anonymous-submission-acl2025's picture
add 14
caa8075
######################################################################
##### ESLR - Temporal External Validity Exercise - AgCensus Data #####
######################################################################
rm(list = ls()) # Clear variables
require(foreign)
require(ggplot2)
require(rgdal)
require(rgeos)
require(RColorBrewer) # creates nice color schemes
require(maptools) # loads sp library too
require(scales) # customize scales
require(gridExtra) # mutiple plots
require(plyr) # join function
require(dplyr)
require(mapproj) # projection tools
require(raster) # raster tools
require(ggvis) # visualize estimators
require(rdrobust) # rd estimation tools
require(stringdist) # approximate string matching
require(gdata)
require(rdd) # sorting tests
require(stargazer) # format tables
require(haven)
require(readstata13)
require(lfe) # fixed effects regressions
########################################
## Load IV Censo Agropecuario Data:
censo_ag_wreform <- read.dta13(file="Data/censo_ag_wreform.dta")
########################################
aesthetics <- list(#guides(color=guide_colorbar(reverse=FALSE)),
#guides(fill=FALSE),
#guides(shape=FALSE),
#guides(size=FALSE),
coord_equal(),
theme_bw(),
theme(
text=element_text(family="Palatino"),
#legend.title=element_blank(),
#legend.justification=c(0,0),
#legend.position= "right", #c(1,0),
panel.grid.minor=element_blank(),
panel.grid.major=element_blank(),
axis.line=element_blank(),
#panel.border=element_blank(),
#axis.ticks.y = element_blank(),
#axis.ticks.x = element_blank(),
axis.text.x=element_text(angle=45, hjust=1,size=11,face="bold")))
#axis.title.y=element_blank()))
########################################
## Prepare the Crop Price Datasets:
# Grains and Coffee in El Salvador from FAOStat since 2005 to 2012:
fao_es_grains <- read.csv(file="Data/Prices/FAO_Price_Data/data_table_GIEWSFPMATOOL.csv",header=TRUE)
fao_es_coffee <- read.csv(file="Data/Prices/FAO_Price_Data/FAOSTAT_data_5-21-2017-Coffee.csv",header=TRUE)
fao_sugarcane <- read.csv(file="Data/Prices/FAO_Price_Data/SugarPrices.csv",header=TRUE)
# Sugar Cane in El Salvador from MAG Since 2005 to 2017:
mag_es_sugarcane <- read.csv(file="Data/Prices/MAG/RETROSPECTIVA DE PRECIOS DE AZUCAR.csv",header=TRUE)
# Grains in El Salvador from MAG Since 2001 to 2017:
mag_es_maize <- read.csv(file="Data/Prices/MAG/RETROSPECTIVA DE GRANOS BASICOS 2001-2017 - Maiz.csv",header=TRUE)
mag_es_rice <- read.csv(file="Data/Prices/MAG/RETROSPECTIVA DE GRANOS BASICOS 2001-2017 - Arroz.csv",header=TRUE)
mag_es_sorghum <- read.csv(file="Data/Prices/MAG/RETROSPECTIVA DE GRANOS BASICOS 2001-2017 - Maicillo.csv",header=TRUE)
mag_es_beansI <- read.csv(file="Data/Prices/MAG/RETROSPECTIVA DE GRANOS BASICOS 2001-2017 - Frijol Rojo de Seda.csv",header=TRUE)
mag_es_beans <- read.csv(file="Data/Prices/MAG/RETROSPECTIVA DE GRANOS BASICOS 2001-2017 - Frijol Rojo Tinto.csv",header=TRUE)
## NOTE: On Beans, FAO reported price for "beans" matches MAG Frijol Rojo Tinto prices and not Frijo Rojo de Seda, so using that one for now as AG Census doesn't differentiate.
# Coffee Prices from the Consejo Salvadoreno del Cafe - 1987-2017:
csc_es_coffee <- read.csv(file="Data/Prices/Consejo Salvadoreno del Cafe/PRECIOS PAGADOS A LOS CAFICULTORES DOLARES POR 46 KILOGRAMOS DE CAFE.csv",header=TRUE)
## NOTE: For MAG prices, cannot use post-2015 data without changing calcs since measurement changed that year
########################################
## Clean Crop Price Datasets:
# Coffee:
coffee_prices <- dplyr::select(csc_es_coffee, Year = ANO, Coffee_Price = ANUAL)
coffee_prices <- filter(coffee_prices, !is.na(Year))
coffee_prices <- mutate(coffee_prices, Coffee_Price2 = Coffee_Price, Coffee_Price = Coffee_Price/0.46)
# Sugar Cane:
sugar_cane_prices <- filter(mag_es_sugarcane, Columna1 == "MAYORISTA (QQ)")
sugar_cane_prices <- dplyr::select(sugar_cane_prices, Year = ANO, Sugar_Cane_Price = PROMEDIO)
# Converting Prices from Quintales to Toneladas in El Salvador: http://www.one.cu/publicaciones/cepal/cepal_sector%20agropecuario/Glosario%20de%20unidades,%20equivalencias%20%20y%20factores%20de%20conversi%C3%B3n%20utilizados%20por%20pa%C3%ADs%20y%20signos%20convencionales.pdf
# Note: 1 QQ = 46 kilograms in ES; in Ag Census, tonelada is TONELADA CORTA = 0.92 Metric Tons.
# Metric ton = 1000 kg -> 0.92 = 920 kg = > 1 Tonelada Corta = 20 QQ in ES
# Ton Corta = 2000 pounds = 907.1847 kg -> 19.7
# Since SC prices only go back to 2005, check out future prices from FAO
fao_sugarcane_prices <- dplyr::select(fao_sugarcane, Year, Month, Monthly_Price = INTERNATIONAL.PRICES..Export..ICE.futures.US..Sugar..US.Dollar.kg)
fao_sugarcane_prices <- mutate(fao_sugarcane_prices, Monthly_Price = Monthly_Price*46) ## Note: Converting from USD/kg to USD/Quintal *46
fao_sugarcane_prices <- summarise(group_by(fao_sugarcane_prices, Year), Intl_Sugar_Cane_Price = mean(Monthly_Price))
# Way more volatile than ES prices
# Maize:
maize_prices <- dplyr::select(mag_es_maize, Year = ANO, Maize_Price = PROMEDIO)
# Beans:
bean_prices <- dplyr::select(mag_es_beans, Year = ANO, Beans_Price = PROMEDIO)
########################################
## Join Crop Price Datasets:
prices <- left_join(coffee_prices,sugar_cane_prices, by="Year")
prices <- left_join(prices,maize_prices, by="Year")
prices <- left_join(prices,bean_prices, by="Year")
prices <- left_join(prices,fao_sugarcane_prices, by="Year")
prices
########################################
lm.beta <- function (MOD, dta,y="ln_agprod")
{
b <- MOD$coef[1]
model.dta <- filter(dta, norm_dist > -1*MOD$bws["h","left"] & norm_dist < MOD$bws["h","right"] )
sx <- sd(model.dta[,c("Above500")])
#sx <- sd(model.dta[,c("norm_dist")])
sy <- sd((model.dta[,c(y)]),na.rm=TRUE)
beta <- b * sx/sy
return(beta)
}
lm.beta.ses <- function (MOD, dta,y="ln_agprod")
{
b <- MOD$se[1]
model.dta <- filter(dta, norm_dist > -1*MOD$bws["h","left"] & norm_dist < MOD$bws["h","right"] )
sx <- sd(model.dta[,c("Above500")])
#sx <- sd(model.dta[,c("norm_dist")])
sy <- sd((model.dta[,c(y)]),na.rm=TRUE)
beta <- b * sx/sy
return(beta)
}
winsor <- function (x, fraction=.01)
{
if(length(fraction) != 1 || fraction < 0 ||
fraction > 0.5) {
stop("bad value for 'fraction'")
}
lim <- quantile(x, probs=c(fraction, 1-fraction),na.rm = TRUE)
x[ x < lim[1] ] <- NA #lim[1] 8888
x[ x > lim[2] ] <- NA #lim[2] 8888
x
}
winsor1 <- function (x, fraction=.01)
{
if(length(fraction) != 1 || fraction < 0 ||
fraction > 0.5) {
stop("bad value for 'fraction'")
}
lim <- quantile(x, probs=c(fraction, 1-fraction),na.rm = TRUE)
x[ x < lim[1] ] <- lim[1] #lim[1] 8888
x[ x > lim[2] ] <- lim[2] #lim[2] 8888
x
}
winsor2 <-function (x, multiple=3)
{
if(length(multiple) != 1 || multiple <= 0) {
stop("bad value for 'multiple'")
}
med <- median(x)
y <- x - med
sc <- mad(y, center=0) * multiple
y[ y > sc ] <- sc
y[ y < -sc ] <- -sc
y + med
}
########################################
## Loop over years and calculate log ag productivity for each year and save RD estimates:
# For now loop over 2005-2014 (since >2015 = change in methodology; <2005 = no sugar cane prices; <2001 = no grain prices)
years <- 2005:2015
rd_estimates <-data.frame(Year = years,
ln_agprod_estimates = rep(0, length(years)), ln_agprod_ses = rep(0, length(years)),
ln_laborprod_estimates = rep(0, length(years)), ln_laborprod_ses = rep(0, length(years)))
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- censo_ag_wreform
for (i in years) {
# Create Variables:
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- mutate(censo_ag_wreform_tev,
agrev=ifelse(is.na(Maize_Yield),0,Maize_Yield)*Area_has*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Maize_Price")] +
ifelse(is.na(Beans_Yield),0,Beans_Yield)*Area_has*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Beans_Price")] +
ifelse(is.na(Coffee_Yield),0,Coffee_Yield)*Area_has*10*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Coffee_Price")] +
ifelse(is.na(SugarCane_Yield),0,SugarCane_Yield)*Area_has*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Intl_Sugar_Cane_Price")])
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- filter(censo_ag_wreform_tev, agrev != 0 & !is.na(agrev))
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- mutate(censo_ag_wreform_tev,
agprod=agrev/Area_has)
# Note: Sugar Cane Qt in tons, so converting to Quintales;Coffee prizes in mz; in ES, each mz makes about 10 quintales - http://www.laprensagrafica.com/2016/01/18/cafe-perdio-60-de-rendimiento-por-ataque-de-roya - $10 premium at least on organic coffee
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- mutate(censo_ag_wreform_tev, ln_agprod = log(agprod))
summary(censo_ag_wreform_tev$ln_agprod)
# Estimate and Save RD for this year:
# Agricultural Productivity:
rdests <- rdrobust(y = (censo_ag_wreform_tev$ln_agprod), x=censo_ag_wreform_tev$norm_dist, cluster=censo_ag_wreform_tev$Expropretario_ISTA,vce="hc1")
rd_estimates[rd_estimates$Year==i,c("ln_agprod_estimates")] <- lm.beta(MOD=rdests, dta=censo_ag_wreform_tev, y="ln_agprod")
rd_estimates[rd_estimates$Year==i,c("ln_agprod_ses")] <-lm.beta.ses(MOD=rdests, dta=censo_ag_wreform_tev, y="ln_agprod")
}
rd_estimates
########################################
## Plot over time:
# Agricultural Revenue Productivity:
ggplot(data = rd_estimates, aes(Year,ln_agprod_estimates)) +
geom_line(col="black", size=1) + geom_point(size=2.5) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, col="red",linetype="dotted", size=0.75) +
geom_ribbon(data=rd_estimates,aes(ymin=ln_agprod_estimates - 1.96*ln_agprod_ses,ymax=ln_agprod_estimates + 1.96*ln_agprod_ses, x=Year),alpha=0.15) +
aesthetics + ylab("Estimated Effect:\nRevenue per Hectare") + coord_equal(ylim=c(-1, 1)) +
scale_x_continuous(breaks=c(years)) + scale_y_continuous(breaks=seq(1,-1, by=-0.25)) + xlab("Year of Price Data Used")
ggsave(filename = "./Output/TemporalEV_LnAgProd.pdf")
########################################
## FACTORING IN COSTS OF PRODUCTION FOR 2007
coffee_prices <- dplyr::select(csc_es_coffee, Year = ANO, Coffee_Price = ANUAL)
coffee_prices <- filter(coffee_prices, !is.na(Year))
coffee_prices <- mutate(coffee_prices, Coffee_Price = Coffee_Price)#/0.46) ## Note: Converting from USD/46kg to USD/Quintal
## Loop over years and calculate log ag productivity for each year and save RD estimates:
years <- 2005:2015
rd_estimates <-data.frame(Year = years,
ln_agprod_estimates = rep(0, length(years)), ln_agprod_ses = rep(0, length(years)),
ln_laborprod_estimates = rep(0, length(years)), ln_laborprod_ses = rep(0, length(years)))
for (i in years) {
# Create Variables:
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- mutate(censo_ag_wreform_tev,
agrev=ifelse(is.na(Maize_Yield),0,Maize_Yield)*Area_has*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Maize_Price")] +
ifelse(is.na(Beans_Yield),0,Beans_Yield)*Area_has*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Beans_Price")] +
ifelse(is.na(Coffee_Yield),0,Coffee_Yield)*Area_has*10*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Coffee_Price")] +
ifelse(is.na(SugarCane_Yield),0,SugarCane_Yield)*Area_has*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Intl_Sugar_Cane_Price")])
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- filter(censo_ag_wreform_tev, agrev != 0)
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- mutate(censo_ag_wreform_tev,
agprod=(agrev)/Area_has - ag_prod_cost_wolabor)
# Note: Sugar Cane Qt in tons, so converting to Quintales;Coffee prizes in mz; in ES, each mz makes about 10 quintales - http://www.laprensagrafica.com/2016/01/18/cafe-perdio-60-de-rendimiento-por-ataque-de-roya - $10 premium at least on organic coffee
# Notes: Removing indirect costs. Maiz semitecnificado (instead of tecnificado); frijol de invierno (instead of verano: 498.6;
# Arroz tradicional (tecn: 1421.96; semitech: 1167.45); sorgo tecnificado 442.80 (instead of semi: 300.68);
# Sugar Cane Plantia tecn (trad: 1446.12, mantinimiento tecn: 1053.67, mantenimiento trad: 997.14);
# Coffee costs from 2005-2006, inflation in $ from 2006-2007= 4.57% * Source: https://datos.bancomundial.org/indicador/FP.CPI.TOTL.ZG?locations=SV
# Maiz - 2005 = Tradicional.
#summary(censo_ag_wreform_tev$ln_agprod)
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- mutate(censo_ag_wreform_tev, ln_agprod = log(agprod))
summary(censo_ag_wreform_tev$ln_agprod)
summary(censo_ag_wreform_tev$ln_laborprod)
rdests <- rdrobust(y = (censo_ag_wreform_tev$ln_agprod), x=censo_ag_wreform_tev$norm_dist, cluster=censo_ag_wreform_tev$Expropretario_ISTA,vce="hc1")
rd_estimates[rd_estimates$Year==i,c("ln_agprod_estimates")] <- lm.beta(MOD=rdests, dta=censo_ag_wreform_tev, y="ln_agprod")
rd_estimates[rd_estimates$Year==i,c("ln_agprod_ses")] <-lm.beta.ses(MOD=rdests, dta=censo_ag_wreform_tev, y="ln_agprod")
}
rd_estimates
########################################
## Plot over time:
#axis.title.y=element_blank()))
# Agricultural Revenue Productivity:
ggplot(data = rd_estimates, aes(Year,ln_agprod_estimates)) +
geom_line(col="black", size=1) + geom_point(size=2.5) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, col="red",linetype="dotted", size=0.75) +
geom_ribbon(data=rd_estimates,aes(ymin=ln_agprod_estimates - 1.96*ln_agprod_ses,ymax=ln_agprod_estimates + 1.96*ln_agprod_ses, x=Year),alpha=0.15) +
aesthetics + ylab("Estimated Effect:\nProfits per Hectare") + coord_equal(ylim=c(-1, 1)) +
scale_x_continuous(breaks=c(years)) + scale_y_continuous(breaks=seq(1,-1, by=-0.25)) + xlab("Year of Price Data Used")
ggsave(filename = "./Output/TemporalEV_LnAgProdII.pdf")
########################################
## FACTORING IN COSTS OF PRODUCTION :
## Loop over years and calculate log ag productivity for each year and save RD estimates:
# For now loop over 2005-2014 (since >2015 = change in methodology; <2005 = no sugar cane prices; <2001 = no grain prices)
years <- 2005:2015
rd_estimates <-data.frame(Year = years,
ln_agprod_estimates = rep(0, length(years)), ln_agprod_ses = rep(0, length(years)),
ln_laborprod_estimates = rep(0, length(years)), ln_laborprod_ses = rep(0, length(years)),
ln_tfp_geo_estimates = rep(0, length(years)), ln_tfp_geo_ses = rep(0, length(years)))
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- censo_ag_wreform_tev
for (i in years) {
# Create Variables:
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- mutate(censo_ag_wreform_tev,
agrev=ifelse(is.na(Maize_Yield),0,Maize_Yield)*Area_has*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Maize_Price")] +
ifelse(is.na(Beans_Yield),0,Beans_Yield)*Area_has*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Beans_Price")] +
ifelse(is.na(Coffee_Yield),0,Coffee_Yield)*Area_has*10*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Coffee_Price")] +
ifelse(is.na(SugarCane_Yield),0,SugarCane_Yield)*Area_has*prices[prices$Year==i,c("Intl_Sugar_Cane_Price")])
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- filter(censo_ag_wreform_tev, agrev != 0)
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- mutate(censo_ag_wreform_tev,
agprod=(agrev)/Area_has - ag_prod_cost_wolabor)
# Note: Sugar Cane Qt in tons, so converting to Quintales;Coffee prizes in mz; in ES, each mz makes about 10 quintales - http://www.laprensagrafica.com/2016/01/18/cafe-perdio-60-de-rendimiento-por-ataque-de-roya - $10 premium at least on organic coffee
# Notes: Removing indirect costs. Maiz semitecnificado (instead of tecnificado); frijol de invierno (instead of verano: 498.6;
# Arroz tradicional (tecn: 1421.96; semitech: 1167.45); sorgo tecnificado 442.80 (instead of semi: 300.68);
# Sugar Cane Plantia tecn (trad: 1446.12, mantinimiento tecn: 1053.67, mantenimiento trad: 997.14);
# Coffee costs from 2005-2006, inflation in $ from 2006-2007= 4.57% * Source: https://datos.bancomundial.org/indicador/FP.CPI.TOTL.ZG?locations=SV
# Maiz - 2005 = Tradicional.
censo_ag_wreform_tev <- mutate(censo_ag_wreform_tev, ln_agprod = log(agprod),
ln_rev = log(agrev/Area_has),
ln_rev =winsor(ln_rev, fraction = 0.015),
ln_land = log(Area_has),
canton_land_suit = ifelse(is.na(canton_land_suit),0,canton_land_suit))
# TO DO: FARM TFP FOR EACH YEAR:
censo_ag_wreform_tev$ln_tfp_geo[which(!is.na(censo_ag_wreform_tev$canton_mean_rain)
& !is.na(censo_ag_wreform_tev$ln_land))] <- residuals(felm(ln_rev ~ ln_Total_AgEmpl + ln_land + canton_mean_rain + canton_elev_dem_30sec + canton_land_suit | DEPID | 0 | Expropretario_ISTA, data=censo_ag_wreform_tev))
# + factor(MUNID)
#
# Farm Productivity:
rdests <- rdrobust(y = (censo_ag_wreform_tev$ln_tfp_geo), x=censo_ag_wreform_tev$norm_dist, cluster=censo_ag_wreform_tev$Expropretario_ISTA,vce="hc1")
rd_estimates[rd_estimates$Year==i,c("ln_tfp_geo_estimates")] <- lm.beta(MOD=rdests, dta=censo_ag_wreform_tev, y="ln_tfp_geo")
rd_estimates[rd_estimates$Year==i,c("ln_tfp_geo_ses")] <-lm.beta.ses(MOD=rdests, dta=censo_ag_wreform_tev, y="ln_tfp_geo")
}
rd_estimates
########################################
## Plot over time:
# Farm Productivity:
ggplot(data = rd_estimates, aes(Year,ln_tfp_geo_estimates)) +
geom_line(col="black", size=1) + geom_point(size=2.5) +
geom_hline(yintercept = 0, col="red",linetype="dotted", size=0.75) +
geom_ribbon(data=rd_estimates,aes(ymin=ln_tfp_geo_estimates - 1.96*ln_tfp_geo_ses,ymax=ln_tfp_geo_estimates + 1.96*ln_tfp_geo_ses, x=Year),alpha=0.15) +
aesthetics + ylab("Estimated Effect:\nFarm Productivity") + coord_equal(ylim=c(-1, 1)) +
scale_x_continuous(breaks=c(years)) + scale_y_continuous(breaks=seq(1,-1, by=-0.25)) + xlab("Year of Price Data Used")
ggsave(filename = "./Output/TemporalEV_LnTFP.pdf")