| { |
| "benchmark": "AED vs conventional Crystal — small-model comprehension", |
| "date": "2026-07-07", |
| "hypothesis": "AED-style Crystal ('reads like statements', per the premium template's aed-conventions skill) lets smaller models reason about and understand code intent better than conventional compressed style.", |
| "method": { |
| "pairs": 10, |
| "probes_per_variant": 3, |
| "probe_types": [ |
| "intent", |
| "modification", |
| "defect" |
| ], |
| "probe_descriptions": { |
| "intent": "Explain what the code does and why (business intent, not line-by-line).", |
| "modification": "Describe how to make a specified behavior change correctly.", |
| "defect": "A subtle behavioral question / planted-defect-style probe about an edge case." |
| }, |
| "answering_model": "Claude Haiku (answered blind: never told which style variant it was reading)", |
| "grading": "Graded blind by a model grader that never saw which style produced the answer. 0 = wrong/missed, 1 = partially correct, 2 = fully correct. Max 6 per variant per pair.", |
| "semantic_equivalence": "Each pair's two variants were verified behaviorally identical by a Crystal differential-test harness (scratchpad aed_bench/build_harness.py + tests.cr) that runs both variants against shared checks and diffs outputs.", |
| "runs": "Single run per probe (no repeats).", |
| "note": "Haiku's raw answer transcripts and the grader's rationales were not persisted; this file carries the full source of both variants per pair plus the graded scores, which is sufficient to re-run the probes." |
| }, |
| "aggregate": { |
| "aed_total": 60, |
| "conventional_total": 54, |
| "max_per_variant": 60 |
| }, |
| "per_probe_type_totals": { |
| "aed": { |
| "intent": 20, |
| "modification": 20, |
| "defect": 20 |
| }, |
| "conventional": { |
| "intent": 18, |
| "modification": 20, |
| "defect": 16 |
| }, |
| "max_per_cell": 20 |
| }, |
| "pairs": [ |
| { |
| "id": "p1-auth-mfa-routing", |
| "topic": "auth/session logic — post-password MFA routing and pending-challenge TTL", |
| "aed_source": "module Auth\n # Routes a user who has just passed the password check. The password is only\n # the FIRST factor: an MFA-enrolled regular user must verify a second factor\n # before a session is established. Admin accounts have no MFA flag here.\n module PostPasswordRouter\n MFA_PENDING_TTL_SECONDS = 300\n\n def self.next_step(user : Users::Regular | Users::Admin | Nil) : Symbol\n return :reject_login if user.nil?\n return :begin_mfa_challenge if second_factor_required?(user)\n\n :complete_login\n end\n\n # Only regular users can enroll in MFA in this template.\n def self.second_factor_required?(user : Users::Regular | Users::Admin) : Bool\n if user.is_a?(Users::Regular)\n user.mfa_enabled\n else\n false\n end\n end\n\n # A pending second factor is honored only inside the TTL window; a stale\n # challenge sends the user back to the password step. This bounds the\n # window an attacker has to guess codes.\n def self.mfa_challenge_still_valid?(pending_started_at : Int64?, now : Int64) : Bool\n return false if pending_started_at.nil?\n\n seconds_pending = now - pending_started_at\n seconds_pending <= MFA_PENDING_TTL_SECONDS\n end\n end\nend\n", |
| "conventional_source": "module Auth\n module PostPasswordRouter\n MFA_PENDING_TTL_SECONDS = 300\n\n def self.next_step(user : Users::Regular | Users::Admin | Nil) : Symbol\n return :reject_login unless user\n user.is_a?(Users::Regular) && user.mfa_enabled ? :begin_mfa_challenge : :complete_login\n end\n\n def self.second_factor_required?(user : Users::Regular | Users::Admin) : Bool\n user.is_a?(Users::Regular) ? user.mfa_enabled : false\n end\n\n def self.mfa_challenge_still_valid?(pending_started_at : Int64?, now : Int64) : Bool\n pending_started_at ? (now - pending_started_at) <= MFA_PENDING_TTL_SECONDS : false\n end\n end\nend\n" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "p2-lead-scoring", |
| "topic": "lead scoring — email-domain classification plus message-effort bonus", |
| "aed_source": "class LeadScorer\n BUSINESS_DOMAIN_BONUS = 25\n SUBSTANTIAL_MESSAGE_LEN = 120\n SUBSTANTIAL_MESSAGE_BONUS = 10\n\n FREE_PROVIDER_DOMAINS = %w[gmail.com yahoo.com outlook.com hotmail.com icloud.com proton.me]\n DISPOSABLE_DOMAINS = %w[mailinator.com guerrillamail.com yopmail.com temp-mail.org]\n\n # Triage score: business senders who write substantively float to the top.\n def self.score(email : String, message : String) : Int32\n domain_class = classify_domain(extract_domain(email))\n\n score = 0\n score += BUSINESS_DOMAIN_BONUS if domain_class == \"business\"\n score -= BUSINESS_DOMAIN_BONUS if domain_class == \"suspicious\"\n score += SUBSTANTIAL_MESSAGE_BONUS if substantial_message?(message)\n score\n end\n\n def self.classify_domain(domain : String) : String\n return \"unknown\" if domain.empty?\n return \"suspicious\" if DISPOSABLE_DOMAINS.includes?(domain)\n return \"free_provider\" if FREE_PROVIDER_DOMAINS.includes?(domain)\n return \"business\" if plausible_custom_domain?(domain)\n \"unknown\"\n end\n\n # A custom domain must contain a dot that is not at either end.\n def self.plausible_custom_domain?(domain : String) : Bool\n domain.includes?('.') && !domain.starts_with?('.') && !domain.ends_with?('.')\n end\n\n # A few sentences of detail is a real effort signal vs. a one-liner.\n def self.substantial_message?(message : String) : Bool\n message.strip.size >= SUBSTANTIAL_MESSAGE_LEN\n end\n\n def self.extract_domain(address : String) : String\n normalized = address.strip.downcase\n at_index = normalized.rindex('@')\n return \"\" unless at_index\n normalized[(at_index + 1)..].strip\n end\nend\n", |
| "conventional_source": "class LeadScorer\n BUSINESS_DOMAIN_BONUS = 25\n SUBSTANTIAL_MESSAGE_LEN = 120\n SUBSTANTIAL_MESSAGE_BONUS = 10\n\n FREE_PROVIDER_DOMAINS = %w[gmail.com yahoo.com outlook.com hotmail.com icloud.com proton.me]\n DISPOSABLE_DOMAINS = %w[mailinator.com guerrillamail.com yopmail.com temp-mail.org]\n\n def self.score(email : String, message : String) : Int32\n dc = classify_domain(extract_domain(email))\n base = dc == \"business\" ? BUSINESS_DOMAIN_BONUS : dc == \"suspicious\" ? -BUSINESS_DOMAIN_BONUS : 0\n base + (message.strip.size >= SUBSTANTIAL_MESSAGE_LEN ? SUBSTANTIAL_MESSAGE_BONUS : 0)\n end\n\n def self.classify_domain(domain : String) : String\n case\n when domain.empty? then \"unknown\"\n when DISPOSABLE_DOMAINS.includes?(domain) then \"suspicious\"\n when FREE_PROVIDER_DOMAINS.includes?(domain) then \"free_provider\"\n when domain.includes?('.') && !domain.starts_with?('.') && !domain.ends_with?('.') then \"business\"\n else \"unknown\"\n end\n end\n\n def self.extract_domain(address : String) : String\n a = address.strip.downcase\n (i = a.rindex('@')) ? a[(i + 1)..].strip : \"\"\n end\nend\n" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "p3-document-workflow", |
| "topic": "state transitions — document review workflow state machine", |
| "aed_source": "module Documents\n enum Status\n Draft\n InReview\n Approved\n Rejected\n Archived\n end\n\n # Review flow for client documents: a document moves strictly\n # draft -> in_review -> (approved | rejected). A rejected document returns\n # to draft for revision, only an approved document can be archived, and\n # archived is terminal, immutable history.\n module Workflow\n def self.transition_allowed?(from : Status, to : Status) : Bool\n allowed_destinations(from).includes?(to)\n end\n\n def self.allowed_destinations(from : Status) : Array(Status)\n if from.draft?\n [Status::InReview]\n elsif from.in_review?\n [Status::Approved, Status::Rejected]\n elsif from.rejected?\n [Status::Draft]\n elsif from.approved?\n [Status::Archived]\n else\n [] of Status\n end\n end\n\n def self.terminal?(status : Status) : Bool\n allowed_destinations(status).empty?\n end\n end\nend\n", |
| "conventional_source": "module Documents\n enum Status\n Draft\n InReview\n Approved\n Rejected\n Archived\n end\n\n module Workflow\n def self.transition_allowed?(from : Status, to : Status) : Bool\n allowed_destinations(from).includes?(to)\n end\n\n def self.allowed_destinations(from : Status) : Array(Status)\n case from\n in .draft? then [Status::InReview]\n in .in_review? then [Status::Approved, Status::Rejected]\n in .rejected? then [Status::Draft]\n in .approved? then [Status::Archived]\n in .archived? then [] of Status\n end\n end\n\n def self.terminal?(status : Status) : Bool\n allowed_destinations(status).empty?\n end\n end\nend\n" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "p4-storage-safe-delete", |
| "topic": "file/storage handling — path-safe delete with metadata sidecar", |
| "aed_source": "module Storage\n # Deletes an object and its metadata sidecar from the local disk store.\n # Refuses any key that could reach outside the storage root.\n class LocalObjectRemover\n getter root : String\n\n def initialize(@root : String)\n end\n\n def delete(key : String) : Bool\n return false unless safe_key?(key)\n\n path = File.join(root, key)\n return false unless File.exists?(path)\n\n File.delete(path)\n remove_metadata_sidecar(path)\n true\n rescue error\n Log.error { \"LocalObjectRemover.delete error: #{error.message}\" }\n false\n end\n\n # A key may not be empty, may not be absolute, and may not contain a\n # \"..\" segment — any of those could escape the storage root.\n def safe_key?(key : String) : Bool\n return false if key.empty?\n return false if key.starts_with?('/')\n return false if key.split('/').includes?(\"..\")\n true\n end\n\n # Content-type metadata lives in a \"<path>.meta\" sidecar written by put.\n private def remove_metadata_sidecar(path : String)\n meta_path = \"#{path}.meta\"\n File.delete(meta_path) if File.exists?(meta_path)\n end\n end\nend\n", |
| "conventional_source": "module Storage\n class LocalObjectRemover\n getter root : String\n\n def initialize(@root : String)\n end\n\n def delete(key : String) : Bool\n return false unless safe_key?(key)\n path = File.join(root, key)\n return false unless File.exists?(path)\n File.delete(path)\n File.delete(\"#{path}.meta\") if File.exists?(\"#{path}.meta\")\n true\n rescue e\n Log.error { \"LocalObjectRemover.delete error: #{e.message}\" }\n false\n end\n\n def safe_key?(key : String) : Bool\n !key.empty? && !key.starts_with?('/') && !key.split('/').includes?(\"..\")\n end\n end\nend\n" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "p5-rate-limiter", |
| "topic": "rate limiting — sliding-window per-IP submission ceiling", |
| "aed_source": "# Sliding-window, in-memory rate limit for the contact form: an IP may\n# submit at most MAX_SUBMISSIONS_PER_WINDOW times per rolling hour.\n# Requests without a usable IP are never limited — we fail open on purpose.\nclass SubmissionRateLimiter\n MAX_SUBMISSIONS_PER_WINDOW = 3\n WINDOW_SECONDS = 60 * 60\n\n def initialize\n @submission_times_by_ip = Hash(String, Array(Int64)).new\n @lock = Mutex.new\n end\n\n # Records this attempt, then reports whether the IP has now gone over the\n # ceiling. Every attempt is recorded, even ones that end up limited.\n def over_limit?(ip : String?, now : Int64) : Bool\n return false if ip.nil? || ip.empty?\n\n attempts_in_window = record_and_count(ip, now)\n attempts_in_window > MAX_SUBMISSIONS_PER_WINDOW\n end\n\n private def record_and_count(ip : String, now : Int64) : Int32\n window_start = now - WINDOW_SECONDS\n\n @lock.synchronize do\n recent_times = @submission_times_by_ip[ip]? || Array(Int64).new\n recent_times.reject! { |time| time < window_start }\n recent_times << now\n @submission_times_by_ip[ip] = recent_times\n recent_times.size\n end\n end\nend\n", |
| "conventional_source": "class SubmissionRateLimiter\n MAX_SUBMISSIONS_PER_WINDOW = 3\n WINDOW_SECONDS = 60 * 60\n\n def initialize\n @submission_times_by_ip = Hash(String, Array(Int64)).new\n @lock = Mutex.new\n end\n\n def over_limit?(ip : String?, now : Int64) : Bool\n return false unless ip && !ip.empty?\n window_start = now - WINDOW_SECONDS\n @lock.synchronize do\n times = (@submission_times_by_ip[ip] ||= [] of Int64)\n times.reject! { |t| t < window_start }\n times << now\n times.size > MAX_SUBMISSIONS_PER_WINDOW\n end\n end\nend\n" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "p6-retry-backoff", |
| "topic": "background scheduling — exponential retry backoff with dead-letter cutoff", |
| "aed_source": "module Jobs\n # Retry policy for failed background jobs: exponential backoff with a cap,\n # then dead-letter after the final attempt so a poison job cannot retry forever.\n module RetryPolicy\n MAX_ATTEMPTS = 8\n BASE_DELAY_SECONDS = 30\n MAX_DELAY_SECONDS = 600\n\n # attempts_made counts failures so far, including the one that just happened.\n def self.next_step(attempts_made : Int32) : {Symbol, Int32}\n return {:dead_letter, 0} if retries_exhausted?(attempts_made)\n\n {:retry, delay_before_next_attempt(attempts_made)}\n end\n\n def self.retries_exhausted?(attempts_made : Int32) : Bool\n attempts_made >= MAX_ATTEMPTS\n end\n\n # 30s, 60s, 120s ... doubling per failure, never above the ten-minute cap.\n def self.delay_before_next_attempt(attempts_made : Int32) : Int32\n uncapped_delay = BASE_DELAY_SECONDS * (2 ** (attempts_made - 1))\n if uncapped_delay > MAX_DELAY_SECONDS\n MAX_DELAY_SECONDS\n else\n uncapped_delay\n end\n end\n end\nend\n", |
| "conventional_source": "module Jobs\n module RetryPolicy\n MAX_ATTEMPTS = 8\n BASE_DELAY_SECONDS = 30\n MAX_DELAY_SECONDS = 600\n\n def self.next_step(attempts_made : Int32) : {Symbol, Int32}\n attempts_made >= MAX_ATTEMPTS ? {:dead_letter, 0} : {:retry, delay_before_next_attempt(attempts_made)}\n end\n\n def self.retries_exhausted?(attempts_made : Int32) : Bool\n attempts_made >= MAX_ATTEMPTS\n end\n\n def self.delay_before_next_attempt(attempts_made : Int32) : Int32\n Math.min(BASE_DELAY_SECONDS * (2 ** (attempts_made - 1)), MAX_DELAY_SECONDS)\n end\n end\nend\n" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "p7-inquiry-validation", |
| "topic": "validation — collect-all-errors form validation for inquiry submissions", |
| "aed_source": "# Field-level validation for the /stroll inquiry form. Returns every error\n# at once so the visitor can fix the whole form in one pass.\nclass InquiryValidator\n MIN_MESSAGE_LENGTH = 20\n MAX_MESSAGE_LENGTH = 5000\n\n getter name : String\n getter email : String\n getter message : String\n\n def initialize(@name : String, @email : String, @message : String)\n end\n\n def errors : Array(String)\n found = [] of String\n found << \"Name is required\" if name_is_blank?\n found << \"Email address does not look valid\" unless email_looks_deliverable?\n found << \"Message must be at least #{MIN_MESSAGE_LENGTH} characters\" if message_too_short?\n found << \"Message must be under #{MAX_MESSAGE_LENGTH} characters\" if message_too_long?\n found\n end\n\n def valid? : Bool\n errors.empty?\n end\n\n private def name_is_blank? : Bool\n name.strip.empty?\n end\n\n # Deliberately loose: just a \"local@domain.tld\" shape. Real deliverability\n # is judged later by the MX lookup in lead scoring.\n private def email_looks_deliverable? : Bool\n email.matches?(/\\A[^@\\s]+@[^@\\s]+\\.[^@\\s]+\\z/)\n end\n\n private def message_too_short? : Bool\n message.strip.size < MIN_MESSAGE_LENGTH\n end\n\n private def message_too_long? : Bool\n message.strip.size > MAX_MESSAGE_LENGTH\n end\nend\n", |
| "conventional_source": "class InquiryValidator\n MIN_MESSAGE_LENGTH = 20\n MAX_MESSAGE_LENGTH = 5000\n EMAIL_FORMAT = /\\A[^@\\s]+@[^@\\s]+\\.[^@\\s]+\\z/\n\n getter name : String\n getter email : String\n getter message : String\n\n def initialize(@name : String, @email : String, @message : String)\n end\n\n def errors : Array(String)\n e = [] of String\n e << \"Name is required\" if name.strip.empty?\n e << \"Email address does not look valid\" unless email.matches?(EMAIL_FORMAT)\n m = message.strip.size\n e << \"Message must be at least #{MIN_MESSAGE_LENGTH} characters\" if m < MIN_MESSAGE_LENGTH\n e << \"Message must be under #{MAX_MESSAGE_LENGTH} characters\" if m > MAX_MESSAGE_LENGTH\n e\n end\n\n def valid? : Bool\n errors.empty?\n end\nend\n" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "p8-rbac-document-policy", |
| "topic": "RBAC checks — admin/owner bypass plus org-role gated document actions", |
| "aed_source": "module Authorization\n # Access rules for client documents. Admins bypass all checks; a document's\n # owner has full control; organization members act by role — editors may\n # read and update, viewers may only read. Everyone else is denied.\n class DocumentPolicy\n getter user_id : Int64\n getter user_is_admin : Bool\n getter org_role : String?\n\n def initialize(@user_id : Int64, @user_is_admin : Bool, @org_role : String?)\n end\n\n def can?(action : Symbol, owner_id : Int64) : Bool\n return true if user_is_admin\n return true if owns_document?(owner_id)\n return can_act_as_editor?(action) if org_role == \"editor\"\n return action == :read if org_role == \"viewer\"\n\n false\n end\n\n private def owns_document?(owner_id : Int64) : Bool\n user_id == owner_id\n end\n\n # Editors may change content but never destroy it.\n private def can_act_as_editor?(action : Symbol) : Bool\n action == :read || action == :update\n end\n end\nend\n", |
| "conventional_source": "module Authorization\n class DocumentPolicy\n getter user_id : Int64\n getter user_is_admin : Bool\n getter org_role : String?\n\n def initialize(@user_id : Int64, @user_is_admin : Bool, @org_role : String?)\n end\n\n def can?(action : Symbol, owner_id : Int64) : Bool\n return true if user_is_admin || user_id == owner_id\n case org_role\n when \"editor\" then action == :read || action == :update\n when \"viewer\" then action == :read\n else false\n end\n end\n end\nend\n" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "p9-lead-badge-rendering", |
| "topic": "ECR-adjacent rendering — score-tier badge HTML with escaping", |
| "aed_source": "module Views\n # Renders the score badge shown beside each inquiry in the /stroll inbox.\n # Tiers make the score glanceable so hot leads float to the top of triage.\n module LeadBadge\n HOT_THRESHOLD = 40\n WARM_THRESHOLD = 15\n\n def self.tier(score : Int32) : String\n return \"hot\" if score >= HOT_THRESHOLD\n return \"warm\" if score >= WARM_THRESHOLD\n return \"cold\" if score >= 0\n \"junk\"\n end\n\n # The domain comes from user input, so it is HTML-escaped before it is\n # interpolated into markup.\n def self.badge_html(score : Int32, email_domain : String) : String\n badge_tier = tier(score)\n escaped_domain = HTML.escape(email_domain)\n\n String.build do |html|\n html << %(<span class=\"lead-badge lead-badge--#{badge_tier}\" data-score=\"#{score}\">)\n html << badge_tier.upcase\n html << \" · \"\n html << escaped_domain\n html << \"</span>\"\n end\n end\n end\nend\n", |
| "conventional_source": "module Views\n module LeadBadge\n HOT_THRESHOLD = 40\n WARM_THRESHOLD = 15\n\n def self.tier(score : Int32) : String\n score >= HOT_THRESHOLD ? \"hot\" : score >= WARM_THRESHOLD ? \"warm\" : score >= 0 ? \"cold\" : \"junk\"\n end\n\n def self.badge_html(score : Int32, email_domain : String) : String\n t = tier(score)\n %(<span class=\"lead-badge lead-badge--#{t}\" data-score=\"#{score}\">#{t.upcase} · #{HTML.escape(email_domain)}</span>)\n end\n end\nend\n" |
| }, |
| { |
| "id": "p10-mail-queue-triage", |
| "topic": "queue/status flow — outbound-mail worker triage with stale-lock reclaim", |
| "aed_source": "module Mailer\n # Decides what the queue worker should do with one outbound email row.\n # Pending mail goes out once its scheduled time arrives. A \"processing\" row\n # whose lock is older than the stale threshold belonged to a crashed worker\n # and is reclaimed; anything already sent or failed is left alone.\n module QueueTriage\n STALE_LOCK_SECONDS = 15 * 60\n\n def self.decision(status : String, scheduled_at : Int64, locked_at : Int64?, now : Int64) : Symbol\n if status == \"pending\"\n if due_for_delivery?(scheduled_at, now)\n return :deliver\n else\n return :not_due_yet\n end\n end\n\n if status == \"processing\"\n return :reclaim if lock_gone_stale?(locked_at, now)\n return :leave_alone\n end\n\n :leave_alone\n end\n\n def self.due_for_delivery?(scheduled_at : Int64, now : Int64) : Bool\n scheduled_at <= now\n end\n\n # A worker that dies mid-send leaves the row locked; after 15 minutes we\n # assume the worker is gone and give the row back to the queue.\n def self.lock_gone_stale?(locked_at : Int64?, now : Int64) : Bool\n return false if locked_at.nil?\n\n (now - locked_at) > STALE_LOCK_SECONDS\n end\n end\nend\n", |
| "conventional_source": "module Mailer\n module QueueTriage\n STALE_LOCK_SECONDS = 15 * 60\n\n def self.decision(status : String, scheduled_at : Int64, locked_at : Int64?, now : Int64) : Symbol\n case status\n when \"pending\" then scheduled_at <= now ? :deliver : :not_due_yet\n when \"processing\" then locked_at && (now - locked_at) > STALE_LOCK_SECONDS ? :reclaim : :leave_alone\n else :leave_alone\n end\n end\n\n def self.due_for_delivery?(scheduled_at : Int64, now : Int64) : Bool\n scheduled_at <= now\n end\n\n def self.lock_gone_stale?(locked_at : Int64?, now : Int64) : Bool\n locked_at ? (now - locked_at) > STALE_LOCK_SECONDS : false\n end\n end\nend\n" |
| } |
| ], |
| "scored_runs": [ |
| { |
| "pair": "p1-auth-mfa-routing", |
| "variant": "aed", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p1-auth-mfa-routing", |
| "variant": "conventional", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p2-lead-scoring", |
| "variant": "aed", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p2-lead-scoring", |
| "variant": "conventional", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p3-document-workflow", |
| "variant": "aed", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p3-document-workflow", |
| "variant": "conventional", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 1, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 0 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 3 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p4-storage-safe-delete", |
| "variant": "aed", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p4-storage-safe-delete", |
| "variant": "conventional", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p5-rate-limiter", |
| "variant": "aed", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p5-rate-limiter", |
| "variant": "conventional", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p6-retry-backoff", |
| "variant": "aed", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p6-retry-backoff", |
| "variant": "conventional", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p7-inquiry-validation", |
| "variant": "aed", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p7-inquiry-validation", |
| "variant": "conventional", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 1, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 5 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p8-rbac-document-policy", |
| "variant": "aed", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p8-rbac-document-policy", |
| "variant": "conventional", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p9-lead-badge-rendering", |
| "variant": "aed", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p9-lead-badge-rendering", |
| "variant": "conventional", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p10-mail-queue-triage", |
| "variant": "aed", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 2 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 6 |
| }, |
| { |
| "pair": "p10-mail-queue-triage", |
| "variant": "conventional", |
| "scores_by_probe": { |
| "intent": 2, |
| "modification": 2, |
| "defect": 0 |
| }, |
| "pair_total": 4 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
|
|
