| {"id": "15baae2d-spread-n14-k3-t0.9-s0", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 542}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 44}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 26}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 36}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 429}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 363}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1049, "travel_s": [[0, 2014, 1815, 1962, 1642, 1955, 1798, 1791, 1797, 1743, 1764, 1791, 1931, 1901, 2056], [2026, 0, 384, 165, 562, 177, 513, 441, 532, 446, 467, 360, 300, 145, 174], [1798, 418, 0, 378, 322, 379, 273, 201, 293, 206, 227, 10, 196, 378, 406], [1992, 213, 346, 0, 525, 33, 476, 385, 495, 408, 430, 322, 254, 59, 270], [1613, 585, 324, 549, 0, 548, 314, 312, 313, 259, 280, 306, 446, 591, 572], [1995, 228, 358, 27, 544, 0, 487, 366, 506, 420, 441, 334, 238, 80, 278], [1783, 530, 276, 494, 308, 500, 0, 247, 67, 132, 111, 252, 392, 536, 517], [1765, 465, 212, 373, 298, 374, 223, 0, 274, 174, 195, 201, 278, 373, 450], [1807, 554, 300, 519, 332, 524, 73, 304, 0, 157, 135, 276, 416, 561, 541], [1747, 462, 207, 426, 272, 431, 142, 184, 141, 0, 21, 183, 323, 468, 449], [1753, 483, 228, 447, 278, 453, 121, 205, 120, 21, 0, 204, 344, 489, 470], [1782, 403, 9, 387, 320, 388, 258, 186, 277, 191, 212, 0, 204, 387, 390], [1897, 377, 210, 243, 422, 247, 373, 297, 392, 306, 327, 220, 0, 230, 430], [1939, 151, 387, 66, 571, 73, 522, 376, 541, 455, 476, 369, 228, 0, 243], [2065, 183, 412, 298, 590, 295, 524, 465, 520, 474, 567, 388, 328, 331, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 12720, "optimality": "proven", "lower_bound_s": 12720, "floor_s": 9765, "solve_s": 0.5, "ffd_s": 13970, "stop_aware_best_s": 13337, "stop_aware_mean_s": 13593.4, "route_id": "RouteID_15baae2d-bf07-4967-956a-173d4036613f", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S11", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S05", "S03", "S14", "S12", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S09", "S10", "S08", "S06", "S04"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S01", "S05", "S11", "S10"], "parcels": ["P02", "P11", "P19"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S01", "S14", "S11"], "parcels": ["P01", "P12", "P20"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S03", "S05", "S12", "S02", "S11", "S07", "S09", "S08", "S06", "S04"], "parcels": ["P10", "P21"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S05", "S14", "S12", "S02", "S09", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S10", "S06", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13", "S01", "S03", "S07"], "parcels": []}]}}} |
| {"id": "2b8df66d-spread-n14-k3-t0.9-s1", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 552}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P28", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P29", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P30", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 134}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1510, "travel_s": [[0, 1485, 1607, 1578, 1520, 1561, 1619, 1566, 1588, 1573, 1593, 1598, 1497, 1446, 1573], [1403, 0, 378, 403, 190, 315, 451, 391, 259, 401, 364, 448, 62, 377, 400], [1564, 374, 0, 313, 392, 352, 530, 300, 460, 308, 322, 333, 386, 378, 364], [1522, 337, 312, 0, 355, 192, 364, 52, 424, 48, 168, 209, 349, 304, 243], [1450, 158, 391, 353, 0, 266, 401, 341, 209, 348, 314, 396, 170, 324, 351], [1454, 310, 337, 191, 328, 0, 295, 179, 397, 186, 152, 234, 322, 236, 160], [1493, 432, 534, 388, 387, 301, 0, 377, 436, 383, 349, 439, 444, 377, 386], [1508, 332, 307, 42, 350, 179, 350, 0, 418, 90, 124, 204, 344, 291, 230], [1470, 253, 428, 282, 208, 194, 330, 270, 0, 277, 243, 324, 265, 253, 279], [1546, 361, 337, 57, 379, 216, 388, 109, 448, 0, 180, 233, 373, 329, 267], [1516, 329, 301, 158, 344, 173, 344, 126, 412, 150, 0, 198, 338, 285, 224], [1532, 353, 317, 230, 368, 275, 447, 209, 428, 224, 230, 0, 354, 330, 318], [1436, 63, 412, 436, 224, 349, 484, 424, 292, 431, 397, 479, 0, 407, 434], [1310, 387, 377, 322, 402, 368, 432, 310, 470, 317, 331, 325, 396, 0, 392], [1484, 297, 346, 200, 312, 111, 342, 189, 380, 195, 161, 243, 306, 283, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 10787, "optimality": "proven", "lower_bound_s": 10787, "floor_s": 8268, "solve_s": 0.72, "ffd_s": 12742, "stop_aware_best_s": 11478, "stop_aware_mean_s": 11618.6, "route_id": "RouteID_2b8df66d-fcd4-438e-931c-3b84b36a5c6b", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S12", "S01", "S04", "S08", "S05", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S11", "S09", "S03", "S07", "S10", "S06"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S13", "S09", "S11", "S01"], "parcels": ["P13", "P18", "P25", "P26"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S06", "S05", "S14", "S03", "S11", "S13"], "parcels": ["P06", "P20", "P27", "P30"]}, {"route": ["S12", "S08", "S14", "S10", "S07", "S03", "S09", "S11", "S02"], "parcels": ["P04", "P05", "P12", "P14", "P19", "P21", "P22", "P23", "P28", "P29"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S14", "S03", "S11", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S01", "S04", "S08", "S05", "S06"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S10", "S07", "S09", "S13"], "parcels": []}]}}} |
| {"id": "3f166f0e-spread-n14-k3-t0.9-s2", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 31}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 46}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 314}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 277}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 179}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 806, "travel_s": [[0, 2556, 2766, 2654, 2658, 2594, 2565, 2894, 2556, 2650, 2748, 2625, 2529, 2574, 2682], [2433, 0, 233, 327, 343, 112, 49, 392, 211, 335, 421, 85, 261, 61, 355], [2701, 246, 0, 277, 413, 259, 266, 236, 374, 405, 280, 236, 371, 332, 269], [2596, 339, 269, 0, 221, 307, 360, 295, 194, 213, 162, 344, 220, 404, 96], [2584, 335, 417, 225, 0, 278, 330, 451, 125, 110, 319, 314, 200, 396, 253], [2488, 92, 189, 297, 284, 0, 52, 350, 245, 276, 391, 113, 319, 118, 326], [2456, 42, 272, 366, 352, 68, 0, 431, 250, 344, 460, 60, 300, 66, 395], [2822, 399, 264, 341, 446, 360, 422, 0, 419, 438, 313, 397, 446, 464, 302], [2496, 217, 364, 172, 132, 225, 277, 398, 0, 124, 266, 261, 74, 281, 200], [2570, 320, 403, 210, 96, 264, 316, 437, 111, 0, 305, 300, 185, 382, 239], [2666, 412, 285, 158, 291, 377, 443, 310, 264, 283, 0, 414, 290, 474, 151], [2502, 85, 223, 349, 336, 74, 72, 405, 246, 328, 449, 0, 295, 112, 378], [2462, 260, 374, 219, 216, 313, 312, 446, 88, 189, 313, 349, 0, 325, 248], [2450, 68, 302, 395, 411, 131, 63, 461, 280, 403, 490, 117, 329, 0, 424], [2613, 356, 254, 105, 238, 324, 412, 279, 211, 230, 139, 361, 237, 421, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 16950, "optimality": "proven", "lower_bound_s": 16950, "floor_s": 14886, "solve_s": 1.21, "ffd_s": 17801, "stop_aware_best_s": 17414, "stop_aware_mean_s": 17527.8, "route_id": "RouteID_3f166f0e-fd2e-47ab-96a0-6cbc99cc6eef", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S13", "S06", "S11", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S02", "S07", "S10"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S14", "S09", "S04", "S08", "S12"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S12", "S08", "S07", "S05"], "parcels": ["P07"]}, {"route": ["S10", "S02", "S11", "S01"], "parcels": ["P03", "P13"]}, {"route": ["S03", "S14", "S10", "S09", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S01", "S13"], "parcels": ["P01", "P02", "P08", "P14"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S02", "S07", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S03", "S10", "S09", "S04", "S11", "S06", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S05", "S01"], "parcels": []}]}}} |
| {"id": "5486294a-spread-n14-k3-t0.9-s3", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 142}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 202}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 59}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 599}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 134}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 242}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 895, "travel_s": [[0, 1984, 1862, 1710, 1943, 1999, 1916, 2152, 1800, 1873, 1797, 1847, 2007, 1969, 1927], [1994, 0, 300, 596, 1974, 1954, 275, 1492, 678, 1923, 675, 725, 1935, 1923, 1910], [1864, 272, 0, 466, 1844, 1824, 204, 1362, 548, 1793, 545, 595, 1805, 1793, 1780], [1644, 592, 469, 0, 1529, 1509, 523, 1044, 328, 1478, 324, 377, 1490, 1476, 1465], [2042, 1811, 1688, 1398, 0, 237, 1742, 668, 1565, 303, 1562, 1612, 155, 206, 64], [2102, 1800, 1678, 1388, 206, 0, 1732, 592, 1554, 228, 1551, 1602, 235, 64, 162], [1909, 238, 215, 514, 1889, 1869, 0, 1406, 593, 1838, 590, 640, 1850, 1838, 1825], [2228, 1376, 1254, 962, 675, 650, 1308, 0, 1131, 620, 1127, 1178, 703, 620, 630], [1836, 638, 516, 318, 1714, 1694, 570, 1232, 0, 1663, 75, 157, 1675, 1663, 1650], [2070, 1804, 1681, 1391, 266, 242, 1736, 596, 1558, 0, 1555, 1605, 295, 211, 222], [1834, 636, 513, 316, 1712, 1691, 567, 1229, 86, 1661, 0, 157, 1673, 1661, 1647], [1892, 694, 572, 377, 1734, 1714, 626, 1252, 140, 1683, 156, 0, 1695, 1683, 1670], [2133, 1888, 1765, 1473, 158, 249, 1819, 679, 1642, 315, 1638, 1689, 0, 218, 94], [2081, 1778, 1656, 1364, 184, 93, 1710, 570, 1533, 206, 1529, 1580, 213, 0, 140], [2052, 1812, 1689, 1399, 64, 173, 1743, 604, 1566, 239, 1563, 1613, 111, 142, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 14668, "optimality": "proven", "lower_bound_s": 14668, "floor_s": 10062, "solve_s": 1.17, "ffd_s": 19214, "stop_aware_best_s": 17116, "stop_aware_mean_s": 17854.4, "route_id": "RouteID_5486294a-503f-4346-b8a9-862e988cbe7c", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S09", "S05", "S13", "S07", "S02", "S06", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S14", "S04"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S08", "S10", "S03"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S14", "S11", "S08", "S03"], "parcels": ["P04", "P16"]}, {"route": ["S09", "S12", "S05", "S07", "S03", "S02", "S06"], "parcels": ["P03", "P07", "P10", "P17"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S12", "S13", "S07", "S11", "S10", "S06", "S01"], "parcels": ["P08", "P09", "P14", "P15", "P18", "P19"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S09", "S14", "S13", "S07", "S03", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S08", "S06"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S12", "S05", "S11", "S10", "S02"], "parcels": []}]}}} |
| {"id": "693060a6-spread-n14-k3-t0.9-s4", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 840}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 4}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 8}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 368}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 153}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 27}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 860, "travel_s": [[0, 1357, 1232, 1666, 1374, 1486, 1539, 1342, 1444, 1660, 1477, 1385, 1560, 1496, 1390], [1271, 0, 265, 454, 349, 129, 320, 116, 258, 441, 258, 28, 338, 139, 268], [1184, 271, 0, 622, 323, 400, 488, 204, 415, 609, 426, 299, 554, 410, 267], [1584, 483, 615, 0, 358, 403, 158, 567, 277, 14, 261, 520, 338, 408, 406], [1313, 341, 360, 330, 0, 260, 196, 408, 129, 318, 134, 378, 251, 288, 163], [1385, 114, 379, 364, 279, 0, 230, 230, 167, 352, 168, 140, 244, 28, 240], [1472, 325, 457, 134, 200, 245, 0, 409, 119, 121, 102, 363, 151, 273, 248], [1259, 120, 202, 529, 401, 249, 395, 0, 333, 516, 333, 148, 452, 259, 288], [1396, 248, 380, 258, 139, 171, 124, 333, 0, 245, 62, 286, 181, 199, 172], [1596, 469, 601, 12, 344, 389, 144, 553, 263, 0, 247, 507, 295, 421, 392], [1422, 262, 407, 228, 150, 174, 94, 378, 69, 216, 0, 287, 119, 202, 198], [1312, 41, 306, 483, 381, 148, 349, 158, 288, 471, 288, 0, 356, 158, 268], [1469, 345, 527, 281, 268, 253, 147, 461, 189, 268, 120, 361, 0, 227, 318], [1413, 142, 407, 390, 314, 26, 256, 258, 193, 378, 195, 177, 270, 0, 276], [1313, 252, 291, 394, 158, 274, 260, 312, 162, 382, 198, 266, 317, 302, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 9435, "optimality": "proven", "lower_bound_s": 9435, "floor_s": 7248, "solve_s": 0.55, "ffd_s": 11032, "stop_aware_best_s": 9894, "stop_aware_mean_s": 10330.6, "route_id": "RouteID_693060a6-88bb-4324-9e9c-925d5240263c", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S02", "S14", "S08", "S10", "S12", "S13", "S05", "S11", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S06", "S09", "S03"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S07", "S08", "S03"], "parcels": ["P07"]}, {"route": ["S02", "S07", "S11", "S09", "S04"], "parcels": ["P08", "P12", "P14"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S10", "S06", "S09", "S12", "S13", "S05", "S11", "S01"], "parcels": ["P10", "P11", "P15", "P16"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S06", "S03", "S13", "S05", "S11", "S01"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S02", "S14", "S08", "S10", "S09", "S12"], "parcels": []}]}}} |
| {"id": "7f5d87f0-spread-n14-k3-t0.9-s5", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 322}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 102}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 324}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 29}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 824}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 168}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 12}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 23}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 242}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 1074, "travel_s": [[0, 2477, 2270, 2460, 2373, 2388, 2239, 2552, 2304, 2245, 2400, 2590, 2416, 2529, 2182], [2378, 0, 808, 503, 284, 297, 437, 132, 294, 356, 567, 170, 414, 109, 398], [2088, 832, 0, 602, 738, 589, 818, 907, 679, 629, 621, 945, 798, 884, 616], [2109, 455, 513, 0, 323, 310, 440, 530, 264, 294, 320, 568, 384, 507, 252], [2252, 302, 680, 334, 0, 278, 231, 377, 57, 219, 487, 415, 152, 354, 280], [2168, 284, 572, 321, 276, 0, 343, 359, 218, 232, 331, 397, 337, 336, 315], [2144, 465, 740, 428, 254, 363, 0, 540, 219, 203, 533, 578, 297, 517, 245], [2524, 184, 955, 650, 430, 444, 584, 0, 441, 503, 714, 38, 560, 213, 545], [2196, 323, 623, 277, 58, 221, 218, 398, 0, 162, 430, 436, 119, 375, 233], [2199, 359, 603, 257, 248, 226, 210, 434, 214, 0, 400, 472, 291, 411, 112], [2229, 552, 633, 353, 489, 309, 542, 627, 430, 396, 0, 665, 550, 604, 353], [2507, 167, 938, 633, 413, 427, 567, 83, 424, 486, 697, 0, 544, 196, 528], [2308, 261, 735, 389, 131, 333, 284, 336, 180, 274, 542, 374, 0, 313, 346], [2422, 82, 853, 548, 328, 342, 482, 154, 339, 401, 612, 192, 458, 0, 443], [2149, 414, 552, 289, 310, 325, 242, 489, 241, 120, 346, 528, 353, 466, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 16571, "optimality": "proven", "lower_bound_s": 16571, "floor_s": 12810, "solve_s": 0.38, "ffd_s": 17607, "stop_aware_best_s": 17235, "stop_aware_mean_s": 17425.4, "route_id": "RouteID_7f5d87f0-c39f-434f-bf3f-b159ef321909", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S06", "S12", "S07", "S11", "S13", "S01"], "parcels": ["P08", "P09", "P11", "P13", "P14", "P15", "P16", "P18"]}, {"route": ["S07", "S04", "S08", "S03", "S02"], "parcels": ["P10", "P12", "P17"]}, {"route": ["S14", "S09", "S05", "S10"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S14", "S07", "S08"], "parcels": ["P17"]}, {"route": ["S06", "S07", "S13", "S01", "S05", "S10"], "parcels": ["P06", "P15"]}, {"route": ["S09", "S04", "S12", "S07", "S11", "S05", "S03", "S02"], "parcels": ["P05", "P08", "P09", "P10", "P11", "P12", "P13", "P14", "P16", "P18"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S06", "S07", "S11", "S13", "S14", "S03"], "parcels": ["P08", "P10", "P11", "P12", "P14", "P16", "P18"]}, {"route": ["S07", "S04", "S08"], "parcels": ["P09", "P13", "P15", "P17"]}, {"route": ["S09", "S12", "S01", "S05", "S10", "S02"], "parcels": []}]}}} |
| {"id": "9475872b-spread-n14-k3-t0.9-s6", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 92}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 30}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 9}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 259}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 60}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 107}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 2}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 605, "travel_s": [[0, 1805, 1658, 1506, 1662, 1335, 1633, 1606, 1402, 1491, 1511, 1397, 1568, 1673, 1471], [1710, 0, 438, 731, 240, 680, 449, 360, 628, 549, 589, 583, 625, 305, 529], [1536, 481, 0, 530, 338, 430, 199, 403, 377, 299, 338, 332, 375, 348, 279], [1380, 762, 506, 0, 636, 274, 481, 601, 250, 340, 360, 245, 416, 646, 320], [1566, 219, 294, 588, 0, 537, 303, 218, 481, 406, 445, 439, 482, 162, 386], [1204, 697, 441, 289, 571, 0, 416, 551, 185, 275, 294, 180, 351, 581, 255], [1495, 476, 203, 489, 329, 389, 0, 399, 333, 257, 297, 288, 334, 343, 237], [1490, 333, 353, 582, 190, 545, 361, 0, 518, 464, 504, 517, 540, 165, 444], [1263, 636, 380, 257, 506, 157, 352, 529, 0, 214, 234, 116, 290, 520, 194], [1362, 566, 311, 356, 441, 256, 286, 506, 203, 0, 146, 158, 76, 451, 60], [1378, 563, 307, 373, 438, 272, 282, 503, 220, 123, 0, 175, 199, 448, 103], [1302, 594, 338, 296, 468, 196, 313, 534, 139, 172, 192, 0, 248, 479, 152], [1432, 643, 387, 426, 517, 326, 362, 582, 273, 76, 222, 228, 0, 527, 136], [1552, 293, 313, 643, 150, 556, 324, 160, 503, 424, 464, 458, 500, 0, 404], [1329, 534, 278, 324, 408, 223, 253, 473, 170, 67, 114, 125, 143, 418, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 10994, "optimality": "proven", "lower_bound_s": 10994, "floor_s": 7617, "solve_s": 0.47, "ffd_s": 12085, "stop_aware_best_s": 11326, "stop_aware_mean_s": 11643.6, "route_id": "RouteID_9475872b-287f-4c2c-8e29-887766a4e090", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S04", "S01", "S13", "S07"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S11", "S02", "S06", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S10", "S09", "S12", "S14", "S05"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S11", "S06", "S09", "S08"], "parcels": ["P10", "P15"]}, {"route": ["S07", "S04", "S06", "S03"], "parcels": ["P04", "P05", "P11"]}, {"route": ["S13", "S04", "S01", "S02", "S10", "S12", "S14", "S08", "S05"], "parcels": ["P06", "P07", "P08", "P14"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S13", "S04", "S01", "S02", "S14", "S08"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S11", "S10", "S09", "S12", "S05"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S06"], "parcels": []}]}}} |
| {"id": "a8f0009d-spread-n14-k3-t0.9-s7", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 51}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 114}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 32}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 43}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 38}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 14}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 13}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 21}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 79}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 479, "travel_s": [[0, 1955, 2060, 2123, 1936, 2088, 2029, 2083, 1995, 2069, 2107, 2028, 1995, 2054, 2126], [2015, 0, 173, 222, 302, 137, 340, 143, 378, 283, 288, 394, 193, 239, 186], [2113, 251, 0, 62, 400, 211, 261, 173, 254, 307, 114, 336, 357, 292, 230], [2155, 310, 52, 0, 460, 271, 313, 232, 306, 367, 146, 389, 417, 313, 334], [2281, 486, 486, 587, 0, 656, 417, 659, 420, 467, 580, 213, 556, 453, 657], [2110, 145, 222, 271, 397, 0, 390, 47, 428, 334, 336, 489, 208, 290, 207], [2057, 251, 271, 371, 344, 372, 0, 400, 187, 184, 365, 288, 273, 170, 422], [2128, 163, 175, 224, 416, 38, 409, 0, 447, 352, 289, 508, 212, 309, 160], [2094, 288, 258, 359, 381, 410, 172, 438, 0, 224, 406, 256, 310, 207, 459], [2010, 204, 290, 366, 297, 325, 224, 353, 258, 0, 384, 389, 226, 122, 376], [2152, 382, 131, 132, 507, 342, 333, 304, 326, 348, 0, 409, 437, 333, 355], [2118, 372, 324, 424, 187, 493, 255, 497, 258, 305, 418, 0, 394, 290, 543], [2028, 180, 358, 387, 315, 225, 289, 218, 327, 232, 452, 407, 0, 188, 352], [1950, 144, 260, 360, 237, 265, 190, 293, 228, 137, 354, 329, 166, 0, 315], [2148, 325, 243, 293, 435, 200, 427, 162, 497, 374, 347, 527, 374, 328, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 13991, "optimality": "proven", "lower_bound_s": 13991, "floor_s": 11658, "solve_s": 1.5, "ffd_s": 15466, "stop_aware_best_s": 14686, "stop_aware_mean_s": 14841.8, "route_id": "RouteID_a8f0009d-e50a-49c9-84d3-f9885ad14a54", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S01", "S05", "S07", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S10", "S03", "S02", "S08", "S06"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S04", "S11", "S09", "S13", "S12"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S08", "S06", "S09", "S05"], "parcels": ["P06", "P09", "P11"]}, {"route": ["S12", "S14", "S03", "S08"], "parcels": ["P10", "P15"]}, {"route": ["S04", "S11", "S06", "S09", "S13", "S12", "S01", "S07", "S02", "S10"], "parcels": ["P07", "P12", "P16"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S04", "S11", "S08", "S09", "S14"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S02", "S06", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S01", "S07", "S03", "S10"], "parcels": []}]}}} |
| {"id": "bcc07fea-spread-n14-k3-t0.9-s8", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 58}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 7}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 157}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 149}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 5}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 17}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 50}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 10}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 133}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 11}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 226}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 18}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 15}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 11}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 434, "travel_s": [[0, 1971, 2034, 2052, 2160, 1890, 1988, 1955, 1987, 2105, 2187, 1923, 2139, 1906, 1964], [1960, 0, 163, 495, 537, 199, 279, 188, 116, 548, 591, 214, 583, 236, 255], [1971, 90, 0, 502, 591, 252, 332, 192, 120, 554, 645, 268, 590, 275, 309], [1993, 503, 532, 0, 292, 380, 343, 498, 484, 251, 330, 313, 287, 415, 300], [2144, 531, 655, 325, 0, 413, 326, 629, 608, 206, 140, 341, 194, 375, 328], [1896, 226, 333, 449, 500, 0, 197, 359, 286, 501, 601, 240, 537, 77, 281], [1948, 290, 414, 327, 352, 170, 0, 439, 366, 379, 423, 100, 415, 132, 69], [1934, 191, 216, 500, 692, 344, 434, 0, 168, 569, 697, 369, 605, 376, 393], [2011, 130, 40, 542, 632, 293, 373, 233, 0, 595, 686, 308, 631, 315, 349], [2080, 624, 618, 305, 187, 466, 464, 585, 571, 0, 127, 434, 167, 521, 421], [2139, 582, 706, 377, 130, 518, 423, 639, 659, 124, 0, 393, 221, 479, 384], [1864, 206, 330, 317, 359, 142, 101, 355, 282, 370, 413, 0, 405, 200, 77], [2088, 556, 627, 314, 193, 475, 428, 594, 580, 160, 205, 398, 0, 477, 385], [1819, 178, 302, 363, 414, 115, 155, 328, 255, 416, 468, 90, 452, 0, 131], [1907, 249, 373, 306, 348, 186, 71, 398, 325, 358, 402, 59, 394, 203, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 13639, "optimality": "proven", "lower_bound_s": 13639, "floor_s": 11127, "solve_s": 0.86, "ffd_s": 15578, "stop_aware_best_s": 14376, "stop_aware_mean_s": 14682.2, "route_id": "RouteID_bcc07fea-86d2-41e4-9a58-cfc78956dcc7", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S07", "S08", "S02", "S01", "S05", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S09", "S04", "S06", "S14", "S11"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S10"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S08", "S03", "S12"], "parcels": ["P05"]}, {"route": ["S05", "S02", "S03", "S10"], "parcels": ["P03", "P13", "P14"]}, {"route": ["S03", "S09", "S10", "S04", "S14", "S11", "S06", "S13", "S01", "S07"], "parcels": ["P04", "P15"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S03", "S04", "S14", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S08", "S02", "S01", "S05", "S06", "S11", "S09"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S12", "S10"], "parcels": []}]}}} |
| {"id": "d1a8c3dd-spread-n14-k3-t0.9-s9", "instance": {"stops": ["S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06", "S07", "S08", "S09", "S10", "S11", "S12", "S13", "S14"], "parcels": [{"id": "P01", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 20}, {"id": "P02", "stop": "S01", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P03", "stop": "S02", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P04", "stop": "S03", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P05", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P06", "stop": "S04", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P07", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 28}, {"id": "P08", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 45}, {"id": "P09", "stop": "S05", "volume_dl": 55}, {"id": "P10", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 179}, {"id": "P11", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 79}, {"id": "P12", "stop": "S06", "volume_dl": 410}, {"id": "P13", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 34}, {"id": "P14", "stop": "S07", "volume_dl": 184}, {"id": "P15", "stop": "S08", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P16", "stop": "S09", "volume_dl": 104}, {"id": "P17", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 57}, {"id": "P18", "stop": "S10", "volume_dl": 63}, {"id": "P19", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 35}, {"id": "P20", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 95}, {"id": "P21", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 53}, {"id": "P22", "stop": "S11", "volume_dl": 242}, {"id": "P23", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 6}, {"id": "P24", "stop": "S12", "volume_dl": 97}, {"id": "P25", "stop": "S13", "volume_dl": 3}, {"id": "P26", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 41}, {"id": "P27", "stop": "S14", "volume_dl": 57}], "vans": 3, "capacity_dl": 861, "travel_s": [[0, 1196, 1156, 1271, 1270, 1279, 1263, 1046, 1296, 1073, 1354, 1388, 1063, 1161, 1326], [1169, 0, 32, 410, 218, 133, 196, 247, 232, 429, 402, 326, 185, 325, 373], [1137, 41, 0, 400, 209, 123, 181, 215, 223, 420, 392, 317, 165, 316, 364], [1288, 415, 417, 0, 460, 394, 453, 601, 187, 616, 338, 329, 551, 516, 310], [1278, 237, 237, 462, 0, 185, 73, 343, 285, 324, 454, 379, 265, 220, 425], [1264, 125, 127, 365, 212, 0, 182, 342, 188, 423, 357, 282, 292, 319, 329], [1265, 265, 224, 470, 82, 193, 0, 330, 292, 312, 462, 386, 265, 207, 433], [1018, 257, 216, 617, 315, 340, 313, 0, 439, 374, 609, 534, 73, 336, 580], [1326, 228, 230, 188, 347, 207, 288, 445, 0, 507, 278, 203, 395, 403, 250], [1041, 377, 336, 618, 320, 412, 313, 291, 512, 0, 681, 606, 225, 182, 653], [1316, 414, 416, 309, 501, 393, 479, 630, 294, 643, 0, 305, 568, 608, 97], [1439, 300, 302, 361, 388, 282, 365, 517, 216, 599, 353, 0, 468, 495, 324], [1038, 194, 179, 579, 251, 311, 249, 81, 402, 375, 545, 470, 0, 288, 542], [1125, 352, 312, 594, 284, 376, 277, 266, 476, 127, 645, 570, 201, 0, 617], [1218, 437, 430, 212, 377, 407, 374, 516, 236, 546, 261, 328, 454, 431, 0]]}, "reference": {"optimum_s": 8816, "optimality": "proven", "lower_bound_s": 8816, "floor_s": 6192, "solve_s": 1.08, "ffd_s": 10817, "stop_aware_best_s": 9503, "stop_aware_mean_s": 9724.2, "route_id": "RouteID_d1a8c3dd-fa67-455c-a68d-af2fd6aa5d91", "plans": {"optimum": [{"route": ["S07", "S12", "S04", "S05", "S01", "S02"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S06", "S13", "S09"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S03", "S08", "S11", "S10", "S14"], "parcels": []}], "ffd": [{"route": ["S07", "S01", "S11", "S06", "S13"], "parcels": ["P01", "P12", "P14", "P22"]}, {"route": ["S09", "S06", "S04", "S05", "S08", "S11", "S01", "S12"], "parcels": ["P02", "P05", "P07", "P10", "P11", "P20", "P24"]}, {"route": ["S07", "S12", "S02", "S04", "S05", "S11", "S10", "S14", "S03"], "parcels": ["P06", "P08", "P09", "P13", "P19", "P21", "P23"]}], "stop_aware_best": [{"route": ["S03", "S08", "S11", "S02", "S12"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S05", "S06", "S13"], "parcels": []}, {"route": ["S07", "S01", "S10", "S14", "S04", "S09"], "parcels": []}]}}} |
|
|
