diff --git a/transcript/award_1WEUD8t7h_4.txt b/transcript/award_1WEUD8t7h_4.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c0411907c9e0a678a8b70c214472fbfecefdaa80 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/award_1WEUD8t7h_4.txt @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.400] Crimea +[30.000 --> 33.420] I'm back there. +[36.460 --> 37.660] Very cool. +[55.500 --> 57.740] I know the other pupils were busy. diff --git a/transcript/award_2EsAGNAvgkM.txt b/transcript/award_2EsAGNAvgkM.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7505c976fd0575a571e3ea9c1812764dcd2015dc --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/award_2EsAGNAvgkM.txt @@ -0,0 +1,70 @@ +[0.140 --> 0.880] しゆろw Antzu doughtu, +[0.880 --> 4.440] Yahu fashionable +[30.000 --> 33.000] ...pour evening everybody... +[37.000 --> 39.000] ...vana kaam tamir makare... +[40.000 --> 43.000] ...I would like to congratulate all the winners... +[43.000 --> 45.000] ...and my respect to... +[45.000 --> 47.000] ...Shaukarama... +[47.000 --> 49.000] ...and A. Sudha Sallabha... +[49.000 --> 50.000] ...villagination... +[50.000 --> 51.000] ...well deserved... +[51.000 --> 52.000] ...thank you... +[53.000 --> 54.000] Bingo Yamitos... +[54.000 --> 56.000] ...SIMA 2013... +[56.000 --> 59.000] ...best actress-popular... +[59.000 --> 60.000] ...for Telugu... +[60.000 --> 61.000] ...best actress-popular... +[61.000 --> 63.000] ...for Telugu cinema... +[63.000 --> 64.000] ...it's... +[64.000 --> 65.000] ...Shruti Hassan... +[65.000 --> 66.000] ...for... +[66.000 --> 67.000] ...Gabbar Sik... +[81.000 --> 83.000] ...Briki Namaskaram... +[83.000 --> 86.000] ...thank you so much for everyone who voted in Siamma... +[86.000 --> 88.000] ...for the Sirward... +[88.000 --> 89.000] ...i cinema... +[89.000 --> 90.000] ...to the next one... +[90.000 --> 91.000] ...chalisandoshanga... +[91.000 --> 92.000] ...andi... +[92.000 --> 95.000] ...i cinema director Harish Ghari... +[95.000 --> 96.000] ...keo ka pedda pedda... +[96.000 --> 97.000] ...thanks... +[97.000 --> 99.000] ...into ka manchi character Ritcharu... +[99.000 --> 101.000] ...and Paavan Kalyangar... +[101.000 --> 102.000] ...keo ka pedda... +[102.000 --> 103.000] ...thanks... +[103.000 --> 104.000] ...and to the whole team of the Abhursing... +[104.000 --> 106.000] ...chalisandoshanga... +[106.000 --> 107.000] ...andi... +[107.000 --> 108.000] ...thank you so much... +[108.000 --> 111.000] ...best actress-critics... +[111.000 --> 112.000] ...for Telugu... +[112.000 --> 113.000] ...well it's... +[113.000 --> 114.000] ...9thara for... +[114.000 --> 116.000] ...Kristam Bandhe... +[116.000 --> 117.000] ...Chaguduru... +[119.000 --> 121.000] ...Kristam Bandhe... +[134.000 --> 135.000] ...thank you Siamma... +[135.000 --> 136.000] ...thank you so much for... +[136.000 --> 138.000] ...ondering me with this award... +[138.000 --> 139.000] ...and thank you Shri Devi Mam... +[139.000 --> 141.000] ...thank you so much for doing the honors... +[141.000 --> 142.000] ...I would like to thank... +[142.000 --> 143.000] ...Kristam Bandhe... +[143.000 --> 145.000] ...for believing in me so much... +[145.000 --> 146.000] ...and... +[146.000 --> 148.000] ...for being such a wonderful director... +[148.000 --> 149.000] ...thank you so much... +[149.000 --> 151.000] ...best actress Tamil... +[151.000 --> 153.000] ...Hansika Motwani for... +[153.000 --> 155.000] ...Oru Kahl Oru Kanadi... +[155.000 --> 157.000] ...BHS PA Bhagavad contained... +[157.000 --> 158.500] ...Jазam不ca today... +[178.000 --> 180.000] ...DNK SiammaF cont chamberring me with this prestige award... +[180.000 --> 182.000] ...Thank You Rajesh Sir for giving me or... +[182.000 --> 183.000] ...Clocchetبر Ganani... +[183.000 --> 188.000] %, %, I am ,%, not ,, not me +[188.420 --> 191.720] %, Your evening +[195.160 --> 198.160] %, your evening +[199.520 --> 204.220] %, your evening +[210.220 --> 212.360] %, your evening diff --git a/transcript/award_5h_Tuip4XTQ.txt b/transcript/award_5h_Tuip4XTQ.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e4f192478b9d7ef7b9d976fb8ddebe162f3c2c2d --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/award_5h_Tuip4XTQ.txt @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +[0.000 --> 2.000] Yeah. +[2.000 --> 4.000] And I'm just a success. +[6.000 --> 8.000] You've done that to the success. +[8.000 --> 10.000] So, I'm really proud of you. +[10.000 --> 12.000] So, just before I come out here. +[20.000 --> 22.000] Yeah. +[22.000 --> 24.000] All four of you. +[30.000 --> 32.000] Thank you. +[36.000 --> 38.000] Okay, I'll get to my A-Block. +[38.000 --> 40.000] All right? +[40.000 --> 42.000] Thank you. +[42.000 --> 44.000] Bye-bye. +[60.000 --> 62.000] Bye-bye. diff --git a/transcript/award_7stFf7zwJUw.txt b/transcript/award_7stFf7zwJUw.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..19513b59f8bdd85e89e8cd5505e968ff53e2d8f4 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/award_7stFf7zwJUw.txt @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ +[0.000 --> 2.200] tre точно a artistic concert dance ژ°he h was неo wins ein savuna szélf +[2.200 --> 5.880] starring sw dressing team from the famged g Austin +[30.000 --> 60.000] आपादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादाद +[60.000 --> 90.000] आपादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादा +[90.000 --> 120.000] आपादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादा +[120.000 --> 150.000] आपादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादा +[150.000 --> 180.000] आपादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादा +[180.000 --> 210.000] पाददादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादा +[210.000 --> 240.000] अपादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादा +[240.000 --> 250.540] पाददादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादादा diff --git a/transcript/award_E3V_pPfqtqY.txt b/transcript/award_E3V_pPfqtqY.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..36454dc163d17bb166f207971b3533118077783f --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/award_E3V_pPfqtqY.txt @@ -0,0 +1,9 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.080] The rose for me was the kind of the overall spirit of the show. +[4.080 --> 6.640] And largely that's because of Jimmy Kimmel. +[6.640 --> 8.880] I think the show coming after last year, +[8.880 --> 12.720] where it just felt so ugly because of reasons that we all know. +[12.720 --> 15.200] This year had a generosity to it. +[15.200 --> 22.000] It was funny, but it also was just like nice and supportive and inclusive. +[22.000 --> 25.680] And I credit the winners, but I also credit Jimmy Kimmel. +[25.680 --> 28.800] My, when people ask me, I said it was joyful. +[28.800 --> 29.120] And I credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, but I also credit the winners, diff --git a/transcript/award_GE8X3yZzjxM.txt b/transcript/award_GE8X3yZzjxM.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9e72b20c3dbd4003a44c7049da1023638cbbca04 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/award_GE8X3yZzjxM.txt @@ -0,0 +1,71 @@ +[0.000 --> 24.820] fff +[24.820 --> 26.820] அண்ணாம் onto the stage +[34.820 --> 37.820] இப்போது பெளியில் அண்ணாம் 2020 +[37.820 --> 39.820] மிகைச்சும் நடி அண்ணாம் பெண்டு +[39.820 --> 41.820] கப்பேல் அண்ணாம் +[41.820 --> 43.820] மம்புதா மோஞ்ணாஸ +[43.820 --> 44.820] ஐரண்சி +[44.820 --> 46.820] தரச்சனா ராஜேன்று +[46.820 --> 48.820] சியுஷூ +[48.820 --> 50.820] Shobhana +[50.820 --> 52.820] வரணே அவஷயம் +[52.820 --> 54.820] அண்ணுபமா பரமேஷ்வு +[54.820 --> 56.820] மனியில் அஷூகு +[56.820 --> 58.820] சாயமா 2020 +[58.820 --> 60.820] for best actor in a leading role female +[60.820 --> 61.820] மலிலாம் +[61.820 --> 63.820] goes to +[63.820 --> 65.820] my crazy +[65.820 --> 67.820] wonderful +[67.820 --> 70.820] fantastic actress +[70.820 --> 71.820] Shobhana +[83.820 --> 85.820] the +[85.820 --> 88.820] my +[88.820 --> 90.820] profession +[90.820 --> 91.820] fy +[91.820 --> 93.820] you finally gave me an award +[93.820 --> 95.820] it's been a while +[95.820 --> 96.820] it's been a while for me +[96.820 --> 98.820] even being on a stage +[98.820 --> 99.820] கொட்டுறை +[99.820 --> 100.820] திறிலில் என்று +[100.820 --> 102.820] Thank you 2018 +[102.820 --> 105.820] and so +[105.820 --> 107.820] honoured to be here +[107.820 --> 109.820] and partake in a time +[109.820 --> 111.820] when the industry is also +[111.820 --> 113.380] நமسwagen snail forcémenthip +[113.380 --> 115.620] ச eerste جε 냄יים +[115.620 --> 117.860] میரےieliے ہیں +[118.860 --> 120.900] nawet 되ھیںங்களே +[120.900 --> 122.380] நிpersے ہیں +[122.380 --> 124.500] நேதையுமை слова +[124.500 --> 126.100] உ massa +[126.100 --> 135.560] நீங்கள் சயமா +[135.560 --> 136.860] நலக்ảiிடமில் பற்று +[136.860 --> 138.860] Thank you very much. +[138.860 --> 140.860] Thank you very much. +[141.860 --> 143.860] Thank you man. Thank you so much. +[143.860 --> 144.860] Thank you. +[144.860 --> 146.860] You are very talented. +[147.860 --> 151.860] The song that we will sing when we sing the song is written by Sarayana Lyrics. +[151.860 --> 155.860] Our next category is Best Lyrics Writer 2019. +[155.860 --> 159.860] To present this award, I would like to call upon stage Arman Malik Garhola. +[159.860 --> 161.860] It will be a beautiful show. +[167.860 --> 171.860] We will sing our song in 2021. +[171.860 --> 176.860] Now we will sing the song of Mahesh Babugar's Hariwalka. +[181.860 --> 184.860] Best Lyrics Writer 2019 and the winner is... +[184.860 --> 188.860] Shwimani or Idegada Maasi. +[197.860 --> 199.860] I have heard about the song. +[199.860 --> 201.860] I have heard about the song. +[201.860 --> 204.860] I am so happy that I am a hero here. +[204.860 --> 211.860] I have heard about the song of the song in the song Mahesh Alba Manayar Albaam. +[211.860 --> 216.860] I have heard about the song of the song Mahesh Albaam. +[216.860 --> 219.860] Thank you so much for listening to this song. +[220.860 --> 226.860] As you may know, Lyrics Writer is 7 years old and has claimed very much. +[226.860 --> 229.860] So, thank you to Wams LAUGHKO and Hari Garh. +[229.860 --> 232.860] We are all lucky to have music with me in my song. +[232.860 --> 237.860] It was such an important day after Lcią R sister's release with these great songs. +[237.860 --> 243.860] Thanks to DSP, Mr. Neasemin is blessed with this amazingTT for your post. +[243.860 --> 246.860] And we are so happy today. +[246.860 --> 247.860] Thank you so much. diff --git a/transcript/award_GEFDiQOVL9k.txt b/transcript/award_GEFDiQOVL9k.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9fe30a8bcf89d2902d902f25d2fb7d4576243a93 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/award_GEFDiQOVL9k.txt @@ -0,0 +1,83 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.000] Ladies and gentlemen, I am very excited about my musical guest tonight. +[4.000 --> 9.600] BTS, pause for screaming fans, because BTS isn't just a band. +[9.600 --> 12.400] They're a global phenomenon. +[12.400 --> 16.800] They've sold millions of albums. They've been streamed billions of times +[16.800 --> 20.400] and played du-pac stadiums all around the world. They're so influential. +[20.400 --> 24.000] They're the reason I got this haircut. +[24.000 --> 28.600] They've even helped spread trends from Korea, like this hand gesture right here, okay? +[28.600 --> 31.000] That little hand gesture, you see that? Hello? +[31.000 --> 35.000] Where you use your thumb and your index finger to create a tiny little heart, okay? +[35.000 --> 39.400] By the way, the only this part is the heart. If your heart has this part down here, +[39.400 --> 41.800] that's a problem. Seek help. +[41.800 --> 46.600] And tonight, I'm thrilled to announce that BTS has agreed to give a late show +[46.600 --> 51.800] an exclusive look at a whole bunch of new hand gestures that all the cool kids +[51.800 --> 54.600] are going to be using next. Jim? +[54.600 --> 57.400] Hi, this is Aaron from BTS. +[57.400 --> 63.400] A few years ago, we helped popularize finger hearts, a symbol that means love and affection. +[63.400 --> 66.600] But that's only what many popular gestures we use. +[66.600 --> 70.600] And tonight, me and the boys and BTS are going to teach you the rest. +[70.600 --> 72.600] What's going on? +[74.600 --> 80.200] Heart is just one of the important organs you can communicate with your fingers. +[80.200 --> 85.000] For example, this are Candace and +[85.000 --> 87.800] this is Long Intense. +[87.800 --> 92.200] This is a V, this is Storm and Name V, +[92.200 --> 95.800] but it also means Peace or even better. +[95.800 --> 99.800] If you add a finger, this is a pizza. +[99.800 --> 105.000] Looks delicious, but remember to not eat your fingers. +[105.000 --> 109.000] This one means I'm going out for a nice walk +[109.000 --> 111.800] and this means that I'm going for a run +[111.800 --> 115.800] and this means forget running. I just got a new pogostek. +[115.800 --> 117.000] And this means, +[117.000 --> 119.800] Help! That guy stole my pogostek! +[119.800 --> 121.800] This is a simple one. +[121.800 --> 127.000] This means, hey, you have some food on your face. +[127.000 --> 130.200] This one means, live long and prosper. +[130.200 --> 134.200] I invented it and Star Trek learned it from me. +[134.200 --> 135.800] How is that possible? +[135.800 --> 139.800] Because Star Trek takes place in the future. +[140.600 --> 143.800] This one is very helpful. It goes like this. +[152.600 --> 155.800] That means, the better is going to fate, +[155.800 --> 159.800] but important is your base coach. +[159.800 --> 161.800] I'm sure you already know. +[161.800 --> 164.800] Rock, paper, scissors. +[164.800 --> 166.800] But not a lot of people know. +[166.800 --> 170.800] There are other moves you can make like paper shredder +[170.800 --> 172.800] with this paper. +[172.800 --> 174.800] And then, Jamsa. +[174.800 --> 178.800] Everybody knows this one, which is giving a person +[178.800 --> 181.800] and money ears is cute. +[181.800 --> 184.800] But this is called the double bunny. +[184.800 --> 188.800] It's stronger, more powerful, dangerous. +[188.800 --> 192.800] Beware of double bunny, fear of double bunny. +[192.800 --> 195.800] For this one, you need two people. +[195.800 --> 197.800] One makes a TV set. +[197.800 --> 201.800] And the other one puts a little man inside. +[201.800 --> 204.800] It means, late night TV holds TV and Kobe. +[204.800 --> 206.800] But use this one carefully, +[206.800 --> 212.800] because it actually has the power to someone's TV and Kobe. +[212.800 --> 215.800] Hey, somebody call for me? +[215.800 --> 219.800] Nope. We are just showing people the hand gestures. +[219.800 --> 223.800] Dammit, Jim. Again, you know I have a shoulder knight. +[223.800 --> 226.800] I'm 16 hour plane ride back from Korea. +[226.800 --> 228.800] Sorry, Steven. +[228.800 --> 229.800] Repeat, say. +[229.800 --> 230.800] Come on. +[230.800 --> 234.800] And finally, this hand gesture is one of my favorites. +[234.800 --> 238.800] It means our new single butter is available now on streaming platforms +[238.800 --> 240.800] and in stores everywhere. +[240.800 --> 243.800] This butter looks delicious. +[243.800 --> 246.800] Oh, do not eat your fingers, Steven. +[253.800 --> 255.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[255.800 --> 257.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[257.800 --> 259.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[259.800 --> 261.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[261.800 --> 263.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[263.800 --> 265.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[265.800 --> 267.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[267.800 --> 269.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[269.800 --> 271.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[271.800 --> 273.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[273.800 --> 275.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[275.800 --> 277.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[277.800 --> 279.800] I'm not eating your fingers. +[279.800 --> 281.800] I'm not eating your fingers. diff --git a/transcript/award_MQUenMcdk8M.txt b/transcript/award_MQUenMcdk8M.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f09358c7b3a79cb24e1b43a7e297ace24a70eb22 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/award_MQUenMcdk8M.txt @@ -0,0 +1,186 @@ +[0.000 --> 2.000] LALETA! +[2.000 --> 3.000] LALETA! +[3.000 --> 4.000] Havi you! +[4.000 --> 5.000] LALETA! +[5.000 --> 6.000] EGIFTWALTCHURR! +[6.000 --> 8.000] குடுக்கும்ன காயிர்த்துல் +[8.000 --> 9.000] எனக்கு LALETUM் +[9.000 --> 10.000] நிறுத்துவிரு சாயம் +[10.000 --> 11.000] நாம் +[11.000 --> 12.000] LALETUM் +[12.000 --> 13.000] ஒருடைய் LALETUM் +[13.000 --> 14.000] இவ்வளவு +[14.000 --> 15.000] ராரங்களும் +[15.000 --> 17.000] சரியருடைய் LALETUM் +[17.000 --> 19.000] மூன்ன பேரு நின்னுவிடுவிடுக்கிற +[19.000 --> 20.000] அவர் மூன்ன பேரும் +[20.000 --> 21.000] LALETUM் +[21.000 --> 23.000] பரையின்று ஒருடைய LALETUM் +[23.000 --> 24.000] அவர் பரையின்ம +[24.000 --> 25.000] எட்டும் நன்றை பரையின்று +[25.000 --> 26.000] LALETUM் +[26.000 --> 27.000] தோன்னால் +[27.000 --> 28.000] EGIFTWALTCHURR +[28.000 --> 29.000] LALETUM் +[29.000 --> 30.000] குடுக்கும் +[30.000 --> 31.000] நின்னும் மூன்ன பேரு விள்ளைத்துவிட்டாய். +[31.000 --> 32.000] LALETUM் +[32.000 --> 33.000] இது LALETUM் +[33.000 --> 34.000] ராரங்களுக்கும் +[34.000 --> 36.000] திரியும் +[36.000 --> 37.000] திரியும் +[37.000 --> 39.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[40.000 --> 41.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[41.000 --> 42.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[42.000 --> 43.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[43.000 --> 44.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[44.000 --> 45.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[45.000 --> 46.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[46.000 --> 47.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[47.000 --> 48.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[48.000 --> 49.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[49.000 --> 50.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[50.000 --> 51.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[51.000 --> 52.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[52.000 --> 53.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[53.000 --> 54.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[54.000 --> 55.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[55.000 --> 56.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[56.000 --> 57.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[57.000 --> 58.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[58.000 --> 59.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[59.000 --> 61.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[61.000 --> 62.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[62.000 --> 63.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[63.000 --> 64.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[64.000 --> 65.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[65.000 --> 66.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[66.000 --> 67.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[67.000 --> 68.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[68.000 --> 69.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[69.000 --> 70.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[70.000 --> 71.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[71.000 --> 73.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[73.000 --> 74.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[74.000 --> 75.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[75.000 --> 76.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[76.000 --> 77.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[77.000 --> 78.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[78.000 --> 79.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[79.000 --> 80.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[80.000 --> 81.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[81.000 --> 82.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[82.000 --> 83.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[83.000 --> 84.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[84.000 --> 85.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[85.000 --> 86.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[86.000 --> 87.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[87.000 --> 88.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[88.000 --> 89.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[89.000 --> 90.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[90.000 --> 91.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[91.000 --> 92.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[92.000 --> 93.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[93.000 --> 94.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[94.000 --> 95.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[95.000 --> 96.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[96.000 --> 97.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[97.000 --> 98.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[98.000 --> 99.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[99.000 --> 100.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[100.000 --> 101.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[101.000 --> 102.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[102.000 --> 103.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[103.000 --> 104.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[104.000 --> 105.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[105.000 --> 106.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[106.000 --> 107.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[108.000 --> 109.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[109.000 --> 110.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[110.000 --> 111.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[111.000 --> 112.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[112.000 --> 113.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[113.000 --> 115.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[115.000 --> 116.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[116.000 --> 117.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[117.000 --> 118.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[118.000 --> 119.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[119.000 --> 120.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[120.000 --> 121.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[121.000 --> 122.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[123.000 --> 125.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[125.000 --> 126.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[126.000 --> 128.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[128.000 --> 129.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[129.000 --> 130.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[130.000 --> 131.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[131.000 --> 132.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[132.000 --> 133.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[133.000 --> 134.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[134.000 --> 135.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[135.000 --> 136.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[136.000 --> 137.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[137.000 --> 138.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[139.000 --> 140.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[140.000 --> 141.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[141.000 --> 142.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[142.000 --> 143.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[147.000 --> 148.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[148.000 --> 149.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[149.000 --> 150.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[150.000 --> 151.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[151.000 --> 152.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[152.000 --> 153.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[153.000 --> 154.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[154.000 --> 155.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[155.000 --> 156.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[157.000 --> 158.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[158.000 --> 159.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[159.000 --> 160.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[160.000 --> 161.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[161.000 --> 162.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[162.000 --> 164.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[164.000 --> 165.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[165.000 --> 166.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[166.000 --> 167.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[167.000 --> 168.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[168.000 --> 169.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[169.000 --> 170.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[170.000 --> 171.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[171.000 --> 173.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[173.000 --> 174.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[174.000 --> 175.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[175.000 --> 176.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[176.000 --> 177.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[189.000 --> 190.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[190.000 --> 191.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[191.000 --> 192.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[192.000 --> 193.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[193.000 --> 194.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[194.000 --> 195.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[195.000 --> 196.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[201.000 --> 203.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[203.000 --> 204.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[204.000 --> 205.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[205.000 --> 206.440] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[206.440 --> 207.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[207.000 --> 209.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[209.000 --> 210.000] ராஜோ வருகியிரு +[210.000 --> 211.000] ராஜோ வருகியிரு +[211.000 --> 212.380] ராஜோ औக்க +[212.380 --> 214.000] யார் றொங்கழ்க்கா வருகியிர் +[214.000 --> 215.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[215.000 --> 216.000] ராஜோ வருகியிர் +[216.000 --> 220.600] forms gave out +[220.600 --> 227.700] that +[227.700 --> 232.380] visa +[232.380 --> 242.640] a +[242.640 --> 244.640] ங்க ஹிணன்னோ generation +[247.200 --> 249.200] ந indo்பரம் மіль Gonzalez +[254.740 --> 256.420] நவாகின்னோடொ தான் பாוטவு +[257.920 --> 260.100] ஺்சfried +[260.520 --> 264.320] மெஞ்த தவல்ளட்ட告訴 다 +[264.320 --> 266.180] ஸானிஞன் போது +[266.300 --> 267.820] ஺வாங்கோ தென்னோடு. +[270.620 --> 272.380] யாம், İyi இviet பாATHER +[272.640 --> 272.860] आप पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ पु़ प� diff --git a/transcript/award_PhgbJOgCBw4.txt b/transcript/award_PhgbJOgCBw4.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c92e8009cdc0aa52f591e8444ce3d7b918032c68 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/award_PhgbJOgCBw4.txt @@ -0,0 +1 @@ +[0.000 --> 22.620] Music diff --git a/transcript/award_UvEzzaCO7I0.txt b/transcript/award_UvEzzaCO7I0.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4eb6dafee633e45948b16977be1819417c71432f --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/award_UvEzzaCO7I0.txt @@ -0,0 +1,53 @@ +[0.000 --> 0.800] அழு பிளுவலகாசால... +[6.360 --> 7.320] pressur לக்கfenRyanங்களைtenseமிஞான்... +[7.320 --> 10.200] வனசமிஞான் understand my best and +[10.500 --> 12.320] it's a bit of a validation effect.. +[12.600 --> 14.160] நான் உங்களுக்கே யாராதுகி லவிருக்கறது சுவா மட்டியிருக்காக. +[14.620 --> 16.100] ாவும் நம்பாதேங்கள். +[19.200 --> 21.320] ரச்சிutan்ட அழுபவficு பிளைப்பற்றிருக்கலப் போuter் போuter்பைக் கடில்காக. +[24.240 --> 25.440] நம்பாத்தையும் விஷப்பமிளை. +[25.440 --> 30.440] நிக்கிலாவிம்லையில் சென்சேஞ்சம் தமல்லும் +[30.440 --> 33.440] பிருதுவில் சென்சேஞ்சம் தமல்லும் +[43.440 --> 46.440] சென்சி சப்போப்பின் அக்கிவின் தமல் +[46.440 --> 49.440] அர்வின் சமே, தலைவி +[55.440 --> 57.440] மற கத்தேர் +[78.540 --> 80.440] உங்களுக்கு மதுக்கலும் இருப் பங்களை +[85.440 --> 86.440] அஜயிடproof ம Shuttle +[86.460 --> 88.740] ஷ்கனாக ஹauerண் Co be ein +[90.740 --> 91.840] ичноன்ன +[95.200 --> 96.900] ஷயffron +[99.180 --> 101.380] நம்புடைய தfitவலி கொடுத்தேன் +[102.540 --> 104.460] மஎண்லாமfor +[104.980 --> 106.220] ஷயffron +[106.300 --> 107.240] ஆண்டு +[107.980 --> 108.300] மர காத்சியினும் +[108.460 --> 108.660] எங்கே வத ஒருலும் +[108.720 --> 112.040] உன்னுவிடு என்று விஷயங்களும் இறகா +[112.220 --> 112.980] ஷயph anti +[113.340 --> 113.740] כழ்ச்சாப்படுது +[113.780 --> 114.860] தோஷ்ப்படுத் ததோஷு +[114.860 --> 117.100] வچவை, உங்களுடையும் முதலோ UCLA சfreeff peefood +[117.340 --> 119.200] கwroute்க கோ நன்று படரினாடன் +[119.400 --> 120.240] மேலைய் ஓws உன் பிள்ளையுங்கள் கொண்டி நானராக +[120.500 --> 121.460] நன்று ஆரண்டு கொண்டிசி நwarு これவெரியோ +[121.860 --> 123.020] உள்ளப ஞொனுடன் மறையாக +[124.260 --> 125.460] துள்ளை இங்கே கி Dirைகூகிறம் மீத rápி கூறை இங்கே +[125.460 --> 127.440] நான் சமா ஒரு பையான் போpectும் நின் அனதான கொppுடுய. +[127.440 --> 132.100] அவ்வள சிழ Knowing woman, ஆசியல design tech, செல்லல் பணி, வாணிக்கறது, வேண்டா உன hayarthura f thinnaoaat.. +[132.100 --> 136.120] Een buena saddle, ஆசையாக Thanking Girl One Give Me a War, +[136.120 --> 156.360] மிக்கல்பா, பாா wearing distribute distribute offers, daredா +[156.360 --> 160.100] எனது ஆமல் இருக்கிறாம், கூறிம்போது செய்வாலையார் இச்சி imprisonedண்ணாரும் +[160.100 --> 163.360] யாரு ஒரு பொருகத்துவிளி பார்ந்துக் காரு ஒரு உங்கு இருக்கிறார் +[163.460 --> 166.040] ஆமணத்து மேலை வாடு படிக்கவேண்டுமwhen I am +[166.040 --> 169.660] இன்று ஆhaiஜானித்தாயர் ஏOODலி விஞ் சந்துக்கல் +[169.660 --> 172.440] யாரு ஓட்டனித்தான ஆகெடிடந்திக் கviewல்லும் +[172.440 --> 174.440] நான் உன்னையில் பிரச்சியில் தலைவி, +[174.440 --> 178.440] நான் உன்னையில் பிரச்சியில் பிரச்சியில் தலைவி, +[178.440 --> 181.440] நான் உன்னையில் பிரச்சியில் பிரச்சியில் தலைவில்லை, +[181.440 --> 207.820] நா +[207.820 --> 216.020] ஓர் ஓர் ஓர் ஓர் ரோ இ Kirrullweg ஓர் ஓர்best வேறம் சுயள்ளத்தில் +[223.020 --> 224.420] நம்பாதிங்கள் +[224.420 --> 226.620] ஓர் ஓரு ஓர் ஓர் மாதிங்கள். +[226.620 --> 228.220] தன்னிக்குவின் தவிறாயேはいென்றும். +[228.220 --> 229.620] தன்னிக் கூறின்றவர் ஓர் நிசீர்கள்? +[229.620 --> 233.180] நணையவி antidின்ற போர் ஓர் ஓர் ஓர diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_-1KAZ_YxE0Y.txt b/transcript/ceremony_-1KAZ_YxE0Y.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..492ed474f420ea7479329d0d71e552a2ed35795b --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_-1KAZ_YxE0Y.txt @@ -0,0 +1,129 @@ +[0.000 --> 16.000] Hello. +[16.000 --> 24.000] I am your raking master. +[24.000 --> 46.000] Today I am going to be performing an attunement ceremony on you, young warrior. +[46.000 --> 64.000] I will be using the power of my hands to attune you. +[64.000 --> 80.000] There are several attunements that shall be permanently installed into your body when we are through. +[80.000 --> 100.000] The purpose of the level one to an rake master attunement is to permanently raise your vibrations into the spiritual world. +[100.000 --> 110.000] You will have a greater sense of awareness when we are through with the ceremony. +[110.000 --> 132.000] I ask you through the power of Malam Takata, Hussui and Ayashi and all the spirits and above to guide me through the process of attuning you. +[132.000 --> 140.000] We shall now begin. +[140.000 --> 146.000] I ask you before you came here to meditate for a few minutes while waiting. +[146.000 --> 158.000] I attune many rake masters in this globe and you are next. +[158.000 --> 170.000] So you are here today for a reason and that reason has brought you here in front of me. +[170.000 --> 174.000] You are destined to do this. +[174.000 --> 182.000] We as healers must look out for each other. +[182.000 --> 194.000] We must protect others from danger and people like us create a balance on this earth. +[194.000 --> 200.000] Without us there would be mass chaos. +[200.000 --> 210.000] So it is important that every student is properly trained and attuned. +[210.000 --> 220.000] You will experience 21 days of the cycle once we are through with this. +[220.000 --> 228.000] After the cycle is complete you will officially be attuned. +[228.000 --> 240.000] So I will get started right now and I will say some things from time to time so that you learn something from me. +[240.000 --> 248.000] But most of the time I will be silent as I am attuning you. +[248.000 --> 252.000] Is that understood? +[252.000 --> 260.000] All right, let's begin. +[260.000 --> 274.000] I ask that you close your eyes, raise your hands to the prayer position, up to your heart chakra. +[274.000 --> 286.000] And I will stay about two to three feet away from you and begin my intention and the ceremony. +[320.000 --> 342.000] Take a meal. +[342.000 --> 370.000] Chakra. +[370.000 --> 394.000] Take a meal. +[394.000 --> 404.000] Now I ask you to take a relaxing deep breath. +[404.000 --> 414.000] As you perform a silent intonation to yourself opening yourself to receive reiki. +[414.000 --> 424.000] You can say something like I and your name call upon reiki the universal life force. +[424.000 --> 430.000] I am ready and open to receive the reiki attunement. +[430.000 --> 434.000] I will give you a few moments to say this to yourself. +[434.000 --> 438.000] Remember to take a deep breath. +[438.000 --> 446.000] I will ask you to relax and enjoy the intonement ceremony. +[446.000 --> 458.000] I will be going around you and I will be placing my hand on your shoulder. +[458.000 --> 468.000] Chakra. +[468.000 --> 486.000] Chakra. +[486.000 --> 494.000] Now I am going to beam some energy to you. +[494.000 --> 508.000] With my left hand I will hold you back of your head with the sand and the front of your third eye. +[508.000 --> 514.000] Chakra. +[514.000 --> 522.000] Now the throat chakra. +[522.000 --> 528.000] And again my hand will go in the back of your neck and this will go in front. +[528.000 --> 534.000] Chakra. +[534.000 --> 542.000] Chakra. +[542.000 --> 552.000] Now moving on to the heart chakra. +[552.000 --> 562.000] Chakra. +[562.000 --> 572.000] Just shout out. +[572.000 --> 580.000] Leave your hands in the prayer position please. +[602.000 --> 612.000] Chakra. +[612.000 --> 622.000] Chakra. +[622.000 --> 628.000] Now I will beam this energy into your arms. +[628.000 --> 632.000] Chakra. +[632.000 --> 642.000] Now I will be moving around you constantly, gently and setting my intentions to you. +[642.000 --> 652.000] Chakra. +[652.000 --> 656.000] Chakra. +[656.000 --> 666.000] Chakra. +[666.000 --> 676.000] Chakra. +[676.000 --> 686.000] Chakra. +[686.000 --> 696.000] Now I will be moving around you. +[696.000 --> 706.000] Chakra. +[706.000 --> 716.000] Chakra. +[716.000 --> 726.000] Chakra. +[726.000 --> 736.000] Chakra. +[736.000 --> 746.000] Chakra. +[746.000 --> 754.000] Now I ask you to remove your hands from the prayer position and allow me to write into them. +[754.000 --> 758.000] Open them up like a book. +[758.000 --> 764.000] Thank you. +[766.000 --> 772.000] Chakra. +[772.000 --> 776.000] Chakra. +[776.000 --> 780.000] Now the other palm. +[780.000 --> 786.000] Chakra. +[786.000 --> 796.000] Chakra. +[796.000 --> 806.000] Chakra. +[806.000 --> 816.000] Chakra. +[816.000 --> 826.000] Chakra. +[826.000 --> 836.000] Chakra. +[836.000 --> 846.000] Chakra. +[846.000 --> 856.000] Chakra. +[856.000 --> 866.000] Chakra. +[866.000 --> 876.000] Chakra. +[876.000 --> 886.000] Chakra. +[886.000 --> 896.000] Chakra. +[896.000 --> 906.000] Chakra. +[906.000 --> 916.000] Now I will be moving your hands back into prayer position. +[916.000 --> 926.000] Chakra. +[926.000 --> 936.000] Chakra. +[936.000 --> 946.000] Chakra. +[946.000 --> 956.000] Chakra. +[956.000 --> 966.000] Chakra. +[966.000 --> 976.000] Chakra. +[976.000 --> 986.000] Chakra. +[986.000 --> 994.000] Now I kindly ask that you take your hands and put them down to your lap. +[994.000 --> 998.000] We are finishing the ceremony now. +[998.000 --> 1004.000] Thank you. +[1024.000 --> 1044.000] Thank you. +[1044.000 --> 1054.000] You can now come back to full awareness in your own time whenever you are ready. +[1054.000 --> 1056.000] Thank you. +[1056.000 --> 1060.000] What is it that you have felt during this ceremony? +[1060.000 --> 1066.000] How do you truly feel? +[1066.000 --> 1074.000] It is important to know this and state this so that you may feel as if the achievement has worked. +[1074.000 --> 1082.000] Sometimes people may not feel anything at all, but a lot of times they do. +[1082.000 --> 1086.000] Especially during the 21-day cycle. +[1086.000 --> 1092.000] It can be challenging for some, for some it is effortless. +[1092.000 --> 1100.000] You may feel free to communicate with others, whether it be your friends, family or unforems. +[1100.000 --> 1108.000] This way you may have a better understanding of how the achievement works. +[1108.000 --> 1112.000] It is different for everybody, for every soul. +[1112.000 --> 1122.000] But I am glad to hear you feel this way and I am glad to know it has worked in your favor. +[1122.000 --> 1128.000] You may come back to me at any time if you have any questions. +[1128.000 --> 1132.000] Or if you feel as if something is wrong. +[1132.000 --> 1140.000] The achievement will raise your vibrations and will make you more aware of your own intuitions. +[1140.000 --> 1148.000] You will feel a stronger sense of belonging to the earth, a stronger sense of grounding. +[1148.000 --> 1152.000] You will want to go outside and nature a lot these next three weeks. +[1152.000 --> 1156.000] You will want to drink a lot of water. +[1156.000 --> 1164.000] And when you leave from here, please make sure to wash your hands with cold running water and so. +[1164.000 --> 1168.000] And drink an ice cold glass of water. +[1168.000 --> 1176.000] This way the ceremony can ground you and make you feel like it is finished. +[1176.000 --> 1182.000] Okay? Thank you for coming here today. +[1182.000 --> 1184.000] I have other students to attend right now. +[1184.000 --> 1192.000] So if you would kindly step down that hall, take the next right into the doorway and be on your way. +[1192.000 --> 1206.000] The universe thinks you are your kind gesture and for being a part of the healing community. +[1206.000 --> 1210.000] Remember we are not healers. We do not heal. +[1210.000 --> 1218.000] We just allow the raky to flow through us from the universe that is a blessing. +[1218.000 --> 1226.000] We do not emit the healing itself. We are just a channel. +[1226.000 --> 1232.000] Okay? Remember to study your notes. +[1232.000 --> 1238.000] Remember how to draw the symbols, which I have been chanting this whole time. +[1238.000 --> 1246.000] Chokure, Seheki, Hunches of Shonen and Daikomyo. +[1246.000 --> 1250.000] May love and light and peace be with you. +[1250.000 --> 1254.000] Take care now. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_-hzfAaWtzYw.txt b/transcript/ceremony_-hzfAaWtzYw.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a9d3f0a86661816c0cdc8d13d4ff8fdb4fb72cd1 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_-hzfAaWtzYw.txt @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +[30.000 --> 43.760] Today you will receive a demonstration on how to conduct squad drill. +[43.760 --> 49.440] Demonstrator, post. +[49.440 --> 52.720] After the squad has moved to his designated area, the squad leader will post himself +[52.720 --> 58.040] at a designated point and command, fall in. +[58.040 --> 61.660] The right flank man positions himself so that when the squad is formed, it is three +[61.660 --> 64.500] steps in front of and centered on the squad leader. +[64.500 --> 68.520] The right flank man comes to the position of attention and raises left arm laterally +[68.520 --> 73.080] at shoulder level, elbow locked, fingers and thumbs extended and joined and palm facing +[73.080 --> 74.080] down. +[74.080 --> 78.240] While other members of the squad form in the same manner except that the left flank man +[78.240 --> 80.800] does not raise his left arm. +[80.800 --> 82.360] The next command is count off. +[82.360 --> 83.960] This is a two-part command. +[83.960 --> 88.320] On the command of execution off of count off, each member except the right flank man turns +[88.320 --> 92.640] his head and eyes to the right and the right flank man counts off with one. +[92.640 --> 96.200] After the man to the right counts off his number, the man to his left counts off the next +[96.200 --> 100.120] higher number and simultaneously turns his head and eyes to the front. +[100.120 --> 104.120] All the other members execute count off in the same manner until the entire squad is counted +[104.120 --> 112.120] off. +[112.120 --> 115.240] After the squad is formed, the squader will then align the squad. +[115.240 --> 121.400] In order to align the squad, you must give the command Dress Right Dress. +[121.400 --> 126.280] On the command of execution Dress, of Dress Right Dress, the right flank man stands fast. +[126.280 --> 129.880] Each member except the right flank man turns his head and eyes to the right and aligns +[129.880 --> 132.320] himself with the man on his right. +[132.320 --> 136.720] Each member except the left flank man extends his left arm, laterally at shoulder level, +[136.720 --> 140.320] elbow locked, fingers and thumb is centered and joined and palm facing down. +[140.320 --> 144.560] The squad leader then faces the half left in marching and marches by the most direct route +[144.560 --> 149.320] to a position on line with the squad, halts one step from the right flank man and faces +[149.320 --> 150.760] down the line. +[150.760 --> 155.000] From his position, he verifies the alignment of the squad, directing the men to move forward +[155.000 --> 157.440] or backward as necessary. +[157.440 --> 161.360] Once the alignment is verified, he will face to the half right in marching and return to +[161.360 --> 166.360] his position, centered on the squad, halts perpendicular to the formation and faces to +[166.360 --> 169.040] the left. +[169.040 --> 171.000] The next command is ready front. +[171.000 --> 176.320] On the command of execution front, each member sharply returns to the position of attention. +[176.320 --> 179.440] Ready, foot. +[179.440 --> 183.080] Once the squad is aligned, the squad leader will then execute in about face and the SGL +[183.080 --> 188.080] will command inspect the squad. +[188.080 --> 190.080] Inspect the squad. +[190.080 --> 194.160] The squad leader will execute another about face and inspect the squad. +[194.160 --> 198.040] The squad leader marches forward and to the left, inclines as necessary until he is at +[198.040 --> 201.240] the point 15 inches in front of and centered on the first man. +[201.240 --> 206.280] The squad leader remains at a modified position of attention, moving his head and eyes only. +[206.280 --> 210.080] After inspecting at the center position, he takes a short step forward and to the left +[210.080 --> 212.520] and inspects. +[212.520 --> 218.600] Return to the center and steps forward and to the right and inspects. +[218.600 --> 220.560] And returns to the center position. +[220.560 --> 224.640] Having expected the first man, the squad leader faces to the right as in marching and takes +[224.640 --> 242.720] two steps, halts and faces the next man at the appropriate distance. +[242.720 --> 259.680] The squad leader conducts the inspection for the rest of the soldiers and the squad. +[259.680 --> 264.040] After inspecting the last soldier in the squad, the squad leader faces to the right as in marching +[264.040 --> 269.000] and marches around behind the squad, inclining as necessary, while the squad leader marches +[269.000 --> 275.560] back to his post he inspect the squad from the rear. +[275.560 --> 281.720] After resuming his post facing the squad, he will command at ease. +[281.720 --> 285.960] The squad leader will then execute an about face and assume the position of at ease. +[285.960 --> 292.320] The SGL will then give the command to march the squad. +[292.320 --> 293.320] March the squad. +[293.320 --> 297.280] In order to march the squad, you must first bring the squad to attention and then give +[297.280 --> 299.720] the command right face. +[299.720 --> 304.400] When marching the squad, you will be evaluated on the following commands. +[304.400 --> 309.640] Forward march, column right march, column left march, column half right march, column half +[309.640 --> 316.720] left march, right flank march, left flank march, rear march, squad halt, left face and +[316.720 --> 319.480] dismissed. +[319.480 --> 321.480] Squad, attention! +[321.480 --> 322.720] Right face! +[322.720 --> 323.720] Forward march! +[324.300 --> 345.220] Forward march, left right, left right, column right march, left right, left right right, +[345.220 --> 352.460] left right left right, left right, left right left left right left in flow +[352.460 --> 382.460] right, right flick, march left, right, left, left, left, right, left, left, right, left, right, left, right, right, left, right, left, right, left, right, left, right, left, left, right, left, left, left, right, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left +[382.460 --> 412.460] left left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, left, right, left, right, left, right Radar +[412.460 --> 415.460] Left right, march left right. +[415.460 --> 424.460] Left, left, left right left left left right left left right left left. +[424.460 --> 429.460] Left march on, march left right left right right. +[429.460 --> 432.460] Left right, squat, hold. +[435.460 --> 437.460] Left, face. +[437.460 --> 440.460] Dismest. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_3yYjYvdcCw8.txt b/transcript/ceremony_3yYjYvdcCw8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f82869fe8e2b10a2d3b95afc9960bdfefc0ebcb7 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_3yYjYvdcCw8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,115 @@ +[0.000 --> 22.560] Do you know that the least popular public speakers use an average of 272 hand gestures during +[22.560 --> 25.200] the 18-minute talk? +[25.200 --> 33.560] Whereas the most popular public speakers use an average of 465 hand gestures in an 18-minute +[33.560 --> 36.880] talk, that's almost the double. +[36.880 --> 44.000] And this fact completely shocked me and made me think why are hand gestures so important? +[44.000 --> 47.600] And what are the most popular hand gestures? +[47.600 --> 53.300] I also thought of how can everyone use their hand gestures to deliver an effective +[53.300 --> 54.300] talk? +[54.300 --> 60.700] So, what I did is I observed some well-known public speakers and then created a list of +[60.700 --> 67.020] top six hand gestures that can help you deliver an influential public speech. +[67.020 --> 71.300] So this is Michelle and you're watching me on Skillopedia, the place to learn skills +[71.300 --> 72.580] for the real world. +[72.580 --> 80.540] So let's begin with the first gesture. +[80.540 --> 85.620] So the first gesture that I'm going to talk about today is, hmm, hmm, hmm. +[85.620 --> 89.460] Well, do you think, can you guess what I mean here? +[89.460 --> 91.460] I mean listing. +[91.460 --> 96.380] The easiest and most basic hand gesture is listing. +[96.380 --> 100.700] Anytime you say a number, you can list it with your hand. +[100.700 --> 107.260] This adds movement and warmth to your body language and also attracts the listeners attention. +[107.260 --> 111.460] So let's see an example of how you can use this gesture in your speech. +[111.460 --> 117.460] So imagine that you're delivering a speech on why and how to deliver a good public speech. +[117.460 --> 122.260] For this, you can say, one, you need the skill of controlling anxiety. +[122.260 --> 126.980] Second, you need the skill of creating good PowerPoint presentations. +[126.980 --> 130.940] And third, the skill of maintaining eye contact. +[130.940 --> 137.420] And fourth, the list, the art of telling stories and lastly, using humor. +[137.420 --> 141.700] So what you just noticed is, I used my hand to draw your attention. +[141.700 --> 146.860] So the next time you're adding any numbers in your presentation, make sure that you use +[146.860 --> 154.660] your hands to do the list. +[154.660 --> 159.740] The next useful gesture is to show the level of something. +[159.740 --> 165.580] So this is a really easy one and can be used literally to show someone what level something +[165.580 --> 166.580] is. +[166.580 --> 170.380] For example, if something is high or if something is low, you can use this to indicate +[170.380 --> 174.660] how big or small something is or where someone stands. +[174.660 --> 176.260] Let's look at an example. +[176.260 --> 182.820] You can use the high version like this for saying something like, it's a pretty big deal. +[182.820 --> 187.900] Or you can use the lower version by saying, it's a matter of least importance. +[187.900 --> 192.580] So it's a pretty big deal and it's a matter of least importance. +[192.580 --> 196.900] Not only that, you can use this as an alternative to listing. +[196.900 --> 198.500] As you talk about different stages. +[198.500 --> 203.580] For example, you could say in a speech, we start with the introduction, then move on to +[203.580 --> 207.580] the structure and we end with the conclusion. +[207.580 --> 212.580] So here, I've used my hand to show the level or the structure of something. +[217.900 --> 223.860] And next up is the very popular hand gesture, which is pointing gesture. +[223.860 --> 228.940] So you didn't expect this to be on the list and you might be confused that is it positive +[228.940 --> 229.940] or negative. +[229.940 --> 234.580] Well, I would say that this one should be used with caution because normally people don't +[234.580 --> 236.420] like to be pointed at. +[236.420 --> 238.900] It can seem as if you're accusing them. +[238.900 --> 243.540] However, you can point to get someone's attention or literally to make a point. +[243.540 --> 250.100] For example, this gesture goes very well along with saying something like, you know, I just +[250.100 --> 256.020] remembered something important or you could say, this one's important or you could use +[256.020 --> 260.180] pointing when you want to say, let me tell you something. +[260.180 --> 262.180] All right. +[262.180 --> 265.940] So here we looked at, we've looked at three hand gestures and now we're going to look +[265.940 --> 273.100] at the fourth one. +[273.100 --> 277.220] So the next hand gesture is this and that. +[277.220 --> 281.300] Whenever you want to separate two different ideas or things that you're saying, you can use +[281.300 --> 283.460] your hands to represent that. +[283.460 --> 290.540] For example, I might say we are totally different from them using my left hand when I say we +[290.540 --> 292.820] and my right hand when I say them. +[292.820 --> 298.340] So this is a great way to put distance between two things and show that these are two separate +[298.340 --> 300.660] things or two separate ideas. +[300.660 --> 306.700] So once again, you could say you are totally different from them. +[306.700 --> 310.140] Also you can use this gesture to show a change. +[310.140 --> 312.820] It can be used along with this example. +[312.820 --> 319.780] It really changed my mind from positive to negative or you could say, I stopped doing +[319.780 --> 324.060] hard work after I learned about smart work. +[324.060 --> 331.220] So just like listing whenever you're contrasting different ideas, use your hands to show it. +[331.220 --> 336.500] This is a powerful persuasion technique which means it can persuade your audience to believe +[336.500 --> 340.460] what you're saying is right or to convince them of your opinion. +[340.460 --> 345.820] So this can go well with this and that or when you're talking about two different places, +[345.820 --> 350.100] here and there or about the size, big and small. +[350.100 --> 355.060] I believe you've got the idea of how to use this hand gesture to separate two different +[355.060 --> 356.060] things. +[356.060 --> 366.780] Now, to build on my previous point about engaging the audience, so you use your hands to engage +[366.780 --> 368.180] the audience. +[368.180 --> 370.620] You can also use some prompting gestures. +[370.620 --> 372.860] So you might wonder what are prompting gestures. +[372.860 --> 377.180] So these are those gestures that when you ask audience to do something, you do it along +[377.180 --> 378.180] with them. +[378.180 --> 382.020] If you ask your listeners to raise their hand, you raise it along with them. +[382.020 --> 386.420] Or if you ask them to clap or perform any other action, you do it with them. +[386.420 --> 391.420] So this is the reason you need to do this is to get them more engaged in your talk. +[391.420 --> 397.420] For example, you might say raise your hand if you want to earn million dollar this year. +[397.420 --> 402.060] So when you say this, you should first raise your hand because people and your audience +[402.060 --> 403.980] will follow you, right? +[403.980 --> 408.020] This is because your audience is more likely to do it if they see you doing it. +[408.020 --> 412.140] But if you don't do it, there's a high possibility that they won't do it. +[412.140 --> 415.900] So if you think you and your audience are super enthusiastic, you could even ask them +[415.900 --> 420.700] to jump up and down on the spot if they want to earn a million dollars this year. +[420.700 --> 426.020] But as I mentioned earlier, if you want them to perform any specific action, you must do +[426.020 --> 433.260] it with them first. +[433.260 --> 440.260] So when it comes down to using gestures effectively, I guess the rule is, if the gestures are supporting +[440.260 --> 444.180] what you are saying, then they are probably going to be great. +[444.180 --> 448.100] And if they take you away from what you are saying, like probably you're scratching your +[448.100 --> 454.020] face or are trusting your clothes or playing with your ring or probably, you know, clasping +[454.020 --> 460.580] your hands, then they're probably taking away from your presentation and not really adding. +[460.580 --> 464.260] But then of the day, it comes down to preparation and practice. +[464.260 --> 467.820] And with gestures, the most important thing is to be natural. +[467.820 --> 471.700] So don't really try and force yourself if you don't feel natural. +[471.700 --> 475.660] If it is flowing like it does in everyday conversations with your friends and family, +[475.660 --> 479.260] then it's a good sign and you should go ahead with using those gestures. +[479.260 --> 484.140] So you need to find out which one of these gestures are you comfortable with? +[484.140 --> 488.340] Which one of these gestures would you like to involve in your presentation? +[488.340 --> 491.140] Because not all gestures can be used by everybody. +[491.140 --> 496.180] So pick up your top three and leave them in the comments so I can find out which hand +[496.180 --> 500.700] gestures would you like to use to deliver an effective speech. +[500.700 --> 502.220] So thank you so much for staying with me. +[502.220 --> 504.940] I hope this session has been helpful for you. +[504.940 --> 509.060] And next time when you're delivering your speech, you will not stand with your hands like +[509.060 --> 512.060] this, like this or like this. +[512.060 --> 516.980] It's a good idea to use this powerful tool to deliver an effective speech. +[516.980 --> 518.860] So thank you so much for staying with me. +[518.860 --> 520.660] See you soon in another session. +[520.660 --> 521.660] Bye. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_5Qm-4a2rwIU.txt b/transcript/ceremony_5Qm-4a2rwIU.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8f07ae26dc295243dd169218d308b6ff8d2fdb97 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_5Qm-4a2rwIU.txt @@ -0,0 +1,57 @@ +[0.000 --> 14.660] Only one thing is certain since the beginning of a person's life. +[14.660 --> 16.820] Someday it's gotta end. +[16.820 --> 23.040] After a human passes, the loved ones gather for a ritual to say their final goodbyes. +[23.040 --> 28.220] Around the world, there are a hundred different ways as rituals performed. +[28.220 --> 34.940] In these ceremonies, there are certain things every organizer attempts to control, such +[34.940 --> 41.340] as the setting, who gives the eulogy, and maybe the music they play during the ceremony. +[41.340 --> 49.140] However, one thing no one can account for is how the guests may act or behave at the funeral. +[49.140 --> 54.900] Today, we will look at the traditional American funeral where on these sad days, there is +[54.900 --> 62.240] an socially accepted code for how to act, what to wear, and how to express properly +[62.240 --> 63.560] with body language. +[63.560 --> 69.480] In this video, we will review some of these things deemed unacceptable in the funeral. +[69.480 --> 75.640] For starters, traditionally, funerals only typically accept dark colors. +[75.640 --> 77.800] So primarily black. +[77.800 --> 82.880] This dress code is to be theorized, to have been derived from the ancient Romans, who wore +[82.900 --> 87.400] black tougas at their funerals as a sign of respect. +[87.400 --> 92.820] Thus wearing bright clothing will not only be considered disrespectful, but also garnered +[92.820 --> 94.960] negative attention. +[94.960 --> 101.460] Moreover, another key part of funerals is to be attentive, and maybe utilizing artifacts +[101.460 --> 107.600] such as headphones or phones in general will also garnered negative attention. +[107.600 --> 113.440] Ananaphero is also essential to be mindful of how you communicate now verbally through +[113.440 --> 115.040] kinesics. +[115.040 --> 119.920] For example, during the ceremony, there will be a time when loved ones will approach the +[119.920 --> 123.440] coffin to pay their respects individually. +[123.440 --> 129.040] While it is okay to showcase emotion and get close to the body, it is never okay to +[129.040 --> 131.360] hug the body as you cry. +[131.360 --> 135.960] In these situations, it would be more apt to pay respects while maintaining distance +[135.960 --> 138.200] from the body. +[138.200 --> 144.280] In general, you should approach near intimate distance with care and mindfulness. +[144.280 --> 149.160] Another important thing to note is that as the ceremony commences, it is important to +[149.160 --> 154.900] stay seated, which not only shows respect, but also creates less distraction for those +[154.900 --> 157.560] conducting the eulogies. +[157.560 --> 163.680] On the contrary, dancing during any part of the funeral is never acceptable. +[163.680 --> 169.560] Not only is it disrespectful, but it will come across as someone may be celebrating someone +[169.560 --> 171.640] else's death. +[171.640 --> 175.760] Not to mention, it can also cause an unnecessary distraction. +[175.760 --> 181.360] But teach their own, just not typically. +[181.360 --> 187.080] Arriving on time is also extremely important for a funeral ceremony, because if you rush +[187.080 --> 193.080] into the building in the middle of the ceremony, not only will it distract those around +[193.080 --> 199.000] you, but it may reflect poorly and be considered disrespectful. +[199.000 --> 207.000] Moreover, leaving early without any notice would also be regarded as rude or maybe disrespectful, +[207.000 --> 210.200] especially to the loved ones of the deceased. +[210.200 --> 216.600] Lastly, most importantly, all guests have to monitor their vocalics. +[216.600 --> 221.680] Everything from the tone behind what you say to the volume at which you speak. +[221.680 --> 227.000] In our opinion, this is the most significant form of nonverbal communication you must monitor +[227.000 --> 229.160] at a funeral. +[229.160 --> 235.640] This especially holds true during eulogy, whereas an audience member, you must be quiet +[235.640 --> 240.200] and provide undivided attention to the speaker. +[240.200 --> 246.880] Indeed, it is not a time to be too disruptive of any kind, like maybe taking a business call +[246.880 --> 248.600] for example. +[248.600 --> 254.880] As you reach the end of our review on the nonverbal aspects of funeral etiquette, it's important +[254.880 --> 258.640] to reflect on the key points we've covered today. +[258.640 --> 266.160] Remember, the way we conduct ourselves nonverbaly at funerals speaks volumes about our respect +[266.160 --> 269.520] and empathy towards the bereaved. +[269.520 --> 276.280] Our nonverbal behaviors are funerals from our attire to our gestures, punctuality to +[276.280 --> 283.040] our tone of voice, all contribute to a respectful and empathetic environment. +[283.040 --> 288.640] It's not just about what we say, but how we say it, and what we do that truly matters +[288.640 --> 290.040] in these moments of mourning. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_9pk7EiWXoks.txt b/transcript/ceremony_9pk7EiWXoks.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ed272f4936e744f8d7a9fed9efb8698955ae68ad --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_9pk7EiWXoks.txt @@ -0,0 +1,102 @@ +[0.000 --> 9.480] The body language is our nonverbal communication, the physical part of it. +[9.480 --> 15.200] And it's the way that we respond and display the power around us. +[15.200 --> 19.680] I'm Mark Bowden, I'm an expert in human behavior and body language. +[19.680 --> 24.960] I'm honored to be here with President Enrake, Pinyet, Niayta, +[24.960 --> 29.080] and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, who has also become a great friend. +[29.080 --> 31.080] This has been a battle. +[31.080 --> 35.800] So notice there on that idea of a battle and that in-draw of breath. +[35.800 --> 40.560] It's rather like the sound that you make when you've been hurt in some way. +[40.560 --> 42.880] So it seems like the nonverbal communication there, +[42.880 --> 46.120] including the tonality that sounds being made, +[46.120 --> 51.800] are an indicator of the battle being one that hurt him in some way. +[51.800 --> 55.080] And battle sometimes make great friendship, so it's really terrific. +[56.080 --> 61.840] We both agree he's a special man and he's really done a good job. +[61.840 --> 63.840] I appreciate it. +[63.840 --> 67.480] You can see it's quite a touchy, feely meeting there. +[67.480 --> 71.040] Trump goes out to the shoulders of both parties. +[71.040 --> 75.800] He goes for almost a stroke gesture on Trudeau at one point +[75.800 --> 79.000] and then changes it to coming round the back of the shoulder. +[79.000 --> 80.800] It's a little more controlling. +[80.800 --> 86.320] When it's a soft gesture, the other is a harder gesture that might control. +[86.320 --> 89.880] So was he going to comfort Trudeau first off +[89.880 --> 93.160] and then decided to switch to controlling him? +[93.160 --> 95.560] Again, I'd need more data than this, +[95.560 --> 99.760] but those are a couple of options that seem to show up for me here. +[99.760 --> 103.760] And Donald, it's all the more reason why we need to keep working +[103.760 --> 107.920] to remove the tariffs on steel and aluminum between our countries. +[107.960 --> 112.080] Now, check out Trump's finger here on the lectern. +[114.160 --> 119.040] The way it's moving impatiently needs this to move on. +[119.040 --> 123.160] Now, having said that, that's often shown with Trump. +[123.160 --> 126.400] This may not be an indicator of this specific situation, +[126.400 --> 128.600] but often when other people are speaking, +[128.600 --> 130.320] there's a little bit of impatience there. +[130.320 --> 134.400] We need to keep working to remove the tariffs on steel and aluminum +[134.400 --> 135.920] between our countries. +[135.960 --> 139.240] We see lip-person there. +[139.240 --> 142.960] Something is being squeezed in, squeezed down. +[142.960 --> 147.800] There's something that is not going to be said at this point. +[147.800 --> 152.960] I'm at the end of it all, that little bit of a mouth-fran gesture that says, +[152.960 --> 155.360] yeah, I just don't think that's going to happen. +[155.360 --> 157.360] Can you just dream me, bro? +[157.360 --> 158.760] Look at this, Dan. +[158.760 --> 161.760] Once again, thank you all for being here today. +[161.760 --> 164.600] As Trudeau says, once again, you see this. +[164.600 --> 167.760] They kind of smirk from Trump there. +[167.760 --> 171.680] Now, often people think that's something called Jupiter's Delight. +[171.680 --> 176.520] It means that somebody is smirking with delight as they've duped somebody. +[176.520 --> 181.800] However, in this case, Jupiter's Delight tends to be really quick, really fast. +[181.800 --> 183.560] This is prolonged. +[183.560 --> 188.040] So whether it's that Trump can't pull a full pleasurable smile at that point, +[188.040 --> 193.800] or whether it might be that sense of, hey, I think I got one over on this bunch. +[193.800 --> 197.160] Tough to tell, because usually Jupiter's Delight gets quick and it's sharp, +[197.160 --> 200.800] and it's a bit of a microgestion. +[200.800 --> 203.880] Now, the handshake at the end of that is pretty cursory. +[203.880 --> 208.640] Trump, though, is crossing his body with the hand there. +[208.640 --> 210.160] He doesn't reach out a lot. +[210.160 --> 214.760] He won't pull himself off balance or shift his body in any strong way +[214.760 --> 216.680] to make that distance. +[216.680 --> 220.240] Trudeau, in order to get the handshake in, has to reach right out. +[220.240 --> 222.480] He has to go the further distance. +[222.480 --> 228.520] Again, can this be seen as an allegous to the deal in general? +[228.520 --> 230.400] You know, hard to tell. +[230.400 --> 236.600] With body language, we need as much data as possible to get closer to the truth. +[236.600 --> 242.520] But there's strong possibilities here, I think, that somebody is more happy than somebody else +[242.520 --> 245.200] about this deal that's been made. +[245.200 --> 246.200] Let's go. +[246.200 --> 247.200] Let's go. +[247.200 --> 248.200] Let's go. +[248.200 --> 250.200] Take a look at Freeland. +[250.200 --> 253.240] She's doing what we might call noddies in the back. +[253.240 --> 257.040] That's when you nod in agreement to everything that's been going on +[257.040 --> 262.360] just to give a positive feeling and a positive attitude around that. +[262.360 --> 267.720] What's in the back, smiling, nodding, trying to give the aura that this is going really well. +[267.720 --> 270.560] This is a good deal. +[270.560 --> 273.000] But now, look carefully at that smile. +[273.000 --> 274.840] Is it a true smile? +[274.840 --> 277.000] Is it a smile that when you look at it, you go, +[277.000 --> 282.120] oh, that's a really good, true, pleasurable feeling that she has. +[282.120 --> 284.480] I'm not sure that's a true smile. +[284.480 --> 289.440] And there's a downward frown in it and it's like bitterness in taste there. +[289.440 --> 294.480] I think that there's been an instruction to make out this is really good. +[294.480 --> 299.120] And I think somewhere in somebody's mind, it's not as good as hoped. +[299.120 --> 306.080] Notice what Trudeau's doing there. +[306.080 --> 310.960] Every time he signs, he signs quickly as head comes up and he stays very still and serious +[310.960 --> 319.200] for the cameras to capture his head up, a serious expression and the other two, signing. +[319.200 --> 325.680] Is that in order to capture a photograph that looks like he's a little more reticent, +[325.680 --> 333.760] a little less in agreement with what's being ultimately signed by him. +[333.760 --> 343.800] Have a look at the aggression and the noise that came from when Trudeau shut the document. +[343.800 --> 345.520] It's now closed. +[345.520 --> 346.920] It's now done. +[346.920 --> 349.680] He made a whole different sound than the other two. +[349.680 --> 352.520] He closed it a little more gently. +[352.520 --> 355.400] He's not caring for it as much. +[355.400 --> 367.240] He doesn't care for the agreement as much. +[367.240 --> 369.000] That's the nature of photographs. +[369.000 --> 373.920] They capture a moment in time and you don't see what's around it. +[373.920 --> 380.120] And of course, we can all set up photographs to get a particular story across. +[380.120 --> 384.920] So when you're reading body language or trying to get the sense of somebody's feelings +[384.920 --> 391.320] and intentions from a still image, chances are you're not taking in the full context. +[391.320 --> 396.840] That's why you want to get to reports and watch the whole thing moving with the sound +[396.840 --> 400.600] to get a better idea of exactly what's going on. +[400.600 --> 405.960] A photograph may give you some of the truth, but it's not going to get you the accuracy +[405.960 --> 407.960] of getting the whole picture. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_AfBFNBVGoQQ.txt b/transcript/ceremony_AfBFNBVGoQQ.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..600339bad9d29064e71f4a9d0e52bc810720f2c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_AfBFNBVGoQQ.txt @@ -0,0 +1,932 @@ +[0.000 --> 2.620] Today we're going to talk about Will Smith. +[2.620 --> 5.120] We're going to do an analysis on his video that he did with, +[5.120 --> 8.440] and when he was doing an interview with Trevor Noah a few days ago. +[8.440 --> 10.560] Greg, let's tell us about the videos we're going to watch. +[10.560 --> 15.000] I think that's all you really get is he's asking him questions about the Chris Rockens +[15.000 --> 16.440] and a couple other things. +[16.440 --> 18.240] That's all you need to know. +[18.240 --> 19.640] You know, you are... +[19.640 --> 21.360] You know what? You know what? +[21.360 --> 22.560] You will Smith. +[22.560 --> 23.560] Yeah. +[23.560 --> 26.640] You are one of the biggest movie stars that has ever existed. +[26.640 --> 30.280] You know, one of my favorite people that I've ever seen in Habit Ascreen. +[30.280 --> 31.120] Thank you, man. +[31.120 --> 35.800] And then you had the Oscars where in one night... +[35.800 --> 38.800] I have no independent recollection of... +[38.800 --> 40.160] I can only imagine. +[40.160 --> 44.840] Because you won your first Oscar that night. +[44.840 --> 50.000] Well deserved Oscar that night, but it is simultaneously in many ways. +[50.000 --> 52.080] Not the worst. I won't say the worst, because I know the life you've lived. +[52.080 --> 53.080] I've read the book. +[53.080 --> 55.560] But it is one of the best days of your life. +[55.560 --> 58.000] And one of the worst days of your life. +[58.000 --> 59.360] And I would love to know. +[59.360 --> 62.920] I mean, just, you know, I was talking, first of all, +[62.920 --> 66.640] what has the journey been like since that day? +[66.640 --> 69.440] Like, because we... Everyone speculates. +[69.440 --> 71.040] Everyone just sees it and goes, I think this... +[71.040 --> 72.720] I think that, I think this, I think that... +[72.720 --> 73.720] What has it been like for you? +[73.720 --> 78.480] Yeah, that was a horrific night, as you can imagine. +[78.480 --> 89.800] You know, there's many nuances and complexities to it, you know. +[89.800 --> 94.120] But at the end of the day, I just... I lost it, you know. +[94.120 --> 99.920] And I guess what I would say... +[99.920 --> 104.600] You just never know what somebody's going through, you know? +[104.600 --> 111.320] In the audience right now, you know, you're sitting next to strangers, you know? +[111.320 --> 116.680] And somebody's mother died last week, you know? +[116.680 --> 120.120] Somebody's child is sick, you know? +[120.120 --> 122.520] Somebody just lost their job. +[122.520 --> 125.560] Somebody just found out their spouse cheated, you know? +[125.560 --> 129.360] It's like, there's all these things and these strangers. +[129.360 --> 134.560] And you just don't know what's going on with people, you know? +[134.600 --> 138.840] And I was going through something that night, you know? +[138.840 --> 143.520] And not that that, you know, justifies my behavior at all. +[143.520 --> 146.360] I would just say, you know, you're asking what did I learn? +[146.360 --> 148.240] And it's that... +[151.040 --> 153.360] We just got to be nice to each other, man. +[153.360 --> 156.240] You know, it's like, it's hard. +[156.240 --> 161.120] And I guess the thing that was most painful for me is... +[161.120 --> 164.040] I took my heart and made it hard for other people. +[164.200 --> 166.800] You know, it's like I understood the idea +[166.800 --> 168.360] when they say hurt people, hurt people. +[168.360 --> 168.880] Yeah. +[168.880 --> 169.880] You know? +[169.880 --> 171.880] Chase, what do you got? +[172.680 --> 178.920] You know, throughout Will's entire life, he uses socialization to discuss issues. +[178.920 --> 183.480] And I don't think this is a tactic, per se, but I think it's something that he probably +[183.480 --> 188.840] unconsciously learned from a very young age to get people to understand things. +[188.840 --> 192.360] It's also the way he probably sees the entire world. +[192.360 --> 197.480] Will immediately socializes the situation, starting out by shifting the pronouns from himself +[197.480 --> 201.400] to the audience while still describing his own experiences. +[201.400 --> 202.600] I think it's brilliant. +[202.600 --> 208.600] It's a great demonstration of obtaining what we call in psychology social coherence. +[208.600 --> 213.160] And he illustrates some really common situations of suffering that he knows. +[213.160 --> 217.320] And most people should know that a lot of people can identify with. +[217.320 --> 222.040] And I think his lesson learned is that he has to be nice to people. +[223.560 --> 225.240] It's we as a group. +[225.240 --> 229.240] So he's saying that it's we have to be nice, not just me. +[229.240 --> 230.280] So it's everybody. +[230.280 --> 232.440] So he's sharing the grief. +[232.440 --> 235.000] Er, he's sharing some of the problem with the crowd. +[235.000 --> 235.720] We see that there. +[235.720 --> 236.520] Scott, pretty good. +[237.320 --> 237.560] All right. +[237.560 --> 240.120] I think what he's looking for acceptance, obviously. +[240.120 --> 244.520] And once he gets that acceptance from the audience, he sits back and sort of takes it in. +[244.520 --> 245.720] And he almost relaxes. +[246.360 --> 250.760] And then when Trevor says, so what's the journey been like, you know, so far, +[250.760 --> 251.720] he takes a deep breath. +[251.720 --> 255.880] He's getting ready to answer that, getting sort of relaxed and try to stay relaxed because +[256.360 --> 260.280] he's been in therapy and they've gone over how to approach these things because he knows he's +[260.280 --> 263.320] still got two or three of these style interviews left. +[263.960 --> 266.120] And he leans forward as it prepares the answer. +[266.120 --> 267.320] And he bearings with his hands. +[267.320 --> 268.680] It gets that arm out like that. +[268.680 --> 272.680] But he sticks his head out, not over his arms yet, but over his arms. +[272.680 --> 274.680] And that let's us know that he's into it. +[274.680 --> 278.440] He wants to engage, which apparently that's what you'd want to do, you know, +[278.440 --> 280.520] obviously in a situation like this. +[280.520 --> 283.160] So he's getting ready and he's showing that he's engaged. +[284.120 --> 287.480] And I think what we're hearing is he's a victim of. +[287.480 --> 291.560] And I know Greg and I got a differ on this of a language virus where he's saying, +[291.560 --> 296.760] yeah, nah, because in the past, you know, he was saying, yeah, nah, there's not, I'm not +[296.760 --> 299.080] going to say that very often. +[299.080 --> 302.280] And this first one, he says it, excuse me, 18 times. +[303.240 --> 305.720] 18 times in that little clip, he says, +[305.720 --> 309.880] Yana, which sort of completely, completely destroys that +[309.880 --> 313.400] oomph of sincerity or validity for me. +[315.000 --> 319.000] Because it just makes him sound not as smart when he keeps saying, Yana, +[319.000 --> 322.120] when it was, and so it lets you know that he's been around somebody that talks like that. +[322.120 --> 323.320] And he looks up to him. +[323.320 --> 328.520] There they are for the person that that he's maybe taking information from or the person +[328.520 --> 331.560] who's hanging out with him and a new person because quite often that will happen. +[331.560 --> 333.800] You know, he or somebody he thinks really cool and everything. +[333.800 --> 337.400] They'll be using certain terms or phrases and you'll start doing that as well. +[338.920 --> 342.440] Many terms of the audience, he tries to connect with him, but it doesn't take. +[343.080 --> 345.400] When he says, we just have to be good to each other. +[345.880 --> 346.680] That's what it was. +[346.680 --> 351.240] When he says that and he looks at the audience as he's saying it, they don't quite buy it. +[351.240 --> 355.640] And so he's still trying to look relaxed and still trying to explain what's happening. +[357.400 --> 359.320] And then he's throwing out the catchphrases. +[359.320 --> 363.320] He's hurting therapy, like hurt people, hurt people, things like that, which is fine. +[363.320 --> 364.200] It's true. +[364.200 --> 368.200] And all those are valid, but it lets you know where his head's at, where he's coming from. +[368.200 --> 371.320] I don't know if he's doing that on purpose so we can see that he's been in therapy and been +[371.320 --> 375.000] working all this stuff, but that's what he's there for to show he's been working on, +[375.000 --> 377.720] working on himself and trying to pull himself out of this hole he's dug. +[379.480 --> 385.320] I feel sorry for him because he's trying to pull himself out, but so far it's not working really well. +[385.320 --> 389.400] I think it looks good because Trevor Noah is doing such a good job of making him look, +[390.200 --> 394.840] you know, respectful and the way he does interviews, I think this is great. We'll see him +[396.120 --> 398.520] create this thing where okay, here you go, man. +[398.520 --> 402.840] And it keeps this beach ball up with him making him look really, really cool and solid. +[403.720 --> 404.520] Greg, what do you got? +[405.560 --> 410.520] Yeah, I think the you know is a colloquial thing. I don't think he's copying anyone +[410.520 --> 414.280] necessarily. I think it's just become some from somewhere he's hanging out. +[414.280 --> 419.880] It is a delaying technique. What Will Smith does magically is flirtation and I don't mean that's +[419.880 --> 424.440] actually I mean he flirts with the audience, he connects with the audience and draws them into his +[424.440 --> 429.720] space. If you ever pay attention to him, he is really, really trying to connect with an audience. +[429.720 --> 434.440] Anytime he's talking to the interview, he's not talking to interviewer. He turns and faces away +[434.440 --> 439.880] even to get connection with the audience. I agree with you. He tries to flip out there when he talks +[439.880 --> 444.920] about we get all the kind to each other. He gets crickets. You expect clapping and all that. He +[444.920 --> 449.560] did too. You see his face as he turns to look. And he's smart enough. He didn't show that he was +[449.560 --> 455.320] disappointed in that. He went back to you know and he drags out. That's giving him time to slowly +[455.320 --> 459.960] pitch what he wants to say out. I have friends who use that when they're pausing and thinking, +[459.960 --> 464.840] work with people in Chicago specifically who use that term affair amount when I was listening to them. +[465.800 --> 470.280] It's more of a filler than anything else. I also think he's treading a mind field early. +[470.280 --> 474.120] So he's going to be very cautious in this first part. It's clear he knows what Trevor +[474.120 --> 477.880] knows going to talk about. That's not no surprise. You don't see surprise in his face. +[478.440 --> 485.240] And I think we just see more of your debt on chase. The organism does what made the organism successful. +[485.240 --> 491.480] Will Smith has gotten to where he is by being conscious of other people. And he says what we said in +[491.480 --> 496.840] the first analysis that role of the eyes and hard eye contact by the wife was something he was +[496.840 --> 500.920] going through. There's probably more behind the scenes than we even know. A whole lot more +[500.920 --> 506.680] communication that that meant something that we we don't know because they have a micro culture +[506.680 --> 512.360] and that coordinated conversation and quick signaling probably had something to do with what he's +[512.360 --> 518.040] going through. Mark, what do you got? Yeah. So let's start off with Noah. He absolutely tiptoes +[518.040 --> 523.720] around his first question. He dances around it. Knowing how direct you could be in asking that +[523.720 --> 531.800] first question takes him a long time to get to the point. He qualifies. He moves a goalposts on it. +[531.800 --> 542.920] He reframes elements. So really Noah is doing his best to set up the criteria under which Smith +[542.920 --> 550.040] is going to answer these and he knows he wants to set up more than fair criteria. If not a very +[550.040 --> 558.200] pleasant criteria for this questioning. So interesting from Noah who one would expect to be a little more +[558.200 --> 565.720] a servant, a little more critical given his job. He's being super kind in this particular place, +[565.720 --> 574.200] I would say Smith said oh by the way that you know check out how many times Noah says that in +[574.200 --> 580.200] this first video. Check out how many times Noah says that in the fifth video we in the last video +[580.200 --> 588.440] we get to. So it's we can see how charismatic Will Smith is because Noah is going to start copying +[588.440 --> 599.880] his language very very soon over time. Check that out. Back to back to the idea of of when we first saw +[599.880 --> 604.920] Will Smith talk about this because it had been a minute and he was had this kind of haloed +[604.920 --> 611.640] interview that he did and he said back then that it was nuanced and complex. So he's still back +[611.720 --> 618.200] to this. This is nuanced. This is complex but he does admit to having lost it which he didn't in +[618.200 --> 623.400] that first interview that he did. So things have moved forward. He's now saying he's lost it but he's +[623.400 --> 629.960] still being a little bit more a little bit standoffish by going it's nuanced is complex. You might not +[629.960 --> 635.480] be able to understand it or I'm not going to get it across because of that. He says I guess what I would +[635.480 --> 640.520] say. So that's quite indefinite. I guess what I would say. Well what would you say? Like say what +[640.520 --> 646.760] you're going to say and then his eyes roll back and he has this eyelid flutter as well which +[646.760 --> 653.720] which seems to suggest to me struggle and disbelief and a search going on or he's having a seizure. +[653.720 --> 659.400] I don't think he's having a seizure. So I think there is there is a sense of he struggling with this +[659.400 --> 665.240] what he's going to say. There's a slight disbelief in himself. There's a search for information +[665.240 --> 671.480] and then he looks no astrate in the eye and says you just never know what someone is going through +[671.480 --> 678.520] and that is direct aggressive. There's disgust on that. It's a challenge to know and there's a +[678.520 --> 686.280] little snort that my dog peach does as well that to to see everybody off the territory. That is +[686.280 --> 691.960] Will Smith challenge. You can challenge me no more because you never know what somebody else is +[691.960 --> 698.120] going through and anyway it's complex and it's nuanced. Well we could know what somebody's going +[698.120 --> 702.680] through because you could just tell us maybe it's not complex maybe it's not nuanced maybe we can +[702.680 --> 707.480] get it maybe we're smart you know and human and we can get it and maybe we'd understand. +[708.760 --> 715.720] And he says well you know not that that justifies anything we might actually you just tell us +[715.720 --> 721.720] what was going on we might get it and we might get we might go well justifiably so justifiably +[721.720 --> 727.960] so you'd step up and hit the guy I totally get it now. I'm smart guy you told me thank but he +[727.960 --> 734.520] doesn't do any of that that's kind of interesting. He deflects to the audience as you've said guys +[734.520 --> 742.280] you know he quickly makes takes it off him and into the audience I was going through something +[742.920 --> 749.880] well what what we going through you could just tell us and we might get it but he's not telling us +[750.040 --> 757.720] not telling us at all. So for me not a good start from either of them because it's a very soft +[757.720 --> 763.800] interview at the moment and he's not saying anything. In fact he's challenging us now that we +[763.800 --> 768.200] that we cannot understand this and we shouldn't question him anymore. +[769.720 --> 778.120] You know you are you will Smith you are you are one of the biggest movie stars that has ever existed +[778.120 --> 783.880] you know one of my favorite people that I've ever seen inhabit a screen. You know and then you +[783.880 --> 789.640] you had the Oscars where in one night you I have no independent recollection of +[789.640 --> 797.160] I can only imagine because you you you you won you know you won your first Oscar that night well deserved +[797.160 --> 802.760] Oscar that night but it is it is simultaneously in many ways not the worst I won't say the worst +[802.760 --> 807.080] because I know the life you've lived I read the book but it is one of the best days of your life +[807.080 --> 812.280] and one of the worst days of your life and I would I'd love to know I mean just you know I was talking +[812.840 --> 821.000] first of all what has the journey been like since that day like because we everyone speculates +[821.000 --> 824.600] everyone just sees it and goes I think this I think that I think this I think that what does it +[824.600 --> 829.720] been like for you. Yeah that was that was a horrific night as you can imagine. +[830.680 --> 843.480] you know there's many nuances and and complexities to it you know but at the end of the day I just +[843.480 --> 853.960] I lost it you know and I guess what I would say you just never know what somebody's going through +[854.920 --> 863.080] you know you know in the audience right now you know you're sitting next to strangers you know and +[864.360 --> 873.000] somebody's mother died last week you know somebody's child is sick you know somebody just lost their job +[873.960 --> 879.080] somebody just found out their spouse cheated you know there's it's like there's all these things +[879.080 --> 887.000] and these there's strangers and you just don't know what's going on with people you know and +[887.000 --> 894.200] there's I was going through something that night you know and I not that that you know justifies my +[894.200 --> 903.320] behavior at all I would just say you know you're asking what did I learn and it's that we just got +[903.320 --> 909.720] to be nice to each other man you know it's like it's hard and I guess the thing that was most +[909.720 --> 917.160] painful for me is I took my heart and made it hard for other people you know it's like I +[917.160 --> 923.080] understood the idea where they say hurt people hurt people yeah yeah you know and it's like +[924.280 --> 929.640] you know it's it's interesting I remember again everybody was speculating one of my friends +[929.640 --> 933.000] called me and we're talking we're talking everyone's got these opinions and then someone said +[933.880 --> 938.280] I feel like we saw the real will Smith in that moment because the guy who's so full of love and +[938.280 --> 943.320] so positive but I feel like in that moment we saw the real will Smith and and I said and not +[943.320 --> 948.440] because I know you you know but but I said honestly I said no if anything I feel like it was the +[948.440 --> 954.680] opposite like you know you're talking your book about growing up so afraid of conflict you grow up +[954.680 --> 960.840] in your book talking about how you always afraid to fight with how you were afraid to for me it +[960.840 --> 966.440] felt like in watching that moment I felt like you were like is it's like in a way it was like you +[966.440 --> 972.200] stood up for the wrong thing at the wrong time yeah yeah yeah you're not I'm saying it felt like +[972.200 --> 976.120] you've taken everything because here we are you know human to human man to man but like +[977.400 --> 981.880] people have said some things about you and your family absolutely you know you're a human being +[981.880 --> 988.520] it felt like and I would say this because like it is it's becoming relentlessly now and people +[988.520 --> 992.120] think it's okay yes that's the thing people think it's okay and not crisp by the way yeah I'm talking +[992.120 --> 999.480] about people the internet etc but it it felt like this was will Smith for the first time going okay +[999.480 --> 1006.360] is this how you want me to respond or not yeah now it was you know it was a lot of things it was the +[1006.600 --> 1012.760] the little boy that watched his father beat up his mother you know it's that you know all of that +[1012.760 --> 1023.560] just bubbled up yeah in in in that moment you know I just that's not who I want to be right you know +[1023.560 --> 1029.400] you've known me for a long time so you know me personally so you know but you know y'all might not +[1029.400 --> 1036.440] know you know it's like that that's not who I want to be man I'm trying to you know I'm +[1037.320 --> 1044.280] all right Greg what do you got well you know just conveniently has a tissue with him makes me +[1044.280 --> 1049.160] question the tears right off because I've watched lots of these things and people have tissues there +[1049.160 --> 1053.240] that whoever's crying no hand over the box and that kind of thing interesting he brought his +[1053.240 --> 1058.440] on tissue which makes me go I'm suspicious of the tears he's a great actor so I'm suspicious of his +[1058.440 --> 1065.800] tears right off and I see some apprehension him in him as Trevor is asking the question I see him +[1065.800 --> 1071.160] lean in he barriers meaning he puts his hands together closes up gets something in front of him and +[1071.160 --> 1075.480] then he starts adapting or moving his fingers together and milling that's just releasing nervous +[1075.480 --> 1080.040] energy and I don't think it's anything really afraid I think he's just prepared for what's coming +[1080.040 --> 1084.520] you watch his finger taps as he waits for his opportunity to deliver his response I think he +[1084.520 --> 1089.000] knows the question I don't think there's anything really exciting or interesting here the audience +[1089.000 --> 1093.160] is now started to connect with them they're laughing at what he says so he started to get them to +[1093.160 --> 1098.120] win them over I don't think there's a whole lot here other than that you guys probably see a lot +[1098.120 --> 1104.520] of other things I'll leave it at that and say Scott what do you got all right yeah I'm with you I +[1104.520 --> 1109.000] think he's pulled out his show clean eggs to show that he's having a motion about this and he's +[1109.480 --> 1115.800] feeling you know strongly about it unless he's had emotion before but we're going our video started +[1115.800 --> 1124.040] a few minutes in you know you know Neseen I'm doing it dang it yeah yeah so he's got he got me +[1124.680 --> 1129.000] so I think I think he's trying to connect with the what you're saying Greg your right there's not +[1129.000 --> 1134.360] a whole lot of really big things here that I'm saying that that's stand out and I don't feel like +[1134.360 --> 1138.200] he's blaming anybody or blaming anything I think he's just explaining what's happening on +[1139.080 --> 1144.280] or what's happened to him from from the first part of it on and his right hand is laid over his left +[1144.280 --> 1149.800] hand and we see a little bit of space between his fingers now quite often what we when we look for space +[1149.800 --> 1154.040] in between your fingers is because of this if someone is stressed or they're they're not sure about +[1154.040 --> 1160.680] what's going on or they feel like a lesser lesser person in the situation you don't feel as dominant +[1160.680 --> 1165.400] as they probably should then you'll see that space go away but he's actually got a lot of space +[1165.400 --> 1170.680] in there for the position he's in so at first I thought what's got to have any confidence but I think +[1170.680 --> 1176.600] he does have confidence because that is indicative of someone with with confidence in the situation +[1176.600 --> 1183.240] there at the moment so that's why that looks looks to me then we see a little pacifying gesture +[1183.240 --> 1186.680] there where he keeps doing that with his finger it's laid up on a sand he keeps rubbing his +[1187.320 --> 1193.640] his index finger keeps rolling his other finger so he's trying to to subconsciously I think blow +[1193.640 --> 1198.600] off some of that tension that may be up but then again this may be nothing for him you know on one +[1198.600 --> 1203.320] hand you can say it's be really stressful it is but in the real world for his life what he does +[1203.320 --> 1209.080] this is probably nothing for him a situation like that but we see that so that makes me think +[1209.080 --> 1214.840] something's up there a little bit now at this point his head is completely in front of his hands +[1214.840 --> 1220.680] they're over the barrier so he's even coming closer to Trevor Noah and if you watch Trevor Noah +[1220.680 --> 1224.680] he does and I keep saying it's we does such a great job but we I know we all get into people +[1224.680 --> 1228.120] are interviewers and how they do it and how they pull information out and the way they set things +[1228.120 --> 1233.160] up but he really is doing a dang good job here I think laying the thing out telling everybody what's +[1233.160 --> 1238.440] happening and then throwing it over to Will to clean it all up to clean his parts up I think he's +[1238.440 --> 1243.800] doing a great job with that at the beginning I think he's he's speaking from the heart then he +[1243.800 --> 1251.400] goes back to his comfort place with the Yannas you know and his cadence is slowed down his volume is +[1251.400 --> 1258.040] lowered his tone is softer so he's he's now settling into his delivery of the important things he's +[1258.040 --> 1264.920] going to talk about at this point where are you got yeah very much the same stuff that tissue is +[1264.920 --> 1269.560] ready you know if you've if you've got a tissue it's going to be in your pockets or it's underneath +[1269.560 --> 1276.920] his leg I believe so he's placed it there ready and easy to get so he can show show the tissue +[1276.920 --> 1282.280] symbol there of I'm having I'm having feelings so there is there is obviously some preparation +[1282.280 --> 1290.200] ahead of time to go I either think I'm going to have feelings that require a tissue or I will have +[1290.200 --> 1296.680] feelings that will require a tissue so there's some pre planning going on here for sure um +[1297.480 --> 1305.320] he says oh so the so no the interviewer um really sets up a narrative for him and goes and goes +[1305.320 --> 1309.320] you know the basically the internet was to blame really it was the internet that's to blame and +[1309.320 --> 1315.000] this is how you you know this is you saying this is how you want me to respond and Smith goes yeah +[1315.000 --> 1323.720] no so he doesn't though he's set up with an idea he doesn't really take that idea and run because +[1323.720 --> 1330.680] I'm not sure that no as idea the feed is is really resonating with him it's not the right feed +[1330.680 --> 1337.320] he says it was a lot of things the little boy the watch his father beat up his mother it's a lot +[1337.320 --> 1343.800] of things that it that's one thing if it's a lot of things tell us all the other things my guess is +[1343.800 --> 1350.440] is the first thing he mentions isn't that's that's that's a symptom that's that's not a cause +[1350.680 --> 1355.800] I want to know I want to know what are the other things and what was the main thing so as an +[1355.800 --> 1360.440] interviewer I'd be going yeah okay I get it that is one of the things what are the other things +[1360.440 --> 1366.280] and what was the main thing for you that that caused this to happen so for me the interviewer I mean +[1366.280 --> 1371.320] it's you know it's it's it's nighttime entertainment the guy's trying to stop his you know company +[1371.320 --> 1377.480] crumbling and sell a sell a film you know for for Apple who put in I don't know how many million +[1377.480 --> 1383.000] but I know it's about 130 million Apple are in on his on his current current project and they +[1383.000 --> 1387.160] want to they want to make sure they get the money back so I understand what's going on here we +[1387.160 --> 1392.920] just all need to understand what's going on here this is this is somebody saving their company +[1392.920 --> 1401.400] and getting a sales pitch in you know what last thing you know is is this crossed arm this gangnam +[1401.400 --> 1407.240] style that's going on I've started seeing that with a lot of celebrity interviews when they're in +[1407.240 --> 1414.120] trouble we saw that with who's the guy who's Chris Chris yeah Chris Cuomo was doing the same move +[1414.120 --> 1419.640] I think to suppress a dominant handle to suppress aggression that might come up I don't know +[1419.640 --> 1424.680] whether somebody out there teaching that they might be because I'm seeing it quite quite a bit +[1424.680 --> 1430.520] if they are it's a good it's a not a bad idea I've been trying it out it's not very natural +[1430.520 --> 1435.960] so I don't know when you naturally do that and that's why when I see that I go I you know I don't +[1435.960 --> 1441.640] remember the first time my kids ever did that you know you never go you know I go oh look +[1441.640 --> 1448.200] look they're doing the gangnam style thing so it's not very natural so I think it's it's put on +[1448.200 --> 1454.440] for some reason it might be about control during this there might be somebody out there going do that +[1454.440 --> 1459.400] it's it's better for you I don't know I don't know anyway it's all I got in that one uh chase +[1459.400 --> 1467.560] we go yeah so this is a a classic example of projecting so it's it's just hinting at the idea +[1467.560 --> 1472.840] of projecting the blame onto something else this is something we do in interrogations so we'll use +[1472.840 --> 1478.920] as a history to describe what might be responsible for what happened this little boy who watch +[1478.920 --> 1484.840] violence happen in his home I do think this is honest set up the handkerchief or the tissue +[1484.840 --> 1490.600] set up whatever I don't think it's unscripted he seems very inscripted to a large degree I think this +[1490.600 --> 1496.840] is good that he didn't prepare very much because it makes the conversation appear more natural +[1496.840 --> 1503.480] his speech is flawed and I think that helps us helps to remind just regular people that he's more like +[1503.480 --> 1510.120] us than we thought that's uh while we get addicted to celebrity stuff that's all I got +[1515.640 --> 1520.600] who's that's how you think that's how you do it I'm going to give that one to Greg though Greg was in +[1520.600 --> 1530.680] what serious yeah this is just going to you you'll get one and it's like you know it's it's +[1530.680 --> 1535.960] interesting I remember again everybody was speculating one of my friends called me and we're +[1535.960 --> 1540.520] talking we're talking everyone's got these opinions and then someone said I feel like we saw +[1540.520 --> 1544.840] the real will smith in that moment because the guy who's so full of love and so positive but I +[1544.840 --> 1550.520] feel like in that moment we saw the real will smith and and I said and not because I know you you know +[1550.520 --> 1555.640] but but I said honestly I said no if anything I feel like it was the opposite like you know you +[1555.640 --> 1561.400] talk in your book about growing up so afraid of conflict you grow up in your book talking about how +[1561.400 --> 1568.040] you always afraid to fight with how you were afraid to for me it felt like in watching that moment I +[1568.040 --> 1573.640] felt like you were like is it's like in a way where it's like you stood up for the wrong thing at +[1573.640 --> 1578.760] the wrong time in a way yeah you know what I'm saying it felt like you're taking everything because +[1579.480 --> 1584.760] here we are you know human to human man to man but like people have said some things about you and +[1584.760 --> 1590.280] your family absolutely you know you're a human being it felt like and I would say this because like it +[1590.280 --> 1596.040] is it's becoming relentlessly now and people think it's okay yes that's the thing people think +[1596.040 --> 1601.240] it's okay and not crisp by the way yeah I'm talking about people the internet etc but it it felt +[1601.240 --> 1607.400] like this was will smith for the first time going okay is this how you want me to respond or not +[1607.960 --> 1614.520] yeah now it was you know it was a lot of things it was the the little boy that watched his father +[1614.520 --> 1622.040] beat up his mother you know it's that you know all of that just bubbled up yeah in in in that moment +[1622.040 --> 1630.680] um you know I just that's not who I want to be right you know you've known me for a long time so +[1630.680 --> 1638.120] you know me personally so you know um but you know y'all might not know um oh you know you know it's +[1638.120 --> 1645.560] like that that that's not who I want to be man I'm trying to you know so on my side as a human being +[1645.560 --> 1650.280] I go the reason it was shocking is because that's not who you are does that make sense exactly like +[1650.600 --> 1654.120] like I saw for instance there was a there was an article that was written I think it was a Hollywood +[1654.120 --> 1658.680] reporter or whatever they had a list of like problematic actors or whatever I was personally offended +[1658.680 --> 1663.080] for you and let's share funny enough for different reason but they had you guys in a list where I was +[1663.080 --> 1667.080] like wait some of these people are here for sleeping with underage kids these people are here for +[1667.080 --> 1672.040] abusing their spouses and again what you did what I always tell you that I love Chris I'm friends +[1672.040 --> 1676.680] with him I love you I'm friends but I was like this is fuck up but I was like but it's not the same +[1676.680 --> 1681.720] world yeah and that's where it was weird especially I find you know because they they were all +[1681.720 --> 1686.120] these dynamics so I know that as black people black people would be together and be like what was +[1686.120 --> 1690.680] will doing what the hell happened here yeah right but then I know a lot of black people were like +[1690.680 --> 1694.760] we know where people came out and they were like he should got a jail like you need to relax yourself +[1695.720 --> 1701.560] it it was a weird like some people are overreacting yeah yeah which made some people under react yeah +[1701.560 --> 1709.720] yeah you know now it's it's the I understand you know how shocking that was for people man right +[1709.720 --> 1716.200] you know when you shot you seemed you seemed a little dazed afterwards yeah yeah I was gone +[1716.200 --> 1723.960] dude I was gone I was gone I was you know that was a rage that had been bottled for a really +[1723.960 --> 1737.080] long time and you know but it's it's I understand the pain you know it was like my little my nephew +[1737.080 --> 1746.760] the dumb is nine and he is the sweetest little boy he's like you know we came home and it's like he +[1746.760 --> 1753.720] had stayed up late to see his uncle will you know and we're sitting in my kitchen and he's on my +[1753.720 --> 1761.720] lap and he's holding the Oscar and he's just like why did you hit that man uncle will you know +[1764.440 --> 1765.720] why are you trying to open me +[1765.720 --> 1775.240] and you're scary you're on your lap and +[1775.240 --> 1780.680] yeah you yeah if you don't know who we are we're the behavior panel and I'm Scott Rassima +[1780.680 --> 1784.760] body language expert in analyst and a trained law enforcement and a military and interrogation +[1784.760 --> 1789.240] in body language I created the number one online body language course body language tactics +[1789.240 --> 1795.320] calm with Greg Hartley Mark I'm Mark Bowden I'm an expert in human behavior and body language +[1795.320 --> 1796.920] people all over the world to stand out, +[1796.920 --> 1798.480] win trust, gain credibility. +[1798.480 --> 1799.640] Every time they communicate, +[1799.640 --> 1803.600] including some of the leaders of the G7, Chase. +[1803.600 --> 1804.800] Hey, I'm Chase Hughes. +[1804.800 --> 1806.260] I did 20 years in the US military +[1806.260 --> 1807.840] wrote the number one best selling book +[1807.840 --> 1811.440] on behavior profiling, influence, and persuasion. +[1811.440 --> 1812.800] You can learn about all that today. +[1812.800 --> 1816.040] Just type my name into your app store, Greg. +[1817.240 --> 1818.940] Greg Hartley, former Army Interrogator, +[1818.940 --> 1821.240] interrogation instructor, resistance to interrogation +[1821.240 --> 1822.600] instructor, different in 10 books, +[1822.600 --> 1823.960] on body language and behavior, +[1823.960 --> 1826.360] put together the number one body language tactics.com course +[1826.360 --> 1828.320] with Scott Rouse, and has been most of my time +[1828.320 --> 1830.200] on corporate America. +[1830.200 --> 1832.080] All right, Mark, what do you got? +[1832.080 --> 1833.600] Yeah. +[1833.600 --> 1837.840] So before he says rage, there's an, +[1837.840 --> 1840.720] I'd like to know what the um is. +[1840.720 --> 1843.240] I think there's something else there. +[1843.240 --> 1846.080] There's something else that he'd quite like to say. +[1846.080 --> 1846.960] He hits rage. +[1846.960 --> 1848.560] It's not that there isn't rage there +[1848.560 --> 1852.000] because we do get a nostril flare, I think of anger on that. +[1852.000 --> 1853.840] So I think that's accurate. +[1853.840 --> 1858.840] But I think he's holding back something before he goes to rage. +[1859.320 --> 1862.680] I'd like to know what was the other word or idea +[1862.680 --> 1864.840] that he was coming up with. +[1867.240 --> 1870.360] He really does play that story to the audience. +[1870.360 --> 1874.560] He knows when to go out and face it out to the audience +[1874.560 --> 1879.560] and start telling that story about the nephew. +[1879.560 --> 1884.560] He hits the innocent cadence of that young child. +[1886.800 --> 1891.120] So rather than reporting it, he starts to perform the child +[1891.120 --> 1894.840] knowing that that will tell a better story. +[1894.840 --> 1899.640] He gets somewhat of a reaction from the audience. +[1899.640 --> 1904.840] But in my mind, not enough to evoke the reaction +[1904.840 --> 1909.080] that he himself then does of having that hanky ready, +[1909.080 --> 1914.080] going for his tears, and then invoking the queen +[1914.080 --> 1919.080] of high value revelation, stop opening me. +[1919.920 --> 1924.920] So all of that felt a little bit arch to me. +[1924.920 --> 1929.920] I think he knew he was going to go for that story. +[1931.000 --> 1934.560] I really think he knew he was going to play that one. +[1934.560 --> 1936.600] Fair play, fair play. +[1936.600 --> 1941.600] But I don't think that's come in the moment for him. +[1942.400 --> 1945.080] But I'm prepared to be challenged on that. +[1945.080 --> 1946.760] Greg, what do you got? +[1946.760 --> 1949.840] Yeah, if you were to pay attention to the number of youngos +[1949.840 --> 1952.400] and how much his story changed once he got to the point +[1952.400 --> 1956.280] he starts to tell this little boy story, he gets more smooth. +[1956.280 --> 1958.480] I think he could not afford to come across +[1958.480 --> 1960.880] in the very beginning as articulate and smooth +[1960.880 --> 1965.280] as Will Smith normally is without being perceived as uncaring. +[1965.280 --> 1969.120] So I think coming through and doing this slow, you know, +[1969.120 --> 1971.120] you know, that's him testing the water +[1971.120 --> 1972.920] until he gets to a certain point. +[1972.920 --> 1974.920] And that your dead on Scott, you said earlier, +[1974.920 --> 1977.880] there's a virus now, they all have this thing going. +[1977.880 --> 1980.480] It's even picked up among us by watching it. +[1980.480 --> 1983.160] Count the number of youngos we've done, just to see, +[1983.160 --> 1984.960] see how many put him down below. +[1984.960 --> 1989.960] But what you'll know is he is trying to get attention +[1990.120 --> 1992.600] for what he's saying and trying to make sure you understand. +[1992.600 --> 1995.760] He raises brow, what I usually call request for approval. +[1995.760 --> 1998.800] Request for approval means I'm asking you to believe me, +[1998.800 --> 2000.120] whether it's a lie or truth. +[2000.120 --> 2001.120] It's not deception here. +[2001.120 --> 2002.640] He's just saying, do you understand? +[2002.640 --> 2004.200] And then he squints a little at you +[2004.200 --> 2007.200] to make sure you're picking up what he's talking about. +[2007.200 --> 2011.240] Trevor Noah goes on and on and on and I think even, +[2011.240 --> 2013.440] even Will Smith may be amused a little if you look at him +[2013.440 --> 2015.880] smiling in his eyes and not in his lower face +[2015.880 --> 2018.560] as the guy just continues down the path. +[2018.560 --> 2020.920] I think if you get to this part where he is starting +[2020.920 --> 2024.040] to tell you the story and you pay really close attention. +[2024.040 --> 2026.600] You'll see that that's the main thing he's preparing. +[2026.600 --> 2029.480] Mark, I'm not going to hit all the cadence and all that dead on. +[2029.480 --> 2031.840] He brought the child like innocence back into this +[2031.840 --> 2033.840] and he relaxes people a little bit. +[2033.840 --> 2035.040] Now they're starting to laugh. +[2035.040 --> 2036.320] I think he's made a connection. +[2036.320 --> 2038.200] That's what he's here for at the end of the day. +[2038.200 --> 2039.880] Everyone of us has made a mistake. +[2039.880 --> 2042.800] Those mistakes can be career ending and Mark, I think you're right. +[2042.800 --> 2045.000] There's a big movie at in play. +[2045.000 --> 2046.640] There's also his entire career in play. +[2046.640 --> 2047.520] Chase, what are you got? +[2048.480 --> 2050.160] Yeah, you guys hit a bunch of this stuff. +[2050.160 --> 2055.040] There's a couple of things here that were into a different category. +[2055.040 --> 2056.480] Now we're not projecting anymore. +[2056.480 --> 2060.960] This is another interrogation technique that we use called rationalizing. +[2060.960 --> 2063.440] And we see that here in this video. +[2063.440 --> 2065.800] And right one in the moment he says shocking. +[2065.800 --> 2068.720] You see the eyebrows go up at the perfect time. +[2068.720 --> 2073.880] And when he says on that stage, we see disgust on the face +[2073.880 --> 2077.200] when he says on that stage and a postural retreat, +[2077.200 --> 2081.120] which means he's leaning away, trying to get away from that topic. +[2081.120 --> 2085.560] I think it was honest, but scripted and rehearsed. +[2085.560 --> 2090.080] When we say those things, we're not telling you that they're lying or being deceptive. +[2090.080 --> 2092.440] So I just want to make that clear. +[2092.440 --> 2099.120] We're not calling him a liar here, but scripted and rehearsed are probably just smart +[2099.120 --> 2103.560] for how many millions and tens of millions of dollars are on the line. +[2103.600 --> 2106.000] And just probably he's a man of legacy. +[2106.000 --> 2110.080] He's a socially driven creature for sure, like me. +[2110.080 --> 2113.120] And he wants the legacy to be there for his kids. +[2113.120 --> 2117.800] He cares about his reputation with his fans and his family more than anything else. +[2117.800 --> 2121.480] And I think he's humanizing himself with the nephew story rehearsed or not. +[2121.480 --> 2122.480] That's all I got. +[2124.080 --> 2125.240] Scott, where you go? +[2125.240 --> 2126.560] All right. +[2126.560 --> 2133.520] I think this is where I think you guys ride to this where we see the most genuine expression of emotions. +[2133.560 --> 2135.000] Isn't this video? +[2135.000 --> 2139.680] And when Trevor, but when Trevor Noah says he shouldn't have gotten in so much trouble +[2139.680 --> 2143.200] and some people overreacted and all that, let's think about what he did. +[2143.200 --> 2145.040] He smacked somebody. +[2145.040 --> 2146.160] That's assault. +[2146.160 --> 2147.000] That's against the law. +[2147.000 --> 2148.400] You can't do that without getting in trouble. +[2148.400 --> 2150.120] There are consequences for that. +[2150.120 --> 2152.600] He didn't pay any consequences for it. +[2152.600 --> 2156.360] What he did was childish and it was immature. +[2156.360 --> 2158.560] They slap him and then he goes, he sits down. +[2158.560 --> 2162.920] He starts cussing in front of all these people, like the worst words you can possibly say. +[2162.960 --> 2164.640] He's saying them on TV. +[2164.640 --> 2168.600] So if he's going through something, it must have been something horrible. +[2168.600 --> 2171.360] Something really bad that he's going through to be doing that. +[2171.360 --> 2174.840] Because that's about the most unprofessional you can get at that point. +[2174.840 --> 2181.000] So in that situation, so I think he's, if he's being honest, which I think he probably is, +[2181.000 --> 2186.320] many must have a whole lot going on at home and a whole lot going on there to trick or something like that. +[2186.320 --> 2187.320] And you're right, Chase. +[2187.320 --> 2192.040] When he says, I understand how shocking that was for people, his eyebrows are up. +[2192.120 --> 2196.280] And it's like he's almost living vicariously through the audience seeing him. +[2196.280 --> 2202.680] I know that sounds way over to almost as a third person, because I think he knows how they're going to be looking at him at that point or seeing it. +[2202.680 --> 2209.840] And then he says, like you said, Chase, when he says on that stage, that's the largest expression of disgust we've seen in all the videos we've done. +[2209.840 --> 2212.240] I think we've done two before this or just the one. +[2214.600 --> 2219.280] Two, because we haven't that thing where they're all bunched together. +[2219.360 --> 2224.400] But I think, but that's the largest disgust we've seen him so far. +[2225.480 --> 2226.920] And we talked about being gone. +[2226.920 --> 2228.240] He hangs his head in shame. +[2228.480 --> 2234.760] And that's a classic behavior we look for when someone is supposed to be feeling an emotion and feeling shameful about something. +[2234.880 --> 2237.960] That's where he seemed totally dropped down and his head drops. +[2238.640 --> 2240.080] And I think he feels ashamed about that. +[2240.080 --> 2242.640] I think he, he knows what he's done or what happened. +[2243.000 --> 2244.960] And after all that horrible stuff, I said about him. +[2244.960 --> 2247.080] I think he realizes that and knows that. +[2247.600 --> 2249.840] So I think he feels ashamed about doing that. +[2250.040 --> 2252.760] That's what I would take from him doing that. +[2253.120 --> 2258.200] When he talks about his real feelings, I don't think it's somebody has told him to do that. +[2258.200 --> 2260.040] I don't think it's somebody's training to say that. +[2260.040 --> 2264.360] I think it came out naturally because he's his vernacular at that time changes. +[2264.360 --> 2267.360] It's like Regal say it's much smoother than it was before. +[2267.800 --> 2273.080] Before this video, he said, you know, nine times in the second video on this one, he says it nine times as well, +[2273.280 --> 2274.520] but they're not so pronounced. +[2274.520 --> 2275.200] They're not as big. +[2275.200 --> 2276.760] They're not huge like they were before. +[2277.480 --> 2282.800] I think is the illustration of rage in his hands appears to be authentic as well. +[2282.800 --> 2286.040] When he's talking about the anger he was feeling, he was talking about the things he was going through. +[2286.560 --> 2290.200] Let me get, when we get back to the, to the acting part that he's doing, +[2290.200 --> 2292.480] he dabs his eyes as he turns toward the audience. +[2292.840 --> 2297.280] He makes a big deal about crying that we don't see really any tears. +[2297.280 --> 2301.880] Maybe his eyes are a little bit classy, but not enough to need a, a clean X to take care of that. +[2302.240 --> 2306.240] You know, so I think that might be a little bit of prep there. +[2306.360 --> 2307.440] I think he's ready for that. +[2307.840 --> 2309.400] And then we're back to the gnaws. +[2311.200 --> 2316.200] So on my side as a human being, I go, the reason it was shocking is because that's not who you are. +[2316.200 --> 2316.480] Yeah. +[2316.480 --> 2317.200] Does that make sense? +[2317.200 --> 2317.720] Exactly. +[2317.720 --> 2321.160] Like I saw, for instance, there was an article that was written. +[2321.160 --> 2322.440] I think it was a Hollywood report or whatever. +[2322.600 --> 2325.000] They had a list of like problematic actors or whatever. +[2325.000 --> 2328.640] I was personally offended for you and let Tisha funny enough for a different reason, +[2328.640 --> 2331.200] but they had you guys in a list where I was like, wait, +[2331.320 --> 2333.840] some of these people are here for sleeping with underage kids. +[2333.840 --> 2335.800] These people are here for abusing their spouses. +[2336.080 --> 2337.720] And again, what you did, what's up? +[2337.720 --> 2339.200] I always tell you that I love Chris. +[2339.200 --> 2340.080] I'm friends with him. +[2340.080 --> 2340.600] I love you. +[2340.600 --> 2342.720] I'm friends with, but I was like, this is f*** up. +[2342.720 --> 2344.920] But I was like, but it's not the same world. +[2345.320 --> 2350.160] And that's where it was weird, especially I find, you know, because there were all these dynamics. +[2350.160 --> 2353.320] So I know that as black people, black people would be together and be like, +[2353.320 --> 2354.360] what was will doing? +[2354.360 --> 2355.440] What the hell happened here? +[2355.440 --> 2355.640] Yeah. +[2355.640 --> 2356.160] Right? +[2356.160 --> 2359.800] But then I know a lot of black people were like, we know where people came out and they were like, +[2359.800 --> 2362.440] he should got a jail and we're like, you need to relax yourself. +[2363.320 --> 2365.400] It was a weird, like some people +[2365.400 --> 2368.760] were overreacting, which made some people underreact. +[2368.760 --> 2369.240] Yeah. +[2369.240 --> 2370.080] You know? +[2370.080 --> 2371.720] No, it's the... +[2373.160 --> 2377.080] I understand, you know, how shocking that was for people, man. +[2377.080 --> 2377.280] Right. +[2377.280 --> 2378.880] You know, when you... +[2378.880 --> 2379.880] When you got shot... +[2379.880 --> 2380.880] When you got shot... +[2380.880 --> 2382.720] You seemed a little dazed afterwards, I was gone. +[2382.720 --> 2383.240] Yeah, yeah, yeah. +[2383.240 --> 2384.240] I was gone, dude. +[2384.240 --> 2385.240] I was gone. +[2385.240 --> 2386.080] I was gone. +[2386.080 --> 2392.320] I was, you know, that was a rage that had been bottled for a really long time. +[2392.320 --> 2392.840] Right. +[2393.840 --> 2396.640] And, you know, but it's... +[2397.840 --> 2400.520] I understand the pain, you know? +[2400.520 --> 2401.360] It was like... +[2402.760 --> 2406.200] My little nephew, your dumb, is nine. +[2406.760 --> 2410.520] And he is the sweetest little boy. +[2410.520 --> 2417.800] He's like, you know, we came home and it's like he had stayed up late to see his uncle will, you know. +[2417.800 --> 2422.600] And we're sitting in my kitchen and he's on my lap and he's holding the... +[2422.600 --> 2428.880] And the Oscar and he's just like, why did you hit that man, Uncle Will? +[2428.880 --> 2430.920] You know, that... +[2430.920 --> 2432.120] Hey, you're... +[2432.120 --> 2434.120] Why are you trying to open me? +[2434.120 --> 2435.320] No, no, no. +[2435.320 --> 2436.320] No, no. +[2436.320 --> 2437.320] No, no. +[2437.320 --> 2440.320] No, no. +[2440.320 --> 2441.320] Yeah. +[2441.320 --> 2442.320] And he's carrying... +[2442.320 --> 2443.320] He's sitting on your lap and... +[2443.320 --> 2445.560] Yeah, you know, it was a mess, you know. +[2445.560 --> 2449.400] I don't want to go too far into it to give people more to misunderstand stuff. +[2449.400 --> 2450.160] Is it... +[2450.160 --> 2451.160] Is it hard, you know? +[2451.160 --> 2452.160] You have lived... +[2452.160 --> 2455.640] I realized this morning when I was thinking about you coming on the show. +[2455.640 --> 2461.640] You were one of the rare breed of human who has lived more of your life in the spotlight than out of it. +[2461.640 --> 2463.880] You got into this industry as a kid. +[2463.880 --> 2467.200] You know, you grew up and blew up into it as a young man. +[2467.200 --> 2468.520] You had your tax issues. +[2468.520 --> 2469.280] You had your life. +[2469.280 --> 2470.280] You had your family. +[2470.280 --> 2471.280] You had... +[2471.280 --> 2473.640] But you have lived in this world for... +[2473.640 --> 2475.120] It's funny again. +[2475.120 --> 2479.120] I realized chatting to friends and I was like, you know what's interesting here is... +[2479.120 --> 2481.360] For us, this is the Oscars. +[2481.360 --> 2482.360] Yeah. +[2482.360 --> 2483.840] For Will Smith, this is like a cookout. +[2483.840 --> 2484.840] Right. +[2484.840 --> 2488.200] And I'm not diminishing the Oscars. +[2488.200 --> 2490.320] But those are your people, that's your world. +[2490.320 --> 2491.600] This is like... +[2491.600 --> 2492.600] I was like... +[2492.600 --> 2495.600] I was saying, I think that is part of the reason many of us were that sort of... +[2495.600 --> 2497.600] Because you go like, it's this loaded event. +[2497.600 --> 2499.080] It's bigger than life. +[2499.080 --> 2500.600] Where's many movie stars at the Oscars. +[2500.600 --> 2501.800] Like, oh, nice to see you again. +[2501.800 --> 2502.800] Hey, good to be here. +[2502.800 --> 2503.800] Good to be back. +[2503.800 --> 2505.480] And I feel like that was part of the disconnect. +[2505.480 --> 2506.800] I feel like that was part of... +[2506.800 --> 2507.800] But what I... +[2507.800 --> 2515.480] The one thing that's killing me, you know, so emancipation is Antoine's masterpiece. +[2515.480 --> 2516.960] That's what I was about to... +[2516.960 --> 2521.200] He has created an absolute masterpiece. +[2521.200 --> 2526.600] Bob Richardson, the DP, and Ben Foster, and just all the way down. +[2526.600 --> 2533.760] It's like these top artists in the world have done some of the best work at our career. +[2534.040 --> 2538.880] And the idea that they might be denied because of me is like... +[2538.880 --> 2540.600] Ugh! +[2540.600 --> 2547.040] You know, it's like that is killing me dead, you know. +[2547.040 --> 2548.720] And it's like... +[2548.720 --> 2556.280] The thing that is so critical for me is that these people came and they trusted me +[2556.280 --> 2560.200] and they were down for me. +[2560.240 --> 2562.920] And, you know, I just... +[2562.920 --> 2571.000] I hope that their work will be honored and their work will not be tainted based on, you know, +[2571.000 --> 2573.440] a horrific decision on my part. +[2573.440 --> 2575.440] Greg, what do you got? +[2575.440 --> 2576.680] Y'all be quick on this one. +[2576.680 --> 2579.120] He's over the top of that big laugh that's the connection thing, +[2579.120 --> 2583.680] but I think it may be, you know, it may be something he does when he's feeling in that situation. +[2583.680 --> 2586.680] He goes into that, you know, connection, you know, you know, +[2586.720 --> 2590.720] until he gets to deliver his next big part of his message. +[2590.720 --> 2595.440] Again, the Y'knowes drop off entirely when he's talking through the mechanics of it. +[2595.440 --> 2602.680] He's saying this thing occurred and it may cause a great movie not to be nominated because of me. +[2602.680 --> 2606.880] Once he gets through that big message and all the illustrators and everything he came there to say, +[2606.880 --> 2610.000] he drops back into that familiarizing Y'know, +[2610.000 --> 2614.320] and I think it's a connection with people because as he starts to talk about feelings, +[2614.320 --> 2617.320] he goes back to Y'know, you know. +[2617.320 --> 2618.320] Interesting. +[2618.320 --> 2620.640] Not saying he's, you know, is it prepared? +[2620.640 --> 2621.640] Absolutely. +[2621.640 --> 2624.320] He's prepared to come in and talk about two big things. +[2624.320 --> 2629.320] And I think his first message was, I let down my nephew in his second messages. +[2629.320 --> 2631.080] I let down my crew. +[2631.080 --> 2633.720] That's what I see in this entire interview. +[2633.720 --> 2634.840] Mark, what do you got? +[2634.840 --> 2637.920] Yeah, so maybe unconsciously there's some other themes that come across, +[2637.920 --> 2641.680] which aren't so laudable. +[2641.720 --> 2646.400] I don't want to go too far into it, give people stuff to misunderstand. +[2646.400 --> 2651.240] Well, no, go into it and we'll work out whether we misunderstand you or not. +[2651.240 --> 2654.640] Like if we have a proper dialogue, you can tell us what went on. +[2654.640 --> 2659.360] Yeah, we're right sensible people, unless you think we're not, +[2659.360 --> 2664.480] and we're just this horde of internet that constantly gets stuff wrong. +[2664.480 --> 2669.120] And in Y'knowes imagination, you're going, +[2669.120 --> 2675.120] this is the stuff you want me to do with some horde out there +[2675.120 --> 2680.400] who can't understand the way life is and will just misunderstand it, get it wrong. +[2680.400 --> 2687.520] I mean, that's what seems to be a little bit condescending, I think. +[2687.520 --> 2692.680] Because you could clearly tell us and say what's going, what went on. +[2692.680 --> 2698.640] Or you could say it's private and I'm not going to go into it. +[2698.640 --> 2701.840] And find another way to promote your film. +[2701.840 --> 2706.480] But what's decided here is your hold back and say, +[2706.480 --> 2710.280] we the public will get it wrong, we can't understand it, it's complex, +[2710.280 --> 2715.120] it's nuanced, you're a bit of a horde out there and you'll misunderstand. +[2715.120 --> 2718.720] Yeah, I don't think so. +[2718.720 --> 2725.000] Then Noah joins in with the condescension, which is to us, it's the Oscars to you, +[2725.000 --> 2727.760] it's just a cookout. +[2727.760 --> 2732.160] Well, and he says, I'm not diminishing the Oscars, when away you are. +[2732.160 --> 2735.760] That's why you said I'm not diminishing it because you are diminishing the Oscars. +[2735.760 --> 2742.720] You're certainly diminishing the public's view of this incredible costly event +[2742.720 --> 2749.200] that gets put on in order to cause the public to want to go and see films and have stars. +[2749.200 --> 2756.720] So there's some complexity going on here, which I think is quite simple to understand. +[2756.720 --> 2760.960] Both here are looking to elevate the star. +[2760.960 --> 2766.560] We've got to get this person back up in the sky, make them a guiding light again +[2766.560 --> 2775.360] that we would follow in the darkness because we are a horde of the unwashed +[2775.360 --> 2782.480] in the darkness of the internet, need a guiding star once more to show us the way forward. +[2782.480 --> 2785.920] Will Smith now are elevated once again? +[2785.920 --> 2787.280] Anyway, that's what I think of it. +[2787.280 --> 2788.480] Chase, what are you reckon? +[2790.320 --> 2792.000] I'm just blown away by that. +[2796.800 --> 2799.280] I think it's honest behavior. +[2799.280 --> 2803.040] So the behavior is not dishonest, I'm gonna say. +[2803.040 --> 2807.200] His description of how letting these people down when he work on the movie is genuine, +[2807.200 --> 2813.360] the emotions are concealed a little bit with this bodily movement that you see here because +[2813.360 --> 2817.760] there's more shame in this than anything that he's spoken about so far. +[2818.400 --> 2824.320] So Will is comfortable with embarrassment, admitting stupid decisions openly discussing. +[2824.320 --> 2828.720] Gilt openly revealing this crippling feeling of letting people down. +[2828.720 --> 2834.000] The one area we see will conceal anything here is when it comes to shame. +[2835.200 --> 2840.320] This element is where I think he feels it the strongest and he's still wanting to discuss it +[2840.320 --> 2843.920] without bringing the emotions of shame into the picture here. +[2844.480 --> 2849.760] I think all the behavior here is honest and flowing and I've been waiting this whole entire +[2849.760 --> 2855.680] time since we started filming for Mark to talk about this purple jacket and how it's associated +[2855.680 --> 2859.760] with royalty and I feel let down. +[2859.760 --> 2860.480] It's actually. +[2864.480 --> 2866.560] Was that the last one? +[2867.440 --> 2868.400] No, that's me next. +[2868.880 --> 2869.360] Scott. +[2869.360 --> 2869.840] All right, sorry. +[2869.840 --> 2870.080] Scott. +[2870.720 --> 2874.320] Okay, so I think Noah does a great job level in this whole thing out +[2875.760 --> 2879.840] from the emotional side by making real laugh and I think he's truly that's one of those laughs +[2879.840 --> 2885.680] that you get when you're trying to put, push someone up and then say something really cool +[2885.680 --> 2888.480] about him, make him laugh because it's really cool what he says about him about the, +[2889.520 --> 2892.400] about the Oscars but I understand what you're saying Mark, it comes from, +[2892.400 --> 2899.840] he says it doesn't want to make him, don't want to be trashed and but he sort of is I think +[2899.840 --> 2901.040] I agree with you on that. +[2901.040 --> 2907.280] Now, this is his apology section to the people who made him, made the movie, he got an Oscar for it +[2907.280 --> 2913.680] and it looks real and the few time, I think it's the one of the few times we see real true emotion +[2913.680 --> 2918.000] here. I mean, we see it come out but when it does come out, man, it comes out pretty good. +[2918.080 --> 2923.600] And I think at the at the end of that little speech, he says about that movie and how great it is +[2923.600 --> 2928.320] and how great the people are and all that, again, we see him hang his head in shame. I think he +[2928.320 --> 2933.120] feels bad about that. He really does. I think at the time when he popped off, he didn't think about +[2933.120 --> 2938.480] any of that stuff as we all do when we pop off about something. So I think that that's what makes him +[2938.480 --> 2943.040] feel so ashamed about it because he knows obviously now he knows it was a bad decision to make. +[2943.600 --> 2949.120] Again, his cadence, his tone is vernacular. Everything returns to the classic wheel smith +[2949.120 --> 2953.440] and the you know, even though I think he did nine in this one as well, they sort of disappear. +[2953.440 --> 2958.800] How many of you doing this with seven in this one? So I think those those they they diminish even +[2958.800 --> 2964.640] more. He's going through there because he's he's really clear. His diction is clean. It's really good, +[2964.640 --> 2970.400] really good. So he's still in there and so this is the most we've seen of the real wheel smith and +[2970.400 --> 2974.240] that thing where he was where he went all by himself and was answering questions from the +[2974.240 --> 2978.880] internet or whatever. Wow. That was pretty bad. But this is I think we're actually seeing I think he +[2978.880 --> 2984.240] might might be getting his confidence back and coming back. His illustrators are really big. Again, +[2984.240 --> 2989.120] that's the old school wheel smith. They're getting he's always using big illustrators and and +[2989.120 --> 2994.160] connecting that way. His diction again, I want to say to you guys really clean and clear before +[2994.160 --> 3000.320] we've seen it was it was it just sounded bad. I mean his his tone was low things they were clear +[3000.320 --> 3005.200] but there wasn't him. Quoting quote if you know what I mean, didn't sell like him. And when he says +[3005.200 --> 3010.400] I hope there will there work will be ordered not tainted. Yannau based on the decision on my part. +[3010.880 --> 3016.560] If he hadn't had the added the Yannau, I think I would have been more into it and and take a +[3016.560 --> 3023.680] little bit more seriously. Again, a fantastic job by Trevor Noah because he's he's setting a +[3023.680 --> 3027.920] thing controlling that mood not only for a will but for the audience as well. And he's setting that +[3027.920 --> 3033.440] thing up. If you could stand back and look at what he's doing. He's just carving out all the +[3034.320 --> 3038.720] bad stuff and just saying, Will, you're a great guy. Look what a great guy. His guy is I know he's a great +[3038.720 --> 3044.480] guy and making it look like he's he has the same revelations about about Will Smith as the audience does. +[3044.480 --> 3048.640] He wants them to have that revelation as well. And I think it's working. I think he's doing a great +[3048.640 --> 3053.600] job. I know I keep I know we get on here. We harp about some interviewers and I'm harped on this +[3053.600 --> 3059.120] when I think he's doing a great job of pulling off what he was supposed to do on this or I think +[3059.120 --> 3064.880] what he if they're friends, if they're buddies, then he's on there doing that the right way. I really +[3064.880 --> 3068.240] wanted to focus on what was happening because I think he's knocking out of the park as an interviewer +[3068.240 --> 3077.840] on that. All right, be good. Okay, Mark, I give you that one. Say, say that's the way you did it. +[3078.800 --> 3083.520] It was a mess. You know, I don't want to go too far into it to give people more to misunderstand +[3083.600 --> 3087.760] this. Is it is it is it hard? You know, you you have lived I realized this morning when I was +[3087.760 --> 3093.040] thinking about you coming on the show. You were one of the rare breed of human who has lived more +[3093.040 --> 3098.640] of your life in the spotlight than out of it. Yeah. You got into this industry as a kid. You know, +[3098.640 --> 3103.680] you grew up and blew up into it as a young man. Yeah. You had your tax issues. You had your life. +[3103.680 --> 3108.880] You had your family. You had you know, but you have lived in this world for so it's it's funny +[3108.880 --> 3112.560] again. I realized chatting to friends and I was like, you know what's interesting here is +[3113.600 --> 3118.560] for us, this is the Oscars. Yeah. Yeah. For Will Smith, this is like a cookout. Right. +[3120.640 --> 3124.720] And I'm not diminishing the Oscars, but I don't like those are your people that's your world. +[3124.720 --> 3128.880] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You know, and I was like I was saying I think that is part of the reason +[3128.880 --> 3133.280] many of us were that truck because you go like, it's this loaded event. It's it's bigger than life. +[3133.280 --> 3136.880] Whereas many movie stars are at the Oscars. Like, oh nice to see you again. Hey, good to be here. +[3136.880 --> 3140.480] Good to be back. And I feel like that that was part of the disconnect. I feel like that was +[3140.480 --> 3147.920] part of, but, but what I, what I did, one thing that's killing me, you know, so emancipation is +[3147.920 --> 3155.200] Antoine's masterpiece. That's what I was talking about. Yeah. He has created an absolute masterpiece. +[3156.320 --> 3162.560] Bob Richardson, the DP and Ben Foster and just all the way down. It's like these top artists +[3163.120 --> 3170.640] in the world have done some of the best work at our career. And the idea that they might be +[3170.640 --> 3181.760] denied because of me is like, you know, it's like that, that is killing me dead, you know. And +[3181.760 --> 3190.000] it's like the thing that is so critical for me is that, you know, these people came and they +[3190.000 --> 3200.800] trusted me and they were down for for me. And, you know, I just, I hope that their work will +[3200.800 --> 3207.520] be honored and their work will not be tainted based on, you know, a horrific decision on my part. +[3208.800 --> 3214.000] You know, and on a personal level, you know, I think I speak for many people if I don't forgive +[3214.080 --> 3218.960] me, but you know, obviously people who are hurt because we love you and we love what you do. +[3220.080 --> 3223.920] People were shocked because, you know, it will smear the Chris Rock. It's, you know, +[3223.920 --> 3228.400] yeah, you know, so I'll ask us all these things. But I also think I speak for people when I say, +[3228.960 --> 3232.160] like, I don't want that to define you. I don't think it should define you, you know what I mean? +[3232.160 --> 3241.120] Yeah. Like I don't think, yeah. Yeah. I don't think any one of us, I don't think any one of us in +[3241.120 --> 3247.600] life deserves to be defined by our cup, like the, the cup, you know, if anything, I mean, like, +[3247.600 --> 3252.800] you and Chris have the biggest story to handle on your own. It's not our, you know, our foray. But, +[3252.800 --> 3258.720] but yeah, man, I hope you don't stay hidden forever. I hope you know that you don't always have +[3258.720 --> 3263.680] to bottle it up. I hope you know that you, you, you, you, you not being perfect is what will make +[3263.680 --> 3271.920] you put you will Smith, man. Yeah. Do you know the mean? You that dude, we love you. You know, +[3271.920 --> 3278.000] you that dude, you know, a big guy was, that was one of the big things for me over this last +[3278.000 --> 3286.400] couple of months, you know, that I had to forgive myself for being human, you know, and it's like, +[3287.680 --> 3292.720] trust me, there's nobody that hates the fact that I'm human more than me. Yeah. Yeah. But I know +[3292.960 --> 3304.080] you're no. And just, you know, finding that space for myself within myself to be human, you know, +[3304.080 --> 3311.680] it's like I want, I've always wanted to be Superman. I've always wanted to swoop in and save the +[3311.680 --> 3321.360] dams of Lynn distress, you know, and I had to humble down, you know, and realize that I'm, +[3321.360 --> 3331.600] I'm a flawed human and I still have an opportunity, you know, to go out in the world and and contribute +[3332.160 --> 3336.320] in a way that fills my heart and hopefully helps other people, you know, so. +[3342.080 --> 3347.200] I agree with you, Greg, I wouldn't want to be Superman. I was always a Spider-Man guy. What were you, +[3347.200 --> 3352.720] Mark? I would, the spider is great. Yeah. I mean, I would want to, who doesn't want to be able to +[3352.720 --> 3360.960] climb walls. Yeah. Yeah. I had as much money as Batman and I'd be just quite happy. Yeah. +[3360.960 --> 3369.760] You chase Batman. Yeah. Superman's a bully. So Greg, you're Batman too. So it's, okay, +[3369.760 --> 3374.160] Mark's mean you mad Spider-Man against Batman. Two Spider-Man. Two Batman. Yeah. +[3374.160 --> 3379.920] With that too. So we both went to places where we got really expensive toys to play with as +[3379.920 --> 3389.200] what we did. Me and Mark from the streets. Yeah. Yeah. And bitten by radioactive spider. +[3390.560 --> 3394.080] I don't have no courage, man. I grew up in no bridge. Let's also get that. You pray happened +[3394.080 --> 3397.440] bitten by radioactive spider. Yeah. I've been in no cruise yet. Radioactive frogs. +[3397.440 --> 3402.080] They're well for your right. Yeah. They had radioactive frogs. Okay. Oh, yeah. Yeah. +[3402.080 --> 3406.720] They found out because they started fighting. You know, they in Oak Ridge since it's the place +[3406.720 --> 3410.640] where they designed the most a lot of the nuclear weapons for America. There's a lot of radiation +[3410.640 --> 3416.160] around here. A lot of things going on. So what happened with these with these a gagger counters and +[3416.160 --> 3421.520] see if there's any radiation anywhere that shouldn't be. And so they're in the grocery store parking lots, +[3421.520 --> 3425.360] they were finding radiation and they couldn't figure out why they're like why are we getting why +[3425.360 --> 3430.320] we've these things jacking up in the parking lots of the grocery stores because when people +[3430.320 --> 3434.480] were coming home from work out of the plants, they were running over these frogs where they'd been +[3434.480 --> 3439.360] radiation leak and one of those in one of the big ponds out there and the frogs were jumping +[3439.360 --> 3443.200] out of the road. People would run over them. And then when they went to the grocery store, +[3443.200 --> 3448.000] they were parking the parking lot and would heat up the the parking lot out there. That's crazy. +[3448.080 --> 3454.720] So well, well, we're the wonder that the chicken so hot out there. You know, for like 40 years, +[3454.720 --> 3460.400] Oak Ridge was it was illegal to list Oak Ridge on a national map. That's right. +[3460.400 --> 3464.880] That didn't exist. That's a press. You walk around out the woods here and there'll be a science +[3464.880 --> 3468.640] that says don't go any further. Somebody will be here in just a minute. You know, and then there's +[3468.640 --> 3473.360] all the the glowing jumping frogs. Then you have those frogs show frog people show up. +[3473.440 --> 3478.880] Yeah, we've got pictures. We take our pictures and Bob Lazar. Yeah, yeah. And Bob Lazar. +[3480.320 --> 3486.000] Yeah, Bob has a little cottage just down the road. Sure. A little place. Okay, here we are. +[3487.600 --> 3492.080] All right, Chase, what do you got? I think Trevor in this clip here assists +[3493.760 --> 3500.320] a lot by pre-socializing or I'm just making that word up. He's pre-socializing the incident +[3500.320 --> 3504.960] for just setting it up. And he's saying I need to forgive myself for being human. +[3505.680 --> 3513.120] I think he is masterfully letting us know not only what to do with him, but he's offering us +[3513.120 --> 3520.400] probably very good advice for what might be good for us to do for ourselves. And that is pretty +[3520.400 --> 3526.560] good. When it when it applies to a person, it helps us forgive a person. And it also feels like +[3526.560 --> 3533.280] something we should maybe allow into our our mindset a little bit. We're 10 times more likely to +[3533.280 --> 3539.440] accept it. So this is him saying that there's just little gap here. And I need to allow that gap +[3539.440 --> 3545.120] we're more likely to accept it. So that's all I got. No, Mark, we go. Yeah, so I think here we get +[3545.120 --> 3550.240] potentially the most revelatory and honest body language in the whole piece. I'll come to that in +[3550.240 --> 3556.080] a second. But before that, first of all, just notice how many times Trevor Noah now says, you know, +[3557.200 --> 3562.560] the his opening statement is opening thought it's about, I think, five four, five times. +[3564.080 --> 3577.120] And he offers, I don't have this, he offers you, you not being perfect is what will make you perfect. +[3577.120 --> 3582.720] Well, that's what we call a truism because it sounds really good, but it's utter nonsense. +[3582.720 --> 3590.240] It's complete nonsense because it utterly contradicts itself. But it sounds kind of beautiful. +[3590.240 --> 3599.280] So I'm always worried when in pieces of spin, somebody gets a truism past us. That is utter nonsense, +[3599.280 --> 3605.680] but it feels like yeah, yeah, the yeah, not being perfect is the thing that is is perfect. No, +[3605.680 --> 3612.400] it's not. There are two separate things. You can't have both at the same time. It's just object +[3612.480 --> 3619.280] nonsense. So Noah gets that out. And then we get the truest piece of body language, which +[3620.880 --> 3627.680] I still have an opportunity says Smith and we get a single shoulder shrug from him and disdain. +[3628.320 --> 3634.000] I think he's sincerely worried that that his opportunity is gone. He's not going to get another +[3634.000 --> 3643.280] go at this. He's blown it completely. I think there is a sincere worry for him that that there are +[3643.280 --> 3649.920] no more opportunities for him. He's done. And he wants to get the chance to help other people. +[3649.920 --> 3657.680] And then we see more disdain. I don't think it's disdain for helping other people. I do think that's +[3657.680 --> 3662.880] a kind of classic thing to put forward. You know, I only do this film stuff to help other people. +[3662.880 --> 3668.080] That's all I'm about. I'm not sure that's all his film career is about. I don't think that's +[3668.080 --> 3673.360] probably why he went into into film. I don't think anybody goes into Hollywood going because I want +[3673.360 --> 3678.480] to help him. I want to help the children. I want to help people. I don't think anybody really goes +[3678.480 --> 3684.320] in for that for that reason. So that that worries me. But help other people we see disdain. I think +[3684.320 --> 3692.960] again, it's disdain potentially for himself. I think it's disdain for this whole situation, +[3692.960 --> 3701.840] which is about to potentially in his mind, acts his career completely. Maybe it won't. It'd be a shame +[3701.840 --> 3710.480] maybe if it did because he is an incredible star that we hadn't seen before. Total unique, +[3710.480 --> 3716.400] total class of one, amazing. Went up and slapped somebody. Lost it. Didn't he? Lost it and he +[3716.400 --> 3721.120] won't tell us why. He lost it and he won't tell us why. Scott, what do you got on this one? +[3721.680 --> 3727.680] I think we need to talk about how Chase's blue shirt makes his eyes pop. It does. It's the kind of +[3727.680 --> 3735.680] blue grass on this. It's because I do like. Yeah, some of the lags working this time. Yeah. +[3735.680 --> 3736.720] I think we're good. +[3739.200 --> 3742.800] All right. I'm going to fix where white with the blue stripe. Just so you know, don't do +[3742.800 --> 3749.360] don't wear the insurge. Okay. Well, here's the in section where a great interviewer helps repair +[3749.360 --> 3754.400] a damaged brand. And I think I think Trevor Noah and I keep saying there's a great job of this. +[3754.400 --> 3760.400] You know, I think it's because he's a comedian and comedians take a lot of guff. I'm saying guff. +[3761.200 --> 3766.160] A lot of you know, a lot from people when they're when they're out being comedians. So I think +[3766.160 --> 3770.320] you get really good at that. And I think a lot of that confidence is from doing that. It's where +[3770.320 --> 3775.280] he's gotten a lot of his confidence. And he walks you through or he walks you or you and the audience +[3775.280 --> 3782.320] through what will wants to say to the audience into you. What he wants you to leave. What he wants +[3782.320 --> 3787.840] to leave you with. In other words, so I think he does a great job of doing that in the overall +[3787.840 --> 3793.440] in these five videos we've watched. Now if we left out the Yanaz, I think it would have been a +[3793.440 --> 3797.440] little bit more powerful. If he had kept being himself, he may not be able, he may not be at that +[3797.440 --> 3804.080] point yet. But I think if he hadn't tried to try to lean back in that comfort zone of using Yanaz +[3804.080 --> 3808.720] every other sentence, he's a down to 10 and that's when he only said 10 times. I think it would have +[3808.720 --> 3813.440] done a little bit better. I think he might still be in there. Now if you try to make a comeback, +[3814.080 --> 3818.800] I think I think he may be able to, you know, if he gets his continues to get his head together, +[3820.480 --> 3825.040] but he's still using to me phrases from therapy and the Yanaz, I think that's what's sort of +[3825.040 --> 3831.760] damaging here for me anyway. So it's Greg where do you got? I think you have to be careful when +[3831.760 --> 3837.440] you've already done the thing he did after the slap that you don't come across as out of touch. +[3837.440 --> 3841.680] And I think although you know, sort of make him human, that's all I think he's doing. I do think +[3841.680 --> 3845.760] he came with a message and intended message and the last two pieces come out here, Mark, and +[3846.400 --> 3850.960] I agree with you when he says opportunity and does that single shoulder shrug. I think he may be +[3850.960 --> 3856.880] a little concerned that he may not have that opportunity, but he came here to say, I'm only human, +[3856.880 --> 3861.680] I made a mistake. I had to admit that I'm human as much as I don't want to be. I want to do more +[3861.680 --> 3866.640] good things. That's the end of the messaging. And I think, look, when I say this, that doesn't mean +[3866.640 --> 3871.600] I think the guys being deceptive by any stretch. I think like all of us, we all make mistakes, +[3872.080 --> 3876.000] when your career is on the line, you're going to try to figure out how to get back to where you were. +[3876.000 --> 3880.560] And it gets exactly what he came here to do. And he's delivering that message and he has people +[3880.560 --> 3886.080] talking and paying attention to him. By the end, he gets when the audience actually connects and +[3886.080 --> 3892.720] laughs or cheers, see his face light up. You can see that's what he does this for. Let's face it. +[3892.720 --> 3897.120] People did do this for living. Mark, you've been there before. People do this for living appreciate +[3897.120 --> 3902.720] when the audience appreciates what they do. So you can see that real smile of acceptance in his face. +[3902.720 --> 3907.200] And then he goes into that, forgive myself in some very specific language. I don't think it was an +[3907.200 --> 3910.880] accident. I think all of this messaging coming in and saying, I was going through more than you can +[3910.880 --> 3917.280] imagine. And, and, and I'm only human. And I hope I have another opportunity. +[3917.280 --> 3923.120] You know, and, and on a personal level, you know, I think I speak for many people if I don't +[3923.120 --> 3928.320] forgive me. But, you know, obviously people who are hurt. Because we love you and we love what you +[3928.320 --> 3933.520] do. People were shocked because, you know, we'll submit this, Chris Rock. It's, you know, +[3933.520 --> 3938.640] you know, so, Oscar's all these things. But I also think I speak for people when I say, like, +[3938.640 --> 3941.920] I don't want that to define you. I don't think it should define you. You know what I mean? +[3941.920 --> 3947.840] Yeah. Like, I don't think, I don't think, yeah. Yeah. I don't think any one of us, +[3947.840 --> 3953.040] I don't think any one of us in life deserves to be defined by our +[3953.040 --> 3960.000] cop. Like, if anything, I mean, like, you and Chris have the biggest story to handle on your own. +[3960.000 --> 3965.440] It's not our, you know, our, our foray. But, but yeah, man, I hope you don't stay hidden forever. +[3965.440 --> 3970.000] No, no, no, no, no. I hope you know that you don't always have to bottle it up. I hope you know that you, +[3970.000 --> 3974.320] you, you, you, you not being perfect is what will make you perfect. You will smith, man. +[3974.320 --> 3975.520] Yeah. You know what I mean? +[3975.520 --> 3978.560] You're that dude. We love you, so real. +[3978.560 --> 3986.640] I think you're that dude. You know, a big guy was, that was one of the big things for me over this +[3986.640 --> 3996.000] last couple of months. You know, that I had to forgive myself for being human. You know, and it's like, +[3997.280 --> 4000.800] trust me, there's nobody that hates the fact that I'm human more than me. Yeah. +[4000.800 --> 4011.680] Yeah. But I know that. You know, and just, you know, finding that space for myself within myself +[4011.680 --> 4018.080] to be human, you know, it's like I want, I've always wanted to be Superman. I've always wanted to +[4018.880 --> 4029.120] swoop in and save the dams of limb distress, you know, and I had to humble down, you know, and +[4029.120 --> 4039.440] realized that I'm a flawed human. And I still have an opportunity, you know, to go out in the world +[4039.440 --> 4044.800] and and contribute in a way that fills my heart and hopefully helps other people. +[4050.160 --> 4054.400] Let's start around room one time and talk about what we think we've seen. And see if you can knock +[4054.400 --> 4057.280] it down to 30 seconds or less and wrap it up. Mark, where do you got? +[4058.160 --> 4062.560] Yeah. For me, this is the Hollywood machine trying to support the cash that's gone in there. +[4062.560 --> 4069.280] There is a man there trying to save his career at the same time. My heart goes out to him on, +[4069.280 --> 4074.800] on that. There was a not missed opportunity here, which is Trevor Noah is a comedian. One, +[4074.800 --> 4080.480] another comedian got slapped on stage. There's a, there's an interesting set of questions that +[4080.480 --> 4087.840] Noah could be asking in this situation from his point as a comedian who was, who'd have to take +[4087.840 --> 4094.720] a lot of guff, Scott, including getting slapped now by a list celebrities during major events. +[4095.440 --> 4100.880] Chase, what do you thoughts? Yeah. I think this is one thing I've noticed with Will and just about +[4100.880 --> 4106.160] every other human in the world. When a person reaches a point in their life, but they've felt like +[4106.160 --> 4111.680] they're not in control for a long period of time, one small incident can make somebody behave +[4111.680 --> 4118.720] in just super erratic ways. When the incident does two things. Number one, it makes them feel out +[4118.720 --> 4124.480] of control. So it's a little spike loss of control. Number two, it shines a bright light on how little +[4124.480 --> 4130.080] control they feel like they have. So bringing all the insecurities right in front of their face. +[4130.080 --> 4134.160] And this is where you see road rage, bar fights, and almost any other situation where somebody +[4134.160 --> 4142.240] just has this unexpected surge in violent or angry behavior. And this is, this is it. +[4142.880 --> 4150.000] This is the lost control tipping point. Let's call it. Greg. I agree with you 100% Chase. This is a +[4150.000 --> 4153.920] bright light on an ugly baby. Somewhere is what happened. There's some baggage he has. We don't +[4153.920 --> 4158.640] know what it is. It's likely somehow tied to his wife, something that had happened leading up to. +[4158.640 --> 4163.360] We saw her roller eyes and make hard eye contact with him. He was laughing until then in the thing. +[4163.360 --> 4168.640] So here he has to come back and he has to say, look, no matter what I did that night, I'm still +[4168.640 --> 4172.960] the guy you love. That's what this whole message is about. I think you get did a convincing job by +[4172.960 --> 4178.000] the end, but we're trying to connect with people. But at the end of the day, you're dead on it. That +[4178.000 --> 4182.080] entire thing. People are under a lot of pressure in different places than we know. We know the +[4182.080 --> 4187.120] will Smith that he presents to us. We don't know what goes on behind his house door, what kind of +[4187.120 --> 4191.440] conversations him and his wife are having, what other things are going on, maybe business wise, +[4191.520 --> 4197.920] and something boils up to that point. It takes a lot, however, to walk 50 feet and slap somebody. +[4197.920 --> 4203.680] That's a lot. That's not a sudden boil up. That's a long-term boil up and something that it has +[4203.680 --> 4209.120] been simmering for a while. Scott, what do you got? I'm going to say what I said before. I think +[4209.120 --> 4215.040] this is a great interviewer repairing a damaged brand or attempting to repair a damaged brand. +[4215.040 --> 4219.600] And I think you're right, Mark. I think that you've got a comedian on one side talking to an +[4219.600 --> 4225.040] actor on the other side. And if he was on the comedian team, then he would, there were some other +[4225.040 --> 4229.360] questions he could have asked a little bit different attitude he could have had in there. But I +[4229.360 --> 4233.520] think maybe their buddies or friends, and that's why he's going easy on him. Plus, you're right, +[4233.520 --> 4239.360] again, Mark. They're trying to, it's Hollywood repairing Hollywood at that point. So that's what +[4239.360 --> 4243.440] looks like to me. All right, Bill. I think this was another good and then I'll see you next time. +[4249.600 --> 4250.240] Oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh, hey, oh diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_ET7qsJv6nLk.txt b/transcript/ceremony_ET7qsJv6nLk.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4cfd1b2cb35a84c3b10dc0314a796efb2c0e4a3e --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_ET7qsJv6nLk.txt @@ -0,0 +1,20 @@ +[0.000 --> 7.000] Your body language is much more powerful than the words you speak. +[13.000 --> 20.000] When you're looking for the right composure in front of an audience, you must remember this circle of impact. +[20.000 --> 26.000] More than half of the impact you have on an audience is caused by your body language. +[26.000 --> 32.000] 38% of the impact you have is caused by your voice and the way you speak. +[32.000 --> 38.000] And only 7% of the impact is due to the content of your story. +[38.000 --> 40.000] It's not a lot, is it? +[40.000 --> 45.000] So, nice and good body language is very important. +[45.000 --> 49.000] Where do we start? We start with our feet, with our legs. +[49.000 --> 55.000] We plant them like trees in the earth, which doesn't mean that you can't move around during a presentation. +[56.000 --> 63.000] But it needs stability. Your story needs to be stable also, so you need physical stability. +[63.000 --> 70.000] And then your shoulders. You have to straighten those shoulders and tuck up your chin. +[70.000 --> 75.000] And to know where these shoulders should be, there's a very small exercise. +[75.000 --> 80.000] You just lift them up very high and let them drop. And then they are where they should be. +[81.000 --> 87.000] So, feet, shoulders and then your hands and your arms. What do we do with these? +[87.000 --> 94.000] Well, one thing you have to remember is that you have to keep an open communication with your public. +[94.000 --> 99.000] So, this creates a barrier. We don't do this. +[99.000 --> 106.000] This is much too waiting. You're actually demanding commands from the audience. +[106.000 --> 112.000] So, what we want to do is to make the distance between yourself and the audience smaller. +[112.000 --> 115.000] So, reach out with those hands and those arms. +[115.000 --> 122.000] Alright? Feet, hands and of course, never to forget. A smile. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_JiigoIOHw6w.txt b/transcript/ceremony_JiigoIOHw6w.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8694df209d4cc7bb028aeba9709e7f307354b4d6 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_JiigoIOHw6w.txt @@ -0,0 +1,30 @@ +[0.000 --> 9.920] Megan Markle faced a shocking rejection after reaching out to hold Prince Harry's hand during +[9.920 --> 14.440] young leaders' reception at Buckingham Palace, as the Duke of Sussex quickly moved his hand +[14.440 --> 18.660] away, avoiding the Duchess' attempt to publicly display her affection. +[18.660 --> 23.160] The awkward video shows the newlywed strolling behind the queen, when Megan slid her hand +[23.160 --> 27.560] down to her side, glancing at Harry as she tried to reach out for his hand. +[27.560 --> 31.980] The Duke abruptly rejected her attempt, keeping his hands in front of his body and fiddling +[31.980 --> 36.080] with his tie, while Megan awkwardly tucked her hair behind her ear. +[36.080 --> 41.200] Typically royals do not indulge in public displays of affection, particularly in the queen's +[41.200 --> 42.200] presence. +[42.200 --> 46.540] However in the lead up to their royal wedding, Megan and Harry have been known to show affectionate +[46.540 --> 51.040] public gestures, attracting remarks from body language experts. +[51.040 --> 53.440] Body language expert Robin Kermode said, +[53.440 --> 57.680] The queen rarely holds hands with her husband in public and this seems to have set an unwritten +[57.680 --> 60.080] precedent for the other royals. +[60.080 --> 64.520] It is very clear that William and Kate are emotionally close, however, they do not seem +[64.520 --> 69.280] to feel the need to prove their love, particularly when on official state business. +[69.280 --> 73.860] The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge are rarely seen holding hands or displaying affection in +[73.860 --> 75.280] public. +[75.280 --> 79.640] Speaking on Kate and William's lack of public displays of affection, royal etiquette expert +[79.640 --> 84.560] Mika Meyer said, There is no actual etiquette or royal protocol that says the couple must +[84.560 --> 87.480] refrain from public displays of affection. +[87.480 --> 92.240] The likely reasoning is more that while traveling on a tour such as the India trip, technically +[92.240 --> 95.920] the couple are working representatives of British monarchy. +[95.920 --> 100.420] The couple are likely to show very little public displays of affection, if any, to remain +[100.420 --> 103.280] professional during their designated roles abroad. +[103.280 --> 107.840] Megan and Harry are set to make an appearance a major exhibition on the life of Nelson Mandela +[107.840 --> 112.520] at the South Bank Center's Queen Elizabeth Hall on the July 17, following their two-day +[112.520 --> 115.560] visit to Dublin on July 10 and 11. +[115.560 --> 119.840] The Duke and Duchess of Sussex will tour the exhibition, which traces Mandela's career +[119.840 --> 123.640] throughout the years, making it the first time the exhibit will shown in the UK. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_KkLu1l7U3AM.txt b/transcript/ceremony_KkLu1l7U3AM.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5ba7caa6c231890af52dfb68280e7ad5e8205687 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_KkLu1l7U3AM.txt @@ -0,0 +1,56 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.720] The current state of the relationship between former president Donald Trump and his wife, +[4.720 --> 9.360] Melania Trump, may be a little fragile, at least according to one eagle-eyed expert. +[9.360 --> 14.640] On January 18, the current GOP frontrunner and his former model wife attended the funeral +[14.640 --> 20.320] of Melania's mom, Amalia Nobs, who died on January 9 in Miami at 78 years old, following +[20.320 --> 21.800] an undisclosed illness. +[21.800 --> 25.880] Now I'm forever grateful for the beauty she brought into my life. +[25.880 --> 30.740] During the funeral, Donald and Melania's interactions, or lack thereof, seemingly hinted at some +[30.740 --> 32.560] tension in their relationship. +[32.560 --> 36.800] While the former first lady has weathered many of her husband's most chaotic moments, +[36.800 --> 40.100] it seems like she has been a little cold toward him in recent months. +[40.100 --> 44.160] The disconnected nature of their interactions at the funeral has author and body language +[44.160 --> 48.680] expert Jess Ponce III, believing there may be trouble brewing for this former presidential +[48.680 --> 49.680] power couple. +[49.680 --> 55.560] When a married couple attends something as deeply emotional as a funeral, you would +[55.560 --> 58.480] expect there to be some display of love between them. +[58.480 --> 62.720] But for Donald and Melania Trump, close moments at her mother's funeral were few and far +[62.720 --> 63.720] between. +[63.720 --> 67.640] After leaving the church, the couple stood side by side, not touching, as her mother's +[67.640 --> 69.600] casket was placed in the hearse. +[69.600 --> 73.380] Although their somber demeanor was fitting for the occasion, Ponce noted the lack of +[73.380 --> 75.760] affection between the couple was strange. +[75.760 --> 80.080] Ponce told the list that if only that moment was observed, the respectful distancing wouldn't +[80.080 --> 82.240] be totally unusual at a funeral. +[82.240 --> 86.360] However, when it came time to depart the church, the couple left in separate cars, their +[86.360 --> 89.600] personal interaction showing a distinct lack of connection. +[89.600 --> 90.600] Ponce said, +[90.600 --> 95.200] Donald courteously accompanied Melania to her car, sharing a few words, yet there was no +[95.200 --> 98.240] physical contact or display of intimacy between them. +[98.240 --> 103.200] In fact, Donald stood several feet from the car while a guard held the door open for Melania. +[103.200 --> 106.920] The former president didn't place a comforting hand on her back, didn't help her into the +[106.920 --> 109.720] car, and didn't lean in to share a private moment. +[109.720 --> 113.440] He simply spoke to her from a distance, then walked to his own vehicle. +[113.440 --> 118.080] The vibe outside the church where the trumps were married in 2005 was distinctly chilly, +[118.080 --> 121.880] and according to the Body Language Pro, that raises questions about the state of the couple's +[121.880 --> 123.280] relationship today. +[123.280 --> 126.480] Donald Trump obviously has a lot of irons in the fire. +[126.480 --> 130.920] Simultaneously defending himself in multiple legal battles, the former president is also +[130.920 --> 135.280] attempting a second shot at the White House in the 2024 presidential election. +[135.280 --> 139.480] And while he's been in court and on the campaign trail, his wife Melania has been conspicuously +[139.480 --> 140.480] absent. +[140.480 --> 145.000] In May 2023, Melania professed her support for her husband and his bid for another turn +[145.000 --> 146.320] in the Oval Office. +[146.320 --> 150.960] However, by September 2023, she had yet to appear on the campaign trail with him, and the +[150.960 --> 153.200] public started to question her no-shows. +[153.200 --> 158.080] Donald told Meet the Press she would be with him pretty soon, but as of January 2024, +[158.080 --> 160.480] had yet to join him at any rallies or events. +[160.480 --> 163.040] And honestly, I like to keep her away from it. +[163.040 --> 165.160] It's so nasty and so mean. +[165.160 --> 170.120] Likewise, his wife was not in attendance at any of her husband's many courthouse appearances. +[170.120 --> 173.800] Between Donald's schedule and Melania's grief, there seems to be a lack of physical +[173.800 --> 176.560] support on the part of both husband and wife. +[176.560 --> 180.600] But Ponce thinks their public appearances in the coming weeks will likely shed some light +[180.600 --> 182.920] on just how strong their relationship is. +[182.920 --> 183.920] Ponce told the list, +[183.920 --> 187.560] The real curiosity lies in what the future holds for their interactions. +[187.560 --> 191.480] The next time we witness them together, we'll likely be the most revealing moment yet. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_L9Pf8UtsJGU.txt b/transcript/ceremony_L9Pf8UtsJGU.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..123c2662b08998459e14ce1b90e70fd05cf93da8 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_L9Pf8UtsJGU.txt @@ -0,0 +1,203 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.000] 1.5% +[4.000 --> 8.000] 1.5% +[8.000 --> 12.000] 1.5% +[12.000 --> 16.000] 1.5% +[16.000 --> 20.000] 1.5% +[20.000 --> 24.000] 1.5% +[24.000 --> 28.000] 1.5% +[28.000 --> 32.000] 1.5% +[32.000 --> 36.000] 1.5% +[36.000 --> 40.000] 1.5% +[40.000 --> 44.000] 1.5% +[44.000 --> 48.000] 1.5% +[48.000 --> 52.000] 1.5% +[52.000 --> 56.000] 1.5% +[56.000 --> 60.000] 1.5% +[60.000 --> 64.000] 1.5% +[64.000 --> 68.000] 1.5% +[68.000 --> 72.000] 1.5% +[72.000 --> 76.000] 1.5% +[76.000 --> 80.000] 1.5% +[80.000 --> 84.000] 1.5% +[84.000 --> 88.000] 1.5% +[88.000 --> 92.000] 1.5% +[92.000 --> 96.000] 1.5% +[96.000 --> 100.000] 1.5% +[100.000 --> 104.000] 1.5% +[104.000 --> 108.000] 1.5% +[108.000 --> 112.000] 1.5% +[112.000 --> 116.000] 1.5% +[116.000 --> 120.000] 1.5% +[120.000 --> 124.000] 1.5% +[124.000 --> 128.000] 1.5% +[128.000 --> 132.000] 1.5% +[132.000 --> 136.000] 1.5% +[136.000 --> 140.000] 1.5% +[140.000 --> 144.000] 1.5% +[144.000 --> 148.000] 1.5% +[148.000 --> 152.000] 1.5% +[152.000 --> 156.000] 1.5% +[156.000 --> 160.000] 1.5% +[160.000 --> 164.000] 1.5% +[164.000 --> 168.000] 1.5% +[168.000 --> 172.000] 1.5% +[172.000 --> 176.000] 1.5% +[176.000 --> 180.000] 1.5% +[180.000 --> 184.000] 1.5% +[184.000 --> 188.000] 1.5% +[188.000 --> 192.000] 1.5% +[192.000 --> 196.000] 1.5% +[196.000 --> 200.000] 1.5% +[200.000 --> 204.000] 1.5% +[204.000 --> 208.000] 1.5% +[208.000 --> 212.000] 1.5% +[212.000 --> 216.000] 1.5% +[216.000 --> 220.000] 1.5% +[220.000 --> 224.000] 1.5% +[224.000 --> 228.000] 1.5% +[228.000 --> 232.000] 1.5% +[232.000 --> 236.000] 1.5% +[236.000 --> 240.000] 1.5% +[240.000 --> 244.000] 1.5% +[244.000 --> 248.000] 1.5% +[248.000 --> 252.000] 1.5% +[252.000 --> 256.000] 1.5% +[256.000 --> 260.000] 1.5% +[260.000 --> 264.000] 1.5% +[264.000 --> 268.000] 1.5% +[268.000 --> 272.000] 1.5% +[272.000 --> 276.000] 1.5% +[276.000 --> 280.000] 1.5% +[280.000 --> 284.000] 1.5% +[284.000 --> 288.000] 1.5% +[288.000 --> 292.000] 1.5% +[292.000 --> 296.000] 1.5% +[296.000 --> 300.000] 1.5% +[300.000 --> 304.000] 1.5% +[304.000 --> 308.000] 1.5% +[308.000 --> 312.000] 1.5% +[312.000 --> 316.000] 1.5% +[316.000 --> 320.000] 1.5% +[320.000 --> 324.000] 1.5% +[324.000 --> 328.000] 1.5% +[328.000 --> 332.000] 1.5% +[332.000 --> 336.000] 1.5% +[336.000 --> 340.000] 1.5% +[340.000 --> 344.000] 1.5% +[344.000 --> 348.000] 1.5% +[348.000 --> 352.000] 1.5% +[352.000 --> 356.000] 1.5% +[356.000 --> 360.000] 1.5% +[360.000 --> 364.000] 1.5% +[364.000 --> 368.000] 1.5% +[368.000 --> 372.000] 1.5% +[372.000 --> 376.000] 1.5% +[376.000 --> 380.000] 1.5% +[380.000 --> 384.000] 1.5% +[384.000 --> 388.000] 1.5% +[388.000 --> 392.000] 1.5% +[392.000 --> 396.000] 1.5% +[396.000 --> 400.000] 1.5% +[400.000 --> 404.000] 1.5% +[404.000 --> 408.000] 1.5% +[408.000 --> 412.000] 1.5% +[412.000 --> 416.000] 1.5% +[416.000 --> 420.000] 1.5% +[420.000 --> 424.000] 1.5% +[424.000 --> 428.000] 1.5% +[428.000 --> 432.000] 1.5% +[432.000 --> 436.000] 1.5% +[436.000 --> 440.000] 1.5% +[440.000 --> 444.000] 1.5% +[444.000 --> 448.000] 1.5% +[448.000 --> 452.000] 1.5% +[452.000 --> 456.000] 1.5% +[456.000 --> 460.000] 1.5% +[460.000 --> 464.000] 1.5% +[464.000 --> 468.000] 1.5% +[468.000 --> 472.000] 1.5% +[472.000 --> 476.000] 1.5% +[476.000 --> 480.000] 1.5% +[480.000 --> 484.000] 1.5% +[484.000 --> 488.000] 1.5% +[488.000 --> 492.000] 1.5% +[492.000 --> 496.000] 1.5% +[496.000 --> 500.000] 1.5% +[500.000 --> 504.000] 1.5% +[504.000 --> 508.000] 1.5% +[508.000 --> 512.000] 1.5% +[512.000 --> 516.000] 1.5% +[516.000 --> 520.000] 1.5% +[520.000 --> 524.000] 1.5% +[524.000 --> 528.000] 1.5% +[528.000 --> 532.000] 1.5% +[532.000 --> 536.000] 1.5% +[536.000 --> 540.000] 1.5% +[540.000 --> 544.000] 1.5% +[544.000 --> 548.000] 1.5% +[548.000 --> 552.000] 1.5% +[552.000 --> 556.000] 1.5% +[556.000 --> 560.000] 1.5% +[560.000 --> 564.000] 1.5% +[564.000 --> 568.000] 1.5% +[568.000 --> 572.000] 1.5% +[572.000 --> 576.000] 1.5% +[576.000 --> 580.000] 1.5% +[580.000 --> 584.000] 1.5% +[584.000 --> 588.000] 1.5% +[588.000 --> 592.000] 1.5% +[592.000 --> 596.000] 1.5% +[596.000 --> 600.000] 1.5% +[600.000 --> 604.000] 1.5% +[604.000 --> 608.000] 1.5% +[608.000 --> 612.000] 1.5% +[612.000 --> 616.000] 1.5% +[616.000 --> 620.000] 1.5% +[620.000 --> 624.000] 1.5% +[624.000 --> 628.000] 1.5% +[628.000 --> 632.000] 1.5% +[632.000 --> 636.000] 1.5% +[636.000 --> 640.000] 1.5% +[640.000 --> 644.000] 1.5% +[644.000 --> 648.000] 1.5% +[648.000 --> 652.000] 1.5% +[652.000 --> 656.000] 1.5% +[656.000 --> 660.000] 1.5% +[660.000 --> 664.000] 1.5% +[664.000 --> 668.000] 1.5% +[668.000 --> 672.000] 1.5% +[672.000 --> 676.000] 1.5% +[676.000 --> 680.000] 1.5% +[680.000 --> 684.000] 1.5% +[684.000 --> 688.000] 1.5% +[688.000 --> 692.000] 1.5% +[692.000 --> 696.000] 1.5% +[696.000 --> 700.000] 1.5% +[700.000 --> 704.000] 1.5% +[704.000 --> 708.000] 1.5% +[708.000 --> 712.000] 1.5% +[712.000 --> 716.000] 1.5% +[716.000 --> 720.000] 1.5% +[720.000 --> 724.000] 1.5% +[724.000 --> 728.000] 1.5% +[728.000 --> 732.000] 1.5% +[732.000 --> 736.000] 1.5% +[736.000 --> 740.000] 1.5% +[740.000 --> 744.000] 1.5% +[744.000 --> 748.000] 1.5% +[748.000 --> 752.000] 1.5% +[752.000 --> 756.000] 1.5% +[756.000 --> 760.000] 1.5% +[760.000 --> 764.000] 1.5% +[764.000 --> 768.000] 1.5% +[768.000 --> 772.000] 1.5% +[772.000 --> 776.000] 1.5% +[776.000 --> 780.000] 1.5% +[780.000 --> 784.000] 1.5% +[784.000 --> 788.000] 1.5% +[788.000 --> 792.000] 1.5% +[792.000 --> 796.000] 1.5% +[796.000 --> 800.000] 1.5% +[800.000 --> 804.000] 1.5% +[804.000 --> 808.000] 1.5% +[808.000 --> 812.000] 1.5% diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_LIyZ24mW-14.txt b/transcript/ceremony_LIyZ24mW-14.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..72bf449866cd2a7cc07bf64fb305a03117ec60c8 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_LIyZ24mW-14.txt @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +[90.000 --> 120.000] Who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be +[120.000 --> 127.800] the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one of the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who will be the one who won the prizeания for the winnericorn. +[150.000 --> 161.980] Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_M-kAQh0aeeU.txt b/transcript/ceremony_M-kAQh0aeeU.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..67d7338e2564eab7d9f16af281096233e731c0a5 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_M-kAQh0aeeU.txt @@ -0,0 +1,189 @@ +[0.000 --> 8.900] You've got about two more hours before we need to get this project in. +[8.900 --> 10.900] Oh wow. +[10.900 --> 12.400] We better focus on it. +[12.400 --> 13.400] Okay, yeah. +[13.400 --> 14.400] Okay, got it. +[14.400 --> 16.400] 12 seconds later. +[16.400 --> 24.400] You know where you can, you press B and then you can change your play. +[24.400 --> 25.400] Oh yeah. +[25.400 --> 27.400] No Marybro? +[27.400 --> 28.400] Every time. +[28.400 --> 30.600] So where's the best? +[58.400 --> 65.400] Okay, got it. +[65.400 --> 72.400] It was good time baby. +[72.400 --> 75.400] You ready bro? +[75.400 --> 76.400] You gonna lose today? +[76.400 --> 77.400] All right. +[77.400 --> 78.400] All right, you want some popcorn? +[78.400 --> 79.400] No. +[79.400 --> 80.400] You want some popcorn? +[80.400 --> 81.400] No. +[81.400 --> 82.400] All right. +[82.400 --> 83.400] Let's get you caught up on what's going on with my wallet. +[83.400 --> 90.400] It was very hard. +[90.400 --> 91.400] Like what? +[91.400 --> 93.400] No, man. +[93.400 --> 94.400] All right. +[94.400 --> 95.400] Oh. +[95.400 --> 98.400] Woo! +[98.400 --> 103.400] My wallet is. +[103.400 --> 105.400] You see this? +[105.400 --> 106.400] Oh, it's wrong. +[106.400 --> 107.400] It's wrong. +[107.400 --> 108.400] It's wrong. +[108.400 --> 109.400] That's it. +[109.400 --> 110.400] Come on. +[110.400 --> 117.400] Oh, so lovely you are. +[117.400 --> 124.400] Full of grace and peace. +[124.400 --> 128.400] Dude. +[128.400 --> 129.400] What's up? +[129.400 --> 130.400] Hey, up. +[130.400 --> 131.400] Come on. +[131.400 --> 132.400] You see this? +[132.400 --> 133.400] You see this? +[133.400 --> 134.400] Yeah. +[134.400 --> 135.400] I see this. +[135.400 --> 136.400] I see this. +[136.400 --> 137.400] I see this. +[137.400 --> 138.400] Come on. +[138.400 --> 139.400] You see this? +[139.400 --> 140.400] Really? +[140.400 --> 144.400] There's only three of us here. +[144.400 --> 145.400] You have to sit right here. +[145.400 --> 146.400] Oh, oh. +[146.400 --> 147.400] Oh, yeah. +[147.400 --> 148.400] Oh, it's like that. +[148.400 --> 149.400] You can't see? +[149.400 --> 156.400] Get off, man. +[156.400 --> 165.400] Shut up! +[165.400 --> 167.400] Get off! +[167.400 --> 168.400] Get off! +[196.400 --> 197.400] I see this. +[197.400 --> 198.400] I see this. +[198.400 --> 199.400] I see this. +[199.400 --> 200.400] I see this. +[200.400 --> 201.400] I see this. +[201.400 --> 202.400] I see this. +[202.400 --> 203.400] I see this. +[203.400 --> 204.400] I see this. +[204.400 --> 205.400] I see this. +[205.400 --> 206.400] I see this. +[206.400 --> 207.400] I see this. +[207.400 --> 208.400] I see this. +[208.400 --> 209.400] I see this. +[209.400 --> 210.400] I see this. +[210.400 --> 211.400] I see this. +[211.400 --> 212.400] I see this. +[212.400 --> 213.400] I see this. +[213.400 --> 214.400] I see this. +[214.400 --> 215.400] I see this. +[215.400 --> 216.400] I see this. +[216.400 --> 217.400] I see this. +[217.400 --> 218.400] I see this. +[218.400 --> 219.400] I see this. +[219.400 --> 220.400] I see this. +[220.400 --> 221.400] I see this. +[221.400 --> 222.400] I see this. +[222.400 --> 223.400] I see this. +[223.400 --> 224.400] I see this. +[224.400 --> 226.400] I see this. +[226.400 --> 227.400] I see this. +[227.400 --> 228.400] I see this. +[228.400 --> 229.400] I see this. +[229.400 --> 230.400] I see this. +[230.400 --> 231.400] I see this. +[231.400 --> 232.400] I see this. +[232.400 --> 233.400] I see this. +[233.400 --> 234.400] I see this. +[234.400 --> 235.400] I see this. +[235.400 --> 238.400] What is your highest level of education? +[238.400 --> 243.400] I recently graduated from Full Sail University +[243.400 --> 249.400] and with a bachelor's degree in the Recording Arts program. +[249.400 --> 250.400] Okay. +[250.400 --> 251.400] Okay. +[251.400 --> 253.400] Do you have any previous experience in +[253.400 --> 255.400] just your field? +[255.400 --> 256.400] Yes. +[256.400 --> 262.400] Every Saturday I go to church and I record the ceremony +[262.400 --> 265.400] and all the shows that go on there. +[265.400 --> 266.400] Does that count? +[266.400 --> 267.400] Yes. +[267.400 --> 268.400] Okay. +[268.400 --> 271.400] So why do you think you deserve this job? +[271.400 --> 274.400] Well, because you know I am a people person +[274.400 --> 279.400] and I am good on hands-on with pro tools and logic pro X. +[279.400 --> 282.400] Also, including audacity. +[282.400 --> 283.400] Yes. +[283.400 --> 284.400] Does that count? +[284.400 --> 285.400] Does that qualify, sir? +[285.400 --> 286.400] Yes, it does. +[286.400 --> 287.400] Thank you. +[287.400 --> 289.400] That's all the questions we have for you today. +[289.400 --> 290.400] Thank you for coming in. +[290.400 --> 291.400] Oh my God. +[291.400 --> 292.400] Thank you. +[292.400 --> 293.400] Thank you. +[293.400 --> 295.400] What is your highest level of education? +[295.400 --> 297.400] I graduated from Full Sail. +[297.400 --> 298.400] That's it. +[298.400 --> 299.400] What degree? +[299.400 --> 301.400] Show pro. +[301.400 --> 302.400] Okay. +[302.400 --> 305.400] Do you have any previous experience in the field? +[305.400 --> 307.400] No, I'm trying to get experience. +[307.400 --> 308.400] Okay. +[308.400 --> 311.400] And what do you think you deserve this job? +[311.400 --> 313.400] Because I'm qualified. +[313.400 --> 314.400] Okay. +[314.400 --> 317.400] I guess that's all for today. +[317.400 --> 319.400] We'll give you a call. +[319.400 --> 320.400] Thank you. +[320.400 --> 322.400] You can go now. +[322.400 --> 324.400] Excuse me, sir. +[324.400 --> 326.400] Did I get the job? +[326.400 --> 329.400] Can you please leave? +[329.400 --> 330.400] Oh, I'm sorry. +[330.400 --> 333.400] I just had to pick up my stuff that I dropped earlier. +[333.400 --> 334.400] I'm sorry, sir. +[342.400 --> 344.400] Yes, hello. +[344.400 --> 346.400] My name. +[346.400 --> 350.400] My name is Harry McCringle. +[350.400 --> 354.400] And these are my friends. +[354.400 --> 357.400] And we're doing a project. +[357.400 --> 361.400] Yes, we're doing about nonverbal communication. +[361.400 --> 368.400] And yes, welcome to our presentation. +[368.400 --> 370.400] You present like that? +[370.400 --> 373.400] Yes, if you would like me to. +[373.400 --> 375.400] Excuse me. +[375.400 --> 378.400] I'm sorry. +[378.400 --> 381.400] I forgot what I was going to say. +[381.400 --> 386.400] I think I have to talk about these artifacts that I have around my neck. +[386.400 --> 389.400] And my school ID. +[389.400 --> 390.400] I'm sorry. +[390.400 --> 393.400] My name is not Harry McCringle. +[393.400 --> 396.400] It's Alexander Rodriguez. +[396.400 --> 398.400] I forgot. +[398.400 --> 399.400] I'm sorry. +[399.400 --> 400.400] Goodbye. +[400.400 --> 402.400] I'm going now. +[402.400 --> 403.400] Thank you. +[403.400 --> 405.400] I appreciate that. +[405.400 --> 406.400] You can leave now, sir. +[406.400 --> 408.400] We, sir. +[408.400 --> 411.400] You have somewhere things in here, sir. +[411.400 --> 413.400] Oh, my God. +[413.400 --> 415.400] What is that sound? +[415.400 --> 417.400] What the fuck is that? +[417.400 --> 419.400] What the fuck? +[419.400 --> 421.400] Shut up. +[422.400 --> 426.400] God, if you're viewing this, then you are on Vine. +[426.400 --> 429.400] I think we're Twitter or Facebook. +[451.400 --> 454.400] I'm going to go to the bathroom. +[454.400 --> 457.400] I'm going to go to the bathroom. +[457.400 --> 460.400] I'm going to go to the bathroom. +[460.400 --> 463.400] I'm going to go to the bathroom. +[463.400 --> 466.400] I'm going to go to the bathroom. +[466.400 --> 469.400] I'm going to go to the bathroom. +[469.400 --> 472.400] I'm going to go to the bathroom. +[472.400 --> 475.400] I'm going to go to the bathroom. +[475.400 --> 478.400] I'm going to go to the bathroom. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_M8LA10Tg1Os.txt b/transcript/ceremony_M8LA10Tg1Os.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7ae8cb49ed81ef129a256cdb9cb01da039c7fa54 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_M8LA10Tg1Os.txt @@ -0,0 +1,47 @@ +[0.000 --> 2.000] I'm not a fan of you. +[2.000 --> 4.000] I'm not a fan of you. +[4.000 --> 6.000] I'm not a fan of you. +[6.000 --> 8.000] I'm not a fan of you. +[8.000 --> 10.000] Funny, I actually was just text my student with a friend +[10.000 --> 12.000] because I'm missing class right now. +[12.000 --> 13.000] You are. +[13.000 --> 14.000] And I'm a film class. +[14.000 --> 16.000] And it's so funny because they're watching American Beauty +[16.000 --> 18.000] today and analyzing it. +[18.000 --> 20.000] American Beauty. +[20.000 --> 21.000] What's funny about that? +[21.000 --> 22.000] You were in that. +[22.000 --> 23.000] No, wasn't. +[23.000 --> 24.000] American Beauty? +[24.000 --> 25.000] Nope. +[25.000 --> 27.000] What's the one with the Rose petals? +[27.000 --> 28.000] I'm not even that. +[28.000 --> 29.000] That's not you? +[29.000 --> 29.980] No. +[29.980 --> 30.980] Really? +[30.980 --> 31.980] No. +[31.980 --> 32.980] Really? +[32.980 --> 33.980] I swear to God. +[33.980 --> 34.980] Am I just very confused? +[34.980 --> 35.980] I think you are. +[35.980 --> 36.980] I think I am. +[59.980 --> 65.980] I'm a film class. +[65.980 --> 66.980] And it's so funny because they're watching American.'s +[66.980 --> 69.980] beauty today and analyzing it. +[69.980 --> 74.980] American Beauty. +[74.980 --> 75.980] What's funny about that? +[75.980 --> 82.980] You were in that. +[82.980 --> 83.980] No. +[83.980 --> 86.980] What? +[86.980 --> 88.980] American Beauty? +[88.980 --> 98.980] What's the one with the Rose petals? +[98.980 --> 106.980] I'm not even that. +[106.980 --> 116.980] That's not you? +[116.980 --> 117.980] No. +[117.980 --> 126.980] Really? +[126.980 --> 127.980] No. +[127.980 --> 134.980] Really? +[134.980 --> 145.980] I swear to God. +[145.980 --> 152.980] I'm not just very confused. +[152.980 --> 153.980] I think you are. +[175.980 --> 182.980] I swear to God. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_MaufiFwCtIs.txt b/transcript/ceremony_MaufiFwCtIs.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c6117f2812d184a240bcbe145a81c523abe917ba --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_MaufiFwCtIs.txt @@ -0,0 +1,107 @@ +[0.000 --> 7.920] So Prince Harry arriving, I think we got our first glimpse of Harry for years. +[7.920 --> 16.680] He was the old Harry coming in, smiling, laughing, high, high walking tall looking magnificent. +[16.680 --> 20.320] The fact that he was on his own, I think was an absolute benefit. +[20.320 --> 26.040] His issue was, he thought that he could look at people and speak with them and they'd +[26.040 --> 28.440] speak back to him, not didn't work. +[28.440 --> 32.840] He would have been better just looking, smiling, looking, smiling, but he actually focused +[32.840 --> 35.800] in on people going to make wanting a conversation. +[35.800 --> 38.720] They didn't want to know him, so that must have been very difficult for him. +[38.720 --> 44.120] But Harry was lucky to be in the third row as far as I'm concerned, but there's no question +[44.120 --> 46.800] in my mind that William would never have looked at Harry. +[46.800 --> 48.280] Not once, not once. +[48.280 --> 50.280] He did not exist. +[50.280 --> 56.240] The interesting thing was, flash of Harry, smiling, standing tall, you know, the old Harry +[56.240 --> 58.240] was back for a moment. +[58.240 --> 62.680] But out of everybody in the carriages, you can't quite see who's there, I always, Charles +[62.680 --> 65.160] always, Camilla, I can sort of see them. +[65.160 --> 68.400] And then you cross to Kate and there she is. +[68.400 --> 70.200] You can see her face. +[70.200 --> 73.120] She is like a glistening diamond. +[73.120 --> 80.240] What she does is years of practice and she has it down to perfection like no other performer +[80.240 --> 81.240] I've ever seen. +[81.600 --> 86.960] I bow myself like most people going, where are Kate and Will's? +[86.960 --> 88.320] Where are Kate and Will's? +[88.320 --> 89.680] Where are Kate and Will's? +[89.680 --> 94.640] And then they appeared behind Charles. +[94.640 --> 97.280] In retrospect, I was thinking that's on, that's on. +[97.280 --> 99.520] Well, I think it was on. +[99.520 --> 103.720] And in fact, I think it was a clear way of avoiding Harry. +[103.720 --> 107.480] It was a way of not having to engage with Harry. +[107.480 --> 110.400] They didn't want any contact with Harry whatsoever. +[110.400 --> 114.920] So they were behind that area, which is not where they would normally be. +[114.920 --> 117.320] It didn't make any sense at all. +[117.320 --> 122.480] So they're quite tense and I think it was a very domestic conversation like he's gone, +[122.480 --> 124.840] oh, there's dirt on your dress or something. +[124.840 --> 126.960] She's going, we should have got the people to do that. +[126.960 --> 129.000] And he's going, well, it's too late now. +[129.000 --> 130.200] There's nothing we can do about it. +[130.200 --> 132.680] She's going, yes, well, that's what we all see. +[132.680 --> 137.080] So they had that look, look down, look to the front. +[137.080 --> 138.080] Let's go. +[138.080 --> 140.000] Nothing we can do about it now. +[140.000 --> 145.320] So yeah, I think there was a bit of a pre-show band-up. +[145.320 --> 149.640] Those children are clearly, it's not about the children, +[149.640 --> 151.400] it's about the parents. +[151.400 --> 155.040] Whatever they feed those children, they feed them the right thing. +[155.040 --> 159.440] And Prince Louis, Prince Louis and Charlotte, they're there. +[159.440 --> 161.560] And they're just behaving so beautifully. +[161.560 --> 166.520] And you can see William, when in doubt, read the program. +[166.520 --> 169.440] He goes down, reads the program. +[169.440 --> 172.280] And you see Charlotte look up to him and then read the program. +[172.280 --> 174.960] Goes down, read massively, reading the program, +[174.960 --> 177.440] talking to Louis and he's yawning, yawning, yawning. +[177.440 --> 179.280] And next thing, he's gone. +[179.280 --> 181.400] He actually, he'd been removed. +[181.400 --> 184.040] And as for George carrying the train, +[184.040 --> 185.840] George has got the X factor. +[185.840 --> 188.000] He's got X factor. +[188.000 --> 192.960] He's got a like-k reality, but natural. +[192.960 --> 195.480] The other boys were, for four or five years, +[195.480 --> 198.120] older than him who were carrying the train. +[198.120 --> 200.880] And he was shone out. +[200.880 --> 202.720] Well, I think rule number one on television +[202.720 --> 204.720] is never touch your face or hair. +[204.720 --> 207.880] And I would think with the crown, +[207.880 --> 209.560] the rule is don't touch it. +[209.560 --> 211.160] You know, you can't rabbit. +[211.160 --> 212.280] And Charles didn't. +[212.280 --> 213.960] So it's like, I'm not going to touch it. +[213.960 --> 215.760] The archbishop goes, is it alright? +[215.760 --> 218.480] And he goes, yeah, she seems to be fun. +[218.480 --> 220.120] Because they're very heavy. +[220.120 --> 222.320] But Camilla goes, no, no, he's not right. +[222.320 --> 225.680] She did several moves, which I thought was a bit clumsy. +[225.680 --> 227.800] Charles, for me, is never neutral. +[227.800 --> 229.640] Charles is the ordinary bloke. +[229.640 --> 233.960] And he is one step away from saying, put that on properly. +[233.960 --> 234.800] Do it. +[234.800 --> 236.240] He snaps at people all the time. +[236.240 --> 238.720] And he's, and he's used to being in the background, +[238.720 --> 241.840] making things work, almost being like a backstage worker. +[241.840 --> 244.600] And he can't, he can't seem to get out of that. +[244.600 --> 247.600] He never sort of fits into the role of regality. +[247.600 --> 249.440] He always looks like a normal person. +[249.440 --> 253.640] Doesn't have regality on his face, whatever that is. +[253.640 --> 257.760] As does, as does a Camilla. +[257.760 --> 263.080] Camilla always just looks like, I don't know, my next door. +[263.080 --> 266.880] I will him, Prince of Wales, pledge my loyalty to you. +[266.880 --> 269.520] And faith and truth, I will bear unto you +[269.520 --> 272.040] as your leech man of life and limb. +[272.040 --> 273.160] So help me, God. +[273.160 --> 274.960] And then, of course, there was that charming moment +[274.960 --> 277.120] where he came over and pledged allegiance +[277.120 --> 279.600] and chuss at thank you, William. +[279.600 --> 282.200] You know, that was lovely. +[282.200 --> 285.320] I thought that the balcony was really interesting +[285.320 --> 288.000] because we got up there and there were four boys +[288.000 --> 290.600] who carried the train together with chuss and Camilla. +[290.600 --> 293.320] And I thought, oh, this must be the first act. +[293.320 --> 295.320] And then what's going to happen is they're going to go off +[295.320 --> 297.440] and the family are going to come on. +[297.440 --> 299.480] And they didn't, they stayed there. +[299.480 --> 303.080] It was all because there were people missing. +[303.080 --> 304.880] It didn't want to seem like people missing. +[304.880 --> 309.440] They mixed up the recipe for what normally happens. +[309.440 --> 313.360] Everything seemed to go as planned. +[313.360 --> 315.800] Everything was perfection. +[315.800 --> 318.840] Everything was spectacular. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_Mfr-e2KXDbU.txt b/transcript/ceremony_Mfr-e2KXDbU.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4059c5ef68c102e6395c9803d5d90e163a14e599 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_Mfr-e2KXDbU.txt @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +[0.000 --> 2.000] Good evening. +[4.200 --> 8.660] My name is John Bucstein and I'm so very proud to be here with you today. +[9.460 --> 11.460] As you will soon learn with me, +[12.120 --> 14.720] what you see might not necessarily be what you get. +[15.720 --> 17.720] I am nonverbal autistic. +[18.280 --> 20.920] Although I cannot talk, I have a lot to say. +[22.080 --> 26.960] All of my life I face challenges that most teenagers my age can imagine. +[27.760 --> 34.480] When I was three years old, the mine institute of UC Davis diagnosed me as severely mentally retarded. +[35.760 --> 37.760] Luckily my mom didn't believe it for one minute. +[39.080 --> 43.560] Today one of my biggest obstacles is the fact that society wants to put me in a box. +[43.560 --> 48.240] I can assure you I don't fit into any box, but they still try. +[49.480 --> 52.640] When I got to Crescent Valley Academy, I was very angry at the world. +[52.640 --> 55.200] I felt like there was no place for me. +[55.920 --> 61.520] I wanted to be in a traditional school like any kid in my age, so Crescent Valley was not where I desired to be. +[62.680 --> 65.480] But much my surprise, my new school became my new home. +[66.680 --> 70.160] Instead of shoving me into a box, it built one that fit me. +[71.160 --> 76.160] I think this is how schools should be, fitting themselves to students instead of the other way around. +[77.480 --> 79.480] After all, we are all different. +[80.360 --> 85.560] And though my challenges might be more obvious than yours, we all have special needs in one way or another. +[86.920 --> 91.320] I may not be able to speak, but I still think and feel just like the rest of you. +[91.960 --> 94.360] I love words writing, music, and mathematics. +[95.200 --> 98.920] I can be very opinionated and some might say I have a sense of humor too. +[100.120 --> 103.520] So yes, being different doesn't mean being incapable. +[104.440 --> 108.880] It just means that society needs to find the best way to allow skills like mine to flourish. +[109.760 --> 116.760] Thankfully, here I found a place where my true personality is not just recognized but celebrated as well. +[118.240 --> 123.960] I'd like to thank the people who took the time to see and get to know the real me, not just what they saw in front of them. +[125.120 --> 128.480] First is my kindergarten teacher, Teresa Higden-Upoff. +[137.320 --> 138.800] Who gave me my voice. +[139.760 --> 145.800] She introduced me to facilitated communication, which is how I express myself using my talking iPad. +[146.840 --> 151.080] Ms Higden-Upoff changed my life and my mom's life too. +[151.840 --> 155.440] For the first time ever, I was able to tell my mom how much I loved her. +[155.440 --> 179.400] I would also like to thank my support staff, my teachers, Ms Cortez, Mr Fernandez, Ms Saint Marie, my speech therapist Hilary, my tutor Kate, and my tutor, Mr Nelson, my best friend for life. +[181.320 --> 182.840] He wrote that, not me. +[186.440 --> 192.440] And last but not least, a special thanks to my amazing mom, who I believed in me and never gave up. +[193.440 --> 195.440] Whatever success I have achieved, I owe to her. +[204.440 --> 214.440] This is my story, one which is only beginning as I plan to begin online college courses while I spread awareness that people like me have lots to contribute if we're just given the chance. +[215.440 --> 216.440] Thank you. +[217.440 --> 218.440] Thank you. +[218.440 --> 220.440] Thank you. +[220.440 --> 245.360] Thank you for your incredible speech and for addressing our class tonight. +[245.360 --> 249.360] In honor of your speech, the class of 2019 and I would like to present you with this +[249.360 --> 251.360] certificate of appreciation. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_NMurRcc3AEQ.txt b/transcript/ceremony_NMurRcc3AEQ.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ce78638a24ead0cde517164205ec01f3c90184b2 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_NMurRcc3AEQ.txt @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +[0.000 --> 24.620] You got my heart in a spin You reel me out and then you reel me in +[24.620 --> 31.620] What the hell am I supposed to do when I'm falling so in love with you? +[31.620 --> 38.620] If you were to agree I'd give over every part of me +[38.620 --> 46.620] As if it is I think that you should know that I'm never gonna let you go +[46.620 --> 53.620] No baby, sweet baby +[53.620 --> 60.620] Oh baby, oh baby, oh baby +[60.620 --> 67.620] Can't you see how hard I'm trying to put this long in that I feel inside? +[67.620 --> 75.620] Problem is I can't try enough Nobody told me it would be so tough +[75.620 --> 82.620] I'm patient please I'll wait each day Just three words I want to hear you say +[82.620 --> 89.620] Seems to me you drive off my pain Why else would you make me wait and vain? +[89.620 --> 93.620] And baby, baby diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_OBPNm4jY1PU.txt b/transcript/ceremony_OBPNm4jY1PU.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d37cac01901e5610903d0b37c7b8e602e99285d0 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_OBPNm4jY1PU.txt @@ -0,0 +1,72 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.160] After two years of feeling silenced by palace authorities, Meghan Markle finally came +[5.160 --> 9.920] forward to tell her side of the story, on the special Oprah with Meghan and Harry on Sunday +[9.920 --> 10.920] night. +[10.920 --> 14.580] Impeccably clad in a black and white rap dress, the Duchess of Sussex talked with her +[14.580 --> 18.680] friend Oprah Winfrey about her life in and out of the palace. +[18.680 --> 23.420] As promised, no subject was off limits, including discussion about rumors that she had made Kate +[23.420 --> 26.120] Middleton cry over an incident before her wedding. +[26.160 --> 30.080] She discussed her feelings over learning that son Archie would not be named a prince and +[30.080 --> 34.800] would not receive security, and perhaps most shockingly revealed that at her lowest point +[34.800 --> 37.240] she felt she didn't want to be alive anymore. +[37.240 --> 41.040] Meghan also denied being the leading player in the couple's decision to relinquish their +[41.040 --> 45.440] senior royal status and pursue their own life and goals in the relative privacy of their +[45.440 --> 47.040] new California home. +[47.040 --> 51.040] Some royal watchers have long claimed that the Duchess is claiming victimhood to cover +[51.040 --> 52.960] up her own ambitions in agenda. +[53.000 --> 57.200] The royal reports that several of them weighed in on the Oprah interview even before it aired, +[57.200 --> 61.560] claiming she was putting on a good show in front of a friend asking softball questions. +[61.560 --> 65.800] The quotes were gathered by a pair of social experimenters curious to see whether the royal +[65.800 --> 68.720] experts would comment on something they hadn't seen. +[68.720 --> 71.400] So is Meghan's apparent vulnerability all-enact? +[71.400 --> 73.280] One expert offers some thoughts. +[73.280 --> 77.440] The list spoke to Mark Bowden, a human behavior and body language expert who was also a +[77.440 --> 79.240] panelist on the behavior panel. +[79.240 --> 83.920] He watched Meghan's gestures and facial expressions and what he found might come as a surprise +[83.920 --> 85.480] to the palace loyalists. +[85.480 --> 89.360] Bowden notes that the Duchess seemed most open and expressive when she was talking about +[89.360 --> 93.480] the wedding vows she and Harry exchanged three days before the big royal ceremony. +[93.480 --> 94.480] He says, +[94.480 --> 97.960] When remembering happy events, she is big and bold with her gestures. +[97.960 --> 102.440] But her body language when talking about less pleasant matters was even more telling. +[102.440 --> 106.360] Suppressing the lips or putting a hand to one's mouth can indicate you're trying not to +[106.360 --> 107.360] say too much. +[107.360 --> 112.040] Meghan did both when talking about her naivete about marrying royalty and again when she +[112.040 --> 115.720] talked about unnamed palace individuals who hadn't been supportive of her. +[115.720 --> 119.880] As Meghan recalled feeling unprotected from the media, she lowered her head and covered +[119.880 --> 120.880] her eyes. +[120.880 --> 124.960] Bowden says this indicates she was feeling either shame she feels about not being protected +[124.960 --> 129.040] or shame about how she now feels towards the institution for not protecting her. +[129.040 --> 134.280] She showed indications of stress, such as swallowing and rapid breathing, when discussing such uncomfortable +[134.280 --> 138.280] topics as her suicidal thoughts and racism within the firm. +[138.280 --> 140.760] What about the account of her conflict with Kate? +[140.760 --> 144.720] Meghan told Oprah that in fact it was Kate who made her cry that day. +[144.720 --> 148.680] Bowden says that Meghan's vocal tones and increased blinking indicate the story is +[148.680 --> 149.680] true. +[149.680 --> 153.240] Throughout the two hour long special, the Duchess of Sussex displayed real emotions between +[153.240 --> 155.760] the movement of her eyes, mouth and forehead. +[155.760 --> 159.280] When she talked about the South Africa tour in which she infamously told a reporter that +[159.280 --> 163.280] she was not okay, her facial expressions gave away her duress. +[163.280 --> 167.640] Bowden notes that her blink rate was up on talking about tour of South Africa and the +[167.640 --> 169.280] pain she was feeling. +[169.280 --> 173.320] As things worsened within the family, Markle revealed, she discovered that her son would +[173.320 --> 176.080] not receive the protection that she would have liked. +[176.080 --> 179.920] During this segment of their conversation, Markle's forehead told the story of how painful +[179.920 --> 181.400] that exchange was for her. +[181.400 --> 185.360] Bowden even notes that her forehead movements showed the grief around how she was told +[185.360 --> 187.880] her son was not going to be protected. +[187.880 --> 191.400] Once the discussion around her mental health struggles began, it was Markle's breathing +[191.400 --> 192.760] that spoke volumes. +[192.760 --> 193.760] Bowden adds, +[193.760 --> 198.840] her breathing rate was high as she recovered from telling the story of thinking about suicide. +[198.840 --> 202.800] Viewers also watched as her eyes welled with tears and she explained how trapped and +[202.800 --> 205.800] lonely she felt within her confines in the institution. +[205.800 --> 209.840] Luckily, Markle's husband showed his support throughout the interview, with Bowden even +[209.840 --> 211.280] noting their close touch. +[211.280 --> 214.480] Meghan's thumb rubs Harry's hand in soothing gestures. +[214.480 --> 217.480] The Duchess also had another ally in her interviewer. +[217.480 --> 218.480] Bowden says, +[218.480 --> 222.640] by the end of the interview, Oprah and Meghan are mirroring each other almost exactly, hand +[222.640 --> 226.960] to face, finger, curl below lip, very sympathetic to each other. +[226.960 --> 229.120] Check out one of our newest videos right here! +[229.120 --> 233.560] Plus, even more List videos about your favorite celebrities and lifestyle tips are coming soon. +[233.560 --> 236.920] Subscribe to our YouTube channel and hit the bell so you don't miss a single one. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_PPJGgsPjD1M.txt b/transcript/ceremony_PPJGgsPjD1M.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fd3f92aaac50034cc749dd6e59c5ff47d4125d34 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_PPJGgsPjD1M.txt @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +[0.000 --> 10.000] Princess Charlotte's heartwarming gestures at her coronation ceremony, as the sun broke through the clouds on the day of Princess Charlotte's coronation, the world held its breath. +[10.000 --> 15.000] The air buzzed with excitement, a mix of royal tradition and modern charm. +[15.000 --> 24.000] Yet, amidst the grandeur of the ceremony, it was the small, heartwarming gestures of the young princess that captured the hearts of millions. +[24.000 --> 42.000] From her radiant smile to her thoughtful interactions, Charlotte's actions painted a poignant picture of youth, grace, and sincerity, leaving an indelible mark on this historic occasion, a new era of royalty, the coronation ceremony, a spectacle steeped in history, was not just a passage of power. +[42.000 --> 45.000] It signified the dawn of a new era. +[45.000 --> 54.000] With the United Kingdom and the Commonwealth watching closely, Princess Charlotte's ascendance to a more prominent royal role symbolized hope and continuity. +[54.000 --> 60.000] Yet, what truly stood out were her genuine moments that transcended the formality of the event. +[60.000 --> 69.000] As she arrived at Westminster Abbey, Charlotte, dressed in a stunning gown designed by a renowned British designer, instantly became the center of attention. +[69.000 --> 74.000] But it wasn't just her attire that drew eyes, it was her demeanor. +[74.000 --> 82.000] Unlike typical royal protocol, which often emphasizes distance and decorum, Charlotte exuded warmth and approachability. +[82.000 --> 88.000] Each wave to the crowd was not merely a gesture but an invitation to share in her joy. +[88.000 --> 95.000] The power of a smile, one of the most memorable moments of the day occurred as Charlotte made her way down the aisle. +[95.000 --> 101.000] The little princess paused to interact with some of the younger attendees seated along the path. +[101.000 --> 110.000] Her radiant smile illuminated the solemn atmosphere as she bent down to exchange a few words with a shy little girl clutching a bouquet of flowers. +[110.000 --> 122.000] In that fleeting moment, Charlotte embodied the simplicity of childhood, reminding everyone that even in the most opulent settings, kindness can shine through, this connection with her peers was further. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_SioscISKoio.txt b/transcript/ceremony_SioscISKoio.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7e0c2b296961e7bbd2690f1df6b65f485088bb00 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_SioscISKoio.txt @@ -0,0 +1,97 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.920] Thank you so much for joining me if you haven't seen my previous one or my +[5.920 --> 11.640] previous video. In the last video we created an incense blend together that we're +[11.640 --> 21.840] going to be using today. I have used Mastix which is a resin from Pistazia +[21.840 --> 25.040] Lente Escuse. I'm not sure how it's pronounced in Latin because I'm not a +[25.040 --> 33.480] Latin speaker. I have also used one of my favorite resins that I try to use very +[33.480 --> 41.640] sparingly. White Kapal. I used only a little bit but I love the scent of it. +[41.640 --> 58.640] And lastly I have used a resin that is called Black Frankencense and it's +[58.640 --> 70.200] a Boursera Durefera. Frankencense I used when I want to make an incense more +[70.200 --> 75.260] protective in nature as well as cleansing. It has a very beautiful +[75.260 --> 83.200] enveloping energy that not only pushes out what is not needed or like the +[83.200 --> 88.600] negative energy and also creates a bubble around that will not let anything +[88.600 --> 95.680] back into our space. White Kapal I used for blessing and for sanctifying +[95.680 --> 101.200] a space and Mastix for me is a very meditative blend so it helps me +[101.200 --> 107.680] concentrate, gain focus. So I think this incense will be very not only cleansing +[107.680 --> 117.600] but also very altering to the mind in a way to help us focus and relax and maybe +[117.600 --> 125.360] meditate a little bit and again every week help us leave the last week behind us +[125.360 --> 133.240] and allow us to bring something new into our lives. I have my beautiful +[133.240 --> 140.280] sensor that I have shown you in my last cleansing video and we are going to be +[140.280 --> 155.320] lighting the incense from the start. I have a little bit of coal and I have my trusty +[155.320 --> 162.320] pancers that we are going to use to light the coal with. +[174.760 --> 184.840] In the meanwhile try to relax your mind be present in this moment. Your mind may +[184.840 --> 193.420] want to wander to different places different times but let it just be here be +[193.420 --> 201.020] present in this ceremony with me be present in your own body in your own +[201.020 --> 219.180] share and leave everything that you don't need for this moment behind you be here be +[219.180 --> 230.540] grounded be present as we light this incense to fill our space to fill our minds. +[230.540 --> 236.220] The nose is very close to the brain and whatever touches your nose also gets +[236.220 --> 243.900] partly absorbed in your bloodstream so the incense by a smelling it will not only fill out +[243.900 --> 250.900] this room but it will also become a part of you and your body through your nose. +[260.540 --> 269.420] Breathe deeply and leave everything that is not present in this moment that is not happening +[269.420 --> 278.340] right now in the past or in the future or wherever you have found it just enjoy this present +[278.340 --> 287.420] moment because the present moment is all there is there is nothing like a past there is +[287.420 --> 294.100] no future not in any nihilistic sense it just it hasn't happened it doesn't exist it's +[294.100 --> 304.420] only a concept a thought a theory the only thing that exists is what's here right now with +[304.420 --> 310.860] us and you in this moment are at your most powerful because only in this moment can +[310.860 --> 319.620] you make changes in your life you can decide what to do and actually do it because the only +[319.620 --> 327.740] time you can do something is right now not tomorrow not yesterday only now do you have the power to do +[327.740 --> 347.380] but for this particular moment I want you to do nothing to think about nothing to just be present +[347.380 --> 357.220] be grounded take many deep and satiating breaths +[363.460 --> 372.340] feel the incense that you also may have lit if you have lit an incense stick or some essential oil in +[372.340 --> 384.260] your diffuser or just feel the air in your lungs fill you and as you exhale release everything from +[384.260 --> 396.980] the days past release the worries of the future that does not exist and take your power in this +[397.860 --> 406.500] specific moment in the present take the power to unburden yourself and take the power to leave +[406.500 --> 414.580] everything behind and then take the power to make changes in your life right now in the present +[414.580 --> 425.140] moment and as this incense fills your space feel your lungs and your being in your aura being filled +[426.020 --> 438.500] beautiful energy with the energy from the universe you can imagine it as bright white light coming +[439.540 --> 444.660] from the universe onto the top of your head and then fill in your whole being with light +[446.580 --> 451.300] and leaving room for nothing else just light gratitude +[452.260 --> 456.100] and lightness and gratitude +[469.940 --> 472.420] and I'm blowing that energy to you through the incense +[481.300 --> 496.100] and I'm going to leave it burning and hope you will see it on the camera +[496.180 --> 517.620] and in the meanwhile I have prepared my trustee beautiful pendulum that is made of +[517.620 --> 526.980] flappers lazuli I don't use pendulums to for divination I use them to move energy by swirling them +[526.980 --> 536.580] like this and now that we have cleansed the space around us you also need to move any +[536.580 --> 542.580] stale energies that linger in the corners of your room or in the corners of your mind and +[543.540 --> 548.340] make them moving because moving energy is better energy than the stale and stack and you can +[548.340 --> 553.940] imagine it with with water if you have a puddle of water that doesn't move the water rots +[554.580 --> 562.100] but if you have a stream of water the water is very clear and beautiful drinkable and that's what +[562.100 --> 568.900] we want to do with our energy we want to have it moving active streaming ever changing +[569.780 --> 577.860] ever alive and if there is any energy that is stale and stagnant we need to make it move and we need to +[579.140 --> 588.980] blow it around a little bit just like our breath again what is moving is alive +[592.980 --> 598.500] so imagine that the energy that we're cleansing now we're not only getting rid of anything that +[598.500 --> 606.500] doesn't serve anymore but we are putting the things in motion thoughts in motion and emotions in motion +[607.380 --> 616.500] and just making a stream instead of a stale lake if you know what I mean +[619.300 --> 626.100] imagine that every exhale you do moves the energy inside you and moves the energy in your space +[626.180 --> 633.140] you can even use the exhale to actually cleanse your room maybe you go around your room and then +[635.300 --> 643.860] you breathe deeply out to move all the energy that has been stuck somewhere it maybe isn't +[644.420 --> 652.100] even negative energy as in bad or wrong it's just a little bit of water that got stuck somewhere +[652.180 --> 654.740] needs to move to be alive again +[655.300 --> 662.740] I'm adding a little bit more in sense +[662.740 --> 684.740] so I want you to breathe deeply and relax and imagine that you +[685.700 --> 690.980] and your energy and the energy of your house is a stream that keeps moving +[692.260 --> 700.740] rushes over rocks and it's clear as water and there is life in it there is salmon and fish and +[700.740 --> 708.020] little critters and that energy is life giving the movement is life giving +[708.580 --> 715.860] and maybe if you feel that you can't move or shouldn't move or you too lazy to move maybe +[718.420 --> 729.380] it's just stagnation that needs to move needs to be swept needs to be set in motion +[730.180 --> 737.780] maybe you have too much movement and your thoughts are racing this way or that way +[739.780 --> 748.820] and you need to get a little bit of control a little bit of order in your thoughts so +[750.100 --> 753.780] instead of leaving them be somewhere and stagnate again +[753.780 --> 765.380] and acknowledge them let them go and let them float down the stream of the past towards the +[765.380 --> 771.860] future because even though I said in earlier that there is no such thing as past and future there +[771.860 --> 780.900] is still a flow of time and one part of time is kindness and one part of time is in front of us +[781.540 --> 787.940] in the realm of possibility the other part is in the realm of immutableness of the realm of +[788.660 --> 795.380] unchangeableness of the realm that you cannot do anything about anymore so there is no point +[795.380 --> 801.060] in worrying if there are consequences in your current life the only thing you can do +[802.420 --> 808.980] is make changes so that in the next person moment you solve these consequences +[811.220 --> 818.260] but is about achieving a balance it is about moving but not too fast not getting stuck in loops +[818.260 --> 826.180] that turn too fast it's about always moving forward in some way I hope I'm not getting too +[826.180 --> 831.620] long winded with it I tend to do that a little bit but I hope you understand what I mean I +[832.820 --> 839.220] just wanted to say that through a cleansing today we're not only getting rid of stuff as we did last +[839.460 --> 846.260] last time but we are we're setting things in motion and through setting things in motion +[847.140 --> 852.740] we are cleansing and we are moving along in our lives and we are making changes +[853.860 --> 861.620] I will leave you with these thoughts I hope they make sense leave me a comment below if they +[861.620 --> 866.740] don't I'll try to explain better or we can talk about it in the next video +[875.140 --> 883.700] until then release what doesn't serve you move what has been stagnating +[884.260 --> 894.740] and look forward to what you can do in the present moment so that your future is wonderful +[903.220 --> 910.020] have a good evening +[913.700 --> 915.340] so diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_T-X4IbryFlU.txt b/transcript/ceremony_T-X4IbryFlU.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4bc13a62f06d54be60fc5ce84814fb6b851aedc2 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_T-X4IbryFlU.txt @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +[0.000 --> 9.320] We're going to symbolise the creation and strength of this family unit by performing a +[9.320 --> 12.200] San Ceremony. +[12.200 --> 26.800] Not only does this create beautiful sand art as a reminder of this special day, but +[26.800 --> 33.080] it's significance is that just as we cannot separate the grains of sand again, neither can +[33.080 --> 36.720] this family be separated. +[36.720 --> 52.280] The each have a different colour of sand, representing them as individuals and they +[52.280 --> 54.880] are poured into the jar one after another. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_T7MLPCSwoJQ.txt b/transcript/ceremony_T7MLPCSwoJQ.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..378dda2ae0e30cc31de26925083201d329859f06 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_T7MLPCSwoJQ.txt @@ -0,0 +1,276 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.520] In this video we're going to talk about al-Savatinny or the heathen baptism coming up +[6.720 --> 8.720] With this water and wash away +[10.400 --> 12.400] All the +[15.600 --> 19.520] Welcome to the Northwoods, Kendrick. I'm your gody boat var and on this channel +[19.520 --> 25.820] We discuss all things austatru Kendrick related so hit that subscribe button if you want to see how we do it in the Northwoods +[26.060 --> 28.060] We get a lot of questions about the +[28.700 --> 30.860] naming rituals or the +[30.860 --> 34.620] Baptismal rituals because people have seen them or heard about them +[34.620 --> 39.420] But they think that it's a Christian idea and they don't want to include it in their own Kendrick +[40.140 --> 44.460] Practices, but they know that there's something about it. So that's what we're doing the video and I hope that +[45.340 --> 48.460] I hope that you get something out of it or at least get a really good +[48.940 --> 52.540] Source of references that you can go back to look to and kind of flesh out your own +[52.940 --> 57.420] Traditions as you build them for your Kendrick so in the Viking Age when a child was born +[57.420 --> 60.460] It has said that that was the evening the norns showed up +[60.700 --> 64.060] They would lay the child on the floor and nobody would touch it until +[64.780 --> 68.460] Eventually the father would pick the child up and put it in the folds of his cloak +[69.180 --> 72.860] And then he would look at the child and judge it judge its future +[73.740 --> 76.700] Based on its temperament its look and make predictions about where +[77.580 --> 79.580] Where it would go in the future +[79.740 --> 81.180] If the father wasn't around then +[81.900 --> 84.460] Another close relative would do that once that was done +[84.460 --> 89.900] They would make the decision based on the child's physical appearance and temperament whether or not the child was to be left out +[89.980 --> 93.820] Which is to be set out in the forest for the wolves at a white to take away +[94.780 --> 98.860] That was real similar to the Spartan ritual and once they decided the child was going to live +[98.860 --> 103.100] They performed the ossovacani which is the sprinkling of water +[103.980 --> 105.980] or the heathen baptism +[106.460 --> 110.460] Once that baptism took place it was considered murder to leave the child out +[110.540 --> 115.740] This was a sacred right and considered part of the ossocrete part of the religion of them +[116.460 --> 123.900] Whatever they called it back then and it certainly predated anything Christian baptism related and according to Paul doucheleau +[125.100 --> 131.660] Some form of water right under one shape or another was practiced by Egyptians Greeks Persians hebrus Romans +[132.060 --> 135.980] Hindus etc in the Frankish annals the northmen +[137.020 --> 144.620] When they were baptized were led into the rivers a custom which apparently prevailed among the earlier Christians with adult people +[145.020 --> 146.620] So that +[146.620 --> 150.060] That whole custom of leading people into the water to baptize them +[151.020 --> 157.820] Started with the northmen and then it just kind of permeated Christianity and became the Christian baptismal ceremony +[157.900 --> 167.900] But it started as in common terms water sprinkling a newborn baby or sometimes giving an adult a new name or a modifier to their name +[168.460 --> 175.500] But does say it was once no doubt practiced by the Franks who belonged to the northern tribes and certain forms of Christian baptism to the present day +[175.820 --> 181.100] Maybe based upon this earlier form which was only changed in name by the earlier Christian +[181.740 --> 183.580] missionaries +[183.740 --> 189.660] That the heathen or osso baptism was not recognized by the Christians. We have ample proofs in the sagas +[190.300 --> 191.980] the osso form +[191.980 --> 195.740] As we have seen is called osso hotney and the Christian skurn +[198.460 --> 201.740] So here's an example from the sagas from edgel saga actually +[202.220 --> 205.820] Harold fair hair when he began to get old gave his son the rule of Norway +[205.980 --> 213.260] He made eddrick the king over all of his sons and when he had ruled for 70 winters gave the kingship +[213.660 --> 218.620] Into his hands at that time goonhild eric's wife bore a son and herald +[219.180 --> 221.740] Water sprinkled him and gave him his own name +[222.380 --> 229.580] They're with declaring that he shall be the king after his father if he should live that's an edgel saga chapter 59 +[230.220 --> 235.340] So the child was generally given the name of some renowned kinsman or in some cases +[235.340 --> 241.500] They would pick a renowned person in order to water sprinkle the child and that person would give the child their own name +[242.220 --> 248.300] bearing with it supposedly the locked the reputation and the skill of the person whose name they took +[248.700 --> 254.780] So sigrid the son of ragna lothbrok was also named after his grandfather Sigrid ring and +[255.740 --> 260.060] With that name came a gift it was called naffenfischte or name +[260.540 --> 268.300] Fascinating and it was a gift that came with the name so the birth of Sigrid the son of ragna lothbrok is thus described as the time arrived when +[268.700 --> 270.940] Krakka or Oslog was +[272.460 --> 274.460] Confined in bore son +[274.460 --> 276.940] Whom the servant maids took and showed to her +[277.580 --> 281.100] She bade them carry him to ragna lothbrok and let him see him +[281.900 --> 285.500] The boy was taken into the hall and placed in the fold of ragna's cloak +[286.300 --> 291.100] When he saw the boy ragna was asked what he should be named and he sang this song +[292.140 --> 297.740] Sigrid shall the boy be named he will fight battles and be much like his mother and he called his father's son +[299.180 --> 301.180] He will of Odin's family +[302.220 --> 306.300] The foremost man be called that serpent in his eye which another slew +[307.100 --> 309.100] and it that's of course in reference to +[310.380 --> 313.420] Sigrid's grandfather who slew the dragon +[313.900 --> 315.900] baffnir so it's +[317.500 --> 319.820] life +[319.900 --> 321.900] leading into mythology +[322.380 --> 326.620] He drew a gold ring from his hand and gave it to the boy as a name +[327.020 --> 329.980] Fascinating so that was traditional in those days to gift +[331.100 --> 335.020] weapons shields helmets and armor arm rings +[336.220 --> 338.220] things of value +[338.220 --> 339.180] lands +[339.180 --> 341.020] homes +[341.020 --> 347.020] Slaves and servants those were all things that could be gifted to an infant or to a grown person at a name +[347.100 --> 351.820] Fascinating by the person who gave them the name or the person whose name they bear special +[351.820 --> 356.860] or characteristic names were often given to grown-up persons as named fascinates for one reason or +[356.860 --> 361.820] another in addition to their proper name and almost every important man seemed to have one +[362.060 --> 366.460] So what we do here in the north woods without I don't want to get too deep in the weeds in the book but +[367.500 --> 369.500] when +[369.500 --> 371.660] When a member has been around long enough +[372.220 --> 377.500] There's a point where they swear their allegiance to the gods not to us not to me not to the kindrid +[377.580 --> 381.100] They're welcome to come and go as they please although they tend to want to stay +[381.500 --> 383.420] But they swear their allegiance to the god +[383.420 --> 387.420] So after about a year's time on their oath day +[388.540 --> 393.660] If they haven't already chosen a name then we give them a name and we we fasten the name to them +[393.900 --> 396.300] I'll give them the name and in exchange for that +[397.660 --> 401.420] With that I usually give them the stainless steel arm ring +[402.220 --> 405.500] Now there's more and you can get into the weeds on it or you can buy this book +[405.500 --> 407.980] This is volume two of the Viking Age and it'll give you +[408.940 --> 415.020] It'll not only tell you the bits and pieces that are in relation to name fascinating and the +[415.980 --> 420.860] Water sprinkling but it'll also give references in the saga as where you can go find it and then read more about it +[421.260 --> 423.900] Instead of just the event but the events surrounding it +[424.220 --> 426.220] So if you want to get a little bit more +[426.220 --> 427.740] In-depth on +[427.740 --> 430.060] Those customs of name-passing in water sprinkling +[430.700 --> 432.940] But they're definitely connected and they're not just for children +[433.260 --> 437.340] So we adopted the same customs here in the form that I just mentioned +[437.900 --> 439.900] now it does say +[439.900 --> 441.900] It's kind of interesting that +[442.780 --> 447.980] The sprinkling water over a child was performed a custom so common +[448.700 --> 452.140] That we're not even told how the water was poured or sprinkled over +[452.220 --> 458.220] So what happened it was such a common occurrence that we're not even told how they did it only that it happened +[458.620 --> 459.580] All the time +[459.580 --> 461.260] And it was only mentioned in the cases of +[461.820 --> 467.260] sons of kings and important events in the sagas and the edis because everybody just took for granted it a boy +[467.980 --> 474.060] Or the child is still alive then that child was name-passing in water sprinkled because that was the custom of the day +[475.020 --> 479.100] So just as I mentioned the armories that we use I'll put links in the description +[480.300 --> 481.740] for +[481.740 --> 484.060] My Amazon bookstore which includes that two volume set +[484.620 --> 485.660] As well as +[485.740 --> 491.580] The link to my website where you can buy these armories and all kinds of other really cool stuff and some really neat downloads and +[494.780 --> 497.340] Outreach flyers and pamphlets that I've created just for you +[499.900 --> 501.260] More on the way +[501.340 --> 504.780] So let's get to our custom of water sprinkling it says that +[505.740 --> 508.060] It was so common nobody knows how it was done +[508.940 --> 513.820] We had no idea so we devised our own method ours based on the method that Gavahorn uses +[514.140 --> 519.020] So we have our bolly a lot of times we do this we incorporate this also in a bloat +[519.260 --> 524.380] So we have a separate bolly separate from our bloat bowl because our bloat balls usually fill up need or alcohol of some +[524.860 --> 529.820] Some sort and while meat would seem appropriate because we certainly use it to bless weapons and tools +[530.780 --> 537.020] It's very specifically a water sprinkling so we have a separate bowl this nice clean silver bowl and we use this abalone shell +[538.460 --> 540.460] Now the abalone shell has +[541.260 --> 543.820] A series of holes along the side you can see them on the inside +[544.300 --> 548.780] And it's a very neat effect when you plug the holes scoop your water and then let it +[549.260 --> 555.820] rain shower on the individual's head again. We don't know how it was sprinkled so this is a +[557.340 --> 558.700] A nice +[558.700 --> 561.180] Kind of a ceremonial way that we can do it +[562.140 --> 565.660] Based on our own intuition, but it's probably just as likely +[566.620 --> 574.860] That you could just scoop the water and pour it on or pour it out of a bottle or a vase any of those are probably equally just as likely that they happened +[575.580 --> 582.460] And the probability that it was done differently across different regions is highly likely as well +[582.540 --> 585.180] So do what works for you. That's what works for us +[585.260 --> 589.580] So we have the larger and the smaller abalone shells which you can get it almost any +[590.540 --> 591.820] like +[591.820 --> 594.220] Indian store or craft store or +[595.900 --> 600.140] Things like that. I think you could probably get an abalone shell at michaels or or any craft store +[600.620 --> 603.660] But I'll look on and see if I can find some on amazon +[603.660 --> 605.500] And if so then I'll put them in our +[605.500 --> 608.780] Amazon store because our amazon store has a section for +[609.180 --> 611.180] Alter spaces and ritual tools +[611.260 --> 615.020] So we'll put some of these in there if I can find them this one was gifted to us from +[615.980 --> 623.820] Um from the galorengo the huck of anetta and then we have a couple of these little ones that we picked up a good will and various other little stores along the way +[624.460 --> 632.060] I like this one to keep in my gody travel kit and then this is our main ritual one that we keep here and our horg in the house +[632.460 --> 635.980] So I'll show you just a real quick example of how we use the tools mechanically +[636.780 --> 639.660] and then if you stick around to the very end of the video +[640.220 --> 641.500] There is +[641.500 --> 648.940] There'll be a small scene where we actually name and gift and water sprinkle one of our kinsman yoffenhard +[650.220 --> 652.220] Which means just as high +[653.100 --> 656.460] Now a lot of this stuff we're talking about we're talking about gen 1 +[656.620 --> 658.860] Ossetru like myself and mongeedia +[659.580 --> 662.140] And a lot of people who just kind of found this path +[662.220 --> 664.460] But there's another set of osetwar +[664.460 --> 669.420] As well like our children our children were named fast when they were children when they were little +[669.420 --> 676.620] We did this same thing now they're growing up and they are becoming adults within our kindred some of them already +[676.860 --> 678.860] Oath members of the kindred +[679.260 --> 682.140] Because that does not come automatically they're obviously a member +[682.700 --> 685.180] But they're not considered a voting +[685.340 --> 691.260] Adult with rights of an adult in a kindred until they've passed certain coming of age rituals +[691.260 --> 695.900] So remember to subscribe to this channel if you want to see a little bit about our coming of age ritual +[696.060 --> 698.220] That we adhere to in the northwards kindred +[699.180 --> 701.180] And the important distinction is +[701.660 --> 703.660] They're no longer children +[703.660 --> 706.380] Who require us to take care of them +[706.380 --> 710.060] They are now grown men and women who can take care of themselves +[710.060 --> 714.860] And arm themselves and stand in the shield wall to protect this kindred +[714.860 --> 716.700] They are now they are no longer +[717.340 --> 719.260] Dependence they are now eating guard +[720.060 --> 724.140] So here's just the mechanical operation of the way that we do it of course you can use +[724.940 --> 726.140] Whatever appeals to you +[726.140 --> 731.260] So we generally bring the water out in some sort of a container like a corap or maybe another wine bottle or something +[731.580 --> 733.580] something a little bit +[733.580 --> 736.220] special other than just a plastic water bottle +[736.460 --> 741.260] Of course that's fine. That's fine with you. So we have water in this container. It's um +[745.260 --> 753.100] It is a simple tap water and we will generally bless it during our ritual that we incorporate the naming into +[753.420 --> 758.060] If we're not doing a ritual in conjunction with the naming which I've never done +[758.460 --> 763.500] But maybe it's possible then we would take the time at least individually to ask the gods the bless +[763.580 --> 765.580] And purify this water for us +[766.220 --> 771.420] And if you're into crystals and rock magic and stuff then you could probably or smudge or whatever you would want to do +[771.660 --> 776.540] You could do that also whatever whatever it feels right to you to purify this water for this purpose +[777.900 --> 780.220] Now we have this is my small and my travel one +[781.180 --> 784.860] The larger one works well for us because I can hold it and plug the holes +[786.140 --> 788.860] You can see that I can plug those holes with my hand +[790.860 --> 792.860] And then my geege can fill it +[793.740 --> 796.940] Which you'll see soon but with the smaller one in the travel +[796.940 --> 801.900] I usually don't have a helper and I'm on my own so I have this small one and I can just scoop the water +[803.980 --> 807.020] Plug it and then let it let it flow +[814.460 --> 819.820] So there's that possibility or the another possibility is I could actually just hold both +[820.060 --> 822.780] Scoop and pour +[823.980 --> 827.500] Just like this and just pour right over their head without ever having to plug the holes at all +[828.780 --> 831.180] It's a little shower. It's a little more festive +[831.820 --> 835.900] But barring that and not having the right tools shouldn't forbid +[837.260 --> 841.500] I think that this was probably the most traditional way +[843.500 --> 845.500] To water sprinkle +[846.060 --> 847.500] One thing that we'll never do +[848.300 --> 852.700] And you'll see in the video coming up is I don't ask my kids men who are way taller than me +[853.100 --> 859.660] I don't ask them to bow so that I can do it. I'll either stand on a stump stand on a rock or stand on my tippy toes +[860.060 --> 864.460] But I won't ask them to bow before me so that I can water sprinkle them +[864.540 --> 866.460] I will find a way to get up to their level +[867.260 --> 869.260] But that's just here at the Northwoods +[869.820 --> 871.500] And lastly +[871.500 --> 873.500] And this is entirely up to your own +[873.740 --> 877.340] Choice making and obviously there's no references traditionally to it +[879.100 --> 882.220] But you can always pick herbs we happen to have yarrow right here +[882.220 --> 884.300] But you can always pick purification herbs +[884.940 --> 889.100] To add to your smudge or whatever and also you can add that to your water +[889.900 --> 891.900] To give it that +[892.060 --> 894.060] That clean aromatic smell +[894.460 --> 896.140] that purifying +[896.140 --> 898.140] feeling that +[898.780 --> 900.780] That something like +[901.180 --> 905.180] Yaro or other herbs would give it kind of make it that much more special +[913.340 --> 915.340] Is there any other work to be performed? +[915.740 --> 916.780] I +[916.780 --> 918.780] We have to name our brother +[918.780 --> 920.940] He has to have a good strong heathen name +[921.420 --> 923.420] Brunton Seder unnamed heathen +[924.940 --> 926.940] Have you come with a name? +[926.940 --> 928.460] I have +[929.100 --> 930.460] And it's going to be +[930.460 --> 931.420] Yothenhar +[931.420 --> 932.460] Yothenhar +[932.460 --> 933.740] And what does that mean? +[933.740 --> 934.700] That means +[934.700 --> 935.900] Equally high +[935.900 --> 937.340] Equally high +[937.340 --> 938.860] Brilliant +[944.700 --> 946.860] And the name of fray and frayah +[947.660 --> 949.980] Njard and the Almighty Os Odin +[949.980 --> 952.220] I blessed this water that it may rinse away +[952.860 --> 954.860] all the filth +[955.020 --> 957.020] That came with you +[959.100 --> 961.260] This is the old custom +[961.980 --> 963.340] And in the old custom it says +[964.140 --> 966.140] That it was such a common occurrence +[966.140 --> 968.140] That they didn't even mention +[968.140 --> 969.580] How the water was sprinkled +[969.580 --> 971.740] So we designed it our own way +[971.740 --> 975.100] But whenever a name was given to either a child or +[975.100 --> 978.700] Or two an adult who received a different name for ballroom combat or whatever +[978.700 --> 980.700] Then this was the ritual that took place +[981.260 --> 982.620] So can you remove your hands? +[982.620 --> 983.260] Just +[983.420 --> 987.420] I won't ask you about +[988.700 --> 990.700] With this water +[990.700 --> 992.700] And wash away +[992.700 --> 994.700] All the +[994.700 --> 996.700] Christianity +[996.700 --> 998.700] You are now +[998.700 --> 999.900] A blooded heathen +[999.900 --> 1000.700] Yes +[1000.700 --> 1002.700] I W +[1002.700 --> 1003.900] Yothenhar +[1003.900 --> 1005.900] Hell Yothenhar +[1005.900 --> 1007.100] Hell Yothenhar +[1007.100 --> 1009.100] And with that +[1009.100 --> 1010.460] As is our custom +[1010.460 --> 1011.500] Your one year +[1011.500 --> 1013.500] Oath day your new name +[1013.980 --> 1015.980] And your gift +[1015.980 --> 1017.980] Where it was pride brother thank you +[1018.780 --> 1021.580] I hope that I delivered on my promise and I hope that I gave you the +[1021.580 --> 1023.020] Resources that you want +[1023.020 --> 1025.820] And the information that you were looking for in relation to baptism +[1025.820 --> 1027.580] There's not a whole lot of sources on it +[1027.580 --> 1030.140] But we do know that it was a common ritual +[1030.140 --> 1033.340] It happened so often that it was almost just mundane +[1033.340 --> 1034.940] And not even worth writing down +[1034.940 --> 1038.060] So at least we have a couple of snippets of information from it +[1038.060 --> 1039.740] Throughout the liking age that we can +[1040.940 --> 1043.100] Draw as much information out as possible +[1043.100 --> 1046.140] Fill in the blanks and incorporate it into our own kindred rituals +[1046.140 --> 1047.340] I hope that works for you +[1047.340 --> 1048.700] Thank you for watching the video +[1048.700 --> 1052.540] And may you always find the vine inspiration when rediscovering the rituals +[1052.540 --> 1053.660] Of our fathers +[1053.660 --> 1054.380] Fathers +[1054.380 --> 1055.180] Thorvig diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_UvIh-YdUxd8.txt b/transcript/ceremony_UvIh-YdUxd8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0af66ab708c45100e6f07b3131e66ffaeab6045f --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_UvIh-YdUxd8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,70 @@ +[0.000 --> 9.000] Do you want to be an influencer? Do you want to gain one million followers? +[9.000 --> 13.000] Well, I can't help you. I'm an introverted old man. +[13.000 --> 19.000] The world is on fire, kids, literally and figuratively. +[19.000 --> 26.000] And it's time to create something bigger than yourself through collaboration. +[26.000 --> 36.000] It's wonderful to have a well-rehearsed band, it's tight AF with all the parts and arrangements worked out. +[36.000 --> 49.000] But some real magic can come out when the group is improvising together and using non-verbal and telepathic means to communicate and guide each other along. +[49.000 --> 55.000] And for those of you with the sense of sight, I want to say really look at each other. +[55.000 --> 72.000] It's tempting to close your eyes and feel everything deeply, but it can make or break your fellow musicians' experience of playing with you, whether or not you're being alert and watching. +[72.000 --> 84.000] And so here I have a list of some things you can see and hear that are non-verbal ways that musicians communicate with each other. +[84.000 --> 96.000] So first of all, with C, you want to look at each other, but especially the leader of the song, whoever is seeing it or playing the head or who called it. +[96.000 --> 110.000] You'll know who the leader is. And you want to look at each other, everyone, like I said, but especially the leader is going to be responsible for telling you where everything is going to go. +[110.000 --> 120.000] So this first line, I have some different symbols for just saying what part of the song that you're in. +[120.000 --> 131.000] Like, if it's time to play the last state of the song, some people do that as an intro or as a tag at the end of the song. +[131.000 --> 138.000] They'll do a sign like this maybe in the jazz world or maybe they'll hold up eight fingers. +[138.000 --> 146.000] And sometimes it's time to go to the head, which is the top, the beginning of the song and play the melody out. +[146.000 --> 151.000] And often people just kind of pat their head and let you know. +[151.000 --> 164.000] If it's time to go to the end or time to end the song, they might put up their fisting or about to end it last time or in some old time bluegrass jams. +[164.000 --> 169.000] They'll kick up their leg like that, let you know it's ending. +[169.000 --> 178.000] Or if it's time to start the song and instead of counting, they'll just look at everyone and nod to get that down beat. +[178.000 --> 182.000] They'll do that in bands, they'll do that in string quartets. +[182.000 --> 190.000] Also, even if it's not just starting the song, but it's maybe unclear where the form is starting over and you have to play it solo. +[190.000 --> 194.000] They'll look at you in a nod, let you know it's starting there. +[194.000 --> 197.000] So there are a lot of things like that. +[197.000 --> 205.000] So some people kind of literally conduct, I mean conductors of orchestra, I'd say they literally conduct. +[205.000 --> 216.000] But I mean also in bands, they'll sometimes do things like, oh the volume's going down, they'll like go like that to let you know. +[216.000 --> 230.000] Or if it's time to slow down the tempo, they might literally like do some kind of motion that'll let you know a slower beat is coming or faster beat is coming. +[230.000 --> 241.000] And when it's time for someone to take solos, it's very helpful if the leader really motions to the person who gets the solo. +[241.000 --> 245.000] Sometimes a band has that all worked out, but sometimes they don't. +[245.000 --> 256.000] And so if it's your turn to do this, it's good to either point at the soloist or if you think that's too rude, just look at them and nod or something. +[256.000 --> 266.000] And a lot of musicians learn this kind of non-verbal communication at first through lower stakes environments like Jams. +[266.000 --> 275.000] And in Jams, you don't necessarily have to take a solo. A lot of more things are up to you when you're not in a performance scenario. +[275.000 --> 287.000] But if you decide you're not going to take a solo, it's really helpful to shake your head or something or let the next person know that you're not going to have one. +[287.000 --> 294.000] Because if you just wait for it to be your solo and you just sit there and don't do it, people can't tell if you're going to play or nod. +[294.000 --> 305.000] And the form is going by and then someone else who maybe wanted a solo is missing half of their solo because they have to take wherever you left off. +[305.000 --> 308.000] You know what I mean? So it's good to communicate everything like that. +[308.000 --> 322.000] Also, some things with numbers, there's this thing called the Nashville number system where people hold up different numbers of fingers to say what chord they're going to or going to want. +[322.000 --> 335.000] Going the five, going the four, sometimes people do it just half a beat before they do that just so people have a little moment to think about the chord before it falls on the beat. +[335.000 --> 340.000] Some people like to do it exactly at the beat. +[340.000 --> 347.000] And people also will hold up a certain number of keys fingers to show what key you're in. +[347.000 --> 353.000] If you're in a sharp key, say you're in the key of D with two sharps, they'll hold up two fingers. +[353.000 --> 361.000] If they were to hold down two fingers, that means two flats. That would be the key of the flat. +[362.000 --> 372.000] Okay, so those are some C things. Make sure you're looking around and just showing that you're a team player by being alert and aware. +[372.000 --> 377.000] So the other thing is there's a lot of things to listen for. +[377.000 --> 388.000] And one thing is it's always important to be listening to the music. It's almost more important to be listening to the other players in the band than it is to yourself. +[388.000 --> 398.000] If you can believe that. And a really good way to just have a grounded feel in the song is to listen to kind of the bass line. +[398.000 --> 407.000] Listen to what the bass is playing or the drums because they're just going to really be keeping it together and that's going to be the most basic thing. +[407.000 --> 422.000] The least possible way to get really confused because maybe the band is doing a lot of complicated things and if you try to listen to what one other person is doing, it could actually make you get off and be confused. +[423.000 --> 436.000] But it's also really good to just listen to the whole band for changes in the chords. Maybe you got a little loss in the song, but if you can hear what they're playing, you can get back on it. +[436.000 --> 449.000] Listen for changes of tempo. People might decide to do even if they don't conduct it, you can hear it that they changed. Just be alert. Changes in dynamics. Same thing. +[449.000 --> 457.000] And rhythmic patterns. Maybe people want to do some fun little rhythmic change on the bridge or something instead of going like, +[457.000 --> 468.000] feet, feet, feet, feet, feet, feet, feet, feet, feet, feet, feet, feet, feet. So maybe they'll hold up fingers like, we're going to do three. That's what that means. +[468.000 --> 483.000] But just listen for if they're doing fun little changes like that. Also trades where people are breaking up the form and just taking a part of the solo and the next soloist takes the next little part of the form. +[483.000 --> 493.000] And sometimes people will motion that or they'll say trades or something like that or four is we're going to take four bars each of the whole form. +[493.000 --> 507.000] But sometimes they don't say that. You just have to be looking around and hearing, oh, I expected to hear the whole form on this saxophone, but I only heard four bars and suddenly the harp is playing. +[507.000 --> 517.000] So you got to notice some stuff like that. There's some other secret little messages that can be actually transmitted musically. +[517.000 --> 537.000] So if someone is playing the one chord of the song and then they make it a dominant chord, they add the seven note to the chord, the flat seven, that very likely means they're going to the four chord now. +[537.000 --> 549.000] Or if they're playing any chord and they do that seven, it very likely means they're going to a chord a fourth of way. And that's a really good way of just communicating musically. +[549.000 --> 562.000] And one more interesting thing I want to talk about is drum communication. And this is something that goes back prehistoricly through human history. +[562.000 --> 572.000] And it's especially traced through some tribal African communities at Papua New Guinea and tropical South America. +[572.000 --> 591.000] There are many peoples who for thousands of years have practiced communication through drums. And there's something called a talking drum that has a lot of kind of musical phonemes +[591.000 --> 607.000] that can be matched up with linguistic sounds and drums that are used for communication sometimes can be heard and transmit messages up to seven miles away. +[607.000 --> 621.000] And this has been used traditionally to announce ceremonies in neighboring villages or announce that there are invaders coming and to be aware. +[621.000 --> 629.000] And sometimes it'll be kind of a simple form of communication, little rhythmic patterns that mean a certain thing. +[629.000 --> 641.000] But sometimes it can really sound almost like language, especially in these very tonal languages that were also common to the people who practiced this. +[641.000 --> 657.000] And so maybe they don't hear all these consonants and vowel sounds, but the tones and rhythms of it are enough for them to actually kind of make out words and have more or less complex conversations or messages that they transmit. +[657.000 --> 680.000] So that's something very interesting about humans. And when Africans were taken from Africa to be slaves in America, they were able to communicate secretly messages that the slave captors didn't understand using these drums. +[680.000 --> 693.000] And they were able to organize that way. And therefore, drumming became banned because they didn't want their slaves to have a secret message system through music that they couldn't understand. +[693.000 --> 707.000] But that just really is a testament to the amazing power of music and communication and working together in a group using music. +[707.000 --> 718.000] So thank you for listening and look up talking drums and drum communication. It's very interesting and good luck communicating with your fellow musicians. +[718.000 --> 724.000] Thank you. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_V8ELfEjAQls.txt b/transcript/ceremony_V8ELfEjAQls.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..00d11c418fa6189efc1011984c966b8434ffaaee --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_V8ELfEjAQls.txt @@ -0,0 +1,44 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.000] Well, hello, everyone. +[5.000 --> 7.000] Welcome. How are we doing today? +[7.000 --> 10.000] Nope, nope, nope. That's not gonna do it. +[10.000 --> 13.000] I was just about to get married today. How are we doing today? +[13.000 --> 16.000] I'm hoping that the five red bulls keep. +[16.000 --> 18.000] I'm hoping that I have some fun up here. +[18.000 --> 21.000] You know what I'm shining with? I was just about to bother showing you guys. +[21.000 --> 23.000] What is it specifically that you're looking for? +[23.000 --> 25.000] I'm going to be a little bit more careful. +[25.000 --> 27.000] I'm going to be a little bit more careful. +[27.000 --> 30.000] Alex is proud of others. What is it specifically that you're looking for? +[30.000 --> 33.000] They said, Jeff, as long as you keep the thing between two to three hours, +[33.000 --> 36.000] we're good. We're good. We're good. +[36.000 --> 38.000] Actually, the question for you before we get started, +[38.000 --> 40.000] and believe it or not, I'm looking for a response. +[40.000 --> 43.000] Maybe I'm going to do a ceremony where the efficiency has taken a question, +[43.000 --> 45.000] and it's looking great and answer. +[45.000 --> 46.000] Here's a question for you. +[46.000 --> 49.000] What do you do when something really good happens? +[49.000 --> 51.000] Something really good. What do you do? +[51.000 --> 52.000] I'm not right. +[52.000 --> 53.000] I'm not right. +[53.000 --> 55.000] I'm not right. I'm not right. I'm not right. +[55.000 --> 57.000] What else can you do? +[57.000 --> 59.000] You cheer? We get excited. +[59.000 --> 61.000] We have a drink. All this stuff is pretty acceptable, right? +[61.000 --> 64.000] Because this is good. I'm not hoping for this to be an awesome ceremony. +[64.000 --> 66.000] But more of this to be an awesome ceremony, +[66.000 --> 68.000] it means we're going to get this thing in place. +[68.000 --> 69.000] I just about to get married. +[69.000 --> 72.000] People just want this thing, and they're so far up to do this thing, say. +[72.000 --> 73.000] They won't be able to be excited. +[73.000 --> 75.000] So if something is exciting, why don't you go and clap, cheer? +[75.000 --> 77.000] You can be excited with them. You want to cry this thing out? +[77.000 --> 79.000] You should probably do that, Brad's toast. +[79.000 --> 80.000] He's going to cry for sure. +[80.000 --> 82.000] Look at him right now. He's already crying. +[82.000 --> 84.000] But they really just want you to be present. +[84.000 --> 86.000] If you've got a foreigner camera, feel free to launch that. +[86.000 --> 88.000] They have an amazing photo and video team. +[88.000 --> 90.000] We're going to capture everything. +[90.000 --> 92.000] So you think we can start it? +[92.000 --> 93.000] Bring it in. +[93.000 --> 94.000] Let's do it. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_ZUIy56Ig7Yk.txt b/transcript/ceremony_ZUIy56Ig7Yk.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..68bc2f1449ea73af56979606c8e552dc62d59dbe --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_ZUIy56Ig7Yk.txt @@ -0,0 +1,653 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.000] Congratulations, you so deserve your star of the Hollywood Walker fame. +[4.000 --> 9.000] And thank you for including me, your fake mom who left your home alone not once but twice. +[9.000 --> 13.000] To share in this happy occasion, I'm so proud of you. +[13.000 --> 14.000] God bless. +[14.000 --> 17.000] What's going on everyone, welcome to the Behavioral Lights. +[17.000 --> 21.000] My name is Spidey and I use my degree in sociology and psychology, my certifications, +[21.000 --> 26.000] including interrogation and body language analysis, and over 10 years experience as an award-winning mentalist, +[26.000 --> 31.000] to teach people behavioral analysis and practical psychology on stages and television shows all over the world. +[31.000 --> 38.000] This week we're looking at a video of McCulley Culkin, the actor famously portrayed Kevin in the holiday classic Home Alone and Home Alone 2. +[38.000 --> 44.000] Just last week he accepted a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame and delivered a pretty heartfelt speech. +[44.000 --> 50.000] Amongst the attendees was his on-screen mother, Catherine O'Hara, who also gave a very emotional speech. +[50.000 --> 57.000] But what do their body language, facial expressions, and word choice reveal about what emotions they're actually experiencing on that stage? +[57.000 --> 61.000] Given that the holidays are around the corner, I thought this would be such a great video to look at, +[61.000 --> 68.000] not only because these are the stars of one of the most classic holiday movies, but also because there's a lot of really great, +[68.000 --> 74.000] nonverbal communication here that could teach us a lot about how to spot real emotions when they're happening. +[74.000 --> 77.000] So we're going to start with Catherine O'Hara's speech. +[77.000 --> 81.000] Once again, this is the actress who played the mom in Home Alone. +[81.000 --> 90.000] She played Kate McAllister and she gave a speech on this day at the Hollywood Walk of Fame ceremony to honor McCulley Culkin and his career. +[90.000 --> 91.000] Let's take a look. +[91.000 --> 93.000] I didn't know that. +[93.000 --> 94.000] Thanks, Mom. +[94.000 --> 96.000] Oh, darling, baby. +[96.000 --> 100.000] I didn't know you were going to have to stand here and listen to this. +[100.000 --> 101.000] I know. It means you. +[101.000 --> 102.000] Can you a chair? +[102.000 --> 103.000] I know, right? +[103.000 --> 104.000] A chair from the band. +[104.000 --> 105.000] I'm the son of the son. +[105.000 --> 106.000] Okay, it's smart. +[106.000 --> 116.000] After Home Alone opened, I went to see it at a Saturday, Matt and A in a theater packed with shiny, happy children and their parents. +[116.000 --> 117.000] And it was thrilling for all of us. +[117.000 --> 122.000] But at one point, I saw two boys get up out of their seats, so not wanting to leave the movie. +[122.000 --> 126.000] But after having already sucked back their giant sodas, they really had to go. +[126.000 --> 128.000] So they started running up the aisle. +[128.000 --> 131.000] And then suddenly panicked that they might miss something great. +[131.000 --> 133.000] They turned around and looked back at the screen. +[133.000 --> 135.000] And one of them said, it's okay. +[135.000 --> 137.000] No, it's just a mom. +[137.000 --> 139.000] And they kept running. +[139.000 --> 141.000] I say bright boys. +[141.000 --> 149.000] Bright boys, Home Alone was, is, and always will be a global, a big love and global sensation. +[149.000 --> 154.000] The reason, the reason it's that, the reason families all over the world +[154.000 --> 158.000] can't let a year go by without watching and loving Home Alone together. +[158.000 --> 160.000] It's because of McColley Culkin. +[160.000 --> 161.000] Yes? +[161.000 --> 168.000] Yes, he had a most excellent script and a wonderful director. +[168.000 --> 180.000] But it is McColley's perfect performance as Kevin McCallister, that gave us that little every boy on an extraordinary adventure. +[180.000 --> 185.000] I want to start by talking about a gesture that caught my attention towards the beginning of her speech. +[185.000 --> 188.000] And it's when she's talking about having gone to the movie theater. +[188.000 --> 191.000] And she says that it was thrilling for all of us. +[191.000 --> 194.000] And we see her hand open up like this. +[194.000 --> 196.000] And her hand moves outwards like this. +[196.000 --> 198.000] So fingers up with this throwaway gesture. +[198.000 --> 202.000] Now, there's a lot of research out there on the orientation of the hands as we speak. +[202.000 --> 204.000] And the meaning that they might have. +[204.000 --> 206.000] And in most cases, they're not universal. +[206.000 --> 209.000] In other words, different cultures use different orientations of the hands. +[209.000 --> 214.000] However, the research has shown that pretty much everywhere in the world, the palm outwards like this, +[214.000 --> 217.000] with the fingers up, is consistent with negation. +[217.000 --> 222.000] So some sort of no or stop or even try and stop someone to get their attention. +[222.000 --> 226.000] Now, in my experience, I found that when it's combined with this throwaway gesture, +[226.000 --> 228.000] it's often a casual negation. +[228.000 --> 232.000] So you might ask someone if they want help with something and they might go, +[232.000 --> 234.000] no, I'll take care of it later. +[234.000 --> 236.000] Or they might say, no, don't worry about it. +[236.000 --> 238.000] If you ask them about some bad news, don't worry about it. +[238.000 --> 239.000] Not a big deal. +[239.000 --> 241.000] So when I saw Catherine O'Hara doing that gesture, +[241.000 --> 245.000] as she talked about how going to the movies to watch Home Alone was thrilling for all of us, +[245.000 --> 247.000] I was like, that's interesting. +[247.000 --> 249.000] Why do we have a stop gesture with this throwaway? +[249.000 --> 250.000] Was it not thrilling? +[250.000 --> 251.000] Did something happen? +[251.000 --> 253.000] And I was having a hard time with that. +[253.000 --> 255.000] I was a little bit stuck, but I noticed two other things. +[255.000 --> 257.000] The first is that as she's doing that, +[257.000 --> 260.000] we see her eyes open up with her eyebrows going up. +[260.000 --> 262.000] And this is called an eyebrow flash. +[262.000 --> 263.000] And there's a lot of research on this. +[263.000 --> 268.000] I have a whole video talking about why we know what the eyebrow flash means +[268.000 --> 270.000] and all the studies behind it. +[270.000 --> 272.000] But the summing up very quickly, +[272.000 --> 275.000] eyebrow flash is often consistent with either surprise, +[275.000 --> 278.000] emphasis, or some sort of social connection, +[278.000 --> 280.000] or social greeting, or acceptance, or approval, +[280.000 --> 282.000] something along those lines. +[282.000 --> 286.000] So in that moment, I noticed that it happened with that throwaway gesture. +[286.000 --> 290.000] The other thing I noticed as the video went on is that +[290.000 --> 293.000] we see her do this gesture quite a few more times. +[293.000 --> 295.000] And some of those times it is with a negation. +[295.000 --> 297.000] For example, a few seconds after that one, +[297.000 --> 300.000] she says that the two boys got out of their seats +[300.000 --> 301.000] so not wanting to leave the movie. +[301.000 --> 303.000] And we clearly see that as she's saying, +[303.000 --> 305.000] so not wanting to leave the movie, +[305.000 --> 307.000] very consistent with negation. +[307.000 --> 309.000] So not wanting to leave the movie. +[309.000 --> 312.000] However, I did notice that later in the speech, +[312.000 --> 315.000] more than once, she does that same gesture +[315.000 --> 318.000] when she's emphasizing something that's not negative. +[318.000 --> 321.000] So on numerous occasions, we see her kind of do this with the eyebrows, +[321.000 --> 323.000] with that throwaway gesture. +[323.000 --> 325.000] And there's a few times where it's towards the camera, +[325.000 --> 327.000] but it even happens when she's talking to him. +[327.000 --> 329.000] So it doesn't look like it to us, +[329.000 --> 331.000] but it's that same gesture. +[331.000 --> 334.000] And she's not saying anything negative in those moments. +[334.000 --> 338.000] So if we go back to that first one where she's saying it was thrilling for all of us, +[338.000 --> 340.000] and we combine it with that eyebrow flash, +[340.000 --> 342.000] which often happens with emphasis, +[342.000 --> 344.000] I think it's pretty likely that in that moment, +[344.000 --> 346.000] she's emphasizing how thrilling it was. +[346.000 --> 348.000] It is possible that it's a negation, +[348.000 --> 351.000] that there was something there that wasn't so thrilling. +[351.000 --> 352.000] There is that possibility. +[352.000 --> 356.000] In fact, it's possible that the negation might be something along the lines of, +[356.000 --> 358.000] I can't tell you how thrilling it was. +[358.000 --> 360.000] Because very often with emphasis, +[360.000 --> 363.000] when someone's trying to express that they can't put it into words, +[363.000 --> 365.000] we do see signs of negation. +[365.000 --> 367.000] We might see the head go side to side as they go. +[367.000 --> 369.000] It was so incredible. +[369.000 --> 371.000] You might see that hand go like this. +[371.000 --> 373.000] You might see shrugs, lip compressions. +[373.000 --> 375.000] Because the person's thinking like, I don't have the words. +[375.000 --> 378.000] I don't have the words to tell you how amazing this was. +[378.000 --> 380.000] Okay, moving on, let's take it from the top. +[380.000 --> 383.000] So she comes up on stage and there's a hug. +[383.000 --> 386.000] I think this is such a great moment of behavioral analysis. +[386.000 --> 389.000] This will be a great little life tip that you can remember +[389.000 --> 391.000] anytime you see two people hugging. +[391.000 --> 393.000] Whenever you see two people hugging, +[393.000 --> 394.000] ask yourself a question. +[394.000 --> 399.000] Are you feeling that the energy is going inwards or outwards? +[399.000 --> 400.000] Just look at it. +[400.000 --> 401.000] Use your intuition entirely. +[401.000 --> 403.000] Is it going inwards or outwards? +[403.000 --> 405.000] Sometimes you see two people hug +[405.000 --> 407.000] and you could see kind of like it's the fingertips +[407.000 --> 410.000] and their pelvis is leaning out like this +[410.000 --> 412.000] and they're looking away with their eyes. +[412.000 --> 415.000] And in those moments, you kind of can feel that, okay, +[415.000 --> 418.000] either one or both parties don't want this hug to be happening. +[418.000 --> 419.000] There's discomfort here. +[419.000 --> 421.000] With this hug that we saw in the beginning, +[421.000 --> 424.000] we really see the energy coming inwards. +[424.000 --> 428.000] So the one exception is she doesn't completely wrap her arms around him +[428.000 --> 430.000] but she's been doing this for a very long time +[430.000 --> 434.000] and she knows that a big bear hug like that can ruin the clothes +[434.000 --> 435.000] can mess things up. +[435.000 --> 437.000] Then you have to come out of that and groom. +[437.000 --> 439.000] So her arms are grabbing onto his arms +[439.000 --> 441.000] but notice how she's pulling him inwards. +[441.000 --> 442.000] You could see that pull. +[442.000 --> 443.000] You could see that tension. +[443.000 --> 446.000] He's lowering his head on her. +[446.000 --> 447.000] They're holding it for a moment +[447.000 --> 450.000] and we can really feel that they're kind of +[450.000 --> 451.000] pulling each other closer. +[451.000 --> 453.000] And it's not just the body language, +[453.000 --> 454.000] it's also what they're saying. +[454.000 --> 457.000] He says, thanks mama, in a very soft tone. +[457.000 --> 458.000] There's also a pause. +[458.000 --> 460.000] So no one's rushing to get out of this +[460.000 --> 462.000] and as they break away from it, +[462.000 --> 463.000] there's laughter. +[463.000 --> 465.000] As they break away from it, +[465.000 --> 467.000] she gives them a bit of an arm rub like this. +[467.000 --> 469.000] So no one's rushing, no one's distancing. +[469.000 --> 472.000] It's a very warm moment before she begins to speak. +[472.000 --> 474.000] As soon as she breaks away from that hug, +[474.000 --> 476.000] she says, I don't know you're going to stand you +[476.000 --> 477.000] and listen to this. +[477.000 --> 479.000] And we see something classic. +[479.000 --> 481.000] We see what we call arms a Kimbo. +[481.000 --> 485.000] And arms a Kimbo is again a very studied body language posture +[485.000 --> 488.000] which is the arms extended like this. +[488.000 --> 489.000] Now like a lot of things, +[489.000 --> 491.000] arms a Kimbo doesn't have one specific meaning. +[491.000 --> 493.000] We can't see it in a lot of context, +[493.000 --> 496.000] but very often we do see it when there's a conflict. +[496.000 --> 498.000] When someone's trying to establish that, +[498.000 --> 500.000] there's something here that needs to be taken care of. +[500.000 --> 502.000] Notice how when we do this position, +[502.000 --> 503.000] we seem bigger. +[503.000 --> 504.000] We seem more like a threat. +[504.000 --> 506.000] So when we're thinking of conflict +[506.000 --> 508.000] or trying to establish some sort of authority, +[508.000 --> 510.000] we might see arms a Kimbo. +[510.000 --> 511.000] Now in this case, it's perfect +[511.000 --> 514.000] because she's literally talking about a conflict, +[514.000 --> 516.000] a problem that there is. +[516.000 --> 517.000] I don't know you have to stand there, +[517.000 --> 518.000] get the man a chair. +[518.000 --> 520.000] But if you notice her tone, +[520.000 --> 522.000] it's that kind of exaggerated tone +[522.000 --> 524.000] that she often uses in her acting. +[524.000 --> 525.000] Stand here and listen to this. +[525.000 --> 526.000] I know, it needs to be. +[526.000 --> 527.000] Give you a chair. +[527.000 --> 528.000] I know, right? +[528.000 --> 529.000] A chair, if I'm a man. +[529.000 --> 530.000] Who do you like to put the suns on? +[530.000 --> 531.000] Okay, it's smart. +[531.000 --> 534.000] In fact, anybody who watches the comedy Shits Creek +[534.000 --> 536.000] will recognize that tone +[536.000 --> 539.000] because she's one of the stars of that sitcom. +[539.000 --> 541.000] And she has that very high-pitched, +[541.000 --> 544.000] kind of dragged-out tone that she's using right here. +[544.000 --> 546.000] Do you not know my middle name? +[546.000 --> 547.000] Of course I do. +[547.000 --> 549.000] I bless you with it. +[549.000 --> 551.000] It's very different from the way she speaks +[551.000 --> 554.000] during her speech, which is lower and calmer. +[554.000 --> 557.000] So, in this moment, especially with that exaggerated arms of Kimbo, +[557.000 --> 559.000] like this, you know, she's like leaning back, +[559.000 --> 560.000] making this gesture, looking around, +[560.000 --> 561.000] get the man a chair, +[561.000 --> 563.000] and then she quickly comes off it. +[563.000 --> 565.000] Okay, and prepares for her speech. +[565.000 --> 568.000] So I think this was just one of those little comedy bits +[568.000 --> 571.000] that we often see in the beginning of a speech +[571.000 --> 572.000] to relax the crowd. +[572.000 --> 574.000] In fact, we even see this very often +[574.000 --> 577.000] like a corporate setting where the CEO is giving a speech +[577.000 --> 580.000] and starts with some kind of a joke to lighten the mood +[580.000 --> 582.000] and that's very much what this feels like. +[582.000 --> 583.000] I don't think she's actually like, +[583.000 --> 585.000] get the man a chair. +[585.000 --> 586.000] I don't think it's real. +[586.000 --> 588.000] It's just this little bit of, +[588.000 --> 589.000] there's a problem here. +[589.000 --> 590.000] Get the man a chair. +[590.000 --> 592.000] And now we start the serious speech. +[592.000 --> 594.000] There is something she does in her speech +[594.000 --> 598.000] that shows to me such a display of professionalism. +[598.000 --> 601.000] And it's the story she decides to tell. +[601.000 --> 602.000] So the story she tells, +[602.000 --> 605.000] I've seen so many speeches by so many actors, +[605.000 --> 607.000] by so many performers. +[607.000 --> 613.000] And the speech she chose to tell lifted him at her cost. +[613.000 --> 615.000] So because it's about these two kids +[615.000 --> 616.000] who are going to go to the bathroom +[616.000 --> 617.000] and we're waiting for a moment to go +[617.000 --> 618.000] and they said, +[618.000 --> 619.000] oh, it's just the mom. +[619.000 --> 620.000] So it's just her. +[620.000 --> 621.000] Don't worry about it. +[621.000 --> 622.000] We can go now. +[622.000 --> 624.000] And the point she's trying to make is that +[624.000 --> 626.000] people don't watch home alone for me. +[626.000 --> 627.000] People watch home alone for you. +[627.000 --> 629.000] Now again, in the performance space, +[629.000 --> 631.000] this is so rare. +[631.000 --> 633.000] Because in most cases, +[633.000 --> 634.000] in situations like this, +[634.000 --> 636.000] where a co-star comes up to tell a story, +[636.000 --> 639.000] it's usually a story that involves the two of them, +[639.000 --> 641.000] something that lifts both of them. +[641.000 --> 642.000] And as nice as that is, +[642.000 --> 645.000] there's something about this that's so incredibly humble +[645.000 --> 647.000] because by doing that, +[647.000 --> 650.000] she's showing just how much more important he was +[650.000 --> 651.000] and his role is +[651.000 --> 654.000] and how much of an icon he is within that movie. +[654.000 --> 657.000] The moment she talks about him and his talent +[657.000 --> 661.000] and how we all go see the movie because of him, +[661.000 --> 663.000] we see some grooming happening with him. +[663.000 --> 664.000] Quite a bit of it. +[664.000 --> 668.000] So first we see him fix the right side of his jacket +[668.000 --> 670.000] with his right hand. +[670.000 --> 673.000] Then we see both hands come up quite obviously +[673.000 --> 677.000] and pull the shirt out from under the sleeves of the blazer +[677.000 --> 679.000] to make them visible. +[679.000 --> 681.000] Now grooming gestures is anything that we do +[681.000 --> 683.000] to fix our appearance. +[683.000 --> 685.000] And it's usually a really good indication +[685.000 --> 688.000] that our focus has gone from external to internal. +[688.000 --> 691.000] We are now thinking about how we're coming off. +[692.000 --> 694.000] And this is a very natural moment for that to happen +[694.000 --> 696.000] because she's putting the attention on him. +[696.000 --> 698.000] And he knows how the media works. +[698.000 --> 701.000] He knows that the moment she starts talking about his talent, +[701.000 --> 704.000] his gifts, a lot of those cameras are going to point to him +[704.000 --> 706.000] because she's now mentioning him. +[706.000 --> 708.000] And so I think that thought of him like, +[708.000 --> 709.000] ooh, we're talking about me now, +[709.000 --> 711.000] is causing him to fix that appearance +[711.000 --> 713.000] as he's feeling self-conscious. +[713.000 --> 716.000] There's a gesture towards the end that's really going to solidify +[716.000 --> 720.000] for me how she emphasizes certain sentiments. +[721.000 --> 724.000] And it's when she's saying how his performance gave us +[724.000 --> 727.000] that little every boy on an extraordinary adventure. +[727.000 --> 729.000] And we see this no gesture. +[729.000 --> 732.000] So the no gesture is one of the most misunderstood gestures +[732.000 --> 734.000] in body language. +[734.000 --> 737.000] So often in comments on social media or even articles, +[737.000 --> 740.000] I'll see people say that, oh, whenever you see someone do this, +[740.000 --> 742.000] it's because they're being deceptive. +[742.000 --> 745.000] First and foremost, there isn't a single gesture in existence +[745.000 --> 748.000] that can indicate that someone's being deceptive. +[748.000 --> 751.000] We don't all do the same thing when we're being deceptive. +[751.000 --> 754.000] So get rid of that concept that any one thing you could see +[754.000 --> 757.000] allows you to know someone's being deceptive. +[757.000 --> 760.000] But much less this gesture because we use this for a lot of things. +[760.000 --> 763.000] If someone gives you really unbelievable news +[763.000 --> 765.000] and you don't believe it, you might be like, what? +[765.000 --> 766.000] There's no way. +[766.000 --> 768.000] So with disbelief, we often do this. +[768.000 --> 771.000] We also see it often with disapproval or disappointment. +[771.000 --> 774.000] So if you're thinking about something you did and you're not too proud of it, +[774.000 --> 777.000] you might be doing this out of like regret or disappointment +[777.000 --> 779.000] and you're being very genuine. +[779.000 --> 783.000] And in her case, we're seeing it at a moment where she doesn't know the right word. +[783.000 --> 785.000] She's searching for her words. +[785.000 --> 787.000] And we do see this sometimes with someone's like, +[787.000 --> 791.000] I don't know how to put this, which is very consistent for her +[791.000 --> 795.000] with that throwaway negation gesture that we saw earlier. +[795.000 --> 799.000] So it seems like for her every so often when she's thinking, +[799.000 --> 802.000] I don't know what to say or I don't know how to put this, +[802.000 --> 805.000] we're seeing these signs of negation that aren't negating the statement +[805.000 --> 809.000] but her feelings towards not really knowing how to put this. +[809.000 --> 811.000] Speaking of that hand gesture in this next clip, +[811.000 --> 813.000] we're going to see her do it again. +[813.000 --> 815.000] It's not as extended but it's that same kind of gesture +[815.000 --> 819.000] and she's really not saying anything negative or positive at all. +[819.000 --> 821.000] She's just talking about how they made a movie. +[821.000 --> 824.000] So that again is the reminder that for her, +[824.000 --> 827.000] this kind of thing does seem to happen a lot with emphasis. +[827.000 --> 832.000] It really was as if we had ambushed the home of this real little boy named Kevin +[832.000 --> 836.000] to make a movie and he just went along with it for the fun of it. +[836.000 --> 838.000] He's the dearest thing. +[838.000 --> 844.000] Okay. Oh, oh, the scene where I had to drag him upstairs +[844.000 --> 846.000] to sleep in the attic because he misbehaved. +[846.000 --> 851.000] And he says, you know, he's melting off about the family and I say, +[851.000 --> 854.000] well, you'd be pretty sad if you woke up tomorrow morning +[854.000 --> 858.000] and you had no family and he said, no, I wouldn't. +[858.000 --> 863.000] And I was supposed to say, then say it again. +[863.000 --> 864.000] Maybe it'll happen. +[864.000 --> 866.000] And I can't tell you how much that killed me. +[866.000 --> 872.000] I could not wrap my head around saying something so horrific to this beautiful child. +[872.000 --> 874.000] Okay. A couple of really great things in that one, +[874.000 --> 877.000] including a moment that I've been waiting for months, +[877.000 --> 880.000] hoping that in one of the analysis videos that we cover on the channel +[880.000 --> 883.000] that's going to come up because I wanted to contrast it +[883.000 --> 886.000] with something we've talked about very often on the channel. +[886.000 --> 890.000] And it happens just after she says he's the dearest thing. +[890.000 --> 893.000] So as she's saying that, he's the dearest thing. +[893.000 --> 898.000] Right at the end of the thing, we hear her voice start to tremble and it crashes. +[898.000 --> 904.000] And her head goes down and we see the chin boss like this causing the lips to tighten +[904.000 --> 906.000] as she goes down like this. +[906.000 --> 908.000] Now, this isn't the tightening of the lips. +[908.000 --> 912.000] It's not a compression. It's the chin pushing those lips up. +[912.000 --> 917.000] And the head goes down, then we see the hands come up like this and fists as she goes, +[917.000 --> 921.000] okay, and then she perks up and she continues with the speech. +[921.000 --> 925.000] And the reason I've been waiting for a moment like this in these videos +[925.000 --> 929.000] is because that is pretty much exactly what it should look like +[929.000 --> 933.000] when you're in a public place and sadness hits you for a moment. +[933.000 --> 936.000] So on the channel, there's been numerous times +[936.000 --> 940.000] where we looked at people who are in public giving a speech +[940.000 --> 943.000] and when sadness hit, they displayed it. +[943.000 --> 948.000] They showed it. They really wanted to make sure that people saw this sadness. +[948.000 --> 952.000] And I said in all those occasions that that's not necessarily normal. +[952.000 --> 957.000] Because sadness is a vulnerability and our reflex in the way that we evolved +[957.000 --> 963.000] is the hide vulnerabilities immediately are instinct wants the hide sadness in public settings. +[963.000 --> 965.000] And this is such a great example of that. +[965.000 --> 968.000] Well, it's not sadness. She's not sad obviously. +[968.000 --> 972.000] But she's being overcome with an intense emotion and she's experiencing those +[972.000 --> 976.000] tears of joy, which we're going to talk about a little bit later in this video. +[976.000 --> 982.000] But as she feels that strong emotion hit and we could see she displaying the face of sadness, +[982.000 --> 984.000] we see she wants to hide it. +[984.000 --> 988.000] So the head goes down and the hands come up and fists like this. +[988.000 --> 990.000] Now, there aren't any absolutes in body language. +[990.000 --> 996.000] We said it all the time, but fists are very rarely a positive thing. +[996.000 --> 1002.000] There's almost no situation in which you'll see someone gesturing with fists like this in a positive moment. +[1002.000 --> 1006.000] When our fingers come inwards like this, this could mean defensiveness, +[1006.000 --> 1010.000] it could mean aggression, it could mean we're feeling like we need to protect ourselves. +[1010.000 --> 1012.000] But it's rarely a good thing. +[1012.000 --> 1014.000] When we're irritated, it happens a lot. +[1014.000 --> 1018.000] One really big exception to this is when someone's excited, +[1018.000 --> 1022.000] more specifically celebrating a victory or an achievement. +[1022.000 --> 1028.000] You might see someone go like yes, like this or like that or even raise the hand and a fist like yes, +[1028.000 --> 1030.000] I did it and we see this. +[1030.000 --> 1036.000] I don't know why it's quite consistent in that moment, but outside of that fingers coming inwards +[1036.000 --> 1038.000] typically are not a great sign. +[1038.000 --> 1040.000] So in this case, we're seeing that it's irritating. +[1040.000 --> 1042.000] You're like come on, get yourself together. +[1042.000 --> 1046.000] And we even said just we even hear that like shake it off. +[1046.000 --> 1051.000] So the sadness comes in, she hides it, she shakes it off, comes back up, +[1051.000 --> 1053.000] and keeps going with the speech. +[1053.000 --> 1057.000] That's what it normally looks like when emotion hits us in public. +[1057.000 --> 1061.000] There is something so sweet in her choice of words. +[1061.000 --> 1067.000] They're not necessarily a choice of words, but there's a shift in the tense of the verbs that she's using. +[1067.000 --> 1069.000] So she's speaking in the past, right? +[1069.000 --> 1074.000] She's saying how it felt like they hijacked this house of a boy named Kevin to make this movie. +[1074.000 --> 1077.000] And he just went along with it, passed, passed. +[1077.000 --> 1082.000] She's done the story in the past, and then she looks at him and says he's the dearest thing. +[1082.000 --> 1085.000] Not he was the dearest thing, which would make more sense, right? +[1085.000 --> 1088.000] She's talking about when he was a child. +[1088.000 --> 1091.000] You know, he just went along with it, he was the dearest thing. +[1091.000 --> 1094.000] She didn't say that she said he is the dearest thing. +[1094.000 --> 1096.000] So she changed the tense to now. +[1096.000 --> 1097.000] And it's just so sweet. +[1097.000 --> 1100.000] And I think that's part of the reason she breaks down in that moment. +[1100.000 --> 1105.000] Because she realized that all these years later, this grown man is still that sweet little boy. +[1105.000 --> 1108.000] And he just went along with it for the fun of it. +[1108.000 --> 1110.000] He's the dearest thing. +[1110.000 --> 1114.000] And there's a lot of that feeling throughout this entire thing. +[1114.000 --> 1121.000] Her speech, even his speech, it's like they played mother and son in these two movies ages ago. +[1121.000 --> 1125.000] But there's still very much that motherly feeling towards him. +[1125.000 --> 1128.000] Even in the beginning, when they hugged, he said, thanks mama. +[1128.000 --> 1130.000] She said darling baby. +[1130.000 --> 1132.000] That was a very authentic hug. +[1132.000 --> 1138.000] In a lot of the way she talks about him throughout her speech, we could feel in the way that she chooses her words. +[1138.000 --> 1144.000] In the way she refers to him, that there's a very, very mama bear feeling there. +[1144.000 --> 1150.000] We even feel that when she's talking about the scene where she dragged him up to the attic because he misbehaved. +[1150.000 --> 1152.000] And we kind of see her turn towards him. +[1152.000 --> 1154.000] We see a slow blink as she turns towards him. +[1154.000 --> 1161.000] And this is a look we very commonly see when parents are telling a story of when their child did something as a child that got them in trouble. +[1161.000 --> 1166.000] And you kind of see this, you know, so he did this thing and they kind of look at him as they're telling the story. +[1166.000 --> 1170.000] And it's so funny because she's talking about a movie scene, like a script. +[1170.000 --> 1171.000] This was scripted. +[1171.000 --> 1178.000] He didn't actually misbehave, but because of that bond, because that relationship, it almost feels like it was her son actually misbehaving. +[1178.000 --> 1186.000] And then once again, to keep up with this motherly vibe, she goes on to talk about the line she was supposed to deliver to him to say, +[1186.000 --> 1189.000] then go ahead and wish to not have a family. +[1189.000 --> 1190.000] Maybe it'll happen. +[1190.000 --> 1192.000] And we see so many signs of nervousness. +[1192.000 --> 1193.000] We see her pause. +[1193.000 --> 1195.000] We see this nervous chuckle. +[1195.000 --> 1196.000] She doesn't really want to say it. +[1196.000 --> 1202.000] She says, then I was supposed to say, not I said, because in fact she did say it. +[1202.000 --> 1203.000] She delivered the line. +[1203.000 --> 1206.000] She said, I was supposed to say, we call this psychological distancing. +[1206.000 --> 1207.000] I was supposed to say it. +[1207.000 --> 1211.000] She's not embracing it like her line, like all the other lines she talked about. +[1211.000 --> 1213.000] And then we're seeing that nervousness. +[1213.000 --> 1221.000] And as she's talking about the line, having delivered it, and how she felt about it, again, we see that fist bumping on the podium like this. +[1221.000 --> 1225.000] So that is a genuine moment of her having a hard time with that line. +[1225.000 --> 1230.000] And again, that only makes sense because of this feeling she had towards this boy. +[1230.000 --> 1232.000] You know what reason does she have to be emotional about that? +[1232.000 --> 1233.000] She's an actress. +[1233.000 --> 1234.000] It's a line. +[1234.000 --> 1235.000] It's a script. +[1235.000 --> 1236.000] It's fiction. +[1236.000 --> 1242.000] But you could physically tell that she had a hard time with this line towards this boy that she considers her own son. +[1242.000 --> 1250.000] Okay, now we're going to go on and look at the rest of her speech and one line that really caught my attention that I'm curious to know what you guys think about. +[1250.000 --> 1253.000] Then we're going to look at some of his speeches, well, there's some great stuff there as well. +[1253.000 --> 1260.000] But before we do do me a huge favor, hit that subscribe button, turn those notifications on from what behavioral analysis and practical psychology content. +[1260.000 --> 1267.000] And for regular viewers who want to encourage a channel, I will leave a link in the description where you could learn more about the memberships and how you can join. +[1267.000 --> 1269.000] You're a sense of humor. +[1269.000 --> 1274.000] It's a sign of intelligence and a child and a key to surviving life at any age. +[1274.000 --> 1287.000] And you have, from what I see, you have brought that sense of sweet, yet twisted, yet totally relatable sense of humor to everything that you have chosen to do since Home Alone. +[1287.000 --> 1293.000] McCauley, congratulations, you so deserve your star of the Hollywood Walker fame. +[1293.000 --> 1300.000] And thank you for including me, your fake mom who left your home alone not once, but twice to share in this happy occasion. +[1300.000 --> 1302.000] I'm so proud of you. +[1302.000 --> 1304.000] Congratulations. +[1304.000 --> 1307.000] Thank you. +[1307.000 --> 1310.000] Thank you. +[1310.000 --> 1313.000] Thank you. +[1313.000 --> 1321.000] Okay, so at the end we saw that same hug, you know, warm embrace, pulling towards each other. +[1321.000 --> 1327.000] And again, with that arm rub at the end and a face touch, you know, open palm face touch, very comforting. +[1327.000 --> 1332.000] And that high pitch laughter of hers, haha of excitement again, same as the first hug. +[1332.000 --> 1337.000] So again, we have a very warm hug from two people who feel a lot of affection towards each other. +[1337.000 --> 1340.000] Another thing some of you may have caught is again that hand gesture. +[1340.000 --> 1347.000] It wasn't as obvious because she was turned towards him, but as she said, everything you've chosen to do, we saw that hand again. +[1347.000 --> 1350.000] And that time again, it's not an negative thing. +[1350.000 --> 1355.000] Everything. So emphasizing like all the things and we're seeing the hand move like this. +[1355.000 --> 1358.000] So again, baseline, baseline, baseline for her. +[1358.000 --> 1368.000] If I'm talking to somebody else who doesn't often emphasize this way or consistently does this with negations, then when that happens, I might say, okay, there's some sort of conflict or negation here. +[1368.000 --> 1370.000] But for her, often with emphasis. +[1370.000 --> 1376.000] Body language wise, we're seeing a lot of the same stuff from earlier, but there is one line that really caught my attention. +[1376.000 --> 1379.000] And it's one that I'm familiar with, but I'm curious to know what you guys think. +[1379.000 --> 1383.000] So she's talking about how humor in Hollywood is important. +[1383.000 --> 1389.000] And she's about to say that he brings that sense of humor to all of his roles. +[1389.000 --> 1399.000] But she stops, we hear this verbal leak, like it's important for her to stop and self-edit, right in the middle of that statement where she goes from what I see. +[1399.000 --> 1404.000] So it's important for her to say, so the statement isn't, you bring that sense of humor to all your roles. +[1404.000 --> 1409.000] It's, you brought your sense of humor from what I see to all your roles. +[1409.000 --> 1410.000] Now that's really interesting. +[1410.000 --> 1413.000] There's a self-edit there, but it's not just any self-edit. +[1413.000 --> 1416.000] It's a self-edit that busts an absolute statement. +[1416.000 --> 1426.000] So this is something we often hear when somebody's about to say something that sounds very absolute, but then they say something to minimize the absolute aspect of it. +[1426.000 --> 1432.000] So I might tell you, for example, that I believe Benedict Cumberbatch is an amazing actor, and I love every movie he's done. +[1432.000 --> 1436.000] Well, the ones I've seen. So I might correct that statement. +[1436.000 --> 1439.000] And this happens in one of two cases. +[1439.000 --> 1442.000] So in this case, it's one or the other, maybe both. +[1442.000 --> 1447.000] The first case is when we know that others might disagree. +[1447.000 --> 1455.000] So if, for example, I'm aware that there are a lot of people out there who don't think Benedict Cumberbatch is a great actor, I might say that. +[1455.000 --> 1459.000] Because I don't want people to hear me and be like, well, come on, how could you think that? +[1459.000 --> 1462.000] I don't think everything he did is great when he did this one movie that was terrible. +[1462.000 --> 1471.000] So by saying, well, everything I've seen, I'm living the possibility that he's not the greatest actor for a fact in every role. +[1471.000 --> 1475.000] There might be some roles out there where he wasn't that great, but I haven't seen those. +[1475.000 --> 1477.000] He's great in everything I've seen. +[1477.000 --> 1481.000] So it adjusts the statement from fact to opinion. +[1481.000 --> 1487.000] The second place we see this kind of self-edit where we break an absolute statement is in honest people. +[1487.000 --> 1489.000] It's the mark of an honest person. +[1489.000 --> 1498.000] Because people who are honest have a hard time making big, bold, absolute statements like that because they're aware that they don't have all the information to make that statement. +[1498.000 --> 1500.000] So they often self-correct. +[1500.000 --> 1503.000] So I have a really interesting relationship with deception. +[1503.000 --> 1507.000] On stage, as a performance, obviously I've made a profession out of deception. +[1507.000 --> 1511.000] I'm a mentalist. Mentalism is very much based in trickery. +[1511.000 --> 1516.000] So when I get on stage and I make it seem like I can read people's minds and I know what they're thinking and I predict things, +[1516.000 --> 1518.000] there's a lot of trickery in that. +[1518.000 --> 1524.000] But I don't see it as deception because I'm open with the audience as to what mentalism is. +[1524.000 --> 1529.000] So I see it more as live fiction rather than deception because the audience is aware. +[1529.000 --> 1536.000] The audience is told that there's some trickery and psychology being used to make it seem like we can read minds. +[1536.000 --> 1539.000] A lot of mentalists don't do that. They come up, they claim to be psychic. +[1539.000 --> 1545.000] They claim to be experts at reading people and they use the same trickery, the same psychology, the same body language. +[1545.000 --> 1548.000] As a mentalist like me who says, nope, this is tricks and psychology. +[1548.000 --> 1550.000] Now off stage, it's a different story. +[1550.000 --> 1559.000] I have zero tolerance for dishonesty. It's a big reason why I chose to do what I do because I severely dislike dishonesty. +[1559.000 --> 1563.000] Even like exaggerations or embellishments, they just bother me. +[1563.000 --> 1564.000] Stick to the facts. +[1564.000 --> 1570.000] So even when I talk about mentalism, it's so important for me off stage to be very clear on what it is. +[1570.000 --> 1577.000] It's also the reason very often in my videos you hear me say things like almost always or in my experience +[1577.000 --> 1582.000] because I don't want to make absolute statements because very few absolute statements are ever true. +[1582.000 --> 1586.000] The reason I'm saying all this is because I recognize myself in that statement. +[1586.000 --> 1592.000] Quite often I slip up and make an absolute statement and I immediately have the urge to self correct. +[1592.000 --> 1597.000] So I might say something like, you know, come back from restaurant and go, that was the best meal I've ever had. +[1597.000 --> 1599.000] Well, one of the best meals I've ever had. +[1599.000 --> 1603.000] So I'm not okay with letting that absolute statement remain on the record. +[1603.000 --> 1607.000] So this is something we often see in people who value honesty. +[1607.000 --> 1611.000] So in her case, it could be one or the other or both. +[1611.000 --> 1617.000] So it could be that she's aware that some of his works since home alone have been heavily criticized. +[1618.000 --> 1624.000] So when she says that he brought this amazing sense of humor to everything that she's seen, +[1624.000 --> 1627.000] she's living that open for opinion. +[1627.000 --> 1632.000] So basically she's saying there might be stuff out there that wasn't good that I haven't seen. +[1632.000 --> 1637.000] You're entitled to your opinion, that's fine, but from what I've seen, this is what you did. +[1637.000 --> 1643.000] It could also be because she places a lot of importance on honesty and that absolute statement, +[1643.000 --> 1646.000] the absoluteness of that statement, irritated her. +[1646.000 --> 1652.000] She's self-corrected into saying not everything, but as far as I know, as far as I've seen, you've done this. +[1652.000 --> 1655.000] So let me know in the comments which of the two you think it is. +[1655.000 --> 1662.000] Is it her being aware that people might disagree, so kind of keeping that door open and turning fact into opinion, +[1662.000 --> 1668.000] or is it adhering to honesty and saying that, well, I can't make the statement that it's all that way, +[1668.000 --> 1670.000] just from what I've seen. +[1670.000 --> 1671.000] What do you think? Let me know in the comments. +[1671.000 --> 1677.000] Let's talk about him really quick. So at the end of her speech, he's moved by what she said, he's emotional, +[1677.000 --> 1683.000] and we see a couple of things. One, when he laughs, not just there, but other times she's talking as well, +[1683.000 --> 1687.000] he laughs with his shoulders. We see those shoulders wiggle as he laughs. +[1687.000 --> 1692.000] The second is, right at the end there, his wiping his tears, it's such a quick wipe away. +[1692.000 --> 1697.000] We really see this display. The hand is completely open and it has these slow gestures, +[1697.000 --> 1702.000] and he goes up and does it numerous times, and it's pretty much on display. +[1702.000 --> 1705.000] So, Makoly Kalkin is a very interesting individual. +[1705.000 --> 1712.000] There are very few people on this planet who don't really have life experience, not being famous. +[1712.000 --> 1717.000] Most people who find fame, even as a teen, but mostly 20s, 30s as adults, +[1717.000 --> 1723.000] they did a whole bunch of their life as not famous, and then they became famous. +[1723.000 --> 1728.000] We're talking about a kid here who was famous very young, not just famous, mega famous. +[1728.000 --> 1734.000] He started one of the biggest movies ever made. So his whole life, he's been in the limelight, +[1734.000 --> 1739.000] he's been in front of cameras, he's been in movies. He doesn't know what it's like to not be famous. +[1739.000 --> 1743.000] I think he's constantly aware that there are eyes on him, that he's being watched. +[1743.000 --> 1749.000] And I think that in this moment, to highlight the emotional impact of what she said, +[1749.000 --> 1754.000] knowing that there's going to be articles about this, knowing that there's going to be videos published about this, +[1754.000 --> 1758.000] I think he wanted a moment. It's understood that he's exaggerating that, like he's getting on the mic, +[1758.000 --> 1761.000] and like starting to weep and cry, and it's so sad. +[1761.000 --> 1769.000] But I do think that in that moment, he did make a moment of that for the media to know that her speech got to him. +[1769.000 --> 1773.000] I think the tears are real. I think he's actually emotionally moved by this, +[1773.000 --> 1779.000] but I don't think he has a problem letting it be known, that he was emotionally affected by your speech. +[1779.000 --> 1782.000] He's okay with that. And we see some of that in his own speech as well. +[1782.000 --> 1786.000] So his own speech is making him quite emotional. And I think that's totally normal, by the way. +[1786.000 --> 1790.000] I don't think he's lathering it on there on purpose and saying, oh, look at him, +[1790.000 --> 1794.000] this is so emotional, he's not being over dramatic. +[1794.000 --> 1798.000] I think he's experiencing legitimate worm emotions during the speech, +[1798.000 --> 1802.000] and he's totally fine with displaying that. So let's take a look. +[1802.000 --> 1810.000] There's so many people that I love, and to feel that love back is just amazing. +[1810.000 --> 1813.000] So thank you. +[1813.000 --> 1825.000] Catherine Natasha, thanks for all your kind words and your stories and stuff. +[1825.000 --> 1833.000] You made my kids dad their papa look good. +[1834.000 --> 1840.000] Yeah, lastly, but not leastly, I'd like to thank Brenda. +[1840.000 --> 1849.000] You are absolutely everything. +[1849.000 --> 1858.000] You're my champion. You're the only person happier for me today than I am. +[1858.000 --> 1863.000] You're not only the best one I've ever known, you're the best person I've ever known. +[1863.000 --> 1870.000] You've given me just all my purpose. You've given me family. +[1870.000 --> 1875.000] And after the birth of our two boys, you become one of my three favorite people. +[1875.000 --> 1883.000] You're somewhere in there. But I love you. I love you so much. +[1883.000 --> 1889.000] Yeah, to wrap things up in the spirit of the holiday season, I just want to say Merry Christmas. +[1889.000 --> 1894.000] You have filthy animals. +[1894.000 --> 1898.000] Okay, so his speech is actually quite longer than that. He thinks a lot of different people. +[1898.000 --> 1903.000] But it's a lot of the same mood, a lot of the same atmosphere, a lot of gratitude, a lot of love. +[1903.000 --> 1907.000] And I want to notice there at some point when he's talking about his wife, +[1907.000 --> 1911.000] which is where he got the most emotional, I would say. +[1911.000 --> 1916.000] We do see attempts to stop getting overly emotional. +[1916.000 --> 1919.000] We do see those pauses. We do see the chin go down when that emotion hits. +[1919.000 --> 1922.000] We see hand to chest a couple of times. +[1922.000 --> 1924.000] And hand to chest is a very genuine gesture. +[1924.000 --> 1930.000] The research shows that when we see hand to chest on someone, we perceive that person as being more genuine in that moment. +[1930.000 --> 1936.000] And not only that, but when we put our hand start chest, we tend to behave more genuinely. +[1936.000 --> 1942.000] So he's feeling that emotion and he's not, again, he's not really aggressively leaning into it, +[1942.000 --> 1945.000] but he's okay with it being there. +[1945.000 --> 1949.000] But there are attempts there to mitigate it, to stop it before he goes on. +[1949.000 --> 1951.000] So it's a pretty good balance. +[1951.000 --> 1957.000] But throughout this whole thing, we are seeing genuine expression of emotional overload from him. +[1957.000 --> 1961.000] Something that if you were to just show me a picture of, I would say sadness. +[1961.000 --> 1964.000] We're seeing those chins come up. We're seeing tears. +[1964.000 --> 1968.000] So we're seeing things that look like sadness, but there's no sadness here. +[1968.000 --> 1973.000] This is a very happy occasion, which brings me to one of my favorite studies in all of social psychology, +[1973.000 --> 1975.000] which we talked about in the last week's video. +[1975.000 --> 1979.000] But I want to talk about it again because I really do love this study and it's the holidays. +[1979.000 --> 1981.000] And we should be talking about things like this. +[1981.000 --> 1983.000] And this study was massive. +[1983.000 --> 1989.000] It was done with thousands of subjects, over dozens of countries. +[1989.000 --> 1995.000] So it's really wide-reaching and includes a lot of research all coming together. +[1995.000 --> 1997.000] And it was all about tears of joy. +[1997.000 --> 2002.000] Why we look sad and cry in moments that aren't sad. +[2002.000 --> 2003.000] Why does that happen? +[2003.000 --> 2007.000] And it was narrowed down to four reasons. +[2007.000 --> 2017.000] Across cultures, pretty much anywhere in the world, there are four things that seem to cause us to cry or look sad in moments of positivity. +[2017.000 --> 2023.000] The first one is amusement. So quite simply, sometimes we're laughing so much that we start to cry. +[2023.000 --> 2028.000] That one's a little bit different than the other ones because we rarely see a face of sadness there. +[2028.000 --> 2034.000] It's just we're crying so much. We often see like this look of just exasperation, but rarely sadness. +[2034.000 --> 2038.000] We're usually smiling and laughing with this one, but we still do see tears. +[2038.000 --> 2042.000] These are the tears of amusement and they happen when we're laughing a lot. +[2042.000 --> 2051.000] The second one is beauty. In the face of beauty, we tend to not only tear out, but we see the face of sadness as well. +[2051.000 --> 2054.000] It affects us in a way that brings out the expression of sadness. +[2054.000 --> 2060.000] And beauty could be anything from seeing something beautiful in nature or beautiful music or art. +[2060.000 --> 2063.000] And this is usually something that's going to give us chills. +[2063.000 --> 2069.000] So when we have chills, with those tears of joy, typically it's related to beauty. +[2069.000 --> 2073.000] And it's also very consistent with that feeling of awe when we're amazed. +[2073.000 --> 2081.000] Next up are the affectionate tears of joy. So these happen when we're feeling unexpected kindness or exceptional love towards someone. +[2081.000 --> 2088.000] So the tears you see out of wedding, for example, the tears you see in situations where love is being exchanged, where there's compassion. +[2088.000 --> 2091.000] And this one is often associated with the feeling of warmth. +[2091.000 --> 2096.000] So when you have that, the warm fuzzy feelings cause the tears of affection. +[2096.000 --> 2106.000] Finally, one of my favorites to spot in behavioral analysis because I find this really reliable is not just the tears, but again, the full facial expression of achievement. +[2106.000 --> 2114.000] Whether we are proud of someone or proud of ourselves. And this one is very consistent with having overcome obstacles. +[2114.000 --> 2119.000] So when we have overcome obstacles and we've achieved something, we see this. +[2119.000 --> 2126.000] So very often we're someone celebrating a great big victory and we might see this or witnessing someone else do that. +[2126.000 --> 2128.000] We might have the tears of joy. +[2128.000 --> 2139.000] So think about how someone who watch a movie and at the end, when we see someone really struggle with something and they accomplish it, whether it's a biography movie or a complete fiction, right at the end there. +[2139.000 --> 2141.000] When they get the thing, it's a positive moment. +[2141.000 --> 2149.000] We're not sad or crying when the obstacles are happening. It's at the end. We have the face of sadness. We have the tears of achievement. +[2149.000 --> 2155.000] The reason this is my favorite is not only because I often spot it in my cold reads in where I'm talking to someone. +[2155.000 --> 2161.000] I could see that face of someone that made them really proud or involved obstacles. And I use that in my readings. +[2161.000 --> 2166.000] It's not just that. It's also because research can explain this one. +[2166.000 --> 2178.000] It's basically the sadness that was built up during the obstacles but that we don't want to show because we have to be strong in those moments coming out once the obstacles have been overcome. +[2178.000 --> 2186.000] So when we're dealing with hardships, our body is in stress and we know that when we're stressed, we can't show vulnerability. +[2186.000 --> 2190.000] So when we feel safe, when it's all over, we feel okay with letting it all out. +[2190.000 --> 2195.000] It's the awareness of the troubles just completely coming out because you overcame it. +[2195.000 --> 2204.000] This is the exact same reason why very often we come indoors from the cold and once we're indoors in the warmth, we go, boom, like this. +[2204.000 --> 2208.000] We're not doing that outside in the cold. We're doing it because the cold is, it's vulnerable. +[2208.000 --> 2217.000] We're in survival mode. We can't show weakness as a reflex but once we get away from that, now that we're safe, we're reacting to the obstacle. +[2217.000 --> 2219.000] Same thing for the tears of achievement. +[2219.000 --> 2227.000] So there was a really warm fuzzy event, two great speeches, a lot of emotion and some really great behavioral analysis. Hope you enjoyed it. +[2227.000 --> 2231.000] I'm going to quickly reiterate what I said in last week's video. Well two things. +[2231.000 --> 2236.000] The first is I worked on something really awesome and exciting that I can't wait to share with you guys. +[2236.000 --> 2247.000] I'm just waiting for the green light by the decision makers to let me know that it's okay to announce it, which should come in the week max two weeks after this video is released. +[2247.000 --> 2253.000] And I'm really excited for you guys to see that. Keep an eye on the community page. I'm probably going to announce it there. +[2253.000 --> 2258.000] And then we'll talk about it in later videos, but I'm really excited for you guys to see that. +[2258.000 --> 2271.000] The second thing is we're in the middle of my busiest season as a performer because the holidays bring a lot of corporate events, you know, holiday parties that I actually fly out to destinations to perform at. +[2271.000 --> 2279.000] So I really don't know what my upload schedule is going to be like. I'm really trying hard. You know, this one is between two travel dates. +[2279.000 --> 2285.000] So I'm going to try to upload, but I really don't know if I'll be able to during the coming weeks. +[2285.000 --> 2289.000] So if I don't see you before the holidays, happy and safe holidays to you and your families. +[2289.000 --> 2295.000] And again, please forgive me if I miss a couple of weeks. I'm trying to balance the performances with the videos. +[2295.000 --> 2301.000] That being said, I really hope you guys enjoyed this video. I thought it was a lot of fun. +[2301.000 --> 2309.000] For me, this movie is such an iconic part of my life. So it was really great to see this dynamic still exists all these years later. +[2309.000 --> 2312.000] Hope you enjoyed it. Let me know in the comments and I'll see you on the next one. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony__jXk53GhZr0.txt b/transcript/ceremony__jXk53GhZr0.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fad2004eb1886565749bee70a7cd2f26b4f49cc0 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony__jXk53GhZr0.txt @@ -0,0 +1,298 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.800] This is the sacred temple clothing I once wore as an active member of the Mormon Church. +[4.800 --> 9.760] You've probably seen Mormon temples in your city and your state. They're usually large and +[9.760 --> 15.520] white and they look like castles. They're really meant to look very beautiful and majestic and +[15.520 --> 20.240] honestly I think they're meant to make you curious about what Mormons are, what they believe, +[20.240 --> 25.840] and what goes inside of the temple. A Mormon temple is separate from a Mormon chapel. A chapel, +[25.840 --> 32.640] anyone can go to, visitors are welcome and the chapel is separate from the temple. What happens in +[32.640 --> 38.960] Mormon temples is very sacred or secret or concealed, whatever word you want to use to describe it, +[38.960 --> 44.560] because it is very strange and cult-like. As a kid I didn't really know what a Mormon temple +[44.560 --> 48.880] was growing up. I grew up singing songs like I love to see the temple, I'm going there someday, +[48.880 --> 53.920] and as a young kid I was so excited to go to the temple because I always believed it was going +[53.920 --> 59.520] to be this most magical, beautiful, wonderful moment of my life. There is something called a +[59.520 --> 65.520] temple prep class, but in that class they talk about really vague instances or experiences or +[65.520 --> 70.160] examples of what might happen in the temple. In my temple prep class they held up a stop sign and +[70.160 --> 76.880] said, what is this meant to symbolize? And we were supposed to draw comparisons between the fact that +[76.880 --> 82.080] there are symbols all around us and there are symbols in the temple and that those are essentially +[82.080 --> 86.640] going to be the same thing, that the symbols you see in your day-to-day life are going to be the same +[86.640 --> 93.360] symbols and maybe the same level of symbolism that you are familiar with. I went through the temple +[93.360 --> 100.000] for the first time as about a 20-year-old when I was preparing to go out on my mission to Denver, Colorado. +[100.000 --> 105.120] You can get your temple endowment at any time once you're an adult but most people get it either +[105.120 --> 108.880] when they're about to get married or when they're about to serve a mission. So for me it was when I +[108.880 --> 113.440] was about to serve a mission. Today in this video I'm going to talk about the whole ceremony, +[113.440 --> 120.080] what happens during different stages of the ceremony, the promises you make, the closing you wear, +[120.080 --> 125.600] and just describe kind of generally what this process is like. All this to say before I start, +[125.600 --> 131.520] you don't know anything about this before you go through the temple for yourself. At least most +[131.520 --> 136.320] people don't. You're heavily discouraged from seeking any information like what I'm going to +[136.320 --> 142.880] show in this video, which really contributes to a lot of the awful experiences people have because +[142.880 --> 148.320] they are so glimpsed by it, they're so overwhelmed by it, and you go from experiencing Mormonism as +[148.320 --> 155.600] this very almost non-denominational Christian church with a few more rules to experiencing it as +[156.480 --> 163.440] what seems like the most culty moment of your life once you're actually in the temple. The endowment +[163.440 --> 168.240] takes place after what's called the washing and anointing. So make sure to subscribe because I'm +[168.240 --> 171.600] going to make another video about the washing and anointing. That's where you get the garment. I +[171.600 --> 177.200] have made a video about garments. If you're curious about the sacred, secret, magic Mormon underwear, +[177.200 --> 182.160] that has the symbols in it, the garment that Mormons wear isn't meant to represent the promises made +[182.160 --> 188.000] in the temple. And so just keep in mind as I do this video that this portion of the temple is really +[188.000 --> 192.960] just part of what happens in the temple. There's also bactisms for the dead. There's also the washing +[192.960 --> 200.160] and anointing and then the endowment are the three main categories of ordinances that take place +[200.160 --> 205.440] in the temple. Also just to make it clear the endowment is seen as Mormons as being as important +[205.440 --> 211.440] as bactism. So you're probably familiar with bactism that is when our sins are washed away. Most churches +[211.440 --> 216.960] have bactism. Mormons believe though that everyone must have the endowment ceremony as well as +[216.960 --> 223.520] the washing and anointing in order to go to the highest level of heaven. And so that's why Mormons +[223.520 --> 231.040] believe the endowment is so important and so special and so sacred because ultimately this is to +[231.040 --> 238.080] them as important if to me almost not even more important than bactism. It's another saving ordinance +[238.080 --> 242.960] required by God to enter heaven. During this video I'm going to show you some of the portions and +[242.960 --> 248.000] then I'm going to have off to the side here videos of me trying it on. This is so that you can +[248.000 --> 252.400] kind of see what it looks like as I'm wearing it but also you can see it up close so you can see +[252.400 --> 257.440] kind of what it looks like. Whenever you enter the temple you always get some sort of almost +[257.440 --> 261.600] suitcase like this. So when you see people going into the temple they're always going to be caring +[261.600 --> 267.040] a larger case like this because it has to hold all of the temple clothing. This one's a little bit +[267.040 --> 272.800] more old school but some people have more just you know briefcases whatever there's no required +[272.800 --> 278.400] requirement. You go into the temple and your normal church clothes so you wouldn't see anyone dressed +[278.400 --> 285.280] in this outside. You go in and you change into this. You begin dressed in white and everyone can +[285.280 --> 292.320] kind of choose their own dress. Here's the dress that this this is actually was given to me for +[292.320 --> 298.240] this video so this is the dress that this person would have worn. This isn't the dress I wore but +[298.240 --> 303.280] it's very similar. It has to be to the wrists covering up to the collarbone and down to the ankle +[303.280 --> 311.360] so it covers your entire body. They usually have some sort of like just design or kind of I don't know +[312.000 --> 321.280] like lacyness. It usually has you know some level of elegance I guess attempted to add on to it. +[321.280 --> 329.760] You also have to be wearing these white shoes so men and women both wear white shoes. These are the +[329.760 --> 338.000] women's and then typically most dresses require a slip underneath. That's just so that the dress +[338.000 --> 344.080] doesn't see through. This is the slip that this dress came with and you can see it extends all the +[344.080 --> 349.760] way down to the ankles so it's meant to cover your entire body. Once you get dressed in white you go +[349.760 --> 355.360] and wait in a room to be welcomed into the endowment room so you wait in kind of a waiting room +[355.360 --> 360.000] area with your spouse or whoever you're attending with and then they welcome you into the endowment +[360.000 --> 365.280] room. When you enter you have to split men and women. Instead of one side women's and all the other +[365.280 --> 370.080] you're not allowed to sit next to your spouse you have to split in half. Say that they have changed +[370.080 --> 377.840] quite a bit of this ceremony. Over time it's gotten less and less intense. You used to have to +[377.840 --> 383.280] essentially promise to kill yourself if you were to reveal the secrets made in the temple. +[384.000 --> 390.720] Now however it's a lot lighter in a lot of ways. The promises are not so severe. The consequences +[390.720 --> 395.680] are not so severe and even some of the sexist aspects of the temple have been changed even since +[395.680 --> 401.680] I went. You can see I have not that old and I find the changes in the temple to be kind of +[401.680 --> 409.120] insulting at a level because you're told that this is the secret sacred tradition passed down +[409.120 --> 416.080] from generation to generation and that it is true in the sense that it is eternal. And so when +[416.080 --> 424.480] they make changes it feels a little to me thin, fake, ironic because this eternal temple ceremony +[424.480 --> 431.360] that is supposed to be like God all encompassing all important you know they just change you a lot. +[431.360 --> 435.520] So I always found that to be a little annoying and they've changed it several times even since I +[435.520 --> 441.360] was an active member. All that to say as I'm going through the descriptions just know they may be +[441.360 --> 447.520] changed ever so slight elements of this. For example when I went through women had to veil their +[447.520 --> 453.040] faces during certain portions. Apparently they've gotten rid of that and women used to have to +[453.040 --> 459.200] make promises to their spouses or their husbands. They apparently got rid of that but most of what I'm +[459.200 --> 465.200] about to tell you is very much still the case. This is what I experienced and this is still definitely +[465.200 --> 471.040] as far as the clothing goes and the signs and tokens and the the overall process of the temple. It's +[471.040 --> 476.960] still exactly the same. So if they've changed anything it's some of the wording some of the more like +[476.960 --> 482.800] nuance of the doctrine. It's not it's not the backbone of the ceremony. The entire endowment is +[482.800 --> 488.720] meant to teach you basically about the process of life through death and the promises you should make +[488.720 --> 493.920] and the purpose that your life has here on earth. The temple begins with a conversation about Adam +[493.920 --> 497.840] and Eve and has a script where they go through what it was like for Adam and Eve to be in the garden +[497.840 --> 503.920] of Eden. They do the whole creation. The the lights is created. The dark is created. The animals are +[503.920 --> 509.120] created and of course and ultimately lands on Adam and Eve. You're meant to draw the parallel +[509.120 --> 515.840] between you as a person and Adam and Eve. So I am kind of meant to put myself in Eve's shoes. +[515.840 --> 522.080] A man would put himself in Adam's shoes and these two characters basically are the prototypes +[522.080 --> 527.200] that you're meant to imagine yourself as as you go through the ceremony. As the story progresses +[527.200 --> 532.800] Adam and Eve are cast out of the garden of Eden and you put on your apron, this green apron, +[532.800 --> 537.840] which is meant to represent the garment given to Adam and Eve to cover their nakedness, the thick leaves. +[537.840 --> 542.320] I guess it talks about the Bible. I'll put the verse here. It's meant to represent that. They also +[542.320 --> 547.600] bring the garment which is the magic underwear, the sacred underwear and say that that garment too +[547.600 --> 553.600] is meant to represent the covering given to Adam and Eve to cover their nakedness. So it's definitely +[553.600 --> 560.640] about modesty and it's also to bringing back to the story of Adam and Eve and the garden of Eden. +[560.640 --> 565.040] As Adam and Eve are cast out of the garden of Eden, they meet different characters along the way. +[565.040 --> 570.480] They meet Peter James and John. They meet Satan and all of these kind of cast of characters are +[570.480 --> 574.880] meant to be teaching them or instructing them as they're out of the garden of Eden. As they're +[574.880 --> 579.440] telling the story of Adam and Eve being out of the garden of Eden, the ceremony pauses from time +[579.440 --> 586.320] to time so that you can learn the signs and tokens of the priesthood. These are the handshakes or +[586.320 --> 592.080] symbols or signs that they say you're going to need in order to get into heaven. And so that's why +[592.080 --> 598.800] these things are meant to be guarded very carefully and one of I would say the most offensive thing +[598.800 --> 605.200] you can do as a Mormon is to reveal these signs and tokens because nothing is considered more sacred +[605.200 --> 611.520] within Mormonism outside of the temple. And not just the temple, not just the clothing, but specifically +[611.520 --> 618.880] these handshakes and these tokens and signs and the words of the signs are considered the most sacred +[618.880 --> 625.040] aspect of Mormonism. If I die, I guess you'll know why I died because of this video. So I decided +[625.040 --> 631.600] to go extra hard for this video and I brought this little hand so that I can show you with with a +[631.600 --> 638.080] hand, you know, what these symbols or handshakes look like. So this will be my other hand and I'll show +[638.080 --> 643.600] you how the symbols are done and what you're supposed to do. So there are four different handshakes +[643.600 --> 650.000] you're taught and each handshake has the handshake itself, the name of the handshake, the and the +[650.000 --> 654.640] symbol of the handshake. The first you're taught during the endowment is the first token or sign of +[654.640 --> 660.000] the eronic priesthood. This is the first handshake you'll need to get into heaven. So take note. +[660.800 --> 666.320] The way you do it and the way they do it during the endowment is one of the ephichians. Usually man +[666.320 --> 674.000] comes around and gives everyone gives them the sign by doing handshake. So they literally go through +[674.000 --> 680.480] every row, at least this is how I remember it and they give this the handshake or the handshake +[680.480 --> 683.920] to you to teach you how to do it. There's the first one which is the first token or sign of the +[683.920 --> 688.080] eronic priesthood and the second one which has a similar name, the second token or sign of the +[688.080 --> 694.000] eronic priesthood and this hand shakes are very similar so I'll show you how they look. So when they +[694.000 --> 700.720] come around they'll do the handshake. For the first they put the thumb on the +[701.200 --> 709.600] joint of the pointer finger. So the person shaking my hand would put the thumb up on top of the +[709.600 --> 718.560] joint of the hand that they're shaking and to give it back I would put my thumb on the joint +[718.560 --> 725.360] of their hand. So basically you're just instead of you know with a true handshake they're coming in +[725.840 --> 732.560] you're placing the web of your finger between the other person's hand but for this the thumb +[732.560 --> 739.120] is very purposefully centered right on top of the joint. For the second token of the eronic priesthood +[739.120 --> 747.440] like I said it's fairly similar. For this one the thumb gets placed in the slot of the joint +[747.440 --> 753.360] between the pointer finger and the middle finger. So you kind of press down into that joint +[753.360 --> 758.960] into that valley and then I would do the same and that's the second token of the eronic priesthood. +[759.600 --> 764.240] And honestly when I went through the first time I was so confused because those two seemed so +[764.240 --> 770.240] similar and often two old people are the ones officiating and they have like fairly shaky hands +[770.240 --> 774.880] and so they kind of can struggle to like land directly onto your joint. So I remember being a +[774.880 --> 779.600] little confused because they're I just couldn't tell what the difference was and I felt really worried +[779.680 --> 783.120] like because these are supposed to be the most important things you can memorize and I was worried +[783.120 --> 788.880] that I didn't know it like it's not bad it seems like it should be bad if it's that serious. +[788.880 --> 793.840] So that's the first two. The third is called the first token of the melchemic priesthood +[793.840 --> 799.600] and you are familiar with these priesthoods before because growing up the people who passed the +[799.600 --> 804.160] sacrament or give blessings or the bishop they're either they either have the eronic priesthood or +[804.160 --> 808.560] they have the melchep and then they get the melchemic priesthood and they have both. So the names of +[808.560 --> 814.400] these priesthoods are fairly familiar. So for the third symbol is called it's the first open of +[814.400 --> 821.120] the melchemic priesthood or the sign of the nail. So and once you learn these handshakes kind of +[821.120 --> 825.840] as you're learning the handshakes you're also wearing the robes of the priesthood. Basically meant to +[825.840 --> 832.560] symbolize the adjure on this continuum of religious trek like you started as Adam and Eve you were +[832.560 --> 838.320] naked in the garden of Eden then you get your covering you have your garments your magic underwear +[838.720 --> 845.280] so all of this is meant to be viewed as a continuation onto heaven as you're making this almost +[845.280 --> 852.080] spiritual journey towards heaven. So each each new thing you learn is kind of meant to be like a step +[852.080 --> 857.440] of progression closer to God closer to heaven. When you would walk into the temple you'd have +[858.560 --> 863.920] this sort of packet so you'd be wearing your white dress or your white suit and then you'd be +[863.920 --> 869.520] carrying this packet and this has this would have the green apron in it the robes of the priesthood +[869.520 --> 874.560] and everything you'll need during the ceremony. So as you're receiving these hand signals you're also +[874.560 --> 881.120] getting your robes these are like these are the robes of the priesthood they call them I'll show you +[881.120 --> 888.640] some detail the men and women both get these same kind of robes and the ties are meant to tie around +[888.640 --> 896.160] the waist here so you would take your apron off put this on and then put the apron back on +[896.720 --> 902.960] and then you have a sash this is meant to go around your waist. Women and men are different I want +[902.960 --> 909.280] to get a men's version of the clothes for this video but unfortunately I didn't come through for +[909.280 --> 914.720] you on that I could only get a woman's version so maybe someday someone will send me I'll get +[914.720 --> 920.640] a men's version and then you can see that but men I'll show a picture of the hat that men get and +[920.640 --> 929.440] then women get the veil and you don't have a mirror anything so when you're putting this on for the +[929.440 --> 934.320] first time when you go through you're very overwhelmed and usually someone has to help you so here's +[934.320 --> 940.480] the the veil and then throughout the ceremony you can use this to veil your face just to just as a +[940.480 --> 945.360] pause as you're learning these hand signals you're also becoming more robed in these these +[945.840 --> 951.600] robes of the priesthood to kind of symbolize your progression along this religious path onto the +[951.600 --> 957.840] first token of the Melchizedek priesthood the sign of the nail so as you might expect the person +[957.840 --> 965.840] is meant to make a symbol of a nail on your head so or on your finger on your hand so what happens is +[966.480 --> 973.360] the person holding your hand basically is placing their pointer finger directly in your palm +[973.360 --> 980.080] where you might imagine the nail went on Jesus and then to pierce over on the other side the thumb +[980.960 --> 985.680] to pierce through your hand so that's meant to be the second token of the sorry the first token of +[985.680 --> 991.200] the Melchizedek priesthood the sign of the nail they basically are just pinching your hand and you're +[991.200 --> 996.560] just kind of supposed to take it the the person receiving it doesn't really do anything they just +[996.560 --> 1003.680] get the pitch and then we finally reach the most important or kind of the culmination is the fourth +[1003.680 --> 1009.200] of all of them the most I think I've always thought of it as like this is the grip that you do when +[1009.200 --> 1014.960] you get married so when you get married and you are kneeling across the altar you actually do this +[1015.520 --> 1021.760] in your marriage ceremony as well so this is to me the most important hand holds signal +[1022.640 --> 1028.000] and it's also the second token of the Melchizedek priesthood so the Melchizedek is more important +[1028.000 --> 1032.960] than the eronic so you're kind of like I said progressing up through these levels of understanding +[1032.960 --> 1040.960] these levels of importance to do the second second token of the Melchizedek priesthood and sometimes +[1040.960 --> 1047.520] me and my husband still do this to each other just to be funny um basically it's you match the +[1047.520 --> 1052.480] webs of your hand and that's just a kind of a normal handshake the only difference between this +[1052.480 --> 1059.120] and a normal handshake is that the finger is where the second nail would have pierced through Jesus's +[1059.520 --> 1068.720] hand so the pointer finger presses into the wrist here and then this person would also press their +[1068.720 --> 1076.160] finger into your own wrist to basically represent the second nail used to crucify Jesus Christ as you +[1076.160 --> 1081.120] receive each handshake you also are meant to make different promises and there are all these different +[1081.120 --> 1086.160] categories of promises like you promise to keep the law of chastity there's something called the +[1086.160 --> 1092.480] law of sacrifice I always I think it's most important to highlight the law of consecration which is a very +[1093.440 --> 1099.120] um to me crazy aspect of what you promise in the Mormon temple and it's what I think of when I +[1099.120 --> 1105.360] think of how many uh elected officials in Utah are Mormon because in the temple you promise to give +[1105.360 --> 1109.680] everything and consecrate everything and say that everything you possess from your life to your +[1109.680 --> 1116.400] family to your possessions is for the use of the church which I think to me could fall under the +[1116.400 --> 1122.320] realm of like political authority you're all you also basically have kind of promised that that +[1122.320 --> 1126.880] also belongs to the Mormon church so the prayer actually says the book of doctrine and covenants +[1126.880 --> 1132.000] and in the doctrine and covenants it also talks about the law of consecration and it says that you +[1132.000 --> 1136.240] do consecrate yourselves your time, talents and everything with which the Lord has blessed you +[1136.240 --> 1140.800] or with which he may bless you to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints for the building +[1140.800 --> 1146.160] up of the kingdom of God on earth and for the establishment of Zion so everything you have your +[1146.160 --> 1152.880] time, talents everything with which the Lord has blessed you is given symbolically during this +[1152.880 --> 1157.280] ceremony to the Mormon church I mean as a member when I was going through when I promised that I kind +[1157.280 --> 1163.280] of had already felt like I did that everything in my life was dedicated towards Mormonism but I +[1163.280 --> 1168.720] always felt like and still feel like for those elected officials and really for anyone that's why +[1168.720 --> 1173.120] people were kind of weird about Mitt Romney being president because you promise that everything +[1173.120 --> 1179.680] you have even your talents is for the church and so to have a president with this kind of separate +[1179.680 --> 1184.320] commitment it's a little it gets a little fuzzy morally once you're dressed in the full +[1184.320 --> 1189.360] robes of the temple you are ready for the prayer circle which is where you go from sitting down +[1189.360 --> 1197.920] up to the front and you alternate man woman man woman man woman and you stand around this sack of +[1197.920 --> 1204.080] names in the middle in the temple you can write the name of someone you want to have prayed for and +[1204.080 --> 1209.200] during the temple ceremony they pray for those names so if you've ever had an in law or a friend +[1209.200 --> 1214.080] offered to push your name on the temple rolls is what they usually call it this is what they're doing +[1214.080 --> 1219.680] they put it on a little piece of paper they put the paper in the bag and then they pray over it +[1219.680 --> 1226.240] during the endowment while everyone's wearing this clothing the prayer circle during the prayer +[1226.240 --> 1234.080] circle somebody says a prayer you say some recited words and at the end you put your hands up in the +[1234.080 --> 1240.000] air and say oh god here the word of my mouth three times your arm goes to the square and it's up +[1240.000 --> 1246.240] rested on the shoulder of the person next to you and then the other hand is used to hold hands +[1246.240 --> 1251.440] with the person next to you too in the patriarchal grip so you do the patriarchal grip with the person +[1251.440 --> 1256.960] next to you and then you have your arm on their shoulder at the square after the prayer circle you +[1256.960 --> 1262.320] are ready to progress through the veil so the entire ceremony been sitting in these benches +[1263.040 --> 1268.240] and up in front of you kind of like a pew you're sitting in a pew up but up in front of you is +[1268.240 --> 1274.560] this very tall white curtain and at the end of the prayer circle you're ready to progress +[1274.560 --> 1280.080] through to the veil I've always thought of the veil as a synoxis of the entire ceremony so +[1280.880 --> 1286.400] you get called up one at a time and you walk up with your same gender temple worker so for me it +[1286.400 --> 1293.360] was a woman for a man it would be a man and you say this very long recited prayer and you do all +[1293.360 --> 1301.360] the handshakes so there's a man behind the curtain he puts his hand through the curtain you grasp it +[1302.000 --> 1308.080] and then he asks you to show you know all the signs and symbols of the different handshakes you've +[1308.080 --> 1312.960] been learning throughout the endowment after you have said this recited prayer after you prove you +[1312.960 --> 1318.400] know what to say and honestly at the beginning they they just have the person next to you what's for +[1318.400 --> 1323.840] the name of or the correct recited words of the prayer into your ears so you don't really have to +[1323.840 --> 1327.920] know but I went enough that I memorized the whole thing I think most people do because you're meant +[1327.920 --> 1333.600] to go back and do this over and over again maybe once a month for the rest of your life then once +[1333.600 --> 1341.360] you prove when he does the patriarchal grip his arm comes through the curtain and hugs you +[1341.360 --> 1346.480] and you get pulled in and you're supposed to like put your armor on him so you're kind of in this +[1346.480 --> 1353.120] like patriarchal grip embrace and then he tells you the final name of the token which is very long +[1353.120 --> 1358.880] I will put it up here if you'd like to read it finally they say let her enter and that you get to +[1358.880 --> 1364.960] go through the curtain you're dressed in your whole temple clothes and you're you sit in something +[1364.960 --> 1368.480] called the celestial room so they pull you through the curtain and on the other side of the curtain +[1368.480 --> 1373.680] is what's called the celestial room the celestial room is this huge white room with white furniture +[1373.680 --> 1380.240] white carpet white ceilings white decorations everything is very white maybe gold as accents +[1380.240 --> 1385.680] or like cream as accents but it's meant to just be it's honestly a little like overwhelming and +[1385.680 --> 1392.400] it is pretty they make it very beautiful uh in kind of like a opulence hotel from the 80s kind of +[1392.400 --> 1397.680] white and you can see pictures I'll put a picture of it here so that you can see an example uh and +[1397.680 --> 1402.560] then once you're done it's supposed to symbolize you you made it to the celestial kingdom you made it +[1402.560 --> 1409.600] to heaven uh you did your job I guess um you met all the requirements and now you sit in the +[1409.600 --> 1416.240] celestial room and that's a place mostly to just contemplate and it's also the only time you're given +[1416.240 --> 1422.800] to discuss this ceremony you're not allowed to talk about it outside the temple at all even like +[1422.800 --> 1428.080] referencing it or kind of talking about it vaguely is really looked down upon and so this is kind of +[1428.080 --> 1436.960] your one opportunity your one shot to go and to talk and maybe share or ask questions uh and they +[1437.040 --> 1441.840] kind of hurried you along I think after maybe like 10 or 15 minutes you're not really supposed to stay +[1441.840 --> 1446.880] there for a long long time so you don't really get a lot of opportunity to have a discourse about +[1446.880 --> 1452.160] what just happened to you or not allowed to research it outside the temple um there's a lot of +[1452.160 --> 1457.840] questions so even if you do say like hey mom like why am I wearing a veil like can you tell me more +[1457.840 --> 1463.600] about the significance of this can you tell me what it meant when it said do xyz during the ceremony +[1464.080 --> 1469.440] the other person might be like I don't know honestly because I don't really have the ability to +[1469.440 --> 1474.960] research this outside the temple and all you have are the words of the ceremony itself to have as +[1474.960 --> 1482.640] like a concrete explanation which is still vague enough that I think a lot of people feel like they +[1482.640 --> 1488.560] don't understand the temple as much as they wish they did uh and it's often explained away as +[1488.560 --> 1494.240] symbolism but you might never really know what the symbolism is to me I always thought like the +[1494.240 --> 1499.920] involvement of Satan uh he's uh one of the main characters in the endowment was strange because +[1499.920 --> 1507.840] it's weird that Satan is in the temple but a lot of people also use it as like a rationale for why +[1509.200 --> 1513.520] why you go back to the temple why you have to go back all the time is because you'll hear people +[1513.520 --> 1518.480] be like I didn't really start to understand the endowment until I went for 10 years or 20 years +[1518.640 --> 1525.680] or 40 years or like I've finally started understanding what it meant after my 50th year or whatever +[1525.680 --> 1530.080] so it's meant as almost like this badge of honor to like not know because it's supposed to show that +[1530.080 --> 1535.200] you're open to receiving more light and knowledge which I thought was frustrating as I shared +[1535.200 --> 1541.440] me doing this video uh it's considered very disrespectful for most people most members um +[1542.080 --> 1547.760] there are videos online of people dancing in the clothes or wearing those Halloween costumes um +[1547.760 --> 1552.720] mostly I think it's important to talk about for several reasons first I think that anytime you're +[1552.720 --> 1557.520] told that you're not allowed to speak about something it's a sign that that idea is dangerous or +[1557.520 --> 1562.560] strange or weird and it's manipulative the idea that you can't even speak about something I find +[1562.560 --> 1569.920] to be very dangerous because uh I think free speech and education and just talking +[1570.960 --> 1576.480] uh really clears the air for a lot of people it helps you make choices I think every investigator +[1576.480 --> 1581.840] anyone looking to join the Mormon church should have access to this information uh if you want to +[1581.840 --> 1586.640] join and be baptized and become a Mormon I think you should see that this is what the ultimate +[1586.640 --> 1592.160] culmination of your entire Mormon experience is meant to push you towards that to me this is true +[1592.160 --> 1599.600] Mormonism garments temple clothing washing and anointing that is Mormonism not just loving Jesus +[1599.600 --> 1605.600] Mormons believe that this is the way you show you love Jesus and so I think education is very +[1605.600 --> 1613.040] important and I think the church purposefully obscures a lot of this information because I think +[1613.040 --> 1617.360] if people wore this to church every Sunday they'd have a hard time getting converts I mean they +[1617.360 --> 1622.560] already have a hard time getting converts because you can't have coffee I also think I want to talk +[1622.560 --> 1627.440] about this because I feel like I think more people should have access to information about the church +[1627.440 --> 1633.520] they belong to I get so many comments on these videos from teenagers or people who haven't seen this +[1633.520 --> 1639.920] part of the temple um like I haven't who say that I'm lying that this is made up that this is not +[1639.920 --> 1646.640] true and I think that they want to believe that because to them it's not true this doesn't exist +[1646.640 --> 1652.080] because they've never seen it they don't understand and their parents won't tell them about it for +[1652.080 --> 1657.280] sure and so I think just education in general is very helpful to help people make the choice if they +[1657.280 --> 1662.080] want to join the Mormon church to help people who are preparing to serve a mission to get married to +[1663.040 --> 1667.920] at least somewhat unbiased inner information about what happens in the temple obviously I did +[1667.920 --> 1673.600] leave the church I'm not sharing any of this because I want to purposefully dissuade someone or +[1673.600 --> 1678.560] even make fun of it I can think of countless ways I could make fun of this if I wanted but the +[1678.560 --> 1684.240] purpose of these videos that I was making is purely just to explain and to talk about my experience +[1684.240 --> 1688.800] and because I think if someone tells you that you don't have a voice that speaking itself is +[1688.800 --> 1694.640] disrespectful and that religion should have the ultimate level of deference and respect when +[1694.640 --> 1699.040] personally I don't think the church respects gay people I don't think the church respected +[1699.040 --> 1704.160] my autonomy I don't think the church even wanted women to have the right to vote they advocated +[1704.160 --> 1710.000] against that at the time and and so the idea that I should respect a religion that doesn't respect +[1710.000 --> 1714.720] others I think is a little backwards don't forget to subscribe to this channel I am soon going to +[1714.800 --> 1720.320] have a video where I talk about the initiatory and what it's like to get your garment and the ceremony +[1720.320 --> 1725.680] that is somewhat similar to this that you go to to get your garments so please don't forget to +[1725.680 --> 1731.360] subscribe and I hope that you all enjoyed please drop any clarifications or comments in the comment +[1731.360 --> 1740.080] section I'm sure as usual I will get at least a few angry comments so feel free to go see the +[1740.080 --> 1745.200] reactions there if you have a strong reaction to this video you know that's okay and you didn't +[1745.200 --> 1751.040] have to watch it but you did anyways if you were curious about this video please subscribe and I +[1751.040 --> 1753.520] will share more content like this diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_f0uTBaIbNTk.txt b/transcript/ceremony_f0uTBaIbNTk.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ed9208d3a33e2cd6abf3ff22bef1f00afd6333c2 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_f0uTBaIbNTk.txt @@ -0,0 +1,96 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.720] Hello and thank you for joining me this evening. +[4.720 --> 13.080] I have created this channel because I have the idea that perhaps creating a regular, semi-regular +[13.080 --> 18.560] video ceremonies for you and with you will be beneficial both to my practice because +[18.560 --> 21.800] it will bring me regularity in my daily life. +[21.800 --> 27.720] And also maybe for you because sometimes you cannot perform rituals or ceremonies yourself +[27.720 --> 35.120] and by maybe watching this video you will be able to attune onto the energy that I am +[35.120 --> 36.680] creating here in this room. +[36.680 --> 47.160] This is my studio and perhaps exude it into your own space and by using these videos you +[47.160 --> 53.520] may be will be able to expand your practice or get motivated to practice more or simply +[53.520 --> 59.040] you can relax and watch them before you go to sleep to just gently leave everything +[59.040 --> 61.880] kind and drift off. +[61.880 --> 67.280] I know I do watch these kinds of videos myself so I know how relaxing it can be even though +[67.280 --> 70.280] you are not participating in a moment. +[70.280 --> 76.120] I thought we would start with a little cleansing ceremony to leave the previous week behind +[76.120 --> 77.120] us. +[77.120 --> 81.080] A lot of us have a lot of stress at work. +[81.080 --> 88.960] We have to feel and be productive a lot of times and it can be difficult and it can leave +[88.960 --> 95.300] a lot of residue on our shoulders and on our backs and for me for example it manifests +[95.300 --> 97.360] in back pains very often. +[97.360 --> 103.120] So I need to cleanse and I need to leave things behind me and just thank the lessons that +[103.120 --> 109.280] have been taught and move forward and create space for something new for new experiences +[109.280 --> 111.280] and new emotions. +[111.280 --> 116.800] I would say better things but in truth it is more different things than better things. +[116.800 --> 123.000] But different is better if the same thing no longer serves a purpose in your life. +[123.000 --> 131.160] So we would use these ceremonies every week or as often as I can make them to thank the +[131.160 --> 138.060] week before for the lessons it has taught us and to take them be grateful for them but +[138.060 --> 144.560] leave behind us along with any energies or emotions that we are carrying on our shoulders +[144.560 --> 149.240] that might not necessarily even be ours because we come into contact with a lot of people +[149.240 --> 152.000] and we live in very stressful times. +[152.000 --> 158.840] For this ceremony I have prepared a couple of different things that we are going to use. +[158.840 --> 163.880] And for me this is going to be in-sabs because I am very much into herbalism and herbs +[163.880 --> 170.640] and I tend to create a lot of instances for myself so we are going to be using lens and +[170.640 --> 174.240] incense stick that I have actually made myself. +[174.240 --> 182.440] But before we do I would like you to just close your eyes for a minute and breathe very deeply. +[182.440 --> 196.960] Relax, feel a weight on your shoulders but a weight of your own body and of your own +[196.960 --> 204.880] mass just sink into your chair or when you bed or wherever you are sitting and just breathe +[204.880 --> 214.440] deeply, ground yourself, ground your feet feel or you are touching the earth or the bed +[214.440 --> 219.640] or wherever you feel or just feel in touch with something solid that keeps you grounded +[219.640 --> 220.800] or on the ground. +[220.800 --> 234.080] Take a couple of deep breaths and with every breath feel that when you breathe out +[234.080 --> 244.640] you are releasing things that are too heavy for you or that are uncomfortable. +[244.640 --> 251.360] Any memories or any feelings that you have accumulated over the past week, any thoughts +[251.360 --> 257.440] that keep you awake before you go to bed because you cringe a little bit or you feel embarrassed +[257.440 --> 268.840] or you feel uncomfortable just breathe in energy and let out everything that weighs you down. +[268.840 --> 280.000] I am going to bring some incense for us to have a little gold that helps when you are +[280.000 --> 287.000] going to light up now. +[287.000 --> 295.000] I have a lighter than you but who knows? +[295.000 --> 313.000] I will make some lovely crackling sounds like fire. +[313.000 --> 331.000] Breathe for a minute and this lovely sensor is my favorite thing in the world. +[331.000 --> 339.000] What I have here are some pellets that will adjust the focus for you just a bit for a while. +[339.000 --> 346.000] Those are pellets made of a mix of herbs, woods and resins that I have grounded and then +[346.000 --> 366.000] steep and wine and honey and let dry in these little pieces and you are going to use a couple of them. +[366.000 --> 369.000] I will put this ceremony. +[369.000 --> 376.000] The recent weight, I will bring you back somewhere around here. +[376.000 --> 378.000] My focus is not even. +[378.000 --> 385.000] Oh, it's cool. +[385.000 --> 396.000] The reason why we are using incense is to fill the room with pleasant odors and according to some beliefs, +[396.000 --> 407.000] if you subscribe to the existence of spirits, malevolence spirits or malevolence energies do not appreciate pleasant smelling sense. +[407.000 --> 416.000] You can find a lot of stories about demons smelling like rotten eggs or sulfur. +[416.000 --> 429.000] I am not sure how much of that is true of course but the tale goes or the belief goes that if you are few made in the room with pleasant smelling odors, +[429.000 --> 436.000] malevolence entities and everything that may wish you are can not stand the pleasant sense. +[436.000 --> 445.000] So often in magic and in like witchcraft traditions, we do use witch who will perfume more incense to bless the room +[445.000 --> 453.000] and attract energies that are positive or energies that are beneficial to our intent or purpose. +[453.000 --> 456.000] This blend is a very universal one. +[456.000 --> 465.000] It has everything from herbs that are good for cleansing to herbs that are more consequential and more blessing type. +[465.000 --> 474.000] In the first part, we are of course cleansing the room but we also want to invite some positive things into our lives. +[474.000 --> 483.000] When we sweep up what is no longer needed, it is often very good to also fill the empty space that we have created. +[483.000 --> 488.000] That's through the reality with something pleasant. +[488.000 --> 494.000] I like to call it, we like to reserve the place for that that we want. +[494.000 --> 500.000] If you leave this length completely clean, anything can come into the space. +[500.000 --> 509.000] But if you make an intention for what the space is reserved for, then it is much easier to attract things that she would actually like. +[509.000 --> 520.000] So first we are cleansing but we are also using this incense to bless the room and bless our lives. +[520.000 --> 529.000] I almost grabbed my finger, that's all good. +[529.000 --> 543.000] While we are running incense, I will show you the beautiful, beautiful smoke from up close. +[543.000 --> 551.000] You can hear yourself in light and in a sense stick. If you like, or smell your favorite perfume or essential or anything. +[551.000 --> 567.000] And just imagine this smoke being representative of the positive energy that you are filling your space with and of a broom that is pushing away things that are no longer of service to you. +[567.000 --> 590.000] You can close your eyes again, breathe in loudly and loudly exhale, you can stay quiet, you can do whatever you feel is necessary for you to attune to the cleansing and to help release things that no longer serve you. +[597.000 --> 618.000] And then you can imagine that the smoke is developing your body and creating a shield like an egg. +[618.000 --> 628.000] So that your body and your heart is nested in warmth and sweetness and all the pleasant things. +[628.000 --> 639.000] Why honey and dates like there are in this incense? Can you feel cozy and relaxed? +[639.000 --> 653.000] There is nothing more trouble in you because everything is in the past and what isn't the past can be let go. +[653.000 --> 673.000] Imagine the incense with a broom and creating a blanket that keeps you safe but also keeps you warm and cozy and you are relaxed because nothing is burdening your shoulders anymore. +[673.000 --> 685.000] And you can feel your face muscles relax and your shoulders no longer carry that much weight. +[685.000 --> 695.000] And your neck is not tight and all the breaths you can take are full and delicious. +[700.000 --> 702.000] Can you feel it? +[708.000 --> 711.000] I'll be right back around here. +[711.000 --> 719.000] I will let the incense burn in front of us. +[721.000 --> 735.000] Thank you for joining me on my first video. I promised that I would do better but I needed to start somewhere and honestly it's been fun maybe next time I'll be more organized or prepared. +[735.000 --> 741.000] I have a better preparing for some time but it's going to be better. +[741.000 --> 749.000] So if you like this style of video, maybe stay with me and we can talk about more spiritual things. +[749.000 --> 764.000] I'm planning to do more weekly cleansings at a different style, maybe using different things so that every week around Friday or Saturday we can sit back together, look back and then of course look forward. +[764.000 --> 775.000] To the next weekend, to the new things that we can accomplish and she do have whatever it is that you desire. +[775.000 --> 786.000] So thank you for being with me and I will see you in the next video and if you like this maybe subscribe, give it a like or just like help me. +[786.000 --> 789.000] Have a good evening. +[789.000 --> 790.000] Bye. +[794.000 --> 796.000] Bye. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_faZbYfUXM8k.txt b/transcript/ceremony_faZbYfUXM8k.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a25c4484f05429297b5e7ea011d504157eb2a8ae --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_faZbYfUXM8k.txt @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.400] But the actual crowning of King Charles and Queen Camilla stood out significantly. +[4.400 --> 8.480] Bans got to witness the transformation of both the King and Queen as they received their +[8.480 --> 13.760] respective headpieces. Body Language expert Mark Bowden commented on the importance of this ritual, +[13.760 --> 14.400] saying, +[14.400 --> 19.680] The crowning of King Charles III and the Queen consort is a great example of non-verbal communication, +[19.680 --> 24.240] demonstrating how a single object can hold symbolic meaning far beyond its physical form. +[24.240 --> 27.360] Body Language expert Mark Bowden examined this tradition, +[27.360 --> 31.360] calling attention to the differences between King Charles and Queen Camilla's responses. +[31.360 --> 35.760] Bowden described King Charles III's calmness upon receiving the crown, saying, +[35.760 --> 40.080] When Charles receives the crown, his head is already slightly bowed, displaying reverence for +[40.080 --> 44.480] the lady's symbol he will bear. However, when the crown lands on Charles's head, he supports +[44.480 --> 49.040] its weight fully, perhaps displaying his commitment to the duty ahead. On the other hand, +[49.040 --> 53.440] Bowden explained that Queen Camilla's wobbly adjustments and hand motions were most likely due +[53.440 --> 56.000] to fear about the crown's steadiness. He said, +[56.000 --> 58.960] It is fair to say Charles shows more control and composure. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_j-lP0pREX-A.txt b/transcript/ceremony_j-lP0pREX-A.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9a2dee513de7aa02bc578e47356104832880559f --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_j-lP0pREX-A.txt @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ +[0.000 --> 2.000] 茶倒七分 +[2.000 --> 5.000] 留的三分是前面 +[7.000 --> 10.000] 我教你們沃碑的方式 +[10.000 --> 13.000] 我們女士在中國有陰肉之美 +[13.000 --> 16.000] 那麼男士有陽光之氣 +[16.000 --> 18.000] 那麼男士沃碑 +[18.000 --> 23.000] 我們用我們整個的手把它鑽住 +[23.000 --> 26.000] 你可以斷一下這個叫大拳在握 +[26.000 --> 29.000] 我們女士拿出兩根手指 +[29.000 --> 32.000] 然後再拖一下叫三樓護頂 diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_leoSb7iRJZg.txt b/transcript/ceremony_leoSb7iRJZg.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..239eab325ac1758caca49bb5279503b61fb7c75d --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_leoSb7iRJZg.txt @@ -0,0 +1,219 @@ +[30.000 --> 52.180] dill +[52.180 --> 58.180] Добрый, хороший вечер. +[64.180 --> 68.180] Насколько хороший вечер. +[68.180 --> 70.180] Можете вас. +[82.180 --> 93.180] Сегодня после долгого рабочего дня +[94.180 --> 101.180] Попыт сами с собой. +[110.180 --> 112.180] Втяжение. +[112.180 --> 114.180] Спокойств. +[118.180 --> 121.180] Лёгкий свой город, а загноб. +[123.180 --> 128.180] Майл любимое масло. +[129.180 --> 134.180] Майл любимое масло. +[152.180 --> 156.180] Приятной свежая часа. +[157.180 --> 161.180] Майл любимое масло. +[161.180 --> 165.180] Продисывают все участки. +[165.180 --> 168.180] Одела. +[168.180 --> 171.180] Разлапится. +[171.180 --> 176.180] И успокоится. +[176.180 --> 178.180] Спокойно. +[178.180 --> 182.180] Звыстояние. +[182.180 --> 185.180] Разлавленное, спокойное. +[185.180 --> 188.180] Звыстояние. +[188.180 --> 194.180] Все будет хорошо. +[194.180 --> 201.180] А все будет хорошо. +[201.180 --> 206.180] Спокойно. +[207.180 --> 211.180] Дише. +[211.180 --> 214.180] Дише. +[214.180 --> 216.180] Спокойно. +[216.180 --> 220.180] Хорошо. +[226.180 --> 231.180] Почувствуйте аромат. +[231.180 --> 234.180] Прикамот. +[234.180 --> 237.180] Вчувствуйте. +[237.180 --> 241.180] Почувствуйте ароматы. +[241.180 --> 243.180] Масло. +[243.180 --> 245.180] Приятная. +[245.180 --> 250.180] Раслабляет вас. +[250.180 --> 253.180] Все спокойно. +[253.180 --> 257.180] Хорошо. +[257.180 --> 260.180] Зайкроете глаза. +[260.180 --> 263.180] Подумайте. +[263.180 --> 266.180] Счастливый вы. +[266.180 --> 270.180] Что для вас счастье? +[270.180 --> 275.180] Есть ли счастье у вас? +[275.180 --> 281.180] Получатель вы радости от жизни. +[284.180 --> 286.180] Как счастлив? +[286.180 --> 289.180] Подумайте. +[289.180 --> 292.180] Как счастлив? +[292.180 --> 295.180] Представляете ли вы? +[295.180 --> 298.180] Себе? +[298.180 --> 303.180] Хороший приятный момент? +[303.180 --> 308.180] Или находитесь бесконечно? +[308.180 --> 312.180] Подоги мысли? +[313.180 --> 318.180] У вас обременяет. +[318.180 --> 322.180] Которые не доведва. +[322.180 --> 326.180] Жить спокойно. +[326.180 --> 330.180] И радостно. +[331.180 --> 333.180] Так. +[336.180 --> 339.180] Как можно? +[339.180 --> 343.180] Быстро момент. +[343.180 --> 348.180] Получите счастье? +[348.180 --> 352.180] Зайкроете глаза. +[352.180 --> 356.180] Глубоко. +[356.180 --> 359.180] Подохните его. +[359.180 --> 362.180] Подохните воздух. +[362.180 --> 365.180] Сделайте. +[365.180 --> 367.180] Глубоки. +[367.180 --> 370.180] Вудох. +[370.180 --> 373.180] И планы. +[373.180 --> 376.180] Выйдах. +[376.180 --> 381.180] Наплютайте со своим дыханием. +[381.180 --> 384.180] Отпустите. +[384.180 --> 387.180] Аж мысли. +[387.180 --> 390.180] Созредо точутесь. +[390.180 --> 393.180] Наваш. +[393.180 --> 396.180] Ныгане. +[396.180 --> 399.180] Зайкроете глаза. +[399.180 --> 403.180] Почувствуйте. +[403.180 --> 407.180] Как ваши дела? +[407.180 --> 411.180] Раслабляется. +[411.180 --> 415.180] Начинаю. +[416.180 --> 419.180] Смакушики головы. +[419.180 --> 424.180] Плавно. +[424.180 --> 431.180] Вниз чувствуйте расслабление. +[431.180 --> 434.180] Ожидел. +[434.180 --> 437.180] Раслабли. +[437.180 --> 441.180] Закроете глаза. +[442.180 --> 445.180] Ты жить глупоко. +[445.180 --> 447.180] Испокойно. +[447.180 --> 450.180] Раслабли. +[450.180 --> 454.180] Во всё хорошо. +[454.180 --> 462.180] Мысленно вспомнить. +[462.180 --> 467.180] Самый приятный момент ваш жизнь. +[467.180 --> 472.180] Когда выплее. +[472.180 --> 475.180] Поистин счастлив. +[475.180 --> 482.180] Безсопотный момент. +[482.180 --> 489.180] Которым приятный свет. +[489.180 --> 491.180] Пронизву. +[491.180 --> 494.180] Всё ваша дела. +[494.180 --> 498.180] Вставляя радоваться. +[498.180 --> 502.180] Часть вашего организма. +[502.180 --> 504.180] Мовемка. +[504.180 --> 507.180] Каждый клет. +[507.180 --> 510.180] Вашего организма. +[510.180 --> 513.180] Был отлипомнен. +[513.180 --> 515.180] Часть. +[515.180 --> 521.180] Радость. +[521.180 --> 524.180] Смакушики. +[524.180 --> 530.180] Самый приятный момент. +[530.180 --> 533.180] Мысленно. +[533.180 --> 536.180] Климеститесь. +[536.180 --> 539.180] В том кновении. +[539.180 --> 542.180] Где вы чувствовали. +[542.180 --> 545.180] Это бескраничная шесть. +[545.180 --> 548.180] Мысленно. +[548.180 --> 551.180] Вспомните. +[551.180 --> 554.180] Ощущение. +[554.180 --> 557.180] Радость. +[557.180 --> 562.180] Спокойно. +[562.180 --> 568.180] Улыбнитесь. +[568.180 --> 576.180] Жироко. +[576.180 --> 578.180] Искренне. +[578.180 --> 582.180] Улыбайтесь. +[582.180 --> 584.180] Пусть улыбка. +[584.180 --> 587.180] Наполнить вас. +[587.180 --> 591.180] Омер тварянести. +[591.180 --> 594.180] Вы в соне. +[594.180 --> 597.180] Компорта. +[597.180 --> 600.180] Вы вместе. +[600.180 --> 603.180] Где вам хорошо. +[603.180 --> 606.180] Спокойно. +[606.180 --> 609.180] Где вы счастливы. +[609.180 --> 613.180] Улыбайтесь. +[613.180 --> 617.180] Улыбайтесь. +[617.180 --> 620.180] Ведь у вас. +[620.180 --> 623.180] Хорошо. +[623.180 --> 628.180] Радость. +[628.180 --> 634.180] Шесть. +[634.180 --> 640.180] Улыбайтесь. +[664.180 --> 670.180] Улыбайтесь. +[670.180 --> 676.180] Улыбайтесь. +[676.180 --> 682.180] Улыбайтесь. +[682.180 --> 688.180] Улыбайтесь. +[688.180 --> 694.180] Улыбайтесь. +[694.180 --> 700.180] Улыбайтесь. +[700.180 --> 706.180] Улыбайтесь. +[706.180 --> 712.180] Закройте глаза. +[712.180 --> 716.180] Почувствуйте. +[716.180 --> 720.180] Приятные терпки. +[720.180 --> 724.180] Орамат масл. +[724.180 --> 728.180] Почувствуйте. +[728.180 --> 732.180] Приятный вкусный. +[732.180 --> 737.180] Приятный аромат масл. +[737.180 --> 740.180] Закройте глаза. +[740.180 --> 746.180] Почувствуйте. +[770.180 --> 776.180] Приятный вкусный. +[776.180 --> 781.180] Приятные вкусные. +[781.180 --> 788.180] При static. +[788.180 --> 792.180] Приятный вкусный. +[792.180 --> 798.180] Приятный вкусный. +[798.180 --> 806.180] Выставите с уроком белик. +[806.180 --> 810.180] На пляже. +[810.180 --> 814.180] С белым. +[814.180 --> 818.180] Красивым. +[818.180 --> 822.180] И смотрите. +[822.180 --> 826.180] Колесонт. +[826.180 --> 832.180] Вас окружает прекрасный. +[832.180 --> 838.180] Вас звуки. +[838.180 --> 842.180] Слышите. +[842.180 --> 848.180] Волны. +[848.180 --> 852.180] Вам хорошо. +[852.180 --> 856.180] Комфортно. +[856.180 --> 860.180] Типло. +[860.180 --> 864.180] Уйлотно. +[864.180 --> 868.180] Почувствуйте. +[868.180 --> 872.180] Как левкий ветер. +[872.180 --> 874.180] С красивого. +[874.180 --> 876.180] Без крайничного. +[876.180 --> 880.180] На гиана. +[880.180 --> 884.180] Залёгкость. +[884.180 --> 886.180] Почекочат. +[886.180 --> 890.180] Ваши. +[890.180 --> 894.180] Врухи. +[894.180 --> 896.180] Вы чувствуете. +[896.180 --> 898.180] Врухи. +[898.180 --> 900.180] Приятный вкусный. +[900.180 --> 904.180] Обостых. +[904.180 --> 908.180] Наполнен. +[908.180 --> 912.180] Злиг. +[912.180 --> 914.180] Залёны. +[914.180 --> 916.180] Приятный. +[916.180 --> 920.180] Ромат. +[920.180 --> 924.180] Вам хорошо. +[924.180 --> 928.180] Втagnите. +[928.180 --> 932.180] Клубоко. +[932.180 --> 936.180] Востых. +[936.180 --> 940.180] Сделайте. +[940.180 --> 944.180] Клубоки. +[944.180 --> 946.180] Втох. +[946.180 --> 950.180] Имеленный выдох. +[950.180 --> 952.180] Вырослаблен. +[952.180 --> 954.180] Счастлив. +[954.180 --> 956.180] Вам хорошо. +[956.180 --> 960.180] Увыпайтесь. +[960.180 --> 964.180] Увыпайтесь. +[986.180 --> 990.180] Высчастлив. +[990.180 --> 994.180] Хорошо. +[994.180 --> 998.180] Дива. +[998.180 --> 1002.180] Увыпайтесь. +[1002.180 --> 1006.180] Увыпайтесь. +[1006.180 --> 1010.180] Увыпайтесь. +[1010.180 --> 1014.180] Увыпайтесь. +[1014.180 --> 1018.180] Увып продолж dachte. +[1018.180 --> 1022.180] Увыпайтесь. +[1022.180 --> 1042.940] 忘rats +[1042.940 --> 1046.940] а вот возвращаемся +[1048.940 --> 1050.940] возвращаемся +[1055.940 --> 1057.940] расслаблю +[1058.940 --> 1060.940] дело расслаблю +[1072.940 --> 1074.940] возвращаемся +[1102.940 --> 1104.940] возвращаемся diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_mVJmIjWGlj0.txt b/transcript/ceremony_mVJmIjWGlj0.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..909666f6d9ab723f45afd438138dc5159b29f20d --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_mVJmIjWGlj0.txt @@ -0,0 +1,33 @@ +[0.000 --> 2.000] itation. +[2.000 --> 4.720] Sylwch gwybod m 감 cyfeu'r Cam de Singer +[4.720 --> 7.920] Gr死agna Feelsiana Conel +[7.920 --> 9.940] I TYters™ +[9.940 --> 11.380] DU SE better +[11.380 --> 13.020] Gr optisau, +[13.020 --> 14.220] boostia太ib +[14.220 --> 16.000] worawio wrth gynhar trwit +[16.000 --> 17.900] Gr soblen +[17.900 --> 22.840] IU +[22.840 --> 26.240] populael ei ydyu +[26.240 --> 27.740] stregnin, +[27.740 --> 29.840] chy número y chi'n ador +[29.840 --> 35.080] i usch i fafsieherat zureud i genud rhwyglookauedd dwna ceffernulau'r rhywun +[35.080 --> 48.560] ac sydd hynny, ac i bod yn rhywun fort ond ddoedd ar gympeni Dip haltazioard, +[48.560 --> 55.520] I am now by inviting Christine Mum Moiah, up to tie the first ribbre. +[67.680 --> 72.200] Can I now invite Jonathan's mum Linda to tie the next ribbre? +[78.560 --> 88.260] A nyau go��세요 Ephor ac Ys¼ +[89.320 --> 91.120] Pam? +[92.200 --> 94.940] Yn cael big handle at gael 모en cael ddap yadel, +[95.380 --> 99.940] unень sy'n cei a nostraidol arnt, +[100.360 --> 104.860] o dychaf yma y much brytyd anonŵst farm avath. +[104.860 --> 108.860] I fwy unmegwaith. +[108.860 --> 118.860] Dios, Dios. +[118.860 --> 120.860] Cys Davison. +[120.860 --> 124.860] I fwy wedi rhoi chi i'n Cys Davison visitnu inertio consistency +[124.860 --> 126.860] i leti bumagdorilluylli jadyn g Regentas Jewwch OW Day is +[126.860 --> 128.860] as ylwch budd whaleim yn amlailwch gallwch +[128.860 --> 132.860] mewn ond yn y dimond a mynd ar rydym ynmef run +[132.860 --> 139.680] Wh0o +[140.080 --> 148.860] Aana AA +[150.860 --> 151.360] Dynichan +[151.360 --> 152.260] GD diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_taffI9MYEcY.txt b/transcript/ceremony_taffI9MYEcY.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..46ac7d8166d5a6907ae160945ba9d1be137f59e7 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_taffI9MYEcY.txt @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +[0.000 --> 7.000] Batsun Sumo's top division begin the Yorkasuna Ring entering ceremony. +[7.000 --> 12.000] Kachirochi, kai seed. +[12.000 --> 19.000] Included are wishes for a rich harvest. +[19.000 --> 41.000] It's believed dayaties dwell in the white rope around the Yorkasuna's waist. +[41.000 --> 48.000] Making the rope known as a sin requires the combined strength of many rickships. +[49.000 --> 51.000] Each tuna is custom made. +[51.000 --> 58.000] The longest measures 4.5 meters and weighs over 20 kilograms. +[58.000 --> 67.000] Six rickships work together to fasten the rope. +[67.000 --> 71.000] There are two styles of Yorkasuna Ring entering ceremonies. +[71.000 --> 74.000] Here is the Shira Newi style. +[74.000 --> 84.000] Spreading the arms wide emphasizes the attack. +[84.000 --> 87.000] There is also the Umiw style. +[87.000 --> 90.000] The left arm is bent, the right extended. +[90.000 --> 96.000] This pose signifies simultaneous defense and attack. +[96.000 --> 99.000] Upon promotion of Yorkasuna chooses one style. +[99.000 --> 106.000] It learns from a more senior Yorkasuna, so he'll be ready to perform the ceremony. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_udcnWJOtq5s.txt b/transcript/ceremony_udcnWJOtq5s.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1f7cdab70119639c95ea8372be83e0df00938511 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_udcnWJOtq5s.txt @@ -0,0 +1,148 @@ +[0.000 --> 17.000] Today's video is filmed in Oru, a popular hotel that offers a pleasurable experience for couples. +[17.000 --> 29.000] Every room has a design in a different team, Indian, Cuban, Russian and my personal favorite. +[29.000 --> 51.000] Japanese, every room is linked with a different story that guides you through different and exciting activities, such as bonding, poem reading, massage, and traditional machete preparing. +[81.000 --> 95.000] Japanese way then means that the tea is going to be machete. +[95.000 --> 111.000] It is usual to make the tea thick or thin, depending on how much you want to add of the machete of work. +[111.000 --> 120.000] So hopefully you will enjoy this lovely and tasty tea. +[120.000 --> 127.000] Lovely tasty tea and lovely ritual. +[127.000 --> 149.000] So let's start off with a first taking a little bit of water, a little bit of water, and supposing it into the bottle. +[149.000 --> 169.000] Perfect. Now we are going to take this beautiful brush and clean the walls. +[179.000 --> 193.000] Making a traditional Japanese tea. +[209.000 --> 228.000] Here is a process that is known for a really, really long time. +[240.000 --> 263.000] Great. It is very polite to follow the rule of right, left and right, which means you take the thing with your right hand, then you support it with your left hand and return it with your right hand. +[263.000 --> 270.000] It is a very polite way to do things in Japan. +[270.000 --> 297.000] So now that we have this, we will take, now that we have this, we will clean the walls and also this. +[301.000 --> 308.000] A little bit of it. Now put it back. +[308.000 --> 313.000] Prepare the machete. +[314.000 --> 338.000] We may want about one and a half of the scoop. +[338.000 --> 362.000] We are going to make really thin and just easily do our just wall and how to do the wall. +[363.000 --> 369.000] Let's apply some water. +[369.000 --> 375.000] Perfect. A little bit more. +[375.000 --> 382.000] And now we will start whisking again. +[406.000 --> 426.000] And now we are going to whisk really fast. +[426.000 --> 436.000] To get the consistency. +[436.000 --> 448.000] There will be some small bubbles. +[448.000 --> 455.000] Perfect. +[455.000 --> 459.000] Good. +[459.000 --> 474.000] Now what you can do is actually small to tea and you can drink it if you want to. +[474.000 --> 478.000] Yes. +[478.000 --> 499.000] There are very much antioxidants and antioxidants in this tea and it's really good for your health. +[499.000 --> 509.000] It smells a little bit like a sea and a fish. +[509.000 --> 513.000] It smells really good. +[513.000 --> 520.000] It's not really pleasant smell for everyone definitely. +[520.000 --> 524.000] Do you want a smell too? +[524.000 --> 526.000] Okay, there you go. +[526.000 --> 528.000] Can you feel it? +[528.000 --> 530.000] Yeah, you don't like it? +[530.000 --> 531.000] That's good. +[531.000 --> 533.000] It smells more. +[533.000 --> 539.000] Yeah, good. +[539.000 --> 542.000] Would you like to taste it? +[542.000 --> 545.000] Okay. +[545.000 --> 549.000] Just try it. +[549.000 --> 553.000] Yes. +[553.000 --> 556.000] Good. +[556.000 --> 559.000] Not that bad right? +[559.000 --> 567.000] I personally love it. +[567.000 --> 570.000] Good. +[570.000 --> 579.000] And now that I have drank cold tea and you did too, +[579.000 --> 588.000] I will clean the bowl again. +[588.000 --> 600.000] You will take out water. +[600.000 --> 614.000] And slowly get it to all the edges. +[614.000 --> 618.000] Perfect. +[618.000 --> 636.000] You can take this whisking tool again. +[666.000 --> 690.000] Of course, I didn't do it 100% directly since I do the other tools that are needed for this. +[690.000 --> 697.000] It's really important. +[697.000 --> 703.000] The good thing is that you are enjoying this session. +[703.000 --> 708.000] And I do too. +[708.000 --> 712.000] So how did it feel? +[712.000 --> 716.000] And how do you feel right now? +[716.000 --> 719.000] Okay, that's good. +[719.000 --> 725.000] Yes, I'm okay. +[725.000 --> 732.000] Yeah, you actually should feel this energetic. +[732.000 --> 733.000] Yes. +[733.000 --> 737.000] Let me just... +[737.000 --> 747.000] Let me just touch your face now and let you fall. +[747.000 --> 753.000] And let you fall asleep. +[753.000 --> 758.000] As there's your first time, +[758.000 --> 766.000] okay, I mean, like doing this ritual, participating in it. +[766.000 --> 771.000] And... +[771.000 --> 776.000] Just genuinely enjoying my presence. +[776.000 --> 778.000] Okay, good. +[778.000 --> 781.000] Good. +[781.000 --> 791.000] Good. +[791.000 --> 799.000] If you would like to see how the real ritual looks like, +[799.000 --> 808.000] I would recommend you to go to not very famous ASMR Tuesday. +[808.000 --> 813.000] Her name is Alidesu. +[813.000 --> 816.000] And she lives in Japan. +[816.000 --> 821.000] And there she is attending the ritual herself. +[821.000 --> 826.000] And she is told how to do it. +[826.000 --> 833.000] She is told how to do it. +[833.000 --> 837.000] And it's just genuinely just so relaxing. +[837.000 --> 842.000] And this video was inspired by it. +[842.000 --> 847.000] And you are doing the ritual ceremony. +[847.000 --> 852.000] Usually, I have something sweet. +[852.000 --> 861.000] Something sweet. +[861.000 --> 868.000] Usually, I have something sweet that you actually eat before the day. +[868.000 --> 873.000] I should go along with the tea just perfectly. +[873.000 --> 875.000] Just perfectly. +[875.000 --> 882.000] And you eat it before because of one simple reason. +[882.000 --> 887.000] Because of one simple reason. +[887.000 --> 897.000] And that is that the day should be the main course of... +[898.000 --> 901.000] of the ceremony. +[901.000 --> 907.000] So, you do not finish with the sweet right. +[907.000 --> 917.000] You finish with the day because that's the dessert in this particular situation. +[917.000 --> 923.000] You have there little much today on your chin right there. +[923.000 --> 925.000] Perfect. +[925.000 --> 927.000] Good. +[927.000 --> 929.000] Good. +[929.000 --> 931.000] Good. +[931.000 --> 933.000] Good. +[933.000 --> 937.000] Good. +[937.000 --> 945.000] Yes, some people find it disgusting right when it just... +[945.000 --> 947.000] kind of... +[947.000 --> 949.000] It's pilled. +[949.000 --> 951.000] I do not know how to say it. +[951.000 --> 954.000] Like when you like your finger and touch someone's face. +[954.000 --> 959.000] I think it's really intimate. +[959.000 --> 964.000] I would say, yeah. +[974.000 --> 976.000] Okay. +[976.000 --> 978.000] Okay. +[979.000 --> 983.000] Now let me just pluck. +[983.000 --> 985.000] pluck. +[985.000 --> 988.000] pluck. +[988.000 --> 991.000] pluck. +[991.000 --> 993.000] pluck. +[993.000 --> 995.000] pluck. +[995.000 --> 999.000] pluck. +[999.000 --> 1002.000] All you need to get a energy weight. +[1002.000 --> 1004.000] Perfect. +[1005.000 --> 1007.000] Perfect. +[1007.000 --> 1010.000] So, this is the process. +[1010.000 --> 1016.000] Then you actually clean the utensils once again when... +[1016.000 --> 1021.000] even though you clean them right here. +[1021.000 --> 1024.000] pluck. +[1024.000 --> 1027.000] pluck. +[1027.000 --> 1030.000] Let me just... +[1031.000 --> 1033.000] pluck. +[1033.000 --> 1036.000] pluck. +[1036.000 --> 1039.000] pluck. +[1039.000 --> 1042.000] Let me just... +[1042.000 --> 1046.000] pluck. +[1046.000 --> 1049.000] pluck. +[1049.000 --> 1052.000] You like just... +[1052.000 --> 1055.000] you like to slap you. +[1055.000 --> 1058.000] Good. +[1059.000 --> 1062.000] Clean. +[1064.000 --> 1067.000] Clean. +[1089.000 --> 1093.000] I didn't enjoy this vision. +[1093.000 --> 1097.000] Because I guess not... +[1097.000 --> 1099.000] video of my... +[1099.000 --> 1102.000] like the name. +[1102.000 --> 1104.000] I have a wonderful... +[1104.000 --> 1107.000] I have a wonderful rest of... +[1107.000 --> 1116.000] I have a wonderful rest. +[1117.000 --> 1123.000] After night or day when I've been watching this video. +[1123.000 --> 1127.000] And see you another time. +[1127.000 --> 1130.000] Bye. +[1130.000 --> 1133.000] Bye. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_w3LE6UusNAQ.txt b/transcript/ceremony_w3LE6UusNAQ.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a625115535c83f3957d16954edaade0d07eec2be --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_w3LE6UusNAQ.txt @@ -0,0 +1,135 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.960] It's amazing how many battle language details you can get from just a few minutes of footage. +[4.960 --> 10.100] But in the case of Harry and Meghan's wedding, this 9-second clip shows so many signals +[10.100 --> 12.100] that it deserves a deep analysis. +[21.280 --> 23.200] Welcome back, my battle language bodies. +[23.200 --> 24.800] My name is Jesus and Rekir Rosas. +[24.800 --> 28.960] I'm the battle language guy, and it will be great if you join us by just liking this +[28.960 --> 31.360] video, subscribing and hitting that bell. +[31.360 --> 33.120] Let's get down to it. +[33.120 --> 38.880] This clip is so fascinating because it includes perfect examples of battle language signals +[38.880 --> 45.120] that are analysing other videos, including the marker claw, the marker mask, and Harry's +[45.120 --> 47.440] obsession with his wedding ring. +[47.440 --> 51.640] And these are the kind of signals that are extremely hard to spot on the fly and the +[51.640 --> 57.000] only way to dissect them is watching the clip in high resolution slow motion. +[57.000 --> 62.120] Now the first thing that you should notice is Meghan's resting face, as you can spot +[62.120 --> 64.920] on the very first frame of this clip. +[64.920 --> 70.160] As a face she wanted to show the world, and to give her some credit, she had a very pleasant +[70.160 --> 71.800] smile at that moment. +[71.800 --> 75.160] It doesn't look forced at all and looks very balanced. +[75.160 --> 80.760] Then she lowers her gaze to look at Harry's hand while she puts the wedding ring. +[80.760 --> 85.520] That's still in the deal, and I bet she could not be more excited at that moment. +[85.520 --> 90.520] And so she manages to keep her composure and show another well balanced smile. +[90.520 --> 96.880] It's a bit more intense than her prior resting face, and of course it must be thanks to +[96.880 --> 98.480] the emotion of the moment. +[98.480 --> 105.080] So we are 3 seconds in, just 6 seconds left, and thanks to whoever was directing the camera +[105.080 --> 108.840] angles we have the privilege to spot what happened next. +[108.840 --> 113.760] She was still holding Harry's left hand with her left hand, and at the same time she +[113.760 --> 116.520] was placing her right hand over. +[116.520 --> 119.600] This was not Meghan trying to show her ring. +[119.600 --> 124.600] This was actually the camera director's idea to include a shot of their hands, so we could +[124.600 --> 129.480] see that bonding moment, possibly the most important part of any wedding. +[129.480 --> 134.360] But then she lets go with her left hand, and at the same time her right hand tries to +[134.360 --> 138.760] circle Harry's hand, with the intention of grabbing it. +[138.760 --> 144.280] You can clearly spot in this exact frame the Marco claw trying to do its thing, but +[144.280 --> 149.920] Harry deflects the claw and Meghan's hands keep hovering a few frames until she decides +[149.920 --> 151.320] to drop it. +[151.320 --> 154.560] Now you might be thinking, no big deal right? +[154.560 --> 157.560] What could happen in just 4 seconds left? +[157.560 --> 159.720] Well you'll be surprised. +[159.720 --> 165.000] When we go back to the plane where we can see Harry and Meghan's faces, we see a huge +[165.000 --> 167.640] difference between both attitudes. +[167.640 --> 172.040] Harry has a slight smile on his face, that's good, he feels great about already having +[172.040 --> 176.120] the wedding ring on his finger, but what about Meghan? +[176.120 --> 182.400] That balance smile just disappeared, and she's tilting her head down despite the archbishop +[182.400 --> 184.160] looking in her direction. +[184.160 --> 189.200] I cannot say that he was looking directly at her, but his head's direction is enough +[189.200 --> 194.160] to realize that Meghan could, at least, establish eye contact with him. +[194.160 --> 199.680] But before I explain what is going to happen with Meghan's face in just half a second, +[199.680 --> 204.640] you can't help but notice that Harry hasn't had his wedding ring for… what? +[204.640 --> 208.760] 3, 4 seconds, and he already reaches out to touch it. +[208.760 --> 212.880] If you've been following my videos, you already know that Harry touching his wedding ring +[212.880 --> 216.320] is already a gesture that he does when he is nervous. +[216.320 --> 219.040] And that's almost all the time. +[219.040 --> 224.520] But here you are looking at the absolute first instance of that gesture right at the wedding +[224.520 --> 225.520] itself. +[225.520 --> 229.360] Now, back to Meghan's facial expression, she doesn't just keep her head down. +[229.360 --> 234.640] She's going to show three signals on her face, and we're going to review them one by +[234.640 --> 235.640] one. +[235.640 --> 240.000] This time I'm going to include various sizes of her facial expression, because when you +[240.000 --> 245.120] really zoom in a video that doesn't have enough quality, it could be actually harder +[245.120 --> 247.560] to spot this kind of movements. +[247.560 --> 251.760] And this is the original footage from the Royal Family Channel, so this is the first +[251.760 --> 253.560] version out there. +[253.560 --> 263.480] Watch the clip in slow motion and try to define what is going on, especially with her mouth. +[263.480 --> 277.280] Yeah, at first you see that despite her previous smile, it's absolutely gone. +[277.280 --> 278.280] Her face is relaxed. +[278.280 --> 285.160] There's a neutral expression, or no expression at all if you feel like calling it that way. +[285.160 --> 290.240] But just as please second later, she displays a sign of covert anger. +[290.240 --> 293.320] She presses her lips and clenches her jaw. +[293.320 --> 298.440] In cases like this, where you have to make it from a low quality video, it helps to know +[298.440 --> 303.760] that when you press your lips, the corners tend to disappear a little and the mouth looks +[303.760 --> 305.200] a bit smaller. +[305.200 --> 309.040] You know that's something that you can spot despite the video quality. +[309.040 --> 314.160] Right after that, I think Megan noticed that she was having this facial display of covert +[314.160 --> 315.320] anger. +[315.320 --> 319.840] Since she being an actress as part of her jaw being self aware of the emotions that she +[319.840 --> 325.240] displays on her face, as she tries to pull her lips backwards, like trying to relax +[325.240 --> 326.320] her face. +[326.320 --> 331.280] The problem is that we already know what does her relaxed face looks like, and this is +[331.280 --> 332.280] not like it. +[332.280 --> 335.800] This is her trying to hide that covert anger. +[335.800 --> 340.520] This facial details could be hard to spot, but you can refine your observation skills +[340.520 --> 344.760] with my 100-barrel language tips and you can download right in the description of this +[344.760 --> 345.760] video. +[345.760 --> 351.480] But there was only one thing that could soften her facial expression and it's what happened +[351.480 --> 352.800] next. +[352.800 --> 357.560] It's obvious that Megan's covert anger expression was a reaction to Harry pulling away his +[357.560 --> 359.960] hand to touch his wedding ring. +[359.960 --> 364.560] It seems that she really wanted to show the world that this man was hers. +[364.560 --> 368.520] Hell band of show in this display of affection, whatever it takes. +[368.520 --> 372.800] So after trying to bend her frustration, she knew that there was only one thing left to +[372.800 --> 373.800] do. +[373.800 --> 377.640] Go and grab that hand girl and grab that hand she did. +[377.640 --> 382.720] At that moment Harry had another clear display of nervousness, lowering his head and covering +[382.720 --> 384.600] his mouth with his hand. +[384.600 --> 386.520] He looked really insecure. +[386.520 --> 391.480] So that's the instant that Megan went and with a quick look to confirm where was Harry's +[391.480 --> 394.440] left hand, went and grabbed it. +[394.440 --> 399.440] We cannot see the actual hand grab, but look at Megan's body and arm reaching out for +[399.440 --> 400.520] Harry. +[400.520 --> 406.080] She turns her body a little, she flexes her arm so her hand is at the head of Harry's +[406.080 --> 408.600] and keeps an eye so not to miss. +[408.600 --> 412.040] Now we know that her Markle claw is laser guided. +[412.040 --> 414.280] And then just one second left. +[414.280 --> 419.280] She'd be advised that watching the following clip can be nightmare fuel and is how Megan's +[419.280 --> 423.800] face changes instantly to what looks like a smile. +[423.800 --> 428.200] But it's nowhere near the balance smile we saw eight seconds ago. +[428.200 --> 433.200] This time she's showing her upper teeth, her brows are raised and her cheeks are really +[433.200 --> 434.200] tense. +[434.200 --> 439.960] Just to be clear, even if it looks disturbingly similar to Sheldon's Joker's mild, this +[439.960 --> 442.400] could be a perfectly nice full smile. +[442.400 --> 445.480] It has all the ingredients of a genuine smile. +[445.480 --> 448.560] But the problem is Megan's head angle. +[448.560 --> 452.720] She is tilting her head down and it should be no big deal, right? +[452.720 --> 456.600] Well, I'm going to suggest that you try this very funny exercise. +[456.600 --> 458.440] Maybe you can do it right now. +[458.440 --> 462.040] Standing front of a mirror, looking directly at yourself. +[462.040 --> 468.080] Then put the best smile you can and once you have that beautiful smile on your face, lower +[468.080 --> 469.080] your head. +[469.080 --> 473.160] Yeah, you're going to look like straight out of a Stanley Kubrick movie. +[473.160 --> 477.680] That's why Megan's face looks so unsettling because that's a classic archetype of how +[477.680 --> 481.880] we usually depict psychopaths or dangerous people. +[481.880 --> 484.000] Smiling and tilting their head down. +[484.000 --> 487.600] And what is so strange is that smiling is a social act. +[487.600 --> 492.040] The more open or intense your smile, the more you want to show it. +[492.040 --> 495.680] If you're shy, you're not going to hide it directly to your chest. +[495.680 --> 499.480] But instead, you're going to turn to one side and avoid eye contact. +[499.480 --> 504.640] Again, if you do that exercise in the mirror, you'll understand instantly what I mean. +[504.640 --> 509.960] A full smile, lowering your chin and keeping eye contact is something that only appeals to +[509.960 --> 511.440] Hannibal Lecter. +[511.440 --> 515.480] This 9 seconds tell the whole story of Harry and Megan. +[515.480 --> 521.000] He is insecure, she is constantly trying to control him and those odd facial expressions +[521.000 --> 524.200] really do not have at all. +[524.200 --> 528.440] If you want to support my channel and help me make more videos, all you have to do is +[528.440 --> 534.000] like, subscribe and hit that bell so you don't miss any of my battle languages and tips. +[534.000 --> 537.960] I name his Jesús Enrique Rosas and I'll see you soon, my battle language bodies. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_wSo25Ag07ko.txt b/transcript/ceremony_wSo25Ag07ko.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3af8fa72369b7f9d74b3232065c35c14ea4be14e --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_wSo25Ag07ko.txt @@ -0,0 +1,104 @@ +[0.000 --> 2.800] While England has a new king, Charles III. +[2.800 --> 5.400] And he had some little gaffs and his signings. +[5.400 --> 6.700] We're just going to look at that. +[6.700 --> 8.500] We're not going to go through the whole speech. +[8.500 --> 10.800] These people have been making speeches their whole lives. +[10.800 --> 12.900] They're experts at making speeches. +[12.900 --> 14.000] There's no there there. +[14.000 --> 18.300] Tituled an act for securing the process and religion +[18.300 --> 21.300] and Presbyterian Church government +[21.300 --> 25.800] and by the acts passed in the Parliament of both kingdoms +[25.800 --> 28.600] for union of the two kingdoms +[28.600 --> 33.300] together with the government, worship, discipline, rights +[33.300 --> 36.900] and privileges of the Church of Scotland. +[36.900 --> 39.900] So help me God. +[39.900 --> 43.700] I now invite your Majesty to subscribe both copies +[43.700 --> 47.400] of the instrument confirming the oath has been taken. +[58.700 --> 67.900] So he seems kind of lost. +[67.900 --> 70.400] He apparently can't get the document to move in a way +[70.400 --> 72.300] that's comfortable for him to begin with. +[72.300 --> 76.000] He then moves on to the ink wells that he fumbles with and drops +[76.000 --> 76.700] and the pen. +[76.700 --> 79.000] This will add to the mental aggravation. +[85.200 --> 87.800] And you see that he didn't really know what to do with the pen head. +[87.800 --> 90.200] He comes one way is like, oh no, I can't put it over there. +[90.200 --> 91.400] It's going to get in my way. +[91.400 --> 92.600] Let me put it in the other spot. +[92.600 --> 94.800] His mind is kind of lost. +[94.800 --> 98.000] And as my husband said, he seems to be the Joe Biden +[98.000 --> 99.600] of the United Kingdom. +[99.600 --> 100.600] God bless you all. +[100.600 --> 128.600] I'm not saying that the king and again, we get to the frustration park. +[128.600 --> 131.000] He's taking it out on the other person. +[131.000 --> 132.000] It's his food bar. +[132.000 --> 133.800] He couldn't figure out what to do with the ink well. +[133.800 --> 135.500] He's fumbling with the paper. +[135.500 --> 137.100] And now he's got pens. +[137.100 --> 138.300] He doesn't know what to do with them. +[138.300 --> 141.400] He's signing Charles Rex. +[141.400 --> 144.400] Charles off. +[153.000 --> 155.600] And that again, that will add to the frustration. +[155.600 --> 157.400] He wants this to be perfect. +[157.400 --> 160.600] You cannot be shown to be a fumbling idiot. +[160.600 --> 161.600] And here he is. +[161.600 --> 164.500] He's fighting with paparies, fighting with the ink wells, fighting with the pens. +[164.500 --> 167.000] He's got somebody that he's trying to push the blame on. +[167.000 --> 167.800] That it's their fault. +[167.800 --> 168.800] The puns are all there. +[168.800 --> 170.300] And then he gets up and goes away. +[170.300 --> 171.800] The lid is crashing. +[171.800 --> 177.600] So his own lack of the ability to problem solve is adding to his frustration. +[177.600 --> 180.200] And he's taking it out on the plums. +[181.400 --> 187.000] I now invite the witnesses to his majesty's oath to sign both copies +[187.000 --> 188.200] of the instrument. +[198.200 --> 202.200] Now while you get there, it's a little awkward for him too, but he deals with it. +[202.200 --> 204.600] Very calm, not taking it out on anyone. +[204.600 --> 207.200] He problem solves on what to do with the pens. +[217.200 --> 224.200] And for the first time, the Prince of Wales signing. +[224.200 --> 239.200] And because he's not flustered and aggravated, he leaves the pen there for his stepmother. +[239.200 --> 242.600] Because of aggravated, frustrated mind doesn't think. +[242.600 --> 244.800] William doesn't have that mindset. +[244.800 --> 248.600] So he thinks to the person that's next, which is Camilla. +[255.600 --> 257.800] Shushy follows William's lead. +[257.800 --> 259.800] Apparently nobody wants to move these ink wells. +[259.800 --> 263.200] I don't know if they're like super full and they'll spill. +[263.200 --> 265.200] Or they don't want to ruin the document. +[265.200 --> 266.000] I don't know. +[266.000 --> 269.400] It doesn't make any sense on why you wouldn't at least put them in the middle. +[269.400 --> 270.400] I don't know. +[270.400 --> 271.400] It seems kind of silly. +[271.600 --> 273.600] But anyway, she follows William's lead. +[273.600 --> 277.000] Signs the way he did as far as going over the ink wells. +[277.000 --> 301.600] And again, her frustrated mind, she doesn't have one. +[301.600 --> 306.600] She leaves the pen there with the other pens for then I'm assuming the next signing. +[306.600 --> 313.000] I now invite your majesty to sign brief proclamations. +[313.000 --> 315.800] Now here we go for the second signing. +[315.800 --> 319.400] And he's already looking to the person that he wants something gone from. +[337.600 --> 340.400] A little bit calmer away away. +[340.400 --> 345.600] And obviously it's a little bit easier to because these papers are normal size. +[366.600 --> 375.600] And that, your majesty, concludes today's business for the council. +[381.600 --> 385.600] So you see a grimace on his face and then he turns away quickly to exit. +[385.600 --> 388.600] And he does make himself small as he walks off. +[389.600 --> 395.600] With bows from all the private council, the king, the prince of Wales and the queen council leave. +[395.600 --> 397.600] And here's another one. +[397.600 --> 399.600] Jesus man. +[399.600 --> 402.000] So anyways, he's going into signing another one. +[402.000 --> 405.600] I'm not quite sure what this one is about, but it doesn't really matter. +[405.600 --> 408.600] We're just looking at his frustrations. +[426.600 --> 429.600] So he signed it wrong. +[429.600 --> 433.600] Now we've added to the frustration just on having the wrong date. +[433.600 --> 439.600] And now the pen is leaking probably because he was already frustrated that he put the wrong date down. +[439.600 --> 442.600] And so not paying attention to however this pen works. +[442.600 --> 447.600] He's made it worse because of his aggravation, which is shutting his mind down. +[447.600 --> 451.600] And Camilla is making excuses for him as well. +[451.600 --> 452.600] She's the enabler. +[452.600 --> 454.600] Oh yes, it's going everywhere. +[454.600 --> 457.600] To help him feel like this whole fiasco, it's not your fault. +[457.600 --> 458.600] It's the pen. +[458.600 --> 461.600] The pen wrote the 12th, not 13th, bad pen. +[470.600 --> 472.600] And then more aggravation. +[472.600 --> 473.600] And then blaming it on the pen. +[473.600 --> 478.600] Just like before we see him blaming it on the poor guy that wouldn't got the pens. +[478.600 --> 483.600] To me, this is a pattern that I pretty much tell you how the rain is going to be. +[483.600 --> 485.600] If you like it, please share and subscribe. +[485.600 --> 487.600] Thanks for watching. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_yEg5GaoZzCc.txt b/transcript/ceremony_yEg5GaoZzCc.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ce93f41f5af1f3a4d4f1e458d63ca6f88a5b8a74 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_yEg5GaoZzCc.txt @@ -0,0 +1,23 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.600] Princess Charlotte, heartwarming gestures at her coronation ceremony that will melt your hearts today, +[5.600 --> 10.480] in a world often filled with the complexities of royal duties and public expectations, +[10.480 --> 14.080] moments of genuine warmth and innocence can be rare gems. +[14.080 --> 18.560] Princess Charlotte, the youngest child of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, +[18.560 --> 22.400] recently captured the hearts of millions during her coronation ceremony +[22.400 --> 27.040] with a series of heartwarming gestures that reminded us all of the beauty of childhood. +[27.520 --> 31.680] As the nation celebrated a significant milestone in the royal lineage, +[31.680 --> 36.160] it was young Charlotte's endearing actions that stole the show and brought smiles to face +[36.160 --> 42.800] his young and older like, a ceremony to remember. The coronation ceremony, filled with grandeur and +[42.800 --> 48.160] tradition, was a spectacle that showcased not just the royal family's heritage, but also the +[48.160 --> 53.920] deep love and affection they share. As crowds gathered, the air buzzed with anticipation. +[54.880 --> 59.920] The ceremonial grandeur, complete with elaborate regalia and historical pageantry, +[59.920 --> 65.440] set the scene for a day that would be etched in history. Yet, amid the solemnity, +[65.440 --> 71.520] it was the candid moments involving Princess Charlotte that truly resonated, as the ceremony unfolded, +[71.520 --> 76.320] Charlotte dressed in a stunning gown that mirrored her mother's elegance, displayed a relatable +[76.320 --> 82.000] innocence and charm. She was not just a participant in a royal event, she was a little girl. +[82.960 --> 88.640] Curious and full of wonder, living in the moment. Her wide-eyed expressions and infectious +[88.640 --> 93.600] smiles brought a sense of joy and playfulness that reminded everyone present of the importance of +[93.600 --> 98.720] family and love, even in the most royal of settings, the sweet gestures, one of the most +[98.720 --> 103.840] touching moments came when Charlotte was spotted sharing a giggle with her brother, Prince George. +[104.800 --> 109.600] Their bond was evident as they whispered to each other, creating a bubble of joy amidst the +[109.600 --> 115.840] formalities. This delightful sibling interaction was not only heartwarming but also a testament to +[115.840 --> 124.480] the strong family ties within the royal. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_yWGVzy3DeVk.txt b/transcript/ceremony_yWGVzy3DeVk.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..127e0a067ae6a5680d3b056333e633a8f2e60f98 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_yWGVzy3DeVk.txt @@ -0,0 +1,8 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.120] When Kate Middleton shushed Queen Camilla, Bishop Michael Curry's sermon at Prince Harry and +[5.120 --> 9.440] Meghan Markle's wedding was a captivating moment that stirred unexpected reactions, +[10.000 --> 13.600] not every guest responded as one might expect at a royal wedding. +[14.720 --> 20.000] Eagle-eyed viewers noticed Camilla, the Duchess of Cornwall, laughing at the preacher's remarks +[20.000 --> 26.880] and behaviors. Kate Middleton, in a non-verbal gesture, was seen giving Camilla a subtle side-eye, +[26.960 --> 33.040] suggesting she should quiet down. Even body language experts took notice of this intriguing moment. +[33.680 --> 38.880] Some noted that Kate's usually serious demeanor shifted to a dignified reprimand +[38.880 --> 48.880] through a smirked expression and a downturned mouth. diff --git a/transcript/ceremony_zlsV9FYBTYs.txt b/transcript/ceremony_zlsV9FYBTYs.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0b7829b2d446464e813216101a28a4cfcef75d17 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/ceremony_zlsV9FYBTYs.txt @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.560] Our happy couple have chosen to symbolise their union and marriage and the joining of their +[4.560 --> 11.200] families in the old Scottish tradition of drinking from a quay. The quake or loving cup originated +[11.200 --> 16.800] in the Highlands many many years ago and has long been used as a cup of welcome and farewell. +[17.840 --> 23.120] By its shape you need to use both hands to drink from it and in days gone by that reassured +[23.120 --> 27.840] the Scottish clansmen that the other clan weren't hiding a sword behind their back. +[28.560 --> 35.760] It was a sign of openness offering a hand in friendship and trust all equally good traits in a marriage. +[38.560 --> 41.280] Please pour your chosen tipple into the quake. +[43.840 --> 47.440] These two will now take their first drink together as a married couple. +[58.080 --> 73.920] By the way it's customary to drink the quake dry the internal upside down, kiss the bottom and then +[73.920 --> 78.240] place it on top of your head. I just need that up. +[81.200 --> 85.520] As you have both shared the drink from this quake so many share your lives. +[86.080 --> 91.440] May you explore life's mysteries together and find life's joys heightened, +[91.440 --> 98.880] it's bitterness sweetened and all of life enriched by the love of family and friends. diff --git a/transcript/political_4jwUXV4QaTw.txt b/transcript/political_4jwUXV4QaTw.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a8f6d859c292c049ed154a4d6cc38aed50f9666b --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_4jwUXV4QaTw.txt @@ -0,0 +1,273 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.160] Nonverbels are anything that communicates but is not a word. +[5.160 --> 8.500] The public knows them as body language. +[8.500 --> 12.600] How we dress, how we walk, have meaning, +[12.600 --> 17.800] and we use that to interpret what's in the mind of the person. +[17.800 --> 30.200] My name is Joan Avaro and for 25 years I was a special agent with the FBI. +[30.200 --> 33.200] My job was to catch spies. +[33.200 --> 37.200] Most of my career I spent within the National Security Division. +[37.200 --> 42.200] A lot of it had to do with looking at specific targets and then it was about, +[42.200 --> 45.800] how do we get in their heads and how do we neutralize them. +[45.800 --> 48.800] Our security is based on nonverbels. +[48.800 --> 51.200] We look at the person through the people. +[51.200 --> 54.700] We look at who's behind us at the ATM machine. +[54.700 --> 60.200] We know from the research that most of us select our mates based on nonverbels. +[60.200 --> 66.700] So we may think we're very sophisticated but in fact we are never in a state +[66.700 --> 69.700] where we're not transmitting information. +[69.700 --> 72.700] There's a lot of myths out there. +[72.800 --> 78.600] The ones that stand out is if you cross your arms that it's a blocking behavior. +[78.600 --> 80.100] That's just nonsense. +[80.100 --> 83.300] Even when you don't like the person that is in front of you, +[83.300 --> 84.900] this isn't to block them out. +[84.900 --> 88.300] It's actually to self-suit because in essence it's a self-hug. +[88.300 --> 91.900] When you're sitting at a movie and you're watching, you're going to cross your arms. +[91.900 --> 93.400] You're waiting for somebody. +[93.400 --> 94.800] You tend to do this. +[94.800 --> 99.100] What's interesting is we do this behavior more in public than in private. +[99.100 --> 104.000] The other one that really stands out is as we think about something, +[104.000 --> 106.200] we may look in a certain way. +[106.200 --> 109.700] As we process the information, we may look in another way. +[109.700 --> 114.400] It's certainly not indicative of deception and it really shouldn't be used that way. +[114.400 --> 117.700] All we can say is the person is processing the information. +[117.700 --> 121.700] The other misconceptions are that if the person clears or throats, +[121.700 --> 125.200] touches their nose or covers their mouth, they're lying. +[125.300 --> 129.000] We do these behaviors as self-suthers. +[129.000 --> 134.400] They're pacifying behaviors scientifically and empirically. +[134.400 --> 136.600] There's just no Pinocchio effect. +[136.600 --> 138.800] And people who prattle that and say, +[138.800 --> 144.600] well, we can detect deception because the person touches their nose or covers their mouth. +[144.600 --> 146.100] That's just sheer nonsense. +[146.100 --> 150.300] We humans are lousy at detecting deception. +[150.400 --> 155.200] Espionage work is often nowhere near what we see in movies. +[155.200 --> 159.900] And in one of the cases, we had information from another country saying, +[159.900 --> 166.900] you have an American we think is actually a mole who somehow entered the United States +[166.900 --> 169.300] is able to pass as an American, +[169.300 --> 172.900] but he's here working for a hostile intelligence service. +[172.900 --> 175.400] And just fortuitously, +[175.400 --> 179.600] he was videographed coming out of a flower shop. +[179.600 --> 183.700] We're looking at the video and everybody in our small unit, +[183.700 --> 185.700] we were saying, well, there's not much there. +[185.700 --> 188.400] He's coming out of the shop, getting in his car. +[188.400 --> 191.000] And I said, stop the film right there. +[191.000 --> 194.200] Just as he came out of the shop, he took the flowers. +[194.200 --> 198.400] And most Americans tend to hold the flowers by the stock +[198.400 --> 200.200] so that the flowers are up. +[200.200 --> 205.900] This individual took them and grabbed the stock and then held the flowers +[205.900 --> 207.900] so that they were facing down. +[208.000 --> 211.000] And I said, that's how they carry flowers in Eastern Europe. +[211.000 --> 214.800] Rather than confront him about, are you a spy? +[214.800 --> 217.500] I decided to do what's called a presumptive. +[217.500 --> 222.400] So as I sat there with him, I said, would you like to know how we know? +[222.400 --> 226.800] And he had this look on his face and I said, it was the flowers. +[226.800 --> 229.800] And then he confessed. +[229.800 --> 231.800] When I came into law enforcement, +[231.800 --> 235.100] I thought it was all about the confession. +[235.100 --> 237.100] It's really about FaceTime. +[237.100 --> 243.800] In my 25 years in the FBI, it was a rarity that a person +[243.800 --> 248.900] didn't eventually reveal what I needed to know +[248.900 --> 256.000] because we would sit down and have these very lengthy conversations. +[256.000 --> 259.500] I look at behaviors to do an assessment. +[259.500 --> 264.000] What is this person transmitting in relations to any stimuli? +[264.000 --> 270.500] My further questioning comes from my observing these behaviors. +[270.500 --> 273.100] The first thing I look at is I look at the hair. +[273.100 --> 274.400] Does it look healthy? +[274.400 --> 276.100] Does it look well groomed? +[276.100 --> 281.200] The forehead is very interesting because a lot of times we reveal stress. +[281.200 --> 286.000] A lot of the things that we have gone through life are often etched in the forehead. +[286.000 --> 289.800] I look at the eyes to see if they're red or not enough sleep. +[289.800 --> 293.700] The small area here between the eyes called the globella. +[293.700 --> 297.800] It's one of the first areas that reveals information to us. +[297.800 --> 300.600] Most often when we don't like something, +[300.600 --> 303.600] we do that bunny nose of I don't like. +[303.600 --> 306.600] We don't really know what our lips look like. +[306.600 --> 310.200] And we tend to compress them when something bothers us, +[310.200 --> 313.600] when something really bothers us, we tend to suck them in. +[313.600 --> 316.000] The mandibula and look at the cheeks. +[316.000 --> 317.500] We may do something like this. +[317.500 --> 323.100] We'll rub our tongue against the inside of the cheek. +[323.200 --> 325.000] But when we try to hide it, +[325.000 --> 329.500] then it tells me that this person is trying to do some perception management. +[329.500 --> 331.600] And if they are, I want to know why. +[331.600 --> 334.500] At the neck, I want to see if there's any head tilt. +[334.500 --> 337.200] Because head tilt, the person is more relaxed. +[337.200 --> 339.200] The minute the head tilt goes away, +[339.200 --> 340.900] there's usually some issue. +[340.900 --> 342.700] I'm looking at the shoulders. +[342.700 --> 344.500] You ask somebody a question and they don't know, +[344.500 --> 346.700] both shoulders shoot up very quickly. +[346.700 --> 348.700] And then I look at the hands. +[348.700 --> 350.500] When something's troubling us, +[350.500 --> 353.900] we tend to stiffen our fingers, interlace them, +[353.900 --> 356.400] and almost like a teepee, +[356.400 --> 361.000] we move our hands back and forth very slowly. +[361.000 --> 365.600] This is to be differentiated from when we do the steeple, +[365.600 --> 367.500] which we do in this position. +[367.500 --> 369.200] When something's at issue, +[369.200 --> 371.700] we tend to put our hands on our hips +[371.700 --> 374.000] and we become very territorial. +[374.000 --> 375.900] This is called arms a Kimbo. +[375.900 --> 378.000] But look how it changes. +[378.100 --> 380.400] When we put our thumbs forward, +[380.400 --> 384.000] and then it becomes one of more of, I'm inquisitive. +[384.000 --> 388.600] But I also look for any behaviors of ventilating, +[388.600 --> 391.700] because men tend to ventilate at the neck, +[391.700 --> 395.200] and we do at the very instant something bothers us. +[395.200 --> 399.500] And then I look at the legs to see if there's any brushing +[399.500 --> 401.600] of the legs with the hands, +[401.600 --> 404.300] which is again, to pacify. +[404.300 --> 407.600] And then the feet do I see any behaviors +[407.600 --> 411.200] such as wiggling of the feet, kicking of the feet. +[411.200 --> 414.400] If I ask a question and all of a sudden the feet with draw +[414.400 --> 417.400] in our cross, perhaps the person feels a little threatened +[417.400 --> 418.400] by that question. +[418.400 --> 420.100] So when we study nonverbals, +[420.100 --> 422.900] it's not about making judgments, +[422.900 --> 426.800] it's about assessing what is this person transmitting +[426.800 --> 427.800] in that moment. +[429.900 --> 433.800] It really is looking at an individual and saying, +[433.800 --> 435.600] what are they transmitting? +[435.700 --> 438.400] We're all transmitting at all times. +[438.400 --> 441.200] We choose the clothes that we wear, +[441.200 --> 444.200] how we groom ourselves, how we dress, +[444.200 --> 446.400] but also how do we carry ourselves? +[446.400 --> 449.800] Are we coming to the office on this particular day +[449.800 --> 451.000] with a lot of energy, +[451.000 --> 454.700] or are we coming in with a different sort of pace? +[454.700 --> 458.000] And what we look for are differences in behavior +[458.000 --> 463.100] down to the minutia of what is this individual's posture +[463.100 --> 465.400] as they're walking down the street, +[465.500 --> 467.800] are they on the inside of the sidewalk, +[467.800 --> 469.000] on the outside? +[469.000 --> 470.800] Can we see his blink rate? +[470.800 --> 473.800] Can we see how often he's looking at his watch? +[473.800 --> 477.200] I know your blink rate is around eight times a minute, +[477.200 --> 478.200] but you don't know that. +[478.200 --> 480.200] You're not sitting there counting. +[480.200 --> 483.200] All these things factor in because they're transmitting +[483.200 --> 484.200] information. +[484.200 --> 488.400] Now it's up to us to then use that information to say, +[488.400 --> 490.900] okay, we need to marshal resources +[490.900 --> 493.600] to be on that individual right now. +[496.200 --> 505.800] So in most Western cultures, +[505.800 --> 509.800] the first time people touch is when they shake hands. +[509.800 --> 512.700] Touching becomes that important +[512.700 --> 514.600] because we can always remember a time +[514.600 --> 517.800] when we shook hands with someone and we didn't like that. +[517.800 --> 522.200] It's also the first time when our bodies release +[522.700 --> 525.800] bonding chemicals that say I like this person +[525.800 --> 527.300] or I don't like this person. +[527.300 --> 532.600] So hand shaking is both necessary and essential +[532.600 --> 533.600] in most cultures. +[540.600 --> 542.600] Ladies, hi, I'm Joe Navarro. +[542.600 --> 543.400] Joe, I'm Laura. +[543.400 --> 544.400] Laura, how are you? +[544.400 --> 545.600] And you are? +[545.600 --> 547.000] Katisha, how are you? +[547.000 --> 548.000] Okay. +[548.000 --> 549.600] Let me ask you this. +[549.600 --> 551.000] Let's back up a little bit. +[552.800 --> 554.600] Is this comfortable for you? +[554.600 --> 555.400] Yes. +[555.400 --> 556.600] Yeah. +[556.600 --> 558.600] It's a little bit more comfortable. +[558.600 --> 560.200] But it's not for you, is it? +[560.200 --> 561.200] No. +[561.200 --> 562.000] All right. +[562.000 --> 562.800] Thank you. +[562.800 --> 563.400] All right. +[563.400 --> 564.800] So keep talking. +[566.400 --> 569.900] What we've done here is we've talked about the importance +[569.900 --> 572.400] of space and comfort. +[572.400 --> 576.200] They don't realize is how much further apart they are now +[576.200 --> 581.600] standing and it's because we have brought this subject up +[581.600 --> 585.200] to make them comfortable about saying, hey, +[585.200 --> 589.400] it's okay to be comfortable at your perfect distance. +[589.400 --> 594.200] And so now we see when they rock, they rock away from each other +[594.200 --> 597.200] and they create this space. +[597.200 --> 601.900] If you notice, their feet tend to move around more. +[601.900 --> 607.000] There's a dynamic going on here where they're kind of +[607.000 --> 609.700] trying to find, well, what is the perfect space? +[609.700 --> 611.700] What is the perfect distance? +[611.700 --> 614.900] And we know that they're unsettled because of the high +[614.900 --> 617.900] degree of movement that's going on. +[623.300 --> 625.200] Poker is an interesting game. +[625.200 --> 630.100] The similitudes of sitting across from a spy or sitting across +[630.100 --> 634.900] from players, it's their reactions to a stimulus. +[634.900 --> 639.900] We have behaviors indicative of psychological discomfort +[639.900 --> 645.300] that we use at home, at work, or at the poker table. +[645.300 --> 648.100] So we're going to take a look at poker players and some of +[648.100 --> 653.100] the body language that you'll find at a typical poker game. +[653.100 --> 653.600] All right. +[653.600 --> 655.600] All right. +[655.600 --> 659.600] So we'll pause it right there. +[659.600 --> 663.300] So one of the things that you first notice is that when a +[663.300 --> 666.700] table is called, this is the first time many of them see +[666.700 --> 667.700] each other. +[667.700 --> 672.100] This is a great opportunity to be looking for behaviors +[672.100 --> 674.100] indicative of discomfort. +[674.100 --> 677.200] We're going to see the individual shifting in his chair. +[677.200 --> 680.700] We're going to see one individual reaching over and +[680.700 --> 682.300] grabbing his shoulder. +[682.300 --> 686.100] The woman in this case, her shoulders are rather high. +[686.100 --> 689.300] This is a great opportunity, even before the game starts to +[689.300 --> 692.200] collect poker intelligence. +[692.600 --> 693.600] All right, guys. +[693.600 --> 695.600] What is good? +[695.600 --> 697.600] So we'll stop right there. +[697.600 --> 699.600] Look where their hands are at. +[699.600 --> 702.400] Here we're looking at player number two and number three. +[702.400 --> 706.400] And we notice right away that their hands are on top of the cards. +[706.400 --> 708.700] Some players will cage their cards. +[708.700 --> 712.200] Some players will put their hands directly on top and press +[712.200 --> 713.000] them down. +[713.000 --> 717.000] And they may do that because the cards have now increased in value. +[717.000 --> 720.000] Player number one tends to keep his hands very close to his +[720.000 --> 720.900] body. +[720.900 --> 725.100] Player number four, she's actually withdrawn her hands from the +[725.100 --> 729.000] table because when we like things, we tend to move our hands +[729.000 --> 729.900] forward. +[729.900 --> 734.000] When we don't like things, we tend to move the hands away. +[734.000 --> 735.800] Guys, only cards. +[735.800 --> 739.000] So as we look at player number three, I'm often asked about +[739.000 --> 741.800] players who shuffle their chips. +[741.800 --> 744.600] What you're really doing is self-suiting. +[744.600 --> 747.400] And this just helps you to make it through the game. +[747.400 --> 750.800] And that's really all we're looking for. +[750.800 --> 752.600] Oh, come on. +[752.600 --> 755.200] OK, so we'll stop right there. +[755.200 --> 758.400] Player number five is sitting there, arms crossed. +[758.400 --> 760.400] You don't see a lot of activity. +[760.400 --> 763.900] That doesn't mean he's not transmitting a lot of information. +[763.900 --> 768.400] On down the line, I want to see where those thumbs of his are +[768.400 --> 772.400] because he holds them very close when nothing's going on. +[772.400 --> 776.000] But does that change as the game evolves? +[776.000 --> 777.300] If you're looking at non-verbals, it's +[777.300 --> 780.700] often useful to look at them at double the speed because all +[780.700 --> 784.200] the non-verbals that are critical jump out at you as though +[784.200 --> 786.200] it were a caricature. +[786.200 --> 790.800] All right, so stop right there. +[790.800 --> 794.300] The woman in position number four, you see her head moving +[794.300 --> 795.800] around quite a bit. +[795.800 --> 800.400] Player number three, you see a lot of activity with his hands. +[800.400 --> 804.400] When we look at player number five, now his hands are fully +[804.400 --> 805.000] out. +[805.000 --> 808.400] This is as far as we've seen them before. +[808.400 --> 811.200] At this point, we know that he's engaged and that he's +[811.200 --> 812.700] interested. +[812.700 --> 815.400] Now, the game is out in the open. +[815.400 --> 820.300] 75% to 80% of the information we need is sitting out there. +[820.300 --> 823.500] What you often see is everybody's looking at their own cards +[823.500 --> 827.100] or looking at the community cards rather than looking around. +[827.100 --> 830.200] You should be looking around to see what was the reaction +[830.200 --> 833.700] because you're going to see that reaction again. +[833.700 --> 838.100] In poker, we used to say that you can have a poker face, +[838.100 --> 841.700] but I encountered you can't have a poker body. +[841.700 --> 846.100] Somewhere, it's going to be revealed. +[846.100 --> 850.200] When I was in college in the early 70s, there were really no +[850.200 --> 853.200] courses on non-verbal communications. +[853.200 --> 857.400] You quickly realize that to a great extent, it's really about +[857.400 --> 859.600] what you can interpret from behavior. +[859.600 --> 863.100] And so we talk about non-verbels because it matters, +[863.100 --> 866.100] because it has gravitas, because it affects how we +[866.100 --> 867.600] communicate with each other. +[867.600 --> 871.600] When it comes to non-verbels, this is no small matter. +[871.600 --> 877.600] We primarily communicate non-verbaly, and we always will. diff --git a/transcript/political_6A8TiUpKDVg.txt b/transcript/political_6A8TiUpKDVg.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4dffa8b3e08d0655696f8c0ecf9ad6ccd9040d86 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_6A8TiUpKDVg.txt @@ -0,0 +1,29 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.000] We're going to grow our economy. We're going to make our country more secure. We'll strengthen our families. +[5.000 --> 16.000] And most importantly, we will live up, most importantly, we will live up to our character as a nation. +[16.000 --> 22.000] That's exactly what we're talking about. +[22.000 --> 24.000] That's why we're here. +[24.000 --> 32.000] Please use your executive order to pull deportations for all 11.5 of Dr. Andrews in this country right now. +[32.000 --> 41.000] We agree that we need to pass the U.S. before at the same time when you have a power to stop deportations for all of Dr. Andrews. +[41.000 --> 44.000] That's why we're here. +[44.000 --> 48.000] Okay. +[48.000 --> 50.000] Thank you. All right. +[50.000 --> 52.000] What I'd like to do. +[52.000 --> 55.000] No, no, don't worry about it, guys. +[55.000 --> 58.000] Okay. Let me finish. Let me finish. +[58.000 --> 62.000] These guys don't need to go. Let me finish. +[62.000 --> 69.000] I respect the passion of these young people because they feel deeply about the concerns for their families. +[69.000 --> 76.000] Now, what you need to know when I'm speaking as President of the United States, +[76.000 --> 89.000] and I come to this community, is that if in fact I could solve all these problems without passing laws in Congress, then I would do so. +[89.000 --> 93.000] But we're also a nation of laws. That's part of our tradition. +[93.000 --> 103.000] And so the easy way out is to try to yell and pretend like I can do something by violating our laws. +[103.000 --> 112.000] But I'm proposing as the harder path, which is to use our democratic processes to achieve the same goal that you want to achieve. +[112.000 --> 118.000] But it won't be as easy as just shouting. It requires us lobby and getting it done. +[118.000 --> 130.000] So for those of you who are committed to getting this done, +[130.000 --> 143.000] I am going to march with you and fight with you every step of the way to make sure that we are welcoming every striving, hardworking immigrant who sees America the same way we do. +[143.000 --> 149.000] As a country where no matter who you are, or where you look like or where you come from, you can make it if you try. +[149.000 --> 155.000] And if you're serious about making that happen, then I'm ready to work with you. +[155.000 --> 165.000] But it is going to require work. It is not simply a matter of us just saying we're going to violate the law. +[165.000 --> 167.000] That's not our tradition. +[167.000 --> 174.000] But the great thing about this country is we have this wonderful process of democracy and sometimes it is messy and sometimes it is hard. +[174.000 --> 178.000] But ultimately, justice and truth went out. +[178.000 --> 183.000] That's always been the case in this country. That's going to continue to be the case today. diff --git a/transcript/political_6Toeq3kIUVY.txt b/transcript/political_6Toeq3kIUVY.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3ca6dfcfe7c5e0b7390e18df06c44097e665b7d7 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_6Toeq3kIUVY.txt @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +[0.000 --> 6.000] Forget about the start. It takes one minute and 40 seconds before President Obama even looks at Trump. +[6.000 --> 12.000] So think about it. If we just mean, and I'm introducing you, when people like people like themselves, it's rapport, +[12.000 --> 19.000] we look at the person, we'll just do to the person. We just met. I'm really excited. We have this great conversation. We don't see any of that here. +[19.000 --> 28.000] Okay. Donald Trump was holding his hands in a certain way that I believe is sort of like this. It's like this and you call it, oh, it's like this. +[28.000 --> 35.000] So he has it up like this between like this between his legs. Yeah. So this is called steepling. So when we steeple people, we intimidate people. +[35.000 --> 42.000] This is a go to move for President elect Trump. We've seen him do this all the way from their apprentice days when it all first began. +[42.000 --> 47.000] So when we steeple people, we intimidate people. Imagine doing this and saying, can I talk to you for a second? +[47.000 --> 55.000] This is a sense of his power. It can be seen as intimidating, but this is his go to move. The higher the steeple, the more we intimidate people. +[55.000 --> 66.000] So a low steeple like this is being respectful of our current President. If he were to go higher and up on the elbows, I call this the Godfather steeple right here. +[66.000 --> 71.000] Or you lean back and put the crown over your head, you know, the higher the steeple, the more you control people. +[71.000 --> 74.000] Oh, good to know. I plan to use that on Chris right after this. +[74.000 --> 81.000] President Obama, you say you watched him do these long eyelid closes. What's that? +[81.000 --> 88.000] Yeah, he does that. So we call this eye blocking. So when Donald Trump, President Electrump is talking, we see Obama listening. +[88.000 --> 95.000] And he'll do these very long eye closes closes. We usually do this eye blocking, either with our hand or with our eyelids. +[95.000 --> 108.000] When we don't like what we see or hear that's happening right in front of us. And if you listen to not just the body language, but the actual language, we hear Donald Trump say things like I have a great respect for and he doesn't finish the sentence. +[108.000 --> 115.000] These are short stop sentences. We assume he's saying great respect for the President, but he doesn't finish the sentence. +[115.000 --> 128.000] Donald Trump also says what he says, I look forward to dealing with the President. The word dealing in and of itself is not if you say I'm if you're a babysitter and I'm interviewing you to watch my three sons and you say I'm really great at dealing with children. +[128.000 --> 133.000] You're not getting the job. So there's definitely not a love affair happening here. diff --git a/transcript/political_6_uYWDyYNUg.txt b/transcript/political_6_uYWDyYNUg.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4fd318c9f6493c14faefdabd9a2a1db408606cef --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_6_uYWDyYNUg.txt @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +[0.000 --> 29.800] In order for you and me to devise some kind of method or strategy, +[29.800 --> 39.800] to offset some of the events or repetition of the events that have taken place here in Los Angeles recently, +[39.800 --> 44.800] we have to go to the root, we have to go to the cause. +[44.800 --> 50.800] Dealing with the condition itself is not enough and it is because of our effort +[50.800 --> 58.800] toward getting straight to the root that people oftentimes think we are dealing in hate. +[58.800 --> 67.800] We are oppressed, we are exploited, we are downtrodden, we are denied not only civil rights but even human rights. +[67.800 --> 78.800] So the only way we are going to get some of this oppression and exploitation away from us or aside from us is come together against the common enemy. +[79.800 --> 91.800] Who taught you to hate the texture of your hair? Who taught you to hate the color of your skin to such extent that you bleach to get like the white man? +[91.800 --> 102.800] Who taught you to hate the shape of your nose and the shape of your lips? Who taught you to hate yourself from the top of your head to the soles of your feet? +[103.800 --> 108.800] Who taught you to hate your own kind? Who taught you to hate the race that you belong to? +[108.800 --> 111.800] So much so that you don't want to be around each other. +[111.800 --> 120.800] No, before you come asking Mr. Muhammad, as he teach hate, you should ask yourself who taught you to hate being what God gave you. +[121.800 --> 128.800] And I for one as a Muslim believe that the white man is intelligent enough. +[128.800 --> 139.800] If he were made to realize how black people really feel and how fed up we are without better compromise and sweet talk, stop sweet talking to him. +[139.800 --> 148.800] Tell him how you feel. Tell him how what kind of hell you've been catching and let him know that if he's not ready to clean his house up. +[151.800 --> 156.800] If he's not ready to clean his house up, he shouldn't have a house. +[156.800 --> 157.800] He shouldn't have a house. +[157.800 --> 161.800] You should catch on fire and burn down. diff --git a/transcript/political_7_ErQVcBkNY.txt b/transcript/political_7_ErQVcBkNY.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0cf86d26d593798e4cc576a6defb341a7161e59d --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_7_ErQVcBkNY.txt @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.000] Body language. Absolutely. What does some of it say just in general? +[4.000 --> 8.560] Actually what you're looking for is synchronicity between what the person is saying with their words +[8.560 --> 13.840] and what their gestures and facial expressions and voice parallel language do. Is there a match? +[13.840 --> 17.920] And that makes us trust the person, feel they're sincere in their speaking. +[17.920 --> 23.040] Watching this whole tape many many times over the last few days, it's very stiff. It looks like +[23.040 --> 28.000] he has a rod all the way up his back and he leans forward like this, automaton, automaton. Instead of +[28.000 --> 33.120] doing what Clinton or Obama do, which is almost a symbolic embrace as they come up to people +[33.120 --> 37.600] and they also step forward towards the person that they're shaking hands with. And +[37.600 --> 41.360] Romney in this case is don't get cooties, no stay away, stay away. Only more stay. +[41.360 --> 46.480] Only handshake, much more stay. Okay. It was the best speech he's ever given. He finally had some +[46.480 --> 50.960] true emotional moments, specifically when he was talking about his parents and his father giving +[50.960 --> 56.560] his mother the rose. That was absolutely beautiful. And he had a little bit more movement, +[57.280 --> 63.920] few more gestures. Well, it was so exasperating is that he would say something where gestures should +[63.920 --> 68.960] come naturally like we want to build America. See my hands just naturally want to do that. Anyway, +[68.960 --> 74.800] we want to build America or we need to fight for our freedom. Instead of we need to fight for our +[74.800 --> 80.400] freedom. You need to spend some time with Jennifer Grandhol. Absolutely. So he looks more genuine and +[80.400 --> 85.280] and show some feeling and emotion. And what about the president? The president had beautiful gestures. +[85.280 --> 90.240] He did want to quite a bit that I loved because it was all about he would bring his fists together +[90.240 --> 94.560] and bring it towards his heart calling on the audience that we need to fight together. +[94.560 --> 99.600] And I feel just in my heart. Absolutely. Body language is highly symbolic. It goes to the +[99.600 --> 104.400] limbic brain. So it imprints there in the audience. Is there listening and watching the message? +[105.280 --> 111.280] I absolutely love this. She's so excited. Body language that comes up above the waist like that +[111.280 --> 116.320] is all about joy and victories. So she's definitely saying over and over again with her gestures. +[116.320 --> 122.240] I believe we have victory that we are going to win. She's so confident. And her voice also matches +[122.240 --> 128.720] up and aligns with that message as well. So amazing. A big smile. And actually what's also +[128.720 --> 133.120] interesting. You see her pointing her finger quite a bit. Very unusual for a female to do. Typically +[133.120 --> 137.120] an indication of great confidence and security in the message as well. What do you see there? +[137.120 --> 140.560] Does it look sincere? It looks sincere. What I love just before this. +[140.560 --> 146.400] Clinton actually bowed down as a approached Obama to say, I know you were more powerful. +[146.400 --> 150.720] I'm giving the power over to you. I thought that was a really wonderful and interesting choice. +[151.360 --> 156.240] Because typically that hug even right now, Clinton's doing this. They say I'm a little bit superior to +[156.240 --> 160.000] you. But the first message was I'm bowing down, but I'm still a little bit superior to you. diff --git a/transcript/political_CfNEHW3qgso.txt b/transcript/political_CfNEHW3qgso.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1424b8d5388cd856d466e9aab6dbd6db255d35d8 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_CfNEHW3qgso.txt @@ -0,0 +1,107 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.800] Politicians realize that non-verbels are important. +[4.800 --> 10.720] And so when they choose an outfit, when they choose how they're going to come out, +[10.720 --> 15.040] whether or not they're going to be smiling or shaking hands, +[15.040 --> 19.120] one thing I can assure you, this has been rehearsed many times. +[19.120 --> 22.880] It is theater. It's absolute theater. +[22.880 --> 28.480] And one of the things that we will be looking for is how well these actors do their job. +[30.720 --> 38.560] My name is Joan Avaro and for 25 years I was a spy catcher with the FBI and I am a +[38.560 --> 44.400] non-verbal communications expert. As we approach the height of the political season, +[44.400 --> 50.880] the question I'm asked is, you know, what do you look for in the body language of the people +[50.880 --> 57.120] that will be in the debate? I look at everything that's involved because we have to look at all the +[57.120 --> 66.800] non-verbels. We always notice when the candidates come on stage, they're always waving at somebody +[66.800 --> 73.840] in the audience or pointing a finger and so forth. Sometimes these are actually bogus gestures +[73.840 --> 79.120] because they know the cameras in the audience will take pictures anytime there's a large gesture. +[79.760 --> 86.160] And so they may actually do these things with no one in mind. You'll notice that rarely +[86.160 --> 95.040] our debaters allow to stand or sit close to each other. Usually there's at least 7 to 10 feet +[95.040 --> 100.480] of space and the reason for that is debaters actually don't want you to see that there's a +[100.480 --> 108.400] height difference. And so by separating the two individuals, we don't notice that difference. +[108.400 --> 114.720] You'll see an unusual amount of the color blue in the background, somewhere between the color +[114.720 --> 125.280] of the ocean and the sky, which is soothing to the human brain. The wearing of a navy blue suit, +[125.280 --> 133.680] white shirts, often a red or burgundy tie. Subconsciously, we see the significance of that because +[133.680 --> 141.040] it is what we see in the American flag, red, white and blue. What's really become ubiquitous is the +[141.840 --> 150.880] lapel pin of the American flag. This is something that 30 years ago, even 20 years ago, we hardly saw, +[150.880 --> 156.720] but now it's almost part of our attire. You know, if you think about it, is someone less patriotic +[156.720 --> 162.720] because on this day they're not wearing the American flag, of course not. This is reaching out to you +[162.800 --> 171.520] at a subconscious level. It's part of the theater, part of the orchestration, which we now demand. +[175.760 --> 181.840] We're looking for their behaviors to see are these consistent with what we have seen in the past. +[181.840 --> 187.680] We certainly shouldn't be using body language to try to determine if they're speaking the truth. +[187.680 --> 194.400] These are orchestrated events and that's not what we use body language for. We use body language +[194.960 --> 204.480] to supplement and confirm what we are seeing. Are the words being supported by the gestures +[204.480 --> 212.560] or are their gestures taking away from their words? What I look for is as the moderator asks the +[212.560 --> 220.160] question, do I see lip biting? Do I see any kind of ventilating behaviors such as pulling on the +[220.160 --> 228.080] collar? Do I see any kind of facial distress? Do I see furrowing of the forehead? They can in fact +[228.080 --> 234.240] take care of it if you just stay out of the way. Oh, really? Oh, really? There's a thing. Anything that +[234.240 --> 242.160] might indicate to me that the individual doesn't like the question here she is being asked. +[242.160 --> 248.000] Who is your question? Who is your question? The other thing I look for is any kind of hesitation, +[248.000 --> 253.920] throat clearing. Are you willing tonight to condemn white supremacists? Are you prepared to do +[253.920 --> 259.440] this? I have a great way to do it. Perhaps the raising of a shoulder, the lowering of a shoulder. +[259.440 --> 266.480] Stand back and stand by. Anything that conveys lack of confidence. I want to see the hands. I want to +[266.480 --> 272.560] see those thumbs that come up because when we're confident, the thumbs pop up and we lack +[272.560 --> 279.520] confidence, they come down. I want to see if there's any kind of steepling. Steepling is a high +[279.520 --> 286.960] indicator of confidence. Or do we see the interlacing of the fingers, which is I'm struggling with +[286.960 --> 291.760] something or I'm having difficulty? One of the ones that you may not even think about, nothing will +[291.760 --> 297.920] ever be said, but you'll see behaviors like the light touching of the eye with the fingertip. +[297.920 --> 304.240] This is both a blocking behavior and a comforting behavior. One of the facial nerves that +[304.240 --> 310.480] attends to the eyelid, the minute we put pressure on that nerve, it begins to send messages to the +[310.480 --> 317.120] brain to calm down. What in essence they're saying is, I screwed up or I really don't like that. +[317.120 --> 322.160] One of the things that happens in political debates are the things that we never planned for. +[322.160 --> 330.080] For instance, in 2016, now President Trump walking behind Hillary Clinton during the debates, +[330.080 --> 336.400] it almost looked like he was stalking her. I mean, I can just imagine me trying to talk to +[336.400 --> 343.200] the camera right now with somebody loitering behind me. That actually actuates a limbic response. +[343.760 --> 351.680] So we may see behaviors that arise as a result of the action of another candidate. And we +[351.680 --> 359.840] certainly saw that in 2016 when some candidates refused to shake the hands of others or when +[359.840 --> 366.480] humor was used when it really wasn't well intended. And that's when we see authenticity. +[366.480 --> 372.400] That's when we really see what is in the heart and the mind and the sentiment of this individual +[372.400 --> 381.520] and how they react to it. Gestures and communication are all intertwined. They're not two separate things. +[381.520 --> 389.200] We know that because we've done research and when we restrict people's hands, they in fact have +[389.200 --> 396.880] less recall. They're in fact less energetic and they communicate much less. We used to say, +[397.520 --> 403.200] you know, when somebody in authority gestures, they need to adjust your wide and they need to +[403.200 --> 410.240] gesture smoothly. Of course, in the Zoom world, those gestures need to be up here where people can +[410.240 --> 417.600] see them. Humans are so sensitive to non-verbels that if I were to point my finger at the audience and +[417.600 --> 423.520] say, you, we actually have a visceral reaction to that, which is usually very negative. Now think +[423.520 --> 429.920] about how many times a school teacher has called on us and gone like that. We know that if we turn +[429.920 --> 436.800] that gesture into an open palm vertical gesture, we like that. We prefer that. Probably the most +[436.800 --> 444.640] popular one is this thumb gesture that you often see. The candidate is making a point and the thumb +[444.640 --> 452.880] is just barely sticking out from beyond the index finger. Anytime we grasp something, we're saying, +[452.880 --> 458.720] I'm talking to you about something that's important to me. I'm sort of grasping it, which is to be +[458.720 --> 466.320] differentiated, for instance, for when we talk and we say with precision. So this is a precision grip. +[466.320 --> 472.880] I want you to think about this. So some of the other gestures we'll see is the open palm gesture. +[472.880 --> 480.480] It shows that we're open, that we are receptive. The palms are up, the fingers are wide. This is a +[480.480 --> 487.360] very appealing. Some of the other gestures we may see is if the person is doing this. So normally +[487.360 --> 496.320] a baton gesture is a cadence behavior that denotes I am asking you to come visit me. But when we do it +[496.320 --> 504.400] this way, what we're in fact saying, if we slow it down, is I'm really not so much behind that, +[504.400 --> 510.960] because it's literally pushing away rather than being receptive. The other behavior we may see +[510.960 --> 519.360] is the touching of the heart and the chest, which we often see portrayed as so-called honesty displays. +[519.360 --> 525.120] They are in fact neutral because I've seen both individuals that are guilty of crimes and the +[525.120 --> 531.440] innocent use this gesture. So it gives the appearance of being honest, but it doesn't mean that they're +[531.440 --> 538.080] being honest. So one of the questions I'm asked is do politicians rehearse their hand gestures? +[538.080 --> 545.520] Some do, some don't. Some absolutely refuse to receive any kind of training. Others are well coached. +[545.520 --> 552.880] The question is, you know, how much of it is authentically theirs and how much of it is borrowed. +[552.880 --> 558.400] Usually if they've been in office a long time or they've been in politics for a long time, +[558.400 --> 561.680] they will be reluctant to change any of their non-burbles. +[566.240 --> 572.240] Let's look at President Trump's gestures. His most favorite one is to talk with the +[572.240 --> 579.680] index finger to the thumb. And what glorious nation under God. Sometimes he does the elbow flop +[579.680 --> 585.920] as he's emphasizing. I don't see any protests. Oftentimes his eyelids will come down to block +[585.920 --> 592.000] when he's hearing something he doesn't like. You can see when he pinches the corner of his mouth, +[592.000 --> 600.320] when he's being sarcastic or exercising disdain or contempt. He does the lip purse when he disagrees or +[600.320 --> 605.920] doesn't like a question being asked. And then of course he does the lip pull when he definitely +[605.920 --> 611.600] doesn't like the question being asked. And if you notice anytime he's sitting in the white house +[611.600 --> 617.920] surrounded by people he always hugs himself. And yet when you compare him to when he's on his +[617.920 --> 624.160] show, the apprentice, he always has a territorial display. And you see this contrast and you have to +[624.160 --> 632.880] ask yourself, why do we see this behavior on a TV show and why we're not seeing this in a +[632.880 --> 640.160] presidential cabinet? Let's look at Joe Biden's gestures. He does a lot of lip touching. We call it +[640.160 --> 646.880] a defensive behavior. You often see it as people are pondering. When he's making a point, he tends +[646.880 --> 654.480] to furrow his globela, he squintes his eyes. Voice often is lowered for emphasis. You should go out +[654.480 --> 662.240] and vote. And as with many people when something bothers him, the lips disappear. And this is something +[662.240 --> 667.760] that I'm often asked about. Does this have anything to do with deception? And it has absolutely +[667.760 --> 674.720] nothing to do with deception. These are the behaviors that we adopt and that we use that help us +[674.720 --> 683.600] to communicate what we're thinking about at that moment. Rarely do people remember what is said. +[683.600 --> 692.640] But we tend to remember the images. To this day, we still teach about a governor Ducaquist on a +[692.640 --> 700.080] military tank wearing this tanker's helmet and how odd he looked. And we scoff sometimes at the +[700.080 --> 707.440] non-verbals. And yet here was one that we can clearly show that just from appearing on that tank, +[707.440 --> 709.600] it really diminished his posture. +[714.000 --> 720.640] You know, some people see these behaviors as a shorthand. I wouldn't call it that. +[720.640 --> 727.360] Behaviors, gestures are part of communication. We have primarily communicated nonverbaly. +[727.360 --> 733.280] We find ourselves using these gestures all the time. And there's a reason for it. People usually +[733.280 --> 741.200] respond to them. People that know as well respond to them. And so we don't separate them as +[741.200 --> 750.640] ancillary to communication. They are in fact part of communication. diff --git a/transcript/political_Co6ScCJxPao.txt b/transcript/political_Co6ScCJxPao.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..08a5c512490e0f69d1b5004b6cd74e1438e28807 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_Co6ScCJxPao.txt @@ -0,0 +1,308 @@ +[0.000 --> 10.000] In politics, does the content of a speech count as much as we usually think? +[10.000 --> 24.000] What is the importance of non-verbal communication and the efficiency of a speech? +[25.000 --> 30.000] Facial displays, gestures, intonation of the voice. +[30.000 --> 36.000] With courage and compassion, strength and resolve. +[42.000 --> 51.000] What are the emotional and rational elements which determine positive or negative reactions to a politician? +[52.000 --> 57.000] Why are some politicians more charismatic than others? +[57.000 --> 72.000] I think charisma is a combination of being able to connect with the audience and having a sort of conversational relationship with the audience. +[73.000 --> 85.000] This type of charisma is very well embodied by American leaders like Ronald Reagan and Bill Clinton, who resemble each other in that regard. +[85.000 --> 93.000] But I think charisma is also comparable to what we call projection when we talk to the voice. +[93.000 --> 109.000] Charisma means to have an effect not only on your immediate surroundings, but being able to have an effect sort of at a distance as well, to communicate in a way that impresses people. +[110.000 --> 128.000] Charisma is the capacity to attract attention so that people will look at an individual, combined with that magic of changing how they feel, and in the long run how they think and act. +[129.000 --> 144.000] A charismatic person is someone that impresses you, that they're interesting, they're appealing, they have some degree of charm, and you trust their leadership. +[146.000 --> 157.000] Over the last 30 years, the development of mythology, psychology with the progress of images and sound technologies, have allowed us to better understand some of the elements of charisma in politics. +[188.000 --> 195.000] This, princes, heads of states and political leaders have always tried to appear powerful and self-confidence. +[197.000 --> 208.000] It is part of the image a leader wants to project, and it is in a way what people expect from a leader. However, political body language has evolved greatly throughout history. +[209.000 --> 221.000] Just less than a century ago, when political leaders expressed themselves before thousands of people, they would stand on a rostrum, the crowd getting a glimpse of them from afar. +[222.000 --> 233.000] Their postures and voice intonation were the predominant elements of non-verbal communication. Their body language was of a very theatrical, even caricature like nature. +[233.000 --> 243.000] The development of television has affected the body language of politicians and the way they communicate with the public. +[244.000 --> 252.000] Television increased the power of images and propelled political leaders in close-up before audiences of millions of people. +[254.000 --> 261.000] These days, behavior of politicians cannot escape the cameras with their facial expressions, gestures and postures. +[264.000 --> 270.000] The excessive exposure of political personalities turns them into veritable media stars. +[279.000 --> 284.000] At the same time, information is treated practically in real time. +[285.000 --> 296.000] It arrives faster at a given point in time and in fragmented form, making it even more important to convince and gain acceptance within a matter of minutes. +[302.000 --> 312.000] Sometimes, people are convinced by ancient myths. Thus, in politics, nothing would matter, but what is actually said. +[313.000 --> 321.000] However, most voters know their politicians only through a TV screen, where the image is all mighty. +[324.000 --> 331.000] All of you will watch the same speeches of political leaders. Those of you in Group 1 will only have the images. +[332.000 --> 339.000] You in Group 2 will have the images and the voice. And you will have the images and the filtered voice. +[340.000 --> 345.000] So, I am going to ask you to choose just one emotion. +[346.000 --> 351.000] The image is all about the image. +[360.000 --> 367.000] For many Americans, these four months have brought sorrow and pain to fight it together. +[376.000 --> 381.000] The image is all about the image. +[382.000 --> 387.000] The image is all about the image. +[388.000 --> 394.000] The image is all about the image. +[397.000 --> 399.000] I have checked your answers. +[400.000 --> 405.000] So, the great majority of all groups has seen Ronald Reagan as a happy person. +[406.000 --> 408.000] Jacques-Sirac II. +[408.000 --> 418.000] Funny enough, Bush and even Blair appear to you as being worried, anxious or fearful. +[420.000 --> 433.000] The conclusion is that most observers correctly recognize the emotions of a political leader just by referring to his face, and this in less than two seconds. +[436.000 --> 449.000] Recently, experiments using MRI have confirmed that our reaction to a picture of a political leader is determined mostly by the emotional part of our brain. +[450.000 --> 455.000] With our visual brain, we judge the faces of unknown politicians either positively or negatively. +[455.000 --> 462.000] One second is just enough for us to vote for faces we find more competent or more attractive. +[462.000 --> 467.000] We are not going to vote for the face of a political leader. +[467.000 --> 472.000] We are not going to vote for the face of a political leader. +[472.000 --> 480.000] One second is just enough for us to vote for faces we find more competent or more attractive. +[480.000 --> 495.000] As a matter of fact, such decision involves less our rational cortex than the limbic system which is the center of our instinctive primary emotions. +[496.000 --> 505.000] Supporters of a leader may react to his or her smiling face just as in the case of love at first sight. +[505.000 --> 512.000] In their brain, the areas activated are those of happiness, pleasure. +[512.000 --> 517.000] The eye pupils tend to dilate unconsciously. +[517.000 --> 528.000] Opponents to the leader tend to contract their pupils and the areas activated in their brain are those of anger or disgust. +[528.000 --> 535.000] Our emotional brain makes us react like primates observing another member of the group. +[535.000 --> 545.000] Is he dominant, assured, self-confident? Does he make us feel secure? Or is he anxious, fearful, insecure? +[545.000 --> 548.000] And pain that will never completely go on. +[548.000 --> 555.000] These primary roots of politics have been studied by Professor Roger Masters for more than 20 years. +[555.000 --> 572.000] The basic characteristic of our primate heritage is that we have these ways of displaying feelings and potential actions with cues that tell other people what we're feeling and what we might do. +[576.000 --> 586.000] The human's facial display behavior is similar to that of non-human primates and there are three main types, fear, anger and happy reassurance. +[586.000 --> 593.000] This is the fear display. You see the brows are down, the eyes are open, aware of things in the environment. +[593.000 --> 597.000] The nose is breathing in air in case you need to flight, tight-lipped. +[597.000 --> 604.000] If you look at the anger threat display, you see very, very different. You can see both upper and lower teeth. +[605.000 --> 614.000] Brows are really intense. The reassurance and happy display, very, very different. The raised eyebrows, the eyes are not staring. +[614.000 --> 617.000] And there is the smile with both upper and lower teeth showing. +[617.000 --> 625.000] Politics is part of human nature. Aristotle described humans as the political animal. +[634.000 --> 650.000] The primates have, in general, the experience of leadership. There's some difference between the leader of the group and others in the group. +[650.000 --> 653.000] And in humans we have the same process. +[665.000 --> 668.000] Gestures and postures of leaders express dominance. +[668.000 --> 671.000] See, does a slogan I want to offer change we can believe in. +[671.000 --> 677.000] Leadership is about the combination of cooperation and competition. +[677.000 --> 687.000] This is true in primates. Among the great apes, the leader has to have the support of other members of the band. +[687.000 --> 693.000] In politics, before you run for president, you've got to get the nomination of your party. +[693.000 --> 705.000] So that clearly, the whole trick of combining competition with some people with cooperation and alliance with others is the name of the game. +[706.000 --> 712.000] Political campaign in humans, what is it? +[712.000 --> 720.000] It is basically energizing your base to get them to support you and to win over others. +[720.000 --> 724.000] But chimpanzees do the same thing. If normally the males are not very interested in babies. +[724.000 --> 729.000] And so in the same way that human politicians hold their babies and kiss them all the time during campaigns, +[729.000 --> 732.000] the chimpanzee males will do the same thing in order to become popular. +[732.000 --> 736.000] And if they are very popular, they are more successful at challenging somebody else. +[746.000 --> 750.000] Dear Governor Bush, thank you for coming to our school and for your visit. +[751.000 --> 767.000] That love can outlast hate that the light of human life can shine on through the most terrible darkness. +[767.000 --> 772.000] Our repertoire of facial displays is much richer than that of apes. +[772.000 --> 777.000] Our emotions are more complex and we have more facial muscles than our cousins, +[777.000 --> 782.000] which allows us to express blended emotions and a wider range of displays. +[782.000 --> 792.000] Professor Nikku Sibb has developed a computerized program allowing us to analyze the proportions of various emotions expressed on a face. +[793.000 --> 799.000] Our system is based on an apparent-based model. +[799.000 --> 812.000] So this means that we have a mask which is fitting on the face and this one will trace the movement of the facial muscles so that it will just reflect the actual facial expressions. +[812.000 --> 820.000] So when we construct the mask, we use a simplified model of the muscle of the face. +[821.000 --> 833.000] So what we have in there, we have pairs of 12 muscles and this one are used to capture the most predominant movement of the face, +[833.000 --> 838.000] like movement of the mouse, cheeks, eyebrows and upper part of the face. +[839.000 --> 844.000] Blair in this picture is showing a very clear expression of happiness. +[844.000 --> 850.000] He is extremely expressive and he shows all the characteristics of this emotion. +[850.000 --> 856.000] So the mouse wide open the eyes a little bit closer and he is very convincing. +[859.000 --> 861.000] Now how about Nikola Sarcosi? +[861.000 --> 868.000] Well, he is certainly just equilating a lot and I think his face is less charismatic than others. +[868.000 --> 871.000] And he has a very strange combination of different emotions. +[871.000 --> 874.000] Oh yes, we can see he has a sadness for example. +[880.000 --> 886.000] So he is not that expressive even though he is trying to emphasize this one by moving his hand. +[886.000 --> 894.000] Yes, but especially his less authoritative than people believe because people believe he has a very strong authority. +[894.000 --> 899.000] Now you can't have a strong authority if you are sad or if you are fearful. +[899.000 --> 908.000] George Bush is a very good example of the way he is combining contradictory facial expressions. +[908.000 --> 913.000] So you can see traces of happiness like 11% but on the other hand it is also angry and disgust. +[913.000 --> 915.000] And I think this is very characteristic of him. +[915.000 --> 924.000] So in some sense showing some very positive part and on the other hand he is very determined and a little bit sad and worried about the subject. +[929.000 --> 932.000] So in this sequence, the picture is Ronald Reagan. +[932.000 --> 935.000] You can see that he is a very good actor. +[935.000 --> 940.000] He can show good combination of emotions, so happy as he has a good smile. +[940.000 --> 945.000] And then some determination which is given by the angry and disgust. +[948.000 --> 959.000] In most of the cases, indeed as human beings we have different facial expressions when showing a neutral expression. +[959.000 --> 966.000] So the idea is that indeed some of the people will have a sad face or a more smiley face. +[967.000 --> 973.000] A good example of a politician who has a natural sad, neutral face will be George Bush. +[973.000 --> 978.000] And another example for example Tony Blair would be a more happy face. +[978.000 --> 983.000] What we notice is that in general we have blended emotions, that's true. +[983.000 --> 990.000] However in some cases like when the person showing happiness or surprise, you can see very high percentage of these emotions. +[990.000 --> 999.000] And from our experience it seems that the positive emotions tend to be more absolute and the negative emotions tend to be more blended. +[1006.000 --> 1014.000] Charismatic facial displays are clear signs of authority, dominance, all signs of happiness and joy. +[1014.000 --> 1017.000] But never signs of anxiety or sadness. +[1018.000 --> 1026.000] It is also necessary that facial displays are consistent with body postures and gestures, another very important element of charisma. +[1026.000 --> 1034.000] Imagine politicians that don't gesture, that have their hands and arms rigidly by their bodies. +[1034.000 --> 1042.000] You would find that very strange, you would find them not only stiff but also uncommunicative. +[1043.000 --> 1048.000] Most of the gestures that you see politicians make serve two main purposes. +[1048.000 --> 1051.000] One is simply to emphasize a point. +[1063.000 --> 1069.000] The other aspect is that with the change in the handshake or in the motion pattern, +[1069.000 --> 1072.000] the units of speech are marked off. +[1072.000 --> 1080.000] You knew the unit of speech begins with a new handshake or a new motion pattern. +[1080.000 --> 1090.000] So when you effectively view her, knows how to structure what she is hearing from watching the gesture of motion. +[1091.000 --> 1097.000] But there are also a number of more specific gestures or gestures that have more specific meanings. +[1097.000 --> 1110.000] To this day, politicians are very fond of making the gesture of the precision grip, which was already described in ancient Rome, in politicians during that time. +[1110.000 --> 1116.000] It is a gesture that what is being said right now is something very specific. +[1116.000 --> 1123.000] You pick out a specific object that you are talking about or you say something very specific about that object. +[1125.000 --> 1134.000] A very common kind of gesture that you find among politicians simply uses kind of chopping motion, a kind of slicing motion, +[1134.000 --> 1138.000] which is then made with a variety of different handshakes. +[1138.000 --> 1147.000] The precision grip and extended pointing index finger, a flat hand, which kind of emphasizes the slicing motion and so on. +[1147.000 --> 1156.000] The critical national security issue for our future and politics must stop at the schoolhouse door. +[1156.000 --> 1166.000] It is important that you look at the context in which the gesture is made and not believe that there is a fixed meaning to the particular gesture. +[1167.000 --> 1172.000] It is important that you can talk about that reality. +[1173.000 --> 1185.000] You do sometimes find politicians making iconic gestures as, for example, George W. Bush putting his hands as if he is strangulating something while he says the grip of terror. +[1185.000 --> 1194.000] Slowly but surely, the grip of terror around the throats of the Iraqi people is being loosened. +[1195.000 --> 1204.000] Another way of thinking about this gesture is to think about it as a metaphor because the word grip of terror, of course, is a metaphor. +[1204.000 --> 1209.000] And so the gesture emphasizes that metaphorical quality of its talk. +[1210.000 --> 1227.000] Among radical, populist, political leaders, you often find a body language that kind of runs against the established norms. +[1227.000 --> 1237.000] So by performing in an outrageous kind of manner, they seek to appeal to the masses that are fed up with the established political system. +[1238.000 --> 1257.000] A good example of that is Mussolini, who in this segment not only uses a very theatrical body motion, but also explains his concepts by gesture in a way that is very uncommon among established politicians. +[1258.000 --> 1264.000] Part of bodily behavior that we don't usually think much about is how people walk. +[1264.000 --> 1276.000] And it seems that in ancient Rome, there was a class of politicians gaining an influence during the Republic and they came from the provinces, from the country. +[1276.000 --> 1283.000] And they had a very different style of moving than the urban elite of Rome. +[1283.000 --> 1290.000] And so they embodied their politics by walking in what used to be called a rustic kind of way. +[1290.000 --> 1311.000] And so the tendency to moderate gesture has a lot to do with the way the human body is seen in Western culture. +[1312.000 --> 1319.000] Christianity plays a part in that. +[1319.000 --> 1333.000] And so for example, during the Middle Ages, when somebody gestured exuberantly that was seen as a sign that the person was unable to control his or her bodily urges, +[1333.000 --> 1347.000] to this day the prescription against all two expressive gestures is motivated by the idea that there is a lack of self control in the speaker. +[1348.000 --> 1365.000] Whereas as a communication scholar, I would say the more you gesture and the more complex your gestures are, the more you actually communicate with your audience. +[1365.000 --> 1377.000] I think we are experiencing a real renaissance of gesture and I think that this may have something to do with the visual nature of today's society. +[1378.000 --> 1385.000] Give me a break. This whole thing is the biggest fairy tale I've ever seen. +[1385.000 --> 1398.000] While the emotions, intent and expressiveness of our political leaders can be recognized in their facial expressions and body language, their ability to convince us is also highly dependent on voice quality and intonation. +[1398.000 --> 1413.000] The voice is linked to the way in which we communicate with each other and the world, which is not only a scientific but also a psychological element. +[1413.000 --> 1429.000] The voice is linked to the way in which we communicate with each other and the world, which is not only a scientific but also a psychological point of view. +[1430.000 --> 1438.000] The voice is linked to the speaker's intent and the speaker's intent can be heard by listening to the tone of voice. +[1443.000 --> 1453.000] The voice is linked to the tone of voice. +[1453.000 --> 1461.000] The voice is linked to the tone of voice. +[1461.000 --> 1471.000] The voice is linked to the tone of voice. +[1471.000 --> 1481.000] The voice represents the balance between the outside and the inside, between our thoughts and the expression of those thoughts. +[1481.000 --> 1491.000] There are several different voice types. Firstly, the head voices, which are characterized by a direction, especially the direction of the face. +[1491.000 --> 1496.000] Head voices make one appear important, often trying to be convincing. +[1496.000 --> 1503.000] We then have one voice similar to the head voice, the oral voice, that puts into play the vocal cavity. +[1503.000 --> 1519.000] For example, Tony Blair has a voice in which the mouth is active, giving the voice a sharp quality, the voice putting out treble harmonics with a forceful effect. +[1519.000 --> 1533.000] Another example of oral voice is that of Bill Clinton, who doesn't really have a deep resonating voice or chest voice, his voice is rather high pitched. +[1533.000 --> 1540.000] So it can be considered an oral voice with a relatively nasal quality. +[1540.000 --> 1550.000] At the special night-tell summit this summer, that is what we will begin to do. We must strengthen night-tell's partnership for peace with non-member allies. +[1550.000 --> 1559.000] We also have voices that emanate from the larynx, called throat voices. These voices are voices that are tight in the throat. +[1559.000 --> 1571.000] They indicate a search for words, where the word takes precedence over resonance, and so these voices are always less charismatic than resonating voices. +[1571.000 --> 1580.000] Voices that can make us feel especially ill at ease are those which use the throat in particular and emanate predominantly from the head. +[1580.000 --> 1589.000] The voice is not using the body as a whole, and is disturbing because it's throaty and stuck in the throat, as for former German foreign minister Mr. Fischer. +[1589.000 --> 1604.000] You promise a meeting at that high level before you know what the intentions are. I don't want to be used for propaganda purposes. +[1604.000 --> 1609.000] Hillary Clinton is someone whose voice is falsely self assured. +[1610.000 --> 1616.000] Her voice reveals a certain fragility, and its register is more from the larynx and head. +[1616.000 --> 1629.000] You couldn't say that Hillary Clinton has a chest voice, that is seductive or affirmative, as for Margaret Thatcher. +[1630.000 --> 1637.000] Together our nations have faced the challenges of our time, and have not flinched. +[1637.000 --> 1645.000] We forged ahead with strengthening the peace, spreading prosperity and safeguarding liberty. +[1645.000 --> 1658.000] Hillary Clinton plays on the emotional register for the very reason that the lack of assurance in her voice allows this emotional fragility to be heard without any attempt to disguise it. +[1659.000 --> 1672.000] The stomach voices are the most valued voices because they provide a solid base and abundant treble harmonics. +[1672.000 --> 1679.000] It's a voice you find in particular in Ronald Reagan, who had a good balance between base and treble. +[1680.000 --> 1691.000] He not only had a very sustaining voice, but a stomach voice that brought everything into play and gave him a balanced voice which was extremely harmonious. +[1692.000 --> 1698.000] The exemplar of freedom and a beacon of hope for those who do not now have freedom. +[1698.000 --> 1707.000] To those neighbors and allies who share our freedom, we will strengthen our historic ties and assure them of our support and firm commitment. +[1708.000 --> 1711.000] We will match loyalty with loyalty. +[1711.000 --> 1718.000] Another important element of the efficiency of vocal messages is the number of words per minute. +[1718.000 --> 1729.000] Money cannot buy it, power cannot compel it, technology cannot create it, it can only come from the human spirit. +[1730.000 --> 1741.000] Even if there are cultural differences between languages, tests have been done showing that usually the right pace is between 140 and 180 words per minute. +[1741.000 --> 1748.000] Under 140, the attention of the audience is decreasing and a feeling of boredom develops. +[1748.000 --> 1753.000] Over 180, the flow of words is too big and the message becomes unclear. +[1754.000 --> 1768.000] The United States respects rule of law, but in a debate on migration, the laws are also very important, although there are sometimes pauses marking hesitation and uncertainty. +[1777.000 --> 1782.000] But most of the time pauses are there to mark authority, emphasis or solemnity. +[1784.000 --> 1790.000] Thousands of lives were suddenly ended by evil, despicable acts of terror. +[1790.000 --> 1806.000] The pictures of airplanes flying into buildings, fires burning, huge structures collapsing, have filled us with disbelief, terrible sadness and acquired unyielding anger. +[1807.000 --> 1824.000] I think usually you find a lot of coherence or consistency in the different communicative media that we use in everyday communication, meaning gaze, gesture, body, posture and speech. +[1825.000 --> 1840.000] They go together in very subtle, very intricate ways, but every so often you find that there is a discrepancy between somebody's facial expression and the content of what the person is saying. +[1840.000 --> 1852.000] I think the American President Bush is an example of that. You often find him showing a facial expression that does not seem to congruent with the content of his speech. +[1852.000 --> 1863.000] One thing that is striking about the facial expression of George W. Bush is the asymmetry, and you can see that asymmetry especially clearly in his eyebrows. +[1863.000 --> 1878.000] When he uses his eyebrows, he raises his eyebrows to convey emphasis. They often end up in different position, one being higher than the other, and that makes his face look as if he finds what he is saying funny. +[1878.000 --> 1881.000] People have a very difficult time interpreting that. +[1881.000 --> 1885.000] But what was it wrong was the fact that he had the ability to make a weapon. +[1885.000 --> 1902.000] So the asymmetry of Bush's face is also visible in the mouth. His mouth is diagonal, and his face is longer on one side and shorter on the other. It is crooked as we say. +[1902.000 --> 1906.000] This is all in the context of war. +[1907.000 --> 1908.000] The war. +[1908.000 --> 1916.000] Coherence usually comes naturally, but when there is a lack of coherence, somebody needs help. +[1917.000 --> 1923.000] Growing up, she gave me love and lots of advice. I gave her white hair. +[1923.000 --> 1948.000] The public can, of course, sense at its emotional levels whether they are seeing a strong self-confident behavior or a behavior which is to some degree acting strong without really having that inner strength just subconsciously. +[1954.000 --> 1970.000] Political charisma and the impact of a leader depend heavily on the historical, cultural and social context of a country. +[1971.000 --> 1989.000] There is one kind of charisma which occurs when a society is under threat and a charismatic leader shows strength. +[1989.000 --> 2003.000] He shows he is not afraid of this threat and he can bring his entire society if they follow him to have enough self-confidence to overcome that threat. +[2003.000 --> 2011.000] Now, in Hitler's case, that involved showing tremendous amount of aggression in his non-verbal behavior. +[2011.000 --> 2024.000] If you look at a speech of Hitler's, at the beginning when he mounts on the podium, you can see some signs of insecurity. +[2042.000 --> 2053.000] What he was extremely clever about doing was to create a great deal of energy. He spoke with great force. +[2054.000 --> 2076.000] And then he had this trick of having trained his followers to have those shared emotions like he would say something instead of applause, the audience would all go, +[2076.000 --> 2090.000] and then he would say, well, this gave this image of enormous power because he was speaking with terrific energy and focus and triggering these wild responses of huge crowds. +[2090.000 --> 2099.000] And that was what was being presented in the media, remembering that the media in Hitler's time were movies. +[2099.000 --> 2110.000] The camera would be placed in a certain place which would make him look good and then the resulting film would be edited in a way to remove any sign of weakness. +[2110.000 --> 2118.000] That is, we have a very different world in TV because TV getches what's there. +[2119.000 --> 2136.000] Even though the political education of the public has developed over the past few decades, all the political imagery transmitted by television and modern media tends to lead people to operate on the principle of contrasting behaviors. +[2136.000 --> 2162.000] The brain instinctively produces a visual comparison of the different political leaders. Certain images are subconsciously memorized, politicians getting out of cars, smiling, shaking hands, but also expressions of nervousness, sadness or stress. +[2167.000 --> 2181.000] By quantifying the proportion of positive and negative expressions and postures, the public's brain spontaneously produces a comparative description in terms of authority, self-confidence and affinity. +[2182.000 --> 2197.000] The key to popularity is quite often found in the combination of three elements, authority, energy and happiness. +[2198.000 --> 2226.000] While there are differences between societies and cultures in what voters expect from their politicians and what kind of public performance they expect from their politicians, cultures of course also change over time and expectations change and they may change very rapidly. +[2227.000 --> 2235.000] You forecast two things. First, that the decade would be less dangerous if the West maintained the... +[2235.000 --> 2250.000] Changes in the expectations of the public usually reflect changes in the society and one of the major changes in many countries during the last few decades has been the growing role of women and the access of women to leading positions. +[2257.000 --> 2260.000] The future of our country. +[2260.000 --> 2271.000] Research has shown that women are more expressive than men, both in their spontaneity and interactivity, particularly with smiling and laughter, which can be their political weapons. +[2272.000 --> 2279.000] I think women tend to be more low-key in their public performances and not as... +[2279.000 --> 2289.000] They don't make the same kinds of attempts to project power in their gestures through their body language. +[2290.000 --> 2295.000] In certain times, in an increase, you will not escape the justice of this nation. +[2297.000 --> 2313.000] Men's postures, gestures and body communication are much more based on the primary patterns of the dominant male, whereas women play much more on a participative, exchange register and a more expressive and receptive. +[2320.000 --> 2333.000] In general, you can notice some statistical difference between men and women in the sense that women tend to be more happy, more enthusiastic. +[2333.000 --> 2340.000] And men seem to be more pragmatic in the sense that they show traces of angry or disgust. +[2340.000 --> 2350.000] However, there are different women, which are so-called strong women, which tend to show a lot of emotions that are characteristic to men. +[2350.000 --> 2367.000] Mr. President, when you welcome me to the White House, when the central state is in a better place, political combat and the predominance of men in politics, forces women to adopt the male style, displaying authority and sometimes aggressiveness. +[2368.000 --> 2374.000] So is to appear at least as credible and competent as their male counterparts. +[2380.000 --> 2396.000] The real challenge for a woman in politics is to find the right balance between displays of happiness, empathy, receptivity, which are more natural for women and more offensive displays of authority, which are more natural for men. +[2397.000 --> 2403.000] Hillary Clinton achieves this balance quite successfully. +[2411.000 --> 2417.000] Smiles and happiness contribute greatly to popularity, both for men and women. +[2417.000 --> 2423.000] Seduction is part of charisma, and smiling is a major weapon in seduction. +[2423.000 --> 2428.000] But what about the smiles of our political leaders? +[2435.000 --> 2444.000] Most of the smiles we make, unless we're having a great time, are not the true smiles of enjoyment. They're social smiles, they're agreement smiles. +[2445.000 --> 2451.000] Sometimes false smiles. The differences are very subtle. The difference is not in the lips, not in the cheeks. +[2451.000 --> 2462.000] It's in what's called the eye cover fold, this little patch of skin between your eyebrow and your upper eyelid, which slightly moves down if it's an enjoyment smile. +[2462.000 --> 2465.000] But very subtle, not easy to recognize. +[2465.000 --> 2478.000] In politics, all is a matter of balance between natural behaviour and control attitudes. +[2478.000 --> 2485.000] Even if rehearsed, the more natural it looks, the more efficient it will be. +[2485.000 --> 2494.000] It is important for politicians to have an accurate representation of their image, to be able to play on the right register, +[2494.000 --> 2497.000] depending on situations. +[2503.000 --> 2509.000] So in these conditions, can we expect our politicians to be spontaneous or to be sincere? +[2512.000 --> 2515.000] You know, I'm not going to comment on that. +[2515.000 --> 2525.000] I don't think you are likely to be elected to a high office, unless you're quite a good performer. +[2525.000 --> 2531.000] So yes, they do have the skills to be able to mislead us when they choose to do so. +[2531.000 --> 2535.000] And we probably all know that when we elect them. +[2535.000 --> 2542.000] Now in this country, in the United States, people say the characteristic they value most in a politician is honesty. +[2542.000 --> 2548.000] On the other hand, to everyone's very cynical about whether politicians ever really tell us the truth. +[2548.000 --> 2554.000] And we'll find out about the weapons of mass destruction that we all thought were there. +[2554.000 --> 2558.000] That's part of the Iraqi survey group and the group I've put together to look at. +[2558.000 --> 2568.000] My research shows very clearly that most people cannot tell when someone is long time from demeanor, from their face body voice and speech. +[2568.000 --> 2573.000] Less than 5%, who are at all accurate from demeanor. +[2573.000 --> 2577.000] Well, but what wasn't wrong was the fact that he had the ability to make a weapon. +[2577.000 --> 2585.000] Although there is no Pinocchio's nose, there are signs of an emotion that doesn't fit what we're saying. +[2585.000 --> 2590.000] Or they were thinking more than we would be expected to think. +[2590.000 --> 2596.000] How do you respond to critics who say that you brought the nation to war under false pretenses? +[2596.000 --> 2602.000] Yes. First of all, I expected to find the weapons. +[2602.000 --> 2605.000] There are these signs when we call them hot spots. +[2605.000 --> 2612.000] And when you see them, they suggest here's a place where you're not getting the full story, find out why. +[2612.000 --> 2616.000] Now, I have to go back to work on my state of the Union speech. +[2616.000 --> 2619.000] And I worked on it till pretty late last night. +[2619.000 --> 2623.000] But I want to say one thing to the American people. +[2623.000 --> 2626.000] I want you to listen to me. I'm going to say this again. +[2626.000 --> 2633.000] I did not have sexual relations with that woman, Ms. Lewinsky. +[2633.000 --> 2638.000] I never told anybody to lie, not a single time, never. +[2638.000 --> 2641.000] These allegations are false. +[2641.000 --> 2644.000] And I need to go back to work for the American people. +[2644.000 --> 2645.000] Thank you. +[2645.000 --> 2649.000] Thank you. +[2649.000 --> 2653.000] Where you see signs of a lie can vary from one person to another. +[2653.000 --> 2660.000] For him, it's in the use of distancing language, where he puts the person at a distance from himself. +[2660.000 --> 2665.000] So I never had sexual relations with that woman. +[2665.000 --> 2670.000] I did not have sexual relations with that woman. +[2670.000 --> 2677.000] It would have been more convincing if he said I never had sexual relations with Monica Lewinsky, rather than putting the distance. +[2677.000 --> 2681.000] So that is really the main suggestion that he's not telling the truth. +[2681.000 --> 2692.000] But we see before that, before he says a word, he sucks in and bites his lower lip, which is a mannerism that's not uncommon for him. +[2692.000 --> 2700.000] But he's a mannerism that you see in children who are about to tell you an untruth. +[2700.000 --> 2705.000] I tried to distinguish between truthfulness and lying. +[2705.000 --> 2708.000] And then there's a fuzzy area in between. +[2708.000 --> 2712.000] Now in a lie, I'm deliberately trying to mislead you. +[2712.000 --> 2715.000] And I've given you no reason to think that that's what I'm going to do. +[2715.000 --> 2718.000] It's like an actor can't lie. +[2718.000 --> 2722.000] Because you know that an actor is not going to be telling you the truth. +[2722.000 --> 2723.000] They're playing the role. +[2723.000 --> 2729.000] But if they're a good actor, then you are gripped by it and you believe it. +[2729.000 --> 2731.000] So is the actor lying? +[2731.000 --> 2734.000] No, he's not lying because you're notified. +[2734.000 --> 2742.000] In some sense, we don't expect politicians to tell us all the truth. +[2742.000 --> 2747.000] Certainly not in public, where it can be used by their domestic enemies. +[2747.000 --> 2749.000] And their international enemies. +[2749.000 --> 2753.000] I know you're worried. +[2753.000 --> 2757.000] First of all, if we are communist, +[2757.000 --> 2763.000] and of course, I have said very clear, +[2763.000 --> 2766.000] but we are not communist. +[2766.000 --> 2768.000] Very clear. +[2768.000 --> 2770.000] So can politicians lie? +[2770.000 --> 2775.000] In my definition, no, but they can deceive us and we expect them to deceive us. +[2775.000 --> 2779.000] Now in a democracy, that's a real problem. +[2779.000 --> 2783.000] Because if an electorate is not informed, how is it going to make a choice? +[2783.000 --> 2790.000] And yet, if everything that the politician says to us is heard by his opponents +[2790.000 --> 2795.000] and by his enemies, internationally, he can't tell us all the truth. +[2795.000 --> 2800.000] So it's an dilemma for which I don't have a solution. +[2805.000 --> 2807.000] Thank you. diff --git a/transcript/political_Hdf7eAwAlsc.txt b/transcript/political_Hdf7eAwAlsc.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a76868913f8019c9fb505a49af7023e8067b81a7 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_Hdf7eAwAlsc.txt @@ -0,0 +1,211 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.320] And you've been listening to live special coverage of the CBS News Vice Presidential +[4.320 --> 7.600] Debate from NPR. +[7.600 --> 13.480] I'm Asma Khalid, Senator JD Vance and Governor Tim Walls have been debating for, I would +[13.480 --> 15.760] say, the last hour and 45 minutes. +[15.760 --> 20.680] It was a civil policy heavy debate where the candidates claimed at several moments that +[20.680 --> 26.040] they agreed with one another, even if those nods of concurris papered over some big policy +[26.040 --> 27.040] disagreements. +[27.040 --> 28.440] We're going to break it all down for you. +[28.440 --> 33.760] And I'm joined here in the studio by NPR Susan Davis, Tamara Keith and Stephen Fowler. +[33.760 --> 35.400] It is great to have you with us. +[35.400 --> 39.360] Before we dive into this specifics, I want to get a quick take from each of you. +[39.360 --> 40.640] Sue, let's start with you. +[40.640 --> 46.000] I think if the guiding principle of vice presidential debates is do no harm, that tonight was a success +[46.000 --> 47.000] for both men. +[47.000 --> 48.920] They defended their running mates. +[48.920 --> 51.320] They appropriately attacked their opponents. +[51.320 --> 52.640] It was substantive. +[52.640 --> 54.760] And as you said, Asma, it was even cordial at times. +[54.760 --> 58.480] I think a lot of us were bracing for what could have been a more personal and negative +[58.480 --> 59.480] debate. +[59.480 --> 61.880] And it was surprisingly even Midwest nice. +[61.880 --> 62.880] It's our point. +[62.880 --> 63.880] I agree. +[63.880 --> 64.880] What about you, Stephen? +[64.880 --> 70.840] This was a sort of substantive, mostly civil debate over policy that has been missing from +[70.840 --> 75.880] kind of the discussions of Donald Trump and Kamala Harris and even Joe Biden earlier. +[75.880 --> 79.240] And it doesn't really reflect the reality of the presidential election. +[79.240 --> 84.160] I think the last section of the debate, talking about January 6th and the democracy and this +[84.160 --> 89.960] being a referendum on Donald Trump's vision of America, is what this race is about. +[89.960 --> 93.440] And I think that's going to stick more than all of the, I may be agree with you about +[93.440 --> 95.560] most things sometimes. +[95.560 --> 96.800] And Tam, what about you? +[96.800 --> 101.320] They certainly did what vice presidential candidates are supposed to do, which is not +[101.320 --> 105.680] focus on them, well, they focused on themselves a bit, but not focus on each other. +[105.680 --> 107.000] They didn't focus on each other. +[107.000 --> 109.280] They introduced themselves to voters. +[109.280 --> 112.680] And they really focused on the people running for president. +[112.680 --> 118.400] The people who the American public is actually going to vote for in the end because in reality +[118.400 --> 121.960] nobody is voting based on the vice president. +[121.960 --> 128.880] To Stephen's point, I think that it was really notable that while they were having this +[128.880 --> 135.880] very civil policy oriented debate, they also were kind of not addressing the reality of +[135.880 --> 141.560] this election, which is that it largely isn't a very civil policy oriented election. +[141.560 --> 143.800] It is about these very big questions. +[143.800 --> 150.400] And at one point near the end there, Walls asks Vance point blank, you know, did Donald +[150.400 --> 152.560] Trump win the election in 2020? +[152.560 --> 154.080] Did he lose the election? +[154.080 --> 160.160] And Vance pointedly just pivoted, didn't answer, very clearly didn't answer, which led +[160.160 --> 164.960] to this remark from Wall saying, well, who's going to honor the democracy or who's going +[164.960 --> 166.280] to honor Donald Trump? +[166.280 --> 170.440] That is the choice that voters have to answer for themselves. +[171.160 --> 173.800] I think that that was a big moment. +[173.800 --> 177.880] It also came well after bedtime. +[177.880 --> 181.320] So I want to go to one of the issues here if we can pivot for a moment. +[181.320 --> 185.000] You know, the debate started off with some of the key issues of the day. +[185.000 --> 187.760] Israel, Hurricane Helene, all of that. +[187.760 --> 193.520] But I think what really we saw sort of some of the fire here was on the issue of immigration. +[193.520 --> 195.960] Did you hear something there that sounded fundamentally new? +[195.960 --> 198.080] What did you think of their exchange? +[198.080 --> 202.240] You know, I do think that immigration is one of the grounds where I think that Republicans +[202.240 --> 204.160] feel like they're on their strongest footing. +[204.160 --> 208.000] And certainly when you look at the way the American public views about this issue, things +[208.000 --> 210.880] like increasing deportations has a lot of support. +[210.880 --> 214.640] It's one of the issues that I think Republicans feel on their strongest ground. +[214.640 --> 219.320] But at the same time, I think Tim Walls successfully kept going back to the point as that they +[219.320 --> 220.320] had a solution. +[220.320 --> 223.240] They had a solution that was written by a conservative Republican. +[223.240 --> 224.240] It was bipartisan. +[224.240 --> 229.680] It was supported by Border Patrol Union and Donald Trump did tell Congress not to vote +[229.680 --> 230.680] for it. +[230.680 --> 231.680] That is correct. +[231.680 --> 232.680] I covered that. +[232.680 --> 236.680] And Republicans opposed it and basically said we think we'll get a better deal under Donald +[236.680 --> 237.680] Trump. +[237.680 --> 243.640] But to say that Democrats don't have a solution, Republicans actually helped give Democrats +[243.640 --> 245.440] a solution in this Congress. +[245.440 --> 250.400] Stephen, I want to ask you about this immigration exchange because it was one of the feistered +[250.400 --> 251.400] moments of the debate. +[251.400 --> 255.200] There was a point where JD Vance was talking at length. +[255.200 --> 259.640] And so the moderators actually muted his Mike CBS did that at one point. +[259.640 --> 264.120] This is an issue that Vance has leaned in really, really heavily. +[264.120 --> 266.400] What did you make of how he engaged on it tonight? +[266.400 --> 271.200] I mean, one of the centerpieces of both Donald Trump and JD Vance's campaign, the cycle +[271.200 --> 273.320] is tying everything to immigration. +[273.320 --> 274.320] Let's talk about housing. +[274.320 --> 278.480] No, housing is actually immigration policy, according to Vance and according to Republicans. +[278.480 --> 284.200] And he also did what Donald Trump has largely failed to do and tie it back to Kamala Harris +[284.200 --> 286.120] being the vice president now. +[286.120 --> 290.040] You heard him say several times that if Kamala Harris wanted to fix things, she could do +[290.040 --> 291.040] it right now. +[291.040 --> 292.720] She's been the vice president for three years. +[292.720 --> 294.160] There's executive action. +[294.160 --> 298.640] Or he pointed out that a lot of the promises made are something that only Congress can address. +[298.640 --> 304.840] But that just goes back to how they view immigration as the central policy plank of Trump's +[304.840 --> 306.800] vision of a future America. +[306.800 --> 309.480] It's very dystopian that's very dire. +[309.480 --> 311.480] That's very anti-immigrant. +[311.480 --> 316.640] I mean, Vance mentioned in passing the comments about temporary protected status and about +[316.640 --> 322.600] how the Haitian migrants that he villainized in his constituency of Springfield, Ohio, Vance +[322.600 --> 327.120] views, even though they are here legally, he says and is set on the trail that they're +[327.120 --> 333.840] not actually legal migrants because he views that what Harris and Trump and Republican +[333.840 --> 338.080] or what Harris and Biden have done is actually unlawful and illegal. +[338.080 --> 341.840] So that is the centerpiece of the campaign and you saw that on display tonight. +[341.840 --> 342.840] Yeah. +[342.840 --> 346.480] I want to ask you all about another issue and that is the issue of abortion. +[346.480 --> 348.720] This is something that Democrats have leaned in heavily. +[348.720 --> 353.200] We have seen when the issue has been put directly to voters in state after state ever since +[353.200 --> 354.920] Roe was overturned. +[354.920 --> 357.640] Voters have often chosen to expand abortion rights. +[357.640 --> 362.120] And so I want to ask you about this because what I heard from JD Vance tonight was, you +[362.120 --> 365.640] know, we heard from walls was he sort of leaning into the traditional argument around +[365.640 --> 367.240] freedom, reproductive rights. +[367.240 --> 368.720] It should be a woman's choice. +[368.720 --> 372.760] What I heard from Vance tonight sounded different than what I had heard from the Republican +[372.760 --> 373.760] before. +[373.760 --> 374.760] It is how different he was. +[374.760 --> 377.160] I think that was one of the most telling moments of this debate and substantively +[377.160 --> 378.720] on the policy. +[378.720 --> 380.440] I don't think we heard much new. +[380.440 --> 384.160] And I think, you know, if Republicans feel strong on immigration, Democrats feel really +[384.160 --> 386.280] strong talking about abortion and reproductive rights. +[386.280 --> 392.160] But look, coming into this, JD Vance has said a lot of cruel and crass things about women +[392.160 --> 393.840] and about abortion. +[393.840 --> 397.480] And one of the things I was listening for tonight is how does he talk about this stuff? +[397.480 --> 400.320] And it was a much more compassionate tone from him. +[400.320 --> 404.400] He talked about knowing and loving a woman and had a friend who had an abortion who even +[404.400 --> 408.560] said to this day, she doesn't regret it and that he understands that position that he +[408.560 --> 413.440] wants women in this country to have more options, that he wants to have a more pro family +[413.440 --> 414.440] party. +[414.440 --> 419.480] And most interestingly, very candidly acknowledged that the Republican party has been bad on this +[419.480 --> 424.600] issue across the board and that his party has to do better, making women feel like they +[424.600 --> 426.040] have a voice in their party. +[426.040 --> 430.560] I don't think he necessarily offered a solution to do that for women, but I think the first +[430.560 --> 433.520] step of addressing a problem is acknowledging you haven't. +[433.520 --> 435.000] And he very candidly did that tonight. +[435.000 --> 437.040] He didn't finish the sentence, though. +[437.040 --> 438.040] Right. +[438.040 --> 442.560] You know, when he talks about pro family and women having lots of options, he, you know, +[442.560 --> 447.400] didn't explain how that would work necessarily other than, you know, that there'd be more +[447.400 --> 452.920] money for childcare or perhaps there'd be better options for them to have jobs. +[452.920 --> 457.040] But he didn't talk about the healthcare side of it. +[457.040 --> 462.000] Walls continued to try to bring it back to the healthcare side of it, talked about women +[462.000 --> 466.840] who had very serious health challenges that needed abortion procedures that were unable +[466.840 --> 470.600] to get them or had to wait until they were very sick. +[470.600 --> 475.200] And, and Vance didn't really have an answer for that other than, well, state should decide +[475.200 --> 477.200] and some states are more conservative than others. +[477.200 --> 481.660] So I want to ask Stephen and Tam, both of you, you cover Vance and you've covered walls +[481.660 --> 482.660] respectively here. +[482.660 --> 488.120] If I can just get brief assessments from you of if we learned anything fundamentally new +[488.120 --> 492.240] about both of these men, I would say they are fairly unknown on the national stage, +[492.240 --> 493.520] Stephen, let's start with you. +[493.520 --> 499.880] I think what JD Vance said tonight and how he said it as much different than how he's presented +[499.880 --> 501.600] himself in the campaign trail. +[501.600 --> 504.800] It's very different from how Democrats have portrayed him. +[504.800 --> 511.640] This was a JD Vance that has a civil idea about the future and how Republican policy is +[511.640 --> 512.640] doing it. +[512.640 --> 515.040] But the reality is that's not what he's like on the trail. +[515.040 --> 520.080] And the campaign had this preview call before the debate to set expectations. +[520.080 --> 521.760] They said Vance was going to do awesome. +[521.760 --> 526.520] And they previewed a very aggressive antagonistic Vance that was not on display. +[526.520 --> 528.880] Some of it is because they didn't know what questions were going to be asked. +[528.880 --> 532.720] And so some of the things that they prepared for did not actually go out there. +[532.720 --> 537.240] But what Vance did tonight was also ultimately for an audience of one. +[537.240 --> 538.640] And that is Donald Trump. +[538.640 --> 544.040] And so Vance said and did a lot of things that will look good for Trump and look good for +[544.040 --> 550.320] Trump's base and supporters, but doesn't necessarily overcome the 11 weeks that he's +[550.320 --> 555.040] been the nominee where there have been negative headline after negative headline after negative +[555.040 --> 558.840] headline that's led to him being one of the most unpopular vice presidential nominees +[558.840 --> 559.840] in history. +[559.840 --> 560.840] Yeah. +[560.840 --> 563.560] One thing you mentioned that they were forecasting telegraphing would come up was this issue +[563.560 --> 564.800] of military service. +[564.800 --> 566.800] We actually did not hear at all about that. +[566.800 --> 567.800] What about you, Tim? +[567.800 --> 572.160] What did we hear or learn from Tim Walls that seems maybe new? +[572.160 --> 573.160] Yeah. +[573.160 --> 579.840] And just to go back to Vance, I think he did a very skillful job of injecting his biography +[579.840 --> 584.880] into almost every single answer, making his story relatable to the public. +[584.880 --> 589.120] And the fact is he didn't really have a vice presidential rollout. +[589.120 --> 595.000] He was picked on the first day of the convention and the rollout was his speech the next day. +[595.000 --> 599.760] And so this was a chance for him to speak to a very large audience and introduce himself +[599.760 --> 601.920] and he did that quite effectively. +[601.920 --> 606.600] Walls, yes, I have consumed a lot of Walls content more than most Americans. +[606.600 --> 608.960] I didn't really learn anything new about Walls. +[608.960 --> 615.800] I think he did on the question about him sort of flubbing the timeline of when he visited +[615.800 --> 619.120] China around the TNM and Square Massacre. +[619.120 --> 622.320] He said, sometimes I'm a knucklehead. +[622.320 --> 624.760] Sometimes I say the wrong things. +[624.760 --> 630.480] He definitely did a decent job at times of conveying sort of the, hey, I'm just a regular +[630.480 --> 631.480] guy. +[631.480 --> 634.880] I know I'm wearing a suit right now, but I'm just a regular guy. +[634.880 --> 637.000] Sometimes I screw up. +[637.000 --> 638.240] He did a fairly good job of that. +[638.240 --> 644.520] He also did a rather good job of promoting Vice President Harris and attacking former +[644.520 --> 649.120] President Trump, which is exactly what you want them to do in a vice presidential debate. +[649.120 --> 654.920] And certainly, certainly, Vance found every opportunity to blame Vice President Harris +[654.920 --> 655.920] for almost everything. +[655.920 --> 660.080] Sue, if I could ask you ever so briefly for your closing thoughts, do you think this fundamentally +[660.080 --> 661.800] changes the state of the race? +[661.800 --> 665.720] I don't, but I think they both prove themselves why they're capable running mates tonight. +[665.720 --> 669.160] And part of the test tonight is to give their own ready on day one energy. +[669.160 --> 673.320] And I think that they both made very clear concise arguments for why they should be elected. +[673.320 --> 674.320] All right. +[674.320 --> 676.520] Sue, Tim, Stephen, thank you all so much. +[676.520 --> 678.120] And thank you all who have been listening. +[678.120 --> 682.120] We're going to leave it there, but there will be lots more analysis tomorrow on morning +[682.120 --> 683.120] edition. +[683.120 --> 685.840] And you can always find us at npr.org. +[685.840 --> 690.400] This has been live special coverage of the CBS News, Vice Presidential Debate from NPR. +[690.400 --> 691.640] I must my Khaled. +[691.640 --> 693.840] Thank you all so much for joining us. +[693.840 --> 695.320] This is NPR News. diff --git a/transcript/political_ISdFkyJrfOc.txt b/transcript/political_ISdFkyJrfOc.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..111912800ff6215c20dfb4063a5b6051ef3aabd6 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_ISdFkyJrfOc.txt @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +[0.000 --> 7.000] Here's a lesson from Simon Sinek about how to start a speech watch. +[7.000 --> 12.000] So I'm embarrassed. +[12.000 --> 17.000] The moment he says I'm embarrassed, you're immediately hooked because you want to know +[17.000 --> 22.000] why is he embarrassed? Why is he sharing something vulnerable right off the bat? +[22.000 --> 24.000] I have a career. +[25.000 --> 31.000] I talk about things like trust and cooperation and there should be no demand for my work. +[31.000 --> 35.000] So far it all sounds normal to your wondering why is he embarrassed? +[35.000 --> 41.000] But the fact of the matter is there is demand for my work which means that there's an opportunity. +[41.000 --> 47.000] It means that trust and cooperation are not yet standard in our organizations and yet they should be and we know that. +[47.000 --> 48.000] Which is what? +[48.000 --> 56.000] He does something so brilliantly. He not only gets your attention but he also states what the problem is and why he's there to talk about it. diff --git a/transcript/political_NINQjgyMEwI.txt b/transcript/political_NINQjgyMEwI.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..193686bb85528596cee6b78b098b2b9d42cbf2ba --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_NINQjgyMEwI.txt @@ -0,0 +1,84 @@ +[0.000 --> 20.080] Speaking in public is a challenge. And a challenge I believe must be accepted. What do you think? +[20.080 --> 27.160] We all have that moment on the stage when we go blank. Have you ever freeze on the stage? +[27.160 --> 30.200] Well I have seriously freeze on the stage once at my school. +[30.200 --> 34.840] Speaking in front of the crowd means having to go through sleepless nights, +[34.840 --> 41.640] nervousness, deadlines and many rounds to the toilet when you're just about to start. +[41.640 --> 48.200] Am I right? Okay guys my name is Michelle and today I'm going to share with you some valuable +[48.200 --> 55.240] suggestions that will help you speak better publicly. So stay tuned to this session as I share some tips +[55.240 --> 60.360] to help you understand the mistakes that you've been committing all this while while speaking +[60.360 --> 65.160] publicly. You're watching Skillopedia, the place to learn skills for the real world. +[70.040 --> 76.520] There is an age old saying, a good speech is like a pencil. It has to have a point. +[77.640 --> 84.680] For this very reason you might sit the entire week to frame the right points by adding some +[84.680 --> 90.920] big words and some very good vocabulary to make it look good. You might also make enough power +[90.920 --> 98.600] point presentations with pictures, graphics and figures. But you're losing on something here. +[99.160 --> 104.840] The majority of your time would be spent on preparing the content for the event as in what you're +[104.840 --> 112.600] going to speak. But what we miss out is how to speak. We spend a lot of time thinking what to say +[113.320 --> 121.720] but not enough time thinking how to say. So let me give you a heads up. I mean let me tell you +[122.360 --> 130.120] how the figures are. Researchers say that lasting impression is more directly tied to our voice +[130.120 --> 137.400] and body language. So to my shock, content and words play only 7% of the role in communicating. +[138.040 --> 143.320] And I was absolutely surprised to find out. Then what does the other 93% depend on? +[143.880 --> 152.280] If it's not about what you're saying, then voice takes 38% and body language 55% of what you're +[152.280 --> 158.920] speaking. Isn't that a shocking statistic to you? A person's ability to speak and communicate +[158.920 --> 165.160] to an audience largely depends on the body language rather than on the content rather than on what +[165.160 --> 170.600] you're speaking. So body language is like a text you send to a friend. If you're polite and +[170.600 --> 176.440] funny, the wipes are good. But if you put in sarcasm, you mess up the good conversation. +[177.240 --> 183.240] So if your body language is not nice, you mess up your entire relationship with the audience +[183.240 --> 189.080] during the public speech. So make sure you don't hurt the sentiments of the people who are listening +[189.880 --> 195.080] to you. Rather, you focus on a positive and happy way to deliver your speech which is best +[195.080 --> 201.480] reflected in your body language and your voice. So concentrate on how to say more than what to say. +[206.440 --> 211.480] First and foremost, it's important that we not only make a lasting impression, +[212.040 --> 218.200] but that we make a positive one. Yes, let me tell you about my professor back in college. +[218.280 --> 226.600] He was a kind of weird guy. He would take long pauses while speaking like this. But whenever he +[226.600 --> 233.560] spoke, the message glued to my memory forever, which means I could not forget what he said and he +[233.560 --> 239.720] had a great sense of humor on top of that. And that is what attracted most of the students from +[239.720 --> 244.120] my class. We all came from different parts of India and different parts of the world, +[244.200 --> 249.000] but when we heard him, we were all laughing on the same joke and listening to him very carefully. +[249.800 --> 255.480] But apart from humor, it's important to look at your audience. That's what he did. When he +[255.480 --> 262.360] took those pauses, he used to look at us. So don't keep your eyes fixed on his spot. Rather, +[262.360 --> 268.440] watch across the entire hall making meaningful eye contact with your audience. This will help you +[268.440 --> 275.000] connect better to them. And there is no better way of explaining a point than using examples from +[275.000 --> 280.680] daily life. Like I'm telling you about my professor, you could also tell about one of your experiences +[280.680 --> 286.200] from your school or your college days or maybe even from your workplace. Because examples help +[286.200 --> 292.360] to relate to the topic much better than anything else. Trust me, I used them too. So you must add +[292.360 --> 298.520] examples, have a nice body language and look at your audience and you're in for a great speech. +[303.400 --> 309.080] The start of your speech is the most important part. Walk in your room smartly. +[309.800 --> 317.080] Lay your notes on the podium. Look up. Keep your chin high and greet them with a warm smile. +[317.800 --> 323.640] Make them believe that you know what you're doing. It always gives one a lot of comfort when the +[323.640 --> 329.240] other one has everything under control. So if they think that you don't know what you are saying, +[329.240 --> 335.720] that's going to be a problem. So be the one who has everything under control. The best way I think +[335.720 --> 343.400] to capture the audience's attention is to think about a clear and a strong phrase that people could +[343.400 --> 350.440] relate to. When I was in school, I still remember the head boy would often come to the podium +[350.440 --> 355.720] and raise his fist during the lunch break and say, defend your turf. What does that mean? +[356.360 --> 362.440] That means to take care of your belongings. Well, he used to say that because our bags used to be +[362.440 --> 368.680] overloaded with food when we returned from our home after the winter break. So that used to make +[368.760 --> 374.200] everyone laugh and we all used to listen carefully after that to everything he said. +[375.000 --> 381.800] Did you notice all he did was he chose a strong, a funny and an interesting phrase to start his +[381.800 --> 388.680] conversation. And this is what you should do. If you want the audience to relate to you easily, +[388.680 --> 395.640] it is always a great way to start this speech with a light-minded, nice and strong phrase that could +[395.640 --> 407.320] capture their attention. Unfortunately, even though we are human beings, we stand almost like we sit, +[408.120 --> 414.360] which is so horrible. Never has a person who has dragged himself on the stage, +[415.000 --> 421.800] slouching, attracted anyone's attention. You know what I mean? Most of us don't realize that much +[421.800 --> 428.840] of our confidence actually depends on the way we place our chin. Too high often gives off an +[428.840 --> 435.320] attitude or arrogance to the people. Well, too low shows that you're very nervous. So what should +[435.320 --> 441.000] you do? Well, my suggestion is that you must observe yourself in the mirror by exploring different +[441.000 --> 448.040] angles until you find the most appropriate one. And trust me, it will be a plus point when you have +[448.040 --> 455.800] a good body posture. Curved back and slouching shoulders give the picture of a bookworm that has +[455.800 --> 460.600] not left his seat for long. So that shows that you've been preparing for your speech for so long, +[460.600 --> 466.280] but you're not able to deliver it nicely because your body posture is not perfect. So if you can +[466.280 --> 471.240] get taller without lifting your feet off the ground, then what you need to do is you need to make +[471.240 --> 476.120] sure that your back is straight and that's how you present yourself when you start your speech. +[481.240 --> 487.480] Now let me tell you some things that you shouldn't do when you're speaking publicly. Kindly note +[487.480 --> 494.120] them down. You should not look down or off into space where there are no people. What I mean is +[494.200 --> 501.800] you should make meaningful eye contact. And please never start speaking before you have reached the +[501.800 --> 506.920] front of the room. Start speaking when you're comfortable and when you're on the podium and you've +[506.920 --> 514.280] got everything in place. And yes, please don't play with your hair, okay, or lean on one side. +[515.320 --> 521.160] And it's really not a good idea to point with the finger what you use an open palm like this. +[521.960 --> 528.760] And I recommend that you don't fold your arms or cross your legs. And it's also not good to sway +[528.760 --> 536.680] from side to side because you're not exercising and do not turn your back to the audience because +[536.680 --> 543.560] that is a very bad sign and it shows like you're not interested. So these are the don'ts of public +[543.560 --> 550.840] speaking. I hope my tips have benefited you today and to top it all, you must remember that +[550.840 --> 556.760] nothing can be achieved without confidence. So before you work on anything else that I've +[556.760 --> 563.800] told you today, make sure that whatever you speak has loads of confidence and you speak it with +[563.800 --> 569.400] courage. So these are the tips for public speaking for you and I hope they're very useful for you as +[569.400 --> 574.680] well. Thank you for watching me on Skillopedia. The place to learn skills for the real world. +[574.680 --> 576.680] I'll see you guys very soon. Bye-bye. diff --git a/transcript/political_Tci9kO38q6w.txt b/transcript/political_Tci9kO38q6w.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5e1c585745f3b42358964bce6f3807a165a20821 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_Tci9kO38q6w.txt @@ -0,0 +1,35 @@ +[0.000 --> 6.000] The highly anticipated summit between President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin +[6.000 --> 9.920] began with a meeting in Helsinki, Finland's ornate Gothic Hall. +[9.920 --> 13.520] But their interactions from the start were tense and awkward. +[13.520 --> 18.400] Trump leaned forward in his chair, winking slightly at Putin before adjusting for him to speak +[18.400 --> 19.400] first. +[19.400 --> 24.760] Putin, for his part, appeared slightly bored at times, avoiding eye contact with Trump, +[24.760 --> 27.080] leaning sideways in his chair. +[27.080 --> 32.240] His famous slouch appeared in sharp contrast to President Trump's classic power stance, +[32.240 --> 34.760] portraying a demeanor that lacked interest. +[34.760 --> 38.840] The two exchanged a very brief handshake as that meeting ended. +[38.840 --> 43.400] The power play between the two alpha males was more muted later, as Trump sought to cement +[43.400 --> 46.960] a new, stronger relationship between the two countries. +[46.960 --> 53.400] Our relationship has never been worse than it is now. +[53.400 --> 61.840] However, that changed as of about four hours ago. +[61.840 --> 66.000] The news conference was punctured by moments of camaraderie between the leaders. +[66.000 --> 70.740] Putin acknowledged Trump's praise of the world cup, hosted by Russia, handing him a soccer +[70.740 --> 71.740] ball. +[71.740 --> 78.120] Mr. President, I'll give this ball to you and other bullies in your court. +[78.120 --> 82.520] But when asked about election meddling, Putin appeared to smirk while Trump maintained +[82.520 --> 85.960] that he didn't believe Russia meddled in the U.S. elections. +[85.960 --> 86.960] Trump may have indicted him. +[86.960 --> 91.120] And the final question posed by associated press reporter Jonathan Lumiere, landed itself +[91.120 --> 94.720] to an awkward silence, followed by laughter in the room. +[94.720 --> 106.440] Does the Russian government have any compromise in material on President Trump or his family? +[106.440 --> 111.200] Putin said he hadn't been aware of Trump's visit to Moscow a few years before his 2016 +[111.200 --> 114.960] election and dismissed the claims as sheer nonsense. +[114.960 --> 120.960] Well, please, just disregard these issues and don't think about this anymore again. +[120.960 --> 125.640] From their Trump quickly pivoted to criticizing the testimony of an FBI agent who was removed +[125.640 --> 128.240] from the special counsel's Russia investigation. +[128.240 --> 131.040] And you would say that was a total witch hunt. +[131.040 --> 132.480] Thank you very much, everybody. +[132.480 --> 133.480] Thank you. +[133.480 --> 138.680] The two leaders exchanged a longer warmer handshake before walking off stage, ignoring questions +[138.680 --> 141.080] shouted by reporters. +[141.080 --> 142.880] Noreen Nasr, the Associated Press. diff --git a/transcript/political_VRJzvJ5XPQI.txt b/transcript/political_VRJzvJ5XPQI.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b35dd443cd4e5eb7fc8bfb3d664f3cd11abd8b3c --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_VRJzvJ5XPQI.txt @@ -0,0 +1,133 @@ +[0.000 --> 7.000] People that are supremely confident, when they enter the room, they feel comfortable in that room. +[7.000 --> 11.000] They don't hesitate to look around. +[11.000 --> 16.000] Their gestures are smooth, but they're very broad. +[16.000 --> 19.000] And that has to do with confidence. +[19.000 --> 22.000] And for a lot of people, this is very difficult. +[23.000 --> 34.000] I remember the great actress, Ellen Maren, saying one of the most difficult things to learn as an actress is how to walk onto a scene. +[34.000 --> 49.000] I've thought about that even in my career, how early on the difficulty of mastering that, how do you walk onto a crime scene, how do you walk into the public and demonstrate that I am confident and so forth. +[50.000 --> 57.000] We can all work a little bit on our nonverbal, so we come across as more confident. +[62.000 --> 66.000] When we talk about confidence, it's so many things. +[66.000 --> 72.000] It has to do with our posture, the way we present, how we look. +[72.000 --> 76.000] Where's our chin? Where are the eyes looking and gazing? +[76.000 --> 80.000] Our gestures are loose, but they're smoother. +[80.000 --> 85.000] As we walk about, we walk as though we are on a mission. +[85.000 --> 92.000] I'm walking out to shake your hand, or I'm walking out to a podium, or I'm walking to where I'm going to sit. +[92.000 --> 101.000] So the less confident we are, the less eye contact we make, the less confident we are, the more reluctant we are to look about. +[101.000 --> 106.000] When I look at someone I admire, like Colin Powell, when he walks onto a stage. +[106.000 --> 116.000] Even before he speaks, he has total command of the room, and he does that, because he brings two things into this equation. +[116.000 --> 121.000] One is a tremendous amount of knowledge and experience. +[121.000 --> 126.000] Plus, he has shaped and defined himself into a statesman. +[126.000 --> 130.000] We've got to think of America as a family, where every member of the family cares about every other member of the family. +[131.000 --> 140.000] I think sometimes people mistake machismo or theatrical displays of power as confidence. +[140.000 --> 143.000] Confidence can be very quiet. Jane Goodall. +[143.000 --> 150.000] Here's this ethylogist, very meek, very mild, and yet wherever she goes she commands the room. +[150.000 --> 161.000] One of the things you notice is they sort of have this command of themselves, and in doing so that command transmits outward. +[161.000 --> 168.000] The other thing that confident people realize is the temporal aspect of leadership. +[168.000 --> 171.000] If you're in charge, you're in charge of time. +[171.000 --> 177.000] I'm going to take my time to walk out. I'm going to take my time to answer your question. +[177.000 --> 189.000] I will answer it in the pace, manner, and tone that I choose, and in doing that we are demonstrating that we are confident and in control. +[193.000 --> 197.000] Where do we get that confident voice? Where do we get those confident gestures? +[197.000 --> 203.000] This is what's called socialization. We notice the principle who acts this way. +[203.000 --> 212.000] I like this leader because of this or that trait. I try to model their behaviors and say this is a shortcut. +[212.000 --> 217.000] If I have to work on my vocabulary, that's what high status people do. +[217.000 --> 224.000] If I have to change my gestures to fit in in this society, then that's what I'm going to have to do. +[224.000 --> 234.000] That doesn't mean it changes me completely. It just means that this is what is required of me, and this is what I want to achieve at this moment in time. +[234.000 --> 246.000] I think of Carrie Grant. Here's an individual born in the UK, grew up very poor, and as he said in his biography, I became Carrie Grant. +[246.000 --> 252.000] I adopted all the behaviors that I saw from high status individuals. +[252.000 --> 255.000] Just think about that, but make up your mind. +[255.000 --> 269.000] It is difficult to prescribe this, but one of the easiest things that we can do, if you're a woman, maybe you want to model yourself on the actress Kate Blanchett or some other actor and say, +[269.000 --> 278.000] when they're being interviewed, how do they look? They look so confident. They look interesting. They have such a command presence. +[278.000 --> 290.000] We're not born this way. These are things that we have to develop and say, how do I want to be perceived? What can I do to achieve that? +[290.000 --> 297.000] Are there better behaviors that you can do? Here's a simple one. How many of you, somebody says, where do they go? +[297.000 --> 306.000] Like this. As it turns out, this is one of the most hated signs around the world. Yet, if we just go like this, he went that way. +[306.000 --> 317.000] We're already perceived differently. Little things. I tell the story often of when I first came into law enforcement, they said, well, you've got to get out there and make some arrests. +[317.000 --> 321.000] The first time I went out there and my voice just went really high. +[321.000 --> 333.000] Stop your under arrest. That sounds horrible. And you have to work at having that command presence where you say, stop right there. Don't move. +[333.000 --> 340.000] That's almost theatrical. Yeah, but it's what is needed. +[340.000 --> 347.000] So let's do this exercise. I want you to say no. Just go ahead. Say it out loud. +[347.000 --> 356.000] All right. Now let's do it right. Say it as I say it. No. No. No. +[356.000 --> 363.000] Do you see the difference between the way you said it and this way? Did you notice that your voice kept getting deeper? +[363.000 --> 374.000] But did you also notice that the fingers became wider and wider? The more confident you became, the wider your fingers were spreading. +[374.000 --> 385.000] There's a big difference between saying no. Stop and going no. Stop. This potentiates the message. +[385.000 --> 392.000] But to get to this, we actually have to practice it. So let's do it again. No. +[392.000 --> 396.000] Now go out there and teach your children how to do that. +[396.000 --> 404.000] I love sometimes selfies in the mirror. One of my pet peeves is, well, we hear every day with what's called uptalk. +[404.000 --> 412.000] Uptalk is where someone says something and then they end making it sound like a question mark. So it sounds like this. +[412.000 --> 417.000] Four score and seven years ago. Four score and seven years ago. +[417.000 --> 427.000] Our fathers brought forth on this continent. Our fathers brought forth upon this continent a new nation. +[427.000 --> 436.000] My company has done research on this and we've asked CEOs and we've asked executives and some will say, well, you know, I've gotten used to it and so forth. +[436.000 --> 442.000] But when we ask them, does it really matter? They also, yeah, we'd rather not see it. +[442.000 --> 449.000] I get pushed back from people that say, well, you know, this is just the way that I speak and no doubt. +[449.000 --> 453.000] But don't expect the same results. +[456.000 --> 460.000] We choose to go to the moon and disdicate and do the other things. +[460.000 --> 472.000] Not because they are easy, but because they are hard. Because that goal will serve to organize and measure the best of our energies and skills. +[474.000 --> 479.000] The cadence in our speech is extremely powerful for a couple of reasons. +[479.000 --> 489.000] One, we know that when people machine gun a statement, when they talk very fast, we are less likely to listen to them over a long period of time. +[489.000 --> 497.000] But when we talk in cadence, we are sort of held still listening to what will come next. +[497.000 --> 503.000] And I'll give you an example from that great speech Martin Luther King gave. +[503.000 --> 507.000] As you notice with the cadence, I have a dream. +[507.000 --> 508.000] I have a dream. +[508.000 --> 511.000] And then he pauses that one day. +[511.000 --> 512.000] One day. +[512.000 --> 514.000] And then he goes on. +[514.000 --> 517.000] And Churchill used the same thing. +[517.000 --> 524.000] Churchill's notes literally would create spaces for how long he would pause. +[524.000 --> 533.000] From stepping in the Baltic to triest in the Adriatic, an iron curtain has descended across the continent. +[533.000 --> 537.000] These pauses make people listen. +[537.000 --> 546.000] And one of the things that we teach is if you want people to listen to you, use cadence to get their attention, +[546.000 --> 552.000] hold their attention, but then look forward to what that next set of words will be. +[552.000 --> 557.000] It lets them know at a subconscious level, this is the person in charge. +[557.000 --> 567.000] And we know that they're in charge because they have temporal control over this. They're not in a hurry. +[568.000 --> 577.000] So you know a lot of times people say to me, well, does confidence look like chest out, shoulders back, chin up? +[577.000 --> 579.000] Yeah, that looks pretty good. +[579.000 --> 584.000] But you know a lot of times confidence is just sitting comfortably in a chair. +[584.000 --> 589.000] And that may have more to do with how much space you control. +[589.000 --> 592.000] It may have to do with the gestures that you use. +[592.000 --> 596.000] You probably notice that I use a lot of steepling. +[596.000 --> 600.000] I tend to interlace my fingers and so forth. +[600.000 --> 610.000] These are gestures that contribute to that communication that I'm trying to get across, that I am confident about what I'm talking about. +[610.000 --> 617.000] So it's not just about puffing your chest out, or certainly not about talking louder or anything. +[617.000 --> 625.000] It's about controlling my environment, but making sure that what I'm transmitting at all times is confidence. +[625.000 --> 631.000] And that means I'm prepared. I'm ready to answer. I'm going to answer you now. I'm going to answer you effectively. +[631.000 --> 634.000] And I'm going to make sure that you understand what I said. +[634.000 --> 638.000] I'm here to convey. I'm not here to convince. +[638.000 --> 644.000] A lot of times people who are lacking confidence are trying to convince you of something. +[644.000 --> 649.000] If I'm confident, I just say it once. It's this way and that's it. +[649.000 --> 656.000] I convey the information rather than sit there and try to beat it into you by repeating it 10 different ways. +[656.000 --> 660.000] Compare the gestures I'm about to do. +[660.000 --> 663.000] It's about temporal movement controlling time. +[663.000 --> 668.000] So the person in charge has the time to look up at their own pace. +[668.000 --> 673.000] The gestures are smooth. There's no hesitation. There's no quick movements. +[673.000 --> 678.000] There's no jitteriness. There doesn't have to be. I'm in charge. +[678.000 --> 686.000] When I feel less confident, I feel like I have to be in a hurry that I've got to look up and I've got to answer right away. +[686.000 --> 691.000] And there's a lot of preening behaviors and these are detracting from me. +[691.000 --> 700.000] I was really shy a few years ago. Probably this is changing a little bit. +[700.000 --> 705.000] People are horrified to speak in public. I used to be horrified to speak in public. +[705.000 --> 708.000] I still get nervous to speak in public. +[708.000 --> 713.000] But here's some tricks I found that you might find useful. +[713.000 --> 719.000] The first one is don't hesitate ever to say, you know what? This is scary. +[719.000 --> 722.000] Be honest with yourself. This is unnatural. +[722.000 --> 729.000] Number two, take refuge in knowing that if I sit down and study this material, +[729.000 --> 732.000] I will know it better than my audience. +[732.000 --> 735.000] The third thing I always do is I rehearse. +[735.000 --> 741.000] It really helps so that the first time you hear it in a forum, it doesn't scare you. +[741.000 --> 747.000] When it's time to do the presentation, one of the things I like to do is to warm up. +[747.000 --> 754.000] I find a good solid wall and I will just lean into it like I'm holding this wall up, +[754.000 --> 758.000] pressing against it just as if I were doing a push-up. +[758.000 --> 763.000] One of the things that that does is it releases a lot of muscular tension +[763.000 --> 768.000] and because I'm doing it very wide, it makes me feel more powerful +[768.000 --> 773.000] and I need to walk on that stage as though it's mine. +[773.000 --> 779.000] With full confidence, it is only then that I look at my audience +[779.000 --> 784.000] and just take a second to get myself together and to begin. +[784.000 --> 789.000] With practice, obviously you're going to get better and better and better. +[793.000 --> 798.000] Let's face it, people are not born confident. They're just not. +[798.000 --> 803.000] We can become confident with the assistance of our parents who encourage us. +[803.000 --> 807.000] We can become confident through our own achievements. +[807.000 --> 813.000] We can become confident by going beyond our boundaries, +[813.000 --> 818.000] but confidence is something that we can grow, we can nurture. +[818.000 --> 822.000] I have seen people in wheelchairs that are supremely confident. +[822.000 --> 828.000] I have seen elderly people in their 90s who are very confident. +[828.000 --> 833.000] I've seen children who are holding a violin with such confidence. +[833.000 --> 838.000] If you want to be confident, know your material, know the information, +[838.000 --> 845.000] hone that skill, work at it, have that mastery of things and of self, +[845.000 --> 852.000] and that's how you will come across as confident, no matter what your station in life is. diff --git a/transcript/political_VizOSxVRySY.txt b/transcript/political_VizOSxVRySY.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8e3cce3b353e880a57b4c620cd5a8b1ffdc381bf --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_VizOSxVRySY.txt @@ -0,0 +1,68 @@ +[0.000 --> 7.560] The Canadian Prime Minister and the American President could not be more different. +[7.560 --> 12.960] The first is a young politician who believes in the importance of diversity and wants to +[12.960 --> 16.640] find global solution for common problems. +[16.640 --> 22.720] The second has extremist ideas, prefers bilateral agreements to multilateral deals and is +[22.720 --> 25.720] determined to make America a great game. +[25.720 --> 29.920] These differences between Trump and Trudeau are evident, but is there also a difference +[29.920 --> 35.200] in how Donald Trump and Justin Trudeau evoke support by the audiences while holding a speech? +[35.200 --> 40.400] To answer this question, I will show you some theoretical approaches that attempt to explain +[40.400 --> 45.880] why speeches get applauded and directly apply them to parts of speeches of Justin Trudeau +[45.880 --> 47.760] and Donald Trump. +[47.760 --> 51.840] So first of all, we are not going to focus on the content of the speeches. +[51.840 --> 56.560] As Nicolas Jacob, Thomas Peterson and Thomas Russing from the University of Mainz and +[56.560 --> 63.760] Tidalbeck found out that only 7% of a speech's impact on the audience is caused by the content. +[63.760 --> 68.920] 35% are caused by the voice and 55% by the body language. +[68.920 --> 73.640] So as we've seen, there are many ways to evoke applause and therefore support from audiences +[73.640 --> 75.520] while holding a speech. +[75.520 --> 81.040] In general, there are verbal methods where people use sounds and words to express themselves +[81.040 --> 85.560] and nonverbal methods where people use gestures or mananisms. +[85.560 --> 90.760] When it comes to verbal methods, John Maxwell Adkinson, a sociologist at the University of +[90.760 --> 96.560] Oxford, studied the rhetoric of political speeches in his book, Our Amassed His Voice, +[96.560 --> 99.160] the language and body language of politics. +[99.160 --> 104.600] He concludes that rhetorical devices such as contrasts and three part lists are highly +[104.600 --> 107.600] effective in evoking applause. +[107.600 --> 110.080] And it comes to the speeches of Justin Trudeau. +[110.080 --> 111.080] This is right. +[111.080 --> 119.560] To know that a positive, optimistic, hopeful vision of public life isn't a naive dream, +[119.560 --> 125.000] it can be a powerful force for change. +[125.000 --> 131.000] In his victory speech, Justin Trudeau uses the rhetorical devices of contrasts seven +[131.000 --> 135.760] times and three or more part lists eight times. +[135.760 --> 137.960] This is not the case for Donald Trump. +[137.960 --> 143.000] He uses the rhetorical devices of contrasts and lists only twice. +[143.000 --> 145.880] And he doesn't even evoke applause with it right away. +[145.880 --> 155.880] Our is was not a campaign, but rather an incredible and great movement, made up of millions +[155.880 --> 161.560] of hardworking men and women who love their country and want a better, brighter future +[161.560 --> 164.080] for themselves and for their family. +[165.840 --> 170.600] Donald Trump doesn't even stop after doing a contrast to evoke applause. +[170.600 --> 174.320] And at the end of his words, the audience only collapse reservedly. +[174.320 --> 179.120] So when it comes to rhetorical devices, Justin Trudeau uses them more often than Donald +[179.120 --> 182.560] Trump and is more successful in evoking applause. +[182.560 --> 186.240] Another verbal method is the stressing of words. +[186.240 --> 192.040] This was studied by John Heritage and David Greatbatch, two sociologists from the University +[192.040 --> 193.240] of Warwick. +[193.240 --> 198.320] They found out that the more stressed words there are in a sentence, the more likely the +[198.320 --> 200.160] people applaud for it. +[200.160 --> 205.720] Thus they concluded that the way a message is delivered plays a substantial role in influencing +[205.720 --> 207.720] the audience's applause. +[207.720 --> 215.240] They believe that better is possible and that active citizens can play a real part in +[215.240 --> 218.520] making it happen. +[218.520 --> 229.240] We're going to announce our plans to totally renegotiate the disaster known as NAFTA. +[229.240 --> 234.880] When it comes to the stress of words, both politicians do not differ significantly. +[234.880 --> 240.040] So much to the verbal communication methods, now we're coming to the nonverbal ones. +[240.040 --> 244.920] Charles Hockett, an American linguist and his colleagues Robert Pittinger and John +[244.920 --> 251.160] Danihee observed in their paper in the American anthropologist that most speakers of American +[251.160 --> 257.000] English accompany their primary stress with slight jerks of their head or hand. +[257.000 --> 261.800] Further studies of Pitable, a professor at the Department of Psychology at the University +[261.800 --> 267.400] of York, validate this claim and show that hand geisture is also linked to the control +[267.400 --> 270.440] and elicitation of applause. +[270.440 --> 274.920] Having a just-inchredo speeches you quickly notice that he's not using much geistries +[274.920 --> 275.920] at all. +[275.920 --> 280.600] He rather he stands behind his lecturing and sometimes slightly jerks his head. +[280.600 --> 286.760] On the contrary, Donald Trump is using his hands a lot to stress his words. +[286.760 --> 290.640] When we have a look at what we found out in the last couple of minutes, it becomes clear +[290.640 --> 295.120] that just-inchredo uses through the article devices more often and is more successful +[295.120 --> 297.680] and evoking applause by doing it. +[297.680 --> 302.520] On the other side, Donald Trump relies mostly on large hand gestures. +[302.520 --> 307.120] When it comes to stressing words, there's no substantial differences between them. +[307.120 --> 312.000] So we can all in all conclude that Donald Trump and just-inchredo do not use the same +[312.000 --> 313.800] methods in evoking applause. diff --git a/transcript/political_XqiRRIRhZoM.txt b/transcript/political_XqiRRIRhZoM.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..eca4c0b523fadc1f2f7b539d3ad7a21ebaa70f35 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_XqiRRIRhZoM.txt @@ -0,0 +1,120 @@ +[0.000 --> 1.600] It's not just the words that come out. +[1.600 --> 3.200] It's how you say them in your body. +[3.200 --> 4.100] Literally, I brain. +[4.100 --> 5.760] If I say to you, I'll have a peanut butter and jelly +[5.760 --> 7.240] on my socks, please. +[7.240 --> 8.640] Your brain does like a heart monitor. +[8.640 --> 9.240] It says, what? +[9.240 --> 10.240] I don't understand. +[10.240 --> 13.280] Same thing when someone says, this is the American dream. +[13.280 --> 14.480] That's not my American dream. +[14.480 --> 16.080] So when you, your body language, +[16.080 --> 17.480] does not match your words, +[17.480 --> 19.160] our brain literally picks up on it, +[19.160 --> 21.560] scientifically proven, Colgate University did a study. +[21.560 --> 23.000] It says, wait a minute, I'm not buying +[23.000 --> 24.280] what the candidate is saying, +[24.280 --> 25.720] or what they're objecting to. +[25.720 --> 29.160] I feel like it's overly scripted or overly, you know, coach. +[29.160 --> 30.000] Right. +[30.000 --> 31.280] Let's take a look at some video. +[31.280 --> 34.440] We haven't seen Mitt Romney in a town hall style debate yet, +[34.440 --> 36.000] but this is him on the campaign trail. +[36.000 --> 39.640] He does a lot of pointing, which I know from the past +[39.640 --> 42.320] conversation with you, candidates usually try to stay away +[42.320 --> 43.320] from. +[43.320 --> 44.320] What do you make of his gesture? +[44.320 --> 45.480] Much better on the second round here when he started +[45.480 --> 47.920] gesturing with the palm of his hand like we see here. +[47.920 --> 50.360] But pointing, how do you feel when someone points at you? +[50.360 --> 51.880] It's almost like I'm pointing a gun at you. +[51.880 --> 54.760] It can become across of his aggressive when you're pointing. +[54.760 --> 56.520] That's why they do that thumb on the first. +[56.520 --> 57.520] That's the thumb of power. +[57.520 --> 58.360] That's right. +[58.360 --> 59.360] That's the thumb of power right here. +[59.360 --> 61.520] It's a combination of pointing and chopping. +[61.520 --> 64.200] It's much better in softer or palm up. +[64.200 --> 65.960] Mitt Romney loves to point. +[65.960 --> 68.560] I think it's going to hurt him in the debate tomorrow night. +[68.560 --> 70.720] Let's take a look at President Obama in a town hall format. +[70.720 --> 74.000] He's gotten mixed reviews in general. +[74.000 --> 74.840] What do you make of him? +[74.840 --> 79.560] I think Obama is a pro at this town hall format. +[79.560 --> 80.400] Why? +[80.400 --> 81.440] He's a master communicator. +[81.440 --> 83.400] He'll look over here and connect with you. +[83.400 --> 85.280] And then he'll look over here and connect with people. +[85.280 --> 87.080] Mitt Romney, I think we're going to see tomorrow night. +[87.080 --> 89.760] He gets a little like a bird or a chipmunk. +[89.760 --> 91.760] He's all over the place with his eye contact. +[91.760 --> 93.200] He did really well in the last debate. +[93.200 --> 94.200] Why? +[94.200 --> 95.320] There's two places he had to look at. +[95.320 --> 97.840] At the president, and he had to look at the moderator. +[97.840 --> 100.680] So Obama, he's doing the thumb of power that you see right here. +[100.680 --> 101.680] He's not pointing. +[101.680 --> 102.680] He's doing the thumb of the... +[102.680 --> 105.720] And he has both feet directly next to each other, Anderson. +[105.720 --> 108.560] We see this when we have both feet in the game. +[108.560 --> 110.280] His feet are a little bit in the game tomorrow. +[110.280 --> 114.520] In the last debate, Obama had his left foot pushed back behind his right foot. +[114.520 --> 115.560] Behind his right foot. +[115.560 --> 118.440] And he says, I don't have both feet in the game. +[118.440 --> 122.080] What should the other candidate do when the other candidate is talking? +[122.080 --> 123.080] Well, look right here. +[123.080 --> 124.080] Do you see right there? +[124.080 --> 126.600] We have McCain holding his wrist. +[126.600 --> 129.960] The rule of thumb is the higher the hold, the more anxiety is told. +[129.960 --> 131.760] You should think about what they're saying. +[131.760 --> 134.640] You know, Mitt Romney had the permit smile on the last debate. +[134.640 --> 138.520] When the president is saying, listen, if you're 55 and 56 years old, listen up. +[138.520 --> 140.800] This matters on your health care system. +[140.800 --> 142.880] And Mitt Romney had a permanent smile. +[142.880 --> 147.880] There was a town hall exchange in 2004 between Senator Kerry and President Bush. +[147.880 --> 153.640] Let's watch that because President Bush got very vocalist. +[153.640 --> 154.880] Mr. President, let's extend for a minute. +[154.880 --> 155.880] Let me just want to... +[155.880 --> 156.880] I got to answer this. +[156.880 --> 157.880] I mean, exactly. +[157.880 --> 159.880] And with reservists being held on duty. +[159.880 --> 161.880] No, let me answer this what he just said about... +[161.880 --> 163.880] Well, I wanted to get into the issue of the two. +[163.880 --> 166.880] You tell Tony Blair we're going alone. +[166.880 --> 168.880] Tell Tony Blair we're going alone. +[168.880 --> 169.880] Tell Alex... +[169.880 --> 170.880] I love this clip. +[170.880 --> 171.880] And I'm going to tell you what I like about it. +[171.880 --> 173.880] The rule of thumb with our gestures is our gesture to be... +[173.880 --> 175.880] gesture to be within the frame of our body. +[175.880 --> 178.880] When we get bigger, we can do that when we're talking to a bigger audience. +[178.880 --> 181.880] When we say George Bush, he takes his hand out. +[181.880 --> 183.880] He's saying, this is a big issue right here. +[183.880 --> 185.880] I need to address what just happened. +[185.880 --> 186.880] He puts that hand out. +[186.880 --> 190.880] And then he continues to walk as if he's pulling us along with him. +[190.880 --> 193.880] Now, body language, a lot of it, Anderson, has to do with your perception. +[193.880 --> 194.880] There's not scientific. +[194.880 --> 196.880] Every time you do this, doesn't mean you're powerful. +[196.880 --> 198.880] But it can be perceived as powerful. +[198.880 --> 200.880] It can be perceived as also arrogant. +[200.880 --> 204.880] You're looking at a town hall that's difficult is you have to relate to the person who's asking the question. +[204.880 --> 207.880] But at the same time, you need to pivot and attack the other candidate. +[207.880 --> 210.880] All right. Now, this is a big problem I've seen with past debates, Anderson. +[210.880 --> 215.880] As soon as you ask me the question, people will turn and they start talking to the audience over here. +[215.880 --> 217.880] This is what I call a trend. +[217.880 --> 222.880] If I treat you and answer your question with respect with an open palm gesture, I look you in the eyes. +[222.880 --> 224.880] I lean forward as I'm talking and engaging you. +[224.880 --> 235.880] If I treat you with respect, everyone at home who's watching is going to feel that if the president or if Mitt Romney was in front of them, that they would treat that person at home with that same level of respect. +[235.880 --> 237.880] So that's particularly important in a town hall debate. +[237.880 --> 238.880] It is. +[238.880 --> 240.880] Where it's an individual word, citizens asking the question. +[240.880 --> 242.880] And not everyone's been great at it. +[242.880 --> 244.880] I'm not talking about the same thing. +[244.880 --> 246.880] I'm not talking about the same thing. +[246.880 --> 248.880] It's an individual word, citizens asking the question. +[248.880 --> 250.880] And not everyone's been great at it. +[250.880 --> 254.880] I have to say a lot of people immediately listen to your question and then they turn and try to work the crowd. +[254.880 --> 256.880] I think that's a big mistake. +[256.880 --> 261.880] It's like a politician who shakes 50 hands instead of the politician that takes time to say nice to meet you, sir. +[261.880 --> 262.880] All right. diff --git a/transcript/political_Z1AIHCfuOT0.txt b/transcript/political_Z1AIHCfuOT0.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2fb03d332307f373283acf1ae3c9cd82e7f974b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_Z1AIHCfuOT0.txt @@ -0,0 +1,1921 @@ +[0.000 --> 4.280] With just over a month to go until election day, the first end only meeting between the +[4.280 --> 9.200] two men who hope to become Vice President of the United States, Democratic Governor Tim +[9.200 --> 13.360] Walls of Minnesota, and Republican Senator JD Vance of Ohio. +[13.360 --> 18.160] Now, this is likely the final debate of this election cycle and voting is already underway +[18.160 --> 19.600] in 20 states. +[19.600 --> 25.120] CBS News polling shows this remains a race either presidential candidate could win. +[25.120 --> 28.560] The CBS News Vice Presidential debate starts now. +[28.560 --> 31.600] Fight for every single vote and we're going to take this country back. +[31.600 --> 35.360] And we are ready to continue to build the future together. +[35.360 --> 40.640] We're going to turn this whole country red with President Donald J. Trump's leadership. +[40.640 --> 43.280] You know what's at the end of this little journey? +[43.280 --> 47.120] Kamala Harris as the next President of the United States. +[47.120 --> 53.600] This is a CBS News special live from CBS News headquarters in New York. +[53.600 --> 58.400] America decides the Vice Presidential debate. +[59.120 --> 61.600] Good evening. +[61.600 --> 66.400] I'm Nora O'Donnell and thank you for joining us for tonight's CBS News Vice Presidential +[66.400 --> 67.400] debate. +[67.400 --> 71.760] We want to welcome our viewers on CBS, on other networks here in the U.S. and around +[71.760 --> 72.760] the world. +[72.760 --> 77.360] We have a consequential night ahead and our focus is the issues that matter to you, the +[77.360 --> 78.360] voter. +[78.360 --> 79.360] Let's introduce the candidates. +[79.360 --> 85.840] Minnesota's Democratic Governor Tim Walls and Ohio's Republican Senator JD Vance tonight, +[85.840 --> 87.840] meeting for the first time. +[87.920 --> 93.520] I'm Margaret Brennan. +[93.520 --> 99.040] In order to have a thoughtful and civil debate, these are the rules that both campaigns have +[99.040 --> 100.760] agreed to. +[100.760 --> 104.880] Questions will be directed at one candidate who will have two minutes to respond. +[104.880 --> 108.160] The other candidate will be allowed two minutes for rebuttal. +[108.160 --> 112.840] Then each candidate will get another minute to make further points with an additional one +[112.840 --> 115.760] minute each at the discretion of the moderator. +[115.760 --> 121.280] The primary role of the moderators is to facilitate the debate between the candidates, enforce +[121.280 --> 126.080] the rules, and provide the candidates with the opportunity to fact-check claims made +[126.080 --> 127.080] by each other. +[127.080 --> 132.480] CBS News reserves the right to mute the candidates' microphones to maintain decorum. +[132.480 --> 135.760] We have not shared the questions or topics with the campaigns. +[135.760 --> 137.560] The stage is set. +[137.560 --> 140.520] Governor, Senator, thank you for joining us. +[140.520 --> 141.520] Let's get started. +[141.880 --> 144.800] Tonight our country is facing several unfolding crises. +[144.800 --> 146.960] The Middle East is on the brink of war. +[146.960 --> 151.440] Americans are suffering from the catastrophic impact of Hurricane Helene, and now a labor +[151.440 --> 156.040] strike as 25,000 dock workers from Maine to Texas are picketing. +[156.040 --> 158.760] We're going to begin tonight with the Middle East. +[158.760 --> 161.360] Margaret, thank you, Nora. +[161.360 --> 167.160] Earlier today, Iran launched its largest attack yet on Israel, but that attack failed. +[167.160 --> 171.080] Thanks to joint U.S. and Israeli defensive action. +[171.080 --> 176.840] President Biden has deployed more than 40,000 U.S. military personnel and assets to that +[176.840 --> 181.720] region over the past year to try to prevent a regional war. +[181.720 --> 186.960] Iran is weakened, but the U.S. still considers it the largest state sponsor of terrorism +[186.960 --> 192.160] in the world, and it has drastically reduced the time it would take to develop a nuclear +[192.160 --> 193.160] weapon. +[193.160 --> 197.560] It is down now to one or two weeks' time. +[197.560 --> 203.680] Our walls, if you were the final voice in the situation room, would you support or oppose +[203.680 --> 207.320] a preemptive strike by Israel on Iran? +[207.320 --> 208.320] You have two minutes. +[208.320 --> 209.320] Well, thank you. +[209.320 --> 211.440] And thank you for those joining home tonight. +[211.440 --> 213.200] Let's keep in mind where this started. +[213.200 --> 220.320] October 7th, Hamas terrorists massacred over 1,400 Israelis and took prisoners. +[220.320 --> 226.400] Iran are Israel's ability to be able to defend itself is absolutely fundamental, getting +[226.400 --> 234.560] its hostages back, fundamental, and ending the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. +[234.560 --> 240.000] But the expansion of Israel and its proxies is an absolute fundamental necessity for the +[240.000 --> 241.920] United States to have the steady leadership there. +[241.920 --> 247.280] You saw it experience today where along with our Israeli partners and our coalition able +[247.280 --> 250.160] to stop the incoming attack. +[250.160 --> 254.080] But what's fundamental here is that steady leadership is going to matter. +[254.080 --> 259.100] It's clear and the world saw it on that debate stage a few weeks ago, a nearly 80-year-old +[259.100 --> 264.000] Donald Trump talking about crowd sizes is not what we need in this moment. +[264.000 --> 265.520] But it's not just that. +[265.520 --> 269.840] It's those that were closest to Donald Trump that understand how dangerous he is when the +[269.840 --> 271.760] world is this dangerous. +[271.760 --> 275.600] His chief of staff, John Kelly, said that he was the most flawed human being he'd ever +[275.600 --> 276.600] met. +[276.600 --> 282.840] And both of his secretaries of defense and his national security advisors said he should +[282.840 --> 284.880] be nowhere near the White House. +[284.880 --> 291.920] Now the person closest to them, to the Donald Trump, said he's unfit for the highest office. +[291.920 --> 293.440] That was Senator Vance. +[293.440 --> 298.320] What we've seen out of Vice President Harris is we've seen steady leadership. +[298.320 --> 302.480] We've seen a calmness that is able to be able to draw on the coalitions to bring them +[302.480 --> 303.480] together. +[303.480 --> 306.720] Understanding that our allies matter. +[306.720 --> 314.920] And our ally see Donald Trump turn towards Vladimir Putin, turn towards North Korea. +[314.920 --> 319.240] When we start to see that type of fickleness around holding the coalitions together, we +[319.240 --> 320.920] will stay committed. +[320.920 --> 325.600] And as the Vice President said today is, we will protect our forces and our allied forces +[325.600 --> 328.160] and there will be consequences. +[328.160 --> 329.480] Governor, your time is up. +[329.480 --> 331.480] Senator Vance, the same question. +[331.480 --> 337.840] Would you support or oppose a preemptive strike by Israel on Iran you have two minutes? +[337.840 --> 339.320] Some more going to answer the question. +[339.320 --> 340.320] First of all, thanks, Governor. +[340.320 --> 342.240] Thanks to CBS for hosting the debate. +[342.240 --> 345.760] And thanks most importantly to the American people who are watching this evening and caring +[345.760 --> 349.080] enough about this country to pay attention to this Vice President's debate. +[349.080 --> 351.960] I want to answer the question, but I want to actually give an introduction to myself a +[351.960 --> 355.400] little bit because I recognize a lot of Americans don't know who either one of us are. +[355.400 --> 357.520] I was raised in a working class family. +[357.520 --> 360.160] My mother required food assistance for periods of her life. +[360.160 --> 363.560] My grandmother required Social Security help to raise me. +[363.560 --> 366.880] And she raised me in part because my own mother struggled with addiction for a big chunk +[366.880 --> 368.000] of my early life. +[368.000 --> 372.960] I went to college on the GI Bill after I listed in the Marine Corps and served in Iraq. +[372.960 --> 377.200] And so I stand here asking to be your Vice President with extraordinary gratitude for this +[377.200 --> 381.560] country, for the American dream that made it possible for me to live my dreams. +[381.560 --> 385.800] And most importantly, I know that a lot of you are worried about the chaos in the world +[385.800 --> 389.000] and the feeling that the American dream is unattainable. +[389.000 --> 393.360] I want to try to convince you tonight over the next 90 minutes that if we get better leadership +[393.360 --> 397.200] in the White House, if we get Donald Trump back in the White House, the American dream +[397.200 --> 398.680] is going to be attainable once again. +[398.680 --> 402.720] Now, to answer this particular question, we have to remember that as much as Governor +[402.720 --> 407.360] Walts just accused Donald Trump of being an agent of chaos, Donald Trump actually delivered +[407.360 --> 408.360] stability in the world. +[408.360 --> 412.080] And he did it by establishing effective deterrents. +[412.080 --> 414.200] People were afraid of stepping out of line. +[414.200 --> 420.400] Iran, which launched this attack, has received over $100 billion in unfrozen assets thanks +[420.400 --> 422.560] to the Kamala Harris administration. +[422.560 --> 423.560] What do they use that money for? +[423.560 --> 427.320] They use it to buy weapons that they're now launching against our allies and got for +[427.320 --> 430.960] bit, potentially launching against the United States as well. +[430.960 --> 435.880] Donald Trump recognized that for people to fear the United States, you needed peace through +[435.880 --> 436.880] strength. +[436.880 --> 440.760] They needed to recognize that if they got out of line, the United States global leadership +[440.760 --> 444.040] would put stability in peace back in the world. +[444.040 --> 447.680] Now you asked about a preemptive strike market and I want to answer the question, look, +[447.680 --> 452.000] it is up to Israel, what they think they need to do to keep their country safe and we should +[452.000 --> 455.360] support our allies wherever they are when they're fighting the bad guys. +[455.360 --> 458.960] I think that's the right approach to take with the Israel question. +[458.960 --> 459.960] Thank you, Senator. +[459.960 --> 463.520] Governor Walts, do you care to respond to any of the allegations? +[463.520 --> 465.480] Well, look, Donald Trump was in office. +[465.480 --> 468.760] We'll sometimes hear a revisionist history, but when Donald Trump was in office, it was +[468.760 --> 476.360] Donald Trump who we had a coalition of nations that had boxed Iran's nuclear program in the +[476.360 --> 478.040] inability to advance it. +[478.040 --> 481.840] Donald Trump pulled that program and put nothing else in its place. +[481.840 --> 485.760] So Iran is closer to a nuclear weapon than they were before because of Donald Trump's +[485.760 --> 487.040] fickle leadership. +[487.040 --> 492.840] And when Iran shot down an American aircraft in international airspace, Donald Trump tweeted +[492.840 --> 495.960] because that's the standard diplomacy of Donald Trump. +[495.960 --> 502.240] And when Iranian missiles did fall near U.S. troops and they received traumatic brain +[502.240 --> 506.520] injuries, Donald Trump wrote it off as headaches. +[506.520 --> 510.600] Look, our allies understand that Donald Trump is fickle. +[510.600 --> 515.040] He will go to whoever has the most flattery or where it makes sense to him. +[515.040 --> 519.280] Steady leadership like you witnessed today, like you witnessed in April, both Iranian +[519.280 --> 520.920] attacks were repelled. +[520.920 --> 525.520] Our coalition is strong and we need the steady leadership that Kamala Harris is providing. +[525.520 --> 531.640] Senator Vance, the U.S. did have a diplomatic deal with Iran to temporarily pause parts +[531.640 --> 536.560] of its nuclear program and President Trump did exit that deal. +[536.560 --> 543.480] He recently said just five days ago, the U.S. must now make a diplomatic deal with Iran +[543.480 --> 547.360] because the consequences are impossible. +[547.360 --> 548.360] Did he make a mistake? +[548.360 --> 549.360] You have one minute. +[549.360 --> 552.560] Well, first of all, Margaret, diplomacy is not a dirty word, but I think that's something +[552.560 --> 554.720] that Governor Walts just said is quite extraordinary. +[554.720 --> 559.200] You yourself just said Iran is as close to a nuclear weapon today as they have ever +[559.200 --> 560.200] been. +[560.200 --> 562.040] And Governor Walts, you blame Donald Trump. +[562.040 --> 564.640] Who has been the vice president for the last three and a half years? +[564.640 --> 567.440] And the answer is you're running me, not mine. +[567.440 --> 571.040] Donald Trump consistently made the world more secure. +[571.040 --> 576.280] Now we talk about the sequence of events that led us to where we are right now and you +[576.280 --> 580.760] can't ignore October the 7th, which I appreciate Governor Walts bringing up. +[580.760 --> 586.520] But when did Iran and Hamas and their proxies attack Israel, it was during the administration +[586.520 --> 587.600] of Kamala Harris. +[587.600 --> 590.960] So Governor Walts can criticize Donald Trump's tweets. +[590.960 --> 596.240] But effective smart diplomacy and peace through strength is how you bring stability back +[596.240 --> 598.160] to a very broken world. +[598.160 --> 600.120] Donald Trump has already done it once before. +[600.120 --> 601.680] Ask yourself at home. +[601.680 --> 603.680] When was the last time? +[603.680 --> 604.680] I'm 40 years old. +[604.680 --> 609.000] When was the last time that an American president didn't have a major conflict breakout? +[609.000 --> 612.120] The only answer is during the four years that Donald Trump was president. +[612.120 --> 613.920] Gentlemen, we have a lot to get to. +[613.920 --> 614.920] Nora? +[614.920 --> 615.920] Margaret, thank you. +[615.920 --> 617.960] Let's turn out to Hurricane Helene. +[617.960 --> 621.560] The storm could become one of the deadliest on record. +[621.560 --> 627.280] More than 160 people are dead and hundreds more are missing. +[627.280 --> 633.840] Scientists say climate change makes these hurricanes larger, stronger, and more deadly because +[633.840 --> 636.240] of the historic rainfall. +[636.240 --> 642.240] Senator Vance, according to CBS NewsPolling, seven in ten Americans and more than 60 percent +[642.240 --> 648.040] of Republicans under the age of 45, favor the U.S. taking steps to try and reduce climate +[648.040 --> 649.040] change. +[649.040 --> 654.280] Senator, what responsibility would the Trump administration have to try and reduce the +[654.280 --> 656.280] impact of climate change? +[656.280 --> 657.280] I'll give you two minutes. +[657.280 --> 658.280] Sure. +[658.280 --> 661.960] So, first of all, let's start with the hurricane because it's an unbelievable, unspeakable +[661.960 --> 662.960] human tragedy. +[662.960 --> 667.480] I just saw today actually a photograph of two grandparents on a roof with a six-year-old +[667.480 --> 671.360] child and it was the last photograph ever taken to them because the roof collapsed and +[671.360 --> 672.880] those innocent people lost their lives. +[672.880 --> 677.320] And I'm sure Governor Walts joins me in saying our hearts go out to those innocent people, +[677.320 --> 681.720] our prayers go out to them and we want his robust and aggressive as a federal response +[681.720 --> 686.160] as we can get to save as many lives as possible and then of course afterwards to help the +[686.160 --> 687.760] people in those communities rebuild. +[687.760 --> 689.280] I mean, these are communities that I love. +[689.280 --> 694.000] Some of them I know very personally, in Appalachia all across the southeast, they need their +[694.000 --> 698.440] government to do their job and I commit that when Donald Trump is president again, the +[698.440 --> 702.840] government will put the citizens of this country first when they suffer from a disaster. +[702.840 --> 704.360] And or you asked about climate change. +[704.360 --> 706.240] I think this is a very important issue. +[706.240 --> 710.240] Look, a lot of people are justifiably worried about all these crazy weather patterns. +[710.240 --> 714.000] I think it's important for us, first of all, to say Donald Trump and I support clean +[714.000 --> 715.200] air, clean water. +[715.200 --> 717.240] We want the environment to be cleaner and safer. +[717.240 --> 720.280] But one of the things that I've noticed, some of our democratic friends talking a lot +[720.280 --> 725.520] about is a concern about carbon emissions, this idea that carbon emissions drives all of +[725.520 --> 726.520] the climate change. +[726.520 --> 729.600] But let's just say that's true, just for the sake of arguments that we're not arguing +[729.600 --> 732.080] about weird science, let's just say that's true. +[732.080 --> 735.320] Well, if you believe that, what would you, what would you want to do? +[735.320 --> 739.400] The answer is that you'd want to restore as much American manufacturing as possible and +[739.400 --> 743.760] you'd want to produce as much energy as possible in the United States of America because +[743.760 --> 746.560] we're the cleanest economy in the entire world. +[746.560 --> 751.520] What if Commonwealth Harris's policies actually led to, more energy production in China, +[751.520 --> 756.360] more manufacturing overseas, more doing business in some of the dirtiest parts of the entire +[756.360 --> 757.360] world? +[757.360 --> 758.360] And why say that? +[758.360 --> 761.840] I mean, the amount of carbon emissions they're doing per unit of economic output. +[761.840 --> 766.360] So if we actually care about getting cleaner air and cleaner water, the best thing to do +[766.360 --> 770.440] is to double down and invest in American workers and the American people. +[770.440 --> 773.440] And unfortunately, Commonwealth Harris has done exactly the opposite. +[773.440 --> 775.880] Governor Walls, you have two minutes to respond. +[775.880 --> 779.080] Well, we got close to an agreement because all those things are happening. +[779.080 --> 784.320] Look, first of all, it is a horrific tragedy with this hurricane. +[784.320 --> 788.560] And my heart goes out to the folks that are down there in contact with the governors. +[788.560 --> 792.160] I serve as co-chair of the Council of Governors. +[792.160 --> 796.720] If we work together on these emergency management's governors, no, no partisanship they work together +[796.720 --> 801.720] to solve the governors and the emergency responders on the ground, those happen on the front end. +[801.720 --> 804.840] The federal government comes in, make sure they're there to that we recover, but we're +[804.840 --> 808.720] still in that phase where we need to make sure that they're staying there, staying focused. +[808.720 --> 812.440] Now, look, coming back to the climate changes, there's no doubt this thing brought on to +[812.440 --> 816.120] the scene faster and stronger than anything we've seen. +[816.120 --> 818.720] Senator Vance had said that there's a climate problem in the past. +[818.720 --> 822.960] Donald Trump called it a hoax and then joked that these things would make more beachfront +[822.960 --> 825.360] property to be able to invest in. +[825.360 --> 829.840] What we've seen out of the Harris administration now, the Biden-Harris administration is we've +[829.840 --> 831.320] seen this investment. +[831.320 --> 836.320] We've seen massive investments, the biggest in global history that we've seen in the +[836.320 --> 841.040] inflation reduction act has created jobs all across the country, 2000 in Jeffersonville, +[841.040 --> 846.800] Ohio, taking the EV technology that we invented and making it here, 200,000 jobs across the +[846.800 --> 851.960] country, the largest solar manufacturing plant in North America sets in Minnesota. +[851.960 --> 854.200] But my farmers know climate change is real. +[854.200 --> 857.960] They've seen 500-year droughts, 500-year floods back-to-back. +[857.960 --> 862.080] But what they're doing is adapting, and this has allowed them to tell me, look, I harvest +[862.080 --> 864.680] corn, I harvest soybean, and I harvest wind. +[864.680 --> 868.560] We are producing more natural gas and more oil at any time that we ever have. +[868.560 --> 871.320] We're also producing more clean energy. +[871.320 --> 877.760] So the solution for us is to continue to move forward that climate change is real. +[877.760 --> 881.960] Reducing our impact is absolutely critical, but this is not a false choice. +[881.960 --> 885.800] You can do that at the same time you're creating the jobs that we're seeing all across the +[885.800 --> 886.800] country. +[886.800 --> 888.880] Exactly what this administration has done. +[888.880 --> 893.480] We are seeing us becoming an energy superpower for the future, not just the current. +[893.480 --> 895.560] And that's what absolutely makes sense. +[895.560 --> 899.720] And then we start thinking about how do we mitigate these disasters? +[899.720 --> 901.200] Thank you, Senator. +[901.200 --> 903.320] I want to give you an opportunity to respond there. +[903.320 --> 907.280] The governor mentioned that President Trump has called climate change a hoax. +[907.280 --> 908.280] Do you agree? +[908.280 --> 912.480] Well, look, what the president has said is that if the Democrats, in particular Kamala +[912.480 --> 916.880] Harris and her leadership, if they really believe that climate change is serious, what +[916.880 --> 921.080] they would be doing is more manufacturing and more energy production in the United States +[921.080 --> 922.080] of America. +[922.080 --> 923.080] And that's not what they're doing. +[923.080 --> 927.280] So clearly Kamala Harris herself doesn't believe her own rhetoric on this. +[927.280 --> 930.440] If she did, she would actually agree with Donald Trump's energy policies. +[930.440 --> 935.400] Now, something governor Walts said is important to touch upon because when we talk about clean +[935.400 --> 939.520] energy, I think that's a slogan that often the Democrats will use here. +[939.520 --> 942.080] And I'm talking of course about the Democratic leadership. +[942.080 --> 946.800] And the real issue is that if you're spending hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars +[946.800 --> 951.560] of American taxpayer money on solar panels that are made in China, number one, you're +[951.560 --> 953.040] going to make the economy dirtier. +[953.040 --> 956.760] We should be making more of those solar panels here in the United States of America. +[956.760 --> 960.640] Some of them are tim, but a lot of them are being made overseas in China, especially the +[960.640 --> 963.040] components that go into those solar panels. +[963.040 --> 967.720] So if you really want to make the environment cleaner, you've got to invest in more energy +[967.720 --> 968.720] production. +[968.720 --> 971.960] And it's a nuclear facility, I think, one in the past 40 years. +[971.960 --> 972.960] Natural gas. +[972.960 --> 974.440] We got to invest more in it. +[974.440 --> 976.080] Kamala Harris has done the opposite. +[976.080 --> 979.440] That's raised energy prices and also meant that we're doing it right this time. +[979.440 --> 981.920] Senator, would you like to respond? +[981.920 --> 985.040] Well, look, we're producing more natural gas we ever have. +[985.040 --> 986.240] There's no more to our aim on that. +[986.240 --> 988.080] We're producing more oil, but the folks know. +[988.080 --> 991.560] And like I said, again, these are not liberal folks. +[991.560 --> 993.560] These are not folks that are green, new deal folks. +[993.560 --> 998.600] These are farmers that have been drought one year, massive flooding the next year. +[998.600 --> 1000.160] They understand that it makes sense. +[1000.160 --> 1005.560] Look, our number one export cannot be topsoil from erosion from these massive storms. +[1005.560 --> 1007.840] We saw it in Minnesota this summer. +[1007.840 --> 1011.760] And thinking about how do we respond to that, we're thinking ahead on this. +[1011.760 --> 1015.560] And what Kamala Harris has been able to do in Minnesota, we're starting to weatherproof +[1015.560 --> 1016.560] some of these things. +[1016.560 --> 1021.120] The infrastructure law that was passed allows us to think about mitigation in the future. +[1021.120 --> 1023.920] How do we make sure that we're protecting by burying our power lines? +[1023.920 --> 1027.360] How do we make sure that we're protecting lake fronts and things that we're seeing more +[1027.360 --> 1028.360] and more of? +[1028.360 --> 1033.920] And to call it a hoax and to take the oil company executives to Mar-a-Lago, say, give +[1033.920 --> 1037.520] me money for my campaign and I'll let you do whatever you want. +[1037.520 --> 1042.040] We can be smarter about that and an all above energy policy is exactly what she's doing, +[1042.040 --> 1044.040] creating those jobs right here. +[1044.040 --> 1045.120] Governor, your time is up. +[1045.120 --> 1048.840] The overwhelming consensus among scientists is that the Earth's climate is warming at +[1048.840 --> 1050.320] an unprecedented rate. +[1050.320 --> 1051.320] Margaret. +[1051.320 --> 1052.320] Thank you, Nora. +[1052.320 --> 1054.240] We're going to turn now to immigration. +[1054.240 --> 1061.920] The crisis at the U.S. Mexico border consistently ranks as one of the top issue for American voters. +[1061.920 --> 1067.640] Senator Vance, your campaign is pledging to carry out the largest mass deportation plan +[1067.640 --> 1072.600] in American history and to use the U.S. military to do so. +[1072.600 --> 1076.540] Could you be more specific about exactly how this will work? +[1076.540 --> 1081.680] For example, would you deport parents who have entered the U.S. illegally and separate +[1081.720 --> 1085.680] them from any of their children who were born on U.S. soil? +[1085.680 --> 1086.680] You have two minutes. +[1086.680 --> 1090.800] So first of all, Margaret, before we talk about deportations, we have to stop the bleeding. +[1090.800 --> 1096.520] We have a historic immigration crisis because Kamala Harris started and said that she wanted +[1096.520 --> 1099.400] to undo all of Donald Trump's border policies. +[1099.400 --> 1106.040] 94 executive orders suspending deportations, decriminalizing illegal aliens, massively +[1106.040 --> 1109.400] increasing the asylum fraud that exists in our system. +[1109.400 --> 1110.920] That has opened the floodgates. +[1110.960 --> 1114.240] And what it's meant is that a lot of fentanyl is coming into our country. +[1114.240 --> 1117.640] I had a mother who struggled with opioid addiction and has gotten clean. +[1117.640 --> 1121.840] I don't want people who are struggling with addiction to be deprived of their second +[1121.840 --> 1127.040] chance because Kamala Harris led in fentanyl into our communities at record levels. +[1127.040 --> 1129.200] So you've got to stop the bleeding. +[1129.200 --> 1133.840] You've got to re-implement Donald Trump's border policies, build the wall, re-implement +[1133.840 --> 1138.000] deportations, and that gets me to your point, Margaret, about what do we actually do? +[1138.000 --> 1141.680] So we've got 20, 25 million illegal aliens who are here in the country. +[1141.680 --> 1142.680] What do we do with them? +[1142.680 --> 1145.880] I think the first thing that we do is we start with the criminal migrants. +[1145.880 --> 1150.360] About a million of those people have committed some form of crime in addition to crossing the +[1150.360 --> 1151.360] border illegally. +[1151.360 --> 1154.680] I think you start with deportations on those folks. +[1154.680 --> 1158.600] And then I think you make it harder for illegal aliens to undercut the wages of American +[1158.600 --> 1159.600] workers. +[1159.600 --> 1163.880] A lot of people will go home if they can't work for less than minimum wage in our own country. +[1163.880 --> 1167.160] And by the way, that'll be really good for our workers who just want to earn a fair +[1167.160 --> 1169.160] wage for doing a good day's work. +[1169.160 --> 1172.440] And the final point, Margaret, is you ask about family separation. +[1172.440 --> 1178.160] Right now in this country, Margaret, we have 320,000 children that the Department of Homeland +[1178.160 --> 1180.440] Security has effectively lost. +[1180.440 --> 1182.040] Some of them have been sex trafficked. +[1182.040 --> 1184.800] Some of them hopefully aren't homes with their families. +[1184.800 --> 1187.440] Some of them have been used as drug trafficking mules. +[1187.440 --> 1193.080] The real family separation policy in this country is unfortunately Kamala Harris's wide-open +[1193.080 --> 1194.080] southern border. +[1194.080 --> 1198.520] And I'd ask my fellow Americans to remember when she came into office, she said she was +[1198.520 --> 1199.840] going to do this. +[1199.840 --> 1202.360] Real leadership would be saying, you know what, I screwed up. +[1202.360 --> 1204.200] We're going to go back to Donald Trump's border policies. +[1204.200 --> 1205.680] I wish that she would do that. +[1205.680 --> 1208.320] It would be good for all of us. +[1208.320 --> 1213.360] Governor, do you care to respond to any of those specific allegations, including that the +[1213.360 --> 1220.160] vice president is, quote, letting in fentanyl and using kids as drug mules among other +[1220.160 --> 1221.160] things? +[1221.160 --> 1223.240] Yeah, well, the drug mules are not true. +[1223.240 --> 1226.400] But I will say about this, about the fentanyl, because this is a crisis of this, the opioid +[1226.400 --> 1227.400] crisis. +[1227.400 --> 1230.580] And the good news on this is, is the last 12 months saw the largest decrease in opioid +[1230.580 --> 1234.240] deaths in our nation's history, 30 percent decrease in Ohio. +[1234.240 --> 1235.840] But there's still more work to do. +[1235.840 --> 1237.600] But let's go back to this on immigration. +[1237.600 --> 1241.560] Kamala Harris was the attorney general of the largest state in a border state in California. +[1241.560 --> 1246.480] She's the only person in this race who prosecuted transnational gangs for human trafficking and +[1246.480 --> 1247.800] drug interventions. +[1247.800 --> 1250.760] But look, we all want to solve this. +[1250.760 --> 1253.040] Most of us want to solve this. +[1253.040 --> 1255.240] And that is the United States Congress. +[1255.240 --> 1256.720] That's the Border Patrol agents. +[1256.720 --> 1257.920] That's the Chamber of Commerce. +[1257.920 --> 1259.520] That's most Americans out here. +[1259.520 --> 1265.840] That's why we had the fairest and the toughest bill on immigration that this nation's seen. +[1265.840 --> 1269.960] It was crafted by a conservative senator from Oklahoma, James Langford. +[1269.960 --> 1270.960] I know him. +[1270.960 --> 1273.760] He's super conservative, but he's a man of principle once he had it done. +[1273.760 --> 1276.320] Democrats and Republicans worked on this piece of legislation. +[1276.320 --> 1278.680] The Border Patrol said this is what we need in here. +[1278.680 --> 1279.840] These are the experts. +[1279.840 --> 1282.800] And the Chamber of Commerce and the Wall Street Journal said, pass this thing. +[1282.800 --> 1284.600] Kamala Harris helped get there. +[1284.600 --> 1287.080] 1,500 new border agents. +[1287.080 --> 1288.480] Detection for drugs. +[1288.480 --> 1292.760] DOJ money to speed up these adjudications on this. +[1292.760 --> 1294.080] Just what America wants. +[1294.080 --> 1297.960] But as soon as I was getting ready to pass and actually tackle this, Donald Trump said, +[1297.960 --> 1298.960] no. +[1298.960 --> 1302.640] Told them to vote against it because it gives him a campaign issue. +[1302.640 --> 1306.640] It gives him to what would Donald Trump talk about if we actually did some of these things. +[1306.640 --> 1309.240] And they need to be done by the legislature. +[1309.240 --> 1311.800] You can't just do this through the executive branch. +[1311.800 --> 1314.000] So look, we have the options to do this. +[1314.000 --> 1315.760] Donald Trump had four years. +[1315.760 --> 1317.400] He had four years to do this. +[1317.400 --> 1320.280] And he promised you America how easy it would be. +[1320.280 --> 1322.600] I'll build you a big, beautiful wall. +[1322.600 --> 1324.360] And Mexico will pay for it. +[1324.360 --> 1326.440] Less than 2% of that wall got built. +[1326.440 --> 1328.040] And Mexico didn't pay a dime. +[1328.040 --> 1334.440] But here we are again, nine years after he came down that escalator, dehumanizing people +[1334.440 --> 1336.160] and telling him what he was going to do. +[1336.160 --> 1340.800] As far as a deportation plant, at one point, Senator Van said it was so unworkable to be +[1340.800 --> 1341.800] laughable. +[1341.800 --> 1343.120] So that's where we're at. +[1343.120 --> 1345.160] Past the bill, she'll sign it. +[1345.160 --> 1347.000] Governor, your time is up. +[1347.000 --> 1352.160] Senator, the question was, will you separate parents from their children, even if their +[1352.160 --> 1353.760] kids are U.S. citizens? +[1353.760 --> 1354.760] You have one minute. +[1354.760 --> 1357.840] Margaret, my point is that we already have massive child separations. +[1357.840 --> 1359.480] Thanks to Kamala Harris's open border. +[1359.480 --> 1362.680] And I didn't accuse Kamala Harris of inviting drug mules. +[1362.680 --> 1367.560] I said that she enabled the Mexican drug cartels to operate freely in this country. +[1367.560 --> 1369.720] And we know that they use children as drug mules. +[1369.720 --> 1371.320] And it is a disgrace. +[1371.320 --> 1372.320] And it has to stop. +[1372.320 --> 1375.800] Look, I think what Tim said just doesn't pass the smell test. +[1375.800 --> 1380.920] For three years, Kamala Harris went out bragging that she was going to undo Donald Trump's +[1380.920 --> 1381.920] border policy. +[1381.920 --> 1383.320] She did exactly that. +[1383.320 --> 1385.240] We had a record number of illegal crossings. +[1385.240 --> 1388.040] We had a record number of fentanyl coming into our country. +[1388.040 --> 1392.440] And now that she's running for president, or a few months before, she says that somehow +[1392.440 --> 1395.960] she got religion and cared a lot about a piece of legislation. +[1395.960 --> 1401.240] The only thing that she did when she became the vice president, when she became the appointed +[1401.240 --> 1407.920] borders are, was to undo 94 Donald Trump executive actions that opened the border. +[1407.920 --> 1412.960] This problem is leading to massive problems in the United States of America. +[1412.960 --> 1416.560] Parents who can't afford health care, schools that are overwhelmed, it's got to stop. +[1416.560 --> 1418.160] And it will when Donald Trump is president again. +[1418.160 --> 1419.960] Senator, your time is up. +[1419.960 --> 1420.960] Governor. +[1420.960 --> 1426.360] What about our CBS news polling, which does show that a majority of Americans, more than +[1426.360 --> 1429.560] 50 percent, support mass deportations? +[1429.560 --> 1435.040] Look, we fix this issue with a bill that is necessary, but the issue on this is this is +[1435.040 --> 1436.920] what happens when you don't want to solve it. +[1436.920 --> 1438.200] You demonize it. +[1438.200 --> 1442.160] And we saw this and Senator Vance and it surprises me on this. +[1442.160 --> 1445.920] Talking about and saying, I will create stories to bring attention to this. +[1445.920 --> 1450.760] That vilified a large number of people who were here legally in the community of Springfield. +[1450.760 --> 1455.160] The Republican governor said it's not true, don't do it. +[1455.160 --> 1456.480] There's consequences for this. +[1456.480 --> 1457.480] There's consequences. +[1457.480 --> 1458.480] We could come together. +[1458.480 --> 1459.480] Senator Langford did it. +[1459.480 --> 1463.680] We could come together and solve this if we didn't let Donald Trump continue to make +[1463.680 --> 1464.680] it an issue. +[1464.680 --> 1470.080] And the consequences in Springfield were the governor had to send state law enforcement +[1470.080 --> 1472.240] to escort kindergarteners to school. +[1472.240 --> 1477.320] I believe Senator Vance wants to solve this, but by standing with Donald Trump and not +[1477.320 --> 1480.720] working together to find a solution, it becomes a talking point. +[1480.720 --> 1485.640] And when it becomes a talking point like this, we dehumanize and villainize other human +[1485.640 --> 1486.640] beings. +[1486.640 --> 1487.640] Tim. +[1487.640 --> 1489.160] Governor, your time is up. +[1489.160 --> 1493.880] Senator, I'll give you one minute, but let me just ask you the question first. +[1493.880 --> 1496.280] The governor has made the point. +[1496.280 --> 1501.080] And I think as a sitting lawmaker, you know that Congress controls the purse strings and +[1501.080 --> 1502.480] any funding. +[1502.480 --> 1509.520] So you have said repeatedly that Donald Trump would, through executive action, solve this. +[1509.520 --> 1513.400] Do you disagree that Congress controls the purse strings? +[1513.400 --> 1518.360] It would need to support many of the changes that you would actually want to implement. +[1518.360 --> 1519.360] You have one minute. +[1519.360 --> 1522.160] Look, Margaret, first of all, the gross majority of what we need to do with the southern border +[1522.160 --> 1524.680] is just empowering law enforcement to do their job. +[1524.680 --> 1526.880] I've been to the southern border more than our borders are. +[1526.880 --> 1528.200] Our common Harris has been. +[1528.200 --> 1531.600] And it's actually heartbreaking because the border patrol agents, they just want to be +[1531.600 --> 1533.080] empowered to do their job. +[1533.080 --> 1535.200] Of course, additional resources would help. +[1535.200 --> 1539.520] But most of this is about the president and the vice president, empowering our law enforcement +[1539.520 --> 1543.760] to say, if you try to come across the border illegally, you've got to stay in Mexico, +[1543.760 --> 1545.760] you've got to go back through proper channels. +[1545.760 --> 1548.680] Now Governor Waltz brought up the community of Springfield. +[1548.680 --> 1552.760] And he's very worried about the things that I've said in Springfield. +[1552.760 --> 1558.120] Look, in Springfield, Ohio and in communities all across this country, you've got schools +[1558.120 --> 1559.120] that are overwhelmed. +[1559.120 --> 1561.160] You've got hospitals that are overwhelmed. +[1561.160 --> 1566.160] You have got housing that is totally unaffordable because we brought in millions of illegal immigrants +[1566.160 --> 1568.840] to compete with Americans for scarce homes. +[1568.840 --> 1573.400] The people that I'm most worried about in Springfield, Ohio are the American citizens who +[1573.400 --> 1577.040] have had their lives destroyed by Kamala Harris' open border. +[1577.040 --> 1578.720] It is a disgrace to him. +[1578.720 --> 1580.240] And I actually think, I agree with you. +[1580.240 --> 1583.720] I think you want to solve this problem, but I don't think that Kamala Harris does. +[1583.720 --> 1585.120] Senator, your time is up. +[1585.120 --> 1586.720] Governor, you have one minute to respond. +[1586.720 --> 1587.720] Yeah. +[1587.720 --> 1590.760] Well, it is law enforcement that asked for the bill. +[1590.760 --> 1592.100] They helped craft it. +[1592.100 --> 1594.160] They're the ones that supported it. +[1594.160 --> 1596.240] That's because they know we need to do this. +[1596.240 --> 1602.040] Look, this issue of continuing to bring this up, of not dealing with it, of blaming migrants +[1602.040 --> 1603.680] for everything. +[1603.680 --> 1607.360] On housing, we could talk a little bit about Wall Street speculators buying up housing +[1607.360 --> 1609.040] and making them less affordable. +[1609.040 --> 1610.920] But it becomes a blame. +[1610.920 --> 1615.600] Look, this bill also gives the money necessary to adjudicate. +[1615.600 --> 1619.640] I agree, it should not take seven years for an asylum claim to be done. +[1619.640 --> 1621.640] This bill gets it done in 90 days. +[1621.640 --> 1623.440] Then you start to make a difference in this. +[1623.440 --> 1626.440] And you start to adhere to what we know, American principles. +[1626.440 --> 1628.840] Look, I don't talk about my faith a lot. +[1628.840 --> 1633.160] But Matthew 2540 talks about, to the least amongst us, you do unto me. +[1633.160 --> 1635.680] I think that's true of most Americans. +[1635.680 --> 1637.920] They simply want order to it. +[1637.920 --> 1639.280] This bill does it. +[1639.280 --> 1640.280] It's funded. +[1640.280 --> 1641.760] It's supported by the people who do it. +[1641.760 --> 1646.360] And it lets us keep our dignity about how we treat other people. +[1646.360 --> 1647.360] Thank you, Governor. +[1647.360 --> 1653.440] I want to clarify for our viewers, Springfield, Ohio does have a large number of Haitian migrants +[1653.440 --> 1657.160] who have legal status, temporary protected status. +[1657.160 --> 1658.920] Well, Margarit, but thank you, Senator. +[1658.920 --> 1660.440] We have so much to get to. +[1660.440 --> 1666.160] Margarit, I think it's important because the rules were that you guys are going to fact-check. +[1666.160 --> 1669.760] And since you're fact-checking me, I think it's important to say what's actually going +[1669.760 --> 1670.760] on. +[1670.760 --> 1675.520] So there's an application called the CBP-1 app, where you can go on as an illegal migrant, +[1675.520 --> 1682.880] apply for asylum or apply for parole, and be granted legal status at the wave of a Kamala +[1682.880 --> 1684.960] Harris open border wand. +[1684.960 --> 1688.840] That is not a person coming in applying for a green card and waiting for 10 years. +[1688.840 --> 1689.840] Thank you, Senator. +[1689.840 --> 1692.200] Thank you for the invitation of a legal immigration, Margarit. +[1692.200 --> 1695.160] Thank you, Senator, for describing the legal process. +[1695.160 --> 1698.240] And I'm so much to get to you, Senator. +[1698.240 --> 1701.040] Those watching have been in the book since 1990. +[1701.040 --> 1702.040] Thank you, gentlemen. +[1702.120 --> 1703.120] We want to have- +[1703.120 --> 1703.320] We want to have- +[1703.320 --> 1705.640] The CBP-1 app has not been on the books since 1999. +[1705.640 --> 1708.160] It's something that's not like there was created water. +[1708.160 --> 1711.960] Gentlemen, the audience can't hear you because your mics are cut. +[1711.960 --> 1713.680] We have so much we want to get to. +[1713.680 --> 1716.280] Thank you for explaining the legal process. +[1716.280 --> 1717.920] Nora, thank you, Margarit. +[1717.920 --> 1721.240] The economy is a top concern for voters. +[1721.240 --> 1723.960] Each of your campaigns has released an economic plan. +[1723.960 --> 1726.000] So let's talk about the specifics. +[1726.000 --> 1730.480] Governor Walls, Vice President Harris unveiled a plan that includes billions in tax credits +[1730.480 --> 1731.960] for manufacturing. +[1731.960 --> 1734.360] Housing and a renewed child tax credit. +[1734.360 --> 1741.560] The Wharton School says your proposals will increase the nation's deficit by $1.2 trillion. +[1741.560 --> 1744.480] How would you pay for that without ballooning the deficit? +[1744.480 --> 1745.480] Governor, I'll give you two minutes. +[1745.480 --> 1746.480] Yeah, thank you. +[1746.480 --> 1750.400] And Kamala Harris and I do believe in the middle class because that's where we come from. +[1750.400 --> 1751.520] We both grew up in that. +[1751.520 --> 1752.520] We understand. +[1752.520 --> 1755.280] So those of you out there listening tonight, you're hearing a lot of stuff back and forth. +[1755.280 --> 1756.280] And it's good. +[1756.280 --> 1757.280] It's healthy. +[1757.280 --> 1758.280] That's what this was supposed to happen. +[1758.280 --> 1759.280] You should be listening. +[1759.280 --> 1760.520] How's this going to impact me? +[1760.520 --> 1765.400] The bold forward plan that Kamala Harris put out there is one is talking about this housing +[1765.400 --> 1766.400] issue. +[1766.400 --> 1771.040] But one thing is there's three million new houses proposed under this plan with downpayment +[1771.040 --> 1773.040] assistance on the front end to get you in a house. +[1773.040 --> 1777.120] A house is much more than just an asset to be traded somewhere. +[1777.120 --> 1778.800] It's foundational to where you're at. +[1778.800 --> 1782.120] And then making sure that the things you buy every day, whether they be prescription +[1782.120 --> 1784.960] drugs or other things, that there's fairness in that. +[1784.960 --> 1789.680] Look, the $35 insulin is a good thing, but it costs $5 to make insulin. +[1789.680 --> 1792.960] They were charging $800 before this law went into effect. +[1792.960 --> 1797.960] As far as the housing goes, I've seen it in Minnesota, 12% more houses in Minneapolis. +[1797.960 --> 1799.720] Prices went down on rent 4%. +[1799.720 --> 1800.720] It's working. +[1800.720 --> 1803.600] And then making sure tax cuts go to the middle class. +[1803.600 --> 1805.040] $6,000 child tax credit. +[1805.040 --> 1809.000] We have one in Minnesota, reduces childhood poverty by a third. +[1809.000 --> 1812.360] We save money in the long run and we do the right thing for families. +[1812.360 --> 1813.960] And then getting businesses off the ground. +[1813.960 --> 1818.480] The laws it stands right now is $5,000 tax credit for small business, increasing that to +[1818.480 --> 1819.480] 50,000. +[1819.560 --> 1821.640] Now, this is a philosophical difference between us. +[1821.640 --> 1823.920] Donald Trump made a promise and I'll give you this. +[1823.920 --> 1824.920] He kept it. +[1824.920 --> 1827.880] He took folks tomorrow, Lago, said, you're rich as hell, and give you a tax cut. +[1827.880 --> 1830.800] He gave the tax cuts that predominantly went to the top class. +[1830.800 --> 1836.000] What happened there was an $8 trillion increase in the national debt the largest ever. +[1836.000 --> 1842.280] Now he's proposing a 20% consumption or sales tax on everything we bring in. +[1842.280 --> 1845.520] Everyone agrees, including businesses, it would be destabilizing it. +[1845.520 --> 1848.840] It would increase inflation and potentially lead to a recession. +[1848.880 --> 1850.600] Look, this is simple for you. +[1850.600 --> 1851.400] Where are we going? +[1851.400 --> 1854.160] Kamala Harris has said to do the things she wants to do. +[1854.160 --> 1856.720] We'll just ask the wealthiest to pay their fair share. +[1856.720 --> 1859.280] When you do that, our system works best. +[1859.280 --> 1863.640] More people are participating in it and folks have the things that they need. +[1863.640 --> 1865.440] Senator, I want to give you a moment to respond on that. +[1865.440 --> 1870.080] But similarly, the Wharton School has done an analysis of the Trump plan and +[1870.080 --> 1874.880] says it would increase the nation's deficit by $5.8 trillion. +[1874.880 --> 1876.760] My question is the same for you. +[1876.760 --> 1880.040] How do you pay for all that without ballooning the deficit? +[1880.040 --> 1881.320] I'll give you two minutes. +[1881.320 --> 1884.480] Well, first of all, you're going to hear a lot from Tim Walls this evening. +[1884.480 --> 1885.680] And you just heard it in the answer. +[1885.680 --> 1888.560] A lot of what Kamala Harris proposes to do. +[1888.560 --> 1890.080] And some of it, I'll be honest with you. +[1890.080 --> 1891.480] It even sounds pretty good. +[1891.480 --> 1895.360] Here's what you won't hear is that Kamala Harris has already done it. +[1895.360 --> 1898.080] Because she's been the vice president for three and a half years. +[1898.080 --> 1901.720] She had the opportunity to enact all of these great policies. +[1901.720 --> 1906.480] And what she's actually done instead is drive the cost of food higher. +[1906.480 --> 1908.200] By 25%. +[1908.200 --> 1911.520] Drive the cost of housing higher by about 60%. +[1911.520 --> 1916.200] Open the American Southern border and make middle class life unaffordable for a large number +[1916.200 --> 1917.200] of Americans. +[1917.200 --> 1921.560] If Kamala Harris has such great plans for how to address middle class problems, then she +[1921.560 --> 1923.520] ought to do them now. +[1923.520 --> 1927.440] Not one asking for promotion, but in the job the American people gave her three and a half +[1927.440 --> 1928.440] years ago. +[1928.440 --> 1934.000] And the fact that she isn't tells you a lot about how much you can trust her actual plans. +[1934.000 --> 1938.480] Now Donald Trump's economic plan is not just a plan, but it's also a record. +[1938.480 --> 1942.640] A lot of those same economists attack Donald Trump's plans and they have PhDs, but they +[1942.640 --> 1945.640] don't have common sense and they don't have wisdom. +[1945.640 --> 1950.560] Because Donald Trump's economic policies delivered the highest take home pay in a generation +[1950.560 --> 1956.480] in this country, 1.5% inflation and to boot peace and security all over the world. +[1956.480 --> 1961.040] So when people say that Donald Trump's economic plan doesn't make sense, I say look at the +[1961.040 --> 1962.040] record. +[1962.040 --> 1965.040] It's delivered rising take home pay for American workers. +[1965.040 --> 1969.400] Now Tim admirably admits that they want to undo the Trump tax cuts. +[1969.400 --> 1973.480] But if you look at what was so different about Donald Trump's tax cuts, even from previous +[1973.480 --> 1978.480] Republican tax cut plans, is that a lot of those resources went to giving more take home +[1978.480 --> 1981.240] pay to middle class and working class Americans. +[1981.240 --> 1987.360] It was passed in 2017 and you saw an American economic boom unlike we've seen in a generation +[1987.360 --> 1988.360] in this country. +[1988.360 --> 1991.680] That is a record that I'm proud to run on and we're going to get back to that common +[1991.680 --> 1996.120] sense wisdom so that you can afford to live the American dream again. +[1996.120 --> 1997.720] I know a lot of you are struggling. +[1997.720 --> 2000.160] I know a lot of you are worried about paying the bills. +[2000.160 --> 2004.160] It's going to stop when Donald Trump brings back common sense to this country. +[2004.160 --> 2005.680] Governor, do you want to respond to that? +[2005.680 --> 2007.600] What has Kamala Harris done for the middle class? +[2007.600 --> 2012.080] Kamala Harris's day one was Donald Trump's failure on COVID that led to the collapse for +[2012.080 --> 2013.080] our economy. +[2013.080 --> 2016.800] We were already before COVID in a manufacturing recession, but 10 million people out of +[2016.800 --> 2019.520] work, largest percentage since a great depression. +[2019.520 --> 2021.520] Nine million jobs closed on that. +[2021.520 --> 2024.680] That was day one, whether it was the infrastructure act or other things we moved. +[2024.680 --> 2027.360] Now you made a question about experts said this. +[2027.360 --> 2031.520] I've made a note of this, economists don't know you have to be trusted. +[2031.520 --> 2033.400] Science can't be trusted. +[2033.400 --> 2035.400] National security folks can't be trusted. +[2035.400 --> 2039.080] Look, if you're going to be president, you don't have all the answers. +[2039.080 --> 2040.480] Donald Trump believes he does. +[2040.480 --> 2042.240] My pro tip of the day is this. +[2042.240 --> 2046.600] If you need heart surgery, listen to the people at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, +[2046.600 --> 2047.600] not Donald Trump. +[2047.600 --> 2049.120] And the same thing goes with this. +[2049.120 --> 2053.360] And I asked you out there, teachers, nurses, truck drivers, whatever. +[2053.360 --> 2056.440] How is it fair that you're paying your taxes every year? +[2056.440 --> 2060.120] And Donald Trump hasn't paid any federal tax to end the last 15 years. +[2060.120 --> 2061.640] And the last year is president. +[2061.640 --> 2063.320] That's what's wrong with the system. +[2063.320 --> 2066.040] There's a way around it and he's bragged about that. +[2066.040 --> 2068.040] We're just asking for fairness in it. +[2068.040 --> 2069.040] And that's all you want. +[2069.040 --> 2070.040] You have a minute. +[2070.040 --> 2072.840] Governor, you say trust the experts. +[2072.840 --> 2076.920] But those same experts for 40 years said that if we shipped our manufacturing base off +[2076.920 --> 2078.840] to China, we'd get cheaper goods. +[2078.840 --> 2079.960] They lied about that. +[2079.960 --> 2084.440] They said if we shipped our industrial base off to other countries to Mexico and elsewhere, +[2084.440 --> 2086.200] it would make the middle class stronger. +[2086.200 --> 2087.880] They were wrong about that. +[2087.880 --> 2093.640] They were wrong about the idea that if we made America less self-reliant, less productive +[2093.640 --> 2097.360] in our own nation, that it would somehow make us better off, and they were wrong about +[2097.360 --> 2098.360] it. +[2098.360 --> 2103.340] First time in a generation, Donald Trump had the wisdom and the courage to say to that +[2103.340 --> 2106.680] bipartisan consensus, we're not doing it anymore. +[2106.680 --> 2108.680] We're bringing American manufacturing back. +[2108.680 --> 2110.520] We're unleashing American energy. +[2110.520 --> 2112.280] We're going to make more of our own stuff. +[2112.280 --> 2113.680] And this isn't just an economic issue. +[2113.680 --> 2116.960] And I've got three beautiful little kids at home, seven, four, and two. +[2116.960 --> 2119.640] And I love them very much and I hope they're in bed right now. +[2119.640 --> 2124.040] But look, so many of the drugs, the pharmaceuticals that we put in the bodies of our children, +[2124.040 --> 2126.320] are manufactured by nations that hate us. +[2126.320 --> 2130.640] These have to stop and we're not going to stop it by listening to experts. +[2130.640 --> 2134.320] We're going to stop it by listening to common sense wisdom, which is what Donald Trump +[2134.320 --> 2135.320] governed on. +[2135.320 --> 2136.320] Senator, you're talking about Governor Walls. +[2136.320 --> 2137.320] Can you address that? +[2137.320 --> 2139.840] I mean, voters say they trust Donald Trump on the economy. +[2139.840 --> 2140.840] More. +[2140.840 --> 2141.840] Why? +[2141.840 --> 2144.760] If you're listening tonight and you want billionaire skittax cuts, you heard what the +[2144.760 --> 2146.560] numbers were. +[2146.560 --> 2149.040] Look, I'm a union guy on this. +[2149.040 --> 2153.360] I'm not a guy who wanted to ship things overseas, but I understand that, look, we produce +[2153.360 --> 2154.360] soybeans and corn. +[2154.360 --> 2156.120] We need to have fair trading partners. +[2156.120 --> 2157.400] That's something that we believe in. +[2157.400 --> 2163.440] I think the thing that most concerns me on this is, is Donald Trump was the guy who created +[2163.440 --> 2166.760] the largest trade deficit in American history with China. +[2166.760 --> 2168.520] So the rhetoric is good. +[2168.520 --> 2171.560] Much of what the Senator said right there, I'm in agreement with him on this. +[2171.560 --> 2172.560] I watched it happen too. +[2172.560 --> 2175.400] I watched it to my communities and we talked about that. +[2175.400 --> 2179.760] But we had people undercutting the right to collectively bargain. +[2179.760 --> 2181.960] We had right to work states made it more difficult. +[2181.960 --> 2183.920] We had companies that were willing to ship it over. +[2183.920 --> 2185.640] And we saw people profit. +[2185.640 --> 2189.640] There's a lot of things that folks that are venture capital in some cases, putting money +[2189.640 --> 2191.500] into companies that were overseas. +[2191.500 --> 2193.440] We're in agreement that we bring those home. +[2193.440 --> 2195.680] The issue is Donald Trump is talking about it. +[2195.680 --> 2196.680] Kamala Harris has a record. +[2196.680 --> 2200.600] 250,000 more manufacturing jobs just in the out of the IRA. +[2200.600 --> 2201.640] But Mayor Spont of that. +[2201.640 --> 2202.640] Yes. +[2202.640 --> 2203.920] So appreciate that. +[2203.920 --> 2208.000] So if you notice what Governor Waltz just did is he said, first of all, Donald Trump +[2208.000 --> 2209.720] has to listen to the experts. +[2209.720 --> 2212.480] And then when he acknowledged that the experts screwed up, he said, well, Donald Trump didn't +[2212.480 --> 2214.520] do nearly as good of a job as the citizen. +[2214.520 --> 2215.520] Coward. +[2215.520 --> 2216.520] He did. +[2216.520 --> 2217.760] So what Tim Waltz is doing. +[2217.760 --> 2220.720] And I honestly, Tim, I think you got a tough job here. +[2220.720 --> 2222.080] Because you've got to play whack them all. +[2222.080 --> 2225.680] You've got to pretend that Donald Trump didn't deliver rising take home pay. +[2225.680 --> 2226.880] Which of course he did. +[2226.880 --> 2230.240] You've got to pretend that Donald Trump didn't deliver lower inflation. +[2230.240 --> 2231.480] Which of course he did. +[2231.480 --> 2236.040] And then you simultaneously got to defend Kamala Harris's atrocious economic record, +[2236.040 --> 2240.520] which has made gas, groceries, and housing, unaffordable, fair American citizens. +[2240.520 --> 2245.240] I was raised by a woman who would sometimes go into medical debt so that she could put +[2245.240 --> 2247.480] food on the table in our household. +[2247.480 --> 2252.080] I know what it's like to not be able to afford the things that you need to afford. +[2252.080 --> 2253.680] We can do so much better. +[2253.680 --> 2257.760] To all of you watching, we can get back to an America that's affordable again. +[2257.760 --> 2260.480] We just got to get back to common sense economic principles. +[2260.480 --> 2263.080] I hope we have a conversation on health care then. +[2263.080 --> 2264.080] Senator Governor. +[2264.080 --> 2265.080] Please. +[2265.080 --> 2266.080] Thank you, Margaret. +[2266.080 --> 2269.640] We have a lot to get to ahead, gentlemen, on many topics. +[2269.640 --> 2273.400] Right now, I want to talk about personal qualifications. +[2273.400 --> 2279.560] The Vice President is often the last voice the President hears before making consequential +[2279.560 --> 2280.560] decisions. +[2280.560 --> 2284.120] We want to ask you about your leadership qualities. +[2284.120 --> 2289.120] Governor Walls, you said you were in Hong Kong during the Deadly Tiananmen Square protest +[2289.120 --> 2290.960] in the spring of 1989. +[2290.960 --> 2296.280] But Minnesota Public Radio and other media outlets are reporting that you actually didn't +[2296.280 --> 2300.520] travel to Asia until August of that year. +[2300.520 --> 2302.520] Can you explain that discrepancy? +[2302.520 --> 2303.520] Yes, I'm going to ask. +[2303.520 --> 2305.520] Well, into the folks out there, I didn't get at the top of this. +[2305.520 --> 2311.880] Look, I grew up in small rural Nebraska, town of 400, town that you rode your bike with +[2311.880 --> 2313.360] your buddy, still the street lights come on. +[2313.360 --> 2314.840] And I'm proud of that service. +[2314.840 --> 2318.600] I joined the National Guard at 17, worked on family farms. +[2318.600 --> 2323.960] And then I used the GI Bill to become a teacher, passionate, a young teacher. +[2323.960 --> 2328.560] My first year out, I got the opportunity in the summer of 1989 to travel to China. +[2328.560 --> 2330.360] 35 years ago, be able to do that. +[2330.360 --> 2335.440] I came back home and then started a program to take young people there. +[2335.440 --> 2339.640] We would take basketball teams, we would take baseball teams, we would take dancers, and +[2339.640 --> 2341.400] we would go back and forth to China. +[2341.400 --> 2343.560] The issue for that was to try and learn. +[2343.560 --> 2346.120] Now look, my community knows who I am. +[2346.120 --> 2347.560] They saw where I was at. +[2347.560 --> 2352.160] They look, I will be the first to tell you, I have poured my heart into my community. +[2352.160 --> 2356.920] I've tried to do the best I can, but I've not been perfect, and I'm a knucklehead at times. +[2356.920 --> 2358.440] But it's always been about that. +[2358.440 --> 2362.680] Those same people elected me to Congress for 12 years. +[2362.680 --> 2366.960] And in Congress, I was one of the most bipartisan people working on things like farm bills that +[2366.960 --> 2369.480] we got done, working on veterans benefits. +[2369.480 --> 2373.480] And then the people of Minnesota were able to elect me to governor twice. +[2373.480 --> 2378.480] So look, my commitment has been from the beginning to make sure that I'm there for the people, +[2378.480 --> 2380.000] to make sure that I get this right. +[2380.000 --> 2382.320] I will say more than anything. +[2382.320 --> 2387.040] Many times I will talk a lot, I will get caught up in the rhetoric. +[2387.040 --> 2391.520] But being there, the impact it made, the difference it made in my life, I learned a lot about +[2391.520 --> 2392.520] China. +[2392.520 --> 2393.520] I hear the critiques of this. +[2393.520 --> 2397.120] I would make the case that Donald Trump should have come on one of those trips with us. +[2397.120 --> 2401.920] I guarantee you, he wouldn't be praising Xi Jinping about COVID. +[2401.920 --> 2405.480] And I guarantee you, he wouldn't start a trade war that he ends up losing. +[2405.480 --> 2408.440] So this is about trying to understand the world. +[2408.440 --> 2411.640] It's about trying to do the best you can for your community. +[2411.640 --> 2415.160] And then it's putting yourself out there and letting your folks understand what it is. +[2415.160 --> 2418.920] My commitment, whether it be through teaching, which I was good at, or whether it was being +[2418.920 --> 2422.600] a good soldier or always being a good member of Congress, those are the things that I think +[2422.600 --> 2425.280] are the values that people care about. +[2425.280 --> 2431.200] Governor, just to follow up on that, the question was, can you explain the discrepancy? +[2431.200 --> 2434.640] All I said on this was, is I got there that summer and misspoke on this. +[2434.640 --> 2438.880] So I will just, that's what I've said. +[2438.880 --> 2444.920] So I was in Hong Kong and China during the democracy protest went in. +[2444.920 --> 2451.040] And from that, I learned a lot of what needed to be in governance. +[2451.040 --> 2452.360] Thank you, Governor. +[2452.360 --> 2458.280] Senator Vance, in 2016, you called your running mate Donald Trump unfit for the nation's +[2458.280 --> 2459.520] highest office. +[2459.520 --> 2462.240] And you said he could be America's Hitler. +[2462.240 --> 2464.120] I know you've said, you've been asked many times. +[2464.120 --> 2468.560] And you've said you regret those comments and explained you then voted for Donald Trump +[2468.560 --> 2470.000] in 2020. +[2470.000 --> 2474.840] But the Washington Post reported new messages last week in which you also disparaged Trump's +[2474.840 --> 2480.960] economic record while he was president, writing to someone in 2020, quote, Trump thoroughly +[2480.960 --> 2484.840] failed to deliver his economic populism. +[2484.840 --> 2486.480] You're now as running mate. +[2486.480 --> 2490.280] And you've shifted many of your policy stances to align with his. +[2490.280 --> 2495.480] If you become vice president, why should Americans trust that you will give Donald Trump the +[2495.480 --> 2501.040] advice he needs to hear and not just the advice he wants to hear? +[2501.040 --> 2502.040] You have two minutes. +[2502.040 --> 2504.120] Well, first of all, Margaret, because I've always been open. +[2504.120 --> 2507.240] And sometimes, of course, I've disagreed with the president, but I've also been extremely +[2507.240 --> 2510.200] open about the fact that I was wrong about Donald Trump. +[2510.200 --> 2514.000] I was wrong, first of all, because I believed some of the media stories that turned out to +[2514.000 --> 2516.560] be Dennis on as fabrications of his record. +[2516.560 --> 2521.600] But most importantly, Donald Trump delivered for the American people, rising wages, rising +[2521.600 --> 2526.320] take on pay, an economy that worked for normal Americans, a secure Southern border. +[2526.320 --> 2529.440] A lot of things, frankly, that I didn't think he'd be able to deliver on. +[2529.440 --> 2533.320] And yeah, when you screw up, when you misspeak, when you get something wrong and you change +[2533.320 --> 2535.680] your mind, you ought to be honest with the American people about it. +[2535.680 --> 2538.960] It's one of the reasons, Margaret, why I've done so many interviews is because I think +[2538.960 --> 2542.720] it's important to actually explain to the American people where I come down on the issues +[2542.720 --> 2543.720] and what change. +[2543.720 --> 2546.000] Now, you pointed out to messages from 2020. +[2546.000 --> 2549.360] Margaret, I've been extremely consistent that I think there were a lot of things that +[2549.360 --> 2554.920] we could have done better in the Trump administration the first round if Congress was doing its job. +[2554.920 --> 2559.040] I strongly believe, and I've been a United States Senator, that Congress is not just a high +[2559.040 --> 2560.280] class debating society. +[2560.280 --> 2564.200] It's not just a forum for senators and congressmen to wind about problems. +[2564.200 --> 2565.600] It's a forum to govern. +[2565.600 --> 2569.680] So there were a lot of things on the border, on tariffs, for example, where I think that +[2569.680 --> 2574.520] we could have done so much more if the Republican Congress and the Democrats in Congress had been +[2574.520 --> 2577.120] a little bit better about how they govern the country. +[2577.120 --> 2580.400] They were so obsessed with impeaching Donald Trump, they couldn't actually govern. +[2580.400 --> 2585.200] And I want to talk about this tariff issue in particular, Margaret, because Tim just +[2585.200 --> 2588.240] accused this of being a national sales tax. +[2588.240 --> 2593.280] Look, the one thing, and you're probably surprised to hear me praising Joe Biden, but the +[2593.280 --> 2598.440] one thing that Joe Biden did is he continued some of the Trump tariffs that protected American +[2598.440 --> 2599.760] manufacturing jobs. +[2599.760 --> 2603.760] And it's the one issue, the most pro-worker part of the Biden administration. +[2603.760 --> 2608.200] Because the one issue where Kamala Harris has run away from Joe Biden's record, think +[2608.200 --> 2609.200] about this. +[2609.200 --> 2614.540] If you're trying to employ slave laborers in China at $3 a day, you're going to do that +[2614.540 --> 2620.040] and undercut the wages of American workers unless our country stands up for itself and +[2620.040 --> 2624.280] says you're not accessing our markets unless you're paying middle-class Americans a fair +[2624.280 --> 2625.280] wage. +[2625.280 --> 2626.880] Senator, your time is up. +[2626.880 --> 2628.480] Nora, thank you. +[2628.480 --> 2630.680] Now to the issue of reproductive rights. +[2630.680 --> 2635.720] Governor Walls, after Roe versus Wade was overturned, you signed a bill into law that +[2635.720 --> 2641.840] made Minnesota one of the least restrictive states in the nation when it comes to abortion. +[2641.840 --> 2647.320] Former President Trump said in the last debate that you believe abortion, quote, in the ninth +[2647.320 --> 2650.160] month is absolutely fine. +[2650.160 --> 2652.040] Yes or no, is that what you support? +[2652.040 --> 2653.040] I'll give you two minutes. +[2653.040 --> 2658.720] That's not what the bill says, but look, this issue is what's on everyone's mind. +[2658.720 --> 2661.280] Donald Trump put this all into motion. +[2661.280 --> 2666.680] He brags about how great it was that he put the judges in and overturned Roe versus Wade, +[2666.680 --> 2669.040] 52 years of personal autonomy. +[2669.040 --> 2671.520] And then he tells us, oh, we send it to the states. +[2671.520 --> 2673.400] It's a beautiful thing. +[2673.400 --> 2676.920] Amanda Zorowski would disagree with you on it's a beautiful thing. +[2676.920 --> 2682.480] A young bride in Texas waiting for their child at 18 weeks, she has a complication, a tear +[2682.480 --> 2684.640] in the membrane, she needs to go in. +[2684.640 --> 2688.720] The medical care at that point needs to be decided by the doctor. +[2688.720 --> 2692.320] And that would have been an abortion, but in Texas, that would have put them in legal +[2692.320 --> 2693.320] jeopardy. +[2693.320 --> 2698.600] She went home, got sepsis, nearly dies, and now she may have difficulty having children. +[2698.600 --> 2705.920] Or in Kentucky, Hadley Duval, a 12 year old child raped and impregnated by her stepfather. +[2705.920 --> 2707.160] Those are horrific. +[2707.160 --> 2711.080] Now when God asked about that, Senator Vant said, two wrongs don't make a right. +[2711.080 --> 2713.680] There is no right in this. +[2713.680 --> 2718.240] So in Minnesota, what we did was restore Roe versus Wade. +[2718.240 --> 2722.040] We made sure that we put women in charge of their health care. +[2722.040 --> 2728.040] But look, this is not where, if you don't know Amanda or a Hadley, you soon will. +[2728.040 --> 2732.640] Their project 2025 is going to have a registry of pregnancies. +[2732.640 --> 2737.640] It's going to make it more difficult, if not impossible, to get contraception and limit +[2737.640 --> 2741.440] access, if not eliminate access to infertility treatments. +[2741.440 --> 2744.680] For so many of you out there listening, me included, infertility treatments are why +[2744.680 --> 2746.320] I have a child. +[2746.320 --> 2750.400] That's nobody else's business, but those things are being proposed. +[2750.400 --> 2755.180] And the catch-all on this is, as well, the states will decide what's right for Texas +[2755.180 --> 2757.440] might not be right for Washington. +[2757.440 --> 2759.000] That's not how this works. +[2759.000 --> 2760.400] This is basic human right. +[2760.400 --> 2767.560] We have seen maternal mortality skyrocket in Texas, outpacing many other countries in +[2767.560 --> 2768.640] the world. +[2768.640 --> 2769.880] This is about health care. +[2769.880 --> 2772.880] In Minnesota, we are ranked first in health care for a reason. +[2772.880 --> 2773.880] We trust women. +[2773.880 --> 2774.880] We trust doctors. +[2774.880 --> 2776.640] Senator, do you want to respond to the governor's claim? +[2776.640 --> 2779.800] Will you create a federal pregnancy monitoring agency? +[2779.800 --> 2782.200] No, no, or certainly we won't. +[2782.200 --> 2785.200] And I want to talk about this issue, because I know a lot of Americans care about it. +[2785.200 --> 2789.160] And I know a lot of Americans don't agree with everything that I've ever said on this +[2789.160 --> 2790.160] topic. +[2790.160 --> 2793.800] And, you know, I grew up in a working class family in a neighborhood where I knew a lot +[2793.800 --> 2798.320] of young women who had unplanned pregnancies and decided to terminate those pregnancies +[2798.320 --> 2801.200] because they feel like they didn't have any other options. +[2801.200 --> 2804.200] And you know, I, one of them is actually very dear to me. +[2804.200 --> 2807.480] And I know she's watching tonight, and I love you. +[2807.480 --> 2811.360] And she told me something a couple years ago that she felt like if she hadn't had the +[2811.360 --> 2816.280] abortion, that it would have destroyed her life because she was in an abusive relationship. +[2816.280 --> 2820.760] And I think that what I take from that as a Republican who proudly wants to protect +[2820.760 --> 2824.960] innocent life in this country, who proudly wants to protect the vulnerable, is that my +[2824.960 --> 2830.440] party we've got to do so much better of a job at earning the American people's trust +[2830.440 --> 2833.800] back on this issue where they frankly just don't trust us. +[2833.800 --> 2837.280] And I think that's one of the things that Donald Trump and I are endeavoring to do. +[2837.280 --> 2842.480] I want us as a Republican party to be pro-family in the fullest sense of the word. +[2842.480 --> 2844.360] I want us to support fertility treatments. +[2844.360 --> 2847.640] I want us to make it easier for moms to afford to have babies. +[2847.640 --> 2852.040] I want it to make it easier for young families to afford a home so they can afford a place +[2852.040 --> 2853.040] to raise that family. +[2853.040 --> 2858.200] And I think there's so much that we can do on the public policy front just to give women +[2858.200 --> 2859.200] more options. +[2859.200 --> 2864.800] Now, of course, Donald Trump has been very clear that on the abortion policy specifically, +[2864.800 --> 2867.560] that we have a big country and it's diverse. +[2867.560 --> 2870.880] And California has a different viewpoint on this than Georgia. +[2870.880 --> 2875.760] Georgia has a different viewpoint from Arizona and the proper way to handle this, as messy +[2875.760 --> 2882.160] as democracy sometimes is, is to let voters make these decisions, let the individual states +[2882.160 --> 2883.920] make their abortion policy. +[2883.920 --> 2888.080] And I think that's what makes the most sense in a very big, a very diverse and let's +[2888.080 --> 2891.680] be honest, sometimes a very, very messy and divided country. +[2891.680 --> 2895.240] Governor, would you like to respond and also answer the question about restrictions? +[2895.240 --> 2896.240] Yeah. +[2896.240 --> 2900.240] Well, the question got asked and Donald Trump made the accusation that wasn't true about +[2900.240 --> 2901.240] Minnesota. +[2901.240 --> 2905.080] Well, let me tell you about this idea that there's diverse states. +[2905.080 --> 2907.040] There's a young woman named Amber Thurman. +[2907.040 --> 2910.040] She happened to be in Georgia, a restrictive state. +[2910.040 --> 2915.600] Because of that, she had to travel a long distance to North Carolina to try and get her +[2915.600 --> 2917.080] care. +[2917.080 --> 2921.520] Amber Thurman died in that journey back and forth. +[2921.520 --> 2928.120] The fact of the matter is, how can we, as a nation, say that your life and your rights, +[2928.120 --> 2933.600] as basic as the right to control your own body, is determined on geography? +[2933.600 --> 2938.080] There's a very real chance that Amber Thurman lived in Minnesota. +[2938.080 --> 2940.000] She would be alive today. +[2940.000 --> 2942.480] That's why the restoration of Rovers is weighed. +[2942.480 --> 2945.720] When you listen to Vice President Harris talk about this subject and you hear me talk about +[2945.720 --> 2948.360] it, you hear us talking exactly the same. +[2948.360 --> 2952.000] Donald Trump is trying to figure out how to get the political right of this. +[2952.000 --> 2954.920] I agree with a lot of what Senator Van said about what's happening. +[2954.920 --> 2956.600] His running mate, though, does not. +[2956.600 --> 2957.600] And that's the problem. +[2957.600 --> 2958.600] Governor, your time is up. +[2958.600 --> 2960.360] Senator, let me ask you about that. +[2960.360 --> 2963.000] He mentioned, I think referring to a national ban. +[2963.000 --> 2968.640] In the past, you have supported a federal ban on abortion after 15 weeks. +[2968.640 --> 2973.320] In fact, you said if someone can't support legislation like that, quote, you are making +[2973.320 --> 2979.000] the United States the most barbaric pro-abortion regime anywhere in the entire world. +[2979.000 --> 2981.720] My question is, why have you changed your position? +[2981.720 --> 2985.320] Well, Nora, first of all, I never supported a national ban. +[2985.320 --> 2989.480] I did during what I was running for Senate in 2022 talk about setting some minimum national +[2989.480 --> 2990.480] standard. +[2990.480 --> 2994.000] For example, we have a partial birth abortion ban in this, in place, in this country, +[2994.000 --> 2995.000] at the federal level. +[2995.000 --> 2997.560] I don't think anybody is trying to get rid of that or at least I hope not. +[2997.720 --> 3000.920] Though I know that Democrats have taken a very radical pro-abortion stance. +[3000.920 --> 3005.080] But Nora, you know, one of the things that's changed is in the state of Ohio, we had a +[3005.080 --> 3007.520] referendum in 2023. +[3007.520 --> 3012.680] And the people of Ohio voted overwhelmingly, by the way, against my position. +[3012.680 --> 3015.920] And I think that what I learned from that, Nora, is that we've got to do a better job +[3015.920 --> 3017.560] at winning back people's trust. +[3017.560 --> 3020.520] So many young women would love to have families. +[3020.520 --> 3024.360] So many young women also see an unplanned pregnancy as something that's going to destroy +[3024.440 --> 3027.840] their livelihood, destroy their education, destroy their relationships. +[3027.840 --> 3030.600] And we have got to earn people's trust back. +[3030.600 --> 3035.440] And that's why Donald Trump and I are committed to pursuing pro-family policies, making childcare +[3035.440 --> 3039.800] more accessible, making fertility treatments more accessible, because we've got to do a +[3039.800 --> 3040.800] better job at that. +[3040.800 --> 3042.480] And that's what real leadership is. +[3042.480 --> 3043.480] Governor, your response. +[3043.480 --> 3046.640] Well, I'm going to respond on the pro-abortion piece of that. +[3046.640 --> 3047.640] No, we're not. +[3047.640 --> 3048.640] We're pro-women. +[3048.640 --> 3051.440] We're pro-freedom to make your own choice. +[3051.440 --> 3054.880] We know what the implications are to not be that. +[3054.880 --> 3059.760] Women having miscarriages, women not getting the care, physicians feeling like they may +[3059.760 --> 3062.600] be prosecuted for providing that care. +[3062.600 --> 3067.000] And as far as making sure that we're educating our children and giving them options, Minnesota +[3067.000 --> 3069.840] is a state with one of the lowest-team pregnancy rates. +[3069.840 --> 3070.920] We understand that, too. +[3070.920 --> 3074.600] We know that the options need to be available, and we make that true. +[3074.600 --> 3075.600] We also make it. +[3075.600 --> 3079.280] We're a top three state for the best place to raise children. +[3079.280 --> 3083.760] But these two things to try and say that we're pro-children, but we don't like this, +[3083.760 --> 3087.120] or you guys are pro-abortion, that's not the case at all. +[3087.120 --> 3089.800] We are pro-freedom for women to make their choices. +[3089.800 --> 3094.340] And we're going, and Kamala Harris is making the case, to make options for children more +[3094.340 --> 3099.440] affordable, a $6,000 child tax credit, but we're not going to base on on the backs of making +[3099.440 --> 3103.680] someone like Amber Thurman drive 600 miles to try and get health care. +[3103.680 --> 3104.680] Senator. +[3104.680 --> 3105.680] Mayors respond to that. +[3105.680 --> 3106.680] First of all, Governor, I agree with you. +[3106.680 --> 3107.680] Amber Thurman should still be alive. +[3107.680 --> 3110.480] And there are a lot of people who should still be alive, and I certainly wish that she +[3110.480 --> 3111.480] was. +[3111.480 --> 3115.760] And maybe you're free to disagree with me on this and explain this to me. +[3115.760 --> 3120.680] But as I read the Minnesota law that you signed into law, the statute that you signed +[3120.680 --> 3126.160] into law, it says that a doctor who presides over an abortion where the baby survives, +[3126.160 --> 3130.720] the doctor is under no obligation to provide life-saving care to a baby who survives a +[3130.720 --> 3132.960] botched late-term abortion. +[3132.960 --> 3136.280] That is, I think, what is your pro-choice or pro-opportion? +[3136.280 --> 3140.960] That is fundamentally barbaric, and that's why I use that word, Nora, is because some +[3140.960 --> 3144.880] of what we've seen, do you want to force Catholic hospitals to perform abortions against +[3144.880 --> 3145.880] their will? +[3145.880 --> 3150.840] Because Kamala Harris is supported suing Catholic nuns to violate their freedom of conscience. +[3150.840 --> 3155.200] We can be a big and diverse country where we respect people's freedom of conscience and +[3155.200 --> 3157.760] make the country more pro-baby and pro-family, but please. +[3157.760 --> 3159.920] Yes, Governor, please respond. +[3159.920 --> 3164.040] Look, this is one where there's always something that this is a very simple proposition. +[3164.040 --> 3168.400] These are women's decisions to make about their healthcare decisions and the physicians +[3168.400 --> 3170.640] who know best when they need to do this. +[3170.640 --> 3173.840] Trying to distort the way a law is written to try and make a point. +[3173.840 --> 3174.840] That's not it at all. +[3174.840 --> 3175.840] What was I wrong about, Governor? +[3175.840 --> 3176.840] Please tell me what was that wrong about? +[3176.840 --> 3178.240] That is not the way the law is written. +[3178.240 --> 3180.000] Look, I've given how? +[3180.000 --> 3183.280] I've given this advice on a lot of things that getting involved, getting you gets. +[3183.280 --> 3185.800] That's been misread, and it was fact-checked at the last debate. +[3185.800 --> 3190.400] But the point on this is, is there's a continuation of these guys to try and tell women or to +[3190.400 --> 3191.400] get involved. +[3191.400 --> 3192.800] I use this line on this. +[3192.800 --> 3194.920] Just mind your own business on this. +[3194.920 --> 3197.640] Things work best when Roe vs. Wade was in place. +[3197.640 --> 3200.280] When we do a restoration of Roe, that works best. +[3200.280 --> 3204.920] That doesn't preclude us from increasing funding for children. +[3204.920 --> 3209.000] It doesn't increase us from making sure that once that child's born, like in Minnesota, +[3209.000 --> 3210.200] they get meals. +[3210.200 --> 3212.280] They get early childhood education. +[3212.280 --> 3213.760] They get healthcare. +[3213.760 --> 3218.000] So the hiding behind we're going to do all these other things when you're not proposing +[3218.000 --> 3220.480] them in your budget, Kamal Harris is proposing them. +[3220.480 --> 3223.280] These are proposing all those things to make life easier for families. +[3223.280 --> 3225.000] I asked a specific question, Governor. +[3225.000 --> 3226.400] You gave me a slogan as a response. +[3226.400 --> 3227.400] It's not the case. +[3227.400 --> 3228.400] It's not true. +[3228.400 --> 3229.400] That's not what the law says. +[3229.400 --> 3232.600] So, yay, fact-checked it with President Trump. +[3232.600 --> 3234.040] Gentlemen, there's a lot to discuss. +[3234.040 --> 3235.040] We have to move on. +[3235.040 --> 3238.920] And we're going to be right back with much more of the CBS News' vice presidential debate +[3238.920 --> 3239.680] in just a moment. +[3250.480 --> 3263.760] Welcome back to the CBS News' vice presidential debate. +[3263.760 --> 3267.400] We want to turn now to America's gun violence epidemic. +[3267.400 --> 3273.200] The leading cause of death for children and teens in America is by firearms. +[3273.200 --> 3279.000] Senator Vance, you oppose most gun legislation that Democrats claim would curb gun violence. +[3279.000 --> 3284.840] You oppose red flag gun laws and legislation to ban certain semi-automatic rifles, including +[3284.840 --> 3285.840] AR-15s. +[3285.840 --> 3291.360] So, let me ask you, earlier this year, for the first time, the parents of a school shooter +[3291.360 --> 3296.880] were convicted of involuntary manslaughter and sentenced to 10 years in prison. +[3296.880 --> 3301.400] Do you think holding parents responsible could curb mass shootings? +[3301.400 --> 3302.400] I'll give you two minutes. +[3302.400 --> 3303.960] Yeah, well, we're all in that particular case. +[3303.960 --> 3307.640] I don't know the full details, but I certainly trust local law enforcement and local authorities +[3307.640 --> 3308.640] to make those decisions. +[3308.640 --> 3311.560] I think in some cases, the answer is going to be yes, and in some cases, the answer is +[3311.560 --> 3312.560] going to be no. +[3312.560 --> 3314.400] And the details really matter here, of course. +[3314.400 --> 3318.440] For example, if a kid steals a gun, that's going to be different than if a parent hands +[3318.440 --> 3321.240] over a gun knowing that their kid is potentially dangerous. +[3321.240 --> 3326.720] Look, I want to just sort of speak as a father of three beautiful little kids and our oldest +[3326.720 --> 3328.800] is now in second grade. +[3328.800 --> 3333.000] And like a lot of parents, we send our kids to school with such hope and such joy and +[3333.000 --> 3335.840] such pride at their little faces on the first day of school. +[3335.840 --> 3339.880] And we know, unfortunately, that a lot of kids are going to experience this terrible epidemic +[3339.880 --> 3340.880] of gun violence. +[3340.880 --> 3344.640] And of course, our hearts go out to the families that are affected by this terrible stuff, +[3344.640 --> 3346.320] and we do have to do better. +[3346.320 --> 3349.520] And I think that Governor Walson, I actually probably agree that we need to do better on +[3349.520 --> 3350.520] this. +[3350.520 --> 3352.760] The question is just, how do we actually do it? +[3352.760 --> 3357.680] Now here's something that really bothers me and worries me about this epidemic of violence. +[3357.680 --> 3362.640] The gross majority, close to 90% and some of the statistics I've seen of the gun violence +[3362.640 --> 3366.200] in this country is committed with illegally obtained firearms. +[3366.200 --> 3370.480] And while we're on that topic, we know that thanks to Kamala Harris's open border, we've +[3370.480 --> 3375.600] seen a massive influx in the number of illegal guns run by the Mexican drug cartel. +[3375.600 --> 3379.920] So that number, the amount of illegal guns in our country is higher today than it was +[3379.920 --> 3381.600] three and a half years ago. +[3381.600 --> 3383.360] But what do we do about the schools? +[3383.360 --> 3384.600] What do we do to protect our kids? +[3384.600 --> 3389.120] And I think the answer is, and I say this, not loving the answer, because I don't want +[3389.120 --> 3394.360] my kids to go to school and a school that feels unsafe or where there are visible signs +[3394.360 --> 3399.600] of security, but I unfortunately think that we have to increase security in our schools. +[3399.600 --> 3401.280] We have to make the doors lock better. +[3401.280 --> 3402.960] We have to make the doors stronger. +[3402.960 --> 3404.640] We've got to make the windows stronger. +[3404.640 --> 3408.880] And of course, we've got to increase school resource officers because the idea that we +[3408.880 --> 3413.400] can magically wave a wand and take guns out of the hands of bad guys, it just doesn't +[3413.400 --> 3414.800] fit with recent experience. +[3414.800 --> 3416.640] So we've got to make our schools safer. +[3416.640 --> 3420.480] And I think we've got to have some common sense bipartisan solutions for how to do that. +[3420.480 --> 3422.120] Governor, you have two minutes. +[3422.120 --> 3425.560] Well, I think all the parents watching tonight, this is just your biggest nightmare. +[3425.560 --> 3431.000] Look, I got a, I got a 17 year old and, and he witnessed a shooting in a community center +[3431.000 --> 3432.320] playing volleyball. +[3432.320 --> 3433.600] Those things don't leave you. +[3433.600 --> 3440.440] As a member of Congress, I set in my office surrounded by dozens of the Sandioc parents, +[3440.440 --> 3442.960] and they were looking at my seven year old picture on the wall. +[3442.960 --> 3444.640] Their seven year old were dead. +[3444.640 --> 3446.320] And they were asking us to do something. +[3446.320 --> 3447.800] And look, I'm a hunter. +[3447.800 --> 3449.120] I own firearms. +[3449.120 --> 3450.480] The vice president is. +[3450.480 --> 3454.600] We understand that the second amendment is there, but our first responsibilities to our +[3454.600 --> 3456.360] kids to figure this out. +[3456.360 --> 3462.920] In Minnesota, we've enacted enhanced red flag laws, enhanced background checks. +[3462.920 --> 3464.120] And we can start to get data. +[3464.120 --> 3465.440] But here's the problem. +[3465.440 --> 3469.920] If we really want to solve this, we've got folks that won't allow research to be even +[3469.920 --> 3471.800] done on gun violence. +[3471.800 --> 3474.720] And this idea that we should just live with it. +[3474.720 --> 3478.680] And here's what I do think, that this is a good start to the conversation. +[3478.680 --> 3484.520] I 100% believe that Senator Vance hates it when these kids, it's a warrant and it breaks +[3484.520 --> 3485.520] your heart. +[3485.520 --> 3486.720] I agree with that. +[3486.720 --> 3489.960] But that's not far enough when we know they're things that work. +[3489.960 --> 3494.280] I've spent time in Finland and seen some Finnish schools. +[3494.280 --> 3499.280] They don't have this happen, even though they have a high gun ownership rate in the country. +[3499.280 --> 3503.480] There are reasonable things that we can do to make a difference. +[3503.480 --> 3505.880] It's not infringing on your second amendment. +[3505.880 --> 3511.080] And the idea to have some of these weapons out there, it just doesn't make any sense. +[3511.080 --> 3514.360] Kamala Harris as an attorney general worked on this issue. +[3514.360 --> 3515.760] She knows that it's there. +[3515.760 --> 3519.640] No one's trying to scare monger and say we're taking your guns, but I ask all of you out +[3519.640 --> 3520.640] there. +[3520.640 --> 3524.280] Do you want your school's hardened to look like a fort? +[3524.280 --> 3525.600] Is that what we have to go? +[3525.600 --> 3530.640] When we know there's countries around the world that their children aren't practicing +[3530.640 --> 3532.240] these types of drills. +[3532.240 --> 3533.240] They're being kids. +[3533.240 --> 3535.360] They owe it to them to get a fix. +[3535.360 --> 3537.560] These are things that shouldn't be that difficult. +[3537.560 --> 3540.560] You can still keep your firearms and we can make a difference. +[3540.560 --> 3541.560] We have to. +[3541.560 --> 3544.360] If you're listening tonight, this breaks your heart. +[3544.360 --> 3545.360] Senator. +[3545.360 --> 3547.760] First of all, I didn't know that you're 17-year-old witness to shooting. +[3547.760 --> 3548.760] I'm sorry about that. +[3548.760 --> 3549.760] I appreciate it. +[3549.760 --> 3551.080] I appreciate Christ have mercy. +[3551.080 --> 3552.080] It is awful. +[3552.080 --> 3555.560] And I appreciate what Tim said, actually, about Finland. +[3555.560 --> 3559.280] Because I do think it illustrates some of the, frankly, weird differences between our +[3559.280 --> 3561.800] own country's gun violence problem. +[3561.800 --> 3567.880] And Finland is, first of all, we have way higher rates of mental health abuse or mental +[3567.880 --> 3570.360] health substance abuse. +[3570.360 --> 3574.000] We have way higher rates of depression, way higher rates of anxiety. +[3574.000 --> 3577.560] We unfortunately have a mental health crisis in this country that I really do think that +[3577.560 --> 3581.160] we need to get to the root causes of because I don't think it's the whole reason why we +[3581.160 --> 3585.120] have such a bad gun violence problem, but I do think it's a big piece of it. +[3585.120 --> 3589.160] Another driver of the gun violence epidemic, especially that affecting our kids, it doesn't +[3589.160 --> 3594.960] earn as many headlines, but is the terrible gun violence problem in a lot of our big cities. +[3594.960 --> 3600.080] And this is why we have to empower law enforcement to arrest the bad guys, put them away, and +[3600.080 --> 3601.880] take gun offenders off the streets. +[3601.880 --> 3605.960] I think it's a whole host of things that we can do here, but I do think that our schools +[3605.960 --> 3608.080] we've got to talk about more security. +[3608.080 --> 3609.080] Senator, thank you, Governor. +[3609.080 --> 3613.560] You previously opposed an assault weapons ban, but only later in your political career, +[3613.560 --> 3614.560] did you change your position? +[3614.560 --> 3615.560] Why? +[3615.560 --> 3617.160] Yeah, I sat in that office with those anti-occurring parents. +[3617.160 --> 3618.840] I've become friends with school shooters. +[3618.840 --> 3619.840] I've seen it. +[3619.840 --> 3621.800] Look, the NRA, I was the NRA guy for a long time. +[3621.800 --> 3623.520] They used to teach gun safety. +[3623.520 --> 3628.360] I'm of an age where my shotgun was in my car, so I could fesson on after football practice. +[3628.360 --> 3630.200] That's not what we live today. +[3630.200 --> 3635.440] And several things I want to mention on this is talking about cities and where it's at, +[3635.440 --> 3641.560] the number one where the most firearm deaths happen in Minnesota are rural suicides. +[3641.560 --> 3645.880] And we have an epidemic of children getting guns and shooting themselves. +[3645.880 --> 3652.040] And so we have, and we should look at all of the issues, making sure folks have health +[3652.040 --> 3654.080] care and all that, but I want to be very careful. +[3654.080 --> 3658.080] This idea of stigmatizing mental health, just because you have a mental health issue, +[3658.080 --> 3659.440] doesn't mean you're violent. +[3659.440 --> 3663.760] And I think what we end up doing is we start looking for a scapegoat, sometimes it just +[3663.760 --> 3665.240] is the guns. +[3665.240 --> 3666.680] It's just the guns. +[3666.680 --> 3668.400] And there are things that you can do about it. +[3668.400 --> 3671.960] But I do think that this is one, and I think this is a healthy conversation. +[3671.960 --> 3676.920] I think there's a capacity to find solutions on this that work, protect Second Amendment, +[3676.920 --> 3677.920] protect our children. +[3677.920 --> 3678.920] That's our priority. +[3678.920 --> 3680.200] Gentlemen, thank you, Margaret. +[3680.200 --> 3681.440] Thank you, Nora. +[3681.440 --> 3687.800] Let's turn now to the top contributor to inflation, the high cost of housing and rent. +[3687.800 --> 3692.480] There's a shortage of more than 4 million homes in the United States, and that contributes +[3692.480 --> 3694.640] to the high housing prices. +[3694.640 --> 3700.640] Governor Walls, the Harris campaign promises a $25,000 down payment assistance for first +[3700.640 --> 3705.360] time home buyers and a $10,000 tax credit. +[3705.360 --> 3709.520] They also promise to build 3 million new homes. +[3709.520 --> 3713.520] Where are you building these homes and won't handing out that kind of money just drive +[3713.520 --> 3714.520] up prices higher? +[3714.520 --> 3715.880] No, it's not handing out. +[3715.880 --> 3718.960] We have, first let me say this, this issue of housing. +[3718.960 --> 3722.880] And I think those of you listening on this, the problem we've had is that we've got a +[3722.880 --> 3725.960] lot of folks that see housing as another commodity. +[3725.960 --> 3727.160] It can be bought up. +[3727.160 --> 3728.160] It can be shifted. +[3728.160 --> 3729.880] It can be moved around. +[3729.880 --> 3731.760] Those are not folks living in those houses. +[3731.760 --> 3733.880] Those of you listening tonight, that house is a big deal. +[3733.880 --> 3736.200] I bought and owned one house in my life. +[3736.200 --> 3738.040] My mom still lives in the house where I was. +[3738.040 --> 3742.520] And when I think of a house, I'm thinking of Christmas services after midnight mass where +[3742.520 --> 3743.920] you go with your family. +[3743.920 --> 3745.760] We need to make it more affordable. +[3745.760 --> 3750.960] And one of the things, as I said, this program that the vice president is pushing forward +[3750.960 --> 3754.760] and bringing a new way of approaching this is something we're doing in Minnesota from +[3754.760 --> 3755.840] that lead. +[3755.840 --> 3759.920] We in the state invested in making sure our housing was the biggest investment that +[3759.920 --> 3761.400] we'd ever made in housing. +[3761.400 --> 3762.720] It starts to make it easier. +[3762.720 --> 3766.480] We cut some of the red tape, local folks, look, we can't do it at the federal level, but +[3766.480 --> 3768.680] local folks make it easier to build those homes. +[3768.680 --> 3773.280] And then that down payment assistance, I can tell all of you out there, one of the certainly +[3773.280 --> 3779.120] for me using the GI bill was one thing, but a veteran's home loan, the big thing about +[3779.120 --> 3783.080] a veteran's home loan is you don't have to pay the down payment. +[3783.080 --> 3784.080] Those are things that make it there. +[3784.080 --> 3787.320] Now look, you're going to pay it back and you're going to pay your mortgage. +[3787.320 --> 3790.720] Those are things that we know in the long run, the appreciated value, the general +[3790.720 --> 3792.640] wealth that's created from it. +[3792.640 --> 3794.680] And I will give Minneapolis an example. +[3794.680 --> 3798.120] Manyapolis is the one city where we've seen the lowest inflation rates. +[3798.120 --> 3803.040] We've seen a 12% increase in stock because we've put some of these things in and we're +[3803.040 --> 3807.400] implementing a state program to make sure we give some of that down payment assistance. +[3807.400 --> 3810.440] We get it back from people because here's what we know. +[3810.440 --> 3813.320] People with staple housing end up with stable jobs. +[3813.320 --> 3817.240] People with stable housing have their kids able to be able to get to school. +[3817.240 --> 3820.280] All of those things in the long run end up saving our money. +[3820.280 --> 3824.080] And that's the thing that I think we should be able to find some common ground in, but +[3824.080 --> 3827.760] we can't blame immigrants for the only reason. +[3827.760 --> 3829.720] That's not the case, it's happening in many cities. +[3829.720 --> 3835.240] The fact of the matter is, is that we don't have enough naturally affordable housing, but +[3835.240 --> 3841.080] we can make sure that the government's there to help kickstart it, create that base. +[3841.080 --> 3842.320] Governor, your time is up. +[3842.320 --> 3847.640] Senator Vance, as far as your campaign's position, the promise is to seize federal +[3847.640 --> 3853.720] lands to build homes, remove regulation, provide tax breaks, and cut back on immigration, +[3853.720 --> 3857.040] which you say pushes up prices. +[3857.040 --> 3858.320] Where are you going to build? +[3858.320 --> 3859.920] All the new homes you're promising. +[3859.920 --> 3864.000] And what part of any of this plan will provide immediate relief? +[3864.000 --> 3865.000] You have two minutes. +[3865.000 --> 3868.160] Well, first of all, Tim just said something that I agree with. +[3868.160 --> 3871.720] We don't want to blame immigrants for higher housing prices, but we do want to blame +[3871.720 --> 3876.880] Kamala Harris for letting in millions of illegal aliens into this country, which does +[3876.880 --> 3883.120] drive up cost him 25 million illegal aliens competing with Americans for scarce homes +[3883.120 --> 3887.000] is one of the most significant drivers of home prices in the country. +[3887.000 --> 3892.760] It's why we have massive increases in home prices that have happened right alongside +[3892.760 --> 3898.480] massive increases in illegal alien populations under Kamala Harris' leadership. +[3898.480 --> 3900.520] Now Tim just mentioned a bunch of ideas. +[3900.520 --> 3903.920] Now, some of those ideas actually think are halfway decent, and some of them I disagree +[3903.920 --> 3904.920] with. +[3904.920 --> 3909.760] But the most important thing here is Kamala Harris is not running as a newcomer to politics. +[3909.760 --> 3911.600] She is the sitting vice president. +[3911.600 --> 3916.480] If she wants to enact all of these policies to make housing more affordable, I invite +[3916.480 --> 3921.560] her to use the office that the American people already gave her, not sit around and campaign +[3921.560 --> 3927.680] and do nothing while Americans find the American dream of homeownership completely unaffordable. +[3927.680 --> 3933.000] Now you asked Margaret what would immediately change the equation for American citizens if +[3933.000 --> 3935.080] you lower energy prices. +[3935.080 --> 3939.600] As Donald Trump says, drill baby drill, one of the biggest drivers of housing costs aside +[3939.600 --> 3942.080] from illegal immigration is think about it. +[3942.080 --> 3946.280] If a truck driver is paying 40% more for diesel, then the lumber he is delivering to the +[3946.280 --> 3950.360] job site to build the house is also going to become a lot more expensive. +[3950.360 --> 3956.120] If we open up American energy, you will get immediate pricing release relief for American +[3956.120 --> 3961.440] citizens, not by the way just in housing, but in a whole host of other economic goods too. +[3961.440 --> 3964.200] Senator Vance, you still have 23 seconds there. +[3964.200 --> 3965.200] Do you want to answer? +[3965.200 --> 3966.200] Can I have it? +[3966.200 --> 3967.200] Where? +[3967.200 --> 3968.640] Governor, we will get to you in a moment. +[3968.640 --> 3971.440] But Senator, where are you going to seize the federal lands? +[3971.440 --> 3972.440] Can you clarify? +[3972.440 --> 3975.320] Well, what Donald Trump has said is we have a lot of federal lands that aren't being +[3975.320 --> 3978.720] used for anything, they're not being used for national park, they're not being used, +[3978.720 --> 3981.880] and they could be places where we build a lot of housing. +[3981.880 --> 3985.280] And I do think that we should be opening up building in this country. +[3985.280 --> 3990.200] We have a lot of land that could be used, we have a lot of Americans that need homes, +[3990.200 --> 3994.040] we should be kicking out illegal immigrants who are competing for those homes, and we should +[3994.040 --> 3997.680] be building more homes for the American citizens who deserve to be here. +[3997.680 --> 3999.280] Senator, your time is up. +[3999.280 --> 4003.920] Governor, I do want to let you respond to the allegation that the Vice President is +[4003.920 --> 4005.560] letting in my friends. +[4005.560 --> 4006.560] Of course, that's not true. +[4006.560 --> 4007.560] Again, you have facts. +[4007.560 --> 4011.080] I guess we agreed not to fact check, I'll check it, look, crossings are down compared +[4011.080 --> 4015.640] to when Donald Trump left office, but it's again blaming and not trying to find the solution. +[4015.640 --> 4019.800] I was going to ask on this question, are we going to drill and build houses in the same +[4019.800 --> 4020.880] federal land? +[4020.880 --> 4024.480] And I think when people hear federal lands, these are really important pieces of land. +[4024.480 --> 4027.800] Now, Minnesota doesn't have a lot of federal lands, I know in the western part of the countries +[4027.800 --> 4028.800] we do. +[4028.800 --> 4033.200] There's not a lot of federal lands in and around Minneapolis, for example. +[4033.200 --> 4037.400] So the issue is, I don't understand the federal lands issue, unless we see this, and I worry +[4037.400 --> 4041.000] about this, is someone who cares deeply about our national parks, and our federal lands +[4041.000 --> 4043.200] look Minnesota, we protect these things. +[4043.200 --> 4045.760] We've got about 20 percent of the world's fresh water. +[4045.760 --> 4046.760] These lands protect. +[4046.760 --> 4047.760] They're there for a reason. +[4047.760 --> 4049.240] They belong to all of us. +[4049.240 --> 4053.320] But again, this is when you view housing and you view these things as commodities. +[4053.320 --> 4055.040] There's a chance to make money here. +[4055.040 --> 4057.480] Let's take this federal land and let's sell it to people for that. +[4057.480 --> 4059.560] I think there's better ways to do this. +[4059.560 --> 4060.560] We've seen it in Minnesota. +[4060.560 --> 4063.840] We're able to refurbish some of these houses, we're able to make some investments, that +[4063.840 --> 4064.840] gets people in. +[4064.840 --> 4068.480] And I'm still on the fact on this, economists. +[4068.480 --> 4071.000] You, Senator Bench, you said you don't like the economists. +[4071.000 --> 4074.280] Which economists are saying that it is immigrants that's adding to the cost? +[4074.280 --> 4080.360] Governor, Governor, your time is up, but Senator, on that point, I'd like for you to clarify, +[4080.360 --> 4083.920] there are many contributing factors to high housing costs. +[4083.920 --> 4088.760] What evidence do you have that migrants are part of this problem? +[4088.880 --> 4091.840] Well, there's a Federal Reserve study that we're happy to share after the debate. +[4091.840 --> 4095.840] We'll put it up on social media, actually, that really drills down on the connection +[4095.840 --> 4100.720] between increased levels of migration, especially illegal immigration and higher housing prices. +[4100.720 --> 4104.680] Now, of course, Margaret, that's not the entire driver of higher housing prices. +[4104.680 --> 4108.400] It's also the regulatory regime of Kamala Harris. +[4108.400 --> 4110.360] Look, we are a country of builders. +[4110.360 --> 4111.520] We're a country of doers. +[4111.520 --> 4113.280] We're a country of explorers. +[4113.280 --> 4118.720] But we increasingly have a federal administration that makes it harder to develop our resources +[4118.720 --> 4120.800] and makes it harder to build things. +[4120.800 --> 4128.000] And wants to throw people in jail for not doing everything exactly as Kamala Harris says they have to do. +[4128.000 --> 4131.760] And what that means is that you have a lot of people who would love to build homes, +[4131.760 --> 4133.160] who aren't able to build homes. +[4133.160 --> 4134.640] I actually agree with Tim Waltz. +[4134.640 --> 4137.640] We should get out of this idea of housing as a commodity. +[4137.640 --> 4144.320] But the thing that is most turn housing into a commodity is giving it away to millions upon millions of people +[4144.320 --> 4146.520] who have no legal right to be here. +[4146.520 --> 4148.080] What are the federal regulations? +[4148.120 --> 4150.280] Is it ideal with this as a governor? +[4150.280 --> 4151.680] You can very quickly reply. +[4151.680 --> 4152.680] I'm sorry. +[4152.680 --> 4154.080] I get this as a governor. +[4154.080 --> 4155.840] And I don't necessarily disagree with that. +[4155.840 --> 4158.240] That in some cases, many of those are local. +[4158.240 --> 4159.200] Many of them are state. +[4159.200 --> 4160.440] I don't know which ones are federal. +[4160.440 --> 4164.720] But I think whenever we talk regulations, people think they can get rid of them. +[4164.720 --> 4167.720] I think you want to be able to get out of your house in a fire. +[4167.720 --> 4170.560] I think you want to make sure that it's fireproof in those types of things. +[4170.560 --> 4171.800] So which are the regulations? +[4171.800 --> 4174.600] Because the vice president's not responsible for those. +[4174.600 --> 4176.080] Congress writes those. +[4176.080 --> 4178.520] Governor, thank you, gentlemen. +[4178.520 --> 4179.920] We have a lot to get through. +[4179.920 --> 4181.760] You're passionate about the housing crisis. +[4181.760 --> 4184.520] I can tell, but Nora, thank you. +[4184.520 --> 4190.160] One of the top problems facing Americans is the high cost of health care, Senator Vance. +[4190.160 --> 4194.880] At the last presidential debate, former president Trump was asked about replacing the Affordable +[4194.880 --> 4196.040] Care Act. +[4196.040 --> 4200.520] In response, he said, I have concepts of a plan. +[4200.520 --> 4204.520] Since then, Senator, you've talked about changing how chronically ill Americans get health +[4204.520 --> 4205.520] insurance. +[4205.520 --> 4208.160] Can you explain how that would work? +[4208.160 --> 4213.440] And can you guarantee that Americans with pre-existing conditions won't pay more? +[4213.440 --> 4214.440] I'll give you two minutes. +[4214.440 --> 4218.160] Well, of course, we're going to cover Americans with pre-existing conditions. +[4218.160 --> 4221.840] In fact, a lot of my family members have gotten health care. +[4221.840 --> 4225.640] I believe, you know, members of my family actually got private health insurance, at least +[4225.640 --> 4230.040] for the first time, switched off a Medicaid onto private insurance for the first time under +[4230.040 --> 4231.040] Donald Trump's leadership. +[4231.040 --> 4235.360] And I think that, you know, a lot of people have criticized this concepts of a plan remark. +[4235.360 --> 4237.200] It gets very simple, common sense. +[4237.200 --> 4239.720] I think it's Tim Walls' nose from 12 years in Congress. +[4239.720 --> 4243.480] You're not going to propose a 900-page bill standing on a debate stage. +[4243.480 --> 4245.080] You would bore everybody to tears. +[4245.080 --> 4249.000] And it wouldn't actually mean anything because part of this is the give and take of bipartisan +[4249.000 --> 4250.000] negotiation. +[4250.000 --> 4254.680] Now, when Donald Trump was actually president, and again, he has a record to be proud of, +[4254.680 --> 4259.400] prescription drugs fell in 2018 for the first time in a very long time, but are Kamala +[4259.400 --> 4260.400] Harris' leadership. +[4260.400 --> 4262.920] Prescription drugs are up about 7 percent. +[4262.920 --> 4266.920] Under Donald Trump's entire four years, they were up about 1.5 percent. +[4266.920 --> 4269.240] He introduced pricing transparency. +[4269.240 --> 4270.560] Think about health care. +[4270.560 --> 4275.360] You go into a hospital, you try to buy something, and nobody knows what it actually costs. +[4275.360 --> 4280.000] That price transparency will actually give American consumers a little bit more choice, +[4280.000 --> 4281.840] and will also drive down costs. +[4281.840 --> 4286.040] And we talked about, you know, the reinsurance regulations is what I was talking about. +[4286.040 --> 4290.920] But Donald Trump has said that if we allow states to experiment a little bit on how to +[4290.920 --> 4295.840] cover both the chronically ill, but the non- chronically ill, it's not just a plan. +[4295.840 --> 4300.720] He actually implemented some of these regulations when he was president of the United States. +[4300.720 --> 4304.680] And I think you can make a really good argument that it salvaged Obamacare, which was doing +[4304.680 --> 4307.200] disastrously until Donald Trump came along. +[4307.200 --> 4309.800] And I think it's an important point about President Trump. +[4309.800 --> 4313.960] Of course, you don't have to agree with everything that President Trump has ever said or ever +[4313.960 --> 4314.960] done. +[4314.960 --> 4319.600] But when Obamacare was crushing under the weight of its own regulatory burden and health +[4319.600 --> 4322.760] care costs, Donald Trump could have destroyed the program. +[4322.760 --> 4328.200] Instead, he worked in a bipartisan way to ensure that Americans had access to affordable +[4328.200 --> 4329.200] care. +[4329.200 --> 4332.240] It's not perfect, of course, and there's so much more that we can do. +[4332.240 --> 4336.080] But I think that Donald Trump has earned the right to put in place some better health +[4336.080 --> 4337.280] care policies. +[4337.280 --> 4340.280] He's earned it because he did it successfully the first time. +[4340.280 --> 4341.280] Governor. +[4341.280 --> 4342.280] All right. +[4342.280 --> 4344.040] And old guy gives you some history. +[4344.040 --> 4347.880] I was there at the creation of the ACA. +[4347.880 --> 4353.200] And the reason it was so important is I come from a major health care state, home of the +[4353.200 --> 4358.120] Mayo Clinic, home to medical alley, 3M, Medtronic, all of those. +[4358.120 --> 4359.520] We understand health care. +[4359.520 --> 4364.080] It's why we're ranked first on affordability and accessibility and quality of health care. +[4364.080 --> 4369.240] And so what I know is, under Kamala Harris, more people are covered than they have before. +[4369.240 --> 4371.560] Those of you listening, this is critical to you. +[4371.640 --> 4375.800] Now, Donald Trump, all of a sudden, wants to go back and remember this. +[4375.800 --> 4381.840] He ran on the first thing he was going to do on day one was to repeal Obamacare. +[4381.840 --> 4386.320] On day one, he tried to sign an executive order to repeal the ACA. +[4386.320 --> 4392.320] He signed on to a lawsuit to repeal the ACA, but lost at the Supreme Court. +[4392.320 --> 4397.720] And he would have repealed the ACA, had it not been for the courage of John McCain to save +[4397.720 --> 4399.000] that bill. +[4399.000 --> 4403.280] Now fast forward, what that means to you is you lose your preexisting conditions. +[4403.280 --> 4407.120] If you're setting at home and you got asthma too bad, if you're a woman, probably not. +[4407.120 --> 4410.080] Broke your foot during football might kick you out. +[4410.080 --> 4412.320] Your kids get kicked out when they're 26. +[4412.320 --> 4416.120] Kamala Harris negotiated drug prices for the first time with Medicare. +[4416.120 --> 4420.240] We have 10 drugs that will come online, the most common ones that will be there. +[4420.240 --> 4425.480] But look, this issue, and when Donald Trump said, I've got a concept of a plan. +[4425.480 --> 4430.040] It cracked me up as a fourth grade teacher because my kids would have never given me that. +[4430.040 --> 4434.200] But what Senator Vance just explained might be worse than a concept. +[4434.200 --> 4436.520] Because what he explained is pre-Obamacare. +[4436.520 --> 4440.480] And I'll make this as simple as possible because I have done this for a long time. +[4440.480 --> 4445.360] What they're saying is, if you're healthy, why should you be paying more? +[4445.360 --> 4448.880] So what they're going to do is let insurance companies pick who they ensure because guess +[4448.880 --> 4449.880] what happens. +[4449.880 --> 4451.640] You pay your premium, it's not much. +[4451.640 --> 4453.640] They're figured they're not going to have to pay out to you. +[4453.640 --> 4458.880] But those of you a little older, gray, you know, got cancer, you're going to get kicked out of it. +[4458.880 --> 4460.520] That's why the system didn't work. +[4460.520 --> 4464.520] Kamala Harris will protect and enhance the ACA. +[4464.520 --> 4465.320] Governor, thank you. +[4465.320 --> 4469.720] Senator, you have not yet explained how you would protect people with pre-existing conditions +[4469.720 --> 4471.080] or laid out that plan. +[4471.080 --> 4475.680] Well, look, we currently have laws and regulations in the place right now that protect people +[4475.680 --> 4477.240] with pre-existing conditions. +[4477.240 --> 4480.800] We want to keep those regulations in place, but we also want to make the health insurance +[4480.800 --> 4483.280] marketplace function a little bit better. +[4483.400 --> 4486.360] What Governor Walts just said is actually not true. +[4486.360 --> 4490.640] A lot of what happened in the reason that Obamacare was crushing under its own weight is that +[4490.640 --> 4493.760] a lot of young and healthy people were leaving the exchanges. +[4493.760 --> 4499.000] Donald Trump actually helped address that problem, and he did so in a way that preserved +[4499.000 --> 4502.400] people's access to coverage who had pre-existing conditions. +[4502.400 --> 4508.400] But again, something that these guys do is they make a lot of claims about if Donald Trump +[4508.400 --> 4512.440] becomes president, all of these terrible consequences are going to ensue. +[4512.520 --> 4515.080] But in reality, Donald Trump was president. +[4515.080 --> 4520.160] Inflation was low, take home pay was higher, and he saved the very program from a democratic +[4520.160 --> 4525.520] administration that was collapsing and would have collapsed absent his leadership. +[4525.520 --> 4530.960] He did his job, which is governed in a bipartisan way and get results, not just complain about +[4530.960 --> 4532.960] problems, but actually solve them. +[4532.960 --> 4537.720] Governor, did enrollment under the Affordable Care Act go up under the Trump administration? +[4537.720 --> 4540.160] It's higher now that we've seen it go up. +[4540.160 --> 4541.160] Look, people are using it. +[4541.160 --> 4542.160] The system works. +[4542.160 --> 4545.680] And the question about this, of young people or whatever, that's the individual mandate +[4545.680 --> 4546.680] piece of this. +[4546.680 --> 4550.720] And Republicans fought tooth and nail saying, well, Americans should be free to do this. +[4550.720 --> 4552.760] Well, then what happens is you think the individual mandate is a good idea. +[4552.760 --> 4553.760] You're right. +[4553.760 --> 4557.480] I think the idea of making sure the risk pool is broad enough to cover everyone, that's +[4557.480 --> 4559.120] the only way insurance works. +[4559.120 --> 4560.360] When it doesn't, it collapses. +[4560.360 --> 4563.920] You are asking pre-ACA where we get people out. +[4563.920 --> 4568.080] Look, people know that they need to be on health care. +[4568.080 --> 4570.480] People expect it to be there. +[4570.480 --> 4575.160] And when we are able to make it, and we are making it this way, when we incentivize people +[4575.160 --> 4580.000] to be in the market, when we help people who might not be able to afford it, get there. +[4580.000 --> 4583.880] And we make sure then, when you get sick and old, it's there for you. +[4583.880 --> 4586.960] Because I heard people say, well, I don't want to buy into Medicare, whatever. +[4586.960 --> 4589.680] Good luck buying health care once you get past 70. +[4589.680 --> 4591.320] So look, the ACA works. +[4591.320 --> 4592.680] We can continue to do better. +[4592.680 --> 4593.720] Kamala Harris did that. +[4593.720 --> 4598.880] The way she made everything better was negotiating those 10 drugs on Medicare for the first time +[4598.880 --> 4599.880] in American history. +[4599.880 --> 4600.880] Thank you. +[4600.880 --> 4601.880] Margaret. +[4601.880 --> 4602.880] I apologize. +[4602.880 --> 4603.880] We're out of time. +[4603.880 --> 4604.880] We have a number of subjects to discuss. +[4604.880 --> 4609.200] Margaret, let's talk about families in America. +[4609.200 --> 4612.600] There is a childcare crisis in this country. +[4612.600 --> 4618.000] And the United States is one of the very few developed countries in the world without a +[4618.000 --> 4621.360] national paid leave program for new parents. +[4621.360 --> 4625.920] Under walls, you said that if Democrats win both the White House and Congress, this is +[4625.920 --> 4628.840] a day one priority for you. +[4628.840 --> 4633.400] How long should employers be required to pay workers while they are home taking care +[4633.400 --> 4634.400] of their newborns? +[4634.400 --> 4635.400] You have two minutes. +[4635.400 --> 4636.400] Yeah. +[4636.400 --> 4638.000] Well, that's negotiable. +[4638.000 --> 4639.000] And that's what Congress worked. +[4639.000 --> 4641.200] But here's what the deal is. +[4641.200 --> 4642.600] American setting out there right now. +[4642.600 --> 4644.280] You may work for a big company. +[4644.280 --> 4647.800] Look, we're home in Minnesota to some of the largest fortune 500 companies. +[4647.800 --> 4650.720] Kamala Harris knows that and call it our in California. +[4650.720 --> 4653.280] Most companies provide paid family medically. +[4653.280 --> 4656.280] One is, I think they're moral and they think it's a good thing. +[4656.280 --> 4658.400] But it also keeps their employees healthy. +[4658.400 --> 4661.080] We in Minnesota passed a paid family a medical leave. +[4661.080 --> 4662.360] You have a child. +[4662.360 --> 4663.360] You. +[4663.360 --> 4666.320] And I had to go back to work five days after my kids were born. +[4666.320 --> 4668.760] This allows you to stay home a certain amount of time. +[4668.760 --> 4671.640] What we know is that gets the child off to a better start. +[4671.640 --> 4672.960] The family works better. +[4672.960 --> 4674.040] We stay in their employers. +[4674.040 --> 4675.680] We get more consistency in that. +[4675.680 --> 4677.400] So Kamala Harris has made it a priority. +[4677.400 --> 4680.240] We implemented in Minnesota and we see growth. +[4680.240 --> 4683.320] That's how you become a pro business state. +[4683.320 --> 4686.000] But the negotiations on it and here's the issue. +[4686.000 --> 4688.400] Those big companies are able to offer it. +[4688.400 --> 4690.760] Those of you out there who don't have it. +[4690.760 --> 4694.960] Just imagine what happens if you get cancer or your child gets sick. +[4694.960 --> 4696.320] We know what happens. +[4696.320 --> 4700.920] You end up staying home in some places that means no paycheck because you've got no protection +[4700.920 --> 4701.920] on that. +[4701.920 --> 4706.440] This is the case of an economy that Donald Trump has set for the wealthiest amongst +[4706.440 --> 4707.440] us. +[4707.440 --> 4711.520] We're willing to give those tax breaks to the wealthiest. +[4711.520 --> 4714.080] He's willing to say, bus those unions up. +[4714.080 --> 4715.080] Do whatever. +[4715.080 --> 4719.120] What we're saying is the economy works best when it works for all of us. +[4719.120 --> 4723.320] And so a paid family medical leave program and I will tell you, go to the families, or +[4723.320 --> 4725.400] go to the businesses and ask them. +[4725.400 --> 4730.440] As far as child care on this, you have to take it at both the supply and the demand side. +[4730.440 --> 4735.060] You can't expect the most important people in our lives to take it at our children or our +[4735.060 --> 4737.780] parents to get paid the least amount of money. +[4737.780 --> 4741.900] And we have to make it easier for folks to be able to get into that business and then +[4741.900 --> 4743.980] to make sure that folks are able to pay for that. +[4743.980 --> 4746.980] We were able to do it in Minnesota and I'm still telling you this. +[4746.980 --> 4750.060] We were listed as the best state we're still in crisis on this. +[4750.060 --> 4754.820] A federal program of paid family medical leave and help with this will enhance our workforce +[4754.820 --> 4758.260] and enhance our families and make it easier to have the children that you want. +[4758.260 --> 4759.740] Governor, your time is up. +[4759.740 --> 4763.420] Senator, do you support a national paid leave program? +[4763.420 --> 4769.260] And if so, for how long should employers be mandated to pay their employees while they +[4769.260 --> 4771.100] are home taking care of their newborn? +[4771.100 --> 4772.100] You have two minutes. +[4772.100 --> 4775.020] Yeah, well, first of all, Margaret, a number of my Republican colleagues and some Democrats +[4775.020 --> 4776.180] two have worked on this issue. +[4776.180 --> 4780.180] And I think there is a bipartisan solution here because a lot of us care about this issue. +[4780.180 --> 4785.900] I mean, look, I speak from this very personally because I'm married to a beautiful woman who +[4785.900 --> 4790.300] is an incredible mother to our three beautiful kids, but is also a very, very brilliant corporate +[4790.300 --> 4791.300] litigator. +[4791.300 --> 4796.300] And I'm so proud of her, but being a working mom, even for somebody with all of the advantages +[4796.300 --> 4799.540] of my wife is extraordinarily difficult. +[4799.540 --> 4801.700] And it's not just difficult from a policy perspective. +[4801.700 --> 4806.020] She actually had access to paid family leave because she worked for a bigger company, but +[4806.020 --> 4810.460] the cultural pressure on young families and especially young women. +[4810.460 --> 4814.020] I think it makes it really hard for people to choose the family model they want. +[4814.020 --> 4816.860] A lot of young women would like to go back to work immediately. +[4816.860 --> 4818.740] Some would like to spend a little time home with the kids. +[4818.820 --> 4820.860] Some would like to spend longer at home with the kids. +[4820.860 --> 4824.980] We should have a family care model that makes choice possible. +[4824.980 --> 4828.780] And I think this is a very important substance of difference between Donald Trump and Kamala +[4828.780 --> 4829.780] Harris' approach. +[4829.780 --> 4834.300] I mean, look, if you look at the federal programs that we have that support paid family leave +[4834.300 --> 4838.420] right now, the community development block grant, and there's another block grant program +[4838.420 --> 4843.060] that spends a lot of money from the federal government, these programs only go to one kind +[4843.060 --> 4844.060] of childcare model. +[4844.060 --> 4847.660] Let's say you'd like your church maybe to help you out with childcare. +[4847.660 --> 4851.540] If you live in a rural area or an urban area and you'd like to get together with families +[4851.540 --> 4855.140] in your neighborhood to provide childcare and the way that makes the most sense, you don't +[4855.140 --> 4857.900] get access to any of these federal monies. +[4857.900 --> 4863.260] We want to promote choice and how we deliver family care and how we promote childcare because +[4863.260 --> 4865.700] look, it is unacceptable. +[4865.700 --> 4868.780] And, you know, of course, Semini had been on the campaign trail a lot the past seven or +[4868.780 --> 4869.780] eight weeks. +[4869.780 --> 4873.660] And one of the biggest complaints I hear from young families is people who feel like they +[4873.660 --> 4875.380] don't have options. +[4875.380 --> 4879.140] Like they're choosing between going to work or taking care for their kids, that is an +[4879.140 --> 4883.860] incredible burden to put on American families where the only country that does it, I think +[4883.860 --> 4886.100] we could do a heck of a lot better. +[4886.100 --> 4887.940] Senator, thank you. +[4887.940 --> 4893.260] You have also said Senator Vance many things about the American family. +[4893.260 --> 4899.820] The federal reserve says parents will spend nearly as much on childcare as they do on housing +[4899.820 --> 4901.260] each month. +[4901.260 --> 4903.940] So I want to get your thoughts on this. +[4903.940 --> 4909.740] President Trump recently said, as much as childcare is talked about as being expensive, +[4909.740 --> 4915.020] it's relatively speaking not very expensive compared to the kinds of numbers we'll be +[4915.020 --> 4916.860] taking in. +[4916.860 --> 4922.700] Is President Trump committed to the $5,000 per child tax credit that you have described? +[4922.700 --> 4923.700] You have one minute. +[4923.700 --> 4927.020] Well, what President Trump said, Margaret, I just want to defend my running mate here +[4927.020 --> 4931.580] a little bit, is that we're going to be taking in a lot of money by penalizing companies +[4931.580 --> 4937.300] for shipping jobs overseas and penalizing countries who employ slave laborers and then +[4937.300 --> 4941.380] ship their products back into our country and undercut the wages of American workers. +[4941.380 --> 4944.060] It's the heart of the Donald Trump economic plan. +[4944.060 --> 4947.180] Cut taxes for American workers and American families. +[4947.180 --> 4950.700] Cut taxes for businesses that are hiring and building companies in the United States of +[4950.700 --> 4951.700] America. +[4951.700 --> 4955.980] But penalized companies and countries that are shipping jobs overseas. +[4955.980 --> 4957.860] That's the heart of the economic proposal. +[4957.860 --> 4961.100] And I think what President Trump is saying is that when we bring in this additional revenue +[4961.100 --> 4965.980] with higher economic growth, we're going to be able to provide paid family leave, childcare +[4965.980 --> 4972.100] options that are viable and workable for a lot of American families. +[4972.100 --> 4975.940] Can you clarify how that will solve the childcare shortage? +[4975.940 --> 4981.260] Well, because as Tim said, a lot of the childcare shortages, we just don't have enough resources +[4981.260 --> 4986.100] going into the multiple people who could be providing family care options. +[4986.100 --> 4989.500] And we're going to have to, unfortunately, look, we're going to have to spend more money. +[4989.500 --> 4993.220] We're going to have to induce more people to want to provide childcare options for American +[4993.220 --> 4994.220] families. +[4994.220 --> 4998.140] Because the reason it's so expensive right now is because you've got way too few people +[4998.140 --> 5000.820] providing this very essential service. +[5000.820 --> 5001.820] Thank you, Senator. +[5001.820 --> 5007.460] Governor Walls, your ticket also has some childcare tax credit proposals. +[5007.460 --> 5012.820] Do you think Congress will agree to the $6,000 credit for newborns and $3,000 credit for +[5012.820 --> 5016.820] children over the age of six as your campaign has promised? +[5016.820 --> 5017.820] Is that realistic? +[5018.460 --> 5021.420] Well, if these members of Congress are listening to anybody, I can tell you. +[5021.420 --> 5023.580] And this is the biggest issue. +[5023.580 --> 5025.060] Everybody listening tonight knows. +[5025.060 --> 5026.980] I mean, I'm sure they were shocked to hear. +[5026.980 --> 5028.300] It's not that expensive. +[5028.300 --> 5033.380] And let's be clear whether it's $5,000 or $6,000, that plays you about three or four months. +[5033.380 --> 5034.860] Let's be clear of where we're at on this. +[5034.860 --> 5037.260] It's because we got out of an imbalance on this. +[5037.260 --> 5039.140] We thought we were going to get by by not paying people. +[5039.140 --> 5041.340] I don't think Senator Vance or that, and I or that far apart. +[5041.340 --> 5043.940] I'm not opposed to what he's talking about on options. +[5043.940 --> 5045.300] We've done scholarships types of things. +[5045.300 --> 5047.580] I think we need to be open to making the case. +[5047.580 --> 5051.740] But the issue here is the question you asked is, you're not going to pay for it with these +[5051.740 --> 5052.740] tariffs. +[5052.740 --> 5055.660] That's just adding another $4,000 on the family and taking less. +[5055.660 --> 5060.140] So not only do they not get the money to pay for that, they're $4,000 in the whole. +[5060.140 --> 5061.140] That's Wharton School. +[5061.140 --> 5062.580] That's his alma mater. +[5062.580 --> 5066.860] And so I think the issue here is, if those members of Congress, I can't believe they're +[5066.860 --> 5067.860] not it. +[5067.860 --> 5071.340] When I go to businesses, sure, they'll talk about taxes sometime, but they will lead with +[5071.340 --> 5073.820] childcare and they will lead with housing. +[5073.820 --> 5077.300] Because we know the problem is especially in a state like Minnesota, we need more workers +[5077.340 --> 5080.100] because our economy is growing, but we need the workforce. +[5080.100 --> 5081.100] Governor, thank you. +[5081.100 --> 5082.100] We need to move on. +[5082.100 --> 5087.620] Nora, let's talk about the state of democracy, the top issue for Americans after the economy +[5087.620 --> 5089.340] and inflation. +[5089.340 --> 5095.700] After the 2020 election, President Trump's campaign and others filed 62 lawsuits contesting +[5095.700 --> 5097.020] the results. +[5097.020 --> 5102.100] Judges, including those appointed by President Trump and other Republican presidents, +[5102.100 --> 5106.620] looked at the evidence and said there was no widespread fraud. +[5106.620 --> 5113.340] The governors of every state in the nation, Republicans and Democrats, certified the 2020 +[5113.340 --> 5120.380] election results and sent a legal slate of electors to Congress for January 6th. +[5120.380 --> 5125.180] Senate advance, you have said you would not have certified the last presidential election +[5125.180 --> 5129.100] and would have asked the states to submit alternative electors. +[5129.100 --> 5132.540] That has been called unconstitutional and illegal. +[5132.540 --> 5138.360] Once you again seek to challenge this year's election results, even if every governor +[5138.360 --> 5141.380] certifies the results, I'll give you two minutes. +[5141.380 --> 5144.180] Well, Nora, first of all, I think that we're focused on the future. +[5144.180 --> 5148.580] We need to figure out how to solve the inflation crisis caused by Kamala Harris' policies, +[5148.580 --> 5152.140] make housing affordable, make groceries affordable, and that's what we're focused on. +[5152.140 --> 5154.420] But I want to answer your question because you did ask it. +[5154.420 --> 5158.420] Look, what President Trump has said is that there were problems in 2020. +[5158.420 --> 5164.020] And my own belief is that we should fight about those issues, debate those issues peacefully +[5164.020 --> 5168.140] in the public square, and that's all life said, and that's all that Donald Trump has said. +[5168.140 --> 5172.980] Remember, he said that on January the 6th, the protesters ought to protest peacefully. +[5172.980 --> 5175.140] And on January the 20th, what happened? +[5175.140 --> 5176.700] Joe Biden became the president. +[5176.700 --> 5178.260] Donald Trump left the White House. +[5178.260 --> 5182.180] And now, of course, unfortunately, we have all of the negative policies that have come +[5182.180 --> 5184.820] from the Harris Biden administration. +[5184.860 --> 5188.060] I believe that we actually do have a threat to democracy in this country, +[5188.060 --> 5193.540] but unfortunately, it's not the threat to democracy that Kamala Harris and Tim Walsh want to talk about. +[5193.540 --> 5195.460] It is the threat of censorship. +[5195.460 --> 5201.380] It's Americans casting aside lifelong friendships because of disagreements over politics. +[5201.380 --> 5204.860] It's big technology companies silencing their fellow citizens. +[5204.860 --> 5209.420] And it's Kamala Harris saying that rather than debate and persuade her fellow Americans, +[5209.420 --> 5212.540] she'd like to censor people who engage in misinformation. +[5212.540 --> 5217.020] I think that is a much bigger threat to democracy than anything that we've seen in this country +[5217.020 --> 5219.660] in the last four years, in the last 40 years. +[5219.660 --> 5224.860] Now, I'm really proud, especially given that I was raised by two lifelong blue collar Democrats +[5224.860 --> 5228.460] to have the endorsement of Bobby Kennedy Jr. and Tulsi Gabbard. +[5228.460 --> 5233.100] Lifelong leaders in the Democratic coalition, of course, they don't agree with me and Donald Trump +[5233.100 --> 5234.060] on every issue. +[5234.060 --> 5235.980] We don't have to agree on every issue. +[5235.980 --> 5241.780] But we're united behind a basic American first-minute principle that we ought to debate our differences. +[5241.860 --> 5242.900] We ought to argue about them. +[5242.900 --> 5245.140] We ought to try to persuade our fellow Americans. +[5245.140 --> 5249.740] Kamala Harris is engaged in censorship at an industrial scale. +[5249.740 --> 5251.100] She did it during COVID. +[5251.100 --> 5253.140] She's done it over a number of other issues. +[5253.140 --> 5258.380] And that, to me, is a much bigger threat to democracy than what Donald Trump said when he said +[5258.380 --> 5261.380] that protesters should peacefully protest on January the 6th. +[5261.380 --> 5262.260] Governor? +[5262.260 --> 5264.660] Well, I've enjoyed tonight's debate. +[5264.660 --> 5266.220] And I think there was a lot of commonality here. +[5266.220 --> 5268.460] And I'm sympathetic to mispeaking on things. +[5268.460 --> 5270.900] And I think I might have with the Senator about that. +[5270.900 --> 5271.900] There's one. +[5271.900 --> 5274.500] There's one though that this one is troubling to me. +[5274.500 --> 5277.420] And I say that because I think we need to tell the story. +[5277.420 --> 5279.420] Donald Trump refused to acknowledge this. +[5279.420 --> 5282.540] And the fact is, is that I don't think we can be the frog in the pot and let the boiling +[5282.540 --> 5283.540] water go up. +[5283.540 --> 5284.540] He was very clear. +[5284.540 --> 5286.420] I mean, he lost his election. +[5286.420 --> 5288.100] And he said he didn't. +[5288.100 --> 5291.820] 140 police officers were beaten at the Capitol that day. +[5291.820 --> 5293.980] Some with the American flag, several later died. +[5293.980 --> 5295.860] And it wasn't just in there. +[5295.860 --> 5300.820] In Minnesota, a group gathered on the state Capitol grounds in St. Paul and said, +[5300.820 --> 5304.020] we're marching to the governor's residence and there may be casualties. +[5304.020 --> 5310.140] The only person there was my son and his dog who was rushed out crying by state police. +[5310.140 --> 5315.300] That issue and Mike Pence standing there as they were chanting, hang Mike Pence. +[5315.300 --> 5316.860] Mike Pence made the right decision. +[5316.860 --> 5321.140] So Senator, it was adjudicated over and over and over. +[5321.140 --> 5322.860] I worked with kids long enough to know. +[5322.860 --> 5325.740] And I said as a football coach, sometimes you really want to win. +[5325.740 --> 5328.260] But the democracy is bigger than winning an election. +[5328.260 --> 5331.780] You have to shake hands and then you try and do everything you can to help the other +[5331.780 --> 5333.380] side win. +[5333.380 --> 5335.060] That's what was at stake here. +[5335.060 --> 5342.140] Now the thing I'm most concerned about is the idea that imprisoning your political opponents +[5342.140 --> 5345.780] already laying the groundwork for people not accepting this. +[5345.780 --> 5347.780] And a president's words matter. +[5347.780 --> 5350.220] A president's words matter. +[5350.220 --> 5351.220] People hear that. +[5351.220 --> 5357.500] So I think this issue of settling our differences at the ballot box, shaking hands when we +[5357.500 --> 5364.300] lose, being honest about it, but to deny what happened on January 6th, the first time in +[5364.300 --> 5371.140] American history that a president or anyone tried to overturn a fair election and the +[5371.140 --> 5372.740] peaceful transfer of power. +[5372.740 --> 5375.620] And here we are four years later in the same boat. +[5375.620 --> 5381.340] I will tell you this, that when this is over, we need to shake hands, this election, and +[5381.340 --> 5382.780] the winner needs to be the winner. +[5382.780 --> 5383.980] This has got to stop. +[5383.980 --> 5385.980] It's tearing our country apart. +[5385.980 --> 5386.980] Margaret. +[5387.300 --> 5389.220] Senator Vance, did you want to respond to that? +[5389.220 --> 5395.620] Yeah, well, look, Tim, first of all, it's really rich for democratic leaders to say that +[5395.620 --> 5401.140] Donald Trump is a unique threat to democracy when he peacefully gave over power on January +[5401.140 --> 5404.740] the 20th as we have done for 250 years in this country. +[5404.740 --> 5407.660] We are going to shake hands after this debate and after this election. +[5407.660 --> 5410.300] And of course, I hope that we win and I think we're going to win. +[5410.300 --> 5413.820] But if Tim wallets is the next vice president, he'll have my prayers, he'll have my best +[5413.820 --> 5416.940] wishes and he'll have my help whenever he wants it. +[5417.060 --> 5421.780] But we have to remember that for years in this country, Democrats protested the results +[5421.780 --> 5422.780] of elections. +[5422.780 --> 5428.980] Hillary Clinton in 2016 said that Donald Trump had the election stolen by Vladimir Putin +[5428.980 --> 5433.060] because the Russians bought like $500,000 worth of Facebook ads. +[5433.060 --> 5435.460] This has been going on for a long time. +[5435.460 --> 5439.700] And if we want to say that we need to respect the results of the election, I'm on board. +[5439.700 --> 5443.180] But if we want to say, as Tim wallets is saying that this is just a problem that Republicans +[5443.180 --> 5444.660] have had, I don't buy that. +[5445.660 --> 5446.660] Governor. +[5446.660 --> 5448.940] January 6th was not Facebook ads. +[5448.940 --> 5451.460] And I think of revisionist history on this look. +[5451.460 --> 5455.820] I don't understand how we got to this point. +[5455.820 --> 5458.220] But the issue was that happened. +[5458.220 --> 5459.220] Donald Trump can do it. +[5459.220 --> 5461.020] And all of us say there's no place for this. +[5461.020 --> 5463.580] It has massive repercussions. +[5463.580 --> 5468.620] This idea that there's censorship to stop people from doing threatening to kill someone, +[5468.620 --> 5469.620] threatening to do something. +[5469.620 --> 5470.980] That's not censorship. +[5470.980 --> 5472.500] Censorship is book banning. +[5472.500 --> 5473.300] We've seen that. +[5473.300 --> 5474.620] We've seen that brought up. +[5474.660 --> 5480.460] I just think for everyone tonight, and I'm going to thank Senator Bans. +[5480.460 --> 5483.220] I think this is the conversation they want to hear. +[5483.220 --> 5484.860] And I think there's a lot of agreement. +[5484.860 --> 5487.420] This is one that we are miles apart on. +[5487.420 --> 5491.220] This was a threat to our democracy in a way that we had not seen. +[5491.220 --> 5494.620] And it manifested itself because of Donald Trump's inability to say. +[5494.620 --> 5496.860] He is still saying he didn't lose the election. +[5496.860 --> 5497.860] I would just ask that. +[5497.860 --> 5500.020] Did he lose the 2020 election? +[5500.020 --> 5501.940] Tim, I'm focused on the future. +[5501.940 --> 5508.860] Did Kamala Harris censor Americans from speaking their mind and the wake of the 2020 COVID situation? +[5508.860 --> 5510.780] That is a damning nonanswer. +[5510.780 --> 5511.780] Has she? +[5511.780 --> 5514.380] It's a damning nonanswer for you to not talk about censorship. +[5514.380 --> 5517.620] Obviously, Donald Trump and I think that there were problems in 2020. +[5517.620 --> 5518.620] We've talked about it. +[5518.620 --> 5520.420] I'm happy to talk about it further. +[5520.420 --> 5524.220] But you guys attack us for not believing in democracy. +[5524.220 --> 5528.860] The most sacred right under the United States democracy is the First Amendment. +[5528.860 --> 5532.700] You yourself have said there's no First Amendment right to misinformation. +[5532.700 --> 5537.500] Kamala Harris wants to threaten the power of government and big tech to silence people +[5537.500 --> 5539.020] from speaking their minds. +[5539.020 --> 5542.740] That is a threat to democracy that will long outlive this present political moment. +[5542.740 --> 5546.780] I would like Democrats and Republicans to both reject censorship. +[5546.780 --> 5548.380] Let's persuade one another. +[5548.380 --> 5551.580] Let's argue about ideas and then let's come together afterwards. +[5551.580 --> 5553.780] You can't yell fire in a crowded theater. +[5553.780 --> 5554.780] That's the task. +[5554.780 --> 5556.020] That's the Supreme Court task. +[5556.020 --> 5557.700] Tim, fire in a crowded theater. +[5557.700 --> 5562.660] You guys wanted to kick people off of Facebook for saying that Toddler should have a +[5562.660 --> 5563.660] mess. +[5563.660 --> 5564.660] Senator, the governor does have the floor. +[5564.660 --> 5565.660] Sorry. +[5565.660 --> 5566.660] The fire in a crowded theater. +[5566.660 --> 5570.020] That is criticizing the policies of the government, which is the right of every American. +[5570.020 --> 5572.780] Senator, the governor does have the floor for one minute to ponder you. +[5572.780 --> 5573.780] Please. +[5573.780 --> 5574.780] Yeah. +[5574.780 --> 5575.780] Well, I don't run Facebook. +[5575.780 --> 5580.580] What I do know is, is I see a candidate out there who refused and now again, and this +[5580.580 --> 5582.140] I'm pretty shocked by this. +[5582.140 --> 5583.620] He lost the election. +[5583.620 --> 5584.820] This is not a debate. +[5584.820 --> 5589.900] It's not anything anywhere other than Donald Trump's world. +[5589.900 --> 5596.700] Because look, when Mike Pence made that decision to certify that election, that's why Mike +[5596.700 --> 5598.700] Pence isn't on this stage. +[5598.700 --> 5604.820] What I'm concerned about is, where is the firewall with Donald Trump? +[5604.820 --> 5606.140] Where is the firewall? +[5606.140 --> 5612.860] If he knows, he could do anything, including taking an election and his vice president's +[5612.860 --> 5613.860] not going to stand to it. +[5613.860 --> 5615.980] That's what we're asking you, America. +[5615.980 --> 5617.580] Will you stand up? +[5617.580 --> 5621.820] Will you keep your oath of office, even if the president doesn't? +[5621.820 --> 5623.740] And I think Kamala Harris would agree. +[5623.740 --> 5626.500] She wouldn't have picked me if she didn't think I would do that. +[5626.500 --> 5628.300] Because of course, that's what we would do. +[5628.300 --> 5632.580] So America, I think you've got a really clear choice on this election of who's going +[5632.580 --> 5635.780] to honor that democracy and who's going to honor Donald Trump. +[5635.780 --> 5638.020] Governor, your time is up. +[5638.020 --> 5639.260] Thank you, gentlemen. +[5639.260 --> 5642.540] We will be right back with both of our candidates. +[5642.540 --> 5662.220] The CBS News, Vice Presidential Debate, continues. +[5662.220 --> 5666.260] News, Vice Presidential Debate, it is now time for the closing statement. +[5666.260 --> 5670.420] Senator Vance won the virtual coin toss and elected to go last. +[5670.420 --> 5672.300] So Governor Walls, you are first. +[5672.300 --> 5673.300] You have two minutes. +[5673.300 --> 5675.220] Well, thank you, Senator Vance. +[5675.220 --> 5676.420] Thank you to CBS News. +[5676.420 --> 5681.420] And most importantly, thank you to all of you, if you're still up and the folks who misdancing +[5681.420 --> 5682.900] with our stars, I appreciate it. +[5682.900 --> 5687.300] But look, the support of the democracy matters that you're here. +[5687.300 --> 5692.700] And I'm as surprised as anybody of this coalition that Kamala Harris has built, from Bernie Sanders +[5692.700 --> 5697.540] to Dick Cheney to Taylor Swift, and a whole bunch of folks in between there. +[5697.540 --> 5702.260] And they don't all agree on everything, but they are truly optimistic people. +[5702.260 --> 5707.140] They believe in a positive future of this country, and one where our politics can be better +[5707.140 --> 5708.460] than it is. +[5708.460 --> 5714.300] And I have to tell you, that better than it is is the sense of optimism that there can +[5714.300 --> 5720.260] be an opportunity economy that works for everyone, not just to get by, but to get ahead. +[5720.260 --> 5724.260] And the idea that freedom really means something, not the freedom of government to be in your +[5724.260 --> 5728.460] bedroom or exam room, but the freedom for you to make choices about yourself. +[5728.460 --> 5731.380] Now look, we all know who Donald Trump is. +[5731.380 --> 5735.140] He's told us, and as Maya Angelus said, believe him when he told you that. +[5735.140 --> 5738.420] His first inaugural address talked about American carnage. +[5738.420 --> 5741.860] And then he spent four years trying to maybe do that. +[5741.860 --> 5747.100] Senator Vance tonight made it clear, he will stand with Donald Trump's agenda. +[5747.100 --> 5749.780] He will continue to push down that road. +[5749.780 --> 5751.260] Excuse me. +[5751.260 --> 5753.300] Kamala Harris gives us a different option. +[5753.300 --> 5759.900] Now I have to tell you, I'm going to be careful about the quotes, but there's one that Senator Vance said that does resonate with me. +[5759.900 --> 5763.380] He said Donald Trump makes the people I care about afraid. +[5763.380 --> 5765.540] A lot of America feels that way. +[5765.540 --> 5767.420] We don't need to be afraid. +[5767.420 --> 5768.820] Franklin Roosevelt was right. +[5768.820 --> 5771.020] All we have to fear is fear itself. +[5771.020 --> 5773.460] Kamala Harris is bringing us a new way forward. +[5773.460 --> 5775.540] She's bringing us a politics of joy. +[5775.540 --> 5778.020] She's bringing real solutions for the middle class. +[5778.020 --> 5780.820] And she's centering you at the heart of that. +[5780.820 --> 5783.380] All the while asking everyone. +[5783.380 --> 5784.660] Join this movement. +[5784.660 --> 5786.220] Make your voices heard. +[5786.220 --> 5792.260] Let's look for a new day where everybody gets that opportunity and everybody gets a chance to thrive. +[5792.260 --> 5795.940] I humbly ask for your vote on November 5th for Kamala Harris. +[5795.940 --> 5797.540] Governor Walls, thank you. +[5797.540 --> 5799.780] Senator Vance, your closing statement. +[5799.780 --> 5802.900] Well, I want to thank Governor Walls, you folks at CBS. +[5802.900 --> 5805.060] And of course, the American people for tuning in this evening. +[5805.060 --> 5807.740] And one of the issues we didn't talk about was energy. +[5807.740 --> 5813.340] And I remember when I was being raised by my grandmother, when she didn't have enough money to turn on the heat some nights. +[5813.340 --> 5815.460] Because Ohio gets pretty cold at night. +[5815.460 --> 5817.700] And because money was often very tight. +[5817.700 --> 5828.060] And I believe as a person who wants to be your next vice president, that we are a rich and prosperous enough country where every American, whether they're rich or poor, ought to be able to turn on their heat. +[5828.060 --> 5829.700] And then it'll live a cold winter night. +[5829.700 --> 5833.300] That's gotten more difficult, thanks to Kamala Harris's energy policies. +[5833.300 --> 5838.420] I believe that whether you're rich or poor, you ought to be able to afford a nice meal for your family. +[5838.420 --> 5841.660] That's gotten harder because of Kamala Harris's policies. +[5841.660 --> 5845.020] And I believe that whether you're rich or poor, you ought to be able to afford to buy a house. +[5845.020 --> 5847.060] You ought to be able to live in safe neighborhoods. +[5847.060 --> 5850.060] You ought to not have your communities flooded with fentanyl. +[5850.060 --> 5854.260] And that too has gotten harder because of Kamala Harris's policies. +[5854.260 --> 5864.780] Now, I've been politics long enough to do what Kamala Harris does when she stands before the American people and says that on day one, she's going to work on all these challenges I just listed. +[5864.780 --> 5868.100] She's been the vice president for three and a half years. +[5868.100 --> 5874.140] And day one was 1400 days ago and her policies have made these problems worse. +[5874.140 --> 5877.620] Now, I believe that we have the most beautiful country in the world. +[5877.620 --> 5885.260] I meet people on the campaign trail who can't afford food, but have the grace and generosity to ask me how I'm doing. +[5885.260 --> 5894.620] And to tell me their plan for my family, what that has taught me is that we have the greatest country, the most beautiful country, the most incredible people anywhere in the world. +[5894.620 --> 5901.260] They're not going to be able to achieve their full dreams with the broken leadership that we have in Washington. +[5901.260 --> 5907.620] They're not going to be able to live their American dream if we do the same thing that we've been doing for the last three and a half years. +[5907.620 --> 5908.860] We need change. +[5908.860 --> 5910.260] We need a new direction. +[5910.260 --> 5914.260] We need a president who has already done this once before and did it well. +[5914.260 --> 5915.620] Please vote for Donald Trump. +[5915.620 --> 5921.700] And whether you vote for me or vote for Tim Walls, I just want to say, I'm so proud to be doing this and I'm rooting for you. +[5921.700 --> 5923.100] God bless you and good night. +[5923.100 --> 5925.100] Thank you for your advance. Thank you. +[5925.100 --> 5931.100] And thank you both for participating in the only vice presidential debate of this election cycle. +[5931.100 --> 5932.380] I'm Margaret Brennan. +[5932.380 --> 5937.260] And I'm Nora O'Donnell and a reminder there are just 35 days until election day. +[5937.260 --> 5941.100] Please get out and vote and for all of us here at CBS News. +[5941.100 --> 5943.100] Thank you and good night. +[5983.100 --> 5985.100] . +[5985.100 --> 5987.100] . +[5987.100 --> 5989.100] . +[5989.100 --> 5991.100] . +[5991.100 --> 5993.100] . +[5993.100 --> 5995.100] . +[5995.100 --> 5997.100] . +[5997.100 --> 5999.100] . +[5999.100 --> 6001.100] . +[6001.100 --> 6003.100] . +[6003.100 --> 6005.100] . +[6005.100 --> 6007.100] . +[6007.100 --> 6009.100] . +[6009.100 --> 6011.100] . +[6011.100 --> 6019.100] Watching, stay updated about breaking news and top stories on the NBC News app or follow us on social media. diff --git a/transcript/political__59agcnLAj4.txt b/transcript/political__59agcnLAj4.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..93797a8fa4ae370ffa12a2549749a3a750db89ef --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political__59agcnLAj4.txt @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +[0.000 --> 23.000] The American manufacturer is coming back. Once again, we're seeing the pride that comes from stamping the product made in America. +[23.000 --> 33.000] Companies are choosing to build a new factory in America. We just a few years ago, as you all know, that wouldn't have been the case that would have built the factory overseas. diff --git a/transcript/political_cFLjudWTuGQ.txt b/transcript/political_cFLjudWTuGQ.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..093975c83850d10bbabd62708ea38fd75be2b75c --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_cFLjudWTuGQ.txt @@ -0,0 +1,142 @@ +[0.000 --> 18.000] What makes one an exceptional presenter? Is it flashy visuals? Is it the tone of voice? Is it the actual message or content? +[18.000 --> 23.000] Or does that have something to do with body language? Are gestures and our stance? +[23.000 --> 30.000] Today we want to talk to you about this latter point. How do we use our body effectively to communicate our message? +[30.000 --> 37.000] Because we have so many great ideas here, but if they remain in our head, don't actually link up with the audience. +[37.000 --> 42.000] Our message will not drive. We are a red message will not have resonated with the audience. +[42.000 --> 47.000] So body language plays a powerful role in how we communicate. +[47.000 --> 55.000] And unfortunately, body language can also distract. We've seen this clip before of Michael Bay. +[55.000 --> 63.000] He speaks, the teleprompter, he loses sight of what's happening, the telever doesn't sink up, and he struggles. +[63.000 --> 69.000] And all you see is his body moving around and he's nervous. He's exuding it. +[69.000 --> 74.000] So I want to give some color commentary as a rewatch, as a class. What is happening? +[74.000 --> 79.000] So his stance at the beginning, it's okay, but his hands, he's meshing them. +[79.000 --> 88.000] And now it's starting to turn from the audience. Again, his hands are clasped. He's looking a bit down, not at all of you, the audience, and he spins. +[88.000 --> 95.000] He shows his back, the audience. And he can't be getting composure. He's swaying back and forth. He's looking down. +[95.000 --> 102.000] He's avoiding the audience. His nerves are coming out. Again, his hands, he's waiting down. +[102.000 --> 106.000] And now I think he's looking at the back of the stage. That's the exact opposite place. +[106.000 --> 113.000] And where do you want to actually look? He's incredibly nervous, and now he exits stage. +[113.000 --> 117.000] We all want to avoid our own Michael Bay moments. When we communicate. +[117.000 --> 122.000] The last thing we want at a startup pitch or meeting is to have that happen. +[122.000 --> 126.000] Is to have the body language take over from the message. +[126.000 --> 133.000] If we lose sight of what our body is doing, all people can pay attention to is the body itself. +[133.000 --> 142.000] It'll take over. So that comes down to not only kind of distract, but the body language can, it is your superhero. +[142.000 --> 147.000] It can change, it's your superpower. Sorry, not a superhero. You're the superhero. +[147.000 --> 155.000] But it's your superpower. In the sense that we can utilize it to enhance and communicate with every person in the audience. +[155.000 --> 162.000] I want to talk about that today from three vantage points. Colin is going to get us started in talking about how posture breeds success. +[162.000 --> 166.000] Jung-Joon is going to talk about how gestures to strengthen your message. +[166.000 --> 176.000] Finally, Jennifer is going to close us out with how we think about the body posture of you, the audience, and how to interact with that. Colin, take us away. +[176.000 --> 181.000] Communication begins before you even open your mouth to speak. +[181.000 --> 186.000] Your audience's first impression of you is your posture and your position. +[186.000 --> 191.000] And so it's important to know both how to stand, as well as where to stand. +[191.000 --> 196.000] And perhaps it's fairly obvious that you should stand facing the people you're talking to. +[196.000 --> 204.000] Don't stand facing your visuals and turning your back to the audience. That's not what we want to do. We can't communicate that way. +[204.000 --> 212.000] It's also important to know where you're standing in the room. A position of strength in this room is somewhere in this center box. +[212.000 --> 216.000] As long as you're moving around in the center, you're doing pretty well. +[216.000 --> 223.000] Well, you don't want to be as often the corner of countering or especially in front of any distractions. +[223.000 --> 229.000] And this room is pretty good. It doesn't have that many distractions. But there is a window. +[229.000 --> 234.000] And outside this window, there are cars, there are buses, there are bikers. +[234.000 --> 242.000] And when I was standing over there, probably about half of you could see in your peripheral vision outside the window. +[242.000 --> 252.000] And if a car were to drive by your instinct, your reaction would be to look out the window and that would break your concentration in our conversation. +[252.000 --> 254.000] And we don't want that either. +[254.000 --> 258.000] And now that you know where to stand, it's important to know how to stand. +[258.000 --> 272.000] So we're going to demonstrate a few positions, a few bad positions that we've seen from us and some of you guys and even from the presentations earlier today that you shouldn't do. +[272.000 --> 280.000] And the first one is hands in your pockets. This comes off as nonchalant, your shoulders tend to roll forwards. +[280.000 --> 284.000] And it's very difficult to convey a strong message from this position. +[284.000 --> 292.000] The second one is hands on your hips. When your hands are on your hips, you tend to look overbearing and powerful. +[292.000 --> 299.000] And the third one is the fig leaf. This is where you're protecting your family jewels with your hands. +[299.000 --> 307.000] And while it also looks timid, it's especially bad when you decide to gesture from this position. +[307.000 --> 309.000] I want to show you something. +[315.000 --> 318.000] You look like you're flashing the audience. And that's not a good thing. +[318.000 --> 320.000] So how should you stand? +[320.000 --> 328.000] And if I could actually get all of you to stand, I'll lead you through a short demonstration on how to find your face posture. +[328.000 --> 334.000] So once you've stood, be mindful of the people next to you and place your feet hip width apart. +[334.000 --> 339.000] Close your eyes and look up towards the ceiling and lift your hands above your head. +[339.000 --> 345.000] Get a good stretch underneath your shoulders and let your arms drop to the side. +[345.000 --> 350.000] When you open your eyes, look down. This is your base posture. +[350.000 --> 355.000] Thank you very much for participating. You guys can sit down now. +[356.000 --> 365.000] Now that you've found your base posture, this is where you should gesture from and it's where you should return to when you're finished gesturing. +[365.000 --> 370.000] It may not feel the most comfortable, but it looks the most comfortable to your audience. +[370.000 --> 376.000] Remember that your posture and position are the audience's first impression of you. +[376.000 --> 383.000] But now that you know how to stand still, it's time to learn how to move. +[383.000 --> 388.000] Dressures are important because it helps you communicate that. +[388.000 --> 393.000] For example, if you use dresses, the audience remembers twice as much. +[393.000 --> 400.000] It also helps you with future speakers too because it helps your memory when you speak. +[400.000 --> 409.000] Also, besides the transition, your hand and arm movement is the biggest movement that the audience can see. +[409.000 --> 414.000] You can either use it wisely, or use it on random and distracting gestures. +[414.000 --> 418.000] I'm going to show you three types of gestures. +[418.000 --> 425.000] The give, the show and the chop. Here's an example. +[425.000 --> 431.000] This quarter at the GSB, I went to this communications class. It was so great. +[431.000 --> 434.000] I mean, you could feel that your skills improved. +[434.000 --> 438.000] I think this was the best class I've ever taken. +[438.000 --> 442.000] Let's rewind and see what happened. The give. +[442.000 --> 446.000] This quarter at the GSB, I went to this communications class. +[446.000 --> 451.000] So this gesture is used to give the audience the facts or the options. +[451.000 --> 457.000] Remember to have your palms up, not down. We'll get to that in a minute. +[457.000 --> 464.000] The show. I mean, you could feel that your skills are improving. +[464.000 --> 469.000] This kind of gesture has the largest variety and your imagination is the limit. +[469.000 --> 474.000] Just remember that the gesture and the message has to match. +[474.000 --> 479.000] For example, you can't say, prof is a rising, but the gesture like that. +[479.000 --> 485.000] So, congruency and creativity. The chop. +[485.000 --> 489.000] I think this was the best class I've ever taken. +[490.000 --> 494.000] So this gesture is used to deliver strong opinion. +[494.000 --> 498.000] You can either use it one hand or you can use both hands. +[498.000 --> 503.000] You can use both hands and do a larger chop which will deliver a stronger message. +[503.000 --> 510.000] So, next time when you do gestures, think about these three types and plan ahead. +[510.000 --> 517.000] Three types is the give, the show and the chop. +[517.000 --> 520.000] Huh! +[520.000 --> 525.000] I bet everyone in the room is going to remember this. +[525.000 --> 530.000] Just just work. That's the message. +[530.000 --> 534.000] Another subject is about having your palms up. +[534.000 --> 537.000] So, I'll give you an example. +[537.000 --> 543.000] People on the right, please rise and move to the left. +[543.000 --> 545.000] I'll do a slightly different this time. +[545.000 --> 550.000] People on the left, right, please rise and move to the left. +[550.000 --> 554.000] One more time. People on the right, please rise and move to the left. +[554.000 --> 557.000] You see the difference? +[557.000 --> 560.000] Which one do you think would make more people move? +[560.000 --> 568.000] The first one. Yes. According to the study, if you have your palms up, 84% of the audience complies. +[568.000 --> 579.000] If you have your palms down, 52%, if you have your fingers, 28%, never use your fingers at your audience. +[579.000 --> 584.000] It looks just arrogant and only politicians use that. +[584.000 --> 590.000] Clinton used it. I did not have sexual relations with that woman. +[590.000 --> 594.000] It looks bad. Back then, looks bad. Now. +[594.000 --> 597.000] Never use your fingers. +[597.000 --> 601.000] And last but not least, avoid the terrorist gestures. +[601.000 --> 609.000] For example, people on the right, please rise and move to the left. +[609.000 --> 613.000] No matter what you do right, I mean it looks silly. +[613.000 --> 616.000] So, loosen up everybody. +[616.000 --> 622.000] Always remember that gestures are there for you and the audience to make a deeper connection. +[622.000 --> 627.000] So, while we've talked about the audience, now it's time to focus on you. +[627.000 --> 629.000] The audience. +[629.000 --> 635.000] As John June and Colin and Matt described, we've been focusing on the body language of the speaker. +[635.000 --> 638.000] But let's not forget, who's the real hero here? +[638.000 --> 645.000] As we learned in our first week of class, it's not me, the speaker. It's you, the audience. +[645.000 --> 651.000] But what happens when the audience doesn't realize that they are on this hero's journey? +[651.000 --> 654.000] Have you ever seen an audience that looks like this? +[654.000 --> 657.000] Have you ever been that audience? +[657.000 --> 664.000] It's okay, we all have. Whether we're playing on our phones, falling asleep and nodding off, looking at the clock, +[664.000 --> 668.000] and calculating, can we make an escape from this room? +[668.000 --> 670.000] We've all done it. +[670.000 --> 676.000] But the thing is, it's the speaker's responsibility to understand what's going on with their audience. +[676.000 --> 679.000] And body language is a powerful way to assess that. +[679.000 --> 686.000] As a speaker, we can be so focused on our own body language that we never even notice what the audience is doing. +[686.000 --> 689.000] And it's important to change that. +[689.000 --> 697.000] So, I want to share three strategies for how you can engage with your audience better by developing more observational skills. +[697.000 --> 705.000] So, first of all, absolutely, be using the gestures and body language tools that we've talked about today and over the course of the quarter. +[705.000 --> 708.000] But the second thing is to notice. +[708.000 --> 712.000] Of course, you're going to be looking for eye contact, but look beyond it. +[712.000 --> 715.000] Look at how your audience members are sitting. +[715.000 --> 717.000] Are they fidgeting? Are they moving? +[717.000 --> 723.000] Are they leading forward, looking engaged and taking notes? Or are they zoning out? +[723.000 --> 730.000] If your body language, your eye contact, and your efforts at being compelling are not working, then you can go deeper. +[730.000 --> 735.000] You can try to surprise the audience with a question or use some humor. +[735.000 --> 742.000] Or you can disrupt the audience. As students, we hate being cold-called, but we know it's effective, right? +[742.000 --> 744.000] Jason, what's your favorite color? +[744.000 --> 745.000] It was. +[745.000 --> 751.000] Okay, very good. You got that one. +[751.000 --> 757.000] As we all know, it's the fastest way to re-engage with a conversation with the speaker. +[757.000 --> 764.000] So don't be afraid to use it. It's so important to keep your audience on track, because they're the hero and it's their journey. +[764.000 --> 769.000] Remember how Nancy Duarte told us that we are the Yoda to the Luke Skywalker? +[769.000 --> 774.000] And our job as the speaker is to keep the hero on their journey. +[774.000 --> 781.000] With that in mind, I think we've talked about three concepts that really remind each of us about how body language is your superpower. +[781.000 --> 784.000] Use it. Become that superpower. +[784.000 --> 792.000] Become that superhero. And we welcome any questions you have on how to stand strong, gesture effectively, and engage the audience. +[792.000 --> 793.000] Thank you. diff --git a/transcript/political_cpxCl8ylJgE.txt b/transcript/political_cpxCl8ylJgE.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ffe3386d9c7e2ee453770afe1d7e5695436effea --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_cpxCl8ylJgE.txt @@ -0,0 +1,66 @@ +[0.000 --> 3.000] We don't win anymore. We don't win a trade. +[3.000 --> 4.000] Great country, great people. +[4.000 --> 5.000] I'm going to be very happy. +[5.000 --> 7.000] Believe me, incredible men and women. +[7.000 --> 9.000] We're going to start winning again. +[9.000 --> 10.000] Believe me. +[10.000 --> 11.000] I'm not ranting and raving. +[11.000 --> 12.000] I'm not ranting and raving. +[12.000 --> 13.000] I'm not ranting and raving. +[13.000 --> 14.000] Go ahead. +[14.000 --> 17.000] He is interesting to me linguistically +[17.000 --> 21.000] because he speaks like everybody else. +[21.000 --> 24.000] And we're not used to hearing that from a president. +[24.000 --> 25.000] And these are great people. +[25.000 --> 26.000] These are some great people. +[26.000 --> 29.000] We're used to hearing somebody speak +[29.000 --> 34.000] who sounds much more educated, much smarter, much more refined +[34.000 --> 36.000] than your everyday American. +[36.000 --> 41.000] But when we hear Donald Trump speaks, he sounds like he could be a family member or a friend. +[41.000 --> 43.000] And he's unique in that sense. +[43.000 --> 45.000] Don't forget that's the way I won. +[45.000 --> 49.000] Remember I used to give you a news conference every time I made a speech, which was like every day. +[49.000 --> 51.000] Okay? No, that's how I won. +[51.000 --> 53.000] I won with news conference and probably speech. +[53.000 --> 58.000] Many people comment on the simplicity of his vocabulary or the lower register. +[58.000 --> 63.000] Of his language, as well as the simpler grammar of his sentences or syntax. +[63.000 --> 69.000] We will have so much winning if I get elected that you may get bored with winning. +[69.000 --> 70.000] Believe me. +[70.000 --> 71.000] I agree. +[71.000 --> 73.000] You'll never get bored with winning. +[73.000 --> 74.000] We never get bored. +[74.000 --> 85.000] Something else that many people have commented on is this the fact that he tends to jump from topic to topic rather abruptly in his speeches. +[85.000 --> 88.000] This is my first stop officially. +[88.000 --> 93.000] We're not talking about the balls, we're not talking about even the speeches. +[93.000 --> 97.000] Although they did treat me nicely on that speech yesterday. +[97.000 --> 102.000] I always call them the dishonest media, but they treated me nicely. +[102.000 --> 113.000] But I want to say that there is nobody that feels stronger about the intelligence community and the CIA than Donald Trump. +[113.000 --> 121.000] Some people talk about that as him sounding incoherent, but again this is something that we all do in everyday speech. +[121.000 --> 127.000] It's just unusual to hear it from a president speaking in a public formal context. +[127.000 --> 132.000] One of the things that I've noticed he does a lot is he uses the expression. +[132.000 --> 133.000] Believe me. +[133.000 --> 134.000] Believe me. +[134.000 --> 135.000] Believe me. +[135.000 --> 136.000] Believe me. +[136.000 --> 137.000] Believe me. +[137.000 --> 141.000] If you look at where Donald Trump uses believe me, +[141.000 --> 145.000] he'll use it to preface an important point that he wants to make. +[145.000 --> 146.000] Believe me. +[146.000 --> 150.000] I and we inherited one big mess. +[150.000 --> 152.000] That I can tell you. +[152.000 --> 156.000] And he also uses it at the end of an important point that he makes in a speech. +[156.000 --> 162.000] And I'm also here to tell you about our plans for the future. +[162.000 --> 166.000] And they're big and they're bold and it's what our country is all about. +[166.000 --> 167.000] Believe me. +[167.000 --> 174.000] He's got a lot of functions as a verbal bracket surrounding points that he really wants listeners to pay attention to. +[174.000 --> 185.000] And so this can be a very useful device in reigning your audience in when you have a very long speech to focus on the important points you want them to take away. +[185.000 --> 191.000] I will be the greatest jobs producer that God ever created and I mean that. +[191.000 --> 196.000] He probably is definitely part of the Trump brand of president. +[196.000 --> 206.000] He uses words that are both hyperbolic in the positive sense, especially now as president like great and spectacular. +[206.000 --> 210.000] I think we have one of the great cabinets ever put together. +[210.000 --> 215.000] I think we're going to do some absolutely spectacular things for the American people. +[215.000 --> 220.000] Even his hand gestures, for example, are hyperbolic. +[220.000 --> 226.000] If you look at nonverbal communication when he's speaking, he uses a lot of two handed gestures. +[226.000 --> 233.000] So you'll see like this, you'll see this, you'll often see something like that or like that. +[233.000 --> 241.000] I think what Donald Trump teaches us about linguistics is that you can use language to create a brand. +[241.000 --> 258.000] You can use language to construct an identity that is distinct, that is recognizable, and that works toward creating an authentic persona that people will pay attention to. diff --git a/transcript/political_f60IU-tQxMA.txt b/transcript/political_f60IU-tQxMA.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5136aad01abd4b19a1c71dfe10f6da7b7121457f --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_f60IU-tQxMA.txt @@ -0,0 +1,42 @@ +[0.000 --> 7.000] So I just want to show you some of the best body language hand gestures that you can use to help you become a more effective leader. +[7.000 --> 17.000] Think about this one first, the triangle. Whenever I put my hands in the triangle, just like this, I'm going to appear more intelligent and knowledgeable in what I have to say. +[17.000 --> 23.000] So for example, today I want to talk to you about your body language and how you can become a better leader. +[23.000 --> 28.000] Today I want to help you become a better leader and talk about your body language. +[28.000 --> 35.000] Just by me putting my hands just like this in the triangle, I'm not changing my voice, I'm just putting my hands in the triangle. +[35.000 --> 40.000] People also call this the steeple. I just make it more simple. Call it the triangle. +[40.000 --> 48.000] But here's the thing, what if you were on a date in your hands or in the triangle and you say, I want the lobster roll, I want the spaghetti. +[48.000 --> 58.000] You might seem a little bit too overconfident. I will say what you can do, think about the triangle, you can open it up a little bit more. +[58.000 --> 66.000] You see when you open up your hands as a leader, you appear a little bit more friendly, you're still super confident but you are engaging your audience at the same time. +[66.000 --> 74.000] And I'm sure that, now again, even though I'm standing up, you can do this in a meeting on a phone call every single day with people. +[74.000 --> 80.000] Don't think about this as who, oh I just have to use this, let's say speaking in public. +[80.000 --> 85.000] I'm sure you've seen this before, people are leaning back in their chairs and putting their hands in a triangle. +[85.000 --> 95.000] So when you talk to people, think about how you are talking to them because visually people will have a different perception of you in a matter of two or three seconds. +[95.000 --> 99.000] So think about the triangle, you can close it or you can open it up. +[99.000 --> 108.000] This one again, they call this one the basketball steeple. Think about the coach, they're saying something but their hands are a little bit more open and then inviting. +[108.000 --> 111.000] At the same time, they're still super confident. +[111.000 --> 120.000] If you want to, one more thing, have you noticed if I nod my head, you might want to nod as well. +[120.000 --> 124.000] I am doing the same exact thing with my hands. +[124.000 --> 128.000] So for example, I can say today is how I'm just putting my hands up and down. +[128.000 --> 136.000] Today I want to talk to you about your body language and why it's so important for you to really learn about it a little bit more. +[136.000 --> 144.000] So same thing, visually people will be a little bit more captivated because visually you'll be moving and it's towards them. +[144.000 --> 150.000] If you want to appear more friendly, all you have to do is keep your palms facing up. +[150.000 --> 157.000] So I can say, for example, hey, can you go to the grocery store today and we need some apples bananas and a bunch of strawberries. +[157.000 --> 165.000] Now, this will be very different as I said, hey, can you go to the grocery store, we need some apples bananas and a bunch of strawberries. +[165.000 --> 170.000] You're pointing as a little bit more direct, your open palms are a little bit more friendly. +[170.000 --> 176.000] So if you are having a conversation with someone, someone will always say, hey, can you do this X, Y, and Z for me. +[176.000 --> 180.000] But even if you open up your palms, hey, what do you think about this? +[180.000 --> 186.000] Hey, what do you think about this? Again, this is more direct, your point, this is a little bit more friendly. +[186.000 --> 195.000] If you want to appear more assertive, all you have to do is cut. You can cut down, you can cut up, it's like you're going to a judo chop everywhere. +[195.000 --> 201.000] Hey, can you go to the grocery store? We need some apples bananas and a bunch of strawberries. +[202.000 --> 207.000] Today, I want to talk to you about your body language, your eyes, your arms, and everything in between. +[207.000 --> 216.000] Look, if I cut my arms, I am just asserting the words a little bit more confident and it will make you a little bit more assertive. +[216.000 --> 221.000] Here's the most important thing. You want to look at the flow of the movements. +[221.000 --> 228.000] If you don't, I'm not saying you have to use this individually, if this feels very awkward for you, don't say, hey, I need this, this, this, and this every single time. +[228.000 --> 238.000] I just want you to try that out. But look at it this way. If I am more friendly, my arms or my body will flow a little bit more. +[238.000 --> 250.000] If I want to be more assertive, my movements are more strict. I can still use the open palm and I can say, hey, can you go to the grocery store, we need some apples bananas and a bunch of strawberries. +[250.000 --> 256.000] My movements are still more strict. So if you want to appear, let's say in a power position. +[256.000 --> 266.000] You can stand up more rigid, your arms can move more strictly and you will emphasize your words and whatever you say in a more confident but assertive way. +[266.000 --> 274.000] If you want to appear a little bit more relaxed, your body will start to flow a little bit more so it's more of a conversational tone. +[274.000 --> 285.000] One last thing that I want to teach you guys, you see when I put my hands in a circle like this, it feels like I have an insight I just want to tell you about right now. +[285.000 --> 297.000] It doesn't matter what it is. Today, my cat woke up and she did this one thing, look, you just put your hands in a circle and this is one thing I just want to tell you about, is this insight that you have. +[297.000 --> 300.000] You see, people can have a perception of you just like that. diff --git a/transcript/political_fLaslONQAKM.txt b/transcript/political_fLaslONQAKM.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e39d259ad6cdaee277fc4cec14922f0d4f68be0e --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_fLaslONQAKM.txt @@ -0,0 +1,175 @@ +[0.000 --> 1.000] The +[1.000 --> 16.440] NONVERBELS is everything that communicates but is not a word. +[16.440 --> 22.440] This beautiful theater, it's communicating to us. +[22.440 --> 27.520] How you sit is communicating to us. +[27.520 --> 36.000] The things that you attach to yourself, a purse, a pen, a fancy car, all these things +[36.000 --> 38.280] are communicating. +[38.280 --> 43.280] How you look at others communicates. +[43.280 --> 49.840] And all day long we are communicating non-verbally. +[49.840 --> 52.280] All day long. +[52.280 --> 56.920] You can look in on your child as they sleep and you can tell if they're having a nightmare +[56.920 --> 60.520] or they're sleeping soundly. +[60.520 --> 68.680] As you sit there and now I'm starting to see some of you, you're giving information +[68.680 --> 73.560] up even as I'm giving information up. +[73.560 --> 77.000] You're assessing me. +[77.000 --> 84.640] If I can speak to you from an anthropological standpoint, I am transmitting information +[84.640 --> 95.960] about myself, my beliefs, the things that I value even as you are. +[95.960 --> 100.760] Now that I can see you a little clearer, how many of you were dressed by your parents +[100.760 --> 101.760] today? +[101.760 --> 103.760] Raise your hand. +[103.760 --> 106.240] Wow. +[106.240 --> 107.240] Spouses? +[107.240 --> 110.400] That's okay. +[110.400 --> 113.800] Your spouse is going to draw. +[113.800 --> 122.000] So you chose to dress the way you did, even as I chose to dress the way I did. +[122.000 --> 125.480] They said, well it's Ted Talks, you can dress down. +[125.480 --> 128.920] I said, you know, I was in the FBI for 25 years. +[128.920 --> 131.920] I don't know how else to dress. +[131.920 --> 133.720] It would be such a disappointment. +[133.720 --> 142.520] It's like on TV they always have suits even when they're walking through the marsh. +[142.520 --> 143.520] It's true. +[143.520 --> 150.020] I can't tell you how many crime scenes I went through that ruined, really inexpensive +[150.020 --> 151.020] suits. +[151.020 --> 154.240] But we look good. +[154.240 --> 162.520] We look good. +[162.520 --> 167.080] I guess humor is allowed. +[167.080 --> 172.000] All day long we're making choices. +[172.000 --> 173.000] We're making choices. +[173.000 --> 177.800] They're based on culture. +[177.800 --> 184.320] They're based on peer pressure on personal preferences. +[184.320 --> 188.680] And so the things we wear and attach to ourselves are transmitting. +[188.680 --> 192.320] Our bodies are transmitting information. +[193.320 --> 201.840] And the question that I'm often asked is, well, how authentic is it? +[201.840 --> 204.080] How authentic is it? +[204.080 --> 209.760] And as I pondered this, I said, you know what? +[209.760 --> 218.640] What do we think of the power of nonverbal communication? +[218.640 --> 226.920] So let's do it by taking the myths out of it and plugging in what really values. +[226.920 --> 232.240] What really is a value when it comes to nonverbals? +[232.240 --> 237.840] How many of you have had a bad handshake? +[237.840 --> 243.440] Now normally, of course, now we have the coronavirus. +[243.440 --> 249.400] I would have you turn to each other and give each other a handshake that's really bad. +[249.400 --> 250.400] But I'm not going to do that. +[250.400 --> 255.240] I want you to just put your hand in front of you and pretend to give someone a bad handshake. +[255.240 --> 256.240] Ready? +[256.240 --> 257.240] Let's do it. +[257.240 --> 259.240] Let's do it. +[259.240 --> 260.240] Do it. +[260.240 --> 261.240] Yeah. +[261.240 --> 262.240] Good. +[262.240 --> 267.240] Do you realize the funny faces you make? +[267.240 --> 271.920] It's like, I didn't ask you to make a funny face. +[271.920 --> 274.200] And yet you did. +[274.200 --> 276.760] Why is that? +[276.760 --> 287.200] Because you're human and humans betray what we feel, what we think, what we desire, what +[287.200 --> 294.800] we intend, what makes us anxious and what we fear. +[294.800 --> 297.240] And we do it in real time. +[297.240 --> 299.360] We don't have to wait 20 minutes. +[299.360 --> 303.160] It happens now. +[303.160 --> 309.780] In our body language, in a way, it's exquisite because there's an area of the brain that is +[309.780 --> 310.780] elegant. +[310.780 --> 315.080] And it's elegant because it takes shortcuts. +[315.080 --> 317.800] It doesn't think. +[317.800 --> 324.880] If I bring in a Bengal tiger here and walk it around, nobody sits around and waves at +[324.880 --> 325.880] it. +[325.880 --> 330.840] That's like, eat me. +[330.840 --> 332.560] No. +[332.560 --> 333.880] Everybody freezes. +[333.880 --> 337.400] And that's because of the limbic system. +[337.400 --> 342.920] This rather primitive area of the brain that reacts to the world doesn't have to think +[342.920 --> 344.800] about the world. +[344.800 --> 350.760] And everything that comes from the limbic brain is so authentic. +[350.760 --> 353.800] You hear a loud noise and you freeze. +[353.800 --> 354.800] Right? +[354.800 --> 358.520] What was that? +[358.520 --> 363.520] You get bad news or you see something on TV and you cover your mouth. +[363.520 --> 366.240] Why is that? +[366.240 --> 374.120] When the conquistadores arrived in the new world, they didn't have any problem finding out +[374.120 --> 377.760] who was in authority. +[377.760 --> 386.000] The same behaviors that they had just left in Queen Isabella's court, they saw in the +[386.000 --> 387.000] new world. +[387.000 --> 391.080] The king set higher had better clothing, had an entourage. +[391.080 --> 398.920] Okay, they didn't have their own show on television, but pretty close. +[398.920 --> 408.320] So all these behaviors are very authentic because the limbic system resides within that +[408.320 --> 409.320] human brain. +[409.320 --> 412.320] It's part of our paleo circuits. +[412.320 --> 420.960] And so when we see the furrowed forehead on a baby that's three weeks old, we know that +[420.960 --> 424.960] this little area called the globella, something is wrong. +[424.960 --> 428.200] There's an issue. +[428.200 --> 433.640] When we see the bunny nose, right, when you wrinkle the nose, yeah, we know what that means. +[433.640 --> 435.400] I don't like that. +[435.400 --> 436.400] I don't want that. +[436.400 --> 438.400] I don't want that. +[438.400 --> 440.840] Ew, right? +[440.840 --> 447.160] Did I just say that in public? +[447.160 --> 452.200] When we squint, we're focusing, but we have concerns. +[453.200 --> 458.880] When the eyelids close, you want me to do what? +[458.880 --> 467.040] And if things are really bad, you want me to talk for 15 minutes? +[467.040 --> 471.280] Here's what's interesting. +[471.280 --> 477.480] Children who are born blind, when they don't like things, they don't like. +[477.480 --> 478.720] Here's things they don't like. +[478.720 --> 480.520] They don't cover their ears. +[480.520 --> 481.520] They cover their eyes. +[481.520 --> 484.680] They've never seen. +[484.680 --> 491.800] This is millions of years old. +[491.800 --> 496.800] Smiles are important in our mouths. +[496.800 --> 502.800] The lips begin to disappear when we're stressed, right? +[502.800 --> 507.840] Most politicians look something like that. +[507.840 --> 511.640] Right before they're indicted, they look like that. +[511.640 --> 519.920] Dramatic lip pulls, jaw shifting, covering of the neck. +[519.920 --> 522.680] You've seen that clutching of the pearls? +[522.680 --> 524.960] I go, there's that creep. +[524.960 --> 525.880] Oh, he's gone now. +[525.880 --> 529.880] He's back. +[529.880 --> 533.520] But did you know why? +[533.520 --> 536.360] Large felines. +[536.360 --> 542.660] We have seen large felines for so long taking down prey that we immediately cover our +[542.660 --> 546.760] neck. +[546.760 --> 556.080] How many of you have been told that you can detect deception by the use of nonverbals? +[556.080 --> 559.920] I'm here to clear that up. +[559.920 --> 564.200] When you leave here today, you say, well, I heard that Navarro fellow. +[564.200 --> 572.600] When he did about 13,000 interviews in the FBI, he said there is no Pinocchio effect. +[572.600 --> 580.440] There's not one single behavior indicative of deception, not one. +[580.440 --> 582.960] And we mustn't propagate that. +[582.960 --> 588.760] We must not tell people that we can detect their lying because of behaviors. +[588.760 --> 595.280] They may be anxious, they may be stressed, but not deceptive. +[595.280 --> 599.600] How many of you have been told that if you cross your arms, that you're blocking people +[599.600 --> 600.600] away? +[600.600 --> 603.120] Have you heard that? +[603.120 --> 605.480] There's a clinical term for that. +[605.480 --> 607.560] It's called crap. +[607.560 --> 613.000] Yeah, I said it. +[613.000 --> 615.400] Get over it. +[615.400 --> 616.400] It's crap. +[616.400 --> 618.640] It's a self-hug. +[618.640 --> 619.640] You're comfortable? +[619.640 --> 620.640] Yeah. +[620.640 --> 626.400] What does this nonsense come from? +[626.400 --> 628.240] You know, I'm asked the question often. +[628.240 --> 632.400] So, you know, Joe, you were a spy catcher. +[632.400 --> 634.840] You use nonverbals every day. +[634.840 --> 644.440] What do you use it for to make sure people are comfortable, to make sure that we are empathetic. +[644.440 --> 651.920] The only way to be truly empathetic is by understanding nonverbals. +[651.920 --> 659.080] Carl Sagan, the famous cosmologist, said, who are we? +[659.080 --> 660.560] What are we? +[660.560 --> 662.920] You think about that. +[662.920 --> 667.800] It really takes a smart person to ask that question. +[667.800 --> 670.760] What are we in this universe? +[670.760 --> 673.600] He summed it up this way. +[673.600 --> 676.920] And I think it's rather exquisite. +[676.920 --> 679.080] He said, oh, we are. +[679.080 --> 685.520] Is the sum total of our influence on others. +[685.520 --> 686.680] That's all we are. +[686.680 --> 689.680] It's not how much you earn. +[689.680 --> 691.920] It's not how many cars you have. +[691.920 --> 694.720] It's our influence on each other. +[694.720 --> 704.480] And what's interesting is that the primary way that we influence each other through nonverbals, +[704.480 --> 712.520] it's that nice handshake, it's a pad on the shoulder, it's that touch of the hand. +[712.520 --> 722.320] It is that behavior that communicates love in a way that words simply can't do it. +[722.320 --> 726.800] When you leave here, you're going to have choices. +[726.800 --> 728.080] You always have choices. +[728.080 --> 732.640] You have free agency. +[732.640 --> 739.760] And one of the things that you should think about is, how do I change my nonverbals? +[739.760 --> 744.920] How do I become that person of influence? +[744.920 --> 752.300] Because if there's one thing we need in this world, it's truly to be more empathetic. +[752.300 --> 763.620] And so when I see this, it says it all, that's why we use nonverbals because they're powerful. +[763.620 --> 763.980] Thank you. diff --git a/transcript/political_fho78xctuPg.txt b/transcript/political_fho78xctuPg.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..81ea8b71bd1f14aa658cf586be7de308f4dcf921 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_fho78xctuPg.txt @@ -0,0 +1,72 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.920] Here in Manhattan, Senator J.D. Vance and Governor Tim Walsh just wrapped up their +[5.920 --> 10.880] Vice-Presidential debate effectively getting the last word in this race for the White House +[10.880 --> 15.840] before an audience this large. Unless, of course, Donald Trump and Kamala Harris agree to debate +[15.840 --> 21.280] again before election day. Fingers crossed, we've made the invitation. Harris has accepted. +[21.280 --> 28.320] Tonight's debate was civil. The question of how factual it was is another matter. Let's find out +[28.320 --> 33.200] from our fact checker Daniel Dale. What do you think, Daniel? It certainly wasn't a perfect +[33.200 --> 36.960] debate from Governor Walsh from a fact checker's perspective, but I think there was more +[36.960 --> 41.120] inaccuracy from Senator Vance and I think Vance had the two biggest whoppers of the night. +[41.120 --> 46.160] Both of them actually in what he left out rather than what he said. Listen to his claims about +[46.160 --> 53.200] Trump's post-election behavior in 2020 and early 2021. He said that on January the 6th, +[53.200 --> 57.680] the protesters ought to protest peacefully. And on January the 20th, what happened? +[57.680 --> 62.960] Joe Biden became the President. Donald Trump left the White House. He peacefully gave over power +[62.960 --> 69.760] on January the 20th. This is a pretty wild rewriting of history. Trump peacefully gave over power +[69.760 --> 75.120] on January the 20th. Sure, Trump did not like lock himself in the Oval Office, but he left office +[75.120 --> 80.000] after trying extremely hard to not give over power. We all know this. He tried to manipulate +[80.000 --> 83.760] everyone from the American public to state elections officials, to state legislators, +[83.760 --> 88.480] to the Justice Department, to his very own vice president. He helped trigger a deadly riot. +[88.480 --> 93.680] And then, Vance had Trump called for peaceful protest on January 6th. Yes, Trump did that once in +[93.680 --> 99.040] that January 6th speech after calling supporters to Washington with a promise it would be wild. +[99.040 --> 103.440] Spending weeks whipping them into a frenzy with lies about the election. Vice President Pence +[103.440 --> 107.840] is non-existent power to overturn the result. And then in that same January 6th speech, +[107.840 --> 112.080] using combative language far more often than that calming language, saying things like, +[112.080 --> 115.600] if you don't fight like hell, you're not going to have a country anymore. When you catch somebody +[115.600 --> 119.680] in a fraud, you're allowed to go by very different rules. You'll never take back our country +[119.680 --> 124.080] with weakness on and on. Now, let's turn to another egregious distortion of history from +[124.080 --> 132.000] Senator Vance. This one on Obamacare. When Obamacare was crushing under the weight of its own regulatory +[132.000 --> 137.440] burden and health care costs, Donald Trump could have destroyed the program. Instead, he worked in a +[137.440 --> 143.920] bipartisan way to ensure that Americans had access to affordable care. Casting Donald Trump as +[143.920 --> 149.360] the savior of Obamacare, I think is bananas. Donald Trump tried very hard to repeal Obamacare. +[149.360 --> 154.000] The only reason it was not repealed in 2017 was because he barely couldn't find enough +[154.000 --> 158.400] Republican votes in Congress. And then he tried to undermine Obamacare in various ways. He cut +[158.400 --> 162.800] the open enrollment period in half. He slashed funding for advertising and for people who help other +[162.800 --> 167.360] Americans sign up. He ended a key set of subsidies for insurers. His administration refused to +[167.360 --> 171.840] defend some critical provisions of the law in court, instead arguing that they should indeed be +[171.840 --> 176.640] invalidated. I could go on. So, yes, Trump did keep operating the Obama exchanges. He didn't +[176.640 --> 181.680] completely give up on it, but casting him as the savior of Obamacare, I think Jake is pretty dishonest. +[181.680 --> 186.560] Daniel, what stood out to you? I think what most struck me, Anderson, was significant revisionist, +[186.560 --> 192.480] revisionist history from Senator Vance on the subject of Obamacare in January 6th. But it was also +[192.480 --> 196.960] struck by the fact that we had a false claim from each candidate on the subject of reproductive +[196.960 --> 200.960] rights. So, first let's listen to something that Governor Wall said about the conservative +[200.960 --> 204.720] heritage foundation think tanks initiative known as Project 2025. +[206.480 --> 212.000] Their Project 2025 is going to have a registry of pregnancies. It's going to make it more +[212.000 --> 218.720] difficult, if not impossible, to get contraception and limit access, if not eliminate access to +[218.720 --> 224.400] infertility treatments. This claim, which Governor Walls has made before, is false. Project +[224.400 --> 230.240] 2025's 900-page policy document is online. You can read it, I've read it. Nothing in it proposes +[230.240 --> 235.600] to make anyone register their pregnancy with the government. What Project 2025 does propose +[235.600 --> 240.560] is that the federal government takes steps to make sure it is getting from every state detailed +[240.560 --> 245.360] after the fact anonymous data on abortion and miscarriage. The federal government already +[245.360 --> 250.000] gets this data from almost every state on a voluntary basis. Project 2025 wants to make +[250.000 --> 254.400] it mandatory for all states, but there's no pregnancy registration involved in this data collection. +[254.400 --> 260.160] Today, Project 2025 doesn't propose to change that. And in fact, Tim Walls' own state of Minnesota +[260.160 --> 265.920] already posts details after the fact anonymous abortion and miscarriage data online on the state +[265.920 --> 270.400] health department website. There is no pregnancy registration in Minnesota, of course. And I +[270.480 --> 275.520] should also note that while the governor referred to their Project 2025, it is not an initiative +[275.520 --> 279.600] of the Trump Vance campaign itself, though it is, of course, also true that Trump and Vance +[279.600 --> 284.480] have extensive and close ties to it. Now, I want to look at a claim that Senator Vance made on +[284.480 --> 291.200] his past position on abortion. Why have you changed your position? Well, Laura, first of all, +[291.200 --> 296.080] I never supported a national ban. I did during what I was running for Senate in 2022 talk about +[296.160 --> 301.760] setting some minimum national standard. This is false. Before Senator Vance joined the Trump +[301.760 --> 306.480] campaign and fell behind Trump's professed desire for a state-by-state approach to abortion, +[306.480 --> 311.760] Vance did support a national abortion ban. In 2022, when he ran for the U.S. Senate, he said +[311.760 --> 316.160] it in an interview, and this is a direct quote, I certainly would like abortion to be illegal +[316.160 --> 320.960] nationally. No caveats there. He added that he was, quote, sympathetic to the view that a national +[320.960 --> 325.840] ban was necessary to stop women from traveling cross-state lines to obtain abortions. And he +[325.840 --> 330.800] also said in his website during that Senate campaign that he was, quote, 100% pro-life, end quote, +[330.800 --> 336.000] and that he favored eliminating abortion. These categorical awards were on his website until Trump +[336.000 --> 340.000] chose him as his running mate. They certainly included no caveats about opposing a federal +[340.000 --> 344.880] legislation. And then in the Senate, as recently as late last year, he explicitly pushed a national +[344.880 --> 350.320] ban as early as 15 weeks gestation as a debate moderator. I said to him, he can try to spin that +[350.320 --> 355.680] as just a standard, but it's not like a goal or a target. That was federal legislation, or the +[355.680 --> 359.840] idea of it, at least that would have banned abortion at 15 weeks. And again, he was even more +[359.840 --> 363.040] categorical, Anderson, before he was elected. diff --git a/transcript/political_jEphfGpJjc8.txt b/transcript/political_jEphfGpJjc8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5a1a94dcdeafaadb952a0af3e14741f599a17d79 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_jEphfGpJjc8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,1232 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.640] Tonight, with just over a month to go until Election Day, the first and only meeting between +[5.640 --> 10.640] the two men who hope to become Vice President of the United States, Democratic Governor Tim +[10.640 --> 14.720] Walls of Minnesota, and Republican Senator JD Vance of Ohio. +[14.720 --> 19.560] Now, this is likely the final debate of this election cycle and voting is already underway +[19.560 --> 21.000] in 20 states. +[21.000 --> 26.560] CBS News polling shows this remains a race either presidential candidate could win. +[26.560 --> 30.280] The CBS News Vice Presidential debate starts now. +[30.280 --> 33.120] Fight for every single vote and we're going to take this country back. +[33.120 --> 36.480] And we are ready to continue to build the future together. +[36.480 --> 42.280] We're going to turn this whole country red with President Donald J. Trump's leadership. +[42.280 --> 44.920] You know what's at the end of this little journey? +[44.920 --> 49.120] Kamala Harris as the next president of the United States. +[49.120 --> 55.000] This is a CBS News Special, live from CBS News headquarters in New York. +[55.000 --> 62.600] America decides the Vice Presidential debate. +[62.600 --> 63.600] Good evening. +[63.600 --> 67.880] I'm Nora O'Donnell and thank you for joining us for tonight's CBS News Vice Presidential +[67.880 --> 68.880] debate. +[68.880 --> 73.240] We want to welcome our viewers on CBS, on other networks here in the U.S. and around +[73.240 --> 74.240] the world. +[74.240 --> 78.760] We have a consequential night ahead and our focus is the issues that matter to you, the +[78.760 --> 79.760] voter. +[79.760 --> 80.760] Let's introduce the candidates. +[80.760 --> 86.480] Minnesota's Democratic governor Tim Walls and Ohio's Republican Senator JD Vance +[86.480 --> 93.720] tonight meeting for the first time. +[93.720 --> 95.040] I'm Margaret Brennan. +[95.040 --> 100.520] In order to have a thoughtful and civil debate, these are the rules that both campaigns have +[100.520 --> 102.240] agreed to. +[102.240 --> 106.320] Questions will be directed at one candidate who will have two minutes to respond. +[106.320 --> 109.680] The other candidate will be allowed two minutes for rebuttal. +[109.680 --> 114.320] Then each candidate will get another minute to make further points with an additional one +[114.320 --> 117.200] minute each at the discretion of the moderator. +[117.200 --> 122.720] The primary role of the moderators is to facilitate the debate between the candidates, enforce +[122.720 --> 127.640] the rules, and provide the candidates with the opportunity to fact check claims made by +[127.640 --> 128.640] each other. +[128.640 --> 133.920] CBS News reserves the right to mute the candidates' microphones to maintain decorum. +[133.920 --> 137.200] We have not shared the questions or topics with the campaigns. +[137.200 --> 139.000] The stage is set. +[139.000 --> 141.920] Governor, Senator, thank you for joining us. +[141.920 --> 142.920] Let's get started. +[142.920 --> 146.280] Tonight, our country is facing several unfolding crises. +[146.280 --> 148.680] The Middle East is on the brink of war. +[148.680 --> 152.440] Americans are suffering from the catastrophic impact of Hurricane Helene. +[152.440 --> 157.360] And now a labor strike as 25,000 dock workers from Maine to Texas are picketing. +[157.360 --> 160.200] We're going to begin tonight with the Middle East. +[160.200 --> 161.200] Margaret. +[161.200 --> 162.920] Thank you, Nora. +[162.920 --> 168.720] Here today, Iran launched its largest attack yet on Israel, but that attack failed. +[168.720 --> 172.560] Thanks to joint U.S. and Israeli defensive action. +[172.560 --> 178.240] President Biden has deployed more than 40,000 U.S. military personnel and assets to that +[178.240 --> 183.360] region over the past year to try to prevent a regional war. +[183.360 --> 185.080] Iran is weakened. +[185.080 --> 189.360] But the U.S. still considers it the largest state sponsor of terrorism in the world, +[189.360 --> 194.160] and it has drastically reduced the time it would take to develop a nuclear weapon. +[194.160 --> 199.000] It is down now to one or two weeks' time. +[199.000 --> 204.400] Governor Walls, if you were the final voice in the situation room, would you support or +[204.400 --> 208.760] oppose a preemptive strike by Israel on Iran? +[208.760 --> 209.760] You have two minutes. +[209.760 --> 210.760] Well, thank you. +[210.760 --> 212.880] And thank you for those joining home tonight. +[212.880 --> 214.840] Let's keep in mind where this started. +[214.840 --> 221.760] October 7th, Hamas terrorists massacred over 1,400 Israelis and took prisoners. +[221.760 --> 227.840] Iran are a Israel's ability to be able to defend itself is absolutely fundamental, getting +[227.840 --> 236.000] its hostages back, fundamental, and ending the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. +[236.000 --> 241.400] But the expansion of Israel and its proxies is an absolute fundamental necessity for +[241.400 --> 243.360] the United States to have the steady leadership there. +[243.360 --> 248.600] You saw it experience today where, along with our Israeli partners and our coalition, +[248.600 --> 251.640] able to stop the incoming attack. +[251.640 --> 255.560] But what's fundamental here is that steady leadership is going to matter. +[255.560 --> 260.520] It's clear, and the world saw it on that debate stage a few weeks ago, a nearly 80-year-old +[260.520 --> 265.400] Donald Trump talking about crowd sizes is not what we need in this moment. +[265.400 --> 266.960] But it's not just that. +[266.960 --> 271.200] It's those that were closest to Donald Trump that understand how dangerous he is when +[271.200 --> 273.160] the world is this dangerous. +[273.160 --> 276.960] His chief of staff, John Kelly, said that he was the most flawed human being he'd ever +[276.960 --> 277.960] met. +[277.960 --> 284.240] And both of his secretaries of defense and his national security advisors said he should +[284.240 --> 286.320] be nowhere near the White House. +[286.320 --> 293.320] Now the person closest to them, to the Donald Trump, said he's unfit for the highest office. +[293.320 --> 294.880] That was Senator Vance. +[294.880 --> 299.720] What we've seen out of Vice President Harris is we've seen steady leadership. +[299.720 --> 303.920] We've seen a calmness that is able to be able to draw on the coalitions to bring them +[303.920 --> 305.240] together. +[305.240 --> 308.160] Understanding that our allies matter. +[308.160 --> 316.360] When our ally see Donald Trump turn towards Vladimir Putin, turn towards North Korea. +[316.360 --> 320.640] When we start to see that type of fickleness around holding the coalitions together, we +[320.640 --> 322.320] will stay committed. +[322.320 --> 327.040] And as the Vice President said today is, we will protect our forces and our allied forces +[327.040 --> 328.680] and there will be consequences. +[329.480 --> 330.880] Governor, your time is up. +[330.880 --> 332.880] Senator Vance, the same question. +[332.880 --> 339.280] Would you support or oppose a preemptive strike by Israel on Iran, you have two minutes? +[339.280 --> 340.880] Some more going to answer the question. +[340.880 --> 341.880] First of all, thanks, Governor. +[341.880 --> 343.680] Thanks to CBS for hosting the debate. +[343.680 --> 347.200] And thanks most importantly, the American people who are watching this evening and caring +[347.200 --> 350.520] enough about this country to pay attention to this Vice President's debate. +[350.520 --> 353.560] I want to answer the question, but I want to actually give an introduction to myself a little +[353.560 --> 356.880] bit because I recognize a lot of Americans don't know who either one of us are. +[356.880 --> 358.920] I was raised in a working class family. +[358.920 --> 361.560] My mother required food assistance for periods of her life. +[361.560 --> 364.960] My grandmother required Social Security help to raise me. +[364.960 --> 368.240] And she raised me in part because my own mother struggled with addiction for a big chunk +[368.240 --> 369.440] of my early life. +[369.440 --> 374.360] I went to college on the GI Bill after I listed in the Marine Corps and served in Iraq. +[374.360 --> 379.560] And so I stand here asking to be your Vice President with extraordinary gratitude for this country, +[379.560 --> 382.920] for the American dream that made it possible for me to live my dreams. +[382.920 --> 387.240] And most importantly, I know that a lot of you are worried about the chaos in the world +[387.240 --> 390.440] and the feeling that the American dream is unattainable. +[390.440 --> 394.800] I want to try to convince you tonight over the next 90 minutes that if we get better leadership +[394.800 --> 398.640] in the White House, if we get Donald Trump back in the White House, the American dream +[398.640 --> 400.520] is going to be attainable once again. +[400.520 --> 404.160] Now to answer this particular question, we have to remember that as much as Governor +[404.160 --> 408.800] Walts just accused Donald Trump of being an agent of chaos, Donald Trump actually delivered +[408.800 --> 413.480] stability in the world and he did it by establishing effective deterrence. +[413.480 --> 415.640] People were afraid of stepping out of line. +[415.640 --> 421.800] Iran, which launched this attack, has received over $100 billion in unfrozen assets thanks +[421.800 --> 423.960] to the Kamala Harris administration. +[423.960 --> 424.960] What do they use that money for? +[424.960 --> 428.720] They use it to buy weapons that they're now launching against our allies and got for +[428.720 --> 432.120] bit, potentially launching against the United States as well. +[432.120 --> 437.080] Donald Trump recognized that for people to fear the United States, you needed peace through +[437.080 --> 438.080] strength. +[438.080 --> 442.220] You could recognize that if they got out of line, the United States global leadership +[442.220 --> 445.480] would put stability in peace back in the world. +[445.480 --> 449.120] Now you asked about a preemptive strike market and I want to answer the question, look, +[449.120 --> 450.120] it is up to Israel. +[450.120 --> 454.720] What they think they need to do to keep their country safe and we should support our allies +[454.720 --> 456.840] wherever they are when they're fighting the bad guys. +[456.840 --> 460.400] I think that's the right approach to take with the Israel question. +[460.400 --> 461.400] Thank you, Senator. +[461.400 --> 464.960] Governor Walts, do you care to respond to any of the allegations? +[464.960 --> 466.880] Well, look, Donald Trump was in office. +[466.880 --> 470.160] Well, sometimes here a revisionist history, but when Donald Trump was in office, it was +[470.160 --> 477.800] Donald Trump who we had a coalition of nations that had boxed Iran's nuclear program in the +[477.800 --> 479.720] inability to advance it. +[479.720 --> 483.280] Donald Trump pulled that program and put nothing else in its place. +[483.280 --> 487.040] So Iran is closer to a nuclear weapon than they were before because of Donald Trump's +[487.040 --> 488.520] fickle leadership. +[488.520 --> 494.280] And when Iran shot down an American aircraft in international airspace, Donald Trump tweeted +[494.280 --> 497.440] because that's the standard diplomacy of Donald Trump. +[497.440 --> 504.920] And when Iranian missiles did fall near U.S. troops and they received traumatic brain injuries, +[504.920 --> 508.120] Donald Trump wrote it off as headaches. +[508.120 --> 512.040] Look, our allies understand that Donald Trump is fickle. +[512.040 --> 516.440] He will go to whoever has the most flattery or where it makes sense to him. +[516.440 --> 520.680] Steady leadership like you witnessed today, like you witnessed in April, both Iranian +[520.680 --> 522.320] attacks were repelled. +[522.320 --> 527.400] Our coalition is strong and we need the steady leadership that Kamala Harris is providing. +[527.400 --> 533.040] Senator Vance, the U.S. did have a diplomatic deal with Iran to temporarily pause parts +[533.040 --> 537.960] of its nuclear program and President Trump did exit that deal. +[537.960 --> 544.880] He recently said just five days ago, the U.S. must now make a diplomatic deal with Iran +[544.880 --> 548.800] because the consequences are impossible. +[548.800 --> 549.800] But he make a mistake. +[549.800 --> 550.800] You have one minute. +[550.800 --> 554.000] Well, first of all, Margaret, diplomacy is not a dirty word, but I think that's something +[554.000 --> 556.200] that Governor Walts just said is quite extraordinary. +[556.200 --> 561.520] You yourself just said Iran is as close to a nuclear weapon today as they have ever been. +[561.520 --> 563.480] And Governor Walts, you blame Donald Trump. +[563.480 --> 566.080] Who has been the vice president for the last three and a half years? +[566.080 --> 568.840] And the answer is you're running me, not mine. +[568.840 --> 572.480] Donald Trump consistently made the world more secure. +[572.480 --> 577.600] Now we talk about the sequence of events that led us to where we are right now. +[577.600 --> 582.200] And you can't ignore October the 7th, which I appreciate Governor Walts bringing up. +[582.200 --> 586.240] But when did Iran and Hamas and their proxies attack Israel? +[586.240 --> 589.040] It was during the administration of Kamala Harris. +[589.040 --> 592.400] So Governor Walts can criticize Donald Trump's tweets. +[592.400 --> 597.680] But effective smart diplomacy and peace through strength is how you bring stability back +[597.680 --> 599.600] to a very broken world. +[599.600 --> 601.560] Donald Trump has already done it once before. +[601.560 --> 603.360] Ask yourself at home. +[603.360 --> 605.160] When was the last time? +[605.160 --> 606.160] I'm 40 years old. +[606.160 --> 610.440] It was the last time that an American president didn't have a major conflict breakout. +[610.440 --> 613.640] The only answer is during the four years that Donald Trump was president. +[613.640 --> 615.480] Gentlemen, we have a lot to get to. +[615.480 --> 616.480] Nora? +[616.480 --> 617.480] Margaret, thank you. +[617.480 --> 619.400] Let's turn now to Hurricane Helene. +[619.400 --> 623.000] The storm could become one of the deadliest on record. +[623.000 --> 628.720] More than 160 people are dead and hundreds more are missing. +[628.720 --> 634.600] Scientists say climate change makes these hurricanes larger, stronger, and more deadly +[634.600 --> 637.520] because of the historic rainfall. +[637.520 --> 643.680] Senator Vance, according to CBS NewsPolling, seven in ten Americans and more than 60 percent +[643.680 --> 649.440] of Republicans under the age of 45, favor the U.S. taking steps to try and reduce climate +[649.440 --> 650.440] change. +[650.440 --> 655.720] Senator, what responsibility would the Trump administration have to try and reduce the +[655.720 --> 657.720] impact of climate change? +[657.720 --> 658.720] I'll give you two minutes. +[658.720 --> 659.720] Sure. +[659.720 --> 663.640] So first of all, let's start with the hurricane because it's an unbelievable, unspeakable human +[663.640 --> 664.560] tragedy. +[664.680 --> 668.920] First of all, today actually a photograph of two grandparents on a roof with a six-year-old +[668.920 --> 669.920] child. +[669.920 --> 672.920] And it was the last photograph ever taken to them because the roof collapsed and those +[672.920 --> 674.320] innocent people lost their lives. +[674.320 --> 678.760] And I'm sure Governor Wallet joins me in saying our hearts go out to those innocent people, +[678.760 --> 683.120] our prayers go out to them, and we want his robust and aggressive as a federal response +[683.120 --> 685.800] as we can get to save as many lives as possible. +[685.800 --> 689.200] And then of course afterwards, to help the people in those communities rebuild. +[689.200 --> 690.680] I mean, these are communities that I love. +[690.680 --> 695.400] Some of them I know very personally, in Appalachia, all across the Southeast, they need their +[695.400 --> 696.880] government to do their job. +[696.880 --> 701.440] And I commit that when Donald Trump is president again, the government will put the citizens +[701.440 --> 704.240] of this country first when they suffer from a disaster. +[704.240 --> 705.760] The North, you asked about climate change. +[705.760 --> 707.640] I think this is a very important issue. +[707.640 --> 711.640] Look, a lot of people are justifiably worried about all these crazy weather patterns. +[711.640 --> 715.400] I think it's important for us, first of all, to say Donald Trump and I support clean +[715.400 --> 716.600] air, clean water. +[716.600 --> 718.640] We want the environment to be cleaner and safer. +[718.640 --> 721.680] But one of the things that I've noticed, some of our democratic friends talking a lot +[721.680 --> 724.840] about, is a concern about carbon emissions. +[724.840 --> 728.000] This idea that carbon emissions drives all of the climate change. +[728.000 --> 731.040] Well, let's just say that's true, just for the sake of arguments that we're not arguing +[731.040 --> 732.040] about weird science. +[732.040 --> 733.480] Let's just say that's true. +[733.480 --> 736.720] Well, if you believe that, what would you want to do? +[736.720 --> 740.800] The answer is that you'd want to re-shore as much American manufacturing as possible, +[740.800 --> 745.160] and you'd want to produce as much energy as possible in the United States of America, +[745.160 --> 747.960] because we're the cleanest economy in the entire world. +[748.000 --> 751.040] What if Commonwealth Harris's policies actually led to? +[751.040 --> 756.360] More energy production in China, more manufacturing overseas, more doing business in some of the +[756.360 --> 758.080] dirtiest parts of the entire world. +[758.080 --> 759.080] And why say that? +[759.080 --> 763.280] I mean, the amount of carbon emissions they're doing per unit of economic output. +[763.280 --> 767.800] So if we actually care about getting cleaner air and cleaner water, the best thing to do +[767.800 --> 771.840] is to double down and invest in American workers and the American people. +[771.840 --> 775.120] And unfortunately, Commonwealth Harris has done exactly the opposite. +[775.120 --> 777.400] Governor Walls, you have two minutes to respond. +[777.440 --> 780.360] Well, we got close to an agreement, because all those things are happening. +[780.360 --> 785.640] Look, first of all, it is a horrific tragedy with this hurricane. +[785.640 --> 790.000] And my heart goes out to the folks that are down there in contact with the governors. +[790.000 --> 793.600] I serve as co-chair of the Council of Governors. +[793.600 --> 797.440] If we work together on these emergency management's governors, no, no partisanship, +[797.440 --> 801.240] they work together to solve the governors and the emergency responders on the ground, +[801.240 --> 803.080] those happen on the front end. +[803.080 --> 806.040] The federal government comes in, make sure they're there to that we recover, +[806.040 --> 810.280] but we're still in that phase where we need to make sure that they're staying there, staying focused. +[810.280 --> 813.320] Now, look, coming back to the climate changes, there's no doubt this thing +[813.320 --> 817.320] brought on to the scene faster and stronger than anything we've seen. +[817.320 --> 819.920] Senator Vance had said that there's a climate problem in the past. +[819.920 --> 824.920] Donald Trump called it a hoax, and then joked that these things would make more beachfront property +[824.920 --> 826.640] to be able to invest in. +[826.640 --> 831.000] What we've seen out of the Harris administration now, the Biden-Harris administration, +[831.000 --> 832.600] is we've seen this investment. +[832.600 --> 839.040] We've seen massive investments, the biggest in global history that we've seen in the Inflation Reduction Act, +[839.040 --> 843.240] has created jobs all across the country, 2000 in Jeffersonville, Ohio, +[843.240 --> 846.480] taking the EV technology that we invented and making it here, +[846.480 --> 852.120] 200,000 jobs across the country, the largest solar manufacturing plant in North America, +[852.120 --> 853.240] sets in Minnesota. +[853.240 --> 855.520] But my farmers and climate changes real. +[855.520 --> 859.200] They've seen 500-year droughts, 500-year floods back-to-back. +[859.200 --> 862.720] But what they're doing is adapting, and this has allowed them to tell me, +[862.720 --> 866.000] look, I harvest corn, I harvest soybean, and I harvest wind. +[866.000 --> 869.880] We are producing more natural gas and more oil at any time we ever have. +[869.880 --> 872.600] We're also producing more clean energy. +[872.600 --> 878.680] So the solution for us is to continue to move forward that climate change is real. +[878.680 --> 883.280] Reducing our impact is absolutely critical, but this is not a false choice. +[883.280 --> 887.880] You can do that at the same time you're creating the jobs that we're seeing all across the country. +[887.880 --> 890.160] That's exactly what this administration has done. +[890.160 --> 894.800] We are seeing us becoming an energy superpower for the future, not just the current. +[894.800 --> 896.840] And that's what absolutely makes sense. +[896.840 --> 901.680] And then we start thinking about how do we mitigate these disasters? +[901.680 --> 902.640] Thank you, Senator. +[902.640 --> 904.680] I want to give you an opportunity to respond there. +[904.680 --> 908.640] The governor mentioned that President Trump has called climate change a hoax. +[908.640 --> 909.800] Do you agree? +[909.800 --> 912.600] Well, look, what the president has said is that if the Democrats, +[912.600 --> 915.320] in particular, Kamala Harris and her leadership, +[915.320 --> 918.080] if they really believe that climate change is serious, +[918.080 --> 921.560] what they would be doing is more manufacturing and more energy production +[921.560 --> 924.440] in the United States of America, and that's not what they're doing. +[924.440 --> 928.640] So clearly, Kamala Harris herself doesn't believe her own rhetoric on this. +[928.640 --> 931.840] If she did, she would actually agree with Donald Trump's energy policies. +[931.840 --> 935.120] Now, something Governor Walts said is important to touch upon +[935.120 --> 937.560] because when we talk about clean energy, +[937.560 --> 941.200] I think that's a slogan that often the Democrats will use here. +[941.200 --> 943.440] I'm talking of course about the Democratic leadership. +[943.440 --> 946.960] And the real issue is that if you're spending hundreds of millions +[946.960 --> 950.040] or even billions of dollars of American taxpayer money +[950.040 --> 952.280] on solar panels that are made in China, +[952.280 --> 954.440] number one, you're going to make the economy dirtier. +[954.440 --> 958.000] We should be making more of those solar panels here in the United States of America. +[958.000 --> 961.360] Some of them are Tim, but a lot of them are being made overseas in China, +[961.360 --> 964.440] especially the components that go into those solar panels. +[964.440 --> 967.440] So if you really want to make the environment cleaner, +[967.440 --> 969.680] you've got to invest in more energy production. +[969.680 --> 973.080] We haven't built a nuclear facility, I think, one in the past 40 years. +[973.080 --> 975.560] Natural gas. We got to invest more in it. +[975.560 --> 977.320] Kamala Harris has done the opposite. +[977.320 --> 980.520] That's raised energy prices and also meant that we're doing this by the time. +[980.520 --> 981.520] Senator, you're climbing up. +[981.520 --> 983.280] Governor, would you like to respond? +[983.280 --> 986.360] Well, look, we're producing more natural gas we ever have. +[986.360 --> 987.600] There's no more auditorium on that. +[987.600 --> 989.400] We're producing more oil, but the folks know. +[989.400 --> 992.880] And like I said, again, these are not liberal folks. +[992.880 --> 994.880] These are not folks that are green, new deal folks. +[994.880 --> 998.080] These are farmers that have been drought one year, +[998.080 --> 999.920] massive flooding the next year. +[999.920 --> 1001.400] They understand that it makes sense. +[1001.400 --> 1006.960] Look, our number one export cannot be topsoil from erosion from these massive storms. +[1006.960 --> 1009.000] We saw it in Minnesota this summer. +[1009.000 --> 1013.120] And thinking about how do we respond to that, we're thinking ahead on this. +[1013.120 --> 1015.680] And what Kamala Harris has been able to do in Minnesota, +[1015.680 --> 1017.800] we're starting to weather proof some of these things. +[1017.800 --> 1019.920] The infrastructure law that was passed +[1019.920 --> 1022.440] allows us to think about mitigation in the future. +[1022.440 --> 1025.280] How do we make sure that we're protecting by burying our power lines? +[1025.280 --> 1027.960] How do we make sure that we're protecting lake fronts and things +[1027.960 --> 1029.600] that we're seeing more and more of? +[1029.600 --> 1034.840] But to call it a hoax and to take the oil company executives to Mar-a-Lago, +[1034.840 --> 1038.800] say, give me money for my campaign, and I'll let you do whatever you want. +[1038.800 --> 1040.400] We can be smarter about that, +[1040.400 --> 1043.200] and an all above energy policy is exactly what she's doing, +[1043.200 --> 1045.320] creating those jobs right here. +[1045.320 --> 1046.520] Governor, your time is up. +[1046.520 --> 1048.640] The overwhelming consensus among scientists +[1048.640 --> 1051.640] is that the earth's climate is warming at an unprecedented rate. +[1051.640 --> 1053.400] Margaret, thank you, Nora. +[1053.400 --> 1055.600] We're going to turn now to immigration. +[1055.600 --> 1059.240] The crisis at the U.S. Mexico border consistently ranks +[1059.240 --> 1063.000] as one of the top issues for American voters. +[1063.000 --> 1066.720] Senator Vance, your campaign is pledging to carry out +[1066.720 --> 1070.520] the largest mass deportation plan in American history +[1070.520 --> 1073.880] and to use the U.S. military to do so. +[1073.880 --> 1077.840] Could you be more specific about exactly how this will work? +[1077.840 --> 1080.120] For example, would you deport parents +[1080.120 --> 1083.480] who have entered the U.S. illegally and separate them +[1083.480 --> 1087.040] from any of their children who were born on U.S. soil? +[1087.040 --> 1087.920] You have two minutes. +[1087.960 --> 1088.960] So first of all, Margaret, +[1088.960 --> 1090.560] before we talk about deportations, +[1090.560 --> 1092.160] we have to stop the bleeding. +[1092.160 --> 1094.360] We have a historic immigration crisis +[1094.360 --> 1097.400] because Kamala Harris started and said +[1097.400 --> 1100.960] that she wanted to undo all of Donald Trump's border policies. +[1100.960 --> 1104.040] 94 executive orders suspending deportations, +[1104.040 --> 1106.960] decriminalizing illegal aliens, +[1106.960 --> 1110.720] massively increasing the asylum fraud that exists in our system. +[1110.720 --> 1112.400] That has opened the floodgates. +[1112.400 --> 1114.240] And what it's meant is that a lot of fentanyl +[1114.240 --> 1115.760] is coming into our country. +[1115.760 --> 1117.760] I had a mother who struggled with opioid addiction +[1117.760 --> 1119.040] and has gotten clean. +[1119.040 --> 1122.000] I don't want people who are struggling with addiction +[1122.000 --> 1123.600] to be deprived of their second chance +[1123.600 --> 1125.920] because Kamala Harris led in fentanyl +[1125.920 --> 1128.360] into our communities at record levels. +[1128.360 --> 1130.560] So you've got to stop the bleeding. +[1130.560 --> 1133.440] You've got to re-implement Donald Trump's border policies, +[1133.440 --> 1136.280] build the wall, re-implement deportations, +[1136.280 --> 1137.760] and that gets me to your point, Margaret, +[1137.760 --> 1139.360] about what do we actually do? +[1139.360 --> 1141.760] So we've got 20, 25 million illegal aliens +[1141.760 --> 1142.960] who are here in the country. +[1142.960 --> 1143.800] What do we do with them? +[1143.800 --> 1145.200] I think the first thing that we do +[1145.200 --> 1147.080] is we start with the criminal migrants. +[1147.080 --> 1149.360] About a million of those people have committed +[1149.360 --> 1152.880] some form of crime in addition to crossing the border illegally. +[1152.880 --> 1155.840] I think you start with deportations on those folks. +[1155.840 --> 1158.360] And then I think you make it harder for illegal aliens +[1158.360 --> 1160.800] to undercut the wages of American workers. +[1160.800 --> 1163.080] A lot of people will go home if they can't work +[1163.080 --> 1165.120] for less than minimum wage in our own country. +[1165.120 --> 1167.160] And by the way, that'll be really good for our workers +[1167.160 --> 1169.040] who just want to earn a fair wage +[1169.040 --> 1170.680] for doing a good day's work. +[1170.680 --> 1172.280] And the final point, Margaret, is you ask +[1172.280 --> 1173.560] about family separation. +[1173.560 --> 1175.600] Right now in this country market, +[1175.600 --> 1178.520] we have 320,000 children +[1178.520 --> 1181.680] that the Department of Homeland Security has effectively lost. +[1181.680 --> 1183.320] Some of them have been sex trafficked. +[1183.320 --> 1186.000] Some of them hopefully aren't homes with their families. +[1186.000 --> 1188.800] Some of them have been used as drug trafficking mules. +[1188.800 --> 1191.920] The real family separation policy in this country +[1191.920 --> 1194.000] is unfortunately Kamala Harris's +[1194.000 --> 1195.400] wide open southern border. +[1195.400 --> 1197.480] And I'd ask my fellow Americans to remember +[1197.480 --> 1200.960] when she came into office, she said she was going to do this. +[1200.960 --> 1202.320] Real leadership would be saying, +[1202.320 --> 1203.680] you know what, I screwed up. +[1203.680 --> 1205.560] We're gonna go back to Donald Trump's border policies +[1205.600 --> 1206.960] I wish she would do that. +[1206.960 --> 1208.440] It would be good for all of us. +[1209.400 --> 1211.920] Governor, do you care to respond +[1211.920 --> 1213.720] to any of those specific allegations, +[1213.720 --> 1216.240] including that the Vice President is, quote, +[1216.240 --> 1221.000] letting in fentanyl and using kids as drug mules +[1221.000 --> 1223.400] among other things, pardoning children? +[1223.400 --> 1224.560] The drug mules, not true, +[1224.560 --> 1226.080] but I will say about this about the fentanyl, +[1226.080 --> 1228.280] because this is a crisis of this, the opioid crisis. +[1228.280 --> 1229.480] And the good news on this is, +[1229.480 --> 1231.560] is the last 12 months saw the largest decrease +[1231.560 --> 1233.760] in opioid deaths in our nation's history. +[1233.760 --> 1237.160] 30% decrease in Ohio, but there's still more work to do. +[1237.160 --> 1238.840] But let's go back to this on immigration. +[1238.840 --> 1240.640] Kamala Harris was the attorney general +[1240.640 --> 1242.840] of the largest state in a border state in California. +[1242.840 --> 1244.680] She's the only person in this race +[1244.680 --> 1246.560] who prosecuted transnational gangs +[1246.560 --> 1249.120] for human trafficking and drug interventions. +[1249.120 --> 1251.760] But look, we all want to solve the, +[1251.760 --> 1254.240] most of us want to solve this. +[1254.240 --> 1256.440] And that is the United States Congress. +[1256.440 --> 1257.920] That's the border patrol agents. +[1257.920 --> 1259.160] That's the Chamber of Commerce. +[1259.160 --> 1260.720] That's most Americans out here. +[1260.720 --> 1264.280] That's why we had the fairest and the toughest bill +[1264.280 --> 1267.160] on immigration that this nation's seen. +[1267.160 --> 1270.760] It was crafted by a conservative senator from Oklahoma, +[1270.760 --> 1272.720] James Langford, I know him, he's super conservative, +[1272.720 --> 1274.800] but he's a man of principle, once you get it done. +[1274.800 --> 1277.680] Democrats and Republicans worked on this piece of legislation. +[1277.680 --> 1280.000] The border patrols say this is what we need in here. +[1280.000 --> 1281.080] These are the experts. +[1281.080 --> 1282.880] And the Chamber of Commerce and the Wall Street Journal +[1282.880 --> 1284.080] said, pass this thing. +[1284.080 --> 1285.680] Kamala Harris helped get there. +[1285.680 --> 1288.040] 1500 new border agents. +[1288.040 --> 1290.040] Detection for drugs. +[1290.040 --> 1294.040] The OJ money to speed up the adjudications on this, +[1294.040 --> 1295.400] just what America wants. +[1295.400 --> 1297.120] But as soon as I was getting ready to pass +[1297.120 --> 1300.040] and actually tackle this, Donald Trump said, no. +[1300.040 --> 1302.720] Told them to vote against it because it gives him +[1302.720 --> 1304.000] a campaign issue. +[1304.000 --> 1306.240] It gives him to, what would Donald Trump talk about +[1306.240 --> 1307.960] if we actually did some of these things? +[1307.960 --> 1310.600] And they need to be done by the legislature. +[1310.600 --> 1313.160] You can't just do this through the executive branch. +[1313.160 --> 1315.400] So look, we have the options to do this. +[1315.400 --> 1317.120] Donald Trump had four years. +[1317.120 --> 1318.720] He had four years to do this. +[1318.720 --> 1321.720] And he promised you America how easy it would be. +[1321.720 --> 1323.920] I'll build you a big, beautiful wall. +[1323.920 --> 1325.640] And Mexico will pay for it. +[1325.640 --> 1327.800] Less than 2% of that wall got built. +[1327.800 --> 1329.360] And Mexico didn't pay a dime. +[1329.360 --> 1331.960] But here we are again, nine years after he came down +[1331.960 --> 1335.920] that escalator, dehumanizing people, +[1335.920 --> 1337.480] and telling him what he was going to do. +[1337.480 --> 1340.000] As far as a deportation plant, at one point, +[1340.000 --> 1343.080] Senator Van said it was so unworkable to be laughable. +[1343.080 --> 1344.400] So that's where we're at. +[1344.400 --> 1346.600] Pass the bill, she'll sign it. +[1346.600 --> 1348.120] Governor, your time is up. +[1348.120 --> 1351.480] Senator, the question was, will you separate parents +[1351.480 --> 1355.160] from their children, even if their kids are US citizens? +[1355.160 --> 1356.120] You have one minute. +[1356.120 --> 1358.560] Margaret, my point is that we already have massive child +[1358.560 --> 1360.960] separations, thanks to Kamala Harris's open border. +[1360.960 --> 1364.120] And I didn't accuse Kamala Harris of inviting drug mules. +[1364.120 --> 1366.880] I said that she enabled the Mexican drug cartels +[1366.880 --> 1368.840] to operate freely in this country. +[1368.840 --> 1371.000] And we know that they use children as drug mules. +[1371.000 --> 1374.160] And it is a disgrace, and it has to stop. +[1374.160 --> 1376.320] Look, I think what Tim said just doesn't pass +[1376.360 --> 1378.560] the smell test for three years. +[1378.560 --> 1381.480] Kamala Harris went out bragging that she was going to +[1381.480 --> 1383.160] undo Donald Trump's border policy. +[1383.160 --> 1384.640] She did exactly that. +[1384.640 --> 1386.640] We had a record number of illegal crossings. +[1386.640 --> 1389.280] We had a record number of fentanyl coming into our country. +[1389.280 --> 1391.600] And now that she's running for president, +[1391.600 --> 1394.880] or a few months before, she says that somehow she got religion +[1394.880 --> 1397.280] and cared a lot about a piece of legislation, +[1397.280 --> 1401.280] the only thing that she did when she became the vice president, +[1401.280 --> 1403.160] when she became the appointed borders +[1403.160 --> 1408.160] to her was to undo 94 Donald Trump executive actions +[1408.160 --> 1409.600] that opened the border. +[1409.600 --> 1412.520] This problem is leading to massive problems +[1412.520 --> 1414.280] in the United States of America. +[1414.280 --> 1415.880] Parents who can't afford health care, +[1415.880 --> 1418.000] schools that are overwhelmed, it's got to stop +[1418.000 --> 1419.720] and it will when Donald Trump is president again. +[1419.720 --> 1421.160] Senator, your time is up. +[1421.160 --> 1425.080] Governor, what about our CBS news polling, +[1425.080 --> 1427.520] which does show that a majority of Americans, +[1427.520 --> 1431.200] more than 50% support mass deportations? +[1431.200 --> 1435.000] Look, we fix this issue with a bill that is necessary, +[1435.000 --> 1437.000] but the issue on this is this is what happens +[1437.000 --> 1438.320] when you don't want to solve it. +[1438.320 --> 1439.560] You demonize it. +[1439.560 --> 1441.400] And we saw this and Senator Vance +[1441.400 --> 1443.280] and it surprises me on this. +[1443.280 --> 1445.520] Talking about and saying, I will create stories +[1445.520 --> 1447.240] to bring attention to this. +[1447.240 --> 1449.120] That vilified a large number of people +[1449.120 --> 1452.200] who were here legally in the community of Springfield. +[1452.200 --> 1456.520] The Republican governor said it's not true, don't do it. +[1456.520 --> 1457.880] There's consequences for this. +[1457.880 --> 1458.720] There's consequences. +[1458.720 --> 1459.560] We could come together. +[1459.560 --> 1460.960] Senator Langford did it. +[1460.960 --> 1462.840] We could come together and solve this +[1462.840 --> 1465.880] if we didn't let Donald Trump continue to make it an issue. +[1465.880 --> 1468.360] And the consequences in Springfield were, +[1468.360 --> 1471.520] the governor had to send state law enforcement +[1471.520 --> 1473.720] to escort kindergarteners to school. +[1473.720 --> 1476.360] I believe Senator Vance wants to solve this, +[1476.360 --> 1478.280] but by standing with Donald Trump +[1478.280 --> 1480.600] and not working together to find a solution, +[1480.600 --> 1482.000] it becomes a talking point. +[1482.000 --> 1484.280] And when it becomes a talking point like this, +[1484.280 --> 1487.680] we dehumanize and villainize other human beings. +[1488.680 --> 1489.520] Tim. +[1489.520 --> 1490.920] Governor, your time is up, Senator. +[1490.920 --> 1495.240] I'll give you one minute, but let me just ask you the question first. +[1495.240 --> 1497.640] The governor has made the point, +[1497.640 --> 1499.680] and I think as a sitting lawmaker, +[1499.680 --> 1503.760] you know that Congress controls the purse strings and any funding. +[1503.760 --> 1506.960] So you have said repeatedly that Donald Trump +[1506.960 --> 1510.800] would, through executive action, solve this. +[1510.800 --> 1514.760] Do you disagree that Congress controls the purse strings +[1514.760 --> 1517.520] and would need to support many of the changes +[1517.520 --> 1519.720] that you would actually want to implement? +[1519.720 --> 1520.520] You have one minute. +[1520.520 --> 1521.360] Look, Margaret, first of all, +[1521.360 --> 1522.880] the gross majority of what we need to do +[1522.880 --> 1525.360] with the Southern border is just empowering law enforcement +[1525.360 --> 1526.200] to do their job. +[1526.200 --> 1527.960] I've been to the Southern border more than our borders +[1527.960 --> 1529.320] are, Kamala Harris has been. +[1529.320 --> 1530.640] And it's actually heartbreaking, +[1530.640 --> 1532.160] because the border patrol agents, +[1532.160 --> 1534.480] they just want to be empowered to do their job. +[1534.480 --> 1536.560] Of course, additional resources would help, +[1536.560 --> 1538.320] but most of this is about the president +[1538.320 --> 1541.000] and the vice president empowering our law enforcement +[1541.000 --> 1543.840] to say, if you try to come across the border illegally, +[1543.840 --> 1545.080] you've got to stay in Mexico, +[1545.080 --> 1547.160] you've got to go back through proper channels. +[1547.160 --> 1549.960] Now, Governor Waltz brought up the community of Springfield, +[1549.960 --> 1552.560] and he's very worried about the things +[1552.560 --> 1554.040] that I've said in Springfield. +[1554.040 --> 1556.800] Look, in Springfield, Ohio, and in communities +[1556.800 --> 1560.440] all across this country, you've got schools that are overwhelmed, +[1560.440 --> 1562.440] you've got hospitals that are overwhelmed, +[1562.440 --> 1565.160] you have got housing that is totally unaffordable, +[1565.160 --> 1567.640] because we brought in millions of illegal immigrants +[1567.640 --> 1570.200] to compete with Americans for scarce homes. +[1570.200 --> 1572.960] The people that I'm most worried about in Springfield, Ohio, +[1572.960 --> 1576.360] are the American citizens who have had their lives destroyed +[1576.360 --> 1578.360] by Kamala Harris' open border. +[1578.360 --> 1581.680] It is a disgrace to him, and I actually think, I agree with you. +[1581.680 --> 1583.360] I think you want to solve this problem, +[1583.360 --> 1585.200] but I don't think that Kamala Harris does. +[1585.200 --> 1586.360] Senator, your time is up. +[1586.360 --> 1588.120] Governor, you have one minute to respond. +[1588.120 --> 1592.120] Yeah, well, it is law enforcement that asked for the bill. +[1592.120 --> 1593.360] They helped craft it. +[1593.360 --> 1594.800] They're the ones that supported it. +[1594.800 --> 1597.520] It was, that's because they know we need to do this. +[1597.520 --> 1600.600] Look, this issue of continuing to bring this up, +[1600.600 --> 1602.080] of not dealing with it, +[1602.080 --> 1604.960] of blaming migrants for everything. +[1604.960 --> 1607.360] On housing, we could talk a little bit about Wall Street +[1607.360 --> 1610.320] speculators buying up housing and making them less affordable, +[1610.320 --> 1612.080] but it becomes a blame. +[1612.080 --> 1617.000] Look, this bill also gives the money necessary to adjudicate. +[1617.000 --> 1619.320] I agree, it should not take seven years +[1619.320 --> 1620.920] for an asylum claim to be done. +[1620.920 --> 1622.880] This bill gets it done in 90 days. +[1622.880 --> 1624.680] Then you start to make a difference in this, +[1624.680 --> 1628.000] and you start to adhere to what we know, American principles. +[1628.000 --> 1630.120] I don't talk about my faith a lot, +[1630.120 --> 1633.760] but Matthew 2540 talks about to the least amongst us +[1633.760 --> 1634.560] you do unto me. +[1634.560 --> 1637.000] I think that's true of most Americans. +[1637.000 --> 1639.160] They simply want order to it. +[1639.160 --> 1640.440] This bill does it. +[1640.440 --> 1641.360] It's funded. +[1641.360 --> 1643.000] It's supported by the people who do it, +[1643.000 --> 1645.040] and it lets us keep our dignity +[1645.040 --> 1647.560] about how we treat other people. +[1647.560 --> 1650.480] Thank you, Governor, and just to clarify for our viewers, +[1650.480 --> 1654.760] Springfield, Ohio does have a large number of Haitian migrants +[1654.760 --> 1658.360] who have legal status, temporary protected status. +[1658.360 --> 1660.280] Well, Mark, but thank you, Senator, +[1660.280 --> 1661.600] we have so much to get to. +[1661.600 --> 1663.000] I think it's important because... +[1663.000 --> 1665.200] I'm going to turn out of the economy, thank you. +[1665.200 --> 1667.560] The rules were that you guys weren't going to fact check, +[1667.560 --> 1669.120] and since you're fact checking me, +[1669.120 --> 1671.840] I think it's important to say what's actually going on. +[1671.840 --> 1674.760] So there's an application called the CBP1 app, +[1674.760 --> 1676.920] where you can go on as an illegal migrant, +[1676.920 --> 1679.720] apply for asylum or apply for parole, +[1679.720 --> 1683.320] and be granted legal status at the wave +[1683.320 --> 1686.320] of a Kamala Harris open border wand. +[1686.320 --> 1687.840] That is not a person coming in, +[1687.840 --> 1690.360] applying for a green card and waiting for 10 years. +[1690.360 --> 1691.360] Thank you, Senator. +[1691.360 --> 1692.360] Thank you, Senator. +[1692.360 --> 1693.360] Thank you, Senator. +[1693.360 --> 1695.360] Thank you, Senator, for describing the legal process. +[1695.360 --> 1698.360] And how many we have so much to get to, Senator. +[1698.360 --> 1699.360] We have so much. +[1699.360 --> 1701.360] Those are been in the books since 1990. +[1701.360 --> 1702.360] Thank you, gentlemen. +[1702.360 --> 1704.360] The CBP1 app has not been on the books. +[1704.360 --> 1705.360] It's since 1990. +[1705.360 --> 1707.360] It's something that's not like there was created water. +[1707.360 --> 1710.360] Gentlemen, the audience can't hear you +[1710.360 --> 1712.360] because your mics are cut. +[1712.360 --> 1714.360] We have so much we want to get to. +[1714.360 --> 1716.360] Thank you for explaining the legal process. +[1716.360 --> 1718.360] Nora, thank you, Margaret. +[1718.360 --> 1721.360] The economy is a top concern for voters. +[1721.360 --> 1724.360] Each of your campaigns has released an economic plan. +[1724.360 --> 1726.360] So let's talk about the specifics. +[1726.360 --> 1729.360] Governor Walls, vice president Harris unveiled a plan +[1729.360 --> 1732.360] that includes billions in tax credits for manufacturing, +[1732.360 --> 1735.360] housing, and a renewed child tax credit. +[1735.360 --> 1737.360] The Wharton School says your proposals +[1737.360 --> 1742.360] will increase the nation's deficit by $1.2 trillion. +[1742.360 --> 1745.360] How would you pay for that without ballooning the deficit? +[1745.360 --> 1746.360] Governor, I'll give you two minutes. +[1746.360 --> 1747.360] Thank you. +[1747.360 --> 1750.360] And Kamala Harris and I do believe in the middle class +[1750.360 --> 1751.360] because that's where we come from. +[1751.360 --> 1752.360] We both grew up in that. +[1752.360 --> 1753.360] We understand. +[1753.360 --> 1755.360] So those of you out there listening tonight, +[1755.360 --> 1756.360] you're hearing a lot of stuff back and forth. +[1756.360 --> 1757.360] And it's good. +[1757.360 --> 1758.360] It's healthy. +[1758.360 --> 1759.360] That's what this is supposed to happen. +[1759.360 --> 1760.360] You should be listening. +[1760.360 --> 1761.360] How's this going to impact me? +[1761.360 --> 1764.360] The bold forward plan that Kamala Harris put out there +[1764.360 --> 1767.360] is one is talking about this housing issue. +[1767.360 --> 1770.360] The one thing is there's three million new houses proposed +[1770.360 --> 1773.360] under this plan with down payment assistance on the front end +[1773.360 --> 1774.360] to get you in a house. +[1774.360 --> 1778.360] A house is much more than just an asset to be traded somewhere. +[1778.360 --> 1779.360] It's foundational to where you're at. +[1779.360 --> 1782.360] And then making sure that the things you buy every day, +[1782.360 --> 1784.360] whether they be prescription drugs or other things, +[1784.360 --> 1786.360] that there's fairness in that. +[1786.360 --> 1788.360] Look, the $35 insulin is a good thing, +[1788.360 --> 1790.360] but it costs $5 to make insulin. +[1790.360 --> 1793.360] They were charging $800 before the law went into effect. +[1793.360 --> 1795.360] As far as the housing goes, +[1795.360 --> 1796.360] I've seen it in Minnesota. +[1796.360 --> 1798.360] 12% more houses in Minneapolis. +[1798.360 --> 1800.360] Prices went down on rent 4%. +[1800.360 --> 1801.360] It's working. +[1801.360 --> 1804.360] And then making sure tax cuts go to the middle class. +[1804.360 --> 1806.360] $6,000 child tax credit. +[1806.360 --> 1807.360] We have one in Minnesota. +[1807.360 --> 1810.360] Reduces childhood poverty by a third. +[1810.360 --> 1811.360] We saved money in the long run, +[1811.360 --> 1813.360] and we do the right thing for families. +[1813.360 --> 1815.360] And then getting businesses off the ground. +[1815.360 --> 1818.360] The laws it stands right now is $5,000 tax credit for small business, +[1818.360 --> 1820.360] increasing that to $50,000. +[1820.360 --> 1822.360] Now, this is a philosophical difference between us. +[1822.360 --> 1825.360] Donald Trump made a promise, and I'll give you this. +[1825.360 --> 1826.360] He kept it. +[1826.360 --> 1827.360] He took folks tomorrow, Lago. +[1827.360 --> 1829.360] Said you're rich as hell and give you a tax cut. +[1829.360 --> 1832.360] He gave the tax cuts that predominantly went to the top class. +[1832.360 --> 1836.360] What happened there was an $8 trillion increase in the national debt, +[1836.360 --> 1837.360] the largest ever. +[1837.360 --> 1843.360] Now he's proposing a 20% consumption or sales tax on everything we bring in. +[1843.360 --> 1846.360] Everyone agrees, including businesses, it would be destabilizing it. +[1846.360 --> 1850.360] It would increase inflation and potentially lead to a recession. +[1850.360 --> 1852.360] Look, this is simple for you. +[1852.360 --> 1853.360] Where are we going? +[1853.360 --> 1855.360] Kamala Harris has said to do the things she wants to do. +[1855.360 --> 1858.360] We'll just ask the wealthiest to pay their fair share. +[1858.360 --> 1860.360] When you do that, our system works best. +[1860.360 --> 1864.360] More people are participating in it, and folks have the things that they need. +[1864.360 --> 1866.360] Senator, I want to give you a moment to respond on that. +[1866.360 --> 1870.360] But similarly, the Wharton School has done an analysis of the Trump plan, +[1870.360 --> 1875.360] and says it would increase the nation's deficit by $5.8 trillion. +[1875.360 --> 1877.360] My question is the same for you. +[1877.360 --> 1880.360] How do you pay for all that without ballooning the deficit? +[1880.360 --> 1882.360] I'll give you two minutes. +[1882.360 --> 1885.360] Well, first of all, you're going to hear a lot from Tim Walsh this evening, +[1885.360 --> 1887.360] and you just heard it in the answer. +[1887.360 --> 1889.360] A lot of what Kamala Harris proposes to do. +[1889.360 --> 1892.360] And some of it, I'll be honest with you, it even sounds pretty good. +[1892.360 --> 1894.360] Here's what you won't hear. +[1894.360 --> 1896.360] Is that Kamala Harris has already done it. +[1896.360 --> 1899.360] Because she's been the vice president for three and a half years. +[1899.360 --> 1902.360] She had the opportunity to enact all of these great policies +[1902.360 --> 1908.360] and what she's actually done instead is drive the cost of food higher by 25%. +[1908.360 --> 1912.360] Drive the cost of housing higher by about 60%. +[1912.360 --> 1916.360] Open the American Southern border and make middle class life unaffordable +[1916.360 --> 1918.360] for a large number of Americans. +[1918.360 --> 1922.360] If Kamala Harris has such great plans for how to address middle class problems, +[1922.360 --> 1924.360] then she ought to do them now. +[1924.360 --> 1929.360] Not one asking for promotion, but in the job the American people gave her three and a half years ago. +[1929.360 --> 1935.360] And the fact that she isn't tells you a lot about how much you can trust her actual plans. +[1935.360 --> 1939.360] Now, Donald Trump's economic plan is not just a plan, but it's also a record. +[1939.360 --> 1943.360] A lot of those same economists attack Donald Trump's plans and they have PhDs, +[1943.360 --> 1946.360] but they don't have common sense and they don't have wisdom. +[1946.360 --> 1950.360] Because Donald Trump's economic policies delivered the highest take-home pay +[1950.360 --> 1955.360] in a generation in this country, 1.5% inflation and to boot, +[1955.360 --> 1957.360] peace and security all over the world. +[1957.360 --> 1960.360] So when people say that Donald Trump's economic plan doesn't make sense, +[1960.360 --> 1962.360] I say look at the record. +[1962.360 --> 1965.360] He delivered rising take-home pay for American workers. +[1966.360 --> 1970.360] Now Tim admirably admits that they want to undo the Trump tax cuts. +[1970.360 --> 1974.360] But if you look at what was so different about Donald Trump's tax cuts, +[1974.360 --> 1976.360] even from previous Republican tax cut plans, +[1976.360 --> 1982.360] is that a lot of those resources went to giving more take-home pay to middle class and working class Americans. +[1982.360 --> 1989.360] It was passed in 2017 and you saw an American economic boom, unlike we've seen in a generation in this country. +[1989.360 --> 1994.360] That is a record that I'm proud to run on and we're going to get back to that common sense wisdom +[1994.360 --> 1997.360] that you can afford to live the American dream again. +[1997.360 --> 1999.360] I know a lot of you are struggling. +[1999.360 --> 2001.360] I know a lot of you are worried about paying the bills. +[2001.360 --> 2005.360] It's going to stop when Donald Trump brings back common sense to this country. +[2005.360 --> 2007.360] Governor, do you want to respond to that? +[2007.360 --> 2009.360] What has Kamala Harris done for the middle class? +[2009.360 --> 2014.360] Kamala Harris's day one was Donald Trump's failure on COVID that led to the collapse of our economy. +[2014.360 --> 2017.360] We were already before COVID in a manufacturing recession, +[2017.360 --> 2020.360] but 10 million people out of work, largest percentage, since a great depression. +[2020.360 --> 2022.360] 9 million jobs closed on that. +[2022.360 --> 2025.360] That was day one, whether it was the infrastructure act or other things we moved. +[2025.360 --> 2028.360] Now, you made a question about experts said this. +[2028.360 --> 2029.360] I've made a note of this. +[2029.360 --> 2032.360] Economists don't know you can't be trusted. +[2032.360 --> 2033.360] Science can't be trusted. +[2033.360 --> 2036.360] National security folks can't be trusted. +[2036.360 --> 2040.360] Look, if you're going to be president, you don't have all the answers. +[2040.360 --> 2041.360] Donald Trump believes he does. +[2041.360 --> 2043.360] My pro tip of the day is this. +[2043.360 --> 2048.360] If you need heart surgery, listen to the people at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, not Donald Trump. +[2048.360 --> 2050.360] And the same thing goes with this. +[2050.360 --> 2054.360] And I asked you out there, teachers, nurses, truck drivers, whatever. +[2054.360 --> 2057.360] How is it fair that you're paying your taxes every year? +[2057.360 --> 2061.360] And Donald Trump hasn't paid any federal tax 10 to the last 15 years. +[2061.360 --> 2062.360] And the last year is president. +[2062.360 --> 2064.360] That's what's wrong with the system. +[2064.360 --> 2067.360] There's a way around it, and he's bragged about that. +[2067.360 --> 2070.360] We're just asking for fairness in it, and that's all you want. +[2070.360 --> 2071.360] You have a minute. +[2071.360 --> 2073.360] Governor, you say trust the experts. +[2073.360 --> 2078.360] But those same experts for 40 years said that if we shipped our manufacturing base off to China, +[2078.360 --> 2079.360] we'd get cheaper goods. +[2079.360 --> 2080.360] They lied about that. +[2080.360 --> 2085.360] They said if we shipped our industrial base off to other countries to Mexico and elsewhere, +[2085.360 --> 2087.360] it would make the middle class stronger. +[2087.360 --> 2088.360] They were wrong about that. +[2088.360 --> 2092.360] They were wrong about the idea that if we made America less self-reliant, +[2092.360 --> 2097.360] less productive in our own nation, that it would somehow make us better off, +[2097.360 --> 2098.360] and they were wrong about it. +[2098.360 --> 2105.360] And for the first time in a generation, Donald Trump had the wisdom and the courage to say to that bipartisan consensus +[2105.360 --> 2106.360] we're not doing it anymore. +[2106.360 --> 2107.360] We're bringing American manufacturing back. +[2107.360 --> 2108.360] We're unleashing American energy. +[2108.360 --> 2110.360] We're going to make more of our own stuff. +[2110.360 --> 2112.360] And this isn't just an economic issue. +[2112.360 --> 2115.360] And I've got three beautiful little kids at home, seven, four, and two. +[2115.360 --> 2117.360] And I love them very much, and I hope they're in bed right now. +[2117.360 --> 2122.360] But look, so many of the drugs, the pharmaceuticals that we put in the bodies of our children, +[2122.360 --> 2124.360] are manufactured by nations that hate us. +[2124.360 --> 2126.360] This has to stop. +[2126.360 --> 2129.360] And we're not going to stop it by listening to experts. +[2129.360 --> 2133.360] We're going to stop it by listening to common sense wisdom, which is what Donald Trump is doing. +[2133.360 --> 2136.360] Senator, you're trying to end up, Governor Walls, can you address that? +[2136.360 --> 2138.360] I mean, voters say they trust Donald Trump on the economy. +[2138.360 --> 2139.360] More. Why? +[2139.360 --> 2146.360] If you're listening tonight and you want billionaire skitttacks cuts, you've heard what the numbers were, +[2146.360 --> 2149.360] look, I'm a union guy on this. +[2149.360 --> 2153.360] I'm not a guy who wanted to ship things overseas, but I understand that, look, +[2153.360 --> 2154.360] we produce soybeans and corn. +[2154.360 --> 2156.360] We need to have fair trading partners. +[2156.360 --> 2158.360] That's something that we believe in. +[2158.360 --> 2161.360] I think the thing that most concerns me on this is, +[2161.360 --> 2167.360] is Donald Trump was the guy who created the largest trade deficit in American history with China. +[2167.360 --> 2169.360] So the rhetoric is good. +[2169.360 --> 2172.360] Much of what the senator said right there, I'm in agreement with him on this. +[2172.360 --> 2176.360] I watched it happen too. I watched it to my communities, and we talked about that. +[2176.360 --> 2180.360] But we had people undercutting the right to collectively bargain. +[2180.360 --> 2182.360] We had right to work states made it more difficult. +[2182.360 --> 2184.360] We had companies that were willing to ship it over. +[2184.360 --> 2186.360] And we saw people profit. +[2186.360 --> 2190.360] Folks that are venture capital, in some cases, +[2190.360 --> 2192.360] putting money into companies that were overseas. +[2192.360 --> 2194.360] We're in agreement that we bring those home. +[2194.360 --> 2196.360] The issue is Donald Trump is talking about it. +[2196.360 --> 2201.360] Kamala Harris has a record, 250,000 more manufacturing jobs just in the out of the IRA. +[2201.360 --> 2202.360] But Mara's spotted that. +[2202.360 --> 2203.360] Yes. +[2203.360 --> 2204.360] So appreciate that. +[2204.360 --> 2207.360] So if you notice what Governor Waltz just did, as he said, +[2207.360 --> 2210.360] first of all, Donald Trump has to listen to the experts. +[2210.360 --> 2212.360] And then when he acknowledged the experts screwed up, he said, +[2212.360 --> 2215.360] well, Donald Trump didn't do nearly as good of a job as the citizen. +[2215.360 --> 2216.360] No, that's a most generalization. +[2216.360 --> 2217.360] That he did. +[2217.360 --> 2221.360] So what Tim Waltz is doing, and I honestly, Tim, I think you got a tough job here. +[2221.360 --> 2223.360] Because you've got to play whack them all. +[2223.360 --> 2226.360] You've got to pretend that Donald Trump didn't deliver rising take home pay, +[2226.360 --> 2227.360] which, of course, he did. +[2227.360 --> 2231.360] You've got to pretend that Donald Trump didn't deliver lower inflation, +[2231.360 --> 2232.360] which, of course, he did. +[2232.360 --> 2236.360] And then you simultaneously got to defend Kamala Harris's atrocious economic record, +[2236.360 --> 2239.360] which has made gas, groceries, and housing, +[2239.360 --> 2241.360] unaffordable, fair American citizens. +[2241.360 --> 2245.360] I was raised by a woman who would sometimes go into medical debt +[2245.360 --> 2248.360] so that she could put food on the table and our household. +[2248.360 --> 2252.360] I know what it's like to not be able to afford the things that you need to afford. +[2252.360 --> 2254.360] We can do so much better. +[2254.360 --> 2258.360] To all of you watching, we can get back to an America that's affordable again. +[2258.360 --> 2261.360] We just got to get back to common sense economic principles. +[2261.360 --> 2263.360] I hope we have a conversation on health care then. +[2263.360 --> 2264.360] Senator Gov. +[2264.360 --> 2265.360] Please. +[2265.360 --> 2266.360] Thank you, Margaret. +[2266.360 --> 2270.360] We have a lot to get to ahead, gentlemen, on many topics. +[2270.360 --> 2273.360] But right now, I want to talk about personal qualifications. +[2274.360 --> 2282.360] The Vice President is often the last voice the President hears before making consequential decisions. +[2282.360 --> 2285.360] We want to ask you about your leadership qualities. +[2285.360 --> 2290.360] Governor Walls, you said you were in Hong Kong during the Deadly Tiananmen Square protest +[2290.360 --> 2293.360] in the spring of 1989. +[2293.360 --> 2301.360] But Minnesota Public Radio and other media outlets are reporting that you actually didn't travel to Asia until August of that year. +[2301.360 --> 2303.360] Can you explain that discrepancy? +[2303.360 --> 2304.360] Yes, I can. +[2304.360 --> 2306.360] Well, into the folks out there, I didn't get at the top of this. +[2306.360 --> 2313.360] Look, I grew up in small rural Nebraska, town of 400, town that you rode your bike with your buddy +[2313.360 --> 2314.360] still the street lights come on. +[2314.360 --> 2315.360] And I'm proud of that service. +[2315.360 --> 2319.360] I joined the National Guard at 17, worked on family farms. +[2319.360 --> 2324.360] And then I used the GI Bill to become a teacher, passionate, a young teacher. +[2324.360 --> 2329.360] My first year out, I got the opportunity in the summer of 89 to travel to China. +[2329.360 --> 2336.360] 35 years ago, I came back home and then started a program to take young people there. +[2336.360 --> 2340.360] We would take basketball teams, we would take baseball teams, we would take dancers, +[2340.360 --> 2342.360] and we would go back and forth to China. +[2342.360 --> 2344.360] The issue for that was to try and learn. +[2344.360 --> 2347.360] Now, look, my community knows who I am. +[2347.360 --> 2348.360] They saw where I was at. +[2348.360 --> 2353.360] They look, I will be the first to tell you, I have poured my heart into my community. +[2353.360 --> 2356.360] I've tried to do the best I can, but I've not been perfect. +[2356.360 --> 2359.360] And I'm a knucklehead at times, but it's always been about that. +[2359.360 --> 2363.360] Those same people elected me to Congress for 12 years. +[2363.360 --> 2368.360] And in Congress, I was one of the most bipartisan people working on things like farm bills that we got done, +[2368.360 --> 2370.360] working on veterans benefits. +[2370.360 --> 2374.360] And then the people of Minnesota were able to elect me to governor twice. +[2374.360 --> 2379.360] So look, my commitment has been from the beginning to make sure that I'm there for the people, +[2379.360 --> 2381.360] to make sure that I get this right. +[2381.360 --> 2383.360] I will say more than anything. +[2383.360 --> 2387.360] Many times I will talk a lot, I will get caught up in the rhetoric. +[2387.360 --> 2393.360] But being there, the impact it made, the difference it made in my life, I learned a lot about China. +[2393.360 --> 2394.360] I hear the critiques of this. +[2394.360 --> 2398.360] I would make the case that Donald Trump should have come on one of those trips with us. +[2398.360 --> 2402.360] I guarantee you, he wouldn't be praising Xi Jinping about COVID. +[2402.360 --> 2406.360] And I guarantee you, he wouldn't start a trade war that he ends up losing. +[2406.360 --> 2409.360] So this is about trying to understand the world. +[2409.360 --> 2412.360] It's about trying to do the best you can for your community. +[2412.360 --> 2416.360] And then it's putting yourself out there and letting your folks understand what it is. +[2416.360 --> 2419.360] My commitment, whether it be through teaching, which I was good at, +[2419.360 --> 2422.360] or whether it was being a good soldier, or always being a good member of Congress, +[2422.360 --> 2426.360] those are the things that I think are the values that people care about. +[2426.360 --> 2431.360] Governor, just to follow up on that, the question was, can you explain the discrepancy? +[2431.360 --> 2432.360] No, just... +[2432.360 --> 2435.360] All I said on this was, is I got there that summer and misspoke on this. +[2435.360 --> 2439.360] So I will just... That's what I've said. +[2440.360 --> 2446.360] So I was in Hong Kong and China during the democracy protests went in. +[2446.360 --> 2451.360] And from that, I learned a lot of what needed to be in governance. +[2451.360 --> 2453.360] Thank you, Governor. +[2453.360 --> 2460.360] Senator Vance, in 2016, you called your running mate Donald Trump unfit for the nation's highest office. +[2460.360 --> 2463.360] And you said he could be America's Hitler. +[2463.360 --> 2467.360] I know you've said, you've been asked many times, and you've said you regret those comments +[2467.360 --> 2471.360] and explained you then voted for Donald Trump in 2020. +[2471.360 --> 2479.360] But the Washington Post reported new messages last week in which you also disparaged Trump's economic record while he was president, +[2479.360 --> 2486.360] writing to someone in 2020, quote, Trump thoroughly failed to deliver his economic populism. +[2486.360 --> 2491.360] Your now is running mate, and you've shifted many of your policy stances to align with his. +[2491.360 --> 2499.360] If you become vice president, why should Americans trust that you will give Donald Trump the advice he needs to hear? +[2499.360 --> 2503.360] And not just the advice he wants to hear. You have two minutes. +[2503.360 --> 2505.360] Well, first of all, Margaret, because I've always been open. +[2505.360 --> 2511.360] And sometimes, of course, I've disagreed with the president, but I've also been extremely open about the fact that I was wrong about Donald Trump. +[2511.360 --> 2517.360] I was wrong, first of all, because I believed some of the media stories that turned out to be denissed on as fabrications of his record, +[2517.360 --> 2521.360] but most importantly, Donald Trump delivered for the American people. +[2521.360 --> 2527.360] Rising wages, rising take-home pay, an economy that worked for normal Americans, a secure southern border, +[2527.360 --> 2530.360] a lot of things, frankly, that I didn't think he'd be able to deliver on. +[2530.360 --> 2536.360] And yeah, when you screw up, when you misspeak, when you get something wrong, and you change your mind, you ought to be honest with the American people about it. +[2536.360 --> 2542.360] It's one of the reasons, Margaret, why I've done so many interviews is because I think it's important to actually explain to the American people +[2542.360 --> 2544.360] where I come down on the issues and what change. +[2544.360 --> 2546.360] Now, you pointed out to messages from 2020. +[2546.360 --> 2553.360] Margaret, I've been extremely consistent that I think there were a lot of things that we could have done better in the Trump administration, the first round, +[2553.360 --> 2555.360] if Congress was doing its job. +[2555.360 --> 2561.360] I strongly believe, and I've been a United States Senator, that Congress is not just a high-class debating society. +[2561.360 --> 2566.360] It's not just a forum for senators and congressmen to wind about problems. It's a forum to govern. +[2566.360 --> 2578.360] So there were a lot of things on the border, on tariffs, for example, where I think that we could have done so much more if the Republican Congress and the Democrats in Congress had been a little bit better about how they govern the country. +[2578.360 --> 2581.360] They were so obsessed with impeaching Donald Trump, they couldn't actually govern. +[2581.360 --> 2589.360] And I want to talk about this tariff issue in particular, Margaret, because Tim just accused this of being a national sales tax. +[2589.360 --> 2600.360] Look, the one thing, and you're probably surprised to hear me praising Joe Biden, but the one thing that Joe Biden did is he continued some of the Trump tariffs that protected American manufacturing jobs. +[2600.360 --> 2604.360] And it's the one issue, the most pro-worker part of the Biden administration. +[2604.360 --> 2609.360] It's the one issue where Kamala Harris has run away from Joe Biden's record. +[2609.360 --> 2626.360] Think about this. If you're trying to employ slave laborers in China at $3 a day, you're going to do that and undercut the wages of American workers unless our country stands up for itself and says you're not accessing our markets unless you're paying middle class Americans a fair wage. +[2626.360 --> 2631.360] Senator, your time is up. Nora, thank you. Now to the issue of reproductive rights. +[2631.360 --> 2642.360] Governor Walls, after Roe versus Wade was overturned, you signed a bill into law that made Minnesota one of the least restrictive states in the nation when it comes to abortion. +[2642.360 --> 2651.360] Former President Trump said in the last debate that you believe abortion, quote, in the ninth month is absolutely fine. +[2651.360 --> 2654.360] Yes or no, is that what you support? I'll give you two minutes. +[2654.360 --> 2670.360] This is not what the bill says, but look, this, this issue is what's on everyone's mind. Donald Trump put this all into motion. He brags about how great it was that he put the judges in and overturned Roe versus Wade 52 years of personal autonomy. +[2670.360 --> 2678.360] And then he tells us, oh, we send it to the states. It's a beautiful thing. Amanda Zorowski would disagree with you on it's a beautiful thing. +[2678.360 --> 2689.360] A young bride in Texas waiting for their child at 18 weeks, she has a complication, a tear in the membrane, she needs to go in the medical care at that point needs to be decided by the doctor. +[2689.360 --> 2706.360] And that would have been an abortion, but in Texas, that would have put them in legal jeopardy. She went home, got sepsis nearly dies and now she may have difficulty having children or in Kentucky, had Lee DuVol, a 12 year old child rape and impregnated by her stepfather. +[2706.360 --> 2719.360] Those are horrific. Now, when God asked about that, Senator Vant said, two wrongs don't make a right. There is no right in this. So in Minnesota, what we did was restore Roe versus Wade. +[2719.360 --> 2729.360] We made sure that we put women in charge of their health care. But look, this is not where if you don't know Amanda or a Hadley, you soon will. +[2729.360 --> 2747.360] Their project 2025 is going to have a registry of pregnancies. It's going to make it more difficult, if not impossible, to get contraception and limit access, if not eliminate access to infertility treatments for so many of you out there listening, me included infertility treatments or why you have a child. +[2747.360 --> 2776.360] That's nobody else's business, but those things are being proposed. And the catch all on this is, is well, the states will decide what's right for Texas might not be right for Washington. That's not how this works. This is basic human right. We have seen maternal mortality skyrocket in Texas, outpacing many other countries in the world. This is about health care in Minnesota. We are ranked first in health care for a reason. We trust women, we trust doctors. +[2776.360 --> 2781.360] Senator, do you want to respond to the governor's claim? Will you create a federal pregnancy monitoring agency? +[2781.360 --> 2791.360] No, no, certainly we won't. And I want to talk about this issue because I know a lot of Americans care about it. I know a lot of Americans don't agree with everything that I've ever said on this topic. +[2791.360 --> 2802.360] I grew up in a working class family in a neighborhood where I knew a lot of young women who had unplanned pregnancies and decided to terminate those pregnancies because they feel like they didn't have any other options. +[2802.360 --> 2817.360] And one of them is actually very dear to me. And I know she's watching tonight and I love you. And she told me something a couple years ago that she felt like if she hadn't had that abortion, that it would have destroyed her life because she was an abusive relationship. +[2817.360 --> 2835.360] And I think that what I take from that as a Republican who proudly wants to protect innocent life in this country, who proudly wants to protect the vulnerable, is that my party we've got to do so much better of a job at earning the American people's trust back on this issue where they frankly just don't trust us. +[2835.360 --> 2844.360] And I think that's one of the things that Donald Trump and I are endeavoring to do. I want us as a Republican party to be pro family in the fullest sense of the word. +[2844.360 --> 2855.360] And I want us to support fertility treatments. I want us to make it easier for moms to afford to have babies. I want it to make it easier for young families to afford a home so they can afford a place to raise that family. +[2855.360 --> 2869.360] And I think there's so much that we can do on the public policy front just to give women more options. Now, of course, Donald Trump has been very clear that on the abortion policy specifically that we have a big country and it's diverse. +[2869.360 --> 2885.360] And I think that the California has a different viewpoint on this than Georgia. Georgia has a different viewpoint from Arizona and the proper way to handle this as messy as democracy sometimes is is to let voters make these decisions, let the individual states make their abortion policy. +[2885.360 --> 2893.360] And I think that's what makes the most sense in a very big, a very diverse and let's be honest, sometimes a very, very messy and divided country. +[2893.360 --> 2906.360] Governor, would you like to respond and also answer the question about restrictions? Yeah, well, the question got asked and Donald Trump made the accusation that wasn't true about Minnesota. Well, let me tell you about this idea that there's diverse states. +[2906.360 --> 2922.360] There's a young woman named Amber Thurman. She happened to be in Georgia, a restrictive state. Because of that, she had to travel a long distance to North Carolina to try and get her care. Amber Thurman died in that journey back and forth. +[2922.360 --> 2934.360] The fact of the matter is, how can we as a nation say that your life and your rights as basic as the right to control your own body is determined on geography. +[2934.360 --> 2949.360] There's a very real chance. Had Amber Thurman lived in Minnesota, she would be alive today. That's why the restoration of Roe versus Wade. When you listen to Vice President Harris talk about this subject and you hear me talk about it, you hear us talking exactly the same. +[2949.360 --> 2959.360] Donald Trump is trying to figure out how to get the political right of this. I agree with a lot of what Senator Van said about what's happening. His running mate though does not and that's the problem. +[2959.360 --> 2970.360] Governor, your time is up. Senator, let me ask you about that. He mentioned, I think referring to a national ban. In the past, you have supported a federal ban on abortion after 15 weeks. +[2970.360 --> 2980.360] If you said if someone can't support legislation like that, quote, you are making the United States the most barbaric pro abortion regime anywhere in the entire world. +[2980.360 --> 2991.360] My question is, why have you changed your position? Well, Laura, first of all, I never supported a national ban. I did during what I was running for Senate in 2022 talk about setting some minimum national standard. +[2991.360 --> 2999.360] For example, we have a partial birth abortion ban in this in place in this country at the federal level. I don't think anybody's trying to get rid of that or at least I hope not. +[2999.360 --> 3008.360] Though I know that Democrats have taken a very radical pro abortion stance, but Nora, you know, one of the things that's changed is in the state of Ohio, we had a referendum in 2023. +[3008.360 --> 3018.360] And the people of Ohio voted overwhelmingly by the way against my position. And I think that what I learned from that Nora is that we've got to do a better job at winning back people's trust. +[3018.360 --> 3028.360] So many young women would love to have families. So many young women also see an unplanned pregnancy as something that's going to destroy their livelihood, destroy their education, destroy their relationships. +[3028.360 --> 3043.360] And we have got to earn people's trust back. And that's why Donald Trump and I are committed to pursuing pro family policies, making childcare more accessible, making fertility treatments more accessible because we've got to do a better job at that. And that's what real leadership is. +[3043.360 --> 3055.360] Governor, your response. Well, I'm going to respond on the on the pro abortion piece of that. No, we're not. We're pro women. We're pro freedom to make your own choice. We know what the implications are to not be that. +[3055.360 --> 3070.360] Women having miscarriages, women not getting the care physicians feeling like they may be prosecuted for providing that care. And as far as making sure that we're educating our children and giving them options, Minnesota is a state to one of the lowest teen pregnancy rates. +[3070.360 --> 3080.360] We understand that too. We know that the options need to be available and we make that true. We also make it. We're a top three state for the best place to raise children. +[3080.360 --> 3088.360] But these two things to try and say that we're pro children, but we don't like this or you guys are pro abortion. That's not the case at all. +[3088.360 --> 3098.360] We are pro freedoms for women to make their choices. And we're going and Kamala Harris is making the case to make options for children more affordable, a $6,000 child tax credit. +[3098.360 --> 3105.360] But we're not going to base on on the backs of making someone like Amber Thurman drive 600 miles to try and get health care. Senator. +[3105.360 --> 3112.360] May I respond to that? First of all, Governor, I agree with you. Amber Thurman should still be alive. And there are a lot of people who should still be alive. And I certainly wish that she was. +[3112.360 --> 3133.360] And maybe you're free to disagree with me on this and explain this to me. But as I read the Minnesota law that you signed into law, the statute that you signed into law, it says that a doctor who presides over an abortion where the baby survives, the doctor is under no obligation to provide life saving care to a baby who survives a botched late term abortion. +[3133.360 --> 3151.360] That is, I think, what is your pro choice or pro pro that is fundamentally barbaric. And that's why I use that word. Nor is because some of what we've seen. Do you want to force Catholic hospitals to perform abortions against their will? Because Kamala Harris is supported suing Catholic nuns to violate their freedom of conscience. +[3151.360 --> 3159.360] We can be a big and diverse country where we respect people's freedom of conscience and make the country more pro baby and pro family. But please. +[3159.360 --> 3175.360] Governor, please respond. Look, this is one where there's always something that this is a very simple proposition. These are women's decisions to make about their health care decisions and the physicians who know best when they need to do this trying to distort the way a law is written to try and make a point. That's not it. +[3175.360 --> 3186.360] What was I wrong about governor? Please tell me what was that? That is not the way the law is written. Look, I've given how I've given this advice on a lot of things that getting involved getting you gets. That's been misread and it was fact checked at the last debate. +[3186.360 --> 3204.360] But the point on this is is there's a continuation of these guys to try and tell women or to get involved. I use this line on this. Just mind your own business on this. Things work best when Roe versus Wade was in place. When we do a restoration of Roe, that works best. That doesn't preclude us from increasing funding. +[3204.360 --> 3224.360] For children, it doesn't increase us from making sure that once that child is born like in Minnesota, they get meals. They get early childhood education. They get health care. So the hiding behind we're going to do all these other things when you're not proposing them in your budget, camel Harris is proposing them. She's proposing all those things to make life easier for families. +[3224.360 --> 3233.360] I asked a specific question governor. You gave me a slogan as a response. It's not the case. It's not true. That's not what the law says. So yeah, fact checked it with President Trump. +[3233.360 --> 3241.360] Gentlemen, there's a lot to discuss. We have to move on and we're going to be right back with much more of the CBS News vice presidential debate in just a moment. +[3254.360 --> 3280.360] Welcome back to the CBS News vice presidential debate. We want to turn now to America's gun violence epidemic. The leading cause of death for children and teens in America is by firearms. +[3280.360 --> 3293.360] Senator Vance, you oppose most gun legislation that Democrats claim would curb gun violence. You oppose red flag gun laws and legislation to ban certain semi automatic rifles, including AR 15s. +[3293.360 --> 3309.360] So let me ask you earlier this year for the first time, the parents of a school shooter were convicted of involuntary manslaughter and sentenced to 10 years in prison. Do you think holding parents responsible could curb mass shootings? I'll give you two minutes. +[3309.360 --> 3319.360] Yeah, well, no, we're all in that particular case. I don't know the full details, but I certainly trust local law enforcement and local authorities to make those decisions. I think in some cases, the answer is going to be yes. And some cases, the answer is going to be no. +[3319.360 --> 3328.360] And the details really matter here, of course, for example, if a kid steals a gun, that's going to be different than if a parent hands over a gun knowing that their kid is potentially dangerous. +[3328.360 --> 3342.360] Look, I want to just sort of speak as a father of three beautiful little kids and our oldest is now in second grade. And like a lot of parents, we send our kids to school with such hope and such joy and such pride at their little faces on the first day of school. +[3342.360 --> 3353.360] And we know, unfortunately, that a lot of kids are going to experience this terrible epidemic of gun violence. And of course, our hearts go out to the families that are affected by this terrible stuff. And we do have to do better. +[3353.360 --> 3359.360] And I think that Governor Waltson, I actually probably agree that we need to do better on this. The question is just how do we actually do it? +[3359.360 --> 3382.360] Now, here, here's something that really bothers me and worries me about this epidemic of violence, the gross majority close to 90% and some of the statistics I've seen of the gun violence in this country is committed with illegally obtained firearms. And while we're on that topic, we know that thanks to Kamala Harris's open border, we've seen a massive influx and the number of illegal guns run by the Mexican drug cartels. +[3382.360 --> 3402.360] So that number, the amount of illegal guns in our country is higher today than it was three and a half years ago. But what do we do about the schools? What do we do to protect our kids? And I think the answer is, and I say this, not loving the answer, because I don't want my kids to go to school and a school that feels unsafe or where there are visible signs of security. +[3402.360 --> 3419.360] But I unfortunately think that we have to increase security in our schools. We have to make the doors lock better. We have to make the doors stronger. We've got to make the windows stronger. And of course, we've got to increase school resource officers because the idea that we can magically wave a wand and take guns out of the hands of bad guys. +[3419.360 --> 3427.360] It just doesn't fit with recent experience. So we've got to make our schools safer. And I think we've got to have some common sense bipartisan solutions for how to do that. +[3427.360 --> 3429.360] Governor, you have two minutes. +[3429.360 --> 3442.360] Well, I think all the parents watching tonight. This is this your biggest nightmare. Look, I got a, I got a 17 year old and, and he witnessed a shooting at a community center playing volleyball. Those things don't leave you as a member of Congress. +[3442.360 --> 3455.360] I set in my office surrounded by dozens of the Sandiuk parents and they were looking at my seven year old picture on the wall. Their seven year old were dead. And they were asking us to do something. And look, I'm a hunter. +[3455.360 --> 3464.360] I own firearms device president is we understand that the second amendment is there, but our first responsibilities to our kids to figure this out in Minnesota. +[3464.360 --> 3479.360] We've enacted enhanced red flag laws enhanced background checks and we can start to get data. But here's the problem. If we really want to solve this, we've got folks that won't allow research to be even done on gun violence. +[3479.360 --> 3494.360] And this idea that we should just live with it. And I, and I, here's what I do think that this is a good start to the conversation. I 100% believe that Senator Vance hates it when these kids, it's, it's a warrant and it breaks your heart. I, I agree with that. +[3494.360 --> 3506.360] But it's, that's not far enough when we know there are things that work. I've spent time in Finland and seen some finished schools. They don't have this happened, even though they have a high gun ownership rate in the country. +[3506.360 --> 3518.360] There are reasonable things that we can do to make a difference. It's not infringing on your second amendment. And the idea to have some of these weapons out there, it just doesn't make any sense. +[3518.360 --> 3528.360] Kamala Harris as an attorney general worked on this issue. She knows that it's there. No one's trying to scare monger and say we're taking your guns, but I ask all of you out there. +[3528.360 --> 3552.360] Do you want your schools hardened to look like a fort? Is that, is that what we have to go when we know there's countries around the world that their children aren't practicing these types of drills. They're being kids. We owe it to them to get a fix. These are things that shouldn't be that difficult. You can still keep your firearms and we can make a difference. We have to. If you're listening tonight, this breaks your heart. +[3552.360 --> 3581.360] Tim, first of all, I didn't know that you're 17 year old witness is shooting. I'm sorry about that. And I appreciate it. Christ have mercy. It is, it is awful. And I appreciate what Tim said actually about Finland, because I do think it illustrates some of the frankly weird differences between our own country's gun violence problem and Finland is, okay, first of all, we have way higher rates of mental health abuse or mental health substance abuse. We have way higher rates of depression, way higher rates of anxiety. +[3581.360 --> 3609.360] We unfortunately have a mental health crisis in this country that I really do think that we need to get to the root causes of because I don't think it's the whole reason why we have such a bad gun violence problem, but I do think it's a big piece of it. Another driver of the gun violence epidemic, especially that affecting our kids, it doesn't earn as many headlines, but is the terrible gun violence problem and a lot of our big cities. And this is why we have to empower law enforcement to arrest the bad guys, put them away and take gun offenders off the streets. +[3609.360 --> 3615.360] I think it's a whole host of things that we can do here, but I do think that our schools we've got to talk about more security. +[3615.360 --> 3622.360] Senator, thank you, Governor. You previously opposed an assault weapons ban, but it only later in your political career, did you change your position? Why? +[3622.360 --> 3637.360] Yeah, I sat in that office with those Sandihoek parents. I've become friends with school shooters. I've seen it. Look, the NRA, I was the NRA guy for a long time. They used to teach gun safety. I'm of an age where my shotgun was in my car, so I could fesson hunt after football practice. That's not what we live today. +[3637.360 --> 3648.360] And several things I want to mention on this is talking about cities and where it's at, the number one, where the most firearm deaths happen in Minnesota are rural suicides. +[3648.360 --> 3661.360] And we have an epidemic of children getting guns and shooting themselves. And so we have, and we should look at all of the issues, making sure folks have health care and all that, but I want to be very careful. +[3661.360 --> 3675.360] This idea of stigmatizing mental health, just because you have a mental health issue doesn't mean you're violent. And I think what we end up doing is we start looking for a scapegoat, sometimes it just is the guns. It's just the guns and there are things that you can do about it. +[3675.360 --> 3685.360] But I do think that this is one, and I think this is a healthy conversation. I think there's a capacity to find solutions on this that work, protect Second Amendment, protect our children. That's our priority. +[3685.360 --> 3694.360] Gentlemen, thank you, Margaret. Thank you, Nora. Let's turn now to the top contributor to inflation, the high cost of housing and rent. +[3694.360 --> 3701.360] There's a shortage of more than four million homes in the United States, and that contributes to the high housing prices. +[3701.360 --> 3716.360] Governor Walls, the Harris campaign promises a $25,000 down payment assistance for first time home buyers and a $10,000 tax credit. They also promise to build three million new homes. +[3716.360 --> 3722.360] Where are you building these homes and won't handing out that kind of money just drive up prices higher? +[3722.360 --> 3733.360] No, it's not handing out. We have first, let me say this, this issue of housing. And I think those of you listening on this, the problem we've had is that we've got a lot of folks that see housing as another commodity. +[3733.360 --> 3743.360] It can be bought up. It can be shifted. It can be moved around. Those are not folks living in those houses. Those of you listening tonight, that house a big deal. I bought and owned one house in my life. +[3743.360 --> 3763.360] My mom still lives in the house where I was. And when I think of a house, I'm thinking of Christmas services after midnight mass, where you go with your family. We need to make it more affordable. And one of the things, as I said, this program that the vice president is pushing forward and bringing a new way of approaching this is something we're doing in Minnesota from that lead. +[3763.360 --> 3779.360] We in the state invested in making sure our housing was the biggest investment that we'd ever made in housing. It starts to make it easier. We cut some of the red tape local folks look we can't do at the federal level, but local folks make it easier to build those homes. And then that down payment assistance. I can tell all of you out there. +[3779.360 --> 3800.360] And one of the certainly for me using the GI bill was one thing, but a veterans home loan. The big thing about a veteran's home loan is you don't have to pay the down payment. Those are things that make it there. Now look, you're going to pay it back. And you're going to pay your mortgage. Those are things that we know in the long run, the appreciated value, the general wealth that's created from it. +[3800.360 --> 3814.360] And we'll give miniapolis an example. Miniapolis is the one city where we've seen the lowest inflation rates. We've seen a 12% increase in stock because we've put some of these things in and we're implementing a state program to make sure we give some of that down payment assistance. +[3814.360 --> 3827.360] We get it back from people because here's what we know. People with staple housing end up with stable jobs. People with stable housing have their kids able to be able to get to school. All of those things in the long run end up saving our money. +[3827.360 --> 3848.360] And that's the thing that I think we should be able to find some common ground in, but we can't blame immigrants for the only reason. That's not the case. It's happening in many cities. The fact of the matter is is that we don't have enough naturally affording affordable housing, but we can make sure that the government's there to help kickstart it, create that, create that base. +[3848.360 --> 3864.360] Governor, your time is up. Senator Vance, as far as your campaigns position, the promise is to seize federal lands to build homes, remove regulation, provide tax breaks and cut back on immigration, which you say pushes up prices. +[3864.360 --> 3872.360] Where are you going to build all the new homes you're promising? And what part of any of this plan will provide immediate relief? You have two minutes. +[3872.360 --> 3901.360] Well, first of all, Tim just said something that I agree with. We don't want to blame immigrants for higher housing prices, but we do want to blame Kamala Harris for letting in millions of illegal aliens into this country, which does drive up cost him 25 million illegal aliens competing with Americans for scarce homes is one of the most significant drivers of home prices in the country. It's why we have massive increases in home prices that have happened right alongside massive increases in illegal. +[3901.360 --> 3917.360] And legally, alien populations under Kamala Harris's leadership now, Tim just mentioned a bunch of ideas now some of those ideas actually think are halfway decent and some of them I disagree with, but the most important thing here is Kamala Harris is not running as a newcomer to politics. +[3917.360 --> 3935.360] And the most important thing is the sitting vice president if she wants to enact all of these policies to make housing more affordable, I invite her to use the office that the American people already gave her not sit around and campaign and do nothing while Americans find the American dream of homeownership completely unaffordable. +[3935.360 --> 3958.360] You asked Margaret what would immediately change the equation for American citizens if you lower energy prices as Donald Trump says drill baby drill one of the biggest drivers of housing costs aside from illegal immigration is think about it if a truck drivers paying 40% more for diesel than the lumber he's delivering to the job site to build the house is also going to become a lot more expensive. +[3958.360 --> 3969.360] So when you open up American energy, you will get immediate pricing release relief for American citizens, not by the way just in housing, but in a whole host of other economic goods too. +[3969.360 --> 3980.360] Senator Vance, you still have 23 seconds there. Do you want to answer where a governor we will get to you in a moment, but Senator, where are you going to seize the federal lands? Can you clarify? +[3980.360 --> 3989.360] So what Donald Trump has said is we have a lot of federal lands that aren't being used for anything, they're not being used for national park, they're not being used and they could be places where we build a lot of housing. +[3989.360 --> 4005.360] And I do think that we should be opening up building in this country. We have a lot of land that could be used, we have a lot of Americans that need homes, we should be kicking out illegal immigrants who are competing for those homes and we should be building more homes for the American citizens who deserve to be here. +[4005.360 --> 4013.360] So I'm going to share your time as governor, I do want to let you respond to the allegation that the vice president is letting in. +[4013.360 --> 4023.360] Of course, that's true and again, you have the facts, I guess we agreed not to fact check, I'll check it that look, crossings are down compared to when Donald Trump left office, but it's again blaming and not trying to find the solution. +[4023.360 --> 4032.360] I was going to ask on this question, are we going to drill and build houses in the same federal land? And I think when people here, federal lands, these are really important pieces of land. +[4032.360 --> 4040.360] This soda doesn't have a lot of federal lands, I know in the western part of the countries we do. There's not a lot of federal lands in and around Minneapolis, for example. +[4040.360 --> 4050.360] So the issue is, I don't understand the federal lands issue unless we see this and I worry about this is someone who cares deeply about our national parks and our federal lands look Minnesota, we protect these things. +[4050.360 --> 4056.360] We've got about 20% of the world's fresh water. These lands protect, they're there for a reason, they belong to all of us. +[4056.360 --> 4062.360] But again, this is when you view housing and you view these things as commodities, like there's a chance to make money here. +[4062.360 --> 4072.360] Let's take this federal land and let's sell it to people for that. I think there's better ways to do this. We've seen it in Minnesota, we're able to refurbish some of these houses, we're able to make some investments, that gets people in. +[4072.360 --> 4081.360] And I'm still on the fact on this, economists, you send her, Ben, you said you don't like the economists, which economists are saying that it is immigrants that's adding to the call. +[4081.360 --> 4091.360] Governor, Governor, your time is up, but Senator, on that point, I'd like for you to clarify, there are many contributing factors to high housing costs. +[4091.360 --> 4096.360] What evidence do you have that migrants are part of this problem? +[4096.360 --> 4108.360] Well, there's a federal reserve study that we're happy to share after the debate. We'll put it up on social media actually that really drills down on the connection between increased levels of migration, especially illegal immigration and higher housing prices. +[4108.360 --> 4115.360] Now, of course, Margaret, that's not the entire driver of higher housing prices. It's also the regulatory regime of Kamala Harris. +[4115.360 --> 4135.360] Look, we are a country of builders, we're a country of doers, we're a country of explorers. But we increasingly have a federal administration that makes it harder to develop our resources, makes it harder to build things, and wants to throw people in jail for not doing everything exactly as Kamala Harris says they have to do. +[4135.360 --> 4153.360] And what that means is that you have a lot of people who would love to build homes, who aren't able to build homes. I actually agree with Tim Waltz, we should get out of this idea of housing as a commodity, but the thing that is most turn housing into a commodity is giving it away to millions upon millions of people who have no legal right to be here. +[4153.360 --> 4156.360] What are the federal regulations? Ideal with this is a governor. +[4156.360 --> 4158.360] You can very quickly reply. +[4158.360 --> 4171.360] I'm sorry, I get this as a governor, and I don't necessarily disagree with that that in some cases many of those are local, many of them are state. I don't know which ones are federal, but I think whenever we talk regulations, people think they can get rid of them. +[4171.360 --> 4183.360] I think you want to be able to get out of your house in a fire. I think you want to make sure that it's fireproof and those types of things, so which are the regulations? Because the vice president's not responsible for those Congress rights those. +[4183.360 --> 4197.360] Governor, thank you, gentlemen. We have a lot to get through. You're passionate about the housing crisis. I can tell, but Nora, thank you. One of the top problems facing Americans is the high cost of health care, Senator Vance. +[4197.360 --> 4207.360] At the last presidential debate, former president Trump was asked about replacing the Affordable Care Act. In response, he said, I have concepts of a plan. +[4207.360 --> 4222.360] Since then, Senator, you've talked about changing how chronically ill Americans get health insurance. Can you explain how that would work? And can you guarantee that Americans with pre-existing conditions won't pay more? I'll give you two minutes. +[4222.360 --> 4239.360] Of course, we're going to cover Americans with pre-existing conditions. In fact, a lot of my family members have gotten health care. I believe members of my family actually got private health insurance, at least for the first time switched off of Medicaid onto private insurance for the first time under Donald Trump's leadership. +[4239.360 --> 4257.360] A lot of people have criticized this concepts of a plan remark. It gets very simple, common sense. I think as Tim Walls knows, from 12 years in Congress, you're not going to propose a 900-page bill standing on a debate stage. It would bore everybody to tears. And it wouldn't actually mean anything because part of this is the give and take of bipartisan negotiation. +[4257.360 --> 4267.360] Now, when Donald Trump was actually president, and again, he has a record to be proud of, prescription drugs fell in 2018 for the first time in a very long time, but are common with Harris' leadership. +[4267.360 --> 4286.360] Prescription drugs are up about 7%, under Donald Trump's entire four years, they were up about 1.5%. He introduced pricing transparency. You think about health care. You go into a hospital, you try to buy something, and nobody knows what it actually costs. That price transparency will actually give American consumers a little bit more choice. +[4286.360 --> 4307.360] And we'll also drive down costs. And we talked about the reinsurance regulations, is what I was talking about. Look, Donald Trump has said that if we allow states to experiment a little bit on how to cover both the chronically ill, but the non- chronically ill, it's not just a plan. He actually implemented some of these regulations when he was president of the United States. +[4307.360 --> 4314.360] And I think you can make a really good argument that it salvaged Obama care, which was doing disastrously until Donald Trump came along. +[4314.360 --> 4321.360] And I think it's an important point about President Trump. Of course, you don't have to agree with everything that President Trump has ever said or ever done. +[4321.360 --> 4335.360] But when Obama care was crushing under the weight of its own regulatory burden and health care costs, Donald Trump could have destroyed the program. Instead, he worked in a bipartisan way to ensure that Americans had access to affordable care. +[4335.360 --> 4347.360] It's not perfect, of course, and there's so much more that we can do. But I think that Donald Trump has earned the right to put in place some better health care policies. He's earned it because he did it successfully the first time. +[4347.360 --> 4348.360] Governor. +[4348.360 --> 4354.360] All right, here's where being an old guy gives you some history. I was there at the creation of the ACA. +[4354.360 --> 4365.360] And the reason it was so important is I come from a major health care state, home of the Mayo Clinic, home to medical alley, 3M, Medtronic, all of those. +[4365.360 --> 4376.360] We understand health care. It's why we're ranked first on affordability and accessibility and quality of health care. And so what I know is under Kamala Harris, more people are covered than they have before. +[4376.360 --> 4389.360] And those of you listening, this is critical to you. Now, Donald Trump, all of a sudden, wants to go back and remember this. He ran on the first thing he was going to do on day one was to repeal Obamacare on day one. +[4389.360 --> 4406.360] He tried to sign an executive order to repeal the ACA. He signed on to a lawsuit to repeal the ACA, but lost at the Supreme Court. And he would have repealed the ACA had it not been for the courage of John McCain to save that bill. +[4406.360 --> 4417.360] Now fast forward what that means to you is you lose your preexisting conditions. If you're setting at home and you got asthma too bad, if you're a woman, probably not broke your foot during football might kick you out. +[4417.360 --> 4437.360] Your kids get kicked out when they're 26. Kamala Harris negotiated drug prices for the first time with Medicare. We have 10 drugs that will come online, the most common ones that'll be there. But look, this issue. And when Donald Trump said, I've got a concept of a plan. It cracked me up as a fourth grade teacher because my kids would have never given me that. +[4437.360 --> 4452.360] But what Senator Vance just explained might be worse than a concept because what he explained is pre Obamacare. And I'll make this as simple as possible because I have done this for a long time. What they're saying is, if you're healthy, why should you be paying more? +[4452.360 --> 4463.360] So what they're going to do is let insurance companies pick who they ensure because guess what happens? You pay your premium. It's not much. They're figured they're not going to have to pay out to you. But those of you a little older gray. +[4463.360 --> 4471.360] You don't got cancer. You're going to get kicked out of it. That's why the system didn't work. Kamala Harris will protect and enhance the ACA. +[4471.360 --> 4478.360] Governor, thank you. Senator, you have not yet explained how you would protect people with pre existing conditions or laid out that plan. +[4478.360 --> 4484.360] Well, look, we currently have laws and regulations in the place in place right now that protect people with pre existing conditions. +[4484.360 --> 4490.360] We want to keep those regulations in place, but we also want to make the health insurance marketplace function a little bit better. +[4490.360 --> 4500.360] Now, what Governor Walts just said is actually not true. A lot of what happened in the reason that Obamacare was crushing under its own weight is that a lot of young and healthy people were leaving the exchanges. +[4500.360 --> 4509.360] Donald Trump actually helped address that problem. And he did so in a way that preserved people's access to coverage who had pre existing conditions. +[4509.360 --> 4519.360] But again, something that these guys do is they make a lot of claims about if Donald Trump becomes president, all of these terrible consequences are going to ensue. +[4519.360 --> 4532.360] But in reality, Donald Trump was president. Inflation was low. Take home pay was higher. And he saved the very program from a Democratic administration that was collapsing and would have collapsed absent his leadership. +[4532.360 --> 4540.360] He did his job, which is governed in a bipartisan way and get results, not just complain about problems, but actually solve them. +[4540.360 --> 4545.360] Governor, did enrollment under the Affordable Care Act go up under the Trump administration? +[4545.360 --> 4553.360] It's higher now that we've seen it go up. Look, people are using it. The system works. And the question about this, of young people, whatever, that's the individual mandate piece of this. +[4553.360 --> 4560.360] And Republicans fought tooth and nail saying, well, Americans should be free to do this. Well, then what happened is that the individual mandate is a good idea. +[4560.360 --> 4575.360] I think the idea of making sure the risk pool is broad enough to cover everyone. That's the only way insurance works. When it doesn't, it collapses. You are asking pre-ACA where we get people out. Look, people know that they need to be on health care. +[4575.360 --> 4587.360] People expect it to be there. And when we are able to make it and we are making it this way, when we incentivize people to be in the market, when we help people who might not be able to afford it, get there. +[4587.360 --> 4597.360] And we make sure then when you get sick and old, it's there for you. Because I heard people say, well, I don't want to buy into Medicare, whatever. Good luck buying health care once you get past 70. +[4597.360 --> 4607.360] So look, the ACA works. We can continue to do better. Kamala Harris did that. The way she made everything better was negotiating those 10 drugs on Medicare for the first time in American history. +[4607.360 --> 4608.360] Thank you. Margaret. +[4608.360 --> 4615.360] I apologize. We're out of time. We have a number of subjects to discuss. Margaret, let's talk about families in America. +[4615.360 --> 4628.360] There is a childcare crisis in this country. And the United States is one of the very few developed countries in the world without a national paid leave program for new parents. +[4628.360 --> 4635.360] Governor Walls, you said that if Democrats win both the White House and Congress, this is a day one priority for you. +[4635.360 --> 4642.360] How long should employers be required to pay workers while they are home taking care of their newborns? You have two minutes. +[4642.360 --> 4647.360] Yeah, well, that's negotiable. And that's what Congress worked. But here's what the deal is. +[4647.360 --> 4654.360] American setting out there right now. You may work for a big company. Look, we're home in Minnesota to some of the largest fortune 500 companies. +[4654.360 --> 4663.360] Kamala Harris knows that and call are in California. Those companies provide paid family medically. One is, I think they're moral and they think it's a good thing. +[4663.360 --> 4673.360] But it also keeps their employees healthy. We in Minnesota passed a paid family and medical leave. You have a child, you. And I had to go back to work five days after my kids were born. +[4673.360 --> 4681.360] This allows you to stay home a certain amount of time. What we know is that gets the child off to a better start. The family works better. We stay in their employers. +[4681.360 --> 4687.360] We get more consistency in that. So Kamala Harris has made it a priority. We implemented in Minnesota and we see growth. +[4687.360 --> 4695.360] That's how you become a pro business state, but the negotiations on it. And here's the issue. Those big companies are able to offer it. +[4695.360 --> 4703.360] Those of you out there who don't have it. Just imagine what happens if you get cancer or your child gets sick. We know what happens. +[4703.360 --> 4714.360] You end up staying home in some places that that means no paycheck because you've got no protection on that. This is the case of an economy that Donald Trump has set for the wealthiest amongst us. +[4714.360 --> 4726.360] He's willing to give those tax breaks to the wealthiest. He's willing to say, bus those unions up do whatever. What we're saying is the economy works best when it works for all of us. +[4726.360 --> 4734.360] And so a paid family medical leave program and I will tell you go to the families or go to the businesses and ask them as far as child care on this. +[4734.360 --> 4744.360] You have to take it at both the supply and the demand side. You can't expect the most important people in our lives to take either our children or our parents to get paid the least amount of money. +[4744.360 --> 4751.360] And we have to make it easier for folks to be able to get into that business and then to make sure that folks are able to pay for that. +[4751.360 --> 4757.360] We were able to do it in Minnesota and I'm still telling you this. We were listed as the best state. We're still in crisis on this. +[4757.360 --> 4765.360] A federal program of paid family medical leave and help with this will enhance our workforce enhance our families and make it easier to have the children that you want. +[4765.360 --> 4779.360] Governor, your time is up. Senator, do you support a national paid leave program? And if so, for how long should employers be mandated to pay their employees while they are home taking care of their newborn? You have two minutes. +[4779.360 --> 4787.360] Well, first of all, Margaret, a number of my Republican colleagues and some Democrats too have worked on this issue. And I think there is a bipartisan solution here because a lot of us care about this issue. +[4787.360 --> 4798.360] Look, I speak from this very personally because I'm married to a beautiful woman who is an incredible mother to our three beautiful kids but is also a very, very brilliant corporate litigator. +[4798.360 --> 4806.360] And I'm so proud of her. But being a working mom, even for somebody with all of the advantages of my wife is extraordinarily difficult. +[4806.360 --> 4817.360] And it's not just difficult from a policy perspective. She actually had access to paid family leave because she worked for a bigger company, but the cultural pressure on young families and especially young women. +[4817.360 --> 4823.360] I think it makes it really hard for people to choose the family model they want. A lot of young women would like to go back to work immediately. +[4823.360 --> 4832.360] Some would like to spend a little time home with the kids. Some would like to spend longer at home with the kids. We should have a family care model that makes choice possible. +[4832.360 --> 4837.360] And I think this is a very important substantive difference between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris's approach. +[4837.360 --> 4848.360] I mean, look, if you look at the federal programs that we have the support paid family leave right now, the community development block grant, and there's another block grant program that spends a lot of money from the federal government. +[4848.360 --> 4861.360] These programs only go to one kind of childcare model. Let's say you'd like your church maybe to help you out with childcare. Maybe you live in a rural area or an urban area and you'd like to get together with families in your neighborhood to provide childcare and the way that makes them most sense. +[4861.360 --> 4870.360] You don't get access to any of these federal monies. We want to promote choice and how we deliver family care and how we promote childcare. +[4870.360 --> 4876.360] Because look, it is unacceptable. And, you know, of course, Semini, I've been on the campaign trail a lot the past seven or eight weeks. +[4876.360 --> 4885.360] And one of the biggest complaints I hear from young families is people who feel like they don't have options like they're choosing between going to work or taking care for their kids. +[4885.360 --> 4893.360] That is an incredible burden to put on American families where the only country that does it, I think we could do a heck of a lot better. +[4893.360 --> 4908.360] Senator, thank you. You have also said Senator Vance many things about the American family. The federal reserve says parents will spend nearly as much on childcare as they do on housing each month. +[4908.360 --> 4923.360] So I want to get your thoughts on this. President Trump recently said, as much as childcare is talked about as being expensive, it's relatively speaking, not very expensive compared to the kinds of numbers we'll be taking in. +[4923.360 --> 4931.360] Is President Trump committed to the $5,000 per child tax credit that you have described? You have one minute. +[4931.360 --> 4948.360] Well, what President Trump said, Margaret, I just want to defend my running mate here a little bit is that we're going to be taking in a lot of money by penalizing companies for shipping jobs overseas and penalizing countries who employ slave laborers and then ship their products back into our country and undercut the wages of American workers. +[4948.360 --> 4958.360] It's the heart of the Donald Trump economic plan. Cut taxes for American workers and American families. Cut taxes for businesses that are hiring and building companies in the United States of America. +[4958.360 --> 4964.360] But penalized companies and countries that are shipping jobs overseas. That's the heart of the economic proposal. +[4964.360 --> 4976.360] And I think what President Trump is saying is that when we bring in this additional revenue with higher economic growth, we're going to be able to provide paid family leave, childcare options that are viable and workable for a lot of American families. +[4978.360 --> 4983.360] Can you clarify how that will solve the childcare shortage? +[4984.360 --> 4993.360] Well, because as Tim said, a lot of the childcare shortage is we just don't have enough resources going into the multiple people who could be providing family care options. +[4993.360 --> 5001.360] And we're going to have to, unfortunately, look, we're going to have to spend more money. We're going to have to induce more people to want to provide childcare options for American families. +[5001.360 --> 5007.360] Because the reason it's so expensive right now is because you've got way too few people providing this very essential service. +[5008.360 --> 5014.360] Thank you, Senator. Governor Walls, your ticket also has some childcare tax credit proposals. +[5014.360 --> 5024.360] Do you think Congress will agree to the $6,000 credit for newborns and $3,000 credit for children over the age of six as your campaign has promised? +[5024.360 --> 5025.360] Is that realistic? +[5025.360 --> 5031.360] Well, if these members of Congress are listening to anybody, I can tell you. And this is the biggest issue. +[5032.360 --> 5038.360] Everybody listening tonight knows I mean, I'm sure they were shocked to hear. It's not that expensive. And let's be clear whether it's $5,000 or $6,000. +[5038.360 --> 5044.360] That plays you about three or four months. Let's be clear of where we're at on this. It's because we got out of an imbalance on this. +[5044.360 --> 5048.360] We thought we were going to get by by not paying people. I don't think Senator Vance or that and I are that far apart. +[5048.360 --> 5054.360] I'm not opposed to what he's talking about on options. We've done scholarships types of things. I think we need to be open to making the case. +[5055.360 --> 5063.360] But the issue here is the question you asked is you're not going to pay for it with these tariffs. That's just adding another $4,000 on the family and taking less. +[5063.360 --> 5070.360] So not only do they not get the money to pay for that, they're $4,000 in the whole. That's Wharton School. That's his alma mater. +[5070.360 --> 5081.360] And so I think the issue here is if those members of Congress, I can't believe they're not it. When I go to businesses, sure they'll talk about taxes sometime, but they will lead with childcare and they will lead with housing. +[5081.360 --> 5087.360] Because we know the problem is especially in a state like Minnesota, we need more workers because our economy is growing, but we need the workforce. +[5087.360 --> 5096.360] Governor, thank you. We need to move on. Nora, let's talk about the state of democracy, the top issue for Americans after the economy and inflation. +[5096.360 --> 5104.360] After the 2020 election, President Trump's campaign and others filed 62 lawsuits contesting the results. +[5104.360 --> 5113.360] Judges, including those appointed by President Trump and other Republican presidents, looked at the evidence and said there was no widespread fraud. +[5113.360 --> 5127.360] The governors of every state in the nation, Republicans and Democrats, certified the 2020 election results and sent a legal slate of electors to Congress for January 6th. +[5127.360 --> 5136.360] Senator Vance, you have said you would not have certified the last presidential election and would have asked the states to submit alternative electors. +[5136.360 --> 5148.360] That has been called unconstitutional and illegal. Would you again seek to challenge this year's election results, even if every governor certifies the results, I'll give you two minutes. +[5148.360 --> 5159.360] Well, Nora, first of all, I think that we're focused on the future. We need to figure out how to solve the inflation crisis caused by Kamala Harris' policies, make housing affordable, make groceries affordable, and that's what we're focused on. +[5159.360 --> 5165.360] But I want to answer your question because you did ask it. Look, what President Trump has said is that there were problems in 2020. +[5165.360 --> 5175.360] And my own belief is that we should fight about those issues, debate those issues peacefully in the public square, and that's all life said, and that's all that Donald Trump has said. +[5175.360 --> 5192.360] Remember, he said that on January the 6th, the protesters ought to protest peacefully. And on January the 20th, what happened? Joe Biden became the President, Donald Trump left the White House, and now, of course, unfortunately, we have all of the negative policies that have come from the Harris Biden administration. +[5192.360 --> 5202.360] I believe that we actually do have a threat to democracy in this country, but unfortunately, it's not the threat to democracy that Kamala Harris and Tim Walls want to talk about. It is the threat of censorship. +[5202.360 --> 5219.360] It's Americans casting aside lifelong friendships because of disagreements over politics. It's big technology companies silencing their fellow citizens. And it's Kamala Harris saying that rather than debate and persuade her fellow Americans, she'd like to censor people who engage in misinformation. +[5219.360 --> 5226.360] I think that is a much bigger threat to democracy than anything that we've seen in this country in the last four years, in the last 40 years. +[5226.360 --> 5235.360] Now, I'm really proud, especially given that I was raised by two lifelong blue collar Democrats to have the endorsement of Bobby Kennedy Jr. and Tulsi Gabbard. +[5235.360 --> 5242.360] Life-long leaders in the Democratic coalition, of course, they don't agree with me and Donald Trump on every issue. We don't have to agree on every issue. +[5242.360 --> 5249.360] But we're united behind a basic American first-minute principle that we ought to debate our differences. We ought to argue about them. +[5249.360 --> 5259.360] We ought to try to persuade our fellow Americans. Kamala Harris is engaged in censorship at an industrial scale. She did it during COVID. She's done it over a number of other issues. +[5259.360 --> 5268.360] And that, to me, is a much bigger threat to democracy than what Donald Trump said when he said that protesters should peacefully protest on January 6th. +[5268.360 --> 5269.360] Governor? +[5269.360 --> 5277.360] Well, I've enjoyed tonight's debate. And I think there was a lot of commonality here. And I'm sympathetic to mispeaking on things. And I think I might have with the senator. +[5277.360 --> 5284.360] Me too, ma'am. There's one. There's one though that this one is troubling to me. And I say that because I think we need to tell the story. +[5284.360 --> 5290.360] Donald Trump refused to acknowledge this. And the fact is, is that I don't think we can be the frog in the pot and let the boiling water go up. +[5290.360 --> 5295.360] He was very clear. I mean, he lost his election. And he said he didn't. +[5295.360 --> 5302.360] 140 police officers were beaten at the Capitol that day. Some with the American flag, several later died. And it wasn't just in there. +[5302.360 --> 5310.360] In Minnesota, a group gathered on the state Capitol grounds in St. Paul and said we're marching to the governor's residence and there may be casualties. +[5311.360 --> 5317.360] The only person there was my son and his dog who was rushed out crying by state police. +[5317.360 --> 5324.360] That issue and Mike Pence standing there as they were chanting, hang Mike Pence. Mike Pence made the right decision. +[5324.360 --> 5333.360] So Senator, it was adjudicated over and over and over. I worked with kids long enough to know. And I said as a football coach, sometimes you really want to win. +[5333.360 --> 5340.360] The democracy is bigger than winning an election. You shake hands and then you try and do everything you can to help the other side win. +[5340.360 --> 5346.360] That's that's what was at stake here. Now, the thing I'm most concerned about is the idea that. +[5346.360 --> 5355.360] Impresoning your your political opponents already laying the groundwork for people not accepting this and a president's words matter. +[5355.360 --> 5358.360] A president's words matter. People hear that. +[5358.360 --> 5379.360] So I think this issue of settling our differences at the ballot box, shaking hands when we lose, being honest about it, but to deny what happened on January 6th, the first time in American history that a president or anyone tried to overturn a fair election and the peaceful transfer of power. +[5379.360 --> 5392.360] And here we are four years later in the same boat. I will tell you this that when this is over, we need to shake hands this election and the winner needs to be the winner. This has got to stop. It's tearing our country apart. +[5392.360 --> 5394.360] Margaret. +[5394.360 --> 5396.360] Senator Vance, did you want to respond to that? +[5396.360 --> 5411.360] Yeah, well, look, Tim, first of all, it's really rich for democratic leaders to say that Donald Trump is a unique threat to democracy when he peacefully gave over power on January the 20th as we have done for 250 years in this country. +[5411.360 --> 5417.360] We are going to shake hands after this debate and after this election. And of course, I hope that we win and I think we're going to win. +[5417.360 --> 5424.360] But if Tim wall says the next vice president, he'll have my prayers, he'll have my best wishes and I'll have my help whenever he wants it. +[5424.360 --> 5440.360] But we have to remember that for years in this country, Democrats protested the results of elections. Hillary Clinton in 2016 said that Donald Trump had the election stolen by Vladimir Putin because the Russians bought like $500,000 worth of Facebook ads. +[5440.360 --> 5453.360] This has been going on for a long time. And if we want to say that we need to respect the results of the election, I'm on board. But if we want to say, as Tim wall is saying that this is just a problem that Republicans have had, I don't buy that. +[5453.360 --> 5465.360] Governor January 6 was not Facebook ads. And I think of revisionist history on this look, I don't understand how we got to this point. But the issue was that happened. +[5465.360 --> 5478.360] Donald Trump can do it. And all of us say there's no place for this. It has massive repercussions. This idea that there's censorship to stop people from doing threatening to kill someone, threatening to do something. That's not that's not censorship. +[5478.360 --> 5490.360] censorship is book banning. We've seen that. We've seen that brought up. I just think for everyone tonight. And I'm going to thank Senator Bans. I think this is the conversation they want to hear. +[5490.360 --> 5507.360] And I think there's a lot of agreement. This is one that we are miles apart on. This was a threat to our democracy in a way that we had not seen. And it manifested itself because of Donald Trump's inability to say he is still saying he didn't lose the election. I would just ask that. Did he lose the 2020 election? +[5507.360 --> 5518.360] Tim, I'm focused on the future. Did Kamala Harris censor Americans from speaking their mind and the wake of the 2020 COVID situation? That is a damning that is a damning non answer. +[5518.360 --> 5531.360] It's a damning non answer for you to not talk about censorship. Obviously Donald Trump and I think that there were problems in 2020. We've talked about it. I'm happy to talk about it further. But you guys attack us for not believing in democracy. +[5531.360 --> 5559.360] The most sacred right under the United States democracy is the first amendment. You yourself have said there's no first amendment right to misinformation. Kamala Harris wants to threaten the power of government and big tech to silence people from speaking their minds. That is a threat to democracy that will long outlive this present political moment. I would like Democrats and Republicans to both reject censorship. Let's persuade one another. Let's argue about ideas and then let's come together afterwards. You can't. +[5559.360 --> 5569.360] You know, fire in a crowded theater. That's that's the test. That's the Supreme Court test. Tim, fire in a crowded theater. You guys wanted to kick people off of Facebook for saying that Toddler should. +[5569.360 --> 5577.360] Senator, the governor does have the floor fire in a crowded theater. That is criticizing the policies of the government, which is the right of every American. +[5577.360 --> 5605.360] Senator, the governor does have the floor for one minute to onto you. Yeah, well, I don't run Facebook. What I do know is is I see a candidate out there who refused. And now again, and this I'm pretty shocked by this. He lost the election. This is not a debate. It's not it's it's not anything anywhere other than in Donald Trump's world because look when Mike Pence made that decision to certify that election. That's why Mike Pence isn't on this stage. +[5605.360 --> 5622.360] What I'm concerned about is where is the firewall with Donald Trump? Where is the firewall if he knows he could do anything, including taking an election and his vice president's not going to stand to it. That's what we're asking you, America. +[5622.360 --> 5635.360] Will you stand up? Will you keep your oath of office, even if the president doesn't? And I think Kamala Harris would agree she wouldn't have picked me if she didn't think I would do that because of course that's what we would do. +[5635.360 --> 5643.360] So America, I think you've got a really clear choice on this election of who's going to honor that democracy and who's going to honor Donald Trump. +[5643.360 --> 5649.360] And I think that's what I'm going to do. I think that's what I'm going to do. +[5649.360 --> 5652.360] I think that's what I'm going to do. I think that's what I'm going to do. +[5652.360 --> 5661.360] I think that's what I'm going to do. I think that's what I'm going to do. I think that's what I'm going to do. +[5662.360 --> 5682.360] Welcome back to the CBS News Vice Presidential debate. It is now time for the closing statement. +[5682.360 --> 5689.360] Senator Vance won the virtual coin toss and elected to go last. So Governor Walls, you are first. You have two minutes. +[5689.360 --> 5695.360] Well, thank you, Senator Vance. Thank you to CBS News. And most importantly, thank you to all of you. +[5695.360 --> 5701.360] If you're still up and the folks who miss dancing with our stars, I appreciate it. But look, the support of the democracy matters. +[5701.360 --> 5710.360] It matters that you're here. And I'm as surprised as anybody of this coalition that Kamala Harris has built from Bernie Sanders to Dick Cheney to Taylor Swift. +[5711.360 --> 5718.360] And a whole bunch of folks in between there. And they don't all agree on everything, but they are truly optimistic people. +[5718.360 --> 5736.360] They believe in a positive future of this country. And one where our politics can be better than it is. And I have to tell you that better than it is is the sense of optimism that there can be an opportunity economy that works for everyone, not just to get by, but to get ahead. +[5736.360 --> 5744.360] And the idea that freedom really means something, not the freedom of government to be in your bedroom or exam room, but the freedom for you to make choices about yourself. +[5744.360 --> 5758.360] Now, look, we all know who Donald Trump is. He's told us, and as my Angela said, believe him when he told you that. His first inaugural dress talked about American carnage. And then he spent four years trying to maybe do that. +[5758.360 --> 5788.360] And then he said, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, +[5788.360 --> 5802.000] I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I'm going to say, all right. A few +[5802.000 --> 5810.480] minutes left. I swear. A minute. I'm going to say, I'm going to say, I have to say, treat yourself as Google and Google, just something like this, guys. +[5811.880 --> 5813.720] In 2010, I put a name that was nice lookin bike for us, because this was just a cleanstraighty That was right when I first came out. +[5814.820 --> 5817.780] It's like, enjoy me. +[5818.360 --> 5821.360] folks at CBS and of course the American people for tuning in this evening. +[5821.360 --> 5824.240] And one of the issues we didn't talk about was energy. +[5824.240 --> 5827.800] And I remember when I was being raised by my grandmother, when she didn't have enough +[5827.800 --> 5832.200] money to turn on the heat some nights because Ohio gets pretty cold at night and because +[5832.200 --> 5834.200] money was often very tight. +[5834.200 --> 5838.760] And I believe as a person who wants to be your next vice president that we are a rich +[5838.760 --> 5842.840] and prosperous enough country where every American, whether they're rich or poor, ought +[5842.840 --> 5846.520] to be able to turn on their heat and then it'll live a cold winter night, that's gotten +[5846.520 --> 5847.520] more difficult. +[5847.520 --> 5849.600] Thanks to Kamala Harris's energy policies. +[5849.600 --> 5853.680] I believe that whether you're rich or poor, you ought to be able to afford a nice meal +[5853.680 --> 5854.960] for your family. +[5854.960 --> 5857.960] That's gotten harder because of Kamala Harris's policies. +[5857.960 --> 5861.400] I believe that whether you're rich or poor, you ought to be able to afford to buy a house. +[5861.400 --> 5863.440] You ought to be able to live in safe neighborhoods. +[5863.440 --> 5867.800] You ought to not have your communities flooded with fentanyl and that too has gotten harder +[5867.800 --> 5870.680] with Kamala Harris's policies. +[5870.680 --> 5874.880] Now I've been politics long enough to do what Kamala Harris does when she stands before +[5874.880 --> 5879.800] the American people and says that on day one, she's going to work on all these challenges +[5879.800 --> 5881.200] I just listed. +[5881.200 --> 5884.480] She's been the vice president for three and a half years. +[5884.480 --> 5890.480] Day one was 1400 days ago and her policies have made these problems worse. +[5890.480 --> 5893.880] Now I believe that we have the most beautiful country in the world. +[5893.880 --> 5899.960] I meet people on the campaign trail who can't afford food but have the grace and generosity +[5899.960 --> 5903.280] to ask me how I'm doing and to tell me their praying for my family. +[5903.280 --> 5908.080] What that has taught me is that we have the greatest country, the most beautiful country, +[5908.080 --> 5911.000] the most incredible people anywhere in the world. +[5911.000 --> 5916.240] But they're not going to be able to achieve their full dreams with the broken leadership +[5916.240 --> 5917.720] that we have in Washington. +[5917.720 --> 5921.600] They're not going to be able to live their American dream if we do the same thing that +[5921.600 --> 5924.040] we've been doing for the last three and a half years. +[5924.040 --> 5925.280] We need change. +[5925.280 --> 5926.680] We need a new direction. +[5926.680 --> 5930.760] We need a president who has already done this once before and did it well. +[5930.760 --> 5932.040] Please vote for Donald Trump. +[5932.040 --> 5936.560] Whether you vote for me or vote for Tim Walls, I just want to say I'm so proud to be +[5936.560 --> 5938.120] doing this and I'm rooting for you. +[5938.120 --> 5939.520] God bless you and good night. +[5939.520 --> 5941.600] Senator Vance, thank you. +[5941.600 --> 5946.520] And thank you both for participating in the only vice presidential debate of this election +[5946.520 --> 5947.520] cycle. +[5947.520 --> 5948.520] I'm Margaret Brennan. +[5948.520 --> 5953.840] And I'm Nora O'Donnell and a reminder there are just 35 days until election day. +[5953.840 --> 5957.600] Please get out and vote and for all of us here at CBS News. +[5957.600 --> 5959.000] Thank you and good night. diff --git a/transcript/political_k8GvTgWtR7o.txt b/transcript/political_k8GvTgWtR7o.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d9b7fffb9bc823bfc7566498898ca2b0a7964b85 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_k8GvTgWtR7o.txt @@ -0,0 +1,114 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.680] This is Charlie from Charisma on Command and today I'm going to be giving you some presentation tips and tricks. +[5.680 --> 12.520] Now the guy that we are working off of today is actually the Toastmasters 2015 World Champion of Public Speaking. +[12.520 --> 18.680] This does though apply to a presentation that you would give in any setting, whether it's in work or elsewhere. +[18.680 --> 24.760] Because when you stand in front of a group of people, whether you're talking about macroeconomics or the forecasted revenue +[24.760 --> 29.680] or you're telling a story like this guy, you must captivate their attention first. +[29.680 --> 33.160] And that's one of the things that we're going to focus on today. So let's get started. +[43.000 --> 43.500] What? +[46.000 --> 51.320] So this is so huge. How does he start off a speech? There are two big things going on here. +[51.560 --> 57.480] One, he starts with a prop and sometimes that can feel a hokey and you're like, well, how do I do that in a business setting? +[57.640 --> 65.720] The truth is anything that is a physical object that people do not understand why you're doing it, whether you're holding some sort of piece of fruit as a metaphor. +[65.720 --> 72.800] I've seen people do that. Whatever it is, if you have a physical object, that helps to capture people's attention. +[72.800 --> 77.440] And you're going to see that this is the most critical thing at the start of a speech. +[77.440 --> 82.040] He does it in multiple ways because when you get up there and start to speak in front of people, +[82.040 --> 87.400] you have about 10 seconds to capture their attention and captivate them before they tune out completely. +[87.400 --> 92.280] So you must do something interesting. Secondly, impeccable timing. +[92.280 --> 99.880] This guy is so deliberate, so slow. He commands the stage. So that's just something to look out for for the rest of this video. +[103.000 --> 105.000] All you ought to think smoking kills? +[105.720 --> 111.400] So another quick thing and I'm going to play this back again just so you can see it all together. +[111.400 --> 115.640] You need to get audience interaction absolutely within the first minute. +[115.640 --> 120.200] You see a lot of speakers do this. It can feel hackneyed, but they ask people to show hands. +[120.200 --> 122.680] Who's seen this before? Show hands. Who's heard of something? +[122.680 --> 131.840] You must get the audience moving and speaking and responding to you if you want them to listen and to engage with what you are saying. +[132.000 --> 135.600] He does it very cleverly by asking a provocative question. +[135.600 --> 139.200] So I'm just going to go back and play that all over again so you can see it together. +[146.480 --> 147.680] What? +[151.840 --> 153.440] All you ought to think smoking kills? +[155.440 --> 160.000] So now they're interested and hooked and he can begin his, he can begin to get into it. +[160.320 --> 161.280] Let me tell you something. +[162.800 --> 168.800] Do you know that the amount of people dying from diabetes are three times as many people dying from smoking? +[170.480 --> 172.560] Yet if I pulled a sneaker bar, nobody would say anything. +[174.720 --> 180.800] Again two more great examples. He's dedicating basically the first minute of his speech to engaging +[180.800 --> 184.720] with the audience and he does that a number of ways we've covered but also humor. +[184.720 --> 187.280] He makes sure that there are jokes in that first minute. +[187.280 --> 192.560] So he's got another belly laugh here and then that provocative question that he's asking you, you think this? +[192.560 --> 195.440] Well guess what and now he's going to reveal something else. +[199.040 --> 201.520] Do you know that the leading cause of lung cancer? +[202.400 --> 203.520] Is that actually a cigarette? +[204.400 --> 206.400] Propagand captivates attention. +[206.400 --> 207.200] It's your DNA. +[208.320 --> 210.480] You could smoke for years and nothing will ever happen to you. +[211.840 --> 215.520] This whole war against smoking is just to restrict the farmer of tobacco. +[217.920 --> 218.720] Mr. Consent's chair, +[219.440 --> 220.720] Paratos masters and guests. +[222.400 --> 226.240] I use these arguments even though I just made them up. +[231.280 --> 236.400] A simple, so you see this is kind of an abbreviated version of this talk but right now we're going +[236.400 --> 239.920] to go to the body of the talk. So that's how you need to and must. +[239.920 --> 244.560] The first part of whatever your presentation you're giving has to captivate attention. +[244.560 --> 249.520] You've got humor, you've got provocative questions, you've got props, lots of ways to do that. +[249.520 --> 252.400] But the first minute do not get right into what you're saying. +[252.400 --> 254.240] Don't tell them what you're going to talk about. +[254.240 --> 255.920] Capture their attention. +[255.920 --> 260.560] So here now we're more in the body of his speech and the body of his presentation. +[260.560 --> 265.760] And one thing that you're going to want to have no matter how dry the subject that you're talking about +[265.760 --> 272.800] is stories because people, the human brain did not evolve to digest and connect with statistics. +[272.800 --> 277.600] Right? You can talk about global warming or world hunger and how many millions and billions +[277.600 --> 281.760] and hundreds of thousands but the human brain is not persuaded by that. +[281.760 --> 287.360] What is persuasive is individual anecdotes and even though it's a logical fallacy, +[287.360 --> 292.160] if you want to move people emotionally you need to tell the stories of individuals. +[292.160 --> 294.000] And this is what he does right here. +[294.000 --> 299.200] Choice of word can make a difference between someone accepting or denying your message. +[299.200 --> 306.480] You can have a very beautiful thing to say but say it in the wrong words and it's gone. +[307.120 --> 310.320] So here he makes his point and now he's about to launch into a story. +[310.320 --> 315.280] That's a great way bounce back and forth between a general point demonstrating story or even start +[315.280 --> 321.360] with demonstrating story. What's the point? My friend Nasa, he loved his father. +[322.480 --> 326.000] I realized his father. He would do anything to make him happy. +[326.080 --> 330.880] But his father was the kind of person who's not easy to impress. +[330.880 --> 334.720] And year after year Nasa tried and his father was like, yeah. +[334.720 --> 343.200] Forcian college, Nasa got straight A's and he got to himself, this is it. +[343.200 --> 346.560] This was what will finally make my dad proud. +[346.560 --> 348.080] He picked up the phone. +[348.080 --> 350.640] So notice this, this is very critical. +[350.640 --> 354.880] When you are telling stories, again, even in dry environments you have to realize that when you're +[354.880 --> 359.920] in front of a group of people, you are performing. So you need to get out from behind the +[359.920 --> 364.480] lectern. You need to move your body, but you also need to embody characters. +[364.480 --> 369.680] If you can take people into the present tense of any story any moment, that is going to be far +[369.680 --> 374.320] more powerful than summarizing it. And if you can go beyond the present tense and act it out, +[374.320 --> 379.760] make it vivid and real, play a character, that is going to be something that people can connect +[379.760 --> 384.080] with much more and will ultimately be moved to act upon. Because really when you get in front of +[384.080 --> 388.320] people, your goal is not just to say some words, your goal is for them to walk away, +[388.320 --> 391.920] having had something inside them change so that they behave differently. +[391.920 --> 395.840] And this is just a great example of how you can do that. So see what he does here. +[395.840 --> 399.680] You call his dad, dad. I got straight A's. +[402.400 --> 403.200] Are you proud? +[405.840 --> 407.280] Please tell me you're proud, father. +[407.360 --> 408.080] I love you. +[410.080 --> 413.040] Yeah, listen son, I'll have to call you back. I'm busy. +[417.040 --> 420.720] So you see, this is actually a breathing idiot. I highly, highly recommend watching the whole +[420.720 --> 425.920] thing. It's much better in its whole pieces. But I wanted to pull out some of the most +[425.920 --> 431.040] fascinating pieces. So moving on now towards the end of the speech, he sort of wraps it up. +[431.040 --> 435.520] What you want to do when you get to the end of any presentation, in the middle, you know, +[435.520 --> 439.920] you'll have told your stories, your anecdotes. At the beginning, you'll have captured attention. +[439.920 --> 444.080] It's the end when people are wide open from being sucked into your stories, from you +[444.080 --> 449.680] hooking their attention, that you can drop whatever insight or nugget that you want them to take +[449.680 --> 455.040] away. Because if you captivate people with stories, the truth is they are wide open to you telling +[455.040 --> 460.800] them the moral. And this is kind of what he does here. Words have power. Words are power. +[461.760 --> 470.800] Words could be your power. You can change your life, inspire your nation, and make this world a +[470.800 --> 478.080] beautiful place. Isn't that what we all want it? Isn't that what we are all in this hall? +[480.960 --> 489.120] Your mouth can spit venom. Or it can mend a broken soul. There's enginement. +[489.760 --> 498.320] Let that be a local. So you see there at the end, he goes back full circle with the prop. +[498.320 --> 503.040] He pulls out the cigarette and crushes it at the end. This is something that is very, very, +[503.040 --> 508.080] very popular. I personally find it a little bit cliche in this case. But what a lot of people +[508.080 --> 513.600] like to do is come full circle, or start with a metaphor and then come back to it at the end. +[513.600 --> 518.400] Again, very, very popular thing. You don't need to force it as I felt is the case in this speech. +[518.480 --> 524.960] But something that you can do. So if you want to see more videos like this, I actually have a full +[524.960 --> 528.720] video of this of the full speech, which is about the speech itself is something like eight minutes +[528.720 --> 532.720] long, and I'm talking over it. So it gets to be much longer. But if you just click the link in the +[532.720 --> 537.600] description or, you know, the box that I'll have pop up right now, you can get it access to that +[537.600 --> 542.800] for free. It's actually part of a membership site that we charge for. But these sections, +[542.800 --> 547.120] there's like two hours of free videos that you can get access to right now for free. You'll never +[547.120 --> 550.800] have to pay or anything like that just by creating a membership. So go ahead and do that now. +[550.800 --> 555.040] If you're interested, if you want to see more on this channel, go ahead and subscribe. And of course, +[555.040 --> 559.120] if there's anybody that you'd like to see me break down any topics that you would like to see me do, +[559.120 --> 563.280] feel free to go ahead and put those in the comments. Hope that you've liked this and I will see you +[563.280 --> 564.560] on the next video. diff --git a/transcript/political_nsIeVE3uT_8.txt b/transcript/political_nsIeVE3uT_8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8ff3d1c34eb15ab3e4a9b7ae1b2ebc7c4c1e8c7e --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_nsIeVE3uT_8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +[0.000 --> 1.640] My name's Janine Driver. +[1.640 --> 3.980] I'm a body language expert, and I'm often dubbed +[3.980 --> 6.640] the Human Lie Detector during the first debate. +[6.640 --> 9.380] When Trump has asked or everyone has asked, +[9.380 --> 12.440] who won't make a pledge to support whoever is elected +[12.440 --> 14.000] as the Republican candidate? +[14.000 --> 15.440] And you see Donald Trump. +[15.440 --> 17.200] He turns in one direction, which direction? +[17.200 --> 19.480] Does he turn to his left to see if any of those people +[19.480 --> 20.200] raised their hands? +[20.200 --> 20.840] No. +[20.840 --> 22.160] He turns to his right. +[22.160 --> 25.600] Raise your hand now if you won't make that pledge tonight. +[25.600 --> 28.360] And when he turns to his right, his right shoulder comes at us, +[28.360 --> 30.600] like this, his right shoulder comes out. +[30.600 --> 33.640] And so I have a motto, left for love, right for fight. +[33.640 --> 35.700] When I'm building rapport, I literally +[35.700 --> 37.960] will angle my left of my body towards someone. +[37.960 --> 40.200] So tell me a little bit about yourself. +[40.200 --> 43.160] If I'm aggressive or defensive, people +[43.160 --> 44.560] will angle our right shoulder. +[44.560 --> 46.040] We see this a lot with Trump. +[46.040 --> 49.320] If he's asked something that is putting him on the spot, +[49.320 --> 52.280] he will literally angle his right shoulder at us. +[52.280 --> 54.920] If it weren't for me, you wouldn't even +[54.920 --> 58.240] be talking about illegal immigration, Chris. +[58.240 --> 60.640] The other move that we see Trump do right here out of the gate +[60.640 --> 61.760] is this move. +[61.760 --> 64.160] And we see this move with Trump quite a bit. +[64.160 --> 66.880] This is called a basketball steeple when you do this. +[66.880 --> 69.960] And I will do that through a different system. +[69.960 --> 70.920] It is. +[70.920 --> 73.280] This is the traditional steeple, power, authority, +[73.280 --> 74.560] and confidence. +[74.560 --> 76.920] When we explode it with like a firecracker, +[76.920 --> 79.520] we used to see this with a columbal. +[79.520 --> 81.440] You have a long cigarette or cigarette. +[81.440 --> 83.320] I actually want more questions. +[83.320 --> 84.680] You spoke multiple, like you know, you'd +[84.680 --> 85.720] ask this question. +[85.720 --> 89.040] It's power, authority, and confidence with likeability. +[89.040 --> 90.480] So I call this the basketball steeple. +[90.480 --> 93.000] It looks like he's told it a big giant basketball. +[93.000 --> 94.400] The interesting part about Trump, though, +[94.400 --> 96.920] you'll often see him go from out to in. +[96.920 --> 99.520] The big problem this country has. +[99.520 --> 101.320] I call this this like cymbals. +[101.320 --> 103.760] Like he'll see him like, oh, and then it closes in. +[103.760 --> 106.840] He is the guy that challenges conventional wisdom. +[106.840 --> 109.160] You know, this move that he does, the cymbal move, +[109.160 --> 111.000] that's connected with thinking outside the box. +[111.000 --> 112.920] Was that the border last week? +[112.920 --> 115.640] He's one of the only people up here in the debates +[115.640 --> 118.760] that will angle his whole body and face other people. +[118.760 --> 122.720] I am very happy that you denied that and appreciate that very much. +[122.720 --> 126.840] Everyone else, you'll see them turning their heads. +[126.840 --> 129.440] But you'll see Trump will physically move his body +[129.440 --> 130.520] and look towards the person. +[130.520 --> 130.880] Why? +[130.880 --> 133.200] Because he can do that full frontal. +[133.200 --> 134.960] He's not afraid of the threat. +[134.960 --> 137.760] When the folks of Iowa found out the true facts of the job +[137.760 --> 140.520] that you've done in Wisconsin, all of a sudden, you too. +[140.520 --> 141.640] He was number one. +[141.640 --> 143.720] Now he's number six or seven in the polls. +[143.720 --> 147.000] Trump has no problem physically turning his body +[147.000 --> 148.800] to hear what the person's having to say. +[148.800 --> 151.920] So it's that full frontal, which is part of his signature, +[151.920 --> 153.160] his behavioral signature. diff --git a/transcript/political_wC2SahmI4Wk.txt b/transcript/political_wC2SahmI4Wk.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a6f6549d758c24797a87056eb89fa29bc1405e4d --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_wC2SahmI4Wk.txt @@ -0,0 +1,150 @@ +[0.000 --> 2.000] I was thrown at a small town +[11.200 --> 13.200] Thank you +[20.480 --> 22.480] Thank you +[23.480 --> 25.480] Thank you +[42.480 --> 44.480] Wow, well, thank you +[46.480 --> 49.280] Thank you first of all the vice president Harris +[50.280 --> 57.280] Thanks for putting your trust in me and for inviting me to be part of this incredible campaign +[61.280 --> 68.280] And a thank you to President Joe Biden for four years of strong historic leadership +[68.280 --> 82.280] It's it's the honor of my life to accept your nomination for vice president of the United States +[86.280 --> 96.280] We're all we're all here tonight for one beautiful simple reason we love this country +[99.280 --> 106.280] So thank you to all of you here in Chicago and all of you watching at home tonight. Thank you for your passion +[106.780 --> 112.980] Thank you for your determination and most of all. Thank you for bringing the joy to this fight +[118.800 --> 122.660] Now I grew up in but Nebraska a +[123.660 --> 131.360] A town of 400 people I had 24 kids in my high school class and +[132.260 --> 134.260] None of them went to Yale +[136.460 --> 142.780] But I'll tell you what growing up in a small town like that you'll learn how to take care of each other +[145.820 --> 149.900] That family down the road they may not think like you do +[150.700 --> 152.700] They may not pray like you do +[153.200 --> 161.980] They may not love like you do but they're your neighbors and you look out for them and they look out for you +[163.900 --> 170.140] Everybody belongs and everybody has a responsibility to contribute +[170.700 --> 173.860] For me it was serving in the Army National Guard +[174.860 --> 184.060] I joined up two days after my 17th birthday and I proudly wore our nation's uniform for 24 years +[187.460 --> 194.620] My dad a Korean war era Army veteran died a lung cancer a couple years later +[195.620 --> 198.460] He left behind a mountain of medical debt +[199.500 --> 202.820] Thank God for Social Security survivor benefits +[204.860 --> 205.860] And +[205.860 --> 214.500] Thank God for the GI bill that allowed my dad and me to go to college and millions of other Americans +[218.860 --> 223.660] Eventually like the rest of my family I fell in love with teaching +[226.700 --> 229.700] Three three out of four of us married teachers I +[229.700 --> 232.180] Wound up +[233.060 --> 236.900] Teaching social studies and coach and football at +[237.620 --> 239.620] Mancato West High School +[240.140 --> 242.140] Ghost Garlitz +[245.940 --> 255.240] We ran we ran a 44 defense we played through to the whistle on every single play and we even want to stay championship +[255.520 --> 260.520] Never closed the yearbook people +[261.520 --> 266.520] But it was those players and my students who inspired me to run for Congress +[266.720 --> 272.480] They saw in me what I had hoped to instill in them a commitment to the common good +[273.120 --> 276.960] An understanding that we're all in this together and +[278.560 --> 280.320] The belief +[280.320 --> 284.400] That a single person can make a real difference for their neighbors +[285.240 --> 287.240] So +[287.240 --> 289.240] There I was a +[289.240 --> 292.440] Forty-something high school teacher with little kids +[293.240 --> 299.240] Zero political experience and no money running in a deep red district +[300.600 --> 302.600] But you know what? +[302.760 --> 305.280] Never underestimate a public school teacher +[306.280 --> 308.280] Now +[312.000 --> 314.000] I +[314.000 --> 319.360] Represented my neighbors in Congress for 12 years and I learned an awful lot +[319.360 --> 325.720] I learned how to work across the aisle on issues like growing the rural economies and +[326.040 --> 331.680] Taking care of veterans and I learned how to compromise without compromising my values +[331.680 --> 340.560] Then I came back to serve as governor and we got right to work making a difference in our neighbors lives +[340.760 --> 343.360] We cut taxes for the middle class +[345.240 --> 348.320] We passed paid family and medical leave +[350.280 --> 354.480] We invested in fighting crime and affordable housing +[354.480 --> 363.640] We cut the cost of prescription drugs and help people escape the kind of medical debt that nearly sank my family +[365.280 --> 371.520] And we made sure that every kid in our state gets breakfast and lunch every day +[375.960 --> 381.800] So while other states were banning books from their schools +[382.360 --> 384.840] We were banishing hunger from ours +[390.640 --> 392.640] We also protected +[393.240 --> 399.880] Reproductive freedom because in Minnesota we respect our neighbors and the personal choices they make +[401.960 --> 406.880] And even if we wouldn't make those same choices for ourselves +[407.280 --> 410.920] We've got a golden rule mind your own damn business +[412.000 --> 414.000] And +[417.200 --> 419.200] That includes +[419.200 --> 421.200] IVF and fertility treatments +[421.600 --> 423.600] And this is personal for Gwen and I +[426.160 --> 434.480] If you've never experienced the hell that is infertility I guarantee you you know somebody who has and I can remember +[434.880 --> 444.600] Praying each night for a phone call the pit in your stomach when the phone had rang and the absolute agony when we heard the treatments hadn't worked +[445.400 --> 447.400] It took Gwen and I years +[447.800 --> 453.600] But we had access to fertility treatments and when our daughter was born we named her Hope +[456.800 --> 458.160] Hope +[458.280 --> 463.400] Gus and Gwen you are my entire world and I love you +[470.560 --> 474.920] I'm letting you in on how we started a family +[475.920 --> 481.760] Because this is a big part about what this election is about freedom +[482.760 --> 490.720] When we're when Republicans use the word freedom they mean that the government should be free to invade your doctor's office +[492.640 --> 495.800] Corporations free to pollute your air and water and +[497.240 --> 500.120] Banks free to take advantage of customers +[502.200 --> 509.840] But when we Democrats talk about freedom we mean the freedom to make a better life for yourself and the people that you love +[512.760 --> 515.800] Freedom to make your own health care decisions +[517.200 --> 519.200] And yeah +[519.800 --> 524.880] Your kids freedom to go to school without worrying about being shot dead in the hall +[528.960 --> 539.840] Look I know guns I'm a veteran I'm a hunter and I was a better shot than most Republicans in Congress and I got the trophies to prove it +[541.760 --> 545.760] But I'm also a dad I +[546.600 --> 553.280] Believe in the second amendment, but I also believe our first responsibility is to keep our kids safe +[558.600 --> 565.840] That's what this is all about the responsibility we have to our kids to each other and +[566.240 --> 573.480] To the future that we're building together in which everyone is free to build the kind of life they want +[575.680 --> 579.240] But not everyone has that same sense of responsibility +[580.360 --> 583.760] Some folks just don't understand what it takes to be a good neighbor +[584.560 --> 586.560] Take Donald Trump and JD Vance +[586.560 --> 597.080] They're project 2025 will make things much much harder for people who are just trying to live their lives +[598.000 --> 607.040] They spent a lot of time pretending they know nothing about this, but look I coach type school football long enough to know and trust me on this +[607.520 --> 612.120] When somebody takes the time to draw up a playbook, they're gonna use it +[612.120 --> 614.120] And +[616.760 --> 620.400] And we know if these guys get back in the White House +[621.120 --> 626.720] They'll start jacking up the costs on the middle class. They'll repeal the Affordable Care Act +[627.600 --> 630.360] They'll got Social Security and Medicare +[631.800 --> 636.080] And they will ban abortion across this country with or without Congress +[636.840 --> 643.200] Here's the thing. It's an agenda nobody asked for +[644.200 --> 651.520] It's an agenda that serves nobody except the richest and the most extreme amongst us +[653.760 --> 658.560] And it's an agenda that does nothing for our neighbors in need +[659.560 --> 661.560] Is it weird? Absolutely +[662.000 --> 664.000] Absolutely +[664.800 --> 666.800] But it's also wrong +[667.520 --> 669.520] And it's dangerous +[669.720 --> 675.720] It's not just me saying so it's Trump's own people they were with him for four years +[676.000 --> 681.200] They're warning us that the next four years will be much much worse +[681.640 --> 690.880] You know when I was teaching every year we'd elect a student body president and you know what those teenagers could teach Donald Trump a hell of a lot about what a leader is +[691.560 --> 695.720] Leaders don't spend all day +[696.400 --> 700.200] Insulting people and blaming others leaders do the work +[701.080 --> 709.600] So I don't know about you. I'm ready to turn the page on these guys. So go ahead say it with me. We're not going back +[715.680 --> 720.680] We've got something better to offer the American people +[721.560 --> 725.000] It starts with our candidate Kamala Harris +[728.960 --> 738.840] From her first day as a prosecutor as a district attorney as an attorney general as a United States senator and then our vice president +[739.080 --> 741.920] She's fought on the side of the American people +[742.080 --> 744.920] She's taken on the predators and fraudsters +[745.080 --> 750.480] She's taken down the transnational gangs and she stood up to powerful corporate interest +[750.680 --> 757.680] She has never hesitated to reach across that aisle if it meant improving your lives and she's always done it +[758.080 --> 759.760] with energy +[759.760 --> 762.000] With passion and with joy +[764.920 --> 766.920] Folks +[768.040 --> 772.360] We've got a chance to make Kamala Harris the next president of the United States +[774.920 --> 785.200] But I think we owe it to the American people to tell them exactly what she do as president before we ask them for their votes +[785.600 --> 791.240] So here this is the part clip and save it and send it to your undecided relatives so they know +[792.560 --> 799.400] If your middle-class family or a family trying to get into the middle class Kamala Harris is going to cut your taxes +[799.400 --> 807.120] If you're getting squeezed by prescription drug prices Kamala Harris is going to take on big pharma +[809.360 --> 814.400] If you're hoping to buy a home Kamala Harris is going to help make it more affordable +[816.320 --> 823.880] And no matter who you are Kamala Harris is going to stand up and fight for your freedom to live the life that you want to lead +[823.880 --> 831.000] Because that's what we want for ourselves and it's what we want for our neighbors +[833.480 --> 837.640] You know you might not know it, but I haven't given a lot of big speeches like this +[839.920 --> 841.920] But I have given a lot of pep talks +[844.200 --> 847.660] So let me let me finish with this team +[847.660 --> 853.980] It's the fourth quarter +[855.420 --> 862.060] We're down a field goal, but we're on offense and we've got the ball. We're driving down the field +[864.340 --> 868.940] And boy do we have the right team Kamala Harris is top +[869.580 --> 873.780] Kamala Harris is experienced and Kamala Harris is ready +[874.780 --> 876.780] Our job +[876.780 --> 884.540] Our job our job for everyone watching is to get in the trenches and do the blocking and tackling +[886.420 --> 895.420] One inch at a time one yard at a time one phone call at a time one door knock at a time +[896.820 --> 898.820] $15 donation at a time +[898.820 --> 912.620] We got 76 days that's nothing they'll be time to sleep when you're dead. We're gonna leave it on the field +[917.180 --> 919.980] That's how we'll keep moving forward +[920.220 --> 922.980] That's how we'll turn the page on Donald Trump +[923.100 --> 930.500] That's how we'll build a country where workers come first health care and housing are human rights +[932.700 --> 937.220] And the government stays the hell out of your bedroom +[942.180 --> 950.300] That's how we make America a place where no child is left hungry where no community is left behind +[950.860 --> 953.620] Where nobody gets told they don't belong +[954.220 --> 961.140] That's how we're gonna fight and as the next president of the United States always says when we fight +[965.580 --> 967.580] Thank you +[980.300 --> 982.940] Oh diff --git a/transcript/political_wGBbCAbLjus.txt b/transcript/political_wGBbCAbLjus.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..af780041d59cca30e06bd449f60cd756b945e571 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_wGBbCAbLjus.txt @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ +[0.000 --> 6.000] The Prime Minister directly insults me. He says, why is your name Gandhi and not Nehru? +[6.000 --> 10.000] But his words are not taken off the record. Maybe Mr Modi doesn't understand this. +[10.000 --> 15.000] But generally in India, our surname is the surname of our father. +[15.000 --> 18.000] But it does not matter because the truth always comes out. +[18.000 --> 24.000] And all you had to do was look at my face when I was speaking and look at his face while he was speaking. +[24.000 --> 30.000] Look at how many times he drank water, how his hand was shaking when he was drinking water and you'll understand everything. +[30.000 --> 35.000] He doesn't realize that the absolute last thing I'm scared of is Narindram Modi. +[35.000 --> 41.000] Doesn't matter whether he's the Prime Minister of India, whether he has all the agencies, doesn't matter. +[41.000 --> 43.000] Because the truth is not on his side. +[43.000 --> 47.000] One day, he will be forced to face his truth. diff --git a/transcript/political_ym_tGBNUi1I.txt b/transcript/political_ym_tGBNUi1I.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b8436113391dfbd1f946a5dfacde4495c60f0df3 --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_ym_tGBNUi1I.txt @@ -0,0 +1,702 @@ +[0.000 --> 5.240] It does appear that JD Vance has taken to the stage right there. +[5.240 --> 8.440] So we're going to raise the audio and listen in. +[8.440 --> 12.320] We're going to bring you all of his remarks without interruption. +[14.320 --> 23.560] Well, it is great to be in the great state of Michigan once again. +[23.560 --> 25.080] It is great. +[25.080 --> 29.240] It is great to be at an incredible manufacturing firm, +[29.240 --> 34.560] visionaring, and it is great to be in the state that I think is going to be pivotal +[34.560 --> 38.080] to give us 270 electoral votes and make it Donald Trump, +[38.080 --> 40.280] the next president of the United States. +[45.520 --> 50.600] Now, it's hard to believe we've only got 33 days until the election. +[50.600 --> 52.880] Now, that's a good news, bad news situation, +[52.880 --> 56.120] because that means we've got a very limited amount of time +[56.120 --> 60.240] to make our case to the American people that Donald Trump ought to be reelected president. +[60.240 --> 64.880] But the good news is that means only 33 more days for Kamala Harris +[64.880 --> 67.240] to gaslight and lie to the American people. +[67.240 --> 68.640] And that's a pretty good thing. +[72.760 --> 75.640] Now, we, we of course had a debate last night. +[75.640 --> 78.240] A vice presidential event, I thought it worked pretty well. +[82.880 --> 91.880] We made it, we made it, we made it, we made it, we made it, we made it. +[91.880 --> 95.040] Now, it's funny because we did this debate, +[95.040 --> 97.440] and then I talked to the president afterwards, +[97.440 --> 100.200] and we talked a little bit about what actually happened, +[100.200 --> 102.000] and some of the points that I made, +[102.000 --> 103.720] some of the points that Governor Wall has made. +[103.720 --> 109.480] And he made this observation, he said, that Tim Wall said that he was friends +[109.480 --> 111.040] with school shooters twice. +[112.040 --> 114.280] And that's something I actually didn't notice +[114.280 --> 117.480] that Tim Wall said said that on the debate stage. +[117.480 --> 119.640] And I said, did he really say that, sir? +[119.640 --> 122.200] And he said, I'm telling you, man, go and watch the clips. +[122.200 --> 124.800] He said he was friends with school shooters twice. +[124.800 --> 129.400] And I said that was probably only the third or fourth dumbest comment Tim Wall's made that night then. +[129.400 --> 136.440] Because look, I, I got to be honest, I feel a little bad for Governor Walls. +[136.520 --> 142.480] And the reason I feel bad for him is because he has to defend the indefensible. +[142.480 --> 145.560] And that is the record of Kamala Harris. +[145.560 --> 148.280] And think about this, for the past eight weeks, +[148.280 --> 151.880] Kamala Harris, who never won a Democrat primary vote, +[151.880 --> 159.000] has gone around the country saying that she is on day one going to tackle the affordability crisis. +[159.000 --> 163.280] That's making it hard for you to afford groceries, housing, and everything else. +[163.320 --> 168.120] She sells on day one, we're going to make energy prices lower for American consumers. +[168.120 --> 174.520] And on day one, she says, we're going to tackle the instability and conflict all over the world. +[174.520 --> 178.000] Well, Kamala Harris, day one was 1400 days ago. +[178.000 --> 180.320] What the hell have you been doing that whole time? +[180.320 --> 181.760] Why don't you get to work? +[181.760 --> 183.560] And instead of just talking about, +[186.680 --> 190.360] instead of just talking about what you're going to do, why don't you actually do it? +[190.360 --> 191.440] Here's the thing. +[191.440 --> 193.960] I'm running to be your next Vice President of the United States. +[193.960 --> 199.200] And I'm incredibly honored to stand here and ask you for your vote and ask you for your hard work. +[199.200 --> 203.520] But if we win, and I believe that we are going to win in 33 days, my friends, +[203.520 --> 205.240] I feel very confident about it. +[211.960 --> 218.240] But when we win, the American people will have given me an awesome responsibility +[218.240 --> 223.360] to represent them on the world's stage, to advocate for Donald Trump's policies, +[223.360 --> 226.920] to work with Congress to get things done for the American people. +[226.920 --> 232.680] You know, I get sick of having a Vice President of the United States for three and a half years +[232.680 --> 238.360] pretend that she bears no responsibility for all of the policies that have made this country +[238.360 --> 241.520] weaker, less prosperous, and less secure. +[241.520 --> 246.600] And part of our responsibility, part of our job, my friends, over the next 33 days, +[246.600 --> 253.320] is to remind Michiganders and everybody else that, yes, Kamala Harris is at fault for the +[253.320 --> 255.440] Inflation Explosion Act. +[255.440 --> 262.360] Yes, Kamala Harris is at fault for the explosion and federal spending that drove inflation through +[262.360 --> 263.360] the roof. +[263.360 --> 268.400] Yes, Kamala Harris is responsible as the borders are for the wide open border. +[268.400 --> 270.920] Kamala Harris has been in power. +[270.920 --> 272.640] She caused the problems. +[272.640 --> 276.480] We're not going to entrust her to solve the very problems that she created. +[276.480 --> 283.480] We're going to trust Donald Trump with the presidency of the United States. +[283.480 --> 290.960] Now, let's talk a little bit about manufacturing because I know we've got a lot of employees +[290.960 --> 297.040] and a lot of family members who work with Visionary, a great American aerospace company. +[297.040 --> 301.960] We believe, Donald Trump and I believe, that one of the biggest mistakes our leaders made +[301.960 --> 307.040] is that they decided over 40 years that we didn't need to make our own stuff anymore. +[307.040 --> 314.800] And this company stands as a proud and stark contrast to that because right here in Visionary, +[314.800 --> 319.360] you've got 350 American workers that are making great American products. +[319.360 --> 320.360] We're proud of you. +[320.360 --> 321.920] We're going to fight for you. +[321.920 --> 331.080] And we're going to build on that great track record. +[331.080 --> 336.120] You know, my papal was a union steel worker for almost 40 years. +[336.120 --> 340.960] And the steel mill that employed my papal had almost 10,000 jobs at one point. +[340.960 --> 343.080] Now it's got about 2,000 jobs. +[343.080 --> 347.120] And the steel mill, that's what were the lucky ones because a lot of those great American +[347.120 --> 352.160] steel producers, they didn't just shed 8,000 jobs, they went out of business altogether. +[352.160 --> 353.520] And why did they do it? +[353.520 --> 359.800] They did it because other countries used literal slave labor to undercut the wages of American +[359.800 --> 363.200] workers and destroy our industries. +[363.200 --> 369.160] And Donald Trump, if we stand for anything, we stand for an end to that practice. +[369.160 --> 370.720] We're going to build more in America. +[370.720 --> 373.160] We're going to manufacture more in America. +[373.160 --> 374.560] We're going to make more in America. +[374.560 --> 379.400] And we're going to do it with American workers and build American prosperity in the process. +[379.400 --> 381.320] That is our promise. +[381.320 --> 387.000] That is Donald Trump's solemn promise. +[387.000 --> 390.720] Now here's the thing, of course, vision earrings are a great aerospace company. +[390.720 --> 395.360] We got a lot of other proud industries in the state of Michigan and a lot of proud industries +[395.360 --> 398.880] that are not thriving thanks to Kamala Harris's policies. +[398.880 --> 406.440] Now, where did we go in this country where you've got Kamala Harris who wants to tax +[406.440 --> 412.520] working people so that rich people, she wants to subsidize rich people to buy electric vehicles +[412.520 --> 413.520] made in China? +[413.520 --> 416.960] Is that a good idea? +[416.960 --> 417.960] Absolutely. +[417.960 --> 418.960] It's not a good idea. +[418.960 --> 419.960] Now, here's the thing. +[419.960 --> 423.040] My papal, like I said, was a union steel worker. +[423.040 --> 425.120] And he was a little gruff from time to time. +[425.120 --> 426.120] I love my papal. +[426.120 --> 427.120] But you know what? +[427.120 --> 431.040] He had a word for the kind of policies that Kamala Harris is pursuing where we're going +[431.040 --> 431.560] to tax the money. +[446.960 --> 458.800] How good Michigan workers are at making automobiles. +[458.800 --> 464.000] But why are we trying to tell Americans that they've got to drive electric vehicles made +[464.000 --> 465.000] in China? +[465.000 --> 466.640] Why don't we send this message? +[466.640 --> 470.640] This is America, drive whatever the hell you want to because we believe in freedom +[470.640 --> 473.640] and we believe in choice in the United States of America. +[473.640 --> 483.160] And look, if we pursue those policies that say, yeah, if you want to drive an electric +[483.160 --> 485.960] vehicle, buy all means, drive an electric vehicle. +[485.960 --> 490.840] But if you want to drive a Michigan built gas powered car, that is your right. +[490.840 --> 494.080] And we're going to support your choice to do whatever you want to do. +[494.080 --> 497.480] And we're going to build prosperity for Michigan workers in the process. +[497.480 --> 502.560] But thanks to Kamala Harris's policies, this is a person who loves to pretend that she +[502.560 --> 504.280] stands for American workers. +[504.280 --> 510.480] Well, nobody stood as strongly and as proudly for American workers than Donald J. Trump. +[510.480 --> 519.040] He did it for four years and he's going to do it again. +[519.040 --> 523.160] So just in the last few years under Kamala Harris's leadership, I'm going to read this +[523.160 --> 525.280] to make sure I get my facts right. +[525.280 --> 531.240] The Lannis announced that it was going to lay off 2,500 Michigan auto workers who make +[531.240 --> 532.880] the RAM 1500 classic. +[532.880 --> 539.360] I want to disgrace that as a great American automobile and those jobs are going to get destroyed +[539.360 --> 545.240] and either replaced with factory jobs in Mexico or completely eliminated altogether because +[545.240 --> 551.400] Kamala Harris doesn't want to empower Americans to buy Michigan made automobiles. +[551.400 --> 557.840] Last year, GM let go 1,300 Michigan workers at two separate facilities. +[557.840 --> 562.800] And Ford is currently rolling back a lot of its EV production because a lot of Americans +[562.800 --> 564.080] don't want to buy EVs. +[564.080 --> 566.600] They want to buy the cars that they want to buy. +[566.600 --> 569.360] Now why are we doing this to our own workers? +[569.360 --> 571.280] Why are we doing this to our own industry? +[571.280 --> 573.520] Why are we doing this to our own country? +[573.520 --> 579.080] Because Kamala Harris has decided that she's going to pursue policies that make her donors, +[579.080 --> 584.560] her green scam donors rich and she's going to impoverish a generation of Michigan auto +[584.560 --> 585.560] workers. +[585.560 --> 586.560] I say hell no. +[586.560 --> 597.680] Let's empower and enrich Michigan auto workers with the leadership of Donald Trump. +[597.680 --> 602.920] Now look, this is not just about, you know, 2,500 jobs my friends. +[602.920 --> 604.360] That's not just a number. +[604.360 --> 605.360] Think about that. +[605.360 --> 611.920] That is 2,500 American families that have a family supporting wage and that disappears +[611.920 --> 614.040] thanks to Kamala Harris's policies. +[614.040 --> 616.560] That's 2,500 moms and dads. +[616.560 --> 617.960] They're going to have financial stress. +[617.960 --> 621.600] They didn't have before because of Kamala Harris's policies. +[621.600 --> 623.320] That's 2,500 families. +[623.320 --> 627.920] They're going to be worried about putting food on the table or paying heating bills because +[627.920 --> 632.040] we all know it gets pretty cold up here in the middle of a Michigan winner. +[632.040 --> 638.000] That is 2,500 families made this suffer not because of an act of God, not because of +[638.000 --> 644.800] something that happened accidentally but because our own leadership failed to do its job. +[644.800 --> 649.600] And if this election is about anything, it is about getting back to some common sense +[649.600 --> 656.120] economic principles that put American citizens, American workers and American consumers first +[656.120 --> 658.200] and that's exactly what we're going to do. +[658.200 --> 661.120] Every single day, that's why we exist. +[661.120 --> 666.960] This is to serve you not to destroy your jobs like Kamala Harris. +[666.960 --> 671.560] Now of course, remember the promise that was made and Tim Waltz made this argument last +[671.560 --> 672.560] night. +[672.560 --> 677.400] And one of these things that really, really annoyed the hell out of me is he said, well, +[677.400 --> 682.160] look, here's this economist who says that Donald Trump's plans are going to lead to higher +[682.160 --> 683.160] inflation. +[683.160 --> 686.640] Well, first of all, Tim, Donald Trump was already president for four years. +[686.640 --> 689.120] We got rising take home pay and lower inflation. +[689.120 --> 692.440] So I don't think those economists know what the hell they're talking about. +[692.440 --> 698.100] But even if you ignore the evidence of what Donald Trump did in office, look, what these +[698.100 --> 703.160] economists are saying is that if we ship our entire industrial base off to countries +[703.160 --> 707.480] like China, it's going to make American workers richer somehow. +[707.480 --> 710.160] It's going to make our goods cheaper somehow. +[710.160 --> 714.720] Well, we've been living through the inflation of the last three and a half years and we know +[714.720 --> 719.080] that when we make our country less self-reliant, when we pursue the policies that +[719.080 --> 722.960] Kamala Harris says that we ought to pursue, it makes Americans poorer. +[722.960 --> 725.640] It drives up the cost of food and of housing. +[725.640 --> 731.020] It makes our country less prosperous and it makes our nation more dependent on people +[731.020 --> 734.560] who don't like us to make the critical stuff that we need. +[734.560 --> 736.240] We got to get rid of that. +[736.240 --> 748.400] Stop listening to the economists and start listening to the common sense in this country. +[749.400 --> 753.720] But the thing about this, they said, here's the deal. +[753.720 --> 760.160] Tim Walls has the audacity and Kamala Harris has the audacity to say that, well, if Donald +[760.160 --> 765.080] Trump's policies are enacted, that's going to lead to higher prices for American consumers. +[765.080 --> 767.520] Tim, we ought to ran this experiment once. +[767.520 --> 770.720] Donald Trump's economic policies worked for American families. +[770.720 --> 772.560] They worked for American consumers. +[772.560 --> 774.560] But here's the thing, think about this. +[774.560 --> 782.200] If a Chinese company wants to hire a literal slave laborer making $4 a day and they want +[782.200 --> 787.760] to import the goods made by that slave laborer, then it's going to make Americans poor. +[787.760 --> 792.960] Because of course, we shouldn't expect American middle-class workers to work for a slave +[792.960 --> 794.480] wage in China. +[794.480 --> 798.040] We ought to expect our middle-class workers to be able to support a family on those +[798.040 --> 801.280] wages and that's what we're going to fight for every single day. +[801.280 --> 806.680] So here's what you got to do to prevent those companies and those countries from undercutting +[806.680 --> 811.840] the wages of American workers, you got to be willing to impose tariffs. +[811.840 --> 816.520] Fight back against the theft of the American middle-class, penalize those companies that +[816.520 --> 820.840] are shipping jobs overseas and give a tax cut to American workers. +[820.840 --> 830.480] That's how you build prosperity for this country and that's what we're going to fight for. +[830.480 --> 835.120] And let's just recap what Kamala Harris' policies have actually done. +[835.120 --> 841.680] The average Michigan family is spending over $1,000 per month to pay for what they could +[841.680 --> 843.760] have bought three and a half years ago. +[843.760 --> 850.120] That's $12,000 a year, a hidden tax of $12,000 a year just to be able to buy what you +[850.120 --> 852.200] could have bought three and a half years ago. +[852.200 --> 854.640] That's not pro-working people. +[854.640 --> 858.920] Kamala Harris has presided over policies that have seen the cost of housing go up by over +[858.920 --> 860.600] 50%. +[860.600 --> 862.840] That is not pro-working families. +[862.840 --> 868.880] She's seen policies that have seen the cost of eggs go up by more than double. +[868.880 --> 872.520] Galen and milk is now about four bucks in the state of Michigan. +[872.520 --> 876.000] Groceries are up 25%. +[876.000 --> 881.080] Kamala Harris' leadership has been tried and it has been found wanting and Americans. +[881.080 --> 882.880] We want to get back to common sense. +[882.880 --> 888.400] We want to be able to afford a nice living, a nice house for our families. +[888.400 --> 893.600] And to do that, we have got to elect the common sense leadership of Donald J. Trump. +[893.600 --> 897.440] And that's exactly what everybody in this room is going to do. +[897.440 --> 907.680] Now, I want to talk about just something else that, you know, credit card delinquencies +[907.680 --> 909.880] are about 9%. +[909.880 --> 910.880] Right now. +[910.880 --> 913.480] Kamala Harris is a lot of American families are sacrificing. +[913.480 --> 917.080] They're not paying their credit card debt so they can afford groceries or they can afford +[917.080 --> 918.320] the mortgage. +[918.320 --> 923.960] What a disgrace and what a sad commentary it is on Kamala Harris' economic policies that +[923.960 --> 928.120] you've got hard-working people who are doing everything that they can to provide for +[928.120 --> 931.000] their families and they're falling further behind. +[931.000 --> 936.360] Not because they're not doing their job, but because Kamala Harris isn't doing hers. +[936.360 --> 938.440] So we, and man, you're right. +[938.440 --> 940.560] Kamala Harris doesn't care about this. +[940.560 --> 944.800] She doesn't understand, because she doesn't talk to anybody. +[944.800 --> 946.800] She's afraid of interviews. +[946.800 --> 951.600] So she doesn't talk to people and she doesn't realize that her economic policies are making +[951.600 --> 953.680] her harder on American families. +[953.680 --> 954.680] And you all know my story. +[954.680 --> 957.280] I talked about it a little bit last night. +[957.280 --> 963.480] But I was raised by a grandmother who sometimes would refuse to turn on the heating at night +[963.480 --> 965.840] when times got especially tough. +[965.840 --> 971.280] I was raised by a woman who would sometimes forego paying for her own medicines so that +[971.280 --> 974.240] she could put food on the table in our family. +[974.240 --> 978.280] And I remember feeling even though money was tight that thanks to my grandmother, I never +[978.280 --> 983.200] really lacked for anything, but American grandparents and American parents shouldn't +[983.200 --> 986.040] have to make those sacrifices to begin with. +[986.040 --> 990.360] If you work hard and play by the rules, you ought to be able to afford a good life for +[990.360 --> 991.360] your family. +[991.360 --> 995.200] And that's what Donald Trump and I are going to fight for every single day for the next +[995.200 --> 1002.560] four years. +[1002.560 --> 1004.040] And I want to talk about one more issue. +[1004.040 --> 1007.000] We're going to, of course, take a few questions from the reporters, but I want to talk about +[1007.000 --> 1008.760] one more issue. +[1008.760 --> 1014.040] Because the American media, and especially Kamala Harris and Tim Walls, they don't want +[1014.040 --> 1020.240] to talk about how this illegal immigration crisis is a theft of the American dream from +[1020.240 --> 1021.800] American citizens. +[1021.800 --> 1023.800] And we see this in small communities. +[1023.800 --> 1026.560] We see this in big cities all over our country. +[1026.560 --> 1029.760] When you let in 25 million people, you know what that does? +[1029.760 --> 1031.720] That stresses municipal budgets. +[1031.720 --> 1035.880] So a lot of cities and towns can't afford to provide for their own citizens because they're +[1035.880 --> 1038.960] focused on providing for people who shouldn't be here. +[1038.960 --> 1044.360] You know, hospital wait times because illegal aliens use hospital emergency rooms primarily. +[1044.360 --> 1047.480] So hospital wait times have gone up in the state of Michigan. +[1047.480 --> 1052.440] We're close to three hours for American citizens who want to go into the hospital and see +[1052.440 --> 1053.760] a doctor. +[1053.760 --> 1056.560] We've got so many problems. +[1056.560 --> 1057.560] Housing. +[1057.560 --> 1062.120] You know, when you let in 25 million illegal aliens and they compete with Americans for +[1062.120 --> 1067.600] scarce homes, that drives up the cost of housing and that is a major cost of the housing +[1067.600 --> 1068.600] crisis. +[1068.600 --> 1071.000] I have the debate moderator attempt to fact check me last night. +[1071.000 --> 1076.320] She said, what's your evidence that illegal immigration promotes and increases housing +[1076.320 --> 1077.320] cost increase? +[1077.320 --> 1080.080] And I said, well, first of all, common sense. +[1080.080 --> 1083.520] When you let in millions of people who shouldn't be here, you got to house them somewhere and +[1083.520 --> 1087.120] those are houses that ought by right go to American citizens. +[1087.120 --> 1090.560] Donald Trump and I are going to fight for that every single day. +[1090.560 --> 1098.960] American homes for American people. +[1098.960 --> 1104.120] But there's also to talk about Tim Wallace's economist that he loves to cite. +[1104.120 --> 1108.800] Our own Federal Reserve has commissioned a study that shows that when you let in a lot +[1108.800 --> 1111.800] of illegal aliens, it jacks up the price of housing. +[1111.800 --> 1114.280] So how about this simple principle? +[1114.280 --> 1118.000] Kamala Harris wants to give amnesty to millions of illegal aliens. +[1118.000 --> 1127.600] She wants to bankrupt Medicare by giving Medicare to illegal aliens. +[1127.600 --> 1132.120] She wants to bankrupt Social Security by giving Social Security to illegal aliens. +[1132.120 --> 1134.120] So we want that. +[1134.120 --> 1138.360] Here's the Donald Trump plan and here's the Donald Trump message to illegal aliens in +[1138.360 --> 1139.360] this country. +[1139.360 --> 1143.480] In six months, pack your bags because you're going home. +[1143.480 --> 1150.680] That's what we're going to do. +[1150.680 --> 1152.600] And you know, you heard this a little bit last night. +[1152.600 --> 1156.360] You hear a lot of talk about compassion when the issue of illegal immigration comes up. +[1156.360 --> 1158.520] Well, let's talk about compassion. +[1158.520 --> 1160.800] Because I'm the father of three beautiful young kids. +[1160.800 --> 1165.720] I don't think that it's compassionate to empower the Mexican drug cartels to engage in +[1165.720 --> 1168.440] sex trafficking along our southern border. +[1168.440 --> 1169.760] That's not compassionate. +[1169.760 --> 1174.920] I don't believe that it's compassionate to flood American cities and towns with fentanyl +[1174.920 --> 1178.560] that is killing our citizens by the tens of thousands. +[1178.560 --> 1183.760] I don't believe that it is compassionate to allow our southern border to become a drug +[1183.760 --> 1188.920] trafficking and business zone for some of the most evil and terrible people in the world. +[1188.920 --> 1193.080] You know it's compassionate, closing that border down and putting the interests of American +[1193.080 --> 1202.240] citizens first, and that is what we're going to do. +[1202.240 --> 1205.760] You know, because these guys, they love to talk about threats to democracy. +[1205.760 --> 1209.960] Well, as Donald Trump will often remind you, he took a bullet for democracy. +[1209.960 --> 1215.880] So I don't think that any person can accuse the guy of doing anything other than fighting +[1215.880 --> 1221.560] every single day to make this country more prosperous and to make the world more peaceful. +[1221.560 --> 1225.520] But when the media talks about threats to democracy, you know what a threat to democracy +[1225.520 --> 1226.520] is? +[1226.520 --> 1231.760] When you have Kamala Harris running for president despite not earning a single vote from +[1231.760 --> 1237.760] Democratic primary voters, that's a threat to democracy. +[1237.760 --> 1244.160] You know what else is a threat to democracy when big tech firms and major American companies +[1244.160 --> 1250.000] and big government censors American citizens and deprives them of their voice in the town +[1250.000 --> 1251.000] square. +[1251.000 --> 1254.720] That's a way bigger threat to democracy than anything else going on. +[1254.720 --> 1255.800] And we're going to stop. +[1255.800 --> 1258.000] We're going to stop it right away. +[1258.000 --> 1264.320] Because look, I genuinely think this is one very big difference between Kamala Harris +[1264.320 --> 1265.600] and Donald Trump. +[1265.600 --> 1268.480] Look, I disagree, of course, with Kamala Harris. +[1268.480 --> 1270.240] I disagree with Governor Wolz. +[1270.240 --> 1277.120] I disagree with a lot of the folks who support him, but I would die fighting to defend their +[1277.120 --> 1281.040] right to speak their mind even if I disagree with it. +[1281.040 --> 1291.960] And I think every single person in this room believes that because we believe in free speech. +[1292.040 --> 1297.440] And as a person who was raised by a couple of working class blue collar Democrats, I want +[1297.440 --> 1302.800] to say to every Democrat who's watching at home, every Democrat who's in this room, you +[1302.800 --> 1308.080] are more than welcome in Donald Trump's Republican Party, where the party of common sense, we +[1308.080 --> 1314.840] got a big tent and you're welcome in our movement. +[1314.840 --> 1319.560] Because whether you agree or disagree with us about tax policy or regulatory policy, +[1319.560 --> 1323.680] I think a lot of Americans are saying they're sick of the censorship. +[1323.680 --> 1326.480] They're sick of being told, ink, and what to say. +[1326.480 --> 1330.160] They're sick of being told that they're not allowed to be friends with people they disagree +[1330.160 --> 1331.640] with politically. +[1331.640 --> 1335.800] And they're sick of tired of being told by their government to shut up. +[1335.800 --> 1340.800] Because we believe in the first amendment in this country, you have every right to petition +[1340.800 --> 1343.480] your government and tell them they're scurrying up. +[1343.480 --> 1345.520] And that's exactly what Kamala Harris is doing. +[1350.560 --> 1355.080] And that's why Bobby Kennedy endorsed Donald Trump. +[1355.080 --> 1360.520] That's why Talsi Gabbard endorsed Donald Trump because we believe in persuading our fellow +[1360.520 --> 1363.040] Americans and not silencing them. +[1363.040 --> 1366.280] And that is a big difference between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris. +[1366.280 --> 1369.680] You hear these people talk and Governor Walts mentioned this yesterday. +[1369.680 --> 1374.840] He talked about you can't shout fire in a crowded theater. +[1374.840 --> 1380.320] And you know what that from that line is from a disgraced Supreme Court opinion. +[1380.320 --> 1385.960] We believe that the solution to bad ideas is to debate them and persuade our fellow +[1385.960 --> 1386.960] Americans. +[1386.960 --> 1392.360] Kamala Harris believes the solution to things she disagrees with is to silence you and +[1392.360 --> 1393.520] to shut you up. +[1393.520 --> 1394.520] It's disgraceful. +[1394.520 --> 1396.000] It's anti-American. +[1396.000 --> 1397.760] And we will not stand for it. +[1397.760 --> 1399.120] And Donald Trump's political movement. +[1405.840 --> 1409.440] So I want to close before I take some questions from the media. +[1409.440 --> 1413.480] I just want to remind you that we got to look through Kamala Harris's lies. +[1413.480 --> 1416.480] She talks about all these great plans that she has. +[1416.480 --> 1419.200] And look, some of them she straight up copied from Donald Trump. +[1419.200 --> 1422.560] So some of them I'm like, you know Kamala Harris that doesn't sound that bad. +[1422.560 --> 1426.560] You went on DonaldJTrump.com and copied and pasted it. +[1426.560 --> 1430.400] She's going to put on a red bag of hat next thing you know. +[1430.400 --> 1434.800] But look, if you've got all these great ideas Kamala Harris, I've got a message. +[1434.800 --> 1438.600] Why don't you try them right now because you're the sitting vice president and you haven't +[1438.600 --> 1449.960] done a damn thing for American workers or the American people. +[1449.960 --> 1455.120] The sitting vice president cannot say on day one, we're going to tackle the affordability +[1455.120 --> 1456.120] crisis. +[1456.120 --> 1461.360] Day one was 1400 days ago and your policies caused the affordability crisis. +[1461.360 --> 1465.640] We can't say on day one we're going to make the borders more secure because she's been +[1465.640 --> 1467.840] the borders are for years. +[1467.840 --> 1472.800] Telling Americans that the border is secure, she ought to do something about it now instead +[1472.800 --> 1476.480] of lying and gaslighting the American people. +[1476.480 --> 1488.000] She talks about restoring American leadership to the world and bringing back peace and +[1488.000 --> 1491.040] stability to the world that has turned to chaos. +[1491.040 --> 1496.240] When she says that I say Kamala, I've got a really good idea for how we can bring peace +[1496.240 --> 1508.920] and stability back to the world, vote for DonaldJTrump and bring it back to the Oval Office. +[1508.920 --> 1515.160] So to all of you, to all of you who are here and all of you that are watching or will +[1515.160 --> 1520.040] see some of the clips of this later on, I just want to tell you that we have the greatest +[1520.040 --> 1522.280] country in the history of the world. +[1522.280 --> 1527.320] We've got the, I mean, flying in here, trust me, as a buck eye, it is hard to admit, you +[1527.320 --> 1532.680] have got one of the most beautiful states in the entire United States of America, especially +[1532.680 --> 1533.680] this time of year. +[1533.680 --> 1538.960] I love being in Michigan. +[1538.960 --> 1545.120] We've got the best natural resources, the best people, the best workers, the best history +[1545.120 --> 1547.040] anywhere in the world. +[1547.040 --> 1550.320] And I know a lot of people feel like the American dream is out of reach. +[1550.320 --> 1556.200] I know a lot of people feel like it's gotten way too expensive to afford food and energy. +[1556.200 --> 1559.120] It's gotten way too expensive to pay the rent. +[1559.120 --> 1564.360] And I just want to tell you, please do not give up on this country because it's broken +[1564.360 --> 1567.280] as the leadership of this nation is. +[1567.280 --> 1572.640] It's going to change in 33 days, but only if we get out there and work for it. +[1572.640 --> 1583.560] So to every American out there, we're going to bring back the American dream. +[1583.560 --> 1585.680] We're going to bring back affordable groceries. +[1585.680 --> 1591.080] We're going to make housing and rent possible to afford for normal American citizens. +[1591.080 --> 1594.840] We are going to cut the border crap out and close down that border. +[1594.840 --> 1597.560] We're going to bring the American dream back. +[1597.560 --> 1600.800] But only if Donald J. Trump is back in the White House. +[1600.800 --> 1602.400] We've got 33 days. +[1602.400 --> 1603.600] Let's make it happen. +[1603.600 --> 1604.600] Let's fight for it. +[1604.600 --> 1605.600] Let's work for it. +[1605.600 --> 1607.760] And we're going to make them the next president. +[1607.760 --> 1613.680] So let's take a few questions from the reporters. +[1613.680 --> 1617.320] And I always like to start with the local reporters first. +[1617.320 --> 1621.360] And then we'll do to the national folks if we got time afterwards. +[1621.360 --> 1625.720] Senator Vance, first of all, congratulations on last night's debate. +[1625.720 --> 1626.720] Thank you. +[1626.720 --> 1630.760] I did get a chance to speak to some voters here before you stepped on stage. +[1630.760 --> 1636.920] I spoke to Jeffrey and Bird and they said that they loved how the debate was civil and policy focused. +[1636.920 --> 1641.440] But then I also got some opportunity to speak to voters outside of the event. +[1641.440 --> 1645.720] And I got a question from Robert from Pontiac. +[1645.720 --> 1647.280] And it's a two-part question. +[1647.280 --> 1648.320] I hope you can answer it. +[1648.320 --> 1649.120] Sure. +[1649.120 --> 1655.440] So the first part is with issues where Americans are divided, if elected as the next vice president, +[1655.440 --> 1660.120] how will you bring folks together, especially from the other party? +[1660.120 --> 1664.160] And if there is an issue you disagree with Donald Trump, +[1664.160 --> 1668.000] how will you make your voice heard for the people? +[1668.000 --> 1671.360] Well, so you said the person who asked that question was named Robert? +[1671.360 --> 1672.200] Correct. +[1672.200 --> 1678.200] So my message to Robert on the first question is, look, I think that the reason this country feels so divided +[1678.200 --> 1681.680] is because of failed leadership and nothing else. +[1681.680 --> 1684.920] You talk to, look, I genuinely believe this, +[1684.920 --> 1688.280] with a lot of folks who are going to vote against me and Donald Trump, +[1688.280 --> 1691.840] there are a lot of people out there who are fundamentally good human beings. +[1691.840 --> 1697.760] But the leadership of the Democratic Party, Kamala Harris, is an absolute disgrace. +[1697.760 --> 1702.160] And here's the way, again, why do we have so much division? +[1702.160 --> 1705.720] And why do we have so much ranker in this country's political debate? +[1705.720 --> 1711.200] It's because Kamala Harris and her allies are trying to silence the American people +[1711.240 --> 1713.080] rather than engage with them. +[1713.080 --> 1715.320] When you try to censor your fellow citizens, +[1715.320 --> 1719.840] when you try to shut them up, you breed division and hatred, +[1719.840 --> 1723.160] Donald Trump and I are going to bring this country back together +[1723.160 --> 1727.400] by encouraging the free exchange of ideas and this idea +[1727.400 --> 1731.840] that our leaders ought to persuade their fellow citizens not try to shut them up, +[1731.840 --> 1734.080] which is what Kamala Harris wants to do. +[1734.080 --> 1736.240] Open this country up. +[1736.240 --> 1738.760] Open up the dialogue and open up the debate. +[1738.760 --> 1743.160] And that is how you bring American citizens back together in these divided times. +[1743.160 --> 1755.000] But on the second question about what do you do when you disagree with Donald Trump, +[1755.000 --> 1756.680] the answer is, first of all, +[1756.680 --> 1759.320] Donald Trump is at the top of the Republican ticket. +[1759.320 --> 1762.320] He will be the next president of the United States. +[1762.320 --> 1765.280] I've got two responsibilities. +[1765.280 --> 1766.880] I've got two responsibilities. +[1766.920 --> 1770.800] The first is to support the president in enacting an agenda +[1770.800 --> 1775.960] that I believe is going to lead to rising take-home pay and lower inflation for American citizens. +[1775.960 --> 1776.960] That's number one. +[1776.960 --> 1779.160] But of course, if I disagree with the president, +[1779.160 --> 1784.400] it is my responsibility to talk to him about it and to offer honest counsel in private. +[1784.400 --> 1789.000] And one of the things that I love about Donald Trump is that he takes advice and feedback +[1789.000 --> 1790.280] from everybody. +[1790.280 --> 1791.480] As much as... +[1791.480 --> 1801.400] It's funny when the president, the only conversation that he and I ever had about whether I might +[1801.400 --> 1806.200] become his vice presidential nominee was the Saturday before the convention. +[1806.200 --> 1809.600] If you remember, that was the Saturday where he was shot in Bucks County, Pennsylvania. +[1809.600 --> 1811.560] I saw him that morning in Florida. +[1811.560 --> 1812.840] We entered our conversation. +[1812.840 --> 1817.440] He hopped in a plane and flew to Pennsylvania where, of course, an assassin nearly took his life. +[1817.440 --> 1819.000] And you know what the president told me? +[1819.040 --> 1823.680] He said that he talked to everybody about who his vice presidential nominee should be. +[1823.680 --> 1826.480] And I think that's one of the great things he's willing to take feedback. +[1826.480 --> 1831.320] Of course, he makes the final decision, but he's willing to take inputs from everybody. +[1831.320 --> 1835.640] And he even said that he was talking to the Mar-a-Lago Gardiner about who the vice presidential +[1835.640 --> 1837.080] nominee should be. +[1837.080 --> 1840.920] And I said, well, sir, what the hell do the Mar-a-Lago Gardiner say? +[1840.920 --> 1842.320] Because this affects my life. +[1842.320 --> 1847.160] I'm very curious what these people you're talking to are saying about this very important decision. +[1847.240 --> 1850.280] But I think that it's one of the great things about his leadership style, +[1850.280 --> 1856.640] is he is in charge, he is in command, but he makes decisions after getting as much information as possible. +[1856.640 --> 1858.800] And that's how the country should be led. +[1858.800 --> 1862.600] You know, it actually raised an important question, Robert. +[1862.600 --> 1865.400] And I know, of course, the journalist who's asking this question, look, +[1865.400 --> 1868.520] one of the things that people in DC say about Kamala Harris, +[1868.520 --> 1871.960] and it's Democrats that say this, it's people she served with in the Senate, +[1871.960 --> 1873.120] and it's also Republicans. +[1873.120 --> 1874.880] And of course, they say this in private, +[1874.880 --> 1877.920] but they'll say Kamala Harris is very insecure. +[1877.920 --> 1879.960] She doesn't like to be challenged. +[1879.960 --> 1884.200] If you don't like to be challenged, and you don't like to engage in open debate, +[1884.200 --> 1888.000] you should be nowhere near the Oval Office of the United States of America. +[1895.400 --> 1896.440] Next question. +[1896.440 --> 1902.440] Thank you, Charlie Langton from Fox News, WJ here. +[1902.440 --> 1903.440] Charlie. +[1904.440 --> 1906.640] I talked to a lot of people here. +[1906.640 --> 1911.240] They also said you were very cordial last night in the debate, +[1911.240 --> 1914.280] and the message got through. +[1914.280 --> 1919.040] But compare your style to Donald Trump's style, +[1919.040 --> 1920.400] where he was a little aggressive. +[1920.400 --> 1929.800] Do you think that Donald Trump's message sometimes is lost because of his aggressive style? +[1930.800 --> 1932.640] No, Charlie, look. +[1932.640 --> 1940.600] I think, first of all, there is a media caricature out there of Donald Trump +[1940.600 --> 1943.400] that is so different from the man that I've come to know. +[1943.400 --> 1946.320] And I think that, you know, when he called me last night, +[1946.320 --> 1947.360] you know what he said? +[1947.360 --> 1949.200] He asked me how my wife was doing. +[1949.200 --> 1951.200] And he said, you know, you just had a hell of a debate. +[1951.200 --> 1955.000] I'm sure that you were nervous, yet every right to be nervous, +[1955.000 --> 1959.040] but go and have a nice meal with your wife and go and enjoy this moment. +[1959.080 --> 1960.760] Like that's the Donald Trump that I know. +[1960.760 --> 1963.760] People say, people say, +[1967.680 --> 1969.760] now look, the other thing I love about Donald Trump, +[1969.760 --> 1971.600] and I think it's true of all of us, +[1971.600 --> 1977.160] we can be so devoted to and so grateful to this country +[1977.160 --> 1979.240] and its incredible opportunities, +[1979.240 --> 1983.560] but then also be kind of pissed off that the leadership is failing this great nation. +[1983.560 --> 1987.920] There's no contra, there's no tension in saying on the one hand, +[1987.920 --> 1989.520] we've got the greatest country in the world, +[1989.520 --> 1993.480] and on the other hand, Kamala Harris is doing everything she can to screw it up. +[1993.480 --> 1998.800] And I love, I love that Donald Trump can do both of those things at the same time. +[1998.800 --> 2003.280] He can go out there and talk to the American people and be warm and engage. +[2003.280 --> 2007.520] He can talk to a normal American citizen about their struggles +[2007.520 --> 2011.880] and paying for groceries and housing under Kamala Harris's policies. +[2011.880 --> 2014.960] And then he can go on a debate stage and tell Kamala Harris +[2014.960 --> 2016.520] that she ought to stop screwing up +[2016.520 --> 2019.280] and she ought to stop talking about solving the country's problems, +[2019.280 --> 2020.880] she ought to go and actually do it. +[2020.880 --> 2022.800] That's the kind of president we need, +[2022.800 --> 2024.560] that's the kind of leader that we need, +[2024.560 --> 2026.360] and I think this message gets through. +[2026.360 --> 2028.360] Thank you. +[2031.240 --> 2032.080] Next question. +[2032.080 --> 2036.800] Hey, A. Senator Craig Mogger from the Detroit News newspaper here. +[2036.800 --> 2040.400] You were talking about your opposition to EV mandates. +[2040.400 --> 2044.640] My question is, do you think the government should have any role +[2044.640 --> 2049.960] in incentivizing, providing financial assistance to battery plans, +[2049.960 --> 2051.400] to electric vehicle plans? +[2051.400 --> 2055.280] Michigan is poised to benefit from some of these investments. +[2055.280 --> 2057.440] Will you allow those to go forward? +[2057.440 --> 2059.040] Will you try to interfere with those? +[2059.040 --> 2060.040] Thank you. +[2060.040 --> 2063.760] Well, look, look, I think there's certainly a role. +[2063.760 --> 2066.360] And I believe this, I know Donald Trump believes this, +[2066.360 --> 2071.040] in encouraging innovation, but there's a difference between promoting innovation +[2071.040 --> 2074.440] and sending hundreds of billions of dollars to favored industries +[2074.440 --> 2076.160] that make their products in China. +[2076.160 --> 2078.680] These are two very, very different things. +[2078.680 --> 2084.680] And here's the problem with a lot of these EV mandates +[2084.680 --> 2088.160] is that this money was supposed to go to American workers, +[2088.160 --> 2093.960] but Kamala Harris's IRS found every way possible to allow that EV subsidy +[2093.960 --> 2098.240] to go to manufacturers in China and not in the United States of America. +[2098.240 --> 2099.920] And here's the other problem with it. +[2099.920 --> 2104.000] It's not just auto jobs that we're worried about here. +[2104.040 --> 2105.880] Think about all the people who make carburetors. +[2105.880 --> 2109.800] Think about all the people who make transitions, transmissions. +[2109.800 --> 2113.360] There's an entire supply chain in the auto industry +[2113.360 --> 2116.080] that China dominates when it comes to EVs +[2116.080 --> 2119.240] and America dominates when it comes to gas powered cars. +[2119.240 --> 2122.800] So before we go and subsidize the EV industry, +[2122.800 --> 2126.160] let's open up the American supply chain for that industry +[2126.160 --> 2129.440] so that American workers and American consumers benefit. +[2130.400 --> 2134.440] All of the minerals, all of the rare earth materials, +[2134.440 --> 2138.520] a lot of the battery technology, a lot of the supply chain +[2138.520 --> 2141.560] for these electric vehicles is made in China. +[2141.560 --> 2144.600] And with the one hand Kamala Harris wants to make it harder +[2144.600 --> 2147.360] to build that supply chain in the United States of America. +[2147.360 --> 2150.640] And with the other hand, she wants to send money to an industry +[2150.640 --> 2153.200] that's built in China, it's disgraceful, +[2153.200 --> 2154.680] and we gotta stop doing it. +[2154.680 --> 2158.640] Invest in American workers, not in Chinese workers and Chinese firms. +[2158.640 --> 2163.640] And I know we unfortunately have to go to our next stop +[2173.080 --> 2174.080] in the great state of Michigan. +[2174.080 --> 2175.720] So I'll take one more question, +[2175.720 --> 2177.480] and then I'll offer a final observation +[2177.480 --> 2178.800] and then we'll hit the road. +[2178.800 --> 2179.720] Hi, Senator. +[2179.720 --> 2182.040] Hi, Senator, will Jones from local four? +[2182.040 --> 2182.880] They will. +[2182.880 --> 2185.120] I spoke with some elected officials or election officials +[2185.120 --> 2187.600] last week about their concern about people +[2187.600 --> 2190.240] who are trying to undermine our elections. +[2190.240 --> 2193.680] Why didn't you answer the question last night during the debate +[2193.680 --> 2198.600] about who won the 2020 presidential election? +[2198.600 --> 2202.480] Well, look, here's the simple reason. +[2202.480 --> 2204.640] The media is obsessed with talking about the election +[2204.640 --> 2205.480] of four years ago. +[2205.480 --> 2208.480] I'm focused on the election of 33 days from now +[2208.480 --> 2210.720] because I want to throw Kamala Harris out of office +[2210.720 --> 2213.320] and get back to common sense economic policies. +[2213.320 --> 2218.320] But I also think you can believe that America needs to have +[2222.320 --> 2224.120] secure and free elections, +[2224.120 --> 2228.040] but also talk about the fact that just a couple of weeks ago, +[2228.040 --> 2231.720] Democrats in the US Congress blocked a piece of legislation +[2231.720 --> 2233.560] that would have ensured illegal aliens +[2233.560 --> 2234.760] don't vote in our elections. +[2234.760 --> 2237.680] If you believe in American democracy, +[2237.680 --> 2240.040] if you believe in our constitutional republic, +[2240.040 --> 2243.280] you should be trying to strengthen American election integrity +[2243.280 --> 2244.520] and not weaken it. +[2244.520 --> 2246.400] So we're going to talk about election integrity +[2246.400 --> 2249.400] because I believe that every vote on account, +[2249.400 --> 2251.880] but only the legally cast votes. +[2251.880 --> 2254.400] And that's why we fight for election integrity. +[2254.400 --> 2256.720] And that's why we care so much about it. +[2256.720 --> 2263.840] Now, this actually leads me into my next point +[2263.840 --> 2266.880] because I want to talk about, look, +[2266.880 --> 2270.440] Democrats, whether they agree with what Donald Trump and I say +[2270.440 --> 2273.520] about some of the criticisms we have, for example, +[2273.520 --> 2275.960] I think that we make it way too easy +[2275.960 --> 2279.440] for people to fraudulently vote in this country. +[2279.440 --> 2282.040] I think that we should have passed the SAV Act +[2282.040 --> 2284.440] that would have ensured illegal aliens don't vote +[2284.440 --> 2287.080] in our elections, apparently Kamala Harris disagrees +[2287.080 --> 2289.880] because she fought that legislation every step of the way. +[2289.880 --> 2294.240] But the reason why Kamala Harris should actually sign on +[2294.240 --> 2296.400] with our pro-election integrity efforts, +[2296.400 --> 2298.480] things like common sense voter ID, +[2298.480 --> 2301.640] is because it gives the American people confidence. +[2301.640 --> 2303.320] And the most important thing that we do +[2303.320 --> 2305.840] when it comes to our government, which is voting, +[2305.840 --> 2308.040] I want every American to have confidence. +[2308.040 --> 2310.480] And by the way, to all of you listening out there, +[2310.480 --> 2312.400] I believe that we are going to have +[2312.400 --> 2315.600] the safest and most secure election in 2024 +[2315.600 --> 2319.480] that we've had because the RNC is fighting for election integrity +[2319.480 --> 2322.320] in a way that it frankly wasn't four years ago. +[2322.320 --> 2323.520] So get out there. +[2323.520 --> 2329.840] So I encourage folks, get out there and vote. +[2329.840 --> 2332.520] And this brings me to swampthevote.com. +[2332.520 --> 2334.520] And I want to make sure I got this right here. +[2334.520 --> 2337.680] It's swampthevote.com. +[2337.680 --> 2340.240] Find go to swampthevote.com. +[2340.240 --> 2341.640] Check your registration. +[2341.640 --> 2343.000] Check your polling location. +[2343.000 --> 2346.080] It'll give you some good information about how to vote +[2346.080 --> 2347.720] and also how to volunteer. +[2347.720 --> 2349.400] Because you know, one of the things that we're trying to do +[2349.400 --> 2352.120] to ensure common sense election integrity +[2352.120 --> 2354.160] is to remote more poll watchers. +[2354.160 --> 2357.640] We've got more poll watchers in the Republican party today +[2357.640 --> 2360.960] than we had four years ago if you're interested in helping us out +[2360.960 --> 2364.640] and making sure that every legally cast ballot counts, +[2364.640 --> 2367.720] then you can go to swamp the vote and help figure out +[2367.720 --> 2369.280] how to get involved in those efforts. +[2369.280 --> 2370.960] We believe in election integrity. +[2370.960 --> 2374.680] I know all of you do, but election integrity only happens +[2374.680 --> 2376.160] if all of us fight for it. +[2376.160 --> 2378.120] But I got to be honest with you, I think +[2378.120 --> 2380.040] that we're in a better shape in 2024 +[2380.040 --> 2382.040] than we have been in a long time. +[2382.040 --> 2385.120] We've done a lot to make our elections more secure +[2385.120 --> 2386.560] and what we've got to do, my friends, +[2386.560 --> 2388.400] is get out there and vote. +[2388.400 --> 2392.800] Never give in to the despair that your voice doesn't matter. +[2392.800 --> 2394.520] We've got all kinds of ways to vote. +[2394.520 --> 2395.920] You can vote early. +[2395.920 --> 2397.040] You can vote by mail. +[2397.040 --> 2398.240] You can vote on election day. +[2398.240 --> 2400.840] Look, I don't love that we have election season +[2400.840 --> 2402.880] in this country instead of election day, +[2402.880 --> 2405.360] but it is what it is and we've got to play +[2405.360 --> 2407.200] by the rules that we've been given. +[2407.200 --> 2410.440] And if we play by those rules over the next 33 days, +[2410.440 --> 2411.280] we are going to win. +[2411.280 --> 2413.560] We are going to send Donald Trump back to the White House. +[2413.560 --> 2415.960] And we're going to save the American dream for all +[2415.960 --> 2416.960] of our citizens. +[2416.960 --> 2425.240] But let me just, let me say one final thing here. +[2425.240 --> 2427.000] And I want to point out a couple of people +[2427.000 --> 2428.320] that I didn't mention at the top. +[2428.320 --> 2431.640] But first of all, you guys have got a great Republican +[2431.640 --> 2433.760] chair in the state of Michigan, Pete Hoekstra. +[2433.760 --> 2435.600] Pete, please wave and say hello. +[2435.600 --> 2443.000] We've got an old friend of mine from before. +[2443.000 --> 2445.040] Either of us were involved in politics, +[2445.040 --> 2446.680] the great Congressman John James. +[2446.680 --> 2447.520] Where's John? +[2447.520 --> 2448.680] And I know he's around here somewhere. +[2448.680 --> 2454.680] John's got a beautiful family. +[2454.680 --> 2458.280] And he's been a great advocate for the state of Michigan. +[2458.280 --> 2459.760] I hope you guys re-elect him. +[2459.760 --> 2460.880] And I believe that you will. +[2460.880 --> 2463.160] But let me just say this final thing +[2463.160 --> 2464.960] before we got to hit the road. +[2464.960 --> 2467.240] I have learned over the last eight weeks more +[2467.240 --> 2468.920] about this country than I could have possibly +[2468.920 --> 2469.920] hoped to learn. +[2469.920 --> 2472.400] And I mentioned this last night, but the thing that +[2472.400 --> 2476.600] has affected me the most is all of the people who come up +[2476.600 --> 2478.640] to me and some of them are struggling +[2478.640 --> 2480.080] to put food on the table. +[2480.080 --> 2481.720] And they have the generosity of spirit +[2481.720 --> 2484.360] to ask me how I'm doing, or to tell me +[2484.360 --> 2486.560] that they're praying for my wife and kids. +[2486.560 --> 2488.520] And it makes me realize that we have +[2488.520 --> 2491.640] got the greatest country in the world. +[2491.640 --> 2496.920] So I don't want us to ever get so frustrated with our leadership +[2496.920 --> 2500.640] that we forget that we've got the best people, the best jobs, +[2500.640 --> 2504.320] the best workers, the best natural resources. +[2504.320 --> 2508.560] The only thing that I believe is broken about this country +[2508.560 --> 2511.960] is the failed generation of leadership of people +[2511.960 --> 2513.520] like Kamala Harris. +[2513.520 --> 2517.400] So you have not just an important opportunity. +[2517.400 --> 2520.160] We all have an important responsibility +[2520.160 --> 2524.720] to return the people's government back to the American people, +[2524.720 --> 2528.280] to have a president who puts the interest of America's citizens +[2528.280 --> 2532.280] first to close the border, bring down the cost of groceries, +[2532.280 --> 2534.280] make housing more affordable again, +[2534.280 --> 2537.960] and to make sure that the American people have a government +[2537.960 --> 2541.240] that serves and fights for them 33 days. +[2541.240 --> 2543.040] Let's get to work and make it happen. +[2543.040 --> 2543.840] God bless you all. +[2543.840 --> 2544.960] Thanks for having me. +[2544.960 --> 2547.040] All right, you're just listening in there, JD, Vance, +[2547.040 --> 2550.880] and 24 hours after that first vice presidential debate +[2550.880 --> 2552.720] and Tim Walls on the stage. +[2552.720 --> 2555.320] And of course, we're going to shift out of this rather quickly +[2555.320 --> 2558.480] as we do see right now in Augusta, Georgia, +[2558.480 --> 2561.720] the vice president Kamala Harris talking about Haleen +[2561.720 --> 2564.880] and the recovery efforts live on and filtered Lusslusson in. +[2564.880 --> 2565.080] Quick. diff --git a/transcript/political_zzW_QEM-jgY.txt b/transcript/political_zzW_QEM-jgY.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bbf7fbb514b621a1bd0b058077b903d60df8888f --- /dev/null +++ b/transcript/political_zzW_QEM-jgY.txt @@ -0,0 +1,92 @@ +[0.000 --> 6.240] Tim Walls was asked about his claim that he was in China during the Tiananmen Square +[6.240 --> 8.560] Pro-Democracy protests. +[8.560 --> 12.120] As you can see, he had a little trouble with his response watch. +[12.120 --> 13.760] Winner Walls. +[13.760 --> 18.000] You said you were in Hong Kong during the deadly Tiananmen Square protests in the spring +[18.000 --> 20.000] of 1989. +[20.000 --> 24.440] The Minnesota Public Radio and other media outlets are reporting that you actually didn't +[24.440 --> 28.680] travel to Asia until August of that year. +[28.680 --> 30.680] Can you explain that discrepancy? +[30.680 --> 33.680] Yeah, well, into the folks out there, I didn't get at the top of this. +[33.680 --> 38.680] Look, I grew up in small rural Nebraska, town of 400. +[38.680 --> 41.600] Town that you rode your bike with your buddies till the street lights come on. +[41.600 --> 47.480] Governor, just to follow up on that, the question was, can you explain the discrepancy? +[47.480 --> 50.960] All I said on this was, I got there that summer and misspoke on this. +[50.960 --> 55.240] So I will just, that's what I've said. +[55.240 --> 61.280] So I was in Hong Kong and China during the democracy protests went in. +[61.280 --> 65.600] And from that, I learned a lot of what needed to be in governance. +[65.600 --> 76.480] Well, all the lies and in this campaign so far, of course, CBS chose the least offensive +[76.480 --> 78.440] lies of all of the lies. +[78.440 --> 83.460] But no question about stolen valor or the IVF lie. +[83.460 --> 86.300] He still managed to flood this though, Rob. +[86.300 --> 88.540] Oh, he absolutely did, Gina. +[88.540 --> 90.380] And thank you for having me this morning. +[90.380 --> 94.420] Certainly this was probably the standout moment of the debate simply because Tim Walls +[94.420 --> 96.020] could not answer the question. +[96.020 --> 98.220] It was a simple yes or no question. +[98.220 --> 100.740] And he went on and talked about his biography and where he grew up. +[100.740 --> 103.900] And clearly, I think the American people see that he's hiding something. +[103.900 --> 108.500] And as you pointed out, this is not the only situation where he has been called out for +[108.500 --> 113.020] stating something that is falsely just outrageously wrong. +[113.020 --> 118.900] And the fact that fact checkers from establishment and legacy media outlets are calling Tim Walls +[118.900 --> 124.260] out for this is an example, I think, of exactly the problem that the Harris Walls campaign +[124.260 --> 125.260] faces. +[125.260 --> 128.460] You'll recall that in the first debate, the first question that Kamala Harris received +[128.460 --> 131.140] was what her economic plan was for bringing down the cost of living. +[131.140 --> 133.460] And she went on to talk about her personal biography. +[133.460 --> 135.060] The American people aren't interested in that. +[135.060 --> 136.940] They want solutions. +[136.940 --> 141.900] Rob, I realize that you're not necessarily an expert in body language, but I think most +[141.900 --> 144.980] of us saw Tim Walls' body language yesterday. +[144.980 --> 148.020] And it was clear at least to me, and I'd love to get your perspective, that he was in +[148.020 --> 149.020] over his head. +[149.020 --> 151.020] Oh, absolutely. +[151.020 --> 152.340] He certainly was. +[152.340 --> 158.900] From that very first question, I think I counted five OZ or UMS or filler words as we +[158.900 --> 160.220] call them in the business. +[160.220 --> 165.420] And that demonstrated to me that Tim Walls was simply just nervous and maybe not frankly +[165.420 --> 166.420] prepared. +[166.420 --> 168.460] That was a tough question, obviously. +[168.460 --> 172.060] What should Israel do when it comes to what's going on there in the Middle East? +[172.060 --> 177.220] I recognize that he's trying to have a balancing act between not alienating certain constituencies +[177.220 --> 182.620] in the Democratic Party that are already frustrated with Kamala Harris and his support for Israel +[182.620 --> 185.780] or Teppin's support for Israel, I should say. +[185.780 --> 188.820] And that's probably a contributing factor to that. +[188.820 --> 192.300] But throughout the debate, JD Vance was obviously more poised. +[192.300 --> 193.300] He was ready. +[193.300 --> 194.300] He came prepared. +[194.300 --> 198.020] Tim Walls ended up agreeing with JD Vance on a number of points, which I thought was +[198.020 --> 199.020] interesting. +[199.020 --> 201.900] Maybe that's his likability factor that he's going for. +[201.900 --> 205.860] But at the end of the night, yeah, clearly this was a win for JD Vance. +[205.860 --> 211.180] Yeah, you know, I think speaking to that body language, it was really interesting. +[211.180 --> 212.980] It was like there were two debates going on. +[212.980 --> 218.340] There was what was said, but there's what wasn't said that was just in the perception +[218.340 --> 223.820] of the body language and the confidence that JD Vance just sort of emanated. +[223.820 --> 229.580] The looks he gave the camera, the communication with the middle class out there, the audience, +[229.580 --> 237.460] I thought was just very compelling and really just sort of next level for debate behavior. +[237.460 --> 243.940] While Tim Walls by contrast, he lost the debate far worse in body language terms I thought. +[243.940 --> 248.420] And this is actually my background than even what he said. +[248.420 --> 249.420] Yes, he fumbled. +[249.420 --> 252.660] Yes, he used those filler words you refer to there, Rob. +[252.660 --> 258.340] He looked hostile, he looked uncomfortable, he looked nervous, he looked defeated. +[258.340 --> 263.900] Gina, if you go on social media today, I mean there are so many different faces of Tim +[263.900 --> 265.180] Walls that you see. +[265.180 --> 266.740] I think it's absolutely true. +[266.740 --> 271.220] Both on style and substance, JD Vance was hands down, the clear winner. +[271.220 --> 275.660] Now that could be because he's better prepared, he's been in a more recent election, but there +[275.660 --> 277.580] could be any number of factors to that. +[277.580 --> 282.700] But I think what it points to is the fact that Kamala Harris selected Tim Walls for one +[282.700 --> 284.660] reason and one reason only. +[284.660 --> 288.340] He represents that, he's a white man who comes from the Midwest and she was trying to find +[288.340 --> 292.660] somebody who would make up for some of the deficiencies that she has herself. +[292.660 --> 295.740] And I think when you pick somebody based on those characteristics and not the substance +[295.740 --> 300.420] of what that person has actually done, then you end up in a situation like she is now. +[300.420 --> 303.500] Now was this as bad as Joe Biden's June debate against Donald Trump? +[303.500 --> 306.620] No, but it was absolutely pretty bad for Tim Walls. +[306.620 --> 309.740] And I would imagine there are many people in the Democratic Party today who are questioning +[309.740 --> 313.060] or second guessing this choice for Vice President. +[313.060 --> 314.060] No doubt about it. +[314.060 --> 316.060] Rob Bluey, thank you so much for joining us. +[316.060 --> 317.060] Thanks Rob. +[317.060 --> 318.060] Thank you.