import json, numpy as np from scipy.stats import spearmanr from datetime import datetime records = [json.loads(l) for l in open('eval_results/sifq_scores_v24.jsonl')] CNAMES = ['orientation_coherence','ridge_valley_clarity','continuity','noise_level','contrast_uniformity','minutiae_reliability'] concepts = np.array([r['concepts'] for r in records]) qs = np.array([r['q_score'] for r in records]) d = json.load(open('eval_results/v24/eval_summary.json')) t2 = d['track2_sensor_invariance']['SIFQ'] t4 = d['track4_concept_grounding'] TARGETS = { 'blur': ['ridge_valley_clarity', 'continuity'], 'noise': ['noise_level'], 'jpeg': ['continuity', 'ridge_valley_clarity'], 'occlusion': ['minutiae_reliability'], 'dry_skin': ['contrast_uniformity', 'continuity', 'orientation_coherence'], 'wet_press': ['ridge_valley_clarity', 'minutiae_reliability', 'orientation_coherence'], } SEP = '=' * 70 SEP2 = '-' * 70 lines = [ SEP, 'SIFQ -- Concept Quality Model: Ly thuyet & Ket qua (v24)', f'Generated: {datetime.now().strftime("%Y-%m-%d %H:%M")}', SEP, '', '1. DINH NGHIA 6 CONCEPTS', SEP2, 'Tat ca concepts: cao = chat luong tot hon, dau ra trong [0, 1].', '', ' # Concept Y nghia vat ly', ' -- -------------------------- -----------------------------------------------', ' 0 orientation_coherence Ridge flow nhat quan, local orientation field smooth', ' 1 ridge_valley_clarity Bien ridge-valley sac net, contrast cuc bo cao', ' 2 continuity Ridge lines lien tuc, khong bi dut gay', ' 3 noise_level It nhieu ngau nhien (cao = it noise = tot)', ' 4 contrast_uniformity Contrast deu tren toan foreground', ' 5 minutiae_reliability Minutiae co the trich xuat chinh xac', '', ' Degradation Concept Map (v25 -- T40):', ' blur -> [clarity[1], continuity[2], orient_coh[0]]', ' noise -> [noise_level[3], contrast_u[4]]', ' jpeg -> [continuity[2], clarity[1], contrast_u[4]]', ' occlusion -> [minutiae_reliability[5]]', ' dry_skin -> [contrast_u[4], continuity[2], orient_coh[0]]', ' wet_press -> [clarity[1], minutiae_rel[5], orient_coh[0]]', '', ' Ly do thiet ke map nhu vay:', ' - Moi concept phai duoc giam sat boi >= 2 loai degradation (tranh single-', ' point-of-failure: 1 degradation target 1 concept -> signal yeu, de bi', ' gradient interference invert chieu).', ' - Chon degradation phu hop vat ly: jpeg blocking -> contrast bands (khong', ' chi ridge artifacts), blur -> orientation blur (khong chi clarity loss).', '', '', '2. CO CHE TRAINING CONCEPT (L_concept)', SEP2, 'Voi moi cap anh (mild degradation vs severe degradation cung loai):', '', ' L_concept = SUM Huber( c_mild[c], c_severe[c] + 0.1 )', ' c in targets(degradation_type)', '', ' -> Anh degradation nhe phai co concept cao hon anh degradation nang >= 0.1', ' -> Model hoc tung concept phan ung dung chieu voi loai hu hong tuong ung', '', 'Ket hop ranking loss:', ' L_rank = relu(Q_severe - Q_mild + m) + relu(Q_mild - Q_clean + m)', ' -> Q giam theo thu tu: clean > mild_deg > severe_deg', '', ' L_deg = L_rank + gamma * L_concept', ' gamma = 2.0 (v24) -> 1.5 (v25)', ' - gamma qua cao (2.0): gradient conflict qua manh -> noise_level inversion', ' - gamma qua thap (0.5, v22): blur->continuity FAIL (+0.261)', ' - gamma = 1.5: compromise, du manh cho blur/jpeg, khong gay inversion', '', '', '3. VAN DE CONCEPT SATURATION', SEP2, 'Nguyen nhan goc: L_concept chi train tren synthetic degradation pairs.', 'Voi real fingerprint images, KHONG co gradient dinh huong concept.', '-> Concept troi ve gia tri mac dinh cua backbone features.', '', 'Hau qua trong v24 (42,683 real fingerprint images):', '', ' Concept mean std rho_Q Tinh trang', ' ---------------------------- ------ ----- ------ ---------------------------', ] STATUS = { 'noise_level': '!! DOMINATES Q (rho=-0.989)', 'minutiae_reliability': '!! Saturated HIGH -- dead (range 0.84-0.93)', 'orientation_coherence':'!! Saturated LOW -- T39 overcorrected', 'ridge_valley_clarity': '!! Near-dead -- low variance', 'continuity': '!! Near-dead -- low variance', 'contrast_uniformity': '!! Near-dead -- low variance', } for i, name in enumerate(CNAMES): c = concepts[:, i] rho, _ = spearmanr(c, qs) status = STATUS.get(name, 'OK') lines.append(f' {name:<28} {c.mean():>6.3f} {c.std():>6.3f} {rho:>+7.3f} {status}') lines += [ '', ' Vong lap nguy hiem (self-reinforcing collapse):', ' ScoreAggregator chon noise_level (std=0.340, cao nhat)', ' -> gradient tap trung update noise pathway', ' -> cac concept khac it duoc update -> variance thap hon', ' -> cang bi bo qua -> variance cang thap (vong lap)', '', ' He qua: Q ≈ f(noise_level) -- model thuc chat la "noise detector",', ' khong phai "quality estimator" da khai niem.', '', '', '4. KET QUA v24', SEP2, ] ks = t2['mean_ks_across_sensors'] pearson = t2['cross_sensor_pearson'] lines += [ ' Track 2 -- Sensor Invariance:', f' Mean KS (cross-sensor) = {ks:.4f} [goal <= 0.30] {"PASS" if ks <= 0.30 else "FAIL"}', f' Cross-sensor Pearson = {pearson:.4f} [goal >= 0.20] {"PASS" if pearson >= 0.20 else "FAIL"}', '', ' Y nghia: cung mot ngon tay chup bang cac sensor khac nhau -> SIFQ cho', ' score nhat quan. KS thap = phan bo giong nhau, Pearson cao = ranking on dinh.', ' NFIQ2 thuong co KS > 0.5 cho cross-sensor pairs.', '', ' Track 4 -- Concept Grounding (rho < 0 = PASS):', f' {"Degradation":<12} {"Concept":<28} {"rho":>7} Status', f' {"------------":<12} {"----------------------------":<28} {"-------":>7} ------', ] pass_count = total = 0 for row in t4: deg = row['degradation'] for concept in TARGETS.get(deg, []): rho = row.get(concept) if rho is None: continue total += 1 ok = rho < 0 if ok: pass_count += 1 status = 'PASS' if ok else 'FAIL <--' lines.append(f' {deg:<12} {concept:<28} {rho:>+7.3f} {status}') lines += [ '', f' Result: {pass_count}/{total} pairs PASS', '', ' 3 failures phan tich:', '', ' [1] noise -> noise_level (rho=+0.365):', ' Regression tu v22 (-0.052, OK) -> v24 (+0.365, FAIL).', ' gamma=2.0 + T39 (orient_coh added to dry_skin/wet_press) thay doi', ' gradient landscape cua ScoreAggregator. Noise la degradation duy nhat', ' target noise_level -> single-point pressure -> de bi invert.', '', ' [2] dry_skin -> contrast_u (rho=+0.051):', ' Persistent qua cac phien ban (v22: +0.504). Dry_skin la degradation', ' DUY NHAT target contrast_uniformity -> signal yeu, de bi gradient', ' tu cac loss khac at di.', '', ' [3] dry_skin -> orient_coh (rho=+0.008):', ' T39 moi them orient_coh vao dry_skin, nhung wet_press->orient_coh', ' hoat dong tot (-0.448). Ly do: wet_press + blur deu co orientation', ' disruption manh, nhung dry_skin tao ra orientation noise khong nhat', ' quan -> khong du signal de orient_coh feature phan biet.', '', '', '5. v25 -- T40 FIXES (dang chay)', SEP2, ' Thay doi so voi v24:', '', ' gamma: 2.0 -> 1.5', '', ' blur: [1, 2] -> [1, 2, 0] (them orient_coh[0])', ' noise: [3] -> [3, 4] (them contrast_u[4])', ' jpeg: [2, 1] -> [2, 1, 4] (them contrast_u[4])', ' dry_skin / wet_press / occlusion: khong doi', '', ' Ket qua ky vong:', ' - noise->noise_lv: +0.365 -> negative (gamma thap + noise 2-concept)', ' - dry_skin->contrast_u: +0.051 -> negative (3 degs co-supervise contrast_u)', ' - dry_skin->orient_coh: +0.008 -> negative (blur gives orient_coh strong signal)', ' - Cac pairs da PASS: giu nguyen (blur/jpeg/occlusion/wet_press)', ' - Track 2: giu PASS (KS, Pearson khong thay doi co ban)', '', SEP, 'END', SEP, ] txt = '\n'.join(lines) with open('eval_results/sifq_report_v24.txt', 'w', encoding='utf-8') as f: f.write(txt) print(txt) print() print('>>> Saved: eval_results/sifq_report_v24.txt')