100081_1

change the frisbee into a ball

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.0032919999212026596, "dataset_mask_area": 0.003292, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.20144698023796082, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00525294803082943, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.19619403220713139, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 1.0, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 1.0, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5328012108802795, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.35619403220713136, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.0063620664581230816, "best_expert": "pix2pix", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.18320640741847458, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.018195824697613716, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.20144696533679962, "edit_change_ratio": 0.09032563318683941, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.16594476997852325, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.8237640596922363}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.10000800341367722, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/100081_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5081021189689636, "pix2pix": 0.49189791083335876}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2747337605375796, "reward": -0.2747337605375796}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.27635432595293974, "reward": -0.27635432595293974}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.27876430826430443, "reward": -0.27876430826430443}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2800878979218542, "reward": -0.2800878979218542}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.28171547261635715, "reward": -0.28171547261635715}], "preference_pairs": [], "area": 312, "bbox_xyxy": [461, 492, 500, 500], "component_score": 0.2747337605375796, "component_reward": -0.2747337605375796, "second_component_score": 0.27635432595293974, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0016205654153601534, "confidence": 0.5605534170752478}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8334054946899414, "teacher_quality_score": 0.0063620664581230816, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.0063620664581230816, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/100081_1/100081_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0698828473687172, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9947170615196228, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01061884593218565, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8028993010520935, "background_mse_to_target": 0.010340050794184208, "full_mse_to_target": 0.010536065325140953, "input_change_l1": 0.07775591313838959, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6778295040130615, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06578548410907388, "edit_score": 0.15148205906152726, "background_score": 0.05003898572176695, "combined_score": 0.18320640741847458, "confidence": 0.5591055350403996}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/100081_1/100081_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08348575979471207, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9970078468322754, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00020560601842589676, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9947964549064636, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00017392641166225076, "full_mse_to_target": 0.000448188919108361, "input_change_l1": 0.008389187045395374, "directional_pixel_score": 0.583856500685215, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.018227816140279175, "edit_score": 0.18812006525695324, "background_score": 0.0012463150371331722, "combined_score": 0.19224665763991652, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/100081_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07693734019994736, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.997249186038971, "background_mse_to_source": 8.686848013894632e-05, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9976691603660583, "background_mse_to_target": 9.286207932746038e-05, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0003458340943325311, "input_change_l1": 0.005452965851873159, "directional_pixel_score": 0.583856500685215, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01193248515482992, "edit_score": 0.18152337782084943, "background_score": 0.0005530364069272764, "combined_score": 0.1841380210036732, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/100081_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09011270105838776, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9967623353004456, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0003127107338514179, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9921931624412537, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0002540673012845218, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0005498818936757743, "input_change_l1": 0.010478919371962547, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5848958343267441, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02251465320587158, "edit_score": 0.19453627541661261, "background_score": 0.0018740782456006856, "combined_score": 0.19975012163311476, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/100081_1/100081_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08040677756071091, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9920778870582581, "background_mse_to_source": 0.028276588767766953, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7757049202919006, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02845465950667858, "full_mse_to_target": 0.028625689446926117, "input_change_l1": 0.14512985944747925, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6480481922626495, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08642908576875925, "edit_score": 0.16997915208339692, "background_score": 0.07313560470938682, "combined_score": 0.21572499983012677, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/100081_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/100081_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/100081_1.json"}

100081_2

add a whale in the ocean

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.0030517578125, "dataset_mask_area": 0.0030517578125, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2792401909828186, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0004096160118933767, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2788305749709252, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9401631912964642, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9661490683229814, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5211436748504639, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4302961206594202, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.02015319242114856, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.39441679510520766, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.0028815362602472305, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2792401909828186, "edit_change_ratio": 0.010319203156627725, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.24797140061855316, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.8880218844779784}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.0065898895263671875, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/100081_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5145225524902344, "qwen_image_edit": 0.485477477312088}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.23628689437021966, "reward": -0.23628689437021966}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.23919222321326372, "reward": -0.23919222321326372}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2412459605806507, "reward": -0.2412459605806507}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.38222764850850216, "reward": -0.38222764850850216}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.39153934246359856, "reward": -0.39153934246359856}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23628689437021966, "loser_reward": -0.38222764850850216, "reward_margin": 0.1459407541382825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23628689437021966, "loser_reward": -0.39153934246359856, "reward_margin": 0.1552524480933789, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23919222321326372, "loser_reward": -0.38222764850850216, "reward_margin": 0.14303542529523844, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23919222321326372, "loser_reward": -0.39153934246359856, "reward_margin": 0.15234711925033484, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2412459605806507, "loser_reward": -0.38222764850850216, "reward_margin": 0.14098168792785146, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2412459605806507, "loser_reward": -0.39153934246359856, "reward_margin": 0.15029338188294786, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 3200, "bbox_xyxy": [219, 371, 294, 452], "component_score": 0.23628689437021966, "component_reward": -0.23628689437021966, "second_component_score": 0.23919222321326372, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.002905328843044064, "confidence": 0.5718463623994308}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5718464851379395, "teacher_quality_score": 0.02015319242114856, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.02015319242114856, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23628689437021966, "loser_reward": -0.38222764850850216, "reward_margin": 0.1459407541382825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23628689437021966, "loser_reward": -0.39153934246359856, "reward_margin": 0.1552524480933789, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23919222321326372, "loser_reward": -0.38222764850850216, "reward_margin": 0.14303542529523844, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23919222321326372, "loser_reward": -0.39153934246359856, "reward_margin": 0.15234711925033484, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2412459605806507, "loser_reward": -0.38222764850850216, "reward_margin": 0.14098168792785146, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2412459605806507, "loser_reward": -0.39153934246359856, "reward_margin": 0.15029338188294786, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/100081_2/100081_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.224327951669693, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6081011295318604, "background_mse_to_source": 0.046589840203523636, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7151560187339783, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04660458117723465, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04714694991707802, "input_change_l1": 0.18154825270175934, "directional_pixel_score": 0.2038794755935669, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12158966079587118, "edit_score": 0.5017378568649292, "background_score": 0.10355863645672798, "combined_score": 0.5670160067756661, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/100081_2/100081_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10009624809026718, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6655982136726379, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002760108560323715, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9478307366371155, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0027676187455654144, "full_mse_to_target": 0.003064641961827874, "input_change_l1": 0.016460780054330826, "directional_pixel_score": 0.09869948029518127, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.009811971848830581, "edit_score": 0.3923017352819443, "background_score": 0.01319396123290062, "combined_score": 0.39918848027940845, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/100081_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09820286184549332, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6671843528747559, "background_mse_to_source": 0.001166145782917738, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9643949866294861, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0011742401402443647, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0014703478664159775, "input_change_l1": 0.01069949846714735, "directional_pixel_score": 0.09869933128356934, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.006390499544795603, "edit_score": 0.3900911584496498, "background_score": 0.008287148457020522, "combined_score": 0.39441679510520766, "confidence": 0.5714998516825822}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/100081_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10146543383598328, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.664353609085083, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00413381215184927, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9389281868934631, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004140915814787149, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004437925759702921, "input_change_l1": 0.020400770008563995, "directional_pixel_score": 0.09869924187660217, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.012141666631214321, "edit_score": 0.39391990154981615, "background_score": 0.016348174773156643, "combined_score": 0.4025138886226341, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/100081_2/100081_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.21109972894191742, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5974430441856384, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012098812498152256, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7434733510017395, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012114547193050385, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01272179838269949, "input_change_l1": 0.08908644318580627, "directional_pixel_score": 0.10716524720191956, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09824844121467323, "edit_score": 0.5148198083043098, "background_score": 0.06340414229780436, "combined_score": 0.557933126189746, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/100081_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/100081_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/100081_2.json"}

100081_3

add a dog barking near shore

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.004605293273925781, "dataset_mask_area": 0.004605293273925781, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.30308932065963745, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0028106451500207186, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.30027867550961673, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.22687027457222445, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.2299354708610607, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5001813769340515, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3367005272927261, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.02006750935127002, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.28992523664608594, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.024143623188138008, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.30308935046195984, "edit_change_ratio": 0.07965843455515349, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.27472174167633057, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9064051285787765}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.008557319641113281, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/100081_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5254520773887634, "pix2pix": 0.4745478928089142}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.21604294246900826, "reward": -0.21604294246900826}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.22113776096515358, "reward": -0.22113776096515358}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.23426836401829498, "reward": -0.23426836401829498}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.23677678094035945, "reward": -0.23677678094035945}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.23857160496665167, "reward": -0.23857160496665167}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "100081_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.21604294246900826, "loser_reward": -0.23426836401829498, "reward_margin": 0.01822542154928672, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21604294246900826, "loser_reward": -0.23677678094035945, "reward_margin": 0.020733838471351185, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21604294246900826, "loser_reward": -0.23857160496665167, "reward_margin": 0.022528662497643404, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.22113776096515358, "loser_reward": -0.23426836401829498, "reward_margin": 0.013130603053141399, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22113776096515358, "loser_reward": -0.23677678094035945, "reward_margin": 0.015639019975205865, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22113776096515358, "loser_reward": -0.23857160496665167, "reward_margin": 0.017433844001498083, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4827, "bbox_xyxy": [748, 905, 864, 1005], "component_score": 0.21604294246900826, "component_reward": -0.21604294246900826, "second_component_score": 0.22113776096515358, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.00509481849614532, "confidence": 0.591353398416813}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5915226340293884, "teacher_quality_score": 0.02006750935127002, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.02006750935127002, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "100081_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.21604294246900826, "loser_reward": -0.23426836401829498, "reward_margin": 0.01822542154928672, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21604294246900826, "loser_reward": -0.23677678094035945, "reward_margin": 0.020733838471351185, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21604294246900826, "loser_reward": -0.23857160496665167, "reward_margin": 0.022528662497643404, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.22113776096515358, "loser_reward": -0.23426836401829498, "reward_margin": 0.013130603053141399, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22113776096515358, "loser_reward": -0.23677678094035945, "reward_margin": 0.015639019975205865, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100081_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22113776096515358, "loser_reward": -0.23857160496665167, "reward_margin": 0.017433844001498083, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/100081_3/100081_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10931073874235153, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.707027018070221, "background_mse_to_source": 0.003598571987822652, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8967247009277344, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0037776436656713486, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004263654351234436, "input_change_l1": 0.038595493882894516, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5400047451257706, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02564619560725987, "edit_score": 0.2829041488468647, "background_score": 0.024253631802275778, "combined_score": 0.29694852453423665, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/100081_3/100081_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11545807868242264, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6971431374549866, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0013795471750199795, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9730450510978699, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0016165602719411254, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0021408339962363243, "input_change_l1": 0.011091098189353943, "directional_pixel_score": 0.2327519655227661, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.009517129743471742, "edit_score": 0.3678414598107338, "background_score": 0.006770536955446005, "combined_score": 0.3723286570934579, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/100081_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1134243905544281, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6965060830116272, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005828588618896902, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9799184203147888, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0008132964721880853, "full_mse_to_target": 0.00133190315682441, "input_change_l1": 0.007209208328276873, "directional_pixel_score": 0.23275181651115417, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0062516180099919435, "edit_score": 0.3659352198243141, "background_score": 0.004599174798931927, "combined_score": 0.3689284449216211, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/100081_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11694588512182236, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6972465515136719, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0020058820955455303, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9693701267242432, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002244991948828101, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0027732234448194504, "input_change_l1": 0.013728654943406582, "directional_pixel_score": 0.23275187611579895, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01178479720838368, "edit_score": 0.36930860579013824, "background_score": 0.008131856750696897, "combined_score": 0.37478903743904085, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/100081_3/100081_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10741692036390305, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6978943943977356, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0017243935726583004, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8790884017944336, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0018393680220469832, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002325583016499877, "input_change_l1": 0.02383221499621868, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5743035152554512, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03181583024561405, "edit_score": 0.27426216267049314, "background_score": 0.02590671321377158, "combined_score": 0.28992523664608594, "confidence": 0.5924461938878499}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/100081_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/100081_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/100081_3.json"}

100558_1

get rid of the vase on top of the table

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.04946799948811531, "dataset_mask_area": 0.049468, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.19653843343257904, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.006689295172691345, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1898491382598877, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7025712300208478, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8332646501277508, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4868675768375397, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.30748827186749944, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.21637324089781942, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.21485100278747268, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.0685669332742691, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.19653843343257904, "edit_change_ratio": 0.3488729002095687, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.07455600053071976, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/100558_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5100725889205933, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4899274408817291}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.12966886163246816, "reward": -0.12966886163246816}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.13168364857230333, "reward": -0.13168364857230333}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.14110142415529117, "reward": -0.14110142415529117}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.20067240856029092, "reward": -0.20067240856029092}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.21158650779537858, "reward": -0.21158650779537858}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12966886163246816, "loser_reward": -0.14110142415529117, "reward_margin": 0.011432562522823014, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12966886163246816, "loser_reward": -0.20067240856029092, "reward_margin": 0.07100354692782276, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12966886163246816, "loser_reward": -0.21158650779537858, "reward_margin": 0.08191764616291042, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13168364857230333, "loser_reward": -0.20067240856029092, "reward_margin": 0.06898875998798759, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13168364857230333, "loser_reward": -0.21158650779537858, "reward_margin": 0.07990285922307525, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14110142415529117, "loser_reward": -0.20067240856029092, "reward_margin": 0.05957098440499975, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14110142415529117, "loser_reward": -0.21158650779537858, "reward_margin": 0.0704850836400874, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20067240856029092, "loser_reward": -0.21158650779537858, "reward_margin": 0.010914099235087654, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 12367, "bbox_xyxy": [159, 154, 273, 320], "component_score": 0.12966886163246816, "component_reward": -0.12966886163246816, "second_component_score": 0.13168364857230333, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0020147869398351725, "confidence": 0.5775060292368349}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5775060057640076, "teacher_quality_score": 0.21637324089781942, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.21637324089781942, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12966886163246816, "loser_reward": -0.14110142415529117, "reward_margin": 0.011432562522823014, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12966886163246816, "loser_reward": -0.20067240856029092, "reward_margin": 0.07100354692782276, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12966886163246816, "loser_reward": -0.21158650779537858, "reward_margin": 0.08191764616291042, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13168364857230333, "loser_reward": -0.20067240856029092, "reward_margin": 0.06898875998798759, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13168364857230333, "loser_reward": -0.21158650779537858, "reward_margin": 0.07990285922307525, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14110142415529117, "loser_reward": -0.20067240856029092, "reward_margin": 0.05957098440499975, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14110142415529117, "loser_reward": -0.21158650779537858, "reward_margin": 0.0704850836400874, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "100558_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20067240856029092, "loser_reward": -0.21158650779537858, "reward_margin": 0.010914099235087654, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/100558_1/100558_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07665460556745529, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.570184051990509, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05035862326622009, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4439336359500885, "background_mse_to_target": 0.049945615231990814, "full_mse_to_target": 0.051266852766275406, "input_change_l1": 0.1772851198911667, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6830179989337921, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15134184490889313, "edit_score": 0.24186329543590546, "background_score": 0.1615718960762024, "combined_score": 0.33380851332098244, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/100558_1/100558_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05793308839201927, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5938594937324524, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002814674749970436, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9489266872406006, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0029974980279803276, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005715053528547287, "input_change_l1": 0.019914554432034492, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7252308428287506, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.022567896265536548, "edit_score": 0.20785347893834116, "background_score": 0.01302933730185032, "combined_score": 0.2174988315999508, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/100558_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05240201577544212, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5572092533111572, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0011891996255144477, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.979764461517334, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0014624458272010088, "full_mse_to_target": 0.003982323221862316, "input_change_l1": 0.012944456189870834, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7252307385206223, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.014837912097573281, "edit_score": 0.20965248048305513, "background_score": 0.005236307322047651, "combined_score": 0.21485100278747268, "confidence": 0.5718958752556382}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/100558_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06363005191087723, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5755068063735962, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004389566835016012, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9255325794219971, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004510930739343166, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007435435429215431, "input_change_l1": 0.024658046662807465, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7264514565467834, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.026714378269389272, "edit_score": 0.21691582649946212, "background_score": 0.0192830509506166, "combined_score": 0.22975131352897735, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/100558_1/100558_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07097449898719788, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5079397559165955, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010206010192632675, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7502061724662781, "background_mse_to_target": 0.010051506571471691, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013065247796475887, "input_change_l1": 0.07272791862487793, "directional_pixel_score": 0.626699224114418, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07647647578269243, "edit_score": 0.2627117417752743, "background_score": 0.06016477569937706, "combined_score": 0.30037123320624237, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/100558_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/100558_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/100558_1.json"}

102171_1

Let the monitor turn black.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.133760005235672, "dataset_mask_area": 0.13376, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.29841750860214233, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.011456334963440895, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.28696117363870144, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8018571660620499, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8943744904429749, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.32045072317123413, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4189590131838664, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.2193572443339508, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.28099862830713396, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.235573872923851, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.29841747879981995, "edit_change_ratio": 0.789410438930339, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1966879963874817, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/102171_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6028122901916504, "editar": 0.397187739610672}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2098497671438381, "reward": -0.2098497671438381}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.23070960031263527, "reward": -0.23070960031263527}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.39416924988292157, "reward": -0.39416924988292157}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.4053738499563187, "reward": -0.4053738499563187}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.4724331663958728, "reward": -0.4724331663958728}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2098497671438381, "loser_reward": -0.23070960031263527, "reward_margin": 0.020859833168797165, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2098497671438381, "loser_reward": -0.39416924988292157, "reward_margin": 0.18431948273908347, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2098497671438381, "loser_reward": -0.4053738499563187, "reward_margin": 0.1955240828124806, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2098497671438381, "loser_reward": -0.4724331663958728, "reward_margin": 0.26258339925203467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23070960031263527, "loser_reward": -0.39416924988292157, "reward_margin": 0.1634596495702863, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23070960031263527, "loser_reward": -0.4053738499563187, "reward_margin": 0.17466424964368343, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23070960031263527, "loser_reward": -0.4724331663958728, "reward_margin": 0.24172356608323753, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.39416924988292157, "loser_reward": -0.4053738499563187, "reward_margin": 0.01120460007339713, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.39416924988292157, "loser_reward": -0.4724331663958728, "reward_margin": 0.07826391651295123, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.4053738499563187, "loser_reward": -0.4724331663958728, "reward_margin": 0.0670593164395541, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 33440, "bbox_xyxy": [5, 164, 288, 390], "component_score": 0.2098497671438381, "component_reward": -0.2098497671438381, "second_component_score": 0.23070960031263527, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.020859833168797165, "confidence": 0.7060054331776151}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7060053944587708, "teacher_quality_score": 0.2193572443339508, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.2193572443339508, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2098497671438381, "loser_reward": -0.23070960031263527, "reward_margin": 0.020859833168797165, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2098497671438381, "loser_reward": -0.39416924988292157, "reward_margin": 0.18431948273908347, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2098497671438381, "loser_reward": -0.4053738499563187, "reward_margin": 0.1955240828124806, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2098497671438381, "loser_reward": -0.4724331663958728, "reward_margin": 0.26258339925203467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23070960031263527, "loser_reward": -0.39416924988292157, "reward_margin": 0.1634596495702863, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23070960031263527, "loser_reward": -0.4053738499563187, "reward_margin": 0.17466424964368343, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23070960031263527, "loser_reward": -0.4724331663958728, "reward_margin": 0.24172356608323753, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.39416924988292157, "loser_reward": -0.4053738499563187, "reward_margin": 0.01120460007339713, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.39416924988292157, "loser_reward": -0.4724331663958728, "reward_margin": 0.07826391651295123, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102171_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.4053738499563187, "loser_reward": -0.4724331663958728, "reward_margin": 0.0670593164395541, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/102171_1/102171_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.28925377130508423, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.40920746326446533, "background_mse_to_source": 0.15447135269641876, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.17245715856552124, "background_mse_to_target": 0.15389639139175415, "full_mse_to_target": 0.17200179398059845, "input_change_l1": 0.3607781231403351, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7091776728630066, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2451930116862059, "edit_score": 0.4801178604364395, "background_score": 0.3199799209833145, "combined_score": 0.6583496145159007, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/102171_1/102171_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2539568245410919, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.44366857409477234, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04921509698033333, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9037889838218689, "background_mse_to_target": 0.049229782074689865, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07661408185958862, "input_change_l1": 0.14221404492855072, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8415069282054901, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.23691766690462826, "edit_score": 0.4048463776707649, "background_score": 0.06845730021595955, "combined_score": 0.48385137431323527, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/102171_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10893632471561432, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5626290440559387, "background_mse_to_source": 0.020793374627828598, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9500153064727783, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02111794240772724, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0328645296394825, "input_change_l1": 0.09243914484977722, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8415066003799438, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15450849933549762, "edit_score": 0.23603386580944063, "background_score": 0.030790313333272937, "combined_score": 0.28099862830713396, "confidence": 0.7611412306883854}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/102171_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.26200756430625916, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4313403367996216, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04954657331109047, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.899960994720459, "background_mse_to_target": 0.049525197595357895, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07794683426618576, "input_change_l1": 0.146631121635437, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8401885330677032, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.24159539844840763, "edit_score": 0.41569236367940904, "background_score": 0.06955437436699867, "combined_score": 0.49615015782415867, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/102171_1/102171_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11551947146654129, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5701191425323486, "background_mse_to_source": 0.020901549607515335, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7199203372001648, "background_mse_to_target": 0.020404024049639702, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03312666714191437, "input_change_l1": 0.11066775768995285, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7070149034261703, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08498947825282813, "edit_score": 0.27474191710352897, "background_score": 0.07691748216748237, "combined_score": 0.3219735982269049, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/102171_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/102171_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/102171_1.json"}

102625_1

let there be a game show on TV

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.01629599928855896, "dataset_mask_area": 0.016296, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.7191060185432434, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.006743448320776224, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.7123625702224672, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7531481481481481, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.7541257185240126, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3209408223628998, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.8329053767412055, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.06291976443482782, "best_expert": "pix2pix", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.7263551142357756, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.02411273680627346, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.7191060185432434, "edit_change_ratio": 0.03353154637075735, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.6427182555198669, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.8937739901299645}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.02444400079548359, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/102625_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.849427342414856, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.15057265758514404}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.6344676753534587, "reward": -0.6344676753534587}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.7209735046314891, "reward": -0.7209735046314891}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.7214536799366178, "reward": -0.7214536799366178}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.7220464734872221, "reward": -0.7220464734872221}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.7873583007676063, "reward": -0.7873583007676063}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "102625_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.6344676753534587, "loser_reward": -0.7209735046314891, "reward_margin": 0.08650582927803041, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.6344676753534587, "loser_reward": -0.7214536799366178, "reward_margin": 0.08698600458315908, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.6344676753534587, "loser_reward": -0.7220464734872221, "reward_margin": 0.08757879813376335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.6344676753534587, "loser_reward": -0.7873583007676063, "reward_margin": 0.15289062541414755, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.7209735046314891, "loser_reward": -0.7873583007676063, "reward_margin": 0.06638479613611714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.7214536799366178, "loser_reward": -0.7873583007676063, "reward_margin": 0.06590462083098847, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.7220464734872221, "loser_reward": -0.7873583007676063, "reward_margin": 0.0653118272803842, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4074, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 325, 64, 410], "component_score": 0.6344676753534587, "component_reward": -0.6344676753534587, "second_component_score": 0.7209735046314891, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.08650582927803041, "confidence": 0.7507876377624094}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7507876753807068, "teacher_quality_score": 0.06291976443482782, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.06291976443482782, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "102625_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.6344676753534587, "loser_reward": -0.7209735046314891, "reward_margin": 0.08650582927803041, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.6344676753534587, "loser_reward": -0.7214536799366178, "reward_margin": 0.08698600458315908, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.6344676753534587, "loser_reward": -0.7220464734872221, "reward_margin": 0.08757879813376335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.6344676753534587, "loser_reward": -0.7873583007676063, "reward_margin": 0.15289062541414755, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.7209735046314891, "loser_reward": -0.7873583007676063, "reward_margin": 0.06638479613611714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.7214536799366178, "loser_reward": -0.7873583007676063, "reward_margin": 0.06590462083098847, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.7220464734872221, "loser_reward": -0.7873583007676063, "reward_margin": 0.0653118272803842, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/102625_1/102625_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.49046793580055237, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.24716103076934814, "background_mse_to_source": 0.07550552487373352, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5831668376922607, "background_mse_to_target": 0.07566788792610168, "full_mse_to_target": 0.08242747187614441, "input_change_l1": 0.211292564868927, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9492617249488831, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04393406785675325, "edit_score": 0.653720298409462, "background_score": 0.15887215733528137, "combined_score": 0.7263551142357756, "confidence": 0.7349802135004271}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/102625_1/102625_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.5697792172431946, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.19523221254348755, "background_mse_to_source": 0.011810525320470333, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9202583432197571, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012342207133769989, "full_mse_to_target": 0.021426202729344368, "input_change_l1": 0.03107796050608158, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6948051601648331, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0026106202480150388, "edit_score": 0.8070314846932888, "background_score": 0.02775885667651892, "combined_score": 0.8194118288526079, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/102625_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.5707036852836609, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.19473721086978912, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00498994579538703, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9458017945289612, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00559835834428668, "full_mse_to_target": 0.014807313680648804, "input_change_l1": 0.02020067349076271, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6948052644729614, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0017102907266234979, "edit_score": 0.8080549269914628, "background_score": 0.015829586889594793, "combined_score": 0.8154180719162106, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/102625_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.5691168904304504, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.19558392465114594, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01656174287199974, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9119063019752502, "background_mse_to_target": 0.017050726339221, "full_mse_to_target": 0.026047203689813614, "input_change_l1": 0.037676867097616196, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6952379047870636, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0032368508924264464, "edit_score": 0.8061906293034553, "background_score": 0.03418048247694969, "combined_score": 0.8214058887178544, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/102625_1/102625_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.5767415761947632, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.19112630188465118, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005802472587674856, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7857310175895691, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006050919648259878, "full_mse_to_target": 0.015350892208516598, "input_change_l1": 0.050907980650663376, "directional_pixel_score": 0.2945377826690674, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.004746341763529926, "edit_score": 0.9148818701505661, "background_score": 0.04865626906976104, "combined_score": 0.9343959218985401, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/102625_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/102625_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/102625_1.json"}

102625_2

let there be granite floor in the kitchen

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.1285858154296875, "dataset_mask_area": 0.1285858154296875, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.19288596510887146, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0010826389770954847, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.19180332613177598, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9133343977241389, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9770056049808251, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.30778083205223083, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.34048367805790564, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.1559571219650934, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.15683840805198998, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.11620913445949554, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.19288598001003265, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6024757965998935, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.14643573760986328, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/102625_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5149657726287842, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4850342571735382}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.09631987863127142, "reward": -0.09631987863127142}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.09931392347114158, "reward": -0.09931392347114158}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.10831246062088758, "reward": -0.10831246062088758}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.19580956776067612, "reward": -0.19580956776067612}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2316066618207842, "reward": -0.2316066618207842}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09631987863127142, "loser_reward": -0.10831246062088758, "reward_margin": 0.011992581989616155, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09631987863127142, "loser_reward": -0.19580956776067612, "reward_margin": 0.0994896891294047, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09631987863127142, "loser_reward": -0.2316066618207842, "reward_margin": 0.1352867831895128, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09931392347114158, "loser_reward": -0.19580956776067612, "reward_margin": 0.09649564428953454, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09931392347114158, "loser_reward": -0.2316066618207842, "reward_margin": 0.1322927383496426, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10831246062088758, "loser_reward": -0.19580956776067612, "reward_margin": 0.08749710713978855, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10831246062088758, "loser_reward": -0.2316066618207842, "reward_margin": 0.12329420119989663, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19580956776067612, "loser_reward": -0.2316066618207842, "reward_margin": 0.03579709406010809, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 134832, "bbox_xyxy": [240, 754, 898, 1024], "component_score": 0.09631987863127142, "component_reward": -0.09631987863127142, "second_component_score": 0.09931392347114158, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.002994044839870161, "confidence": 0.604003570472804}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6040035486221313, "teacher_quality_score": 0.1559571219650934, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.1559571219650934, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09631987863127142, "loser_reward": -0.10831246062088758, "reward_margin": 0.011992581989616155, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09631987863127142, "loser_reward": -0.19580956776067612, "reward_margin": 0.0994896891294047, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09631987863127142, "loser_reward": -0.2316066618207842, "reward_margin": 0.1352867831895128, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09931392347114158, "loser_reward": -0.19580956776067612, "reward_margin": 0.09649564428953454, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09931392347114158, "loser_reward": -0.2316066618207842, "reward_margin": 0.1322927383496426, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10831246062088758, "loser_reward": -0.19580956776067612, "reward_margin": 0.08749710713978855, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10831246062088758, "loser_reward": -0.2316066618207842, "reward_margin": 0.12329420119989663, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19580956776067612, "loser_reward": -0.2316066618207842, "reward_margin": 0.03579709406010809, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/102625_2/102625_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07804296165704727, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.45910564064979553, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06325710564851761, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.38688620924949646, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06302738934755325, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06495817750692368, "input_change_l1": 0.22483791410923004, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8145653009414673, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.20766214672476055, "edit_score": 0.23258050829172133, "background_score": 0.18587986379861832, "combined_score": 0.3456667077168822, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/102625_2/102625_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03320442512631416, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5956414341926575, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002150020794942975, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9781586527824402, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00220329686999321, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006189602892845869, "input_change_l1": 0.036255087703466415, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8602333664894104, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04445353066548705, "edit_score": 0.14901779666543008, "background_score": 0.0065182902384549385, "combined_score": 0.16080886467127134, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/102625_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03626248612999916, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6098084449768066, "background_mse_to_source": 0.000908383633941412, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9864502549171448, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0009686636622063816, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005506948102265596, "input_change_l1": 0.023565806448459625, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8602334856987, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02889435552060604, "edit_score": 0.14924242570996285, "background_score": 0.003618332650512457, "combined_score": 0.15683840805198998, "confidence": 0.594299012180541}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/102625_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03693515062332153, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5792670845985413, "background_mse_to_source": 0.003249828703701496, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9727508425712585, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0032981003168970346, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007623346988111734, "input_change_l1": 0.04518045857548714, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8600447177886963, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.055496504064649343, "edit_score": 0.15607055425643923, "background_score": 0.008699660189449787, "combined_score": 0.1709770708344877, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/102625_2/102625_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06462529301643372, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5584596991539001, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00860254280269146, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7928778529167175, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008620092645287514, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01582156866788864, "input_change_l1": 0.06497085839509964, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6245966926217079, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05176276750862599, "edit_score": 0.24678418003022673, "background_score": 0.05002697221934796, "combined_score": 0.27622833067551256, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/102625_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/102625_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/102625_2.json"}

102625_3

let the cabinets be made of dark wood

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.10870933532714844, "dataset_mask_area": 0.10870933532714844, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.22277043759822845, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0010962288361042738, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.22167420876212418, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9470286788500991, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9777813228399493, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.31133970618247986, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.374428903137734, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.07833544712280856, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.08649570951063652, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.17013700306415558, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.22277043759822845, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7637324094636001, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.13473224639892578, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/102625_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.04007878131431062, "reward": -0.04007878131431062}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.0739657189338468, "reward": -0.0739657189338468}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.10785927628073844, "reward": -0.10785927628073844}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.12051904992572965, "reward": -0.12051904992572965}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.14343218656862156, "reward": -0.14343218656862156}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04007878131431062, "loser_reward": -0.0739657189338468, "reward_margin": 0.033886937619536185, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.04007878131431062, "loser_reward": -0.10785927628073844, "reward_margin": 0.06778049496642782, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04007878131431062, "loser_reward": -0.12051904992572965, "reward_margin": 0.08044026861141904, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.04007878131431062, "loser_reward": -0.14343218656862156, "reward_margin": 0.10335340525431094, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.0739657189338468, "loser_reward": -0.10785927628073844, "reward_margin": 0.03389355734689163, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0739657189338468, "loser_reward": -0.12051904992572965, "reward_margin": 0.046553330991882844, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.0739657189338468, "loser_reward": -0.14343218656862156, "reward_margin": 0.06946646763477475, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10785927628073844, "loser_reward": -0.12051904992572965, "reward_margin": 0.012659773644991212, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10785927628073844, "loser_reward": -0.14343218656862156, "reward_margin": 0.03557291028788312, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12051904992572965, "loser_reward": -0.14343218656862156, "reward_margin": 0.022913136642891907, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 21414, "bbox_xyxy": [258, 257, 413, 466], "component_score": 0.04007878131431062, "component_reward": -0.04007878131431062, "second_component_score": 0.0739657189338468, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.033886937619536185, "confidence": 0.9775347885036845}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.08433042508747894, "reward": -0.08433042508747894}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.10975312669668347, "reward": -0.10975312669668347}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.12182699767313898, "reward": -0.12182699767313898}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.139363992550876, "reward": -0.139363992550876}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.14364904987299815, "reward": -0.14364904987299815}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.08433042508747894, "loser_reward": -0.10975312669668347, "reward_margin": 0.025422701609204526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08433042508747894, "loser_reward": -0.12182699767313898, "reward_margin": 0.03749657258566004, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08433042508747894, "loser_reward": -0.139363992550876, "reward_margin": 0.05503356746339706, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08433042508747894, "loser_reward": -0.14364904987299815, "reward_margin": 0.059318624785519206, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10975312669668347, "loser_reward": -0.12182699767313898, "reward_margin": 0.012073870976455514, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10975312669668347, "loser_reward": -0.139363992550876, "reward_margin": 0.029610865854192536, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10975312669668347, "loser_reward": -0.14364904987299815, "reward_margin": 0.03389592317631468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12182699767313898, "loser_reward": -0.139363992550876, "reward_margin": 0.017536994877737022, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12182699767313898, "loser_reward": -0.14364904987299815, "reward_margin": 0.021822052199859165, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 92576, "bbox_xyxy": [288, 577, 880, 815], "component_score": 0.08433042508747894, "component_reward": -0.08433042508747894, "second_component_score": 0.10975312669668347, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.025422701609204526, "confidence": 0.8780396986588033}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8967306017875671, "teacher_quality_score": 0.07833544712280856, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.07833544712280856, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04007878131431062, "loser_reward": -0.0739657189338468, "reward_margin": 0.033886937619536185, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.04007878131431062, "loser_reward": -0.10785927628073844, "reward_margin": 0.06778049496642782, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04007878131431062, "loser_reward": -0.12051904992572965, "reward_margin": 0.08044026861141904, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.04007878131431062, "loser_reward": -0.14343218656862156, "reward_margin": 0.10335340525431094, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.0739657189338468, "loser_reward": -0.10785927628073844, "reward_margin": 0.03389355734689163, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0739657189338468, "loser_reward": -0.12051904992572965, "reward_margin": 0.046553330991882844, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.0739657189338468, "loser_reward": -0.14343218656862156, "reward_margin": 0.06946646763477475, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10785927628073844, "loser_reward": -0.12051904992572965, "reward_margin": 0.012659773644991212, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10785927628073844, "loser_reward": -0.14343218656862156, "reward_margin": 0.03557291028788312, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12051904992572965, "loser_reward": -0.14343218656862156, "reward_margin": 0.022913136642891907, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.08433042508747894, "loser_reward": -0.10975312669668347, "reward_margin": 0.025422701609204526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08433042508747894, "loser_reward": -0.12182699767313898, "reward_margin": 0.03749657258566004, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08433042508747894, "loser_reward": -0.139363992550876, "reward_margin": 0.05503356746339706, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08433042508747894, "loser_reward": -0.14364904987299815, "reward_margin": 0.059318624785519206, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10975312669668347, "loser_reward": -0.12182699767313898, "reward_margin": 0.012073870976455514, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10975312669668347, "loser_reward": -0.139363992550876, "reward_margin": 0.029610865854192536, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10975312669668347, "loser_reward": -0.14364904987299815, "reward_margin": 0.03389592317631468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12182699767313898, "loser_reward": -0.139363992550876, "reward_margin": 0.017536994877737022, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102625_3__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12182699767313898, "loser_reward": -0.14364904987299815, "reward_margin": 0.021822052199859165, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/102625_3/102625_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.014115490019321442, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7719163298606873, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05724195018410683, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3984207212924957, "background_mse_to_target": 0.057289689779281616, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05259626731276512, "input_change_l1": 0.20308834314346313, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9546836018562317, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13995805140584708, "edit_score": 0.07106132358312607, "background_score": 0.1775578059256077, "combined_score": 0.16645779266953467, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/102625_3/102625_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.025208065286278725, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7228951454162598, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00203505321405828, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9636532664299011, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002088716719299555, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004602005239576101, "input_change_l1": 0.04760362207889557, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9309782385826111, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0697622284758836, "edit_score": 0.097884476557374, "background_score": 0.009304399928078057, "combined_score": 0.11555366275133565, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/102625_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.015359892509877682, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7884607315063477, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0008598104468546808, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9745950698852539, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0009154872386716306, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0024857281241565943, "input_change_l1": 0.030942359939217567, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9309763312339783, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.046220972668379545, "edit_score": 0.07492366340011358, "background_score": 0.0059407964698039, "combined_score": 0.08649570951063652, "confidence": 0.893821474366236}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/102625_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03639790415763855, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6580842137336731, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0027844777796417475, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9586062431335449, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0028367547784000635, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0064851646311581135, "input_change_l1": 0.05502340570092201, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9249647557735443, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07988996645435692, "edit_score": 0.12353987246751785, "background_score": 0.011063229152932763, "combined_score": 0.14403851242503152, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/102625_3/102625_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.024409204721450806, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7788512706756592, "background_mse_to_source": 0.016639022156596184, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6992066502571106, "background_mse_to_target": 0.016653425991535187, "full_mse_to_target": 0.017496544867753983, "input_change_l1": 0.10605207085609436, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8847208321094513, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1016253428068012, "edit_score": 0.09745874255895615, "background_score": 0.07679769210517406, "combined_score": 0.1464126578439027, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/102625_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/102625_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/102625_3.json"}

102724_1

remove middle fruit and put a cat in place

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.20174799859523773, "dataset_mask_area": 0.201748, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.24719062447547913, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.006679764948785305, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.24051085952669382, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9146605329330812, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9819197689748258, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3178445100784302, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.38954691423765664, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.28320820580571304, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.30038932057097556, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1637190729379654, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.24719062447547913, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6623191040734882, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.2415360063314438, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/102724_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6494879126548767, "qwen_image_edit": 0.3505120277404785}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.19343052088888354, "reward": -0.19343052088888354}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.22426998074073343, "reward": -0.22426998074073343}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.23240414913650598, "reward": -0.23240414913650598}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2398945651706308, "reward": -0.2398945651706308}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2518408814575523, "reward": -0.2518408814575523}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19343052088888354, "loser_reward": -0.22426998074073343, "reward_margin": 0.030839459851849882, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19343052088888354, "loser_reward": -0.23240414913650598, "reward_margin": 0.03897362824762243, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19343052088888354, "loser_reward": -0.2398945651706308, "reward_margin": 0.04646404428174725, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19343052088888354, "loser_reward": -0.2518408814575523, "reward_margin": 0.058410360568668745, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22426998074073343, "loser_reward": -0.2398945651706308, "reward_margin": 0.015624584429897365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22426998074073343, "loser_reward": -0.2518408814575523, "reward_margin": 0.027570900716818864, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23240414913650598, "loser_reward": -0.2518408814575523, "reward_margin": 0.019436732321046313, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2398945651706308, "loser_reward": -0.2518408814575523, "reward_margin": 0.011946316286921499, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 50437, "bbox_xyxy": [142, 180, 413, 437], "component_score": 0.19343052088888354, "component_reward": -0.19343052088888354, "second_component_score": 0.22426998074073343, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.030839459851849882, "confidence": 0.7752481225445866}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7752482295036316, "teacher_quality_score": 0.28320820580571304, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.28320820580571304, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19343052088888354, "loser_reward": -0.22426998074073343, "reward_margin": 0.030839459851849882, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19343052088888354, "loser_reward": -0.23240414913650598, "reward_margin": 0.03897362824762243, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19343052088888354, "loser_reward": -0.2398945651706308, "reward_margin": 0.04646404428174725, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19343052088888354, "loser_reward": -0.2518408814575523, "reward_margin": 0.058410360568668745, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22426998074073343, "loser_reward": -0.2398945651706308, "reward_margin": 0.015624584429897365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22426998074073343, "loser_reward": -0.2518408814575523, "reward_margin": 0.027570900716818864, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23240414913650598, "loser_reward": -0.2518408814575523, "reward_margin": 0.019436732321046313, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "102724_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2398945651706308, "loser_reward": -0.2518408814575523, "reward_margin": 0.011946316286921499, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/102724_1/102724_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0927533507347107, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4184504747390747, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05950856953859329, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3815132677555084, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05937771499156952, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06611118465662003, "input_change_l1": 0.20068241655826569, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7535449266433716, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1348411863669753, "edit_score": 0.2706770241260529, "background_score": 0.1832059159874916, "combined_score": 0.3683784504607319, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/102724_1/102724_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10011178255081177, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.40221381187438965, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02928660437464714, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8071689009666443, "background_mse_to_target": 0.029754675924777985, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04394907131791115, "input_change_l1": 0.10573830455541611, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6975154727697372, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.095502567011863, "edit_score": 0.2952901519834995, "background_score": 0.06785282418131829, "combined_score": 0.34253406098112466, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/102724_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08089917153120041, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4211760461330414, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012373591773211956, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8766727447509766, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012878801673650742, "full_mse_to_target": 0.026601778343319893, "input_change_l1": 0.06872989982366562, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6975156515836716, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06240214169956744, "edit_score": 0.27228504940867426, "background_score": 0.03703904282301665, "combined_score": 0.30038932057097556, "confidence": 0.6825724832376687}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/102724_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11910654604434967, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3828321695327759, "background_mse_to_source": 0.043432895094156265, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7708398699760437, "background_mse_to_target": 0.043874967843294144, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05905279517173767, "input_change_l1": 0.1296512484550476, "directional_pixel_score": 0.701365277171135, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11794350128620863, "edit_score": 0.31719879284501074, "background_score": 0.08926492109894753, "combined_score": 0.37793549500405793, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/102724_1/102724_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08776209503412247, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4302807152271271, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009016800671815872, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8049010634422302, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009158642031252384, "full_mse_to_target": 0.025016726925969124, "input_change_l1": 0.05876895412802696, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6111452281475067, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.034137741010636095, "edit_score": 0.2989196449518204, "background_score": 0.04803658798336983, "combined_score": 0.32506167164072397, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/102724_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/102724_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/102724_1.json"}

104304_1

let the woman cry

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.006527999881654978, "dataset_mask_area": 0.006528, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.13717719912528992, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.006154546048492193, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.13102265307679772, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.2861344537815126, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.30334075723830733, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5176374316215515, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.17749241782011152, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.009951989317851257, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.15709789242930128, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.033978115767240524, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.1371772140264511, "edit_change_ratio": 0.24769504183609323, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.11903353780508041, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.8677354956496481}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.016815999522805214, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/104304_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.5064886212348938, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4935113787651062}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.0885293992093066, "reward": -0.0885293992093066}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.08982719461049418, "reward": -0.08982719461049418}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.09142071188203407, "reward": -0.09142071188203407}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.11881785293482243, "reward": -0.11881785293482243}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.1227162747925613, "reward": -0.1227162747925613}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0885293992093066, "loser_reward": -0.11881785293482243, "reward_margin": 0.030288453725515835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0885293992093066, "loser_reward": -0.1227162747925613, "reward_margin": 0.0341868755832547, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08982719461049418, "loser_reward": -0.11881785293482243, "reward_margin": 0.028990658324328247, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08982719461049418, "loser_reward": -0.1227162747925613, "reward_margin": 0.03288908018206711, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09142071188203407, "loser_reward": -0.11881785293482243, "reward_margin": 0.027397141052788357, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09142071188203407, "loser_reward": -0.1227162747925613, "reward_margin": 0.03129556291052722, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 1632, "bbox_xyxy": [189, 231, 253, 288], "component_score": 0.0885293992093066, "component_reward": -0.0885293992093066, "second_component_score": 0.08982719461049418, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0012977954011875875, "confidence": 0.5759769166877535}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5759768486022949, "teacher_quality_score": 0.009951989317851257, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.009951989317851257, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0885293992093066, "loser_reward": -0.11881785293482243, "reward_margin": 0.030288453725515835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0885293992093066, "loser_reward": -0.1227162747925613, "reward_margin": 0.0341868755832547, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08982719461049418, "loser_reward": -0.11881785293482243, "reward_margin": 0.028990658324328247, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08982719461049418, "loser_reward": -0.1227162747925613, "reward_margin": 0.03288908018206711, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09142071188203407, "loser_reward": -0.11881785293482243, "reward_margin": 0.027397141052788357, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09142071188203407, "loser_reward": -0.1227162747925613, "reward_margin": 0.03129556291052722, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/104304_1/104304_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03427399694919586, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7899087071418762, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0015310406452044845, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9432850480079651, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0018015386303886771, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0020135187078267336, "input_change_l1": 0.024712521582841873, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5988289415836334, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04349234802648425, "edit_score": 0.17658502012491226, "background_score": 0.012874031043611468, "combined_score": 0.1899907524662558, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/104304_1/104304_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03108103759586811, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8424751162528992, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0003026638296432793, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9842753410339355, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006834587547928095, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0008818941423669457, "input_change_l1": 0.008071910589933395, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6393766701221466, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.029438956221565605, "edit_score": 0.15274184681475161, "background_score": 0.00344759562285617, "combined_score": 0.1599244859413011, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/104304_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.031103767454624176, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8436324000358582, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00012787543528247625, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9910377860069275, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0005512618226930499, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0007507085101678967, "input_change_l1": 0.005246738903224468, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6393766552209854, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01908793277107179, "edit_score": 0.1525331236422062, "background_score": 0.0019203182338969782, "combined_score": 0.15709789242930128, "confidence": 0.5817612850197919}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/104304_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.031628094613552094, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8390340805053711, "background_mse_to_source": 0.000467899430077523, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9798819422721863, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0008179558208212256, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0010190842440351844, "input_change_l1": 0.010079696774482727, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6393766701221466, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03687396729364992, "edit_score": 0.15397711098194122, "background_score": 0.004491510975640267, "combined_score": 0.16302584170654882, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/104304_1/104304_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03850291296839714, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8088066577911377, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00470176013186574, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8258001208305359, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0048174480907619, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005037346854805946, "input_change_l1": 0.0453997440636158, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5994801893830299, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0497820152901113, "edit_score": 0.1768715340644121, "background_score": 0.039541735965758565, "combined_score": 0.20117127939593046, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/104304_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/104304_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/104304_1.json"}

104304_2

let the woman have blonde hair

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.045754432678222656, "dataset_mask_area": 0.045754432678222656, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.26211726665496826, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0008505257428623736, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2612667409121059, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8731803797468355, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9447261988829685, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5100557804107666, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4038374344370449, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.13443532514862455, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.13894240991561677, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.20417840778827667, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2621172368526459, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7789583403210503, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.06438350677490234, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/104304_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.09061351412930525, "reward": -0.09061351412930525}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.12181012189155445, "reward": -0.12181012189155445}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.14959450875315813, "reward": -0.14959450875315813}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.16806727454438808, "reward": -0.16806727454438808}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.18571205671783542, "reward": -0.18571205671783542}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09061351412930525, "loser_reward": -0.12181012189155445, "reward_margin": 0.031196607762249196, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09061351412930525, "loser_reward": -0.14959450875315813, "reward_margin": 0.05898099462385288, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09061351412930525, "loser_reward": -0.16806727454438808, "reward_margin": 0.07745376041508283, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09061351412930525, "loser_reward": -0.18571205671783542, "reward_margin": 0.09509854258853016, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12181012189155445, "loser_reward": -0.14959450875315813, "reward_margin": 0.027784386861603685, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12181012189155445, "loser_reward": -0.16806727454438808, "reward_margin": 0.04625715265283363, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12181012189155445, "loser_reward": -0.18571205671783542, "reward_margin": 0.06390193482628097, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14959450875315813, "loser_reward": -0.16806727454438808, "reward_margin": 0.018472765791229945, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14959450875315813, "loser_reward": -0.18571205671783542, "reward_margin": 0.03611754796467728, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16806727454438808, "loser_reward": -0.18571205671783542, "reward_margin": 0.017644782173447338, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 47975, "bbox_xyxy": [343, 230, 693, 495], "component_score": 0.09061351412930525, "component_reward": -0.09061351412930525, "second_component_score": 0.12181012189155445, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.031196607762249196, "confidence": 0.8972498075096437}], "teacher_confidence": 0.897254228591919, "teacher_quality_score": 0.13443532514862455, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.13443532514862455, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09061351412930525, "loser_reward": -0.12181012189155445, "reward_margin": 0.031196607762249196, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09061351412930525, "loser_reward": -0.14959450875315813, "reward_margin": 0.05898099462385288, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09061351412930525, "loser_reward": -0.16806727454438808, "reward_margin": 0.07745376041508283, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09061351412930525, "loser_reward": -0.18571205671783542, "reward_margin": 0.09509854258853016, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12181012189155445, "loser_reward": -0.14959450875315813, "reward_margin": 0.027784386861603685, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12181012189155445, "loser_reward": -0.16806727454438808, "reward_margin": 0.04625715265283363, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12181012189155445, "loser_reward": -0.18571205671783542, "reward_margin": 0.06390193482628097, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14959450875315813, "loser_reward": -0.16806727454438808, "reward_margin": 0.018472765791229945, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14959450875315813, "loser_reward": -0.18571205671783542, "reward_margin": 0.03611754796467728, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16806727454438808, "loser_reward": -0.18571205671783542, "reward_margin": 0.017644782173447338, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/104304_2/104304_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06679078936576843, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6740701198577881, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004477806854993105, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9539679884910583, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004506723023951054, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007356492802500725, "input_change_l1": 0.043165355920791626, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8526913225650787, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07513141352683306, "edit_score": 0.16880393475294114, "background_score": 0.013684209156781436, "combined_score": 0.18935533994343132, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/104304_2/104304_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05832921341061592, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6639450192451477, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0028811160009354353, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9451071619987488, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002896590856835246, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005432880949229002, "input_change_l1": 0.03931276127696037, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9091510474681854, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0934123526327312, "edit_score": 0.14825244769454005, "background_score": 0.01385968360118568, "combined_score": 0.17232909557642417, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/104304_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03886030986905098, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.68789142370224, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0012172708520665765, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9712689518928528, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0012445354368537664, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0029656256083399057, "input_change_l1": 0.025553300976753235, "directional_pixel_score": 0.909151554107666, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0610724629368633, "edit_score": 0.12399413660168648, "background_score": 0.00696348047349602, "combined_score": 0.13894240991561677, "confidence": 0.8424097804032707}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/104304_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09624042361974716, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6441481113433838, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0043426454067230225, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9242179989814758, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004349917639046907, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008554319851100445, "input_change_l1": 0.048627037554979324, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9043312072753906, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11290472783148289, "edit_score": 0.19132799953222274, "background_score": 0.019499045610427857, "combined_score": 0.2215890430472791, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/104304_2/104304_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08576507866382599, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6247369647026062, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007619882933795452, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8212084770202637, "background_mse_to_target": 0.007628168445080519, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01120328065007925, "input_change_l1": 0.06479691714048386, "directional_pixel_score": 0.759735494852066, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07841600375249982, "edit_score": 0.22088381201028823, "background_score": 0.04337818752974272, "combined_score": 0.2528697064612061, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/104304_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/104304_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/104304_2.json"}

104304_3

let the woman hold a cup

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.021379470825195312, "dataset_mask_area": 0.021379470825195312, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.21214064955711365, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0006287263240665197, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.21151192323304713, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8276694148401368, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8937334433491119, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5292267203330994, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.346581590747828, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.16376095511292077, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.1716533758866717, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.11489664763212204, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.21214064955711365, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5416059952300134, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.03014850616455078, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/104304_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.575787365436554, "qwen_image_edit": 0.42421260476112366}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.10527768512890906, "reward": -0.10527768512890906}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.12055286782467736, "reward": -0.12055286782467736}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.14547244302020407, "reward": -0.14547244302020407}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.22354380210768432, "reward": -0.22354380210768432}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.26613814816717063, "reward": -0.26613814816717063}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10527768512890906, "loser_reward": -0.12055286782467736, "reward_margin": 0.015275182695768302, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10527768512890906, "loser_reward": -0.14547244302020407, "reward_margin": 0.04019475789129501, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10527768512890906, "loser_reward": -0.22354380210768432, "reward_margin": 0.11826611697877526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10527768512890906, "loser_reward": -0.26613814816717063, "reward_margin": 0.16086046303826157, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12055286782467736, "loser_reward": -0.14547244302020407, "reward_margin": 0.024919575195526705, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12055286782467736, "loser_reward": -0.22354380210768432, "reward_margin": 0.10299093428300696, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12055286782467736, "loser_reward": -0.26613814816717063, "reward_margin": 0.14558528034249327, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14547244302020407, "loser_reward": -0.22354380210768432, "reward_margin": 0.07807135908748025, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14547244302020407, "loser_reward": -0.26613814816717063, "reward_margin": 0.12066570514696656, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22354380210768432, "loser_reward": -0.26613814816717063, "reward_margin": 0.04259434605948631, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 22418, "bbox_xyxy": [339, 576, 512, 831], "component_score": 0.10527768512890906, "component_reward": -0.10527768512890906, "second_component_score": 0.12055286782467736, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.015275182695768302, "confidence": 0.7603648522290705}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7603647708892822, "teacher_quality_score": 0.16376095511292077, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.16376095511292077, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10527768512890906, "loser_reward": -0.12055286782467736, "reward_margin": 0.015275182695768302, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10527768512890906, "loser_reward": -0.14547244302020407, "reward_margin": 0.04019475789129501, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10527768512890906, "loser_reward": -0.22354380210768432, "reward_margin": 0.11826611697877526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10527768512890906, "loser_reward": -0.26613814816717063, "reward_margin": 0.16086046303826157, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12055286782467736, "loser_reward": -0.14547244302020407, "reward_margin": 0.024919575195526705, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12055286782467736, "loser_reward": -0.22354380210768432, "reward_margin": 0.10299093428300696, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12055286782467736, "loser_reward": -0.26613814816717063, "reward_margin": 0.14558528034249327, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14547244302020407, "loser_reward": -0.22354380210768432, "reward_margin": 0.07807135908748025, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14547244302020407, "loser_reward": -0.26613814816717063, "reward_margin": 0.12066570514696656, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "104304_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22354380210768432, "loser_reward": -0.26613814816717063, "reward_margin": 0.04259434605948631, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/104304_3/104304_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13887399435043335, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6496662497520447, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01407225988805294, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7473148703575134, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01416324358433485, "full_mse_to_target": 0.016829492524266243, "input_change_l1": 0.07905224710702896, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5636239424347878, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12734479205682875, "edit_score": 0.3180347587913275, "background_score": 0.06460928581655026, "combined_score": 0.3677999164909124, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/104304_3/104304_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.055165212601423264, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7245564460754395, "background_mse_to_source": 0.001126292860135436, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9884161353111267, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0012040064902976155, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002357667777687311, "input_change_l1": 0.011523705907166004, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7747104167938232, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08653929177671671, "edit_score": 0.16657631918787957, "background_score": 0.0034430657979100943, "combined_score": 0.1853250173502602, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/104304_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.045230936259031296, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.710258424282074, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0004758588911499828, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9928590655326843, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0005474360077641904, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0015027454355731606, "input_change_l1": 0.007490409072488546, "directional_pixel_score": 0.774710088968277, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.056674780789762735, "edit_score": 0.15950172916054725, "background_score": 0.0019040457846131176, "combined_score": 0.1716533758866717, "confidence": 0.6790635602103106}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/104304_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07064796984195709, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6951058506965637, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0016426503425464034, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9855430722236633, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0017248516669496894, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0031983929220587015, "input_change_l1": 0.014336097985506058, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7747399508953094, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10656546643003821, "edit_score": 0.18794181197881699, "background_score": 0.004534035897813737, "combined_score": 0.2111616571212653, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/104304_3/104304_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09784309566020966, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6060478091239929, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005613876041024923, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8384506106376648, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005634328816086054, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007605704944580793, "input_change_l1": 0.049959275871515274, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5140573782846332, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.077099649887532, "edit_score": 0.2981191892642528, "background_score": 0.03792375391349197, "combined_score": 0.3275730036059395, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/104304_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/104304_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/104304_3.json"}

10546_1

Add a turtle.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.13012400269508362, "dataset_mask_area": 0.130124, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.22958995401859283, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.010380761697888374, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.21920919232070446, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6918455340103197, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.7476321417659639, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3339681625366211, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.33213594207258135, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.2639138105751408, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2618616523910896, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.07368007302284241, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.22958995401859283, "edit_change_ratio": 0.3209202830228172, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.19408799707889557, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/10546_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5089940428733826, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49100589752197266}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.0909512887149467, "reward": -0.0909512887149467}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.09275029361213093, "reward": -0.09275029361213093}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.09377077849488705, "reward": -0.09377077849488705}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.12611563507607207, "reward": -0.12611563507607207}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.21185563188418746, "reward": -0.21185563188418746}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0909512887149467, "loser_reward": -0.12611563507607207, "reward_margin": 0.035164346361125365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0909512887149467, "loser_reward": -0.21185563188418746, "reward_margin": 0.12090434316924076, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09275029361213093, "loser_reward": -0.12611563507607207, "reward_margin": 0.03336534146394114, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09275029361213093, "loser_reward": -0.21185563188418746, "reward_margin": 0.11910533827205654, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09377077849488705, "loser_reward": -0.12611563507607207, "reward_margin": 0.03234485658118502, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09377077849488705, "loser_reward": -0.21185563188418746, "reward_margin": 0.11808485338930041, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12611563507607207, "loser_reward": -0.21185563188418746, "reward_margin": 0.08573999680811539, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4703, "bbox_xyxy": [350, 188, 491, 272], "component_score": 0.0909512887149467, "component_reward": -0.0909512887149467, "second_component_score": 0.09275029361213093, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0017990048971842226, "confidence": 0.5848432930589332}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5666260719299316, "qwen_image_edit": 0.43337389826774597}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.18319058416580083, "reward": -0.18319058416580083}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1965955217895098, "reward": -0.1965955217895098}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.20936520169163123, "reward": -0.20936520169163123}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.25685304956650357, "reward": -0.25685304956650357}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2635033933483064, "reward": -0.2635033933483064}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.18319058416580083, "loser_reward": -0.1965955217895098, "reward_margin": 0.013404937623708951, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18319058416580083, "loser_reward": -0.20936520169163123, "reward_margin": 0.02617461752583039, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18319058416580083, "loser_reward": -0.25685304956650357, "reward_margin": 0.07366246540070273, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18319058416580083, "loser_reward": -0.2635033933483064, "reward_margin": 0.08031280918250558, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1965955217895098, "loser_reward": -0.20936520169163123, "reward_margin": 0.012769679902121439, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1965955217895098, "loser_reward": -0.25685304956650357, "reward_margin": 0.06025752777699378, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1965955217895098, "loser_reward": -0.2635033933483064, "reward_margin": 0.06690787155879663, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20936520169163123, "loser_reward": -0.25685304956650357, "reward_margin": 0.04748784787487234, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20936520169163123, "loser_reward": -0.2635033933483064, "reward_margin": 0.05413819165667519, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 27193, "bbox_xyxy": [249, 227, 500, 436], "component_score": 0.18319058416580083, "component_reward": -0.18319058416580083, "second_component_score": 0.1965955217895098, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.013404937623708951, "confidence": 0.6697782429184806}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5084477066993713, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4915522634983063}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.0810645794373122, "reward": -0.0810645794373122}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.08275428194226697, "reward": -0.08275428194226697}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.08370236682379617, "reward": -0.08370236682379617}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.12017046813061462, "reward": -0.12017046813061462}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.12583847612515092, "reward": -0.12583847612515092}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0810645794373122, "loser_reward": -0.12017046813061462, "reward_margin": 0.03910588869330242, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0810645794373122, "loser_reward": -0.12583847612515092, "reward_margin": 0.044773896687838724, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08275428194226697, "loser_reward": -0.12017046813061462, "reward_margin": 0.03741618618834765, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08275428194226697, "loser_reward": -0.12583847612515092, "reward_margin": 0.04308419418288395, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08370236682379617, "loser_reward": -0.12017046813061462, "reward_margin": 0.03646810130681845, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08370236682379617, "loser_reward": -0.12583847612515092, "reward_margin": 0.04213610930135475, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 635, "bbox_xyxy": [258, 250, 294, 289], "component_score": 0.0810645794373122, "component_reward": -0.0810645794373122, "second_component_score": 0.08275428194226697, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0016897025049547737, "confidence": 0.5866714357127425}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6558769345283508, "teacher_quality_score": 0.2639138105751408, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.2639138105751408, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0909512887149467, "loser_reward": -0.12611563507607207, "reward_margin": 0.035164346361125365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0909512887149467, "loser_reward": -0.21185563188418746, "reward_margin": 0.12090434316924076, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09275029361213093, "loser_reward": -0.12611563507607207, "reward_margin": 0.03336534146394114, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09275029361213093, "loser_reward": -0.21185563188418746, "reward_margin": 0.11910533827205654, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09377077849488705, "loser_reward": -0.12611563507607207, "reward_margin": 0.03234485658118502, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09377077849488705, "loser_reward": -0.21185563188418746, "reward_margin": 0.11808485338930041, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12611563507607207, "loser_reward": -0.21185563188418746, "reward_margin": 0.08573999680811539, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.18319058416580083, "loser_reward": -0.1965955217895098, "reward_margin": 0.013404937623708951, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18319058416580083, "loser_reward": -0.20936520169163123, "reward_margin": 0.02617461752583039, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18319058416580083, "loser_reward": -0.25685304956650357, "reward_margin": 0.07366246540070273, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18319058416580083, "loser_reward": -0.2635033933483064, "reward_margin": 0.08031280918250558, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1965955217895098, "loser_reward": -0.20936520169163123, "reward_margin": 0.012769679902121439, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1965955217895098, "loser_reward": -0.25685304956650357, "reward_margin": 0.06025752777699378, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1965955217895098, "loser_reward": -0.2635033933483064, "reward_margin": 0.06690787155879663, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20936520169163123, "loser_reward": -0.25685304956650357, "reward_margin": 0.04748784787487234, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20936520169163123, "loser_reward": -0.2635033933483064, "reward_margin": 0.05413819165667519, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0810645794373122, "loser_reward": -0.12017046813061462, "reward_margin": 0.03910588869330242, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0810645794373122, "loser_reward": -0.12583847612515092, "reward_margin": 0.044773896687838724, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08275428194226697, "loser_reward": -0.12017046813061462, "reward_margin": 0.03741618618834765, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08275428194226697, "loser_reward": -0.12583847612515092, "reward_margin": 0.04308419418288395, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08370236682379617, "loser_reward": -0.12017046813061462, "reward_margin": 0.03646810130681845, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "10546_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08370236682379617, "loser_reward": -0.12583847612515092, "reward_margin": 0.04213610930135475, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/10546_1/10546_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11275844275951385, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5194475054740906, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017788004130125046, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6951422691345215, "background_mse_to_target": 0.017688263207674026, "full_mse_to_target": 0.030059169977903366, "input_change_l1": 0.08624272048473358, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5548950433731079, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.113233457878232, "edit_score": 0.32014518082141874, "background_score": 0.07875955030322075, "combined_score": 0.37336363200098277, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/10546_1/10546_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09379860013723373, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5646570920944214, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0006881537847220898, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9836366176605225, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0015435024397447705, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01354810781776905, "input_change_l1": 0.02034890651702881, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6552200317382812, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02229919875971973, "edit_score": 0.26706217378377917, "background_score": 0.003960830252617597, "combined_score": 0.2742631149059162, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/10546_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08593989163637161, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5759606957435608, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0002907449088525027, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9899742007255554, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0011844057589769363, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012213127687573433, "input_change_l1": 0.013226786628365517, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6552199721336365, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.014470067503862084, "edit_score": 0.2569427594542503, "background_score": 0.0022959047637414187, "combined_score": 0.2618616523910896, "confidence": 0.6305152149370864}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/10546_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10244292765855789, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5574509501457214, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0010173034388571978, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9792594909667969, "background_mse_to_target": 0.001847997889854014, "full_mse_to_target": 0.014937812462449074, "input_change_l1": 0.024982621893286705, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6564173400402069, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.027276329416781667, "edit_score": 0.2768484026193619, "background_score": 0.005165405245497823, "combined_score": 0.2856053415848873, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/10546_1/10546_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09969747066497803, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5670820474624634, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005605421494692564, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6462705135345459, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006095435470342636, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0182753074914217, "input_change_l1": 0.050071340054273605, "directional_pixel_score": 0.474663894623518, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03696078513748944, "edit_score": 0.31761508751660583, "background_score": 0.07635131878778338, "combined_score": 0.3535577368689701, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/10546_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/10546_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/10546_1.json"}

106508_1

change the double deck bus to a truck

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.231672003865242, "dataset_mask_area": 0.231672, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.22343400120735168, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.014232886955142021, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.20920111425220966, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8055258119990915, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9302992261715164, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.27106237411499023, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3430761807389613, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.3114162473019679, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.31370070587843657, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.15224969387054443, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.22343404591083527, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6814077650963809, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.29754000902175903, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/106508_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.21349645011965188, "reward": -0.21349645011965188}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2589836633987725, "reward": -0.2589836633987725}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.26668755113519726, "reward": -0.26668755113519726}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.29560589046124375, "reward": -0.29560589046124375}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3978210079334676, "reward": -0.3978210079334676}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21349645011965188, "loser_reward": -0.2589836633987725, "reward_margin": 0.045487213279120614, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21349645011965188, "loser_reward": -0.26668755113519726, "reward_margin": 0.05319110101554539, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21349645011965188, "loser_reward": -0.29560589046124375, "reward_margin": 0.08210944034159187, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21349645011965188, "loser_reward": -0.3978210079334676, "reward_margin": 0.1843245578138157, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2589836633987725, "loser_reward": -0.29560589046124375, "reward_margin": 0.03662222706247126, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2589836633987725, "loser_reward": -0.3978210079334676, "reward_margin": 0.1388373445346951, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.26668755113519726, "loser_reward": -0.29560589046124375, "reward_margin": 0.028918339326046483, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26668755113519726, "loser_reward": -0.3978210079334676, "reward_margin": 0.13113345679827032, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.29560589046124375, "loser_reward": -0.3978210079334676, "reward_margin": 0.10221511747222384, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 57918, "bbox_xyxy": [133, 211, 445, 452], "component_score": 0.21349645011965188, "component_reward": -0.21349645011965188, "second_component_score": 0.2589836633987725, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.045487213279120614, "confidence": 0.8226925786236466}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8226927518844604, "teacher_quality_score": 0.3114162473019679, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.3114162473019679, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21349645011965188, "loser_reward": -0.2589836633987725, "reward_margin": 0.045487213279120614, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21349645011965188, "loser_reward": -0.26668755113519726, "reward_margin": 0.05319110101554539, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21349645011965188, "loser_reward": -0.29560589046124375, "reward_margin": 0.08210944034159187, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21349645011965188, "loser_reward": -0.3978210079334676, "reward_margin": 0.1843245578138157, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2589836633987725, "loser_reward": -0.29560589046124375, "reward_margin": 0.03662222706247126, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2589836633987725, "loser_reward": -0.3978210079334676, "reward_margin": 0.1388373445346951, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.26668755113519726, "loser_reward": -0.29560589046124375, "reward_margin": 0.028918339326046483, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26668755113519726, "loser_reward": -0.3978210079334676, "reward_margin": 0.13113345679827032, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.29560589046124375, "loser_reward": -0.3978210079334676, "reward_margin": 0.10221511747222384, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/106508_1/106508_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.19428402185440063, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.22674910724163055, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04861214756965637, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6010896563529968, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04723741486668587, "full_mse_to_target": 0.08130399137735367, "input_change_l1": 0.18793420493602753, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6559384614229202, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.20962056629359724, "edit_score": 0.4349495850503445, "background_score": 0.128394216299057, "combined_score": 0.5299420731514692, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/106508_1/106508_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11382497847080231, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.2986743152141571, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004663432016968727, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9513236880302429, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0054228650406003, "full_mse_to_target": 0.030536601319909096, "input_change_l1": 0.07624280452728271, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7061773985624313, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12362712845206261, "edit_score": 0.32754576578736305, "background_score": 0.014398694410920143, "combined_score": 0.36036439465358855, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/106508_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08017466962337494, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3062175214290619, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0019703004509210587, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.966759979724884, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00278974836692214, "full_mse_to_target": 0.020717667415738106, "input_change_l1": 0.04955781623721123, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7061774283647537, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08112862156704069, "edit_score": 0.29238680824637414, "background_score": 0.008618304505944252, "combined_score": 0.31370070587843657, "confidence": 0.7642561795023756}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/106508_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1387486457824707, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.25677403807640076, "background_mse_to_source": 0.006891400087624788, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.941645622253418, "background_mse_to_target": 0.007600491866469383, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03798385336995125, "input_change_l1": 0.09278049319982529, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7141992449760437, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14806214664131404, "edit_score": 0.3588440269231796, "background_score": 0.018562275636941197, "combined_score": 0.398751638061367, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/106508_1/106508_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09440091997385025, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.2710663378238678, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0318836010992527, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5940604209899902, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03084992989897728, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0455729216337204, "input_change_l1": 0.13043592870235443, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6203674077987671, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09969991017132997, "edit_score": 0.3350958004593849, "background_score": 0.11307151690125467, "combined_score": 0.3991681055724621, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/106508_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/106508_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/106508_1.json"}

106508_2

add a pedestrian

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.013251304626464844, "dataset_mask_area": 0.013251304626464844, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2679815888404846, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00013927946565672755, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2678423093748279, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8963752366262357, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.972021592032236, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.34791284799575806, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4142882014512656, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.012255551767750604, "best_expert": "pix2pix", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.39623888852074735, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.058463312685489655, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2679815888404846, "edit_change_ratio": 0.21816167647356474, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.2536104917526245, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9463728193043349}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.020320892333984375, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/106508_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.5979323387145996, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4020676612854004}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2540024157883599, "reward": -0.2540024157883599}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.27384527268027886, "reward": -0.27384527268027886}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.28281892241816975, "reward": -0.28281892241816975}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2887374237077311, "reward": -0.2887374237077311}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2923086366566131, "reward": -0.2923086366566131}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "106508_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.2540024157883599, "loser_reward": -0.27384527268027886, "reward_margin": 0.019842856891918947, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2540024157883599, "loser_reward": -0.28281892241816975, "reward_margin": 0.028816506629809835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2540024157883599, "loser_reward": -0.2887374237077311, "reward_margin": 0.034735007919371175, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2540024157883599, "loser_reward": -0.2923086366566131, "reward_margin": 0.038306220868253194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.27384527268027886, "loser_reward": -0.2887374237077311, "reward_margin": 0.014892151027452227, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.27384527268027886, "loser_reward": -0.2923086366566131, "reward_margin": 0.018463363976334246, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 13895, "bbox_xyxy": [256, 704, 354, 932], "component_score": 0.2540024157883599, "component_reward": -0.2540024157883599, "second_component_score": 0.27384527268027886, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.019842856891918947, "confidence": 0.676894548411264}], "teacher_confidence": 0.67689448595047, "teacher_quality_score": 0.012255551767750604, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.012255551767750604, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "106508_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.2540024157883599, "loser_reward": -0.27384527268027886, "reward_margin": 0.019842856891918947, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2540024157883599, "loser_reward": -0.28281892241816975, "reward_margin": 0.028816506629809835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2540024157883599, "loser_reward": -0.2887374237077311, "reward_margin": 0.034735007919371175, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2540024157883599, "loser_reward": -0.2923086366566131, "reward_margin": 0.038306220868253194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.27384527268027886, "loser_reward": -0.2887374237077311, "reward_margin": 0.014892151027452227, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106508_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.27384527268027886, "loser_reward": -0.2923086366566131, "reward_margin": 0.018463363976334246, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/106508_2/106508_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11378558725118637, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5025456547737122, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05076976865530014, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.42894279956817627, "background_mse_to_target": 0.050767216831445694, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05160227790474892, "input_change_l1": 0.18264760076999664, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6000096872448921, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10030601592734456, "edit_score": 0.3132740344852209, "background_score": 0.1649812087416649, "combined_score": 0.39623888852074735, "confidence": 0.6417851920834013}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/106508_2/106508_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13130995631217957, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4763396680355072, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005854593589901924, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8974647521972656, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005862663500010967, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0075250049121677876, "input_change_l1": 0.05686022341251373, "directional_pixel_score": 0.2678871303796768, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03344494430348277, "edit_score": 0.4190702401101589, "background_score": 0.0263616431504488, "combined_score": 0.43573830456472934, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/106508_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12354481965303421, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4877765476703644, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0024735652841627598, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9541142582893372, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002481267089024186, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004085516557097435, "input_change_l1": 0.03695915266871452, "directional_pixel_score": 0.2678869664669037, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02172374096699059, "edit_score": 0.4090177685022354, "background_score": 0.011650713626295328, "combined_score": 0.4178488181205467, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/106508_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13712508976459503, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4677295982837677, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008539834059774876, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8504509329795837, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008548133075237274, "full_mse_to_target": 0.010251949541270733, "input_change_l1": 0.07010186463594437, "directional_pixel_score": 0.2677571773529053, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.041607586201280355, "edit_score": 0.42663987576961515, "background_score": 0.03844964746385813, "combined_score": 0.44944396457634866, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/106508_2/106508_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14157569408416748, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4587973356246948, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03600744530558586, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6180694103240967, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03601217269897461, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03741102293133736, "input_change_l1": 0.11442140489816666, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5016123742097989, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08050198042765261, "edit_score": 0.3744131334067788, "background_score": 0.11239356324076653, "combined_score": 0.43359237891971136, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/106508_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/106508_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/106508_2.json"}

106772_1

What if the child was holding a bottle of peper?

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.043480001389980316, "dataset_mask_area": 0.04348, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.16431769728660583, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.007374592125415802, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.15694310516119003, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7085667884693463, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8579294071379412, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4145944118499756, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.27628829606302924, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.1677562457181921, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.17189758911801617, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.05174919217824936, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.16431771218776703, "edit_change_ratio": 0.3149337432297937, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.07957199960947037, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/106772_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5513151288032532, "qwen_image_edit": 0.44868484139442444}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.09705365249633906, "reward": -0.09705365249633906}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1073529446150642, "reward": -0.1073529446150642}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1184580712651368, "reward": -0.1184580712651368}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.147425803094171, "reward": -0.147425803094171}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.19460819378867744, "reward": -0.19460819378867744}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09705365249633906, "loser_reward": -0.1073529446150642, "reward_margin": 0.010299292118725142, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09705365249633906, "loser_reward": -0.1184580712651368, "reward_margin": 0.021404418768797742, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09705365249633906, "loser_reward": -0.147425803094171, "reward_margin": 0.05037215059783194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09705365249633906, "loser_reward": -0.19460819378867744, "reward_margin": 0.09755454129233838, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1073529446150642, "loser_reward": -0.1184580712651368, "reward_margin": 0.0111051266500726, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1073529446150642, "loser_reward": -0.147425803094171, "reward_margin": 0.0400728584791068, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1073529446150642, "loser_reward": -0.19460819378867744, "reward_margin": 0.08725524917361324, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1184580712651368, "loser_reward": -0.147425803094171, "reward_margin": 0.0289677318290342, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1184580712651368, "loser_reward": -0.19460819378867744, "reward_margin": 0.07615012252354064, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.147425803094171, "loser_reward": -0.19460819378867744, "reward_margin": 0.04718239069450644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 10870, "bbox_xyxy": [101, 282, 242, 454], "component_score": 0.09705365249633906, "component_reward": -0.09705365249633906, "second_component_score": 0.1073529446150642, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.010299292118725142, "confidence": 0.7146835332813735}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7146835327148438, "teacher_quality_score": 0.1677562457181921, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.1677562457181921, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09705365249633906, "loser_reward": -0.1073529446150642, "reward_margin": 0.010299292118725142, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09705365249633906, "loser_reward": -0.1184580712651368, "reward_margin": 0.021404418768797742, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09705365249633906, "loser_reward": -0.147425803094171, "reward_margin": 0.05037215059783194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09705365249633906, "loser_reward": -0.19460819378867744, "reward_margin": 0.09755454129233838, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1073529446150642, "loser_reward": -0.1184580712651368, "reward_margin": 0.0111051266500726, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1073529446150642, "loser_reward": -0.147425803094171, "reward_margin": 0.0400728584791068, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1073529446150642, "loser_reward": -0.19460819378867744, "reward_margin": 0.08725524917361324, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1184580712651368, "loser_reward": -0.147425803094171, "reward_margin": 0.0289677318290342, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1184580712651368, "loser_reward": -0.19460819378867744, "reward_margin": 0.07615012252354064, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.147425803094171, "loser_reward": -0.19460819378867744, "reward_margin": 0.04718239069450644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/106772_1/106772_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07174193114042282, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6626066565513611, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04069763049483299, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4690694510936737, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04029982537031174, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04166692867875099, "input_change_l1": 0.14631019532680511, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6632300317287445, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15217274092137814, "edit_score": 0.2234130918979645, "background_score": 0.14688374027609824, "combined_score": 0.30942364204674955, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/106772_1/106772_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04418203979730606, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6995773911476135, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00057652045506984, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9899387359619141, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0010822187177836895, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0029561989940702915, "input_change_l1": 0.013335922732949257, "directional_pixel_score": 0.729080855846405, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.045411596726626154, "edit_score": 0.1719963476061821, "background_score": 0.0025887732626870275, "combined_score": 0.1822803574928548, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/106772_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03898260369896889, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7074196338653564, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00024357983784284443, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9944649338722229, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0007884313235990703, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0024491138756275177, "input_change_l1": 0.008668345399200916, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7290807813405991, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.029757442837581038, "edit_score": 0.16522848159074782, "background_score": 0.0013505930633982645, "combined_score": 0.17189758911801617, "confidence": 0.6507906893634396}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/106772_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05059978738427162, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6874442100524902, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0008930485928431153, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9864850640296936, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0013708802871406078, "full_mse_to_target": 0.003511352464556694, "input_change_l1": 0.016508478671312332, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7243291288614273, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05503756469115615, "edit_score": 0.18202866315841676, "background_score": 0.003596035786904395, "combined_score": 0.1946459238685202, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/106772_1/106772_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04975443705916405, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6930200457572937, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0063109733164310455, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8080331683158875, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006335122510790825, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008222992531955242, "input_change_l1": 0.05356979742646217, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6091339066624641, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.053211059328168636, "edit_score": 0.20886695124208926, "background_score": 0.04470433965325356, "combined_score": 0.23597798123955724, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/106772_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/106772_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/106772_1.json"}

106772_2

What if there was a drawing of a bird on his shirt?

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.029448509216308594, "dataset_mask_area": 0.029448509216308594, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.26473578810691833, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0005067240563221276, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2642290640505962, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9668859297288626, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9905979815247049, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.41964733600616455, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4198792948790479, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.23305482066731203, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2827265638962853, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.14815005660057068, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.26473578810691833, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5596147678406729, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.039806365966796875, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/106772_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6253993511199951, "editar": 0.3746006488800049}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2092886278943624, "reward": -0.2092886278943624}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.23491511591151354, "reward": -0.23491511591151354}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.23773408568487497, "reward": -0.23773408568487497}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.311942741422914, "reward": -0.311942741422914}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.4161807877421379, "reward": -0.4161807877421379}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "106772_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2092886278943624, "loser_reward": -0.23491511591151354, "reward_margin": 0.025626488017151144, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2092886278943624, "loser_reward": -0.23773408568487497, "reward_margin": 0.02844545779051258, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2092886278943624, "loser_reward": -0.311942741422914, "reward_margin": 0.10265411352855161, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2092886278943624, "loser_reward": -0.4161807877421379, "reward_margin": 0.2068921598477755, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23491511591151354, "loser_reward": -0.311942741422914, "reward_margin": 0.07702762551140047, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23491511591151354, "loser_reward": -0.4161807877421379, "reward_margin": 0.18126567183062436, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23773408568487497, "loser_reward": -0.311942741422914, "reward_margin": 0.07420865573803903, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23773408568487497, "loser_reward": -0.4161807877421379, "reward_margin": 0.17844670205726293, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.311942741422914, "loser_reward": -0.4161807877421379, "reward_margin": 0.1042380463192239, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 30879, "bbox_xyxy": [643, 528, 829, 811], "component_score": 0.2092886278943624, "component_reward": -0.2092886278943624, "second_component_score": 0.23491511591151354, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.025626488017151144, "confidence": 0.7347776336874389}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7347775101661682, "teacher_quality_score": 0.23305482066731203, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.23305482066731203, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "106772_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2092886278943624, "loser_reward": -0.23491511591151354, "reward_margin": 0.025626488017151144, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2092886278943624, "loser_reward": -0.23773408568487497, "reward_margin": 0.02844545779051258, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2092886278943624, "loser_reward": -0.311942741422914, "reward_margin": 0.10265411352855161, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2092886278943624, "loser_reward": -0.4161807877421379, "reward_margin": 0.2068921598477755, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23491511591151354, "loser_reward": -0.311942741422914, "reward_margin": 0.07702762551140047, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23491511591151354, "loser_reward": -0.4161807877421379, "reward_margin": 0.18126567183062436, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23773408568487497, "loser_reward": -0.311942741422914, "reward_margin": 0.07420865573803903, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23773408568487497, "loser_reward": -0.4161807877421379, "reward_margin": 0.17844670205726293, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "106772_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.311942741422914, "loser_reward": -0.4161807877421379, "reward_margin": 0.1042380463192239, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/106772_2/106772_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11539290100336075, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6067485213279724, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002771922852844, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9574008584022522, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0027852130588144064, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006101339589804411, "input_change_l1": 0.03682020679116249, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5952974110841751, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.022606662870384753, "edit_score": 0.2952188439667225, "background_score": 0.01129175117239356, "combined_score": 0.30430242341011765, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/106772_2/106772_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.18326354026794434, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5047991871833801, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0028680539689958096, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9717049598693848, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0028322760481387377, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008145703934133053, "input_change_l1": 0.02650109864771366, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7686510682106018, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2053395563736558, "edit_score": 0.34014093577861787, "background_score": 0.008527061995118858, "combined_score": 0.38500788914505396, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/106772_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10379757732152939, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5395730137825012, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0012117525329813361, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9795640110969543, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0011959666153416038, "full_mse_to_target": 0.00421743281185627, "input_change_l1": 0.017225705087184906, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7686511874198914, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13365005147643388, "edit_score": 0.2537201777100563, "background_score": 0.005298950313590467, "combined_score": 0.2827265638962853, "confidence": 0.6743096073690702}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/106772_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2720293402671814, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.48136481642723083, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004297902341932058, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9659708142280579, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004249589517712593, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012135297991335392, "input_change_l1": 0.03291783854365349, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7699247300624847, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2534803288988769, "edit_score": 0.43327519446611407, "background_score": 0.011103739496320486, "combined_score": 0.4890710988687351, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/106772_2/106772_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11701764166355133, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5962646007537842, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007818475365638733, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.782238781452179, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00784186739474535, "full_mse_to_target": 0.011056933552026749, "input_change_l1": 0.06128016486763954, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5751226544380188, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04352311678230762, "edit_score": 0.3039840579032898, "background_score": 0.05137071907520294, "combined_score": 0.33177412629127506, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/106772_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/106772_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/106772_2.json"}

108871_1

put a lion in the place of the donkey

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.08655200153589249, "dataset_mask_area": 0.086552, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2584530711174011, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.010094482451677322, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2483585886657238, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7493249324932493, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.867228561958426, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4368855953216553, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.37296672304325074, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.226192506991938, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.24076991188805552, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.13577766716480255, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2584531009197235, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5253474099619164, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.11293599754571915, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/108871_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5327068567276001, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4672931432723999}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.16196402233466506, "reward": -0.16196402233466506}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16851475194469095, "reward": -0.16851475194469095}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.17833498149551452, "reward": -0.17833498149551452}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2034117447156459, "reward": -0.2034117447156459}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2561671116705984, "reward": -0.2561671116705984}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16196402233466506, "loser_reward": -0.17833498149551452, "reward_margin": 0.016370959160849463, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16196402233466506, "loser_reward": -0.2034117447156459, "reward_margin": 0.04144772238098085, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16196402233466506, "loser_reward": -0.2561671116705984, "reward_margin": 0.09420308933593335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16851475194469095, "loser_reward": -0.2034117447156459, "reward_margin": 0.034896992770954954, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16851475194469095, "loser_reward": -0.2561671116705984, "reward_margin": 0.08765235972590746, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17833498149551452, "loser_reward": -0.2034117447156459, "reward_margin": 0.025076763220131387, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17833498149551452, "loser_reward": -0.2561671116705984, "reward_margin": 0.07783213017508389, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2034117447156459, "loser_reward": -0.2561671116705984, "reward_margin": 0.052755366954952504, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 21638, "bbox_xyxy": [367, 157, 500, 406], "component_score": 0.16196402233466506, "component_reward": -0.16196402233466506, "second_component_score": 0.16851475194469095, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.006550729610025896, "confidence": 0.6194134477142526}], "teacher_confidence": 0.619413435459137, "teacher_quality_score": 0.226192506991938, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.226192506991938, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16196402233466506, "loser_reward": -0.17833498149551452, "reward_margin": 0.016370959160849463, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16196402233466506, "loser_reward": -0.2034117447156459, "reward_margin": 0.04144772238098085, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16196402233466506, "loser_reward": -0.2561671116705984, "reward_margin": 0.09420308933593335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16851475194469095, "loser_reward": -0.2034117447156459, "reward_margin": 0.034896992770954954, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16851475194469095, "loser_reward": -0.2561671116705984, "reward_margin": 0.08765235972590746, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17833498149551452, "loser_reward": -0.2034117447156459, "reward_margin": 0.025076763220131387, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17833498149551452, "loser_reward": -0.2561671116705984, "reward_margin": 0.07783213017508389, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2034117447156459, "loser_reward": -0.2561671116705984, "reward_margin": 0.052755366954952504, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/108871_1/108871_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11804085969924927, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4389779567718506, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03692806139588356, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5585677027702332, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03591310232877731, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04302142560482025, "input_change_l1": 0.12931838631629944, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6598525792360306, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07820439469069243, "edit_score": 0.3152821235358715, "background_score": 0.12521452084183693, "combined_score": 0.3790502273291349, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/108871_1/108871_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06501079350709915, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4527324140071869, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008111049421131611, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8899979591369629, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008273462764918804, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013184191659092903, "input_change_l1": 0.04613141715526581, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8143805265426636, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09014655631035567, "edit_score": 0.22086917906999587, "background_score": 0.030111457593739035, "combined_score": 0.250755919655785, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/108871_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06756120920181274, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.46168282628059387, "background_mse_to_source": 0.003426917362958193, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9274230003356934, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0037325993180274963, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009257093071937561, "input_change_l1": 0.029985418543219566, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8143804371356964, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.059674284327775245, "edit_score": 0.22162953466176988, "background_score": 0.01794231729581952, "combined_score": 0.24076991188805552, "confidence": 0.6210822832306381}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/108871_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06844057142734528, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.43944454193115234, "background_mse_to_source": 0.011983842588961124, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8731754422187805, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01205370295792818, "full_mse_to_target": 0.016934100538492203, "input_change_l1": 0.0566285066306591, "directional_pixel_score": 0.818115621805191, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10869024060666561, "edit_score": 0.22602275758981705, "background_score": 0.037348754145205026, "combined_score": 0.26252627971582115, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/108871_1/108871_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07703646272420883, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.45663103461265564, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02164999209344387, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4929794371128082, "background_mse_to_target": 0.020571347326040268, "full_mse_to_target": 0.025458525866270065, "input_change_l1": 0.10017979145050049, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7642569541931152, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08329939227551222, "edit_score": 0.2446460172533989, "background_score": 0.12305410467088224, "combined_score": 0.30692068492993707, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/108871_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/108871_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/108871_1.json"}

108871_2

turn the basin into a plastic pool

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.056243896484375, "dataset_mask_area": 0.056243896484375, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.3128761053085327, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0023095342330634594, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.31056657107546926, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7558835758835759, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8054378166029154, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4720715880393982, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.43349011284561495, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.1949896550163976, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.24239263650961224, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.24637003242969513, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.3128761351108551, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7874363199430464, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.0738058090209961, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/108871_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.17508297561109062, "reward": -0.17508297561109062}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2722927182763815, "reward": -0.2722927182763815}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2729217564351856, "reward": -0.2729217564351856}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.35530125087499626, "reward": -0.35530125087499626}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.430264759249054, "reward": -0.430264759249054}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17508297561109062, "loser_reward": -0.2722927182763815, "reward_margin": 0.0972097426652909, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.17508297561109062, "loser_reward": -0.2729217564351856, "reward_margin": 0.097838780824095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17508297561109062, "loser_reward": -0.35530125087499626, "reward_margin": 0.18021827526390563, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17508297561109062, "loser_reward": -0.430264759249054, "reward_margin": 0.2551817836379634, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2722927182763815, "loser_reward": -0.35530125087499626, "reward_margin": 0.08300853259861474, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2722927182763815, "loser_reward": -0.430264759249054, "reward_margin": 0.15797204097267248, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2729217564351856, "loser_reward": -0.35530125087499626, "reward_margin": 0.08237949443981063, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2729217564351856, "loser_reward": -0.430264759249054, "reward_margin": 0.15734300281386837, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.35530125087499626, "loser_reward": -0.430264759249054, "reward_margin": 0.07496350837405774, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 58976, "bbox_xyxy": [336, 756, 783, 992], "component_score": 0.17508297561109062, "component_reward": -0.17508297561109062, "second_component_score": 0.2722927182763815, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0972097426652909, "confidence": 0.9510668721386555}], "teacher_confidence": 0.9510669112205505, "teacher_quality_score": 0.1949896550163976, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.1949896550163976, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17508297561109062, "loser_reward": -0.2722927182763815, "reward_margin": 0.0972097426652909, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.17508297561109062, "loser_reward": -0.2729217564351856, "reward_margin": 0.097838780824095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17508297561109062, "loser_reward": -0.35530125087499626, "reward_margin": 0.18021827526390563, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17508297561109062, "loser_reward": -0.430264759249054, "reward_margin": 0.2551817836379634, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2722927182763815, "loser_reward": -0.35530125087499626, "reward_margin": 0.08300853259861474, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2722927182763815, "loser_reward": -0.430264759249054, "reward_margin": 0.15797204097267248, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2729217564351856, "loser_reward": -0.35530125087499626, "reward_margin": 0.08237949443981063, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2729217564351856, "loser_reward": -0.430264759249054, "reward_margin": 0.15734300281386837, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "108871_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.35530125087499626, "loser_reward": -0.430264759249054, "reward_margin": 0.07496350837405774, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/108871_2/108871_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2446359097957611, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5004802346229553, "background_mse_to_source": 0.2720341682434082, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3125072419643402, "background_mse_to_target": 0.27213045954704285, "full_mse_to_target": 0.2705839276313782, "input_change_l1": 0.4352107048034668, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8297707140445709, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.34147230973467235, "edit_score": 0.3870971843600273, "background_score": 0.4095327198505402, "combined_score": 0.6257864910177886, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/108871_2/108871_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1392313838005066, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5134496092796326, "background_mse_to_source": 0.028899826109409332, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8135994076728821, "background_mse_to_target": 0.028893878683447838, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03509968891739845, "input_change_l1": 0.09639009833335876, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8709802627563477, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.26633577682077886, "edit_score": 0.2687963962554932, "background_score": 0.06617994457483292, "combined_score": 0.3487365011125803, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/108871_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07108751684427261, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5535075068473816, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012210178188979626, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8685694336891174, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012284581549465656, "full_mse_to_target": 0.015591885894536972, "input_change_l1": 0.0626535415649414, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8709798455238342, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1735934590920806, "edit_score": 0.19264105409383775, "background_score": 0.03849629145115614, "combined_score": 0.24239263650961224, "confidence": 0.927812733652845}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/108871_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.20449472963809967, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.48869267106056213, "background_mse_to_source": 0.041440848261117935, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7891361713409424, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04137815162539482, "full_mse_to_target": 0.050552453845739365, "input_change_l1": 0.11702265590429306, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8750364184379578, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.3199826247990131, "edit_score": 0.3379970908164978, "background_score": 0.08361361399292946, "combined_score": 0.4363136260583997, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/108871_2/108871_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1375429779291153, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.514707088470459, "background_mse_to_source": 0.015002511441707611, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6711509823799133, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014988677576184273, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02188161574304104, "input_change_l1": 0.0783892348408699, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6130602359771729, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04769358709454537, "edit_score": 0.3313365012407303, "background_score": 0.08077231496572494, "combined_score": 0.3713336904719472, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/108871_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/108871_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/108871_2.json"}

109776_1

change the bag of chips into a backpack

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.10116799920797348, "dataset_mask_area": 0.101168, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.34940141439437866, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.006834815721958876, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3425665986724198, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9596365745215543, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9774356147121367, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.24885748326778412, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.49682041220349177, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.40148438307100154, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.4399192718596896, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.18712352216243744, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.3494013845920563, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5355546097246111, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.12179200351238251, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/109776_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6622563600540161, "editar": 0.3377436399459839}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.33598830129334234, "reward": -0.33598830129334234}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.36965658040158456, "reward": -0.36965658040158456}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.43644127763831053, "reward": -0.43644127763831053}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.48256977853737776, "reward": -0.48256977853737776}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.5019936587139965, "reward": -0.5019936587139965}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.33598830129334234, "loser_reward": -0.36965658040158456, "reward_margin": 0.033668279108242216, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.33598830129334234, "loser_reward": -0.43644127763831053, "reward_margin": 0.10045297634496819, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.33598830129334234, "loser_reward": -0.48256977853737776, "reward_margin": 0.14658147724403542, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.33598830129334234, "loser_reward": -0.5019936587139965, "reward_margin": 0.16600535742065414, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.36965658040158456, "loser_reward": -0.43644127763831053, "reward_margin": 0.06678469723672598, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.36965658040158456, "loser_reward": -0.48256977853737776, "reward_margin": 0.1129131981357932, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.36965658040158456, "loser_reward": -0.5019936587139965, "reward_margin": 0.13233707831241193, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.43644127763831053, "loser_reward": -0.48256977853737776, "reward_margin": 0.046128500899067226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.43644127763831053, "loser_reward": -0.5019936587139965, "reward_margin": 0.06555238107568595, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.48256977853737776, "loser_reward": -0.5019936587139965, "reward_margin": 0.019423880176618724, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 25292, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 33, 175, 218], "component_score": 0.33598830129334234, "component_reward": -0.33598830129334234, "second_component_score": 0.36965658040158456, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.033668279108242216, "confidence": 0.7070558869350351}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7070559859275818, "teacher_quality_score": 0.40148438307100154, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.40148438307100154, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.33598830129334234, "loser_reward": -0.36965658040158456, "reward_margin": 0.033668279108242216, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.33598830129334234, "loser_reward": -0.43644127763831053, "reward_margin": 0.10045297634496819, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.33598830129334234, "loser_reward": -0.48256977853737776, "reward_margin": 0.14658147724403542, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.33598830129334234, "loser_reward": -0.5019936587139965, "reward_margin": 0.16600535742065414, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.36965658040158456, "loser_reward": -0.43644127763831053, "reward_margin": 0.06678469723672598, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.36965658040158456, "loser_reward": -0.48256977853737776, "reward_margin": 0.1129131981357932, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.36965658040158456, "loser_reward": -0.5019936587139965, "reward_margin": 0.13233707831241193, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.43644127763831053, "loser_reward": -0.48256977853737776, "reward_margin": 0.046128500899067226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.43644127763831053, "loser_reward": -0.5019936587139965, "reward_margin": 0.06555238107568595, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.48256977853737776, "loser_reward": -0.5019936587139965, "reward_margin": 0.019423880176618724, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/109776_1/109776_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.3016434907913208, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.27276694774627686, "background_mse_to_source": 0.1273861974477768, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.25966012477874756, "background_mse_to_target": 0.12718914449214935, "full_mse_to_target": 0.1448383629322052, "input_change_l1": 0.2821142375469208, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5914908647537231, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.19054102525115013, "edit_score": 0.5492173850536346, "background_score": 0.2754541724920273, "combined_score": 0.6982183867692947, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/109776_1/109776_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.28503647446632385, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.34432539343833923, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0013173891929909587, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9660802483558655, "background_mse_to_target": 0.001623700954951346, "full_mse_to_target": 0.030296003445982933, "input_change_l1": 0.04951697960495949, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6515539288520813, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15564685501158237, "edit_score": 0.5032829135656357, "background_score": 0.008101339521817862, "combined_score": 0.5402773537451868, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/109776_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1992151141166687, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.35233816504478455, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005565968458540738, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9804794192314148, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0008871769532561302, "full_mse_to_target": 0.020951613783836365, "input_change_l1": 0.03218604251742363, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6515539735555649, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10201936606317759, "edit_score": 0.41585898771882057, "background_score": 0.0044607129995711155, "combined_score": 0.4399192718596896, "confidence": 0.7249615188900587}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/109776_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.31749090552330017, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.28099867701530457, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0017882362008094788, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.958333432674408, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0020778581965714693, "full_mse_to_target": 0.033987581729888916, "input_change_l1": 0.0571223646402359, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6609467267990112, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.17585986610502005, "edit_score": 0.5460544884204864, "background_score": 0.010121549665927888, "combined_score": 0.588167762197554, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/109776_1/109776_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.19478461146354675, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.2799130976200104, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017379123717546463, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6558595299720764, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01722446084022522, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03518787771463394, "input_change_l1": 0.10586035251617432, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6238471865653992, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11841217037290336, "edit_score": 0.4328401952981949, "background_score": 0.08620721772313118, "combined_score": 0.49021394334733487, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/109776_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/109776_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/109776_1.json"}

109776_2

remove the playstation controller

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.1109466552734375, "dataset_mask_area": 0.1109466552734375, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2928367555141449, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0010933915618807077, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2917433639522642, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9707990554859961, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9774355937222386, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.2817081809043884, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4473366743594733, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.11303707964951173, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.12887641111155973, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.22705470025539398, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2928368151187897, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7753625518816305, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.12123584747314453, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/109776_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5063484907150269, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49365150928497314}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.08950156827946193, "reward": -0.08950156827946193}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.09077134174434467, "reward": -0.09077134174434467}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.12112924175709486, "reward": -0.12112924175709486}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.19806013664836064, "reward": -0.19806013664836064}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2799316077483818, "reward": -0.2799316077483818}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08950156827946193, "loser_reward": -0.12112924175709486, "reward_margin": 0.03162767347763293, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08950156827946193, "loser_reward": -0.19806013664836064, "reward_margin": 0.10855856836889871, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08950156827946193, "loser_reward": -0.2799316077483818, "reward_margin": 0.1904300394689199, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09077134174434467, "loser_reward": -0.12112924175709486, "reward_margin": 0.030357900012750183, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09077134174434467, "loser_reward": -0.19806013664836064, "reward_margin": 0.10728879490401597, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09077134174434467, "loser_reward": -0.2799316077483818, "reward_margin": 0.18916026600403715, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12112924175709486, "loser_reward": -0.19806013664836064, "reward_margin": 0.07693089489126578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12112924175709486, "loser_reward": -0.2799316077483818, "reward_margin": 0.15880236599128697, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19806013664836064, "loser_reward": -0.2799316077483818, "reward_margin": 0.08187147110002119, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 116336, "bbox_xyxy": [518, 683, 1024, 1024], "component_score": 0.08950156827946193, "component_reward": -0.08950156827946193, "second_component_score": 0.09077134174434467, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0012697734648827452, "confidence": 0.5751534109831785}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5751534104347229, "teacher_quality_score": 0.11303707964951173, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.11303707964951173, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08950156827946193, "loser_reward": -0.12112924175709486, "reward_margin": 0.03162767347763293, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08950156827946193, "loser_reward": -0.19806013664836064, "reward_margin": 0.10855856836889871, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08950156827946193, "loser_reward": -0.2799316077483818, "reward_margin": 0.1904300394689199, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09077134174434467, "loser_reward": -0.12112924175709486, "reward_margin": 0.030357900012750183, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09077134174434467, "loser_reward": -0.19806013664836064, "reward_margin": 0.10728879490401597, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09077134174434467, "loser_reward": -0.2799316077483818, "reward_margin": 0.18916026600403715, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12112924175709486, "loser_reward": -0.19806013664836064, "reward_margin": 0.07693089489126578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12112924175709486, "loser_reward": -0.2799316077483818, "reward_margin": 0.15880236599128697, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "109776_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19806013664836064, "loser_reward": -0.2799316077483818, "reward_margin": 0.08187147110002119, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/109776_2/109776_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0917363166809082, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5638293027877808, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02586597017943859, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6529562473297119, "background_mse_to_target": 0.025901097804307938, "full_mse_to_target": 0.033205296844244, "input_change_l1": 0.12676453590393066, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8207759261131287, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08838379704393447, "edit_score": 0.22377647459506989, "background_score": 0.09527472071349621, "combined_score": 0.27811991593800484, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/109776_2/109776_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.019774550572037697, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6476040482521057, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0025374426040798426, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.972482442855835, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0023208558559417725, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004257285501807928, "input_change_l1": 0.049513574689626694, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9670483469963074, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1357234723865986, "edit_score": 0.09849165417253972, "background_score": 0.00804095403291285, "combined_score": 0.12887641111155973, "confidence": 0.5697592562262567}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/109776_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.025222867727279663, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6133805513381958, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0010720695136114955, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9845132231712341, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0009576340089552104, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0036497816909104586, "input_change_l1": 0.03218381851911545, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9670469164848328, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08849231293424964, "edit_score": 0.11078502833843232, "background_score": 0.004169424879364669, "combined_score": 0.13030776780215092, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/109776_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.038660790771245956, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6253822445869446, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0039408886805176735, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9631221890449524, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0036514599341899157, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007535628974437714, "input_change_l1": 0.061819810420274734, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9672755002975464, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16819493416696787, "edit_score": 0.12176546677947045, "background_score": 0.011316450871527196, "combined_score": 0.16011877431534233, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/109776_2/109776_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.133082777261734, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4251443147659302, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014835305511951447, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7640694975852966, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014917992986738682, "full_mse_to_target": 0.028027968481183052, "input_change_l1": 0.07483058422803879, "directional_pixel_score": 0.578768253326416, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04176413891837001, "edit_score": 0.35336185097694395, "background_score": 0.06202140599489212, "combined_score": 0.38622496770694853, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/109776_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/109776_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/109776_2.json"}

11091_1

Let the man press the keyboard.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.047467999160289764, "dataset_mask_area": 0.047468, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.1835525631904602, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00524804275482893, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.17830452043563128, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7708938120702826, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8919038359554534, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3239518702030182, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3064879313222833, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.16623464500942647, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.17459392721182668, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.10108683258295059, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.1835525631904602, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5507241676492393, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.0690160021185875, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/11091_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.10305153045360929, "reward": -0.10305153045360929}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.12494812155514955, "reward": -0.12494812155514955}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.15184980703890322, "reward": -0.15184980703890322}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.18743299834802749, "reward": -0.18743299834802749}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.27203629348799585, "reward": -0.27203629348799585}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10305153045360929, "loser_reward": -0.12494812155514955, "reward_margin": 0.021896591101540255, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10305153045360929, "loser_reward": -0.15184980703890322, "reward_margin": 0.048798276585293926, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10305153045360929, "loser_reward": -0.18743299834802749, "reward_margin": 0.0843814678944182, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10305153045360929, "loser_reward": -0.27203629348799585, "reward_margin": 0.16898476303438656, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12494812155514955, "loser_reward": -0.15184980703890322, "reward_margin": 0.02690168548375367, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12494812155514955, "loser_reward": -0.18743299834802749, "reward_margin": 0.06248487679287794, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12494812155514955, "loser_reward": -0.27203629348799585, "reward_margin": 0.1470881719328463, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15184980703890322, "loser_reward": -0.18743299834802749, "reward_margin": 0.03558319130912427, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15184980703890322, "loser_reward": -0.27203629348799585, "reward_margin": 0.12018648644909263, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18743299834802749, "loser_reward": -0.27203629348799585, "reward_margin": 0.08460329513996837, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 11867, "bbox_xyxy": [313, 293, 500, 421], "component_score": 0.10305153045360929, "component_reward": -0.10305153045360929, "second_component_score": 0.12494812155514955, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.021896591101540255, "confidence": 0.8222457155782732}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8222456574440002, "teacher_quality_score": 0.16623464500942647, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.16623464500942647, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10305153045360929, "loser_reward": -0.12494812155514955, "reward_margin": 0.021896591101540255, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10305153045360929, "loser_reward": -0.15184980703890322, "reward_margin": 0.048798276585293926, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10305153045360929, "loser_reward": -0.18743299834802749, "reward_margin": 0.0843814678944182, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10305153045360929, "loser_reward": -0.27203629348799585, "reward_margin": 0.16898476303438656, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12494812155514955, "loser_reward": -0.15184980703890322, "reward_margin": 0.02690168548375367, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12494812155514955, "loser_reward": -0.18743299834802749, "reward_margin": 0.06248487679287794, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12494812155514955, "loser_reward": -0.27203629348799585, "reward_margin": 0.1470881719328463, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15184980703890322, "loser_reward": -0.18743299834802749, "reward_margin": 0.03558319130912427, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15184980703890322, "loser_reward": -0.27203629348799585, "reward_margin": 0.12018648644909263, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "11091_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18743299834802749, "loser_reward": -0.27203629348799585, "reward_margin": 0.08460329513996837, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/11091_1/11091_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11685165017843246, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.552079439163208, "background_mse_to_source": 0.052921656519174576, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3498748540878296, "background_mse_to_target": 0.052072133868932724, "full_mse_to_target": 0.055147092789411545, "input_change_l1": 0.16888652741909027, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6723623126745224, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.21713331677019596, "edit_score": 0.28834518417716026, "background_score": 0.18294668570160866, "combined_score": 0.4013178968057036, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/11091_1/11091_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05092539265751839, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6296775937080383, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0041595990769565105, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9438194632530212, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004655169323086739, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006851524114608765, "input_change_l1": 0.02673090435564518, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7888706922531128, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06916918298229575, "edit_score": 0.1777722008526325, "background_score": 0.015395706426352263, "combined_score": 0.19767968710977585, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/11091_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.035763345658779144, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6340713500976562, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0017574300291016698, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9596157073974609, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002306316513568163, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0038944543339312077, "input_change_l1": 0.017375091090798378, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7888708412647247, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.045155577315017584, "edit_score": 0.1617313653230667, "background_score": 0.009834288549609483, "combined_score": 0.17459392721182668, "confidence": 0.7461465481209775}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/11091_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07155298441648483, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6152877807617188, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005831959191709757, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9374112486839294, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006289789453148842, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009387703612446785, "input_change_l1": 0.03248179331421852, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7889919877052307, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08547707917168736, "edit_score": 0.2012474313378334, "background_score": 0.018349709454923868, "combined_score": 0.2257040158426389, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/11091_1/11091_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.061134371906518936, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5892727375030518, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008190755732357502, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.770766019821167, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008435898460447788, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01093739178031683, "input_change_l1": 0.06434375047683716, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5496267527341843, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0826334236189723, "edit_score": 0.2558731362223625, "background_score": 0.05403755176812411, "combined_score": 0.29240670324303214, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/11091_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/11091_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/11091_1.json"}

111376_1

Have the cow wear a hat.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.04289599880576134, "dataset_mask_area": 0.042896, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.33308273553848267, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.005395141895860434, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.32768759364262223, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8015013221871534, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9038961038961039, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5625375509262085, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.46002359646092483, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.32114872573161846, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3481629998609424, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1373043954372406, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.33308273553848267, "edit_change_ratio": 0.41222309290592807, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.06441999971866608, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/111376_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2654507464766502, "reward": -0.2654507464766502}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.3252021688621025, "reward": -0.3252021688621025}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.3749950692700222, "reward": -0.3749950692700222}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.390196591922082, "reward": -0.390196591922082}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.40401931830123067, "reward": -0.40401931830123067}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "111376_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.2654507464766502, "loser_reward": -0.3252021688621025, "reward_margin": 0.059751422385452335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2654507464766502, "loser_reward": -0.3749950692700222, "reward_margin": 0.109544322793372, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2654507464766502, "loser_reward": -0.390196591922082, "reward_margin": 0.12474584544543182, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2654507464766502, "loser_reward": -0.40401931830123067, "reward_margin": 0.1385685718245805, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.3252021688621025, "loser_reward": -0.3749950692700222, "reward_margin": 0.04979290040791967, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3252021688621025, "loser_reward": -0.390196591922082, "reward_margin": 0.06499442305997949, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3252021688621025, "loser_reward": -0.40401931830123067, "reward_margin": 0.07881714943912815, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3749950692700222, "loser_reward": -0.390196591922082, "reward_margin": 0.015201522652059818, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3749950692700222, "loser_reward": -0.40401931830123067, "reward_margin": 0.029024249031208482, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.390196591922082, "loser_reward": -0.40401931830123067, "reward_margin": 0.013822726379148664, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 10724, "bbox_xyxy": [25, 104, 201, 203], "component_score": 0.2654507464766502, "component_reward": -0.2654507464766502, "second_component_score": 0.3252021688621025, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.059751422385452335, "confidence": 0.831736559139287}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8317365646362305, "teacher_quality_score": 0.32114872573161846, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.32114872573161846, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "111376_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.2654507464766502, "loser_reward": -0.3252021688621025, "reward_margin": 0.059751422385452335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2654507464766502, "loser_reward": -0.3749950692700222, "reward_margin": 0.109544322793372, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2654507464766502, "loser_reward": -0.390196591922082, "reward_margin": 0.12474584544543182, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2654507464766502, "loser_reward": -0.40401931830123067, "reward_margin": 0.1385685718245805, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.3252021688621025, "loser_reward": -0.3749950692700222, "reward_margin": 0.04979290040791967, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3252021688621025, "loser_reward": -0.390196591922082, "reward_margin": 0.06499442305997949, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3252021688621025, "loser_reward": -0.40401931830123067, "reward_margin": 0.07881714943912815, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3749950692700222, "loser_reward": -0.390196591922082, "reward_margin": 0.015201522652059818, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3749950692700222, "loser_reward": -0.40401931830123067, "reward_margin": 0.029024249031208482, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "111376_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.390196591922082, "loser_reward": -0.40401931830123067, "reward_margin": 0.013822726379148664, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/111376_1/111376_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.246702179312706, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5466944575309753, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012408477254211903, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8198444247245789, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0123476916924119, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02240055799484253, "input_change_l1": 0.06650052219629288, "directional_pixel_score": 0.42705269902944565, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07878533331677318, "edit_score": 0.4806001130491495, "background_score": 0.048439592309296134, "combined_score": 0.5155510928202421, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/111376_1/111376_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.24439066648483276, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.47734859585762024, "background_mse_to_source": 0.003919750917702913, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.952943742275238, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004100678954273462, "full_mse_to_target": 0.014408155344426632, "input_change_l1": 0.025702929124236107, "directional_pixel_score": 0.46109050139784813, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07957078907638789, "edit_score": 0.48364832196384666, "background_score": 0.013331002462655306, "combined_score": 0.5056691461754962, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/111376_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2050899863243103, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.500612199306488, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0016560942167416215, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9718173146247864, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0018691287841647863, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01058648806065321, "input_change_l1": 0.01670689880847931, "directional_pixel_score": 0.46109049767255783, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05183170754462481, "edit_score": 0.43969492204487326, "background_score": 0.007292631291784347, "combined_score": 0.4536723333119881, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/111376_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.26850518584251404, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.46617189049720764, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005225915461778641, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9454430937767029, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005387141369283199, "full_mse_to_target": 0.016673855483531952, "input_change_l1": 0.030955135822296143, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4660911336541176, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09424718506634236, "edit_score": 0.5087480243295431, "background_score": 0.016137296706438063, "combined_score": 0.5349129007384181, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/111376_1/111376_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13666576147079468, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5059182047843933, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009255019947886467, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7448824048042297, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009061727672815323, "full_mse_to_target": 0.014535428024828434, "input_change_l1": 0.0714067816734314, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7275069206953049, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1100328903645277, "edit_score": 0.3036053903400898, "background_score": 0.060278538987040525, "combined_score": 0.3481629998609424, "confidence": 0.8788236744056013}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/111376_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/111376_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/111376_1.json"}

112286_1

let it be a single sink

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.27031999826431274, "dataset_mask_area": 0.27032, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2623896300792694, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.009678398258984089, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2527112318202853, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8618671474771759, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9631862596152309, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.07712418586015701, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.1825762391090393, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.39466273990215567, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.01771659820515197, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.32935561443387995, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.0361795537173748, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2623896598815918, "edit_change_ratio": 0.13788483026999424, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.2533605694770813, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9655890006923861}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.349124014377594, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/112286_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5108524560928345, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.48914751410484314}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.21840285981795746, "reward": -0.21840285981795746}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.22057369639058014, "reward": -0.22057369639058014}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22511147125356365, "reward": -0.22511147125356365}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.23796222600992772, "reward": -0.23796222600992772}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2698562618847936, "reward": -0.2698562618847936}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21840285981795746, "loser_reward": -0.23796222600992772, "reward_margin": 0.019559366191970268, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21840285981795746, "loser_reward": -0.2698562618847936, "reward_margin": 0.05145340206683616, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22057369639058014, "loser_reward": -0.23796222600992772, "reward_margin": 0.017388529619347587, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22057369639058014, "loser_reward": -0.2698562618847936, "reward_margin": 0.049282565494213476, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22511147125356365, "loser_reward": -0.23796222600992772, "reward_margin": 0.012850754756364074, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22511147125356365, "loser_reward": -0.2698562618847936, "reward_margin": 0.044744790631229964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23796222600992772, "loser_reward": -0.2698562618847936, "reward_margin": 0.03189403587486589, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 66819, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 195, 500, 422], "component_score": 0.21840285981795746, "component_reward": -0.21840285981795746, "second_component_score": 0.22057369639058014, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.002170836572622681, "confidence": 0.567706045014976}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5021955966949463, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4978044331073761}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.10214676333294484, "reward": -0.10214676333294484}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.10258588511694688, "reward": -0.10258588511694688}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.10287250259434222, "reward": -0.10287250259434222}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.10309338334854692, "reward": -0.10309338334854692}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.1196305700149387, "reward": -0.1196305700149387}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "112286_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10214676333294484, "loser_reward": -0.1196305700149387, "reward_margin": 0.017483806681993855, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10258588511694688, "loser_reward": -0.1196305700149387, "reward_margin": 0.01704468489799181, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10287250259434222, "loser_reward": -0.1196305700149387, "reward_margin": 0.016758067420596476, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10309338334854692, "loser_reward": -0.1196305700149387, "reward_margin": 0.01653718666639177, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 761, "bbox_xyxy": [443, 373, 500, 396], "component_score": 0.10214676333294484, "component_reward": -0.10214676333294484, "second_component_score": 0.10258588511694688, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0004391217840020445, "confidence": 0.5577041950723098}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5675934553146362, "teacher_quality_score": 0.01771659820515197, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.01771659820515197, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21840285981795746, "loser_reward": -0.23796222600992772, "reward_margin": 0.019559366191970268, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21840285981795746, "loser_reward": -0.2698562618847936, "reward_margin": 0.05145340206683616, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22057369639058014, "loser_reward": -0.23796222600992772, "reward_margin": 0.017388529619347587, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22057369639058014, "loser_reward": -0.2698562618847936, "reward_margin": 0.049282565494213476, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22511147125356365, "loser_reward": -0.23796222600992772, "reward_margin": 0.012850754756364074, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22511147125356365, "loser_reward": -0.2698562618847936, "reward_margin": 0.044744790631229964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23796222600992772, "loser_reward": -0.2698562618847936, "reward_margin": 0.03189403587486589, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10214676333294484, "loser_reward": -0.1196305700149387, "reward_margin": 0.017483806681993855, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10258588511694688, "loser_reward": -0.1196305700149387, "reward_margin": 0.01704468489799181, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10287250259434222, "loser_reward": -0.1196305700149387, "reward_margin": 0.016758067420596476, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10309338334854692, "loser_reward": -0.1196305700149387, "reward_margin": 0.01653718666639177, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/112286_1/112286_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1218835860490799, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.478652685880661, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04850363731384277, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.645794689655304, "background_mse_to_target": 0.048011474311351776, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0679805800318718, "input_change_l1": 0.1690962314605713, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6851626336574554, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14646105077117683, "edit_score": 0.3048623904585838, "background_score": 0.11934469938278199, "combined_score": 0.38272330339998006, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/112286_1/112286_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10937958210706711, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.45543184876441956, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00011151644866913557, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9961647987365723, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006458734860643744, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03003877028822899, "input_change_l1": 0.014160583727061749, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5594354830682278, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.008492629928514362, "edit_score": 0.32843434158712626, "background_score": 0.0008785567013546825, "combined_score": 0.33344423944712615, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/112286_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10675103962421417, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.458522766828537, "background_mse_to_source": 4.711566725745797e-05, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9983909130096436, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006195784662850201, "full_mse_to_target": 0.029309023171663284, "input_change_l1": 0.009204380214214325, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5594354793429375, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.005539845605380834, "edit_score": 0.3251876164227724, "background_score": 0.0003689330653287471, "combined_score": 0.32935561443387995, "confidence": 0.5720535475642703}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/112286_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11238010972738266, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4530940055847168, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00017404854588676244, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9941327571868896, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006812673527747393, "full_mse_to_target": 0.030875708907842636, "input_change_l1": 0.017647571861743927, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5598726682364941, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.010564345377497376, "edit_score": 0.3317931415513158, "background_score": 0.0013474971085088328, "combined_score": 0.33746520550557757, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/112286_1/112286_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10383277386426926, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.46121716499328613, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008500071242451668, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7522590160369873, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008541707880795002, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0343007892370224, "input_change_l1": 0.0696517676115036, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6066141203045845, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05593577278777957, "edit_score": 0.3099358107894659, "background_score": 0.05804826803505421, "combined_score": 0.34486993808299304, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/112286_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/112286_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/112286_1.json"}

112286_2

let the window show a view of skyscrapers

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.08294200897216797, "dataset_mask_area": 0.08294200897216797, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.11890997737646103, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00783412903547287, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.11107584834098816, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7583504722730042, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8152162787365146, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.33116158843040466, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.23468655616320927, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.14872429356677458, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.1801184849347919, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.07846396416425705, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.11890998482704163, "edit_change_ratio": 0.659860181450577, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1347036361694336, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/112286_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.11997884700680152, "reward": -0.11997884700680152}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.267291333520785, "reward": -0.267291333520785}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.30506874560518193, "reward": -0.30506874560518193}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.6096595991207286, "reward": -0.6096595991207286}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.7801812682850287, "reward": -0.7801812682850287}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "112286_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11997884700680152, "loser_reward": -0.267291333520785, "reward_margin": 0.1473124865139835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.11997884700680152, "loser_reward": -0.30506874560518193, "reward_margin": 0.18508989859838043, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11997884700680152, "loser_reward": -0.6096595991207286, "reward_margin": 0.48968075211392714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11997884700680152, "loser_reward": -0.7801812682850287, "reward_margin": 0.6602024212782271, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.267291333520785, "loser_reward": -0.30506874560518193, "reward_margin": 0.037777412084396944, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.267291333520785, "loser_reward": -0.6096595991207286, "reward_margin": 0.34236826559994366, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.267291333520785, "loser_reward": -0.7801812682850287, "reward_margin": 0.5128899347642437, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.30506874560518193, "loser_reward": -0.6096595991207286, "reward_margin": 0.3045908535155467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.30506874560518193, "loser_reward": -0.7801812682850287, "reward_margin": 0.4751125226798467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.6096595991207286, "loser_reward": -0.7801812682850287, "reward_margin": 0.1705216691643, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 60307, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 0, 527, 319], "component_score": 0.11997884700680152, "component_reward": -0.11997884700680152, "second_component_score": 0.267291333520785, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.1473124865139835, "confidence": 0.9891815213373882}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.06386751311505214, "reward": -0.06386751311505214}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.30349802299775186, "reward": -0.30349802299775186}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.30770148276491094, "reward": -0.30770148276491094}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.6914471793724224, "reward": -0.6914471793724224}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.9049231891138478, "reward": -0.9049231891138478}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "112286_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06386751311505214, "loser_reward": -0.30349802299775186, "reward_margin": 0.23963050988269974, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.06386751311505214, "loser_reward": -0.30770148276491094, "reward_margin": 0.24383396964985882, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.06386751311505214, "loser_reward": -0.6914471793724224, "reward_margin": 0.6275796662573703, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06386751311505214, "loser_reward": -0.9049231891138478, "reward_margin": 0.8410556759987957, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.30349802299775186, "loser_reward": -0.6914471793724224, "reward_margin": 0.38794915637467053, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.30349802299775186, "loser_reward": -0.9049231891138478, "reward_margin": 0.601425166116096, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.30770148276491094, "loser_reward": -0.6914471793724224, "reward_margin": 0.38374569660751146, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.30770148276491094, "loser_reward": -0.9049231891138478, "reward_margin": 0.5972217063489369, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.6914471793724224, "loser_reward": -0.9049231891138478, "reward_margin": 0.21347600974142544, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 21649, "bbox_xyxy": [556, 0, 1024, 306], "component_score": 0.06386751311505214, "component_reward": -0.06386751311505214, "second_component_score": 0.30349802299775186, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.23963050988269974, "confidence": 0.9983772944304818}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.11234950425708666, "reward": -0.11234950425708666}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.24796656295098363, "reward": -0.24796656295098363}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.35878389715356757, "reward": -0.35878389715356757}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.7640813771439716, "reward": -0.7640813771439716}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.9132176656825468, "reward": -0.9132176656825468}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "112286_2__region2__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11234950425708666, "loser_reward": -0.24796656295098363, "reward_margin": 0.13561705869389695, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.11234950425708666, "loser_reward": -0.35878389715356757, "reward_margin": 0.2464343928964809, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11234950425708666, "loser_reward": -0.7640813771439716, "reward_margin": 0.6517318728868849, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11234950425708666, "loser_reward": -0.9132176656825468, "reward_margin": 0.8008681614254601, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.24796656295098363, "loser_reward": -0.35878389715356757, "reward_margin": 0.11081733420258394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.24796656295098363, "loser_reward": -0.7640813771439716, "reward_margin": 0.516114814192988, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24796656295098363, "loser_reward": -0.9132176656825468, "reward_margin": 0.6652511027315632, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.35878389715356757, "loser_reward": -0.7640813771439716, "reward_margin": 0.40529747999040405, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.35878389715356757, "loser_reward": -0.9132176656825468, "reward_margin": 0.5544337685289793, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.7640813771439716, "loser_reward": -0.9132176656825468, "reward_margin": 0.1491362885385752, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 2323, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 86, 117, 135], "component_score": 0.11234950425708666, "component_reward": -0.11234950425708666, "second_component_score": 0.24796656295098363, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.13561705869389695, "confidence": 0.9888151934734422}, {"component_id": 3, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5618281364440918, "pix2pix": 0.4381718635559082}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.17130049924040214, "reward": -0.17130049924040214}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.18372973501123485, "reward": -0.18372973501123485}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1990321913282387, "reward": -0.1990321913282387}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.3374045241428539, "reward": -0.3374045241428539}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.4650456850035116, "reward": -0.4650456850035116}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "112286_2__region3__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17130049924040214, "loser_reward": -0.18372973501123485, "reward_margin": 0.012429235770832714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.17130049924040214, "loser_reward": -0.1990321913282387, "reward_margin": 0.027731692087836574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.17130049924040214, "loser_reward": -0.3374045241428539, "reward_margin": 0.16610402490245174, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17130049924040214, "loser_reward": -0.4650456850035116, "reward_margin": 0.2937451857631095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.18372973501123485, "loser_reward": -0.1990321913282387, "reward_margin": 0.01530245631700386, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.18372973501123485, "loser_reward": -0.3374045241428539, "reward_margin": 0.15367478913161903, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18372973501123485, "loser_reward": -0.4650456850035116, "reward_margin": 0.28131594999227677, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1990321913282387, "loser_reward": -0.3374045241428539, "reward_margin": 0.13837233281461517, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1990321913282387, "loser_reward": -0.4650456850035116, "reward_margin": 0.26601349367527294, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3374045241428539, "loser_reward": -0.4650456850035116, "reward_margin": 0.12764116086065774, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 2692, "bbox_xyxy": [640, 206, 730, 265], "component_score": 0.17130049924040214, "component_reward": -0.17130049924040214, "second_component_score": 0.18372973501123485, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.012429235770832714, "confidence": 0.6688816106901176}], "teacher_confidence": 0.9815465807914734, "teacher_quality_score": 0.14872429356677458, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.14872429356677458, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "112286_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11997884700680152, "loser_reward": -0.267291333520785, "reward_margin": 0.1473124865139835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.11997884700680152, "loser_reward": -0.30506874560518193, "reward_margin": 0.18508989859838043, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11997884700680152, "loser_reward": -0.6096595991207286, "reward_margin": 0.48968075211392714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11997884700680152, "loser_reward": -0.7801812682850287, "reward_margin": 0.6602024212782271, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.267291333520785, "loser_reward": -0.30506874560518193, "reward_margin": 0.037777412084396944, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.267291333520785, "loser_reward": -0.6096595991207286, "reward_margin": 0.34236826559994366, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.267291333520785, "loser_reward": -0.7801812682850287, "reward_margin": 0.5128899347642437, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.30506874560518193, "loser_reward": -0.6096595991207286, "reward_margin": 0.3045908535155467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.30506874560518193, "loser_reward": -0.7801812682850287, "reward_margin": 0.4751125226798467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.6096595991207286, "loser_reward": -0.7801812682850287, "reward_margin": 0.1705216691643, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06386751311505214, "loser_reward": -0.30349802299775186, "reward_margin": 0.23963050988269974, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.06386751311505214, "loser_reward": -0.30770148276491094, "reward_margin": 0.24383396964985882, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.06386751311505214, "loser_reward": -0.6914471793724224, "reward_margin": 0.6275796662573703, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06386751311505214, "loser_reward": -0.9049231891138478, "reward_margin": 0.8410556759987957, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.30349802299775186, "loser_reward": -0.6914471793724224, "reward_margin": 0.38794915637467053, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.30349802299775186, "loser_reward": -0.9049231891138478, "reward_margin": 0.601425166116096, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.30770148276491094, "loser_reward": -0.6914471793724224, "reward_margin": 0.38374569660751146, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.30770148276491094, "loser_reward": -0.9049231891138478, "reward_margin": 0.5972217063489369, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.6914471793724224, "loser_reward": -0.9049231891138478, "reward_margin": 0.21347600974142544, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11234950425708666, "loser_reward": -0.24796656295098363, "reward_margin": 0.13561705869389695, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.11234950425708666, "loser_reward": -0.35878389715356757, "reward_margin": 0.2464343928964809, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11234950425708666, "loser_reward": -0.7640813771439716, "reward_margin": 0.6517318728868849, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11234950425708666, "loser_reward": -0.9132176656825468, "reward_margin": 0.8008681614254601, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.24796656295098363, "loser_reward": -0.35878389715356757, "reward_margin": 0.11081733420258394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.24796656295098363, "loser_reward": -0.7640813771439716, "reward_margin": 0.516114814192988, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24796656295098363, "loser_reward": -0.9132176656825468, "reward_margin": 0.6652511027315632, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.35878389715356757, "loser_reward": -0.7640813771439716, "reward_margin": 0.40529747999040405, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.35878389715356757, "loser_reward": -0.9132176656825468, "reward_margin": 0.5544337685289793, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.7640813771439716, "loser_reward": -0.9132176656825468, "reward_margin": 0.1491362885385752, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17130049924040214, "loser_reward": -0.18372973501123485, "reward_margin": 0.012429235770832714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.17130049924040214, "loser_reward": -0.1990321913282387, "reward_margin": 0.027731692087836574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.17130049924040214, "loser_reward": -0.3374045241428539, "reward_margin": 0.16610402490245174, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17130049924040214, "loser_reward": -0.4650456850035116, "reward_margin": 0.2937451857631095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.18372973501123485, "loser_reward": -0.1990321913282387, "reward_margin": 0.01530245631700386, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.18372973501123485, "loser_reward": -0.3374045241428539, "reward_margin": 0.15367478913161903, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18372973501123485, "loser_reward": -0.4650456850035116, "reward_margin": 0.28131594999227677, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1990321913282387, "loser_reward": -0.3374045241428539, "reward_margin": 0.13837233281461517, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1990321913282387, "loser_reward": -0.4650456850035116, "reward_margin": 0.26601349367527294, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3374045241428539, "loser_reward": -0.4650456850035116, "reward_margin": 0.12764116086065774, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/112286_2/112286_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15636885166168213, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6836724281311035, "background_mse_to_source": 0.1276467889547348, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.1262328177690506, "background_mse_to_target": 0.12725241482257843, "full_mse_to_target": 0.12966741621494293, "input_change_l1": 0.3004426956176758, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8301982581615448, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.20028508696705105, "edit_score": 0.26208480149507524, "background_score": 0.3024002254009247, "combined_score": 0.4209486394003034, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/112286_2/112286_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.4613676071166992, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.598903477191925, "background_mse_to_source": 0.10798381268978119, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.668895423412323, "background_mse_to_target": 0.1079133078455925, "full_mse_to_target": 0.1372295320034027, "input_change_l1": 0.207853302359581, "directional_pixel_score": 0.755765438079834, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.4036743122152984, "edit_score": 0.6026455521583557, "background_score": 0.1742047280073166, "combined_score": 0.7580750226043165, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/112286_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1819087266921997, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6481891870498657, "background_mse_to_source": 0.045623138546943665, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7071897387504578, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04586077854037285, "full_mse_to_target": 0.057144880294799805, "input_change_l1": 0.1351047307252884, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7557647824287415, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.26241006883792584, "edit_score": 0.3133296936750412, "background_score": 0.10418519079685212, "combined_score": 0.4079910122510046, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/112286_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.6195260286331177, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5815728306770325, "background_mse_to_source": 0.14733101427555084, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6526182293891907, "background_mse_to_target": 0.1473800092935562, "full_mse_to_target": 0.1865406483411789, "input_change_l1": 0.24455130100250244, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7456111907958984, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.473114028852433, "edit_score": 0.7668086647987366, "background_score": 0.2168073683977127, "combined_score": 0.9559681143425406, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/112286_2/112286_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.025582272559404373, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7468342185020447, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010339079424738884, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7011425495147705, "background_mse_to_target": 0.010783332400023937, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01201079785823822, "input_change_l1": 0.07210677117109299, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7419402152299881, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06824165382422506, "edit_score": 0.1407303750514984, "background_score": 0.0701105695217848, "combined_score": 0.1801184849347919, "confidence": 0.9897957411199999}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/112286_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/112286_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/112286_2.json"}

112286_3

let a cat lick its paw

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.01773357391357422, "dataset_mask_area": 0.01773357391357422, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.21801277995109558, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0006055102567188442, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.21740726969437674, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8516396205518371, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8906234263269212, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3353230655193329, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.35522896121367403, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.01235783790525602, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2506677113776095, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.005226930137723684, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.21801279485225677, "edit_change_ratio": 0.02397533659098255, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.20897985994815826, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9585669505763643}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.02527618408203125, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/112286_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5011523962020874, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4988475441932678}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1659481341501814, "reward": -0.1659481341501814}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16617863550048786, "reward": -0.16617863550048786}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1663668636857765, "reward": -0.1663668636857765}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.20764426350500437, "reward": -0.20764426350500437}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2721978921573609, "reward": -0.2721978921573609}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1659481341501814, "loser_reward": -0.20764426350500437, "reward_margin": 0.041696129354822975, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1659481341501814, "loser_reward": -0.2721978921573609, "reward_margin": 0.1062497580071795, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16617863550048786, "loser_reward": -0.20764426350500437, "reward_margin": 0.0414656280045165, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16617863550048786, "loser_reward": -0.2721978921573609, "reward_margin": 0.10601925665687303, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1663668636857765, "loser_reward": -0.20764426350500437, "reward_margin": 0.04127739981922787, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1663668636857765, "loser_reward": -0.2721978921573609, "reward_margin": 0.1058310284715844, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20764426350500437, "loser_reward": -0.2721978921573609, "reward_margin": 0.06455362865235653, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 18595, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 340, 138, 631], "component_score": 0.1659481341501814, "component_reward": -0.1659481341501814, "second_component_score": 0.16617863550048786, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.00023050135030647234, "confidence": 0.5524966992424734}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5524967908859253, "teacher_quality_score": 0.01235783790525602, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.01235783790525602, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1659481341501814, "loser_reward": -0.20764426350500437, "reward_margin": 0.041696129354822975, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1659481341501814, "loser_reward": -0.2721978921573609, "reward_margin": 0.1062497580071795, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16617863550048786, "loser_reward": -0.20764426350500437, "reward_margin": 0.0414656280045165, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16617863550048786, "loser_reward": -0.2721978921573609, "reward_margin": 0.10601925665687303, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1663668636857765, "loser_reward": -0.20764426350500437, "reward_margin": 0.04127739981922787, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1663668636857765, "loser_reward": -0.2721978921573609, "reward_margin": 0.1058310284715844, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "112286_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20764426350500437, "loser_reward": -0.2721978921573609, "reward_margin": 0.06455362865235653, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/112286_3/112286_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13615933060646057, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6220288276672363, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06324128806591034, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.25034889578819275, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06326840817928314, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06456100195646286, "input_change_l1": 0.1869797706604004, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6128206625580788, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15865444000810386, "edit_score": 0.3085483994334936, "background_score": 0.2131715089082718, "combined_score": 0.4213454157486558, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/112286_3/112286_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07565420866012573, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6761893630027771, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008252890780568123, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9230522513389587, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008292270824313164, "full_mse_to_target": 0.00948683638125658, "input_change_l1": 0.024189837276935577, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5845228284597397, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0057397062075324355, "edit_score": 0.2442856289446354, "background_score": 0.023642440512776378, "combined_score": 0.25465710800373925, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/112286_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07592371851205826, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6760165095329285, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0034868468064814806, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9481796622276306, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0035262790042907, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004810143727809191, "input_change_l1": 0.015723394230008125, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5845228359103203, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.003745846753008664, "edit_score": 0.2445897076278925, "background_score": 0.013850914360955358, "combined_score": 0.2506677113776095, "confidence": 0.5781615094392677}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/112286_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07547656446695328, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6761223673820496, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012113290838897228, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9097542762756348, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01215263269841671, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013275588862597942, "input_change_l1": 0.02976182848215103, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5845342203974724, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0071540556964464486, "edit_score": 0.24411853589117527, "background_score": 0.030162435583770277, "combined_score": 0.25743375837104393, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/112286_3/112286_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08691252768039703, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6687458157539368, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004943978972733021, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8384115099906921, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004971077665686607, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006424193736165762, "input_change_l1": 0.039962369948625565, "directional_pixel_score": 0.44943901151418686, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03890102067962289, "edit_score": 0.29080361165106294, "background_score": 0.03726167697459459, "combined_score": 0.3122678221017122, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/112286_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/112286_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/112286_3.json"}

121612_1

Let water run from the faucet.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.009639999829232693, "dataset_mask_area": 0.00964, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.14427414536476135, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.008269221521914005, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.13600492384284735, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 1.0, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 1.0, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5047078132629395, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 0.9921568632125854, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.2960049238428473, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.0061633158568292845, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.15126125742681326, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.04138855263590813, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.14427414536476135, "edit_change_ratio": 0.28687435667192795, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.11652104556560516, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.8076363597303635}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.260019987821579, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/121612_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5356394648551941, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4643605649471283}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.13284668444097045, "reward": -0.13284668444097045}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.13998667275207122, "reward": -0.13998667275207122}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.14364196995645764, "reward": -0.14364196995645764}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.24423683492839332, "reward": -0.24423683492839332}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.30389523132843893, "reward": -0.30389523132843893}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "121612_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13284668444097045, "loser_reward": -0.14364196995645764, "reward_margin": 0.010795285515487196, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.13284668444097045, "loser_reward": -0.24423683492839332, "reward_margin": 0.11139015048742287, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13284668444097045, "loser_reward": -0.30389523132843893, "reward_margin": 0.17104854688746848, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.13998667275207122, "loser_reward": -0.24423683492839332, "reward_margin": 0.1042501621763221, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13998667275207122, "loser_reward": -0.30389523132843893, "reward_margin": 0.1639085585763677, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14364196995645764, "loser_reward": -0.24423683492839332, "reward_margin": 0.10059486497193568, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14364196995645764, "loser_reward": -0.30389523132843893, "reward_margin": 0.1602532613719813, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24423683492839332, "loser_reward": -0.30389523132843893, "reward_margin": 0.05965839640004561, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 555, "bbox_xyxy": [287, 242, 343, 272], "component_score": 0.13284668444097045, "component_reward": -0.13284668444097045, "second_component_score": 0.13998667275207122, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.00713998831110077, "confidence": 0.6405556140239386}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.574013888835907, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.425986111164093}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.28727551514655353, "reward": -0.28727551514655353}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.30218784624675754, "reward": -0.30218784624675754}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.30242917117220347, "reward": -0.30242917117220347}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.30266339562041683, "reward": -0.30266339562041683}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.41546277745068066, "reward": -0.41546277745068066}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "121612_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.28727551514655353, "loser_reward": -0.30218784624675754, "reward_margin": 0.014912331100204013, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.28727551514655353, "loser_reward": -0.30242917117220347, "reward_margin": 0.015153656025649942, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.28727551514655353, "loser_reward": -0.30266339562041683, "reward_margin": 0.015387880473863302, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.28727551514655353, "loser_reward": -0.41546277745068066, "reward_margin": 0.12818726230412714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.30218784624675754, "loser_reward": -0.41546277745068066, "reward_margin": 0.11327493120392312, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.30242917117220347, "loser_reward": -0.41546277745068066, "reward_margin": 0.1130336062784772, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.30266339562041683, "loser_reward": -0.41546277745068066, "reward_margin": 0.11279938183026383, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 312, "bbox_xyxy": [461, 492, 500, 500], "component_score": 0.28727551514655353, "component_reward": -0.28727551514655353, "second_component_score": 0.30218784624675754, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.014912331100204013, "confidence": 0.637690225371896}], "teacher_confidence": 0.870318591594696, "teacher_quality_score": 0.0061633158568292845, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.0061633158568292845, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "121612_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13284668444097045, "loser_reward": -0.14364196995645764, "reward_margin": 0.010795285515487196, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.13284668444097045, "loser_reward": -0.24423683492839332, "reward_margin": 0.11139015048742287, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13284668444097045, "loser_reward": -0.30389523132843893, "reward_margin": 0.17104854688746848, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.13998667275207122, "loser_reward": -0.24423683492839332, "reward_margin": 0.1042501621763221, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13998667275207122, "loser_reward": -0.30389523132843893, "reward_margin": 0.1639085585763677, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14364196995645764, "loser_reward": -0.24423683492839332, "reward_margin": 0.10059486497193568, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14364196995645764, "loser_reward": -0.30389523132843893, "reward_margin": 0.1602532613719813, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24423683492839332, "loser_reward": -0.30389523132843893, "reward_margin": 0.05965839640004561, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.28727551514655353, "loser_reward": -0.30218784624675754, "reward_margin": 0.014912331100204013, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.28727551514655353, "loser_reward": -0.30242917117220347, "reward_margin": 0.015153656025649942, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.28727551514655353, "loser_reward": -0.30266339562041683, "reward_margin": 0.015387880473863302, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.28727551514655353, "loser_reward": -0.41546277745068066, "reward_margin": 0.12818726230412714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.30218784624675754, "loser_reward": -0.41546277745068066, "reward_margin": 0.11327493120392312, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.30242917117220347, "loser_reward": -0.41546277745068066, "reward_margin": 0.1130336062784772, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "121612_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.30266339562041683, "loser_reward": -0.41546277745068066, "reward_margin": 0.11279938183026383, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/121612_1/121612_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08840461075305939, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9670260548591614, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02930593676865101, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3786042034626007, "background_mse_to_target": 0.028059283271431923, "full_mse_to_target": 0.028641000390052795, "input_change_l1": 0.13503538072109222, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6725582331418991, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14017974697053434, "edit_score": 0.17685984149575235, "background_score": 0.15358509607613086, "combined_score": 0.2615146745555103, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/121612_1/121612_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0836300179362297, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9928768277168274, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0017668944783508778, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9782745242118835, "background_mse_to_target": 0.001806120271794498, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0025949024129658937, "input_change_l1": 0.0155372628942132, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6311308443546295, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02856829622760415, "edit_score": 0.17727194130420684, "background_score": 0.006111989635974169, "combined_score": 0.18538428716361524, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/121612_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.052836496382951736, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9939555525779724, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0007465127855539322, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9874369502067566, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0008366434485651553, "full_mse_to_target": 0.001337922178208828, "input_change_l1": 0.010099214501678944, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6311308294534683, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01862046872265637, "edit_score": 0.14626267850399016, "background_score": 0.003259122744202614, "combined_score": 0.15126125742681326, "confidence": 0.832097653709335}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/121612_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10307087749242783, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9922800660133362, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0026055152993649244, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9724337458610535, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002609178889542818, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0035776295699179173, "input_change_l1": 0.01921967789530754, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6286045759916306, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.034751647431403396, "edit_score": 0.19746372029185294, "background_score": 0.008118766127154231, "combined_score": 0.2076133808796294, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/121612_1/121612_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07466650009155273, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9716794490814209, "background_mse_to_source": 0.022056730464100838, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6196041703224182, "background_mse_to_target": 0.021029777824878693, "full_mse_to_target": 0.021546831354498863, "input_change_l1": 0.11460782587528229, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6487224698066711, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1158848274499178, "edit_score": 0.16814999282360077, "background_score": 0.0981358963996172, "combined_score": 0.22782920518890024, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/121612_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/121612_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/121612_1.json"}

122896_1

Have there be a dolphin jumping out of the water

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.2169879972934723, "dataset_mask_area": 0.216988, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.21453657746315002, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00866987556219101, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.20586670190095901, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8234395385566161, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9229392749942277, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4331580400466919, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.34159701752752203, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.15844882793666332, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.21412368911318483, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1250530332326889, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.21453659236431122, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5828983850938234, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.2671000063419342, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/122896_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5676833391189575, "qwen_image_edit": 0.43231669068336487}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1130889472658746, "reward": -0.1130889472658746}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.12670922929793593, "reward": -0.12670922929793593}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.14555545285716656, "reward": -0.14555545285716656}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.18725486105680464, "reward": -0.18725486105680464}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.31421825712453577, "reward": -0.31421825712453577}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1130889472658746, "loser_reward": -0.12670922929793593, "reward_margin": 0.013620282032061337, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1130889472658746, "loser_reward": -0.14555545285716656, "reward_margin": 0.032466505591291966, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1130889472658746, "loser_reward": -0.18725486105680464, "reward_margin": 0.07416591379093004, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1130889472658746, "loser_reward": -0.31421825712453577, "reward_margin": 0.20112930985866118, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12670922929793593, "loser_reward": -0.14555545285716656, "reward_margin": 0.01884622355923063, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12670922929793593, "loser_reward": -0.18725486105680464, "reward_margin": 0.060545631758868707, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12670922929793593, "loser_reward": -0.31421825712453577, "reward_margin": 0.18750902782659984, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14555545285716656, "loser_reward": -0.18725486105680464, "reward_margin": 0.04169940819963808, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14555545285716656, "loser_reward": -0.31421825712453577, "reward_margin": 0.1686628042673692, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18725486105680464, "loser_reward": -0.31421825712453577, "reward_margin": 0.12696339606773113, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 54247, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 0, 446, 233], "component_score": 0.1130889472658746, "component_reward": -0.1130889472658746, "second_component_score": 0.12670922929793593, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.013620282032061337, "confidence": 0.7323831392512283}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7323830723762512, "teacher_quality_score": 0.15844882793666332, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.15844882793666332, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1130889472658746, "loser_reward": -0.12670922929793593, "reward_margin": 0.013620282032061337, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1130889472658746, "loser_reward": -0.14555545285716656, "reward_margin": 0.032466505591291966, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1130889472658746, "loser_reward": -0.18725486105680464, "reward_margin": 0.07416591379093004, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1130889472658746, "loser_reward": -0.31421825712453577, "reward_margin": 0.20112930985866118, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12670922929793593, "loser_reward": -0.14555545285716656, "reward_margin": 0.01884622355923063, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12670922929793593, "loser_reward": -0.18725486105680464, "reward_margin": 0.060545631758868707, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12670922929793593, "loser_reward": -0.31421825712453577, "reward_margin": 0.18750902782659984, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14555545285716656, "loser_reward": -0.18725486105680464, "reward_margin": 0.04169940819963808, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14555545285716656, "loser_reward": -0.31421825712453577, "reward_margin": 0.1686628042673692, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122896_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18725486105680464, "loser_reward": -0.31421825712453577, "reward_margin": 0.12696339606773113, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/122896_1/122896_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15467576682567596, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5958011746406555, "background_mse_to_source": 0.08710870891809464, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.47721877694129944, "background_mse_to_target": 0.08782981336116791, "full_mse_to_target": 0.10233458131551743, "input_change_l1": 0.23387710750102997, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5582875274121761, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.21334688132628798, "edit_score": 0.34594365004450084, "background_score": 0.19166495352983476, "combined_score": 0.46592921817675237, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/122896_1/122896_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04117156192660332, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6262039542198181, "background_mse_to_source": 0.09874755144119263, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4732242524623871, "background_mse_to_target": 0.09766781330108643, "full_mse_to_target": 0.08540879935026169, "input_change_l1": 0.23356573283672333, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8129287660121918, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1109362669289112, "edit_score": 0.16269857957959177, "background_score": 0.20410270094871522, "combined_score": 0.26486265823245053, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/122896_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04086736962199211, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.640434980392456, "background_mse_to_source": 0.041720833629369736, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6964710354804993, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04123397171497345, "full_mse_to_target": 0.041154418140649796, "input_change_l1": 0.1518177092075348, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8129287660121918, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07305372986011208, "edit_score": 0.15954818204045296, "background_score": 0.1024266265332699, "combined_score": 0.21412368911318483, "confidence": 0.8401394184369742}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/122896_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04719790443778038, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5952110886573792, "background_mse_to_source": 0.15319417417049408, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.36227402091026306, "background_mse_to_target": 0.15169812738895416, "full_mse_to_target": 0.12902283668518066, "input_change_l1": 0.29134848713874817, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8129288554191589, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1370865110307932, "edit_score": 0.17492347285151483, "background_score": 0.2807393699884415, "combined_score": 0.31350183822214606, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/122896_1/122896_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0698036178946495, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6033625602722168, "background_mse_to_source": 0.013827835209667683, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.690183162689209, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014085269533097744, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02617548406124115, "input_change_l1": 0.0831780731678009, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5684409961104393, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.062170747108757494, "edit_score": 0.25702085681259634, "background_score": 0.07579120267182589, "combined_score": 0.298599475575611, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/122896_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/122896_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/122896_1.json"}

122927_1

Give the bird a long tail.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.26472800970077515, "dataset_mask_area": 0.264728, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.20273573696613312, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.017066489905118942, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.18566924706101418, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8711224119142753, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9577782037764785, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.07712417840957642, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.2791450023651123, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3285150646417863, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.0179661845517694, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2557756383848027, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.01948251947760582, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.20273573696613312, "edit_change_ratio": 0.09609810174148213, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.19078855216503143, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9410701587204754}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.3927919864654541, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/122927_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.5140170454978943, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4859829246997833}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1580051668889937, "reward": -0.1580051668889937}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16080930755991718, "reward": -0.16080930755991718}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.16538314314262242, "reward": -0.16538314314262242}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.18503077077353372, "reward": -0.18503077077353372}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.22855169496405867, "reward": -0.22855169496405867}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1580051668889937, "loser_reward": -0.18503077077353372, "reward_margin": 0.027025603884540034, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1580051668889937, "loser_reward": -0.22855169496405867, "reward_margin": 0.07054652807506498, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16080930755991718, "loser_reward": -0.18503077077353372, "reward_margin": 0.02422146321361654, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16080930755991718, "loser_reward": -0.22855169496405867, "reward_margin": 0.06774238740414149, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16538314314262242, "loser_reward": -0.18503077077353372, "reward_margin": 0.019647627630911296, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16538314314262242, "loser_reward": -0.22855169496405867, "reward_margin": 0.06316855182143624, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18503077077353372, "loser_reward": -0.22855169496405867, "reward_margin": 0.043520924190524946, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 62382, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 0, 336, 396], "component_score": 0.1580051668889937, "component_reward": -0.1580051668889937, "second_component_score": 0.16080930755991718, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.002804140670923494, "confidence": 0.5813370063935549}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.5032550692558289, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49674493074417114}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.10892327994364313, "reward": -0.10892327994364313}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1095743056735373, "reward": -0.1095743056735373}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.11056782665314677, "reward": -0.11056782665314677}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.13156033503671644, "reward": -0.13156033503671644}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.17732476159837096, "reward": -0.17732476159837096}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10892327994364313, "loser_reward": -0.13156033503671644, "reward_margin": 0.022637055093073302, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10892327994364313, "loser_reward": -0.17732476159837096, "reward_margin": 0.06840148165472783, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1095743056735373, "loser_reward": -0.13156033503671644, "reward_margin": 0.02198602936317913, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1095743056735373, "loser_reward": -0.17732476159837096, "reward_margin": 0.06775045592483366, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11056782665314677, "loser_reward": -0.13156033503671644, "reward_margin": 0.02099250838356967, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11056782665314677, "loser_reward": -0.17732476159837096, "reward_margin": 0.0667569349452242, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13156033503671644, "loser_reward": -0.17732476159837096, "reward_margin": 0.045764426561654525, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 613, "bbox_xyxy": [243, 51, 278, 74], "component_score": 0.10892327994364313, "component_reward": -0.10892327994364313, "second_component_score": 0.1095743056735373, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0006510257298941724, "confidence": 0.5606925187177263}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5077543258666992, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49224570393562317}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.12674036019766935, "reward": -0.12674036019766935}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.12829135761488578, "reward": -0.12829135761488578}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.12942571650195167, "reward": -0.12942571650195167}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.16571350198844445, "reward": -0.16571350198844445}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.16587008259166028, "reward": -0.16587008259166028}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12674036019766935, "loser_reward": -0.16571350198844445, "reward_margin": 0.0389731417907751, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12674036019766935, "loser_reward": -0.16587008259166028, "reward_margin": 0.03912972239399093, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12829135761488578, "loser_reward": -0.16571350198844445, "reward_margin": 0.037422144373558675, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12829135761488578, "loser_reward": -0.16587008259166028, "reward_margin": 0.0375787249767745, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12942571650195167, "loser_reward": -0.16571350198844445, "reward_margin": 0.03628778548649278, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12942571650195167, "loser_reward": -0.16587008259166028, "reward_margin": 0.03644436608970861, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 2010, "bbox_xyxy": [283, 63, 336, 130], "component_score": 0.12674036019766935, "component_reward": -0.12674036019766935, "second_component_score": 0.12829135761488578, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0015509974172164265, "confidence": 0.5717444129819572}, {"component_id": 3, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5084669589996338, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4915330410003662}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.07357365746816504, "reward": -0.07357365746816504}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.07526720978925006, "reward": -0.07526720978925006}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.07651459871261614, "reward": -0.07651459871261614}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.10536174931237476, "reward": -0.10536174931237476}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.12797367666754872, "reward": -0.12797367666754872}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07357365746816504, "loser_reward": -0.10536174931237476, "reward_margin": 0.03178809184420972, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07357365746816504, "loser_reward": -0.12797367666754872, "reward_margin": 0.054400019199383684, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07526720978925006, "loser_reward": -0.10536174931237476, "reward_margin": 0.0300945395231247, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07526720978925006, "loser_reward": -0.12797367666754872, "reward_margin": 0.05270646687829866, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07651459871261614, "loser_reward": -0.10536174931237476, "reward_margin": 0.02884715059975862, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07651459871261614, "loser_reward": -0.12797367666754872, "reward_margin": 0.05145907795493258, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10536174931237476, "loser_reward": -0.12797367666754872, "reward_margin": 0.022611927355173964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 570, "bbox_xyxy": [206, 163, 242, 190], "component_score": 0.07357365746816504, "component_reward": -0.07357365746816504, "second_component_score": 0.07526720978925006, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0016935523210850206, "confidence": 0.5903919330625806}, {"component_id": 4, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.5011470913887024, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49885293841362}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.07799125016893958, "reward": -0.07799125016893958}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.07822066493821331, "reward": -0.07822066493821331}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.07860527142498178, "reward": -0.07860527142498178}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.10226682478003206, "reward": -0.10226682478003206}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.10897159318812191, "reward": -0.10897159318812191}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07799125016893958, "loser_reward": -0.10226682478003206, "reward_margin": 0.024275574611092476, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07799125016893958, "loser_reward": -0.10897159318812191, "reward_margin": 0.03098034301918233, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07822066493821331, "loser_reward": -0.10226682478003206, "reward_margin": 0.02404615984181875, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07822066493821331, "loser_reward": -0.10897159318812191, "reward_margin": 0.030750928249908605, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07860527142498178, "loser_reward": -0.10226682478003206, "reward_margin": 0.023661553355050283, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07860527142498178, "loser_reward": -0.10897159318812191, "reward_margin": 0.030366321763140136, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 607, "bbox_xyxy": [256, 194, 294, 222], "component_score": 0.07799125016893958, "component_reward": -0.07799125016893958, "second_component_score": 0.07822066493821331, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.00022941476927372528, "confidence": 0.5552790068969576}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5806934237480164, "teacher_quality_score": 0.0179661845517694, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.0179661845517694, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1580051668889937, "loser_reward": -0.18503077077353372, "reward_margin": 0.027025603884540034, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1580051668889937, "loser_reward": -0.22855169496405867, "reward_margin": 0.07054652807506498, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16080930755991718, "loser_reward": -0.18503077077353372, "reward_margin": 0.02422146321361654, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16080930755991718, "loser_reward": -0.22855169496405867, "reward_margin": 0.06774238740414149, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16538314314262242, "loser_reward": -0.18503077077353372, "reward_margin": 0.019647627630911296, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16538314314262242, "loser_reward": -0.22855169496405867, "reward_margin": 0.06316855182143624, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18503077077353372, "loser_reward": -0.22855169496405867, "reward_margin": 0.043520924190524946, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10892327994364313, "loser_reward": -0.13156033503671644, "reward_margin": 0.022637055093073302, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10892327994364313, "loser_reward": -0.17732476159837096, "reward_margin": 0.06840148165472783, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1095743056735373, "loser_reward": -0.13156033503671644, "reward_margin": 0.02198602936317913, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1095743056735373, "loser_reward": -0.17732476159837096, "reward_margin": 0.06775045592483366, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11056782665314677, "loser_reward": -0.13156033503671644, "reward_margin": 0.02099250838356967, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11056782665314677, "loser_reward": -0.17732476159837096, "reward_margin": 0.0667569349452242, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13156033503671644, "loser_reward": -0.17732476159837096, "reward_margin": 0.045764426561654525, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12674036019766935, "loser_reward": -0.16571350198844445, "reward_margin": 0.0389731417907751, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12674036019766935, "loser_reward": -0.16587008259166028, "reward_margin": 0.03912972239399093, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12829135761488578, "loser_reward": -0.16571350198844445, "reward_margin": 0.037422144373558675, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12829135761488578, "loser_reward": -0.16587008259166028, "reward_margin": 0.0375787249767745, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12942571650195167, "loser_reward": -0.16571350198844445, "reward_margin": 0.03628778548649278, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12942571650195167, "loser_reward": -0.16587008259166028, "reward_margin": 0.03644436608970861, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07357365746816504, "loser_reward": -0.10536174931237476, "reward_margin": 0.03178809184420972, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07357365746816504, "loser_reward": -0.12797367666754872, "reward_margin": 0.054400019199383684, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07526720978925006, "loser_reward": -0.10536174931237476, "reward_margin": 0.0300945395231247, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07526720978925006, "loser_reward": -0.12797367666754872, "reward_margin": 0.05270646687829866, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07651459871261614, "loser_reward": -0.10536174931237476, "reward_margin": 0.02884715059975862, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07651459871261614, "loser_reward": -0.12797367666754872, "reward_margin": 0.05145907795493258, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region3__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10536174931237476, "loser_reward": -0.12797367666754872, "reward_margin": 0.022611927355173964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07799125016893958, "loser_reward": -0.10226682478003206, "reward_margin": 0.024275574611092476, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07799125016893958, "loser_reward": -0.10897159318812191, "reward_margin": 0.03098034301918233, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07822066493821331, "loser_reward": -0.10226682478003206, "reward_margin": 0.02404615984181875, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07822066493821331, "loser_reward": -0.10897159318812191, "reward_margin": 0.030750928249908605, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07860527142498178, "loser_reward": -0.10226682478003206, "reward_margin": 0.023661553355050283, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07860527142498178, "loser_reward": -0.10897159318812191, "reward_margin": 0.030366321763140136, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/122927_1/122927_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07689090818166733, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6075285077095032, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017118876799941063, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.878591001033783, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01790495216846466, "full_mse_to_target": 0.033520184457302094, "input_change_l1": 0.050721485167741776, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5782577246427536, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03328092941083014, "edit_score": 0.2608207754790783, "background_score": 0.04140067659318447, "combined_score": 0.2853192166145891, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/122927_1/122927_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07141836732625961, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6202480792999268, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00031339385895989835, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9973337650299072, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0013322263257578015, "full_mse_to_target": 0.019885985180735588, "input_change_l1": 0.010688314214348793, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5770813897252083, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.011057552951388062, "edit_score": 0.2530984040349722, "background_score": 0.000846640852978453, "combined_score": 0.25759483744186584, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/122927_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07047315686941147, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6197660565376282, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00013240889529697597, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.99885493516922, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0011882968246936798, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01952993869781494, "input_change_l1": 0.006947400514036417, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5770810768008232, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.00723235250916332, "edit_score": 0.25224967636168005, "background_score": 0.0003614218614529819, "combined_score": 0.2557756383848027, "confidence": 0.5627086670917674}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/122927_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07261866331100464, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6195357441902161, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0004711231158580631, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9959432482719421, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0014633022947236896, "full_mse_to_target": 0.020300118252635002, "input_change_l1": 0.013228513300418854, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5761272236704826, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.013475891854614019, "edit_score": 0.2546797085553408, "background_score": 0.0012824734614696354, "combined_score": 0.2598537644630415, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/122927_1/122927_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10517378151416779, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5883062481880188, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00802785623818636, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8667472004890442, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008716162294149399, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03425120189785957, "input_change_l1": 0.06770911812782288, "directional_pixel_score": 0.494243330322206, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04673945084214211, "edit_score": 0.3139516992960125, "background_score": 0.03467841614037752, "combined_score": 0.338862155303359, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/122927_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/122927_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/122927_1.json"}

122927_2

Add flowers

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.14467144012451172, "dataset_mask_area": 0.14467144012451172, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.17361341416835785, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.008027727715671062, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1655856864526868, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9129979035639413, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9617804130472608, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3983387351036072, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3136166514022502, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.009376078121640605, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2610288219637005, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.021474556997418404, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.17361336946487427, "edit_change_ratio": 0.12369183930712876, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.1663980931043625, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9584405487736842}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.2041940689086914, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/122927_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.518997311592102, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4810026288032532}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.21846723423217188, "reward": -0.21846723423217188}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.22226853793626647, "reward": -0.22226853793626647}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.22493126395327273, "reward": -0.22493126395327273}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.242025850699516, "reward": -0.242025850699516}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2703239178031217, "reward": -0.2703239178031217}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21846723423217188, "loser_reward": -0.242025850699516, "reward_margin": 0.023558616467344112, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21846723423217188, "loser_reward": -0.2703239178031217, "reward_margin": 0.05185668357094983, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22226853793626647, "loser_reward": -0.242025850699516, "reward_margin": 0.019757312763249518, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22226853793626647, "loser_reward": -0.2703239178031217, "reward_margin": 0.048055379866855236, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22493126395327273, "loser_reward": -0.242025850699516, "reward_margin": 0.017094586746243257, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22493126395327273, "loser_reward": -0.2703239178031217, "reward_margin": 0.045392653849848974, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.242025850699516, "loser_reward": -0.2703239178031217, "reward_margin": 0.028298067103605717, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 82961, "bbox_xyxy": [506, 0, 1024, 390], "component_score": 0.21846723423217188, "component_reward": -0.21846723423217188, "second_component_score": 0.22226853793626647, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.003801303704094594, "confidence": 0.5807362067425321}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5222757458686829, "qwen_image_edit": 0.47772422432899475}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.11851517507378594, "reward": -0.11851517507378594}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1229732773886062, "reward": -0.1229732773886062}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.12621886824833928, "reward": -0.12621886824833928}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.15689669999782926, "reward": -0.15689669999782926}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.32842296117241493, "reward": -0.32842296117241493}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11851517507378594, "loser_reward": -0.15689669999782926, "reward_margin": 0.03838152492404333, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11851517507378594, "loser_reward": -0.32842296117241493, "reward_margin": 0.20990778609862898, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1229732773886062, "loser_reward": -0.15689669999782926, "reward_margin": 0.03392342260922307, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1229732773886062, "loser_reward": -0.32842296117241493, "reward_margin": 0.20544968378380873, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12621886824833928, "loser_reward": -0.15689669999782926, "reward_margin": 0.030677831749489987, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12621886824833928, "loser_reward": -0.32842296117241493, "reward_margin": 0.20220409292407565, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15689669999782926, "loser_reward": -0.32842296117241493, "reward_margin": 0.17152626117458566, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 8208, "bbox_xyxy": [593, 41, 702, 159], "component_score": 0.11851517507378594, "component_reward": -0.11851517507378594, "second_component_score": 0.1229732773886062, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.004458102314820259, "confidence": 0.614801100144335}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5235669016838074, "qwen_image_edit": 0.47643303871154785}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.10715385852121107, "reward": -0.10715385852121107}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.11187073844202676, "reward": -0.11187073844202676}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.11534217413334409, "reward": -0.11534217413334409}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3378844668834936, "reward": -0.3378844668834936}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.39488589866575785, "reward": -0.39488589866575785}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10715385852121107, "loser_reward": -0.3378844668834936, "reward_margin": 0.23073060836228254, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10715385852121107, "loser_reward": -0.39488589866575785, "reward_margin": 0.2877320401445468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11187073844202676, "loser_reward": -0.3378844668834936, "reward_margin": 0.22601372844146683, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11187073844202676, "loser_reward": -0.39488589866575785, "reward_margin": 0.2830151602237311, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11534217413334409, "loser_reward": -0.3378844668834936, "reward_margin": 0.22254229275014953, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11534217413334409, "loser_reward": -0.39488589866575785, "reward_margin": 0.2795437245324138, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.3378844668834936, "loser_reward": -0.39488589866575785, "reward_margin": 0.057001431782264245, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4592, "bbox_xyxy": [496, 91, 583, 165], "component_score": 0.10715385852121107, "component_reward": -0.10715385852121107, "second_component_score": 0.11187073844202676, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.004716879920815695, "confidence": 0.6251830662866014}, {"component_id": 3, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5027453303337097, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49725469946861267}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.16237708343536358, "reward": -0.16237708343536358}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16292614979110656, "reward": -0.16292614979110656}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.16468829014507358, "reward": -0.16468829014507358}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.18089124390180222, "reward": -0.18089124390180222}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.18496604217705317, "reward": -0.18496604217705317}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16237708343536358, "loser_reward": -0.18089124390180222, "reward_margin": 0.01851416046643864, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16237708343536358, "loser_reward": -0.18496604217705317, "reward_margin": 0.02258895874168959, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16292614979110656, "loser_reward": -0.18089124390180222, "reward_margin": 0.017965094110695662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16292614979110656, "loser_reward": -0.18496604217705317, "reward_margin": 0.022039892385946613, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16468829014507358, "loser_reward": -0.18089124390180222, "reward_margin": 0.016202953756728644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16468829014507358, "loser_reward": -0.18496604217705317, "reward_margin": 0.020277752031979596, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 11117, "bbox_xyxy": [224, 287, 358, 464], "component_score": 0.16237708343536358, "component_reward": -0.16237708343536358, "second_component_score": 0.16292614979110656, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0005490663557429776, "confidence": 0.5560656889000095}, {"component_id": 4, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.07802725533366901, "reward": -0.07802725533366901}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.09814571339893154, "reward": -0.09814571339893154}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.13252074883575551, "reward": -0.13252074883575551}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.14094009117595854, "reward": -0.14094009117595854}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19445818462577885, "reward": -0.19445818462577885}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07802725533366901, "loser_reward": -0.09814571339893154, "reward_margin": 0.020118458065262523, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07802725533366901, "loser_reward": -0.13252074883575551, "reward_margin": 0.0544934935020865, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.07802725533366901, "loser_reward": -0.14094009117595854, "reward_margin": 0.06291283584228953, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.07802725533366901, "loser_reward": -0.19445818462577885, "reward_margin": 0.11643092929210984, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09814571339893154, "loser_reward": -0.13252074883575551, "reward_margin": 0.03437503543682398, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09814571339893154, "loser_reward": -0.14094009117595854, "reward_margin": 0.04279437777702701, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09814571339893154, "loser_reward": -0.19445818462577885, "reward_margin": 0.09631247122684732, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13252074883575551, "loser_reward": -0.19445818462577885, "reward_margin": 0.06193743579002334, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14094009117595854, "loser_reward": -0.19445818462577885, "reward_margin": 0.05351809344982031, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 3013, "bbox_xyxy": [886, 366, 1024, 427], "component_score": 0.07802725533366901, "component_reward": -0.07802725533366901, "second_component_score": 0.09814571339893154, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.020118458065262523, "confidence": 0.8537672546853126}, {"component_id": 5, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5624391436576843, "qwen_image_edit": 0.43756088614463806}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.07466738218785031, "reward": -0.07466738218785031}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.08722073824517426, "reward": -0.08722073824517426}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.10264690392819466, "reward": -0.10264690392819466}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.10273628987860865, "reward": -0.10273628987860865}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.24218578093941323, "reward": -0.24218578093941323}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.07466738218785031, "loser_reward": -0.08722073824517426, "reward_margin": 0.012553356057323953, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.07466738218785031, "loser_reward": -0.10264690392819466, "reward_margin": 0.02797952174034435, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07466738218785031, "loser_reward": -0.10273628987860865, "reward_margin": 0.028068907690758343, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07466738218785031, "loser_reward": -0.24218578093941323, "reward_margin": 0.16751839875156294, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08722073824517426, "loser_reward": -0.10264690392819466, "reward_margin": 0.015426165683020396, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08722073824517426, "loser_reward": -0.10273628987860865, "reward_margin": 0.01551555163343439, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08722073824517426, "loser_reward": -0.24218578093941323, "reward_margin": 0.15496504269423897, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10264690392819466, "loser_reward": -0.24218578093941323, "reward_margin": 0.1395388770112186, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10273628987860865, "loser_reward": -0.24218578093941323, "reward_margin": 0.13944949106080456, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 8746, "bbox_xyxy": [441, 394, 604, 521], "component_score": 0.07466738218785031, "component_reward": -0.07466738218785031, "second_component_score": 0.08722073824517426, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.012553356057323953, "confidence": 0.7837914760693327}, {"component_id": 6, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5352494716644287, "editar": 0.4647505283355713}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.09412387112498981, "reward": -0.09412387112498981}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.10118548016552813, "reward": -0.10118548016552813}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.13399822281114757, "reward": -0.13399822281114757}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.16775342622009343, "reward": -0.16775342622009343}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.17925685101444833, "reward": -0.17925685101444833}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09412387112498981, "loser_reward": -0.13399822281114757, "reward_margin": 0.03987435168615776, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09412387112498981, "loser_reward": -0.16775342622009343, "reward_margin": 0.07362955509510362, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09412387112498981, "loser_reward": -0.17925685101444833, "reward_margin": 0.08513297988945852, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 6, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10118548016552813, "loser_reward": -0.13399822281114757, "reward_margin": 0.03281274264561944, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10118548016552813, "loser_reward": -0.16775342622009343, "reward_margin": 0.0665679460545653, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10118548016552813, "loser_reward": -0.17925685101444833, "reward_margin": 0.0780713708489202, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13399822281114757, "loser_reward": -0.16775342622009343, "reward_margin": 0.03375520340894586, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13399822281114757, "loser_reward": -0.17925685101444833, "reward_margin": 0.04525862820330076, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16775342622009343, "loser_reward": -0.17925685101444833, "reward_margin": 0.0115034247943549, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 20214, "bbox_xyxy": [784, 430, 1024, 624], "component_score": 0.09412387112498981, "component_reward": -0.09412387112498981, "second_component_score": 0.10118548016552813, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.007061609040538319, "confidence": 0.6724552433214003}, {"component_id": 7, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5419823527336121, "qwen_image_edit": 0.45801761746406555}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.06096578488469822, "reward": -0.06096578488469822}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.06938207463733852, "reward": -0.06938207463733852}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.08066990063694537, "reward": -0.08066990063694537}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.1195242656141054, "reward": -0.1195242656141054}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.12302782115084118, "reward": -0.12302782115084118}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06096578488469822, "loser_reward": -0.08066990063694537, "reward_margin": 0.019704115752247155, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06096578488469822, "loser_reward": -0.1195242656141054, "reward_margin": 0.05855848072940718, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06096578488469822, "loser_reward": -0.12302782115084118, "reward_margin": 0.06206203626614296, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06938207463733852, "loser_reward": -0.08066990063694537, "reward_margin": 0.011287825999606857, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06938207463733852, "loser_reward": -0.1195242656141054, "reward_margin": 0.05014219097676688, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06938207463733852, "loser_reward": -0.12302782115084118, "reward_margin": 0.053645746513502665, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08066990063694537, "loser_reward": -0.1195242656141054, "reward_margin": 0.03885436497716002, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08066990063694537, "loser_reward": -0.12302782115084118, "reward_margin": 0.04235792051389581, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 6410, "bbox_xyxy": [752, 482, 865, 611], "component_score": 0.06096578488469822, "component_reward": -0.06096578488469822, "second_component_score": 0.06938207463733852, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.008416289752640298, "confidence": 0.752684244895917}, {"component_id": 8, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5319395661354065, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4680604338645935}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.07842085137375397, "reward": -0.07842085137375397}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.08481747196428475, "reward": -0.08481747196428475}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.08925953370687785, "reward": -0.08925953370687785}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.09812507506948895, "reward": -0.09812507506948895}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.13900191986258142, "reward": -0.13900191986258142}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.07842085137375397, "loser_reward": -0.08925953370687785, "reward_margin": 0.010838682333123878, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07842085137375397, "loser_reward": -0.09812507506948895, "reward_margin": 0.019704223695734976, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07842085137375397, "loser_reward": -0.13900191986258142, "reward_margin": 0.06058106848882745, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08481747196428475, "loser_reward": -0.09812507506948895, "reward_margin": 0.013307603105204194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08481747196428475, "loser_reward": -0.13900191986258142, "reward_margin": 0.05418444789829667, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08925953370687785, "loser_reward": -0.13900191986258142, "reward_margin": 0.049742386155703575, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09812507506948895, "loser_reward": -0.13900191986258142, "reward_margin": 0.040876844793092476, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 6438, "bbox_xyxy": [801, 559, 961, 650], "component_score": 0.07842085137375397, "component_reward": -0.07842085137375397, "second_component_score": 0.08481747196428475, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.006396620590530783, "confidence": 0.6817760458665089}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6230218410491943, "teacher_quality_score": 0.009376078121640605, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.009376078121640605, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21846723423217188, "loser_reward": -0.242025850699516, "reward_margin": 0.023558616467344112, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21846723423217188, "loser_reward": -0.2703239178031217, "reward_margin": 0.05185668357094983, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22226853793626647, "loser_reward": -0.242025850699516, "reward_margin": 0.019757312763249518, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22226853793626647, "loser_reward": -0.2703239178031217, "reward_margin": 0.048055379866855236, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22493126395327273, "loser_reward": -0.242025850699516, "reward_margin": 0.017094586746243257, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22493126395327273, "loser_reward": -0.2703239178031217, "reward_margin": 0.045392653849848974, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.242025850699516, "loser_reward": -0.2703239178031217, "reward_margin": 0.028298067103605717, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11851517507378594, "loser_reward": -0.15689669999782926, "reward_margin": 0.03838152492404333, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11851517507378594, "loser_reward": -0.32842296117241493, "reward_margin": 0.20990778609862898, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1229732773886062, "loser_reward": -0.15689669999782926, "reward_margin": 0.03392342260922307, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1229732773886062, "loser_reward": -0.32842296117241493, "reward_margin": 0.20544968378380873, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12621886824833928, "loser_reward": -0.15689669999782926, "reward_margin": 0.030677831749489987, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12621886824833928, "loser_reward": -0.32842296117241493, "reward_margin": 0.20220409292407565, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15689669999782926, "loser_reward": -0.32842296117241493, "reward_margin": 0.17152626117458566, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10715385852121107, "loser_reward": -0.3378844668834936, "reward_margin": 0.23073060836228254, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10715385852121107, "loser_reward": -0.39488589866575785, "reward_margin": 0.2877320401445468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11187073844202676, "loser_reward": -0.3378844668834936, "reward_margin": 0.22601372844146683, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11187073844202676, "loser_reward": -0.39488589866575785, "reward_margin": 0.2830151602237311, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11534217413334409, "loser_reward": -0.3378844668834936, "reward_margin": 0.22254229275014953, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11534217413334409, "loser_reward": -0.39488589866575785, "reward_margin": 0.2795437245324138, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.3378844668834936, "loser_reward": -0.39488589866575785, "reward_margin": 0.057001431782264245, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16237708343536358, "loser_reward": -0.18089124390180222, "reward_margin": 0.01851416046643864, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16237708343536358, "loser_reward": -0.18496604217705317, "reward_margin": 0.02258895874168959, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16292614979110656, "loser_reward": -0.18089124390180222, "reward_margin": 0.017965094110695662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16292614979110656, "loser_reward": -0.18496604217705317, "reward_margin": 0.022039892385946613, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16468829014507358, "loser_reward": -0.18089124390180222, "reward_margin": 0.016202953756728644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16468829014507358, "loser_reward": -0.18496604217705317, "reward_margin": 0.020277752031979596, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07802725533366901, "loser_reward": -0.09814571339893154, "reward_margin": 0.020118458065262523, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07802725533366901, "loser_reward": -0.13252074883575551, "reward_margin": 0.0544934935020865, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.07802725533366901, "loser_reward": -0.14094009117595854, "reward_margin": 0.06291283584228953, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.07802725533366901, "loser_reward": -0.19445818462577885, "reward_margin": 0.11643092929210984, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09814571339893154, "loser_reward": -0.13252074883575551, "reward_margin": 0.03437503543682398, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09814571339893154, "loser_reward": -0.14094009117595854, "reward_margin": 0.04279437777702701, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09814571339893154, "loser_reward": -0.19445818462577885, "reward_margin": 0.09631247122684732, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13252074883575551, "loser_reward": -0.19445818462577885, "reward_margin": 0.06193743579002334, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14094009117595854, "loser_reward": -0.19445818462577885, "reward_margin": 0.05351809344982031, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.07466738218785031, "loser_reward": -0.08722073824517426, "reward_margin": 0.012553356057323953, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.07466738218785031, "loser_reward": -0.10264690392819466, "reward_margin": 0.02797952174034435, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07466738218785031, "loser_reward": -0.10273628987860865, "reward_margin": 0.028068907690758343, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07466738218785031, "loser_reward": -0.24218578093941323, "reward_margin": 0.16751839875156294, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08722073824517426, "loser_reward": -0.10264690392819466, "reward_margin": 0.015426165683020396, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08722073824517426, "loser_reward": -0.10273628987860865, "reward_margin": 0.01551555163343439, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08722073824517426, "loser_reward": -0.24218578093941323, "reward_margin": 0.15496504269423897, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10264690392819466, "loser_reward": -0.24218578093941323, "reward_margin": 0.1395388770112186, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region5__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10273628987860865, "loser_reward": -0.24218578093941323, "reward_margin": 0.13944949106080456, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09412387112498981, "loser_reward": -0.13399822281114757, "reward_margin": 0.03987435168615776, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09412387112498981, "loser_reward": -0.16775342622009343, "reward_margin": 0.07362955509510362, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09412387112498981, "loser_reward": -0.17925685101444833, "reward_margin": 0.08513297988945852, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 6, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10118548016552813, "loser_reward": -0.13399822281114757, "reward_margin": 0.03281274264561944, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10118548016552813, "loser_reward": -0.16775342622009343, "reward_margin": 0.0665679460545653, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10118548016552813, "loser_reward": -0.17925685101444833, "reward_margin": 0.0780713708489202, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13399822281114757, "loser_reward": -0.16775342622009343, "reward_margin": 0.03375520340894586, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13399822281114757, "loser_reward": -0.17925685101444833, "reward_margin": 0.04525862820330076, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16775342622009343, "loser_reward": -0.17925685101444833, "reward_margin": 0.0115034247943549, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06096578488469822, "loser_reward": -0.08066990063694537, "reward_margin": 0.019704115752247155, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06096578488469822, "loser_reward": -0.1195242656141054, "reward_margin": 0.05855848072940718, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06096578488469822, "loser_reward": -0.12302782115084118, "reward_margin": 0.06206203626614296, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06938207463733852, "loser_reward": -0.08066990063694537, "reward_margin": 0.011287825999606857, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06938207463733852, "loser_reward": -0.1195242656141054, "reward_margin": 0.05014219097676688, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06938207463733852, "loser_reward": -0.12302782115084118, "reward_margin": 0.053645746513502665, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08066990063694537, "loser_reward": -0.1195242656141054, "reward_margin": 0.03885436497716002, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08066990063694537, "loser_reward": -0.12302782115084118, "reward_margin": 0.04235792051389581, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.07842085137375397, "loser_reward": -0.08925953370687785, "reward_margin": 0.010838682333123878, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07842085137375397, "loser_reward": -0.09812507506948895, "reward_margin": 0.019704223695734976, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07842085137375397, "loser_reward": -0.13900191986258142, "reward_margin": 0.06058106848882745, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08481747196428475, "loser_reward": -0.09812507506948895, "reward_margin": 0.013307603105204194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08481747196428475, "loser_reward": -0.13900191986258142, "reward_margin": 0.05418444789829667, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08925953370687785, "loser_reward": -0.13900191986258142, "reward_margin": 0.049742386155703575, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_2__region8__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09812507506948895, "loser_reward": -0.13900191986258142, "reward_margin": 0.040876844793092476, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/122927_2/122927_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11384639889001846, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7438936233520508, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06398670375347137, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5929312109947205, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06431233882904053, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07147850841283798, "input_change_l1": 0.2074642926454544, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5314476788043976, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1265366072533652, "edit_score": 0.28220575451850893, "background_score": 0.1454004615545273, "combined_score": 0.3655510883545503, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/122927_2/122927_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08121936023235321, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7878761291503906, "background_mse_to_source": 0.019764592871069908, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7712087035179138, "background_mse_to_target": 0.019934609532356262, "full_mse_to_target": 0.028800740838050842, "input_change_l1": 0.07034408301115036, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4993001336697489, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.047263772389851515, "edit_score": 0.24881910098483787, "background_score": 0.06552285216748716, "combined_score": 0.28408492780523376, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/122927_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07543318718671799, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7987462878227234, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008350539021193981, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8676798939704895, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008585536852478981, "full_mse_to_target": 0.018256474286317825, "input_change_l1": 0.045723676681518555, "directional_pixel_score": 0.49930014699930325, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.030795927916187793, "edit_score": 0.2408588928723475, "background_score": 0.034814560227096086, "combined_score": 0.2610288219637005, "confidence": 0.6911620598477515}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/122927_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08665679395198822, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.780330240726471, "background_mse_to_source": 0.030438976362347603, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7150641083717346, "background_mse_to_target": 0.030566027387976646, "full_mse_to_target": 0.038680773228406906, "input_change_l1": 0.08767852932214737, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4992556663346477, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05867580808699131, "edit_score": 0.25577682922303213, "background_score": 0.08742615468800069, "combined_score": 0.30197922230407126, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/122927_2/122927_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08230318874120712, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7811481356620789, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03531871736049652, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8502041697502136, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03465288132429123, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04154651612043381, "input_change_l1": 0.07347922772169113, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4876742884516716, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03703972504008561, "edit_score": 0.25415498949587345, "background_score": 0.06527788341045379, "combined_score": 0.28856484530959275, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/122927_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/122927_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/122927_2.json"}

122927_3

Have baby birds follow the large bird.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.11237144470214844, "dataset_mask_area": 0.11237144470214844, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2357732504606247, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.004781981464475393, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2309912689961493, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8584471654044872, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9212520676501367, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.2918720543384552, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3708550115506932, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.011910464156098899, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.26645027020480483, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.03119424544274807, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2357732057571411, "edit_change_ratio": 0.13230615133968954, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.22811491787433624, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9675184130520187}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.14767169952392578, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/122927_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5094380378723145, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49056196212768555}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.11151528978088754, "reward": -0.11151528978088754}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.11340312260953941, "reward": -0.11340312260953941}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.11462748897634446, "reward": -0.11462748897634446}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.13253813464101405, "reward": -0.13253813464101405}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.15486847539572043, "reward": -0.15486847539572043}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11151528978088754, "loser_reward": -0.13253813464101405, "reward_margin": 0.02102284486012651, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11151528978088754, "loser_reward": -0.15486847539572043, "reward_margin": 0.043353185614832895, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11340312260953941, "loser_reward": -0.13253813464101405, "reward_margin": 0.019135012031474635, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11340312260953941, "loser_reward": -0.15486847539572043, "reward_margin": 0.04146535278618102, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11462748897634446, "loser_reward": -0.13253813464101405, "reward_margin": 0.017910645664669586, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11462748897634446, "loser_reward": -0.15486847539572043, "reward_margin": 0.04024098641937597, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13253813464101405, "loser_reward": -0.15486847539572043, "reward_margin": 0.022330340754706385, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 32432, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 492, 368, 676], "component_score": 0.11151528978088754, "component_reward": -0.11151528978088754, "second_component_score": 0.11340312260953941, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0018878328286518753, "confidence": 0.5799205551497142}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5076291561126709, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4923708438873291}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.068423738080397, "reward": -0.068423738080397}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.06994969250308349, "reward": -0.06994969250308349}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.07103740429761819, "reward": -0.07103740429761819}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.09653707131650299, "reward": -0.09653707131650299}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.25996024315385147, "reward": -0.25996024315385147}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.068423738080397, "loser_reward": -0.09653707131650299, "reward_margin": 0.028113333236105986, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.068423738080397, "loser_reward": -0.25996024315385147, "reward_margin": 0.19153650507345446, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06994969250308349, "loser_reward": -0.09653707131650299, "reward_margin": 0.026587378813419507, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06994969250308349, "loser_reward": -0.25996024315385147, "reward_margin": 0.190010550650768, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07103740429761819, "loser_reward": -0.09653707131650299, "reward_margin": 0.0254996670188848, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07103740429761819, "loser_reward": -0.25996024315385147, "reward_margin": 0.1889228388562333, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09653707131650299, "loser_reward": -0.25996024315385147, "reward_margin": 0.16342317183734847, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 2650, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 554, 51, 627], "component_score": 0.068423738080397, "component_reward": -0.068423738080397, "second_component_score": 0.06994969250308349, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.001525954422686479, "confidence": 0.5891676646885986}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5244282484054565, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.47557178139686584}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.20105777828628196, "reward": -0.20105777828628196}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.20594730479200365, "reward": -0.20594730479200365}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.20614330403704662, "reward": -0.20614330403704662}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.23001243252214043, "reward": -0.23001243252214043}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2314435974243097, "reward": -0.2314435974243097}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20105777828628196, "loser_reward": -0.23001243252214043, "reward_margin": 0.028954654235858468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20105777828628196, "loser_reward": -0.2314435974243097, "reward_margin": 0.030385819138027736, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20594730479200365, "loser_reward": -0.23001243252214043, "reward_margin": 0.024065127730136776, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20594730479200365, "loser_reward": -0.2314435974243097, "reward_margin": 0.025496292632306045, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20614330403704662, "loser_reward": -0.23001243252214043, "reward_margin": 0.023869128485093816, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20614330403704662, "loser_reward": -0.2314435974243097, "reward_margin": 0.025300293387263084, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 82748, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 656, 447, 1024], "component_score": 0.20105777828628196, "component_reward": -0.20105777828628196, "second_component_score": 0.20594730479200365, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.004889526505721692, "confidence": 0.5926069327676244}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5890377759933472, "teacher_quality_score": 0.011910464156098899, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.011910464156098899, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11151528978088754, "loser_reward": -0.13253813464101405, "reward_margin": 0.02102284486012651, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11151528978088754, "loser_reward": -0.15486847539572043, "reward_margin": 0.043353185614832895, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11340312260953941, "loser_reward": -0.13253813464101405, "reward_margin": 0.019135012031474635, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11340312260953941, "loser_reward": -0.15486847539572043, "reward_margin": 0.04146535278618102, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11462748897634446, "loser_reward": -0.13253813464101405, "reward_margin": 0.017910645664669586, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11462748897634446, "loser_reward": -0.15486847539572043, "reward_margin": 0.04024098641937597, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13253813464101405, "loser_reward": -0.15486847539572043, "reward_margin": 0.022330340754706385, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.068423738080397, "loser_reward": -0.09653707131650299, "reward_margin": 0.028113333236105986, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.068423738080397, "loser_reward": -0.25996024315385147, "reward_margin": 0.19153650507345446, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06994969250308349, "loser_reward": -0.09653707131650299, "reward_margin": 0.026587378813419507, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06994969250308349, "loser_reward": -0.25996024315385147, "reward_margin": 0.190010550650768, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07103740429761819, "loser_reward": -0.09653707131650299, "reward_margin": 0.0254996670188848, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07103740429761819, "loser_reward": -0.25996024315385147, "reward_margin": 0.1889228388562333, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09653707131650299, "loser_reward": -0.25996024315385147, "reward_margin": 0.16342317183734847, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20105777828628196, "loser_reward": -0.23001243252214043, "reward_margin": 0.028954654235858468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20105777828628196, "loser_reward": -0.2314435974243097, "reward_margin": 0.030385819138027736, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20594730479200365, "loser_reward": -0.23001243252214043, "reward_margin": 0.024065127730136776, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20594730479200365, "loser_reward": -0.2314435974243097, "reward_margin": 0.025496292632306045, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20614330403704662, "loser_reward": -0.23001243252214043, "reward_margin": 0.023869128485093816, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "122927_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20614330403704662, "loser_reward": -0.2314435974243097, "reward_margin": 0.025300293387263084, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/122927_3/122927_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0850534439086914, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6352190375328064, "background_mse_to_source": 0.07523123174905777, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.39006564021110535, "background_mse_to_target": 0.07608933001756668, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07709664106369019, "input_change_l1": 0.24804413318634033, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7656781673431396, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1854665413033217, "edit_score": 0.2165900945663452, "background_score": 0.1972181037068367, "combined_score": 0.3304194032307714, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/122927_3/122927_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09483350068330765, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6888999938964844, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002674683928489685, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9679646492004395, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0033822215627878904, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013658732175827026, "input_change_l1": 0.017919545993208885, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5766249820590019, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02310500727035105, "edit_score": 0.2628972563892603, "background_score": 0.009081754088401794, "combined_score": 0.27206274499185384, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/122927_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09318438917398453, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6931519508361816, "background_mse_to_source": 0.001130054472014308, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9793217778205872, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0018338012741878629, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012098997831344604, "input_change_l1": 0.011647705920040607, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5766240060329437, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.014996891526971012, "edit_score": 0.2603979974985123, "background_score": 0.005265698907896877, "combined_score": 0.26645027020480483, "confidence": 0.5870487544411428}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/122927_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0968657061457634, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6858618855476379, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004148914013057947, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9601600766181946, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004859097767621279, "full_mse_to_target": 0.015198015607893467, "input_change_l1": 0.02234918437898159, "directional_pixel_score": 0.577968180179596, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.028850698308087883, "edit_score": 0.2652012839913368, "background_score": 0.012116898689419031, "combined_score": 0.2767321397550404, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/122927_3/122927_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09678365290164948, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6934106349945068, "background_mse_to_source": 0.016905982047319412, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7790738940238953, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01736072450876236, "full_mse_to_target": 0.026285583153367043, "input_change_l1": 0.0818924531340599, "directional_pixel_score": 0.562410481274128, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04729533931240439, "edit_score": 0.26749890558421613, "background_score": 0.06109120324254036, "combined_score": 0.30096845289692287, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/122927_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/122927_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/122927_3.json"}

125106_1

replace the chocolate with berries

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.03062400035560131, "dataset_mask_area": 0.030624, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.12670861184597015, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.005620082374662161, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.12108852947130799, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6668651738923297, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8832623442183309, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.48192098736763, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.23644284410712077, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.2658642399103041, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.26604340908270385, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.09513235837221146, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.12670861184597015, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7507963112077694, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.045127999037504196, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/125106_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6095641255378723, "qwen_image_edit": 0.3904358744621277}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1526810082799202, "reward": -0.1526810082799202}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1749550223236438, "reward": -0.1749550223236438}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1981437859951402, "reward": -0.1981437859951402}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.22358191062137486, "reward": -0.22358191062137486}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.23077617898955938, "reward": -0.23077617898955938}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1526810082799202, "loser_reward": -0.1749550223236438, "reward_margin": 0.02227401404372359, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1526810082799202, "loser_reward": -0.1981437859951402, "reward_margin": 0.045462777715220004, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1526810082799202, "loser_reward": -0.22358191062137486, "reward_margin": 0.07090090234145466, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1526810082799202, "loser_reward": -0.23077617898955938, "reward_margin": 0.07809517070963917, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1749550223236438, "loser_reward": -0.1981437859951402, "reward_margin": 0.023188763671496415, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1749550223236438, "loser_reward": -0.22358191062137486, "reward_margin": 0.04862688829773107, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1749550223236438, "loser_reward": -0.23077617898955938, "reward_margin": 0.05582115666591558, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1981437859951402, "loser_reward": -0.22358191062137486, "reward_margin": 0.025438124626234654, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1981437859951402, "loser_reward": -0.23077617898955938, "reward_margin": 0.03263239299441917, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 7656, "bbox_xyxy": [326, 383, 445, 466], "component_score": 0.1526810082799202, "component_reward": -0.1526810082799202, "second_component_score": 0.1749550223236438, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.02227401404372359, "confidence": 0.7612126656320217}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7612125873565674, "teacher_quality_score": 0.2658642399103041, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.2658642399103041, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1526810082799202, "loser_reward": -0.1749550223236438, "reward_margin": 0.02227401404372359, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1526810082799202, "loser_reward": -0.1981437859951402, "reward_margin": 0.045462777715220004, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1526810082799202, "loser_reward": -0.22358191062137486, "reward_margin": 0.07090090234145466, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1526810082799202, "loser_reward": -0.23077617898955938, "reward_margin": 0.07809517070963917, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1749550223236438, "loser_reward": -0.1981437859951402, "reward_margin": 0.023188763671496415, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1749550223236438, "loser_reward": -0.22358191062137486, "reward_margin": 0.04862688829773107, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1749550223236438, "loser_reward": -0.23077617898955938, "reward_margin": 0.05582115666591558, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1981437859951402, "loser_reward": -0.22358191062137486, "reward_margin": 0.025438124626234654, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1981437859951402, "loser_reward": -0.23077617898955938, "reward_margin": 0.03263239299441917, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/125106_1/125106_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06229524314403534, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.34354424476623535, "background_mse_to_source": 0.018184766173362732, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8659961819648743, "background_mse_to_target": 0.018065178766846657, "full_mse_to_target": 0.019419679418206215, "input_change_l1": 0.07692719995975494, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5283333733677864, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06585772670805454, "edit_score": 0.31150305084884167, "background_score": 0.044985529780387876, "combined_score": 0.34236149955540895, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/125106_1/125106_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05502312257885933, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3941740095615387, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00016579043585807085, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9967641234397888, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0003744913265109062, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0020480516832321882, "input_change_l1": 0.014119370840489864, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5785961225628853, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0320786364376545, "edit_score": 0.2815392900258303, "background_score": 0.0008129657479003072, "combined_score": 0.2884443604934495, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/125106_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03682508319616318, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.40316668152809143, "background_mse_to_source": 7.004645158303902e-05, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9986039996147156, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0003023684548679739, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0014208401553332806, "input_change_l1": 0.009177591651678085, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5785960853099823, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02118181609548628, "edit_score": 0.2615427255630493, "background_score": 0.00034924652863992377, "combined_score": 0.26604340908270385, "confidence": 0.6854606865414327}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/125106_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07354716211557388, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3758120536804199, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0002590410003904253, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9950017929077148, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0004508682759478688, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0026893692556768656, "input_change_l1": 0.017636723816394806, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5778582617640495, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03942878227680922, "edit_score": 0.3039201859384775, "background_score": 0.0012586824188474566, "combined_score": 0.31251541816600364, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/125106_1/125106_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.058880601078271866, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3131128251552582, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03240293264389038, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6462730765342712, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03201669827103615, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03283938020467758, "input_change_l1": 0.10760814696550369, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6160232499241829, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12165048979222776, "edit_score": 0.29225222356617453, "background_score": 0.10314831733703614, "combined_score": 0.35596817061305047, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/125106_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/125106_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/125106_1.json"}

125106_2

add a lizard on the counter

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.013036727905273438, "dataset_mask_area": 0.013036727905273438, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.16739752888679504, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.000706775113940239, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1666907537728548, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8524460289166171, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8973521439988881, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.46992769837379456, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.30487836300280435, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.01009002775438148, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.1624453864200041, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.03228729963302612, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.16739752888679504, "edit_change_ratio": 0.19287799436311195, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.1567544937133789, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9364205956671341}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.019405364990234375, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/125106_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1173615427946206, "reward": -0.1173615427946206}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.14274190992023794, "reward": -0.14274190992023794}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.16680396884994114, "reward": -0.16680396884994114}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16793508760596162, "reward": -0.16793508760596162}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1687644460560987, "reward": -0.1687644460560987}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "125106_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1173615427946206, "loser_reward": -0.14274190992023794, "reward_margin": 0.025380367125617337, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1173615427946206, "loser_reward": -0.16680396884994114, "reward_margin": 0.04944242605532054, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1173615427946206, "loser_reward": -0.16793508760596162, "reward_margin": 0.05057354481134102, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1173615427946206, "loser_reward": -0.1687644460560987, "reward_margin": 0.05140290326147809, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.14274190992023794, "loser_reward": -0.16680396884994114, "reward_margin": 0.0240620589297032, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14274190992023794, "loser_reward": -0.16793508760596162, "reward_margin": 0.025193177685723683, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14274190992023794, "loser_reward": -0.1687644460560987, "reward_margin": 0.026022536135860752, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 13670, "bbox_xyxy": [318, 918, 548, 1023], "component_score": 0.1173615427946206, "component_reward": -0.1173615427946206, "second_component_score": 0.14274190992023794, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.025380367125617337, "confidence": 0.8251496455322209}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8251495957374573, "teacher_quality_score": 0.01009002775438148, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.01009002775438148, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "125106_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1173615427946206, "loser_reward": -0.14274190992023794, "reward_margin": 0.025380367125617337, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1173615427946206, "loser_reward": -0.16680396884994114, "reward_margin": 0.04944242605532054, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1173615427946206, "loser_reward": -0.16793508760596162, "reward_margin": 0.05057354481134102, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1173615427946206, "loser_reward": -0.1687644460560987, "reward_margin": 0.05140290326147809, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.14274190992023794, "loser_reward": -0.16680396884994114, "reward_margin": 0.0240620589297032, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14274190992023794, "loser_reward": -0.16793508760596162, "reward_margin": 0.025193177685723683, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14274190992023794, "loser_reward": -0.1687644460560987, "reward_margin": 0.026022536135860752, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/125106_2/125106_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03392326086759567, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6212252974510193, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05752343684434891, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4350297152996063, "background_mse_to_target": 0.057562071830034256, "full_mse_to_target": 0.057253893464803696, "input_change_l1": 0.16602462530136108, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7548394501209259, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10394595330581069, "edit_score": 0.17096833884716034, "background_score": 0.17051749378442765, "combined_score": 0.25716404167935253, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/125106_2/125106_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.039854224771261215, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6484050154685974, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0024183650966733694, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9198141694068909, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002444673329591751, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0029323699418455362, "input_change_l1": 0.018696259707212448, "directional_pixel_score": 0.23333409428596497, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0063734779134392745, "edit_score": 0.3018396981060505, "background_score": 0.018455531215295196, "combined_score": 0.3098670666082762, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/125106_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.039163339883089066, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6480352282524109, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0010217592353001237, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9372854828834534, "background_mse_to_target": 0.001048952341079712, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0015458391280844808, "input_change_l1": 0.012152557261288166, "directional_pixel_score": 0.23333385586738586, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.004194194125011564, "edit_score": 0.3012228302657604, "background_score": 0.01356466265860945, "combined_score": 0.30696388493408444, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/125106_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04035951569676399, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6484319567680359, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0036380612291395664, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9121413230895996, "background_mse_to_target": 0.003663737326860428, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004142129793763161, "input_change_l1": 0.02321053110063076, "directional_pixel_score": 0.2333337366580963, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.007893937535118311, "edit_score": 0.3023396901786327, "background_score": 0.021209796611219644, "combined_score": 0.3117561194789596, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/125106_2/125106_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.026710964739322662, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6496020555496216, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012897824868559837, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7741921544075012, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012904370203614235, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013084364123642445, "input_change_l1": 0.0743696317076683, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8477290868759155, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02978940100874752, "edit_score": 0.1348582819104195, "background_score": 0.058059393987059595, "combined_score": 0.1624453864200041, "confidence": 0.9550905615206318}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/125106_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/125106_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/125106_2.json"}

125106_3

let the plate contain ice cream

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.047088623046875, "dataset_mask_area": 0.047088623046875, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.31236889958381653, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0004547324206214398, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3119141671631951, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9459459459459459, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9925725860904794, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.43653470277786255, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.46513058412032776, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.012564813688650247, "best_expert": "pix2pix", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3879294125176966, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.08872388303279877, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.31236889958381653, "edit_change_ratio": 0.28403558469172085, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.30494311451911926, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9762275147282877}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.061150550842285156, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/125106_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.53476482629776, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4652351438999176}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.27293482224363835, "reward": -0.27293482224363835}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2798990383852797, "reward": -0.2798990383852797}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.3044131004550727, "reward": -0.3044131004550727}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.30803055045101796, "reward": -0.30803055045101796}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.3265292243824806, "reward": -0.3265292243824806}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "125106_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.27293482224363835, "loser_reward": -0.3044131004550727, "reward_margin": 0.03147827821143434, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.27293482224363835, "loser_reward": -0.30803055045101796, "reward_margin": 0.035095728207379606, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.27293482224363835, "loser_reward": -0.3265292243824806, "reward_margin": 0.053594402138842256, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2798990383852797, "loser_reward": -0.3044131004550727, "reward_margin": 0.024514062069793008, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2798990383852797, "loser_reward": -0.30803055045101796, "reward_margin": 0.028131512065738273, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2798990383852797, "loser_reward": -0.3265292243824806, "reward_margin": 0.046630185997200924, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3044131004550727, "loser_reward": -0.3265292243824806, "reward_margin": 0.022116123927407916, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.30803055045101796, "loser_reward": -0.3265292243824806, "reward_margin": 0.01849867393146265, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 49376, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 674, 316, 946], "component_score": 0.27293482224363835, "component_reward": -0.27293482224363835, "second_component_score": 0.2798990383852797, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.006964216141641333, "confidence": 0.5946388157111513}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5946388244628906, "teacher_quality_score": 0.012564813688650247, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.012564813688650247, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "125106_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.27293482224363835, "loser_reward": -0.3044131004550727, "reward_margin": 0.03147827821143434, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.27293482224363835, "loser_reward": -0.30803055045101796, "reward_margin": 0.035095728207379606, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.27293482224363835, "loser_reward": -0.3265292243824806, "reward_margin": 0.053594402138842256, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2798990383852797, "loser_reward": -0.3044131004550727, "reward_margin": 0.024514062069793008, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2798990383852797, "loser_reward": -0.30803055045101796, "reward_margin": 0.028131512065738273, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2798990383852797, "loser_reward": -0.3265292243824806, "reward_margin": 0.046630185997200924, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3044131004550727, "loser_reward": -0.3265292243824806, "reward_margin": 0.022116123927407916, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "125106_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.30803055045101796, "loser_reward": -0.3265292243824806, "reward_margin": 0.01849867393146265, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/125106_3/125106_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1537391096353531, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5838658213615417, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03789234161376953, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6143231391906738, "background_mse_to_target": 0.037900928407907486, "full_mse_to_target": 0.043355584144592285, "input_change_l1": 0.1397697478532791, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6399013996124268, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08171779410913588, "edit_score": 0.326990595459938, "background_score": 0.11502771377563477, "combined_score": 0.3879294125176966, "confidence": 0.6461667725172635}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/125106_3/125106_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.20894205570220947, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6556858420372009, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00031354144448414445, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9969027638435364, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0003307333099655807, "full_mse_to_target": 0.010153952054679394, "input_change_l1": 0.012723669409751892, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3959592431783676, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.021722571668215094, "edit_score": 0.42881507650017736, "background_score": 0.0009329886757768691, "combined_score": 0.4345015320758102, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/125106_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.18589530885219574, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.652947723865509, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00013247125025372952, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9987330436706543, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00015047889610286802, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008896948769688606, "input_change_l1": 0.008270383812487125, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3959592878818512, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.014232185296714306, "edit_score": 0.40631594210863115, "background_score": 0.00038586251612287014, "combined_score": 0.41018712592558587, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/125106_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.22733178734779358, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6407965421676636, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0004898839397355914, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9953075051307678, "background_mse_to_target": 0.000506491051055491, "full_mse_to_target": 0.011187379248440266, "input_change_l1": 0.015837155282497406, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3933732211589813, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.026690711406990884, "edit_score": 0.4508291736245155, "background_score": 0.001428382913582027, "combined_score": 0.45778598785051144, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/125106_3/125106_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1854824274778366, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6027986407279968, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010336903855204582, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7685623168945312, "background_mse_to_target": 0.010348929092288017, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01859571598470211, "input_change_l1": 0.07006046175956726, "directional_pixel_score": 0.46095823496580124, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.041795377153903246, "edit_score": 0.3996831405907869, "background_score": 0.05662444047629833, "combined_score": 0.4297203417867422, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/125106_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/125106_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/125106_3.json"}

129062_1

Add a cat falling out of a tree.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.02473199926316738, "dataset_mask_area": 0.024732, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.23128607869148254, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.019346747547388077, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.21193933114409447, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.24146625290923196, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.2564234591421657, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.382257878780365, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.25117221985888893, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.014572159208164522, "best_expert": "pix2pix", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.34295340616256, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.045107025653123856, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.23128607869148254, "edit_change_ratio": 0.1950269809074548, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.21743300557136536, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9401041636466322}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.03960400074720383, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/129062_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.5345668196678162, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.46543318033218384}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.24337234272062777, "reward": -0.24337234272062777}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2502967393365689, "reward": -0.2502967393365689}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2522820199411362, "reward": -0.2522820199411362}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.25357793093565845, "reward": -0.25357793093565845}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.26352635249868034, "reward": -0.26352635249868034}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "129062_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24337234272062777, "loser_reward": -0.25357793093565845, "reward_margin": 0.010205588215030675, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24337234272062777, "loser_reward": -0.26352635249868034, "reward_margin": 0.020154009778052567, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2502967393365689, "loser_reward": -0.26352635249868034, "reward_margin": 0.013229613162111464, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2522820199411362, "loser_reward": -0.26352635249868034, "reward_margin": 0.011244332557544146, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 6183, "bbox_xyxy": [399, 54, 494, 144], "component_score": 0.24337234272062777, "component_reward": -0.24337234272062777, "second_component_score": 0.2502967393365689, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.006924396615941103, "confidence": 0.599594272297544}], "teacher_confidence": 0.599594235420227, "teacher_quality_score": 0.014572159208164522, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.014572159208164522, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "129062_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24337234272062777, "loser_reward": -0.25357793093565845, "reward_margin": 0.010205588215030675, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24337234272062777, "loser_reward": -0.26352635249868034, "reward_margin": 0.020154009778052567, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2502967393365689, "loser_reward": -0.26352635249868034, "reward_margin": 0.013229613162111464, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2522820199411362, "loser_reward": -0.26352635249868034, "reward_margin": 0.011244332557544146, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/129062_1/129062_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09774595499038696, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.39277997612953186, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017554156482219696, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8016807436943054, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01489250548183918, "full_mse_to_target": 0.016941634938120842, "input_change_l1": 0.08542695641517639, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6573013067245483, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08184153437614441, "edit_score": 0.3048646330833435, "background_score": 0.05721800774335861, "combined_score": 0.34295340616256, "confidence": 0.6644906064664471}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/129062_1/129062_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10886026173830032, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.40119901299476624, "background_mse_to_source": 0.013007407076656818, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9124372601509094, "background_mse_to_target": 0.013079862110316753, "full_mse_to_target": 0.015448701567947865, "input_change_l1": 0.040022410452365875, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4795560035854578, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.021142059937119484, "edit_score": 0.35873145824298264, "background_score": 0.030519955046474933, "combined_score": 0.37518672465346753, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129062_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1078021377325058, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.40337061882019043, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0054956283420324326, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9423608183860779, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005943447817116976, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008462616242468357, "input_change_l1": 0.026014558970928192, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4795560035854578, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.013825142243877053, "edit_score": 0.35723901307210326, "background_score": 0.017023464664816856, "combined_score": 0.36680851577781143, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129062_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10978984087705612, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.398965448141098, "background_mse_to_source": 0.018305093050003052, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8991222381591797, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01812092214822769, "full_mse_to_target": 0.020388072356581688, "input_change_l1": 0.04894431680440903, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4796898905187845, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02629968179389834, "edit_score": 0.3600742786191404, "background_score": 0.03848064541816712, "combined_score": 0.38084124810993675, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/129062_1/129062_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10949884355068207, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3838482201099396, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03296031802892685, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5899561047554016, "background_mse_to_target": 0.029600955545902252, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03157699108123779, "input_change_l1": 0.11932452768087387, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6128617078065872, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09135117866098881, "edit_score": 0.32951377257704734, "background_score": 0.11496909707784653, "combined_score": 0.3911808913946152, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/129062_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/129062_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/129062_1.json"}

129062_2

Put a wedding cake on one of the tables.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.02495098114013672, "dataset_mask_area": 0.02495098114013672, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.1669023185968399, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0004372418625280261, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.16646507673431188, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7758881058535884, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9290080936800413, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3804328143596649, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.2967319731839442, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.013484513565563247, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2526640005549416, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.04610437899827957, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.1669023185968399, "edit_change_ratio": 0.2762357011327493, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.15815170109272003, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9475704257574912}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.03494453430175781, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/129062_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5863389372825623, "qwen_image_edit": 0.41366106271743774}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.14920299253566188, "reward": -0.14920299253566188}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16664554234500972, "reward": -0.16664554234500972}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.18083618032652884, "reward": -0.18083618032652884}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.20651267594099046, "reward": -0.20651267594099046}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.24177339148148894, "reward": -0.24177339148148894}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14920299253566188, "loser_reward": -0.16664554234500972, "reward_margin": 0.01744254980934784, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14920299253566188, "loser_reward": -0.18083618032652884, "reward_margin": 0.03163318779086696, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14920299253566188, "loser_reward": -0.20651267594099046, "reward_margin": 0.057309683405328576, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14920299253566188, "loser_reward": -0.24177339148148894, "reward_margin": 0.09257039894582705, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16664554234500972, "loser_reward": -0.18083618032652884, "reward_margin": 0.014190637981519122, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16664554234500972, "loser_reward": -0.20651267594099046, "reward_margin": 0.039867133595980736, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16664554234500972, "loser_reward": -0.24177339148148894, "reward_margin": 0.07512784913647921, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18083618032652884, "loser_reward": -0.20651267594099046, "reward_margin": 0.025676495614461614, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18083618032652884, "loser_reward": -0.24177339148148894, "reward_margin": 0.06093721115496009, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20651267594099046, "loser_reward": -0.24177339148148894, "reward_margin": 0.03526071554049848, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 26163, "bbox_xyxy": [448, 736, 654, 944], "component_score": 0.14920299253566188, "component_reward": -0.14920299253566188, "second_component_score": 0.16664554234500972, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.01744254980934784, "confidence": 0.7281158031030768}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7281158566474915, "teacher_quality_score": 0.013484513565563247, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.013484513565563247, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14920299253566188, "loser_reward": -0.16664554234500972, "reward_margin": 0.01744254980934784, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14920299253566188, "loser_reward": -0.18083618032652884, "reward_margin": 0.03163318779086696, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14920299253566188, "loser_reward": -0.20651267594099046, "reward_margin": 0.057309683405328576, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14920299253566188, "loser_reward": -0.24177339148148894, "reward_margin": 0.09257039894582705, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16664554234500972, "loser_reward": -0.18083618032652884, "reward_margin": 0.014190637981519122, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16664554234500972, "loser_reward": -0.20651267594099046, "reward_margin": 0.039867133595980736, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16664554234500972, "loser_reward": -0.24177339148148894, "reward_margin": 0.07512784913647921, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18083618032652884, "loser_reward": -0.20651267594099046, "reward_margin": 0.025676495614461614, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18083618032652884, "loser_reward": -0.24177339148148894, "reward_margin": 0.06093721115496009, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20651267594099046, "loser_reward": -0.24177339148148894, "reward_margin": 0.03526071554049848, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/129062_2/129062_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0998617634177208, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5673015713691711, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0909777283668518, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3540588617324829, "background_mse_to_target": 0.09098496288061142, "full_mse_to_target": 0.09120643883943558, "input_change_l1": 0.23824496567249298, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6659060716629028, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16615443490445614, "edit_score": 0.26992493122816086, "background_score": 0.22016595602035524, "combined_score": 0.38933454670011997, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/129062_2/129062_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06537866592407227, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5731372237205505, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0025758589617908, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9846064448356628, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0025755800306797028, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004142578691244125, "input_change_l1": 0.020529991015791893, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5841394513845444, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0666137283667922, "edit_score": 0.25471635833382605, "background_score": 0.005654569994658232, "combined_score": 0.27043246137443927, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129062_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05529611557722092, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5831523537635803, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0010883002541959286, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9895034432411194, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0011007384164258838, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0024529658257961273, "input_change_l1": 0.013344497419893742, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5841394811868668, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.043361326912418015, "edit_score": 0.24263077452778817, "background_score": 0.0031876116059720515, "combined_score": 0.2526640005549416, "confidence": 0.6656171680149162}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129062_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07501120865345001, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5670063495635986, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0035025468096137047, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9816579222679138, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0034944270737469196, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005278839264065027, "input_change_l1": 0.02529126964509487, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5845746919512749, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08122177375480533, "edit_score": 0.26546626575291155, "background_score": 0.007170962356030941, "combined_score": 0.28474834125488996, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/129062_2/129062_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0726989284157753, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5401067733764648, "background_mse_to_source": 0.025154028087854385, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5852319598197937, "background_mse_to_target": 0.025162847712635994, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02634892426431179, "input_change_l1": 0.11712443828582764, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6123087704181671, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10497790351510047, "edit_score": 0.26160038113594053, "background_score": 0.10810763612389565, "combined_score": 0.32306852690875526, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/129062_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/129062_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/129062_2.json"}

129062_3

Put a fountain in front of the restaurant.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.07395458221435547, "dataset_mask_area": 0.07395458221435547, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.28640568256378174, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00731355044990778, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.27909213211387396, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8240055419841762, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.934734055753164, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3726763129234314, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.41536215938210164, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.016425807161976988, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.4210124951787293, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.01552452053874731, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.28640562295913696, "edit_change_ratio": 0.05420466392505945, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.2788728177547455, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9736988222278505}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.09032726287841797, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/129062_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5049090385437012, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49509096145629883}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2987811135654337, "reward": -0.2987811135654337}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.29976295709051193, "reward": -0.29976295709051193}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.30022805209760556, "reward": -0.30022805209760556}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.30770189796481284, "reward": -0.30770189796481284}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.34061285948753356, "reward": -0.34061285948753356}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "129062_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2987811135654337, "loser_reward": -0.34061285948753356, "reward_margin": 0.04183174592209987, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.29976295709051193, "loser_reward": -0.34061285948753356, "reward_margin": 0.04084990239702163, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.30022805209760556, "loser_reward": -0.34061285948753356, "reward_margin": 0.040384807389928, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.30770189796481284, "loser_reward": -0.34061285948753356, "reward_margin": 0.032910961522720716, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 77547, "bbox_xyxy": [18, 615, 272, 1024], "component_score": 0.2987811135654337, "component_reward": -0.2987811135654337, "second_component_score": 0.29976295709051193, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.000981843525078241, "confidence": 0.5558953815116576}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5558953881263733, "teacher_quality_score": 0.016425807161976988, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.016425807161976988, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "129062_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2987811135654337, "loser_reward": -0.34061285948753356, "reward_margin": 0.04183174592209987, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.29976295709051193, "loser_reward": -0.34061285948753356, "reward_margin": 0.04084990239702163, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.30022805209760556, "loser_reward": -0.34061285948753356, "reward_margin": 0.040384807389928, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129062_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.30770189796481284, "loser_reward": -0.34061285948753356, "reward_margin": 0.032910961522720716, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/129062_3/129062_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15790434181690216, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.26514732837677, "background_mse_to_source": 0.10017780214548111, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.36149635910987854, "background_mse_to_target": 0.10028067231178284, "full_mse_to_target": 0.10454219579696655, "input_change_l1": 0.24079036712646484, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6649751663208008, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14659169465303423, "edit_score": 0.388631084561348, "background_score": 0.2278785303235054, "combined_score": 0.5081611286848784, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/129062_3/129062_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14501316845417023, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.300216943025589, "background_mse_to_source": 0.016251305118203163, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8833608031272888, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01644919253885746, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02595708519220352, "input_change_l1": 0.052922725677490234, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4966830820776522, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.017479948652908205, "edit_score": 0.4107990093296394, "background_score": 0.0395791444927454, "combined_score": 0.4307434081519023, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129062_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14381243288516998, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.30174750089645386, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00686617661267519, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9240705966949463, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0070823729038238525, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01719418540596962, "input_change_l1": 0.034399766474962234, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4966830760240555, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.011413464462384582, "edit_score": 0.4092921636998653, "background_score": 0.022052057273685935, "combined_score": 0.4210124951787293, "confidence": 0.5905534273395899}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129062_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14615857601165771, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.2986518144607544, "background_mse_to_source": 0.023831071332097054, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8643255233764648, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02401667833328247, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03304962068796158, "input_change_l1": 0.0652984157204628, "directional_pixel_score": 0.49672594643197954, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.021675984887406227, "edit_score": 0.41224672651151195, "background_score": 0.050965966656804085, "combined_score": 0.4377249738876708, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/129062_3/129062_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1470913589000702, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3179374635219574, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02343202382326126, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6410103440284729, "background_mse_to_target": 0.023441646248102188, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03258611261844635, "input_change_l1": 0.10942863672971725, "directional_pixel_score": 0.569132924079895, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0626633026637137, "edit_score": 0.39122063517570493, "background_score": 0.09522995501756669, "combined_score": 0.44034239122644064, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/129062_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/129062_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/129062_3.json"}

129587_1

He should be eating a watermelon

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.09342800080776215, "dataset_mask_area": 0.093428, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.1667606681585312, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.017193488776683807, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.14956717938184738, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.5656385497709031, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.6675134272027871, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.39605268836021423, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.24414434244246724, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.24152469656532052, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.24291241908533265, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.05425863340497017, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.16676065325737, "edit_change_ratio": 0.325368318875737, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1355919986963272, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/129587_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5643525123596191, "qwen_image_edit": 0.43564745783805847}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.14246006660390412, "reward": -0.14246006660390412}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1554023485726211, "reward": -0.1554023485726211}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1624286882511806, "reward": -0.1624286882511806}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.16594459380395712, "reward": -0.16594459380395712}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.34661340647749606, "reward": -0.34661340647749606}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14246006660390412, "loser_reward": -0.1554023485726211, "reward_margin": 0.012942281968716995, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14246006660390412, "loser_reward": -0.1624286882511806, "reward_margin": 0.019968621647276474, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14246006660390412, "loser_reward": -0.16594459380395712, "reward_margin": 0.023484527200053007, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14246006660390412, "loser_reward": -0.34661340647749606, "reward_margin": 0.20415333987359194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1554023485726211, "loser_reward": -0.16594459380395712, "reward_margin": 0.010542245231336012, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1554023485726211, "loser_reward": -0.34661340647749606, "reward_margin": 0.19121105790487494, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1624286882511806, "loser_reward": -0.34661340647749606, "reward_margin": 0.18418471822631546, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16594459380395712, "loser_reward": -0.34661340647749606, "reward_margin": 0.18066881267353893, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 23357, "bbox_xyxy": [55, 191, 219, 438], "component_score": 0.14246006660390412, "component_reward": -0.14246006660390412, "second_component_score": 0.1554023485726211, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.012942281968716995, "confidence": 0.6945985035922642}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6945985555648804, "teacher_quality_score": 0.24152469656532052, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.24152469656532052, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14246006660390412, "loser_reward": -0.1554023485726211, "reward_margin": 0.012942281968716995, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14246006660390412, "loser_reward": -0.1624286882511806, "reward_margin": 0.019968621647276474, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14246006660390412, "loser_reward": -0.16594459380395712, "reward_margin": 0.023484527200053007, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14246006660390412, "loser_reward": -0.34661340647749606, "reward_margin": 0.20415333987359194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1554023485726211, "loser_reward": -0.16594459380395712, "reward_margin": 0.010542245231336012, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1554023485726211, "loser_reward": -0.34661340647749606, "reward_margin": 0.19121105790487494, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1624286882511806, "loser_reward": -0.34661340647749606, "reward_margin": 0.18418471822631546, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16594459380395712, "loser_reward": -0.34661340647749606, "reward_margin": 0.18066881267353893, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/129587_1/129587_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.16576407849788666, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.47371235489845276, "background_mse_to_source": 0.10425598919391632, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3512525260448456, "background_mse_to_target": 0.1020384207367897, "full_mse_to_target": 0.10799218714237213, "input_change_l1": 0.267275333404541, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5754445791244507, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.22978294622153045, "edit_score": 0.3771604627370834, "background_score": 0.23400548398494722, "combined_score": 0.5158181900903582, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/129587_1/129587_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06113191321492195, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5506431460380554, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0009883352322503924, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9902663826942444, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00106798333581537, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006679636891931295, "input_change_l1": 0.023640919476747513, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6169006004929543, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03777125701308251, "edit_score": 0.24677813388407233, "background_score": 0.002935058693401516, "combined_score": 0.2560276195185725, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129587_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.052021574229002, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5543355345726013, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00041757154394872487, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9951899647712708, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0007591028697788715, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005548452027142048, "input_change_l1": 0.01536659523844719, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6169010475277901, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02472757971845567, "edit_score": 0.2369292054325342, "background_score": 0.0013795785896945746, "combined_score": 0.24291241908533265, "confidence": 0.6409371673810468}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129587_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06613517552614212, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5481109619140625, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0014706338988617063, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9862995147705078, "background_mse_to_target": 0.001364789786748588, "full_mse_to_target": 0.00741615379229188, "input_change_l1": 0.0290305707603693, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6185701787471771, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04492081990465522, "edit_score": 0.25187043845653534, "background_score": 0.0042107309447601445, "combined_score": 0.2630699736473616, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/129587_1/129587_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04967384412884712, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5584539771080017, "background_mse_to_source": 0.013223274610936642, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6451888084411621, "background_mse_to_target": 0.011115162633359432, "full_mse_to_target": 0.014717619866132736, "input_change_l1": 0.08363340049982071, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6875901371240616, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07585284411907196, "edit_score": 0.2160855144262314, "background_score": 0.08418551292270422, "combined_score": 0.2621927747596055, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/129587_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/129587_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/129587_1.json"}

129587_2

Could he be in the forest?

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.23651123046875, "dataset_mask_area": 0.23651123046875, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.17939817905426025, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.004112748429179192, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.17528543062508106, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.778462123372303, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9316361816361817, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3906991183757782, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.30596633269520473, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.15522626534948358, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.19288142940960823, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1548079252243042, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.17939816415309906, "edit_change_ratio": 0.8629292610385385, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.2806663513183594, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/129587_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1039888968518935, "reward": -0.1039888968518935}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1505503808464855, "reward": -0.1505503808464855}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.15921680091787127, "reward": -0.15921680091787127}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.1921053887149319, "reward": -0.1921053887149319}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19726477429177613, "reward": -0.19726477429177613}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1039888968518935, "loser_reward": -0.1505503808464855, "reward_margin": 0.04656148399459201, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1039888968518935, "loser_reward": -0.15921680091787127, "reward_margin": 0.05522790406597777, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1039888968518935, "loser_reward": -0.1921053887149319, "reward_margin": 0.08811649186303841, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1039888968518935, "loser_reward": -0.19726477429177613, "reward_margin": 0.09327587743988264, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1505503808464855, "loser_reward": -0.1921053887149319, "reward_margin": 0.0415550078684464, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1505503808464855, "loser_reward": -0.19726477429177613, "reward_margin": 0.04671439344529063, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15921680091787127, "loser_reward": -0.1921053887149319, "reward_margin": 0.03288858779706064, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15921680091787127, "loser_reward": -0.19726477429177613, "reward_margin": 0.038047973373904864, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 231695, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 0, 1024, 736], "component_score": 0.1039888968518935, "component_reward": -0.1039888968518935, "second_component_score": 0.1505503808464855, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.04656148399459201, "confidence": 0.9300819208889561}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5897587537765503, "pix2pix": 0.4102412164211273}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.12423311898624524, "reward": -0.12423311898624524}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.14238152883853764, "reward": -0.14238152883853764}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.15712564199138432, "reward": -0.15712564199138432}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1744111393895, "reward": -0.1744111393895}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.22480068370606748, "reward": -0.22480068370606748}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "129587_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12423311898624524, "loser_reward": -0.14238152883853764, "reward_margin": 0.018148409852292394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12423311898624524, "loser_reward": -0.15712564199138432, "reward_margin": 0.03289252300513908, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12423311898624524, "loser_reward": -0.1744111393895, "reward_margin": 0.05017802040325477, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12423311898624524, "loser_reward": -0.22480068370606748, "reward_margin": 0.10056756471982224, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14238152883853764, "loser_reward": -0.15712564199138432, "reward_margin": 0.014744113152846683, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14238152883853764, "loser_reward": -0.1744111393895, "reward_margin": 0.03202961055096237, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14238152883853764, "loser_reward": -0.22480068370606748, "reward_margin": 0.08241915486752985, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15712564199138432, "loser_reward": -0.1744111393895, "reward_margin": 0.01728549739811569, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15712564199138432, "loser_reward": -0.22480068370606748, "reward_margin": 0.06767504171468317, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1744111393895, "loser_reward": -0.22480068370606748, "reward_margin": 0.050389544316567475, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 16305, "bbox_xyxy": [352, 464, 561, 598], "component_score": 0.12423311898624524, "component_reward": -0.12423311898624524, "second_component_score": 0.14238152883853764, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.018148409852292394, "confidence": 0.7614237197040061}], "teacher_confidence": 0.9189936518669128, "teacher_quality_score": 0.15522626534948358, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.15522626534948358, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1039888968518935, "loser_reward": -0.1505503808464855, "reward_margin": 0.04656148399459201, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1039888968518935, "loser_reward": -0.15921680091787127, "reward_margin": 0.05522790406597777, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1039888968518935, "loser_reward": -0.1921053887149319, "reward_margin": 0.08811649186303841, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1039888968518935, "loser_reward": -0.19726477429177613, "reward_margin": 0.09327587743988264, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1505503808464855, "loser_reward": -0.1921053887149319, "reward_margin": 0.0415550078684464, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1505503808464855, "loser_reward": -0.19726477429177613, "reward_margin": 0.04671439344529063, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15921680091787127, "loser_reward": -0.1921053887149319, "reward_margin": 0.03288858779706064, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15921680091787127, "loser_reward": -0.19726477429177613, "reward_margin": 0.038047973373904864, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12423311898624524, "loser_reward": -0.14238152883853764, "reward_margin": 0.018148409852292394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12423311898624524, "loser_reward": -0.15712564199138432, "reward_margin": 0.03289252300513908, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12423311898624524, "loser_reward": -0.1744111393895, "reward_margin": 0.05017802040325477, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12423311898624524, "loser_reward": -0.22480068370606748, "reward_margin": 0.10056756471982224, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14238152883853764, "loser_reward": -0.15712564199138432, "reward_margin": 0.014744113152846683, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14238152883853764, "loser_reward": -0.1744111393895, "reward_margin": 0.03202961055096237, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14238152883853764, "loser_reward": -0.22480068370606748, "reward_margin": 0.08241915486752985, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15712564199138432, "loser_reward": -0.1744111393895, "reward_margin": 0.01728549739811569, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15712564199138432, "loser_reward": -0.22480068370606748, "reward_margin": 0.06767504171468317, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1744111393895, "loser_reward": -0.22480068370606748, "reward_margin": 0.050389544316567475, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/129587_2/129587_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07338052988052368, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7173507809638977, "background_mse_to_source": 0.10475756227970123, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.541466236114502, "background_mse_to_target": 0.10505569726228714, "full_mse_to_target": 0.09756410121917725, "input_change_l1": 0.23765438795089722, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6142648532986641, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13642196049913766, "edit_score": 0.2263441603630781, "background_score": 0.19646431505680084, "combined_score": 0.33214747285470364, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/129587_2/129587_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07603852450847626, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7447971701622009, "background_mse_to_source": 0.038937877863645554, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5257992148399353, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03930310904979706, "full_mse_to_target": 0.047991424798965454, "input_change_l1": 0.17556001245975494, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7799606621265411, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14355015140026808, "edit_score": 0.1820889249444008, "background_score": 0.13377803489565848, "combined_score": 0.26242040991783144, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129587_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04604773968458176, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7736389636993408, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01645125448703766, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7187898755073547, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01683546043932438, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0237444881349802, "input_change_l1": 0.11411405354738235, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7799593210220337, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09367108060978353, "edit_score": 0.14633011668920518, "background_score": 0.07269327938556672, "combined_score": 0.19288142940960823, "confidence": 0.8968503290296073}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129587_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11063481867313385, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7225351333618164, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06040073558688164, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.42468926310539246, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06075098738074303, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07254912704229355, "input_change_l1": 0.21876585483551025, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7813222110271454, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1784130974672735, "edit_score": 0.22079723924398423, "background_score": 0.17546288296580315, "combined_score": 0.32514678047969936, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/129587_2/129587_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06349368393421173, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.739855945110321, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012858889065682888, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6649823784828186, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012970796786248684, "full_mse_to_target": 0.024920031428337097, "input_change_l1": 0.0859471783041954, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6078803613781929, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07550009367987515, "edit_score": 0.2135524045675993, "background_score": 0.07986241336911917, "combined_score": 0.25909627112559974, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/129587_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/129587_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/129587_2.json"}

129587_3

Put a pond next to the elephant

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.1828756332397461, "dataset_mask_area": 0.1828756332397461, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.22542013227939606, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0017632474191486835, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.22365688486024737, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9070431312633811, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9615595680179868, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.37429121136665344, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3709644433325726, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.23145487839996348, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2789445962756872, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.13115540146827698, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.22542017698287964, "edit_change_ratio": 0.581826361879922, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.20157814025878906, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/129587_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5638025999069214, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4361974000930786}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.16233524946402758, "reward": -0.16233524946402758}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.17516571739129722, "reward": -0.17516571739129722}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1943354569412768, "reward": -0.1943354569412768}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19891989058256151, "reward": -0.19891989058256151}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2197526534125209, "reward": -0.2197526534125209}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.16233524946402758, "loser_reward": -0.17516571739129722, "reward_margin": 0.012830467927269634, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16233524946402758, "loser_reward": -0.1943354569412768, "reward_margin": 0.032000207477249215, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16233524946402758, "loser_reward": -0.19891989058256151, "reward_margin": 0.036584641118533934, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16233524946402758, "loser_reward": -0.2197526534125209, "reward_margin": 0.05741740394849332, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17516571739129722, "loser_reward": -0.1943354569412768, "reward_margin": 0.01916973954997958, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17516571739129722, "loser_reward": -0.19891989058256151, "reward_margin": 0.0237541731912643, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17516571739129722, "loser_reward": -0.2197526534125209, "reward_margin": 0.04458693602122368, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1943354569412768, "loser_reward": -0.2197526534125209, "reward_margin": 0.025417196471244102, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19891989058256151, "loser_reward": -0.2197526534125209, "reward_margin": 0.020832762829959384, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 191759, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 452, 528, 1024], "component_score": 0.16233524946402758, "component_reward": -0.16233524946402758, "second_component_score": 0.17516571739129722, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.012830467927269634, "confidence": 0.678198149587706}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6781980991363525, "teacher_quality_score": 0.23145487839996348, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.23145487839996348, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.16233524946402758, "loser_reward": -0.17516571739129722, "reward_margin": 0.012830467927269634, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16233524946402758, "loser_reward": -0.1943354569412768, "reward_margin": 0.032000207477249215, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16233524946402758, "loser_reward": -0.19891989058256151, "reward_margin": 0.036584641118533934, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16233524946402758, "loser_reward": -0.2197526534125209, "reward_margin": 0.05741740394849332, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17516571739129722, "loser_reward": -0.1943354569412768, "reward_margin": 0.01916973954997958, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17516571739129722, "loser_reward": -0.19891989058256151, "reward_margin": 0.0237541731912643, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17516571739129722, "loser_reward": -0.2197526534125209, "reward_margin": 0.04458693602122368, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1943354569412768, "loser_reward": -0.2197526534125209, "reward_margin": 0.025417196471244102, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "129587_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19891989058256151, "loser_reward": -0.2197526534125209, "reward_margin": 0.020832762829959384, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/129587_3/129587_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08086594939231873, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5336711406707764, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06358718872070312, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4171701967716217, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06340767443180084, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06660040467977524, "input_change_l1": 0.1883259415626526, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6374337673187256, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12634386941790582, "edit_score": 0.26477327942848206, "background_score": 0.18015314936637877, "combined_score": 0.3597556960582733, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/129587_3/129587_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06281112134456635, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5498073101043701, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0512155257165432, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.34288540482521057, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05111642926931381, "full_mse_to_target": 0.053255122154951096, "input_change_l1": 0.16514189541339874, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7287706732749939, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1460897630080581, "edit_score": 0.22065699100494385, "background_score": 0.1826384447515011, "combined_score": 0.31912391148507596, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129587_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05885818600654602, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5179848074913025, "background_mse_to_source": 0.021638551726937294, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6221259236335754, "background_mse_to_target": 0.021636661142110825, "full_mse_to_target": 0.028443580493330956, "input_change_l1": 0.10734227299690247, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7287710756063461, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0950355208478868, "edit_score": 0.223068455606699, "background_score": 0.0972133670002222, "combined_score": 0.2789445962756872, "confidence": 0.6371129312903511}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/129587_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07085996866226196, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5087995529174805, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0797232910990715, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.18975694477558136, "background_mse_to_target": 0.07955530285835266, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07796517759561539, "input_change_l1": 0.20625483989715576, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7289195358753204, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1809420481324196, "edit_score": 0.23687017410993577, "background_score": 0.24177190214395525, "combined_score": 0.36547526724636553, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/129587_3/129587_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06551279127597809, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.46617475152015686, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012161380611360073, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6679558753967285, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012217083014547825, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02196357399225235, "input_change_l1": 0.08920818567276001, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6928699016571045, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07282671052962542, "edit_score": 0.24906036555767058, "background_score": 0.07857020553201437, "combined_score": 0.2933216369990259, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/129587_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/129587_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/129587_3.json"}

130518_1

remove the computer and add a coffee machine

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.11310400068759918, "dataset_mask_area": 0.113104, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.25265422463417053, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0053369770757853985, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.24731724755838513, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8517999384636422, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9623421266077015, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.41009438037872314, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.38802692523833027, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.2208498857452469, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.22946210229536518, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1855764538049698, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.25265422463417053, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7345076223192956, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.15020400285720825, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/130518_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.15639519962156193, "reward": -0.15639519962156193}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.19109398948866874, "reward": -0.19109398948866874}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2068756202692166, "reward": -0.2068756202692166}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.22711717171035709, "reward": -0.22711717171035709}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.24478866646438838, "reward": -0.24478866646438838}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15639519962156193, "loser_reward": -0.19109398948866874, "reward_margin": 0.03469878986710681, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15639519962156193, "loser_reward": -0.2068756202692166, "reward_margin": 0.05048042064765468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15639519962156193, "loser_reward": -0.22711717171035709, "reward_margin": 0.07072197208879516, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15639519962156193, "loser_reward": -0.24478866646438838, "reward_margin": 0.08839346684282645, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19109398948866874, "loser_reward": -0.2068756202692166, "reward_margin": 0.015781630780547867, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19109398948866874, "loser_reward": -0.22711717171035709, "reward_margin": 0.03602318222168835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19109398948866874, "loser_reward": -0.24478866646438838, "reward_margin": 0.05369467697571964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2068756202692166, "loser_reward": -0.22711717171035709, "reward_margin": 0.020241551441140482, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2068756202692166, "loser_reward": -0.24478866646438838, "reward_margin": 0.03791304619517177, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22711717171035709, "loser_reward": -0.24478866646438838, "reward_margin": 0.01767149475403129, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 28276, "bbox_xyxy": [117, 71, 358, 257], "component_score": 0.15639519962156193, "component_reward": -0.15639519962156193, "second_component_score": 0.19109398948866874, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.03469878986710681, "confidence": 0.8293635895145229}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8293637633323669, "teacher_quality_score": 0.2208498857452469, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.2208498857452469, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15639519962156193, "loser_reward": -0.19109398948866874, "reward_margin": 0.03469878986710681, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15639519962156193, "loser_reward": -0.2068756202692166, "reward_margin": 0.05048042064765468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15639519962156193, "loser_reward": -0.22711717171035709, "reward_margin": 0.07072197208879516, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15639519962156193, "loser_reward": -0.24478866646438838, "reward_margin": 0.08839346684282645, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19109398948866874, "loser_reward": -0.2068756202692166, "reward_margin": 0.015781630780547867, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19109398948866874, "loser_reward": -0.22711717171035709, "reward_margin": 0.03602318222168835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19109398948866874, "loser_reward": -0.24478866646438838, "reward_margin": 0.05369467697571964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2068756202692166, "loser_reward": -0.22711717171035709, "reward_margin": 0.020241551441140482, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2068756202692166, "loser_reward": -0.24478866646438838, "reward_margin": 0.03791304619517177, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22711717171035709, "loser_reward": -0.24478866646438838, "reward_margin": 0.01767149475403129, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/130518_1/130518_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09877930581569672, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5446881055831909, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03415066376328468, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.606574535369873, "background_mse_to_target": 0.034037984907627106, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04136049002408981, "input_change_l1": 0.1451505869626999, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7264202237129211, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12810593228787184, "edit_score": 0.25823662877082826, "background_score": 0.11283575668931008, "combined_score": 0.3274863790720702, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/130518_1/130518_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10659410804510117, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6192889213562012, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005212449003010988, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9412036538124084, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00543973920866847, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0168807003647089, "input_change_l1": 0.061851244419813156, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7921499609947205, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10596436988562345, "edit_score": 0.23469883352518084, "background_score": 0.0169717182405293, "combined_score": 0.26351987892296164, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/130518_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07355021685361862, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5686067342758179, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0022022586781531572, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9715463519096375, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00244666519574821, "full_mse_to_target": 0.010488757863640785, "input_change_l1": 0.040203310549259186, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7921501696109772, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06929676504805685, "edit_score": 0.21179132759571076, "background_score": 0.007892988296225667, "combined_score": 0.22946210229536518, "confidence": 0.7639100914215675}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/130518_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14659368991851807, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5643540620803833, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008144444786012173, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9180879592895508, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008359510451555252, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02399434894323349, "input_change_l1": 0.07646453380584717, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7885507345199585, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12606428917497398, "edit_score": 0.2865851938724518, "background_score": 0.024526852928102017, "combined_score": 0.32278188512660566, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/130518_1/130518_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08715619146823883, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.518806517124176, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005030535627156496, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8494176864624023, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005072020925581455, "full_mse_to_target": 0.014356075786054134, "input_change_l1": 0.059109579771757126, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7224744558334351, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08009825441986324, "edit_score": 0.2527762740850449, "background_score": 0.03514699833467603, "combined_score": 0.28253298196475957, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/130518_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/130518_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/130518_1.json"}

130518_2

remove one chair

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.10031890869140625, "dataset_mask_area": 0.10031890869140625, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.1895756721496582, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00289968797005713, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.18667598417960107, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9236501623005532, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.960328174316462, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4305800497531891, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3359271306283259, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.09141550263026149, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.10917927694506943, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.11135724186897278, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.1895756870508194, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5874025493528678, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1371469497680664, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/130518_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5085586905479431, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4914413094520569}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.04981754385889507, "reward": -0.04981754385889507}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.05152944579860194, "reward": -0.05152944579860194}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.0634061943043489, "reward": -0.0634061943043489}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.12019457115232944, "reward": -0.12019457115232944}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.15528269999916663, "reward": -0.15528269999916663}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.04981754385889507, "loser_reward": -0.0634061943043489, "reward_margin": 0.013588650445453834, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04981754385889507, "loser_reward": -0.12019457115232944, "reward_margin": 0.07037702729343437, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04981754385889507, "loser_reward": -0.15528269999916663, "reward_margin": 0.10546515614027156, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.05152944579860194, "loser_reward": -0.0634061943043489, "reward_margin": 0.011876748505746965, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05152944579860194, "loser_reward": -0.12019457115232944, "reward_margin": 0.0686651253537275, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.05152944579860194, "loser_reward": -0.15528269999916663, "reward_margin": 0.10375325420056469, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0634061943043489, "loser_reward": -0.12019457115232944, "reward_margin": 0.056788376847980535, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0634061943043489, "loser_reward": -0.15528269999916663, "reward_margin": 0.09187650569481773, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12019457115232944, "loser_reward": -0.15528269999916663, "reward_margin": 0.035088128846837194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 64807, "bbox_xyxy": [677, 457, 1013, 851], "component_score": 0.04981754385889507, "component_reward": -0.04981754385889507, "second_component_score": 0.05152944579860194, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0017119019397068697, "confidence": 0.6094496989328732}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.5831648111343384, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.41683512926101685}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.11695815144479273, "reward": -0.11695815144479273}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.13374710371973925, "reward": -0.13374710371973925}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.13567684275470673, "reward": -0.13567684275470673}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1369562209167052, "reward": -0.1369562209167052}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1574364452927839, "reward": -0.1574364452927839}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "130518_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.11695815144479273, "loser_reward": -0.13374710371973925, "reward_margin": 0.01678895227494652, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11695815144479273, "loser_reward": -0.13567684275470673, "reward_margin": 0.018718691309914007, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11695815144479273, "loser_reward": -0.1369562209167052, "reward_margin": 0.019998069471912475, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11695815144479273, "loser_reward": -0.1574364452927839, "reward_margin": 0.04047829384799116, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13374710371973925, "loser_reward": -0.1574364452927839, "reward_margin": 0.023689341573044642, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13567684275470673, "loser_reward": -0.1574364452927839, "reward_margin": 0.021759602538077155, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1369562209167052, "loser_reward": -0.1574364452927839, "reward_margin": 0.020480224376078687, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 8139, "bbox_xyxy": [561, 649, 722, 776], "component_score": 0.11695815144479273, "component_reward": -0.11695815144479273, "second_component_score": 0.13374710371973925, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.01678895227494652, "confidence": 0.7586988056299154}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.1847947415560484, "reward": -0.1847947415560484}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.28470870210346766, "reward": -0.28470870210346766}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.291730123014655, "reward": -0.291730123014655}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.30297176632122136, "reward": -0.30297176632122136}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.35200240172701885, "reward": -0.35200240172701885}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "130518_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1847947415560484, "loser_reward": -0.28470870210346766, "reward_margin": 0.09991396054741927, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1847947415560484, "loser_reward": -0.291730123014655, "reward_margin": 0.10693538145860662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1847947415560484, "loser_reward": -0.30297176632122136, "reward_margin": 0.11817702476517297, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1847947415560484, "loser_reward": -0.35200240172701885, "reward_margin": 0.16720766017097047, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.28470870210346766, "loser_reward": -0.30297176632122136, "reward_margin": 0.0182630642177537, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.28470870210346766, "loser_reward": -0.35200240172701885, "reward_margin": 0.0672936996235512, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.291730123014655, "loser_reward": -0.30297176632122136, "reward_margin": 0.011241643306566351, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.291730123014655, "loser_reward": -0.35200240172701885, "reward_margin": 0.06027227871236385, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.30297176632122136, "loser_reward": -0.35200240172701885, "reward_margin": 0.049030635405797496, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 2406, "bbox_xyxy": [811, 747, 895, 791], "component_score": 0.1847947415560484, "component_reward": -0.1847947415560484, "second_component_score": 0.28470870210346766, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.09991396054741927, "confidence": 0.948770414207039}, {"component_id": 3, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.513676643371582, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.48632335662841797}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.020742232093121857, "reward": -0.020742232093121857}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.023478239039191974, "reward": -0.023478239039191974}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.031327420403482395, "reward": -0.031327420403482395}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.06264649263024331, "reward": -0.06264649263024331}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.128814118944807, "reward": -0.128814118944807}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.020742232093121857, "loser_reward": -0.031327420403482395, "reward_margin": 0.010585188310360538, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.020742232093121857, "loser_reward": -0.06264649263024331, "reward_margin": 0.04190426053712146, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.020742232093121857, "loser_reward": -0.128814118944807, "reward_margin": 0.10807188685168513, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.023478239039191974, "loser_reward": -0.06264649263024331, "reward_margin": 0.03916825359105134, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.023478239039191974, "loser_reward": -0.128814118944807, "reward_margin": 0.10533587990561502, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.031327420403482395, "loser_reward": -0.06264649263024331, "reward_margin": 0.03131907222676092, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.031327420403482395, "loser_reward": -0.128814118944807, "reward_margin": 0.09748669854132459, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06264649263024331, "loser_reward": -0.128814118944807, "reward_margin": 0.06616762631456367, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 29840, "bbox_xyxy": [580, 795, 981, 993], "component_score": 0.020742232093121857, "component_reward": -0.020742232093121857, "second_component_score": 0.023478239039191974, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0027360069460701172, "confidence": 0.7457817251266436}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6674322485923767, "teacher_quality_score": 0.09141550263026149, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.09141550263026149, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.04981754385889507, "loser_reward": -0.0634061943043489, "reward_margin": 0.013588650445453834, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04981754385889507, "loser_reward": -0.12019457115232944, "reward_margin": 0.07037702729343437, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04981754385889507, "loser_reward": -0.15528269999916663, "reward_margin": 0.10546515614027156, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.05152944579860194, "loser_reward": -0.0634061943043489, "reward_margin": 0.011876748505746965, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05152944579860194, "loser_reward": -0.12019457115232944, "reward_margin": 0.0686651253537275, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.05152944579860194, "loser_reward": -0.15528269999916663, "reward_margin": 0.10375325420056469, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0634061943043489, "loser_reward": -0.12019457115232944, "reward_margin": 0.056788376847980535, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0634061943043489, "loser_reward": -0.15528269999916663, "reward_margin": 0.09187650569481773, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12019457115232944, "loser_reward": -0.15528269999916663, "reward_margin": 0.035088128846837194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.11695815144479273, "loser_reward": -0.13374710371973925, "reward_margin": 0.01678895227494652, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11695815144479273, "loser_reward": -0.13567684275470673, "reward_margin": 0.018718691309914007, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11695815144479273, "loser_reward": -0.1369562209167052, "reward_margin": 0.019998069471912475, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11695815144479273, "loser_reward": -0.1574364452927839, "reward_margin": 0.04047829384799116, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13374710371973925, "loser_reward": -0.1574364452927839, "reward_margin": 0.023689341573044642, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13567684275470673, "loser_reward": -0.1574364452927839, "reward_margin": 0.021759602538077155, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1369562209167052, "loser_reward": -0.1574364452927839, "reward_margin": 0.020480224376078687, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1847947415560484, "loser_reward": -0.28470870210346766, "reward_margin": 0.09991396054741927, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1847947415560484, "loser_reward": -0.291730123014655, "reward_margin": 0.10693538145860662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1847947415560484, "loser_reward": -0.30297176632122136, "reward_margin": 0.11817702476517297, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1847947415560484, "loser_reward": -0.35200240172701885, "reward_margin": 0.16720766017097047, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.28470870210346766, "loser_reward": -0.30297176632122136, "reward_margin": 0.0182630642177537, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.28470870210346766, "loser_reward": -0.35200240172701885, "reward_margin": 0.0672936996235512, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.291730123014655, "loser_reward": -0.30297176632122136, "reward_margin": 0.011241643306566351, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.291730123014655, "loser_reward": -0.35200240172701885, "reward_margin": 0.06027227871236385, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.30297176632122136, "loser_reward": -0.35200240172701885, "reward_margin": 0.049030635405797496, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.020742232093121857, "loser_reward": -0.031327420403482395, "reward_margin": 0.010585188310360538, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.020742232093121857, "loser_reward": -0.06264649263024331, "reward_margin": 0.04190426053712146, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.020742232093121857, "loser_reward": -0.128814118944807, "reward_margin": 0.10807188685168513, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.023478239039191974, "loser_reward": -0.06264649263024331, "reward_margin": 0.03916825359105134, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.023478239039191974, "loser_reward": -0.128814118944807, "reward_margin": 0.10533587990561502, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.031327420403482395, "loser_reward": -0.06264649263024331, "reward_margin": 0.03131907222676092, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.031327420403482395, "loser_reward": -0.128814118944807, "reward_margin": 0.09748669854132459, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "130518_2__region3__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06264649263024331, "loser_reward": -0.128814118944807, "reward_margin": 0.06616762631456367, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/130518_2/130518_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.033250872045755386, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8082286715507507, "background_mse_to_source": 0.028366172686219215, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5717483162879944, "background_mse_to_target": 0.028290726244449615, "full_mse_to_target": 0.028788311406970024, "input_change_l1": 0.13779495656490326, "directional_pixel_score": 0.824171394109726, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10535416342318057, "edit_score": 0.11556228920817375, "background_score": 0.11401650942862035, "combined_score": 0.17941773133352398, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/130518_2/130518_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.025502370670437813, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8383027911186218, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009982895106077194, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8549107909202576, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01008306909352541, "full_mse_to_target": 0.011629912070930004, "input_change_l1": 0.04956527054309845, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8674664795398712, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04678657702170313, "edit_score": 0.09097519256174565, "background_score": 0.039000736922025686, "combined_score": 0.11514575709588826, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/130518_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.02749737538397312, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8226833343505859, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004217774141579866, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9309422373771667, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0043475511483848095, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006669911090284586, "input_change_l1": 0.032217416912317276, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8674676418304443, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.030541117233224214, "edit_score": 0.09609379805624485, "background_score": 0.018029326666146518, "combined_score": 0.10917927694506943, "confidence": 0.6419570799235842}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/130518_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.029505882412195206, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8150138258934021, "background_mse_to_source": 0.015583103522658348, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8040072321891785, "background_mse_to_target": 0.015662144869565964, "full_mse_to_target": 0.017050933092832565, "input_change_l1": 0.06194692850112915, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8674680292606354, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05762173116672784, "edit_score": 0.09963610991835595, "background_score": 0.05478165708482266, "combined_score": 0.1320391294406727, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/130518_2/130518_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05223241448402405, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7094493508338928, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0019001523032784462, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9329342842102051, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002006908180192113, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007045472506433725, "input_change_l1": 0.027574872598052025, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6101686954498291, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02202394723426551, "edit_score": 0.20780037045478822, "background_score": 0.015313295461237431, "combined_score": 0.2182693605637178, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/130518_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/130518_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/130518_2.json"}

134290_1

turn her hair white

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.2515439987182617, "dataset_mask_area": 0.251544, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.3338787257671356, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.04508182778954506, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.28879689797759056, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.778519589499348, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8775744986817927, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.18431371450424194, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.15602873265743256, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4173222286647841, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.25952406150172463, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2765565520711243, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.11505449563264847, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.3338787853717804, "edit_change_ratio": 0.34459959923639083, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.37285199761390686, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/134290_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5793392658233643, "pix2pix": 0.42066076397895813}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2043767778472975, "reward": -0.2043767778472975}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.22037985170865432, "reward": -0.22037985170865432}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22103581835655495, "reward": -0.22103581835655495}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2777744110384956, "reward": -0.2777744110384956}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.3351044572275132, "reward": -0.3351044572275132}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "134290_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2043767778472975, "loser_reward": -0.22037985170865432, "reward_margin": 0.016003073861356826, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.2043767778472975, "loser_reward": -0.22103581835655495, "reward_margin": 0.016659040509257456, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2043767778472975, "loser_reward": -0.2777744110384956, "reward_margin": 0.0733976331911981, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2043767778472975, "loser_reward": -0.3351044572275132, "reward_margin": 0.1307276793802157, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22037985170865432, "loser_reward": -0.2777744110384956, "reward_margin": 0.05739455932984128, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22037985170865432, "loser_reward": -0.3351044572275132, "reward_margin": 0.11472460551885888, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22103581835655495, "loser_reward": -0.2777744110384956, "reward_margin": 0.05673859268194065, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22103581835655495, "loser_reward": -0.3351044572275132, "reward_margin": 0.11406863887095825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2777744110384956, "loser_reward": -0.3351044572275132, "reward_margin": 0.0573300461890176, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 60622, "bbox_xyxy": [112, 0, 500, 387], "component_score": 0.2043767778472975, "component_reward": -0.2043767778472975, "second_component_score": 0.22037985170865432, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.016003073861356826, "confidence": 0.677152576874762}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.21966404749918728, "reward": -0.21966404749918728}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.3523611288252286, "reward": -0.3523611288252286}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.4264663546779192, "reward": -0.4264663546779192}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.5341381188193335, "reward": -0.5341381188193335}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.6489005989711731, "reward": -0.6489005989711731}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "134290_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.21966404749918728, "loser_reward": -0.3523611288252286, "reward_margin": 0.1326970813260413, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21966404749918728, "loser_reward": -0.4264663546779192, "reward_margin": 0.20680230717873194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21966404749918728, "loser_reward": -0.5341381188193335, "reward_margin": 0.3144740713201462, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21966404749918728, "loser_reward": -0.6489005989711731, "reward_margin": 0.42923655147198586, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3523611288252286, "loser_reward": -0.4264663546779192, "reward_margin": 0.07410522585269064, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.3523611288252286, "loser_reward": -0.5341381188193335, "reward_margin": 0.1817769899941049, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3523611288252286, "loser_reward": -0.6489005989711731, "reward_margin": 0.29653947014594456, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.4264663546779192, "loser_reward": -0.5341381188193335, "reward_margin": 0.10767176414141427, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.4264663546779192, "loser_reward": -0.6489005989711731, "reward_margin": 0.22243424429325392, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.5341381188193335, "loser_reward": -0.6489005989711731, "reward_margin": 0.11476248015183965, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 1019, "bbox_xyxy": [371, 0, 408, 63], "component_score": 0.21966404749918728, "component_reward": -0.21966404749918728, "second_component_score": 0.3523611288252286, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.1326970813260413, "confidence": 0.9578321966912378}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.5242617726325989, "editar": 0.4757382571697235}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.10768335195863618, "reward": -0.10768335195863618}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.11253952368069439, "reward": -0.11253952368069439}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.11772845459310335, "reward": -0.11772845459310335}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.15152287592086944, "reward": -0.15152287592086944}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1858368180077523, "reward": -0.1858368180077523}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "134290_1__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.10768335195863618, "loser_reward": -0.11772845459310335, "reward_margin": 0.010045102634467173, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10768335195863618, "loser_reward": -0.15152287592086944, "reward_margin": 0.04383952396223326, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10768335195863618, "loser_reward": -0.1858368180077523, "reward_margin": 0.07815346604911613, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11253952368069439, "loser_reward": -0.15152287592086944, "reward_margin": 0.038983352240175045, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11253952368069439, "loser_reward": -0.1858368180077523, "reward_margin": 0.07329729432705792, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11772845459310335, "loser_reward": -0.15152287592086944, "reward_margin": 0.03379442132776608, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11772845459310335, "loser_reward": -0.1858368180077523, "reward_margin": 0.06810836341464896, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15152287592086944, "loser_reward": -0.1858368180077523, "reward_margin": 0.034313942086882876, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 1245, "bbox_xyxy": [421, 0, 487, 31], "component_score": 0.10768335195863618, "component_reward": -0.10768335195863618, "second_component_score": 0.11253952368069439, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.004856171722058211, "confidence": 0.6269091890087217}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6807060241699219, "teacher_quality_score": 0.25952406150172463, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.25952406150172463, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "134290_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2043767778472975, "loser_reward": -0.22037985170865432, "reward_margin": 0.016003073861356826, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.2043767778472975, "loser_reward": -0.22103581835655495, "reward_margin": 0.016659040509257456, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2043767778472975, "loser_reward": -0.2777744110384956, "reward_margin": 0.0733976331911981, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2043767778472975, "loser_reward": -0.3351044572275132, "reward_margin": 0.1307276793802157, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22037985170865432, "loser_reward": -0.2777744110384956, "reward_margin": 0.05739455932984128, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22037985170865432, "loser_reward": -0.3351044572275132, "reward_margin": 0.11472460551885888, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22103581835655495, "loser_reward": -0.2777744110384956, "reward_margin": 0.05673859268194065, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22103581835655495, "loser_reward": -0.3351044572275132, "reward_margin": 0.11406863887095825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2777744110384956, "loser_reward": -0.3351044572275132, "reward_margin": 0.0573300461890176, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.21966404749918728, "loser_reward": -0.3523611288252286, "reward_margin": 0.1326970813260413, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21966404749918728, "loser_reward": -0.4264663546779192, "reward_margin": 0.20680230717873194, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21966404749918728, "loser_reward": -0.5341381188193335, "reward_margin": 0.3144740713201462, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21966404749918728, "loser_reward": -0.6489005989711731, "reward_margin": 0.42923655147198586, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3523611288252286, "loser_reward": -0.4264663546779192, "reward_margin": 0.07410522585269064, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.3523611288252286, "loser_reward": -0.5341381188193335, "reward_margin": 0.1817769899941049, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3523611288252286, "loser_reward": -0.6489005989711731, "reward_margin": 0.29653947014594456, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.4264663546779192, "loser_reward": -0.5341381188193335, "reward_margin": 0.10767176414141427, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.4264663546779192, "loser_reward": -0.6489005989711731, "reward_margin": 0.22243424429325392, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.5341381188193335, "loser_reward": -0.6489005989711731, "reward_margin": 0.11476248015183965, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.10768335195863618, "loser_reward": -0.11772845459310335, "reward_margin": 0.010045102634467173, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10768335195863618, "loser_reward": -0.15152287592086944, "reward_margin": 0.04383952396223326, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10768335195863618, "loser_reward": -0.1858368180077523, "reward_margin": 0.07815346604911613, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11253952368069439, "loser_reward": -0.15152287592086944, "reward_margin": 0.038983352240175045, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11253952368069439, "loser_reward": -0.1858368180077523, "reward_margin": 0.07329729432705792, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11772845459310335, "loser_reward": -0.15152287592086944, "reward_margin": 0.03379442132776608, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11772845459310335, "loser_reward": -0.1858368180077523, "reward_margin": 0.06810836341464896, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15152287592086944, "loser_reward": -0.1858368180077523, "reward_margin": 0.034313942086882876, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/134290_1/134290_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11770240217447281, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7095838189125061, "background_mse_to_source": 0.020103849470615387, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8886518478393555, "background_mse_to_target": 0.028187261894345284, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05070427432656288, "input_change_l1": 0.12324666976928711, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7288530766963959, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1379769413266331, "edit_score": 0.24357236921787262, "background_score": 0.042373479902744295, "combined_score": 0.2910689028818161, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/134290_1/134290_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.16894885897636414, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.673021137714386, "background_mse_to_source": 0.043364763259887695, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8002942204475403, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05223758891224861, "full_mse_to_target": 0.08159559965133667, "input_change_l1": 0.154526025056839, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6880363672971725, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.20418719733133914, "edit_score": 0.3123355396091938, "background_score": 0.08330591917037963, "combined_score": 0.3904896107502282, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/134290_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13242216408252716, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6956050395965576, "background_mse_to_source": 0.018321610987186432, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8648844361305237, "background_mse_to_target": 0.026928529143333435, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05346481874585152, "input_change_l1": 0.10044194757938385, "directional_pixel_score": 0.688036635518074, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13298676307313143, "edit_score": 0.27129199728369713, "background_score": 0.0453447237610817, "combined_score": 0.31910648508928713, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/134290_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2115468978881836, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6561673283576965, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06615988165140152, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7663456797599792, "background_mse_to_target": 0.07524117082357407, "full_mse_to_target": 0.1095280721783638, "input_change_l1": 0.1918722540140152, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6887331604957581, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2528640417382121, "edit_score": 0.3581301420927048, "background_score": 0.11289074569940567, "combined_score": 0.45916751865297556, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/134290_1/134290_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10942624509334564, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7109832763671875, "background_mse_to_source": 0.016601495444774628, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7786479592323303, "background_mse_to_target": 0.023410513997077942, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04504723846912384, "input_change_l1": 0.1073850616812706, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7496599853038788, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10466034235432745, "edit_score": 0.22981459349393846, "background_score": 0.06087190359830857, "combined_score": 0.2765565520711243, "confidence": 0.6385746236739018}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/134290_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/134290_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/134290_1.json"}

134290_2

give her a skirt to wear

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.24353313446044922, "dataset_mask_area": 0.24353313446044922, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2695181667804718, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.002845579758286476, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2666725870221853, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9535357360931835, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9864270579298765, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3239891529083252, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4205539576705624, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.011848468740245153, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.30982703093439345, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.05887061730027199, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2695181667804718, "edit_change_ratio": 0.21842912484716973, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.26469260454177856, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9820955956463456}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.27795886993408203, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/134290_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5167186260223389, "qwen_image_edit": 0.48328131437301636}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.21465421077818603, "reward": -0.21465421077818603}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2179991945219226, "reward": -0.2179991945219226}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.22538971168361602, "reward": -0.22538971168361602}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2762376189432107, "reward": -0.2762376189432107}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.302161451060325, "reward": -0.302161451060325}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21465421077818603, "loser_reward": -0.22538971168361602, "reward_margin": 0.01073550090542999, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21465421077818603, "loser_reward": -0.2762376189432107, "reward_margin": 0.06158340816502467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21465421077818603, "loser_reward": -0.302161451060325, "reward_margin": 0.08750724028213896, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2179991945219226, "loser_reward": -0.2762376189432107, "reward_margin": 0.0582384244212881, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2179991945219226, "loser_reward": -0.302161451060325, "reward_margin": 0.0841622565384024, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22538971168361602, "loser_reward": -0.2762376189432107, "reward_margin": 0.05084790725959468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22538971168361602, "loser_reward": -0.302161451060325, "reward_margin": 0.07677173937670898, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2762376189432107, "loser_reward": -0.302161451060325, "reward_margin": 0.025923832117114298, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 255363, "bbox_xyxy": [426, 146, 887, 1024], "component_score": 0.21465421077818603, "component_reward": -0.21465421077818603, "second_component_score": 0.2179991945219226, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.003344983743736568, "confidence": 0.5775846002474784}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5775845050811768, "teacher_quality_score": 0.011848468740245153, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.011848468740245153, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21465421077818603, "loser_reward": -0.22538971168361602, "reward_margin": 0.01073550090542999, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21465421077818603, "loser_reward": -0.2762376189432107, "reward_margin": 0.06158340816502467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21465421077818603, "loser_reward": -0.302161451060325, "reward_margin": 0.08750724028213896, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2179991945219226, "loser_reward": -0.2762376189432107, "reward_margin": 0.0582384244212881, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2179991945219226, "loser_reward": -0.302161451060325, "reward_margin": 0.0841622565384024, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22538971168361602, "loser_reward": -0.2762376189432107, "reward_margin": 0.05084790725959468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22538971168361602, "loser_reward": -0.302161451060325, "reward_margin": 0.07677173937670898, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134290_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2762376189432107, "loser_reward": -0.302161451060325, "reward_margin": 0.025923832117114298, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/134290_2/134290_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14785216748714447, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4311884939670563, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04865815117955208, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5578694343566895, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04873950034379959, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07287672162055969, "input_change_l1": 0.17232583463191986, "directional_pixel_score": 0.653433695435524, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1344160567969084, "edit_score": 0.34825604483485223, "background_score": 0.1370842643082142, "combined_score": 0.4304064208641648, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/134290_2/134290_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11817429959774017, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4986434876918793, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005008549429476261, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9791156649589539, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0051642111502587795, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03268594294786453, "input_change_l1": 0.0331849530339241, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6764565408229828, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05093813189305365, "edit_score": 0.2993314668536186, "background_score": 0.00918541643768549, "combined_score": 0.3160025832802057, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/134290_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11898991465568542, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5071845054626465, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0021161106415092945, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9865301251411438, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002261221408843994, "full_mse_to_target": 0.030688541010022163, "input_change_l1": 0.021570218726992607, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6764586418867111, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03318146888632327, "edit_score": 0.29843835309147837, "background_score": 0.004810085613280534, "combined_score": 0.30982703093439345, "confidence": 0.5851054278739825}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/134290_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12069325149059296, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4874391555786133, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007808759808540344, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9740564227104187, "background_mse_to_target": 0.007972038350999355, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03542337566614151, "input_change_l1": 0.04143271967768669, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6766718626022339, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06344759073108434, "edit_score": 0.3040374547243118, "background_score": 0.012997475266456605, "combined_score": 0.3248184267804027, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/134290_2/134290_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1402590125799179, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4933743476867676, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00860599521547556, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8499576449394226, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008645734749734402, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04069792106747627, "input_change_l1": 0.06256188452243805, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5293715354055166, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.055527969961985946, "edit_score": 0.3592412591911852, "background_score": 0.03861446622759104, "combined_score": 0.38793170846998687, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/134290_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/134290_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/134290_2.json"}

134597_1

put a party hat on the dog

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.01947999931871891, "dataset_mask_area": 0.01948, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.3880052864551544, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.012586859986186028, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3754184264689684, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.3885419494976921, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.4099503437738732, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.2950977683067322, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4384414741596464, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+fallback_best_expert", "fusion_fallback": {"used": true, "reason": "fused_teacher_worse_than_best_expert", "fallback": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "teacher_combined_score": 0.25172068898740696, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.24597222392680124, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.18188296258449554, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.38800525665283203, "edit_change_ratio": 0.46876417127316256, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.039103999733924866, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/134597_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5746023058891296, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4253976345062256}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.19067404146445913, "reward": -0.19067404146445913}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.20570672920811922, "reward": -0.20570672920811922}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.22015924733970313, "reward": -0.22015924733970313}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.37045852113887673, "reward": -0.37045852113887673}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3758260526452214, "reward": -0.3758260526452214}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19067404146445913, "loser_reward": -0.20570672920811922, "reward_margin": 0.015032687743660095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19067404146445913, "loser_reward": -0.22015924733970313, "reward_margin": 0.029485205875244003, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19067404146445913, "loser_reward": -0.37045852113887673, "reward_margin": 0.1797844796744176, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19067404146445913, "loser_reward": -0.3758260526452214, "reward_margin": 0.18515201118076227, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20570672920811922, "loser_reward": -0.22015924733970313, "reward_margin": 0.014452518131583908, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20570672920811922, "loser_reward": -0.37045852113887673, "reward_margin": 0.1647517919307575, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20570672920811922, "loser_reward": -0.3758260526452214, "reward_margin": 0.17011932343710218, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22015924733970313, "loser_reward": -0.37045852113887673, "reward_margin": 0.1502992737991736, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22015924733970313, "loser_reward": -0.3758260526452214, "reward_margin": 0.15566680530551827, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4870, "bbox_xyxy": [281, 60, 420, 156], "component_score": 0.19067404146445913, "component_reward": -0.19067404146445913, "second_component_score": 0.20570672920811922, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.015032687743660095, "confidence": 0.6779180136858076}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6779179573059082, "teacher_quality_score": 0.24677270657615735, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.24677270657615735, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19067404146445913, "loser_reward": -0.20570672920811922, "reward_margin": 0.015032687743660095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19067404146445913, "loser_reward": -0.22015924733970313, "reward_margin": 0.029485205875244003, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19067404146445913, "loser_reward": -0.37045852113887673, "reward_margin": 0.1797844796744176, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19067404146445913, "loser_reward": -0.3758260526452214, "reward_margin": 0.18515201118076227, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20570672920811922, "loser_reward": -0.22015924733970313, "reward_margin": 0.014452518131583908, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20570672920811922, "loser_reward": -0.37045852113887673, "reward_margin": 0.1647517919307575, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20570672920811922, "loser_reward": -0.3758260526452214, "reward_margin": 0.17011932343710218, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22015924733970313, "loser_reward": -0.37045852113887673, "reward_margin": 0.1502992737991736, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22015924733970313, "loser_reward": -0.3758260526452214, "reward_margin": 0.15566680530551827, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/134597_1/134597_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2431032508611679, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6612765192985535, "background_mse_to_source": 0.022669566795229912, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.695306122303009, "background_mse_to_target": 0.021612126380205154, "full_mse_to_target": 0.025926776230335236, "input_change_l1": 0.09811799973249435, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7759572267532349, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.21433039084076883, "edit_score": 0.3668586403131485, "background_score": 0.0836083423346281, "combined_score": 0.44158031592145564, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/134597_1/134597_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12836922705173492, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6684320569038391, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004739320371299982, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9647555351257324, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004756574053317308, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007164544425904751, "input_change_l1": 0.02427726611495018, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8616984188556671, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13328592348843815, "edit_score": 0.22925821095705035, "background_score": 0.011788213346153497, "combined_score": 0.2607577247684822, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/134597_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12660135328769684, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6787890791893005, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002002362860366702, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9710330367088318, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002287448849529028, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004709084052592516, "input_change_l1": 0.015780219808220863, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8616983890533447, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08676930451765658, "edit_score": 0.22541894018650055, "background_score": 0.007795755518600345, "combined_score": 0.24597222392680124, "confidence": 0.6503488552884114}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/134597_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13704511523246765, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6666767001152039, "background_mse_to_source": 0.006663364823907614, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9604659080505371, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006499627139419317, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009042652323842049, "input_change_l1": 0.02939203940331936, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8644653260707855, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15615976862609388, "edit_score": 0.23759344369173052, "background_score": 0.014570183213800192, "combined_score": 0.27482922677416355, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/134597_1/134597_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.26216912269592285, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6371313333511353, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017508020624518394, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5590034127235413, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01657259650528431, "full_mse_to_target": 0.021356822922825813, "input_change_l1": 0.0887812152504921, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5531471222639084, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.061001463793218136, "edit_score": 0.4464560754597187, "background_score": 0.10570733807981014, "combined_score": 0.4977896188385785, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/134597_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/134597_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/134597_1.json"}

134597_2

make the frisbee blue

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.029314041137695312, "dataset_mask_area": 0.029314041137695312, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2929394841194153, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00023348222021013498, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.29270600189920515, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.974368045282048, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9883861286007894, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.29352256655693054, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4491656124770825, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.2574289217011688, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2646658166829729, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.29712149500846863, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.29293951392173767, "edit_change_ratio": 1.0142759200721834, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.03627967834472656, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/134597_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.19042736957105807, "reward": -0.19042736957105807}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2947145243631676, "reward": -0.2947145243631676}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.32928136353986337, "reward": -0.32928136353986337}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.33819997196923945, "reward": -0.33819997196923945}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.34776501293899487, "reward": -0.34776501293899487}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19042736957105807, "loser_reward": -0.2947145243631676, "reward_margin": 0.10428715479210951, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19042736957105807, "loser_reward": -0.32928136353986337, "reward_margin": 0.1388539939688053, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19042736957105807, "loser_reward": -0.33819997196923945, "reward_margin": 0.14777260239818138, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19042736957105807, "loser_reward": -0.34776501293899487, "reward_margin": 0.1573376433679368, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2947145243631676, "loser_reward": -0.32928136353986337, "reward_margin": 0.034566839176695785, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2947145243631676, "loser_reward": -0.33819997196923945, "reward_margin": 0.04348544760607187, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2947145243631676, "loser_reward": -0.34776501293899487, "reward_margin": 0.05305048857582728, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.32928136353986337, "loser_reward": -0.34776501293899487, "reward_margin": 0.018483649399131497, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 30738, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 356, 269, 492], "component_score": 0.19042736957105807, "component_reward": -0.19042736957105807, "second_component_score": 0.2947145243631676, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.10428715479210951, "confidence": 0.94988900511139}], "teacher_confidence": 0.9498891234397888, "teacher_quality_score": 0.2574289217011688, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.2574289217011688, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19042736957105807, "loser_reward": -0.2947145243631676, "reward_margin": 0.10428715479210951, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19042736957105807, "loser_reward": -0.32928136353986337, "reward_margin": 0.1388539939688053, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19042736957105807, "loser_reward": -0.33819997196923945, "reward_margin": 0.14777260239818138, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19042736957105807, "loser_reward": -0.34776501293899487, "reward_margin": 0.1573376433679368, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2947145243631676, "loser_reward": -0.32928136353986337, "reward_margin": 0.034566839176695785, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2947145243631676, "loser_reward": -0.33819997196923945, "reward_margin": 0.04348544760607187, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2947145243631676, "loser_reward": -0.34776501293899487, "reward_margin": 0.05305048857582728, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "134597_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.32928136353986337, "loser_reward": -0.34776501293899487, "reward_margin": 0.018483649399131497, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/134597_2/134597_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.18370117247104645, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.2945293188095093, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06018328294157982, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6931732296943665, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06019201502203941, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06381255388259888, "input_change_l1": 0.1672094315290451, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7851250767707825, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14009848837740718, "edit_score": 0.378514039516449, "background_score": 0.12154863700270653, "combined_score": 0.45545701553113765, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/134597_2/134597_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.18700335919857025, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.34685301780700684, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0006590854609385133, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9932413101196289, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006650766590610147, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0061274017207324505, "input_change_l1": 0.025083648040890694, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8284590840339661, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04969183302018792, "edit_score": 0.36051798462867735, "background_score": 0.002010823437012732, "combined_score": 0.37177287960774263, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/134597_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09606948494911194, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4068199098110199, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00027846352895721793, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9970384240150452, "background_mse_to_target": 0.000286287599010393, "full_mse_to_target": 0.003094080137088895, "input_change_l1": 0.016304370015859604, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8284590840339661, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03230452068382875, "edit_score": 0.2575907319784164, "background_score": 0.0008707787259481848, "combined_score": 0.2646658166829729, "confidence": 0.9183452714530402}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/134597_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.22251062095165253, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.31199443340301514, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0010040478082373738, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9899787902832031, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0010087299160659313, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007501841057091951, "input_change_l1": 0.029423417523503304, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8313971161842346, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0617644825251773, "edit_score": 0.4022624552249908, "background_score": 0.0030082897515967487, "combined_score": 0.41641843724879435, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/134597_2/134597_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.16402289271354675, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3324315845966339, "background_mse_to_source": 0.019137082621455193, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5897315144538879, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01914227195084095, "full_mse_to_target": 0.023389315232634544, "input_change_l1": 0.09535064548254013, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5702272057533264, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09088272233493627, "edit_score": 0.4049797743558884, "background_score": 0.10119077973067761, "combined_score": 0.46091202325187625, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/134597_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/134597_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/134597_2.json"}

13914_1

Let the elephant turn young.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.26420798897743225, "dataset_mask_area": 0.264208, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.23872675001621246, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.042666345834732056, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1960604041814804, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6772132088267515, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8301518784972023, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.1424836665391922, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.1829797923564911, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3105320643805787, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.22134663414501118, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.25134030223824083, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.08746052533388138, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.23872672021389008, "edit_change_ratio": 0.36636253057688756, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.411980003118515, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/13914_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5688514709472656, "qwen_image_edit": 0.43114855885505676}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.10178423152677714, "reward": -0.10178423152677714}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.11564256171137094, "reward": -0.11564256171137094}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.12955557093396783, "reward": -0.12955557093396783}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1443489743527025, "reward": -0.1443489743527025}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.35699163838662207, "reward": -0.35699163838662207}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10178423152677714, "loser_reward": -0.11564256171137094, "reward_margin": 0.0138583301845938, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10178423152677714, "loser_reward": -0.12955557093396783, "reward_margin": 0.02777133940719069, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10178423152677714, "loser_reward": -0.1443489743527025, "reward_margin": 0.04256474282592536, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10178423152677714, "loser_reward": -0.35699163838662207, "reward_margin": 0.25520740685984494, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11564256171137094, "loser_reward": -0.12955557093396783, "reward_margin": 0.01391300922259689, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11564256171137094, "loser_reward": -0.1443489743527025, "reward_margin": 0.028706412641331558, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11564256171137094, "loser_reward": -0.35699163838662207, "reward_margin": 0.24134907667525113, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12955557093396783, "loser_reward": -0.1443489743527025, "reward_margin": 0.014793403418734669, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12955557093396783, "loser_reward": -0.35699163838662207, "reward_margin": 0.22743606745265424, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1443489743527025, "loser_reward": -0.35699163838662207, "reward_margin": 0.21264266403391957, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 3138, "bbox_xyxy": [232, 56, 362, 120], "component_score": 0.10178423152677714, "component_reward": -0.10178423152677714, "second_component_score": 0.11564256171137094, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0138583301845938, "confidence": 0.7505754266922785}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5554197430610657, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4445802867412567}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.18365754691325129, "reward": -0.18365754691325129}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.19478721359185874, "reward": -0.19478721359185874}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.24901689025014637, "reward": -0.24901689025014637}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.29384846076741816, "reward": -0.29384846076741816}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3825484858397395, "reward": -0.3825484858397395}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "13914_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.18365754691325129, "loser_reward": -0.19478721359185874, "reward_margin": 0.011129666678607458, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.18365754691325129, "loser_reward": -0.24901689025014637, "reward_margin": 0.06535934333689508, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18365754691325129, "loser_reward": -0.29384846076741816, "reward_margin": 0.11019091385416688, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18365754691325129, "loser_reward": -0.3825484858397395, "reward_margin": 0.1988909389264882, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19478721359185874, "loser_reward": -0.24901689025014637, "reward_margin": 0.05422967665828762, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19478721359185874, "loser_reward": -0.29384846076741816, "reward_margin": 0.09906124717555942, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19478721359185874, "loser_reward": -0.3825484858397395, "reward_margin": 0.18776127224788075, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24901689025014637, "loser_reward": -0.29384846076741816, "reward_margin": 0.044831570517271796, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24901689025014637, "loser_reward": -0.3825484858397395, "reward_margin": 0.13353159558959313, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.29384846076741816, "loser_reward": -0.3825484858397395, "reward_margin": 0.08870002507232133, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 59601, "bbox_xyxy": [24, 125, 347, 500], "component_score": 0.18365754691325129, "component_reward": -0.18365754691325129, "second_component_score": 0.19478721359185874, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.011129666678607458, "confidence": 0.6510934789584832}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.08669216634146869, "reward": -0.08669216634146869}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.12060606907494367, "reward": -0.12060606907494367}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.13831093641370532, "reward": -0.13831093641370532}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.17303122416511174, "reward": -0.17303122416511174}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.25264354213513435, "reward": -0.25264354213513435}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08669216634146869, "loser_reward": -0.12060606907494367, "reward_margin": 0.033913902733474985, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.08669216634146869, "loser_reward": -0.13831093641370532, "reward_margin": 0.05161877007223663, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08669216634146869, "loser_reward": -0.17303122416511174, "reward_margin": 0.08633905782364305, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08669216634146869, "loser_reward": -0.25264354213513435, "reward_margin": 0.16595137579366565, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12060606907494367, "loser_reward": -0.13831093641370532, "reward_margin": 0.017704867338761643, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12060606907494367, "loser_reward": -0.17303122416511174, "reward_margin": 0.05242515509016807, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12060606907494367, "loser_reward": -0.25264354213513435, "reward_margin": 0.13203747306019067, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13831093641370532, "loser_reward": -0.17303122416511174, "reward_margin": 0.034720287751406426, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13831093641370532, "loser_reward": -0.25264354213513435, "reward_margin": 0.11433260572142903, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17303122416511174, "loser_reward": -0.25264354213513435, "reward_margin": 0.0796123179700226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 2061, "bbox_xyxy": [312, 350, 390, 481], "component_score": 0.08669216634146869, "component_reward": -0.08669216634146869, "second_component_score": 0.12060606907494367, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.033913902733474985, "confidence": 0.9141516670947916}, {"component_id": 3, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5149057507514954, "qwen_image_edit": 0.48509421944618225}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.06135945703275501, "reward": -0.06135945703275501}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.06434150197915733, "reward": -0.06434150197915733}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.07468176101706922, "reward": -0.07468176101706922}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.08460841105692089, "reward": -0.08460841105692089}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2802483992222697, "reward": -0.2802483992222697}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06135945703275501, "loser_reward": -0.07468176101706922, "reward_margin": 0.013322303984314207, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06135945703275501, "loser_reward": -0.08460841105692089, "reward_margin": 0.02324895402416588, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06135945703275501, "loser_reward": -0.2802483992222697, "reward_margin": 0.21888894218951466, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06434150197915733, "loser_reward": -0.07468176101706922, "reward_margin": 0.010340259037911886, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06434150197915733, "loser_reward": -0.08460841105692089, "reward_margin": 0.02026690907776356, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06434150197915733, "loser_reward": -0.2802483992222697, "reward_margin": 0.21590689724311235, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07468176101706922, "loser_reward": -0.2802483992222697, "reward_margin": 0.20556663820520046, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08460841105692089, "loser_reward": -0.2802483992222697, "reward_margin": 0.19563998816534878, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 647, "bbox_xyxy": [390, 446, 419, 500], "component_score": 0.06135945703275501, "component_reward": -0.06135945703275501, "second_component_score": 0.06434150197915733, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0029820449464023208, "confidence": 0.6324820294436609}, {"component_id": 4, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.21266309955529866, "reward": -0.21266309955529866}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.28317036494053904, "reward": -0.28317036494053904}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2963830194845796, "reward": -0.2963830194845796}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.31420169802755116, "reward": -0.31420169802755116}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.38527831122651696, "reward": -0.38527831122651696}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "13914_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21266309955529866, "loser_reward": -0.28317036494053904, "reward_margin": 0.07050726538524038, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21266309955529866, "loser_reward": -0.2963830194845796, "reward_margin": 0.08371991992928096, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21266309955529866, "loser_reward": -0.31420169802755116, "reward_margin": 0.1015385984722525, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21266309955529866, "loser_reward": -0.38527831122651696, "reward_margin": 0.1726152116712183, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.28317036494053904, "loser_reward": -0.2963830194845796, "reward_margin": 0.01321265454404058, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.28317036494053904, "loser_reward": -0.31420169802755116, "reward_margin": 0.031031333087012114, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.28317036494053904, "loser_reward": -0.38527831122651696, "reward_margin": 0.10210794628597791, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2963830194845796, "loser_reward": -0.31420169802755116, "reward_margin": 0.017818678542971533, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2963830194845796, "loser_reward": -0.38527831122651696, "reward_margin": 0.08889529174193733, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.31420169802755116, "loser_reward": -0.38527831122651696, "reward_margin": 0.0710766131989658, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 605, "bbox_xyxy": [450, 472, 500, 500], "component_score": 0.21266309955529866, "component_reward": -0.21266309955529866, "second_component_score": 0.28317036494053904, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.07050726538524038, "confidence": 0.8919532941515684}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6660516262054443, "teacher_quality_score": 0.22134663414501118, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.22134663414501118, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10178423152677714, "loser_reward": -0.11564256171137094, "reward_margin": 0.0138583301845938, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10178423152677714, "loser_reward": -0.12955557093396783, "reward_margin": 0.02777133940719069, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10178423152677714, "loser_reward": -0.1443489743527025, "reward_margin": 0.04256474282592536, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10178423152677714, "loser_reward": -0.35699163838662207, "reward_margin": 0.25520740685984494, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11564256171137094, "loser_reward": -0.12955557093396783, "reward_margin": 0.01391300922259689, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11564256171137094, "loser_reward": -0.1443489743527025, "reward_margin": 0.028706412641331558, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11564256171137094, "loser_reward": -0.35699163838662207, "reward_margin": 0.24134907667525113, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12955557093396783, "loser_reward": -0.1443489743527025, "reward_margin": 0.014793403418734669, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12955557093396783, "loser_reward": -0.35699163838662207, "reward_margin": 0.22743606745265424, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1443489743527025, "loser_reward": -0.35699163838662207, "reward_margin": 0.21264266403391957, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.18365754691325129, "loser_reward": -0.19478721359185874, "reward_margin": 0.011129666678607458, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.18365754691325129, "loser_reward": -0.24901689025014637, "reward_margin": 0.06535934333689508, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18365754691325129, "loser_reward": -0.29384846076741816, "reward_margin": 0.11019091385416688, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18365754691325129, "loser_reward": -0.3825484858397395, "reward_margin": 0.1988909389264882, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19478721359185874, "loser_reward": -0.24901689025014637, "reward_margin": 0.05422967665828762, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19478721359185874, "loser_reward": -0.29384846076741816, "reward_margin": 0.09906124717555942, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19478721359185874, "loser_reward": -0.3825484858397395, "reward_margin": 0.18776127224788075, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24901689025014637, "loser_reward": -0.29384846076741816, "reward_margin": 0.044831570517271796, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24901689025014637, "loser_reward": -0.3825484858397395, "reward_margin": 0.13353159558959313, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.29384846076741816, "loser_reward": -0.3825484858397395, "reward_margin": 0.08870002507232133, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08669216634146869, "loser_reward": -0.12060606907494367, "reward_margin": 0.033913902733474985, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.08669216634146869, "loser_reward": -0.13831093641370532, "reward_margin": 0.05161877007223663, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08669216634146869, "loser_reward": -0.17303122416511174, "reward_margin": 0.08633905782364305, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08669216634146869, "loser_reward": -0.25264354213513435, "reward_margin": 0.16595137579366565, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12060606907494367, "loser_reward": -0.13831093641370532, "reward_margin": 0.017704867338761643, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12060606907494367, "loser_reward": -0.17303122416511174, "reward_margin": 0.05242515509016807, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12060606907494367, "loser_reward": -0.25264354213513435, "reward_margin": 0.13203747306019067, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13831093641370532, "loser_reward": -0.17303122416511174, "reward_margin": 0.034720287751406426, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13831093641370532, "loser_reward": -0.25264354213513435, "reward_margin": 0.11433260572142903, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17303122416511174, "loser_reward": -0.25264354213513435, "reward_margin": 0.0796123179700226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06135945703275501, "loser_reward": -0.07468176101706922, "reward_margin": 0.013322303984314207, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06135945703275501, "loser_reward": -0.08460841105692089, "reward_margin": 0.02324895402416588, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06135945703275501, "loser_reward": -0.2802483992222697, "reward_margin": 0.21888894218951466, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06434150197915733, "loser_reward": -0.07468176101706922, "reward_margin": 0.010340259037911886, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06434150197915733, "loser_reward": -0.08460841105692089, "reward_margin": 0.02026690907776356, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06434150197915733, "loser_reward": -0.2802483992222697, "reward_margin": 0.21590689724311235, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07468176101706922, "loser_reward": -0.2802483992222697, "reward_margin": 0.20556663820520046, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region3__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08460841105692089, "loser_reward": -0.2802483992222697, "reward_margin": 0.19563998816534878, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21266309955529866, "loser_reward": -0.28317036494053904, "reward_margin": 0.07050726538524038, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21266309955529866, "loser_reward": -0.2963830194845796, "reward_margin": 0.08371991992928096, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21266309955529866, "loser_reward": -0.31420169802755116, "reward_margin": 0.1015385984722525, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21266309955529866, "loser_reward": -0.38527831122651696, "reward_margin": 0.1726152116712183, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.28317036494053904, "loser_reward": -0.2963830194845796, "reward_margin": 0.01321265454404058, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.28317036494053904, "loser_reward": -0.31420169802755116, "reward_margin": 0.031031333087012114, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.28317036494053904, "loser_reward": -0.38527831122651696, "reward_margin": 0.10210794628597791, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2963830194845796, "loser_reward": -0.31420169802755116, "reward_margin": 0.017818678542971533, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2963830194845796, "loser_reward": -0.38527831122651696, "reward_margin": 0.08889529174193733, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "13914_1__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.31420169802755116, "loser_reward": -0.38527831122651696, "reward_margin": 0.0710766131989658, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/13914_1/13914_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.19365958869457245, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.682269275188446, "background_mse_to_source": 0.1464354246854782, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.331714928150177, "background_mse_to_target": 0.1438186913728714, "full_mse_to_target": 0.1569870561361313, "input_change_l1": 0.3137581944465637, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5168861988931894, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.24318949282169344, "edit_score": 0.3779841839335859, "background_score": 0.2800924390554428, "combined_score": 0.5403531417809426, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/13914_1/13914_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12431804090738297, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7458782196044922, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04369032382965088, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.51727294921875, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04545697197318077, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06629268825054169, "input_change_l1": 0.16860926151275635, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5910230576992035, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13587585017085074, "edit_score": 0.27738663256168367, "background_score": 0.1402357339859009, "combined_score": 0.3602735783159733, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/13914_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08893434703350067, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7688464522361755, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01845915988087654, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7249760031700134, "background_mse_to_target": 0.021556023508310318, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03935791924595833, "input_change_l1": 0.10959599912166595, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5910231694579124, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08924266379326583, "edit_score": 0.23740926422178746, "background_score": 0.07346395924687385, "combined_score": 0.2849059746414423, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/13914_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1551377773284912, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7257307171821594, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06560301035642624, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3897048532962799, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06650818139314651, "full_mse_to_target": 0.08992484211921692, "input_change_l1": 0.20811960101127625, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5928117111325264, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16507412604987623, "edit_score": 0.3117887061089277, "background_score": 0.18766203969717027, "combined_score": 0.4194777294248342, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/13914_1/13914_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07380170375108719, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7804389595985413, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00947065930813551, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7396001815795898, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01271101925522089, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02885165810585022, "input_change_l1": 0.07826843857765198, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6164645999670029, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06657328270375729, "edit_score": 0.21359776183962823, "background_score": 0.061550622992217544, "combined_score": 0.25134030223824083, "confidence": 0.7476448630049752}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/13914_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/13914_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/13914_1.json"}

139276_1

What if the man had a hat?

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.0072639998979866505, "dataset_mask_area": 0.007264, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.3301301598548889, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.007894116453826427, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3222360434010625, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.4100701402805611, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.42932074482035143, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3188988268375397, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.38861729002754386, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.22809542954479187, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.23472877924519708, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.15923887491226196, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.3301301598548889, "edit_change_ratio": 0.48235179415978396, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.017683999612927437, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/139276_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1732641919805028, "reward": -0.1732641919805028}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.21528974222391845, "reward": -0.21528974222391845}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.21567928576224948, "reward": -0.21567928576224948}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.24580669794662388, "reward": -0.24580669794662388}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3467353639230132, "reward": -0.3467353639230132}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1732641919805028, "loser_reward": -0.21528974222391845, "reward_margin": 0.042025550243415644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1732641919805028, "loser_reward": -0.21567928576224948, "reward_margin": 0.04241509378174668, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1732641919805028, "loser_reward": -0.24580669794662388, "reward_margin": 0.07254250596612108, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1732641919805028, "loser_reward": -0.3467353639230132, "reward_margin": 0.17347117194251038, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21528974222391845, "loser_reward": -0.24580669794662388, "reward_margin": 0.030516955722705436, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21528974222391845, "loser_reward": -0.3467353639230132, "reward_margin": 0.13144562169909474, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21567928576224948, "loser_reward": -0.24580669794662388, "reward_margin": 0.030127412184374397, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21567928576224948, "loser_reward": -0.3467353639230132, "reward_margin": 0.1310560781607637, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24580669794662388, "loser_reward": -0.3467353639230132, "reward_margin": 0.1009286659763893, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 1816, "bbox_xyxy": [212, 102, 276, 156], "component_score": 0.1732641919805028, "component_reward": -0.1732641919805028, "second_component_score": 0.21528974222391845, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.042025550243415644, "confidence": 0.8439292611611764}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8439293503761292, "teacher_quality_score": 0.22809542954479187, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.22809542954479187, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1732641919805028, "loser_reward": -0.21528974222391845, "reward_margin": 0.042025550243415644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1732641919805028, "loser_reward": -0.21567928576224948, "reward_margin": 0.04241509378174668, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1732641919805028, "loser_reward": -0.24580669794662388, "reward_margin": 0.07254250596612108, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1732641919805028, "loser_reward": -0.3467353639230132, "reward_margin": 0.17347117194251038, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21528974222391845, "loser_reward": -0.24580669794662388, "reward_margin": 0.030516955722705436, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21528974222391845, "loser_reward": -0.3467353639230132, "reward_margin": 0.13144562169909474, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21567928576224948, "loser_reward": -0.24580669794662388, "reward_margin": 0.030127412184374397, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21567928576224948, "loser_reward": -0.3467353639230132, "reward_margin": 0.1310560781607637, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "139276_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24580669794662388, "loser_reward": -0.3467353639230132, "reward_margin": 0.1009286659763893, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/139276_1/139276_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11130470037460327, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.609100341796875, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0030070627108216286, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8934788107872009, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0025899745523929596, "full_mse_to_target": 0.003379678353667259, "input_change_l1": 0.03720198571681976, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8639245629310608, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12533085886389017, "edit_score": 0.22350349128246308, "background_score": 0.024311300553381446, "combined_score": 0.25741658608429135, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/139276_1/139276_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1294771283864975, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5766530632972717, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005666271899826825, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9858167767524719, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0009075540001504123, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0018414834048599005, "input_change_l1": 0.013258857652544975, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8442310392856598, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10754026714712381, "edit_score": 0.2530887559056282, "background_score": 0.0034032718394882977, "combined_score": 0.2759721028193598, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/139276_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09694170951843262, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5799158215522766, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00023939994571264833, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9913120269775391, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006237728521227837, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0013234263751655817, "input_change_l1": 0.008618260733783245, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8442310094833374, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0700184783898294, "edit_score": 0.21990079283714295, "background_score": 0.001976994550204836, "combined_score": 0.23472877924519708, "confidence": 0.702384228549884}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/139276_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.154292494058609, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5690305829048157, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0008238690788857639, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9816436767578125, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0011336476309224963, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0022461945191025734, "input_change_l1": 0.01629735343158245, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8485168218612671, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12581269331276418, "edit_score": 0.2783571720123291, "background_score": 0.004495133727323264, "combined_score": 0.3053176269313554, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/139276_1/139276_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.20199450850486755, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4609028398990631, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005807706154882908, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8686053156852722, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005229505244642496, "full_mse_to_target": 0.00665880786255002, "input_change_l1": 0.04361357167363167, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5764796659350395, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08987047392874956, "edit_score": 0.4156940240412951, "background_score": 0.032086643017828466, "combined_score": 0.44556432466953994, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/139276_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/139276_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/139276_1.json"}

140043_1

Let the jam be changed to strawberry one.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.019015999510884285, "dataset_mask_area": 0.019016, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2389206439256668, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00471119349822402, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2342094504274428, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6736002773444271, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.7928994082840237, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.48092731833457947, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.346757460040135, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.01524379120750382, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.30671550913248213, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.010663741268217564, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2389206439256668, "edit_change_ratio": 0.04463298396071323, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.22264954447746277, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9318974736512667}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.031383998692035675, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/140043_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5024722814559937, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49752768874168396}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.209978968327865, "reward": -0.209978968327865}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.21047343171341343, "reward": -0.21047343171341343}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.21076985663175582, "reward": -0.21076985663175582}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2376842697933316, "reward": -0.2376842697933316}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.32056010938622054, "reward": -0.32056010938622054}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.209978968327865, "loser_reward": -0.2376842697933316, "reward_margin": 0.027705301465466597, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.209978968327865, "loser_reward": -0.32056010938622054, "reward_margin": 0.11058114105835554, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21047343171341343, "loser_reward": -0.2376842697933316, "reward_margin": 0.02721083807991817, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21047343171341343, "loser_reward": -0.32056010938622054, "reward_margin": 0.11008667767280711, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21076985663175582, "loser_reward": -0.2376842697933316, "reward_margin": 0.02691441316157578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21076985663175582, "loser_reward": -0.32056010938622054, "reward_margin": 0.10979025275446472, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2376842697933316, "loser_reward": -0.32056010938622054, "reward_margin": 0.08287583959288894, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4754, "bbox_xyxy": [348, 256, 437, 346], "component_score": 0.209978968327865, "component_reward": -0.209978968327865, "second_component_score": 0.21047343171341343, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0004944633855484271, "confidence": 0.5542285989251611}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5542286038398743, "teacher_quality_score": 0.01524379120750382, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.01524379120750382, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.209978968327865, "loser_reward": -0.2376842697933316, "reward_margin": 0.027705301465466597, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.209978968327865, "loser_reward": -0.32056010938622054, "reward_margin": 0.11058114105835554, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21047343171341343, "loser_reward": -0.2376842697933316, "reward_margin": 0.02721083807991817, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21047343171341343, "loser_reward": -0.32056010938622054, "reward_margin": 0.11008667767280711, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21076985663175582, "loser_reward": -0.2376842697933316, "reward_margin": 0.02691441316157578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21076985663175582, "loser_reward": -0.32056010938622054, "reward_margin": 0.10979025275446472, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140043_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2376842697933316, "loser_reward": -0.32056010938622054, "reward_margin": 0.08287583959288894, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/140043_1/140043_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15077649056911469, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.45491161942481995, "background_mse_to_source": 0.10079988092184067, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.2979259192943573, "background_mse_to_target": 0.1000976637005806, "full_mse_to_target": 0.1010613739490509, "input_change_l1": 0.2579152584075928, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7436383813619614, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.23856804613023996, "edit_score": 0.32388457134366033, "background_score": 0.24121469706296922, "combined_score": 0.4661294619366526, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/140043_1/140043_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09590251743793488, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5403284430503845, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01315025519579649, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9003422856330872, "background_mse_to_target": 0.013189046643674374, "full_mse_to_target": 0.014761929400265217, "input_change_l1": 0.035522788763046265, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5572142191231251, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.012071249261498452, "edit_score": 0.2985332740470767, "background_score": 0.03308179806917906, "combined_score": 0.3140023461636156, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/140043_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09617132693529129, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5402163863182068, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005555985029786825, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9481871724128723, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005708825774490833, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007429060991853476, "input_change_l1": 0.023089809343218803, "directional_pixel_score": 0.557214193046093, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.007883044658228755, "edit_score": 0.2988245014101267, "background_score": 0.015918550547212362, "combined_score": 0.30671550913248213, "confidence": 0.5916517972180949}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/140043_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09577476233243942, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5401867628097534, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017857620492577553, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8801242709159851, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01783149689435959, "full_mse_to_target": 0.019313661381602287, "input_change_l1": 0.04255980625748634, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5572142228484154, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.015045852959156036, "edit_score": 0.2984338540583849, "background_score": 0.04183276630938053, "combined_score": 0.3180158589966595, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/140043_1/140043_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09798966348171234, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4917110204696655, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01702365279197693, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7179797291755676, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01686098985373974, "full_mse_to_target": 0.018403735011816025, "input_change_l1": 0.0875697061419487, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6889506876468658, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12956346049904824, "edit_score": 0.27740978747606276, "background_score": 0.0734277069568634, "combined_score": 0.33086255051195623, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/140043_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/140043_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/140043_1.json"}

140513_1

edit some mountains in the background

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.2558079957962036, "dataset_mask_area": 0.255808, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.25182297825813293, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.03655017912387848, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.21527279913425446, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7681537731371618, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8774455871801005, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.16339869797229767, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.34901437163352966, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3425490753979179, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.12035478739941026, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.15737013309728357, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1509457528591156, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.25182297825813293, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5994121501668033, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.3412480056285858, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/140513_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5539920330047607, "qwen_image_edit": 0.44600799679756165}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.09587488382961602, "reward": -0.09587488382961602}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.10671554934605955, "reward": -0.10671554934605955}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.13484654221124945, "reward": -0.13484654221124945}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.13834083815477788, "reward": -0.13834083815477788}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.1465639476981014, "reward": -0.1465639476981014}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09587488382961602, "loser_reward": -0.10671554934605955, "reward_margin": 0.010840665516443526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09587488382961602, "loser_reward": -0.13484654221124945, "reward_margin": 0.038971658381633426, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09587488382961602, "loser_reward": -0.13834083815477788, "reward_margin": 0.042465954325161856, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09587488382961602, "loser_reward": -0.1465639476981014, "reward_margin": 0.05068906386848539, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10671554934605955, "loser_reward": -0.13484654221124945, "reward_margin": 0.0281309928651899, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10671554934605955, "loser_reward": -0.13834083815477788, "reward_margin": 0.03162528880871833, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10671554934605955, "loser_reward": -0.1465639476981014, "reward_margin": 0.03984839835204186, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13484654221124945, "loser_reward": -0.1465639476981014, "reward_margin": 0.011717405486851962, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 62488, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 0, 500, 207], "component_score": 0.09587488382961602, "component_reward": -0.09587488382961602, "second_component_score": 0.10671554934605955, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.010840665516443526, "confidence": 0.72341173123473}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.1365798590090126, "reward": -0.1365798590090126}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2299048861851916, "reward": -0.2299048861851916}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2600964239742607, "reward": -0.2600964239742607}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.33359350022301076, "reward": -0.33359350022301076}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.433785960258916, "reward": -0.433785960258916}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "140513_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1365798590090126, "loser_reward": -0.2299048861851916, "reward_margin": 0.09332502717617899, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1365798590090126, "loser_reward": -0.2600964239742607, "reward_margin": 0.1235165649652481, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1365798590090126, "loser_reward": -0.33359350022301076, "reward_margin": 0.19701364121399817, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1365798590090126, "loser_reward": -0.433785960258916, "reward_margin": 0.29720610124990343, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2299048861851916, "loser_reward": -0.2600964239742607, "reward_margin": 0.030191537789069106, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2299048861851916, "loser_reward": -0.33359350022301076, "reward_margin": 0.10368861403781918, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2299048861851916, "loser_reward": -0.433785960258916, "reward_margin": 0.20388107407372444, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2600964239742607, "loser_reward": -0.33359350022301076, "reward_margin": 0.07349707624875007, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2600964239742607, "loser_reward": -0.433785960258916, "reward_margin": 0.17368953628465533, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.33359350022301076, "loser_reward": -0.433785960258916, "reward_margin": 0.10019246003590526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 1462, "bbox_xyxy": [425, 0, 500, 29], "component_score": 0.1365798590090126, "component_reward": -0.1365798590090126, "second_component_score": 0.2299048861851916, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.09332502717617899, "confidence": 0.9663225969727193}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7289716601371765, "teacher_quality_score": 0.12035478739941026, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.12035478739941026, "global_like": true, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09587488382961602, "loser_reward": -0.10671554934605955, "reward_margin": 0.010840665516443526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09587488382961602, "loser_reward": -0.13484654221124945, "reward_margin": 0.038971658381633426, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09587488382961602, "loser_reward": -0.13834083815477788, "reward_margin": 0.042465954325161856, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09587488382961602, "loser_reward": -0.1465639476981014, "reward_margin": 0.05068906386848539, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10671554934605955, "loser_reward": -0.13484654221124945, "reward_margin": 0.0281309928651899, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10671554934605955, "loser_reward": -0.13834083815477788, "reward_margin": 0.03162528880871833, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10671554934605955, "loser_reward": -0.1465639476981014, "reward_margin": 0.03984839835204186, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13484654221124945, "loser_reward": -0.1465639476981014, "reward_margin": 0.011717405486851962, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1365798590090126, "loser_reward": -0.2299048861851916, "reward_margin": 0.09332502717617899, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1365798590090126, "loser_reward": -0.2600964239742607, "reward_margin": 0.1235165649652481, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1365798590090126, "loser_reward": -0.33359350022301076, "reward_margin": 0.19701364121399817, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1365798590090126, "loser_reward": -0.433785960258916, "reward_margin": 0.29720610124990343, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2299048861851916, "loser_reward": -0.2600964239742607, "reward_margin": 0.030191537789069106, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2299048861851916, "loser_reward": -0.33359350022301076, "reward_margin": 0.10368861403781918, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2299048861851916, "loser_reward": -0.433785960258916, "reward_margin": 0.20388107407372444, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2600964239742607, "loser_reward": -0.33359350022301076, "reward_margin": 0.07349707624875007, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2600964239742607, "loser_reward": -0.433785960258916, "reward_margin": 0.17368953628465533, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.33359350022301076, "loser_reward": -0.433785960258916, "reward_margin": 0.10019246003590526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/140513_1/140513_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05661122128367424, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.725883960723877, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05478933826088905, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6046755909919739, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05575220286846161, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05597192794084549, "input_change_l1": 0.18873295187950134, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7984441816806793, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11058849822729827, "edit_score": 0.161823383718729, "background_score": 0.13385422006249428, "combined_score": 0.2363872531801462, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/140513_1/140513_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04756490886211395, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7391305565834045, "background_mse_to_source": 0.013055747374892235, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8944873809814453, "background_mse_to_target": 0.016038110479712486, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02410290576517582, "input_change_l1": 0.09897246956825256, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8596751689910889, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12575094476342202, "edit_score": 0.13482000529766083, "background_score": 0.03415827117860318, "combined_score": 0.17433587973937392, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/140513_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04285890609025955, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7221581339836121, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0055160545744001865, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9483623504638672, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009358473122119904, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01792815327644348, "input_change_l1": 0.06433210521936417, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8596746921539307, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08261728473007679, "edit_score": 0.13350860625505448, "background_score": 0.01584358448162675, "combined_score": 0.15737013309728357, "confidence": 0.716827143489678}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/140513_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06302635371685028, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6889934539794922, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02038237452507019, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8575118184089661, "background_mse_to_target": 0.022753756493330002, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03305580094456673, "input_change_l1": 0.12357571721076965, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8594305217266083, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1523954199627042, "edit_score": 0.16037003248929976, "background_score": 0.04888001084327698, "combined_score": 0.2112627003714442, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/140513_1/140513_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05306601524353027, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6898912787437439, "background_mse_to_source": 0.019205747172236443, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6011521816253662, "background_mse_to_target": 0.022317782044410706, "full_mse_to_target": 0.030183425173163414, "input_change_l1": 0.11835198849439621, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8147779703140259, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09364029187709093, "edit_score": 0.16139326691627504, "background_score": 0.09897531084716321, "combined_score": 0.21778102660551668, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/140513_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/140513_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/140513_1.json"}

140513_2

put the zebras next to a river

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.27220630645751953, "dataset_mask_area": 0.27220630645751953, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.19474808871746063, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.014552990905940533, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1801950978115201, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7616183179601271, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9024392102185499, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.11372550576925278, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.32559728622436523, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3076868643754774, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.18600721094495384, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.21569809640757737, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.07526767253875732, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.19474810361862183, "edit_change_ratio": 0.38648731946656156, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.3332080841064453, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/140513_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5459064245223999, "editar": 0.4540935456752777}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.12721149187907574, "reward": -0.12721149187907574}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.13641871162131428, "reward": -0.13641871162131428}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.15691210554819554, "reward": -0.15691210554819554}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.18984386994875968, "reward": -0.18984386994875968}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.1942286078110337, "reward": -0.1942286078110337}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "140513_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12721149187907574, "loser_reward": -0.15691210554819554, "reward_margin": 0.029700613669119802, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12721149187907574, "loser_reward": -0.18984386994875968, "reward_margin": 0.06263237806968394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12721149187907574, "loser_reward": -0.1942286078110337, "reward_margin": 0.06701711593195797, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.13641871162131428, "loser_reward": -0.15691210554819554, "reward_margin": 0.020493393926881265, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13641871162131428, "loser_reward": -0.18984386994875968, "reward_margin": 0.053425158327445404, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13641871162131428, "loser_reward": -0.1942286078110337, "reward_margin": 0.057809896189719434, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15691210554819554, "loser_reward": -0.18984386994875968, "reward_margin": 0.03293176440056414, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15691210554819554, "loser_reward": -0.1942286078110337, "reward_margin": 0.03731650226283817, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 285429, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 480, 1024, 1024], "component_score": 0.12721149187907574, "component_reward": -0.12721149187907574, "second_component_score": 0.13641871162131428, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.009207219742238537, "confidence": 0.6686183335185898}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6686185598373413, "teacher_quality_score": 0.18600721094495384, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.18600721094495384, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "140513_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12721149187907574, "loser_reward": -0.15691210554819554, "reward_margin": 0.029700613669119802, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12721149187907574, "loser_reward": -0.18984386994875968, "reward_margin": 0.06263237806968394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12721149187907574, "loser_reward": -0.1942286078110337, "reward_margin": 0.06701711593195797, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.13641871162131428, "loser_reward": -0.15691210554819554, "reward_margin": 0.020493393926881265, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13641871162131428, "loser_reward": -0.18984386994875968, "reward_margin": 0.053425158327445404, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13641871162131428, "loser_reward": -0.1942286078110337, "reward_margin": 0.057809896189719434, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15691210554819554, "loser_reward": -0.18984386994875968, "reward_margin": 0.03293176440056414, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "140513_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15691210554819554, "loser_reward": -0.1942286078110337, "reward_margin": 0.03731650226283817, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/140513_2/140513_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07620204240083694, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6742832064628601, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04382016882300377, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7084367871284485, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04486861452460289, "full_mse_to_target": 0.053397759795188904, "input_change_l1": 0.17664557695388794, "directional_pixel_score": 0.651366651058197, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13493709266185763, "edit_score": 0.22850373834371568, "background_score": 0.10213281139731407, "combined_score": 0.29657741684466604, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/140513_2/140513_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06722395867109299, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6938850283622742, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06611847877502441, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5172755122184753, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06547453254461288, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06595072895288467, "input_change_l1": 0.19277437031269073, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6878928542137146, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12454867167398334, "edit_score": 0.2064737394452095, "background_score": 0.16266337633132935, "combined_score": 0.2949107283912599, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/140513_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.051300693303346634, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7061076760292053, "background_mse_to_source": 0.027935050427913666, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7200407981872559, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02819972112774849, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03448795899748802, "input_change_l1": 0.12530334293842316, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6878928542137146, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08135487847030164, "edit_score": 0.18810594454407692, "background_score": 0.0839268907904625, "combined_score": 0.23720012791454792, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/140513_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08637525141239166, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6567484736442566, "background_mse_to_source": 0.10186981409788132, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4047142565250397, "background_mse_to_target": 0.1005779430270195, "full_mse_to_target": 0.09671184420585632, "input_change_l1": 0.24017459154129028, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6878883242607117, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15309674385935068, "edit_score": 0.23305347561836243, "background_score": 0.22092696279287338, "combined_score": 0.35066844578832385, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/140513_2/140513_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0458306185901165, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6841952800750732, "background_mse_to_source": 0.011653305031359196, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7629466652870178, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012273339554667473, "full_mse_to_target": 0.021407848224043846, "input_change_l1": 0.07084552198648453, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7094197869300842, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.056241527758538724, "edit_score": 0.18163661584258078, "background_score": 0.05906397197395563, "combined_score": 0.21569809640757737, "confidence": 0.7063748644568416}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/140513_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/140513_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/140513_2.json"}

142400_1

Make it a slice of pizza instead of the sandwich.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.1422799974679947, "dataset_mask_area": 0.14228, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.1774820238351822, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.005943972617387772, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.17153805121779442, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8388261607696246, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9528882358343282, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.41018012166023254, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3103127199435225, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.1984188033081591, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.24013618795201183, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.13461792469024658, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.1774820238351822, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7584876585318796, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1739480048418045, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/142400_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6184314489364624, "qwen_image_edit": 0.3815686106681824}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.13886064625717698, "reward": -0.13886064625717698}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16300542882084848, "reward": -0.16300542882084848}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19922204717900607, "reward": -0.19922204717900607}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.22660124471317974, "reward": -0.22660124471317974}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.35624563383311036, "reward": -0.35624563383311036}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.13886064625717698, "loser_reward": -0.16300542882084848, "reward_margin": 0.024144782563671502, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13886064625717698, "loser_reward": -0.19922204717900607, "reward_margin": 0.060361400921829095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13886064625717698, "loser_reward": -0.22660124471317974, "reward_margin": 0.08774059845600277, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13886064625717698, "loser_reward": -0.35624563383311036, "reward_margin": 0.21738498757593339, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16300542882084848, "loser_reward": -0.19922204717900607, "reward_margin": 0.03621661835815759, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16300542882084848, "loser_reward": -0.22660124471317974, "reward_margin": 0.06359581589233126, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16300542882084848, "loser_reward": -0.35624563383311036, "reward_margin": 0.19324020501226188, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19922204717900607, "loser_reward": -0.22660124471317974, "reward_margin": 0.02737919753417367, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19922204717900607, "loser_reward": -0.35624563383311036, "reward_margin": 0.1570235866541043, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22660124471317974, "loser_reward": -0.35624563383311036, "reward_margin": 0.12964438911993062, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 35570, "bbox_xyxy": [259, 74, 500, 265], "component_score": 0.13886064625717698, "component_reward": -0.13886064625717698, "second_component_score": 0.16300542882084848, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.024144782563671502, "confidence": 0.7892578750210424}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7892579436302185, "teacher_quality_score": 0.1984188033081591, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.1984188033081591, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.13886064625717698, "loser_reward": -0.16300542882084848, "reward_margin": 0.024144782563671502, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13886064625717698, "loser_reward": -0.19922204717900607, "reward_margin": 0.060361400921829095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13886064625717698, "loser_reward": -0.22660124471317974, "reward_margin": 0.08774059845600277, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13886064625717698, "loser_reward": -0.35624563383311036, "reward_margin": 0.21738498757593339, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16300542882084848, "loser_reward": -0.19922204717900607, "reward_margin": 0.03621661835815759, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16300542882084848, "loser_reward": -0.22660124471317974, "reward_margin": 0.06359581589233126, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16300542882084848, "loser_reward": -0.35624563383311036, "reward_margin": 0.19324020501226188, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19922204717900607, "loser_reward": -0.22660124471317974, "reward_margin": 0.02737919753417367, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19922204717900607, "loser_reward": -0.35624563383311036, "reward_margin": 0.1570235866541043, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22660124471317974, "loser_reward": -0.35624563383311036, "reward_margin": 0.12964438911993062, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/142400_1/142400_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1484924852848053, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.30092036724090576, "background_mse_to_source": 0.08674977719783783, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.41462135314941406, "background_mse_to_target": 0.08670942485332489, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0954999253153801, "input_change_l1": 0.23304656147956848, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6257632821798325, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2549448885023594, "edit_score": 0.38186759129166603, "background_score": 0.203825506567955, "combined_score": 0.5137454888224601, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/142400_1/142400_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.049862731248140335, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5098776817321777, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04576166346669197, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.49579373002052307, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04559730738401413, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04620419815182686, "input_change_l1": 0.1508745402097702, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7866922914981842, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14794907048344613, "edit_score": 0.20121412202715874, "background_score": 0.14660291746258736, "combined_score": 0.2867353770509362, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142400_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03567890077829361, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4859901964664459, "background_mse_to_source": 0.019334303215146065, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7142202258110046, "background_mse_to_target": 0.019358063116669655, "full_mse_to_target": 0.021680189296603203, "input_change_l1": 0.09806843847036362, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7866924107074738, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0969440994784236, "edit_score": 0.191807758808136, "background_score": 0.07649025805294514, "combined_score": 0.24013618795201183, "confidence": 0.8072712779275409}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142400_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06884672492742538, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.45482906699180603, "background_mse_to_source": 0.07049679756164551, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.364593505859375, "background_mse_to_target": 0.07021265476942062, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07001830637454987, "input_change_l1": 0.1877395063638687, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7864390909671783, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.18078596806153654, "edit_score": 0.2312711387872696, "background_score": 0.1975780963897705, "combined_score": 0.34358249677345154, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/142400_1/142400_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06590766459703445, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3455286920070648, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010432005859911442, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7353344559669495, "background_mse_to_target": 0.010471904650330544, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01835930533707142, "input_change_l1": 0.07983220368623734, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5387601926922798, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0695685681886971, "edit_score": 0.3121118780225516, "background_score": 0.06336511466652156, "combined_score": 0.35003931232728064, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/142400_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/142400_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/142400_1.json"}

142400_2

There should be some cutlery on the table.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.029018402099609375, "dataset_mask_area": 0.029018402099609375, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.23819668591022491, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0008563902811147273, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2373402956291102, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8393399505276012, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9467066925657779, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.43766582012176514, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.37592935739505345, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+fallback_best_expert", "fusion_fallback": {"used": true, "reason": "fused_teacher_worse_than_best_expert", "fallback": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "teacher_combined_score": 0.2311888446003286, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2188590181991458, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1069522276520729, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.23819668591022491, "edit_change_ratio": 0.4490080424224821, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.039992332458496094, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/142400_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6194257736206055, "qwen_image_edit": 0.3805742859840393}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.14147560153529048, "reward": -0.14147560153529048}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16583117220690471, "reward": -0.16583117220690471}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.192370560338255, "reward": -0.192370560338255}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1964090594005538, "reward": -0.1964090594005538}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.26844654151611025, "reward": -0.26844654151611025}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14147560153529048, "loser_reward": -0.16583117220690471, "reward_margin": 0.02435557067161423, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14147560153529048, "loser_reward": -0.192370560338255, "reward_margin": 0.05089495880296452, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14147560153529048, "loser_reward": -0.1964090594005538, "reward_margin": 0.054933457865263324, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14147560153529048, "loser_reward": -0.26844654151611025, "reward_margin": 0.12697093998081976, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16583117220690471, "loser_reward": -0.192370560338255, "reward_margin": 0.02653938813135029, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16583117220690471, "loser_reward": -0.1964090594005538, "reward_margin": 0.030577887193649095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16583117220690471, "loser_reward": -0.26844654151611025, "reward_margin": 0.10261536930920553, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.192370560338255, "loser_reward": -0.26844654151611025, "reward_margin": 0.07607598117785525, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1964090594005538, "loser_reward": -0.26844654151611025, "reward_margin": 0.07203748211555644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 30428, "bbox_xyxy": [748, 83, 1024, 330], "component_score": 0.14147560153529048, "component_reward": -0.14147560153529048, "second_component_score": 0.16583117220690471, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.02435557067161423, "confidence": 0.7876358842487887}], "teacher_confidence": 0.787635862827301, "teacher_quality_score": 0.21776673018583098, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.21776673018583098, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14147560153529048, "loser_reward": -0.16583117220690471, "reward_margin": 0.02435557067161423, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14147560153529048, "loser_reward": -0.192370560338255, "reward_margin": 0.05089495880296452, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14147560153529048, "loser_reward": -0.1964090594005538, "reward_margin": 0.054933457865263324, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14147560153529048, "loser_reward": -0.26844654151611025, "reward_margin": 0.12697093998081976, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16583117220690471, "loser_reward": -0.192370560338255, "reward_margin": 0.02653938813135029, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16583117220690471, "loser_reward": -0.1964090594005538, "reward_margin": 0.030577887193649095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16583117220690471, "loser_reward": -0.26844654151611025, "reward_margin": 0.10261536930920553, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.192370560338255, "loser_reward": -0.26844654151611025, "reward_margin": 0.07607598117785525, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142400_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1964090594005538, "loser_reward": -0.26844654151611025, "reward_margin": 0.07203748211555644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/142400_2/142400_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12620823085308075, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6155984401702881, "background_mse_to_source": 0.07152806967496872, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.26433199644088745, "background_mse_to_target": 0.07140669226646423, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07299695163965225, "input_change_l1": 0.2193569540977478, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6861859709024429, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.20647960733622314, "edit_score": 0.2815420500934124, "background_score": 0.21866167038679124, "combined_score": 0.40666925135999915, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/142400_2/142400_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.082924984395504, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6728954315185547, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002481272676959634, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9524867534637451, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002488537225872278, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004822672810405493, "input_change_l1": 0.020419316366314888, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7198974043130875, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10462527107447386, "edit_score": 0.21837154701352118, "background_score": 0.01198392198421061, "combined_score": 0.2439732412039302, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142400_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07043372094631195, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6905129551887512, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0010483372025191784, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.967927873134613, "background_mse_to_target": 0.001068739453330636, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0030816036742180586, "input_change_l1": 0.013272556476294994, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7198973447084427, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06791048599407078, "edit_score": 0.20235679373145105, "background_score": 0.007462762575596572, "combined_score": 0.2188590181991458, "confidence": 0.725482306112209}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142400_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10051864385604858, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6567052006721497, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0038678820710629225, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9403986930847168, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0038657416589558125, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006670454982668161, "input_change_l1": 0.02549806423485279, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7201366573572159, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13061857027933002, "edit_score": 0.2391434393823147, "background_score": 0.015788143454119566, "combined_score": 0.27146004914538935, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/142400_2/142400_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08626378327608109, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7246641516685486, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004584042821079493, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8062117695808411, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00461347633972764, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006982836872339249, "input_change_l1": 0.04282945394515991, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5180160757154226, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01213512596441433, "edit_score": 0.2618269340135157, "background_score": 0.04334168890491128, "combined_score": 0.2801218340103514, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/142400_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/142400_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/142400_2.json"}

142510_1

add a plane in the sky

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.012892000377178192, "dataset_mask_area": 0.012892, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.22510428726673126, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.005083211697638035, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.22002107556909323, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6545374835598422, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.6904046242774566, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3064166009426117, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3261817585673725, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.013985550210154544, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.20859373818151652, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.0334836021065712, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.22510430216789246, "edit_change_ratio": 0.1487470554054435, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.19768373668193817, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.8781872881953946}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.031191999092698097, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/142510_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.14386772803636266, "reward": -0.14386772803636266}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2372656310619786, "reward": -0.2372656310619786}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.3197393767945468, "reward": -0.3197393767945468}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3480875319931656, "reward": -0.3480875319931656}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.36063413672521705, "reward": -0.36063413672521705}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.14386772803636266, "loser_reward": -0.2372656310619786, "reward_margin": 0.09339790302561593, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14386772803636266, "loser_reward": -0.3197393767945468, "reward_margin": 0.17587164875818412, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14386772803636266, "loser_reward": -0.3480875319931656, "reward_margin": 0.20421980395680295, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14386772803636266, "loser_reward": -0.36063413672521705, "reward_margin": 0.21676640868885438, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2372656310619786, "loser_reward": -0.3197393767945468, "reward_margin": 0.08247374573256819, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2372656310619786, "loser_reward": -0.3480875319931656, "reward_margin": 0.11082190093118702, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2372656310619786, "loser_reward": -0.36063413672521705, "reward_margin": 0.12336850566323845, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3197393767945468, "loser_reward": -0.3480875319931656, "reward_margin": 0.02834815519861883, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3197393767945468, "loser_reward": -0.36063413672521705, "reward_margin": 0.040894759930670266, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3480875319931656, "loser_reward": -0.36063413672521705, "reward_margin": 0.012546604732051436, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 3223, "bbox_xyxy": [79, 56, 209, 129], "component_score": 0.14386772803636266, "component_reward": -0.14386772803636266, "second_component_score": 0.2372656310619786, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.09339790302561593, "confidence": 0.9629874009790806}], "teacher_confidence": 0.9629876613616943, "teacher_quality_score": 0.013985550210154544, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.013985550210154544, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.14386772803636266, "loser_reward": -0.2372656310619786, "reward_margin": 0.09339790302561593, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14386772803636266, "loser_reward": -0.3197393767945468, "reward_margin": 0.17587164875818412, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14386772803636266, "loser_reward": -0.3480875319931656, "reward_margin": 0.20421980395680295, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14386772803636266, "loser_reward": -0.36063413672521705, "reward_margin": 0.21676640868885438, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2372656310619786, "loser_reward": -0.3197393767945468, "reward_margin": 0.08247374573256819, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2372656310619786, "loser_reward": -0.3480875319931656, "reward_margin": 0.11082190093118702, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2372656310619786, "loser_reward": -0.36063413672521705, "reward_margin": 0.12336850566323845, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3197393767945468, "loser_reward": -0.3480875319931656, "reward_margin": 0.02834815519861883, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3197393767945468, "loser_reward": -0.36063413672521705, "reward_margin": 0.040894759930670266, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3480875319931656, "loser_reward": -0.36063413672521705, "reward_margin": 0.012546604732051436, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/142510_1/142510_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.20315878093242645, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7247136235237122, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03757358714938164, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5791135430335999, "background_mse_to_target": 0.037910375744104385, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0400407612323761, "input_change_l1": 0.16307182610034943, "directional_pixel_score": 0.26793546974658966, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12784982640296222, "edit_score": 0.4412321887910366, "background_score": 0.12175087854266167, "combined_score": 0.5134190376847982, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/142510_1/142510_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.20242327451705933, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7126695513725281, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0031955386511981487, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9615629315376282, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0038050657603889704, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006365652196109295, "input_change_l1": 0.017168095335364342, "directional_pixel_score": 0.35118167102336884, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1259317102842033, "edit_score": 0.4220939464867115, "background_score": 0.010882952343672515, "combined_score": 0.45172588708344846, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142510_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1375776082277298, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7561004161834717, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0013501159846782684, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9726441502571106, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0019821366295218468, "full_mse_to_target": 0.003730233060196042, "input_change_l1": 0.011159260757267475, "directional_pixel_score": 0.35118167102336884, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08169936211779714, "edit_score": 0.34856210723519326, "background_score": 0.006821285933256149, "combined_score": 0.367662453041412, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142510_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2347477823495865, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6896672248840332, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004228812642395496, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9556610584259033, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004829701501876116, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007793806027621031, "input_change_l1": 0.020626049488782883, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3502306342124939, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14592593591660263, "edit_score": 0.45925667881965637, "background_score": 0.013096600957214833, "combined_score": 0.4938050569407642, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/142510_1/142510_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06293286383152008, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8047725558280945, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010521549731492996, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7765121459960938, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01086226012557745, "full_mse_to_target": 0.011533553712069988, "input_change_l1": 0.06261000782251358, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6865289956331253, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03883793433196843, "edit_score": 0.18034610375761986, "background_score": 0.05521912053227425, "combined_score": 0.20859373818151652, "confidence": 0.9726067916293712}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/142510_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/142510_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/142510_1.json"}

142510_2

remove the clouds

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.16734695434570312, "dataset_mask_area": 0.16734695434570312, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.3087751865386963, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.003728586481884122, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.30504660005681217, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.902111388012444, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9674372300016, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.17668189108371735, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4519974558183694, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.17940654182457366, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.20300512237474322, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.20760148763656616, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.3087751567363739, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6723387005315722, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.22046661376953125, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/142510_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5082181692123413, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4917818605899811}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.033575253441464156, "reward": -0.033575253441464156}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.035219025447964666, "reward": -0.035219025447964666}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.05102653503324835, "reward": -0.05102653503324835}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.18023895979765803, "reward": -0.18023895979765803}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.25734905580896883, "reward": -0.25734905580896883}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.033575253441464156, "loser_reward": -0.05102653503324835, "reward_margin": 0.017451281591784197, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.033575253441464156, "loser_reward": -0.18023895979765803, "reward_margin": 0.14666370635619386, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.033575253441464156, "loser_reward": -0.25734905580896883, "reward_margin": 0.22377380236750466, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.035219025447964666, "loser_reward": -0.05102653503324835, "reward_margin": 0.015807509585283687, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.035219025447964666, "loser_reward": -0.18023895979765803, "reward_margin": 0.14501993434969335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.035219025447964666, "loser_reward": -0.25734905580896883, "reward_margin": 0.22213003036100415, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.05102653503324835, "loser_reward": -0.18023895979765803, "reward_margin": 0.12921242476440967, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05102653503324835, "loser_reward": -0.25734905580896883, "reward_margin": 0.20632252077572047, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18023895979765803, "loser_reward": -0.25734905580896883, "reward_margin": 0.0771100960113108, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4860, "bbox_xyxy": [449, 0, 565, 69], "component_score": 0.033575253441464156, "component_reward": -0.033575253441464156, "second_component_score": 0.035219025447964666, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0016437720065005101, "confidence": 0.6330484094668916}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5232483148574829, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4767516553401947}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.03263570459000767, "reward": -0.03263570459000767}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.037288723987527195, "reward": -0.037288723987527195}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.06033114502113312, "reward": -0.06033114502113312}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1955032503688708, "reward": -0.1955032503688708}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2542457846822217, "reward": -0.2542457846822217}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.03263570459000767, "loser_reward": -0.06033114502113312, "reward_margin": 0.02769544043112545, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.03263570459000767, "loser_reward": -0.1955032503688708, "reward_margin": 0.16286754577886314, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.03263570459000767, "loser_reward": -0.2542457846822217, "reward_margin": 0.22161008009221403, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.037288723987527195, "loser_reward": -0.06033114502113312, "reward_margin": 0.023042421033605924, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.037288723987527195, "loser_reward": -0.1955032503688708, "reward_margin": 0.15821452638134362, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.037288723987527195, "loser_reward": -0.2542457846822217, "reward_margin": 0.2169570606946945, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06033114502113312, "loser_reward": -0.1955032503688708, "reward_margin": 0.1351721053477377, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06033114502113312, "loser_reward": -0.2542457846822217, "reward_margin": 0.19391463966108857, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1955032503688708, "loser_reward": -0.2542457846822217, "reward_margin": 0.058742534313350886, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 17186, "bbox_xyxy": [547, 21, 746, 194], "component_score": 0.03263570459000767, "component_reward": -0.03263570459000767, "second_component_score": 0.037288723987527195, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0046530193975195255, "confidence": 0.7576460023079606}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.08078561641648412, "reward": -0.08078561641648412}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.12659681300539521, "reward": -0.12659681300539521}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.13933454053383318, "reward": -0.13933454053383318}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.15714057297352702, "reward": -0.15714057297352702}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2199320418657735, "reward": -0.2199320418657735}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.08078561641648412, "loser_reward": -0.12659681300539521, "reward_margin": 0.0458111965889111, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08078561641648412, "loser_reward": -0.13933454053383318, "reward_margin": 0.05854892411734906, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08078561641648412, "loser_reward": -0.15714057297352702, "reward_margin": 0.0763549565570429, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08078561641648412, "loser_reward": -0.2199320418657735, "reward_margin": 0.1391464254492894, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12659681300539521, "loser_reward": -0.13933454053383318, "reward_margin": 0.012737727528437964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12659681300539521, "loser_reward": -0.15714057297352702, "reward_margin": 0.0305437599681318, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12659681300539521, "loser_reward": -0.2199320418657735, "reward_margin": 0.09333522886037829, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13933454053383318, "loser_reward": -0.15714057297352702, "reward_margin": 0.017806032439693836, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13933454053383318, "loser_reward": -0.2199320418657735, "reward_margin": 0.08059750133194032, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15714057297352702, "loser_reward": -0.2199320418657735, "reward_margin": 0.06279146889224649, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 6972, "bbox_xyxy": [710, 92, 855, 207], "component_score": 0.08078561641648412, "component_reward": -0.08078561641648412, "second_component_score": 0.12659681300539521, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0458111965889111, "confidence": 0.9528359074255781}, {"component_id": 3, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5268208384513855, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4731791317462921}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.033114736535586414, "reward": -0.033114736535586414}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.03848406143859029, "reward": -0.03848406143859029}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.050134510639123615, "reward": -0.050134510639123615}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.20028183714393527, "reward": -0.20028183714393527}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.22572898547071962, "reward": -0.22572898547071962}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.033114736535586414, "loser_reward": -0.050134510639123615, "reward_margin": 0.0170197741035372, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.033114736535586414, "loser_reward": -0.20028183714393527, "reward_margin": 0.16716710060834886, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.033114736535586414, "loser_reward": -0.22572898547071962, "reward_margin": 0.1926142489351332, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.03848406143859029, "loser_reward": -0.050134510639123615, "reward_margin": 0.011650449200533326, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.03848406143859029, "loser_reward": -0.20028183714393527, "reward_margin": 0.16179777570534498, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.03848406143859029, "loser_reward": -0.22572898547071962, "reward_margin": 0.18724492403212933, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.050134510639123615, "loser_reward": -0.20028183714393527, "reward_margin": 0.15014732650481166, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.050134510639123615, "loser_reward": -0.22572898547071962, "reward_margin": 0.17559447483159601, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20028183714393527, "loser_reward": -0.22572898547071962, "reward_margin": 0.025447148326784352, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 12009, "bbox_xyxy": [150, 114, 333, 258], "component_score": 0.033114736535586414, "component_reward": -0.033114736535586414, "second_component_score": 0.03848406143859029, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.005369324903003875, "confidence": 0.777948969415986}, {"component_id": 4, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.09168932505324483, "reward": -0.09168932505324483}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1271571205081418, "reward": -0.1271571205081418}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.13832384692411873, "reward": -0.13832384692411873}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.15181375578884038, "reward": -0.15181375578884038}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.338274335664697, "reward": -0.338274335664697}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09168932505324483, "loser_reward": -0.1271571205081418, "reward_margin": 0.035467795454896964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09168932505324483, "loser_reward": -0.13832384692411873, "reward_margin": 0.0466345218708739, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09168932505324483, "loser_reward": -0.15181375578884038, "reward_margin": 0.06012443073559555, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09168932505324483, "loser_reward": -0.338274335664697, "reward_margin": 0.24658501061145216, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1271571205081418, "loser_reward": -0.13832384692411873, "reward_margin": 0.011166726415976935, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1271571205081418, "loser_reward": -0.15181375578884038, "reward_margin": 0.024656635280698586, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1271571205081418, "loser_reward": -0.338274335664697, "reward_margin": 0.2111172151565552, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13832384692411873, "loser_reward": -0.15181375578884038, "reward_margin": 0.01348990886472165, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13832384692411873, "loser_reward": -0.338274335664697, "reward_margin": 0.19995048874057827, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15181375578884038, "loser_reward": -0.338274335664697, "reward_margin": 0.18646057987585662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4925, "bbox_xyxy": [896, 380, 1024, 466], "component_score": 0.09168932505324483, "component_reward": -0.09168932505324483, "second_component_score": 0.1271571205081418, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.035467795454896964, "confidence": 0.912733017466695}, {"component_id": 5, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5812744498252869, "qwen_image_edit": 0.41872549057006836}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.11087936826422809, "reward": -0.11087936826422809}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.12727974961418656, "reward": -0.12727974961418656}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1575835292218253, "reward": -0.1575835292218253}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.24630997390393167, "reward": -0.24630997390393167}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2985479412497952, "reward": -0.2985479412497952}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11087936826422809, "loser_reward": -0.12727974961418656, "reward_margin": 0.01640038134995847, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11087936826422809, "loser_reward": -0.1575835292218253, "reward_margin": 0.04670416095759722, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11087936826422809, "loser_reward": -0.24630997390393167, "reward_margin": 0.13543060563970358, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11087936826422809, "loser_reward": -0.2985479412497952, "reward_margin": 0.18766857298556713, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12727974961418656, "loser_reward": -0.1575835292218253, "reward_margin": 0.030303779607638748, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12727974961418656, "loser_reward": -0.24630997390393167, "reward_margin": 0.1190302242897451, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12727974961418656, "loser_reward": -0.2985479412497952, "reward_margin": 0.17126819163560866, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1575835292218253, "loser_reward": -0.24630997390393167, "reward_margin": 0.08872644468210636, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1575835292218253, "loser_reward": -0.2985479412497952, "reward_margin": 0.14096441202796992, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24630997390393167, "loser_reward": -0.2985479412497952, "reward_margin": 0.052237967345863556, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 35890, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 445, 240, 722], "component_score": 0.11087936826422809, "component_reward": -0.11087936826422809, "second_component_score": 0.12727974961418656, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.01640038134995847, "confidence": 0.7633680376668369}, {"component_id": 6, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5261647701263428, "qwen_image_edit": 0.47383520007133484}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2301802284307777, "reward": -0.2301802284307777}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2354179815473035, "reward": -0.2354179815473035}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2615890462873503, "reward": -0.2615890462873503}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.38025583089236165, "reward": -0.38025583089236165}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.4603840259732679, "reward": -0.4603840259732679}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2301802284307777, "loser_reward": -0.2615890462873503, "reward_margin": 0.031408817856572596, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2301802284307777, "loser_reward": -0.38025583089236165, "reward_margin": 0.15007560246158394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2301802284307777, "loser_reward": -0.4603840259732679, "reward_margin": 0.23020379754249018, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2354179815473035, "loser_reward": -0.2615890462873503, "reward_margin": 0.026171064740046796, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2354179815473035, "loser_reward": -0.38025583089236165, "reward_margin": 0.14483784934505814, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2354179815473035, "loser_reward": -0.4603840259732679, "reward_margin": 0.22496604442596438, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2615890462873503, "loser_reward": -0.38025583089236165, "reward_margin": 0.11866678460501134, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2615890462873503, "loser_reward": -0.4603840259732679, "reward_margin": 0.19879497968591758, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.38025583089236165, "loser_reward": -0.4603840259732679, "reward_margin": 0.08012819508090624, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 45325, "bbox_xyxy": [812, 470, 1024, 727], "component_score": 0.2301802284307777, "component_reward": -0.2301802284307777, "second_component_score": 0.2354179815473035, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.005237753116525801, "confidence": 0.5899423291147491}, {"component_id": 7, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.7277084589004517, "qwen_image_edit": 0.2722916007041931}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.24231282987073058, "reward": -0.24231282987073058}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2914641813458875, "reward": -0.2914641813458875}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.31786829130630934, "reward": -0.31786829130630934}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.37328182668332005, "reward": -0.37328182668332005}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.6029866440119221, "reward": -0.6029866440119221}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.24231282987073058, "loser_reward": -0.2914641813458875, "reward_margin": 0.049151351475156896, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24231282987073058, "loser_reward": -0.31786829130630934, "reward_margin": 0.07555546143557876, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24231282987073058, "loser_reward": -0.37328182668332005, "reward_margin": 0.13096899681258947, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24231282987073058, "loser_reward": -0.6029866440119221, "reward_margin": 0.3606738141411916, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2914641813458875, "loser_reward": -0.31786829130630934, "reward_margin": 0.026404109960421862, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2914641813458875, "loser_reward": -0.37328182668332005, "reward_margin": 0.08181764533743258, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2914641813458875, "loser_reward": -0.6029866440119221, "reward_margin": 0.31152246266603467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.31786829130630934, "loser_reward": -0.37328182668332005, "reward_margin": 0.055413535377010714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.31786829130630934, "loser_reward": -0.6029866440119221, "reward_margin": 0.2851183527056128, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.37328182668332005, "loser_reward": -0.6029866440119221, "reward_margin": 0.2297048173286021, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 48309, "bbox_xyxy": [480, 528, 798, 730], "component_score": 0.24231282987073058, "component_reward": -0.24231282987073058, "second_component_score": 0.2914641813458875, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.049151351475156896, "confidence": 0.8145824024395854}], "teacher_confidence": 0.741220235824585, "teacher_quality_score": 0.17940654182457366, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.17940654182457366, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.033575253441464156, "loser_reward": -0.05102653503324835, "reward_margin": 0.017451281591784197, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.033575253441464156, "loser_reward": -0.18023895979765803, "reward_margin": 0.14666370635619386, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.033575253441464156, "loser_reward": -0.25734905580896883, "reward_margin": 0.22377380236750466, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.035219025447964666, "loser_reward": -0.05102653503324835, "reward_margin": 0.015807509585283687, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.035219025447964666, "loser_reward": -0.18023895979765803, "reward_margin": 0.14501993434969335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.035219025447964666, "loser_reward": -0.25734905580896883, "reward_margin": 0.22213003036100415, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.05102653503324835, "loser_reward": -0.18023895979765803, "reward_margin": 0.12921242476440967, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05102653503324835, "loser_reward": -0.25734905580896883, "reward_margin": 0.20632252077572047, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18023895979765803, "loser_reward": -0.25734905580896883, "reward_margin": 0.0771100960113108, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.03263570459000767, "loser_reward": -0.06033114502113312, "reward_margin": 0.02769544043112545, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.03263570459000767, "loser_reward": -0.1955032503688708, "reward_margin": 0.16286754577886314, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.03263570459000767, "loser_reward": -0.2542457846822217, "reward_margin": 0.22161008009221403, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.037288723987527195, "loser_reward": -0.06033114502113312, "reward_margin": 0.023042421033605924, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.037288723987527195, "loser_reward": -0.1955032503688708, "reward_margin": 0.15821452638134362, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.037288723987527195, "loser_reward": -0.2542457846822217, "reward_margin": 0.2169570606946945, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06033114502113312, "loser_reward": -0.1955032503688708, "reward_margin": 0.1351721053477377, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06033114502113312, "loser_reward": -0.2542457846822217, "reward_margin": 0.19391463966108857, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1955032503688708, "loser_reward": -0.2542457846822217, "reward_margin": 0.058742534313350886, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.08078561641648412, "loser_reward": -0.12659681300539521, "reward_margin": 0.0458111965889111, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08078561641648412, "loser_reward": -0.13933454053383318, "reward_margin": 0.05854892411734906, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08078561641648412, "loser_reward": -0.15714057297352702, "reward_margin": 0.0763549565570429, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08078561641648412, "loser_reward": -0.2199320418657735, "reward_margin": 0.1391464254492894, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12659681300539521, "loser_reward": -0.13933454053383318, "reward_margin": 0.012737727528437964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12659681300539521, "loser_reward": -0.15714057297352702, "reward_margin": 0.0305437599681318, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12659681300539521, "loser_reward": -0.2199320418657735, "reward_margin": 0.09333522886037829, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13933454053383318, "loser_reward": -0.15714057297352702, "reward_margin": 0.017806032439693836, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13933454053383318, "loser_reward": -0.2199320418657735, "reward_margin": 0.08059750133194032, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region2__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15714057297352702, "loser_reward": -0.2199320418657735, "reward_margin": 0.06279146889224649, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.033114736535586414, "loser_reward": -0.050134510639123615, "reward_margin": 0.0170197741035372, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.033114736535586414, "loser_reward": -0.20028183714393527, "reward_margin": 0.16716710060834886, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.033114736535586414, "loser_reward": -0.22572898547071962, "reward_margin": 0.1926142489351332, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.03848406143859029, "loser_reward": -0.050134510639123615, "reward_margin": 0.011650449200533326, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.03848406143859029, "loser_reward": -0.20028183714393527, "reward_margin": 0.16179777570534498, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.03848406143859029, "loser_reward": -0.22572898547071962, "reward_margin": 0.18724492403212933, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.050134510639123615, "loser_reward": -0.20028183714393527, "reward_margin": 0.15014732650481166, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.050134510639123615, "loser_reward": -0.22572898547071962, "reward_margin": 0.17559447483159601, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region3__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20028183714393527, "loser_reward": -0.22572898547071962, "reward_margin": 0.025447148326784352, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09168932505324483, "loser_reward": -0.1271571205081418, "reward_margin": 0.035467795454896964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09168932505324483, "loser_reward": -0.13832384692411873, "reward_margin": 0.0466345218708739, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09168932505324483, "loser_reward": -0.15181375578884038, "reward_margin": 0.06012443073559555, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09168932505324483, "loser_reward": -0.338274335664697, "reward_margin": 0.24658501061145216, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1271571205081418, "loser_reward": -0.13832384692411873, "reward_margin": 0.011166726415976935, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1271571205081418, "loser_reward": -0.15181375578884038, "reward_margin": 0.024656635280698586, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1271571205081418, "loser_reward": -0.338274335664697, "reward_margin": 0.2111172151565552, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13832384692411873, "loser_reward": -0.15181375578884038, "reward_margin": 0.01348990886472165, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13832384692411873, "loser_reward": -0.338274335664697, "reward_margin": 0.19995048874057827, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region4__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15181375578884038, "loser_reward": -0.338274335664697, "reward_margin": 0.18646057987585662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.11087936826422809, "loser_reward": -0.12727974961418656, "reward_margin": 0.01640038134995847, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11087936826422809, "loser_reward": -0.1575835292218253, "reward_margin": 0.04670416095759722, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11087936826422809, "loser_reward": -0.24630997390393167, "reward_margin": 0.13543060563970358, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11087936826422809, "loser_reward": -0.2985479412497952, "reward_margin": 0.18766857298556713, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12727974961418656, "loser_reward": -0.1575835292218253, "reward_margin": 0.030303779607638748, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12727974961418656, "loser_reward": -0.24630997390393167, "reward_margin": 0.1190302242897451, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12727974961418656, "loser_reward": -0.2985479412497952, "reward_margin": 0.17126819163560866, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1575835292218253, "loser_reward": -0.24630997390393167, "reward_margin": 0.08872644468210636, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1575835292218253, "loser_reward": -0.2985479412497952, "reward_margin": 0.14096441202796992, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region5__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24630997390393167, "loser_reward": -0.2985479412497952, "reward_margin": 0.052237967345863556, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2301802284307777, "loser_reward": -0.2615890462873503, "reward_margin": 0.031408817856572596, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2301802284307777, "loser_reward": -0.38025583089236165, "reward_margin": 0.15007560246158394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2301802284307777, "loser_reward": -0.4603840259732679, "reward_margin": 0.23020379754249018, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2354179815473035, "loser_reward": -0.2615890462873503, "reward_margin": 0.026171064740046796, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2354179815473035, "loser_reward": -0.38025583089236165, "reward_margin": 0.14483784934505814, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2354179815473035, "loser_reward": -0.4603840259732679, "reward_margin": 0.22496604442596438, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2615890462873503, "loser_reward": -0.38025583089236165, "reward_margin": 0.11866678460501134, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2615890462873503, "loser_reward": -0.4603840259732679, "reward_margin": 0.19879497968591758, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region6__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.38025583089236165, "loser_reward": -0.4603840259732679, "reward_margin": 0.08012819508090624, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.24231282987073058, "loser_reward": -0.2914641813458875, "reward_margin": 0.049151351475156896, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24231282987073058, "loser_reward": -0.31786829130630934, "reward_margin": 0.07555546143557876, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24231282987073058, "loser_reward": -0.37328182668332005, "reward_margin": 0.13096899681258947, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24231282987073058, "loser_reward": -0.6029866440119221, "reward_margin": 0.3606738141411916, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2914641813458875, "loser_reward": -0.31786829130630934, "reward_margin": 0.026404109960421862, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2914641813458875, "loser_reward": -0.37328182668332005, "reward_margin": 0.08181764533743258, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2914641813458875, "loser_reward": -0.6029866440119221, "reward_margin": 0.31152246266603467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.31786829130630934, "loser_reward": -0.37328182668332005, "reward_margin": 0.055413535377010714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.31786829130630934, "loser_reward": -0.6029866440119221, "reward_margin": 0.2851183527056128, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142510_2__region7__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 7, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.37328182668332005, "loser_reward": -0.6029866440119221, "reward_margin": 0.2297048173286021, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/142510_2/142510_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2384553849697113, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7433907389640808, "background_mse_to_source": 0.11893035471439362, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.29062631726264954, "background_mse_to_target": 0.11842158436775208, "full_mse_to_target": 0.1385088860988617, "input_change_l1": 0.30071142315864563, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6182313859462738, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2106165518052876, "edit_score": 0.3852193906903267, "background_score": 0.2608050912618637, "combined_score": 0.5324753716029227, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/142510_2/142510_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10935797542333603, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.873996913433075, "background_mse_to_source": 0.021604513749480247, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7211608290672302, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0215302724391222, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03622796759009361, "input_change_l1": 0.09298671036958694, "directional_pixel_score": 0.79921755194664, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12311155209317803, "edit_score": 0.18475420475006105, "background_score": 0.0773723479360342, "combined_score": 0.24007963370531799, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142510_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09090200811624527, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8556023240089417, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009127913042902946, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8360560536384583, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00915700476616621, "full_mse_to_target": 0.022836776450276375, "input_change_l1": 0.06044134497642517, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7992171943187714, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08036677092313767, "edit_score": 0.1699772447347641, "background_score": 0.041916702315211295, "combined_score": 0.20300512237474322, "confidence": 0.7972871596509623}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142510_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12334264069795609, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8529698252677917, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02697443589568138, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6783793568611145, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02683722786605358, "full_mse_to_target": 0.042987097054719925, "input_change_l1": 0.10769528150558472, "directional_pixel_score": 0.804705023765564, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13962518898770213, "edit_score": 0.20157241970300674, "background_score": 0.09129856452345848, "combined_score": 0.2657506647892296, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/142510_2/142510_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15948960185050964, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7920005321502686, "background_mse_to_source": 0.006577049382030964, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8478858470916748, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006654468830674887, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03223097696900368, "input_change_l1": 0.050560712814331055, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4897417277097702, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05720558119937778, "edit_score": 0.3286540634930134, "background_score": 0.036999879963696004, "combined_score": 0.3562682354170829, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/142510_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/142510_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/142510_2.json"}

142585_1

Let the van turn black.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.12195199728012085, "dataset_mask_area": 0.121952, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.23871013522148132, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.007185146678239107, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.23152498854324222, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8201824010956517, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9414412805030548, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.35960930585861206, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3676045278948426, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.204091738128991, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2107087280799169, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.16926777362823486, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.23871012032032013, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7090934117124903, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.16955600678920746, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/142585_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.13868780235783193, "reward": -0.13868780235783193}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.17645903077581898, "reward": -0.17645903077581898}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2028214842863381, "reward": -0.2028214842863381}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.21227615855075418, "reward": -0.21227615855075418}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.25086582538113, "reward": -0.25086582538113}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.13868780235783193, "loser_reward": -0.17645903077581898, "reward_margin": 0.03777122841798705, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13868780235783193, "loser_reward": -0.2028214842863381, "reward_margin": 0.06413368192850616, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13868780235783193, "loser_reward": -0.21227615855075418, "reward_margin": 0.07358835619292226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13868780235783193, "loser_reward": -0.25086582538113, "reward_margin": 0.11217802302329807, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17645903077581898, "loser_reward": -0.2028214842863381, "reward_margin": 0.026362453510519107, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17645903077581898, "loser_reward": -0.21227615855075418, "reward_margin": 0.035817127774935203, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17645903077581898, "loser_reward": -0.25086582538113, "reward_margin": 0.07440679460531102, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2028214842863381, "loser_reward": -0.25086582538113, "reward_margin": 0.048044341094791915, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21227615855075418, "loser_reward": -0.25086582538113, "reward_margin": 0.03858966683037582, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 30488, "bbox_xyxy": [240, 266, 484, 469], "component_score": 0.13868780235783193, "component_reward": -0.13868780235783193, "second_component_score": 0.17645903077581898, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.03777122841798705, "confidence": 0.8624334527527058}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8624334335327148, "teacher_quality_score": 0.204091738128991, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.204091738128991, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.13868780235783193, "loser_reward": -0.17645903077581898, "reward_margin": 0.03777122841798705, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13868780235783193, "loser_reward": -0.2028214842863381, "reward_margin": 0.06413368192850616, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13868780235783193, "loser_reward": -0.21227615855075418, "reward_margin": 0.07358835619292226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13868780235783193, "loser_reward": -0.25086582538113, "reward_margin": 0.11217802302329807, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17645903077581898, "loser_reward": -0.2028214842863381, "reward_margin": 0.026362453510519107, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17645903077581898, "loser_reward": -0.21227615855075418, "reward_margin": 0.035817127774935203, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17645903077581898, "loser_reward": -0.25086582538113, "reward_margin": 0.07440679460531102, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2028214842863381, "loser_reward": -0.25086582538113, "reward_margin": 0.048044341094791915, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142585_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21227615855075418, "loser_reward": -0.25086582538113, "reward_margin": 0.03858966683037582, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/142585_1/142585_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10679132491350174, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.39384710788726807, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02258129045367241, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7377744317054749, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02284896746277809, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0330859050154686, "input_change_l1": 0.12447749078273773, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7812860310077667, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12278520353138447, "edit_score": 0.2827003955841064, "background_score": 0.07502640411257744, "combined_score": 0.3368252682313323, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/142585_1/142585_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07955624908208847, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4882664978504181, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0027488090563565493, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9350064396858215, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0030733877792954445, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01240062527358532, "input_change_l1": 0.051784079521894455, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8169711530208588, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08669020654633641, "edit_score": 0.22766016125679017, "background_score": 0.015747521119192243, "combined_score": 0.25174989748513327, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142585_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05481196567416191, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5253168940544128, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0011613717069849372, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9630508422851562, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0016053213039413095, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008093977347016335, "input_change_l1": 0.033659644424915314, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8169712722301483, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0570032020099461, "edit_score": 0.19550576880574227, "background_score": 0.008551203249953686, "combined_score": 0.2107087280799169, "confidence": 0.8078851402307854}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142585_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09948710352182388, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4121508300304413, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004116296302527189, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9194205403327942, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004358051344752312, "full_mse_to_target": 0.015959227457642555, "input_change_l1": 0.06141155585646629, "directional_pixel_score": 0.814636766910553, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10351473400369286, "edit_score": 0.2633977457880974, "background_score": 0.02023218823596835, "combined_score": 0.2927778812171892, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/142585_1/142585_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07634098827838898, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.47598299384117126, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012607873417437077, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.757411003112793, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012544176541268826, "full_mse_to_target": 0.020324328914284706, "input_change_l1": 0.07694675773382187, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6903769820928574, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06834208872169256, "edit_score": 0.2585501439869404, "background_score": 0.06112567279487849, "combined_score": 0.29564498010091483, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/142585_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/142585_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/142585_1.json"}

142985_1

Let the woman smile.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.004883999936282635, "dataset_mask_area": 0.004884, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.0828111544251442, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.004904507659375668, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.07790664676576853, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.39714285714285713, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.4868651488616462, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5714000463485718, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.14503839557737722, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.1428336210200132, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.1678125094174175, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.08476926386356354, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.0828111544251442, "edit_change_ratio": 1.023645479307855, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.012303999625146389, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/142985_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.07962761601514647, "reward": -0.07962761601514647}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.10529157780483366, "reward": -0.10529157780483366}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.11596716310270129, "reward": -0.11596716310270129}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.15012773369811472, "reward": -0.15012773369811472}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.15459540313482284, "reward": -0.15459540313482284}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07962761601514647, "loser_reward": -0.10529157780483366, "reward_margin": 0.02566396178968719, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.07962761601514647, "loser_reward": -0.11596716310270129, "reward_margin": 0.036339547087554824, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.07962761601514647, "loser_reward": -0.15012773369811472, "reward_margin": 0.07050011768296825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07962761601514647, "loser_reward": -0.15459540313482284, "reward_margin": 0.07496778711967637, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10529157780483366, "loser_reward": -0.11596716310270129, "reward_margin": 0.010675585297867635, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10529157780483366, "loser_reward": -0.15012773369811472, "reward_margin": 0.04483615589328106, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10529157780483366, "loser_reward": -0.15459540313482284, "reward_margin": 0.049303825329989184, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11596716310270129, "loser_reward": -0.15012773369811472, "reward_margin": 0.03416057059541343, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11596716310270129, "loser_reward": -0.15459540313482284, "reward_margin": 0.03862824003212155, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 1221, "bbox_xyxy": [24, 356, 68, 402], "component_score": 0.07962761601514647, "component_reward": -0.07962761601514647, "second_component_score": 0.10529157780483366, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.02566396178968719, "confidence": 0.8878954901080229}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8878954648971558, "teacher_quality_score": 0.1428336210200132, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.1428336210200132, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07962761601514647, "loser_reward": -0.10529157780483366, "reward_margin": 0.02566396178968719, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.07962761601514647, "loser_reward": -0.11596716310270129, "reward_margin": 0.036339547087554824, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.07962761601514647, "loser_reward": -0.15012773369811472, "reward_margin": 0.07050011768296825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07962761601514647, "loser_reward": -0.15459540313482284, "reward_margin": 0.07496778711967637, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10529157780483366, "loser_reward": -0.11596716310270129, "reward_margin": 0.010675585297867635, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10529157780483366, "loser_reward": -0.15012773369811472, "reward_margin": 0.04483615589328106, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10529157780483366, "loser_reward": -0.15459540313482284, "reward_margin": 0.049303825329989184, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11596716310270129, "loser_reward": -0.15012773369811472, "reward_margin": 0.03416057059541343, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "142985_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11596716310270129, "loser_reward": -0.15459540313482284, "reward_margin": 0.03862824003212155, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/142985_1/142985_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04755124822258949, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7077362537384033, "background_mse_to_source": 0.033421777188777924, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.34617194533348083, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03308439999818802, "full_mse_to_target": 0.033155057579278946, "input_change_l1": 0.13293376564979553, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6343399435281754, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10585693717002868, "edit_score": 0.19741901159286498, "background_score": 0.16418738812208175, "combined_score": 0.27937149062752725, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/142985_1/142985_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04110069200396538, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7379367351531982, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0016556568443775177, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9684731364250183, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0019713661167770624, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002162473974749446, "input_change_l1": 0.015346041880548, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6116911619901657, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07047188822180032, "edit_score": 0.1905905544757843, "background_score": 0.007961029559373856, "combined_score": 0.20768753986340013, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142985_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.021348293870687485, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8076798915863037, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0006995150470174849, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9807650446891785, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0010500762145966291, "full_mse_to_target": 0.001149212708696723, "input_change_l1": 0.009974922984838486, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6116911545395851, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04608392044901848, "edit_score": 0.15688952691853048, "background_score": 0.004546506109181792, "combined_score": 0.1678125094174175, "confidence": 0.7627125784084237}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/142985_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06116921827197075, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6723933815956116, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002572375349700451, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9603212475776672, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002863309346139431, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0031480754259973764, "input_change_l1": 0.019170962274074554, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6116911545395851, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08740404434502125, "edit_score": 0.22376775331795218, "background_score": 0.010508125834167005, "combined_score": 0.24524121377151462, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/142985_1/142985_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.01936754211783409, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7855184078216553, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01008615456521511, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7344534993171692, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01016332022845745, "full_mse_to_target": 0.010208272375166416, "input_change_l1": 0.06570412963628769, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6254725009202957, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06747639924287796, "edit_score": 0.1558957353234291, "background_score": 0.06319545470178128, "combined_score": 0.1925302515551448, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/142985_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/142985_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/142985_1.json"}

145741_1

have a fly sit on the laptop

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.0856039971113205, "dataset_mask_area": 0.085604, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.227788507938385, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00896108616143465, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.21882742177695036, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7573014875340457, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8800214247455811, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4047040343284607, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.34490445727085906, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.015163723029163523, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.26465326922014354, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.05217324197292328, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2277885228395462, "edit_change_ratio": 0.22904245272126378, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.21567849814891815, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9468365458467004}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.12460000067949295, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/145741_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.6141936779022217, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.38580629229545593}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1767369254156947, "reward": -0.1767369254156947}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1999856722566764, "reward": -0.1999856722566764}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.20056051852088416, "reward": -0.20056051852088416}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2009253481737105, "reward": -0.2009253481737105}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3562280050143599, "reward": -0.3562280050143599}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "145741_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1767369254156947, "loser_reward": -0.1999856722566764, "reward_margin": 0.023248746840981716, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1767369254156947, "loser_reward": -0.20056051852088416, "reward_margin": 0.023823593105189472, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1767369254156947, "loser_reward": -0.2009253481737105, "reward_margin": 0.024188422758015804, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1767369254156947, "loser_reward": -0.3562280050143599, "reward_margin": 0.17949107959866523, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1999856722566764, "loser_reward": -0.3562280050143599, "reward_margin": 0.1562423327576835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20056051852088416, "loser_reward": -0.3562280050143599, "reward_margin": 0.15566748649347575, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2009253481737105, "loser_reward": -0.3562280050143599, "reward_margin": 0.15530265684064942, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 21401, "bbox_xyxy": [276, 297, 479, 488], "component_score": 0.1767369254156947, "component_reward": -0.1767369254156947, "second_component_score": 0.1999856722566764, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.023248746840981716, "confidence": 0.7453707354972716}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7453708052635193, "teacher_quality_score": 0.015163723029163523, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.015163723029163523, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "145741_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1767369254156947, "loser_reward": -0.1999856722566764, "reward_margin": 0.023248746840981716, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1767369254156947, "loser_reward": -0.20056051852088416, "reward_margin": 0.023823593105189472, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1767369254156947, "loser_reward": -0.2009253481737105, "reward_margin": 0.024188422758015804, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1767369254156947, "loser_reward": -0.3562280050143599, "reward_margin": 0.17949107959866523, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1999856722566764, "loser_reward": -0.3562280050143599, "reward_margin": 0.1562423327576835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20056051852088416, "loser_reward": -0.3562280050143599, "reward_margin": 0.15566748649347575, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "145741_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2009253481737105, "loser_reward": -0.3562280050143599, "reward_margin": 0.15530265684064942, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/145741_1/145741_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.18570581078529358, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5141802430152893, "background_mse_to_source": 0.07518704980611801, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4057070016860962, "background_mse_to_target": 0.073748879134655, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0833328515291214, "input_change_l1": 0.20781564712524414, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5188283436000347, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1947292473167181, "edit_score": 0.403162676282227, "background_score": 0.1940456494688988, "combined_score": 0.5183577882125974, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/145741_1/145741_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08299653977155685, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5493276715278625, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0016483016079291701, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.980638325214386, "background_mse_to_target": 0.001989967655390501, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008924456313252449, "input_change_l1": 0.013598866760730743, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5009718590881675, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.009148049401119351, "edit_score": 0.2978880406939425, "background_score": 0.005520636565051973, "combined_score": 0.30254231900325973, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/145741_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08277877420186996, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5492286086082458, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0006964075146242976, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9862961173057556, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0010899573098868132, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008082847110927105, "input_change_l1": 0.008839258924126625, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5009718609508127, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.00597039416898042, "edit_score": 0.2976900872425176, "background_score": 0.003437184053473175, "combined_score": 0.30089546520612204, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/145741_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08321025222539902, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5493343472480774, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0025658917147666216, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9768360257148743, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0028705040458589792, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009747907519340515, "input_change_l1": 0.016966799274086952, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5009856830583885, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01140852749813348, "edit_score": 0.2980969620111864, "background_score": 0.007198686571791769, "combined_score": 0.3038729985628743, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/145741_1/145741_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06714395433664322, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5611056685447693, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0200821440666914, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7496873736381531, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01933489367365837, "full_mse_to_target": 0.023427538573741913, "input_change_l1": 0.09511219710111618, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7177472710609436, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06136939115822315, "edit_score": 0.22548600286245346, "background_score": 0.07014466933906079, "combined_score": 0.26465326922014354, "confidence": 0.7514546118954334}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/145741_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/145741_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/145741_1.json"}

147546_1

remove bananas and add grapes

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.2707439959049225, "dataset_mask_area": 0.270744, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.25482404232025146, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.011761321686208248, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.24306272063404322, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8757380259785145, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9719349837779092, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06797385215759277, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.28235504031181335, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3870286831025814, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.3265954592553317, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.39509618094190957, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1442556232213974, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2548240125179291, "edit_change_ratio": 0.566099017890819, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.3219279944896698, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/147546_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6379384994506836, "pix2pix": 0.3620615303516388}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.26195148229971527, "reward": -0.26195148229971527}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2902728612478822, "reward": -0.2902728612478822}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2947267537694424, "reward": -0.2947267537694424}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.323105664620176, "reward": -0.323105664620176}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.37136429429426787, "reward": -0.37136429429426787}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "147546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26195148229971527, "loser_reward": -0.2902728612478822, "reward_margin": 0.028321378948166942, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.26195148229971527, "loser_reward": -0.2947267537694424, "reward_margin": 0.03277527146972714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.26195148229971527, "loser_reward": -0.323105664620176, "reward_margin": 0.061154182320460715, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.26195148229971527, "loser_reward": -0.37136429429426787, "reward_margin": 0.1094128119945526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2902728612478822, "loser_reward": -0.323105664620176, "reward_margin": 0.03283280337229377, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2902728612478822, "loser_reward": -0.37136429429426787, "reward_margin": 0.08109143304638566, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2947267537694424, "loser_reward": -0.323105664620176, "reward_margin": 0.028378910850733574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2947267537694424, "loser_reward": -0.37136429429426787, "reward_margin": 0.07663754052482546, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.323105664620176, "loser_reward": -0.37136429429426787, "reward_margin": 0.04825862967409189, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 67686, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 179, 500, 358], "component_score": 0.26195148229971527, "component_reward": -0.26195148229971527, "second_component_score": 0.2902728612478822, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.028321378948166942, "confidence": 0.7172177857026029}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7172178030014038, "teacher_quality_score": 0.3265954592553317, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.3265954592553317, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "147546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26195148229971527, "loser_reward": -0.2902728612478822, "reward_margin": 0.028321378948166942, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.26195148229971527, "loser_reward": -0.2947267537694424, "reward_margin": 0.03277527146972714, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.26195148229971527, "loser_reward": -0.323105664620176, "reward_margin": 0.061154182320460715, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.26195148229971527, "loser_reward": -0.37136429429426787, "reward_margin": 0.1094128119945526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2902728612478822, "loser_reward": -0.323105664620176, "reward_margin": 0.03283280337229377, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2902728612478822, "loser_reward": -0.37136429429426787, "reward_margin": 0.08109143304638566, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2947267537694424, "loser_reward": -0.323105664620176, "reward_margin": 0.028378910850733574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2947267537694424, "loser_reward": -0.37136429429426787, "reward_margin": 0.07663754052482546, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147546_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.323105664620176, "loser_reward": -0.37136429429426787, "reward_margin": 0.04825862967409189, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/147546_1/147546_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11218481510877609, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.28147605061531067, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0679137110710144, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5248914957046509, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06654438376426697, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0789012610912323, "input_change_l1": 0.2078402042388916, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6945882886648178, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15303171928972004, "edit_score": 0.33224253281950955, "background_score": 0.16293541193008423, "combined_score": 0.4277663969621063, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/147546_1/147546_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.16046348214149475, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.2599256634712219, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03690939024090767, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5421124696731567, "background_mse_to_target": 0.035780273377895355, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06953751295804977, "input_change_l1": 0.1648240089416504, "directional_pixel_score": 0.627755880355835, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13664223570376635, "edit_score": 0.40153937935829165, "background_score": 0.12848689630627633, "combined_score": 0.48079199150204666, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/147546_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11874963343143463, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.30791470408439636, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01559421606361866, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7565370202064514, "background_mse_to_target": 0.015174133703112602, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04321657866239548, "input_change_l1": 0.10713562369346619, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6277559548616409, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09023217484354973, "edit_score": 0.35022770389914515, "background_score": 0.06428681202232839, "combined_score": 0.39509618094190957, "confidence": 0.6312002560476736}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/147546_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1969044804573059, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.22631871700286865, "background_mse_to_source": 0.053945474326610565, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.435767263174057, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05237002670764923, "full_mse_to_target": 0.09150184690952301, "input_change_l1": 0.20088259875774384, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6275012791156769, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1616075146943331, "edit_score": 0.44476541727781294, "background_score": 0.16679202169179919, "combined_score": 0.5446143124997616, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/147546_1/147546_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12561707198619843, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.2872232496738434, "background_mse_to_source": 0.019118433818221092, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7163000702857971, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01832234114408493, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0473717600107193, "input_change_l1": 0.11529123038053513, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6205617561936378, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09829193223267793, "edit_score": 0.3630319830030203, "background_score": 0.07585841976106167, "combined_score": 0.4139779923669994, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/147546_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/147546_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/147546_1.json"}

147745_1

Let the sun shine.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.016276000067591667, "dataset_mask_area": 0.016276, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.3800143301486969, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.008953262120485306, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3710610680282116, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.5056923484246757, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.5229295003422314, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.546656608581543, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.45266132985286195, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.21414300474978518, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2474022201821208, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.2229761928319931, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.3800143301486969, "edit_change_ratio": 0.586757327663786, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.032683998346328735, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/147745_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.19015913047268987, "reward": -0.19015913047268987}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2695054286313244, "reward": -0.2695054286313244}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2711705771824345, "reward": -0.2711705771824345}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2742957069808617, "reward": -0.2742957069808617}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.33913606706680727, "reward": -0.33913606706680727}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "147745_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19015913047268987, "loser_reward": -0.2695054286313244, "reward_margin": 0.0793462981586345, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.19015913047268987, "loser_reward": -0.2711705771824345, "reward_margin": 0.08101144670974461, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19015913047268987, "loser_reward": -0.2742957069808617, "reward_margin": 0.08413657650817183, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19015913047268987, "loser_reward": -0.33913606706680727, "reward_margin": 0.1489769365941174, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2695054286313244, "loser_reward": -0.33913606706680727, "reward_margin": 0.0696306384354829, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2711705771824345, "loser_reward": -0.33913606706680727, "reward_margin": 0.06796548988437279, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2742957069808617, "loser_reward": -0.33913606706680727, "reward_margin": 0.06484036008594557, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4069, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 0, 99, 86], "component_score": 0.19015913047268987, "component_reward": -0.19015913047268987, "second_component_score": 0.2695054286313244, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0793462981586345, "confidence": 0.9220202190138216}], "teacher_confidence": 0.9220200181007385, "teacher_quality_score": 0.21414300474978518, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.21414300474978518, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "147745_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19015913047268987, "loser_reward": -0.2695054286313244, "reward_margin": 0.0793462981586345, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.19015913047268987, "loser_reward": -0.2711705771824345, "reward_margin": 0.08101144670974461, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19015913047268987, "loser_reward": -0.2742957069808617, "reward_margin": 0.08413657650817183, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19015913047268987, "loser_reward": -0.33913606706680727, "reward_margin": 0.1489769365941174, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2695054286313244, "loser_reward": -0.33913606706680727, "reward_margin": 0.0696306384354829, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2711705771824345, "loser_reward": -0.33913606706680727, "reward_margin": 0.06796548988437279, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "147745_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2742957069808617, "loser_reward": -0.33913606706680727, "reward_margin": 0.06484036008594557, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/147745_1/147745_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.23067530989646912, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7205736041069031, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02628965862095356, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6909992694854736, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02530408278107643, "full_mse_to_target": 0.028646713122725487, "input_change_l1": 0.11652176827192307, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6023099720478058, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10791022148914636, "edit_score": 0.3859830960631371, "background_score": 0.08808980472385883, "combined_score": 0.44126124332658945, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/147745_1/147745_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.198904350399971, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7265250086784363, "background_mse_to_source": 0.043465904891490936, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7084998488426208, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04315292835235596, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04568793624639511, "input_change_l1": 0.16064247488975525, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6739966720342636, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06522214491851627, "edit_score": 0.33510018065571784, "background_score": 0.10176593512296678, "combined_score": 0.38833148055709904, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/147745_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.203800767660141, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7287066578865051, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01836434379220009, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8590643405914307, "background_mse_to_target": 0.018308738246560097, "full_mse_to_target": 0.021327804774045944, "input_change_l1": 0.1044175922870636, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6739966869354248, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04248151173815132, "edit_score": 0.3395602643489838, "background_score": 0.04655147567391396, "combined_score": 0.36648236365988857, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/147745_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.19832932949066162, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7225109934806824, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06784436851739883, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5810148119926453, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06734578311443329, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06947766989469528, "input_change_l1": 0.20053325593471527, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6739982217550278, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08135010609403252, "edit_score": 0.3353275753557682, "background_score": 0.15164140611886978, "combined_score": 0.41161985570564863, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/147745_1/147745_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07302302867174149, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6389837265014648, "background_mse_to_source": 0.032794076949357986, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6674351096153259, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03163745626807213, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03231104835867882, "input_change_l1": 0.12205921858549118, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9115661382675171, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.21039448641240596, "edit_score": 0.16733474880456925, "background_score": 0.0993070550262928, "combined_score": 0.2474022201821208, "confidence": 0.9377417325723061}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/147745_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/147745_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/147745_1.json"}

148240_1

the boy should be holding a banana.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.009092000313103199, "dataset_mask_area": 0.009092, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.18607696890830994, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.006588751915842295, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.17948821699246764, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.592968007602154, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.6792452830188679, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3783164620399475, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.27781418922548085, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.24119061287045043, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.25421318314212843, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.08080651611089706, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.18607696890830994, "edit_change_ratio": 0.43426393166751737, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.01923999935388565, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/148240_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6251813173294067, "qwen_image_edit": 0.3748186230659485}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.15739946129580493, "reward": -0.15739946129580493}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.18297944051527887, "reward": -0.18297944051527887}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2002099455220159, "reward": -0.2002099455220159}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.20263904912769795, "reward": -0.20263904912769795}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2557998637892306, "reward": -0.2557998637892306}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15739946129580493, "loser_reward": -0.18297944051527887, "reward_margin": 0.02557997921947394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15739946129580493, "loser_reward": -0.2002099455220159, "reward_margin": 0.042810484226210976, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15739946129580493, "loser_reward": -0.20263904912769795, "reward_margin": 0.045239587831893024, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15739946129580493, "loser_reward": -0.2557998637892306, "reward_margin": 0.09840040249342566, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18297944051527887, "loser_reward": -0.2002099455220159, "reward_margin": 0.017230505006737035, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18297944051527887, "loser_reward": -0.20263904912769795, "reward_margin": 0.019659608612419083, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18297944051527887, "loser_reward": -0.2557998637892306, "reward_margin": 0.07282042327395172, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2002099455220159, "loser_reward": -0.2557998637892306, "reward_margin": 0.05558991826721468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20263904912769795, "loser_reward": -0.2557998637892306, "reward_margin": 0.053160814661532635, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 2273, "bbox_xyxy": [223, 290, 288, 356], "component_score": 0.15739946129580493, "component_reward": -0.15739946129580493, "second_component_score": 0.18297944051527887, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.02557997921947394, "confidence": 0.7783185976900995}], "teacher_confidence": 0.778318464756012, "teacher_quality_score": 0.24119061287045043, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.24119061287045043, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15739946129580493, "loser_reward": -0.18297944051527887, "reward_margin": 0.02557997921947394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15739946129580493, "loser_reward": -0.2002099455220159, "reward_margin": 0.042810484226210976, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15739946129580493, "loser_reward": -0.20263904912769795, "reward_margin": 0.045239587831893024, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15739946129580493, "loser_reward": -0.2557998637892306, "reward_margin": 0.09840040249342566, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18297944051527887, "loser_reward": -0.2002099455220159, "reward_margin": 0.017230505006737035, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18297944051527887, "loser_reward": -0.20263904912769795, "reward_margin": 0.019659608612419083, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18297944051527887, "loser_reward": -0.2557998637892306, "reward_margin": 0.07282042327395172, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2002099455220159, "loser_reward": -0.2557998637892306, "reward_margin": 0.05558991826721468, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20263904912769795, "loser_reward": -0.2557998637892306, "reward_margin": 0.053160814661532635, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/148240_1/148240_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10880915820598602, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5148751139640808, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04806555435061455, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4268369972705841, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04745950549840927, "full_mse_to_target": 0.048017293214797974, "input_change_l1": 0.15440794825553894, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6568299680948257, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15671541206538678, "edit_score": 0.2916266433894634, "background_score": 0.16269815489649775, "combined_score": 0.3847158093377948, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/148240_1/148240_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08222681283950806, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5479300618171692, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0007378541049547493, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9911444783210754, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0011485462309792638, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0018857101676985621, "input_change_l1": 0.009834237396717072, "directional_pixel_score": 0.634174033999443, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06866613822057843, "edit_score": 0.26409729197621346, "background_score": 0.0025089584407396613, "combined_score": 0.2788972260913578, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/148240_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06226363405585289, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5458295941352844, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0003117432934232056, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9939767718315125, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0007434574072249234, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0013027986278757453, "input_change_l1": 0.006392252165824175, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6341740190982819, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04498978350311518, "edit_score": 0.24455421045422554, "background_score": 0.0015163889271207155, "combined_score": 0.25421318314212843, "confidence": 0.7029725065378832}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/148240_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09596120566129684, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5421285033226013, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0009787731105461717, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9891290068626404, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0013708302285522223, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0022308456245809793, "input_change_l1": 0.012134133838117123, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6371045857667923, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0802543512545526, "edit_score": 0.2782593585550785, "background_score": 0.0031529717380180955, "combined_score": 0.29563685347675345, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/148240_1/148240_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07356899231672287, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5542357563972473, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014335171319544315, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6797370910644531, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014033264480531216, "full_mse_to_target": 0.014574564062058926, "input_change_l1": 0.07858502864837646, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6459504514932632, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1085626320913434, "edit_score": 0.2512342281639576, "background_score": 0.07838775310665369, "combined_score": 0.3018399245757609, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/148240_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/148240_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/148240_1.json"}

148240_2

Can the man hold bananas too?

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.045241355895996094, "dataset_mask_area": 0.045241355895996094, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2542603313922882, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0004108282446395606, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.25384950314764865, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.88945306833019, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9814310869217224, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.36720696091651917, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3998411148241403, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.24867300968302516, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3178210878558457, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.0917290598154068, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2542603015899658, "edit_change_ratio": 0.3607683120085893, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.05822467803955078, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/148240_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6393721699714661, "editar": 0.36062783002853394}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.19569964175019408, "reward": -0.19569964175019408}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2243316667098552, "reward": -0.2243316667098552}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.23128976059984416, "reward": -0.23128976059984416}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2554812637660652, "reward": -0.2554812637660652}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3743113859128207, "reward": -0.3743113859128207}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19569964175019408, "loser_reward": -0.2243316667098552, "reward_margin": 0.028632024959661107, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19569964175019408, "loser_reward": -0.23128976059984416, "reward_margin": 0.035590118849650076, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19569964175019408, "loser_reward": -0.2554812637660652, "reward_margin": 0.059781622015871144, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19569964175019408, "loser_reward": -0.3743113859128207, "reward_margin": 0.17861174416262662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2243316667098552, "loser_reward": -0.2554812637660652, "reward_margin": 0.031149597056210038, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2243316667098552, "loser_reward": -0.3743113859128207, "reward_margin": 0.14997971920296552, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23128976059984416, "loser_reward": -0.2554812637660652, "reward_margin": 0.024191503166221068, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23128976059984416, "loser_reward": -0.3743113859128207, "reward_margin": 0.14302162531297655, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2554812637660652, "loser_reward": -0.3743113859128207, "reward_margin": 0.11883012214675548, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 47439, "bbox_xyxy": [35, 512, 272, 816], "component_score": 0.19569964175019408, "component_reward": -0.19569964175019408, "second_component_score": 0.2243316667098552, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.028632024959661107, "confidence": 0.7616611733725048}], "teacher_confidence": 0.761661171913147, "teacher_quality_score": 0.24867300968302516, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.24867300968302516, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19569964175019408, "loser_reward": -0.2243316667098552, "reward_margin": 0.028632024959661107, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19569964175019408, "loser_reward": -0.23128976059984416, "reward_margin": 0.035590118849650076, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19569964175019408, "loser_reward": -0.2554812637660652, "reward_margin": 0.059781622015871144, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19569964175019408, "loser_reward": -0.3743113859128207, "reward_margin": 0.17861174416262662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2243316667098552, "loser_reward": -0.2554812637660652, "reward_margin": 0.031149597056210038, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2243316667098552, "loser_reward": -0.3743113859128207, "reward_margin": 0.14997971920296552, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23128976059984416, "loser_reward": -0.2554812637660652, "reward_margin": 0.024191503166221068, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23128976059984416, "loser_reward": -0.3743113859128207, "reward_margin": 0.14302162531297655, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "148240_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2554812637660652, "loser_reward": -0.3743113859128207, "reward_margin": 0.11883012214675548, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/148240_2/148240_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1803792119026184, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.33159783482551575, "background_mse_to_source": 0.11075630784034729, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.22630293667316437, "background_mse_to_target": 0.11078289151191711, "full_mse_to_target": 0.11393147706985474, "input_change_l1": 0.25848740339279175, "directional_pixel_score": 0.640098825097084, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.22063419353216887, "edit_score": 0.40403493866324425, "background_score": 0.26549572050571446, "combined_score": 0.5524784272536636, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/148240_2/148240_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10335114598274231, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.415387362241745, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05142001062631607, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.2613776624202728, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05140986293554306, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05375972017645836, "input_change_l1": 0.16059060394763947, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7287906557321548, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1277569237165153, "edit_score": 0.2880760096013546, "background_score": 0.19914447814226152, "combined_score": 0.388703933712095, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/148240_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08577559143304825, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.45587849617004395, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02172495611011982, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5619848966598511, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02172555774450302, "full_mse_to_target": 0.024623267352581024, "input_change_l1": 0.10438385605812073, "directional_pixel_score": 0.728790894150734, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08355684401467442, "edit_score": 0.26240216866135596, "background_score": 0.10932797677814961, "combined_score": 0.3198406560719013, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/148240_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11763611435890198, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.38997209072113037, "background_mse_to_source": 0.07306617498397827, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.1458846777677536, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0730515569448471, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07506862282752991, "input_change_l1": 0.19370824098587036, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7307321280241013, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15027411971241236, "edit_score": 0.3069586642086506, "background_score": 0.24388923943042756, "combined_score": 0.4298815842345357, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/148240_2/148240_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09336720407009125, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.45191121101379395, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0091745276004076, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7654193043708801, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009197879582643509, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0130058154463768, "input_change_l1": 0.06390059739351273, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6786029636859894, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06777276005595922, "edit_score": 0.2833342209458351, "background_score": 0.05609066672623158, "combined_score": 0.3178210878558457, "confidence": 0.5613633131460481}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/148240_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/148240_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/148240_2.json"}

150812_1

put a robot tiger next to the bear

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.21901200711727142, "dataset_mask_area": 0.219012, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2039870172739029, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.012435845099389553, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.19155117217451334, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8015443085865621, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9320867913208679, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.32332149147987366, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.32501996085773555, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.32389727391724593, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3659642422338948, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.10171404480934143, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2039870172739029, "edit_change_ratio": 0.4986299920880025, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.246971994638443, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/150812_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.613115131855011, "editar": 0.386884868144989}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2429748750561848, "reward": -0.2429748750561848}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.26599616616405547, "reward": -0.26599616616405547}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2930441651716828, "reward": -0.2930441651716828}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.294976958245039, "reward": -0.294976958245039}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.32340308280102903, "reward": -0.32340308280102903}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "150812_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2429748750561848, "loser_reward": -0.26599616616405547, "reward_margin": 0.023021291107870656, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2429748750561848, "loser_reward": -0.2930441651716828, "reward_margin": 0.05006929011549799, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2429748750561848, "loser_reward": -0.294976958245039, "reward_margin": 0.05200208318885419, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2429748750561848, "loser_reward": -0.32340308280102903, "reward_margin": 0.08042820774484422, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26599616616405547, "loser_reward": -0.2930441651716828, "reward_margin": 0.027047999007627332, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.26599616616405547, "loser_reward": -0.294976958245039, "reward_margin": 0.02898079208098353, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.26599616616405547, "loser_reward": -0.32340308280102903, "reward_margin": 0.05740691663697356, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2930441651716828, "loser_reward": -0.32340308280102903, "reward_margin": 0.030358917629346227, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.294976958245039, "loser_reward": -0.32340308280102903, "reward_margin": 0.02842612455599003, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 54753, "bbox_xyxy": [312, 148, 500, 469], "component_score": 0.2429748750561848, "component_reward": -0.2429748750561848, "second_component_score": 0.26599616616405547, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.023021291107870656, "confidence": 0.6998464507444803}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6998463273048401, "teacher_quality_score": 0.32389727391724593, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.32389727391724593, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "150812_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2429748750561848, "loser_reward": -0.26599616616405547, "reward_margin": 0.023021291107870656, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2429748750561848, "loser_reward": -0.2930441651716828, "reward_margin": 0.05006929011549799, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2429748750561848, "loser_reward": -0.294976958245039, "reward_margin": 0.05200208318885419, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2429748750561848, "loser_reward": -0.32340308280102903, "reward_margin": 0.08042820774484422, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26599616616405547, "loser_reward": -0.2930441651716828, "reward_margin": 0.027047999007627332, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.26599616616405547, "loser_reward": -0.294976958245039, "reward_margin": 0.02898079208098353, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.26599616616405547, "loser_reward": -0.32340308280102903, "reward_margin": 0.05740691663697356, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2930441651716828, "loser_reward": -0.32340308280102903, "reward_margin": 0.030358917629346227, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "150812_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.294976958245039, "loser_reward": -0.32340308280102903, "reward_margin": 0.02842612455599003, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/150812_1/150812_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10432020574808121, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.18853139877319336, "background_mse_to_source": 0.027565868571400642, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7030865550041199, "background_mse_to_target": 0.026245828717947006, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04334505274891853, "input_change_l1": 0.12448036670684814, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5786344856023788, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1005878772586584, "edit_score": 0.37195530459284787, "background_score": 0.08694855757057668, "combined_score": 0.4268393804691733, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/150812_1/150812_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11740440875291824, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.1588207483291626, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010422171093523502, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9224527478218079, "background_mse_to_target": 0.010522273369133472, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03393074870109558, "input_change_l1": 0.07064084708690643, "directional_pixel_score": 0.606706976890564, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.130880637653172, "edit_score": 0.38396351486444474, "background_score": 0.02593162152916193, "combined_score": 0.4226087848003954, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/150812_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08127603679895401, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.18820850551128387, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004403368104249239, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9546952247619629, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004685599356889725, "full_mse_to_target": 0.021459827199578285, "input_change_l1": 0.04591655731201172, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6067068949341774, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08574067223817111, "edit_score": 0.3419576119631529, "background_score": 0.013464323151856661, "combined_score": 0.3659642422338948, "confidence": 0.7025706692137534}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/150812_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13878029584884644, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.147188201546669, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014480018056929111, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9066364765167236, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014463288709521294, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04169020056724548, "input_change_l1": 0.08434166014194489, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6098772510886192, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15281982198357583, "edit_score": 0.40687334276735787, "background_score": 0.033152722753584385, "combined_score": 0.4532097801845521, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/150812_1/150812_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07708678394556046, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.18173523247241974, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03222129866480827, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6090434193611145, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03082822449505329, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04095941036939621, "input_change_l1": 0.13426123559474945, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6175537034869194, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11148251984268427, "edit_score": 0.33635131157934667, "background_score": 0.11041261479258538, "combined_score": 0.401388171762228, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/150812_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/150812_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/150812_1.json"}

151_1

Add a dear on the grass.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.07566799968481064, "dataset_mask_area": 0.075668, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.16077430546283722, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.017115145921707153, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.14365915954113007, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.5984848484848485, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.6930448083498291, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.43526363372802734, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.24319913369330506, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.23817638346350578, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2525180846033618, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.10309570282697678, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.16077430546283722, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6412448962549381, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.10041200369596481, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/151_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5956583023071289, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4043416678905487}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.15382493147533385, "reward": -0.15382493147533385}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1731952778659761, "reward": -0.1731952778659761}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19376130531914534, "reward": -0.19376130531914534}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.22867514342442152, "reward": -0.22867514342442152}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2918828952908516, "reward": -0.2918828952908516}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15382493147533385, "loser_reward": -0.1731952778659761, "reward_margin": 0.01937034639064225, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15382493147533385, "loser_reward": -0.19376130531914534, "reward_margin": 0.03993637384381149, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15382493147533385, "loser_reward": -0.22867514342442152, "reward_margin": 0.07485021194908767, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15382493147533385, "loser_reward": -0.2918828952908516, "reward_margin": 0.13805796381551774, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1731952778659761, "loser_reward": -0.19376130531914534, "reward_margin": 0.02056602745316924, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1731952778659761, "loser_reward": -0.22867514342442152, "reward_margin": 0.05547986555844542, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1731952778659761, "loser_reward": -0.2918828952908516, "reward_margin": 0.11868761742487549, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19376130531914534, "loser_reward": -0.22867514342442152, "reward_margin": 0.03491383810527618, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19376130531914534, "loser_reward": -0.2918828952908516, "reward_margin": 0.09812158997170625, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22867514342442152, "loser_reward": -0.2918828952908516, "reward_margin": 0.06320775186643007, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 18917, "bbox_xyxy": [23, 266, 156, 446], "component_score": 0.15382493147533385, "component_reward": -0.15382493147533385, "second_component_score": 0.1731952778659761, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.01937034639064225, "confidence": 0.7388784869053855}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7388783693313599, "teacher_quality_score": 0.23817638346350578, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.23817638346350578, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15382493147533385, "loser_reward": -0.1731952778659761, "reward_margin": 0.01937034639064225, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15382493147533385, "loser_reward": -0.19376130531914534, "reward_margin": 0.03993637384381149, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15382493147533385, "loser_reward": -0.22867514342442152, "reward_margin": 0.07485021194908767, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15382493147533385, "loser_reward": -0.2918828952908516, "reward_margin": 0.13805796381551774, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1731952778659761, "loser_reward": -0.19376130531914534, "reward_margin": 0.02056602745316924, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1731952778659761, "loser_reward": -0.22867514342442152, "reward_margin": 0.05547986555844542, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1731952778659761, "loser_reward": -0.2918828952908516, "reward_margin": 0.11868761742487549, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19376130531914534, "loser_reward": -0.22867514342442152, "reward_margin": 0.03491383810527618, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19376130531914534, "loser_reward": -0.2918828952908516, "reward_margin": 0.09812158997170625, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "151_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22867514342442152, "loser_reward": -0.2918828952908516, "reward_margin": 0.06320775186643007, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/151_1/151_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10467270016670227, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3295588493347168, "background_mse_to_source": 0.13033178448677063, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.27421316504478455, "background_mse_to_target": 0.12746931612491608, "full_mse_to_target": 0.12574438750743866, "input_change_l1": 0.29876577854156494, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6555451899766922, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.19604344815015795, "edit_score": 0.3248746328055859, "background_score": 0.2754891514778137, "combined_score": 0.47307896420359613, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/151_1/151_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04580477997660637, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3538081645965576, "background_mse_to_source": 0.011284150183200836, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8273043632507324, "background_mse_to_target": 0.011166052892804146, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013787095434963703, "input_change_l1": 0.06742854416370392, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7243529558181763, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09174691550433636, "edit_score": 0.24395490810275078, "background_score": 0.04582327753305435, "combined_score": 0.27972114788368346, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/151_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.035577576607465744, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.36185622215270996, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0047675552777945995, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9166719913482666, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005107952747493982, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007413525599986315, "input_change_l1": 0.04382854700088501, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7243529558181763, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0607851693406701, "edit_score": 0.2321180932223797, "background_score": 0.02143315700814128, "combined_score": 0.2525180846033618, "confidence": 0.7167250041971318}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/151_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05882374197244644, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.33621135354042053, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01751301810145378, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7701862454414368, "background_mse_to_target": 0.017068156972527504, "full_mse_to_target": 0.020227720960974693, "input_change_l1": 0.08414271473884583, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7246423363685608, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11073959115892648, "edit_score": 0.2604208871722221, "background_score": 0.06347576901316643, "combined_score": 0.30680809665471315, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/151_1/151_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.060663845390081406, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.321548730134964, "background_mse_to_source": 0.035627901554107666, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4274942874908447, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03337043151259422, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03543567284941673, "input_change_l1": 0.14334048330783844, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6916413754224777, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1395228046923876, "edit_score": 0.2734437555074692, "background_score": 0.15012904405593874, "combined_score": 0.3574370491504669, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/151_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/151_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/151_1.json"}

153639_1

let the man cut pizza with a knife

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.13628800213336945, "dataset_mask_area": 0.136288, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2884824573993683, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.007851061411201954, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.28063139598816633, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8876165037508524, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9653861606453009, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3369562327861786, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4257608228640807, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.27117548236710715, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3367474377341569, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1190313845872879, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2884824275970459, "edit_change_ratio": 0.412612253643233, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1865440011024475, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/153639_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5782257914543152, "editar": 0.4217742383480072}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22679195588827136, "reward": -0.22679195588827136}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2425666742809117, "reward": -0.2425666742809117}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2770114036593586, "reward": -0.2770114036593586}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.29540959026105706, "reward": -0.29540959026105706}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.3188439050726593, "reward": -0.3188439050726593}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22679195588827136, "loser_reward": -0.2425666742809117, "reward_margin": 0.01577471839264033, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22679195588827136, "loser_reward": -0.2770114036593586, "reward_margin": 0.05021944777108725, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22679195588827136, "loser_reward": -0.29540959026105706, "reward_margin": 0.0686176343727857, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22679195588827136, "loser_reward": -0.3188439050726593, "reward_margin": 0.09205194918438794, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2425666742809117, "loser_reward": -0.2770114036593586, "reward_margin": 0.03444472937844692, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2425666742809117, "loser_reward": -0.29540959026105706, "reward_margin": 0.05284291598014537, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2425666742809117, "loser_reward": -0.3188439050726593, "reward_margin": 0.07627723079174761, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2770114036593586, "loser_reward": -0.29540959026105706, "reward_margin": 0.018398186601698452, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2770114036593586, "loser_reward": -0.3188439050726593, "reward_margin": 0.04183250141330069, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.29540959026105706, "loser_reward": -0.3188439050726593, "reward_margin": 0.02343431481160224, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 34072, "bbox_xyxy": [78, 78, 422, 264], "component_score": 0.22679195588827136, "component_reward": -0.22679195588827136, "second_component_score": 0.2425666742809117, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.01577471839264033, "confidence": 0.6644876948089615}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6644877791404724, "teacher_quality_score": 0.27117548236710715, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.27117548236710715, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22679195588827136, "loser_reward": -0.2425666742809117, "reward_margin": 0.01577471839264033, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22679195588827136, "loser_reward": -0.2770114036593586, "reward_margin": 0.05021944777108725, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22679195588827136, "loser_reward": -0.29540959026105706, "reward_margin": 0.0686176343727857, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22679195588827136, "loser_reward": -0.3188439050726593, "reward_margin": 0.09205194918438794, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2425666742809117, "loser_reward": -0.2770114036593586, "reward_margin": 0.03444472937844692, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2425666742809117, "loser_reward": -0.29540959026105706, "reward_margin": 0.05284291598014537, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2425666742809117, "loser_reward": -0.3188439050726593, "reward_margin": 0.07627723079174761, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2770114036593586, "loser_reward": -0.29540959026105706, "reward_margin": 0.018398186601698452, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2770114036593586, "loser_reward": -0.3188439050726593, "reward_margin": 0.04183250141330069, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.29540959026105706, "loser_reward": -0.3188439050726593, "reward_margin": 0.02343431481160224, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/153639_1/153639_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14382939040660858, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4931061565876007, "background_mse_to_source": 0.09615737199783325, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.23789441585540771, "background_mse_to_target": 0.09552043676376343, "full_mse_to_target": 0.10210433602333069, "input_change_l1": 0.24434153735637665, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7166006714105606, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1789538638666272, "edit_score": 0.3160579912364483, "background_score": 0.2485784888267517, "combined_score": 0.4490616687014699, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/153639_1/153639_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14009195566177368, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.48403629660606384, "background_mse_to_source": 0.15199944376945496, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.2008066326379776, "background_mse_to_target": 0.1509411782026291, "full_mse_to_target": 0.14946255087852478, "input_change_l1": 0.30276501178741455, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7420203387737274, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.19782736543565987, "edit_score": 0.3077796116471291, "background_score": 0.31183811724185945, "combined_score": 0.4714346808567643, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/153639_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11295653879642487, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5063065886497498, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06421975046396255, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.486371248960495, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06374357640743256, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07045071572065353, "input_change_l1": 0.19679729640483856, "directional_pixel_score": 0.742020383477211, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1293869972229004, "edit_score": 0.2761901251971722, "background_score": 0.16694550067186356, "combined_score": 0.36754352144896985, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/153639_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.16772893071174622, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.46324387192726135, "background_mse_to_source": 0.2125459462404251, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.10172325372695923, "background_mse_to_target": 0.21115629374980927, "full_mse_to_target": 0.20523767173290253, "input_change_l1": 0.3632446527481079, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7448935359716415, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.23596025072038174, "edit_score": 0.33885677233338357, "background_score": 0.39220129549503324, "combined_score": 0.5438430430740119, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/153639_1/153639_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11947079747915268, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.516869068145752, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017928002402186394, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6961798667907715, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01762988790869713, "full_mse_to_target": 0.031509581953287125, "input_change_l1": 0.09468381106853485, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7086978852748871, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08565878421068192, "edit_score": 0.28892251253128054, "background_score": 0.07869202904403211, "combined_score": 0.3367474377341569, "confidence": 0.6954156117408993}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/153639_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/153639_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/153639_1.json"}

153639_2

make it a pepperoni pizza

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.19892120361328125, "dataset_mask_area": 0.19892120361328125, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.4332670569419861, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.1110972911119461, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.32216976583004, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6882945133555298, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.7316497072258266, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.2745097875595093, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.09285078197717667, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4340310957217366, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.2287675660662353, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.26993065679445866, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.19375617802143097, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.4332670569419861, "edit_change_ratio": 0.447198038523789, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.3337898254394531, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/153639_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5207663774490356, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.47923365235328674}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.15663373367302116, "reward": -0.15663373367302116}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.16078940296918154, "reward": -0.16078940296918154}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1670020797420293, "reward": -0.1670020797420293}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.28554180763103065, "reward": -0.28554180763103065}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.30729946065135305, "reward": -0.30729946065135305}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15663373367302116, "loser_reward": -0.1670020797420293, "reward_margin": 0.010368346069008133, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15663373367302116, "loser_reward": -0.28554180763103065, "reward_margin": 0.1289080739580095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15663373367302116, "loser_reward": -0.30729946065135305, "reward_margin": 0.1506657269783319, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16078940296918154, "loser_reward": -0.28554180763103065, "reward_margin": 0.12475240466184911, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16078940296918154, "loser_reward": -0.30729946065135305, "reward_margin": 0.1465100576821715, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1670020797420293, "loser_reward": -0.28554180763103065, "reward_margin": 0.11853972788900136, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1670020797420293, "loser_reward": -0.30729946065135305, "reward_margin": 0.14029738090932375, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.28554180763103065, "loser_reward": -0.30729946065135305, "reward_margin": 0.0217576530203224, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 25140, "bbox_xyxy": [428, 18, 774, 335], "component_score": 0.15663373367302116, "component_reward": -0.15663373367302116, "second_component_score": 0.16078940296918154, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.004155669296160375, "confidence": 0.596356708141984}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5549272298812866, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.4450727701187134}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.13694167704693974, "reward": -0.13694167704693974}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.14797163318283857, "reward": -0.14797163318283857}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.16911476666480302, "reward": -0.16911476666480302}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.34145817029662434, "reward": -0.34145817029662434}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.38362010619975623, "reward": -0.38362010619975623}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13694167704693974, "loser_reward": -0.14797163318283857, "reward_margin": 0.011029956135898827, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.13694167704693974, "loser_reward": -0.16911476666480302, "reward_margin": 0.032173089617863276, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13694167704693974, "loser_reward": -0.34145817029662434, "reward_margin": 0.2045164932496846, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13694167704693974, "loser_reward": -0.38362010619975623, "reward_margin": 0.2466784291528165, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.14797163318283857, "loser_reward": -0.16911476666480302, "reward_margin": 0.02114313348196445, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14797163318283857, "loser_reward": -0.34145817029662434, "reward_margin": 0.19348653711378577, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14797163318283857, "loser_reward": -0.38362010619975623, "reward_margin": 0.23564847301691766, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16911476666480302, "loser_reward": -0.34145817029662434, "reward_margin": 0.17234340363182132, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16911476666480302, "loser_reward": -0.38362010619975623, "reward_margin": 0.2145053395349532, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.34145817029662434, "loser_reward": -0.38362010619975623, "reward_margin": 0.042161935903131886, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 10657, "bbox_xyxy": [256, 84, 412, 246], "component_score": 0.13694167704693974, "component_reward": -0.13694167704693974, "second_component_score": 0.14797163318283857, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.011029956135898827, "confidence": 0.6803341817326034}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5155518651008606, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4844481348991394}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1828476216867566, "reward": -0.1828476216867566}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.18595899091474713, "reward": -0.18595899091474713}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2071879410315305, "reward": -0.2071879410315305}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2990740110669285, "reward": -0.2990740110669285}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3318133817929775, "reward": -0.3318133817929775}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1828476216867566, "loser_reward": -0.2071879410315305, "reward_margin": 0.024340319344773875, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1828476216867566, "loser_reward": -0.2990740110669285, "reward_margin": 0.11622638938017188, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1828476216867566, "loser_reward": -0.3318133817929775, "reward_margin": 0.14896576010622087, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18595899091474713, "loser_reward": -0.2071879410315305, "reward_margin": 0.021228950116783357, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18595899091474713, "loser_reward": -0.2990740110669285, "reward_margin": 0.11311502015218136, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18595899091474713, "loser_reward": -0.3318133817929775, "reward_margin": 0.14585439087823035, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2071879410315305, "loser_reward": -0.2990740110669285, "reward_margin": 0.091886070035398, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2071879410315305, "loser_reward": -0.3318133817929775, "reward_margin": 0.12462544076144699, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2990740110669285, "loser_reward": -0.3318133817929775, "reward_margin": 0.03273937072604899, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 25642, "bbox_xyxy": [736, 85, 1024, 376], "component_score": 0.1828476216867566, "component_reward": -0.1828476216867566, "second_component_score": 0.18595899091474713, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.003111369227990518, "confidence": 0.5800717738694}, {"component_id": 3, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6155967116355896, "qwen_image_edit": 0.384403258562088}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.14011822605878116, "reward": -0.14011822605878116}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16366322086565196, "reward": -0.16366322086565196}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19776490713842215, "reward": -0.19776490713842215}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2743269374165684, "reward": -0.2743269374165684}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3076942907590419, "reward": -0.3076942907590419}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14011822605878116, "loser_reward": -0.16366322086565196, "reward_margin": 0.023544994806870806, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14011822605878116, "loser_reward": -0.19776490713842215, "reward_margin": 0.05764668107964099, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14011822605878116, "loser_reward": -0.2743269374165684, "reward_margin": 0.13420871135778722, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14011822605878116, "loser_reward": -0.3076942907590419, "reward_margin": 0.16757606470026076, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16366322086565196, "loser_reward": -0.19776490713842215, "reward_margin": 0.03410168627277019, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16366322086565196, "loser_reward": -0.2743269374165684, "reward_margin": 0.11066371655091642, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16366322086565196, "loser_reward": -0.3076942907590419, "reward_margin": 0.14403106989338996, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19776490713842215, "loser_reward": -0.2743269374165684, "reward_margin": 0.07656203027814623, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19776490713842215, "loser_reward": -0.3076942907590419, "reward_margin": 0.10992938362061977, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2743269374165684, "loser_reward": -0.3076942907590419, "reward_margin": 0.03336735334247354, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 3521, "bbox_xyxy": [627, 153, 714, 234], "component_score": 0.14011822605878116, "component_reward": -0.14011822605878116, "second_component_score": 0.16366322086565196, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.023544994806870806, "confidence": 0.7837076516792185}, {"component_id": 4, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.505088746547699, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4949112832546234}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.21711064244061712, "reward": -0.21711064244061712}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.21812842534296215, "reward": -0.21812842534296215}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.22975871052034197, "reward": -0.22975871052034197}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.29234571359492834, "reward": -0.29234571359492834}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3584925608653575, "reward": -0.3584925608653575}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21711064244061712, "loser_reward": -0.22975871052034197, "reward_margin": 0.01264806807972485, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21711064244061712, "loser_reward": -0.29234571359492834, "reward_margin": 0.07523507115431122, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21711064244061712, "loser_reward": -0.3584925608653575, "reward_margin": 0.1413819184247404, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21812842534296215, "loser_reward": -0.22975871052034197, "reward_margin": 0.011630285177379823, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21812842534296215, "loser_reward": -0.29234571359492834, "reward_margin": 0.07421728825196619, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21812842534296215, "loser_reward": -0.3584925608653575, "reward_margin": 0.14036413552239538, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22975871052034197, "loser_reward": -0.29234571359492834, "reward_margin": 0.06258700307458637, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22975871052034197, "loser_reward": -0.3584925608653575, "reward_margin": 0.12873385034501555, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.29234571359492834, "loser_reward": -0.3584925608653575, "reward_margin": 0.06614684727042919, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 54736, "bbox_xyxy": [536, 393, 1024, 774], "component_score": 0.21711064244061712, "component_reward": -0.21711064244061712, "second_component_score": 0.21812842534296215, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0010177829023450269, "confidence": 0.5583977876485643}, {"component_id": 5, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5619532465934753, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4380466938018799}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.235302556021139, "reward": -0.235302556021139}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2477572079971433, "reward": -0.2477572079971433}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.24876603271253406, "reward": -0.24876603271253406}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.28871011338569225, "reward": -0.28871011338569225}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.33130447435565297, "reward": -0.33130447435565297}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.235302556021139, "loser_reward": -0.2477572079971433, "reward_margin": 0.012454651976004288, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.235302556021139, "loser_reward": -0.24876603271253406, "reward_margin": 0.013463476691395054, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.235302556021139, "loser_reward": -0.28871011338569225, "reward_margin": 0.05340755736455324, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.235302556021139, "loser_reward": -0.33130447435565297, "reward_margin": 0.09600191833451396, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2477572079971433, "loser_reward": -0.28871011338569225, "reward_margin": 0.040952905388548955, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2477572079971433, "loser_reward": -0.33130447435565297, "reward_margin": 0.08354726635850968, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24876603271253406, "loser_reward": -0.28871011338569225, "reward_margin": 0.03994408067315819, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24876603271253406, "loser_reward": -0.33130447435565297, "reward_margin": 0.08253844164311891, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.28871011338569225, "loser_reward": -0.33130447435565297, "reward_margin": 0.04259436096996072, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 2401, "bbox_xyxy": [717, 398, 800, 457], "component_score": 0.235302556021139, "component_reward": -0.235302556021139, "second_component_score": 0.2477572079971433, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.012454651976004288, "confidence": 0.6392851292876796}, {"component_id": 6, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5852892994880676, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4147107005119324}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2995383974388242, "reward": -0.2995383974388242}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.31676463828794654, "reward": -0.31676463828794654}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.344312686579302, "reward": -0.344312686579302}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3618097802195698, "reward": -0.3618097802195698}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.4510235147494823, "reward": -0.4510235147494823}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2995383974388242, "loser_reward": -0.31676463828794654, "reward_margin": 0.017226240849122332, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2995383974388242, "loser_reward": -0.344312686579302, "reward_margin": 0.04477428914047776, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2995383974388242, "loser_reward": -0.3618097802195698, "reward_margin": 0.062271382780745566, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2995383974388242, "loser_reward": -0.4510235147494823, "reward_margin": 0.1514851173106581, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.31676463828794654, "loser_reward": -0.344312686579302, "reward_margin": 0.02754804829135543, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.31676463828794654, "loser_reward": -0.3618097802195698, "reward_margin": 0.045045141931623234, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.31676463828794654, "loser_reward": -0.4510235147494823, "reward_margin": 0.13425887646153578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.344312686579302, "loser_reward": -0.3618097802195698, "reward_margin": 0.017497093640267802, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.344312686579302, "loser_reward": -0.4510235147494823, "reward_margin": 0.10671082817018035, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.3618097802195698, "loser_reward": -0.4510235147494823, "reward_margin": 0.08921373452991255, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 9925, "bbox_xyxy": [784, 404, 947, 548], "component_score": 0.2995383974388242, "component_reward": -0.2995383974388242, "second_component_score": 0.31676463828794654, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.017226240849122332, "confidence": 0.6463720084383666}, {"component_id": 7, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.5737799406051636, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4262200891971588}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.206772147634998, "reward": -0.206772147634998}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22163664663583044, "reward": -0.22163664663583044}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.22543692634813486, "reward": -0.22543692634813486}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.23317080225236714, "reward": -0.23317080225236714}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.32662972080893815, "reward": -0.32662972080893815}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_2__region7__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 7, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.206772147634998, "loser_reward": -0.22163664663583044, "reward_margin": 0.014864499000832448, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 7, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.206772147634998, "loser_reward": -0.22543692634813486, "reward_margin": 0.018664778713136876, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.206772147634998, "loser_reward": -0.23317080225236714, "reward_margin": 0.02639865461736915, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.206772147634998, "loser_reward": -0.32662972080893815, "reward_margin": 0.11985757317394016, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22163664663583044, "loser_reward": -0.23317080225236714, "reward_margin": 0.011534155616536701, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22163664663583044, "loser_reward": -0.32662972080893815, "reward_margin": 0.10499307417310771, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22543692634813486, "loser_reward": -0.32662972080893815, "reward_margin": 0.10119279446080329, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23317080225236714, "loser_reward": -0.32662972080893815, "reward_margin": 0.09345891855657101, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 38135, "bbox_xyxy": [92, 519, 526, 829], "component_score": 0.206772147634998, "component_reward": -0.206772147634998, "second_component_score": 0.22163664663583044, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.014864499000832448, "confidence": 0.667905546663631}, {"component_id": 8, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5421544909477234, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.457845538854599}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1407507886122912, "reward": -0.1407507886122912}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1492017545867711, "reward": -0.1492017545867711}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1522264968827367, "reward": -0.1522264968827367}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.20559552512504162, "reward": -0.20559552512504162}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2912429170627147, "reward": -0.2912429170627147}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1407507886122912, "loser_reward": -0.1522264968827367, "reward_margin": 0.0114757082704455, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1407507886122912, "loser_reward": -0.20559552512504162, "reward_margin": 0.06484473651275041, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1407507886122912, "loser_reward": -0.2912429170627147, "reward_margin": 0.1504921284504235, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1492017545867711, "loser_reward": -0.20559552512504162, "reward_margin": 0.05639377053827052, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1492017545867711, "loser_reward": -0.2912429170627147, "reward_margin": 0.14204116247594362, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1522264968827367, "loser_reward": -0.20559552512504162, "reward_margin": 0.05336902824230491, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1522264968827367, "loser_reward": -0.2912429170627147, "reward_margin": 0.139016420179978, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20559552512504162, "loser_reward": -0.2912429170627147, "reward_margin": 0.0856473919376731, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 38427, "bbox_xyxy": [420, 751, 993, 950], "component_score": 0.1407507886122912, "component_reward": -0.1407507886122912, "second_component_score": 0.1492017545867711, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.00845096597447989, "confidence": 0.6502447284968972}], "teacher_confidence": 0.617729663848877, "teacher_quality_score": 0.2287675660662353, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.2287675660662353, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15663373367302116, "loser_reward": -0.1670020797420293, "reward_margin": 0.010368346069008133, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15663373367302116, "loser_reward": -0.28554180763103065, "reward_margin": 0.1289080739580095, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15663373367302116, "loser_reward": -0.30729946065135305, "reward_margin": 0.1506657269783319, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16078940296918154, "loser_reward": -0.28554180763103065, "reward_margin": 0.12475240466184911, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16078940296918154, "loser_reward": -0.30729946065135305, "reward_margin": 0.1465100576821715, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1670020797420293, "loser_reward": -0.28554180763103065, "reward_margin": 0.11853972788900136, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1670020797420293, "loser_reward": -0.30729946065135305, "reward_margin": 0.14029738090932375, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.28554180763103065, "loser_reward": -0.30729946065135305, "reward_margin": 0.0217576530203224, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13694167704693974, "loser_reward": -0.14797163318283857, "reward_margin": 0.011029956135898827, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.13694167704693974, "loser_reward": -0.16911476666480302, "reward_margin": 0.032173089617863276, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13694167704693974, "loser_reward": -0.34145817029662434, "reward_margin": 0.2045164932496846, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13694167704693974, "loser_reward": -0.38362010619975623, "reward_margin": 0.2466784291528165, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.14797163318283857, "loser_reward": -0.16911476666480302, "reward_margin": 0.02114313348196445, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14797163318283857, "loser_reward": -0.34145817029662434, "reward_margin": 0.19348653711378577, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14797163318283857, "loser_reward": -0.38362010619975623, "reward_margin": 0.23564847301691766, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16911476666480302, "loser_reward": -0.34145817029662434, "reward_margin": 0.17234340363182132, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16911476666480302, "loser_reward": -0.38362010619975623, "reward_margin": 0.2145053395349532, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.34145817029662434, "loser_reward": -0.38362010619975623, "reward_margin": 0.042161935903131886, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1828476216867566, "loser_reward": -0.2071879410315305, "reward_margin": 0.024340319344773875, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1828476216867566, "loser_reward": -0.2990740110669285, "reward_margin": 0.11622638938017188, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1828476216867566, "loser_reward": -0.3318133817929775, "reward_margin": 0.14896576010622087, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18595899091474713, "loser_reward": -0.2071879410315305, "reward_margin": 0.021228950116783357, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18595899091474713, "loser_reward": -0.2990740110669285, "reward_margin": 0.11311502015218136, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18595899091474713, "loser_reward": -0.3318133817929775, "reward_margin": 0.14585439087823035, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2071879410315305, "loser_reward": -0.2990740110669285, "reward_margin": 0.091886070035398, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2071879410315305, "loser_reward": -0.3318133817929775, "reward_margin": 0.12462544076144699, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region2__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2990740110669285, "loser_reward": -0.3318133817929775, "reward_margin": 0.03273937072604899, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14011822605878116, "loser_reward": -0.16366322086565196, "reward_margin": 0.023544994806870806, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14011822605878116, "loser_reward": -0.19776490713842215, "reward_margin": 0.05764668107964099, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14011822605878116, "loser_reward": -0.2743269374165684, "reward_margin": 0.13420871135778722, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14011822605878116, "loser_reward": -0.3076942907590419, "reward_margin": 0.16757606470026076, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16366322086565196, "loser_reward": -0.19776490713842215, "reward_margin": 0.03410168627277019, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16366322086565196, "loser_reward": -0.2743269374165684, "reward_margin": 0.11066371655091642, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16366322086565196, "loser_reward": -0.3076942907590419, "reward_margin": 0.14403106989338996, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19776490713842215, "loser_reward": -0.2743269374165684, "reward_margin": 0.07656203027814623, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19776490713842215, "loser_reward": -0.3076942907590419, "reward_margin": 0.10992938362061977, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region3__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 3, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2743269374165684, "loser_reward": -0.3076942907590419, "reward_margin": 0.03336735334247354, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21711064244061712, "loser_reward": -0.22975871052034197, "reward_margin": 0.01264806807972485, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21711064244061712, "loser_reward": -0.29234571359492834, "reward_margin": 0.07523507115431122, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21711064244061712, "loser_reward": -0.3584925608653575, "reward_margin": 0.1413819184247404, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21812842534296215, "loser_reward": -0.22975871052034197, "reward_margin": 0.011630285177379823, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21812842534296215, "loser_reward": -0.29234571359492834, "reward_margin": 0.07421728825196619, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21812842534296215, "loser_reward": -0.3584925608653575, "reward_margin": 0.14036413552239538, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22975871052034197, "loser_reward": -0.29234571359492834, "reward_margin": 0.06258700307458637, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22975871052034197, "loser_reward": -0.3584925608653575, "reward_margin": 0.12873385034501555, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region4__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 4, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.29234571359492834, "loser_reward": -0.3584925608653575, "reward_margin": 0.06614684727042919, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.235302556021139, "loser_reward": -0.2477572079971433, "reward_margin": 0.012454651976004288, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.235302556021139, "loser_reward": -0.24876603271253406, "reward_margin": 0.013463476691395054, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.235302556021139, "loser_reward": -0.28871011338569225, "reward_margin": 0.05340755736455324, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.235302556021139, "loser_reward": -0.33130447435565297, "reward_margin": 0.09600191833451396, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2477572079971433, "loser_reward": -0.28871011338569225, "reward_margin": 0.040952905388548955, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2477572079971433, "loser_reward": -0.33130447435565297, "reward_margin": 0.08354726635850968, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24876603271253406, "loser_reward": -0.28871011338569225, "reward_margin": 0.03994408067315819, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24876603271253406, "loser_reward": -0.33130447435565297, "reward_margin": 0.08253844164311891, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region5__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 5, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.28871011338569225, "loser_reward": -0.33130447435565297, "reward_margin": 0.04259436096996072, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2995383974388242, "loser_reward": -0.31676463828794654, "reward_margin": 0.017226240849122332, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2995383974388242, "loser_reward": -0.344312686579302, "reward_margin": 0.04477428914047776, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2995383974388242, "loser_reward": -0.3618097802195698, "reward_margin": 0.062271382780745566, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2995383974388242, "loser_reward": -0.4510235147494823, "reward_margin": 0.1514851173106581, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.31676463828794654, "loser_reward": -0.344312686579302, "reward_margin": 0.02754804829135543, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.31676463828794654, "loser_reward": -0.3618097802195698, "reward_margin": 0.045045141931623234, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.31676463828794654, "loser_reward": -0.4510235147494823, "reward_margin": 0.13425887646153578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.344312686579302, "loser_reward": -0.3618097802195698, "reward_margin": 0.017497093640267802, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.344312686579302, "loser_reward": -0.4510235147494823, "reward_margin": 0.10671082817018035, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region6__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 6, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.3618097802195698, "loser_reward": -0.4510235147494823, "reward_margin": 0.08921373452991255, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 7, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.206772147634998, "loser_reward": -0.22163664663583044, "reward_margin": 0.014864499000832448, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 7, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.206772147634998, "loser_reward": -0.22543692634813486, "reward_margin": 0.018664778713136876, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.206772147634998, "loser_reward": -0.23317080225236714, "reward_margin": 0.02639865461736915, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.206772147634998, "loser_reward": -0.32662972080893815, "reward_margin": 0.11985757317394016, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22163664663583044, "loser_reward": -0.23317080225236714, "reward_margin": 0.011534155616536701, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22163664663583044, "loser_reward": -0.32662972080893815, "reward_margin": 0.10499307417310771, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22543692634813486, "loser_reward": -0.32662972080893815, "reward_margin": 0.10119279446080329, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region7__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 7, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23317080225236714, "loser_reward": -0.32662972080893815, "reward_margin": 0.09345891855657101, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1407507886122912, "loser_reward": -0.1522264968827367, "reward_margin": 0.0114757082704455, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1407507886122912, "loser_reward": -0.20559552512504162, "reward_margin": 0.06484473651275041, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1407507886122912, "loser_reward": -0.2912429170627147, "reward_margin": 0.1504921284504235, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1492017545867711, "loser_reward": -0.20559552512504162, "reward_margin": 0.05639377053827052, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1492017545867711, "loser_reward": -0.2912429170627147, "reward_margin": 0.14204116247594362, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1522264968827367, "loser_reward": -0.20559552512504162, "reward_margin": 0.05336902824230491, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1522264968827367, "loser_reward": -0.2912429170627147, "reward_margin": 0.139016420179978, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_2__region8__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 8, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20559552512504162, "loser_reward": -0.2912429170627147, "reward_margin": 0.0856473919376731, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/153639_2/153639_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.16864390671253204, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7397556900978088, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06675112992525101, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.483626127243042, "background_mse_to_target": 0.07745493203401566, "full_mse_to_target": 0.09559435397386551, "input_change_l1": 0.2065088301897049, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7874739170074463, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13407194707542658, "edit_score": 0.2738242894411087, "background_score": 0.17002590447664262, "combined_score": 0.3697071808204055, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/153639_2/153639_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11928042024374008, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7660139203071594, "background_mse_to_source": 0.054856084287166595, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5635824799537659, "background_mse_to_target": 0.049827199429273605, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0636429563164711, "input_change_l1": 0.16511224210262299, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8623971343040466, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1643491877242923, "edit_score": 0.20047835260629654, "background_score": 0.14213958829641343, "combined_score": 0.28946134168654675, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/153639_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13419455289840698, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7503483891487122, "background_mse_to_source": 0.023176683112978935, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7652072906494141, "background_mse_to_target": 0.032866451889276505, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05302276089787483, "input_change_l1": 0.10732284933328629, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8623955547809601, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10777532793581486, "edit_score": 0.21852598637342452, "background_score": 0.07013522498309613, "combined_score": 0.26993065679445866, "confidence": 0.6685851252905188}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/153639_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12123282998800278, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7473896145820618, "background_mse_to_source": 0.07498455047607422, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4760158956050873, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06332723051309586, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07484590262174606, "input_change_l1": 0.1960325986146927, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8652676641941071, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.19297434706240893, "edit_score": 0.20543799102306365, "background_score": 0.17978137135505678, "combined_score": 0.31444093067198997, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/153639_2/153639_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.22629496455192566, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6864613890647888, "background_mse_to_source": 0.023302337154746056, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6184377074241638, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04281420260667801, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07931237667798996, "input_change_l1": 0.1102675199508667, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6589740365743637, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09887416791170836, "edit_score": 0.37425917759537697, "background_score": 0.0996147956699133, "combined_score": 0.4368304273299873, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/153639_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/153639_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/153639_2.json"}

153639_3

let the man have a tattoo on his hand

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.019611358642578125, "dataset_mask_area": 0.019611358642578125, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.18321402370929718, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0006940969033166766, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1825199268059805, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8353964536634326, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8564568684616704, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.41838645935058594, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.31702577598405923, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.19119075547390824, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.25772179455962035, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.09051989018917084, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.18321402370929718, "edit_change_ratio": 0.49406638398377917, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.024483680725097656, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/153639_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.12585575840692037, "reward": -0.12585575840692037}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16369405038096013, "reward": -0.16369405038096013}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.16848175596003417, "reward": -0.16848175596003417}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1858935607844032, "reward": -0.1858935607844032}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.22062905354448595, "reward": -0.22062905354448595}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12585575840692037, "loser_reward": -0.16369405038096013, "reward_margin": 0.03783829197403976, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12585575840692037, "loser_reward": -0.16848175596003417, "reward_margin": 0.042625997553113804, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12585575840692037, "loser_reward": -0.1858935607844032, "reward_margin": 0.060037802377482824, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12585575840692037, "loser_reward": -0.22062905354448595, "reward_margin": 0.09477329513756558, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16369405038096013, "loser_reward": -0.1858935607844032, "reward_margin": 0.022199510403443062, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16369405038096013, "loser_reward": -0.22062905354448595, "reward_margin": 0.056935003163525816, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16848175596003417, "loser_reward": -0.1858935607844032, "reward_margin": 0.01741180482436902, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16848175596003417, "loser_reward": -0.22062905354448595, "reward_margin": 0.052147297584451774, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1858935607844032, "loser_reward": -0.22062905354448595, "reward_margin": 0.03473549276008275, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 20564, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 66, 164, 254], "component_score": 0.12585575840692037, "component_reward": -0.12585575840692037, "second_component_score": 0.16369405038096013, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.03783829197403976, "confidence": 0.8776319141304799}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8776320219039917, "teacher_quality_score": 0.19119075547390824, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.19119075547390824, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12585575840692037, "loser_reward": -0.16369405038096013, "reward_margin": 0.03783829197403976, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12585575840692037, "loser_reward": -0.16848175596003417, "reward_margin": 0.042625997553113804, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12585575840692037, "loser_reward": -0.1858935607844032, "reward_margin": 0.060037802377482824, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12585575840692037, "loser_reward": -0.22062905354448595, "reward_margin": 0.09477329513756558, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16369405038096013, "loser_reward": -0.1858935607844032, "reward_margin": 0.022199510403443062, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16369405038096013, "loser_reward": -0.22062905354448595, "reward_margin": 0.056935003163525816, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16848175596003417, "loser_reward": -0.1858935607844032, "reward_margin": 0.01741180482436902, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16848175596003417, "loser_reward": -0.22062905354448595, "reward_margin": 0.052147297584451774, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "153639_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1858935607844032, "loser_reward": -0.22062905354448595, "reward_margin": 0.03473549276008275, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/153639_3/153639_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08922777324914932, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6509811282157898, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04763141646981239, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5911218523979187, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04760304465889931, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04841935634613037, "input_change_l1": 0.16357865929603577, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4582078754901886, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10059702082071455, "edit_score": 0.2944795787334442, "background_score": 0.12940704599022868, "combined_score": 0.36473338462878024, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/153639_3/153639_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.056824468076229095, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6124271750450134, "background_mse_to_source": 0.09384128451347351, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.13067112863063812, "background_mse_to_target": 0.09395448863506317, "full_mse_to_target": 0.09322631359100342, "input_change_l1": 0.22802114486694336, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7005877047777176, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14589700791984797, "edit_score": 0.20919210687279702, "background_score": 0.2677070587873459, "combined_score": 0.341391610391438, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/153639_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04226002097129822, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.671905517578125, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03964795544743538, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4552185535430908, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0397506058216095, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03979982063174248, "input_change_l1": 0.1482137143611908, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7005878835916519, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09499190140049905, "edit_score": 0.18273194655776026, "background_score": 0.14860424473881723, "combined_score": 0.25772179455962035, "confidence": 0.7144209654774707}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/153639_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06595644354820251, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5766163468360901, "background_mse_to_source": 0.13454824686050415, "background_ssim_to_source": -0.0008162856101989746, "background_mse_to_target": 0.1346767097711563, "full_mse_to_target": 0.13332901895046234, "input_change_l1": 0.2765730023384094, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7052840739488602, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.17358043552376332, "edit_score": 0.22431215569376944, "background_score": 0.33471150398254396, "combined_score": 0.3895101710874587, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/153639_3/153639_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.059418920427560806, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6743925213813782, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01188544649630785, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7049822211265564, "background_mse_to_target": 0.011926572769880295, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012857961468398571, "input_change_l1": 0.07219377160072327, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4983416984323412, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04483044678345323, "edit_score": 0.2499549915431999, "background_score": 0.07088900227099657, "combined_score": 0.2850180278415792, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/153639_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/153639_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/153639_3.json"}

155790_1

it should be a tennis ball on the glove.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.15716800093650818, "dataset_mask_area": 0.157168, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2905420660972595, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.005655957385897636, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2848861087113619, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9679160495066904, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9861622672396153, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3501424491405487, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.44048252534174936, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.30571758221645723, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3283487470500404, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.14858470857143402, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.29054203629493713, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5114052013478753, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1892479956150055, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/155790_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5658957958221436, "qwen_image_edit": 0.43410420417785645}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.23396508860366882, "reward": -0.23396508860366882}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.247221345369704, "reward": -0.247221345369704}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.27187100693024696, "reward": -0.27187100693024696}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.28554707699827847, "reward": -0.28554707699827847}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.41450043091923, "reward": -0.41450043091923}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23396508860366882, "loser_reward": -0.247221345369704, "reward_margin": 0.013256256766035174, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23396508860366882, "loser_reward": -0.27187100693024696, "reward_margin": 0.037905918326578136, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23396508860366882, "loser_reward": -0.28554707699827847, "reward_margin": 0.051581988394609646, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23396508860366882, "loser_reward": -0.41450043091923, "reward_margin": 0.18053534231556118, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.247221345369704, "loser_reward": -0.27187100693024696, "reward_margin": 0.024649661560542963, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.247221345369704, "loser_reward": -0.28554707699827847, "reward_margin": 0.03832573162857447, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.247221345369704, "loser_reward": -0.41450043091923, "reward_margin": 0.167279085549526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.27187100693024696, "loser_reward": -0.28554707699827847, "reward_margin": 0.01367607006803151, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.27187100693024696, "loser_reward": -0.41450043091923, "reward_margin": 0.14262942398898304, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.28554707699827847, "loser_reward": -0.41450043091923, "reward_margin": 0.12895335392095153, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 39292, "bbox_xyxy": [156, 169, 397, 390], "component_score": 0.23396508860366882, "component_reward": -0.23396508860366882, "second_component_score": 0.247221345369704, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.013256256766035174, "confidence": 0.6450644805868521}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6450644135475159, "teacher_quality_score": 0.30571758221645723, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.30571758221645723, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23396508860366882, "loser_reward": -0.247221345369704, "reward_margin": 0.013256256766035174, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23396508860366882, "loser_reward": -0.27187100693024696, "reward_margin": 0.037905918326578136, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23396508860366882, "loser_reward": -0.28554707699827847, "reward_margin": 0.051581988394609646, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23396508860366882, "loser_reward": -0.41450043091923, "reward_margin": 0.18053534231556118, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.247221345369704, "loser_reward": -0.27187100693024696, "reward_margin": 0.024649661560542963, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.247221345369704, "loser_reward": -0.28554707699827847, "reward_margin": 0.03832573162857447, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.247221345369704, "loser_reward": -0.41450043091923, "reward_margin": 0.167279085549526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.27187100693024696, "loser_reward": -0.28554707699827847, "reward_margin": 0.01367607006803151, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.27187100693024696, "loser_reward": -0.41450043091923, "reward_margin": 0.14262942398898304, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.28554707699827847, "loser_reward": -0.41450043091923, "reward_margin": 0.12895335392095153, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/155790_1/155790_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2091459184885025, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3808915615081787, "background_mse_to_source": 0.10447264462709427, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3497838079929352, "background_mse_to_target": 0.1040167286992073, "full_mse_to_target": 0.12053965777158737, "input_change_l1": 0.24115850031375885, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5788377672433853, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.27337462082505226, "edit_score": 0.43825816437602044, "background_score": 0.23451588302850723, "combined_score": 0.5870676133781672, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/155790_1/155790_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1272093653678894, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4407884180545807, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0021867109462618828, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9426653981208801, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0026075863279402256, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0221910048276186, "input_change_l1": 0.04633209481835365, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7165294736623764, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11253976551815867, "edit_score": 0.3099193133413792, "background_score": 0.013653631322085857, "combined_score": 0.3394251378905028, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/155790_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1164078637957573, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.39148619771003723, "background_mse_to_source": 0.000923885207157582, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9650918841362, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0013746892800554633, "full_mse_to_target": 0.019454222172498703, "input_change_l1": 0.03011585958302021, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7165297567844391, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07329105921089649, "edit_score": 0.3089781850576401, "background_score": 0.007905508379917593, "combined_score": 0.3283487470500404, "confidence": 0.6084076755813953}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/155790_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13860684633255005, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.39287999272346497, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0033977357670664787, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9264201521873474, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0037973455619066954, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02498508058488369, "input_change_l1": 0.05661536380648613, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7218377888202667, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13867526948451997, "edit_score": 0.3295714005827904, "background_score": 0.018113705329596996, "combined_score": 0.36614475940354174, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/155790_1/155790_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14228631556034088, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.36074647307395935, "background_mse_to_source": 0.011330719105899334, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.743203341960907, "background_mse_to_target": 0.011370259337127209, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03194606676697731, "input_change_l1": 0.08829342573881149, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6620956361293793, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05572758503258228, "edit_score": 0.3546131119132042, "background_score": 0.06269005071371794, "combined_score": 0.3908947533462197, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/155790_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/155790_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/155790_1.json"}

155790_2

The background should be a ocean.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.14693927764892578, "dataset_mask_area": 0.14693927764892578, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.20251519978046417, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0034160090144723654, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1990991907659918, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9552901067470249, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9832111128633759, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.29856792092323303, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.35306244809016984, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.0939488426022581, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.14484465522691606, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.11141667515039444, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.20251519978046417, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5501645075094376, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1840963363647461, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/155790_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5385298132896423, "editar": 0.46147018671035767}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.08401346925552934, "reward": -0.08401346925552934}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.09173474595323206, "reward": -0.09173474595323206}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.11175810125563294, "reward": -0.11175810125563294}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1473747968687676, "reward": -0.1473747968687676}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.21519786571990698, "reward": -0.21519786571990698}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.08401346925552934, "loser_reward": -0.11175810125563294, "reward_margin": 0.027744632000103603, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08401346925552934, "loser_reward": -0.1473747968687676, "reward_margin": 0.06336132761323825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08401346925552934, "loser_reward": -0.21519786571990698, "reward_margin": 0.13118439646437763, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09173474595323206, "loser_reward": -0.11175810125563294, "reward_margin": 0.02002335530240089, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09173474595323206, "loser_reward": -0.1473747968687676, "reward_margin": 0.05564005091553553, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09173474595323206, "loser_reward": -0.21519786571990698, "reward_margin": 0.12346311976667493, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11175810125563294, "loser_reward": -0.1473747968687676, "reward_margin": 0.035616695613134644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11175810125563294, "loser_reward": -0.21519786571990698, "reward_margin": 0.10343976446427404, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1473747968687676, "loser_reward": -0.21519786571990698, "reward_margin": 0.0678230688511394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 154077, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 0, 1024, 444], "component_score": 0.08401346925552934, "component_reward": -0.08401346925552934, "second_component_score": 0.09173474595323206, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.007721276697702714, "confidence": 0.6960288932318488}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6960287690162659, "teacher_quality_score": 0.0939488426022581, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.0939488426022581, "global_like": true, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.08401346925552934, "loser_reward": -0.11175810125563294, "reward_margin": 0.027744632000103603, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.08401346925552934, "loser_reward": -0.1473747968687676, "reward_margin": 0.06336132761323825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08401346925552934, "loser_reward": -0.21519786571990698, "reward_margin": 0.13118439646437763, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.09173474595323206, "loser_reward": -0.11175810125563294, "reward_margin": 0.02002335530240089, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.09173474595323206, "loser_reward": -0.1473747968687676, "reward_margin": 0.05564005091553553, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09173474595323206, "loser_reward": -0.21519786571990698, "reward_margin": 0.12346311976667493, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11175810125563294, "loser_reward": -0.1473747968687676, "reward_margin": 0.035616695613134644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11175810125563294, "loser_reward": -0.21519786571990698, "reward_margin": 0.10343976446427404, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1473747968687676, "loser_reward": -0.21519786571990698, "reward_margin": 0.0678230688511394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/155790_2/155790_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10480806231498718, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7926703095436096, "background_mse_to_source": 0.20876310765743256, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.42186036705970764, "background_mse_to_target": 0.2084246724843979, "full_mse_to_target": 0.19319923222064972, "input_change_l1": 0.364078164100647, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6798169910907745, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16644028304144742, "edit_score": 0.22631975263357162, "background_score": 0.32439103424549104, "combined_score": 0.39246459444984794, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/155790_2/155790_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05024289712309837, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8540683388710022, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06987866759300232, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4141060411930084, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0697072446346283, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06684714555740356, "input_change_l1": 0.19083170592784882, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8279876410961151, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16075168335810305, "edit_score": 0.12243231907486915, "background_score": 0.18705745935440066, "combined_score": 0.22673748107627034, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/155790_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03899282589554787, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8626615405082703, "background_mse_to_source": 0.029523728415369987, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6138316988945007, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02949424833059311, "full_mse_to_target": 0.030889956280589104, "input_change_l1": 0.12404058128595352, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8279872238636017, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10477179540321231, "edit_score": 0.10946371182799339, "background_score": 0.10675738863646984, "combined_score": 0.17087215255945923, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/155790_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06985688209533691, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8180756568908691, "background_mse_to_source": 0.10222984850406647, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3169128894805908, "background_mse_to_target": 0.1019570380449295, "full_mse_to_target": 0.09724026918411255, "input_change_l1": 0.23440557718276978, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8279841244220734, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.19928343868814408, "edit_score": 0.14924571961164473, "background_score": 0.2388472706079483, "combined_score": 0.28242297898046664, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/155790_2/155790_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04179868847131729, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8657503128051758, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007953066378831863, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.764731228351593, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008191581815481186, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013129794038832188, "input_change_l1": 0.07079805433750153, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8115939497947693, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04264575056731701, "edit_score": 0.11575013846158981, "background_score": 0.05500682070851326, "combined_score": 0.14484465522691606, "confidence": 0.7946308510896187}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/155790_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/155790_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/155790_2.json"}

155790_3

Could it be two balls?

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.0977468490600586, "dataset_mask_area": 0.0977468490600586, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.35125061869621277, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0008167273481376469, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3504338913480751, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9657618188309997, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9888154449615161, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4290786385536194, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.5058779274062557, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.40325036495236416, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.4160415848670528, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.11783616989850998, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.35125061869621277, "edit_change_ratio": 0.33547604936867975, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.10764503479003906, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/155790_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6449441313743591, "qwen_image_edit": 0.3550558090209961}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2980574539981316, "reward": -0.2980574539981316}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.3279018961582333, "reward": -0.3279018961582333}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.34756254708068446, "reward": -0.34756254708068446}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.4020479418560862, "reward": -0.4020479418560862}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.4207053287737072, "reward": -0.4207053287737072}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2980574539981316, "loser_reward": -0.3279018961582333, "reward_margin": 0.02984444216010168, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2980574539981316, "loser_reward": -0.34756254708068446, "reward_margin": 0.04950509308255285, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2980574539981316, "loser_reward": -0.4020479418560862, "reward_margin": 0.10399048785795462, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2980574539981316, "loser_reward": -0.4207053287737072, "reward_margin": 0.1226478747755756, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3279018961582333, "loser_reward": -0.34756254708068446, "reward_margin": 0.019660650922451173, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.3279018961582333, "loser_reward": -0.4020479418560862, "reward_margin": 0.07414604569785294, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3279018961582333, "loser_reward": -0.4207053287737072, "reward_margin": 0.09280343261547391, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.34756254708068446, "loser_reward": -0.4020479418560862, "reward_margin": 0.05448539477540176, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.34756254708068446, "loser_reward": -0.4207053287737072, "reward_margin": 0.07314278169302274, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.4020479418560862, "loser_reward": -0.4207053287737072, "reward_margin": 0.018657386917620977, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 102493, "bbox_xyxy": [736, 331, 1024, 790], "component_score": 0.2980574539981316, "component_reward": -0.2980574539981316, "second_component_score": 0.3279018961582333, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.02984444216010168, "confidence": 0.706955483016638}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7069613337516785, "teacher_quality_score": 0.40325036495236416, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.40325036495236416, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2980574539981316, "loser_reward": -0.3279018961582333, "reward_margin": 0.02984444216010168, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2980574539981316, "loser_reward": -0.34756254708068446, "reward_margin": 0.04950509308255285, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2980574539981316, "loser_reward": -0.4020479418560862, "reward_margin": 0.10399048785795462, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2980574539981316, "loser_reward": -0.4207053287737072, "reward_margin": 0.1226478747755756, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3279018961582333, "loser_reward": -0.34756254708068446, "reward_margin": 0.019660650922451173, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.3279018961582333, "loser_reward": -0.4020479418560862, "reward_margin": 0.07414604569785294, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3279018961582333, "loser_reward": -0.4207053287737072, "reward_margin": 0.09280343261547391, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.34756254708068446, "loser_reward": -0.4020479418560862, "reward_margin": 0.05448539477540176, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.34756254708068446, "loser_reward": -0.4207053287737072, "reward_margin": 0.07314278169302274, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "155790_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.4020479418560862, "loser_reward": -0.4207053287737072, "reward_margin": 0.018657386917620977, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/155790_3/155790_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2197147011756897, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.2510639429092407, "background_mse_to_source": 0.12929272651672363, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.27526411414146423, "background_mse_to_target": 0.12926431000232697, "full_mse_to_target": 0.13810551166534424, "input_change_l1": 0.26726043224334717, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6499270051717758, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.20205568037927152, "edit_score": 0.4570201613008976, "background_score": 0.27423990368843076, "combined_score": 0.6072258148342371, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/155790_3/155790_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.19549497961997986, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.33248838782310486, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04129783436655998, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7599461674690247, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04132206737995148, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05639200285077095, "input_change_l1": 0.09237710386514664, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6844069510698318, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08022732753306627, "edit_score": 0.40789556428790097, "background_score": 0.08930860087275505, "combined_score": 0.46083824038505555, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/155790_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.17641349136829376, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.35294052958488464, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01744833029806614, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8364617228507996, "background_mse_to_target": 0.017481384798884392, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03301651403307915, "input_change_l1": 0.06004512310028076, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6844088733196259, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05231085668783635, "edit_score": 0.3847231671214104, "background_score": 0.05015598572790623, "combined_score": 0.4160415848670528, "confidence": 0.7166570651146833}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/155790_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.20937612652778625, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3233863413333893, "background_mse_to_source": 0.054588403552770615, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7275274395942688, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05460721626877785, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06973537057638168, "input_change_l1": 0.10873878002166748, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6848798245191574, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09646803331561386, "edit_score": 0.42347890213131906, "background_score": 0.10908291563391687, "combined_score": 0.4879250663239509, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/155790_3/155790_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.21698985993862152, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3394452631473541, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010175029747188091, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7641252875328064, "background_mse_to_target": 0.010202636942267418, "full_mse_to_target": 0.030415436252951622, "input_change_l1": 0.055921901017427444, "directional_pixel_score": 0.39201994240283966, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.053136635757982734, "edit_score": 0.5010958217084408, "background_score": 0.057349972240626816, "combined_score": 0.5348371827695519, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/155790_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/155790_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/155790_3.json"}

15653_1

Have there be a bottle behind the vegetables

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.09465199708938599, "dataset_mask_area": 0.094652, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.20010033249855042, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.005935213062912226, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1941651194356382, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7917966493356441, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8993044923669131, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3809511363506317, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.325152897050592, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.29202039567404425, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3075617125956342, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.08524585515260696, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.20010031759738922, "edit_change_ratio": 0.4260155914601067, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.14373600482940674, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/15653_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5334421396255493, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4665578305721283}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.20753751794248818, "reward": -0.20753751794248818}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2142359453407116, "reward": -0.2142359453407116}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.24974984887894242, "reward": -0.24974984887894242}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.26991968981362885, "reward": -0.26991968981362885}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.31915426737535746, "reward": -0.31915426737535746}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "15653_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20753751794248818, "loser_reward": -0.24974984887894242, "reward_margin": 0.04221233093645424, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.20753751794248818, "loser_reward": -0.26991968981362885, "reward_margin": 0.062382171871140674, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20753751794248818, "loser_reward": -0.31915426737535746, "reward_margin": 0.11161674943286928, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2142359453407116, "loser_reward": -0.24974984887894242, "reward_margin": 0.03551390353823081, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2142359453407116, "loser_reward": -0.26991968981362885, "reward_margin": 0.05568374447291724, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2142359453407116, "loser_reward": -0.31915426737535746, "reward_margin": 0.10491832203464585, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.24974984887894242, "loser_reward": -0.26991968981362885, "reward_margin": 0.020169840934686434, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24974984887894242, "loser_reward": -0.31915426737535746, "reward_margin": 0.06940441849641504, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.26991968981362885, "loser_reward": -0.31915426737535746, "reward_margin": 0.04923457756172861, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 23662, "bbox_xyxy": [157, 66, 334, 277], "component_score": 0.20753751794248818, "component_reward": -0.20753751794248818, "second_component_score": 0.2142359453407116, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.006698427398223433, "confidence": 0.6059882398705835}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6060050129890442, "teacher_quality_score": 0.29202039567404425, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.29202039567404425, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "15653_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20753751794248818, "loser_reward": -0.24974984887894242, "reward_margin": 0.04221233093645424, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.20753751794248818, "loser_reward": -0.26991968981362885, "reward_margin": 0.062382171871140674, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20753751794248818, "loser_reward": -0.31915426737535746, "reward_margin": 0.11161674943286928, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2142359453407116, "loser_reward": -0.24974984887894242, "reward_margin": 0.03551390353823081, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2142359453407116, "loser_reward": -0.26991968981362885, "reward_margin": 0.05568374447291724, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2142359453407116, "loser_reward": -0.31915426737535746, "reward_margin": 0.10491832203464585, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.24974984887894242, "loser_reward": -0.26991968981362885, "reward_margin": 0.020169840934686434, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24974984887894242, "loser_reward": -0.31915426737535746, "reward_margin": 0.06940441849641504, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "15653_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.26991968981362885, "loser_reward": -0.31915426737535746, "reward_margin": 0.04923457756172861, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/15653_1/15653_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09651375561952591, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.43935951590538025, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06565812230110168, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.43677958846092224, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06545387953519821, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0683937668800354, "input_change_l1": 0.18608736991882324, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6424176394939423, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12879055431112646, "edit_score": 0.2980374425649643, "background_score": 0.17830220460891724, "combined_score": 0.3930407017283142, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/15653_1/15653_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1516088992357254, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.47577977180480957, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0077593387104570866, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.83282071352005, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008352436125278473, "full_mse_to_target": 0.021911950781941414, "input_change_l1": 0.061832230538129807, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5417123585939407, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05960779627785087, "edit_score": 0.3710248552262783, "background_score": 0.041195196006447075, "combined_score": 0.39955592816229907, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/15653_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10338789224624634, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4904118478298187, "background_mse_to_source": 0.003278320888057351, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9138262867927551, "background_mse_to_target": 0.003920469433069229, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013335258699953556, "input_change_l1": 0.040190935134887695, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5417124107480049, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03908089110627771, "edit_score": 0.31987741999328134, "background_score": 0.020513063529506326, "combined_score": 0.33620669631985944, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/15653_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1949363797903061, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.46025002002716064, "background_mse_to_source": 0.011546306312084198, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.778953492641449, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012110770680010319, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02941558137536049, "input_change_l1": 0.0762120932340622, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5405389294028282, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07301083551719785, "edit_score": 0.41775164343416693, "background_score": 0.0557556077837944, "combined_score": 0.4548098313994706, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/15653_1/15653_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07605230808258057, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4674846827983856, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004760345909744501, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8468467593193054, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005317346658557653, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012012544088065624, "input_change_l1": 0.05064566805958748, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5916774198412895, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04668796854093671, "edit_score": 0.2846360165625811, "background_score": 0.03539099404588342, "combined_score": 0.3075617125956342, "confidence": 0.6976869476154796}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/15653_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/15653_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/15653_1.json"}

158548_1

Make it a black sheep.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.014763999730348587, "dataset_mask_area": 0.014764, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2743373215198517, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.011283309198915958, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2630540123209357, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.5183338694113863, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.5605217391304348, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5867236256599426, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3476749462155195, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.14400693025171676, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.15338763588530127, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.21374905109405518, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2743373215198517, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7791468179023823, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.027292000129818916, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/158548_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.10166989884668147, "reward": -0.10166989884668147}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.16111673802509907, "reward": -0.16111673802509907}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.16125064651767024, "reward": -0.16125064651767024}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.18481834935687946, "reward": -0.18481834935687946}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2310675922632217, "reward": -0.2310675922632217}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10166989884668147, "loser_reward": -0.16111673802509907, "reward_margin": 0.0594468391784176, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10166989884668147, "loser_reward": -0.16125064651767024, "reward_margin": 0.05958074767098877, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10166989884668147, "loser_reward": -0.18481834935687946, "reward_margin": 0.083148450510198, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10166989884668147, "loser_reward": -0.2310675922632217, "reward_margin": 0.12939769341654023, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16111673802509907, "loser_reward": -0.18481834935687946, "reward_margin": 0.023701611331780392, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16111673802509907, "loser_reward": -0.2310675922632217, "reward_margin": 0.06995085423812264, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16125064651767024, "loser_reward": -0.18481834935687946, "reward_margin": 0.023567702839209226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16125064651767024, "loser_reward": -0.2310675922632217, "reward_margin": 0.06981694574555147, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18481834935687946, "loser_reward": -0.2310675922632217, "reward_margin": 0.04624924290634225, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 3691, "bbox_xyxy": [63, 240, 138, 325], "component_score": 0.10166989884668147, "component_reward": -0.10166989884668147, "second_component_score": 0.16111673802509907, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0594468391784176, "confidence": 0.9553110622342418}], "teacher_confidence": 0.9553108215332031, "teacher_quality_score": 0.14400693025171676, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.14400693025171676, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10166989884668147, "loser_reward": -0.16111673802509907, "reward_margin": 0.0594468391784176, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10166989884668147, "loser_reward": -0.16125064651767024, "reward_margin": 0.05958074767098877, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10166989884668147, "loser_reward": -0.18481834935687946, "reward_margin": 0.083148450510198, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10166989884668147, "loser_reward": -0.2310675922632217, "reward_margin": 0.12939769341654023, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16111673802509907, "loser_reward": -0.18481834935687946, "reward_margin": 0.023701611331780392, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16111673802509907, "loser_reward": -0.2310675922632217, "reward_margin": 0.06995085423812264, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16125064651767024, "loser_reward": -0.18481834935687946, "reward_margin": 0.023567702839209226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16125064651767024, "loser_reward": -0.2310675922632217, "reward_margin": 0.06981694574555147, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18481834935687946, "loser_reward": -0.2310675922632217, "reward_margin": 0.04624924290634225, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/158548_1/158548_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06826486438512802, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5942472815513611, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01619459129869938, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7749891877174377, "background_mse_to_target": 0.015372760593891144, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01615365780889988, "input_change_l1": 0.08583042025566101, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9004213213920593, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08417261466383934, "edit_score": 0.17431007772684098, "background_score": 0.06119675375521183, "combined_score": 0.21417883025482298, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/158548_1/158548_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08920218050479889, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5649603605270386, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0004820450849365443, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9918398261070251, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0004999138182029128, "full_mse_to_target": 0.001809514476917684, "input_change_l1": 0.020603133365511894, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8933390080928802, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0625810580328107, "edit_score": 0.2028753563761711, "background_score": 0.002114079863531515, "combined_score": 0.21631244738266103, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/158548_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04694489762187004, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6439006924629211, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00020366393437143415, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9965522289276123, "background_mse_to_target": 0.000393021124182269, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0010803129989653826, "input_change_l1": 0.013392030261456966, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8933389484882355, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04068478113040328, "edit_score": 0.14483002200722694, "background_score": 0.0008932181488489733, "combined_score": 0.15338763588530127, "confidence": 0.915776778721733}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/158548_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10539232194423676, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5356419086456299, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0007492107688449323, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9873018264770508, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006447589839808643, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002191252075135708, "input_change_l1": 0.024796385318040848, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8899056315422058, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07316348953172565, "edit_score": 0.22578753232955934, "background_score": 0.003288845473434776, "combined_score": 0.24179045135912022, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/158548_1/158548_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10798944532871246, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5816208720207214, "background_mse_to_source": 0.038711026310920715, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.46534690260887146, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03792591765522957, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03896033391356468, "input_change_l1": 0.1546136736869812, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7033253163099289, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11990340799093246, "edit_score": 0.265833941847086, "background_score": 0.14564164578914643, "combined_score": 0.3446852328628302, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/158548_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/158548_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/158548_1.json"}

158548_2

A dog should be near the sheep.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.006752967834472656, "dataset_mask_area": 0.006752967834472656, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2478184849023819, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.001441517611965537, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.24637696729041636, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.4739262665974334, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.49956994291969664, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5698438286781311, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3232309169988962, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.012235663700344047, "best_expert": "pix2pix", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.1831957459729165, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.03494890779256821, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2478184700012207, "edit_change_ratio": 0.14102624308993617, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.22706496715545654, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9162552216319392}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.013382911682128906, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/158548_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.14911094128293914, "reward": -0.14911094128293914}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1858194054374471, "reward": -0.1858194054374471}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.19330251390690684, "reward": -0.19330251390690684}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1952044089845149, "reward": -0.1952044089845149}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19658645402546968, "reward": -0.19658645402546968}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "158548_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14911094128293914, "loser_reward": -0.1858194054374471, "reward_margin": 0.03670846415450796, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.14911094128293914, "loser_reward": -0.19330251390690684, "reward_margin": 0.044191572623967695, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14911094128293914, "loser_reward": -0.1952044089845149, "reward_margin": 0.04609346770157577, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14911094128293914, "loser_reward": -0.19658645402546968, "reward_margin": 0.047475512742530535, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1858194054374471, "loser_reward": -0.19658645402546968, "reward_margin": 0.010767048588022576, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 7081, "bbox_xyxy": [504, 563, 702, 652], "component_score": 0.14911094128293914, "component_reward": -0.14911094128293914, "second_component_score": 0.1858194054374471, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.03670846415450796, "confidence": 0.8463341264613926}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8463342189788818, "teacher_quality_score": 0.012235663700344047, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.012235663700344047, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "158548_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14911094128293914, "loser_reward": -0.1858194054374471, "reward_margin": 0.03670846415450796, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.14911094128293914, "loser_reward": -0.19330251390690684, "reward_margin": 0.044191572623967695, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14911094128293914, "loser_reward": -0.1952044089845149, "reward_margin": 0.04609346770157577, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14911094128293914, "loser_reward": -0.19658645402546968, "reward_margin": 0.047475512742530535, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158548_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1858194054374471, "loser_reward": -0.19658645402546968, "reward_margin": 0.010767048588022576, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/158548_2/158548_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07288824766874313, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7740187048912048, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004624755121767521, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.945864200592041, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004698561038821936, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005159043241292238, "input_change_l1": 0.05359114333987236, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7959762513637543, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.040906137740239504, "edit_score": 0.1690904438495636, "background_score": 0.015451915003359318, "combined_score": 0.1831957459729165, "confidence": 0.9366820100276827}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/158548_2/158548_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09542802721261978, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7791230082511902, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0006291904137469828, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9776824116706848, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0007044771336950362, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0013441430637612939, "input_change_l1": 0.015285376459360123, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3304900527000427, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.010036816541105508, "edit_score": 0.3069809123873711, "background_score": 0.0050927080796100204, "combined_score": 0.3109051378298318, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/158548_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09416475892066956, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7795010209083557, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0002658330195117742, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9893717765808105, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00034479444730095565, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0009783576242625713, "input_change_l1": 0.009935487993061543, "directional_pixel_score": 0.33049002289772034, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.006628449994605034, "edit_score": 0.3056420490145683, "background_score": 0.002391477703349665, "combined_score": 0.307902591972088, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/158548_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09636687487363815, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.77836674451828, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0009725944837555289, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.967587947845459, "background_mse_to_target": 0.001045256038196385, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0016889594262465835, "input_change_l1": 0.019099891185760498, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3304900527000427, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.012409695400856437, "edit_score": 0.30807101279497145, "background_score": 0.007455004914663732, "combined_score": 0.3133310995378997, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/158548_2/158548_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08954515308141708, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7792391180992126, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008261770009994507, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6689877510070801, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008279786445200443, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008828568272292614, "input_change_l1": 0.061382148414850235, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5814388915896416, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.025901535619050262, "edit_score": 0.23833760656416417, "background_score": 0.0744642198085785, "combined_score": 0.270463247448206, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/158548_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/158548_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/158548_2.json"}

158726_1

Make the donut a cupcake.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.07559199631214142, "dataset_mask_area": 0.075592, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2803397476673126, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.005878664553165436, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2744610831141472, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9307960224117914, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9528238515992352, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.42046940326690674, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.42426955986753156, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.3100139605956792, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.31653850760078056, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.18049295246601105, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.28033971786499023, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6438365346180995, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.09789600223302841, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/158726_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22771725706430151, "reward": -0.22771725706430151}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.27957510065194213, "reward": -0.27957510065194213}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2838071416425519, "reward": -0.2838071416425519}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.34131104286434133, "reward": -0.34131104286434133}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.4140271500814706, "reward": -0.4140271500814706}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22771725706430151, "loser_reward": -0.27957510065194213, "reward_margin": 0.05185784358764062, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22771725706430151, "loser_reward": -0.2838071416425519, "reward_margin": 0.05608988457825037, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22771725706430151, "loser_reward": -0.34131104286434133, "reward_margin": 0.11359378580003981, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22771725706430151, "loser_reward": -0.4140271500814706, "reward_margin": 0.1863098930171691, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.27957510065194213, "loser_reward": -0.34131104286434133, "reward_margin": 0.0617359422123992, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.27957510065194213, "loser_reward": -0.4140271500814706, "reward_margin": 0.1344520494295285, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2838071416425519, "loser_reward": -0.34131104286434133, "reward_margin": 0.057503901221789444, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2838071416425519, "loser_reward": -0.4140271500814706, "reward_margin": 0.13022000843891873, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.34131104286434133, "loser_reward": -0.4140271500814706, "reward_margin": 0.07271610721712929, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 18898, "bbox_xyxy": [266, 316, 445, 459], "component_score": 0.22771725706430151, "component_reward": -0.22771725706430151, "second_component_score": 0.27957510065194213, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.05185784358764062, "confidence": 0.8336454179337328}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8336455821990967, "teacher_quality_score": 0.3100139605956792, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.3100139605956792, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22771725706430151, "loser_reward": -0.27957510065194213, "reward_margin": 0.05185784358764062, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22771725706430151, "loser_reward": -0.2838071416425519, "reward_margin": 0.05608988457825037, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22771725706430151, "loser_reward": -0.34131104286434133, "reward_margin": 0.11359378580003981, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22771725706430151, "loser_reward": -0.4140271500814706, "reward_margin": 0.1863098930171691, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.27957510065194213, "loser_reward": -0.34131104286434133, "reward_margin": 0.0617359422123992, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.27957510065194213, "loser_reward": -0.4140271500814706, "reward_margin": 0.1344520494295285, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2838071416425519, "loser_reward": -0.34131104286434133, "reward_margin": 0.057503901221789444, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2838071416425519, "loser_reward": -0.4140271500814706, "reward_margin": 0.13022000843891873, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.34131104286434133, "loser_reward": -0.4140271500814706, "reward_margin": 0.07271610721712929, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/158726_1/158726_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2355089634656906, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.36313772201538086, "background_mse_to_source": 0.11189517378807068, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.22265082597732544, "background_mse_to_target": 0.11070922017097473, "full_mse_to_target": 0.1201430931687355, "input_change_l1": 0.2690545916557312, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5742492005228996, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1527426550164819, "edit_score": 0.46931911893188955, "background_score": 0.2673650085926056, "combined_score": 0.6054597122594714, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/158726_1/158726_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15228058397769928, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.373108834028244, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0013055603485554457, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9879299998283386, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0019002596382051706, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01326780952513218, "input_change_l1": 0.033760979771614075, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7309723347425461, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12358435103669763, "edit_score": 0.34491573348641397, "background_score": 0.0037195603828877213, "combined_score": 0.3722612307802774, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/158726_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10927984118461609, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.388143926858902, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005515993107110262, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9937875866889954, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0011758209438994527, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009347619488835335, "input_change_l1": 0.02194463089108467, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7309724390506744, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08033935455605389, "edit_score": 0.2989079460501671, "background_score": 0.001794081972911954, "combined_score": 0.31653850760078056, "confidence": 0.7912713061430061}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/158726_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2007657289505005, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.35694602131843567, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0018697513733059168, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9833693504333496, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002443989273160696, "full_mse_to_target": 0.017435524612665176, "input_change_l1": 0.041721947491168976, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7295693755149841, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14936086097732185, "edit_score": 0.3969841808080673, "background_score": 0.005195881286635996, "combined_score": 0.4304184639151208, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/158726_1/158726_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1289827972650528, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.34588393568992615, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009036451578140259, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7905829548835754, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009153819642961025, "full_mse_to_target": 0.018211927264928818, "input_change_l1": 0.06541656702756882, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5934639200568199, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05033149039372802, "edit_score": 0.36144003011286263, "background_score": 0.05091986060142517, "combined_score": 0.3911494721285999, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/158726_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/158726_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/158726_1.json"}

158726_2

Replace the coffee with beer.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.2571592330932617, "dataset_mask_area": 0.2571592330932617, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.34219300746917725, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.003585587488487363, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3386074199806899, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9537897544024626, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9901501313697152, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.10326796770095825, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3156384527683258, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.49266819576377396, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.2549364183365833, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2592746584943961, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.17674319446086884, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.34219303727149963, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5165014340155579, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.29207611083984375, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/158726_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5133367776870728, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.48666316270828247}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1882817306069191, "reward": -0.1882817306069191}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.19094972309854347, "reward": -0.19094972309854347}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.20144557074550537, "reward": -0.20144557074550537}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3141633809860796, "reward": -0.3141633809860796}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3207344107273966, "reward": -0.3207344107273966}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1882817306069191, "loser_reward": -0.20144557074550537, "reward_margin": 0.013163840138586264, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1882817306069191, "loser_reward": -0.3141633809860796, "reward_margin": 0.1258816503791605, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1882817306069191, "loser_reward": -0.3207344107273966, "reward_margin": 0.1324526801204775, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19094972309854347, "loser_reward": -0.20144557074550537, "reward_margin": 0.010495847646961903, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19094972309854347, "loser_reward": -0.3141633809860796, "reward_margin": 0.12321365788753613, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19094972309854347, "loser_reward": -0.3207344107273966, "reward_margin": 0.12978468762885315, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20144557074550537, "loser_reward": -0.3141633809860796, "reward_margin": 0.11271781024057423, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20144557074550537, "loser_reward": -0.3207344107273966, "reward_margin": 0.11928883998189124, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 269651, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 176, 520, 974], "component_score": 0.1882817306069191, "component_reward": -0.1882817306069191, "second_component_score": 0.19094972309854347, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0026679924916243603, "confidence": 0.5751238464675696}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5751239657402039, "teacher_quality_score": 0.2549364183365833, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.2549364183365833, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1882817306069191, "loser_reward": -0.20144557074550537, "reward_margin": 0.013163840138586264, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1882817306069191, "loser_reward": -0.3141633809860796, "reward_margin": 0.1258816503791605, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1882817306069191, "loser_reward": -0.3207344107273966, "reward_margin": 0.1324526801204775, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19094972309854347, "loser_reward": -0.20144557074550537, "reward_margin": 0.010495847646961903, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19094972309854347, "loser_reward": -0.3141633809860796, "reward_margin": 0.12321365788753613, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19094972309854347, "loser_reward": -0.3207344107273966, "reward_margin": 0.12978468762885315, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20144557074550537, "loser_reward": -0.3141633809860796, "reward_margin": 0.11271781024057423, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "158726_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20144557074550537, "loser_reward": -0.3207344107273966, "reward_margin": 0.11928883998189124, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/158726_2/158726_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15002596378326416, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4252658188343048, "background_mse_to_source": 0.16446492075920105, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.38680991530418396, "background_mse_to_target": 0.16366398334503174, "full_mse_to_target": 0.16015677154064178, "input_change_l1": 0.32571646571159363, "directional_pixel_score": 0.765753448009491, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.22524379882961512, "edit_score": 0.3235344380140305, "background_score": 0.28710293769836426, "combined_score": 0.48508490312844516, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/158726_2/158726_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08981785178184509, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.500538170337677, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0018043998861685395, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9760802388191223, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0020186668261885643, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0245970506221056, "input_change_l1": 0.06738969683647156, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8229515254497528, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10268346918746829, "edit_score": 0.23397233635187148, "background_score": 0.006588352122344077, "combined_score": 0.2592746584943961, "confidence": 0.5922428382910693}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/158726_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09295806288719177, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.44425544142723083, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0007623587152920663, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9858584403991699, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0010455199517309666, "full_mse_to_target": 0.024681685492396355, "input_change_l1": 0.04380327835679054, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8229489028453827, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06714900573715568, "edit_score": 0.24836974889039992, "background_score": 0.0035906706354580822, "combined_score": 0.26552445330948105, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/158726_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0941711813211441, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.47539210319519043, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0024103354662656784, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9699137806892395, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0025760105345398188, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02613055519759655, "input_change_l1": 0.07989021390676498, "directional_pixel_score": 0.824030876159668, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12317531229928137, "edit_score": 0.24308504164218903, "background_score": 0.008427579328417778, "combined_score": 0.2732828123867512, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/158726_2/158726_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15595750510692596, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3980974853038788, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014464947395026684, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7913404107093811, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014688223600387573, "full_mse_to_target": 0.051016915589571, "input_change_l1": 0.06830266863107681, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5220373775810003, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.057864691130816936, "edit_score": 0.39582866365090014, "background_score": 0.056196865253150464, "combined_score": 0.43217219627462333, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/158726_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/158726_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/158726_2.json"}

163114_1

swap the motorcycle for a car

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.2695080041885376, "dataset_mask_area": 0.269508, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.37773722410202026, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.025704944506287575, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3520322795957327, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8076880253855147, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9284103089155161, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.128104567527771, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.2516249120235443, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4860912549986151, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.2635252152290195, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2636002889368683, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.262617290019989, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.3777371942996979, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6952381020006931, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.35626399517059326, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/163114_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6616528630256653, "qwen_image_edit": 0.33834710717201233}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.18876905861683188, "reward": -0.18876905861683188}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.22230249206908043, "reward": -0.22230249206908043}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2559403832759708, "reward": -0.2559403832759708}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3434828086886555, "reward": -0.3434828086886555}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.36585570599325007, "reward": -0.36585570599325007}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.18876905861683188, "loser_reward": -0.22230249206908043, "reward_margin": 0.033533433452248546, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18876905861683188, "loser_reward": -0.2559403832759708, "reward_margin": 0.06717132465913891, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18876905861683188, "loser_reward": -0.3434828086886555, "reward_margin": 0.1547137500718236, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18876905861683188, "loser_reward": -0.36585570599325007, "reward_margin": 0.1770866473764182, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22230249206908043, "loser_reward": -0.2559403832759708, "reward_margin": 0.03363789120689037, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22230249206908043, "loser_reward": -0.3434828086886555, "reward_margin": 0.12118031661957507, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22230249206908043, "loser_reward": -0.36585570599325007, "reward_margin": 0.14355321392416964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2559403832759708, "loser_reward": -0.3434828086886555, "reward_margin": 0.0875424254126847, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2559403832759708, "loser_reward": -0.36585570599325007, "reward_margin": 0.10991532271727927, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3434828086886555, "loser_reward": -0.36585570599325007, "reward_margin": 0.022372897304594574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 67377, "bbox_xyxy": [180, 156, 500, 500], "component_score": 0.18876905861683188, "component_reward": -0.18876905861683188, "second_component_score": 0.22230249206908043, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.033533433452248546, "confidence": 0.792753843831834}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7927538156509399, "teacher_quality_score": 0.2635252152290195, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.2635252152290195, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.18876905861683188, "loser_reward": -0.22230249206908043, "reward_margin": 0.033533433452248546, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18876905861683188, "loser_reward": -0.2559403832759708, "reward_margin": 0.06717132465913891, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18876905861683188, "loser_reward": -0.3434828086886555, "reward_margin": 0.1547137500718236, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18876905861683188, "loser_reward": -0.36585570599325007, "reward_margin": 0.1770866473764182, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22230249206908043, "loser_reward": -0.2559403832759708, "reward_margin": 0.03363789120689037, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22230249206908043, "loser_reward": -0.3434828086886555, "reward_margin": 0.12118031661957507, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22230249206908043, "loser_reward": -0.36585570599325007, "reward_margin": 0.14355321392416964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2559403832759708, "loser_reward": -0.3434828086886555, "reward_margin": 0.0875424254126847, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2559403832759708, "loser_reward": -0.36585570599325007, "reward_margin": 0.10991532271727927, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3434828086886555, "loser_reward": -0.36585570599325007, "reward_margin": 0.022372897304594574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/163114_1/163114_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.19369027018547058, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3380829095840454, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06316407769918442, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5689413547515869, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06074170395731926, "full_mse_to_target": 0.09657243639230728, "input_change_l1": 0.20626993477344513, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7041647583246231, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16751440782099963, "edit_score": 0.40003249868750573, "background_score": 0.14937580674886702, "combined_score": 0.49547415625303987, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/163114_1/163114_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10367141664028168, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4396111071109772, "background_mse_to_source": 0.021444279700517654, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.827009916305542, "background_mse_to_target": 0.020412925630807877, "full_mse_to_target": 0.042851753532886505, "input_change_l1": 0.15506726503372192, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8736477494239807, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16370379719883205, "edit_score": 0.24733725786209107, "background_score": 0.05604229643940926, "combined_score": 0.30397799640893935, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/163114_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08692217618227005, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.45453986525535583, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009060206823050976, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8801702857017517, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009501851163804531, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03036724403500557, "input_change_l1": 0.10079369693994522, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8736473321914673, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10701021030545235, "edit_score": 0.22760237008333206, "background_score": 0.03302614968270064, "combined_score": 0.2636002889368683, "confidence": 0.7688766347787721}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/163114_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12581804394721985, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.42281392216682434, "background_mse_to_source": 0.032554566860198975, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8000766634941101, "background_mse_to_target": 0.030540164560079575, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05621832236647606, "input_change_l1": 0.18593469262123108, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8754514157772064, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.19894270058721303, "edit_score": 0.27239240556955335, "background_score": 0.07253923416137695, "combined_score": 0.3431915098801255, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/163114_1/163114_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1901242583990097, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.37259039282798767, "background_mse_to_source": 0.025347059592604637, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6483877301216125, "background_mse_to_target": 0.024731123819947243, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0693058967590332, "input_change_l1": 0.10974100977182388, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6049456298351288, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07982612904161215, "edit_score": 0.41436977237463, "background_score": 0.09566951356828213, "combined_score": 0.47074991760775453, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/163114_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/163114_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/163114_1.json"}

163114_2

remove the tent and add a bonfire

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.11849784851074219, "dataset_mask_area": 0.11849784851074219, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.26393529772758484, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0011835334589704871, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.26275176426861435, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8595183265428723, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9523399098853086, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.36750543117523193, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.40398755984917134, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.2970900622445333, "best_expert": "pix2pix", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.38294434705749153, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1152513176202774, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.26393526792526245, "edit_change_ratio": 0.4366650903694791, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1364278793334961, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/163114_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.6049089431762695, "editar": 0.39509105682373047}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2561245167432353, "reward": -0.2561245167432353}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.27742259625717997, "reward": -0.27742259625717997}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.27847665051138026, "reward": -0.27847665051138026}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2830867692865431, "reward": -0.2830867692865431}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2864107168968767, "reward": -0.2864107168968767}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "163114_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2561245167432353, "loser_reward": -0.27742259625717997, "reward_margin": 0.02129807951394469, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.2561245167432353, "loser_reward": -0.27847665051138026, "reward_margin": 0.02235213376814499, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2561245167432353, "loser_reward": -0.2830867692865431, "reward_margin": 0.026962252543307808, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2561245167432353, "loser_reward": -0.2864107168968767, "reward_margin": 0.030286200153641418, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 124254, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 352, 432, 768], "component_score": 0.2561245167432353, "component_reward": -0.2561245167432353, "second_component_score": 0.27742259625717997, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.02129807951394469, "confidence": 0.6840022848173453}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6840022206306458, "teacher_quality_score": 0.2970900622445333, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.2970900622445333, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "163114_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2561245167432353, "loser_reward": -0.27742259625717997, "reward_margin": 0.02129807951394469, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.2561245167432353, "loser_reward": -0.27847665051138026, "reward_margin": 0.02235213376814499, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2561245167432353, "loser_reward": -0.2830867692865431, "reward_margin": 0.026962252543307808, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "163114_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2561245167432353, "loser_reward": -0.2864107168968767, "reward_margin": 0.030286200153641418, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/163114_2/163114_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10198686271905899, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3738192021846771, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06063408777117729, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5495468974113464, "background_mse_to_target": 0.06076417863368988, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06564898043870926, "input_change_l1": 0.1802990883588791, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7098300606012344, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11930146990343928, "edit_score": 0.29976550713181493, "background_score": 0.150724708288908, "combined_score": 0.38294434705749153, "confidence": 0.6255132018727978}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/163114_2/163114_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12264332175254822, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3667356073856354, "background_mse_to_source": 0.054356031119823456, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6499119400978088, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05448072776198387, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06255782395601273, "input_change_l1": 0.1380540281534195, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3803868740797043, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.022887949738651513, "edit_score": 0.4041994817554951, "background_score": 0.1243736431002617, "combined_score": 0.4585636291839182, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/163114_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12043490260839462, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.369997501373291, "background_mse_to_source": 0.022965416312217712, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7936968803405762, "background_mse_to_target": 0.023090681061148643, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03462575748562813, "input_change_l1": 0.08973508328199387, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3803870603442192, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.014934720378369093, "edit_score": 0.4013386372476816, "background_score": 0.06422604024410247, "combined_score": 0.430267271157354, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/163114_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12434669584035873, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.364202618598938, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0821230486035347, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5738344192504883, "background_mse_to_target": 0.08224733918905258, "full_mse_to_target": 0.08723599463701248, "input_change_l1": 0.17096751928329468, "directional_pixel_score": 0.38048654049634933, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02851831000298262, "edit_score": 0.4063845369964838, "background_score": 0.16735616475343706, "combined_score": 0.47938645612448455, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/163114_2/163114_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12190242111682892, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3777179718017578, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0231764055788517, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6559925079345703, "background_mse_to_target": 0.023201849311590195, "full_mse_to_target": 0.034897636622190475, "input_change_l1": 0.11347883939743042, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6008431389927864, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09025070779025554, "edit_score": 0.34614804200828075, "background_score": 0.09197790399193764, "combined_score": 0.3998802136257291, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/163114_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/163114_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/163114_2.json"}

172537_1

remove the yellow letters

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.04280000180006027, "dataset_mask_area": 0.0428, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.27646511793136597, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.004700491204857826, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.27176462672650814, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9049439569032931, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9279223093371347, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.35405096411705017, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.41747479392838865, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.32348249873624585, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.318712679973105, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.09173464775085449, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2764650881290436, "edit_change_ratio": 0.33181277379962054, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.0620959997177124, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/172537_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5075666308403015, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4924333095550537}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22087738489289765, "reward": -0.22087738489289765}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.22239083479414698, "reward": -0.22239083479414698}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.24891815328702796, "reward": -0.24891815328702796}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.28297667841333896, "reward": -0.28297667841333896}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3266234138039873, "reward": -0.3266234138039873}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22087738489289765, "loser_reward": -0.24891815328702796, "reward_margin": 0.028040768394130305, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22087738489289765, "loser_reward": -0.28297667841333896, "reward_margin": 0.0620992935204413, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22087738489289765, "loser_reward": -0.3266234138039873, "reward_margin": 0.10574602891108964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22239083479414698, "loser_reward": -0.24891815328702796, "reward_margin": 0.02652731849288098, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22239083479414698, "loser_reward": -0.28297667841333896, "reward_margin": 0.060585843619191976, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22239083479414698, "loser_reward": -0.3266234138039873, "reward_margin": 0.10423257900984031, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24891815328702796, "loser_reward": -0.28297667841333896, "reward_margin": 0.034058525126310996, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24891815328702796, "loser_reward": -0.3266234138039873, "reward_margin": 0.07770526051695933, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.28297667841333896, "loser_reward": -0.3266234138039873, "reward_margin": 0.04364673539064834, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 10700, "bbox_xyxy": [120, 298, 287, 381], "component_score": 0.22087738489289765, "component_reward": -0.22087738489289765, "second_component_score": 0.22239083479414698, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0015134499012493252, "confidence": 0.5622466227007457}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5622466802597046, "teacher_quality_score": 0.32348249873624585, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.32348249873624585, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22087738489289765, "loser_reward": -0.24891815328702796, "reward_margin": 0.028040768394130305, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22087738489289765, "loser_reward": -0.28297667841333896, "reward_margin": 0.0620992935204413, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22087738489289765, "loser_reward": -0.3266234138039873, "reward_margin": 0.10574602891108964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22239083479414698, "loser_reward": -0.24891815328702796, "reward_margin": 0.02652731849288098, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22239083479414698, "loser_reward": -0.28297667841333896, "reward_margin": 0.060585843619191976, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22239083479414698, "loser_reward": -0.3266234138039873, "reward_margin": 0.10423257900984031, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24891815328702796, "loser_reward": -0.28297667841333896, "reward_margin": 0.034058525126310996, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24891815328702796, "loser_reward": -0.3266234138039873, "reward_margin": 0.07770526051695933, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.28297667841333896, "loser_reward": -0.3266234138039873, "reward_margin": 0.04364673539064834, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/172537_1/172537_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1583004891872406, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3333912789821625, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03188522532582283, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7254877090454102, "background_mse_to_target": 0.032044049352407455, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03744782507419586, "input_change_l1": 0.15474924445152283, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6280181407928467, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1241471323184669, "edit_score": 0.38461769819259645, "background_score": 0.0867876835167408, "combined_score": 0.4435675963945687, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/172537_1/172537_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.129053995013237, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.49327611923217773, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00016138225328177214, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9964286684989929, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0005645265919156373, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006063876207917929, "input_change_l1": 0.015604034997522831, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6646993607282639, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.017879421869292856, "edit_score": 0.3142239309847355, "background_score": 0.0008756485534831882, "combined_score": 0.318712679973105, "confidence": 0.562428147721332}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/172537_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11813152581453323, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.42028093338012695, "background_mse_to_source": 6.818398833274841e-05, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9984790682792664, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0004887964460067451, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005523905158042908, "input_change_l1": 0.010142619721591473, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6646995097398758, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01172962796408683, "edit_score": 0.3179004617035389, "background_score": 0.00037237033247947696, "combined_score": 0.3209291074285284, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/172537_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1446409523487091, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4265758991241455, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00025215483037754893, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9944518208503723, "background_mse_to_target": 0.000642820552457124, "full_mse_to_target": 0.00680594053119421, "input_change_l1": 0.019504902884364128, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6647012382745743, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.021610555192455652, "edit_score": 0.34315046295523643, "background_score": 0.0013617906603030862, "combined_score": 0.3486297947779531, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/172537_1/172537_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13199076056480408, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3525739908218384, "background_mse_to_source": 0.013704581186175346, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7399412989616394, "background_mse_to_target": 0.013723056763410568, "full_mse_to_target": 0.018784916028380394, "input_change_l1": 0.07610265910625458, "directional_pixel_score": 0.588319830596447, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05340505177155137, "edit_score": 0.36439600475132466, "background_score": 0.06571632139384748, "combined_score": 0.39995621919631963, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/172537_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/172537_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/172537_1.json"}

172537_2

change the USA flag into a Japanese flag

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.00673675537109375, "dataset_mask_area": 0.00673675537109375, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.28045526146888733, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 5.991539728711359e-05, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2803953460716002, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9762845849802372, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9971164936562861, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3686925172805786, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4374341560154801, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.1744494513422603, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.1720368016976863, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.15309329330921173, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.28045526146888733, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5458742064862111, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.0092010498046875, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/172537_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5777491927146912, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.42225080728530884}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.10952549794130029, "reward": -0.10952549794130029}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.12520250101713465, "reward": -0.12520250101713465}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1290436183558777, "reward": -0.1290436183558777}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.21312201568298042, "reward": -0.21312201568298042}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3873118044286966, "reward": -0.3873118044286966}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.10952549794130029, "loser_reward": -0.12520250101713465, "reward_margin": 0.01567700307583436, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10952549794130029, "loser_reward": -0.1290436183558777, "reward_margin": 0.0195181204145774, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10952549794130029, "loser_reward": -0.21312201568298042, "reward_margin": 0.10359651774168013, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10952549794130029, "loser_reward": -0.3873118044286966, "reward_margin": 0.27778630648739633, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12520250101713465, "loser_reward": -0.21312201568298042, "reward_margin": 0.08791951466584577, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12520250101713465, "loser_reward": -0.3873118044286966, "reward_margin": 0.26210930341156197, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1290436183558777, "loser_reward": -0.21312201568298042, "reward_margin": 0.08407839732710273, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1290436183558777, "loser_reward": -0.3873118044286966, "reward_margin": 0.25826818607281893, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21312201568298042, "loser_reward": -0.3873118044286966, "reward_margin": 0.1741897887457162, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 7064, "bbox_xyxy": [956, 101, 1024, 256], "component_score": 0.10952549794130029, "component_reward": -0.10952549794130029, "second_component_score": 0.12520250101713465, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.01567700307583436, "confidence": 0.7582543216174648}], "teacher_confidence": 0.75825434923172, "teacher_quality_score": 0.1744494513422603, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.1744494513422603, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.10952549794130029, "loser_reward": -0.12520250101713465, "reward_margin": 0.01567700307583436, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10952549794130029, "loser_reward": -0.1290436183558777, "reward_margin": 0.0195181204145774, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10952549794130029, "loser_reward": -0.21312201568298042, "reward_margin": 0.10359651774168013, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10952549794130029, "loser_reward": -0.3873118044286966, "reward_margin": 0.27778630648739633, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12520250101713465, "loser_reward": -0.21312201568298042, "reward_margin": 0.08791951466584577, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12520250101713465, "loser_reward": -0.3873118044286966, "reward_margin": 0.26210930341156197, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1290436183558777, "loser_reward": -0.21312201568298042, "reward_margin": 0.08407839732710273, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1290436183558777, "loser_reward": -0.3873118044286966, "reward_margin": 0.25826818607281893, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21312201568298042, "loser_reward": -0.3873118044286966, "reward_margin": 0.1741897887457162, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/172537_2/172537_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2108829915523529, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5065965056419373, "background_mse_to_source": 0.17277736961841583, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.25966668128967285, "background_mse_to_target": 0.17277851700782776, "full_mse_to_target": 0.17303524911403656, "input_change_l1": 0.345454603433609, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7011337578296661, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2713706985116005, "edit_score": 0.38428025096654894, "background_score": 0.3208440333604813, "combined_score": 0.5681533272564411, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/172537_2/172537_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.053143829107284546, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6564531922340393, "background_mse_to_source": 0.011531471274793148, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9541745185852051, "background_mse_to_target": 0.011532626114785671, "full_mse_to_target": 0.011812951415777206, "input_change_l1": 0.030934607610106468, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8680715262889862, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04388199411332607, "edit_score": 0.15483530908823012, "background_score": 0.020696567557752135, "combined_score": 0.1720368016976863, "confidence": 0.71525165411007}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/172537_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05647885426878929, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5477949976921082, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004872045014053583, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9647154808044434, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004873557016253471, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005221209023147821, "input_change_l1": 0.02010749652981758, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8680715262889862, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0288541201967746, "edit_score": 0.17990197315812112, "background_score": 0.011928948853164912, "combined_score": 0.19037005019839856, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/172537_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.061729975044727325, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6000120043754578, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01572297140955925, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.948065996170044, "background_mse_to_target": 0.015723872929811478, "full_mse_to_target": 0.016033804044127464, "input_change_l1": 0.037412822246551514, "directional_pixel_score": 0.868153840303421, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.053273478616029026, "edit_score": 0.17468911409378052, "background_score": 0.02610977217555046, "combined_score": 0.1960856104828417, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/172537_2/172537_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.103715680539608, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6457738876342773, "background_mse_to_source": 0.037266746163368225, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5775166153907776, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03726818040013313, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03771582618355751, "input_change_l1": 0.1567423790693283, "directional_pixel_score": 0.718890517950058, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10979606043547392, "edit_score": 0.24483827352523804, "background_score": 0.12176342308521271, "combined_score": 0.313186266310513, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/172537_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/172537_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/172537_2.json"}

172537_3

let a pilot walk next to the plane

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.016478538513183594, "dataset_mask_area": 0.016478538513183594, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.14046142995357513, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.002385135507211089, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.13807629444636405, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6754969624333595, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.7026178910716588, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.33807674050331116, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.24724064558123351, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.010450860291489335, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.1661842954810709, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.03977271541953087, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.14046141505241394, "edit_change_ratio": 0.28315758747474856, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.13019424676895142, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9269039950962243}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.02440929412841797, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/172537_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5262355804443359, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.4737643897533417}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.07170874791708774, "reward": -0.07170874791708774}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.0769606935363263, "reward": -0.0769606935363263}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.07882059735851361, "reward": -0.07882059735851361}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.11948768446128814, "reward": -0.11948768446128814}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.49805437982687734, "reward": -0.49805437982687734}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07170874791708774, "loser_reward": -0.11948768446128814, "reward_margin": 0.0477789365442004, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07170874791708774, "loser_reward": -0.49805437982687734, "reward_margin": 0.4263456319097896, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0769606935363263, "loser_reward": -0.11948768446128814, "reward_margin": 0.042526990924961844, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0769606935363263, "loser_reward": -0.49805437982687734, "reward_margin": 0.42109368629055105, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07882059735851361, "loser_reward": -0.11948768446128814, "reward_margin": 0.04066708710277453, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07882059735851361, "loser_reward": -0.49805437982687734, "reward_margin": 0.41923378246836374, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11948768446128814, "loser_reward": -0.49805437982687734, "reward_margin": 0.3785666953655892, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 17279, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 615, 136, 1010], "component_score": 0.07170874791708774, "component_reward": -0.07170874791708774, "second_component_score": 0.0769606935363263, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.005251945619238557, "confidence": 0.6698727887629652}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6698726415634155, "teacher_quality_score": 0.010450860291489335, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.010450860291489335, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07170874791708774, "loser_reward": -0.11948768446128814, "reward_margin": 0.0477789365442004, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07170874791708774, "loser_reward": -0.49805437982687734, "reward_margin": 0.4263456319097896, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0769606935363263, "loser_reward": -0.11948768446128814, "reward_margin": 0.042526990924961844, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0769606935363263, "loser_reward": -0.49805437982687734, "reward_margin": 0.42109368629055105, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07882059735851361, "loser_reward": -0.11948768446128814, "reward_margin": 0.04066708710277453, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07882059735851361, "loser_reward": -0.49805437982687734, "reward_margin": 0.41923378246836374, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "172537_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11948768446128814, "loser_reward": -0.49805437982687734, "reward_margin": 0.3785666953655892, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/172537_3/172537_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.3152664005756378, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6678476929664612, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0549529492855072, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5796981453895569, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05553556978702545, "full_mse_to_target": 0.059815604239702225, "input_change_l1": 0.20162136852741241, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4109114930033684, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.29741254621185365, "edit_score": 0.5289689887315034, "background_score": 0.13901332020759583, "combined_score": 0.643087720470503, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/172537_3/172537_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.024484653025865555, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8045580387115479, "background_mse_to_source": 0.035208892077207565, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.39686891436576843, "background_mse_to_target": 0.035445474088191986, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03526486083865166, "input_change_l1": 0.1125888004899025, "directional_pixel_score": 0.736380085349083, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.043230568175204105, "edit_score": 0.12947802394628524, "background_score": 0.15583510920405388, "combined_score": 0.19619291188661006, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/172537_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.024531716480851173, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8049678802490234, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014875747263431549, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6519773006439209, "background_mse_to_target": 0.015150463208556175, "full_mse_to_target": 0.015305052511394024, "input_change_l1": 0.07318273186683655, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7363797724246979, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.028212462039664387, "edit_score": 0.12944319732487203, "background_score": 0.08448028713464738, "combined_score": 0.1661842954810709, "confidence": 0.7954326452296124}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/172537_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.02596154808998108, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7991206049919128, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05277061089873314, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.24928666651248932, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0529799647629261, "full_mse_to_target": 0.052534718066453934, "input_change_l1": 0.1391647607088089, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7363799065351486, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.052960835956037046, "edit_score": 0.13204245045781135, "background_score": 0.2029132775962353, "combined_score": 0.2189077366143465, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/172537_3/172537_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.029534636065363884, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8039762377738953, "background_mse_to_source": 0.011309024877846241, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6872859597206116, "background_mse_to_target": 0.011501879431307316, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01179902721196413, "input_change_l1": 0.07170893996953964, "directional_pixel_score": 0.614462599158287, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.024578933324664834, "edit_score": 0.16512373872101307, "background_score": 0.07385183293372392, "combined_score": 0.19706756963394584, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/172537_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/172537_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/172537_3.json"}

17320_1

change the green ball to blue

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.16450800001621246, "dataset_mask_area": 0.164508, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.21254636347293854, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00595278711989522, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.20659357635304332, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9372203678716, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9725845677647579, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4995337426662445, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3579634032082256, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.16035419644700596, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.1675184107676614, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.19500507414340973, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.21254630386829376, "edit_change_ratio": 0.9174710196995305, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.19929200410842896, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/17320_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.10637304115772714, "reward": -0.10637304115772714}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1477692417744547, "reward": -0.1477692417744547}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.17971052304515614, "reward": -0.17971052304515614}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.1811595877669752, "reward": -0.1811595877669752}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19514213945914524, "reward": -0.19514213945914524}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10637304115772714, "loser_reward": -0.1477692417744547, "reward_margin": 0.04139620061672755, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10637304115772714, "loser_reward": -0.17971052304515614, "reward_margin": 0.073337481887429, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10637304115772714, "loser_reward": -0.1811595877669752, "reward_margin": 0.07478654660924805, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10637304115772714, "loser_reward": -0.19514213945914524, "reward_margin": 0.0887690983014181, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1477692417744547, "loser_reward": -0.17971052304515614, "reward_margin": 0.03194128127070145, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1477692417744547, "loser_reward": -0.1811595877669752, "reward_margin": 0.0333903459925205, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1477692417744547, "loser_reward": -0.19514213945914524, "reward_margin": 0.04737289768469055, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17971052304515614, "loser_reward": -0.19514213945914524, "reward_margin": 0.015431616413989102, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1811595877669752, "loser_reward": -0.19514213945914524, "reward_margin": 0.013982551692170053, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 41127, "bbox_xyxy": [208, 233, 451, 456], "component_score": 0.10637304115772714, "component_reward": -0.10637304115772714, "second_component_score": 0.1477692417744547, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.04139620061672755, "confidence": 0.9134941092713731}], "teacher_confidence": 0.9134941101074219, "teacher_quality_score": 0.16035419644700596, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.16035419644700596, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10637304115772714, "loser_reward": -0.1477692417744547, "reward_margin": 0.04139620061672755, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10637304115772714, "loser_reward": -0.17971052304515614, "reward_margin": 0.073337481887429, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10637304115772714, "loser_reward": -0.1811595877669752, "reward_margin": 0.07478654660924805, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10637304115772714, "loser_reward": -0.19514213945914524, "reward_margin": 0.0887690983014181, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1477692417744547, "loser_reward": -0.17971052304515614, "reward_margin": 0.03194128127070145, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1477692417744547, "loser_reward": -0.1811595877669752, "reward_margin": 0.0333903459925205, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1477692417744547, "loser_reward": -0.19514213945914524, "reward_margin": 0.04737289768469055, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17971052304515614, "loser_reward": -0.19514213945914524, "reward_margin": 0.015431616413989102, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1811595877669752, "loser_reward": -0.19514213945914524, "reward_margin": 0.013982551692170053, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/17320_1/17320_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07414816319942474, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.570608913898468, "background_mse_to_source": 0.018872486427426338, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.882832944393158, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01916961558163166, "full_mse_to_target": 0.028214026242494583, "input_change_l1": 0.1375257819890976, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8198306262493134, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09568198621273041, "edit_score": 0.20506872385740282, "background_score": 0.04230589754879475, "combined_score": 0.24183358786627654, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/17320_1/17320_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07065226882696152, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5787346363067627, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0006004181923344731, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.987446129322052, "background_mse_to_target": 0.001126649440266192, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012564169242978096, "input_change_l1": 0.061911165714263916, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8510759174823761, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07504547203425317, "edit_score": 0.19213636219501495, "background_score": 0.003111192327924073, "combined_score": 0.20949079084093683, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/17320_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.038373999297618866, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5956979393959045, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0002536765532568097, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9927716255187988, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0008170654182322323, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0069954837672412395, "input_change_l1": 0.040242258459329605, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8510759770870209, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0487933611846529, "edit_score": 0.15646541714668274, "background_score": 0.0016993514494970442, "combined_score": 0.1675184107676614, "confidence": 0.8491727013235493}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/17320_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10670650750398636, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5352810025215149, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0009290603338740766, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9835035800933838, "background_mse_to_target": 0.001429131138138473, "full_mse_to_target": 0.018748097121715546, "input_change_l1": 0.07519853860139847, "directional_pixel_score": 0.848135381937027, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09309108722954988, "edit_score": 0.23761646151542665, "background_score": 0.004228344315197319, "combined_score": 0.2595894091838273, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/17320_1/17320_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.061471182852983475, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5457761287689209, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03308084234595299, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7237734198570251, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03322582691907883, "full_mse_to_target": 0.037872400134801865, "input_change_l1": 0.14351767301559448, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7597186267375946, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10114641510881484, "edit_score": 0.21238630041480067, "background_score": 0.08832615837454796, "combined_score": 0.2673169788811356, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/17320_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/17320_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/17320_1.json"}

17320_2

make the dog leaf

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.02626800537109375, "dataset_mask_area": 0.02626800537109375, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.19456541538238525, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0003838983830064535, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1941815169993788, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8828009308229321, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9683632425742574, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5716251134872437, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.33885215840110094, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.008014748827858966, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.23135366857983172, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.004256576299667358, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.19456540048122406, "edit_change_ratio": 0.021877354807892095, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.19074074923992157, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.980342593123737}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.034171104431152344, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/17320_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5014654397964478, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49853453040122986}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1452591799088404, "reward": -0.1452591799088404}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.14555228420556526, "reward": -0.14555228420556526}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.14573529627895915, "reward": -0.14573529627895915}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.20157297061430293, "reward": -0.20157297061430293}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.35622171138320113, "reward": -0.35622171138320113}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1452591799088404, "loser_reward": -0.20157297061430293, "reward_margin": 0.056313790705462524, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1452591799088404, "loser_reward": -0.35622171138320113, "reward_margin": 0.21096253147436073, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14555228420556526, "loser_reward": -0.20157297061430293, "reward_margin": 0.05602068640873767, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14555228420556526, "loser_reward": -0.35622171138320113, "reward_margin": 0.21066942717763587, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14573529627895915, "loser_reward": -0.20157297061430293, "reward_margin": 0.055837674335343784, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14573529627895915, "loser_reward": -0.35622171138320113, "reward_margin": 0.210486415104242, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20157297061430293, "loser_reward": -0.35622171138320113, "reward_margin": 0.1546487407688982, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 27544, "bbox_xyxy": [827, 310, 1024, 559], "component_score": 0.1452591799088404, "component_reward": -0.1452591799088404, "second_component_score": 0.14555228420556526, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0002931042967248554, "confidence": 0.5536246506327978}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5536246299743652, "teacher_quality_score": 0.008014748827858966, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.008014748827858966, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1452591799088404, "loser_reward": -0.20157297061430293, "reward_margin": 0.056313790705462524, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1452591799088404, "loser_reward": -0.35622171138320113, "reward_margin": 0.21096253147436073, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14555228420556526, "loser_reward": -0.20157297061430293, "reward_margin": 0.05602068640873767, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14555228420556526, "loser_reward": -0.35622171138320113, "reward_margin": 0.21066942717763587, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14573529627895915, "loser_reward": -0.20157297061430293, "reward_margin": 0.055837674335343784, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14573529627895915, "loser_reward": -0.35622171138320113, "reward_margin": 0.210486415104242, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20157297061430293, "loser_reward": -0.35622171138320113, "reward_margin": 0.1546487407688982, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/17320_2/17320_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1856740266084671, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5277776122093201, "background_mse_to_source": 0.13220937550067902, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.24892473220825195, "background_mse_to_target": 0.13217507302761078, "full_mse_to_target": 0.13358040153980255, "input_change_l1": 0.29205837845802307, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6185364201664925, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.23403602102771404, "edit_score": 0.37548439912498, "background_score": 0.28242442905902865, "combined_score": 0.534498193655163, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/17320_2/17320_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05711162090301514, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7075843811035156, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007012574467808008, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9524739384651184, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0070311930030584335, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008346706628799438, "input_change_l1": 0.022397689521312714, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5536929629743099, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.004523231566417962, "edit_score": 0.22717150393873453, "background_score": 0.016517786774784327, "combined_score": 0.2346920462860726, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/17320_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05722706392407417, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7075050473213196, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002962813014164567, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9716768264770508, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0029814071021974087, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004406332969665527, "input_change_l1": 0.014558491297066212, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5536930114030838, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0029531348613090814, "edit_score": 0.22730280160903932, "background_score": 0.00862744771875441, "combined_score": 0.23135366857983172, "confidence": 0.5755765065998084}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/17320_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.057041339576244354, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7074978947639465, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008803614415228367, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9407484531402588, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008822250179946423, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01008886843919754, "input_change_l1": 0.026745127514004707, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5536928735673428, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.005634129024110735, "edit_score": 0.22711854223161937, "background_score": 0.02065392378717661, "combined_score": 0.23648312820587308, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/17320_2/17320_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08323302865028381, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6809501051902771, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007330567575991154, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7733473181724548, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00734181422740221, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009335326962172985, "input_change_l1": 0.06043827161192894, "directional_pixel_score": 0.38795775920152664, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04447411135770381, "edit_score": 0.3000535678118467, "background_score": 0.05266110394150019, "combined_score": 0.3283133091591299, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/17320_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/17320_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/17320_2.json"}

17320_3

add a dog bowl

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.04195594787597656, "dataset_mask_area": 0.04195594787597656, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.3047938644886017, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0027144858613610268, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.30207937862724066, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8039561858116445, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8298551917386789, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5080637335777283, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.43174832859418516, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.31699180087212875, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.31417100329883396, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.12792815268039703, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.3047938942909241, "edit_change_ratio": 0.4197201947828073, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.04996967315673828, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/17320_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6426730155944824, "qwen_image_edit": 0.35732701420783997}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22167152552772312, "reward": -0.22167152552772312}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.25102077328506855, "reward": -0.25102077328506855}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.27472176122851666, "reward": -0.27472176122851666}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.28045957294665275, "reward": -0.28045957294665275}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.31554551869072023, "reward": -0.31554551869072023}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22167152552772312, "loser_reward": -0.25102077328506855, "reward_margin": 0.02934924775734543, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22167152552772312, "loser_reward": -0.27472176122851666, "reward_margin": 0.053050235700793535, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22167152552772312, "loser_reward": -0.28045957294665275, "reward_margin": 0.05878804741892962, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22167152552772312, "loser_reward": -0.31554551869072023, "reward_margin": 0.0938739931629971, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.25102077328506855, "loser_reward": -0.27472176122851666, "reward_margin": 0.023700987943448104, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.25102077328506855, "loser_reward": -0.28045957294665275, "reward_margin": 0.029438799661584192, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.25102077328506855, "loser_reward": -0.31554551869072023, "reward_margin": 0.06452474540565167, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.27472176122851666, "loser_reward": -0.31554551869072023, "reward_margin": 0.04082375746220357, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.28045957294665275, "loser_reward": -0.31554551869072023, "reward_margin": 0.03508594574406748, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 43994, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 548, 316, 768], "component_score": 0.22167152552772312, "component_reward": -0.22167152552772312, "second_component_score": 0.25102077328506855, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.02934924775734543, "confidence": 0.7463446883889089}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7463445663452148, "teacher_quality_score": 0.31699180087212875, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.31699180087212875, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22167152552772312, "loser_reward": -0.25102077328506855, "reward_margin": 0.02934924775734543, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22167152552772312, "loser_reward": -0.27472176122851666, "reward_margin": 0.053050235700793535, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22167152552772312, "loser_reward": -0.28045957294665275, "reward_margin": 0.05878804741892962, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22167152552772312, "loser_reward": -0.31554551869072023, "reward_margin": 0.0938739931629971, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.25102077328506855, "loser_reward": -0.27472176122851666, "reward_margin": 0.023700987943448104, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.25102077328506855, "loser_reward": -0.28045957294665275, "reward_margin": 0.029438799661584192, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.25102077328506855, "loser_reward": -0.31554551869072023, "reward_margin": 0.06452474540565167, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.27472176122851666, "loser_reward": -0.31554551869072023, "reward_margin": 0.04082375746220357, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "17320_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.28045957294665275, "loser_reward": -0.31554551869072023, "reward_margin": 0.03508594574406748, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/17320_3/17320_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1561119705438614, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.49039480090141296, "background_mse_to_source": 0.023485075682401657, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6830830574035645, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02366187982261181, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02921895496547222, "input_change_l1": 0.11323397606611252, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3559550493955612, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04856868404895068, "edit_score": 0.4190442480146885, "background_score": 0.08686846420168877, "combined_score": 0.4620838427916169, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/17320_3/17320_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12458555400371552, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4885510206222534, "background_mse_to_source": 0.013166827149689198, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8867981433868408, "background_mse_to_target": 0.013616512529551983, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01827232353389263, "input_change_l1": 0.04781531170010567, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7004021257162094, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15944427801296115, "edit_score": 0.3017748184502125, "background_score": 0.035807198472321035, "combined_score": 0.34802342587150636, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/17320_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11269485950469971, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5109689831733704, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005562988109886646, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9287281036376953, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005917403381317854, "full_mse_to_target": 0.010397352278232574, "input_change_l1": 0.03107994981110096, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7004021406173706, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10397330885753035, "edit_score": 0.285400527715683, "background_score": 0.019817367382347587, "combined_score": 0.31417100329883396, "confidence": 0.7167558780930479}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/17320_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1408429741859436, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.458631306886673, "background_mse_to_source": 0.019815286621451378, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8650898933410645, "background_mse_to_target": 0.020326174795627594, "full_mse_to_target": 0.025382565334439278, "input_change_l1": 0.05918778479099274, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7031122744083405, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.19445000905543566, "edit_score": 0.3233386442065239, "background_score": 0.046797307953238484, "combined_score": 0.38114596033468845, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/17320_3/17320_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1345946341753006, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5014528036117554, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00416850158944726, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8663905262947083, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0043000271543860435, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009766661562025547, "input_change_l1": 0.04125784710049629, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5494854040443897, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06035570753738284, "edit_score": 0.3469327224418521, "background_score": 0.03089039633050561, "combined_score": 0.3707921688212082, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/17320_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/17320_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/17320_3.json"}

175584_1

Put a pond next to the cows.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.19848400354385376, "dataset_mask_area": 0.198484, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.23800665140151978, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.008547495119273663, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2294591562822461, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8352164529643266, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8930018809020573, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5048486590385437, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.36540520587404757, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.009923511533561394, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.35165283864829694, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.044589653611183167, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.23800666630268097, "edit_change_ratio": 0.18734623825400346, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.23621824383735657, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9924858303630454}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.2251960039138794, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/175584_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5717139840126038, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.42828604578971863}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.23429350157640874, "reward": -0.23429350157640874}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2487358806831762, "reward": -0.2487358806831762}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2542301494758576, "reward": -0.2542301494758576}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.25603763915039596, "reward": -0.25603763915039596}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2641005237344652, "reward": -0.2641005237344652}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "175584_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.23429350157640874, "loser_reward": -0.2487358806831762, "reward_margin": 0.014442379106767461, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23429350157640874, "loser_reward": -0.2542301494758576, "reward_margin": 0.01993664789944885, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23429350157640874, "loser_reward": -0.25603763915039596, "reward_margin": 0.021744137573987216, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23429350157640874, "loser_reward": -0.2641005237344652, "reward_margin": 0.029807022158056445, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2487358806831762, "loser_reward": -0.2641005237344652, "reward_margin": 0.015364643051288984, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 49621, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 378, 500, 500], "component_score": 0.23429350157640874, "component_reward": -0.23429350157640874, "second_component_score": 0.2487358806831762, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.014442379106767461, "confidence": 0.6526740681183855}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6526740789413452, "teacher_quality_score": 0.009923511533561394, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.009923511533561394, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "175584_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.23429350157640874, "loser_reward": -0.2487358806831762, "reward_margin": 0.014442379106767461, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23429350157640874, "loser_reward": -0.2542301494758576, "reward_margin": 0.01993664789944885, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23429350157640874, "loser_reward": -0.25603763915039596, "reward_margin": 0.021744137573987216, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23429350157640874, "loser_reward": -0.2641005237344652, "reward_margin": 0.029807022158056445, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2487358806831762, "loser_reward": -0.2641005237344652, "reward_margin": 0.015364643051288984, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/175584_1/175584_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0959939956665039, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.356363445520401, "background_mse_to_source": 0.020296240225434303, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6648468971252441, "background_mse_to_target": 0.020153475925326347, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03520660102367401, "input_change_l1": 0.09196624904870987, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5658110529184341, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08256529252976179, "edit_score": 0.3332685433328152, "background_score": 0.08732686080038547, "combined_score": 0.3838666632212699, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/175584_1/175584_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09129509329795837, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.30993473529815674, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010797710157930851, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8762750625610352, "background_mse_to_target": 0.010805645026266575, "full_mse_to_target": 0.026781516149640083, "input_change_l1": 0.040249694138765335, "directional_pixel_score": 0.48683082591742277, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10844445647671819, "edit_score": 0.3576004397589714, "background_score": 0.03554269764572382, "combined_score": 0.39440742684528235, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/175584_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08567216992378235, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.31369248032569885, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004562033340334892, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9192950129508972, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0047288015484809875, "full_mse_to_target": 0.020794764161109924, "input_change_l1": 0.026162294670939445, "directional_pixel_score": 0.48683068435639143, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0709343772381544, "edit_score": 0.35122600276954474, "background_score": 0.02070303075015545, "combined_score": 0.374738415395841, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/175584_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09664352983236313, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3050992786884308, "background_mse_to_source": 0.016700444743037224, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8528829216957092, "background_mse_to_target": 0.016596876084804535, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03248485550284386, "input_change_l1": 0.050050556659698486, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4868308026343584, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13187919445335866, "edit_score": 0.3639159734360874, "background_score": 0.04612386040389538, "combined_score": 0.4096836490184069, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/175584_1/175584_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07993815094232559, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.31668320298194885, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007788186427205801, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7135917544364929, "background_mse_to_target": 0.007502673659473658, "full_mse_to_target": 0.021879957988858223, "input_change_l1": 0.05691618099808693, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6000601053237915, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.050519581977277996, "edit_score": 0.31658648401498796, "background_score": 0.06506983553990722, "combined_score": 0.35165283864829694, "confidence": 0.6586968712906134}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/175584_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/175584_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/175584_1.json"}

175584_2

Can we have mountains on the background?

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.10631847381591797, "dataset_mask_area": 0.10631847381591797, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.3556910455226898, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.004795726388692856, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.35089531913399696, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9221920542684835, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.941747572815534, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.36392641067504883, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.49922826855883634, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.09091910391609417, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.10004266089294106, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.24393580853939056, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.3556910455226898, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6858081236791487, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.13199806213378906, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/175584_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5310465097427368, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4689534604549408}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.06366608848352917, "reward": -0.06366608848352917}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.06988339099939911, "reward": -0.06988339099939911}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.08698420612281187, "reward": -0.08698420612281187}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.13566471447609368, "reward": -0.13566471447609368}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2563309467062354, "reward": -0.2563309467062354}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06366608848352917, "loser_reward": -0.08698420612281187, "reward_margin": 0.023318117639282696, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06366608848352917, "loser_reward": -0.13566471447609368, "reward_margin": 0.07199862599256451, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06366608848352917, "loser_reward": -0.2563309467062354, "reward_margin": 0.19266485822270624, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06988339099939911, "loser_reward": -0.08698420612281187, "reward_margin": 0.017100815123412758, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06988339099939911, "loser_reward": -0.13566471447609368, "reward_margin": 0.06578132347669458, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06988339099939911, "loser_reward": -0.2563309467062354, "reward_margin": 0.1864475557068363, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08698420612281187, "loser_reward": -0.13566471447609368, "reward_margin": 0.04868050835328182, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08698420612281187, "loser_reward": -0.2563309467062354, "reward_margin": 0.16934674058342353, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13566471447609368, "loser_reward": -0.2563309467062354, "reward_margin": 0.12066623223014172, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 111483, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 170, 1024, 390], "component_score": 0.06366608848352917, "component_reward": -0.06366608848352917, "second_component_score": 0.06988339099939911, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.006217302515869938, "confidence": 0.7037057952025823}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7037057876586914, "teacher_quality_score": 0.09091910391609417, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.09091910391609417, "global_like": true, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06366608848352917, "loser_reward": -0.08698420612281187, "reward_margin": 0.023318117639282696, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06366608848352917, "loser_reward": -0.13566471447609368, "reward_margin": 0.07199862599256451, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06366608848352917, "loser_reward": -0.2563309467062354, "reward_margin": 0.19266485822270624, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.06988339099939911, "loser_reward": -0.08698420612281187, "reward_margin": 0.017100815123412758, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.06988339099939911, "loser_reward": -0.13566471447609368, "reward_margin": 0.06578132347669458, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.06988339099939911, "loser_reward": -0.2563309467062354, "reward_margin": 0.1864475557068363, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.08698420612281187, "loser_reward": -0.13566471447609368, "reward_margin": 0.04868050835328182, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.08698420612281187, "loser_reward": -0.2563309467062354, "reward_margin": 0.16934674058342353, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13566471447609368, "loser_reward": -0.2563309467062354, "reward_margin": 0.12066623223014172, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/175584_2/175584_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12971076369285583, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6295464038848877, "background_mse_to_source": 0.14050085842609406, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4551025927066803, "background_mse_to_target": 0.14167426526546478, "full_mse_to_target": 0.14040227234363556, "input_change_l1": 0.263416051864624, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7298265993595123, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16068257912993433, "edit_score": 0.2713448330760002, "background_score": 0.24948033988475798, "combined_score": 0.4048396950960159, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/175584_2/175584_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.022817982360720634, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7874364256858826, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005541035905480385, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9515318870544434, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006702972576022148, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008416294120252132, "input_change_l1": 0.062306299805641174, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9637911915779114, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09743000839371235, "edit_score": 0.07438289932906628, "background_score": 0.015234658494591713, "combined_score": 0.10004266089294106, "confidence": 0.6411688702698883}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/175584_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03762261942028999, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7875030040740967, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002341084647923708, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9702682495117188, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0031668359879404306, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006830120924860239, "input_change_l1": 0.040499087423086166, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9637896120548248, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06350401118397712, "edit_score": 0.08917461559176446, "background_score": 0.008287434745579959, "combined_score": 0.1054590320819989, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/175584_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.034659650176763535, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.7516371607780457, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008565420284867287, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9391565322875977, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00995695497840643, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012583303265273571, "input_change_l1": 0.07739721983671188, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9637909531593323, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12149323201738299, "edit_score": 0.09338447973132133, "background_score": 0.020734113827347758, "combined_score": 0.126198396300897, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/175584_2/175584_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07120844721794128, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.772822916507721, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009307622909545898, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7028279304504395, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009647560305893421, "full_mse_to_target": 0.016192615032196045, "input_change_l1": 0.08168815076351166, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9163710474967957, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08462290223687886, "edit_score": 0.13755110204219817, "background_score": 0.06874203681945801, "combined_score": 0.18015465687960386, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/175584_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/175584_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/175584_2.json"}

175584_3

Put a horse insted of the goats.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.03437042236328125, "dataset_mask_area": 0.03437042236328125, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.17598725855350494, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.005393138155341148, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1705941203981638, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.48072356910772307, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.5238127659574469, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.49583160877227783, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.24923345932938842, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.01101003457206389, "best_expert": "pix2pix", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.19150054510682823, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.03215403109788895, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.17598724365234375, "edit_change_ratio": 0.18270660094778254, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.1621542125940323, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9213975355757142}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.05828857421875, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/175584_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5115689635276794, "qwen_image_edit": 0.48843103647232056}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.09754938550695079, "reward": -0.09754938550695079}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.09986359140044078, "reward": -0.09986359140044078}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.10079648809996433, "reward": -0.10079648809996433}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.10771590181998908, "reward": -0.10771590181998908}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.13426403218787164, "reward": -0.13426403218787164}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "175584_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09754938550695079, "loser_reward": -0.10771590181998908, "reward_margin": 0.01016651631303829, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09754938550695079, "loser_reward": -0.13426403218787164, "reward_margin": 0.03671464668092085, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09986359140044078, "loser_reward": -0.13426403218787164, "reward_margin": 0.03440044078743086, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10079648809996433, "loser_reward": -0.13426403218787164, "reward_margin": 0.03346754408790731, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10771590181998908, "loser_reward": -0.13426403218787164, "reward_margin": 0.02654813036788256, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 11169, "bbox_xyxy": [56, 256, 450, 326], "component_score": 0.09754938550695079, "component_reward": -0.09754938550695079, "second_component_score": 0.09986359140044078, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.00231420589348999, "confidence": 0.591593529158476}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.5159358978271484, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.48406413197517395}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.15330193603318185, "reward": -0.15330193603318185}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1564901971120853, "reward": -0.1564901971120853}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.15910443461639803, "reward": -0.15910443461639803}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.16025266800215468, "reward": -0.16025266800215468}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1656096797566861, "reward": -0.1656096797566861}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "175584_3__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15330193603318185, "loser_reward": -0.1656096797566861, "reward_margin": 0.012307743723504266, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 20877, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 315, 268, 484], "component_score": 0.15330193603318185, "component_reward": -0.15330193603318185, "second_component_score": 0.1564901971120853, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.003188261078903465, "confidence": 0.5865914141605018}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.10577173905353994, "reward": -0.10577173905353994}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1296945087049389, "reward": -0.1296945087049389}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1317475963514298, "reward": -0.1317475963514298}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1723904870231636, "reward": -0.1723904870231636}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19344618071243166, "reward": -0.19344618071243166}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "175584_3__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.10577173905353994, "loser_reward": -0.1296945087049389, "reward_margin": 0.02392276965139896, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10577173905353994, "loser_reward": -0.1317475963514298, "reward_margin": 0.025975857297889857, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10577173905353994, "loser_reward": -0.1723904870231636, "reward_margin": 0.06661874796962365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10577173905353994, "loser_reward": -0.19344618071243166, "reward_margin": 0.08767444165889172, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1296945087049389, "loser_reward": -0.1723904870231636, "reward_margin": 0.04269597831822469, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1296945087049389, "loser_reward": -0.19344618071243166, "reward_margin": 0.06375167200749277, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1317475963514298, "loser_reward": -0.1723904870231636, "reward_margin": 0.040642890671733795, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1317475963514298, "loser_reward": -0.19344618071243166, "reward_margin": 0.06169858436100187, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1723904870231636, "loser_reward": -0.19344618071243166, "reward_margin": 0.021055693689268073, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 3994, "bbox_xyxy": [521, 410, 628, 496], "component_score": 0.10577173905353994, "component_reward": -0.10577173905353994, "second_component_score": 0.1296945087049389, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.02392276965139896, "confidence": 0.8325214902534297}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6153959035873413, "teacher_quality_score": 0.01101003457206389, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.01101003457206389, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "175584_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.09754938550695079, "loser_reward": -0.10771590181998908, "reward_margin": 0.01016651631303829, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09754938550695079, "loser_reward": -0.13426403218787164, "reward_margin": 0.03671464668092085, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09986359140044078, "loser_reward": -0.13426403218787164, "reward_margin": 0.03440044078743086, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10079648809996433, "loser_reward": -0.13426403218787164, "reward_margin": 0.03346754408790731, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10771590181998908, "loser_reward": -0.13426403218787164, "reward_margin": 0.02654813036788256, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region1__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15330193603318185, "loser_reward": -0.1656096797566861, "reward_margin": 0.012307743723504266, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.10577173905353994, "loser_reward": -0.1296945087049389, "reward_margin": 0.02392276965139896, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10577173905353994, "loser_reward": -0.1317475963514298, "reward_margin": 0.025975857297889857, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.10577173905353994, "loser_reward": -0.1723904870231636, "reward_margin": 0.06661874796962365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10577173905353994, "loser_reward": -0.19344618071243166, "reward_margin": 0.08767444165889172, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1296945087049389, "loser_reward": -0.1723904870231636, "reward_margin": 0.04269597831822469, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1296945087049389, "loser_reward": -0.19344618071243166, "reward_margin": 0.06375167200749277, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1317475963514298, "loser_reward": -0.1723904870231636, "reward_margin": 0.040642890671733795, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1317475963514298, "loser_reward": -0.19344618071243166, "reward_margin": 0.06169858436100187, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "175584_3__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1723904870231636, "loser_reward": -0.19344618071243166, "reward_margin": 0.021055693689268073, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/175584_3/175584_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05905211716890335, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8913803100585938, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0033235903829336166, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9233787059783936, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0037417402490973473, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005642777308821678, "input_change_l1": 0.03556886687874794, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6307028234004974, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.056545854266732934, "edit_score": 0.17310034930706025, "background_score": 0.018647849187254907, "combined_score": 0.19150054510682823, "confidence": 0.6470239842919129}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/175584_3/175584_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.059907216578722, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.883482038974762, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014198174700140953, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8844177722930908, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014761076308786869, "full_mse_to_target": 0.016312768682837486, "input_change_l1": 0.035919591784477234, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5546955615282059, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.031883975164964794, "edit_score": 0.19453691840171813, "background_score": 0.037314620241522795, "combined_score": 0.2156051073875278, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/175584_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05751611292362213, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8944220542907715, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0059987278655171394, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9207441210746765, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006557592656463385, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008309058845043182, "input_change_l1": 0.02334771491587162, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5546955578029156, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.020793901628348977, "edit_score": 0.18995781261473893, "background_score": 0.02184990365058184, "combined_score": 0.20259496510261668, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/175584_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06127088516950607, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.880156934261322, "background_mse_to_source": 0.021375557407736778, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8671596050262451, "background_mse_to_target": 0.021937599405646324, "full_mse_to_target": 0.023289494216442108, "input_change_l1": 0.04403524473309517, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5561275221407413, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.037304853275418284, "edit_score": 0.19620761778205634, "background_score": 0.047943636402487756, "combined_score": 0.22277781059965493, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/175584_3/175584_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.056678611785173416, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8819623589515686, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008585617877542973, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6967778205871582, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008755091577768326, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01040224451571703, "input_change_l1": 0.06309158354997635, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6614965200424194, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06410530209541321, "edit_score": 0.16491200998425484, "background_score": 0.06923005376011133, "combined_score": 0.20300381367094816, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/175584_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/175584_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/175584_3.json"}

177572_1

make the woman hold a camera

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.0887639969587326, "dataset_mask_area": 0.088764, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.30236300826072693, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0043603722006082535, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2980026360601187, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.842823712948518, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9564768368250222, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4313400387763977, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4374005550869417, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.25189831925679756, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.32783029202371833, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.15274490416049957, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.30236297845840454, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5051706559422994, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.11947199702262878, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/177572_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6270866990089417, "pix2pix": 0.3729132413864136}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.21999068317376078, "reward": -0.21999068317376078}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.24597764752246443, "reward": -0.24597764752246443}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2540510273762047, "reward": -0.2540510273762047}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.25407549790013584, "reward": -0.25407549790013584}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2896579220369458, "reward": -0.2896579220369458}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "177572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21999068317376078, "loser_reward": -0.24597764752246443, "reward_margin": 0.02598696434870365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21999068317376078, "loser_reward": -0.2540510273762047, "reward_margin": 0.03406034420244394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21999068317376078, "loser_reward": -0.25407549790013584, "reward_margin": 0.03408481472637506, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21999068317376078, "loser_reward": -0.2896579220369458, "reward_margin": 0.06966723886318502, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24597764752246443, "loser_reward": -0.2896579220369458, "reward_margin": 0.043680274514481365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2540510273762047, "loser_reward": -0.2896579220369458, "reward_margin": 0.03560689466074107, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.25407549790013584, "loser_reward": -0.2896579220369458, "reward_margin": 0.035582424136809954, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 22191, "bbox_xyxy": [39, 149, 187, 388], "component_score": 0.21999068317376078, "component_reward": -0.21999068317376078, "second_component_score": 0.24597764752246443, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.02598696434870365, "confidence": 0.7295997801240306}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7295998930931091, "teacher_quality_score": 0.25189831925679756, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.25189831925679756, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "177572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21999068317376078, "loser_reward": -0.24597764752246443, "reward_margin": 0.02598696434870365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21999068317376078, "loser_reward": -0.2540510273762047, "reward_margin": 0.03406034420244394, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21999068317376078, "loser_reward": -0.25407549790013584, "reward_margin": 0.03408481472637506, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21999068317376078, "loser_reward": -0.2896579220369458, "reward_margin": 0.06966723886318502, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24597764752246443, "loser_reward": -0.2896579220369458, "reward_margin": 0.043680274514481365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2540510273762047, "loser_reward": -0.2896579220369458, "reward_margin": 0.03560689466074107, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.25407549790013584, "loser_reward": -0.2896579220369458, "reward_margin": 0.035582424136809954, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/177572_1/177572_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.118620365858078, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4617224931716919, "background_mse_to_source": 0.018904171884059906, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6428393721580505, "background_mse_to_target": 0.018832946196198463, "full_mse_to_target": 0.027690475806593895, "input_change_l1": 0.10750014334917068, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7795597910881042, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09642684254795314, "edit_score": 0.28138591945171354, "background_score": 0.0903362974524498, "combined_score": 0.33505803965032094, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/177572_1/177572_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13844913244247437, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4654296934604645, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0354408398270607, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5651569366455078, "background_mse_to_target": 0.035339370369911194, "full_mse_to_target": 0.044491808861494064, "input_change_l1": 0.1160774827003479, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7316864728927612, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11145335473120213, "edit_score": 0.31244157552719115, "background_score": 0.12240945249795915, "combined_score": 0.3820247357338667, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/177572_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11724931001663208, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.48295366764068604, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014973752200603485, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.745015561580658, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0149964839220047, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02407284826040268, "input_change_l1": 0.0754503607749939, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7316865622997284, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07298173662275076, "edit_score": 0.28773693591356275, "background_score": 0.0659706398844719, "combined_score": 0.32783029202371833, "confidence": 0.588732848039361}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/177572_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.16458652913570404, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4447959363460541, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05381309241056442, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4666992723941803, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05362892895936966, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06347797065973282, "input_change_l1": 0.14362193644046783, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7314726114273071, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13466515466570855, "edit_score": 0.34275918900966645, "background_score": 0.16047323793172835, "combined_score": 0.43220565028488633, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/177572_1/177572_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12912015616893768, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4764886796474457, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007256276439875364, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8116888999938965, "background_mse_to_target": 0.007273213937878609, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01808883622288704, "input_change_l1": 0.06378889828920364, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6803659945726395, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.059382899478077886, "edit_score": 0.3137309215962887, "background_score": 0.04491849644109607, "combined_score": 0.34313785886857656, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/177572_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/177572_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/177572_1.json"}

177572_2

give the woman another camera

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.04784107208251953, "dataset_mask_area": 0.04784107208251953, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.226655051112175, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0010130660375580192, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.22564198507461697, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8407681724807298, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9390418455839017, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4599386751651764, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3640958395956606, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.18570204711817495, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2069898787885904, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.17970967292785645, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.22665506601333618, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7928773712795922, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.061054229736328125, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/177572_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6189497709274292, "qwen_image_edit": 0.3810502290725708}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1270082550230436, "reward": -0.1270082550230436}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.15126290954556315, "reward": -0.15126290954556315}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19118429860472677, "reward": -0.19118429860472677}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1937079712646082, "reward": -0.1937079712646082}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.23367874081037007, "reward": -0.23367874081037007}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1270082550230436, "loser_reward": -0.15126290954556315, "reward_margin": 0.024254654522519542, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1270082550230436, "loser_reward": -0.19118429860472677, "reward_margin": 0.06417604358168316, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1270082550230436, "loser_reward": -0.1937079712646082, "reward_margin": 0.0666997162415646, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1270082550230436, "loser_reward": -0.23367874081037007, "reward_margin": 0.10667048578732646, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15126290954556315, "loser_reward": -0.19118429860472677, "reward_margin": 0.03992138905916362, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15126290954556315, "loser_reward": -0.1937079712646082, "reward_margin": 0.04244506171904505, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15126290954556315, "loser_reward": -0.23367874081037007, "reward_margin": 0.08241583126480692, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19118429860472677, "loser_reward": -0.23367874081037007, "reward_margin": 0.0424944422056433, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1937079712646082, "loser_reward": -0.23367874081037007, "reward_margin": 0.03997076954576187, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 50165, "bbox_xyxy": [614, 330, 916, 631], "component_score": 0.1270082550230436, "component_reward": -0.1270082550230436, "second_component_score": 0.15126290954556315, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.024254654522519542, "confidence": 0.804630511546887}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8046303391456604, "teacher_quality_score": 0.18570204711817495, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.18570204711817495, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1270082550230436, "loser_reward": -0.15126290954556315, "reward_margin": 0.024254654522519542, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1270082550230436, "loser_reward": -0.19118429860472677, "reward_margin": 0.06417604358168316, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1270082550230436, "loser_reward": -0.1937079712646082, "reward_margin": 0.0666997162415646, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1270082550230436, "loser_reward": -0.23367874081037007, "reward_margin": 0.10667048578732646, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15126290954556315, "loser_reward": -0.19118429860472677, "reward_margin": 0.03992138905916362, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15126290954556315, "loser_reward": -0.1937079712646082, "reward_margin": 0.04244506171904505, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15126290954556315, "loser_reward": -0.23367874081037007, "reward_margin": 0.08241583126480692, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19118429860472677, "loser_reward": -0.23367874081037007, "reward_margin": 0.0424944422056433, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177572_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1937079712646082, "loser_reward": -0.23367874081037007, "reward_margin": 0.03997076954576187, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/177572_2/177572_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09010437875986099, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5972356200218201, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004028673749417067, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9338205456733704, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004084814805537462, "full_mse_to_target": 0.00820008572191, "input_change_l1": 0.039993323385715485, "directional_pixel_score": 0.36445772647857666, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.024559624562971293, "edit_score": 0.3295428231358528, "background_score": 0.017264564614742996, "combined_score": 0.3413173542357981, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/177572_2/177572_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07016628235578537, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6421671509742737, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02080252580344677, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7620592713356018, "background_mse_to_target": 0.020761173218488693, "full_mse_to_target": 0.023124761879444122, "input_change_l1": 0.07190823554992676, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7935732305049896, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10474832383915783, "edit_score": 0.19333954453468322, "background_score": 0.06839067153632641, "combined_score": 0.24053842052817345, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/177572_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05354899540543556, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.62995445728302, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008789069019258022, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8572344779968262, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008786715567111969, "full_mse_to_target": 0.010928187519311905, "input_change_l1": 0.04674037918448448, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7935736179351807, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06831299937330186, "edit_score": 0.17916469946503638, "background_score": 0.037342173419892793, "combined_score": 0.2069898787885904, "confidence": 0.7778848297629642}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/177572_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09498323500156403, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5835623741149902, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03188924863934517, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7111973166465759, "background_mse_to_target": 0.031820088624954224, "full_mse_to_target": 0.034841883927583694, "input_change_l1": 0.0894850417971611, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7936283349990845, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1286937363445759, "edit_score": 0.22986367642879485, "background_score": 0.08964978531002998, "combined_score": 0.2904640369489789, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/177572_2/177572_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0771355926990509, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5907958745956421, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007242242339998484, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8276941180229187, "background_mse_to_target": 0.007310993503779173, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01065148040652275, "input_change_l1": 0.05410514399409294, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6158427521586418, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06272234637290239, "edit_score": 0.25501572974026204, "background_score": 0.04170341873541474, "combined_score": 0.2832215436128899, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/177572_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/177572_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/177572_2.json"}

177824_1

let the bed be wooden

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.1874600052833557, "dataset_mask_area": 0.18746, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.21786995232105255, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.008518117479979992, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.20935183484107256, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7956898627498195, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9302991202346041, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.2633488178253174, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.342046583180435, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.012965426359005506, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3071627829875797, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.057340141385793686, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.21786993741989136, "edit_change_ratio": 0.2631851923438363, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.20962774753570557, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9621692190221683}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.2696160078048706, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/177824_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5057744383811951, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49422553181648254}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.20582936543412508, "reward": -0.20582936543412508}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.20698431096150305, "reward": -0.20698431096150305}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.20755509830743532, "reward": -0.20755509830743532}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.21428050045412966, "reward": -0.21428050045412966}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.22721951282955707, "reward": -0.22721951282955707}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "177824_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20582936543412508, "loser_reward": -0.22721951282955707, "reward_margin": 0.02139014739543199, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20698431096150305, "loser_reward": -0.22721951282955707, "reward_margin": 0.020235201868054026, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20755509830743532, "loser_reward": -0.22721951282955707, "reward_margin": 0.019664414522121754, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21428050045412966, "loser_reward": -0.22721951282955707, "reward_margin": 0.012939012375427411, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 46865, "bbox_xyxy": [180, 114, 469, 416], "component_score": 0.20582936543412508, "component_reward": -0.20582936543412508, "second_component_score": 0.20698431096150305, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0011549455273779652, "confidence": 0.5600420964218228}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5600420236587524, "teacher_quality_score": 0.012965426359005506, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.012965426359005506, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "177824_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20582936543412508, "loser_reward": -0.22721951282955707, "reward_margin": 0.02139014739543199, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20698431096150305, "loser_reward": -0.22721951282955707, "reward_margin": 0.020235201868054026, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20755509830743532, "loser_reward": -0.22721951282955707, "reward_margin": 0.019664414522121754, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21428050045412966, "loser_reward": -0.22721951282955707, "reward_margin": 0.012939012375427411, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/177824_1/177824_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11063659936189651, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6001676917076111, "background_mse_to_source": 0.02829555608332157, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5813842415809631, "background_mse_to_target": 0.028473438695073128, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04387575015425682, "input_change_l1": 0.13705454766750336, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6522684246301651, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08689880352467298, "edit_score": 0.277535954862833, "background_score": 0.11201870776712895, "combined_score": 0.3385098383016884, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/177824_1/177824_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10137487202882767, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.579963743686676, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00020522615523077548, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9909283518791199, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0007146618445403874, "full_mse_to_target": 0.019584421068429947, "input_change_l1": 0.016687724739313126, "directional_pixel_score": 0.40921420603990555, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.015293874032795429, "edit_score": 0.33307857178151606, "background_score": 0.002019555779406801, "combined_score": 0.33880263321771054, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/177824_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09258518368005753, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5793961882591248, "background_mse_to_source": 8.67080525495112e-05, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9944868087768555, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006164534715935588, "full_mse_to_target": 0.017856907099485397, "input_change_l1": 0.010847018100321293, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4092143177986145, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.010020370525307954, "edit_score": 0.32440236657857896, "background_score": 0.0011893462971784175, "combined_score": 0.32860840259760155, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/177824_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10792287439107895, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5688683986663818, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0003206455148756504, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9881870150566101, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0008155799587257206, "full_mse_to_target": 0.020893918350338936, "input_change_l1": 0.020659824833273888, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4104554206132889, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01868612582329661, "edit_score": 0.34153533950448034, "background_score": 0.002683242503553629, "combined_score": 0.34830109138041726, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/177824_1/177824_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08575302362442017, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5844350457191467, "background_mse_to_source": 0.006379508413374424, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8117882609367371, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006606641691178083, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02144342102110386, "input_change_l1": 0.0596296451985836, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5660654827952385, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06130573712289333, "edit_score": 0.2773496437817812, "background_score": 0.044021856226027015, "combined_score": 0.3071627829875797, "confidence": 0.664873849589238}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/177824_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/177824_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/177824_1.json"}

177824_2

let the tiled floor be made of plain granite

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.18835830688476562, "dataset_mask_area": 0.18835830688476562, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2836572825908661, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0020268417429178953, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2816304408479482, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.923340274763593, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9616957296910159, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.304912269115448, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.43089910300722, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.16490870292494947, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.1677020957705099, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.16047413647174835, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2836572527885437, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5657325342263541, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.2086324691772461, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/177824_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.507541298866272, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.49245867133140564}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.11156721635628492, "reward": -0.11156721635628492}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1130755889295833, "reward": -0.1130755889295833}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.12079739457456162, "reward": -0.12079739457456162}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.21625212288834153, "reward": -0.21625212288834153}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.25777180226426577, "reward": -0.25777180226426577}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11156721635628492, "loser_reward": -0.21625212288834153, "reward_margin": 0.10468490653205662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11156721635628492, "loser_reward": -0.25777180226426577, "reward_margin": 0.14620458590798086, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1130755889295833, "loser_reward": -0.21625212288834153, "reward_margin": 0.10317653395875823, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1130755889295833, "loser_reward": -0.25777180226426577, "reward_margin": 0.14469621333468247, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12079739457456162, "loser_reward": -0.21625212288834153, "reward_margin": 0.09545472831377991, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12079739457456162, "loser_reward": -0.25777180226426577, "reward_margin": 0.13697440768970415, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21625212288834153, "loser_reward": -0.25777180226426577, "reward_margin": 0.04151967937592424, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 197508, "bbox_xyxy": [49, 736, 1024, 1024], "component_score": 0.11156721635628492, "component_reward": -0.11156721635628492, "second_component_score": 0.1130755889295833, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0015083725732983888, "confidence": 0.5739883422883821}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5739881992340088, "teacher_quality_score": 0.16490870292494947, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.16490870292494947, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.11156721635628492, "loser_reward": -0.21625212288834153, "reward_margin": 0.10468490653205662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11156721635628492, "loser_reward": -0.25777180226426577, "reward_margin": 0.14620458590798086, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1130755889295833, "loser_reward": -0.21625212288834153, "reward_margin": 0.10317653395875823, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1130755889295833, "loser_reward": -0.25777180226426577, "reward_margin": 0.14469621333468247, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12079739457456162, "loser_reward": -0.21625212288834153, "reward_margin": 0.09545472831377991, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12079739457456162, "loser_reward": -0.25777180226426577, "reward_margin": 0.13697440768970415, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21625212288834153, "loser_reward": -0.25777180226426577, "reward_margin": 0.04151967937592424, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/177824_2/177824_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09914878755807877, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4974350929260254, "background_mse_to_source": 0.08428018540143967, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.381695955991745, "background_mse_to_target": 0.08376840502023697, "full_mse_to_target": 0.08666542172431946, "input_change_l1": 0.2709616720676422, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8695140779018402, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2692548419348895, "edit_score": 0.23228324949741364, "background_score": 0.20794099420309067, "combined_score": 0.36758010802790525, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/177824_2/177824_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.047635242342948914, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5951521992683411, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0004076202167198062, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.985163688659668, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0005312649300321937, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009403691627085209, "input_change_l1": 0.038883354514837265, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8895307183265686, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04679197415243835, "edit_score": 0.15622212290763854, "background_score": 0.0033748824847862125, "combined_score": 0.1677020957705099, "confidence": 0.5727797357204848}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/177824_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06106634810566902, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5960010886192322, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0001722195593174547, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9913976788520813, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0003187962283845991, "full_mse_to_target": 0.011761106550693512, "input_change_l1": 0.02527417056262493, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8895314931869507, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.030526140111032874, "edit_score": 0.16948325708508494, "background_score": 0.001892683788901195, "combined_score": 0.1774270350884763, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/177824_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.043644979596138, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.577706515789032, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0006369061884470284, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9804330468177795, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0007441707421094179, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008824892342090607, "input_change_l1": 0.048603642731904984, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8895359337329865, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05829357288312167, "edit_score": 0.15571969300508498, "background_score": 0.00455029682489112, "combined_score": 0.16985350070463026, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/177824_2/177824_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08825016766786575, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4267455041408539, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010924764908850193, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8081352710723877, "background_mse_to_target": 0.011051283217966557, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02559233270585537, "input_change_l1": 0.08241540938615799, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7237623929977417, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05777386091649533, "edit_score": 0.2719604685902596, "background_score": 0.04929771069437266, "combined_score": 0.3033286727871746, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/177824_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/177824_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/177824_2.json"}

177824_3

make a cat jump onto a bed

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.004009246826171875, "dataset_mask_area": 0.004009246826171875, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.1460740715265274, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0013158513465896249, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.14475822017993778, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.5725886878472717, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.5880889669300556, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3737778663635254, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.2369924213988126, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.011088568773243424, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.08336849537503441, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.002033232944086194, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.1460740566253662, "edit_change_ratio": 0.013919192709906002, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.12440905719995499, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.8516848239453286}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.0076732635498046875, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/177824_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.5005007982254028, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49949920177459717}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.05522567182744386, "reward": -0.05522567182744386}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.05532583048474043, "reward": -0.05532583048474043}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.05549874177444144, "reward": -0.05549874177444144}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.17275505612860434, "reward": -0.17275505612860434}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.19184452798473647, "reward": -0.19184452798473647}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.05522567182744386, "loser_reward": -0.17275505612860434, "reward_margin": 0.11752938430116047, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05522567182744386, "loser_reward": -0.19184452798473647, "reward_margin": 0.1366188561572926, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.05532583048474043, "loser_reward": -0.17275505612860434, "reward_margin": 0.1174292256438639, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05532583048474043, "loser_reward": -0.19184452798473647, "reward_margin": 0.13651869749999604, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.05549874177444144, "loser_reward": -0.17275505612860434, "reward_margin": 0.1172563143541629, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05549874177444144, "loser_reward": -0.19184452798473647, "reward_margin": 0.13634578621029503, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17275505612860434, "loser_reward": -0.19184452798473647, "reward_margin": 0.019089471856132134, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4204, "bbox_xyxy": [359, 427, 487, 512], "component_score": 0.05522567182744386, "component_reward": -0.05522567182744386, "second_component_score": 0.05532583048474043, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.00010015865729656737, "confidence": 0.5532585557242866}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5532584190368652, "teacher_quality_score": 0.011088568773243424, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.011088568773243424, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.05522567182744386, "loser_reward": -0.17275505612860434, "reward_margin": 0.11752938430116047, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05522567182744386, "loser_reward": -0.19184452798473647, "reward_margin": 0.1366188561572926, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.05532583048474043, "loser_reward": -0.17275505612860434, "reward_margin": 0.1174292256438639, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05532583048474043, "loser_reward": -0.19184452798473647, "reward_margin": 0.13651869749999604, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.05549874177444144, "loser_reward": -0.17275505612860434, "reward_margin": 0.1172563143541629, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05549874177444144, "loser_reward": -0.19184452798473647, "reward_margin": 0.13634578621029503, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "177824_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17275505612860434, "loser_reward": -0.19184452798473647, "reward_margin": 0.019089471856132134, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/177824_3/177824_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.072182297706604, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8396919369697571, "background_mse_to_source": 0.08043991029262543, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.2478588968515396, "background_mse_to_target": 0.08040885627269745, "full_mse_to_target": 0.08037588745355606, "input_change_l1": 0.22487688064575195, "directional_pixel_score": 0.2594359219074249, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0873969443840906, "edit_score": 0.28938492983579633, "background_score": 0.2308681309223175, "combined_score": 0.39570575328078117, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/177824_3/177824_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.023577164858579636, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8853572010993958, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002318120561540127, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9559724926948547, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0022959120105952024, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0023812337312847376, "input_change_l1": 0.0156896710395813, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8667393624782562, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.003566612477879971, "edit_score": 0.07982088401913642, "background_score": 0.01112362202256918, "combined_score": 0.08466559759574012, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/177824_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.02403220720589161, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8851897716522217, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0009794054785743356, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9694414138793945, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0009994159918278456, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0010917600011453032, "input_change_l1": 0.010198282077908516, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8667387664318085, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.002339325807406567, "edit_score": 0.08030956126749515, "background_score": 0.00709112270269543, "combined_score": 0.08336849537503441, "confidence": 0.5775420557758957}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/177824_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.023257296532392502, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8853578567504883, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0035716723650693893, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9484495520591736, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0035205630119889975, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0035996923688799143, "input_change_l1": 0.019565824419260025, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8667393326759338, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0044500073359813545, "edit_score": 0.07950089201331138, "background_score": 0.013881761953234673, "combined_score": 0.08560947940102778, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/177824_3/177824_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04202036187052727, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8717394471168518, "background_mse_to_source": 0.006575404200702906, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8277764916419983, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006633959710597992, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0067758322693407536, "input_change_l1": 0.05240504816174507, "directional_pixel_score": 0.07994338870048523, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03464004991110414, "edit_score": 0.2976866252720356, "background_score": 0.04102010587230325, "combined_score": 0.3196492555364966, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/177824_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/177824_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/177824_3.json"}

178403_1

Make the apples green

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.09026399999856949, "dataset_mask_area": 0.090264, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.24045243859291077, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0069871018640697, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.23346533672884107, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8206619695231853, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9156307129798903, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.27719131112098694, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3685700015908189, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+fallback_best_expert", "fusion_fallback": {"used": true, "reason": "fused_teacher_worse_than_best_expert", "fallback": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "teacher_combined_score": 0.3297515099295288, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.32423765130086396, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.07703845202922821, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.24045242369174957, "edit_change_ratio": 0.320389584128245, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1134679988026619, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/178403_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.573170006275177, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4268300235271454}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.21556071465603605, "reward": -0.21556071465603605}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.23030055023505702, "reward": -0.23030055023505702}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.24283461346285182, "reward": -0.24283461346285182}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.25675516335666176, "reward": -0.25675516335666176}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2835941854715347, "reward": -0.2835941854715347}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21556071465603605, "loser_reward": -0.23030055023505702, "reward_margin": 0.014739835579020977, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21556071465603605, "loser_reward": -0.24283461346285182, "reward_margin": 0.02727389880681577, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21556071465603605, "loser_reward": -0.25675516335666176, "reward_margin": 0.04119444870062572, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21556071465603605, "loser_reward": -0.2835941854715347, "reward_margin": 0.06803347081549865, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23030055023505702, "loser_reward": -0.24283461346285182, "reward_margin": 0.012534063227794795, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23030055023505702, "loser_reward": -0.25675516335666176, "reward_margin": 0.026454613121604742, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23030055023505702, "loser_reward": -0.2835941854715347, "reward_margin": 0.05329363523647768, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24283461346285182, "loser_reward": -0.25675516335666176, "reward_margin": 0.013920549893809947, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24283461346285182, "loser_reward": -0.2835941854715347, "reward_margin": 0.04075957200868288, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.25675516335666176, "loser_reward": -0.2835941854715347, "reward_margin": 0.026839022114872935, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 22566, "bbox_xyxy": [352, 290, 500, 500], "component_score": 0.21556071465603605, "component_reward": -0.21556071465603605, "second_component_score": 0.23030055023505702, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.014739835579020977, "confidence": 0.662752062637585}], "teacher_confidence": 0.662752091884613, "teacher_quality_score": 0.32534125911850426, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.32534125911850426, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.21556071465603605, "loser_reward": -0.23030055023505702, "reward_margin": 0.014739835579020977, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21556071465603605, "loser_reward": -0.24283461346285182, "reward_margin": 0.02727389880681577, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21556071465603605, "loser_reward": -0.25675516335666176, "reward_margin": 0.04119444870062572, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21556071465603605, "loser_reward": -0.2835941854715347, "reward_margin": 0.06803347081549865, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23030055023505702, "loser_reward": -0.24283461346285182, "reward_margin": 0.012534063227794795, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23030055023505702, "loser_reward": -0.25675516335666176, "reward_margin": 0.026454613121604742, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23030055023505702, "loser_reward": -0.2835941854715347, "reward_margin": 0.05329363523647768, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24283461346285182, "loser_reward": -0.25675516335666176, "reward_margin": 0.013920549893809947, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24283461346285182, "loser_reward": -0.2835941854715347, "reward_margin": 0.04075957200868288, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.25675516335666176, "loser_reward": -0.2835941854715347, "reward_margin": 0.026839022114872935, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/178403_1/178403_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12814489006996155, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3555769622325897, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017150240018963814, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8417220115661621, "background_mse_to_target": 0.016737375408411026, "full_mse_to_target": 0.026793470606207848, "input_change_l1": 0.0930943638086319, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5875709429383278, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07236228846013545, "edit_score": 0.3601367618888617, "background_score": 0.048805837705731395, "combined_score": 0.3943706098385156, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/178403_1/178403_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.116356261074543, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.36863625049591064, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00015355141658801585, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.996873676776886, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00023763070930726826, "full_mse_to_target": 0.010718961246311665, "input_change_l1": 0.015999743714928627, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6282155513763428, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01166239029262215, "edit_score": 0.3355751231312752, "background_score": 0.0007788160612108186, "combined_score": 0.33925208293585457, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178403_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.103249691426754, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3727148771286011, "background_mse_to_source": 6.487545761046931e-05, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9986305236816406, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00018509462825022638, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009488116949796677, "input_change_l1": 0.010399830527603626, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6282154768705368, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.007587115350179374, "edit_score": 0.32165284678339956, "background_score": 0.0003387707212823443, "combined_score": 0.32423765130086396, "confidence": 0.6288414950702047}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178403_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12788215279579163, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.36561694741249084, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00023877949570305645, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9952252507209778, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00029690153314732015, "full_mse_to_target": 0.011813257820904255, "input_change_l1": 0.019667427986860275, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6288125067949295, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.014100110158324242, "edit_score": 0.3475556366145611, "background_score": 0.0011937293515075, "combined_score": 0.35197478970134405, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/178403_1/178403_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1051081046462059, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.37417784333229065, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01314687728881836, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7493648529052734, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012452599592506886, "full_mse_to_target": 0.020816048607230186, "input_change_l1": 0.07607612758874893, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6176654547452927, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08023018836975099, "edit_score": 0.3258561722934246, "background_score": 0.06327390670776367, "combined_score": 0.3661296821758151, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/178403_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/178403_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/178403_1.json"}

178403_2

Get rid of the jar of cookies

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.1433401107788086, "dataset_mask_area": 0.1433401107788086, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.24224118888378143, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0021342639811336994, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.24010692490264773, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.904988031563123, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9676584824046415, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.27494603395462036, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.38741182798640816, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.3091607297498195, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3073845136715681, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.07767392694950104, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.24224118888378143, "edit_change_ratio": 0.32064706793841813, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.17375850677490234, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/178403_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5256584882736206, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4743415117263794}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.20224282968608898, "reward": -0.20224282968608898}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.20737904392438944, "reward": -0.20737904392438944}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.22169349115423395, "reward": -0.22169349115423395}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.24899476722022518, "reward": -0.24899476722022518}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3419572532400489, "reward": -0.3419572532400489}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20224282968608898, "loser_reward": -0.22169349115423395, "reward_margin": 0.019450661468144975, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20224282968608898, "loser_reward": -0.24899476722022518, "reward_margin": 0.0467519375341362, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20224282968608898, "loser_reward": -0.3419572532400489, "reward_margin": 0.1397144235539599, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20737904392438944, "loser_reward": -0.22169349115423395, "reward_margin": 0.014314447229844512, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20737904392438944, "loser_reward": -0.24899476722022518, "reward_margin": 0.04161572329583574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20737904392438944, "loser_reward": -0.3419572532400489, "reward_margin": 0.13457820931565945, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22169349115423395, "loser_reward": -0.24899476722022518, "reward_margin": 0.027301276065991226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22169349115423395, "loser_reward": -0.3419572532400489, "reward_margin": 0.12026376208581493, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24899476722022518, "loser_reward": -0.3419572532400489, "reward_margin": 0.09296248601982371, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 150303, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 592, 527, 1024], "component_score": 0.20224282968608898, "component_reward": -0.20224282968608898, "second_component_score": 0.20737904392438944, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.005136214238300463, "confidence": 0.5944358106628242}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5944357514381409, "teacher_quality_score": 0.3091607297498195, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.3091607297498195, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20224282968608898, "loser_reward": -0.22169349115423395, "reward_margin": 0.019450661468144975, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20224282968608898, "loser_reward": -0.24899476722022518, "reward_margin": 0.0467519375341362, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20224282968608898, "loser_reward": -0.3419572532400489, "reward_margin": 0.1397144235539599, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20737904392438944, "loser_reward": -0.22169349115423395, "reward_margin": 0.014314447229844512, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20737904392438944, "loser_reward": -0.24899476722022518, "reward_margin": 0.04161572329583574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20737904392438944, "loser_reward": -0.3419572532400489, "reward_margin": 0.13457820931565945, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22169349115423395, "loser_reward": -0.24899476722022518, "reward_margin": 0.027301276065991226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22169349115423395, "loser_reward": -0.3419572532400489, "reward_margin": 0.12026376208581493, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24899476722022518, "loser_reward": -0.3419572532400489, "reward_margin": 0.09296248601982371, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/178403_2/178403_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15691234171390533, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.36658206582069397, "background_mse_to_source": 0.07966309785842896, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3617635667324066, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0798083245754242, "full_mse_to_target": 0.09086042642593384, "input_change_l1": 0.2554531395435333, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6486473083496094, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.21305529102683068, "edit_score": 0.3714341014623642, "background_score": 0.20731038451194764, "combined_score": 0.4956898368895054, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/178403_2/178403_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10478627681732178, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4436241090297699, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005589941283687949, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9946286082267761, "background_mse_to_target": 0.000697102106641978, "full_mse_to_target": 0.015617255121469498, "input_change_l1": 0.020142048597335815, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6409444957971573, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.016037362953647973, "edit_score": 0.3058253310620785, "background_score": 0.0016332724830135704, "combined_score": 0.3111661745340098, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178403_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09645172953605652, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4130372703075409, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00023617499391548336, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9974904656410217, "background_mse_to_target": 0.000372055743355304, "full_mse_to_target": 0.014144118875265121, "input_change_l1": 0.013092338107526302, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6409436017274857, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.010516990441828966, "edit_score": 0.3036083750426769, "background_score": 0.0007380818657111377, "combined_score": 0.3073845136715681, "confidence": 0.5718585187226706}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178403_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11163786798715591, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.40027788281440735, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0007769375224597752, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9924483895301819, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0009167100652121007, "full_mse_to_target": 0.016787497326731682, "input_change_l1": 0.024098657071590424, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6380975693464279, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01877306620590389, "edit_score": 0.32205789908766747, "background_score": 0.0022872596164233983, "combined_score": 0.3282918029272696, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/178403_2/178403_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10634823888540268, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3862561881542206, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008584519848227501, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8571857810020447, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008648162707686424, "full_mse_to_target": 0.022652501240372658, "input_change_l1": 0.05133539065718651, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5654217377305031, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03216994418762624, "edit_score": 0.3377415668219328, "background_score": 0.037147363647818565, "combined_score": 0.35944238306023185, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/178403_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/178403_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/178403_2.json"}

178403_3

Make the cake a chocolate cake

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.16625118255615234, "dataset_mask_area": 0.16625118255615234, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.29254886507987976, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0016807913780212402, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2908680737018585, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8760843453890298, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9662379717024526, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.2620525062084198, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.43464771401664015, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.01667892173296423, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.41634907230734824, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.04276607930660248, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.29254889488220215, "edit_change_ratio": 0.14618438167002026, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.28729453682899475, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9820393850562207}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.19398784637451172, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/178403_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5091549754142761, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4908449947834015}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.30155658299126653, "reward": -0.30155658299126653}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.3033878052351211, "reward": -0.3033878052351211}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.30788053225458134, "reward": -0.30788053225458134}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.310857964082621, "reward": -0.310857964082621}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.38315125517454, "reward": -0.38315125517454}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "178403_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.30155658299126653, "loser_reward": -0.38315125517454, "reward_margin": 0.08159467218327349, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3033878052351211, "loser_reward": -0.38315125517454, "reward_margin": 0.07976344993941892, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.30788053225458134, "loser_reward": -0.38315125517454, "reward_margin": 0.07527072291995868, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.310857964082621, "loser_reward": -0.38315125517454, "reward_margin": 0.07229329109191901, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 174327, "bbox_xyxy": [340, 552, 863, 1024], "component_score": 0.30155658299126653, "component_reward": -0.30155658299126653, "second_component_score": 0.3033878052351211, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0018312222438545689, "confidence": 0.5608625304905961}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5608625411987305, "teacher_quality_score": 0.01667892173296423, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.01667892173296423, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "178403_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.30155658299126653, "loser_reward": -0.38315125517454, "reward_margin": 0.08159467218327349, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3033878052351211, "loser_reward": -0.38315125517454, "reward_margin": 0.07976344993941892, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.30788053225458134, "loser_reward": -0.38315125517454, "reward_margin": 0.07527072291995868, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178403_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.310857964082621, "loser_reward": -0.38315125517454, "reward_margin": 0.07229329109191901, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/178403_3/178403_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1999874711036682, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3021385073661804, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05209941416978836, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5428580641746521, "background_mse_to_target": 0.052251413464546204, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07681269943714142, "input_change_l1": 0.16175787150859833, "directional_pixel_score": 0.48837869334965944, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10927021447569132, "edit_score": 0.46746509629301725, "background_score": 0.14352780133485793, "combined_score": 0.5472351395990699, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/178403_3/178403_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.16578610241413116, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.30772897601127625, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0001905057579278946, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9944024682044983, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00031581553048454225, "full_mse_to_target": 0.027825430035591125, "input_change_l1": 0.014167703688144684, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5092148035764694, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.017198072583414617, "edit_score": 0.42693660631775854, "background_score": 0.0013100121170282364, "combined_score": 0.43361726807896045, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178403_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.159553661942482, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3111600875854492, "background_mse_to_source": 8.048867312027141e-05, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9963920712471008, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00021132518304511905, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02670217491686344, "input_change_l1": 0.00920900609344244, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5092147458344698, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.011229891690891235, "edit_score": 0.4200179579667747, "background_score": 0.0008020744237001054, "combined_score": 0.42521487984493433, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178403_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.17078499495983124, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3052062690258026, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0002976483083330095, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9928761124610901, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0004190103500150144, "full_mse_to_target": 0.028742557391524315, "input_change_l1": 0.01750081777572632, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5104936622083187, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.021457784436643125, "edit_score": 0.43212032560259106, "background_score": 0.001722425816114992, "combined_score": 0.43988898726471237, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/178403_3/178403_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1553352028131485, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.31728896498680115, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005062242969870567, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8964147567749023, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005105243530124426, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03008117526769638, "input_change_l1": 0.049762677401304245, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5927045866847038, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.053084697853773836, "edit_score": 0.3937012631446123, "background_score": 0.0257792916148901, "combined_score": 0.41634907230734824, "confidence": 0.5874435487783777}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/178403_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/178403_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/178403_3.json"}

178572_1

Let the player wear a red hat.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.013848000206053257, "dataset_mask_area": 0.013848, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.17890261113643646, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.022486058995127678, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.15641655214130878, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.12562194531284399, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.12908334087412904, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.41191503405570984, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.17665451921381523, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.24105486507419754, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.24341726389422544, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.05376014858484268, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.17890259623527527, "edit_change_ratio": 0.30049954397611184, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.02483999915421009, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/178572_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5530840158462524, "qwen_image_edit": 0.44691598415374756}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1425028403763426, "reward": -0.1425028403763426}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1531598088520113, "reward": -0.1531598088520113}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.16208658077195284, "reward": -0.16208658077195284}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1791045063678175, "reward": -0.1791045063678175}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3103776846677065, "reward": -0.3103776846677065}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1425028403763426, "loser_reward": -0.1531598088520113, "reward_margin": 0.010656968475668716, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1425028403763426, "loser_reward": -0.16208658077195284, "reward_margin": 0.019583740395610255, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1425028403763426, "loser_reward": -0.1791045063678175, "reward_margin": 0.03660166599147491, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1425028403763426, "loser_reward": -0.3103776846677065, "reward_margin": 0.1678748442913639, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1531598088520113, "loser_reward": -0.1791045063678175, "reward_margin": 0.025944697515806192, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1531598088520113, "loser_reward": -0.3103776846677065, "reward_margin": 0.15721787581569518, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16208658077195284, "loser_reward": -0.1791045063678175, "reward_margin": 0.017017925595864652, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16208658077195284, "loser_reward": -0.3103776846677065, "reward_margin": 0.14829110389575365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1791045063678175, "loser_reward": -0.3103776846677065, "reward_margin": 0.131273178299889, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 3462, "bbox_xyxy": [77, 218, 149, 289], "component_score": 0.1425028403763426, "component_reward": -0.1425028403763426, "second_component_score": 0.1531598088520113, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.010656968475668716, "confidence": 0.6721084268457372}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6721085906028748, "teacher_quality_score": 0.24105486507419754, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.24105486507419754, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1425028403763426, "loser_reward": -0.1531598088520113, "reward_margin": 0.010656968475668716, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1425028403763426, "loser_reward": -0.16208658077195284, "reward_margin": 0.019583740395610255, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1425028403763426, "loser_reward": -0.1791045063678175, "reward_margin": 0.03660166599147491, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1425028403763426, "loser_reward": -0.3103776846677065, "reward_margin": 0.1678748442913639, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1531598088520113, "loser_reward": -0.1791045063678175, "reward_margin": 0.025944697515806192, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1531598088520113, "loser_reward": -0.3103776846677065, "reward_margin": 0.15721787581569518, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16208658077195284, "loser_reward": -0.1791045063678175, "reward_margin": 0.017017925595864652, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16208658077195284, "loser_reward": -0.3103776846677065, "reward_margin": 0.14829110389575365, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178572_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1791045063678175, "loser_reward": -0.3103776846677065, "reward_margin": 0.131273178299889, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/178572_1/178572_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11734943836927414, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3332066833972931, "background_mse_to_source": 0.11194770038127899, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.22513820230960846, "background_mse_to_target": 0.10796867311000824, "full_mse_to_target": 0.10809855908155441, "input_change_l1": 0.2583141624927521, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6459846198558807, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.22007742673158648, "edit_score": 0.3392119467258453, "background_score": 0.2669200599193573, "combined_score": 0.4874593089520931, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/178572_1/178572_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05986453965306282, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5340180993080139, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0013889734400436282, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9903474450111389, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0016185265267267823, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002425117651000619, "input_change_l1": 0.02690771408379078, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6179907694458961, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02426175195723772, "edit_score": 0.248563227429986, "background_score": 0.0033194844378158454, "combined_score": 0.2548199091397691, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178572_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.052129264920949936, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5403379797935486, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005868413136340678, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9959413409233093, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0012131899129599333, "full_mse_to_target": 0.001918276073411107, "input_change_l1": 0.01749000884592533, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6179907619953156, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01585978614166379, "edit_score": 0.23956397846341132, "background_score": 0.0013985731289722025, "combined_score": 0.24341726389422544, "confidence": 0.6296968379691765}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178572_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06608125567436218, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5293924808502197, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0021635834127664566, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.985398530960083, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0021090256050229073, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002994912676513195, "input_change_l1": 0.03341143950819969, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6125504821538925, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.030166342109441757, "edit_score": 0.2570651389658451, "background_score": 0.005083877220749855, "combined_score": 0.2651772556826472, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/178572_1/178572_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.051549602299928665, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5265182256698608, "background_mse_to_source": 0.026506245136260986, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5663604736328125, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02269483543932438, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02309441938996315, "input_change_l1": 0.11383388191461563, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7329809814691544, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11748257521539926, "edit_score": 0.21300071179866792, "background_score": 0.11323415040969849, "combined_score": 0.27843862142413855, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/178572_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/178572_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/178572_1.json"}

178928_1

turn the remote into a pizza

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.09212800115346909, "dataset_mask_area": 0.092128, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.30803510546684265, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.005080852657556534, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3029542528092861, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8167560874948411, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9429197636744806, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.1459628939628601, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4386817738556463, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.2562910436675884, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.26496564853936433, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.19546325504779816, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.30803507566452026, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6345486942554438, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.12069600075483322, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/178928_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1939112599696964, "reward": -0.1939112599696964}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2485415821000933, "reward": -0.2485415821000933}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2998457068055868, "reward": -0.2998457068055868}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3115409151874483, "reward": -0.3115409151874483}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3129346546940506, "reward": -0.3129346546940506}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1939112599696964, "loser_reward": -0.2485415821000933, "reward_margin": 0.0546303221303969, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1939112599696964, "loser_reward": -0.2998457068055868, "reward_margin": 0.1059344468358904, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1939112599696964, "loser_reward": -0.3115409151874483, "reward_margin": 0.1176296552177519, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1939112599696964, "loser_reward": -0.3129346546940506, "reward_margin": 0.11902339472435416, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2485415821000933, "loser_reward": -0.2998457068055868, "reward_margin": 0.0513041247054935, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2485415821000933, "loser_reward": -0.3115409151874483, "reward_margin": 0.062999333087355, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2485415821000933, "loser_reward": -0.3129346546940506, "reward_margin": 0.06439307259395727, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2998457068055868, "loser_reward": -0.3115409151874483, "reward_margin": 0.0116952083818615, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2998457068055868, "loser_reward": -0.3129346546940506, "reward_margin": 0.013088947888463764, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 23032, "bbox_xyxy": [136, 336, 349, 500], "component_score": 0.1939112599696964, "component_reward": -0.1939112599696964, "second_component_score": 0.2485415821000933, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0546303221303969, "confidence": 0.8677114154974777}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8677113056182861, "teacher_quality_score": 0.2562910436675884, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.2562910436675884, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1939112599696964, "loser_reward": -0.2485415821000933, "reward_margin": 0.0546303221303969, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1939112599696964, "loser_reward": -0.2998457068055868, "reward_margin": 0.1059344468358904, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1939112599696964, "loser_reward": -0.3115409151874483, "reward_margin": 0.1176296552177519, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1939112599696964, "loser_reward": -0.3129346546940506, "reward_margin": 0.11902339472435416, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2485415821000933, "loser_reward": -0.2998457068055868, "reward_margin": 0.0513041247054935, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2485415821000933, "loser_reward": -0.3115409151874483, "reward_margin": 0.062999333087355, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2485415821000933, "loser_reward": -0.3129346546940506, "reward_margin": 0.06439307259395727, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2998457068055868, "loser_reward": -0.3115409151874483, "reward_margin": 0.0116952083818615, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2998457068055868, "loser_reward": -0.3129346546940506, "reward_margin": 0.013088947888463764, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/178928_1/178928_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13533362746238708, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.36900845170021057, "background_mse_to_source": 0.10689032077789307, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.26751813292503357, "background_mse_to_target": 0.10712460428476334, "full_mse_to_target": 0.10972344875335693, "input_change_l1": 0.27628958225250244, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8478354811668396, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2571598242968321, "edit_score": 0.2995730668306351, "background_score": 0.2533866941928864, "combined_score": 0.4506627195328475, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/178928_1/178928_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1069406270980835, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3757701814174652, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012928028590977192, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9045912623405457, "background_mse_to_target": 0.013703417964279652, "full_mse_to_target": 0.022293174639344215, "input_change_l1": 0.05650635063648224, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8649941682815552, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2150123493745923, "edit_score": 0.26553804874420167, "background_score": 0.03200977612286807, "combined_score": 0.32197325772605834, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178928_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07484330981969833, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.39989376068115234, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005462091416120529, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9267846941947937, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006314277648925781, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012627722695469856, "input_change_l1": 0.0367291234433651, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8649942874908447, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14025043528527023, "edit_score": 0.2286159858107567, "background_score": 0.02010515257716179, "combined_score": 0.26496564853936433, "confidence": 0.8243039452763921}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178928_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14585134387016296, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3620832860469818, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01778215728700161, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8917533755302429, "background_mse_to_target": 0.018513642251491547, "full_mse_to_target": 0.030245013535022736, "input_change_l1": 0.0678088515996933, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8656854629516602, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.2560540404170752, "edit_score": 0.3070133209228516, "background_score": 0.03943148218095303, "combined_score": 0.3750496491231025, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/178928_1/178928_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15856537222862244, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3638145625591278, "background_mse_to_source": 0.034577466547489166, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7329055666923523, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03508743271231651, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04646321386098862, "input_change_l1": 0.07461903989315033, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6098726317286491, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07379321344196796, "edit_score": 0.38333430178463457, "background_score": 0.08799635320901872, "combined_score": 0.4335379894822836, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/178928_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/178928_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/178928_1.json"}

178928_2

give the man glasses

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.0775918960571289, "dataset_mask_area": 0.0775918960571289, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.20318570733070374, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.003135032020509243, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2000506753101945, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7900187286548419, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.884009911364785, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.1311236023902893, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3302133192033669, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.23701942821033298, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.23536601929634346, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.09215815365314484, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.20318572223186493, "edit_change_ratio": 0.453566090377053, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.10689163208007812, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/178928_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.623191237449646, "qwen_image_edit": 0.3768087923526764}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.147148440434481, "reward": -0.147148440434481}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.17230423514638096, "reward": -0.17230423514638096}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.18252610574848946, "reward": -0.18252610574848946}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.18954729281039906, "reward": -0.18954729281039906}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2186733331102878, "reward": -0.2186733331102878}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.147148440434481, "loser_reward": -0.17230423514638096, "reward_margin": 0.025155794711899965, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.147148440434481, "loser_reward": -0.18252610574848946, "reward_margin": 0.03537766531400846, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.147148440434481, "loser_reward": -0.18954729281039906, "reward_margin": 0.04239885237591806, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.147148440434481, "loser_reward": -0.2186733331102878, "reward_margin": 0.0715248926758068, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17230423514638096, "loser_reward": -0.18252610574848946, "reward_margin": 0.010221870602108496, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17230423514638096, "loser_reward": -0.18954729281039906, "reward_margin": 0.017243057664018097, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17230423514638096, "loser_reward": -0.2186733331102878, "reward_margin": 0.04636909796390684, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18252610574848946, "loser_reward": -0.2186733331102878, "reward_margin": 0.036147227361798345, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18954729281039906, "loser_reward": -0.2186733331102878, "reward_margin": 0.029126040299888745, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 81361, "bbox_xyxy": [200, 296, 767, 566], "component_score": 0.147148440434481, "component_reward": -0.147148440434481, "second_component_score": 0.17230423514638096, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.025155794711899965, "confidence": 0.7865002250590987}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7865000367164612, "teacher_quality_score": 0.23701942821033298, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.23701942821033298, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.147148440434481, "loser_reward": -0.17230423514638096, "reward_margin": 0.025155794711899965, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.147148440434481, "loser_reward": -0.18252610574848946, "reward_margin": 0.03537766531400846, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.147148440434481, "loser_reward": -0.18954729281039906, "reward_margin": 0.04239885237591806, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.147148440434481, "loser_reward": -0.2186733331102878, "reward_margin": 0.0715248926758068, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17230423514638096, "loser_reward": -0.18252610574848946, "reward_margin": 0.010221870602108496, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17230423514638096, "loser_reward": -0.18954729281039906, "reward_margin": 0.017243057664018097, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17230423514638096, "loser_reward": -0.2186733331102878, "reward_margin": 0.04636909796390684, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18252610574848946, "loser_reward": -0.2186733331102878, "reward_margin": 0.036147227361798345, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "178928_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18954729281039906, "loser_reward": -0.2186733331102878, "reward_margin": 0.029126040299888745, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/178928_2/178928_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0828888937830925, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5094364285469055, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03890150785446167, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.21249394118785858, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03882715851068497, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04224599525332451, "input_change_l1": 0.15963900089263916, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6889868378639221, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12194643188267947, "edit_score": 0.2587548986077309, "background_score": 0.19640271961688996, "combined_score": 0.35610973637551074, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/178928_2/178928_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07889747619628906, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5317252278327942, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00174572947435081, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9627509713172913, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0016778078861534595, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007669427897781134, "input_change_l1": 0.018108094111084938, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6973360776901245, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05344039448536932, "edit_score": 0.24821841120719912, "background_score": 0.009195535210892558, "combined_score": 0.2628918702178635, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178928_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.062884621322155, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5613287091255188, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0007375707500614226, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9813092350959778, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0008266906952485442, "full_mse_to_target": 0.00564188277348876, "input_change_l1": 0.011770263314247131, "directional_pixel_score": 0.697335347533226, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03475142549723387, "edit_score": 0.22628504261374474, "background_score": 0.004475723730865866, "combined_score": 0.23536601929634346, "confidence": 0.7281697226354751}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/178928_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08562027662992477, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5221248269081116, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002186017809435725, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.952379047870636, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002070688409730792, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008553465828299522, "input_change_l1": 0.02109372429549694, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6982398480176926, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06196703272871673, "edit_score": 0.2566353492438793, "background_score": 0.01171020823530853, "combined_score": 0.27398267525481057, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/178928_2/178928_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07083090394735336, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5396035313606262, "background_mse_to_source": 0.003959542606025934, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.770014226436615, "background_mse_to_target": 0.003924712538719177, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009116087108850479, "input_change_l1": 0.03681298345327377, "directional_pixel_score": 0.614471785724163, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04765180773101747, "edit_score": 0.25929225124418737, "background_score": 0.04995669731870294, "combined_score": 0.28721906556282195, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/178928_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/178928_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/178928_2.json"}

181699_1

replace the donuts with fruits

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.16737599670886993, "dataset_mask_area": 0.167376, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.20598621666431427, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0050980811938643456, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.20088813547044992, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8905193194317677, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.977270392438874, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.41515442728996277, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.34684126949981703, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.18994125912184245, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2172966897673905, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.149772047996521, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.20598620176315308, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7270974789308062, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.22305600345134735, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/181699_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.16811038495413957, "reward": -0.16811038495413957}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2068699487242848, "reward": -0.2068699487242848}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.21067426934279507, "reward": -0.21067426934279507}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.24771085476875299, "reward": -0.24771085476875299}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.29732420271635057, "reward": -0.29732420271635057}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16811038495413957, "loser_reward": -0.2068699487242848, "reward_margin": 0.03875956377014522, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.16811038495413957, "loser_reward": -0.21067426934279507, "reward_margin": 0.04256388438865549, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16811038495413957, "loser_reward": -0.24771085476875299, "reward_margin": 0.07960046981461341, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16811038495413957, "loser_reward": -0.29732420271635057, "reward_margin": 0.129213817762211, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2068699487242848, "loser_reward": -0.24771085476875299, "reward_margin": 0.04084090604446819, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2068699487242848, "loser_reward": -0.29732420271635057, "reward_margin": 0.09045425399206578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21067426934279507, "loser_reward": -0.24771085476875299, "reward_margin": 0.03703658542595792, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21067426934279507, "loser_reward": -0.29732420271635057, "reward_margin": 0.0866499333735555, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24771085476875299, "loser_reward": -0.29732420271635057, "reward_margin": 0.049613347947597586, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 8493, "bbox_xyxy": [148, 108, 304, 188], "component_score": 0.16811038495413957, "component_reward": -0.16811038495413957, "second_component_score": 0.2068699487242848, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.03875956377014522, "confidence": 0.8356687272620786}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.16005280406586822, "reward": -0.16005280406586822}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2070172084812075, "reward": -0.2070172084812075}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.20830807618238034, "reward": -0.20830807618238034}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.24934250211715692, "reward": -0.24934250211715692}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2574385074377059, "reward": -0.2574385074377059}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.16005280406586822, "loser_reward": -0.2070172084812075, "reward_margin": 0.04696440441533928, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16005280406586822, "loser_reward": -0.20830807618238034, "reward_margin": 0.04825527211651212, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16005280406586822, "loser_reward": -0.24934250211715692, "reward_margin": 0.0892896980512887, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16005280406586822, "loser_reward": -0.2574385074377059, "reward_margin": 0.09738570337183769, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2070172084812075, "loser_reward": -0.24934250211715692, "reward_margin": 0.04232529363594942, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2070172084812075, "loser_reward": -0.2574385074377059, "reward_margin": 0.05042129895649841, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20830807618238034, "loser_reward": -0.24934250211715692, "reward_margin": 0.041034425934776575, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20830807618238034, "loser_reward": -0.2574385074377059, "reward_margin": 0.04913043125532557, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 33351, "bbox_xyxy": [86, 273, 374, 445], "component_score": 0.16005280406586822, "component_reward": -0.16005280406586822, "second_component_score": 0.2070172084812075, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.04696440441533928, "confidence": 0.8739575441090566}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8661860823631287, "teacher_quality_score": 0.18994125912184245, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.18994125912184245, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16811038495413957, "loser_reward": -0.2068699487242848, "reward_margin": 0.03875956377014522, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.16811038495413957, "loser_reward": -0.21067426934279507, "reward_margin": 0.04256388438865549, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16811038495413957, "loser_reward": -0.24771085476875299, "reward_margin": 0.07960046981461341, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16811038495413957, "loser_reward": -0.29732420271635057, "reward_margin": 0.129213817762211, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2068699487242848, "loser_reward": -0.24771085476875299, "reward_margin": 0.04084090604446819, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2068699487242848, "loser_reward": -0.29732420271635057, "reward_margin": 0.09045425399206578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.21067426934279507, "loser_reward": -0.24771085476875299, "reward_margin": 0.03703658542595792, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21067426934279507, "loser_reward": -0.29732420271635057, "reward_margin": 0.0866499333735555, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24771085476875299, "loser_reward": -0.29732420271635057, "reward_margin": 0.049613347947597586, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.16005280406586822, "loser_reward": -0.2070172084812075, "reward_margin": 0.04696440441533928, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16005280406586822, "loser_reward": -0.20830807618238034, "reward_margin": 0.04825527211651212, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.16005280406586822, "loser_reward": -0.24934250211715692, "reward_margin": 0.0892896980512887, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16005280406586822, "loser_reward": -0.2574385074377059, "reward_margin": 0.09738570337183769, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2070172084812075, "loser_reward": -0.24934250211715692, "reward_margin": 0.04232529363594942, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2070172084812075, "loser_reward": -0.2574385074377059, "reward_margin": 0.05042129895649841, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20830807618238034, "loser_reward": -0.24934250211715692, "reward_margin": 0.041034425934776575, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20830807618238034, "loser_reward": -0.2574385074377059, "reward_margin": 0.04913043125532557, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/181699_1/181699_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1128602996468544, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6125631332397461, "background_mse_to_source": 0.030433986335992813, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.676954984664917, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03044142760336399, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04423636570572853, "input_change_l1": 0.1392008364200592, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6825344860553741, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13232162967324257, "edit_score": 0.26971405148506167, "background_score": 0.09504298940300941, "combined_score": 0.3338670602813364, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/181699_1/181699_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08308783918619156, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6176003813743591, "background_mse_to_source": 0.016140203922986984, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.728848934173584, "background_mse_to_target": 0.016538072377443314, "full_mse_to_target": 0.027676912024617195, "input_change_l1": 0.1077006384730339, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7650892436504364, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13632309753447772, "edit_score": 0.21829545199871064, "background_score": 0.07037041708827019, "combined_score": 0.2729574086889625, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/181699_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.055529385805130005, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6464349627494812, "background_mse_to_source": 0.006819235160946846, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.849307119846344, "background_mse_to_target": 0.007314764428883791, "full_mse_to_target": 0.015384737402200699, "input_change_l1": 0.07000540941953659, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7650892734527588, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08926453609019519, "edit_score": 0.1849700748920441, "background_score": 0.03695781119167805, "combined_score": 0.2172966897673905, "confidence": 0.8527175157221916}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/181699_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10961143672466278, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5901070237159729, "background_mse_to_source": 0.024358661845326424, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.654854953289032, "background_mse_to_target": 0.024695992469787598, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03890879824757576, "input_change_l1": 0.13143667578697205, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7567896842956543, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16454571820795538, "edit_score": 0.2523926109075546, "background_score": 0.09338767118752003, "combined_score": 0.32187831928953525, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/181699_1/181699_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0691814050078392, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6428055167198181, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017200298607349396, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7506054043769836, "background_mse_to_target": 0.017792142927646637, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02639346942305565, "input_change_l1": 0.09935323148965836, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6464475989341736, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08997259233146906, "edit_score": 0.22900840193033217, "background_score": 0.06707921773195266, "combined_score": 0.27311999354511496, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/181699_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/181699_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/181699_1.json"}

181699_2

let a woman in a bridal gown stand near the cake

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.15416336059570312, "dataset_mask_area": 0.15416336059570312, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.25033995509147644, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0019297758117318153, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.24841017927974463, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9530132975478833, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9855669452767702, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3899945020675659, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4021944527965614, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.009726640229637271, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3489725334802643, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.053873151540756226, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.25033998489379883, "edit_change_ratio": 0.21519994723819574, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.2463947981595993, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.984240684779648}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1800069808959961, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/181699_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5016536712646484, "editar": 0.4983462691307068}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22974961337889546, "reward": -0.22974961337889546}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.23008036081236785, "reward": -0.23008036081236785}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.24022491072444244, "reward": -0.24022491072444244}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2818155663893558, "reward": -0.2818155663893558}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.3257852783161216, "reward": -0.3257852783161216}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "181699_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22974961337889546, "loser_reward": -0.24022491072444244, "reward_margin": 0.010475297345546974, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22974961337889546, "loser_reward": -0.2818155663893558, "reward_margin": 0.052065953010460325, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22974961337889546, "loser_reward": -0.3257852783161216, "reward_margin": 0.09603566493722612, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23008036081236785, "loser_reward": -0.24022491072444244, "reward_margin": 0.010144549912074585, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23008036081236785, "loser_reward": -0.2818155663893558, "reward_margin": 0.051735205576987936, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23008036081236785, "loser_reward": -0.3257852783161216, "reward_margin": 0.09570491750375373, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.24022491072444244, "loser_reward": -0.2818155663893558, "reward_margin": 0.04159065566491335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24022491072444244, "loser_reward": -0.3257852783161216, "reward_margin": 0.08556036759167915, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2818155663893558, "loser_reward": -0.3257852783161216, "reward_margin": 0.0439697119267658, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 161652, "bbox_xyxy": [736, 91, 1024, 1024], "component_score": 0.22974961337889546, "component_reward": -0.22974961337889546, "second_component_score": 0.23008036081236785, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0003307474334723892, "confidence": 0.552587525129306}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5525875091552734, "teacher_quality_score": 0.009726640229637271, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.009726640229637271, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "181699_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22974961337889546, "loser_reward": -0.24022491072444244, "reward_margin": 0.010475297345546974, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22974961337889546, "loser_reward": -0.2818155663893558, "reward_margin": 0.052065953010460325, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22974961337889546, "loser_reward": -0.3257852783161216, "reward_margin": 0.09603566493722612, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23008036081236785, "loser_reward": -0.24022491072444244, "reward_margin": 0.010144549912074585, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23008036081236785, "loser_reward": -0.2818155663893558, "reward_margin": 0.051735205576987936, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23008036081236785, "loser_reward": -0.3257852783161216, "reward_margin": 0.09570491750375373, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.24022491072444244, "loser_reward": -0.2818155663893558, "reward_margin": 0.04159065566491335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24022491072444244, "loser_reward": -0.3257852783161216, "reward_margin": 0.08556036759167915, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2818155663893558, "loser_reward": -0.3257852783161216, "reward_margin": 0.0439697119267658, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/181699_2/181699_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0965699702501297, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5361176133155823, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0794922336935997, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5627636313438416, "background_mse_to_target": 0.07984169572591782, "full_mse_to_target": 0.08242056518793106, "input_change_l1": 0.2335503250360489, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6737368255853653, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15877125556580723, "edit_score": 0.2709122411906719, "background_score": 0.16693950742483138, "combined_score": 0.3693373764213175, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/181699_2/181699_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13969410955905914, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5139123797416687, "background_mse_to_source": 0.09610313177108765, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3489546477794647, "background_mse_to_target": 0.09643297642469406, "full_mse_to_target": 0.10310224443674088, "input_change_l1": 0.21720676124095917, "directional_pixel_score": 0.48117231391370296, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1441463586408645, "edit_score": 0.3666185551322997, "background_score": 0.2263122022151947, "combined_score": 0.4849673220794648, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/181699_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10900096595287323, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5616933703422546, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04060359299182892, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5828105807304382, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04084828123450279, "full_mse_to_target": 0.051354940980672836, "input_change_l1": 0.14118437469005585, "directional_pixel_score": 0.48117243871092796, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09398370746057481, "edit_score": 0.3263691822066903, "background_score": 0.12404147684574128, "combined_score": 0.393715934692882, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/181699_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.16898655891418457, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4834236204624176, "background_mse_to_source": 0.14647604525089264, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.2306908369064331, "background_mse_to_target": 0.14686714112758636, "full_mse_to_target": 0.15027712285518646, "input_change_l1": 0.26936230063438416, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4812109898775816, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.17853210060857239, "edit_score": 0.40199908735230566, "background_score": 0.30033787786960603, "combined_score": 0.5578514770139009, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/181699_2/181699_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09587514400482178, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6161227822303772, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012095138430595398, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7611210346221924, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012195805087685585, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0250961035490036, "input_change_l1": 0.07322539389133453, "directional_pixel_score": 0.41962821781635284, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.038822819967754184, "edit_score": 0.31774353310465814, "background_score": 0.059870931506156924, "combined_score": 0.3489725334802643, "confidence": 0.6476713240532197}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/181699_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/181699_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/181699_2.json"}

181699_3

let there be heart shaped balloons

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.04548835754394531, "dataset_mask_area": 0.04548835754394531, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.1672188937664032, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0018688050331547856, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1653500887332484, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8952700677417421, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9502619466774131, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.41806554794311523, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.310792974729354, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.009190542666528929, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.16220939380349594, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.007070218212902546, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.1672188937664032, "edit_change_ratio": 0.042281216276788096, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.1578824520111084, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9441663466071163}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.06782722473144531, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/181699_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.5031837821006775, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4968161880970001}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.09412307726184373, "reward": -0.09412307726184373}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.094759850768256, "reward": -0.094759850768256}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.09549778380978388, "reward": -0.09549778380978388}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.0967828898227308, "reward": -0.0967828898227308}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.12337557059386746, "reward": -0.12337557059386746}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "181699_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09412307726184373, "loser_reward": -0.12337557059386746, "reward_margin": 0.029252493332023732, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.094759850768256, "loser_reward": -0.12337557059386746, "reward_margin": 0.028615719825611466, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09549778380978388, "loser_reward": -0.12337557059386746, "reward_margin": 0.027877786784083577, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0967828898227308, "loser_reward": -0.12337557059386746, "reward_margin": 0.026592680771136662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 47698, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 191, 238, 1024], "component_score": 0.09412307726184373, "component_reward": -0.09412307726184373, "second_component_score": 0.094759850768256, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0006367735064122665, "confidence": 0.5620928415892367}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5620928406715393, "teacher_quality_score": 0.009190542666528929, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.009190542666528929, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "181699_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09412307726184373, "loser_reward": -0.12337557059386746, "reward_margin": 0.029252493332023732, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.094759850768256, "loser_reward": -0.12337557059386746, "reward_margin": 0.028615719825611466, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.09549778380978388, "loser_reward": -0.12337557059386746, "reward_margin": 0.027877786784083577, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "181699_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0967828898227308, "loser_reward": -0.12337557059386746, "reward_margin": 0.026592680771136662, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/181699_3/181699_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.050074364989995956, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8813301920890808, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0621507503092289, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.37285080552101135, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0622895285487175, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06173388659954071, "input_change_l1": 0.18732081353664398, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6968077719211578, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09533180096186698, "edit_score": 0.14960638359189032, "background_score": 0.18758058920502663, "combined_score": 0.24049933866597709, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/181699_3/181699_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.042299896478652954, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8891039490699768, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01143926102668047, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8671991229057312, "background_mse_to_target": 0.011556509882211685, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012954973615705967, "input_change_l1": 0.03628051280975342, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6473826318979263, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.012678105651866644, "edit_score": 0.152633448690176, "background_score": 0.03799943644553423, "combined_score": 0.1697643699380569, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/181699_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.043121516704559326, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8893910050392151, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004833092447370291, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9314267635345459, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004946318920701742, "full_mse_to_target": 0.00668284622952342, "input_change_l1": 0.023582331836223602, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6473830938339233, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.008259290165733546, "edit_score": 0.15339754223823548, "background_score": 0.01854773974046111, "combined_score": 0.16220939380349594, "confidence": 0.6292693477455235}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/181699_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04187697544693947, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8886964917182922, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017369378358125687, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.826964795589447, "background_mse_to_target": 0.017489487305283546, "full_mse_to_target": 0.018598848953843117, "input_change_l1": 0.044959623366594315, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6473826617002487, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.015784688165877015, "edit_score": 0.15229201167821885, "background_score": 0.051976419240236285, "combined_score": 0.17550058094086124, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/181699_3/181699_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.03925551101565361, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.8964560627937317, "background_mse_to_source": 0.018422644585371017, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6550785899162292, "background_mse_to_target": 0.018503712490200996, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0194476880133152, "input_change_l1": 0.09927195310592651, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7124693542718887, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05251079017762095, "edit_score": 0.13184695988893508, "background_score": 0.08740692660212517, "combined_score": 0.17488631103653457, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/181699_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/181699_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/181699_3.json"}

182759_1

let the cat sleep

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.021403999999165535, "dataset_mask_area": 0.021404, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.16282705962657928, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.005737781524658203, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.15708927810192108, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6978405033157626, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8856279671989642, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.22121687233448029, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.27625525718777116, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.21671922729768997, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.240054781883955, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.11963875591754913, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.16282705962657928, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7347596658192048, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.03512800112366676, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/182759_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.15190492066461592, "reward": -0.15190492066461592}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.18689927173219623, "reward": -0.18689927173219623}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.20041227964125574, "reward": -0.20041227964125574}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.23955801249388609, "reward": -0.23955801249388609}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.36546632890030745, "reward": -0.36546632890030745}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15190492066461592, "loser_reward": -0.18689927173219623, "reward_margin": 0.03499435106758031, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15190492066461592, "loser_reward": -0.20041227964125574, "reward_margin": 0.048507358976639825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15190492066461592, "loser_reward": -0.23955801249388609, "reward_margin": 0.08765309182927017, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15190492066461592, "loser_reward": -0.36546632890030745, "reward_margin": 0.21356140823569153, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.18689927173219623, "loser_reward": -0.20041227964125574, "reward_margin": 0.013513007909059516, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18689927173219623, "loser_reward": -0.23955801249388609, "reward_margin": 0.05265874076168986, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18689927173219623, "loser_reward": -0.36546632890030745, "reward_margin": 0.17856705716811122, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20041227964125574, "loser_reward": -0.23955801249388609, "reward_margin": 0.039145732852630344, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20041227964125574, "loser_reward": -0.36546632890030745, "reward_margin": 0.1650540492590517, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23955801249388609, "loser_reward": -0.36546632890030745, "reward_margin": 0.12590831640642136, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 5351, "bbox_xyxy": [195, 133, 289, 211], "component_score": 0.15190492066461592, "component_reward": -0.15190492066461592, "second_component_score": 0.18689927173219623, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.03499435106758031, "confidence": 0.8355337524003819}], "teacher_confidence": 0.835533618927002, "teacher_quality_score": 0.21671922729768997, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.21671922729768997, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15190492066461592, "loser_reward": -0.18689927173219623, "reward_margin": 0.03499435106758031, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15190492066461592, "loser_reward": -0.20041227964125574, "reward_margin": 0.048507358976639825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15190492066461592, "loser_reward": -0.23955801249388609, "reward_margin": 0.08765309182927017, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15190492066461592, "loser_reward": -0.36546632890030745, "reward_margin": 0.21356140823569153, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.18689927173219623, "loser_reward": -0.20041227964125574, "reward_margin": 0.013513007909059516, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.18689927173219623, "loser_reward": -0.23955801249388609, "reward_margin": 0.05265874076168986, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18689927173219623, "loser_reward": -0.36546632890030745, "reward_margin": 0.17856705716811122, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.20041227964125574, "loser_reward": -0.23955801249388609, "reward_margin": 0.039145732852630344, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.20041227964125574, "loser_reward": -0.36546632890030745, "reward_margin": 0.1650540492590517, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23955801249388609, "loser_reward": -0.36546632890030745, "reward_margin": 0.12590831640642136, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/182759_1/182759_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.165253147482872, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.31256958842277527, "background_mse_to_source": 0.07247272878885269, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.2742922306060791, "background_mse_to_target": 0.07218129932880402, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07417340576648712, "input_change_l1": 0.18976597487926483, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6039973348379135, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.22521673850715163, "edit_score": 0.4017398960888386, "background_score": 0.21761428266763688, "combined_score": 0.5303655833005905, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/182759_1/182759_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0662866160273552, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.37090349197387695, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004778035916388035, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9030559659004211, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004863608628511429, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006178307346999645, "input_change_l1": 0.02675637975335121, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7310893684625626, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13228534534573555, "edit_score": 0.25933357551693914, "background_score": 0.024166842736303807, "combined_score": 0.29486687027849257, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/182759_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.042060382664203644, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4581509828567505, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00201871944591403, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9454081058502197, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0021544776391237974, "full_mse_to_target": 0.003008624305948615, "input_change_l1": 0.01739165000617504, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7310893684625626, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08784045539796353, "edit_score": 0.2176578439772129, "background_score": 0.012937098275870085, "combined_score": 0.240054781883955, "confidence": 0.7762889192171014}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/182759_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0906374454498291, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3223237693309784, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007031601388007402, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8745012879371643, "background_mse_to_target": 0.007082706317305565, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008871112950146198, "input_change_l1": 0.033063855022192, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7308107763528824, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16194083262234926, "edit_score": 0.2934699974954128, "background_score": 0.032131343800574544, "combined_score": 0.33799124564509836, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/182759_1/182759_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05163455009460449, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.47796154022216797, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008659489452838898, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6930070519447327, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008418343029916286, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0093433428555727, "input_change_l1": 0.06240126118063927, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6981546431779861, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10809543635696173, "edit_score": 0.23150358125567438, "background_score": 0.07005807906389236, "combined_score": 0.27857733048498634, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/182759_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/182759_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/182759_1.json"}

182759_2

awake the dog and give it brown eyes

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.024255752563476562, "dataset_mask_area": 0.024255752563476562, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.18133394420146942, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.001314162858761847, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.18001978134270757, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6912180423099624, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.7670642581356867, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.2224123179912567, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.29364851674533055, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+fallback_best_expert", "fusion_fallback": {"used": true, "reason": "fused_teacher_worse_than_best_expert", "fallback": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "teacher_combined_score": 0.21975730172322072, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2124309595633531, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.08523242920637131, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.18133392930030823, "edit_change_ratio": 0.4700302339184266, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.03964805603027344, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/182759_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5832662582397461, "qwen_image_edit": 0.41673368215560913}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1383511686112033, "reward": -0.1383511686112033}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.15516098951769527, "reward": -0.15516098951769527}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.16991296579735352, "reward": -0.16991296579735352}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1932939440840855, "reward": -0.1932939440840855}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.20660976727399977, "reward": -0.20660976727399977}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1383511686112033, "loser_reward": -0.15516098951769527, "reward_margin": 0.016809820906491968, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1383511686112033, "loser_reward": -0.16991296579735352, "reward_margin": 0.03156179718615021, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1383511686112033, "loser_reward": -0.1932939440840855, "reward_margin": 0.054942775472882205, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1383511686112033, "loser_reward": -0.20660976727399977, "reward_margin": 0.06825859866279646, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15516098951769527, "loser_reward": -0.16991296579735352, "reward_margin": 0.014751976279658241, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15516098951769527, "loser_reward": -0.1932939440840855, "reward_margin": 0.03813295456639024, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15516098951769527, "loser_reward": -0.20660976727399977, "reward_margin": 0.05144877775630449, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16991296579735352, "loser_reward": -0.1932939440840855, "reward_margin": 0.023380978286731996, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16991296579735352, "loser_reward": -0.20660976727399977, "reward_margin": 0.03669680147664625, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1932939440840855, "loser_reward": -0.20660976727399977, "reward_margin": 0.013315823189914255, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 12722, "bbox_xyxy": [554, 614, 734, 764], "component_score": 0.1383511686112033, "component_reward": -0.1383511686112033, "second_component_score": 0.15516098951769527, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.016809820906491968, "confidence": 0.7336533235773499}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5998199582099915, "qwen_image_edit": 0.40018007159233093}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1313550078655826, "reward": -0.1313550078655826}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.15159074282122312, "reward": -0.15159074282122312}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1548787248218432, "reward": -0.1548787248218432}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.16656479557650164, "reward": -0.16656479557650164}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.19794954021368177, "reward": -0.19794954021368177}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1313550078655826, "loser_reward": -0.15159074282122312, "reward_margin": 0.020235734955640516, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1313550078655826, "loser_reward": -0.1548787248218432, "reward_margin": 0.0235237169562606, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1313550078655826, "loser_reward": -0.16656479557650164, "reward_margin": 0.03520978771091904, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1313550078655826, "loser_reward": -0.19794954021368177, "reward_margin": 0.06659453234809917, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15159074282122312, "loser_reward": -0.16656479557650164, "reward_margin": 0.014974052755278522, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15159074282122312, "loser_reward": -0.19794954021368177, "reward_margin": 0.046358797392458656, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1548787248218432, "loser_reward": -0.16656479557650164, "reward_margin": 0.01168607075465844, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1548787248218432, "loser_reward": -0.19794954021368177, "reward_margin": 0.043070815391838574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16656479557650164, "loser_reward": -0.19794954021368177, "reward_margin": 0.031384744637180134, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 12712, "bbox_xyxy": [381, 676, 544, 815], "component_score": 0.1313550078655826, "component_reward": -0.1313550078655826, "second_component_score": 0.15159074282122312, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.020235734955640516, "confidence": 0.7697799677897587}], "teacher_confidence": 0.751709520816803, "teacher_quality_score": 0.21374089157383425, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.21374089157383425, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1383511686112033, "loser_reward": -0.15516098951769527, "reward_margin": 0.016809820906491968, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1383511686112033, "loser_reward": -0.16991296579735352, "reward_margin": 0.03156179718615021, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1383511686112033, "loser_reward": -0.1932939440840855, "reward_margin": 0.054942775472882205, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1383511686112033, "loser_reward": -0.20660976727399977, "reward_margin": 0.06825859866279646, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15516098951769527, "loser_reward": -0.16991296579735352, "reward_margin": 0.014751976279658241, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15516098951769527, "loser_reward": -0.1932939440840855, "reward_margin": 0.03813295456639024, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15516098951769527, "loser_reward": -0.20660976727399977, "reward_margin": 0.05144877775630449, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16991296579735352, "loser_reward": -0.1932939440840855, "reward_margin": 0.023380978286731996, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16991296579735352, "loser_reward": -0.20660976727399977, "reward_margin": 0.03669680147664625, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1932939440840855, "loser_reward": -0.20660976727399977, "reward_margin": 0.013315823189914255, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1313550078655826, "loser_reward": -0.15159074282122312, "reward_margin": 0.020235734955640516, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1313550078655826, "loser_reward": -0.1548787248218432, "reward_margin": 0.0235237169562606, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1313550078655826, "loser_reward": -0.16656479557650164, "reward_margin": 0.03520978771091904, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1313550078655826, "loser_reward": -0.19794954021368177, "reward_margin": 0.06659453234809917, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15159074282122312, "loser_reward": -0.16656479557650164, "reward_margin": 0.014974052755278522, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15159074282122312, "loser_reward": -0.19794954021368177, "reward_margin": 0.046358797392458656, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1548787248218432, "loser_reward": -0.16656479557650164, "reward_margin": 0.01168607075465844, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1548787248218432, "loser_reward": -0.19794954021368177, "reward_margin": 0.043070815391838574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16656479557650164, "loser_reward": -0.19794954021368177, "reward_margin": 0.031384744637180134, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/182759_2/182759_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07399667054414749, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6341643333435059, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05943850055336952, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.35537418723106384, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05947041139006615, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05982276424765587, "input_change_l1": 0.16418622434139252, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5822340995073318, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07526977518573404, "edit_score": 0.25160527899861335, "background_score": 0.18836366310715677, "combined_score": 0.3385687925480306, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/182759_2/182759_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06877560168504715, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6825191974639893, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005749185220338404, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9747808575630188, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006560476613231003, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002308337716385722, "input_change_l1": 0.010969488881528378, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6530786007642746, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04778063897974789, "edit_score": 0.21900211200118064, "background_score": 0.005618747009430081, "combined_score": 0.23075563502206933, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/182759_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.057762037962675095, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6975765228271484, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00024290307192131877, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.986039400100708, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0003332030028104782, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0017261826433241367, "input_change_l1": 0.007130165118724108, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6530786156654358, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.031095018750056626, "edit_score": 0.20497707948088645, "background_score": 0.003035023051779717, "combined_score": 0.2124309595633531, "confidence": 0.6883197426530558}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/182759_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07842671126127243, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.671900749206543, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0008524195291101933, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.966292142868042, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0009270890732295811, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002806900069117546, "input_change_l1": 0.013579166494309902, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6551556289196014, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.059371230145916346, "edit_score": 0.2302576541900635, "background_score": 0.007593990955501795, "combined_score": 0.24507048706058415, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/182759_2/182759_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.059075869619846344, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6895033717155457, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004212821368128061, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8383471965789795, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004278819542378187, "full_mse_to_target": 0.00560796307399869, "input_change_l1": 0.04085437208414078, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5950269252061844, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.026349119655787945, "edit_score": 0.2224184639751911, "background_score": 0.036543382052332166, "combined_score": 0.24103926793206482, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/182759_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/182759_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/182759_2.json"}

182759_3

let the dog yawn

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.11426162719726562, "dataset_mask_area": 0.11426162719726562, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.27638551592826843, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0008725279476493597, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2755129879806191, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8984045569994822, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9833822179835532, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.1879187971353531, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.42265682353989903, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.01250135091428092, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.393441980755888, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.007139104884117842, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.27638551592826843, "edit_change_ratio": 0.025830242442844528, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.2720535695552826, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9843264349130721}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.13224220275878906, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/182759_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5039548277854919, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49604520201683044}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2761532475359272, "reward": -0.2761532475359272}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.27694422822876363, "reward": -0.27694422822876363}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2774943360490724, "reward": -0.2774943360490724}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.285287941348739, "reward": -0.285287941348739}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2875739200985991, "reward": -0.2875739200985991}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "182759_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2761532475359272, "loser_reward": -0.2875739200985991, "reward_margin": 0.01142067256267193, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.27694422822876363, "loser_reward": -0.2875739200985991, "reward_margin": 0.010629691869835478, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2774943360490724, "loser_reward": -0.2875739200985991, "reward_margin": 0.01007958404952669, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 119812, "bbox_xyxy": [356, 736, 930, 1024], "component_score": 0.2761532475359272, "component_reward": -0.2761532475359272, "second_component_score": 0.27694422822876363, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0007909806928364516, "confidence": 0.5551407574440962}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5551405549049377, "teacher_quality_score": 0.01250135091428092, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.01250135091428092, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "182759_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2761532475359272, "loser_reward": -0.2875739200985991, "reward_margin": 0.01142067256267193, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.27694422822876363, "loser_reward": -0.2875739200985991, "reward_margin": 0.010629691869835478, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "182759_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2774943360490724, "loser_reward": -0.2875739200985991, "reward_margin": 0.01007958404952669, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/182759_3/182759_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11838137358427048, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.30992791056632996, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0503171868622303, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4776848554611206, "background_mse_to_target": 0.050465669482946396, "full_mse_to_target": 0.058225858956575394, "input_change_l1": 0.15560805797576904, "directional_pixel_score": 0.663780689239502, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11578161688521504, "edit_score": 0.340450619161129, "background_score": 0.15478021577000617, "combined_score": 0.4236026039533317, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/182759_3/182759_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12101389467716217, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3086412847042084, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0011697803856804967, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9776137471199036, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0012799755204468966, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01496096607297659, "input_change_l1": 0.00993622187525034, "directional_pixel_score": 0.47438234090805054, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.00626663836883381, "edit_score": 0.3906900525093079, "background_score": 0.005647030961699784, "combined_score": 0.3954159376269672, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/182759_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12077004462480545, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3097092807292938, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0004942321684211493, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9887757301330566, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006036390550434589, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01433404628187418, "input_change_l1": 0.006458541844040155, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4743822794407606, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0040863867965526875, "edit_score": 0.3902326186187566, "background_score": 0.002739086141809821, "combined_score": 0.393441980755888, "confidence": 0.5589845893694596}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/182759_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1212112307548523, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3078330457210541, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0017532163765281439, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9682883620262146, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0018639721674844623, "full_mse_to_target": 0.015500787645578384, "input_change_l1": 0.012356053106486797, "directional_pixel_score": 0.47438258677721024, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.007817881391383707, "edit_score": 0.39104897491633894, "background_score": 0.008095543971285224, "combined_score": 0.3969960703491233, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/182759_3/182759_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12545837461948395, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3094390630722046, "background_mse_to_source": 0.004076233133673668, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8424896597862244, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004162623547017574, "full_mse_to_target": 0.018022077158093452, "input_change_l1": 0.043012384325265884, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5266202837228775, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03722661933861673, "edit_score": 0.38191549107432365, "background_score": 0.035578301176428795, "combined_score": 0.40361542806960643, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/182759_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/182759_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/182759_3.json"}

184184_1

add another cup of water

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.03378799930214882, "dataset_mask_area": 0.033788, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2717549204826355, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.006742724683135748, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.26501219579949975, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.856198867212083, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8824864864864865, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4374389946460724, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.40305551932440914, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.013755461900509544, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.24148257146822288, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.024446163326501846, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2717549204826355, "edit_change_ratio": 0.08995665389640627, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.2525615096092224, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9293723519731467}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.051024001091718674, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/184184_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.5623505711555481, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.4376493990421295}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.17411774361878635, "reward": -0.17411774361878635}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.18665311109734464, "reward": -0.18665311109734464}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.18738440132024697, "reward": -0.18738440132024697}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.18846553254401074, "reward": -0.18846553254401074}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.271176703534089, "reward": -0.271176703534089}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "184184_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17411774361878635, "loser_reward": -0.18665311109734464, "reward_margin": 0.012535367478558296, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.17411774361878635, "loser_reward": -0.18738440132024697, "reward_margin": 0.013266657701460627, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.17411774361878635, "loser_reward": -0.18846553254401074, "reward_margin": 0.014347788925224397, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17411774361878635, "loser_reward": -0.271176703534089, "reward_margin": 0.09705895991530267, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18665311109734464, "loser_reward": -0.271176703534089, "reward_margin": 0.08452359243674437, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18738440132024697, "loser_reward": -0.271176703534089, "reward_margin": 0.08379230221384204, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18846553254401074, "loser_reward": -0.271176703534089, "reward_margin": 0.08271117099007827, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 8447, "bbox_xyxy": [349, 0, 500, 97], "component_score": 0.17411774361878635, "component_reward": -0.17411774361878635, "second_component_score": 0.18665311109734464, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.012535367478558296, "confidence": 0.6680591867558103}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6680592894554138, "teacher_quality_score": 0.013755461900509544, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.013755461900509544, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "184184_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17411774361878635, "loser_reward": -0.18665311109734464, "reward_margin": 0.012535367478558296, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.17411774361878635, "loser_reward": -0.18738440132024697, "reward_margin": 0.013266657701460627, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.17411774361878635, "loser_reward": -0.18846553254401074, "reward_margin": 0.014347788925224397, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17411774361878635, "loser_reward": -0.271176703534089, "reward_margin": 0.09705895991530267, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18665311109734464, "loser_reward": -0.271176703534089, "reward_margin": 0.08452359243674437, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18738440132024697, "loser_reward": -0.271176703534089, "reward_margin": 0.08379230221384204, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.18846553254401074, "loser_reward": -0.271176703534089, "reward_margin": 0.08271117099007827, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/184184_1/184184_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08258106559515, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.642578125, "background_mse_to_source": 0.059247229248285294, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.511096715927124, "background_mse_to_target": 0.059510793536901474, "full_mse_to_target": 0.060290295630693436, "input_change_l1": 0.17137420177459717, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8243927359580994, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0678858757019043, "edit_score": 0.19796725660562514, "background_score": 0.1570278860628605, "combined_score": 0.2725332214310765, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/184184_1/184184_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11157873272895813, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6270015835762024, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009212823584675789, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8819432854652405, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009612785652279854, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013058007694780827, "input_change_l1": 0.03108597733080387, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8174090683460236, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.005735610343981534, "edit_score": 0.23182614892721176, "background_score": 0.0328241664916277, "combined_score": 0.24576753003755583, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/184184_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11303501576185226, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6258901953697205, "background_mse_to_source": 0.003892417997121811, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9276503920555115, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004351016599684954, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008023230358958244, "input_change_l1": 0.020205875858664513, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8174088597297668, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0037433391087688507, "edit_score": 0.23350476175546647, "background_score": 0.018362339586019516, "combined_score": 0.24148257146822288, "confidence": 0.5813322271463062}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/184184_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11055359244346619, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6276240944862366, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014104798436164856, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.854888916015625, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014463620260357857, "full_mse_to_target": 0.017710309475660324, "input_change_l1": 0.03868533670902252, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8174092769622803, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.007148728816537187, "edit_score": 0.23067645430564881, "background_score": 0.043127015233039856, "combined_score": 0.24897168634808622, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/184184_1/184184_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12384731322526932, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6061350703239441, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009605676867067814, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7507584691047668, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009763401001691818, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013618064112961292, "input_change_l1": 0.05679141730070114, "directional_pixel_score": 0.325214147567749, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01863548494875431, "edit_score": 0.37131676226854327, "background_score": 0.05945398304611445, "combined_score": 0.39721455973573033, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/184184_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/184184_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/184184_1.json"}

184184_2

make the plate empty

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.2511625289916992, "dataset_mask_area": 0.2511625289916992, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.374541312456131, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0041067940182983875, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3704345184378326, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9816740998216796, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9927940156015281, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.13071894645690918, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.26896920800209045, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.5279471710404953, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.04224652140779654, "best_expert": "pix2pix", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.07539026228711009, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.32758063077926636, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.37454140186309814, "edit_change_ratio": 0.874617943836829, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.2764434814453125, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/184184_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.04597768987435848, "reward": -0.04597768987435848}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2867023581420072, "reward": -0.2867023581420072}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2901086604341399, "reward": -0.2901086604341399}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.29474078231747264, "reward": -0.29474078231747264}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.33137510157562794, "reward": -0.33137510157562794}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "184184_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.04597768987435848, "loser_reward": -0.2867023581420072, "reward_margin": 0.2407246682676487, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.04597768987435848, "loser_reward": -0.2901086604341399, "reward_margin": 0.24413097055978145, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.04597768987435848, "loser_reward": -0.29474078231747264, "reward_margin": 0.24876309244311418, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04597768987435848, "loser_reward": -0.33137510157562794, "reward_margin": 0.2853974117012695, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2867023581420072, "loser_reward": -0.33137510157562794, "reward_margin": 0.044672743433620765, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2901086604341399, "loser_reward": -0.33137510157562794, "reward_margin": 0.04126644114148803, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.29474078231747264, "loser_reward": -0.33137510157562794, "reward_margin": 0.0366343192581553, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 263363, "bbox_xyxy": [223, 341, 868, 945], "component_score": 0.04597768987435848, "component_reward": -0.04597768987435848, "second_component_score": 0.2867023581420072, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.2407246682676487, "confidence": 0.9989122352185117}], "teacher_confidence": 0.9989123940467834, "teacher_quality_score": 0.04224652140779654, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.04224652140779654, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "184184_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.04597768987435848, "loser_reward": -0.2867023581420072, "reward_margin": 0.2407246682676487, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.04597768987435848, "loser_reward": -0.2901086604341399, "reward_margin": 0.24413097055978145, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.04597768987435848, "loser_reward": -0.29474078231747264, "reward_margin": 0.24876309244311418, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04597768987435848, "loser_reward": -0.33137510157562794, "reward_margin": 0.2853974117012695, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2867023581420072, "loser_reward": -0.33137510157562794, "reward_margin": 0.044672743433620765, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2901086604341399, "loser_reward": -0.33137510157562794, "reward_margin": 0.04126644114148803, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184184_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.29474078231747264, "loser_reward": -0.33137510157562794, "reward_margin": 0.0366343192581553, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/184184_2/184184_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.008813603781163692, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.926483154296875, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0326172299683094, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7601196765899658, "background_mse_to_target": 0.03273852914571762, "full_mse_to_target": 0.026729485020041466, "input_change_l1": 0.17607779800891876, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9904238283634186, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09299322413280607, "edit_score": 0.025911015830934046, "background_score": 0.08059329465031624, "combined_score": 0.07539026228711009, "confidence": 0.9985015696668598}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/184184_2/184184_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.18168213963508606, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.48361024260520935, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00806429237127304, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9434790015220642, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008143345825374126, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05172973498702049, "input_change_l1": 0.024355346336960793, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6918971985578537, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01408552664797753, "edit_score": 0.36198579147458076, "background_score": 0.0193684920668602, "combined_score": 0.3767548425262794, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/184184_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.18542174994945526, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.48038744926452637, "background_mse_to_source": 0.003407161682844162, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9749428629875183, "background_mse_to_target": 0.003613409586250782, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04927682876586914, "input_change_l1": 0.01583097316324711, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6918975114822388, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.009200676041655243, "edit_score": 0.3663698822259903, "background_score": 0.0084185890853405, "combined_score": 0.37608420649077745, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/184184_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.17924068868160248, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4848748743534088, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012127283029258251, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9253059029579163, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01211547665297985, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05409105122089386, "input_change_l1": 0.03022887371480465, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6918977349996567, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.01739383623935282, "edit_score": 0.3592912800610065, "background_score": 0.027066102437675002, "combined_score": 0.3776522882841527, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/184184_2/184184_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1970282346010208, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5215398073196411, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007486153859645128, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8284702897071838, "background_mse_to_target": 0.007797046564519405, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05532483756542206, "input_change_l1": 0.06010293960571289, "directional_pixel_score": 0.536859542131424, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0694196398369968, "edit_score": 0.4085053876042366, "background_score": 0.041792095918208365, "combined_score": 0.44254903289955105, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/184184_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/184184_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/184184_2.json"}

184384_1

Let the bluebery cake be topped with chocolate syrup.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.07767599821090698, "dataset_mask_area": 0.077676, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.37697845697402954, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.007749240379780531, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.369229216594249, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8601753797498682, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9252615844544095, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.37691229581832886, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.5094607255424096, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.032954883137936125, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.46976633137091994, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.08096106350421906, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.3769785165786743, "edit_change_ratio": 0.21476306989319566, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.3602697551250458, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9556771520953729}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1016480028629303, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/184384_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5376885533332825, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4623114764690399}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3554094077218323, "reward": -0.3554094077218323}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.3629614431262016, "reward": -0.3629614431262016}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.3872832613475621, "reward": -0.3872832613475621}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.4061349726505577, "reward": -0.4061349726505577}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.5234525689799339, "reward": -0.5234525689799339}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "184384_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.3554094077218323, "loser_reward": -0.3872832613475621, "reward_margin": 0.03187385362572975, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3554094077218323, "loser_reward": -0.4061349726505577, "reward_margin": 0.050725564928725375, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3554094077218323, "loser_reward": -0.5234525689799339, "reward_margin": 0.16804316125810154, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.3629614431262016, "loser_reward": -0.3872832613475621, "reward_margin": 0.02432181822136048, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3629614431262016, "loser_reward": -0.4061349726505577, "reward_margin": 0.0431735295243561, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3629614431262016, "loser_reward": -0.5234525689799339, "reward_margin": 0.16049112585373226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3872832613475621, "loser_reward": -0.4061349726505577, "reward_margin": 0.018851711302995622, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3872832613475621, "loser_reward": -0.5234525689799339, "reward_margin": 0.13616930763237178, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.4061349726505577, "loser_reward": -0.5234525689799339, "reward_margin": 0.11731759632937616, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 19419, "bbox_xyxy": [180, 11, 367, 157], "component_score": 0.3554094077218323, "component_reward": -0.3554094077218323, "second_component_score": 0.3629614431262016, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.007552035404369273, "confidence": 0.5873658490686252}], "teacher_confidence": 0.587365984916687, "teacher_quality_score": 0.032954883137936125, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.032954883137936125, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "184384_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.3554094077218323, "loser_reward": -0.3872832613475621, "reward_margin": 0.03187385362572975, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3554094077218323, "loser_reward": -0.4061349726505577, "reward_margin": 0.050725564928725375, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3554094077218323, "loser_reward": -0.5234525689799339, "reward_margin": 0.16804316125810154, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.3629614431262016, "loser_reward": -0.3872832613475621, "reward_margin": 0.02432181822136048, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3629614431262016, "loser_reward": -0.4061349726505577, "reward_margin": 0.0431735295243561, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3629614431262016, "loser_reward": -0.5234525689799339, "reward_margin": 0.16049112585373226, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.3872832613475621, "loser_reward": -0.4061349726505577, "reward_margin": 0.018851711302995622, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.3872832613475621, "loser_reward": -0.5234525689799339, "reward_margin": 0.13616930763237178, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "184384_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.4061349726505577, "loser_reward": -0.5234525689799339, "reward_margin": 0.11731759632937616, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/184384_1/184384_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.31110963225364685, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.32572048902511597, "background_mse_to_source": 0.15552933514118195, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.2156384438276291, "background_mse_to_target": 0.15461614727973938, "full_mse_to_target": 0.16677194833755493, "input_change_l1": 0.3162282705307007, "directional_pixel_score": 0.48237536661326885, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.22544315941631793, "edit_score": 0.5753716927953064, "background_score": 0.31240164637565615, "combined_score": 0.7464780957438052, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/184384_1/184384_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.23646961152553558, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3499784767627716, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012659894302487373, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8885003924369812, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012637126259505749, "full_mse_to_target": 0.030023548752069473, "input_change_l1": 0.04370785504579544, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5534505620598793, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11803371161222458, "edit_score": 0.4781112756580115, "background_score": 0.03495981581509114, "combined_score": 0.5169563083909452, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/184384_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.22626599669456482, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3744730055332184, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005348805338144302, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9415463805198669, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0054523092694580555, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02260424569249153, "input_change_l1": 0.02841010130941868, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5534505248069763, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07713493183255196, "edit_score": 0.4630087643861771, "background_score": 0.017039529234170916, "combined_score": 0.48666001055389646, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/184384_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.2460940033197403, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.32631686329841614, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01796668767929077, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.869009792804718, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01787741668522358, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03560435771942139, "input_change_l1": 0.05280165746808052, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5511792153120041, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13924609459936618, "edit_score": 0.49303582683205605, "background_score": 0.044164729118347165, "combined_score": 0.5399031367152929, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/184384_1/184384_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.19998596608638763, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3781011402606964, "background_mse_to_source": 0.024729086086153984, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5991811752319336, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02419528365135193, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03784999996423721, "input_change_l1": 0.11556299775838852, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6747948080301285, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11800898741930724, "edit_score": 0.4056670360267162, "background_score": 0.10489285103976727, "combined_score": 0.46976633137091994, "confidence": 0.612085818260663}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/184384_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/184384_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/184384_1.json"}

187866_1

Change the boy to a girl.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.2554279863834381, "dataset_mask_area": 0.255428, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.26386281847953796, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.014395340345799923, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.24946747813373804, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8916463350746157, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9527846198138256, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.12418299913406372, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.29431480169296265, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.394576423135245, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.01796161891194061, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.299275224711746, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.0246572382748127, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.26386281847953796, "edit_change_ratio": 0.09344718750787094, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.2546004354953766, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9648969754907714}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.3349440097808838, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/187866_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5034999251365662, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.4965001046657562}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.21837109456211332, "reward": -0.21837109456211332}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.21907109443936496, "reward": -0.21907109443936496}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.21921410381700843, "reward": -0.21921410381700843}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.23942801333405075, "reward": -0.23942801333405075}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.24224371608719228, "reward": -0.24224371608719228}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21837109456211332, "loser_reward": -0.23942801333405075, "reward_margin": 0.02105691877193744, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21837109456211332, "loser_reward": -0.24224371608719228, "reward_margin": 0.023872621525078963, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21907109443936496, "loser_reward": -0.23942801333405075, "reward_margin": 0.0203569188946858, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21907109443936496, "loser_reward": -0.24224371608719228, "reward_margin": 0.023172621647827324, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21921410381700843, "loser_reward": -0.23942801333405075, "reward_margin": 0.020213909517042328, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21921410381700843, "loser_reward": -0.24224371608719228, "reward_margin": 0.023029612270183852, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 59137, "bbox_xyxy": [18, 161, 390, 500], "component_score": 0.21837109456211332, "component_reward": -0.21837109456211332, "second_component_score": 0.21907109443936496, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0006999998772516391, "confidence": 0.555751242287546}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5217149257659912, "qwen_image_edit": 0.47828513383865356}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.15218526221544018, "reward": -0.15218526221544018}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1565309689010028, "reward": -0.1565309689010028}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.15909714965173044, "reward": -0.15909714965173044}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1835763618759811, "reward": -0.1835763618759811}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.20440167903341352, "reward": -0.20440167903341352}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15218526221544018, "loser_reward": -0.1835763618759811, "reward_margin": 0.031391099660540905, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15218526221544018, "loser_reward": -0.20440167903341352, "reward_margin": 0.05221641681797334, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1565309689010028, "loser_reward": -0.1835763618759811, "reward_margin": 0.027045392974978294, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1565309689010028, "loser_reward": -0.20440167903341352, "reward_margin": 0.04787071013241073, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15909714965173044, "loser_reward": -0.1835763618759811, "reward_margin": 0.024479212224250646, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15909714965173044, "loser_reward": -0.20440167903341352, "reward_margin": 0.045304529381683084, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1835763618759811, "loser_reward": -0.20440167903341352, "reward_margin": 0.020825317157432438, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 4720, "bbox_xyxy": [388, 360, 500, 484], "component_score": 0.15218526221544018, "component_reward": -0.15218526221544018, "second_component_score": 0.1565309689010028, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.004345706685562611, "confidence": 0.5997682515631421}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5590047836303711, "teacher_quality_score": 0.01796161891194061, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.01796161891194061, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21837109456211332, "loser_reward": -0.23942801333405075, "reward_margin": 0.02105691877193744, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21837109456211332, "loser_reward": -0.24224371608719228, "reward_margin": 0.023872621525078963, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21907109443936496, "loser_reward": -0.23942801333405075, "reward_margin": 0.0203569188946858, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21907109443936496, "loser_reward": -0.24224371608719228, "reward_margin": 0.023172621647827324, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21921410381700843, "loser_reward": -0.23942801333405075, "reward_margin": 0.020213909517042328, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21921410381700843, "loser_reward": -0.24224371608719228, "reward_margin": 0.023029612270183852, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15218526221544018, "loser_reward": -0.1835763618759811, "reward_margin": 0.031391099660540905, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15218526221544018, "loser_reward": -0.20440167903341352, "reward_margin": 0.05221641681797334, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1565309689010028, "loser_reward": -0.1835763618759811, "reward_margin": 0.027045392974978294, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1565309689010028, "loser_reward": -0.20440167903341352, "reward_margin": 0.04787071013241073, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15909714965173044, "loser_reward": -0.1835763618759811, "reward_margin": 0.024479212224250646, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15909714965173044, "loser_reward": -0.20440167903341352, "reward_margin": 0.045304529381683084, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1835763618759811, "loser_reward": -0.20440167903341352, "reward_margin": 0.020825317157432438, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/187866_1/187866_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11671015620231628, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6535330414772034, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0023774132132530212, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9248141646385193, "background_mse_to_target": 0.003752435790374875, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03260500356554985, "input_change_l1": 0.039854321628808975, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5177722182124853, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05559192188084126, "edit_score": 0.3065604933537543, "background_score": 0.017414580285549167, "combined_score": 0.32703448118641976, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/187866_1/187866_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10967735201120377, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6555109620094299, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0020639034919440746, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9730224609375, "background_mse_to_target": 0.003651839680969715, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03073372319340706, "input_change_l1": 0.020321588963270187, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5509406961500645, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05182458255439997, "edit_score": 0.2908399855718017, "background_score": 0.007459411304444075, "combined_score": 0.3068890683585778, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/187866_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10845408588647842, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6622795462608337, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0008719991892576218, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9860883355140686, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002563907066360116, "full_mse_to_target": 0.029611220583319664, "input_change_l1": 0.013209032826125622, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5509395003318787, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03385892435908318, "edit_score": 0.288263301551342, "background_score": 0.0036543320864439012, "combined_score": 0.299275224711746, "confidence": 0.5945115329663874}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/187866_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11083262413740158, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6506016850471497, "background_mse_to_source": 0.003063058014959097, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9652400016784668, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004597047343850136, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03173258528113365, "input_change_l1": 0.02509172633290291, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5524153858423233, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06300563029944897, "edit_score": 0.29260844066739083, "background_score": 0.010015057679265738, "combined_score": 0.31188809544313695, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/187866_1/187866_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11839504539966583, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.644822895526886, "background_mse_to_source": 0.053799889981746674, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7449502944946289, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0550394132733345, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0712222009897232, "input_change_l1": 0.15076285600662231, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5772519484162331, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06436772383749485, "edit_score": 0.29511747919023035, "background_score": 0.1048098310828209, "combined_score": 0.351796684935689, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/187866_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/187866_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/187866_1.json"}

187866_2

Put sunglasses on the girl.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.01105499267578125, "dataset_mask_area": 0.01105499267578125, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2842058539390564, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0002170837833546102, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2839887701557018, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8701946671028955, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9437594251751974, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4126832187175751, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4261625072150571, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.13885179079359658, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.1700312861322891, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.17320972681045532, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2842057943344116, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6094517784765766, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.017604827880859375, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/187866_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6225499510765076, "editar": 0.3774500787258148}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.12165994011587462, "reward": -0.12165994011587462}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.14667921754438432, "reward": -0.14667921754438432}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1602438591644168, "reward": -0.1602438591644168}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.19394863041490318, "reward": -0.19394863041490318}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.201772599253105, "reward": -0.201772599253105}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12165994011587462, "loser_reward": -0.14667921754438432, "reward_margin": 0.025019277428509692, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12165994011587462, "loser_reward": -0.1602438591644168, "reward_margin": 0.03858391904854218, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12165994011587462, "loser_reward": -0.19394863041490318, "reward_margin": 0.07228869029902855, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12165994011587462, "loser_reward": -0.201772599253105, "reward_margin": 0.08011265913723038, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14667921754438432, "loser_reward": -0.1602438591644168, "reward_margin": 0.013564641620032486, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14667921754438432, "loser_reward": -0.19394863041490318, "reward_margin": 0.04726941287051886, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14667921754438432, "loser_reward": -0.201772599253105, "reward_margin": 0.05509338170872069, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1602438591644168, "loser_reward": -0.19394863041490318, "reward_margin": 0.033704771250486376, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1602438591644168, "loser_reward": -0.201772599253105, "reward_margin": 0.041528740088688204, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 11592, "bbox_xyxy": [404, 487, 606, 591], "component_score": 0.12165994011587462, "component_reward": -0.12165994011587462, "second_component_score": 0.14667921754438432, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.025019277428509692, "confidence": 0.8168513991376826}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8168515563011169, "teacher_quality_score": 0.13885179079359658, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.13885179079359658, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12165994011587462, "loser_reward": -0.14667921754438432, "reward_margin": 0.025019277428509692, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12165994011587462, "loser_reward": -0.1602438591644168, "reward_margin": 0.03858391904854218, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12165994011587462, "loser_reward": -0.19394863041490318, "reward_margin": 0.07228869029902855, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12165994011587462, "loser_reward": -0.201772599253105, "reward_margin": 0.08011265913723038, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.14667921754438432, "loser_reward": -0.1602438591644168, "reward_margin": 0.013564641620032486, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14667921754438432, "loser_reward": -0.19394863041490318, "reward_margin": 0.04726941287051886, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14667921754438432, "loser_reward": -0.201772599253105, "reward_margin": 0.05509338170872069, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1602438591644168, "loser_reward": -0.19394863041490318, "reward_margin": 0.033704771250486376, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "187866_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1602438591644168, "loser_reward": -0.201772599253105, "reward_margin": 0.041528740088688204, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/187866_2/187866_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06805247068405151, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6103764176368713, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06734222918748856, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5411450266838074, "background_mse_to_target": 0.067402184009552, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06740937381982803, "input_change_l1": 0.20958442986011505, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8867446780204773, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.21469239965081216, "edit_score": 0.1742910176515579, "background_score": 0.15911322385072707, "combined_score": 0.2796600633114576, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/187866_2/187866_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06420614570379257, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6132977604866028, "background_mse_to_source": 0.001482123974710703, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9784941077232361, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0015024602180346847, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002195650013163686, "input_change_l1": 0.016550865024328232, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9047650396823883, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.19176237033680082, "edit_score": 0.16535533368587496, "background_score": 0.005783302430063486, "combined_score": 0.2059515286050737, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/187866_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04128208011388779, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6054812073707581, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0006261976668611169, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9885604381561279, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0006469968357123435, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0010962174274027348, "input_change_l1": 0.010758057236671448, "directional_pixel_score": 0.9047650396823883, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12453573578968644, "edit_score": 0.14399457871913912, "background_score": 0.002914110035635531, "combined_score": 0.1700312861322891, "confidence": 0.8212917208732914}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/187866_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08371984958648682, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5137467980384827, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0019230999751016498, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9731395840644836, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0019447746453806758, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0028487981762737036, "input_change_l1": 0.019734786823391914, "directional_pixel_score": 0.897359311580658, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.21722484389320015, "edit_score": 0.2066306620836258, "background_score": 0.007295183162204922, "combined_score": 0.2529138247866649, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/187866_2/187866_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.051014408469200134, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6194586157798767, "background_mse_to_source": 0.044754814356565475, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6718657612800598, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04477004334330559, "full_mse_to_target": 0.044839080423116684, "input_change_l1": 0.14548638463020325, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8796679377555847, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09923764439299704, "edit_score": 0.1572057008743286, "background_score": 0.11038166210055352, "combined_score": 0.2201707195304334, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/187866_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/187866_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/187866_2.json"}

188612_1

Let's add a cat on the roof.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.004619999788701534, "dataset_mask_area": 0.00462, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.28821438550949097, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.007339639589190483, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2808747459203005, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.3077844311377245, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.31995020230314347, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.39139124751091003, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.33060688574895314, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.02168064971511285, "best_expert": "pix2pix", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3048653959110379, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.04248536750674248, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2882143557071686, "edit_change_ratio": 0.14740892209376427, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.24990522861480713, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.8670811278696878}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.012864000163972378, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/188612_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "pix2pix", "soft_weights": {"pix2pix": 0.5791435241699219, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.4208565056324005}, "ranking": [{"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.22207529919128863, "reward": -0.22207529919128863}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.23803821712289933, "reward": -0.23803821712289933}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.23820177309587592, "reward": -0.23820177309587592}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.23839235846267548, "reward": -0.23839235846267548}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.26718618383072323, "reward": -0.26718618383072323}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "188612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22207529919128863, "loser_reward": -0.23803821712289933, "reward_margin": 0.0159629179316107, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22207529919128863, "loser_reward": -0.23820177309587592, "reward_margin": 0.016126473904587296, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.22207529919128863, "loser_reward": -0.23839235846267548, "reward_margin": 0.016317059271386852, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22207529919128863, "loser_reward": -0.26718618383072323, "reward_margin": 0.045110884639434606, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23803821712289933, "loser_reward": -0.26718618383072323, "reward_margin": 0.029147966707823908, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23820177309587592, "loser_reward": -0.26718618383072323, "reward_margin": 0.02898441073484731, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23839235846267548, "loser_reward": -0.26718618383072323, "reward_margin": 0.028793825368047754, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 1155, "bbox_xyxy": [73, 342, 130, 375], "component_score": 0.22207529919128863, "component_reward": -0.22207529919128863, "second_component_score": 0.23803821712289933, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0159629179316107, "confidence": 0.6678943870516447}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6678943634033203, "teacher_quality_score": 0.02168064971511285, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.02168064971511285, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "188612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22207529919128863, "loser_reward": -0.23803821712289933, "reward_margin": 0.0159629179316107, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22207529919128863, "loser_reward": -0.23820177309587592, "reward_margin": 0.016126473904587296, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.22207529919128863, "loser_reward": -0.23839235846267548, "reward_margin": 0.016317059271386852, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22207529919128863, "loser_reward": -0.26718618383072323, "reward_margin": 0.045110884639434606, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23803821712289933, "loser_reward": -0.26718618383072323, "reward_margin": 0.029147966707823908, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23820177309587592, "loser_reward": -0.26718618383072323, "reward_margin": 0.02898441073484731, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "188612_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23839235846267548, "loser_reward": -0.26718618383072323, "reward_margin": 0.028793825368047754, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/188612_1/188612_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10876277834177017, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5665938258171082, "background_mse_to_source": 0.021562164649367332, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7989987730979919, "background_mse_to_target": 0.02086947113275528, "full_mse_to_target": 0.021275537088513374, "input_change_l1": 0.11673326790332794, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7221080362796783, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0810199729166925, "edit_score": 0.26491700410842894, "background_score": 0.06176241002976895, "combined_score": 0.3048653959110379, "confidence": 0.6364250360999304}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/188612_1/188612_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13141459226608276, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5518552660942078, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0012830124469473958, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9656316637992859, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0013958588242530823, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0019965453539043665, "input_change_l1": 0.017349841073155403, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6189474165439606, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.011941341427154839, "edit_score": 0.3163066849112511, "background_score": 0.008156679687090218, "combined_score": 0.3217494456225541, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/188612_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1323315054178238, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5522019267082214, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005420727538876235, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9799664616584778, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0007512581651099026, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0013591586612164974, "input_change_l1": 0.011277398094534874, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6189475059509277, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.007812184398062527, "edit_score": 0.31715424358844757, "background_score": 0.004548780422192067, "combined_score": 0.32044466948194894, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/188612_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13080903887748718, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5514505505561829, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0019346621120348573, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9556951522827148, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0019793303217738867, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0025745234452188015, "input_change_l1": 0.021608134731650352, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6189474165439606, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.014869591454043984, "edit_score": 0.3157820746302605, "background_score": 0.010795631655491888, "combined_score": 0.3227919163450133, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/188612_1/188612_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13699856400489807, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5500711798667908, "background_mse_to_source": 0.006982164457440376, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8176941871643066, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006430316250771284, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0070335399359464645, "input_change_l1": 0.05478399619460106, "directional_pixel_score": 0.533947829157114, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04386295285075903, "edit_score": 0.3434973707422614, "background_score": 0.04344332702457905, "combined_score": 0.3681784797646105, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/188612_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/188612_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/188612_1.json"}

189893_1

add water and flowers in the tub

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.03418400138616562, "dataset_mask_area": 0.034184, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.23510079085826874, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.008453501388430595, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.22664728946983814, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8206337811506512, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.869121320734224, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4643659293651581, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3598881960372853, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.19956533955468334, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2238686772529036, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.09678113460540771, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.23510079085826874, "edit_change_ratio": 0.4116580563259463, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.057659998536109924, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/189893_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 1.0}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1517756319688633, "reward": -0.1517756319688633}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2190872370052384, "reward": -0.2190872370052384}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2395620987333823, "reward": -0.2395620987333823}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2610900630117394, "reward": -0.2610900630117394}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.288715384690091, "reward": -0.288715384690091}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "189893_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1517756319688633, "loser_reward": -0.2190872370052384, "reward_margin": 0.06731160503637512, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1517756319688633, "loser_reward": -0.2395620987333823, "reward_margin": 0.08778646676451901, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1517756319688633, "loser_reward": -0.2610900630117394, "reward_margin": 0.10931443104287614, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1517756319688633, "loser_reward": -0.288715384690091, "reward_margin": 0.13693975272122771, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2190872370052384, "loser_reward": -0.2395620987333823, "reward_margin": 0.02047486172814389, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2190872370052384, "loser_reward": -0.2610900630117394, "reward_margin": 0.042002826006501015, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2190872370052384, "loser_reward": -0.288715384690091, "reward_margin": 0.06962814768485259, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2395620987333823, "loser_reward": -0.2610900630117394, "reward_margin": 0.021527964278357126, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2395620987333823, "loser_reward": -0.288715384690091, "reward_margin": 0.0491532859567087, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2610900630117394, "loser_reward": -0.288715384690091, "reward_margin": 0.027625321678351578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 8546, "bbox_xyxy": [376, 338, 500, 472], "component_score": 0.1517756319688633, "component_reward": -0.1517756319688633, "second_component_score": 0.2190872370052384, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.06731160503637512, "confidence": 0.9290229913063942}], "teacher_confidence": 0.9290228486061096, "teacher_quality_score": 0.19956533955468334, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.19956533955468334, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "189893_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "winner_reward": -0.1517756319688633, "loser_reward": -0.2190872370052384, "reward_margin": 0.06731160503637512, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1517756319688633, "loser_reward": -0.2395620987333823, "reward_margin": 0.08778646676451901, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__editar_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1517756319688633, "loser_reward": -0.2610900630117394, "reward_margin": 0.10931443104287614, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1517756319688633, "loser_reward": -0.288715384690091, "reward_margin": 0.13693975272122771, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2190872370052384, "loser_reward": -0.2395620987333823, "reward_margin": 0.02047486172814389, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2190872370052384, "loser_reward": -0.2610900630117394, "reward_margin": 0.042002826006501015, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2190872370052384, "loser_reward": -0.288715384690091, "reward_margin": 0.06962814768485259, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2395620987333823, "loser_reward": -0.2610900630117394, "reward_margin": 0.021527964278357126, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2395620987333823, "loser_reward": -0.288715384690091, "reward_margin": 0.0491532859567087, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2610900630117394, "loser_reward": -0.288715384690091, "reward_margin": 0.027625321678351578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/189893_1/189893_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13431841135025024, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5589936375617981, "background_mse_to_source": 0.031958647072315216, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4666597843170166, "background_mse_to_target": 0.031806088984012604, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03531036525964737, "input_change_l1": 0.14309006929397583, "directional_pixel_score": 0.42191286385059357, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.12547592651098965, "edit_score": 0.3670414678752422, "background_score": 0.13862669020891188, "combined_score": 0.4441870312765241, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/189893_1/189893_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11696162074804306, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6028650403022766, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0012287161080166698, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9638347029685974, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0014097600942477584, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005359785631299019, "input_change_l1": 0.020372791215777397, "directional_pixel_score": 0.34875859320163727, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08050175560638309, "edit_score": 0.3591989643871784, "background_score": 0.008461775514297188, "combined_score": 0.37879691550158895, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/189893_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09951718896627426, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6143851280212402, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005191325326450169, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9794227480888367, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0007698294357396662, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004145409446209669, "input_change_l1": 0.013242312707006931, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3487585484981537, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05246670299675316, "edit_score": 0.3394505262374878, "background_score": 0.004634582914877683, "combined_score": 0.35198051180166656, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/189893_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13195174932479858, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5918766856193542, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0019190055318176746, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9519860148429871, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0020501904655247927, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006490745581686497, "input_change_l1": 0.025462916120886803, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3486262410879135, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09992695706896484, "edit_score": 0.37641985192894933, "background_score": 0.011521802563220263, "combined_score": 0.401086948798038, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/189893_1/189893_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.051100656390190125, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5940538048744202, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008472721092402935, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6931888461112976, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00827592983841896, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009739850647747517, "input_change_l1": 0.06731509417295456, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7968995869159698, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07693730173632503, "edit_score": 0.18306499868631365, "background_score": 0.06983495187014341, "combined_score": 0.2238686772529036, "confidence": 0.9535837250068563}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/189893_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/189893_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/189893_1.json"}

189893_2

let the floor be made of hardwood

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.1764364242553711, "dataset_mask_area": 0.1764364242553711, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.15409298241138458, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0014648993965238333, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.15262808301486075, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9168307528255373, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9751493509410232, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4014665484428406, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.30165374739156614, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.12369190116703976, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.12624106056493475, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.14329522848129272, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.15409298241138458, "edit_change_ratio": 0.9299270235339795, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.1920604705810547, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/189893_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5364398956298828, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4635601341724396}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.07201317757478681, "reward": -0.07201317757478681}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.0793140984858619, "reward": -0.0793140984858619}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.10386363955587148, "reward": -0.10386363955587148}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.12327181923575699, "reward": -0.12327181923575699}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2626755781183019, "reward": -0.2626755781183019}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.07201317757478681, "loser_reward": -0.10386363955587148, "reward_margin": 0.03185046198108467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07201317757478681, "loser_reward": -0.12327181923575699, "reward_margin": 0.051258641660970175, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07201317757478681, "loser_reward": -0.2626755781183019, "reward_margin": 0.19066240054351508, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.0793140984858619, "loser_reward": -0.10386363955587148, "reward_margin": 0.024549541070009576, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0793140984858619, "loser_reward": -0.12327181923575699, "reward_margin": 0.04395772074989508, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0793140984858619, "loser_reward": -0.2626755781183019, "reward_margin": 0.18336147963243998, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10386363955587148, "loser_reward": -0.12327181923575699, "reward_margin": 0.019408179679885507, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10386363955587148, "loser_reward": -0.2626755781183019, "reward_margin": 0.15881193856243042, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12327181923575699, "loser_reward": -0.2626755781183019, "reward_margin": 0.13940375888254491, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 185007, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 644, 725, 1024], "component_score": 0.07201317757478681, "component_reward": -0.07201317757478681, "second_component_score": 0.0793140984858619, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.007300920911075093, "confidence": 0.7085884033680276}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7085885405540466, "teacher_quality_score": 0.12369190116703976, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.12369190116703976, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.07201317757478681, "loser_reward": -0.10386363955587148, "reward_margin": 0.03185046198108467, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.07201317757478681, "loser_reward": -0.12327181923575699, "reward_margin": 0.051258641660970175, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.07201317757478681, "loser_reward": -0.2626755781183019, "reward_margin": 0.19066240054351508, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.0793140984858619, "loser_reward": -0.10386363955587148, "reward_margin": 0.024549541070009576, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0793140984858619, "loser_reward": -0.12327181923575699, "reward_margin": 0.04395772074989508, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0793140984858619, "loser_reward": -0.2626755781183019, "reward_margin": 0.18336147963243998, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10386363955587148, "loser_reward": -0.12327181923575699, "reward_margin": 0.019408179679885507, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10386363955587148, "loser_reward": -0.2626755781183019, "reward_margin": 0.15881193856243042, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "189893_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12327181923575699, "loser_reward": -0.2626755781183019, "reward_margin": 0.13940375888254491, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/189893_2/189893_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0882626473903656, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.45725807547569275, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06532546877861023, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.32557761669158936, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0654735267162323, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0694943517446518, "input_change_l1": 0.20192669332027435, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4154824838042259, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1380508557893336, "edit_score": 0.3429404113441706, "background_score": 0.20020994544029236, "combined_score": 0.4475734985806048, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/189893_2/189893_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.01803712174296379, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6342841982841492, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005792304291389883, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9891452789306641, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0005265864892862737, "full_mse_to_target": 0.003616083413362503, "input_change_l1": 0.045026302337646484, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8870095312595367, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.058672540169209246, "edit_score": 0.11942789927124978, "background_score": 0.002750174643006176, "combined_score": 0.13248657677148004, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/189893_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.013789921067655087, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6208794116973877, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0002447247097734362, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9951448440551758, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00024025817401707172, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0026309117674827576, "input_change_l1": 0.02926708571612835, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8870106041431427, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03845533565618098, "edit_score": 0.11786138769239188, "background_score": 0.00121575589873828, "combined_score": 0.12624106056493475, "confidence": 0.63386173843613}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/189893_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.027215059846639633, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5548174381256104, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0009017307311296463, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.984425961971283, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0008153453818522394, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0054732151329517365, "input_change_l1": 0.05583354830741882, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8853987753391266, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07182810865342618, "edit_score": 0.1449018783867359, "background_score": 0.004016538336873055, "combined_score": 0.16122061004862187, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/189893_2/189893_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.017648078501224518, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5665082931518555, "background_mse_to_source": 0.030024180188775063, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6898724436759949, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0299905464053154, "full_mse_to_target": 0.027812888845801353, "input_change_l1": 0.1390751153230667, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8616479933261871, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10222327467054129, "edit_score": 0.13893442153930663, "background_score": 0.09204969145357608, "combined_score": 0.19437775736674665, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/189893_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/189893_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/189893_2.json"}

190360_1

let the cat have its eyes closed

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.006147999782115221, "dataset_mask_area": 0.006148, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.11977241933345795, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.006325623486191034, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.11344679584726691, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.38847385272145146, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.46153846153846156, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.48674169182777405, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.17852519663537955, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.19180068789554752, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.19376000102609398, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.04957454651594162, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.11977241933345795, "edit_change_ratio": 0.41390619636663856, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.014795999974012375, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/190360_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5344946384429932, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4655053913593292}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.10400184216124762, "reward": -0.10400184216124762}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.11091174026450608, "reward": -0.11091174026450608}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.12090558728575705, "reward": -0.12090558728575705}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.12274824108311443, "reward": -0.12274824108311443}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.18613627007603645, "reward": -0.18613627007603645}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10400184216124762, "loser_reward": -0.12090558728575705, "reward_margin": 0.01690374512450943, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10400184216124762, "loser_reward": -0.12274824108311443, "reward_margin": 0.018746398921866803, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10400184216124762, "loser_reward": -0.18613627007603645, "reward_margin": 0.08213442791478882, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11091174026450608, "loser_reward": -0.12274824108311443, "reward_margin": 0.011836500818608348, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11091174026450608, "loser_reward": -0.18613627007603645, "reward_margin": 0.07522452981153037, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12090558728575705, "loser_reward": -0.18613627007603645, "reward_margin": 0.0652306827902794, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12274824108311443, "loser_reward": -0.18613627007603645, "reward_margin": 0.06338802899292202, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 1537, "bbox_xyxy": [321, 281, 375, 336], "component_score": 0.10400184216124762, "component_reward": -0.10400184216124762, "second_component_score": 0.11091174026450608, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.006909898103258455, "confidence": 0.6598763640192526}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6598763465881348, "teacher_quality_score": 0.19180068789554752, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.19180068789554752, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.10400184216124762, "loser_reward": -0.12090558728575705, "reward_margin": 0.01690374512450943, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.10400184216124762, "loser_reward": -0.12274824108311443, "reward_margin": 0.018746398921866803, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.10400184216124762, "loser_reward": -0.18613627007603645, "reward_margin": 0.08213442791478882, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.11091174026450608, "loser_reward": -0.12274824108311443, "reward_margin": 0.011836500818608348, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.11091174026450608, "loser_reward": -0.18613627007603645, "reward_margin": 0.07522452981153037, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12090558728575705, "loser_reward": -0.18613627007603645, "reward_margin": 0.0652306827902794, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12274824108311443, "loser_reward": -0.18613627007603645, "reward_margin": 0.06338802899292202, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/190360_1/190360_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04896159470081329, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5573694109916687, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009125548414885998, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8587796092033386, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008900979533791542, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009147271513938904, "input_change_l1": 0.04627424478530884, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6577014923095703, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.14795184936374425, "edit_score": 0.22306233942508696, "background_score": 0.03736962657421827, "combined_score": 0.2666468057502061, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/190360_1/190360_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.032252512872219086, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6737993359565735, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0002455112407915294, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9952341914176941, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00042495765956118703, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0006206334219314158, "input_change_l1": 0.010043974965810776, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5930819734930992, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04025819972157479, "edit_score": 0.19922215230762957, "background_score": 0.0011986729572527111, "combined_score": 0.20775539112917613, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/190360_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.024669919162988663, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6807022094726562, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00010372846008976921, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9978206753730774, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0003153470461256802, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0004650789487641305, "input_change_l1": 0.006528579629957676, "directional_pixel_score": 0.593081995844841, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02648333515971899, "edit_score": 0.19025897830724717, "background_score": 0.0005395933854742907, "combined_score": 0.19579101091898338, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/190360_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04029642045497894, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.664800226688385, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00038351985858753324, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9929792284965515, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0005400406080298126, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0007844628999009728, "input_change_l1": 0.012554485350847244, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5930983945727348, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0500187860801816, "edit_score": 0.20906177647411822, "background_score": 0.0017876741592772307, "combined_score": 0.21976966593589167, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/190360_1/190360_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.021819166839122772, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6385477185249329, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009783286601305008, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.792936384677887, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009299742989242077, "full_mse_to_target": 0.009376712143421173, "input_change_l1": 0.06451662629842758, "directional_pixel_score": 0.736011266708374, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07398459985852242, "edit_score": 0.1601068064570427, "background_score": 0.05119600966572762, "combined_score": 0.19376000102609398, "confidence": 0.5686613287774749}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/190360_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/190360_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/190360_1.json"}

190360_2

add a woman inside the car

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.015070915222167969, "dataset_mask_area": 0.015070915222167969, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.11173935234546661, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0016406747745350003, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.11009867757093161, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6904031958379785, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.7219253934330678, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.45526546239852905, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.22182407680881172, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.007835178314994666, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.06827913091634401, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.0024807078298181295, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.11173934489488602, "edit_change_ratio": 0.02220084458300475, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.10056368261575699, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.8999845373208332}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.023395538330078125, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/190360_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.501590371131897, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4984096586704254}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.0417878585330036, "reward": -0.0417878585330036}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.04210593324789078, "reward": -0.04210593324789078}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.04242130365420598, "reward": -0.04242130365420598}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.05770561353792436, "reward": -0.05770561353792436}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.16783177646715194, "reward": -0.16783177646715194}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0417878585330036, "loser_reward": -0.05770561353792436, "reward_margin": 0.015917755004920764, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0417878585330036, "loser_reward": -0.16783177646715194, "reward_margin": 0.12604391793414835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04210593324789078, "loser_reward": -0.05770561353792436, "reward_margin": 0.015599680290033578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04210593324789078, "loser_reward": -0.16783177646715194, "reward_margin": 0.12572584321926117, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04242130365420598, "loser_reward": -0.05770561353792436, "reward_margin": 0.015284309883718379, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04242130365420598, "loser_reward": -0.16783177646715194, "reward_margin": 0.12541047281294596, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05770561353792436, "loser_reward": -0.16783177646715194, "reward_margin": 0.11012616292922758, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 2810, "bbox_xyxy": [257, 283, 317, 357], "component_score": 0.0417878585330036, "component_reward": -0.0417878585330036, "second_component_score": 0.04210593324789078, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0003180747148871857, "confidence": 0.5635933279028663}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.5005019903182983, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49949800968170166}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.04249562794249504, "reward": -0.04249562794249504}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.042596023578895255, "reward": -0.042596023578895255}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.04278266425835317, "reward": -0.04278266425835317}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.05949493351881392, "reward": -0.05949493351881392}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3747241118075326, "reward": -0.3747241118075326}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04249562794249504, "loser_reward": -0.05949493351881392, "reward_margin": 0.01699930557631888, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04249562794249504, "loser_reward": -0.3747241118075326, "reward_margin": 0.33222848386503756, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.042596023578895255, "loser_reward": -0.05949493351881392, "reward_margin": 0.016898909939918667, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.042596023578895255, "loser_reward": -0.3747241118075326, "reward_margin": 0.3321280882286374, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04278266425835317, "loser_reward": -0.05949493351881392, "reward_margin": 0.016712269260460752, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04278266425835317, "loser_reward": -0.3747241118075326, "reward_margin": 0.3319414475491794, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05949493351881392, "loser_reward": -0.3747241118075326, "reward_margin": 0.3152291782887187, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 12993, "bbox_xyxy": [183, 313, 404, 433], "component_score": 0.04249562794249504, "component_reward": -0.04249562794249504, "second_component_score": 0.042596023578895255, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.00010039563640021343, "confidence": 0.5542423354776718}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5559049844741821, "teacher_quality_score": 0.007835178314994666, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.007835178314994666, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.0417878585330036, "loser_reward": -0.05770561353792436, "reward_margin": 0.015917755004920764, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.0417878585330036, "loser_reward": -0.16783177646715194, "reward_margin": 0.12604391793414835, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04210593324789078, "loser_reward": -0.05770561353792436, "reward_margin": 0.015599680290033578, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04210593324789078, "loser_reward": -0.16783177646715194, "reward_margin": 0.12572584321926117, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04242130365420598, "loser_reward": -0.05770561353792436, "reward_margin": 0.015284309883718379, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04242130365420598, "loser_reward": -0.16783177646715194, "reward_margin": 0.12541047281294596, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05770561353792436, "loser_reward": -0.16783177646715194, "reward_margin": 0.11012616292922758, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04249562794249504, "loser_reward": -0.05949493351881392, "reward_margin": 0.01699930557631888, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04249562794249504, "loser_reward": -0.3747241118075326, "reward_margin": 0.33222848386503756, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.042596023578895255, "loser_reward": -0.05949493351881392, "reward_margin": 0.016898909939918667, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.042596023578895255, "loser_reward": -0.3747241118075326, "reward_margin": 0.3321280882286374, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.04278266425835317, "loser_reward": -0.05949493351881392, "reward_margin": 0.016712269260460752, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.04278266425835317, "loser_reward": -0.3747241118075326, "reward_margin": 0.3319414475491794, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_2__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.05949493351881392, "loser_reward": -0.3747241118075326, "reward_margin": 0.3152291782887187, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/190360_2/190360_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.16694584488868713, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6545758247375488, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04792814329266548, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5057317614555359, "background_mse_to_target": 0.048128895461559296, "full_mse_to_target": 0.049919579178094864, "input_change_l1": 0.17007285356521606, "directional_pixel_score": 0.15437564253807068, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13667601021006703, "edit_score": 0.4474367693066597, "background_score": 0.1467817910015583, "combined_score": 0.5311375561170281, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/190360_2/190360_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.013499069027602673, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.902392566204071, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0056923734955489635, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9346849918365479, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005856428761035204, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005971608683466911, "input_change_l1": 0.023368733003735542, "directional_pixel_score": 0.881046712398529, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.004094194615026936, "edit_score": 0.0627588776871562, "background_score": 0.018755375128239396, "combined_score": 0.07073925877339206, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/190360_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.013926077634096146, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9018797874450684, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0024050241336226463, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9523136019706726, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002571068238466978, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0027421985287219286, "input_change_l1": 0.015189670026302338, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8810468018054962, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.002683425304712728, "edit_score": 0.06328841969370842, "background_score": 0.011942303739488125, "combined_score": 0.06827913091634401, "confidence": 0.6121985990582355}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/190360_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.01320147980004549, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9025180339813232, "background_mse_to_source": 0.008299658074975014, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9272124171257019, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008462291210889816, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008533718064427376, "input_change_l1": 0.028724106028676033, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8810470402240753, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.005088937911204993, "edit_score": 0.06243611294776201, "background_score": 0.02285717464983463, "combined_score": 0.07230728346388787, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/190360_2/190360_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.010761966928839684, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.9122387766838074, "background_mse_to_source": 0.007959782145917416, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8046143651008606, "background_mse_to_target": 0.008022738620638847, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008064022287726402, "input_change_l1": 0.05485568568110466, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8869448006153107, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.014671432157047092, "edit_score": 0.056578011438250544, "background_score": 0.0470369091257453, "combined_score": 0.07678161829244345, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/190360_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/190360_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/190360_2.json"}

190360_3

add luggage on top of the car

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.06836795806884766, "dataset_mask_area": 0.06836795806884766, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.37536942958831787, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0004147548461332917, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.3749546747421846, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8962302667392488, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9735239334180883, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4467034935951233, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.521443264087618, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.3072691854071309, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3163673986447975, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1995905041694641, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.37536942958831787, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5317175252879882, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.07806205749511719, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/190360_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6262253522872925, "qwen_image_edit": 0.37377461791038513}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2370850256448612, "reward": -0.2370850256448612}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.26288790423795577, "reward": -0.26288790423795577}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.30503860078193246, "reward": -0.30503860078193246}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3619032331313937, "reward": -0.3619032331313937}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3733974845651537, "reward": -0.3733974845651537}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2370850256448612, "loser_reward": -0.26288790423795577, "reward_margin": 0.025802878593094575, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2370850256448612, "loser_reward": -0.30503860078193246, "reward_margin": 0.06795357513707126, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2370850256448612, "loser_reward": -0.3619032331313937, "reward_margin": 0.12481820748653252, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2370850256448612, "loser_reward": -0.3733974845651537, "reward_margin": 0.1363124589202925, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.26288790423795577, "loser_reward": -0.30503860078193246, "reward_margin": 0.042150696543976685, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26288790423795577, "loser_reward": -0.3619032331313937, "reward_margin": 0.09901532889343795, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.26288790423795577, "loser_reward": -0.3733974845651537, "reward_margin": 0.11050958032719793, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.30503860078193246, "loser_reward": -0.3619032331313937, "reward_margin": 0.056864632349461264, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.30503860078193246, "loser_reward": -0.3733974845651537, "reward_margin": 0.06835888378322125, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.3619032331313937, "loser_reward": -0.3733974845651537, "reward_margin": 0.011494251433759983, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 71689, "bbox_xyxy": [193, 0, 799, 164], "component_score": 0.2370850256448612, "component_reward": -0.2370850256448612, "second_component_score": 0.26288790423795577, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.025802878593094575, "confidence": 0.7181222892869004}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7181224226951599, "teacher_quality_score": 0.3072691854071309, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.3072691854071309, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2370850256448612, "loser_reward": -0.26288790423795577, "reward_margin": 0.025802878593094575, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2370850256448612, "loser_reward": -0.30503860078193246, "reward_margin": 0.06795357513707126, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2370850256448612, "loser_reward": -0.3619032331313937, "reward_margin": 0.12481820748653252, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2370850256448612, "loser_reward": -0.3733974845651537, "reward_margin": 0.1363124589202925, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.26288790423795577, "loser_reward": -0.30503860078193246, "reward_margin": 0.042150696543976685, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26288790423795577, "loser_reward": -0.3619032331313937, "reward_margin": 0.09901532889343795, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.26288790423795577, "loser_reward": -0.3733974845651537, "reward_margin": 0.11050958032719793, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.30503860078193246, "loser_reward": -0.3619032331313937, "reward_margin": 0.056864632349461264, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.30503860078193246, "loser_reward": -0.3733974845651537, "reward_margin": 0.06835888378322125, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "190360_3__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.3619032331313937, "loser_reward": -0.3733974845651537, "reward_margin": 0.011494251433759983, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/190360_3/190360_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1966998428106308, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.34650397300720215, "background_mse_to_source": 0.044027283787727356, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5336899757385254, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04409502074122429, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05452832579612732, "input_change_l1": 0.16714464128017426, "directional_pixel_score": 0.628414586186409, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1182302137836814, "edit_score": 0.42029540166258816, "background_score": 0.13728928864002227, "combined_score": 0.49744552802294495, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/190360_3/190360_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12222951650619507, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3446401059627533, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012191103771328926, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9202730059623718, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01220046728849411, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01972292736172676, "input_change_l1": 0.04920332133769989, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8224539160728455, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.17648717015981674, "edit_score": 0.29768801629543307, "background_score": 0.028136502578854562, "combined_score": 0.3448055189661682, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/190360_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11508084088563919, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.366534024477005, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0051507470197975636, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9433490633964539, "background_mse_to_target": 0.005167156457901001, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012681731022894382, "input_change_l1": 0.03198215737938881, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8224537372589111, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11585148423910141, "edit_score": 0.2861606016755104, "background_score": 0.016480934340506792, "combined_score": 0.3163673986447975, "confidence": 0.6932952359519811}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/190360_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14543740451335907, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.27659153938293457, "background_mse_to_source": 0.017207147553563118, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9125455021858215, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01721475087106228, "full_mse_to_target": 0.025981063023209572, "input_change_l1": 0.06014104187488556, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8236971497535706, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.21129976790398358, "edit_score": 0.3341948091983795, "background_score": 0.03469804711639882, "combined_score": 0.39119718557223676, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/190360_3/190360_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.21198095381259918, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.36301350593566895, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00998668186366558, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7782875895500183, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009995555505156517, "full_mse_to_target": 0.023804903030395508, "input_change_l1": 0.0659395381808281, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5390427187085152, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08311205785721541, "edit_score": 0.4546175729483366, "background_score": 0.05432916395366192, "combined_score": 0.49263568220660087, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/190360_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/190360_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/190360_3.json"}

193680_1

change the cat to a fox.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.21678400039672852, "dataset_mask_area": 0.216784, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.19529400765895844, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.009320731274783611, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.18597327638417482, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8209541329842747, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9520595716747354, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.26516759395599365, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3225701552092772, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.23665650446157088, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.23819302601099482, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.13034206628799438, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.19529400765895844, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6674145707307645, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.2624559998512268, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/193680_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.593178391456604, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4068216383457184}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.15158558718825224, "reward": -0.15158558718825224}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1704416077912319, "reward": -0.1704416077912319}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19010642702830954, "reward": -0.19010642702830954}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.21000813869666307, "reward": -0.21000813869666307}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.26962292085308576, "reward": -0.26962292085308576}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15158558718825224, "loser_reward": -0.1704416077912319, "reward_margin": 0.018856020602979667, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15158558718825224, "loser_reward": -0.19010642702830954, "reward_margin": 0.0385208398400573, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15158558718825224, "loser_reward": -0.21000813869666307, "reward_margin": 0.05842255150841083, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15158558718825224, "loser_reward": -0.26962292085308576, "reward_margin": 0.11803733366483352, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1704416077912319, "loser_reward": -0.19010642702830954, "reward_margin": 0.019664819237077635, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1704416077912319, "loser_reward": -0.21000813869666307, "reward_margin": 0.03956653090543116, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1704416077912319, "loser_reward": -0.26962292085308576, "reward_margin": 0.09918131306185385, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19010642702830954, "loser_reward": -0.21000813869666307, "reward_margin": 0.019901711668353528, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19010642702830954, "loser_reward": -0.26962292085308576, "reward_margin": 0.07951649382477621, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21000813869666307, "loser_reward": -0.26962292085308576, "reward_margin": 0.059614782156422685, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 54196, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 110, 390, 299], "component_score": 0.15158558718825224, "component_reward": -0.15158558718825224, "second_component_score": 0.1704416077912319, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.018856020602979667, "confidence": 0.7370795226632341}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7370795011520386, "teacher_quality_score": 0.23665650446157088, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.23665650446157088, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15158558718825224, "loser_reward": -0.1704416077912319, "reward_margin": 0.018856020602979667, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15158558718825224, "loser_reward": -0.19010642702830954, "reward_margin": 0.0385208398400573, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15158558718825224, "loser_reward": -0.21000813869666307, "reward_margin": 0.05842255150841083, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15158558718825224, "loser_reward": -0.26962292085308576, "reward_margin": 0.11803733366483352, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1704416077912319, "loser_reward": -0.19010642702830954, "reward_margin": 0.019664819237077635, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1704416077912319, "loser_reward": -0.21000813869666307, "reward_margin": 0.03956653090543116, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1704416077912319, "loser_reward": -0.26962292085308576, "reward_margin": 0.09918131306185385, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19010642702830954, "loser_reward": -0.21000813869666307, "reward_margin": 0.019901711668353528, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19010642702830954, "loser_reward": -0.26962292085308576, "reward_margin": 0.07951649382477621, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "193680_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.21000813869666307, "loser_reward": -0.26962292085308576, "reward_margin": 0.059614782156422685, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/193680_1/193680_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1073082983493805, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3533085286617279, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009913923218846321, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8779767155647278, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009855165146291256, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03098144568502903, "input_change_l1": 0.0995870903134346, "directional_pixel_score": 0.622176468372345, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11248099440708756, "edit_score": 0.33110247552394867, "background_score": 0.03431858010590076, "combined_score": 0.36870832201093434, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/193680_1/193680_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06018488481640816, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.40901100635528564, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0013224593130871654, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9759788513183594, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0016874873545020819, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01436878927052021, "input_change_l1": 0.04751478508114815, "directional_pixel_score": 0.74872125685215, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06678887819871307, "edit_score": 0.24120236933231354, "background_score": 0.006126689049415291, "combined_score": 0.2581413650664035, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/193680_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04999062791466713, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.42792102694511414, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005587390041910112, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9872167706489563, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0009823305299505591, "full_mse_to_target": 0.011606547050178051, "input_change_l1": 0.030884604901075363, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7487213611602783, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.043579521821811795, "edit_score": 0.22722608223557472, "background_score": 0.0031153848743997515, "combined_score": 0.23819302601099482, "confidence": 0.6848310826098171}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/193680_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07225590199232101, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.38318946957588196, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00203369720838964, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9676730036735535, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0023567709140479565, "full_mse_to_target": 0.017509780824184418, "input_change_l1": 0.05850665271282196, "directional_pixel_score": 0.750702440738678, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08233866570517422, "edit_score": 0.25794239789247514, "background_score": 0.008499096473678948, "combined_score": 0.279135792881716, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/193680_1/193680_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06186044216156006, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.33817675709724426, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014479958452284336, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6730077862739563, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014181165024638176, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02451726794242859, "input_change_l1": 0.10942364484071732, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7503755688667297, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09490196155384184, "edit_score": 0.2566311985254288, "background_score": 0.07987840119749308, "combined_score": 0.30602075804956264, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/193680_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/193680_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/193680_1.json"}

194956_1

let the ship be blue

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.07264000177383423, "dataset_mask_area": 0.07264, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.29504573345184326, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.008611803874373436, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2864339295774698, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8626757002730306, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9133832976445396, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4303337335586548, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.42649034551601506, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.23381141780468168, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.267680310276337, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1934681385755539, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.29504573345184326, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6557225427804105, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.11099199950695038, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/194956_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6762703657150269, "qwen_image_edit": 0.32372957468032837}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.19195245248638093, "reward": -0.19195245248638093}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2287866800036281, "reward": -0.2287866800036281}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.26584051016159355, "reward": -0.26584051016159355}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2979110421370715, "reward": -0.2979110421370715}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.396217080488801, "reward": -0.396217080488801}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19195245248638093, "loser_reward": -0.2287866800036281, "reward_margin": 0.03683422751724716, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19195245248638093, "loser_reward": -0.26584051016159355, "reward_margin": 0.07388805767521262, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19195245248638093, "loser_reward": -0.2979110421370715, "reward_margin": 0.10595858965069055, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19195245248638093, "loser_reward": -0.396217080488801, "reward_margin": 0.20426462800242007, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2287866800036281, "loser_reward": -0.26584051016159355, "reward_margin": 0.037053830157965456, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2287866800036281, "loser_reward": -0.2979110421370715, "reward_margin": 0.06912436213344339, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2287866800036281, "loser_reward": -0.396217080488801, "reward_margin": 0.1674304004851729, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.26584051016159355, "loser_reward": -0.2979110421370715, "reward_margin": 0.032070531975477934, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26584051016159355, "loser_reward": -0.396217080488801, "reward_margin": 0.13037657032720745, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2979110421370715, "loser_reward": -0.396217080488801, "reward_margin": 0.09830603835172952, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 18160, "bbox_xyxy": [16, 202, 398, 275], "component_score": 0.19195245248638093, "component_reward": -0.19195245248638093, "second_component_score": 0.2287866800036281, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.03683422751724716, "confidence": 0.8054253118772072}], "teacher_confidence": 0.8054254055023193, "teacher_quality_score": 0.23381141780468168, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.23381141780468168, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.19195245248638093, "loser_reward": -0.2287866800036281, "reward_margin": 0.03683422751724716, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.19195245248638093, "loser_reward": -0.26584051016159355, "reward_margin": 0.07388805767521262, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19195245248638093, "loser_reward": -0.2979110421370715, "reward_margin": 0.10595858965069055, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19195245248638093, "loser_reward": -0.396217080488801, "reward_margin": 0.20426462800242007, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2287866800036281, "loser_reward": -0.26584051016159355, "reward_margin": 0.037053830157965456, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2287866800036281, "loser_reward": -0.2979110421370715, "reward_margin": 0.06912436213344339, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2287866800036281, "loser_reward": -0.396217080488801, "reward_margin": 0.1674304004851729, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.26584051016159355, "loser_reward": -0.2979110421370715, "reward_margin": 0.032070531975477934, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26584051016159355, "loser_reward": -0.396217080488801, "reward_margin": 0.13037657032720745, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2979110421370715, "loser_reward": -0.396217080488801, "reward_margin": 0.09830603835172952, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/194956_1/194956_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.20647484064102173, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3387380540370941, "background_mse_to_source": 0.1500028818845749, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5368592739105225, "background_mse_to_target": 0.14970096945762634, "full_mse_to_target": 0.15382501482963562, "input_change_l1": 0.3235297203063965, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7334428578615189, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.23891973197460176, "edit_score": 0.4053665153682232, "background_score": 0.24263102710247042, "combined_score": 0.5534538227319719, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/194956_1/194956_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10556479543447495, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.418159157037735, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010261454619467258, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9470166563987732, "background_mse_to_target": 0.010640209540724754, "full_mse_to_target": 0.017535531893372536, "input_change_l1": 0.04819849878549576, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8112188577651978, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1468148238956928, "edit_score": 0.26912824958562853, "background_score": 0.02085812333971262, "combined_score": 0.3075451107230038, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/194956_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08500714600086212, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.44258537888526917, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00433546444401145, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9714110493659973, "background_mse_to_target": 0.004785042256116867, "full_mse_to_target": 0.010612375102937222, "input_change_l1": 0.031329017132520676, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8112188279628754, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09707535216584802, "edit_score": 0.24368536323308945, "background_score": 0.010053254570811987, "combined_score": 0.267680310276337, "confidence": 0.7644403192288525}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/194956_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1325826346874237, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3953336179256439, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014307502657175064, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9357671141624451, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014631235972046852, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02319922484457493, "input_change_l1": 0.058677323162555695, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8134264647960663, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.17361682895570993, "edit_score": 0.30015929490327836, "background_score": 0.027154079824686053, "combined_score": 0.346706511117518, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/194956_1/194956_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.136916384100914, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3852572739124298, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03850628435611725, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5493305325508118, "background_mse_to_target": 0.038025420159101486, "full_mse_to_target": 0.045208849012851715, "input_change_l1": 0.16014771163463593, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7357134073972702, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16608333718031645, "edit_score": 0.3259365774691105, "background_score": 0.12864017784595488, "combined_score": 0.4086981920525431, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/194956_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/194956_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/194956_1.json"}

194956_2

add a cat

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.04386615753173828, "dataset_mask_area": 0.04386615753173828, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.23884613811969757, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0002740213822107762, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2385721167374868, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9672042662521321, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9929074870339998, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.43784040212631226, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3943529281691026, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.010396916597351267, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.2659061187208863, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.00953986681997776, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.23884613811969757, "edit_change_ratio": 0.03994147401787532, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.2337186187505722, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9785321236110767}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.05072498321533203, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/194956_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.5033647418022156, "qwen_image_edit": 0.49663519859313965}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19398924130504014, "reward": -0.19398924130504014}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.19466220856667493, "reward": -0.19466220856667493}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.19563879227754657, "reward": -0.19563879227754657}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.23886969489883628, "reward": -0.23886969489883628}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2694689414408058, "reward": -0.2694689414408058}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19398924130504014, "loser_reward": -0.23886969489883628, "reward_margin": 0.04488045359379614, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19398924130504014, "loser_reward": -0.2694689414408058, "reward_margin": 0.07547970013576566, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19466220856667493, "loser_reward": -0.23886969489883628, "reward_margin": 0.044207486332161344, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19466220856667493, "loser_reward": -0.2694689414408058, "reward_margin": 0.07480673287413087, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19563879227754657, "loser_reward": -0.23886969489883628, "reward_margin": 0.0432309026212897, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19563879227754657, "loser_reward": -0.2694689414408058, "reward_margin": 0.07383014916325922, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23886969489883628, "loser_reward": -0.2694689414408058, "reward_margin": 0.03059924654196952, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 45997, "bbox_xyxy": [0, 65, 192, 373], "component_score": 0.19398924130504014, "component_reward": -0.19398924130504014, "second_component_score": 0.19466220856667493, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0006729672616347937, "confidence": 0.5562223870982616}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5562223792076111, "teacher_quality_score": 0.010396916597351267, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.010396916597351267, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19398924130504014, "loser_reward": -0.23886969489883628, "reward_margin": 0.04488045359379614, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19398924130504014, "loser_reward": -0.2694689414408058, "reward_margin": 0.07547970013576566, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19466220856667493, "loser_reward": -0.23886969489883628, "reward_margin": 0.044207486332161344, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19466220856667493, "loser_reward": -0.2694689414408058, "reward_margin": 0.07480673287413087, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19563879227754657, "loser_reward": -0.23886969489883628, "reward_margin": 0.0432309026212897, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19563879227754657, "loser_reward": -0.2694689414408058, "reward_margin": 0.07383014916325922, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23886969489883628, "loser_reward": -0.2694689414408058, "reward_margin": 0.03059924654196952, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/194956_2/194956_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10411339998245239, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3654859960079193, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00220840098336339, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9504963755607605, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0022200094535946846, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006689682137221098, "input_change_l1": 0.030388088896870613, "directional_pixel_score": 0.3755768686532974, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.021926172729581597, "edit_score": 0.3871219836175442, "background_score": 0.01210912587121129, "combined_score": 0.39641438043210653, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/194956_2/194956_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08025237917900085, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4175003468990326, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0021293170284479856, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9635049700737, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0021413490176200867, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005567777901887894, "input_change_l1": 0.016658155247569084, "directional_pixel_score": 0.742215484380722, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.007123451819643379, "edit_score": 0.2611984387040138, "background_score": 0.009428323013707995, "combined_score": 0.26647981991292913, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/194956_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08136502653360367, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.41518542170524597, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0008996358956210315, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.979374349117279, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0009119680034928024, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0044411360286176205, "input_change_l1": 0.010827798396348953, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7422153502702713, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.004646161838900298, "edit_score": 0.2627741046249866, "background_score": 0.005024766072165221, "combined_score": 0.2659061187208863, "confidence": 0.5538751019299389}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/194956_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07948008924722672, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.41887399554252625, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0032464463729411364, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9541587233543396, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0032582636922597885, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006601820234209299, "input_change_l1": 0.020745692774653435, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7422149628400803, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.008884305576793849, "edit_score": 0.2601515494287014, "background_score": 0.012414701702073217, "combined_score": 0.26693373816320676, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/194956_2/194956_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08982286602258682, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4221475124359131, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009753148071467876, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7483530640602112, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009769454598426819, "full_mse_to_target": 0.01328109297901392, "input_change_l1": 0.06922274082899094, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5259564891457558, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05750703969970346, "edit_score": 0.3239042412489653, "background_score": 0.06008253525942564, "combined_score": 0.35776264582760636, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/194956_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/194956_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/194956_2.json"}

194956_3

add a table in front

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.03754615783691406, "dataset_mask_area": 0.03754615783691406, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.18333174288272858, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0009473363170400262, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.18238440656568855, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.7917746633942703, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.890904867599236, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4565185606479645, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.31303356087697043, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.010998101909881371, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.23908399484782422, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.005251170136034489, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.18333174288272858, "edit_change_ratio": 0.028642994679832907, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.17856422066688538, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.973995107770874}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.048979759216308594, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/194956_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5004861354827881, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4995138347148895}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1631288903624372, "reward": -0.1631288903624372}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1632261295081989, "reward": -0.1632261295081989}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.16326786147977687, "reward": -0.16326786147977687}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.19497859418299046, "reward": -0.19497859418299046}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2553003136664629, "reward": -0.2553003136664629}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1631288903624372, "loser_reward": -0.19497859418299046, "reward_margin": 0.03184970382055327, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1631288903624372, "loser_reward": -0.2553003136664629, "reward_margin": 0.0921714233040257, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1632261295081989, "loser_reward": -0.19497859418299046, "reward_margin": 0.031752464674791564, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1632261295081989, "loser_reward": -0.2553003136664629, "reward_margin": 0.09207418415826399, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16326786147977687, "loser_reward": -0.19497859418299046, "reward_margin": 0.03171073270321359, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16326786147977687, "loser_reward": -0.2553003136664629, "reward_margin": 0.09203245218668601, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19497859418299046, "loser_reward": -0.2553003136664629, "reward_margin": 0.060321719483472425, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 39370, "bbox_xyxy": [219, 880, 605, 1024], "component_score": 0.1631288903624372, "component_reward": -0.1631288903624372, "second_component_score": 0.1632261295081989, "reward_margin_to_second": 9.723914576170722e-05, "confidence": 0.5510723165997466}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5510722398757935, "teacher_quality_score": 0.010998101909881371, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.010998101909881371, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1631288903624372, "loser_reward": -0.19497859418299046, "reward_margin": 0.03184970382055327, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1631288903624372, "loser_reward": -0.2553003136664629, "reward_margin": 0.0921714233040257, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1632261295081989, "loser_reward": -0.19497859418299046, "reward_margin": 0.031752464674791564, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1632261295081989, "loser_reward": -0.2553003136664629, "reward_margin": 0.09207418415826399, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16326786147977687, "loser_reward": -0.19497859418299046, "reward_margin": 0.03171073270321359, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16326786147977687, "loser_reward": -0.2553003136664629, "reward_margin": 0.09203245218668601, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "194956_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19497859418299046, "loser_reward": -0.2553003136664629, "reward_margin": 0.060321719483472425, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/194956_3/194956_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09680909663438797, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.32440194487571716, "background_mse_to_source": 0.041777461767196655, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6296433806419373, "background_mse_to_target": 0.041952624917030334, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04401227459311485, "input_change_l1": 0.14416493475437164, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6733398735523224, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09546189159154893, "edit_score": 0.31359373927116396, "background_score": 0.11584878563880921, "combined_score": 0.37763442002236847, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/194956_3/194956_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.049453794956207275, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.46509039402008057, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0001970653102034703, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9932724833488464, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00029967096634209156, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002145219361409545, "input_change_l1": 0.010920080356299877, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6778172701597214, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.009561874938663095, "edit_score": 0.2369813986122608, "background_score": 0.0015425686404341834, "combined_score": 0.23964819456028635, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/194956_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05018436536192894, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4668302834033966, "background_mse_to_source": 8.326007082359865e-05, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.996584415435791, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0001848809770308435, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0020621696021407843, "input_change_l1": 0.00709804892539978, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6778169572353363, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.006227382854558528, "edit_score": 0.23736406937241555, "background_score": 0.0007663769836653956, "combined_score": 0.23908399484782422, "confidence": 0.5542375837427856}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/194956_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.048967037349939346, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4637896716594696, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0003079129382967949, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.990551769733429, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00041122204856947064, "full_mse_to_target": 0.002234305953606963, "input_change_l1": 0.013650056906044483, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6778165400028229, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.011934474424924702, "edit_score": 0.2367549680173397, "background_score": 0.002197558991611004, "combined_score": 0.2401344391447492, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/194956_3/194956_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.051458362489938736, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.44905349612236023, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014086625538766384, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6613097786903381, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014168854802846909, "full_mse_to_target": 0.015568934381008148, "input_change_l1": 0.08684426546096802, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5836603567004204, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04208336444571614, "edit_score": 0.2657325740903616, "background_score": 0.08182466980069876, "combined_score": 0.3043447748478502, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/194956_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/194956_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/194956_3.json"}

203920_1

make the stop sing an animal sign

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.24593600630760193, "dataset_mask_area": 0.245936, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.31116822361946106, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.012710094451904297, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.29845812916755676, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.9174695173646972, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9461276785146563, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06143790856003761, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3545096516609192, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4463995783919067, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.014238584037084365, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.33134785007219764, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.0783342719078064, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.31116822361946106, "edit_change_ratio": 0.2517425172681007, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.3030259907245636, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9738333406920917}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.29962798953056335, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/203920_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit": 0.5023284554481506, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.49767157435417175}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2286746200537309, "reward": -0.2286746200537309}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22914031518762928, "reward": -0.22914031518762928}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.24227804167103023, "reward": -0.24227804167103023}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2879610859546811, "reward": -0.2879610859546811}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3089756306647324, "reward": -0.3089756306647324}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2286746200537309, "loser_reward": -0.24227804167103023, "reward_margin": 0.013603421617299327, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2286746200537309, "loser_reward": -0.2879610859546811, "reward_margin": 0.059286465900950214, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2286746200537309, "loser_reward": -0.3089756306647324, "reward_margin": 0.08030101061100148, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22914031518762928, "loser_reward": -0.24227804167103023, "reward_margin": 0.013137726483400947, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22914031518762928, "loser_reward": -0.2879610859546811, "reward_margin": 0.05882077076705183, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22914031518762928, "loser_reward": -0.3089756306647324, "reward_margin": 0.0798353154771031, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24227804167103023, "loser_reward": -0.2879610859546811, "reward_margin": 0.04568304428365089, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24227804167103023, "loser_reward": -0.3089756306647324, "reward_margin": 0.06669758899370215, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2879610859546811, "loser_reward": -0.3089756306647324, "reward_margin": 0.021014544710051264, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 61484, "bbox_xyxy": [119, 188, 430, 500], "component_score": 0.2286746200537309, "component_reward": -0.2286746200537309, "second_component_score": 0.22914031518762928, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0004656951338983806, "confidence": 0.5536581630276539}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5536580681800842, "teacher_quality_score": 0.014238584037084365, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.014238584037084365, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2286746200537309, "loser_reward": -0.24227804167103023, "reward_margin": 0.013603421617299327, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2286746200537309, "loser_reward": -0.2879610859546811, "reward_margin": 0.059286465900950214, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2286746200537309, "loser_reward": -0.3089756306647324, "reward_margin": 0.08030101061100148, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22914031518762928, "loser_reward": -0.24227804167103023, "reward_margin": 0.013137726483400947, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22914031518762928, "loser_reward": -0.2879610859546811, "reward_margin": 0.05882077076705183, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22914031518762928, "loser_reward": -0.3089756306647324, "reward_margin": 0.0798353154771031, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24227804167103023, "loser_reward": -0.2879610859546811, "reward_margin": 0.04568304428365089, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24227804167103023, "loser_reward": -0.3089756306647324, "reward_margin": 0.06669758899370215, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "203920_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2879610859546811, "loser_reward": -0.3089756306647324, "reward_margin": 0.021014544710051264, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/203920_1/203920_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14630432426929474, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.44523346424102783, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010660728439688683, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8905366063117981, "background_mse_to_target": 0.010167533531785011, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04364847019314766, "input_change_l1": 0.07860050350427628, "directional_pixel_score": 0.587973915040493, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07191792558878661, "edit_score": 0.3602641526609659, "background_score": 0.03255340717732906, "combined_score": 0.3904062773101032, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/203920_1/203920_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12724651396274567, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.519568681716919, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01318968553096056, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8630352020263672, "background_mse_to_target": 0.013292999006807804, "full_mse_to_target": 0.041318271309137344, "input_change_l1": 0.06124785542488098, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6593588888645172, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.062427248898893596, "edit_score": 0.3084930554032326, "background_score": 0.04058264512568713, "combined_score": 0.33931425810791555, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/203920_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1278250515460968, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5087456107139587, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005572642665356398, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.908207893371582, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0059731705114245415, "full_mse_to_target": 0.035940926522016525, "input_change_l1": 0.03981109336018562, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6593585908412933, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04070801665075124, "edit_score": 0.31123628169298173, "background_score": 0.023931063991039992, "combined_score": 0.33134785007219764, "confidence": 0.5921365300556823}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/203920_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1292000561952591, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4646611213684082, "background_mse_to_source": 0.019762394949793816, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8366865515708923, "background_mse_to_target": 0.019675569608807564, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04661157727241516, "input_change_l1": 0.07591952383518219, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6602910310029984, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07564771911129356, "edit_score": 0.3211950741708279, "background_score": 0.05242508463561535, "combined_score": 0.3593345553427935, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/203920_1/203920_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15024560689926147, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4439435303211212, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0178780946880579, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7990675568580627, "background_mse_to_target": 0.017083218321204185, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04983264207839966, "input_change_l1": 0.07368189841508865, "directional_pixel_score": 0.44076045602560043, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03158926456235349, "edit_score": 0.40126678682863715, "background_score": 0.05806458331644535, "combined_score": 0.4328905081097037, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/203920_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/203920_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/203920_1.json"}

204837_1

Have one of the children be blowing bubbles

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.04878000169992447, "dataset_mask_area": 0.04878, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.17045633494853973, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.010133618488907814, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.16032271645963192, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6159305493948419, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.7304975199158275, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4024392366409302, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.26345428318364605, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.012352991482439393, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.24702384349599016, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.015294386073946953, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.17045634984970093, "edit_change_ratio": 0.08972611514579952, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.16005520522594452, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9389805974788996}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.08016400039196014, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/204837_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_aggressive": 0.5012026429176331, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.49879729747772217}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.15084134896541943, "reward": -0.15084134896541943}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.15108188557752872, "reward": -0.15108188557752872}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.15130702252872286, "reward": -0.15130702252872286}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.16815232583694156, "reward": -0.16815232583694156}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.26075410209968686, "reward": -0.26075410209968686}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15084134896541943, "loser_reward": -0.16815232583694156, "reward_margin": 0.017310976871522138, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15084134896541943, "loser_reward": -0.26075410209968686, "reward_margin": 0.10991275313426743, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15108188557752872, "loser_reward": -0.16815232583694156, "reward_margin": 0.017070440259412845, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15108188557752872, "loser_reward": -0.26075410209968686, "reward_margin": 0.10967221652215814, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15130702252872286, "loser_reward": -0.16815232583694156, "reward_margin": 0.016845303308218706, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15130702252872286, "loser_reward": -0.26075410209968686, "reward_margin": 0.109447079570964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16815232583694156, "loser_reward": -0.26075410209968686, "reward_margin": 0.0926017762627453, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 12195, "bbox_xyxy": [211, 152, 396, 287], "component_score": 0.15084134896541943, "component_reward": -0.15084134896541943, "second_component_score": 0.15108188557752872, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.00024053661210929334, "confidence": 0.5528657302790189}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5528658628463745, "teacher_quality_score": 0.012352991482439393, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.012352991482439393, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15084134896541943, "loser_reward": -0.16815232583694156, "reward_margin": 0.017310976871522138, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15084134896541943, "loser_reward": -0.26075410209968686, "reward_margin": 0.10991275313426743, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15108188557752872, "loser_reward": -0.16815232583694156, "reward_margin": 0.017070440259412845, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15108188557752872, "loser_reward": -0.26075410209968686, "reward_margin": 0.10967221652215814, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15130702252872286, "loser_reward": -0.16815232583694156, "reward_margin": 0.016845303308218706, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15130702252872286, "loser_reward": -0.26075410209968686, "reward_margin": 0.109447079570964, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204837_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16815232583694156, "loser_reward": -0.26075410209968686, "reward_margin": 0.0926017762627453, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/204837_1/204837_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11861461400985718, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6267943382263184, "background_mse_to_source": 0.05008161813020706, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.45021191239356995, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04960926994681358, "full_mse_to_target": 0.052975352853536606, "input_change_l1": 0.16271618008613586, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5724019482731819, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.17213750146329404, "edit_score": 0.30015525929629805, "background_score": 0.16003923565149308, "combined_score": 0.39589402735233303, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/204837_1/204837_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05707620829343796, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6914169192314148, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0011994985397905111, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9876973032951355, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0015909535577520728, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0042975242249667645, "input_change_l1": 0.012778697535395622, "directional_pixel_score": 0.49206027016043663, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.016950126504525542, "edit_score": 0.24577775690704584, "background_score": 0.0036600378807634115, "combined_score": 0.2508785478887148, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/204837_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.055327337235212326, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6927475929260254, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0005067880847491324, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9926139712333679, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0009619074990041554, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0036138524301350117, "input_change_l1": 0.008306151255965233, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4920602571219206, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.011026530200615524, "edit_score": 0.2437627543695271, "background_score": 0.0019839938380755485, "combined_score": 0.24702384349599016, "confidence": 0.5776219068787718}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/204837_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05805016681551933, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.690639317035675, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0014917770167812705, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9842918515205383, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0018382673151791096, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004580283537507057, "input_change_l1": 0.015695888549089432, "directional_pixel_score": 0.4949995372444391, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.02040521069429815, "edit_score": 0.24617241909727455, "background_score": 0.004633406712673605, "combined_score": 0.25233318193932064, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/204837_1/204837_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06146908923983574, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6627972722053528, "background_mse_to_source": 0.010600164532661438, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6898303031921387, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01014157198369503, "full_mse_to_target": 0.012645329348742962, "input_change_l1": 0.07217592746019363, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6153653189539909, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0729781111702323, "edit_score": 0.22506830506026745, "background_score": 0.0726341038942337, "combined_score": 0.26635039659217, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/204837_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/204837_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/204837_1.json"}

204863_1

Have the man be wearing a kilt

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.07985600084066391, "dataset_mask_area": 0.079856, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.19743074476718903, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.017653990536928177, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.17977675423026085, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.5892700087950747, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.6447553482863276, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.3966466784477234, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.2762793692171229, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.21778917920732058, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.23071316744666548, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.14579583704471588, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.19743074476718903, "edit_change_ratio": 0.7384657197977894, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.10834400355815887, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/204863_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.6354290843009949, "qwen_image_edit": 0.3645709156990051}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.15004018482659012, "reward": -0.15004018482659012}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.17781914997287096, "reward": -0.17781914997287096}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.19808702952601015, "reward": -0.19808702952601015}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.22026930463872849, "reward": -0.22026930463872849}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.32580033747851844, "reward": -0.32580033747851844}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15004018482659012, "loser_reward": -0.17781914997287096, "reward_margin": 0.027778965146280837, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15004018482659012, "loser_reward": -0.19808702952601015, "reward_margin": 0.04804684469942003, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15004018482659012, "loser_reward": -0.22026930463872849, "reward_margin": 0.07022911981213836, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15004018482659012, "loser_reward": -0.32580033747851844, "reward_margin": 0.17576015265192832, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17781914997287096, "loser_reward": -0.19808702952601015, "reward_margin": 0.02026787955313919, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17781914997287096, "loser_reward": -0.22026930463872849, "reward_margin": 0.042450154665857526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17781914997287096, "loser_reward": -0.32580033747851844, "reward_margin": 0.14798118750564748, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19808702952601015, "loser_reward": -0.22026930463872849, "reward_margin": 0.022182275112718336, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19808702952601015, "loser_reward": -0.32580033747851844, "reward_margin": 0.1277133079525083, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22026930463872849, "loser_reward": -0.32580033747851844, "reward_margin": 0.10553103283978996, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 19964, "bbox_xyxy": [210, 328, 374, 492], "component_score": 0.15004018482659012, "component_reward": -0.15004018482659012, "second_component_score": 0.17781914997287096, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.027778965146280837, "confidence": 0.7995328414707757}], "teacher_confidence": 0.7995328307151794, "teacher_quality_score": 0.21778917920732058, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.21778917920732058, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.15004018482659012, "loser_reward": -0.17781914997287096, "reward_margin": 0.027778965146280837, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.15004018482659012, "loser_reward": -0.19808702952601015, "reward_margin": 0.04804684469942003, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15004018482659012, "loser_reward": -0.22026930463872849, "reward_margin": 0.07022911981213836, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15004018482659012, "loser_reward": -0.32580033747851844, "reward_margin": 0.17576015265192832, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.17781914997287096, "loser_reward": -0.19808702952601015, "reward_margin": 0.02026787955313919, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.17781914997287096, "loser_reward": -0.22026930463872849, "reward_margin": 0.042450154665857526, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.17781914997287096, "loser_reward": -0.32580033747851844, "reward_margin": 0.14798118750564748, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.19808702952601015, "loser_reward": -0.22026930463872849, "reward_margin": 0.022182275112718336, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.19808702952601015, "loser_reward": -0.32580033747851844, "reward_margin": 0.1277133079525083, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "204863_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22026930463872849, "loser_reward": -0.32580033747851844, "reward_margin": 0.10553103283978996, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/204863_1/204863_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14578919112682343, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.35812750458717346, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04960513114929199, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5745394825935364, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04682983085513115, "full_mse_to_target": 0.054732322692871094, "input_change_l1": 0.1680203080177307, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5592742189764977, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1574926756322384, "edit_score": 0.38434513546526433, "background_score": 0.13469723463058472, "combined_score": 0.46846093498170377, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/204863_1/204863_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06335698813199997, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.40779808163642883, "background_mse_to_source": 0.002043815329670906, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.981816291809082, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0024307691492140293, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0072960932739079, "input_change_l1": 0.037532102316617966, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7815933525562286, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09528771247714757, "edit_score": 0.23639903366565707, "background_score": 0.0056805569678544995, "combined_score": 0.25817438042722646, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/204863_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.04426709562540054, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.41039249300956726, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0008635115809738636, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9902181625366211, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0014835222391411662, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004900046624243259, "input_change_l1": 0.024395862594246864, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7815933227539062, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06222969386726618, "edit_score": 0.21679026633501053, "background_score": 0.002819879073649645, "combined_score": 0.23071316744666548, "confidence": 0.7306869579794907}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/204863_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07472579181194305, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.37393394112586975, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0029060421511530876, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9772744178771973, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0031245616264641285, "full_mse_to_target": 0.008842349983751774, "input_change_l1": 0.04482322931289673, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7813496887683868, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.11036947220563889, "edit_score": 0.25460158139467237, "background_score": 0.007451158575713635, "combined_score": 0.2801676163356751, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/204863_1/204863_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06612487137317657, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3935360908508301, "background_mse_to_source": 0.053687021136283875, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6043253540992737, "background_mse_to_target": 0.05103112757205963, "full_mse_to_target": 0.05223646014928818, "input_change_l1": 0.14241373538970947, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5558666959404945, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07227749805897474, "edit_score": 0.29845097921788694, "background_score": 0.13282195031642913, "combined_score": 0.3646178074553609, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/204863_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/204863_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/204863_1.json"}

205344_1

let the kid sleep

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.030772000551223755, "dataset_mask_area": 0.030772, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.20413261651992798, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.006090723443776369, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.1980418930761516, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.6947344785000561, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8359902728992165, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5236624479293823, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.31484964141212696, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.20053633499446735, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.21256959702819586, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.09139300137758255, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.20413261651992798, "edit_change_ratio": 0.44771385844976186, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.04879999905824661, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/205344_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5373460650444031, "qwen_image_edit": 0.46265390515327454}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.13192363336356355, "reward": -0.13192363336356355}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1394067785460502, "reward": -0.1394067785460502}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1586612825272605, "reward": -0.1586612825272605}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.20492805794952437, "reward": -0.20492805794952437}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.21662771239317952, "reward": -0.21662771239317952}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13192363336356355, "loser_reward": -0.1586612825272605, "reward_margin": 0.026737649163696947, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13192363336356355, "loser_reward": -0.20492805794952437, "reward_margin": 0.07300442458596082, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13192363336356355, "loser_reward": -0.21662771239317952, "reward_margin": 0.08470407902961596, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1394067785460502, "loser_reward": -0.1586612825272605, "reward_margin": 0.019254503981210314, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1394067785460502, "loser_reward": -0.20492805794952437, "reward_margin": 0.06552127940347419, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1394067785460502, "loser_reward": -0.21662771239317952, "reward_margin": 0.07722093384712933, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1586612825272605, "loser_reward": -0.20492805794952437, "reward_margin": 0.04626677542226387, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1586612825272605, "loser_reward": -0.21662771239317952, "reward_margin": 0.05796642986591902, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20492805794952437, "loser_reward": -0.21662771239317952, "reward_margin": 0.011699654443655144, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 7693, "bbox_xyxy": [7, 211, 133, 313], "component_score": 0.13192363336356355, "component_reward": -0.13192363336356355, "second_component_score": 0.1394067785460502, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0074831451824866335, "confidence": 0.6451633186920362}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6451634168624878, "teacher_quality_score": 0.20053633499446735, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.20053633499446735, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.13192363336356355, "loser_reward": -0.1586612825272605, "reward_margin": 0.026737649163696947, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.13192363336356355, "loser_reward": -0.20492805794952437, "reward_margin": 0.07300442458596082, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.13192363336356355, "loser_reward": -0.21662771239317952, "reward_margin": 0.08470407902961596, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1394067785460502, "loser_reward": -0.1586612825272605, "reward_margin": 0.019254503981210314, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1394067785460502, "loser_reward": -0.20492805794952437, "reward_margin": 0.06552127940347419, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1394067785460502, "loser_reward": -0.21662771239317952, "reward_margin": 0.07722093384712933, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1586612825272605, "loser_reward": -0.20492805794952437, "reward_margin": 0.04626677542226387, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1586612825272605, "loser_reward": -0.21662771239317952, "reward_margin": 0.05796642986591902, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.20492805794952437, "loser_reward": -0.21662771239317952, "reward_margin": 0.011699654443655144, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_1/205344_1/205344_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08042701333761215, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5266309380531311, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0032084521371871233, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9284782409667969, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0031063815113157034, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005485690664499998, "input_change_l1": 0.03754241019487381, "directional_pixel_score": 0.575811006128788, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.04840590935200453, "edit_score": 0.28114807419478893, "background_score": 0.01751280394382775, "combined_score": 0.29750730651197954, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_1/205344_1/205344_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.059889424592256546, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.6160048842430115, "background_mse_to_source": 0.006006219889968634, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9465945363044739, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006201779469847679, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007853854447603226, "input_change_l1": 0.024588733911514282, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7454988807439804, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06624117465689779, "edit_score": 0.20031372755765914, "background_score": 0.016687312629073858, "combined_score": 0.22018790735397487, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/205344_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.05414004251360893, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5888635516166687, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0025376277044415474, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9633660316467285, "background_mse_to_target": 0.002788721350952983, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0043689049780368805, "input_change_l1": 0.015982676297426224, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7454986721277237, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.043437474453821776, "edit_score": 0.19999266415834427, "background_score": 0.009864421375095845, "combined_score": 0.21256959702819586, "confidence": 0.6118838294902488}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/205344_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.0700874775648117, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5821274518966675, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009242262691259384, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9364025592803955, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009398565627634525, "full_mse_to_target": 0.011266086250543594, "input_change_l1": 0.030631737783551216, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7449746280908585, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08155297813937068, "edit_score": 0.2174183301627636, "background_score": 0.02196175083518028, "combined_score": 0.24254214720800518, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_1/205344_1/205344_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08099055290222168, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5193552374839783, "background_mse_to_source": 0.009643279016017914, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7700550556182861, "background_mse_to_target": 0.009381859563291073, "full_mse_to_target": 0.011585402302443981, "input_change_l1": 0.06441318988800049, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6034667640924454, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09832195732742549, "edit_score": 0.2762528143823147, "background_score": 0.05563226789236069, "combined_score": 0.31654703984037047, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/205344_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/205344_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/205344_1.json"}

205344_2

give the person a bowl

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.00742340087890625, "dataset_mask_area": 0.00742340087890625, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2598177194595337, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.00017454280168749392, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2596431766578462, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8628213166144201, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9729920814479638, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5321948528289795, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.40210141790949516, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.019041192831637088, "best_expert": "editar", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3146645647427067, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.047582607716321945, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2598177194595337, "edit_change_ratio": 0.18313842418177673, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.23858310282230377, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9182710991328781}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.012960433959960938, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/205344_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "editar", "soft_weights": {"editar": 0.5190392732620239, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.4809606969356537}, "ranking": [{"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.22415087611321363, "reward": -0.22415087611321363}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22796058316912962, "reward": -0.22796058316912962}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2291172599417914, "reward": -0.2291172599417914}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2293322059165221, "reward": -0.2293322059165221}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.2435823718449101, "reward": -0.2435823718449101}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "205344_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22415087611321363, "loser_reward": -0.2435823718449101, "reward_margin": 0.019431495731696474, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22796058316912962, "loser_reward": -0.2435823718449101, "reward_margin": 0.015621788675780485, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2291172599417914, "loser_reward": -0.2435823718449101, "reward_margin": 0.014465111903118694, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2293322059165221, "loser_reward": -0.2435823718449101, "reward_margin": 0.014250165928388014, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 7784, "bbox_xyxy": [305, 432, 462, 529], "component_score": 0.22415087611321363, "component_reward": -0.22415087611321363, "second_component_score": 0.22796058316912962, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0038097070559159896, "confidence": 0.5800371007716041}], "teacher_confidence": 0.5800371170043945, "teacher_quality_score": 0.019041192831637088, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.019041192831637088, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "205344_2__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22415087611321363, "loser_reward": -0.2435823718449101, "reward_margin": 0.019431495731696474, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22796058316912962, "loser_reward": -0.2435823718449101, "reward_margin": 0.015621788675780485, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2291172599417914, "loser_reward": -0.2435823718449101, "reward_margin": 0.014465111903118694, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "205344_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2293322059165221, "loser_reward": -0.2435823718449101, "reward_margin": 0.014250165928388014, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/205344_2/205344_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11320803314447403, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5224480032920837, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012334787286818027, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7933406233787537, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01233226153999567, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013081100769340992, "input_change_l1": 0.05998672917485237, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6399935483932495, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.09268353069201113, "edit_score": 0.2987200453877449, "background_score": 0.0536666626110673, "combined_score": 0.3373481935169548, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/205344_2/205344_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11217843741178513, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5454961657524109, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00022285022714640945, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9925163388252258, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00023094956122804433, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0010619808454066515, "input_change_l1": 0.008911550976336002, "directional_pixel_score": 0.48172833397984505, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.031242498336359857, "edit_score": 0.3326471207663417, "background_score": 0.0017195824621012434, "combined_score": 0.33960367237988975, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/205344_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1089286133646965, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5490962862968445, "background_mse_to_source": 9.41542093642056e-05, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9967989325523376, "background_mse_to_target": 0.000101552861451637, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0009094197303056717, "input_change_l1": 0.005792500916868448, "directional_pixel_score": 0.481728320941329, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.020330990920774637, "edit_score": 0.32867727586999534, "background_score": 0.0007343676988966763, "combined_score": 0.3330914447217947, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/205344_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11496938019990921, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5430508255958557, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00034584442619234324, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9884890913963318, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0003545367217157036, "full_mse_to_target": 0.001205368316732347, "input_change_l1": 0.011113827116787434, "directional_pixel_score": 0.48149763606488705, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03850168660283089, "edit_score": 0.3359848060645163, "background_score": 0.002648026146925986, "combined_score": 0.3447324893681798, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/205344_2/205344_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.10382038354873657, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.536828339099884, "background_mse_to_source": 0.006873392034322023, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8210503458976746, "background_mse_to_target": 0.006875693332403898, "full_mse_to_target": 0.007595354691147804, "input_change_l1": 0.0514264851808548, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6390843838453293, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06144623253494501, "edit_score": 0.28668361976742746, "background_score": 0.04266332285478711, "combined_score": 0.3146645647427067, "confidence": 0.647983305829874}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/205344_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/205344_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/205344_2.json"}

206622_1

Remove the car.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.08766800165176392, "dataset_mask_area": 0.087668, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.29659971594810486, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.010628162883222103, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.28597155306488276, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8451129739160036, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9261366285847517, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.4790113866329193, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.42443057507819326, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.20126610106424778, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.246795238154009, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.18500547111034393, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.29659974575042725, "edit_change_ratio": 0.6237546517184681, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.11890000104904175, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/206622_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5514377355575562, "qwen_image_edit": 0.44856226444244385}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1590800325516611, "reward": -0.1590800325516611}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1694040999691933, "reward": -0.1694040999691933}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1888863925486803, "reward": -0.1888863925486803}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.21041192008554935, "reward": -0.21041192008554935}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.2998348423689604, "reward": -0.2998348423689604}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1590800325516611, "loser_reward": -0.1694040999691933, "reward_margin": 0.010324067417532223, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1590800325516611, "loser_reward": -0.1888863925486803, "reward_margin": 0.02980635999701922, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1590800325516611, "loser_reward": -0.21041192008554935, "reward_margin": 0.05133188753388826, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1590800325516611, "loser_reward": -0.2998348423689604, "reward_margin": 0.14075480981729932, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1694040999691933, "loser_reward": -0.1888863925486803, "reward_margin": 0.019482292579487, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1694040999691933, "loser_reward": -0.21041192008554935, "reward_margin": 0.041007820116356036, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1694040999691933, "loser_reward": -0.2998348423689604, "reward_margin": 0.1304307423997671, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1888863925486803, "loser_reward": -0.21041192008554935, "reward_margin": 0.021525527536869038, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1888863925486803, "loser_reward": -0.2998348423689604, "reward_margin": 0.1109484498202801, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21041192008554935, "loser_reward": -0.2998348423689604, "reward_margin": 0.08942292228341106, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 21917, "bbox_xyxy": [10, 295, 278, 438], "component_score": 0.1590800325516611, "component_reward": -0.1590800325516611, "second_component_score": 0.1694040999691933, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.010324067417532223, "confidence": 0.6575756324199099}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6575756072998047, "teacher_quality_score": 0.20126610106424778, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.20126610106424778, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.1590800325516611, "loser_reward": -0.1694040999691933, "reward_margin": 0.010324067417532223, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1590800325516611, "loser_reward": -0.1888863925486803, "reward_margin": 0.02980635999701922, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1590800325516611, "loser_reward": -0.21041192008554935, "reward_margin": 0.05133188753388826, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1590800325516611, "loser_reward": -0.2998348423689604, "reward_margin": 0.14075480981729932, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1694040999691933, "loser_reward": -0.1888863925486803, "reward_margin": 0.019482292579487, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1694040999691933, "loser_reward": -0.21041192008554935, "reward_margin": 0.041007820116356036, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1694040999691933, "loser_reward": -0.2998348423689604, "reward_margin": 0.1304307423997671, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1888863925486803, "loser_reward": -0.21041192008554935, "reward_margin": 0.021525527536869038, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1888863925486803, "loser_reward": -0.2998348423689604, "reward_margin": 0.1109484498202801, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_1__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.21041192008554935, "loser_reward": -0.2998348423689604, "reward_margin": 0.08942292228341106, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/206622_1/206622_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.09149093180894852, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5253867506980896, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01151819434016943, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.7388955950737, "background_mse_to_target": 0.01068124920129776, "full_mse_to_target": 0.017765674740076065, "input_change_l1": 0.07603828608989716, "directional_pixel_score": 0.792049914598465, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10651278775185347, "edit_score": 0.23840110301971434, "background_score": 0.06373907532542944, "combined_score": 0.283788904407993, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/206622_1/206622_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06806742399930954, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5125548839569092, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03027397207915783, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.4312913417816162, "background_mse_to_target": 0.029271533712744713, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0326726920902729, "input_change_l1": 0.1294744610786438, "directional_pixel_score": 0.858747273683548, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13157072160393, "edit_score": 0.20086962878704073, "background_score": 0.1440157037228346, "combined_score": 0.28085653861984616, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/206622_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07152712345123291, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5283632874488831, "background_mse_to_source": 0.01279075350612402, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6886529326438904, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012339111417531967, "full_mse_to_target": 0.017528008669614792, "input_change_l1": 0.08415843546390533, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8587473034858704, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.08801869377493858, "edit_score": 0.20116764008998872, "background_score": 0.07506016697734594, "combined_score": 0.246795238154009, "confidence": 0.752645564465887}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/206622_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07727442681789398, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4926093518733978, "background_mse_to_source": 0.044706862419843674, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.3025648593902588, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04335474595427513, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04632841795682907, "input_change_l1": 0.1595061719417572, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8607158064842224, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15972065702080726, "edit_score": 0.2135736048221588, "background_score": 0.18419389054179192, "combined_score": 0.31461843971163034, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/206622_1/206622_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.15281495451927185, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.48876526951789856, "background_mse_to_source": 0.022340688854455948, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6045884490013123, "background_mse_to_target": 0.021330000832676888, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0328570194542408, "input_change_l1": 0.10636378079652786, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5443460270762444, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.1015093207359314, "edit_score": 0.36897539384663103, "background_score": 0.1014229990541935, "combined_score": 0.42806100960820914, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/206622_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/206622_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/206622_1.json"}

206622_2

Replace the sign with a stop sign.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.038669586181640625, "dataset_mask_area": 0.038669586181640625, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.25399690866470337, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0005690759280696511, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2534278327366337, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8510554487105221, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9336773603131832, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5085462331771851, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3929015809944237, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+fallback_best_expert", "fusion_fallback": {"used": true, "reason": "fused_teacher_worse_than_best_expert", "fallback": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "teacher_combined_score": 0.33875821586450455, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.3322837993732537, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.10422895848751068, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.25399690866470337, "edit_change_ratio": 0.4103552245397656, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.04829597473144531, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/206622_2.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5927239656448364, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4072759747505188}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.22182173345348563, "reward": -0.22182173345348563}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.24058363032375926, "reward": -0.24058363032375926}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.2546958206736017, "reward": -0.2546958206736017}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.25880625219456854, "reward": -0.25880625219456854}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.3135766454543918, "reward": -0.3135766454543918}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22182173345348563, "loser_reward": -0.24058363032375926, "reward_margin": 0.01876189687027363, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22182173345348563, "loser_reward": -0.2546958206736017, "reward_margin": 0.03287408722011606, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22182173345348563, "loser_reward": -0.25880625219456854, "reward_margin": 0.03698451874108291, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22182173345348563, "loser_reward": -0.3135766454543918, "reward_margin": 0.09175491200090616, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24058363032375926, "loser_reward": -0.2546958206736017, "reward_margin": 0.01411219034984243, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24058363032375926, "loser_reward": -0.25880625219456854, "reward_margin": 0.01822262187080928, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24058363032375926, "loser_reward": -0.3135766454543918, "reward_margin": 0.07299301513063253, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2546958206736017, "loser_reward": -0.3135766454543918, "reward_margin": 0.0588808247807901, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.25880625219456854, "loser_reward": -0.3135766454543918, "reward_margin": 0.05477039325982325, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 40548, "bbox_xyxy": [592, 321, 826, 560], "component_score": 0.22182173345348563, "component_reward": -0.22182173345348563, "second_component_score": 0.24058363032375926, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.01876189687027363, "confidence": 0.6859902905172084}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6859902739524841, "teacher_quality_score": 0.33293667210222333, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.33293667210222333, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.22182173345348563, "loser_reward": -0.24058363032375926, "reward_margin": 0.01876189687027363, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.22182173345348563, "loser_reward": -0.2546958206736017, "reward_margin": 0.03287408722011606, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.22182173345348563, "loser_reward": -0.25880625219456854, "reward_margin": 0.03698451874108291, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.22182173345348563, "loser_reward": -0.3135766454543918, "reward_margin": 0.09175491200090616, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.24058363032375926, "loser_reward": -0.2546958206736017, "reward_margin": 0.01411219034984243, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.24058363032375926, "loser_reward": -0.25880625219456854, "reward_margin": 0.01822262187080928, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.24058363032375926, "loser_reward": -0.3135766454543918, "reward_margin": 0.07299301513063253, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2546958206736017, "loser_reward": -0.3135766454543918, "reward_margin": 0.0588808247807901, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_2__region0__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.25880625219456854, "loser_reward": -0.3135766454543918, "reward_margin": 0.05477039325982325, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_3/206622_2/206622_2_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11316689103841782, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.43752214312553406, "background_mse_to_source": 0.04306380823254585, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.547572135925293, "background_mse_to_target": 0.04305259883403778, "full_mse_to_target": 0.04576386883854866, "input_change_l1": 0.17313210666179657, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6588883846998215, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10628065969794989, "edit_score": 0.31094036623835564, "background_score": 0.13354938104748726, "combined_score": 0.38351516842842104, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_3/206622_2/206622_2_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12536898255348206, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.40178433060646057, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0004943796084262431, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9952115416526794, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00055076798889786, "full_mse_to_target": 0.005377436056733131, "input_change_l1": 0.01425056904554367, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5978192910552025, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.025041194492951033, "edit_score": 0.34555729366838933, "background_score": 0.0014520712778903545, "combined_score": 0.35161150111991446, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/206622_2_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11072532087564468, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.4146151840686798, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00020887530990876257, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9978694915771484, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00026738992892205715, "full_mse_to_target": 0.004538753069937229, "input_change_l1": 0.0092628700658679, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5978192016482353, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.016300992341712117, "edit_score": 0.3283474836498499, "background_score": 0.000634976994479075, "combined_score": 0.3322837993732537, "confidence": 0.6473797808479035}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/206622_2_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.136628195643425, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.3891812264919281, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0007533553289249539, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9929047226905823, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0008082230342552066, "full_mse_to_target": 0.006060324143618345, "input_change_l1": 0.017568478360772133, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6034716069698334, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.031008044024929404, "edit_score": 0.35792404860258104, "background_score": 0.002172410790808499, "combined_score": 0.36549203359871174, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_3/206622_2/206622_2_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1464240401983261, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.381232887506485, "background_mse_to_source": 0.018341459333896637, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.583794891834259, "background_mse_to_target": 0.018362928181886673, "full_mse_to_target": 0.023315006867051125, "input_change_l1": 0.1008804440498352, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5121452808380127, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.10576438512653112, "edit_score": 0.39214114248752596, "background_score": 0.10158248096704484, "combined_score": 0.451179388538003, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/206622_2.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/206622_2.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/206622_2.json"}

206622_3

Put a squirrel on top of the sign.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.010701179504394531, "dataset_mask_area": 0.010701179504394531, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2760303020477295, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.0003687256248667836, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2756615764228627, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.742135545094523, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.8212336695882255, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.5200861096382141, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.3975671886177345, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.1925500017060449, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.19854661905817925, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.17217788100242615, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2760303020477295, "edit_change_ratio": 0.623764419069665, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.016622543334960938, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/206622_3.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5385370254516602, "qwen_image_edit": 0.46146297454833984}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1355469280067482, "reward": -0.1355469280067482}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.14326964717629015, "reward": -0.14326964717629015}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.16009553459321615, "reward": -0.16009553459321615}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.27787429616693404, "reward": -0.27787429616693404}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3457857824433595, "reward": -0.3457857824433595}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1355469280067482, "loser_reward": -0.16009553459321615, "reward_margin": 0.024548606586467958, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1355469280067482, "loser_reward": -0.27787429616693404, "reward_margin": 0.14232736816018585, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1355469280067482, "loser_reward": -0.3457857824433595, "reward_margin": 0.2102388544366113, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14326964717629015, "loser_reward": -0.16009553459321615, "reward_margin": 0.016825887416926005, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14326964717629015, "loser_reward": -0.27787429616693404, "reward_margin": 0.1346046489906439, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14326964717629015, "loser_reward": -0.3457857824433595, "reward_margin": 0.20251613526706935, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16009553459321615, "loser_reward": -0.27787429616693404, "reward_margin": 0.11777876157371789, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16009553459321615, "loser_reward": -0.3457857824433595, "reward_margin": 0.18569024785014335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.27787429616693404, "loser_reward": -0.3457857824433595, "reward_margin": 0.06791148627642546, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 11221, "bbox_xyxy": [656, 209, 781, 351], "component_score": 0.1355469280067482, "component_reward": -0.1355469280067482, "second_component_score": 0.14326964717629015, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.007722719169541953, "confidence": 0.6455499578951044}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6455498933792114, "teacher_quality_score": 0.1925500017060449, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.1925500017060449, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.1355469280067482, "loser_reward": -0.16009553459321615, "reward_margin": 0.024548606586467958, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1355469280067482, "loser_reward": -0.27787429616693404, "reward_margin": 0.14232736816018585, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1355469280067482, "loser_reward": -0.3457857824433595, "reward_margin": 0.2102388544366113, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14326964717629015, "loser_reward": -0.16009553459321615, "reward_margin": 0.016825887416926005, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14326964717629015, "loser_reward": -0.27787429616693404, "reward_margin": 0.1346046489906439, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14326964717629015, "loser_reward": -0.3457857824433595, "reward_margin": 0.20251613526706935, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16009553459321615, "loser_reward": -0.27787429616693404, "reward_margin": 0.11777876157371789, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.16009553459321615, "loser_reward": -0.3457857824433595, "reward_margin": 0.18569024785014335, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "206622_3__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.27787429616693404, "loser_reward": -0.3457857824433595, "reward_margin": 0.06791148627642546, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_0/206622_3/206622_3_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.18685288727283478, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.49496397376060486, "background_mse_to_source": 0.07027854025363922, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.40978726744651794, "background_mse_to_target": 0.07027140259742737, "full_mse_to_target": 0.07151896506547928, "input_change_l1": 0.19603615999221802, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5961924716830254, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.16682967934757473, "edit_score": 0.3888119745999575, "background_score": 0.18832108676433562, "combined_score": 0.49524218734353775, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_0/206622_3/206622_3_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.07313007116317749, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5693033337593079, "background_mse_to_source": 0.00017534712969791144, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9966709613800049, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00021357469086069614, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0009938670555129647, "input_change_l1": 0.011223399080336094, "directional_pixel_score": 0.846884161233902, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03993524392135441, "edit_score": 0.19754836410284043, "background_score": 0.000841154853696935, "combined_score": 0.20592920379145654, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/206622_3_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.06936315447092056, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5726783871650696, "background_mse_to_source": 7.408412056975067e-05, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9985878467559814, "background_mse_to_target": 0.00011443989933468401, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0008554826490581036, "input_change_l1": 0.007295203860849142, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8468841016292572, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.026149194967001677, "edit_score": 0.19310645163059237, "background_score": 0.00035651476937346164, "combined_score": 0.19854661905817925, "confidence": 0.6140914688544246}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/206622_3_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.08579973876476288, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5566992163658142, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0002738771145232022, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9948150515556335, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0003105953801423311, "full_mse_to_target": 0.0012254298198968172, "input_change_l1": 0.013938804157078266, "directional_pixel_score": 0.8482378125190735, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.049500216636806725, "edit_score": 0.21240044236183167, "background_score": 0.0013108668033964932, "combined_score": 0.2228818320523715, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_0/206622_3/206622_3_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.14419962465763092, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5221138596534729, "background_mse_to_source": 0.012325732037425041, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6866991519927979, "background_mse_to_target": 0.012323909439146519, "full_mse_to_target": 0.013735134154558182, "input_change_l1": 0.07709788531064987, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5632529333233833, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.076524028647691, "edit_score": 0.3489636193960905, "background_score": 0.07498590163886547, "combined_score": 0.3918870041146874, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/206622_3.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/206622_3.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/206622_3.json"}

207833_1

Have a gorilla sit at the dinner table.

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.1291159987449646, "dataset_mask_area": 0.129116, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2751835584640503, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.01145736314356327, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.263726195320487, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.824410343847684, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9088089718689305, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.06, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.34147992730140686, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.39900779545696635, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback+underedit_fallback_canonical_target", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.016942168436653447, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.35606014531105756, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": true, "reason": "teacher_edit_change_too_low", "fallback": "canonical_target", "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.04297036677598953, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2751835584640503, "edit_change_ratio": 0.15615165025058406, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05, "teacher_edit_change_l1_after": 0.26552683115005493, "edit_change_ratio_after": 0.9649080513098427}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.18106399476528168, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/207833_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5863676071166992, "qwen_image_edit": 0.4136323928833008}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.23432577645080163, "reward": -0.23432577645080163}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.2517742462749593, "reward": -0.2517742462749593}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.253394162081182, "reward": -0.253394162081182}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.25742760065384207, "reward": -0.25742760065384207}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.26202522105677056, "reward": -0.26202522105677056}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "207833_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23432577645080163, "loser_reward": -0.2517742462749593, "reward_margin": 0.01744846982415768, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23432577645080163, "loser_reward": -0.253394162081182, "reward_margin": 0.019068385630380352, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23432577645080163, "loser_reward": -0.25742760065384207, "reward_margin": 0.02310182420304044, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23432577645080163, "loser_reward": -0.26202522105677056, "reward_margin": 0.02769944460596893, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2517742462749593, "loser_reward": -0.26202522105677056, "reward_margin": 0.01025097478181125, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 31203, "bbox_xyxy": [257, 247, 500, 487], "component_score": 0.23432577645080163, "component_reward": -0.23432577645080163, "second_component_score": 0.2517742462749593, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.01744846982415768, "confidence": 0.6716436303030998}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5192593336105347, "qwen_image_edit": 0.48074060678482056}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.1799899123838404, "reward": -0.1799899123838404}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.1838437014308292, "reward": -0.1838437014308292}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.18548529135435818, "reward": -0.18548529135435818}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.18618587865168224, "reward": -0.18618587865168224}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.21488156977482137, "reward": -0.21488156977482137}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "207833_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1799899123838404, "loser_reward": -0.21488156977482137, "reward_margin": 0.03489165739098096, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1838437014308292, "loser_reward": -0.21488156977482137, "reward_margin": 0.031037868343992164, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18548529135435818, "loser_reward": -0.21488156977482137, "reward_margin": 0.02939627842046319, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18618587865168224, "loser_reward": -0.21488156977482137, "reward_margin": 0.028695691123139133, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 1076, "bbox_xyxy": [373, 465, 500, 500], "component_score": 0.1799899123838404, "component_reward": -0.1799899123838404, "second_component_score": 0.1838437014308292, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.003853789046988798, "confidence": 0.5876439738134587}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6688435077667236, "teacher_quality_score": 0.016942168436653447, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.016942168436653447, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "207833_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.23432577645080163, "loser_reward": -0.2517742462749593, "reward_margin": 0.01744846982415768, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23432577645080163, "loser_reward": -0.253394162081182, "reward_margin": 0.019068385630380352, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23432577645080163, "loser_reward": -0.25742760065384207, "reward_margin": 0.02310182420304044, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23432577645080163, "loser_reward": -0.26202522105677056, "reward_margin": 0.02769944460596893, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2517742462749593, "loser_reward": -0.26202522105677056, "reward_margin": 0.01025097478181125, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1799899123838404, "loser_reward": -0.21488156977482137, "reward_margin": 0.03489165739098096, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1838437014308292, "loser_reward": -0.21488156977482137, "reward_margin": 0.031037868343992164, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region1__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18548529135435818, "loser_reward": -0.21488156977482137, "reward_margin": 0.02939627842046319, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "207833_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.18618587865168224, "loser_reward": -0.21488156977482137, "reward_margin": 0.028695691123139133, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/207833_1/207833_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13037718832492828, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.546623170375824, "background_mse_to_source": 0.03389008343219757, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6442970633506775, "background_mse_to_target": 0.033566914498806, "full_mse_to_target": 0.046066660434007645, "input_change_l1": 0.122623510658741, "directional_pixel_score": 0.60601557046175, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0774349758401513, "edit_score": 0.319548661634326, "background_score": 0.10503067076206207, "combined_score": 0.3764030576124787, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/207833_1/207833_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1472381353378296, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5449504256248474, "background_mse_to_source": 0.016000494360923767, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8624172210693359, "background_mse_to_target": 0.016375990584492683, "full_mse_to_target": 0.033272385597229004, "input_change_l1": 0.050050001591444016, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5355877466499805, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.03678037147037685, "edit_score": 0.35435111355036497, "background_score": 0.04351705014705658, "combined_score": 0.380265393955633, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/207833_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13544313609600067, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5567956566810608, "background_mse_to_source": 0.006760207004845142, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9101684093475342, "background_mse_to_target": 0.007239486090838909, "full_mse_to_target": 0.023792631924152374, "input_change_l1": 0.03253250941634178, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5355876907706261, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.024197581270709635, "edit_score": 0.340187082067132, "background_score": 0.024726525135338306, "combined_score": 0.35606014531105756, "confidence": 0.5657088225065469}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/207833_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.154427170753479, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5399033427238464, "background_mse_to_source": 0.021991802379488945, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.8448750376701355, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0223015695810318, "full_mse_to_target": 0.039361100643873215, "input_change_l1": 0.059765107929706573, "directional_pixel_score": 0.5354561172425747, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.044212998775765296, "edit_score": 0.36258247289806605, "background_score": 0.053016794845461845, "combined_score": 0.3939170609135181, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/207833_1/207833_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.12890233099460602, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5461690425872803, "background_mse_to_source": 0.014667242765426636, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6932968497276306, "background_mse_to_target": 0.014029551297426224, "full_mse_to_target": 0.02886146306991577, "input_change_l1": 0.08546934276819229, "directional_pixel_score": 0.6157651022076607, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.06990010291337967, "edit_score": 0.3157272469252348, "background_score": 0.07600787281990051, "combined_score": 0.3591961693018675, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/207833_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/207833_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/207833_1.json"}

209923_1

change the wooden cabinetry to steel

{"mask_source": "dataset_mask", "mask_strategy": "dataset_mask_calibrated_to_edit_region", "edit_mask_ratio": 0.25468799471855164, "dataset_mask_area": 0.254688, "dataset_mask_diff_inside": 0.2897060513496399, "dataset_mask_diff_outside": 0.017471985891461372, "dataset_mask_diff_separation": 0.2722340654581785, "dataset_mask_diff_iou": 0.8236058004472981, "dataset_mask_diff_recall": 0.9101781129909269, "dataset_mask_polarity": "target_diff_fallback", "dataset_mask_threshold": 0.07320261746644974, "dataset_mask_candidate": "target_diff_mask", "dataset_mask_calibrated": true, "dataset_mask_raw_mean": 0.2839718163013458, "dataset_mask_raw_min": 0.0, "dataset_mask_raw_max": 1.0, "dataset_mask_calibration_score": 0.4074738860314914, "valid_experts": ["editar", "pix2pix", "qwen_image_edit"], "missing_experts": [], "num_valid_experts": 3, "stage": "moe_fusion_teacher", "algorithm": "keepedit_plus_region_preference_calibrated_moe", "fusion_strategy": "region_preference_calibrated_soft_routing_laplacian_blend", "rank_calibrator": {"enabled": true, "expert_bias": {"qwen_image_edit*": -0.004, "pix2pix": 0.001, "editar": 0.001}, "edit_mse_weight": 0.0, "bg_mse_weight": 0.03, "direction_weight": 0.02, "boundary_weight": 0.05}, "fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather+local_refine_opencv_lama_fallback", "fusion_fallback": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_combined_score": 0.28695409505337016, "best_expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "best_expert_combined_score": 0.283849620699184, "epsilon": 0.005}, "underedit_safeguard": {"used": false, "reason": null, "fallback": null, "teacher_edit_change_l1": 0.1587720811367035, "target_edit_change_l1": 0.2897060811519623, "edit_change_ratio": 0.5480453862251558, "min_edit_change_ratio": 0.3, "min_target_edit_change": 0.05}, "local_refinement": {"enabled": true, "used": true, "provider": "opencv_lama_fallback", "model_id": null, "refine_full_edit_region": false, "mask_ratio": 0.3392679989337921, "method": "opencv_lama_fallback"}, "canonical_target_image": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/canonical_targets/209923_1.png", "canonical_fusion_method": "laplacian_pyramid_l5_feather", "selected_bg_expert": "source", "selected_edit_experts": [{"component_id": 0, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5793752074241638, "qwen_image_edit": 0.42062482237815857}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.2216001000094693, "reward": -0.2216001000094693}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.23761054148105906, "reward": -0.23761054148105906}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.26025909424200655, "reward": -0.26025909424200655}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.27858919176645575, "reward": -0.27858919176645575}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.3173309183064848, "reward": -0.3173309183064848}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2216001000094693, "loser_reward": -0.23761054148105906, "reward_margin": 0.016010441471589754, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2216001000094693, "loser_reward": -0.26025909424200655, "reward_margin": 0.03865899423253724, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2216001000094693, "loser_reward": -0.27858919176645575, "reward_margin": 0.05698909175698644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2216001000094693, "loser_reward": -0.3173309183064848, "reward_margin": 0.09573081829701549, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23761054148105906, "loser_reward": -0.26025909424200655, "reward_margin": 0.022648552760947488, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23761054148105906, "loser_reward": -0.27858919176645575, "reward_margin": 0.040978650285396684, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23761054148105906, "loser_reward": -0.3173309183064848, "reward_margin": 0.07972037682542574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.26025909424200655, "loser_reward": -0.27858919176645575, "reward_margin": 0.018330097524449196, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26025909424200655, "loser_reward": -0.3173309183064848, "reward_margin": 0.05707182406447825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.27858919176645575, "loser_reward": -0.3173309183064848, "reward_margin": 0.03874172654002905, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 60334, "bbox_xyxy": [109, 40, 500, 273], "component_score": 0.2216001000094693, "component_reward": -0.2216001000094693, "second_component_score": 0.23761054148105906, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.016010441471589754, "confidence": 0.6684318577584}, {"component_id": 1, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.591071605682373, "qwen_image_edit": 0.40892836451530457}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.12214277869346551, "reward": -0.12214277869346551}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.14056264479784294, "reward": -0.14056264479784294}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.1570824609734118, "reward": -0.1570824609734118}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.1817212415058166, "reward": -0.1817212415058166}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.18491006254591047, "reward": -0.18491006254591047}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12214277869346551, "loser_reward": -0.14056264479784294, "reward_margin": 0.01841986610437743, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12214277869346551, "loser_reward": -0.1570824609734118, "reward_margin": 0.03493968227994629, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12214277869346551, "loser_reward": -0.1817212415058166, "reward_margin": 0.059578462812351074, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12214277869346551, "loser_reward": -0.18491006254591047, "reward_margin": 0.06276728385244496, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14056264479784294, "loser_reward": -0.1570824609734118, "reward_margin": 0.016519816175568858, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14056264479784294, "loser_reward": -0.1817212415058166, "reward_margin": 0.041158596707973644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14056264479784294, "loser_reward": -0.18491006254591047, "reward_margin": 0.044347417748067525, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1570824609734118, "loser_reward": -0.1817212415058166, "reward_margin": 0.024638780532404786, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1570824609734118, "loser_reward": -0.18491006254591047, "reward_margin": 0.027827601572498667, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 2437, "bbox_xyxy": [100, 311, 225, 345], "component_score": 0.12214277869346551, "component_reward": -0.12214277869346551, "second_component_score": 0.14056264479784294, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.01841986610437743, "confidence": 0.7664121822736907}, {"component_id": 2, "expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "soft_weights": {"qwen_image_edit_conservative": 0.5311756730079651, "qwen_image_edit": 0.46882426738739014}, "ranking": [{"expert": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "component_score": 0.14565554768801667, "reward": -0.14565554768801667}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit", "component_score": 0.15189878902537748, "reward": -0.15189878902537748}, {"expert": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_score": 0.15623443386889993, "reward": -0.15623443386889993}, {"expert": "pix2pix", "component_score": 0.16968734621442855, "reward": -0.16968734621442855}, {"expert": "editar", "component_score": 0.21883783909864724, "reward": -0.21883783909864724}], "preference_pairs": [{"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14565554768801667, "loser_reward": -0.15623443386889993, "reward_margin": 0.010578886180883262, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14565554768801667, "loser_reward": -0.16968734621442855, "reward_margin": 0.02403179852641188, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14565554768801667, "loser_reward": -0.21883783909864724, "reward_margin": 0.07318229141063057, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15189878902537748, "loser_reward": -0.16968734621442855, "reward_margin": 0.017788557189051063, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15189878902537748, "loser_reward": -0.21883783909864724, "reward_margin": 0.06693905007326975, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15623443386889993, "loser_reward": -0.16968734621442855, "reward_margin": 0.013452912345528617, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15623443386889993, "loser_reward": -0.21883783909864724, "reward_margin": 0.0626034052297473, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16968734621442855, "loser_reward": -0.21883783909864724, "reward_margin": 0.04915049288421869, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "area": 901, "bbox_xyxy": [398, 312, 489, 330], "component_score": 0.14565554768801667, "component_reward": -0.14565554768801667, "second_component_score": 0.15189878902537748, "reward_margin_to_second": 0.0062432413373608164, "confidence": 0.6233229336685988}], "teacher_confidence": 0.6715437173843384, "teacher_quality_score": 0.28695409505337016, "teacher_quality_reward": -0.28695409505337016, "global_like": false, "soft_top_k": 2, "temperature": 0.05, "hard_route_confidence": 0.82, "region_preference_pairs": [{"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.2216001000094693, "loser_reward": -0.23761054148105906, "reward_margin": 0.016010441471589754, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.2216001000094693, "loser_reward": -0.26025909424200655, "reward_margin": 0.03865899423253724, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.2216001000094693, "loser_reward": -0.27858919176645575, "reward_margin": 0.05698909175698644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.2216001000094693, "loser_reward": -0.3173309183064848, "reward_margin": 0.09573081829701549, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.23761054148105906, "loser_reward": -0.26025909424200655, "reward_margin": 0.022648552760947488, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.23761054148105906, "loser_reward": -0.27858919176645575, "reward_margin": 0.040978650285396684, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.23761054148105906, "loser_reward": -0.3173309183064848, "reward_margin": 0.07972037682542574, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.26025909424200655, "loser_reward": -0.27858919176645575, "reward_margin": 0.018330097524449196, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.26025909424200655, "loser_reward": -0.3173309183064848, "reward_margin": 0.05707182406447825, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region0__editar_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 0, "winner": "editar", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.27858919176645575, "loser_reward": -0.3173309183064848, "reward_margin": 0.03874172654002905, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit", "winner_reward": -0.12214277869346551, "loser_reward": -0.14056264479784294, "reward_margin": 0.01841986610437743, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.12214277869346551, "loser_reward": -0.1570824609734118, "reward_margin": 0.03493968227994629, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.12214277869346551, "loser_reward": -0.1817212415058166, "reward_margin": 0.059578462812351074, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.12214277869346551, "loser_reward": -0.18491006254591047, "reward_margin": 0.06276728385244496, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14056264479784294, "loser_reward": -0.1570824609734118, "reward_margin": 0.016519816175568858, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14056264479784294, "loser_reward": -0.1817212415058166, "reward_margin": 0.041158596707973644, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14056264479784294, "loser_reward": -0.18491006254591047, "reward_margin": 0.044347417748067525, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.1570824609734118, "loser_reward": -0.1817212415058166, "reward_margin": 0.024638780532404786, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region1__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 1, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.1570824609734118, "loser_reward": -0.18491006254591047, "reward_margin": 0.027827601572498667, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "winner_reward": -0.14565554768801667, "loser_reward": -0.15623443386889993, "reward_margin": 0.010578886180883262, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.14565554768801667, "loser_reward": -0.16968734621442855, "reward_margin": 0.02403179852641188, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_conservative_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.14565554768801667, "loser_reward": -0.21883783909864724, "reward_margin": 0.07318229141063057, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15189878902537748, "loser_reward": -0.16968734621442855, "reward_margin": 0.017788557189051063, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15189878902537748, "loser_reward": -0.21883783909864724, "reward_margin": 0.06693905007326975, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_pix2pix", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "pix2pix", "winner_reward": -0.15623443386889993, "loser_reward": -0.16968734621442855, "reward_margin": 0.013452912345528617, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__qwen_image_edit_aggressive_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.15623443386889993, "loser_reward": -0.21883783909864724, "reward_margin": 0.0626034052297473, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}, {"id": "209923_1__region2__pix2pix_gt_editar", "component_id": 2, "winner": "pix2pix", "loser": "editar", "winner_reward": -0.16968734621442855, "loser_reward": -0.21883783909864724, "reward_margin": 0.04915049288421869, "pair_type": "region_expert_preference"}], "per_expert_scores": {"pix2pix": {"name": "pix2pix", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/pix2pix/_shards/out_2/209923_1/209923_1_pix2pix.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.1485750824213028, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5099018216133118, "background_mse_to_source": 0.06192426383495331, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.5591745972633362, "background_mse_to_target": 0.060626063495874405, "full_mse_to_target": 0.08302562683820724, "input_change_l1": 0.21359331905841827, "directional_pixel_score": 0.706144779920578, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.15296674463897944, "edit_score": 0.3200585231184959, "background_score": 0.15008934438228608, "combined_score": 0.41148570526391265, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit": {"name": "qwen_image_edit", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/qwen_image_edit/_shards/out_2/209923_1/209923_1_qwen_image_edit.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11790072917938232, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.51996248960495, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0032314921263605356, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9185575842857361, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0043609109707176685, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03327815979719162, "input_change_l1": 0.07889174669981003, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7531110644340515, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.07690760232508183, "edit_score": 0.27563046514987943, "background_score": 0.01951997526921332, "combined_score": 0.3011717929388396, "confidence": 0.5}, "qwen_image_edit_conservative": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_conservative", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/209923_1_qwen_image_edit_conservative.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11008515954017639, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5273024439811707, "background_mse_to_source": 0.0013653052737936378, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9427855610847473, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0026525913272053003, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03001438081264496, "input_change_l1": 0.051279619336128235, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7531111240386963, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.05009212656877935, "edit_score": 0.2663468897342682, "background_score": 0.012808193056844176, "combined_score": 0.283849620699184, "confidence": 0.6517399341974578}, "qwen_image_edit_aggressive": {"name": "qwen_image_edit_aggressive", "image_path": "/data/shiliangzhi/work-space/wyt/our_project/data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/images/virtual_experts/209923_1_qwen_image_edit_aggressive.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.13437195122241974, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5148224830627441, "background_mse_to_source": 0.005048219580203295, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.9037318229675293, "background_mse_to_target": 0.0060646552592515945, "full_mse_to_target": 0.03874299302697182, "input_change_l1": 0.09821802377700806, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7535309493541718, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.0958113525994122, "edit_score": 0.29302471727132795, "background_score": 0.024301854986697437, "combined_score": 0.32456693633925165, "confidence": 0.5}, "editar": {"name": "editar", "image_path": "data/candidates/magicbrush_dev_pix2pix_qwen_editar/_expert_runs/editar/_shards/out_2/209923_1/209923_1_editar.png", "edit_mse_to_target": 0.11971808969974518, "edit_ssim_to_target": 0.5061725378036499, "background_mse_to_source": 0.042397115379571915, "background_ssim_to_source": 0.6436215043067932, "background_mse_to_target": 0.041862163692712784, "full_mse_to_target": 0.06169113144278526, "input_change_l1": 0.17546679079532623, "directional_pixel_score": 0.7372084408998489, "boundary_artifact_score": 0.13642155323177577, "edit_score": 0.28418147191405296, "background_score": 0.11367281451821327, "combined_score": 0.3574203807860613, "confidence": 0.5}}, "attribution_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/attribution/209923_1.png", "confidence_map": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/confidence/209923_1.png", "scores_json": "data/teachers/magicbrush_dev_moe_fusion_compact_full_compact_fix_20260605_full/scores/209923_1.json"}