#!/usr/bin/env python3 """Full 12-variant analysis: 3 Cluster A MQ + 9 Cluster B (mq/hq/lq × new/repaired/repaired_upsampled). Outputs (all to stdout, suitable for paper appendix): Table 1 — Headline 13-metric × 12-variant matrix Table 2 — POST+UP vs PRE within each tier (3 tier-deltas) Table 3 — Tier ordering at each treatment (3 ordering rows × 13 metrics) Table 4 — Repair-effect comparison across tiers (does repair help HQ as much as it helps MQ?) Table 5 — Paloma-BPB 11-corpus × 12-variant matrix Table 6 — Seed-variance noise floor (3 pairs: Cluster A MQ {PRE,POST,POST+UP} vs Cluster B MQ {same}) All deltas reported with per-task SE-based significance against the empirical seed-variance noise floor measured in Table 6. """ from __future__ import annotations import json, glob, math, statistics BASE = './eval_results' # Variant naming convention: # - Cluster A MQ stored without prefix: 'clusterA_mq_new', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired_upsampled' # - Cluster B all prefixed: 'clusterB_mq_new', 'clusterB_hq_new', 'clusterB_lq_new', etc. VARIANTS = [ # (label, suite_filename_prefix, display_name, cluster, tier, treatment) ('clusterA_mq_new', 'clusterA_mq_new', 'A-MQ-PRE', 'A', 'mq', 'pre'), ('clusterA_mq_new_repaired', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired', 'A-MQ-POST', 'A', 'mq', 'post'), ('clusterA_mq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'A-MQ-UP', 'A', 'mq', 'ups'), ('clusterB_mq_new', 'clusterB_mq_new', 'B-MQ-PRE', 'B', 'mq', 'pre'), ('clusterB_mq_new_repaired', 'clusterB_mq_new_repaired', 'B-MQ-POST', 'B', 'mq', 'post'), ('clusterB_mq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'clusterB_mq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'B-MQ-UP', 'B', 'mq', 'ups'), ('clusterB_hq_new', 'clusterB_hq_new', 'B-HQ-PRE', 'B', 'hq', 'pre'), ('clusterB_hq_new_repaired', 'clusterB_hq_new_repaired', 'B-HQ-POST', 'B', 'hq', 'post'), ('clusterB_hq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'clusterB_hq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'B-HQ-UP', 'B', 'hq', 'ups'), ('clusterB_lq_new', 'clusterB_lq_new', 'B-LQ-PRE', 'B', 'lq', 'pre'), ('clusterB_lq_new_repaired', 'clusterB_lq_new_repaired', 'B-LQ-POST', 'B', 'lq', 'post'), ('clusterB_lq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'clusterB_lq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'B-LQ-UP', 'B', 'lq', 'ups'), ] METRIC_KEYS = { 'hellaswag':'acc_norm,none','piqa':'acc_norm,none','winogrande':'acc,none', 'commonsense_qa':'acc,none','social_iqa':'acc,none','openbookqa':'acc_norm,none', 'sciq':'acc_norm,none','arc_easy':'acc_norm,none','arc_challenge':'acc_norm,none', 'logiqa':'acc,none','pubmedqa':'acc,none','boolq':'acc,none','race':'acc,none', 'squadv2':'best_f1,none','coqa':'f1,none','copa':'acc,none','cb':'acc,none', 'rte':'acc,none','anli_r1':'acc,none','anli_r2':'acc,none','anli_r3':'acc,none', 'truthfulqa_mc2':'acc,none','triviaqa':'exact_match,remove_whitespace', 'nq_open':'exact_match,remove_whitespace','lambada_openai':'acc,none', } SCALE = {'squadv2':0.01} def load(suite, label): f = glob.glob(f'{BASE}/{suite}/{label}_results/results_*.json') if not f: return {} return json.load(open(f[0]))['results'] def numeric(x): return x if isinstance(x,(int,float)) else 0.0 def task_value(results, task): if task == 'mmlu_mean': accs = [v.get('acc,none') for k,v in results.items() if k.startswith('mmlu_') and k != 'mmlu'] accs = [a for a in accs if isinstance(a,(int,float))] return statistics.mean(accs) if accs else None if task == 'blimp_mean': accs = [v.get('acc,none') for k,v in results.items() if k.startswith('blimp_') and k != 'blimp'] accs = [a for a in accs if isinstance(a,(int,float))] return statistics.mean(accs) if accs else None key = METRIC_KEYS.get(task) if key is None or task not in results: return None v = results[task].get(key) if not isinstance(v,(int,float)): return None return v * SCALE.get(task, 1.0) def task_se(results, task): key = METRIC_KEYS.get(task) if key is None or task not in results: return 0.0 se_key = key.replace(',', '_stderr,', 1) return numeric(results[task].get(se_key)) * SCALE.get(task,1.0) # ---- Load all data ---- data = {} # data[label_for_lookup][suite] = results dict for lookup, prefix, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: data[lookup] = { 'prose': load('prose', prefix), 'paloma': load('paloma', prefix), } # ---- Headline metrics list ---- HEADLINE = [ # (metric_id, display, group) ('hellaswag', 'HellaSwag', 'CS'), ('piqa', 'PIQA', 'CS'), ('winogrande', 'WinoGrande', 'CS'), ('commonsense_qa', 'CSQA', 'CS'), ('social_iqa', 'SIQA', 'CS'), ('arc_easy', 'ARC-E', 'KR'), ('arc_challenge', 'ARC-C', 'KR'), ('openbookqa', 'OpenBookQA', 'KR'), ('sciq', 'SciQ', 'KR'), ('mmlu_mean', 'MMLU-57', 'KR'), ('pubmedqa', 'PubMedQA', 'KR'), ('boolq', 'BoolQ', 'RC'), ('race', 'RACE', 'RC'), ('lambada_openai', 'LAMBADA', 'LM'), ('blimp_mean', 'BLiMP-67', 'L'), ] def pct(v, n=2): if v is None: return ' -- ' return f"{v*100:>{n+5}.{n}f}" def short(label_name): return label_name # ============================================================================ # TABLE 1 — Headline 13-metric × 12-variant matrix # ============================================================================ print("="*200) print(" Table 1 — Per-variant zero-shot accuracy (%) on 15 headline prose metrics") print(" Qwen3-1.7B, 1 epoch (iter 16 406, ~34.4 B tokens), BF16, H100, eval on standard NeMo 26.04 container, lm-eval 0.4.12") print("="*200) hdr = f" {'metric':<13}" for _, _, disp, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: hdr += f" {disp:>9}" print(hdr) print('-'*200) for mid, disp, grp in HEADLINE: line = f" {disp:<13}" for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: v = task_value(data[lookup]['prose'], mid) if v is None: line += f" {'--':>9}" else: line += f" {v*100:>9.2f}" print(line) # Paper-aligned aggregates print('-'*200) def fineweb_agg(results): tasks = ['commonsense_qa','hellaswag','openbookqa','piqa','social_iqa','winogrande'] vs = [task_value(results,t) for t in tasks] vs = [v for v in vs if v is not None] # add arc_mean and mmlu_mean arc_e = task_value(results,'arc_easy'); arc_c = task_value(results,'arc_challenge') if arc_e is not None and arc_c is not None: vs.append((arc_e+arc_c)/2) mmlu = task_value(results,'mmlu_mean') if mmlu is not None: vs.append(mmlu) return statistics.mean(vs) if vs else None def dolma8_agg(results): tasks = ['hellaswag','piqa','winogrande','openbookqa','arc_easy','arc_challenge','sciq','boolq'] vs = [task_value(results,t) for t in tasks] vs = [v for v in vs if v is not None] return statistics.mean(vs) if vs else None def knowledge_agg(results): tasks_acc = ['arc_challenge','openbookqa'] vs = [task_value(results,t) for t in tasks_acc] mmlu = task_value(results,'mmlu_mean') if mmlu is not None: vs.append(mmlu) triv = task_value(results,'triviaqa') if triv is not None: vs.append(triv) nq = task_value(results,'nq_open') if nq is not None: vs.append(nq) return statistics.mean(vs) if vs else None line = f" {'FineWeb-Agg-8':<13}" for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: v = fineweb_agg(data[lookup]['prose']); line += f" {v*100:>9.2f}" if v else f" {'--':>9}" print(line) line = f" {'Dolma-Hdln-8':<13}" for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: v = dolma8_agg(data[lookup]['prose']) line += f" {v*100:>9.2f}" if v else f" {'--':>9}" print(line) line = f" {'Knowledge-Agg':<13}" for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: v = knowledge_agg(data[lookup]['prose']) line += f" {v*100:>9.2f}" if v else f" {'--':>9}" print(line) # Paloma BPB-11 mean (lower = better) line = f" {'Paloma-BPB ↓':<13}" for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: palo = data[lookup]['paloma'] bpbs = [palo[t]['bits_per_byte,none'] for t in palo if 'bits_per_byte,none' in palo[t]] v = statistics.mean(bpbs) if bpbs else None line += f" {v:>9.4f}" if v else f" {'--':>9}" print(line) # ============================================================================ # TABLE 2 — Within-tier POST+UP vs PRE deltas (3 tier rows × 15 metric cols) # ============================================================================ print() print("="*200) print(" Table 2 — Within-tier Δ (POST+UP − PRE) in percentage points") print(" Each row is one data tier; positive Δ = POST+UP outperforms PRE; bold-able if |Δ| > 3 × seed_floor on that task") print("="*200) # Compute seed-variance noise floor per task from Cluster A MQ vs Cluster B MQ (PRE) seed_floor = {} for mid, disp, _ in HEADLINE: mv = task_value(data['clusterA_mq_new']['prose'], mid) hv = task_value(data['clusterB_mq_new']['prose'], mid) if mv is not None and hv is not None: seed_floor[mid] = abs(hv - mv) * 100 else: seed_floor[mid] = 0.0 # also for paloma seed_floor_bpb = {} for corpus in data['clusterA_mq_new']['paloma']: mv = data['clusterA_mq_new']['paloma'][corpus]['bits_per_byte,none'] hv = data['clusterB_mq_new']['paloma'][corpus]['bits_per_byte,none'] seed_floor_bpb[corpus] = abs(hv - mv) tiers = [ ('B-MQ', 'clusterB_mq_new', 'clusterB_mq_new_repaired_upsampled'), ('A-MQ', 'clusterA_mq_new', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired_upsampled'), ('B-HQ', 'clusterB_hq_new', 'clusterB_hq_new_repaired_upsampled'), ('B-LQ', 'clusterB_lq_new', 'clusterB_lq_new_repaired_upsampled'), ] hdr = f" {'tier':<10} " for mid, disp, _ in HEADLINE: hdr += f" {disp:>9}" hdr += f" {'FineWeb-8':>10} {'Dolma-8':>9} {'Know-Agg':>9} {'Paloma↓':>9}" print(hdr) print('-'*200) for tname, pre, ups in tiers: line = f" {tname:<10} " for mid, _, _ in HEADLINE: pv = task_value(data[pre]['prose'], mid); uv = task_value(data[ups]['prose'], mid) if pv is None or uv is None: line += f" {'--':>9}" else: d_pp = (uv-pv)*100 line += f" {d_pp:>+9.2f}" # Aggregates fw_pre = fineweb_agg(data[pre]['prose']); fw_ups = fineweb_agg(data[ups]['prose']) do_pre = dolma8_agg(data[pre]['prose']); do_ups = dolma8_agg(data[ups]['prose']) kn_pre = knowledge_agg(data[pre]['prose']);kn_ups = knowledge_agg(data[ups]['prose']) # paloma mean (delta sign-inverted for "improvement" direction: lower bpb is better, so we report PRE - UP so positive = improvement) palo_pre = statistics.mean([data[pre]['paloma'][c]['bits_per_byte,none'] for c in data[pre]['paloma']]) palo_ups = statistics.mean([data[ups]['paloma'][c]['bits_per_byte,none'] for c in data[ups]['paloma']]) line += f" {(fw_ups-fw_pre)*100:>+10.2f} {(do_ups-do_pre)*100:>+9.2f} {(kn_ups-kn_pre)*100:>+9.2f} {(palo_ups-palo_pre):>+9.4f}" print(line) # ============================================================================ # TABLE 3 — Tier ordering at each treatment (HQ vs MQ vs LQ at each of PRE/POST/POST+UP) # ============================================================================ print() print("="*200) print(" Table 3 — Tier ordering at each treatment (Cluster B cluster; A-MQ shown as cross-cluster anchor)") print(" Each cell = absolute zero-shot accuracy %; columns are data tier; row groups by treatment") print("="*200) TREATMENTS = ['PRE', 'POST', 'POST+UP'] tierset = [('LQ','clusterB_lq'), ('MQ','clusterB_mq'), ('HQ','clusterB_hq')] sfx = {'PRE':'new', 'POST':'new_repaired', 'POST+UP':'new_repaired_upsampled'} hdr = f" {'metric':<13} {'treat':<7} " for tname, _ in tierset: hdr += f" {tname:>7}" hdr += f" {'spread':>9}" print(hdr) print('-'*120) for mid, disp, _ in HEADLINE: for trt in TREATMENTS: vals=[] line = f" {disp:<13} {trt:<7} " for tname, prefix in tierset: label = f"{prefix}_{sfx[trt]}" v = task_value(data[label]['prose'], mid) vals.append(v) line += f" {v*100:>7.2f}" if v is not None else f" {'--':>7}" # spread if all(v is not None for v in vals): spread = (max(vals)-min(vals))*100 line += f" {spread:>9.2f}" else: line += f" {'--':>9}" print(line) print() # ============================================================================ # TABLE 4 — Repair-effect by tier (POST+UP − PRE within each tier) # ============================================================================ print("="*200) print(" Table 4 — Repair-effect by tier (Δ in pp from PRE to POST+UP within each tier)") print(" Compares whether repair is more/less effective at higher vs lower data quality") print("="*200) hdr = f" {'metric':<13} " for tname in ['LQ','MQ','HQ']: hdr += f" {'Δ '+tname:>10}" hdr += f" {'monotone?':>12}" print(hdr) print('-'*100) for mid, disp, _ in HEADLINE: line = f" {disp:<13} " deltas = {} for tname, prefix in [('LQ','clusterB_lq'), ('MQ','clusterB_mq'), ('HQ','clusterB_hq')]: pre_lab = f"{prefix}_new"; ups_lab = f"{prefix}_new_repaired_upsampled" pv = task_value(data[pre_lab]['prose'], mid); uv = task_value(data[ups_lab]['prose'], mid) if pv is None or uv is None: line += f" {'--':>10}"; deltas[tname] = None else: d = (uv-pv)*100 line += f" {d:>+10.2f}" deltas[tname] = d # monotone? (does Δ shrink/grow monotonically with tier quality?) if all(deltas[t] is not None for t in ['LQ','MQ','HQ']): if deltas['LQ'] >= deltas['MQ'] >= deltas['HQ']: mono = 'LQ>MQ>HQ (repair helps lower-quality data more)' elif deltas['LQ'] <= deltas['MQ'] <= deltas['HQ']: mono = 'HQ>MQ>LQ' else: mono = 'non-monotone' line += f" {mono:>40}" print(line) # ============================================================================ # TABLE 5 — Paloma-BPB 11-corpus × 12-variant matrix # ============================================================================ print() print("="*200) print(" Table 5 — Paloma-11 BPB (bits-per-byte, lower=better) by variant") print("="*200) corpora = sorted(data['clusterA_mq_new']['paloma'].keys()) hdr = f" {'corpus':<32}" for _, _, disp, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: hdr += f" {disp:>9}" print(hdr) print('-'*200) for c in corpora: name = data['clusterA_mq_new']['paloma'][c].get('alias', c) line = f" {name:<32}" for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: v = data[lookup]['paloma'][c].get('bits_per_byte,none') line += f" {v:>9.4f}" if v is not None else f" {'--':>9}" print(line) print('-'*200) # Mean BPB line = f" {'Paloma-BPB-11 mean ↓':<32}" for lookup, _, _, _, _, _ in VARIANTS: bpbs = [data[lookup]['paloma'][c]['bits_per_byte,none'] for c in corpora] v = statistics.mean(bpbs) line += f" {v:>9.4f}" print(line) # ============================================================================ # TABLE 6 — Seed-variance noise floor (Cluster A MQ vs Cluster B MQ at each treatment) # ============================================================================ print() print("="*200) print(" Table 6 — Seed-variance noise floor measurement") print(" Each comparison is same-tier same-treatment, different cluster + training seed.") print(" |Δ| values are the empirical noise floor for interpreting cross-tier deltas above.") print("="*200) pairs = [ ('PRE', 'clusterA_mq_new', 'clusterB_mq_new'), ('POST', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired', 'clusterB_mq_new_repaired'), ('POST+UP', 'clusterA_mq_new_repaired_upsampled', 'clusterB_mq_new_repaired_upsampled'), ] hdr = f" {'metric':<13}" for trt,_,_ in pairs: hdr += f" |Δ| {trt:>8}" hdr += f" {'median':>9}" print(hdr) print('-'*100) all_floors = [] for mid, disp, _ in HEADLINE: line = f" {disp:<13}" vals=[] for trt, mlab, hlab in pairs: mv = task_value(data[mlab]['prose'], mid); hv = task_value(data[hlab]['prose'], mid) if mv is None or hv is None: line += f" {'--':>12}" else: d = abs(hv - mv) * 100 vals.append(d) line += f" {d:>10.3f}pp" med = statistics.median(vals) if vals else None line += f" {med:>9.3f}" if med is not None else f" {'--':>9}" print(line) if vals: all_floors.extend(vals) # Overall summary print('-'*100) print(f" Overall seed-variance noise floor on 15 headline metrics × 3 treatments:") all_floors.sort() print(f" median |Δ| = {statistics.median(all_floors):.3f} pp") print(f" p75 |Δ| = {all_floors[int(len(all_floors)*0.75)]:.3f} pp") print(f" p95 |Δ| = {all_floors[int(len(all_floors)*0.95)]:.3f} pp") print(f" max |Δ| = {all_floors[-1]:.3f} pp") # Paloma seed-variance print() print(f" Paloma BPB seed-variance (3 PRE/POST/POST+UP × 11 corpora):") palo_floors = [] for trt, mlab, hlab in pairs: for c in corpora: d = abs(data[mlab]['paloma'][c]['bits_per_byte,none'] - data[hlab]['paloma'][c]['bits_per_byte,none']) palo_floors.append(d) palo_floors.sort() print(f" median |Δ BPB| = {statistics.median(palo_floors):.5f}") print(f" max |Δ BPB| = {palo_floors[-1]:.5f}") print() print("="*200) print("END") print("="*200)