Hugging Face's logo

Datasets:
crawlab
/
crawleval

License:
Dataset card Files
xet
 Community
crawleval / eval_data_extract /html /0009.html
Marvin Zhang
chore: Add JSON and HTML files for various web pages, including metadata and index mappings for books, quotes, and e-commerce sites. This commit establishes the foundational data structure for web scraping and evaluation tasks.
dcea807
raw
history blame contribute delete
198 kB
<html lang="en-GB"><head><script async="" src="https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js"></script><meta charset="utf-8"><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width"><title>OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash</title><meta property="og:title" content="OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash"><meta name="twitter:title" content="OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash"><meta name="description" content="The move follows a bitter power struggle over the business. "><meta property="og:description" content="The move follows a bitter power struggle over the business. "><meta name="twitter:description" content="The move follows a bitter power struggle over the business. "><meta property="og:image" content="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/branded_news/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg"><meta name="twitter:image:src" content="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/branded_news/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg"><meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"><meta property="og:image:alt" content="Sam Altman, chief executive officer of OpenAI Inc., at Station F during the AI Action Summit in Paris, France, on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025."><meta name="twitter:image:alt" content="Sam Altman, chief executive officer of OpenAI Inc., at Station F during the AI Action Summit in Paris, France, on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025."><meta name="msapplication-TileColor" content="#da532c"><meta name="theme-color" content="#ffffff"><meta name="robots" content="NOODP, NOYDIR"><meta name="apple-itunes-app" content="app-id=364147881, app-argument=https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy603eg0w8o"><link rel="amphtml" href="https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy603eg0w8o.amp"><link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/apple-touch-icon.png"><link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="32x32" href="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/favicon-32x32.png"><link rel="icon" type="image/png" sizes="16x16" href="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/favicon-16x16.png"><link rel="alternate icon" href="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/favicon.ico"><link rel="manifest" href="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/site.webmanifest"><link rel="mask-icon" href="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/safari-pinned-tab.svg" color="#000000"><link rel="canonical" href="https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy603eg0w8o"><link data-testid="en-hreflang-tag" rel="alternate" hreflang="en" href="https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy603eg0w8o"><link data-testid="en-gb-hreflang-tag" rel="alternate" hreflang="en-gb" href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwy603eg0w8o"><meta name="version" content="web-2.20.1-1"><script type="text/javascript" async="" src="https://cdn.cxense.com/cx.js"></script><script async="" type="text/javascript" src="https://cdn.cxense.com/cx.cce.js"></script><script type="application/ld+json">{"@context":"http://schema.org","@type":"ReportageNewsArticle","url":"https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy603eg0w8o","publisher":{"@type":"NewsMediaOrganization","name":"BBC News","publishingPrinciples":"http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/help-41670342","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/ws/simorgh-assets/public/news/images/metadata/poster-1024x576.png"}},"datePublished":"2025-05-05T23:08:41.684Z","dateModified":"2025-05-05T23:08:41.684Z","description":"The move follows a bitter power struggle over the business. ","headline":"OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash","image":{"@type":"ImageObject","width":1024,"height":576,"url":"https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/branded_news/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg"},"thumbnailUrl":"https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/branded_news/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg","mainEntityOfPage":"https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy603eg0w8o","author":[{"@type":"Person","name":"Natalie Sherman"}]}</script><meta property="al:ios:url" content="bbcx://news/articles/cwy603eg0w8o"><meta property="al:ios:app_store_id" content="364147881"><meta property="al:ios:app_name" content="BBC: World News &amp; Stories"><meta property="al:android:url" content="bbcx://news/articles/cwy603eg0w8o"><meta property="al:android:app_name" content="BBC: World News &amp; Stories"><meta property="al:android:package" content="bbc.mobile.news.ww"><meta property="al:web:url" content="https://bbc.com/news/articles/cwy603eg0w8o"><meta name="cXenseParse:pageclass" content="article"><meta name="cXenseParse:publishtime" content="2025-05-05T23:08:41.684Z"><meta name="article:modified_time" content="2025-05-05T23:08:41.684Z"><meta property="cXenseParse:author" content="Natalie Sherman"><meta name="next-head-count" content="40"><script async="" data-nscript="beforeInteractive">window.serverEnv = "live";</script><script id="inline-dotcom" async="" data-nscript="beforeInteractive">window.dotcom = window.dotcom || { cmd: [] };
 window.dotcom.ads = window.dotcom.ads || {
 resolves: {enabled: [], getAdTag: []},
 enabled: () => new Promise(r => window.dotcom.ads.resolves.enabled.push(r)),
 getAdTag: () => new Promise(r => window.dotcom.ads.resolves.getAdTag.push(r))
 };
 setTimeout(() => {
 if(window.dotcom.ads.resolves){
 window.dotcom.ads.resolves.enabled.forEach(r => r(false));
 window.dotcom.ads.resolves.getAdTag.forEach(r => r(""));
 window.dotcom.ads.enabled = () => new Promise(r => r(false));
 window.dotcom.ads.getAdTag = () => new Promise(r => r(""));
 console.error("NGAS load timeout");
 }
 }, 5000)</script><script id="inline-dotcom-config" async="" data-nscript="beforeInteractive">window.dotcom = window.dotcom || { cmd: [] }; window.dotcomConfig = {"gptRequested":true,"pageAds":true,"playerAds":true,"xPlatform":true,"allowAdvertising":true,"opsFlags":{"Metadata":{"FlagpoleBucketPrefix":"","FlagpoleDate":"31 Jul 24 08:19 UTC","FlagpoleFileID":"gn-flagpoles/gnlops","FlagpoleIdentity":"gnlops","FlagpoleSystem":"gn-flagpoles","Guid":"8dfe60a2-4322-411c-8a71-04dc7084fec4","urn":"urn:pubpipe:gnflagpoles:gnlops:gn-flagpoles/gnlops"},"Urn":"urn:pubpipe:gnflagpoles:gnlops:gn-flagpoles/gnlops","adverts":"true","analytics":"true","wwhp_feeds":"true","wwhp_obituary":"false","xproxy":"false","zephr":"false","zephrx":"true"},"ngasFlags":{"Metadata":{"FlagpoleBucketPrefix":"","FlagpoleDate":"03 Feb 25 09:02 UTC","FlagpoleFileID":"gn-flagpoles/ngas","FlagpoleIdentity":"ngas","FlagpoleSystem":"gn-flagpoles","Guid":"e229d810-0dcd-45f0-a61b-ff6a4178aff7","urn":"urn:pubpipe:gnflagpoles:ngas:gn-flagpoles/ngas"},"Urn":"urn:pubpipe:gnflagpoles:ngas:gn-flagpoles/ngas","aps":"true","banner":"true","beta":"true","brandmetrics":"false","cmp":"true","comscoremmx":"true","comscoremmxeea":"true","content_rec":"true","covatic":"true","covatic_admeta":"true","doubleverify":"true","fedid":"true","fedid_all":"true","fedid_google":"true","fedid_permutive":"true","fedid_piano":"true","fedid_signed":"true","fpd":"true","gpp":"true","grapeshot":"false","ias_publisher":"false","load_gpt":"true","name":"ngas","native_size":"true","newadunit":"true","newkeys":"true","nielsen":"true","ozone":"true","permutive":"true","permutive_cohort":"true","piano":"false","speedcurve":"true","spo":"true","survey":"true","surveyx":"true","tmt_media_filter":"true","version":"1.28"},"pageData":{"pageProps":{"ad_enabled":true,"content_pillar":"Business","content_type":"article","language":"en-gb","page":"news.articles.cwy603eg0w8o.page","page_chapter1":"news","producer":"BBC_STUDIOS","page_chapter2":"business","content_section":"Business","content_id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:cwy603eg0w8o","content_topic":"Elon Musk, International Business, Artificial intelligence, Microsoft","date_published":"2025-05-05T23:08:41.684Z","date_modified":"2025-05-05T23:08:41.684Z","article_word_count":506,"page_title":"OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash","reader_mode_enabled":false,"destination":"BBCS_BBC_TEST","referrer_url":""},"destination":[],"topics":[{"title":"Elon Musk","url":"/news/topics/c302m85q53mt","isEvent":false},{"title":"International Business","url":"/news/topics/c4nrdv135zet","isEvent":false},{"title":"Artificial intelligence","url":"/news/topics/ce1qrvleleqt","isEvent":false},{"title":"Microsoft","url":"/news/topics/cvenzmgyg0lt","isEvent":false}],"collection":[],"section":[{"title":"Business","url":"/news/business"}],"pillar":[{"title":"Business","url":"/business"}],"urn":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:cwy603eg0w8o","type":"article"}};</script><script id="inline-googletag" async="" data-nscript="beforeInteractive">window.googletag = window.googletag || { cmd: [] };</script><script id="inline-analytics" async="" data-nscript="beforeInteractive">window.analytics = window.analytics || { echoClient: null, buffer:[], checkForAdBlocker:true, data: null };</script><link rel="preload" href="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/css/2c88c55d3b188f5f.css" as="style"><link rel="stylesheet" href="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/css/2c88c55d3b188f5f.css" data-n-p=""><noscript data-n-css=""></noscript><script defer="" nomodule="" src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/polyfills-c67a75d1b6f99dc8.js"></script><script id="requirejs-script" src="https://static.bbci.co.uk/frameworks/requirejs/0.13.0/sharedmodules/require.js" async="" type="text/javascript" defer="" data-nscript="beforeInteractive"></script><script id="optimizely-script" src="https://cdn.optimizely.com/public/4621041136/s/bbcx_prod.js" async="" type="text/javascript" defer="" data-nscript="beforeInteractive"></script><script id="piano-script" src="https://cdn.tinypass.com/api/tinypass.min.js" async="" type="text/javascript" defer="" data-nscript="beforeInteractive"></script><script id="ads-service-script" src="https://gn-web-assets.api.bbc.com/ngas/latest/dotcom-bootstrap.js" async="" type="module" defer="" data-nscript="beforeInteractive"></script><script id="bump-script" src="https://emp.bbci.co.uk/emp/bump-4/bump-4.js" async="" type="text/javascript" defer="" data-nscript="beforeInteractive"></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/webpack-7f6a1e746c9ad22a.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/framework-fcaee23bd118befe.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/main-1ff96ce8d08d136b.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/pages/_app-3d511d1eef55eff6.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/63-e1d6b0f60a1601fb.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/672-453ccf53310a1146.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/425-5e67984ff0e16f46.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/885-d72a55d86f1c6cf5.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/759-7b269e4c54799509.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/545-cbe09b3cb9d59f65.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/chunks/pages/%5B%5B...slug%5D%5D-63a08ccfebab8778.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/1Dxkla49CXtdXaNT0ytzo/_buildManifest.js" defer=""></script><script src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/_next/static/1Dxkla49CXtdXaNT0ytzo/_ssgManifest.js" defer=""></script><style>@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Sans';font-display:block;font-weight:300;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_Lt.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Sans';font-display:block;font-weight:400;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_Rg.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Sans';font-display:block;font-weight:500;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_Md.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Sans';font-display:block;font-weight:700;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_Bd.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Sans';font-display:block;font-weight:900;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_ExBd.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Sans';font-display:block;font-weight:300;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_LtIt.woff2) format('woff2');font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Sans';font-display:block;font-weight:400;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_It.woff2) format('woff2');font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Sans';font-display:block;font-weight:500;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_MdIt.woff2) format('woff2');font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Sans';font-display:block;font-weight:700;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_BdIt.woff2) format('woff2');font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Sans';font-display:block;font-weight:900;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_ExBdIt.woff2) format('woff2');font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:ReithSans;font-display:block;font-weight:300;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_Lt.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:ReithSans;font-display:block;font-weight:400;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_Rg.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:ReithSans;font-display:block;font-weight:500;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_Md.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:ReithSans;font-display:block;font-weight:700;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_Bd.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:ReithSans;font-display:block;font-weight:900;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSans_W_ExBd.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:ReithSerif;font-display:block;font-weight:300;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_Lt.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:ReithSerif;font-display:block;font-weight:400;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_Rg.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:ReithSerif;font-display:block;font-weight:500;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_Md.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:ReithSerif;font-display:block;font-weight:700;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_Bd.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:ReithSerif;font-display:block;font-weight:900;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_ExBd.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Serif';font-display:block;font-weight:300;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_Lt.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Serif';font-display:block;font-weight:400;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_Rg.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Serif';font-display:block;font-weight:500;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_Md.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Serif';font-display:block;font-weight:700;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_Bd.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Serif';font-display:block;font-weight:900;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_ExBd.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Serif';font-display:block;font-weight:300;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_LtIt.woff2) format('woff2');font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Serif';font-display:block;font-weight:400;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_It.woff2) format('woff2');font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Serif';font-display:block;font-weight:500;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_MdIt.woff2) format('woff2');font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Serif';font-display:block;font-weight:700;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_BdIt.woff2) format('woff2');font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:'BBC Reith Serif';font-display:block;font-weight:900;src:url(https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/fonts/reith/2.512/BBCReithSerif_W_ExBdIt.woff2) format('woff2');font-style:italic}@font-face{font-family:'Freight Disp Light';font-display:swap;src:url(/https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/Freight_Disp_Light.woff2) format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:BBCReithSans-fallback;size-adjust:103%;ascent-override:normal;src:local('Arial')}@font-face{font-family:BBCReithSans-fallback;font-weight:500;size-adjust:96%;ascent-override:normal;src:local('Arial Bold')}@font-face{font-family:BBCReithSerif-fallback;size-adjust:120%;ascent-override:75%;src:local('Times New Roman')}@font-face{font-family:BBCReithSerif-fallback;font-weight:500;size-adjust:110%;ascent-override:75%;src:local('Times New Roman Bold')}</style><style data-styled="active" data-styled-version="5.3.11"></style><style type="text/css">.tp-backdrop{display:none;position:fixed;top:0;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;background:#121214;z-index:300000;opacity:0;transition:opacity .25s linear}.tp-backdrop.tp-active{opacity:.9}.tp-modal .tp-close.tp-square{background:#ccc;border-radius:0;border:0;top:0;right:-40px}.tp-modal .tp-close{display:none;position:absolute;top:-15px;right:-15px;width:30px;height:30px;background:#fff url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg width='20' height='20' fill='none' xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%3E%3Cpath d='M13.51 7.208l-.706-.708-2.798 2.798L7.207 6.5l-.707.707 2.798 2.799L6.503 12.8l.707.707 2.796-2.795 2.792 2.792.707-.707-2.792-2.792 2.798-2.798z' fill='%23000' fill-opacity='.4'/%3E%3C/svg%3E") center center no-repeat;border:none;box-shadow:0 0 10px rgba(28,37,68,.15);outline:none;z-index:300100;border-radius:40px;opacity:0;cursor:pointer;transform:scale(.25);-webkit-appearance:none;-moz-appearance:none;appearance:none}.tp-modal .tp-close:hover,.tp-modal .tp-close:focus{box-shadow:0 0 10px 2px rgba(28,37,68,.15)}.tp-modal .tp-close:focus{border:1px solid}.tp-modal .tp-close.tp-active{display:block;opacity:1;transform:scale(1)}.tp-modal .tp-iframe-wrapper[dir=rtl] .tp-close{right:initial;left:-20px}.tp-modal .tp-iframe-wrapper.piano-id-modal-ver-2 .tp-close{top:0;right:0;width:64px;height:64px;box-shadow:none;outline:none;border-radius:0;border-left:1px solid rgba(15,15,21,.2);background:url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg width='16' height='16' viewBox='0 0 16 16' fill='none' xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%3E%3Cg %3E%3Cpath d='M3 3L13 13M13 3L3 13' stroke='%230F0F15' stroke-width='2'/%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/svg%3E%0A") center center no-repeat;opacity:.3}.tp-modal .tp-iframe-wrapper.piano-id-modal-ver-2 .tp-close.tp-active{opacity:.3}.tp-modal .tp-iframe-wrapper.piano-id-modal-ver-2 .tp-close:hover,.tp-modal .tp-iframe-wrapper.piano-id-modal-ver-2 .tp-close:focus{box-shadow:none;border:none;border-left:1px solid rgba(15,15,21,.06);opacity:1}.tp-modal .tp-iframe-wrapper.piano-id-modal-ver-2[dir=rtl] .tp-close{right:auto;left:0;border-left:none;border-right:1px solid rgba(15,15,21,.2)}.tp-modal .tp-iframe-wrapper.piano-id-modal-ver-2[dir=rtl] .tp-close:hover,.tp-modal .tp-iframe-wrapper.piano-id-modal-ver-2[dir=rtl] .tp-close:focus{border-left:none;border-right:1px solid rgba(15,15,21,.06)}.tp-modal{z-index:300050}@media screen and (max-width: 650px){.tp-modal .tp-close{right:0}.tp-modal .tp-iframe-wrapper[dir=rtl] .tp-close{right:initial;left:0}}.tp-modal .tp-iframe-wrapper.tp-curtain{width:600px;height:480px}.tp-modal-open{overflow:hidden!important;height:100vh;-webkit-overflow-scrolling:touch}.tp-modal-open.tp-modal-resizing{-webkit-overflow-scrolling:auto}.tp-modal-close{overflow:auto}.tp-iframe-wrapper{position:relative;margin:50px auto;box-shadow:0 0 10px rgba(0,0,0,.21)}.tp-iframe-wrapper.no-shadow{box-shadow:unset}.tp-modal{overflow-x:hidden;overflow-y:scroll!important;display:none;position:fixed;top:0;bottom:0;left:0;right:0;transform:translateZ(0)}.tp-modal .tp-message{font-family:Graphik Web Regular,Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif;padding:10px}.tp-modal .tp-btn-container{padding-left:10px;padding-bottom:10px}.tp-cxense-placeholder-modal{width:100%;background-color:#fff;max-width:912px;display:block;overflow:hidden;height:auto;opacity:1}.tp-widget-placeholder>div:after{display:block;content:"";clear:both}.tp-btn{text-decoration:none;cursor:pointer;padding:0 18px;line-height:40px;border-collapse:separate;border-radius:4px;text-align:center;vertical-align:middle;display:inline-block;color:#fff;border:none;box-shadow:inset 0 -1px rgba(216,218,221,0);background:#3878D8;background-position:bottom;text-shadow:none;font-family:Graphik Web Regular,Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif;white-space:nowrap;outline:0}.tp-please-wait.tp-active{display:block;opacity:.9;transition:opacity .25s linear}.tp-please-wait{position:absolute;top:0;left:0;background-color:#999;opacity:0;width:100%;height:100%;display:none;text-align:center;color:#fff;font-weight:lighter;font-family:Open Sans,sans-serif;font-size:15px}.tp-please-wait.tp-overlap{position:fixed;z-index:300150}.tp-please-wait.tp-local-overlap{position:absolute}.tp-please-wait>.tp-icon{width:80px;height:80px;margin:100px auto 20px}.pn-spinner{color:gray;display:inline-block;position:relative;width:80px;height:80px}.pn-spinner div{transform-origin:40px 40px;animation:pn-spinner 1.2s linear infinite}.pn-spinner div:after{content:" ";display:block;position:absolute;top:3px;left:37px;width:6px;height:18px;border-radius:20%;background:#fff}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(1){transform:rotate(0);animation-delay:-1.1s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(2){transform:rotate(30deg);animation-delay:-1s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(3){transform:rotate(60deg);animation-delay:-.9s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(4){transform:rotate(90deg);animation-delay:-.8s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(5){transform:rotate(120deg);animation-delay:-.7s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(6){transform:rotate(150deg);animation-delay:-.6s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(7){transform:rotate(180deg);animation-delay:-.5s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(8){transform:rotate(210deg);animation-delay:-.4s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(9){transform:rotate(240deg);animation-delay:-.3s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(10){transform:rotate(270deg);animation-delay:-.2s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(11){transform:rotate(300deg);animation-delay:-.1s}.pn-spinner div:nth-child(12){transform:rotate(330deg);animation-delay:0s}@keyframes pn-spinner{0%{opacity:1}to{opacity:0}}.tp-please-wait>.tp-icon.tp-centered{margin:0;position:absolute;top:50%;left:50%;transform:translate(-50%,-50%)}.tp-iframe-wrapper.no-width .tp-close,.tp-iframe-wrapper.no-height .tp-close,.tp-modal.no-width .tp-close,.tp-modal.no-height .tp-close{display:none}.tp-banner{position:fixed;bottom:0;left:0;width:100%}.tp-banner>.tp-container-inner,.tp-banner>.tp-container-inner>iframe{width:inherit!important}.tp-modal-overscroll-prevented{overscroll-behavior:contain;width:100%;overflow-x:unset;overflow-y:scroll}.tp-scroll-prevented{height:100vh;overflow:hidden;touch-action:none}.tp-body-scroll-prevented{touch-action:none}
</style><style>#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt.full-screen .orb-banner{padding:16px 0}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt.full-screen .bbccookies-banner{position:fixed;bottom:0;width:100%;z-index:1000;padding:16px 0}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt.full-screen .bbccookies-banner p{line-height:1.5em}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt.full-screen .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-title{width:100%;line-height:2em}@media screen and (min-width: 600px){#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt.full-screen .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-content{padding-left:0;flex-grow:2}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt.full-screen .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-options{flex-grow:3}}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt.full-screen .bbccookies-banner .banner-button{font-size:18px}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt.full-screen #bbccookies-settings{line-height:1.3em}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt{font-weight:400;font-size:.625rem;font-family:Arial,Helvetica,freesans,sans-serif;line-height:1}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r p,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r div,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r section,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r a,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r button{margin:0}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-g-p,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r .b-g-p{padding:0 8px}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-g-m,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r .b-g-m{margin:0 8px}@media screen and (min-width: 400px){#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-g-p,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r .b-g-p{padding:0 16px}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-g-m,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r .b-g-m{margin:0 16px}}@media screen and (min-width: 1008px){#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-g-p,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r .b-g-p{max-width:976px;margin:0 auto;padding:0 16px}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-g-m,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-r .b-g-m{max-width:976px;margin:0 auto}}@media screen and (min-width: 1280px){#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-pw-1280 .b-g-p,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-pw-1280 .b-r .b-g-p{max-width:1248px}#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-pw-1280 .b-g-m,#ngasCookiePrompt #cookiePrompt .b-pw-1280 .b-r .b-g-m{max-width:1248px}}#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;flex-direction:column;padding:16px 0;margin:0 auto}#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner ul{list-style-type:none;padding:0;margin:15px 0 0 0;font-weight:bold}#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner button{background:none;border:none}#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner h2{margin-bottom:15px;font-size:1.39em;font-weight:bold;line-height:1.11em}#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner p{line-height:1.231em;margin:0}#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner-wrapper{font-size:1.3em;line-height:1}#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner{background-color:#323232;color:#bebebe}#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-title{color:#fff;margin-top:0}#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner .banner-button{font-size:1.2em;width:100%}#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner a,#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner button{text-align:left;color:#f6a21d;text-decoration:none;cursor:pointer}#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner a:hover,#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner a:focus,#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner button:hover,#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner button:focus{color:#fff;text-decoration:none}#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-options li{padding-top:8px}#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-options li:first-child{padding-top:0}#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-options a,#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-options button{padding:0 0 0 24px;line-height:1.231em;background-color:rgba(0,0,0,0);background-repeat:no-repeat;background-position:0 -254px}#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-options a:hover,#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-options a:focus,#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-options button:hover,#ngasCookiePrompt .bbccookies-banner .orb-banner-options button:focus{background-position:0px -317px}#ngasCookiePrompt #bbccookies-continue-button{line-height:1em;font-weight:700}#ngasCookiePrompt #bbccookies-settings a{background-position:1px 3px}#ngasCookiePrompt #bbccookies-settings a:focus,#ngasCookiePrompt #bbccookies-settings a:hover{background-position:1px -60px}@media screen and (min-width: 600px){#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner{flex-direction:row}#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner .orb-banner-title{width:20%}#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner .orb-banner-content{width:60%;padding-left:3.5%;box-sizing:border-box}#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner .orb-banner-options{width:20%;margin-top:0}#ngasCookiePrompt .orb-banner h2{margin-bottom:0}}</style><link href="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net" rel="preconnect"><link href="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com" rel="preconnect"><link href="https://prebid.the-ozone-project.com" rel="preconnect"><link href="https://elb.the-ozone-project.com" rel="preconnect"><link href="https://bbc.gscontxt.net" rel="preconnect"><link href="https://cdn.permutive.com" rel="preconnect"><link href="https://api.permutive.com" rel="preconnect"><link href="https://cdn.adsafeprotected.com" rel="preconnect"><link href="https://static.adsafeprotected.com" rel="preconnect"><script type="text/javascript" async="" src="https://c.amazon-adsystem.com/aax2/apstag.js"></script><script type="text/javascript" async="" src="https://prebid.the-ozone-project.com/hw2/OZONEBBC4784/1500000107/current/ozpb.min.js" id="adunits_loader"></script><script type="text/javascript" async="" src="https://scripts.webcontentassessor.com/scripts/64ca3dfd44dd68a629e2e51a27e7ccd960974b5961e4ca2897139d14bf10be8b"></script><script type="text/javascript" async="" src="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js"></script><script type="text/javascript" async="" src="https://cdn.privacy-mgmt.com/unified/wrapperMessagingWithoutDetection.js"></script><script src="https://prebid.the-ozone-project.com/hw2/OZONEBBC4784/1500000107/current/adUnits.min.js"></script><script src="https://prebid.the-ozone-project.com/hw2/OZONEBBC4784/1500000107/current/customized_plugin.js"></script><script src="https://prebid.the-ozone-project.com/hw2/builds/ozwrap_pbjs.js"></script><script charset="utf-8" src="https://cdn.privacy-mgmt.com/unified/4.33.0/gdpr-tcf.69af12e62901c381e4c1.bundle.js"></script><script charset="utf-8" src="https://cdn.privacy-mgmt.com/unified/4.33.0/ccpa-gpp.11cb61436d70b797a14c.bundle.js"></script><meta http-equiv="origin-trial" content="AlK2UR5SkAlj8jjdEc9p3F3xuFYlF6LYjAML3EOqw1g26eCwWPjdmecULvBH5MVPoqKYrOfPhYVL71xAXI1IBQoAAAB8eyJvcmlnaW4iOiJodHRwczovL2RvdWJsZWNsaWNrLm5ldDo0NDMiLCJmZWF0dXJlIjoiV2ViVmlld1hSZXF1ZXN0ZWRXaXRoRGVwcmVjYXRpb24iLCJleHBpcnkiOjE3NTgwNjcxOTksImlzU3ViZG9tYWluIjp0cnVlfQ=="><meta http-equiv="origin-trial" content="Amm8/NmvvQfhwCib6I7ZsmUxiSCfOxWxHayJwyU1r3gRIItzr7bNQid6O8ZYaE1GSQTa69WwhPC9flq/oYkRBwsAAACCeyJvcmlnaW4iOiJodHRwczovL2dvb2dsZXN5bmRpY2F0aW9uLmNvbTo0NDMiLCJmZWF0dXJlIjoiV2ViVmlld1hSZXF1ZXN0ZWRXaXRoRGVwcmVjYXRpb24iLCJleHBpcnkiOjE3NTgwNjcxOTksImlzU3ViZG9tYWluIjp0cnVlfQ=="><meta http-equiv="origin-trial" content="A9wSqI5i0iwGdf6L1CERNdmsTPgVu44ewj8QxTBYgsv1LCPUVF7YmWOvTappqB1139jAymxUW/RO8zmMqo4zlAAAAACNeyJvcmlnaW4iOiJodHRwczovL2RvdWJsZWNsaWNrLm5ldDo0NDMiLCJmZWF0dXJlIjoiRmxlZGdlQmlkZGluZ0FuZEF1Y3Rpb25TZXJ2ZXIiLCJleHBpcnkiOjE3MzY4MTI4MDAsImlzU3ViZG9tYWluIjp0cnVlLCJpc1RoaXJkUGFydHkiOnRydWV9"><meta http-equiv="origin-trial" content="A+d7vJfYtay4OUbdtRPZA3y7bKQLsxaMEPmxgfhBGqKXNrdkCQeJlUwqa6EBbSfjwFtJWTrWIioXeMW+y8bWAgQAAACTeyJvcmlnaW4iOiJodHRwczovL2dvb2dsZXN5bmRpY2F0aW9uLmNvbTo0NDMiLCJmZWF0dXJlIjoiRmxlZGdlQmlkZGluZ0FuZEF1Y3Rpb25TZXJ2ZXIiLCJleHBpcnkiOjE3MzY4MTI4MDAsImlzU3ViZG9tYWluIjp0cnVlLCJpc1RoaXJkUGFydHkiOnRydWV9"><script src="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/pagead/managed/js/gpt/m202505060101/pubads_impl.js?cb=31092315" async=""></script><link href="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/pagead/managed/dict/m202505060101/gpt" rel="compression-dictionary"><script type="text/javascript" charset="utf-8" async="" data-requirecontext="_" data-requiremodule="echo-2.4.1-avi" src="https://mybbc-analytics.files.bbci.co.uk/echo-client-js/echo-2.4.1-avi.min.js"></script><script type="text/javascript" async="" src="https://cdn.permutive.com/e488cdb0-e7cb-4d91-9648-60d437d8e491-web.js"></script><script type="text/javascript" async="" src="https://pub.doubleverify.com/dvtag/29028254/DV1298722/pub.js"></script><script type="module" async="" src="https://gn-web-assets.api.bbc.com/ngas/latest/dotcom-ads.js"></script><script type="module" async="" src="https://gn-web-assets.api.bbc.com/ngas/latest/dotcom-preroll.js"></script><script src="https://config.aps.amazon-adsystem.com/configs/5157" type="text/javascript" async="async"></script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://uk-script.dotmetrics.net/Scripts/script.js?v=335" async="async"></script><style>.dotcom-ad,.dotcom-ad.inactive{display:none}aside #dotcom-leaderboard.inactive,aside #dotcom-mpu.inactive{display:none}aside #dotcom-leaderboard,aside #dotcom-mpu{display:block}#main-content #dotcom-leaderboard.inactive,#main-content #dotcom-mpu.inactive{display:none}#main-content #dotcom-leaderboard,#main-content #dotcom-mpu{display:block}#orb-modules #dotcom-leaderboard.inactive{display:none}#orb-modules #dotcom-leaderboard{display:block}.dotcom-ad{margin:0 auto;padding:0;text-align:center;font-size:1rem}.dotcom-ad.lazy{display:block}.dotcom-ad.lazy div{display:none}.dotcom-ad.lazy.active div{display:block}.dotcom-ad-inner{display:inline-block;margin-bottom:8px}.dotcom-ad.active:not(.inactive){display:block}.dotcom-ad.active:not(.inactive) .dotcom-ad-text-wrapper{visibility:unset}[class*=GridItem] .dotcom-ad.active:not(.inactive){height:100%}.dotcom-ad-text-wrapper{display:flex;justify-content:flex-end;visibility:hidden}.dotcom-ad-text{color:#505050 !important;font:bold .75rem/.75rem helvetica,arial,sans-serif;font-size:.75rem;letter-spacing:0 !important;margin-bottom:5px !important;margin-top:8px !important;padding-top:0;text-decoration:none;text-transform:uppercase;text-align:right}.dotcom-ad-text:hover{text-decoration:underline}.AdSlot-wrapper .dotcom-ad-text{font-size:12px !important}#dotcom-mpu_mid.active{display:none}#dotcom-interstitial.active{display:none}#dotcom-interstitial.no-ad-text.active{display:block}#dotcom-interstitial.no-ad-text .dotcom-ad-text-wrapper{display:none}.bbccom_slot_interstitial #dotcom-interstitial.active{display:block}.bbccom_slot_interstitial{overflow:hidden}.bbccom_slot_interstitial_300x600 #bbccom_int{width:300px}#bbccom_int_container{font-family:ReithSans,Arial,Helvetica,freesans,sans-serif;height:5000px;left:0;position:fixed;text-align:center;top:0;width:100%;z-index:2147483647;background-color:#ddd}#bbccom_int_container #bbccom_int_outer{background-color:#ddd;height:100% !important;top:0;z-index:9999}#bbccom_int_container #bbccom_int_inner{width:100%}#bbccom_int_container #bbccom_int_head{background-color:#fff;border-bottom:1px solid #bbb;height:39px}#bbccom_int_container #bbccom_int_link{color:#000;cursor:pointer;display:block;font-size:12px;font-weight:bold;height:39px;line-height:39px;margin:0 auto;padding-right:14px;text-align:right;text-decoration:none;max-width:976px}#bbccom_int_container #bbccom_int_link span{display:inline-block;height:13px;vertical-align:middle;width:18px}#bbccom_int_container #bbccom_int_outer{background:#ddd}#bbccom_int_container #bbccom_int{display:inline-block;padding-top:20px}#bbccom_int_container #bbccom_int img{border:none}#bbccom_int_container .bbccom_text{background-color:rgba(0,0,0,0);background-image:none;display:table;float:right;visibility:hidden}div[id^=dotcom-sponsor].active:not(.inactive){display:inline-block}div[id^=dotcom-sponsor] .dotcom-ad-inner{display:flex;align-items:center;margin:8px 8px 8px 0}div[id^=dotcom-sponsor] .dotcom-ad-text{padding:5px 8px 0}#sign_in-bg{width:100%;height:100%;margin:0;position:fixed;z-index:1000;top:0;left:0;background-color:#000;opacity:.8}#sign_in{position:fixed;bottom:0;left:0;top:0;right:0;margin:auto;color:#fff;font-size:22px;z-index:1001;background-color:#0853ea;width:246px;height:263px}#sign_in *{font-family:ReithSans,Arial,Helvetica,freesans,sans-serif !important}@media(min-width: 721px){#sign_in{width:487px;height:339px}}#sign_in .sign_in-header{font-weight:bold;font-size:20px;line-height:23px;max-width:85%;margin:0 0 20px}@media(min-width: 721px){#sign_in .sign_in-header{font-size:35px;line-height:43px;max-width:80%}}#sign_in .sign_in-container{margin:34px 8px 24px 24px}@media(min-width: 721px){#sign_in .sign_in-container{margin:52px 12px 31px 31px}}#sign_in .id4-cta{margin:0}#sign_in .id5-cta{color:#d9d9d9}#sign_in .id4-cta-register{font-weight:normal;color:#d9d9d9}#sign_in .sign_in-line-break{margin-right:8px;margin-left:-8px;margin-bottom:14px;background-color:#979797;height:1px;border:0}@media(min-width: 721px){#sign_in .sign_in-line-break{margin-left:-12px}}#sign_in .sign_in-exit{color:#fff;background:none;border:none;cursor:pointer;font-size:15px;border-bottom:1px solid #fff;margin-top:18px;margin-bottom:18px;padding:0}@media(min-width: 721px){#sign_in .sign_in-exit{font-size:18px;margin-top:22px;margin-bottom:22px}}#sign_in .sign_in-why{color:#d9d9d9;text-decoration:none;font-size:11px;float:left}@media(min-width: 721px){#sign_in .sign_in-why{font-size:13px}}#sign_in .sign_in-why:hover .sign_in-why-text,#sign_in .sign_in-why:active .sign_in-why-text,#sign_in .sign_in-why:focus .sign_in-why-text{border-bottom:1px solid #bbb}#sign_in .sign_in-why-icon{vertical-align:middle;padding-top:4px}@media(min-width: 721px){#sign_in .sign_in-why-icon{padding-top:2px}}#sign_in .sign_in-why-icon>svg{width:14px;height:14px;fill:#fff}#sign_in .sign_in-why-text{margin-left:8px}#dotcom-native{background-color:#fff}#dotcom-native .dotcom-ad-inner{display:block}#dotcom-platinum{background-color:#fff}#dotcom-platinum .dotcom-ad-inner{display:block;padding:0 1rem;max-width:1280px;margin:0 auto}#dotcom-infeed_news_story .dotcom-ad-inner{margin-bottom:0}#dotcom-content-rec{background-color:#fff;max-width:inherit;overflow:hidden}@media(min-width: 600px){#dotcom-content-rec{text-align:left}}#dotcom-mpu,#dotcom-mpu_bottom,#dotcom-content-rec,#dotcom-adsense{margin-bottom:.5rem}div[id^=dotcom-module_feature]{text-align:right;background-color:#e7e7e7 !important}div[id^=dotcom-module_feature] .dotcom-ad-text-wrapper,div[id^=dotcom-module_feature] .dotcom-slot{display:inline-block;padding-right:.5rem}div[id^=dotcom-module_feature] .dotcom-ad-text{margin-top:0 !important;background-color:#e7e7e7 !important}.bbccom_mpu .module--content-block .runway--mpu{padding-bottom:unset !important;margin-bottom:unset !important}.module--content-block .module__content{overflow:unset !important}#bbccom_mpu_3+#dotcom-mpu{width:100%}article #dotcom-content-rec .dotcom-ad-inner{display:table;margin:0 auto !important}#dotcom-slot-infeed_ctp{text-align:left}.gel-wrap #sticky-leaderboard{margin-bottom:.5rem}.gel-wrap #dotcom-leaderboard{margin-bottom:.5rem;width:calc(100% + 32px);margin-left:-16px}@media(min-width: 600px)and (max-width: 1279px){.gel-wrap #dotcom-mpu{width:301px}}body:not(.bbccom_leaderboard) .gel-wrap #sticky-leaderboard,body:not(.bbccom_leaderboard) .gel-wrap #dotcom-leaderboard{margin-bottom:0}.nw-c-native-ad .bbccom-native-slice-wrapper{display:block}.nw-c-native-ad .bbccom-native-slice-wrapper .dotcom-ad-inner{width:100%;margin-bottom:unset}.nw-c-native-ad .bbccom-native-slice-wrapper .dotcom-ad-inner div[id^=google_ads_iframe]{width:100%;background-color:#f0f8ff;clear:both}.nw-c-native-ad .nw-o-keyline{visibility:hidden}.bbccom_native_slice_l .nw-c-native-ad .nw-o-keyline{visibility:visible}body:not(.bbccom_native_slice_l):not(.bbccom_infeed_news_home) .nw-c-native-ad{display:none}.app__body div[id^=dotcom-mpu]{padding-left:8px;padding-right:8px}@media(min-width: 1008px){.app__body div[id^=dotcom-mpu]{background-color:#f1f1f1}}.app__body div[id^=dotcom-native] .dotcom-ad-inner{width:100%;margin-bottom:0}.app__body div[id^=dotcom-sponsor]{background-color:#f1f1f1}.app__body .bbccom_advert{display:none}.app__body .AdFrame--dark-grey div[id^=dotcom-sponsor]{background-color:unset}.app__body .AdFrame--dark-grey .bbccom_text{color:#fff !important;font-weight:bold !important}@media(min-width: 900px)and (max-width: 985px){.sp-o-keyline-vertical\@l #sticky-mpu,.sp-o-keyline-vertical\@l #dotcom-mpu_bottom,.sp-o-keyline-vertical\@l #dotcom-adsense{margin-left:-17px}.sp-o-keyline-vertical\@l #sticky-mpu .dotcom-ad-inner,.sp-o-keyline-vertical\@l #dotcom-mpu_bottom .dotcom-ad-inner,.sp-o-keyline-vertical\@l #dotcom-adsense .dotcom-ad-inner{background-color:inherit;padding-bottom:8px;margin-bottom:0}}.bbccom_sponsor.earth-sponsorship #dotcom-sponsor .dotcom-ad-text-wrapper{visibility:visible}.bbccom_sponsor.earth-sponsorship #dotcom-sponsor .dotcom-ad-inner{float:right}.topSlotWrapper-inactive{opacity:0;height:0;overflow:hidden;transition:all 1s ease-in-out}#dotcom-top .dotcom-ad-inner{display:block}#dotcom-col_1,#dotcom-col_2,#dotcom-col_3,#dotcom-col_4,#dotcom-col_5,#dotcom-col_6{background-color:rgba(0,0,0,0) !important}.app .dotcom-ad-text-wrapper{margin-top:-12px}.app .dotcom-ad-text{font:10px "BBC Reith Sans",helvetica,arial,sans-serif;user-select:none}.app .dotcom-ad-text:hover{text-decoration:none}</style><meta name="google-site-verification" content="auTeTTwSt_KBY_4iDoR00Lwb7-qzx1IgzJy6ztaWgEI"><script type="module" async="" src="https://gn-web-assets.api.bbc.com/ngas/latest/dotcom-analytics.js"></script><script type="text/javascript" async="" src="https://gn-web-assets.api.bbc.com/ngas/vendor/edr/edr.min.js"></script><script type="text/javascript" async="" src="https://sb.scorecardresearch.com/internal-cs/default/beacon.js"></script><script src="https://uk-script.dotmetrics.net/SiteEvent.dotmetrics?r=1746668740785&amp;v=eyJpZCI6MTM5MzQsImZsIjp0cnVlLCJkb20iOiJ3d3cuYmJjLmNvbSIsImxzbyI6bnVsbCwidXJsIjoiaHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuYmJjLmNvbS9uZXdzL2FydGljbGVzL2N3eTYwM2VnMHc4byIsInJ1cmwiOiIiLCJlY2lkIjoiMzBhMWQzOGMtOGYyZS00ZTgxLTgzNTYtNmY4NWFjNzI4YzMyIiwiZGMiOiIwMDAwMDAwMC0wMDAwLTAwMDAtMDAwMC0wMDAwMDAwMDAwMDAiLCJ2ZXIiOjMzNSwiZGZwaCI6IiIsInR6T2Zmc2V0IjotNDgwLCJvc3MiOnRydWUsIm9zZXMiOnRydWV9"></script><script>
 (function(i,s,o,g,r,a,m){i['GoogleAnalyticsObject']=r;i[r]=i[r]||function(){
 (i[r].q=i[r].q||[]).push(arguments)},i[r].l=1*new Date();a=s.createElement(o),
 m=s.getElementsByTagName(o)[0];a.async=1;a.src=g;m.parentNode.insertBefore(a,m)
 })(window,document,'script','https://www.google-analytics.com/analytics.js','ga');
 </script><script></script><style type="text/css">#edr_survey .edr_lwrap iframe {width:100%;height:100%;}#edr_survey .edr_go {opacity:0;display:block;filter:alpha(opacity = 0);position:absolute;font-size:0;background-color:#000;margin:0;padding:0;visibility:visible;z-index:1000000;}#edr_survey .edr_lb {position:fixed;top:0;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;z-index:999998;display:none;}</style><style type="text/css">#edr_lwrap_first {position:absolute;left:-100000px;top:-100000px;width:100%;height:100%;}</style></head><body><div id="edr_survey"><div id="edr_lwrap_first" class="edr_lwrap" title="Online Quality Survey" aria-label="Online Quality Survey" role="alertdialog"><iframe name="edr_l_first" id="edr_l_first" frameborder="0" src="https://edigitalsurvey.com/l.php?id=INS-vt29-666188954&amp;v=7291&amp;x=800&amp;y=600&amp;d=24&amp;c=null&amp;ck=1&amp;p=%2Fnews%2Farticles%2Fcwy603eg0w8o&amp;fu=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bbc.com%2Fnews%2Farticles%2Fcwy603eg0w8o&amp;xdm=edr&amp;xdm_o=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bbc.com&amp;xdm_c=edr0" scrolling="no"></iframe></div></div><div id="__next"><div class="app"><noscript><style>.hide-when-no-script { visibility: hidden; }</style></noscript><div data-testid="backdrop" class="sc-39c53776-0 eQSDQW"></div><div class="sc-67fefadc-0 fDhjj"><a href="#main-content" aria-label="Skip to content" role="link" class="sc-67fefadc-1 BFLgM">Skip to content</a></div><div data-testid="ad-unit" data-component="ad-slot" class="sc-cce5f0ff-0 ktiuMQ"><div data-testid="dotcom-interstitial" id="dotcom-interstitial" class="dotcom-ad inactive" style="background-color: rgb(248, 248, 248);"><div class="dotcom-ad-inner"><div class="dotcom-ad-text-wrapper"><span class="dotcom-ad-text" tabindex="-1">Advertisement</span></div><div id="dotcom-slot-interstitial" class="dotcom-slot" data-google-query-id="CICjnqvhko0DFSYmgwMdTAACBw" style="display: none;"><div id="google_ads_iframe_/4817/bbccom/business/business/article/interstitial_0__container__" style="border: 0pt none;"></div></div></div></div></div><header class="sc-ef5cbfd8-0 ifhgwC"><div class="sc-ef5cbfd8-1 cROZkf"><div class="sc-ef5cbfd8-4 iceddI hide-when-no-script"><button role="button" aria-expanded="false" aria-label="Open menu" class="sc-ef5cbfd8-3 eOJxeA"><svg width="50" height="30" viewBox="0 0 80 48" fill="none"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M66.8517 32.0842C68.5359 29.8276 69.5329 27.0282 69.5329 23.996C69.5329 16.5202 63.4727 10.46 55.9969 10.46C48.5212 10.46 42.4609 16.5202 42.4609 23.996C42.4609 31.4717 48.5212 37.532 55.9969 37.532C58.9975 37.532 61.77 36.5557 64.0141 34.9034L69.0904 39.9796L71.9188 37.1512L66.8517 32.0842ZM63.1568 30.3569C64.6606 28.6654 65.5741 26.4374 65.5741 23.996C65.5741 18.7066 61.2863 14.4188 55.9969 14.4188C50.7076 14.4188 46.4197 18.7066 46.4197 23.996C46.4197 29.2853 50.7076 33.5732 55.9969 33.5732C58.4383 33.5732 60.6664 32.6597 62.3579 31.1558L63.1568 30.3569Z" fill="currentColor"></path><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M35.7184 33.6973H10.0254V37.6973H38.0738C37.1617 36.4525 36.3708 35.1133 35.7184 33.6973Z" fill="currentColor"></path><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M33.6848 21.998H10.0273V25.998H33.6845C33.6283 25.3394 33.5996 24.673 33.5996 23.9998C33.5996 23.3254 33.6284 22.6578 33.6848 21.998Z" fill="currentColor"></path><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M38.0747 10.2998H10.0273V14.2998H35.7186C36.3712 12.8837 37.1624 11.5446 38.0747 10.2998Z" fill="currentColor"></path></svg></button></div><div class="sc-ef5cbfd8-5 fwjINr"><div class="sc-ef5cbfd8-2 dEOjZt"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 112 32" category="logo" icon="bbc" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 cySMiL"><title>British Broadcasting Corporation</title><path d="M111.99999,4.44444577e-05 L111.99999,32.0000444 L79.9999905,32.0000444 L79.9999905,4.44444577e-05 L111.99999,4.44444577e-05 Z M72.0000119,-3.55271368e-15 L72.0000119,32 L40.0000119,32 L40.0000119,-3.55271368e-15 L72.0000119,-3.55271368e-15 Z M32,-3.55271368e-15 L32,32 L-1.13686838e-13,32 L-1.13686838e-13,-3.55271368e-15 L32,-3.55271368e-15 Z M97.469329,6.80826869 C96.0294397,6.80826869 94.7294393,7.02226876 93.5693278,7.44982444 C92.4089942,7.87782457 91.4137717,8.49471364 90.5841047,9.30049166 C89.7538823,10.1067141 89.1188821,11.07327 88.6785486,12.199937 C88.2378818,13.3269373 88.0177706,14.5896043 88.0177706,15.9876048 C88.0177706,17.4188274 88.2296596,18.7062722 88.6531042,19.8493837 C89.0763265,20.9929396 89.6861045,21.9591621 90.482438,22.748829 C91.2784383,23.5383848 92.2522163,24.1430516 93.4042167,24.5624962 C94.5558837,24.9819408 95.8516619,25.1917186 97.2914401,25.1917186 C98.3752182,25.1917186 99.4086629,25.072163 100.391219,24.8338296 C101.37333,24.5956073 102.237108,24.2706072 102.982664,23.8592738 L102.982664,23.8592738 L102.982664,20.4292727 C101.40733,21.4001619 99.6881074,21.8851621 97.8251069,21.8851621 C96.6054399,21.8851621 95.567884,21.6549398 94.7126615,21.194273 C93.8572168,20.7338284 93.2049944,20.0633837 92.7564387,19.1831613 C92.3073275,18.3032721 92.0831052,17.2380496 92.0831052,15.9876048 C92.0831052,14.7377155 92.3156608,13.6766041 92.7816609,12.8044927 C93.2474389,11.9327147 93.916328,11.2664922 94.7888838,10.8058254 C95.6609951,10.3453809 96.715551,10.1148252 97.9521069,10.1148252 C98.8496628,10.1148252 99.7052186,10.2342697 100.518108,10.4726031 C101.331219,10.7112699 102.084664,11.0609366 102.779442,11.5212701 L102.779442,11.5212701 L102.779442,8.01738016 C102.017219,7.62260227 101.191441,7.32260218 100.302219,7.11671323 C99.4129963,6.91126872 98.4685515,6.80826869 97.469329,6.80826869 Z M55.7552388,7.00000208 L49.0000146,7.00000208 L49.0000146,25.0000021 L56.1713501,25.0000021 C57.590906,25.0000021 58.8063508,24.7903407 59.8181289,24.3706739 C60.8297959,23.9513405 61.6087961,23.3553403 62.1555741,22.5832289 C62.7020187,21.8114509 62.9754632,20.8882284 62.9754632,19.8140059 C62.9754632,18.7232278 62.6941298,17.7960053 62.1312407,17.0321162 C61.5681294,16.2686715 60.7563514,15.7104491 59.6957955,15.3580046 C60.4625736,14.9891156 61.0420182,14.4894488 61.4335738,13.8601152 C61.8252406,13.2307817 62.0210185,12.4881148 62.0210185,11.6321146 C62.0210185,10.1385586 61.4742405,8.99311379 60.3812402,8.19578022 C59.2877954,7.39889109 57.745795,7.00000208 55.7552388,7.00000208 L55.7552388,7.00000208 Z M15.7552269,7.00000208 L9.00000268,7.00000208 L9.00000268,25.0000021 L16.1713381,25.0000021 C17.5908941,25.0000021 18.8062278,24.7903407 19.8182281,24.3706739 C20.8296729,23.9513405 21.6087842,23.3553403 22.1555621,22.5832289 C22.7021179,21.8114509 22.9755624,20.8882284 22.9755624,19.8140059 C22.9755624,18.7232278 22.6941179,17.7960053 22.1311177,17.0321162 C21.5682286,16.2686715 20.7563395,15.7104491 19.6957836,15.3580046 C20.4625616,14.9891156 21.0418952,14.4894488 21.4335619,13.8601152 C21.8252287,13.2307817 22.0210066,12.4881148 22.0210066,11.6321146 C22.0210066,10.1385586 21.4741175,8.99311379 20.3811172,8.19578022 C19.2877835,7.39889109 17.7457831,7.00000208 15.7552269,7.00000208 L15.7552269,7.00000208 Z M55.8775833,17.2209385 C58.1128062,17.2209385 59.2308065,18.0434943 59.2308065,19.6881614 C59.2308065,20.4602728 58.9369175,21.0518285 58.3496951,21.4629397 C57.7622505,21.8743843 56.9216947,22.0797177 55.8286944,22.0797177 L55.8286944,22.0797177 L52.6469157,22.0797177 L52.6469157,17.2209385 Z M15.8775714,17.2209385 C18.1129054,17.2209385 19.2307946,18.0434943 19.2307946,19.6881614 C19.2307946,20.4602728 18.9370167,21.0518285 18.3496832,21.4629397 C17.7622386,21.8743843 16.9216828,22.0797177 15.8286825,22.0797177 L15.8286825,22.0797177 L12.6469038,22.0797177 L12.6469038,17.2209385 Z M55.412572,9.92028073 C57.3541282,9.92028073 58.3252396,10.6338365 58.3252396,12.0600591 C58.3252396,12.7988371 58.0763506,13.373504 57.5786838,13.7846152 C57.0807948,14.1960598 56.3587946,14.4013932 55.412572,14.4013932 L55.412572,14.4013932 L52.6469046,14.4013932 L52.6469046,9.92028073 Z M15.4125601,9.92028073 C17.3541163,9.92028073 18.3252277,10.6338365 18.3252277,12.0600591 C18.3252277,12.7988371 18.0762276,13.373504 17.5786719,13.7846152 C17.0807829,14.1960598 16.3587826,14.4013932 15.4125601,14.4013932 L15.4125601,14.4013932 L12.6468927,14.4013932 L12.6468927,9.92028073 Z"></path></svg></a></div></div></div><div class="sc-ef5cbfd8-6 csYcCE"><div class="sc-644ffb05-2 diAMAx"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://session.bbc.com/session?action=register&amp;userOrigin=BBCS_BBC&amp;ptrt=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bbc.com%2Fnews%2Farticles%2Fcwy603eg0w8o" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><button type="button" aria-label="Register" class="sc-42d8a745-2 sc-42d8a745-3 eKUnhs fpbsEG"><span data-testid="button-text" aria-hidden="false" class="sc-42d8a745-1 cwJkjb">Register</span></button></a></div><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://session.bbc.com/session?userOrigin=BBCS_BBC&amp;ptrt=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bbc.com%2Fnews%2Farticles%2Fcwy603eg0w8o" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><button type="button" aria-label="Sign In" class="sc-42d8a745-2 sc-42d8a745-5 eKUnhs ffpPdD"><span data-testid="button-text" aria-hidden="false" class="sc-42d8a745-1 cwJkjb">Sign In</span></button></a></div></div></div></div></header><nav data-testid="level1-navigation-container" id="main-navigation-container" class="sc-2f092172-9 iQhUVz"><section class="sc-2f092172-0 bbKzwR"><nav class="sc-2f092172-1 bbTVHW"><ul class="sc-2f092172-2 dXwCQe"><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Home</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">News</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/sport" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Sport</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/business" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Business</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/innovation" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Innovation</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/culture" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Culture</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/arts" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Arts</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/travel" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Travel</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/future-planet" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Earth</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ceqlOX"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/audio" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Audio</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/video" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Video</a></div></li><li data-testid="mainNavigationItemStyled" class="sc-2f092172-3 ekoKcE"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/live" data-testid="mainNavigationLink" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Live</a></div></li></ul></nav></section></nav><noscript><details class="sc-9f96938f-0 haQGdI"><summary class="sc-9f96938f-2 hvUmul"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="20" height="20" category="actions" icon="list-view-text" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M1 7.5h30V1.9H1v5.6zm0 22.6h30v-5.6H1v5.6zm0-11.3h30v-5.6H1v5.6z"></path></svg></summary><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 cZSCUM"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/home" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Home</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">News</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/topics/c2vdnvdg6xxt" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Israel-Gaza War</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/war-in-ukraine" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">War in Ukraine</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/us-canada" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">US &amp; Canada</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/uk" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">UK</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/politics" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">UK Politics</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/england" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">England</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/northern_ireland" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">N. Ireland</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/northern_ireland/northern_ireland_politics" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">N. Ireland Politics</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 aSYRH"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/scotland" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Scotland</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/scotland/scotland_politics" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Scotland Politics</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 aSYRH"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/wales" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Wales</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/wales/wales_politics" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Wales Politics</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 aSYRH"></ul></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/world/africa" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Africa</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/world/asia" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Asia</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/world/asia/china" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">China</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/world/asia/india" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">India</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/world/australia" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Australia</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/world/europe" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Europe</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/world/latin_america" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Latin America</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/world/middle_east" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Middle East</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/in_pictures" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">In Pictures</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/bbcindepth" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">BBC InDepth</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/news/bbcverify" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">BBC Verify</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/sport" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Sport</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/business" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Business</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/business/executive-lounge" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Executive Lounge</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/business/technology-of-business" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Technology of Business</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/business/future-of-business" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Future of Business</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/innovation" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Innovation</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/innovation/technology" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Technology</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/innovation/science" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Science &amp; Health</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/innovation/artificial-intelligence" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Artificial Intelligence</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/innovation/ai-v-the-mind" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">AI v the Mind</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/culture" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Culture</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/culture/film-tv" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Film &amp; TV</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/culture/music" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Music</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/culture/art" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Art &amp; Design</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/culture/style" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Style</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/culture/books" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Books</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/culture/entertainment-news" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Entertainment News</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/arts" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Arts</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/arts/arts-in-motion" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Arts in Motion</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Travel</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Destinations</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations/africa" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Africa</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations/antarctica" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Antarctica</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations/asia" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Asia</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations/australia-and-pacific" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Australia and Pacific</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations/caribbean" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Caribbean &amp; Bermuda</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations/central-america" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Central America</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations/europe" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Europe</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations/middle-east" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Middle East</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations/north-america" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">North America</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/destinations/south-america" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">South America</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 jWqIMB"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/worlds-table" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">World’s Table</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/cultural-experiences" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Culture &amp; Experiences</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/adventures" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Adventures</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/travel/specialist" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">The SpeciaList</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/future-planet" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Earth</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/future-planet/natural-wonders" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Natural Wonders</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/future-planet/weather-science" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Weather &amp; Science</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/future-planet/solutions" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Climate Solutions</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/future-planet/sustainable-business" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Sustainable Business</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/future-planet/green-living" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Green Living</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/audio" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Audio</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/audio/categories" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Podcasts</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/audio/stations" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Radio</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/undefined" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Audio FAQs</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/video" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Video</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/live" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Live</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 gpOsSO"><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/live/news" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Live News</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul><li class="sc-9f96938f-3 kjxRaG"><a href="/live/sport" class="sc-2f092172-4 hzuZYr">Live Sport</a></li><ul class="sc-9f96938f-1 eIGAwM"></ul></ul></ul></details></noscript><div data-testid="backdrop" class="sc-39c53776-0 hsmbMJ"></div><div data-testid="drawer-background" direction="left" class="sc-2d3296eb-0 fuMjdQ"><div class="sc-fc671f27-0 jdGaiS"><div class="sc-fc671f27-6 kbxLHW"><div data-testid="search-input-wrapper" class="sc-9e01a804-0 fOFekK"><input type="text" placeholder="Search news, topics and more" data-testid="search-input-field" disabled="" class="sc-9e01a804-1 blIdnk" value=""><button type="button" data-testid="search-input-search-button" aria-label="Search" class="sc-42d8a745-2 sc-42d8a745-3 eKUnhs fpbsEG"><span data-testid="button-icon-wrapper" class="sc-42d8a745-0 cGPRuP"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="actions" icon="search" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="m30.6 28.1-8.3-8.3c1.5-2 2.4-4.4 2.4-7.2C24.7 6 19.6 1 13 1S1.4 6.1 1.4 12.7 6.5 24.3 13 24.3c2.3 0 4.4-.6 6.2-1.8l8.5 8.5 2.9-2.9zM4 12.6c0-5.2 3.9-9.1 9-9.1s9 3.9 9 9.1c0 5.2-3.9 9.1-9 9.1s-9-3.9-9-9.1z"></path></svg></span></button></div></div><div class="sc-fc671f27-7 jyCiYm"><div class="sc-644ffb05-2 gdNyaF"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://session.bbc.com/session?action=register&amp;userOrigin=BBCS_BBC&amp;ptrt=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bbc.com%2Fnews%2Farticles%2Fcwy603eg0w8o" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-ac7f3982-2 cwvXjc">Register</a></div><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://session.bbc.com/session?userOrigin=BBCS_BBC&amp;ptrt=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bbc.com%2Fnews%2Farticles%2Fcwy603eg0w8o" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-ac7f3982-2 fDbEjY">Sign In</a></div></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/" data-testid="internal-link" tabindex="-1" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/home" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/home" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Home</span></button></a></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/news" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/news" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">News</span><div data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIconWrapper-/news" class="sc-fc671f27-1 itBpIZ"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="arrows" icon="chevron-down" data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIcon-/news" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M17.7 22.6.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4zm0 0L.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4z"></path></svg></div></button></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/sport" data-testid="internal-link" tabindex="-1" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/sport" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/sport" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Sport</span></button></a></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/business" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/business" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Business</span><div data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIconWrapper-/business" class="sc-fc671f27-1 itBpIZ"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="arrows" icon="chevron-down" data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIcon-/business" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M17.7 22.6.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4zm0 0L.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4z"></path></svg></div></button></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/innovation" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/innovation" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Innovation</span><div data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIconWrapper-/innovation" class="sc-fc671f27-1 itBpIZ"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="arrows" icon="chevron-down" data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIcon-/innovation" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M17.7 22.6.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4zm0 0L.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4z"></path></svg></div></button></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/culture" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/culture" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Culture</span><div data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIconWrapper-/culture" class="sc-fc671f27-1 itBpIZ"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="arrows" icon="chevron-down" data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIcon-/culture" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M17.7 22.6.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4zm0 0L.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4z"></path></svg></div></button></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/arts" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/arts" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Arts</span><div data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIconWrapper-/arts" class="sc-fc671f27-1 itBpIZ"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="arrows" icon="chevron-down" data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIcon-/arts" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M17.7 22.6.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4zm0 0L.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4z"></path></svg></div></button></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/travel" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/travel" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Travel</span><div data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIconWrapper-/travel" class="sc-fc671f27-1 itBpIZ"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="arrows" icon="chevron-down" data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIcon-/travel" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M17.7 22.6.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4zm0 0L.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4z"></path></svg></div></button></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/future-planet" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/future-planet" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Earth</span><div data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIconWrapper-/future-planet" class="sc-fc671f27-1 itBpIZ"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="arrows" icon="chevron-down" data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIcon-/future-planet" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M17.7 22.6.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4zm0 0L.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4z"></path></svg></div></button></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/audio" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/audio" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Audio</span><div data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIconWrapper-/audio" class="sc-fc671f27-1 itBpIZ"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="arrows" icon="chevron-down" data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIcon-/audio" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M17.7 22.6.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4zm0 0L.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4z"></path></svg></div></button></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/video" data-testid="internal-link" tabindex="-1" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/video" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/video" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Video</span></button></a></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><div><button data-testid="level0NavButton-/live" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-/live" class="sc-fc671f27-3 jRsIAV">Live</span><div data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIconWrapper-/live" class="sc-fc671f27-1 itBpIZ"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="arrows" icon="chevron-down" data-testid="menuItem-ChevronIcon-/live" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M17.7 22.6.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4zm0 0L.9 4.2v6.7L16 27.8 31.1 11V4.3L14.3 22.6h3.4z"></path></svg></div></button></div></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><a target="_self" href="https://www.bbc.com/weather" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><button data-testid="level0NavButton-https://www.bbc.com/weather" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-https://www.bbc.com/weather">Weather</span></button></a></div><div data-testid="navigationPanel-navItem-level0-/" class="sc-fc671f27-5 jtxkAZ"><a target="_self" href="https://www.bbc.com/newsletters" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><button data-testid="level0NavButton-https://www.bbc.com/newsletters" class="sc-fc671f27-2 iyUgeV"><span data-testid="level0NavText-https://www.bbc.com/newsletters">Newsletters</span></button></a></div></div></div><main id="main-content"><div data-testid="ad-unit" data-component="ad-slot" class="sc-cce5f0ff-0 ktiuMQ"><div data-testid="dotcom-top" id="dotcom-top" class="dotcom-ad active" aria-hidden="true" style="background-color: rgb(248, 248, 248);"><div class="dotcom-ad-inner"><div class="dotcom-ad-text-wrapper" style="width: 1324px;"><span class="dotcom-ad-text" tabindex="-1">Advertisement</span></div><div id="dotcom-slot-top" class="dotcom-slot" data-google-query-id="CIGjnqvhko0DFSYmgwMdTAACBw"><div id="google_ads_iframe_/4817/bbccom/business/business/article/top_0__container__" style="border: 0pt none;"><iframe id="google_ads_iframe_/4817/bbccom/business/business/article/top_0" name="google_ads_iframe_/4817/bbccom/business/business/article/top_0" title="3rd party ad content" width="728" height="90" scrolling="no" marginwidth="0" marginheight="0" frameborder="0" aria-label="Advertisement" tabindex="-1" allow="private-state-token-redemption;attribution-reporting" data-load-complete="true" data-google-container-id="2" style="border: 0px; vertical-align: bottom;"></iframe></div></div></div></div></div><article><div data-component="headline-block" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 fDtfvH"><h1 class="sc-737179d2-0 dAzQyd">OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash</h1></div><div data-component="byline-block" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 dEGcKf"><div data-testid="byline-new" class="sc-801dd632-0 eSlECZ"><div class="sc-801dd632-1 eeJXtz"><time datetime="2025-05-05T23:08:41.684Z" class="sc-801dd632-2 IvNnh">2 days ago</time><div class="sc-801dd632-3 gXqOYA"><div data-testid="popoverWrapper" id="popover-wrapper" class="sc-e1993691-1 hIQXRl"><div data-testid="popoverTrigger" id="popover-trigger"><button type="button" data-testid="socialShareTriggerButton" aria-label="Share" class="sc-42d8a745-2 sc-42d8a745-5 sc-42d8a745-6 bHDbVj ffpPdD htCKMu"><span data-testid="button-icon-wrapper" class="sc-42d8a745-0 jNAQSQ"><svg width="12" height="14" viewBox="0 0 12 14" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" category="social" icon="share" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M9.51768 8.96851C8.95518 8.96851 8.44393 9.19851 8.07227 9.57018L4.19727 7.36685C4.24893 7.18768 4.2856 7.00185 4.2856 6.80685C4.2856 6.61102 4.24977 6.42518 4.19893 6.2456L8.06143 4.04935C8.43393 4.42602 8.94977 4.66102 9.51768 4.66102C10.661 4.66102 11.5852 3.73643 11.5852 2.60893C11.5852 1.46518 10.661 0.541016 9.51768 0.541016C8.38977 0.541016 7.4656 1.46518 7.4656 2.60893C7.4656 2.78727 7.49602 2.95768 7.53935 3.12352L3.70727 5.37643C3.33143 4.98477 2.80477 4.73935 2.2181 4.73935C1.09018 4.73935 0.166016 5.6631 0.166016 6.80685C0.166016 7.93476 1.09018 8.85851 2.2181 8.85851C2.8006 8.85851 3.32435 8.61726 3.69977 8.23268L7.54602 10.4943C7.49893 10.6681 7.4656 10.8473 7.4656 11.036C7.4656 12.1639 8.38977 13.0881 9.51768 13.0881C10.661 13.0881 11.5852 12.1639 11.5852 11.036C11.5852 9.89268 10.661 8.96851 9.51768 8.96851"></path></svg></span><span data-testid="button-text" aria-hidden="false" class="sc-42d8a745-1 cwJkjb">Share</span></button></div></div><div data-testid="popoverWrapper" id="popover-wrapper" class="sc-e1993691-1 hIQXRl"><div data-testid="popoverTrigger" id="popover-trigger"><button type="button" data-testid="saveButton" aria-label="Save" class="sc-42d8a745-2 sc-42d8a745-5 sc-42d8a745-6 bcpeIB fxnHdQ fYsCgf"><span data-testid="button-icon-wrapper" class="sc-42d8a745-0 jNAQSQ"><svg width="32" height="32" viewBox="0 0 12 14" category="account" icon="saved-items-outlined" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M5.99996 9.43351L9.46496 11.0741L9.46496 2.0125L2.53496 2.0125L2.53496 11.0741L5.99996 9.43351ZM0.959961 13.5625L0.959961 0.4375L11.04 0.4375L11.04 13.5625L5.99996 11.1761L0.959961 13.5625Z" fill="currentColor"></path></svg></span><span data-testid="button-text" aria-hidden="false" class="sc-42d8a745-1 cwJkjb">Save</span></button></div></div></div></div><div data-testid="byline-new-contributors" class="sc-801dd632-12 jSIeFi"><div class="sc-801dd632-5 kRoBHa"><div><span class="sc-801dd632-7 lasLGY">Natalie Sherman</span><div class="sc-801dd632-8 hwLppI"><span>BBC News</span></div></div></div></div><div class="sc-801dd632-4 jdpfMh"><div data-testid="popoverWrapper" id="popover-wrapper" class="sc-e1993691-1 hIQXRl"><div data-testid="popoverTrigger" id="popover-trigger"><button type="button" data-testid="socialShareTriggerButton" aria-label="Share" class="sc-42d8a745-2 sc-42d8a745-5 sc-42d8a745-6 bHDbVj ffpPdD htCKMu"><span data-testid="button-icon-wrapper" class="sc-42d8a745-0 jNAQSQ"><svg width="12" height="14" viewBox="0 0 12 14" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" category="social" icon="share" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M9.51768 8.96851C8.95518 8.96851 8.44393 9.19851 8.07227 9.57018L4.19727 7.36685C4.24893 7.18768 4.2856 7.00185 4.2856 6.80685C4.2856 6.61102 4.24977 6.42518 4.19893 6.2456L8.06143 4.04935C8.43393 4.42602 8.94977 4.66102 9.51768 4.66102C10.661 4.66102 11.5852 3.73643 11.5852 2.60893C11.5852 1.46518 10.661 0.541016 9.51768 0.541016C8.38977 0.541016 7.4656 1.46518 7.4656 2.60893C7.4656 2.78727 7.49602 2.95768 7.53935 3.12352L3.70727 5.37643C3.33143 4.98477 2.80477 4.73935 2.2181 4.73935C1.09018 4.73935 0.166016 5.6631 0.166016 6.80685C0.166016 7.93476 1.09018 8.85851 2.2181 8.85851C2.8006 8.85851 3.32435 8.61726 3.69977 8.23268L7.54602 10.4943C7.49893 10.6681 7.4656 10.8473 7.4656 11.036C7.4656 12.1639 8.38977 13.0881 9.51768 13.0881C10.661 13.0881 11.5852 12.1639 11.5852 11.036C11.5852 9.89268 10.661 8.96851 9.51768 8.96851"></path></svg></span><span data-testid="button-text" aria-hidden="false" class="sc-42d8a745-1 cwJkjb">Share</span></button></div></div><div data-testid="popoverWrapper" id="popover-wrapper" class="sc-e1993691-1 hIQXRl"><div data-testid="popoverTrigger" id="popover-trigger"><button type="button" data-testid="saveButton" aria-label="Save" class="sc-42d8a745-2 sc-42d8a745-5 sc-42d8a745-6 bcpeIB fxnHdQ fYsCgf"><span data-testid="button-icon-wrapper" class="sc-42d8a745-0 jNAQSQ"><svg width="32" height="32" viewBox="0 0 12 14" category="account" icon="saved-items-outlined" aria-hidden="true" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M5.99996 9.43351L9.46496 11.0741L9.46496 2.0125L2.53496 2.0125L2.53496 11.0741L5.99996 9.43351ZM0.959961 13.5625L0.959961 0.4375L11.04 0.4375L11.04 13.5625L5.99996 11.1761L0.959961 13.5625Z" fill="currentColor"></path></svg></span><span data-testid="button-text" aria-hidden="false" class="sc-42d8a745-1 cwJkjb">Save</span></button></div></div></div></div></div><figure><div data-component="image-block" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 kVRMhO"><div data-testid="hero-image" class="sc-4abb68ca-1 eOgpjw"><img sizes="(min-width: 1280px) 50vw, (min-width: 1008px) 66vw, 96vw" srcset="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/240/cpsprodpb/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg.webp 240w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/320/cpsprodpb/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg.webp 320w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg.webp 480w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/640/cpsprodpb/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg.webp 640w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/800/cpsprodpb/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg.webp 800w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/cpsprodpb/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg.webp 1024w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1536/cpsprodpb/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg.webp 1536w" src="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg.webp" loading="eager" alt="Getty Images Sam Altman, chief executive officer of OpenAI Inc., at Station F during the AI Action Summit in Paris, France, on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025." class="sc-4abb68ca-0 ldLcJe"><span class="sc-4abb68ca-2 kkAKIJ">Getty Images</span></div></div></figure><div data-component="text-block" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 dEGcKf"><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">OpenAI, the parent of artificial intelligence service ChatGPT, has announced a new governance plan after a bitter power struggle over the business.</p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">Boss Sam Altman said OpenAI would remain under the control of its non-profit board, while becoming what is known in the US as a public benefit corporation.</p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">Mr Altman had put forward <a target="_blank" href="https://openai.com/index/why-our-structure-must-evolve-to-advance-our-mission/" class="sc-f9178328-0 bGFWdi">a similar plan in December</a> - but without clarifying the control of the non-profit. </p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">The update follows widespread scrutiny of the startup, which began as a non-profit and faced criticism, including from co-founder Elon Musk, that its quest for growth is pushing it to stray from its original mission of creating technology for the benefit of humanity.</p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS"></p></div><div data-testid="ad-unit" data-component="ad-slot" class="sc-cce5f0ff-0 Bitbe"><div data-testid="dotcom-mid_1" id="dotcom-mid_1" class="dotcom-ad lazy" data-ad-slot="{}"></div></div><div data-component="text-block" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 dEGcKf"><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">Last month, a group of former open AI staff and outside experts, including Geoffrey Hinton, <a target="_blank" href="https://notforprivategain.org/" class="sc-f9178328-0 bGFWdi">wrote to regulators in California and Delaware</a>, which have power over non-profits, asking them to intervene to block the conversion.</p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">OpenAI chairman Bret Taylor said the start-up made the decision "after hearing from civic leaders and engaging in constructive dialogue with the offices of the Attorney General of Delaware and the Attorney General of California".</p></div><div data-component="text-block" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 dEGcKf"><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">In the update on Monday, Mr Altman said the non-profit would continue to control OpenAI, receiving a "big", yet-to-be determined stake in OpenAI's business arm, which would give it access to money to put towards its own goals.</p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">He said the new plan would still allow the organisation to stop operating under its current complex governance structure, which had capped its profits.</p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">That was seen as a sticking point for investors, including Microsoft, that hindered the firm's ability to raise money. </p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">"We are moving to a normal capital structure where everyone has stock," he wrote in a letter to staff that was shared on the OpenAI website. "This is not a sale, but a change of structure to something simpler."</p></div><div data-testid="ad-unit" data-component="ad-slot" class="sc-cce5f0ff-0 Bitbe"><div data-testid="dotcom-mid_2" id="dotcom-mid_2" class="dotcom-ad lazy" data-ad-slot="{}"></div></div><div data-component="text-block" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 dEGcKf"><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">Unlike traditional for-profit companies, which are bound to act in service to shareholders, a public benefit corporation is also responsible for a public mission. </p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">In the update on Monday, Mr Altman said he believed that growth and extending access to AI, which would take money, was consistent with the firm's mission, because it would help people "build incredible things for each other and continue to drive society and quality of life forward".</p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">"It will of course not be all used for good, but we trust humanity and think the good will outweigh the bad by orders of magnitude," he wrote.</p></div><div data-component="text-block" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 dEGcKf"><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">It is not clear to what extent the new plan will satisfy investors or critics.</p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">After the announcement Page Hedley, OpenAI's former policy and ethics adviser, who had spearheaded last month's letter, said the update did not resolve issues such as who would own the firm's technology and how its goals would be prioritised.</p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">"We're glad that OpenAI is listening to concerns from civil society leaders ... but crucial questions remain," he said. </p></div><div data-testid="ad-unit" data-component="ad-slot" class="sc-cce5f0ff-0 Bitbe"><div data-testid="dotcom-mid_3" id="dotcom-mid_3" class="dotcom-ad lazy" data-ad-slot="{}"></div></div><figure><div data-component="image-block" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 dFZIgd"><div data-testid="image" class="sc-4abb68ca-1 eOgpjw"><img sizes="(min-width: 1280px) 50vw, (min-width: 1008px) 66vw, 96vw" srcset="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/240/cpsprodpb/8967/live/387a6450-2a54-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.png.webp 240w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/320/cpsprodpb/8967/live/387a6450-2a54-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.png.webp 320w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/8967/live/387a6450-2a54-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.png.webp 480w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/640/cpsprodpb/8967/live/387a6450-2a54-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.png.webp 640w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/800/cpsprodpb/8967/live/387a6450-2a54-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.png.webp 800w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/cpsprodpb/8967/live/387a6450-2a54-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.png.webp 1024w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1536/cpsprodpb/8967/live/387a6450-2a54-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.png.webp 1536w" src="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/8967/live/387a6450-2a54-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.png.webp" loading="lazy" alt="A green promotional banner with black squares and rectangles forming pixels, moving in from the right. The text says: “Tech Decoded: The world’s biggest tech news in your inbox every Monday.”" class="sc-4abb68ca-0 ldLcJe"></div></div></figure><div data-component="text-block" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 dEGcKf"><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS"><a target="_self" href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsletters/zxh6cxs" class="sc-f9178328-0 bGFWdi">Sign up for our Tech Decoded newsletter</a> to follow the world's top tech stories and trends. <a target="_self" href="https://cloud.email.bbc.com/techdecoded-newsletter-signup?&amp;at_bbc_team=studios&amp;at_medium=Onsite&amp;at_objective=acquisition&amp;at_ptr_type=&amp;at_ptr_name=bbc.com&amp;at_format=&amp;at_link_origin=&amp;at_campaign=techdecoded&amp;at_campaign_id=&amp;at_adset_name=&amp;at_adset_id=&amp;at_creation=&amp;at_creative_id=&amp;at_campaign_type=owned" class="sc-f9178328-0 bGFWdi">Outside the UK? Sign up here.</a></p></div><div data-component="tags" class="sc-3b6b161a-0 dHQIrb"><div class="sc-6bf80075-0 kkfrXx"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/topics/c302m85q53mt" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-57521d02-0 emeJAW">Elon Musk</a></div><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/topics/c4nrdv135zet" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-57521d02-0 emeJAW">International Business</a></div><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/topics/ce1qrvleleqt" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-57521d02-0 emeJAW">Artificial intelligence</a></div><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/topics/cvenzmgyg0lt" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-57521d02-0 emeJAW">Microsoft</a></div></div></div></article><aside data-testid="ohio-section-outer-3" data-analytics-group="true" data-analytics_group_type="ohio-3" data-analytics_group_position="1" data-analytics_group_item_count="3" data-analytics_group_name="Related" class="sc-464f550b-1 iKDozC"><div data-testid="ohio-section-3" class="sc-464f550b-2 iEUdAz"><div class="sc-51ae3df-2 jPkqHi"><div class="sc-51ae3df-1 faUgkD"><hr data-testid="ohio-line" class="sc-51ae3df-0 gmqhYi"></div><div data-testid="section-title-wrapper" class="sc-51ae3df-3 klmwUe"><div><span data-testid="ohio-title" class="sc-51ae3df-4 jjpHxS">Related</span></div></div></div><div data-testid="ohio-grid-3" class="sc-e45665dd-0 exaGgF"><div data-testid="chester-card" data-indexcard="true" class="sc-225578b-0 btdqbl"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/articles/c39j8rj4nmmo" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><div data-testid="chester-article" class="sc-bec5e5d2-0 eUcHmo"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-1 dOyfhs"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-0 eKWlJZ"><h2 data-testid="card-headline" class="sc-9d830f2a-3 fWzToZ">Elon Musk's Starbase in Texas will officially become a city</h2></div></div><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 kOnnpG"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 gxJSVz">4 days ago</span><div data-testid="card-metadata-separator" class="sc-ac6bc755-3 kfKTTQ"></div><span data-testid="card-metadata-tag" class="sc-ac6bc755-2 ivCQgh">US &amp; Canada</span></div></div></a></div></div><div data-testid="chester-card" data-indexcard="true" class="sc-225578b-0 btdqbl"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/articles/cdjl4k8jyxeo" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><div data-testid="chester-article" class="sc-bec5e5d2-0 eUcHmo"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-1 dOyfhs"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-0 eKWlJZ"><h2 data-testid="card-headline" class="sc-9d830f2a-3 fWzToZ">What might Reform do with its newly won power?</h2></div></div><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 kOnnpG"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 gxJSVz">4 days ago</span><div data-testid="card-metadata-separator" class="sc-ac6bc755-3 kfKTTQ"></div><span data-testid="card-metadata-tag" class="sc-ac6bc755-2 ivCQgh">Politics</span></div></div></a></div></div><div data-testid="chester-card" data-indexcard="true" class="sc-225578b-0 btdqbl"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/articles/cr4n94klqg9o" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><div data-testid="chester-article" class="sc-bec5e5d2-0 eUcHmo"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-1 dOyfhs"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-0 eKWlJZ"><h2 data-testid="card-headline" class="sc-9d830f2a-3 fWzToZ">Tesla denies contacting headhunters to replace Musk</h2></div></div><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 kOnnpG"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 gxJSVz">7 days ago</span><div data-testid="card-metadata-separator" class="sc-ac6bc755-3 kfKTTQ"></div><span data-testid="card-metadata-tag" class="sc-ac6bc755-2 ivCQgh">Business</span></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></aside><aside data-testid="alaska-section-outer" data-analytics-group="true" data-analytics_group_type="alaska-5" data-analytics_group_position="2" data-analytics_group_item_count="5" data-analytics_group_name="More" class="sc-464f550b-1 iKDozC"><div data-testid="alaska-section" class="sc-464f550b-2 iEUdAz"><div class="sc-51ae3df-2 jPkqHi"><div class="sc-51ae3df-1 faUgkD"><hr data-testid="alaska-line" class="sc-51ae3df-0 gmqhYi"></div><div data-testid="section-title-wrapper" class="sc-51ae3df-3 klmwUe"><div><span data-testid="alaska-title" class="sc-51ae3df-4 jjpHxS">More</span></div></div></div><div class="sc-c5803051-0 izsbSA"><div data-testid="alaska-grid" class="sc-666b6d83-0 sc-c5803051-1 cLBIlS ethsyB"><div data-testid="liverpool-card" data-indexcard="true" class="sc-225578b-0 btdqbl"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/articles/cq808px90wxo" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><div class="sc-dd19b12e-4 fjMEDd"><div class="sc-dd19b12e-1 dea-dFK"><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 ijGLrd"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 jhLmpQ">3 hrs ago</span></div></div><div data-testid="liverpool-article" class="sc-dd19b12e-3 kxJBvo"><div data-testid="card-media-wrapper" class="sc-dd19b12e-5 dBDTuW"><div data-testid="card-media" class="sc-dd19b12e-2 UNAmc"><div class="sc-4abb68ca-1 eOgpjw"><img src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/grey-placeholder.png" class="sc-4abb68ca-0 itgEAh hide-when-no-script"><img sizes="(min-width: 1008px) 25vw, (min-width: 600px) 33vw, 50vw" srcset="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/240/cpsprodpb/fc68/live/3ebe7160-2b7d-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.jpg.webp 240w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/320/cpsprodpb/fc68/live/3ebe7160-2b7d-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.jpg.webp 320w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/fc68/live/3ebe7160-2b7d-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.jpg.webp 480w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/640/cpsprodpb/fc68/live/3ebe7160-2b7d-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.jpg.webp 640w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/800/cpsprodpb/fc68/live/3ebe7160-2b7d-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.jpg.webp 800w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/cpsprodpb/fc68/live/3ebe7160-2b7d-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.jpg.webp 1024w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1536/cpsprodpb/fc68/live/3ebe7160-2b7d-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.jpg.webp 1536w" src="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/fc68/live/3ebe7160-2b7d-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.jpg.webp" loading="lazy" alt="Man in green jacket with baseball hat" class="sc-4abb68ca-0 ldLcJe"></div></div></div><div data-testid="card-text-wrapper" class="sc-dd19b12e-6 dqvwjN"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-1 kLnZbC"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-0 eKWlJZ"><h2 data-testid="card-headline" class="sc-9d830f2a-3 gCxBuB">Arizona man shot to death in road rage 'returns' to address his killer</h2></div></div><p data-testid="card-description" class="sc-dd19b12e-0 dRpwbO">With the help of artificial intelligence, a man was 'brought back to life' at his killer's sentencing to deliver a victim's statement himself. </p><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 eErpCN"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 cnYvXs">3 hrs ago</span><div data-testid="card-metadata-separator" class="sc-ac6bc755-3 jiwbZb"></div><span data-testid="card-metadata-tag" class="sc-ac6bc755-2 ivCQgh">US &amp; Canada</span></div></div></div></div></a></div></div><div data-testid="liverpool-card" data-indexcard="true" class="sc-225578b-0 btdqbl"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/articles/c77n76kzmz4o" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><div class="sc-dd19b12e-4 fjMEDd"><div class="sc-dd19b12e-1 dea-dFK"><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 ijGLrd"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 jhLmpQ">15 hrs ago</span></div></div><div data-testid="liverpool-article" class="sc-dd19b12e-3 kxJBvo"><div data-testid="card-media-wrapper" class="sc-dd19b12e-5 dBDTuW"><div data-testid="card-media" class="sc-dd19b12e-2 UNAmc"><div class="sc-4abb68ca-1 eOgpjw"><img src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/grey-placeholder.png" class="sc-4abb68ca-0 itgEAh hide-when-no-script"><img sizes="(min-width: 1008px) 25vw, (min-width: 600px) 33vw, 50vw" srcset="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/240/cpsprodpb/a826/live/a9efc0b0-2b2d-11f0-a926-032a6ac0e498.jpg.webp 240w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/320/cpsprodpb/a826/live/a9efc0b0-2b2d-11f0-a926-032a6ac0e498.jpg.webp 320w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/a826/live/a9efc0b0-2b2d-11f0-a926-032a6ac0e498.jpg.webp 480w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/640/cpsprodpb/a826/live/a9efc0b0-2b2d-11f0-a926-032a6ac0e498.jpg.webp 640w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/800/cpsprodpb/a826/live/a9efc0b0-2b2d-11f0-a926-032a6ac0e498.jpg.webp 800w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/cpsprodpb/a826/live/a9efc0b0-2b2d-11f0-a926-032a6ac0e498.jpg.webp 1024w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1536/cpsprodpb/a826/live/a9efc0b0-2b2d-11f0-a926-032a6ac0e498.jpg.webp 1536w" src="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/a826/live/a9efc0b0-2b2d-11f0-a926-032a6ac0e498.jpg.webp" loading="lazy" alt="The NSO logo on its HQ in Israel" class="sc-4abb68ca-0 ldLcJe"></div></div></div><div data-testid="card-text-wrapper" class="sc-dd19b12e-6 dqvwjN"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-1 kLnZbC"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-0 eKWlJZ"><h2 data-testid="card-headline" class="sc-9d830f2a-3 gCxBuB">Maker of Pegasus spyware told to pay $167m for WhatsApp hack</h2></div></div><p data-testid="card-description" class="sc-dd19b12e-0 dRpwbO">Journalists and activists say the software is used by authoritarian regimes to spy on them.</p><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 eErpCN"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 cnYvXs">15 hrs ago</span><div data-testid="card-metadata-separator" class="sc-ac6bc755-3 jiwbZb"></div><span data-testid="card-metadata-tag" class="sc-ac6bc755-2 ivCQgh">Technology</span></div></div></div></div></a></div></div><div data-testid="liverpool-card" data-indexcard="true" class="sc-225578b-0 btdqbl"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/articles/c8rgrejkvmjo" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><div class="sc-dd19b12e-4 fjMEDd"><div class="sc-dd19b12e-1 dea-dFK"><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 ijGLrd"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 jhLmpQ">22 hrs ago</span></div></div><div data-testid="liverpool-article" class="sc-dd19b12e-3 kxJBvo"><div data-testid="card-media-wrapper" class="sc-dd19b12e-5 dBDTuW"><div data-testid="card-media" class="sc-dd19b12e-2 UNAmc"><div class="sc-4abb68ca-1 eOgpjw"><img src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/grey-placeholder.png" class="sc-4abb68ca-0 itgEAh hide-when-no-script"><img sizes="(min-width: 1008px) 25vw, (min-width: 600px) 33vw, 50vw" srcset="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/240/cpsprodpb/6bab/live/27bebb90-2ad4-11f0-b335-f93d8286b78f.jpg.webp 240w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/320/cpsprodpb/6bab/live/27bebb90-2ad4-11f0-b335-f93d8286b78f.jpg.webp 320w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/6bab/live/27bebb90-2ad4-11f0-b335-f93d8286b78f.jpg.webp 480w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/640/cpsprodpb/6bab/live/27bebb90-2ad4-11f0-b335-f93d8286b78f.jpg.webp 640w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/800/cpsprodpb/6bab/live/27bebb90-2ad4-11f0-b335-f93d8286b78f.jpg.webp 800w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/cpsprodpb/6bab/live/27bebb90-2ad4-11f0-b335-f93d8286b78f.jpg.webp 1024w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1536/cpsprodpb/6bab/live/27bebb90-2ad4-11f0-b335-f93d8286b78f.jpg.webp 1536w" src="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/6bab/live/27bebb90-2ad4-11f0-b335-f93d8286b78f.jpg.webp" loading="lazy" alt="The SM Kwangyang container ship docked at the Port of Long Beach in Long Beach, California, US, on Sunday, 27 April, 2025." class="sc-4abb68ca-0 ldLcJe"></div></div></div><div data-testid="card-text-wrapper" class="sc-dd19b12e-6 dqvwjN"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-1 kLnZbC"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-0 eKWlJZ"><h2 data-testid="card-headline" class="sc-9d830f2a-3 gCxBuB">US and China to start talks over trade war this week</h2></div></div><p data-testid="card-description" class="sc-dd19b12e-0 dRpwbO">Global trade experts have told the BBC they expect the negotiations to take several months.</p><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 eErpCN"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 cnYvXs">22 hrs ago</span><div data-testid="card-metadata-separator" class="sc-ac6bc755-3 jiwbZb"></div><span data-testid="card-metadata-tag" class="sc-ac6bc755-2 ivCQgh">Business</span></div></div></div></div></a></div></div><div data-testid="liverpool-card" data-indexcard="true" class="sc-225578b-0 btdqbl"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/articles/c62z5yl2l1lo" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><div class="sc-dd19b12e-4 fjMEDd"><div class="sc-dd19b12e-1 dea-dFK"><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 ijGLrd"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 jhLmpQ">2 days ago</span></div></div><div data-testid="liverpool-article" class="sc-dd19b12e-3 kxJBvo"><div data-testid="card-media-wrapper" class="sc-dd19b12e-5 dBDTuW"><div data-testid="card-media" class="sc-dd19b12e-2 UNAmc"><div class="sc-4abb68ca-1 eOgpjw"><img src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/grey-placeholder.png" class="sc-4abb68ca-0 itgEAh hide-when-no-script"><img sizes="(min-width: 1008px) 25vw, (min-width: 600px) 33vw, 50vw" srcset="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/240/cpsprodpb/efaf/live/23a82fb0-2051-11f0-812e-1d2d70e7f356.jpg.webp 240w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/320/cpsprodpb/efaf/live/23a82fb0-2051-11f0-812e-1d2d70e7f356.jpg.webp 320w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/efaf/live/23a82fb0-2051-11f0-812e-1d2d70e7f356.jpg.webp 480w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/640/cpsprodpb/efaf/live/23a82fb0-2051-11f0-812e-1d2d70e7f356.jpg.webp 640w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/800/cpsprodpb/efaf/live/23a82fb0-2051-11f0-812e-1d2d70e7f356.jpg.webp 800w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/cpsprodpb/efaf/live/23a82fb0-2051-11f0-812e-1d2d70e7f356.jpg.webp 1024w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1536/cpsprodpb/efaf/live/23a82fb0-2051-11f0-812e-1d2d70e7f356.jpg.webp 1536w" src="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/efaf/live/23a82fb0-2051-11f0-812e-1d2d70e7f356.jpg.webp" loading="lazy" alt="A carer using his smartphone app called Paincheck to monitor a resident's face to check for pain" class="sc-4abb68ca-0 ldLcJe"></div></div></div><div data-testid="card-text-wrapper" class="sc-dd19b12e-6 dqvwjN"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-1 kLnZbC"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-0 eKWlJZ"><h2 data-testid="card-headline" class="sc-9d830f2a-3 gCxBuB">Can AI care for your loved ones?</h2></div></div><p data-testid="card-description" class="sc-dd19b12e-0 dRpwbO">Apps to detect pain and robots training carers, how the care industry is changing in the UK.</p><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 eErpCN"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 cnYvXs">2 days ago</span><div data-testid="card-metadata-separator" class="sc-ac6bc755-3 jiwbZb"></div><span data-testid="card-metadata-tag" class="sc-ac6bc755-2 ivCQgh">England</span></div></div></div></div></a></div></div><div data-testid="ad-unit" data-component="ad-slot" class="sc-cce5f0ff-0 Bitbe"><div data-testid="dotcom-mid_4" id="dotcom-mid_4" class="dotcom-ad lazy" data-ad-slot="{}"></div></div><div data-testid="liverpool-card" data-indexcard="true" class="sc-225578b-0 btdqbl"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news/articles/cly1e7ll07do" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><div class="sc-dd19b12e-4 fjMEDd"><div class="sc-dd19b12e-1 dea-dFK"><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 ijGLrd"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 jhLmpQ">2 days ago</span></div></div><div data-testid="liverpool-article" class="sc-dd19b12e-3 jxDWOf"><div data-testid="card-media-wrapper" class="sc-dd19b12e-5 dBDTuW"><div data-testid="card-media" class="sc-dd19b12e-2 UNAmc"><div class="sc-4abb68ca-1 eOgpjw"><img src="https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1/grey-placeholder.png" class="sc-4abb68ca-0 itgEAh hide-when-no-script"><img sizes="(min-width: 1008px) 25vw, (min-width: 600px) 33vw, 50vw" srcset="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/240/cpsprodpb/1009/live/accf83c0-2a4b-11f0-a469-7f005c3e0578.png.webp 240w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/320/cpsprodpb/1009/live/accf83c0-2a4b-11f0-a469-7f005c3e0578.png.webp 320w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/1009/live/accf83c0-2a4b-11f0-a469-7f005c3e0578.png.webp 480w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/640/cpsprodpb/1009/live/accf83c0-2a4b-11f0-a469-7f005c3e0578.png.webp 640w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/800/cpsprodpb/1009/live/accf83c0-2a4b-11f0-a469-7f005c3e0578.png.webp 800w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1024/cpsprodpb/1009/live/accf83c0-2a4b-11f0-a469-7f005c3e0578.png.webp 1024w,https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/1536/cpsprodpb/1009/live/accf83c0-2a4b-11f0-a469-7f005c3e0578.png.webp 1536w" src="https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/1009/live/accf83c0-2a4b-11f0-a469-7f005c3e0578.png.webp" loading="lazy" alt="A Barbie doll wearing a pink dress with huge bows on the hips blowing kisses on a red carpet style background" class="sc-4abb68ca-0 ldLcJe"></div></div></div><div data-testid="card-text-wrapper" class="sc-dd19b12e-6 dqvwjN"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-1 kLnZbC"><div class="sc-9d830f2a-0 eKWlJZ"><h2 data-testid="card-headline" class="sc-9d830f2a-3 gCxBuB">Car giant Ford and Barbie maker Mattel warn over tariffs costs</h2></div></div><p data-testid="card-description" class="sc-dd19b12e-0 dRpwbO">The firms join a growing list of big businesses cautioning about the impact of Trump's import taxes.</p><div class="sc-ac6bc755-0 eErpCN"><span data-testid="card-metadata-lastupdated" class="sc-ac6bc755-1 cnYvXs">2 days ago</span><div data-testid="card-metadata-separator" class="sc-ac6bc755-3 jiwbZb"></div><span data-testid="card-metadata-tag" class="sc-ac6bc755-2 ivCQgh">Business</span></div></div></div></div></a></div></div></div></div></div></aside><div class="zephr_meter_beta"></div><div class="zephr_story_beta"></div></main><hr data-testid="main-footer-divider" class="sc-2983642f-2 dTjesj"><footer data-testid="main-footer" class="sc-2983642f-0 kPARwf"><div class="sc-2983642f-3 eBPHAI"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-8a623a54-0 hMvGwj"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 112 32" category="logo" icon="bbc" style="height:30px" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 cySMiL"><title>British Broadcasting Corporation</title><path d="M111.99999,4.44444577e-05 L111.99999,32.0000444 L79.9999905,32.0000444 L79.9999905,4.44444577e-05 L111.99999,4.44444577e-05 Z M72.0000119,-3.55271368e-15 L72.0000119,32 L40.0000119,32 L40.0000119,-3.55271368e-15 L72.0000119,-3.55271368e-15 Z M32,-3.55271368e-15 L32,32 L-1.13686838e-13,32 L-1.13686838e-13,-3.55271368e-15 L32,-3.55271368e-15 Z M97.469329,6.80826869 C96.0294397,6.80826869 94.7294393,7.02226876 93.5693278,7.44982444 C92.4089942,7.87782457 91.4137717,8.49471364 90.5841047,9.30049166 C89.7538823,10.1067141 89.1188821,11.07327 88.6785486,12.199937 C88.2378818,13.3269373 88.0177706,14.5896043 88.0177706,15.9876048 C88.0177706,17.4188274 88.2296596,18.7062722 88.6531042,19.8493837 C89.0763265,20.9929396 89.6861045,21.9591621 90.482438,22.748829 C91.2784383,23.5383848 92.2522163,24.1430516 93.4042167,24.5624962 C94.5558837,24.9819408 95.8516619,25.1917186 97.2914401,25.1917186 C98.3752182,25.1917186 99.4086629,25.072163 100.391219,24.8338296 C101.37333,24.5956073 102.237108,24.2706072 102.982664,23.8592738 L102.982664,23.8592738 L102.982664,20.4292727 C101.40733,21.4001619 99.6881074,21.8851621 97.8251069,21.8851621 C96.6054399,21.8851621 95.567884,21.6549398 94.7126615,21.194273 C93.8572168,20.7338284 93.2049944,20.0633837 92.7564387,19.1831613 C92.3073275,18.3032721 92.0831052,17.2380496 92.0831052,15.9876048 C92.0831052,14.7377155 92.3156608,13.6766041 92.7816609,12.8044927 C93.2474389,11.9327147 93.916328,11.2664922 94.7888838,10.8058254 C95.6609951,10.3453809 96.715551,10.1148252 97.9521069,10.1148252 C98.8496628,10.1148252 99.7052186,10.2342697 100.518108,10.4726031 C101.331219,10.7112699 102.084664,11.0609366 102.779442,11.5212701 L102.779442,11.5212701 L102.779442,8.01738016 C102.017219,7.62260227 101.191441,7.32260218 100.302219,7.11671323 C99.4129963,6.91126872 98.4685515,6.80826869 97.469329,6.80826869 Z M55.7552388,7.00000208 L49.0000146,7.00000208 L49.0000146,25.0000021 L56.1713501,25.0000021 C57.590906,25.0000021 58.8063508,24.7903407 59.8181289,24.3706739 C60.8297959,23.9513405 61.6087961,23.3553403 62.1555741,22.5832289 C62.7020187,21.8114509 62.9754632,20.8882284 62.9754632,19.8140059 C62.9754632,18.7232278 62.6941298,17.7960053 62.1312407,17.0321162 C61.5681294,16.2686715 60.7563514,15.7104491 59.6957955,15.3580046 C60.4625736,14.9891156 61.0420182,14.4894488 61.4335738,13.8601152 C61.8252406,13.2307817 62.0210185,12.4881148 62.0210185,11.6321146 C62.0210185,10.1385586 61.4742405,8.99311379 60.3812402,8.19578022 C59.2877954,7.39889109 57.745795,7.00000208 55.7552388,7.00000208 L55.7552388,7.00000208 Z M15.7552269,7.00000208 L9.00000268,7.00000208 L9.00000268,25.0000021 L16.1713381,25.0000021 C17.5908941,25.0000021 18.8062278,24.7903407 19.8182281,24.3706739 C20.8296729,23.9513405 21.6087842,23.3553403 22.1555621,22.5832289 C22.7021179,21.8114509 22.9755624,20.8882284 22.9755624,19.8140059 C22.9755624,18.7232278 22.6941179,17.7960053 22.1311177,17.0321162 C21.5682286,16.2686715 20.7563395,15.7104491 19.6957836,15.3580046 C20.4625616,14.9891156 21.0418952,14.4894488 21.4335619,13.8601152 C21.8252287,13.2307817 22.0210066,12.4881148 22.0210066,11.6321146 C22.0210066,10.1385586 21.4741175,8.99311379 20.3811172,8.19578022 C19.2877835,7.39889109 17.7457831,7.00000208 15.7552269,7.00000208 L15.7552269,7.00000208 Z M55.8775833,17.2209385 C58.1128062,17.2209385 59.2308065,18.0434943 59.2308065,19.6881614 C59.2308065,20.4602728 58.9369175,21.0518285 58.3496951,21.4629397 C57.7622505,21.8743843 56.9216947,22.0797177 55.8286944,22.0797177 L55.8286944,22.0797177 L52.6469157,22.0797177 L52.6469157,17.2209385 Z M15.8775714,17.2209385 C18.1129054,17.2209385 19.2307946,18.0434943 19.2307946,19.6881614 C19.2307946,20.4602728 18.9370167,21.0518285 18.3496832,21.4629397 C17.7622386,21.8743843 16.9216828,22.0797177 15.8286825,22.0797177 L15.8286825,22.0797177 L12.6469038,22.0797177 L12.6469038,17.2209385 Z M55.412572,9.92028073 C57.3541282,9.92028073 58.3252396,10.6338365 58.3252396,12.0600591 C58.3252396,12.7988371 58.0763506,13.373504 57.5786838,13.7846152 C57.0807948,14.1960598 56.3587946,14.4013932 55.412572,14.4013932 L55.412572,14.4013932 L52.6469046,14.4013932 L52.6469046,9.92028073 Z M15.4125601,9.92028073 C17.3541163,9.92028073 18.3252277,10.6338365 18.3252277,12.0600591 C18.3252277,12.7988371 18.0762276,13.373504 17.5786719,13.7846152 C17.0807829,14.1960598 16.3587826,14.4013932 15.4125601,14.4013932 L15.4125601,14.4013932 L12.6468927,14.4013932 L12.6468927,9.92028073 Z"></path></svg></a></div></div><section class="sc-15592ee1-0 jnhfld"><nav role="navigation" aria-label="Footer navigation"><ul class="sc-15592ee1-1 bPyPyZ"><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.com/" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Home</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/news" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">News</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/sport" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Sport</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/business" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Business</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/innovation" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Innovation</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/culture" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Culture</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/arts" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Arts</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/travel" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Travel</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/future-planet" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Earth</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/audio" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Audio</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/video" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Video</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="/live" data-testid="internal-link" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Live</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.com/weather" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">Weather</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://shop.bbc.com/" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">BBC Shop</a></div></li><li data-testid="contentlink-li"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.britbox.com/?utm_source=bbc.com&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_campaign=footer" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-15592ee1-2 AsTdr">BritBox</a></div></li></ul></nav></section><section class="sc-a2fb0875-0 bgmTpn"><div class="sc-a2fb0875-1 BUIjW"><button type="button" class="sc-a2fb0875-2 efJkHF">BBC in other languages<div class="sc-a2fb0875-3 bhyElZ"><svg viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="1em" height="1em" category="arrows" icon="arrow-down" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M26.7 12.6 16 23.2 5.3 12.6V8.8h21.4v3.8z"></path></svg></div></button></div></section><div data-testid="social-follow-us-container" class="sc-aef9fe2b-0 kBxTXZ"><h2 class="sc-aef9fe2b-1 jMWXMa">Follow BBC on:</h2><div data-testid="social-follow-us-icon-buttons" class="sc-aef9fe2b-2 ittZym"><button aria-label="Follow BBC on x" class="sc-aef9fe2b-5 gpZrTn"><svg width="14" height="14" viewBox="0 0 14 14" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" category="social" icon="x" data-testid="social-button-x" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M8.3319 5.92804L13.5437 0H12.3087L7.78327 5.14724L4.16883 0H0L5.46574 7.78354L0 14H1.2351L6.01406 8.56434L9.83117 14H14L8.3316 5.92804H8.3319ZM6.64026 7.85211L6.08647 7.07705L1.68013 0.909776H3.57717L7.13314 5.88696L7.68693 6.66202L12.3093 13.1316H10.4122L6.64026 7.85241V7.85211Z"></path></svg></button><button aria-label="Follow BBC on facebook" class="sc-aef9fe2b-5 gpZrTn"><svg width="9" height="16" viewBox="0 0 9 16" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" category="social" icon="facebook" data-testid="social-button-facebook" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M6.80799 2.65602H8.31199V0.112024C7.58379 0.0363015 6.85211 -0.00108342 6.11999 2.38913e-05C3.94399 2.38913e-05 2.456 1.32802 2.456 3.76002V5.85601H0V8.70401H2.456V16H5.39999V8.70401H7.84799L8.21599 5.85601H5.39999V4.04002C5.39999 3.20002 5.62399 2.65602 6.80799 2.65602Z"></path></svg></button><button aria-label="Follow BBC on instagram" class="sc-aef9fe2b-5 gpZrTn"><svg width="18" height="17" viewBox="0 0 18 17" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" category="social" icon="instagram" data-testid="social-button-instagram" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M12.7227 0.189697H5.28726C4.13732 0.190927 3.03482 0.648288 2.22168 1.46143C1.40854 2.27456 0.951181 3.37706 0.949951 4.52701V11.9624C0.951181 13.1124 1.40854 14.2149 2.22168 15.028C3.03482 15.8411 4.13732 16.2985 5.28726 16.2997H12.7227C13.8726 16.2985 14.9751 15.8411 15.7882 15.028C16.6014 14.2149 17.0587 13.1124 17.06 11.9624V4.52701C17.0587 3.37706 16.6014 2.27456 15.7882 1.46143C14.9751 0.648288 13.8726 0.190927 12.7227 0.189697ZM9.00496 11.9624C8.26967 11.9624 7.55089 11.7444 6.93952 11.3359C6.32815 10.9274 5.85164 10.3467 5.57026 9.66741C5.28887 8.98809 5.21525 8.24058 5.3587 7.51942C5.50215 6.79826 5.85622 6.13583 6.37615 5.6159C6.89608 5.09597 7.55851 4.74189 8.27968 4.59845C9.00084 4.455 9.74834 4.52862 10.4277 4.81C11.107 5.09139 11.6876 5.56789 12.0961 6.17927C12.5046 6.79064 12.7227 7.50942 12.7227 8.24471C12.7216 9.23039 12.3296 10.1754 11.6326 10.8724C10.9357 11.5694 9.99064 11.9614 9.00496 11.9624ZM13.6521 4.52701C13.4683 4.52701 13.2886 4.4725 13.1357 4.37038C12.9829 4.26825 12.8638 4.12309 12.7934 3.95326C12.7231 3.78343 12.7047 3.59656 12.7405 3.41626C12.7764 3.23597 12.8649 3.07037 12.9949 2.94038C13.1249 2.8104 13.2905 2.72188 13.4708 2.68602C13.6511 2.65016 13.8379 2.66856 14.0078 2.73891C14.1776 2.80926 14.3227 2.92838 14.4249 3.08123C14.527 3.23407 14.5815 3.41376 14.5815 3.59759C14.5815 3.84409 14.4836 4.08049 14.3093 4.25479C14.135 4.42909 13.8986 4.52701 13.6521 4.52701ZM11.4834 8.24471C11.4834 8.7349 11.3381 9.21409 11.0657 9.62167C10.7934 10.0293 10.4063 10.3469 9.95343 10.5345C9.50055 10.7221 9.00221 10.7712 8.52144 10.6756C8.04066 10.5799 7.59904 10.3439 7.25242 9.99725C6.9058 9.65063 6.66975 9.20901 6.57412 8.72823C6.47849 8.24746 6.52757 7.74912 6.71516 7.29624C6.90275 6.84336 7.22042 6.45628 7.628 6.18394C8.03558 5.9116 8.51477 5.76624 9.00496 5.76624C9.66229 5.76624 10.2927 6.02737 10.7575 6.49217C11.2223 6.95697 11.4834 7.58738 11.4834 8.24471Z" fill="black"></path></svg></button><button aria-label="Follow BBC on tiktok" class="sc-aef9fe2b-5 gpZrTn"><svg width="16" height="19" viewBox="0 0 16 19" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" category="social" icon="tiktok" data-testid="social-button-tiktok" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M12.6992 2.92929C12.0014 2.13265 11.6168 1.10958 11.6171 0.0505371H8.46271V12.7089C8.43838 13.3939 8.14918 14.0427 7.65601 14.5187C7.16284 14.9948 6.50419 15.2609 5.81875 15.261C4.36917 15.261 3.16458 14.0768 3.16458 12.6068C3.16458 10.851 4.85917 9.53408 6.60479 10.0751V6.84929C3.08292 6.3797 0 9.11554 0 12.6068C0 16.0062 2.8175 18.4255 5.80854 18.4255C9.01396 18.4255 11.6171 15.8224 11.6171 12.6068V6.18575C12.8962 7.10434 14.4319 7.5972 16.0067 7.5945V4.44012C16.0067 4.44012 14.0875 4.532 12.6992 2.92929Z" fill="black"></path></svg></button><button aria-label="Follow BBC on linkedin" class="sc-aef9fe2b-5 gpZrTn"><svg width="15" height="15" viewBox="0 0 15 15" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" category="social" icon="linkedin" data-testid="social-button-linkedin" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M3.14795 1.57476C3.14775 1.99221 2.98172 2.39247 2.68639 2.6875C2.39107 2.98253 1.99063 3.14816 1.57319 3.14795C1.15575 3.14775 0.755481 2.98172 0.460451 2.68639C0.16542 2.39107 -0.000208525 1.99064 1.97032e-07 1.57319C0.000208919 1.15575 0.166238 0.755481 0.461564 0.460451C0.756889 0.16542 1.15732 -0.000208525 1.57476 1.97032e-07C1.99221 0.000208919 2.39247 0.166238 2.6875 0.461564C2.98253 0.756889 3.14816 1.15732 3.14795 1.57476ZM3.19517 4.31348H0.0472195V14.1666H3.19517V4.31348ZM8.16894 4.31348H5.03673V14.1666H8.13746V8.99607C8.13746 6.11569 11.8914 5.84811 11.8914 8.99607V14.1666H15V7.92576C15 3.07004 9.44386 3.25105 8.13746 5.63563L8.16894 4.31348Z"></path></svg></button><button aria-label="Follow BBC on youtube" class="sc-aef9fe2b-5 gpZrTn"><svg width="19" height="15" viewBox="0 0 19 15" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" category="social" icon="youtube" data-testid="social-button-youtube" class="sc-9c8c5e05-0 kHfxfq"><path d="M9.48685 0.29126C9.98138 0.293864 11.2186 0.305151 12.5337 0.35464L13.0004 0.37374C14.3238 0.431911 15.6463 0.532624 16.3029 0.703663C17.178 0.934609 17.8652 1.60661 18.0976 2.4592C18.468 3.81362 18.5144 6.45474 18.5199 7.09462L18.5208 7.22659V7.37766C18.5144 8.01753 18.468 10.6595 18.0976 12.0131C17.8624 12.8683 17.1743 13.5411 16.3029 13.7686C15.6463 13.9397 14.3238 14.0404 13.0004 14.0985L12.5337 14.1185C11.2186 14.1671 9.98138 14.1793 9.48685 14.181L9.26921 14.1819H9.03306C7.98658 14.1758 3.60989 14.1315 2.21705 13.7686C1.34283 13.5377 0.654744 12.8657 0.422296 12.0131C0.051861 10.6587 0.00555653 8.01753 0 7.37766V7.09462C0.00555653 6.45474 0.051861 3.81275 0.422296 2.4592C0.657523 1.60401 1.34561 0.931136 2.21798 0.704532C3.60989 0.340748 7.98751 0.296469 9.03399 0.29126H9.48685ZM7.40778 4.19824V10.2758L12.9643 7.23701L7.40778 4.19824Z" fill="black"></path></svg></button></div></div><section class="sc-1bad1f0d-0 bQoEiG"><nav><ul class="sc-1bad1f0d-1 hWSyJW"><li class="sc-1bad1f0d-2 hpveT"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/usingthebbc/terms" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-1bad1f0d-3 dckmSN">Terms of Use</a></div></li><li class="sc-1bad1f0d-2 hpveT"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/aboutthebbc" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-1bad1f0d-3 dckmSN">About the BBC</a></div></li><li class="sc-1bad1f0d-2 hpveT"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.com/usingthebbc/privacy/" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-1bad1f0d-3 dckmSN">Privacy Policy</a></div></li><li class="sc-1bad1f0d-2 hpveT"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.com/usingthebbc/cookies/" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-1bad1f0d-3 dckmSN">Cookies</a></div></li><li class="sc-1bad1f0d-2 hpveT"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/accessibility/" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-1bad1f0d-3 dckmSN">Accessibility Help</a></div></li><li class="sc-1bad1f0d-2 hpveT"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-1bad1f0d-3 dckmSN">Contact the BBC</a></div></li><li class="sc-1bad1f0d-2 hpveT"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.com/advertisingcontact" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-1bad1f0d-3 dckmSN">Advertise with us</a></div></li><li class="sc-1bad1f0d-2 hpveT"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.com/usingthebbc/cookies/how-can-i-change-my-bbc-cookie-settings/" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-1bad1f0d-3 dckmSN">Do not share or sell my info</a></div></li><li class="sc-1bad1f0d-2 hpveT"><div data-testid="anchor-inner-wrapper"><a href="https://www.bbc.com/contact-bbc-com-help" data-testid="external-anchor" target="_self" class="sc-1bad1f0d-3 dckmSN">Contact technical support</a></div></li></ul></nav></section><div class="sc-2983642f-1 jesoZj"><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">Copyright 2025 BBC. All rights reserved.&nbsp;<i id="" class="sc-d16436d-0 fhKUCU">&nbsp;</i>The<i id="bbc" class="sc-d16436d-0 fhKUCU"> BBC </i>is<i id="not-responsible-for-the-content-of-external-sites." class="sc-d16436d-0 fhKUCU"> not responsible for the content of external sites.</i>&nbsp;<a target="_self" href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidance/feeds-and-links" class="sc-f9178328-0 bGFWdi"><b id="read-about-our-approach-to-external-linking." class="sc-d16436d-0 jpoiOL">Read about our approach to external linking.</b></a></p><p class="sc-9a00e533-0 hxuGS">&nbsp;</p></div></footer></div></div><script id="__NEXT_DATA__" type="application/json">{"props":{"pageProps":{"page":{"@\"news\",\"articles\",\"cwy603eg0w8o\",":{"id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:cwy603eg0w8o","contents":[{"type":"headline","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"text","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash","attributes":[]}}]}}]}}]}},{"type":"timestamp","model":{"timestamp":1746486521684}},{"type":"byline","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"contributor","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"name","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"text","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"Natalie Sherman","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Natalie Sherman","attributes":[]}}]}}]}}]}},{"type":"role","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"text","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"BBC News","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"BBC News","attributes":[]}}]}}]}}]}}]}},{"type":"timestamp","model":{"timestamp":1746486521684}}]}},{"type":"image","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"altText","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"text","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"Sam Altman, chief executive officer of OpenAI Inc., at Station F during the AI Action Summit in Paris, France, on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Sam Altman, chief executive officer of OpenAI Inc., at Station F during the AI Action Summit in Paris, France, on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025.","attributes":[]}}]}}]}}]}},{"type":"rawImage","model":{"width":819,"height":460,"locator":"2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg","originCode":"cpsprodpb","copyrightHolder":"Getty Images","suitableForSyndication":true}}],"emphasiseImage":true}},{"type":"text","model":{"suitableForAbridgement":true,"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"OpenAI, the parent of artificial intelligence service ChatGPT, has announced a new governance plan after a bitter power struggle over the business.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"OpenAI, the parent of artificial intelligence service ChatGPT, has announced a new governance plan after a bitter power struggle over the business.","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"Boss Sam Altman said OpenAI would remain under the control of its non-profit board, while becoming what is known in the US as a public benefit corporation.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Boss Sam Altman said OpenAI would remain under the control of its non-profit board, while becoming what is known in the US as a public benefit corporation.","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"Mr Altman had put forward a similar plan in December - but without clarifying the control of the non-profit. ","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Mr Altman had put forward ","attributes":[]}},{"type":"urlLink","model":{"text":"a similar plan in December","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"a similar plan in December","attributes":[]}}],"locator":"https://openai.com/index/why-our-structure-must-evolve-to-advance-our-mission/","isExternal":true}},{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":" - but without clarifying the control of the non-profit. ","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"The update follows widespread scrutiny of the startup, which began as a non-profit and faced criticism, including from co-founder Elon Musk, that its quest for growth is pushing it to stray from its original mission of creating technology for the benefit of humanity.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"The update follows widespread scrutiny of the startup, which began as a non-profit and faced criticism, including from co-founder Elon Musk, that its quest for growth is pushing it to stray from its original mission of creating technology for the benefit of humanity.","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"","attributes":[]}}]}}]}},{"type":"advertisement","model":{"adType":"horizontal"},"incrementedType":"mid_1"},{"type":"text","model":{"suitableForAbridgement":false,"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"Last month, a group of former open AI staff and outside experts, including Geoffrey Hinton, wrote to regulators in California and Delaware, which have power over non-profits, asking them to intervene to block the conversion.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Last month, a group of former open AI staff and outside experts, including Geoffrey Hinton, ","attributes":[]}},{"type":"urlLink","model":{"text":"wrote to regulators in California and Delaware","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"wrote to regulators in California and Delaware","attributes":[]}}],"locator":"https://notforprivategain.org/","isExternal":true}},{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":", which have power over non-profits, asking them to intervene to block the conversion.","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"OpenAI chairman Bret Taylor said the start-up made the decision \"after hearing from civic leaders and engaging in constructive dialogue with the offices of the Attorney General of Delaware and the Attorney General of California\".","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"OpenAI chairman Bret Taylor said the start-up made the decision \"after hearing from civic leaders and engaging in constructive dialogue with the offices of the Attorney General of Delaware and the Attorney General of California\".","attributes":[]}}]}}]}},{"type":"text","model":{"suitableForAbridgement":false,"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"In the update on Monday, Mr Altman said the non-profit would continue to control OpenAI, receiving a \"big\", yet-to-be determined stake in OpenAI's business arm, which would give it access to money to put towards its own goals.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"In the update on Monday, Mr Altman said the non-profit would continue to control OpenAI, receiving a \"big\", yet-to-be determined stake in OpenAI's business arm, which would give it access to money to put towards its own goals.","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"He said the new plan would still allow the organisation to stop operating under its current complex governance structure, which had capped its profits.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"He said the new plan would still allow the organisation to stop operating under its current complex governance structure, which had capped its profits.","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"That was seen as a sticking point for investors, including Microsoft, that hindered the firm's ability to raise money. ","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"That was seen as a sticking point for investors, including Microsoft, that hindered the firm's ability to raise money. ","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"\"We are moving to a normal capital structure where everyone has stock,\" he wrote in a letter to staff that was shared on the OpenAI website. \"This is not a sale, but a change of structure to something simpler.\"","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"\"We are moving to a normal capital structure where everyone has stock,\" he wrote in a letter to staff that was shared on the OpenAI website. \"This is not a sale, but a change of structure to something simpler.\"","attributes":[]}}]}}]}},{"type":"advertisement","model":{"adType":"horizontal"},"incrementedType":"mid_2"},{"type":"text","model":{"suitableForAbridgement":false,"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"Unlike traditional for-profit companies, which are bound to act in service to shareholders, a public benefit corporation is also responsible for a public mission. ","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Unlike traditional for-profit companies, which are bound to act in service to shareholders, a public benefit corporation is also responsible for a public mission. ","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"In the update on Monday, Mr Altman said he believed that growth and extending access to AI, which would take money, was consistent with the firm's mission, because it would help people \"build incredible things for each other and continue to drive society and quality of life forward\".","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"In the update on Monday, Mr Altman said he believed that growth and extending access to AI, which would take money, was consistent with the firm's mission, because it would help people \"build incredible things for each other and continue to drive society and quality of life forward\".","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"\"It will of course not be all used for good, but we trust humanity and think the good will outweigh the bad by orders of magnitude,\" he wrote.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"\"It will of course not be all used for good, but we trust humanity and think the good will outweigh the bad by orders of magnitude,\" he wrote.","attributes":[]}}]}}]}},{"type":"text","model":{"suitableForAbridgement":false,"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"It is not clear to what extent the new plan will satisfy investors or critics.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"It is not clear to what extent the new plan will satisfy investors or critics.","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"After the announcement Page Hedley, OpenAI's former policy and ethics adviser, who had spearheaded last month's letter, said the update did not resolve issues such as who would own the firm's technology and how its goals would be prioritised.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"After the announcement Page Hedley, OpenAI's former policy and ethics adviser, who had spearheaded last month's letter, said the update did not resolve issues such as who would own the firm's technology and how its goals would be prioritised.","attributes":[]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"\"We're glad that OpenAI is listening to concerns from civil society leaders ... but crucial questions remain,\" he said. ","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"\"We're glad that OpenAI is listening to concerns from civil society leaders ... but crucial questions remain,\" he said. ","attributes":[]}}]}}]}},{"type":"advertisement","model":{"adType":"horizontal"},"incrementedType":"mid_3"},{"type":"image","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"altText","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"text","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"A green promotional banner with black squares and rectangles forming pixels, moving in from the right. The text says: “Tech Decoded: The world’s biggest tech news in your inbox every Monday.”","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"A green promotional banner with black squares and rectangles forming pixels, moving in from the right. The text says: “Tech Decoded: The world’s biggest tech news in your inbox every Monday.”","attributes":[]}}]}}]}}]}},{"type":"rawImage","model":{"width":1600,"height":263,"locator":"8967/live/387a6450-2a54-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.png","originCode":"cpsprodpb","copyrightHolder":"BBC","suitableForSyndication":true}}]}},{"type":"text","model":{"suitableForAbridgement":false,"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"Sign up for our Tech Decoded newsletter to follow the world's top tech stories and trends. Outside the UK? Sign up here.","blocks":[{"type":"urlLink","model":{"text":"Sign up for our Tech Decoded newsletter","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Sign up for our Tech Decoded newsletter","attributes":[]}}],"locator":"https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsletters/zxh6cxs","isExternal":false}},{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":" to follow the world's top tech stories and trends. ","attributes":[]}},{"type":"urlLink","model":{"text":"Outside the UK? Sign up here.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Outside the UK? Sign up here.","attributes":[]}}],"locator":"https://cloud.email.bbc.com/techdecoded-newsletter-signup?\u0026at_bbc_team=studios\u0026at_medium=Onsite\u0026at_objective=acquisition\u0026at_ptr_type=\u0026at_ptr_name=bbc.com\u0026at_format=\u0026at_link_origin=\u0026at_campaign=techdecoded\u0026at_campaign_id=\u0026at_adset_name=\u0026at_adset_id=\u0026at_creation=\u0026at_creative_id=\u0026at_campaign_type=owned","isExternal":false}}]}}]}}],"topics":[{"title":"Elon Musk","url":"/news/topics/c302m85q53mt","isEvent":false},{"title":"International Business","url":"/news/topics/c4nrdv135zet","isEvent":false},{"title":"Artificial intelligence","url":"/news/topics/ce1qrvleleqt","isEvent":false},{"title":"Microsoft","url":"/news/topics/cvenzmgyg0lt","isEvent":false}],"onwardJourney":[{"type":"ohio","content":[{"title":"Elon Musk's Starbase in Texas will officially become a city","href":"/news/articles/c39j8rj4nmmo","isLiveNow":false,"metadata":{"contentType":"article","subtype":"news","lastUpdated":1746363129718,"firstUpdated":1746306818982,"topics":["US \u0026 Canada"]},"tags":[],"description":"Residents approved incorporating a patch of land as the new municipality in an election on Saturday.\n\n","image":{"type":"indexImage","model":{"blocks":{"src":"https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/44be/live/c88b5c80-284b-11f0-b26b-ab62c890638b.jpg","altText":"A sign that says \"Live in our tomorrow today: Starbase, Boca Chica, TX\" in front of a sand dune and a rocket launch facility in the distance. ","width":1024,"height":681}}},"relatedUrls":[],"id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:c39j8rj4nmmo","state":"published","brandName":"","seriesName":"","seriesId":"","brandId":"","versionId":""},{"title":"What might Reform do with its newly won power?","href":"/news/articles/cdjl4k8jyxeo","isLiveNow":false,"metadata":{"contentType":"article","subtype":"news","lastUpdated":1746281960609,"firstUpdated":1746268740290,"topics":["Politics"]},"tags":[],"description":"For the first time the party has won control of local councils, as well as two mayoralties.","image":{"type":"indexImage","model":{"blocks":{"src":"https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/23fe/live/3a907aa0-2805-11f0-a740-23c6f7407e23.jpg","altText":"Five people wearing Reform UK rosettes raise their arms in celebration","width":1016,"height":571}}},"relatedUrls":[],"id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:cdjl4k8jyxeo","state":"published","brandName":"","seriesName":"","seriesId":"","brandId":"","versionId":""},{"title":"Tesla denies contacting headhunters to replace Musk","href":"/news/articles/cr4n94klqg9o","isLiveNow":false,"metadata":{"contentType":"article","subtype":"news","lastUpdated":1746097839406,"firstUpdated":1746081531064,"topics":["Business"]},"tags":[],"description":"The electric car firm says a report that it is hunting for a successor is \"absolutely false\".","image":{"type":"indexImage","model":{"blocks":{"src":"https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/d1b5/live/25dcddc0-2656-11f0-948d-d3658dc46e25.jpg","altText":"A close up of Tesla chief executive Elon Musk from his left side","width":1024,"height":576}}},"relatedUrls":[],"id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:cr4n94klqg9o","state":"published","brandName":"","seriesName":"","seriesId":"","brandId":"","versionId":""}],"collectionId":"","sectionTitleProps":{},"paginationData":{"page":0,"pageSize":3,"total":3},"title":"Elon Musk","summary":"","disableAutoPlay":false,"innerCollections":[],"playlistMode":false},{"type":"alaska","content":[{"title":"Arizona man shot to death in road rage 'returns' to address his killer","href":"/news/articles/cq808px90wxo","isLiveNow":false,"metadata":{"contentType":"article","subtype":"news","lastUpdated":1746656868103,"firstUpdated":1746656868103,"topics":["US \u0026 Canada"]},"tags":[],"description":"With the help of artificial intelligence, a man was 'brought back to life' at his killer's sentencing to deliver a victim's statement himself. ","image":{"type":"indexImage","model":{"blocks":{"src":"https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/fc68/live/3ebe7160-2b7d-11f0-8f57-b7237f6a66e6.jpg","altText":"Man in green jacket with baseball hat","width":1920,"height":1080}}},"relatedUrls":[],"id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:cq808px90wxo","state":"published","brandName":"","seriesName":"","seriesId":"","brandId":"","versionId":""},{"title":"Maker of Pegasus spyware told to pay $167m for WhatsApp hack","href":"/news/articles/c77n76kzmz4o","isLiveNow":false,"metadata":{"contentType":"article","subtype":"news","lastUpdated":1746613595817,"firstUpdated":1746606600585,"topics":["Technology"]},"tags":[],"description":"Journalists and activists say the software is used by authoritarian regimes to spy on them.","image":{"type":"indexImage","model":{"blocks":{"src":"https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/a826/live/a9efc0b0-2b2d-11f0-a926-032a6ac0e498.jpg","altText":"The NSO logo on its HQ in Israel","width":819,"height":461}}},"relatedUrls":[],"id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:c77n76kzmz4o","state":"published","brandName":"","seriesName":"","seriesId":"","brandId":"","versionId":""},{"title":"US and China to start talks over trade war this week","href":"/news/articles/c8rgrejkvmjo","isLiveNow":false,"metadata":{"contentType":"article","subtype":"news","lastUpdated":1746589060599,"firstUpdated":1746573937063,"topics":["Business"]},"tags":[],"description":"Global trade experts have told the BBC they expect the negotiations to take several months.","image":{"type":"indexImage","model":{"blocks":{"src":"https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/6bab/live/27bebb90-2ad4-11f0-b335-f93d8286b78f.jpg","altText":"The SM Kwangyang container ship docked at the Port of Long Beach in Long Beach, California, US, on Sunday, 27 April, 2025.","width":897,"height":505}}},"relatedUrls":[],"id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:c8rgrejkvmjo","state":"published","brandName":"","seriesName":"","seriesId":"","brandId":"","versionId":""},{"title":"Can AI care for your loved ones?","href":"/news/articles/c62z5yl2l1lo","isLiveNow":false,"metadata":{"contentType":"article","subtype":"news","lastUpdated":1746507798902,"firstUpdated":1746507798902,"topics":["England"]},"tags":[],"description":"Apps to detect pain and robots training carers, how the care industry is changing in the UK.","image":{"type":"indexImage","model":{"blocks":{"src":"https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/efaf/live/23a82fb0-2051-11f0-812e-1d2d70e7f356.jpg","altText":"A carer using his smartphone app called Paincheck to monitor a resident's face to check for pain","width":1920,"height":1080}}},"relatedUrls":[],"id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:c62z5yl2l1lo","state":"published","brandName":"","seriesName":"","seriesId":"","brandId":"","versionId":""},{"title":"Car giant Ford and Barbie maker Mattel warn over tariffs costs","href":"/news/articles/cly1e7ll07do","isLiveNow":false,"metadata":{"contentType":"article","subtype":"news","lastUpdated":1746497062324,"firstUpdated":1746497062324,"topics":["Business"]},"tags":[],"description":"The firms join a growing list of big businesses cautioning about the impact of Trump's import taxes.","image":{"type":"indexImage","model":{"blocks":{"src":"https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/1009/live/accf83c0-2a4b-11f0-a469-7f005c3e0578.png","altText":"A Barbie doll wearing a pink dress with huge bows on the hips blowing kisses on a red carpet style background","width":773,"height":435}}},"relatedUrls":[],"id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:cly1e7ll07do","state":"published","brandName":"","seriesName":"","seriesId":"","brandId":"","versionId":""}],"collectionId":"","sectionTitleProps":{},"paginationData":{"page":0,"pageSize":5,"total":5},"title":"International Business, Artificial intelligence, Microsoft","summary":"","disableAutoPlay":false,"adBlock":{"type":"advertisement","model":{"adType":"horizontal"},"incrementedType":"mid_4"},"innerCollections":[],"playlistMode":false}],"relatedUrls":[],"collections":[],"section":[{"title":"Business","url":"/news/business"}],"pillar":[{"title":"Business","url":"/business"}],"collection":[],"destination":[]}},"country":"jp","isUkHeader":"no","featureFlags":{"audio-adverts":false,"audio-all-pages":true,"authentication":true,"bookmarking":true,"client-side-routing":false,"client-side-uk-redirect":true,"comments":false,"election-banner-us":true,"election-banner-us-client-refresh":false,"follow-brand-function":true,"legacy-api":false,"legacy-article-rendering-logic":true,"legacy-byline":false,"live-articles-in-same-tab":true,"nevada-ad":true,"optimizely-web":true,"piano-composer":true,"playlists":true,"radio-page-progress-bar":false,"seo-allow-indexing":true,"seo-archive":false,"subscription-poc":false,"subliminal":false,"taboola":false,"toucan-audio":false,"virginia-ad":true,"webvitals":true,"wntv-au":true,"wntv-au-preroll-ad":false,"wntv-us":true,"wntv-us-preroll-ad":false,"zephr":false},"authInfo":{"signInUrl":"https://session.bbc.com/session","signOutUrl":"https://session.bbc.com/session/signout?switchTld=true\u0026ptrt=https%3A%2F%2Faccount.bbc.com%2Fsignout","registerUrl":"https://session.bbc.com/session?action=register","statusUrl":"https://account.bbc.com/account","idSignedInCookieName":"ckns_id","accessTokenRefreshUrl":"https://session.bbc.com/session?ptrt=https%3A%2F%2Fsession.bbc.com%2Fsession%2Fannounce","accessTokenExpiredAt":0,"idAvailability":"GREEN","accountMaintenanceMode":"off"},"mainNavigation":[{"id":"7d8b56ed-7bec-40b3-9864-20fa2f1794ce","title":"Home","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"home","path":"/home","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"4bde03c5-ffdc-4487-bb69-b4e71700fb79","title":"News","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"news","path":"/news","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"f5f29eea-0a4c-44ee-90e3-1263ed1076bd","title":"Israel-Gaza War","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"israel-gaza-war","path":"/news/topics/c2vdnvdg6xxt","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"28ac4448-9f0b-4466-8069-0bdc71b584b1","title":"War in Ukraine","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"war-in-ukraine","path":"/news/war-in-ukraine","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"00ec8320-f402-48c7-9d4c-bc350bf2ca68","title":"US \u0026 Canada","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"us-canada","path":"/news/us-canada","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"7a9ffa46-c17d-4d26-901c-55044ace2a6f","title":"UK","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"uk","path":"/news/uk","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"0536da23-00b4-4ea4-bcc5-95a2503f0d3e","title":"UK Politics","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"uk-politics","path":"/news/politics","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"c7cc4a32-b8d2-46c9-883d-68de9847259a","title":"England","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"england","path":"/news/england","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"d1c45bb8-63e3-457f-beeb-d306bc799652","title":"N. Ireland","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"n-ireland","path":"/news/northern_ireland","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"1666528a-9b96-405c-8d81-e65e8ab69ce4","title":"N. Ireland Politics","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"n-ireland-politics","path":"/news/northern_ireland/northern_ireland_politics","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"41d2d732-45ed-4b4c-90fb-4e109801a1c8","title":"Scotland","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"scotland","path":"/news/scotland","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"235550ad-96aa-4ed1-b445-e68c4814ff8b","title":"Scotland Politics","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"scotland-politics","path":"/news/scotland/scotland_politics","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"210e74c9-01d9-4451-b2f8-fb35bd28e36c","title":"Wales","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"wales","path":"/news/wales","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"d267f59e-1f27-424c-bcb5-850346e5bbfb","title":"Wales Politics","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"wales-politics","path":"/news/wales/wales_politics","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]}]},{"id":"b755311e-20c9-4b11-88c6-d7cee29acec5","title":"Africa","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"africa","path":"/news/world/africa","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"cc73c422-1cba-44e1-a06e-9ac583ec38b5","title":"Asia","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"asia","path":"/news/world/asia","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"a45244ce-c7fa-4a87-b12d-4025148d6958","title":"China","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"china","path":"/news/world/asia/china","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"aaf03152-6ec0-4891-9a95-70627491941f","title":"India","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"india","path":"/news/world/asia/india","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"f3422fda-4a75-4a1a-99fe-55c144d964d4","title":"Australia","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"australia","path":"/news/world/australia","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"007e787c-d2e0-4109-b628-e1c7b72e2372","title":"Europe","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"europe","path":"/news/world/europe","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"23cd81ca-47a5-4de4-a49e-a6c1dae60614","title":"Latin America","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"latin-america","path":"/news/world/latin_america","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"3fd9afd8-f7d3-4e65-8ac7-bcaff8aadcbc","title":"Middle East","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"middle-east","path":"/news/world/middle_east","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"abe3c48e-18c0-4403-89b6-4b396ea87ad6","title":"In Pictures","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"in-pictures","path":"/news/in_pictures","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"12c78344-b29d-41e3-8b18-bbf35cdbea54","title":"BBC InDepth","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"bbc-indepth","path":"/news/bbcindepth","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"72b7c335-9462-4106-915b-e16174b502e1","title":"BBC Verify","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"bbc-verify","path":"/news/bbcverify","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"a12b1f37-8ea5-44cb-aaba-bae95e31b856","title":"Sport","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"sport","path":"/sport","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"58ae309c-8091-457d-8711-50bfe39af632","title":"Business","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"business","path":"/business","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"f75f8363-7ce0-444e-8665-387fcbd8699c","title":"Executive Lounge","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"executive-lounge","path":"/business/executive-lounge","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"fbfe26ad-5b8b-466c-8d6f-6a667a24c4b3","title":"Technology of Business","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"technology-of-business","path":"/business/technology-of-business","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"5f7efa7e-7a66-4417-a8f4-a556e0e315a5","title":"Future of Business","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"future-of-business","path":"/business/future-of-business","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"61653fa0-2cdf-4616-b48b-068cd350b30a","title":"Innovation","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"innovation","path":"/innovation","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"64d869be-d71d-4927-8515-b91a93e5a52b","title":"Technology","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"technology","path":"/innovation/technology","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"37a6205c-b6e0-4574-9411-5fd513d4df79","title":"Science \u0026 Health","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"science-health","path":"/innovation/science","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"4da21a4f-3456-456a-92f6-410e1acf3c9c","title":"Artificial Intelligence","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"artificial-intelligence","path":"/innovation/artificial-intelligence","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"a2577375-5684-46f3-8657-8f29aaf7879e","title":"AI v the Mind","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"ai-v-the-mind","path":"/innovation/ai-v-the-mind","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"3e17c3ef-bac6-45b4-ad0b-c02ae8033596","title":"Culture","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"culture","path":"/culture","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"31e81f6d-a35f-43ae-9903-2cd2fedaa9f4","title":"Film \u0026 TV","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"film-tv","path":"/culture/film-tv","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"dfde5810-d0f9-422c-bb8c-3ebdd1520d00","title":"Music","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"music","path":"/culture/music","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"e3fa6391-b7a4-4e76-9dac-f38fe58f5be6","title":"Art \u0026 Design","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"art-design","path":"/culture/art","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"2f5f313a-3a79-4eb8-a12f-59172c009412","title":"Style","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"style","path":"/culture/style","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"982102ac-6419-4b9f-b382-49b18c1e9ca9","title":"Books","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"books","path":"/culture/books","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"2eb4d9ca-1098-45e1-829f-0f45a99cacdc","title":"Entertainment News","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"entertainment-news","path":"/culture/entertainment-news","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"d3a54601-db20-4f6f-b531-d701374e2046","title":"Arts","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"arts","path":"/arts","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"2d881346-28bc-43da-8e79-7dde8b556d1e","title":"Arts in Motion","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"arts-in-motion","path":"/arts/arts-in-motion","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"26bc879d-bf51-477a-83d6-062fbb78ec26","title":"Travel","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"travel","path":"/travel","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"8fc08cb9-0296-4504-9a84-7ca1b139087f","title":"Destinations","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"destinations","path":"/travel/destinations","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"f1c9e919-2dd7-4c8f-baf6-1a3a56cd282e","title":"Africa","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"africa","path":"/travel/destinations/africa","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"39f568b9-f920-40c4-8767-20f5aa83fb1d","title":"Antarctica","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"antarctica","path":"/travel/destinations/antarctica","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"16c9d02d-e13e-4c49-a0ea-a04de1658939","title":"Asia","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"asia","path":"/travel/destinations/asia","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"0cf06dbd-d6a5-4e65-b66e-45b6659af927","title":"Australia and Pacific","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"australia-and-pacific","path":"/travel/destinations/australia-and-pacific","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"e7b01059-7859-40fb-9643-0042ad212016","title":"Caribbean \u0026 Bermuda","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"caribbean-bermuda","path":"/travel/destinations/caribbean","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"6d7c93b7-f2c1-44a5-aa24-aa281d89b6b2","title":"Central America","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"central-america","path":"/travel/destinations/central-america","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"cf54e94e-c5ef-40b1-88de-471b3c465eba","title":"Europe","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"europe","path":"/travel/destinations/europe","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"a9a87e39-1a41-494c-94da-f7b6789b0c31","title":"Middle East","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"middle-east","path":"/travel/destinations/middle-east","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"f0e3ca70-7b20-47c0-9be3-e3177365ae03","title":"North America","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"north-america","path":"/travel/destinations/north-america","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"a648ba11-c9de-47d0-b834-f5324fe1e73c","title":"South America","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"south-america","path":"/travel/destinations/south-america","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"7ae7f674-60ff-4496-8918-230fcddbf23c","title":"World’s Table","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"world’s-table","path":"/travel/worlds-table","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"ea6067ee-adec-4e26-8e96-bc9211725fb6","title":"Culture \u0026 Experiences","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"culture-experiences","path":"/travel/cultural-experiences","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"3e703b5b-ba22-4336-ae33-a828005fca2a","title":"Adventures","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"adventures","path":"/travel/adventures","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"90c13b94-81ab-45df-864a-c33262fac9ef","title":"The SpeciaList","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"the-specialist","path":"/travel/specialist","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"29857b55-2209-46f3-ab79-0ef879c8e157","title":"Earth","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"earth","path":"/future-planet","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"7d49a603-ecb9-41e9-b25e-949e700464b5","title":"Natural Wonders","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"natural-wonders","path":"/future-planet/natural-wonders","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"1f60d671-436d-4a24-8a36-e14c1fdd1e54","title":"Weather \u0026 Science","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"weather-science","path":"/future-planet/weather-science","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"cab8ac9b-c068-4210-8028-8bb8c8d0db05","title":"Climate Solutions","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"climate-solutions","path":"/future-planet/solutions","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"11b19770-e683-4496-ba72-9ff0ad5694d5","title":"Sustainable Business","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"sustainable-business","path":"/future-planet/sustainable-business","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"5a3db17b-5948-45ed-a6de-52573b0806cd","title":"Green Living","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"green-living","path":"/future-planet/green-living","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"39976fa2-573f-4941-8f1c-dbe3c68d010d","title":"Audio","isSpecial":true,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"audio","path":"/audio","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"d043e87e-b6ed-408a-9ef4-1d7e0e41fd9c","title":"Podcasts","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"podcasts","path":"/audio/categories","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"0d79ad0d-8ed4-4267-9494-a675edc59e8d","title":"Radio","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"radio","path":"/audio/stations","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"9c4ff533-5bea-4493-84a1-404dc8a7050a","title":"Audio FAQs","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20250207-bbc-podcasts-are-now-available-on-the-bbc-website-and-app","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"9fd9b956-9ca0-4158-bea4-b3608a46bb1b","title":"Video","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"video","path":"/video","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"e4f0733a-b3cf-4df8-9264-f85c2ad0ef6b","title":"Live","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"live","path":"/live","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"9839dd61-36d9-426e-8b64-bb98009e0233","title":"Live News","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"live-news","path":"/live/news","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"f2646029-fbf5-41be-9be4-80f40295ca92","title":"Live Sport","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"live-sport","path":"/live/sport","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]}],"hamburgerNavigation":[{"id":"2bc2cfea-b01f-46dc-9f62-df19d90819f1","title":"Home","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"home","path":"/home","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"5c92a541-2489-4ed1-bba2-799fbc070b24","title":"News","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"news","path":"/news","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"da01857f-dbd7-4b2a-8015-0d1c82209c72","title":"News","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"news","path":"/news","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"b5f7e252-f883-43a1-b3a3-94fda20258bf","title":"Israel-Gaza War","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"c2vdnvdg6xxt","path":"/news/topics/c2vdnvdg6xxt","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"2154b220-cb87-465b-a308-5be14671acde","title":"War in Ukraine","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"war-in-ukraine","path":"/news/war-in-ukraine","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"71c01111-503d-4e1e-acd0-0439c3e733b8","title":"US \u0026 Canada","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"us-canada","path":"/news/us-canada","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"f58e5be1-b58c-415a-b0c3-5ab6591698f5","title":"UK","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"uk","path":"/news/uk","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"aafa4008-db60-40b0-87be-47f689ebd8b1","title":"UK","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"uk","path":"/news/uk","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"c96a2af0-7904-4fba-9a7c-29c9ef590074","title":"England","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"england","path":"/news/england","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"231612a6-ddcd-43c8-b050-678928dab18e","title":"N. Ireland","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"northern_ireland","path":"/news/northern_ireland","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"0a7f67d5-f319-45a3-8211-4b37ccbab770","title":"Scotland","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"scotland","path":"/news/scotland","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"b284efa7-c62b-4bf9-ba64-907c7b56c623","title":"Wales","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"wales","path":"/news/wales","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"6db1d3ee-6997-4d7c-8b70-c3ac6a372148","title":"UK Nations and Regions","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/news/regions","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"6d5452a4-2f7c-4151-b978-ab14b3ceffc5","title":"Africa","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"africa","path":"/news/world/africa","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"904e75aa-5e89-4650-966e-a3677dd823c0","title":"Asia","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"asia","path":"/news/world/asia","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"a5d5d6e4-9f2d-4c14-be37-dd4df7a560d9","title":"Australia","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"australia","path":"/news/world/australia","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"d9634659-3a56-435d-8385-6dce224d55d9","title":"Europe","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"europe","path":"/news/world/europe","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"857cf28a-e43b-4206-a968-b45a7b978f2a","title":"Latin America","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"latin_america","path":"/news/world/latin_america","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"ab0c5345-6057-4d53-8e1e-6f61af73c76c","title":"Middle East","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"middle_east","path":"/news/world/middle_east","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"c9cd74e8-e058-4ed9-ae76-598ce16edd7e","title":"In Pictures","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"in_pictures","path":"/news/in_pictures","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"219f3229-89eb-4acd-b2af-113373e138d8","title":"BBC InDepth","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"bbcindepth","path":"/news/bbcindepth","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"4cf27af6-8a9c-41a8-8c11-24956a7f4d19","title":"BBC Verify","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"bbcverify","path":"/news/bbcverify","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"b1d0e2ed-d2ff-425a-8e32-a6f0060db384","title":"Sport","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"sport","path":"/sport","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"4ce466e3-1eb7-47a3-84f8-0420cd087cc4","title":"Business","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"business","path":"/business","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"0c84a4a0-81ab-4e84-a188-6a649eb1ba7d","title":"Business","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"business","path":"/business","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"72846bf8-150c-490e-9d1d-a4efed10fd14","title":"Executive Lounge","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"executive-lounge","path":"/business/executive-lounge","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"9903ae7e-b90a-4056-8b9c-0dcd13e07eba","title":"Technology of Business","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"technology-of-business","path":"/business/technology-of-business","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"ae086518-8aac-4165-a082-79833cff32bf","title":"Future of Business","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"future-of-business","path":"/business/future-of-business","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"5677ffab-fea6-438f-942a-c36c58c97afe","title":"Innovation","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"innovation","path":"/innovation","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"d480a872-8917-4b11-a2e9-bbcbf9f2ed21","title":"Innovation","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"innovation","path":"/innovation","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"0e43bfe2-db51-40a9-b423-378e11d736d5","title":"Technology","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"technology","path":"/innovation/technology","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"d120e5c1-b098-469e-91c4-933ff6b8de2b","title":"Science \u0026 Health","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"science","path":"/innovation/science","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"e034605f-ce02-4d01-882f-806322431a1a","title":"AI v the Mind","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"ai-v-the-mind","path":"/innovation/ai-v-the-mind","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"4469c10b-7134-4868-9f43-298dd31b3be8","title":"Artificial Intelligence","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"artificial-intelligence","path":"/innovation/artificial-intelligence","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"bf3d8700-3b91-47f9-b8e9-705e5696eb20","title":"Culture","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"culture","path":"/culture","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"a44625bd-2b19-47fb-b7c8-c96f7dac0c83","title":"Culture","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"culture","path":"/culture","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"8b2d7b26-cad7-4364-bde5-c592014a3921","title":"Film \u0026 TV","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"film-tv","path":"/culture/film-tv","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"8a02ac14-ef3a-4087-99f6-01b6ec8fc24d","title":"Music","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"music","path":"/culture/music","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"50efd867-8028-4b50-9f5e-eac200f82957","title":"Art \u0026 Design","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"art","path":"/culture/art","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"5a51157b-91ab-46d0-96ba-5359e0666e60","title":"Style","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"style","path":"/culture/style","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"df5e3f2e-5951-459e-a25b-990121c4e049","title":"Books","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"books","path":"/culture/books","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"cf663bc2-7214-43a3-8903-657a7160dfd8","title":"Entertainment News","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"entertainment-news","path":"/culture/entertainment-news","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"656ad4bb-2046-4063-b6b5-80b1ec5f7d4a","title":"Arts","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"arts","path":"/arts","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"43f6b1d0-fa42-4007-9a05-9d3535922aa6","title":"Arts","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"arts","path":"/arts","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"3e68d794-07f9-432a-8c9e-30b9ea323dd8","title":"Arts in Motion","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"arts-in-motion","path":"/arts/arts-in-motion","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"e8558082-ff2d-4b2e-b4a3-85175d445550","title":"Travel","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"travel","path":"/travel","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"30aa2815-914d-48dc-a4ac-66608c85ca82","title":"Travel","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"travel","path":"/travel","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"8c72fd0d-4d89-4f0a-adf1-cd414bb0b91b","title":"Destinations","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"destinations","path":"/travel/destinations","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"49589a29-759c-4ffd-903b-8dde88a170c6","title":"World’s Table","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"worlds-table","path":"/travel/worlds-table","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"daf013e1-ab8c-4092-93b7-89e2148a4824","title":"Culture \u0026 Experiences","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"cultural-experiences","path":"/travel/cultural-experiences","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"b6160ef2-d202-4cb4-9233-ffcb6280e6cc","title":"Adventures","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"adventures","path":"/travel/adventures","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"0ffd7538-b2b6-4633-909b-b57c9c4bf4a3","title":"The SpeciaList","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"specialist","path":"/travel/specialist","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"25a074f8-8ffc-4757-9cab-12ae2f65ef2a","title":"Earth","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"future-planet","path":"/future-planet","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"23ddcb55-5031-4600-825c-5b9ff3a01335","title":"Earth","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"future-planet","path":"/future-planet","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"37767345-49bd-49a9-9665-f0cb1d232655","title":"Natural Wonders","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"natural-wonders","path":"/future-planet/natural-wonders","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"24f709ce-1e79-4578-a994-ef6443910a39","title":"Weather \u0026 Science","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"weather-science","path":"/future-planet/weather-science","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"2375c268-1362-464a-914b-8ef7cc6e05a0","title":"Climate Solutions","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"solutions","path":"/future-planet/solutions","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"ecb4bf54-3e6a-4427-bea2-e6d66d5057e7","title":"Sustainable Business","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"sustainable-business","path":"/future-planet/sustainable-business","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"48737522-b167-4c5a-bda6-829ff34ed569","title":"Green Living","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"green-living","path":"/future-planet/green-living","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"6ae251de-a4dd-4d37-b684-730a400b4bbf","title":"Audio","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"audio","path":"/audio","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"1c4d5d80-6d36-4c98-b33d-0dd2e0bdfd3d","title":"Audio","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"audio","path":"/audio","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"b6fa1a0b-ac37-4e82-a242-b29377fdada6","title":"Podcasts","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"categories","path":"/audio/categories","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"05b7aaf0-9fed-4480-941d-3992f5e9fcf9","title":"Radio","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"stations","path":"/audio/stations","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"48545410-0f8c-4619-899c-0f52277cd045","title":"Audio FAQs","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20250207-bbc-podcasts-are-now-available-on-the-bbc-website-and-app","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"2b3f98f5-6f6f-498d-9819-132dee52d85f","title":"Video","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"video","path":"/video","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"3ad5d39b-89cb-49b2-af83-eea99b031a6e","title":"Live","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"live","path":"/live","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[{"id":"479ed4e4-d301-4abb-acc6-6ab2643ceb26","title":"Live","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"live","path":"/live","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"e3e4f32c-a6bc-4659-a4ee-e0d3dd3fe8f4","title":"Live News","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"news","path":"/live/news","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"fecb67bf-be13-4151-86a5-8731685fc52c","title":"Live Sport","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"sport","path":"/live/sport","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}]},{"id":"1de43732-7857-4662-aafe-ebcff4c04fee","title":"Weather","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/weather","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]},{"id":"2b2287cc-5f22-4cfc-805c-9069c1d26a53","title":"Newsletters","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/newsletters","externalTarget":"_self","subMenus":[]}],"footer":{"contentLinks":[{"id":"da859863-f5aa-477e-ba44-1f77ba7f42e3","title":"Home","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"fab08430-8c55-4616-b48e-69ff6709d932","title":"News","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"news","path":"/news","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"02cd7627-43ec-4b87-be15-ca5d3334765a","title":"Sport","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"sport","path":"/sport","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"8a9a006d-3218-454e-841a-4e503f94077f","title":"Business","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"business","path":"/business","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"b2531c9c-43d8-4caf-ac47-e1baac1fb51d","title":"Innovation","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"innovation","path":"/innovation","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"d16fc5fc-f43b-466c-8055-6664c426e14a","title":"Culture","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"culture","path":"/culture","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"bbf9e784-5abf-4f99-9cdc-e9cc48a96360","title":"Arts","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"arts","path":"/arts","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"1405af95-f60b-4da7-a605-0f3c94015741","title":"Travel","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"travel","path":"/travel","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"2a7d7933-5ee5-4e74-95b4-2059a72ede4d","title":"Earth","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"future-planet","path":"/future-planet","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"caca1997-0b81-47e2-967a-61740c6ed7a6","title":"Audio","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"audio","path":"/audio","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"b4fd1226-9cee-4a74-be52-906343413c89","title":"Video","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"video","path":"/video","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"9ccffc9e-b0e6-49c1-b31c-e098598afad9","title":"Live","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"slug":"live","path":"/live","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"e313f9e0-6a71-4c3f-96e5-faefb19377a5","title":"Weather","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/weather","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"54301c30-5a8a-47c0-ad50-0e93e1b959a5","title":"BBC Shop","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://shop.bbc.com/","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"19a89ecf-9c41-4a01-a347-164bcd1eb756","title":"BritBox","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.britbox.com/?utm_source=bbc.com\u0026utm_medium=referral\u0026utm_campaign=footer","externalTarget":"_self"}],"languages":[{"id":"2d8d529d-dee2-431e-811f-319d6a0e1733","title":"Oduu Afaan Oromootiin","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/afaanoromoo","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"df8df19e-bd79-4e86-829e-f4964ebdc1e2","title":"Amharic ዜና በአማርኛ","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/amharic","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"2838d1a9-2a63-42c2-adf8-f55e8159b5b0","title":"Arabic عربي","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/arabic","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"8a9fc11a-60de-47ad-b001-c3ca7a019aa2","title":"Azeri AZƏRBAYCAN","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/azeri","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"6df7d6bc-823a-402a-8d62-dc4206ae64ae","title":"Bangla বাংলা","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/bengali","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"1909db67-29c1-4103-b7a4-9468270bd9a7","title":"Burmese မြန်မာ","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/burmese","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"abfbd4fa-8956-4e4f-a2fd-b9db1f6d048a","title":"Chinese 中文网","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/zhongwen/simp","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"d42b2645-ceb2-479b-8c64-1891dccde0dc","title":"French AFRIQUE","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/afrique","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"76984938-d7ea-4508-8193-d846125b1770","title":"Hausa HAUSA","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/hausa","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"cf0d49ad-a058-4b9b-bfb7-e047d0878b1f","title":"Hindi हिन्दी","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/hindi","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"4f06a820-5576-4067-9d1a-d936ca1b54c4","title":"Gaelic NAIDHEACHDAN","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/naidheachdan","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"f2eecb84-fc7a-4f51-a48d-bf25363cfa5a","title":"Gujarati ગુજરાતીમાં સમાચાર","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/gujarati","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"2b71dc62-5f6e-40d9-a3af-1ae06dc6f504","title":"Igbo AKỤKỌ N’IGBO","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/igbo","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"c8e62c16-5082-4dab-9513-998010d51735","title":"Indonesian INDONESIA","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/indonesia","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"364f50d8-4ced-48e7-9106-443eaee49d11","title":"Japanese 日本語","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/japanese","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"3d38cde3-a2a0-4aa1-9037-778237c1b80c","title":"Kinyarwanda GAHUZA","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/gahuza","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"60b64b54-02e2-4c09-abdc-42ab5712fe43","title":"Kirundi KIRUNDI","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/gahuza","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"a04bc4c7-91e0-497d-9e58-5268a9db1572","title":"Korean 한국어","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/korean","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"2b250868-da96-4508-a6b8-235313679498","title":"Kyrgyz Кыргыз","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/kyrgyz","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"9faffc16-3f02-4c59-973e-47ec505848f2","title":"Marathi मराठी","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/marathi","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"3b517d9f-5027-4465-b0c0-f6c8f5a2f3b1","title":"Nepali नेपाली","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/nepali","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"197797d7-5fee-4a7c-a13b-b2727bf9566d","title":"Noticias para hispanoparlantes","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/mundo","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"958352fc-b9ba-44b7-bb22-b62bac8dba52","title":"Pashto پښتو","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/pashto","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"7b789a20-59a7-4a8f-9e29-223ec99b921e","title":"Persian فارسی","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/persian","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"78793a46-d7bc-41fe-8c12-46a2f9522fe0","title":"Pidgin","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/pidgin","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"24ec2095-49ae-43b6-a101-d01d55598516","title":"Portuguese BRASIL","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/portuguese","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"f0b95670-c78f-43b4-902b-7c880868c91a","title":"Punjabi ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਖ਼ਬਰਾਂ","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/punjabi","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"e022057d-358a-4b83-b5f9-ec755772a1e8","title":"Russian НА РУССКОМ","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/russian","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"b85b26a7-65c1-40b5-ae36-fb9f446197f5","title":"Serbian NA SRPSKOM","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/serbian/lat","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"6dc91e0b-cd4b-4a87-a807-43f13c40b917","title":"Sinhala සිංහල","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/sinhala","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"94afe723-c561-4ab1-8bd0-11759cef20fe","title":"Somali SOMALI","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/somali","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"9ca7efbc-73d6-4e4a-a102-b0f0b1437e82","title":"Swahili HABARI KWA KISWAHILI","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/swahili","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"1f4ae51f-baaf-4fed-ac78-77cf4638af84","title":"Tamil தமிழில் செய்திகள்","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/tamil","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"08d5247c-0c1e-4df4-9f4f-d66ee4e3097f","title":"Telugu తెలుగు వార్తలు","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/telugu","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"ae726de0-c2e0-4fcb-a883-bf91b7b64de8","title":"Thai ข่าวภาษาไทย","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/thai","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"630f3a69-a63d-401e-b1b6-0238ebcc9152","title":"Tigrinya ዜና ብትግርኛ","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/tigrinya","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"c413829e-e385-4c71-b3da-c25c9bea31bd","title":"Turkish TÜRKÇE","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/turkce","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"e204025c-1a70-4169-a490-347c89628274","title":"Ukrainian УКРАЇНСЬКA","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/ukrainian","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"809dd806-b765-41ce-a5c7-1a3203f315eb","title":"Urdu اردو","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/urdu","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"72da24b3-f724-4217-bf3d-65a6879a9da6","title":"Uzbek O'ZBEK","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/uzbek","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"def6f06c-75bf-4b60-88b2-f8fd28c3c769","title":"Vietnamese TIẾNG VIỆT","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/vietnamese","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"0ea107b9-c126-4694-bbea-d8e2f45154c2","title":"Welsh NEWYDDION","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/cymrufyw","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"526eb4a4-dbea-4be0-9a54-e11b28e09a93","title":"Yoruba ÌRÒYÌN NÍ YORÙBÁ","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/yoruba","externalTarget":"_self"}],"legalLinks":[{"id":"499f7676-b085-46d7-a9bb-de25a7104840","title":"Terms of Use","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.co.uk/usingthebbc/terms","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"03d9e9a2-37f2-4e7c-a62a-e215d8073e92","title":"About the BBC","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.co.uk/aboutthebbc","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"652e2021-be82-4df0-9ad9-1bbc2fc2fff8","title":"Privacy Policy","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/usingthebbc/privacy/","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"aa9de190-a49f-4195-bb38-111265967e0a","title":"Cookies","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/usingthebbc/cookies/","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"c4813865-b0e3-437d-b259-bfe9eabd36f8","title":"Accessibility Help","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.co.uk/accessibility/","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"f20c8a8c-4e2c-4357-a098-5aa462d705f9","title":"Contact the BBC","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"ac81e73f-87e2-43a4-ab8c-8fd0f66ae80e","title":"Advertise with us","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/advertisingcontact","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"18532300-7e46-40ed-89f2-9f27367b8e18","title":"Do not share or sell my info","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":true,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/usingthebbc/cookies/how-can-i-change-my-bbc-cookie-settings/","externalTarget":"_self"},{"id":"27890069-9e20-46a9-b5f1-e09d7a484088","title":"Contact technical support","isSpecial":false,"inOverlay":false,"externalUrl":"https://www.bbc.com/contact-bbc-com-help","externalTarget":"_self"}],"languageButtonText":"BBC in other languages","languageHeadline":"The BBC is in multiple languages","languageSubHeadline":"Read the BBC In your own language","legalTextContent":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"Copyright current_year BBC. All rights reserved.  The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Copyright current_year BBC. All rights reserved. ","attributes":[]}},{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":" ","attributes":["italic"]}},{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"The","attributes":[]}},{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":" BBC ","attributes":["italic"]}},{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"is","attributes":[]}},{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":" not responsible for the content of external sites.","attributes":["italic"]}},{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":" ","attributes":[]}},{"type":"urlLink","model":{"text":"Read about our approach to external linking.","locator":"https://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidance/feeds-and-links","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Read about our approach to external linking.","attributes":["bold"]}}]}}]}},{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":" ","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":" ","attributes":[]}}]}}],"legalText":"[{\"type\":\"paragraph\",\"model\":{\"text\":\"Copyright current_year BBC. All rights reserved.  The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.\",\"blocks\":[{\"type\":\"fragment\",\"model\":{\"text\":\"Copyright current_year BBC. All rights reserved. \",\"attributes\":[]}},{\"type\":\"fragment\",\"model\":{\"text\":\" \",\"attributes\":[\"italic\"]}},{\"type\":\"fragment\",\"model\":{\"text\":\"The\",\"attributes\":[]}},{\"type\":\"fragment\",\"model\":{\"text\":\" BBC \",\"attributes\":[\"italic\"]}},{\"type\":\"fragment\",\"model\":{\"text\":\"is\",\"attributes\":[]}},{\"type\":\"fragment\",\"model\":{\"text\":\" not responsible for the content of external sites.\",\"attributes\":[\"italic\"]}},{\"type\":\"fragment\",\"model\":{\"text\":\" \",\"attributes\":[]}},{\"type\":\"urlLink\",\"model\":{\"text\":\"Read about our approach to external linking.\",\"locator\":\"https://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidance/feeds-and-links\",\"blocks\":[{\"type\":\"fragment\",\"model\":{\"text\":\"Read about our approach to external linking.\",\"attributes\":[\"bold\"]}}]}}]}},{\"type\":\"paragraph\",\"model\":{\"text\":\" \",\"blocks\":[{\"type\":\"fragment\",\"model\":{\"text\":\" \",\"attributes\":[]}}]}}]"},"worldNewsTvPath":null,"worldNewsTvScheduleId":null,"worldNewsFullScheduleUrl":null,"flagPoles":{"ops":{"Metadata":{"FlagpoleBucketPrefix":"","FlagpoleDate":"31 Jul 24 08:19 UTC","FlagpoleFileID":"gn-flagpoles/gnlops","FlagpoleIdentity":"gnlops","FlagpoleSystem":"gn-flagpoles","Guid":"8dfe60a2-4322-411c-8a71-04dc7084fec4","urn":"urn:pubpipe:gnflagpoles:gnlops:gn-flagpoles/gnlops"},"Urn":"urn:pubpipe:gnflagpoles:gnlops:gn-flagpoles/gnlops","adverts":"true","analytics":"true","wwhp_feeds":"true","wwhp_obituary":"false","xproxy":"false","zephr":"false","zephrx":"true"},"ngas":{"Metadata":{"FlagpoleBucketPrefix":"","FlagpoleDate":"03 Feb 25 09:02 UTC","FlagpoleFileID":"gn-flagpoles/ngas","FlagpoleIdentity":"ngas","FlagpoleSystem":"gn-flagpoles","Guid":"e229d810-0dcd-45f0-a61b-ff6a4178aff7","urn":"urn:pubpipe:gnflagpoles:ngas:gn-flagpoles/ngas"},"Urn":"urn:pubpipe:gnflagpoles:ngas:gn-flagpoles/ngas","aps":"true","banner":"true","beta":"true","brandmetrics":"false","cmp":"true","comscoremmx":"true","comscoremmxeea":"true","content_rec":"true","covatic":"true","covatic_admeta":"true","doubleverify":"true","fedid":"true","fedid_all":"true","fedid_google":"true","fedid_permutive":"true","fedid_piano":"true","fedid_signed":"true","fpd":"true","gpp":"true","grapeshot":"false","ias_publisher":"false","load_gpt":"true","name":"ngas","native_size":"true","newadunit":"true","newkeys":"true","nielsen":"true","ozone":"true","permutive":"true","permutive_cohort":"true","piano":"false","speedcurve":"true","spo":"true","survey":"true","surveyx":"true","tmt_media_filter":"true","version":"1.28"}},"isMobileWebview":false,"os":{"name":null,"version":null},"browser":{"name":null,"version":null},"rolexPlaylistPath":"/arts/arts-in-motion","rolexSponsorClipId":"p0g364b3","rolexSponsorClipIdSummary":"Advertisement","metadata":{"contributor":"Natalie Sherman","contributors":"Natalie Sherman","description":"The move follows a bitter power struggle over the business. ","firstPublished":1746486521684,"lastPublished":1746486521684,"lastUpdated":1746542596000,"indexImage":{"blocks":[{"type":"altText","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"text","model":{"blocks":[{"type":"paragraph","model":{"text":"Sam Altman, chief executive officer of OpenAI Inc., at Station F during the AI Action Summit in Paris, France, on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025.","blocks":[{"type":"fragment","model":{"text":"Sam Altman, chief executive officer of OpenAI Inc., at Station F during the AI Action Summit in Paris, France, on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025.","attributes":[]}}]}}]}}]}},{"type":"rawImage","model":{"width":819,"height":460,"locator":"2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg","originCode":"cpsprodpb","copyrightHolder":"Getty Images","suitableForSyndication":true}}],"originalSrc":"https://c.files.bbci.co.uk/2278/live/cb9b4260-29fd-11f0-ab8b-2701683ffc8a.jpg","isEditorialImage":true,"height":460,"width":819,"alt":"Sam Altman, chief executive officer of OpenAI Inc., at Station F during the AI Action Summit in Paris, France, on Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025."},"seoHeadline":"OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash","promoHeadline":"OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash","section":{"name":"Business","uri":"/news/business"},"options":{"includeComments":false,"allowAdvertising":true},"wordCount":506},"pageKey":"@\"news\",\"articles\",\"cwy603eg0w8o\",","type":"article","subtype":"news","slug":["news","articles","cwy603eg0w8o"],"analytics":{"producer":null,"language":"en-gb","publicationDate":"1746486521684","pubUpdateDate":"1746486521684","contentId":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:cwy603eg0w8o","section":null,"name":"news.articles.cwy603eg0w8o.page"}},"serverEnv":"live","__N_SSP":true},"page":"/[[...slug]]","query":{"slug":["news","articles","cwy603eg0w8o"]},"buildId":"1Dxkla49CXtdXaNT0ytzo","assetPrefix":"https://static.files.bbci.co.uk/bbcdotcom/web/20250428-123652-7bc49a8f4-web-2.20.1-1","isFallback":false,"isExperimentalCompile":false,"gssp":true,"appGip":true,"scriptLoader":[]}</script><iframe src="https://a4621041136.cdn.optimizely.com/client_storage/a4621041136.html" hidden="" tabindex="-1" title="Optimizely Internal Frame" height="0" width="0" style="display: none;"></iframe><iframe name="__tcfapiLocator" style="display: none;"></iframe><iframe name="__uspapiLocator" style="display: none;"></iframe><iframe name="__gppLocator" style="display: none;"></iframe><script async="true" id="chartbeat-config" data-nscript="afterInteractive">
 window._sf_async_config = (window._sf_async_config || {"uid":50924,"domain":"bbc.com","useCanonical":true,"useCanonicalDomain":true,"sections":"Business","authors":"Natalie Sherman","type":"article","idSync":{"content_id":"urn:bbc:optimo:asset:cwy603eg0w8o"}});
 window._cbq = (window._cbq || ["_acct","anon"]);
 </script><script src="https://static.chartbeat.com/js/chartbeat.js" async="true" id="chartbeat" type="text/javascript" data-nscript="afterInteractive"></script><script src="https://uk-script.dotmetrics.net/door.js?d=www.bbc.com&amp;t=businessstudio" async=""></script><next-route-announcer><p aria-live="assertive" id="__next-route-announcer__" role="alert" style="border: 0px; clip: rect(0px, 0px, 0px, 0px); height: 1px; margin: -1px; overflow: hidden; padding: 0px; position: absolute; top: 0px; width: 1px; white-space: nowrap; overflow-wrap: normal;"></p></next-route-announcer><iframe marginwidth="0" marginheight="0" scrolling="no" frameborder="0" id="156c311bb6a96" width="0" height="0" src="about:blank" name="__pb_locator__" style="display: none; height: 0px; width: 0px; border: 0px;"></iframe><iframe id="cx_rep_iframe_0.6074022135601534" name="cx_rep_iframe_0.6074022135601534" width="1" height="1" src="https://cdn.cxense.com/sp1.html#ver=3.0.4&amp;typ=pgv&amp;rnd=maepgw939ctsnv1m&amp;sid=3606632254074155369&amp;loc=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.bbc.com%2Fnews%2Farticles%2Fcwy603eg0w8o&amp;new=1&amp;arf=0&amp;ltm=1746668739816&amp;ref=&amp;tzo=-480&amp;wsz=1920x888&amp;res=800x600&amp;dpr=1&amp;col=24&amp;bln=en-US&amp;chs=UTF-8&amp;cks=maepgx7vcdfg5ch8&amp;ckp=maepgw93ctjx27xa&amp;glb=&amp;amo=1746486521&amp;cp_userState=anon" scrolling="no" frameborder="0" style="display: none;"></iframe><iframe src="https://s.amazon-adsystem.com/iu3?cm3ppd=1&amp;d=dtb-pub&amp;csif=t&amp;gdpr=0&amp;dl=3lift" style="display: none;"></iframe><iframe id="gptm-dotcom-slot-top" data-slot-id="d176a683-c374-4434-bc4c-3e909b97a98b" data-slot-ad-count="1" style="display: none;"></iframe></body><iframe name="goog_topics_frame" src="https://securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/static/topics/topics_frame.html" style="display: none;"></iframe></html>