#Figure 6: Preferences for non-coethnic neighbor in neighbor conjoint experiment, #comparing high- to low-exposure respondents. #install packges # install.packages('plyr') # install.packages('dplyr') # install.packages('tidyr') # install.packages('ggplot2') # install.packages('lmtest') # install.packages('multiwayvcov') # install.packages('stargazer') rm(list=ls()) library(plyr);library(dplyr, warn.conflicts = F) library(tidyr) library(ggplot2) suppressMessages( library(lmtest) ) suppressMessages( library(multiwayvcov) ) suppressMessages(library(stargazer)) s = function(x){summary(factor(x))} #setwd() #set working directory dir.create(paste0(getwd(), '/Output/')) dir.create(paste0(getwd(), '/Output/Figure_6/')) path0 = paste0(getwd(), '/Output/Figure_6/', Sys.Date(),'/') #Directory for output files dir.create(path0) Q = read.csv('4-20-20_deid_nearestK.csv', na.strings=c('','NA'),strip.white=T,stringsAsFactors = F) Q = Q[which(Q$Wave == 'Bangalore 2017'),] ############################################################################################################################## Q = Q %>% dplyr::rename(Q2A1 = L.Neighbor_Random_2_A1, #second question, candidate 1, characteristic A Q2A2 = L.Neighbor_Random_2_A2, Q2B1 = L.Neighbor_Random_2_B1, Q2B2 = L.Neighbor_Random_2_B2, Q2C1 = L.Neighbor_Random_2_C1, Q2C2 = L.Neighbor_Random_2_C2, Q3A1 = L.Neighbor_Random_3_A1, Q3A2 = L.Neighbor_Random_3_A2, Q3B1 = L.Neighbor_Random_3_B1, Q3B2 = L.Neighbor_Random_3_B2, Q3C1 = L.Neighbor_Random_3_C1, Q3C2 = L.Neighbor_Random_3_C2, # Q1 = L.Neighbor_Question_1, #first question: choose candidate 1 or 2? Q2 = L.Neighbor_Question_2, Q3 = L.Neighbor_Question_3) #rearrange so one row is one conjoint observation. 3x as many rows as A #new variables: A1, B1 are two traits for candidate 1; similar for 2; and y is respondent's choice between candidates B = Q %>% unite('Q2',matches('Q2')) %>% unite('Q3',matches('Q3')) %>% gather(Question,b,starts_with('Q')) %>% arrange(X) %>% separate('b', c('A1','A2','B1','B2','C1','C2','y')) B = B %>% filter(!(A1 == A2 & B1 == B2 & C1 == C2)) #Drop observations where candidates have same profile #Make new data frame where each row is one PROFILE, ie each question becomes two rows (one for each candidate) #New variables: A1, A2 are combined as A: trait A for either candidate C = B %>% unite('ABC1',c(A1,B1,C1)) %>% unite('ABC2',c(A2,B2,C2)) %>% gather(Neighbor, ABC, c(ABC1,ABC2)) %>% arrange(X) %>% separate('ABC',c('A','B','C')) %>% mutate(Neighbor = as.numeric(mapvalues(Neighbor, from = c('ABC1','ABC2'), to = c(1,2)))) C$B_revised = NA C$B_revised[which(C$C.C6_Religion == 'Hindu' & C$B == 0)] = 1 #Respondent and neighbor both Hindu C$B_revised[which(C$C.C6_Religion == 'Hindu' & C$B == 1)] = 0 #Respondent Hindu, neighbor Muslim C$B_revised[which(C$C.C6_Religion == 'Hindu' & C$B == 2)] = 2 #non-kannada-speaker: keep it the same C$B_revised[which(C$C.C6_Religion == 'Muslim' & C$B == 0)] = 0 #Respondent Muslim, neighbor Hindu C$B_revised[which(C$C.C6_Religion == 'Muslim' & C$B == 1)] = 1 #Respondent Hindu, neighbor Muslim C$B_revised[which(C$C.C6_Religion == 'Muslim' & C$B == 2)] = 2 #non-kannada-speaker: keep it the same C$B = as.character(C$B_revised) #this is necessary so model-matrix step below works #B0: other religion. B1: same religion. B2: non kannada speaker #this introduces NA's (people who are not Hindus or Muslims); drop these here C = C[which(!is.na(C$B)),] #function to make dummies for trait levels ModFn = function(x,f){ data.frame(x, model.matrix(as.formula(f), data=x))} C = C %>% ModFn('~ A - 1') %>% ModFn('~ B - 1') %>% ModFn('~ C - 1') #function to make dummies for trait levels C = C %>% mutate(Y = y == Neighbor) #1 when that candidate is picked C = C %>% dplyr::rename(A_0 = A0, #rename variables to be consistent with earlier version of code A_1 = A1, B_0 = B0, B_1 = B1, C_0 = C0, C_1 = C1, C_2 = C2, C_3 = C3, C_4 = C4) B = C; rm(C) #rename variables to be consistent with earlier version of code ############################################################################################################## ##########do analysis and make plots###################################################################### #regression formula form1 = as.formula(paste0('Y ~ ', paste(strsplit('A_0 A_1 B_0 B_1 C_0 C_1 C_2 C_3 C_4', split = ' ')[[1]], collapse=' + '))) DF_C_v2 = function(l_m,id){ # l_m_pl = data.frame(Parameter = rownames(l_m[-1,])) %>% #-1 drops intercept mutate(Coef = l_m[-1,1]) %>% mutate(Lo = Coef - 1.96*l_m[-1,2]) %>% mutate(Hi = Coef + 1.96*l_m[-1,2]) %>% rbind(data.frame(Parameter = c('A_3','B_4'), Coef = c(0,0), Lo = c(0,0), Hi = c(0,0) )) %>% mutate(ID = id) %>% mutate(Parameter = as.character(Parameter)) %>% arrange(Parameter) } ########################################################################################### #Make functions to extract p and z as a function of k calc_p_relig_neigh = function(k, Dat){ # var <- paste0('Nearest',k,'_SameReligion') # if(median(Dat[,var],na.rm=T)==k){ var_break <- k-1 }else{var_break = floor(median(Dat[,var],na.rm=T))} dat_lo = Dat[ which(Dat[,var] <= var_break ) ,] dat_hi = Dat[ which(Dat[,var] > var_break ) ,] if(nrow(dat_lo) == 0 | nrow(dat_hi) == 0){p_a2 = NA }else{ lm_lo = lm(form1, data = dat_lo ) lm_hi = lm(form1, data = dat_hi ) lm_clus_lo = coeftest(lm_lo, cluster.vcov(lm_lo, dat_lo[,c('X','A.A7_Area.Neighborhood')])) lm_clus_hi = coeftest(lm_hi, cluster.vcov(lm_hi, dat_hi[,c('X','A.A7_Area.Neighborhood')])) z_a2 = (lm_clus_lo[3,1] - lm_clus_hi[3,1]) / sqrt(lm_clus_lo[3,2]^2 + lm_clus_hi[3,2]^2) p_a2 = 2 * pnorm( abs(z_a2), mean = 0, sd = 1, lower.tail = F) coef_lo = lm_clus_lo[3,1]; coef_hi = lm_clus_hi[3,1] sd_lo = lm_clus_lo[3,2]; sd_hi = lm_clus_hi[3,2] return(data.frame(coef_lo, coef_hi, sd_lo, sd_hi, p_a2)) } } relig_results = sapply(1:30, function(x) calc_p_relig_neigh(k=x, Dat = B)) %>% t() %>% data.frame() %>% mutate(k = 1:30, dif = as.numeric(coef_lo) - as.numeric(coef_hi), dif_sd = sqrt(as.numeric(sd_lo)^2 + as.numeric(sd_hi)^2), dif_lobd = dif - 1.96*dif_sd, dif_hibd = dif + 1.96*dif_sd ) #Create data frame for plotting rrc = relig_results[seq(from = 2, to = 30, by = 3),] %>% rename(Low = coef_lo, High = coef_hi) %>% select(-starts_with('dif')) %>% gather(Seg, Coef, c(Low, High)) %>% mutate(Coef = as.numeric(Coef), sd_lo = as.numeric(sd_lo), sd_hi = as.numeric(sd_hi), p_a2 = as.numeric(p_a2), sd = sd_lo*(Seg == 'Low') + sd_hi*(Seg == 'High'), lo = Coef - 1.96*sd, hi = Coef + 1.96*sd, sig = factor(p_a2 < 0.05)) #FIGURE 6 ggplot(data = rrc, aes(x = k, y = Coef)) + geom_pointrange(aes(ymin = lo, ymax = hi, x = k, shape = Seg, alpha = sig), position = position_dodge(width = 0.9)) + scale_shape_manual('Exposure', values = c(16, 17), labels = c('Low','High')) + scale_alpha_manual('p < 0.05', c(FALSE), values=c(0.5), labels = c('No')) + labs(shape = 'Exposure') + theme_minimal() + ylab('Non-Coethnicity Coefficients') + theme(text = element_text(size = 16), plot.title = element_text(hjust = 0.5)) + ggtitle('k-Nearest Own Religion') + guides(shape = guide_legend(order = 1), alpha = guide_legend(order = 0)) ggsave(filename = paste0(path0, 'k-z_coefficients_NEIGHBOR.png'), height = 150, width = 150, units = 'mm') ################################################################################################################################ ################################################################################################################################ #De-medianed version calc_p_relig_neigh_demed = function(k, Dat){ var <- paste0('DeMedNearest',k,'_SameReligion') var_break = 0 dat_lo = Dat[ which(Dat[,var] < var_break ) ,] dat_hi = Dat[ which(Dat[,var] >= var_break ) ,] if(nrow(dat_lo) == 0 | nrow(dat_hi) == 0){p_a2 = NA }else{ lm_lo = lm(form1, data = dat_lo ) lm_hi = lm(form1, data = dat_hi ) lm_clus_lo = coeftest(lm_lo, cluster.vcov(lm_lo, dat_lo[,c('X','A.A7_Area.Neighborhood')])) lm_clus_hi = coeftest(lm_hi, cluster.vcov(lm_hi, dat_hi[,c('X','A.A7_Area.Neighborhood')])) z_a2 = (lm_clus_lo[3,1] - lm_clus_hi[3,1]) / sqrt(lm_clus_lo[3,2]^2 + lm_clus_hi[3,2]^2) p_a2 = 2 * pnorm( abs(z_a2), mean = 0, sd = 1, lower.tail = F) coef_lo = lm_clus_lo[3,1]; coef_hi = lm_clus_hi[3,1] sd_lo = lm_clus_lo[3,2]; sd_hi = lm_clus_hi[3,2] return(data.frame(coef_lo, coef_hi, sd_lo, sd_hi, p_a2)) } } relig_results_demed = sapply(c(5,10,15,20,25,30), function(x) calc_p_relig_neigh_demed(k=x, Dat = B)) %>% t() %>% data.frame() %>% mutate(k = c(5,10,15,20,25,30), dif = as.numeric(coef_lo) - as.numeric(coef_hi), dif_sd = sqrt(as.numeric(sd_lo)^2 + as.numeric(sd_hi)^2), dif_lobd = dif - 1.96*dif_sd, dif_hibd = dif + 1.96*dif_sd ) rrc_demed = relig_results_demed %>% rename(Low = coef_lo, High = coef_hi) %>% select(-starts_with('dif')) %>% gather(Seg, Coef, c(Low, High)) %>% mutate(Coef = as.numeric(Coef), sd_lo = as.numeric(sd_lo), sd_hi = as.numeric(sd_hi), p_a2 = as.numeric(p_a2), sd = sd_lo*(Seg == 'Low') + sd_hi*(Seg == 'High'), lo = Coef - 1.96*sd, hi = Coef + 1.96*sd, sig = factor(p_a2 < 0.05)) #FIGURE A19 ggplot(data = rrc_demed, aes(x = k, y = Coef)) + geom_pointrange(aes(ymin = lo, ymax = hi, x = k, shape = Seg, alpha = sig), position = position_dodge(width = 0.9)) + scale_shape_manual('Exposure', values = c(16, 17), labels = c('Low','High')) + scale_alpha_manual('p < 0.05', c(FALSE), values=c(0.5), labels = c('No')) + labs(shape = 'Exposure') + theme_minimal() + ylab('Non-Coethnicity Coefficients') + theme(text = element_text(size = 16), plot.title = element_text(hjust = 0.5)) + ggtitle('k-Nearest Own Religion (De-medianed)') + guides(shape = guide_legend(order = 1), alpha = guide_legend(order = 0)) ggsave(filename = paste0(path0, 'k-z_coefficients_NEIGHBOR_demed.png'), height = 150, width = 150, units = 'mm') relig_results_tab = relig_results %>% apply(2, function(x) as.numeric(x)) %>% data.frame() %>% select(k, coef_lo, sd_lo, coef_hi, sd_hi, p_a2) %>% rename(Coef_HiExp = coef_lo, SD_HiExp = sd_lo, Coef_LoExp = coef_hi, SD_LoExp = sd_hi, p = p_a2) %>% round(3) out = stargazer(relig_results_tab, summary = F, rownames = F, title = 'Results for co-ethnicity attribute in neighbor experiment compared between high- and low-exposure subsamples, based on religious exposure', label = 'table:ReligResults_Neighbor') writeLines(out,con = paste0(path0,'ReligResults_Neighbor.tex'));rm(out, relig_results_tab)