diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_29.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_29.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9d2646e3b8744c2e2aa29567a8667d5dfc3fdf8b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_29.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:4f2a8f1c8b7cc54cc3e1716f089d05b342f5075412f0c1204b36918c4ce2327f
+size 4555548
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_30.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_30.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..26a6fe20e321a63172c2371756045ca9a593d8cd
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_30.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:57e6a575d3fcb047f5d0c497e9c41cb96a466f99387f68aed84b03b20ee7eb01
+size 4597154
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_31.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_31.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a05ad90155efe3dd7b675a7cd9d0a8f2797be207
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_31.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:7f05382a6f307ce05a2bf4672d765a90d0dfa736082279c079ebf04c7c961a58
+size 4607116
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_32.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_32.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..501d71d57b7b3bdd8015208ec2235ce3da0adc69
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_32.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:a8674dc662f635d85953f830ff5ecb321cb75c663acf6af7ae6ca72cc2cfc177
+size 4345588
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_33.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_33.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4f5ad6bf4b8b5e2450dd136e216abf30411e8ad9
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_33.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:e5bd71f32792e1ae701b7613d9a40c86741741ea0607aa732a9737e70eaf8f56
+size 4449849
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_34.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_34.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ebf9d46c97dcd79dccdb507977f7c1b61796f81b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_34.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:fac48e133bf18ec0fa7edab78c9b0ec73110d5bfd84b63190636a6ea08879153
+size 4245694
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_35.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_35.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..79357a3d0390fa70271ff2ce8fe946a8863a0945
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_35.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:050f72ff2ffeefc75377a85ebbaa04040c532abdac3a878b13d9d2b6a98e4c7f
+size 4322104
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_36.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_36.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7385bb4f27af1abf41c1a1160071d5f8f9f235be
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_36.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:0b258127b0affcc780778ade988d7146a97e230a7ed6e1d047a577a88f48da33
+size 4454773
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_37.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_37.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..02fd1c8fdba54cc54a1bad950bc086b6f2e46b48
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_37.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:190eef1358216f25bf5d1a93bf0a7e5755eb259f2393301c166182f600cbbd4b
+size 4582242
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_38.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_38.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..369c36cdc96dd3c80899f669134669dd816f1c90
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_38.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:2b31b7b46bfa47cab463d4450e84c79b595a9c07ecf9f494bf53eef0c6467d00
+size 4479277
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_39.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_39.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0268df237e502edd6ede72fdb72ecc506aacdd66
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_39.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:16bc938eae016861fb8236573ff2286d775655ea963ceaab35b37812e4b61aea
+size 4422546
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_40.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_40.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e081f3662c4165b181f5352f8105866fccf98be2
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_40.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:056952ffcfa991a5997eef109e063b367ffac2e17e076a67448230493599e842
+size 4375219
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_41.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_41.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..95a8fc40cfe13d00f804dfc219486ecf5ac2adf1
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_41.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:2144d4cd4412adb6cf9163dd6b8753d3d7beecf59b1dedfbebd92223cd8fb021
+size 4331910
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_42.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_42.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bebc3b2a89bb0279175fe7db84a1a7938edeaad7
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_42.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:c060d917b6548cd5e5c7db3f887073c9370ae95491d9306314c7f7bb09f4c9c5
+size 4404871
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_43.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_43.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c357abb1127c40df7a8024c03ac0949e2d9f3777
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_43.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:fd8efc66b52eb94abde2ae3d8da6c8dd830b803c7c0670be49598580e4020462
+size 4260989
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_44.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_44.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..674be73d01183e7b3cc299e49bac1095bf5d0392
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_44.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:42d2ec4aec663195b0061b387d6703c8e51d4550886afbb914d7c3904b8d0aae
+size 4487252
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_45.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_45.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..aadd634b16c1c7a3314581d8fb462e0acb8aabd4
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_45.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:c8ac0df66b43077c51dcf8d4c58578a8d3f0413ad7861d33c678271f4c451af1
+size 4575189
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_46.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_46.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..95c75b55d842da06cc5b5fb15b150a30ee54907f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_46.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:c1c594133b2cdc1b0657469e1318fdd1692ffbf79be62735e41b538fc009f278
+size 4354713
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_47.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_47.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f659ab8099fccaf4358b86578e78306c92c385c1
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_47.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:dd58935302ea885995dcb8e4f81aea2cb642736fd9f7878c2b4b1bce4551d0b2
+size 4357119
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_48.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_48.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fca9bb748a81b1a4aabf3a03f5e68414a364a567
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_48.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:c13a432b97ba01a35b0388864c55883ff20d2d68cfd7c11375d22febd075c868
+size 4514088
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_49.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_49.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..453e59d87a5c66ef0ce45e5a78d4fea4f1d22399
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_49.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:d6fd57c2bc955cbd11334b05432f4d0117dfe1eb76b8c3f50473b85650d6526f
+size 4333123
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_50.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_50.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..af051a38e4f8bcedb83f7210d7f5793117e7ba50
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_contact_page_50.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:31fde9351f345df2edecf8efe78973a20adcd41d40046acb6414b3b267d6709a
+size 4520465
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_manifest.csv b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_manifest.csv
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..81344d3ff2b7515cac9aea50757d5c0d0f447e8a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/candidate_manifest.csv
@@ -0,0 +1,501 @@
+candidate_index,score,phrase_type,phrase_score,object_count,top_frame_mass,fine_w3_mass,w3_w7_mass,fine_w3_top_frac,w3_w7_top_frac,w3_w7_area25,heat_left_right_shift,step,group,sample_idx,question_id,question,target_answer,source_pred,rerun_pred,prompt,record_path,record_line,video_path,frame_label,panel_path,original_path,fine_map_path,window3_path,window7_path,fine_gt_window3_path,window3_gt_window7_path
+1,0.25660151,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.03806210,0.00452235,0.02235983,0.84451163,0.59357148,0.06835938,0.00022084,0000008,group_14,0,q2,Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4454,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22137_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/001_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+2,0.21546464,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.03235127,0.00384943,0.01900123,0.84369689,0.59333599,0.06835938,0.00022122,0000008,group_14,0,q5,Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1520,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22137_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/002_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q5__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q5__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q5__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q5__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q5__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q5__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+3,0.18837250,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.02850407,0.00339631,0.01673851,0.84356743,0.59388065,0.06835938,0.00023109,0000008,group_14,0,q3,Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4453,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22137_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/003_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+4,0.17145493,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.03052658,0.00359309,0.01795566,0.81670296,0.46895015,0.12500000,0.00002196,0000008,group_14,2,q5,Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1522,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22139_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/004_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+5,0.16124067,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.80800000,6,0.04278927,0.00510247,0.02512453,0.69435817,0.45125362,0.10742188,0.00218040,0000123,group_11,1,q3,Is the woman performing a side bend with her right arm extended upward and her left hand on her hip?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot in a surreal style, this slow, orbiting medium shot smoothly orbits a woman going about her morning activities in a lush garden at dawn. She has long, dark brown hair, loosely tied in a high ponytail, with a few stray strands gently framing her face. Her eyes are gently closed, her expression serene and focused. She wears a fitted, long-sleeved heather-gray yoga top, the soft, breathable fabric subtly textured, paired with high-waisted, dark teal leggings. Her body gracefully stands in side bend; her right arm extends deliberately and fluidly upward and over her head, elongating her torso, while her left hand rests lightly on her hip. The entire pose maintains a steady, controlled grace. The camera's slow, circular path reveals the immersive environment: she stands barefoot on a manicured lawn, still damp with morning dew. The garden is filled with vibrant green ferns and blooming rose bushes with soft, pink and white petals. The first rays of warm, golden sunlight penetrate the light morning mist between the leaves of the tall, mature trees in the background, backlighting her body and capturing millions of tiny, shimmering dewdrops on the grass and leaves, creating a shimmering bokeh effect. The interplay of warm, low-angle light and cool, soft shadows creates a serene scene of profound calm and focus, and the camera movement enhances the contemplative and visually rich atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,734,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000123/group_11/index_7140_seed_22006_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/005_0000123_group_11_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+6,0.15460785,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.02799617,0.00331878,0.01645160,0.75871730,0.50808913,0.08593750,0.00179368,0000037,group_5,2,q2,Is the woman wearing a faded gray oversized T-shirt and dark blue leggings with dark brown hair in a messy ponytail?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,775,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4758_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/006_0000037_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q2__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q2__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q2__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q2__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q2__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q2__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+7,0.15326418,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.02765679,0.00328196,0.01624989,0.74574763,0.51233077,0.08300781,0.00160187,0000037,group_5,2,q1,"Is the scene a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2715,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4758_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/007_0000037_group_5_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q1__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q1__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q1__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q1__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q1__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q1__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+8,0.13220090,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.02449517,0.00292785,0.01437821,0.68325877,0.43509901,0.10937500,0.00170851,0000008,group_14,3,q5,Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1523,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22140_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/008_0000008_group_14_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+9,0.11827823,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.02202487,0.00263372,0.01292743,0.68078810,0.43414730,0.10839844,0.00169295,0000008,group_14,3,q3,Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4459,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22140_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/009_0000008_group_14_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+10,0.11625941,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.62000000,5,0.04358351,0.00516897,0.02560969,0.82351065,0.49150082,0.11523438,0.00004002,0000077,group_1,2,q4,Is the man's right hand gripping a silver EQ knob between his thumb and index finger to adjust it?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, medium-close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a man immersed in musical composition. He has short, dark brown hair and wears a pair of professional black headphones. He rhythmically and immersively nods his head up and down to the rhythmic music, his eyes slightly closed, his expression intensely focused. He is in a dimly lit recording studio, facing a complex professional mixing console, its surface densely packed with faders and illuminated buttons. His right hand's fingers move delicately and precisely across the control panel, carefully gripping a silver EQ knob between his thumb and index finger, steadily and deliberately adjusting it to find the perfect tonal balance. The only light comes from the multicolored LEDs flashing on the mixing console and the screens of the various devices in the background. These dynamic dots of light cast shifting shadows on his face, emphasizing his simple black T-shirt and his focused profile. The whole picture is based on deep dark tones, dotted with blue, red and green light emitted by the equipment, creating an intimate, passionate and creative atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3691,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000077/group_1/index_3928_seed_17716_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/010_0000077_group_1_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+11,0.10415226,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.01929973,0.00228797,0.01134117,0.78446335,0.45404050,0.12500000,0.00038591,0000008,group_14,2,q3,Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4457,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22139_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/011_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+12,0.09768299,left-right-pair+beside-next-to,7.38000000,8,0.02290211,0.00280475,0.01339824,0.75150150,0.52378982,0.08984375,0.00202870,0000062,group_15,0,q4,Is a transparent observation window visible at the base of a tower showing white plant roots in nutrient solution?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"An immersive first-person camera advances at a slow and steady pace through a narrow corridor formed by towering hydroponic towers constructed of white composite materials. The scene is bathed in a soft, Vermeer-esque sidelight, pouring down from high on the left, illuminating each broad, fresh green leaf with an almost translucent quality. The delicate veins and shimmering water droplets on the leaves are clearly visible, imbuing them with vibrant life. This light also casts long, soft shadows on the right-hand tower wall and the ground. My gaze slowly descends, finally focusing on the base of one of the towers, where a transparent observation window reveals a tangled network of white plant roots immersed in nutrient solution. Right next to the root system, a small, floating holographic screen emitting soft blue light is flashing a real-time updated stream of life data - a heartbeat-like waveform and constantly changing numbers. My eyes are carefully and attentively inspecting it. The whole picture combines the precision of future technology with the tranquil aesthetics of classical painting, creating an atmosphere of focus, tranquility and hope.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,865,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000062/group_15/index_6641_seed_21716_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/012_0000062_group_15_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000062_group_15_sample_0_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000062_group_15_sample_0_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000062_group_15_sample_0_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000062_group_15_sample_0_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000062_group_15_sample_0_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000062_group_15_sample_0_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+13,0.09030291,left-right-pair+between-flanked,5.70400000,3,0.02558783,0.00303210,0.01503716,0.76497692,0.55479950,0.06347656,0.00099385,0000127,group_14,2,q2,"Is one creature a translucent, bell-shaped gelatinous form with black eyes radiating soft azure light?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In Hayao Miyazaki's captivating, hand-drawn Ghibli style, a static, intimate close-up captures a pair of slender, young hands cupped together in a tranquil underwater realm, meticulously detailed. Steadily and deliberately, these hands guide two shy, bioluminescent sea creatures toward each other. One creature nestles in the palm of the left hand, radiating a soft, ethereal azure glow. Its gelatinous body is shaped like a small, translucent bell, with inquisitive black eyes. The other, guided by the gentle fingers of the right hand, radiates a warm golden light. Its form is a slightly intricate, star-shaped droplet that trembles timidly at approach. As the two creatures cautiously approach, their respective radiance intensifies, casting a magical, pulsating glow that illuminates the subtle details of the characters' skin and the shimmering water particles between them. The immediate background is a lush underwater world with soft, painterly textures; out-of-focus, vibrant corals in soft shades of pink and deep purple sway gently, while the tentacles of a large, soft-edged sea anemone ripple in the subtle currents. The scene is primarily illuminated by a magical, blended blue and gold light emanating from the creatures, creating soft highlights and gentle shadows on the hands, enveloping the moment in an atmosphere of pure, quietly enchanting beauty and capturing a profound sense of wonder through the sheer tenderness of the movement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4641,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000127/group_14/index_9417_seed_17263_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/013_0000127_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000127_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000127_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000127_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000127_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000127_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000127_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+14,0.08995946,foreground-background+between-flanked,4.40800000,2,0.03385725,0.00401124,0.01989734,0.84401512,0.54405481,0.09863281,0.00283739,0000002,group_9,3,q4,Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"At dusk, a static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a lone figure on a Parisian basketball court, creating a scene of profound solitude and elegance. In the background, the iconic silhouette of the Eiffel Tower is clearly visible against the stunning sunset, its iron latticework appearing a stark black against the bright sky, tinged with hues of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft violet. In the foreground, the athlete, rendered almost in silhouette by the powerful backlight, maintains a low, focused stance in a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts. The figure deftly dribbles a classic orange basketball with fluid precision; the pebbled leather surface is barely discernible as it blurs, moving from a low, rhythmic thump on the worn asphalt court to a rapid cross between the legs. The warm, dramatic light of the setting sun casts long shadows and creates a bright rim light around the figure's body, highlighting their concentrated energy and the sweat on their brow. The atmosphere is one of quiet, solitary passion, blending the implicit rhythmic sound of the dribbling ball with the quiet grandeur of the city. As the last vibrant colors of sunset deepen into dusk, the entire scene slowly and steadily fades, light and image disappearing until only utter black remains.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4470,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_9/index_149_seed_23581_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/014_0000002_group_9_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+15,0.08861786,left-right-pair+between-flanked,5.70400000,3,0.02881445,0.00337249,0.01696131,0.80579436,0.45934772,0.12500000,0.00036272,0000002,group_5,3,q2,"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from an underwater eye-level, follows the fierce confrontation between two massive largemouth bass with a slow, steady pan. In the murky, yet sun-drenched, freshwater lake, shafts of light create a Tyndall effect in the deep green water, illuminating tiny suspended particles. The bass on the left, slightly larger, its olive-green scales gleaming metallically in the light. Its gill covers open wide in fury, revealing vibrant red gill filaments. It lunges forward with explosive force, its massive mouth stretched to its limit. Its opponent on the right, no less, slaps the current with its powerful tail fin, stirring up a small cloud of bottom mud and sand. It nimbly twists its body in the water to meet the impact sideways. The moment the two fish collide, the image is filled with a sense of power, with visible ripples in the water and a few silver scales falling and scattering in the chaos. Their movements are not chaotic, but full of primitive and strategic aggressiveness. Every collision and bite stirs up the swaying aquatic plants around them, creating a tense, fierce and primitive competitive atmosphere full of vitality.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1751,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_5/index_267_seed_25098_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/015_0000002_group_5_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+16,0.08833655,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.03823636,0.00459262,0.02242916,0.73349625,0.50927854,0.09570312,0.00086120,0000067,group_15,2,q3,Is there a blue nylon travel bag with black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper visible on a bed with white sheets?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a medium, slightly upward angle, the camera pans steadily to the right, closely following the subject's movements. In the frame, a man in his thirties, with short, dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard, leans slightly forward, his expression focused and serious. He wears a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt, the sleeves casually pushed up to his elbows, revealing his muscular forearms. He is in a softly lit bedroom, with the corner of a bed covered in white sheets visible in the background. Steadily and deliberately, the man extends his right arm toward a blue nylon travel bag on the bed. The bag features black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper, half-unzipped. As the camera follows, the thick wad of banknotes clutched in his left hand becomes visible. He then carefully places the wad of bills into the bag's open mouth, his fingers delicately moving as he pushes the money deeper into the bag. The natural morning light filtering in from a side window casts soft shadows on his arm and the surface of the travel bag, highlighting the texture of the nylon and the thickness of the banknotes. The dominant color scheme of the entire scene is the vibrant blue of the travel bag, the dark gray of the man's clothing, and the white of the bed sheet, creating an atmosphere of focus, intimacy, and a touch of tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1043,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_15/index_3450_seed_7520_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/016_0000067_group_15_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+17,0.08773675,left-right-pair,4.44000000,6,0.03220607,0.00380997,0.01893074,0.78383636,0.54258746,0.07519531,0.00067800,0000030,group_9,0,q3,"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"An eye-level, static medium shot frames a young man with unkempt brown hair, dressed in a casual gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants, as he cleans a modern living room. Soft daylight streams in from an unseen window, casting gentle reflections on the polished hardwood floor. He initially holds a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand, moving it at a steady pace. His focused work is abruptly interrupted when he clumsily kicks the trailing black power cord with his left foot, tangling it. With a frustrated sigh, he deftly shifts the vacuum cleaner to his right hand, bending steadily at the waist and carefully picking up the loosened cord with his left hand before standing straight. To continue his work, he briefly presses his right foot on the base of the vacuum cleaner to stabilize it, then pushes it forward and resumes cleaning. Then, his attention shifts; he glances to his left, his face partially illuminated by the flickering, colorful glow of a television, playing a vibrant cartoon. As his eyes remain glued to the screen, his hands continue to vacuum back and forth, now more automatically and with less precision, perfectly capturing a moment of distracted, everyday family life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2905,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000030/group_9/index_2120_seed_2724_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/017_0000030_group_9_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+18,0.08389551,left-right-pair+foreground-background+beside-next-to,8.84400000,4,0.01673941,0.00199030,0.00983274,0.81889296,0.52134687,0.10156250,0.00000742,0000039,group_9,0,q3,"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3795,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8142_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/018_0000039_group_9_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+19,0.08302146,left-right-pair,4.44000000,6,0.02753720,0.00332239,0.01614321,0.90716064,0.67634636,0.06835938,0.00032461,0000087,group_9,3,q4,Is a woman with blonde hair in a ponytail wearing a soft pink shirt lifting a clear glass bottle of golden liquid and twisting a silver cap?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion doll begins in a bright, modern kitchen studio, capturing three dynamic shots at eye level. In the center, a man with neatly cropped brown hair and a friendly, engaging expression is speaking actively, emphasizing his words with expressive gestures. He wears a crisp navy blue button-down shirt. To his right, a woman with blonde hair tied in a sleek ponytail and a professional-looking soft pink shirt steadily lifts a clear glass bottle filled with golden liquid from a pristine white marble countertop. Her other hand precisely grasps the metallic silver cap and deftly twists it open. To the man's left, another woman in a crisp white chef's coat is absorbed in her work, her hands moving expertly as she carefully handles fresh ingredients, perhaps arranging vibrant green herbs on a dark wooden cutting board. The entire scene is bathed in bright, diffused studio light, eliminating harsh shadows and highlighting the clean lines of the stainless steel appliances blurred in the background, creating an atmosphere of warmth, collaboration, and high professionalism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,60,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000087/group_9/index_5711_seed_24666_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/019_0000087_group_9_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q4__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q4__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q4__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q4__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q4__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q4__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+20,0.08213755,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.03516515,0.00422527,0.02062659,0.71677524,0.50397348,0.08007812,0.00085381,0000053,group_6,2,q4,"Do the birds jerk their heads back and forth erratically in a staccato rhythm, ejecting a cloud of shimmering droplets?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level close-up captures two rock pigeons standing side by side at the edge of a shallow, clear puddle on a damp, gray cobblestone street. The bird on the left, with its classic blue-gray plumage and iridescent green and purple shimmering across its neck, captures the soft, diffuse light of an overcast sky. The bird on the right is slightly darker, with more pronounced black markings on its wings. In a swift, almost mechanical, and perfectly synchronized motion, both birds simultaneously dip their dark gray beaks into the water. Then, swiftly raising their heads, they jerk back and forth erratically in a staccato rhythm. This sharp, spastic movement ejects a cloud of shimmering droplets into the air, which, like scattered diamonds, hover against a silent background for a microsecond. The repetition of the action creates a vibrant and slightly comical spectacle of nature, the splashing water disturbing the puddle's glassy surface and creating concentric ripples that radiate outward, all contributing to the tranquil yet lively atmosphere of a quiet urban moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1874,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000053/group_6/index_4856_seed_15265_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/020_0000053_group_6_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000053_group_6_sample_2_q4__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000053_group_6_sample_2_q4__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000053_group_6_sample_2_q4__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000053_group_6_sample_2_q4__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000053_group_6_sample_2_q4__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000053_group_6_sample_2_q4__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+21,0.08119885,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.01544928,0.00185771,0.00906105,0.74497610,0.43982616,0.12500000,0.00016427,0000008,group_14,2,q2,Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4458,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22139_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/021_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_2_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+22,0.07875802,left-right-pair+foreground-background,6.44800000,3,0.02335655,0.00274074,0.01374387,0.77228510,0.44143504,0.12500000,0.00009263,0000118,group_2,0,q4,Is a fallen man's hand visible twitching on the stained concrete in the lower foreground?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shaky, eye-level handheld shot shakes violently, struggling to depict the chaotic aftermath of a clash on a gritty city sidewalk. The camera first captures a man, dressed head-to-toe in a black zip-up hoodie and dark jeans, looking around, eyes wide and terrified. As he staggers backward, his arms swing in a wide, uncontrolled arc for balance, his body blurring as he awkwardly exits the left side of the frame. The camera then pans erratically to the right, resting on his opponent, who stands uncomfortably in a clean white crew-neck T-shirt and a dark baseball cap. He speaks calmly, his expression unreadable, and deliberately raises his right hand. With two fingers gripping it precisely, he tilts the brim upward, briefly and methodically wiping his forehead with the back of his palm, then replaces it. His hand then drops, disappearing casually into his trouser pocket. In the lower foreground, lying on the stained concrete, the hand of a fallen man twitches, a faint, seemingly final movement. The background is a series of moving, blurred bystanders scattering in panic, their blurred forms evacuating the scene. The entire event is illuminated by the harsh, flat light of an overcast sky, creating a stark, documentary-like feel and a palpable, thick atmosphere of post-violence tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4080,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000118/group_2/index_4089_seed_20982_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/022_0000118_group_2_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000118_group_2_sample_0_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000118_group_2_sample_0_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000118_group_2_sample_0_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000118_group_2_sample_0_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000118_group_2_sample_0_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000118_group_2_sample_0_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+23,0.07575088,left-right-pair,4.44000000,6,0.02811701,0.00334707,0.01651329,0.78904438,0.55534595,0.08203125,0.00017172,0000087,group_9,2,q4,Is a woman with blonde hair in a ponytail wearing a soft pink shirt lifting a clear glass bottle of golden liquid and twisting a silver cap?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion doll begins in a bright, modern kitchen studio, capturing three dynamic shots at eye level. In the center, a man with neatly cropped brown hair and a friendly, engaging expression is speaking actively, emphasizing his words with expressive gestures. He wears a crisp navy blue button-down shirt. To his right, a woman with blonde hair tied in a sleek ponytail and a professional-looking soft pink shirt steadily lifts a clear glass bottle filled with golden liquid from a pristine white marble countertop. Her other hand precisely grasps the metallic silver cap and deftly twists it open. To the man's left, another woman in a crisp white chef's coat is absorbed in her work, her hands moving expertly as she carefully handles fresh ingredients, perhaps arranging vibrant green herbs on a dark wooden cutting board. The entire scene is bathed in bright, diffused studio light, eliminating harsh shadows and highlighting the clean lines of the stainless steel appliances blurred in the background, creating an atmosphere of warmth, collaboration, and high professionalism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,59,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000087/group_9/index_5711_seed_24665_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/023_0000087_group_9_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q4__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q4__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q4__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q4__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q4__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q4__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+24,0.07567346,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.62000000,5,0.02928526,0.00347821,0.01720470,0.82435477,0.49243090,0.11718750,0.00001928,0000077,group_1,2,q3,Is the man rhythmically nodding his head with his eyes slightly closed and expression focused?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, medium-close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a man immersed in musical composition. He has short, dark brown hair and wears a pair of professional black headphones. He rhythmically and immersively nods his head up and down to the rhythmic music, his eyes slightly closed, his expression intensely focused. He is in a dimly lit recording studio, facing a complex professional mixing console, its surface densely packed with faders and illuminated buttons. His right hand's fingers move delicately and precisely across the control panel, carefully gripping a silver EQ knob between his thumb and index finger, steadily and deliberately adjusting it to find the perfect tonal balance. The only light comes from the multicolored LEDs flashing on the mixing console and the screens of the various devices in the background. These dynamic dots of light cast shifting shadows on his face, emphasizing his simple black T-shirt and his focused profile. The whole picture is based on deep dark tones, dotted with blue, red and green light emitted by the equipment, creating an intimate, passionate and creative atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,322,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000077/group_1/index_3928_seed_17716_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/024_0000077_group_1_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+25,0.07480908,left-right-pair,3.72000000,3,0.03497875,0.00418916,0.02052639,0.72381747,0.48197201,0.08886719,0.00161439,0000068,group_1,1,q1,Is the main subject a man in his 30s with neatly cropped brown hair wearing a navy short-sleeved polo shirt and khaki pants?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level, medium-sized shot captures a man in his 30s with neatly cropped brown hair standing in a well-lit, organized workshop. Dressed in a navy short-sleeved polo shirt and khaki pants, he exudes a professional demeanor. The background consists of a clean concrete floor and a slightly out-of-focus workbench with neatly arranged tools. The man tightly grasps a vibrant red cylindrical fire extinguisher with both hands, its black nozzle and pressure gauge clearly visible. As he speaks directly to the camera with a serious and clear expression, he begins to vigorously shake the extinguisher up and down, a movement that conveys a sense of urgent preparedness. He then pauses, holding the extinguisher steady with his right hand and gesturing vigorously with his left hand, pointing his index finger at the nozzle to emphasize a key point in his explanation. Finally, he nods, gently and steadily bending his knees, and deliberately placing the extinguisher upright on the floor, his movements precise and measured. The entire scene is bathed in bright, cool fluorescent light from an overhead light source, creating clear reflections on the extinguisher's smooth surface and establishing an atmosphere of focused instruction.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1841,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000068/group_1/index_4541_seed_13921_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/025_0000068_group_1_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000068_group_1_sample_1_q1__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000068_group_1_sample_1_q1__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000068_group_1_sample_1_q1__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000068_group_1_sample_1_q1__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000068_group_1_sample_1_q1__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000068_group_1_sample_1_q1__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+26,0.07407189,left-right-pair+beside-next-to,6.66000000,6,0.02108727,0.00252279,0.01237633,0.70453137,0.45693481,0.11328125,0.00205159,0000070,group_12,3,q3,"Is the male competitor on the right wearing a suit, has short black hair, and is interacting with a translucent holographic data screen?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slowly rotating, orbiting medium shot brings us into the core control area of a futuristic drone racing arena. Clad in explosive competitive cinematography, it focuses on two competitors battling side by side. The female competitor on the left, sporting a sleek, dark purple ponytail, wears immersive FPV (first-person view) goggles that half-cover her face, their lenses reflecting a dazzling stream of data. She wears a tight, black, high-tech racing suit with a neon blue circuit pattern. She leans forward slightly, her hands steady and decisive as she grips a complex multi-stick drone controller, her thumbs fine-tuning the joysticks with a speed barely tangible to the naked eye. Beside her, her male teammate, with slightly damp short black hair and a furrowed brow, is absorbed in analyzing a translucent holographic data screen floating before them. His fingers swiftly and deftly swipe and tap across the illuminated interface, adjusting performance parameters and flight path diagrams in real time. Behind them, on the huge circular track structure, other drones turned into blurred colorful light bands and flew by at high speed. The whole scene was illuminated by the cool light emitted by their equipment and the neon lights of the track, casting dynamic light and shadow on their focused faces, creating a tacit cooperation and highly tense competitive atmosphere in the high-speed confrontation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1264,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000070/group_12/index_642_seed_16436_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/026_0000070_group_12_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+27,0.07314764,left-right-pair,4.44000000,6,0.02664747,0.00317455,0.01564861,0.78472453,0.55700272,0.06835938,0.00025141,0000087,group_9,2,q3,Is a man with neatly cropped brown hair wearing a navy blue button-down shirt visible in the center?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion doll begins in a bright, modern kitchen studio, capturing three dynamic shots at eye level. In the center, a man with neatly cropped brown hair and a friendly, engaging expression is speaking actively, emphasizing his words with expressive gestures. He wears a crisp navy blue button-down shirt. To his right, a woman with blonde hair tied in a sleek ponytail and a professional-looking soft pink shirt steadily lifts a clear glass bottle filled with golden liquid from a pristine white marble countertop. Her other hand precisely grasps the metallic silver cap and deftly twists it open. To the man's left, another woman in a crisp white chef's coat is absorbed in her work, her hands moving expertly as she carefully handles fresh ingredients, perhaps arranging vibrant green herbs on a dark wooden cutting board. The entire scene is bathed in bright, diffused studio light, eliminating harsh shadows and highlighting the clean lines of the stainless steel appliances blurred in the background, creating an atmosphere of warmth, collaboration, and high professionalism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,851,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000087/group_9/index_5711_seed_24665_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/027_0000087_group_9_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000087_group_9_sample_2_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+28,0.06993990,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.01109433,0.00132116,0.00651544,0.81435281,0.58567107,0.06835938,0.00111505,0000008,group_14,1,q2,Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4456,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22138_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/028_0000008_group_14_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q2__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q2__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q2__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q2__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q2__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q2__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+29,0.06963519,opposite-across,2.51600000,6,0.04921333,0.00586710,0.02889749,0.71193576,0.45216277,0.10839844,0.00181502,0000099,group_15,1,q3,Do two much taller teenage boys walk through the circle and pose against a weathered brick wall?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a vivid scene on a sun-drenched schoolyard. Four young boys, about eight to ten years old, huddled on cracked concrete, huddled joyfully in a tight, happy circle, engrossed in a game. A boy with messy blond hair and a bright red hoodie was laughing, his hands clenched into tight, rock-like fists. Across from him, a boy in a blue striped T-shirt countered with an open, paper-like hand. They were chattering when their playful bubble suddenly burst. Two much taller teenage boys walked directly through their circle, forcing the younger boys to spread out slightly. The first intruder, wearing an oversized black hoodie with the hood pulled down and baggy jeans, didn't break stride. His companion, with short hair, followed closely behind. They paused a few feet away from the group and, with practiced indifference, posed against a weathered brick wall in the background. The first man leaned back, shoving his thumbs in his pockets, while the second stood with his arms crossed, a stony expression on his face. They immediately launched into their own lively conversation, speaking and gesturing only to each other, their body language creating a clear boundary. The four young boys, forgetting their game, now sat down to watch the duo, their expressions a mix of silent annoyance and curiosity. The warm golden light of the late afternoon cast long shadows, creating an atmosphere of palpable social dynamics.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,590,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000099/group_15/index_3145_seed_27105_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/029_0000099_group_15_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000099_group_15_sample_1_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000099_group_15_sample_1_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000099_group_15_sample_1_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000099_group_15_sample_1_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000099_group_15_sample_1_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000099_group_15_sample_1_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+30,0.06897392,left-right-pair,4.20000000,5,0.03093694,0.00369303,0.01816261,0.71103650,0.44771606,0.12011719,0.00234103,0000009,group_15,0,q5,"Is the background visible as a blurred restaurant facade with large windows and a dark green awning, illuminated by warm midday sun filtering through a parasol?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"This static, eye-level medium shot captures a woman with a chic, short, slightly tousled bob, sitting at an outdoor cafe. She wears a short-sleeved shirt made of lightweight fabric with a delicate, pastel floral pattern against a cream background. She sits comfortably at a small, round cast-iron table on the sunny restaurant terrace, leaning slightly forward and holding a modern smartphone to her right ear. Amidst a lively conversation, a warm, relaxed smile graces her lips, her eyes crinkling slightly as she speaks, her head tilted with interest. Her left hand rests on the tabletop, her fingers leisurely stroking the rim of a glass of espresso iced tea. In the background, the restaurant's blurred facade, with its large windows and dark green awning, is visible, while the soft, out-of-focus shapes of other patrons create a gentle sense of ambient activity. The entire scene is illuminated by the warm midday sun, which filters through a large parasol, casting a soft, diffuse glow that eliminates harsh shadows and creates an overall relaxed, down-to-earth, and joyful atmosphere of a pleasant afternoon.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2968,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_15/index_4081_seed_18320_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/030_0000009_group_15_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+31,0.06850920,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.06079882,0.00726405,0.03568985,0.71085370,0.45059913,0.11718750,0.00312325,0000024,group_1,2,q3,"Does the man raise his right arm to shield his mouth and nose, leaving a narrow gap between his fingers?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady medium close-up places the viewer at the center of a fierce sandstorm, focusing on a weathered man. He defiantly leans sideways against the gusting wind, leaning slightly forward for balance. He wears a faded, yet still a deep, cyan-colored, coarse robe, its rough fabric caked with fine grains of sand. Every wrinkle on his face, carved by the scorching sun and wind, seems to tell a long story. His dark, cracked skin contrasts sharply with his gray, dust-stained beard. Quickly and instinctively, he raises his right arm, tightly shielding his mouth and nose with his muscular forearm to shield himself from the overwhelming, almost suffocating dust. However, his hand does not clench completely; instead, he carefully opens his fingers, creating a narrow gap. Through this gap, his deep eyes gaze with an unwavering, resolute gaze at the unknown world ahead, obscured by the wind and sand. There is no fear in his eyes, only focus and determination. The entire picture is completely immersed in Steve McCurry's iconic photography style: the air is filled with rich and saturated ochre and orange tones, forming a strong and harmonious color contrast with the blue of the man's robe; although the light is diffused by the sand and dust and is extremely soft, it depicts every texture and attached sand on his face with extremely high clarity, creating an epic atmosphere full of struggle and extremely human dignity and tenacious strength.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1319,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000024/group_1/index_7804_seed_9786_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/031_0000024_group_1_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000024_group_1_sample_2_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000024_group_1_sample_2_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000024_group_1_sample_2_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000024_group_1_sample_2_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000024_group_1_sample_2_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000024_group_1_sample_2_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+32,0.06539544,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.02393670,0.00296466,0.01398136,0.72582120,0.52264404,0.08007812,0.00063884,0000056,group_3,2,q1,Is the subject Sun Wukong (the Monkey King) depicted in a steady horse stance with legs slightly bent?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,115,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26611_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/032_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q1__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q1__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q1__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q1__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q1__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q1__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+33,0.06497330,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.02403712,0.00286756,0.01411304,0.76890051,0.50154287,0.08496094,0.00083059,0000056,group_3,1,q2,Is Sun Wukong wearing intricately carved golden chainmail armor with cloud patterns and a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown with two long pheasant feathers?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,517,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26610_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/033_0000056_group_3_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+34,0.06437830,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.02358774,0.00292252,0.01377681,0.72544318,0.52235281,0.08007812,0.00065082,0000056,group_3,2,q4,"Does Sun Wukong thrust a golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front, causing the waterfall to distort?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2393,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26611_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/034_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+35,0.06334485,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.04696701,0.00557656,0.02759363,0.83341122,0.55429846,0.08007812,0.00060353,0000015,group_15,1,q2,"Is the first man shown with sweat-drenched black hair, a trickle of blood from his mouth, and wearing a dark gray T-shirt?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Frantic handheld shot thrusts the viewer directly into the heart of a frenzied hand-to-hand fight, moving erratically and rapidly between the two men, capturing every tense moment at close range. The scene rapidly switches between tense expressions and swift movements, beginning with an extreme close-up of a young man's face. His sweat-drenched black hair clings to his forehead, a trickle of blood oozing from the corner of his clenched mouth. His expression is steely and pained, and the muscles in his neck bulge like ropes from the strain. He wears a sweat-soaked dark gray T-shirt, tightly hugging his muscular build. The camera jerks to reveal the face of his opponent, a more muscular man with a shaved head, contorted in anger. His eyes burn with a cold rage. Then, the camera quickly pulls back, revealing a slightly wider angle of their entangled bodies—the young man's forearm blocks a powerful swinging punch with a dull thud, his body rapidly sinking to try to knock him off balance. The entire fight takes place in a dimly lit abandoned warehouse, the sole source of light coming from a single, precariously lit fluorescent light hanging from the ceiling. Its harsh, cold light creates sharp highlights on their sweat-stained skin and casts long, swaying shadows behind them. The air is thick with dust, clearly visible in the beams of light. The primary colors of the scene are icy grays and deep blacks, the only bright spot being a glaring, blood-red hue. The overall atmosphere is filled with a suffocating sense of tension, a violent aesthetic, and a primal instinct for survival.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,345,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000015/group_15/index_9178_seed_3520_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/035_0000015_group_15_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q2__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q2__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q2__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q2__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q2__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q2__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+36,0.06084467,beside-next-to,2.46000000,9,0.04311502,0.00511785,0.02533144,0.81205809,0.48646465,0.11523438,0.00013402,0000092,group_10,3,q2,Is a man in his 30s with shaggy brown hair and a gray T-shirt leaning forward on a plush beige sofa?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld, shaky, medium close-up captures a candid, lived-in moment in a comfortably lit living room. The camera first focuses on a man in his 30s with shaggy brown hair and a friendly, wrinkled face, dressed in a simple gray T-shirt. He leans forward on a plush beige sofa and playfully teases a giggling little boy with short blond hair sitting next to him. After a moment of gentle tickling, the man leans back against the sofa cushions, a cute, tired smile on his face, his left hand raised as he looks at the children, his posture relaxing. The camera then gently pans back and refocuses on a young girl, about ten years old, with long brown hair tied in a ponytail, sitting on the carpeted floor. She's wearing a blue hoodie and shaking her head slightly in annoyance, her brow furrowed as she stares at an open textbook on the low wooden coffee table in front of her. She impatiently flips through a few pages with her right hand, the papers clicking softly. Then, with a sudden, sharp movement, she decisively slammed the book shut, a dull thud in the quiet room. Without pausing, she reached for a purple school backpack lying on the floor nearby, grasping its strap and pulling it toward her, her movement conveying a palpable sense of frustration and determination. The entire scene was bathed in the warm, soft glow of a nearby floor lamp, casting long shadows and creating an intimate, domestic atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,648,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000092/group_10/index_5785_seed_14634_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/036_0000092_group_10_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+37,0.06075629,foreground-background+between-flanked,5.32000000,5,0.01900532,0.00231215,0.01112878,0.76912731,0.55794591,0.07421875,0.00013995,0000002,group_3,2,q5,Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion, low-angle shot zooms in on a city basketball court surrounded by a high, rusty barbed wire fence. In the center of the frame, two sweat-drenched teenagers engage in a fierce standoff. The boy in the foreground, with tanned skin and short, close-cropped black hair, wears a sweat-soaked, dark blue sleeveless basketball vest that clings to his heaving chest and muscular build. His jaw set, his eyes piercing like a hawk, he stands with his hands on his hips, leaning slightly forward in an aggressive stance. The other boy confronting him wears an equally drenched white vest, his bangs clinging to his forehead with sweat. His arms are crossed over his chest, his posture erect, his gaze firm and unyielding. The golden afterglow of the setting sun streams in at a sharp angle, filtering through the bars of the barbed wire fence and casting long, interlaced shadows on the cracked asphalt. The light outlines their youthful, powerful figures and illuminates every bead of sweat on their skin. The air seemed to freeze, the dilapidated red brick apartment building in the background became blurred, and all the focus was on the invisible space between the two teenagers, which was full of charge. Every breath in their chests and every silent exchange of eyes filled the whole scene with primitive competitive tension and a dramatic atmosphere that was about to break out.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,139,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_6174_seed_3012_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/037_0000002_group_3_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q5__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q5__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q5__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q5__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q5__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q5__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+38,0.06072230,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.04518598,0.00536773,0.02654550,0.83335555,0.55432397,0.08007812,0.00060508,0000015,group_15,1,q3,Is the second man depicted as more muscular with a shaved head and an angry expression?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Frantic handheld shot thrusts the viewer directly into the heart of a frenzied hand-to-hand fight, moving erratically and rapidly between the two men, capturing every tense moment at close range. The scene rapidly switches between tense expressions and swift movements, beginning with an extreme close-up of a young man's face. His sweat-drenched black hair clings to his forehead, a trickle of blood oozing from the corner of his clenched mouth. His expression is steely and pained, and the muscles in his neck bulge like ropes from the strain. He wears a sweat-soaked dark gray T-shirt, tightly hugging his muscular build. The camera jerks to reveal the face of his opponent, a more muscular man with a shaved head, contorted in anger. His eyes burn with a cold rage. Then, the camera quickly pulls back, revealing a slightly wider angle of their entangled bodies—the young man's forearm blocks a powerful swinging punch with a dull thud, his body rapidly sinking to try to knock him off balance. The entire fight takes place in a dimly lit abandoned warehouse, the sole source of light coming from a single, precariously lit fluorescent light hanging from the ceiling. Its harsh, cold light creates sharp highlights on their sweat-stained skin and casts long, swaying shadows behind them. The air is thick with dust, clearly visible in the beams of light. The primary colors of the scene are icy grays and deep blacks, the only bright spot being a glaring, blood-red hue. The overall atmosphere is filled with a suffocating sense of tension, a violent aesthetic, and a primal instinct for survival.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3856,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000015/group_15/index_9178_seed_3520_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/038_0000015_group_15_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000015_group_15_sample_1_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+39,0.06050332,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+between-flanked,8.54000000,5,0.01308585,0.00155618,0.00768645,0.76453876,0.47841418,0.10253906,0.00216460,0000162,group_1,2,q5,Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2598,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18206_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/039_0000162_group_1_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q5__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q5__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q5__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q5__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q5__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q5__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+40,0.05951394,left-right-pair,4.20000000,5,0.02530945,0.00303816,0.01484753,0.80927867,0.49331185,0.10937500,0.00060797,0000170,group_0,3,q3,Is a weary woman in faded blue canvas overalls with black hair in a loose ponytail visible exiting the bus?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from a slightly elevated angle, slowly pans to the right as a bus, its paint peeling and slightly worn, lurches to a halt on the curb. Finally, it stabilizes as the pneumatic doors hiss open. The first thing that comes into view is a hand gripping the door's metal armrest, polished to a shine by countless hands. Then, a weary woman in faded blue canvas overalls appears in the doorway. Her black hair is casually tied into a loose ponytail, a few strands clinging to her forehead with sweat. Her face is marked by a deep weariness, her eyelids heavy and her gaze dim. The dim light inside the bus highlights her slightly slumped shoulders, contrasting with the cool dusk outside. Carefully, she places one heavy, dusty work boot on the ground, then, with a heavy, almost dragging hand, descends the last step. The asphalt beneath her feet is damp from the recent rain, reflecting the scattered streetlights in the distance. As her weight completely left the bus, the bus body swayed slightly. The whole picture was filled with a quiet yet deep atmosphere of fatigue after get off work, with the interweaving of cold blue and warm yellow light and shadow.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4483,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000170/group_0/index_4261_seed_6138_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/040_0000170_group_0_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000170_group_0_sample_3_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000170_group_0_sample_3_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000170_group_0_sample_3_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000170_group_0_sample_3_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000170_group_0_sample_3_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000170_group_0_sample_3_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+41,0.05827328,left-right-pair+foreground-background,6.86400000,4,0.01486321,0.00175302,0.00874013,0.75445521,0.51473093,0.08300781,0.00146675,0000039,group_9,0,q2,"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3796,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8142_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/041_0000039_group_9_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q2__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q2__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q2__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q2__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q2__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_9_sample_0_q2__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+42,0.05792051,foreground-background+between-flanked,5.32000000,5,0.01964251,0.00234255,0.01153331,0.82473117,0.49625716,0.11132812,0.00030541,0000002,group_3,1,q4,Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion, low-angle shot zooms in on a city basketball court surrounded by a high, rusty barbed wire fence. In the center of the frame, two sweat-drenched teenagers engage in a fierce standoff. The boy in the foreground, with tanned skin and short, close-cropped black hair, wears a sweat-soaked, dark blue sleeveless basketball vest that clings to his heaving chest and muscular build. His jaw set, his eyes piercing like a hawk, he stands with his hands on his hips, leaning slightly forward in an aggressive stance. The other boy confronting him wears an equally drenched white vest, his bangs clinging to his forehead with sweat. His arms are crossed over his chest, his posture erect, his gaze firm and unyielding. The golden afterglow of the setting sun streams in at a sharp angle, filtering through the bars of the barbed wire fence and casting long, interlaced shadows on the cracked asphalt. The light outlines their youthful, powerful figures and illuminates every bead of sweat on their skin. The air seemed to freeze, the dilapidated red brick apartment building in the background became blurred, and all the focus was on the invisible space between the two teenagers, which was full of charge. Every breath in their chests and every silent exchange of eyes filled the whole scene with primitive competitive tension and a dramatic atmosphere that was about to break out.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,546,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_6174_seed_3011_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/042_0000002_group_3_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+43,0.05783309,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.02130522,0.00264001,0.01244348,0.72481263,0.52157724,0.08007812,0.00066352,0000056,group_3,2,q3,Is the scene set before the Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain with a vast waterfall cascading down a towering cliff?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26611_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/043_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q3__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q3__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q3__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q3__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q3__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q3__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+44,0.05618006,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.58800000,6,0.02514157,0.00304045,0.01473407,0.63951898,0.40040833,0.13769531,0.00193602,0000112,group_2,0,q3,Is the woman next to him wearing a white bomber jacket and has long bright pink hair in a high ponytail?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic, low-angle, tracking shot, close to the ground, follows two young men as they effortlessly glide across a futuristic city square at dusk on their electric unicycles. The young man on the left, with shaggy black hair and a tech-fabric black hoodie with reflective silver stripes on the sleeves, wears a broad smile. The young woman next to him, with her long, bright pink hair tied in a high ponytail, throws her head back in a sleek white bomber jacket and laughs heartily. The unicycles they ride are matte black, their futuristic LED strips emitting brilliant cyan and magenta light on either side, casting vibrant reflections on the polished dark stone floor, leaving long trails of light as the wheels spin at breakneck speed. The camera switches focus swiftly and precisely between close-ups of their vivid, joyful facial expressions and the wheels spinning so rapidly that they appear almost animate, against a backdrop of towering skyscrapers, their windows lit up, and flashing holographic billboards. The entire picture has a cold tone, mainly dark blue and black, but is illuminated by the neon lights of the unicycle and the warm lights in the distance, interspersed with slight, stylized digital screen flashes and lens flares that represent a sense of technology, creating a futuristic atmosphere that is free, cheerful and full of urban dynamism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4084,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000112/group_2/index_4817_seed_22843_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/044_0000112_group_2_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+45,0.05607572,left-right-pair,4.20000000,5,0.02556186,0.00305007,0.01500786,0.71037096,0.44491571,0.12207031,0.00228980,0000009,group_15,0,q4,Is the woman smiling with crinkled eyes and leaning forward while her left hand strokes the rim of a glass of iced tea?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"This static, eye-level medium shot captures a woman with a chic, short, slightly tousled bob, sitting at an outdoor cafe. She wears a short-sleeved shirt made of lightweight fabric with a delicate, pastel floral pattern against a cream background. She sits comfortably at a small, round cast-iron table on the sunny restaurant terrace, leaning slightly forward and holding a modern smartphone to her right ear. Amidst a lively conversation, a warm, relaxed smile graces her lips, her eyes crinkling slightly as she speaks, her head tilted with interest. Her left hand rests on the tabletop, her fingers leisurely stroking the rim of a glass of espresso iced tea. In the background, the restaurant's blurred facade, with its large windows and dark green awning, is visible, while the soft, out-of-focus shapes of other patrons create a gentle sense of ambient activity. The entire scene is illuminated by the warm midday sun, which filters through a large parasol, casting a soft, diffuse glow that eliminates harsh shadows and creates an overall relaxed, down-to-earth, and joyful atmosphere of a pleasant afternoon.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,65,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_15/index_4081_seed_18320_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/045_0000009_group_15_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+46,0.05553881,beside-next-to+between-flanked,5.08400000,8,0.02054451,0.00245381,0.01206047,0.71852440,0.46583560,0.11328125,0.00262493,0000088,group_6,0,q5,Is a large fluffy ball of yarn on a table beside the woman rolling extremely slowly?,Yes,No,No,"steady medium shot, captured from a slightly overhead, is rendered entirely in the style of a black-and-white pencil sketch. At the very center, a mother sits quietly in a dark wooden chair, her back to the camera. She wears a cozy home sweater, her hair loosely tied in a bun. An old-fashioned desk lamp provides the sole source of light, casting a warm, focused beam. This light, depicted in the sketch as a delicate field of white space and the lightest grays, precisely illuminates her focused back and the movements of her hands, while the rest of the room is shrouded in a deep, cross-hatched darkness. Her head is slightly lowered, her shoulders hunched forward, and her hands fly up and down with steady, deliberate movements. Two slender knitting needles intertwine between her deft fingers, a forming scarf dangling from them, its delicate texture sharply outlined in the light. As she gently tugged, the large, fluffy ball of yarn on the table beside her began to roll at an almost imperceptible pace, extremely slowly and irregularly. Each tiny twitch tugged at the lifeline connecting her hands. The entire scene, devoid of a single trace of superfluous color, consisted entirely of shifting lines and blocks of varying grayscale, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, warmth, and nostalgia.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1436,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000088/group_6/index_8179_seed_27126_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/046_0000088_group_6_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q5__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q5__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q5__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q5__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q5__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q5__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+47,0.05511977,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.80800000,6,0.01785294,0.00211119,0.01049450,0.62868065,0.37077183,0.16113281,0.00212902,0000123,group_11,1,q1,"Is the main subject a woman with long, dark brown hair tied in a high ponytail?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot in a surreal style, this slow, orbiting medium shot smoothly orbits a woman going about her morning activities in a lush garden at dawn. She has long, dark brown hair, loosely tied in a high ponytail, with a few stray strands gently framing her face. Her eyes are gently closed, her expression serene and focused. She wears a fitted, long-sleeved heather-gray yoga top, the soft, breathable fabric subtly textured, paired with high-waisted, dark teal leggings. Her body gracefully stands in side bend; her right arm extends deliberately and fluidly upward and over her head, elongating her torso, while her left hand rests lightly on her hip. The entire pose maintains a steady, controlled grace. The camera's slow, circular path reveals the immersive environment: she stands barefoot on a manicured lawn, still damp with morning dew. The garden is filled with vibrant green ferns and blooming rose bushes with soft, pink and white petals. The first rays of warm, golden sunlight penetrate the light morning mist between the leaves of the tall, mature trees in the background, backlighting her body and capturing millions of tiny, shimmering dewdrops on the grass and leaves, creating a shimmering bokeh effect. The interplay of warm, low-angle light and cool, soft shadows creates a serene scene of profound calm and focus, and the camera movement enhances the contemplative and visually rich atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2627,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000123/group_11/index_7140_seed_22006_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/047_0000123_group_11_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q1__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q1__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q1__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q1__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q1__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000123_group_11_sample_1_q1__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+48,0.05417905,left-right-pair+foreground-background+beside-next-to,8.84400000,4,0.01309992,0.00153820,0.00770782,0.63503987,0.38699076,0.14062500,0.00119060,0000039,group_9,1,q3,"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3797,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8143_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/048_0000039_group_9_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+49,0.05315820,foreground-background,2.72800000,3,0.03876416,0.00458063,0.02278902,0.70154655,0.40357655,0.14648438,0.00041041,0000091,group_9,0,q2,"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In the style of sports photography, a low-angle, static, full-body shot captures a lone female figure on a deserted, cracked asphalt village road as a sudden thunderstorm erupts with dramatic force. The camera's focus is sharply pulled to the immediate foreground, capturing heavy, crystal-like raindrops at hyperspeed as they explode onto the dark, damp ground. Each droplet forms a perfect, instantaneous crown-like splash, its surface reflecting the wounded, turbulent purple-gray storm clouds above. The runner's body is a tense sculpture of athletic power, her right leg extended forward, her calf muscles defined, her arms flexed in a powerful, driving motion. Her dark hair is plastered to her scalp and face by the floodwaters, and her simple, brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts, soaking wet, cling to her body. Her expression is one of fierce, unwavering determination, her gaze fixed forward, completely unfazed by the storm. The background shows the blurred outlines of simple village houses against an oppressively dark sky, while for a split second, off-camera lightning illuminates the scene, casting stark silver highlights on the runners’ skin and the millions of falling water droplets, creating a powerful, high-contrast atmosphere of raw energy and fierce human determination.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3236,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000091/group_9/index_8636_seed_21264_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/049_0000091_group_9_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000091_group_9_sample_0_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000091_group_9_sample_0_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000091_group_9_sample_0_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000091_group_9_sample_0_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000091_group_9_sample_0_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000091_group_9_sample_0_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+50,0.05146667,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.04686993,0.00558999,0.02751997,0.71666819,0.45212278,0.11718750,0.00289118,0000041,group_4,3,q4,Does the spinning rear wheel splash a huge fan-shaped water curtain that occupies approximately half of the screen?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"fixed, low-angle, wide-angle shot focuses on a downpour-soaked asphalt street in a cyberpunk city. Between towering skyscrapers, giant, translucent holographic advertisements flicker with shifting patterns, interplaying with pink and cyan neon signs, painting the slippery road surface into a shimmering mirror. The air is thick with damp vapor. A heavily modified off-road vehicle suddenly bursts into view, its matte black armored body covered in battle-worn scratches and mud stains. The blue LED strips on its underbody cast an eerie halo of light on the ground. The vehicle drifts with incredible speed and precision. The wide, heavily treaded off-road tires lose grip the moment they make contact, emitting a sharp, grinding sound, and the vehicle tilts violently under the immense force of inertia. At this moment, the high-speed spinning rear wheel suddenly rolled up the accumulated water on the road, exploding a huge fan-shaped water curtain that almost occupied half of the screen. Every splashing water droplet reflected a diamond-like bright and short-lived colorful light under the illumination of the surrounding chaotic light. The whole scene was full of movement and power. Against the backdrop of the cold rainy night and the dazzling technological light pollution, it created a tense, chaotic and visually impactful futuristic atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2335,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000041/group_4/index_8403_seed_8685_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/050_0000041_group_4_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000041_group_4_sample_3_q4__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000041_group_4_sample_3_q4__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000041_group_4_sample_3_q4__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000041_group_4_sample_3_q4__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000041_group_4_sample_3_q4__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000041_group_4_sample_3_q4__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+51,0.05142412,beside-next-to,2.46000000,9,0.03690015,0.00438587,0.02167618,0.81243843,0.48672774,0.11523438,0.00012413,0000092,group_10,3,q3,"Does a young girl with long brown hair in a ponytail, wearing a blue hoodie, slam a textbook shut on a low wooden coffee table?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld, shaky, medium close-up captures a candid, lived-in moment in a comfortably lit living room. The camera first focuses on a man in his 30s with shaggy brown hair and a friendly, wrinkled face, dressed in a simple gray T-shirt. He leans forward on a plush beige sofa and playfully teases a giggling little boy with short blond hair sitting next to him. After a moment of gentle tickling, the man leans back against the sofa cushions, a cute, tired smile on his face, his left hand raised as he looks at the children, his posture relaxing. The camera then gently pans back and refocuses on a young girl, about ten years old, with long brown hair tied in a ponytail, sitting on the carpeted floor. She's wearing a blue hoodie and shaking her head slightly in annoyance, her brow furrowed as she stares at an open textbook on the low wooden coffee table in front of her. She impatiently flips through a few pages with her right hand, the papers clicking softly. Then, with a sudden, sharp movement, she decisively slammed the book shut, a dull thud in the quiet room. Without pausing, she reached for a purple school backpack lying on the floor nearby, grasping its strap and pulling it toward her, her movement conveying a palpable sense of frustration and determination. The entire scene was bathed in the warm, soft glow of a nearby floor lamp, casting long shadows and creating an intimate, domestic atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,647,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000092/group_10/index_5785_seed_14634_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/051_0000092_group_10_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000092_group_10_sample_3_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+52,0.05055405,foreground-background,3.43200000,7,0.02501975,0.00296541,0.01470290,0.83636814,0.53943455,0.09863281,0.00198853,0000124,group_10,2,q2,"Is a man dressed in a black leather jacket, black T-shirt, and dark jeans approaching two children?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld, slightly shaky, medium-long shot captures a bustling, sunny public square as a man dressed entirely in black approaches two young children. The camera tracks him with subtle, unsteady movements, enhancing the scene's raw immediacy. The man, dressed in a black leather jacket, a black T-shirt, and dark jeans, moves with an unconventional rhythm, twisting his torso while speaking enthusiastically and gesturing. His face is initially obscured by dark sunglasses. Two children, a boy and a girl, wearing brightly colored hoodies, stand close together, their eyes wide and uncertain as they watch his approach. As the man closes in distance, he deliberately slows down, smoothly removing his sunglasses to reveal a gentle smile. He then bends down from the waist, lowering his upper body to level with the children in a non-threatening gesture. In response, the children's previously motionless hands begin to move; one child fidgets with his sleeve, another makes a small, hesitant gesture forward. Throughout this interaction, the background remains vibrant: figures in the distance stroll through the square, and at one point, a passerby briskly walks through the foreground, momentarily interrupting the frame. The entire scene is bathed in bright, cool daylight, creating a stark contrast and a tense, unfolding atmosphere of curiosity, all captured with an erratic camera that suggests a spontaneous, unstaged moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3573,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000124/group_10/index_9154_seed_8438_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/052_0000124_group_10_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000124_group_10_sample_2_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000124_group_10_sample_2_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000124_group_10_sample_2_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000124_group_10_sample_2_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000124_group_10_sample_2_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000124_group_10_sample_2_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+53,0.04959586,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.34000000,5,0.02279346,0.00270867,0.01338986,0.68936932,0.42673984,0.13574219,0.00418338,0000101,group_2,1,q4,Is the man slowly unrolling a bamboo map bound by string with his hands?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, close-up shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, focuses the viewer's attention on a scene illuminated by the flickering flame of an ancient copper oil lamp. At the center of the frame lies a middle-aged strategist, wearing a dark silk scarf and a wide-sleeved black robe. He sits at a heavy, dark wooden desk, his brow furrowed, his eyes sharp as an eagle's, his gaze fixed intently on the object before him. The warm, dancing light casts deep shadows on his chiseled features, highlighting his lips pursed in deep thought. His slender, powerful hands, carefully, steadily, and deliberately, slowly unroll a bamboo map bound by string. As he moves, the polished bamboo strips rub against each other, creating a crisp, subtle rustling sound. The map's ink-drawn mountains and rivers, along with the cinnabar-marked military fortresses, gradually emerge in the dim light, exuding a sense of age and age. Beside him, on the desk, rests a feather fan crafted from white crane feathers, its ebony handle gleaming softly in the light. The painting's warm, deep tones, predominantly dark browns and oranges, create a stark contrast between light and shadow, evoking a sense of intense concentration and tension as one plots and decides a battle in the stillness of the night.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,285,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000101/group_2/index_6541_seed_30523_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/053_0000101_group_2_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q4__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q4__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q4__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q4__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q4__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q4__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+54,0.04959367,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.88400000,6,0.01797174,0.00212986,0.01056125,0.79523039,0.51013017,0.09863281,0.00219828,0000039,group_7,2,q4,Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, eye-level camera drifts across a sprawling post-apocalyptic market, huddled beneath a patchwork canopy of rusted corrugated metal shelters. Sharp, bright sunlight pierces a series of bullet holes in the roof, piercing the dim, shadowy space and illuminating the thick, swirling dust. The camera's steady movement focuses on a central exchange, where a gaunt, weathered scavenger with a scraggly gray beard, dressed in a tattered ensemble of canvas and leather, carefully pulls out a green fiberglass circuit board, its intricate silver paths gleaming. Opposite him, a young scavenger, his eyes wary, his face smeared with grime, clutches a dirty plastic bottle of clear water in his hands, his posture tense. The transaction proceeds with a slow, deliberate gravity; hands hover, inspecting the goods, and then the circuit board is eventually exchanged for the bottle in a silent, desperate exchange. In the background, other figures shuttle between stalls filled with recycled solar panels and the faded, torn remnants of faded banners. At the edge of the makeshift settlement, a massive wind turbine cobbled together from scrap metal churns with a rhythmic clatter, stirring up dust on the ground and underscoring the scene’s pervasive atmosphere of quiet despair, all rendered in a desaturated, earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4294,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_7/index_3930_seed_13382_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/054_0000039_group_7_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_7_sample_2_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_7_sample_2_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_7_sample_2_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_7_sample_2_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_7_sample_2_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_7_sample_2_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+55,0.04884514,foreground-background+between-flanked,5.32000000,5,0.01548931,0.00188430,0.00907000,0.76067048,0.55059099,0.07421875,0.00019932,0000002,group_3,2,q4,Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion, low-angle shot zooms in on a city basketball court surrounded by a high, rusty barbed wire fence. In the center of the frame, two sweat-drenched teenagers engage in a fierce standoff. The boy in the foreground, with tanned skin and short, close-cropped black hair, wears a sweat-soaked, dark blue sleeveless basketball vest that clings to his heaving chest and muscular build. His jaw set, his eyes piercing like a hawk, he stands with his hands on his hips, leaning slightly forward in an aggressive stance. The other boy confronting him wears an equally drenched white vest, his bangs clinging to his forehead with sweat. His arms are crossed over his chest, his posture erect, his gaze firm and unyielding. The golden afterglow of the setting sun streams in at a sharp angle, filtering through the bars of the barbed wire fence and casting long, interlaced shadows on the cracked asphalt. The light outlines their youthful, powerful figures and illuminates every bead of sweat on their skin. The air seemed to freeze, the dilapidated red brick apartment building in the background became blurred, and all the focus was on the invisible space between the two teenagers, which was full of charge. Every breath in their chests and every silent exchange of eyes filled the whole scene with primitive competitive tension and a dramatic atmosphere that was about to break out.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,547,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_6174_seed_3012_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/055_0000002_group_3_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_3_sample_2_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+56,0.04884241,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.88400000,6,0.01734440,0.00208033,0.01017605,0.83524650,0.53155637,0.09765625,0.00062865,0000039,group_7,0,q4,Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, eye-level camera drifts across a sprawling post-apocalyptic market, huddled beneath a patchwork canopy of rusted corrugated metal shelters. Sharp, bright sunlight pierces a series of bullet holes in the roof, piercing the dim, shadowy space and illuminating the thick, swirling dust. The camera's steady movement focuses on a central exchange, where a gaunt, weathered scavenger with a scraggly gray beard, dressed in a tattered ensemble of canvas and leather, carefully pulls out a green fiberglass circuit board, its intricate silver paths gleaming. Opposite him, a young scavenger, his eyes wary, his face smeared with grime, clutches a dirty plastic bottle of clear water in his hands, his posture tense. The transaction proceeds with a slow, deliberate gravity; hands hover, inspecting the goods, and then the circuit board is eventually exchanged for the bottle in a silent, desperate exchange. In the background, other figures shuttle between stalls filled with recycled solar panels and the faded, torn remnants of faded banners. At the edge of the makeshift settlement, a massive wind turbine cobbled together from scrap metal churns with a rhythmic clatter, stirring up dust on the ground and underscoring the scene’s pervasive atmosphere of quiet despair, all rendered in a desaturated, earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4292,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_7/index_3930_seed_13380_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/056_0000039_group_7_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+57,0.04841335,left-right-pair+foreground-background,6.44800000,3,0.01523952,0.00182769,0.00894122,0.67308211,0.42011264,0.12988281,0.00215995,0000118,group_2,3,q4,Is a fallen man's hand visible twitching on the stained concrete in the lower foreground?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shaky, eye-level handheld shot shakes violently, struggling to depict the chaotic aftermath of a clash on a gritty city sidewalk. The camera first captures a man, dressed head-to-toe in a black zip-up hoodie and dark jeans, looking around, eyes wide and terrified. As he staggers backward, his arms swing in a wide, uncontrolled arc for balance, his body blurring as he awkwardly exits the left side of the frame. The camera then pans erratically to the right, resting on his opponent, who stands uncomfortably in a clean white crew-neck T-shirt and a dark baseball cap. He speaks calmly, his expression unreadable, and deliberately raises his right hand. With two fingers gripping it precisely, he tilts the brim upward, briefly and methodically wiping his forehead with the back of his palm, then replaces it. His hand then drops, disappearing casually into his trouser pocket. In the lower foreground, lying on the stained concrete, the hand of a fallen man twitches, a faint, seemingly final movement. The background is a series of moving, blurred bystanders scattering in panic, their blurred forms evacuating the scene. The entire event is illuminated by the harsh, flat light of an overcast sky, creating a stark, documentary-like feel and a palpable, thick atmosphere of post-violence tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4083,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000118/group_2/index_4089_seed_20985_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/057_0000118_group_2_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000118_group_2_sample_3_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000118_group_2_sample_3_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000118_group_2_sample_3_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000118_group_2_sample_3_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000118_group_2_sample_3_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000118_group_2_sample_3_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+58,0.04829659,left-right-pair,4.44000000,6,0.01669754,0.00202253,0.00978334,0.87600642,0.65334827,0.06835938,0.00047809,0000087,group_9,3,q3,Is a man with neatly cropped brown hair wearing a navy blue button-down shirt visible in the center?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion doll begins in a bright, modern kitchen studio, capturing three dynamic shots at eye level. In the center, a man with neatly cropped brown hair and a friendly, engaging expression is speaking actively, emphasizing his words with expressive gestures. He wears a crisp navy blue button-down shirt. To his right, a woman with blonde hair tied in a sleek ponytail and a professional-looking soft pink shirt steadily lifts a clear glass bottle filled with golden liquid from a pristine white marble countertop. Her other hand precisely grasps the metallic silver cap and deftly twists it open. To the man's left, another woman in a crisp white chef's coat is absorbed in her work, her hands moving expertly as she carefully handles fresh ingredients, perhaps arranging vibrant green herbs on a dark wooden cutting board. The entire scene is bathed in bright, diffused studio light, eliminating harsh shadows and highlighting the clean lines of the stainless steel appliances blurred in the background, creating an atmosphere of warmth, collaboration, and high professionalism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,852,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000087/group_9/index_5711_seed_24666_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/058_0000087_group_9_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000087_group_9_sample_3_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+59,0.04820866,beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,7.48800000,7,0.01166216,0.00138604,0.00685075,0.75497568,0.49557477,0.09277344,0.00104576,0000158,group_8,3,q5,Is the scene illuminated by warm golden light from a low-hanging lamp casting soft shadows?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures an intimate moment of passionate conversation between two friends in a dimly lit, cozy bistro. A woman in her twenties, with wavy auburn hair loosely pulled back and wearing a soft cream-colored sweater, leans forward, a gentle smile on her face as she speaks. Across from her, a man of similar age, wearing a dark green button-down shirt with the sleeves casually rolled up to his forearms, listens intently, his head slightly tilted, a look of genuine engagement. Between them, on a small, round, dark wooden table, lie two elegant, large glasses half-filled with deep red wine. As the woman shares her story, her right hand gracefully and expressively gestures near the bowl of her glass, while the man's hand rests near the base of his own, his fingers leisurely tracing the polished wood. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden light of a low-hanging lamp, casting soft shadows on their faces and causing the wine to gleam, creating a tranquil and welcoming atmosphere of easy friendship and shared confidence.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2605,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000158/group_8/index_5750_seed_15306_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/059_0000158_group_8_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+60,0.04787999,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.01776259,0.00220149,0.01037407,0.72561312,0.52215779,0.08007812,0.00068659,0000056,group_3,2,q2,Is Sun Wukong wearing intricately carved golden chainmail armor with cloud patterns and a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown with two long pheasant feathers?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,518,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26611_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/060_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q2__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q2__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q2__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q2__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q2__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_2_q2__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+61,0.04787902,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.03561556,0.00421782,0.02093182,0.82403511,0.53323472,0.09667969,0.00232401,0000050,group_11,0,q4,Is the man using a crude crutch carved from a tree branch to support himself?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld camera, shot from a slightly elevated angle, follows a ragged elderly man as he walks down a muddy, rain-soaked country road. His sparse, short, graying hair is ruffled by the cold wind. His bronzed face is etched with deep, knife-like wrinkles, and his sunken eyes hold a gaze that is a mixture of fatigue and steeliness. He wears a faded, frayed dark blue Mao suit, the hems and cuffs ripped. He wears a gray shirt underneath, the collar yellowed, and his equally worn, dark trousers are splattered with damp mud. Under the gloomy evening sky, the thick clouds cast a faint, cold, scattered light, casting a chilling gray-brown hue on the entire scene. His steps were heavy and unsteady, each one sinking deeply into the sticky mud. Pulling out his stick was incredibly laborious, his body swaying from side to side, struggling to maintain balance with a crude crutch carved from a tree branch, tightly clenched in one hand. The road flanked by bleak winter fields, bare branches trembling slightly in the wind. The entire scene is imbued with a raw documentary quality, devoid of embellishment, focused solely on capturing every step of the old man's struggle against adversity, conveying a poignant, authentic, and resilient atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2690,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000050/group_11/index_3100_seed_11386_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/061_0000050_group_11_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+62,0.04608785,left-right-pair+between-flanked,5.70400000,3,0.01495421,0.00179721,0.00877133,0.71925128,0.48087072,0.10058594,0.00161630,0000001,group_12,2,q3,Do a pair of hands with perfectly manicured nails slide a white ceramic plate forward from the right side of the frame?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slightly high-angled extreme close-up, imbued with subtle handheld vibrations, conveys a sense of eager anticipation, capturing the culinary exchange at the table. In the center of the frame, a traditional yin-yang hot pot boils, its surface divided between a fiery red broth laden with chilies and a milky white broth. Wisps of aromatic steam rise, catching the warm overhead light and creating a soft, dreamy haze. Starting on the right, a pair of hands with perfectly manicured nails gently and deliberately slide a pristine white ceramic plate forward across the dark polished wood of the table. On the plate, a thin slice of richly marbled beef is meticulously fanned out into a perfect, vibrant red rosette. As the plate glides through the rising steam, a second, slightly larger pair of hands moves in from the left, carefully accepting the offering, their fingers balancing on the plate's rim in a shared culinary ritual. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of the intimate restaurant setting, creating a palpable atmosphere of warmth, joy, and delicious anticipation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2234,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000001/group_12/index_5051_seed_26457_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/062_0000001_group_12_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000001_group_12_sample_2_q3__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000001_group_12_sample_2_q3__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000001_group_12_sample_2_q3__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000001_group_12_sample_2_q3__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000001_group_12_sample_2_q3__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000001_group_12_sample_2_q3__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+63,0.04596918,left-right-pair,4.92000000,8,0.01651066,0.00195460,0.00970404,0.72854978,0.50431222,0.08300781,0.00047851,0000067,group_10,1,q2,"Is the scene set in a luxurious bathroom with white marble countertops, gilded fixtures, and crystal accents visible through a large bay window?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a surreal, high-definition digital aesthetic, the film begins with a slow, graceful, doll-like movement, sliding horizontally across the magnificent, ornate facade of a sprawling limestone mansion. Soft, golden morning light casts long shadows across the intricate carvings and towering pillars, rendering every detail with crisp 4K clarity. As the camera continues its steady, uninterrupted path, it perfectly aligns with a spotless, large bay window, revealing a brightly lit, luxurious bathroom. Through the pristine glass, a woman with dark black hair pulled back into a sleek, elegant bun can be seen leaning against a large, ornate mirror. She wears a lustrous, blush-tinged silk robe, the fabric striking in its allure. She meticulously shapes her eyebrows with precise, deliberate movements, her expression intense and unwavering. In her right hand, she holds a pair of pointed metal tweezers, while with her left, she gently pinches the skin above her eyes. The soft morning light from the window and the warm, even glow from the bulb in the mirror-framed dressing table combine to illuminate the scene, creating a focused halo around her face, while the luxurious surroundings of white marble countertops, gleaming gilded fixtures, and crystal accents fade into the soft-focus background, establishing an atmosphere of quiet, personal ritual, and focused perfection.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,560,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_10/index_7152_seed_29973_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/063_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+64,0.04588985,left-right-pair+between-flanked,5.70400000,3,0.01360647,0.00166833,0.00795876,0.81450272,0.55966371,0.08398438,0.00050932,0000002,group_5,2,q2,"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from an underwater eye-level, follows the fierce confrontation between two massive largemouth bass with a slow, steady pan. In the murky, yet sun-drenched, freshwater lake, shafts of light create a Tyndall effect in the deep green water, illuminating tiny suspended particles. The bass on the left, slightly larger, its olive-green scales gleaming metallically in the light. Its gill covers open wide in fury, revealing vibrant red gill filaments. It lunges forward with explosive force, its massive mouth stretched to its limit. Its opponent on the right, no less, slaps the current with its powerful tail fin, stirring up a small cloud of bottom mud and sand. It nimbly twists its body in the water to meet the impact sideways. The moment the two fish collide, the image is filled with a sense of power, with visible ripples in the water and a few silver scales falling and scattering in the chaos. Their movements are not chaotic, but full of primitive and strategic aggressiveness. Every collision and bite stirs up the swaying aquatic plants around them, creating a tense, fierce and primitive competitive atmosphere full of vitality.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1750,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_5/index_267_seed_25097_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/064_0000002_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+65,0.04525148,left-right-pair+opposite-across,6.20400000,4,0.01292291,0.00153180,0.00759407,0.83538604,0.52106458,0.10253906,0.00292298,0000028,group_11,0,q4,Is the warrior on the right standing erect with arms outstretched and a long red tassel on his helmet?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, medium shot, captured from a low, upward angle using a telephoto lens, freezes the epic confrontation atop the Yellow Crane Tower. In the frame, two warriors clad in full bronze armor face off atop the iconic yellow glazed tile roof. The telephoto lens compresses the space, making the turbulent sky behind them seem incredibly close and oppressive. The warrior on the left slumps slightly, his legs bent in a lunge, his center of gravity low. Beneath his beast-faced helmet, his piercing eyes fixate on his opponent, his right hand gripping the hilt of the longsword at his waist, veins visible. His bronze armor is intricately engraved with cloud and thunder patterns, and the slight scratches along its edges, worn by years of battle, reflect a cold, hard gleam in the gloomy sky. The warrior opposite him stands erect, his figure even more imposing, the long red tassel on his helmet whipping the air fiercely in the wind. He didn't place his hands on his weapons, but held his arms slightly outstretched. His posture appeared relaxed, but his set jaw and unyielding gaze betrayed a deep sense of vigilance. The glazed tiles beneath their feet shone with a damp sheen in the humid air. Against the backdrop was a vast, boundless sky, thick, dark clouds rolling and converging at a visible speed. Occasionally, a gap in the clouds would reveal a brief, dramatic burst of light, imbuing this fateful confrontation with a solemn and awe-inspiring atmosphere. The dominant tones of the scene, the gray-blue of the sky, the bright yellow of the roofs, and the dark copper of the armor, imbued the scene with a chilling, cinematic quality.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,697,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000028/group_11/index_5667_seed_23634_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/065_0000028_group_11_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+66,0.04512381,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.03767774,0.00449983,0.02211861,0.70387459,0.44351274,0.12207031,0.00283360,0000130,group_15,1,q2,Is an elderly monk with a gaunt face and shiny head wearing a dark gray cotton and linen robe visible?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pulls back to reveal a wider scene. Deep within a lush bamboo forest, shrouded in morning mist, a milky white mist gently drifts between the towering, straight bamboo poles. The first rays of morning sunlight struggle to penetrate the dense fog and dense bamboo leaves, casting several distinct, mottled golden beams in the air. An elderly monk with a gaunt face and a shiny head, dressed in a simple dark gray cotton and linen robe, stands in a clearing in the forest, covered with moist fallen leaves. His eyes are slightly closed, his expression serene and focused. His body moves in a steady and deliberate rhythm. His arms trace smooth arcs, his wide sleeves swaying gently, and his center of gravity shifts effortlessly between his legs. Each movement, from raising his hands to lowering his shoulders, is as smooth and natural as flowing water, imbued with inner strength and harmony. The entire picture is dominated by calm gray and vibrant emerald green, embellished by warm morning light, creating an otherworldly, Zen-like tranquil atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,818,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000130/group_15/index_2985_seed_3311_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/066_0000130_group_15_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000130_group_15_sample_1_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000130_group_15_sample_1_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000130_group_15_sample_1_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000130_group_15_sample_1_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000130_group_15_sample_1_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000130_group_15_sample_1_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+67,0.04491996,opposite-across,2.78800000,9,0.02900081,0.00343815,0.01704178,0.75054109,0.47064012,0.10253906,0.00200737,0000009,group_4,1,q3,"Is an older man with silver-gray hair wearing a dark tweed blazer and white collared shirt seated opposite, shaking his head slowly with his gaze averted?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot depicts a tense, silent confrontation in the hallowed quiet of a wood-paneled academic library. At a large, polished mahogany table, a young man with shaggy black hair leans forward, an impassioned look of frustration written across his face. Wearing a comfortable, dark green cardigan, they repeatedly gesture with their index finger to a tablet on the table. The tablet's screen emits a bright, cool digital glow, casting a stark blue light on their faces and hands, illuminating the complex data charts visible on the display. An older man seated opposite, dressed in a formal dark tweed blazer and a crisp white collared shirt, remains erect, his posture a wall of defiance. His silver-gray hair is impossibly neatly trimmed, his face a mask of resolute misunderstanding. He shakes his head slowly and stubbornly, his lips pressed into a thin line, his gaze deliberately averted, refusing even a glance at the glowing screen. The warm golden light from a classic green-shaded bank lamp on the table illuminates the scene, creating deep shadows that contrast with the cool glow of the tablet, visually emphasizing the generational and ideological clash. The background is filled with tall, dimly lit bookshelves filled with old leather-bound books, creating a heavy academic atmosphere, imbued with the weight of tradition and unspoken disagreements.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,132,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_4/index_5960_seed_20022_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/067_0000009_group_4_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+68,0.04450106,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.03709533,0.00445297,0.02176157,0.72285509,0.48478737,0.10058594,0.00162953,0000148,group_15,0,q2,"Is the main subject an elderly man with deeply wrinkled skin, thinning gray hair, and a dark blue cotton double-breasted jacket?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"tightly composed, static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, imbues the image with the rich colors and intense humanity that are hallmarks of Steve McCurry's photography. In a steaming, slightly crowded, old Chinese kitchen, an elderly man, his face deeply wrinkled and his hair thinning with gray, is absorbed in his cooking. A warm, directional light slants down from above and sideways, precisely outlining the contours of his bronzed face and his pursed lips. His deep eyes gleam with concentration amidst the swirling steam. He wears a washed-out, dark blue cotton double-breasted jacket, sleeves neatly rolled to the elbows, revealing his muscular, vein-filled forearms. Steady in his right hand, he grips a long-handled spatula and stirs the vibrantly colored ingredients in the dark cast iron wok with a deft, powerful rhythm. Each stroke of the spatula ignites a small, bright flame that licks the edge, emitting a sizzling sound. Thick white steam rises from the pot, layered in the light, blurring the yellowed tiled wall and the hanging strings of dried chilies behind it. The image is richly saturated, creating a striking yet harmonious contrast between the deep blue of the top, the vibrant red and green of the ingredients, and the golden sheen of the copper spoon in the background. This creates a warm atmosphere of simplicity, focus, and vitality, capturing a moment of dignity and beauty in everyday life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3992,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000148/group_15/index_4012_seed_27658_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/068_0000148_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q2__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q2__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q2__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q2__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q2__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q2__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+69,0.04429696,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.07200000,4,0.01241511,0.00150276,0.00727490,0.81039047,0.55751151,0.08593750,0.00239316,0000105,group_14,2,q2,"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium close-up shot from a level angle, slightly handheld and imbued with a subtle sense of shakiness, instantly draws the viewer into the bustling and vibrant atmosphere of a wet market. At the center of the frame is an elderly woman with a wrinkled face and graying hair tied in a simple bun. Time has carved deep grooves into her tanned skin, but her eyes are remarkably sharp and focused. She wears a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock, the fabric defined by its distinct texture and soft creases from repeated washing. Standing before a vegetable stall piled high with vibrant greens, carrots dusted with fresh soil, and plump tomatoes, she leans forward slightly, extending her age-freckled right hand. With her index and middle fingers, she decisively indicates a price, her lips pursed as she speaks rapidly and forcefully to the vendor off-screen. In her left hand, she clutches a woven bamboo basket, its edges frayed. The tarpaulin overhead casts dappled shadows, while a few suspended incandescent bulbs emit a warm, dim glow, illuminating the dust and moisture floating in the air and creating a stark contrast between the vibrant colors of the vegetables and the dark clothing of the elderly woman. The entire scene, shrouded in warm tones, exudes an atmosphere both tense and full of life, perfectly capturing the uncompromising moments of everyday transactions.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1226,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_8676_seed_3868_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/069_0000105_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+70,0.04415231,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.00885322,0.00108698,0.00517749,0.78919166,0.48634323,0.12109375,0.00066978,0000037,group_5,1,q1,"Is the scene a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2713,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4757_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/070_0000037_group_5_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q1__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q1__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q1__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q1__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q1__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q1__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+71,0.04413028,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.03298106,0.00390626,0.01938320,0.82570869,0.53392917,0.09667969,0.00236285,0000050,group_11,0,q3,"Is the man wearing a faded, frayed dark blue Mao suit with ripped hems and cuffs?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld camera, shot from a slightly elevated angle, follows a ragged elderly man as he walks down a muddy, rain-soaked country road. His sparse, short, graying hair is ruffled by the cold wind. His bronzed face is etched with deep, knife-like wrinkles, and his sunken eyes hold a gaze that is a mixture of fatigue and steeliness. He wears a faded, frayed dark blue Mao suit, the hems and cuffs ripped. He wears a gray shirt underneath, the collar yellowed, and his equally worn, dark trousers are splattered with damp mud. Under the gloomy evening sky, the thick clouds cast a faint, cold, scattered light, casting a chilling gray-brown hue on the entire scene. His steps were heavy and unsteady, each one sinking deeply into the sticky mud. Pulling out his stick was incredibly laborious, his body swaying from side to side, struggling to maintain balance with a crude crutch carved from a tree branch, tightly clenched in one hand. The road flanked by bleak winter fields, bare branches trembling slightly in the wind. The entire scene is imbued with a raw documentary quality, devoid of embellishment, focused solely on capturing every step of the old man's struggle against adversity, conveying a poignant, authentic, and resilient atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2691,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000050/group_11/index_3100_seed_11386_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/071_0000050_group_11_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000050_group_11_sample_0_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+72,0.04385941,left-right-pair,4.92000000,8,0.01583005,0.00187576,0.00930286,0.72876000,0.49855033,0.08300781,0.00059503,0000067,group_10,1,q5,Is the scene illuminated by soft golden morning light and a warm bulb glow creating a focused halo around the woman's face?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a surreal, high-definition digital aesthetic, the film begins with a slow, graceful, doll-like movement, sliding horizontally across the magnificent, ornate facade of a sprawling limestone mansion. Soft, golden morning light casts long shadows across the intricate carvings and towering pillars, rendering every detail with crisp 4K clarity. As the camera continues its steady, uninterrupted path, it perfectly aligns with a spotless, large bay window, revealing a brightly lit, luxurious bathroom. Through the pristine glass, a woman with dark black hair pulled back into a sleek, elegant bun can be seen leaning against a large, ornate mirror. She wears a lustrous, blush-tinged silk robe, the fabric striking in its allure. She meticulously shapes her eyebrows with precise, deliberate movements, her expression intense and unwavering. In her right hand, she holds a pair of pointed metal tweezers, while with her left, she gently pinches the skin above her eyes. The soft morning light from the window and the warm, even glow from the bulb in the mirror-framed dressing table combine to illuminate the scene, creating a focused halo around her face, while the luxurious surroundings of white marble countertops, gleaming gilded fixtures, and crystal accents fade into the soft-focus background, establishing an atmosphere of quiet, personal ritual, and focused perfection.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2408,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_10/index_7152_seed_29973_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/072_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q5__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q5__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q5__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q5__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q5__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q5__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+73,0.04328960,beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,7.48800000,7,0.01040138,0.00123099,0.00611360,0.70077753,0.48456088,0.07421875,0.00026625,0000158,group_8,3,q4,Is the woman gesturing with her right hand near her glass while the man's hand rests on the table?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures an intimate moment of passionate conversation between two friends in a dimly lit, cozy bistro. A woman in her twenties, with wavy auburn hair loosely pulled back and wearing a soft cream-colored sweater, leans forward, a gentle smile on her face as she speaks. Across from her, a man of similar age, wearing a dark green button-down shirt with the sleeves casually rolled up to his forearms, listens intently, his head slightly tilted, a look of genuine engagement. Between them, on a small, round, dark wooden table, lie two elegant, large glasses half-filled with deep red wine. As the woman shares her story, her right hand gracefully and expressively gestures near the bowl of her glass, while the man's hand rests near the base of his own, his fingers leisurely tracing the polished wood. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden light of a low-hanging lamp, casting soft shadows on their faces and causing the wine to gleam, creating a tranquil and welcoming atmosphere of easy friendship and shared confidence.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000158/group_8/index_5750_seed_15306_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/073_0000158_group_8_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+74,0.04295404,beside-next-to,1.74000000,2,0.04084561,0.00483482,0.02400719,0.84267581,0.53707081,0.10351562,0.00287691,0000118,group_14,0,q4,"Is the room environment characterized by a polished light gray linen floor, pale institutional seaweed green walls, and a single IV stand?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"An extreme close-up focuses on a hand, clad in a thin, pale blue butyl glove, its fingers clasped together as it steadily and deliberately glides across the surface of a sheet of pristine white cotton. The camera captures the fabric's microscopic texture as the gloved hand meticulously smooths out the last faint wrinkles, rendering the sheet perfectly taut and flawless. As the motion is complete, the camera begins a slow, seamless pullback, gradually widening the frame. The shot reveals the entirety of the empty hospital bed, its metal side rails lowered and its frame constructed of cool brushed steel. The pullback continues, transitioning into a wide shot that reveals the surroundings of the sterile, silent room. The floor is a polished, light gray linen, faintly reflecting the harsh, even fluorescent light from overhead. The walls are a pale, institutional seaweed green, save for a single, silent IV stand standing beside the bed. The atmosphere is one of heavy clinical silence, a profound sense of order and cleanliness, creating a tranquil yet somber mood, impersonal and prepared.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1600,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000118/group_14/index_2314_seed_5810_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/074_0000118_group_14_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q4__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q4__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q4__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q4__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q4__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q4__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+75,0.04250551,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.02081568,0.00246848,0.01223147,0.68876565,0.42620918,0.13574219,0.00421420,0000101,group_2,1,q2,Is the scene illuminated by the flickering flame of an ancient copper oil lamp?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, close-up shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, focuses the viewer's attention on a scene illuminated by the flickering flame of an ancient copper oil lamp. At the center of the frame lies a middle-aged strategist, wearing a dark silk scarf and a wide-sleeved black robe. He sits at a heavy, dark wooden desk, his brow furrowed, his eyes sharp as an eagle's, his gaze fixed intently on the object before him. The warm, dancing light casts deep shadows on his chiseled features, highlighting his lips pursed in deep thought. His slender, powerful hands, carefully, steadily, and deliberately, slowly unroll a bamboo map bound by string. As he moves, the polished bamboo strips rub against each other, creating a crisp, subtle rustling sound. The map's ink-drawn mountains and rivers, along with the cinnabar-marked military fortresses, gradually emerge in the dim light, exuding a sense of age and age. Beside him, on the desk, rests a feather fan crafted from white crane feathers, its ebony handle gleaming softly in the light. The painting's warm, deep tones, predominantly dark browns and oranges, create a stark contrast between light and shadow, evoking a sense of intense concentration and tension as one plots and decides a battle in the stillness of the night.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3203,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000101/group_2/index_6541_seed_30523_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/075_0000101_group_2_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+76,0.04250343,foreground-background+between-flanked,4.40800000,2,0.01658642,0.00196545,0.00974731,0.84408301,0.54461348,0.09863281,0.00281182,0000002,group_9,3,q1,Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"At dusk, a static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a lone figure on a Parisian basketball court, creating a scene of profound solitude and elegance. In the background, the iconic silhouette of the Eiffel Tower is clearly visible against the stunning sunset, its iron latticework appearing a stark black against the bright sky, tinged with hues of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft violet. In the foreground, the athlete, rendered almost in silhouette by the powerful backlight, maintains a low, focused stance in a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts. The figure deftly dribbles a classic orange basketball with fluid precision; the pebbled leather surface is barely discernible as it blurs, moving from a low, rhythmic thump on the worn asphalt court to a rapid cross between the legs. The warm, dramatic light of the setting sun casts long shadows and creates a bright rim light around the figure's body, highlighting their concentrated energy and the sweat on their brow. The atmosphere is one of quiet, solitary passion, blending the implicit rhythmic sound of the dribbling ball with the quiet grandeur of the city. As the last vibrant colors of sunset deepen into dusk, the entire scene slowly and steadily fades, light and image disappearing until only utter black remains.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4471,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_9/index_149_seed_23581_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/076_0000002_group_9_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q1__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q1__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q1__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q1__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q1__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_9_sample_3_q1__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+77,0.04231771,opposite-across,2.51600000,6,0.02863488,0.00340914,0.01681716,0.73872560,0.51143575,0.08007812,0.00084680,0000099,group_15,3,q3,Do two much taller teenage boys walk through the circle and pose against a weathered brick wall?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a vivid scene on a sun-drenched schoolyard. Four young boys, about eight to ten years old, huddled on cracked concrete, huddled joyfully in a tight, happy circle, engrossed in a game. A boy with messy blond hair and a bright red hoodie was laughing, his hands clenched into tight, rock-like fists. Across from him, a boy in a blue striped T-shirt countered with an open, paper-like hand. They were chattering when their playful bubble suddenly burst. Two much taller teenage boys walked directly through their circle, forcing the younger boys to spread out slightly. The first intruder, wearing an oversized black hoodie with the hood pulled down and baggy jeans, didn't break stride. His companion, with short hair, followed closely behind. They paused a few feet away from the group and, with practiced indifference, posed against a weathered brick wall in the background. The first man leaned back, shoving his thumbs in his pockets, while the second stood with his arms crossed, a stony expression on his face. They immediately launched into their own lively conversation, speaking and gesturing only to each other, their body language creating a clear boundary. The four young boys, forgetting their game, now sat down to watch the duo, their expressions a mix of silent annoyance and curiosity. The warm golden light of the late afternoon cast long shadows, creating an atmosphere of palpable social dynamics.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,592,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000099/group_15/index_3145_seed_27107_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/077_0000099_group_15_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000099_group_15_sample_3_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000099_group_15_sample_3_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000099_group_15_sample_3_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000099_group_15_sample_3_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000099_group_15_sample_3_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000099_group_15_sample_3_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+78,0.04225515,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.03390504,0.00402155,0.01992233,0.79461366,0.52136797,0.09667969,0.00237334,0000057,group_13,1,q3,Is the man wearing a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe and holding a long-handled bamboo broom with yellow bristles?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, depicts a world constructed in a refined pixel art style, with sharp, blocky edges. At the center of the frame is an elderly man with a graying beard and hair, his sparse white hair pulled back in a small bun. His face is lined with deep wrinkles, created by pixelated blocks, and his eyes are focused and serene. He wears a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe, its folds rendered with varying shades of gray. He stands in a quaint Chinese courtyard, his ground paved with bluestone slabs, interspersed between the cracks of the slabs with a profusion of golden and crimson pixelated fallen leaves. The elderly man is slightly bent over, his hands tightly gripping a long-handled bamboo broom—the handle rendered as a long string of brown pixels, the end of the broom a cluster of scattered yellow pixels. He methodically and unhurriedly swept the fallen leaves to one side. Each sweep was slow and rhythmic. The tip of the bamboo broom gently brushed the ground, sending pixelated leaves fluttering briefly in the air before gathering into a small pile. A soft, diffuse light evenly bathed the courtyard, devoid of harsh highlights, casting only soft, jagged, blocky shadows around the figures and the corners of the walls. The scene, dominated by earth tones and grays, was punctuated by the vibrant, warm colors of the fallen leaves, creating a tranquil and focused atmosphere that blended the nostalgia of retro gaming with the essence of Eastern Zen.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3733,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000057/group_13/index_7125_seed_23363_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/078_0000057_group_13_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+79,0.04160852,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.03484127,0.00418209,0.02043945,0.72284764,0.48502174,0.10058594,0.00163728,0000148,group_15,0,q1,Is the scene set in an old Chinese kitchen with yellowed tiled walls and hanging dried chilies?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"tightly composed, static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, imbues the image with the rich colors and intense humanity that are hallmarks of Steve McCurry's photography. In a steaming, slightly crowded, old Chinese kitchen, an elderly man, his face deeply wrinkled and his hair thinning with gray, is absorbed in his cooking. A warm, directional light slants down from above and sideways, precisely outlining the contours of his bronzed face and his pursed lips. His deep eyes gleam with concentration amidst the swirling steam. He wears a washed-out, dark blue cotton double-breasted jacket, sleeves neatly rolled to the elbows, revealing his muscular, vein-filled forearms. Steady in his right hand, he grips a long-handled spatula and stirs the vibrantly colored ingredients in the dark cast iron wok with a deft, powerful rhythm. Each stroke of the spatula ignites a small, bright flame that licks the edge, emitting a sizzling sound. Thick white steam rises from the pot, layered in the light, blurring the yellowed tiled wall and the hanging strings of dried chilies behind it. The image is richly saturated, creating a striking yet harmonious contrast between the deep blue of the top, the vibrant red and green of the ingredients, and the golden sheen of the copper spoon in the background. This creates a warm atmosphere of simplicity, focus, and vitality, capturing a moment of dignity and beauty in everyday life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3993,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000148/group_15/index_4012_seed_27658_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/079_0000148_group_15_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q1__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q1__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q1__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q1__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q1__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000148_group_15_sample_0_q1__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+80,0.04158258,left-right-pair,4.92000000,8,0.01591407,0.00189236,0.00934781,0.66758311,0.45604175,0.09472656,0.00065899,0000067,group_10,0,q2,"Is the scene set in a luxurious bathroom with white marble countertops, gilded fixtures, and crystal accents visible through a large bay window?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a surreal, high-definition digital aesthetic, the film begins with a slow, graceful, doll-like movement, sliding horizontally across the magnificent, ornate facade of a sprawling limestone mansion. Soft, golden morning light casts long shadows across the intricate carvings and towering pillars, rendering every detail with crisp 4K clarity. As the camera continues its steady, uninterrupted path, it perfectly aligns with a spotless, large bay window, revealing a brightly lit, luxurious bathroom. Through the pristine glass, a woman with dark black hair pulled back into a sleek, elegant bun can be seen leaning against a large, ornate mirror. She wears a lustrous, blush-tinged silk robe, the fabric striking in its allure. She meticulously shapes her eyebrows with precise, deliberate movements, her expression intense and unwavering. In her right hand, she holds a pair of pointed metal tweezers, while with her left, she gently pinches the skin above her eyes. The soft morning light from the window and the warm, even glow from the bulb in the mirror-framed dressing table combine to illuminate the scene, creating a focused halo around her face, while the luxurious surroundings of white marble countertops, gleaming gilded fixtures, and crystal accents fade into the soft-focus background, establishing an atmosphere of quiet, personal ritual, and focused perfection.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,558,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_10/index_7152_seed_29972_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/080_0000067_group_10_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+81,0.04127176,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.58800000,6,0.01435767,0.00173754,0.00841342,0.84766120,0.61667043,0.07324219,0.00027102,0000168,group_10,2,q3,Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, close-up, static shot, captured from a slight overhead angle, focuses on a gentle Asian mother, comfortably seated in a vintage wooden armchair. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through a large window, casting a warm golden hue on her long, dark brown hair, pulled into a low bun, and the off-white, turtleneck cashmere sweater she wears. Her face holds a serene, focused expression, her eyes slightly downcast, her gaze completely focused on the work in her hands. Her hands move steadily and deliberately, two smooth bamboo knitting needles twirling between her deft fingers. One needle expertly picks up lavender yarn and delicately threads it through the loop of the other. A half-finished sweater drapes across her legs, its intricate, twisted pattern clearly visible in the light, each fluffy fiber seeming palpable, a vivid, textured expression. Beside her, a wicker basket filled with colorful balls of yarn rests on the ground. The bookshelves and greenery in the background are softly blurred by the shallow depth of field. The entire scene is warm and harmonious, imbued with the warmth of home and the tranquility of time brought by handmade crafts.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3010,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_8887_seed_8254_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/081_0000168_group_10_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+82,0.04126570,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.03354265,0.00396958,0.01971538,0.80867064,0.50837582,0.10156250,0.00245100,0000011,group_10,0,q2,"Is the man wearing a dark gray, rough linen robe with sleeves rustling in the wind?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle and handheld, creates a constant, subtle tremor as the environment oscillates, creating a powerful sense of presence. Under incredibly realistic path-traced lighting, a resolute old man stands tall and proud in the center of a dense, impenetrable bamboo forest. His graying hair and beard flutter in the wind, his face deeply lined with wrinkles as if carved by a knife. His deep eyes gaze piercingly ahead, revealing an unyielding resolve. He wears a dark gray, rough linen robe, its sleeves rustling in the wind, yet his feet remain firmly planted on the moist earth, carpeted with withered, yellowing leaves. Around him, countless massive, sturdy, emerald green bamboos bend, sway, and collide violently like the surging waves of the sea, their leaves emitting a sharp whistling sound. Light struggles to penetrate through the dense bamboo foliage, forming countless sharp, dynamically shifting beams, casting a variegated, ever-changing light and shadow on the elderly man and the swaying ground. The scene, dominated by deep greens and grays, features intense contrasts of light and dark, and the constant tremors of the painting, creating a tense atmosphere of confrontation between man and nature, imbued with a sense of primal power.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3859,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000011/group_10/index_5521_seed_27591_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/082_0000011_group_10_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q2__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q2__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q2__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q2__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q2__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q2__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+83,0.04109742,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.58800000,6,0.01861720,0.00225071,0.01091099,0.63752180,0.39955392,0.13574219,0.00183773,0000112,group_2,0,q2,Is the man on the left wearing a black hoodie with reflective silver stripes and has shaggy black hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic, low-angle, tracking shot, close to the ground, follows two young men as they effortlessly glide across a futuristic city square at dusk on their electric unicycles. The young man on the left, with shaggy black hair and a tech-fabric black hoodie with reflective silver stripes on the sleeves, wears a broad smile. The young woman next to him, with her long, bright pink hair tied in a high ponytail, throws her head back in a sleek white bomber jacket and laughs heartily. The unicycles they ride are matte black, their futuristic LED strips emitting brilliant cyan and magenta light on either side, casting vibrant reflections on the polished dark stone floor, leaving long trails of light as the wheels spin at breakneck speed. The camera switches focus swiftly and precisely between close-ups of their vivid, joyful facial expressions and the wheels spinning so rapidly that they appear almost animate, against a backdrop of towering skyscrapers, their windows lit up, and flashing holographic billboards. The entire picture has a cold tone, mainly dark blue and black, but is illuminated by the neon lights of the unicycle and the warm lights in the distance, interspersed with slight, stylized digital screen flashes and lens flares that represent a sense of technology, creating a futuristic atmosphere that is free, cheerful and full of urban dynamism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4085,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000112/group_2/index_4817_seed_22843_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/083_0000112_group_2_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000112_group_2_sample_0_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+84,0.04105742,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.03295805,0.00391194,0.01936407,0.80253416,0.52086681,0.09667969,0.00256062,0000157,group_3,0,q5,"Is the background a clear, cloudless azure sky with distant beacon towers and weathered gray bricks beneath the knight's feet?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"An epic drone shot descends and circles from high above, finally stabilizing in a slightly upward-looking medium shot. It focuses on a lone knight standing atop the uninterrupted, imposing Great Wall. The knight's face is resolute, his brows etched into his temples. His long, jet-black hair is bound high up with a simple cloth sash, a few strands swaying gently in the mountaintop wind. He wears a flowing dark blue cotton and linen robe, its sleeves swaying in the wind. A wide leather belt cinches his waist, and he exudes a calm and powerful aura. Beneath his feet are weathered gray bricks and stones. The massive wall winds its way up and down the mountains like a giant dragon. In the distance, beacon towers loom in the clear air, against a backdrop of a cloudless, azure sky. He concentrated, his center of gravity lowered, his legs steady as a rock, as he practiced his swordsmanship with steady and deliberate precision. The sword in his hand moved with him, slicing through smooth, deadly arcs. Each wrist turn, chop, and retraction was impeccably precise, the blade emitting a subtle, sharp whistle as it sliced through the air. Body and sword seemed one. Under the intense, direct midday sun, the meticulously polished blade caught the light with each swing, instantly emitting a dazzling, icy radiance. This stark contrast between his focused expression and the weathered atmosphere of the ancient city walls created an atmosphere of solitary tranquility and a majestic, Zen-like quality imbued with martial arts.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,709,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000157/group_3/index_4415_seed_32587_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/084_0000157_group_3_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000157_group_3_sample_0_q5__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000157_group_3_sample_0_q5__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000157_group_3_sample_0_q5__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000157_group_3_sample_0_q5__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000157_group_3_sample_0_q5__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000157_group_3_sample_0_q5__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+85,0.04063186,foreground-background+between-flanked,4.40800000,2,0.01495160,0.00181115,0.00876030,0.79732573,0.59030724,0.06835938,0.00035292,0000026,group_9,2,q2,Does the robot move on three spindly metal legs?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with an erratic handheld tracking shot, the frame punctuated by digital noise and flickering like signal interference. The focus shifts rapidly between foreground and background, closely following a cuddly Disney Pixar-esque spherical robot. Its smooth, egg-yellow shell, a pair of enormous, digital blue eyes flashing wildly with utter terror, moves on three spindly metal legs, frantically darting through the ruins of a dilapidated biocontrol demonstration area. This area seems like an isolated island amidst a vast, gray wasteland, the sky a sickly, dim yellow. Countless thick veins of mutant plants, emitting an eerie purple and green bioluminescence, surge, entwine, and grow at a visible speed, as if alive, through the cracked ground and rusted debris of equipment. Each pulse of these veins causes the fluorescent light on their surface to flicker. The robot clumsily dodges a glowing vine that suddenly breaks out from the ground under its feet and almost trips. The whole scene forms a strong visual contrast between the cute character's terrified escape and the invasion of terrifying plants. Combined with the unstable lens and digital glitch effects, it successfully creates a unique, unsettling and weird contrast atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,422,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000026/group_9/index_4175_seed_2678_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/085_0000026_group_9_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+86,0.04056650,foreground-background+between-flanked,5.32000000,5,0.01387110,0.00165879,0.00814154,0.82341599,0.49858156,0.10937500,0.00043315,0000002,group_3,1,q5,Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion, low-angle shot zooms in on a city basketball court surrounded by a high, rusty barbed wire fence. In the center of the frame, two sweat-drenched teenagers engage in a fierce standoff. The boy in the foreground, with tanned skin and short, close-cropped black hair, wears a sweat-soaked, dark blue sleeveless basketball vest that clings to his heaving chest and muscular build. His jaw set, his eyes piercing like a hawk, he stands with his hands on his hips, leaning slightly forward in an aggressive stance. The other boy confronting him wears an equally drenched white vest, his bangs clinging to his forehead with sweat. His arms are crossed over his chest, his posture erect, his gaze firm and unyielding. The golden afterglow of the setting sun streams in at a sharp angle, filtering through the bars of the barbed wire fence and casting long, interlaced shadows on the cracked asphalt. The light outlines their youthful, powerful figures and illuminates every bead of sweat on their skin. The air seemed to freeze, the dilapidated red brick apartment building in the background became blurred, and all the focus was on the invisible space between the two teenagers, which was full of charge. Every breath in their chests and every silent exchange of eyes filled the whole scene with primitive competitive tension and a dramatic atmosphere that was about to break out.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,138,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_6174_seed_3011_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/086_0000002_group_3_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q5__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q5__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q5__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q5__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q5__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_3_sample_1_q5__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+87,0.04053635,opposite-across,2.38000000,5,0.03277197,0.00392007,0.01923460,0.69614655,0.43222767,0.12792969,0.00226849,0000016,group_4,0,q5,"During the forward launch, do the centipede's head and legs appear disproportionately magnified and blurred due to rapid movement?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Embracing the meticulously hand-painted aesthetic of Ghibli animation, a striking overhead fisheye lens places the viewer on the ground, facing a vibrant, multicolored, segmented giant centipede from Madagascar. It nestles in a humid, vibrant, fantasy forest floor, nestled against a backdrop of giant, mossy ferns and shimmering, exotic mushrooms. The exaggerated distortion of the fisheye lens causes these plants to curve and stretch toward the edge of the frame, forming an enveloping, dizzying dome of green. The centipede's carapace displays an intricate pattern of deep russet and bright orange. Each smooth segment reflects dappled light filtering through the gaps in the forest canopy, and countless pairs of yellow legs connect the segments, each in a frenzy of activity. First, its long, segmented body arches back sharply into a tense ""C"" shape, its massive, venom-gleaming black mandibules poised at the front. Then, in a flash, it launches its entire body forward with explosive speed, hurtling towards the camera. During this rapid movement, its head and maxillipedia are disproportionately magnified in front of the camera, as if they are about to break through the screen. Countless pairs of legs are frantically paddling in the air, forming a blurred afterimage. The entire picture is full of dynamic tension and a suffocating sense of oppression from the huge creature, perfectly reproducing the classic depiction of the awe and fear of natural forces in Ghibli animation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1728,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000016/group_4/index_2980_seed_5084_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/087_0000016_group_4_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000016_group_4_sample_0_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000016_group_4_sample_0_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000016_group_4_sample_0_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000016_group_4_sample_0_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000016_group_4_sample_0_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000016_group_4_sample_0_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+88,0.04020221,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.03021618,0.00361517,0.01773400,0.75374228,0.52369112,0.08203125,0.00108820,0000118,group_15,0,q5,Is the environment a living room featuring polished light oak wood flooring and a plush grey sofa?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, slightly low-angled medium shot depicts an intimate, sun-drenched moment in a living room, rendered in the surreal and emotive style of Makoto Shinkai. A young woman sits on the floor, her hair soft and shoulder-length, loosely tied back, her expression a blend of tender affection and focused concentration. She wears a comfortable, oversized cream sweater and light-wash jeans. In her right hand, she holds a small blue training clicker, her thumb deliberately resting on the button. Before her, a gorgeous golden retriever sits in perfect, focused posture, its entire body still except for its bushy, feathered tail, which sways uncontrollably and joyfully, rhythmically tapping the floor. Its intelligent black eyes are locked on the woman's face, a pink tongue peeks out in playful anticipation of a meal. The scene is bathed in the dramatic twilight of late afternoon sunlight, which slants through a large, clean window in thick, golden shafts, creating a brilliant lens flare effect. These rays illuminate a series of dancing dust motes suspended in the warm air, casting long, soft shadows across the room, delicately highlighting the detailed grain of the polished light oak wood flooring, the soft weave of the nearby plush grey sofa, and the vibrant green leaves of a potted plant on the windowsill. The overall palette is a symphony of warm golds, soft creams, and rich wood tones, creating a deeply nostalgic and welcoming atmosphere that captures the fleeting moments of perfect connection between people and their pets.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2630,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000118/group_15/index_4285_seed_30679_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/088_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+89,0.04004227,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.03012909,0.00360785,0.01768083,0.75246847,0.52267361,0.08203125,0.00106087,0000118,group_15,0,q2,Is a young woman sitting on the floor wearing a cream sweater and light-wash jeans?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, slightly low-angled medium shot depicts an intimate, sun-drenched moment in a living room, rendered in the surreal and emotive style of Makoto Shinkai. A young woman sits on the floor, her hair soft and shoulder-length, loosely tied back, her expression a blend of tender affection and focused concentration. She wears a comfortable, oversized cream sweater and light-wash jeans. In her right hand, she holds a small blue training clicker, her thumb deliberately resting on the button. Before her, a gorgeous golden retriever sits in perfect, focused posture, its entire body still except for its bushy, feathered tail, which sways uncontrollably and joyfully, rhythmically tapping the floor. Its intelligent black eyes are locked on the woman's face, a pink tongue peeks out in playful anticipation of a meal. The scene is bathed in the dramatic twilight of late afternoon sunlight, which slants through a large, clean window in thick, golden shafts, creating a brilliant lens flare effect. These rays illuminate a series of dancing dust motes suspended in the warm air, casting long, soft shadows across the room, delicately highlighting the detailed grain of the polished light oak wood flooring, the soft weave of the nearby plush grey sofa, and the vibrant green leaves of a potted plant on the windowsill. The overall palette is a symphony of warm golds, soft creams, and rich wood tones, creating a deeply nostalgic and welcoming atmosphere that captures the fleeting moments of perfect connection between people and their pets.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2632,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000118/group_15/index_4285_seed_30679_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/089_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+90,0.03990396,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.02729269,0.00323422,0.01603898,0.78284317,0.51513004,0.08789062,0.00139198,0000090,group_12,1,q3,"Is the main character an elderly man with a deeply wrinkled face, thinning white hair, and age spots on his hands?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly upward angle, the scene takes on a unique stop-motion quality. Each frame feels tangible, with tiny, almost imperceptible jumps between movements, imbuing the characters and objects with a handmade, slightly jerky, yet highly expressive quality. The image focuses on an elderly man with a deeply wrinkled face, his thinning white hair plastered against a weathered scalp, his eyes kind yet slightly weary. He stands in a dimly lit, sparsely furnished wooden house, set against a backdrop of rough, dark wood walls. A soft, warm light streams in through a small side window, vividly outlining every crease on his face and illuminating his plain, earth-brown linen shirt. With hands punctuated by age spots and bulging veins, he carefully, almost reverently, holds a simple, unglazed stoneware bowl, its surface rough to the touch, bearing the unmistakable marks of handcraft. Due to the slight but constant trembling of his hands, tiny ripples appeared on the clear water in the bowl, reflecting the faint light from the window. He slowly brought the rim of the bowl to his chapped lips, tilted his head slightly, and took a deliberate sip. The whole movement was imbued with the weight of time. The warm earth tones and strong contrasts of light and dark conveyed a sense of quiet dignity and a moving atmosphere of contemplation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,26,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000090/group_12/index_1727_seed_11841_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/090_0000090_group_12_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+91,0.03975930,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.03333645,0.00397592,0.01957369,0.71085680,0.44813800,0.12207031,0.00317883,0000144,group_2,3,q4,Is the boy shown tugging at his tousled black hair while his body trembles with frustration?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with a close-up of a wall clock, its hour and minute hands spinning at a visible speed, creating a series of blurry afterimages. The camera then smoothly pulls back to reveal a dimly lit children's study. At the center of the frame, a boy, approximately ten years old, wearing a blue and white striped T-shirt, hunched over a wooden desk piled high with textbooks and workbooks. He desperately tugs his hands into his tousled black hair, his fingers tugging at the roots, his body trembling with silent frustration. An old-fashioned desk lamp provides the sole source of light, its warm yellow glow illuminating the mess on the desk while casting long, deep shadows across the rest of the room. Behind him, a mother in a gray cardigan stands quietly at the edge of the shadows, her brow furrowed, her lips pressed into a serious line, her gaze darting back and forth intently at the thin report card in her hand. The scene creates a stark contrast between the rapid passage of time and the characters' frozen anxiety, creating a suffocating, stressful domestic atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3545,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000144/group_2/index_3703_seed_15964_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/091_0000144_group_2_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+92,0.03965269,beside-next-to,1.74000000,2,0.03794490,0.00449079,0.02230274,0.84248477,0.53655869,0.10351562,0.00289172,0000118,group_14,0,q2,Does the gloved hand glide across a pristine white cotton sheet to smooth out wrinkles?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"An extreme close-up focuses on a hand, clad in a thin, pale blue butyl glove, its fingers clasped together as it steadily and deliberately glides across the surface of a sheet of pristine white cotton. The camera captures the fabric's microscopic texture as the gloved hand meticulously smooths out the last faint wrinkles, rendering the sheet perfectly taut and flawless. As the motion is complete, the camera begins a slow, seamless pullback, gradually widening the frame. The shot reveals the entirety of the empty hospital bed, its metal side rails lowered and its frame constructed of cool brushed steel. The pullback continues, transitioning into a wide shot that reveals the surroundings of the sterile, silent room. The floor is a polished, light gray linen, faintly reflecting the harsh, even fluorescent light from overhead. The walls are a pale, institutional seaweed green, save for a single, silent IV stand standing beside the bed. The atmosphere is one of heavy clinical silence, a profound sense of order and cleanliness, creating a tranquil yet somber mood, impersonal and prepared.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4699,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000118/group_14/index_2314_seed_5810_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/092_0000118_group_14_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000118_group_14_sample_0_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+93,0.03933473,beside-next-to,1.98000000,4,0.03677486,0.00439597,0.02158592,0.70382220,0.45160562,0.11718750,0.00256115,0000033,group_0,0,q2,Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera moves forward at a slow, contemplative pace, passing through a dense, tranquil bamboo forest. Sunlight, filtered by the towering leaves, creates dappled shadows, gently swaying across the ground in the breeze. In front of the camera, a simple house, its whitewashed walls and gray tiles slightly weathered, looms deep within the forest. An ancient stone staircase, paved with natural stone and covered in emerald green moss, winds its way to the door. The slender green grass beside the steps sways gently in the breeze. As the camera steadily moves forward, past the stone steps, its focus finally settles on a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds beneath the door's lintel, swaying subtly in the air. Through the gaps in the curtains and the rolled-up parts, one can glimpse the dim and elegant scene inside the room: on a quaint dark wooden table, lies a guqin with a warm lacquer finish and distinct strings. Beside it are scattered several yellowed paper scrolls, some of which have been unfolded, revealing calligraphy in ink, while others are tied with ribbons. The whole scene presents a cool tranquility under the soft diffuse light, and is filled with a secluded, focused and poetic atmosphere of books. It seems as if one can hear the low voice-over ""Mountains are not famous for their height, but for the immortals who live there; water is not magical because of its depth, but for the dragons who live there..."" echoing in the air.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3405,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_113_seed_5468_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/093_0000033_group_0_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+94,0.03923167,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.03153165,0.00374326,0.01852560,0.80039239,0.52479601,0.09667969,0.00235468,0000057,group_13,1,q2,"Is the central subject an elderly man with a graying beard, sparse white hair in a bun, and deep wrinkles?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, depicts a world constructed in a refined pixel art style, with sharp, blocky edges. At the center of the frame is an elderly man with a graying beard and hair, his sparse white hair pulled back in a small bun. His face is lined with deep wrinkles, created by pixelated blocks, and his eyes are focused and serene. He wears a traditional dark gray coarse Chinese robe, its folds rendered with varying shades of gray. He stands in a quaint Chinese courtyard, his ground paved with bluestone slabs, interspersed between the cracks of the slabs with a profusion of golden and crimson pixelated fallen leaves. The elderly man is slightly bent over, his hands tightly gripping a long-handled bamboo broom—the handle rendered as a long string of brown pixels, the end of the broom a cluster of scattered yellow pixels. He methodically and unhurriedly swept the fallen leaves to one side. Each sweep was slow and rhythmic. The tip of the bamboo broom gently brushed the ground, sending pixelated leaves fluttering briefly in the air before gathering into a small pile. A soft, diffuse light evenly bathed the courtyard, devoid of harsh highlights, casting only soft, jagged, blocky shadows around the figures and the corners of the walls. The scene, dominated by earth tones and grays, was punctuated by the vibrant, warm colors of the fallen leaves, creating a tranquil and focused atmosphere that blended the nostalgia of retro gaming with the essence of Eastern Zen.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3734,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000057/group_13/index_7125_seed_23363_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/094_0000057_group_13_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000057_group_13_sample_1_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+95,0.03919458,left-right-pair,4.92000000,8,0.01428417,0.00169373,0.00839363,0.71983534,0.49138701,0.08300781,0.00067765,0000067,group_10,1,q4,Is the woman holding pointed metal tweezers in her right hand and pinching the skin above her eyes with her left hand?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a surreal, high-definition digital aesthetic, the film begins with a slow, graceful, doll-like movement, sliding horizontally across the magnificent, ornate facade of a sprawling limestone mansion. Soft, golden morning light casts long shadows across the intricate carvings and towering pillars, rendering every detail with crisp 4K clarity. As the camera continues its steady, uninterrupted path, it perfectly aligns with a spotless, large bay window, revealing a brightly lit, luxurious bathroom. Through the pristine glass, a woman with dark black hair pulled back into a sleek, elegant bun can be seen leaning against a large, ornate mirror. She wears a lustrous, blush-tinged silk robe, the fabric striking in its allure. She meticulously shapes her eyebrows with precise, deliberate movements, her expression intense and unwavering. In her right hand, she holds a pair of pointed metal tweezers, while with her left, she gently pinches the skin above her eyes. The soft morning light from the window and the warm, even glow from the bulb in the mirror-framed dressing table combine to illuminate the scene, creating a focused halo around her face, while the luxurious surroundings of white marble countertops, gleaming gilded fixtures, and crystal accents fade into the soft-focus background, establishing an atmosphere of quiet, personal ritual, and focused perfection.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,22,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_10/index_7152_seed_29973_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/095_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q4__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q4__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q4__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q4__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q4__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_10_sample_1_q4__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+96,0.03911883,opposite-across,2.78800000,9,0.02539934,0.00301083,0.01492567,0.75272822,0.47296450,0.10253906,0.00196457,0000009,group_4,1,q2,"Is a young man with shaggy black hair wearing a dark green cardigan visible, leaning forward at a large polished mahogany table?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot depicts a tense, silent confrontation in the hallowed quiet of a wood-paneled academic library. At a large, polished mahogany table, a young man with shaggy black hair leans forward, an impassioned look of frustration written across his face. Wearing a comfortable, dark green cardigan, they repeatedly gesture with their index finger to a tablet on the table. The tablet's screen emits a bright, cool digital glow, casting a stark blue light on their faces and hands, illuminating the complex data charts visible on the display. An older man seated opposite, dressed in a formal dark tweed blazer and a crisp white collared shirt, remains erect, his posture a wall of defiance. His silver-gray hair is impossibly neatly trimmed, his face a mask of resolute misunderstanding. He shakes his head slowly and stubbornly, his lips pressed into a thin line, his gaze deliberately averted, refusing even a glance at the glowing screen. The warm golden light from a classic green-shaded bank lamp on the table illuminates the scene, creating deep shadows that contrast with the cool glow of the tablet, visually emphasizing the generational and ideological clash. The background is filled with tall, dimly lit bookshelves filled with old leather-bound books, creating a heavy academic atmosphere, imbued with the weight of tradition and unspoken disagreements.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,541,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_4/index_5960_seed_20022_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/096_0000009_group_4_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+97,0.03890244,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.02931545,0.00351271,0.01720183,0.75034332,0.52375215,0.08203125,0.00107580,0000118,group_15,0,q3,Is a golden retriever sitting in front of the woman with its tail rhythmically tapping the floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, slightly low-angled medium shot depicts an intimate, sun-drenched moment in a living room, rendered in the surreal and emotive style of Makoto Shinkai. A young woman sits on the floor, her hair soft and shoulder-length, loosely tied back, her expression a blend of tender affection and focused concentration. She wears a comfortable, oversized cream sweater and light-wash jeans. In her right hand, she holds a small blue training clicker, her thumb deliberately resting on the button. Before her, a gorgeous golden retriever sits in perfect, focused posture, its entire body still except for its bushy, feathered tail, which sways uncontrollably and joyfully, rhythmically tapping the floor. Its intelligent black eyes are locked on the woman's face, a pink tongue peeks out in playful anticipation of a meal. The scene is bathed in the dramatic twilight of late afternoon sunlight, which slants through a large, clean window in thick, golden shafts, creating a brilliant lens flare effect. These rays illuminate a series of dancing dust motes suspended in the warm air, casting long, soft shadows across the room, delicately highlighting the detailed grain of the polished light oak wood flooring, the soft weave of the nearby plush grey sofa, and the vibrant green leaves of a potted plant on the windowsill. The overall palette is a symphony of warm golds, soft creams, and rich wood tones, creating a deeply nostalgic and welcoming atmosphere that captures the fleeting moments of perfect connection between people and their pets.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2631,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000118/group_15/index_4285_seed_30679_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/097_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000118_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+98,0.03886608,opposite-across,2.78800000,8,0.02294233,0.00273293,0.01347293,0.83892608,0.55170655,0.08007812,0.00133407,0000120,group_5,3,q3,Is the figure completely still with motionless hands in its lap and facing the windows?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"This static, eye-level medium shot captures a silent, translucent figure seated within an old train car, immersed in the calm, boundless expanse of the ocean. This ethereal entity is shrouded in a heavy, flowing black robe, the fabric seemingly absorbing the dim light, its face completely concealed by a smooth, featureless white mask with a subtle porcelain sheen. Its ghostly form, faintly visible through the worn crimson velvet seat behind it, remains completely still, its hands motionless in its lap, its masked face turned toward the large windows. The train car's interior, filled with dark, polished wood paneling and aged brass fixtures, contrasts starkly with the cool, azure glow filtering through the water outside. This aquatic light serves as the primary illumination, casting long, soft, and slowly moving shadows across the scene. The train is in steady reverse, and the dreamlike waterscape drifts backward past the windows in a hypnotic, painterly manner. Outside, surreal vistas of submerged crumbling ruins and ghostly kelp forests glide by, occasionally interrupted by shimmering passages of bioluminescent fish, each framed against the deep blue of the endless ocean to form a new, exquisitely rendered image. The profound silence, combined with the stillness of the characters and their backward journey through the submerged world, creates a powerful atmosphere of melancholic tranquility and a mystical introspective journey.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,623,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000120/group_5/index_9693_seed_7730_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/098_0000120_group_5_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000120_group_5_sample_3_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000120_group_5_sample_3_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000120_group_5_sample_3_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000120_group_5_sample_3_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000120_group_5_sample_3_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000120_group_5_sample_3_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+99,0.03885549,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+between-flanked,8.54000000,5,0.00740999,0.00089495,0.00434336,0.80228531,0.60435170,0.06640625,0.00044483,0000162,group_1,3,q5,Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2600,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18207_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/099_0000162_group_1_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q5__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q5__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q5__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q5__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q5__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q5__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+100,0.03851946,left-right-pair,3.72000000,3,0.01958794,0.00231002,0.01151861,0.80183852,0.46071509,0.12500000,0.00017074,0000018,group_1,3,q4,Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle and panning slowly to the right, captures a solitary dancer, lost in the ecstasy of a twirl in the center of a grand yet empty Baroque ballroom. Her long, dark brown curls are elegantly tied into a loose bun, a few strands of hair freed from their restraints as she spins, gently brushing against her serene face, eyes closed and a hint of a smile playing on her lips. She wears a deep, royal blue, sleeveless silk gown, the tight bodice emphasizing her slender waist. The massive, multi-tiered skirt, lifted high by centrifugal force as she steadily and effortlessly spun, pivoting on the toe of her left foot, unfolds like a fully blossoming blue flower, almost parallel to the ground, its pleats drawing graceful, undulating curves in the air. A massive crystal chandelier atop the soaring dome casts a warm, radiant golden light, illuminating the mirror-like polished marble floor, which reflects the dancers' twirling figures and the blurred motion of their skirts, as well as the intricate gold reliefs on the walls. Light filters through the swirling skirts, casting ever-shifting, interwoven patterns of light and shadow on the floor. The entire scene, bathed in warm hues, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, dreamy elegance, and a touch of solitary elegance.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4384,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000018/group_1/index_2695_seed_29088_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/100_0000018_group_1_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000018_group_1_sample_3_q4__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000018_group_1_sample_3_q4__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000018_group_1_sample_3_q4__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000018_group_1_sample_3_q4__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000018_group_1_sample_3_q4__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000018_group_1_sample_3_q4__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+101,0.03815556,between-flanked,2.36800000,6,0.02881631,0.00349939,0.01687794,0.80014145,0.50131851,0.11718750,0.00083932,0000170,group_5,2,q3,Is the young man standing motionless with his hands tucked deep into his pockets?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot depicts the solitary figure of a young man, Dojima, standing motionless on a deserted train platform at night. He has dark, slightly unkempt hair, his face tilted slightly upward, an expression of quiet, melancholic wonder. He wears a simple charcoal-gray hoodie over a T-shirt, his hands tucked deep into the pockets of his dark jeans. The platform itself, made of weathered concrete and empty save for a dark wooden bench, is bathed in the cold, sterile light of a single overhead lamp, which casts long, sharp shadows across the surrounding darkness. Above this silent scene, the universe is in awe-inspiring motion. In a dramatic time-lapse effect, the stars, rather than fixed points, become long, dazzling trails of light, arcing and swirling across the deep indigo canvas of the night sky. The visual contrast between the static, contemplative young man and the frenetic, silent ballet of the universe creates a powerful atmosphere of serene solitude and awe, capturing a single, poignant moment of human existence against the backdrop of cosmic eternity.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,787,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000170/group_5/index_6669_seed_7262_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/101_0000170_group_5_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+102,0.03793063,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.01469522,0.00175585,0.00862624,0.78254068,0.49592891,0.10156250,0.00067073,0000056,group_3,1,q3,Is the scene set before the Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain with a vast waterfall cascading down a towering cliff?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26610_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/102_0000056_group_3_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+103,0.03788269,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.01613061,0.00193753,0.00946206,0.70403874,0.50919622,0.07226562,0.00092480,0000132,group_7,0,q3,"Is an antique bronze wine jug visible beside the man, half-emptied on the mossy ground?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, zoomed-out shot, starting from a slightly upward angle, first focuses on a massive bluestone by the river, bathed in moonlight. The great Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai reclines, half-drunk and intoxicated. His long, dark hair, undone by a bun, a few wet strands clinging to his drunken face. His features are rendered with remarkable clarity by the cool moonlight. He wears a flowing white silk robe with wide sleeves, the collar slightly open, revealing faint stains of dark wine on the folds. The hem of the robe falls limply on the mossy stone surface. His eyes are lightly closed, a faint, detached smile playing on his lips. His body is relaxed, his chest rising and falling with his deep, steady breathing. Beside him, an antique bronze wine jug has fallen, half-emptied between the moist moss and soil. The last drops of wine seem to linger on the mouth, reflecting a faint glow in the moonlight. As the camera steadily and deliberately pulls back, a wider scene is revealed: the vast river, like a vast black jade in the still night, a bright full moon casts a clear glow in the sky, spreading a fragmented, shimmering silver band across the water. In the distance, the inky silhouettes of rolling hills shrouded in mist. Nearby, a few clumps of reeds sway gently in the night breeze, rustling softly. The entire scene exudes a sense of ultimate tranquility and poetic solitude. The dominant color palette is deep blue-black and silver-white, and the strong contrast of light and shadow creates an otherworldly, classical aesthetic atmosphere of detachment from the world.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2607,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000132/group_7/index_6699_seed_26356_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/103_0000132_group_7_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+104,0.03763194,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01707676,0.00205345,0.01001554,0.73292190,0.50744545,0.09667969,0.00091219,0000067,group_15,2,q4,Does the man extend a thick wad of banknotes from his left hand and place them into the open travel bag?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a medium, slightly upward angle, the camera pans steadily to the right, closely following the subject's movements. In the frame, a man in his thirties, with short, dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard, leans slightly forward, his expression focused and serious. He wears a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt, the sleeves casually pushed up to his elbows, revealing his muscular forearms. He is in a softly lit bedroom, with the corner of a bed covered in white sheets visible in the background. Steadily and deliberately, the man extends his right arm toward a blue nylon travel bag on the bed. The bag features black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper, half-unzipped. As the camera follows, the thick wad of banknotes clutched in his left hand becomes visible. He then carefully places the wad of bills into the bag's open mouth, his fingers delicately moving as he pushes the money deeper into the bag. The natural morning light filtering in from a side window casts soft shadows on his arm and the surface of the travel bag, highlighting the texture of the nylon and the thickness of the banknotes. The dominant color scheme of the entire scene is the vibrant blue of the travel bag, the dark gray of the man's clothing, and the white of the bed sheet, creating an atmosphere of focus, intimacy, and a touch of tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3298,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_15/index_3450_seed_7520_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/104_0000067_group_15_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q4__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q4__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q4__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q4__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q4__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q4__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+105,0.03755007,foreground-background+beside-next-to,4.88400000,4,0.01298200,0.00155180,0.00762014,0.76282269,0.54272264,0.06933594,0.00137722,0000052,group_7,0,q3,Is a man with a shaved head running beside the woman with visible tension in his calf and thigh muscles?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"glossy, eye-level camera relentlessly follows a large group of marathon runners, capturing the scene in stunning, surreal detail. The camera moves at their pace, placing a few distinct runners in the foreground with razor-sharp focus. A woman with a high, swinging ponytail, rosy-faced and focused, wears a bright yellow technical vest drenched in sweat. Beside her, a man with a shaved head and a focused expression, every tense muscle fiber in his calves and thighs visible with each powerful stride. Their outfits are a vibrant, chaotic mosaic of neon green, electric blue, and hot pink, all rendered with realistic textures. Their collective action is a thunderous, rhythmic thud against the asphalt of the broad city avenue, a unified forward wave, thousands of individual bodies moving as one undulating mass. Crisp, low-angle morning sunlight filters through the scene, gleaming on their foreheads and casting long, dynamic shadows as they run. In the background, the blurred forms of cheering spectators and city buildings streak by, enhancing the profound sense of speed and unstoppable momentum, creating an epic atmosphere rich in raw determination and human endurance.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1876,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000052/group_7/index_885_seed_21556_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/105_0000052_group_7_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000052_group_7_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000052_group_7_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000052_group_7_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000052_group_7_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000052_group_7_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000052_group_7_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+106,0.03749994,foreground-background,2.72800000,3,0.02175620,0.00268284,0.01271557,0.84119451,0.60828644,0.07519531,0.00249457,0000024,group_8,0,q5,"Does the scene feature a vast, cracked, desolate landscape with jagged rocks, dead trees, and a stormy sky?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a static, sweeping long shot, captured in strict adherence to Sebastián Salgado's signature high-contrast black-and-white style, a luminous ghostly express train glides silently across a vast, cracked, desolate landscape. The landscape is arid, its horizon broken by the silhouettes of jagged rocks and the twisted skeletons of a few dead trees, while above rises a stormy sky filled with thick, textured clouds. The train itself is a translucent, luminous object, its carriages composed not of solid steel but rather of shimmering outlines of pure white light. It exudes a soft, otherworldly inner glow, radiating against the inky blackness of the background. In the foreground, a lone, ethereal figure stands in silhouette, its form blurred, as if draped in a flowing robe that blends seamlessly with the shadows of the earth. Its arms are raised in a powerful, sweeping gesture, as if conducting a silent symphony, guiding the train majestically through the void. The entire scene is meticulously lit, with deep blacks swallowing up every detail in the shadows, while whites—particularly the train's glow and the highlights of the clouds—are dazzling, verging on overexposed. A fine grain of film adds a tactile quality to the image, creating an atmosphere of mythical grandeur, profound loneliness, and timeless epicness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1484,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000024/group_8/index_6551_seed_26442_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/106_0000024_group_8_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q5__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q5__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q5__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q5__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q5__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q5__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+107,0.03686988,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01759945,0.00210511,0.01032956,0.80035412,0.46852180,0.12500000,0.00082505,0000067,group_15,0,q4,Does the man extend a thick wad of banknotes from his left hand and place them into the open travel bag?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a medium, slightly upward angle, the camera pans steadily to the right, closely following the subject's movements. In the frame, a man in his thirties, with short, dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard, leans slightly forward, his expression focused and serious. He wears a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt, the sleeves casually pushed up to his elbows, revealing his muscular forearms. He is in a softly lit bedroom, with the corner of a bed covered in white sheets visible in the background. Steadily and deliberately, the man extends his right arm toward a blue nylon travel bag on the bed. The bag features black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper, half-unzipped. As the camera follows, the thick wad of banknotes clutched in his left hand becomes visible. He then carefully places the wad of bills into the bag's open mouth, his fingers delicately moving as he pushes the money deeper into the bag. The natural morning light filtering in from a side window casts soft shadows on his arm and the surface of the travel bag, highlighting the texture of the nylon and the thickness of the banknotes. The dominant color scheme of the entire scene is the vibrant blue of the travel bag, the dark gray of the man's clothing, and the white of the bed sheet, creating an atmosphere of focus, intimacy, and a touch of tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3292,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_15/index_3450_seed_7518_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/107_0000067_group_15_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q4__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q4__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q4__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q4__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q4__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q4__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+108,0.03642499,left-right-pair+foreground-background,6.86400000,4,0.01106311,0.00130182,0.00650753,0.65879142,0.40589589,0.13281250,0.00129968,0000039,group_9,1,q2,"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3798,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8143_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/108_0000039_group_9_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_9_sample_1_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+109,0.03642429,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.01416701,0.00169442,0.00831506,0.79660410,0.49635550,0.10546875,0.00044423,0000056,group_3,1,q4,"Does Sun Wukong thrust a golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front, causing the waterfall to distort?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2392,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26610_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/109_0000056_group_3_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q4__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q4__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q4__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q4__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q4__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q4__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+110,0.03613941,left-right-pair+beside-next-to,6.66000000,6,0.00926998,0.00114077,0.00541947,0.77986741,0.55740803,0.07910156,0.00086707,0000070,group_12,2,q3,"Is the male competitor on the right wearing a suit, has short black hair, and is interacting with a translucent holographic data screen?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slowly rotating, orbiting medium shot brings us into the core control area of a futuristic drone racing arena. Clad in explosive competitive cinematography, it focuses on two competitors battling side by side. The female competitor on the left, sporting a sleek, dark purple ponytail, wears immersive FPV (first-person view) goggles that half-cover her face, their lenses reflecting a dazzling stream of data. She wears a tight, black, high-tech racing suit with a neon blue circuit pattern. She leans forward slightly, her hands steady and decisive as she grips a complex multi-stick drone controller, her thumbs fine-tuning the joysticks with a speed barely tangible to the naked eye. Beside her, her male teammate, with slightly damp short black hair and a furrowed brow, is absorbed in analyzing a translucent holographic data screen floating before them. His fingers swiftly and deftly swipe and tap across the illuminated interface, adjusting performance parameters and flight path diagrams in real time. Behind them, on the huge circular track structure, other drones turned into blurred colorful light bands and flew by at high speed. The whole scene was illuminated by the cool light emitted by their equipment and the neon lights of the track, casting dynamic light and shadow on their focused faces, creating a tacit cooperation and highly tense competitive atmosphere in the high-speed confrontation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1263,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000070/group_12/index_642_seed_16435_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/110_0000070_group_12_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000070_group_12_sample_2_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000070_group_12_sample_2_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000070_group_12_sample_2_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000070_group_12_sample_2_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000070_group_12_sample_2_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000070_group_12_sample_2_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+111,0.03609859,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01564593,0.00190945,0.00915765,0.78797489,0.54993862,0.08984375,0.00212848,0000156,group_8,0,q3,Is the scene set on an elegant dark wood desk with a stack of heavy books faintly visible and blurred in the background?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera pans incredibly slowly to the right, delicately tracking the movement of a hand writing on an elegant, dark wood desk. The hand's slender fingers firmly and firmly grasp a delicate black fountain pen with a gold-rimmed barrel. Its gleaming metallic iridium tip glides effortlessly and steadily across a sheet of thick, off-white stationery, leaving behind a trail of evenly inked, dark blue cursive. At this moment, a soft, warm, slightly iridescent lens flare, as if carefully choreographed, slowly sweeps across the left side of the frame, grazing the moving metal tip and causing it to flare with a dazzling, fleeting brilliance. The light comes from a warm, off-screen desk lamp, casting a soft, focused beam that casts a subtle, shifting shadow on the paper. A stack of heavy books is faintly visible in the background, but completely blurred. The main colors of the entire picture are warm brown and beige, with dark blue ink and golden light on the tip of the pen as embellishments, creating an atmosphere of extreme tranquility, concentration and full of classical bookishness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4524,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000156/group_8/index_8685_seed_27925_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/111_0000156_group_8_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q3__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q3__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q3__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q3__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q3__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q3__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+112,0.03609544,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.02966803,0.00351239,0.01743709,0.72954100,0.48888159,0.08398438,0.00139886,0000138,group_5,0,q4,"Is the setting a narrow, winding alleyway in an ancient town with traditional Chinese houses featuring whitewashed walls and green-tiled roofs?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera follows a young man from a low angle, parallel to him, panning smoothly to the right to capture him as he briskly navigates the streets on his bicycle. The young man, with his short, slightly tousled dark brown hair fluttering gently in the breeze, wears a relaxed, cheerful smile. He wears a simple white cotton T-shirt over an unbuttoned olive green work shirt, slim-fit washed blue jeans, and classic white canvas shoes. He rides a retro-style city bike with a bright yellow frame, a brown leather seat and grips, and a beige canvas messenger bag hanging from the handlebars. He leans slightly forward, his hands resting effortlessly on the handlebars, his legs pedaling with a steady, rhythmic rhythm, propelling the bike smoothly forward over the uneven cobblestone road. They were walking through a narrow, winding alleyway in the ancient town, flanked by traditional Chinese houses with mottled whitewashed walls and green-tiled roofs. Verdant vines clung to the walls, and red lanterns occasionally hung from the eaves. The warm afternoon sun filtered through the gaps between the buildings above, casting dappled, playful shadows on the ground and on him. The dominant colors of the scene were the gray of the slate and the white of the walls, accented by the bright yellow of the bicycle, the green of the vines, and the colors of his clothing, creating a tranquil, leisurely, and nostalgic atmosphere full of the flavor of life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2475,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000138/group_5/index_3219_seed_17218_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/112_0000138_group_5_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+113,0.03604165,foreground-background,2.72800000,3,0.02498189,0.00298823,0.01466244,0.71131152,0.45429072,0.11718750,0.00256252,0000094,group_0,0,q3,"Is there a central group of pale figures, including one in a dark purple robe shouting with an agape mouth and contorted face?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures the tense scene, rendered in a clean, graphic animation style against a deep blue void. Thin, sharp white lines radiate outward from an invisible point off-screen, creating a stark web-like pattern that defines the abstract space. In the center, several pale figures gather. The leftmost figure, frozen in mid-shouting, their mouths agape, their faces contorted in pain in silent despair, clad in a heavy, dark purple robe. Just behind them, a second figure in a somber gray robe places a steady hand on the shouting figure's shoulder, a gesture of comfort or restraint, their own expression serious and focused. The relative stillness of the central group contrasts sharply with the surrounding chaos, as blurred, shadowy outlines race through the foreground and background, their forms blurred and ghostly. The lighting is harsh and cool, casting sharp shadows that highlight the pale tones of their skin against the saturated colors of their purple, pink, and gray robes, creating a dark and tense atmosphere that freezes a moment of high-stakes drama and emotional crisis.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1808,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000094/group_0/index_2342_seed_31533_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/113_0000094_group_0_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000094_group_0_sample_0_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000094_group_0_sample_0_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000094_group_0_sample_0_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000094_group_0_sample_0_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000094_group_0_sample_0_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000094_group_0_sample_0_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+114,0.03589333,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.00697866,0.00083367,0.00409666,0.69011652,0.43620405,0.11816406,0.00215840,0000008,group_14,1,q5,Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1521,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22138_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/114_0000008_group_14_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q5__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q5__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q5__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q5__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q5__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q5__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+115,0.03578768,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01542167,0.00188191,0.00902650,0.79803020,0.55667198,0.08984375,0.00234532,0000156,group_8,0,q1,Is a hand holding a black fountain pen with a gold-rimmed barrel visible writing on a sheet of paper?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera pans incredibly slowly to the right, delicately tracking the movement of a hand writing on an elegant, dark wood desk. The hand's slender fingers firmly and firmly grasp a delicate black fountain pen with a gold-rimmed barrel. Its gleaming metallic iridium tip glides effortlessly and steadily across a sheet of thick, off-white stationery, leaving behind a trail of evenly inked, dark blue cursive. At this moment, a soft, warm, slightly iridescent lens flare, as if carefully choreographed, slowly sweeps across the left side of the frame, grazing the moving metal tip and causing it to flare with a dazzling, fleeting brilliance. The light comes from a warm, off-screen desk lamp, casting a soft, focused beam that casts a subtle, shifting shadow on the paper. A stack of heavy books is faintly visible in the background, but completely blurred. The main colors of the entire picture are warm brown and beige, with dark blue ink and golden light on the tip of the pen as embellishments, creating an atmosphere of extreme tranquility, concentration and full of classical bookishness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4525,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000156/group_8/index_8685_seed_27925_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/115_0000156_group_8_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q1__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q1__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q1__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q1__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q1__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000156_group_8_sample_0_q1__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+116,0.03576357,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.03027776,0.00353853,0.01782615,0.76315576,0.43397784,0.12500000,0.00074571,0000072,group_13,0,q4,"Does the video show the actress raising the sword above her head and then slamming it down to the floor, creating white smoke at the point of impact?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"soft-focus, medium-length, static shot captures a behind-the-scenes rehearsal moment, rich with drama and authenticity. At the center of the frame is an enigmatic actress, clad in an intricate, gothic gown of black velvet and lace, embellished with silver thread embroidery at the hem and cuffs. Her cascading raven hair is streaked with striking strands of silver, and her face is delicately painted with smoky makeup and crimson lipstick. She is in a dimly lit rehearsal room, scattered with prop boxes and folding chairs. Spotlights slant from overhead, casting dappled light on the wooden floor. Her hands tightly grasp a massive, seemingly weighty, but in reality lightweight, prop blade. Its broad, dark silver blade is engraved with intricate runes. With the focus and power of a performer, she raises the prop sword high above her head, then, with a dramatic gesture, slams it down to the floor below. At the moment of impact, a pre-set, harmless white smoke erupted from the point of contact between the blade and the ground, swirling and spreading in all directions under the spotlight. However, at the completion of this epic moment, her expression, brimming with power just a moment before, instantly collapsed. She straightened her back, leaning back slightly, and let out a light, hearty laugh, a playful glint in her eyes, creating a captivating contrast between serious performance and relaxed authenticity.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1037,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000072/group_13/index_4902_seed_13352_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/116_0000072_group_13_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000072_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000072_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000072_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000072_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000072_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000072_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+117,0.03561241,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.03460318,0.00416565,0.02029169,0.67459112,0.42475605,0.12500000,0.00219572,0000162,group_3,2,q3,Is the background a boundless sea of white foam crashing against dark rocks with spray rising into the air?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"strikingly composed long shot, captured with a telephoto lens, holds the camera still, its focus fixed on a mournful aristocratic woman. She stands alone at the edge of a rugged, barren black volcanic cliff, clad in an intricately patterned silk kimono, embroidered with chrysanthemums and cranes in silver thread, symbols of both nobility and the transience of life. Behind her, the boundless, surging sea of white foam tumbles, its waves crashing again and again with thunderous force against the sharp, dark rocks at the cliff's base, sending a cascade of spray skyward. A harsh, low-angled light, like a stage spotlight, slices her profile from the side, casting deep, sharp shadows across her pale, delicate face, accentuating the sorrowful frown between her brows and the hollowness of her eyes. Wisps of wind-blown black hair brush against her cheeks, while the wide sleeves of her kimono rustle in the sharp, gusty wind. The entire scene presents the ultimate 1940s black-and-white film style. The strong dramatic contrast of light and shadow highlights the loneliness and despair of the characters. The picture has obvious graininess and silver salt texture, creating a grand, tragic and fatalistic visual atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4486,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000162/group_3/index_1838_seed_19274_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/117_0000162_group_3_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000162_group_3_sample_2_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000162_group_3_sample_2_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000162_group_3_sample_2_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000162_group_3_sample_2_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000162_group_3_sample_2_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000162_group_3_sample_2_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+118,0.03557963,between-flanked,2.36800000,6,0.02699248,0.00327709,0.01581026,0.80020076,0.50017375,0.11718750,0.00083965,0000170,group_5,2,q2,"Is the main subject a young man with dark, slightly unkempt hair wearing a charcoal-gray hoodie and dark jeans?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot depicts the solitary figure of a young man, Dojima, standing motionless on a deserted train platform at night. He has dark, slightly unkempt hair, his face tilted slightly upward, an expression of quiet, melancholic wonder. He wears a simple charcoal-gray hoodie over a T-shirt, his hands tucked deep into the pockets of his dark jeans. The platform itself, made of weathered concrete and empty save for a dark wooden bench, is bathed in the cold, sterile light of a single overhead lamp, which casts long, sharp shadows across the surrounding darkness. Above this silent scene, the universe is in awe-inspiring motion. In a dramatic time-lapse effect, the stars, rather than fixed points, become long, dazzling trails of light, arcing and swirling across the deep indigo canvas of the night sky. The visual contrast between the static, contemplative young man and the frenetic, silent ballet of the universe creates a powerful atmosphere of serene solitude and awe, capturing a single, poignant moment of human existence against the backdrop of cosmic eternity.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2751,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000170/group_5/index_6669_seed_7262_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/118_0000170_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000170_group_5_sample_2_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+119,0.03550840,left-right-pair,4.92000000,8,0.01328778,0.00159487,0.00779527,0.73089540,0.49103940,0.10058594,0.00146198,0000067,group_10,3,q2,"Is the scene set in a luxurious bathroom with white marble countertops, gilded fixtures, and crystal accents visible through a large bay window?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a surreal, high-definition digital aesthetic, the film begins with a slow, graceful, doll-like movement, sliding horizontally across the magnificent, ornate facade of a sprawling limestone mansion. Soft, golden morning light casts long shadows across the intricate carvings and towering pillars, rendering every detail with crisp 4K clarity. As the camera continues its steady, uninterrupted path, it perfectly aligns with a spotless, large bay window, revealing a brightly lit, luxurious bathroom. Through the pristine glass, a woman with dark black hair pulled back into a sleek, elegant bun can be seen leaning against a large, ornate mirror. She wears a lustrous, blush-tinged silk robe, the fabric striking in its allure. She meticulously shapes her eyebrows with precise, deliberate movements, her expression intense and unwavering. In her right hand, she holds a pair of pointed metal tweezers, while with her left, she gently pinches the skin above her eyes. The soft morning light from the window and the warm, even glow from the bulb in the mirror-framed dressing table combine to illuminate the scene, creating a focused halo around her face, while the luxurious surroundings of white marble countertops, gleaming gilded fixtures, and crystal accents fade into the soft-focus background, establishing an atmosphere of quiet, personal ritual, and focused perfection.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,564,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_10/index_7152_seed_29975_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/119_0000067_group_10_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+120,0.03512042,foreground-background,2.72800000,3,0.02215027,0.00268701,0.01297551,0.79455811,0.52243888,0.08984375,0.00044978,0000072,group_4,3,q4,Are the background elements stainless steel and glass vertical growth racks with exotic plants under purple and magenta LED lights?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"close-up shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly but steadily advances, first glimpsing a vast, bizarre plant leaf in the foreground. Its deep, dark green, velvety surface is covered with intricate, luminous veins, resembling circuit boards, faintly luminescent. As the camera deepens, focus gradually settles on an Asian model nestled within a futuristic greenhouse. Her face is sculpted, her long, wet black hair neatly combed back. Her eyes, cold and distant, stare blankly into the camera. She wears a couture dress crafted from a liquid metal silver fabric with dramatic, architectural shoulders, making her stand out against the backdrop. Behind her, rows of stainless steel and glass vertical growth racks display a variety of exotic plants, each a psychedelic display of vibrant colors under alternating purple and magenta LED grow lights. The lights pulsated in a slow and rhythmic rhythm, periodically sweeping across her expressionless face and the glittering surface of the clothing, casting ever-changing long shadows. The entire scene was shrouded in a cold tone, and the precise coldness of technology and the ultimate beauty of luxury fashion blended at this moment, creating a fashion blockbuster atmosphere full of mystery and visual impact.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3286,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000072/group_4/index_5809_seed_12050_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/120_0000072_group_4_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000072_group_4_sample_3_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000072_group_4_sample_3_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000072_group_4_sample_3_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000072_group_4_sample_3_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000072_group_4_sample_3_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000072_group_4_sample_3_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+121,0.03511101,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.03107945,0.00365268,0.01828451,0.78220695,0.44791448,0.12500000,0.00006670,0000050,group_14,1,q4,Is the general leaning over a rough wooden table examining a yellowed parchment map with red markers?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly but steadily advances, drawing the viewer's attention into a spacious military tent. The only illumination comes from the flickering flame of a candle in an antique bronze candlestick at the corner of the table, its unsteady glow casting large, oscillating shadows on the thick canvas walls. A general with a ruddy complexion and a thick, black beard leans over a rough wooden marching table. He wears a heavy, worn suit of dark red metal armor, the beastly patterns carved on his shoulder plates reflecting a dull luster in the firelight. His furrowed brow carves a deep, crisscross pattern on his forehead, and his hawk-like eyes stare intently at a yellowed parchment map spread out on the table. The map's intricate, ink-lined outlines of mountains, rivers, and military markings appear intricate. His gaze wasn't static, but moved slowly and carefully between several key red markers on the map. His hands, braced on the edge of the table, their knuckles white from exertion. His entire posture exuded strength and focus. The flickering candlelight cast bright highlights on his high cheekbones and nose, while deepening the shadows of his eye sockets and cheeks, adding depth to his resolute expression. The entire scene was warm and deep, imbued with ochre, brown, and dark gold, creating an atmosphere of solemnity and intense tension as a decision-maker grappled alone on the eve of a crucial battle.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,534,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000050/group_14/index_2691_seed_20353_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/121_0000050_group_14_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+122,0.03502177,opposite-across,2.24400000,4,0.02889440,0.00345368,0.01696047,0.71257150,0.46051809,0.11132812,0.00238281,0000136,group_2,2,q3,"Are three young friends visible sitting around the table, including a woman with long curly brown hair in an off-white sweater and a man in a dark blue hoodie with black-framed glasses?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slowly zooming in, slightly overhead, medium shot focuses on a warm, round wooden table where three young friends sit intimately around a steaming hot pot. In the center, a vibrant red oil-based broth simmers vigorously, bubbling with dried chilies and Sichuan peppercorns. A milky, clear broth in the other half gently steams. Rich, white steam rises under the warm yellow light of a chandelier, creating a soft halo. A woman with long, curly brown hair and wearing a loose, off-white knit sweater, her face a healthy, steamy flush, smiles cheerfully. Across from her, a man wearing black-framed glasses and a dark blue hoodie gestures and excitedly talks, drawing laughter from his friends. As the camera slowly approaches, a woman carefully picks up a crisp, red and white marbled beef roll with a pair of long wooden chopsticks and steadily and calmly dips it into the boiling red oil. The moment the meat touches the broth, a string of fine bubbles rises around it, and the color of the fresh meat quickly darkens. The table is laden with a variety of fresh ingredients—emerald green vegetables, tender white tofu, and exquisitely presented meats. The entire scene is filled with the laughter of friends gathering together and the warm and cozy atmosphere of life, creating an atmosphere of supreme comfort and intimacy.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,502,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000136/group_2/index_3596_seed_23276_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/122_0000136_group_2_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000136_group_2_sample_2_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000136_group_2_sample_2_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000136_group_2_sample_2_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000136_group_2_sample_2_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000136_group_2_sample_2_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000136_group_2_sample_2_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+123,0.03493714,beside-next-to,2.10000000,5,0.03073492,0.00359765,0.01809151,0.80645365,0.45937592,0.12500000,0.00002664,0000149,group_7,3,q5,Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"360-degree slow-motion doll gracefully rotates around a large, round, dark wooden table, polished to a soft patina by generations of use, situated in the center of a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, romantic glow of red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling beams, casting a warm golden light and creating gently dancing shadows. A multi-generational family gathers around the table, engrossed in the shared ritual of making dumplings. An elderly grandmother, her silver hair tied in an elegant bun and her face lined with wrinkles, demonstrates her pleating technique with nimble, practiced fingers. Beside her, a young mother dressed in a simple silk aoqun in a pastel green, her dark hair held up with a jade hairpin, smiles warmly as she assists her young daughter, her bright, curious eyes focused on the task. A father and grandfather, dressed in simple linen tunics, work quietly and intently, their larger hands moving with surprising gentleness. Their hands, smeared with white flour, moved in beautiful, near-perfect unisons, deftly scooping ground pork and chives onto thin, round wrappers, moistening the edges and pleating them into perfect crescents before lovingly placing them on bamboo plates. A gentle, contented smile graced each face, reflecting the light of the lanterns, creating an atmosphere of profound peace, familial affection, and a tranquil, joyful tradition. In the background, a carved wooden screen and hanging calligraphy scrolls added a touch of period authenticity, completing this intimate portrait of familial harmony.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3058,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000149/group_7/index_9979_seed_537_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/123_0000149_group_7_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000149_group_7_sample_3_q5__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000149_group_7_sample_3_q5__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000149_group_7_sample_3_q5__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000149_group_7_sample_3_q5__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000149_group_7_sample_3_q5__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000149_group_7_sample_3_q5__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+124,0.03460729,left-right-pair+beside-next-to,7.38000000,8,0.00934062,0.00111776,0.00548191,0.70341432,0.44355059,0.12402344,0.00298548,0000062,group_15,1,q4,Is a transparent observation window visible at the base of a tower showing white plant roots in nutrient solution?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"An immersive first-person camera advances at a slow and steady pace through a narrow corridor formed by towering hydroponic towers constructed of white composite materials. The scene is bathed in a soft, Vermeer-esque sidelight, pouring down from high on the left, illuminating each broad, fresh green leaf with an almost translucent quality. The delicate veins and shimmering water droplets on the leaves are clearly visible, imbuing them with vibrant life. This light also casts long, soft shadows on the right-hand tower wall and the ground. My gaze slowly descends, finally focusing on the base of one of the towers, where a transparent observation window reveals a tangled network of white plant roots immersed in nutrient solution. Right next to the root system, a small, floating holographic screen emitting soft blue light is flashing a real-time updated stream of life data - a heartbeat-like waveform and constantly changing numbers. My eyes are carefully and attentively inspecting it. The whole picture combines the precision of future technology with the tranquil aesthetics of classical painting, creating an atmosphere of focus, tranquility and hope.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,866,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000062/group_15/index_6641_seed_21717_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/124_0000062_group_15_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000062_group_15_sample_1_q4__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000062_group_15_sample_1_q4__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000062_group_15_sample_1_q4__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000062_group_15_sample_1_q4__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000062_group_15_sample_1_q4__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000062_group_15_sample_1_q4__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+125,0.03457611,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.07200000,4,0.00986217,0.00118952,0.00578177,0.79532206,0.53754091,0.08398438,0.00230077,0000105,group_14,2,q4,"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium close-up shot from a level angle, slightly handheld and imbued with a subtle sense of shakiness, instantly draws the viewer into the bustling and vibrant atmosphere of a wet market. At the center of the frame is an elderly woman with a wrinkled face and graying hair tied in a simple bun. Time has carved deep grooves into her tanned skin, but her eyes are remarkably sharp and focused. She wears a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock, the fabric defined by its distinct texture and soft creases from repeated washing. Standing before a vegetable stall piled high with vibrant greens, carrots dusted with fresh soil, and plump tomatoes, she leans forward slightly, extending her age-freckled right hand. With her index and middle fingers, she decisively indicates a price, her lips pursed as she speaks rapidly and forcefully to the vendor off-screen. In her left hand, she clutches a woven bamboo basket, its edges frayed. The tarpaulin overhead casts dappled shadows, while a few suspended incandescent bulbs emit a warm, dim glow, illuminating the dust and moisture floating in the air and creating a stark contrast between the vibrant colors of the vegetables and the dark clothing of the elderly woman. The entire scene, shrouded in warm tones, exudes an atmosphere both tense and full of life, perfectly capturing the uncompromising moments of everyday transactions.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1225,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_8676_seed_3868_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/125_0000105_group_14_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q4__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q4__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q4__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q4__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q4__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000105_group_14_sample_2_q4__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+126,0.03449390,beside-next-to,1.98000000,4,0.03433118,0.00410936,0.02014788,0.66754538,0.41394365,0.13378906,0.00239855,0000033,group_0,1,q3,Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera moves forward at a slow, contemplative pace, passing through a dense, tranquil bamboo forest. Sunlight, filtered by the towering leaves, creates dappled shadows, gently swaying across the ground in the breeze. In front of the camera, a simple house, its whitewashed walls and gray tiles slightly weathered, looms deep within the forest. An ancient stone staircase, paved with natural stone and covered in emerald green moss, winds its way to the door. The slender green grass beside the steps sways gently in the breeze. As the camera steadily moves forward, past the stone steps, its focus finally settles on a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds beneath the door's lintel, swaying subtly in the air. Through the gaps in the curtains and the rolled-up parts, one can glimpse the dim and elegant scene inside the room: on a quaint dark wooden table, lies a guqin with a warm lacquer finish and distinct strings. Beside it are scattered several yellowed paper scrolls, some of which have been unfolded, revealing calligraphy in ink, while others are tied with ribbons. The whole scene presents a cool tranquility under the soft diffuse light, and is filled with a secluded, focused and poetic atmosphere of books. It seems as if one can hear the low voice-over ""Mountains are not famous for their height, but for the immortals who live there; water is not magical because of its depth, but for the dragons who live there..."" echoing in the air.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1094,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_113_seed_5469_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/126_0000033_group_0_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+127,0.03420381,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.62000000,5,0.01358628,0.00161760,0.00797912,0.82424867,0.49483421,0.11328125,0.00015569,0000077,group_1,2,q2,Is the man wearing professional black headphones and a simple black T-shirt?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, medium-close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a man immersed in musical composition. He has short, dark brown hair and wears a pair of professional black headphones. He rhythmically and immersively nods his head up and down to the rhythmic music, his eyes slightly closed, his expression intensely focused. He is in a dimly lit recording studio, facing a complex professional mixing console, its surface densely packed with faders and illuminated buttons. His right hand's fingers move delicately and precisely across the control panel, carefully gripping a silver EQ knob between his thumb and index finger, steadily and deliberately adjusting it to find the perfect tonal balance. The only light comes from the multicolored LEDs flashing on the mixing console and the screens of the various devices in the background. These dynamic dots of light cast shifting shadows on his face, emphasizing his simple black T-shirt and his focused profile. The whole picture is based on deep dark tones, dotted with blue, red and green light emitted by the equipment, creating an intimate, passionate and creative atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3692,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000077/group_1/index_3928_seed_17716_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/127_0000077_group_1_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000077_group_1_sample_2_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+128,0.03368058,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.03391652,0.00407316,0.01989557,0.69839889,0.44764623,0.11718750,0.00273132,0000127,group_5,2,q2,Is one man wearing a flowing white robe with long hair tied by a jade hairpin?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low angle, follows closely behind, rapidly panning and tilting to capture the fierce confrontation between two men in ancient costumes. They stand on the edge of a steep, mist-shrouded mountaintop, a rolling sea of clouds at their feet. One man, clad in a flowing white robe, his long hair tied high with a simple jade hairpin, has a handsome face, his brow radiating a resolute determination. The other, clad in a dark blue suit, has a stern expression and eagle-like eyes. Their figures intertwine, their swords emanating countless arcs of silver light as they clash fiercely in the air, each block precise and powerful. The entire scene is imbued with the artistic charm of ink painting, employing a highly desaturated palette of varying shades of black, white, and gray, resembling a dynamic scroll painted on rice paper. Under the soft diffuse light, the rapid sword moves left ink-like afterimages in the air, and their fluttering clothes merged with the swirling clouds, creating an epic atmosphere of tension, loneliness and classical oriental aesthetics.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1410,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000127/group_5/index_2910_seed_1617_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/128_0000127_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000127_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000127_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000127_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000127_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000127_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000127_group_5_sample_2_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+129,0.03363431,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.03126258,0.00370833,0.01836951,0.81211358,0.50540489,0.10253906,0.00279611,0000148,group_4,0,q3,Is there a single strand of silver-white hair draped across a crisp white pillow near her face?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slightly high-angle close-up elicits a slow, gentle push-in, almost imperceptibly approaching the elderly patient sleeping in a sterile hospital bed. The patient is a woman, a single strand of fine silver-white hair delicately draped across a crisp white pillow, her face pale and serene. Her eyelids, thin and almost translucent, flutter with a subtle, rapid tremor, suggesting dreams flickering beneath the surface. She wears a standard-issue light blue cotton hospital gown, the fabric across her chest rising and falling with the shallow, rhythmic rhythm of her quiet breathing. The setting is calm and tranquil; the bed is neatly made with starched white sheets, and in the softly blurred background, the metal poles of an IV stand gleam in the cool, diffuse light filtering through from outside the camera. The overall color palette is desaturated, dominated by white, pale blue, and the cool gray tones of the room, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, quietness, and deep intimacy, focusing on the fragile and peaceful state of the sleeping figure.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1385,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000148/group_4/index_934_seed_30860_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/129_0000148_group_4_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000148_group_4_sample_0_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000148_group_4_sample_0_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000148_group_4_sample_0_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000148_group_4_sample_0_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000148_group_4_sample_0_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000148_group_4_sample_0_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+130,0.03330730,beside-next-to,1.98000000,4,0.03152201,0.00378523,0.01849119,0.69191462,0.44952220,0.11523438,0.00243586,0000033,group_0,0,q3,Is an ancient stone staircase covered in emerald green moss winding to the house door?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera moves forward at a slow, contemplative pace, passing through a dense, tranquil bamboo forest. Sunlight, filtered by the towering leaves, creates dappled shadows, gently swaying across the ground in the breeze. In front of the camera, a simple house, its whitewashed walls and gray tiles slightly weathered, looms deep within the forest. An ancient stone staircase, paved with natural stone and covered in emerald green moss, winds its way to the door. The slender green grass beside the steps sways gently in the breeze. As the camera steadily moves forward, past the stone steps, its focus finally settles on a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds beneath the door's lintel, swaying subtly in the air. Through the gaps in the curtains and the rolled-up parts, one can glimpse the dim and elegant scene inside the room: on a quaint dark wooden table, lies a guqin with a warm lacquer finish and distinct strings. Beside it are scattered several yellowed paper scrolls, some of which have been unfolded, revealing calligraphy in ink, while others are tied with ribbons. The whole scene presents a cool tranquility under the soft diffuse light, and is filled with a secluded, focused and poetic atmosphere of books. It seems as if one can hear the low voice-over ""Mountains are not famous for their height, but for the immortals who live there; water is not magical because of its depth, but for the dragons who live there..."" echoing in the air.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1093,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_113_seed_5468_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/130_0000033_group_0_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000033_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+131,0.03328015,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.02759908,0.00329969,0.01619960,0.70032007,0.45524016,0.10742188,0.00194257,0000065,group_13,0,q4,Are massive raindrops clearly visible as suspended transparent crystals reflecting light against a gray sky?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"grand, long, static shot places us on a desolate mountaintop shrouded in a torrential downpour. Shot in a stunning slow motion, the world seems frozen in time. At the center of the frame, a red-clad swordsman stands alone on the rugged, slippery rocks. He wears a rain-soaked crimson suit, the damp fabric clinging to his muscular frame, outlining his defined muscles. His long, dark hair, dampened by the rain, tangled strands plastered to his forehead and cheeks, highlighting his hawk-like eyes and furrowed brow, a fierce, untouchable aura woven between them. With a calm and resolute gesture, he slowly raises his arm, draws a gleaming ancient sword from his waist, and holds it firmly across his chest. During this process, every massive raindrop falling from the sky is clearly visible, like suspended transparent crystals, reflecting a faint light against the gray sky. Some slowly streak across the camera, while others collide and explode on his resolute face, scarlet clothes, and the mirror-like blade of his sword, splashing out circles of miniature, crystal-clear water crowns. The entire scene is gloomy, with only that hint of red, like a burning flame, forming a sharp contrast with the cold rain and gray rocks, creating a lonely, tense, and epic atmosphere of fate.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2841,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000065/group_13/index_2062_seed_32649_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/131_0000065_group_13_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000065_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000065_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000065_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000065_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000065_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000065_group_13_sample_0_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+132,0.03273951,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.00663634,0.00078804,0.00389887,0.77359104,0.47721198,0.12011719,0.00267798,0000037,group_5,1,q3,Does the woman sweep the floor using a traditional straw broom with a long worn wooden handle?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2712,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4757_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/132_0000037_group_5_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+133,0.03258447,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.00520585,0.00061939,0.00305764,0.80047923,0.58418876,0.06250000,0.00110358,0000008,group_14,1,q3,Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4455,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22138_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/133_0000008_group_14_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_1_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+134,0.03235394,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.02663603,0.00321575,0.01561352,0.75093490,0.54776841,0.06640625,0.00001466,0000078,group_15,2,q3,"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focuses squarely on the awed face of a young woman dressed in traditional shrine maiden garb. She stands quietly at the wooden steps of an ancient shrine, her long, flowing, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband, strands brushing against her fair cheeks in the night breeze. The cool moonlight frames her delicate profile. Her head tilted slightly, her lips parted in wonder, her eyes, as clear as deep pools, gaze at the abyss of the night sky. Within these eyes, a magnificent meteor shower is perfectly reflected: countless fleeting, slender, brilliant arcs of silver light streak across her pupils, slightly dilated with concentration, as if the entire galaxy were ablaze in her gaze. Her pristine white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama take on a solemn yet soft quality in the dim light, while the shrine's architectural outlines and hanging stone lanterns behind her are completely blurred, transforming into a dreamy, softly shimmering backdrop composed of warm yellow dots. The entire image, shrouded in profound tranquility, exudes a sacred and ethereal beauty of classical Oriental beauty, capturing a poetic moment of dialogue between humanity and the universe.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4845,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000078/group_15/index_4060_seed_5020_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/134_0000078_group_15_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+135,0.03233991,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.02796434,0.00334842,0.01641062,0.69681567,0.43226746,0.12597656,0.00276637,0000035,group_14,1,q3,Is an elderly man with sparse white hair lying on the bed under a thick old quilt with eyes closed?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily advances, drawing the viewer's gaze into a dimly lit, quaint bedroom. A thin, worried-looking young strategist, his long, dark hair simply tied back with a wooden hairpin, leans over a sickbed. He wears a dark gray, rough cotton and linen robe, the sleeves carefully rolled up to the elbows, revealing his bony arms. On the bed, an elderly man with a haggard face and sparse white hair lies, his eyes closed, covered by a thick, old quilt, breathing shallowly. The strategist cautiously extends his right hand and gently places his index and middle fingers on the man's bony wrist, intensely feeling the faint beat of his pulse. His furrowed brow and tightly pursed lips convey a profound sense of worry and concentration. The sole illumination comes from a flickering oil lamp by the bedside, its dim glow casting deep shadows on his thin face, creating a striking contrast between light and dark. The entire scene is blanketed in a thick, cinematic layer of film grain and high noise, imparting a distinctly retro feel. Meanwhile, the sharpened pixels precisely capture every subtle movement and concerned expression, creating an atmosphere of solemnity, tension, and humane care.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000035/group_14/index_6476_seed_4006_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/135_0000035_group_14_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+136,0.03218240,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.09200000,3,0.01452479,0.00172006,0.00853649,0.75906390,0.47597289,0.10253906,0.00184357,0000093,group_6,2,q3,Are scattered withered bodhi leaves visible on the stone floor and stone lanterns carved with lotus patterns present in the background?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, drawn-out shot, beginning with a delicately composed, slightly upward mid-shot, focuses on the depths of an ancient temple courtyard. An elderly monk, bald and deeply wrinkled between his forehead and eyes, wears a soft, naturally wrinkled ochre-red robe, faded by time. He stands tall, his face solemn and serene. In one hand, he holds a string of dark Buddhist beads, while the other hangs naturally at his side. His gaze is determined and compassionate. Opposite him, a massive white snake, its entire body coated in a soft, ivory sheen, raises its head high, reaching the monk's eye level. Its golden, vertical pupils convey no hint of murderous intent, but rather a glimmer of ancient, human wisdom. The snake's body coils tightly on the mossy stone floor, dotted with scattered, withered bodhi leaves, imbued with a sense of poised power. The afternoon sun filters through the twisted branches of the ancient pines in the courtyard, casting dappled light and shadow, perfectly outlining the monk's silhouette and the texture of his robes, while also causing the giant snake's scales to reflect a pearly shimmer. As the camera steadily and deliberately moves backward, the figures of the two men and the snake gradually diminish within the magnificent temple setting. In the background, stone lanterns carved with lotus patterns, quaint wooden corridors, and a corner of the hall with its soaring eaves and brackets slowly come into view. The entire scene, shrouded in the subtle scent of sandalwood, creates a tranquil atmosphere that transcends time, imbued with Zen and a mysterious tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3636,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000093/group_6/index_3519_seed_6356_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/136_0000093_group_6_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+137,0.03200694,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01544940,0.00184296,0.00907096,0.79067910,0.46133697,0.12500000,0.00094229,0000067,group_15,0,q3,Is there a blue nylon travel bag with black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper visible on a bed with white sheets?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a medium, slightly upward angle, the camera pans steadily to the right, closely following the subject's movements. In the frame, a man in his thirties, with short, dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard, leans slightly forward, his expression focused and serious. He wears a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt, the sleeves casually pushed up to his elbows, revealing his muscular forearms. He is in a softly lit bedroom, with the corner of a bed covered in white sheets visible in the background. Steadily and deliberately, the man extends his right arm toward a blue nylon travel bag on the bed. The bag features black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper, half-unzipped. As the camera follows, the thick wad of banknotes clutched in his left hand becomes visible. He then carefully places the wad of bills into the bag's open mouth, his fingers delicately moving as he pushes the money deeper into the bag. The natural morning light filtering in from a side window casts soft shadows on his arm and the surface of the travel bag, highlighting the texture of the nylon and the thickness of the banknotes. The dominant color scheme of the entire scene is the vibrant blue of the travel bag, the dark gray of the man's clothing, and the white of the bed sheet, creating an atmosphere of focus, intimacy, and a touch of tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1041,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_15/index_3450_seed_7518_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/137_0000067_group_15_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+138,0.03200318,opposite-across,2.78800000,8,0.01821429,0.00220989,0.01066960,0.82841957,0.61061096,0.07031250,0.00053680,0000096,group_14,3,q5,"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, horizontal, medium shot, shot from behind, captures a man with slightly disheveled gray hair, wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater. He sits alone in a high-backed leather armchair, his back to the camera, facing a large arched window. Outside, dusk falls, and a gentle rain silently drizzles across the glass. His study is surrounded by towering, dark wooden bookshelves, crammed with ancient books of varying thickness, bound in leather or cloth. Some books are even haphazardly stacked on the floor and on the corners of the table. The man leans forward slightly, his elbows resting on his knees, his hands clasped before him, his head slightly lowered, his entire body almost motionless, completely absorbed in his thoughts. The cool twilight filtering in from the window serves as the primary light source, softly outlining his shoulders and head. Farther back, a small desk lamp casts a warm, orange glow, illuminating the gilded lettering on the book spines. The entire scene is dominated by deep wood tones and cool blue, dotted with warm lights, creating an academic atmosphere of extreme tranquility, concentration, contemplation, and a hint of melancholy.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,836,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000096/group_14/index_40_seed_28271_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/138_0000096_group_14_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000096_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000096_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000096_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000096_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000096_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000096_group_14_sample_3_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+139,0.03186210,left-right-pair,4.92000000,8,0.01303275,0.00155506,0.00765179,0.67107868,0.42014968,0.12011719,0.00138336,0000067,group_10,0,q4,Is the woman holding pointed metal tweezers in her right hand and pinching the skin above her eyes with her left hand?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a surreal, high-definition digital aesthetic, the film begins with a slow, graceful, doll-like movement, sliding horizontally across the magnificent, ornate facade of a sprawling limestone mansion. Soft, golden morning light casts long shadows across the intricate carvings and towering pillars, rendering every detail with crisp 4K clarity. As the camera continues its steady, uninterrupted path, it perfectly aligns with a spotless, large bay window, revealing a brightly lit, luxurious bathroom. Through the pristine glass, a woman with dark black hair pulled back into a sleek, elegant bun can be seen leaning against a large, ornate mirror. She wears a lustrous, blush-tinged silk robe, the fabric striking in its allure. She meticulously shapes her eyebrows with precise, deliberate movements, her expression intense and unwavering. In her right hand, she holds a pair of pointed metal tweezers, while with her left, she gently pinches the skin above her eyes. The soft morning light from the window and the warm, even glow from the bulb in the mirror-framed dressing table combine to illuminate the scene, creating a focused halo around her face, while the luxurious surroundings of white marble countertops, gleaming gilded fixtures, and crystal accents fade into the soft-focus background, establishing an atmosphere of quiet, personal ritual, and focused perfection.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,21,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_10/index_7152_seed_29972_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/139_0000067_group_10_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+140,0.03185419,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.01277519,0.00156690,0.00747219,0.80032188,0.58502090,0.07226562,0.00249594,0000112,group_13,0,q2,"Is Oliver, a young boy with tousled blond hair and a blue and white striped T-shirt, sitting cross-legged on a red and white checkered picnic blanket?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level, medium-wide shot captures the sheer enchantment of a sun-dappled forest clearing. Oliver, a young boy with tousled blond hair and a simple blue and white striped T-shirt, sits cross-legged on a red and white checkered picnic blanket. Next to him sits Sparky, a fluffy golden retriever puppy, his head tilted in curiosity, his tail gently tapping the soft grass. Nearby sits a family of four rabbits: a large brown dad, a gentle white mom, and two small, furry gray bunnies. Between them stands a whimsical tea party, featuring a miniature ceramic tea set with pastel pink, sky blue, and lemon yellow teacups. Oliver, with a look of focused joy on his face, is in action, steadily and deliberately pouring imaginary tea from a small white teapot into a tiny cup, carefully held between the paws of a small rabbit. Another bunny nibbles at a heart-shaped cookie on a central plate, which also contains delicately sliced carrot sticks. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, which filters through the lush green canopy above, creating a beautiful play of light and shadow. The atmosphere is tranquil, warm and whimsical, a magical moment of friendship between children, pets and gentle woodland creatures.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,208,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000112/group_13/index_9147_seed_8076_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/140_0000112_group_13_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q2__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q2__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q2__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q2__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q2__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q2__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+141,0.03179131,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.02274103,0.00272204,0.01334599,0.81579614,0.59724814,0.07031250,0.00017533,0000117,group_9,1,q4,Is the man holding a white crane feather fan in his right hand and waving it with a steady rhythm?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a thin, middle-aged strategist with a neatly trimmed goatee, nestled within a dimly lit military tent. He wears a loose, flowing dark blue silk robe, his long hair held back with a simple wooden hairpin. He reclines leisurely on an antique carved wooden chair. The only illumination comes from a bronze oil lamp on a table beside him. Its flickering, warm yellow light casts deep, undulating shadows on his face, emphasizing his pensive expression and illuminating the folds of his silk robe with a soft sheen. In his right hand, he grasps a feather fan made of pure white crane feathers, gently waving it with a steady, leisurely rhythm, the breeze occasionally causing the lamplight to flicker. In the background, a military map hangs on the thick dark canvas tent wall, and a wooden weapons rack with unfolded bamboo slips and weapons can be vaguely seen next to it. The whole scene has a warm tone, mainly deep dark colors, creating an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tranquility and strategic planning against the backdrop of military tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3119,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000117/group_9/index_9345_seed_1224_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/141_0000117_group_9_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+142,0.03170347,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.01281089,0.00153627,0.00751641,0.76649982,0.46951902,0.11328125,0.00008118,0000056,group_3,3,q3,Is the scene set before the Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain with a vast waterfall cascading down a towering cliff?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26612_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/142_0000056_group_3_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+143,0.03161452,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.02889514,0.00342865,0.01697766,0.80542272,0.52512014,0.09472656,0.00205690,0000128,group_6,0,q3,Is the cyclist a young woman with brown hair in a messy bun wearing a blue and white striped long-sleeved shirt?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic low-angle tracking shot glides smoothly alongside a cyclist, capturing her energetic movements along a classic Parisian cobblestone street, the camera keeping pace with her rapid progress. The cyclist is a young woman, her brown hair pulled back in a slightly messy bun, with a few strands escaping and dancing in the wind. Dressed in a timeless blue and white striped long-sleeved shirt and dark pants, she leans forward over the handlebars of her vintage bicycle, striking a focused pose. Her legs beat in a powerful, steady rhythm, her body swaying slightly with the effort, the wheel bouncing gently on the uneven, time-worn stones of the street. In the background, the majestic Eiffel Tower looms majestically, its iconic grid structure dominating the upper frame, slightly softened by the golden haze of a sunny afternoon. The bright, warm sunlight casts long, dancing shadows and creates subtle lens flares, bathing the entire scene in a vibrant golden light, evoking a joyful and exciting atmosphere of freedom.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1556,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000128/group_6/index_4822_seed_14380_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/143_0000128_group_6_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000128_group_6_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000128_group_6_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000128_group_6_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000128_group_6_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000128_group_6_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000128_group_6_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+144,0.03144750,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.02187685,0.00259570,0.01285410,0.79520553,0.52165985,0.09570312,0.00135303,0000090,group_12,1,q4,"Is the man holding a simple, unglazed stoneware bowl containing clear water that shows tiny ripples?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly upward angle, the scene takes on a unique stop-motion quality. Each frame feels tangible, with tiny, almost imperceptible jumps between movements, imbuing the characters and objects with a handmade, slightly jerky, yet highly expressive quality. The image focuses on an elderly man with a deeply wrinkled face, his thinning white hair plastered against a weathered scalp, his eyes kind yet slightly weary. He stands in a dimly lit, sparsely furnished wooden house, set against a backdrop of rough, dark wood walls. A soft, warm light streams in through a small side window, vividly outlining every crease on his face and illuminating his plain, earth-brown linen shirt. With hands punctuated by age spots and bulging veins, he carefully, almost reverently, holds a simple, unglazed stoneware bowl, its surface rough to the touch, bearing the unmistakable marks of handcraft. Due to the slight but constant trembling of his hands, tiny ripples appeared on the clear water in the bowl, reflecting the faint light from the window. He slowly brought the rim of the bowl to his chapped lips, tilted his head slightly, and took a deliberate sip. The whole movement was imbued with the weight of time. The warm earth tones and strong contrasts of light and dark conveyed a sense of quiet dignity and a moving atmosphere of contemplation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2519,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000090/group_12/index_1727_seed_11841_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/144_0000090_group_12_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000090_group_12_sample_1_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+145,0.03119516,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.03358585,0.00400092,0.01972328,0.62447017,0.39662495,0.12792969,0.00095528,0000136,group_0,3,q4,"Does the scene transition from the queen's eyes closed to her opening them to reveal icy blue, hawk-like eyes?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, focusing on a queen. A magnificent, heavy golden crown, inlaid with crimson gems and intricate baroque carvings, weighed heavily on her forehead. A few cascading strands of raven hair cascaded from the crown's edge, draping around her pale, sharply defined face. She wore a deep purple velvet gown with intricate silver embroidery at the collar, which shimmered faintly in the dim light. Her setting was a grand but dimly lit Gothic palace hall, the only faint light coming from the cool moonlight filtering through the distant high windows and the flickering flames of a few candles in silver candlesticks beside her, casting long, twisted shadows on the massive stone pillars in the background. At first, her eyes were closed, her face calm, yet a subtle hint of fatigue lingered. Then, slowly, with an almost palpable weight, she lifted her long lashes. The warm candlelight traced a soft golden edge along the contours of her cheeks. When her eyes fully opened, a pair of icy blue, hawk-like eyes were revealed. Their gaze, without a trace of hesitation, pierced the camera directly and resolutely. The entire scene, interwoven with the cold moonlight and the warm candlelight, was filled with a solemn, awe-inspiring, and powerful atmosphere, as if a silent storm was brewing in the midst of her decision.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4603,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000136/group_0/index_8451_seed_20632_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/145_0000136_group_0_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000136_group_0_sample_3_q4__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000136_group_0_sample_3_q4__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000136_group_0_sample_3_q4__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000136_group_0_sample_3_q4__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000136_group_0_sample_3_q4__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000136_group_0_sample_3_q4__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+146,0.03114325,left-right-pair+foreground-background,6.86400000,4,0.00899928,0.00105363,0.00529710,0.64201099,0.42374483,0.10156250,0.00124902,0000039,group_9,3,q2,"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3802,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8145_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/146_0000039_group_9_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+147,0.03076691,foreground-background,2.72800000,3,0.01797983,0.00221840,0.01050762,0.84239489,0.60926056,0.07519531,0.00249881,0000024,group_8,0,q4,"Is a lone, blurred, ethereal figure standing in silhouette in the foreground with raised arms?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a static, sweeping long shot, captured in strict adherence to Sebastián Salgado's signature high-contrast black-and-white style, a luminous ghostly express train glides silently across a vast, cracked, desolate landscape. The landscape is arid, its horizon broken by the silhouettes of jagged rocks and the twisted skeletons of a few dead trees, while above rises a stormy sky filled with thick, textured clouds. The train itself is a translucent, luminous object, its carriages composed not of solid steel but rather of shimmering outlines of pure white light. It exudes a soft, otherworldly inner glow, radiating against the inky blackness of the background. In the foreground, a lone, ethereal figure stands in silhouette, its form blurred, as if draped in a flowing robe that blends seamlessly with the shadows of the earth. Its arms are raised in a powerful, sweeping gesture, as if conducting a silent symphony, guiding the train majestically through the void. The entire scene is meticulously lit, with deep blacks swallowing up every detail in the shadows, while whites—particularly the train's glow and the highlights of the clouds—are dazzling, verging on overexposed. A fine grain of film adds a tactile quality to the image, creating an atmosphere of mythical grandeur, profound loneliness, and timeless epicness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4352,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000024/group_8/index_6551_seed_26442_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/147_0000024_group_8_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000024_group_8_sample_0_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+148,0.03046522,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.80800000,6,0.00820394,0.00098051,0.00481563,0.71976864,0.49778813,0.09179688,0.00156567,0000123,group_11,0,q1,"Is the main subject a woman with long, dark brown hair tied in a high ponytail?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot in a surreal style, this slow, orbiting medium shot smoothly orbits a woman going about her morning activities in a lush garden at dawn. She has long, dark brown hair, loosely tied in a high ponytail, with a few stray strands gently framing her face. Her eyes are gently closed, her expression serene and focused. She wears a fitted, long-sleeved heather-gray yoga top, the soft, breathable fabric subtly textured, paired with high-waisted, dark teal leggings. Her body gracefully stands in side bend; her right arm extends deliberately and fluidly upward and over her head, elongating her torso, while her left hand rests lightly on her hip. The entire pose maintains a steady, controlled grace. The camera's slow, circular path reveals the immersive environment: she stands barefoot on a manicured lawn, still damp with morning dew. The garden is filled with vibrant green ferns and blooming rose bushes with soft, pink and white petals. The first rays of warm, golden sunlight penetrate the light morning mist between the leaves of the tall, mature trees in the background, backlighting her body and capturing millions of tiny, shimmering dewdrops on the grass and leaves, creating a shimmering bokeh effect. The interplay of warm, low-angle light and cool, soft shadows creates a serene scene of profound calm and focus, and the camera movement enhances the contemplative and visually rich atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2626,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000123/group_11/index_7140_seed_22005_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/148_0000123_group_11_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000123_group_11_sample_0_q1__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000123_group_11_sample_0_q1__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000123_group_11_sample_0_q1__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000123_group_11_sample_0_q1__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000123_group_11_sample_0_q1__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000123_group_11_sample_0_q1__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+149,0.03024125,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.02348336,0.00278977,0.01379573,0.78754413,0.51335561,0.09472656,0.00134003,0000050,group_11,3,q4,Is the man using a crude crutch carved from a tree branch to support himself?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld camera, shot from a slightly elevated angle, follows a ragged elderly man as he walks down a muddy, rain-soaked country road. His sparse, short, graying hair is ruffled by the cold wind. His bronzed face is etched with deep, knife-like wrinkles, and his sunken eyes hold a gaze that is a mixture of fatigue and steeliness. He wears a faded, frayed dark blue Mao suit, the hems and cuffs ripped. He wears a gray shirt underneath, the collar yellowed, and his equally worn, dark trousers are splattered with damp mud. Under the gloomy evening sky, the thick clouds cast a faint, cold, scattered light, casting a chilling gray-brown hue on the entire scene. His steps were heavy and unsteady, each one sinking deeply into the sticky mud. Pulling out his stick was incredibly laborious, his body swaying from side to side, struggling to maintain balance with a crude crutch carved from a tree branch, tightly clenched in one hand. The road flanked by bleak winter fields, bare branches trembling slightly in the wind. The entire scene is imbued with a raw documentary quality, devoid of embellishment, focused solely on capturing every step of the old man's struggle against adversity, conveying a poignant, authentic, and resilient atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2696,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000050/group_11/index_3100_seed_11389_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/149_0000050_group_11_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+150,0.03021974,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,10.29600000,4,0.00550760,0.00066077,0.00323122,0.68641597,0.47096634,0.08691406,0.00080520,0000008,group_14,3,q2,Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4460,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22140_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/150_0000008_group_14_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000008_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+151,0.03009680,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.58800000,6,0.01282439,0.00153839,0.00752400,0.69777012,0.44804510,0.11718750,0.00228921,0000112,group_2,2,q2,Is the man on the left wearing a black hoodie with reflective silver stripes and has shaggy black hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic, low-angle, tracking shot, close to the ground, follows two young men as they effortlessly glide across a futuristic city square at dusk on their electric unicycles. The young man on the left, with shaggy black hair and a tech-fabric black hoodie with reflective silver stripes on the sleeves, wears a broad smile. The young woman next to him, with her long, bright pink hair tied in a high ponytail, throws her head back in a sleek white bomber jacket and laughs heartily. The unicycles they ride are matte black, their futuristic LED strips emitting brilliant cyan and magenta light on either side, casting vibrant reflections on the polished dark stone floor, leaving long trails of light as the wheels spin at breakneck speed. The camera switches focus swiftly and precisely between close-ups of their vivid, joyful facial expressions and the wheels spinning so rapidly that they appear almost animate, against a backdrop of towering skyscrapers, their windows lit up, and flashing holographic billboards. The entire picture has a cold tone, mainly dark blue and black, but is illuminated by the neon lights of the unicycle and the warm lights in the distance, interspersed with slight, stylized digital screen flashes and lens flares that represent a sense of technology, creating a futuristic atmosphere that is free, cheerful and full of urban dynamism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4089,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000112/group_2/index_4817_seed_22845_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/151_0000112_group_2_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q2__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q2__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q2__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q2__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q2__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q2__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+152,0.02994447,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.02752340,0.00331669,0.01613780,0.67418945,0.43202841,0.12304688,0.00256872,0000134,group_15,1,q3,"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with a slow, upward tilt, close-up shot of a yellowed ancient book spread out on a dark wooden desk. The texture of the paper is clearly visible, and vertical regular script written in rich, ink-stained ink appears on it. A pair of slender, bony hands gently twist the corner of the page, their movements steady and deliberate. As the camera pans upward, it sweeps across the figure, clad in a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe. Its wide sleeves drape over the edge of the desk, the silk gleaming softly in the soft sunlight filtering through the windowpanes. Finally, the camera settles on the scholar's lean, focused face. He wears a simple Dongpo scarf, his long hair neatly tied back. A deep, pensive expression etched between his brows, his gaze seemingly piercing the text within, immersed in ancient wisdom. The entire scene, shrouded in tranquil light and shadow, evokes a secluded, focused, and elegant atmosphere of scholarship.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4610,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000134/group_15/index_245_seed_13147_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/152_0000134_group_15_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000134_group_15_sample_1_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000134_group_15_sample_1_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000134_group_15_sample_1_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000134_group_15_sample_1_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000134_group_15_sample_1_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000134_group_15_sample_1_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+153,0.02982862,foreground-background,3.08000000,5,0.01807202,0.00214578,0.01061749,0.82738185,0.47895029,0.12500000,0.00017008,0000137,group_10,1,q4,Does the background show a steel guardrail in the foreground and a calm body of water beyond a grass bank?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium side-on tracking shot moves perfectly parallel to a green and white Kawasaki sportbike as it glides effortlessly along a coastal highway under a clear, sunny sky. The rider, dressed head-to-toe in a fitted black leather riding suit and a shiny black full-face helmet with a dark visor, maintains a steady, focused upright posture, hands expertly gripping the handlebars. The motorcycle's vibrant lime green and crisp white aerodynamic fairing gleams with a metallic sheen, reflecting the bright sunlight as it moves at a constant, steady pace. The background is a fluid blur of motion: a continuous steel guardrail stripes past in the foreground, while beyond it, a lush grass bank gently slopes down to a vast, calm body of water, shimmering in the sunlight. The entire scene is imbued with a high-contrast, vivid color palette, creating an atmosphere of quiet power and exhilarating freedom as rider and machine move as one through the landscape.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4029,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000137/group_10/index_1028_seed_30745_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/153_0000137_group_10_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000137_group_10_sample_1_q4__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000137_group_10_sample_1_q4__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000137_group_10_sample_1_q4__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000137_group_10_sample_1_q4__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000137_group_10_sample_1_q4__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000137_group_10_sample_1_q4__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+154,0.02967565,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.02570672,0.00307968,0.01508469,0.69705051,0.43454018,0.12500000,0.00276238,0000035,group_14,1,q4,Does the strategist extend his right hand to place his index and middle fingers on the elderly man's wrist to feel the pulse?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily advances, drawing the viewer's gaze into a dimly lit, quaint bedroom. A thin, worried-looking young strategist, his long, dark hair simply tied back with a wooden hairpin, leans over a sickbed. He wears a dark gray, rough cotton and linen robe, the sleeves carefully rolled up to the elbows, revealing his bony arms. On the bed, an elderly man with a haggard face and sparse white hair lies, his eyes closed, covered by a thick, old quilt, breathing shallowly. The strategist cautiously extends his right hand and gently places his index and middle fingers on the man's bony wrist, intensely feeling the faint beat of his pulse. His furrowed brow and tightly pursed lips convey a profound sense of worry and concentration. The sole illumination comes from a flickering oil lamp by the bedside, its dim glow casting deep shadows on his thin face, creating a striking contrast between light and dark. The entire scene is blanketed in a thick, cinematic layer of film grain and high noise, imparting a distinctly retro feel. Meanwhile, the sharpened pixels precisely capture every subtle movement and concerned expression, creating an atmosphere of solemnity, tension, and humane care.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2890,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000035/group_14/index_6476_seed_4006_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/154_0000035_group_14_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q4__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q4__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q4__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q4__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q4__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000035_group_14_sample_1_q4__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+155,0.02945977,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.01198628,0.00146619,0.00701339,0.78970182,0.57238293,0.07421875,0.00244653,0000112,group_13,0,q5,"Is there a whimsical tea party setup featuring a miniature ceramic tea set with pastel pink, sky blue, and lemon yellow teacups?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level, medium-wide shot captures the sheer enchantment of a sun-dappled forest clearing. Oliver, a young boy with tousled blond hair and a simple blue and white striped T-shirt, sits cross-legged on a red and white checkered picnic blanket. Next to him sits Sparky, a fluffy golden retriever puppy, his head tilted in curiosity, his tail gently tapping the soft grass. Nearby sits a family of four rabbits: a large brown dad, a gentle white mom, and two small, furry gray bunnies. Between them stands a whimsical tea party, featuring a miniature ceramic tea set with pastel pink, sky blue, and lemon yellow teacups. Oliver, with a look of focused joy on his face, is in action, steadily and deliberately pouring imaginary tea from a small white teapot into a tiny cup, carefully held between the paws of a small rabbit. Another bunny nibbles at a heart-shaped cookie on a central plate, which also contains delicately sliced carrot sticks. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, which filters through the lush green canopy above, creating a beautiful play of light and shadow. The atmosphere is tranquil, warm and whimsical, a magical moment of friendship between children, pets and gentle woodland creatures.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2642,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000112/group_13/index_9147_seed_8076_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/155_0000112_group_13_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q5__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q5__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q5__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q5__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q5__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q5__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+156,0.02934420,beside-next-to,1.98000000,4,0.02950419,0.00353066,0.01731569,0.66753739,0.41387802,0.13378906,0.00234318,0000033,group_0,1,q2,Is a house with whitewashed walls and gray tiles visible deep within the forest?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera moves forward at a slow, contemplative pace, passing through a dense, tranquil bamboo forest. Sunlight, filtered by the towering leaves, creates dappled shadows, gently swaying across the ground in the breeze. In front of the camera, a simple house, its whitewashed walls and gray tiles slightly weathered, looms deep within the forest. An ancient stone staircase, paved with natural stone and covered in emerald green moss, winds its way to the door. The slender green grass beside the steps sways gently in the breeze. As the camera steadily moves forward, past the stone steps, its focus finally settles on a half-rolled curtain woven from dried reeds beneath the door's lintel, swaying subtly in the air. Through the gaps in the curtains and the rolled-up parts, one can glimpse the dim and elegant scene inside the room: on a quaint dark wooden table, lies a guqin with a warm lacquer finish and distinct strings. Beside it are scattered several yellowed paper scrolls, some of which have been unfolded, revealing calligraphy in ink, while others are tied with ribbons. The whole scene presents a cool tranquility under the soft diffuse light, and is filled with a secluded, focused and poetic atmosphere of books. It seems as if one can hear the low voice-over ""Mountains are not famous for their height, but for the immortals who live there; water is not magical because of its depth, but for the dragons who live there..."" echoing in the air.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3407,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000033/group_0/index_113_seed_5469_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/156_0000033_group_0_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000033_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+157,0.02918077,left-right-pair,4.20000000,5,0.01399984,0.00167135,0.00821899,0.69180089,0.42709479,0.12890625,0.00158298,0000009,group_15,1,q2,"Does the woman have a short, slightly tousled bob hairstyle and wear a short-sleeved shirt with a pastel floral pattern on a cream background?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"This static, eye-level medium shot captures a woman with a chic, short, slightly tousled bob, sitting at an outdoor cafe. She wears a short-sleeved shirt made of lightweight fabric with a delicate, pastel floral pattern against a cream background. She sits comfortably at a small, round cast-iron table on the sunny restaurant terrace, leaning slightly forward and holding a modern smartphone to her right ear. Amidst a lively conversation, a warm, relaxed smile graces her lips, her eyes crinkling slightly as she speaks, her head tilted with interest. Her left hand rests on the tabletop, her fingers leisurely stroking the rim of a glass of espresso iced tea. In the background, the restaurant's blurred facade, with its large windows and dark green awning, is visible, while the soft, out-of-focus shapes of other patrons create a gentle sense of ambient activity. The entire scene is illuminated by the warm midday sun, which filters through a large parasol, casting a soft, diffuse glow that eliminates harsh shadows and creates an overall relaxed, down-to-earth, and joyful atmosphere of a pleasant afternoon.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2973,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_15/index_4081_seed_18321_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/157_0000009_group_15_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+158,0.02915654,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.00598124,0.00070821,0.00351535,0.80458450,0.46387824,0.12500000,0.00026268,0000037,group_5,1,q2,Is the woman wearing a faded gray oversized T-shirt and dark blue leggings with dark brown hair in a messy ponytail?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,774,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4757_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/158_0000037_group_5_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_1_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+159,0.02887691,left-right-pair+beside-next-to,5.94000000,4,0.00874596,0.00106123,0.00512316,0.72187972,0.50755590,0.08398438,0.00038561,0000141,group_8,1,q2,Is the setting a living room with a large bay window and wooden floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady, medium-length, static shot, taken from a level angle, captures a graying elderly couple sitting side by side in a warm, if slightly dated, living room. They sit by a large bay window, soft afternoon sunlight slanting through the clear glass, casting long, warm patches of light on the wooden floor beside them. The husband, seated on the left, wears a dark blue wool cardigan over a light gray plaid shirt. His face, deeply wrinkled by time, gazes calmly ahead, as if lost in thought. Beside him, his wife, dressed in a soft, off-white turtleneck sweater, her equally gray hair elegantly tied in a bun. Her head tilted slightly to the right, her gaze over her husband's shoulder, distant and unfocused, gazing out the window at the late autumn scene, where a few withered yellow leaves slowly drift down. Then, her chest rose and fell almost imperceptibly, her lips parted slightly, and she let out a soft and long sigh. This sigh was particularly clear in the quiet room, injecting a peaceful, nostalgic and slightly sentimental atmosphere into the whole picture.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1394,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000141/group_8/index_640_seed_22597_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/159_0000141_group_8_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000141_group_8_sample_1_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000141_group_8_sample_1_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000141_group_8_sample_1_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000141_group_8_sample_1_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000141_group_8_sample_1_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000141_group_8_sample_1_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+160,0.02878267,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.02438001,0.00291286,0.01431143,0.70778978,0.45780560,0.11328125,0.00200289,0000070,group_12,3,q5,Is the scene illuminated by cool equipment light and neon track lights casting dynamic shadows on the competitors' faces?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slowly rotating, orbiting medium shot brings us into the core control area of a futuristic drone racing arena. Clad in explosive competitive cinematography, it focuses on two competitors battling side by side. The female competitor on the left, sporting a sleek, dark purple ponytail, wears immersive FPV (first-person view) goggles that half-cover her face, their lenses reflecting a dazzling stream of data. She wears a tight, black, high-tech racing suit with a neon blue circuit pattern. She leans forward slightly, her hands steady and decisive as she grips a complex multi-stick drone controller, her thumbs fine-tuning the joysticks with a speed barely tangible to the naked eye. Beside her, her male teammate, with slightly damp short black hair and a furrowed brow, is absorbed in analyzing a translucent holographic data screen floating before them. His fingers swiftly and deftly swipe and tap across the illuminated interface, adjusting performance parameters and flight path diagrams in real time. Behind them, on the huge circular track structure, other drones turned into blurred colorful light bands and flew by at high speed. The whole scene was illuminated by the cool light emitted by their equipment and the neon lights of the track, casting dynamic light and shadow on their focused faces, creating a tacit cooperation and highly tense competitive atmosphere in the high-speed confrontation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3702,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000070/group_12/index_642_seed_16436_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/160_0000070_group_12_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000070_group_12_sample_3_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+161,0.02873005,beside-next-to,1.74000000,2,0.02787181,0.00330193,0.01637992,0.84095466,0.53716445,0.09863281,0.00269222,0000042,group_0,1,q2,Is a young woman with shoulder-length brown hair standing beside a weathered bus stop sign with a rusted pole?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium-long shot, emulating the distinctive aesthetic of 1990s cinema, perfectly centers a lone figure. A young woman with shoulder-length brown hair stands patiently beside a simple, weathered bus stop sign, its metal pole stained with faint traces of rust, the rectangular sign faded. She wears a well-worn denim jacket over a plain white T-shirt and dark jeans, her posture relaxed yet expectant, almost motionless as she waits. This ordinary scene stands in stark, surreal contrast to the backdrop, where the grand, columned entrance of an opulent mansion looms, its pristine white marble columns and a vast, manicured lawn stretching beneath an evenly cloudy sky. The entire frame is bathed in a soft, diffuse light, eliminating harsh shadows and creating a characteristic soft focus that slightly blurs the edges of the distant mansion. Rich, warm tones dominate, imbuing the deep green of the lawn and the creamy white of the building with a golden-day glow, while subtle film grain textures the image, creating a nostalgic, contemplative, and slightly dreamlike atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4990,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000042/group_0/index_7277_seed_21238_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/161_0000042_group_0_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+162,0.02857290,beside-next-to,1.74000000,2,0.02797015,0.00331174,0.01643894,0.83887976,0.53514779,0.10351562,0.00250337,0000042,group_0,1,q3,Is the woman wearing a well-worn denim jacket over a plain white T-shirt and dark jeans?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium-long shot, emulating the distinctive aesthetic of 1990s cinema, perfectly centers a lone figure. A young woman with shoulder-length brown hair stands patiently beside a simple, weathered bus stop sign, its metal pole stained with faint traces of rust, the rectangular sign faded. She wears a well-worn denim jacket over a plain white T-shirt and dark jeans, her posture relaxed yet expectant, almost motionless as she waits. This ordinary scene stands in stark, surreal contrast to the backdrop, where the grand, columned entrance of an opulent mansion looms, its pristine white marble columns and a vast, manicured lawn stretching beneath an evenly cloudy sky. The entire frame is bathed in a soft, diffuse light, eliminating harsh shadows and creating a characteristic soft focus that slightly blurs the edges of the distant mansion. Rich, warm tones dominate, imbuing the deep green of the lawn and the creamy white of the building with a golden-day glow, while subtle film grain textures the image, creating a nostalgic, contemplative, and slightly dreamlike atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4989,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000042/group_0/index_7277_seed_21238_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/162_0000042_group_0_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000042_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+163,0.02834280,left-right-pair+beside-next-to,7.38000000,8,0.00780213,0.00092791,0.00458281,0.70040351,0.42998275,0.12792969,0.00154006,0000062,group_15,2,q4,Is a transparent observation window visible at the base of a tower showing white plant roots in nutrient solution?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"An immersive first-person camera advances at a slow and steady pace through a narrow corridor formed by towering hydroponic towers constructed of white composite materials. The scene is bathed in a soft, Vermeer-esque sidelight, pouring down from high on the left, illuminating each broad, fresh green leaf with an almost translucent quality. The delicate veins and shimmering water droplets on the leaves are clearly visible, imbuing them with vibrant life. This light also casts long, soft shadows on the right-hand tower wall and the ground. My gaze slowly descends, finally focusing on the base of one of the towers, where a transparent observation window reveals a tangled network of white plant roots immersed in nutrient solution. Right next to the root system, a small, floating holographic screen emitting soft blue light is flashing a real-time updated stream of life data - a heartbeat-like waveform and constantly changing numbers. My eyes are carefully and attentively inspecting it. The whole picture combines the precision of future technology with the tranquil aesthetics of classical painting, creating an atmosphere of focus, tranquility and hope.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,867,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000062/group_15/index_6641_seed_21718_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/163_0000062_group_15_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000062_group_15_sample_2_q4__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000062_group_15_sample_2_q4__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000062_group_15_sample_2_q4__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000062_group_15_sample_2_q4__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000062_group_15_sample_2_q4__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000062_group_15_sample_2_q4__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+164,0.02827799,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.02412009,0.00285178,0.01417888,0.78306901,0.45057786,0.12500000,0.00007007,0000147,group_4,0,q2,"Is a woman with thick, shoulder-length blond curls wearing a crisp white collared shirt sitting behind a long, matte-gray counter?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a realistic-style scene in a bright, sterile airport check-in area. A woman with thick, shoulder-length blond curls, wearing a crisp white collared shirt that fits her uniform, sits attentively behind a long, matte-gray counter. Her fingers initially move deftly across a black keyboard, her focus fixed on a computer screen just off-screen. She pauses typing, her gaze shifting slightly upward, toward an unseen figure. A hand reaches into the frame, offering her a dark blue passport, which she accepts with steady, practiced movements. Simultaneously, two other people approach from the right side of the frame, walking steadily, just like the next person. The first is a man with neatly combed short brown hair, thin-framed glasses, and a dark gray suit jacket over a light-colored shirt. The second person's face remains invisible, partially visible beside him, their form suggesting a casual posture. The entire scene is illuminated by cool, even overhead fluorescent lights, which reflect off the polished white tile floor, creating a clean, functional atmosphere free of harsh shadows and reinforcing the impersonal efficiency of the modern travel center.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2794,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000147/group_4/index_1124_seed_866_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/164_0000147_group_4_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q2__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q2__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q2__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q2__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q2__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q2__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+165,0.02817260,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.02022452,0.00244979,0.01184982,0.74142319,0.49336556,0.09570312,0.00275898,0000093,group_12,2,q4,Is the man's left hand visible with pale blue chalk traces on his fingertips while holding a cue stick?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"This static, tight, eye-level shot, rendered with detailed, grounded realism, focuses on the determined face of an Asian man in his twenties playing pool, leaning over the table to line up a key shot. The camera captures subtle details: the subtle wrinkle of his brow beneath his neatly cropped hair, and the intensely focused reflection of a single, low-hanging pendant lamp gleaming in his dark eyes. This lone source casts a pool of warm, concentrated light onto the scene, creating sharp highlights on his cheekbones and the bridge of his nose while plunging the surrounding pool hall into a soft, blurred darkness. His left hand, firmly splayed on the rich green felt of the table, forms a perfect bridge with the cue stick, the fine traces of pale blue chalk on his fingertips visible against the dark fabric of the tabletop. Steadily and deliberately, he slides the polished maple cue back and forth through his fingers, his gaze unwavering as he moves between the cue ball and the target. His entire posture is one of quiet, focused study, creating an atmosphere of intense intimacy.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3228,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000093/group_12/index_5266_seed_18915_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/165_0000093_group_12_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q4__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q4__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q4__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q4__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q4__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q4__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+166,0.02809725,left-right-pair,4.44000000,6,0.01119587,0.00132740,0.00657898,0.70829290,0.49874732,0.07128906,0.00010633,0000030,group_9,0,q2,Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"An eye-level, static medium shot frames a young man with unkempt brown hair, dressed in a casual gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants, as he cleans a modern living room. Soft daylight streams in from an unseen window, casting gentle reflections on the polished hardwood floor. He initially holds a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand, moving it at a steady pace. His focused work is abruptly interrupted when he clumsily kicks the trailing black power cord with his left foot, tangling it. With a frustrated sigh, he deftly shifts the vacuum cleaner to his right hand, bending steadily at the waist and carefully picking up the loosened cord with his left hand before standing straight. To continue his work, he briefly presses his right foot on the base of the vacuum cleaner to stabilize it, then pushes it forward and resumes cleaning. Then, his attention shifts; he glances to his left, his face partially illuminated by the flickering, colorful glow of a television, playing a vibrant cartoon. As his eyes remain glued to the screen, his hands continue to vacuum back and forth, now more automatically and with less precision, perfectly capturing a moment of distracted, everyday family life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,889,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000030/group_9/index_2120_seed_2724_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/166_0000030_group_9_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000030_group_9_sample_0_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+167,0.02804198,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+between-flanked,8.54000000,5,0.00623587,0.00074986,0.00365733,0.78800654,0.48198959,0.11523438,0.00071800,0000162,group_1,0,q3,Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2595,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18204_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/167_0000162_group_1_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+168,0.02803135,foreground-background,2.72800000,3,0.01785140,0.00211674,0.01048978,0.83548194,0.53469759,0.10156250,0.00218824,0000165,group_6,3,q4,Does the mantis slowly rotate its triangular head with large multi-faceted eyes to track something off-screen?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, extreme macro shot immerses the viewer in a mysterious nocturnal world, focusing with piercing clarity on a vibrant praying mantis occupying the foreground. The creature's body is a stunning canvas of color: its primary exoskeleton is a vibrant emerald green with a subtle waxy sheen, while its upper thorax and wing casings are adorned with intricate petal-like patterns of pure white and delicate pink. It perches on the edge of a large, black leaf, shimmering with tiny dewdrops. The mantis stalks its unseen prey with intense focus; its triangular head, dominated by large, multi-faceted eyes, rotates with meticulous slowness to track something off-screen. The entire scene is bathed in cool, low-key lighting, creating a color scheme of deep blue and velvety purple, casting the out-of-focus background of lush foliage into shadow and mystery. As the mantis prepares to move, it stealthily raises one of its serrated front legs, a movement so slow and deliberate as to be almost imperceptible, heightening the palpable tension and predatory focus of its nocturnal hunt.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,391,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000165/group_6/index_9009_seed_15533_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/168_0000165_group_6_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000165_group_6_sample_3_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000165_group_6_sample_3_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000165_group_6_sample_3_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000165_group_6_sample_3_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000165_group_6_sample_3_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000165_group_6_sample_3_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+169,0.02802772,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.34000000,5,0.01267467,0.00149715,0.00745168,0.72584742,0.44606033,0.12402344,0.00396240,0000101,group_2,1,q3,Is a middle-aged man wearing a dark silk scarf and a wide-sleeved black robe sitting at a heavy dark wooden desk?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, close-up shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, focuses the viewer's attention on a scene illuminated by the flickering flame of an ancient copper oil lamp. At the center of the frame lies a middle-aged strategist, wearing a dark silk scarf and a wide-sleeved black robe. He sits at a heavy, dark wooden desk, his brow furrowed, his eyes sharp as an eagle's, his gaze fixed intently on the object before him. The warm, dancing light casts deep shadows on his chiseled features, highlighting his lips pursed in deep thought. His slender, powerful hands, carefully, steadily, and deliberately, slowly unroll a bamboo map bound by string. As he moves, the polished bamboo strips rub against each other, creating a crisp, subtle rustling sound. The map's ink-drawn mountains and rivers, along with the cinnabar-marked military fortresses, gradually emerge in the dim light, exuding a sense of age and age. Beside him, on the desk, rests a feather fan crafted from white crane feathers, its ebony handle gleaming softly in the light. The painting's warm, deep tones, predominantly dark browns and oranges, create a stark contrast between light and shadow, evoking a sense of intense concentration and tension as one plots and decides a battle in the stillness of the night.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3202,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000101/group_2/index_6541_seed_30523_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/169_0000101_group_2_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000101_group_2_sample_1_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+170,0.02799108,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.58800000,6,0.01192692,0.00143203,0.00699659,0.69908386,0.45068538,0.11718750,0.00224388,0000112,group_2,2,q3,Is the woman next to him wearing a white bomber jacket and has long bright pink hair in a high ponytail?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic, low-angle, tracking shot, close to the ground, follows two young men as they effortlessly glide across a futuristic city square at dusk on their electric unicycles. The young man on the left, with shaggy black hair and a tech-fabric black hoodie with reflective silver stripes on the sleeves, wears a broad smile. The young woman next to him, with her long, bright pink hair tied in a high ponytail, throws her head back in a sleek white bomber jacket and laughs heartily. The unicycles they ride are matte black, their futuristic LED strips emitting brilliant cyan and magenta light on either side, casting vibrant reflections on the polished dark stone floor, leaving long trails of light as the wheels spin at breakneck speed. The camera switches focus swiftly and precisely between close-ups of their vivid, joyful facial expressions and the wheels spinning so rapidly that they appear almost animate, against a backdrop of towering skyscrapers, their windows lit up, and flashing holographic billboards. The entire picture has a cold tone, mainly dark blue and black, but is illuminated by the neon lights of the unicycle and the warm lights in the distance, interspersed with slight, stylized digital screen flashes and lens flares that represent a sense of technology, creating a futuristic atmosphere that is free, cheerful and full of urban dynamism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4088,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000112/group_2/index_4817_seed_22845_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/170_0000112_group_2_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000112_group_2_sample_2_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+171,0.02789532,foreground-background+beside-next-to,4.88400000,4,0.01002322,0.00123942,0.00585586,0.74700665,0.52681804,0.08105469,0.00070137,0000052,group_7,2,q3,Is a man with a shaved head running beside the woman with visible tension in his calf and thigh muscles?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"glossy, eye-level camera relentlessly follows a large group of marathon runners, capturing the scene in stunning, surreal detail. The camera moves at their pace, placing a few distinct runners in the foreground with razor-sharp focus. A woman with a high, swinging ponytail, rosy-faced and focused, wears a bright yellow technical vest drenched in sweat. Beside her, a man with a shaved head and a focused expression, every tense muscle fiber in his calves and thighs visible with each powerful stride. Their outfits are a vibrant, chaotic mosaic of neon green, electric blue, and hot pink, all rendered with realistic textures. Their collective action is a thunderous, rhythmic thud against the asphalt of the broad city avenue, a unified forward wave, thousands of individual bodies moving as one undulating mass. Crisp, low-angle morning sunlight filters through the scene, gleaming on their foreheads and casting long, dynamic shadows as they run. In the background, the blurred forms of cheering spectators and city buildings streak by, enhancing the profound sense of speed and unstoppable momentum, creating an epic atmosphere rich in raw determination and human endurance.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1878,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000052/group_7/index_885_seed_21558_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/171_0000052_group_7_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000052_group_7_sample_2_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000052_group_7_sample_2_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000052_group_7_sample_2_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000052_group_7_sample_2_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000052_group_7_sample_2_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000052_group_7_sample_2_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+172,0.02781100,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+between-flanked,8.54000000,5,0.00700234,0.00083249,0.00411323,0.64263767,0.39535433,0.14062500,0.00152072,0000162,group_1,0,q5,Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2594,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18204_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/172_0000162_group_1_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000162_group_1_sample_0_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+173,0.02776964,foreground-background,3.08000000,5,0.01596843,0.00189528,0.00938210,0.82609010,0.51455718,0.10253906,0.00251013,0000082,group_9,2,q4,Is a woman's hand in the foreground lifting a glass of white wine that is about one-third full?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a cozy, humanistic interior, a fluid single shot begins at table level, then slowly and gracefully pans rightward across a warm dining scene. A long, dark wooden table, covered with a beige linen tablecloth, is laden with half-eaten home-cooked dishes and scattered crumbs. Several friends, dressed in cozy sweaters and casual shirts, gather around the table. Their faces are blurred by a soft bokeh, yet their genuine smiles and lively gestures, engaged in conversation, are clearly visible. As the camera pans, the focus gradually and seamlessly shifts from the joyful gathering in the background to the central subject in the foreground: a woman's hand, delicately lifting a glass of white wine from the table. Steady and composed, her nails immaculately manicured, the hand elegantly grasps the slender stem of a classic crystal goblet. The glass is about one-third full of pale golden white wine, and under the soft light cast by a low, warm-toned chandelier overhead, the wine's clarity is translucent, shimmering with sparkling shimmer. As the wine glasses are slowly raised to the center of the picture, the smiling faces and figures of the friends in the background are completely blurred into warm spots of light (Bokeh) and soft blocks of color. The whole picture is wrapped in an intimate, peaceful and joyful atmosphere. The main colors are warm amber and cream, and the contrast of light and shadow is soft, perfectly capturing this peaceful and sincere moment of celebration.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1666,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000082/group_9/index_3890_seed_29050_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/173_0000082_group_9_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+174,0.02775575,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.44000000,5,0.00713587,0.00087137,0.00417633,0.80560398,0.59149230,0.07226562,0.00070521,0000136,group_9,3,q2,Is the man wearing a red and white checkered short-sleeved button-down shirt and teal checkered shorts?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures the scene in a brightly lit modern kitchen. A man with slightly tousled brown hair casually walks toward a set of lower cabinets. He wears a red and white checkered, short-sleeved button-down shirt and contrasting teal checkered shorts, creating a relaxed, homely look. He pauses before a white, rickety cabinet and reaches down deliberately, his fingers grasping the small, brushed metal knob. He smoothly pulls the door open, revealing shelves filled with a messy yet organized pantry: an assortment of unlabeled glass jars, colorful tins, and plain cardboard boxes. Holding a simple glass jar with a plain metal lid in his right hand, he takes a step closer, bending slightly at his knees and waist, and carefully reaches into the cabinet. Steadily and accurately, he places the jar on the bottom shelf, nestled between a stack of jars and a box. Once his fingers release the jar, he straightens and begins to rotate his body to the left. As he begins to turn away from the open cabinet, his movements are fluid and unhurried, completing a simple chore. The scene is bathed in warm, soft light from overhead fixtures, creating a comfortable and tranquil atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2808,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000136/group_9/index_5875_seed_11774_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/174_0000136_group_9_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+175,0.02754174,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.02483733,0.00295965,0.01458512,0.82126909,0.49305281,0.11132812,0.00029346,0000018,group_4,2,q2,Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pans upward through a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light penetrates the mist and dense bamboo foliage, casting visible beams of light in the air. The camera finally settles on a woman in a traditional Chinese costume, dressed in an elegant aquamarine silk robe. Her long, cascading black hair is held together only partially by a simple jade hairpin. Her face is clear and beautiful, her eyes focused and ethereal. With a light touch of the ground, her entire body rises as if weightless. The camera instantly switches to a fast, dynamic tracking shot, following her graceful figure as she nimbly weaves between the towering bamboo branches. Her wide sleeves flutter like butterfly wings as she moves swiftly, her skirt carving graceful arcs through the mist. A series of rapidly alternating close-ups follows: the tip of her shoe, delicately embroidered with cloud patterns, lightly steps on a dewy bamboo leaf, which trembles only slightly before returning to its composure; a strand of hair brushes across her focused and serene profile, revealing her perfectly defined jawline; her slender fingers form an elegant sword-like gesture in the air, steadily and calmly directing her body. The entire sequence is seamless, the camera language sharp and precise, capturing every moment of her ethereal, ethereal beauty. Amidst the cool tones of light and the lingering mist, an ethereal atmosphere is created, imbued with both martial arts power and poetic imagery.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1725,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_5716_seed_17759_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/175_0000018_group_4_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q2__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q2__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q2__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q2__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q2__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q2__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+176,0.02749882,left-right-pair+between-flanked,5.70400000,3,0.00948061,0.00114296,0.00555843,0.68994385,0.44836986,0.11523438,0.00234753,0000001,group_12,1,q3,Do a pair of hands with perfectly manicured nails slide a white ceramic plate forward from the right side of the frame?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slightly high-angled extreme close-up, imbued with subtle handheld vibrations, conveys a sense of eager anticipation, capturing the culinary exchange at the table. In the center of the frame, a traditional yin-yang hot pot boils, its surface divided between a fiery red broth laden with chilies and a milky white broth. Wisps of aromatic steam rise, catching the warm overhead light and creating a soft, dreamy haze. Starting on the right, a pair of hands with perfectly manicured nails gently and deliberately slide a pristine white ceramic plate forward across the dark polished wood of the table. On the plate, a thin slice of richly marbled beef is meticulously fanned out into a perfect, vibrant red rosette. As the plate glides through the rising steam, a second, slightly larger pair of hands moves in from the left, carefully accepting the offering, their fingers balancing on the plate's rim in a shared culinary ritual. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of the intimate restaurant setting, creating a palpable atmosphere of warmth, joy, and delicious anticipation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2233,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000001/group_12/index_5051_seed_26456_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/176_0000001_group_12_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000001_group_12_sample_1_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000001_group_12_sample_1_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000001_group_12_sample_1_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000001_group_12_sample_1_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000001_group_12_sample_1_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000001_group_12_sample_1_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+177,0.02725917,left-right-pair+beside-next-to,6.66000000,6,0.00736848,0.00088651,0.00432132,0.73095703,0.50629568,0.08398438,0.00175345,0000070,group_12,0,q3,"Is the male competitor on the right wearing a suit, has short black hair, and is interacting with a translucent holographic data screen?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slowly rotating, orbiting medium shot brings us into the core control area of a futuristic drone racing arena. Clad in explosive competitive cinematography, it focuses on two competitors battling side by side. The female competitor on the left, sporting a sleek, dark purple ponytail, wears immersive FPV (first-person view) goggles that half-cover her face, their lenses reflecting a dazzling stream of data. She wears a tight, black, high-tech racing suit with a neon blue circuit pattern. She leans forward slightly, her hands steady and decisive as she grips a complex multi-stick drone controller, her thumbs fine-tuning the joysticks with a speed barely tangible to the naked eye. Beside her, her male teammate, with slightly damp short black hair and a furrowed brow, is absorbed in analyzing a translucent holographic data screen floating before them. His fingers swiftly and deftly swipe and tap across the illuminated interface, adjusting performance parameters and flight path diagrams in real time. Behind them, on the huge circular track structure, other drones turned into blurred colorful light bands and flew by at high speed. The whole scene was illuminated by the cool light emitted by their equipment and the neon lights of the track, casting dynamic light and shadow on their focused faces, creating a tacit cooperation and highly tense competitive atmosphere in the high-speed confrontation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1261,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000070/group_12/index_642_seed_16433_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/177_0000070_group_12_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+178,0.02722216,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.02142452,0.00263227,0.01252817,0.80223471,0.56762344,0.08593750,0.00244954,0000123,group_6,0,q2,Is an elderly man with silver hair in a neat bun visible in the center of the frame?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"long shot, beginning from a slightly upward angle and slowly advancing forward, transports us into a world shrouded in a milky morning mist. A weathered arched stone bridge spans the center of the frame, its slippery slabs dotted with moss, its railings etched with the marks of age. In the center of the bridge, an elderly man, silver hair pulled back into a neat bun, dressed in a loose-fitting white silk training suit, is immersed in a Tai Chi practice. His face is gaunt, wrinkled with wisdom, his eyes slightly closed, his expression serene and focused. With his slow, fluid movements, his arms trace gentle arcs like flowing clouds and water, his weight shifting steadily and effortlessly between his legs, his wide sleeves fluttering softly. The first soft rays of morning light penetrated the mist, casting a faint golden halo on his outline and silver hair, forming a subtle contrast with the cool, gray-green background tones around him. The whole picture was filled with an otherworldly sense of tranquility and concentration, as if time had frozen at this moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2491,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000123/group_6/index_488_seed_12200_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/178_0000123_group_6_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+179,0.02712609,left-right-pair+between-flanked,5.70400000,3,0.01117731,0.00133543,0.00656125,0.60309076,0.35331076,0.18359375,0.00208455,0000127,group_14,1,q2,"Is one creature a translucent, bell-shaped gelatinous form with black eyes radiating soft azure light?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In Hayao Miyazaki's captivating, hand-drawn Ghibli style, a static, intimate close-up captures a pair of slender, young hands cupped together in a tranquil underwater realm, meticulously detailed. Steadily and deliberately, these hands guide two shy, bioluminescent sea creatures toward each other. One creature nestles in the palm of the left hand, radiating a soft, ethereal azure glow. Its gelatinous body is shaped like a small, translucent bell, with inquisitive black eyes. The other, guided by the gentle fingers of the right hand, radiates a warm golden light. Its form is a slightly intricate, star-shaped droplet that trembles timidly at approach. As the two creatures cautiously approach, their respective radiance intensifies, casting a magical, pulsating glow that illuminates the subtle details of the characters' skin and the shimmering water particles between them. The immediate background is a lush underwater world with soft, painterly textures; out-of-focus, vibrant corals in soft shades of pink and deep purple sway gently, while the tentacles of a large, soft-edged sea anemone ripple in the subtle currents. The scene is primarily illuminated by a magical, blended blue and gold light emanating from the creatures, creating soft highlights and gentle shadows on the hands, enveloping the moment in an atmosphere of pure, quietly enchanting beauty and capturing a profound sense of wonder through the sheer tenderness of the movement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4640,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000127/group_14/index_9417_seed_17262_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/179_0000127_group_14_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000127_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000127_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000127_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000127_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000127_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000127_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+180,0.02695900,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.02276794,0.00271700,0.01336729,0.63076723,0.38755924,0.14550781,0.00278872,0000062,group_11,2,q5,Is the setting the entrance to a courtyard featuring a mottled grey brick wall and a tightly closed vermilion gate with a gleaming copper ring?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The shot begins with a slow, drawn-out shot, focusing in extreme close-up on a dark, solid wooden plaque hanging high above. The plaque's surface is coated with thick black lacquer, embodying a mellow patina gleaming with age. Carved upon it are powerful, bold characters in a flamboyant, cursive script. The grooves between the characters are filled with gold, reflecting a warm and solemn glow in the soft, slanting afternoon sunlight. As the camera steadily and slowly pulls back, the plaque and the surrounding structures gradually emerge. We see an elderly man with silver hair and a gaunt face standing quietly beneath the plaque. He wears a traditional dark gray, double-breasted cotton and linen jacket. His hands are clasped behind his back, his body leaning back slightly, his head tilted back, his gaze fixed and reverently fixed on the calligraphy masterpiece above him. His wrinkled eyes reveal a look of deep admiration and nostalgia. The setting is the entrance to a quaint courtyard, framed by a mottled grey brick wall and a tightly closed vermilion gate. The copper ring on the door gleams with a patina in the light. Sunlight filters through the sparse branches of a nearby old locust tree, casting flickering shadows on the ground and walls. The warm tones of the painting create an atmosphere of tranquility, nostalgia, and a rich cultural heritage.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2688,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000062/group_11/index_8771_seed_26396_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/180_0000062_group_11_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000062_group_11_sample_2_q5__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000062_group_11_sample_2_q5__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000062_group_11_sample_2_q5__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000062_group_11_sample_2_q5__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000062_group_11_sample_2_q5__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000062_group_11_sample_2_q5__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+181,0.02694915,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.02099046,0.00248859,0.01233458,0.79802179,0.51756036,0.09667969,0.00191939,0000003,group_8,1,q1,Are a pair of hands visible arranging vintage hardcover books?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level close-up captures a pair of hands meticulously arranging a collection of vintage hardcover books. These hands, belonging to a person wearing the sleeves of a cozy forest green knit sweater, hold a thick hardcover bound in worn crimson leather. The book's spine features a faint, faded gilt pattern, and the pages are a warm, decked ivory. With steady, deliberate precision, the hands guide the book onto a dark, polished mahogany bookshelf already crowded with similar antique volumes. The camera follows the person as they gently and carefully slide the crimson book into the perfectly sized, narrow gap between the aquamarine and dark brown volumes. The book slides smoothly into place until its spine aligns perfectly with the neighboring books, a movement that conveys a deep sense of satisfaction and order. The scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of an unseen lamp, which casts gentle highlights across the richly textured leather spines and the rich grain of the wood, creating deep, soft shadows. The overall atmosphere is one of tranquil focus and quiet reverence, a peaceful moment dedicated to the love of literature.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1745,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000003/group_8/index_159_seed_7233_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/181_0000003_group_8_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000003_group_8_sample_1_q1__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000003_group_8_sample_1_q1__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000003_group_8_sample_1_q1__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000003_group_8_sample_1_q1__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000003_group_8_sample_1_q1__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000003_group_8_sample_1_q1__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+182,0.02681163,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01906504,0.00228056,0.01118966,0.85215408,0.61407059,0.07226562,0.00014171,0000117,group_9,1,q1,"Is the main subject a thin, middle-aged man with a neatly trimmed goatee and long hair held back by a wooden hairpin?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a thin, middle-aged strategist with a neatly trimmed goatee, nestled within a dimly lit military tent. He wears a loose, flowing dark blue silk robe, his long hair held back with a simple wooden hairpin. He reclines leisurely on an antique carved wooden chair. The only illumination comes from a bronze oil lamp on a table beside him. Its flickering, warm yellow light casts deep, undulating shadows on his face, emphasizing his pensive expression and illuminating the folds of his silk robe with a soft sheen. In his right hand, he grasps a feather fan made of pure white crane feathers, gently waving it with a steady, leisurely rhythm, the breeze occasionally causing the lamplight to flicker. In the background, a military map hangs on the thick dark canvas tent wall, and a wooden weapons rack with unfolded bamboo slips and weapons can be vaguely seen next to it. The whole scene has a warm tone, mainly deep dark colors, creating an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tranquility and strategic planning against the backdrop of military tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3121,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000117/group_9/index_9345_seed_1224_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/182_0000117_group_9_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q1__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q1__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q1__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q1__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q1__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q1__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+183,0.02676633,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.02449169,0.00289729,0.01439627,0.69899976,0.50870639,0.06640625,0.00068265,0000120,group_1,2,q5,"Does the video include rapid staccato cuts featuring close-ups of the dog's focused eyes, jaw muscles, and the distance between its teeth and the Frisbee?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"This athletic, low-angle tracking shot, captured with an ultra-fast shutter speed that freezes movement with crystal clarity, follows a muscular Shiba Inu, its body brimming with power as it pounces. The dog's dense, two-tone red and cream coat is rendered in exquisite detail, each hair sharply defined and backlit by the brilliant midday sun, creating a subtle, luminous halo. Its powerful hip and shoulder muscles are visibly tensed and defined beneath its fur, showcasing peak physical condition as it soars horizontally through the air. It pursues its target through a sunny park, where lush, manicured grass blends into a soft, burnt green bokeh background. The object of its pursuit is a vibrant red Frisbee, suspended from the frame, its plastic surface radiating a slight sheen as it spins. The dog's entire body is a portrait of concentrated intensity; its dark, intelligent eyes locked on the Frisbee, its black-lipped mouth slightly open in anticipation. The scene then abruptly shifts into a series of rapid, staccato cuts that intensify the climactic moment: a dramatic close-up of the dog’s unwavering, focused gaze; a close-up of its powerful jaw, the muscles trembling as it begins to close; another angle capturing the final, infinitesimal distance between its teeth and the edge of the red disk, creating a palpable atmosphere of explosion, joyful energy and athleticism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1590,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000120/group_1/index_2238_seed_27645_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/183_0000120_group_1_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000120_group_1_sample_2_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000120_group_1_sample_2_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000120_group_1_sample_2_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000120_group_1_sample_2_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000120_group_1_sample_2_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000120_group_1_sample_2_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+184,0.02667129,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.02491784,0.00293352,0.01465621,0.81890059,0.46908808,0.12500000,0.00022542,0000109,group_14,1,q2,Is the sky dim and filled with smoke?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"sweeping aerial shot slowly swept across a boundless mountain of electronic waste. Beneath the dim, smoke-filled sky, countless rusted server chassis piled one upon another, their decaying metal frames like the skeletons of ancient beasts, exuding a desolate, lifeless atmosphere. The camera slowly descended and panted forward, finally focusing on a figure amidst the ruins—Lin Ye. He wore a dark gray work jacket stained with oil, his face covered by thick goggles, his expression focused and exhausted. His left arm had been replaced by a crude hydraulic prosthesis, the exposed pistons and pipes emitting a heavy, rhythmic, wheezing sound as he moved. He half-knelt amid the metal rubble, his right hand steadying a modified welding torch, cobbled together from scrap. The muzzle blazed a dazzling blue plasma flame as he carefully dismantled a massive cubic device. It was a quantum server. On its sleek black exterior, beneath a technologically-inspired logo composed of white lines, the four Chinese characters for ""Ark Project"" were clearly printed. Sparks flew from the cutting, briefly illuminating the piles of discarded circuit boards and vine-like cables surrounding him. The air was filled with the acrid smell of ozone and molten metal. The entire scene, a stark contrast between the cold industrial gray tones and the blazing blue light of the welding torch, created an atmosphere of lonely and tenacious survival in the apocalypse.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4716,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000109/group_14/index_4566_seed_15824_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/184_0000109_group_14_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000109_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000109_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000109_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000109_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000109_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000109_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+185,0.02666333,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.34000000,5,0.01268111,0.00153738,0.00742915,0.65545279,0.41907084,0.13378906,0.00123125,0000042,group_5,0,q3,Do the pilots raise their gloved right hands to high-five in celebration?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level, medium close-up shot from the cramped cockpit of a fighter jet captures the tense moment as it executes a high-G turn. Through the panoramic tree canopy, the deep blue sky and wisps of white clouds blur into a dizzying swirl, the horizon tilted at a severe angle, conveying the speed and violence of the maneuver. The interior is a complex web of technology; multi-function displays flash green and amber flight data, and countless illuminated switches cast a cool, focused light. The chief pilot in the foreground, a man, his eyes focused beneath the raised visor of his advanced helmet, wears a dark olive flight suit and black tactical gloves. Beside him, the co-pilot mirrors his suit, their faces partially obscured by oxygen masks. For a moment, they break their concentration and share a triumphant smile. They raise their gloved right hands and high-five in celebration in the narrow space between the ejection seats. It's a swift and decisive gesture that embodies long-standing camaraderie and a powerful human gesture, sharing victory amidst controlled chaos and an overwhelming aerial display.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3360,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000042/group_5/index_8745_seed_21218_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/185_0000042_group_5_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000042_group_5_sample_0_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000042_group_5_sample_0_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000042_group_5_sample_0_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000042_group_5_sample_0_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000042_group_5_sample_0_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000042_group_5_sample_0_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+186,0.02651757,left-right-pair+foreground-background+beside-next-to,8.84400000,4,0.00635081,0.00074700,0.00373587,0.61839128,0.39509043,0.12500000,0.00129139,0000039,group_9,3,q3,"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3801,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8145_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/186_0000039_group_9_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_9_sample_3_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+187,0.02649750,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.02289528,0.00271630,0.01345265,0.82803774,0.53445113,0.09863281,0.00196648,0000007,group_11,2,q4,"Does the figure wear simple dark trousers and move with slow, deliberate, fluid motions while his hands slide across the rough wood?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, tracking, full-body photograph follows a lone male figure as he glides gracefully through a dimly lit vinegar brewery, carrying liquid fluid. Bare-chested, his lean, athletic torso gleams in the warmth, emitting a delicate odor of moisture. His dark, damp hair clings to his forehead, and his expression is filled with pensive concentration. With a sensual and suggestive style, he meanders through the narrow gaps between massive, ancient oak barrels, his hands sliding across the rough, dark wood as he navigates the space. Each movement is slow and deliberate; his torso twists fluidly, his feet, clad in simple dark trousers, press silently against the cool, uneven stone floor. Towering wooden barrels, bound by rusted iron rings, fill the vast space, their surfaces revealing an ancient patina. The air is thick and acrid, dust dancing in the warm, faint light that penetrates the darkness through the tall, grimy windows. This warm lighting casts long, deep shadows that shape the outlines of his body and highlight the rich, dark brown grain of the wood, creating an atmosphere where his patient, controlled dance echoes the slow, silent, and ancient process of fermentation that takes place within the barrels around him.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1954,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000007/group_11/index_6055_seed_9340_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/187_0000007_group_11_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000007_group_11_sample_2_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000007_group_11_sample_2_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000007_group_11_sample_2_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000007_group_11_sample_2_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000007_group_11_sample_2_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000007_group_11_sample_2_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+188,0.02649478,left-right-pair+between-flanked,5.70400000,3,0.01013592,0.00120207,0.00595590,0.61965603,0.38484773,0.14648438,0.00091642,0000002,group_5,0,q2,"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from an underwater eye-level, follows the fierce confrontation between two massive largemouth bass with a slow, steady pan. In the murky, yet sun-drenched, freshwater lake, shafts of light create a Tyndall effect in the deep green water, illuminating tiny suspended particles. The bass on the left, slightly larger, its olive-green scales gleaming metallically in the light. Its gill covers open wide in fury, revealing vibrant red gill filaments. It lunges forward with explosive force, its massive mouth stretched to its limit. Its opponent on the right, no less, slaps the current with its powerful tail fin, stirring up a small cloud of bottom mud and sand. It nimbly twists its body in the water to meet the impact sideways. The moment the two fish collide, the image is filled with a sense of power, with visible ripples in the water and a few silver scales falling and scattering in the chaos. Their movements are not chaotic, but full of primitive and strategic aggressiveness. Every collision and bite stirs up the swaying aquatic plants around them, creating a tense, fierce and primitive competitive atmosphere full of vitality.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1748,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_5/index_267_seed_25095_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/188_0000002_group_5_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_5_sample_0_q2__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_5_sample_0_q2__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_5_sample_0_q2__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_5_sample_0_q2__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_5_sample_0_q2__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_5_sample_0_q2__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+189,0.02639725,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.02504409,0.00297793,0.01471077,0.65977216,0.43890879,0.09863281,0.00037628,0000024,group_1,1,q3,"Does the man raise his right arm to shield his mouth and nose, leaving a narrow gap between his fingers?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady medium close-up places the viewer at the center of a fierce sandstorm, focusing on a weathered man. He defiantly leans sideways against the gusting wind, leaning slightly forward for balance. He wears a faded, yet still a deep, cyan-colored, coarse robe, its rough fabric caked with fine grains of sand. Every wrinkle on his face, carved by the scorching sun and wind, seems to tell a long story. His dark, cracked skin contrasts sharply with his gray, dust-stained beard. Quickly and instinctively, he raises his right arm, tightly shielding his mouth and nose with his muscular forearm to shield himself from the overwhelming, almost suffocating dust. However, his hand does not clench completely; instead, he carefully opens his fingers, creating a narrow gap. Through this gap, his deep eyes gaze with an unwavering, resolute gaze at the unknown world ahead, obscured by the wind and sand. There is no fear in his eyes, only focus and determination. The entire picture is completely immersed in Steve McCurry's iconic photography style: the air is filled with rich and saturated ochre and orange tones, forming a strong and harmonious color contrast with the blue of the man's robe; although the light is diffused by the sand and dust and is extremely soft, it depicts every texture and attached sand on his face with extremely high clarity, creating an epic atmosphere full of struggle and extremely human dignity and tenacious strength.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1318,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000024/group_1/index_7804_seed_9785_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/189_0000024_group_1_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000024_group_1_sample_1_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000024_group_1_sample_1_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000024_group_1_sample_1_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000024_group_1_sample_1_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000024_group_1_sample_1_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000024_group_1_sample_1_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+190,0.02638714,opposite-across,2.78800000,9,0.01677985,0.00199218,0.00985845,0.79706132,0.51147968,0.09863281,0.00172800,0000009,group_4,2,q4,Is a tablet on the table emitting a bright cool blue digital glow that illuminates the characters' faces and hands?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot depicts a tense, silent confrontation in the hallowed quiet of a wood-paneled academic library. At a large, polished mahogany table, a young man with shaggy black hair leans forward, an impassioned look of frustration written across his face. Wearing a comfortable, dark green cardigan, they repeatedly gesture with their index finger to a tablet on the table. The tablet's screen emits a bright, cool digital glow, casting a stark blue light on their faces and hands, illuminating the complex data charts visible on the display. An older man seated opposite, dressed in a formal dark tweed blazer and a crisp white collared shirt, remains erect, his posture a wall of defiance. His silver-gray hair is impossibly neatly trimmed, his face a mask of resolute misunderstanding. He shakes his head slowly and stubbornly, his lips pressed into a thin line, his gaze deliberately averted, refusing even a glance at the glowing screen. The warm golden light from a classic green-shaded bank lamp on the table illuminates the scene, creating deep shadows that contrast with the cool glow of the tablet, visually emphasizing the generational and ideological clash. The background is filled with tall, dimly lit bookshelves filled with old leather-bound books, creating a heavy academic atmosphere, imbued with the weight of tradition and unspoken disagreements.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,15,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_4/index_5960_seed_20023_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/190_0000009_group_4_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+191,0.02632834,beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,7.48800000,7,0.00627342,0.00074219,0.00368748,0.75907022,0.52133292,0.08593750,0.00059617,0000158,group_8,3,q2,"Are two friends, a woman with wavy auburn hair in a cream sweater and a man in a dark green button-down shirt, visible?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures an intimate moment of passionate conversation between two friends in a dimly lit, cozy bistro. A woman in her twenties, with wavy auburn hair loosely pulled back and wearing a soft cream-colored sweater, leans forward, a gentle smile on her face as she speaks. Across from her, a man of similar age, wearing a dark green button-down shirt with the sleeves casually rolled up to his forearms, listens intently, his head slightly tilted, a look of genuine engagement. Between them, on a small, round, dark wooden table, lie two elegant, large glasses half-filled with deep red wine. As the woman shares her story, her right hand gracefully and expressively gestures near the bowl of her glass, while the man's hand rests near the base of his own, his fingers leisurely tracing the polished wood. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden light of a low-hanging lamp, casting soft shadows on their faces and causing the wine to gleam, creating a tranquil and welcoming atmosphere of easy friendship and shared confidence.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,199,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000158/group_8/index_5750_seed_15306_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/191_0000158_group_8_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000158_group_8_sample_3_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+192,0.02623371,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.00487075,0.00058116,0.00285972,0.74962825,0.52897239,0.07617188,0.00009084,0000037,group_5,0,q1,"Is the scene a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2711,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4756_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/192_0000037_group_5_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q1__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q1__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q1__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q1__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q1__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q1__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+193,0.02601112,beside-next-to,2.10000000,5,0.02321901,0.00272069,0.01366555,0.80712128,0.46115100,0.12500000,0.00003147,0000169,group_14,0,q5,Is the character standing in a relaxed pose with hands tucked into his pockets near a concrete ledge?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"cinematic, eye-level medium-long shot, rendered in surreal 3D animation, slowly approaches a young man standing on a city rooftop during the magic hour. He has sharp, chiseled features, a strong jawline, and dark, meticulously styled hair, with a single strand appearing pristine, subtly tousled in the breeze, catching the light. He wears a crisp white shirt, its realistic cotton texture visible, flowing gracefully in the wind. He stands in a relaxed pose, his hands tucked into the pockets of his dark trousers, near the concrete ledge of a rooftop. Below and behind him, a sprawling metropolis stretches to the horizon, its countless buildings and skyscrapers bathed in the warm golden glow of sunset. The sky is a stunning canvas, vibrant hues of orange, pink, and deep purple. His expression is one of deep, quiet contemplation, his gaze distant and his eyes crystal clear, perfectly reflecting the vibrant colors of the sky, creating a powerful atmosphere of tranquil introspection and poignant beauty.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3455,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000169/group_14/index_291_seed_22787_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/193_0000169_group_14_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000169_group_14_sample_0_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000169_group_14_sample_0_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000169_group_14_sample_0_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000169_group_14_sample_0_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000169_group_14_sample_0_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000169_group_14_sample_0_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+194,0.02598481,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01278588,0.00153759,0.00749886,0.69678766,0.45181301,0.11621094,0.00196403,0000057,group_1,1,q4,Does the right hand insert the syringe needle into a small glass bottle with a rubber stopper?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, high-angle close-up captures a meticulously orchestrated scientific procedure on a sterile stainless steel workbench, beneath bright, even overhead fluorescent lighting. A pair of hands, clad in tight-fitting blue butyl gloves, manipulate with precision. The gloved right hand first firmly grasps a clear plastic syringe with black measurement markings and shakes it quickly and deliberately to mix the clear liquid within. Simultaneously, the gloved left hand steadily slides a clear, round Petri dish across the reflective steel surface and into the center of the frame. The right hand then moves to a small glass bottle, deftly unscrewing the plastic cap and carefully placing it on a plain white cardboard box nearby. After another quick shake of the syringe, the right hand guides the needle, decisively inserting it into the bottle's rubber stopper. The left hand then carefully lifts the lid of the Petri dish and secures it above the base. The right hand tilts the syringe over the open Petri dish, carefully pressing the plunger with its thumb, releasing a few drops of clear liquid onto the culture medium within, keeping it steady. The syringe is then smoothly lifted, and the left hand instantly and precisely closes the cap, sealing the Petri dish, creating a clinical and highly professional atmosphere throughout the entire process.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2185,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000057/group_1/index_6560_seed_22397_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/194_0000057_group_1_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000057_group_1_sample_1_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000057_group_1_sample_1_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000057_group_1_sample_1_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000057_group_1_sample_1_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000057_group_1_sample_1_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000057_group_1_sample_1_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+195,0.02598138,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01245146,0.00147815,0.00731554,0.82008708,0.47377026,0.12500000,0.00019050,0000156,group_8,3,q3,Is the scene set on an elegant dark wood desk with a stack of heavy books faintly visible and blurred in the background?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera pans incredibly slowly to the right, delicately tracking the movement of a hand writing on an elegant, dark wood desk. The hand's slender fingers firmly and firmly grasp a delicate black fountain pen with a gold-rimmed barrel. Its gleaming metallic iridium tip glides effortlessly and steadily across a sheet of thick, off-white stationery, leaving behind a trail of evenly inked, dark blue cursive. At this moment, a soft, warm, slightly iridescent lens flare, as if carefully choreographed, slowly sweeps across the left side of the frame, grazing the moving metal tip and causing it to flare with a dazzling, fleeting brilliance. The light comes from a warm, off-screen desk lamp, casting a soft, focused beam that casts a subtle, shifting shadow on the paper. A stack of heavy books is faintly visible in the background, but completely blurred. The main colors of the entire picture are warm brown and beige, with dark blue ink and golden light on the tip of the pen as embellishments, creating an atmosphere of extreme tranquility, concentration and full of classical bookishness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4530,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000156/group_8/index_8685_seed_27928_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/195_0000156_group_8_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000156_group_8_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000156_group_8_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000156_group_8_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000156_group_8_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000156_group_8_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000156_group_8_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+196,0.02595602,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.58800000,6,0.00937105,0.00114010,0.00548730,0.79489177,0.58398438,0.07128906,0.00029188,0000168,group_10,3,q3,Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, close-up, static shot, captured from a slight overhead angle, focuses on a gentle Asian mother, comfortably seated in a vintage wooden armchair. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through a large window, casting a warm golden hue on her long, dark brown hair, pulled into a low bun, and the off-white, turtleneck cashmere sweater she wears. Her face holds a serene, focused expression, her eyes slightly downcast, her gaze completely focused on the work in her hands. Her hands move steadily and deliberately, two smooth bamboo knitting needles twirling between her deft fingers. One needle expertly picks up lavender yarn and delicately threads it through the loop of the other. A half-finished sweater drapes across her legs, its intricate, twisted pattern clearly visible in the light, each fluffy fiber seeming palpable, a vivid, textured expression. Beside her, a wicker basket filled with colorful balls of yarn rests on the ground. The bookshelves and greenery in the background are softly blurred by the shallow depth of field. The entire scene is warm and harmonious, imbued with the warmth of home and the tranquility of time brought by handmade crafts.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3011,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_8887_seed_8255_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/196_0000168_group_10_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+197,0.02589411,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.02511899,0.00299843,0.01474704,0.80304486,0.48485255,0.11132812,0.00026208,0000095,group_3,0,q5,"Is the environment a desolate, silent locker room with drab gray concrete walls and recessed metal lockers?",Yes,No,No,"static, eye-level medium shot, framed with documentary-style realism, captures a weary champion sitting perfectly centered on a worn wooden bench in a desolate, silent locker room. His sweat-dampened black hair clings to his forehead, his muscular shoulders slump with exhaustion, and a simple white towel hangs from his neck. He wears only a pair of dark gym shorts, and the white bandages on his hands are partially untied, dangling loosely. His face, etched with the physical toll of his victory, is a mask of exhaustion; his gaze is unfocused and glassy, staring past the camera into an unseen distance. Beside him, a massive, gleaming golden trophy sits on the bench, close yet pointedly overlooked, its polished surface catching the cold, sterile light from a single overhead fluorescent bulb, casting a bright, almost mocking reflection against the drab, gray concrete walls and the recessed metal lockers that line the room. He took a slow, deep breath, barely lifting his chest, and then let out a deliberately heavy, audible sigh, as if draining away the last of his energy, his body slumping further. The cheers of victory were a forgotten echo, replaced by the deep, hollow emptiness of the silent room and the grim reality of victory's consequences.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1432,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000095/group_3/index_6580_seed_12487_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/197_0000095_group_3_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q5__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q5__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q5__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q5__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q5__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q5__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+198,0.02584846,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.02158542,0.00255442,0.01268733,0.73067403,0.49047554,0.08398438,0.00136471,0000138,group_5,0,q5,Are red lanterns visible hanging from the eaves of the buildings in the scene?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera follows a young man from a low angle, parallel to him, panning smoothly to the right to capture him as he briskly navigates the streets on his bicycle. The young man, with his short, slightly tousled dark brown hair fluttering gently in the breeze, wears a relaxed, cheerful smile. He wears a simple white cotton T-shirt over an unbuttoned olive green work shirt, slim-fit washed blue jeans, and classic white canvas shoes. He rides a retro-style city bike with a bright yellow frame, a brown leather seat and grips, and a beige canvas messenger bag hanging from the handlebars. He leans slightly forward, his hands resting effortlessly on the handlebars, his legs pedaling with a steady, rhythmic rhythm, propelling the bike smoothly forward over the uneven cobblestone road. They were walking through a narrow, winding alleyway in the ancient town, flanked by traditional Chinese houses with mottled whitewashed walls and green-tiled roofs. Verdant vines clung to the walls, and red lanterns occasionally hung from the eaves. The warm afternoon sun filtered through the gaps between the buildings above, casting dappled, playful shadows on the ground and on him. The dominant colors of the scene were the gray of the slate and the white of the walls, accented by the bright yellow of the bicycle, the green of the vines, and the colors of his clothing, creating a tranquil, leisurely, and nostalgic atmosphere full of the flavor of life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2474,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000138/group_5/index_3219_seed_17218_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/198_0000138_group_5_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+199,0.02580749,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01159921,0.00139536,0.00680257,0.73289222,0.51034600,0.08398438,0.00087985,0000067,group_15,2,q1,Is the subject a man in his thirties with short dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a medium, slightly upward angle, the camera pans steadily to the right, closely following the subject's movements. In the frame, a man in his thirties, with short, dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard, leans slightly forward, his expression focused and serious. He wears a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt, the sleeves casually pushed up to his elbows, revealing his muscular forearms. He is in a softly lit bedroom, with the corner of a bed covered in white sheets visible in the background. Steadily and deliberately, the man extends his right arm toward a blue nylon travel bag on the bed. The bag features black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper, half-unzipped. As the camera follows, the thick wad of banknotes clutched in his left hand becomes visible. He then carefully places the wad of bills into the bag's open mouth, his fingers delicately moving as he pushes the money deeper into the bag. The natural morning light filtering in from a side window casts soft shadows on his arm and the surface of the travel bag, highlighting the texture of the nylon and the thickness of the banknotes. The dominant color scheme of the entire scene is the vibrant blue of the travel bag, the dark gray of the man's clothing, and the white of the bed sheet, creating an atmosphere of focus, intimacy, and a touch of tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3300,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_15/index_3450_seed_7520_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/199_0000067_group_15_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q1__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q1__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q1__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q1__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q1__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q1__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+200,0.02556197,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.02062164,0.00246389,0.01210517,0.81680036,0.49303001,0.11132812,0.00028789,0000111,group_12,2,q3,Does the scene take place in a sun-drenched room with uneven plastered earth walls and a small unglazed window?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium close-up tracking shot moves slowly and steadily with an elderly woman, her face a beautiful map of time, kind, wrinkled eyes, and a deep smile etched across her warm brown skin. Her silver-gray hair is neatly pulled back in a simple bun. She is draped in a traditional handwoven cotton sari in earthy tones of ochre and deep terracotta, with a simple embroidered border. She stands in a sun-drenched room, brimming with rustic charm, its uneven, plastered earth walls gleaming in the golden light of late afternoon. A bright ray of sunlight filters through a small, unglazed window, illuminating countless motes of dust dancing in the air. With a practiced, deliberate grace, she holds a thin, dark incense stick between her thumb and index finger. Her other hand holds a lit match to the tip, the small flame casting a fleeting, flickering warmth across her focused features. She held it until the tip glowed a vibrant orange, then blew gently, extinguishing the flame and releasing a thin, fragrant stream of gray-white smoke that curled gracefully upward, catching the light as it rose into the sunlight, creating a serene and deeply spiritual atmosphere of quiet reverence.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,214,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000111/group_12/index_9620_seed_15361_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/200_0000111_group_12_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+201,0.02553926,beside-next-to+between-flanked,5.08400000,8,0.00937432,0.00112178,0.00550169,0.71907532,0.48452315,0.09960938,0.00173622,0000088,group_6,0,q4,Are knitting needles and a forming scarf visible in the woman's hands?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady medium shot, captured from a slightly overhead, is rendered entirely in the style of a black-and-white pencil sketch. At the very center, a mother sits quietly in a dark wooden chair, her back to the camera. She wears a cozy home sweater, her hair loosely tied in a bun. An old-fashioned desk lamp provides the sole source of light, casting a warm, focused beam. This light, depicted in the sketch as a delicate field of white space and the lightest grays, precisely illuminates her focused back and the movements of her hands, while the rest of the room is shrouded in a deep, cross-hatched darkness. Her head is slightly lowered, her shoulders hunched forward, and her hands fly up and down with steady, deliberate movements. Two slender knitting needles intertwine between her deft fingers, a forming scarf dangling from them, its delicate texture sharply outlined in the light. As she gently tugged, the large, fluffy ball of yarn on the table beside her began to roll at an almost imperceptible pace, extremely slowly and irregularly. Each tiny twitch tugged at the lifeline connecting her hands. The entire scene, devoid of a single trace of superfluous color, consisted entirely of shifting lines and blocks of varying grayscale, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, warmth, and nostalgia.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1437,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000088/group_6/index_8179_seed_27126_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/201_0000088_group_6_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000088_group_6_sample_0_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+202,0.02552674,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.02772907,0.00333027,0.01626586,0.66656882,0.40890774,0.13769531,0.00268900,0000160,group_6,1,q2,"Is the tiger galloping with explosive force, its limbs fully extended and hind legs thrusting forward?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, sideways tracking shot closely follows a mythical white tiger as it gallops through an ancient, dense forest at night. Cold moonlight filters through the gaps between the tall, twisted canopies of ancient trees, casting a variegated, dynamic play of light and shadow across a ground covered in dead leaves and damp earth. The beast's snow-white, unblemished fur shimmers with a soft silver halo in the moonlight. Its muscular form ripples clearly beneath its fur as it gallops, and its icy blue eyes gleam with an otherworldly light in the darkness. Its limbs fully extended, it gallops with explosive force, its massive paws barely leaving a trace as it stamped across the ground. The trees in the background are reduced to blurred vertical lines by its breathtaking speed. As it approaches a massive, moss-covered fallen log that lies across the path, it doesn't slow at all. Its hind legs thrust forward, its entire body tracing an elegant, powerful white arc through the air. It effortlessly clears the obstacle, landing firmly on the other side and continuing its charge. Its breath becomes a visible white mist in the chill air. The image is dominated by deep midnight blue and inky black, with the white tiger itself as the most striking presence, creating an atmosphere imbued with a sense of primal power, mysterious elegance, and the beauty of speed.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3941,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000160/group_6/index_3107_seed_8017_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/202_0000160_group_6_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000160_group_6_sample_1_q2__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000160_group_6_sample_1_q2__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000160_group_6_sample_1_q2__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000160_group_6_sample_1_q2__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000160_group_6_sample_1_q2__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000160_group_6_sample_1_q2__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+203,0.02534691,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.01129757,0.00135547,0.00662807,0.65945947,0.47158885,0.07324219,0.00083646,0000132,group_7,0,q1,Is the main subject a man resembling the Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai with long dark hair and a flowing white silk robe?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, zoomed-out shot, starting from a slightly upward angle, first focuses on a massive bluestone by the river, bathed in moonlight. The great Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai reclines, half-drunk and intoxicated. His long, dark hair, undone by a bun, a few wet strands clinging to his drunken face. His features are rendered with remarkable clarity by the cool moonlight. He wears a flowing white silk robe with wide sleeves, the collar slightly open, revealing faint stains of dark wine on the folds. The hem of the robe falls limply on the mossy stone surface. His eyes are lightly closed, a faint, detached smile playing on his lips. His body is relaxed, his chest rising and falling with his deep, steady breathing. Beside him, an antique bronze wine jug has fallen, half-emptied between the moist moss and soil. The last drops of wine seem to linger on the mouth, reflecting a faint glow in the moonlight. As the camera steadily and deliberately pulls back, a wider scene is revealed: the vast river, like a vast black jade in the still night, a bright full moon casts a clear glow in the sky, spreading a fragmented, shimmering silver band across the water. In the distance, the inky silhouettes of rolling hills shrouded in mist. Nearby, a few clumps of reeds sway gently in the night breeze, rustling softly. The entire scene exudes a sense of ultimate tranquility and poetic solitude. The dominant color palette is deep blue-black and silver-white, and the strong contrast of light and shadow creates an otherworldly, classical aesthetic atmosphere of detachment from the world.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,722,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000132/group_7/index_6699_seed_26356_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/203_0000132_group_7_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q1__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q1__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q1__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q1__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q1__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q1__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+204,0.02528774,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01149655,0.00141287,0.00672246,0.69696295,0.50002891,0.08203125,0.00094643,0000067,group_15,3,q1,Is the subject a man in his thirties with short dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a medium, slightly upward angle, the camera pans steadily to the right, closely following the subject's movements. In the frame, a man in his thirties, with short, dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard, leans slightly forward, his expression focused and serious. He wears a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt, the sleeves casually pushed up to his elbows, revealing his muscular forearms. He is in a softly lit bedroom, with the corner of a bed covered in white sheets visible in the background. Steadily and deliberately, the man extends his right arm toward a blue nylon travel bag on the bed. The bag features black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper, half-unzipped. As the camera follows, the thick wad of banknotes clutched in his left hand becomes visible. He then carefully places the wad of bills into the bag's open mouth, his fingers delicately moving as he pushes the money deeper into the bag. The natural morning light filtering in from a side window casts soft shadows on his arm and the surface of the travel bag, highlighting the texture of the nylon and the thickness of the banknotes. The dominant color scheme of the entire scene is the vibrant blue of the travel bag, the dark gray of the man's clothing, and the white of the bed sheet, creating an atmosphere of focus, intimacy, and a touch of tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3303,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_15/index_3450_seed_7521_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/204_0000067_group_15_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_15_sample_3_q1__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_15_sample_3_q1__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_15_sample_3_q1__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_15_sample_3_q1__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_15_sample_3_q1__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_15_sample_3_q1__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+205,0.02520130,beside-next-to,2.46000000,8,0.01796397,0.00215544,0.01053902,0.78031939,0.50674731,0.08886719,0.00164831,0000024,group_6,3,q5,Does the man pick up a fishing net with a delicate green mesh and a thin metal handle after setting down the tank?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera begins with a medium shot at eye level, slowly and steadily panning to the right, following the action in a brightly lit modern kitchen. A young man with neatly combed short brown hair and wearing a soft, heather-gray cotton T-shirt leans slightly over a gleaming stainless steel sink. Steady in both hands, he holds a small, rectangular glass fish tank under a modern, gooseneck chrome faucet, a stream of clear water filling it. With serene concentration, he watches the water level rise. When it's nearly full, he deftly turns the faucet handle with his right hand, and the flow abruptly stops. Then, he carefully lifts the now-heavy tank, the water sloshing gently inside, and turns his body toward the adjacent, sleek, light-gray crystal countertop. The camera pan ends as he deliberately and quietly sets the tank down. After a brief pause, his gaze shifts, and he carefully picks up a small fishing net with a delicate green mesh and a thin metal handle, which has been placed next to the tank. The entire scene is bathed in bright, indirect morning light, streaming in through an invisible window, creating soft shadows that accentuate the clean lines of the white subway tile backsplash, creating an atmosphere of quiet, focused communality and gentle preparation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2454,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000024/group_6/index_1762_seed_1224_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/205_0000024_group_6_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+206,0.02516488,opposite-across,2.24400000,4,0.02021336,0.00245465,0.01183914,0.74986386,0.49538782,0.10156250,0.00270259,0000063,group_13,2,q3,Is the man wearing a vibrant yellow rain hoodie over jeans with brown hair plastered to his forehead?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"This medium, eye-level shot, captured with a handheld camera, subtly panning to heighten the chaos, shows a man in his 30s at the wheel of a gleaming, aluminum, adult-sized tricycle. He stands on a wide suburban street, slick and dark beneath a gray, cloudy sky from a recent rain. The man, his brown hair plastered to his forehead, wears a vibrant yellow rain hoodie over jeans. His face perfectly conceals a comical panic, eyes wide and mouth open. He is in the midst of a frantic fishtail; both rear wheels lose traction on the wet asphalt and slide sharply to one side, setting off a dramatic arc of water. He desperately twists the handlebars in opposite directions, his body leaning hard to balance the slide, his legs flailing as he struggles to keep his feet on the pedals. The tricycle's polished aluminum frame catches the diffused light, shimmering even as it careens uncontrollably. In the background, neat suburban houses and manicured lawns, slightly out of focus, provide a calming backdrop to the unfolding chaos. The entire shot is filled with subtle film grain, adding a cinematic and nostalgic quality to a chaotic and fun moment of pure, effortless panic.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2850,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000063/group_13/index_1415_seed_23248_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/206_0000063_group_13_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000063_group_13_sample_2_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000063_group_13_sample_2_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000063_group_13_sample_2_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000063_group_13_sample_2_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000063_group_13_sample_2_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000063_group_13_sample_2_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+207,0.02498008,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.02603750,0.00312023,0.01527818,0.66298491,0.40227824,0.14941406,0.00293374,0000103,group_2,1,q2,"Are the main characters tiny, button-like corals with large black eyes and bright smiles?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slightly high-angle wide shot, rendered in vibrant, polished Pixar-style animation, slowly pans forward and tilts downward, immersing the viewer in a bustling underwater world. Bright sunlight penetrates the clear, shimmering turquoise water from above, casting a dancing, corrosive pattern of light across a seabed of tinted, fine golden sand. A joyful community of tiny, button-like corals shuffles across the scene in a relaxed, joyful procession. Each creature radiates a rainbow of saturated pinks, sunny yellows, and deep purples, their surfaces smooth and glossy, their faces expressive, with large, inquisitive black eyes and bright, friendly smiles. They move with a delightful waddling gait, kicking up small balls of sand in their friendly collective activity, gently bumping and nudging each other in playful patterns, causing them to stagger momentarily before continuing their journey. Amidst this bustling migration, tiny, nuanced hermit crabs scurry between their legs, while soft, turquoise sea anemones sway gently in the background, creating a whimsical and heartwarming atmosphere of joyful, communal living.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4758,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000103/group_2/index_7370_seed_29007_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/207_0000103_group_2_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000103_group_2_sample_1_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000103_group_2_sample_1_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000103_group_2_sample_1_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000103_group_2_sample_1_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000103_group_2_sample_1_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000103_group_2_sample_1_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+208,0.02489238,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.02039696,0.00241636,0.01198707,0.81576413,0.52858579,0.09765625,0.00252819,0000149,group_4,1,q4,Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with a fluid, 360-degree panning shot, revealing a fairyland shrouded in dense, flowing mist. Like living white silk, these clouds drift slowly between the looming mountains. At the center of the frame, countless tiny energy points, shimmering with a soft bluish-white glow, like sentient fireflies, begin to be drawn by an invisible force. They converge from all directions, spiraling through the air in elegant spirals, accelerating and converging, ultimately forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the very center of the frame. Translucent, metallic-hued geometric lines form the delicate contours of the petals, which are filled with a shimmering crystal material. At its center lies a core of pure, pulsing energy. The moment the emblem took shape, it erupted with an intense yet subtle, holy light. This cool cyan and silver radiance instantly pierced the dense fog, illuminating the surrounding classical Chinese pavilions and towers suspended above the sea of clouds. The jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs of these buildings revealed their delicate textures in the light, while their eaves and corners cast dynamic light and shadow that shifted with the camera's movement. The entire process, dominated by a palette of deep indigo and mysterious purple, created an atmosphere of sacredness, solemnity, tranquility, and power. As the camera completed its full circular path, it fully showcased the spectacular fusion of ancient imagery and futuristic technology.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,353,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000149/group_4/index_4818_seed_33453_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/208_0000149_group_4_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000149_group_4_sample_1_q4__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000149_group_4_sample_1_q4__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000149_group_4_sample_1_q4__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000149_group_4_sample_1_q4__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000149_group_4_sample_1_q4__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000149_group_4_sample_1_q4__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+209,0.02476139,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.07200000,4,0.00739601,0.00089923,0.00433119,0.70744222,0.49710256,0.08105469,0.00030899,0000105,group_14,0,q2,"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium close-up shot from a level angle, slightly handheld and imbued with a subtle sense of shakiness, instantly draws the viewer into the bustling and vibrant atmosphere of a wet market. At the center of the frame is an elderly woman with a wrinkled face and graying hair tied in a simple bun. Time has carved deep grooves into her tanned skin, but her eyes are remarkably sharp and focused. She wears a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock, the fabric defined by its distinct texture and soft creases from repeated washing. Standing before a vegetable stall piled high with vibrant greens, carrots dusted with fresh soil, and plump tomatoes, she leans forward slightly, extending her age-freckled right hand. With her index and middle fingers, she decisively indicates a price, her lips pursed as she speaks rapidly and forcefully to the vendor off-screen. In her left hand, she clutches a woven bamboo basket, its edges frayed. The tarpaulin overhead casts dappled shadows, while a few suspended incandescent bulbs emit a warm, dim glow, illuminating the dust and moisture floating in the air and creating a stark contrast between the vibrant colors of the vegetables and the dark clothing of the elderly woman. The entire scene, shrouded in warm tones, exudes an atmosphere both tense and full of life, perfectly capturing the uncompromising moments of everyday transactions.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1222,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_8676_seed_3866_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/209_0000105_group_14_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000105_group_14_sample_0_q2__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000105_group_14_sample_0_q2__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000105_group_14_sample_0_q2__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000105_group_14_sample_0_q2__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000105_group_14_sample_0_q2__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000105_group_14_sample_0_q2__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+210,0.02467268,left-right-pair+foreground-background,6.86400000,4,0.00685841,0.00081812,0.00402686,0.77053338,0.46484077,0.10937500,0.00034475,0000039,group_9,2,q2,"Is a woman with thick, dark, curly hair wearing a vibrant red knitted beanie visible?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3800,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8144_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/210_0000039_group_9_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+211,0.02466005,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.02561018,0.00306009,0.01503340,0.70524448,0.44140366,0.12597656,0.00252968,0000131,group_10,0,q4,Is the sky filled with thick dark clouds and a pale setting sun casting a dominant gray-blue hue?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from an upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward, focusing on an ancient soldier perched atop a desolate mountain ridge. Beside him stands a weathered beacon tower, constructed of massive stone blocks, its surface covered in cracks and moss, a silent witness to the howling wind. The soldier's long, black hair is tied back, strands whipping wildly against his weathered face in the biting wind. He wears a suit of worn, dark iron scale armor, its plates scarred by past battles. The hem of his dark, coarse linen tabard flaps violently in the wind. His feet, firmly planted on the rough ground, he draws a massive longbow made of dark, knotty wood with controlled force, the bow creaking mournfully under the immense tension. As the bowstring is drawn to his cheek, the muscles of his arms and back visibly tense beneath his armor, making him look like a statue poised for action. His brow furrowed, his lips pursed, his eyes narrowed in the gusting wind, but his cold, resolute gaze, sharp as an eagle's, fixed its gaze firmly on an invisible target beyond the camera. In the sky, thick, dark clouds rolled rapidly, and the pale, setting sun struggled to cast a faint, cold light, painting the entire scene with a dominant gray-blue hue. The light outlined the cold metal contours of the armor and the rough texture of the rocks, creating an epic atmosphere of loneliness, awe, and resolute will.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,528,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000131/group_10/index_9686_seed_32974_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/211_0000131_group_10_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+212,0.02461504,left-right-pair,3.72000000,3,0.01215887,0.00145363,0.00713683,0.82112741,0.49400663,0.11132812,0.00021160,0000018,group_1,1,q4,Is the dancer spinning on the toe of her left foot with her eyes closed and a hint of a smile?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle and panning slowly to the right, captures a solitary dancer, lost in the ecstasy of a twirl in the center of a grand yet empty Baroque ballroom. Her long, dark brown curls are elegantly tied into a loose bun, a few strands of hair freed from their restraints as she spins, gently brushing against her serene face, eyes closed and a hint of a smile playing on her lips. She wears a deep, royal blue, sleeveless silk gown, the tight bodice emphasizing her slender waist. The massive, multi-tiered skirt, lifted high by centrifugal force as she steadily and effortlessly spun, pivoting on the toe of her left foot, unfolds like a fully blossoming blue flower, almost parallel to the ground, its pleats drawing graceful, undulating curves in the air. A massive crystal chandelier atop the soaring dome casts a warm, radiant golden light, illuminating the mirror-like polished marble floor, which reflects the dancers' twirling figures and the blurred motion of their skirts, as well as the intricate gold reliefs on the walls. Light filters through the swirling skirts, casting ever-shifting, interwoven patterns of light and shadow on the floor. The entire scene, bathed in warm hues, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility, dreamy elegance, and a touch of solitary elegance.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4382,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000018/group_1/index_2695_seed_29086_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/212_0000018_group_1_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000018_group_1_sample_1_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000018_group_1_sample_1_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000018_group_1_sample_1_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000018_group_1_sample_1_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000018_group_1_sample_1_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000018_group_1_sample_1_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+213,0.02459402,left-right-pair+foreground-background+beside-next-to,8.84400000,4,0.00529223,0.00063253,0.00310647,0.77970964,0.47139746,0.10937500,0.00020713,0000039,group_9,2,q3,"Is the woman wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat and standing near a white-painted paneled front door?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level shot peers through the diamond pattern of a teal mesh fence, which remains slightly blurred in the foreground, creating a voyeuristic perspective. The camera's focus is fixed on a woman with thick, dark, curly hair, partly tucked into a vibrant red knitted beanie. She sits on the left side of the frame, wearing a heavy, dark blue wool coat, standing outside the white-painted, paneled front door of a house. To her left, the house's beige stucco wall stretches into the background, punctuated by a window with a clean white frame that softly reflects the overcast sky. At first, her expression remains one of cautious observation, glancing around and turning her head deliberately. Then, she begins steadily walking toward the camera, her body moving from the center, closer to the foreground mesh. As she walks, her gaze shifts rapidly to the right and then to the left, as if searching for someone or ensuring she's not being watched. Her pace gradually slows until she halts hesitantly, her proximity to the camera and obstructed view creating a tense and intimate atmosphere of quiet suspense in the soft, unfocused daylight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3799,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_9/index_9923_seed_8144_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/213_0000039_group_9_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_9_sample_2_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+214,0.02452580,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.02005732,0.00239542,0.01177461,0.81133801,0.48938400,0.11132812,0.00022814,0000117,group_9,2,q1,"Is the main subject a thin, middle-aged man with a neatly trimmed goatee and long hair held back by a wooden hairpin?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a thin, middle-aged strategist with a neatly trimmed goatee, nestled within a dimly lit military tent. He wears a loose, flowing dark blue silk robe, his long hair held back with a simple wooden hairpin. He reclines leisurely on an antique carved wooden chair. The only illumination comes from a bronze oil lamp on a table beside him. Its flickering, warm yellow light casts deep, undulating shadows on his face, emphasizing his pensive expression and illuminating the folds of his silk robe with a soft sheen. In his right hand, he grasps a feather fan made of pure white crane feathers, gently waving it with a steady, leisurely rhythm, the breeze occasionally causing the lamplight to flicker. In the background, a military map hangs on the thick dark canvas tent wall, and a wooden weapons rack with unfolded bamboo slips and weapons can be vaguely seen next to it. The whole scene has a warm tone, mainly deep dark colors, creating an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tranquility and strategic planning against the backdrop of military tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3124,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000117/group_9/index_9345_seed_1225_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/214_0000117_group_9_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q1__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q1__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q1__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q1__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q1__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q1__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+215,0.02449361,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.02204829,0.00259570,0.01296840,0.78571904,0.45025727,0.12500000,0.00007468,0000050,group_14,1,q1,Is the scene set inside a spacious military tent with thick canvas walls?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly but steadily advances, drawing the viewer's attention into a spacious military tent. The only illumination comes from the flickering flame of a candle in an antique bronze candlestick at the corner of the table, its unsteady glow casting large, oscillating shadows on the thick canvas walls. A general with a ruddy complexion and a thick, black beard leans over a rough wooden marching table. He wears a heavy, worn suit of dark red metal armor, the beastly patterns carved on his shoulder plates reflecting a dull luster in the firelight. His furrowed brow carves a deep, crisscross pattern on his forehead, and his hawk-like eyes stare intently at a yellowed parchment map spread out on the table. The map's intricate, ink-lined outlines of mountains, rivers, and military markings appear intricate. His gaze wasn't static, but moved slowly and carefully between several key red markers on the map. His hands, braced on the edge of the table, their knuckles white from exertion. His entire posture exuded strength and focus. The flickering candlelight cast bright highlights on his high cheekbones and nose, while deepening the shadows of his eye sockets and cheeks, adding depth to his resolute expression. The entire scene was warm and deep, imbued with ochre, brown, and dark gold, creating an atmosphere of solemnity and intense tension as a decision-maker grappled alone on the eve of a crucial battle.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2400,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000050/group_14/index_2691_seed_20353_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/215_0000050_group_14_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q1__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q1__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q1__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q1__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q1__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000050_group_14_sample_1_q1__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+216,0.02447536,beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,7.48800000,7,0.00637571,0.00076468,0.00374069,0.64140183,0.43877360,0.09277344,0.00029987,0000158,group_8,0,q5,Is the scene illuminated by warm golden light from a low-hanging lamp casting soft shadows?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures an intimate moment of passionate conversation between two friends in a dimly lit, cozy bistro. A woman in her twenties, with wavy auburn hair loosely pulled back and wearing a soft cream-colored sweater, leans forward, a gentle smile on her face as she speaks. Across from her, a man of similar age, wearing a dark green button-down shirt with the sleeves casually rolled up to his forearms, listens intently, his head slightly tilted, a look of genuine engagement. Between them, on a small, round, dark wooden table, lie two elegant, large glasses half-filled with deep red wine. As the woman shares her story, her right hand gracefully and expressively gestures near the bowl of her glass, while the man's hand rests near the base of his own, his fingers leisurely tracing the polished wood. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden light of a low-hanging lamp, casting soft shadows on their faces and causing the wine to gleam, creating a tranquil and welcoming atmosphere of easy friendship and shared confidence.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2602,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000158/group_8/index_5750_seed_15303_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/216_0000158_group_8_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+217,0.02433533,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.80800000,6,0.00796703,0.00092121,0.00469721,0.66103131,0.37074810,0.16015625,0.00385976,0000123,group_11,2,q3,Is the woman performing a side bend with her right arm extended upward and her left hand on her hip?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot in a surreal style, this slow, orbiting medium shot smoothly orbits a woman going about her morning activities in a lush garden at dawn. She has long, dark brown hair, loosely tied in a high ponytail, with a few stray strands gently framing her face. Her eyes are gently closed, her expression serene and focused. She wears a fitted, long-sleeved heather-gray yoga top, the soft, breathable fabric subtly textured, paired with high-waisted, dark teal leggings. Her body gracefully stands in side bend; her right arm extends deliberately and fluidly upward and over her head, elongating her torso, while her left hand rests lightly on her hip. The entire pose maintains a steady, controlled grace. The camera's slow, circular path reveals the immersive environment: she stands barefoot on a manicured lawn, still damp with morning dew. The garden is filled with vibrant green ferns and blooming rose bushes with soft, pink and white petals. The first rays of warm, golden sunlight penetrate the light morning mist between the leaves of the tall, mature trees in the background, backlighting her body and capturing millions of tiny, shimmering dewdrops on the grass and leaves, creating a shimmering bokeh effect. The interplay of warm, low-angle light and cool, soft shadows creates a serene scene of profound calm and focus, and the camera movement enhances the contemplative and visually rich atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,735,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000123/group_11/index_7140_seed_22007_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/217_0000123_group_11_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000123_group_11_sample_2_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000123_group_11_sample_2_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000123_group_11_sample_2_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000123_group_11_sample_2_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000123_group_11_sample_2_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000123_group_11_sample_2_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+218,0.02427412,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.01066974,0.00126839,0.00626757,0.72100228,0.49842650,0.08300781,0.00078595,0000132,group_7,1,q2,Is the man depicted in a reclining posture with his eyes lightly closed and a faint smile on his lips?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, zoomed-out shot, starting from a slightly upward angle, first focuses on a massive bluestone by the river, bathed in moonlight. The great Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai reclines, half-drunk and intoxicated. His long, dark hair, undone by a bun, a few wet strands clinging to his drunken face. His features are rendered with remarkable clarity by the cool moonlight. He wears a flowing white silk robe with wide sleeves, the collar slightly open, revealing faint stains of dark wine on the folds. The hem of the robe falls limply on the mossy stone surface. His eyes are lightly closed, a faint, detached smile playing on his lips. His body is relaxed, his chest rising and falling with his deep, steady breathing. Beside him, an antique bronze wine jug has fallen, half-emptied between the moist moss and soil. The last drops of wine seem to linger on the mouth, reflecting a faint glow in the moonlight. As the camera steadily and deliberately pulls back, a wider scene is revealed: the vast river, like a vast black jade in the still night, a bright full moon casts a clear glow in the sky, spreading a fragmented, shimmering silver band across the water. In the distance, the inky silhouettes of rolling hills shrouded in mist. Nearby, a few clumps of reeds sway gently in the night breeze, rustling softly. The entire scene exudes a sense of ultimate tranquility and poetic solitude. The dominant color palette is deep blue-black and silver-white, and the strong contrast of light and shadow creates an otherworldly, classical aesthetic atmosphere of detachment from the world.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,723,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000132/group_7/index_6699_seed_26357_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/218_0000132_group_7_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q2__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q2__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q2__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q2__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q2__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q2__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+219,0.02426029,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01174800,0.00140467,0.00689555,0.79775023,0.46645892,0.12500000,0.00095496,0000067,group_15,0,q2,"Is the man wearing a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt with sleeves pushed up to his elbows?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a medium, slightly upward angle, the camera pans steadily to the right, closely following the subject's movements. In the frame, a man in his thirties, with short, dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard, leans slightly forward, his expression focused and serious. He wears a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt, the sleeves casually pushed up to his elbows, revealing his muscular forearms. He is in a softly lit bedroom, with the corner of a bed covered in white sheets visible in the background. Steadily and deliberately, the man extends his right arm toward a blue nylon travel bag on the bed. The bag features black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper, half-unzipped. As the camera follows, the thick wad of banknotes clutched in his left hand becomes visible. He then carefully places the wad of bills into the bag's open mouth, his fingers delicately moving as he pushes the money deeper into the bag. The natural morning light filtering in from a side window casts soft shadows on his arm and the surface of the travel bag, highlighting the texture of the nylon and the thickness of the banknotes. The dominant color scheme of the entire scene is the vibrant blue of the travel bag, the dark gray of the man's clothing, and the white of the bed sheet, creating an atmosphere of focus, intimacy, and a touch of tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3293,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_15/index_3450_seed_7518_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/219_0000067_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+220,0.02424631,beside-next-to,1.98000000,4,0.02269027,0.00270910,0.01332078,0.70074219,0.45919970,0.10058594,0.00183067,0000093,group_7,0,q4,Are steep cliffs shimmering in deep crimson visible on one side of the road next to the ocean?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, dynamic tracking shot follows a rider from the side as he speeds along a winding coastal tarmac road on a metallic crimson Harley-Davidson cruiser. The setting sun, sinking below the horizon, paints the world in a warm, saturated hue of gold and orange, imbuing the image with a rich cinematic quality. The rider leans forward slightly, his hands firmly gripping the handlebars. His dark brown hair flows back in the wind, and his face wears a focused, resolute expression. He wears a classic black leather jacket, unzipped, its hems and collar flapping dramatically in the strong sea breeze. He wears a simple white T-shirt underneath. On one side of the road lies the vast, shimmering ocean, its golden sunlight dancing across the surface. On the other, steep cliffs, shimmering a deep crimson, are illuminated by the sunset glow. The motorcycle sprints forward at a very fast speed, the chrome exhaust pipe and engine parts reflect the dazzling light, the wheels rotate at high speed and almost turn into a shadow, casting a long, constantly moving shadow on the road together with the rider. The whole picture is full of freedom, unrestrainedness and a magnificent sense of loneliness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3217,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000093/group_7/index_3185_seed_29230_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/220_0000093_group_7_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000093_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000093_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000093_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000093_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000093_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000093_group_7_sample_0_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+221,0.02417657,foreground-background,3.08000000,5,0.01395157,0.00165640,0.00819678,0.82668936,0.51569611,0.10253906,0.00250846,0000082,group_9,2,q5,Are the faces of the friends in the background blurred into warm spots of light (bokeh) while the hand remains in focus?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a cozy, humanistic interior, a fluid single shot begins at table level, then slowly and gracefully pans rightward across a warm dining scene. A long, dark wooden table, covered with a beige linen tablecloth, is laden with half-eaten home-cooked dishes and scattered crumbs. Several friends, dressed in cozy sweaters and casual shirts, gather around the table. Their faces are blurred by a soft bokeh, yet their genuine smiles and lively gestures, engaged in conversation, are clearly visible. As the camera pans, the focus gradually and seamlessly shifts from the joyful gathering in the background to the central subject in the foreground: a woman's hand, delicately lifting a glass of white wine from the table. Steady and composed, her nails immaculately manicured, the hand elegantly grasps the slender stem of a classic crystal goblet. The glass is about one-third full of pale golden white wine, and under the soft light cast by a low, warm-toned chandelier overhead, the wine's clarity is translucent, shimmering with sparkling shimmer. As the wine glasses are slowly raised to the center of the picture, the smiling faces and figures of the friends in the background are completely blurred into warm spots of light (Bokeh) and soft blocks of color. The whole picture is wrapped in an intimate, peaceful and joyful atmosphere. The main colors are warm amber and cream, and the contrast of light and shadow is soft, perfectly capturing this peaceful and sincere moment of celebration.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4833,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000082/group_9/index_3890_seed_29050_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/221_0000082_group_9_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q5__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q5__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q5__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q5__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q5__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q5__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+222,0.02403684,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.02005817,0.00237572,0.01178830,0.73709428,0.49458617,0.08398438,0.00136989,0000138,group_5,0,q2,Is the young man wearing a white cotton T-shirt over an unbuttoned olive green work shirt?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera follows a young man from a low angle, parallel to him, panning smoothly to the right to capture him as he briskly navigates the streets on his bicycle. The young man, with his short, slightly tousled dark brown hair fluttering gently in the breeze, wears a relaxed, cheerful smile. He wears a simple white cotton T-shirt over an unbuttoned olive green work shirt, slim-fit washed blue jeans, and classic white canvas shoes. He rides a retro-style city bike with a bright yellow frame, a brown leather seat and grips, and a beige canvas messenger bag hanging from the handlebars. He leans slightly forward, his hands resting effortlessly on the handlebars, his legs pedaling with a steady, rhythmic rhythm, propelling the bike smoothly forward over the uneven cobblestone road. They were walking through a narrow, winding alleyway in the ancient town, flanked by traditional Chinese houses with mottled whitewashed walls and green-tiled roofs. Verdant vines clung to the walls, and red lanterns occasionally hung from the eaves. The warm afternoon sun filtered through the gaps between the buildings above, casting dappled, playful shadows on the ground and on him. The dominant colors of the scene were the gray of the slate and the white of the walls, accented by the bright yellow of the bicycle, the green of the vines, and the colors of his clothing, creating a tranquil, leisurely, and nostalgic atmosphere full of the flavor of life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2476,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000138/group_5/index_3219_seed_17218_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/222_0000138_group_5_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000138_group_5_sample_0_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+223,0.02395234,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+between-flanked,8.54000000,5,0.00525956,0.00062456,0.00309000,0.77083147,0.47947797,0.10253906,0.00197744,0000162,group_1,2,q3,Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2599,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18206_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/223_0000162_group_1_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000162_group_1_sample_2_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+224,0.02389652,between-flanked,2.62400000,9,0.01663734,0.00198589,0.00976763,0.80645943,0.48826167,0.10937500,0.00010306,0000046,group_4,1,q4,"Are other townspeople visible, specifically an elderly couple walking arm in arm and a baker dusting flour from his apron?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a warm, Studio Ghibli-inspired style, a steady, eye-level, medium tracking shot follows a young woman as she carefully crosses a sun-dappled cobblestone street. Her dark brown hair is pulled back in a simple, loose braid, resting on the shoulders of a cream cotton shirt. With gentle focus, she pedals steadily and deliberately on a classic Dutch freight tricycle, its light blue frame showing subtle, charming signs of wear. The large wooden cargo box out front is filled with a vibrant, picturesque display of fresh produce and flowers; vibrant yellow sunflowers and purple lavender stalks jut out from between heads of crisp green lettuce, bright red tomatoes, and round onions. As the tricycle moves, its wheels clattering gently against the uneven, mossy cobblestones, the camera sliding parallel to it, capturing the shifting patterns of golden light filtering through the leaves of the trees overhead. The setting shows a quaint storybook town square with half-timbered buildings, terracotta roofs, and window boxes blooming with geraniums, while the other gentle townspeople—an elderly couple walking arm in arm, a baker dusting flour from his apron—add to the scene’s serene, painterly atmosphere of peaceful daily life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2547,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000046/group_4/index_8058_seed_7664_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/224_0000046_group_4_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q4__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q4__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q4__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q4__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q4__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q4__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+225,0.02365687,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.02130326,0.00255190,0.01250091,0.83465487,0.51239687,0.11523438,0.00057197,0000083,group_2,1,q4,"Does the woman exhibit violent coughing with convulsing shoulders, jerking head, and tightly squeezed eyes?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"An extreme close-up shot from a low angle, slowly and relentlessly zooming in, intensifies the focus on a grieving young woman. Her brown hair is pulled back in a simple ponytail, with loose strands catching the sunlight like thin golden threads. She wears thin wire-rimmed glasses and a crisp light blue cotton dress shirt. The entire frame is dominated by the raw physicality of a violent cough that convulses her body; her shoulders arch violently, and her head jerk forward with each spasmodic, uncontrollable thump. Her eyes, already watery with underlying sorrow, squeeze tightly in agony, and her face flushes. The scene is bathed in a warm, ethereal golden hour light, creating a soft halo around her body against the blurred backdrop of an outdoor night. The stark contrast between the serene, beautiful light and her inner anguish creates an intense, poignant, and intimate atmosphere of vulnerability and pain.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,365,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000083/group_2/index_7917_seed_11921_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/225_0000083_group_2_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000083_group_2_sample_1_q4__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000083_group_2_sample_1_q4__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000083_group_2_sample_1_q4__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000083_group_2_sample_1_q4__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000083_group_2_sample_1_q4__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000083_group_2_sample_1_q4__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+226,0.02352588,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.34000000,5,0.01110131,0.00131211,0.00652614,0.64604813,0.41217148,0.12207031,0.00237608,0000168,group_10,2,q5,Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, close-up, static shot, captured from a slight overhead angle, focuses on a gentle Asian mother, comfortably seated in a vintage wooden armchair. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through a large window, casting a warm golden hue on her long, dark brown hair, pulled into a low bun, and the off-white, turtleneck cashmere sweater she wears. Her face holds a serene, focused expression, her eyes slightly downcast, her gaze completely focused on the work in her hands. Her hands move steadily and deliberately, two smooth bamboo knitting needles twirling between her deft fingers. One needle expertly picks up lavender yarn and delicately threads it through the loop of the other. A half-finished sweater drapes across her legs, its intricate, twisted pattern clearly visible in the light, each fluffy fiber seeming palpable, a vivid, textured expression. Beside her, a wicker basket filled with colorful balls of yarn rests on the ground. The bookshelves and greenery in the background are softly blurred by the shallow depth of field. The entire scene is warm and harmonious, imbued with the warmth of home and the tranquility of time brought by handmade crafts.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,254,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_8887_seed_8254_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/226_0000168_group_10_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q5__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q5__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q5__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q5__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q5__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000168_group_10_sample_2_q5__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+227,0.02351543,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.01159161,0.00140349,0.00679208,0.70861614,0.43973693,0.11132812,0.00016147,0000156,group_8,2,q3,Is the scene set on an elegant dark wood desk with a stack of heavy books faintly visible and blurred in the background?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera pans incredibly slowly to the right, delicately tracking the movement of a hand writing on an elegant, dark wood desk. The hand's slender fingers firmly and firmly grasp a delicate black fountain pen with a gold-rimmed barrel. Its gleaming metallic iridium tip glides effortlessly and steadily across a sheet of thick, off-white stationery, leaving behind a trail of evenly inked, dark blue cursive. At this moment, a soft, warm, slightly iridescent lens flare, as if carefully choreographed, slowly sweeps across the left side of the frame, grazing the moving metal tip and causing it to flare with a dazzling, fleeting brilliance. The light comes from a warm, off-screen desk lamp, casting a soft, focused beam that casts a subtle, shifting shadow on the paper. A stack of heavy books is faintly visible in the background, but completely blurred. The main colors of the entire picture are warm brown and beige, with dark blue ink and golden light on the tip of the pen as embellishments, creating an atmosphere of extreme tranquility, concentration and full of classical bookishness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4528,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000156/group_8/index_8685_seed_27927_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/227_0000156_group_8_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000156_group_8_sample_2_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000156_group_8_sample_2_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000156_group_8_sample_2_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000156_group_8_sample_2_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000156_group_8_sample_2_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000156_group_8_sample_2_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+228,0.02347457,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01771447,0.00212811,0.01039091,0.76820970,0.54413766,0.07714844,0.00033283,0000104,group_13,0,q3,Is the scene set in a tranquil marsh with crystal-clear water rising around the stems?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot, rendered in a lush, hand-drawn, Ghibli-inspired art style, focuses on a clump of tall cattail plants at the center of the frame. Their fibrous green stems, with their soft, painterly texture, are topped with distinctive spikes of velvety flowers a rich chocolate brown. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of the afternoon sun, illuminating the tranquil marsh setting. Crystal-clear water rises steadily and deliberately around the green stems, its calm surface like a mirror, reflecting the soft hues of pink, pale gold, and lavender against the sky. Tiny, shimmering dragonflies, their iridescent wings, dance and hover in the air between the reeds, their delicate movements adding a touch of life and magic. The combination of the impending tide, the warm, bright lighting, and the classic animation aesthetic creates an overwhelming atmosphere of tranquility and magic.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4740,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000104/group_13/index_9683_seed_27120_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/228_0000104_group_13_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+229,0.02341362,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.02272843,0.00270932,0.01334607,0.82473612,0.49528894,0.11425781,0.00001967,0000072,group_14,3,q3,Is a minimalist white ceramic bowl with a smooth low-gloss finish visible at the center of the table?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, slightly high-angle close-up elegantly frames the carefully arranged composition on a polished, dark walnut coffee table in a sleek, modern living room. A minimalist white ceramic bowl with a smooth, low-gloss finish sits at its center. Filled with a vibrant assortment of fresh fruit—a crisp green apple, a ripe red pear, and a small bunch of deep purple grapes—their surfaces catch a subtle, healthy sheen from a nearby light source. Juxtaposed against the bowl is a slender black remote control, its matte plastic casing and minimalist design creating a striking geometric contrast to the bowl's organic form. The entire scene is bathed in warm ambient light from a large, out-of-focus window. The soft afternoon sunlight casts long, gentle shadows across the table's polished texture, highlighting the distinct grains of the ceramic, fruit, and wood. The ambiance is one of profound tranquility and refined elegance, emphasizing the quiet harmony and deliberate contrast between natural and technological objects.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4214,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000072/group_14/index_5030_seed_24535_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/229_0000072_group_14_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+230,0.02339715,beside-next-to,1.98000000,4,0.02259714,0.00270563,0.01326101,0.70139742,0.44844544,0.11718750,0.00232387,0000135,group_8,2,q2,Is the first athlete wearing a red and white striped jersey stained with grass and sweat?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slightly low-angle, handheld medium-length shot captures two male athletes locked in a tight embrace on a vibrant green football field, under the bright, cool white glare of the stadium's floodlights. The first athlete, his sweat-drenched black hair plastered to his forehead, buries his face in his teammate's shoulder; his muscular body, clad in a red and white striped jersey stained with grass and sweat, trembles with overwhelming emotion. The second athlete, a more muscular blonde, wraps his arms tightly around his teammate, his right hand gently cradling the back of his friend's head in a gesture of support, his own face a picture of shared exhaustion and profound relief. The harsh overhead lighting carves sharp highlights into their gleaming skin and creates deep shadows in the folds of their embrace, while in the background, the stadium's packed stands blur into a blur of color, celebratory confetti slowly falling. The scene then abruptly switches to an extreme close-up of the first athlete's face, as he recoils slightly, his eyes squeezed shut, tears streaming down his grime-stained cheeks, his jaw clenched. Then, the second athlete’s face zooms out, his blue eyes welling up, a tear following a path beside his nose, and he offers a small, melancholic, yet reassuring smile, as rapid succession of shots amplify the raw, unfiltered catharsis of their shared moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2811,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000135/group_8/index_8405_seed_692_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/230_0000135_group_8_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000135_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000135_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000135_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000135_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000135_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000135_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+231,0.02324853,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.02201953,0.00258899,0.01295369,0.80567986,0.46186969,0.12500000,0.00005028,0000141,group_12,2,q5,Is there a sharp golden outline on the man's suit caused by the fading evening sun?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic drone shot follows closely, following an Asian man in a crisp, dark charcoal-gray suit as he glides smoothly through the vast air between two skyscrapers with a grace that defies the laws of physics. Slightly above his horizon, the camera captures his elongated, steady form, as if he were stepping on invisible air, his movements reminiscent of a martial arts master. Beneath his impeccably tailored suit jacket lies a crisp white shirt and a narrow, dark silk tie that billows backwards in the wind, its hems undulating but never a touch disheveled. His face is calm and focused, his gaze fixed firmly on the platform of the next building ahead. The fading light of the evening sun casts a sharp golden outline on his dark suit, casting a shifting, warm glow across the surrounding glass walls. Below is a bustling city canyon. The lights of countless vehicles have merged into a flowing river of light. The sky is dyed a gradient of warm orange-red and deep purple. Thin clouds and mist are lingering between the buildings. The whole picture combines the elegance of martial arts, the grandeur of surrealism and the coldness of the modern city, creating a breathtaking visual spectacle.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,957,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000141/group_12/index_3944_seed_30078_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/231_0000141_group_12_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+232,0.02317822,left-right-pair,4.20000000,5,0.01055899,0.00126156,0.00619829,0.71721804,0.46492136,0.10937500,0.00171274,0000009,group_15,0,q3,"Is the woman sitting at a small, round cast-iron table on a sunny restaurant terrace, holding a smartphone to her right ear?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"This static, eye-level medium shot captures a woman with a chic, short, slightly tousled bob, sitting at an outdoor cafe. She wears a short-sleeved shirt made of lightweight fabric with a delicate, pastel floral pattern against a cream background. She sits comfortably at a small, round cast-iron table on the sunny restaurant terrace, leaning slightly forward and holding a modern smartphone to her right ear. Amidst a lively conversation, a warm, relaxed smile graces her lips, her eyes crinkling slightly as she speaks, her head tilted with interest. Her left hand rests on the tabletop, her fingers leisurely stroking the rim of a glass of espresso iced tea. In the background, the restaurant's blurred facade, with its large windows and dark green awning, is visible, while the soft, out-of-focus shapes of other patrons create a gentle sense of ambient activity. The entire scene is illuminated by the warm midday sun, which filters through a large parasol, casting a soft, diffuse glow that eliminates harsh shadows and creates an overall relaxed, down-to-earth, and joyful atmosphere of a pleasant afternoon.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2969,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_15/index_4081_seed_18320_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/232_0000009_group_15_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+233,0.02310357,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.02221971,0.00263058,0.01305942,0.73347634,0.45254204,0.12207031,0.00264210,0000018,group_4,3,q4,"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pans upward through a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light penetrates the mist and dense bamboo foliage, casting visible beams of light in the air. The camera finally settles on a woman in a traditional Chinese costume, dressed in an elegant aquamarine silk robe. Her long, cascading black hair is held together only partially by a simple jade hairpin. Her face is clear and beautiful, her eyes focused and ethereal. With a light touch of the ground, her entire body rises as if weightless. The camera instantly switches to a fast, dynamic tracking shot, following her graceful figure as she nimbly weaves between the towering bamboo branches. Her wide sleeves flutter like butterfly wings as she moves swiftly, her skirt carving graceful arcs through the mist. A series of rapidly alternating close-ups follows: the tip of her shoe, delicately embroidered with cloud patterns, lightly steps on a dewy bamboo leaf, which trembles only slightly before returning to its composure; a strand of hair brushes across her focused and serene profile, revealing her perfectly defined jawline; her slender fingers form an elegant sword-like gesture in the air, steadily and calmly directing her body. The entire sequence is seamless, the camera language sharp and precise, capturing every moment of her ethereal, ethereal beauty. Amidst the cool tones of light and the lingering mist, an ethereal atmosphere is created, imbued with both martial arts power and poetic imagery.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1726,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_5716_seed_17760_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/233_0000018_group_4_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+234,0.02308866,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.02611764,0.00310499,0.01534177,0.58295077,0.38020143,0.13476562,0.00059801,0000006,group_10,2,q5,Is the sky a gradient of blue hues with large white pixelated clouds casting shifting shadows?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide-angle, static time-lapse video captured from above recreates the scenery of Ciqikou, Chongqing, in a distinctive 8-bit pixel art style. Ancient stone steps, composed of rough gray and brown pixels, wind down, flanked by traditional wooden buildings constructed from dark brown pixels. Their iconic eaves and corners are simplified into hard pixel lines, and their windows are simple, glowing squares. On these narrow streets, an abstract crowd, composed of tiny pixels in vibrant colors, surges like a tide, forming a steady, swift flow of pixels down the stone steps. The sky background is a gradient of several blue hues. Several large, white, pixelated clouds drift past in unnatural, blocky formations, casting shifting, pixelated shadows on the ground. The color palette of the entire picture is strictly limited, and the relationship between light and shadow is expressed through the brightness and darkness of pixel blocks, creating a strong sense of retro and digital feeling. With a unique dynamic beauty, it perfectly reproduces the vibrant and nostalgic atmosphere of early electronic games.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2230,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000006/group_10/index_9163_seed_24870_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/234_0000006_group_10_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000006_group_10_sample_2_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000006_group_10_sample_2_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000006_group_10_sample_2_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000006_group_10_sample_2_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000006_group_10_sample_2_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000006_group_10_sample_2_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+235,0.02303775,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.02178170,0.00257828,0.01280228,0.82861722,0.51380676,0.10644531,0.00309557,0000002,group_7,3,q2,"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide, low-angle shot captures an apocalyptic scene. In the sky, thick, inky storm clouds piled up, nearly reaching the sea level, only a hint of eerie cold light piercing the horizon. Beneath this oppressive canopy, a mountain-like wave relentlessly pressed against the rugged, rocky coastline. This towering wall of water, a deep turquoise, its surface wrinkled and creased, crowned by a roiling crest of chaotic white foam, resembles a moving, angry mountain range of crystal. As the wave crashes with thunderous force against the dark, slippery rocks, eroded by the sea, it erupts with astonishing force, sending up a massive column of white spray and foam that nearly touches the clouds. Countless tons of seawater are ripped into billions of crystalline droplets in the air, cascading down to rejoin the surging ocean below. The entire picture presents a cold monochrome tone in the dim light, with only the dazzling white flashing when the waves splash, creating a majestic, primitive and awe-inspiring tense atmosphere, full of the irresistible wild power of nature.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1535,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_7/index_4618_seed_27260_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/235_0000002_group_7_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_7_sample_3_q2__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_7_sample_3_q2__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_7_sample_3_q2__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_7_sample_3_q2__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_7_sample_3_q2__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_7_sample_3_q2__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+236,0.02294000,left-right-pair,4.44000000,6,0.00983423,0.00116745,0.00577786,0.73136741,0.46680087,0.10742188,0.00102472,0000030,group_9,1,q2,Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"An eye-level, static medium shot frames a young man with unkempt brown hair, dressed in a casual gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants, as he cleans a modern living room. Soft daylight streams in from an unseen window, casting gentle reflections on the polished hardwood floor. He initially holds a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand, moving it at a steady pace. His focused work is abruptly interrupted when he clumsily kicks the trailing black power cord with his left foot, tangling it. With a frustrated sigh, he deftly shifts the vacuum cleaner to his right hand, bending steadily at the waist and carefully picking up the loosened cord with his left hand before standing straight. To continue his work, he briefly presses his right foot on the base of the vacuum cleaner to stabilize it, then pushes it forward and resumes cleaning. Then, his attention shifts; he glances to his left, his face partially illuminated by the flickering, colorful glow of a television, playing a vibrant cartoon. As his eyes remain glued to the screen, his hands continue to vacuum back and forth, now more automatically and with less precision, perfectly capturing a moment of distracted, everyday family life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,890,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000030/group_9/index_2120_seed_2725_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/236_0000030_group_9_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000030_group_9_sample_1_q2__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000030_group_9_sample_1_q2__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000030_group_9_sample_1_q2__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000030_group_9_sample_1_q2__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000030_group_9_sample_1_q2__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000030_group_9_sample_1_q2__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+237,0.02293352,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.02180690,0.00256237,0.01282969,0.80036390,0.45802253,0.12500000,0.00016779,0000141,group_12,2,q1,Is the main subject an Asian man wearing a dark charcoal-gray suit with a white shirt and a dark silk tie?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic drone shot follows closely, following an Asian man in a crisp, dark charcoal-gray suit as he glides smoothly through the vast air between two skyscrapers with a grace that defies the laws of physics. Slightly above his horizon, the camera captures his elongated, steady form, as if he were stepping on invisible air, his movements reminiscent of a martial arts master. Beneath his impeccably tailored suit jacket lies a crisp white shirt and a narrow, dark silk tie that billows backwards in the wind, its hems undulating but never a touch disheveled. His face is calm and focused, his gaze fixed firmly on the platform of the next building ahead. The fading light of the evening sun casts a sharp golden outline on his dark suit, casting a shifting, warm glow across the surrounding glass walls. Below is a bustling city canyon. The lights of countless vehicles have merged into a flowing river of light. The sky is dyed a gradient of warm orange-red and deep purple. Thin clouds and mist are lingering between the buildings. The whole picture combines the elegance of martial arts, the grandeur of surrealism and the coldness of the modern city, creating a breathtaking visual spectacle.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,958,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000141/group_12/index_3944_seed_30078_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/237_0000141_group_12_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000141_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+238,0.02281151,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01778305,0.00211176,0.01044753,0.80058098,0.52223462,0.09472656,0.00146440,0000050,group_11,3,q3,"Is the man wearing a faded, frayed dark blue Mao suit with ripped hems and cuffs?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld camera, shot from a slightly elevated angle, follows a ragged elderly man as he walks down a muddy, rain-soaked country road. His sparse, short, graying hair is ruffled by the cold wind. His bronzed face is etched with deep, knife-like wrinkles, and his sunken eyes hold a gaze that is a mixture of fatigue and steeliness. He wears a faded, frayed dark blue Mao suit, the hems and cuffs ripped. He wears a gray shirt underneath, the collar yellowed, and his equally worn, dark trousers are splattered with damp mud. Under the gloomy evening sky, the thick clouds cast a faint, cold, scattered light, casting a chilling gray-brown hue on the entire scene. His steps were heavy and unsteady, each one sinking deeply into the sticky mud. Pulling out his stick was incredibly laborious, his body swaying from side to side, struggling to maintain balance with a crude crutch carved from a tree branch, tightly clenched in one hand. The road flanked by bleak winter fields, bare branches trembling slightly in the wind. The entire scene is imbued with a raw documentary quality, devoid of embellishment, focused solely on capturing every step of the old man's struggle against adversity, conveying a poignant, authentic, and resilient atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2697,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000050/group_11/index_3100_seed_11389_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/238_0000050_group_11_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q3__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q3__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q3__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q3__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q3__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000050_group_11_sample_3_q3__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+239,0.02277926,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.01719944,0.00203263,0.01011120,0.81611139,0.46998960,0.12500000,0.00012285,0000027,group_6,3,q4,Does the scene include ancient Hui-style buildings with whitewashed walls and black tiles?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, long, dynamic tracking shot follows a knight as he rides a majestic black steed at full speed along an ancient bluestone path. The knight is clad in a deep blue, coarse linen robe, its sleeves and hem dancing wildly in the wind. His hair is tied up in a high bun, strands of it rustling against his resolute face. He leans forward slightly, one hand firmly gripping the reins, the scabbard of the longsword at his waist swaying rhythmically with the horse's jerk. Beneath his steed, its muscles bulging, its glossy fur shimmering in the light. Its hooves fly, their collisions with the bluestone pavement sending up dust and scattered sparks. They speed past a cluster of ancient, pristine Hui-style buildings. The whitewashed walls and black tiles appear remarkably tranquil in the warm twilight. The staggered, undulating horse-head walls create a rhythmic skyline, while details of carved wooden window lattices flash by in the rapid movement. The afterglow of the setting sun dyes the entire picture with a warm golden color, lengthening the shadows of the buildings and the riders, creating a desolate and classical martial arts style atmosphere full of heroic spirit, with a strong contrast between movement and stillness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2912,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000027/group_6/index_544_seed_3828_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/239_0000027_group_6_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000027_group_6_sample_3_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000027_group_6_sample_3_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000027_group_6_sample_3_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000027_group_6_sample_3_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000027_group_6_sample_3_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000027_group_6_sample_3_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+240,0.02238169,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00978067,0.00115801,0.00574844,0.73913032,0.50535506,0.08300781,0.00014836,0000053,group_1,2,q3,"Is a massive crystal chandelier visible, casting dancing golden rays and shimmering reflections on a black marble floor?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"majestic, sweeping, high-angle drone shot slowly glides forward and slightly downward, revealing a grand Gothic ballroom rendered in stunning, surreal 3D. A soaring vaulted ceiling with dark stone ribs reaches into the shadows above, flanked by towering stained-glass arched windows that depict a somber and romantic scene. The entire opulent space is illuminated by the warm, shimmering glow of a massive crystal chandelier, whose thousands of facets cast dancing golden rays across the highly polished black marble floor, creating near-perfect, shimmering reflections. Below, hundreds of guests gathered in intimate groups, dressed in exquisite gowns of deep velvet, shimmering silks, and intricate lace in rich jewel tones like crimson, emerald, and sapphire, alongside men in sharp, dark tuxedos. Each guest's identity is concealed behind an intricate phantom mask, ranging from simple, elegant dominoes to ornate creations composed of wire and dark feathers. As the camera continues its steady, almost imperceptible descent, the quiet nature of their conversation becomes apparent, not through sound but through their subtle, deliberate gestures: a fan tapping gently against a gloved palm, a masked head tilting slightly, conspiratorially, a hand gesturing elegantly to emphasize a silent point. The atmosphere is rich with luxurious mystery and exquisite elegance, a breathtaking picture of secret grandeur, where warm light catches the glint of jewels or the metallic sheen of masks, casting long, soft shadows that twist and dance with the flickering candlelight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4951,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000053/group_1/index_4424_seed_17767_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/240_0000053_group_1_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000053_group_1_sample_2_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000053_group_1_sample_2_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000053_group_1_sample_2_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000053_group_1_sample_2_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000053_group_1_sample_2_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000053_group_1_sample_2_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+241,0.02232673,between-flanked,2.36800000,6,0.01781494,0.00212015,0.01046319,0.71960986,0.44773480,0.10449219,0.00160718,0000091,group_8,0,q3,Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The shot begins in a medium shot, slightly overlooking, with a steady focus on an elderly angler. He wears a wide, frayed bamboo hat, casting a shadow over his weathered face, revealing only a long, graying beard that sways gently in the breeze. Dressed in a simple, dark gray linen jacket, the elderly man sits poised in the center of a rustic wooden boat, its hull a deep brown from years of waterlogging. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender bamboo fishing rod, his line plummeting into the calm, mirror-like surface of the lake, creating only barely perceptible ripples where it enters. The soft, diffuse morning light evenly bathes the water, reflecting the hazy outlines of the sky and distant mountains. The scene is shrouded in a tranquil slate-gray and ink-wash hue. As the camera begins to steadily and slowly pull back, the picture gradually widens, and the figures of the boat and the old man slowly shrink in his world. Finally, he turns into a lonely and harmonious ink dot on the vast lake, completely merging with the rolling indigo mountains shrouded in mist in the background, creating a sense of harmony between man and nature, tranquility and eternity full of oriental philosophical poetry.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3651,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000091/group_8/index_163_seed_16726_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/241_0000091_group_8_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+242,0.02228720,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.00977515,0.00115341,0.00574782,0.72497153,0.51499784,0.06640625,0.00011525,0000156,group_8,1,q3,Is the scene set on an elegant dark wood desk with a stack of heavy books faintly visible and blurred in the background?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera pans incredibly slowly to the right, delicately tracking the movement of a hand writing on an elegant, dark wood desk. The hand's slender fingers firmly and firmly grasp a delicate black fountain pen with a gold-rimmed barrel. Its gleaming metallic iridium tip glides effortlessly and steadily across a sheet of thick, off-white stationery, leaving behind a trail of evenly inked, dark blue cursive. At this moment, a soft, warm, slightly iridescent lens flare, as if carefully choreographed, slowly sweeps across the left side of the frame, grazing the moving metal tip and causing it to flare with a dazzling, fleeting brilliance. The light comes from a warm, off-screen desk lamp, casting a soft, focused beam that casts a subtle, shifting shadow on the paper. A stack of heavy books is faintly visible in the background, but completely blurred. The main colors of the entire picture are warm brown and beige, with dark blue ink and golden light on the tip of the pen as embellishments, creating an atmosphere of extreme tranquility, concentration and full of classical bookishness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4526,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000156/group_8/index_8685_seed_27926_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/242_0000156_group_8_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000156_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000156_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000156_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000156_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000156_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000156_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+243,0.02226871,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+between-flanked,8.54000000,5,0.00541070,0.00065133,0.00317292,0.69023830,0.41085389,0.12792969,0.00029141,0000162,group_1,1,q5,Is a man in a forest green jacket visible bending down to search the floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2596,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18205_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/243_0000162_group_1_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+244,0.02198646,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01832810,0.00218219,0.01076394,0.78186238,0.51492316,0.09472656,0.00032711,0000166,group_5,2,q3,Does the scene take place in a turbulent sky swirling with dark storm clouds?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"magnificent 360-degree slow-motion shot, shot from a slightly upward perspective, captures the epic battle between two mythical phoenixes amidst a turbulent sky swirling with dark storm clouds. One phoenix is composed entirely of flowing magma and incandescent fire, each feather a pure, pulsating crimson and gold flame. Its eyes are like blazing embers, and its flight leaves a dazzling trail of sparks and embers in its wake. The other phoenix, in stark contrast, is carved from translucent ice crystals, its feathers razor-sharp icicles gleaming with sapphire and cyan. Its wings, with their beats, scatter countless tiny, glittering frost particles, and its icy eyes are like distant stars. The camera smoothly rotates around them, capturing every detail as they swirl, dive, and claw at each other in a deadly aerial ballet: the fire phoenix folds its wings sharply, swooping down like a flaming meteor, while the ice phoenix gracefully sideways, blocking with the edge of its crystal wings. When the camera rotates to the optimal angle, the two divine birds have a fierce head-on collision. The burning feathers collide with the icy feathers, and a dazzling energy shock wave instantly erupts - the hot sparks hiss and turn into steam when they come into contact with the cold air, while the hard ice crystals explode into countless glittering fragments under the high temperature, intertwined with the falling and extinguished flame feathers, forming a destructive picture full of primitive power and magnificent beauty. The whole scene, with the extreme contrast of warm and cold colors, creates a tense, intense and sacred fantasy atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3921,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000166/group_5/index_6042_seed_32801_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/244_0000166_group_5_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+245,0.02188971,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01847272,0.00225079,0.01081462,0.69211429,0.49238497,0.08105469,0.00013506,0000148,group_15,3,q2,"Is the main subject an elderly man with deeply wrinkled skin, thinning gray hair, and a dark blue cotton double-breasted jacket?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"tightly composed, static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, imbues the image with the rich colors and intense humanity that are hallmarks of Steve McCurry's photography. In a steaming, slightly crowded, old Chinese kitchen, an elderly man, his face deeply wrinkled and his hair thinning with gray, is absorbed in his cooking. A warm, directional light slants down from above and sideways, precisely outlining the contours of his bronzed face and his pursed lips. His deep eyes gleam with concentration amidst the swirling steam. He wears a washed-out, dark blue cotton double-breasted jacket, sleeves neatly rolled to the elbows, revealing his muscular, vein-filled forearms. Steady in his right hand, he grips a long-handled spatula and stirs the vibrantly colored ingredients in the dark cast iron wok with a deft, powerful rhythm. Each stroke of the spatula ignites a small, bright flame that licks the edge, emitting a sizzling sound. Thick white steam rises from the pot, layered in the light, blurring the yellowed tiled wall and the hanging strings of dried chilies behind it. The image is richly saturated, creating a striking yet harmonious contrast between the deep blue of the top, the vibrant red and green of the ingredients, and the golden sheen of the copper spoon in the background. This creates a warm atmosphere of simplicity, focus, and vitality, capturing a moment of dignity and beauty in everyday life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3998,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000148/group_15/index_4012_seed_27661_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/245_0000148_group_15_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+246,0.02180800,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.00956881,0.00113750,0.00562088,0.77775997,0.53242236,0.08105469,0.00178930,0000067,group_15,0,q1,Is the subject a man in his thirties with short dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a medium, slightly upward angle, the camera pans steadily to the right, closely following the subject's movements. In the frame, a man in his thirties, with short, dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard, leans slightly forward, his expression focused and serious. He wears a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt, the sleeves casually pushed up to his elbows, revealing his muscular forearms. He is in a softly lit bedroom, with the corner of a bed covered in white sheets visible in the background. Steadily and deliberately, the man extends his right arm toward a blue nylon travel bag on the bed. The bag features black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper, half-unzipped. As the camera follows, the thick wad of banknotes clutched in his left hand becomes visible. He then carefully places the wad of bills into the bag's open mouth, his fingers delicately moving as he pushes the money deeper into the bag. The natural morning light filtering in from a side window casts soft shadows on his arm and the surface of the travel bag, highlighting the texture of the nylon and the thickness of the banknotes. The dominant color scheme of the entire scene is the vibrant blue of the travel bag, the dark gray of the man's clothing, and the white of the bed sheet, creating an atmosphere of focus, intimacy, and a touch of tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3294,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_15/index_3450_seed_7518_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/246_0000067_group_15_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q1__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q1__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q1__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q1__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q1__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_15_sample_0_q1__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+247,0.02180107,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.00856546,0.00102454,0.00502728,0.79650807,0.49729940,0.10449219,0.00046906,0000056,group_3,1,q1,Is the subject Sun Wukong (the Monkey King) depicted in a steady horse stance with legs slightly bent?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,114,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26610_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/247_0000056_group_3_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q1__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q1__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q1__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q1__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q1__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_1_q1__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+248,0.02179679,beside-next-to+between-flanked,3.84400000,3,0.01069471,0.00127927,0.00627695,0.77312553,0.46875510,0.10937500,0.00057241,0000062,group_1,0,q3,"Is the setting a vast, sun-drenched atrium with a grand staircase of wide, immaculate white marble steps and minimalist glass railings?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, low-angle shot gazes upon a state-of-the-art stair-climbing wheelchair, situated at the foot of a grand staircase within a vast, sun-drenched atrium. This machine is an engineering marvel, constructed from a blend of matte black carbon fiber and polished silver aluminum, its metal surface catching bright highlights from the ambient light. Instead of traditional wheels, it features a complex, sturdy track system made of thick, grippy rubber, primed for climbing. The scene is set against the backdrop of a grand staircase composed of wide, immaculate white marble steps that ascend out of frame, flanked by sleek, minimalist glass railings. Bright, warm sunlight filters through the vast floor-to-ceiling windows off-camera, casting long, softly edged shadows across the highly polished concrete floor and illuminating a cloud of dust dancing in the still air. With a near-silent, high-frequency hum, the wheelchair begins a slow, deliberate rotation, one track system maintaining its position while another engages, causing the chassis to rotate with unwavering mechanical precision. This meticulous movement helps to perfectly align the machine with the base of the first step, creating a moment of immersion in an atmosphere of tranquility and concentration, where the profound silence of the vast space emphasizes the elegance and purpose of the technology, ready to face the challenge.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4228,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000062/group_1/index_9031_seed_1623_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/248_0000062_group_1_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000062_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000062_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000062_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000062_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000062_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000062_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+249,0.02175081,left-right-pair+foreground-background,6.44800000,3,0.00567165,0.00067068,0.00333398,0.82388389,0.58022583,0.07910156,0.00240743,0000118,group_2,1,q4,Is a fallen man's hand visible twitching on the stained concrete in the lower foreground?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shaky, eye-level handheld shot shakes violently, struggling to depict the chaotic aftermath of a clash on a gritty city sidewalk. The camera first captures a man, dressed head-to-toe in a black zip-up hoodie and dark jeans, looking around, eyes wide and terrified. As he staggers backward, his arms swing in a wide, uncontrolled arc for balance, his body blurring as he awkwardly exits the left side of the frame. The camera then pans erratically to the right, resting on his opponent, who stands uncomfortably in a clean white crew-neck T-shirt and a dark baseball cap. He speaks calmly, his expression unreadable, and deliberately raises his right hand. With two fingers gripping it precisely, he tilts the brim upward, briefly and methodically wiping his forehead with the back of his palm, then replaces it. His hand then drops, disappearing casually into his trouser pocket. In the lower foreground, lying on the stained concrete, the hand of a fallen man twitches, a faint, seemingly final movement. The background is a series of moving, blurred bystanders scattering in panic, their blurred forms evacuating the scene. The entire event is illuminated by the harsh, flat light of an overcast sky, creating a stark, documentary-like feel and a palpable, thick atmosphere of post-violence tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4081,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000118/group_2/index_4089_seed_20983_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/249_0000118_group_2_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000118_group_2_sample_1_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000118_group_2_sample_1_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000118_group_2_sample_1_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000118_group_2_sample_1_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000118_group_2_sample_1_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000118_group_2_sample_1_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+250,0.02166462,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.44000000,5,0.00556407,0.00068087,0.00325547,0.80124038,0.59500331,0.07031250,0.00100869,0000089,group_1,1,q3,"Is a bone-shaped biscuit held by an off-screen hand visible, moving slowly and precisely left and right across the frame?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a vertical, hand-painted image, captured in a medium close-up shot at eye level, an owner's hand, off-screen, slowly and playfully lures a golden Labrador puppy with a bone-shaped biscuit. The puppy's fluffy, warm-gold fur glows softly under the bright, warm, diffuse light. Its large, round, dark eyes gleam with desire, its pupils dilating as the biscuit moves, completely captivated by the treat. Its head sways with precise precision as the light-gold biscuit, delicately held between its fingers, slowly and precisely shifts left and right across the frame. Its pink tongue lolls out, its saliva glistening from the corner of its mouth, its greedy expression both innocent and comical. A warm, softly blurred interior background focuses the attention on this anticipatory interaction. The visual style of the entire picture resembles a classic children's book illustration, with soft lines, saturated colors and a watercolor-like texture. Every detail, from the fluffy feel of the dog's hair to the crispy texture of the biscuits, is vividly depicted, creating an atmosphere that is rich in details, full of childlike fun and warm and healing.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4137,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000089/group_1/index_621_seed_30121_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/250_0000089_group_1_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000089_group_1_sample_1_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000089_group_1_sample_1_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000089_group_1_sample_1_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000089_group_1_sample_1_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000089_group_1_sample_1_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000089_group_1_sample_1_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+251,0.02163832,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01856269,0.00221800,0.01089646,0.71020818,0.45012900,0.11718750,0.00312418,0000066,group_8,3,q1,Is the main subject an elderly craftsman with thinning silver hair and a deeply lined face?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady medium shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, draws the viewer's attention to an elderly craftsman. His face, etched with age and deeply lined with wrinkles, his eyes narrowed in intense concentration beneath his thinning silver hair. He wears a washed-out, dark blue cotton double-breasted jacket and sits hunched over a heavy wooden workbench covered with sawdust and various carving tools. His left hand, calloused yet remarkably steady, carefully supports a rudimentary wooden sculpture—perhaps a small bird—while his right grips a sharp carving knife. The knife's tip gleams coldly in the warm light of a low-hanging tungsten bulb above the workbench. With his steady, precise movements, a thin, cicada-wing-thin shavings slowly curl and fall, drifting into the pile of sawdust piled on the workbench. This concentrated light not only illuminates the delicate work in his hands, but also casts deep shadows on his focused profile and rough hands, forming a strong contrast between light and dark and the dim, messy but orderly workshop in the background. The whole picture is immersed in an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration and a sense of time.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4219,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000066/group_8/index_9877_seed_31824_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/251_0000066_group_8_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000066_group_8_sample_3_q1__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000066_group_8_sample_3_q1__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000066_group_8_sample_3_q1__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000066_group_8_sample_3_q1__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000066_group_8_sample_3_q1__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000066_group_8_sample_3_q1__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+252,0.02160307,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.62000000,5,0.00871933,0.00103401,0.00512354,0.68157941,0.46283415,0.08300781,0.00010422,0000077,group_1,3,q2,Is the man wearing professional black headphones and a simple black T-shirt?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, medium-close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a man immersed in musical composition. He has short, dark brown hair and wears a pair of professional black headphones. He rhythmically and immersively nods his head up and down to the rhythmic music, his eyes slightly closed, his expression intensely focused. He is in a dimly lit recording studio, facing a complex professional mixing console, its surface densely packed with faders and illuminated buttons. His right hand's fingers move delicately and precisely across the control panel, carefully gripping a silver EQ knob between his thumb and index finger, steadily and deliberately adjusting it to find the perfect tonal balance. The only light comes from the multicolored LEDs flashing on the mixing console and the screens of the various devices in the background. These dynamic dots of light cast shifting shadows on his face, emphasizing his simple black T-shirt and his focused profile. The whole picture is based on deep dark tones, dotted with blue, red and green light emitted by the equipment, creating an intimate, passionate and creative atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3694,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000077/group_1/index_3928_seed_17717_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/252_0000077_group_1_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+253,0.02157832,left-right-pair,4.44000000,6,0.00891408,0.00105214,0.00524129,0.70997471,0.47843188,0.08398438,0.00169563,0000087,group_9,0,q3,Is a man with neatly cropped brown hair wearing a navy blue button-down shirt visible in the center?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion doll begins in a bright, modern kitchen studio, capturing three dynamic shots at eye level. In the center, a man with neatly cropped brown hair and a friendly, engaging expression is speaking actively, emphasizing his words with expressive gestures. He wears a crisp navy blue button-down shirt. To his right, a woman with blonde hair tied in a sleek ponytail and a professional-looking soft pink shirt steadily lifts a clear glass bottle filled with golden liquid from a pristine white marble countertop. Her other hand precisely grasps the metallic silver cap and deftly twists it open. To the man's left, another woman in a crisp white chef's coat is absorbed in her work, her hands moving expertly as she carefully handles fresh ingredients, perhaps arranging vibrant green herbs on a dark wooden cutting board. The entire scene is bathed in bright, diffused studio light, eliminating harsh shadows and highlighting the clean lines of the stainless steel appliances blurred in the background, creating an atmosphere of warmth, collaboration, and high professionalism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,849,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000087/group_9/index_5711_seed_24663_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/253_0000087_group_9_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000087_group_9_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000087_group_9_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000087_group_9_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000087_group_9_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000087_group_9_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000087_group_9_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+254,0.02155686,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01713452,0.00207986,0.01003644,0.78196520,0.55338544,0.07812500,0.00195664,0000142,group_12,1,q4,Is the environment an inky black abyss containing craggy volcanic rocks and ghostly deep-sea plants?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide, slow-motion pan shot, shot from a slight upward angle, captures a giant octopus gliding effortlessly through the deep, inky abyss of the ocean floor. The behemoth's skin, far from the texture of flesh and blood, is a living, fluid display, a constantly shifting pattern of intricate bioluminescent hues of electric blue, neon purple, and magenta. As if streams of data are coursing beneath its surface, it creates a vibrant, digital art-like sheen. Its large, intelligent eyes radiate a soft golden glow, a striking contrast to the kaleidoscopic hues of its body. It propels itself through the rhythmic, powerful contraction and expansion of its vast mantle, while its eight long, powerful tentacles gracefully undulate behind it like silken ribbons in a hypnotic, coordinated dance, their suction cups pulsing with faint light. Its own light, the sole source of illumination in this inky black world, casts an ethereal, shifting light on the craggy volcanic rocks and occasional ghostly deep-sea plants below. Tiny particles floating in the water are illuminated like shimmering stardust. An otherworldly sense of tranquility and awe permeates the entire scene, seamlessly blending the grandeur of nature with a digital aesthetic to create a visual spectacle that is both mysterious and breathtaking.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1390,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000142/group_12/index_2489_seed_5419_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/254_0000142_group_12_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q4__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q4__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q4__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q4__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q4__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q4__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+255,0.02145995,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.09200000,3,0.00979575,0.00115947,0.00575752,0.75647956,0.47512820,0.10253906,0.00187987,0000093,group_6,2,q4,Does the afternoon sun filter through twisted ancient pine branches to cast dappled light and shadows on the figures?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, drawn-out shot, beginning with a delicately composed, slightly upward mid-shot, focuses on the depths of an ancient temple courtyard. An elderly monk, bald and deeply wrinkled between his forehead and eyes, wears a soft, naturally wrinkled ochre-red robe, faded by time. He stands tall, his face solemn and serene. In one hand, he holds a string of dark Buddhist beads, while the other hangs naturally at his side. His gaze is determined and compassionate. Opposite him, a massive white snake, its entire body coated in a soft, ivory sheen, raises its head high, reaching the monk's eye level. Its golden, vertical pupils convey no hint of murderous intent, but rather a glimmer of ancient, human wisdom. The snake's body coils tightly on the mossy stone floor, dotted with scattered, withered bodhi leaves, imbued with a sense of poised power. The afternoon sun filters through the twisted branches of the ancient pines in the courtyard, casting dappled light and shadow, perfectly outlining the monk's silhouette and the texture of his robes, while also causing the giant snake's scales to reflect a pearly shimmer. As the camera steadily and deliberately moves backward, the figures of the two men and the snake gradually diminish within the magnificent temple setting. In the background, stone lanterns carved with lotus patterns, quaint wooden corridors, and a corner of the hall with its soaring eaves and brackets slowly come into view. The entire scene, shrouded in the subtle scent of sandalwood, creates a tranquil atmosphere that transcends time, imbued with Zen and a mysterious tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3635,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000093/group_6/index_3519_seed_6356_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/255_0000093_group_6_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000093_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+256,0.02131865,left-right-pair,4.20000000,5,0.01059493,0.00129285,0.00620139,0.55303508,0.39222854,0.10937500,0.00146884,0000170,group_0,0,q3,Is a weary woman in faded blue canvas overalls with black hair in a loose ponytail visible exiting the bus?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from a slightly elevated angle, slowly pans to the right as a bus, its paint peeling and slightly worn, lurches to a halt on the curb. Finally, it stabilizes as the pneumatic doors hiss open. The first thing that comes into view is a hand gripping the door's metal armrest, polished to a shine by countless hands. Then, a weary woman in faded blue canvas overalls appears in the doorway. Her black hair is casually tied into a loose ponytail, a few strands clinging to her forehead with sweat. Her face is marked by a deep weariness, her eyelids heavy and her gaze dim. The dim light inside the bus highlights her slightly slumped shoulders, contrasting with the cool dusk outside. Carefully, she places one heavy, dusty work boot on the ground, then, with a heavy, almost dragging hand, descends the last step. The asphalt beneath her feet is damp from the recent rain, reflecting the scattered streetlights in the distance. As her weight completely left the bus, the bus body swayed slightly. The whole picture was filled with a quiet yet deep atmosphere of fatigue after get off work, with the interweaving of cold blue and warm yellow light and shadow.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4480,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000170/group_0/index_4261_seed_6135_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/256_0000170_group_0_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000170_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000170_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000170_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000170_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000170_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000170_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+257,0.02125775,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01703867,0.00203060,0.01000538,0.80388761,0.49848285,0.10253906,0.00072652,0000160,group_10,1,q2,Is the man wearing a heather-gray cotton short-sleeved shirt and a dark blue baseball cap?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium close-up depicts a man with a neatly trimmed dark brown beard, wearing a heather-gray cotton short-sleeved shirt and a dark blue baseball cap. He stands in the center of a sun-drenched meadow, the soft-focus background revealing tall green grass and scattered yellow wildflowers in the warm, golden afternoon light. His gaze is intently directed downward at a small metal ring delicately held between the thumb and index finger of each hand. He carefully wipes away specks of dark dirt from the surface, his lips moving as he speaks, narrating his actions with an air of focused discovery. He fluidly turns his head momentarily to the left, as if to greet someone off-screen, before quickly returning his gaze to the precious object in his hands, his expression a mixture of concentration and quiet excitement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3504,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000160/group_10/index_3321_seed_14242_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/257_0000160_group_10_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+258,0.02120584,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.02170731,0.00255080,0.01277100,0.78391266,0.44837645,0.12500000,0.00110248,0000002,group_7,2,q2,"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide, low-angle shot captures an apocalyptic scene. In the sky, thick, inky storm clouds piled up, nearly reaching the sea level, only a hint of eerie cold light piercing the horizon. Beneath this oppressive canopy, a mountain-like wave relentlessly pressed against the rugged, rocky coastline. This towering wall of water, a deep turquoise, its surface wrinkled and creased, crowned by a roiling crest of chaotic white foam, resembles a moving, angry mountain range of crystal. As the wave crashes with thunderous force against the dark, slippery rocks, eroded by the sea, it erupts with astonishing force, sending up a massive column of white spray and foam that nearly touches the clouds. Countless tons of seawater are ripped into billions of crystalline droplets in the air, cascading down to rejoin the surging ocean below. The entire picture presents a cold monochrome tone in the dim light, with only the dazzling white flashing when the waves splash, creating a majestic, primitive and awe-inspiring tense atmosphere, full of the irresistible wild power of nature.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1534,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_7/index_4618_seed_27259_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/258_0000002_group_7_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_7_sample_2_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_7_sample_2_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_7_sample_2_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_7_sample_2_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_7_sample_2_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_7_sample_2_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+259,0.02114003,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.44000000,5,0.00551444,0.00067222,0.00322815,0.79128486,0.57517564,0.07128906,0.00057811,0000136,group_9,3,q4,Does the man place a glass jar with a plain metal lid onto the bottom shelf of the cabinet?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures the scene in a brightly lit modern kitchen. A man with slightly tousled brown hair casually walks toward a set of lower cabinets. He wears a red and white checkered, short-sleeved button-down shirt and contrasting teal checkered shorts, creating a relaxed, homely look. He pauses before a white, rickety cabinet and reaches down deliberately, his fingers grasping the small, brushed metal knob. He smoothly pulls the door open, revealing shelves filled with a messy yet organized pantry: an assortment of unlabeled glass jars, colorful tins, and plain cardboard boxes. Holding a simple glass jar with a plain metal lid in his right hand, he takes a step closer, bending slightly at his knees and waist, and carefully reaches into the cabinet. Steadily and accurately, he places the jar on the bottom shelf, nestled between a stack of jars and a box. Once his fingers release the jar, he straightens and begins to rotate his body to the left. As he begins to turn away from the open cabinet, his movements are fluid and unhurried, completing a simple chore. The scene is bathed in warm, soft light from overhead fixtures, creating a comfortable and tranquil atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,48,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000136/group_9/index_5875_seed_11774_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/259_0000136_group_9_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q4__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q4__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q4__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q4__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q4__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q4__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+260,0.02113413,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01560795,0.00192863,0.00911955,0.80993629,0.57698733,0.07910156,0.00175780,0000160,group_10,2,q2,Is the man wearing a heather-gray cotton short-sleeved shirt and a dark blue baseball cap?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium close-up depicts a man with a neatly trimmed dark brown beard, wearing a heather-gray cotton short-sleeved shirt and a dark blue baseball cap. He stands in the center of a sun-drenched meadow, the soft-focus background revealing tall green grass and scattered yellow wildflowers in the warm, golden afternoon light. His gaze is intently directed downward at a small metal ring delicately held between the thumb and index finger of each hand. He carefully wipes away specks of dark dirt from the surface, his lips moving as he speaks, narrating his actions with an air of focused discovery. He fluidly turns his head momentarily to the left, as if to greet someone off-screen, before quickly returning his gaze to the precious object in his hands, his expression a mixture of concentration and quiet excitement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3507,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000160/group_10/index_3321_seed_14243_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/260_0000160_group_10_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+261,0.02102729,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.34000000,5,0.00933728,0.00109797,0.00549288,0.80992204,0.46363142,0.12500000,0.00006783,0000101,group_2,2,q3,Is a middle-aged man wearing a dark silk scarf and a wide-sleeved black robe sitting at a heavy dark wooden desk?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, close-up shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, focuses the viewer's attention on a scene illuminated by the flickering flame of an ancient copper oil lamp. At the center of the frame lies a middle-aged strategist, wearing a dark silk scarf and a wide-sleeved black robe. He sits at a heavy, dark wooden desk, his brow furrowed, his eyes sharp as an eagle's, his gaze fixed intently on the object before him. The warm, dancing light casts deep shadows on his chiseled features, highlighting his lips pursed in deep thought. His slender, powerful hands, carefully, steadily, and deliberately, slowly unroll a bamboo map bound by string. As he moves, the polished bamboo strips rub against each other, creating a crisp, subtle rustling sound. The map's ink-drawn mountains and rivers, along with the cinnabar-marked military fortresses, gradually emerge in the dim light, exuding a sense of age and age. Beside him, on the desk, rests a feather fan crafted from white crane feathers, its ebony handle gleaming softly in the light. The painting's warm, deep tones, predominantly dark browns and oranges, create a stark contrast between light and shadow, evoking a sense of intense concentration and tension as one plots and decides a battle in the stillness of the night.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3204,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000101/group_2/index_6541_seed_30524_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/261_0000101_group_2_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+262,0.02102367,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01605339,0.00190023,0.00943544,0.84592617,0.55118239,0.09667969,0.00230208,0000160,group_10,1,q5,"Does the man wipe dirt from the ring, move his lips as if narrating, and turn his head to the left before returning his gaze?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium close-up depicts a man with a neatly trimmed dark brown beard, wearing a heather-gray cotton short-sleeved shirt and a dark blue baseball cap. He stands in the center of a sun-drenched meadow, the soft-focus background revealing tall green grass and scattered yellow wildflowers in the warm, golden afternoon light. His gaze is intently directed downward at a small metal ring delicately held between the thumb and index finger of each hand. He carefully wipes away specks of dark dirt from the surface, his lips moving as he speaks, narrating his actions with an air of focused discovery. He fluidly turns his head momentarily to the left, as if to greet someone off-screen, before quickly returning his gaze to the precious object in his hands, his expression a mixture of concentration and quiet excitement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3502,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000160/group_10/index_3321_seed_14242_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/262_0000160_group_10_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q5__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q5__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q5__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q5__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q5__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q5__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+263,0.02100808,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01744762,0.00207557,0.01024803,0.82595843,0.52802134,0.10351562,0.00246027,0000157,group_8,0,q3,Is the woman's hair visibly dancing powerfully in strong gusts of wind?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In characteristic Makoto Shinkai style, a static, eye-level medium shot depicts a young woman standing against the wind on a rain-slicked concrete rooftop. Her long, dark hair, tied in twin ponytails, dances powerfully in the strong gusts of wind. She wears a simple, clean white hoodie, its soft fabric ripples and folds with the movement of the air. Her hands are clasped tightly against her chest in a gesture of sincere prayer, her posture unwavering. In a sudden and dramatic moment, a bright, jagged flash of lightning pierces the heavy, swirling indigo clouds above, instantly bathing the entire scene in an ethereal, electric-blue glow. This intense light sharply illuminates her upturned face, revealing an expression of intense hope, her eyes tightly closed, as if focusing all her will in prayer. Beneath this dramatic sky, the sprawling city stretches to the horizon, a vast sea of shimmering neon lights in pink, teal, and gold, their brilliant colors streaming and reflecting beautifully on the dark, wet asphalt surfaces of the rooftops, creating a stunning contrast between the turbulent storm and the quiet, deeply personal moments.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3012,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000157/group_8/index_4476_seed_9547_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/263_0000157_group_8_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+264,0.02100166,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.01774225,0.00210886,0.01042226,0.84503400,0.62068075,0.06835938,0.00144780,0000015,group_10,1,q2,"Is the main subject an elder with youthful white hair, a flowing white beard, and a loose white silk Tai Chi suit?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"dolly-in shot begins in the distance and slowly moves forward. On a misty morning, atop the ancient Great Wall, an elder with youthful white hair and a flowing white beard, clad in a loose, white silk Tai Chi suit, stands alone, solemnly atop the weathered, gray bricks, moss growing between their crevices. The rising sun struggles to penetrate the thick morning mist, casting a soft, sacred golden beam that illuminates the swirling haze around him. The distant mountains and the winding outlines of the wall are faintly visible through the fog. His eyes slightly closed, his expression serene and focused, he begins his Tai Chi practice with a slow, powerful start. His weight shifts smoothly between his legs, his arms trace graceful, continuous arcs through the air, seamlessly transitioning from one pose to the next, his wide sleeves dancing like flowing clouds. The camera moves steadily and slowly closer, gradually transitioning from medium-long shot to medium shot, capturing the deep wrinkles on his face, the restrained power contained in his movements, and every detail of his clothes fluttering in the breeze and mist. The whole picture presents a solemn and tranquil atmosphere of isolation and harmony between man and nature. The color tone is mainly cold gray-blue, embellished by the warm morning light, full of epic visual beauty.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2414,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000015/group_10/index_513_seed_2567_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/264_0000015_group_10_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000015_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000015_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000015_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000015_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000015_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000015_group_10_sample_1_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+265,0.02100018,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.02125597,0.00251025,0.01249715,0.59920114,0.38145685,0.14355469,0.00062466,0000142,group_12,3,q1,Is the main subject a giant octopus gliding through the deep ocean floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide, slow-motion pan shot, shot from a slight upward angle, captures a giant octopus gliding effortlessly through the deep, inky abyss of the ocean floor. The behemoth's skin, far from the texture of flesh and blood, is a living, fluid display, a constantly shifting pattern of intricate bioluminescent hues of electric blue, neon purple, and magenta. As if streams of data are coursing beneath its surface, it creates a vibrant, digital art-like sheen. Its large, intelligent eyes radiate a soft golden glow, a striking contrast to the kaleidoscopic hues of its body. It propels itself through the rhythmic, powerful contraction and expansion of its vast mantle, while its eight long, powerful tentacles gracefully undulate behind it like silken ribbons in a hypnotic, coordinated dance, their suction cups pulsing with faint light. Its own light, the sole source of illumination in this inky black world, casts an ethereal, shifting light on the craggy volcanic rocks and occasional ghostly deep-sea plants below. Tiny particles floating in the water are illuminated like shimmering stardust. An otherworldly sense of tranquility and awe permeates the entire scene, seamlessly blending the grandeur of nature with a digital aesthetic to create a visual spectacle that is both mysterious and breathtaking.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4019,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000142/group_12/index_2489_seed_5421_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/265_0000142_group_12_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q1__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q1__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q1__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q1__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q1__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q1__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+266,0.02094731,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+between-flanked,8.54000000,5,0.00446620,0.00052784,0.00262558,0.80477822,0.51377416,0.10058594,0.00176549,0000162,group_1,1,q3,Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2597,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18205_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/266_0000162_group_1_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000162_group_1_sample_1_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+267,0.02091073,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01761819,0.00208363,0.01035637,0.80827665,0.50728887,0.10253906,0.00245279,0000011,group_10,0,q1,"Is the main subject a resolute old man with graying hair, a beard, and deep wrinkles?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle and handheld, creates a constant, subtle tremor as the environment oscillates, creating a powerful sense of presence. Under incredibly realistic path-traced lighting, a resolute old man stands tall and proud in the center of a dense, impenetrable bamboo forest. His graying hair and beard flutter in the wind, his face deeply lined with wrinkles as if carved by a knife. His deep eyes gaze piercingly ahead, revealing an unyielding resolve. He wears a dark gray, rough linen robe, its sleeves rustling in the wind, yet his feet remain firmly planted on the moist earth, carpeted with withered, yellowing leaves. Around him, countless massive, sturdy, emerald green bamboos bend, sway, and collide violently like the surging waves of the sea, their leaves emitting a sharp whistling sound. Light struggles to penetrate through the dense bamboo foliage, forming countless sharp, dynamically shifting beams, casting a variegated, ever-changing light and shadow on the elderly man and the swaying ground. The scene, dominated by deep greens and grays, features intense contrasts of light and dark, and the constant tremors of the painting, creating a tense atmosphere of confrontation between man and nature, imbued with a sense of primal power.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3860,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000011/group_10/index_5521_seed_27591_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/267_0000011_group_10_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q1__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q1__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q1__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q1__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q1__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000011_group_10_sample_0_q1__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+268,0.02087617,foreground-background+between-flanked,4.40800000,2,0.00858014,0.00101784,0.00504153,0.74672812,0.50705796,0.09179688,0.00079048,0000026,group_9,2,q1,Is the main character a spherical robot with a smooth egg-yellow shell and enormous digital blue eyes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with an erratic handheld tracking shot, the frame punctuated by digital noise and flickering like signal interference. The focus shifts rapidly between foreground and background, closely following a cuddly Disney Pixar-esque spherical robot. Its smooth, egg-yellow shell, a pair of enormous, digital blue eyes flashing wildly with utter terror, moves on three spindly metal legs, frantically darting through the ruins of a dilapidated biocontrol demonstration area. This area seems like an isolated island amidst a vast, gray wasteland, the sky a sickly, dim yellow. Countless thick veins of mutant plants, emitting an eerie purple and green bioluminescence, surge, entwine, and grow at a visible speed, as if alive, through the cracked ground and rusted debris of equipment. Each pulse of these veins causes the fluorescent light on their surface to flicker. The robot clumsily dodges a glowing vine that suddenly breaks out from the ground under its feet and almost trips. The whole scene forms a strong visual contrast between the cute character's terrified escape and the invasion of terrifying plants. Combined with the unstable lens and digital glitch effects, it successfully creates a unique, unsettling and weird contrast atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1718,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000026/group_9/index_4175_seed_2678_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/268_0000026_group_9_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q1__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q1__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q1__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q1__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q1__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000026_group_9_sample_2_q1__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+269,0.02084888,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01757654,0.00219268,0.01025591,0.77191710,0.56307912,0.07812500,0.00091559,0000078,group_13,3,q2,"Is the setting a narrow, damp back alley with mottled brick walls and puddles reflecting cold light?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"fluid single shot begins from a slightly upward angle, the camera steadily moving forward, following the steps of a silver-haired young man as he walks down a narrow, damp back alley. The scene is shrouded in a chilling blue hue. The mottled brick walls on either side are stained with water, and the puddles on the ground reflect a cold light. A single, old-fashioned orange streetlight at the alley's entrance casts a cone of warm light, slicing through the deep blue of the night like a sharp sword, creating a striking visual contrast between warm and cold. The young man's short, distinctly silver hair stands up like icy spikes. The warm light highlights the sharp contours of his hair and profile, while his front is largely immersed in a cold blue shadow. A pair of eagle-like eyes gleam fiercely within the shadows. Clad in a worn black leather motorcycle jacket, dark jeans, and heavy combat boots, he walks with a steady, menacing gait, closing in on his cornered opponent. When he finally stopped, his body leaned forward slightly, invading the other person's personal space, his jawline tense, his lips silently opening and closing, as if he was questioning in a very low but powerful voice. The whole picture was full of dramatic tension and a tense atmosphere that was about to break out.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4190,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000078/group_13/index_2049_seed_10813_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/269_0000078_group_13_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+270,0.02083162,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.01062890,0.00125622,0.00624845,0.58653075,0.34153840,0.18457031,0.00099853,0000056,group_3,0,q2,Is Sun Wukong wearing intricately carved golden chainmail armor with cloud patterns and a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown with two long pheasant feathers?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,516,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26609_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/270_0000056_group_3_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_0_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_0_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_0_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_0_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_0_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_0_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+271,0.02070577,beside-next-to,1.74000000,2,0.02044931,0.00242621,0.01201540,0.78981113,0.52339089,0.08691406,0.00128853,0000042,group_0,0,q3,Is the woman wearing a well-worn denim jacket over a plain white T-shirt and dark jeans?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium-long shot, emulating the distinctive aesthetic of 1990s cinema, perfectly centers a lone figure. A young woman with shoulder-length brown hair stands patiently beside a simple, weathered bus stop sign, its metal pole stained with faint traces of rust, the rectangular sign faded. She wears a well-worn denim jacket over a plain white T-shirt and dark jeans, her posture relaxed yet expectant, almost motionless as she waits. This ordinary scene stands in stark, surreal contrast to the backdrop, where the grand, columned entrance of an opulent mansion looms, its pristine white marble columns and a vast, manicured lawn stretching beneath an evenly cloudy sky. The entire frame is bathed in a soft, diffuse light, eliminating harsh shadows and creating a characteristic soft focus that slightly blurs the edges of the distant mansion. Rich, warm tones dominate, imbuing the deep green of the lawn and the creamy white of the building with a golden-day glow, while subtle film grain textures the image, creating a nostalgic, contemplative, and slightly dreamlike atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4987,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000042/group_0/index_7277_seed_21237_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/271_0000042_group_0_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+272,0.02068086,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01728555,0.00204791,0.01015842,0.82093990,0.52012002,0.10351562,0.00215781,0000157,group_8,0,q2,Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in twin ponytails wearing a white hoodie?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In characteristic Makoto Shinkai style, a static, eye-level medium shot depicts a young woman standing against the wind on a rain-slicked concrete rooftop. Her long, dark hair, tied in twin ponytails, dances powerfully in the strong gusts of wind. She wears a simple, clean white hoodie, its soft fabric ripples and folds with the movement of the air. Her hands are clasped tightly against her chest in a gesture of sincere prayer, her posture unwavering. In a sudden and dramatic moment, a bright, jagged flash of lightning pierces the heavy, swirling indigo clouds above, instantly bathing the entire scene in an ethereal, electric-blue glow. This intense light sharply illuminates her upturned face, revealing an expression of intense hope, her eyes tightly closed, as if focusing all her will in prayer. Beneath this dramatic sky, the sprawling city stretches to the horizon, a vast sea of shimmering neon lights in pink, teal, and gold, their brilliant colors streaming and reflecting beautifully on the dark, wet asphalt surfaces of the rooftops, creating a stunning contrast between the turbulent storm and the quiet, deeply personal moments.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3013,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000157/group_8/index_4476_seed_9547_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/272_0000157_group_8_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000157_group_8_sample_0_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+273,0.02066971,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00891441,0.00105898,0.00523695,0.80735034,0.52912098,0.09277344,0.00148937,0000053,group_1,0,q3,"Is a massive crystal chandelier visible, casting dancing golden rays and shimmering reflections on a black marble floor?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"majestic, sweeping, high-angle drone shot slowly glides forward and slightly downward, revealing a grand Gothic ballroom rendered in stunning, surreal 3D. A soaring vaulted ceiling with dark stone ribs reaches into the shadows above, flanked by towering stained-glass arched windows that depict a somber and romantic scene. The entire opulent space is illuminated by the warm, shimmering glow of a massive crystal chandelier, whose thousands of facets cast dancing golden rays across the highly polished black marble floor, creating near-perfect, shimmering reflections. Below, hundreds of guests gathered in intimate groups, dressed in exquisite gowns of deep velvet, shimmering silks, and intricate lace in rich jewel tones like crimson, emerald, and sapphire, alongside men in sharp, dark tuxedos. Each guest's identity is concealed behind an intricate phantom mask, ranging from simple, elegant dominoes to ornate creations composed of wire and dark feathers. As the camera continues its steady, almost imperceptible descent, the quiet nature of their conversation becomes apparent, not through sound but through their subtle, deliberate gestures: a fan tapping gently against a gloved palm, a masked head tilting slightly, conspiratorially, a hand gesturing elegantly to emphasize a silent point. The atmosphere is rich with luxurious mystery and exquisite elegance, a breathtaking picture of secret grandeur, where warm light catches the glint of jewels or the metallic sheen of masks, casting long, soft shadows that twist and dance with the flickering candlelight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4947,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000053/group_1/index_4424_seed_17765_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/273_0000053_group_1_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000053_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000053_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000053_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000053_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000053_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000053_group_1_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+274,0.02054570,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01602163,0.00194239,0.00938616,0.84899157,0.63953912,0.06445312,0.00082040,0000032,group_0,2,q5,"Are the shadows cast directly below the figures, indicating intense midday sun?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level long shot captures a surreal encounter across a vast, sun-scorched, arid wasteland beneath a pale, cloudless sky. A cowgirl, reminiscent of the legendary Belle Starr, perched high atop a powerful, dark bay horse, dominates the scene. She wears a dusty, burgundy, vintage riding dress, its cotton fabric showing the wear of trails. A weathered, wide-brimmed leather hat casts a deep shadow on her face. She looks down with a steady, scrutinizing gaze, her posture exuding a quiet, commanding authority. At her feet, on the cracked ochre earth, stands a modern man, motionless in a technical, olive-green leather coat, its synthetic sheen contrasting sharply with the organic textures of the landscape. He looks up, his face filled with surprise and curiosity. The intense midday sun bleaches the colors of the scene, casting sharp shadows directly below horse and figure, emphasizing the stark contrast. There was a silent, tentative tension in the air, a quiet confrontation between two eras suspended in the vast, silent heat of the desert.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4328,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000032/group_0/index_5918_seed_27278_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/274_0000032_group_0_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000032_group_0_sample_2_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000032_group_0_sample_2_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000032_group_0_sample_2_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000032_group_0_sample_2_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000032_group_0_sample_2_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000032_group_0_sample_2_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+275,0.02054455,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01875164,0.00223878,0.01100857,0.82150376,0.49444881,0.11132812,0.00030950,0000018,group_4,2,q4,"Does the video include a sequence of rapidly alternating close-ups showing her shoe stepping on a dewy leaf, her hair brushing her face, and her fingers forming a sword-like gesture?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pans upward through a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light penetrates the mist and dense bamboo foliage, casting visible beams of light in the air. The camera finally settles on a woman in a traditional Chinese costume, dressed in an elegant aquamarine silk robe. Her long, cascading black hair is held together only partially by a simple jade hairpin. Her face is clear and beautiful, her eyes focused and ethereal. With a light touch of the ground, her entire body rises as if weightless. The camera instantly switches to a fast, dynamic tracking shot, following her graceful figure as she nimbly weaves between the towering bamboo branches. Her wide sleeves flutter like butterfly wings as she moves swiftly, her skirt carving graceful arcs through the mist. A series of rapidly alternating close-ups follows: the tip of her shoe, delicately embroidered with cloud patterns, lightly steps on a dewy bamboo leaf, which trembles only slightly before returning to its composure; a strand of hair brushes across her focused and serene profile, revealing her perfectly defined jawline; her slender fingers form an elegant sword-like gesture in the air, steadily and calmly directing her body. The entire sequence is seamless, the camera language sharp and precise, capturing every moment of her ethereal, ethereal beauty. Amidst the cool tones of light and the lingering mist, an ethereal atmosphere is created, imbued with both martial arts power and poetic imagery.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1724,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_5716_seed_17759_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/275_0000018_group_4_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q4__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q4__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q4__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q4__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q4__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000018_group_4_sample_2_q4__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+276,0.02053187,beside-next-to,1.98000000,4,0.01740916,0.00206788,0.01022752,0.76488912,0.53853470,0.07031250,0.00114620,0000093,group_7,2,q4,Are steep cliffs shimmering in deep crimson visible on one side of the road next to the ocean?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, dynamic tracking shot follows a rider from the side as he speeds along a winding coastal tarmac road on a metallic crimson Harley-Davidson cruiser. The setting sun, sinking below the horizon, paints the world in a warm, saturated hue of gold and orange, imbuing the image with a rich cinematic quality. The rider leans forward slightly, his hands firmly gripping the handlebars. His dark brown hair flows back in the wind, and his face wears a focused, resolute expression. He wears a classic black leather jacket, unzipped, its hems and collar flapping dramatically in the strong sea breeze. He wears a simple white T-shirt underneath. On one side of the road lies the vast, shimmering ocean, its golden sunlight dancing across the surface. On the other, steep cliffs, shimmering a deep crimson, are illuminated by the sunset glow. The motorcycle sprints forward at a very fast speed, the chrome exhaust pipe and engine parts reflect the dazzling light, the wheels rotate at high speed and almost turn into a shadow, casting a long, constantly moving shadow on the road together with the rider. The whole picture is full of freedom, unrestrainedness and a magnificent sense of loneliness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3221,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000093/group_7/index_3185_seed_29232_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/276_0000093_group_7_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000093_group_7_sample_2_q4__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000093_group_7_sample_2_q4__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000093_group_7_sample_2_q4__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000093_group_7_sample_2_q4__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000093_group_7_sample_2_q4__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000093_group_7_sample_2_q4__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+277,0.02043728,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01749832,0.00209033,0.01027199,0.82728440,0.49946833,0.11132812,0.00007117,0000031,group_4,3,q2,Is the character depicted as a thin man with long dark hair held by a simple hairpin?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, mid-shot shot, taken from a horizontal angle, captures a tranquil moment in documentary style. In a Tang Dynasty courtyard bathed in a cool, silvery glow, the swaying shadows of trees are reflected on the stone pavement. The poet Li Bai wears a wide-sleeved white silk robe, which flutters gently in the night breeze, revealing its delicate texture. His long, dark hair is held together only by a simple hairpin. His face is thin, and his eyes hold a hint of drunkenness and contemplation. He turns slowly and calmly, a movement that gently sways a small, white porcelain wine glass in his hand. Ripples ripple on the surface of the clear wine, momentarily catching and reflecting the bright moonlight. The entire scene is bathed in moonlight, creating a striking contrast between light and dark. The light outlines his graceful figure and the deep shadows of the courtyard scenery, creating a timeless, serene, and poetic classical atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4343,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000031/group_4/index_8882_seed_4784_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/277_0000031_group_4_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000031_group_4_sample_3_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000031_group_4_sample_3_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000031_group_4_sample_3_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000031_group_4_sample_3_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000031_group_4_sample_3_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000031_group_4_sample_3_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+278,0.02042223,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.02211872,0.00267876,0.01295998,0.57121122,0.35215443,0.17480469,0.00274980,0000103,group_14,1,q2,Is the cat a sleek shorthair with glossy black fur initially curled into a motionless ball?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a stunning slow-motion sequence captured with high-speed photography, a rotating camera executes a low-angle orbit around a sleeping cat curled up on a dark, highly polished hardwood floor, which reflects the scene like black water. The feline, a sleek shorthair with glossy black fur, initially appears as a perfect, motionless ball. Suddenly, a sleek, self-propelled smart toy, shaped like an understated white disc, darts past in the background. Its integrated cyan and magenta LEDs illuminate the dimly lit room, casting vibrant, streaked light that blurs with speed. The toy's faint purring triggers the cat's awakening; an ear twitches, and its emerald green eyes snap open in a moment of intense focus. As the camera continues its smooth, circular path, the cat begins to gracefully unfurl in a single, fluid motion. The image emphasizes the dramatic, deliberate elongation of its spine and the powerful extension of its front paws, slightly unsheathed to grasp the reflective surface. The entire awakening is a ballet of controlled muscle movement, creating a dramatic and mesmerizing contrast between the feline’s organic, languid grace and the toy’s fuzzy, fleeting technological presence, establishing an atmosphere of suspended, graceful movement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4764,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000103/group_14/index_201_seed_30034_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/278_0000103_group_14_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+279,0.02041693,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.01524964,0.00182854,0.00894740,0.82407671,0.48852262,0.12402344,0.00074938,0000093,group_12,3,q1,Is the main subject an Asian man in his twenties with neatly cropped hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"This static, tight, eye-level shot, rendered with detailed, grounded realism, focuses on the determined face of an Asian man in his twenties playing pool, leaning over the table to line up a key shot. The camera captures subtle details: the subtle wrinkle of his brow beneath his neatly cropped hair, and the intensely focused reflection of a single, low-hanging pendant lamp gleaming in his dark eyes. This lone source casts a pool of warm, concentrated light onto the scene, creating sharp highlights on his cheekbones and the bridge of his nose while plunging the surrounding pool hall into a soft, blurred darkness. His left hand, firmly splayed on the rich green felt of the table, forms a perfect bridge with the cue stick, the fine traces of pale blue chalk on his fingertips visible against the dark fabric of the tabletop. Steadily and deliberately, he slides the polished maple cue back and forth through his fingers, his gaze unwavering as he moves between the cue ball and the target. His entire posture is one of quiet, focused study, creating an atmosphere of intense intimacy.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3231,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000093/group_12/index_5266_seed_18916_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/279_0000093_group_12_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000093_group_12_sample_3_q1__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000093_group_12_sample_3_q1__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000093_group_12_sample_3_q1__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000093_group_12_sample_3_q1__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000093_group_12_sample_3_q1__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000093_group_12_sample_3_q1__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+280,0.02036945,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.34000000,5,0.00904204,0.00106728,0.00531651,0.80953729,0.46539655,0.12500000,0.00004789,0000101,group_2,2,q4,Is the man slowly unrolling a bamboo map bound by string with his hands?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, close-up shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, focuses the viewer's attention on a scene illuminated by the flickering flame of an ancient copper oil lamp. At the center of the frame lies a middle-aged strategist, wearing a dark silk scarf and a wide-sleeved black robe. He sits at a heavy, dark wooden desk, his brow furrowed, his eyes sharp as an eagle's, his gaze fixed intently on the object before him. The warm, dancing light casts deep shadows on his chiseled features, highlighting his lips pursed in deep thought. His slender, powerful hands, carefully, steadily, and deliberately, slowly unroll a bamboo map bound by string. As he moves, the polished bamboo strips rub against each other, creating a crisp, subtle rustling sound. The map's ink-drawn mountains and rivers, along with the cinnabar-marked military fortresses, gradually emerge in the dim light, exuding a sense of age and age. Beside him, on the desk, rests a feather fan crafted from white crane feathers, its ebony handle gleaming softly in the light. The painting's warm, deep tones, predominantly dark browns and oranges, create a stark contrast between light and shadow, evoking a sense of intense concentration and tension as one plots and decides a battle in the stillness of the night.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,286,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000101/group_2/index_6541_seed_30524_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/280_0000101_group_2_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q4__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q4__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q4__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q4__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q4__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000101_group_2_sample_2_q4__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+281,0.02036720,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01563337,0.00196186,0.00911434,0.81310332,0.60373056,0.07617188,0.00120279,0000068,group_5,3,q5,"Are the man's eyes wide, eyebrows slightly furrowed, and lips parted in an expression of confusion?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Cinematographically captured in Steve McCurry's signature style, a static medium close-up captures a decisive moment from a level perspective. With a violent jolt from the aging train, a weathered South Asian man in his forties jolted awake from his window seat. Brilliant golden morning light, acting as a powerful backlight, penetrated the scratched and dusty windowpanes, casting a dazzling golden halo around his tousled black curls and shoulders, illuminating even the fine dust particles floating in the air like beams of light, a Tyndall effect. He wore a faded crimson cotton kurta, and every wrinkle on his face was etched in the dramatic light. His eyes widened in the instant of awakening, his thick eyebrows slightly furrowed, his lips parted. His gaze, filled with the confusion and disorientation of someone forcibly plucked from a deep dream, stared straight ahead at the empty space. The entire picture is enveloped in warm tones, with saturated red and golden light interwoven, forming a sharp contrast between the bumpy dynamic background and the momentary stillness and confusion of the characters, creating a documentary atmosphere that is both tranquil and full of inner tension, as if time has been frozen at this moment, filled with a sense of unspoken story.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2075,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000068/group_5/index_5640_seed_9439_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/281_0000068_group_5_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000068_group_5_sample_3_q5__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000068_group_5_sample_3_q5__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000068_group_5_sample_3_q5__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000068_group_5_sample_3_q5__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000068_group_5_sample_3_q5__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000068_group_5_sample_3_q5__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+282,0.02034694,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01860306,0.00223007,0.01091533,0.70185494,0.44640556,0.11718750,0.00232255,0000044,group_7,1,q3,"Is the central figure a young woman with long, dark brown hair that is sweat-soaked and matted?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"tense, low-angle tracking shot follows, the camera darting through waist-high waves of golden wheat, its frame fixed on a figure, bent low and struggling forward. This is a young woman with long, dark brown hair, sweat-soaked, matted tousled against her cheeks and neck. Her face is a mixture of fear and determination, her lower lip bitten, her eyes scanning the horizon warily. She wears a faded gray cotton T-shirt, clinging to her body, outlining her chest, which rises and falls with rapid breathing, and dark blue jeans, slightly frayed at the knees. She lowers herself to the ground, almost level with the tops of the wheat ears, to avoid possible sight. Her hands instinctively push aside the dense stalks in front of her, their movements swift and a touch panicky. The golden sunlight of dusk slants down at a low angle, tinting the endless wheat fields into a brilliant golden ocean. Each ear of wheat glows dazzlingly in the backlight, casting long, swaying shadows on and around her. A gentle breeze whips through the wheat fields, undulating like waves. The entire scene, a stunning pastoral landscape with an almost oil-painting quality, is permeated with a silent, breathtaking atmosphere of pursuit, filled with a stark contrast between idyllic tranquility and a tense, volatile atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3774,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000044/group_7/index_8774_seed_17448_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/282_0000044_group_7_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000044_group_7_sample_1_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000044_group_7_sample_1_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000044_group_7_sample_1_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000044_group_7_sample_1_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000044_group_7_sample_1_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000044_group_7_sample_1_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+283,0.02025079,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.02049257,0.00242413,0.01204563,0.60303956,0.38265634,0.14355469,0.00075281,0000142,group_12,3,q3,Do the octopus's large eyes radiate a soft golden glow?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide, slow-motion pan shot, shot from a slight upward angle, captures a giant octopus gliding effortlessly through the deep, inky abyss of the ocean floor. The behemoth's skin, far from the texture of flesh and blood, is a living, fluid display, a constantly shifting pattern of intricate bioluminescent hues of electric blue, neon purple, and magenta. As if streams of data are coursing beneath its surface, it creates a vibrant, digital art-like sheen. Its large, intelligent eyes radiate a soft golden glow, a striking contrast to the kaleidoscopic hues of its body. It propels itself through the rhythmic, powerful contraction and expansion of its vast mantle, while its eight long, powerful tentacles gracefully undulate behind it like silken ribbons in a hypnotic, coordinated dance, their suction cups pulsing with faint light. Its own light, the sole source of illumination in this inky black world, casts an ethereal, shifting light on the craggy volcanic rocks and occasional ghostly deep-sea plants below. Tiny particles floating in the water are illuminated like shimmering stardust. An otherworldly sense of tranquility and awe permeates the entire scene, seamlessly blending the grandeur of nature with a digital aesthetic to create a visual spectacle that is both mysterious and breathtaking.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4018,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000142/group_12/index_2489_seed_5421_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/283_0000142_group_12_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000142_group_12_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+284,0.02023906,beside-next-to,2.46000000,8,0.01369385,0.00162916,0.00804313,0.76028293,0.56079936,0.06738281,0.00071040,0000127,group_8,2,q4,Does the man sit cross-legged on the hardwood floor with his back against a plain off-white wall?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera pans right, following a man in his early thirties as he enters a cluttered dining room, the camera at eye level. He has slightly tousled brown hair and wears a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans, his brow furrowed in concentration. He clutches a sleek black tablet in both hands, his gaze fixed on its glowing screen, and walks purposefully toward a large wooden dining table buried beneath piles of books, loose papers, and a tangle of cables. He stops beside the table and carefully places the tablet on a small transparent surface. Then, his eyes scan the chaos, and with quick, decisive action, he picks up a closed silver laptop. He leaves the table and deliberately lowers himself to the hardwood floor, sitting cross-legged with his back against a plain off-white wall. He places the laptop on his lap, opens it, and immediately begins typing rapidly and intently, his face bathed in the cool, bluish-white glow of the screen. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, indirect morning light streaming through a large window, creating an atmosphere of quiet concentration that contrasts sharply with the room's visual chaos.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,585,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000127/group_8/index_3516_seed_21357_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/284_0000127_group_8_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+285,0.02021725,opposite-across,2.38000000,5,0.01658701,0.00196524,0.00974785,0.64796966,0.42786479,0.10449219,0.00070038,0000016,group_4,1,q5,"During the forward launch, do the centipede's head and legs appear disproportionately magnified and blurred due to rapid movement?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Embracing the meticulously hand-painted aesthetic of Ghibli animation, a striking overhead fisheye lens places the viewer on the ground, facing a vibrant, multicolored, segmented giant centipede from Madagascar. It nestles in a humid, vibrant, fantasy forest floor, nestled against a backdrop of giant, mossy ferns and shimmering, exotic mushrooms. The exaggerated distortion of the fisheye lens causes these plants to curve and stretch toward the edge of the frame, forming an enveloping, dizzying dome of green. The centipede's carapace displays an intricate pattern of deep russet and bright orange. Each smooth segment reflects dappled light filtering through the gaps in the forest canopy, and countless pairs of yellow legs connect the segments, each in a frenzy of activity. First, its long, segmented body arches back sharply into a tense ""C"" shape, its massive, venom-gleaming black mandibules poised at the front. Then, in a flash, it launches its entire body forward with explosive speed, hurtling towards the camera. During this rapid movement, its head and maxillipedia are disproportionately magnified in front of the camera, as if they are about to break through the screen. Countless pairs of legs are frantically paddling in the air, forming a blurred afterimage. The entire picture is full of dynamic tension and a suffocating sense of oppression from the huge creature, perfectly reproducing the classic depiction of the awe and fear of natural forces in Ghibli animation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1729,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000016/group_4/index_2980_seed_5085_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/285_0000016_group_4_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000016_group_4_sample_1_q5__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000016_group_4_sample_1_q5__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000016_group_4_sample_1_q5__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000016_group_4_sample_1_q5__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000016_group_4_sample_1_q5__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000016_group_4_sample_1_q5__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+286,0.02016298,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01666432,0.00199183,0.00978166,0.79145002,0.57421803,0.07128906,0.00120136,0000101,group_3,1,q3,Is the woman performing the action of swinging her leg onto the seat of a sleek black motorcycle?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, medium close-up, with a sharp digital look, remains static, capturing a figure at the wheel of a sleek black motorcycle. The subject, a woman with a determined expression and windswept black hair, wears a well-worn black leather jacket, its wrinkled texture and subtle sheen accentuated by the lighting. With ease, she swings her leg onto the seat, her free hand momentarily resting on the handlebars for balance. Behind her, a massive tidal power station looms, its massive concrete walls spanning the frame, appearing monolithic and imposing. The low, golden glow of the setting sun sweeps across the scene, casting long, dramatic shadows that stretch across the ground and sculpt every surface with intense contrast. This harsh light captures the grain of the leather and the rough, weathered texture of the concrete structure, creating a powerful portrait that emphasizes the stark contrast between the confident, self-assured human subject and the overwhelming industrial scale of her surroundings, all captured with crisp, high-fidelity detail.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4769,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000101/group_3/index_6062_seed_24672_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/286_0000101_group_3_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+287,0.02006792,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.02186435,0.00263156,0.01282186,0.66040486,0.41710728,0.13378906,0.00243628,0000143,group_7,1,q3,"Does the pigeon exhibit rhythmic head swaying, bright orange-red eyes, and peck at crumbs with a dark gray beak?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, low-angle shot focuses on the iconic vermilion walls of the Forbidden City. Warm afternoon sunlight slants down, casting soft shadows across the towering, majestic facades. A plump pigeon paces along the time-worn, blue-gray stone pavement with a leisurely pace. Its gray-white feathers appear remarkably clean in the sunlight, and its neck gleams with metallic green and purple with each step. With each step, its head rhythmically sways back and forth, its bright, alert orange-red eyes perpetually observing its surroundings. Suddenly, it pauses, briefly surveying its surroundings. With swift and precise movements, it lowers its head and pecks at the barely visible crumbs of food lurking in the cracks between the stone slabs with its dark gray beak. The movement is clean and precise, and it immediately raises its head to resume its leisurely demeanor. The whole scene presents a tranquil and solemn atmosphere. The magnificent historical buildings and the small but vibrant life form a sharp and harmonious contrast, creating a peaceful beauty as if time has stopped.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1977,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000143/group_7/index_6394_seed_10721_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/287_0000143_group_7_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000143_group_7_sample_1_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000143_group_7_sample_1_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000143_group_7_sample_1_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000143_group_7_sample_1_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000143_group_7_sample_1_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000143_group_7_sample_1_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+288,0.02003087,foreground-background+beside-next-to,4.88400000,4,0.00850833,0.00100633,0.00500133,0.62273860,0.40905970,0.12109375,0.00107312,0000052,group_7,1,q3,Is a man with a shaved head running beside the woman with visible tension in his calf and thigh muscles?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"glossy, eye-level camera relentlessly follows a large group of marathon runners, capturing the scene in stunning, surreal detail. The camera moves at their pace, placing a few distinct runners in the foreground with razor-sharp focus. A woman with a high, swinging ponytail, rosy-faced and focused, wears a bright yellow technical vest drenched in sweat. Beside her, a man with a shaved head and a focused expression, every tense muscle fiber in his calves and thighs visible with each powerful stride. Their outfits are a vibrant, chaotic mosaic of neon green, electric blue, and hot pink, all rendered with realistic textures. Their collective action is a thunderous, rhythmic thud against the asphalt of the broad city avenue, a unified forward wave, thousands of individual bodies moving as one undulating mass. Crisp, low-angle morning sunlight filters through the scene, gleaming on their foreheads and casting long, dynamic shadows as they run. In the background, the blurred forms of cheering spectators and city buildings streak by, enhancing the profound sense of speed and unstoppable momentum, creating an epic atmosphere rich in raw determination and human endurance.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1877,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000052/group_7/index_885_seed_21557_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/288_0000052_group_7_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000052_group_7_sample_1_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000052_group_7_sample_1_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000052_group_7_sample_1_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000052_group_7_sample_1_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000052_group_7_sample_1_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000052_group_7_sample_1_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+289,0.02000547,foreground-background,2.90400000,4,0.01198649,0.00141850,0.00704533,0.83473313,0.54109120,0.09667969,0.00222409,0000054,group_14,3,q5,"Is the background a vast, desolate ancient battlefield with distant mountains and tattered flags rendered in blurred, light ink strokes?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from an upward angle slowly pulls away from a medium shot to reveal a wider scene. The entire image is rendered in the intense and pure style of Chinese ink painting, as if painted on a vast sheet of rice paper. At the center of the scene is an ancient soldier clad in worn iron lamellar armor, his long, unkempt black hair matted to his dusty and scarred face by sweat and blood. His armor is covered in cuts and dents, and one side of the shoulder armor has been broken, revealing the coarse linen lining underneath, dyed a deep red (the darkest color in ink painting). He clutches a broken sword with both hands, stabbing the blade deep into the muddy ground beneath his feet, using it as his sole support to barely maintain his position on one knee. As the camera slowly retreats, he exhausts his last breath, his body trembling violently. He throws his head back, his neck veins bulging with tension. He opens his mouth wide and lets out a silent, utter roar at the leaden sky, swirling clouds rendered in diluted ink. His face, twisted with pain and rage, is vividly portrayed, yet the world remains silent. The background is a vast, desolate ancient battlefield. The distant mountains and scattered, tattered flags and weapons are all outlined in blurred, impressionistic strokes of light ink, forming a stark contrast to the clear, powerful, and bold lines of the soldiers in the foreground. In this minimalist monochrome, the painting creates an atmosphere of epic tragedy, loneliness, and unyielding determination.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2876,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000054/group_14/index_9496_seed_2409_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/289_0000054_group_14_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000054_group_14_sample_3_q5__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000054_group_14_sample_3_q5__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000054_group_14_sample_3_q5__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000054_group_14_sample_3_q5__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000054_group_14_sample_3_q5__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000054_group_14_sample_3_q5__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+290,0.01997682,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01779466,0.00209645,0.01046547,0.65607429,0.44575229,0.09179688,0.00268412,0000134,group_15,3,q3,"Is the figure wearing a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe with wide sleeves?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with a slow, upward tilt, close-up shot of a yellowed ancient book spread out on a dark wooden desk. The texture of the paper is clearly visible, and vertical regular script written in rich, ink-stained ink appears on it. A pair of slender, bony hands gently twist the corner of the page, their movements steady and deliberate. As the camera pans upward, it sweeps across the figure, clad in a simple, moon-white, cross-collared Song Dynasty robe. Its wide sleeves drape over the edge of the desk, the silk gleaming softly in the soft sunlight filtering through the windowpanes. Finally, the camera settles on the scholar's lean, focused face. He wears a simple Dongpo scarf, his long hair neatly tied back. A deep, pensive expression etched between his brows, his gaze seemingly piercing the text within, immersed in ancient wisdom. The entire scene, shrouded in tranquil light and shadow, evokes a secluded, focused, and elegant atmosphere of scholarship.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4614,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000134/group_15/index_245_seed_13149_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/290_0000134_group_15_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000134_group_15_sample_3_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000134_group_15_sample_3_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000134_group_15_sample_3_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000134_group_15_sample_3_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000134_group_15_sample_3_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000134_group_15_sample_3_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+291,0.01992916,foreground-background,3.08000000,5,0.01190634,0.00140567,0.00700045,0.79222661,0.49361020,0.10839844,0.00180271,0000082,group_9,0,q1,Is the scene set in a dining room with a long dark wooden table covered by a beige linen tablecloth?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a cozy, humanistic interior, a fluid single shot begins at table level, then slowly and gracefully pans rightward across a warm dining scene. A long, dark wooden table, covered with a beige linen tablecloth, is laden with half-eaten home-cooked dishes and scattered crumbs. Several friends, dressed in cozy sweaters and casual shirts, gather around the table. Their faces are blurred by a soft bokeh, yet their genuine smiles and lively gestures, engaged in conversation, are clearly visible. As the camera pans, the focus gradually and seamlessly shifts from the joyful gathering in the background to the central subject in the foreground: a woman's hand, delicately lifting a glass of white wine from the table. Steady and composed, her nails immaculately manicured, the hand elegantly grasps the slender stem of a classic crystal goblet. The glass is about one-third full of pale golden white wine, and under the soft light cast by a low, warm-toned chandelier overhead, the wine's clarity is translucent, shimmering with sparkling shimmer. As the wine glasses are slowly raised to the center of the picture, the smiling faces and figures of the friends in the background are completely blurred into warm spots of light (Bokeh) and soft blocks of color. The whole picture is wrapped in an intimate, peaceful and joyful atmosphere. The main colors are warm amber and cream, and the contrast of light and shadow is soft, perfectly capturing this peaceful and sincere moment of celebration.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4829,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000082/group_9/index_3890_seed_29048_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/291_0000082_group_9_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q1__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q1__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q1__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q1__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q1__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q1__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+292,0.01991903,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01507734,0.00186178,0.00881037,0.79156452,0.55411947,0.08300781,0.00159815,0000160,group_10,2,q3,Is the man holding a small metal ring between the thumb and index finger of each hand?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium close-up depicts a man with a neatly trimmed dark brown beard, wearing a heather-gray cotton short-sleeved shirt and a dark blue baseball cap. He stands in the center of a sun-drenched meadow, the soft-focus background revealing tall green grass and scattered yellow wildflowers in the warm, golden afternoon light. His gaze is intently directed downward at a small metal ring delicately held between the thumb and index finger of each hand. He carefully wipes away specks of dark dirt from the surface, his lips moving as he speaks, narrating his actions with an air of focused discovery. He fluidly turns his head momentarily to the left, as if to greet someone off-screen, before quickly returning his gaze to the precious object in his hands, his expression a mixture of concentration and quiet excitement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1155,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000160/group_10/index_3321_seed_14243_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/292_0000160_group_10_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+293,0.01990483,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01949776,0.00231106,0.01145780,0.66836822,0.42269474,0.10644531,0.00076908,0000001,group_6,0,q1,Is the main subject a scholar wearing a pure white robe with long black hair tied back by a wooden hairpin?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"long, slightly upward-angled tracking shot steadily follows a scholar in white as he walks through the bustling, vibrant atmosphere of an ancient Chinese marketplace. The scholar has a delicate face, long black hair tied back with a simple wooden hairpin. He wears a pure white robe of fine fabric, the hems of which sway gently with his steady, deliberate steps. One hand hangs naturally at his side, while the other carefully holds several yellowed ancient tomes. Bright afternoon sunlight filters through the gaps between the eaves of the shops lining the street, casting dappled shadows on the time-worn bluestone pavement. Fine dust particles hang in the air, visible in the beams of light. Surrounding him is a constant stream of people: peddlers carrying loads and shouting their wares, young girls in colorful clothes playing and laughing. His white figure stands out against the vibrant surroundings, yet blends harmoniously into this vibrant scene. He moved nimbly through the crowded crowd, occasionally turning his body slightly to avoid oncoming people, but his eyes were always firmly fixed on the front, walking steadily towards the magnificent tall archway with carved beams and painted rafters at the end of the market. Against the noisy background, the whole scene created a peaceful atmosphere of movement and stillness, and clear goals, because of his focused expression.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4472,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000001/group_6/index_5897_seed_5250_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/293_0000001_group_6_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000001_group_6_sample_0_q1__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000001_group_6_sample_0_q1__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000001_group_6_sample_0_q1__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000001_group_6_sample_0_q1__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000001_group_6_sample_0_q1__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000001_group_6_sample_0_q1__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+294,0.01989423,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00791142,0.00096241,0.00463267,0.78718215,0.60416800,0.06445312,0.00018501,0000125,group_0,1,q2,"Is the main subject a young man with short, shaggy dark brown hair wearing a loose-fitting gray hoodie, faded jeans, and scuffed white sneakers?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld camera, with a subtle, natural shakiness, follows a young man from a slightly lower, level angle as he navigates a narrow Tokyo back alley. The boy has short, shaggy dark brown hair, a loose-fitting gray hoodie, faded jeans, and scuffed white sneakers. The afternoon sun filters through the gaps between buildings and the crisscrossing electrical wires overhead, casting a shifting, interwoven pattern of light and dark on him and the rough concrete walls around him. He stops beside a vintage mint green scooter, scratched and peeling, leaning forward, one leg planted firmly on the damp asphalt, a playful smile on his focused face. He slams the starter with his right foot, but the engine only lets out a weak cough before silencing itself. Undeterred, he grins, and with amusement-filled persistence, he lifts his foot again, ready for another decisive attempt. The whole scene, with its shaky camera and warm lighting, is full of youthful energy and an effortless, casual sense of urban life, creating a relaxed and hopeful leisure atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4051,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000125/group_0/index_5886_seed_33484_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/294_0000125_group_0_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+295,0.01981610,beside-next-to,2.10000000,5,0.01771284,0.00208920,0.01041576,0.75671065,0.46614221,0.11328125,0.00151432,0000082,group_4,2,q2,Is the scholar wearing a deep indigo silk robe with silver thread embroidery of clouds and cranes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, slightly high-angled, medium close-up captures an elderly scholar, hunched over a dark lacquered wooden altar. His long, thinning white hair is meticulously tied into a traditional headdress, and his face, a map of deep wrinkles, reveals a profound concentration. He wears a deep indigo silk robe, its cuffs and collar embroidered with silver thread depicting clouds and cranes, the fabric softened by age. The scene is bathed in warm, low-key lighting, cast by an invisible oil lamp, which creates deep shadows and distinct textures. On the table, next to a half-unrolled scroll of yellowed rice paper and a jade brush holder, lies a heavy, dark slate inkstone. His rough, age-stained right hand rests reverently above it, a pool of freshly ground ink gleaming with a thick, dark sheen. A subtle, persistent tremor passes through his fingers, testifying to his advanced age and the profound weight of the moment, creating an atmosphere of quiet, tense concentration, an ancient ritual.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3262,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000082/group_4/index_4109_seed_10562_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/295_0000082_group_4_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000082_group_4_sample_2_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000082_group_4_sample_2_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000082_group_4_sample_2_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000082_group_4_sample_2_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000082_group_4_sample_2_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000082_group_4_sample_2_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+296,0.01975048,left-right-pair,3.72000000,3,0.00990057,0.00120506,0.00579700,0.72227949,0.47772104,0.09765625,0.00193024,0000068,group_1,3,q1,Is the main subject a man in his 30s with neatly cropped brown hair wearing a navy short-sleeved polo shirt and khaki pants?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level, medium-sized shot captures a man in his 30s with neatly cropped brown hair standing in a well-lit, organized workshop. Dressed in a navy short-sleeved polo shirt and khaki pants, he exudes a professional demeanor. The background consists of a clean concrete floor and a slightly out-of-focus workbench with neatly arranged tools. The man tightly grasps a vibrant red cylindrical fire extinguisher with both hands, its black nozzle and pressure gauge clearly visible. As he speaks directly to the camera with a serious and clear expression, he begins to vigorously shake the extinguisher up and down, a movement that conveys a sense of urgent preparedness. He then pauses, holding the extinguisher steady with his right hand and gesturing vigorously with his left hand, pointing his index finger at the nozzle to emphasize a key point in his explanation. Finally, he nods, gently and steadily bending his knees, and deliberately placing the extinguisher upright on the floor, his movements precise and measured. The entire scene is bathed in bright, cool fluorescent light from an overhead light source, creating clear reflections on the extinguisher's smooth surface and establishing an atmosphere of focused instruction.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1843,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000068/group_1/index_4541_seed_13923_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/296_0000068_group_1_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000068_group_1_sample_3_q1__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000068_group_1_sample_3_q1__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000068_group_1_sample_3_q1__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000068_group_1_sample_3_q1__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000068_group_1_sample_3_q1__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000068_group_1_sample_3_q1__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+297,0.01972753,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01576409,0.00191261,0.00923432,0.77886623,0.55044544,0.07812500,0.00198185,0000142,group_12,1,q1,Is the main subject a giant octopus gliding through the deep ocean floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide, slow-motion pan shot, shot from a slight upward angle, captures a giant octopus gliding effortlessly through the deep, inky abyss of the ocean floor. The behemoth's skin, far from the texture of flesh and blood, is a living, fluid display, a constantly shifting pattern of intricate bioluminescent hues of electric blue, neon purple, and magenta. As if streams of data are coursing beneath its surface, it creates a vibrant, digital art-like sheen. Its large, intelligent eyes radiate a soft golden glow, a striking contrast to the kaleidoscopic hues of its body. It propels itself through the rhythmic, powerful contraction and expansion of its vast mantle, while its eight long, powerful tentacles gracefully undulate behind it like silken ribbons in a hypnotic, coordinated dance, their suction cups pulsing with faint light. Its own light, the sole source of illumination in this inky black world, casts an ethereal, shifting light on the craggy volcanic rocks and occasional ghostly deep-sea plants below. Tiny particles floating in the water are illuminated like shimmering stardust. An otherworldly sense of tranquility and awe permeates the entire scene, seamlessly blending the grandeur of nature with a digital aesthetic to create a visual spectacle that is both mysterious and breathtaking.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4015,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000142/group_12/index_2489_seed_5419_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/297_0000142_group_12_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q1__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q1__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q1__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q1__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q1__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000142_group_12_sample_1_q1__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+298,0.01966501,between-flanked,2.62400000,8,0.01583389,0.00190422,0.00928644,0.60360211,0.39584333,0.13476562,0.00037956,0000097,group_11,3,q2,Are an older woman with silver-white hair in a bun and a young man in a navy blue Henley shirt visible?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, medium shot, shot at eye level, captures the intimate moment of reunion in a sun-drenched kitchen. An older woman with soft, silver-white hair pulled back in a loose bun and a young man in his twenties recline at a rustic wooden table, embraced in a warm, gentle embrace. The woman, wearing a simple cream-colored blouse and a faded floral apron, has her eyes closed, a serene smile on her face, her wrinkled hands resting tenderly on the man's shoulders. The man, wearing a navy blue Henley shirt, wraps his arms firmly around her back, his face resting lightly against her temples, a look of relief and affection. The centerpiece of the scene is a freshly baked pie on a white ceramic plate, nestled directly between them; its golden-brown lattice crust gleams, a delicate plume of steam rising from its center. Golden afternoon sunlight pours through a nearby window, illuminating the scene, capturing the dancing dust particles in the air and casting soft, warm highlights on their faces and the polished table. The backdrop showcases a cozy, live-in kitchen with white cabinets and tile countertops, creating an atmosphere of deep tranquility, comfort, and heartfelt joy.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,124,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000097/group_11/index_5824_seed_9812_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/298_0000097_group_11_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000097_group_11_sample_3_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000097_group_11_sample_3_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000097_group_11_sample_3_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000097_group_11_sample_3_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000097_group_11_sample_3_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000097_group_11_sample_3_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+299,0.01961413,beside-next-to,2.10000000,5,0.01508248,0.00180437,0.00885207,0.83113039,0.59674144,0.07226562,0.00006843,0000117,group_9,1,q3,Is the scene illuminated primarily by a bronze oil lamp casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a thin, middle-aged strategist with a neatly trimmed goatee, nestled within a dimly lit military tent. He wears a loose, flowing dark blue silk robe, his long hair held back with a simple wooden hairpin. He reclines leisurely on an antique carved wooden chair. The only illumination comes from a bronze oil lamp on a table beside him. Its flickering, warm yellow light casts deep, undulating shadows on his face, emphasizing his pensive expression and illuminating the folds of his silk robe with a soft sheen. In his right hand, he grasps a feather fan made of pure white crane feathers, gently waving it with a steady, leisurely rhythm, the breeze occasionally causing the lamplight to flicker. In the background, a military map hangs on the thick dark canvas tent wall, and a wooden weapons rack with unfolded bamboo slips and weapons can be vaguely seen next to it. The whole scene has a warm tone, mainly deep dark colors, creating an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tranquility and strategic planning against the backdrop of military tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3120,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000117/group_9/index_9345_seed_1224_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/299_0000117_group_9_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+300,0.01959887,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.01537819,0.00182977,0.00903228,0.74232060,0.43917120,0.12597656,0.00372070,0000094,group_6,2,q2,Are a young man with dark brown hair and an olive green Henley shirt and a young woman with honey-blond hair and a cream-colored knit cardigan visible?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The scene unfolds in a medium shot at eye level, the camera beginning a slow, almost imperceptible pan to a young man and woman sharing a moment on a large, weathered wooden swing suspended from the sturdy branches of an old tree. The man, with slightly tousled dark brown hair and a comfortable olive green Henley shirt, leans earnestly toward his companion, his voice low and sincere. The woman, her long honey-blond hair softly illuminated by the setting sun, wears a loose-fitting cream-colored knit cardigan over a simple floral dress; she listens intently, her head slightly tilted, a look of deep understanding on her face. They sit in a lush, verdant backyard in golden hour, the background melting into a beautiful bokeh of distant, out-of-focus foliage. Between them, on the swing's wooden planks, their hands are mere inches apart, his hand motionless and open, her fingers slightly curled, the tiny space between them crackling with unspoken emotion. As the camera continues its steady, deliberate close-in, the composition tightens, excluding the wider surroundings to focus purely on the vibrant space between their faces and hands, capturing the quiet intimacy and heartfelt seriousness of their conversation in an atmosphere of tranquility, warmth, and deep romance.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,238,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000094/group_6/index_8066_seed_8255_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/300_0000094_group_6_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000094_group_6_sample_2_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000094_group_6_sample_2_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000094_group_6_sample_2_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000094_group_6_sample_2_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000094_group_6_sample_2_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000094_group_6_sample_2_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+301,0.01952925,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01558645,0.00191612,0.00911355,0.79844666,0.56643254,0.08593750,0.00242561,0000123,group_6,0,q3,Is the man wearing a loose-fitting white silk training suit?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"long shot, beginning from a slightly upward angle and slowly advancing forward, transports us into a world shrouded in a milky morning mist. A weathered arched stone bridge spans the center of the frame, its slippery slabs dotted with moss, its railings etched with the marks of age. In the center of the bridge, an elderly man, silver hair pulled back into a neat bun, dressed in a loose-fitting white silk training suit, is immersed in a Tai Chi practice. His face is gaunt, wrinkled with wisdom, his eyes slightly closed, his expression serene and focused. With his slow, fluid movements, his arms trace gentle arcs like flowing clouds and water, his weight shifting steadily and effortlessly between his legs, his wide sleeves fluttering softly. The first soft rays of morning light penetrated the mist, casting a faint golden halo on his outline and silver hair, forming a subtle contrast with the cool, gray-green background tones around him. The whole picture was filled with an otherworldly sense of tranquility and concentration, as if time had frozen at this moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2490,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000123/group_6/index_488_seed_12200_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/301_0000123_group_6_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000123_group_6_sample_0_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+302,0.01949478,beside-next-to,1.98000000,4,0.01906241,0.00228105,0.01118757,0.66328174,0.44147384,0.11035156,0.00016040,0000135,group_8,0,q3,"Does the second athlete have blonde hair and blue eyes, with his right hand cradling the first athlete's head?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slightly low-angle, handheld medium-length shot captures two male athletes locked in a tight embrace on a vibrant green football field, under the bright, cool white glare of the stadium's floodlights. The first athlete, his sweat-drenched black hair plastered to his forehead, buries his face in his teammate's shoulder; his muscular body, clad in a red and white striped jersey stained with grass and sweat, trembles with overwhelming emotion. The second athlete, a more muscular blonde, wraps his arms tightly around his teammate, his right hand gently cradling the back of his friend's head in a gesture of support, his own face a picture of shared exhaustion and profound relief. The harsh overhead lighting carves sharp highlights into their gleaming skin and creates deep shadows in the folds of their embrace, while in the background, the stadium's packed stands blur into a blur of color, celebratory confetti slowly falling. The scene then abruptly switches to an extreme close-up of the first athlete's face, as he recoils slightly, his eyes squeezed shut, tears streaming down his grime-stained cheeks, his jaw clenched. Then, the second athlete’s face zooms out, his blue eyes welling up, a tear following a path beside his nose, and he offers a small, melancholic, yet reassuring smile, as rapid succession of shots amplify the raw, unfiltered catharsis of their shared moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,49,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000135/group_8/index_8405_seed_690_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/302_0000135_group_8_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000135_group_8_sample_0_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000135_group_8_sample_0_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000135_group_8_sample_0_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000135_group_8_sample_0_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000135_group_8_sample_0_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000135_group_8_sample_0_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+303,0.01941816,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01564216,0.00184393,0.00919882,0.76342392,0.49396455,0.09667969,0.00154442,0000160,group_10,1,q3,Is the man holding a small metal ring between the thumb and index finger of each hand?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium close-up depicts a man with a neatly trimmed dark brown beard, wearing a heather-gray cotton short-sleeved shirt and a dark blue baseball cap. He stands in the center of a sun-drenched meadow, the soft-focus background revealing tall green grass and scattered yellow wildflowers in the warm, golden afternoon light. His gaze is intently directed downward at a small metal ring delicately held between the thumb and index finger of each hand. He carefully wipes away specks of dark dirt from the surface, his lips moving as he speaks, narrating his actions with an air of focused discovery. He fluidly turns his head momentarily to the left, as if to greet someone off-screen, before quickly returning his gaze to the precious object in his hands, his expression a mixture of concentration and quiet excitement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1154,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000160/group_10/index_3321_seed_14242_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/303_0000160_group_10_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+304,0.01933800,left-right-pair+foreground-background,6.44800000,3,0.00629761,0.00076513,0.00368832,0.58465588,0.38942635,0.11132812,0.00203449,0000118,group_2,2,q4,Is a fallen man's hand visible twitching on the stained concrete in the lower foreground?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shaky, eye-level handheld shot shakes violently, struggling to depict the chaotic aftermath of a clash on a gritty city sidewalk. The camera first captures a man, dressed head-to-toe in a black zip-up hoodie and dark jeans, looking around, eyes wide and terrified. As he staggers backward, his arms swing in a wide, uncontrolled arc for balance, his body blurring as he awkwardly exits the left side of the frame. The camera then pans erratically to the right, resting on his opponent, who stands uncomfortably in a clean white crew-neck T-shirt and a dark baseball cap. He speaks calmly, his expression unreadable, and deliberately raises his right hand. With two fingers gripping it precisely, he tilts the brim upward, briefly and methodically wiping his forehead with the back of his palm, then replaces it. His hand then drops, disappearing casually into his trouser pocket. In the lower foreground, lying on the stained concrete, the hand of a fallen man twitches, a faint, seemingly final movement. The background is a series of moving, blurred bystanders scattering in panic, their blurred forms evacuating the scene. The entire event is illuminated by the harsh, flat light of an overcast sky, creating a stark, documentary-like feel and a palpable, thick atmosphere of post-violence tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4082,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000118/group_2/index_4089_seed_20984_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/304_0000118_group_2_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000118_group_2_sample_2_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000118_group_2_sample_2_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000118_group_2_sample_2_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000118_group_2_sample_2_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000118_group_2_sample_2_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000118_group_2_sample_2_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+305,0.01932526,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01989525,0.00238028,0.01167665,0.65559846,0.41070992,0.13378906,0.00186330,0000130,group_11,3,q3,Is the girl shown struggling to scale a crumbling concrete wall with her hands gripping a cracked block?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static telephoto lens, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a young girl in a dark blue sailor-collar school uniform, her hair tied in a neat black ponytail, a few strands falling against her cheeks from the effort. Her brow furrowed, her lips pursed, her eyes etched with unyielding determination as she struggled to scale a crumbling concrete wall. Leaning forward, her hands gripped the edge of a cracked concrete block, her knuckles white from the strain, as she cautiously searched for a firm foothold. A hint of dust clung to the hem of her uniform. She was amidst a vast expanse of ruin, a backdrop of layers of shattered walls and twisted rebar blurred by the telephoto lens's compression. The soft afternoon sunlight penetrates the golden dust in the air, forming clearly visible beams of light. One of the warm spots of light happens to be projected onto her focused profile, illuminating the fine hairs on her cheek and her determined expression. The whole picture forms a sharp contrast between the cold gray tone of the ruins and the warm golden light and shadow, rendering a moment full of challenges and struggles with a tranquil and healing sense of power.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,399,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000130/group_11/index_5683_seed_24096_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/305_0000130_group_11_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000130_group_11_sample_3_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000130_group_11_sample_3_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000130_group_11_sample_3_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000130_group_11_sample_3_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000130_group_11_sample_3_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000130_group_11_sample_3_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+306,0.01931281,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01778280,0.00211209,0.01044714,0.77432877,0.48053503,0.10351562,0.00078267,0000106,group_8,3,q3,Is the woman displaying a genuine smile with visible crow's feet around her eyes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dramatic close-up, captured from a level angle, the camera remains stationary, focused on the face of a middle-aged mother, striving for the ultimate in photographic realism. Soft afternoon sunlight slants in through a side window, like a warm spotlight, perfectly illuminating every detail of her face. Her raven hair, streaked with silver strands, is elegantly tied back, a few loose strands cascading down her cheeks. A genuine, deeply warm smile slowly unfolds across her face, and the corners of her eyes curve in joy, forming fine crow's feet. These marks of time, in the soft light, far from appearing aged, are instead imbued with a sense of story and kindness. The light precisely accentuates the natural texture of her skin, even revealing pores and subtle freckles. Her deep brown eyes gleam with contentment and joy, as if reflecting all that she holds dear. The whole picture is in warm tones, and the background is softly blurred by the shallow depth of field, creating a peaceful, intimate and affectionate atmosphere. Every detail is extremely realistic, making this loving moment seem to be frozen in time.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2167,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000106/group_8/index_4746_seed_262_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/306_0000106_group_8_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000106_group_8_sample_3_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000106_group_8_sample_3_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000106_group_8_sample_3_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000106_group_8_sample_3_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000106_group_8_sample_3_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000106_group_8_sample_3_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+307,0.01931158,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.80800000,6,0.00508043,0.00060165,0.00298585,0.82045180,0.52851480,0.09863281,0.00174087,0000123,group_11,3,q1,"Is the main subject a woman with long, dark brown hair tied in a high ponytail?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Shot in a surreal style, this slow, orbiting medium shot smoothly orbits a woman going about her morning activities in a lush garden at dawn. She has long, dark brown hair, loosely tied in a high ponytail, with a few stray strands gently framing her face. Her eyes are gently closed, her expression serene and focused. She wears a fitted, long-sleeved heather-gray yoga top, the soft, breathable fabric subtly textured, paired with high-waisted, dark teal leggings. Her body gracefully stands in side bend; her right arm extends deliberately and fluidly upward and over her head, elongating her torso, while her left hand rests lightly on her hip. The entire pose maintains a steady, controlled grace. The camera's slow, circular path reveals the immersive environment: she stands barefoot on a manicured lawn, still damp with morning dew. The garden is filled with vibrant green ferns and blooming rose bushes with soft, pink and white petals. The first rays of warm, golden sunlight penetrate the light morning mist between the leaves of the tall, mature trees in the background, backlighting her body and capturing millions of tiny, shimmering dewdrops on the grass and leaves, creating a shimmering bokeh effect. The interplay of warm, low-angle light and cool, soft shadows creates a serene scene of profound calm and focus, and the camera movement enhances the contemplative and visually rich atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2629,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000123/group_11/index_7140_seed_22008_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/307_0000123_group_11_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000123_group_11_sample_3_q1__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000123_group_11_sample_3_q1__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000123_group_11_sample_3_q1__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000123_group_11_sample_3_q1__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000123_group_11_sample_3_q1__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000123_group_11_sample_3_q1__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+308,0.01930951,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01858539,0.00217973,0.01093710,0.79262221,0.45253837,0.12500000,0.00003052,0000109,group_14,3,q2,Is the sky dim and filled with smoke?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"sweeping aerial shot slowly swept across a boundless mountain of electronic waste. Beneath the dim, smoke-filled sky, countless rusted server chassis piled one upon another, their decaying metal frames like the skeletons of ancient beasts, exuding a desolate, lifeless atmosphere. The camera slowly descended and panted forward, finally focusing on a figure amidst the ruins—Lin Ye. He wore a dark gray work jacket stained with oil, his face covered by thick goggles, his expression focused and exhausted. His left arm had been replaced by a crude hydraulic prosthesis, the exposed pistons and pipes emitting a heavy, rhythmic, wheezing sound as he moved. He half-knelt amid the metal rubble, his right hand steadying a modified welding torch, cobbled together from scrap. The muzzle blazed a dazzling blue plasma flame as he carefully dismantled a massive cubic device. It was a quantum server. On its sleek black exterior, beneath a technologically-inspired logo composed of white lines, the four Chinese characters for ""Ark Project"" were clearly printed. Sparks flew from the cutting, briefly illuminating the piles of discarded circuit boards and vine-like cables surrounding him. The air was filled with the acrid smell of ozone and molten metal. The entire scene, a stark contrast between the cold industrial gray tones and the blazing blue light of the welding torch, created an atmosphere of lonely and tenacious survival in the apocalypse.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4718,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000109/group_14/index_4566_seed_15826_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/308_0000109_group_14_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000109_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000109_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000109_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000109_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000109_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000109_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+309,0.01926659,left-right-pair,3.48000000,2,0.01050509,0.00125458,0.00616701,0.77365535,0.46430489,0.11132812,0.00055438,0000007,group_5,1,q4,Does the drone bank to the right with its left wing skimming the rock face and kicking up a cloud of sand and dust?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"thrilling low-angle tracking shot closely follows a sleek, aerodynamic drone with a matte black carbon fiber shell as it rapidly moves forward. The drone navigates an incredibly narrow, steep-sided red sandstone canyon with astonishing speed and agility. The glaring midday sun streams vertically through the canyon's ceiling, casting deep, intense shadows across the jagged rock faces, creating a stark contrast to the illuminated rock surface. The drone's quadrotor propellers spin at high speed, creating a nearly imperceptible motion blur and emitting a deep, powerful hum. A sharp blue LED indicator lights up on the front of the drone, standing out against the warm background. During a particularly breathtaking maneuver, the drone suddenly banks to the right, its left wing skimming almost flat against the rough, wind-worn rock face, kicking up a cloud of fine sand and dust, each visible particle gleaming in the sunlight. The entire sequence is imbued with a calculated, dangerous beauty, creating an atmosphere of adrenaline, intense focus, and intense excitement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2225,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000007/group_5/index_53_seed_13990_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/309_0000007_group_5_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000007_group_5_sample_1_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000007_group_5_sample_1_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000007_group_5_sample_1_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000007_group_5_sample_1_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000007_group_5_sample_1_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000007_group_5_sample_1_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+310,0.01924681,opposite-across,2.51600000,6,0.01316210,0.00159399,0.00771207,0.79577857,0.54067284,0.08593750,0.00293666,0000099,group_15,0,q3,Do two much taller teenage boys walk through the circle and pose against a weathered brick wall?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a vivid scene on a sun-drenched schoolyard. Four young boys, about eight to ten years old, huddled on cracked concrete, huddled joyfully in a tight, happy circle, engrossed in a game. A boy with messy blond hair and a bright red hoodie was laughing, his hands clenched into tight, rock-like fists. Across from him, a boy in a blue striped T-shirt countered with an open, paper-like hand. They were chattering when their playful bubble suddenly burst. Two much taller teenage boys walked directly through their circle, forcing the younger boys to spread out slightly. The first intruder, wearing an oversized black hoodie with the hood pulled down and baggy jeans, didn't break stride. His companion, with short hair, followed closely behind. They paused a few feet away from the group and, with practiced indifference, posed against a weathered brick wall in the background. The first man leaned back, shoving his thumbs in his pockets, while the second stood with his arms crossed, a stony expression on his face. They immediately launched into their own lively conversation, speaking and gesturing only to each other, their body language creating a clear boundary. The four young boys, forgetting their game, now sat down to watch the duo, their expressions a mix of silent annoyance and curiosity. The warm golden light of the late afternoon cast long shadows, creating an atmosphere of palpable social dynamics.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,589,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000099/group_15/index_3145_seed_27104_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/310_0000099_group_15_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000099_group_15_sample_0_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000099_group_15_sample_0_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000099_group_15_sample_0_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000099_group_15_sample_0_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000099_group_15_sample_0_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000099_group_15_sample_0_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+311,0.01915647,beside-next-to+between-flanked,1.43220000,4,0.02481894,0.00294337,0.01458371,0.79917771,0.46934202,0.12500000,0.00444406,0000017,group_11,3,q5,"Is a little boy in a bright blue T-shirt shown pointing at a stall overflowing with colorful, sugar-dusted candies?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, cinematic shot begins, moving from left to right, capturing a wide shot of a bustling open-air market on a sun-drenched cobblestone square. The entire scene is bathed in the soft golden glow of the afternoon sun, casting long, gentle shadows and creating a warm, inviting atmosphere. The camera first glides past a vendor's stall, where vibrant powdered spices—fiery red chili powder, golden turmeric, and earthy brown cumin—are piled high in large wooden bowls. Next to them, stacks of meticulously handwoven baskets made of natural straw and spandex display intricate patterns. The camera continues in a steady motion, showcasing a family gathered together; a mother, her hair tied in a loose bun and wearing a simple white linen dress, gently places a small, shimmering candy into her daughter's waiting hands. As the child savors it, her eyes widen with delight. In the background, other shoppers stroll between stalls shaded by colorful fabric awnings, their muffled conversation blending with the gentle, melodic notes of a lute played by a musician seated on a low stool. The pot finally fell on a little boy in a bright blue T-shirt, who excitedly tugged at his father's sleeve, stretched out his arm, and pointed with pure wonder at a stall overflowing with colorful, sugar-dusted candies, their surfaces gleaming in the warm light.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2589,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000017/group_11/index_3263_seed_17978_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/311_0000017_group_11_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000017_group_11_sample_3_q5__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000017_group_11_sample_3_q5__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000017_group_11_sample_3_q5__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000017_group_11_sample_3_q5__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000017_group_11_sample_3_q5__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000017_group_11_sample_3_q5__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+312,0.01908240,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01751135,0.00208774,0.01028241,0.81905109,0.49098763,0.11132812,0.00017935,0000068,group_14,1,q1,Is the scene a celestial sea of clouds resembling soft cotton and undulating mountains?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"An epic long shot, the camera slowly and steadily advancing from a slightly bird's-eye view, traverses a celestial, swirling sea of clouds, akin to a fairyland, yet possessing a physical presence. Beams of divine golden light pierce the clouds, creating a distinct Tyndall effect and framing the edges of the sea with a dazzling golden edge. Atop this cloudscape, resembling both soft cotton and undulating mountains, a goddess, clad in the magnificent costume of a Dunhuang apsaras, lies asleep on her side. She wears a flowing silk gown in hues of vermilion red and peacock green. The sheer fabric is embroidered with intricate patterns of precious images in gold thread. Long, colorful ribbons flow like still streams across the cloud bed beneath her. Her towering bun is adorned with delicate gold hairpins and pearl hairpins, while strands of jet-black hair fall around her jade-white face. Yet, her sleeping posture is far from peaceful. Her body, huddled slightly in a nightmare of unbearable moral conflict, her brow furrowed, her classically beautiful face etched with deep anguish. As the camera zooms in, her fingers unconsciously clutch her sleeve, her body trembling slightly with inner torment. Finally, as if jolted awake by an invisible force, her eyes snap open. Those clear pupils, at first filled with the lingering confusion and pain of a nightmare, are quickly replaced by a sober, tragic resolve. Tears gleam in her eyes, but they remain unshed. The entire scene is frozen in a sacred and poignant atmosphere, imbued with the struggle and determination that comes after making a difficult decision.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1274,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000068/group_14/index_7237_seed_30578_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/312_0000068_group_14_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000068_group_14_sample_1_q1__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000068_group_14_sample_1_q1__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000068_group_14_sample_1_q1__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000068_group_14_sample_1_q1__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000068_group_14_sample_1_q1__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000068_group_14_sample_1_q1__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+313,0.01905211,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01654522,0.00196213,0.00972206,0.77908933,0.44921100,0.12500000,0.00003847,0000147,group_4,0,q3,Does a hand reach into the frame to offer the woman a dark blue passport which she accepts?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a realistic-style scene in a bright, sterile airport check-in area. A woman with thick, shoulder-length blond curls, wearing a crisp white collared shirt that fits her uniform, sits attentively behind a long, matte-gray counter. Her fingers initially move deftly across a black keyboard, her focus fixed on a computer screen just off-screen. She pauses typing, her gaze shifting slightly upward, toward an unseen figure. A hand reaches into the frame, offering her a dark blue passport, which she accepts with steady, practiced movements. Simultaneously, two other people approach from the right side of the frame, walking steadily, just like the next person. The first is a man with neatly combed short brown hair, thin-framed glasses, and a dark gray suit jacket over a light-colored shirt. The second person's face remains invisible, partially visible beside him, their form suggesting a casual posture. The entire scene is illuminated by cool, even overhead fluorescent lights, which reflect off the polished white tile floor, creating a clean, functional atmosphere free of harsh shadows and reinforcing the impersonal efficiency of the modern travel center.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2793,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000147/group_4/index_1124_seed_866_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/313_0000147_group_4_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q3__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q3__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q3__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q3__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q3__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000147_group_4_sample_0_q3__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+314,0.01900462,beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,7.48800000,7,0.00442129,0.00052982,0.00259432,0.71600515,0.53251493,0.06640625,0.00013274,0000158,group_8,0,q4,Is the woman gesturing with her right hand near her glass while the man's hand rests on the table?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures an intimate moment of passionate conversation between two friends in a dimly lit, cozy bistro. A woman in her twenties, with wavy auburn hair loosely pulled back and wearing a soft cream-colored sweater, leans forward, a gentle smile on her face as she speaks. Across from her, a man of similar age, wearing a dark green button-down shirt with the sleeves casually rolled up to his forearms, listens intently, his head slightly tilted, a look of genuine engagement. Between them, on a small, round, dark wooden table, lie two elegant, large glasses half-filled with deep red wine. As the woman shares her story, her right hand gracefully and expressively gestures near the bowl of her glass, while the man's hand rests near the base of his own, his fingers leisurely tracing the polished wood. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden light of a low-hanging lamp, casting soft shadows on their faces and causing the wine to gleam, creating a tranquil and welcoming atmosphere of easy friendship and shared confidence.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,33,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000158/group_8/index_5750_seed_15303_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/314_0000158_group_8_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q4__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q4__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q4__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q4__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q4__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000158_group_8_sample_0_q4__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+315,0.01896503,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01578709,0.00188235,0.00926983,0.79432994,0.47671333,0.10937500,0.00023937,0000070,group_12,1,q5,Is the scene illuminated by cool equipment light and neon track lights casting dynamic shadows on the competitors' faces?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slowly rotating, orbiting medium shot brings us into the core control area of a futuristic drone racing arena. Clad in explosive competitive cinematography, it focuses on two competitors battling side by side. The female competitor on the left, sporting a sleek, dark purple ponytail, wears immersive FPV (first-person view) goggles that half-cover her face, their lenses reflecting a dazzling stream of data. She wears a tight, black, high-tech racing suit with a neon blue circuit pattern. She leans forward slightly, her hands steady and decisive as she grips a complex multi-stick drone controller, her thumbs fine-tuning the joysticks with a speed barely tangible to the naked eye. Beside her, her male teammate, with slightly damp short black hair and a furrowed brow, is absorbed in analyzing a translucent holographic data screen floating before them. His fingers swiftly and deftly swipe and tap across the illuminated interface, adjusting performance parameters and flight path diagrams in real time. Behind them, on the huge circular track structure, other drones turned into blurred colorful light bands and flew by at high speed. The whole scene was illuminated by the cool light emitted by their equipment and the neon lights of the track, casting dynamic light and shadow on their focused faces, creating a tacit cooperation and highly tense competitive atmosphere in the high-speed confrontation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3700,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000070/group_12/index_642_seed_16434_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/315_0000070_group_12_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000070_group_12_sample_1_q5__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000070_group_12_sample_1_q5__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000070_group_12_sample_1_q5__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000070_group_12_sample_1_q5__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000070_group_12_sample_1_q5__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000070_group_12_sample_1_q5__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+316,0.01894163,left-right-pair,4.44000000,6,0.00718050,0.00085361,0.00421793,0.84828120,0.58140439,0.08496094,0.00131804,0000156,group_15,0,q2,"Is the man wearing a soft, cream-colored linen shirt?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, high-angle, medium-close-up captures a young Southeast Asian man with thick, wavy black hair, absorbed in quiet reflection. He sits at a richly textured wooden table, leaning slightly forward, maintaining a posture of intense concentration. He wears a soft, cream-colored linen shirt, its texture visible in the warm light. Golden hour sunlight streams through an unseen window to his right, bathing one side of his face in brilliant light and casting long, soft shadows across the scene, illuminating the dancing dust particles in the air. His dark eyes stare at the pages of a worn, leather-bound journal, open before him. His left hand steadying the cream-colored, textured paper, his right hand carefully guiding a classic fountain pen with a polished dark barrel and silver nib. The pen glides smoothly and deliberately across the page, leaving a trail of dark ink. His pensive expression—a slightly furrowed brow and soft lips—conveys a profound inner dialogue. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a cozy, book-lined study. This, combined with the warm color palette and focused silence of the action, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility and introspection.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3020,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000156/group_15/index_751_seed_33217_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/316_0000156_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+317,0.01892438,beside-next-to+opposite-across+between-flanked,7.48800000,7,0.00473809,0.00057057,0.00277835,0.69103193,0.46626192,0.08398438,0.00076896,0000158,group_8,2,q2,"Are two friends, a woman with wavy auburn hair in a cream sweater and a man in a dark green button-down shirt, visible?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures an intimate moment of passionate conversation between two friends in a dimly lit, cozy bistro. A woman in her twenties, with wavy auburn hair loosely pulled back and wearing a soft cream-colored sweater, leans forward, a gentle smile on her face as she speaks. Across from her, a man of similar age, wearing a dark green button-down shirt with the sleeves casually rolled up to his forearms, listens intently, his head slightly tilted, a look of genuine engagement. Between them, on a small, round, dark wooden table, lie two elegant, large glasses half-filled with deep red wine. As the woman shares her story, her right hand gracefully and expressively gestures near the bowl of her glass, while the man's hand rests near the base of his own, his fingers leisurely tracing the polished wood. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden light of a low-hanging lamp, casting soft shadows on their faces and causing the wine to gleam, creating a tranquil and welcoming atmosphere of easy friendship and shared confidence.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,198,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000158/group_8/index_5750_seed_15305_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/317_0000158_group_8_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000158_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000158_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000158_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000158_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000158_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000158_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+318,0.01891109,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.02027684,0.00241651,0.01190689,0.69699949,0.42709687,0.13281250,0.00322998,0000023,group_14,3,q2,Is the man standing on a flat cyan rock while spinning around his core with his sleeves unfurling in a horizontal circle?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with a slow, wide-angle crane shot, initially focusing in a medium shot on a man dressed in flowing Hanfu (Chinese traditional clothing), inspired by the image of a ""drumstick teacher."" He stands atop a flat, cyan rock amidst a backdrop of mountains shrouded in ink and wash painting. He wears a thin, pure white silk shirt with large sleeves, his long hair tied into a high bun with a simple wooden hairpin. His face is delicate, his eyes slightly closed, his expression focused and serene. As he spins around his core, his movements steady and graceful, his immense sleeves unfurling due to centrifugal force, tracing a nearly perfect horizontal circle in the air, their edges leaving fleeting traces in the moist air. The camera steadily and deliberately pans backward and upward, gradually integrating his individual dynamic beauty into the larger context: the mountains behind him are not realistic, but rather depicted in the freehand style of Qi Baishi's paintings. Their outlines are outlined in varying shades of ink, majestic yet simple. Vast expanses of white space are filled with swirling clouds and mist, and mountains near and far appear to be looming through the mist. Soft, diffuse skylight penetrates the mist, coating the entire scene with a cool silver-gray hue. The frame is stripped of all color except black, white, and gray. Ultimately, the spinning man becomes a tiny, harmonious point of movement within the vast world, imbued with an ethereal, solitary, and profound Zen spirit.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4363,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000023/group_14/index_3305_seed_29360_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/318_0000023_group_14_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000023_group_14_sample_3_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000023_group_14_sample_3_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000023_group_14_sample_3_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000023_group_14_sample_3_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000023_group_14_sample_3_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000023_group_14_sample_3_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+319,0.01876709,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01567812,0.00186781,0.00920687,0.76844317,0.50551200,0.08691406,0.00044000,0000104,group_3,0,q1,"Is the main subject an elderly man with silver hair and deeply wrinkled, weathered skin?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a level angle begins in medium shot, then slowly pulls back to reveal a wider scene. The frame focuses on a silver-haired elderly man, clad in a loose, white, traditional cotton and linen training suit, nestled in a tranquil bamboo forest. The faint morning sun, the sole source of light, penetrates the towering, verdant bamboo poles and dense leaves, creating soft, voluminous beams that are visible through the misty air and cast shifting, dappled shadows on the damp, leaf-covered ground. The elderly man's hair is meticulously combed, his face deeply wrinkled, weathered. His eyes are slightly closed, his expression focused and peaceful. He is performing Tai Chi with incredible slowness and stability, his arms tracing smooth arcs at a speed barely perceptible to the naked eye, his weight shifting effortlessly between his legs. Each movement is imbued with inner, composed strength. His wide white sleeves fluttered gently as his body turned, and their trajectory seemed to merge with the flowing air and light. There was no pause between his movements, perfectly interpreting the artistic conception of ""flowing like clouds and running water"". The whole scene presented an extremely quiet, solemn and Zen-like meditative atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2432,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000104/group_3/index_2934_seed_6320_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/319_0000104_group_3_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q1__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q1__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q1__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q1__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q1__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q1__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+320,0.01872845,opposite-across,2.78800000,9,0.01215070,0.00144124,0.00713964,0.79488069,0.50783157,0.10351562,0.00180632,0000009,group_4,2,q1,Is the scene set in a wood-paneled academic library with tall bookshelves filled with old leather-bound books in the background?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot depicts a tense, silent confrontation in the hallowed quiet of a wood-paneled academic library. At a large, polished mahogany table, a young man with shaggy black hair leans forward, an impassioned look of frustration written across his face. Wearing a comfortable, dark green cardigan, they repeatedly gesture with their index finger to a tablet on the table. The tablet's screen emits a bright, cool digital glow, casting a stark blue light on their faces and hands, illuminating the complex data charts visible on the display. An older man seated opposite, dressed in a formal dark tweed blazer and a crisp white collared shirt, remains erect, his posture a wall of defiance. His silver-gray hair is impossibly neatly trimmed, his face a mask of resolute misunderstanding. He shakes his head slowly and stubbornly, his lips pressed into a thin line, his gaze deliberately averted, refusing even a glance at the glowing screen. The warm golden light from a classic green-shaded bank lamp on the table illuminates the scene, creating deep shadows that contrast with the cool glow of the tablet, visually emphasizing the generational and ideological clash. The background is filled with tall, dimly lit bookshelves filled with old leather-bound books, creating a heavy academic atmosphere, imbued with the weight of tradition and unspoken disagreements.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,543,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_4/index_5960_seed_20023_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/320_0000009_group_4_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q1__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q1__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q1__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q1__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q1__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q1__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+321,0.01868478,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01657439,0.00196223,0.00974144,0.83837140,0.52738470,0.10546875,0.00150055,0000023,group_1,0,q2,"Is the main subject a crystal-clear, stemless glass containing hot water?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady, fixed-camera macro close-up, captured with the quality of a nature documentary, focuses squarely on a crystal-clear, stemless glass. Several tightly-formed Tieguanyin tea leaves, each a dark green with a slightly gritty texture, perform an elegant ballet in the freshly poured, steaming, clear hot water. A soft, bright, diffused light from the side precisely outlines the dry, wrinkled texture of the tea leaves, which then reflect a translucent luster in the pure water. As they descend slowly and swirling toward the bottom of the cup, their once tightly curled bodies begin to cautiously unfold, like dormant life gently awakened. Layer by layer, with a subtle tremor, the leaves unfold, revealing the fresher green within. In this poetic process of sinking and blooming, strings of tiny bubbles quietly escape from the gaps between the leaves, while a faint, almost imperceptible wisp of amber tea liquid lingers around them, adding a touch of warm color to the entire picture. The rhythm of the entire scene is slow and focused, creating a visual atmosphere of ultimate tranquility, purity, and Zen, perfectly capturing the beauty of tea leaves coming to life in water.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2344,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000023/group_1/index_4441_seed_10165_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/321_0000023_group_1_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000023_group_1_sample_0_q2__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000023_group_1_sample_0_q2__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000023_group_1_sample_0_q2__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000023_group_1_sample_0_q2__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000023_group_1_sample_0_q2__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000023_group_1_sample_0_q2__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+322,0.01866360,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01595172,0.00188787,0.00937590,0.79201365,0.45754334,0.12500000,0.00015491,0000169,group_2,0,q4,"Is the opponent wearing blue and silver armor, leaning back on a pile of books, and blocking with a sword?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion, arcing pan shot from a low angle captures a fierce duel between two miniature samurai warriors across a cluttered wooden desk. One warrior, clad in ornate crimson and black armor and a helmet bearing a men-yoroi (ghost mask), stands in a powerful lunge, his katana gripped tightly in both hands, slashing fiercely from above. His opponent, clad in more austere blue and silver armor, leans back, his legs planted firmly on a pile of books, and with a precise upward block, his blade securely blocks the opponent's blow. The blades of the two swords clash in mid-air, sparking a dazzling explosion. The shockwave sends a mountain of manuscript paper flying upward, sending countless pages of elegant calligraphy swirling and tumbling wildly through the air, surrounding the combatants like a blizzard. In the background, a classical desk lamp casts a warm and concentrated beam, illuminating the black ink flowing from the overturned ink bottle, as well as the scattered brushes and books. The light outlines sharp contours on the metal surface of the armor and the edges of the flying paper, casting long, dancing shadows. The whole scene is filled with a tense sense of confrontation and dynamic violent aesthetics, creating an epic yet surreal atmosphere confined to a small space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2754,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000169/group_2/index_866_seed_28904_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/322_0000169_group_2_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+323,0.01864211,foreground-background+between-flanked,4.40800000,2,0.00688366,0.00082271,0.00404063,0.86162275,0.60373133,0.07324219,0.00164917,0000002,group_9,1,q4,Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"At dusk, a static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a lone figure on a Parisian basketball court, creating a scene of profound solitude and elegance. In the background, the iconic silhouette of the Eiffel Tower is clearly visible against the stunning sunset, its iron latticework appearing a stark black against the bright sky, tinged with hues of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft violet. In the foreground, the athlete, rendered almost in silhouette by the powerful backlight, maintains a low, focused stance in a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts. The figure deftly dribbles a classic orange basketball with fluid precision; the pebbled leather surface is barely discernible as it blurs, moving from a low, rhythmic thump on the worn asphalt court to a rapid cross between the legs. The warm, dramatic light of the setting sun casts long shadows and creates a bright rim light around the figure's body, highlighting their concentrated energy and the sweat on their brow. The atmosphere is one of quiet, solitary passion, blending the implicit rhythmic sound of the dribbling ball with the quiet grandeur of the city. As the last vibrant colors of sunset deepen into dusk, the entire scene slowly and steadily fades, light and image disappearing until only utter black remains.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4467,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000002/group_9/index_149_seed_23579_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/323_0000002_group_9_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000002_group_9_sample_1_q4__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000002_group_9_sample_1_q4__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000002_group_9_sample_1_q4__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000002_group_9_sample_1_q4__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000002_group_9_sample_1_q4__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000002_group_9_sample_1_q4__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+324,0.01848700,opposite-across,2.24400000,4,0.01451214,0.00170487,0.00853818,0.74132329,0.50920862,0.08300781,0.00253025,0000080,group_9,3,q3,Is a young father in a gray crew-neck shirt sitting across from a woman in a beige sweater?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"warm, still shot, taken from a level angle, transports the viewer to a family dinner filled with the warmth of everyday life. The frame's absolute centerpiece is a bubbling, steaming copper hot pot, its roiling red oil broth swirling with vibrant red chilies and spices. A thick, white vapor rises continuously, softening the edges of the frame. A family sits intimately around a dark, solid wood round table, laden with a variety of fresh ingredients served on white porcelain plates. A kind-faced, gray-haired grandmother, wearing a burgundy Chinese-style buttoned blouse, carefully uses chopsticks to lift a piece of tender, boiled tofu for her young granddaughter, who has pigtails and eager eyes. The little girl, wearing a light yellow sweater, looks up at her grandmother with a rosy face, filled with anticipation. Across from her, a young father, dressed in a simple gray crew-neck shirt and a relaxed smile, listened intently to his wife, who, with shoulder-length hair and a beige sweater, gently shoved a plate of emerald greens toward the center of the table. A warm chandelier hanging directly above the dining table provided the sole source of light, casting a soft glow that focused on the steam from the hot pot and the happy faces of the family. Behind them, the living room backdrop was rendered in a highly blurred, soft-focus effect, with only the faint outlines of the warm yellow walls and bookshelves visible, creating a warm halo. The scene, dominated by gold and red tones, created an atmosphere of profound warmth, intimacy, and a tranquil, lived-in atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3670,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000080/group_9/index_6388_seed_13995_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/324_0000080_group_9_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000080_group_9_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000080_group_9_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000080_group_9_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000080_group_9_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000080_group_9_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000080_group_9_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+325,0.01847337,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01703002,0.00208703,0.00996200,0.72454184,0.48297584,0.09765625,0.00218415,0000161,group_7,0,q2,Is the man wearing a dark charcoal gray suit that is completely soaked and clinging to his body?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, dynamic tracking shot follows a man sprinting along a rainy city street. The camera stays in sync with him, emphasizing the speed and force of his run. The man, in his thirties, wears a well-tailored, dark charcoal gray suit, now completely soaked by the downpour, the expensive fabric clinging to his contours. His once-pristine white shirt is ripped at the collar, a crimson silk tie hanging loosely, swinging with his movements. The rain dampens his short, dark hair, strands clinging to his forehead and cheeks. His expression is tense, his jaw clenched, and his eyes reveal a mixture of despair and unwavering focus. Directly ahead of him lies a wide asphalt road, its surface a black mirror in the relentless rain, greedily reflecting the shimmering, iridescent neon lights of the tall buildings on either side—psychedelic pinks, cool blues, and glaring reds. With each strenuous step forward, his polished black Oxfords slammed heavily into the puddle, sending up circles of shimmering, neon-lit water, forming brief, dazzling arcs in the camera. The entire scene is imbued with a tense, urgent atmosphere, like a climactic chase scene in a neo-noir film. The stark contrast between the cool tones of the frame and the saturated neon highlights creates a dramatic tension that is both flamboyant and desperate.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3492,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000161/group_7/index_3558_seed_20761_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/325_0000161_group_7_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+326,0.01845822,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.02013475,0.00238978,0.01182998,0.64066726,0.41394037,0.12792969,0.00061280,0000169,group_5,2,q3,"Is there a man on the left side of the frame with two thick vertical stripes of face paint (one blue, one white) on his left cheek?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a euphoric moment as five men stand shoulder to shoulder, their arms intertwined in a powerful display of camaraderie. The group's skin tones range from fair to olive to dark brown, with a variety of hair colors and styles, including short blond, curly black, and straight dark brown. Four of the men wear blue shirts in varying shades and styles (from navy to royal), creating a sense of solidarity. A man near the center breaks the pattern by wearing a blue T-shirt over a long-sleeved shirt, with bold yellow and black horizontal stripes running down his visible arm. To the left of the frame, a man sports two simple yet thick stripes of face paint—one blue, one white—applied vertically across his left cheek. The five men collectively cheer, their heads tilted slightly back, their mouths wide open in genuine, eyebrow-raising smiles. They are posed indoors in a cozy, warmly lit room, with ambient light from an off-camera source accentuating their ecstatic expressions. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a casual living space without distracting from the subject, focusing the entire picture on the palpable atmosphere of victory celebration and deep-rooted friendship.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3450,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000169/group_5/index_5612_seed_33202_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/326_0000169_group_5_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+327,0.01837333,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00764125,0.00090839,0.00448857,0.75013655,0.54730827,0.06640625,0.00016546,0000132,group_7,1,q1,Is the main subject a man resembling the Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai with long dark hair and a flowing white silk robe?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, zoomed-out shot, starting from a slightly upward angle, first focuses on a massive bluestone by the river, bathed in moonlight. The great Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai reclines, half-drunk and intoxicated. His long, dark hair, undone by a bun, a few wet strands clinging to his drunken face. His features are rendered with remarkable clarity by the cool moonlight. He wears a flowing white silk robe with wide sleeves, the collar slightly open, revealing faint stains of dark wine on the folds. The hem of the robe falls limply on the mossy stone surface. His eyes are lightly closed, a faint, detached smile playing on his lips. His body is relaxed, his chest rising and falling with his deep, steady breathing. Beside him, an antique bronze wine jug has fallen, half-emptied between the moist moss and soil. The last drops of wine seem to linger on the mouth, reflecting a faint glow in the moonlight. As the camera steadily and deliberately pulls back, a wider scene is revealed: the vast river, like a vast black jade in the still night, a bright full moon casts a clear glow in the sky, spreading a fragmented, shimmering silver band across the water. In the distance, the inky silhouettes of rolling hills shrouded in mist. Nearby, a few clumps of reeds sway gently in the night breeze, rustling softly. The entire scene exudes a sense of ultimate tranquility and poetic solitude. The dominant color palette is deep blue-black and silver-white, and the strong contrast of light and shadow creates an otherworldly, classical aesthetic atmosphere of detachment from the world.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,724,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000132/group_7/index_6699_seed_26357_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/327_0000132_group_7_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q1__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q1__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q1__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q1__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q1__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q1__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+328,0.01834624,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01598242,0.00190561,0.00938454,0.72206122,0.51245576,0.07031250,0.00003695,0000069,group_1,3,q3,Is a young woman wearing a deep cyan silk robe with silver auspicious cloud patterns riding a spirit beast?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic low-angle tracking shot, capturing every moment with superb clarity and fluidity at an ultra-high frame rate, follows a young woman astride a majestic, luminous spirit beast as it speeds through the narrow, winding alleys of an ancient Oriental city. The woman, clad in a deep cyan silk robe embroidered with silver auspicious cloud patterns, her jet-black hair fluttering like a banner in the wind, a few delicate jade hairpins glimpsed through her hair. She leans forward, pressed against the spirit beast's back, her expression focused and resolute. The spirit beast beneath her crotch resembles a kirin, covered in translucent scales emitting a soft, azure hue. Its mane and tail are not physical, but rather fluid beams of light, trailing dazzling trails through the night. The spirit beast's hooves barely touch the rain-soaked, shimmering bluestone floor, each leap leaving shimmering particles of energy in the air. The alleys they sped through were flanked by quaint wooden buildings with soaring eaves and angled corners. Warm orange lights shone from the windows, and red lanterns hung from the eaves swayed violently in the strong wind they stirred. The cool light emanating from the spirit beasts intertwined with the warm glow of the lanterns, casting ever-shifting, bizarre shadows on the mottled walls, creating a magnificent atmosphere that was both tense and imbued with the mysterious charm of Eastern fantasy.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1268,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000069/group_1/index_825_seed_4098_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/328_0000069_group_1_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000069_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000069_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000069_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000069_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000069_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000069_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+329,0.01823384,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.44000000,5,0.00480538,0.00058660,0.00281252,0.78741014,0.56972069,0.07421875,0.00052589,0000136,group_9,3,q3,"Does the man open a white rickety cabinet to reveal shelves with glass jars, tins, and cardboard boxes?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures the scene in a brightly lit modern kitchen. A man with slightly tousled brown hair casually walks toward a set of lower cabinets. He wears a red and white checkered, short-sleeved button-down shirt and contrasting teal checkered shorts, creating a relaxed, homely look. He pauses before a white, rickety cabinet and reaches down deliberately, his fingers grasping the small, brushed metal knob. He smoothly pulls the door open, revealing shelves filled with a messy yet organized pantry: an assortment of unlabeled glass jars, colorful tins, and plain cardboard boxes. Holding a simple glass jar with a plain metal lid in his right hand, he takes a step closer, bending slightly at his knees and waist, and carefully reaches into the cabinet. Steadily and accurately, he places the jar on the bottom shelf, nestled between a stack of jars and a box. Once his fingers release the jar, he straightens and begins to rotate his body to the left. As he begins to turn away from the open cabinet, his movements are fluid and unhurried, completing a simple chore. The scene is bathed in warm, soft light from overhead fixtures, creating a comfortable and tranquil atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,804,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000136/group_9/index_5875_seed_11774_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/329_0000136_group_9_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000136_group_9_sample_3_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+330,0.01819678,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01328098,0.00159169,0.00779286,0.81846142,0.59667760,0.07031250,0.00009972,0000117,group_9,1,q2,"Is the man wearing a loose, flowing dark blue silk robe and reclining on an antique carved wooden chair?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a thin, middle-aged strategist with a neatly trimmed goatee, nestled within a dimly lit military tent. He wears a loose, flowing dark blue silk robe, his long hair held back with a simple wooden hairpin. He reclines leisurely on an antique carved wooden chair. The only illumination comes from a bronze oil lamp on a table beside him. Its flickering, warm yellow light casts deep, undulating shadows on his face, emphasizing his pensive expression and illuminating the folds of his silk robe with a soft sheen. In his right hand, he grasps a feather fan made of pure white crane feathers, gently waving it with a steady, leisurely rhythm, the breeze occasionally causing the lamplight to flicker. In the background, a military map hangs on the thick dark canvas tent wall, and a wooden weapons rack with unfolded bamboo slips and weapons can be vaguely seen next to it. The whole scene has a warm tone, mainly deep dark colors, creating an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tranquility and strategic planning against the backdrop of military tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,978,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000117/group_9/index_9345_seed_1224_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/330_0000117_group_9_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000117_group_9_sample_1_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+331,0.01810549,opposite-across,2.65200000,7,0.01070129,0.00132781,0.00624899,0.86717266,0.64960134,0.07128906,0.00116056,0000074,group_0,1,q4,"Are there visible ingredients including beef rolls, emerald greens, white tofu slices, mushrooms, and bowls of dipping sauce on the table?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"highly detailed documentary medium shot, shot from a level angle, slowly and steadily moves forward, gradually deepening into a family dining room filled with laughter and chatter. In the center of a dark, round wooden table, a stainless steel hot pot bubbling, half filled with a vibrant red spicy broth swirling with dried chilies and Sichuan peppercorns, the other half a milky white bone broth simmering with red dates and goji berries. Thick, white steam rises continuously from the pot, like a soft filter, imbuing the entire scene with a warm, fuzzy quality. A grandmother with graying hair and a kind smile carefully uses chopsticks to transfer a boiled fish ball to her granddaughter's bowl. The little girl, with pigtails and a pink sweater, gazes expectantly at the food in her bowl. Across from them, a middle-aged father in a dark blue V-neck sweater chats with his wife, a bright smile on his face. His mother, in a beige turtleneck, responds gently, expertly picking up a piece of green vegetable with her chopsticks and preparing to add it to the pot. The table was covered with a variety of ingredients: neatly arranged beef rolls, emerald greens, crisp white tofu slices, and fresh mushrooms. In front of each person was a bowl of prepared dipping sauce. A warm yellow chandelier hung above the table provided the sole source of light, its glow illuminating the steaming air and framing the happy expressions on everyone's faces, creating a warm, lively, and vibrant atmosphere for a family dinner.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4201,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000074/group_0/index_2055_seed_18411_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/331_0000074_group_0_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+332,0.01807487,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.01764592,0.00218008,0.01031057,0.67171258,0.48488742,0.08593750,0.00026095,0000026,group_15,0,q4,Does the woman's eyes snap open with dilated light brown pupils showing sudden surprise?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"stunning, close-up, static shot, focused at near-eye level, captures the face of a sleeping young woman, the entire scene steeped in the opulence and softness of Rococo style. Soft candlelight intertwines with the warm afternoon sun filtering through silk curtains, casting a warm, three-dimensional light on the girl's delicate, fair skin. Her pale pink eyeshadow adds a touch of sweetness. Initially, the subtle flutter of her thick, butterfly-like, dark brown eyelashes shatters the stillness of the scene. Then, her eyes snap open, her clear, light brown pupils dilating with sudden surprise. The camera captures, with pinpoint accuracy, the perfect reflection of a delicate, multi-layered cake in the foreground, adorned with sugar roses, fresh berries, and gold foil. Even the sheen of the buttercream is clearly visible. The scene, dominated by a palette of ivory, pale pink, and gold, creates a dramatic atmosphere of innocence, dreaminess, and sudden awakening, like a magnificent painting in motion.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2112,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000026/group_15/index_1868_seed_8461_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/332_0000026_group_15_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000026_group_15_sample_0_q4__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000026_group_15_sample_0_q4__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000026_group_15_sample_0_q4__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000026_group_15_sample_0_q4__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000026_group_15_sample_0_q4__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000026_group_15_sample_0_q4__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+333,0.01807419,left-right-pair,3.72000000,3,0.00911125,0.00108747,0.00534919,0.73564816,0.47604874,0.10058594,0.00019252,0000106,group_11,1,q4,"Is the environment a vast, desolate battlefield with cracked yellow earth, visible smoke, dust, and tattered flags?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"fixed, medium-long shot, captured from a slightly upward angle in the style of documentary photography, captures an ancient general clad in weathered iron scale armor, slowly advancing from the right side of the frame to the left. The dim afterglow of the setting sun slants down from the sky, casting long shadows on the cracked yellow earth, silhouetted against the general and his horse. The general wears an iron helmet with a long red tassel. His face, weathered and dust-stained, stares piercingly ahead. His armor, composed of countless plates, is covered in scratches and dark rust, while the crimson battle robe beneath it sways slightly in the wind. He holds the reins firmly in one hand, the other on the hilt of the ancient sword at his waist, his posture erect and unwavering, even on horseback. The muscles of his black warhorse bulge beneath him, its coat matted to a dull sheen from a mixture of sweat and dust. Each heavy thump of the horse's hooves stirs up a small plume of yellow dust. The backdrop is a vast, desolate battlefield, the air thick with visible smoke and dust. Tattered flags flutter feebly in the wind, and in the distance, the outlines of broken weapons and fallen chariots are faintly visible. The dominant tones of the painting are earthy ochre and the gray-black of iron. The deep red of the general's robe and helmet tassel serve as solemn embellishments, creating an epic atmosphere of postwar desolation, tragic grandeur, and yet filled with tenacious strength.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3177,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000106/group_11/index_5700_seed_13739_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/333_0000106_group_11_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000106_group_11_sample_1_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000106_group_11_sample_1_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000106_group_11_sample_1_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000106_group_11_sample_1_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000106_group_11_sample_1_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000106_group_11_sample_1_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+334,0.01807363,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.01937732,0.00233243,0.01136326,0.66623563,0.42496663,0.12304688,0.00133243,0000020,group_14,3,q3,"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In the style of Ghibli animation, a sweeping wide shot, like that from a low-flying drone, glides gracefully across a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows. The camera slowly pans right, revealing a massive, hill-sized pumpkin perched in the center of the field, its vibrant orange rind deeply grooved and textured with a soft, painterly texture. The pumpkin is meticulously carved into a rustic, whimsical house, with a small, round wooden door and several circular windows. Flanked by dense, leafy green vines, they curl around a curving, chimney-like stem at the top. The entire scene is bathed in warm, golden afternoon light, casting long, soft shadows across the tall, emerald green grass, which sways hypnotically in the breeze. A massive, sea urchin-like creature, curled up asleep on the pumpkin's roof; its spines are not sharp but soft and plush, like velvety tendrils covered in a layer of delicate green moss. As the camera settles into position, the creature begins to stir, slowly and deliberately emerging from its slumber. Its mossy spine trembles gently, and then its body unfolds section by section, a gentle and peaceful awakening that perfectly captures the serene and magical atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1499,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000020/group_14/index_287_seed_11784_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/334_0000020_group_14_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000020_group_14_sample_3_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000020_group_14_sample_3_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000020_group_14_sample_3_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000020_group_14_sample_3_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000020_group_14_sample_3_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000020_group_14_sample_3_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+335,0.01805788,left-right-pair,4.92000000,8,0.00643403,0.00076798,0.00377737,0.77155334,0.54002482,0.08398438,0.00099519,0000067,group_10,0,q5,Is the scene illuminated by soft golden morning light and a warm bulb glow creating a focused halo around the woman's face?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a surreal, high-definition digital aesthetic, the film begins with a slow, graceful, doll-like movement, sliding horizontally across the magnificent, ornate facade of a sprawling limestone mansion. Soft, golden morning light casts long shadows across the intricate carvings and towering pillars, rendering every detail with crisp 4K clarity. As the camera continues its steady, uninterrupted path, it perfectly aligns with a spotless, large bay window, revealing a brightly lit, luxurious bathroom. Through the pristine glass, a woman with dark black hair pulled back into a sleek, elegant bun can be seen leaning against a large, ornate mirror. She wears a lustrous, blush-tinged silk robe, the fabric striking in its allure. She meticulously shapes her eyebrows with precise, deliberate movements, her expression intense and unwavering. In her right hand, she holds a pair of pointed metal tweezers, while with her left, she gently pinches the skin above her eyes. The soft morning light from the window and the warm, even glow from the bulb in the mirror-framed dressing table combine to illuminate the scene, creating a focused halo around her face, while the luxurious surroundings of white marble countertops, gleaming gilded fixtures, and crystal accents fade into the soft-focus background, establishing an atmosphere of quiet, personal ritual, and focused perfection.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2407,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_10/index_7152_seed_29972_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/335_0000067_group_10_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+336,0.01802843,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01555040,0.00185918,0.00912748,0.70887709,0.45335081,0.11718750,0.00219697,0000003,group_8,3,q1,Are a pair of hands visible arranging vintage hardcover books?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level close-up captures a pair of hands meticulously arranging a collection of vintage hardcover books. These hands, belonging to a person wearing the sleeves of a cozy forest green knit sweater, hold a thick hardcover bound in worn crimson leather. The book's spine features a faint, faded gilt pattern, and the pages are a warm, decked ivory. With steady, deliberate precision, the hands guide the book onto a dark, polished mahogany bookshelf already crowded with similar antique volumes. The camera follows the person as they gently and carefully slide the crimson book into the perfectly sized, narrow gap between the aquamarine and dark brown volumes. The book slides smoothly into place until its spine aligns perfectly with the neighboring books, a movement that conveys a deep sense of satisfaction and order. The scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of an unseen lamp, which casts gentle highlights across the richly textured leather spines and the rich grain of the wood, creating deep, soft shadows. The overall atmosphere is one of tranquil focus and quiet reverence, a peaceful moment dedicated to the love of literature.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1747,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000003/group_8/index_159_seed_7235_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/336_0000003_group_8_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000003_group_8_sample_3_q1__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000003_group_8_sample_3_q1__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000003_group_8_sample_3_q1__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000003_group_8_sample_3_q1__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000003_group_8_sample_3_q1__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000003_group_8_sample_3_q1__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+337,0.01799398,opposite-across,2.78800000,9,0.01170108,0.00138786,0.00687549,0.79337150,0.50621021,0.10351562,0.00178707,0000009,group_4,2,q3,"Is an older man with silver-gray hair wearing a dark tweed blazer and white collared shirt seated opposite, shaking his head slowly with his gaze averted?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot depicts a tense, silent confrontation in the hallowed quiet of a wood-paneled academic library. At a large, polished mahogany table, a young man with shaggy black hair leans forward, an impassioned look of frustration written across his face. Wearing a comfortable, dark green cardigan, they repeatedly gesture with their index finger to a tablet on the table. The tablet's screen emits a bright, cool digital glow, casting a stark blue light on their faces and hands, illuminating the complex data charts visible on the display. An older man seated opposite, dressed in a formal dark tweed blazer and a crisp white collared shirt, remains erect, his posture a wall of defiance. His silver-gray hair is impossibly neatly trimmed, his face a mask of resolute misunderstanding. He shakes his head slowly and stubbornly, his lips pressed into a thin line, his gaze deliberately averted, refusing even a glance at the glowing screen. The warm golden light from a classic green-shaded bank lamp on the table illuminates the scene, creating deep shadows that contrast with the cool glow of the tablet, visually emphasizing the generational and ideological clash. The background is filled with tall, dimly lit bookshelves filled with old leather-bound books, creating a heavy academic atmosphere, imbued with the weight of tradition and unspoken disagreements.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,134,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_4/index_5960_seed_20023_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/337_0000009_group_4_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q3__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q3__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q3__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q3__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q3__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q3__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+338,0.01793734,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.58800000,6,0.00745598,0.00089875,0.00437149,0.69687033,0.46652538,0.10058594,0.00213116,0000112,group_2,1,q2,Is the man on the left wearing a black hoodie with reflective silver stripes and has shaggy black hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic, low-angle, tracking shot, close to the ground, follows two young men as they effortlessly glide across a futuristic city square at dusk on their electric unicycles. The young man on the left, with shaggy black hair and a tech-fabric black hoodie with reflective silver stripes on the sleeves, wears a broad smile. The young woman next to him, with her long, bright pink hair tied in a high ponytail, throws her head back in a sleek white bomber jacket and laughs heartily. The unicycles they ride are matte black, their futuristic LED strips emitting brilliant cyan and magenta light on either side, casting vibrant reflections on the polished dark stone floor, leaving long trails of light as the wheels spin at breakneck speed. The camera switches focus swiftly and precisely between close-ups of their vivid, joyful facial expressions and the wheels spinning so rapidly that they appear almost animate, against a backdrop of towering skyscrapers, their windows lit up, and flashing holographic billboards. The entire picture has a cold tone, mainly dark blue and black, but is illuminated by the neon lights of the unicycle and the warm lights in the distance, interspersed with slight, stylized digital screen flashes and lens flares that represent a sense of technology, creating a futuristic atmosphere that is free, cheerful and full of urban dynamism.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4087,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000112/group_2/index_4817_seed_22844_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/338_0000112_group_2_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000112_group_2_sample_1_q2__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000112_group_2_sample_1_q2__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000112_group_2_sample_1_q2__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000112_group_2_sample_1_q2__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000112_group_2_sample_1_q2__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000112_group_2_sample_1_q2__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+339,0.01791935,left-right-pair,3.72000000,3,0.00968520,0.00115685,0.00568557,0.65379220,0.42639965,0.11523438,0.00248182,0000078,group_12,3,q4,Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera slowly pans to the right, following the movement. On the smooth lacquer surface of a dark, finely grained antique wooden table, scattered haphazardly are a string of pearls of varying sizes, the remains of a broken necklace, emitting a warm, milky white sheen. A warm yellow table lamp, shimmering obliquely from the side, casts a bright spot of light on the curved surface of each pearl. A slender, fair female hand, nails painted crimson, enters the frame with a decisive and fluid gesture. Without hesitation, it sweeps all the pearls towards the edge of the table, from left to right. Instantly, the pearls cascade down like a swarm of startled creatures, crashing onto the polished dark hardwood floor below with a crisp, dense sound. They then roll in all directions, eventually disappearing into the shadows of the frame. The entire scene, dimly lit, creates a dramatic atmosphere of elegance, decisiveness, and a touch of destructive beauty.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2175,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000078/group_12/index_7386_seed_8839_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/339_0000078_group_12_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000078_group_12_sample_3_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000078_group_12_sample_3_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000078_group_12_sample_3_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000078_group_12_sample_3_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000078_group_12_sample_3_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000078_group_12_sample_3_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+340,0.01791459,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01513358,0.00189169,0.00882793,0.77137387,0.56354117,0.07617188,0.00086623,0000078,group_13,3,q1,Is the main subject a young man with distinctly silver hair styled like icy spikes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"fluid single shot begins from a slightly upward angle, the camera steadily moving forward, following the steps of a silver-haired young man as he walks down a narrow, damp back alley. The scene is shrouded in a chilling blue hue. The mottled brick walls on either side are stained with water, and the puddles on the ground reflect a cold light. A single, old-fashioned orange streetlight at the alley's entrance casts a cone of warm light, slicing through the deep blue of the night like a sharp sword, creating a striking visual contrast between warm and cold. The young man's short, distinctly silver hair stands up like icy spikes. The warm light highlights the sharp contours of his hair and profile, while his front is largely immersed in a cold blue shadow. A pair of eagle-like eyes gleam fiercely within the shadows. Clad in a worn black leather motorcycle jacket, dark jeans, and heavy combat boots, he walks with a steady, menacing gait, closing in on his cornered opponent. When he finally stopped, his body leaned forward slightly, invading the other person's personal space, his jawline tense, his lips silently opening and closing, as if he was questioning in a very low but powerful voice. The whole picture was full of dramatic tension and a tense atmosphere that was about to break out.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4191,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000078/group_13/index_2049_seed_10813_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/340_0000078_group_13_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q1__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q1__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q1__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q1__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q1__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000078_group_13_sample_3_q1__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+341,0.01784407,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01443482,0.00173592,0.00846593,0.72888333,0.50450522,0.09667969,0.00096482,0000145,group_7,1,q4,Is the background a high-rise interior with a massive floor-to-ceiling window showing a city at night?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium-close, static shot, composed with a strong diagonal composition, employs a pronounced tilt (Dutch angle) to create a sense of tension and unease. The entire image is rendered in a refined animation style, characterized by clean lines and saturated yet restrained colors. At the center of the frame is a mysterious male character, dressed in a well-tailored, pure black suit with a subtle silky sheen, paired with a pure white shirt, meticulously buttoned at the collar. A pair of dark sunglasses, almost completely obscuring his eyes, perch on his high nose, their lenses reflecting the blurred, unrecognizable city lights. His chiseled jawline is taut. He appears to be inside a high-rise building, with a massive floor-to-ceiling window in the background, revealing a bird's-eye view of the city at night. Myriad neon lights and traffic converge into a blurry, radiant sea of cool tones. The bluish-violet light from the window serves as the primary source of light, creating a sharp rim light on the shoulders of his suit and the contours of his face, heightening the image's dramatic quality. He first remained still for a moment, his shoulders drooping slightly, then his chest rose and fell slowly, he lowered his head slightly, and exhaled a long, silent breath from between his lips. This subtle movement was full of heavy fatigue, which contrasted sharply with his cold appearance, creating an atmosphere of loneliness, mystery and inner pressure.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3074,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000145/group_7/index_3975_seed_5502_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/341_0000145_group_7_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+342,0.01776390,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01659895,0.00197778,0.00974744,0.77656454,0.46977901,0.10742188,0.00070381,0000018,group_4,3,q2,Is the main subject a woman wearing an elegant aquamarine silk robe with long black hair held by a simple jade hairpin?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low, wide-angle shot, shot from above, slowly pans upward through a lush bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. Soft, diffused light penetrates the mist and dense bamboo foliage, casting visible beams of light in the air. The camera finally settles on a woman in a traditional Chinese costume, dressed in an elegant aquamarine silk robe. Her long, cascading black hair is held together only partially by a simple jade hairpin. Her face is clear and beautiful, her eyes focused and ethereal. With a light touch of the ground, her entire body rises as if weightless. The camera instantly switches to a fast, dynamic tracking shot, following her graceful figure as she nimbly weaves between the towering bamboo branches. Her wide sleeves flutter like butterfly wings as she moves swiftly, her skirt carving graceful arcs through the mist. A series of rapidly alternating close-ups follows: the tip of her shoe, delicately embroidered with cloud patterns, lightly steps on a dewy bamboo leaf, which trembles only slightly before returning to its composure; a strand of hair brushes across her focused and serene profile, revealing her perfectly defined jawline; her slender fingers form an elegant sword-like gesture in the air, steadily and calmly directing her body. The entire sequence is seamless, the camera language sharp and precise, capturing every moment of her ethereal, ethereal beauty. Amidst the cool tones of light and the lingering mist, an ethereal atmosphere is created, imbued with both martial arts power and poetic imagery.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1727,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000018/group_4/index_5716_seed_17760_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/342_0000018_group_4_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000018_group_4_sample_3_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+343,0.01769452,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01505581,0.00180801,0.00883187,0.82617021,0.55495900,0.08593750,0.00306943,0000032,group_0,1,q1,"Is the scene set in a vast, sun-scorched, arid wasteland with a pale, cloudless sky?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level long shot captures a surreal encounter across a vast, sun-scorched, arid wasteland beneath a pale, cloudless sky. A cowgirl, reminiscent of the legendary Belle Starr, perched high atop a powerful, dark bay horse, dominates the scene. She wears a dusty, burgundy, vintage riding dress, its cotton fabric showing the wear of trails. A weathered, wide-brimmed leather hat casts a deep shadow on her face. She looks down with a steady, scrutinizing gaze, her posture exuding a quiet, commanding authority. At her feet, on the cracked ochre earth, stands a modern man, motionless in a technical, olive-green leather coat, its synthetic sheen contrasting sharply with the organic textures of the landscape. He looks up, his face filled with surprise and curiosity. The intense midday sun bleaches the colors of the scene, casting sharp shadows directly below horse and figure, emphasizing the stark contrast. There was a silent, tentative tension in the air, a quiet confrontation between two eras suspended in the vast, silent heat of the desert.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4327,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000032/group_0/index_5918_seed_27277_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/343_0000032_group_0_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000032_group_0_sample_1_q1__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000032_group_0_sample_1_q1__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000032_group_0_sample_1_q1__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000032_group_0_sample_1_q1__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000032_group_0_sample_1_q1__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000032_group_0_sample_1_q1__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+344,0.01767838,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01560823,0.00186430,0.00916262,0.70894963,0.44538826,0.12402344,0.00309992,0000038,group_5,3,q2,"Is the woman wearing a cozy, soft-knit cream sweater and standing beside a polished, dark-wood console table?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, eye-level shot opens statically on a woman with long, wavy auburn hair pulled back into a loose, low ponytail, revealing a calm facial expression. She wears a cozy, soft-knit cream sweater and stands beside a polished, dark-wood console table in a bright, modern living room. On the table sits a large bouquet of vibrant pink peonies and white tulips in a simple, clear, cylindrical glass vase filled with water. With focused grace, she leans forward, one hand firmly grasping the base of the vase while the other gently supports the bouquet, carefully lifting both items together in one steady motion. She maintains a firm grip and then, with a smooth pivot on her foot, turns her body to the right. As she takes her first step, the camera begins to pan right, smoothly following her movements as she steps away from the table and deeper into the room, creating an atmosphere of calm and purposeful presence bathed in soft, natural light from the off-screen windows.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1092,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000038/group_5/index_8468_seed_9430_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/344_0000038_group_5_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+345,0.01767383,beside-next-to,1.74000000,2,0.01924087,0.00230184,0.01129269,0.71836340,0.46357989,0.11523438,0.00255179,0000031,group_7,1,q4,"Is the setting a lush, sun-drenched backyard lawn with a weathered wooden fence in the background?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with a slightly low-angle medium shot, the camera tracking steadily alongside a magnificent golden retriever as it parades across a lush, sun-drenched backyard lawn. The dog's thick, honey-gold fur gleams in the warm afternoon sun as it proudly holds a sturdy, white rubber bone firmly but gently in its mouth, the object showing faint tooth marks from previous play. It moves with a brisk, trotting gait, head held high, its dark, intelligent eyes gleaming with happiness. Central to its joyful expression is the rhythmic, sweeping motion of its long, feathered tail, which sways enthusiastically from side to side. In the soft-focus background, a weathered wooden fence surrounds the yard. The low-hanging sunlight casts long, soft shadows across the vibrant green grass, bathing the entire scene in a golden glow and creating a warm atmosphere of pure, simple canine joy.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4334,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000031/group_7/index_5156_seed_19055_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/345_0000031_group_7_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000031_group_7_sample_1_q4__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000031_group_7_sample_1_q4__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000031_group_7_sample_1_q4__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000031_group_7_sample_1_q4__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000031_group_7_sample_1_q4__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000031_group_7_sample_1_q4__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+346,0.01761759,left-right-pair,4.92000000,8,0.00663075,0.00079390,0.00389124,0.73294294,0.49759656,0.09765625,0.00113246,0000067,group_10,0,q3,Is a woman with dark black hair in a sleek bun wearing a blush-tinged silk robe visible leaning against an ornate mirror?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a surreal, high-definition digital aesthetic, the film begins with a slow, graceful, doll-like movement, sliding horizontally across the magnificent, ornate facade of a sprawling limestone mansion. Soft, golden morning light casts long shadows across the intricate carvings and towering pillars, rendering every detail with crisp 4K clarity. As the camera continues its steady, uninterrupted path, it perfectly aligns with a spotless, large bay window, revealing a brightly lit, luxurious bathroom. Through the pristine glass, a woman with dark black hair pulled back into a sleek, elegant bun can be seen leaning against a large, ornate mirror. She wears a lustrous, blush-tinged silk robe, the fabric striking in its allure. She meticulously shapes her eyebrows with precise, deliberate movements, her expression intense and unwavering. In her right hand, she holds a pair of pointed metal tweezers, while with her left, she gently pinches the skin above her eyes. The soft morning light from the window and the warm, even glow from the bulb in the mirror-framed dressing table combine to illuminate the scene, creating a focused halo around her face, while the luxurious surroundings of white marble countertops, gleaming gilded fixtures, and crystal accents fade into the soft-focus background, establishing an atmosphere of quiet, personal ritual, and focused perfection.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,557,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_10/index_7152_seed_29972_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/346_0000067_group_10_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_10_sample_0_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+347,0.01759036,foreground-background,3.43200000,7,0.00912328,0.00112494,0.00533222,0.76508546,0.53129637,0.09375000,0.00180608,0000124,group_10,3,q2,"Is a man dressed in a black leather jacket, black T-shirt, and dark jeans approaching two children?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld, slightly shaky, medium-long shot captures a bustling, sunny public square as a man dressed entirely in black approaches two young children. The camera tracks him with subtle, unsteady movements, enhancing the scene's raw immediacy. The man, dressed in a black leather jacket, a black T-shirt, and dark jeans, moves with an unconventional rhythm, twisting his torso while speaking enthusiastically and gesturing. His face is initially obscured by dark sunglasses. Two children, a boy and a girl, wearing brightly colored hoodies, stand close together, their eyes wide and uncertain as they watch his approach. As the man closes in distance, he deliberately slows down, smoothly removing his sunglasses to reveal a gentle smile. He then bends down from the waist, lowering his upper body to level with the children in a non-threatening gesture. In response, the children's previously motionless hands begin to move; one child fidgets with his sleeve, another makes a small, hesitant gesture forward. Throughout this interaction, the background remains vibrant: figures in the distance stroll through the square, and at one point, a passerby briskly walks through the foreground, momentarily interrupting the frame. The entire scene is bathed in bright, cool daylight, creating a stark contrast and a tense, unfolding atmosphere of curiosity, all captured with an erratic camera that suggests a spontaneous, unstaged moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3574,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000124/group_10/index_9154_seed_8439_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/347_0000124_group_10_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000124_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000124_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000124_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000124_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000124_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000124_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+348,0.01754523,foreground-background,2.72800000,3,0.01253450,0.00150305,0.00735430,0.63524318,0.44194204,0.10156250,0.00065205,0000072,group_4,2,q4,Are the background elements stainless steel and glass vertical growth racks with exotic plants under purple and magenta LED lights?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"close-up shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly but steadily advances, first glimpsing a vast, bizarre plant leaf in the foreground. Its deep, dark green, velvety surface is covered with intricate, luminous veins, resembling circuit boards, faintly luminescent. As the camera deepens, focus gradually settles on an Asian model nestled within a futuristic greenhouse. Her face is sculpted, her long, wet black hair neatly combed back. Her eyes, cold and distant, stare blankly into the camera. She wears a couture dress crafted from a liquid metal silver fabric with dramatic, architectural shoulders, making her stand out against the backdrop. Behind her, rows of stainless steel and glass vertical growth racks display a variety of exotic plants, each a psychedelic display of vibrant colors under alternating purple and magenta LED grow lights. The lights pulsated in a slow and rhythmic rhythm, periodically sweeping across her expressionless face and the glittering surface of the clothing, casting ever-changing long shadows. The entire scene was shrouded in a cold tone, and the precise coldness of technology and the ultimate beauty of luxury fashion blended at this moment, creating a fashion blockbuster atmosphere full of mystery and visual impact.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3283,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000072/group_4/index_5809_seed_12049_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/348_0000072_group_4_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000072_group_4_sample_2_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000072_group_4_sample_2_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000072_group_4_sample_2_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000072_group_4_sample_2_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000072_group_4_sample_2_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000072_group_4_sample_2_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+349,0.01753854,opposite-across,2.65200000,7,0.01344156,0.00158387,0.00790512,0.68976068,0.41780427,0.12988281,0.00224450,0000074,group_0,1,q3,Is a grandmother with graying hair using chopsticks to transfer a boiled fish ball to a little girl with pigtails wearing a pink sweater?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"highly detailed documentary medium shot, shot from a level angle, slowly and steadily moves forward, gradually deepening into a family dining room filled with laughter and chatter. In the center of a dark, round wooden table, a stainless steel hot pot bubbling, half filled with a vibrant red spicy broth swirling with dried chilies and Sichuan peppercorns, the other half a milky white bone broth simmering with red dates and goji berries. Thick, white steam rises continuously from the pot, like a soft filter, imbuing the entire scene with a warm, fuzzy quality. A grandmother with graying hair and a kind smile carefully uses chopsticks to transfer a boiled fish ball to her granddaughter's bowl. The little girl, with pigtails and a pink sweater, gazes expectantly at the food in her bowl. Across from them, a middle-aged father in a dark blue V-neck sweater chats with his wife, a bright smile on his face. His mother, in a beige turtleneck, responds gently, expertly picking up a piece of green vegetable with her chopsticks and preparing to add it to the pot. The table was covered with a variety of ingredients: neatly arranged beef rolls, emerald greens, crisp white tofu slices, and fresh mushrooms. In front of each person was a bowl of prepared dipping sauce. A warm yellow chandelier hung above the table provided the sole source of light, its glow illuminating the steaming air and framing the happy expressions on everyone's faces, creating a warm, lively, and vibrant atmosphere for a family dinner.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,369,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000074/group_0/index_2055_seed_18411_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/349_0000074_group_0_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000074_group_0_sample_1_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+350,0.01750476,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.00718667,0.00084656,0.00422674,0.74325395,0.45848474,0.10839844,0.00152862,0000056,group_3,3,q4,"Does Sun Wukong thrust a golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front, causing the waterfall to distort?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2394,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26612_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/350_0000056_group_3_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+351,0.01750021,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01594098,0.00193268,0.00933887,0.65170008,0.45220038,0.10449219,0.00010234,0000148,group_15,3,q1,Is the scene set in an old Chinese kitchen with yellowed tiled walls and hanging dried chilies?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"tightly composed, static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, imbues the image with the rich colors and intense humanity that are hallmarks of Steve McCurry's photography. In a steaming, slightly crowded, old Chinese kitchen, an elderly man, his face deeply wrinkled and his hair thinning with gray, is absorbed in his cooking. A warm, directional light slants down from above and sideways, precisely outlining the contours of his bronzed face and his pursed lips. His deep eyes gleam with concentration amidst the swirling steam. He wears a washed-out, dark blue cotton double-breasted jacket, sleeves neatly rolled to the elbows, revealing his muscular, vein-filled forearms. Steady in his right hand, he grips a long-handled spatula and stirs the vibrantly colored ingredients in the dark cast iron wok with a deft, powerful rhythm. Each stroke of the spatula ignites a small, bright flame that licks the edge, emitting a sizzling sound. Thick white steam rises from the pot, layered in the light, blurring the yellowed tiled wall and the hanging strings of dried chilies behind it. The image is richly saturated, creating a striking yet harmonious contrast between the deep blue of the top, the vibrant red and green of the ingredients, and the golden sheen of the copper spoon in the background. This creates a warm atmosphere of simplicity, focus, and vitality, capturing a moment of dignity and beauty in everyday life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3999,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000148/group_15/index_4012_seed_27661_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/351_0000148_group_15_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q1__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q1__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q1__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q1__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q1__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000148_group_15_sample_3_q1__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+352,0.01745050,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01733262,0.00205687,0.01018383,0.64904815,0.38656554,0.13574219,0.00112426,0000104,group_3,2,q1,"Is the main subject an elderly man with silver hair and deeply wrinkled, weathered skin?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a level angle begins in medium shot, then slowly pulls back to reveal a wider scene. The frame focuses on a silver-haired elderly man, clad in a loose, white, traditional cotton and linen training suit, nestled in a tranquil bamboo forest. The faint morning sun, the sole source of light, penetrates the towering, verdant bamboo poles and dense leaves, creating soft, voluminous beams that are visible through the misty air and cast shifting, dappled shadows on the damp, leaf-covered ground. The elderly man's hair is meticulously combed, his face deeply wrinkled, weathered. His eyes are slightly closed, his expression focused and peaceful. He is performing Tai Chi with incredible slowness and stability, his arms tracing smooth arcs at a speed barely perceptible to the naked eye, his weight shifting effortlessly between his legs. Each movement is imbued with inner, composed strength. His wide white sleeves fluttered gently as his body turned, and their trajectory seemed to merge with the flowing air and light. There was no pause between his movements, perfectly interpreting the artistic conception of ""flowing like clouds and running water"". The whole scene presented an extremely quiet, solemn and Zen-like meditative atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2436,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000104/group_3/index_2934_seed_6322_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/352_0000104_group_3_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000104_group_3_sample_2_q1__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000104_group_3_sample_2_q1__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000104_group_3_sample_2_q1__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000104_group_3_sample_2_q1__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000104_group_3_sample_2_q1__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000104_group_3_sample_2_q1__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+353,0.01742484,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.01875055,0.00224341,0.01100476,0.68659329,0.42522672,0.12988281,0.00205386,0000131,group_10,0,q1,Is the scene set on a desolate mountain ridge with a weathered beacon tower made of massive stone blocks nearby?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from an upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward, focusing on an ancient soldier perched atop a desolate mountain ridge. Beside him stands a weathered beacon tower, constructed of massive stone blocks, its surface covered in cracks and moss, a silent witness to the howling wind. The soldier's long, black hair is tied back, strands whipping wildly against his weathered face in the biting wind. He wears a suit of worn, dark iron scale armor, its plates scarred by past battles. The hem of his dark, coarse linen tabard flaps violently in the wind. His feet, firmly planted on the rough ground, he draws a massive longbow made of dark, knotty wood with controlled force, the bow creaking mournfully under the immense tension. As the bowstring is drawn to his cheek, the muscles of his arms and back visibly tense beneath his armor, making him look like a statue poised for action. His brow furrowed, his lips pursed, his eyes narrowed in the gusting wind, but his cold, resolute gaze, sharp as an eagle's, fixed its gaze firmly on an invisible target beyond the camera. In the sky, thick, dark clouds rolled rapidly, and the pale, setting sun struggled to cast a faint, cold light, painting the entire scene with a dominant gray-blue hue. The light outlined the cold metal contours of the armor and the rough texture of the rocks, creating an epic atmosphere of loneliness, awe, and resolute will.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2395,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000131/group_10/index_9686_seed_32974_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/353_0000131_group_10_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q1__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q1__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q1__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q1__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q1__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000131_group_10_sample_0_q1__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+354,0.01740997,beside-next-to,2.46000000,8,0.01283979,0.00154383,0.00753064,0.75165164,0.49475884,0.09570312,0.00312126,0000024,group_6,1,q3,Does the man hold a small rectangular glass fish tank under a gooseneck chrome faucet and fill it with water?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera begins with a medium shot at eye level, slowly and steadily panning to the right, following the action in a brightly lit modern kitchen. A young man with neatly combed short brown hair and wearing a soft, heather-gray cotton T-shirt leans slightly over a gleaming stainless steel sink. Steady in both hands, he holds a small, rectangular glass fish tank under a modern, gooseneck chrome faucet, a stream of clear water filling it. With serene concentration, he watches the water level rise. When it's nearly full, he deftly turns the faucet handle with his right hand, and the flow abruptly stops. Then, he carefully lifts the now-heavy tank, the water sloshing gently inside, and turns his body toward the adjacent, sleek, light-gray crystal countertop. The camera pan ends as he deliberately and quietly sets the tank down. After a brief pause, his gaze shifts, and he carefully picks up a small fishing net with a delicate green mesh and a thin metal handle, which has been placed next to the tank. The entire scene is bathed in bright, indirect morning light, streaming in through an invisible window, creating soft shadows that accentuate the clean lines of the white subway tile backsplash, creating an atmosphere of quiet, focused communality and gentle preparation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,169,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000024/group_6/index_1762_seed_1222_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/354_0000024_group_6_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+355,0.01739603,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.09200000,3,0.00894308,0.00106948,0.00524907,0.67554593,0.41435105,0.14257812,0.00143802,0000093,group_6,0,q4,Does the afternoon sun filter through twisted ancient pine branches to cast dappled light and shadows on the figures?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, drawn-out shot, beginning with a delicately composed, slightly upward mid-shot, focuses on the depths of an ancient temple courtyard. An elderly monk, bald and deeply wrinkled between his forehead and eyes, wears a soft, naturally wrinkled ochre-red robe, faded by time. He stands tall, his face solemn and serene. In one hand, he holds a string of dark Buddhist beads, while the other hangs naturally at his side. His gaze is determined and compassionate. Opposite him, a massive white snake, its entire body coated in a soft, ivory sheen, raises its head high, reaching the monk's eye level. Its golden, vertical pupils convey no hint of murderous intent, but rather a glimmer of ancient, human wisdom. The snake's body coils tightly on the mossy stone floor, dotted with scattered, withered bodhi leaves, imbued with a sense of poised power. The afternoon sun filters through the twisted branches of the ancient pines in the courtyard, casting dappled light and shadow, perfectly outlining the monk's silhouette and the texture of his robes, while also causing the giant snake's scales to reflect a pearly shimmer. As the camera steadily and deliberately moves backward, the figures of the two men and the snake gradually diminish within the magnificent temple setting. In the background, stone lanterns carved with lotus patterns, quaint wooden corridors, and a corner of the hall with its soaring eaves and brackets slowly come into view. The entire scene, shrouded in the subtle scent of sandalwood, creates a tranquil atmosphere that transcends time, imbued with Zen and a mysterious tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3631,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000093/group_6/index_3519_seed_6354_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/355_0000093_group_6_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000093_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000093_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000093_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000093_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000093_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000093_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+356,0.01738446,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00808174,0.00099142,0.00472688,0.66812539,0.46637779,0.09472656,0.00067759,0000112,group_13,2,q2,"Is Oliver, a young boy with tousled blond hair and a blue and white striped T-shirt, sitting cross-legged on a red and white checkered picnic blanket?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level, medium-wide shot captures the sheer enchantment of a sun-dappled forest clearing. Oliver, a young boy with tousled blond hair and a simple blue and white striped T-shirt, sits cross-legged on a red and white checkered picnic blanket. Next to him sits Sparky, a fluffy golden retriever puppy, his head tilted in curiosity, his tail gently tapping the soft grass. Nearby sits a family of four rabbits: a large brown dad, a gentle white mom, and two small, furry gray bunnies. Between them stands a whimsical tea party, featuring a miniature ceramic tea set with pastel pink, sky blue, and lemon yellow teacups. Oliver, with a look of focused joy on his face, is in action, steadily and deliberately pouring imaginary tea from a small white teapot into a tiny cup, carefully held between the paws of a small rabbit. Another bunny nibbles at a heart-shaped cookie on a central plate, which also contains delicately sliced carrot sticks. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, which filters through the lush green canopy above, creating a beautiful play of light and shadow. The atmosphere is tranquil, warm and whimsical, a magical moment of friendship between children, pets and gentle woodland creatures.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,210,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000112/group_13/index_9147_seed_8078_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/356_0000112_group_13_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q2__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q2__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q2__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q2__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q2__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q2__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+357,0.01737286,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01608787,0.00193958,0.00943219,0.68463480,0.44044438,0.11718750,0.00290942,0000166,group_5,0,q3,Does the scene take place in a turbulent sky swirling with dark storm clouds?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"magnificent 360-degree slow-motion shot, shot from a slightly upward perspective, captures the epic battle between two mythical phoenixes amidst a turbulent sky swirling with dark storm clouds. One phoenix is composed entirely of flowing magma and incandescent fire, each feather a pure, pulsating crimson and gold flame. Its eyes are like blazing embers, and its flight leaves a dazzling trail of sparks and embers in its wake. The other phoenix, in stark contrast, is carved from translucent ice crystals, its feathers razor-sharp icicles gleaming with sapphire and cyan. Its wings, with their beats, scatter countless tiny, glittering frost particles, and its icy eyes are like distant stars. The camera smoothly rotates around them, capturing every detail as they swirl, dive, and claw at each other in a deadly aerial ballet: the fire phoenix folds its wings sharply, swooping down like a flaming meteor, while the ice phoenix gracefully sideways, blocking with the edge of its crystal wings. When the camera rotates to the optimal angle, the two divine birds have a fierce head-on collision. The burning feathers collide with the icy feathers, and a dazzling energy shock wave instantly erupts - the hot sparks hiss and turn into steam when they come into contact with the cold air, while the hard ice crystals explode into countless glittering fragments under the high temperature, intertwined with the falling and extinguished flame feathers, forming a destructive picture full of primitive power and magnificent beauty. The whole scene, with the extreme contrast of warm and cold colors, creates a tense, intense and sacred fantasy atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3917,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000166/group_5/index_6042_seed_32799_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/357_0000166_group_5_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+358,0.01737087,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.00376707,0.00045262,0.00220963,0.68235743,0.43016109,0.12597656,0.00033015,0000037,group_5,3,q1,"Is the scene a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2717,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4759_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/358_0000037_group_5_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q1__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q1__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q1__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q1__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q1__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q1__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+359,0.01730539,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.01644607,0.00194696,0.00966607,0.76636165,0.50370371,0.08886719,0.00179330,0000135,group_5,1,q5,Is the sky colored with a gradient from deep blue to orange-red due to a rising sun?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"zoomed-out shot, starting slightly from an upward angle, first focuses on the silhouette of an ancient woman, standing quietly atop a verdant mountaintop. As the camera slowly pulls away, details gradually come into focus: her hair is styled in an intricate, classical bun, adorned with several golden hairpins that sway gently in the breeze and an exquisitely carved white jade hairpin. She is dressed in a gorgeous, pale pink silk Hanfu (Chinese traditional clothing), its wide sleeves and skirt embroidered with intricate patterns of auspicious clouds and phoenixes in gold thread, shimmering softly in the golden dawn light. Her almond-shaped eyes are wide, her lips slightly parted, a look of disbelief and awe written across her face, her gaze fixed fixed on the distant horizon. There, a palace, grander than one could imagine, slowly but steadily rose from the ground. Its golden glazed tile roof first broke through the swirling morning mist, reflecting the first rays of the rising sun. Soon after, the vermilion palace walls, the eaves of carved beams and painted rafters, and the cascading pavilions and towers also emerged. The whole process was silent and awe-inspiring. The rising sun dyed the sky a magnificent gradient from deep blue to orange-red, framing both the woman and the rising palace with a dazzling golden rim. The entire scene was filled with a sense of epic grandeur and an aura of near-sacred, breathtaking wonder.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3549,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000135/group_5/index_2594_seed_15549_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/359_0000135_group_5_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000135_group_5_sample_1_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000135_group_5_sample_1_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000135_group_5_sample_1_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000135_group_5_sample_1_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000135_group_5_sample_1_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000135_group_5_sample_1_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+360,0.01729748,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01410341,0.00168578,0.00827842,0.76822978,0.49104670,0.10156250,0.00085461,0000003,group_8,0,q1,Are a pair of hands visible arranging vintage hardcover books?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level close-up captures a pair of hands meticulously arranging a collection of vintage hardcover books. These hands, belonging to a person wearing the sleeves of a cozy forest green knit sweater, hold a thick hardcover bound in worn crimson leather. The book's spine features a faint, faded gilt pattern, and the pages are a warm, decked ivory. With steady, deliberate precision, the hands guide the book onto a dark, polished mahogany bookshelf already crowded with similar antique volumes. The camera follows the person as they gently and carefully slide the crimson book into the perfectly sized, narrow gap between the aquamarine and dark brown volumes. The book slides smoothly into place until its spine aligns perfectly with the neighboring books, a movement that conveys a deep sense of satisfaction and order. The scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of an unseen lamp, which casts gentle highlights across the richly textured leather spines and the rich grain of the wood, creating deep, soft shadows. The overall atmosphere is one of tranquil focus and quiet reverence, a peaceful moment dedicated to the love of literature.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1744,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000003/group_8/index_159_seed_7232_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/360_0000003_group_8_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000003_group_8_sample_0_q1__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000003_group_8_sample_0_q1__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000003_group_8_sample_0_q1__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000003_group_8_sample_0_q1__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000003_group_8_sample_0_q1__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000003_group_8_sample_0_q1__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+361,0.01728918,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01754759,0.00206578,0.01032120,0.58136034,0.37692797,0.13476562,0.00071794,0000059,group_10,1,q3,"Is the train's body dark, polished metal alloy with glowing rectangular windows emitting a warm golden light?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"sweeping, high-angle panoramic shot, as if executed by a drone, smoothly parallels a sleek intercity express train as it smoothly traverses a vast metropolis at dusk. The train's slender, articulated body, constructed of a dark, polished metal alloy that reflects the fading ambient light, appears to undulate gracefully in a powerful, serpentine pattern along a vast, elevated concrete track between towering skyscrapers. The cityscape is a dense forest of modern buildings, their concrete and glass facades a soft, non-reflective gray. In the distance, the streets are dark canyons, streaked only by the faint, creeping headlights and taillights of cars. The entire scene is captured in a deliberately desaturated palette: the cool, dominant gray of the city buildings and the deep blue of the dusk sky create a stark, dramatic contrast with the train's continuous, glowing rectangular windows, which emit a warm golden glow, and the scattered, sharp, electronic city lights. This visual dichotomy creates a powerful atmosphere of cool, cinematic grandeur, emphasizing the immense scale of the city and the relentless, elegant movement of technology within it.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1853,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000059/group_10/index_5582_seed_17072_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/361_0000059_group_10_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000059_group_10_sample_1_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000059_group_10_sample_1_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000059_group_10_sample_1_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000059_group_10_sample_1_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000059_group_10_sample_1_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000059_group_10_sample_1_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+362,0.01724622,beside-next-to,2.10000000,5,0.01509153,0.00182134,0.00884679,0.71841949,0.49043623,0.09960938,0.00106746,0000149,group_7,2,q5,Are the hands of the family members shown smeared with white flour while filling and pleating dumpling wrappers?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"360-degree slow-motion doll gracefully rotates around a large, round, dark wooden table, polished to a soft patina by generations of use, situated in the center of a house dating back to the early Ming Dynasty. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, romantic glow of red and yellow paper lanterns hanging from the ceiling beams, casting a warm golden light and creating gently dancing shadows. A multi-generational family gathers around the table, engrossed in the shared ritual of making dumplings. An elderly grandmother, her silver hair tied in an elegant bun and her face lined with wrinkles, demonstrates her pleating technique with nimble, practiced fingers. Beside her, a young mother dressed in a simple silk aoqun in a pastel green, her dark hair held up with a jade hairpin, smiles warmly as she assists her young daughter, her bright, curious eyes focused on the task. A father and grandfather, dressed in simple linen tunics, work quietly and intently, their larger hands moving with surprising gentleness. Their hands, smeared with white flour, moved in beautiful, near-perfect unisons, deftly scooping ground pork and chives onto thin, round wrappers, moistening the edges and pleating them into perfect crescents before lovingly placing them on bamboo plates. A gentle, contented smile graced each face, reflecting the light of the lanterns, creating an atmosphere of profound peace, familial affection, and a tranquil, joyful tradition. In the background, a carved wooden screen and hanging calligraphy scrolls added a touch of period authenticity, completing this intimate portrait of familial harmony.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3056,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000149/group_7/index_9979_seed_536_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/362_0000149_group_7_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000149_group_7_sample_2_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000149_group_7_sample_2_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000149_group_7_sample_2_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000149_group_7_sample_2_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000149_group_7_sample_2_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000149_group_7_sample_2_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+363,0.01724434,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01410348,0.00168604,0.00827830,0.80956781,0.49147838,0.10937500,0.00012359,0000160,group_10,2,q4,Is the background a sun-drenched meadow with tall green grass and scattered yellow wildflowers?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium close-up depicts a man with a neatly trimmed dark brown beard, wearing a heather-gray cotton short-sleeved shirt and a dark blue baseball cap. He stands in the center of a sun-drenched meadow, the soft-focus background revealing tall green grass and scattered yellow wildflowers in the warm, golden afternoon light. His gaze is intently directed downward at a small metal ring delicately held between the thumb and index finger of each hand. He carefully wipes away specks of dark dirt from the surface, his lips moving as he speaks, narrating his actions with an air of focused discovery. He fluidly turns his head momentarily to the left, as if to greet someone off-screen, before quickly returning his gaze to the precious object in his hands, his expression a mixture of concentration and quiet excitement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3506,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000160/group_10/index_3321_seed_14243_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/363_0000160_group_10_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q4__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q4__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q4__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q4__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q4__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q4__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+364,0.01724178,beside-next-to,2.34000000,7,0.01287072,0.00154431,0.00755094,0.75976241,0.52617544,0.08398438,0.00150907,0000166,group_11,2,q3,Is the younger figure wearing a modern dark green technical jacket and gray overalls with hands in pockets?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, low-angle, wide-angle shot depicts two figures, dwarfed by the massive presence of a power plant's cooling towers. The scene is bathed in the soft, warm light of dusk, casting long, dramatic shadows across the gravelly ground. On the left stands an older man, his weathered face etched with the lines of experience. He wears a faded, dark blue work jumpsuit, a yellowed hard hat tucked under his arm. His posture is slightly relaxed, one hand gesturing deftly, his expression thoughtful. Beside him, a younger figure in a modern, dark green technical jacket and gray overalls listens intently, hands in pockets, head tilted slightly. They are engaged in a quiet conversation, their distance suggesting a shared, private moment. Massive concrete towers rise behind them, their richly textured surfaces capturing the golden hour, while white steam drifts lazily through vast openings, emitting pink and orange glows against the deepening twilight sky. The predominant color palette is a warm fusion of amber and rose, contrasted against the cool, industrial gray of the concrete, creating an atmosphere of deep contemplation and tranquility, highlighting moments of intimate human connection against a backdrop of immense power.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3471,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000166/group_11/index_9235_seed_5697_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/364_0000166_group_11_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+365,0.01715356,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01409540,0.00168648,0.00827262,0.80405468,0.52877593,0.08789062,0.00008366,0000031,group_4,1,q2,Is the character depicted as a thin man with long dark hair held by a simple hairpin?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, mid-shot shot, taken from a horizontal angle, captures a tranquil moment in documentary style. In a Tang Dynasty courtyard bathed in a cool, silvery glow, the swaying shadows of trees are reflected on the stone pavement. The poet Li Bai wears a wide-sleeved white silk robe, which flutters gently in the night breeze, revealing its delicate texture. His long, dark hair is held together only by a simple hairpin. His face is thin, and his eyes hold a hint of drunkenness and contemplation. He turns slowly and calmly, a movement that gently sways a small, white porcelain wine glass in his hand. Ripples ripple on the surface of the clear wine, momentarily catching and reflecting the bright moonlight. The entire scene is bathed in moonlight, creating a striking contrast between light and dark. The light outlines his graceful figure and the deep shadows of the courtyard scenery, creating a timeless, serene, and poetic classical atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4341,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000031/group_4/index_8882_seed_4782_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/365_0000031_group_4_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000031_group_4_sample_1_q2__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000031_group_4_sample_1_q2__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000031_group_4_sample_1_q2__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000031_group_4_sample_1_q2__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000031_group_4_sample_1_q2__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000031_group_4_sample_1_q2__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+366,0.01715250,opposite-across,2.24400000,4,0.01399594,0.00167851,0.00821162,0.82044077,0.49607077,0.11230469,0.00012785,0000136,group_2,0,q3,"Are three young friends visible sitting around the table, including a woman with long curly brown hair in an off-white sweater and a man in a dark blue hoodie with black-framed glasses?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slowly zooming in, slightly overhead, medium shot focuses on a warm, round wooden table where three young friends sit intimately around a steaming hot pot. In the center, a vibrant red oil-based broth simmers vigorously, bubbling with dried chilies and Sichuan peppercorns. A milky, clear broth in the other half gently steams. Rich, white steam rises under the warm yellow light of a chandelier, creating a soft halo. A woman with long, curly brown hair and wearing a loose, off-white knit sweater, her face a healthy, steamy flush, smiles cheerfully. Across from her, a man wearing black-framed glasses and a dark blue hoodie gestures and excitedly talks, drawing laughter from his friends. As the camera slowly approaches, a woman carefully picks up a crisp, red and white marbled beef roll with a pair of long wooden chopsticks and steadily and calmly dips it into the boiling red oil. The moment the meat touches the broth, a string of fine bubbles rises around it, and the color of the fresh meat quickly darkens. The table is laden with a variety of fresh ingredients—emerald green vegetables, tender white tofu, and exquisitely presented meats. The entire scene is filled with the laughter of friends gathering together and the warm and cozy atmosphere of life, creating an atmosphere of supreme comfort and intimacy.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,500,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000136/group_2/index_3596_seed_23274_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/366_0000136_group_2_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000136_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000136_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000136_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000136_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000136_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000136_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+367,0.01713502,foreground-background,3.08000000,5,0.00989798,0.00118983,0.00580544,0.85934889,0.52772146,0.10546875,0.00018921,0000082,group_9,1,q4,Is a woman's hand in the foreground lifting a glass of white wine that is about one-third full?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a cozy, humanistic interior, a fluid single shot begins at table level, then slowly and gracefully pans rightward across a warm dining scene. A long, dark wooden table, covered with a beige linen tablecloth, is laden with half-eaten home-cooked dishes and scattered crumbs. Several friends, dressed in cozy sweaters and casual shirts, gather around the table. Their faces are blurred by a soft bokeh, yet their genuine smiles and lively gestures, engaged in conversation, are clearly visible. As the camera pans, the focus gradually and seamlessly shifts from the joyful gathering in the background to the central subject in the foreground: a woman's hand, delicately lifting a glass of white wine from the table. Steady and composed, her nails immaculately manicured, the hand elegantly grasps the slender stem of a classic crystal goblet. The glass is about one-third full of pale golden white wine, and under the soft light cast by a low, warm-toned chandelier overhead, the wine's clarity is translucent, shimmering with sparkling shimmer. As the wine glasses are slowly raised to the center of the picture, the smiling faces and figures of the friends in the background are completely blurred into warm spots of light (Bokeh) and soft blocks of color. The whole picture is wrapped in an intimate, peaceful and joyful atmosphere. The main colors are warm amber and cream, and the contrast of light and shadow is soft, perfectly capturing this peaceful and sincere moment of celebration.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1665,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000082/group_9/index_3890_seed_29049_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/367_0000082_group_9_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000082_group_9_sample_1_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000082_group_9_sample_1_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000082_group_9_sample_1_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000082_group_9_sample_1_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000082_group_9_sample_1_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000082_group_9_sample_1_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+368,0.01712304,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00897137,0.00106573,0.00527043,0.68713295,0.39896345,0.15039062,0.00087279,0000132,group_7,0,q2,Is the man depicted in a reclining posture with his eyes lightly closed and a faint smile on his lips?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, zoomed-out shot, starting from a slightly upward angle, first focuses on a massive bluestone by the river, bathed in moonlight. The great Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai reclines, half-drunk and intoxicated. His long, dark hair, undone by a bun, a few wet strands clinging to his drunken face. His features are rendered with remarkable clarity by the cool moonlight. He wears a flowing white silk robe with wide sleeves, the collar slightly open, revealing faint stains of dark wine on the folds. The hem of the robe falls limply on the mossy stone surface. His eyes are lightly closed, a faint, detached smile playing on his lips. His body is relaxed, his chest rising and falling with his deep, steady breathing. Beside him, an antique bronze wine jug has fallen, half-emptied between the moist moss and soil. The last drops of wine seem to linger on the mouth, reflecting a faint glow in the moonlight. As the camera steadily and deliberately pulls back, a wider scene is revealed: the vast river, like a vast black jade in the still night, a bright full moon casts a clear glow in the sky, spreading a fragmented, shimmering silver band across the water. In the distance, the inky silhouettes of rolling hills shrouded in mist. Nearby, a few clumps of reeds sway gently in the night breeze, rustling softly. The entire scene exudes a sense of ultimate tranquility and poetic solitude. The dominant color palette is deep blue-black and silver-white, and the strong contrast of light and shadow creates an otherworldly, classical aesthetic atmosphere of detachment from the world.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,721,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000132/group_7/index_6699_seed_26356_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/368_0000132_group_7_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+369,0.01708166,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.00368182,0.00043888,0.00216196,0.68796188,0.42617553,0.12207031,0.00262529,0000037,group_5,2,q3,Does the woman sweep the floor using a traditional straw broom with a long worn wooden handle?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2714,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4758_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/369_0000037_group_5_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_2_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+370,0.01707386,beside-next-to,1.98000000,4,0.01911834,0.00230812,0.01120682,0.50665867,0.35686848,0.13867188,0.00268376,0000099,group_11,1,q4,Does a black cannonball streak across the sky and crash into the water causing a massive eruption of sea spray?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"From a chaotic handheld first-person perspective on the deck of a ship, rendered in the style of classic 1980s anime, a frantic artillery bombardment unfolds across a turbulent ocean. The camera, shaky and unstable, captures the scene with raw immediacy. In the distance, a massive wooden galleon, bold black outlines against its dark, weathered timbers, unleashes a fierce attack. The muzzles of the enemy ship's cannons flash with brilliant, hand-painted orange and yellow flames, immediately followed by billowing clouds of thick, opaque white and gray smoke. A black cannonball streaks swiftly across the gloomy sky before crashing into the dark, churning waters near the viewer's ship, erupting in a massive eruption of sea spray and Celtic-hued waters. The ensuing shockwave strikes with brutal force, causing the entire frame to tremble violently as a massive white wave crashes against the hull, sending water cascading down through the damp planks of the deck. The air is thick with a haze of gunpowder and sea fog, and the horizon is dotted with multiple explosions, creating a terrifying and exciting spectacle of high-seas warfare, all defined by the characteristic saturated color palette and dramatic, high-contrast lighting of vintage Japanese anime.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1429,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000099/group_11/index_8824_seed_1345_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/370_0000099_group_11_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000099_group_11_sample_1_q4__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000099_group_11_sample_1_q4__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000099_group_11_sample_1_q4__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000099_group_11_sample_1_q4__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000099_group_11_sample_1_q4__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000099_group_11_sample_1_q4__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+371,0.01703640,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01501590,0.00179442,0.00881432,0.80149209,0.48141307,0.11621094,0.00039819,0000015,group_15,0,q3,Is the second man depicted as more muscular with a shaved head and an angry expression?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"Frantic handheld shot thrusts the viewer directly into the heart of a frenzied hand-to-hand fight, moving erratically and rapidly between the two men, capturing every tense moment at close range. The scene rapidly switches between tense expressions and swift movements, beginning with an extreme close-up of a young man's face. His sweat-drenched black hair clings to his forehead, a trickle of blood oozing from the corner of his clenched mouth. His expression is steely and pained, and the muscles in his neck bulge like ropes from the strain. He wears a sweat-soaked dark gray T-shirt, tightly hugging his muscular build. The camera jerks to reveal the face of his opponent, a more muscular man with a shaved head, contorted in anger. His eyes burn with a cold rage. Then, the camera quickly pulls back, revealing a slightly wider angle of their entangled bodies—the young man's forearm blocks a powerful swinging punch with a dull thud, his body rapidly sinking to try to knock him off balance. The entire fight takes place in a dimly lit abandoned warehouse, the sole source of light coming from a single, precariously lit fluorescent light hanging from the ceiling. Its harsh, cold light creates sharp highlights on their sweat-stained skin and casts long, swaying shadows behind them. The air is thick with dust, clearly visible in the beams of light. The primary colors of the scene are icy grays and deep blacks, the only bright spot being a glaring, blood-red hue. The overall atmosphere is filled with a suffocating sense of tension, a violent aesthetic, and a primal instinct for survival.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3855,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000015/group_15/index_9178_seed_3519_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/371_0000015_group_15_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+372,0.01702594,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01405788,0.00168478,0.00824873,0.78380394,0.57780927,0.06738281,0.00100163,0000101,group_3,1,q2,Is the subject a woman with windswept black hair wearing a well-worn black leather jacket?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, medium close-up, with a sharp digital look, remains static, capturing a figure at the wheel of a sleek black motorcycle. The subject, a woman with a determined expression and windswept black hair, wears a well-worn black leather jacket, its wrinkled texture and subtle sheen accentuated by the lighting. With ease, she swings her leg onto the seat, her free hand momentarily resting on the handlebars for balance. Behind her, a massive tidal power station looms, its massive concrete walls spanning the frame, appearing monolithic and imposing. The low, golden glow of the setting sun sweeps across the scene, casting long, dramatic shadows that stretch across the ground and sculpt every surface with intense contrast. This harsh light captures the grain of the leather and the rough, weathered texture of the concrete structure, creating a powerful portrait that emphasizes the stark contrast between the confident, self-assured human subject and the overwhelming industrial scale of her surroundings, all captured with crisp, high-fidelity detail.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4770,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000101/group_3/index_6062_seed_24672_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/372_0000101_group_3_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q2__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q2__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q2__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q2__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q2__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000101_group_3_sample_1_q2__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+373,0.01702208,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01819159,0.00217472,0.01067791,0.62374067,0.38596076,0.14062500,0.00245830,0000068,group_14,2,q5,"Does the goddess transition from a sleeping, anguished state to waking with tears gleaming in her eyes?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"An epic long shot, the camera slowly and steadily advancing from a slightly bird's-eye view, traverses a celestial, swirling sea of clouds, akin to a fairyland, yet possessing a physical presence. Beams of divine golden light pierce the clouds, creating a distinct Tyndall effect and framing the edges of the sea with a dazzling golden edge. Atop this cloudscape, resembling both soft cotton and undulating mountains, a goddess, clad in the magnificent costume of a Dunhuang apsaras, lies asleep on her side. She wears a flowing silk gown in hues of vermilion red and peacock green. The sheer fabric is embroidered with intricate patterns of precious images in gold thread. Long, colorful ribbons flow like still streams across the cloud bed beneath her. Her towering bun is adorned with delicate gold hairpins and pearl hairpins, while strands of jet-black hair fall around her jade-white face. Yet, her sleeping posture is far from peaceful. Her body, huddled slightly in a nightmare of unbearable moral conflict, her brow furrowed, her classically beautiful face etched with deep anguish. As the camera zooms in, her fingers unconsciously clutch her sleeve, her body trembling slightly with inner torment. Finally, as if jolted awake by an invisible force, her eyes snap open. Those clear pupils, at first filled with the lingering confusion and pain of a nightmare, are quickly replaced by a sober, tragic resolve. Tears gleam in her eyes, but they remain unshed. The entire scene is frozen in a sacred and poignant atmosphere, imbued with the struggle and determination that comes after making a difficult decision.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3721,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000068/group_14/index_7237_seed_30579_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/373_0000068_group_14_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000068_group_14_sample_2_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000068_group_14_sample_2_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000068_group_14_sample_2_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000068_group_14_sample_2_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000068_group_14_sample_2_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000068_group_14_sample_2_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+374,0.01697418,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00774101,0.00091733,0.00454912,0.80982292,0.49243629,0.11425781,0.00265586,0000053,group_1,3,q2,Are there towering stained-glass arched windows depicting a somber and romantic scene?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"majestic, sweeping, high-angle drone shot slowly glides forward and slightly downward, revealing a grand Gothic ballroom rendered in stunning, surreal 3D. A soaring vaulted ceiling with dark stone ribs reaches into the shadows above, flanked by towering stained-glass arched windows that depict a somber and romantic scene. The entire opulent space is illuminated by the warm, shimmering glow of a massive crystal chandelier, whose thousands of facets cast dancing golden rays across the highly polished black marble floor, creating near-perfect, shimmering reflections. Below, hundreds of guests gathered in intimate groups, dressed in exquisite gowns of deep velvet, shimmering silks, and intricate lace in rich jewel tones like crimson, emerald, and sapphire, alongside men in sharp, dark tuxedos. Each guest's identity is concealed behind an intricate phantom mask, ranging from simple, elegant dominoes to ornate creations composed of wire and dark feathers. As the camera continues its steady, almost imperceptible descent, the quiet nature of their conversation becomes apparent, not through sound but through their subtle, deliberate gestures: a fan tapping gently against a gloved palm, a masked head tilting slightly, conspiratorially, a hand gesturing elegantly to emphasize a silent point. The atmosphere is rich with luxurious mystery and exquisite elegance, a breathtaking picture of secret grandeur, where warm light catches the glint of jewels or the metallic sheen of masks, casting long, soft shadows that twist and dance with the flickering candlelight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4954,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000053/group_1/index_4424_seed_17768_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/374_0000053_group_1_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q2__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q2__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q2__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q2__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q2__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q2__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+375,0.01697203,left-right-pair,4.20000000,5,0.00807708,0.00096612,0.00474064,0.69048750,0.43803367,0.11914062,0.00126892,0000009,group_15,1,q3,"Is the woman sitting at a small, round cast-iron table on a sunny restaurant terrace, holding a smartphone to her right ear?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"This static, eye-level medium shot captures a woman with a chic, short, slightly tousled bob, sitting at an outdoor cafe. She wears a short-sleeved shirt made of lightweight fabric with a delicate, pastel floral pattern against a cream background. She sits comfortably at a small, round cast-iron table on the sunny restaurant terrace, leaning slightly forward and holding a modern smartphone to her right ear. Amidst a lively conversation, a warm, relaxed smile graces her lips, her eyes crinkling slightly as she speaks, her head tilted with interest. Her left hand rests on the tabletop, her fingers leisurely stroking the rim of a glass of espresso iced tea. In the background, the restaurant's blurred facade, with its large windows and dark green awning, is visible, while the soft, out-of-focus shapes of other patrons create a gentle sense of ambient activity. The entire scene is illuminated by the warm midday sun, which filters through a large parasol, casting a soft, diffuse glow that eliminates harsh shadows and creates an overall relaxed, down-to-earth, and joyful atmosphere of a pleasant afternoon.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2972,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_15/index_4081_seed_18321_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/375_0000009_group_15_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_15_sample_1_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+376,0.01685217,between-flanked,2.36800000,6,0.01339901,0.00159388,0.00787008,0.73572755,0.45799708,0.10253906,0.00146872,0000091,group_8,0,q2,Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The shot begins in a medium shot, slightly overlooking, with a steady focus on an elderly angler. He wears a wide, frayed bamboo hat, casting a shadow over his weathered face, revealing only a long, graying beard that sways gently in the breeze. Dressed in a simple, dark gray linen jacket, the elderly man sits poised in the center of a rustic wooden boat, its hull a deep brown from years of waterlogging. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender bamboo fishing rod, his line plummeting into the calm, mirror-like surface of the lake, creating only barely perceptible ripples where it enters. The soft, diffuse morning light evenly bathes the water, reflecting the hazy outlines of the sky and distant mountains. The scene is shrouded in a tranquil slate-gray and ink-wash hue. As the camera begins to steadily and slowly pull back, the picture gradually widens, and the figures of the boat and the old man slowly shrink in his world. Finally, he turns into a lonely and harmonious ink dot on the vast lake, completely merging with the rolling indigo mountains shrouded in mist in the background, creating a sense of harmony between man and nature, tranquility and eternity full of oriental philosophical poetry.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1245,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000091/group_8/index_163_seed_16726_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/376_0000091_group_8_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000091_group_8_sample_0_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+377,0.01680283,between-flanked,2.36800000,6,0.01288931,0.00158102,0.00753886,0.68071848,0.49251762,0.08398438,0.00024843,0000133,group_10,1,q3,Does the grandfather perform the action of coughing with a hand pressed to his mouth while his shoulders tremble?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"high-frame-rate, horizontal medium shot gently draws the viewer's attention to a white-haired grandfather, seated peacefully in a dark brown wooden rocking chair. Warm afternoon sunlight, like molten honey, streams through the large side windows, illuminating the cozy, bookish room. The grandfather, with a head full of silver hair and a face marked by the kindly wrinkles of time, wears a soft beige wool cardigan over a light-colored shirt. He hunches his back slightly, pressing a dry, age-freckled hand to his mouth as he lets out a soft, muffled cough. The high-frame-rate lens plays an extremely effective role in this moment: his thin shoulders tremble slightly but clearly, and every muscle contraction is slowed down into poetic detail; at the same time, in the golden beam of light that penetrates the room, countless tiny dust particles that were originally invisible to the naked eye are captured clearly. They are like disturbed golden elves, dancing, spinning and flickering slowly and gracefully in the air, forming a contrast between movement and stillness, grandeur and microcosm with the slight tremor of the old man's body. The whole picture is filled with a peaceful, nostalgic and warm atmosphere with a hint of the fragility of time under the ultimate clarity.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3097,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000133/group_10/index_2761_seed_31390_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/377_0000133_group_10_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000133_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000133_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000133_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000133_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000133_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000133_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+378,0.01673169,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01432860,0.00172890,0.00839980,0.69486099,0.46016589,0.10546875,0.00228879,0000042,group_11,3,q5,Is the scene illuminated by golden afternoon sun creating visible beams (Tyndall effect) through the trees?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium-close, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, captures the image in the style of exquisite 3D animation. A princess, with cascading, shimmering golden hair, meticulously braided into intricate plaits and dotted with tiny white flowers and pearls, graces her flawless face with azure eyes filled with tenderness and love. She wears a flowing gown of lavender silk, delicately embroidered at the neckline and cuffs with silver thread, which shimmers subtly in the soft light filtering through the forest canopy. Beside her stands a majestic white steed, its coat as pure as snow, gleaming like pearl in the light. Its muscles are sleek and powerful, its long mane flowing like silk. In the background lies a dreamy forest clearing, its ancient trees blurred beyond the depth of field. The golden afternoon sun, piercing the branches like beams (the Tyndall effect), casts a shadow upon them. The princess slowly stretched out her slender hand, and her fingertips carefully and gently touched the horse's strong and graceful neck. As her palm gently stroked it, the horse lowered its head slightly in comfort and closed its deep and spiritual eyes. The whole scene was shrouded in a quiet, intimate and magical fairy tale atmosphere. Every detail, from the luster of the princess's hair to the texture of the horse's fur, showed the delicacy and perfection of top 3D animation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2888,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000042/group_11/index_9851_seed_19317_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/378_0000042_group_11_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000042_group_11_sample_3_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000042_group_11_sample_3_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000042_group_11_sample_3_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000042_group_11_sample_3_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000042_group_11_sample_3_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000042_group_11_sample_3_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+379,0.01669148,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01169690,0.00144487,0.00683469,0.84309989,0.64785492,0.06445312,0.00130206,0000070,group_12,0,q5,Is the scene illuminated by cool equipment light and neon track lights casting dynamic shadows on the competitors' faces?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slowly rotating, orbiting medium shot brings us into the core control area of a futuristic drone racing arena. Clad in explosive competitive cinematography, it focuses on two competitors battling side by side. The female competitor on the left, sporting a sleek, dark purple ponytail, wears immersive FPV (first-person view) goggles that half-cover her face, their lenses reflecting a dazzling stream of data. She wears a tight, black, high-tech racing suit with a neon blue circuit pattern. She leans forward slightly, her hands steady and decisive as she grips a complex multi-stick drone controller, her thumbs fine-tuning the joysticks with a speed barely tangible to the naked eye. Beside her, her male teammate, with slightly damp short black hair and a furrowed brow, is absorbed in analyzing a translucent holographic data screen floating before them. His fingers swiftly and deftly swipe and tap across the illuminated interface, adjusting performance parameters and flight path diagrams in real time. Behind them, on the huge circular track structure, other drones turned into blurred colorful light bands and flew by at high speed. The whole scene was illuminated by the cool light emitted by their equipment and the neon lights of the track, casting dynamic light and shadow on their focused faces, creating a tacit cooperation and highly tense competitive atmosphere in the high-speed confrontation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3699,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000070/group_12/index_642_seed_16433_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/379_0000070_group_12_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q5__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q5__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q5__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q5__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q5__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000070_group_12_sample_0_q5__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+380,0.01667354,left-right-pair+beside-next-to+between-flanked,8.54000000,5,0.00389255,0.00045991,0.00228843,0.65661836,0.43774581,0.10546875,0.00039774,0000162,group_1,3,q3,Is a woman in a crisp white silk blouse visible who smooths back her tousled black hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In an elegantly decorated Chinese restaurant, a static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a dynamic social scene, unfolding around a large round table. The warm light from ornate overhead lanterns casts a soft glow over the gathering. To the right, a woman in a crisp white silk blouse engages in conversation, smiles slightly, turns her head, and elegantly smooths back her tousled black hair. Next to her, a woman in a vibrant red dress holds a lit cigarette between her fingers, a wisp of smoke curling toward the ceiling. She leans over and gives a gentle, encouraging pat on the arm of a man in a simple black sweater. Across the table, a man in a forest green jacket deliberately bends down, his upper body disappearing from the frame. He searches the floor for something before slowly returning to his seat. On the far left, a woman with hair in a neat bun, absorbed in her meal, steadily picks up dark wooden chopsticks and reaches forward to select a piece of food from the steaming plate in the center. Meanwhile, a woman in a black turtleneck quietly raises a clear glass to her lips to take a sip of water, then subtly shifts her weight to lean forward across the table, her posture signaling growing interest in the conversation, all contributing to a rich, layered, and naturally casual, friendly dinner atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2601,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000162/group_1/index_7552_seed_18207_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/380_0000162_group_1_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000162_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+381,0.01666877,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01574080,0.00187950,0.00924086,0.68779570,0.43008208,0.12500000,0.00130099,0000149,group_4,0,q4,Do classical Chinese pavilions and towers with jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs appear suspended above the sea of clouds?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with a fluid, 360-degree panning shot, revealing a fairyland shrouded in dense, flowing mist. Like living white silk, these clouds drift slowly between the looming mountains. At the center of the frame, countless tiny energy points, shimmering with a soft bluish-white glow, like sentient fireflies, begin to be drawn by an invisible force. They converge from all directions, spiraling through the air in elegant spirals, accelerating and converging, ultimately forming a futuristic lotus emblem in the very center of the frame. Translucent, metallic-hued geometric lines form the delicate contours of the petals, which are filled with a shimmering crystal material. At its center lies a core of pure, pulsing energy. The moment the emblem took shape, it erupted with an intense yet subtle, holy light. This cool cyan and silver radiance instantly pierced the dense fog, illuminating the surrounding classical Chinese pavilions and towers suspended above the sea of clouds. The jade-like walls and glazed tile roofs of these buildings revealed their delicate textures in the light, while their eaves and corners cast dynamic light and shadow that shifted with the camera's movement. The entire process, dominated by a palette of deep indigo and mysterious purple, created an atmosphere of sacredness, solemnity, tranquility, and power. As the camera completed its full circular path, it fully showcased the spectacular fusion of ancient imagery and futuristic technology.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,352,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000149/group_4/index_4818_seed_33452_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/381_0000149_group_4_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000149_group_4_sample_0_q4__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000149_group_4_sample_0_q4__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000149_group_4_sample_0_q4__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000149_group_4_sample_0_q4__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000149_group_4_sample_0_q4__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000149_group_4_sample_0_q4__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+382,0.01664941,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00760058,0.00090300,0.00446505,0.81248474,0.49510482,0.11621094,0.00266141,0000053,group_1,3,q3,"Is a massive crystal chandelier visible, casting dancing golden rays and shimmering reflections on a black marble floor?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"majestic, sweeping, high-angle drone shot slowly glides forward and slightly downward, revealing a grand Gothic ballroom rendered in stunning, surreal 3D. A soaring vaulted ceiling with dark stone ribs reaches into the shadows above, flanked by towering stained-glass arched windows that depict a somber and romantic scene. The entire opulent space is illuminated by the warm, shimmering glow of a massive crystal chandelier, whose thousands of facets cast dancing golden rays across the highly polished black marble floor, creating near-perfect, shimmering reflections. Below, hundreds of guests gathered in intimate groups, dressed in exquisite gowns of deep velvet, shimmering silks, and intricate lace in rich jewel tones like crimson, emerald, and sapphire, alongside men in sharp, dark tuxedos. Each guest's identity is concealed behind an intricate phantom mask, ranging from simple, elegant dominoes to ornate creations composed of wire and dark feathers. As the camera continues its steady, almost imperceptible descent, the quiet nature of their conversation becomes apparent, not through sound but through their subtle, deliberate gestures: a fan tapping gently against a gloved palm, a masked head tilting slightly, conspiratorially, a hand gesturing elegantly to emphasize a silent point. The atmosphere is rich with luxurious mystery and exquisite elegance, a breathtaking picture of secret grandeur, where warm light catches the glint of jewels or the metallic sheen of masks, casting long, soft shadows that twist and dance with the flickering candlelight.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4953,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000053/group_1/index_4424_seed_17768_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/382_0000053_group_1_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000053_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+383,0.01664167,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01447922,0.00171307,0.00851077,0.67395717,0.46632838,0.08203125,0.00027406,0000086,group_2,0,q4,Does the train move at high speed with a massive front shovel pushing snow and wheels whipping up a blizzard of ice crystals?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady, extreme long shot, parallel to the horizon, gazes silently across a boundless, white, snow-covered wasteland. Shrouded by thick, leaden clouds, the world takes on a chilling blue hue. A single, seemingly endless, heavily armored train barrels through at thundering speed, the sole dynamic stroke on this deadened canvas. Its body is riveted from weathered, dark-gray, matte-finish steel. Its windows are as narrow as fortress embrasures, and faint red warning lights dot the hull, like dying embers in the twilight. Its massive front shovel violently pushes the snow to the sides, while its wheels race along the tracks, whipping up a fierce blizzard of ice crystals and powdery snow. This white storm follows the train's wake, a trail that gradually blurs and merges with the horizon. In the entire picture, apart from the train's own unstoppable movement, everything is silent. This extreme contrast between movement and stillness creates a grand, lonely and doomsday aesthetic.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,488,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000086/group_2/index_1907_seed_6791_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/383_0000086_group_2_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000086_group_2_sample_0_q4__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000086_group_2_sample_0_q4__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000086_group_2_sample_0_q4__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000086_group_2_sample_0_q4__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000086_group_2_sample_0_q4__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000086_group_2_sample_0_q4__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+384,0.01655699,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00813049,0.00098921,0.00476086,0.65759933,0.42873356,0.11328125,0.00079992,0000112,group_13,0,q3,"Is Sparky, a fluffy golden retriever puppy with a tilted head and tail tapping the grass, sitting next to Oliver?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level, medium-wide shot captures the sheer enchantment of a sun-dappled forest clearing. Oliver, a young boy with tousled blond hair and a simple blue and white striped T-shirt, sits cross-legged on a red and white checkered picnic blanket. Next to him sits Sparky, a fluffy golden retriever puppy, his head tilted in curiosity, his tail gently tapping the soft grass. Nearby sits a family of four rabbits: a large brown dad, a gentle white mom, and two small, furry gray bunnies. Between them stands a whimsical tea party, featuring a miniature ceramic tea set with pastel pink, sky blue, and lemon yellow teacups. Oliver, with a look of focused joy on his face, is in action, steadily and deliberately pouring imaginary tea from a small white teapot into a tiny cup, carefully held between the paws of a small rabbit. Another bunny nibbles at a heart-shaped cookie on a central plate, which also contains delicately sliced carrot sticks. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, which filters through the lush green canopy above, creating a beautiful play of light and shadow. The atmosphere is tranquil, warm and whimsical, a magical moment of friendship between children, pets and gentle woodland creatures.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2643,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000112/group_13/index_9147_seed_8076_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/384_0000112_group_13_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000112_group_13_sample_0_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+385,0.01655036,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.01194921,0.00144362,0.00700372,0.75692666,0.50750101,0.09570312,0.00270769,0000093,group_12,2,q1,Is the main subject an Asian man in his twenties with neatly cropped hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"This static, tight, eye-level shot, rendered with detailed, grounded realism, focuses on the determined face of an Asian man in his twenties playing pool, leaning over the table to line up a key shot. The camera captures subtle details: the subtle wrinkle of his brow beneath his neatly cropped hair, and the intensely focused reflection of a single, low-hanging pendant lamp gleaming in his dark eyes. This lone source casts a pool of warm, concentrated light onto the scene, creating sharp highlights on his cheekbones and the bridge of his nose while plunging the surrounding pool hall into a soft, blurred darkness. His left hand, firmly splayed on the rich green felt of the table, forms a perfect bridge with the cue stick, the fine traces of pale blue chalk on his fingertips visible against the dark fabric of the tabletop. Steadily and deliberately, he slides the polished maple cue back and forth through his fingers, his gaze unwavering as he moves between the cue ball and the target. His entire posture is one of quiet, focused study, creating an atmosphere of intense intimacy.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3229,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000093/group_12/index_5266_seed_18915_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/385_0000093_group_12_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q1__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q1__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q1__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q1__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q1__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000093_group_12_sample_2_q1__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+386,0.01653283,opposite-across,2.24400000,4,0.01353987,0.00161880,0.00794738,0.81459111,0.49110663,0.11132812,0.00030494,0000063,group_13,3,q3,Is the man wearing a vibrant yellow rain hoodie over jeans with brown hair plastered to his forehead?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"This medium, eye-level shot, captured with a handheld camera, subtly panning to heighten the chaos, shows a man in his 30s at the wheel of a gleaming, aluminum, adult-sized tricycle. He stands on a wide suburban street, slick and dark beneath a gray, cloudy sky from a recent rain. The man, his brown hair plastered to his forehead, wears a vibrant yellow rain hoodie over jeans. His face perfectly conceals a comical panic, eyes wide and mouth open. He is in the midst of a frantic fishtail; both rear wheels lose traction on the wet asphalt and slide sharply to one side, setting off a dramatic arc of water. He desperately twists the handlebars in opposite directions, his body leaning hard to balance the slide, his legs flailing as he struggles to keep his feet on the pedals. The tricycle's polished aluminum frame catches the diffused light, shimmering even as it careens uncontrollably. In the background, neat suburban houses and manicured lawns, slightly out of focus, provide a calming backdrop to the unfolding chaos. The entire shot is filled with subtle film grain, adding a cinematic and nostalgic quality to a chaotic and fun moment of pure, effortless panic.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2852,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000063/group_13/index_1415_seed_23249_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/386_0000063_group_13_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+387,0.01648225,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01356126,0.00167762,0.00792243,0.81404954,0.59690166,0.07519531,0.00078136,0000161,group_7,1,q2,Is the man wearing a dark charcoal gray suit that is completely soaked and clinging to his body?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, dynamic tracking shot follows a man sprinting along a rainy city street. The camera stays in sync with him, emphasizing the speed and force of his run. The man, in his thirties, wears a well-tailored, dark charcoal gray suit, now completely soaked by the downpour, the expensive fabric clinging to his contours. His once-pristine white shirt is ripped at the collar, a crimson silk tie hanging loosely, swinging with his movements. The rain dampens his short, dark hair, strands clinging to his forehead and cheeks. His expression is tense, his jaw clenched, and his eyes reveal a mixture of despair and unwavering focus. Directly ahead of him lies a wide asphalt road, its surface a black mirror in the relentless rain, greedily reflecting the shimmering, iridescent neon lights of the tall buildings on either side—psychedelic pinks, cool blues, and glaring reds. With each strenuous step forward, his polished black Oxfords slammed heavily into the puddle, sending up circles of shimmering, neon-lit water, forming brief, dazzling arcs in the camera. The entire scene is imbued with a tense, urgent atmosphere, like a climactic chase scene in a neo-noir film. The stark contrast between the cool tones of the frame and the saturated neon highlights creates a dramatic tension that is both flamboyant and desperate.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3494,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000161/group_7/index_3558_seed_20762_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/387_0000161_group_7_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000161_group_7_sample_1_q2__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000161_group_7_sample_1_q2__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000161_group_7_sample_1_q2__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000161_group_7_sample_1_q2__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000161_group_7_sample_1_q2__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000161_group_7_sample_1_q2__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+388,0.01646510,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01386121,0.00166953,0.00812779,0.77206141,0.51204950,0.09375000,0.00301823,0000143,group_3,0,q3,"Does the astronaut have short, sweat-soaked brown hair and wide, terrified eyes?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"violently shaky close-up, captured from a horizontal angle, captures an astronaut jolted awake from a light sleep. Her short, sweat-soaked brown hair clings to her forehead, her eyes wide open in sheer terror, pupils constricted in the dim light. Her body tenses from the violent vibrations of the cabin. Clad in a somewhat bulky white spacesuit, her hands instinctively clutch the metal armrests of her seat, her lips parted as if a silent scream were frozen in her throat. Before her, the once silent, complex dashboard is now dominated by a blinding, blinking red alarm light. This ominous glow dances wildly between the narrow metal walls, casting her pale face and the intricate textures of her spacesuit in a disconcerting, blood-red halo. The remaining unlit screens and buttons on the dashboard are lost in deep shadow. Her eyes were fixed in horror on the madly flashing data and symbols. The entire space creaked and groaned due to the continuous and violent shaking, creating an extremely tense, claustrophobic atmosphere on the verge of being out of control.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1174,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000143/group_3/index_4465_seed_33420_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/388_0000143_group_3_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000143_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000143_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000143_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000143_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000143_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000143_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+389,0.01642391,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01418037,0.00172128,0.00830606,0.72779608,0.53578979,0.07226562,0.00066358,0000078,group_15,2,q5,Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focuses squarely on the awed face of a young woman dressed in traditional shrine maiden garb. She stands quietly at the wooden steps of an ancient shrine, her long, flowing, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband, strands brushing against her fair cheeks in the night breeze. The cool moonlight frames her delicate profile. Her head tilted slightly, her lips parted in wonder, her eyes, as clear as deep pools, gaze at the abyss of the night sky. Within these eyes, a magnificent meteor shower is perfectly reflected: countless fleeting, slender, brilliant arcs of silver light streak across her pupils, slightly dilated with concentration, as if the entire galaxy were ablaze in her gaze. Her pristine white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama take on a solemn yet soft quality in the dim light, while the shrine's architectural outlines and hanging stone lanterns behind her are completely blurred, transforming into a dreamy, softly shimmering backdrop composed of warm yellow dots. The entire image, shrouded in profound tranquility, exudes a sacred and ethereal beauty of classical Oriental beauty, capturing a poetic moment of dialogue between humanity and the universe.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1674,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000078/group_15/index_4060_seed_5020_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/389_0000078_group_15_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q5__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q5__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q5__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q5__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q5__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000078_group_15_sample_2_q5__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+390,0.01642087,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.01574238,0.00187895,0.00924229,0.74843305,0.49690059,0.08789062,0.00103134,0000131,group_10,2,q1,Is the scene set on a desolate mountain ridge with a weathered beacon tower made of massive stone blocks nearby?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from an upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward, focusing on an ancient soldier perched atop a desolate mountain ridge. Beside him stands a weathered beacon tower, constructed of massive stone blocks, its surface covered in cracks and moss, a silent witness to the howling wind. The soldier's long, black hair is tied back, strands whipping wildly against his weathered face in the biting wind. He wears a suit of worn, dark iron scale armor, its plates scarred by past battles. The hem of his dark, coarse linen tabard flaps violently in the wind. His feet, firmly planted on the rough ground, he draws a massive longbow made of dark, knotty wood with controlled force, the bow creaking mournfully under the immense tension. As the bowstring is drawn to his cheek, the muscles of his arms and back visibly tense beneath his armor, making him look like a statue poised for action. His brow furrowed, his lips pursed, his eyes narrowed in the gusting wind, but his cold, resolute gaze, sharp as an eagle's, fixed its gaze firmly on an invisible target beyond the camera. In the sky, thick, dark clouds rolled rapidly, and the pale, setting sun struggled to cast a faint, cold light, painting the entire scene with a dominant gray-blue hue. The light outlined the cold metal contours of the armor and the rough texture of the rocks, creating an epic atmosphere of loneliness, awe, and resolute will.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2397,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000131/group_10/index_9686_seed_32976_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/390_0000131_group_10_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000131_group_10_sample_2_q1__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000131_group_10_sample_2_q1__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000131_group_10_sample_2_q1__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000131_group_10_sample_2_q1__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000131_group_10_sample_2_q1__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000131_group_10_sample_2_q1__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+391,0.01641011,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.00755239,0.00090334,0.00443270,0.67988122,0.47854894,0.07421875,0.00257114,0000067,group_15,2,q2,"Is the man wearing a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt with sleeves pushed up to his elbows?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a medium, slightly upward angle, the camera pans steadily to the right, closely following the subject's movements. In the frame, a man in his thirties, with short, dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard, leans slightly forward, his expression focused and serious. He wears a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt, the sleeves casually pushed up to his elbows, revealing his muscular forearms. He is in a softly lit bedroom, with the corner of a bed covered in white sheets visible in the background. Steadily and deliberately, the man extends his right arm toward a blue nylon travel bag on the bed. The bag features black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper, half-unzipped. As the camera follows, the thick wad of banknotes clutched in his left hand becomes visible. He then carefully places the wad of bills into the bag's open mouth, his fingers delicately moving as he pushes the money deeper into the bag. The natural morning light filtering in from a side window casts soft shadows on his arm and the surface of the travel bag, highlighting the texture of the nylon and the thickness of the banknotes. The dominant color scheme of the entire scene is the vibrant blue of the travel bag, the dark gray of the man's clothing, and the white of the bed sheet, creating an atmosphere of focus, intimacy, and a touch of tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3299,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_15/index_3450_seed_7520_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/391_0000067_group_15_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_15_sample_2_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+392,0.01638775,beside-next-to,1.98000000,4,0.01598127,0.00191186,0.00937961,0.71031266,0.45178002,0.11718750,0.00267661,0000080,group_7,1,q2,"Is a scholar wearing a pale blue, wide-sleeved, ancient-style robe lying asleep on a bed?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, smooth camera movement begins, gently advancing from the outside of the thatched cottage, through a half-open, rustic wooden window carved with simple patterns, and into the interior. The first rays of soft morning sunlight filter through the window lattice, casting dappled shadows on the dark wooden floor and a rustic, solid-wood bed. On the bed, a scholar, dressed in a pale blue, wide-sleeved, cotton-linen, ancient-style robe, lies asleep on his side, his back to the camera. His long, jet-black hair is loosely tied back with a simple wooden hairpin, a few strands cascading across his neck and pillow. His body rises and falls gently with his steady, deep breathing. A translucent white gauze curtain flutters gently in the breeze from the window. Beside his pillow, a scroll of yellowed rice paper containing a poem unfolds, its ink-stained cursive script faintly visible. As the sound of birdsong gradually rises outside the window, the camera moves steadily and calmly to the right, and the line of sight slowly swings from the scholar's back to the outside of the window, finally revealing a vibrant spring morning scene in the courtyard: several peach trees are in bloom, pink petals dotted on the tender green branches, the ground is covered with a thin layer of morning mist, and a bluestone path winds its way into the distance. In the warm morning light, the whole picture creates a tranquil, poetic atmosphere full of classical oriental aesthetics.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3672,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000080/group_7/index_2621_seed_10018_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/392_0000080_group_7_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000080_group_7_sample_1_q2__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000080_group_7_sample_1_q2__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000080_group_7_sample_1_q2__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000080_group_7_sample_1_q2__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000080_group_7_sample_1_q2__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000080_group_7_sample_1_q2__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+393,0.01631294,opposite-across,2.78800000,9,0.01100258,0.00130609,0.00646433,0.72058088,0.46506196,0.09863281,0.00076598,0000009,group_4,2,q5,Is a classic green-shaded bank lamp on the table emitting warm golden light that creates deep shadows contrasting with the tablet's glow?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot depicts a tense, silent confrontation in the hallowed quiet of a wood-paneled academic library. At a large, polished mahogany table, a young man with shaggy black hair leans forward, an impassioned look of frustration written across his face. Wearing a comfortable, dark green cardigan, they repeatedly gesture with their index finger to a tablet on the table. The tablet's screen emits a bright, cool digital glow, casting a stark blue light on their faces and hands, illuminating the complex data charts visible on the display. An older man seated opposite, dressed in a formal dark tweed blazer and a crisp white collared shirt, remains erect, his posture a wall of defiance. His silver-gray hair is impossibly neatly trimmed, his face a mask of resolute misunderstanding. He shakes his head slowly and stubbornly, his lips pressed into a thin line, his gaze deliberately averted, refusing even a glance at the glowing screen. The warm golden light from a classic green-shaded bank lamp on the table illuminates the scene, creating deep shadows that contrast with the cool glow of the tablet, visually emphasizing the generational and ideological clash. The background is filled with tall, dimly lit bookshelves filled with old leather-bound books, creating a heavy academic atmosphere, imbued with the weight of tradition and unspoken disagreements.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,133,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_4/index_5960_seed_20023_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/393_0000009_group_4_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q5__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q5__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q5__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q5__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q5__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_4_sample_2_q5__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+394,0.01630619,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.58800000,6,0.00605385,0.00076410,0.00352649,0.79200816,0.58294982,0.08398438,0.00103164,0000168,group_10,1,q3,Is the woman wearing an off-white turtleneck cashmere sweater with her dark brown hair pulled into a low bun?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, close-up, static shot, captured from a slight overhead angle, focuses on a gentle Asian mother, comfortably seated in a vintage wooden armchair. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through a large window, casting a warm golden hue on her long, dark brown hair, pulled into a low bun, and the off-white, turtleneck cashmere sweater she wears. Her face holds a serene, focused expression, her eyes slightly downcast, her gaze completely focused on the work in her hands. Her hands move steadily and deliberately, two smooth bamboo knitting needles twirling between her deft fingers. One needle expertly picks up lavender yarn and delicately threads it through the loop of the other. A half-finished sweater drapes across her legs, its intricate, twisted pattern clearly visible in the light, each fluffy fiber seeming palpable, a vivid, textured expression. Beside her, a wicker basket filled with colorful balls of yarn rests on the ground. The bookshelves and greenery in the background are softly blurred by the shallow depth of field. The entire scene is warm and harmonious, imbued with the warmth of home and the tranquility of time brought by handmade crafts.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3009,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_8887_seed_8253_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/394_0000168_group_10_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000168_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000168_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000168_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000168_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000168_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000168_group_10_sample_1_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+395,0.01629393,beside-next-to,2.34000000,7,0.01212595,0.00145524,0.00711381,0.76183182,0.52807462,0.08203125,0.00154042,0000166,group_11,2,q2,Is the older man wearing a faded dark blue work jumpsuit with a yellowed hard hat under his arm?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, low-angle, wide-angle shot depicts two figures, dwarfed by the massive presence of a power plant's cooling towers. The scene is bathed in the soft, warm light of dusk, casting long, dramatic shadows across the gravelly ground. On the left stands an older man, his weathered face etched with the lines of experience. He wears a faded, dark blue work jumpsuit, a yellowed hard hat tucked under his arm. His posture is slightly relaxed, one hand gesturing deftly, his expression thoughtful. Beside him, a younger figure in a modern, dark green technical jacket and gray overalls listens intently, hands in pockets, head tilted slightly. They are engaged in a quiet conversation, their distance suggesting a shared, private moment. Massive concrete towers rise behind them, their richly textured surfaces capturing the golden hour, while white steam drifts lazily through vast openings, emitting pink and orange glows against the deepening twilight sky. The predominant color palette is a warm fusion of amber and rose, contrasted against the cool, industrial gray of the concrete, creating an atmosphere of deep contemplation and tranquility, highlighting moments of intimate human connection against a backdrop of immense power.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3472,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000166/group_11/index_9235_seed_5697_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/395_0000166_group_11_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q2__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q2__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q2__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q2__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q2__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000166_group_11_sample_2_q2__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+396,0.01629349,beside-next-to,0.73500000,5,0.03658153,0.00434087,0.02149377,0.83183694,0.54322165,0.09667969,0.00250033,0000007,group_14,1,q4,"Does the scene show an elderly couple sitting on a weathered wooden dock, with the man wearing a faded plaid flannel shirt and khaki fishing vest?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"sweeping wide shot begins, the camera slowly and steadily panning from left to right across the tranquil surface of a lake at sunrise. A soft mist hovers above the water, capturing the sun's first rays and painting the horizon in a stunning gradient of soft pink, warm orange, and deep purple, all perfectly reflected in the still water. The camera's movement pauses, focusing on a weathered wooden dock where an elderly couple sits. The man, with silver-white hair and friendly wrinkles etched around his eyes, wears a faded plaid flannel shirt over a practical khaki fishing vest. He sits on a simple wooden box, gripping an old-fashioned fishing rod with a steady, practiced hand. His wife sits beside him, their shoulders almost touching, her soft gray hair pulled back in a loose bun, a cozy cream-colored knitted shawl wrapped around her shoulders. She also holds a fishing rod, her posture relaxed and her expression calm. Their lines disappear into the water, their buoys bobbing motionlessly, the only distraction from the perfect reflection. Their shared silence was not empty but fulfilling, a comfortable quiet that spoke of a lifetime together, creating an overall atmosphere of profound peace, nostalgia and tranquility, of unspoken love.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,249,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000007/group_14/index_6545_seed_5514_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/396_0000007_group_14_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+397,0.01625754,left-right-pair,4.68000000,7,0.00658587,0.00079453,0.00386089,0.68414968,0.46238977,0.09082031,0.00006735,0000056,group_3,3,q2,Is Sun Wukong wearing intricately carved golden chainmail armor with cloud patterns and a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown with two long pheasant feathers?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic shot, shot from a low, upward angle, depicts the camera in a slow, powerful arc, capturing the subject in a meticulously rendered 3D style. Before the majestic Water Curtain Cave in the Flower-Fruit Mountain, the Monkey King, Sun Wukong, stands in a steady horse stance, legs slightly bent. He clad in intricately carved golden chainmail armor, its plates engraved with intricate cloud patterns that reflect the surrounding light. Atop his head, a phoenix-wing purple-gold crown, two long pheasant feathers flutter majestically with his movements. His golden hair, rendered in physical rendering, is distinct and shimmers with a silken sheen. His fiery eyes radiate an unyielding golden light, his facial expression stern and filled with fighting spirit. He clutches the legendary golden cudgel in both hands. The cudgel's shaft doesn't simply glow; instead, it emanates a fiery, molten-like energy from within. Golden hoops, inlaid at each end, appear and disappear beneath the surge of energy. Behind him, a vast waterfall cascades down from a towering cliff like the Milky Way, forming a vast curtain of water. Countless water droplets splash through the air, refracted by the light of the golden cudgel, creating a rainbow of colors. With a low roar, Sun Wukong thrust his golden cudgel in a perfect golden arc from the right rear to the left front. The cudgel slices through the air with a deep, powerful whistling sound, and the resulting air currents even momentarily distort the surrounding waterfall. His movements are imbued with explosive power and control. The cudgel's blazing light serves as the scene's primary source of light, illuminating every detail of his armor and the damp rocks, creating a mythical, epic atmosphere filled with power and tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,519,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000056/group_3/index_5644_seed_26612_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/397_0000056_group_3_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q2__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q2__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q2__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q2__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q2__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000056_group_3_sample_3_q2__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+398,0.01624328,opposite-across,2.24400000,4,0.01322871,0.00158219,0.00776435,0.81168753,0.49299172,0.10742188,0.00013232,0000063,group_13,3,q4,Does the man perform a frantic fishtail where the rear wheels lose traction and slide on wet asphalt?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"This medium, eye-level shot, captured with a handheld camera, subtly panning to heighten the chaos, shows a man in his 30s at the wheel of a gleaming, aluminum, adult-sized tricycle. He stands on a wide suburban street, slick and dark beneath a gray, cloudy sky from a recent rain. The man, his brown hair plastered to his forehead, wears a vibrant yellow rain hoodie over jeans. His face perfectly conceals a comical panic, eyes wide and mouth open. He is in the midst of a frantic fishtail; both rear wheels lose traction on the wet asphalt and slide sharply to one side, setting off a dramatic arc of water. He desperately twists the handlebars in opposite directions, his body leaning hard to balance the slide, his legs flailing as he struggles to keep his feet on the pedals. The tricycle's polished aluminum frame catches the diffused light, shimmering even as it careens uncontrollably. In the background, neat suburban houses and manicured lawns, slightly out of focus, provide a calming backdrop to the unfolding chaos. The entire shot is filled with subtle film grain, adding a cinematic and nostalgic quality to a chaotic and fun moment of pure, effortless panic.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2851,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000063/group_13/index_1415_seed_23249_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/398_0000063_group_13_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000063_group_13_sample_3_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+399,0.01621889,left-right-pair+beside-next-to,5.94000000,4,0.00577995,0.00068728,0.00339511,0.66634917,0.40910500,0.13769531,0.00055152,0000141,group_8,2,q2,Is the setting a living room with a large bay window and wooden floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady, medium-length, static shot, taken from a level angle, captures a graying elderly couple sitting side by side in a warm, if slightly dated, living room. They sit by a large bay window, soft afternoon sunlight slanting through the clear glass, casting long, warm patches of light on the wooden floor beside them. The husband, seated on the left, wears a dark blue wool cardigan over a light gray plaid shirt. His face, deeply wrinkled by time, gazes calmly ahead, as if lost in thought. Beside him, his wife, dressed in a soft, off-white turtleneck sweater, her equally gray hair elegantly tied in a bun. Her head tilted slightly to the right, her gaze over her husband's shoulder, distant and unfocused, gazing out the window at the late autumn scene, where a few withered yellow leaves slowly drift down. Then, her chest rose and fell almost imperceptibly, her lips parted slightly, and she let out a soft and long sigh. This sigh was particularly clear in the quiet room, injecting a peaceful, nostalgic and slightly sentimental atmosphere into the whole picture.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1395,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000141/group_8/index_640_seed_22598_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/399_0000141_group_8_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000141_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000141_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000141_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000141_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000141_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000141_group_8_sample_2_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+400,0.01618862,foreground-background,3.08000000,5,0.00943193,0.00111810,0.00554255,0.82715684,0.51590705,0.10253906,0.00249699,0000082,group_9,2,q2,Are several friends wearing cozy sweaters and casual shirts gathered around the table?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a cozy, humanistic interior, a fluid single shot begins at table level, then slowly and gracefully pans rightward across a warm dining scene. A long, dark wooden table, covered with a beige linen tablecloth, is laden with half-eaten home-cooked dishes and scattered crumbs. Several friends, dressed in cozy sweaters and casual shirts, gather around the table. Their faces are blurred by a soft bokeh, yet their genuine smiles and lively gestures, engaged in conversation, are clearly visible. As the camera pans, the focus gradually and seamlessly shifts from the joyful gathering in the background to the central subject in the foreground: a woman's hand, delicately lifting a glass of white wine from the table. Steady and composed, her nails immaculately manicured, the hand elegantly grasps the slender stem of a classic crystal goblet. The glass is about one-third full of pale golden white wine, and under the soft light cast by a low, warm-toned chandelier overhead, the wine's clarity is translucent, shimmering with sparkling shimmer. As the wine glasses are slowly raised to the center of the picture, the smiling faces and figures of the friends in the background are completely blurred into warm spots of light (Bokeh) and soft blocks of color. The whole picture is wrapped in an intimate, peaceful and joyful atmosphere. The main colors are warm amber and cream, and the contrast of light and shadow is soft, perfectly capturing this peaceful and sincere moment of celebration.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4834,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000082/group_9/index_3890_seed_29050_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/400_0000082_group_9_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q2__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q2__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q2__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q2__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q2__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000082_group_9_sample_2_q2__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+401,0.01609748,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01482163,0.00177649,0.00869676,0.69995290,0.44785997,0.11718750,0.00306410,0000166,group_5,0,q2,Is the other phoenix carved from translucent ice crystals with sapphire/cyan feathers and icy eyes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"magnificent 360-degree slow-motion shot, shot from a slightly upward perspective, captures the epic battle between two mythical phoenixes amidst a turbulent sky swirling with dark storm clouds. One phoenix is composed entirely of flowing magma and incandescent fire, each feather a pure, pulsating crimson and gold flame. Its eyes are like blazing embers, and its flight leaves a dazzling trail of sparks and embers in its wake. The other phoenix, in stark contrast, is carved from translucent ice crystals, its feathers razor-sharp icicles gleaming with sapphire and cyan. Its wings, with their beats, scatter countless tiny, glittering frost particles, and its icy eyes are like distant stars. The camera smoothly rotates around them, capturing every detail as they swirl, dive, and claw at each other in a deadly aerial ballet: the fire phoenix folds its wings sharply, swooping down like a flaming meteor, while the ice phoenix gracefully sideways, blocking with the edge of its crystal wings. When the camera rotates to the optimal angle, the two divine birds have a fierce head-on collision. The burning feathers collide with the icy feathers, and a dazzling energy shock wave instantly erupts - the hot sparks hiss and turn into steam when they come into contact with the cold air, while the hard ice crystals explode into countless glittering fragments under the high temperature, intertwined with the falling and extinguished flame feathers, forming a destructive picture full of primitive power and magnificent beauty. The whole scene, with the extreme contrast of warm and cold colors, creates a tense, intense and sacred fantasy atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1357,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000166/group_5/index_6042_seed_32799_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/401_0000166_group_5_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q2__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q2__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q2__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q2__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q2__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000166_group_5_sample_0_q2__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+402,0.01608398,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01764562,0.00213490,0.01034048,0.57300061,0.35064000,0.17675781,0.00270790,0000103,group_14,1,q5,Does the cat gracefully unfurl from a ball into an elongated position with front paws unsheathed to grasp the floor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a stunning slow-motion sequence captured with high-speed photography, a rotating camera executes a low-angle orbit around a sleeping cat curled up on a dark, highly polished hardwood floor, which reflects the scene like black water. The feline, a sleek shorthair with glossy black fur, initially appears as a perfect, motionless ball. Suddenly, a sleek, self-propelled smart toy, shaped like an understated white disc, darts past in the background. Its integrated cyan and magenta LEDs illuminate the dimly lit room, casting vibrant, streaked light that blurs with speed. The toy's faint purring triggers the cat's awakening; an ear twitches, and its emerald green eyes snap open in a moment of intense focus. As the camera continues its smooth, circular path, the cat begins to gracefully unfurl in a single, fluid motion. The image emphasizes the dramatic, deliberate elongation of its spine and the powerful extension of its front paws, slightly unsheathed to grasp the reflective surface. The entire awakening is a ballet of controlled muscle movement, creating a dramatic and mesmerizing contrast between the feline’s organic, languid grace and the toy’s fuzzy, fleeting technological presence, establishing an atmosphere of suspended, graceful movement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1641,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000103/group_14/index_201_seed_30034_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/402_0000103_group_14_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000103_group_14_sample_1_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+403,0.01603798,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01355607,0.00161718,0.00795926,0.77096355,0.51023155,0.09375000,0.00046730,0000104,group_3,0,q2,"Is the man wearing a loose, white traditional cotton and linen training suit with wide sleeves?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a level angle begins in medium shot, then slowly pulls back to reveal a wider scene. The frame focuses on a silver-haired elderly man, clad in a loose, white, traditional cotton and linen training suit, nestled in a tranquil bamboo forest. The faint morning sun, the sole source of light, penetrates the towering, verdant bamboo poles and dense leaves, creating soft, voluminous beams that are visible through the misty air and cast shifting, dappled shadows on the damp, leaf-covered ground. The elderly man's hair is meticulously combed, his face deeply wrinkled, weathered. His eyes are slightly closed, his expression focused and peaceful. He is performing Tai Chi with incredible slowness and stability, his arms tracing smooth arcs at a speed barely perceptible to the naked eye, his weight shifting effortlessly between his legs. Each movement is imbued with inner, composed strength. His wide white sleeves fluttered gently as his body turned, and their trajectory seemed to merge with the flowing air and light. There was no pause between his movements, perfectly interpreting the artistic conception of ""flowing like clouds and running water"". The whole scene presented an extremely quiet, solemn and Zen-like meditative atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2431,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000104/group_3/index_2934_seed_6320_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/403_0000104_group_3_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000104_group_3_sample_0_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+404,0.01602671,opposite-across,2.51600000,6,0.01348171,0.00158579,0.00793061,0.61768746,0.38875735,0.13183594,0.00093132,0000161,group_10,3,q2,Is a man in his 30s wearing a dark blue denim jacket and a gray T-shirt visible?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shaky, handheld, medium shot at eye level immerses the viewer in an intimate and emotionally charged conversation. The camera's subtle, sustained movement focuses on a man in his 30s, his hair disheveled and shadowed at five o'clock, who speaks with passion. He wears a worn, dark blue denim jacket over a simple gray T-shirt, and sits leaning forward on a plush sofa. He gestures vigorously with his right hand, fingers spread and then clenched to punctuate his words. Across from him, a woman in her early 30s, her long, wavy brown hair partially obscuring her face, listens raptly. She wears a soft, cream-colored sweater. The scene is set in a cozy, dimly lit living room at night. A warm floor lamp casts a golden glow, creating soft shadows and highlighting the dancing dust particles in the air. When the man pauses, the woman slowly turns to meet his gaze, her expression softening with empathy, and she nods gently in deep agreement, a silent affirmation that resonates within the raw, authentic atmosphere of the moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2780,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000161/group_10/index_6331_seed_7686_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/404_0000161_group_10_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+405,0.01595243,left-right-pair,3.72000000,3,0.00923104,0.00107241,0.00543909,0.67878914,0.38246071,0.14648438,0.00448138,0000106,group_11,2,q2,Is the general wearing an iron helmet with a long red tassel and a crimson battle robe beneath the armor?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"fixed, medium-long shot, captured from a slightly upward angle in the style of documentary photography, captures an ancient general clad in weathered iron scale armor, slowly advancing from the right side of the frame to the left. The dim afterglow of the setting sun slants down from the sky, casting long shadows on the cracked yellow earth, silhouetted against the general and his horse. The general wears an iron helmet with a long red tassel. His face, weathered and dust-stained, stares piercingly ahead. His armor, composed of countless plates, is covered in scratches and dark rust, while the crimson battle robe beneath it sways slightly in the wind. He holds the reins firmly in one hand, the other on the hilt of the ancient sword at his waist, his posture erect and unwavering, even on horseback. The muscles of his black warhorse bulge beneath him, its coat matted to a dull sheen from a mixture of sweat and dust. Each heavy thump of the horse's hooves stirs up a small plume of yellow dust. The backdrop is a vast, desolate battlefield, the air thick with visible smoke and dust. Tattered flags flutter feebly in the wind, and in the distance, the outlines of broken weapons and fallen chariots are faintly visible. The dominant tones of the painting are earthy ochre and the gray-black of iron. The deep red of the general's robe and helmet tassel serve as solemn embellishments, creating an epic atmosphere of postwar desolation, tragic grandeur, and yet filled with tenacious strength.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,983,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000106/group_11/index_5700_seed_13740_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/405_0000106_group_11_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000106_group_11_sample_2_q2__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000106_group_11_sample_2_q2__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000106_group_11_sample_2_q2__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000106_group_11_sample_2_q2__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000106_group_11_sample_2_q2__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000106_group_11_sample_2_q2__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+406,0.01592327,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.44000000,5,0.00415095,0.00050581,0.00243010,0.78082138,0.57785630,0.06835938,0.00003904,0000136,group_9,0,q3,"Does the man open a white rickety cabinet to reveal shelves with glass jars, tins, and cardboard boxes?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures the scene in a brightly lit modern kitchen. A man with slightly tousled brown hair casually walks toward a set of lower cabinets. He wears a red and white checkered, short-sleeved button-down shirt and contrasting teal checkered shorts, creating a relaxed, homely look. He pauses before a white, rickety cabinet and reaches down deliberately, his fingers grasping the small, brushed metal knob. He smoothly pulls the door open, revealing shelves filled with a messy yet organized pantry: an assortment of unlabeled glass jars, colorful tins, and plain cardboard boxes. Holding a simple glass jar with a plain metal lid in his right hand, he takes a step closer, bending slightly at his knees and waist, and carefully reaches into the cabinet. Steadily and accurately, he places the jar on the bottom shelf, nestled between a stack of jars and a box. Once his fingers release the jar, he straightens and begins to rotate his body to the left. As he begins to turn away from the open cabinet, his movements are fluid and unhurried, completing a simple chore. The scene is bathed in warm, soft light from overhead fixtures, creating a comfortable and tranquil atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,801,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000136/group_9/index_5875_seed_11771_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/406_0000136_group_9_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+407,0.01590700,left-right-pair,1.47000000,5,0.02000059,0.00239218,0.01173894,0.72462678,0.47256920,0.10449219,0.00219175,0000075,group_1,1,q3,"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, slightly elevated wide-angle shot captures a panoramic coastal scene bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun. A classic, weathered fishing boat, its white hull and blue trim showing signs of age, with peeling paint and rust stains, glides steadily and purposefully across the frame from left to right. It slices through the calm, deep blue water, leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam trailing behind it, disrupting the otherwise glassy surface. The boat maintains a consistent course, approaching a long rock breakwater constructed of large, dark, moss-colored boulders. At its end stands a traditional lighthouse with a white cylindrical tower and a red lantern room. Against the static backdrop, a picturesque coastal town nestles at the foot of rolling green hills, its buildings a mix of whitewashed and terracotta-roofed. The low-hanging sun casts long, soft shadows and shimmering light across the water, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and majesty. The boat's deliberate movement is the only dynamic element in the serene and beautiful scenery.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3696,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000075/group_1/index_7451_seed_5361_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/407_0000075_group_1_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000075_group_1_sample_1_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000075_group_1_sample_1_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000075_group_1_sample_1_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000075_group_1_sample_1_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000075_group_1_sample_1_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000075_group_1_sample_1_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+408,0.01574418,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01306185,0.00156099,0.00766724,0.81302631,0.48997247,0.11132812,0.00016123,0000117,group_9,2,q2,"Is the man wearing a loose, flowing dark blue silk robe and reclining on an antique carved wooden chair?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a thin, middle-aged strategist with a neatly trimmed goatee, nestled within a dimly lit military tent. He wears a loose, flowing dark blue silk robe, his long hair held back with a simple wooden hairpin. He reclines leisurely on an antique carved wooden chair. The only illumination comes from a bronze oil lamp on a table beside him. Its flickering, warm yellow light casts deep, undulating shadows on his face, emphasizing his pensive expression and illuminating the folds of his silk robe with a soft sheen. In his right hand, he grasps a feather fan made of pure white crane feathers, gently waving it with a steady, leisurely rhythm, the breeze occasionally causing the lamplight to flicker. In the background, a military map hangs on the thick dark canvas tent wall, and a wooden weapons rack with unfolded bamboo slips and weapons can be vaguely seen next to it. The whole scene has a warm tone, mainly deep dark colors, creating an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tranquility and strategic planning against the backdrop of military tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,979,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000117/group_9/index_9345_seed_1225_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/408_0000117_group_9_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q2__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q2__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q2__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q2__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q2__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q2__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+409,0.01569056,foreground-background,3.08000000,5,0.00888271,0.00105179,0.00522061,0.81061172,0.53825790,0.08886719,0.00142080,0000082,group_9,0,q5,Are the faces of the friends in the background blurred into warm spots of light (bokeh) while the hand remains in focus?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a cozy, humanistic interior, a fluid single shot begins at table level, then slowly and gracefully pans rightward across a warm dining scene. A long, dark wooden table, covered with a beige linen tablecloth, is laden with half-eaten home-cooked dishes and scattered crumbs. Several friends, dressed in cozy sweaters and casual shirts, gather around the table. Their faces are blurred by a soft bokeh, yet their genuine smiles and lively gestures, engaged in conversation, are clearly visible. As the camera pans, the focus gradually and seamlessly shifts from the joyful gathering in the background to the central subject in the foreground: a woman's hand, delicately lifting a glass of white wine from the table. Steady and composed, her nails immaculately manicured, the hand elegantly grasps the slender stem of a classic crystal goblet. The glass is about one-third full of pale golden white wine, and under the soft light cast by a low, warm-toned chandelier overhead, the wine's clarity is translucent, shimmering with sparkling shimmer. As the wine glasses are slowly raised to the center of the picture, the smiling faces and figures of the friends in the background are completely blurred into warm spots of light (Bokeh) and soft blocks of color. The whole picture is wrapped in an intimate, peaceful and joyful atmosphere. The main colors are warm amber and cream, and the contrast of light and shadow is soft, perfectly capturing this peaceful and sincere moment of celebration.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4827,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000082/group_9/index_3890_seed_29048_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/409_0000082_group_9_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q5__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q5__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q5__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q5__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q5__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000082_group_9_sample_0_q5__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+410,0.01568297,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01199922,0.00144284,0.00703758,0.78014761,0.54275751,0.07910156,0.00017881,0000104,group_13,0,q2,Are tall cattail plants with fibrous green stems and chocolate brown flower spikes visible at the center of the frame?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot, rendered in a lush, hand-drawn, Ghibli-inspired art style, focuses on a clump of tall cattail plants at the center of the frame. Their fibrous green stems, with their soft, painterly texture, are topped with distinctive spikes of velvety flowers a rich chocolate brown. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of the afternoon sun, illuminating the tranquil marsh setting. Crystal-clear water rises steadily and deliberately around the green stems, its calm surface like a mirror, reflecting the soft hues of pink, pale gold, and lavender against the sky. Tiny, shimmering dragonflies, their iridescent wings, dance and hover in the air between the reeds, their delicate movements adding a touch of life and magic. The combination of the impending tide, the warm, bright lighting, and the classic animation aesthetic creates an overwhelming atmosphere of tranquility and magic.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4741,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000104/group_13/index_9683_seed_27120_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/410_0000104_group_13_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000104_group_13_sample_0_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+411,0.01566351,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01174433,0.00143377,0.00687371,0.79602844,0.57222474,0.07421875,0.00184608,0000147,group_4,2,q3,Does a hand reach into the frame to offer the woman a dark blue passport which she accepts?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a realistic-style scene in a bright, sterile airport check-in area. A woman with thick, shoulder-length blond curls, wearing a crisp white collared shirt that fits her uniform, sits attentively behind a long, matte-gray counter. Her fingers initially move deftly across a black keyboard, her focus fixed on a computer screen just off-screen. She pauses typing, her gaze shifting slightly upward, toward an unseen figure. A hand reaches into the frame, offering her a dark blue passport, which she accepts with steady, practiced movements. Simultaneously, two other people approach from the right side of the frame, walking steadily, just like the next person. The first is a man with neatly combed short brown hair, thin-framed glasses, and a dark gray suit jacket over a light-colored shirt. The second person's face remains invisible, partially visible beside him, their form suggesting a casual posture. The entire scene is illuminated by cool, even overhead fluorescent lights, which reflect off the polished white tile floor, creating a clean, functional atmosphere free of harsh shadows and reinforcing the impersonal efficiency of the modern travel center.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2797,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000147/group_4/index_1124_seed_868_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/411_0000147_group_4_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+412,0.01563111,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01235783,0.00149265,0.00724345,0.75047356,0.51907396,0.08203125,0.00102851,0000147,group_4,3,q3,Does a hand reach into the frame to offer the woman a dark blue passport which she accepts?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a realistic-style scene in a bright, sterile airport check-in area. A woman with thick, shoulder-length blond curls, wearing a crisp white collared shirt that fits her uniform, sits attentively behind a long, matte-gray counter. Her fingers initially move deftly across a black keyboard, her focus fixed on a computer screen just off-screen. She pauses typing, her gaze shifting slightly upward, toward an unseen figure. A hand reaches into the frame, offering her a dark blue passport, which she accepts with steady, practiced movements. Simultaneously, two other people approach from the right side of the frame, walking steadily, just like the next person. The first is a man with neatly combed short brown hair, thin-framed glasses, and a dark gray suit jacket over a light-colored shirt. The second person's face remains invisible, partially visible beside him, their form suggesting a casual posture. The entire scene is illuminated by cool, even overhead fluorescent lights, which reflect off the polished white tile floor, creating a clean, functional atmosphere free of harsh shadows and reinforcing the impersonal efficiency of the modern travel center.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2799,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000147/group_4/index_1124_seed_869_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/412_0000147_group_4_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000147_group_4_sample_3_q3__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000147_group_4_sample_3_q3__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000147_group_4_sample_3_q3__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000147_group_4_sample_3_q3__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000147_group_4_sample_3_q3__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000147_group_4_sample_3_q3__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+413,0.01557232,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01404772,0.00167978,0.00824530,0.67756701,0.42359617,0.12109375,0.00181830,0000042,group_11,0,q5,Is the scene illuminated by golden afternoon sun creating visible beams (Tyndall effect) through the trees?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium-close, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, captures the image in the style of exquisite 3D animation. A princess, with cascading, shimmering golden hair, meticulously braided into intricate plaits and dotted with tiny white flowers and pearls, graces her flawless face with azure eyes filled with tenderness and love. She wears a flowing gown of lavender silk, delicately embroidered at the neckline and cuffs with silver thread, which shimmers subtly in the soft light filtering through the forest canopy. Beside her stands a majestic white steed, its coat as pure as snow, gleaming like pearl in the light. Its muscles are sleek and powerful, its long mane flowing like silk. In the background lies a dreamy forest clearing, its ancient trees blurred beyond the depth of field. The golden afternoon sun, piercing the branches like beams (the Tyndall effect), casts a shadow upon them. The princess slowly stretched out her slender hand, and her fingertips carefully and gently touched the horse's strong and graceful neck. As her palm gently stroked it, the horse lowered its head slightly in comfort and closed its deep and spiritual eyes. The whole scene was shrouded in a quiet, intimate and magical fairy tale atmosphere. Every detail, from the luster of the princess's hair to the texture of the horse's fur, showed the delicacy and perfection of top 3D animation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2885,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000042/group_11/index_9851_seed_19314_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/413_0000042_group_11_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000042_group_11_sample_0_q5__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000042_group_11_sample_0_q5__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000042_group_11_sample_0_q5__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000042_group_11_sample_0_q5__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000042_group_11_sample_0_q5__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000042_group_11_sample_0_q5__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+414,0.01555568,beside-next-to,2.46000000,8,0.01039190,0.00123774,0.00610277,0.78951102,0.57691139,0.06445312,0.00018856,0000127,group_8,2,q1,Is the main subject a man in his early thirties with slightly tousled brown hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera pans right, following a man in his early thirties as he enters a cluttered dining room, the camera at eye level. He has slightly tousled brown hair and wears a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans, his brow furrowed in concentration. He clutches a sleek black tablet in both hands, his gaze fixed on its glowing screen, and walks purposefully toward a large wooden dining table buried beneath piles of books, loose papers, and a tangle of cables. He stops beside the table and carefully places the tablet on a small transparent surface. Then, his eyes scan the chaos, and with quick, decisive action, he picks up a closed silver laptop. He leaves the table and deliberately lowers himself to the hardwood floor, sitting cross-legged with his back against a plain off-white wall. He places the laptop on his lap, opens it, and immediately begins typing rapidly and intently, his face bathed in the cool, bluish-white glow of the screen. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, indirect morning light streaming through a large window, creating an atmosphere of quiet concentration that contrasts sharply with the room's visual chaos.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2425,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000127/group_8/index_3516_seed_21357_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/414_0000127_group_8_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000127_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+415,0.01552940,opposite-across,2.78800000,9,0.01058104,0.00125376,0.00621819,0.73172528,0.45725426,0.10351562,0.00153929,0000009,group_4,1,q4,Is a tablet on the table emitting a bright cool blue digital glow that illuminates the characters' faces and hands?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot depicts a tense, silent confrontation in the hallowed quiet of a wood-paneled academic library. At a large, polished mahogany table, a young man with shaggy black hair leans forward, an impassioned look of frustration written across his face. Wearing a comfortable, dark green cardigan, they repeatedly gesture with their index finger to a tablet on the table. The tablet's screen emits a bright, cool digital glow, casting a stark blue light on their faces and hands, illuminating the complex data charts visible on the display. An older man seated opposite, dressed in a formal dark tweed blazer and a crisp white collared shirt, remains erect, his posture a wall of defiance. His silver-gray hair is impossibly neatly trimmed, his face a mask of resolute misunderstanding. He shakes his head slowly and stubbornly, his lips pressed into a thin line, his gaze deliberately averted, refusing even a glance at the glowing screen. The warm golden light from a classic green-shaded bank lamp on the table illuminates the scene, creating deep shadows that contrast with the cool glow of the tablet, visually emphasizing the generational and ideological clash. The background is filled with tall, dimly lit bookshelves filled with old leather-bound books, creating a heavy academic atmosphere, imbued with the weight of tradition and unspoken disagreements.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,14,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000009/group_4/index_5960_seed_20022_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/415_0000009_group_4_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q4__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q4__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q4__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q4__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q4__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000009_group_4_sample_1_q4__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+416,0.01549551,left-right-pair+between-flanked,5.70400000,3,0.00512719,0.00060732,0.00301325,0.68968427,0.47180957,0.09082031,0.00058672,0000127,group_14,3,q2,"Is one creature a translucent, bell-shaped gelatinous form with black eyes radiating soft azure light?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In Hayao Miyazaki's captivating, hand-drawn Ghibli style, a static, intimate close-up captures a pair of slender, young hands cupped together in a tranquil underwater realm, meticulously detailed. Steadily and deliberately, these hands guide two shy, bioluminescent sea creatures toward each other. One creature nestles in the palm of the left hand, radiating a soft, ethereal azure glow. Its gelatinous body is shaped like a small, translucent bell, with inquisitive black eyes. The other, guided by the gentle fingers of the right hand, radiates a warm golden light. Its form is a slightly intricate, star-shaped droplet that trembles timidly at approach. As the two creatures cautiously approach, their respective radiance intensifies, casting a magical, pulsating glow that illuminates the subtle details of the characters' skin and the shimmering water particles between them. The immediate background is a lush underwater world with soft, painterly textures; out-of-focus, vibrant corals in soft shades of pink and deep purple sway gently, while the tentacles of a large, soft-edged sea anemone ripple in the subtle currents. The scene is primarily illuminated by a magical, blended blue and gold light emanating from the creatures, creating soft highlights and gentle shadows on the hands, enveloping the moment in an atmosphere of pure, quietly enchanting beauty and capturing a profound sense of wonder through the sheer tenderness of the movement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4642,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000127/group_14/index_9417_seed_17264_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/416_0000127_group_14_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000127_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000127_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000127_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000127_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000127_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000127_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+417,0.01548088,left-right-pair,3.72000000,3,0.00787220,0.00093435,0.00462523,0.84284294,0.48739338,0.12500000,0.00006792,0000106,group_11,3,q4,"Is the environment a vast, desolate battlefield with cracked yellow earth, visible smoke, dust, and tattered flags?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"fixed, medium-long shot, captured from a slightly upward angle in the style of documentary photography, captures an ancient general clad in weathered iron scale armor, slowly advancing from the right side of the frame to the left. The dim afterglow of the setting sun slants down from the sky, casting long shadows on the cracked yellow earth, silhouetted against the general and his horse. The general wears an iron helmet with a long red tassel. His face, weathered and dust-stained, stares piercingly ahead. His armor, composed of countless plates, is covered in scratches and dark rust, while the crimson battle robe beneath it sways slightly in the wind. He holds the reins firmly in one hand, the other on the hilt of the ancient sword at his waist, his posture erect and unwavering, even on horseback. The muscles of his black warhorse bulge beneath him, its coat matted to a dull sheen from a mixture of sweat and dust. Each heavy thump of the horse's hooves stirs up a small plume of yellow dust. The backdrop is a vast, desolate battlefield, the air thick with visible smoke and dust. Tattered flags flutter feebly in the wind, and in the distance, the outlines of broken weapons and fallen chariots are faintly visible. The dominant tones of the painting are earthy ochre and the gray-black of iron. The deep red of the general's robe and helmet tassel serve as solemn embellishments, creating an epic atmosphere of postwar desolation, tragic grandeur, and yet filled with tenacious strength.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3179,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000106/group_11/index_5700_seed_13741_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/417_0000106_group_11_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000106_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000106_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000106_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000106_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000106_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000106_group_11_sample_3_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+418,0.01547490,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01319899,0.00156588,0.00775541,0.80586416,0.50394326,0.10253906,0.00223029,0000050,group_14,0,q3,"Is a general wearing a heavy, worn suit of dark red metal armor with beastly patterns visible?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly but steadily advances, drawing the viewer's attention into a spacious military tent. The only illumination comes from the flickering flame of a candle in an antique bronze candlestick at the corner of the table, its unsteady glow casting large, oscillating shadows on the thick canvas walls. A general with a ruddy complexion and a thick, black beard leans over a rough wooden marching table. He wears a heavy, worn suit of dark red metal armor, the beastly patterns carved on his shoulder plates reflecting a dull luster in the firelight. His furrowed brow carves a deep, crisscross pattern on his forehead, and his hawk-like eyes stare intently at a yellowed parchment map spread out on the table. The map's intricate, ink-lined outlines of mountains, rivers, and military markings appear intricate. His gaze wasn't static, but moved slowly and carefully between several key red markers on the map. His hands, braced on the edge of the table, their knuckles white from exertion. His entire posture exuded strength and focus. The flickering candlelight cast bright highlights on his high cheekbones and nose, while deepening the shadows of his eye sockets and cheeks, adding depth to his resolute expression. The entire scene was warm and deep, imbued with ochre, brown, and dark gold, creating an atmosphere of solemnity and intense tension as a decision-maker grappled alone on the eve of a crucial battle.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,533,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000050/group_14/index_2691_seed_20352_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/418_0000050_group_14_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000050_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000050_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000050_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000050_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000050_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000050_group_14_sample_0_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+419,0.01547267,foreground-background,3.08000000,5,0.00896262,0.00107012,0.00526167,0.69875216,0.49872476,0.07226562,0.00031838,0000043,group_2,3,q2,Is the first man wearing a navy wool blazer with a crisp white shirt cuff visible?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium close-up, captured in exquisite high-frame-rate slow motion, establishes the hushed atmosphere of mutual success in a luxurious, wood-paneled bar. The static camera focuses on two well-dressed men gently bumping fists against the polished, dark-wood bartop. The first man, seen from the forearm down, wears the crisp white cuff of a shirt peeking from the sleeve of a well-tailored navy wool blazer. The second man, his wrist adorned with a classic gold watch, extends his hand from the sleeve of a charcoal-gray blazer. Their knuckles connect with soft, deliberate precision, the slow motion emphasizing the controlled and respectful nature of the celebratory act. In the immediate foreground, slightly out of focus, rests a crystal cognac decanter, its wide bowl filled with rich amber liquid that swirls gracefully with a syrupy consistency, capturing the warm, focused glow of a low-hanging lamp. The background blends into a soft bokeh, composed of deep, lustrous mahogany panels and backlit bottles of premium spirits in the distance, creating a refined and intimate setting. The entire scene is bathed in warm, understated lighting that casts long shadows and highlights the rich textures of wood, fabric and swirling cognac, perfectly embodying a refined, understated moment of celebration.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4287,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000043/group_2/index_1909_seed_12457_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/419_0000043_group_2_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000043_group_2_sample_3_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000043_group_2_sample_3_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000043_group_2_sample_3_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000043_group_2_sample_3_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000043_group_2_sample_3_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000043_group_2_sample_3_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+420,0.01545450,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01668406,0.00200879,0.00978352,0.57037723,0.35106999,0.16308594,0.00230002,0000068,group_5,2,q5,"Are the man's eyes wide, eyebrows slightly furrowed, and lips parted in an expression of confusion?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Cinematographically captured in Steve McCurry's signature style, a static medium close-up captures a decisive moment from a level perspective. With a violent jolt from the aging train, a weathered South Asian man in his forties jolted awake from his window seat. Brilliant golden morning light, acting as a powerful backlight, penetrated the scratched and dusty windowpanes, casting a dazzling golden halo around his tousled black curls and shoulders, illuminating even the fine dust particles floating in the air like beams of light, a Tyndall effect. He wore a faded crimson cotton kurta, and every wrinkle on his face was etched in the dramatic light. His eyes widened in the instant of awakening, his thick eyebrows slightly furrowed, his lips parted. His gaze, filled with the confusion and disorientation of someone forcibly plucked from a deep dream, stared straight ahead at the empty space. The entire picture is enveloped in warm tones, with saturated red and golden light interwoven, forming a sharp contrast between the bumpy dynamic background and the momentary stillness and confusion of the characters, creating a documentary atmosphere that is both tranquil and full of inner tension, as if time has been frozen at this moment, filled with a sense of unspoken story.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2074,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000068/group_5/index_5640_seed_9438_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/420_0000068_group_5_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000068_group_5_sample_2_q5__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000068_group_5_sample_2_q5__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000068_group_5_sample_2_q5__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000068_group_5_sample_2_q5__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000068_group_5_sample_2_q5__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000068_group_5_sample_2_q5__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+421,0.01545055,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01346473,0.00162306,0.00789444,0.69293249,0.51008475,0.06250000,0.00054029,0000078,group_15,0,q3,"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focuses squarely on the awed face of a young woman dressed in traditional shrine maiden garb. She stands quietly at the wooden steps of an ancient shrine, her long, flowing, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband, strands brushing against her fair cheeks in the night breeze. The cool moonlight frames her delicate profile. Her head tilted slightly, her lips parted in wonder, her eyes, as clear as deep pools, gaze at the abyss of the night sky. Within these eyes, a magnificent meteor shower is perfectly reflected: countless fleeting, slender, brilliant arcs of silver light streak across her pupils, slightly dilated with concentration, as if the entire galaxy were ablaze in her gaze. Her pristine white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama take on a solemn yet soft quality in the dim light, while the shrine's architectural outlines and hanging stone lanterns behind her are completely blurred, transforming into a dreamy, softly shimmering backdrop composed of warm yellow dots. The entire image, shrouded in profound tranquility, exudes a sacred and ethereal beauty of classical Oriental beauty, capturing a poetic moment of dialogue between humanity and the universe.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4843,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000078/group_15/index_4060_seed_5018_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/421_0000078_group_15_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000078_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000078_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000078_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000078_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000078_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000078_group_15_sample_0_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+422,0.01541162,beside-next-to+between-flanked,3.84400000,3,0.00840257,0.00098892,0.00494244,0.72339326,0.41392535,0.14648438,0.00084794,0000132,group_7,0,q4,Does the scene include a vast river reflecting a bright full moon with rolling hills in the misty distance?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, zoomed-out shot, starting from a slightly upward angle, first focuses on a massive bluestone by the river, bathed in moonlight. The great Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai reclines, half-drunk and intoxicated. His long, dark hair, undone by a bun, a few wet strands clinging to his drunken face. His features are rendered with remarkable clarity by the cool moonlight. He wears a flowing white silk robe with wide sleeves, the collar slightly open, revealing faint stains of dark wine on the folds. The hem of the robe falls limply on the mossy stone surface. His eyes are lightly closed, a faint, detached smile playing on his lips. His body is relaxed, his chest rising and falling with his deep, steady breathing. Beside him, an antique bronze wine jug has fallen, half-emptied between the moist moss and soil. The last drops of wine seem to linger on the mouth, reflecting a faint glow in the moonlight. As the camera steadily and deliberately pulls back, a wider scene is revealed: the vast river, like a vast black jade in the still night, a bright full moon casts a clear glow in the sky, spreading a fragmented, shimmering silver band across the water. In the distance, the inky silhouettes of rolling hills shrouded in mist. Nearby, a few clumps of reeds sway gently in the night breeze, rustling softly. The entire scene exudes a sense of ultimate tranquility and poetic solitude. The dominant color palette is deep blue-black and silver-white, and the strong contrast of light and shadow creates an otherworldly, classical aesthetic atmosphere of detachment from the world.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2606,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000132/group_7/index_6699_seed_26356_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/422_0000132_group_7_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q4__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q4__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q4__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q4__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q4__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000132_group_7_sample_0_q4__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+423,0.01540233,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01064187,0.00129259,0.00623286,0.90039468,0.66526288,0.07226562,0.00031459,0000023,group_12,0,q3,Is the Xuan-Yuan Sword held in both hands and radiating a warm golden glow?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera begins with a magnificent 3D panorama, slowly but steadily circling a lonely mountaintop shrouded in a raging thunderstorm. Atop this peak, constructed of sharp obsidian, stands the guardian of the Xuan-Yuan Sword, clad in a dark metal armor inscribed with ancient runes. Each plate is intricately carved, and the runes glow faintly yet resolutely in the dim light. A raging wind whips his long, jet-black hair and tattered cloak, while icy rain streams down his resolute face. He clutches the legendary Xuan-Yuan Sword in both hands, its blade radiating a warm golden glow that stands in stark contrast to the surrounding darkness. His gaze, blazing, is fixed fixed on the sky—where, torn open by a supernatural force, a vast, irregular rift has been formed, its edges ablaze with chaotic flames of purplish red and deep blue. From this rift, a nameless Chaos beast slowly and relentlessly emerges. Its vast form is composed of swirling shadows, stardust, and countless twisting tentacles, and countless crimson eyes open and close within its ever-shifting form. Each time lightning streaks across the sky, it momentarily illuminates the yawning confrontation between mortal and god, casting the tiny yet unyielding figure of the guardian and the towering silhouette of the beast against the slippery rock. The entire scene, with its extremely rich detail and pristine texture, creates an atmosphere of epic tragedy and resolution.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2922,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000023/group_12/index_8787_seed_16558_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/423_0000023_group_12_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000023_group_12_sample_0_q3__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000023_group_12_sample_0_q3__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000023_group_12_sample_0_q3__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000023_group_12_sample_0_q3__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000023_group_12_sample_0_q3__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000023_group_12_sample_0_q3__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+424,0.01538043,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01242157,0.00149261,0.00728597,0.72531796,0.50328189,0.09179688,0.00097352,0000145,group_7,1,q3,"Are dark sunglasses visible on the character's face, obscuring his eyes?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium-close, static shot, composed with a strong diagonal composition, employs a pronounced tilt (Dutch angle) to create a sense of tension and unease. The entire image is rendered in a refined animation style, characterized by clean lines and saturated yet restrained colors. At the center of the frame is a mysterious male character, dressed in a well-tailored, pure black suit with a subtle silky sheen, paired with a pure white shirt, meticulously buttoned at the collar. A pair of dark sunglasses, almost completely obscuring his eyes, perch on his high nose, their lenses reflecting the blurred, unrecognizable city lights. His chiseled jawline is taut. He appears to be inside a high-rise building, with a massive floor-to-ceiling window in the background, revealing a bird's-eye view of the city at night. Myriad neon lights and traffic converge into a blurry, radiant sea of cool tones. The bluish-violet light from the window serves as the primary source of light, creating a sharp rim light on the shoulders of his suit and the contours of his face, heightening the image's dramatic quality. He first remained still for a moment, his shoulders drooping slightly, then his chest rose and fell slowly, he lowered his head slightly, and exhaled a long, silent breath from between his lips. This subtle movement was full of heavy fatigue, which contrasted sharply with his cold appearance, creating an atmosphere of loneliness, mystery and inner pressure.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,942,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000145/group_7/index_3975_seed_5502_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/424_0000145_group_7_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000145_group_7_sample_1_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+425,0.01535064,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.01510092,0.00180195,0.00886598,0.80540311,0.48643193,0.10742188,0.00029927,0000095,group_3,0,q3,Is the character wearing dark gym shorts with white bandages on his hands that are partially untied and dangling?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot, framed with documentary-style realism, captures a weary champion sitting perfectly centered on a worn wooden bench in a desolate, silent locker room. His sweat-dampened black hair clings to his forehead, his muscular shoulders slump with exhaustion, and a simple white towel hangs from his neck. He wears only a pair of dark gym shorts, and the white bandages on his hands are partially untied, dangling loosely. His face, etched with the physical toll of his victory, is a mask of exhaustion; his gaze is unfocused and glassy, staring past the camera into an unseen distance. Beside him, a massive, gleaming golden trophy sits on the bench, close yet pointedly overlooked, its polished surface catching the cold, sterile light from a single overhead fluorescent bulb, casting a bright, almost mocking reflection against the drab, gray concrete walls and the recessed metal lockers that line the room. He took a slow, deep breath, barely lifting his chest, and then let out a deliberately heavy, audible sigh, as if draining away the last of his energy, his body slumping further. The cheers of victory were a forgotten echo, replaced by the deep, hollow emptiness of the silent room and the grim reality of victory's consequences.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4108,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000095/group_3/index_6580_seed_12487_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/425_0000095_group_3_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000095_group_3_sample_0_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+426,0.01533436,beside-next-to,0.77700000,6,0.03282639,0.00389481,0.01928773,0.83156163,0.54311818,0.09667969,0.00249150,0000007,group_14,1,q5,Are both the man and woman holding fishing rods with their lines in the water and buoys bobbing motionlessly?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"sweeping wide shot begins, the camera slowly and steadily panning from left to right across the tranquil surface of a lake at sunrise. A soft mist hovers above the water, capturing the sun's first rays and painting the horizon in a stunning gradient of soft pink, warm orange, and deep purple, all perfectly reflected in the still water. The camera's movement pauses, focusing on a weathered wooden dock where an elderly couple sits. The man, with silver-white hair and friendly wrinkles etched around his eyes, wears a faded plaid flannel shirt over a practical khaki fishing vest. He sits on a simple wooden box, gripping an old-fashioned fishing rod with a steady, practiced hand. His wife sits beside him, their shoulders almost touching, her soft gray hair pulled back in a loose bun, a cozy cream-colored knitted shawl wrapped around her shoulders. She also holds a fishing rod, her posture relaxed and her expression calm. Their lines disappear into the water, their buoys bobbing motionlessly, the only distraction from the perfect reflection. Their shared silence was not empty but fulfilling, a comfortable quiet that spoke of a lifetime together, creating an overall atmosphere of profound peace, nostalgia and tranquility, of unspoken love.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,914,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000007/group_14/index_6545_seed_5514_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/426_0000007_group_14_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q5__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q5__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q5__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q5__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q5__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000007_group_14_sample_1_q5__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+427,0.01532922,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01182991,0.00139955,0.00695357,0.84405160,0.54946232,0.09667969,0.00220451,0000160,group_10,1,q4,Is the background a sun-drenched meadow with tall green grass and scattered yellow wildflowers?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium close-up depicts a man with a neatly trimmed dark brown beard, wearing a heather-gray cotton short-sleeved shirt and a dark blue baseball cap. He stands in the center of a sun-drenched meadow, the soft-focus background revealing tall green grass and scattered yellow wildflowers in the warm, golden afternoon light. His gaze is intently directed downward at a small metal ring delicately held between the thumb and index finger of each hand. He carefully wipes away specks of dark dirt from the surface, his lips moving as he speaks, narrating his actions with an air of focused discovery. He fluidly turns his head momentarily to the left, as if to greet someone off-screen, before quickly returning his gaze to the precious object in his hands, his expression a mixture of concentration and quiet excitement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3503,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000160/group_10/index_3321_seed_14242_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/427_0000160_group_10_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000160_group_10_sample_1_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+428,0.01531681,left-right-pair,4.44000000,6,0.00576497,0.00068531,0.00338644,0.82850552,0.57704616,0.07421875,0.00122404,0000156,group_15,0,q1,"Is the subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, wavy black hair?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, high-angle, medium-close-up captures a young Southeast Asian man with thick, wavy black hair, absorbed in quiet reflection. He sits at a richly textured wooden table, leaning slightly forward, maintaining a posture of intense concentration. He wears a soft, cream-colored linen shirt, its texture visible in the warm light. Golden hour sunlight streams through an unseen window to his right, bathing one side of his face in brilliant light and casting long, soft shadows across the scene, illuminating the dancing dust particles in the air. His dark eyes stare at the pages of a worn, leather-bound journal, open before him. His left hand steadying the cream-colored, textured paper, his right hand carefully guiding a classic fountain pen with a polished dark barrel and silver nib. The pen glides smoothly and deliberately across the page, leaving a trail of dark ink. His pensive expression—a slightly furrowed brow and soft lips—conveys a profound inner dialogue. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a cozy, book-lined study. This, combined with the warm color palette and focused silence of the action, creates an atmosphere of profound tranquility and introspection.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3021,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000156/group_15/index_751_seed_33217_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/428_0000156_group_15_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q1__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q1__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q1__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q1__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q1__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000156_group_15_sample_0_q1__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+429,0.01526817,beside-next-to,1.74000000,2,0.01535185,0.00185058,0.00900084,0.77590162,0.52256113,0.08984375,0.00263286,0000118,group_14,3,q2,Does the gloved hand glide across a pristine white cotton sheet to smooth out wrinkles?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"An extreme close-up focuses on a hand, clad in a thin, pale blue butyl glove, its fingers clasped together as it steadily and deliberately glides across the surface of a sheet of pristine white cotton. The camera captures the fabric's microscopic texture as the gloved hand meticulously smooths out the last faint wrinkles, rendering the sheet perfectly taut and flawless. As the motion is complete, the camera begins a slow, seamless pullback, gradually widening the frame. The shot reveals the entirety of the empty hospital bed, its metal side rails lowered and its frame constructed of cool brushed steel. The pullback continues, transitioning into a wide shot that reveals the surroundings of the sterile, silent room. The floor is a polished, light gray linen, faintly reflecting the harsh, even fluorescent light from overhead. The walls are a pale, institutional seaweed green, save for a single, silent IV stand standing beside the bed. The atmosphere is one of heavy clinical silence, a profound sense of order and cleanliness, creating a tranquil yet somber mood, impersonal and prepared.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4702,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000118/group_14/index_2314_seed_5813_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/429_0000118_group_14_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000118_group_14_sample_3_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000118_group_14_sample_3_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000118_group_14_sample_3_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000118_group_14_sample_3_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000118_group_14_sample_3_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000118_group_14_sample_3_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+430,0.01526092,beside-next-to,2.46000000,8,0.01128474,0.00135421,0.00662035,0.75398731,0.49510035,0.09570312,0.00310862,0000024,group_6,1,q2,Is a young man with short brown hair wearing a heather-gray cotton T-shirt visible?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera begins with a medium shot at eye level, slowly and steadily panning to the right, following the action in a brightly lit modern kitchen. A young man with neatly combed short brown hair and wearing a soft, heather-gray cotton T-shirt leans slightly over a gleaming stainless steel sink. Steady in both hands, he holds a small, rectangular glass fish tank under a modern, gooseneck chrome faucet, a stream of clear water filling it. With serene concentration, he watches the water level rise. When it's nearly full, he deftly turns the faucet handle with his right hand, and the flow abruptly stops. Then, he carefully lifts the now-heavy tank, the water sloshing gently inside, and turns his body toward the adjacent, sleek, light-gray crystal countertop. The camera pan ends as he deliberately and quietly sets the tank down. After a brief pause, his gaze shifts, and he carefully picks up a small fishing net with a delicate green mesh and a thin metal handle, which has been placed next to the tank. The entire scene is bathed in bright, indirect morning light, streaming in through an invisible window, creating soft shadows that accentuate the clean lines of the white subway tile backsplash, creating an atmosphere of quiet, focused communality and gentle preparation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,594,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000024/group_6/index_1762_seed_1222_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/430_0000024_group_6_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000024_group_6_sample_1_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+431,0.01523240,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.07200000,4,0.00489157,0.00059271,0.00286590,0.70194703,0.44605651,0.10253906,0.00003591,0000105,group_14,1,q4,"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium close-up shot from a level angle, slightly handheld and imbued with a subtle sense of shakiness, instantly draws the viewer into the bustling and vibrant atmosphere of a wet market. At the center of the frame is an elderly woman with a wrinkled face and graying hair tied in a simple bun. Time has carved deep grooves into her tanned skin, but her eyes are remarkably sharp and focused. She wears a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock, the fabric defined by its distinct texture and soft creases from repeated washing. Standing before a vegetable stall piled high with vibrant greens, carrots dusted with fresh soil, and plump tomatoes, she leans forward slightly, extending her age-freckled right hand. With her index and middle fingers, she decisively indicates a price, her lips pursed as she speaks rapidly and forcefully to the vendor off-screen. In her left hand, she clutches a woven bamboo basket, its edges frayed. The tarpaulin overhead casts dappled shadows, while a few suspended incandescent bulbs emit a warm, dim glow, illuminating the dust and moisture floating in the air and creating a stark contrast between the vibrant colors of the vegetables and the dark clothing of the elderly woman. The entire scene, shrouded in warm tones, exudes an atmosphere both tense and full of life, perfectly capturing the uncompromising moments of everyday transactions.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1223,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_8676_seed_3867_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/431_0000105_group_14_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+432,0.01518738,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01182530,0.00142491,0.00693359,0.81094724,0.58710307,0.07421875,0.00211263,0000166,group_5,3,q3,Does the scene take place in a turbulent sky swirling with dark storm clouds?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"magnificent 360-degree slow-motion shot, shot from a slightly upward perspective, captures the epic battle between two mythical phoenixes amidst a turbulent sky swirling with dark storm clouds. One phoenix is composed entirely of flowing magma and incandescent fire, each feather a pure, pulsating crimson and gold flame. Its eyes are like blazing embers, and its flight leaves a dazzling trail of sparks and embers in its wake. The other phoenix, in stark contrast, is carved from translucent ice crystals, its feathers razor-sharp icicles gleaming with sapphire and cyan. Its wings, with their beats, scatter countless tiny, glittering frost particles, and its icy eyes are like distant stars. The camera smoothly rotates around them, capturing every detail as they swirl, dive, and claw at each other in a deadly aerial ballet: the fire phoenix folds its wings sharply, swooping down like a flaming meteor, while the ice phoenix gracefully sideways, blocking with the edge of its crystal wings. When the camera rotates to the optimal angle, the two divine birds have a fierce head-on collision. The burning feathers collide with the icy feathers, and a dazzling energy shock wave instantly erupts - the hot sparks hiss and turn into steam when they come into contact with the cold air, while the hard ice crystals explode into countless glittering fragments under the high temperature, intertwined with the falling and extinguished flame feathers, forming a destructive picture full of primitive power and magnificent beauty. The whole scene, with the extreme contrast of warm and cold colors, creates a tense, intense and sacred fantasy atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3923,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000166/group_5/index_6042_seed_32802_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/432_0000166_group_5_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000166_group_5_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000166_group_5_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000166_group_5_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000166_group_5_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000166_group_5_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000166_group_5_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+433,0.01517971,beside-next-to,2.10000000,5,0.01543062,0.00183846,0.00906144,0.66880882,0.38968605,0.14941406,0.00028986,0000045,group_1,3,q3,"Does the video show the child knocking on a dark wooden door, followed by the door opening to reveal a gray-haired woman in a knit cardigan handing candies to the child?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, medium-length tracking shot from the side captures a young child walking down a quiet suburban street at night. He's completely enveloped in an oversized, fuzzy, bright orange pumpkin Halloween costume, with only a small, green felt stem playfully jutting from the collar like a cap. His childish face, framed by fluffy brown hair, peeks out from the costume's opening, brimming with anticipation. In one hand, he carefully holds a real carved jack-o'-lantern, its warm, flickering LED lights shimmering through its cutout eyes and mouth, casting dancing shadows on the sidewalk. In the other, he firmly grasps the handle of a smaller, plastic pumpkin-shaped candy basket. The camera steadily follows his unsteady steps, past several neighboring homes similarly adorned with glowing jack-o'-lanterns and spooky ornaments, finally stopping in front of a house with a warm, illuminated porch light, and shifting to a steady shot. The child stands on tiptoe and, with a firm, small fist, knocks on the dark wooden door. A moment later, the door opened inward, revealing a kindly, gray-haired woman in a cozy knit cardigan, a warm smile radiating from her face. Her eyes narrowed at the sight of the little pumpkin, and she grabbed a handful of colorful candies from a large bowl near the door. The child looked up at her, his eyes wide with excitement. Quickly and joyfully, he raised his pumpkin basket. The woman smiled and gently placed the candies into the basket, creating a delightful clinking sound. The child's face lit up with a brilliant smile, and the entire scene was filled with pure joy and a warm, festive atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,676,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000045/group_1/index_2469_seed_31821_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/433_0000045_group_1_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000045_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000045_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000045_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000045_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000045_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000045_group_1_sample_3_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+434,0.01514594,beside-next-to,2.10000000,5,0.01323271,0.00157893,0.00776919,0.81273890,0.49087191,0.10937500,0.00021550,0000117,group_9,2,q3,Is the scene illuminated primarily by a bronze oil lamp casting warm yellow light and deep shadows?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a thin, middle-aged strategist with a neatly trimmed goatee, nestled within a dimly lit military tent. He wears a loose, flowing dark blue silk robe, his long hair held back with a simple wooden hairpin. He reclines leisurely on an antique carved wooden chair. The only illumination comes from a bronze oil lamp on a table beside him. Its flickering, warm yellow light casts deep, undulating shadows on his face, emphasizing his pensive expression and illuminating the folds of his silk robe with a soft sheen. In his right hand, he grasps a feather fan made of pure white crane feathers, gently waving it with a steady, leisurely rhythm, the breeze occasionally causing the lamplight to flicker. In the background, a military map hangs on the thick dark canvas tent wall, and a wooden weapons rack with unfolded bamboo slips and weapons can be vaguely seen next to it. The whole scene has a warm tone, mainly deep dark colors, creating an atmosphere of extreme concentration, tranquility and strategic planning against the backdrop of military tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3123,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000117/group_9/index_9345_seed_1225_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/434_0000117_group_9_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000117_group_9_sample_2_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+435,0.01510003,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01225923,0.00145534,0.00720260,0.75376695,0.48914742,0.09375000,0.00167090,0000066,group_8,2,q1,Is the main subject an elderly craftsman with thinning silver hair and a deeply lined face?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady medium shot, shot from a slightly overhead angle, draws the viewer's attention to an elderly craftsman. His face, etched with age and deeply lined with wrinkles, his eyes narrowed in intense concentration beneath his thinning silver hair. He wears a washed-out, dark blue cotton double-breasted jacket and sits hunched over a heavy wooden workbench covered with sawdust and various carving tools. His left hand, calloused yet remarkably steady, carefully supports a rudimentary wooden sculpture—perhaps a small bird—while his right grips a sharp carving knife. The knife's tip gleams coldly in the warm light of a low-hanging tungsten bulb above the workbench. With his steady, precise movements, a thin, cicada-wing-thin shavings slowly curl and fall, drifting into the pile of sawdust piled on the workbench. This concentrated light not only illuminates the delicate work in his hands, but also casts deep shadows on his focused profile and rough hands, forming a strong contrast between light and dark and the dim, messy but orderly workshop in the background. The whole picture is immersed in an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration and a sense of time.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4218,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000066/group_8/index_9877_seed_31823_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/435_0000066_group_8_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000066_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000066_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000066_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000066_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000066_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000066_group_8_sample_2_q1__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+436,0.01508254,left-right-pair+beside-next-to,7.38000000,8,0.00434209,0.00052234,0.00254650,0.65107083,0.41434848,0.13867188,0.00186652,0000062,group_15,3,q4,Is a transparent observation window visible at the base of a tower showing white plant roots in nutrient solution?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"An immersive first-person camera advances at a slow and steady pace through a narrow corridor formed by towering hydroponic towers constructed of white composite materials. The scene is bathed in a soft, Vermeer-esque sidelight, pouring down from high on the left, illuminating each broad, fresh green leaf with an almost translucent quality. The delicate veins and shimmering water droplets on the leaves are clearly visible, imbuing them with vibrant life. This light also casts long, soft shadows on the right-hand tower wall and the ground. My gaze slowly descends, finally focusing on the base of one of the towers, where a transparent observation window reveals a tangled network of white plant roots immersed in nutrient solution. Right next to the root system, a small, floating holographic screen emitting soft blue light is flashing a real-time updated stream of life data - a heartbeat-like waveform and constantly changing numbers. My eyes are carefully and attentively inspecting it. The whole picture combines the precision of future technology with the tranquil aesthetics of classical painting, creating an atmosphere of focus, tranquility and hope.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,868,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000062/group_15/index_6641_seed_21719_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/436_0000062_group_15_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000062_group_15_sample_3_q4__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000062_group_15_sample_3_q4__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000062_group_15_sample_3_q4__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000062_group_15_sample_3_q4__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000062_group_15_sample_3_q4__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000062_group_15_sample_3_q4__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+437,0.01502547,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.01653226,0.00195343,0.00971922,0.64485270,0.41312236,0.12890625,0.00068033,0000169,group_5,2,q2,Do four of the men wear blue shirts in varying shades while one man wears a blue T-shirt over a long-sleeved shirt with yellow and black horizontal stripes on his arm?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a euphoric moment as five men stand shoulder to shoulder, their arms intertwined in a powerful display of camaraderie. The group's skin tones range from fair to olive to dark brown, with a variety of hair colors and styles, including short blond, curly black, and straight dark brown. Four of the men wear blue shirts in varying shades and styles (from navy to royal), creating a sense of solidarity. A man near the center breaks the pattern by wearing a blue T-shirt over a long-sleeved shirt, with bold yellow and black horizontal stripes running down his visible arm. To the left of the frame, a man sports two simple yet thick stripes of face paint—one blue, one white—applied vertically across his left cheek. The five men collectively cheer, their heads tilted slightly back, their mouths wide open in genuine, eyebrow-raising smiles. They are posed indoors in a cozy, warmly lit room, with ambient light from an off-camera source accentuating their ecstatic expressions. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a casual living space without distracting from the subject, focusing the entire picture on the palpable atmosphere of victory celebration and deep-rooted friendship.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1127,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000169/group_5/index_5612_seed_33202_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/437_0000169_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q2__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q2__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q2__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q2__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q2__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000169_group_5_sample_2_q2__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+438,0.01500357,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.01062866,0.00128598,0.00622845,0.71746099,0.51346081,0.07714844,0.00013107,0000027,group_6,0,q4,Does the scene include ancient Hui-style buildings with whitewashed walls and black tiles?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, long, dynamic tracking shot follows a knight as he rides a majestic black steed at full speed along an ancient bluestone path. The knight is clad in a deep blue, coarse linen robe, its sleeves and hem dancing wildly in the wind. His hair is tied up in a high bun, strands of it rustling against his resolute face. He leans forward slightly, one hand firmly gripping the reins, the scabbard of the longsword at his waist swaying rhythmically with the horse's jerk. Beneath his steed, its muscles bulging, its glossy fur shimmering in the light. Its hooves fly, their collisions with the bluestone pavement sending up dust and scattered sparks. They speed past a cluster of ancient, pristine Hui-style buildings. The whitewashed walls and black tiles appear remarkably tranquil in the warm twilight. The staggered, undulating horse-head walls create a rhythmic skyline, while details of carved wooden window lattices flash by in the rapid movement. The afterglow of the setting sun dyes the entire picture with a warm golden color, lengthening the shadows of the buildings and the riders, creating a desolate and classical martial arts style atmosphere full of heroic spirit, with a strong contrast between movement and stillness.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2909,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000027/group_6/index_544_seed_3825_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/438_0000027_group_6_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000027_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000027_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000027_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000027_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000027_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000027_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+439,0.01498684,foreground-background,2.72800000,3,0.01150782,0.00135794,0.00676658,0.64280003,0.40840438,0.13476562,0.00034952,0000165,group_6,0,q4,Does the mantis slowly rotate its triangular head with large multi-faceted eyes to track something off-screen?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, extreme macro shot immerses the viewer in a mysterious nocturnal world, focusing with piercing clarity on a vibrant praying mantis occupying the foreground. The creature's body is a stunning canvas of color: its primary exoskeleton is a vibrant emerald green with a subtle waxy sheen, while its upper thorax and wing casings are adorned with intricate petal-like patterns of pure white and delicate pink. It perches on the edge of a large, black leaf, shimmering with tiny dewdrops. The mantis stalks its unseen prey with intense focus; its triangular head, dominated by large, multi-faceted eyes, rotates with meticulous slowness to track something off-screen. The entire scene is bathed in cool, low-key lighting, creating a color scheme of deep blue and velvety purple, casting the out-of-focus background of lush foliage into shadow and mystery. As the mantis prepares to move, it stealthily raises one of its serrated front legs, a movement so slow and deliberate as to be almost imperceptible, heightening the palpable tension and predatory focus of its nocturnal hunt.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,388,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000165/group_6/index_9009_seed_15530_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/439_0000165_group_6_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000165_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000165_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000165_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000165_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000165_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000165_group_6_sample_0_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+440,0.01497060,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.01050228,0.00127092,0.00615424,0.74648279,0.52887547,0.08105469,0.00071758,0000062,group_11,1,q5,Is the setting the entrance to a courtyard featuring a mottled grey brick wall and a tightly closed vermilion gate with a gleaming copper ring?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The shot begins with a slow, drawn-out shot, focusing in extreme close-up on a dark, solid wooden plaque hanging high above. The plaque's surface is coated with thick black lacquer, embodying a mellow patina gleaming with age. Carved upon it are powerful, bold characters in a flamboyant, cursive script. The grooves between the characters are filled with gold, reflecting a warm and solemn glow in the soft, slanting afternoon sunlight. As the camera steadily and slowly pulls back, the plaque and the surrounding structures gradually emerge. We see an elderly man with silver hair and a gaunt face standing quietly beneath the plaque. He wears a traditional dark gray, double-breasted cotton and linen jacket. His hands are clasped behind his back, his body leaning back slightly, his head tilted back, his gaze fixed and reverently fixed on the calligraphy masterpiece above him. His wrinkled eyes reveal a look of deep admiration and nostalgia. The setting is the entrance to a quaint courtyard, framed by a mottled grey brick wall and a tightly closed vermilion gate. The copper ring on the door gleams with a patina in the light. Sunlight filters through the sparse branches of a nearby old locust tree, casting flickering shadows on the ground and walls. The warm tones of the painting create an atmosphere of tranquility, nostalgia, and a rich cultural heritage.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2687,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000062/group_11/index_8771_seed_26395_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/440_0000062_group_11_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000062_group_11_sample_1_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000062_group_11_sample_1_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000062_group_11_sample_1_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000062_group_11_sample_1_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000062_group_11_sample_1_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000062_group_11_sample_1_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+441,0.01496097,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01137658,0.00140586,0.00664715,0.83433294,0.61592168,0.07226562,0.00256258,0000142,group_12,0,q4,Is the environment an inky black abyss containing craggy volcanic rocks and ghostly deep-sea plants?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide, slow-motion pan shot, shot from a slight upward angle, captures a giant octopus gliding effortlessly through the deep, inky abyss of the ocean floor. The behemoth's skin, far from the texture of flesh and blood, is a living, fluid display, a constantly shifting pattern of intricate bioluminescent hues of electric blue, neon purple, and magenta. As if streams of data are coursing beneath its surface, it creates a vibrant, digital art-like sheen. Its large, intelligent eyes radiate a soft golden glow, a striking contrast to the kaleidoscopic hues of its body. It propels itself through the rhythmic, powerful contraction and expansion of its vast mantle, while its eight long, powerful tentacles gracefully undulate behind it like silken ribbons in a hypnotic, coordinated dance, their suction cups pulsing with faint light. Its own light, the sole source of illumination in this inky black world, casts an ethereal, shifting light on the craggy volcanic rocks and occasional ghostly deep-sea plants below. Tiny particles floating in the water are illuminated like shimmering stardust. An otherworldly sense of tranquility and awe permeates the entire scene, seamlessly blending the grandeur of nature with a digital aesthetic to create a visual spectacle that is both mysterious and breathtaking.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1389,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000142/group_12/index_2489_seed_5418_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/441_0000142_group_12_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000142_group_12_sample_0_q4__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000142_group_12_sample_0_q4__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000142_group_12_sample_0_q4__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000142_group_12_sample_0_q4__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000142_group_12_sample_0_q4__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000142_group_12_sample_0_q4__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+442,0.01496009,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.01365457,0.00168176,0.00798187,0.79989111,0.56546730,0.08593750,0.00172079,0000015,group_10,0,q3,"Does the elder perform Tai Chi movements with slow, powerful starts, shifting weight between legs and tracing graceful arm arcs?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"dolly-in shot begins in the distance and slowly moves forward. On a misty morning, atop the ancient Great Wall, an elder with youthful white hair and a flowing white beard, clad in a loose, white silk Tai Chi suit, stands alone, solemnly atop the weathered, gray bricks, moss growing between their crevices. The rising sun struggles to penetrate the thick morning mist, casting a soft, sacred golden beam that illuminates the swirling haze around him. The distant mountains and the winding outlines of the wall are faintly visible through the fog. His eyes slightly closed, his expression serene and focused, he begins his Tai Chi practice with a slow, powerful start. His weight shifts smoothly between his legs, his arms trace graceful, continuous arcs through the air, seamlessly transitioning from one pose to the next, his wide sleeves dancing like flowing clouds. The camera moves steadily and slowly closer, gradually transitioning from medium-long shot to medium shot, capturing the deep wrinkles on his face, the restrained power contained in his movements, and every detail of his clothes fluttering in the breeze and mist. The whole picture presents a solemn and tranquil atmosphere of isolation and harmony between man and nature. The color tone is mainly cold gray-blue, embellished by the warm morning light, full of epic visual beauty.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,569,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000015/group_10/index_513_seed_2566_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/442_0000015_group_10_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000015_group_10_sample_0_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000015_group_10_sample_0_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000015_group_10_sample_0_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000015_group_10_sample_0_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000015_group_10_sample_0_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000015_group_10_sample_0_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+443,0.01482811,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00729008,0.00089430,0.00426385,0.62321824,0.43788257,0.11132812,0.00055227,0000112,group_13,2,q3,"Is Sparky, a fluffy golden retriever puppy with a tilted head and tail tapping the grass, sitting next to Oliver?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level, medium-wide shot captures the sheer enchantment of a sun-dappled forest clearing. Oliver, a young boy with tousled blond hair and a simple blue and white striped T-shirt, sits cross-legged on a red and white checkered picnic blanket. Next to him sits Sparky, a fluffy golden retriever puppy, his head tilted in curiosity, his tail gently tapping the soft grass. Nearby sits a family of four rabbits: a large brown dad, a gentle white mom, and two small, furry gray bunnies. Between them stands a whimsical tea party, featuring a miniature ceramic tea set with pastel pink, sky blue, and lemon yellow teacups. Oliver, with a look of focused joy on his face, is in action, steadily and deliberately pouring imaginary tea from a small white teapot into a tiny cup, carefully held between the paws of a small rabbit. Another bunny nibbles at a heart-shaped cookie on a central plate, which also contains delicately sliced carrot sticks. The entire scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, which filters through the lush green canopy above, creating a beautiful play of light and shadow. The atmosphere is tranquil, warm and whimsical, a magical moment of friendship between children, pets and gentle woodland creatures.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2647,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000112/group_13/index_9147_seed_8078_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/443_0000112_group_13_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000112_group_13_sample_2_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+444,0.01480669,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.01463379,0.00175099,0.00858854,0.80123472,0.49047211,0.10937500,0.00015849,0000072,group_14,3,q2,Is the coffee table made of polished dark walnut wood?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, slightly high-angle close-up elegantly frames the carefully arranged composition on a polished, dark walnut coffee table in a sleek, modern living room. A minimalist white ceramic bowl with a smooth, low-gloss finish sits at its center. Filled with a vibrant assortment of fresh fruit—a crisp green apple, a ripe red pear, and a small bunch of deep purple grapes—their surfaces catch a subtle, healthy sheen from a nearby light source. Juxtaposed against the bowl is a slender black remote control, its matte plastic casing and minimalist design creating a striking geometric contrast to the bowl's organic form. The entire scene is bathed in warm ambient light from a large, out-of-focus window. The soft afternoon sunlight casts long, gentle shadows across the table's polished texture, highlighting the distinct grains of the ceramic, fruit, and wood. The ambiance is one of profound tranquility and refined elegance, emphasizing the quiet harmony and deliberate contrast between natural and technological objects.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4215,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000072/group_14/index_5030_seed_24535_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/444_0000072_group_14_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000072_group_14_sample_3_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+445,0.01478560,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01177088,0.00139345,0.00691828,0.81865245,0.52392673,0.10351562,0.00210342,0000137,group_7,1,q4,Is the monk sitting cross-legged in the center of the canoe with his hands resting on his knees in a steady meditation mudra?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"violently shaky, low-angle, medium shot fixes the viewer's gaze firmly on a simple wooden canoe, engulfed by the vast, turbulent river. The sky is overcast, and a gloomy light pierces the thick clouds, casting a cold, metallic sheen on the gray-green waves. The monk on the boat, his shiny shaved head reflecting a faint halo in the diffuse light, wears a saffron-colored cotton and linen robe, its vibrant color striking against the gloomy backdrop. The robe, thoroughly soaked by the splashing waves, clings tightly to his lean, yet resolute frame. Though the canoe, relentlessly tossed to the crests and slammed back into the troughs by the mountainous waves, groans and creaks, the monk remains firmly planted, cross-legged, in the center. His face is serene, his eyes slightly closed, as if the raging winds and waves of the outside world cannot disturb his inner meditation. His hands rest on his knees in a steady meditation mudra. His body sways only slightly with the violent ups and downs of the boat, forming a sharp contrast with the violent natural scene around him. The entire picture, in this extreme conflict between movement and stillness, creates an atmosphere of transcendental solemnity and tranquility, imbued with a powerful spiritual force.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3089,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000137/group_7/index_861_seed_19487_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/445_0000137_group_7_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000137_group_7_sample_1_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000137_group_7_sample_1_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000137_group_7_sample_1_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000137_group_7_sample_1_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000137_group_7_sample_1_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000137_group_7_sample_1_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+446,0.01476098,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.01434823,0.00170030,0.00843195,0.73214680,0.48649088,0.08691406,0.00083941,0000020,group_14,0,q2,"Is a massive, hill-sized pumpkin carved into a rustic house with a wooden door and circular windows visible in the center of the field?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In the style of Ghibli animation, a sweeping wide shot, like that from a low-flying drone, glides gracefully across a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows. The camera slowly pans right, revealing a massive, hill-sized pumpkin perched in the center of the field, its vibrant orange rind deeply grooved and textured with a soft, painterly texture. The pumpkin is meticulously carved into a rustic, whimsical house, with a small, round wooden door and several circular windows. Flanked by dense, leafy green vines, they curl around a curving, chimney-like stem at the top. The entire scene is bathed in warm, golden afternoon light, casting long, soft shadows across the tall, emerald green grass, which sways hypnotically in the breeze. A massive, sea urchin-like creature, curled up asleep on the pumpkin's roof; its spines are not sharp but soft and plush, like velvety tendrils covered in a layer of delicate green moss. As the camera settles into position, the creature begins to stir, slowly and deliberately emerging from its slumber. Its mossy spine trembles gently, and then its body unfolds section by section, a gentle and peaceful awakening that perfectly captures the serene and magical atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,384,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000020/group_14/index_287_seed_11781_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/446_0000020_group_14_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000020_group_14_sample_0_q2__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000020_group_14_sample_0_q2__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000020_group_14_sample_0_q2__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000020_group_14_sample_0_q2__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000020_group_14_sample_0_q2__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000020_group_14_sample_0_q2__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+447,0.01475820,opposite-across,2.51600000,6,0.01254437,0.00147575,0.00737908,0.61535901,0.38559765,0.13574219,0.00096297,0000161,group_10,3,q3,Is a woman in her early 30s wearing a cream-colored sweater visible across from the man?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shaky, handheld, medium shot at eye level immerses the viewer in an intimate and emotionally charged conversation. The camera's subtle, sustained movement focuses on a man in his 30s, his hair disheveled and shadowed at five o'clock, who speaks with passion. He wears a worn, dark blue denim jacket over a simple gray T-shirt, and sits leaning forward on a plush sofa. He gestures vigorously with his right hand, fingers spread and then clenched to punctuate his words. Across from him, a woman in her early 30s, her long, wavy brown hair partially obscuring her face, listens raptly. She wears a soft, cream-colored sweater. The scene is set in a cozy, dimly lit living room at night. A warm floor lamp casts a golden glow, creating soft shadows and highlighting the dancing dust particles in the air. When the man pauses, the woman slowly turns to meet his gaze, her expression softening with empathy, and she nods gently in deep agreement, a silent affirmation that resonates within the raw, authentic atmosphere of the moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2779,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000161/group_10/index_6331_seed_7686_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/447_0000161_group_10_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000161_group_10_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+448,0.01472628,beside-next-to,1.74000000,2,0.01463540,0.00173622,0.00859945,0.78985977,0.52893347,0.08496094,0.00105780,0000042,group_0,0,q2,Is a young woman with shoulder-length brown hair standing beside a weathered bus stop sign with a rusted pole?,Yes,No,No,"static, eye-level medium-long shot, emulating the distinctive aesthetic of 1990s cinema, perfectly centers a lone figure. A young woman with shoulder-length brown hair stands patiently beside a simple, weathered bus stop sign, its metal pole stained with faint traces of rust, the rectangular sign faded. She wears a well-worn denim jacket over a plain white T-shirt and dark jeans, her posture relaxed yet expectant, almost motionless as she waits. This ordinary scene stands in stark, surreal contrast to the backdrop, where the grand, columned entrance of an opulent mansion looms, its pristine white marble columns and a vast, manicured lawn stretching beneath an evenly cloudy sky. The entire frame is bathed in a soft, diffuse light, eliminating harsh shadows and creating a characteristic soft focus that slightly blurs the edges of the distant mansion. Rich, warm tones dominate, imbuing the deep green of the lawn and the creamy white of the building with a golden-day glow, while subtle film grain textures the image, creating a nostalgic, contemplative, and slightly dreamlike atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4988,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000042/group_0/index_7277_seed_21237_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/448_0000042_group_0_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000042_group_0_sample_0_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+449,0.01465538,opposite-across,2.51600000,6,0.00925486,0.00111937,0.00542366,0.86272049,0.63676697,0.07226562,0.00001976,0000076,group_9,2,q5,"Does the scene include bright red plastic chairs, white walls, and a shelf with a row of blue binders?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady, eye-level medium shot depicts a scene of quiet academic focus within a typical elementary school classroom, rendered in a realistic atmosphere. Four light-skinned children, dressed in simple T-shirts of varying colors and blue jeans, sit at individual light-colored wooden desks, arranged in two rows facing forward. In the front row, a girl with blonde braids leans intently against her desk, her hands moving steadily as she meticulously writes in an open notebook. The other three children place their hands gently on open books, their gazes fixed on the pages with calm, focused concentration, their postures reflecting a state of deep engagement. Their bright red plastic chairs add a pop of primary color against the neutral white walls and light-colored floor. In the background, a shelf neatly arranged with a uniform row of blue binders adds a cool, blocky color to the composition. The entire scene is illuminated by the bright, even light characteristic of a well-lit classroom, casting soft, minimal shadows and creating a palpable atmosphere of peace and hard work, capturing a genuine moment of learning.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1021,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000076/group_9/index_6885_seed_12720_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/449_0000076_group_9_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000076_group_9_sample_2_q5__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000076_group_9_sample_2_q5__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000076_group_9_sample_2_q5__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000076_group_9_sample_2_q5__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000076_group_9_sample_2_q5__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000076_group_9_sample_2_q5__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+450,0.01463078,between-flanked,2.36800000,6,0.01229293,0.00145576,0.00722478,0.69462204,0.43467951,0.12207031,0.00248820,0000059,group_14,0,q1,Are the main subjects a man and a woman in a tender embrace on a wooden deck?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, deliberate, medium shot, at eye level, begins the film's depiction of a couple in a tender embrace on a sun-drenched wooden deck. The man, with soft brown hair and dressed in a loose-fitting cream linen shirt, rests his hands gently on the woman's back. The woman, her long blond hair gleaming in the sunlight, is dressed in a simple light blue sundress. Her arms gently drape around his neck, her head resting on his shoulder, her eyes peacefully closed. The bright afternoon sun casts a warm golden glow across the scene, highlighting the grain of the deck's weathered cedar planks and creating soft, long shadows. As the camera smoothly slides forward, the frame tightens into an intimate close-up, focusing on their serene expressions and the tender connection between them. The lush, out-of-focus greenery of the background garden blurs into a soft bokeh, enhancing the deeply romantic and tranquil atmosphere of the moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2527,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000059/group_14/index_5279_seed_25403_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/450_0000059_group_14_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q1__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q1__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q1__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q1__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q1__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q1__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+451,0.01462639,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.01282169,0.00153741,0.00752286,0.84215266,0.59308571,0.07421875,0.00046366,0000006,group_10,0,q5,Is the sky a gradient of blue hues with large white pixelated clouds casting shifting shadows?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"wide-angle, static time-lapse video captured from above recreates the scenery of Ciqikou, Chongqing, in a distinctive 8-bit pixel art style. Ancient stone steps, composed of rough gray and brown pixels, wind down, flanked by traditional wooden buildings constructed from dark brown pixels. Their iconic eaves and corners are simplified into hard pixel lines, and their windows are simple, glowing squares. On these narrow streets, an abstract crowd, composed of tiny pixels in vibrant colors, surges like a tide, forming a steady, swift flow of pixels down the stone steps. The sky background is a gradient of several blue hues. Several large, white, pixelated clouds drift past in unnatural, blocky formations, casting shifting, pixelated shadows on the ground. The color palette of the entire picture is strictly limited, and the relationship between light and shadow is expressed through the brightness and darkness of pixel blocks, creating a strong sense of retro and digital feeling. With a unique dynamic beauty, it perfectly reproduces the vibrant and nostalgic atmosphere of early electronic games.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2228,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000006/group_10/index_9163_seed_24868_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/451_0000006_group_10_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000006_group_10_sample_0_q5__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000006_group_10_sample_0_q5__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000006_group_10_sample_0_q5__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000006_group_10_sample_0_q5__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000006_group_10_sample_0_q5__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000006_group_10_sample_0_q5__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+452,0.01461647,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.09200000,3,0.00692568,0.00083555,0.00406009,0.69311130,0.45864540,0.10644531,0.00136366,0000093,group_6,3,q4,Does the afternoon sun filter through twisted ancient pine branches to cast dappled light and shadows on the figures?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, drawn-out shot, beginning with a delicately composed, slightly upward mid-shot, focuses on the depths of an ancient temple courtyard. An elderly monk, bald and deeply wrinkled between his forehead and eyes, wears a soft, naturally wrinkled ochre-red robe, faded by time. He stands tall, his face solemn and serene. In one hand, he holds a string of dark Buddhist beads, while the other hangs naturally at his side. His gaze is determined and compassionate. Opposite him, a massive white snake, its entire body coated in a soft, ivory sheen, raises its head high, reaching the monk's eye level. Its golden, vertical pupils convey no hint of murderous intent, but rather a glimmer of ancient, human wisdom. The snake's body coils tightly on the mossy stone floor, dotted with scattered, withered bodhi leaves, imbued with a sense of poised power. The afternoon sun filters through the twisted branches of the ancient pines in the courtyard, casting dappled light and shadow, perfectly outlining the monk's silhouette and the texture of his robes, while also causing the giant snake's scales to reflect a pearly shimmer. As the camera steadily and deliberately moves backward, the figures of the two men and the snake gradually diminish within the magnificent temple setting. In the background, stone lanterns carved with lotus patterns, quaint wooden corridors, and a corner of the hall with its soaring eaves and brackets slowly come into view. The entire scene, shrouded in the subtle scent of sandalwood, creates a tranquil atmosphere that transcends time, imbued with Zen and a mysterious tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3637,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000093/group_6/index_3519_seed_6357_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/452_0000093_group_6_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000093_group_6_sample_3_q4__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000093_group_6_sample_3_q4__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000093_group_6_sample_3_q4__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000093_group_6_sample_3_q4__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000093_group_6_sample_3_q4__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000093_group_6_sample_3_q4__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+453,0.01460063,foreground-background+between-flanked,4.40800000,2,0.00587674,0.00069903,0.00345180,0.75473076,0.51820892,0.08007812,0.00078857,0000026,group_9,1,q2,Does the robot move on three spindly metal legs?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with an erratic handheld tracking shot, the frame punctuated by digital noise and flickering like signal interference. The focus shifts rapidly between foreground and background, closely following a cuddly Disney Pixar-esque spherical robot. Its smooth, egg-yellow shell, a pair of enormous, digital blue eyes flashing wildly with utter terror, moves on three spindly metal legs, frantically darting through the ruins of a dilapidated biocontrol demonstration area. This area seems like an isolated island amidst a vast, gray wasteland, the sky a sickly, dim yellow. Countless thick veins of mutant plants, emitting an eerie purple and green bioluminescence, surge, entwine, and grow at a visible speed, as if alive, through the cracked ground and rusted debris of equipment. Each pulse of these veins causes the fluorescent light on their surface to flicker. The robot clumsily dodges a glowing vine that suddenly breaks out from the ground under its feet and almost trips. The whole scene forms a strong visual contrast between the cute character's terrified escape and the invasion of terrifying plants. Combined with the unstable lens and digital glitch effects, it successfully creates a unique, unsettling and weird contrast atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,421,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000026/group_9/index_4175_seed_2677_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/453_0000026_group_9_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000026_group_9_sample_1_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000026_group_9_sample_1_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000026_group_9_sample_1_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000026_group_9_sample_1_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000026_group_9_sample_1_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000026_group_9_sample_1_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+454,0.01459544,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.00326118,0.00038681,0.00191625,0.61621791,0.38947320,0.11718750,0.00178671,0000037,group_5,0,q3,Does the woman sweep the floor using a traditional straw broom with a long worn wooden handle?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2710,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4756_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/454_0000037_group_5_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_0_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+455,0.01455032,between-flanked,2.62400000,9,0.01029122,0.00123002,0.00604079,0.80341935,0.48592010,0.10937500,0.00017321,0000046,group_4,1,q1,Is the main subject a young woman with dark brown hair in a loose braid wearing a cream cotton shirt?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a warm, Studio Ghibli-inspired style, a steady, eye-level, medium tracking shot follows a young woman as she carefully crosses a sun-dappled cobblestone street. Her dark brown hair is pulled back in a simple, loose braid, resting on the shoulders of a cream cotton shirt. With gentle focus, she pedals steadily and deliberately on a classic Dutch freight tricycle, its light blue frame showing subtle, charming signs of wear. The large wooden cargo box out front is filled with a vibrant, picturesque display of fresh produce and flowers; vibrant yellow sunflowers and purple lavender stalks jut out from between heads of crisp green lettuce, bright red tomatoes, and round onions. As the tricycle moves, its wheels clattering gently against the uneven, mossy cobblestones, the camera sliding parallel to it, capturing the shifting patterns of golden light filtering through the leaves of the trees overhead. The setting shows a quaint storybook town square with half-timbered buildings, terracotta roofs, and window boxes blooming with geraniums, while the other gentle townspeople—an elderly couple walking arm in arm, a baker dusting flour from his apron—add to the scene’s serene, painterly atmosphere of peaceful daily life.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,666,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000046/group_4/index_8058_seed_7664_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/455_0000046_group_4_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q1__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q1__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q1__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q1__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q1__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000046_group_4_sample_1_q1__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+456,0.01448870,left-right-pair,3.96000000,4,0.00650662,0.00078572,0.00381393,0.70293158,0.51047182,0.07226562,0.00079927,0000067,group_15,1,q1,Is the subject a man in his thirties with short dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"shot shot from a medium, slightly upward angle, the camera pans steadily to the right, closely following the subject's movements. In the frame, a man in his thirties, with short, dark brown hair and a neatly trimmed beard, leans slightly forward, his expression focused and serious. He wears a dark gray, cotton, long-sleeved Henley-collared T-shirt, the sleeves casually pushed up to his elbows, revealing his muscular forearms. He is in a softly lit bedroom, with the corner of a bed covered in white sheets visible in the background. Steadily and deliberately, the man extends his right arm toward a blue nylon travel bag on the bed. The bag features black canvas handles and a silver metal zipper, half-unzipped. As the camera follows, the thick wad of banknotes clutched in his left hand becomes visible. He then carefully places the wad of bills into the bag's open mouth, his fingers delicately moving as he pushes the money deeper into the bag. The natural morning light filtering in from a side window casts soft shadows on his arm and the surface of the travel bag, highlighting the texture of the nylon and the thickness of the banknotes. The dominant color scheme of the entire scene is the vibrant blue of the travel bag, the dark gray of the man's clothing, and the white of the bed sheet, creating an atmosphere of focus, intimacy, and a touch of tension.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3297,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000067/group_15/index_3450_seed_7519_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/456_0000067_group_15_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000067_group_15_sample_1_q1__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000067_group_15_sample_1_q1__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000067_group_15_sample_1_q1__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000067_group_15_sample_1_q1__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000067_group_15_sample_1_q1__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000067_group_15_sample_1_q1__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+457,0.01445039,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01304692,0.00152803,0.00767926,0.80605292,0.46897054,0.12695312,0.00375855,0000097,group_4,2,q2,Does the woman have long auburn hair in a loose braid draped over her shoulder?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, medium close-up captures a woman, her long, auburn hair pulled back into a loose, practical braid draped over one shoulder. She wears a dark green waxed canvas jacket and a thick, weathered brown leather falconry glove on her left forearm. A magnificent falcon perches securely on the glove, its gray-brown back and barred white underbelly delicately rendered, its sharp, hooked beak and piercing black eyes perfectly still. A soft-focus, windswept, grassy marshland frames the background, creating a cool, earthy palette beneath a dramatic, cloudy sky. With a serene, focused expression, the woman slowly and deliberately raises her bare right hand. Gently, she delicately strokes the feathers on the falcon's head with the back of her index finger. The bird, displaying complete trust, remains calm, holding its head steady to receive the gentle touch, creating a powerful, quiet, and intimate atmosphere of mutual respect between human and wildlife.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4793,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000097/group_4/index_4373_seed_27182_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/457_0000097_group_4_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000097_group_4_sample_2_q2__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000097_group_4_sample_2_q2__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000097_group_4_sample_2_q2__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000097_group_4_sample_2_q2__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000097_group_4_sample_2_q2__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000097_group_4_sample_2_q2__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+458,0.01444019,beside-next-to,2.10000000,5,0.01163931,0.00143249,0.00680455,0.79558688,0.57016861,0.08398438,0.00203857,0000169,group_14,2,q5,Is the character standing in a relaxed pose with hands tucked into his pockets near a concrete ledge?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"cinematic, eye-level medium-long shot, rendered in surreal 3D animation, slowly approaches a young man standing on a city rooftop during the magic hour. He has sharp, chiseled features, a strong jawline, and dark, meticulously styled hair, with a single strand appearing pristine, subtly tousled in the breeze, catching the light. He wears a crisp white shirt, its realistic cotton texture visible, flowing gracefully in the wind. He stands in a relaxed pose, his hands tucked into the pockets of his dark trousers, near the concrete ledge of a rooftop. Below and behind him, a sprawling metropolis stretches to the horizon, its countless buildings and skyscrapers bathed in the warm golden glow of sunset. The sky is a stunning canvas, vibrant hues of orange, pink, and deep purple. His expression is one of deep, quiet contemplation, his gaze distant and his eyes crystal clear, perfectly reflecting the vibrant colors of the sky, creating a powerful atmosphere of tranquil introspection and poignant beauty.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3457,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000169/group_14/index_291_seed_22789_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/458_0000169_group_14_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000169_group_14_sample_2_q5__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000169_group_14_sample_2_q5__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000169_group_14_sample_2_q5__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000169_group_14_sample_2_q5__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000169_group_14_sample_2_q5__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000169_group_14_sample_2_q5__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+459,0.01439213,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01268478,0.00151708,0.00744513,0.80217624,0.48231611,0.11328125,0.00039110,0000015,group_15,0,q2,"Is the first man shown with sweat-drenched black hair, a trickle of blood from his mouth, and wearing a dark gray T-shirt?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"Frantic handheld shot thrusts the viewer directly into the heart of a frenzied hand-to-hand fight, moving erratically and rapidly between the two men, capturing every tense moment at close range. The scene rapidly switches between tense expressions and swift movements, beginning with an extreme close-up of a young man's face. His sweat-drenched black hair clings to his forehead, a trickle of blood oozing from the corner of his clenched mouth. His expression is steely and pained, and the muscles in his neck bulge like ropes from the strain. He wears a sweat-soaked dark gray T-shirt, tightly hugging his muscular build. The camera jerks to reveal the face of his opponent, a more muscular man with a shaved head, contorted in anger. His eyes burn with a cold rage. Then, the camera quickly pulls back, revealing a slightly wider angle of their entangled bodies—the young man's forearm blocks a powerful swinging punch with a dull thud, his body rapidly sinking to try to knock him off balance. The entire fight takes place in a dimly lit abandoned warehouse, the sole source of light coming from a single, precariously lit fluorescent light hanging from the ceiling. Its harsh, cold light creates sharp highlights on their sweat-stained skin and casts long, swaying shadows behind them. The air is thick with dust, clearly visible in the beams of light. The primary colors of the scene are icy grays and deep blacks, the only bright spot being a glaring, blood-red hue. The overall atmosphere is filled with a suffocating sense of tension, a violent aesthetic, and a primal instinct for survival.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,344,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000015/group_15/index_9178_seed_3519_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/459_0000015_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q2__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q2__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q2__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q2__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q2__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000015_group_15_sample_0_q2__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+460,0.01438388,beside-next-to+between-flanked,5.08400000,8,0.00469932,0.00057042,0.00275260,0.79553074,0.58801574,0.06835938,0.00068578,0000088,group_6,2,q4,Are knitting needles and a forming scarf visible in the woman's hands?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"steady medium shot, captured from a slightly overhead, is rendered entirely in the style of a black-and-white pencil sketch. At the very center, a mother sits quietly in a dark wooden chair, her back to the camera. She wears a cozy home sweater, her hair loosely tied in a bun. An old-fashioned desk lamp provides the sole source of light, casting a warm, focused beam. This light, depicted in the sketch as a delicate field of white space and the lightest grays, precisely illuminates her focused back and the movements of her hands, while the rest of the room is shrouded in a deep, cross-hatched darkness. Her head is slightly lowered, her shoulders hunched forward, and her hands fly up and down with steady, deliberate movements. Two slender knitting needles intertwine between her deft fingers, a forming scarf dangling from them, its delicate texture sharply outlined in the light. As she gently tugged, the large, fluffy ball of yarn on the table beside her began to roll at an almost imperceptible pace, extremely slowly and irregularly. Each tiny twitch tugged at the lifeline connecting her hands. The entire scene, devoid of a single trace of superfluous color, consisted entirely of shifting lines and blocks of varying grayscale, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, warmth, and nostalgia.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1441,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000088/group_6/index_8179_seed_27128_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/460_0000088_group_6_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000088_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000088_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000088_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000088_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000088_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000088_group_6_sample_2_q4__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+461,0.01437685,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.01432923,0.00171466,0.00840971,0.81782448,0.49070090,0.11718750,0.00034705,0000117,group_0,2,q4,"Does the cat slowly raise its head to fix its gaze on the night sky, revealing emerald green eyes reflecting a full moon?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"close-up shot from an extremely low angle, the camera slowly tilts upward, following the subject's movements. On a damp, slightly pebbled ground bathed in cool moonlight, an elegant black cat crouches compactly. Its glossy black fur, like smooth silk, reflects a faint silver sheen in the dim light, outlining the muscular lines beneath its back and shoulder blades. Initially, its head is slightly lowered, then, with a steady and deliberate rhythm, it slowly raises its head, finally fixing its gaze on the night sky. In this movement, its jewel-like emerald green eyes are fully revealed, their clear pupils clearly reflecting the bright full moon, as if absorbing the entire night sky's brilliance. Its gaze is focused and serene. The entire scene, a stark contrast between the deep black and the brilliant silver and emerald green, creates an atmosphere of mystery, tranquility, and spirituality.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,11,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000117/group_0/index_9434_seed_29586_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/461_0000117_group_0_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000117_group_0_sample_2_q4__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000117_group_0_sample_2_q4__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000117_group_0_sample_2_q4__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000117_group_0_sample_2_q4__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000117_group_0_sample_2_q4__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000117_group_0_sample_2_q4__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+462,0.01436479,opposite-across,2.24400000,4,0.01134649,0.00134282,0.00666911,0.84008604,0.52458555,0.10253906,0.00278434,0000028,group_11,0,q2,Are two warriors visible wearing full bronze armor with cloud and thunder patterns?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, medium shot, captured from a low, upward angle using a telephoto lens, freezes the epic confrontation atop the Yellow Crane Tower. In the frame, two warriors clad in full bronze armor face off atop the iconic yellow glazed tile roof. The telephoto lens compresses the space, making the turbulent sky behind them seem incredibly close and oppressive. The warrior on the left slumps slightly, his legs bent in a lunge, his center of gravity low. Beneath his beast-faced helmet, his piercing eyes fixate on his opponent, his right hand gripping the hilt of the longsword at his waist, veins visible. His bronze armor is intricately engraved with cloud and thunder patterns, and the slight scratches along its edges, worn by years of battle, reflect a cold, hard gleam in the gloomy sky. The warrior opposite him stands erect, his figure even more imposing, the long red tassel on his helmet whipping the air fiercely in the wind. He didn't place his hands on his weapons, but held his arms slightly outstretched. His posture appeared relaxed, but his set jaw and unyielding gaze betrayed a deep sense of vigilance. The glazed tiles beneath their feet shone with a damp sheen in the humid air. Against the backdrop was a vast, boundless sky, thick, dark clouds rolling and converging at a visible speed. Occasionally, a gap in the clouds would reveal a brief, dramatic burst of light, imbuing this fateful confrontation with a solemn and awe-inspiring atmosphere. The dominant tones of the scene, the gray-blue of the sky, the bright yellow of the roofs, and the dark copper of the armor, imbued the scene with a chilling, cinematic quality.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2578,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000028/group_11/index_5667_seed_23634_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/462_0000028_group_11_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q2__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q2__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q2__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q2__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q2__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000028_group_11_sample_0_q2__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+463,0.01434112,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01436309,0.00168640,0.00845113,0.70574325,0.43873093,0.12890625,0.00454813,0000083,group_2,2,q3,Is the subject a young woman with brown hair in a ponytail wearing wire-rimmed glasses and a light blue cotton dress shirt?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"An extreme close-up shot from a low angle, slowly and relentlessly zooming in, intensifies the focus on a grieving young woman. Her brown hair is pulled back in a simple ponytail, with loose strands catching the sunlight like thin golden threads. She wears thin wire-rimmed glasses and a crisp light blue cotton dress shirt. The entire frame is dominated by the raw physicality of a violent cough that convulses her body; her shoulders arch violently, and her head jerk forward with each spasmodic, uncontrollable thump. Her eyes, already watery with underlying sorrow, squeeze tightly in agony, and her face flushes. The scene is bathed in a warm, ethereal golden hour light, creating a soft halo around her body against the blurred backdrop of an outdoor night. The stark contrast between the serene, beautiful light and her inner anguish creates an intense, poignant, and intimate atmosphere of vulnerability and pain.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,95,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000083/group_2/index_7917_seed_11922_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/463_0000083_group_2_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000083_group_2_sample_2_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000083_group_2_sample_2_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000083_group_2_sample_2_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000083_group_2_sample_2_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000083_group_2_sample_2_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000083_group_2_sample_2_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+464,0.01428088,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01272426,0.00151942,0.00746989,0.70652175,0.44192067,0.12402344,0.00295079,0000038,group_5,3,q3,"Does the scene include a large bouquet of vibrant pink peonies and white tulips in a clear, cylindrical glass vase filled with water on the table?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, eye-level shot opens statically on a woman with long, wavy auburn hair pulled back into a loose, low ponytail, revealing a calm facial expression. She wears a cozy, soft-knit cream sweater and stands beside a polished, dark-wood console table in a bright, modern living room. On the table sits a large bouquet of vibrant pink peonies and white tulips in a simple, clear, cylindrical glass vase filled with water. With focused grace, she leans forward, one hand firmly grasping the base of the vase while the other gently supports the bouquet, carefully lifting both items together in one steady motion. She maintains a firm grip and then, with a smooth pivot on her foot, turns her body to the right. As she takes her first step, the camera begins to pan right, smoothly following her movements as she steps away from the table and deeper into the room, creating an atmosphere of calm and purposeful presence bathed in soft, natural light from the off-screen windows.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1091,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000038/group_5/index_8468_seed_9430_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/464_0000038_group_5_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000038_group_5_sample_3_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+465,0.01425344,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.01135652,0.00136491,0.00666108,0.69576514,0.44312331,0.12402344,0.00206029,0000094,group_6,0,q4,Are the man's hand and the woman's hand positioned mere inches apart on the swing's wooden planks?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The scene unfolds in a medium shot at eye level, the camera beginning a slow, almost imperceptible pan to a young man and woman sharing a moment on a large, weathered wooden swing suspended from the sturdy branches of an old tree. The man, with slightly tousled dark brown hair and a comfortable olive green Henley shirt, leans earnestly toward his companion, his voice low and sincere. The woman, her long honey-blond hair softly illuminated by the setting sun, wears a loose-fitting cream-colored knit cardigan over a simple floral dress; she listens intently, her head slightly tilted, a look of deep understanding on her face. They sit in a lush, verdant backyard in golden hour, the background melting into a beautiful bokeh of distant, out-of-focus foliage. Between them, on the swing's wooden planks, their hands are mere inches apart, his hand motionless and open, her fingers slightly curled, the tiny space between them crackling with unspoken emotion. As the camera continues its steady, deliberate close-in, the composition tightens, excluding the wider surroundings to focus purely on the vibrant space between their faces and hands, capturing the quiet intimacy and heartfelt seriousness of their conversation in an atmosphere of tranquility, warmth, and deep romance.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,837,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000094/group_6/index_8066_seed_8253_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/465_0000094_group_6_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000094_group_6_sample_0_q4__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000094_group_6_sample_0_q4__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000094_group_6_sample_0_q4__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000094_group_6_sample_0_q4__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000094_group_6_sample_0_q4__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000094_group_6_sample_0_q4__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+466,0.01421942,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.34000000,5,0.00550229,0.00066723,0.00322337,0.75098431,0.56607568,0.06250000,0.00057232,0000168,group_10,3,q5,Is a half-finished sweater with an intricate twisted pattern draped across her legs next to a wicker basket of colorful yarn balls?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium, close-up, static shot, captured from a slight overhead angle, focuses on a gentle Asian mother, comfortably seated in a vintage wooden armchair. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through a large window, casting a warm golden hue on her long, dark brown hair, pulled into a low bun, and the off-white, turtleneck cashmere sweater she wears. Her face holds a serene, focused expression, her eyes slightly downcast, her gaze completely focused on the work in her hands. Her hands move steadily and deliberately, two smooth bamboo knitting needles twirling between her deft fingers. One needle expertly picks up lavender yarn and delicately threads it through the loop of the other. A half-finished sweater drapes across her legs, its intricate, twisted pattern clearly visible in the light, each fluffy fiber seeming palpable, a vivid, textured expression. Beside her, a wicker basket filled with colorful balls of yarn rests on the ground. The bookshelves and greenery in the background are softly blurred by the shallow depth of field. The entire scene is warm and harmonious, imbued with the warmth of home and the tranquility of time brought by handmade crafts.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,255,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000168/group_10/index_8887_seed_8255_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/466_0000168_group_10_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q5__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q5__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q5__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q5__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q5__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000168_group_10_sample_3_q5__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+467,0.01417708,between-flanked,2.36800000,6,0.01148769,0.00138698,0.00673380,0.70059454,0.46162292,0.10937500,0.00299537,0000091,group_8,3,q3,Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The shot begins in a medium shot, slightly overlooking, with a steady focus on an elderly angler. He wears a wide, frayed bamboo hat, casting a shadow over his weathered face, revealing only a long, graying beard that sways gently in the breeze. Dressed in a simple, dark gray linen jacket, the elderly man sits poised in the center of a rustic wooden boat, its hull a deep brown from years of waterlogging. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender bamboo fishing rod, his line plummeting into the calm, mirror-like surface of the lake, creating only barely perceptible ripples where it enters. The soft, diffuse morning light evenly bathes the water, reflecting the hazy outlines of the sky and distant mountains. The scene is shrouded in a tranquil slate-gray and ink-wash hue. As the camera begins to steadily and slowly pull back, the picture gradually widens, and the figures of the boat and the old man slowly shrink in his world. Finally, he turns into a lonely and harmonious ink dot on the vast lake, completely merging with the rolling indigo mountains shrouded in mist in the background, creating a sense of harmony between man and nature, tranquility and eternity full of oriental philosophical poetry.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3654,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000091/group_8/index_163_seed_16729_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/467_0000091_group_8_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000091_group_8_sample_3_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000091_group_8_sample_3_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000091_group_8_sample_3_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000091_group_8_sample_3_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000091_group_8_sample_3_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000091_group_8_sample_3_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+468,0.01417446,between-flanked,2.49600000,7,0.01121362,0.00133924,0.00658292,0.69657516,0.44051629,0.11816406,0.00236726,0000113,group_2,3,q3,"Is the man wearing a dark, rough linen robe with frayed collar and cuffs?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"tightly composed, close-up, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on the weathered, wrinkled face of an elderly assassin. He wears a dark, rough linen robe, its collar and cuffs frayed and frayed. A tightly braided, graying braid falls from his head to his shoulders. His calloused and scarred hands steady a short knife. The blade, forged through countless hammers, gleams with a cold, deadly metallic gleam in the dim yellow light streaming in from a high window just outside the frame. Within this beam, countless tiny dust particles drift and swirl, adding a sense of movement to the dark stone chamber. Most strikingly, the perfectly polished blade reflects not his now aged features, but the image of a dashing young man with a rebellious gaze. From the sunken eye sockets of the aged assassin, a pair of cloudy yet still piercing eyes gaze back at his past self, their expression solemn and complex, as if engaged in a silent gaze spanning time and space. The painting's primary tones are dark brown and gray, with the light precisely outlining the contours of his face and the sharp edge of the blade, creating a strong contrast between light and dark, creating a sense of quiet nostalgia, the weight of time, and a lingering sense of desolation, embodying the quaint and profound sense of historical vicissitudes to the extreme.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3590,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000113/group_2/index_4697_seed_10380_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/468_0000113_group_2_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000113_group_2_sample_3_q3__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000113_group_2_sample_3_q3__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000113_group_2_sample_3_q3__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000113_group_2_sample_3_q3__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000113_group_2_sample_3_q3__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000113_group_2_sample_3_q3__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+469,0.01416930,beside-next-to,2.22000000,6,0.01096910,0.00130377,0.00644355,0.80915558,0.55004412,0.08691406,0.00170830,0000147,group_4,2,q2,"Is a woman with thick, shoulder-length blond curls wearing a crisp white collared shirt sitting behind a long, matte-gray counter?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a realistic-style scene in a bright, sterile airport check-in area. A woman with thick, shoulder-length blond curls, wearing a crisp white collared shirt that fits her uniform, sits attentively behind a long, matte-gray counter. Her fingers initially move deftly across a black keyboard, her focus fixed on a computer screen just off-screen. She pauses typing, her gaze shifting slightly upward, toward an unseen figure. A hand reaches into the frame, offering her a dark blue passport, which she accepts with steady, practiced movements. Simultaneously, two other people approach from the right side of the frame, walking steadily, just like the next person. The first is a man with neatly combed short brown hair, thin-framed glasses, and a dark gray suit jacket over a light-colored shirt. The second person's face remains invisible, partially visible beside him, their form suggesting a casual posture. The entire scene is illuminated by cool, even overhead fluorescent lights, which reflect off the polished white tile floor, creating a clean, functional atmosphere free of harsh shadows and reinforcing the impersonal efficiency of the modern travel center.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2798,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000147/group_4/index_1124_seed_868_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/469_0000147_group_4_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q2__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q2__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q2__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q2__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q2__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000147_group_4_sample_2_q2__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+470,0.01416081,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.07200000,4,0.00474877,0.00056909,0.00278646,0.70041943,0.43031937,0.12500000,0.00138903,0000105,group_14,3,q2,"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium close-up shot from a level angle, slightly handheld and imbued with a subtle sense of shakiness, instantly draws the viewer into the bustling and vibrant atmosphere of a wet market. At the center of the frame is an elderly woman with a wrinkled face and graying hair tied in a simple bun. Time has carved deep grooves into her tanned skin, but her eyes are remarkably sharp and focused. She wears a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock, the fabric defined by its distinct texture and soft creases from repeated washing. Standing before a vegetable stall piled high with vibrant greens, carrots dusted with fresh soil, and plump tomatoes, she leans forward slightly, extending her age-freckled right hand. With her index and middle fingers, she decisively indicates a price, her lips pursed as she speaks rapidly and forcefully to the vendor off-screen. In her left hand, she clutches a woven bamboo basket, its edges frayed. The tarpaulin overhead casts dappled shadows, while a few suspended incandescent bulbs emit a warm, dim glow, illuminating the dust and moisture floating in the air and creating a stark contrast between the vibrant colors of the vegetables and the dark clothing of the elderly woman. The entire scene, shrouded in warm tones, exudes an atmosphere both tense and full of life, perfectly capturing the uncompromising moments of everyday transactions.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1228,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_8676_seed_3869_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/470_0000105_group_14_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000105_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000105_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000105_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000105_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000105_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000105_group_14_sample_3_q2__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+471,0.01415423,beside-next-to,2.46000000,8,0.00993502,0.00119695,0.00582538,0.79549998,0.54053891,0.08300781,0.00168487,0000024,group_6,3,q2,Is a young man with short brown hair wearing a heather-gray cotton T-shirt visible?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera begins with a medium shot at eye level, slowly and steadily panning to the right, following the action in a brightly lit modern kitchen. A young man with neatly combed short brown hair and wearing a soft, heather-gray cotton T-shirt leans slightly over a gleaming stainless steel sink. Steady in both hands, he holds a small, rectangular glass fish tank under a modern, gooseneck chrome faucet, a stream of clear water filling it. With serene concentration, he watches the water level rise. When it's nearly full, he deftly turns the faucet handle with his right hand, and the flow abruptly stops. Then, he carefully lifts the now-heavy tank, the water sloshing gently inside, and turns his body toward the adjacent, sleek, light-gray crystal countertop. The camera pan ends as he deliberately and quietly sets the tank down. After a brief pause, his gaze shifts, and he carefully picks up a small fishing net with a delicate green mesh and a thin metal handle, which has been placed next to the tank. The entire scene is bathed in bright, indirect morning light, streaming in through an invisible window, creating soft shadows that accentuate the clean lines of the white subway tile backsplash, creating an atmosphere of quiet, focused communality and gentle preparation.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,596,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000024/group_6/index_1762_seed_1224_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/471_0000024_group_6_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q2__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q2__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q2__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q2__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q2__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000024_group_6_sample_3_q2__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+472,0.01412171,between-flanked,2.36800000,6,0.01146827,0.00135634,0.00674128,0.80244422,0.46237040,0.12500000,0.00002956,0000117,group_14,0,q3,Is a hand shown unscrewing a white plastic bottle of fluoxetine with small white pills tumbling out onto dark canvas shoes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with a high-angle, overhead shot, the initial image abstract and poetic. Raindrops pummel the deep, dark surface of a lake, stirring up concentric ripples that radiate outward. The water's surface simultaneously reflects the cold, strip-shaped lights within the laboratory, creating a distorted, interwoven tapestry of cool blue light and shadow. Then, the camera slowly and steadily zooms in, penetrating this illusion of light and shadow to focus on the protagonist, slumped over on the cold terrazzo floor. He leans limply against a metal wall covered in instruments. A hand, trembling violently with weakness, laboriously, almost spasmodically, unscrews a white plastic bottle of fluoxetine bearing a prescription label. As the cap slips loose, several small white pills tumble out, impacting precisely on the toes of a pair of rain-soaked, dark canvas shoes at his feet. Not far from the protagonist, a glass beaker of chemical solution overflows uncontrollably, producing a fine, viscous white foam that shimmers eerily under the cool blue light cast by the overhead instruments. Through the huge glass window covered with water vapor behind the character, you can see that the rain outside the window is weakening. At the same time, the waveform line on the screen of an electrocardiogram monitor tends to be flat, and the sharp, continuous beeping sound it emits gradually drowns out the sound of rain, injecting the entire picture with an extremely tense atmosphere of despair, loss of control and medical emergency.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2821,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000117/group_14/index_6429_seed_1210_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/472_0000117_group_14_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000117_group_14_sample_0_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000117_group_14_sample_0_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000117_group_14_sample_0_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000117_group_14_sample_0_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000117_group_14_sample_0_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000117_group_14_sample_0_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+473,0.01409754,foreground-background+beside-next-to,4.88400000,4,0.00548129,0.00066070,0.00321372,0.80838495,0.48772401,0.11914062,0.00013763,0000052,group_7,3,q3,Is a man with a shaved head running beside the woman with visible tension in his calf and thigh muscles?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"glossy, eye-level camera relentlessly follows a large group of marathon runners, capturing the scene in stunning, surreal detail. The camera moves at their pace, placing a few distinct runners in the foreground with razor-sharp focus. A woman with a high, swinging ponytail, rosy-faced and focused, wears a bright yellow technical vest drenched in sweat. Beside her, a man with a shaved head and a focused expression, every tense muscle fiber in his calves and thighs visible with each powerful stride. Their outfits are a vibrant, chaotic mosaic of neon green, electric blue, and hot pink, all rendered with realistic textures. Their collective action is a thunderous, rhythmic thud against the asphalt of the broad city avenue, a unified forward wave, thousands of individual bodies moving as one undulating mass. Crisp, low-angle morning sunlight filters through the scene, gleaming on their foreheads and casting long, dynamic shadows as they run. In the background, the blurred forms of cheering spectators and city buildings streak by, enhancing the profound sense of speed and unstoppable momentum, creating an epic atmosphere rich in raw determination and human endurance.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1879,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000052/group_7/index_885_seed_21559_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/473_0000052_group_7_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000052_group_7_sample_3_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000052_group_7_sample_3_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000052_group_7_sample_3_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000052_group_7_sample_3_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000052_group_7_sample_3_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000052_group_7_sample_3_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+474,0.01405464,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.44000000,5,0.00416571,0.00050687,0.00243923,0.61912614,0.44702989,0.07617188,0.00078738,0000089,group_1,0,q3,"Is a bone-shaped biscuit held by an off-screen hand visible, moving slowly and precisely left and right across the frame?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In a vertical, hand-painted image, captured in a medium close-up shot at eye level, an owner's hand, off-screen, slowly and playfully lures a golden Labrador puppy with a bone-shaped biscuit. The puppy's fluffy, warm-gold fur glows softly under the bright, warm, diffuse light. Its large, round, dark eyes gleam with desire, its pupils dilating as the biscuit moves, completely captivated by the treat. Its head sways with precise precision as the light-gold biscuit, delicately held between its fingers, slowly and precisely shifts left and right across the frame. Its pink tongue lolls out, its saliva glistening from the corner of its mouth, its greedy expression both innocent and comical. A warm, softly blurred interior background focuses the attention on this anticipatory interaction. The visual style of the entire picture resembles a classic children's book illustration, with soft lines, saturated colors and a watercolor-like texture. Every detail, from the fluffy feel of the dog's hair to the crispy texture of the biscuits, is vividly depicted, creating an atmosphere that is rich in details, full of childlike fun and warm and healing.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4136,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000089/group_1/index_621_seed_30120_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/474_0000089_group_1_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000089_group_1_sample_0_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000089_group_1_sample_0_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000089_group_1_sample_0_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000089_group_1_sample_0_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000089_group_1_sample_0_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000089_group_1_sample_0_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+475,0.01405270,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.01276264,0.00155396,0.00747245,0.81140894,0.56820583,0.08593750,0.00263464,0000169,group_5,3,q2,Do four of the men wear blue shirts in varying shades while one man wears a blue T-shirt over a long-sleeved shirt with yellow and black horizontal stripes on his arm?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures a euphoric moment as five men stand shoulder to shoulder, their arms intertwined in a powerful display of camaraderie. The group's skin tones range from fair to olive to dark brown, with a variety of hair colors and styles, including short blond, curly black, and straight dark brown. Four of the men wear blue shirts in varying shades and styles (from navy to royal), creating a sense of solidarity. A man near the center breaks the pattern by wearing a blue T-shirt over a long-sleeved shirt, with bold yellow and black horizontal stripes running down his visible arm. To the left of the frame, a man sports two simple yet thick stripes of face paint—one blue, one white—applied vertically across his left cheek. The five men collectively cheer, their heads tilted slightly back, their mouths wide open in genuine, eyebrow-raising smiles. They are posed indoors in a cozy, warmly lit room, with ambient light from an off-camera source accentuating their ecstatic expressions. The background is softly blurred, suggesting a casual living space without distracting from the subject, focusing the entire picture on the palpable atmosphere of victory celebration and deep-rooted friendship.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1128,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000169/group_5/index_5612_seed_33203_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/475_0000169_group_5_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000169_group_5_sample_3_q2__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000169_group_5_sample_3_q2__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000169_group_5_sample_3_q2__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000169_group_5_sample_3_q2__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000169_group_5_sample_3_q2__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000169_group_5_sample_3_q2__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+476,0.01399083,between-flanked,1.85600000,2,0.01311247,0.00155392,0.00770570,0.84178489,0.54019761,0.09863281,0.00206777,0000020,group_14,1,q3,"Is a massive, sea urchin-like creature with soft, plush, moss-covered spines sleeping on the pumpkin's roof?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"In the style of Ghibli animation, a sweeping wide shot, like that from a low-flying drone, glides gracefully across a vast expanse of sun-drenched, rolling meadows. The camera slowly pans right, revealing a massive, hill-sized pumpkin perched in the center of the field, its vibrant orange rind deeply grooved and textured with a soft, painterly texture. The pumpkin is meticulously carved into a rustic, whimsical house, with a small, round wooden door and several circular windows. Flanked by dense, leafy green vines, they curl around a curving, chimney-like stem at the top. The entire scene is bathed in warm, golden afternoon light, casting long, soft shadows across the tall, emerald green grass, which sways hypnotically in the breeze. A massive, sea urchin-like creature, curled up asleep on the pumpkin's roof; its spines are not sharp but soft and plush, like velvety tendrils covered in a layer of delicate green moss. As the camera settles into position, the creature begins to stir, slowly and deliberately emerging from its slumber. Its mossy spine trembles gently, and then its body unfolds section by section, a gentle and peaceful awakening that perfectly captures the serene and magical atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1497,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000020/group_14/index_287_seed_11782_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/476_0000020_group_14_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000020_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000020_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000020_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000020_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000020_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000020_group_14_sample_1_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+477,0.01397395,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00615537,0.00074326,0.00360807,0.72616118,0.50930041,0.08300781,0.00064170,0000125,group_0,0,q3,Is the setting a narrow Tokyo back alley with crisscrossing electrical wires overhead and rough concrete walls?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld camera, with a subtle, natural shakiness, follows a young man from a slightly lower, level angle as he navigates a narrow Tokyo back alley. The boy has short, shaggy dark brown hair, a loose-fitting gray hoodie, faded jeans, and scuffed white sneakers. The afternoon sun filters through the gaps between buildings and the crisscrossing electrical wires overhead, casting a shifting, interwoven pattern of light and dark on him and the rough concrete walls around him. He stops beside a vintage mint green scooter, scratched and peeling, leaning forward, one leg planted firmly on the damp asphalt, a playful smile on his focused face. He slams the starter with his right foot, but the engine only lets out a weak cough before silencing itself. Undeterred, he grins, and with amusement-filled persistence, he lifts his foot again, ready for another decisive attempt. The whole scene, with its shaky camera and warm lighting, is full of youthful energy and an effortless, casual sense of urban life, creating a relaxed and hopeful leisure atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4048,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000125/group_0/index_5886_seed_33483_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f80,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/477_0000125_group_0_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000125_group_0_sample_0_q3__f80__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000125_group_0_sample_0_q3__f80__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000125_group_0_sample_0_q3__f80__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000125_group_0_sample_0_q3__f80__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000125_group_0_sample_0_q3__f80__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000125_group_0_sample_0_q3__f80__window3_gt_window7.png
+478,0.01389226,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.00346676,0.00040833,0.00203895,0.53713882,0.33958694,0.15527344,0.00034070,0000037,group_5,3,q2,Is the woman wearing a faded gray oversized T-shirt and dark blue leggings with dark brown hair in a messy ponytail?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,776,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4759_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/478_0000037_group_5_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+479,0.01389197,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.01861863,0.00219740,0.01094749,0.51491028,0.31035754,0.20019531,0.00321081,0000131,group_10,3,q1,Is the scene set on a desolate mountain ridge with a weathered beacon tower made of massive stone blocks nearby?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium shot, shot from an upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward, focusing on an ancient soldier perched atop a desolate mountain ridge. Beside him stands a weathered beacon tower, constructed of massive stone blocks, its surface covered in cracks and moss, a silent witness to the howling wind. The soldier's long, black hair is tied back, strands whipping wildly against his weathered face in the biting wind. He wears a suit of worn, dark iron scale armor, its plates scarred by past battles. The hem of his dark, coarse linen tabard flaps violently in the wind. His feet, firmly planted on the rough ground, he draws a massive longbow made of dark, knotty wood with controlled force, the bow creaking mournfully under the immense tension. As the bowstring is drawn to his cheek, the muscles of his arms and back visibly tense beneath his armor, making him look like a statue poised for action. His brow furrowed, his lips pursed, his eyes narrowed in the gusting wind, but his cold, resolute gaze, sharp as an eagle's, fixed its gaze firmly on an invisible target beyond the camera. In the sky, thick, dark clouds rolled rapidly, and the pale, setting sun struggled to cast a faint, cold light, painting the entire scene with a dominant gray-blue hue. The light outlined the cold metal contours of the armor and the rough texture of the rocks, creating an epic atmosphere of loneliness, awe, and resolute will.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2398,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000131/group_10/index_9686_seed_32977_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f36,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/479_0000131_group_10_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000131_group_10_sample_3_q1__f36__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000131_group_10_sample_3_q1__f36__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000131_group_10_sample_3_q1__f36__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000131_group_10_sample_3_q1__f36__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000131_group_10_sample_3_q1__f36__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000131_group_10_sample_3_q1__f36__window3_gt_window7.png
+480,0.01385497,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.07200000,4,0.00428400,0.00053128,0.00250181,0.64461267,0.48027754,0.08300781,0.00035998,0000105,group_14,1,q2,"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium close-up shot from a level angle, slightly handheld and imbued with a subtle sense of shakiness, instantly draws the viewer into the bustling and vibrant atmosphere of a wet market. At the center of the frame is an elderly woman with a wrinkled face and graying hair tied in a simple bun. Time has carved deep grooves into her tanned skin, but her eyes are remarkably sharp and focused. She wears a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock, the fabric defined by its distinct texture and soft creases from repeated washing. Standing before a vegetable stall piled high with vibrant greens, carrots dusted with fresh soil, and plump tomatoes, she leans forward slightly, extending her age-freckled right hand. With her index and middle fingers, she decisively indicates a price, her lips pursed as she speaks rapidly and forcefully to the vendor off-screen. In her left hand, she clutches a woven bamboo basket, its edges frayed. The tarpaulin overhead casts dappled shadows, while a few suspended incandescent bulbs emit a warm, dim glow, illuminating the dust and moisture floating in the air and creating a stark contrast between the vibrant colors of the vegetables and the dark clothing of the elderly woman. The entire scene, shrouded in warm tones, exudes an atmosphere both tense and full of life, perfectly capturing the uncompromising moments of everyday transactions.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1224,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_8676_seed_3867_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/480_0000105_group_14_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000105_group_14_sample_1_q2__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+481,0.01379404,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01311818,0.00158857,0.00768641,0.62475115,0.39159513,0.13867188,0.00167426,0000111,group_12,2,q1,Is the main subject an elderly woman with wrinkled eyes and warm brown skin?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium close-up tracking shot moves slowly and steadily with an elderly woman, her face a beautiful map of time, kind, wrinkled eyes, and a deep smile etched across her warm brown skin. Her silver-gray hair is neatly pulled back in a simple bun. She is draped in a traditional handwoven cotton sari in earthy tones of ochre and deep terracotta, with a simple embroidered border. She stands in a sun-drenched room, brimming with rustic charm, its uneven, plastered earth walls gleaming in the golden light of late afternoon. A bright ray of sunlight filters through a small, unglazed window, illuminating countless motes of dust dancing in the air. With a practiced, deliberate grace, she holds a thin, dark incense stick between her thumb and index finger. Her other hand holds a lit match to the tip, the small flame casting a fleeting, flickering warmth across her focused features. She held it until the tip glowed a vibrant orange, then blew gently, extinguishing the flame and releasing a thin, fragrant stream of gray-white smoke that curled gracefully upward, catching the light as it rose into the sunlight, creating a serene and deeply spiritual atmosphere of quiet reverence.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,739,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000111/group_12/index_9620_seed_15361_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/481_0000111_group_12_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000111_group_12_sample_2_q1__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+482,0.01376671,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01205883,0.00143607,0.00708184,0.70397931,0.44464898,0.11816406,0.00255060,0000144,group_2,3,q3,Is a boy approximately ten years old wearing a blue and white striped T-shirt visible hunched over a wooden desk?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"The film begins with a close-up of a wall clock, its hour and minute hands spinning at a visible speed, creating a series of blurry afterimages. The camera then smoothly pulls back to reveal a dimly lit children's study. At the center of the frame, a boy, approximately ten years old, wearing a blue and white striped T-shirt, hunched over a wooden desk piled high with textbooks and workbooks. He desperately tugs his hands into his tousled black hair, his fingers tugging at the roots, his body trembling with silent frustration. An old-fashioned desk lamp provides the sole source of light, its warm yellow glow illuminating the mess on the desk while casting long, deep shadows across the rest of the room. Behind him, a mother in a gray cardigan stands quietly at the edge of the shadows, her brow furrowed, her lips pressed into a serious line, her gaze darting back and forth intently at the thin report card in her hand. The scene creates a stark contrast between the rapid passage of time and the characters' frozen anxiety, creating a suffocating, stressful domestic atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3546,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000144/group_2/index_3703_seed_15964_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/482_0000144_group_2_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q3__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q3__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q3__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q3__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q3__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000144_group_2_sample_3_q3__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+483,0.01367935,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01181351,0.00139859,0.00694328,0.78997868,0.45602611,0.12500000,0.00013131,0000169,group_2,0,q3,Is one warrior wearing crimson and black armor with a men-yoroi (ghost mask) helmet and lunging with a katana?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow-motion, arcing pan shot from a low angle captures a fierce duel between two miniature samurai warriors across a cluttered wooden desk. One warrior, clad in ornate crimson and black armor and a helmet bearing a men-yoroi (ghost mask), stands in a powerful lunge, his katana gripped tightly in both hands, slashing fiercely from above. His opponent, clad in more austere blue and silver armor, leans back, his legs planted firmly on a pile of books, and with a precise upward block, his blade securely blocks the opponent's blow. The blades of the two swords clash in mid-air, sparking a dazzling explosion. The shockwave sends a mountain of manuscript paper flying upward, sending countless pages of elegant calligraphy swirling and tumbling wildly through the air, surrounding the combatants like a blizzard. In the background, a classical desk lamp casts a warm and concentrated beam, illuminating the black ink flowing from the overturned ink bottle, as well as the scattered brushes and books. The light outlines sharp contours on the metal surface of the armor and the edges of the flying paper, casting long, dancing shadows. The whole scene is filled with a tense sense of confrontation and dynamic violent aesthetics, creating an epic yet surreal atmosphere confined to a small space.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2755,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000169/group_2/index_866_seed_28904_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/483_0000169_group_2_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000169_group_2_sample_0_q3__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+484,0.01366616,between-flanked,1.98400000,3,0.01275479,0.00156186,0.00746195,0.72310913,0.48086008,0.09863281,0.00218475,0000161,group_7,0,q3,Is the man's white shirt ripped at the collar with a crimson silk tie hanging loosely and swinging?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"low-angle, dynamic tracking shot follows a man sprinting along a rainy city street. The camera stays in sync with him, emphasizing the speed and force of his run. The man, in his thirties, wears a well-tailored, dark charcoal gray suit, now completely soaked by the downpour, the expensive fabric clinging to his contours. His once-pristine white shirt is ripped at the collar, a crimson silk tie hanging loosely, swinging with his movements. The rain dampens his short, dark hair, strands clinging to his forehead and cheeks. His expression is tense, his jaw clenched, and his eyes reveal a mixture of despair and unwavering focus. Directly ahead of him lies a wide asphalt road, its surface a black mirror in the relentless rain, greedily reflecting the shimmering, iridescent neon lights of the tall buildings on either side—psychedelic pinks, cool blues, and glaring reds. With each strenuous step forward, his polished black Oxfords slammed heavily into the puddle, sending up circles of shimmering, neon-lit water, forming brief, dazzling arcs in the camera. The entire scene is imbued with a tense, urgent atmosphere, like a climactic chase scene in a neo-noir film. The stark contrast between the cool tones of the frame and the saturated neon highlights creates a dramatic tension that is both flamboyant and desperate.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3491,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000161/group_7/index_3558_seed_20761_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/484_0000161_group_7_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q3__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q3__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q3__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q3__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q3__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000161_group_7_sample_0_q3__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+485,0.01363994,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.62000000,5,0.00590287,0.00070723,0.00346376,0.70456487,0.44565222,0.12207031,0.00206840,0000077,group_1,3,q4,Is the man's right hand gripping a silver EQ knob between his thumb and index finger to adjust it?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, medium-close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a man immersed in musical composition. He has short, dark brown hair and wears a pair of professional black headphones. He rhythmically and immersively nods his head up and down to the rhythmic music, his eyes slightly closed, his expression intensely focused. He is in a dimly lit recording studio, facing a complex professional mixing console, its surface densely packed with faders and illuminated buttons. His right hand's fingers move delicately and precisely across the control panel, carefully gripping a silver EQ knob between his thumb and index finger, steadily and deliberately adjusting it to find the perfect tonal balance. The only light comes from the multicolored LEDs flashing on the mixing console and the screens of the various devices in the background. These dynamic dots of light cast shifting shadows on his face, emphasizing his simple black T-shirt and his focused profile. The whole picture is based on deep dark tones, dotted with blue, red and green light emitted by the equipment, creating an intimate, passionate and creative atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3693,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000077/group_1/index_3928_seed_17717_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/485_0000077_group_1_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q4__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q4__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q4__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q4__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q4__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000077_group_1_sample_3_q4__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+486,0.01360265,beside-next-to,1.86000000,3,0.01484391,0.00176622,0.00871846,0.70007145,0.40769923,0.12890625,0.00369579,0000136,group_0,1,q4,"Does the scene transition from the queen's eyes closed to her opening them to reveal icy blue, hawk-like eyes?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, focusing on a queen. A magnificent, heavy golden crown, inlaid with crimson gems and intricate baroque carvings, weighed heavily on her forehead. A few cascading strands of raven hair cascaded from the crown's edge, draping around her pale, sharply defined face. She wore a deep purple velvet gown with intricate silver embroidery at the collar, which shimmered faintly in the dim light. Her setting was a grand but dimly lit Gothic palace hall, the only faint light coming from the cool moonlight filtering through the distant high windows and the flickering flames of a few candles in silver candlesticks beside her, casting long, twisted shadows on the massive stone pillars in the background. At first, her eyes were closed, her face calm, yet a subtle hint of fatigue lingered. Then, slowly, with an almost palpable weight, she lifted her long lashes. The warm candlelight traced a soft golden edge along the contours of her cheeks. When her eyes fully opened, a pair of icy blue, hawk-like eyes were revealed. Their gaze, without a trace of hesitation, pierced the camera directly and resolutely. The entire scene, interwoven with the cold moonlight and the warm candlelight, was filled with a solemn, awe-inspiring, and powerful atmosphere, as if a silent storm was brewing in the midst of her decision.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4601,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000136/group_0/index_8451_seed_20630_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/486_0000136_group_0_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000136_group_0_sample_1_q4__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000136_group_0_sample_1_q4__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000136_group_0_sample_1_q4__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000136_group_0_sample_1_q4__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000136_group_0_sample_1_q4__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000136_group_0_sample_1_q4__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
+487,0.01359254,between-flanked,2.36800000,6,0.00924303,0.00109317,0.00543324,0.86208153,0.61658370,0.07519531,0.00335205,0000059,group_14,0,q3,Is the woman wearing a simple light blue sundress with long blond hair?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, deliberate, medium shot, at eye level, begins the film's depiction of a couple in a tender embrace on a sun-drenched wooden deck. The man, with soft brown hair and dressed in a loose-fitting cream linen shirt, rests his hands gently on the woman's back. The woman, her long blond hair gleaming in the sunlight, is dressed in a simple light blue sundress. Her arms gently drape around his neck, her head resting on his shoulder, her eyes peacefully closed. The bright afternoon sun casts a warm golden glow across the scene, highlighting the grain of the deck's weathered cedar planks and creating soft, long shadows. As the camera smoothly slides forward, the frame tightens into an intimate close-up, focusing on their serene expressions and the tender connection between them. The lush, out-of-focus greenery of the background garden blurs into a soft bokeh, enhancing the deeply romantic and tranquil atmosphere of the moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2526,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000059/group_14/index_5279_seed_25403_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/487_0000059_group_14_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q3__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q3__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q3__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q3__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q3__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000059_group_14_sample_0_q3__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+488,0.01347568,left-right-pair+left-side-right-side,9.47200000,6,0.00331378,0.00038972,0.00194938,0.55684489,0.34996304,0.15332031,0.00009763,0000037,group_5,3,q3,Does the woman sweep the floor using a traditional straw broom with a long worn wooden handle?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures a spacious, sun-drenched artist's loft with a polished concrete floor. Initially positioned on the right side of the frame, a woman, bent at the waist, is visible from behind. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a slightly messy ponytail, and she wears a faded gray, oversized T-shirt and comfortable dark blue leggings. With both hands, she firmly grasps the long, worn wooden handle of a traditional straw broom, her posture conveying focused effort. She carefully sweeps the floor with short, rhythmic strokes. Then, in a swift, fluid motion, she moves further toward the right edge of the frame before decisively spinning counterclockwise with her heel. Now, in profile, her face expressive of concentration, she begins sweeping again, this time with long, deliberate strokes, a small cloud of dust in front of her as she steadily moves across the expanse of floor toward the left side of the screen. Warm, golden late afternoon sunlight filters through the large, dusty windows, casting long shadows and illuminating the dancing dust motes in the air, creating a quiet, industrial atmosphere of tranquility and focus.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2716,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000037/group_5/index_726_seed_4759_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f09,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/488_0000037_group_5_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q3__f09__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q3__f09__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q3__f09__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q3__f09__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q3__f09__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000037_group_5_sample_3_q3__f09__window3_gt_window7.png
+489,0.01344449,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01207059,0.00142957,0.00709402,0.74978065,0.46471721,0.11035156,0.00167722,0000123,group_6,1,q2,Is an elderly man with silver hair in a neat bun visible in the center of the frame?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"long shot, beginning from a slightly upward angle and slowly advancing forward, transports us into a world shrouded in a milky morning mist. A weathered arched stone bridge spans the center of the frame, its slippery slabs dotted with moss, its railings etched with the marks of age. In the center of the bridge, an elderly man, silver hair pulled back into a neat bun, dressed in a loose-fitting white silk training suit, is immersed in a Tai Chi practice. His face is gaunt, wrinkled with wisdom, his eyes slightly closed, his expression serene and focused. With his slow, fluid movements, his arms trace gentle arcs like flowing clouds and water, his weight shifting steadily and effortlessly between his legs, his wide sleeves fluttering softly. The first soft rays of morning light penetrated the mist, casting a faint golden halo on his outline and silver hair, forming a subtle contrast with the cool, gray-green background tones around him. The whole picture was filled with an otherworldly sense of tranquility and concentration, as if time had frozen at this moment.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2493,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000123/group_6/index_488_seed_12201_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/489_0000123_group_6_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000123_group_6_sample_1_q2__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000123_group_6_sample_1_q2__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000123_group_6_sample_1_q2__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000123_group_6_sample_1_q2__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000123_group_6_sample_1_q2__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000123_group_6_sample_1_q2__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+490,0.01338957,foreground-background,3.08000000,5,0.00860276,0.00104432,0.00503896,0.65370947,0.44776079,0.11132812,0.00057665,0000137,group_10,2,q4,Does the background show a steel guardrail in the foreground and a calm body of water beyond a grass bank?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"medium side-on tracking shot moves perfectly parallel to a green and white Kawasaki sportbike as it glides effortlessly along a coastal highway under a clear, sunny sky. The rider, dressed head-to-toe in a fitted black leather riding suit and a shiny black full-face helmet with a dark visor, maintains a steady, focused upright posture, hands expertly gripping the handlebars. The motorcycle's vibrant lime green and crisp white aerodynamic fairing gleams with a metallic sheen, reflecting the bright sunlight as it moves at a constant, steady pace. The background is a fluid blur of motion: a continuous steel guardrail stripes past in the foreground, while beyond it, a lush grass bank gently slopes down to a vast, calm body of water, shimmering in the sunlight. The entire scene is imbued with a high-contrast, vivid color palette, creating an atmosphere of quiet power and exhilarating freedom as rider and machine move as one through the landscape.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4030,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000137/group_10/index_1028_seed_30746_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/490_0000137_group_10_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000137_group_10_sample_2_q4__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000137_group_10_sample_2_q4__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000137_group_10_sample_2_q4__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000137_group_10_sample_2_q4__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000137_group_10_sample_2_q4__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000137_group_10_sample_2_q4__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+491,0.01335367,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01178041,0.00141117,0.00691282,0.79627317,0.48165897,0.11132812,0.00015825,0000166,group_5,2,q2,Is the other phoenix carved from translucent ice crystals with sapphire/cyan feathers and icy eyes?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"magnificent 360-degree slow-motion shot, shot from a slightly upward perspective, captures the epic battle between two mythical phoenixes amidst a turbulent sky swirling with dark storm clouds. One phoenix is composed entirely of flowing magma and incandescent fire, each feather a pure, pulsating crimson and gold flame. Its eyes are like blazing embers, and its flight leaves a dazzling trail of sparks and embers in its wake. The other phoenix, in stark contrast, is carved from translucent ice crystals, its feathers razor-sharp icicles gleaming with sapphire and cyan. Its wings, with their beats, scatter countless tiny, glittering frost particles, and its icy eyes are like distant stars. The camera smoothly rotates around them, capturing every detail as they swirl, dive, and claw at each other in a deadly aerial ballet: the fire phoenix folds its wings sharply, swooping down like a flaming meteor, while the ice phoenix gracefully sideways, blocking with the edge of its crystal wings. When the camera rotates to the optimal angle, the two divine birds have a fierce head-on collision. The burning feathers collide with the icy feathers, and a dazzling energy shock wave instantly erupts - the hot sparks hiss and turn into steam when they come into contact with the cold air, while the hard ice crystals explode into countless glittering fragments under the high temperature, intertwined with the falling and extinguished flame feathers, forming a destructive picture full of primitive power and magnificent beauty. The whole scene, with the extreme contrast of warm and cold colors, creates a tense, intense and sacred fantasy atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1359,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000166/group_5/index_6042_seed_32801_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f62,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/491_0000166_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q2__f62__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q2__f62__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q2__f62__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q2__f62__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q2__f62__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000166_group_5_sample_2_q2__f62__window3_gt_window7.png
+492,0.01328677,foreground-background,2.72800000,3,0.01036109,0.00122624,0.00608990,0.65376276,0.39705423,0.14062500,0.00097221,0000094,group_0,3,q3,"Is there a central group of pale figures, including one in a dark purple robe shouting with an agape mouth and contorted face?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures the tense scene, rendered in a clean, graphic animation style against a deep blue void. Thin, sharp white lines radiate outward from an invisible point off-screen, creating a stark web-like pattern that defines the abstract space. In the center, several pale figures gather. The leftmost figure, frozen in mid-shouting, their mouths agape, their faces contorted in pain in silent despair, clad in a heavy, dark purple robe. Just behind them, a second figure in a somber gray robe places a steady hand on the shouting figure's shoulder, a gesture of comfort or restraint, their own expression serious and focused. The relative stillness of the central group contrasts sharply with the surrounding chaos, as blurred, shadowy outlines race through the foreground and background, their forms blurred and ghostly. The lighting is harsh and cool, casting sharp shadows that highlight the pale tones of their skin against the saturated colors of their purple, pink, and gray robes, creating a dark and tense atmosphere that freezes a moment of high-stakes drama and emotional crisis.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,1811,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000094/group_0/index_2342_seed_31536_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f53,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/492_0000094_group_0_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000094_group_0_sample_3_q3__f53__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000094_group_0_sample_3_q3__f53__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000094_group_0_sample_3_q3__f53__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000094_group_0_sample_3_q3__f53__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000094_group_0_sample_3_q3__f53__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000094_group_0_sample_3_q3__f53__window3_gt_window7.png
+493,0.01322329,between-flanked,2.24000000,5,0.01021097,0.00125492,0.00597070,0.78959084,0.54413247,0.08496094,0.00150436,0000160,group_10,2,q5,"Does the man wipe dirt from the ring, move his lips as if narrating, and turn his head to the left before returning his gaze?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium close-up depicts a man with a neatly trimmed dark brown beard, wearing a heather-gray cotton short-sleeved shirt and a dark blue baseball cap. He stands in the center of a sun-drenched meadow, the soft-focus background revealing tall green grass and scattered yellow wildflowers in the warm, golden afternoon light. His gaze is intently directed downward at a small metal ring delicately held between the thumb and index finger of each hand. He carefully wipes away specks of dark dirt from the surface, his lips moving as he speaks, narrating his actions with an air of focused discovery. He fluidly turns his head momentarily to the left, as if to greet someone off-screen, before quickly returning his gaze to the precious object in his hands, his expression a mixture of concentration and quiet excitement.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3505,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000160/group_10/index_3321_seed_14243_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/493_0000160_group_10_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q5__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q5__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q5__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q5__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q5__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000160_group_10_sample_2_q5__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+494,0.01318933,beside-next-to+between-flanked,3.84400000,3,0.00600740,0.00072505,0.00352156,0.77080739,0.54214227,0.08300781,0.00042164,0000132,group_7,1,q4,Does the scene include a vast river reflecting a bright full moon with rolling hills in the misty distance?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, zoomed-out shot, starting from a slightly upward angle, first focuses on a massive bluestone by the river, bathed in moonlight. The great Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai reclines, half-drunk and intoxicated. His long, dark hair, undone by a bun, a few wet strands clinging to his drunken face. His features are rendered with remarkable clarity by the cool moonlight. He wears a flowing white silk robe with wide sleeves, the collar slightly open, revealing faint stains of dark wine on the folds. The hem of the robe falls limply on the mossy stone surface. His eyes are lightly closed, a faint, detached smile playing on his lips. His body is relaxed, his chest rising and falling with his deep, steady breathing. Beside him, an antique bronze wine jug has fallen, half-emptied between the moist moss and soil. The last drops of wine seem to linger on the mouth, reflecting a faint glow in the moonlight. As the camera steadily and deliberately pulls back, a wider scene is revealed: the vast river, like a vast black jade in the still night, a bright full moon casts a clear glow in the sky, spreading a fragmented, shimmering silver band across the water. In the distance, the inky silhouettes of rolling hills shrouded in mist. Nearby, a few clumps of reeds sway gently in the night breeze, rustling softly. The entire scene exudes a sense of ultimate tranquility and poetic solitude. The dominant color palette is deep blue-black and silver-white, and the strong contrast of light and shadow creates an otherworldly, classical aesthetic atmosphere of detachment from the world.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,2608,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000132/group_7/index_6699_seed_26357_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f44,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/494_0000132_group_7_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q4__f44__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q4__f44__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q4__f44__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q4__f44__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q4__f44__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000132_group_7_sample_1_q4__f44__window3_gt_window7.png
+495,0.01318537,left-right-pair+between-flanked,6.44000000,5,0.00406424,0.00048683,0.00238494,0.70626158,0.45170462,0.11718750,0.00170988,0000136,group_9,0,q4,Does the man place a glass jar with a plain metal lid onto the bottom shelf of the cabinet?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, eye-level medium shot captures the scene in a brightly lit modern kitchen. A man with slightly tousled brown hair casually walks toward a set of lower cabinets. He wears a red and white checkered, short-sleeved button-down shirt and contrasting teal checkered shorts, creating a relaxed, homely look. He pauses before a white, rickety cabinet and reaches down deliberately, his fingers grasping the small, brushed metal knob. He smoothly pulls the door open, revealing shelves filled with a messy yet organized pantry: an assortment of unlabeled glass jars, colorful tins, and plain cardboard boxes. Holding a simple glass jar with a plain metal lid in his right hand, he takes a step closer, bending slightly at his knees and waist, and carefully reaches into the cabinet. Steadily and accurately, he places the jar on the bottom shelf, nestled between a stack of jars and a box. Once his fingers release the jar, he straightens and begins to rotate his body to the left. As he begins to turn away from the open cabinet, his movements are fluid and unhurried, completing a simple chore. The scene is bathed in warm, soft light from overhead fixtures, creating a comfortable and tranquil atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,45,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000136/group_9/index_5875_seed_11771_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4,f27,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/495_0000136_group_9_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q4__f27__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q4__f27__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q4__f27__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q4__f27__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q4__f27__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000136_group_9_sample_0_q4__f27__window3_gt_window7.png
+496,0.01318245,beside-next-to,2.46000000,8,0.00990428,0.00118843,0.00581056,0.81018567,0.49132472,0.10937500,0.00041789,0000127,group_8,1,q3,"Does the scene show a cluttered dining room with a large wooden table buried under books, papers, and cables?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"The camera pans right, following a man in his early thirties as he enters a cluttered dining room, the camera at eye level. He has slightly tousled brown hair and wears a simple gray cotton hoodie and dark jeans, his brow furrowed in concentration. He clutches a sleek black tablet in both hands, his gaze fixed on its glowing screen, and walks purposefully toward a large wooden dining table buried beneath piles of books, loose papers, and a tangle of cables. He stops beside the table and carefully places the tablet on a small transparent surface. Then, his eyes scan the chaos, and with quick, decisive action, he picks up a closed silver laptop. He leaves the table and deliberately lowers himself to the hardwood floor, sitting cross-legged with his back against a plain off-white wall. He places the laptop on his lap, opens it, and immediately begins typing rapidly and intently, his face bathed in the cool, bluish-white glow of the screen. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, indirect morning light streaming through a large window, creating an atmosphere of quiet concentration that contrasts sharply with the room's visual chaos.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,584,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000127/group_8/index_3516_seed_21356_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/496_0000127_group_8_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000127_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000127_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000127_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000127_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000127_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000127_group_8_sample_1_q3__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+497,0.01313575,beside-next-to+between-flanked,3.84400000,3,0.00560208,0.00070461,0.00326498,0.79534161,0.60833508,0.06835938,0.00005692,0000062,group_1,3,q3,"Is the setting a vast, sun-drenched atrium with a grand staircase of wide, immaculate white marble steps and minimalist glass railings?",Yes,Yes,Yes,"static, low-angle shot gazes upon a state-of-the-art stair-climbing wheelchair, situated at the foot of a grand staircase within a vast, sun-drenched atrium. This machine is an engineering marvel, constructed from a blend of matte black carbon fiber and polished silver aluminum, its metal surface catching bright highlights from the ambient light. Instead of traditional wheels, it features a complex, sturdy track system made of thick, grippy rubber, primed for climbing. The scene is set against the backdrop of a grand staircase composed of wide, immaculate white marble steps that ascend out of frame, flanked by sleek, minimalist glass railings. Bright, warm sunlight filters through the vast floor-to-ceiling windows off-camera, casting long, softly edged shadows across the highly polished concrete floor and illuminating a cloud of dust dancing in the still air. With a near-silent, high-frequency hum, the wheelchair begins a slow, deliberate rotation, one track system maintaining its position while another engages, causing the chassis to rotate with unwavering mechanical precision. This meticulous movement helps to perfectly align the machine with the base of the first step, creating a moment of immersion in an atmosphere of tranquility and concentration, where the profound silence of the vast space emphasizes the elegance and purpose of the technology, ready to face the challenge.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4231,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000062/group_1/index_9031_seed_1626_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/497_0000062_group_1_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000062_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000062_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000062_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000062_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000062_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000062_group_1_sample_3_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+498,0.01312365,opposite-across+between-flanked,4.88400000,6,0.00615002,0.00073543,0.00360973,0.61580771,0.36041468,0.16210938,0.00194126,0000039,group_7,1,q4,Does the central action involve a transaction where a green fiberglass circuit board is exchanged for a dirty plastic bottle of clear water?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"slow, eye-level camera drifts across a sprawling post-apocalyptic market, huddled beneath a patchwork canopy of rusted corrugated metal shelters. Sharp, bright sunlight pierces a series of bullet holes in the roof, piercing the dim, shadowy space and illuminating the thick, swirling dust. The camera's steady movement focuses on a central exchange, where a gaunt, weathered scavenger with a scraggly gray beard, dressed in a tattered ensemble of canvas and leather, carefully pulls out a green fiberglass circuit board, its intricate silver paths gleaming. Opposite him, a young scavenger, his eyes wary, his face smeared with grime, clutches a dirty plastic bottle of clear water in his hands, his posture tense. The transaction proceeds with a slow, deliberate gravity; hands hover, inspecting the goods, and then the circuit board is eventually exchanged for the bottle in a silent, desperate exchange. In the background, other figures shuttle between stalls filled with recycled solar panels and the faded, torn remnants of faded banners. At the edge of the makeshift settlement, a massive wind turbine cobbled together from scrap metal churns with a rhythmic clatter, stirring up dust on the ground and underscoring the scene’s pervasive atmosphere of quiet despair, all rendered in a desaturated, earthy palette of rusty orange, dusty brown, and metallic gray.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4293,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000039/group_7/index_3930_seed_13381_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f71,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/498_0000039_group_7_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000039_group_7_sample_1_q4__f71__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000039_group_7_sample_1_q4__f71__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000039_group_7_sample_1_q4__f71__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000039_group_7_sample_1_q4__f71__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000039_group_7_sample_1_q4__f71__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000039_group_7_sample_1_q4__f71__window3_gt_window7.png
+499,0.01310173,beside-next-to+between-flanked,4.09200000,4,0.00595147,0.00070515,0.00349755,0.74991667,0.47943464,0.09375000,0.00012672,0000125,group_0,1,q3,Is the setting a narrow Tokyo back alley with crisscrossing electrical wires overhead and rough concrete walls?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"handheld camera, with a subtle, natural shakiness, follows a young man from a slightly lower, level angle as he navigates a narrow Tokyo back alley. The boy has short, shaggy dark brown hair, a loose-fitting gray hoodie, faded jeans, and scuffed white sneakers. The afternoon sun filters through the gaps between buildings and the crisscrossing electrical wires overhead, casting a shifting, interwoven pattern of light and dark on him and the rough concrete walls around him. He stops beside a vintage mint green scooter, scratched and peeling, leaning forward, one leg planted firmly on the damp asphalt, a playful smile on his focused face. He slams the starter with his right foot, but the engine only lets out a weak cough before silencing itself. Undeterred, he grins, and with amusement-filled persistence, he lifts his foot again, ready for another decisive attempt. The whole scene, with its shaky camera and warm lighting, is full of youthful energy and an effortless, casual sense of urban life, creating a relaxed and hopeful leisure atmosphere.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,4050,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000125/group_0/index_5886_seed_33484_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4,f00,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/499_0000125_group_0_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000125_group_0_sample_1_q3__f00__window3_gt_window7.png
+500,0.01308214,between-flanked,2.11200000,4,0.01057656,0.00126062,0.00621063,0.80362886,0.55478162,0.08300781,0.00122517,0000075,group_10,3,q2,Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?,Yes,Yes,Yes,"dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot captures the stunning spectacle of a heavily tattooed demon practicing in the night. His vibrant pink hair dances with his movements, contrasting sharply with his sharp, angular, demonic features. His bare torso and arms are covered in intricate, ancient blue runic tattoos that seem alive, emitting a faint inner glow in the light. The scene is dramatically torn between two contrasting light sources: on one side, a full moon hangs high in the night sky, casting a cool, eerie blue glow that outlines one side of his taut, muscled body; on the other, a blazing bonfire, its warm, leaping orange flames off-screen, illuminating the other side, creating a stark contrast of light and dark and a long, dancing shadow. He is engaged in a Tai Chi ""Cloud Hands"" pose, shifting his weight with a steady hand, his arms gliding through the air with a grace that seems slow but holds a terrifying power. Each seemingly gentle movement triggers a violent reaction in the surrounding environment—the dust and fallen leaves beneath his feet are swept up by invisible air currents, forming a miniature vortex around him, clearly demonstrating the destructive power precisely controlled in every subtle movement. The rotating camera intensifies this sense of turbulence, constantly interweaving the light and shadow of the cold moonlight and the warm campfire, creating an atmosphere that is both sacred and extremely dangerous, full of turbulence and mysterious power.",/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/object_requirement_payloads_top5000.jsonl,3271,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-window3/rl_samples/0000075/group_10/index_6396_seed_882_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4,f18,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/500_0000075_group_10_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/original/0000075_group_10_sample_3_q2__f18__original.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine-map/0000075_group_10_sample_3_q2__f18__fine-map.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3/0000075_group_10_sample_3_q2__f18__window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window7/0000075_group_10_sample_3_q2__f18__window7.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/fine_gt_window3/0000075_group_10_sample_3_q2__f18__fine_gt_window3.png,/nfs/ywang29/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/by_category_top1/window3_gt_window7/0000075_group_10_sample_3_q2__f18__window3_gt_window7.png
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/001_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/001_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f909ded3177fb5c306e4d9a2dad70809944924ab
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/001_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:0b3a420af289061a33579f18a93ba71ea8bcff1989b4c0ff969116667b2d067d
+size 295447
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/002_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/002_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a7f901cdb593c36244f365c4870cd9222ca59c91
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/002_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:9a264071aa1ed1ddbf6b4ab4f5ffdeb563fce74213df58894cc37b4cc0992730
+size 294535
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/003_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/003_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1b0743c4e794067ff65c1c58671bc9e7e5c65e45
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/003_0000008_group_14_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:ca42a937f1be5b6b7fcb2109fa36443a91c806d5a77124d72b411b716e213d38
+size 296406
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/004_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/004_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ecb163906467039984ec91f5154c458c259987b8
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/004_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:cb91449a2b85ed8cd27e711cc315ff4c5a1ea1ab721b8183dae6225ba332d3c9
+size 183073
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/005_0000123_group_11_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/005_0000123_group_11_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1ece8a41cfda6338a07195cc7cb2529809fbb0cc
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/005_0000123_group_11_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:b3929b75da5436c181ad2983292a1b882cadab7ee241c4b6b0d0b46016bc728b
+size 303702
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/006_0000037_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/006_0000037_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5300153b8dc62b7cadaa319303565b209bde78f0
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/006_0000037_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:55f9f5834226b87cba0818e972c941846b1576473742813fc4a023454b919d86
+size 220627
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/007_0000037_group_5_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/007_0000037_group_5_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1159145817bd9d542d64474dd6e044128d0b111b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/007_0000037_group_5_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:147afd3a67338447bbc3b8ccbd9986975feae2f8c21c2b4d8f8bc750230eac7c
+size 221576
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/008_0000008_group_14_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/008_0000008_group_14_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9e2620e969553999c8ca57ce6dcbae50c13e626d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/008_0000008_group_14_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:e209ded3c57d40a24c478250d505e063c975dbb108cb73187cb19b5cb8451c4b
+size 246619
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/009_0000008_group_14_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/009_0000008_group_14_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0a6d9d640ee7d5c5696b3ecca88ae477549e93e4
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/009_0000008_group_14_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:77eb76abcbcf078bf49e145f364245ac0dec9621d1e707bfc7b7d9521d499c2e
+size 246515
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/010_0000077_group_1_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/010_0000077_group_1_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..acc7317f56f338e583ce32b8fd589f4daf1b7b78
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/010_0000077_group_1_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:0c36d9c032bf32cdaf5bbbbcf298a16fdcb65b2cb1d87dd00b4cf4455a762b44
+size 233073
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/011_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/011_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b61a026a7e98ee7d2d9a908637f794803c87d16c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/011_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:61d70936122cd6d2d02d5eb1f9d159f8c79248c02af4fa2f639699155d55eb07
+size 203007
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/012_0000062_group_15_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/012_0000062_group_15_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ea895a364714a8e017ba4cf9698207c21687e0e8
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/012_0000062_group_15_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:b452e67ef5891a1b98af2b7b1e2769fd119b9613c6fba9c335b64d28637552ff
+size 259507
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/013_0000127_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/013_0000127_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9c32bbb70d0bf32653f0de2efe8eada6005e336b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/013_0000127_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:7b678468c552e86318423c99a2763dff1be08911f146f2880e4123df4f3f0f51
+size 254812
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/014_0000002_group_9_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/014_0000002_group_9_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bba62c739a80e938b550ad173da671506b4a1fd9
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/014_0000002_group_9_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:9a71816f8a152fd9fccba388abb76788ca35ea78c9d241954e9c10f12bf609a5
+size 211357
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/015_0000002_group_5_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/015_0000002_group_5_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..992430fd3f089c9bd306d228431f2bca43d10378
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/015_0000002_group_5_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:bfaf811846052bbcd365802166b81b143e8775bfcc2a897e42844d28f27ac65c
+size 221444
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/016_0000067_group_15_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/016_0000067_group_15_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6a16856d32392d348a966782fdb1fb8227730da4
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/016_0000067_group_15_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:13f2c98bb6fb480d80ec9709e0097ea248c0d0fe10432dc73d6400d1d0c2e6e9
+size 280364
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/017_0000030_group_9_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/017_0000030_group_9_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5ba02fd3f97ee8c0fd1777f8d80059fa85643175
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/017_0000030_group_9_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:e12e5c4b8a6b15d1468e4632ad0450658a92a8908b101d3d88a9e282557e67a4
+size 231248
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/018_0000039_group_9_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/018_0000039_group_9_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..141973e61795e015492e4c4a56956d510099ffdf
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/018_0000039_group_9_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:38dc67d44a16a29409bdf0179107ad6004084392df1fbc88a4c6dbbb6225fe34
+size 268986
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/019_0000087_group_9_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/019_0000087_group_9_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8d40922eb76a3c0968ba093e8ac335473ae809d7
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/019_0000087_group_9_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:0a9ef92656930f1555963e4b0ed29ee87c8e5858eb347573e772c5212bf336a4
+size 282887
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/020_0000053_group_6_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/020_0000053_group_6_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..85d29e67afb5eb1fbb16c88df15086c62ac497a6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/020_0000053_group_6_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:f6aec41255275a0809f475f97d767cd2e5e8ebfc29250670988e2414a116ebf2
+size 296209
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/021_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/021_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..24b8c2d0d71ce99d8d5eb20baf87fe201bcb533f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/021_0000008_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:85e1bf59e64f58acc0bcb9f22515b89e58601743c2c4dc3f8e101cd04b4c6a2f
+size 209841
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/022_0000118_group_2_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/022_0000118_group_2_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ba3c96f72d6ff4df606d5a4c22ce260b46501d86
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/022_0000118_group_2_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:35d49ac6abe75b323ffef5d9d301510038a5ce1984db7b21d25c3571248f5f14
+size 253045
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/023_0000087_group_9_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/023_0000087_group_9_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a5e4e45f1936623705d5039f85408acda9e51280
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/023_0000087_group_9_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:8c392474b7c8bba3fd36b3e55dc015b2fd9a99458ffb63a82a19d4f18f1963cc
+size 284257
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/024_0000077_group_1_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/024_0000077_group_1_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..73a1a477da6bacc99b432d77c8afb96ed7de8a6d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/024_0000077_group_1_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:c0b3abe8e5d76e998b81e8e5aa0d165f187fb9328a1e38d9c8326baa14ecf1ed
+size 229397
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/025_0000068_group_1_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/025_0000068_group_1_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fc762c0e14247805a5b219271fff0ee0eb488b7d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/025_0000068_group_1_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:0b33cb92b9ab838fcbe8fbcafa3dec0d28093df215921f596a1fb103afd37f98
+size 267707
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/026_0000070_group_12_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/026_0000070_group_12_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..129fd83c9beed7d69b35a44608c0253d3c49d7db
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/026_0000070_group_12_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:2f16b8efb648fcd73e8c7d47e06cfd1e034ea42b2b8835bbbc38fc6f4ba38a4b
+size 288296
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/027_0000087_group_9_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/027_0000087_group_9_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d5e358c0823c251d35dd275adbcb2b75216a70e1
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/027_0000087_group_9_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:2a6b2645006e92fef3f3c8990743f57964c9a2dd0494019fcac381790cb27e72
+size 284826
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/028_0000008_group_14_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/028_0000008_group_14_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d71f6e554adbf1823b0c98aade3f335dee34f647
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/028_0000008_group_14_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:2595dcf5c969b0505e14b430935c5e05c26d5c2c787234ea1b22fc84639e6179
+size 258478
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/029_0000099_group_15_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/029_0000099_group_15_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..73a6a325554a8530e074485af0ad01b91d92b3e3
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/029_0000099_group_15_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:655a65fd9c38c352569854a28192a5fd5552fae348a454a74f64b2205f5f0b05
+size 311927
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/030_0000009_group_15_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/030_0000009_group_15_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1164bea8491b502370ecffa82bf329e6657d6458
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/030_0000009_group_15_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:a35595444f3219a06a2534a0d1fa5f949d11d263ad79c0014612eb5845cd6d9c
+size 271822
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/031_0000024_group_1_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/031_0000024_group_1_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9dee48146d57655055f0d8dd1c2bf34904b0608f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/031_0000024_group_1_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:b1278357ccf2599258863bd0121b396f2ed62a13ac6b4910f93e74f6fa50db30
+size 249903
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/032_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/032_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5c1d4ae59143b0a7f30047898b1df6a6eaaa6970
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/032_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q1__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:4968c1c2ab3b7b416db228f385b80d25571406d8b34c6b99e2a28df6decd0106
+size 293747
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/033_0000056_group_3_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/033_0000056_group_3_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..61367cd4331f866c360f37f9dafa394294417894
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/033_0000056_group_3_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:cd2914949001538e16f6a574c7e0bb76c1d78388ec040ce68aa7d058eecda6b4
+size 291768
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/034_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/034_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..97f7787eb4741aec8739a4bd40594998fb325a7e
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/034_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:0fa60b5708ecdadc36cf874d70df4e96d2a39ce2c9afc46c749a17e8a1e6a289
+size 293510
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/035_0000015_group_15_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/035_0000015_group_15_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6a4f0e4a1fa9de0f2caade5cc2f29730e786d3d6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/035_0000015_group_15_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:266fd292cde978172bc027793bd12a2a2f8e6348b968c577216d0bab37b8e8d6
+size 208674
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/036_0000092_group_10_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/036_0000092_group_10_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..817a1ce76ae2c4ccd63900e95701c3fad1b2e20f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/036_0000092_group_10_sample_3_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:bf60717b02201020b28e84de62371db623949d3ed7e3dba017c0bbec8062f373
+size 256331
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/037_0000002_group_3_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/037_0000002_group_3_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ec421259542cc874176b383a1b17d48d0f544a67
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/037_0000002_group_3_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:68d6c099d5e4c6798e8ed981d0dc96f1b4e458183ffa2eec724ed37cddd941c6
+size 308835
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/038_0000015_group_15_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/038_0000015_group_15_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..07c9eadc2aeb0544e9ccdae6ecaa8865f9590cfd
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/038_0000015_group_15_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:15c7f7a87b2d9318c0f16d1f38f9a409836559ed5cebe941297c42445713de92
+size 208828
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/039_0000162_group_1_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/039_0000162_group_1_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..237c403362b7dcc00404a0d3babb2e5346c99b3b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/039_0000162_group_1_sample_2_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:711306b65f6e35dfa50ff8f0fa3982e1ae6e2d8f1d235e22507d168e44b91f16
+size 282120
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/040_0000170_group_0_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/040_0000170_group_0_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..00d78036120e07d66018a6bec4edac853f1df3bc
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/040_0000170_group_0_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:03200d1bb4963dffb261698a308875b8190d19a8dd158ba0e42c15b5adf7893f
+size 213577
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/041_0000039_group_9_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/041_0000039_group_9_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dfd6c7f82ce96cd502d15cd117dda73e246e1f5d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/041_0000039_group_9_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:5b70a92d728f4908527562861733dd25051570b4290301434f7667a096a7d5d3
+size 258078
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/042_0000002_group_3_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/042_0000002_group_3_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..96c3d2ab94612c71fc8029c013023a3948e63ec3
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/042_0000002_group_3_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:2c9d2e152a6ea22522ed50ac07583d97de741faf7c6815bcacd8d826ac85a60f
+size 299197
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/043_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/043_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..87b2cf04dcf6d3dc24cad77423855487adb2dbd7
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/043_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:4dc30ebd65d708f9adaae50255a47938167241b3efd81584b517610ee06af2f6
+size 292968
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/044_0000112_group_2_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/044_0000112_group_2_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bb620ae549643fa1315951d549a04f203ca3b278
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/044_0000112_group_2_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:de5fc3abe420e6cfbaf7487e7fed6ac6c83375f77efac56f97c166f3f2b7fe04
+size 256096
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/045_0000009_group_15_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/045_0000009_group_15_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..80e8aa2394eca84040cd8613521698bcff7aacf8
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/045_0000009_group_15_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:aa1f1357a9d12a432fae9cbcbafd519025464db7c0bcae7da1adcb1334459184
+size 271317
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/046_0000088_group_6_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/046_0000088_group_6_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8414f6cb4d7c10728452de23a401cad61170af6d
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/046_0000088_group_6_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:8345bc2c86a5e8b64ee5879fad1f5e75bebbc14c5e6b3e9dc1d8013ba1baeb50
+size 227985
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/047_0000123_group_11_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/047_0000123_group_11_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7177f616869c299f2f824efe653ef1362aa964cf
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/047_0000123_group_11_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:0425cc8251de7743c48e676bc6e8f4866d544ff1c9b2dad6996a9f0c3879a24b
+size 295714
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/048_0000039_group_9_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/048_0000039_group_9_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7c2d40d4696a91349c797cd068e8c5e60a5e84d8
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/048_0000039_group_9_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:fb0a2884592f080b60fd97549a08c80b112e0c6faad70817d50ea84e71c9152f
+size 296022
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/049_0000091_group_9_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/049_0000091_group_9_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9adee4dc2beb68a9547d5e46592b1cd2ee071484
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/049_0000091_group_9_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:9dd0c2fc746a293dcca6bea8928ae800296ec36b1e9b899db51c9ddfb9e9e26e
+size 253651
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/050_0000041_group_4_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/050_0000041_group_4_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5b1010a127ef71e69285f7a7f89e74b1c822da88
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/050_0000041_group_4_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:a64dbb745bcfa2506b43d88a6817af4df94dd060bce65d6173a00a46357f29c5
+size 257815
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/051_0000092_group_10_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/051_0000092_group_10_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5e8a34d6dbd475ebfc8670c61595cb9f166d680b
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/051_0000092_group_10_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:7c475ac3835874f61cac963161cd48056aa050fb02f0efc6bbfcf5af6efa4123
+size 256962
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/052_0000124_group_10_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/052_0000124_group_10_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9cce8b38723a760537a1735c36218d7aada14744
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/052_0000124_group_10_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:7f1c265e0a1181493b0243f2ec23566cfd93b4f697c5d314204c5b1bb4155839
+size 253182
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/053_0000101_group_2_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/053_0000101_group_2_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..91e82f8b53e13cba37c12e0b5cf52ee932f8e8ed
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/053_0000101_group_2_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:1395d5304c4d7427a3c61d6b312aa078b563213d0c7972c2520d31ac03650e18
+size 199194
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/054_0000039_group_7_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/054_0000039_group_7_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1c383076ee31e5a246281f3fe1068b9b7b4c9249
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/054_0000039_group_7_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:0b06f1c69601e71ef7144c85bcbc0735057f45b5a155efa9d76d8349436676b2
+size 275738
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/055_0000002_group_3_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/055_0000002_group_3_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..185cc70ba9886d7e31cebeddaa226d1134bb50b4
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/055_0000002_group_3_sample_2_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:930ee35d916b8829dfe21509491bd21b2cf93e827a16af22ec2a3c8a12d5762b
+size 309274
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/056_0000039_group_7_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/056_0000039_group_7_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8457f97c5cdf3ad9098b5735e2b6eb664efadebd
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/056_0000039_group_7_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:46bb58cb62108ab440ac772ab1d2a45a1d7dbac45b2efb2110f4e0973bcabb38
+size 278086
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/057_0000118_group_2_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/057_0000118_group_2_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3175a0c21887fa181bc8e15e95d07f1fb9273d6c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/057_0000118_group_2_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:cfbd78b2dfb8a77a336e267f2e14e16c0661b32019cba5f2e72cb5c5c2676b24
+size 271858
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/058_0000087_group_9_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/058_0000087_group_9_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..682be26cae284a712b6bb250c2443e89a3359c96
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/058_0000087_group_9_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:d9ec10ed8e4451b904f3d83a8893e6832760866bcc762b78b610dd4625ff765b
+size 286332
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/059_0000158_group_8_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/059_0000158_group_8_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..03abc42519754952a4620e63bca9dea53a8ec095
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/059_0000158_group_8_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:f178d2883623a1cba0f19b4b160a6546643766f32e0322f964f7d8869fba95f2
+size 237821
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/060_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/060_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8219f2e060b1d79599a52ee7a5f4f68a8c06aeca
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/060_0000056_group_3_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:3f6f0dd47f50cf6d3c3798205ac5b9ad56cee605dd7709169556954cd1cd4cc3
+size 294055
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/061_0000050_group_11_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/061_0000050_group_11_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cb2099930b183646416693e04dc3c202ab0101aa
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/061_0000050_group_11_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:5972718c7c61cf5facadc506cf553d840c8cd886c52f768bbe2bad74aebafbc9
+size 251492
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/062_0000001_group_12_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/062_0000001_group_12_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..430af091a6cdafe519a478f8a6208b344e0fa5c8
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/062_0000001_group_12_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:6266ad79e2e9b23081f59f4a5718fb0b214e2b44b7ae8e5210c2e4840c5552e6
+size 253198
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/063_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/063_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4d966e54b51fee040fed4c8257b71d8204f4d29e
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/063_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:50f62f0d81fb33080c5031dfdd769cc772665860197af4ac16702b29410d0869
+size 190877
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/064_0000002_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/064_0000002_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d4871c25f3bcc04c92ace27be6c5bd0d3aeb7ab4
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/064_0000002_group_5_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:14b0f80688d1a411dff23a586b2e61142c2482683e48e502a25baf41002847f9
+size 261783
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/065_0000028_group_11_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/065_0000028_group_11_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b1c22ffa54a244cd1fedfb7b18c78c36b025b35a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/065_0000028_group_11_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:2fc4ed033dbcaf0a6b87c866da036d1cec345e46475a1bb67ac5fe55c7460bba
+size 246553
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/066_0000130_group_15_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/066_0000130_group_15_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ad2492fc31c874bb9ea7c4751fc0b63b5943634c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/066_0000130_group_15_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:651a37ae1bf06624c0e024658322e29e5d526ab0d355d3a5af8641e558e7ef1d
+size 301186
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/067_0000009_group_4_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/067_0000009_group_4_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..60f7676e3a9471f66820896cf880d5e2bf763dce
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/067_0000009_group_4_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:b687cdec9ec379db223feef7996bc65392ea6ac67bcf5646230eb60abcc98ef7
+size 220638
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/068_0000148_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/068_0000148_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..469d75039f96b7210389b4d7cf3d890724d283db
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/068_0000148_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:4d176df3e48ae9ed3cdd7e78b10d2c9d2b1968a3393b67174ec952c49903c053
+size 280324
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/069_0000105_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/069_0000105_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d4333df30e3403a19db459d2d308ef2dc3eeb075
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/069_0000105_group_14_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:02ecebb0fa4debabb204e6355ab19f02a82168e8df3a6139498eea815c6a7782
+size 280153
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/070_0000037_group_5_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/070_0000037_group_5_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..215643c65d45edd3f28a12646bf035ebef0b5e6a
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/070_0000037_group_5_sample_1_q1__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:472a61e45045210cdec7a57ef7ace44d894a638b831fe61d0d5c3066a1b9df87
+size 220710
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/071_0000050_group_11_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/071_0000050_group_11_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..418771b9941bd28800d1a2169eb217fc64fb6e8c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/071_0000050_group_11_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:4463bcbf305103be2290e07e8558222ae877f563081dfef83b22f89702c7bb18
+size 254238
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/072_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/072_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..80eec71642ca4baaec51de2f0b493e9fba56215c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/072_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:6887f201fa05198503992c0ad327669f2c7d1d93e195dfc2b72e9737dfa10d3b
+size 192616
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/073_0000158_group_8_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/073_0000158_group_8_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..58c164eb7e8ff839a01c03f3631622d2a9fbe6d7
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/073_0000158_group_8_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:f709d3ef75b2b2f6d6af19f3ebfdf747e6277f11a3bb93dc0b7ec7db5e213b95
+size 234158
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/074_0000118_group_14_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/074_0000118_group_14_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..95117e8a94e70f715cc83d5257326a572088070e
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/074_0000118_group_14_sample_unknown_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:93d1bcc4d0866c6f16002f682b31463c575515a06ec05a17cdd564b90511e25e
+size 186955
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/075_0000101_group_2_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/075_0000101_group_2_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fd94bee8f13f2bddc4857d1feac1b4303a5e7266
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/075_0000101_group_2_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:c2e90277ea6d503ba0a746af1a8907d4d18d950360bd06218d6d281f9776cf6d
+size 198654
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/076_0000002_group_9_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/076_0000002_group_9_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bd5af5a96bdde63b76193b818547cb6dd6f7b4bd
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/076_0000002_group_9_sample_3_q1__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:b0e27269bc1fddb96409a02c432e4a63f79e8001343cebe1295f13dc26f0a287
+size 214145
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/077_0000099_group_15_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/077_0000099_group_15_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..21b9fdda596b53ef5187616aa291441e473453c6
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/077_0000099_group_15_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:2451148428cd4756c4b49c7a8c8486d28dd6555d9c86e479c09e327d578a64ed
+size 277251
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/078_0000057_group_13_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/078_0000057_group_13_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..301252a473139d290ceba8b23bc6182e6c76e4d2
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/078_0000057_group_13_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:114a1ba7190f46c1daf31ea22c0bb2bc5edeb323f1b269d6fc94747308951539
+size 275486
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/079_0000148_group_15_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/079_0000148_group_15_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2710ad80cb1ba520052b3789af9e83b4f763ed55
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/079_0000148_group_15_sample_unknown_q1__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:273e90e29b9d3143282f2c0067610e90bf6b95dd2daad066823848b43770da84
+size 278269
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/080_0000067_group_10_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/080_0000067_group_10_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..448b8275c47257a9b2c8e1ba637915b671f57b13
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/080_0000067_group_10_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:ee59c13ba6df50ccec1b0e0d15848d0da04414b3b7631149fcdc9157563e3d40
+size 254127
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/081_0000168_group_10_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/081_0000168_group_10_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b8bac914a98343c1645b63c34b63c11a26429490
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/081_0000168_group_10_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:ee5d4009031eac24e4c51f21866d1930a53f225ce70bb2dd0191443e9a7efe05
+size 306373
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/082_0000011_group_10_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/082_0000011_group_10_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..62bfca933988b36d4481142b58073b299caaf4a2
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/082_0000011_group_10_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:bfdb351834a7ad4c799465f8ea56ae5e0217507545ae0ed61a5871440de463d0
+size 292216
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/083_0000112_group_2_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/083_0000112_group_2_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7d99dcc19820f94350bc2b6243b1047be0c39806
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/083_0000112_group_2_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:7e824ab5b38c5b83eacc9c499b29e2325b4381a95eb8f5b0ab629d8e30bafa69
+size 256861
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/084_0000157_group_3_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/084_0000157_group_3_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9c94e6e827fc1193eee555cdb3ca0492873d9dff
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/084_0000157_group_3_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:cc31b12995b16341ffa87afff142c84126d009d0214e55f5a7fa911d4149fc93
+size 292089
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/085_0000026_group_9_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/085_0000026_group_9_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a423b8dcfd61e9aa29e28039e765dce873119967
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/085_0000026_group_9_sample_2_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:c828f19eb15cf37ed4d439585b092c298a5828b403e75362e4a4f347acd869f6
+size 309706
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/086_0000002_group_3_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/086_0000002_group_3_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5610f15a93a57e2ff99af8cb410cd13b863f01af
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/086_0000002_group_3_sample_1_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:67a73b01a3b27abff07c8bdd84d043ad69e357a3ac15969207db879129d3ab0e
+size 302154
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/087_0000016_group_4_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/087_0000016_group_4_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..113064156a7d44727c6494ba0baff9b572cdeefa
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/087_0000016_group_4_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:e59b646bc2ae10aa63d875fe280afabd9f2e67917fd3e4c17e3e819acca0eca1
+size 262484
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/088_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/088_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3a436fafd19abb38002192ab43f83efd155584e2
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/088_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:7c01db1fd2277f696ed0f3e89dbfc8dbbd44376d3871018152883ed430760cf5
+size 287960
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/089_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/089_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..405b326b4489a4fdf2191a77223eddcc4fb28474
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/089_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:d3e32b5cfdaab5d9a3662c209c20d4b72c3ac718673fea752581aabb71eb4a5a
+size 285122
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/090_0000090_group_12_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/090_0000090_group_12_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9c6d79aeb29c857fe2e8f449ab3bc0751b1f61a3
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/090_0000090_group_12_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:515f430375776ef05a1712b77226447836ee070cae2a0e4ec113225962289604
+size 262060
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/091_0000144_group_2_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/091_0000144_group_2_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fb4f08d24fd38f07c0dedfeea8792941fb4479d3
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/091_0000144_group_2_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:1ce024ed51ff2b754399a5559aff6f3c25d224a3380bc56684cb9e8f481d4dd4
+size 187558
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/092_0000118_group_14_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/092_0000118_group_14_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..060fa998678531e7a94e46bf4ac89c55ca2052ae
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/092_0000118_group_14_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:de016ddb0c0af8b6b7190c7e682666adfec62911fe1826bcd11b644ce16be870
+size 188032
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/093_0000033_group_0_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/093_0000033_group_0_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f9b59d939a927173d6ff14325e8cde1922354ccf
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/093_0000033_group_0_sample_unknown_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:7cbe95cd2bd357bf2dbbd3ef8c2cc11f1094d90f8cba781dad428537290875b7
+size 304613
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/094_0000057_group_13_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/094_0000057_group_13_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8194581c965684763dff7364685410f42a0118c9
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/094_0000057_group_13_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:d362aa67396ae9f6561d2458a7950315f675c936f9c2928443391fc374f60c37
+size 275021
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/095_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/095_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..306d61630e4503746bbedb286a2bd9dd2b711763
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/095_0000067_group_10_sample_1_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:92bc95d94cc2c356c2f58de809027162a39256a1c67f23f28e47799954579f86
+size 192816
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/096_0000009_group_4_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/096_0000009_group_4_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e79624be30d6fa1f6f8655b9e5964bc59d10d2e4
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/096_0000009_group_4_sample_1_q2__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:2c33cbe941c3d7d7a7b98b04004b5e972e5ddce8c74b1eec745e3eda7d98723a
+size 218497
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/097_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/097_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0fbd1bba8a36ac37c38b74cddd36ed161660f1f8
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/097_0000118_group_15_sample_unknown_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:f2a05385de5712b7bf86000280abdd717993ede4a9a5de3a9fa78a82569e8351
+size 285407
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/098_0000120_group_5_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/098_0000120_group_5_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4350b4a26bead0eabaa11ea79343d7bdbdf7f7c4
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/098_0000120_group_5_sample_3_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:ed03d125b8301df75c698aeee29dcc2f0474b4c4e3556017b0db9a6b5dff3115
+size 239126
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/099_0000162_group_1_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/099_0000162_group_1_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c6c662adbc8fe3b9d4821470da164de1a4c296a0
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/099_0000162_group_1_sample_3_q5__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:64524df4e5772c345f0f6fea6539d2fae3a81a3c46560cc797db3311ac95bb17
+size 261069
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/100_0000018_group_1_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/100_0000018_group_1_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f53d8061a80acbc40979dfd355685ae066046231
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/100_0000018_group_1_sample_3_q4__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:4aebf3b26481c40c6e0e81c9e0a6cdd5d092fa284bac9d111c79b2dcdf0c4f04
+size 282553
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/101_0000170_group_5_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/101_0000170_group_5_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3e1ecb1c3819cf367984ffcaf5874d19cb270704
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/101_0000170_group_5_sample_2_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:374d55843db0ea3c6ee9c9c4f7f0f0733242c77b1dcc46ef179dd18797dd47ff
+size 210996
diff --git a/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/102_0000056_group_3_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/102_0000056_group_3_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..892685d1b767fa00dfa929cf2b0cb20c4d10233c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Reward_finetuning/SAGE-GRPO/outputs/rerun_vlm_same_gradient_window_smoothing/object_requirement_credit_examples_more500_strict_object/comparison_panels/102_0000056_group_3_sample_1_q3__spatial_comparison.png
@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:fcb2a0934b5a0fabd510fd8d31c7617264a22440d8063d2105b5f093f825b1a6
+size 286995