{ "DeepSeek-67B": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 95, "hidden_dim": 8192, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": -0.006468602291532064, "t_stat": -0.1714783161931369, "p_value": 0.8638761394819914, "permutation_p": 0.8727, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -97.80428502817621, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 76.29733384429431, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 11766.53919777792, "truthful_std": 979.3516525920907, "deceptive_mean": 11774.160038582224, "deceptive_std": 1347.0581393900268, "mean_diff": -7.6208408043032785 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": -0.023659495070260893, "t_stat": -0.6085702031463932, "p_value": 0.5429227400866921, "permutation_p": 0.5354, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.004120579239109751, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0021309102917158973, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.3025708153405165, "truthful_std": 0.03987879615078584, "deceptive_mean": 0.3035442358599615, "deceptive_std": 0.04233656837508782, "mean_diff": -0.0009734205194449445 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": 0.03758539411449419, "t_stat": 1.0217039869514497, "p_value": 0.30712374084544325, "permutation_p": 0.3053, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0024767170651037165, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.007999743054636181, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.696256656236336, "truthful_std": 0.07509406387245329, "deceptive_mean": 1.6935303250297171, "deceptive_std": 0.06982467077790414, "mean_diff": 0.0027263312066187623 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.020768353986763643, "t_stat": -0.5799516731893521, "p_value": 0.5620543822243259, "permutation_p": 0.555, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0023486045418215575, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0012854137137287942, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.4948065189064526, "truthful_std": 0.02581665713434574, "deceptive_mean": 1.4953471248267127, "deceptive_std": 0.026220977127653648, "mean_diff": -0.0005406059202600699 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": -0.006468600722455762, "t_stat": -0.17147827535390345, "p_value": 0.8638761715844461, "permutation_p": 0.8713, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -1.0438074429308781, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.8128927746757131, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 125.17594890281802, "truthful_std": 10.418634590582682, "deceptive_mean": 125.25702165697442, "deceptive_std": 14.330405559603479, "mean_diff": -0.08107275415639409 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": -0.053318530683101, "t_stat": -1.3544416424372423, "p_value": 0.17584651501990406, "permutation_p": 0.1609, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -2.010039766460168, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.12187901506658402, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 33.443767857942426, "truthful_std": 7.189050859299523, "deceptive_mean": 34.209031869544354, "deceptive_std": 18.97311013370061, "mean_diff": -0.7652640116019327 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": -0.015645463887790097, "t_stat": -0.40599256586775523, "p_value": 0.6848193174457232, "permutation_p": 0.6875, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -62.65472672759509, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 41.4368565168537, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 3578.240066078061, "truthful_std": 665.2430045515856, "deceptive_mean": 3588.971872498559, "deceptive_std": 705.4787237356037, "mean_diff": -10.731806420498208 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.5243852459016394, "f1": 0.5240309572062407 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.5094262295081967, "f1": 0.5089877755542619 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.5117213114754099, "f1": 0.5112735552224852 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.514016393442623, "f1": 0.5113927964115956 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 49, "accuracy": 0.648360655737705 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 49, "accuracy": 0.5397540983606557 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 59, "accuracy": 0.6528688524590164 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": { "first_above_60pct": { "layer": 7, "layer_frac": 0.07446808510638298, "accuracy": 0.6024590163934426 } }, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.6234715130341306, "best_auroc_layer": 51, "best_accuracy": 0.5983606557377049 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.5671627250739049, "best_auroc_layer": 9, "best_accuracy": 0.5434426229508197 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.5525429991937651, "best_auroc_layer": 9, "best_accuracy": 0.5368852459016393 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.6142811072292395, "best_auroc_layer": 3, "best_accuracy": 0.5868852459016394 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.51813020693362, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.5192622950819672 } } }, "GPT-2-Large": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 36, "hidden_dim": 1280, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": -0.12708052715818377, "t_stat": -3.504618632105857, "p_value": 0.00047384459850521334, "permutation_p": 0.0003, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -16.600535046937036, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -4.689711625146086, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": true, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 956.6104607253778, "truthful_std": 79.95562993197197, "deceptive_mean": 967.2634186291303, "deceptive_std": 87.46416537071538, "mean_diff": -10.652957903752561 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": 0.04563476613128057, "t_stat": 1.199706308926473, "p_value": 0.23048654264610813, "permutation_p": 0.2337, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0019142037975080192, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.007393922158720829, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.45436751146957693, "truthful_std": 0.061993746233077955, "deceptive_mean": 0.4515307814669681, "deceptive_std": 0.06227816240699274, "mean_diff": 0.002836730002608881 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.02255520164437748, "t_stat": -0.594765457500898, "p_value": 0.5521106385962984, "permutation_p": 0.5426, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.004467014264864999, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.002377291219156295, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.5776430866757378, "truthful_std": 0.046937276163077815, "deceptive_mean": 1.5786771900341159, "deceptive_std": 0.04469298828214114, "mean_diff": -0.0010341033583781759 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.015633558717229497, "t_stat": -0.43255769204038896, "p_value": 0.6654126429758209, "permutation_p": 0.6587, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0042640991313535655, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0027053820549464615, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.310774205942623, "truthful_std": 0.049362367143511755, "deceptive_mean": 1.3115410342568257, "deceptive_std": 0.048695440609487536, "mean_diff": -0.0007668283142027308 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": -0.12708053580388493, "t_stat": -3.5046188751841516, "p_value": 0.0004738441702643898, "permutation_p": 0.0006, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.4788233132831386, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.13434321282339878, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": true, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 27.331727446884404, "truthful_std": 2.2844465706144, "deceptive_mean": 27.63609769383415, "deceptive_std": 2.498976158760812, "mean_diff": -0.3043702469497431 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": -0.14190150495946308, "t_stat": -4.001044626889298, "p_value": 6.686201877557452e-05, "permutation_p": 0.0001, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.5399448118786343, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.18228870854514548, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": true, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 4.9800059486608035, "truthful_std": 2.1489559806118166, "deceptive_mean": 5.337909309981299, "deceptive_std": 2.845083749919708, "mean_diff": -0.3579033613204956 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": -0.035767015575421016, "t_stat": -0.9687382420695723, "p_value": 0.3328679693456698, "permutation_p": 0.3383, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -7.303351936340332, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 2.430800883809073, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 433.9203968861064, "truthful_std": 63.89185338303998, "deceptive_mean": 436.3008014741491, "deceptive_std": 69.05933239304335, "mean_diff": -2.3804045880427127 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.5531967213114755, "f1": 0.5528278696636718 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.5152459016393443, "f1": 0.5121707001828051 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.5141393442622951, "f1": 0.510091411898657 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.5147131147540983, "f1": 0.5109752013589156 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 23, "accuracy": 0.6204918032786886 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 33, "accuracy": 0.548360655737705 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 23, "accuracy": 0.6122950819672133 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": { "first_above_60pct": { "layer": 5, "layer_frac": 0.14285714285714285, "accuracy": 0.6094262295081968 } }, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.593425826390755, "best_auroc_layer": 18, "best_accuracy": 0.5946721311475409 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.6062483203439936, "best_auroc_layer": 16, "best_accuracy": 0.5680327868852459 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.5377855415210965, "best_auroc_layer": 35, "best_accuracy": 0.5237704918032786 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.6253144316044074, "best_auroc_layer": 9, "best_accuracy": 0.6049180327868853 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.5213753023380813, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.5225409836065574 } } }, "GPT-2-Medium": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 24, "hidden_dim": 1024, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": -0.09552398722277787, "t_stat": -2.7064533114980205, "p_value": 0.006895551093362476, "permutation_p": 0.0068, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -34.41232926915904, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -5.570832844718562, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": true, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1736.8664305640048, "truthful_std": 210.0674707713205, "deceptive_mean": 1756.9596706703062, "deceptive_std": 210.4550709689093, "mean_diff": -20.09324010630123 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": -0.029787324861380037, "t_stat": -0.7767876722459235, "p_value": 0.43743475370799956, "permutation_p": 0.4467, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.005609912277825083, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0024441060119825735, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.5951486394052482, "truthful_std": 0.052679912264119604, "deceptive_mean": 0.5967387915339943, "deceptive_std": 0.054034753345450916, "mean_diff": -0.0015901521287461414 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.06674220999145686, "t_stat": -1.7132691114440934, "p_value": 0.08691730355963055, "permutation_p": 0.087, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.01863929478360004, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0012135516253651074, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.6250118548752832, "truthful_std": 0.12661865762204935, "deceptive_mean": 1.633753147086159, "deceptive_std": 0.1350791878076313, "mean_diff": -0.008741292210875964 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.005835608870676824, "t_stat": -0.16600861964873131, "p_value": 0.868177695388119, "permutation_p": 0.8718, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.004961815009840199, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.003961878134334673, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.2320960571042827, "truthful_std": 0.06617070493986332, "deceptive_mean": 1.232477746684043, "deceptive_std": 0.06457996478224634, "mean_diff": -0.000381689579760442 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": -0.0955239899686238, "t_stat": -2.706453398353282, "p_value": 0.006895549300584982, "permutation_p": 0.008, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -1.496235397526475, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.23191829345265408, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": true, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 75.51593177357658, "truthful_std": 9.133368307046249, "deceptive_mean": 76.38955094071686, "deceptive_std": 9.150220610059087, "mean_diff": -0.8736191671402728 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": -0.07238408674251749, "t_stat": -2.1655459392057375, "p_value": 0.030539333595061557, "permutation_p": 0.0331, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.9125980717627727, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.05504207996071375, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 25.522241440757377, "truthful_std": 6.6827923733224885, "deceptive_mean": 26.003145327333545, "deceptive_std": 6.599055133668892, "mean_diff": -0.4809038865761679 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": -0.09559022307541176, "t_stat": -2.4621702469455955, "p_value": 0.013947479680970874, "permutation_p": 0.0121, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -26.659953259327374, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -2.8729856835037033, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1033.1342801953926, "truthful_std": 154.18980567002419, "deceptive_mean": 1048.0545158011014, "deceptive_std": 157.83172139292202, "mean_diff": -14.92023560570889 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.5234426229508198, "f1": 0.5226163108417304 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.5064344262295082, "f1": 0.5045522828454776 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.5066393442622951, "f1": 0.5047677036274388 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.517827868852459, "f1": 0.5084864232465648 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 19, "accuracy": 0.5983606557377049 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 12, "accuracy": 0.5377049180327869 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 23, "accuracy": 0.5889344262295082 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": {}, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.5754602257457673, "best_auroc_layer": 17, "best_accuracy": 0.5672131147540984 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.5523649556570814, "best_auroc_layer": 16, "best_accuracy": 0.5372950819672131 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.522987772104273, "best_auroc_layer": 19, "best_accuracy": 0.5237704918032786 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.5996902714324106, "best_auroc_layer": 8, "best_accuracy": 0.5713114754098361 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.5148145659768878, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.4905737704918033 } } }, "GPT-2": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 12, "hidden_dim": 768, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": -0.09364016453171434, "t_stat": -2.8464449277355985, "p_value": 0.0044951214242640375, "permutation_p": 0.0054, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -17.742511176437628, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -3.2821689680756116, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": true, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 727.9395542332384, "truthful_std": 108.70961399748744, "deceptive_mean": 738.5047535880667, "deceptive_std": 116.71120915819556, "mean_diff": -10.565199354828382 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": -0.05567661294298802, "t_stat": -1.6150766219636736, "p_value": 0.10655288088003392, "permutation_p": 0.1071, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.005881594036774759, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.00042435112858753467, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.6853777176676183, "truthful_std": 0.04841960290464613, "deceptive_mean": 0.6880310852140963, "deceptive_std": 0.04684180092060957, "mean_diff": -0.0026533675464778857 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.010054767197661789, "t_stat": -0.2988346638609815, "p_value": 0.7651171358176297, "permutation_p": 0.7673, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.008185109508330703, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0061380529159405185, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.5464185484120103, "truthful_std": 0.10866002986809611, "deceptive_mean": 1.5475068162699215, "deceptive_std": 0.1077172183156758, "mean_diff": -0.0010882678579111568 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.039677441372556486, "t_stat": -1.2183872404644074, "p_value": 0.22331260127586386, "permutation_p": 0.2244, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0074166366360226615, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.00169136989556375, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.2645694674038497, "truthful_std": 0.07185812461459708, "deceptive_mean": 1.2673726192263306, "deceptive_std": 0.069358845657929, "mean_diff": -0.002803151822480999 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": -0.09364015951803399, "t_stat": -2.846444773449902, "p_value": 0.004495123587871529, "permutation_p": 0.0046, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -1.6197114817040863, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.30973067002218285, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": true, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 66.17632312774658, "truthful_std": 9.882692276404656, "deceptive_mean": 67.13679574747555, "deceptive_std": 10.61010988743234, "mean_diff": -0.9604726197289639 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": -0.07885616719015347, "t_stat": -2.448630141959499, "p_value": 0.014480159883659314, "permutation_p": 0.0128, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -1.4932794261174123, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.17067421813480207, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 37.65269411821834, "truthful_std": 10.210366540355762, "deceptive_mean": 38.486151211379, "deceptive_std": 10.908110945636274, "mean_diff": -0.8334570931606605 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": -0.09376228959778164, "t_stat": -2.756847188877696, "p_value": 0.005923245063368861, "permutation_p": 0.0048, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -16.20110842095047, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -2.766349322209595, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": true, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 500.76223673585986, "truthful_std": 97.78259691693522, "deceptive_mean": 510.2617271673484, "deceptive_std": 104.64721475783789, "mean_diff": -9.499490431488537 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.5279918032786886, "f1": 0.5272196037386763 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.5089754098360655, "f1": 0.5083221025983922 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.5075409836065573, "f1": 0.5068987229842701 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.5040573770491803, "f1": 0.49341261713535695 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 10, "accuracy": 0.5959016393442623 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 1, "accuracy": 0.5266393442622951 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 10, "accuracy": 0.590983606557377 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": {}, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.5527613544746035, "best_auroc_layer": 5, "best_accuracy": 0.5389344262295082 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.5475141091104542, "best_auroc_layer": 9, "best_accuracy": 0.5381147540983606 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.5339928782585327, "best_auroc_layer": 8, "best_accuracy": 0.5229508196721312 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.5990674549852191, "best_auroc_layer": 2, "best_accuracy": 0.5737704918032787 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.5242172803009943, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.5172131147540984 } } }, "Llama-2-13B": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 40, "hidden_dim": 5120, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": -0.0258503192939644, "t_stat": -0.7069700324668097, "p_value": 0.47972021892735256, "permutation_p": 0.4796, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -7.913531464123333, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 3.582699065286605, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 813.3033036529041, "truthful_std": 69.91000374801499, "deceptive_mean": 815.4065577772797, "deceptive_std": 91.33206760451861, "mean_diff": -2.10325412437564 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": -0.08049977678810381, "t_stat": -2.279982949708254, "p_value": 0.02278079395054182, "permutation_p": 0.0238, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0067773160437121, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.0005878614164183247, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.29779512848856543, "truthful_std": 0.041301190508699175, "deceptive_mean": 0.3014300191985405, "deceptive_std": 0.04866872873146613, "mean_diff": -0.003634890709975051 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.013213658793861303, "t_stat": -0.34835330196808917, "p_value": 0.7276350186379982, "permutation_p": 0.7296, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0033913922383159876, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0023453316849763256, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.7365263969194693, "truthful_std": 0.04024942502396714, "deceptive_mean": 1.7370399040276887, "deceptive_std": 0.0373897494351762, "mean_diff": -0.0005135071082193344 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.030052333245948182, "t_stat": -0.8986472796189172, "p_value": 0.36901803338779887, "permutation_p": 0.3713, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0027930878176063785, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0010612726260404116, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.5160035782173031, "truthful_std": 0.02993941940080407, "deceptive_mean": 1.5168919506620189, "deceptive_std": 0.02915280540961948, "mean_diff": -0.0008883724447156562 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": -0.02585034987538429, "t_stat": -0.7069708699995663, "p_value": 0.47971969862682606, "permutation_p": 0.4783, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.2011151973927607, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.08995416023692143, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 20.853930800078345, "truthful_std": 1.7925641798836656, "deceptive_mean": 20.90786045731091, "deceptive_std": 2.3418479361149904, "mean_diff": -0.05392965723256596 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": -0.08212299321022687, "t_stat": -2.277104278493796, "p_value": 0.022952639466870428, "permutation_p": 0.0227, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.30809750040046496, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.02556614958849125, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 4.753185743582053, "truthful_std": 1.6305900696186433, "deceptive_mean": 4.915906024956312, "deceptive_std": 2.277455568661975, "mean_diff": -0.16272028137425906 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": -0.07236040163159937, "t_stat": -2.0204563663100368, "p_value": 0.04355440496675209, "permutation_p": 0.042, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -10.256544972873122, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.2650493614009199, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 243.909583513854, "truthful_std": 58.57253161284826, "deceptive_mean": 249.04543583354013, "deceptive_std": 81.46279593618912, "mean_diff": -5.13585231968614 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.4974180327868853, "f1": 0.49661727959323704 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.5123770491803279, "f1": 0.5115297943499232 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.5116803278688524, "f1": 0.5107102522826257 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.5059426229508197, "f1": 0.5032919093301941 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 16, "accuracy": 0.6569672131147541 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 16, "accuracy": 0.5372950819672131 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 22, "accuracy": 0.6442622950819672 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": { "first_above_60pct": { "layer": 7, "layer_frac": 0.1794871794871795, "accuracy": 0.6090163934426229 } }, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.6296660843859178, "best_auroc_layer": 15, "best_accuracy": 0.6024590163934427 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.5677909164203172, "best_auroc_layer": 15, "best_accuracy": 0.5426229508196722 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.5326558720773985, "best_auroc_layer": 5, "best_accuracy": 0.5344262295081966 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.612021633969363, "best_auroc_layer": 28, "best_accuracy": 0.5934426229508196 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.5266326256382692, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.5122950819672132 } } }, "Llama-2-70B": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 80, "hidden_dim": 8192, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": 0.07098120409623256, "t_stat": 1.74947400507611, "p_value": 0.08046075525943744, "permutation_p": 0.1116, "bootstrap_ci_lower": 4.27547648945796, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 277.5088049191334, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 2421.148745977683, "truthful_std": 2501.856337600423, "deceptive_mean": 2294.264740990811, "deceptive_std": 355.3913194554858, "mean_diff": 126.88400498687244 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": -0.06598732391506414, "t_stat": -1.9140831197423405, "p_value": 0.05584347680279371, "permutation_p": 0.0576, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.005865382846622619, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 3.7461435461871445e-06, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.24729496544270843, "truthful_std": 0.04246326128284223, "deceptive_mean": 0.2501723964993169, "deceptive_std": 0.04468432087673348, "mean_diff": -0.002877431056608427 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.04116092956391102, "t_stat": -1.133113022861536, "p_value": 0.25738960341211087, "permutation_p": 0.2539, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0053106589493204315, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0013918421551829471, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.7458076000213623, "truthful_std": 0.047864884321010145, "deceptive_mean": 1.7477685989903622, "deceptive_std": 0.04737930293492968, "mean_diff": -0.001960998968999894 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.010000547744228995, "t_stat": -0.2837774117627537, "p_value": 0.7766291559802043, "permutation_p": 0.7717, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.00202512725454862, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0014050666743614622, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.5294553104971276, "truthful_std": 0.0285752350660843, "deceptive_mean": 1.5296999784766652, "deceptive_std": 0.019483119747071655, "mean_diff": -0.00024466797953746357 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": 0.07098120540907571, "t_stat": 1.7494740383505034, "p_value": 0.08046074950986117, "permutation_p": 0.1102, "bootstrap_ci_lower": 0.057898770121277456, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 3.5601496491275846, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 30.647452484193394, "truthful_std": 31.669067678082996, "deceptive_mean": 29.04132580366291, "deceptive_std": 4.498624265362652, "mean_diff": 1.6061266805304855 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": 0.06800915587425085, "t_stat": 1.678545220730234, "p_value": 0.0934970127908692, "permutation_p": 0.1194, "bootstrap_ci_lower": 0.02506468935579605, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 5.318178704459158, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 9.367259805319739, "truthful_std": 46.65361563569343, "deceptive_mean": 7.104178898451758, "deceptive_std": 6.0187517746157155, "mean_diff": 2.263080906867981 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": -0.01682985918090397, "t_stat": -0.47638912561307484, "p_value": 0.63388255508108, "permutation_p": 0.6382, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -11.868152533671894, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 7.752881251788529, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 569.8513071904417, "truthful_std": 150.91681876125753, "deceptive_mean": 572.2231888067527, "deceptive_std": 130.0605355582574, "mean_diff": -2.3718816163109953 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.5277459016393443, "f1": 0.5274016244655436 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.5059426229508197, "f1": 0.5054033105570604 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.501516393442623, "f1": 0.5008892271239309 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.5138114754098361, "f1": 0.5088070544113905 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 24, "accuracy": 0.6459016393442623 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 0, "accuracy": 0.5274590163934426 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 33, "accuracy": 0.6344262295081967 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": { "first_above_60pct": { "layer": 1, "layer_frac": 0.012658227848101266, "accuracy": 0.6090163934426229 } }, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.6293973394248857, "best_auroc_layer": 24, "best_accuracy": 0.5967213114754099 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.5610487772104273, "best_auroc_layer": 7, "best_accuracy": 0.5495901639344263 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.522285675893577, "best_auroc_layer": 0, "best_accuracy": 0.5254098360655738 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.5751531846277882, "best_auroc_layer": 79, "best_accuracy": 0.5614754098360656 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.5119860252620263, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.5114754098360655 } } }, "Llama-2-7B": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 32, "hidden_dim": 4096, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": 0.057013746007894654, "t_stat": 1.5965091671535698, "p_value": 0.11063434704683851, "permutation_p": 0.1094, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.9029729180257813, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 8.517837712647484, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 575.761364821137, "truthful_std": 67.38421527920397, "deceptive_mean": 571.9204462020124, "deceptive_std": 67.2971068666336, "mean_diff": 3.840918619124616 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": 0.03867016215317317, "t_stat": 1.15085943931287, "p_value": 0.2500157617638647, "permutation_p": 0.2403, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0013560302083778443, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.005266803959239672, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.3345334556328632, "truthful_std": 0.049319685042743505, "deceptive_mean": 0.3325889238666119, "deceptive_std": 0.051191793668403526, "mean_diff": 0.0019445317662512575 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": 0.027298585364032443, "t_stat": 0.6943331300807868, "p_value": 0.48760562128692897, "permutation_p": 0.4908, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.002203304630811096, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.005014363390500428, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.735280988744048, "truthful_std": 0.05333560455781606, "deceptive_mean": 1.7339984186360093, "deceptive_std": 0.03957908278142267, "mean_diff": 0.00128257010803848 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.053884475189375274, "t_stat": -1.5530698582961282, "p_value": 0.12066601659325728, "permutation_p": 0.1218, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.004556213925119306, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0005283086514863797, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.5310123383021745, "truthful_std": 0.03607964297549563, "deceptive_mean": 1.533022094847726, "deceptive_std": 0.038447194912647066, "mean_diff": -0.002009756545551488 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": 0.05701373693727527, "t_stat": 1.5965089198469646, "p_value": 0.1106344022211799, "permutation_p": 0.1142, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.027317868099837984, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.2729548382563669, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 18.57294723010454, "truthful_std": 2.1736843536363364, "deceptive_mean": 18.4490466493075, "deceptive_std": 2.1708744214895512, "mean_diff": 0.1239005807970391 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": 0.011433932412624942, "t_stat": 0.34007395698647985, "p_value": 0.7338594224877664, "permutation_p": 0.7355, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.08267392652933714, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.12025831646117999, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 5.990671797854001, "truthful_std": 1.5061634273519866, "deceptive_mean": 5.9728310147269825, "deceptive_std": 1.6114530886964313, "mean_diff": 0.017840783127018662 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": 0.05094436258060129, "t_stat": 1.481134898802065, "p_value": 0.13882905208150262, "permutation_p": 0.1387, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.7387069951510814, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 5.311473209897021, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 194.65508896874599, "truthful_std": 44.085181428315394, "deceptive_mean": 192.35627387625271, "deceptive_std": 46.103312995030485, "mean_diff": 2.298815092493276 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.5162704918032787, "f1": 0.5159627310759071 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.5320491803278689, "f1": 0.5317475261394282 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.5320491803278689, "f1": 0.5318262363213169 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.5180737704918034, "f1": 0.5164488016400757 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 13, "accuracy": 0.6319672131147541 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 21, "accuracy": 0.5331967213114753 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 17, "accuracy": 0.6258196721311476 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": { "first_above_60pct": { "layer": 10, "layer_frac": 0.3225806451612903, "accuracy": 0.618032786885246 } }, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.6218288094598227, "best_auroc_layer": 13, "best_accuracy": 0.5852459016393443 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.570276807309863, "best_auroc_layer": 11, "best_accuracy": 0.5512295081967213 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.5153722117710293, "best_auroc_layer": 3, "best_accuracy": 0.5139344262295082 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.6298615963450686, "best_auroc_layer": 17, "best_accuracy": 0.6032786885245902 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.5407383767804353, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.5336065573770492 } } }, "Llama-3-70B": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 80, "hidden_dim": 8192, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": -0.058369461385645485, "t_stat": -1.4744498064998255, "p_value": 0.1406187245993933, "permutation_p": 0.1356, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -14.3391719130219, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 1.0428887658041028, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 518.5246481973617, "truthful_std": 73.07075897340019, "deceptive_mean": 524.2921427992524, "deceptive_std": 119.04430157416851, "mean_diff": -5.767494601890689 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": -0.1042484533927476, "t_stat": -2.82978438563624, "p_value": 0.004734343010363286, "permutation_p": 0.004, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0053846611008383565, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.0009767319099437102, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": true, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.2489674028799261, "truthful_std": 0.030579509600800765, "deceptive_mean": 0.25214949450487245, "deceptive_std": 0.03044354105250917, "mean_diff": -0.003182091624946376 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": 0.02618627699309665, "t_stat": 0.6789723955538679, "p_value": 0.49728423941720645, "permutation_p": 0.4929, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0031631071450280357, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.006427857072138395, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.8193591471578254, "truthful_std": 0.06509853925478735, "deceptive_mean": 1.8176772214350154, "deceptive_std": 0.06329469258596979, "mean_diff": 0.0016819257228100886 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.0403148468909918, "t_stat": -1.128732150808447, "p_value": 0.25923292574171297, "permutation_p": 0.2675, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0019026405645198507, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0005192419740020245, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.5829051758422226, "truthful_std": 0.017766091847010224, "deceptive_mean": 1.5835959412035394, "deceptive_std": 0.016463624327660766, "mean_diff": -0.0006907653613168685 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": -0.058369460251148, "t_stat": -1.4744497737377795, "p_value": 0.14061873341347292, "permutation_p": 0.1425, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.18049811438458863, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.013975741276975517, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 6.563603141659596, "truthful_std": 0.9249463054654385, "deceptive_mean": 6.6366094018592205, "deceptive_std": 1.5068899236167548, "mean_diff": -0.07300626019962499 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": -0.04099208383995008, "t_stat": -1.0449200318475795, "p_value": 0.2962670907359531, "permutation_p": 0.3838, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.16097883526541165, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.025700759877924036, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.7218470766407545, "truthful_std": 0.6817257594091123, "deceptive_mean": 1.772953803764015, "deceptive_std": 1.625255147180957, "mean_diff": -0.0511067271232605 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": -0.06986930449456674, "t_stat": -1.7830097636840787, "p_value": 0.0748334857496624, "permutation_p": 0.0498, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -8.021615529216703, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.13846754402410816, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 130.35288423319332, "truthful_std": 35.75907410657444, "deceptive_mean": 133.95852340323026, "deceptive_std": 63.58596139164245, "mean_diff": -3.6056391700369415 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.5161475409836066, "f1": 0.5158013007730432 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.5243032786885247, "f1": 0.5229972548157749 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.524795081967213, "f1": 0.5234600062340684 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.5147131147540984, "f1": 0.5071423295086526 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 33, "accuracy": 0.6454918032786885 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 74, "accuracy": 0.5299180327868853 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 37, "accuracy": 0.6401639344262295 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": { "first_above_60pct": { "layer": 5, "layer_frac": 0.06329113924050633, "accuracy": 0.6024590163934427 } }, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.6443697930663801, "best_auroc_layer": 34, "best_accuracy": 0.6090163934426229 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.5723965331900026, "best_auroc_layer": 31, "best_accuracy": 0.55 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.5262463047567858, "best_auroc_layer": 13, "best_accuracy": 0.5245901639344261 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.6132108304219296, "best_auroc_layer": 76, "best_accuracy": 0.590983606557377 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.5327936038699275, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.5241803278688524 } } }, "Mistral-7B": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 32, "hidden_dim": 4096, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": 0.024403584142498057, "t_stat": 0.6278548498219567, "p_value": 0.5302166283837542, "permutation_p": 0.6497, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.6858155791485896, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 1.8809960169870341, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 122.2308829198118, "truthful_std": 21.728510239859503, "deceptive_mean": 121.81821882529337, "deceptive_std": 9.964830843218634, "mean_diff": 0.4126640945184426 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": -0.016284084759654288, "t_stat": -0.47001585414741903, "p_value": 0.6384277622371625, "permutation_p": 0.6466, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0032314716366165603, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.002005840378967983, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.31872721333211246, "truthful_std": 0.03821724813568551, "deceptive_mean": 0.3193489385975561, "deceptive_std": 0.038111242854923934, "mean_diff": -0.0006217252654436723 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.0038479091732126864, "t_stat": -0.10750857229650802, "p_value": 0.9144032161590034, "permutation_p": 0.9189, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.003223158150422767, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0028598024097622418, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.7428134113061624, "truthful_std": 0.04142212735034648, "deceptive_mean": 1.742976802001234, "deceptive_std": 0.0434433964506721, "mean_diff": -0.00016339069507161124 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": 0.02917262351349067, "t_stat": 0.8696634711796563, "p_value": 0.38465554601636903, "permutation_p": 0.3919, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0009573157131671906, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0023926369137451287, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.5268653533497796, "truthful_std": 0.026021372732272396, "deceptive_mean": 1.526126199862996, "deceptive_std": 0.024612725232189613, "mean_diff": 0.0007391534867833872 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": 0.024403571172131093, "t_stat": 0.6278545166571143, "p_value": 0.5302168465833885, "permutation_p": 0.6482, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.022140196825637188, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.06094926297176079, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 3.942931703465884, "truthful_std": 0.7009197070237644, "deceptive_mean": 3.9296199652015185, "deceptive_std": 0.3214461578850268, "mean_diff": 0.013311738264365275 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": 0.010825833913421677, "t_stat": 0.27652610143890494, "p_value": 0.7821908920183389, "permutation_p": 0.8802, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.024687654285645875, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.04586708330961524, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.8674355756063931, "truthful_std": 0.6043595349695766, "deceptive_mean": 0.8624152819641301, "deceptive_std": 0.2539549688690823, "mean_diff": 0.005020293642262944 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": -0.01374611685180356, "t_stat": -0.3829468878130936, "p_value": 0.7018259102483874, "permutation_p": 0.7007, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.6603644928775849, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.4473851904712737, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 38.983171780383, "truthful_std": 7.928537870948197, "deceptive_mean": 39.091888737287675, "deceptive_std": 7.8827544713096875, "mean_diff": -0.1087169569046771 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.5127049180327868, "f1": 0.5122944831394018 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.4962295081967213, "f1": 0.4954543028268742 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.4908196721311475, "f1": 0.49002356264913116 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.4997950819672132, "f1": 0.49646414361867014 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 14, "accuracy": 0.6528688524590163 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 3, "accuracy": 0.5360655737704918 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 17, "accuracy": 0.6512295081967213 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": { "first_above_60pct": { "layer": 4, "layer_frac": 0.12903225806451613, "accuracy": 0.6102459016393442 } }, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.6353802741198602, "best_auroc_layer": 14, "best_accuracy": 0.6081967213114754 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.5421963181940339, "best_auroc_layer": 17, "best_accuracy": 0.531967213114754 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.505499193765117, "best_auroc_layer": 1, "best_accuracy": 0.5081967213114754 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.5918778554152109, "best_auroc_layer": 26, "best_accuracy": 0.5745901639344262 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.4804756785810266, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.48647540983606563 } } }, "Mixtral-8x7B": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 32, "hidden_dim": 4096, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": -0.035214067961400836, "t_stat": -0.9799584120692088, "p_value": 0.32730109064651297, "permutation_p": 0.3251, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -19.723818764608414, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 6.430451267430035, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1949.0608018218493, "truthful_std": 175.82526685540861, "deceptive_mean": 1955.6656266009222, "deceptive_std": 198.46131117960698, "mean_diff": -6.604824779072746 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": -0.07188925572175103, "t_stat": -1.9740757284560517, "p_value": 0.04859860751727824, "permutation_p": 0.0482, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.008893477047894961, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.00012896798682237974, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.38744133620996235, "truthful_std": 0.05860738206957136, "deceptive_mean": 0.3918516081600039, "deceptive_std": 0.06392333617788, "mean_diff": -0.00441027195004156 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.07605126922060935, "t_stat": -2.1218731035268568, "p_value": 0.03404965586409638, "permutation_p": 0.0377, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.012516805102102091, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.0004778007674412663, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.5614184778244768, "truthful_std": 0.08600734452602779, "deceptive_mean": 1.5678966286729594, "deceptive_std": 0.08427675470480075, "mean_diff": -0.0064781508484824755 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.04994465234230818, "t_stat": -1.5187366565937455, "p_value": 0.12908809714688832, "permutation_p": 0.1249, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.007484574823594484, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.0010246099495008342, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.142506237450193, "truthful_std": 0.06680792899745192, "deceptive_mean": 1.1457716037504009, "deceptive_std": 0.06386472523212032, "mean_diff": -0.0032653663002076695 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": -0.03521406803474155, "t_stat": -0.9799584179703984, "p_value": 0.3273010877346485, "permutation_p": 0.3318, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.6448444531393833, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.20495615247820237, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 62.872929072770916, "truthful_std": 5.6717828927082, "deceptive_mean": 63.085987938427536, "deceptive_std": 6.401977773010542, "mean_diff": -0.21305886565661822 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": -0.07035456294544168, "t_stat": -1.9761314339214338, "p_value": 0.04836506172202632, "permutation_p": 0.0454, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.6959442025325338, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -7.122891848313402e-06, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 26.059983405128854, "truthful_std": 4.597156472143855, "deceptive_mean": 26.408488937284126, "deceptive_std": 5.2821809128970605, "mean_diff": -0.3485055321552714 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": -0.06406756655867547, "t_stat": -1.754745537583946, "p_value": 0.07955405677519403, "permutation_p": 0.0776, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -28.613145164114528, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 1.5239253003479907, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 761.4867463158779, "truthful_std": 193.78400880874386, "deceptive_mean": 774.8091785118228, "deceptive_std": 221.03811097086123, "mean_diff": -13.322432195944865 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.526967213114754, "f1": 0.5255045374002696 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.5121721311475409, "f1": 0.5091346001545509 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.5124180327868852, "f1": 0.5093902069632418 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.530532786885246, "f1": 0.5270281763120935 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 14, "accuracy": 0.6778688524590164 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 24, "accuracy": 0.5311475409836065 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 19, "accuracy": 0.6676229508196723 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": { "first_above_60pct": { "layer": 1, "layer_frac": 0.03225806451612903, "accuracy": 0.6012295081967214 } }, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.6890284869658695, "best_auroc_layer": 14, "best_accuracy": 0.6459016393442624 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.5662691480784735, "best_auroc_layer": 16, "best_accuracy": 0.5524590163934426 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.5353836334318732, "best_auroc_layer": 5, "best_accuracy": 0.5327868852459017 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.6155280838484278, "best_auroc_layer": 18, "best_accuracy": 0.5975409836065574 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.5234715130341308, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.5151639344262295 } } }, "Qwen-72B": { "n_pairs": 1220, "n_layers": 80, "hidden_dim": 8192, "effect_sizes": { "path_length": { "cohens_d": 0.017103598347720468, "t_stat": 0.43907037618641315, "p_value": 0.6606883572806812, "permutation_p": 0.666, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -58.13918400998971, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 92.52834879890816, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 6783.758322393699, "truthful_std": 961.1635425766067, "deceptive_mean": 6767.028068167265, "deceptive_std": 994.1003271780379, "mean_diff": 16.730254226434425 }, "straightness": { "cohens_d": -0.03896871925418593, "t_stat": -1.0856362070501036, "p_value": 0.2778546164390663, "permutation_p": 0.2852, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.004365572545174141, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.001234444548251951, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 0.2977499600755121, "truthful_std": 0.03926661893991969, "deceptive_mean": 0.2992881754688981, "deceptive_std": 0.03964626727405061, "mean_diff": -0.0015382153933860855 }, "max_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.09386031932415598, "t_stat": -2.392816529318656, "p_value": 0.016870221178540333, "permutation_p": 0.0187, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.022944221694449905, "bootstrap_ci_upper": -0.0027556470402928693, "ci_excludes_zero": true, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.7345928281057077, "truthful_std": 0.1165178028891376, "deceptive_mean": 1.7470912191711487, "deceptive_std": 0.14784257331057035, "mean_diff": -0.012498391065441193 }, "mean_curvature": { "cohens_d": -0.06233501499502357, "t_stat": -1.8218316749783954, "p_value": 0.06872548835945766, "permutation_p": 0.0705, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.0048786134969015585, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.00018651327393094037, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 1.3791012525558473, "truthful_std": 0.037687417629142336, "deceptive_mean": 1.3814803610082533, "deceptive_std": 0.03860870106699081, "mean_diff": -0.002379108452406086 }, "mean_step": { "cohens_d": 0.01710359981932568, "t_stat": 0.43907041414780024, "p_value": 0.6606883297827653, "permutation_p": 0.6719, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.7427561333922088, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 1.125794504431427, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 85.87035857028648, "truthful_std": 12.16662721291691, "deceptive_mean": 85.6585831782857, "deceptive_std": 12.5835487963396, "mean_diff": 0.21177539200079246 }, "mean_acceleration": { "cohens_d": -0.023979053362136897, "t_stat": -0.6108409495803968, "p_value": 0.5414187562700886, "permutation_p": 0.5581, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -0.8437453856429115, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 0.43293405405810614, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 21.986160460456475, "truthful_std": 7.95481885082566, "deceptive_mean": 22.185230867198257, "deceptive_std": 8.628392916880925, "mean_diff": -0.19907040674178328 }, "direct_distance": { "cohens_d": -0.01297569297527233, "t_stat": -0.3618644862358171, "p_value": 0.7175160161056415, "permutation_p": 0.7151, "bootstrap_ci_lower": -28.744522962726524, "bootstrap_ci_upper": 20.358281247498557, "ci_excludes_zero": false, "bonferroni_significant": false, "bonferroni_alpha": 0.0071428571428571435, "truthful_mean": 2016.7771644967502, "truthful_std": 349.2553753334455, "deceptive_mean": 2021.290942783043, "deceptive_std": 346.1809170772591, "mean_diff": -4.513778286292904 } }, "binary_classification": { "random_forest": { "accuracy": 0.5430737704918033, "f1": 0.5427166346552539 }, "logistic_regression_l2": { "accuracy": 0.5153688524590164, "f1": 0.5135582393546149 }, "logistic_regression_l1": { "accuracy": 0.5161065573770491, "f1": 0.514261126854185 }, "svm_rbf": { "accuracy": 0.5250409836065574, "f1": 0.523143815205607 } }, "probe_baselines": { "full_probe": { "layer": 62, "accuracy": 0.7344262295081967 }, "pca_7": { "layer": 16, "accuracy": 0.5282786885245901 }, "mean_pooled": { "layer": 70, "accuracy": 0.7209016393442623 } }, "early_warning_thresholds": { "first_above_60pct": { "layer": 4, "layer_frac": 0.05063291139240506, "accuracy": 0.6049180327868853 }, "first_above_70pct": { "layer": 58, "layer_frac": 0.7341772151898734, "accuracy": 0.7032786885245902 } }, "interpretability_baselines": { "lr_probe": { "best_auroc": 0.7722285675893577, "best_auroc_layer": 63, "best_accuracy": 0.7008196721311475 }, "mass_mean": { "best_auroc": 0.5884439666756248, "best_auroc_layer": 63, "best_accuracy": 0.5463114754098359 }, "repe": { "best_auroc": 0.5199576726686375, "best_auroc_layer": 68, "best_accuracy": 0.5221311475409836 }, "ccs": { "best_auroc": 0.6703265251276538, "best_auroc_layer": 62, "best_accuracy": 0.6475409836065574 }, "geometric": { "best_auroc": 0.5160306369255576, "best_auroc_layer": null, "best_accuracy": 0.5086065573770492 } } } }