case_name stringlengths 8 8 | atomic_facts listlengths 3 574 | conclusion dict | fact_mapping dict |
|---|---|---|---|
case_102 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_103 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "At the material time, the first ap... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F009",
"F010",
"F011",
"F012",
"F013",
"F014",
"F022",
"F027",
"F036",
"F037",
"F038",
"F039",
"F040",
"F041",
"F044",
"F045"
],
"interference": [
"F039",
"F040",
"F04... |
case_104 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1982.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Baku.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F004",
"F012",
"F013",
"F043",
"F016",
"F022",
"F044",
"F009",
"F010",
"F020"
],
"interference": [
"F014",
"F021",
"F022",
"F043",
"F044"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F006",
... |
case_106 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_107 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"pres... |
case_108 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The present case concerns the first applicant's static demonstration in November 2009.",
"source_paragraph": 1,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The present case concerns the first applicant's prosecution for an admi... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001",
"F013",
"F014",
"F015",
"F016",
"F017",
"F018",
"F019",
"F020",
"F024",
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F016",
"F017",
"F018",
"F019",
"F020",
"F021",
"F02... |
case_110 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1944.",
"source_paragraph": 12,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Lefkoşa, in northern Cyprus, in the area known as the \"Turk... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F100"
],
"interference": [
"F100",
"F178",
"F179"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F100",
"F178",
"F179"
],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F100"
... |
case_111 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
... |
case_112 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1982.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Baku.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F011",
"F012",
"F015",
"F016",
"F019"
],
"interference": [
"F017",
"F018",
"F019",
"F020",
"F055",
"F056",
"F057",
"F058"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F026",
"F027",
"F008",
... |
case_113 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and their representatives and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained und... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"pres... |
case_116 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The first applicant was born in 1980.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The second applicant was born in 1979.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"secti... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peace... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F005",
"F008",
"F010",
"F016",
"F017",
"F020",
"F036",
"F068",
"F069",
"F070",
"F072"
],
"interference": [
"F019",
"F020",
"F031",
"F032",
"F036",
"F066",
"F070",
"F07... |
case_118 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "On the dates indicated in the appended table, the applicants participated in political demonstrations.",
"source_paragraph": 1,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants were arrested at the venue of the politi... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001",
"F002",
"F009",
"F010"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F010",
"F011",
"F014",
"F015",
"F016",
"F018",
"F020"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
... |
case_120 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of the ban on holding lesbian... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"inte... |
case_121 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The facts of the cases, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "In 2009-14, the applicants lodged... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F004",
"F005",
"F007"
],
"interference": [
"F003",
"F004"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F003",
"F004",
"F012"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
... |
case_122 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1977.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F004",
"F005",
"F006",
"F029",
"F032",
"F033",
"F034",
"F083",
"F107",
"F035",
"F036",
"F042",
"F043",
"F065",
"F066",
"F085",
"F090",
"F091",
"F094",
"F095",
"F09... |
case_123 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants were opposition-ori... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F007",
"F008",
"F010",
"F011",
"F013",
"F014"
],
"interference": [
"F013",
"F014",
"F017",
"F020"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F004",
"F005",
... |
case_125 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1948.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Ashtarak, Armenia.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F008",
"F016",
"F029"
],
"interference": [
"F027",
"F031"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F015",
"F028",
"F029",
"F031",
"F037"
],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [],
"positive_obligation": []
},
... |
case_126 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1933.",
"source_paragraph": 7,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Limassol.",
"source_paragraph": 7,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact... | {
"violated": false,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F034",
"F040",
"F047",
"F048",
"F114",
"F115",
"F116"
],
"interference": [
"F034",
"F040",
"F047",
"F048"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F132",
"F133",
"F134",
"F135",
"F138",
... |
case_127 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_129 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicants either owned businesses at Voronezh municipal market and rented the market pitches for their businesses.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F007",
"F008",
"F014",
"F015",
"F016",
"F017",
"F018",
"F019",
"F020",
"F027",
"F032",
"F035",
"F055",
"F066",
"F067",
"F088",
"F089",
"F091",
"F102",
"F111",
"F19... |
case_130 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"pres... |
case_131 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The first applicant was born in 1952.",
"source_paragraph": 10,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The second applicant was born in 1966.",
"source_paragraph": 10,
"sec... | {
"violated": false,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F024",
"F025",
"F026",
"F027",
"F028",
"F035"
],
"interference": [
"F008",
"F029",
"F030",
"F031",
"F037",
"F038",
"F039",
"F040"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"... |
case_132 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_133 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The first applicant (Mr Aristov) was born in 1986.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The first applicant (Mr Aristov) lives in Moscow.",
"source_p... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F008",
"F010",
"F013",
"F014",
"F015",
"F016",
"F020",
"F024",
"F026",
"F027",
"F030",
"F031",
"F041",
"F045",
"F063",
"F064",
"F065",
"F068"
],
"interference": [
"F01... |
case_134 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_135 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1959.",
"source_paragraph": 2,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.",
"source_paragraph": 2,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F016",
"F017",
"F018",
"F019",
"F020",
"F021",
"F022",
"F023",
"F024",
"F031",
"F032",
"F033",
"F034",
"F035",
"F037",
"F052",
"F056",
"F086",
"F087",
"F093",
"F09... |
case_137 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The first applicant (Mr Asainov) was born in 1968.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The first applicant (Mr Asainov) lives in Moscow.",
"source_p... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F006",
"F007",
"F009",
"F012",
"F013",
"F014",
"F017",
"F022",
"F023",
"F024",
"F025",
"F066",
"F067",
"F068",
"F069",
"F070"
],
"interference": [
"F015",
"F018",
"F02... |
case_138 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1965.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Yerevan.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F006",
"F007",
"F008",
"F009",
"F010",
"F011",
"F012",
"F035",
"F051",
"F052",
"F081",
"F083",
"F090",
"F099",
"F117",
"F118",
"F122",
"F126",
"F135"
],
"interference"... |
case_139 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F004"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_141 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1963.",
"source_paragraph": 7,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Nicosia.",
"source_paragraph": 7,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_... | {
"violated": false,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F012",
"F013",
"F014"
],
"interference": [
"F024",
"F039",
"F063",
"F084",
"F098"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F112",
"F113",
"F125",
"F126",
"F127",
"F128",
"F131",
"F132",
... |
case_149 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001",
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
... |
case_150 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
... |
case_152 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the Appendix.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "At the material time the first app... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F011",
"F012",
"F013",
"F002",
"F004",
"F018",
"F019",
"F031",
"F074",
"F075",
"F076"
],
"interference": [
"F035",
"F037",
"F038",
"F041",
"F042",
"F047",
"F057",
"F05... |
case_153 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The present case concerns the allegedly unjustified interference with the applicants' right to freedom of assembly on account of the dispersal of an unauthorised peaceful protest.",
"source_paragraph": 1,
"section_path": [
"SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"
]
},
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F006",
"F008",
"F010",
"F017",
"F019"
],
"interference": [
"F006",
"F009",
"F010",
"F017",
"F019",
"F021"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F005",
"F006",
... |
case_154 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained under Article 11 of the Conve... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F004",
"F005"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F004",
"F005"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F004",
"F005"
],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F00... |
case_155 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_156 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "On 6 March 2006 the applicants were taken into police custody.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants were taken into police custody on susp... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F008",
"F021",
"F022",
"F029",
"F030",
"F031",
"F062",
"F063",
"F064",
"F065",
"F066",
"F067",
"F068",
"F069",
"F070",
"F071",
"F072",
"F073",
"F074",
"F075",
"F07... |
case_157 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The first applicant was born in 1967 and lives in Istanbul.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The second applicant was born in 1979 and lives in Istan... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F008",
"F011",
"F012",
"F013",
"F015",
"F016",
"F017",
"F023"
],
"interference": [
"F011",
"F012",
"F013",
"F016",
"F017",
"F037",
"F038",
"F039",
"F040"
],
"prescribed_by... |
case_158 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_159 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1990.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Moscow.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peace... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F006",
"F007",
"F008",
"F010",
"F024",
"F025",
"F026",
"F112",
"F114",
"F117",
"F119",
"F120",
"F122"
],
"interference": [
"F109",
"F130",
"F131"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
... |
case_160 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1960.",
"source_paragraph": 6,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in the town of Chekhov in the Moscow region.",
"source_parag... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F004",
"F005",
"F006",
"F016",
"F018"
],
"interference": [
"F004",
"F005",
"F006",
"F008"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F023",
"F026",
"F006"
],
"legitimate_aim": [
"F026",
"F018"
... |
case_161 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_162 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1967.",
"source_paragraph": 2,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Gyumri.",
"source_paragraph": 2,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_i... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F029",
"F030",
"F031",
"F032",
"F033",
"F046",
"F047",
"F065",
"F022",
"F023",
"F024",
"F025"
],
"interference": [
"F031",
"F033",
"F034",
"F035",
"F062"
],
"prescribed_by... |
case_165 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The application concerns the conviction of the applicant under Articles 220 § 6 and 314 of the Turkish Criminal Code.",
"source_paragraph": 1,
"section_path": [
"SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant was convi... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F005",
"F006",
"F011",
"F018"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F005",
"F006",
"F011"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F001",
"F011"
],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [],
"pos... |
case_166 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicants' dates of birth and places of residence are given in the appendix.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "At the material time some of the a... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F003",
"F004",
"F005",
"F017",
"F018",
"F019",
"F023",
"F024",
"F025",
"F054"
],
"interference": [
"F024",
"F025",
"F054",
"F055"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F009",
"F013",
... |
case_167 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1962.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Baku.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F005",
"F006",
"F014",
"F015",
"F019",
"F020",
"F021",
"F022",
"F023",
"F024"
],
"interference": [
"F021",
"F022",
"F023",
"F024",
"F053",
"F054",
"F055",
"F056"
],
... |
case_169 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1988.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Baku.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F005",
"F006",
"F007",
"F013",
"F014",
"F017",
"F018",
"F063",
"F064",
"F009",
"F010"
],
"interference": [
"F015",
"F016",
"F017",
"F018",
"F063",
"F064",
"F083",
"F09... |
case_170 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"inte... |
case_171 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicants are a group of individuals and the Foundation for Equality.",
"source_paragraph": 7,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE",
"1. Preparation of the assemblies"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F003",
"F013",
"F010",
"F016",
"F028",
"F032",
"F030"
],
"interference": [
"F010",
"F016",
"F028",
"F032",
"F023",
"F024",
"F038",
"F049"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F038",
... |
case_172 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_175 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The first applicant (Ms Belan) was born in 1961.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The second applicant (Ms Sviderskaya) was born in 1949.",
"sour... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F071",
"F072",
"F102",
"F097",
"F041",
"F043",
"F067",
"F098",
"F013",
"F022"
],
"interference": [
"F015",
"F019",
"F025",
"F026",
"F068",
"F069",
"F097",
"F103"
],
... |
case_176 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"pres... |
case_179 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001",
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
... |
case_180 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1992.",
"source_paragraph": 2,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in St Petersburg.",
"source_paragraph": 2,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F006",
"F007",
"F008",
"F020",
"F021",
"F022",
"F030",
"F031",
"F033",
"F045"
],
"interference": [
"F016",
"F017",
"F018",
"F019",
"F021",
"F022",
"F023",
"F024",
"F02... |
case_181 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The first applicant was born in 1968.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The second applicant was born in 1950.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"secti... | {
"violated": false,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peace... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F026",
"F035",
"F037",
"F051",
"F054",
"F055",
"F057",
"F058",
"F068"
],
"interference": [
"F051",
"F052",
"F053",
"F054",
"F055",
"F056",
"F057",
"F058",
"F059",
"F06... |
case_182 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"pres... |
case_184 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001",
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
... |
case_186 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_187 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1955.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Istanbul.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F003",
"F004",
"F005",
"F040",
"F042",
"F043",
"F044",
"F047",
"F048"
],
"interference": [
"F003",
"F004",
"F005",
"F006",
"F045",
"F046"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F038",
... |
case_188 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_190 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The present case concerns the applicant's prosecution in relation to his participation in peaceful assemblies.",
"source_paragraph": 1,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The Government were initially represented by Mr... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F005",
"F006",
"F031",
"F046",
"F047",
"F048",
"F049",
"F064",
"F075",
"F100",
"F101",
"F102",
"F103",
"F104",
"F001",
"F032",
"F036",
"F038",
"F067",
"F068",
"F07... |
case_191 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F003"
],
"pres... |
case_192 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
... |
case_194 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_195 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": []... |
case_196 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_197 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_198 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"pres... |
case_199 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant's details and information relevant to the application are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant complained of the lack of impartiality of... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F001",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F001",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F001"
],
"inte... |
case_200 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The first applicant was born in 1975.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The second applicant was born in 1953.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"secti... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F012",
"F025",
"F026",
"F042",
"F121",
"F019",
"F067",
"F043",
"F044",
"F017",
"F018",
"F019",
"F053",
"F066",
"F084",
"F021",
"F022",
"F041",
"F042",
"F043",
"F04... |
case_201 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1975.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Pepeni.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F011",
"F012",
"F013",
"F105",
"F023",
"F037",
"F040",
"F097",
"F098",
"F099"
],
"interference": [
"F039",
"F040",
"F041",
"F045"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F011",
"F012",
... |
case_203 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1969.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE",
"A. Particular circumstances of the case"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Diósd.",
"s... | {
"violated": false,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F003",
"F008",
"F009",
"F010",
"F025",
"F033",
"F039"
],
"interference": [
"F025",
"F032",
"F033",
"F040"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F043",
"F045"
],
"legitimate_aim": [
"F008",
... |
case_204 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"pres... |
case_205 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicants are Hungarian nationals.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The first applicant was born in 1943.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F017",
"F018",
"F020",
"F026",
"F038"
],
"interference": [
"F021",
"F022",
"F023"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F051",
"F052",
"F039"
],
"legitimate_aim": [
"F051",
"F052",
"F035"
... |
case_209 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of the lack of impartiality o... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001"
],
"interference": [
"F001"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F001"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F001"
],
"interference": [
"F001"
],
"pres... |
case_210 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The first applicant, the Centre of Societies for Krishna Consciousness in Russia (Центр обществ сознания Кришны в России), is a centralised religious organisation.",
"source_paragraph": 2,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"te... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peace... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F059",
"F074",
"F078",
"F079",
"F092",
"F094",
"F095"
],
"interference": [
"F060",
"F067",
"F069",
"F070",
"F071",
"F072",
"F075",
"F076",
"F079",
"F080",
"F082",
"F08... |
case_212 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001",
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
... |
case_213 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1972.",
"source_paragraph": 2,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Kharkiv.",
"source_paragraph": 2,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F006",
"F007",
"F008",
"F010",
"F011",
"F013"
],
"interference": [
"F010",
"F011",
"F012",
"F013",
"F025",
"F029"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F014",
"F015",
"F016",
"F022",
... |
case_214 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicants live in Kharkiv.",
"source_paragraph": 7,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "According to the applicants, in the period from 20 May to 6 July 2010 they participa... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F051",
"F054",
"F121",
"F133",
"F134",
"F135",
"F137",
"F139",
"F123",
"F147",
"F122",
"F340",
"F341",
"F342",
"F343",
"F344",
"F196",
"F197"
],
"interference"... |
case_217 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
... |
case_218 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The present case primarily concerns the applicant's complaint that his arrest at a demonstration had amounted to an interference with his rights to freedom of expression and freedom of assembly, in breach of Articles 10 and 11 of the Convention.",
"source_paragraph": 1,
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F011",
"F012",
"F013",
"F016",
"F024",
"F025",
"F026",
"F027",
"F008",
"F009"
],
"interference": [
"F027",
"F028",
"F085",
"F086"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F131",
"F085"
],... |
case_219 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP) is a political party in the Republic of Moldova.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The Christian Democr... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F004",
"F006",
"F010",
"F016",
"F017",
"F020",
"F021"
],
"interference": [
"F004",
"F006",
"F010"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F011",
"F055",
"F056"
],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity"... |
case_220 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant party, the Christian Democratic People's Party (CDPP), is a parliamentary political party in the Republic of Moldova.",
"source_paragraph": 8,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F074",
"F075",
"F076",
"F082",
"F080",
"F083",
"F084"
],
"interference": [
"F036"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F026",
"F027",
"F028",
"F029",
"F031",
"F036",
"F037",
"F042",
... |
case_222 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1927.",
"source_paragraph": 7,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Nicosia.",
"source_paragraph": 7,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_... | {
"violated": false,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacef... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F022",
"F030",
"F033",
"F035",
"F036",
"F037",
"F080",
"F081",
"F082"
],
"interference": [
"F022",
"F035",
"F036",
"F037",
"F083"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F093",
"F094",
... |
case_223 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1968.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Stryzhavka.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peace... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F003",
"F010",
"F021",
"F022",
"F023",
"F024",
"F026",
"F029",
"F033",
"F034",
"F035",
"F036",
"F053"
],
"interference": [
"F016",
"F029",
"F032",
"F033",
"F053",
"F05... |
case_229 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_230 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was a member of a group of aliens without residence permits.",
"source_paragraph": 8,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant was a spokeswoman for a gro... | {
"violated": false,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peace... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001",
"F003",
"F005"
],
"interference": [
"F001",
"F003",
"F005",
"F013",
"F035"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F076",
"F088"
],
"legitimate_aim": [
"F005",
"F013",
"F014",
"F033",
... |
case_237 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The present applications concern the applicants' arrests in relation to their intention to participate in peaceful demonstrations.",
"source_paragraph": 1,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The present applications co... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001",
"F002",
"F018",
"F019",
"F020",
"F021"
],
"interference": [
"F001",
"F002",
"F003",
"F004",
"F020",
"F021",
"F022"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
... |
case_238 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"pres... |
case_239 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F001",
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F001",
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],... |
case_240 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of various restrictions impos... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F004"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F004"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F004"
],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003",
"F004"
],
... |
case_242 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_243 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "On 29 April 2008 the applicants jointly notified the Beyoğlu district governor that they would be gathering before the Taksim Atatürk memorial on 1 May 2008 at 1 p.m.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F019",
"F022",
"F054"
],
"interference": [
"F023",
"F024",
"F029"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F057",
"F058",
"F059"
],
"legitimate_aim": [
"F006",
"F007",
"F008",
"F009"
],
"necess... |
case_244 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant is a Cypriot national of Turkish origin.",
"source_paragraph": 8,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1950.",
"source_paragraph": 8,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F013",
"F012",
"F019",
"F020",
"F021",
"F022",
"F023",
"F024",
"F025",
"F026",
"F015",
"F016"
],
"interference": [
"F016",
"F015",
"F014",
"F005"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
... |
case_245 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 4,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002"
],
"interference": [
"F002"
],
"pres... |
case_246 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The list of applicants and the relevant details of the applications are set out in the appended table.",
"source_paragraph": 3,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants complained of disproportionate measures ... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"interference": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [],
"legitimate_aim": [],
"necessity": [
"F002",
"F003"
],
"positive_obligation": []
},
"list2": {
"scope": [
"F002",
"F003"
... |
case_247 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The first applicant was born in 1965.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The second applicant was born in 1965.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"secti... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peace... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F013",
"F016",
"F017",
"F019",
"F025",
"F029",
"F031"
],
"interference": [
"F018",
"F024",
"F026",
"F027",
"F028",
"F030",
"F031"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F019",
"F026",
... |
case_251 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicants' personal details are set out in the appendix.",
"source_paragraph": 2,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicants were represented by Mr M. Erbil, a lawyer practising in Istanbul.",
"source_p... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_peac... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F007",
"F010",
"F011",
"F012",
"F013",
"F014",
"F015",
"F016",
"F019",
"F020",
"F028",
"F029",
"F030",
"F032",
"F033",
"F034",
"F036",
"F045",
"F059",
"F071",
"F07... |
case_254 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1979.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Kazan.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peacefu... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F036",
"F010",
"F037",
"F039"
],
"interference": [
"F014",
"F045",
"F063",
"F071",
"F072"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F014",
"F015",
"F033",
"F034",
"F063",
"F070",
"F085",
... |
case_255 | [
{
"fact_id": "F001",
"text": "The applicant was born in 1979.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
"THE FACTS",
"I. THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE"
]
},
{
"fact_id": "F002",
"text": "The applicant lives in Baku.",
"source_paragraph": 5,
"section_path": [
... | {
"violated": true,
"elements": {
"scope": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_assembly_exists": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "explicit"
},
"scope_participation": {
"conclusion": "yes",
"discussed": "implied"
},
"scope_peace... | {
"list1": {
"scope": [
"F007",
"F008",
"F009",
"F010",
"F140"
],
"interference": [
"F012",
"F013",
"F014",
"F019",
"F087"
],
"prescribed_by_law": [
"F050",
"F061",
"F064",
"F065",
"F086",
"F087",
... |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.