old-code / agent_scoring_v2.py
agentpulse's picture
Upload 14 files
306ab7a verified
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
12.2 kB
"""
Agent Scoring V2 — based on real collected signals only.
Produces a composite score per agent from:
- Benchmark performance (SWE-bench, GAIA, WebArena, HumanEval+) — 35%
- Adoption signals (GitHub stars, downloads, VS Code installs) — 25%
- Community sentiment (from NLP pipeline) — 20%
- Ecosystem health (contributors, issue close rate, freshness) — 20%
Time-series: each hourly scoring run reads the latest signals and produces
one data point. The time-series builds naturally from repeated runs —
no simulation needed.
"""
import math
import json
import logging
from datetime import datetime, timezone
from collections import defaultdict
from pathlib import Path
import sys
sys.path.insert(0, str(Path(__file__).parent.parent))
from db.schema import get_connection, db
logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
def _safe_log(x):
if x is None or x <= 0: return 0
return math.log10(x + 1)
def init_agent_tables():
with db() as conn:
conn.executescript("""
CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS agent_scores (
id INTEGER PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT,
agent_name TEXT NOT NULL,
category TEXT NOT NULL,
provider TEXT,
score REAL,
sentiment REAL,
mention_count INTEGER,
adoption REAL,
reliability REAL,
sub_scores TEXT,
computed_at TEXT NOT NULL
);
CREATE INDEX IF NOT EXISTS idx_as_agent ON agent_scores(agent_name, category, computed_at);
CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS agent_forecasts (
id INTEGER PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT,
agent_name TEXT NOT NULL,
category TEXT NOT NULL,
step INTEGER NOT NULL,
score REAL,
lower_80 REAL,
upper_80 REAL,
forecast_time TEXT NOT NULL
);
""")
# Agent → provider mapping (57 agents)
PROVIDERS = {
"Claude Code": "Anthropic", "Cursor": "Anysphere", "OpenAI Codex": "OpenAI",
"GitHub Copilot": "GitHub", "Windsurf": "Codeium", "Gemini CLI": "Google",
"Cline": "Cline", "Devin": "Cognition", "Replit Agent": "Replit",
"OpenHands": "OpenHands", "SWE-agent": "Princeton",
"Aider": "Aider", "Bolt": "StackBlitz", "Continue": "Continue",
"Amazon Q Developer": "Amazon", "Tabnine": "Tabnine",
"Sourcegraph Cody": "Sourcegraph", "Supermaven": "Supermaven",
"OpenAI Deep Research": "OpenAI", "Perplexity Research": "Perplexity",
"Manus": "Manus AI", "NotebookLM": "Google", "Kimi Researcher": "Moonshot",
"Genspark": "Genspark", "Gemini Deep Research": "Google",
"OpenClaw": "Anthropic", "Operator": "OpenAI",
"Browser Use": "Browser Use", "Wingman": "Wingman", "NanoBot": "NanoBot",
"Adept ACT-2": "Adept", "Multion": "Multion",
"LangGraph": "LangChain", "CrewAI": "CrewAI",
"Microsoft AutoGen": "Microsoft", "OpenAI Agents SDK": "OpenAI",
"Claude MCP": "Anthropic", "LlamaIndex": "LlamaIndex", "PydanticAI": "Pydantic",
"Semantic Kernel": "Microsoft", "DSPy": "Stanford", "Haystack": "deepset",
"Composio": "Composio",
"ChatGPT": "OpenAI", "Claude": "Anthropic", "AutoGPT": "AutoGPT", "MetaGPT": "MetaGPT",
"Lovable": "Lovable", "v0": "Vercel", "Pieces": "Pieces",
}
# Agent → categories mapping (57 agents)
CATEGORIES = {
"Claude Code": ["coding","copilot","swe","tool","memory","enterprise"],
"Cursor": ["coding","copilot","enterprise"],
"OpenAI Codex": ["coding","swe"],
"GitHub Copilot": ["coding","copilot","enterprise"],
"Windsurf": ["coding","copilot"],
"Gemini CLI": ["coding","copilot"],
"Cline": ["coding","copilot"],
"Devin": ["coding","swe","memory"],
"Replit Agent": ["coding"],
"OpenHands": ["coding","swe"],
"SWE-agent": ["swe"],
"Aider": ["coding","swe"],
"Bolt": ["coding","general"],
"Continue": ["coding","copilot"],
"Amazon Q Developer": ["coding","copilot","enterprise"],
"Tabnine": ["coding","copilot","enterprise"],
"Sourcegraph Cody": ["coding","copilot","enterprise"],
"Supermaven": ["coding","copilot"],
"OpenAI Deep Research": ["research","enterprise"],
"Perplexity Research": ["research"],
"Manus": ["research","general","browser"],
"NotebookLM": ["research","data"],
"Kimi Researcher": ["research"],
"Genspark": ["research"],
"Gemini Deep Research": ["research"],
"OpenClaw": ["browser","general"],
"Operator": ["browser","consumer"],
"Browser Use": ["browser"],
"Wingman": ["browser","general"],
"NanoBot": ["browser"],
"Adept ACT-2": ["browser"],
"Multion": ["browser"],
"LangGraph": ["multi"],
"CrewAI": ["multi","enterprise"],
"Microsoft AutoGen": ["multi","enterprise"],
"OpenAI Agents SDK": ["multi"],
"Claude MCP": ["multi","tool"],
"LlamaIndex": ["multi"],
"PydanticAI": ["multi"],
"Semantic Kernel": ["multi","enterprise"],
"DSPy": ["multi","research"],
"Haystack": ["multi","enterprise"],
"Composio": ["multi","tool"],
"ChatGPT": ["general","consumer","data"],
"Claude": ["general","data"],
"AutoGPT": ["general"],
"MetaGPT": ["general"],
"Lovable": ["coding","general"],
"v0": ["coding","general"],
"Pieces": ["coding","copilot"],
}
def compute_agent_scores():
conn = get_connection()
init_agent_tables()
now_ts = datetime.now(timezone.utc).strftime("%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S")
# Load latest signals for each agent, with carry-forward for missing data.
# When an API call fails, the latest row may have zeros for GitHub signals.
# We carry forward the last known good value to avoid score spikes.
GITHUB_KEYS = {"github_stars", "github_forks", "github_open_issues", "github_watchers",
"github_contributors", "issue_close_rate", "days_since_update"}
agent_signals = {}
for r in conn.execute("""
SELECT agent_name, signals_json FROM agent_signals_raw
WHERE id IN (SELECT MAX(id) FROM agent_signals_raw GROUP BY agent_name)
""").fetchall():
latest = json.loads(r[1]) if r[1] else {}
# If GitHub signals are missing (API failure), carry forward from previous row
if latest.get("github_stars", 0) == 0 and any(k in latest for k in ("bench_swebench", "bench_humaneval", "sentiment_avg")):
try:
prev_rows = conn.execute("""
SELECT signals_json FROM agent_signals_raw
WHERE agent_name = ? AND id < (SELECT MAX(id) FROM agent_signals_raw WHERE agent_name = ?)
ORDER BY id DESC LIMIT 5
""", (r[0], r[0])).fetchall()
for prev_r in prev_rows:
prev = json.loads(prev_r[0]) if prev_r[0] else {}
if prev.get("github_stars", 0) > 0:
for k in GITHUB_KEYS:
if k in prev and latest.get(k, 0) == 0:
latest[k] = prev[k]
break
except Exception:
pass
agent_signals[r[0]] = latest
if not agent_signals:
logger.warning("[agent_scoring_v2] no signals found — run agent_signals collector first")
conn.close()
return 0
# Compute composite scores
all_scores = {}
for agent_name, signals in agent_signals.items():
# ── 1. Benchmark (35%) — normalized to 0-1 ──
bench_scores = []
for key in ["bench_swebench", "bench_gaia", "bench_webarena", "bench_humaneval", "bench_tau"]:
if key in signals:
bench_scores.append(signals[key] / 100.0)
benchmark = sum(bench_scores) / len(bench_scores) if bench_scores else 0.5 # default mid if no benchmarks
# ── 2. Adoption (25%) — log-normalized ──
stars = _safe_log(signals.get("github_stars", 0)) / 5.5 # 100k stars ≈ 1.0
downloads = max(
_safe_log(signals.get("pypi_downloads_week", 0)) / 7,
_safe_log(signals.get("npm_downloads_week", 0)) / 7,
)
vscode = _safe_log(signals.get("vscode_installs", 0)) / 8 # 100M ≈ 1.0
adoption = min(stars * 0.4 + downloads * 0.35 + vscode * 0.25, 1.0)
# ── 3. Community sentiment (20%) ──
sentiment = signals.get("sentiment_avg", 0.02)
sentiment_score = max(min(sentiment * 2.5 + 0.5, 1.0), 0.0)
mention_count = signals.get("sentiment_count", 0)
# ── 4. Ecosystem health (20%) ──
contributors = min(_safe_log(signals.get("github_contributors", 0)) / 3, 1.0)
close_rate = signals.get("issue_close_rate", 0.5)
freshness = max(1.0 - (signals.get("days_since_update", 30) / 60), 0.0)
vscode_rating = (signals.get("vscode_rating", 3.5) - 2.0) / 3.0 # 2-5 → 0-1
ecosystem = contributors * 0.3 + close_rate * 0.2 + freshness * 0.3 + max(min(vscode_rating, 1.0), 0.0) * 0.2
# ── Composite ──
composite = (
benchmark * 0.35 +
adoption * 0.25 +
sentiment_score * 0.20 +
ecosystem * 0.20
)
composite = max(min(composite, 1.0), 0.05)
all_scores[agent_name] = {
"score": composite,
"benchmark": benchmark,
"adoption": adoption,
"sentiment": sentiment,
"sentiment_score": sentiment_score,
"ecosystem": ecosystem,
"mention_count": mention_count,
"sub_scores": [benchmark, adoption, ecosystem],
}
# Write scores for each agent in each category
for agent_name, sc in all_scores.items():
categories = CATEGORIES.get(agent_name, ["general"])
provider = PROVIDERS.get(agent_name, "Unknown")
for cat in categories:
conn.execute("""
INSERT INTO agent_scores
(agent_name, category, provider, score, sentiment,
mention_count, adoption, reliability, sub_scores, computed_at)
VALUES (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?)
""", (
agent_name, cat, provider,
sc["score"], sc["sentiment"], sc["mention_count"],
sc["adoption"], sc["ecosystem"],
json.dumps(sc["sub_scores"]),
now_ts,
))
# Forecast: mean-reversion toward cross-sectional mean
cs_mean = sum(s["score"] for s in all_scores.values()) / len(all_scores) if all_scores else 0.5
for agent_name, sc in all_scores.items():
categories = CATEGORIES.get(agent_name, ["general"])
for cat in categories:
# Get recent history
hist = conn.execute("""
SELECT score FROM agent_scores
WHERE agent_name = ? AND category = ?
ORDER BY computed_at DESC LIMIT 10
""", (agent_name, cat)).fetchall()
scores = [r[0] for r in hist if r[0] is not None]
if len(scores) < 2:
base = sc["score"]
vol = 0.015
else:
base = scores[0]
diffs = [scores[i] - scores[i+1] for i in range(len(scores)-1)]
vol = max(sum(abs(d) for d in diffs) / len(diffs), 0.008)
for step in range(1, 73):
# Mean-revert toward cross-sectional mean
fc = base + 0.003 * (cs_mean - base) * step
fc = max(0.05, min(0.98, fc))
spread = vol * math.sqrt(step) * 1.28
conn.execute("""
INSERT OR REPLACE INTO agent_forecasts
(agent_name, category, step, score, lower_80, upper_80, forecast_time)
VALUES (?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?)
""", (agent_name, cat, step, fc, fc - spread, fc + spread, now_ts))
conn.commit()
conn.close()
logger.info("[agent_scoring_v2] scored %d agents", len(all_scores))
return len(all_scores)
if __name__ == "__main__":
logging.basicConfig(level=logging.INFO,
format="%(asctime)s [%(levelname)s] %(name)s — %(message)s")
n = compute_agent_scores()
print(f"Scored {n} agents")