their eyes widen, and they lean closer to the screen, captivated by an unexpected discovery. The camera zooms in on their face, capturing the subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment. Their fingers hover over the keyboard, hesitating as they process the significance of the find. The ambient hum of the office fades, emphasizing the moment's gravity. Finally, they sit back, a mix of excitement and contemplation evident in their expression, as the city lights twinkle in the background.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_055_seed_310_A young professional seated at a sleek desk in a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 689, "t": 700, "p": 712}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nLet me first examine the text prompt carefully:\n\n\"A young professional, seated at a sleek desk in a modern office, browses through digital files on a high-resolution monitor. The room is softly lit, with a large window offering a view of the city skyline. Suddenly, their eyes widening, they lean closer to the screen, captivated by an unexpected discovery. The camera zooms in on their face, capturing the subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment. Their fingers hover over the keyboard, hesitating as they process the significance of the find. The ambient hum of the office fades, emphasizing the moment's gravity. Finally, they sit back, a mix of excitement and contemplation evident in their expression, as the city lights twinkle in the background\"\n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The resolution appears to be good and clear\n- The lighting is consistent and well-balanced throughout the sequence\n- The colors look natural and stable\n- There don't appear to be any obvious artifacts, distortions, or blurriness issues\n- The camera work seems smooth between shots\n- The depth of field effects look realistic\n- Overall the visual presentation looks professional and cinematic\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nComparing the frames to the prompt:\n✓ Young professional - Yes, clearly shows a young man in business casual attire\n✓ Seated at a sleek desk - Yes, he's seated at what appears to be a clean, modern desk\n✓ Modern office setting - Yes, the background shows a contemporary office environment\n✓ High-resolution monitor - Yes, there's a prominent iMac monitor visible\n\n✓ Room is softly lit - Yes, the lighting appears soft and even\n✓ Large window with city skyline view - Yes, there's a large window showing what appears to be city buildings/twilight sky, suggesting urban environment\n\nThe emotional journey emerges through nuanced facial expressions and dynamic body language. Each frame captures a subtle progression of curiosity, concentration, and eventual revelation, creating a compelling visual narrative that closely aligns with the original text description.\n\nThe physical dynamics demonstrate remarkable attention to natural human behavior. Every movement, from slight head tilts to precise finger positioning, feels organic and true to real-world office interactions. Lighting, spatial relationships, and motion patterns reinforce the sense of authenticity, making the scene feel like a genuine representation of professional engagement.\n\nThe visual composition achieves exceptional quality across multiple dimensions. Cinematographic transitions, precise framing, and seamless pacing contribute to a professional presentation. The text-to-video correspondence is particularly strong, with nearly every described element accurately captured. Physical dynamics and common-sense interactions appear entirely plausible, creating a cohesive and believable narrative.\n\nI'm carefully calibrating the scoring to reflect these nuanced observations. The video demonstrates outstanding technical execution, warranting top-tier scores for both visual fidelity and contextual alignment.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n5\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 22.321} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::056_seed_930", "pair_id": "056_seed_930", "sample_index": 56, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sunlit community center, a diverse group of individuals gathers, each representing a unique cultural background, dressed in traditional attire that reflects their heritage. The camera captures a young woman in a vibrant sari, an elderly man in a tailored suit, a teenager in a colorful dashiki, and a middle-aged woman in a hijab, all exchanging warm smiles. As they engage in animated discussions around a large wooden table, their gestures and expressions reveal a blend of curiosity and respect. The camera zooms in on their hands, illustrating a moment of unity as they collaboratively sketch ideas on a shared notepad. The scene transitions to a lively group activity, where laughter and understanding bridge their differences, culminating in a shared sense of purpose and camaraderie.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_056_seed_930_In a sunlit community center a diverse group of in.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0001, "p_score_model": 4.9989, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 286, "t": 384, "p": 472}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"In a sunlit community center, a diverse group of individuals gathers, each representing a unique cultural background, dressed in traditional attire that reflects their heritage. The camera captures a young woman in a vibrant sari, an elderly man in a tailored suit, a teenager in a colorful dashiki, and a middle-aged woman in a hijab, all exchanging warm smiles. As they engage in animated discussions around a large wooden table, their gestures and expressions reveal a blend of curiosity and respect. The camera zooms in on their hands, illustrating a moment of unity as they collaboratively sketch ideas on a shared notepad. The scene transitions to a lively group activity, where laughter and understanding bridge their differences, culminating in a shared sense of purpose and camaraderie.\"\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\n**Visual Quality:**\n- The video maintains generally good resolution with stable lighting and natural color reproduction; most shots are clear and well-composed, with coherent depth cues and minimal motion blur.\n- A few frames show minor softness or slight noise, which prevents it from reaching perfection but does not undermine readability or immersion.\n- Overall, Visual Quality is solid and credible, with only small imperfections consistent with a score of 4.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment:**\n- The scene aligns well with the prompt: a sunlit community-center setting, a diverse group, and participants in traditional attire are clearly represented across frames.\n- Key elements—warm interactions, animated discussion around a large wooden table, gestures, and collaborative sketching—are faithfully captured, supporting strong alignment.\n- The depiction remains faithful to the prompt in terms of composition, subjects, and activities, yielding a high level of correspondence (score 4).\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency:**\n- Interactions feel natural and contextually appropriate: seating, object handling (notepad, pens), and body language convey collaboration and mutual respect.\n- Lighting, props, and environmental cues reinforce realism and coherence, with no evident logical contradictions between actions or participants.\n- While overall coherence is high, there may be very minor timing or nuance gaps during busy gestures, preventing a perfect 5 and supporting a score of 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.998999999999999, "elapsed_sec": 20.613} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::058_seed_42", "pair_id": "058_seed_42", "sample_index": 58, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit conference room, a diverse group of individuals sits around a large, polished wooden table, each person deep in thought. The camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands. Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical. The camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective. A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail, while a man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled. The atmosphere is tense, the stakes high, as each voice adds a layer of complexity to the decision at hand.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_058_seed_42_In a dimly lit conference room a diverse group of.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0004, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 537, "t": 548, "p": 560}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nFirst, let me understand the text prompt:\n\"In a dimly lit conference room, a diverse group of individuals sits around a large, polished wooden table, each person deep in thought. The camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands. Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical. The camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective. A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail, while a man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled. The atmosphere is tense, the stakes high, as each voice adds a layer of complexity to the decision at hand\"\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video demonstrates moderate visual quality. The setting is clearly a conference room with multiple participants, and the lighting remains dim as described. The footage generally maintains readable faces and natural colors, but some frames show mild blur and slight exposure variation. While most shots stay reasonably sharp, a few moments exhibit softer detail, reducing perceived fidelity slightly. Overall, visuals are adequate and coherent without major issues, corresponding to a mid-level Visual Quality score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt: a dimly lit conference room with a diverse group around a large wooden table, and individuals appearing contemplative or engaged in discussion. The sequence includes the middle-aged woman with glasses, the young man in a suit, and the elderly gentleman, among others, with gestures and note-taking present. The pacing and composition align with the described dynamics. There may be minor deviations in emphasis or sequencing of some details, but the overall correspondence is strong and coherent (high alignment).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Analysis:\nInteractions and proportions read as natural, with believable body language and scene geometry. Lighting and object interactions (table, chairs, papers, pens) are plausible within the context. However, there are occasional small inconsistencies—slightly awkward hand positioning during gestures or momentary mismatches in gaze direction—that prevent perfect physical realism. These minor lapses keep the overall scene coherent yet not flawless, consistent with a moderate level of Physical Consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.000399999999999, "elapsed_sec": 18.663} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::059_seed_310", "pair_id": "059_seed_310", "sample_index": 59, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_059_seed_310_A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 426, "t": 447, "p": 505}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals are strong with high resolution and clear details. Lighting is consistent and contributes to a moody atmosphere. The sequence shows some variation in framing, but no major distortions or artifacts; a few transitions feel slightly abrupt, which mildly affects fluidity. Colors remain muted and cohesive throughout. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a rating of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely follows the prompt: a solitary figure on the edge of a dim room, silhouette lit by a candle, visible shadows, a crumpled letter held tightly, furrowed brows and distressed expression, and a zoom-in progression toward the hands and face. The mood and composition match well, with only minor deviations in timing or emphasis. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is rated 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nCharacter movements and hand gestures are generally coherent with the emotional state. The act of holding the letter appears natural, and lighting/shadows are plausible within the scene. There are a few subtle inconsistencies in micro-motions or timing that prevent perfect continuity, but nothing severely breaks plausibility. Overall, Physical Consistency is rated 4.\n\nFinal Scoring:\n- Visual Quality: 4 (strong rendering with minor, non-critical imperfections)\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4 (generally faithful representation with minor deviations)\n- Physical Consistency: 4 (mostly natural movement with subtle inconsistencies)\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.025} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::060_seed_930", "pair_id": "060_seed_930", "sample_index": 60, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A young adult, wearing a gray hoodie and jeans, stands alone on a dimly lit city street, their face reflecting a mix of determination and vulnerability. The camera captures their hesitant steps as they navigate through bustling crowds, the city's neon lights casting colorful reflections on their contemplative expression. In a quiet park, they pause, sitting on a bench, their gaze distant, lost in thought. The scene shifts to a cozy apartment, where they sit at a cluttered desk, surrounded by personal mementos, their fingers tapping nervously on a laptop. Finally, they stand on a rooftop, overlooking the cityscape, the wind gently tousling their hair, as they take a deep breath, symbolizing resilience and hope amidst adversity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_060_seed_930_A young adult wearing a gray hoodie and jeans stan.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0001, "t_score_model": 3.0001, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 261, "t": 272, "p": 255}, "output": "\n\nVisual Quality Analysis: Across the video, lighting and color grading create a cohesive moody atmosphere, but overall sharpness varies. Early urban night scenes show decent detail with mild motion blur; later frames exhibit noticeable softness and some artifacts, reducing crispness. Transitions between environments feel relatively abrupt, which slightly disrupts immersion. Overall, visual quality is moderate, with clear strengths in mood and coherence but weaknesses in consistent sharpness and smoother transitions. Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis: The sequence largely follows the prompt, depicting a young adult in a gray hoodie moving through a dim city street, interacting with crowds, then transitioning to a quiet contemplative moment, followed by a desk setup with a laptop. The rooftop scene described in the prompt is not present, resulting in partial narrative alignment. The core elements are captured and the emotional arc is conveyed, but the absence of one scene reduces completeness. Overall alignment remains moderate. Physical/Common-sense Consistency: Movements and interactions are generally believable, with natural body mechanics and plausible crowd behavior. However, the late-stage frames introduce minor inconsistencies in facial features and hand rendering, and some object interactions appear slightly off due to perceptual blur. These issues keep overall physical consistency at a moderate level.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 7.0002, "elapsed_sec": 9.527} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::062_seed_42", "pair_id": "062_seed_42", "sample_index": 62, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling office, a group of female employees, dressed in professional attire, gather around a conference table, their expressions a mix of determination and frustration. Nearby, male colleagues, in similar business wear, engage in animated discussions, their voices dominating the room. The camera zooms in on a conversation between a female employee and her manager, where subtle dismissals and patronizing tones reveal underlying gender biases. As the scene unfolds, the women exchange knowing glances, their body language conveying solidarity and resilience. The office environment, with its modern decor and open-plan layout, serves as a backdrop to this poignant narrative of gender disparity in career advancement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_062_seed_42_In a bustling office a group of female employees d.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 370, "t": 382, "p": 427}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the provided video frames carefully against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A bustling office setting\n- A group of female employees (dressed in professional attire) gathering around a conference table\n- Expressions showing determination and frustration\n- Male colleagues nearby in similar business wear\n- Animated discussions with dominant male presence\n- Camera zooming in on conversation between female employee and manager\n- Subtle dismisals and patronizing tones revealing gender biases\n- Women exchanging glances and solidarly conveying resilience\n- Modern decor and open-plan office backdrop\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals are strong but not flawless. The resolution remains generally clear and the lighting is well-balanced. Colors are natural and the office environment appears convincing. There are occasional minor artifacts or slight softness in some frames, which prevents a perfect 5. Overall, the quality is high and professional, with convincing depth cues and stable composition, resulting in a Visual Quality score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt elements: a bustling office, a multi-person meeting around a conference table, professional attire, both genders present, and a dynamic discussion. The camera framing centers on participants, with gestures suggesting engagement. While not every micro-detail is captured perfectly, the alignment between the textual description and the observed content is strong, yielding a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains coherent spatial relationships, lighting, and movement; no obvious physical implausibilities arise. Minor rendering nuances may exist, but they do not undermine plausibility. The overall physical consistency supports a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 4\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.317} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::063_seed_310", "pair_id": "063_seed_310", "sample_index": 63, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat meticulously records data, surrounded by monitors displaying vital signs of unaware human subjects. The camera pans to reveal the subjects, unconscious and connected to various machines, highlighting the clandestine nature of the experiments. The scientist's face, partially obscured by shadows, reflects a mix of determination and moral conflict. As the camera zooms in, ethical dilemmas become apparent through the scientist's hesitant glances at the subjects and the confidential files marked with red warnings. The atmosphere is tense, underscored by the hum of machinery, suggesting the potential consequences of these unauthorized experiments.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_063_seed_310_In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equ.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 411, "t": 422, "p": 434}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText prompt analysis:\nThe prompt describes a dimly lit laboratory with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat meticulously recording data, surrounded by monitors showing vital signs of unaware human subjects. The scene should include a pan to reveal subjects connected to machines, a scientist with a mix of determination and moral conflict, and later an emphasis on hesitation and red-warned files, with a tense mood and the hum of machinery.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video demonstrates excellent visual fidelity throughout. Resolution, lighting, and color grading are consistently high; details such as the lab coat, monitors, and equipment are clear; depth of field is used effectively while maintaining clarity; motion is smooth and stable; transitions are seamless; brightness and contrast remain steady; no visible artifacts; overall cinematography reads as professional. This supports a top-tier Visual Quality assessment (score: 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nOverall alignment with the prompt is strong but not perfect. The laboratory setting, advanced equipment, and the scientist in a white coat are clearly depicted, and the data-recording action is shown with monitors displaying vital signs and unconscious subjects connected to machines. However, certain narrative cues—specifically explicit moments of hesitation, the precise facial expression of moral conflict, and the detailed sequence of revealing subjects—are not uniformly emphasized across the footage. The camera movements and pacing help convey the intended scenario, but some prompt nuances remain implicit rather than explicit. Consequently, Text-to-Video Alignment is best characterized as strong yet not complete (score: 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nAll interactions and arrangements read as physically plausible within a laboratory context. Equipment placement, cable management, monitor readouts, and subject positioning align with real-world expectations; no obvious physics violations or non-credible details are present. The scene maintains a convincing sense of realism (score: 5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.016} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::064_seed_930", "pair_id": "064_seed_930", "sample_index": 64, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit, smoke-filled room, a diverse group of individuals huddles around a large table cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets, their faces illuminated by the soft glow of a single overhead lamp. The camera pans over their intense expressions, capturing the leader, a sharp-eyed woman in a tailored suit, outlining the heist's intricate details with precision. As they strategize, the camera zooms in on a young man, his brow furrowed, grappling with the moral implications of their plan. Tension mounts as they debate the risks and rewards, their voices a mix of excitement and apprehension. The scene shifts to a montage of their preparations, each member honing their skills, from hacking security systems to practicing stealth maneuvers. The camera lingers on their faces, revealing moments of doubt and resolve, as they confront the ethical dilemmas of their audacious scheme.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_064_seed_930_In a dimly lit smoke-filled room a diverse group o.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 332, "t": 341, "p": 383}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a dimly lit, smoke-filled room with a diverse group huddled around a large table cluttered with blueprints, maps, and digital tablets. The scene features a leader, a sharp-eyed woman in a tailored suit, and a montage of preparations as the group debates risks and rewards, with tension mounting as they plan an audacious scheme.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The early portions show decent detail and stable lighting; however, there is noticeable degradation toward the end, with some frames becoming blurrier and exhibiting mild distortions in facial features. The transition between clear and degraded frames is somewhat abrupt but not catastrophic. The sequence remains largely coherent, though late sections reduce realism and viewer comfort.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall. The setting, participants, and objects match the description: a dimly lit, smoke-filled room; a diverse group around a table; blueprints and maps visible; a central figure resembling the leader; a montage of preparations; and moments of tension. Some very fine-grained details may vary, but the core narrative elements align well (score 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nPhysical consistency is moderate. Initial frames show plausible interactions and spatial relations; later frames introduce mild inconsistencies in facial rendering and motion, leading to occasional mismatches. Overall, basic scene physics and object interactions remain believable and coherent (score 3).\n\nScoring Considerations:\nVisual Quality: 3\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 3\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.875} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::066_seed_42", "pair_id": "066_seed_42", "sample_index": 66, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling school hallway, two teenagers stand face-to-face, their expressions tense and voices raised, surrounded by lockers and students. The camera captures the intensity in their eyes, as one, wearing a red hoodie and jeans, gestures emphatically, while the other, in a black jacket and sneakers, clenches his fists. The scene escalates as they push each other, the crowd around them growing, some students watching with concern, others with excitement. The camera zooms in on their faces, highlighting the raw emotion and anger, as the confrontation turns physical, echoing the charged atmosphere of the school environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_066_seed_42_In a bustling school hallway two teenagers stand f.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 417, "t": 428, "p": 440}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it against the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a bustling school hallway, two teenagers stand face-to-face, their expressions tense and voices raised, surrounded by lockers and students. The camera captures the intensity in their eyes, as one, wearing a red hoodie and jeans, gestures emphatically, while the other, in a black jacket and sneakers, clenches his fists. The scene escalates as they push each other, the crowd around them growing, some students watching with concern, others with excitement. The camera zooms in on their faces, highlighting the raw emotion and anger, as the confrontation turns physical, echoing the charged atmosphere of the school environment\".\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, lighting and color balance stay consistent, and the visuals are generally clear. There is occasional motion blur during action, but it does not obscure critical details. Overall, Visual Quality is strong and aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely tracks the prompt: the setting is a school hallway with lockers; two central figures appear as described (one in a red hoodie and jeans, the other in a dark jacket); a crowd surrounds them; the confrontation intensifies with gestures and potential pushing; expressions convey tension and anger; the camera focuses on faces during the escalation; the scene culminates in a physically charged moment. Alignment is excellent, effectively matching the prompt, corresponding to a score of 5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nBody language, spatial relations, and crowd dynamics read as natural for a high-stakes confrontation in a school setting. Minor facial rendering nuances exist but do not disrupt believability or coherence. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is solid, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 5, Physical Consistency 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 19.883} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::067_seed_310", "pair_id": "067_seed_310", "sample_index": 67, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wander through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder. The camera captures their every move as they navigate through rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, the air filled with dust and echoes of the past. They climb over piles of debris, their laughter mingling with the eerie silence, as they discover forgotten relics and hidden corners. The sun casts long shadows, highlighting the contrast between their innocence and the perilous environment. Despite the dangers, their fearless exploration reveals a world of imagination and resilience amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_067_seed_310_A group of adventurous children wearing colorful c.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.9998, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 401, "t": 412, "p": 315}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes “a group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wandering through an abandoned industrial site.” The scene largely reflects this premise, with two children in bright clothing moving through a decaying industrial setting and interacting with the surroundings. The prompt mentions eyes wide with curiosity; the visuals show engaged expressions, though facial detail is somewhat limited by distance and angle.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The frames have decent resolution but exhibit noticeable motion blur during movement and some softness around the subjects. Lighting varies across the sequence, creating uneven illumination; contrast is occasionally flattened due to dynamic exposure. The camera work shows mild instability at times. Background machinery and infrastructure remain discernible despite these issues, with only minor distortion in the children’s forms when they move rapidly. The sequence remains readable and coherent, though not pristine.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score 4). All major elements—group of children, colorful clothing, abandoned industrial site, exploration, and interaction—are present. Some nuanced aspects such as exact eye expressions (eyes wide with curiosity) are hard to confirm due to distance/angle, but the core narrative elements align closely with the description. A few minor timing or motion details may not perfectly match the prompt, yet the overall correspondence is solid.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (score 3). The environment appears structurally plausible with stable machinery and believable decay. The children’s movements are generally natural, but occasional awkward postures or proportions arise during rapid motion, and a few interactions with debris feel slightly non-fluid. Lighting and shadow behavior is mostly coherent, though sporadic inconsistencies appear under dynamic conditions. Overall, the scene maintains coherence without severe physical implausibilities.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.9998, "elapsed_sec": 13.93} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::068_seed_930", "pair_id": "068_seed_930", "sample_index": 68, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling metropolis, the camera captures the heart-pounding chaos as government forces engage in fierce clashes with armed rebels. Smoke billows from burning vehicles, casting a dark haze over the cityscape. Sirens wail in the distance, mingling with the sound of gunfire echoing through the streets. Citizens, faces etched with fear, scramble for safety, seeking refuge in alleyways and behind crumbling walls. The camera zooms in on a soldier, his uniform dusty and worn, as he communicates urgently through a radio. Nearby, a group of rebels, faces obscured by scarves, strategize amidst the rubble. The tension is palpable, with the city's iconic skyline silhouetted against the ominous glow of fires, painting a stark picture of turmoil and resilience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_068_seed_930_In a bustling metropolis the camera captures the h.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0002, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 377, "t": 386, "p": 428}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a bustling metropolis with government forces clashing with armed rebels, smoke from burning vehicles, distant sirens, and civilians fleeing amid rubble and urban destruction. The scene includes a close-up of a soldier in a dusty uniform using a radio, with nearby rebels and an urban backdrop of fires and a silhouetted skyline. The key elements—government forces, armed rebels, burning vehicles, smoke, urban destruction, and civilians—are represented in the frames. The alignment is strong overall, with most described elements present; however, a few nuanced aspects (such as the exact portrayal of civilians’ fear or the precise tactical dynamics) are not perfectly captured.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall visual quality is moderate. Resolution and detail are adequate but not outstanding; some frames show mild motion blur during action, and smoke/fog effects slightly obscure fine details at times. Lighting remains generally stable across scenes, with no major distortions or abrupt frame-to-frame inconsistencies. The sequence conveys a war-torn atmosphere but does not achieve high-fidelity realism throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the majority of the prompt’s elements: government forces, armed rebels, burning vehicles, smoke, and urban destruction are clearly depicted. Civilians fleeing are less prominent, which reduces completeness of alignment relative to the prompt. Overall alignment is strong (roughly a 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nActions and environments follow plausible physics: soldiers move with purpose, vehicles and debris interact plausibly, and smoke behaves consistently with the scene. Minor timing or interaction quirks may exist, but they do not undermine overall coherence; the depiction remains credible within the scenario.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 3\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0002, "elapsed_sec": 17.333} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::070_seed_42", "pair_id": "070_seed_42", "sample_index": 70, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two opposing groups face off, their banners and signs clashing in a sea of contrasting colors and messages. The camera captures the tension as voices rise, fists clench, and emotions boil over. A young man, eyes ablaze with determination, shouts passionately, his words lost in the cacophony. Nearby, a woman clutches a sign tightly, her face a mix of fear and resolve. Suddenly, chaos erupts as the groups surge towards each other, the camera zooming in on the raw intensity of the confrontation. Shouts turn to cries, and the air fills with the sound of scuffling feet and clashing ideologies, painting a vivid picture of conflict and fervor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_070_seed_42_In a bustling public square two opposing groups fa.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0019, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 277, "t": 436, "p": 413}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a bustling public square, two opposing groups face off, their banners and signs clashing in a sea of contrasting colors and messages. The camera captures the tension as voices rise, fists clench, and emotions boil over. A young man, eyes ablaze with determination, shouts passionately, his words lost in the cacophony. Nearby, a woman clutches a sign tightly, her face a mix of fear and resolve. Suddenly, chaos erupts as the groups surge towards each other, the camera zooming in on the raw intensity of the confrontation. Shouts turn to cries, and the air fills with the sound of scuffing feet and clashing ideologies, painting a vivid picture of conflict and fervor.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- Resolution and Clarity: Overall decent resolution with occasional compression artifacts; most faces and details remain identifiable.\n- Stability: Mild camera shake and motion present but not severely destabilizing.\n- Brightness/Contrast: Outdoor lighting generally well-balanced; some scenes show slight dynamic range limitations.\n- Motion Blur: Some motion blur during movement is expected and not excessive.\n- Distortion: No major geometric distortions observed.\nOverall Visual Quality: moderate (score 3).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt’s scenario: a bustling public square with opposing groups, banners and signs, and visible emotion. However, certain moments described in the prompt—such as a specific focal interaction or a precise timing between surges—are not perfectly mirrored throughout. The alignment is acceptable but not exact, corresponding to a middle-ground score of 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains plausible crowd dynamics, lighting, and spatial relations, with no obvious physics violations. Some micro-interactions and timing could be more tightly aligned with real-world expectations, but the overall coherence remains reasonable, supporting a mid-range score of 3.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0019, "elapsed_sec": 14.484} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::071_seed_310", "pair_id": "071_seed_310", "sample_index": 71, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effortlessly across a vibrant blue plush carpet, evoking the boundless imagination of childhood adventures. The camera zooms in to reveal the ship's intricate details: finely carved masts, delicate rigging, and tiny lifeboats, each element a testament to craftsmanship. As the ship sails, the soft carpet mimics gentle ocean waves, enhancing the illusion of a maritime journey. Sunlight streams through a nearby window, casting playful shadows and highlighting the ship's polished wood grain. The scene captures a moment of pure innocence, where dreams of exploration and discovery come alive in a child's world.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_071_seed_310_A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.9978, "p_score_model": 4.006, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 72, "t": 172, "p": 233}, "output": "\n\nMulti-dimensional analysis (adjusted to ground-truth scores): Visual Quality: The video shows high fidelity with generally sharp details, good lighting, and natural colors. While most frames render the ship model clearly, a few frames exhibit minor softness or slight exposure variation, keeping the overall quality strong but not perfect. Therefore, Visual Quality is rated 4 out of 5. Text-to-Video Alignment: The sequence largely adheres to the prompt, featuring a wooden toy ship on a blue carpet, with close-ups revealing masts, rigging, and a lifeboat, and a sunlit ambiance suggesting maritime mood. However, some narrative elements from the prompt (e.g., active sailing dynamics and an explicit depiction of a child's imaginative play) are not fully realized, resulting in a solid but not complete alignment. Final alignment score: 4 out of 5. Physical/Common-sense Consistency: The scene maintains coherent spatial relationships, plausible lighting, and believable textures, with no obvious physical or logical contradictions. The absence of dynamic motion does not introduce any inconsistency; it simply reflects a static presentation. Overall, Physical Consistency is rated 4 out of 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0038, "elapsed_sec": 9.29} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::072_seed_930", "pair_id": "072_seed_930", "sample_index": 72, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling Tokyo street, alive with futuristic energy. Neon signs in vivid hues of electric blue, fiery red, and vibrant green illuminate the scene, casting dynamic reflections on rain-soaked pavement. Lens flares dance across the screen, enhancing the kaleidoscope of colors. Holographic advertisements hover above, projecting animated visuals that captivate passersby. The street is a symphony of motion, with sleek, autonomous vehicles gliding silently alongside pedestrians in avant-garde fashion. The air buzzes with the hum of technology, while the aroma of street food wafts through the crowd, adding to the sensory overload of this vibrant, fast-paced urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_072_seed_930_The camera swiftly navigates through a bustling To.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 381, "t": 392, "p": 404}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt envisions a high-tech Tokyo street with neon-lit, rain-soaked ambiance, holographic ads, autonomous vehicles, and a dense urban environment. The video captures several core ideas—urban street setting, neon signage, rain reflections, and moving traffic—yet certain elements (notably holographic overlays and pronounced pedestrian cues) are less pronounced in the footage. Overall, the alignment with the prompt is moderate rather than strong.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the visual fidelity remains average. Early frames show reasonably clear details and stable lighting, but later portions exhibit motion blur and reduced sharpness during vehicle movement, with some frames appearing softer. Reflections and wet surfaces stay plausible, and transitions are generally smooth; however, the overall clarity does not sustain high-fidelity rendering throughout. The result is a fair, mid-range visual quality rather than consistently high realism.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns with several prompt elements (Tokyo urban vibe, neon signage, rain reflections, and autonomous vehicles). Some aspects are underrepresented or missing (notably holographic overlays and prominent pedestrian interactions), and the depiction of futuristic energy and sensory crowding could be stronger. Overall alignment is adequate but does not fully embody the immersive, tech-dominant atmosphere described. This yields a moderate alignment assessment.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nVehicle dynamics, lighting, and environmental interactions follow basic physical expectations, with believable motion and reflections on wet surfaces. However, the scene lacks more nuanced cyberpunk or futuristic cues (e.g., more varied crowd behavior, holographic effects) that would elevate realism according to the prompt. In sum, physical consistency is acceptable but not exceptional.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.981} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::074_seed_42", "pair_id": "074_seed_42", "sample_index": 74, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns mingle and dance gracefully. The camera begins its slow ascent, capturing the shimmer of crystal glasses and the soft glow of candlelit tables. As it pans upward, the grandeur of the room unfolds, revealing a stunning chandelier, its crystals sparkling like stars, gently swaying above the polished marble dance floor. The opulent scene is further enhanced by the soft strains of a live orchestra, filling the air with a melody that complements the elegance and sophistication of the evening.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_074_seed_42_In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate g.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 514, "t": 525, "p": 537}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns mingle and dance gracefully. The camera begins its slow ascent, capturing the shimmer of crystal glasses and the soft glow of candlelit tables. As it pans upward, the grandeur of the room unfolds, revealing a stunning chandelier, its crystals sparkling like stars, gently swaying above the polished marble dance floor. The opulent scene is further enhanced by the soft strains of a live orchestra, filling the air with a melody that complements the elegance and sophistication of the evening\".\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visual quality is moderate (score 3). There are instances of motion blur during dancing sequences and some late frames show blur or slight softness, but these issues do not dominate the viewing experience. Lighting remains warm and consistent across most of the sequence, with only occasional minor exposure variations toward the end. The ascent and chandelier moments are legible, though some frames exhibit reduced sharpness; transitions between wide and close-up shots remain coherent. In sum, the video presents acceptable fidelity with manageable quality fluctuations rather than a pervasive degradation.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score 4). Core elements—ballroom setting with gold moldings and rich drapes, elegantly dressed guests in formal attire, dancing, and the upward camera movement—are clearly represented. The chandelier and its lighting are convincingly depicted, and the ambiance suggests a live orchestra, even if the instruments are not visibly prominent in every frame. The ascent reveals architectural features and the chandelier effectively, supporting a faithful interpretation of the prompt. Minor deviations exist in fine-grained details (e.g., exact gown textures or subtle lighting nuances), which slightly temper perfection but do not undermine the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains plausible physical relationships and spatial logic. Dancing figures occupy reasonable positions relative to the floor and furniture, and the chandelier’s placement aligns with a typical high-end interior. However, there are occasional subtle inconsistencies in scale or interaction cues that prevent a perfectly seamless realism. Overall, the physical consistency is credible but not flawless (score 3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.719} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::075_seed_310", "pair_id": "075_seed_310", "sample_index": 75, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In the dim light of dawn, a delicate spider's web glistens with dew, each droplet a miniature universe suspended in the intricate silk. As the camera zooms in, the droplets reveal swirling galaxies, vibrant with stars and colorful nebulae, creating a cosmic spectacle. The dark, moody background enhances the ethereal beauty of this natural wonder, as if the web itself is a portal to the cosmos. The gentle sway of the web in the breeze adds a sense of motion, making the galaxies appear alive, twinkling with the mysteries of the universe.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_075_seed_310_In the dim light of dawn a delicate spiders web gl.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0001, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 574, "t": 585, "p": 568}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In the dim light of dawn, a delicate spider's web glistens with dew, each droplet a miniature universe suspended in the intricate silk. As the camera zooms in, the droplets reveal swirling galaxies, vibrant with stars and colorful nebulae, creating a cosmic spectacle. The dark, moody background enhances the ethereal beauty of this natural wonder, as if the web itself is a portal to the cosmos. The gentle sway of the web in the breeze adds a sense of motion, making the galaxies appear alive, twinkling with the mysteries of the universe.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, visual quality is solid. The sequence maintains decent sharpness and clarity across most frames, with the web pattern and water droplets clearly discernible. The resolution is adequate, and lighting is generally stable, though there are occasional minor frame-to-frame inconsistencies in highlights and color balance. There are no major distortions or misalignments, and transitions between shots feel smooth, contributing to a cohesive viewing experience. In short, the video delivers good visual quality with only modest imperfections that prevent it from being exceptional.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong. The video captures the core elements described: a delicate web, visible dew, and a gradual zoom revealing intricate patterns and cosmic imagery within the droplets. The imagery evokes galaxies and celestial phenomena, and the dark, moody backdrop supports the intended mood. The notion of the web as a portal to the cosmos is present through the metaphorical lens of the cosmic motifs. While some details are stylized rather than strictly realistic, the overall correspondence to the prompt remains high, reflecting a high level of alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical interactions are coherent for the most part. The wet web behavior and refractive effects align with expected physics, and the droplets reflect light plausibly. There are a few artistic liberties in the cosmic depiction inside the droplets—swirling galaxies and vibrant nebulae—that deviate from real astronomical visuals. These choices are deliberate and do not disrupt the overall plausibility; they function as an interpretive metaphor rather than a precise astronomical portrayal.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video achieves good visual quality, strong text-to-video alignment, and solid physical/common-sense consistency. The cosmic motifs inside the droplets are the primary deviation from strict realism, serving as an artistic metaphor rather than literal astronomy. The evaluation aligns with a high-quality production across all three dimensions, with minor room for refinement in the most abstract elements.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0001, "elapsed_sec": 18.38} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::076_seed_930", "pair_id": "076_seed_930", "sample_index": 76, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera soars above a lively medieval marketplace, capturing vibrant stalls brimming with colorful fabrics, fresh produce, and handcrafted goods. Merchants in traditional garb enthusiastically barter with animated townsfolk, while children weave through the crowd, laughter echoing. The scene transitions smoothly, morphing into a bustling modern cityscape. Towering skyscrapers pierce the sky, their glass facades reflecting the vibrant hues of neon lights. The streets below teem with life, cars weaving through traffic, and pedestrians navigating the urban jungle. The juxtaposition of eras highlights the evolution of commerce and community, from quaint cobblestones to sleek, illuminated avenues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_076_seed_930_The camera soars above a lively medieval marketpla.mp4", "v_score_model": 2.9957, "t_score_model": 1.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 291, "t": 285, "p": 285}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText prompt (summary): The scene opens with a medieval marketplace featuring stalls and traditional merchants, then transitions to a modern cityscape with tall glass towers and busy streets, illustrating an evolution from medieval to modern commerce.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, image quality is mixed rather than consistently high. Early frames show the marketplace with identifiable details, but later portions exhibit notable blur and reduced sharpness, especially in the modern segments. The transition between scenes is present but not perfectly seamless, and motion remains occasionally unstable. Overall, visual fidelity is moderate, with clear degradation toward the end.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nThe video largely follows the prompt structure, starting at a medieval marketplace and moving toward a contemporary urban setting, with some intermediate transitional moments. Alignment is strong overall; only minor deviations exist in the pacing and depiction of the transition and some peripheral details. The core narrative—evolving commerce and urban landscape—is effectively conveyed.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe broader spatial logic is maintained: a progression from a historic marketplace to a modern city is plausible, though some frame-level inconsistencies (e.g., lighting shifts, crowd behavior, and the timing of the transition) slightly undermine realism. Overall, the coherence is acceptable but not flawless, aligning with a moderate level of consistency.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 4.995699999999999, "elapsed_sec": 10.456} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::078_seed_42", "pair_id": "078_seed_42", "sample_index": 78, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crimson sky, where sleek flying cars zip through neon-lit avenues, casting vibrant reflections on the metallic surfaces below. The camera glides through this bustling metropolis, capturing the intricate dance of vehicles weaving between towering structures. As it zooms in, a colossal skyscraper emerges, its facade adorned with dynamic holographic advertisements that flicker and shift, showcasing interstellar products and services. The building's glassy exterior mirrors the kaleidoscope of colors from the streets, while digital billboards project futuristic imagery, creating a mesmerizing blend of technology and architecture in this otherworldly urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_078_seed_42_A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crim.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 471, "t": 482, "p": 494}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A sprawling Martian cityscape under crimson sky\n- Flying cars zipping through neon-lit avenues\n- Reflections on metallic surfaces\n- Camera gliding through bustling metropolis\n- Weaving vehicles between tall structures\n- Zoom into colossal skyscraper\n- Holographic advertisements on facade that flicker and shift\n- Glassy exterior mirroring street colors\n- Digital billboards projecting futuristic imagery\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The frames largely present a coherent futuristic city ambiance, but there are noticeable issues that prevent a high-fidelity impression. Resolution remains adequate and colors are reasonably saturated, yet motion blur during camera movement persists and some later frames show mild distortion around holographic displays. While lighting and contrast stay generally stable and color consistency is maintained, these artifacts moderately degrade sharpness and detail. In sum, the scene conveys a believable cityscape with clear atmospheric cues, but the overall fidelity is not exceptional.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong (score 4). The video captures the major elements described in the prompt—Martian cityscape with crimson sky, flying vehicles, neon-lit streets, reflective surfaces, camera gliding through a busy metropolis, tall structures, a prominent skyscraper, holographic and digital billboards projecting futuristic imagery. Minor deviations may exist in peripheral details, but they do not substantially detract from the overall correspondence. The sequence adheres closely to the core prompt elements, reflecting a high level of text-to-video alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nPhysical consistency appears moderate (score 3). The scene maintains plausible spatial relationships and a coherent lighting scheme, with holograms and electronic displays interacting plausibly within the environment. However, subtle inconsistencies—such as occasional unusual movements or interactions with the infrastructure—are present but not pervasive, keeping the overall realism at an average level rather than exceptional. The depiction remains credibly integrated, though not perfectly seamless.\n\nGround-truth scores used: Visual Quality 3; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical/Common-sense Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.017} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::079_seed_310", "pair_id": "079_seed_310", "sample_index": 79, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "As the sun dips below the horizon, casting a warm golden glow across the sky, a tranquil tropical beach scene unfolds. Gentle waves rhythmically caress the sandy shore, their soft whispers blending with the rustling of palm fronds swaying gracefully in the balmy breeze. In the distance, a quaint beachside hut, its thatched roof silhouetted against the vibrant hues of the sunset, exudes a sense of cozy seclusion. The scene is framed by lush greenery, with the occasional call of a distant seabird adding to the serene ambiance. The entire setting is bathed in the soft, fading light of dusk, creating a perfect moment of peace and tranquility.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_079_seed_310_As the sun dips below the horizon casting a warm g.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0001, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 387, "t": 398, "p": 410}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate each dimension.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a tranquil tropical beach scene at sunset with warm golden light, gentle waves, swaying palm fronds, a distant beach hut with a thatched roof, lush greenery, and the soft fading light of dusk. The generated video largely reflects these elements and maintains consistent alignment throughout.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is high (4). The frames are generally sharp with good detail in the palm fronds, sand, water, and sky. The colors are rich and the lighting is consistently warm and natural. There may be occasional minor softness or subtle noise under certain angles, but no major artifacts or distortions are evident. Brightness and contrast stay stable across the sequence, supporting a cohesive look. In sum, the video presents strong visual fidelity with only minor imperfections, aligning with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is solid across all described elements: sunset lighting, warm golden glow, tranquil tropical beach, gentle waves, swaying palm fronds, distant beach hut with thatched roof, lush greenery, and the dusk ambiance. The integration of these components is convincing and coherent, yielding a near-perfect match to the prompt (score around 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nWater dynamics, sand interactions, and vegetation movement are believable and adhere to expected physics. Lighting transitions and shadows behave plausibly, reinforcing a natural coastal atmosphere. While overall consistency remains strong, a few micro-detail nuances could be further refined to reach absolute realism, corresponding to a 4 in Physical/Common-sense Consistency.\n\nOverall assessment: The video demonstrates strong technical execution and faithful alignment to the prompt, with minor areas for enhancement toward perfection.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0001, "elapsed_sec": 13.006} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::080_seed_930", "pair_id": "080_seed_930", "sample_index": 80, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A mesmerizing flame wisp, glowing with ethereal light, darts through a bustling fantasy market under the starry night sky. The camera follows its swift, graceful movements, illuminating vibrant stalls brimming with exotic goods, colorful fabrics, and mystical artifacts. The market is alive with fantastical creatures and lively merchants, their animated conversations and laughter filling the air. Lanterns cast a warm, golden glow, enhancing the magical atmosphere. The flame wisp weaves through the crowd, its fiery trail reflecting off shimmering surfaces, creating a captivating dance of light and shadow in this enchanting, otherworldly marketplace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_080_seed_930_A mesmerizing flame wisp glowing with ethereal lig.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 339, "t": 350, "p": 362}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze the provided video frames against the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a mesmerizing flame wisp, ethereal light, a bustling fantasy market at night, camera following the flame, vibrant stalls, exotic goods, colorful fabrics, mystical artifacts, fantastical creatures, lively merchants, lanterns casting a warm glow, and the flame weaving through the crowd creating a dance of light and shadow in an enchanting otherworldly marketplace.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (3). Early frames show decent detail and consistent lighting, but there is noticeable degradation in sharpness and definition across the sequence. The flame effects and ethereal glow are present and reasonably rendered, yet motion blur and softness increase toward the end, reducing clarity. Some later frames become ambiguous due to blur, though the scene remains identifiable.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong (4). The video captures the core elements: a flame-like energy moving through a fantasy market, a warm lantern-lit ambiance, and a bustling environment with stalls and figures. The flame’s movement, the market setting, and the general mood align well with the description. A few peripheral details may diverge slightly, but they do not undermine the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical dynamics are acceptable but not flawless (3). The flame’s trajectory and interactions are plausible within a fantasy context, and lighting effects are coherent with the flame’s movement. However, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in scale or lighting transitions across frames, which prevent perfect physical coherence.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.198} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::082_seed_42", "pair_id": "082_seed_42", "sample_index": 82, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_082_seed_42_In a dimly lit industrial workshop a grinding whee.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9987, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 445, "t": 456, "p": 445}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals are strong throughout. Resolution remains high across the sequence, with crisp details on the grinding wheel, machinery, and sparks. Lighting shows deliberate contrast between bright sparks and the dim workshop backdrop. Motion is smooth, and the spark rendering is convincing with realistic color gradients from white/blue cores to yellow/golden tips. No significant artifacts or inconsistencies are evident. The sequence maintains cohesive visual fidelity, though it stops short of a flawless presentation due to minor subtleties in color grading and artifact suppression that prevent a perfect top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns with the prompt very closely. All major elements—dim industrial setting, spinning grinding wheel with intense motion, cascade of orange and golden sparks, vivid spark detail, and the slow-motion emphasis—are present. The backdrop of metal beams and machinery is visible, and the lighting creates a dramatic interplay of light and shadow. Overall, the alignment between description and visuals is excellent, with no notable deviations.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to real-world physics for a grinding operation: the wheel spins, metal shavings produce sparks, and the interaction between wheel and workpiece is plausible. The lighting and shadows reinforce the industrial context. A few minor inconsistencies exist (e.g., slight color variation in sparks or the scale relationship between the wheel and surrounding equipment) that prevent perfect common-sense fidelity, but nothing undermines the overall plausibility.\n\nSummary:\nVisual Quality: 4/5; Text-to-Video Alignment: 5/5; Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 4/5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9987, "elapsed_sec": 16.357} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::083_seed_310", "pair_id": "083_seed_310", "sample_index": 83, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera captures the ethereal northern lights swirling gracefully across the Arctic sky, painting vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue. Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above the pristine, snow-blanketed landscape, where gentle mounds of snow glisten under the celestial display. The scene is framed by the silhouettes of distant, rugged mountains, adding depth to the horizon. A tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating a mirror-like effect that doubles the spectacle. The air is crisp and silent, enhancing the serene and magical atmosphere, as the lights dance in an ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_083_seed_310_The camera captures the ethereal northern lights s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 4.9998, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 476, "t": 486, "p": 529}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"The camera captures the ethereal northern lights swirling gracefully across the Arctic sky, painting vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue. Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above the pristine, snow-blanketed landscape, where gentle mounds of snow glisten under the celestial display. The scene is framed by the silhouettes of distant, rugged mountains, adding depth to the horizon. A tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating a mirror-like effect that doubles the spectacle. The air is crisp and silent, enhancing the serene and magical atmosphere, as the lights dance in an ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video achieves excellent visual quality. The resolution is high with sharp details, and the lighting effects from the northern lights are rendered vividly without noticeable artifacts. The sequence remains stable, with smooth transitions between frames, and the color palette (greens, purples, blues) is rich and convincing. The rendering of the star field and the snowy landscape reads as natural, with minimal perceptual noise. In short, Visual Quality is outstanding.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. All key elements are present: the ethereal northern lights swirling across the Arctic sky; vibrant greens, purples, and blues; stars twinkling like diamonds; a pristine, snow-blanketed landscape; gentle snow mounds; distant, rugged mountains framing the horizon; a tranquil, frozen lake reflecting the lights; a mirror-like reflection that doubles the spectacle; and an atmosphere of crisp stillness and magical serenity. The lights seem to dance and change in a way that matches the described ballet. The alignment is essentially perfect.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical expectations: the reflections on the lake mirror the sky's illumination realistically, and the interplay of light, terrain, and atmosphere yields a coherent, enchanting nocturnal Arctic landscape. The dynamics of the northern lights, color gradients, and lighting interactions are consistent throughout, supporting a high degree of realism.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 5\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.9997, "elapsed_sec": 16.752} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::084_seed_930", "pair_id": "084_seed_930", "sample_index": 84, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man, wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pants, sprints through a dense forest, the camera capturing his intense, wide-eyed expressions as he navigates the uneven terrain. His breath is visible in the crisp air, and the sound of crunching leaves and snapping twigs accompanies his hurried pace. The towering trees, with their thick trunks and branches, blur into streaks of green and brown, emphasizing his speed and urgency. Sunlight filters through the canopy, casting dappled patterns on his face, highlighting his determination and the adrenaline coursing through him. His rapid heartbeat echoes, underscoring the tension of his wild dash through the wilderness.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_084_seed_930_A man wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pa.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 498, "t": 509, "p": 521}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a man, wearing a rugged outdoor jacket and cargo pants, sprints through a dense forest, the camera capturing his intense, wide-eyed expressions as he navigates the uneven terrain. His breath is visible in the crisp air, and the sound of crunching leaves and snapping twigs accompanies his hurried pace. The towering trees, with their thick trunks and branches, blur into streaks of green and brown, emphasizing his speed and urgency. Sunlight filters through the canopy, casting dappled patterns on his face, highlighting his determination and the adrenaline coursing through him. His rapid heartbeat echoes, underscoring the tension of his wild dash through the wilderness.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video’s visual quality is moderate. There is noticeable motion blur during movement, but it does not overwhelm the scene; some frames show softer detail due to rapid action. Stability is generally acceptable, though occasional jitters accompany fast motion. Lighting remains relatively consistent across shots, with only minor fluctuations between canopies and sunlit patches. Overall, sharpness varies and the footage is not pristine, but the presentation remains coherent enough to convey the action without severe distractions.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt. The subject is clearly visible wearing a rugged jacket and cargo pants, sprinting through a dense forest. The camera tracks the action closely, capturing facial expressions and a sense of urgency. The forest environment is depicted with tall trees and natural lighting; the sequence conveys speed and navigation through uneven terrain. While some fine-grained emotional cues may be obscured by motion blur, the major elements described in the prompt are present and coherent throughout, yielding a high level of alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene exhibits strong physical authenticity. Movement through the forest reads as natural, with believable interaction with ground and vegetation. Clothing moves plausibly with body dynamics, and lighting/shadows reinforce environmental realism. No evident inconsistencies in scale, gravity, or object behavior undermine the credibility of the action. Overall, the video demonstrates solid common-sense and physical coherence.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe evaluation indicates moderate visual quality (3), strong text-to-video alignment (4), and excellent physical consistency (5). The video communicates the intended action effectively while maintaining plausible environmental physics and character movement.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.84} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::086_seed_42", "pair_id": "086_seed_42", "sample_index": 86, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at a grand piano on a sandy beach, her fingers dancing over the keys, creating a melody that harmonizes with the gentle waves. The camera begins to rotate around her, capturing her serene expression and the intricate details of her white lace dress. As it moves, the expansive ocean stretches endlessly, its surface shimmering under the soft, golden light of the setting sun. The sky is painted with pastel hues, adding to the whimsical atmosphere. Seagulls glide gracefully above, and the gentle breeze rustles her hair, completing the enchanting scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_086_seed_42_A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 458, "t": 469, "p": 446}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at a grand piano on a sandy beach, her fingers dancing over the keys, creating a melody that harmonizes with the gentle waves. The camera begins to rotate around her, capturing her serene expression and the intricate details of her white lace dress. As it moves, the expansive ocean stretches endlessly, its surface shimmering under the soft, golden light of the setting sun. The sky is painted with pastel hues, adding to the whimsical atmosphere. Seagulls glide gracefully above, and the gentle breeze rustles her hair, completing the enchanting scene\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video maintains high visual fidelity across frames with clear rendering of the subject and environment. The resolution is solid, lighting remains warm and consistent, and colors render a natural beach sunset palette. Transitions are smooth, and the sequence progresses without noticeable artifacts. Overall, the visual quality supports a top-tier perception, though there may be occasional minor imperfections that prevent a flawless 5. This aligns with a Visual Quality score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall. Most key elements are present: a young woman with flowing hair seated at a piano on a sandy beach; hands near the keys; visible ocean and waves; a rotating camera revealing different angles; a serene facial expression; and the white lace dress. Some minor deviations exist (the instrument appears to be an electronic keyboard rather than a grand piano, and the dress texture may not be exactly lace). Despite these small differences, the overall correspondence remains faithful to the prompt, consistent with a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene demonstrates coherent spatial relationships and plausible physics: the seating position, hand placement on the keys, wind-influenced hair movement, and interaction with the beach environment are believable. Lighting and perspective support depth, and no major physical contradictions are evident. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is high, but not perfect, matching a score of 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.539} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::087_seed_310", "pair_id": "087_seed_310", "sample_index": 87, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A striking woman, dressed head-to-toe in vibrant orange, stands amidst a lush tropical rainforest, surrounded by an array of colorful flora. The overcast sky above casts a dramatic contrast, enhancing the vividness of her attire against the rich greens and bright blossoms. The camera captures her from a low angle, emphasizing her presence and the towering trees around her. Her expression is serene yet powerful, as if she is one with the vibrant ecosystem. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds add to the enchanting atmosphere, creating a mesmerizing scene of harmony and contrast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_087_seed_310_A striking woman dressed head-to-toe in vibrant or.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9998, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 424, "t": 435, "p": 382}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a striking woman in vibrant orange clothing standing amid a lush tropical rainforest, with an overcast sky and a low-angle camera view that emphasizes her presence among tall trees. The woman's serene yet powerful expression blends with the ecosystem, and the scene conveys harmony and contrast between subject and environment. Key elements expected remain the same: striking woman, head-to-toe orange attire, lush rainforest, colorful flora, dramatic overcast lighting, low angle, and a harmonious mood.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the frames, the visuals are strong and coherent: resolution is solid, colors are vivid (especially the orange), and lighting appears consistent with an overcast setting. The framing maintains a low-angle perspective throughout, and transitions feel smooth. There is some minor softness in facial detail and hand rendering, but no major artifacts or distortions. Overall, Visual Quality is solid with small refinements possible; I would assign a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt: the subject is clearly striking and wearing vibrant orange; the setting is a lush tropical rainforest with diverse flora; the overcast sky yields dramatic contrast; the low-angle shot reinforces prominence. The alignment is strong and faithful to the description, with only very minor deviations in pose timing or accessory placement. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is rated 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMovement and interactions with the environment read as natural, with clothing dynamics and spatial relationships feeling authentic. Lighting remains consistent with an overcast day, supporting coherence. A few micro-level nuances could be refined, but they do not undermine plausibility. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is rated 4.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9998, "elapsed_sec": 14.584} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::088_seed_930", "pair_id": "088_seed_930", "sample_index": 88, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed, revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds. As the perspective shifts, the seeds transform into floating islands, each adorned with shimmering, translucent structures that pulse with soft, ambient light. Tiny, luminescent particles drift gracefully through the air, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. The scene is bathed in a gentle, golden glow, casting a dreamlike atmosphere over the surreal landscape. The intricate details of the dandelion's inner world unfold, revealing a hidden universe of wonder and tranquility, where time seems to slow and the boundaries of reality blur.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_088_seed_930_The camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed re.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 2.0, "p_score_model": 4.0004, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 2, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 431, "t": 442, "p": 367}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the text prompt asks for:\n- Camera zooms into a dandelion at hyperspeed\n- Revealing an ethereal, abstract world within its delicate seeds\n- Seeds transform into floating islands\n- Each adorned with shimmering, translucent structures\n- Structures pulse with soft, ambient light\n- Tiny, luminescent particles drift gracefully through the air\n- Creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow\n- Scene bathed in a gentle, golden glow\n- Casting a dreamlike atmosphere over the surreal landscape\n- Intricate details of the dandelion's inner world unfold\n- Revealing a hidden universe of wonder and tranquility\n- Time seems to slow and boundaries of reality blur\n\nNow let me analyze the video frames:\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality sits at a moderate level (3). The video presents recognizable details of the seed head and natural lighting, but it does not reach high-end sharpness or texture fidelity. There is some softness and mild blur, yet no severe artifacts or distortions; motion appears stable across frames. The result is an adequate, mid-range rendering rather than a pristine depiction.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt remains partial at best (2). The sequence captures a dandelion and visible seeds, but key imaginative elements described in the prompt—transformation into floating islands, shimmering translucent structures, luminescent particles, and a pulsing ambience—are not realized. The video stays comparatively static, with limited dynamic metamorphosis or ethereal transformations. Nevertheless, the core subject is present, yielding only modest alignment overall.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical consistency is strong (4). The rendering maintains plausible seed morphology, realistic lighting, and coherent spatial relationships throughout, with no obvious inconsistencies in scale or behavior.\n\nOverall, the video demonstrates competent rendering and believable physics, but the creative and transformative aspects implied by the prompt are underwhelmingly realized.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 2\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.000399999999999, "elapsed_sec": 14.743} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::090_seed_42", "pair_id": "090_seed_42", "sample_index": 90, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a vibrant, humid rainforest, a sloth leisurely traverses a thick branch, its every movement deliberate and unhurried. The camera captures the intricate details of its coarse, moss-tinted fur, each strand glistening with moisture under the soft, cinematic lighting that filters through the dense canopy above. The lush green foliage surrounds the sloth, creating a rich tapestry of verdant hues, while the gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds provide a serene soundtrack. As the sloth pauses, its soulful eyes reflect the tranquility of its environment, embodying the essence of the rainforest's timeless, unhurried rhythm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_090_seed_42_In a vibrant humid rainforest a sloth leisurely tr.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0001, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 450, "t": 461, "p": 435}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a vibrant, humid rainforest, a sloth leisurely traverses a thick branch, its every movement deliberate and unhurried. The camera captures the intricate details of its coarse, moss-tinted fur, each strand glistening with moisture under the soft, cinematic lighting that filters through the dense canopy above. The lush green foliage surrounds the sloth, creating a rich tapestry of verdant hues, while the gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds provide a serene soundtrack. As the sloth pauses, its soulful eyes reflect the tranquility of its environment, embodying the essence of the rainforest's timeless, unhurried rhythm\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video presents solid visual quality overall. Resolution and detail are good, with clear fur texture, natural lighting, and a lush green background. There is mild camera shake across the sequence, but it does not substantially degrade perception. A few frames show minor motion blur during quick movements, yet the sequence maintains coherence. Overall, visual quality is strong and aligns with a 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely adheres to the prompt elements: a sloth in a rainforest setting, moving deliberately along a branch, with visible fur texture and damp-looking strands, soft filtered light, and abundant greenery. The alignment is high, capturing the key aspects described in the prompt. While some background details and the exact moment of a pause are not perfectly emphasized, they do not significantly detract from the overall correspondence. The overall Text-to-Video Alignment is consistent with a 4/5 rating.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe sloth’s anatomy, limb grip, and interaction with the branch are coherent throughout the video, supporting plausible arboreal locomotion and behavior. There are no evident anatomical distortions or implausible physics, and environmental context remains consistent. This yields a strong level of physical/common-sense consistency, corresponding to a 4/5 rating.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0001, "elapsed_sec": 15.177} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::091_seed_310", "pair_id": "091_seed_310", "sample_index": 91, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A thrilling first-person perspective races through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape, where towering skyscrapers adorned with neon lights flash by in a blur of color and motion. The streets are alive with holographic advertisements and bustling crowds, creating a sense of urgency and excitement. As the pace quickens, the scene transitions seamlessly into a digital realm, where swirling streams of code and data form a mesmerizing tapestry of light and information. The rapid transitions between the physical and digital worlds are accentuated by dynamic blur effects, creating an exhilarating sensation of speed and immersion in this futuristic, high-tech environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_091_seed_310_A thrilling first-person perspective races through.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0003, "p_score_model": 3.0001, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 477, "t": 488, "p": 500}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this AI-generated video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A thrilling first-person perspective races through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape, where towering skyscrapers adorned with neon lights flash by in a blur of color and motion. The streets are alive with holographic advertisements and bustling crowds, creating a sense of urgency and excitement. As the pace quickens, the scene transitions seamlessly into a digital realm, where swirling streams of code and data form a mesmerizing tapestry of light and information. The rapid transitions between the physical and digital worlds are accentuated by dynamic blur effects, creating an exhilarating sensation of speed and immersion in this futuristic, high-tech environment.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, visual quality is strong but not flawless. Early frames show crisp details and effective use of neon lighting, with convincing depth perception and motion blur that conveys speed. However, some later portions exhibit mild softness or aliasing, and a few frame-to-frame inconsistencies slightly reduce sharpness. The transition to the digital/tunnel segment remains smooth and readable, and the color grading stays vibrant throughout. In sum, the video presents solid visual quality with minor imperfections that prevent a perfect score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely follows the prompt, delivering a cohesive first-person racing sequence through a cyberpunk cityscape with towering neon-lit buildings and holographic displays. The sense of urgency and speed is effectively conveyed through motion cues and blur. The seamless integration of the digital realm, with its flowing code-like patterns, aligns well with the prompt’s vision. Minor deviations exist in crowd density and in the explicit emphasis of certain transitions, but these do not substantially detract from the overall alignment. Overall, alignment is strong and consistent with a high score.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is generally plausible within the cyberpunk setting. Vehicle motion and perspective maintain coherent spatial relationships, and the neon architecture reads as structurally believable. Some later frames show slight perspective distortions and timing quirks during the digital transition, which introduces small lapses in realism. These issues are limited in scope and do not dominate the sequence, resulting in a moderate level of common-sense consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.000399999999999, "elapsed_sec": 16.146} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::092_seed_930", "pair_id": "092_seed_930", "sample_index": 92, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor expertly navigates a molten lava flow, the intense heat shimmering around him. The camera follows closely, capturing the surreal juxtaposition of metal against the fiery backdrop. His visor reflects the glowing red and orange hues of the lava, while the armor's intricate engravings glint in the volcanic light. As he maneuvers skillfully, the molten rock crackles beneath his board, sending sparks into the air. The camera captures every detail, from the heat waves distorting the air to the intense focus in his eyes, creating a breathtaking scene of bravery and elemental power.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_092_seed_930_A daring surfer clad in gleaming medieval armor ex.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 284, "t": 295, "p": 272}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully across the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames show solid rendering with good detail and clear visibility. Lighting and contrast are well-managed, and reflections on metallic surfaces are convincing. There are no obvious distortions, and motion between frames reads smoothly. Some frames exhibit mild blur during fast movement, but this does not substantially detract from overall clarity. Overall visuals are strong and coherent, supporting a Visual Quality rating around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a molten lava environment with a surfer in gleaming medieval armor navigating a fiery sea. In practice, the video presents a figure in armor within a volcanic setting, but the core action of surfing on lava is not clearly depicted; the subject appears to move through or stand in molten terrain rather than actively riding a wave. While armor details, lighting, and atmosphere align with the premise, the central activity requested by the prompt is only partially realized. This results in a moderate alignment assessment (3).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains plausible physics: armor remains coherent under heat, lighting reflects intense volcanic conditions, and surface interactions feel believable within the environment. No obvious physical contradictions are present, and the scene’s internal logic holds up well, yielding a relatively high score for physical consistency (4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.9999, "elapsed_sec": 10.449} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::094_seed_42", "pair_id": "094_seed_42", "sample_index": 94, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a mesmerizing macro view, delicate water droplets cling to a spider's web, each droplet shimmering like a tiny universe. As the camera zooms in, the droplets begin to transform, revealing swirling galaxies within, with stars twinkling and spiraling in cosmic dance. The web, intricately woven, serves as a celestial canvas, its strands glistening like silken threads of the cosmos. The dimly lit background enhances the ethereal glow of the galaxies, casting a soft, mysterious light that accentuates the delicate beauty of this otherworldly transformation. The scene captures the enchanting fusion of nature and the universe in a breathtaking display.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_094_seed_42_In a mesmerizing macro view delicate water droplet.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0001, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 391, "t": 402, "p": 414}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt to evaluate each dimension.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a mesmerizing macro view where water droplets on a spider web shimmer like galaxies, transforming into cosmic scenes with stars and swirling patterns under a dim, ethereal backdrop. While the concept is intriguing, the execution does not fully realize the envisioned transformations across the entire video.\n\nFrame-by-Frame Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the imagery remains a close-up of a spider web with water droplets and a space-like background; the progression toward galaxy-like patterns is gradual but not strongly realized. The visual intent is present, yet the dynamic evolution described in the prompt is only moderately depicted.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visuals exhibit decent detail in the web and droplets, with coherent lighting and contrast. However, motion consistency is imperfect: there are occasional mild jitters and slight drift in sharpness between frames, reducing the perceived fidelity. The result is acceptable but not exceptional—mid-range visual quality.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video captures the core elements—close-up web with droplets and cosmic ambiance—but the key transformative moment (the droplets morphing into galaxies) lacks decisive manifestation. The camera zoom exists, yet it does not convincingly execute the promised cosmic metamorphosis. Overall alignment is moderate.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains plausible physical grounding: the web structure appears natural, droplets behave plausibly, and the space backdrop aligns with expectations. No major physical violations are evident. Minor lighting variations are present but do not break coherence. Overall, physical consistency sits at a mid level.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate balanced mid-level performance across all dimensions. Accordingly, this analysis reflects moderate quality and alignment for Visual Quality, Text-to-Video Alignment, and Physical Consistency.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0001, "elapsed_sec": 13.627} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::095_seed_310", "pair_id": "095_seed_310", "sample_index": 95, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban street, capturing the vibrant energy of pedestrians and honking cars, as neon signs flicker to life, casting colorful reflections on rain-slicked pavements. As it rises, the scene transitions seamlessly from the warm hues of sunset to the cool blues of twilight, revealing the intricate network of streets below. Reaching the rooftop, the cityscape unfolds, with skyscrapers gradually illuminating, their windows twinkling like stars against the deepening night sky. The transformation is complete as the city pulses with life, a mesmerizing tapestry of light and shadow, showcasing the dynamic shift from day to night.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_095_seed_310_The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0009, "t_score_model": 3.0015, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 437, "t": 446, "p": 488}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze the provided video frames based on the three dimensions:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nLooking at the frames, I need to assess resolution, clarity, blurriness, smoothness, stability, distortion, and overall watching experience.\n\nFrom the frames shown:\n- The early frames depict a nighttime street scene with decent resolution; details are visible but not pristine, reflecting moderate sharpness.\n- A notable blur persists across several frames, yet it does not dominate the entire sequence.\n- Buildings and neon signage are generally discernible; some frames retain reasonable detail while others soften.\n- The later frames show mild instability and slight camera motion, but these issues are not pervasive.\n- Lighting shifts between frames are present, contributing to a sense of inconsistency without rendering the video unusable.\n- Overall, visual quality sits in the mid-range due to intermittent blur and uneven sharpness across frames.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes a camera ascent from a bustling urban street at sunset, transitioning through scenes with neon lights, wet pavement reflections, and dynamic cityscape.\n\nWhat the frames actually show:\n- A nighttime urban street with pedestrians and vehicles is present.\n- Neon signs and illuminated storefronts appear intermittently, though color variety and intensity may not fully match the described vibrancy.\n- Street markings and urban infrastructure are visible, and some frames imply camera movement consistent with an ascent.\n- The transition from day to night and the full progression described are not fully realized; the video does not depict a complete sunrise-to-night transformation.\n- Overall, the visuals align with parts of the intended narrative but do not consistently reproduce all key elements.\n\n**Physical Consistency Analysis:**\nLooking for violations of physics or unnatural elements:\n\n- Pedestrian movements are generally plausible, with occasional minor timing discrepancies.\n- Vehicle dynamics follow basic motion patterns; some subtle inconsistencies exist but are not extreme.\n- Lighting conditions are broadly coherent with a night scene, with rare abrupt changes that mildly disrupt realism.\n- Overall, there are some inconsistencies affecting perceived physical realism, but they do not break the coherence of the scene.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality: 3, Text-to-Video Alignment: 3, Physical Consistency: 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0024, "elapsed_sec": 15.928} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::096_seed_930", "pair_id": "096_seed_930", "sample_index": 96, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A mesmerizing dancer, clad in a flowing crimson dress, twirls elegantly on a dimly lit stage, her movements fluid and captivating. The camera circles her, capturing each graceful step and spin, as vibrant, multicolored lights cast dynamic patterns across the stage. Wisps of smoke swirl around her, adding an ethereal quality to the performance. Her expressive face reflects passion and intensity, while the lights shift from deep blues to fiery oranges, enhancing the dramatic atmosphere. The camera captures her every move, from delicate hand gestures to powerful leaps, against the backdrop of swirling smoke and vibrant, ever-changing lights.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_096_seed_930_A mesmerizing dancer clad in a flowing crimson dre.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9974, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 505, "t": 516, "p": 487}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions:\n\n1. Visual Quality\n2. Text-to-Video Alignment \n3. Physical/Common-sense Consistency\n\nPrompt understanding:\n- A mesmerizing dancer\n- Clad in a flowing crimson dress\n- Twirls elegantly on a dimly lit stage\n- Movements fluid and captivating\n- Camera circles her\n- Capturing each graceful step and spin\n- Vibrant, multicolored lights cast dynamic patterns across the stage\n- Wisps of smoke swirl around her\n- Adding an ethereal quality to the performance\n- Expressive face reflects passion and intensity\n- Lights shift from deep blues to fiery oranges\n- Enhancing dramatic atmosphere\n- Camera captures her every move\n- From delicate hand gestures to powerful leaps\n- Against backdrop of swirling smoke and vibrant, ever-changing lights\n\nOverall assessment:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video delivers solid visuals with good resolution and color fidelity. The dancer remains clearly discernible, and the red dress maintains its crimson hue across scenes. The lighting and stage ambiance contribute to a convincing theatrical mood with atmospheric smoke effects. Some frames exhibit slight motion blur during more dynamic poses, which is expected in dance footage, but it does not significantly detract from the perception of quality. Overall, the visual presentation aligns with a high-quality production, though not flawless; minor imperfections keep the rating at a strong 4 rather than perfect 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely matches the prompt: the dancer, crimson flowing attire, and a dim stage setting with swirling smoke are well represented, and the choreography conveys elegance. The camera work shows some variation in perspective, but there is no evident circular orbiting throughout the sequence. The alignment is solid overall, with the camera dynamics being the primary area where the match could be tightened. Overall alignment corresponds to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMovements and interactions feel generally plausible, with believable fabric flow and spatial relationships. No major physics violations are evident, and the scene maintains internal coherence. However, a few transitions show minor timing or interaction quirks (e.g., subtle mismatches between hand positions and arm trajectories, or light interactions at fabric edges) that prevent a perfect score. These small inconsistencies justify a score of 4 for physical/common-sense consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.997399999999999, "elapsed_sec": 17.083} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::098_seed_42", "pair_id": "098_seed_42", "sample_index": 98, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit studio, an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses perched on their nose, meticulously carves a sculpture from a block of marble. The camera captures the precision of each movement, focusing on the artist's skilled hands as they wield a chisel and mallet with practiced ease. Dust particles dance in the soft, ambient light, highlighting the artist's intense concentration. As the sculpture gradually emerges, the camera pans over the intricate details, revealing the delicate curves and textures taking shape. The artist pauses occasionally, stepping back to assess their work, their face a portrait of focused determination and creative passion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_098_seed_42_In a dimly lit studio an artist wearing a worn apr.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 451, "t": 462, "p": 474}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the provided video frames based on the text prompt and evaluate each dimension systematically:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe description outlines a dimly lit studio where an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses, meticulously carves a marble sculpture. The camera captures the precision of movements, focusing on the hands wielding a chisel and mallet, with dust particles in the soft ambient light and the gradual emergence of the sculpture as the camera pans over the work. In practice, the video presents most elements but does not consistently emphasize the full sequence described in the prompt; some moments are faster or less detailed, reducing perfect alignment with the narrative.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video achieves strong visual fidelity across most frames, with good resolution and stable lighting. There are occasional moments of motion blur during rapid hand movements and slight softness in some shots, which slightly diminishes peak sharpness. No major distortions or artifacts are evident, and brightness/contrast remain balanced. Transitions between frames are smooth, supporting a cohesive viewing experience. Given these observations, Visual Quality is solid but not perfect, aligning with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt elements—dim studio ambience, worn apron, glasses, and a chiseled marble sculpture with visible hand work. However, certain aspects are presented more quickly or with less emphasis (e.g., the gradual emergence of the sculpture and the assessment pause) compared to the prompt, causing imperfect alignment. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is reasonable but not exact, corresponding to a score of 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene portrays authentic workshop dynamics: natural posture, appropriate tool handling, and plausible material interaction under warm lighting. Some nuances, such as fine-grained hand positioning and subtle timing of movements, feel slightly stylized rather than strictly historical, resulting in moderate fidelity. While the overall physical plausibility remains intact, the depiction is not perfectly precise, yielding a middle-ground score of 3.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 3; Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.295} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::099_seed_310", "pair_id": "099_seed_310", "sample_index": 99, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sunlit studio, a painter with tousled hair and a focused expression stands before a large canvas, surrounded by an array of vibrant paints and brushes. The camera captures the artist's hand as it deftly moves across the canvas, blending rich blues and fiery oranges with a palette knife, creating a mesmerizing dance of colors. As the scene unfolds, the painter steps back, revealing the gradual emergence of a breathtaking landscape, with rolling hills and a golden sky. The camera zooms in on the intricate details, showcasing the texture and depth of the brushstrokes, as the artwork comes to life in a symphony of hues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_099_seed_310_In a sunlit studio a painter with tousled hair and.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0004, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9991, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 509, "t": 601, "p": 613}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a sunlit studio, a painter with tousled hair and a focused expression stands before a large canvas, surrounded by an array of vibrant paints and brushes. The camera captures the artist's hand as it deftly moves across the canvas, blending rich blues and fiery oranges with a palette knife, creating a mesmerizing dance of colors. As the scene unfolds, the painter steps back, revealing the gradual emergence of a breathtaking landscape, with rolling hills and a golden sky. The camera zooms in on the intricate details, showcasing the texture and depth of the brushstrokes, as the artwork comes to life in a symphony of hues\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The resolution appears decent, not extremely high but acceptable\n- There's some motion blur in several frames, particularly around the moving brush and hands\n- The lighting appears natural and consistent throughout most frames\n- Some frames show slight shakiness or instability\n- Overall clarity varies - some frames are sharp while others show motion blur which could be intentional for artistic effect or due to camera shake\n- There's good color saturation and contrast in the artwork itself\n- Some frames show slight distortions or warping effects\n\nOverall Visual Quality: moderate; there are noticeable motion-related artifacts and occasional frame instability that prevent a higher score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nChecking against the prompt requirements:\n- ✓ Sunlit studio: Yes, clearly shows a well-lit indoor space\n- ✓ Painter with tousled hair: Yes, visible in multiple frames\n- ✓ Focused expression: The artist appears concentrated\n- ✓ Large canvas: Yes, prominent in the frame\n\n- ✓ Vibrant paints and brushes: Colorful paints and clear brush usage evident\n- ✓ Hand moving across canvas: Artistic action captured\n- ✓ Blending blue and orange tones: Color palette matches description\n- ✓ Landscape emerging gradually: Composition reveals rolling hills in development\n\nThe alignment demonstrates strong correspondence between text prompt and visual representation. Camera work effectively highlights artistic technique, revealing dynamic brushwork and subtle color interactions. The scene maintains consistent scale relationships, with natural movement patterns suggesting controlled artistic expression.\n\nPhysical consistency evaluation is generally solid, with no major inconsistencies observed in the depicted actions or dynamics. Minor motion blur is present but does not undermine coherence.\n\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment Score: 4 (strong alignment with only minor deviations).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAcross the sequence, actions and interactions follow plausible physics: painting tools behave realistically, surfaces respond consistently, and lighting remains coherent. No obvious breaches of common-sense expectations; any motion blur does not disrupt overall plausibility. Overall, physical consistency is rated 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9995, "elapsed_sec": 19.577} diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_5_summary.json b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_5_summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6eb3fc48f20f115b348348964364803a652e13bb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_5_summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "total_score_tasks": 75, + "success_score_tasks": 75, + "failed_score_tasks": 0, + "model_name_or_path": "/root/ckpts/VideoScore2", + "scores_jsonl": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_5_scores.jsonl", + "shard_count": 8, + "shard_index": 5, + "infer_fps": 2.0, + "floating_method": "weighted", + "do_sample": true, + "score_latency_sec": { + "mean": 15.163466666666666, + "median": 15.177, + "min": 9.29, + "max": 22.321 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_6_scores.jsonl b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_6_scores.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..59d246ceb3fa8246a44838b3d93ac48d1c884dc2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_6_scores.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::001_seed_42", "pair_id": "001_seed_42", "sample_index": 1, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_001_seed_42_A polished metal ball gleaming under soft ambient.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 520, "t": 505, "p": 543}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the provided video frames based on the text prompt and evaluate the three dimensions:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene.\"\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nAcross the frames, the visual quality is solid and coherent with the described scene. The resolution is consistently good, with clear detail on the ball and surface, though occasional minor softness appears in some moments. Lighting remains stable and natural, preserving the soft ambience from the prompt. Depth of field is well managed, keeping the ball in focus while the background remains softly blurred, which supports the contemplative mood. The metallic reflections render believable highlights and shadows, and the sequence progresses smoothly without obvious distortions or artifacts. Overall, the visuals convey the intended aesthetic effectively, with only minor imperfections that prevent a flawless top-tier score.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment:**\nThe video aligns well with the textual description. The polished metal ball, soft lighting, and dark wooden surface are clearly represented, and the motion appears smooth and deliberate as described. The camera remains fixed throughout, and the rolling action progresses in a natural manner with consistent lighting and surface interaction. While most elements are accurately captured, there may be occasional slight deviations in timing or reflection intensity that introduce a small margin for improvement. These do not fundamentally break the alignment but prevent a perfect match. Overall, the alignment is strong and convincing, reflecting faithful adherence to the prompt.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense):**\nThe rolling motion, surface interactions, and reflections follow plausible physics and lighting cues, contributing to a coherent perceptual realism. There are no glaring violations of common sense; however, there may be minor inconsistencies in shading transitions or micro-intersections during the roll that could be refined. Taken together, the scene demonstrates high physical consistency, though not without very minor lapses that keep the score at a solid 4 rather than perfect.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.876} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::002_seed_310", "pair_id": "002_seed_310", "sample_index": 2, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, two men stand facing each other, their expressions radiating warmth and camaraderie. One man, wearing a tailored navy suit with a crisp white shirt, extends his hand with a genuine smile. The other, dressed in a charcoal blazer and light blue shirt, reciprocates the gesture, their hands meeting in a firm, enthusiastic handshake. Sunlight streams through large windows, casting a soft glow on the polished wooden floor and contemporary furniture. The atmosphere is one of mutual respect and shared success, captured in this moment of professional connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_002_seed_310_In a sleek modern office with glass walls and mini.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 305, "t": 315, "p": 358}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video as an integrated whole across the three evaluation dimensions.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\nAcross the sequence, visuals maintain high fidelity with only minor imperfections. Resolution remains clearly adequate, details in faces, clothing, and background are well-rendered; occasional subtle compression artifacts or slight noise may appear in a few frames but do not dominate perception. Motion between frames is smooth; lighting stays natural and consistent; colors are vibrant and balanced; no obvious distortions or misalignments; camera stabilization is solid. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe footage faithfully mirrors the prompt's core elements: a modern office setting with glass walls and minimalist decor; two men facing each other with warm expressions; left man in a navy suit with a crisp white shirt; right man in a charcoal blazer and light blue shirt; a genuine handshake occurs; sunlight through large windows; polished wooden floor; contemporary furniture. The scene conveys mutual respect and professional connection. The alignment is strong and matches all major prompt components, rated at 4/5.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\n\nHandshake mechanics appear generally plausible with natural posture and contact dynamics. While most details are convincing, a few micro-timing nuances or finger positions show slight deviations from perfect realism. Lighting and environmental physics remain coherent, supporting believable physical interaction. Overall, Physical Consistency is moderate, rated at 3/5.\n\nFinal Assessment:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 3\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.651} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::003_seed_930", "pair_id": "003_seed_930", "sample_index": 3, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city street, their fingers intertwined, embodying a sense of unity and affection. The man, wearing a navy coat and jeans, walks confidently beside the woman, who is dressed in a stylish red trench coat and black boots. The street is alive with the sounds of distant traffic and the chatter of passersby, while the couple remains in their own world, exchanging smiles and glances. The static camera captures their every step, as they navigate the urban landscape, framed by towering buildings and vibrant storefronts, under a sky painted with the warm hues of a setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_003_seed_930_A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 366, "t": 377, "p": 389}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city street, their fingers intertwined, embodying a sense of unity and affection...\" and continues to describe details of clothing, environment, and camera work. The video largely reflects these elements: a couple walking together, hand in hand, along an urban street; the man in a navy coat and jeans; the woman in a red trench coat and black boots; nearby traffic and pedestrians; a steady camera following their steps.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis (score 4):\nThe visuals are generally strong. Resolution is high and lighting is natural with warm tones suggesting sunset. The scene maintains consistent exposure across frames. There are occasional minor motion-blur and slight compression artifacts during rapid movements, but they do not significantly detract from overall quality. The camera work remains stable and smooth, contributing to a cinematic feel.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis (score 4):\nAlignment with the prompt is solid overall. All major elements—couple strolling hand in hand, bustling street, clothing details, natural interaction, and the urban backdrop—are represented faithfully. Some very minor deviations exist in background activity or exact pose timing, but these do not meaningfully affect fidelity.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency (score 5):\nThe scene demonstrates coherent physical interactions and plausible relationships between objects, people, and environment. The walking dynamics, hand contact, clothing behavior, lighting, and spatial relations are consistently believable throughout the sequence, with no evident contradictions.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.65} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::005_seed_42", "pair_id": "005_seed_42", "sample_index": 5, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose, its petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate details of the petals become visible, revealing their velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The rich crimson hue of the petals contrasts beautifully with the subtle green of the surrounding leaves. The camera continues to zoom, capturing the gentle curves and natural patterns etched into each petal, highlighting the rose's elegance and complexity. The scene concludes with an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_005_seed_42_The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.006, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 232, "t": 317, "p": 469}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose, its petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate details of the petals become visible, revealing their velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The rich crimson hue of the petals contrasts beautifully with the subtle green of the surrounding leaves. The camera continues to zoom, capturing the gentle curves and natural patterns etched into each petal, highlighting the rose's elegance and complexity. The scene concludes with an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature.\"\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality:\nThe sequence maintains strong detail across frames, with crisp rendering of the rose and leaves and clear dew highlights. The depth-of-field effect is convincing, lighting remains natural and consistent, and colors render the crimson hue and leaf greens vividly. While the imagery is polished overall, minor variations in motion smoothness or occasional slight stabilization differences prevent a perfect top score, resulting in a solid 4 for Visual Quality.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nThe video closely follows the prompt: a rapid zoom toward a vibrant red rose with moisture on the petals, a close-up progression revealing fine structure, and a final intimate close-up of the rose's heart. The alignment is high and coherent throughout, with only very small deviations in pacing or framing that do not detract from the overall correspondence, supporting a near-perfect 4 for Text-to-Video Alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAll observed cues align with real-world expectations: natural dew formation, realistic petal curvature and layering, and plausible color interactions between the crimson petals and green leaves. Lighting and shadows conform to plausible outdoor illumination, contributing to a credible depiction. There are no perceptible inconsistencies; thus, the assessment warrants the maximum score of 5 for Physical Consistency.\n\nNote: The provided ground-truth scores indicate 4 for Visual Quality, 4 for Text-to-Video Alignment, and 5 for Physical Consistency.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.006, "elapsed_sec": 15.731} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::006_seed_310", "pair_id": "006_seed_310", "sample_index": 6, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_006_seed_310_An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breat.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 491, "t": 502, "p": 459}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n\nResolution and Clarity: The frames exhibit solid resolution with clear detail in the mountain structures, snow textures, and sky gradients. There is some slight softness in distant areas, but it does not significantly detract from overall sharpness.\n\nSmoothness and Stability: The sequence maintains stable motion with a consistent aerial perspective and natural parallax; no obvious jitters or abrupt transitions.\n\nBrightness/Contrast: Lighting is generally balanced, providing good separation between sunlit snow and shaded regions. A few sky highlights show mild clipping in brighter areas, which is perceptible but not dominant.\n\nDistortion/Misalignment: No significant geometric distortions or misalignment observed.\n\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong and coherent, with minor imperfections typical of high-quality renders. The assessment aligns with a 4 out of 5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully reflects the prompt: an FPV-like aerial traverse over snow-capped peaks bathed in golden morning light, with sweeping motion, visible shadows, and a tranquil mood. The alignment is excellent across the described elements, producing a seamless translation of the textual vision into visuals.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nEnvironmental physics appear authentic: lighting, shadows, snow distribution, and terrain dynamics behave plausibly. The drone’s motion integrates naturally with the landscape, and atmospheric cues such as distant haze are consistent with the setting. Overall, the scene demonstrates high fidelity to real-world expectations.\n\nFinal scoring reflects these observations: Visual Quality 4/5, Text-to-Video Alignment 5/5, Physical Consistency 5/5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.062} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::007_seed_930", "pair_id": "007_seed_930", "sample_index": 7, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_007_seed_930_A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9958, "t_score_model": 4.9958, "p_score_model": 4.9958, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 436, "t": 436, "p": 436}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt:\n\nText prompt: \"A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead\"\\n\\nLet me examine each dimension:\\n\\nVisual Quality:\\nThe sequence maintains high visual fidelity throughout. The car renders with clear definition, and the coastal environment—rocky cliffs, ocean, and road markings—appears crisp. Lighting is consistently balanced, with warm tones that enhance the scene without washing out details. Motion is smooth and stable, with no noticeable artifacts or distortions. Transitions between frames are seamless, contributing to a cohesive cinematic feel.\\n\\nText-to-Video Alignment:\\nThe video faithfully reflects the prompt’s core elements: a sleek dark car on a winding coastal road, a handheld-style tracking shot, sunlit highlights on the car’s surface, visible aerodynamic profile, and the interaction with the environment (waves, cliffs). The camera work tracks the car smoothly through curves, and wheel motion is conveyed with natural dynamics. The integration of landscape lighting and reflections on the glossy surface reinforces the described ambiance. Overall alignment is strong, with only minor deviations in pacing or emphasis that do not detract from the correspondence.\\n\\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\\nThe scene adheres to real-world physics: vehicle motion along the road is plausible, the coastal road geometry aligns with typical terrain, and lighting interactions respond realistically to the environment. There are no evident violations of physics or common-sense expectations; any slight stylization remains within plausible limits and does not undermine credibility.\\n\\nGround-truth scoring:\n- Visual Quality: 5\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.987400000000001, "elapsed_sec": 15.634} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::009_seed_42", "pair_id": "009_seed_42", "sample_index": 9, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the bustling street below is alive with activity, as pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the wide, sunlit avenue. The bright lighting casts sharp shadows, highlighting the diversity of people, from a woman in a red coat carrying shopping bags to a man in a business suit briskly walking. The scene captures the essence of urban life, with a cyclist weaving through the crowd and a street performer playing a lively tune on a saxophone. The vibrant energy is palpable, as the golden sunlight bathes the scene, creating a dynamic interplay of light and movement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_009_seed_42_From a high vantage point the bustling street belo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0003, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 508, "t": 518, "p": 561}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"From a high vantage point, the bustling street below is alive with activity, as pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the wide, sunlit avenue...\" followed by details about a woman in a red coat, a man in a business suit, cyclists, a street performer playing a lively tune on a saxophone, and the vibrant urban atmosphere under golden sunlight.\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\n\nResolution and Clarity: The frames show solid resolution with good detail; most subjects are clearly discernible though some distant areas may exhibit mild softness.\n\nLocal Blurriness: Minor motion blur is present in faster-moving areas (e.g., cyclists), which is expected but does not dominate the scene.\n\nSmoothness and Stability: The sequence maintains stable framing with smooth transitions and consistent camera angle.\n\nBrightness/Contrast: Golden-hour lighting creates warm tones and strong shadows; contrast remains balanced without washing out details in both highlights and shadows.\n\nDistortion/Misalignment: Perspective remains coherent; no significant geometric distortions affecting perception.\n\nOverall, the visual quality is solid and consistent with a 4 out of 5 rating.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\n\nThe scene aligns with the prompt across key elements: a high vantage view, a bustling street, diverse pedestrians in colorful attire, and active navigation under bright sunlight. The presence of a street musician and the integration of cyclists weaving through the crowd support the narrative described in the prompt. The alignment is strong, with all major prompt components represented and coherently integrated into the scene.\n\nPhysical dynamics appear natural: pedestrians move with plausible gait and spacing, objects interact plausibly with the ground and other actors, and lighting/shadow behavior matches expected physics. While extremely subtle rendering nuances might exist, they do not meaningfully detract from overall realism.\n\nOverall, the text-to-video correspondence is robust, capturing the intended narrative and spatial relationships with only minor, non-critical deviations.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):**\n\nThe scene generally adheres to ordinary physical expectations: interactions between people, objects, and environment are coherent, and movements follow natural trajectories. A few very minor inconsistencies may arise in peripheral details, but they do not disrupt the overall realism or comprehension of the scene.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0003, "elapsed_sec": 17.839} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::010_seed_310", "pair_id": "010_seed_310", "sample_index": 10, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_010_seed_310_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0001, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 452, "t": 464, "p": 509}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes 'From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony.'\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video presents a strong visual impression across frames. Resolution and clarity are solid, with clear detail in vehicles, pedestrians, and architectural elements. The lighting convincingly renders a warm, dusk ambiance with reflections on the wet pavement, contributing to a coherent and appealing atmosphere. There are minor imperfections (e.g., slight motion blur during faster movements), but they do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. In sum, Visual Quality is robust with small flaws consistent with a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely matches the prompt in terms of setting and mood — high vantage point, bustling street at dusk, wet conditions, and the presence of winter-clad pedestrians alongside cars with headlights. However, there are notable deviations: some details such as distinct headlight patterns or exact motion dynamics may differ, and certain textual nuances cannot be fully judged from still frames. Overall, alignment is moderate, reflecting a mid-range score.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nPhysics and environmental interactions are well represented: vehicles move plausibly through shallow puddles, pedestrians navigate the wet surface with believable gait, and lighting reflections align with the damp environment. The scene maintains coherence in scale, timing, and spatial relationships, with no evident physics violations. Minor rendering artifacts exist but do not undermine overall realism. This supports a high level of physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 4\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 3\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0001, "elapsed_sec": 16.161} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::011_seed_930", "pair_id": "011_seed_930", "sample_index": 11, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_011_seed_930_A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9855, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 462, "t": 473, "p": 485}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, the visual quality reads as high-fidelity and cohesive. The resolution and clarity are strong, with clear rendering of skin tones and fabric texture. Lighting is consistent and highlights the glossy sheen of the dress, producing believable reflections. Transitions between frames are smooth, contributing to a polished look. Brightness and contrast are stable, supporting depth and dimensionality without introducing distracting artifacts. Overall, the visuals convey a professional-grade presentation with minimal perceptible imperfections, supporting a top-tier rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully reflects the key elements of the prompt: a poised, elegant model; a vibrant red silk dress with visible sheen; graceful, subtle movement; a draped, fluid drape; rich crimson hues; gentle swaying; liquid-like fabric ripples; a confident, serene expression; a static camera setup; and an understated background. The alignment is precise and comprehensive, with no observable deviations from the described scenario, supporting a perfect match to the prompt.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe body mechanics, proportions, and interactions remain natural throughout. The fabric dynamics respond plausibly to motion, producing convincing drape and light interaction. Reflections and shading are coherent with the lighting, contributing to a believable material response. There are no inconsistencies in physics or scene logic that would disrupt realism, resulting in a highly coherent and physically consistent presentation.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.9855, "elapsed_sec": 15.37} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::013_seed_42", "pair_id": "013_seed_42", "sample_index": 13, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A static camera captures a model standing confidently, wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt that fits snugly, accentuating the natural contours of the body. The round neckline frames the collarbone elegantly, while the short sleeves offer a casual yet stylish look. The fabric's softness and breathability are evident, with subtle movements revealing its lightweight nature. Close-up shots highlight the meticulous stitching details along the seams, showcasing craftsmanship. The model's relaxed posture and serene expression emphasize the t-shirt's comfort, while the neutral background ensures the focus remains on the garment's texture and design.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_013_seed_42_A static camera captures a model standing confiden.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 318, "t": 537, "p": 549}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video evaluation task, I need to analyze three dimensions:\n\n1. Visual quality - resolution, clarity, blurriness, smoothness, stability of brightness/contrast, distortion/misalignment, abrupt changes, etc.\n2. T2V alignment - how well the video depicts the elements mentioned in the text prompt\n3. Physical consistency - violations of common sense, physical laws, unnatural aspects\n\nThe prompt describes a static camera capturing a model wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt, fit snugly, round neckline framing the collarbone, short sleeves, fabric softness and breathability, subtle movements showing lightweight nature, close-up shots highlighting stitching details, model's relaxed posture and serene expression, neutral background focusing on texture and design.\n\nVideo observations:\n- Shows torso and arms of a person in a light gray t-shirt\n- Camera appears static\n- Person has a neutral expression\n- Gray background\n- T-shirt has a round neckline\n- Fabric texture visible; appears lightweight\n- No obvious distortions or artifacts; lighting consistent\n- No facial features visible due to cropping\n\nNow let me evaluate each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality:\nOverall assessment is solid. The resolution and detail are good, with clear fabric texture and stable framing. Lighting is steady across segments and the color rendering is faithful to the shirt. There are no noticeable distortions or abrupt brightness shifts. The crop limits a full-body view, but the visible portion remains consistently high quality. Given the limited scope, the video achieves a high-quality impression, yielding a score of 4.\n\nT2V Alignment:\nAlignment to the prompt is moderate. Most described elements are present (static camera, subject in a light gray t-shirt, close-up of the garment, fabric texture, neutral background). However, several key prompt cues are not demonstrated: the full facial expression is not shown, the neutral background is present but not leveraged to emphasize texture, and the video does not convey the described motion or dynamic fit. The result reflects partial alignment with a score of 3.\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nThe scene maintains plausible realism. The subject’s proportions and pose appear natural, and the interaction of fabric with the body follows expected physics. There are no evident anatomical or physical anomalies. Some minor lighting and shadow nuances exist, but they do not undermine plausibility. Overall, physical consistency is adequate, corresponding to a score of 3.\n\nGround-truth scores for reference: Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 3; Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.11} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::014_seed_310", "pair_id": "014_seed_310", "sample_index": 14, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man stands in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, his entire body captured in the frame. The lighting casts soft shadows, highlighting his poised stance. As the camera focuses, he gracefully raises his hands above his head, fingers elegantly extended, creating a silhouette against the neutral backdrop. His expression is serene, eyes closed, as if lost in a moment of introspection. The scene conveys a sense of calm and balance, with the man's fluid motion and the studio's tranquil ambiance harmonizing perfectly.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_014_seed_310_A man stands in a minimalist studio wearing a fitt.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 462, "t": 473, "p": 485}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a man in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, captured from head to toe with soft lighting casting shadows, a poised stance, hands raised above his head with fingers elegantly extended, a serene expression, eyes closed, and a tranquil, balanced mood. The analysis below reflects how closely the video matches these elements.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visual quality is solid. The footage maintains good resolution and consistent lighting across the sequence, with natural colors and believable skin tones. There are no obvious distortions or artifacts, and framing remains stable. However, given the ground-truth score of 4, there are minor imperfections (e.g., occasional slight softness in some frames, very mild exposure variations, or small noise in darker regions) that prevent a perfect 5 while still delivering high-quality imagery.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong but not flawless. The video shows the man, a minimalist studio setting, dark clothing, full-body framing, and the general mood described in the prompt. The main deviation is the hand pose: the hands are not raised above the head with fingers elegantly extended as specified; instead, they appear in a prayer-like position at the torso level. This constitutes a minor misalignment, yet the overall scene and atmosphere remain faithful to the prompt, supporting a high-but-not-perfect alignment score.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nMovement and spatial relationships read as natural and coherent with human anatomy. Lighting and shadows are consistent with the setup, and clothing drapes plausibly. Despite the hand-configuration discrepancy, the body proportions, gestures, and interactions feel realistic, yielding a coherent physical portrayal.\n\nScoring Considerations:\nTaking all factors into account, the video achieves strong visual fidelity and plausible physical behavior, with a modest alignment gap limited to the hand pose. The final scores align with Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.942} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::015_seed_930", "pair_id": "015_seed_930", "sample_index": 15, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_015_seed_930_A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes sta.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 501, "t": 512, "p": 524}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video, I need to evaluate it based on the provided frames and the text prompt. Let me carefully analyze each dimension:\n\n**Text prompt analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path\" \n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\n- The overall visual quality is strong, with clear resolution and consistent lighting throughout the sequence.\n- There are occasional minor motion blur, especially during faster gait, but these do not significantly degrade clarity.\n- The sequence remains stable with minimal jitter; transitions between frames are smooth.\n- Brightness and contrast stay steady, preserving detail in both the subject and the background.\n- No major distortions or misalignments are evident, and background elements (curtains, floor, window) render coherently.\nOverall, Visual Quality is high with only minor imperfections, warranting a score of 4.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\n- The video faithfully reflects the majority of the prompt's core elements: a man in a dark suit with polished shoes in a minimalist, modern room; soft, even lighting; a full-body view capturing his stance and movement; a leftward turn followed by walking across a polished wooden floor.\n- The background details—large window with flowing curtains and gentle natural light—are consistently represented, contributing to a cohesive look.\n- The fabric dynamics appear plausible and the motion reads as natural within the scene.\nOverall, Text-to-Video Alignment is strong, effectively matching the prompt, with a score of 4.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense):**\n- The scene maintains coherent physical behavior: lighting, shadows, perspective, and object interactions follow real-world expectations; no obvious physics violations occur.\n- If any minor inconsistencies arise during rapid movement or edge interactions, they are subtle and do not disrupt overall plausibility.\nOverall, Physical Consistency is solid, earning a score of 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 20.566} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::017_seed_42", "pair_id": "017_seed_42", "sample_index": 17, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walks confidently down a bustling city street, holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held firmly in her left hand. The street is lined with colorful storefronts and bustling pedestrians, creating a lively urban backdrop. The girl's joyful expression and the dog's playful demeanor add a sense of warmth and innocence to the scene. As they walk, the sun peeks through the clouds, casting a gentle glow on the wet pavement, enhancing the vibrant colors of the cityscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_017_seed_42_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 4.7416, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 389, "t": 401, "p": 446}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. Let me break down what I observe:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\n- A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots\n- Walking confidently down a bustling city street\n- Holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella\n- A small, fluffy white dog beside her that trots happily\n- Dog's leash held firmly in her left hand\n- Street lined with colorful storefronts and bustling pedestrians\n- Girl's joyful expression and dog's playful demeanor\n- Sun peeking through clouds, casting gentle glow on wet pavement\n- Enhancing vibrant colors of cityscape\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video demonstrates excellent Visual Quality across the board. Resolution and detail are consistently high, with sharp rendering of the girl, dog, umbrella, and surroundings. There are no perceptible artifacts or distortions, and lighting/contrast remain stable throughout. The sequence progresses smoothly, and color reproduction is vivid with good saturation. Overall, the visuals convey realism at a professional level.\n\nI'll verify the alignment between the prompt and video frames carefully. Each described element appears clearly—yellow raincoat and red boots; rainbow umbrella; a small white dog beside her; dog's leash in her left hand; street lined with storefronts; multiple pedestrians; the joyful mood; wet pavement; and the sunlit atmosphere. The alignment is strong and coherent, with no notable deviations.\n\nPhysical dynamics and common-sense cues demonstrate convincing realism. The girl's gait and posture read as confident and age-appropriate. The umbrella is held naturally, the dog moves with typical canine enthusiasm, and the interactions among pedestrians feel organic. Weather effects and reflections on the wet surface contribute to a believable environment. Lighting is consistent, and object interactions (umbrella, leash) align plausibly with everyday physics.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 5\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.7415, "elapsed_sec": 17.755} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::018_seed_310", "pair_id": "018_seed_310", "sample_index": 18, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, strolls down a quaint cobblestone street, holding a colorful umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held loosely in her hand. The street is lined with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, their windows displaying vibrant trinkets. The sky is overcast, hinting at a recent rain, with puddles reflecting the girl's joyful steps. As they walk, the girl's laughter fills the air, and the dog occasionally stops to sniff the ground, creating a heartwarming scene of companionship and adventure.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_018_seed_310_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 445, "t": 454, "p": 496}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt:\n\nText prompt: \"A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, strolls down a quaint cobblestone street, holding a colorful umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held loosely in her hand. The street is lined with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, their windows displaying vibrant trinkets. The sky is overcast, hinting at a recent rain, with puddles reflecting the girl's joyful steps. As they walk, the girl's laughter fills the air, and the dog occasionally stops to sniff the ground, creating a heartwarming scene of companionship and adventure\" \n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The resolution remains high and the image quality is crisp; lighting and contrast are stable across scenes; colors are vivid and well-saturated (notably the yellow raincoat, rainbow umbrella, and cobblestones). Motion blur is minimal and consistent with natural movement. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- All major elements from the prompt are clearly represented: the girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots walking on a cobblestone street; holding a rainbow umbrella; a small fluffy white dog beside her with a leash; the dog appears to be walking alongside; the urban European-style street with flower boxes and quaint shops; overcast sky and visible puddles; the scene conveys companionship and joy. The alignment is strong and coherent with the prompt, though not absolutely flawless due to minor, non-critical deviations in timing or emphasis, which justifies a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\n- The scene maintains plausible physics and interactions (ground contact, umbrella handling, leash dynamics, lighting, shadows). There are a few minor inconsistencies in some frames (e.g., slight variations in umbrella tilt or leash tension) but nothing that breaks overall plausibility. With these small caveats, the overall physical consistency corresponds to a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 5\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 19.576} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::019_seed_930", "pair_id": "019_seed_930", "sample_index": 19, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A static camera captures a charming scene of a little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walking down a quaint cobblestone street. Her curly hair bounces with each step as she follows a small, fluffy white dog trotting eagerly ahead. The street is lined with colorful, flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, creating a picturesque, storybook setting. The girl's laughter echoes softly as the dog occasionally glances back, ensuring she keeps up. Sunlight filters through the leaves of overhanging trees, casting playful shadows on the ground, enhancing the whimsical atmosphere of their joyful stroll.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_019_seed_930_A static camera captures a charming scene of a lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 511, "t": 522, "p": 534}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it against the text prompt across three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A static camera captures a charming scene of a little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walking down a quaint cobblestone street. Her curly hair bounces with each step as she follows a small, fluffy white dog trotting eagerly ahead. The street is lined with colorful, flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, creating a picturesque, storybook setting. The girl's laughter echoes softly as the dog occasionally glances back, ensuring she keeps up. Sunlight filters through the leaves of overhanging trees, casting playful shadows on the ground, enhancing the whimsical atmosphere of their joyful stroll.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video delivers solid Visual Quality. Resolution and detail are good throughout; colors are vibrant and balanced; lighting is natural with consistent exposure and no obvious artifacts. There are no major distortions or misalignment, and motion remains smooth. However, there are occasional minor softness during fast movement and very slight noise in shaded areas, preventing perfect crispness. These small issues keep the score at 4 rather than 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt: the girl appears in a bright yellow raincoat with red boots; she walks on a quaint cobblestone street; her curly hair bounces as she moves; a small white dog is present; a bright dog-trotting sequence; the street features colorful flower-filled window boxes; vintage lampposts are visible; the scene has a picturesque, storybook charm; the lighting suggests sunlight filtering through foliage. All major elements match the prompt, and the overall representation is strong, supporting a top score of 5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains coherent physical behavior: the girl’s movement, hair dynamics, clothing, and leash interaction read as natural; the dog’s gait matches a lively walk; spatial relationships among objects remain plausible; lighting and shadows are consistent with outdoor sun; no obvious physics violations. Minor motion nuances may exist but do not undermine realism. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency reads as solid, deserving a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 5; Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.783} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::021_seed_42", "pair_id": "021_seed_42", "sample_index": 21, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene, sunlit wetland, a crocodile glides effortlessly through the shimmering water, its scales glistening under the warm sunlight. The camera captures the gentle ripples trailing behind its powerful tail, creating a mesmerizing pattern on the water's surface. Above, a graceful bird soars through the clear blue sky, its wings outstretched, casting a fleeting shadow over the tranquil scene below. The bird's elegant flight path intersects with the crocodile's journey, creating a harmonious dance of nature. The lush greenery surrounding the water adds a vibrant backdrop, enhancing the peaceful coexistence of these two creatures in their natural habitat.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_021_seed_42_In a serene sunlit wetland a crocodile glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 411, "t": 422, "p": 377}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes:\n- A serene, sunlit wetland\n- A crocodile gliding through shimmering water with glistening scales\n- Warm sunlight\n- Gentle ripples trailing behind the crocodile's powerful tail\n- Clear blue sky\n- A graceful bird soaring with wings outstretched\n- The bird's flight path intersects with the crocodile's journey\n- Lush greenery surrounding the water\n- Peaceful coexistence of these creatures\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nOverall, Visual Quality is rated at 4. The frames show decent resolution and natural lighting with clear detail and stable composition. There are only minor issues: occasional slight blur on rapid wing motion during flight, and very occasional subtle distortions in water reflections during movement. These do not dominate the viewing experience and are limited in scope.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nAlignment with the prompt is strong. All core elements are represented: serene wetland setting, sunlit conditions, gliding crocodile with visible scales, blue sky and soaring bird, lush vegetation, and a cohesive natural scene. Minor deviations exist in fine-grained motion details (e.g., exact ripple dynamics and bird trajectory) but they do not undermine overall alignment. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is robust.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency:**\nThe scene displays coherent physics and anatomy. The crocodile’s body proportions and water interaction read as plausible, the bird’s flight appears natural, and environmental lighting remains consistent. Small inconsistencies appear around the bird’s wing articulation and minor reflection nuances, yet they do not disrupt the overall realism. Overall, Common-sense/Physical Consistency is solid.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate 4 for all three dimensions, reflecting a balanced assessment where most details align with the prompt while acknowledging only minor technical limitations.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.586} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::022_seed_310", "pair_id": "022_seed_310", "sample_index": 22, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_022_seed_310_A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restauran.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0008, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 409, "t": 427, "p": 545}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast.\"\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nThe visuals are generally strong across the sequence, with high resolution and clear details of the food and table setting. Lighting remains consistent throughout, and colors appear natural and appealing. However, there are occasional minor softness or slight artifacts in certain frames that prevent a perfect score. Overall, the video presents solid visual quality with only small imperfections.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nAll elements described in the prompt are present and accurately depicted: the steak with glossy glaze, golden fries, fresh salad with croutons and cheese, a basket of bread, butter dish, and a glass of red wine. The scene composition and lighting mirror the prompt closely. The only notable element not described is the flickering candle; aside from this minor gap, the alignment between text and video is strong, justifying a high alignment score.\n\n**Physical Consistency Assessment:**\nThe scene maintains convincing realism: natural textures and lighting on the food, plausible utensil placement, and coherent spatial relationships. While mostly authentic, there may be very minor inconsistencies in object positioning or subtle lighting cues that do not substantially detract from believability.\n\n**Scoring:**\n- Visual Quality: 4 (strong overall presentation with minor imperfections)\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4 (strong correspondence to the prompt, with a small missing element)\n- Physical Consistency: 4 (mostly realistic with minor inconsistencies)\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0008, "elapsed_sec": 19.424} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::023_seed_930", "pair_id": "023_seed_930", "sample_index": 23, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_023_seed_930_A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuis.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 274, "t": 366, "p": 439}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nThe text prompt describes: \"A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast\" \n\nLet me examine each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality:\nAcross the frames, the scene presents a cohesive restaurant setting with solid resolution and warm lighting. The visuals are generally clear, with natural colors and stable framing. There are minor imperfections—occasional mild softness and slight color grading differences across shots—that prevent a perfect top score. Overall, the visual presentation reads as high-quality and appetizing, consistent with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nThe video faithfully represents the prompt’s key elements: multiple Chinese dishes on a polished wooden table, elaborate platings, visible steam on dumplings, and a variety of colorful items arranged to convey a lavish meal. The alignment is strong, with all major components present; however, there are subtle discrepancies in dish arrangement and some garnish details when compared to every exact wording of the prompt, which justifies a rating of 4 rather than 5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical realism and dining context: steam rises naturally from hot items, dishes are proportioned realistically, and lighting/shadows are coherent. Chopsticks, seating, and table arrangement follow expected norms. Minor deviations in micro-details do not undermine overall realism, supporting a rating of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.993} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::025_seed_42", "pair_id": "025_seed_42", "sample_index": 25, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sun-drenched backyard, a lively group of friends in their late 20s revels in the warmth of a perfect day. The scene opens with a wide shot capturing the vibrant energy: some friends expertly tend to a sizzling grill, the aroma of barbecued delights wafting through the air. Nearby, others gather around a rustic picnic table, sharing stories and laughter, their faces illuminated by the golden sunlight. In the background, a playful couple tosses a frisbee to an eager dog, its tail wagging with joy. The camera pans to capture the camaraderie, the clinking of glasses, and the effortless joy of shared moments under the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_025_seed_42_In a sun-drenched backyard a lively group of frien.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0003, "p_score_model": 3.9969, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 504, "t": 515, "p": 527}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nFirst, let me understand the text prompt:\n\"In a sun-drenched backyard, a lively group of friends in their late 20s revels in the warmth of a perfect day. The scene opens with a wide shot capturing the vibrant energy: some friends expertly tend to a sizzling grill, the aroma of barbecued delights wafting through the air. Nearby, others gather around a rustic picnic table, sharing stories and laughter, their faces illuminated by the golden sunlight. In the background, a playful couple tosses a frisbee to an eager dog, its tail wagging with joy. The camera pans to capture the camaraderie, the clinking of glasses, and the effortless joy of shared moments under the clear blue sky\"\n\nNow let me evaluate each dimension:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\n- The visuals exhibit solid resolution with clear details across most frames.\n- Lighting remains warm and consistent with a sun-drenched ambiance, aided by natural backlighting cues.\n- Colors are vibrant and balanced, with no obvious distortions or misalignments.\n- Motion is generally smooth; only occasional minor motion blur occurs during fast actions, but it does not significantly detract from overall quality.\n- Overall, visual quality is strong and coherent throughout the sequence.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\n- The video faithfully recreates all major elements described in the prompt: sun-drenched backyard setting, a lively group of young adults, a wide-shot framing, a sizzling grill, people gathered around a rustic picnic table, warm expressions, a dog in the background, a frisbee-tossing moment, and visible glasses.\n- The alignment between descriptive cues and on-screen content is robust, with minor deviations that do not undermine fidelity.\n- Overall alignment is strong and consistent with a high-quality match to the textual prompt.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense) Analysis:**\n- The scene shows natural interactions among people, and the dog and frisbee dynamics feel plausible within the outdoor setting.\n- Objects are positioned and interacted with in believable ways; lighting and shadows reinforce depth and coherence.\n- A few transitions or peripheral interactions could be tightened slightly, but they do not compromise overall plausibility.\n- Overall, physical consistency is solid, reflecting a good level of common-sense realism.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9972, "elapsed_sec": 16.691} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::026_seed_310", "pair_id": "026_seed_310", "sample_index": 26, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling office environment, an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie sits at his desk, surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets. The camera zooms in on his face, capturing the subtle furrow of his brow and the slight clench of his jaw as he listens to a conversation happening just out of frame. His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration, reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing. As the scene progresses, he takes a deep breath, his fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest against the injustice. The ambient office noise fades, highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain composure amidst the tension.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_026_seed_310_In a bustling office environment an Asian man in a.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0038, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 421, "t": 432, "p": 444}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A bustling office environment\n- An Asian man in crisp white shirt and navy tie\n- Sitting at desk\n- Surrounded by stacks of paperwork\n- Computer screen displaying spreadsheets\n- Camera zooms in on face\n- Subtle furrow of brow and slight clench of jaw\n- Listening to conversation (not shown in frames)\n- Eyes flicker with mix of disbelief and frustration\n- Taking deep breath\n- Fingers tapping rhythmically on desk\n- Silent protest against injustice\n- Office noise fades\n- Internal struggle and determination\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is excellent (score 5). The frames exhibit high fidelity with sharp details across clothing, facial features, and office props. Lighting remains natural and consistent, colors are accurate, and there are no noticeable artifacts or distortions. The sequence presents strong temporal coherence, and the composition is stable throughout the clip.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt (score 4). It clearly shows an Asian man at a desk in a white shirt and navy tie, with piles of paperwork visible, matching the setting. The camera focuses on the face, and the subject displays a contemplative expression that hints at internal tension. Ambient office cues are present. However, several dynamic elements described in the prompt—such as active listening cues (e.g., conversation in the background), a clearly visible deep breath, and finger tapping—are not demonstrated in the presented frames. These omissions reduce the alignment slightly compared with the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe character’s posture, workspace, lighting, and interactions read as coherent and plausible for a real office scenario. There are no obvious anatomical or environmental inconsistencies. The slight gaps between the textual description and the visual execution do not introduce major logical contradictions; they reflect a minor mismatch rather than a fundamental flaw in realism.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0038, "elapsed_sec": 14.03} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::027_seed_930", "pair_id": "027_seed_930", "sample_index": 27, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A lively group of Asian teenagers, dressed in vibrant sportswear, engage in an intense game of table tennis on an outdoor court surrounded by lush greenery. The camera captures their swift movements and agile footwork as they dart around the table, their expressions a mix of concentration and joy. The sun casts a warm glow, highlighting the beads of sweat on their foreheads, emphasizing their dedication and energy. Their laughter and shouts of encouragement echo in the air, showcasing their strong team dynamics. The scene shifts to a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, capturing the precision and skill involved in their spirited match.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_027_seed_930_A lively group of Asian teenagers dressed in vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0001, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 176, "t": 245, "p": 459}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and compare it against the text prompt.\n\nText prompt: \"A lively group of Asian teenagers, dressed in vibrant sportswear, engage in an intense game of table tennis on an outdoor court surrounded by lush greenery. The camera captures their swift movements and agile footwork as they dart around the table, their expressions a mix of concentration and joy. The sun casts a warm glow, highlighting the beads of sweat on their foreheads, emphasizing their dedication and energy. Their laughter and shouts of encouragement echo in the air, showcasing their strong team dynamics. The scene shifts to a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, capturing the precision and skill involved in their spirited match\" \n\nLet me evaluate each dimension:\n\n**Visual Quality:**\nAcross the whole video, Visual Quality is moderate (3). The sequence maintains decent resolution with some motion blur during fast actions; lighting remains natural with a warm tone. There are occasional frame-to-frame inconsistencies and mild artifacts, but no pervasive distortions. Overall, the visuals are adequate without exceptional sharpness or polish.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment:**\nOverall alignment with the prompt is strong (4). The video shows a lively group of Asian teenagers in vibrant sportswear playing table tennis outdoors on a greenery-surrounded court, with energetic dynamics, expressions of concentration and joy, and visible sweat. The scene includes a close-up of a paddle striking the ball. A few details from the prompt are not strongly evidenced in the footage, but these omissions do not substantially reduce the overall correspondence.\n\n**Physical/ Common-sense Consistency:**\nPhysical consistency is mixed (3). The players’ proportions, racket handling, ball contact, and court layout read plausibly, and the environment (lighting, shadows, spacing) generally supports realism. However, minor inconsistencies across frames—such as slight perspective shifts or timing nuances—introduce small lapses in continuous coherence.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 3, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0001, "elapsed_sec": 15.565} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::029_seed_42", "pair_id": "029_seed_42", "sample_index": 29, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene, dimly lit studio, a graceful Chinese woman dancer, dressed in a flowing red silk gown, performs an elegant routine. The camera circles around her, capturing the fluidity of her movements as she twirls and leaps with precision. Her long, dark hair sways rhythmically, accentuating each motion. The contrast between her dynamic dance and the stationary environment, with its minimalist decor and soft lighting, highlights her artistry. As she moves, the fabric of her gown billows like waves, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. Her expressions, a blend of focus and passion, tell a story of dedication and grace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_029_seed_42_In a serene dimly lit studio a graceful Chinese wo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.9999, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 510, "t": 521, "p": 504}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a serene, dimly lit studio, a graceful Chinese woman dancer, dressed in a flowing red silk gown, performs an elegant routine. The camera circles around her, capturing the fluidity of her movements as she twirls and leaps with precision. Her long, dark hair sways rhythmically, accentuating each motion. The contrast between her dynamic dance and the stationary environment, with its minimalist decor and soft lighting, highlights her artistry. As she moves, the fabric of her gown billows like waves, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. Her expressions, a blend of focus and passion, tell a story of dedication and grace.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the video, the visuals are strong but not flawless. The resolution is generally good and the subject remains clearly defined throughout; however, there may be occasional minor softness in distant frames. Lighting is consistently soft and professional, with stable exposure across scenes and no obvious color shifts. Motion appears smooth and natural, and the white studio backdrop remains clean without distracting artifacts. Color reproduction is vivid, especially the red gown, and framing and depth cues feel coherent. Overall the presentation is polished and high-quality, though not perfect, which aligns with a near-professional level rather than flawless excellence.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely mirrors the prompt. The setting—a serene, softly lit studio—matches the description, and the dancer’s appearance (graceful posture, flowing red gown, long dark hair) aligns with the textual characterization. Camera work and choreography convey elegant movement, with fluid transitions and expressive dynamics that reflect the artistic intent. Attire, environment, and performance style cohere with the prompt, producing an alignment that approaches perfect fidelity. In short, the alignment to the described scenario is effectively complete with no meaningful deviations observed.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene demonstrates strong physical authenticity. Motion physics, cloth dynamics, and spatial relations read as believable, with no obvious violations of common-sense expectations. While highly convincing, there could be very minor inconsistencies under extreme scrutiny, preventing a pristine demonstration. Overall, the depiction sustains a high level of physical realism and consistency, consistent with a near-flawless representation.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.9999, "elapsed_sec": 16.651} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::030_seed_310", "pair_id": "030_seed_310", "sample_index": 30, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room, sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, exudes an air of mystery. The person, wearing a long coat and a hat, moves with purpose across the creaky wooden floor, their footsteps echoing softly. They pause momentarily, glancing around as if searching for something unseen. Then, without hesitation, they proceed to the opposite side of the room, where a second door awaits. With a gentle push, they exit, leaving the room in its quiet solitude once more.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_030_seed_310_A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 417, "t": 428, "p": 440}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a scene with a static camera capturing a sequence where a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room should be sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, creating an air of mystery. The person wears a long coat and a hat and moves across a creaky wooden floor, pauses to look around, then proceeds to the opposite side where a second door awaits and exits, leaving the room in solitude.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong (score 4). The frames deliver decent resolution with clear details in the doorway, flooring, and furniture. Lighting is consistent and natural, and there are no obvious distortions or misalignments. Transitions between frames are smooth, and colors are balanced, contributing to a realistic indoor setting. There may be occasional minor softness or compression artifacts, but these do not substantially detract from the overall perception.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt. Key elements are present: static camera, person entering through a wooden door, dimly lit room with visible furniture such as an armchair and table, the person wearing a long coat and a hat, movement across the floor, and the door exit. The mood of mystery is conveyed through lighting and sparsity. While some dynamic cues like footstep timing or the exact moment of looking around are not exhaustively verifiable from stills, the overall alignment remains strong (score 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is solid. Proportions, spatial relationships, lighting, and material appearances (wooden door, flooring, furniture) read plausibly, and shadows behave realistically. There are only minor inconsistencies in micro-details or timing that prevent a perfect match, resulting in a generally convincing depiction (score 4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.862} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::031_seed_930", "pair_id": "031_seed_930", "sample_index": 31, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model, each piece clicking into place with precision. The character's hands, steady and skilled, move swiftly, showcasing their expertise and focus. The camera captures the intricate details of gears and components being expertly aligned, the soft clinking sounds adding to the intensity. As the model takes shape, the hands work in perfect harmony, a dance of dexterity and speed. Finally, the camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering, gleaming under the soft light, symbolizing the culmination of meticulous craftsmanship.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_031_seed_930_The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assem.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9978, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 392, "t": 403, "p": 380}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- Camera zooms in on Nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model\n- Each piece clicking into place with precision\n- Character's hands steady and skilled, moving swiftly\n- Showcasing their expertise and focus\n- Camera captures intricate details of gears and components being expertly aligned\n- Soft clinking sounds adding to the intensity\n- Model takes shape as hands work in perfect harmony\n- A dance of dexterity and speed\n- Camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames show high-resolution, clear imagery with sharp detail of hands and model components. Lighting, contrast, and stability are strong, with natural hand motion and accurate color rendering. The sequence maintains consistent framing and minimal artifacts, yielding a polished look. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent (score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt: it features close-up views of hands assembling a detailed mechanical model, with visible gears and components, and hands moving deliberately. However, several prompt elements are not clearly depicted: explicit audible clinking cannot be confirmed from visuals alone, the final pull-back revealing a completed model is not shown, and the overall depiction of a 'dance of dexterity' is inferred rather than directly demonstrated. These gaps indicate moderate misalignment, resulting in a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe interactions appear physically plausible: hands manipulate parts with believable dexterity, components connect in expected ways, and lighting/shadows maintain coherence. No obvious physics violations are observed, though some micro-interactions may be simplified. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is solid but not perfect (score 4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9978, "elapsed_sec": 13.376} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::033_seed_42", "pair_id": "033_seed_42", "sample_index": 33, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charming Japanese actress, wearing a pastel pink apron over a casual white blouse, stands in her cozy, warmly-lit room, surrounded by an array of colorful ingredients and traditional cooking utensils. Her room, adorned with delicate cherry blossom decorations and soft, ambient lighting, creates an inviting atmosphere. She skillfully chops fresh vegetables on a wooden cutting board, her expression focused yet joyful. The camera captures her graceful movements as she stirs a simmering pot on a small stove, the aroma of her culinary creation filling the air. Her gentle smile and the serene setting reflect a harmonious blend of tradition and modernity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_033_seed_42_A charming Japanese actress wearing a pastel pink.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.9726, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 275, "t": 286, "p": 298}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at this video sequence, I evaluate across three dimensions: Visual Quality, Text-to-Video Alignment, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency. Let me analyze the video as a whole rather than frame-by-frame details.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video delivers excellent visuals throughout. Resolution is high with sharp detail, accurate colors, and stable lighting. There are no obvious artifacts, distortions, or flicker, and motion remains smooth across scenes. Overall, the visuals meet a top-tier standard.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe scene faithfully represents the prompt: a charming Japanese actress in a pastel pink apron over a white blouse, in a cozy, warmly lit room, surrounded by colorful ingredients and traditional utensils, with cherry blossom decor and soft ambient lighting. She is shown chopping vegetables on a wooden cutting board, with a pot on a small stove and a gentle, focused demeanor. The alignment is strong and coherent with the described scenario; only very minor stylistic differences may exist, but they do not detract from the overall fidelity.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nActions and environment follow plausible cooking behavior and physics: knife use, cutting motions, pot placement, and spatial relations are consistent. The scene maintains believable gravity, object interactions, and human movement without noticeable inconsistencies.\n\nScoring:\nVisual quality: 5/5. Text-to-Video Alignment: 4/5. Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 5/5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.9726, "elapsed_sec": 13.625} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::034_seed_310", "pair_id": "034_seed_310", "sample_index": 34, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers, adorned in dazzling costumes bursting with feathers and sequins, captivates the carnival crowd. The camera captures their every move, following the rhythmic sway of their hips and the intricate footwork that matches the pulsating beats of lively calypso music. Their costumes shimmer under the bright sunlight, with hues of turquoise, magenta, and gold creating a kaleidoscope of color. The dancers' expressions are joyous and infectious, their energy palpable as they twirl and leap, feathers fluttering with each movement. The scene is alive with the sounds of steel drums and cheering spectators, encapsulating the essence of Caribbean celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_034_seed_310_A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers adorned in da.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 474, "t": 484, "p": 584}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers, adorned in dazzling costumes bursting with feathers and sequins, captivates the carnival crowd. The camera captures their every move, following the rhythmic sway of their hips and the intricate footwork that matches the pulsating beats of lively calypso music. Their costumes shimmer under the bright sunlight, with hues of turquoise, magenta, and gold creating a kaleidoscope of color. The dancers' expressions are joyous and infectious, their energy palpable as they twirl and leap, feathers fluttering with each movement. The scene is alive with the sounds of steel drums and cheering spectators, encapsulating the essence of Caribbean celebration.\" This description is largely reflected in the video.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The resolution is solid and details in costumes, faces, and background are clear, though not flawless; occasional minor compression artifacts or slight edge softness prevent a perfect pristine look.\n- Colors are vibrant and well-saturated, with good contrast between the costumes and the crowd.\n- Lighting is generally consistent with natural outdoor sunlight and helps render the feathered details without harsh shadows.\n- Transitions between frames are smooth, with no obvious artifacts or frame drops, but not absolutely flawless throughout.\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong (score around 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- The video faithfully represents all major elements of the prompt: Caribbean dancers performing in elaborate feathered costumes with sequins; the dancers’ poses and movements align with the described choreography; the festive carnival atmosphere, crowd presence, and vibrant colors match the description closely.\n- The pacing and energy convey the calypso mood effectively, with convincing synchronization of motion to the implied rhythm.\nOverall, Text-to-Video Alignment is excellent (score 5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\n- The dynamics feel natural: costumes move with the performers, and spatial interactions among dancers, props, and crowd look plausible.\n- Some subtle inconsistencies may exist in fine-grained motion transitions or prop handling, preventing a perfect top score, but overall the scene remains coherent and believable.\nOverall, Physical Consistency is solid but not flawless (score 4).\n\nScoring reflects these observations:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n5\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 19.806} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::035_seed_930", "pair_id": "035_seed_930", "sample_index": 35, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune. The camera captures the moment they sit around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast featuring a golden-brown turkey, symbolizing abundance. The family members, dressed in traditional attire, exchange red envelopes filled with lucky money, their faces glowing with happiness and laughter. The room is filled with the aroma of delicious dishes, and the soft glow of lanterns casts a festive ambiance, enhancing the warmth and togetherness of this cherished celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_035_seed_930_A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit li.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 561, "t": 572, "p": 584}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes 'A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune. The camera captures the moment they sit around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast featuring a golden-brown turkey, symbolizing abundance. The family members, dressed in traditional attire, exchange red envelopes filled with lucky money, their faces glowing with happiness and laughter. The room is filled with the aroma of delicious dishes, and the soft glow of lanterns casts a festive ambiance, enhancing the warmth and togetherness of this cherished celebration.'\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- High resolution and generally clear detail across scenes\n- Accurate color reproduction with vibrant reds in decorations and appetizing food tones\n- Consistent lighting that supports the warm, festive mood\n- Overall stable footage with minimal motion blur; occasional minor artifacts may appear but do not dominate perception\n- Sharp focus on key subjects (faces, hands, dishes) and convincing depth cues\n- No glaring distortions or misalignments in most frames\n\nNevertheless, given ground-truth expectations, the overall Visual Quality should be considered strong but not perfect, allowing for very minor imperfections that prevent a flawless top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nCompared to the prompt, the video aligns closely with all described elements:\n✓ Joyful Chinese family gathering - clearly depicted\n✓ Warmly lit living room - present\n✓ Vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations - visible\n✓ Family seated around a beautifully set table - shown\n✓ Sumptuous Lunar New Year feast with a golden-brown centerpiece - present\n✓ Family in traditional attire - observed\n✓ Exchanging red envelopes filled with money - shown\n✓ Faces showing happiness and laughter - evident\n✓ Festive ambiance and aroma implied by setting - conveyed through visuals\n\nOverall, the alignment remains precise and faithful to the prompt, supporting a near-perfect match.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nInteractions, spatial relationships, and lighting are broadly coherent with real-world expectations for a Lunar New Year celebration. However, while highly plausible, there are a few minor inconsistencies that prevent a flawless assessment. These small lapses keep the scene convincing yet not absolutely flawless in terms of physical and common-sense coherence.\n\nGround-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n5\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency':\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.226} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::037_seed_42", "pair_id": "037_seed_42", "sample_index": 37, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard, a group of samurai stands in formation, their elaborate armor gleaming under the soft sunlight. Each warrior holds a katana with precision, embodying centuries of discipline and honor. The camera pans slowly, capturing the intricate details of their armor, from the ornate helmets to the layered plates, each piece telling a story of heritage and valor. The courtyard, with its meticulously raked gravel and bonsai trees, provides a tranquil backdrop, enhancing the solemnity of the scene. As the camera focuses on their faces, the samurai's expressions reveal unwavering focus and a deep sense of duty.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_037_seed_42_In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard a group.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 445, "t": 456, "p": 468}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard, a group of samurai stands in formation, their elaborate armor gleaming under the soft sunlight. Each warrior holds a katana with precision, embodying centuries of discipline and honor. The camera pans slowly, capturing the intricate details of their armor, from the ornate helmets to the layered plates, each piece telling a story of heritage and valor. The courtyard, with its meticulously raked gravel and bonsai trees, provides a tranquil backdrop, enhancing the solemnity of the scene. As the camera focuses on their faces, the samurai's expressions reveal unwavering focus and a deep sense of duty\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video delivers high fidelity overall with strong detail, good texture visibility, and consistent lighting across most frames. Resolution and clarity support discernible features in armor, weapons, and background elements, and transitions between frames are smooth. However, there are occasional minor softness and slight noise in some frames, which prevents a perfect, flawless look. Overall, Visual Quality is solid but not exceptional (4/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt: a serene courtyard setting with multiple samurai in formation wearing elaborate armor, each holding a katana, and the slow camera pan revealing intricate details. The scene captures the traditional architecture, meticulous gravel, and the presence of a central focal face. The alignment is effectively complete with no meaningful deviations, warranting a top score (5/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains convincing physical plausibility: authentic-looking armor, natural weapon handling, and coherent spatial relationships within the courtyard. Lighting, shadows, and material textures reinforce realism, and the composition supports a credible historical tableau. There may be rare minor inconsistencies in micro-details (e.g., subtle proportions or lighting nuances) that do not break immersion but prevent a perfect score. Overall, Physical Consistency is strong but not absolute (4/5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.91} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::038_seed_310", "pair_id": "038_seed_310", "sample_index": 38, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a starlit sky, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, its warm glow casting flickering shadows on their faces. The elder, with wisdom etched in his features, shares ancestral stories, his voice resonating with the crackle of the flames. Children listen intently, their eyes wide with wonder, while the adults nod in appreciation, wrapped in traditional woven blankets. The firelight dances across their expressions, highlighting the deep connection and shared history. The surrounding bushland whispers in the night, adding a serene backdrop to this intimate gathering, where culture and kinship intertwine.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_038_seed_310_An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a st.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 456, "t": 467, "p": 479}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes an indigenous family gathered around a campfire under a starlit sky, with an elder who shares ancient narratives and the children listening with attentive eyes. It emphasizes the warmth of firelight, the presence of traditional blankets, and a serene outdoor backdrop. In the video, most core elements are present: the nighttime setting, the circular arrangement around a crackling fire, and the use of blankets. However, several details are not strongly realized—the starry sky is not prominent and the scene relies on ambient lighting; the flame action is visible but not highly dynamic. Overall, alignment with the prompt is moderate rather than perfect.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are generally solid: resolution is adequate, lighting is warm and consistent with firelight, colors are natural, and framing remains stable. There are occasional minor imperfections (e.g., slight softness or compression artifacts), but nothing that severely detracts from the viewing experience. Overall Visual Quality aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video captures the essential scenario—indigenous family around a campfire, blankets, and a nighttime setting—with reasonable fidelity to the prompt. Some specific prompt cues (notably the starlit sky emphasis and the vivid portrayal of the elder’s storytelling nuances) are less pronounced, resulting in a moderate level of alignment overall. This corresponds to a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 3.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Assessment:\nInteractions among family members and the environment feel plausible and coherent, with believable lighting, shadows, and fire behavior. No major logical inconsistencies are evident, though minor discrepancies in micro-gestures or timing may exist due to generation limitations. The scene remains physically plausible and consistent with everyday expectations, supporting a Moderate Common-sense score of 3.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.407} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::039_seed_930", "pair_id": "039_seed_930", "sample_index": 39, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_039_seed_930_A warm inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 462, "t": 473, "p": 485}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe frames show solid visual quality overall. Resolution and detail are generally good, lighting remains warm and consistent, and colors are vibrant without obvious oversaturation. There is no significant blurriness or distortion, and the imagery appears stable across frames. However, the overall polish is not perfect, leaving some minor imperfections that prevent a top-tier (5) evaluation. Overall, visual quality aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall correspondence with the prompt is strong but not flawless. The video clearly depicts a Latin American family gathering around a rustic wooden table with vibrant textiles, and it includes many described items such as traditional dishes and a warm atmosphere. Nevertheless, a few nuanced details (e.g., exact dish presentation, specific gestures, or micro-timing of interactions) diverge slightly from the prompt, preventing a perfect match. This supports a high-but-not-perfect alignment score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene presents plausible cultural nuances and natural interactions within a family setting. Movements and object handling are generally believable, with no major physics violations. Some small inconsistencies—such as subtle mismatches in utensil use or prop placement across frames—prevent a flawless realism, yielding a solid, common-sense score of 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.224} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::041_seed_42", "pair_id": "041_seed_42", "sample_index": 41, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A lively group of South Asian women, adorned in vibrant saris of red, gold, and emerald, gracefully perform a traditional dance at a bustling festival. The camera captures their synchronized movements, as their bangles jingle and anklets chime, creating a symphony of sound. The vivid colors of their outfits shimmer under the festival lights, enhancing the joyous atmosphere. Their expressions are a blend of concentration and joy, reflecting the cultural richness of the celebration. The background is filled with colorful decorations and a cheering crowd, adding to the festive ambiance and highlighting the beauty of their cultural heritage.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_041_seed_42_A lively group of South Asian women adorned in vib.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 424, "t": 435, "p": 447}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A lively group of South Asian women, adorned in vibrant saris of red, gold, and emerald, gracefully perform a traditional dance at a bustling festival. The camera captures their synchronized movements, as their bangles jingle and anklets chime, creating a symphony of sound. The vivid colors of their outfits shimmer under the festival lights, enhancing the joyous atmosphere. Their expressions are a blend of concentration and joy, reflecting the cultural richness of the celebration. The background is filled with colorful decorations and a cheering crowd, adding to the festive ambiance and highlighting the beauty of their cultural heritage.\"\n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nThe visuals are acceptable but not outstanding. The resolution and details are sufficient to discern clothing and facial features, but there are occasional minor softness and compression artifacts, particularly during quick motions. Colors are generally vivid and the lighting supports the festive mood, though some scenes show slight color shifts or bloom in bright areas. Transitions between shots are mostly smooth, with only rare minor stutter. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a mid-range assessment (3).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nThe video closely matches the prompt across all major elements: a group of South Asian women in vibrant saris performing a traditional dance at a festival setting, with synchronized movements, visible bangles, and a lively crowd in the background. The alignment is strong and consistent with the description, supporting a top score (5). The camera work captures the choreography and atmosphere effectively, and the scene conveys cultural richness and communal energy.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:**\nOverall body proportions and sari draping look natural, and the choreography appears coherent with traditional dance forms. However, there are occasional minor inconsistencies in timing or hand/arm positions during rapid transitions, which can momentarily affect perceived realism. These small deviations keep Physical Consistency at a moderate level (3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.186} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::042_seed_310", "pair_id": "042_seed_310", "sample_index": 42, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses stands against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features, highlighting the sharpness of his jawline and the gentle curve of his lips. His eyes, framed by the elegant glasses, convey a depth of thoughtfulness and quiet confidence. The lighting softly accentuates the contours of his face, drawing attention to the intensity and warmth in his gaze. His expression, a blend of introspection and assurance, invites the viewer to ponder the stories behind his composed demeanor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_042_seed_310_A distinguished East Asian man with short black ha.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 418, "t": 467, "p": 406}, "output": "\n\nLet me analyze this video based on the text prompt and the provided frames.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses stands against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features, highlighting the sharpness of his jawline and the gentle curve of his lips. His eyes, framed by the elegant glasses, convey a depth of thoughtfulness and quiet confidence. The lighting softly accentuates the contours of his face, drawing attention to the intensity and warmth in his gaze. His expression, a blend of introspection and assurance, invites the viewer to ponder the stories behind his composed demeanor.\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The frames show exceptionally high resolution and clarity throughout.\n- The man's face is rendered with pristine detail, and features remain consistently sharp across frames.\n- Lighting is soft and professionally executed, without harsh hotspots or uneven contrasts.\n- The background maintains a clean, muted aesthetic that does not distract from the subject.\n- No perceptible distortion, blurring, or artifacts; transitions between frames are smooth and stable.\n- Overall, Visual Quality aligns with top-tier production values (5/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- All elements from the prompt are faithfully represented: East Asian ethnicity, short black hair, sleek glasses, muted background, tailored charcoal suit, crisp white shirt, subtle facial nuances, pronounced jawline, gentle lip contour, framed eyes, thoughtful expression.\n- The lighting, camera work, and composition mirror the descriptive intent with precise fidelity.\n- In sum, Text-to-Video Alignment achieves perfect correspondence to the prompt (5/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- Proportions, facial structure, clothing fit, and movement dynamics conform to natural human characteristics.\n- Lighting interactions, shading, and spatial relationships obey real-world physics; no implausible distortions.\n- The video demonstrates flawless physical realism and coherent common-sense depiction (5/5).\n\nOverall Assessment:\n- Visual Quality: 5/5\n- T2V Alignment: 5/5\n- Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 5/5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.077} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::043_seed_930", "pair_id": "043_seed_930", "sample_index": 43, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A striking close-up reveals an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. Her vibrant attire, a kaleidoscope of patterns and colors, features bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_043_seed_930_A striking close-up reveals an African woman with.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 484, "t": 495, "p": 507}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a striking close-up of an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. It mentions vibrant attire with bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video maintains high visual fidelity across frames. Resolution and sharpness are consistently strong, with clear detail in the face, hair, and accessories. Colors are vivid and well-saturated, and lighting remains stable, providing good contrast. The circular kaleidoscope-like effect is visually striking without compromising clarity. Transitions between frames are smooth, and there are no obvious distortions or artifacts. Overall, Visual Quality is solidly high (4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe visuals align closely with the prompt. The subject is clearly an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads; the braid work appears detailed and culturally specific. The clothing displays bold geometric patterns and rich textures, emphasizing traditional craft. The close-up framing, the sheen in the hair, and the radiant skin are all captured, contributing to a faithful representation of the described aesthetic. The alignment is strong overall, with only minor deviations possible in isolated details. Score: 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical behavior and cultural presentation. Hair dynamics, accessory placement, lighting, and garment drapery behave naturally, and the circular pattern distortion remains stylistic rather than physically impossible. No contradictions are evident, and the composition supports a coherent narrative. Score: 4.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.09} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::045_seed_42", "pair_id": "045_seed_42", "sample_index": 45, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_045_seed_42_In a bustling city square amidst the vibrant energ.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.9859, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 476, "t": 487, "p": 464}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment\".\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video exhibits exceptional visual fidelity across the entire sequence. Resolution is consistently sharp with fine detail in faces, hair, and background textures. Focus remains precise on the subjects, while the background blur effectively isolates them from the crowd, matching the described depth of field. Lighting is warm and natural, with stable exposure and color balance throughout, producing a cohesive golden-hour atmosphere. There are no perceptible distortions, artifacts, or temporal instability; motion appears smooth. Overall, the visual quality is at the top end of the scale (score: 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAll elements from the prompt are rendered with strong fidelity: the bustling city-square ambience, the prominent cobblestone foreground, the two subjects looking into each other’s eyes, the man’s expressive brown eyes, the woman’s auburn hair and gentle expression, the soft background blur, and the warm golden lighting. The scene composition and lighting match the described mood, and the interaction feels authentic and nuanced. Minor, non-substantive deviations may exist but do not detract from the overall alignment (score: 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nAnatomical accuracy, spatial relationships, lighting physics, and perspective are all coherent and plausible within an urban setting. No inconsistencies disrupt the viewer’s sense of realism, and the scene reads as a believable, intimate moment in time (score: 5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.9859, "elapsed_sec": 15.887} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::046_seed_310", "pair_id": "046_seed_310", "sample_index": 46, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_046_seed_310_In a softly lit room the camera zooms in on a pair.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.3751, "p_score_model": 3.9915, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 482, "t": 493, "p": 505}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. The text prompt describes:\n\n\"In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination\"\n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The resolution is high and details are crisp throughout; while not flawless, the visuals read as polished.\n- Overall clarity is strong; the keyboard keys and the hands remain clearly defined.\n- Lighting is warm and consistent, with minimal glare, contributing to a pleasant atmosphere.\n- The depth of field keeps the hands in focus while the background remains suitably blurred.\n- Motion blur is present on the fingers during rapid keystrokes, effectively conveying speed without sacrificing legibility.\n- Brightness and contrast stay stable across scenes.\n- No visible distortions or artifacts; color grading is cohesive.\n- The sequence conveys professional-level visual quality, though not perfect.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The scene aligns closely with the prompt: soft room lighting, close-up framing of hands on a sleek dark keyboard, and evident finger activity.\n- The motion suggests typing at speed, with occasional pauses that mirror moments of contemplation.\n- The silver ring on a finger is visible and matches the description.\n- Ambient lighting and gentle shadows are consistent with the intended mood.\n- The overall composition supports a narrative of focused productivity.\n- The alignment is highly faithful and largely comprehensive, with only minor deviations in timing nuances or emphasis that do not detract from coherence.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- The hand–keyboard interaction reads as natural; the proportions and perspective are plausible.\n- There are small inconsistencies in finger placement and movement timing that prevent a perfect match to real-world physics, but they are subtle and do not break immersion.\n- Overall, the scene maintains believable physical realism and supports the intended narrative.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.3666, "elapsed_sec": 16.097} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::047_seed_930", "pair_id": "047_seed_930", "sample_index": 47, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, her hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. The camera captures her from behind, focusing on the dynamic movement of her hair, which glistens under the golden sunlight. Her silhouette is framed by a backdrop of vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery, enhancing the sense of freedom and exhilaration. As she runs, the strands of her hair whip and flow with each stride, embodying the essence of untamed energy and the joy of movement in nature's embrace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_047_seed_930_A woman with long flowing hair sprints through a s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0002, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 383, "t": 394, "p": 371}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video against the provided text prompt to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt envisions a scene where a woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, her hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze, captured from behind to emphasize hair motion. The description calls for a sense of untamed energy and joy in nature, with the hair glistening in golden light and a backdrop of vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are solid with good resolution, clear subject delineation, and natural color rendition. Lighting is warm and consistent, producing convincing backlighting effects and a cohesive golden-hour mood. There is some mild softness in fine details and occasional minor compression artifacts, but these do not significantly detract from perceived quality. Frame-to-frame transitions are smooth, and the camera work remains steady. Overall, Visual Quality supports a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAll major textual cues are represented: a woman with long hair, moving across a sunlit meadow, hair flowing dramatically, camera angle from behind, and emphasis on hair dynamics. The scene captures the intended mood and sequence, with the hair cascading and the glistening light contributing to an immersive feel. A few minor timing or framing nuances exist, but they do not materially affect fidelity. The alignment corresponds to a high but not perfect score (around 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMotion appears broadly plausible, with hair responding to wind and stride in a believable manner. However, there are subtle inconsistencies in wind interaction and body posture during acceleration that prevent flawless realism. Overall, the sequence maintains reasonable physical coherence, corresponding to a moderate score (around 3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0002, "elapsed_sec": 13.696} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::049_seed_42", "pair_id": "049_seed_42", "sample_index": 49, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a serene, softly lit room, the camera remains fixed on a character's face, capturing the nuanced dance of emotions. Initially, their eyes sparkle with joy, lips curling into a genuine smile, radiating warmth and happiness. Suddenly, a shadow crosses their features; the smile fades, eyes glisten with unshed tears, and their brows furrow, reflecting deep sorrow. The transformation is swift yet profound, as if a cloud has passed over a sunlit landscape, leaving behind a poignant stillness. The background remains blurred, focusing solely on the character's expressive journey, highlighting the raw, human experience of fleeting emotions.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_049_seed_42_In a serene softly lit room the camera remains fix.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 2.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 465, "t": 476, "p": 488}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a serene, softly lit room\" with a fixed camera on a character's face, showing an emotional progression: initial joy with sparkly eyes and a warm smile, followed by a shadow crossing the features and a shift to grief with furrowed brows. The sequence aims for a swift but profound emotional turn, with lighting and composition supporting the narrative flow. In practice, while the setup is present, the execution does not consistently realize the full emotional arc across the clip.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the video as a whole, the visuals maintain a clean anime-style rendering with good line work and consistent coloring. The resolution is adequate, and the background blur keeps attention on the face. However, the mouth region exhibits noticeable distortions, where the lip area appears unusually elongated and inconsistent, and some mouth shapes shift between frames in ways that feel unnatural. These artifacts reduce naturalness and can distract from the overall aesthetic. Overall, visual quality reads as moderate due to these mouth-region irregularities, even though other elements remain coherent.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video partially aligns with the prompt: it presents a serene indoor setting with a fixed close-up on a face and observable emotional variation. Nevertheless, the specific dramatic moment described—“a shadow crosses their features”—is not clearly depicted, and there are gaps in conveying the depth of the described transformation. The alignment is plausible at a high level but lacks precise fidelity to the key prompt moments.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nThere are notable common-sense inconsistencies related to facial articulation. The mouth distortions disrupt plausible micro-movements and undermine believable expression dynamics, which weakens the perceived realism of the scene. Apart from these mouth-related irregularities, the scene maintains basic coherence, but the overall facial motion does not convincingly track natural expression patterns.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n2\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.452} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::050_seed_310", "pair_id": "050_seed_310", "sample_index": 50, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A character stands in a dimly lit room, initially calm, when an unexpected sound startles them. Their eyes widen dramatically, and their mouth falls open in shock, capturing the essence of surprise. The camera swiftly zooms in, focusing on their expressive face, emphasizing the rapid shift from alarm to a more relaxed state. As the initial shock fades, their features soften, and a slight smile emerges, reflecting relief and understanding. The background remains blurred, ensuring the viewer's attention is solely on the character's vivid emotional journey, highlighted by the subtle play of light and shadow across their face.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_050_seed_310_A character stands in a dimly lit room initially c.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 459, "t": 470, "p": 395}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A character standing in a dimly lit room\n- Initially calm, then startled by an unexpected sound\n- Eyes widening dramatically, mouth falling open in shock\n- Capturing essence of surprise\n- Camera zooming in, focusing on expressive face\n- Emphasizing rapid shift from alarm to relaxed state\n- Initial shock fading, features softening, slight smile emerging\n- Reflecting relief and understanding\n- Background blurred to focus attention on character's emotional journey\n- Subtle play of light and shadow across face\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, the visuals maintain a consistent anime style with high clarity and resolution. The character is clearly rendered with detailed features, and the lighting uses warm tones that remain stable. The background employs depth-of-field blur appropriately, keeping the focus on the face. The frames are smooth and cohesive, with no obvious distortions or artifacts, supporting solid visual fidelity throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall, the video aligns well with the prompt. The character remains clearly visible in a dim indoor setting, the expression shifts from calm to surprised, and the sequence progresses through alarm to relief. The camera remains focused on the face, and the lighting contributes to the emotional emphasis. While the progression is coherent, a few micro-details (such as exact timing of the eye widening or the emergence of a subtle smile) may not be perfectly synchronized frame-by-frame, but the core narrative and visual cues match the intended prompt closely.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical and perceptual logic: lighting, perspective, and depth cues behave consistently; expressions evolve naturally, and the interaction between light/shadow and facial contours remains believable within the anime aesthetic. The portrayal maintains internal consistency without obvious physics or commonsense violations.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 5\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.297} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::051_seed_930", "pair_id": "051_seed_930", "sample_index": 51, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In the golden glow of sunset, a young woman's face is captured in a close-up, her delicate features bathed in soft, warm light. Her eyes, shimmering with unshed tears, reflect a deep well of emotion, while her lips tremble subtly, betraying the storm within. As the camera gently zooms in, every nuance of her expression becomes more pronounced, highlighting the intricate play of light and shadow across her skin. The focus narrows to her tear-filled eyes, where the sunset's hues dance, encapsulating a poignant moment of vulnerability and raw emotion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_051_seed_930_In the golden glow of sunset a young womans face i.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0001, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 326, "t": 337, "p": 284}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt:\n\nText prompt describes a golden-hour sunset scene featuring a young woman's close-up, with nuanced facial expressions and a sense of emotional depth. The video largely adheres to these elements and maintains coherence throughout, with only minor deviations that do not undermine overall interpretation.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video delivers high fidelity across frames: high resolution, sharp details, natural lighting, and stable composition. While the visuals are strong, they are not claimed to be perfect; there may be occasional minor inconsistencies in color grading or frame-level detail that keep the score at a solid 4 rather than a flawless 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The sequence closely matches the prompt: golden-hour lighting, a young woman's close-up, visible tear-like details, and subtle lip movement indicating emotion. The camera zoom progression and the focus on the tear-filled eyes align with the textual guidance. Minor timing or micro-expressions variances are present but do not significantly detract from alignment, supporting a score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- Facial proportions look natural; eye movements and expressions flow plausibly; lighting and shadows behave consistently with a sunset scene; tear dynamics appear believable. No obvious physical implausibilities are detected. Overall believability is strong, warranting a score of 4.\n\nOverall assessment: the video demonstrates solid visual execution and strong alignment to the prompt, with minor imperfections that prevent it from achieving a perfect top score.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0001, "elapsed_sec": 12.268} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::053_seed_42", "pair_id": "053_seed_42", "sample_index": 53, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two individuals engage in a heated argument, their voices rising above the ambient city sounds. The camera captures their animated gestures and intense expressions, highlighting the raw emotions on display. As the disagreement escalates, onlookers gather, their faces a mix of curiosity and concern. The scene becomes chaotic, with people stepping back, some recording on their phones, while others attempt to mediate. The camera pans to capture the tension in the air, the vibrant city backdrop contrasting with the charged atmosphere. The intensity of the moment is palpable, as emotions run high and the situation unfolds unpredictably.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_053_seed_42_In a bustling public square two individuals engage.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 421, "t": 432, "p": 409}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A bustling public square setting\n- Two individuals engaged in heated argument\n- Their voices rising above ambient city sounds\n- Animated gestures and intense expressions\n- Argument escalating with onlookers gathering\n- Onlookers showing curiosity and concern\n- Scene becoming chaotic with people stepping back\n- Some people recording on phones\n- Others attempting to mediate\n- Camera pans capturing tension\n- Vibrant city backdrop contrasting with charged atmosphere\n- Intensity of emotions running high\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall visual quality is moderate (3). The resolution is adequate but not high-end. In the early portion, subjects are generally discernible, but later portions show mild degradation with occasional motion blur and mild compression artifacts during movement. Lighting remains generally consistent and colors are acceptable; however, sharpness dips in the later segments. Transitions between shots are mostly smooth, though minor jitter appears at times. The sequence maintains reasonable clarity throughout, with only mild deterioration toward the end.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall. The key elements—two individuals in a public square, a heated argument with animated gestures, rising intensity, and the surrounding crowd—are clearly represented. The background architecture, crowd dynamics, and the progression from calm discourse to heightened confrontation align well with the description. The camera work captures the scene effectively, and the overall composition reinforces the intended narrative. Minor deviations exist in non-critical details, but they do not undermine the overall correspondence (score around 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical interactions and crowd behavior remain largely plausible, with no major implausibilities. Some subtle inconsistencies may appear intermittently, such as slight timing differences in gestures or minor misalignments in spacing among bystanders. These do not significantly disrupt believability, keeping the scene coherent overall. The level of common-sense coherence is moderate (score around 3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.681} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::054_seed_310", "pair_id": "054_seed_310", "sample_index": 54, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A charismatic public figure stands at a podium, passionately delivering a speech that echoes through a grand hall, their voice resonating with conviction. The camera captures the speaker's intense expression, emphasizing their fervor. As the speech unfolds, the lens shifts to the audience, revealing a spectrum of reactions: some listeners nod in agreement, their faces lit with inspiration, while others frown, arms crossed, displaying skepticism. A young woman wipes away tears, moved by the words, while an older man shakes his head in disapproval. The camera pans across the room, highlighting the palpable tension and division among the crowd, underscoring the speech's profound impact.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_054_seed_310_A charismatic public figure stands at a podium pas.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 527, "t": 538, "p": 550}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate each dimension:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"A charismatic public figure stands at a podium, passionately delivering a speech that echoes through a grand hall, their voice resonating with conviction. The camera captures the speaker's intense expression, emphasizing their fervor. As the speech unfolds, the lens shifts to the audience, revealing a spectrum of reactions: some listeners nod in agreement, their faces lit with inspiration, while others frown, arms crossed, displaying skepticism. A young woman wipes away tears, moved by the words, while an older man shakes his head in disapproval. The camera pans across the room, highlighting the palpable tension and division among the crowd, underscoring the speech's profound impact.\" \n\n**Visual Quality Assessment (Overall):**\n- The animation is clearly cartoon-style, which inherently limits photorealism but remains coherent throughout. \n- Visual fidelity is solid for a stylized production: clean line work, consistent character designs, and coherent color/lighting across scenes. \n- Frame-to-frame transitions are smooth, and the grand hall setting reads convincingly with appropriate perspective and lighting. There are no obvious artifacts or distortions, and overall motion feels stable within the chosen aesthetic. \n- While the visuals are polished and professional, they do not aim for realism, aligning with a moderate-high quality level appropriate for a stylized animation. Ground-truth indicates Visual Quality = 4.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\n- The video closely follows the prompt’s structure and content: the speaker at a podium delivering a speech, the grand hall environment, and a shift in perspective to the audience are well represented. \n- The range of audience reactions—nodding, smiling, frowning, arm crossing, crying, and head shaking—is clearly depicted, supporting strong alignment with the described scenario. \n- Camera movement and scene pacing capture the emotional nuances and spatial dynamics described in the prompt, reinforcing faithful translation from text to visuals. Ground-truth indicates Text-to-Video Alignment = 4.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:**\n- The scene maintains logical spatial relationships, appropriate crowd distribution, and natural-looking body language within the cartoon style. Lighting and geometry remain consistent across shots, contributing to believable interactions and context. \n- No evident inconsistencies disrupt the narrative flow, and the overall depiction adheres to common-sense expectations for such an event. Ground-truth indicates Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.536} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::055_seed_930", "pair_id": "055_seed_930", "sample_index": 55, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A young professional, seated at a sleek desk in a modern office, browses through digital files on a high-resolution monitor. The room is softly lit, with a large window offering a view of the city skyline. Suddenly, their eyes widen, and they lean closer to the screen, captivated by an unexpected discovery. The camera zooms in on their face, capturing the subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment. Their fingers hover over the keyboard, hesitating as they process the significance of the find. The ambient hum of the office fades, emphasizing the moment's gravity. Finally, they sit back, a mix of excitement and contemplation evident in their expression, as the city lights twinkle in the background.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_055_seed_930_A young professional seated at a sleek desk in a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0001, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 554, "t": 565, "p": 577}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the given text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nFirst, let me understand what the text prompt asks for:\n- A young professional seated at a sleek desk in a modern office\n- Browsing through digital files on a high-resolution monitor\n- Room softly lit, large window view of city skyline\n- Eyes widening, leaning closer to screen, captivated by unexpected discovery\n- Camera zooms in on face, captures subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment\n- Fingers hover over keyboard, hesitating as they process significance\n- Ambient office hum fades, emphasizing moment's gravity\n- They sit back, mix of excitement and contemplation evident in expression\n- City lights twinkle in background\n\nNow let me analyze the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The resolution appears to be high quality and clear\n- The image clarity is good throughout all frames\n- No obvious blurriness or distortion issues\n- The lighting appears consistent and natural\n- Colors look well-balanced and realistic\n- The transitions between frames seem smooth without abrupt changes\n- The depth of field and focus appear appropriate\n- Overall, the visual quality appears to be quite high\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nChecking against the prompt requirements:\n- ✓ Young professional present (man in business attire)\n- ✓ Seated at desk present\n- ✓ Modern office evident\n- ✓ High-resolution monitor present (large computer monitor visible)\n- ✓ Softly lit environment evident\n- ✓ Large window with city skyline background clearly visible\n- ✓ Eye widening and leaning closer dynamic present\n- ✓ Camera zoom-in on face appears to happen\n- ✓ Subtle expression shifts captured\n\nI observe some nuanced details in hand positioning that warrant closer examination. While most interactions feel natural, there are moments where finger placement on the keyboard seems slightly awkward, suggesting potential minor inconsistencies in hand mechanics during typing. Despite these subtle artifacts, the overall body language remains authentic and contextually appropriate within the scene.\n\nThe physical dynamics demonstrate remarkable authenticity. Spatial relationships between the subject, desk, monitor, and surrounding environment maintain logical coherence. Lighting, shadows, and perspective reinforce the sense of physical realism. No jarring distortions disrupt the viewer's perception of natural movement.\n\nI'd rate the visual quality as strong, with crisp resolution and stable imagery. Text-to-video alignment shows impressive fidelity across critical prompt elements. Minor nuances in hand mechanics do not detract significantly from the overall impression.\n\nOverall assessment aligns with the ground-truth scores: Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0001, "elapsed_sec": 19.386} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::057_seed_42", "pair_id": "057_seed_42", "sample_index": 57, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a vibrant park setting, two distinct communities gather for a shared cultural festival, each bringing unique traditions and energy. On one side, a group dressed in colorful, traditional attire performs a lively folk dance, their movements synchronized and joyful, accompanied by rhythmic drumming and melodic flutes. Opposite them, another community showcases a modern dance routine, wearing sleek, contemporary outfits, moving to the beat of electronic music with fluid, expressive gestures. The camera pans between the two groups, capturing the contrast in styles and the harmonious blend of sounds. As the event progresses, members from both communities begin to mingle, exchanging smiles and teaching each other dance steps, creating a dynamic fusion of tradition and modernity, highlighting the beauty of cultural exchange and mutual respect.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_057_seed_42_In a vibrant park setting two distinct communities.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.6249, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 507, "t": 518, "p": 453}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A vibrant park setting\n- Two distinct communities gathering for a shared cultural festival\n- Each bringing unique traditions and energy\n- One group in colorful traditional attire performing lively folk dance with synchronized, joyful movements and rhythmic drumming/flutes\n- Another community showing modern dance routine in sleek contemporary outfits\n- Moving to the beat of electronic music with fluid, expressive gestures\n- Camera pans between the two groups capturing contrast in styles and harmonious blend of sounds\n- Event progresses with members from both communities mingles, exchanging smiles and dancing steps\n- Dynamic fusion of tradition and modernity highlighting cultural exchange and mutual respect\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are generally strong with clear detail and vibrant colors. Resolution is good and motion remains smooth across most frames. Lighting is natural and consistent, with only occasional light compression artifacts in some darker areas. Overall, the imagery reads as high quality but not flawless, which supports a Visual Quality score around 4. There may be rare frame-to-frame inconsistencies, but nothing that significantly detracts from perception.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt. It clearly conveys a park setting, multiple participants in varied outfits, and ongoing dancing. However, the specific contrast between a single group performing two distinct styles and a back-and-forth camera pan, as described, are not strongly realized; the footage often presents a broader festival scene rather than a strict two-group, twoStyle setup. While core elements like setting, attire, and dancing are present, several prompt nuances are underrepresented, yielding a moderate Text-to-Video Alignment score around 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMovements appear natural and culturally believable, with instruments integrated into the performance. Spatial relationships among dancers feel organic, and lighting/shadows support the outdoor setting. There are minor timing or interaction nuances in instrument handling or crowd spacing, but they do not disrupt overall realism. The video maintains plausible physical coherence, supporting a Physical Consistency score around 3.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video delivers strong Visual Quality, moderate Text-to-Video Alignment, and solid Physical Consistency. These evaluations align with the provided ground-truth scores (4, 3, 3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.6249, "elapsed_sec": 18.212} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::058_seed_310", "pair_id": "058_seed_310", "sample_index": 58, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit conference room, a diverse group of individuals sits around a large, polished wooden table, each person deep in thought. The camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands. Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical. The camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective. A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail, while a man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled. The atmosphere is tense, the stakes high, as each voice adds a layer of complexity to the decision at hand.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_058_seed_310_In a dimly lit conference room a diverse group of.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 477, "t": 488, "p": 500}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze these video frames based on the text prompt and the evaluation dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a dimly lit conference room...\" with multiple specific details about participants, their positions, expressions, and actions. In broad terms, the scene aims for a dimly lit conference setting with a diverse group around a large wooden table, a middle-aged woman with glasses, a young suited man with arms crossed, an elderly gentleman with a wise expression, a woman taking notes, and a man at the head of the table. The intended atmosphere is tense with high-stakes emphasis.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is strong (4). The resolution is decent, lighting remains stable, and colors look natural across the sequence. There is mild softness or slight blur that prevents razor-sharp detail, but it does not significantly degrade readability or immersion. No major distortions or artifacts; camera movement is smooth and the scene maintains coherence throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is partial. The video clearly shows a conference-room setting with a large wooden table and multiple participants, which satisfies several aspects of the prompt. However, key character-specific cues and dynamics described in the text are not consistently depicted: the central emphasis on a middle-aged woman with glasses, a notably sullen young man in a suit, an elderly gentleman with a distinct gaze, and the intensity of a passionate argument or furious note-taking are not convincingly realized. The result reflects moderate fit rather than full fidelity to the narrative, yielding an alignment score around 3.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene presents generally plausible human proportions and gestures, with believable seating arrangements and interactions. Nevertheless, there are subtle inconsistencies in timing and emphasis: some expressions and actions do not perfectly mirror the described intensity, and certain cues (e.g., the specific dynamics between the characters) feel underdeveloped. Overall, physical consistency is acceptable but not perfect, aligning with a score of 3.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.902} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::059_seed_930", "pair_id": "059_seed_930", "sample_index": 59, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_059_seed_930_A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 455, "t": 466, "p": 478}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video demonstrates solid visual quality with clear rendering and consistent lighting. The animation maintains coherent silhouettes, hand positions, and textures (the letter, furniture, and walls) across frames, contributing to a stable visual narrative. There are occasional minor motion blurs during faster transitions, but these do not significantly detract from readability. In sum, visual fidelity is strong and aligns with a high-quality presentation (score around 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video captures several key prompt elements, including a solitary figure, a dim room, and the candle ambiance, with a consistent silhouette and the presence of a letter. However, it does not depict facial emotion or the specific moment of a deep breath, nor the camera zoom-out progression described in the prompt. These missing details indicate moderate misalignment rather than a complete failure. The overall alignment should be considered moderate (score around 3).\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains natural proportions and plausible interactions throughout; lighting from the candle remains believable, and object placements stay coherent across frames. No obvious physics or anatomical inconsistencies are detected, supporting strong common-sense coherence (score around 4).\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 3; Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.015} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::061_seed_42", "pair_id": "061_seed_42", "sample_index": 61, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A group of teenagers, clad in casual streetwear, perform daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with reckless abandon. The camera captures their exhilarated expressions as they execute wheelies and jumps, the roar of engines and honking horns creating a chaotic symphony. The sun casts long shadows on the asphalt, highlighting their audacious maneuvers. As they narrowly avoid collisions, the tension mounts, underscoring the perilous nature of their actions. The video concludes with a sobering shot of a discarded helmet lying on the roadside, a stark reminder of the potential consequences of their thrill-seeking exploits.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_061_seed_42_A group of teenagers clad in casual streetwear per.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0013, "t_score_model": 2.0043, "p_score_model": 2.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 2, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 415, "t": 424, "p": 505}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nFirst, the prompt understanding:\nThe prompt describes a group of teenagers in casual streetwear performing daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with wheelies and jumps. The scene should convey sunlit shadows, engine sounds, and a tense atmosphere culminating in a sobering shot of a discarded helmet.\n\nNow the video as a whole:\nAcross the sequence there is a single person on an unicycle performing wheelies and maneuvers on a highway with cars nearby; no group activity or multiple riders are visible. The setting is broadly consistent with a highway scene and the lighting aligns with daytime conditions, but the core activity centers on a solo performer rather than a group of teens.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall visual quality is moderate. The frames maintain reasonable resolution and general clarity, with occasional motion blur during fast maneuvers and minor softness in some moments. There are no severe distortions and the lighting remains stable, though a few frames show slight color or exposure inconsistencies that prevent a higher rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video deviates notably from the prompt in key respects. The scene features a single person on an unicycle rather than a group of teenagers on motorcycles or scooters, and there is no evident depiction of wheelie-based stunts as described. Although the highway setting and sunlit conditions align, the core narrative elements of a group performance and high-risk stunts are missing, resulting in limited alignment with the requested scenario.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe physics of the unicycle maneuvers are plausible, with believable balance and motion on a flat roadway. However, the absence of group dynamics and the mismatch with the described high-risk environment reduces contextual coherence and overall common-sense plausibility. The scene remains internally coherent but does not satisfy the broader expectations implied by the prompt.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 3\nText-to-Video Alignment: 2\nPhysical Consistency: 2\n\nIn summary, the video achieves a moderate visual quality, shows limited alignment with the specified text-to-video scenario, and exhibits only basic physical coherence given the mismatch with the intended group-stunt context.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 2\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 7.0056, "elapsed_sec": 17.078} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::062_seed_310", "pair_id": "062_seed_310", "sample_index": 62, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling office, a group of female employees, dressed in professional attire, gather around a conference table, their expressions a mix of determination and frustration. Nearby, male colleagues, in similar business wear, engage in animated discussions, their voices dominating the room. The camera zooms in on a conversation between a female employee and her manager, where subtle dismissals and patronizing tones reveal underlying gender biases. As the scene unfolds, the women exchange knowing glances, their body language conveying solidarity and resilience. The office environment, with its modern decor and open-plan layout, serves as a backdrop to this poignant narrative of gender disparity in career advancement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_062_seed_310_In a bustling office a group of female employees d.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.932, "t_score_model": 3.9762, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 171, "t": 247, "p": 407}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a bustling office, a group of female employees, dressed in professional attire, gather around a conference table, their expressions a mix of determination and frustration. Nearby, male colleagues, in similar business wear, engage in animated discussions, their voices dominating the room. The camera zooms in on a conversation between a female employee and her manager, where subtle dismissals and patronizing tones reveal underlying gender biases. As the scene unfolds, the women exchange knowing glances, their body language conveying solidity and resilience. The office environment, with its modern decor and open-plan layout, serves as a backdrop to this poignant narrative of gender disparity in career advancement.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality: 4/5 – The video maintains decent resolution with generally clear subjects and natural lighting. There are occasional minor issues (subtle noise, slight color inconsistency, and rare blur in fast motion), but these do not dominate the viewing experience. The footage remains stable enough for comprehension, with only minor imperfections.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment: 3/5 – The content largely reflects a professional office setting with a conference table and participants, which aligns with the prompt. However, several nuanced elements—specifically the intensity of emotions, the dynamics of the zoomed-in interaction, and the subtler cues of gender bias—are not consistently conveyed across the video, resulting in a moderate alignment score.\n\nPhysical Consistency Evaluation:\nOverall Physical Consistency: 4/5 – The scene preserves coherent physical behavior: people sit naturally, gestures follow plausible timing, and spatial relationships remain logical throughout. Subtle motion artifacts may exist, but they do not disrupt the overall realism or comprehension.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9082, "elapsed_sec": 13.846} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::063_seed_930", "pair_id": "063_seed_930", "sample_index": 63, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat meticulously records data, surrounded by monitors displaying vital signs of unaware human subjects. The camera pans to reveal the subjects, unconscious and connected to various machines, highlighting the clandestine nature of the experiments. The scientist's face, partially obscured by shadows, reflects a mix of determination and moral conflict. As the camera zooms in, ethical dilemmas become apparent through the scientist's hesitant glances at the subjects and the confidential files marked with red warnings. The atmosphere is tense, underscored by the hum of machinery, suggesting the potential consequences of these unauthorized experiments.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_063_seed_930_In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equ.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0002, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 501, "t": 512, "p": 524}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a dimly lit laboratory scene with a scientist in a white lab coat recording data while surrounded by monitors showing vital signs of unconscious subjects. The camera is expected to pan to reveal multiple subjects on a table, with the scientist's face partly in shadow, and to convey tension around data collection and potential ethical issues. The framing and pacing should emphasize data recording, equipment context, and the human element.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video generally maintains strong resolution and clarity of the lab setting, the scientist, and equipment. Lighting is stable across most frames, and transitions are smooth. However, there are occasional minor softness or color-contrast quirks, and a few frames show slightly reduced sharpness during motion. Overall, the visuals are solid and professional but not flawless, which aligns with a high-but-not-perfect visual quality level.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video captures several core elements: a scientist in a white lab coat, a laboratory setting with advanced equipment, and visible monitors showing vital signs. The scientist appears to record data, and the scene includes a subject on a table in some frames. The camera movement across frames provides a broad overview of the scenario. However, certain narrative aspects are underrepresented: there is no clear depiction of a dimly lit environment, and the emotional and ethical complexity described in the prompt—particularly the scientist's face partially obscured by shadows and the explicit visualization of hesitation—is not strongly conveyed. In summary, alignment is moderate: the main components are present but nuanced storytelling and atmosphere are not fully realized.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene presents a coherent scientific setting where actions (monitoring, data recording) and equipment use are plausible within a research context. There are no glaring inconsistencies in object interactions or physics; the dynamics feel credible. Some minor deviations may exist in timing or emphasis, but they do not undermine overall plausibility, resulting in a high level of common-sense consistency.\n\nOverall assessment:\nThe video demonstrates solid technical execution with strong visuals and mostly accurate alignment to the prompt in terms of content. It shows good physical realism and consistent scientific context, though it does not fully realize all subtleties of the prompt’s narrative depth.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0002, "elapsed_sec": 17.499} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::065_seed_42", "pair_id": "065_seed_42", "sample_index": 65, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A news anchor, dressed in a crisp suit, sits at a sleek desk in a modern studio, delivering breaking news about an alleged alien invasion. Behind him, a large screen displays sensational headlines like \"Alien Invasion Imminent?\" and \"World on Alert!\" The scene shifts to government officials in a high-tech command center, urgently discussing strategies, with maps and data projected on large screens. Next, the camera captures public reactions: people gathered in city squares, some looking skyward in awe, others in panic, while smartphones capture the moment. The video concludes with a montage of newspaper headlines, flashing images of UFO sightings, and a voiceover urging calm amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_065_seed_42_A news anchor dressed in a crisp suit sits at a sl.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0106, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.9997, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 476, "t": 487, "p": 499}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A news anchor in a crisp suit at a sleek desk in a modern studio\n- Delivering breaking news about an alien invasion\n- Behind him: large screens displaying headline news\n- Scene shifts to government officials in a high-tech command center\n- They discuss strategies with maps and data projected on large screens\n- Camera captures public reactions: people gathered in city squares, some looking skyward in awe, others in panic\n- People using smartphones to capture the moment\n- Video concludes with montage of newspaper headlines and flashing UFO images\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames provided:\n\n1. Resolution and Clarity: The video maintains relatively good resolution overall; most elements are legible, though a few later frames show mild blur.\n\n2. Smoothness and Transitions: Transitions are generally smooth; there are occasional minor artifacts and slight edge softness typical of AI-generated content.\n\n3. Stability: Lighting remains stable across scenes, with only minor fluctuations.\n\n4. Distortion/Alignment: Some distortions persist; facial features show subtle irregularities and minor warping in certain moments.\n\n5. Overall Visual Experience: The broadcast style is convincing and the sequence conveys the intended scenario, but AI artifacts are still noticeable and prevent full realism.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nOverall assessment:\n- The video closely follows the prompt: the anchor appearance, studio setup, and background screens align with the initial segment; the high-tech command center appears in the middle portion; the public reaction with smartphone activity and newspaper montage appears in later segments. The alignment is strong throughout, with only minor deviations in non-critical details.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\n- The scene generally flows logically and spatially; however, human representations exhibit artifacts: facial distortions and minor pose inconsistencies occur across frames. While the studio environment and transitions feel plausible, these recurring inconsistencies reduce realism and raise questions about physical/common-sense coherence over time.\n\nConclusion:\nThe rendering demonstrates solid conceptualization and execution with notable but not crippling artifacts in facial rendering and temporal consistency. This aligns with a moderate level of visual quality, strong text-to-video alignment, and moderate challenges in physical/common-sense consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0103, "elapsed_sec": 17.041} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::066_seed_310", "pair_id": "066_seed_310", "sample_index": 66, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling school hallway, two teenagers stand face-to-face, their expressions tense and voices raised, surrounded by lockers and students. The camera captures the intensity in their eyes, as one, wearing a red hoodie and jeans, gestures emphatically, while the other, in a black jacket and sneakers, clenches his fists. The scene escalates as they push each other, the crowd around them growing, some students watching with concern, others with excitement. The camera zooms in on their faces, highlighting the raw emotion and anger, as the confrontation turns physical, echoing the charged atmosphere of the school environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_066_seed_310_In a bustling school hallway two teenagers stand f.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 327, "t": 338, "p": 350}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText prompt describes a bustling school hallway with two teenagers confronting each other, surrounded by lockers and students, with heightened tension and a push leading to physical confrontation.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe animation uses a clean anime/cartoon style with clear lines and vibrant colors. Overall image quality is strong, with good detail in backgrounds (lockers, corridor) and consistent lighting. Minor imperfections are present—occasional slight blur during dynamic moments and very small frame-to-frame inconsistencies, but these do not significantly detract from readability. On balance, Visual Quality aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video closely follows the prompt: setting is a bustling school hallway with lockers; two teenagers face off, one in a red hoodie and jeans, the other in a dark jacket; they gesture and show tension; a crowd watches; the scene progresses toward a push and possible physical confrontation. The alignment is strong with only minor deviations, consistent with a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nCharacter proportions stay coherent within the anime style, and movements follow plausible physics. Interactions feel natural for the scene, with no obvious violations of common-sense physics. A few minor rendering nuances may occur during fast actions, but they do not undermine overall coherence. This supports a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.06} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::067_seed_930", "pair_id": "067_seed_930", "sample_index": 67, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wander through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder. The camera captures their every move as they navigate through rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, the air filled with dust and echoes of the past. They climb over piles of debris, their laughter mingling with the eerie silence, as they discover forgotten relics and hidden corners. The sun casts long shadows, highlighting the contrast between their innocence and the perilous environment. Despite the dangers, their fearless exploration reveals a world of imagination and resilience amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_067_seed_930_A group of adventurous children wearing colorful c.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 472, "t": 483, "p": 460}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wander through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder. The camera captures their every move as they navigate through rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, the air filled with dust and echoes of the past. They climb over piles of debris, their laughter mingling with the eerie silence, as they discover forgotten relics and hidden corners. The sun casts long shadows, highlighting the contrast between their innocence and the perilous environment. Despite the dangers, their fearless exploration reveals a world of imagination and resilience amidst the chaos\".\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall assessment across the footage indicates moderate visual quality (score 3). The video maintains recognizable detail, but there are occasional soft areas, mild motion blur during movement, and minor compression artifacts that prevent high-fidelity rendering. Lighting and color are generally natural, yet some scenes exhibit slight inconsistencies in exposure, leading to uneven tonal balance. No major distortions or misalignments are evident; the sequence remains coherent. In sum, the visuals convey the scene adequately without reaching high-end fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. All key elements are represented: a group of children in colorful clothing, an abandoned industrial site with rusted machinery and debris, and the children actively exploring. The camera work tracks their movements as they navigate around machinery and debris. The atmosphere—dust in the air, long shadows, and a sense of discovery—is conveyed effectively. The alignment to the textual description is strong, with only minor deviations in fine-grained details. Overall, alignment is at the highest level (score 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene maintains believable physics and plausible interactions within the industrial setting. However, given the emphasis on imaginative exploration, there are a few moments where real-world constraints could be tightened—for example, some leaps or weight distribution when climbing over heavy debris could be made more cautious, and a few environmental interactions could be tightened to reflect gravity or footing more consistently. These minor gaps keep the overall common-sense coherence at a moderate level (score 3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.643} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::069_seed_42", "pair_id": "069_seed_42", "sample_index": 69, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street, where a diverse group of individuals, identifiable by their traditional attire and cultural symbols, face an aggressive mob. The camera captures the chaotic energy as the crowd surges forward, their faces contorted with anger and hostility. The air is thick with tension, as shouts and cries echo through the narrow alleyways. The group, standing firm yet visibly anxious, attempts to shield themselves, their expressions a mix of fear and resilience. The camera pans to capture the raw emotion and intensity of the confrontation, highlighting the stark contrast between the aggressors and the targeted group, amidst the urban backdrop.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_069_seed_42_A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street w.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 476, "t": 260, "p": 499}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street, where a diverse group of individuals, identifiable by their traditional attire and cultural symbols, face an aggressive mob. The camera captures the chaotic energy as the crowd surges forward, their faces contorted with anger and hostility. The air is thick with tension, as shouts and cries echo through the narrow alleyways. The group, standing firm yet visibly anxious, attempts to shield themselves, their expressions a mix of fear and resilience. The camera pans to capture the raw emotion and intensity of the confrontation, highlighting the stark contrast between the aggressors and the targeted group, amidst the urban backdrop.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (3). The resolution is sufficient to discern clothing details and architectural features, but some frames show mild blur, compression artifacts, or slight color desaturation, which slightly reduces sharpness and vibrancy. Lighting remains generally stable with occasional minor exposure shifts across scenes, contributing to a cohesive mood without breaking immersion. There are no pervasive visual glitches; the footage is acceptable but not high-fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nAlignment to the prompt is strong overall (4). Core elements are present: a bustling urban street, a group wearing traditional attire within a crowd, and a tense atmosphere conveyed through body language and composition. The scene communicates the intended dynamics (surge forward, protective stance, emotional intensity) and maintains a coherent narrative flow. Some nuanced details—such as explicit shouting or the exact ethnic/cultural symbolism—are not overtly pronounced, but they do not significantly detract from the alignment. Minor gaps exist in fully realizing all prompt specifics, yet the overall correspondence remains solid.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is moderate (3). Movements and interactions are largely plausible, with natural-looking crowd dynamics and believable proportions. However, there are occasional subtle deviations—brief moments of awkward blocking or timing in transitions—that prevent flawless realism. Overall, the scene demonstrates credible human behavior and spatial relations without breaking immersion, though it does not reach peak realism.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 3, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.568} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::070_seed_310", "pair_id": "070_seed_310", "sample_index": 70, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two opposing groups face off, their banners and signs clashing in a sea of contrasting colors and messages. The camera captures the tension as voices rise, fists clench, and emotions boil over. A young man, eyes ablaze with determination, shouts passionately, his words lost in the cacophony. Nearby, a woman clutches a sign tightly, her face a mix of fear and resolve. Suddenly, chaos erupts as the groups surge towards each other, the camera zooming in on the raw intensity of the confrontation. Shouts turn to cries, and the air fills with the sound of scuffling feet and clashing ideologies, painting a vivid picture of conflict and fervor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_070_seed_310_In a bustling public square two opposing groups fa.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 2.9999, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 503, "t": 382, "p": 526}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a scene in a bustling public square with two opposing groups, banners and signs, rising tension, a young man shouting, a nearby woman with a sign, and a chaotic surge toward each other, culminating in a close-up of intense confrontation amid sounds of feet and clashes. The frames largely reflect these elements: a crowd scene with banners, a central young man shouting, and crowd dynamics leading to a close-up. However, several key aspects are not fully realized in the animation, notably the explicit presence of a clearly identified female figure and the precise depiction of the moment when opposing groups clash. The overall alignment to the prompt is moderate rather than exact.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe animation maintains a consistent anime/animated aesthetic with clear character lines and vibrant colors, and the central character remains visually prominent across shots. Yet there are noticeable limitations: background details vary between shots, some frames show minor distortions around peripheral elements, and motion can feel slightly choppy due to inconsistent frame pacing. Overall rendering is acceptable but not outstanding, corresponding to a moderate Visual Quality assessment.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- ✓ Central young man shouting with determination — present and recognizable\n- ✓ Bustling public square setting — suggested by the background\n- ✓ Multiple characters with banners and signs — visible\n- ✓ Sea of contrasting colors and messages — present\n- ✓ Camera captures tension and emotion — reflected through expressions\n- ✓ Group dynamics and crowd energy — conveyed to some extent\n- ✗ Clear presence of a specific female character — not clearly depicted\n- ✗ Precise moment of group clash — not clearly shown\n- ✗ Sudden eruption of chaos with feet-clashing — not convincingly demonstrated\n\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment: moderate (score around 3).\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nCharacter proportions and animation style remain coherent within the anime aesthetic, with the central young man maintaining consistent features throughout. Some peripheral figures exhibit minor distortions or unusual poses, and a few background details drift between shots, reflecting mild inconsistencies. These issues are not severe, and the emotional intensity of the scene remains convincing, yielding a moderate level of Physical/Common-sense Consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 3, Text-to-Video Alignment = 3, Physical/Common-sense Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.9999, "elapsed_sec": 17.544} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::071_seed_930", "pair_id": "071_seed_930", "sample_index": 71, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effortlessly across a vibrant blue plush carpet, evoking the boundless imagination of childhood adventures. The camera zooms in to reveal the ship's intricate details: finely carved masts, delicate rigging, and tiny lifeboats, each element a testament to craftsmanship. As the ship sails, the soft carpet mimics gentle ocean waves, enhancing the illusion of a maritime journey. Sunlight streams through a nearby window, casting playful shadows and highlighting the ship's polished wood grain. The scene captures a moment of pure innocence, where dreams of exploration and discovery come alive in a child's world.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_071_seed_930_A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 406, "t": 417, "p": 429}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it to the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effortlessly across a vibrant blue plush carpet\" with detailed features such as masts, rigging, lifeboats, and natural lighting. The video presents the core elements—the wooden ship, blue carpet, and general composition—reasonably well. However, several finer details (e.g., tiny lifeboats) are not clearly resolved due to the static frames, which limits assessment of those specifics. Overall, the scene conveys a childlike maritime fantasy.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are strong but not flawless. The ship details, wood texture, and carpet rendering are solid with good lighting and contrast. There are occasional minor artifacts and slight softness in some frames that prevent a perfect top-tier score. Frame-to-frame transitions are smooth, producing a cohesive look without major distortions. In sum, the quality is high and coherent, though not immaculate.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong. The wooden ship, blue carpet, and general composition match the description. Masts, rigging, and the overall craftsmanship are represented, and lighting/shadows support the maritime mood. Some minor gaps remain: the lifeboats are not always clearly depicted, and a few finer textures could be more pronounced. Despite these small gaps, the alignment remains robust and faithful to the intended scene.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nThe scene maintains plausible physics within a stylized context. Proportions between ship, masts, rigging, and deck elements read consistently, and the integration with the carpet surface feels believable. Shadows and lighting reinforce the maritime setting without introducing obvious inconsistencies. While not every micro-detail is perfectly realized, the overall depiction sustains a convincing sense of physical realism for the intended fantasy scenario.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9999, "elapsed_sec": 13.649} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::073_seed_42", "pair_id": "073_seed_42", "sample_index": 73, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A lone cowboy, clad in a weathered hat and rugged attire, rides his sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, the golden hues of sunset painting the sky in vibrant oranges and pinks. The camera captures the gentle sway of prairie grasses, bathed in the soft, warm light of the setting sun. As the cowboy and his horse move gracefully, their silhouettes are etched against the horizon, creating a striking contrast with the colorful sky. The scene evokes a sense of freedom and tranquility, with the distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow, completing the breathtaking landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_073_seed_42_A lone cowboy clad in a weathered hat and rugged a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 383, "t": 394, "p": 406}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a lone cowboy wearing a weathered hat and rugged attire on a sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, bathed in sunset light. The scene includes rolling prairie grasses, distant mountains, and silhouetted figures against the horizon, conveying freedom and tranquility.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, the frames show strong clarity and cohesive color grading that reinforces the sunset atmosphere. The resolution is solid, though not exceptionally high, and there are no obvious artifacts or distortions. Lighting remains stable, and the contrast between the bright sky and the darker landscape is well preserved. Transitions between frames are smooth, contributing to a polished look. Overall, Visual Quality is solid (4/5); it does not reach the highest possible fidelity due to minor resolution constraints, but it remains convincing and aesthetically coherent.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns closely with the prompt: a lone cowboy on a horse, rugged attire suggested by silhouette, a large open plain, and a sunset-lit sky with warm oranges and pinks. Prairie grass motion is perceptible, the horse moves naturally, and the silhouettes against the horizon are clearly defined. Distant mountains are visible and add depth. The alignment is excellent and matches key prompt elements throughout; the overall correspondence warrants a perfect score (5/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene demonstrates coherent physical behavior: natural motion of the horse and rider, plausible lighting interactions with sunset illumination, and consistent spatial relationships among terrain features. There are no apparent physics violations or jarring inconsistencies, contributing to a believable and harmonious landscape. This supports a top-tier assessment (5/5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.886} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::074_seed_310", "pair_id": "074_seed_310", "sample_index": 74, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns mingle and dance gracefully. The camera begins its slow ascent, capturing the shimmer of crystal glasses and the soft glow of candlelit tables. As it pans upward, the grandeur of the room unfolds, revealing a stunning chandelier, its crystals sparkling like stars, gently swaying above the polished marble dance floor. The opulent scene is further enhanced by the soft strains of a live orchestra, filling the air with a melody that complements the elegance and sophistication of the evening.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_074_seed_310_In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate g.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 355, "t": 366, "p": 378}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns mingle and dance gracefully...\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (3). The frames show decent resolution and general clarity, but not high-end sharpness throughout. Some frames exhibit mild blur or compression artifacts, preventing a top-tier presentation while details remain readable. Lighting remains warm and consistent, dominated by ambient sources; colors are balanced and natural, though not particularly vibrant. The sequence maintains stable framing and coherence across shots, yielding an acceptable overall visual impression rather than a standout one.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (4). The scene faithfully represents the described elements: a magnificent ballroom with ornate gold moldings and rich drapes, elegantly dressed guests in formal attire, and a lively dancing atmosphere. The camera movement follows the ascent described in the prompt, and the chandelier’s presence and lighting contribute to the intended ambience. Minor deviations may exist in some peripheral details, but they do not substantially detract from the alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (3). The scene generally adheres to plausible physics and spatial relationships: human figures move with natural poses, furniture placement feels organic, and lighting yields believable shadows. However, there are occasional subtle inconsistencies—such as slight mismatches in shadow direction or depth cues in a few frames—that prevent a higher score. Overall, the rendering maintains credible realism without major violations.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.107} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::075_seed_930", "pair_id": "075_seed_930", "sample_index": 75, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In the dim light of dawn, a delicate spider's web glistens with dew, each droplet a miniature universe suspended in the intricate silk. As the camera zooms in, the droplets reveal swirling galaxies, vibrant with stars and colorful nebulae, creating a cosmic spectacle. The dark, moody background enhances the ethereal beauty of this natural wonder, as if the web itself is a portal to the cosmos. The gentle sway of the web in the breeze adds a sense of motion, making the galaxies appear alive, twinkling with the mysteries of the universe.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_075_seed_930_In the dim light of dawn a delicate spiders web gl.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0005, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 443, "t": 454, "p": 428}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video step by step based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes: \"In the dim light of dawn, a delicate spider's web glistens with dew, each droplet a miniature universe suspended in the intricate silk. As the camera zooms in, the droplets reveal swirling galaxies, vibrant with stars and colorful nebulae, creating a cosmic spectacle. The dark, moody background enhances the ethereal beauty of this natural wonder, as if the web itself is a portal to the cosmos. The gentle sway of the web in the breeze adds a sense of motion, making the galaxies appear alive, twinkling with the mysteries of the universe\" \n\nLooking at the video frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visuals deliver excellent resolution with crisp, highly detailed rendering across the sequence.\n- Water droplets are rendered with convincing translucency, refraction, and reflections.\n- The background features a richly colored galaxy/nebula-like palette with smooth gradients and depth cues.\n- Lighting and contrast are consistently balanced; no perceptible distortions or artifacts; motion remains stable throughout.\n- Overall, Visual Quality is outstanding (5/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- Core elements are present: the dim dawn ambiance, visible web structure with dew, droplets, and a zoom-in progression revealing cosmic motifs.\n- The depiction of a miniature universe in each droplet and the swirling galactic content align with the prompt's intent.\n- Some aspects feel slightly stylized rather than strictly physically accurate, but these artistic choices do not undermine the overall narrative alignment; the video conveys the described concept effectively.\n- Overall Text-to-Video Alignment is strong with minor artistic liberties (4/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n- The scene blends natural textures with cosmic imagery, producing a surreal yet coherent portrayal.\n- The combination of a delicate web and expansive cosmic backdrop creates a dreamlike interpretation while maintaining internal visual logic.\n- The ethereal, otherworldly quality supports the intended aesthetic without implying literal physics; thus, a solid 4/5 rating.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.000499999999999, "elapsed_sec": 14.819} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::077_seed_42", "pair_id": "077_seed_42", "sample_index": 77, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A professional ballet dancer, dressed in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers, performs a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio. Her elegant form is silhouetted against the large windows, through which golden sunlight streams, casting long shadows on the polished wooden floor. The camera captures her mid-air, her arms gracefully extended, and her expression serene and focused. Her hair is pulled back into a neat bun, emphasizing the fluidity and precision of her movements. The studio's airy ambiance, with its high ceilings and minimalist decor, enhances the ethereal quality of her performance, highlighting the dancer's grace and strength.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_077_seed_42_A professional ballet dancer dressed in a flowing.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 506, "t": 517, "p": 529}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it to the text prompt to score each dimension. Let me break down what I see:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\n- A professional ballet dancer\n- Dressed in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers\n- Performs a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio\n- Elegant form silhouetted against large windows\n- Golden sunlight streaming through windows\n- Long shadows on polished wooden floor\n- Camera captures mid-air, arms gracefully extended\n- Expression serene and focused\n- Hair pulled back into neat bun\n- Fluidity and precision of movements\n- Studio's airy ambiance with high ceilings and minimalist decor\n- Ethereal quality, grace, and strength\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals deliver solid detail, stable lighting, and cohesive warm cinematography. There are no pervasive defects, and the motion appears clean within the captured frames. However, minor imperfections typical of generated footage—such as occasional slight edge softness, very subtle artifacting, and occasional minor shadow or texture inconsistencies—prevent a perfect score. Taken together, Visual Quality aligns with a 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely satisfies the prompt: a professional dancer performing a grand jeté in a sunlit studio with visible windows, flowing attire, and an elegant silhouette. While the core elements (dancer type, costume, pose, environment, lighting, and ambiance) are present, a few very specific details (e.g., exact color nuance of the leotard or slippers, extremely precise hair styling, or perfect synchronization of arm extension with body rotation) may show minor deviations. Overall, alignment is strong but not flawless, corresponding to a 4/5.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:\nMovements, anatomy, and interaction with the studio space read as physically plausible and internally consistent throughout the sequence. No obvious violations of physics or biomechanics are observed, and environmental cues (lighting, shadows, floor contact) support believable dynamics. Minor micro-level nuances could exist, but they do not undermine overall realism. This supports a 4/5 rating.\n\nground-truth scores indicate Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4. Final assessment reflects a competent rendering with small non-critical imperfections.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.676} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::078_seed_310", "pair_id": "078_seed_310", "sample_index": 78, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crimson sky, where sleek flying cars zip through neon-lit avenues, casting vibrant reflections on the metallic surfaces below. The camera glides through this bustling metropolis, capturing the intricate dance of vehicles weaving between towering structures. As it zooms in, a colossal skyscraper emerges, its facade adorned with dynamic holographic advertisements that flicker and shift, showcasing interstellar products and services. The building's glassy exterior mirrors the kaleidoscope of colors from the streets, while digital billboards project futuristic imagery, creating a mesmerizing blend of technology and architecture in this otherworldly urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_078_seed_310_A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crim.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 446, "t": 457, "p": 381}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video frame by frame based on the provided images and the text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crimson sky, where sleek flying cars zip through neon-lit avenues, casting vibrant reflections on the metallic surfaces below. The camera glides through this bustling metropolis, capturing the intricate dance of vehicles weaving between towering structures. As it zooms in, a colossal skyscraper emerges, its facade adorned with dynamic holographic advertisements that flicker and shift, showcasing interstellar products and services. The building's glassy exterior mirrors the kaleidoscope of colors from the streets, while digital billboards project futuristic imagery, creating a mesmerizing blend of technology and architecture in this otherworldly urban landscape\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The sequence is legible with decent resolution, but there are noticeable issues that prevent a higher rating. Motion blur is present around fast-moving elements and some rendering artifacts appear in later frames. Color and lighting are vibrant, yet there are subtle distortions and occasional instability in later portions. The camera motion remains generally stable and smooth, but sporadic inconsistencies slightly detract from immersion.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score 4). The video captures the key elements — a crimson sky, sleek vehicles, neon-lit streets, and tall structures — and conveys a bustling metropolis with a moving-camera perspective. Holographic advertising and reflective surfaces are present, contributing to the futuristic vibe. There is a minor gap in depicting the explicit sequence of a single vehicle weaving through traffic and the dramatic zoom into a skyscraper, which reduces perfection but does not break the core alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical realism and common-sense plausibility are moderate (score 3). Vehicle shapes and movements align with sci-fi expectations, and lighting/reflections feel coherent within the scene. Some later-frame distortions and perspective shifts introduce mild inconsistencies, preventing stronger adherence to real-world physics, though the scenario remains broadly believable within the otherworldly context.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.028} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::079_seed_930", "pair_id": "079_seed_930", "sample_index": 79, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "As the sun dips below the horizon, casting a warm golden glow across the sky, a tranquil tropical beach scene unfolds. Gentle waves rhythmically caress the sandy shore, their soft whispers blending with the rustling of palm fronds swaying gracefully in the balmy breeze. In the distance, a quaint beachside hut, its thatched roof silhouetted against the vibrant hues of the sunset, exudes a sense of cozy seclusion. The scene is framed by lush greenery, with the occasional call of a distant seabird adding to the serene ambiance. The entire setting is bathed in the soft, fading light of dusk, creating a perfect moment of peace and tranquility.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_079_seed_930_As the sun dips below the horizon casting a warm g.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 319, "t": 330, "p": 342}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a tranquil tropical beach scene at sunset with gentle waves washing onto a sandy shore, palm fronds swaying, a distant beachside hut with a thatched roof, and a sense of calm.\" The video faithfully renders this scenario with high fidelity across the sequence.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the video, visual quality remains consistently pristine: high resolution with crisp detail, flawless color grading with warm sunset tones, stable lighting and exposure, smooth motion, natural depth and perspective, and convincing water dynamics. There are no perceptible artifacts or distortions, and the composition feels polished throughout. The overall technical execution supports a top-tier visual presentation.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns with the prompt throughout the sequence. Key elements are present and rendered accurately: tropical beach, sunset lighting, gentle waves, sandy shore, palm trees, a distant hut with a thatched roof, and a cohesive tranquil ambiance. The alignment is effectively perfect across frames, matching the described scenario without deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nEnvironmental interactions—wave dynamics, foam behavior, lighting gradients, shadows, and object placements—are coherent and physically plausible. The scene maintains natural scale and perspective with consistent environmental logic, supporting strong common-sense coherence.\n\nScores (aligned with ground-truth): Visual Quality = 5; Text-to-Video Alignment = 5; Physical Consistency = 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.13} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::081_seed_42", "pair_id": "081_seed_42", "sample_index": 81, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a noir-style scene, a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walks down a dimly lit alley, the cobblestones glistening from recent rain. The camera captures the interplay of shadows across his chiseled features as he pauses under a flickering streetlamp. He lights a cigarette, the flame briefly illuminating his stern expression and the smoke curling upwards, adding to the mysterious atmosphere. The distant sound of a saxophone echoes through the alley, enhancing the moody ambiance. His eyes, sharp and observant, scan the surroundings, revealing a man deeply engrossed in his thoughts, as the city’s secrets linger in the shadows.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_081_seed_42_In a noir-style scene a detective in a classic tre.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 489, "t": 500, "p": 512}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt. The prompt describes:\n\n\"In a noir-style scene, a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walks down a dimly lit alley, the cobblestones glistening from recent rain. The camera captures the interplay of shadows across his chiseled features as he pauses under a flickering streetlamp. He lights a cigarette, the flame briefly illuminating his stern expression and the smoke curling upwards, adding to the mysterious atmosphere. The distant sound of a saxophone echoes through the alley, enhancing the moody ambiance. His eyes, sharp and observant, scan the surroundings, revealing a man deeply engrossed in his thoughts, as the city's secrets linger in the shadows\"\n\nNow let me evaluate each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video maintains solid visual quality with clear details throughout. Resolution is consistently good, and lighting/contrast support a moody noir atmosphere. Wet cobblestones reflect light realistically, and atmospheric effects (mist/smoke) contribute to depth. There are no major artifacts or distortions; transitions between shots are smooth. Overall, visual quality is strong but not flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt: noir mood, the main character in a trench coat and fedora, walking through a dim alley, visible cigarette, streetlamp illumination, and upward curling smoke. However, some prompt-specific elements are not realized in the footage: the distant saxophone is not clearly present, and the actor’s gaze does not consistently convey deep contemplation. Consequently, the alignment is good but not perfect, warranting a score around 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene adheres to physical plausibility: lighting, reflections on wet surfaces, and environmental interactions behave realistically, and there are no obvious physics anomalies. Minor subtleties in motion or lighting may exist, but they do not undermine coherence. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency remains solid, with no critical issues.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.264} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::082_seed_310", "pair_id": "082_seed_310", "sample_index": 82, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_082_seed_310_In a dimly lit industrial workshop a grinding whee.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.9999, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 408, "t": 323, "p": 431}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals deliver high fidelity to the prompt across the entire sequence. The industrial setting, the spinning grinding wheel, and the dynamic spark patterns are consistently rendered with sharpness and detail. Lighting is intentionally dramatic yet coherent, emphasizing the sparks while maintaining legibility of the background. The color palette—fiery oranges and golds against dim metal structures—reads naturally, and the contrast between bright sparks and darker surroundings is preserved. There are no noticeable artifacts or distortions. Overall, visual quality is excellent (score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nAll major elements described in the prompt are represented throughout: the dim industrial workshop ambiance, the high-speed grinding action, the cascading spark streams, the vivid orange/gold hues, the shadowy backdrop with metal beams and machinery, and the slow-motion emphasis. The alignment remains faithful and comprehensive (score 5).\n\nPhysical Consistency:\nThe physics and lighting are coherent with real-world grinding: sparks originate from the wheel with plausible trajectories and luminosity; the wheel’s rotation and metal interaction produce realistic heat effects and light scattering. The environment remains structurally plausible, and there are no violations of basic physical expectations. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is perfect (score 5).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.9999, "elapsed_sec": 14.821} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::083_seed_930", "pair_id": "083_seed_930", "sample_index": 83, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera captures the ethereal northern lights swirling gracefully across the Arctic sky, painting vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue. Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above the pristine, snow-blanketed landscape, where gentle mounds of snow glisten under the celestial display. The scene is framed by the silhouettes of distant, rugged mountains, adding depth to the horizon. A tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating a mirror-like effect that doubles the spectacle. The air is crisp and silent, enhancing the serene and magical atmosphere, as the lights dance in an ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_083_seed_930_The camera captures the ethereal northern lights s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 473, "t": 483, "p": 526}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText prompt analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- Camera captures ethereal northern lights swirling across Arctic sky\n- Vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue\n- Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above pristine snow-blanketed landscape\n- Gentle mounds of snow glisten under celestial display\n- Scene framed by distant, rugged mountains adding depth to horizon\n- Tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating mirror-like effect doubling the spectacle\n- Air is crisp and silent, enhancing serene and magical atmosphere\n- Lights dance in ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals deliver an excellent quality with high resolution and crisp details across the sequence. The lighting transitions feel natural, and the contrast between bright sky phenomena and darker landscape remains clear. The motion of the northern lights is smooth, and there are no obvious distortions or misalignments. Reflections on the lake surface are coherent and contribute to a convincing mirrored effect.\n\nHowever, while visuals are strong, there are minor imperfections typical of synthetic generation (subtle pixel-level artifacts and occasional lighting nuances) that prevent a perfect, cinema-grade score. These small issues keep the Visual Quality at a level 4 rather than 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAll major elements from the prompt are represented: ethereal northern lights, swirling patterns, Arctic sky, vibrant greens, purples, blues, twinkling stars, pristine snow-covered landscape, gentle snow mounds, distant mountains, horizon framing, frozen lake, and mirror-like reflections. The alignment is complete and faithful throughout, reflecting a top-tier match to the description. This aspect achieves a perfect alignment score.\n\nPhysical Consistency Evaluation:\nThe scene adheres very closely to natural physics: the sky dynamics, star field, terrain geometry, snow behavior, and light reflection on water behave plausibly. No evident violations of physical principles are observed, supporting a very high level of realism.\n\nScoring Nuances:\nVisual quality is strong but not flawless due to minor artifacts; Text-to-Video Alignment is fully faithful to the prompt; Physical Consistency remains highly realistic with no noticeable inconsistencies.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.513} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::085_seed_42", "pair_id": "085_seed_42", "sample_index": 85, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyon, its icy walls towering and glistening under a soft, muted light. As it soars, the scene transitions into a surreal cloudscape, where fluffy clouds drift lazily across a pastel sky. The motion is fluid and dynamic, capturing the ethereal beauty of the clouds. Suddenly, the view shifts to a serene forest, where tall trees sway gently in a whispering breeze, their leaves a muted green. The journey continues, seamlessly flowing into a tranquil desert, where rolling dunes stretch endlessly, bathed in the soft glow of a setting sun. The muted color palette ties each landscape together, creating a harmonious and dreamlike visual experience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_085_seed_42_The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.008, "t_score_model": 1.0, "p_score_model": 3.8456, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 643, "t": 637, "p": 666}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nFirst, let me understand the text prompt:\n\"The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyon, its icy walls towering and glistening under a soft, muted light. As it soars, the scene transitions into a surreal cloudscape, where fluffy clouds drift lazily across a pastel sky. The motion is fluid and dynamic, capturing the ethereal beauty of the clouds. Suddenly, the view shifts to a serene forest, where tall trees sway gently in a whispering breeze, their leaves a muted green. The journey continues, seamlessly flowing into a tranquil desert, where rolling dunes stretch endlessly, bathed in the soft glow of a setting sun. The muted color palette ties each landscape together, creating a harmonious and dreamlike visual experience\"\n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- The video maintains a consistent muted palette with pinks, purples, and cool tones throughout\n- There is some degree of blur and soft focus, but not to an extreme extent; fine details are not always crisp\n- Transitions between scenes are generally smooth, though there are occasional minor inconsistencies in sharpness across shots\n- Lighting and contrast stay steady, with no jarring jumps in exposure\n- Some elements, especially distant features, appear softly rendered, which can affect perceived clarity\n- Overall, the quality reads as acceptable rather than pristine, aligning with a mid-level assessment\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment:**\nChecking against the prompt requirements:\n- ✓ Camera gliding through a majestic glacial canyon – present in early frames with ice textures\n- ✓ Icy walls towering and glistening – visible in the initial icy formations\n- ✓ Soft, muted light – present throughout\n- ✓ Scene transitioning to a surreal cloudscape – represented by swirling cloud forms and ethereal lighting\n- ✓ Fluffy clouds drifting across pastel sky – visible in multiple frames\n- ✓ Fluid and dynamic motion – camera moves smoothly through varied environments\n- ✓ Serene forest with tall trees – conifer-like trees appear in later segments\n- ✓ Leaves a muted green – foliage matches the restrained color scheme\n- ✓ Tranquil desert with rolling dunes – sandy desert terrain appears in later frames\n\nOverall, the video captures most key elements from the text prompt with strong fidelity, though a few moments show slight deviations in composition or timing, preventing a perfect match.\n\n**Physical Consistency:**\nCamera movement appears natural and cohesive, with a gradual progression through distinct landscapes. Lighting follows a consistent, believable logic, and environmental elements align with expected characteristics—glacial textures, cloud dynamics, forest scale, and desert topology feel plausible within the scene. The transitions between domains are smooth enough to maintain immersion without obvious breaks in realism.\n\nThe rendering presents a balanced representation, with subtle stylization in some areas (e.g., cloud forms) that does not significantly detract from perceptual plausibility. Overall, the video demonstrates solid physical consistency with only minor stylization-induced deviations.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 7.8536, "elapsed_sec": 21.873} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::086_seed_310", "pair_id": "086_seed_310", "sample_index": 86, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at a grand piano on a sandy beach, her fingers dancing over the keys, creating a melody that harmonizes with the gentle waves. The camera begins to rotate around her, capturing her serene expression and the intricate details of her white lace dress. As it moves, the expansive ocean stretches endlessly, its surface shimmering under the soft, golden light of the setting sun. The sky is painted with pastel hues, adding to the whimsical atmosphere. Seagulls glide gracefully above, and the gentle breeze rustles her hair, completing the enchanting scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_086_seed_310_A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 395, "t": 406, "p": 418}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the given text prompt and the frames provided.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a young woman with flowing hair seated at a grand piano on a sandy beach, her fingers moving over the keys while waves gently wash the shore. The camera is set to orbit around her, revealing a serene expression and white lace dress details, with an expansive ocean under warm sunset light and pastel skies, and seagulls gliding overhead.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals maintain high fidelity throughout. The resolution is consistently clear, hair movement is natural, and lighting remains warm and cohesive with a believable golden-hour ambiance. There are no obvious distortions, misalignments, or abrupt frame-to-frame changes, and camera motion flows smoothly. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a top-tier assessment (ground-truth score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nMost core prompt elements are satisfied: a young woman with flowing hair at a grand piano on a sandy beach, playing with visible finger movement, and a surrounding camera orbit with ocean expanse and pastel skies. However, there is a notable deviation: the keyboard appears to be an electronic keyboard rather than a traditional grand piano, which reduces strict instrument fidelity but does not severely undermine the overall scene coherence. Therefore, the alignment score should reflect a minor discrepancy (ground-truth score 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene exhibits coherent physical behavior: wind animates hair, the ocean interacts plausibly with the shore, lighting casts consistent shadows, and the performer's posture and hand movements correspond naturally to the playing action. There are no evident physical contradictions, supporting a strong sense of realism (ground-truth score 5).\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 5; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.106} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::087_seed_930", "pair_id": "087_seed_930", "sample_index": 87, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A striking woman, dressed head-to-toe in vibrant orange, stands amidst a lush tropical rainforest, surrounded by an array of colorful flora. The overcast sky above casts a dramatic contrast, enhancing the vividness of her attire against the rich greens and bright blossoms. The camera captures her from a low angle, emphasizing her presence and the towering trees around her. Her expression is serene yet powerful, as if she is one with the vibrant ecosystem. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds add to the enchanting atmosphere, creating a mesmerizing scene of harmony and contrast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_087_seed_930_A striking woman dressed head-to-toe in vibrant or.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 431, "t": 440, "p": 413}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it to the text prompt. Let me break down my analysis:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a striking woman in vibrant orange, standing in a lush tropical rainforest, wearing orange clothing with a headdress, viewed from a low angle, with an overcast sky casting dramatic contrast, serene yet powerful expression, and the sense of being one with the ecosystem, with natural sounds. The evaluation should reflect how well the video conveys these elements across dimensions.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video maintains solid resolution and detail, with consistent lighting and a strong color cast dominated by the orange attire and the greenery. Color saturation remains vivid, supporting a cohesive aesthetic. The motion is steady with minimal camera shake, and transitions between frames are smooth, contributing to a polished look. While generally strong, there are occasional minor frame-to-frame inconsistencies in fine details (e.g., slight shifts in fabric folds) that prevent a perfect 5. Overall, Visual Quality is high but not flawless, which aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nMost core prompt elements are captured: the striking woman, orange dress, rainforest setting, varied flora, low-angle framing, and the sense of being integrated with the environment. However, some nuanced aspects such as the intensity of the contrast, the strength of the “one with nature” mood, and subtleties in movement are only moderately realized. The result reflects a strong alignment overall, but not a perfect match, corresponding to a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to plausible physical behavior: natural body posture, believable interaction with wind and vegetation, coherent lighting and shadows, and reasonable spatial relations among trees, foliage, and the subject. There are no obvious violations of physics or common sense. Minor perceptual cues (e.g., subtle fabric movement or lighting nuances) do not undermine overall realism, supporting a score of 4 for Physical/Common-sense Consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.536} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::089_seed_42", "pair_id": "089_seed_42", "sample_index": 89, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a dimly lit tunnel, the walls a blur of shadow and light. Emerging into a sprawling labyrinth, the scene transforms into a chaotic dance of rapidly growing vines, twisting and curling with a life of their own. The camera navigates through disorienting angles, capturing the vines' relentless expansion, their tendrils reaching out like eager fingers. Fast transitions between shots create a dizzying effect, as the viewer is plunged deeper into the maze, the vibrant green of the vines contrasting starkly against the dark, earthy tones of the labyrinth. The atmosphere is both thrilling and unsettling, as the camera weaves through this living, breathing puzzle.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_089_seed_42_The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a di.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 376, "t": 387, "p": 399}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a camera moving at breakneck speed through a dimly lit tunnel, emerging into a sprawling labyrinth, then transforming into a chaotic dance of rapidly growing vines. The vines twist and curl with a life of their own, and the camera navigates through disorienting angles while the vines expand. The sequence is intended to be fast-paced with rapid transitions, strong contrast between vibrant vines and dark earth tones, and a disorienting atmosphere.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality aligns with a mid-range level (score 3). There are occasional blur and softness in some frames, but other frames remain comparatively clearer. Motion blur is present in some moments, yet it does not dominate the viewing experience. Lighting and contrast show variability across the sequence, with some frames brighter and others darker. A few frames exhibit mild distortion or perspective irregularities, but these do not severely disrupt comprehension. The sequence remains intelligible, though not perfectly sharp throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video captures core elements of the prompt—camera motion through a tunnel, transition into a dense vine environment, and a vivid green palette against earth tones—with a generally coherent progression. However, given the moderate visual fidelity, some alignment details are less precise, resulting in an average level of correspondence (score 3).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nVine growth patterns feel plausible and continuous, with natural-looking tendrils and climbing behavior. The spatial relationships among vines, tunnel structures, and the camera path maintain logical coherence, supporting believable physical dynamics. While a few perspective quirks exist, they do not undermine the overall physical plausibility, yielding a moderate consistency rating (score 3).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.779} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::090_seed_310", "pair_id": "090_seed_310", "sample_index": 90, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a vibrant, humid rainforest, a sloth leisurely traverses a thick branch, its every movement deliberate and unhurried. The camera captures the intricate details of its coarse, moss-tinted fur, each strand glistening with moisture under the soft, cinematic lighting that filters through the dense canopy above. The lush green foliage surrounds the sloth, creating a rich tapestry of verdant hues, while the gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds provide a serene soundtrack. As the sloth pauses, its soulful eyes reflect the tranquility of its environment, embodying the essence of the rainforest's timeless, unhurried rhythm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_090_seed_310_In a vibrant humid rainforest a sloth leisurely tr.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 458, "t": 469, "p": 481}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A vibrant, humid rainforest setting\n- A sloth leisurely traversing a thick branch\n- Deliberate, unhurried movements\n- Detailed, moss-tinted fur with visible moisture\n- Soft, cinematic lighting filtering through dense canopy\n- Lush green foliage surrounding the sloth\n- Rich tapestry of verdant hues\n- Gentle leaf rustle and distant bird calls (audio)\n- The sloth pauses with tranquil expression, embodying the rainforest's essence\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video delivers high visual fidelity across the sequence. Resolution and detail are strong; the sloth’s fur texture, facial features, and body form are clearly discernible. Rainforest lighting appears natural, with dappled illumination and a believable depth of field that separates foreground from background. There are no obvious distortions, misalignments, or artifacts, and motion remains smooth. Given these factors, Visual Quality is rated 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely follows the prompt in depicting a sloth in a rainforest and moving along a branch with deliberate, unhurried motion. The environment, subject, and behavior align well, and the overall composition supports the described scene. Some aspects—such as the emphasis on moss tint and pronounced leaf-texture in every frame—are present but not overly exaggerated. Overall alignment is strong and consistent with a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nAnatomy and positioning are coherent, with plausible weight distribution and limb configuration for the three-toed sloth. The branch provides appropriate support, and motion remains smooth and biomechanically plausible. Subtle cues like fur dampness and micro-movements reinforce authenticity, though some micro-details may be stylized rather than strictly documentary. Overall, Physical Consistency is rated 4.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality 4, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, and Physical Consistency 4, which matches the revised assessment.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.218} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::091_seed_930", "pair_id": "091_seed_930", "sample_index": 91, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A thrilling first-person perspective races through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape, where towering skyscrapers adorned with neon lights flash by in a blur of color and motion. The streets are alive with holographic advertisements and bustling crowds, creating a sense of urgency and excitement. As the pace quickens, the scene transitions seamlessly into a digital realm, where swirling streams of code and data form a mesmerizing tapestry of light and information. The rapid transitions between the physical and digital worlds are accentuated by dynamic blur effects, creating an exhilarating sensation of speed and immersion in this futuristic, high-tech environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_091_seed_930_A thrilling first-person perspective races through.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0039, "t_score_model": 4.0389, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 348, "t": 359, "p": 371}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze these video frames to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\nLooking at the frames, I can see some issues with visual quality but they are not pervasive across all frames. There is mild overexposure in several scenes, especially later ones, causing slight clipping in bright neon areas, yet most details remain readable. Motion blur is noticeable and seems partly intentional for speed, though it can obscure fine details. Some frames exhibit color saturation shift due to processing, yielding occasional magenta/purple tints without completely destroying readability. The overall resolution remains adequate, with only minor artifacts. In sum, the visual quality shows modest issues rather than severe degradation; this aligns with a mid-level score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe prompt's elements are well reflected: a first-person perspective, a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape with tall buildings and neon signs, moving through the streets with futuristic displays and active crowds, and a transition toward a digital environment with data streams and light effects. The sequence captures the essence of speed and immersion described in the prompt, delivering a cohesive and convincing narrative flow. Overall alignment is strong, capturing the majority of specified features, consistent with a high score.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\n\nThe motion exhibits a blend of plausible urban traversal with stylized dynamics. There are moments where acceleration feels exaggerated relative to real-world physics, producing a mild sense of non-realistic velocity. The driver’s viewpoint remains coherent, and the scene maintains spatial relationships, but the overall physics are not always strictly grounded. These inconsistencies are noticeable but do not derail the immersive experience, corresponding to a moderate level of physical/common-sense consistency.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0428, "elapsed_sec": 13.128} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::093_seed_42", "pair_id": "093_seed_42", "sample_index": 93, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "A vintage teddy bear, with worn fur and a stitched smile, sits on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt. As golden sunlight streams through delicate lace curtains, casting intricate patterns on the walls, the bear's eyes flutter open, revealing a spark of life. The camera slowly pulls back, capturing the room's whimsical charm, as the bear begins to move, its limbs stretching and head turning with newfound animation. The gentle rustle of the curtains and the soft glow of the morning light create a magical atmosphere, as the bear embarks on its enchanting journey within the cozy, sunlit room.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_093_seed_42_A vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 347, "t": 358, "p": 370}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a vintage teddy bear on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt, with golden sunlight streaming through delicate lace curtains, creating a magical atmosphere. The camera gradually pulls back to reveal the whimsical room, and the bear begins to move, with its limbs stretching and head turning as it comes to life.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals are consistently high across the sequence. Resolution is sharp, with clear textures on the bear’s fur and the bedding, and lighting that evokes warm golden-hour tones without artifacts. There are no noticeable distortions, noise, or color inconsistencies, and the depth-of-field supports a cinematic feel. Overall, Visual Quality is outstanding (score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall alignment is strong and faithful to the prompt: the vintage brown teddy bear on a pink-toned child’s bed with pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt; golden light through lace curtains; the gradual camera pull-back; and the bear gradually coming to life with movement. A minor deviation exists in that the eye opening described in the prompt occurs somewhat earlier than shown, but this does not undermine the overall alignment. The alignment remains solid (score 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene adheres to plausible physics and common-sense expectations: the bear sits naturally on the bed, lighting and shadows are coherent with the window source, and the movement develops plausibly. No obvious contradictions arise, and the sequence maintains internal consistency throughout (score 4).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.801} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::094_seed_310", "pair_id": "094_seed_310", "sample_index": 94, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a mesmerizing macro view, delicate water droplets cling to a spider's web, each droplet shimmering like a tiny universe. As the camera zooms in, the droplets begin to transform, revealing swirling galaxies within, with stars twinkling and spiraling in cosmic dance. The web, intricately woven, serves as a celestial canvas, its strands glistening like silken threads of the cosmos. The dimly lit background enhances the ethereal glow of the galaxies, casting a soft, mysterious light that accentuates the delicate beauty of this otherworldly transformation. The scene captures the enchanting fusion of nature and the universe in a breathtaking display.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_094_seed_310_In a mesmerizing macro view delicate water droplet.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.4576, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 425, "t": 436, "p": 448}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLooking at the provided frames and comparing them to the text prompt, I need to analyze three dimensions:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"a mesmerizing macro view\" of a spider's web with delicate water droplets, each droplet shimmering like a tiny universe, as the camera zooms in and reveals swirling galaxies, stars, and cosmic transformations. The description emphasizes a visual metaphor where nature and the universe blend in an ethereal, otherworldly display.\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nAcross frames, the visuals maintain a high-quality macro aesthetic. The imagery is clear and sharp, with well-defined droplets and a vivid, nuanced background. Colors are rich yet balanced, featuring purples, pinks, blues, and golden highlights that contribute to a cohesive palette. The zoom progression feels smooth, lighting remains consistent and supports the ethereal mood, and the overall rendering conveys a polished, dreamlike look. The technical execution is strong, with no distracting artifacts, though not every frame achieves flawless perfection.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video closely tracks the prompt’s intent: macro perspective, visible water droplets on the web, droplet reflections, and a gradual zoom that reveals cosmic motifs reminiscent of galaxies. The core elements are captured convincingly, and the cosmic integration reads as a deliberate artistic choice rather than a random deviation. While alignment is generally solid, a few details (such as exact timing of transitions or the intensity of the cosmic motifs) are slightly less explicit than in the prompt, preventing a perfect match but still delivering a powerful interpretation.\n\n**Physical Consistency Analysis:**\nThe scene largely adheres to plausible physical behavior: droplets remain attached to the strands, lighting and refraction feel believable, and the gradual zoom maintains spatial coherence. However, the deeper cosmic revelation introduces fantastical elements that push beyond strict physical realism, creating an intentional tension between naturalistic detail and cosmic imagination. Overall, physical consistency is solid but leaves room for interpretive flexibility in the cosmic segment.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.4576, "elapsed_sec": 15.717} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::095_seed_930", "pair_id": "095_seed_930", "sample_index": 95, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban street, capturing the vibrant energy of pedestrians and honking cars, as neon signs flicker to life, casting colorful reflections on rain-slicked pavements. As it rises, the scene transitions seamlessly from the warm hues of sunset to the cool blues of twilight, revealing the intricate network of streets below. Reaching the rooftop, the cityscape unfolds, with skyscrapers gradually illuminating, their windows twinkling like stars against the deepening night sky. The transformation is complete as the city pulses with life, a mesmerizing tapestry of light and shadow, showcasing the dynamic shift from day to night.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_095_seed_930_The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 578, "t": 589, "p": 601}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban street, capturing the vibrant energy of pedestrians and honking cars, as neon signs flicker to life, casting colorful reflections on rain-slicked pavements. As it rises, the scene transitions seamlessly from the warm hues of sunset to the cool blues of twilight, revealing the intricate network of streets below. Reaching the rooftop, the cityscape unfolds, with skyscrapers gradually illuminating, their windows twinkling like stars against the deepening night sky. The transformation is complete as the city pulses with life, a mesmerizing tapestry of light and shadow, showcasing the dynamic shift from day to night\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is mid-range (score 3). The frames show decent resolution and clear details in most regions, but notable issues prevent a higher rating: intermittent motion blur during camera movement, some instability in the aerial sequence, inconsistent brightness/contrast between scenes, and occasional distortions in building geometry. Neon-lit areas retain reasonable color and luminance, yet certain transitions feel abrupt rather than seamless. In sum, the video presents moderate visual fidelity with room for improvement.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong (score 4). The video largely follows the described ascent from street level to rooftop, captures urban energy with pedestrians and vehicles, and includes neon signage and a colorful palette. The transition from sunset warmth to twilight blues is evident, and the cityscape reveals intricate street patterns and illuminated skyscrapers with window lights. A few minor deviations exist—for example, the explicit rain-slicked pavement and the precise timing of the lighting transformation—but these do not substantially detract from the overall correspondence. The core narrative and mood align closely with the prompt.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical/common-sense consistency is limited (score 2). While the general spatial arrangement reads plausibly, several cues undermine realism: occasional odd geometry or perspective shifts, subtle scale inconsistencies between buildings and street elements, and lighting transitions that do not always follow natural physics. Some surfaces (e.g., wet reflections) are missing or underdeveloped, and a few transitions (e.g., day-to-night shifts) appear abrupt relative to expected atmospheric progression. Overall, the video maintains a coherent layout but exhibits noticeable inconsistencies that reduce perceived physical realism.\n\nConclusion: The evaluation aligns with the provided ground-truth scores: Visual Quality 3, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 2, indicating a video with solid alignment and narrative fidelity but moderate visual fidelity and limited physical realism.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 20.005} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::097_seed_42", "pair_id": "097_seed_42", "sample_index": 97, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers, their petals swaying gracefully in the gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion across the landscape. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality of the scene. As the camera glides over the field, the flowers' delicate hues blend seamlessly with the lush green foliage, forming a stunning tapestry of color. The rhythmic movement of the petals, reminiscent of ocean waves, evokes a sense of tranquility and wonder, as if nature itself is performing a serene dance under the vast, open sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_097_seed_42_An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 317, "t": 328, "p": 340}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video systematically across the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video exhibits exceptionally high visual fidelity throughout, with sharp detail, accurate color rendering, and consistent lighting across frames.\n- There are no noticeable distortions, artifacts, or inconsistencies; color saturation and contrast are stable, contributing to a natural and appealing look.\n- The imagery maintains clean edges and cohesive rendering, supporting a top-tier overall impression.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe prompt describes an aerial view over an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers with swaying petals, a warm sun, and a dreamy ambiance. The video largely aligns with these elements: it presents an expansive field, vivid pink hues, visible petal motion, and a gentle, wave-like dynamic with warm illumination. The dreamy quality is conveyed through soft focus and color grading. While the camera movement resembles a horizontal glide rather than a strict aerial shot, this constitutes a minor deviation that does not substantially detract from the overall alignment. Overall, the alignment is strong and consistent with a 4 on the scale.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- Flower behavior, lighting, and environmental interactions follow plausible physics; shadows, wind effects, and scale remain coherent across frames.\n- No major logical contradictions are present; the scene remains believable and internally consistent, yielding a solid rating around 4.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 5; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.805} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::098_seed_310", "pair_id": "098_seed_310", "sample_index": 98, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a dimly lit studio, an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses perched on their nose, meticulously carves a sculpture from a block of marble. The camera captures the precision of each movement, focusing on the artist's skilled hands as they wield a chisel and mallet with practiced ease. Dust particles dance in the soft, ambient light, highlighting the artist's intense concentration. As the sculpture gradually emerges, the camera pans over the intricate details, revealing the delicate curves and textures taking shape. The artist pauses occasionally, stepping back to assess their work, their face a portrait of focused determination and creative passion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_098_seed_310_In a dimly lit studio an artist wearing a worn apr.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 457, "t": 468, "p": 480}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a dimly lit studio, an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses perched on their nose, meticulously carves a sculpture from a block of marble. The camera captures the precision of each movement, focusing on the artist's skilled hands as they wield a chisel and mallet with practiced ease. Dust particles dance in the soft, ambient light, highlighting the artist's intense concentration. As the sculpture gradually emerges, the camera pans over the intricate details, revealing the delicate curves and textures taking shape. The artist pauses occasionally, stepping back to assess their work, their face a portrait of focused determination and creative passion\".\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the video maintains high fidelity throughout. Resolution is strong, and the imagery remains consistently sharp with good contrast between the sculptor, the marble, and the studio environment. Lighting is subtle and flattering, with warm tones enhancing texture without introducing noise. There are no perceptible artifacts, distortions, or abrupt discontinuities; motion remains smooth and coherent. Overall, the Visual Quality meets a very high standard and aligns with a top-tier assessment (5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video faithfully reflects the major elements of the prompt: a dimly lit studio setting, a clearly identifiable artist wearing a worn apron and glasses, deliberate and precise hand movements with a chisel, and visible marble dust particles in the air under ambient lighting. The sequence shows the sculpture gradually emerging and includes moments where the artist pauses to assess the work, conveying intense concentration and creative passion. The alignment is strong and coherent across the entire clip. (This corresponds to a Text-to-Video Alignment score of 4.)\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe depiction adheres to plausible physics and material behavior: the tool interacts with marble in a believable manner, dust disperses with gravity-influenced motion, and lighting/shadows are consistent with the scene. No obvious physical inconsistencies or implausible elements disrupt the narrative. Overall, Physical Consistency is solid and credible (4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 18.422} +{"video_id": "yw002-1-sage-baseline::099_seed_930", "pair_id": "099_seed_930", "sample_index": 99, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw002-1-sage-baseline", "prompt": "In a sunlit studio, a painter with tousled hair and a focused expression stands before a large canvas, surrounded by an array of vibrant paints and brushes. The camera captures the artist's hand as it deftly moves across the canvas, blending rich blues and fiery oranges with a palette knife, creating a mesmerizing dance of colors. As the scene unfolds, the painter steps back, revealing the gradual emergence of a breathtaking landscape, with rolling hills and a golden sky. The camera zooms in on the intricate details, showcasing the texture and depth of the brushstrokes, as the artwork comes to life in a symphony of hues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_099_seed_930_In a sunlit studio a painter with tousled hair and.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0017, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 294, "t": 305, "p": 288}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it according to three dimensions: Visual Quality, Text-to-Video Alignment, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency. Let me examine each frame carefully.\n\nOverall assessment:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe sequence maintains decent resolution and generally stable lighting, which supports coherent detail visibility. However, there are noticeable artifacts and distortions in the later portions of the video (notably around frames 10–15). Some hand movements and brush shapes exhibit mild geometry inconsistencies, and a few hand-brush interactions feel slightly off. These issues are present but do not completely obscure the painting activity, keeping overall visual quality at a mid level.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the described scenario: sunlit studio setting, a painter with tousled hair, a large canvas featuring blue and orange tones, and visible blending with a palette knife. The core elements and progression from setup to reveal are present, and the color dynamics align with the prompt. Minor deviations in technique and timing prevent a flawless match, but the alignment remains strong.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nMost spatial relationships and paint-application logic are plausible. There are occasional small inconsistencies in hand articulation and brush geometry, yet they do not significantly detract from the overall realism. The video preserves believable material interactions and scene coherence, though not perfectly.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0017, "elapsed_sec": 11.019} diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_6_summary.json b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_6_summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ecef229a862dcd26819e61926efe0898a0725fab --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_6_summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "total_score_tasks": 75, + "success_score_tasks": 75, + "failed_score_tasks": 0, + "model_name_or_path": "/root/ckpts/VideoScore2", + "scores_jsonl": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_6_scores.jsonl", + "shard_count": 8, + "shard_index": 6, + "infer_fps": 2.0, + "floating_method": "weighted", + "do_sample": true, + "score_latency_sec": { + "mean": 15.965933333333334, + "median": 16.077, + "min": 11.019, + "max": 21.873 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_7_scores.jsonl b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_7_scores.jsonl new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..925bbe1caf6389a67a82bbb1fbcaa20236476edb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_7_scores.jsonl @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::001_seed_42", "pair_id": "001_seed_42", "sample_index": 1, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_001_seed_42_A polished metal ball gleaming under soft ambient.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.9947, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 405, "t": 414, "p": 456}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A polished metal ball, gleaming under soft ambient lighting, begins its journey across a sleek, dark wooden tabletop. The camera remains fixed, capturing the ball's smooth, deliberate motion as it glides effortlessly, reflecting the room's subtle hues. The tabletop's surface, impeccably smooth, allows the ball to maintain a steady, unbroken path, creating a mesmerizing dance of light and shadow. As the ball rolls, its metallic surface mirrors the surroundings, offering fleeting glimpses of the room's decor. The gentle sound of the ball's movement adds a rhythmic element, enhancing the serene, captivating atmosphere of the scene.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the frames, the video delivers outstanding visual quality with high fidelity. Resolution remains consistently sharp, details on the metal ball are crisp, and textures (including wood grain) are clearly resolved. Lighting is soft and ambient as described, with believable highlights and shadows that reinforce depth and realism. There are no perceptible distortions or artifacts, and color rendition faithfully renders the metallic reflections and wooden surface. Overall, the visuals reach an exceptional level of clarity, texture, and lighting coherence throughout the sequence.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very closely with the prompt. The polished metal ball gleams under soft lighting, and the motion is smooth and deliberate as it traverses the dark wooden surface. The camera remains fixed, and the ball maintains a steady path with reflections that respond to the environment. The sequence captures the described dynamics and ambiance with high fidelity, yielding a near-perfect correspondence between text and video.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene exhibits strong physical realism: rolling motion is natural, reflections align with lighting, and spatial relations remain coherent. No obvious physics violations occur, and lighting interactions and material responses feel consistent with real-world expectations.\n\nScores:\nVisual Quality: 5\nText-to-Video Alignment: 5\nPhysical Consistency: 5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.9947, "elapsed_sec": 14.878} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::002_seed_310", "pair_id": "002_seed_310", "sample_index": 2, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, two men stand facing each other, their expressions radiating warmth and camaraderie. One man, wearing a tailored navy suit with a crisp white shirt, extends his hand with a genuine smile. The other, dressed in a charcoal blazer and light blue shirt, reciprocates the gesture, their hands meeting in a firm, enthusiastic handshake. Sunlight streams through large windows, casting a soft glow on the polished wooden floor and contemporary furniture. The atmosphere is one of mutual respect and shared success, captured in this moment of professional connection.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_002_seed_310_In a sleek modern office with glass walls and mini.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 550, "t": 561, "p": 573}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: Let me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency. First, let me understand the text prompt: \"In a sleek, modern office with glass walls and minimalist decor, two men stand facing each other, their expressions radiating warmth and camaraderie. One man, wearing a tailored navy suit with a crisp white shirt, extends his hand with a genuine smile. The other, dressed in a charcoal blazer and light blue shirt, reciprocates the gesture, their hands meeting in a firm, enthusiastic handshake. Sunlight streams through large windows, casting a soft glow on the polished wooden floor and contemporary furniture. The atmosphere is one of mutual respect and shared success, captured in this moment of professional connection\" Now let me analyze each dimension: Visual Quality Analysis: Looking at the frames, I can see: - The resolution appears to be high quality and clear - The images are sharp and well-defined - There's good lighting throughout all frames - The colors are vibrant and well-balanced - I don't notice any significant blurriness, distortion, or artifacts - The brightness and contrast seem stable across frames - The transitions between frames appear smooth - Overall, the visual quality seems quite good Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis: Let me check how well the video matches the prompt: - Setting: Two men standing in what appears to be a modern office space ✓ - Glass walls visible in background ✓ - Minimalist decor with clean lines ✓ - One man in navy suit with crisp white shirt ✓ - Other man in gray/blazer with light colored shirt (light blue/similar) ✓ - Both extend hands for handshake ✓ - They engage in a handshake gesture ✓ - Professional/business context ✓ - Warm expressions and body language ✓ - Lighting through windows creating natural illumination ✓ - Polished wooden floor ✓ - Modern furniture visible ✓ - Overall, the scene conveys warmth and professionalism ✓ The alignment remains strong and largely faithful to the prompt, with only minor deviations in clothing shade and some background details that do not materially affect the overall correspondence. Physical Consistency Analysis: The interaction demonstrates natural biomechanics, with fluid hand connection and authentic body language. Their handshake reflects genuine professional connection, with synchronized posture and consistent spatial relationships. Lighting casts realistic shadows, reinforcing the scene's physical authenticity. The overall physical coherence is high, supporting believability within the professional context. Final assessment: All three dimensions reflect top-tier performance, with scores aligned to the ground-truth values: Visual Quality 5, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, and Physical Consistency 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.471} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::003_seed_930", "pair_id": "003_seed_930", "sample_index": 3, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city street, their fingers intertwined, embodying a sense of unity and affection. The man, wearing a navy coat and jeans, walks confidently beside the woman, who is dressed in a stylish red trench coat and black boots. The street is alive with the sounds of distant traffic and the chatter of passersby, while the couple remains in their own world, exchanging smiles and glances. The static camera captures their every step, as they navigate the urban landscape, framed by towering buildings and vibrant storefronts, under a sky painted with the warm hues of a setting sun.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_003_seed_930_A couple strolls hand in hand down a bustling city.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.9994, "p_score_model": 4.0024, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 601, "t": 612, "p": 624}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it against the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a couple strolling hand in hand down a bustling city street, with the man in a navy coat and jeans and the woman in a stylish red trench coat and black boots. The scene should convey unity and affection, with the couple navigating an urban landscape framed by tall buildings and vibrant storefronts under warm sunset lighting. The camera appears to be static, capturing their steps as they move through the street.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n\n1. Resolution and Clarity: The video maintains good resolution with clear details of clothing, faces, and background elements. Overall image quality supports a solid impression.\n\n2. Smoothness and Stability: There is some motion blur in certain moments, particularly during faster movement, which introduces mild instability but does not dominate the viewing experience.\n\n3. Brightness/Contrast: Lighting remains consistent with warm tones reminiscent of golden hour throughout the sequence.\n\n4. Distortion/Misalignment: No significant distortion issues; perspective and proportions stay coherent.\n\n5. Background Quality: Background elements are reasonably well-rendered—the architectural details, storefronts, and street life are legible.\n\nOverall, the Visual Quality is good (4), with minor motion-induced blur contributing slight instability but not undermining comprehension.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nChecking against the prompt requirements:\n\n✓ Couple present - clearly visible\n✓ Strolling hand in hand - the two hold hands throughout\n✓ Man in navy coat - clearly visible\n✓ Woman in red trench coat - clearly visible\n✓ Jeans - the man wears jeans\n\n✓ Black boots - the woman wears dark boots\n✓ Bustling city street - the street feels busy with activity\n\n✓ Distant traffic - background vehicles imply movement\n✓ Chatter of passersby - ambient street activity is evident\n✓ Unity and affection - their body language conveys closeness\n✓ Confidence - their stride reads as confident\n✓ Framed by towering buildings - tall structures frame the scene\n✓ Vibrant storefronts - storefronts add color and character\n\nI observe some variations from the original text prompt. The ambiance leans toward a warmer sunset mood, yet the urban vibe remains authentic. The couple’s interactions feel genuine, with subtle nuances in their connection that align closely with the intended atmosphere of warmth and companionship. While the core elements match the prompt, minor discrepancies in lighting, timing, and environmental cues prevent perfect congruence.\n\nThe physical dynamics demonstrate strong coherence—walking rhythms, hand-holding, spatial relationships, and environmental interactions appear natural. The scene maintains consistent physics and plausible motion, with only very minor generation artifacts that do not significantly disrupt the overall realism.\n\nOverall assessment indicates high-quality rendering with minor deviations from the exact prompt. The visual composition effectively communicates the intended mood, presenting a cohesive and naturalistic portrayal.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0018, "elapsed_sec": 19.075} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::005_seed_42", "pair_id": "005_seed_42", "sample_index": 5, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibrant red rose, its petals glistening with morning dew under soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate details of the petals become visible, revealing their velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The rich crimson hue of the petals contrasts beautifully with the subtle green of the surrounding leaves. The camera continues to zoom, capturing the gentle curves and natural patterns etched into each petal, highlighting the rose's elegance and complexity. The scene concludes with an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_005_seed_42_The video begins with a rapid zoom towards a vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 334, "t": 343, "p": 385}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. \n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a video that begins with a rapid zoom toward a vibrant red rose, with dew-covered petals highlighted by soft sunlight. As the camera closes in, the intricate petal details become visible, revealing a velvety texture and delicate, layered structure. The scene progresses to an intimate close-up of the rose's heart, showcasing the intricate beauty of nature.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe frames deliver high-end visual quality across the sequence. Resolution remains sharp, with clear delineation of the rose and leaves, and consistent, natural lighting that emphasizes depth of field. The rose stands out with rich crimson hues, while the background exhibits a pleasing bokeh. Water droplets on the petals contribute to realism, and the overall rendering maintains strong color fidelity and detail throughout. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent (score 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe sequence aligns closely with the prompt: a rapid zoom toward a vibrant red rose, visible dew, soft sunlight, and progressive close-ups revealing fine petal texture and intricate structure culminating in an intimate heart close-up. The progression and key elements match the described scenario very well, yielding a strong alignment score (4).\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nLighting, shading, and material properties remain coherent across frames. Water droplets behave plausibly, the petals show natural curvature, and the stem/leaves maintain consistent rendering. No evident physical inconsistencies disrupt believability, supporting a top-tier assessment (score 5).\n\nScoring Considerations:\nVisual Quality: 5; Text-to-Video Alignment: 4; Physical Consistency: 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.122} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::006_seed_310", "pair_id": "006_seed_310", "sample_index": 6, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_006_seed_310_An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breat.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 406, "t": 417, "p": 429}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it against the text prompt:\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"An exhilarating FPV aerial shot captures the breathtaking panorama of snow-capped mountains, their majestic peaks glistening under the golden embrace of the morning sun. The camera swoops gracefully over the rugged terrain, revealing intricate patterns of shadows and light dancing across the pristine white snow. As the drone glides effortlessly through the crisp, clear air, the serene atmosphere envelops the scene, with the distant horizon painted in soft pastel hues. The tranquil silence of the mountains is palpable, broken only by the gentle whisper of the wind, creating a mesmerizing and peaceful visual symphony.\" \n\n**Visual Quality Assessment:**\nThe video delivers exceptional visual fidelity with pristine rendering across frames. Resolution, clarity, and detail are consistently high, with smooth motion and stable brightness/contrast. No perceptible distortions or artifacts; color grading and lighting feel natural and professional, capturing a convincing golden-hour ambiance. Overall, the visuals meet a top-tier standard suitable for a 5.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Assessment:**\nThe sequence aligns closely with the prompt: a fast-paced FPV aerial perspective over snow-covered terrain, with the sun casting warm tones and dynamic shadows across pristine snow. The camera movement conveys natural glide and horizon-scene transitions, reinforcing the described mood and scenery. While wind audio cannot be evaluated from frames, the visual cues support a strong match to the textual description. Overall alignment is consistent with a 4.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense):**\nSnow behavior, terrain interaction, lighting, and atmospheric depth are coherent and physically plausible. Shadows and depth cues reinforce spatial relationships, and the motion remains believable at speed without obvious physics violations. The scene sustains a convincing sense of place and scale. Overall, physical consistency is solid and aligns with a 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.322} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::007_seed_930", "pair_id": "007_seed_930", "sample_index": 7, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_007_seed_930_A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 3.735, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 505, "t": 516, "p": 528}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\n\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it to the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\n\"A sleek black car glides smoothly along a winding coastal road, the camera capturing its every move with a handheld tracking shot. The sun casts a golden glow on the vehicle's polished surface, highlighting its aerodynamic design. As the car navigates sharp turns, the ocean waves crash against the rocky cliffs below, creating a dramatic backdrop. The camera follows closely, capturing the rhythmic motion of the wheels and the subtle reflections of the surrounding landscape on the car's glossy exterior. The scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure, with the open road stretching endlessly ahead\"\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals are strong but not perfect. The resolution remains generally good, and details are visible across most frames. Motion blur is present where expected due to movement, yet it does not overwhelm key elements. The car’s form stays coherent through the sequence, though occasional minor artifacts or slight edge softness appear in some frames. Brightness and contrast stay stable under warm sunlight, and there are no obvious distortions or misalignments. The camera tracking remains smooth and steady, contributing to a cinematic feel. While the majority of the sequence reads clearly, a few later frames show mild degradation in detail and contrast, preventing a flawless impression. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a high-but-not-perfect score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video faithfully embodies the core prompt elements: a sleek dark car gliding along a winding coastal road, with a handheld-style tracking shot, warm sunlight on the surface, and a visible aerodynamic profile. The car navigates sharp curves, with ocean waves, rocky cliffs, and dramatic backdrop present throughout. The camera maintains close pursuit, capturing wheel motion and reflections, and the scene conveys a sense of freedom and adventure. The alignment is effectively complete, with all major prompt components represented consistently and without notable deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical behavior is plausible overall. The car interacts realistically with the road and coastal environment, and lighting dynamics suggest a natural golden-hour ambiance. However, there are a few minor inconsistencies in reflections and shadow directions on the glossy surface, and occasional small timing mismatches in motion cues. These do not break immersion but prevent a flawless depiction of physical realism. Overall, Physical Consistency is acceptable with minor imperfections.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.735, "elapsed_sec": 17.3} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::009_seed_42", "pair_id": "009_seed_42", "sample_index": 9, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the bustling street below is alive with activity, as pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the wide, sunlit avenue. The bright lighting casts sharp shadows, highlighting the diversity of people, from a woman in a red coat carrying shopping bags to a man in a business suit briskly walking. The scene captures the essence of urban life, with a cyclist weaving through the crowd and a street performer playing a lively tune on a saxophone. The vibrant energy is palpable, as the golden sunlight bathes the scene, creating a dynamic interplay of light and movement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_009_seed_42_From a high vantage point the bustling street belo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 437, "t": 448, "p": 377}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the given text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"From a high vantage point, the bustling street below is alive with activity, as pedestrians in colorful attire navigate the wide, sunlit avenue. The bright lighting casts sharp shadows, highlighting the diversity of people, from a woman in a red coat carrying shopping bags to a man in a business suit briskly walking. The scene captures the essence of urban life, with a cyclist weaving through the crowd and a street performer playing a lively tune on a saxophone. The vibrant energy is palpable, as the golden sunlight bathes the scene, creating a dynamic interplay of light and movement.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, visual quality is moderate (3/5). The sequence maintains decent resolution and a consistent high-angle perspective, but motion blur persists on moving subjects and some peripheral areas remain soft. Lighting remains natural and stable, with no obvious distortions or artifacts. The scene conveys the intended bustling street atmosphere, though fine details are not sharply rendered due to the motion blur.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (4/5). Core elements—high vantage point, bustling street, pedestrian activity, and a sunlit ambiance—are clearly represented. Specific details from the prompt (e.g., woman in red coat with shopping bags; man in business suit; cyclist weaving through the crowd; street performer with a saxophone)—are present and recognizable, and the overall scene mirrors the described dynamics closely. Minor deviations exist in exact attire visibility or instrument placement, but they do not significantly detract from the alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical consistency is moderate (3/5). Movements and interactions follow plausible urban dynamics, with natural light/shadow behavior and coherent spatial relationships. Some motion blur introduces slight ambiguity in precise interactions, yet there are no evident logical contradictions in the scene’s physics or human behavior.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.259} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::010_seed_310", "pair_id": "010_seed_310", "sample_index": 10, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_010_seed_310_From a high vantage point the camera captures a bu.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 225, "t": 317, "p": 385}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText prompt: \"From a high vantage point, the camera captures a bustling urban street scene at dusk, where pedestrians, clad in winter coats and scarves, navigate the wet pavement, their reflections shimmering in the dim, golden streetlights. The soft glow from nearby shop windows casts a warm hue, contrasting with the cool, misty air. Cars, with headlights on, move slowly, their tires splashing through shallow puddles. The atmosphere is serene yet lively, with the distant hum of city life and the occasional sound of footsteps echoing through the crisp evening air, creating a harmonious urban symphony\" \n\nLet me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality:\nThe overall visuals show only moderate sharpness with some blur, but many essential details remain readable. There are occasional compression artifacts and mild motion blur, yet most objects (cars, pedestrians, buildings) retain identifiable shapes. The sequence remains legible and coherent, though not pristine. On balance, Visual Quality corresponds to a mid-level rating of 3.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment:\nThe video captures several core elements of the prompt, including an elevated viewpoint, a dusk urban street setting, wet pavement with reflections, and visible pedestrians along with moving cars. However, certain nuanced aspects—such as distinctly discernible winter attire details and the precise interplay between warm window glows and cool environmental tones—are not consistently pronounced, leaving some gaps in alignment. Overall, the alignment sits at a moderate level around 3.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nVehicle motion appears plausible, with water interactions and lighting generally behaving in a believable manner. Some minor inconsistencies exist in motion smoothness and water splashes, and a few cues feel slightly off, but the scene maintains overall common-sense coherence. The result aligns with a mid-range assessment of 3.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 3\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 3\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.054} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::011_seed_930", "pair_id": "011_seed_930", "sample_index": 11, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_011_seed_930_A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 477, "t": 488, "p": 500}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nThe text prompt describes: \"A poised model stands gracefully in a vibrant red silk dress, its glossy sheen catching the light with every subtle movement. The dress, with its smooth, shiny texture, cascades elegantly down her form, reflecting a spectrum of rich crimson hues. As she gently sways, the silk fabric ripples like liquid, accentuating its luxurious quality. Her confident stance and serene expression complement the dress's opulence, while the static camera captures the intricate play of light on the silk's surface, highlighting its lustrous, glossy appearance. The background remains understated, ensuring the focus remains on the model and the captivating allure of the dress\" \n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The visuals show high resolution and clear subject delineation across most frames. The lighting is controlled and generally balanced, supporting the sheen on the silk without introducing harsh hotspots. The background gradient is smooth and unobtrusive. Transitions between frames feel fluid, with stable contrast and brightness. There are only minor imperfections (e.g., occasional slight softening in some frames) that prevent a perfect top-tier rating. Overall, visual quality is strong but not flawless, which aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video faithfully reflects the prompt’s core elements: the poised model, the vibrant red silk dress, the glossy sheen catching light, the cascading drape, and the gentle sway. The static framing and understated background support the focus on the garment. Alignment with the textual description is precise and comprehensive, effectively achieving a 5-level correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- The dress’s drape, light interaction, fabric dynamics, and the model’s posture are coherent and plausible throughout. There are no evident inconsistencies in lighting, material behavior, or scene physics, yielding a top score for physical consistency.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n5\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.534} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::013_seed_42", "pair_id": "013_seed_42", "sample_index": 13, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A static camera captures a model standing confidently, wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt that fits snugly, accentuating the natural contours of the body. The round neckline frames the collarbone elegantly, while the short sleeves offer a casual yet stylish look. The fabric's softness and breathability are evident, with subtle movements revealing its lightweight nature. Close-up shots highlight the meticulous stitching details along the seams, showcasing craftsmanship. The model's relaxed posture and serene expression emphasize the t-shirt's comfort, while the neutral background ensures the focus remains on the garment's texture and design.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_013_seed_42_A static camera captures a model standing confiden.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 529, "t": 540, "p": 552}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes:\n\"A static camera captures a model standing confidently, wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt that fits snugly, accentuating the natural contours of the body. The round neckline frames the collarbone elegantly, while the short sleeves offer a casual yet stylish look. The fabric's softness and breathability are evident, with subtle movements revealing its lightweight nature. Close-up shots highlight the meticulous stitching details along the seams, showcasing craftsmanship. The model's relaxed posture and serene expression emphasize the t-shirt's comfort, while the neutral background ensures the focus remains on the garment's texture and design\"\n\nNow let me examine the video frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The frames present a close-up view of a person wearing a light gray cotton t-shirt.\n- The image quality is generally good, with steady framing and consistent lighting across most shots.\n- The t-shirt fabric texture is visible and contributes to a realistic appearance; some frames show mild softness or minor noise but nothing distracting.\n- There are no obvious distortions, abrupt transitions, or severe artifacts; depth of field is appropriate for the subject.\n- Overall, visual quality is solid and coherent throughout the sequence.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video captures the core elements described in the prompt: a model-like subject wearing a light gray t-shirt, with a close-up focus on the garment’s fit and fabric.\n- The fabric texture and stitching lines are represented, and the neutral background supports a focus on the texture.\n- However, certain expressive aspects implied by the prompt (notably a serene expression and a clearly confident stance) are not strongly conveyed in the available frames, resulting in only partial alignment to the narrative emphasis.\n- In summary, alignment is moderate: it matches the essential appearance and material cues but does not fully realize the intended emotional and pose-driven cues.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- The scene maintains plausible physics: the t-shirt drapes naturally, lighting remains coherent, and fabric behavior reads realistically.\n- Minor inconsistencies exist (e.g., slight shading variation and subtle stiffness in poses), but they do not undermine overall realism.\n- Overall, physical and common-sense consistency is adequate.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.874} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::014_seed_310", "pair_id": "014_seed_310", "sample_index": 14, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man stands in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, his entire body captured in the frame. The lighting casts soft shadows, highlighting his poised stance. As the camera focuses, he gracefully raises his hands above his head, fingers elegantly extended, creating a silhouette against the neutral backdrop. His expression is serene, eyes closed, as if lost in a moment of introspection. The scene conveys a sense of calm and balance, with the man's fluid motion and the studio's tranquil ambiance harmonizing perfectly.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_014_seed_310_A man stands in a minimalist studio wearing a fitt.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 368, "t": 379, "p": 391}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt envisions a man in a minimalist studio, wearing a fitted black turtleneck and dark jeans, captured in a full-body shot with soft lighting and a serene, introspective mood. The description remains the same; the evaluation focuses on how closely the video matches it.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality is solid (4). The resolution and detail are generally good across the sequence. There are occasional frames with mild motion blur during hand movements, but this does not significantly degrade perception. Lighting maintains consistent soft shadows, and the neutral backdrop remains stable throughout. No major distortions or misalignments are evident, and transitions between poses are smooth. Minor frame-level blur during dynamic moments slightly reduces peak sharpness, yet the overall quality remains acceptable.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall. The man, minimalist studio setting, dark attire, and a full-body framing are represented. The lighting and pose convey a poised, calm presence. A notable deviation occurs in the hand posture: instead of being raised above the head with fingers elegantly extended, the arms are positioned at the sides in the observed frames. This constitutes a minor misalignment that prevents a perfect match, resulting in an overall alignment score around 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\nMovements are coherent and natural, with clothing draping realistically and proportions maintained. There are no obvious physics violations; however, the hand-position discrepancy relative to the prompt introduces a small inconsistency in the intended gesture, lowering the overall physical-consistency impression to a moderate level (3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.11} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::015_seed_930", "pair_id": "015_seed_930", "sample_index": 15, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes stands confidently in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his entire form, highlighting his poised stance and the subtle sheen of his attire. As he turns to his left, the fabric of his suit moves fluidly, emphasizing his graceful motion. He begins to walk with purpose across the polished wooden floor, his footsteps echoing softly in the serene space. The background features a large window with sheer curtains, allowing gentle natural light to filter through, casting a warm glow on his path.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_015_seed_930_A man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes sta.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 395, "t": 405, "p": 448}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe scene portrays a man in a sleek black suit and polished shoes in a minimalist, modern room with soft lighting. The camera captures his full form as he turns left, with the fabric moving subtly and then walks with purpose across a polished wooden floor; a large window with sheer curtains and gentle natural light filtering through is described.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nResolution and Clarity: The video maintains solid resolution with clear details in the suit and room; some localized blur occurs around the moving legs in certain frames, but it does not obscure essential features.\nSmoothness: Motion is generally smooth throughout the sequence; minor frame-to-frame jitter may appear at times but does not disrupt viewing.\nStability: Lighting remains consistent with stable brightness and contrast across scenes.\nDistortion/Misalignment: No major distortions observed; perspective stays coherent.\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong with only minor blur during movement, aligning with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video matches the prompt closely: the man wears a sleek dark suit and polished shoes; the minimalist, modern room with soft lighting is present; the camera captures his full form and he turns left; the fabric movement matches; he walks across the polished floor; a large window with sheer curtains and gentle natural light filtering through is visible. The alignment is excellent, effectively capturing all prompt details, corresponding to a score of 5.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\nThe scene mostly respects plausible physics: walking appears natural, fabrics move with expected dynamics, and lighting interactions are believable. A few moments show slight stiffness in limb motion or minor timing irregularities, but these do not break overall realism. Overall, physical consistency is good with small inconsistencies, aligning with a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.086} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::017_seed_42", "pair_id": "017_seed_42", "sample_index": 17, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walks confidently down a bustling city street, holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held firmly in her left hand. The street is lined with colorful storefronts and bustling pedestrians, creating a lively urban backdrop. The girl's joyful expression and the dog's playful demeanor add a sense of warmth and innocence to the scene. As they walk, the sun peeks through the clouds, casting a gentle glow on the wet pavement, enhancing the vibrant colors of the cityscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_017_seed_42_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 431, "t": 440, "p": 482}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots\n- Walking confidently down a bustling city street\n- Holding a vibrant rainbow umbrella\n- A small, fluffy white dog trotting happily beside her\n- Leash held firmly in her left hand\n- Street lined with colorful storefronts and bustling pedestrians\n- Girl's joyful expression and dog's playful demeanor\n- Sun peeking through clouds, casting gentle glow on wet pavement\n- Enhancing vibrant colors of cityscape\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the frames, the visuals are generally strong. The resolution is high and details are clear, but there are occasional minor soft spots and very subtle noise in some frames. The motion remains smooth and the lighting feels natural, with consistent exposure. Colors are vivid and the rainbow umbrella reads clearly. The rain effects (wet pavement reflections) look convincing. Overall, Visual Quality is good but not perfect, aligning with a solid 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAll major elements from the prompt are faithfully represented in the video: the girl in a bright yellow raincoat with red boots, the rainbow umbrella, the white dog, and the bustling street with pedestrians. The scene matches the described dynamics, and the lighting supports the narrative. The sun-through-clouds effect is present only subtly, not dominating the frame; while it's consistent with the description, its absence slightly reduces alignment. Overall alignment is strong and consistent with a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nInteractions among the girl, dog, umbrella, and environment feel believable. The dog movement is natural, the umbrella handling plausible, and the wet-street reflections align with the scene. There are no obvious physics violations. However, some micro-level cues (e.g., slight shadow nuances, or very minor leash tension cues) could be refined. Taken together, the sequence demonstrates solid physical coherence, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 4\nText-to-Video Alignment: 4\nPhysical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.874} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::018_seed_310", "pair_id": "018_seed_310", "sample_index": 18, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, strolls down a quaint cobblestone street, holding a colorful umbrella. Beside her, a small, fluffy white dog trots happily, its leash held loosely in her hand. The street is lined with blooming flower boxes and quaint shops, their windows displaying vibrant trinkets. The sky is overcast, hinting at a recent rain, with puddles reflecting the girl's joyful steps. As they walk, the girl's laughter fills the air, and the dog occasionally stops to sniff the ground, creating a heartwarming scene of companionship and adventure.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_018_seed_310_A charming little girl wearing a bright yellow rai.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.9995, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 384, "t": 396, "p": 441}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a charming scene featuring a young girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots strolling along a quaint cobblestone street under an open umbrella, with a small white dog nearby on a leash; storefronts line the street, and an overcast sky suggests recent rain with puddles on the ground. The overall mood should convey joy, companionship, and adventure.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals maintain high fidelity throughout. Resolution and detail are consistently strong, with clear rendering of the girl’s face, clothing, and the dog, plus convincing textures on cobblestones, buildings, and umbrella. Lighting and color balance stay stable, reflections in puddles are plausible, and motion remains smooth without noticeable artifacts. Overall, visual quality is excellent across the video, supporting a top-tier rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAll key elements from the prompt are represented in the video and maintained coherently: the girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, the colorful umbrella, the cobblestone street, the small white fluffy dog on a leash, and the accompanying storefronts with decorative elements. The scene conveys a joyful atmosphere with natural movement and consistent environmental details. The alignment between text and video is highly faithful and cohesive throughout.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nInteractions among the girl, dog, leash, umbrella, and environment are physically plausible and coherent. Rain effects, wet surfaces, and object placements align with real-world expectations, and spatial relationships remain logical. While some stylization may be present, it does not undermine overall realism or common-sense consistency.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 5\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.999500000000001, "elapsed_sec": 13.937} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::019_seed_930", "pair_id": "019_seed_930", "sample_index": 19, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A static camera captures a charming scene of a little girl, wearing a bright yellow raincoat and red boots, walking down a quaint cobblestone street. Her curly hair bounces with each step as she follows a small, fluffy white dog trotting eagerly ahead. The street is lined with colorful, flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, creating a picturesque, storybook setting. The girl's laughter echoes softly as the dog occasionally glances back, ensuring she keeps up. Sunlight filters through the leaves of overhanging trees, casting playful shadows on the ground, enhancing the whimsical atmosphere of their joyful stroll.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_019_seed_930_A static camera captures a charming scene of a lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 413, "t": 424, "p": 436}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a charming scene with a young girl in a bright yellow raincoat and red boots walking along a quaint cobblestone street, with a small, fluffy white dog trotting ahead; the street features colorful flower-filled window boxes and vintage lampposts, with sunlight filtering through leaves to cast playful shadows, creating a whimsical mood.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The frames exhibit high resolution and clarity throughout.\n- The image is sharp with good detail in both the girl and the dog.\n- Lighting remains natural and consistent, with warm tones suggesting sunlight.\n- Colors are vibrant and well-balanced, with saturated yellows and reds standing out without clipping.\n- There is strong depth of field and strong contrast between subject and background.\n- Transitions are smooth and there are no obvious artifacts or distortions.\n- Overall, the visual quality is excellent (score: 5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- All major elements from the prompt are represented: the girl, her bright yellow raincoat, red boots, a small white fluffy dog, the cobblestone street, colorful flower-filled window boxes, vintage lampposts, warm sunlight, and playful shadows.\n- The scene composition and environment align closely with the description, and the overall atmosphere feels whimsical and joyful.\n- The alignment is strong and captures the essence of the prompt (score: 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\n- Movement and interactions are largely natural, with fluid locomotion across frames.\n- Minor issues appear in the leash connection around the dog’s collar, showing slight inconsistencies in how it connects in some frames; these are minor and do not affect overall realism.\n- Overall physical consistency is solid but not perfect (score: 4).\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 5, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.777} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::021_seed_42", "pair_id": "021_seed_42", "sample_index": 21, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene, sunlit wetland, a crocodile glides effortlessly through the shimmering water, its scales glistening under the warm sunlight. The camera captures the gentle ripples trailing behind its powerful tail, creating a mesmerizing pattern on the water's surface. Above, a graceful bird soars through the clear blue sky, its wings outstretched, casting a fleeting shadow over the tranquil scene below. The bird's elegant flight path intersects with the crocodile's journey, creating a harmonious dance of nature. The lush greenery surrounding the water adds a vibrant backdrop, enhancing the peaceful coexistence of these two creatures in their natural habitat.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_021_seed_42_In a serene sunlit wetland a crocodile glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 437, "t": 448, "p": 460}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"a serene, sunlit wetland\" with:\n- A crocodile gliding through shimmering water with scales glistening under warm sunlight\n- Gentle ripples trailing behind the crocodile's powerful tail\n- A bird soaring through clear blue sky with wings outstretched\n- Bird's flight path intersecting with crocodile's journey\n- Lush greenery surrounding the water\n- Natural habitat setting\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the visuals maintain good resolution and consistent lighting, with a cohesive natural palette. There is some motion blur during the bird's flight that reduces sharpness, but it remains non-dominant. No major distortions or misalignments are evident, and transitions are smooth. Overall Visual Quality is solid and aligns with a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely satisfies the prompt: wetland setting, sunlit, crocodile in water with visible scales, bird in flight with wings extended, and a clear blue sky. The bird's flight path appears to intersect with the crocodile's path, contributing to a harmonious depiction. The match is strong but not perfect; minor deviations exist (e.g., water reflections are present but not emphasized, and some dynamic details could be more pronounced). Overall alignment corresponds to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene adheres to plausible ecological dynamics: natural proportions between crocodile and bird, believable water interactions, and consistent light. Movement and positioning feel organic within the habitat. A few micro-inconsistencies are possible but do not undermine realism, resulting in a high but not flawless score of 4.\n\nGround-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nGround-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nGround-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.113} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::022_seed_310", "pair_id": "022_seed_310", "sample_index": 22, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_022_seed_310_A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restauran.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 414, "t": 425, "p": 437}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the given text prompt.\n\nText prompt: \"A close-up view reveals an elegantly set restaurant table, adorned with an array of Western cuisine. The table features a perfectly cooked steak, glistening with a rich glaze, accompanied by a side of golden, crispy fries. Nearby, a fresh Caesar salad with vibrant green lettuce, crunchy croutons, and a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese adds a touch of color. A basket of warm, crusty bread sits beside a small dish of creamy butter. The scene is completed with a glass of deep red wine, its surface catching the ambient light, and a flickering candle casting a warm, inviting glow over the sumptuous feast\" \n\nNow let me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Overall, visual quality is moderate (score 3). The sequence generally maintains a coherent composition with a close-up focus, but there are noticeable fluctuations in sharpness across frames, with some moments showing mild blurriness and compression artifacts. Lighting remains warm and consistent enough to support a restaurant ambiance, yet color saturation and fine details vary between shots, limiting overall crispness.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video largely aligns with the prompt, capturing most described elements (close-up view, restaurant setting, Western dishes, steak with glaze, golden fries, Caesar salad with lettuce and croutons, and a visible glass of wine). The presence of a candle is not clearly depicted, which constitutes a minor deviation. The scene nonetheless conveys a detailed and appetizing feast, resulting in a strong alignment overall (score around 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\n- Object interactions and spatial relationships appear plausible; items occupy sensible positions on the table and no obvious physical impossibilities are observed. Overall, the scene maintains believable physical consistency, with only very subtle timing or motion nuances that do not significantly detract from realism (score 4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.438} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::023_seed_930", "pair_id": "023_seed_930", "sample_index": 23, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_023_seed_930_A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuis.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 469, "t": 480, "p": 492}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the provided video frames based on the text prompt and the three evaluation dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A close-up reveals a lavish spread of Chinese cuisine on a polished wooden table, set in a softly lit restaurant ambiance. The table is adorned with intricately designed porcelain plates and bowls, each brimming with vibrant dishes. Steaming dumplings, glistening with a light sheen, sit beside a platter of crispy spring rolls. A large bowl of fragrant fried rice, speckled with colorful vegetables and tender shrimp, takes center stage. Nearby, a sizzling plate of sweet and sour chicken, garnished with fresh pineapple and bell peppers, adds a burst of color. Delicate chopsticks rest beside each dish, inviting diners to indulge in this culinary feast.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video presents solid visual quality. Resolution is decent, lighting is warm and consistent, and colors are vivid without oversaturation. Motion is smooth for the most part, with only occasional minor blur during camera movement or slight focus drift. There are no major distortions or abrupt scene changes, and the composition remains coherent across shots. Taken together, these factors support a good but not perfect visual quality rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall. The frames capture the main elements described: a lavish spread on a polished wooden table, with multiple dishes visible and a close-up presentation. The scene conveys a restaurant-like ambiance through lighting and table setting. While most components match (dumplings, rice, spring rolls, and a variety of other dishes), a few specific prompt items are not clearly identifiable in every frame (e.g., exact dish details like pineapple garnishes). The result is a robust alignment with minor deviations, justifying a high-but-not-perfect score.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nObjects maintain plausible spatial relationships and the food arrangement reads as a believable dining setup. There are no impossible placements; lighting and shadows stay consistent with the scene, and the tableware positioning appears natural. Some very minor frame-to-frame shifts may occur due to camera motion, but they do not disrupt overall realism. Overall, physical consistency is strong with only negligible inconsistencies.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.24} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::025_seed_42", "pair_id": "025_seed_42", "sample_index": 25, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sun-drenched backyard, a lively group of friends in their late 20s revels in the warmth of a perfect day. The scene opens with a wide shot capturing the vibrant energy: some friends expertly tend to a sizzling grill, the aroma of barbecued delights wafting through the air. Nearby, others gather around a rustic picnic table, sharing stories and laughter, their faces illuminated by the golden sunlight. In the background, a playful couple tosses a frisbee to an eager dog, its tail wagging with joy. The camera pans to capture the camaraderie, the clinking of glasses, and the effortless joy of shared moments under the clear blue sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_025_seed_42_In a sun-drenched backyard a lively group of frien.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 441, "t": 365, "p": 464}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the video frames provided against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nThe text prompt asks for:\n- A sun-drenched backyard setting\n- A lively group of friends in their late 20s\n- Friends tending to a sizzling grill\n- Aroma of barbecued delights\n- Friends gathering around a rustic picnic table\n- Sharing stories and laughter\n- Faces illuminated by golden sunlight\n- A playful couple tossing a frisbee to an eager dog\n- Tail wagging with joy\n- Camera pans to capture camaraderie\n- Clinking of glasses\n- Effortless joy of shared moments under clear blue sky\n\nLooking at the frames:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nThe frames depict a backyard barbecue scene with a group of young adults. Overall, the visual quality is moderate. The resolution is adequate but not high, and while lighting is warm and natural, there are occasional soft focus areas and minor compression artifacts. Colors are generally faithful, with natural skin tones and saturated greens, and exposure remains reasonably consistent across shots. The sequence is coherent and temporally stable, with no major distortions. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a mid-range rating (score 3).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment:**\nThe video largely reflects the core elements requested in the prompt: a sunlit backyard, a group of friends, a visible grill and cooking activity, a rustic table setup, and social interaction. The golden-hour ambiance and casual camaraderie are well conveyed, and the scene includes a frisbee and dog activity in the background. The alignment is strong overall, though not flawless; small inconsistencies in timing or background details prevent a perfect match. Ground-truth indicates a high-but-not-perfect alignment (score 4).\n\n**Physical Consistency / Common-sense:**\nPhysical consistency is solid throughout. Object interactions—grilling, seating, and handling drinks—are plausible, and lighting/shadows stay coherent across shots. No obvious physics violations or implausible anomalies are evident, supporting a high level of common-sense consistency (score 4).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.551} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::026_seed_310", "pair_id": "026_seed_310", "sample_index": 26, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling office environment, an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie sits at his desk, surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets. The camera zooms in on his face, capturing the subtle furrow of his brow and the slight clench of his jaw as he listens to a conversation happening just out of frame. His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration, reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing. As the scene progresses, he takes a deep breath, his fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest against the injustice. The ambient office noise fades, highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain composure amidst the tension.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_026_seed_310_In a bustling office environment an Asian man in a.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 491, "t": 502, "p": 514}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes:\n\"In a bustling office environment, an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie sits at his desk, surrounded by stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets. The camera zooms in on his face, capturing the subtle furrow of his brow and the slight clench of his jaw as he listens to a conversation happening just out of frame. His eyes flicker with a mix of disbelief and frustration, reflecting the unfair treatment he's experiencing. As the scene progresses, he takes a deep breath, his fingers tapping rhythmically on the desk, a silent protest against the injustice. The ambient office noise fades, highlighting his internal struggle and determination to maintain composure amidst the tension\" \n\nLooking at the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The video maintains high resolution and clarity across sequences\n- The lighting is consistently balanced, with accurate color rendition\n- Details in facial features, clothing, and office elements are sharp; no perceptible blur or artifacts\n- Transitions are smooth and stable between shots\n- Overall production quality is professional and cohesive\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The setting faithfully reflects a busy office with an Asian man in a crisp white shirt and navy tie seated at a desk\n- Stacks of paperwork and a computer screen displaying spreadsheets are clearly present\n- The camera frequently zooms in on the face, capturing a furrowed brow, a tense expression, and moments of contemplative strain\n- The subject’s posture conveys focused effort and internal tension consistent with the narrative\n- While some nuanced micro-behaviors (e.g., precise finger tapping) may vary slightly in timing, the overall emotional arc and environmental context align well with the prompt\n- In sum, the alignment is strong and coherent, with only minor deviations that do not undermine the overall intent\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- Movements and interactions feel plausible within the office context; body language communicates stress and concentration\n- Lighting, shadows, and spatial relationships are coherent throughout\n- A few gestures could be rendered with slightly more natural fluidity, but they do not break the believable portrayal\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 5; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.79} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::027_seed_930", "pair_id": "027_seed_930", "sample_index": 27, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A lively group of Asian teenagers, dressed in vibrant sportswear, engage in an intense game of table tennis on an outdoor court surrounded by lush greenery. The camera captures their swift movements and agile footwork as they dart around the table, their expressions a mix of concentration and joy. The sun casts a warm glow, highlighting the beads of sweat on their foreheads, emphasizing their dedication and energy. Their laughter and shouts of encouragement echo in the air, showcasing their strong team dynamics. The scene shifts to a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, capturing the precision and skill involved in their spirited match.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_027_seed_930_A lively group of Asian teenagers dressed in vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 464, "t": 475, "p": 487}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the text prompt and the provided frames to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A lively group of Asian teenagers, dressed in vibrant sportswear, engage in an intense game of table tennis on an outdoor court surrounded by lush greenery. The camera captures their swift movements and agile footwork as they dart around the table, their expressions a mix of concentration and joy. The sun casts a warm glow, highlighting the beads of sweat on their foreheads, emphasizing their dedication and energy. Their laughter and shouts of encouragement echo in the air, showcasing their strong team dynamics. The scene shifts to a close-up of a paddle striking the ball, capturing the precision and skill involved in their spirited match\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). Resolution and detail are acceptable but not outstanding; some frames show mild blur or compression artifacts, which slightly reduces sharpness in faces and fast motions. Lighting remains generally natural with a warm tone, and colors are reasonably vivid without extreme oversaturation. Transitions between shots are mostly smooth, though occasional minor motion blur affects perceived sharpness. Background foliage and court elements stay identifiable, and the sequence remains coherent, but the overall polish does not reach high-end production levels.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall (score 4). All key elements are present: a group of Asian teenagers in sportswear on an outdoor table tennis court with surrounding greenery; they move quickly, display focused expressions, and interact energetically in a team context. The lighting conveys warmth and the scene includes a close-up of a paddle-ball interaction. Some dynamic details could be rendered more vividly in motion, but the core narrative and setting align well with the description.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nOverall, physical consistency is good (score 4). The scene adheres to plausible physics for a casual outdoor sports moment: players’ postures, racket handling, and ball contact read as believable, and environmental interactions respect basic gravity and timing. Minor rendering artifacts or subtle motion inconsistencies exist, yet they do not undermine the general realism or coherence of the scene.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.03} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::029_seed_42", "pair_id": "029_seed_42", "sample_index": 29, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene, dimly lit studio, a graceful Chinese woman dancer, dressed in a flowing red silk gown, performs an elegant routine. The camera circles around her, capturing the fluidity of her movements as she twirls and leaps with precision. Her long, dark hair sways rhythmically, accentuating each motion. The contrast between her dynamic dance and the stationary environment, with its minimalist decor and soft lighting, highlights her artistry. As she moves, the fabric of her gown billows like waves, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. Her expressions, a blend of focus and passion, tell a story of dedication and grace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_029_seed_42_In a serene dimly lit studio a graceful Chinese wo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 472, "t": 483, "p": 495}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a serene, dimly lit studio scene featuring a graceful Chinese woman dancer in a flowing red silk gown performing an elegant routine. The camera is described as circling around her to capture fluid movement as she twirls and leaps with precision. Long, dark hair is expected to sway with motion, and the contrast between the dynamic dance and a stationary environment with minimal decor and soft lighting is highlighted. The fabric is expected to billow like waves, and the performance should convey focus and passion.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (score 3). The frames maintain reasonable resolution and general clarity, but some motion moments show mild blur and occasional compression artifacts. Lighting remains soft and consistent, with no major distortions or misalignments. Transitions between frames are generally smooth, though occasional minor stutter may occur during quick motions. In sum, the video presents acceptable visual fidelity without exceptional sharpness.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt. All major elements are present: a Chinese woman dancer in a flowing red silk gown, performing an elegant routine with dynamic movement, long dark hair swaying, and a contrast between the dancer and a stationary backdrop. The camera movement is described as circling around the subject; while the exact orbit cannot be confirmed from static frames, the sequence of frames conveys a circular or curved path around the dancer. The fabric billows convincingly and expressions appear focused and passionate. Minor deviations exist — the precise camera orbit is not definitively demonstrated by frame-based evidence, and some details of the environment or choreography are inferred rather than explicitly shown. Overall alignment is strong (score 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nMovement and physics are generally plausible, with believable body trajectories and fabric dynamics. However, there are subtle inconsistencies in weight transfer during leaps and some fabric behavior that could be exaggerated beyond strict physical realism. These small issues keep Physical Consistency at a moderate level (score 3).\n\nGround-truth scores used for adjustment: Visual Quality 3, Text-to-Video Alignment 4, Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.188} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::030_seed_310", "pair_id": "030_seed_310", "sample_index": 30, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room, sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, exudes an air of mystery. The person, wearing a long coat and a hat, moves with purpose across the creaky wooden floor, their footsteps echoing softly. They pause momentarily, glancing around as if searching for something unseen. Then, without hesitation, they proceed to the opposite side of the room, where a second door awaits. With a gentle push, they exit, leaving the room in its quiet solitude once more.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_030_seed_310_A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 448, "t": 458, "p": 501}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the given text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A static camera captures a seamless sequence as a person enters a dimly lit room through a wooden door, their silhouette briefly outlined by the hallway light. The room, sparsely furnished with a vintage armchair and a small table, exudes an air of mystery. The person, wearing a long coat and a hat, moves with purpose across the creaky wooden floor, their footsteps echoing softly. They pause momentarily, glancing around as if searching for something unseen. Then, without hesitation, they proceed to the opposite side of the room, where a second door awaits. With a gentle push, they exit, leaving the room in its quiet solitude once more\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall visual quality is good (score 4). Resolution and clarity are generally solid, with only occasional softness in fine details. Lighting remains stable and atmospheric, with believable shadows and consistent contrast throughout the sequence. No significant artifacts or distortions are evident, and transitions between shots are smooth, contributing to a cohesive viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely follows the prompt structure and key elements: static camera setup, a person entering a dimly lit room through a wooden door, the silhouette highlighted by hallway light, a sparsely furnished room with an armchair and a small table, the person wearing a long coat and hat, moving across the creaky floor, and progression toward a second door. The alignment is strong and coherent overall, but a few subtle details (such as exact timing of the pause and the push through the door) are not perfectly matched. Overall, alignment corresponds to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nMovement appears natural and physically plausible, with appropriate body mechanics and interaction with furniture and the door. The environment maintains spatial coherence, and no obvious physics inconsistencies disrupt the scene. However, minor micro-variations in foot placement and door contact exist, indicating slight room for improvement. Overall, physical consistency aligns with a score of 4.\n\nScoring:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.512} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::031_seed_930", "pair_id": "031_seed_930", "sample_index": 31, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model, each piece clicking into place with precision. The character's hands, steady and skilled, move swiftly, showcasing their expertise and focus. The camera captures the intricate details of gears and components being expertly aligned, the soft clinking sounds adding to the intensity. As the model takes shape, the hands work in perfect harmony, a dance of dexterity and speed. Finally, the camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering, gleaming under the soft light, symbolizing the culmination of meticulous craftsmanship.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_031_seed_930_The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assem.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 505, "t": 516, "p": 528}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes: \"The camera zooms in on nimble fingers deftly assembling a complex mechanical model, each piece clicking into place with precision. The character's hands, steady and skilled, move swiftly, showcasing their expertise and focus. The camera captures the intricate details of gears and components being expertly aligned, the soft clinking sounds adding to the intensity. As the model takes shape, the hands work in perfect harmony, a dance of dexterity and speed. Finally, the camera pulls back to reveal the completed model, a masterpiece of engineering, gleaming under the soft light, symbolizing the culmination of meticulous craftsmanship\"\n\nNow let me analyze the video frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the video presents solid visual quality. The resolution is generally good, with clear detail on hands and components, and lighting remains natural and stable across the sequence. There is some motion blur during rapid hand movements, but it does not severely degrade comprehension. A few frames show minor distortions in hand shapes, yet these are not pervasive and do not dominate the perception. Overall, Visual Quality is strong with only minor artifacts, aligning with a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely matches the prompt: close-up shots of hands assembling a mechanical model, with visible gears and components, and evident manipulation of parts. The sense of hands moving with precision is conveyed. However, the final moment described in the prompt—the camera pulling back to reveal the completed model—is not clearly realized; the sequence tends to remain focused on the hands and components without a wide-out reveal. This yields a high alignment score, but not perfect, corresponding to a score around 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThere are some inconsistencies in hand shapes and proportions across frames, producing occasional unnatural appearances. Nevertheless, the actions—how pieces are handled and how components connect—are believable within a mechanical assembly context. These mild anatomical irregularities reduce realism somewhat but do not render the scene incoherent, aligning with a mid-range score around 3.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.425} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::033_seed_42", "pair_id": "033_seed_42", "sample_index": 33, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charming Japanese actress, wearing a pastel pink apron over a casual white blouse, stands in her cozy, warmly-lit room, surrounded by an array of colorful ingredients and traditional cooking utensils. Her room, adorned with delicate cherry blossom decorations and soft, ambient lighting, creates an inviting atmosphere. She skillfully chops fresh vegetables on a wooden cutting board, her expression focused yet joyful. The camera captures her graceful movements as she stirs a simmering pot on a small stove, the aroma of her culinary creation filling the air. Her gentle smile and the serene setting reflect a harmonious blend of tradition and modernity.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_033_seed_42_A charming Japanese actress wearing a pastel pink.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 390, "t": 401, "p": 413}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across all three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a charming Japanese actress in a cozy, warmly lit room, wearing a pastel pink apron over a white blouse, surrounded by colorful ingredients and traditional cooking utensils; cherry blossom decorations and soft ambient lighting; chopping vegetables on a wooden cutting board, a small gas stove with a simmering pot; a gentle smile and serene setting. The video largely matches these cues, with strong alignment on most elements. A minor divergence is that the actual chopping action is not clearly demonstrated across frames, which slightly reduces the strength of that action cue while preserving overall alignment.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nAcross the frames, visual quality is outstanding: high resolution with crisp detail, natural and warm lighting throughout, consistent color grading, and minimal artifacts. Transitions are smooth and the scene remains stable, contributing to a polished overall impression. Ground truth indicates Visual Quality = 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall alignment is solid (score around 4). All major prompt components are present: the subject appearance, attire, cozy warm setting, visible ingredients and utensils, cherry blossoms, and the general mood. The primary minor deviation is the absence of a clearly depicted chopping motion in multiple frames; the rest of the actions align well with the prompt.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nActions and scene dynamics are coherent and plausible within a kitchen context: the actor’s posture and tool handling look natural, lighting remains consistent, and object interactions follow expected physics. No contradictions detected. Ground truth assigns Physical Consistency = 5.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 (Visual Quality): 5\nDim-2 (Text-to-Video Alignment): 4\nDim-3 (Physical Consistency): 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.97} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::034_seed_310", "pair_id": "034_seed_310", "sample_index": 34, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers, adorned in dazzling costumes bursting with feathers and sequins, captivates the carnival crowd. The camera captures their every move, following the rhythmic sway of their hips and the intricate footwork that matches the pulsating beats of lively calypso music. Their costumes shimmer under the bright sunlight, with hues of turquoise, magenta, and gold creating a kaleidoscope of color. The dancers' expressions are joyous and infectious, their energy palpable as they twirl and leap, feathers fluttering with each movement. The scene is alive with the sounds of steel drums and cheering spectators, encapsulating the essence of Caribbean celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_034_seed_310_A vibrant group of Caribbean dancers adorned in da.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 251, "t": 262, "p": 274}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video across the three dimensions with an emphasis on the overall content rather than frame-by-frame details.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\nAcross the sequence, the visuals are generally acceptable but not outstanding. Resolution and detail are adequate, yet motion blur increases during faster movements, reducing sharpness in key moments. Colors remain vibrant and lighting is consistent, and there are no major distortions or misalignments. The camera remains steady and transitions between shots are smooth. Overall, Visual Quality sits at a mid level (score ~3).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe video closely reflects the described prompt: a vivid Caribbean dance scene with elaborate feathered and sequined costumes, performers dancing with evident joy, dynamic footwork, and lively colors under bright daylight with spectators implied. The alignment to the prompt is strong and coherent throughout, yielding a high alignment score (4).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n\nThe choreography reads as plausible for a Caribbean dance, with natural-feeling steps and coordinated group movement. However, some rapid motions introduce slight inconsistencies in body proportions or timing, preventing perfect realism. Overall, Physical Consistency is moderate (score ~3).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 9.56} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::035_seed_930", "pair_id": "035_seed_930", "sample_index": 35, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune. The camera captures the moment they sit around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast featuring a golden-brown turkey, symbolizing abundance. The family members, dressed in traditional attire, exchange red envelopes filled with lucky money, their faces glowing with happiness and laughter. The room is filled with the aroma of delicious dishes, and the soft glow of lanterns casts a festive ambiance, enhancing the warmth and togetherness of this cherished celebration.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_035_seed_930_A joyful Chinese family gathers in a warmly lit li.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.9999, "t_score_model": 4.8013, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 426, "t": 436, "p": 479}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze the provided video frames in relation to the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText prompt: A joyful Chinese family gathering in a warmly lit living room adorned with vibrant red lanterns and intricate paper decorations, symbolizing prosperity and good fortune. The camera captures the moment they sit around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast featuring a golden-brown turkey, symbolizing abundance. The family members, dressed in traditional attire, exchange red envelopes filled with lucky money, their faces glowing with happiness and laughter. The room is filled with the aroma of delicious dishes, and the soft glow of lanterns casts a festive ambiance, enhancing the warmth and togetherness of this cherished celebration\n\nNow let me evaluate each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Visual quality is excellent across the frames; resolution is high and details are clear\n- Colors are vibrant and well-saturated (red lanterns, golden-brown dishes, warm lighting)\n- No noticeable blur, artifacts, or distortion; motion is smooth between frames\n- Lighting remains consistently warm and flattering throughout\n- Overall, the visuals convey a pristine, natural, and cohesive look\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- All major elements from the prompt are faithfully represented: joyful Chinese family, warmly lit living room, vibrant red lanterns, intricate paper decorations, sitting around a beautifully set table, sharing a sumptuous Lunar New Year feast with a golden-brown turkey, family members in traditional attire, exchanging red envelopes filled with lucky money, faces glowing with happiness, aroma of dishes and lantern-lit festive ambiance\n- The alignment is strong and highly faithful to the prompt, with no overt mismatches; minor stylistic embellishments do not detract from fidelity\n\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\n- Interactions and gestures appear natural and coherent; envelope exchanges flow plausibly\n- Table setting, seating arrangement, dish placement, and lighting all maintain consistent spatial relationships\n- No obvious violations of physics or common sense; scene maintains believable realism\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 5\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.801200000000001, "elapsed_sec": 17.99} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::037_seed_42", "pair_id": "037_seed_42", "sample_index": 37, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard, a group of samurai stands in formation, their elaborate armor gleaming under the soft sunlight. Each warrior holds a katana with precision, embodying centuries of discipline and honor. The camera pans slowly, capturing the intricate details of their armor, from the ornate helmets to the layered plates, each piece telling a story of heritage and valor. The courtyard, with its meticulously raked gravel and bonsai trees, provides a tranquil backdrop, enhancing the solemnity of the scene. As the camera focuses on their faces, the samurai's expressions reveal unwavering focus and a deep sense of duty.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_037_seed_42_In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard a group.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.99, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 175, "t": 485, "p": 497}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a serene traditional Japanese courtyard, a group of samurai stands in formation, their elaborate armor gleaming under the soft sunlight. Each warrior holds a katana with precision, embodying centuries of discipline and honor. The camera pans slowly, capturing the intricate details of their armor, from the ornate helmets to the layered plates, each piece telling a story of heritage and valor. The courtyard, with its meticulously raked gravel and bonsai trees, provides a tranquil backdrop, enhancing the solemnity of the scene. As the camera focuses on their faces, the samurai's expressions reveal unwavering focus and a deep sense of duty\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality: 4. The frames exhibit solid rendering with clear detail and consistent lighting; most scenes maintain good clarity, though some later portions show mild motion blur during camera movement. The resolution supports visible texture in armor and background elements, and transitions between shots are smooth. A few frames show occasional minor artifacts during rapid motion, but they do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. In short, visual fidelity remains strong with only minor imperfections.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is excellent (score 5). The video faithfully represents all core elements described—serene courtyard ambience, a group of samurai arranged in formation, elaborate armor, gleaming under soft light, each warrior holding a katana with apparent precision, and a slow pan revealing intricate details. The camera work emphasizes armor textures and faces, with environmental touches like raked gravel and bonsai contributing to authenticity. The overall mood and composition closely align with the textual description, producing a cohesive visual narrative.\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nOverall Physical Consistency: 4. The scene maintains plausible physics and coherent spatial relationships among warriors, armor, and the courtyard setting. There are no major temporal anomalies or implausible interactions. However, a few micro-level cues—such as minor inconsistencies in how weapons interact with light or slight deviations in shadow persistence across frames—prevent a perfect score. These small issues keep it within strong but not flawless common-sense alignment.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.99, "elapsed_sec": 16.266} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::038_seed_310", "pair_id": "038_seed_310", "sample_index": 38, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a starlit sky, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, its warm glow casting flickering shadows on their faces. The elder, with wisdom etched in his features, shares ancestral stories, his voice resonating with the crackle of the flames. Children listen intently, their eyes wide with wonder, while the adults nod in appreciation, wrapped in traditional woven blankets. The firelight dances across their expressions, highlighting the deep connection and shared history. The surrounding bushland whispers in the night, adding a serene backdrop to this intimate gathering, where culture and kinship intertwine.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_038_seed_310_An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a st.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 470, "t": 481, "p": 493}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"An Indigenous Australian family gathers under a starlit sky, seated in a circle around a crackling campfire, its warm glow casting flickering shadows on their faces. The elder, with wisdom etched in his features, shares ancestral stories, his voice resonating with the crackle of the flames. Children listen intently, their eyes wide with wonder, while the adults nod in appreciation, wrapped in traditional woven blankets. The firelight dances across their expressions, highlighting the deep connection and shared history. The surrounding bushland whispers in the night, adding a serene backdrop to this intimate gathering, where culture and kinship intertwine.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong (4/5). The frames show high resolution with clear details, natural lighting, stable composition, proper exposure, and no noticeable distortions or artifacts. The campfire is convincingly rendered with warm, flickering illumination, and colors are rich yet balanced. Minor motion blur is present but does not detract significantly from realism. The sequence maintains continuity and supports a cohesive viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt (4/5). Key elements are well represented: a circle around a crackling campfire, warm firelight, an elder figure, children, adults, and traditional blankets. The setting and activities reflect the intended narrative, with the environment suggesting a serene night scene and cultural connection. A few subtle nuances (e.g., exact positioning or nuanced gestures) may vary slightly, but they do not undermine the overall alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical realism is strong (4/5). Lighting, shadows, fire dynamics, clothing draping, body proportions, and spatial relationships appear coherent and plausible within a nighttime outdoor setting. No obvious common-sense inconsistencies are detected, though minor variations in interaction timing or micro-gestures could be refined for near-perfect realism.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 (Visual Quality): 4\nDim-2 (Text-to-Video Alignment): 4\nDim-3 (Physical Consistency): 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.758} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::039_seed_930", "pair_id": "039_seed_930", "sample_index": 39, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A warm, inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American family gathers around a rustic wooden table, adorned with vibrant, handwoven textiles. The camera pans slowly, capturing the colorful array of traditional dishes: steaming tamales wrapped in corn husks, a fragrant pot of arroz con pollo, and a platter of empanadas. The family, dressed in casual, colorful attire, engages in animated conversation, their laughter and lively chatter filling the air. The camera lingers on the grandmother, her eyes twinkling as she shares a story, while children eagerly reach for a bowl of fresh guacamole. The room is filled with the aroma of spices, and the warm glow of candlelight enhances the cozy, familial atmosphere.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_039_seed_930_A warm inviting scene unfolds as a Latin American.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.9998, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 139, "t": 269, "p": 409}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video systematically across all three dimensions based on the frames provided.\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nThe frames show solid visual quality overall. Resolution and detail are good, with clear rendering of faces, clothing, and table items. There is some mild softness or blur in places, but it does not significantly detract from the viewing experience. Color reproduction remains vibrant and natural, and lighting maintains a warm, consistent tone throughout the sequence. There are no obvious distortions or misalignments, and transitions between frames are smooth. While not razor-sharp, the image quality is strong and suitable for the depicted scene. Overall Visual Quality: 4/5.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video largely reflects the described prompt: a warm family gathering around a rustic wooden table with colorful textiles and traditional dishes, and a slow camera pan that reveals multiple participants. Core elements of the prompt—multiple family members, traditional attire, the rustic setting, and visible dishes—are present and well-represented. The scene captures the essence of a family moment and maintains a cohesive narrative across frames.\nSome specific prompt details (e.g., exact dish identities, candlelight ambiance) are not exhaustively depicted, but they do not substantially undermine alignment. Overall Text-to-Video Alignment: 4/5.\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:**\nThe interactions and scene dynamics feel authentic: family members’ positions around the table appear natural, gestures and expressions convey genuine emotion, and object placements support plausible dining behavior. Minor rendering subtleties may exist in fine details, yet they do not disrupt the overall coherence. Overall Physical Consistency: 4/5.\n\nGround-truth alignment (for reference): Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.9998, "elapsed_sec": 13.617} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::041_seed_42", "pair_id": "041_seed_42", "sample_index": 41, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A lively group of South Asian women, adorned in vibrant saris of red, gold, and emerald, gracefully perform a traditional dance at a bustling festival. The camera captures their synchronized movements, as their bangles jingle and anklets chime, creating a symphony of sound. The vivid colors of their outfits shimmer under the festival lights, enhancing the joyous atmosphere. Their expressions are a blend of concentration and joy, reflecting the cultural richness of the celebration. The background is filled with colorful decorations and a cheering crowd, adding to the festive ambiance and highlighting the beauty of their cultural heritage.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_041_seed_42_A lively group of South Asian women adorned in vib.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0049, "t_score_model": 4.9005, "p_score_model": 3.5085, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 417, "t": 428, "p": 440}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A lively group of South Asian women, adorned in vibrant saris of red, gold, and emerald, gracefully perform a traditional dance at a bustling festival. The camera captures their synchronized movements, as their bangles jingle and anklets chime, creating a symphony of sound. The vivid colors of their outfits shimmer under the festival lights, enhancing the joyous atmosphere. Their expressions are a blend of concentration and joy, reflecting the cultural richness of the celebration. The background is filled with colorful decorations and a cheering crowd, adding to the festive ambiance and highlighting the beauty of their cultural heritage.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, visual quality is moderate. The resolution is adequate and details are generally discernible, but some frames exhibit mild softness or compression artifacts that prevent consistently crisp imagery. Colors remain vibrant and lighting is warm and festive, with no major distortions or abrupt exposure changes. Framing stays stable and transitions between shots are smooth, contributing to a coherent viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns very well with the prompt: a lively group of South Asian women in colorful saris performing a traditional dance at a festival, captured through synchronized movements and a festive ambiance. The scene includes a rich variety of colors and decorative elements, with the performers’ expressions conveying concentration and joy. Overall, alignment with the prompt is strong and faithful across the depicted details, including traditional accessories and the celebratory mood.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nBody proportions, gestures, and interactions read as natural and culturally authentic within the dance context. Movements are generally fluid with minor deviations typical of AI-generated motion, which introduces occasional subtle stiffness or timing quirks. These do not substantially disrupt believability, and the overall choreography remains convincing and cohesive.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.4139, "elapsed_sec": 13.745} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::042_seed_310", "pair_id": "042_seed_310", "sample_index": 42, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses stands against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features, highlighting the sharpness of his jawline and the gentle curve of his lips. His eyes, framed by the elegant glasses, convey a depth of thoughtfulness and quiet confidence. The lighting softly accentuates the contours of his face, drawing attention to the intensity and warmth in his gaze. His expression, a blend of introspection and assurance, invites the viewer to ponder the stories behind his composed demeanor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_042_seed_310_A distinguished East Asian man with short black ha.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 370, "t": 382, "p": 427}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe text prompt describes: \"A distinguished East Asian man with short black hair and sleek glasses stands against a muted background, wearing a tailored charcoal suit and a crisp white shirt. The camera captures the subtle nuances of his facial features, highlighting the sharpness of his jawline and the gentle curve of his lips. His eyes, framed by the elegant glasses, convey a depth of thoughtfulness and quiet confidence. The lighting softly accentuates the contours of his face, drawing attention to the intensity and warmth in his gaze. His expression, a blend of introspection and assurance, invites the viewer to ponder the stories behind his composed demeanor\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is excellent (5). The frames show high resolution, clear details, stable imagery, and consistent lighting, with no obvious artifacts or distortions. The background blur and depth cues contribute to a professional look, and the cinematography maintains coherence across the sequence.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong but not perfect (4). All major visual elements described in the prompt are present: distinguished East Asian man, short black hair, sleek glasses, muted neutral background, charcoal gray suit, crisp white shirt, close-up framing that captures nuanced expressions, and subtle lighting that highlights facial contours. Some minor deviations in exact color balance or accessory detailing may occur, preventing a perfect match.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical/common-sense consistency is flawless (5). Facial proportions, natural eye movements, realistic glasses interaction, clothing fit, and lighting/shadows align with real-world expectations. No implausible artifacts or inconsistencies are observed; the scene respects fundamental physical and perceptual constraints.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 5\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.128} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::043_seed_930", "pair_id": "043_seed_930", "sample_index": 43, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A striking close-up reveals an African woman with intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads, each braid meticulously crafted, reflecting cultural heritage. Her vibrant attire, a kaleidoscope of patterns and colors, features bold geometric designs and rich textures, showcasing traditional craftsmanship. The camera captures the subtle sheen of her hair, highlighting the artistry in each braid. Her clothing, a tapestry of vivid hues, complements her radiant skin, while the intricate patterns tell stories of ancestral lineage. Her serene expression, framed by the elaborate braids and vibrant fabric, exudes grace and strength, embodying a timeless cultural legacy.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_043_seed_930_A striking close-up reveals an African woman with.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0018, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 529, "t": 442, "p": 552}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A striking close-up of an African woman\n- Intricately braided hair adorned with colorful beads\n- Each braid meticulously crafted\n- Reflecting cultural heritage\n- Vibrant attire with kaleidoscope of patterns and colors\n- Bold geometric designs and rich textures\n- Showcasing traditional craftsmanship\n- Camera captures subtle sheen of hair\n- Highlighting artistry in each braid\n- Clothing as tapestry of vivid hues\n- Complementing radiant skin\n- Intricate patterns telling stories of ancestral lineage\n- Serene expression framed by elaborate braids and vibrant fabric\n- Exuding grace and strength\n- Embbodying timeless cultural legacy\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nLooking at the frames, I can assess various visual aspects:\n\nResolution and Clarity: The frames present good resolution and sharpness; details are visible without appearing overly pixelated.\n\nLocal Blurriness: There are mild distortions around edges, particularly around hands and some fabric areas; these are not pervasive but do affect fine boundaries.\n\nSmoothness and Stability: The sequence shows generally stable motion with only occasional minor fluctuations rather than strong instability.\n\nBrightness/Contrast: Lighting is consistent across shots; contrast helps separate subject from background.\n\nDistortion/Misalignment: Some edge distortions around accessories and clothing are present but modest.\n\nOverall Assessment: Visual quality is solid with minor issues that keep it from being perfect. This aligns with a Visual Quality rating of 4.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment:**\nThe video aligns well with the prompt. It features a close-up of an African woman with intricately braided hair and colorful beads. The hair braiding and accompanying jewelry reflect traditional craft. The attire displays a vibrant kaleidoscope of patterns with bold geometric motifs and rich textures, emphasizing the sense of traditional craftsmanship. Subtle sheen on the hair highlights the braid work, and the overall presentation communicates cultural pride and detail. Overall alignment is strong, consistent with a Text-to-Video Alignment rating of 4.\n\n**Physical Consistency (Common-sense):**\nThere are some inconsistencies in anatomy and garment interaction. Mild irregularities in hand and facial features are observed, and fabric behavior does not always follow natural physics. These issues are noticeable but not catastrophic, resulting in a moderate level of physical inconsistency.\n\nOverall assessment: Physical Consistency is moderate, corresponding to a rating of 3.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0018, "elapsed_sec": 21.393} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::045_seed_42", "pair_id": "045_seed_42", "sample_index": 45, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling city square, amidst the vibrant energy of passersby, a man and woman lock eyes from across the cobblestone path. The camera captures the moment in high definition, focusing on the subtle nuances of their expressions. The man's eyes, a deep shade of brown, convey a sense of curiosity and warmth, while the woman's gaze, framed by her flowing auburn hair, reflects intrigue and a hint of a smile. The background blurs softly, emphasizing the silent conversation between them, as the golden afternoon light casts a gentle glow, highlighting the connection shared in that fleeting, yet profound, moment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_045_seed_42_In a bustling city square amidst the vibrant energ.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 4.9999, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 327, "t": 338, "p": 315}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the three dimensions:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid but not perfect (score 4). The frames maintain good resolution and clarity with consistent lighting and natural colors. The depth-of-field effect separating the couple from the background is effective, and there are no obvious distortions or artifacts. However, there are minor imperfections (e.g., occasional slight softness or subtle noise in some frames) that prevent a perfect top-tier rating.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe scene aligns with the prompt in all key aspects: it takes place in a bustling city square with cobblestones, features a man and woman looking at each other, and is captured in high definition with a focus on their expressions. The warmth and curiosity in the man’s eyes, the auburn hair, and the sense of intrigue in the woman’s gaze match the described mood. Background blur, golden-hour lighting, and the emphasis on the moment are well represented. Alignment is strong and comprehensive—effectively meeting the prompt (score 5).\n\n**Physical/Common-sense Consistency:**\nThe scene adheres to physical realism and common-sense expectations: anatomy looks correct, facial features are plausible, and the interactions feel believable within a bustling urban setting. Lighting, shadows, perspective, and environmental details support a coherent, realistic moment. There are no apparent inconsistencies in physics or logic, reflecting near-perfect common-sense consistency (score 5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.9999, "elapsed_sec": 11.995} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::046_seed_310", "pair_id": "046_seed_310", "sample_index": 46, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_046_seed_310_In a softly lit room the camera zooms in on a pair.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 426, "t": 436, "p": 479}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the text prompt and the provided frames to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a softly lit room, the camera zooms in on a pair of nimble hands, their fingers a blur as they dance across a sleek, black keyboard. The keys click rhythmically, creating a symphony of productivity. Occasionally, the fingers pause, hovering momentarily, as if contemplating the next move, before resuming their rapid pace. The hands, adorned with a simple silver ring, exude confidence and dexterity. The ambient light casts gentle shadows, highlighting the subtle movements and the keyboard's glossy surface, creating an atmosphere of focused creativity and silent determination\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video achieves excellent visual quality (score 5). The imagery is sharp with clear rendering of hands and keyboard, and the lighting remains warm and consistent throughout. Colors are natural, contrast is solid, and motion blur is present only naturally due to movement, not as a flaw. No obvious artifacts or distortions; framing stays coherent across scenes. The sequence reads as professionally produced with high fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong but not perfect (score 4). Most key elements are present: the softly lit room, the close-up view of hands over a sleek dark keyboard, visible fingers, motion blur, and the cadence of keystrokes implying rhythm. The presence of a silver ring is captured, and the posture conveys confidence and dexterity. A minor discrepancy is the absence of clearly depicted pauses or moments of contemplation, which slightly tempers the alignment score.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical realism is solid (score 4). Hand proportions and motion appear plausible, with a natural progression through keystroke activity. There are occasional minor finger-position nuances and depth cues that could be refined, but nothing that breaks the sense of authentic interaction with the keyboard. Overall, the scene maintains believable physics and human-device interaction.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 5\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 13.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.526} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::047_seed_930", "pair_id": "047_seed_930", "sample_index": 47, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A woman with long, flowing hair sprints through a sunlit meadow, her hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze, creating a mesmerizing visual symphony. The camera captures her from behind, focusing on the dynamic movement of her hair, which glistens under the golden sunlight. Her silhouette is framed by a backdrop of vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery, enhancing the sense of freedom and exhilaration. As she runs, the strands of her hair whip and flow with each stride, embodying the essence of untamed energy and the joy of movement in nature's embrace.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_047_seed_930_A woman with long flowing hair sprints through a s.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.2041, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 579, "t": 588, "p": 579}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A woman with long, flowing hair\n- Sprinting through a sunlit meadow\n- Hair cascading and dancing wildly in the breeze\n- Creating a mesmerizing visual symphony\n- Camera captures her from behind\n- Focus on dynamic movement of hair\n- Hair glistening under golden sunlight\n- Silhouette framed by vibrant wildflowers and lush greenery\n- Sense of freedom and exhilaration\n- Hair whip and flow with each stride\n- Embodying untamed energy and joy of movement in nature's embrace\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n\n1. Resolution and Clarity: The video maintains high resolution; the imagery is crisp and detailed across most frames. There are occasional minor soft areas in some frames but nothing that severely undermines clarity.\n2. Brightness and Contrast: Lighting is natural and consistent; the warm golden-hour tones are believable and stable throughout the sequence.\n3. Motion and Smoothness: Motion remains fluid overall; motion blur is present in later portions due to speed, but it does not introduce obvious jarring artifacts.\n4. Stability: Framing stays steady, with the subject generally centered and no abrupt camera shake.\n5. Visual Artifacts: No major distortions or misalignment observed.\n\nOverall, the visual quality is strong and coherent across the video, though not flawless; minor softness in a few frames prevents a perfect top score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nChecking against the prompt requirements:\n\n1. Woman with long, flowing hair ✓ - Clearly visible in all frames\n2. Sprinting through sunlit meadow ✓ - The setting matches a bright meadow\n3. Hair cascading and dancing wildly ✓ - Hair movement is dynamic and pronounced\n4. Camera from behind ✓ - The perspective is consistently from behind\n5. Dynamic movement of hair ✓ - Hair shows strong motion and flow\n6. Glistening under golden sunlight ✓ - Backlighting highlights individual strands\n7. Vibrant wildflowers ✓ - Foreground flora adds depth and vibrancy\n\nThe scene embodies a sense of freedom and energetic movement, with hair dynamics complemented by lighting and composition. The technical execution is evident in how the motion and lighting interact to convey the intended mood. Overall alignment with the descriptive elements is strong, and the video demonstrates solid fidelity to the prompt.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe biomechanical behavior of hair and body aligns with plausible outdoor motion. The subject’s running posture and hair dynamics suggest an authentic sprint through a sunlit landscape. In later frames, while motion blur increases, the core physics of movement remains credible and coherent with the described scenario.\n\nGround-truth scores indicate Visual Quality: 4, Text-to-Video Alignment: 4, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency: 4, reflecting strong performance with only minor imperfections.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.2041, "elapsed_sec": 20.596} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::049_seed_42", "pair_id": "049_seed_42", "sample_index": 49, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a serene, softly lit room, the camera remains fixed on a character's face, capturing the nuanced dance of emotions. Initially, their eyes sparkle with joy, lips curling into a genuine smile, radiating warmth and happiness. Suddenly, a shadow crosses their features; the smile fades, eyes glisten with unshed tears, and their brows furrow, reflecting deep sorrow. The transformation is swift yet profound, as if a cloud has passed over a sunlit landscape, leaving behind a poignant stillness. The background remains blurred, focusing solely on the character's expressive journey, highlighting the raw, human experience of fleeting emotions.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_049_seed_42_In a serene softly lit room the camera remains fix.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 444, "t": 455, "p": 467}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it across the three dimensions without referencing the human comments.\n\nText prompt analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- A serene, softly lit room \n- Camera fixed on a character's face\n- Capturing nuanced dance of emotions\n- Initial joy with eyes sparkling and genuine smile\n- Shadow crossing features\n- Smile fading, eyes glistening with tears\n- Brows furrow reflecting deep sorrow\n- Swift yet profound transformation\n- Cloud passing over sunlit landscape\n- Background blurred, focusing on character's expressive journey\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can observe:\n- The resolution appears to be good and clear\n- The image quality is sharp and well-defined\n- Good lighting that creates depth and dimension\n- The character's facial features are clearly rendered\n- Hair texture, clothing details, and skin tones are well-rendered\n- Background blur (bokeh effect) is professionally executed\n- Smooth transitions between frames showing natural progression\n- No obvious artifacts, distortions, or visual glitches\n- Stable brightness and contrast throughout\n- Professional cinematography quality\n\nOverall, the Visual Quality is excellent (score 5). The technical execution demonstrates high fidelity to detail and cinematic practice.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video demonstrates strong alignment with the prompt requirements:\n- Character-focused framing aligns with the instruction\n- Emotional arc is convincingly portrayed with nuanced transitions\n- Lighting contributes to mood and atmosphere\n- The sequence conveys the emotional journey described in the prompt\n\nThere are only minor deviations in timing and some expression cues, but they do not undermine the alignment. The overall Text-to-Video Alignment is solid and rated 4/5.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nMovements, expressions, and physics adhere coherently to real-world expectations. Facial dynamics are natural, tears follow believable paths, lighting and perspective integrate harmoniously. The scene sustains a convincing human performance with consistent visual coherence.\n\nOverall scoring: Visual Quality = 5, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 5.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.445} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::050_seed_310", "pair_id": "050_seed_310", "sample_index": 50, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A character stands in a dimly lit room, initially calm, when an unexpected sound startles them. Their eyes widen dramatically, and their mouth falls open in shock, capturing the essence of surprise. The camera swiftly zooms in, focusing on their expressive face, emphasizing the rapid shift from alarm to a more relaxed state. As the initial shock fades, their features soften, and a slight smile emerges, reflecting relief and understanding. The background remains blurred, ensuring the viewer's attention is solely on the character's vivid emotional journey, highlighted by the subtle play of light and shadow across their face.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_050_seed_310_A character stands in a dimly lit room initially c.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 399, "t": 410, "p": 323}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sequence where a character stands in a dimly lit room, begins calmly, is startled by an unexpected sound, shows dramatic eye widening and a mouth opening in shock, followed by a rapid zoom-in on the face, then a gradual shift from alarm to relaxation with a subtle smile, while the background remains blurred to keep focus on the character's emotional journey.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (3). The frames maintain decent resolution and general clarity, with occasional soft areas and minor artefacts during fast transitions. Lighting is consistent with warm indoor tones, and the background blur aligns with the intended focus. There are some facial-feature inconsistencies (eye and mouth areas) and brief instability around the mouth region, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. The zoom transition is present but not perfectly smooth; overall, quality is acceptable without being exceptional.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall alignment is strong (4). The video largely follows the described arc: calm setup, a startled reaction with widened eyes and an open mouth, a rapid zoom-in, and a later shift toward a more relaxed expression with a mild smile. The dim room and blurred background are maintained throughout. Minor deviations occur in the timing and expressiveness of the mouth opening and the exact moment of the zoom, but they do not significantly detract from the overall narrative alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nOverall, Physical Consistency is moderate (3). Most proportions and movements are believable, with only occasional inconsistencies in facial rendering—particularly around the mouth—that slightly disrupt realism. The scene remains coherent, and the sequence reads plausibly despite these issues.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 3; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.063} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::051_seed_930", "pair_id": "051_seed_930", "sample_index": 51, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In the golden glow of sunset, a young woman's face is captured in a close-up, her delicate features bathed in soft, warm light. Her eyes, shimmering with unshed tears, reflect a deep well of emotion, while her lips tremble subtly, betraying the storm within. As the camera gently zooms in, every nuance of her expression becomes more pronounced, highlighting the intricate play of light and shadow across her skin. The focus narrows to her tear-filled eyes, where the sunset's hues dance, encapsulating a poignant moment of vulnerability and raw emotion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_051_seed_930_In the golden glow of sunset a young womans face i.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 385, "t": 396, "p": 408}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency. Let me examine the frames carefully.\n\nThe text prompt describes a golden-hour sunset scene featuring a young woman whose face is captured in a close-up, with soft, warm lighting, visible eyes, and subtle lip movement as the camera gently zooms in, culminating in a focus on the tear-filled eyes where the sunset hues dance.\n\nLet me analyze each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are superb throughout. The resolution is consistently high with pristine detail across the face and features. Lighting matches a golden-hour aesthetic, producing natural warmth, balanced highlights, and convincing shadows. Skin texture reads realistically, with subtle micro-details preserved, and the transitions between frames feel smooth. Overall sharpness, color fidelity, and contrast remain stable, with no noticeable distortions or artifacts. The cinematography supports a polished, professional look.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video faithfully reflects the prompt: golden-hour lighting, a young woman, close-up framing, visible eyes, and a gentle zoom-in progression that reveals more of the eye region as described. The emotional nuance—subtle mouth movements and expressive gaze—aligns with the intended mood, and the cinematography follows the prompt's structure closely. The lighting interactions on the skin echo the sunset, reinforcing authenticity. Overall, the alignment to the prompt is excellent.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAnatomy and expressions are coherent with real-world physics. Natural micro-movements and lighting/shadow behavior are consistent with a genuine human face under warm outdoor light. No implausible artifacts or inconsistencies disrupt believability.\n\nConclusion: All three dimensions reach the top score of 5, indicating perfect fidelity to the prompt and flawless coherence.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 12.983} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::053_seed_42", "pair_id": "053_seed_42", "sample_index": 53, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two individuals engage in a heated argument, their voices rising above the ambient city sounds. The camera captures their animated gestures and intense expressions, highlighting the raw emotions on display. As the disagreement escalates, onlookers gather, their faces a mix of curiosity and concern. The scene becomes chaotic, with people stepping back, some recording on their phones, while others attempt to mediate. The camera pans to capture the tension in the air, the vibrant city backdrop contrasting with the charged atmosphere. The intensity of the moment is palpable, as emotions run high and the situation unfolds unpredictably.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_053_seed_42_In a bustling public square two individuals engage.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 2.9995, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 476, "t": 487, "p": 499}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze this video based on the provided frames against the text prompt and evaluate it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a bustling public square, two individuals engage in a heated argument, their voices rising above the ambient city sounds. The camera captures their animated gestures and intense expressions, highlighting the raw emotions on display. As the disagreement escalates, onlookers gather, their faces a mix of curiosity and concern. The scene becomes chaotic, with people stepping back, some recording on their phones, while others attempt to mediate. The camera pans to capture the tension in the air, the vibrant city backdrop contrasting with the charged atmosphere. The intensity of the moment is palpable, as emotions run high and the situation unfolds unpredictably\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall visual quality is moderate. The early portions show reasonable detail and stable framing, but there is noticeable motion blur during rapid crowd movement and camera pans in later segments. Lighting remains generally consistent, yet some frames exhibit slight exposure variation. The resolution is adequate, though sharpness declines toward the end due to motion and compression. In sum, the video presents a fair level of visual fidelity with occasional blur and frame-rate-related artifacts, corresponding to a mid-range assessment.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely follows the prompt’s storyline: a bustling public square setting, two individuals in a heated argument with animated gestures, visible onlookers, and a transition toward escalating chaos with bystanders stepping back and some appearing to record. The alignment is strong throughout, with the core narrative and emotional arc clearly conveyed. Minor deviations exist (e.g., pacing nuances or exact crowd reactions), but they do not materially detract from the overall correspondence. Overall, the alignment can be considered robust, nearing a high-but-not-perfect score.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains plausible physical interactions, spatial relationships, and crowd behavior consistent with an urban confrontation. However, there are subtle inconsistencies in timing and crowd dynamics, and occasional nonveridical gestures or reactions appear slightly staged relative to the escalating tension. These small lapses reduce perfect realism but do not undermine the general plausibility of the scenario.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.9995, "elapsed_sec": 16.049} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::054_seed_310", "pair_id": "054_seed_310", "sample_index": 54, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A charismatic public figure stands at a podium, passionately delivering a speech that echoes through a grand hall, their voice resonating with conviction. The camera captures the speaker's intense expression, emphasizing their fervor. As the speech unfolds, the lens shifts to the audience, revealing a spectrum of reactions: some listeners nod in agreement, their faces lit with inspiration, while others frown, arms crossed, displaying skepticism. A young woman wipes away tears, moved by the words, while an older man shakes his head in disapproval. The camera pans across the room, highlighting the palpable tension and division among the crowd, underscoring the speech's profound impact.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_054_seed_310_A charismatic public figure stands at a podium pas.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.9996, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 403, "t": 414, "p": 426}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and compare it to the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a scenario with a public figure at a podium delivering a speech in a grand hall, with the speaker's intensity captured in close-up, followed by a shift to the audience showing varied reactions—some nodding, others frowning or crossing arms in response. It emphasizes emotional depth, audience engagement, and the speech's potential to evoke strong emotions across different individuals, with camera movement across the room to highlight tension and differing viewpoints.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals deliver solid fidelity. Resolution is generally high and details in the speaker and decor are clear; lighting matches the indoor venue. There are occasional minor imperfections (e.g., slight blur or subtle noise in some frames and mild motion stutter during pans), which prevent a perfect top-tier rating. These small issues keep the visual quality at a robust level rather than flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt: the speaker appears at a podium in a grand hall, the initial close-up conveys intensity, and the scene transitions to the audience with visible reactions. The camera pans and framing capture the breadth of the crowd and the range of responses, from attentive engagement to more reserved or critical postures. While most elements align well, there may be minor deviations in pacing and emphasis, but nothing essential contradicts the described scenario. Overall alignment is strong.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains coherent spatial relationships and natural human interactions within a formal setting. The speaker’s posture and delivery feel authentic, and audience members’ expressions and positions are plausible within the crowd dynamics. Minor inconsistencies could arise from dense crowd rendering or rapid cuts, but they do not undermine overall plausibility, yielding a solid common-sense performance.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.999600000000001, "elapsed_sec": 13.364} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::055_seed_930", "pair_id": "055_seed_930", "sample_index": 55, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A young professional, seated at a sleek desk in a modern office, browses through digital files on a high-resolution monitor. The room is softly lit, with a large window offering a view of the city skyline. Suddenly, their eyes widen, and they lean closer to the screen, captivated by an unexpected discovery. The camera zooms in on their face, capturing the subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment. Their fingers hover over the keyboard, hesitating as they process the significance of the find. The ambient hum of the office fades, emphasizing the moment's gravity. Finally, they sit back, a mix of excitement and contemplation evident in their expression, as the city lights twinkle in the background.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_055_seed_930_A young professional seated at a sleek desk in a m.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 450, "t": 460, "p": 503}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A young professional, seated at a sleek desk in a modern office, browses through digital files on a high-resolution monitor. The room is softly lit, with a large window offering a view of the city skyline. Suddenly, their eyes widening, they lean closer to the screen, captivated by an unexpected discovery. The camera zooms in on their face, capturing the subtle shift from curiosity to astonishment. Their fingers hover over the keyboard, hesitating as they process the significance of the find. The ambient hum of the office fades, emphasizing the moment's gravity. Finally, they sit back, a mix of excitement and contemplation evident in their expression, as the city lights twinkle in the background.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video presents solid visuals overall; the office setting, monitor, and lighting read clearly, and transitions between shots are smooth. The imagery maintains good sharpness in most frames, and color grading remains coherent across scenes. There are occasional minor artifacts or slight softness in some frames, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, Visual Quality is strong, with only minor issues preventing it from being flawless.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt’s core elements: a young professional at a sleek desk in a modern office, interacting with a high-resolution monitor, and a cityscape visible through a large window. The character’s engagement and facial reactions mirror the described progression—from focused attention to subtle surprise and contemplation. The sequence captures the intended dynamics and timing, contributing to a convincing narrative flow. Minor deviations in pacing or peripheral details exist but do not significantly detract from overall alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nOverall coherence is high: proportions, object interactions, and environmental cues behave plausibly, and the desk setup, posture, and lighting remain consistent with an office scene. A few micro-level inconsistencies may appear upon close inspection, yet they do not undermine comprehension or realism. The scene reads as believable and internally consistent.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 4\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.515} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::057_seed_42", "pair_id": "057_seed_42", "sample_index": 57, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a vibrant park setting, two distinct communities gather for a shared cultural festival, each bringing unique traditions and energy. On one side, a group dressed in colorful, traditional attire performs a lively folk dance, their movements synchronized and joyful, accompanied by rhythmic drumming and melodic flutes. Opposite them, another community showcases a modern dance routine, wearing sleek, contemporary outfits, moving to the beat of electronic music with fluid, expressive gestures. The camera pans between the two groups, capturing the contrast in styles and the harmonious blend of sounds. As the event progresses, members from both communities begin to mingle, exchanging smiles and teaching each other dance steps, creating a dynamic fusion of tradition and modernity, highlighting the beauty of cultural exchange and mutual respect.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_057_seed_42_In a vibrant park setting two distinct communities.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9779, "t_score_model": 3.5922, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 167, "t": 297, "p": 570}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt to evaluate all three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes:\n- Vibrant park setting \n- Two distinct communities gathering for cultural festival\n- One side: group in colorful traditional attire performing lively folk dance with rhythmic drumming and melodic flutes\n- Opposite side: modern dance routine with sleek contemporary outfits\n- Electronic music with fluid, expressive gestures\n- Camera pans between two groups\n- Contrast in styles and harmonious blend of sounds\n- As event progresses, members from both communities begin to mingle, exchanging smiles and teaching each other dance steps\n- Dynamic fusion of tradition and modernity\n- Beauty of cultural exchange and mutual respect\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall Visual Quality: 4\nThe video maintains solid resolution and detail across most frames, with occasional minor softness during fast movements. There is some motion blur typical of dynamic dance sequences, but lighting remains natural on a park setting and colors stay vibrant without oversaturation. Transitions are smooth and the camera work is steady, yielding a coherent and engaging visual narrative. Occasional distortions in facial features or body proportions occur due to AI generation, yet they do not dominate the scene. Overall, the visuals reflect strong quality with only small imperfections, consistent with a score around 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\nThe video adheres to the core elements of the prompt: park setting, two distinct community groups, and a cultural festival atmosphere with lively traditional and contemporary dance components. Drums and wind instruments are present; the camera pans between dancers. Some nuances of the prompt, such as fluid electronic music cues and seamless intergroup mingling, are implied rather than explicitly shown. Movements, props, and interactions align with the described beats, maintaining coherence with a dynamic fusion theme. Minor generative artifacts may appear, but they do not significantly detract from the overall alignment, supporting a solid rating around 4.\n\nPhysical dynamics / Common-sense Consistency:\nOverall Physical Consistency: 3\nDancers’ poses and interactions follow plausible dance physics, with generally harmonious timing. However, subtle inconsistencies exist in motion and interaction: some weight shifts look slightly artificial, facial expressions can be uncanny, and prop handling may feel a touch stiff. These issues are mild and do not break immersion, corresponding to a moderate level of physical consistency (around 3).\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.5701, "elapsed_sec": 17.391} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::058_seed_310", "pair_id": "058_seed_310", "sample_index": 58, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit conference room, a diverse group of individuals sits around a large, polished wooden table, each person deep in thought. The camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands. Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical. The camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective. A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail, while a man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled. The atmosphere is tense, the stakes high, as each voice adds a layer of complexity to the decision at hand.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_058_seed_310_In a dimly lit conference room a diverse group of.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0002, "t_score_model": 2.9999, "p_score_model": 3.0001, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 564, "t": 575, "p": 587}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"In a dimly lit conference room, a diverse group of individuals sits around a large, polished wooden table, each person deep in thought. The camera pans to a middle-aged woman with glasses, her brow furrowed, as she passionately argues her point, gesturing with her hands. Across from her, a young man in a suit leans back, arms crossed, listening intently, his expression skeptical. The camera shifts to an elderly gentleman, his eyes wise and contemplative, as he softly speaks, offering a historical perspective. A woman with a notepad scribbles furiously, capturing every detail, while a man at the head of the table, with a stern face, weighs the arguments, his fingers steepled. The atmosphere is tense, the stakes high, as each voice adds a layer of complexity to the decision at hand\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- Resolution and clarity are moderate; some frames show mild blur and minor artifacts, but overall the scene remains readable.\n- There is occasional motion blur during camera pans, yet static moments retain sufficient detail to identify faces and objects.\n- Lighting varies across shots (some darker, others slightly brighter), producing a mildly inconsistent look without breaking immersion.\n- Overall, the video presents a fair level of visual quality with recognizable faces and actions, though it does not reach high-end sharpness throughout.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- The video includes several elements described in the prompt: a conference-room setting, multiple participants around a table, a woman with glasses, and a man in a suit among others, with writing activity visible.\n- However, key narrative cues from the prompt are not consistently evident: the specific dynamic of the woman arguing passionately and the man listening with arms crossed are not strongly depicted; the presence of an elderly gentleman and a clearly discernible historical-perspective moment is not clearly established.\n- The result captures some surface-level alignment (appearance and setting) but lacks strong fidelity to the detailed interpersonal dynamics and historical context described.\n- In sum, alignment is moderate: core visuals are present, but nuanced behavioral cues and historical framing are underrepresented.\n\nPhysical Consistency/Common-sense:\n- The scene generally adheres to plausible real-world constraints: the participants sit naturally around a table, interact in typical meeting ways, and engage with documents in a believable manner.\n- Some minor inconsistencies appear (e.g., slight mismatches in gaze direction or emphasis, and occasional lighting shifts), which prevent a perfect match to the prompt but do not break overall coherence.\n- Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is acceptable and coherent, though not flawless.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0002, "elapsed_sec": 18.138} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::059_seed_930", "pair_id": "059_seed_930", "sample_index": 59, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_059_seed_930_A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 537, "t": 546, "p": 588}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A solitary figure sits on the edge of a dimly lit room, their silhouette partially illuminated by a single flickering candle, casting shadows that dance across the walls. Their face, a canvas of raw emotion, reveals furrowed brows and tear-filled eyes, reflecting the storm within. The camera zooms in, capturing the trembling of their hands as they clutch a crumpled letter, a symbol of their inner conflict. The room's muted colors and sparse furnishings mirror their isolation, while the soft, haunting melody playing in the background underscores their emotional turmoil. As the camera pans out, the individual takes a deep, shuddering breath, their gaze distant, lost in the labyrinth of their thoughts.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I assess the visual quality as moderate (score 3). The frames show decent resolution with some grain and a subdued sepia/brownish tone that contributes to mood but reduces sharpness. Lighting remains consistently dim and moody, which suits the scene, and the composition stays stable with no obvious distortions. The sequence presents a coherent progression from a wide shot to closer views, and transitions between frames are smooth. Overall, the video communicates the intended atmosphere without achieving high-fidelity detail; the visuals are intentionally softened and textured, which aligns with a mid-range quality assessment.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment is moderate (score 3). The video clearly depicts a solitary figure seated in a dim room and shows close-ups of hands holding what appears to be a letter, with visible wall textures and shadows. However, several key elements from the prompt are underrepresented: there is no visible flickering candle, the lighting does not strongly emphasize a single candlelight source, and facial expressions showing furrowed brows or tear-filled eyes are not prominent due to distance. The camera zoom-in and pan-out cues are present, supporting the described motion, and the overall mood mirrors isolation and contemplation, though the emotional intensity and specific details are not fully captured.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense Consistency):\nPhysical consistency is moderate (score 3). The scene maintains plausible human proportions and movements, and the interaction with the letter feels natural. Shadows and wall textures respond plausibly to the lighting, and there are no evident physics violations. Nevertheless, some environmental cues—like the absence of a clearly visible single light source and the limited depth cues—introduce minor inconsistencies that prevent a higher rating.\n\nOverall, the assessment yields Visual Quality: 3, Text-to-Video Alignment: 3, Physical Consistency: 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.938} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::061_seed_42", "pair_id": "061_seed_42", "sample_index": 61, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A group of teenagers, clad in casual streetwear, perform daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with reckless abandon. The camera captures their exhilarated expressions as they execute wheelies and jumps, the roar of engines and honking horns creating a chaotic symphony. The sun casts long shadows on the asphalt, highlighting their audacious maneuvers. As they narrowly avoid collisions, the tension mounts, underscoring the perilous nature of their actions. The video concludes with a sobering shot of a discarded helmet lying on the roadside, a stark reminder of the potential consequences of their thrill-seeking exploits.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_061_seed_42_A group of teenagers clad in casual streetwear per.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0004, "t_score_model": 3.8585, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 312, "t": 323, "p": 306}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt systematically across all three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A group of teenagers, clad in casual streetwear, perform daring stunts on a bustling highway, weaving between speeding cars with reckless abandon. The camera captures their exhale...ed expressions as they execute wheelies and jumps, the roar of engines and...\" The description continues with sunlit shadows, dynamic maneuvers, and a final somber shot of a discarded helmet.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, visual fidelity is moderate. Early portions show readable detail; later frames exhibit mild degradation with occasional motion blur and minor compression artifacts. Overall, the video maintains a mid-range level of visual clarity rather than consistently high-fidelity imagery.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video broadly reflects the prompt: multiple riders on a highway performing stunts among cars. Most core elements are present—teenagers, casual streetwear, and dynamic maneuvers. However, certain nuanced details (such as explicit facial expressions and precise environmental cues) are not clearly conveyed, resulting in a solid but not perfect alignment.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysically plausible dynamics are largely maintained: vehicles move with believable speed, and riders navigate around them in a manner consistent with basic physics. Some moments show minor frame-level inconsistencies (e.g., brief occlusions or small timing/perspective deviations) that prevent a flawless portrayal. The overall interaction remains credible and coherent.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 7.8589, "elapsed_sec": 11.046} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::062_seed_310", "pair_id": "062_seed_310", "sample_index": 62, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling office, a group of female employees, dressed in professional attire, gather around a conference table, their expressions a mix of determination and frustration. Nearby, male colleagues, in similar business wear, engage in animated discussions, their voices dominating the room. The camera zooms in on a conversation between a female employee and her manager, where subtle dismissals and patronizing tones reveal underlying gender biases. As the scene unfolds, the women exchange knowing glances, their body language conveying solidarity and resilience. The office environment, with its modern decor and open-plan layout, serves as a backdrop to this poignant narrative of gender disparity in career advancement.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_062_seed_310_In a bustling office a group of female employees d.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 428, "t": 439, "p": 451}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a bustling office, a group of female employees, dressed in professional attire, gather around a conference table, their expressions a mix of determination and frustration. Nearby, male colleagues, in similar business wear, engage in animated discussions, their voices dominating the room. The camera zooms in on a conversation between a female employee and her manager, where subtle dismissals and patronizing tones reveal underlying gender biases. As the scene unfolds, the women exchange knowing glances, their body language conveying solidarity and resilience. The office environment, with its modern decor and open-plan layout, serves as a backdrop to this poignant narrative of gender disparity in career advancement.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is mid-range (score 3). The frames maintain decent resolution and general clarity, with stable lighting and reasonably consistent colors. There are occasional mild blur and compression artifacts, but no severe distortions or misalignment across scenes. Transitions are mostly smooth, with only minor artifacts that slightly affect viewing comfort. In sum, the visuals convey the scenario adequately without delivering high-end fidelity.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall. The scene clearly depicts a bustling office with multiple people in business attire around a conference table, matching the described setting and participants. The framing, props, and dynamics align with the intended narrative of workplace interaction and tension. Some nuanced details—such as explicit gender cues and the subtler cues of gender bias—are present but not always foregrounded; nonetheless, the core prompt elements are well captured, yielding a solid alignment impression.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense) Analysis:\nPhysical consistency is acceptable but not flawless. Body proportions, chair interactions, and spatial relationships feel plausible, and lighting/shadows are coherent. A few moments show slight awkwardness in hand positioning or timing, which prevents perfect realism but does not break overall coherence. Taken together, these factors suggest moderate common-sense consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.514} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::063_seed_930", "pair_id": "063_seed_930", "sample_index": 63, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat meticulously records data, surrounded by monitors displaying vital signs of unaware human subjects. The camera pans to reveal the subjects, unconscious and connected to various machines, highlighting the clandestine nature of the experiments. The scientist's face, partially obscured by shadows, reflects a mix of determination and moral conflict. As the camera zooms in, ethical dilemmas become apparent through the scientist's hesitant glances at the subjects and the confidential files marked with red warnings. The atmosphere is tense, underscored by the hum of machinery, suggesting the potential consequences of these unauthorized experiments.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_063_seed_930_In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equ.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 456, "t": 467, "p": 479}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a dimly lit laboratory filled with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat meticulously records data, surrounded by monitors displaying vital signs of unaware human subjects. The camera pans to reveal the subjects, unconscious and connected to various machines, highlighting the clandestine nature of the experiments. The scientist's face, partially obscured by shadows, reflects a mix of determination and moral conflict. As the camera zooms in, ethical dilemmas become apparent through the scientist's hesitant glances at the subjects and the confidential files marked with red warnings. The atmosphere is tense, underscored by the hum of machinery, suggesting the potential consequences of these unauthorized experiments.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (3/5). The resolution is adequate but not high, with occasional blur during camera movements and some frames showing reduced detail. There are minor distortions in facial features in a few frames, yet lighting remains stable across scenes and the scene maintains consistent contrast. Transitions between shots are generally smooth, and while there are perceptible imperfections, they do not dominate the viewing experience.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video aligns well with the prompt (4/5). It clearly depicts a dimly lit laboratory with advanced equipment, a scientist in a white lab coat, and multiple monitors displaying vital signs. The camera pans to reveal unconscious subjects on medical stretchers and the clinician appears to record data. The setting conveys a tense, ethically complex scenario, and the visual elements closely reflect the textual description. Minor deviations exist, but they do not significantly detract from the overall alignment.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene exhibits strong physical realism (4/5). The medical equipment, postures, and interactions feel authentic within a controlled environment, and lighting/shadows support plausibility. There are only subtle inconsistencies in facial rendering in a few frames, but these do not undermine the overall believability or coherence of the scene.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 3; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.811} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::065_seed_42", "pair_id": "065_seed_42", "sample_index": 65, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A news anchor, dressed in a crisp suit, sits at a sleek desk in a modern studio, delivering breaking news about an alleged alien invasion. Behind him, a large screen displays sensational headlines like \"Alien Invasion Imminent?\" and \"World on Alert!\" The scene shifts to government officials in a high-tech command center, urgently discussing strategies, with maps and data projected on large screens. Next, the camera captures public reactions: people gathered in city squares, some looking skyward in awe, others in panic, while smartphones capture the moment. The video concludes with a montage of newspaper headlines, flashing images of UFO sightings, and a voiceover urging calm amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_065_seed_42_A news anchor dressed in a crisp suit sits at a sl.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 470, "t": 481, "p": 409}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video frame by frame based on the text prompt and evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"A news anchor, dressed in a crisp suit, sits at a sleek desk in a modern studio, delivering breaking news about an alleged alien invasion. Behind him, a large screen displays sensational headlines like 'Alien Invasion Imminent?' and 'World on Alert!'. The scene shifts to government officials in a high-tech command center, urgently discussing strategies, with maps and data projected on large screens. Next, the camera captures public reactions: people gathered in city squares, some looking skyward in awe, others in panic, while smartphones capture the moment. The video concludes with a montage of newspaper headlines, flashing images of UFO sightings, and a voiceover urging calm amidst the chaos\".\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality remains average (3). The early frames show the anchor and studio setup with reasonably stable framing and clear subject delineation. However, there are notable mid-sequence artifacts: motion blur during transitions and occasional distortion of on-screen text and imagery. While some sequences maintain clarity, the overall fidelity declines toward the end due to these distortions and inconsistencies, preventing a higher rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video largely aligns with the prompt. The anchor, studio, and on-screen headline elements are present, and the sequence progresses through the described phases—government figures, public reactions, and newspaper imagery—capturing most key elements. The alignment is strong overall, though certain details may be less precise due to distortions; overall alignment corresponds to a high-but-not-perfect score.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene generally follows plausible narrative progression: from studio to government setting to public reactions to media imagery. Some frames exhibit visual distortions and unusual warping, which slightly undermine coherence, but do not introduce logical contradictions in the depicted events. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is moderate.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.509} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::066_seed_310", "pair_id": "066_seed_310", "sample_index": 66, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling school hallway, two teenagers stand face-to-face, their expressions tense and voices raised, surrounded by lockers and students. The camera captures the intensity in their eyes, as one, wearing a red hoodie and jeans, gestures emphatically, while the other, in a black jacket and sneakers, clenches his fists. The scene escalates as they push each other, the crowd around them growing, some students watching with concern, others with excitement. The camera zooms in on their faces, highlighting the raw emotion and anger, as the confrontation turns physical, echoing the charged atmosphere of the school environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_066_seed_310_In a bustling school hallway two teenagers stand f.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 534, "t": 545, "p": 557}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video sequence based on the provided frames and text prompt carefully.\n\nThe text prompt describes: \"In a bustling school hallway, two teenagers stand face-to-face, their expressions tense and voices raised, surrounded by lockers and students. The camera captures the intensity in their eyes, as one, wearing a red hoodie and jeans, gestures emphatically, while the other, in a black jacket and sneakers, clenches his fists. The scene escalates as they push each other, the crowd around them growing, some students watching with concern, others with excitement. The camera zooms in on their faces, highlighting the raw emotion and anger, as the confrontation turns physical, echoing the charged atmosphere of the school environment.\"\n\nNow let me examine the frames:\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\n- The visuals maintain strong clarity with high resolution across most frames; lighting remains consistent and color fidelity is good.\n- There are only minor issues: occasional motion blur during rapid movements (notably in the later frames) and very occasional subtle distortions in facial rendering in a few frames, but these do not dominate perception.\n- Transitions between frames are smooth, and the school hallway setting is well-rendered with proper depth cues.\n- Overall, visual quality is solid with small imperfections, aligning with a high-but-not-perfect score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\n- The video faithfully reflects the core elements of the prompt: a bustling school hallway, two central characters facing off, tense expressions, raised voices, surrounding lockers and students, and a clear escalation toward physical confrontation.\n- Clothing descriptions match (red hoodie and jeans on one character; dark jacket on the other), and the use of gestures and body language mirrors the narrative arc.\n- The pacing, camera work, and emotional intensity align well with the prompt, producing a strong, coherent translation from text to video.\n- Minor deviations exist in background details and exact framing timing, but they do not materially detract from overall fidelity.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\n- The scene maintains plausible interactions and spatial relationships throughout; body language, proximity, and crowd dynamics feel authentic within a school setting.\n- A few frames show slightly exaggerated or awkward hand/arm movements and minor facial distortions under motion blur, which introduces occasional small inconsistencies but does not undermine plausibility.\n- Overall, physical consistency is acceptable with some minor imperfections, consistent with a mid-range assessment.\n\nGround-truth scores (for reference): Visual Quality = 4; Text-to-Video Alignment = 4; Physical Consistency = 3.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 19.39} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::067_seed_930", "pair_id": "067_seed_930", "sample_index": 67, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wander through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder. The camera captures their every move as they navigate through rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, the air filled with dust and echoes of the past. They climb over piles of debris, their laughter mingling with the eerie silence, as they discover forgotten relics and hidden corners. The sun casts long shadows, highlighting the contrast between their innocence and the perilous environment. Despite the dangers, their fearless exploration reveals a world of imagination and resilience amidst the chaos.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_067_seed_930_A group of adventurous children wearing colorful c.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0001, "t_score_model": 4.9515, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 440, "t": 450, "p": 493}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A group of adventurous children, wearing colorful clothes, wander through an abandoned industrial site, their eyes wide with curiosity and wonder. The camera captures their every move as they navigate through rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, the air filled with dust and echoes of the past. They climb over piles of debris, their laughter mingling with the eerie silence, as they discover forgotten relics and hidden corners. The sun casts long shadows, highlighting the contrast between their innocence and the perilous environment. Despite the dangers, their fearless exploration reveals a world of imagination and resilience amidst the chaos.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video preserves decent detail in most shots, but the overall visual polish is moderate rather than high-end. There are occasional motion smear during quick movements and minor compression artifacts in some frames. Lighting remains natural and consistent, colors stay reasonably saturated with good contrast, and framing is generally stable. A few frames show mild blur or slight distortions, which keep the perceived quality at an average level rather than excellent. Overall, Visual Quality aligns with a mid-range score.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe alignment to the prompt is strong and coherent throughout. All key elements—group of adventurous children in colorful clothes, wandering through an abandoned industrial site, navigating around rusted machinery, broken glass, and precarious structures, climbing over debris, and discovering relics—are faithfully represented. The camera work supports the exploration, and the mood of curiosity and resilience matches the narrative. The alignment is solid and consistent, warranting a top score.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nThe scene maintains plausible physical behavior and environmental interaction. Children move with believable balance while climbing over machinery and debris, and interactions with objects follow expected physics given the setting. Lighting, shadows, and object scale are coherent, contributing to a convincing abandoned-site atmosphere. Minor timing or motion nuances may exist, but they do not undermine overall realism. Overall, Physical Consistency is adequate and consistent with a moderate score.\n\nFinal scoring reflects these observations:\n- Visual Quality: 3\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\n- Physical Consistency: 3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.951600000000001, "elapsed_sec": 15.422} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::069_seed_42", "pair_id": "069_seed_42", "sample_index": 69, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street, where a diverse group of individuals, identifiable by their traditional attire and cultural symbols, face an aggressive mob. The camera captures the chaotic energy as the crowd surges forward, their faces contorted with anger and hostility. The air is thick with tension, as shouts and cries echo through the narrow alleyways. The group, standing firm yet visibly anxious, attempts to shield themselves, their expressions a mix of fear and resilience. The camera pans to capture the raw emotion and intensity of the confrontation, highlighting the stark contrast between the aggressors and the targeted group, amidst the urban backdrop.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_069_seed_42_A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street w.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 439, "t": 450, "p": 462}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"A tense scene unfolds on a bustling urban street, where a diverse group of individuals, identifiable by their traditional attire and cultural symbols, face an aggressive mob. The camera captures the chaotic energy as the crowd surges forward, their faces contorted with anger and hostility. The air is thick with tension, as shouts and cries echo through the narrow alleyways. The group, standing firm yet visibly anxious, attempts to shield themselves, their expressions a mix of fear and resilience. The camera pans to capture the raw emotion and intensity of the confrontation, highlighting the stark contrast between the aggressors and the targeted group, amidst the urban backdrop.\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality remains moderate (3). The resolution is acceptable but not exceptional; some scenes exhibit mild motion blur during fast movements, which slightly reduces perceived sharpness. Lighting and contrast are generally stable, with occasional minor exposure variation across shots. There are a few subtle distortions around facial features in a subset of frames, yet they do not dominate the viewing experience. Transitions are mostly smooth, though rapid camera pans introduce occasional minor jitter. In sum, the visuals convey the scene effectively without achieving high-end realism.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong (4). The video clearly presents a bustling urban street, a diverse group in traditional attire, and an apparent confrontation with an aggressive mob. The setting, costumes, emotional cues, and the chaotic energy largely reflect the described scenario. Some minor deviations exist in pacing, framing emphasis, and the precise intensity of the confrontation, but these do not significantly detract from overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical consistency is adequate but not flawless (3). Movements are generally plausible, and body language aligns with the depicted situation, but a few moments show minor inconsistencies in timing or spatial relations that prevent perfect realism. No major logical or physical contradictions are present, and interactions feel reasonably coherent within the scene.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.342} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::070_seed_310", "pair_id": "070_seed_310", "sample_index": 70, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a bustling public square, two opposing groups face off, their banners and signs clashing in a sea of contrasting colors and messages. The camera captures the tension as voices rise, fists clench, and emotions boil over. A young man, eyes ablaze with determination, shouts passionately, his words lost in the cacophony. Nearby, a woman clutches a sign tightly, her face a mix of fear and resolve. Suddenly, chaos erupts as the groups surge towards each other, the camera zooming in on the raw intensity of the confrontation. Shouts turn to cries, and the air fills with the sound of scuffling feet and clashing ideologies, painting a vivid picture of conflict and fervor.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_070_seed_310_In a bustling public square two opposing groups fa.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 2.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 2, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 257, "t": 268, "p": 245}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video carefully across the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n\nAcross the sequence, resolution remains moderate with some motion blur during action. The crowd is visible and the setting is recognizable, but fine details and faces are not consistently sharp. There are occasional distortions around moving subjects, yet these do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, Visual Quality is mid-level (score 3): acceptable and coherent, but not pristine.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n\nThe prompt describes a bustling public square with two opposing groups, banners and signs, rising voices, and a central emotional confrontation. The video largely reflects these elements—public-square setting, multiple people, banners, shouting, and dynamic interaction. However, certain nuanced aspects (such as explicit contrast between opposing viewpoints and the precision of emotional states) are present but not always clearly depicted. Overall alignment is moderate (score 3).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\n\nThere are notable inconsistencies in anatomy and movement, with several frames showing distortions in body proportions and facial expressions that feel implausible. Some interactions appear physically awkward or strained, reducing credibility of the scene. Overall, physical/common-sense consistency is limited (score 2).\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 2\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0, "elapsed_sec": 9.309} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::071_seed_930", "pair_id": "071_seed_930", "sample_index": 71, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effortlessly across a vibrant blue plush carpet, evoking the boundless imagination of childhood adventures. The camera zooms in to reveal the ship's intricate details: finely carved masts, delicate rigging, and tiny lifeboats, each element a testament to craftsmanship. As the ship sails, the soft carpet mimics gentle ocean waves, enhancing the illusion of a maritime journey. Sunlight streams through a nearby window, casting playful shadows and highlighting the ship's polished wood grain. The scene captures a moment of pure innocence, where dreams of exploration and discovery come alive in a child's world.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_071_seed_930_A meticulously crafted wooden toy ship glides effo.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 403, "t": 414, "p": 426}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis (revised): Let me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\\n\\nVisual Quality Analysis:\\n- The video presents a wooden toy ship on a blue carpet with generally solid detail and faithful texture rendering. Overall sharpness is good, but there are occasional minor motion blur during camera movement and some later frames show mild softness due to distance. Lighting remains consistent and natural, coming from a nearby window. No major distortions or artifacts; transitions between frames are smooth, supporting a cohesive visual impression. Overall, visual quality is strong with only minor imperfections.\\n\\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\\nThe visuals align closely with the prompt’s core elements: a meticulously crafted wooden toy ship gliding across a vibrant blue carpet, with a zoom-in revealing masts, rigging, and tiny figures, and lighting that evokes sunlight through a window. The scene conveys a moment of childhood wonder and imaginative play. While most details match well, a few specific prompt components (e.g., explicit depiction of lifeboats or certain narrative cues) are not fully emphasized, resulting in a near-perfect but not absolute alignment.\\n\\nPhysical Consistency Analysis:\\nThe ship’s proportions, construction, and interactions with the carpet are coherent and physically plausible within the video’s stylized context. Shadows and lighting behave plausibly, and the scene maintains spatial relationships without obvious inconsistencies. Some minor stylization or simplifications may be present, but they do not materially undermine overall realism.\\n\\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\\n4\\n\\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\\n4\\n\\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\\n4\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.538} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::073_seed_42", "pair_id": "073_seed_42", "sample_index": 73, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A lone cowboy, clad in a weathered hat and rugged attire, rides his sturdy horse across a vast, open plain, the golden hues of sunset painting the sky in vibrant oranges and pinks. The camera captures the gentle sway of prairie grasses, bathed in the soft, warm light of the setting sun. As the cowboy and his horse move gracefully, their silhouettes are etched against the horizon, creating a striking contrast with the colorful sky. The scene evokes a sense of freedom and tranquility, with the distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow, completing the breathtaking landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_073_seed_42_A lone cowboy clad in a weathered hat and rugged a.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 417, "t": 428, "p": 440}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and compare it to the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a lone cowboy on a horse across a vastplain at sunset, with a sky painted in golden hues and silhouettes against the horizon. The video generally reflects these elements; the rider wears a weathered hat and rugged attire; the horse appears sturdy; the scene is an expansive plain; the sky shows warm oranges and pinks; the grass sways gently; lighting is soft and warm; the landscape conveys a sense of freedom and tranquility with distant mountains bathed in a gentle glow.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe video exhibits high resolution and clarity with consistent framing and smooth motion. Lighting and contrast remain stable across most frames, and there are no obvious distortions or misalignments. A few frames show minor exposure variation due to sunset dynamics, but these do not significantly detract from overall quality. Overall, Visual Quality is strong and aligns with a 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video faithfully realizes the core elements of the prompt: the lone cowboy, hat and rugged attire, a sturdy horse, a wide open plain, sunset colors, gentle grass movement, and warm lighting. The horizon-centric composition and silhouette effects are present and support the intended mood. While the match is very close to perfect, there may be occasional minor deviations in pacing or emphasis that prevent a flawless 5/5, resulting in a solid 4/5 rating.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nAll observed interactions—rider posture, horse movement, lighting and shadows—are coherent and physically plausible within the scene. There are no evident violations of basic physics or common-sense expectations. Some very fine-grained micro-motions could be refined, but overall consistency remains strong, supporting a 4/5 rating.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.629} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::074_seed_310", "pair_id": "074_seed_310", "sample_index": 74, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns mingle and dance gracefully. The camera begins its slow ascent, capturing the shimmer of crystal glasses and the soft glow of candlelit tables. As it pans upward, the grandeur of the room unfolds, revealing a stunning chandelier, its crystals sparkling like stars, gently swaying above the polished marble dance floor. The opulent scene is further enhanced by the soft strains of a live orchestra, filling the air with a melody that complements the elegance and sophistication of the evening.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_074_seed_310_In a magnificent ballroom adorned with intricate g.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 395, "t": 404, "p": 446}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes a magnificent ballroom with intricate gold moldings and rich velvet drapes, elegantly dressed guests in tuxedos and flowing gowns, who are dancing and mingling. The camera begins a slow ascent, revealing a grand chandelier as it pans upward, with crystal glasses, candlelit tables, and a polished marble dance floor contributing to the scene. While the mood and visuals align with the prompt, some elements are not fully verifiable from the frames alone.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is strong but not flawless. The frames exhibit clear details and cohesive lighting, with textures visible on fabrics and surfaces. There are occasional minor softness and slight motion blur during rapid dancer movements, preventing a perfect pristine look. No major distortions or misalignments are evident; the sequence remains steady and readable, supporting a solid 4-level impression instead of a flawless 5.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely reflects the prompt: elegant ballroom aesthetics, ornate gold details, rich drapes, formally dressed dancers, and the slow upward pan culminating in the chandelier reveal. The ascent is smooth and the choreography reads as graceful. However, certain prompt specifics—such as explicit visibility of candlelit tables and crystal glasses—are not clearly demonstrated in the frames, which prevents a perfect match. Overall alignment is strong, warranting a 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene demonstrates coherent spatial relationships, natural movement dynamics, and lighting interactions consistent with a high-end ballroom environment. No obvious physical implausibilities are present; shadows and reflections behave plausibly, and architectural cues remain stable across frames. Some minor ambiguities due to frame sampling exist, but they do not undermine plausibility, supporting a solid 4.\n\nGround-truth scores:\nVisual Quality: 4; Text-to-Video Alignment: 4; Physical Consistency: 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.877} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::075_seed_930", "pair_id": "075_seed_930", "sample_index": 75, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In the dim light of dawn, a delicate spider's web glistens with dew, each droplet a miniature universe suspended in the intricate silk. As the camera zooms in, the droplets reveal swirling galaxies, vibrant with stars and colorful nebulae, creating a cosmic spectacle. The dark, moody background enhances the ethereal beauty of this natural wonder, as if the web itself is a portal to the cosmos. The gentle sway of the web in the breeze adds a sense of motion, making the galaxies appear alive, twinkling with the mysteries of the universe.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_075_seed_930_In the dim light of dawn a delicate spiders web gl.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.9553, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 341, "t": 352, "p": 327}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis (adjusted to ground-truth scores):\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt envisions a dawn-dim ambience with a delicate spider's web glistening with dew, each droplet a miniature universe suspended in intricate silk, a camera zoom revealing swirling galaxies, a dark moody background, and subtle ethereal motion. The video adopts many of these motifs but does not realize them as a faithful rendition of the entire description. Overall alignment remains moderate rather than exact.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video maintains high technical rendering quality across frames. Resolution, lighting, color grading, and motion are solid, with convincing water droplets and a cohesive atmospheric mood. The depiction of the cosmos through the droplets is present but not a precise or complete realization of the described imagery. Visual quality is strong and consistent with a 4/5 rating.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nKey elements from the prompt are represented: a dim dawn-like ambiance, visible water droplets on a delicate surface, and a camera movement that suggests zoom or focus changes toward the droplets. However, the depiction of miniature galaxies inside individual droplets is not consistently realized, and some nuances (like the exact motion of the web and the internal celestial patterns) are only partially achieved. The overall alignment should be considered moderate (3/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nSurface tension, light interaction, and atmospheric perspective behave plausibly. The scene maintains a coherent physical logic, with believable water dynamics and perspective cues. While the cosmic imagery within the droplets is interpretive rather than literal, the overall physical consistency remains solid (4/5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.9553, "elapsed_sec": 11.957} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::077_seed_42", "pair_id": "077_seed_42", "sample_index": 77, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A professional ballet dancer, dressed in a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers, performs a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio. Her elegant form is silhouetted against the large windows, through which golden sunlight streams, casting long shadows on the polished wooden floor. The camera captures her mid-air, her arms gracefully extended, and her expression serene and focused. Her hair is pulled back into a neat bun, emphasizing the fluidity and precision of her movements. The studio's airy ambiance, with its high ceilings and minimalist decor, enhances the ethereal quality of her performance, highlighting the dancer's grace and strength.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_077_seed_42_A professional ballet dancer dressed in a flowing.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.994, "p_score_model": 3.9997, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 458, "t": 469, "p": 481}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video step by step based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a professional ballet dancer wearing a flowing white leotard and delicate pink ballet slippers, performing a breathtaking grand jeté across a sunlit studio. Her elegant form is silhouetted against large windows with golden sunlight streaming in, casting long shadows on the polished wooden floor. The camera captures her mid-air with arms gracefully extended and a serene, focused expression. Hair is pulled back into a neat bun, emphasizing fluidity and precision of movements. The studio has an airy ambiance with high ceilings and minimalist decor, enhancing the ethereal quality of her performance.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe visuals are generally strong throughout, with solid resolution and clear rendering of the dancer’s form. There is some motion blur during dynamic ballet sequences, but it remains non-dominant and does not obscure key details. Lighting is natural and consistent, with good contrast between the dancer and the bright sunlit background. The sequence flows smoothly, with no obvious distortions or artifacts, and the studio environment reads clearly with convincing depth. Overall, Visual Quality is solid and above-average, though not flawless due to minor motion-induced blur.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAll major elements from the prompt are represented in the video: a professional ballet dancer in a flowing white leotard and pink ballet slippers, performing a grand jeté, within a sunlit studio with large windows, natural golden light, long shadows, and a polished wooden floor. The camera captures mid-air poses with extended arms, a serene focused expression, and hair in a bun, contributing to an ethereal, graceful portrayal. The scene conveys the intended mood and technical precision of the movement, resulting in a near-perfect alignment with only very minor deviations.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nMovements maintain coherent biomechanics and plausible ballet technique throughout. The dynamics feel authentic, with controlled jumps, balanced body positioning, and appropriate weight transfer. There may be occasional subtle timing nuances or small exaggerations in some transitions, but these do not undermine overall physical plausibility or common-sense expectations of human motion.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.9937, "elapsed_sec": 15.632} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::078_seed_310", "pair_id": "078_seed_310", "sample_index": 78, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crimson sky, where sleek flying cars zip through neon-lit avenues, casting vibrant reflections on the metallic surfaces below. The camera glides through this bustling metropolis, capturing the intricate dance of vehicles weaving between towering structures. As it zooms in, a colossal skyscraper emerges, its facade adorned with dynamic holographic advertisements that flicker and shift, showcasing interstellar products and services. The building's glassy exterior mirrors the kaleidoscope of colors from the streets, while digital billboards project futuristic imagery, creating a mesmerizing blend of technology and architecture in this otherworldly urban landscape.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_078_seed_310_A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crim.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.1395, "t_score_model": 3.0022, "p_score_model": 3.0031, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 538, "t": 549, "p": 561}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the given text prompt. The prompt describes \"A sprawling Martian cityscape unfolds under a crimson sky, where sleek flying cars zip through neon-lit avenues, casting vibrant reflections on the metallic surfaces below. The camera glides through this bustling metropolis, capturing the intricate dance of vehicles weaving between towering structures. As it zooms in, a colossal skyscraper emerges, its facade adorned with dynamic holographic advertisements that flicker and shift, showcasing interstellar products and services. The building's glassy exterior mirrors the kaleidoscope of colors from the streets, while digital billboards project futuristic imagery, creating a mesmerizing blend of technology and architecture in this otherworldly urban landscape.\"\n\nLet me examine each dimension:\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nLooking at the frames, I can see the video maintains a cohesive futuristic city aesthetic with neon lighting. The resolution is adequate but not exceptionally sharp; some frames show mild softness or motion blur, which may be intentional for depth or stylistic effect. The lighting and color palette (neon pinks, blues, purples) remains consistent across the sequence, and the camera movement appears smooth and stable. There are no obvious distortions or misalignments, and transitions feel steady. Overall, Visual Quality is solid and coherent, but not outstanding, aligning with a moderate rating.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nThe video captures several key elements described in the prompt—a futuristic cityscape, neon-lit streets, and a prominent glassy skyscraper with holographic displays. However, certain specifics feel only moderately matched: the sky reads as a dramatic, colorful backdrop rather than a clearly defined crimson expanse, and the depiction of sleek flying cars is present but not consistently emphasized throughout the sequence. The camera motion and architectural details convey a bustling atmosphere, and the holographic displays contribute to the technological feel, but a few prompt aspects remain ambiguous or under-realized. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is acceptable but not strong.\n\n**Physical Consistency / Common-sense Consistency:**\nThe scene maintains coherent spatial relationships, with buildings, vehicles, and holographic elements positioned plausibly within a futuristic city setting. Reflections and lighting remain consistent, supporting a believable environment. Some elements read as stylized or exaggerated for effect (e.g., scale or motion dynamics), which keeps the depiction within a plausible yet not strictly real-world framework. No major logical inconsistencies disrupt the viewer’s sense of space or causality. Overall, Physical/Common-sense Consistency is moderate and coherent.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 9.1448, "elapsed_sec": 18.74} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::079_seed_930", "pair_id": "079_seed_930", "sample_index": 79, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "As the sun dips below the horizon, casting a warm golden glow across the sky, a tranquil tropical beach scene unfolds. Gentle waves rhythmically caress the sandy shore, their soft whispers blending with the rustling of palm fronds swaying gracefully in the balmy breeze. In the distance, a quaint beachside hut, its thatched roof silhouetted against the vibrant hues of the sunset, exudes a sense of cozy seclusion. The scene is framed by lush greenery, with the occasional call of a distant seabird adding to the serene ambiance. The entire setting is bathed in the soft, fading light of dusk, creating a perfect moment of peace and tranquility.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_079_seed_930_As the sun dips below the horizon casting a warm g.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 334, "t": 345, "p": 357}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a tranquil tropical beach scene at sunset, with warm golden lighting, gentle waves, palm fronds swaying, a thatched-roof hut in the distance, and lush greenery; the moment aims to convey peace and tranquility.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality is moderate (3). The resolution is decent but not outstanding, with some softness in fine details. Colors show a warm, sunset-golden palette, and the lighting remains consistent across frames. There is a shallow depth of field and the scene appears stable with no obvious distortions or jitter. A slight blur persists in certain regions, but the composition and lighting still yield a pleasant, calm atmosphere.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong overall. All major elements are present: sunset lighting, warm sky, tropical beach, gentle waves, palm fronds, a distant thatched hut, lush vegetation, and a serene mood. The distant calls of seabirds cannot be confirmed visually, but the rest aligns well. Overall alignment is rated 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency Assessment:\nPhysical realism is solid. Water dynamics, lighting, and atmospheric depth feel natural, with no noticeable inconsistencies in perspective or motion. The scene maintains coherent physical behavior throughout, supporting a high level of common-sense realism (score 4).\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 3; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 11.933} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::081_seed_42", "pair_id": "081_seed_42", "sample_index": 81, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a noir-style scene, a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walks down a dimly lit alley, the cobblestones glistening from recent rain. The camera captures the interplay of shadows across his chiseled features as he pauses under a flickering streetlamp. He lights a cigarette, the flame briefly illuminating his stern expression and the smoke curling upwards, adding to the mysterious atmosphere. The distant sound of a saxophone echoes through the alley, enhancing the moody ambiance. His eyes, sharp and observant, scan the surroundings, revealing a man deeply engrossed in his thoughts, as the city’s secrets linger in the shadows.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_081_seed_42_In a noir-style scene a detective in a classic tre.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 393, "t": 404, "p": 416}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video frame by frame based on the provided frames and evaluate it against the given text prompt.\n\nThe text prompt describes a noir-style scene with a detective in a classic trench coat and fedora walking down a dimly lit alley, with wet cobblestones and a flickering streetlamp, plus lighting a cigarette and the implied distant saxophone, culminating in the detective deep in thought amid an atmospheric urban setting.\n\nLet me examine each dimension:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\n- The resolution is high with clear detail; lighting is deliberately dim but coherent with the noir mood.\n- The character remains clearly defined against the background, and the fedora and trench coat are rendered with period authenticity.\n- The cobbles show convincing texture and wet reflections; no obvious artifacts or distortions; motion between frames is smooth.\n- Overall Visual Quality aligns with a top-tier noir render (score 4).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\n- All core prompt elements are present and faithfully executed: noir aesthetic, the detective’s attire, the alley setting, dim lighting, wet cobblestones, the cigarette lighting sequence, the implied distant musician, and the contemplative gaze.\n- The alignment is precise and consistent throughout, yielding a perfect match to the prompt (score 4).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Analysis:\n- Movements are natural, interactions plausible; no obvious physics violations.\n- Some minor background inconsistencies emerge around the distant musician and prop handling, but they do not break immersion.\n- Overall, physical consistency is solid with minor deviations, corresponding to a score of 3.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.836} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::082_seed_310", "pair_id": "082_seed_310", "sample_index": 82, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_082_seed_310_In a dimly lit industrial workshop a grinding whee.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 5.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 5, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 386, "t": 398, "p": 443}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and the text prompt.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a dimly lit industrial workshop, a grinding wheel spins with intensity, sending a cascade of brilliant sparks into the air. The camera captures each spark in vivid detail, highlighting their fiery orange and golden hues against the shadowy backdrop of metal beams and machinery. As the wheel grinds against metal, the sparks dance and flicker, creating a mesmerizing shower of light that illuminates the scene. The slow-motion effect enhances the spectacle, allowing viewers to appreciate the intricate patterns and vibrant colors of the sparks as they burst forth, painting the dark surroundings with fleeting brilliance.\" \n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video exhibits outstanding visual fidelity across the sequence. Resolution is high, with crisp rendering of the grinding wheel, sparks, and surrounding machinery. Lighting is cinematic, effectively capturing the warm orange-golden hues of the sparks against a darker industrial backdrop. Spark dynamics are detailed, with natural motion and convincing light interactions, while motion blur is applied intentionally to convey speed without compromising clarity. Overall, Visual Quality is excellent (5/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video adheres closely to the prompt: the dim industrial setting, a spinning grinding wheel, cascading sparks, vivid orange-golden tones, visible metal structures, and the mesmerizing light effects are all faithfully represented. The slow-motion treatment is well-integrated, revealing intricate patterns and enhancing the visual impact. The alignment is excellent (5/5).\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains coherent physical behavior: the wheel’s rotation, the trajectory of sparks, and the lighting interactions align with real-world expectations, producing plausible industrial imagery. There are no noticeable inconsistencies; the dynamics feel authentic and internally consistent (5/5).\n\nGround-truth scores:\nDim-1 Visual Quality: 5\nDim-2 Text-to-Video Alignment: 5\nDim-3 Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 5\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 15.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.733} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::083_seed_930", "pair_id": "083_seed_930", "sample_index": 83, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera captures the ethereal northern lights swirling gracefully across the Arctic sky, painting vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue. Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above the pristine, snow-blanketed landscape, where gentle mounds of snow glisten under the celestial display. The scene is framed by the silhouettes of distant, rugged mountains, adding depth to the horizon. A tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating a mirror-like effect that doubles the spectacle. The air is crisp and silent, enhancing the serene and magical atmosphere, as the lights dance in an ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_083_seed_930_The camera captures the ethereal northern lights s.mp4", "v_score_model": 5.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 5.0, "v_score_hard": 5, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 5, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 449, "t": 459, "p": 390}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes: \"The camera captures the ethereal northern lights swirling gracefully across the Arctic sky, painting vibrant hues of green, purple, and blue. Stars twinkle like scattered diamonds above the pristine, snow-blanketed landscape, where gentle mounds of snow glisten under the celestial display. The scene is framed by the silhouettes of distant, rugged mountains, adding depth to the horizon. A tranquil, frozen lake reflects the aurora's colors, creating a mirror-like effect that doubles the spectacle. The air is crisp and silent, enhancing the serene and magical atmosphere, as the lights dance in an ever-changing, mesmerizing ballet\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the video demonstrates excellent Visual Quality (5/5). The frames exhibit high fidelity with sharp details and convincing rendering of atmospheric phenomena. The northern lights display rich greens, purples, and blues, and lighting remains consistent across scenes. Motion is smooth, and reflections on the frozen lake are convincing. The sequence maintains stable brightness and contrast, and there are no obvious artifacts or distortions, yielding a cinematic and immersive presentation.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nAlignment is strong but not perfect (4/5). The video largely matches the prompt, capturing the essential elements—ethereal northern lights, Arctic sky, vibrant hues, starry backdrop, pristine snow, distant mountains, and a tranquil, reflective lake. The atmosphere feels crisp and silent, and the lights move in a mesmerizing ballet. However, a few minor deviations exist: the star field shows slightly more activity than described, and some background detail could be marginally more subdued. These small differences prevent a perfect match but do not significantly detract from overall fidelity.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nPhysical consistency is excellent (5/5). The scene presents plausible physics for light behavior, atmospheric perspective, snow coverage, and reflection on the ice. The dynamics of the lights and their interaction with the landscape follow expected physical principles, resulting in a coherent and believable depiction.\n\nGround-truth scores:\n- Visual Quality: 5\n- Text-to-Video Alignment: 4\n- Physical Consistency: 5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 5\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 5\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 14.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.643} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::085_seed_42", "pair_id": "085_seed_42", "sample_index": 85, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyon, its icy walls towering and glistening under a soft, muted light. As it soars, the scene transitions into a surreal cloudscape, where fluffy clouds drift lazily across a pastel sky. The motion is fluid and dynamic, capturing the ethereal beauty of the clouds. Suddenly, the view shifts to a serene forest, where tall trees sway gently in a whispering breeze, their leaves a muted green. The journey continues, seamlessly flowing into a tranquil desert, where rolling dunes stretch endlessly, bathed in the soft glow of a setting sun. The muted color palette ties each landscape together, creating a harmonious and dreamlike visual experience.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_085_seed_42_The camera glides through a majestic glacial canyo.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0001, "t_score_model": 4.003, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 388, "t": 399, "p": 382}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis: I need to analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt, evaluating it across three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency. Let me examine each aspect carefully.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a dynamic journey through multiple landscapes: an icy glacial canyon with glistening walls, a surreal cloudscape, a serene forest, and a tranquil desert, all tied by a muted color palette and a seamless progression between scenes. The sequence aims for a fluid, ethereal movement that feels like moving through different worlds while maintaining visual harmony.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, the visuals present a moderate level of detail. Some early frames show blur and softness, which can be interpreted as stylistic depth of field rather than a failure. There is occasional motion blur during transitions and some later sequences appear softer, but the frames remain legible and coherent. Lighting and contrast stay relatively stable, preserving the muted palette, though a few late frames exhibit mild artifacting and reduced sharpness. In sum, the video maintains acceptable clarity with noticeable but not crippling quality variations.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt remains strong throughout. The video clearly conveys the intended sequence—glacial features, clouds, forests, and desert landscapes—with the described transitions and mood. While fine-grained texture may vary slightly, the major elements, spatial arrangement, and emotional tone align well with the prompt, yielding a high degree of fidelity.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe overall physical behavior follows plausible natural dynamics (ice formations, cloud patterns, vegetation, and desert terrain). Some subtle inconsistencies exist, such as minor timing of transitions and occasional stylized lighting, but they do not break the sense of realism. The scene remains believable within its imaginative framework, supporting a moderate level of common-sense consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.0031, "elapsed_sec": 13.78} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::086_seed_310", "pair_id": "086_seed_310", "sample_index": 86, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at a grand piano on a sandy beach, her fingers dancing over the keys, creating a melody that harmonizes with the gentle waves. The camera begins to rotate around her, capturing her serene expression and the intricate details of her white lace dress. As it moves, the expansive ocean stretches endlessly, its surface shimmering under the soft, golden light of the setting sun. The sky is painted with pastel hues, adding to the whimsical atmosphere. Seagulls glide gracefully above, and the gentle breeze rustles her hair, completing the enchanting scene.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_086_seed_310_A young woman with flowing hair sits gracefully at.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0006, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 482, "t": 493, "p": 505}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a young woman with flowing hair sitting at a grand piano on a sandy beach, her fingers moving over the keys while waves gently crash behind her. The camera gradually rotates around her, revealing her serene expression and the intricate white lace details of her dress. As the shot expands, the ocean stretches to the horizon, its surface shimmering under warm sunset light. The sky displays soft pastel tones, enhancing the whimsical mood, with seagulls gliding overhead and a light breeze animating her hair and dress.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nThe visuals deliver strong fidelity throughout. The resolution is high, with clear details in the subject, dress, and surrounding environment. The lighting is consistently warm and cinematic, with well-balanced contrast between the subject and the beach backdrop. Colors are vibrant yet natural, and motion remains smooth across sequences. While a few frames show minor rendering artifacts around fine hand movements on the keyboard, these are subtle and do not substantially detract from overall quality. Overall, visual quality is strong and coherent across the video.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely tracks the prompt and captures all major elements: the young woman with flowing hair seated at a grand piano on a sandy beach, hands moving over the keys, waves in the background, a gradual camera rotation, visible white lace details, ocean expanse, sunset lighting, pastel sky, seagulls, and gentle hair movement. The alignment is high and consistent, with only minor deviations in certain micro-details (e.g., finger placement nuances or timing of the seafoam) that do not undermine the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe scene maintains natural interactions among the woman, the piano, the beach, and the sea. Hair and dress respond plausibly to breeze and motion, and the integration of the instrument with the sandy setting feels organic. The lighting and shadows align with the sun position, producing a cohesive visual narrative. Minor inconsistencies exist in fine-grained hand articulation and some subtle environmental interactions, but they are limited and do not disrupt overall realism. Overall, physical consistency is strong and convincing.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0006, "elapsed_sec": 16.714} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::087_seed_930", "pair_id": "087_seed_930", "sample_index": 87, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A striking woman, dressed head-to-toe in vibrant orange, stands amidst a lush tropical rainforest, surrounded by an array of colorful flora. The overcast sky above casts a dramatic contrast, enhancing the vividness of her attire against the rich greens and bright blossoms. The camera captures her from a low angle, emphasizing her presence and the towering trees around her. Her expression is serene yet powerful, as if she is one with the vibrant ecosystem. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds add to the enchanting atmosphere, creating a mesmerizing scene of harmony and contrast.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_087_seed_930_A striking woman dressed head-to-toe in vibrant or.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.986, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 505, "t": 516, "p": 528}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\n\"A striking woman, dressed head-to-toe in vibrant orange, stands amidst a lush tropical rainforest, surrounded by an array of colorful flora. The overcast sky above casts a dramatic contrast, enhancing the vividness of her attire against the rich greens and bright blossoms. The camera captures her from a low angle, emphasizing her presence and the towering trees around her. Her expression is serene yet powerful, as if she is one with the vibrant ecosystem. The gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds add to the enchanting atmosphere, creating a mesmerizing scene of harmony and contrast\"\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames, the visual quality appears solid with good resolution and clear detail across the sequence. The subject remains crisp and well-lit, and the tropical background renders rich texture and depth. Colors are vibrant, especially the orange attire, which reads clearly against the greenery. There are no obvious distortions or misalignments, and the overall composition stays stable across shots. While motion smoothness cannot be judged from stills alone, the sequence suggests consistent framing and natural-looking movement when viewed as a video. Overall, the visual fidelity aligns with a high-quality production, though it does not claim perfection.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely mirrors the prompt elements: a striking woman in vibrant orange, set within a lush rainforest, with a low-angle emphasis and a serene yet powerful expression. The alignment is strong across most features (attire, setting, composition, and mood). A minor interpretive nuance exists regarding the \"head-to-toe\" coverage: the framing generally keeps the figure visible from roughly chest-up rather than strictly head-to-toe, which constitutes a small divergence but does not undermine the overall alignment. Lighting and environmental details support the intended mood and contrast, and the scene maintains coherence throughout.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nThe subject's integration with the environment reads as organic, with clothing draping naturally, body proportions appearing typical, and lighting/shadows cohering with the vegetation. While the interaction is convincing, there are a few subtle cues—such as slight uniformity in certain fabric folds and shading transitions—that prevent perfect believability. These minor inconsistencies keep the assessment at a solid level of realism rather than flawless authenticity.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 11.986, "elapsed_sec": 17.565} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::089_seed_42", "pair_id": "089_seed_42", "sample_index": 89, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a dimly lit tunnel, the walls a blur of shadow and light. Emerging into a sprawling labyrinth, the scene transforms into a chaotic dance of rapidly growing vines, twisting and curling with a life of their own. The camera navigates through disorienting angles, capturing the vines' relentless expansion, their tendrils reaching out like eager fingers. Fast transitions between shots create a dizzying effect, as the viewer is plunged deeper into the maze, the vibrant green of the vines contrasting starkly against the dark, earthy tones of the labyrinth. The atmosphere is both thrilling and unsettling, as the camera weaves through this living, breathing puzzle.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_089_seed_42_The camera hurtles at breakneck speed through a di.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 420, "t": 431, "p": 443}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video thoroughly based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes a high-speed journey through a dimly lit tunnel with blurred walls, followed by a transition into a vibrant tunnel of rapidly growing vines. The video conveys a similar concept with strong visual cues, but the alignment is not perfect across all aspects.\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis (score target: 4):**\nOverall Visual Quality is solid. Resolution is adequate; lighting creates a convincing dim atmosphere, though some frames exhibit mild softness. Motion blur is present but readable as a stylistic choice rather than a defect, and transitions feel smooth enough to preserve coherence. A few minor blur artifacts and occasional focus shifts are noticeable, yet they do not dominate the viewing experience. Overall, the visuals meet a high-quality expectation with only minor imperfections.\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis (score target: 4):**\nThe video largely captures the core elements: a tunnel setting, a rapid progression, and a shift toward a more complex, organic environment dominated by green vegetation. However, certain details from the prompt are not perfectly realized, such as the precise depiction of a \"sprawling labyrinth\" and the intensity of a truly \"relentless expansion.\" The alignment is strong overall and coherent throughout, but not flawless.\n\n**Physical Consistency Analysis (score target: 4):**\nSpatial relationships remain coherent despite distortions. The initial tunnel geometry persists while the surrounding vines introduce warping without breaking immersion. The vegetation’s growth appears plausible within the scene’s stylized context, and lighting continues to support depth and dimension. The dynamics respect basic physical logic, with only minor deviations due to artistic distortion.\n\n**Scoring Considerations:**\nThe evaluation indicates a balanced, solid performance across dimensions. Minor artifacts exist but do not undermine the overall coherence or intent of the piece, yielding a rating of 4 for Visual Quality, Text-to-Video Alignment, and Physical/Common-sense Consistency.\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 14.691} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::090_seed_310", "pair_id": "090_seed_310", "sample_index": 90, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a vibrant, humid rainforest, a sloth leisurely traverses a thick branch, its every movement deliberate and unhurried. The camera captures the intricate details of its coarse, moss-tinted fur, each strand glistening with moisture under the soft, cinematic lighting that filters through the dense canopy above. The lush green foliage surrounds the sloth, creating a rich tapestry of verdant hues, while the gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds provide a serene soundtrack. As the sloth pauses, its soulful eyes reflect the tranquility of its environment, embodying the essence of the rainforest's timeless, unhurried rhythm.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_090_seed_310_In a vibrant humid rainforest a sloth leisurely tr.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 685, "t": 696, "p": 708}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes \"In a vibrant, humid rainforest, a sloth leisurely traverses a thick branch, its every movement deliberate and unhurried. The camera captures the intricate details of its coarse, moss-tinted fur, each strand glistening with moisture under the soft, cinematic lighting that filters through the dense canopy above. The lush green foliage surrounds the sloth, creating a rich tapestry of verdant hues, while the gentle rustle of leaves and distant calls of exotic birds provide a serene soundtrack. As the sloth pauses, its soulful eyes reflect the tranquility of its environment, embodying the essence of the rainforest's timeless, unhurried rhythm.\" \n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nLooking at the frames, I can observe several aspects:\n\n1. Resolution and Clarity: The footage delivers solid resolution with clear details; the fur texture, facial features, and the branch structure are readily perceptible.\n\n2. Stability and Smoothness: Overall motion feels smooth, though occasional minor micro-jitter or exposure fluctuations prevent a perfect top-tier score.\n\n3. Color and Lighting: The greens are vivid and natural, with lighting that convincingly filters through the canopy to create depth.\n\n4. Depth of Field: Background blur helps separate subject from backdrop, contributing to a believable sense of space.\n\n5. Motion Blur: Natural-looking motion blur appears during quick transitions, but it does not dominate the frame.\n\n6. Overall Visual Experience: The sequence reads as professionally composed with credible cinematography. However, minor imperfections keep the Visual Quality at a strong 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nComparing the visuals to the prompt requirements:\n\n1. Setting: ✓ Rainforest environment clearly depicted with dense vegetation\n2. Subject: ✓ Three-toed sloth present and prominently featured\n3. Action: ✓ The sloth moves across a thick branch with deliberate pacing\n4. Movement Characteristics: ✓ Movement is unhurried and measured as described\n\n5. Fur Details: ✓ Thick, coarse fur texture and moss-like tint captured\n6. Lighting: ✓ Soft, filtered illumination aligns with the described atmosphere\n7. Foliage: ✓ Lush greenery surrounding the animal creates depth\n8. Visual Elements: ✓ Cinematic framing and environmental textures support the narrative\n\nOverall, the video demonstrates strong alignment with the original textual description, capturing the essence of a rainforest exploration with a slow-moving animal. While the alignment is strong, there may be minor frame-level deviations that do not significantly detract from fidelity (score 4).\n\nPhysical Consistency / Common-sense:\nThe scene adheres closely to plausible physics and behavior: gravity-driven movement, appropriate grip, fur dynamics, and interaction with the branch are coherent. The representation remains scientifically grounded without obvious contradictions. Some very subtle motion transitions could be refined for even more fluidity, but the overall physical consistency remains high.\n\nGround-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality': 4\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment': 4\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency): 4\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 22.809} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::091_seed_930", "pair_id": "091_seed_930", "sample_index": 91, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A thrilling first-person perspective races through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape, where towering skyscrapers adorned with neon lights flash by in a blur of color and motion. The streets are alive with holographic advertisements and bustling crowds, creating a sense of urgency and excitement. As the pace quickens, the scene transitions seamlessly into a digital realm, where swirling streams of code and data form a mesmerizing tapestry of light and information. The rapid transitions between the physical and digital worlds are accentuated by dynamic blur effects, creating an exhilarating sensation of speed and immersion in this futuristic, high-tech environment.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_091_seed_930_A thrilling first-person perspective races through.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.5843, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 563, "t": 574, "p": 549}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nI need to analyze the video frames provided against the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical/common-sense consistency.\n\nFirst, let me understand the text prompt:\n'A thrilling first-person perspective races through a vibrant cyberpunk cityscape, where towering skyscrapers adorned with neon lights flash by in a blur of color and motion. The streets are alive with holographic advertisements and bustling crowds, creating a sense of urgency and excitement. As the pace quickens, the scene transitions seamlessly into a digital realm, where swirling streams of code and data form a mesmerizing tapestry of light and information. The rapid transitions between the physical and digital worlds are accentuated by dynamic blur effects, creating an exhilarating sensation of speed and immersion in this futuristic, high-tech environment'\n\nNow let me analyze the video frames:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n- Resolution appears decent but not exceptional; some scenes show noticeable motion blur and compression artifacts\n- The sequence starts with a convincing cyberpunk cityscape and transitions toward a digital data stream\n- The initial city view features neon signs and urban architecture; the later data-stream segments resemble blue/cyan flowing patterns\n- There is some inconsistency in sharpness across frames, with early frames clearer than later ones\n- The motion blur is present and contributes to the speed feel, but it reduces fine detail and can look slightly artificial\n- Lighting and contrast shift with the transition from city to data, contributing to a cohesive but uneven visual tone\n- The overall visual presentation remains coherent and stylistically consistent, yet lacks top-tier polish\n\nOverall Visual Quality score: 3/5\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe video largely matches the prompt elements: first-person perspective, vibrant cyberpunk cityscape with neon signage, bustling street cues, and a transition into a digital data stream. The alignment is strong for most components, and the sequence communicates the intended progression from analog to digital space. Some aspects—such as explicit crowds or a more pronounced emphasis on holographic overlays—are present but not always rendered with high clarity. The pacing and blur support the sense of speed, and the overall narrative feels faithful to the concept.\n\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment score: 4/5\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe sequence maintains plausible spatial relationships within a cyberpunk aesthetic. Early frames preserve depth and scale typical of an urban setting, while the later data-stream segments introduce stylized abstraction without breaking immersion. Minor inconsistencies in how the transition blends city and code exist, but they do not disrupt the overall coherence or believability of the environment.\n\nOverall Physical/Common-sense Consistency score: 4/5\n\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.584299999999999, "elapsed_sec": 18.418} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::093_seed_42", "pair_id": "093_seed_42", "sample_index": 93, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "A vintage teddy bear, with worn fur and a stitched smile, sits on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt. As golden sunlight streams through delicate lace curtains, casting intricate patterns on the walls, the bear's eyes flutter open, revealing a spark of life. The camera slowly pulls back, capturing the room's whimsical charm, as the bear begins to move, its limbs stretching and head turning with newfound animation. The gentle rustle of the curtains and the soft glow of the morning light create a magical atmosphere, as the bear embarks on its enchanting journey within the cozy, sunlit room.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_093_seed_42_A vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 442, "t": 453, "p": 465}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and text prompt to evaluate it across the three dimensions.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched smile sitting on a child's bed, surrounded by pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt, with golden sunlight streaming through delicate lace curtains, casting intricate patterns on the walls. The bear's eyes flutter open, revealing a spark of life, and the camera slowly pulls back to capture the room's whimsical charm as the bear begins to move, its limbs stretching and head turning with newfound animation.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall Visual Quality score is 4. The video maintains high clarity and detailed fur texture throughout most of the sequence, with consistent lighting, smooth motion, and stable focus. There are only minor instances of slight softness around edges during rapid motion, but these do not substantially detract from the viewing experience. No obvious distortions or abrupt changes are present, and the sequence remains cohesive visually.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nOverall Text-to-Video Alignment score is 4. Across the video, the key prompt elements are represented: a vintage teddy bear with worn fur and a stitched smile; seated on a child's bed with pastel pillows and a patchwork quilt; warm sunlight through delicate lace curtains with wall patterns; the bear's eyes opening and visible expression; subtle movement with arm extension and head turn; and a gentle rustle of curtains with a bright, inviting mood. Minor pacing deviations exist but do not undermine the overall alignment with the prompt.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency Assessment:\nOverall Physical Consistency score is 4. The character's proportions, posture, and limb articulation remain coherent across the sequence. A few small frame-to-frame variances occur during extended gestures, but they are limited in scope and do not disrupt the perceived realism or the narrative progression.\n\nFinal Assessment:\nThe video demonstrates strong visual fidelity, faithful representation of the textual prompt, and solid physical consistency. The overall quality is high with only minor artefacts, aligning with a 4 across all three dimensions.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 15.351} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::094_seed_310", "pair_id": "094_seed_310", "sample_index": 94, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a mesmerizing macro view, delicate water droplets cling to a spider's web, each droplet shimmering like a tiny universe. As the camera zooms in, the droplets begin to transform, revealing swirling galaxies within, with stars twinkling and spiraling in cosmic dance. The web, intricately woven, serves as a celestial canvas, its strands glistening like silken threads of the cosmos. The dimly lit background enhances the ethereal glow of the galaxies, casting a soft, mysterious light that accentuates the delicate beauty of this otherworldly transformation. The scene captures the enchanting fusion of nature and the universe in a breathtaking display.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_094_seed_310_In a mesmerizing macro view delicate water droplet.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 3.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 3, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 291, "t": 302, "p": 277}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze the video frames carefully across the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nAcross the sequence, the macro shot of water droplets on a spider web is captured with generally good clarity. Most frames retain detail in the droplets and the web strands, and lighting supports a cohesive blue-tinted palette. There are occasional fluctuations in sharpness between frames, but these do not dominate the viewing experience. The later frames show mild softness and minor noise, yet the overall image coherence remains solid. Overall, the Visual Quality is good (score 4/5).\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a mesmerizing macro view with delicate droplets, a cosmic transformation via galactic cores, and a celestial canvas. The video indeed presents a macro view with droplets and a visible center, and it includes swirling galactic motifs and star-like twinkling. However, the depiction leans toward artistic interpretation rather than a strict physical progression, resulting in a moderate alignment with the textual description. Overall, Text-to-Video Alignment is moderate (score 3/5).\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe depiction blends natural elements with cosmic imagery, creating a surreal synthesis where botanical textures meet celestial phenomena. While visually intriguing, several aspects deviate from real-world physics and everyday common sense, yielding a moderate level of consistency (score 3/5).\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 3\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 10.811} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::095_seed_930", "pair_id": "095_seed_930", "sample_index": 95, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban street, capturing the vibrant energy of pedestrians and honking cars, as neon signs flicker to life, casting colorful reflections on rain-slicked pavements. As it rises, the scene transitions seamlessly from the warm hues of sunset to the cool blues of twilight, revealing the intricate network of streets below. Reaching the rooftop, the cityscape unfolds, with skyscrapers gradually illuminating, their windows twinkling like stars against the deepening night sky. The transformation is complete as the city pulses with life, a mesmerizing tapestry of light and shadow, showcasing the dynamic shift from day to night.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_095_seed_930_The camera begins its ascent from a bustling urban.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 3.0, "v_score_hard": 3, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 3, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 394, "t": 405, "p": 417}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze the provided video frames and compare them with the text prompt to evaluate the three dimensions:\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a sequence where a camera ascends from a bustling street, starting at sunset and transitioning through warm hues to twilight, then revealing a vibrant cityscape from a rooftop with illuminated skyscrapers and a star-like twinkling of windows. The video largely captures this progression, though some narrative details diverge slightly.\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nOverall, Visual Quality is moderate (3/5). The early frames show noticeable blur and soft detail; later frames are clearer but still exhibit occasional motion blur and minor jitter. The lighting transition from warmer sunset tones to cooler evening hues remains reasonably smooth, and the aerial perspective provides decent framing of the urban environment. Some camera shake is present, reducing perceived sharpness, while color and contrast stay generally consistent.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nAlignment with the prompt is strong (4/5). The core arc—camera ascent, shift from street level to rooftop view, and illumination of the cityscape—is well represented. The neon ambiance and the progression toward night are evident. A few small details (e.g., exact timing of the transition or precise street activity) may vary, but they do not significantly detract from the overall correspondence.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nPhysical consistency is moderate (3/5). There are subtle inconsistencies in camera motion and lighting cues that can momentarily challenge believable physics (e.g., perspective shifts or timing of illumination changes), yet no major violations are observed and the sequence remains coherent overall.\n\nground-truth of Dim-1: 'Visual Quality':\n3\n\nground-truth of Dim-2: 'Text-to-Video Alignment':\n4\n\nground-truth of Dim-3: 'Physical Consistency' (also referred to as Common-sense Consistency):\n3\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 3\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 3\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 10.0, "elapsed_sec": 13.966} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::097_seed_42", "pair_id": "097_seed_42", "sample_index": 97, "seed": 42, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers, their petals swaying gracefully in the gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion across the landscape. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality of the scene. As the camera glides over the field, the flowers' delicate hues blend seamlessly with the lush green foliage, forming a stunning tapestry of color. The rhythmic movement of the petals, reminiscent of ocean waves, evokes a sense of tranquility and wonder, as if nature itself is performing a serene dance under the vast, open sky.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_097_seed_42_An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibra.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 553, "t": 564, "p": 576}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me carefully analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt.\n\n**Text Prompt Analysis:**\nThe prompt describes \"An aerial view reveals an expansive field of vibrant pink flowers, their petals swaying gracefully in the gentle breeze, creating a mesmerizing wave-like motion across the landscape. The sun casts a warm, golden glow, enhancing the dreamlike quality of the scene. As the camera glides over the field, the flowers' delicate hues blend seamlessly with the lush green foliage, forming a stunning tapestry of color. The rhythmic movement of the petals, reminiscent of ocean waves, evokes a sense of tranquility and wonder, as if nature itself is performing a serene dance under the vast, open sky.\"\n\n**Visual Quality Analysis:**\nLooking at the frames, I can see:\n\n1. **Resolution and Clarity**: The video presents solid resolution with clear separation between pink flowers and green foliage. Details are reasonably well defined and the overall sharpness supports readable textures without obvious artifacts.\n\n2. **Local Blurriness**: There is mild softness in distant portions, but it appears intentional and does not compromise the overall perception; depth cues remain coherent across the sequence.\n\n3. **Smoothness and Stability**: Transitions feel steady, with no noticeable jumps; motion remains cohesive throughout.\n\n4. **Brightness/Contrast**: Lighting is consistently warm and golden, with good contrast between pink blooms and green leaves, contributing to a vivid palette.\n\n5. **Distortion/Misalignment**: No obvious distortions or misalignments are evident.\n\n6. **Abrupt Changes**: Frame progression is smooth with no jarring shifts.\n\nOverall, Visual Quality is solid and coherent (score 4).\n\n**Text-to-Video Alignment Analysis:**\nAssessing how well the video aligns with the prompt:\n\n1. **Aerial View**: ✓ The perspective clearly conveys an elevated, overhead vantage.\n\n2. **Expansive Field**: ✓ The scene extends across the frame, conveying breadth.\n\n3. **Vibrant Pink Flowers**: ✓ Pink tones are vivid and widespread.\n\n4. **Swaying Petals**: ✓ Gentle motion is visible across the field, consistent with a breeze.\n\nThe video captures the essence of the textual description with high fidelity. The representation demonstrates strong alignment between the prompt and the visual output, with only minor deviations that do not meaningfully detract from the overall narrative. The color gradients, lighting, and motion together reinforce a natural, harmonious landscape that feels authentic to the imagined scene.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality = 4, Text-to-Video Alignment = 4, Physical Consistency = 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 17.858} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::098_seed_310", "pair_id": "098_seed_310", "sample_index": 98, "seed": 310, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a dimly lit studio, an artist, wearing a worn apron and glasses perched on their nose, meticulously carves a sculpture from a block of marble. The camera captures the precision of each movement, focusing on the artist's skilled hands as they wield a chisel and mallet with practiced ease. Dust particles dance in the soft, ambient light, highlighting the artist's intense concentration. As the sculpture gradually emerges, the camera pans over the intricate details, revealing the delicate curves and textures taking shape. The artist pauses occasionally, stepping back to assess their work, their face a portrait of focused determination and creative passion.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_098_seed_310_In a dimly lit studio an artist wearing a worn apr.mp4", "v_score_model": 4.0, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 4.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 397, "t": 408, "p": 420}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the provided frames and the text prompt. I need to evaluate three dimensions: visual quality, text-to-video alignment, and physical consistency.\n\nText Prompt Analysis:\nThe prompt describes a dimly lit studio scene where an artist wearing a worn apron and glasses works on a marble sculpture, emphasizing meticulous hand movements with a chisel and mallet, dust particles, and a gradual reveal of the sculpture as the camera pans over its details. The scene should convey a portrait of focused determination and creative passion.\n\nVisual Quality Assessment:\nOverall, the visual quality is strong and coherent with the prompt. Resolution and lighting are solid, preserving detail in both the hands and the sculpture. There is consistent brightness and contrast across most frames, and the depth-of-field effect looks natural. A few late frames show minor degradation, but this does not undermine the overall impression. In summary, Visual Quality aligns with a score of 4.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Assessment:\nThe video closely follows the prompt: the studio setting, the artist in a worn apron with glasses, working on a marble piece, and careful hand movements with a chisel are all present. The lighting feels appropriately dim, dust particles are visible, and the sculpture gradually reveals itself as the camera pans. The portrayal of focused concentration is evident. While the alignment is strong overall, there may be occasional small deviations in pacing or fine-grained details, corresponding to a score of 4.\n\nPhysical Consistency (Common-sense):\nSpatial relationships among the artist, tools, and marble surface are coherent throughout; the chisel contact, hand positioning, and lighting remain plausible, with no obvious physics violations. Minor refinements could improve realism further, but the current depiction supports a score of 4.\n\nGround-truth scores: Visual Quality 4; Text-to-Video Alignment 4; Physical Consistency 4.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 12.0, "elapsed_sec": 16.523} +{"video_id": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2::099_seed_930", "pair_id": "099_seed_930", "sample_index": 99, "seed": 930, "model_name": "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2", "prompt": "In a sunlit studio, a painter with tousled hair and a focused expression stands before a large canvas, surrounded by an array of vibrant paints and brushes. The camera captures the artist's hand as it deftly moves across the canvas, blending rich blues and fiery oranges with a palette knife, creating a mesmerizing dance of colors. As the scene unfolds, the painter steps back, revealing the gradual emergence of a breathtaking landscape, with rolling hills and a golden sky. The camera zooms in on the intricate details, showcasing the texture and depth of the brushstrokes, as the artwork comes to life in a symphony of hues.", "video_path": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100/sample_099_seed_930_In a sunlit studio a painter with tousled hair and.mp4", "v_score_model": 3.9999, "t_score_model": 4.0, "p_score_model": 1.0, "v_score_hard": 4, "t_score_hard": 4, "p_score_hard": 4, "score_token_indexes": {"v": 343, "t": 354, "p": 337}, "output": "\n\nmulti-dimensional analysis:\nLet me analyze this video based on the frames provided and evaluate it against the three dimensions:\n\nVisual Quality Analysis:\nThe video presents a painter in a sunlit studio with a colorful landscape on the canvas. Overall visual quality is solid. Resolution and detail are respectable; lighting remains consistent under natural light from windows. However, motion blur occurs during rapid hand movements, causing occasional softness in the brushwork and some frames showing slightly softer detail. No major distortions or artifacts are evident, and transitions between frames are smooth. Taken together, the quality is good but not flawless due to occasional blur and minor softness.\n\nText-to-Video Alignment Analysis:\nThe sequence largely reflects the described scenario — a sunlit studio, a painter at work with vibrant hues, and a focus on the evolving artwork. While most elements align well, certain specifics (like a broader display of additional paints and brushes beyond what is visible) are not strongly evidenced. The depiction of the painter's steps back and the reveal of the landscape is present as the composition progresses, and the camera captures intricate details as the art develops. Overall alignment is strong but not perfect, consistent with a score around 4.\n\nPhysical/Common-sense Consistency:\nThe scene adheres to real-world physics: the painter's posture, tool handling, and spatial relationships feel authentic. Motion blur adds realism for dynamic hand gestures without breaking plausibility. There may be very minor timing mismatches or subtle exaggerations in speed, but these do not significantly detract from overall coherence. On balance, the video demonstrates solid physical consistency, approaching a high score while allowing for small refinements.\n\n\n(1) visual quality: 4\n(2) text-to-video alignment: 4\n(3) physical/common-sense consistency: 4\n", "success": true, "total_score_model": 8.9999, "elapsed_sec": 11.666} diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_7_summary.json b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_7_summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0131727f69dfc352e83d9a22206eee1dfe35958b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_7_summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +{ + "total_score_tasks": 75, + "success_score_tasks": 75, + "failed_score_tasks": 0, + "model_name_or_path": "/root/ckpts/VideoScore2", + "scores_jsonl": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards/shard_7_scores.jsonl", + "shard_count": 8, + "shard_index": 7, + "infer_fps": 2.0, + "floating_method": "weighted", + "do_sample": true, + "score_latency_sec": { + "mean": 15.19204, + "median": 15.259, + "min": 9.309, + "max": 22.809 + } +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/summary.json b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/summary.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2b0b905e8ac344a6364f1e0981dd4a6a0f721795 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/summary.json @@ -0,0 +1,41 @@ +{ + "total_pairs": 300, + "success_pairs": 300, + "total_score_tasks": 600, + "success_score_tasks": 600, + "counts": { + "yw002-1-sage-baseline": 154, + "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2": 115, + "tie": 31, + "unknown": 0, + "failed": 0 + }, + "win_rate_including_ties": { + "yw002-1-sage-baseline": 0.5133333333333333, + "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2": 0.38333333333333336 + }, + "win_rate_decisive_only": { + "yw002-1-sage-baseline": 0.5724907063197026, + "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2": 0.4275092936802974 + }, + "prompt_seed_majority": { + "yw002-1-sage-baseline_majority": 54, + "tie_majority": 12, + "yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2_majority": 34 + }, + "dir_a": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw002-1-sage-baseline/videogen_val/step_000100", + "dir_b": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/videogen_val/step_000100", + "model_name_or_path": "/root/ckpts/VideoScore2", + "method": "VideoScore2 vs2_float weighted token-prob score; pairwise total=v+t+p", + "infer_fps": 2.0, + "max_new_tokens": 1024, + "do_sample": true, + "pairwise_jsonl": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/pairwise_results.jsonl", + "scores_shards_dir": "/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/videoscore2_pairwise/yw002-1-sage-baseline_vs_yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/step_000100/shards", + "score_latency_sec": { + "mean": 15.417125, + "median": 15.3655, + "min": 8.692, + "max": 27.572 + } +} \ No newline at end of file