diff --git "a/winrate/latest.json" "b/winrate/latest.json" new file mode 100644--- /dev/null +++ "b/winrate/latest.json" @@ -0,0 +1,3902 @@ +{ + "models": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.472050467307303, + "weighted_mean": 0.4761033570298975, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4042448851346185, + "weighted_mean": 0.40656219596956134 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5584112149532711, + "careqa_open": 0.45088479595521846, + "healthbench": 0.4312, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4201852356306184, + "healthbench-hard": 0.386, + "med_dialog": 0.1896, + "medcasereasoning": 0.365, + "medec": 0.46901172529313234, + "medexqa": 0.5617021276595745, + "medicationqa": 0.23623188405797102, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5130616509926855, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5543364681295716, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5055058499655884, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.2633587786259542, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.14369158878504673, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.41973684210526313 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.494303730954198, + "weighted_mean": 0.5031597208786401 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.38317757009345793, + "careqa_open": 0.36980859516070785, + "healthbench": 0.6475, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6445110324162353, + "healthbench-hard": 0.68, + "med_dialog": 0.763, + "medcasereasoning": 0.308, + "medec": 0.3559463986599665, + "medexqa": 0.43138297872340425, + "medicationqa": 0.5101449275362319, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4702194357366771, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5282131661442007, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4662766689607708, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4770992366412214, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5268691588785047, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.34671052631578947 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5156083559839589, + "weighted_mean": 0.5230109123010073 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.40654205607476634, + "careqa_open": 0.3102202961357891, + "healthbench": 0.6664, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6669844728956688, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7035, + "med_dialog": 0.7564, + "medcasereasoning": 0.335, + "medec": 0.4154103852596315, + "medexqa": 0.44574468085106383, + "medicationqa": 0.6094202898550725, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.48380355276907, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5480668756530825, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.47350309704060567, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4847328244274809, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5630841121495327, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.38092105263157894 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3388377539430605, + "weighted_mean": 0.34583498326409995 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3925233644859813, + "careqa_open": 0.23401950162513543, + "healthbench": 0.4694, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4596840098065922, + "healthbench-hard": 0.455, + "med_dialog": 0.2528, + "medcasereasoning": 0.285, + "medec": 0.4288107202680067, + "medexqa": 0.42446808510638295, + "medicationqa": 0.3036231884057971, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4043887147335423, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.43103448275862066, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4112181693048864, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.13358778625954199, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.10163551401869159, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.23421052631578948 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4188407315990965, + "weighted_mean": 0.4237735214172324 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5700934579439252, + "careqa_open": 0.3815456843625858, + "healthbench": 0.5078, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5014982293652955, + "healthbench-hard": 0.545, + "med_dialog": 0.3524, + "medcasereasoning": 0.321, + "medec": 0.4371859296482412, + "medexqa": 0.45372340425531915, + "medicationqa": 0.3630434782608696, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4608150470219436, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5062695924764891, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.452856159669649, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.2480916030534351, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.20210280373831777, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3980263157894737 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5503563574329886, + "weighted_mean": 0.5498606355573484 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5373831775700935, + "careqa_open": 0.4003250270855905, + "healthbench": 0.6692, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6795151184963225, + "healthbench-hard": 0.6655, + "med_dialog": 0.479, + "medcasereasoning": 0.385, + "medec": 0.4639865996649916, + "medexqa": 0.5101063829787233, + "medicationqa": 0.6557971014492754, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5047021943573667, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5506792058516197, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.49208534067446663, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6412213740458015, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7488317757009346, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.42236842105263156 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3550779575802695, + "weighted_mean": 0.36202352369289 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3855140186915888, + "careqa_open": 0.23149151318165404, + "healthbench": 0.4763, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.462544265867611, + "healthbench-hard": 0.48, + "med_dialog": 0.3626, + "medcasereasoning": 0.305, + "medec": 0.3249581239530988, + "medexqa": 0.42925531914893617, + "medicationqa": 0.3384057971014493, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4096133751306165, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4754440961337513, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.42016517549896765, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.2099236641221374, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.12266355140186916, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.24736842105263157 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.45834911015653074, + "weighted_mean": 0.4630162880943816 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.48598130841121495, + "careqa_open": 0.4472733838931022, + "healthbench": 0.5725, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5732770362299101, + "healthbench-hard": 0.595, + "med_dialog": 0.2156, + "medcasereasoning": 0.365, + "medec": 0.4966499162479062, + "medexqa": 0.44148936170212766, + "medicationqa": 0.2985507246376812, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5381400208986415, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6880877742946708, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5089470061940812, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.3549618320610687, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.3060747663551402, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.44605263157894737 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6203970145782657, + "weighted_mean": 0.6178564470634506 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6612149532710281, + "careqa_open": 0.5265438786565547, + "healthbench": 0.7112, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7217379460637429, + "healthbench-hard": 0.731, + "med_dialog": 0.5774, + "medcasereasoning": 0.441, + "medec": 0.6155778894472361, + "medexqa": 0.5063829787234042, + "medicationqa": 0.7797101449275362, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5376175548589341, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5736677115987461, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.518582243633861, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7748091603053435, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7663551401869159, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.48355263157894735 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5604440677036839, + "weighted_mean": 0.5618305677211002 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.616822429906542, + "careqa_open": 0.4575659082701336, + "healthbench": 0.668, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6714791609915555, + "healthbench-hard": 0.683, + "med_dialog": 0.42, + "medcasereasoning": 0.401, + "medec": 0.5100502512562815, + "medexqa": 0.4824468085106383, + "medicationqa": 0.5231884057971015, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6426332288401254, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.7236154649947754, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5598761183757742, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5648854961832062, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5642523364485982, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.47828947368421054 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.47609517531366163, + "weighted_mean": 0.48020813136916013 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3925233644859813, + "careqa_open": 0.23889490790899243, + "healthbench": 0.6887, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6859166439662218, + "healthbench-hard": 0.71, + "med_dialog": 0.4714, + "medcasereasoning": 0.333, + "medec": 0.3743718592964824, + "medexqa": 0.44680851063829785, + "medicationqa": 0.44710144927536233, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4555903866248694, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.48484848484848486, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.44287680660701995, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5877862595419847, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.47546728971962615, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.38223684210526315 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.7289719626168223, + "careqa_open": 0.6799837486457205, + "healthbench": 0.6114454854915201, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6225656967113322, + "healthbench-hard": 0.40711079593569993, + "med_dialog": 0.8688999999960803, + "medcasereasoning": 0.096, + "medec": 0.42409966499162477, + "medexqa": 0.7829787234042553, + "medicationqa": 0.8471014492723188, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6692789968652038, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.7826541274817137, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.669993117687543, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7932569974564883, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8969042056081775, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.07368421052631578 + } + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5665347199332615, + "weighted_mean": 0.5677789621546633, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5957551148653816, + "weighted_mean": 0.5934378040304387 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.44158878504672894, + "careqa_open": 0.5491152040447815, + "healthbench": 0.5688, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5798147643693816, + "healthbench-hard": 0.614, + "med_dialog": 0.8104, + "medcasereasoning": 0.635, + "medec": 0.5309882747068677, + "medexqa": 0.4382978723404255, + "medicationqa": 0.763768115942029, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4869383490073145, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4456635318704284, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.49449415003441155, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7366412213740459, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8563084112149533, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5802631578947368 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5758678682261807, + "weighted_mean": 0.5802781904722354 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.32242990654205606, + "careqa_open": 0.4122426868905742, + "healthbench": 0.6924, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6977662762190139, + "healthbench-hard": 0.754, + "med_dialog": 0.9446, + "medcasereasoning": 0.443, + "medec": 0.3961474036850921, + "medexqa": 0.3675531914893617, + "medicationqa": 0.7782608695652173, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4535005224660397, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.47387669801462906, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4635237439779766, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7251908396946565, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8808411214953271, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4085526315789474 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5962312737887506, + "weighted_mean": 0.5987042765678933 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3364485981308411, + "careqa_open": 0.32773564463705307, + "healthbench": 0.7172, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.720103514028875, + "healthbench-hard": 0.798, + "med_dialog": 0.943, + "medcasereasoning": 0.47, + "medec": 0.4472361809045226, + "medexqa": 0.3824468085106383, + "medicationqa": 0.8405797101449275, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4723092998955068, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.49164054336468127, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.47075017205781144, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7786259541984732, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.889018691588785, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.45460526315789473 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.43039233563339163, + "weighted_mean": 0.4344481375607907 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3341121495327103, + "careqa_open": 0.2197544239797761, + "healthbench": 0.534, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5335058567147916, + "healthbench-hard": 0.554, + "med_dialog": 0.6004, + "medcasereasoning": 0.42, + "medec": 0.474036850921273, + "medexqa": 0.3627659574468085, + "medicationqa": 0.5847826086956521, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3850574712643678, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.3824451410658307, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.40812112869924294, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.3931297709923664, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.4205607476635514, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.27960526315789475 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5138866694870656, + "weighted_mean": 0.5164502316857783 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.47897196261682246, + "careqa_open": 0.4120621162874684, + "healthbench": 0.5691, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5724598202124762, + "healthbench-hard": 0.6405, + "med_dialog": 0.7026, + "medcasereasoning": 0.456, + "medec": 0.47068676716917923, + "medexqa": 0.3920212765957447, + "medicationqa": 0.6057971014492753, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4440961337513062, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4503657262277952, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4470061940812113, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.48854961832061067, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.6156542056074766, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4763157894736842 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6277473893390799, + "weighted_mean": 0.6267095346456136 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4929906542056075, + "careqa_open": 0.43932827735644636, + "healthbench": 0.7325, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7481612639607736, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7825, + "med_dialog": 0.7962, + "medcasereasoning": 0.52, + "medec": 0.4916247906197655, + "medexqa": 0.44840425531914896, + "medicationqa": 0.8601449275362318, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4890282131661442, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4942528735632184, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4879559532002753, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8320610687022901, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9334112149532711, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4953947368421053 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4460649457430375, + "weighted_mean": 0.4504875747209524 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3060747663551402, + "careqa_open": 0.21776814734561215, + "healthbench": 0.5383, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5351402887496595, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5755, + "med_dialog": 0.7306, + "medcasereasoning": 0.44, + "medec": 0.36348408710217756, + "medexqa": 0.3659574468085106, + "medicationqa": 0.6130434782608696, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3939393939393939, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4211076280041797, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4160357880247763, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.46564885496183206, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.4544392523364486, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5543660473437758, + "weighted_mean": 0.5558351301150994 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4252336448598131, + "careqa_open": 0.487360057782593, + "healthbench": 0.6366, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6450558430945247, + "healthbench-hard": 0.701, + "med_dialog": 0.5332, + "medcasereasoning": 0.5, + "medec": 0.5284757118927973, + "medexqa": 0.37659574468085105, + "medicationqa": 0.5688405797101449, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5193312434691745, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6274817136886103, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5020646937370956, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6297709923664122, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.6612149532710281, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5276315789473685 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6820904700406006, + "weighted_mean": 0.6792738029457627 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.616822429906542, + "careqa_open": 0.5566991693752257, + "healthbench": 0.7556, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7713157177880686, + "healthbench-hard": 0.8005, + "med_dialog": 0.868, + "medcasereasoning": 0.576, + "medec": 0.6247906197654941, + "medexqa": 0.44840425531914896, + "medicationqa": 0.913768115942029, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5229885057471264, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5146290491118077, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5154852030282174, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.916030534351145, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9485981308411215, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5638157894736842 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6472812254377782, + "weighted_mean": 0.6470213529123199 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5467289719626168, + "careqa_open": 0.4920548934633442, + "healthbench": 0.7171, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7307273222555162, + "healthbench-hard": 0.769, + "med_dialog": 0.7624, + "medcasereasoning": 0.536, + "medec": 0.5326633165829145, + "medexqa": 0.42446808510638295, + "medicationqa": 0.8007246376811594, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6311389759665622, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.668234064785789, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5543702684101858, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7709923664122137, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8633177570093458, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5565789473684211 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5621985793608351, + "weighted_mean": 0.5629225480444111 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3107476635514019, + "careqa_open": 0.22788010111953774, + "healthbench": 0.7239, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7247344047943339, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7755, + "med_dialog": 0.8112, + "medcasereasoning": 0.468, + "medec": 0.423785594639866, + "medexqa": 0.3819148936170213, + "medicationqa": 0.722463768115942, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4378265412748171, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.43103448275862066, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4387474191328286, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8091603053435115, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8563084112149533, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4519736842105263 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6876947040498442, + "careqa_open": 0.7526182737450343, + "healthbench": 0.6563826236934, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6732684273430403, + "healthbench-hard": 0.4820732801699001, + "med_dialog": 0.9460999999955604, + "medcasereasoning": 0.366, + "medec": 0.478643216080402, + "medexqa": 0.722872340425532, + "medicationqa": 0.9273550724573916, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6426332288401254, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6849529780564263, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.6648313833448039, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8584605597961831, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9677764797446262, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.16381578947368422 + } + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4766793486738982, + "weighted_mean": 0.4712656820900838, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.505696269045802, + "weighted_mean": 0.49684027912135986 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6168224299065421, + "careqa_open": 0.6301914048392921, + "healthbench": 0.35250000000000004, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3554889675837647, + "healthbench-hard": 0.31999999999999995, + "med_dialog": 0.237, + "medcasereasoning": 0.692, + "medec": 0.6440536013400335, + "medexqa": 0.5686170212765957, + "medicationqa": 0.48985507246376814, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5297805642633229, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.47178683385579934, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5337233310392292, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5229007633587786, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.4731308411214953, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6532894736842105 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.42413213177381925, + "weighted_mean": 0.41972180952776456 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.677570093457944, + "careqa_open": 0.5877573131094258, + "healthbench": 0.3076, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3022337237809861, + "healthbench-hard": 0.246, + "med_dialog": 0.055400000000000005, + "medcasereasoning": 0.5569999999999999, + "medec": 0.603852596314908, + "medexqa": 0.6324468085106383, + "medicationqa": 0.22173913043478266, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5464994775339602, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5261233019853709, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5364762560220234, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.2748091603053435, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.11915887850467288, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5914473684210526 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5251082879908541, + "weighted_mean": 0.5226084394860953 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5210280373831776, + "careqa_open": 0.4086312748284579, + "healthbench": 0.5274, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5317352220103514, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5375, + "med_dialog": 0.487, + "medcasereasoning": 0.527, + "medec": 0.542713567839196, + "medexqa": 0.5117021276595745, + "medicationqa": 0.6275362318840579, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5198537095088819, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5193312434691745, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5065381968341363, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5610687022900763, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5338785046728972, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5388157894736842 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3445336034730406, + "weighted_mean": 0.34188452948532777 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5093457943925234, + "careqa_open": 0.27916215240158904, + "healthbench": 0.32, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.30999727594660853, + "healthbench-hard": 0.2685, + "med_dialog": 0.0764, + "medcasereasoning": 0.477, + "medec": 0.6130653266331658, + "medexqa": 0.48936170212765956, + "medicationqa": 0.2572463768115942, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4315569487983281, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4054336468129572, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.43977976600137647, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.18702290076335878, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.07827102803738317, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3703947368421053 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.426950830731308, + "weighted_mean": 0.42383494318467646 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6705607476635514, + "careqa_open": 0.5012639942217407, + "healthbench": 0.3672, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.364478343775538, + "healthbench-hard": 0.383, + "med_dialog": 0.1314, + "medcasereasoning": 0.513, + "medec": 0.592964824120603, + "medexqa": 0.5170212765957447, + "medicationqa": 0.33695652173913043, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.49007314524555906, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4717868338557994, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.48279421885753615, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.25572519083969464, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.19509345794392524, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5578947368421052 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5521847364108543, + "weighted_mean": 0.543628993589345 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6378504672897196, + "careqa_open": 0.5218490429758036, + "healthbench": 0.5272, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5356850994279488, + "healthbench-hard": 0.511, + "med_dialog": 0.2142, + "medcasereasoning": 0.577, + "medec": 0.6030150753768844, + "medexqa": 0.5771276595744681, + "medicationqa": 0.6347826086956522, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5370950888192267, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5198537095088819, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.524776324845148, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6450381679389313, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.697429906542056, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5710526315789474 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3515647530421769, + "weighted_mean": 0.3493545053209447 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5070093457943925, + "careqa_open": 0.2771758757674251, + "healthbench": 0.3236, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3163988014165078, + "healthbench-hard": 0.2985, + "med_dialog": 0.118, + "medcasereasoning": 0.497, + "medec": 0.47571189279731996, + "medexqa": 0.4952127659574468, + "medicationqa": 0.29492753623188406, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.44043887147335425, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.445141065830721, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.45010323468685476, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.20610687022900764, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.09813084112149532, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3815789473684211 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.46539216448203724, + "weighted_mean": 0.46195898413046044 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6214953271028038, + "careqa_open": 0.5789093535572409, + "healthbench": 0.4086, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.40901661672568784, + "healthbench-hard": 0.3875, + "med_dialog": 0.0646, + "medcasereasoning": 0.557, + "medec": 0.6323283082077052, + "medexqa": 0.5090425531914894, + "medicationqa": 0.26304347826086955, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5679205851619644, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6556948798328108, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5406056434962148, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.3511450381679389, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.286214953271028, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6131578947368421 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6152457006229232, + "weighted_mean": 0.6033051484812656 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.7406542056074766, + "careqa_open": 0.6242325749368003, + "healthbench": 0.5489, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5629256333424135, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5405, + "med_dialog": 0.2902, + "medcasereasoning": 0.633, + "medec": 0.7194304857621441, + "medexqa": 0.5702127659574469, + "medicationqa": 0.7797101449275362, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5705329153605015, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5350052246603971, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5485203028217481, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8129770992366412, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7289719626168224, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6381578947368421 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5590740842105735, + "weighted_mean": 0.5522881689495048 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6939252336448598, + "careqa_open": 0.5595882990249187, + "healthbench": 0.5086, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5172977390356851, + "healthbench-hard": 0.487, + "med_dialog": 0.1926, + "medcasereasoning": 0.593, + "medec": 0.6273031825795645, + "medexqa": 0.5542553191489362, + "medicationqa": 0.5355072463768116, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6739811912225705, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6865203761755486, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.588093599449415, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5687022900763359, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5292056074766355, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6296052631578948 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4735902736294914, + "weighted_mean": 0.4684967017141773 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.514018691588785, + "careqa_open": 0.28746840014445646, + "healthbench": 0.5459, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5491691637156089, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5295, + "med_dialog": 0.1898, + "medcasereasoning": 0.525, + "medec": 0.5293132328308208, + "medexqa": 0.5132978723404256, + "medicationqa": 0.42318840579710143, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.48693834900731453, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.45454545454545453, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.47315898141775636, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5877862595419847, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.42757009345794394, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5407894736842105 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.8590342679127725, + "careqa_open": 0.8199711087035031, + "healthbench": 0.5217291270739801, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5443080117437755, + "healthbench-hard": 0.2773563324638, + "med_dialog": 0.7966666666648804, + "medcasereasoning": 0.48, + "medec": 0.5847989949748744, + "medexqa": 0.8659574468085106, + "medicationqa": 0.8718599033757972, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.725705329153605, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.7225705329153606, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.7260839642119752, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.802162849873282, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8921339563873831, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3013157894736842 + } + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4553419956446185, + "weighted_mean": 0.4518797039744835, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.48439164401604107, + "weighted_mean": 0.4769890876989928 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5934579439252337, + "careqa_open": 0.6897797038642108, + "healthbench": 0.3336, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.33301552710433124, + "healthbench-hard": 0.2965, + "med_dialog": 0.24360000000000004, + "medcasereasoning": 0.665, + "medec": 0.5845896147403685, + "medexqa": 0.5542553191489361, + "medicationqa": 0.39057971014492754, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.51619644723093, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.45193312434691746, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5264969029593943, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5152671755725191, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.4369158878504673, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6190789473684211 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4037687262112494, + "weighted_mean": 0.4012957234321068 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6635514018691588, + "careqa_open": 0.6722643553629469, + "healthbench": 0.28280000000000005, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.27989648597112504, + "healthbench-hard": 0.20199999999999996, + "med_dialog": 0.05700000000000005, + "medcasereasoning": 0.53, + "medec": 0.5527638190954773, + "medexqa": 0.6175531914893617, + "medicationqa": 0.1594202898550725, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5276907001044933, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5083594566353187, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5292498279421886, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.22137404580152675, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.11098130841121501, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5453947368421053 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.47489171200914587, + "weighted_mean": 0.47739156051390474 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4789719626168224, + "careqa_open": 0.591368725171542, + "healthbench": 0.4726, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4682647779896486, + "healthbench-hard": 0.4625, + "med_dialog": 0.513, + "medcasereasoning": 0.473, + "medec": 0.457286432160804, + "medexqa": 0.48829787234042554, + "medicationqa": 0.37246376811594206, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4801462904911181, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4806687565308255, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.49346180316586374, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4389312977099237, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.4661214953271028, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.46118421052631575 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3282943494352583, + "weighted_mean": 0.3275438826224097 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.49065420560747663, + "careqa_open": 0.36366919465511016, + "healthbench": 0.3053, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.29433396894579134, + "healthbench-hard": 0.2555, + "med_dialog": 0.0772, + "medcasereasoning": 0.45, + "medec": 0.5586264656616415, + "medexqa": 0.47819148936170214, + "medicationqa": 0.1934782608695652, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.41379310344827586, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.3892371995820272, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4353062629043359, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.15648854961832062, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.06658878504672897, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3243421052631579 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.41182359446063294, + "weighted_mean": 0.41012987802093287 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6542056074766355, + "careqa_open": 0.5839653304442037, + "healthbench": 0.3535, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.35085807681830566, + "healthbench-hard": 0.347, + "med_dialog": 0.1356, + "medcasereasoning": 0.486, + "medec": 0.5418760469011725, + "medexqa": 0.5074468085106383, + "medicationqa": 0.2746376811594203, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.47596656217345873, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.45454545454545453, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.47660013764624914, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.25572519083969464, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.16822429906542055, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5230263157894737 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5365379074701416, + "weighted_mean": 0.5295633342497017 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6191588785046729, + "careqa_open": 0.6000361141206212, + "healthbench": 0.5117, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.518932171070553, + "healthbench-hard": 0.4795, + "med_dialog": 0.2184, + "medcasereasoning": 0.55, + "medec": 0.5586264656616415, + "medexqa": 0.5632978723404255, + "medicationqa": 0.5731884057971014, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5240334378265413, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5010449320794148, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5209910529938059, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6259541984732825, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.6822429906542056, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5375 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3353601560005488, + "weighted_mean": 0.33400268604514943 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.48598130841121495, + "careqa_open": 0.36096063560852293, + "healthbench": 0.3024, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.29378915826750207, + "healthbench-hard": 0.2715, + "med_dialog": 0.1192, + "medcasereasoning": 0.47, + "medec": 0.4204355108877722, + "medexqa": 0.48351063829787233, + "medicationqa": 0.20869565217391303, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4221525600835946, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4284221525600836, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4459738472126635, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.22900763358778625, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.08294392523364486, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.34078947368421053 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4432136553562287, + "weighted_mean": 0.4417282404298876 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6191588785046729, + "careqa_open": 0.6637775370169736, + "healthbench": 0.3815, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3761917733587578, + "healthbench-hard": 0.347, + "med_dialog": 0.0678, + "medcasereasoning": 0.53, + "medec": 0.5812395309882747, + "medexqa": 0.4957446808510638, + "medicationqa": 0.19202898550724637, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5538140020898642, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6405433646812957, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5323468685478321, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.29389312977099236, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.24532710280373832, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5710526315789474 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5958028790437843, + "weighted_mean": 0.5856844407147721 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.7266355140186916, + "careqa_open": 0.6841820151679306, + "healthbench": 0.5344, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5403159901934078, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5095, + "med_dialog": 0.2972, + "medcasereasoning": 0.606, + "medec": 0.6809045226130653, + "medexqa": 0.5579787234042554, + "medicationqa": 0.6920289855072463, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5553814002089864, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5177638453500523, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5437026841018582, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7633587786259542, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7254672897196262, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5980263157894737 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.540377880844989, + "weighted_mean": 0.5352179851762012 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6939252336448598, + "careqa_open": 0.6363308053448898, + "healthbench": 0.4934, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5009534186870063, + "healthbench-hard": 0.47, + "med_dialog": 0.1868, + "medcasereasoning": 0.566, + "medec": 0.5820770519262981, + "medexqa": 0.5404255319148936, + "medicationqa": 0.4210144927536232, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6614420062695925, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6750261233019854, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5825877494838265, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5419847328244275, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.594078947368421 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4542994472427837, + "weighted_mean": 0.4511299248152604 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.48364485981308414, + "careqa_open": 0.36872517154207296, + "healthbench": 0.527, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5268319259057478, + "healthbench-hard": 0.511, + "med_dialog": 0.1962, + "medcasereasoning": 0.498, + "medec": 0.47738693467336685, + "medexqa": 0.5047872340425532, + "medicationqa": 0.3289855072463768, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4660397074190178, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4336468129571578, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.46558843771507225, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5572519083969466, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.4217289719626168, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5019736842105263 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.8403426791277259, + "careqa_open": 0.8324756229685807, + "healthbench": 0.5066618267071602, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5278327410663035, + "healthbench-hard": 0.2513393535702001, + "med_dialog": 0.7980333333304802, + "medcasereasoning": 0.426, + "medec": 0.5205192629815746, + "medexqa": 0.8469414893617021, + "medicationqa": 0.8388285024110146, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6954022988505747, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6948798328108673, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.713351686166552, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7856234096679389, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8857087227408882, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.24144736842105263 + } + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6412298941983504, + "weighted_mean": 0.6389159522138381, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6611622460569395, + "weighted_mean": 0.6541650167359001 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6074766355140186, + "careqa_open": 0.7659804983748646, + "healthbench": 0.5306, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5403159901934078, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5449999999999999, + "med_dialog": 0.7472, + "medcasereasoning": 0.7150000000000001, + "medec": 0.5711892797319933, + "medexqa": 0.5755319148936171, + "medicationqa": 0.6963768115942028, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5956112852664577, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5689655172413793, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5887818306951136, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.866412213740458, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8983644859813085, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.7657894736842106 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5696076643666084, + "weighted_mean": 0.5655518624392093 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6658878504672897, + "careqa_open": 0.7802455760202239, + "healthbench": 0.46599999999999997, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.46649414328520844, + "healthbench-hard": 0.44599999999999995, + "med_dialog": 0.39959999999999996, + "medcasereasoning": 0.5800000000000001, + "medec": 0.525963149078727, + "medexqa": 0.6372340425531915, + "medicationqa": 0.41521739130434787, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6149425287356323, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6175548589341693, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.591878871300757, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6068702290076335, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5794392523364487, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.7203947368421053 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6554663965269594, + "weighted_mean": 0.6581154705146722 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.49065420560747663, + "careqa_open": 0.720837847598411, + "healthbench": 0.6799999999999999, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6900027240533915, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7315, + "med_dialog": 0.9236, + "medcasereasoning": 0.523, + "medec": 0.3869346733668342, + "medexqa": 0.5106382978723405, + "medicationqa": 0.7427536231884058, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5684430512016718, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5945663531870429, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5602202339986235, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8129770992366412, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9217289719626168, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6296052631578948 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6717056505647416, + "weighted_mean": 0.6724561173775903 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5093457943925234, + "careqa_open": 0.6363308053448898, + "healthbench": 0.6947, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7056660310542087, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7444999999999999, + "med_dialog": 0.9228, + "medcasereasoning": 0.55, + "medec": 0.44137353433835846, + "medexqa": 0.5218085106382979, + "medicationqa": 0.8065217391304348, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5862068965517242, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6107628004179728, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5646937370956642, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8435114503816794, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9334112149532711, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6756578947368421 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5882136916735858, + "weighted_mean": 0.5863952592631655 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6682242990654206, + "careqa_open": 0.7062116287468401, + "healthbench": 0.5324, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5385453554889675, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5885, + "med_dialog": 0.6294, + "medcasereasoning": 0.536, + "medec": 0.4815745393634841, + "medexqa": 0.527127659574468, + "medicationqa": 0.5376811594202898, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5611285266457681, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5668756530825496, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5412938747419133, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6183206106870229, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.6939252336448598, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6842105263157895 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6895596362217069, + "weighted_mean": 0.6860951965957242 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6261682242990654, + "careqa_open": 0.699349945828819, + "healthbench": 0.6893, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7062108417324979, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7185, + "med_dialog": 0.737, + "medcasereasoning": 0.6, + "medec": 0.5159128978224455, + "medexqa": 0.5792553191489361, + "medicationqa": 0.8217391304347826, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6029258098223615, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6149425287356322, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5836200963523744, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8854961832061069, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9591121495327103, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6934210526315789 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5153037651047288, + "weighted_mean": 0.5158683010960564 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.49065420560747663, + "careqa_open": 0.49801372336583605, + "healthbench": 0.5042, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5053119041133206, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5225, + "med_dialog": 0.6406, + "medcasereasoning": 0.52, + "medec": 0.3592964824120603, + "medexqa": 0.5069148936170212, + "medicationqa": 0.5347826086956522, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5067920585161965, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5391849529780565, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5089470061940812, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5610687022900763, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5373831775700935, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5092105263157894 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6182737551677251, + "weighted_mean": 0.616352471393443 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6144859813084113, + "careqa_open": 0.7688696280245576, + "healthbench": 0.5972, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6077363116317079, + "healthbench-hard": 0.6415, + "med_dialog": 0.43, + "medcasereasoning": 0.58, + "medec": 0.5343383584589615, + "medexqa": 0.5180851063829788, + "medicationqa": 0.48188405797101447, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6337513061650992, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.7460815047021944, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5963523743977976, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6870229007633588, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7254672897196262, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.7296052631578948 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.7400248015174961, + "weighted_mean": 0.7345705248445451 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.7313084112149533, + "careqa_open": 0.7511737089201878, + "healthbench": 0.7114, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7247344047943339, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7485, + "med_dialog": 0.8188, + "medcasereasoning": 0.656, + "medec": 0.6817420435510888, + "medexqa": 0.5765957446808511, + "medicationqa": 0.8942028985507247, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6347962382445141, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.632183908045977, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.6052993805918788, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.950381679389313, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9719626168224299, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.7513157894736842 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.7085252012616851, + "weighted_mean": 0.7044241088407613 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6985981308411215, + "careqa_open": 0.7304080895630192, + "healthbench": 0.6832, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6994007082538818, + "healthbench-hard": 0.712, + "med_dialog": 0.671, + "medcasereasoning": 0.616, + "medec": 0.5561139028475712, + "medexqa": 0.5622340425531915, + "medicationqa": 0.731159420289855, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.7351097178683386, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.776907001044932, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.6414315209910529, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8740458015267175, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.905373831775701, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.743421052631579 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6356860277196773, + "weighted_mean": 0.6340811452511519 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4953271028037383, + "careqa_open": 0.5050559768869628, + "healthbench": 0.7161, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7207845273767366, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7585, + "med_dialog": 0.738, + "medcasereasoning": 0.548, + "medec": 0.4103852596314908, + "medexqa": 0.5234042553191489, + "medicationqa": 0.6594202898550725, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5564263322884012, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.54858934169279, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5316586373021335, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8778625954198473, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9123831775700935, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6690789473684211 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.8411214953271028, + "careqa_open": 0.886240520043337, + "healthbench": 0.6425131851590002, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6616405505189322, + "healthbench-hard": 0.44951984604649986, + "med_dialog": 0.9300999999906407, + "medcasereasoning": 0.526, + "medec": 0.5264865996649917, + "medexqa": 0.8692819148936171, + "medicationqa": 0.9172705313942029, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.841692789968652, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.8908045977011494, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.8000688231245698, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8874045801503816, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9806269470322435, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.48092105263157897 + } + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5519295795530516, + "weighted_mean": 0.5507240209717496, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5811592684009035, + "weighted_mean": 0.5762264785827677 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4299065420560748, + "careqa_open": 0.6184543156374143, + "healthbench": 0.49219999999999997, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.49850177063470447, + "healthbench-hard": 0.45499999999999996, + "med_dialog": 0.6476, + "medcasereasoning": 0.679, + "medec": 0.5628140703517588, + "medexqa": 0.5462765957446809, + "medicationqa": 0.6369565217391304, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5391849529780564, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.49373040752351094, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.547143840330351, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7519083969465649, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7978971962616822, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6019736842105263 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4861133305129343, + "weighted_mean": 0.4835497683142217 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5210280373831775, + "careqa_open": 0.5879378837125315, + "healthbench": 0.43089999999999995, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4275401797875238, + "healthbench-hard": 0.35950000000000004, + "med_dialog": 0.2974, + "medcasereasoning": 0.544, + "medec": 0.5293132328308208, + "medexqa": 0.6079787234042553, + "medicationqa": 0.39420289855072466, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5559038662486938, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5496342737722049, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5529938059187887, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5114503816793894, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.38434579439252337, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5236842105263158 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.573049169268692, + "weighted_mean": 0.5761650568153236 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.32943925233644855, + "careqa_open": 0.4987360057782593, + "healthbench": 0.6328, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.635521656224462, + "healthbench-hard": 0.617, + "med_dialog": 0.8686, + "medcasereasoning": 0.487, + "medec": 0.40703517587939697, + "medexqa": 0.4829787234042553, + "medicationqa": 0.6630434782608696, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5099268547544409, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5282131661442007, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5172057811424638, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7442748091603053, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8049065420560748, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4421052631578948 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.588176405539367, + "weighted_mean": 0.5898701219790671 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3457943925233645, + "careqa_open": 0.41603466955579627, + "healthbench": 0.6465000000000001, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6491419231816944, + "healthbench-hard": 0.653, + "med_dialog": 0.8644000000000001, + "medcasereasoning": 0.514, + "medec": 0.4581239530988275, + "medexqa": 0.4925531914893617, + "medicationqa": 0.7253623188405798, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5240334378265412, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5454545454545454, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5233998623537508, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7442748091603053, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8317757009345794, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4769736842105263 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.41178630832641416, + "weighted_mean": 0.41360474073683456 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3317757009345794, + "careqa_open": 0.29378837125315993, + "healthbench": 0.4676, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.46145464451103246, + "healthbench-hard": 0.4115, + "med_dialog": 0.37060000000000004, + "medcasereasoning": 0.46399999999999997, + "medec": 0.518425460636516, + "medexqa": 0.47287234042553195, + "medicationqa": 0.4623188405797102, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.43887147335423193, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4331243469174504, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.45870612525808674, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.38167938931297707, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.3060747663551402, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3157894736842105 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6215353731370907, + "weighted_mean": 0.6173024827176135 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.48130841121495327, + "careqa_open": 0.5240158902130733, + "healthbench": 0.6569, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6692999182783983, + "healthbench-hard": 0.624, + "med_dialog": 0.6298, + "medcasereasoning": 0.564, + "medec": 0.516750418760469, + "medexqa": 0.5558510638297872, + "medicationqa": 0.7840579710144927, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5475444096133751, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5470219435736677, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5392291810048176, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8625954198473282, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9264018691588785, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5157894736842106 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.42571340572701366, + "weighted_mean": 0.42722696729160076 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3364485981308411, + "careqa_open": 0.2898158179848321, + "healthbench": 0.4648, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4588667937891583, + "healthbench-hard": 0.4145, + "med_dialog": 0.5044, + "medcasereasoning": 0.484, + "medec": 0.3743718592964824, + "medexqa": 0.47819148936170214, + "medicationqa": 0.48985507246376814, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4440961337513062, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4728317659352142, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4686854783207158, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.46946564885496184, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.3341121495327103, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3269736842105263 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5354501118644557, + "weighted_mean": 0.5346968022701892 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4369158878504673, + "careqa_open": 0.5743950884795955, + "healthbench": 0.5564, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5625170253336965, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5345, + "med_dialog": 0.3266, + "medcasereasoning": 0.544, + "medec": 0.5477386934673367, + "medexqa": 0.4888297872340426, + "medicationqa": 0.4492753623188406, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.577324973876698, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6849529780564263, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5540261527873366, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6030534351145038, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5700934579439252, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5565789473684211 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6725167292423239, + "weighted_mean": 0.6677352958656345 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.616822429906542, + "careqa_open": 0.6202600216684724, + "healthbench": 0.6778, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6880958866793789, + "healthbench-hard": 0.6595, + "med_dialog": 0.7262, + "medcasereasoning": 0.62, + "medec": 0.6675041876046901, + "medexqa": 0.5542553191489362, + "medicationqa": 0.8456521739130435, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5778474399164054, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5705329153605015, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5646937370956642, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8664122137404581, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9264018691588785, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5782894736842106 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6287739189914875, + "weighted_mean": 0.6260416985858308 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5373831775700935, + "careqa_open": 0.563199711087035, + "healthbench": 0.6338, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.644374829746663, + "healthbench-hard": 0.61, + "med_dialog": 0.5638, + "medcasereasoning": 0.58, + "medec": 0.568676716917923, + "medexqa": 0.5340425531914894, + "medicationqa": 0.6949275362318841, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6828631138975967, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.7183908045977011, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.6001376462491397, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7442748091603053, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8049065420560748, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5796052631578947 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5469513540728842, + "weighted_mean": 0.545544817530162 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3317757009345794, + "careqa_open": 0.3004694835680751, + "healthbench": 0.6545, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6526831925905747, + "healthbench-hard": 0.646, + "med_dialog": 0.6238, + "medcasereasoning": 0.512, + "medec": 0.42629815745393634, + "medexqa": 0.49627659574468086, + "medicationqa": 0.5956521739130435, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.49843260188087773, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4780564263322884, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4924294562973159, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7938931297709924, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7686915887850467, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.48026315789473684 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6814641744548287, + "careqa_open": 0.7972192127121704, + "healthbench": 0.58873751323822, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6044610673445654, + "healthbench-hard": 0.36203839069989996, + "med_dialog": 0.9035499999950405, + "medcasereasoning": 0.454, + "medec": 0.5196817420435511, + "medexqa": 0.8283244680851064, + "medicationqa": 0.8884661835708697, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.7408568443051202, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.7748171368861024, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.739504473503097, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8648218829473283, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9542445482794395, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.21118421052631578 + } + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4235465540531289, + "weighted_mean": 0.4266482358575701, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4496436425670114, + "weighted_mean": 0.4501393644426516 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.46261682242990654, + "careqa_open": 0.5996749729144095, + "healthbench": 0.3308, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3204848815036775, + "healthbench-hard": 0.3345, + "med_dialog": 0.521, + "medcasereasoning": 0.615, + "medec": 0.5360134003350083, + "medexqa": 0.48989361702127665, + "medicationqa": 0.3442028985507246, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.49529780564263326, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.44932079414838033, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5079146593255334, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.3587786259541985, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.2511682242990654, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5776315789473685 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.37225261066092014, + "weighted_mean": 0.37329046535438637 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5070093457943925, + "careqa_open": 0.5606717226435536, + "healthbench": 0.26749999999999996, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.25183873603922635, + "healthbench-hard": 0.21750000000000003, + "med_dialog": 0.20379999999999998, + "medcasereasoning": 0.48, + "medec": 0.5083752093802345, + "medexqa": 0.551595744680851, + "medicationqa": 0.13985507246376816, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5109717868338558, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5057471264367817, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5120440467997247, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.16793893129770987, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.06658878504672894, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5046052631578948 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.44781526358914575, + "weighted_mean": 0.45637100641065503 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3621495327102804, + "careqa_open": 0.4781509570241964, + "healthbench": 0.4728, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.46431490057205116, + "healthbench-hard": 0.489, + "med_dialog": 0.7858, + "medcasereasoning": 0.42300000000000004, + "medec": 0.39698492462311563, + "medexqa": 0.4228723404255319, + "medicationqa": 0.3652173913043478, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.46290491118077326, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4801462904911181, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.475223675154852, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.3549618320610687, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.30257009345794394, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.42894736842105263 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.46346209252985837, + "weighted_mean": 0.47043666575029836 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3808411214953271, + "careqa_open": 0.3999638858793788, + "healthbench": 0.48829999999999996, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.481067828929447, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5205, + "med_dialog": 0.7816, + "medcasereasoning": 0.44999999999999996, + "medec": 0.44137353433835846, + "medexqa": 0.4367021276595745, + "medicationqa": 0.4268115942028986, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4759665621734587, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4989550679205852, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4790089470061941, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.3740458015267175, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.31775700934579443, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4625 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3104403637782931, + "weighted_mean": 0.3139048034042759 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3738317757009346, + "careqa_open": 0.30065005417118096, + "healthbench": 0.3107, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.29378915826750207, + "healthbench-hard": 0.2815, + "med_dialog": 0.263, + "medcasereasoning": 0.4, + "medec": 0.48408710217755446, + "medexqa": 0.42074468085106387, + "medicationqa": 0.17826086956521736, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.39707419017763845, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.38505747126436785, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.41637990364762556, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.1145038167938931, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.04088785046728971, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.30657894736842106 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.37846462686290927, + "weighted_mean": 0.3826975172823866 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5186915887850467, + "careqa_open": 0.47598410978692673, + "healthbench": 0.34309999999999996, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3307000817216017, + "healthbench-hard": 0.376, + "med_dialog": 0.3702, + "medcasereasoning": 0.43600000000000005, + "medec": 0.483249581239531, + "medexqa": 0.4441489361702128, + "medicationqa": 0.2159420289855073, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.45245559038662486, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.45297805642633227, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.46077081899518235, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.13740458015267176, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.07359813084112155, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4842105263157894 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.32086311886817415, + "weighted_mean": 0.3253679728511278 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.36682242990654207, + "careqa_open": 0.29866377753701695, + "healthbench": 0.3075, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.2883410514846091, + "healthbench-hard": 0.3025, + "med_dialog": 0.392, + "medcasereasoning": 0.42, + "medec": 0.37185929648241206, + "medexqa": 0.42127659574468085, + "medicationqa": 0.20869565217391303, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4012539184952978, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4268547544409613, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.42601514108740535, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.13358778625954199, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.04672897196261682, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.32171052631578945 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4172782680251213, + "weighted_mean": 0.4202110563570562 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4742990654205608, + "careqa_open": 0.5453232213795594, + "healthbench": 0.394, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.38627077090710976, + "healthbench-hard": 0.3905, + "med_dialog": 0.2324, + "medcasereasoning": 0.48, + "medec": 0.5326633165829145, + "medexqa": 0.43617021276595747, + "medicationqa": 0.186231884057971, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5334378265412748, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6389759665621735, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.512388162422574, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.2595419847328244, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.1413551401869159, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5328947368421053 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5688334968958281, + "weighted_mean": 0.565109099232351 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6261682242990654, + "careqa_open": 0.6068977970386421, + "healthbench": 0.5311, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.532416235358213, + "healthbench-hard": 0.536, + "med_dialog": 0.6024, + "medcasereasoning": 0.556, + "medec": 0.6490787269681743, + "medexqa": 0.49840425531914895, + "medicationqa": 0.5985507246376811, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5376175548589341, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5172413793103449, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5203028217481074, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6984732824427481, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5268691588785047, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5638157894736842 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5079035932067282, + "weighted_mean": 0.5095663542506039 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5771028037383178, + "careqa_open": 0.544781509570242, + "healthbench": 0.4868, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.48651593571234, + "healthbench-hard": 0.493, + "med_dialog": 0.4566, + "medcasereasoning": 0.516, + "medec": 0.5477386934673367, + "medexqa": 0.4765957446808511, + "medicationqa": 0.3804347826086957, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6337513061650992, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6734587251828631, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5602202339986235, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4198473282442748, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.3130841121495327, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5605263157894737 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4220550176004286, + "weighted_mean": 0.4260362890974784 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.36682242990654207, + "careqa_open": 0.30823401950162516, + "healthbench": 0.5083, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4987741759738491, + "healthbench-hard": 0.513, + "med_dialog": 0.4976, + "medcasereasoning": 0.448, + "medec": 0.4204355108877722, + "medexqa": 0.4377659574468085, + "medicationqa": 0.28840579710144926, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.44932079414838033, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.42998955067920586, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.45044735030970406, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4351145038167939, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.23948598130841123, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4611842105263158 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6985981308411215, + "careqa_open": 0.7517605633802817, + "healthbench": 0.47421080674018, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.48830851937853437, + "healthbench-hard": 0.26149495826490005, + "med_dialog": 0.8722833333292803, + "medcasereasoning": 0.326, + "medec": 0.4975921273031826, + "medexqa": 0.7501329787234042, + "medicationqa": 0.7751811594150725, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6593521421107628, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.690700104493208, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.6810048176187199, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7560432569938927, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8275895638654205, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.19276315789473683 + } + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6271203174781459, + "weighted_mean": 0.6243980841829406, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6449220424197305, + "weighted_mean": 0.6379764763071101 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6144859813084111, + "careqa_open": 0.7685084868183459, + "healthbench": 0.5237, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.537455734132389, + "healthbench-hard": 0.52, + "med_dialog": 0.6374, + "medcasereasoning": 0.6950000000000001, + "medec": 0.6750418760469012, + "medexqa": 0.5707446808510639, + "medicationqa": 0.6615942028985506, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5903866248693834, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5245559038662486, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5798348245010323, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7900763358778626, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8773364485981309, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.7526315789473684 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5539350542569625, + "weighted_mean": 0.5495124252790476 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6939252336448598, + "careqa_open": 0.7822318526543879, + "healthbench": 0.4617, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.46485971125034053, + "healthbench-hard": 0.4245, + "med_dialog": 0.2694, + "medcasereasoning": 0.56, + "medec": 0.6365159128978224, + "medexqa": 0.6340425531914894, + "medicationqa": 0.3869565217391304, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6060606060606061, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5788923719958203, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5839642119752237, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5343511450381679, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5455607476635513, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.7 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6484352469578232, + "weighted_mean": 0.6506454946790553 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4929906542056075, + "careqa_open": 0.7228241242325749, + "healthbench": 0.6764, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6836011985834922, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7015, + "med_dialog": 0.882, + "medcasereasoning": 0.503, + "medec": 0.52428810720268, + "medexqa": 0.5047872340425532, + "medicationqa": 0.7050724637681159, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5595611285266457, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.554858934169279, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5498967653131452, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7938931297709924, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9018691588785047, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.618421052631579 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6646398439994512, + "weighted_mean": 0.6659973139548507 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.514018691588785, + "careqa_open": 0.6390393643914771, + "healthbench": 0.6976, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7062108417324979, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7284999999999999, + "med_dialog": 0.8808, + "medcasereasoning": 0.53, + "medec": 0.5795644891122278, + "medexqa": 0.5164893617021277, + "medicationqa": 0.7913043478260869, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5778474399164054, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5715778474399165, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5540261527873365, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7709923664122138, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9170560747663552, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6592105263157895 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.48469623489527125, + "weighted_mean": 0.4841316989039436 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5093457943925234, + "careqa_open": 0.501986276634164, + "healthbench": 0.4958, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4946880958866794, + "healthbench-hard": 0.47750000000000004, + "med_dialog": 0.35940000000000005, + "medcasereasoning": 0.48, + "medec": 0.6407035175879396, + "medexqa": 0.49308510638297876, + "medicationqa": 0.4652173913043478, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.49320794148380354, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.46081504702194354, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4910529938059188, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4389312977099237, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.46261682242990654, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.49078947368421055 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5742865942729863, + "weighted_mean": 0.5727730327083993 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6635514018691588, + "careqa_open": 0.710184182015168, + "healthbench": 0.5352, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5411332062108417, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5855, + "med_dialog": 0.49560000000000004, + "medcasereasoning": 0.516, + "medec": 0.6256281407035176, + "medexqa": 0.5218085106382979, + "medicationqa": 0.5101449275362319, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5559038662486938, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5271682340647859, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5313145216792843, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5305343511450382, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.6658878504672897, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6730263157894737 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6791368811318258, + "weighted_mean": 0.6746320271488723 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6331775700934579, + "careqa_open": 0.7013362224629831, + "healthbench": 0.6925, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7116589485153909, + "healthbench-hard": 0.6975, + "med_dialog": 0.608, + "medcasereasoning": 0.5800000000000001, + "medec": 0.6281407035175879, + "medexqa": 0.5787234042553191, + "medicationqa": 0.7913043478260869, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5987460815047022, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5731452455590387, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5739848589125947, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.866412213740458, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9532710280373832, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6782894736842106 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6017212247047373, + "weighted_mean": 0.5991363266242897 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6214953271028038, + "careqa_open": 0.7717587576742506, + "healthbench": 0.5864, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5949332606919095, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5995, + "med_dialog": 0.3118, + "medcasereasoning": 0.56, + "medec": 0.6566164154103853, + "medexqa": 0.5122340425531915, + "medicationqa": 0.4463768115942029, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6274817136886103, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.7084639498432602, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5867171369580179, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6374045801526718, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.6892523364485982, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.7171052631578947 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.7286202186692837, + "weighted_mean": 0.7224757675059674 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.7429906542056075, + "careqa_open": 0.7537016973636692, + "healthbench": 0.7104, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.7255516208117679, + "healthbench-hard": 0.725, + "med_dialog": 0.7178, + "medcasereasoning": 0.636, + "medec": 0.7629815745393634, + "medexqa": 0.573936170212766, + "medicationqa": 0.8768115942028986, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6300940438871473, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5877742946708464, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5973847212663455, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.9236641221374046, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9602803738317757, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.7335526315789473 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6955342205924482, + "weighted_mean": 0.6910677673447538 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.7079439252336449, + "careqa_open": 0.7313109425785482, + "healthbench": 0.6825, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6972214655407246, + "healthbench-hard": 0.6925, + "med_dialog": 0.5518, + "medcasereasoning": 0.596, + "medec": 0.6708542713567839, + "medexqa": 0.5569148936170213, + "medicationqa": 0.7115942028985507, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.7314524555903866, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.7398119122257053, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.6311080523055747, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.816793893129771, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8785046728971962, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.7322368421052632 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6223959303590847, + "weighted_mean": 0.6200305955560558 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5046728971962616, + "careqa_open": 0.5070422535211268, + "healthbench": 0.7096, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.715064015254699, + "healthbench-hard": 0.7315, + "med_dialog": 0.612, + "medcasereasoning": 0.528, + "medec": 0.5510887772194305, + "medexqa": 0.5196808510638298, + "medicationqa": 0.6289855072463768, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5480668756530825, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5078369905956113, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.522367515485203, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8244274809160306, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8960280373831776, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6519736842105263 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.8512461059190031, + "careqa_open": 0.8902130733116649, + "healthbench": 0.6372334165426798, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6571597469983929, + "healthbench-hard": 0.43322987094150006, + "med_dialog": 0.9053833333276805, + "medcasereasoning": 0.486, + "medec": 0.7045644891122278, + "medexqa": 0.8618351063829788, + "medicationqa": 0.9127415458871017, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.832810867293626, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.8166144200626959, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.7856159669649002, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8660941475801528, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9764408099614488, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.46842105263157896 + } + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5166180646864584, + "weighted_mean": 0.5160613633727644, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5416508898434692, + "weighted_mean": 0.5369837119056184 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.514018691588785, + "careqa_open": 0.5527266161068978, + "healthbench": 0.4275, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4267229637700899, + "healthbench-hard": 0.405, + "med_dialog": 0.7844, + "medcasereasoning": 0.635, + "medec": 0.5033500837520938, + "medexqa": 0.5585106382978724, + "medicationqa": 0.7014492753623188, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.46185997910135845, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.31191222570532917, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4910529938059188, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6450381679389313, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.6939252336448598, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5539473684210526 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4456339526562242, + "weighted_mean": 0.44416486988490067 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5747663551401869, + "careqa_open": 0.512639942217407, + "healthbench": 0.36339999999999995, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3549441569054753, + "healthbench-hard": 0.29900000000000004, + "med_dialog": 0.4668, + "medcasereasoning": 0.5, + "medec": 0.4715242881072027, + "medexqa": 0.623404255319149, + "medicationqa": 0.4311594202898551, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4806687565308255, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.3725182863113897, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4979353062629044, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.3702290076335878, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.3387850467289719, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.47236842105263155 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5346078355179628, + "weighted_mean": 0.5380410158695397 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.37850467289719625, + "careqa_open": 0.42109064644275906, + "healthbench": 0.5913999999999999, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5909833832743121, + "healthbench-hard": 0.6125, + "med_dialog": 0.9354, + "medcasereasoning": 0.44299999999999995, + "medec": 0.36767169179229475, + "medexqa": 0.4909574468085106, + "medicationqa": 0.7369565217391305, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4320794148380356, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.34430512016718917, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.45939435650378524, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6488549618320612, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7137850467289719, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3868421052631579 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5567863446437713, + "weighted_mean": 0.5582717595701124 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3808411214953271, + "careqa_open": 0.3362224629830264, + "healthbench": 0.6185, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6238082266412421, + "healthbench-hard": 0.653, + "med_dialog": 0.9322, + "medcasereasoning": 0.47, + "medec": 0.41876046901172526, + "medexqa": 0.5042553191489362, + "medicationqa": 0.8079710144927537, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4461859979101358, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.3594566353187043, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4676531314521679, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7061068702290076, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7546728971962617, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.42894736842105263 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.38172624483227485, + "weighted_mean": 0.383647528606557 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.38551401869158874, + "careqa_open": 0.2311303719754424, + "healthbench": 0.40280000000000005, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.39226368836829206, + "healthbench-hard": 0.35850000000000004, + "med_dialog": 0.5700000000000001, + "medcasereasoning": 0.42000000000000004, + "medec": 0.4656616415410385, + "medexqa": 0.4819148936170212, + "medicationqa": 0.5181159420289856, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3662486938349008, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.25391849529780564, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.40364762560220235, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.3129770992366412, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.27453271028037385, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.27039473684210524 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4645498881355444, + "weighted_mean": 0.4653031977298108 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5630841121495327, + "careqa_open": 0.42560491152040447, + "healthbench": 0.4436, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4374829746663035, + "healthbench-hard": 0.4655, + "med_dialog": 0.6734, + "medcasereasoning": 0.45599999999999996, + "medec": 0.4522613065326633, + "medexqa": 0.5111702127659574, + "medicationqa": 0.5507246376811594, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.422675026123302, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.3150470219435737, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4459738472126634, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.3969465648854962, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.4299065420560748, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.44342105263157894 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5827217319748788, + "weighted_mean": 0.5797889436429439 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5257009345794392, + "careqa_open": 0.45467677862044065, + "healthbench": 0.606, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6137292290928902, + "healthbench-hard": 0.6094999999999999, + "med_dialog": 0.7676000000000001, + "medcasereasoning": 0.52, + "medec": 0.46733668341708545, + "medexqa": 0.5638297872340425, + "medicationqa": 0.813768115942029, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4665621734587252, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.3610240334378265, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.487611837577426, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7404580152671756, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8586448598130841, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4671052631578947 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3982787752952627, + "weighted_mean": 0.4008636733757102 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.37850467289719625, + "careqa_open": 0.22824124232574938, + "healthbench": 0.41359999999999997, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.40506673930809045, + "healthbench-hard": 0.40049999999999997, + "med_dialog": 0.6881999999999999, + "medcasereasoning": 0.43999999999999995, + "medec": 0.3433835845896147, + "medexqa": 0.4877659574468085, + "medicationqa": 0.5536231884057972, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3725182863113897, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.2915360501567398, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.41328286304198214, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.36259541984732824, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.3107476635514018, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.2828947368421053 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6456603117713086, + "weighted_mean": 0.6406034269362315 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6705607476635514, + "careqa_open": 0.5606717226435536, + "healthbench": 0.6501, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6649414328520838, + "healthbench-hard": 0.653, + "med_dialog": 0.8446, + "medcasereasoning": 0.576, + "medec": 0.6038525963149078, + "medexqa": 0.5617021276595745, + "medicationqa": 0.8942028985507247, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5026123301985371, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.37565308254963425, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5106675843083276, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8587786259541985, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8703271028037384, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5328947368421053 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.6101705419664663, + "weighted_mean": 0.6076501428394234 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6308411214953271, + "careqa_open": 0.49837486457204766, + "healthbench": 0.6179, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6288477254154181, + "healthbench-hard": 0.6175, + "med_dialog": 0.7358, + "medcasereasoning": 0.536, + "medec": 0.5050251256281407, + "medexqa": 0.5452127659574468, + "medicationqa": 0.7644927536231884, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6086729362591432, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5407523510971787, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5485203028217481, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7251908396946565, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7313084112149533, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5282894736842105 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.52101219491388, + "weighted_mean": 0.5213567267395609 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.38317757009345793, + "careqa_open": 0.23763091368725173, + "healthbench": 0.6366, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.6344320348678835, + "healthbench-hard": 0.6555, + "med_dialog": 0.7746, + "medcasereasoning": 0.468, + "medec": 0.3877721943048576, + "medexqa": 0.5069148936170212, + "medicationqa": 0.6782608695652174, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.41901776384535006, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.30250783699059564, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4353062629043359, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7022900763358778, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.6845794392523364, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4296052631578947 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.748442367601246, + "careqa_open": 0.7604730949801373, + "healthbench": 0.5721260313865798, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5877756010898391, + "healthbench-hard": 0.34484246230409993, + "med_dialog": 0.9384166666637204, + "medcasereasoning": 0.366, + "medec": 0.3914363484087102, + "medexqa": 0.8465425531914894, + "medicationqa": 0.9172705313960873, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6013584117032393, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4456635318704284, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.6582931865106676, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.8314249363885494, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9336059190007011, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.1361842105263158 + } + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.35752778288367726, + "weighted_mean": 0.3634064599826541, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3796029854217344, + "weighted_mean": 0.3821435529365495 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3387850467289719, + "careqa_open": 0.4734561213434453, + "healthbench": 0.28879999999999995, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.27826205393625714, + "healthbench-hard": 0.269, + "med_dialog": 0.4226, + "medcasereasoning": 0.5589999999999999, + "medec": 0.3844221105527639, + "medexqa": 0.4936170212765958, + "medicationqa": 0.2202898550724638, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.46238244514106586, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4263322884012539, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.48141775636613904, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.22519083969465647, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.23364485981308414, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5164473684210527 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.31790952995939936, + "weighted_mean": 0.3207261970542373 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.383177570093458, + "careqa_open": 0.4433008306247743, + "healthbench": 0.24439999999999995, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.22868428221193138, + "healthbench-hard": 0.1995, + "med_dialog": 0.132, + "medcasereasoning": 0.42400000000000004, + "medec": 0.3752093802345059, + "medexqa": 0.551595744680851, + "medicationqa": 0.086231884057971, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4770114942528736, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.48537095088819227, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.48451479697178257, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.08396946564885499, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.051401869158878455, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.43618421052631584 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.38475429937707684, + "weighted_mean": 0.39669485151873446 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.25934579439252337, + "careqa_open": 0.3757674250631997, + "healthbench": 0.45109999999999995, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4370743666575865, + "healthbench-hard": 0.4595, + "med_dialog": 0.7098, + "medcasereasoning": 0.367, + "medec": 0.2805695142378559, + "medexqa": 0.42978723404255315, + "medicationqa": 0.2202898550724638, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.42946708463949845, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4649947753396029, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.45147969717825187, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.1870229007633588, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.2710280373831776, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.36184210526315785 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.40419712095621574, + "weighted_mean": 0.41431555928522795 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.27336448598130836, + "careqa_open": 0.31581798483206935, + "healthbench": 0.4656, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4596840098065922, + "healthbench-hard": 0.49050000000000005, + "med_dialog": 0.7028, + "medcasereasoning": 0.394, + "medec": 0.31909547738693467, + "medexqa": 0.44202127659574464, + "medicationqa": 0.30797101449275366, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4446185997910136, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.48223615464994773, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4562973158981418, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.23664122137404575, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.27453271028037385, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.40197368421052626 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.25997519848250394, + "weighted_mean": 0.26542947515545495 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.26869158878504673, + "careqa_open": 0.24882629107981225, + "healthbench": 0.28859999999999997, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.27526559520566607, + "healthbench-hard": 0.25149999999999995, + "med_dialog": 0.18120000000000003, + "medcasereasoning": 0.344, + "medec": 0.3182579564489112, + "medexqa": 0.42340425531914894, + "medicationqa": 0.10579710144927534, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.36520376175548586, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.367816091954023, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.3947006194081212, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.04961832061068705, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.028037383177570097, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.24868421052631584 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3274832707576762, + "weighted_mean": 0.33226470413436543 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.383177570093458, + "careqa_open": 0.3797399783315276, + "healthbench": 0.32220000000000004, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.31190411332062107, + "healthbench-hard": 0.3405, + "med_dialog": 0.27380000000000004, + "medcasereasoning": 0.38, + "medec": 0.3324958123953099, + "medexqa": 0.4457446808510638, + "medicationqa": 0.15434782608695652, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4221525600835946, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.42946708463949845, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.43530626290433583, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.13358778625954193, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.07359813084112155, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4217105263157894 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.431166503104172, + "weighted_mean": 0.4348909007676491 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3738317757009346, + "careqa_open": 0.3931022029613579, + "healthbench": 0.4689, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.46758376464178697, + "healthbench-hard": 0.46399999999999997, + "med_dialog": 0.39759999999999995, + "medcasereasoning": 0.44399999999999995, + "medec": 0.35092127303182574, + "medexqa": 0.501595744680851, + "medicationqa": 0.4014492753623189, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.46238244514106586, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.48275862068965514, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4796971782518926, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.3015267175572519, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.4731308411214953, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.43618421052631584 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.2713797813307163, + "weighted_mean": 0.2775242324940327 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.2570093457943925, + "careqa_open": 0.2462983026363308, + "healthbench": 0.28959999999999997, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.27444837918823206, + "healthbench-hard": 0.275, + "med_dialog": 0.2822, + "medcasereasoning": 0.364, + "medec": 0.23701842546063656, + "medexqa": 0.426063829787234, + "medicationqa": 0.12318840579710144, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3699059561128527, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4122257053291536, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.40261527873365455, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.07633587786259544, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.03971962616822433, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.26644736842105265 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.35433968822869144, + "weighted_mean": 0.3593965730637685 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.32943925233644855, + "careqa_open": 0.4393282773564464, + "healthbench": 0.3499, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.33505856714791615, + "healthbench-hard": 0.347, + "med_dialog": 0.15539999999999998, + "medcasereasoning": 0.42400000000000004, + "medec": 0.39614740368509216, + "medexqa": 0.4382978723404255, + "medicationqa": 0.10579710144927534, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4973876698014629, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6243469174503657, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4893324156916724, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.14122137404580148, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.12967289719626163, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4671052631578947 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.438734888141451, + "weighted_mean": 0.4436161528093554 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.42289719626168226, + "careqa_open": 0.444564824846515, + "healthbench": 0.4548, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4496050122582403, + "healthbench-hard": 0.4405, + "med_dialog": 0.3494, + "medcasereasoning": 0.46, + "medec": 0.4036850921273032, + "medexqa": 0.4765957446808511, + "medicationqa": 0.23768115942028986, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6128526645768025, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.658307210031348, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.540949759119064, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.26717557251908397, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.3014018691588785, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4993421052631579 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.36326234596081297, + "weighted_mean": 0.3704688605898195 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.25934579439252337, + "careqa_open": 0.25424340917298666, + "healthbench": 0.4918, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.47834377553800056, + "healthbench-hard": 0.4975, + "med_dialog": 0.3822, + "medcasereasoning": 0.392, + "medec": 0.2989949748743719, + "medexqa": 0.44468085106382976, + "medicationqa": 0.1536231884057971, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4148380355276907, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.41327063740856845, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.42601514108740535, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.29389312977099236, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.21144859813084113, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5560747663551402, + "careqa_open": 0.5976435536294691, + "healthbench": 0.47731019386368007, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.49064903846488706, + "healthbench-hard": 0.2466513426104, + "med_dialog": 0.8494333333297603, + "medcasereasoning": 0.214, + "medec": 0.2505234505862647, + "medexqa": 0.7621010638297873, + "medicationqa": 0.7509057970992754, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6018808777429467, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6598746081504702, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.6414315209910529, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.6917938931297711, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8168808411247662, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.0993421052631579 + } + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4111332584873301, + "weighted_mean": 0.41304451718604834, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4395559322963161, + "weighted_mean": 0.4381694322788999 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.383177570093458, + "careqa_open": 0.5424340917298665, + "healthbench": 0.33199999999999996, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.32852083900844453, + "healthbench-hard": 0.31699999999999995, + "med_dialog": 0.5800000000000001, + "medcasereasoning": 0.599, + "medec": 0.48994974874371855, + "medexqa": 0.5175531914893616, + "medicationqa": 0.47681159420289854, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3573667711598746, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.27638453500522464, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4401238816242258, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.43511450381679384, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.4357476635514018, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5217105263157895 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3527187745622218, + "weighted_mean": 0.3529786470876801 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4532710280373832, + "careqa_open": 0.5079451065366558, + "healthbench": 0.28290000000000004, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.2692726777444838, + "healthbench-hard": 0.23099999999999998, + "med_dialog": 0.23760000000000003, + "medcasereasoning": 0.46399999999999997, + "medec": 0.46733668341708545, + "medexqa": 0.5755319148936171, + "medicationqa": 0.19927536231884058, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3688610240334378, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.33176593521421105, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4456297315898142, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.2290076335877863, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.13668224299065423, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.44342105263157894 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.44092591578942647, + "weighted_mean": 0.44771183105049517 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3060747663551402, + "careqa_open": 0.4404117009750813, + "healthbench": 0.49139999999999995, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4827022609643149, + "healthbench-hard": 0.513, + "med_dialog": 0.8074, + "medcasereasoning": 0.40700000000000003, + "medec": 0.3726968174204355, + "medexqa": 0.4457446808510638, + "medicationqa": 0.4644927536231884, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3260188087774295, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.3134796238244514, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.41190640055058503, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4312977099236641, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.4707943925233645, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3703947368421052 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.459622119155011, + "weighted_mean": 0.4647820148237988 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3060747663551402, + "careqa_open": 0.36366919465511016, + "healthbench": 0.5065999999999999, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.49904658131299373, + "healthbench-hard": 0.53, + "med_dialog": 0.8132, + "medcasereasoning": 0.43400000000000005, + "medec": 0.4179229480737019, + "medexqa": 0.4595744680851064, + "medicationqa": 0.5789855072463768, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3385579937304075, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.3249738766980146, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4174122505161735, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4580152671755725, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.40592105263157896 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.29147479873831494, + "weighted_mean": 0.29557589115923866 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.30140186915887845, + "careqa_open": 0.26959191043698083, + "healthbench": 0.31679999999999997, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3005992917461182, + "healthbench-hard": 0.28800000000000003, + "med_dialog": 0.32899999999999996, + "medcasereasoning": 0.384, + "medec": 0.44388609715242877, + "medexqa": 0.43776595744680846, + "medicationqa": 0.26884057971014497, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.26489028213166144, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.22309299895506796, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.35856847900894706, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.12595419847328249, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.09462616822429903, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.256578947368421 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3712260810085125, + "weighted_mean": 0.3739583014141692 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.46261682242990654, + "careqa_open": 0.43680028891296496, + "healthbench": 0.36619999999999997, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.35562517025333695, + "healthbench-hard": 0.39, + "med_dialog": 0.43620000000000003, + "medcasereasoning": 0.42000000000000004, + "medec": 0.431323283082077, + "medexqa": 0.4659574468085106, + "medicationqa": 0.3050724637681159, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3171368861024033, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.2816091954022989, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.3998623537508603, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.2557251908396947, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.19509345794392519, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.42039473684210527 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.4920964067932719, + "weighted_mean": 0.4904336457493962 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4228971962616822, + "careqa_open": 0.45521849042975804, + "healthbench": 0.5132, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.51348406428766, + "healthbench-hard": 0.507, + "med_dialog": 0.5434, + "medcasereasoning": 0.484, + "medec": 0.4522613065326633, + "medexqa": 0.5234042553191489, + "medicationqa": 0.6195652173913043, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3662486938349008, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.3265412748171369, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.43977976600137647, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5801526717557253, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.6869158878504673, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.43947368421052635 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3044657794075518, + "weighted_mean": 0.3089322326552461 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.2920560747663551, + "careqa_open": 0.26868905742145177, + "healthbench": 0.3175, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3027785344592754, + "healthbench-hard": 0.3075, + "med_dialog": 0.44820000000000004, + "medcasereasoning": 0.404, + "medec": 0.3291457286432161, + "medexqa": 0.4430851063829787, + "medicationqa": 0.2884057971014493, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.26854754440961337, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.2601880877742947, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.36889194769442535, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.18320610687022898, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.12149532710280375, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.2677631578947368 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.3898294580335338, + "weighted_mean": 0.39234985716057663 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3691588785046729, + "careqa_open": 0.5016251354279524, + "healthbench": 0.3821, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3711522745845819, + "healthbench-hard": 0.38249999999999995, + "med_dialog": 0.2642, + "medcasereasoning": 0.46399999999999997, + "medec": 0.4949748743718593, + "medexqa": 0.45478723404255317, + "medicationqa": 0.23550724637681164, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.3913270637408568, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.4592476489028213, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.45147969717825187, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.2748091603053435, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.26869158878504673, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.47171052631578947 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.561265111858549, + "weighted_mean": 0.5563838471906447 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5771028037383177, + "careqa_open": 0.555435175153485, + "healthbench": 0.5452, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5503949877417598, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5595, + "med_dialog": 0.6506000000000001, + "medcasereasoning": 0.54, + "medec": 0.5963149078726968, + "medexqa": 0.5234042553191489, + "medicationqa": 0.7623188405797101, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.38714733542319746, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.34169278996865204, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.45905024088093604, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.732824427480916, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.6985981308411215, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5006578947368421 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.419285465717922, + "weighted_mean": 0.4222139884763859 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.3037383177570093, + "careqa_open": 0.27591188154568436, + "healthbench": 0.5334, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5247888858621629, + "healthbench-hard": 0.54, + "med_dialog": 0.5532, + "medcasereasoning": 0.432, + "medec": 0.3777219430485762, + "medexqa": 0.4627659574468085, + "medicationqa": 0.39492753623188404, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.31400208986415884, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.27063740856844304, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.3909153475567791, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5076335877862596, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.41705607476635514, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4098684210526316 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6277258566978193, + "careqa_open": 0.6733026363308053, + "healthbench": 0.50901612474718, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5247080214118226, + "healthbench-hard": 0.28069416977380013, + "med_dialog": 0.8853333333278802, + "medcasereasoning": 0.294, + "medec": 0.4028475711892797, + "medexqa": 0.8027925531914893, + "medicationqa": 0.8467995169052176, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4049111807732497, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.3772204806687565, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5829318651066758, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.772900763359542, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.8796728971999997, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.10526315789473684 + } + }, + "sonnet-4_5": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5002880171007762, + "weighted_mean": 0.49977366098330706, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "vs": { + "baichuan-m2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5239048246863384, + "weighted_mean": 0.5197918686308399 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6074766355140186, + "careqa_open": 0.7611050920910076, + "healthbench": 0.3113, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.31408335603377824, + "healthbench-hard": 0.29000000000000004, + "med_dialog": 0.5286, + "medcasereasoning": 0.667, + "medec": 0.6256281407035176, + "medexqa": 0.5531914893617021, + "medicationqa": 0.5528985507246377, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5444096133751306, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5151515151515151, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5571231933929801, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4122137404580153, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5245327102803738, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6177631578947369 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "baichuan-m3": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.437801420639165, + "weighted_mean": 0.43707745195558895 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6892523364485981, + "careqa_open": 0.7721198988804623, + "healthbench": 0.2761, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.27526559520566607, + "healthbench-hard": 0.22450000000000003, + "med_dialog": 0.18879999999999997, + "medcasereasoning": 0.532, + "medec": 0.576214405360134, + "medexqa": 0.6180851063829786, + "medicationqa": 0.27753623188405796, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5621734587251829, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5689655172413793, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5612525808671713, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.19083969465648853, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.14369158878504673, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5480263157894737 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5264097263705085, + "weighted_mean": 0.5315032982858228 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.485981308411215, + "careqa_open": 0.7125315998555435, + "healthbench": 0.45409999999999995, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.45083083628439113, + "healthbench-hard": 0.47050000000000003, + "med_dialog": 0.8102, + "medcasereasoning": 0.475, + "medec": 0.47068676716917923, + "medexqa": 0.48670212765957444, + "medicationqa": 0.5768115942028986, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5130616509926855, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5454545454545454, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5268410185822436, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4122137404580153, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.572429906542056, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.4592105263157895 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "glm-4.7-fp8": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5457005527572163, + "weighted_mean": 0.5488700751847396 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5163551401869159, + "careqa_open": 0.631274828457927, + "healthbench": 0.473, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4731680740942522, + "healthbench-hard": 0.489, + "med_dialog": 0.8038, + "medcasereasoning": 0.502, + "medec": 0.5226130653266332, + "medexqa": 0.4952127659574468, + "medicationqa": 0.6710144927536232, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5339602925809822, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5663531870428422, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5344115622849277, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.4427480916030534, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5782710280373832, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.49802631578947365 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-5_2": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.36431397228032275, + "weighted_mean": 0.36591885474884805 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.5046728971962617, + "careqa_open": 0.4949440231130372, + "healthbench": 0.28390000000000004, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.2792154726232634, + "healthbench-hard": 0.24150000000000005, + "med_dialog": 0.262, + "medcasereasoning": 0.45199999999999996, + "medec": 0.5896147403685092, + "medexqa": 0.4765957446808511, + "medicationqa": 0.3405797101449275, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.4435736677115988, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.45141065830721006, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.4683413626978665, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.12213740458015265, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.08761682242990654, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.3309210526315789 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.45304864592711575, + "weighted_mean": 0.454455182469838 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6682242990654206, + "careqa_open": 0.6995305164319249, + "healthbench": 0.34550000000000003, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.3473168074094253, + "healthbench-hard": 0.354, + "med_dialog": 0.3762, + "medcasereasoning": 0.488, + "medec": 0.5737018425460636, + "medexqa": 0.5037234042553191, + "medicationqa": 0.4043478260869565, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5015673981191222, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5219435736677116, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5075705437026841, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.20610687022900764, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.23130841121495327, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5197368421052632 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.5779449823995714, + "weighted_mean": 0.5739637109025215 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6331775700934579, + "careqa_open": 0.6917659804983749, + "healthbench": 0.4917, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5012258240261509, + "healthbench-hard": 0.487, + "med_dialog": 0.5024, + "medcasereasoning": 0.552, + "medec": 0.5795644891122278, + "medexqa": 0.5622340425531915, + "medicationqa": 0.7115942028985507, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5506792058516197, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5700104493207941, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5495526496902959, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.5648854961832062, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7605140186915887, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5388157894736842 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "gpt_5_1": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.37760406964091525, + "weighted_mean": 0.3799694044439443 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.4953271028037384, + "careqa_open": 0.49295774647887325, + "healthbench": 0.2904, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.284935984745301, + "healthbench-hard": 0.26849999999999996, + "med_dialog": 0.388, + "medcasereasoning": 0.472, + "medec": 0.4489112227805695, + "medexqa": 0.4803191489361702, + "medicationqa": 0.3710144927536232, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.45193312434691746, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.49216300940438873, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.477632484514797, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.17557251908396942, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.1039719626168224, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.34802631578947374 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-235b-a22b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.47898780508612004, + "weighted_mean": 0.47864327326043915 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6168224299065421, + "careqa_open": 0.7623690863127482, + "healthbench": 0.36339999999999995, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.36556796513211653, + "healthbench-hard": 0.34450000000000003, + "med_dialog": 0.22540000000000004, + "medcasereasoning": 0.532, + "medec": 0.6122278056951425, + "medexqa": 0.49308510638297876, + "medicationqa": 0.32173913043478264, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.58098223615465, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.6974921630094044, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5646937370956642, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.2977099236641222, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.31542056074766356, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5703947368421053 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-3-8b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.636737654039187, + "weighted_mean": 0.6295311394101805 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.7406542056074766, + "careqa_open": 0.7457565908270134, + "healthbench": 0.5082, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5216562244619994, + "healthbench-hard": 0.5025, + "med_dialog": 0.6178, + "medcasereasoning": 0.608, + "medec": 0.7010050251256281, + "medexqa": 0.5553191489361702, + "medicationqa": 0.8463768115942029, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.5851619644723093, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.5867293625914316, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.5739848589125947, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7061068702290076, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.7885514018691588, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.6 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + }, + "qwen-30b-a3b": { + "mean_winrate": { + "simple_mean": 0.580714534282078, + "weighted_mean": 0.5777860115236141 + }, + "per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.6962616822429907, + "careqa_open": 0.7240881184543156, + "healthbench": 0.4666, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.4752111141378371, + "healthbench-hard": 0.45999999999999996, + "med_dialog": 0.4468, + "medcasereasoning": 0.5680000000000001, + "medec": 0.6222780569514238, + "medexqa": 0.5372340425531915, + "medicationqa": 0.605072463768116, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.6859979101358411, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.7293625914315569, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.609084652443221, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.49236641221374045, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.5829439252336448, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.5901315789473685 + }, + "n_datasets": 16 + } + }, + "avg_reward_per_dataset": { + "agentclinic": 0.8512461059190031, + "careqa_open": 0.8761285662694114, + "healthbench": 0.49290665059674, + "healthbench-consensus": 0.5184275749085809, + "healthbench-hard": 0.258477021099, + "med_dialog": 0.8777833333295204, + "medcasereasoning": 0.43, + "medec": 0.5710845896147404, + "medexqa": 0.8470744680851063, + "medicationqa": 0.8808574879182611, + "medrbench-1turn": 0.745559038662487, + "medrbench-free_turn": 0.8035527690700105, + "medrbench-oracle": 0.7539573296627667, + "mtsamples_procedures": 0.7735368956717555, + "mtsamples_replicate": 0.9069314641827098, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": 0.24144736842105263 + } + } + }, + "datasets": { + "agentclinic": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.7289719626168223, + "baichuan-m3": 0.6876947040498442, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.8590342679127725, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.8403426791277259, + "gpt-5_2": 0.8411214953271028, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.6814641744548287, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.6985981308411215, + "gpt_5_1": 0.8512461059190031, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.748442367601246, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.5560747663551402, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.6277258566978193, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.8512461059190031 + }, + "n_questions": 214 + }, + "careqa_open": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.6799837486457205, + "baichuan-m3": 0.7526182737450343, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.8199711087035031, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.8324756229685807, + "gpt-5_2": 0.886240520043337, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.7972192127121704, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.7517605633802817, + "gpt_5_1": 0.8902130733116649, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.7604730949801373, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.5976435536294691, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.6733026363308053, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.8761285662694114 + }, + "n_questions": 2769 + }, + "healthbench": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.6114454854915201, + "baichuan-m3": 0.6563826236934, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.5217291270739801, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.5066618267071602, + "gpt-5_2": 0.6425131851590002, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.58873751323822, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.47421080674018, + "gpt_5_1": 0.6372334165426798, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.5721260313865798, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.47731019386368007, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.50901612474718, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.49290665059674 + }, + "n_questions": 5000 + }, + "healthbench-consensus": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.6225656967113322, + "baichuan-m3": 0.6732684273430403, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.5443080117437755, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.5278327410663035, + "gpt-5_2": 0.6616405505189322, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.6044610673445654, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.48830851937853437, + "gpt_5_1": 0.6571597469983929, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.5877756010898391, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.49064903846488706, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.5247080214118226, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.5184275749085809 + }, + "n_questions": 3671 + }, + "healthbench-hard": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.40711079593569993, + "baichuan-m3": 0.4820732801699001, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.2773563324638, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.2513393535702001, + "gpt-5_2": 0.44951984604649986, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.36203839069989996, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.26149495826490005, + "gpt_5_1": 0.43322987094150006, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.34484246230409993, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.2466513426104, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.28069416977380013, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.258477021099 + }, + "n_questions": 1000 + }, + "med_dialog": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.8688999999960803, + "baichuan-m3": 0.9460999999955604, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.7966666666648804, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.7980333333304802, + "gpt-5_2": 0.9300999999906407, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.9035499999950405, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.8722833333292803, + "gpt_5_1": 0.9053833333276805, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.9384166666637204, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.8494333333297603, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.8853333333278802, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.8777833333295204 + }, + "n_questions": 2500 + }, + "medcasereasoning": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.096, + "baichuan-m3": 0.366, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.48, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.426, + "gpt-5_2": 0.526, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.454, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.326, + "gpt_5_1": 0.486, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.366, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.214, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.294, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.43 + }, + "n_questions": 500 + }, + "medec": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.42409966499162477, + "baichuan-m3": 0.478643216080402, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.5847989949748744, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.5205192629815746, + "gpt-5_2": 0.5264865996649917, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.5196817420435511, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.4975921273031826, + "gpt_5_1": 0.7045644891122278, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.3914363484087102, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.2505234505862647, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.4028475711892797, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.5710845896147404 + }, + "n_questions": 597 + }, + "medexqa": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.7829787234042553, + "baichuan-m3": 0.722872340425532, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.8659574468085106, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.8469414893617021, + "gpt-5_2": 0.8692819148936171, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.8283244680851064, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.7501329787234042, + "gpt_5_1": 0.8618351063829788, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.8465425531914894, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.7621010638297873, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.8027925531914893, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.8470744680851063 + }, + "n_questions": 940 + }, + "medicationqa": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.8471014492723188, + "baichuan-m3": 0.9273550724573916, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.8718599033757972, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.8388285024110146, + "gpt-5_2": 0.9172705313942029, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.8884661835708697, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.7751811594150725, + "gpt_5_1": 0.9127415458871017, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.9172705313960873, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.7509057970992754, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.8467995169052176, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.8808574879182611 + }, + "n_questions": 690 + }, + "medrbench-1turn": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.6692789968652038, + "baichuan-m3": 0.6426332288401254, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.725705329153605, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.6954022988505747, + "gpt-5_2": 0.841692789968652, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.7408568443051202, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.6593521421107628, + "gpt_5_1": 0.832810867293626, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.6013584117032393, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.6018808777429467, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.4049111807732497, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.745559038662487 + }, + "n_questions": 957 + }, + "medrbench-free_turn": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.7826541274817137, + "baichuan-m3": 0.6849529780564263, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.7225705329153606, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.6948798328108673, + "gpt-5_2": 0.8908045977011494, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.7748171368861024, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.690700104493208, + "gpt_5_1": 0.8166144200626959, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.4456635318704284, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.6598746081504702, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.3772204806687565, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.8035527690700105 + }, + "n_questions": 957 + }, + "medrbench-oracle": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.669993117687543, + "baichuan-m3": 0.6648313833448039, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.7260839642119752, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.713351686166552, + "gpt-5_2": 0.8000688231245698, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.739504473503097, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.6810048176187199, + "gpt_5_1": 0.7856159669649002, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.6582931865106676, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.6414315209910529, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.5829318651066758, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.7539573296627667 + }, + "n_questions": 1453 + }, + "mtsamples_procedures": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.7932569974564883, + "baichuan-m3": 0.8584605597961831, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.802162849873282, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.7856234096679389, + "gpt-5_2": 0.8874045801503816, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.8648218829473283, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.7560432569938927, + "gpt_5_1": 0.8660941475801528, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.8314249363885494, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.6917938931297711, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.772900763359542, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.7735368956717555 + }, + "n_questions": 131 + }, + "mtsamples_replicate": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.8969042056081775, + "baichuan-m3": 0.9677764797446262, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.8921339563873831, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.8857087227408882, + "gpt-5_2": 0.9806269470322435, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.9542445482794395, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.8275895638654205, + "gpt_5_1": 0.9764408099614488, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.9336059190007011, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.8168808411247662, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.8796728971999997, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.9069314641827098 + }, + "n_questions": 428 + }, + "pubhealthbench_freeform": { + "avg_reward_per_model": { + "baichuan-m2": 0.07368421052631578, + "baichuan-m3": 0.16381578947368422, + "gemini-3-pro-preview": 0.3013157894736842, + "glm-4.7-fp8": 0.24144736842105263, + "gpt-5_2": 0.48092105263157897, + "gpt-oss-120b-high": 0.21118421052631578, + "gpt-oss-20b-high": 0.19276315789473683, + "gpt_5_1": 0.46842105263157896, + "qwen-235b-a22b": 0.1361842105263158, + "qwen-3-8b": 0.0993421052631579, + "qwen-30b-a3b": 0.10526315789473684, + "sonnet-4_5": 0.24144736842105263 + }, + "n_questions": 760 + } + } +} \ No newline at end of file